Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser.
The ideal of ‘taking X seriously’, with X being either a particular group of people studied or certain ideas or practices of theirs, has become something of an anthropological trope. While it is not always clear exactly how one is supposed to realise this ideal, it generally involves an engagement with the wider implications of a human being thinking or doing what the observing scholar claims they think or do. In Egyptology, on the other hand, such engagement is rare, and this is especially pronounced than in the area of Egyptian religion. By subsuming religion under the category of ‘belief’, it is effectively protected from such engagement, since ‘beliefs’ cannot be compared or judged by outside yardsticks – especially where the ideas expressed can conveniently be ascribed to the afterlife. In the cases where this leads to ideas that are evidently very difficult to take seriously, such as Egyptological interpretations of shabtis or heart scarabs, this tends to be regarded as purely the fault of the Egyptians, not of the Egyptologist. In anthropology, by contrast, such apparently absurd ideas have traditionally spurred theoretical development from Lévy-Bruhl’s ‘prelogical’ thinking to the recent ‘ontological turn’. This difference in stance between Egyptology and anthropology is used as a point of departure for a discussion of the colonial roots of the discipline of Egyptology which are nowhere more strongly felt than in the interpretation of mortuary religion. The paper argues that in order to ‘take seriously’ ancient Egyptian practices, much of the Victorian baggage still with us in the traditional idea of the ‘quest for immortality’ needs to be rethought, and that not only does recent anthropological work on ontology provide a useful inspiration for this, but the Egyptian material also has a lot to offer in such cross-cultural discussions.
Journal of Ancient Egyptian Interconnections
2018. “Taking Ancient Egyptian Mortuary Religion Seriously”: Why Would We, and How Could We?2018 •
Ancient Egyptian mortuary religion is full of ideas which, in their conventional Egyptological interpretation, are very difficult to take seriously, seemingly contradictory and naïve as they are. This has not been a major problem within the field of Egyptology itself due to a disciplinary stance that tends to avoid engagement with the ideas ascribed to the ancient Egyptian actor, but in comparison with anthropological approaches — especially the recent “ontological turn” — such apparently absurd ideas raise a significant challenge. This paper argues that in order to “take seriously” ancient Egyptian practices, much of the Victorian baggage still with us in the traditional idea of the “quest for immortality” needs to be rethought.
2019 •
The aim of this dissertation is to trace the diachronic development of the notion of Duat, the ancient Egyptian realm of the dead. Despite being a key component of the afterlife beliefs, this notion has defied all scholarly attempts at a clear definition, as it underwent a process of evolution over thousands of years without ever designating just one place at a time, but always possessing both chthonic and celestial features at once. Furthermore, new images and ideas were constantly introduced, and new layers were added to the core ideological framework established in earlier times. This study is based on the analysis of royal and non-royal funerary texts from the end of the Old Kingdom to the end of the New Kingdom (Pyramid and Coffin Texts, Book of the Dead, Underworld Books, and Books of the Sky) and aims to outline what the term Duat encompassed, where it was thought to be located, and how its characterization evolved over time. Besides presenting the most significant passages mentioning and/or describing the Duat in the various funerary compositions, each chapter will also discuss any relevant theological, cosmological, geographical, and astronomical notions necessary to clarify the conceptual framework, of which the Duat formed but a part, and will try to relate its evolution to the concurrent changes in Egyptian culture, society, and ideology. Additionally, since patterns of distribution of texts and imagery played a significant role in both temples and tombs, an analysis of the correlation between the various funerary texts and their material support complements the study, with the purpose of highlighting what the Egyptians believed to be a magical synergy between the texts for the afterlife and their context. By bringing together all these aspects, significant insight will be gained not only into the conceptualization of the next, metaphysical world but also into the understanding of the physical reality in which the Egyptians lived every day, long before those funerary texts would be of any use to them.
2016 •
Death Rituals, Social Order and the Archaeology of Immortality in the Ancient World. edited by Renfrew, C., Boyd, D. and Morley, I.
Locating a sense of immortality in early Egyptian cemeteries2015 •
Collective representations of death can provide particularly germane departure points for the inference of prehistoric notions of immortality. Building on the idea that humans may have an intuitive sense of the continued existence of others after death, I suggest that one way in which a sense of immortality can be stimulated is through the communal and embodied experience of how others are buried and how social relationships are dramatized in mortuary rites and settings. In the case of early Egypt, from the late Neolithic through to Early Bronze Age, social relationships were dramatically reconfigured over an interval of some 1500 years—from pastoralist communities to a state society headed by divine kingship. The establishment of the latter, I propose, was achieved not primarily through the elevation of ancestors to divine status as is so commonly inferred, but via fundamental changes in the spatial performance of social relations and the concomitant reorientation of temporal references in certain elite cemeteries.
Journal of Ancient Egyptian Interconnections
Editorial Introduction - Egyptology and Anthropology: Historiography, Theoretical Exchange, and Conceptual Development2018 •
Building on the ongoing debates surrounding the archaeological application of New Materialism, posthumanism, speculative realism, object-oriented ontology, and the anthropological ontological turn, this paper examines sexual interactions between deities and humans, as well as among deities represented as statues in ancient Egypt. Acknowledging the existence of such sexual encounters and providing detailed descriptions of the involved entities alone does not fully recognize the underlying gender and class structures. This paper argues that these analyzed sexual encounters were shaped by gender and class-based power asymmetries, revealing that the ancient Egyptians and contemporary perspectives are not as distinct as they might seem.
Living with the Dead: Ancestor Worship and Mortuary Cult in Ancient Egypt
Living with the Dead: Ancestor Worship and Mortuary Cult in Ancient Egypt2013 •
Living with the Dead presents a detailed analysis of ancestor worship in Egypt, using a diverse range of material, both archaeological and anthropological, to examine the relationship between the living and the dead. Iconography and terminology associated with the deceased reveal indistinct differences between the blessedness and malevolence and that the potent spirit of the dead required constant propitiation in the form of worship and offerings. A range of evidence is presented for mortuary cults that were in operation throughout Egyptian history and for the various places, such as the house, shrines, chapels and tomb doorways, where the living could interact with the dead. The private statue cult, where images of individuals were venerated as intermediaries between people and the Gods is also discussed. Collective gatherings and ritual feasting accompanied the burial rites with separate, mortuary banquets serving to maintain ongoing ritual practices focusing on the deceased. Something of a contradiction in attitudes is expressed in the evidence for tomb robbery, the reuse of tombs and funerary equipment and the ways in which communities dealt with the death and burial of children and others on the fringe of society.
Roczniki Humanistyczne
Motywy i motywacje duchowe w Mistrzu i Małgorzacie Michaiła Bułhakowa w polskich źródłach periodycznych i zwartych po roku 19892021 •
El Mercurio Legal
Una oportunidad para mejorar los sistemas de designaciones judiciales (y con participación judicial)2024 •
International Journal of Creative Research Thoughts (IJCRT)
REVIEW ON CUSTOMER PERCEPTION TOWARDS ONLINE FOOD DELIVERY SERVICES2021 •
2011 •
Comprehensive Guide to Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
Documentation of Torture and Mental (Psychiatric) Findings2015 •
European Journal of Case Reports in Internal Medicine
Splenic Infarctions in Polycythaemia Vera are Not Always a CatastropheDocumentación Administrativa
La administración electrónica al servicio de las políticas públicasJournal of Islamic Business Law
Pemberian Hadiah Pada Turnamen Game Mobile Legends Perspektif Yusuf Qardhawi2020 •
2010 •
International Journal of Solids and Structures
A framework for microplane models at large strain, with application to hyperelasticity2004 •