Disaster Risk Reduction
Methods, Approaches and Practices
Umma Habiba
Md. Anwarul Abedin
Abu Wali Raghib Hassan
Rajib Shaw Editors
Food Security
and Risk
Reduction in
Bangladesh
Disaster Risk Reduction
Methods, Approaches and Practices
Series editor
Rajib Shaw, Kyoto University, Japan
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
About the Series
Scope of the Series
Disaster risk reduction is a process, which leads to the safety of community and
nations. After the 2005 World Conference on Disaster Reduction, held in Kobe, Japan,
the Hyogo Framework for Action (HFA) was adopted as a framework of risk reduction.
The academic research and higher education in disaster risk reduction has made/is
making gradual shift from pure basic research to applied, implementation oriented
research. More emphasis is given on the multi-stakeholder collaboration and multidisciplinary research. Emerging university networks in Asia, Europe, Africa and
Americas have urged for the process-oriented research in disaster risk reduction field.
Keeping this in mind, this new series will promote the outputs of action research on
disaster risk reduction, which will be useful for a wider range of stakeholders including
academicians, professionals, practitioners, and students and researchers in the related
field. The series will focus on some of emerging needs in the risk reduction field,
starting from climate change adaptation, urban ecosystem, coastal risk reduction,
education for sustainable development, community based practices, risk
communication, human security, etc. Through academic review, this series will
encourage young researchers and practitioners to analyze field practices, and link it to
theory and policies with logic, data and evidences. Thus, the series emphasizes
evidence based risk reduction methods, approaches and practices.
Editorial Advisory Group
1. Ms. Margareta Wahlstorm, Special Representative of the Secretary General of
the United Nations for the Disaster Risk Reduction, and head of UN ISDR
(International Strategy for Disaster Reduction), Geneva, Switzerland
2. Dr. Juha Uitto, Deputy Director, Evaluation Office, UNDP (United Nations
Development Programme), NY, USA
3. Professor Kaoru Takara, Disaster Prevention Research Institute (DPRI), Kyoto
University, Kyoto, Japan
4. Professor Joy Jacquline Pereira, University Kebansan Malaysia (UKM), Malaysia
5. Professor David Sanderson, Director, Centre for Development and Emergency
Practice (CENDEP), Faculty of Technology, Design and Environment, Oxford
Brookes University, Oxford Brooks University, Oxford, UK
6. Dr. Anshu Sharma, Board Member, SEEDS India, Delhi, India
7. Professor Ailsa Holloway, Director, Disaster Mitigation for Sustainable
Livelihoods Programme, Stellenbosch University, South Africa
8. Professor Arnold Howitt, Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University,
USA
9. Professor Fuad Mallick, Chair of Disaster Management Program, BRAC
University, Dhaka, Bangladesh
10. Professor Jayant K Routray, Coordinator of Disaster Preparedness, Mitigation
and Management Academic Program, Asian Institute of Technology, Pathumthani,
Thailand
More information about this series at http://www.springer.com/series/11575
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Umma Habiba • Md. Anwarul Abedin
Abu Wali Raghib Hassan • Rajib Shaw
Editors
Food Security and Risk
Reduction in Bangladesh
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Editors
Umma Habiba
Department of Agricultural Extension
Ministry of Agriculture
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Abu Wali Raghib Hassan
Department of Agricultural Extension
Ministry of Agriculture
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Md. Anwarul Abedin
Department of Soil Science
Bangladesh Agricultural University
Mymensingh, Bangladesh
Rajib Shaw
Graduate School of Global
Environmental Studies
Kyoto University
Kyoto, Japan
ISSN 2196-4106
ISSN 2196-4114 (electronic)
Disaster Risk Reduction
ISBN 978-4-431-55410-3
ISBN 978-4-431-55411-0 (eBook)
DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0
Library of Congress Control Number: 2015935561
Springer Tokyo Heidelberg New York Dordrecht London
© Springer Japan 2015
This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved by the Publisher, whether the whole or part of
the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation,
broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in any other physical way, and transmission or information
storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology
now known or hereafter developed.
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publication
does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant
protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use.
The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book
are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors or the
editors give a warranty, express or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any errors
or omissions that may have been made.
Printed on acid-free paper
Springer Japan KK is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Preface
This book outlines food security issues and their implications for risk reduction
approaches in Bangladesh, drawing examples and lessons from the output of the
national- and community-level programs and projects and other experiences of the
country. The challenges of ensuring an uninterrupted supply of food for 160 million
people is a formidable one. It is even more challenging in view of the shrinking size
of the net cultivable land and the growing population. Despite the recent slowdown
in population growth and lower fertility rate, at a population growth rate of about
1.6 %, Bangladesh would have to feed an additional 2.25 million mouths each year.
Therefore, this book attempts to draw some of the key lessons learned from different sectors related to food security and analyzes them. Finally, for increasing food
production and attaining food sufficiency, this book provides an integrated approach
that helps to ensure food security in the context of Bangladesh.
Promising and innovative initiatives that tackle hunger while building long-term
resilience and food security are now being developed throughout the world. Food
security, climate change, and disaster risk reduction research and policy agendas are
also increasingly centered on resilience and how to bring together ideas, innovations, and lessons from these three fields.
Within the above-described context, this book is a modest attempt to provide an
overview of food security issues in Bangladesh that helps to combat natural disasters and to ensure security at both the individual and national levels. Although
Bangladesh attained self-sufficiency in food production in 1999–2000, increased
population growth, climate change, scarcity of natural resources, and a high incidence of poverty, urbanization, and malnutrition have put great pressure on the government for ensuring food security. The book has 14 chapters. The first is an
overview and the last one is analysis. The remaining 12 chapters are divided into
causes and issues of food security (three chapters), implications from different sectors (two chapters), policy analysis (two chapters), and various stakeholders’ actions
(five chapters) to enhance food security.
v
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Preface
vi
This book is written for students, young researchers, and practitioners in the
fields of disaster risk reduction and environmental studies. We hope that they will
find the book useful and relevant to their work.
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Mymensingh, Bangladesh
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Kyoto, Japan
Umma Habiba
Md. Anwarul Abedin
Abu Wali Raghib Hassan
Rajib Shaw
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Contents
1
2
3
4
Introduction and Overview of Food Security and Risk
Reduction Issues ......................................................................................
Umma Habiba, Md. Anwarul Abedin, and Rajib Shaw
1
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure, Demographic
Changes, Urbanization and Its Implication on Food Security............
Sheikh M. Rafiqul Hasan and Umma Habiba
19
Natural Causes: Climate Change Implications,
Resource Management and Food Security ...........................................
Sanjib Kumar Saha and Shampa Barmon
39
Social Issues: Occupation Change and Food Security
in Bangladesh ..........................................................................................
Abu Wali Raghib Hassan and Anil Kumar Das
53
5
Livelihood Security: Implications from Agriculture Sectors ..............
Abu Wali Raghib Hassan and Rajib Shaw
65
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors ............
Mostafa A.R. Hossain, Humayun Kabir,
Ali Muhammad Omar Faruque, and Monjur Hossain
83
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues
on Food Security...................................................................................... 111
Md. Abu Syed
8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security .......... 135
Fazle Rabbi Sadeque Ahmed
9
People and Community Actions on Food Security ............................... 157
Md. Anwarul Abedin and Umma Habiba
vii
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
viii
Contents
10
Climate Change and Food Security
in Vulnerable Coastal Zones of Bangladesh ......................................... 173
Md. Golam Rabbani, A. Atiq Rahman,
Ishtiaque Jahan Shoef, and Zoheb Mahmud Khan
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective
from Southwestern Coastal Region of Bangladesh .............................. 187
Abu Zofar Md. Moslehuddin, Md. Anwarul Abedin,
Mostafa A.R. Hossain, and Umma Habiba
12
Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring
Food Security ........................................................................................... 213
Rezaur Rahman and M. Shahjahan Mondal
13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security and Human Health:
Cross-Cutting Issues in Bangladesh ...................................................... 235
Gulsan Ara Parvin, Kumiko Fujita, Akiko Matsuyama,
Rajib Shaw, and Maiko Sakamoto
14
Future Approaches of Food Security, Sustainable Development,
Environment and Resource Management and Risk Reduction .......... 255
Umma Habiba, Md. Anwarul Abedin, and Rajib Shaw
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Contributors
Md. Anwarul Abedin Department of Soil Science, Bangladesh Agricultural
University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh
Fazle Rabbi Sadeque Ahmed Deputy Secretary, Ministry of Public Administration,
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Shampa Barmon Mission Jannat, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Anil Kumar Das Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture,
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Ali Muhammad Omar Faruque Department of Fisheries, Ministry of Fisheries
and Livestock, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Kumiko Fujita Graduate School of Global Environmental Studies, Kyoto
University, Kyoto, Japan
Umma Habiba Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture,
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Sheikh M. Rafiqul Hasan University of Dhaka, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Abu Wali Raghib Hassan Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of
Agriculture, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Monjur Hossain PMTC (Bangladesh) Ltd., Dhaka, Bangladesh
Mostafa A.R. Hossain Department of Fish Biology & Genetics, Bangladesh
Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh
Humayun Kabir Department of Fisheries, Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock,
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Zoheb Mahmud Khan Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies (BCAS), Dhaka,
Bangladesh
ix
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
x
Contributors
Akiko Matsuyama School of International Health Development, Nagasaki
University, Nagasaki, Japan
M. Shahjahan Mondal Institute of Water and Flood management, Bangladesh
University of Engineering & Technology (BUET), Dhaka, Bangladesh
Abu Zofar Md. Moslehuddin Department of Soil Science, Bangladesh
Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh
Gulsan Ara Parvin Graduate School of Global Environmental Studies, Kyoto
University, Kyoto, Japan
Md. Golam Rabbani Environment and Climate Change Division, Bangladesh
Centre for Advanced Studies (BCAS), Dhaka, Bangladesh
A. Atiq Rahman Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies (BCAS), Dhaka,
Bangladesh
Rezaur Rahman Institute of Water and Flood management, Bangladesh University
of Engineering & Technology (BUET), Dhaka, Bangladesh
Sanjib Kumar Saha Comprehensive Disaster Management Programme (CDMP),
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), Dhaka, Bangladesh
Maiko Sakamoto Graduate School of Frontier Sciences, The University of Tokyo,
Tokyo, Japan
Rajib Shaw Graduate School of Global Environmental Studies, Kyoto University,
Kyoto, Japan
Ishtiaque Jahan Shoef Data Management Division, Bangladesh Centre for
Advanced Studies (BCAS), Dhaka, Bangladesh
Md. Abu Syed Remote Sensing, GIS and Modeling Division; NRM, Ecosystem
Modeling and Adaptation Division, Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies
(BCAS), Dhaka, Bangladesh
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
About the Editors
Umma Habiba is an Agricultural Extension Officer at Ministry of Agriculture in
Bangladesh. She has completed her Ph.D. studies in the Graduate School of Global
Environmental Studies of Kyoto University, Japan, and she also completed her postdoctoral research as GCOE-ARS Postdoctoral Fellow from the same Graduate
School of Kyoto University. She has done extensive research in the arena of agriculture, drought, risk reduction, climate change adaptation and food security issues.
Her research interests are climate change adaptation, disaster risk reduction, sustainable agriculture and food security.
Md. Anwarul Abedin is an Associate Professor at Bangladesh Agricultural
University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh. He holds a Ph.D. degree in Environmental
Studies from Graduate School of Global Environmental Studies, Kyoto University,
Japan, and also completed his postdoctoral research as JSPS Fellow in Kyoto
University. He has done extensive research in the field of water and arsenic contamination and community based disaster risk reduction in the coastal Bangladesh. His
recent work involves flood risk management, climate change and health issues, ecosystem services and poverty alleviation in coastal Bangladesh. His research interests are community adaptation and networking, natural hazards (salinity, arsenic,
drought, etc.) risk and resilience, water vulnerability and food security issues.
Abu Wali Raghib Hasan, Deputy Director of Department of Agricultural Extension,
at Ministry of Agriculture in Bangladesh. He has completed his Ph.D. in Soil
Science from Bangabanghu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman Agriculture University,
Bangladesh, and did an Advance Diploma on Agriculture Management in Rural
Development Projects from Nordic Agriculture College, Denmark. He has more
than 29 years’ practical experiences on crop production, protection and preservation,
IPM, climate change adaptation, food security, farmers field school (FFS) etc. He also
worked as Project Director of “Disaster and Climate Risk Management in Agriculture
xi
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
xii
About the Editors
Project” under Comprehensive Disaster Management Program Phase-II, Department
of Agricultural Extension. His research interests are drought, saline, flood and flash
flood prone areas on disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation.
Rajib Shaw is a Professor in the Graduate School of Global Environmental Studies
of Kyoto University, Japan. He worked closely with the local communities, NGOs,
governments and international organization, including United Nations, especially in
the Asian countries. He is currently the Chair of the United Nations Asia Regional
Task Force for Urban Risk Reduction and the President of Asian University Network
of Environment and Disaster Management (AUEDM). His research interests are:
community based disaster risk management, climate change adaptation, urban risk
management, and disaster and environmental education. He has published several
books in the field of disaster and environmental management. He is also the Chief
Editor of Asian Journal of Environment and Disaster Management.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 1
Introduction and Overview of Food Security
and Risk Reduction Issues
Umma Habiba, Md. Anwarul Abedin, and Rajib Shaw
Abstract A series of recent events have stimulated broader interest in food security
and food systems. About 850 million people in the world are undernourished,
particularly in the developing countries. In spite of making considerable progress in
food sufficiency, however, food security is a major concern in Bangladesh, as being
over populated and disaster prone country. Although, food security is mostly
affected by extreme climatic events, making resource-poor farmers/fishers/herders
even more vulnerable to disasters and impacts of climate change. Half of all rural
children are reported as chronically malnourished and 14 % suffer from acute malnutrition. Therefore, the main focus of this chapter is to highlight a brief overview
of food security, climate change impacts on it and necessitate the integration of risk
reduction into the ongoing activities carried out through national to local level in
Bangladesh context.
Keywords Food security • Food sufficiency • Climate change • Risk reduction •
Bangladesh
1.1
Introduction
The concept of food security has evolved over time and the world has taken a more
comprehensive view of food and nutrition in recent years. During the 1960s, the
emphasis was mostly on food supply or availability at the national level from
domestic production and/or imports. The 1974 World Food Summit emphasized the
U. Habiba (*)
Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture, Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: shimuagri@yahoo.com
Md.A. Abedin
Department of Soil Science, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh
e-mail: masumagriculture@yahoo.com
R. Shaw
Graduate School of Global Environmental Studies, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
e-mail: shaw.rajib.5u@kyoto-u.ac.jp
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_1
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
1
2
U. Habiba et al.
need to make food available at stable prices in both national and international
markets. Many developing countries then seemed to have achieved this objective
through the ‘Green Revolution’ – dissemination of modern high yielding variety
(HYV) technology – by growing more food. However, this boost in production did
not benefit everyone and it certainly did not eliminate hunger and malnutrition
across most low income countries. About 850 million people in the world are undernourished – a number that has hardly changed since the 1990–1992 base period for
the World Food Summit and Millennium Development Goal commitments on
reducing hunger half by 2015. As of May 2006, 39 countries in the world were
experiencing serious food emergencies and required external assistance for dealing
with critical food insecurity: 25 in Africa, 11 in Asia and Near East, 2 in Latin
America and 1 in Europe.
Global food security is exacerbated by the frequent natural disasters occurred
through climate changes which make the situation in crisis to meet the basic
demands. According to the IPCC Fourth Assessment Report along with other scientific studies, it is clearly understood that climate change has a direct impact on
agriculture, livestock and fishing, particularly in countries of tropics and sub-tropics,
which will not only affect local but the global food security (Bals et al. 2008).
Climate change affects food security in a complex way. Changing precipitation
level due to climate change increase the possibility of coastal storm, flooding and
saline water intuition is likely to reduce livestock productivity and increase livestock mortality and also reduce agricultural yield. In addition, changing temperature
due to climate change reduce the rainfall pattern that affect growing season in the
tropic and sub tropic. At least 120 days rain is required by most of cereal crops,
reduce rainfall affecting the crop yields in most of Africa especially North Africa
and Southern Africa. Moreover those countries are also having water stress
(Faisal and Parveen 2004; Devereux and Edwards 2009). Both sudden and slow
onset climate change impacts has direct effect on economic activities and that raise
the issue of food crisis, particularly for the poor countries where food security is
already volatile and faces serious risks and challenges. Climate change increases the
food crisis for most of the developing countries by affecting the production and
supply process (Tandon 2012). Moreover introduction of bio-fuel and rapid increase
of food price are making this food crisis more crucial (Viveros 2012). Therefore,
there is a growing urgency to protect future food security, because changing climate
is clearly change food production and distribution line and a high price have to be
paid by the consumers to ensure minimum survival intake (Schmidhuber and
Tubiello 2007).
Agriculture is important for food security in two ways: it produces the food
people eat and (perhaps, even more important), it provides the primary source of
livelihood for 36 % of the world’s total workforce. In the heavily populated countries
like Asia and the Pacific, this share ranges from 40 % to 60 % and in Sub-Saharan
Africa; two-thirds of the working population still make their living from agriculture
(ILO 2007). In Bangladesh, agriculture is the most important sector of economy due
to its role in food security, employment and livelihoods. The current share of GDP is
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
1
Introduction and Overview of Food Security and Risk Reduction Issues
3
around 15.02 % of the total GDP of the country (BBS 2013) and employs about 48 %
of the population. However, substantial year to year fluctuations of GDP is declined
due to the result of a loss of production in both food and cash crops happened
through natural calamities. Agricultural production is influenced by seasonal
characteristics and climatic variables such as temperature, rainfall, humidity, day
length, etc. (MOEF 2009). Furthermore, various types of climatic disasters like
flood, cyclone, drought, etc. hinder it.
Bangladesh has made remarkable progress in agricultural development and food
production in the recent decades. But the emerging impacts of global climate change
are posing serious threats to food security of the people, particularly of the poor and
marginal people of the society. Since independence in 1971, the national food
production progress has been boosted through the use of high yielding varieties,
fertilizer, irrigation and pesticide. However, a large part of the population still lacks
access to sufficient, safe and nutritious food. Therefore, ensuring food security for
everyone is a high priority for the Government of Bangladesh today.
1.2
1.2.1
Definition and Dimensions of Food Security
Defining Food Security
Food security as a concept originated in the 1974, in the discussions of international
food problems at a time of global food crisis. The initial focus was the volume and
stability of food suppliers. During that period, food security was defined by World
Food Summit (WFS) in the 1974 as: “availability at all times of adequate world
food supplies of basic food stuffs to sustain a steady expansion of food consumption
and to offset fluctuations in production and prices” (United Nations 1975). The
most recent careful redefinition of food security is that negotiated in the process of
international consultation leading to the WFS in November 1996. According to
WFS (1996) definition, “Food security exists when all people, at all times, have
physical and economic access to sufficient, safe and nutritious food that meets their
dietary needs and food preferences for an active and healthy life”. This definition
addresses four key components of food supplies and security namely: availability,
stability, access and utilization (Schmidhuber and Tubiello 2007).
Over time a large number of different definitions have been proposed. However,
at the World Summit of Food Security in 2009, this definition was reconfirmed, and
the concept was extended and specified by adding that the “four pillars of food
security are availability, access, utilization, and stability” and stated that “the nutritional dimension is integral to the concept”. The strength of this definition is its
comprehensiveness and imperative for “concerted actions at all levels” (that are
“individual, household, national, regional, and global levels”) and “coordinated
efforts and shared responsibilities” across institutions, societies, and economies to
tackle food insecurity effectively (FAO 1996).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
U. Habiba et al.
4
Fig. 1.1 Dimensions of food
security
1.2.2
Dimensions of Food Security
Food security is the outcome of food system operating efficiently. Efficient food
system continues positively to all dimensions of food security. The dimensions of
food security are described under the following sub-headings (Fig. 1.1):
Food Availability
The dimension addresses supply side of the food security and expects sufficient
quantities of quality food from domestic agricultural production or imports. This is
simple mathematical calculation weather the food available in certain territory/
country is enough to feed the total population in that particular territory and calculated from the level of local agriculture population at that territory, stock levels and
net import/export.
The dimension of food security at different levels can be assessed by precipitation record, food balance sheet, food market survey, agricultural production planet.
Similarly, indicators of food security for this dimension at different levels are
fertility rate, food production, population flows, harvesting time, staple food
production, food shortage, consumption of wild foods, etc.
Food Access
Having sufficient food at national level or at certain territory cannot be taken as the
proof that all the household or individuals in the country/territory have enough food to
eat. Food access is another dimension of food security which encompasses income,
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
1
Introduction and Overview of Food Security and Risk Reduction Issues
5
expenditure and buying capacity of households or individuals. Food access addresses
whether the households or individuals have enough resources to acquire appropriate
quantity of quality foods.
Some of the indicators of this dimension at different levels are food price, wage
rate, per capita food consumption, meal frequency, employment rate, etc. and the
dimension can be assessed by Vulnerability Assessment Mapping (VAM), Food
Access Survey, Food Focus Group Discussion, Intra-household food frequency
questionnaire etc. Interventions to improve this dimension of food security are inter
alia on-farm, off-farm and non-farm employment creation, school-feeding program,
breast-feeding campaign etc.
Food Utilization
Food Utilization is another dimension of food security which addresses not only
how much food the people eat but also what and how they eat. It also covers the food
production, intra-household food distribution, water and sanitation and health care
practices. The nutritional outcome of the food eaten by an individual will be appropriate and optimum only when food is prepared/cooked properly, there is adequate
diversity of the diet and proper feeding and caring practices are practiced.
Stunting rate, wasting rate, prevention of diarrheal diseases, latrine usage, weight
for age, goitre, anemia, night blinders etc. are the indicators at different level for this
dimensions which can be assessed by demographic and health survey, immunization
chart etc.
Stability
This dimension addresses the stability of the other three dimensions over time.
People cannot be considered food secure until they feel so and they do not feel food
secure until there is stability of availability, accessibility and proper utilization condition. Instability of market price of staple food and inadequate risk baring capacity
of the people in the case of adverse condition (e.g. natural disaster, unexpected
weather etc.), political instability and unemployment are the major factors affecting
stability of the dimensions of food security.
This dimension of food security can be assessed by Global Information Early
Warning System, Anthropometric survey, weighing chart of pregnant women etc.
against certain indicators like food price fluctuation, women etc. against certain
indicators like food price fluctuation, women’s BMI, pre-harvest food practice,
migration etc. Interventions to address this dimension are saving and loan policy,
inter-household food exchange, grain bank, food storage etc.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
1.3
U. Habiba et al.
Measuring Food Security and Insecurity
In order to understand better the nature and extent of the food security situation and
the possible ways to improving it, it is important to distinguish between food security
at the national, local, household and intra-household level. The ultimate goal is to
meet the food requirements of the people at all levels.
• Food security at the national level is determined by the availability of enough
resources for the whole population. The most widely used indicators are quantities
of available food compared with needs, as well as import requirements compared
with the country’s capacity to import.
• At the sub-regional levels, food security can be measured by comparing regional
nutritional requirements with availability of dietary calories per head.
Furthermore, the problem is increasingly being used in terms of seasonal or local
level.
• At the household level, food security is dependent on a household’s access to
enough food. Thus it is closely linked with the issue of poverty, access, sufficiency, vulnerability and sustainability. At the household level, food security is
measured by actual dietary intake of all household members using household
income and expenditure surveys. It is important that changes in socio-economic
and demographic variables be monitored continuously over time.
A food poverty indicator shows the number of individuals living in a household
whose access to food is sufficient to provide a dietary intake adequate for growth,
activity and good health. Individual food security implies an intake of food and
absorption of nutrients sufficient to meet an individual’s needs for activity, health,
growth and development. The individual’s age, gender, body size, health status and
level of physical activity determine the level of need.
1.4
Food Security in Bangladesh
Over the past three decades, Bangladesh has made significant progress in increasing
domestic production of food grains. This country attained self-sufficiency in food
production in 1999–2000 with a gross production of rice and wheat of 24.9 million
metric tons, which marginally met the country’s requirement of 21.4 million metric
tons (MT) for the population. This is possible because this country has managed its
rice production triple since its independence, from 10 million MT in 1971 to over
32 million MT today. Introduction of modern varieties of rice has cultivated over
75 % of the total cropped area. Along with, 8.44 million ha of the land are irrigated,
which is over seven times more than in 1990 (Bangladesh Agriculture Statistics
2013). Therefore, food security situation of Bangladesh has improved, especially on
average per capita dietary energy supply has improved from 1,800 kcal in 1970s to
3,055 kcal in 2009 (BBS 2010). There has also been substantial improvement in the
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
1
7
Introduction and Overview of Food Security and Risk Reduction Issues
Table 1.1 Production and availability of food grains (rice and wheat) in Bangladesh
Gross domestic
production
Year
(thousand m.tons)
1991–1992 19,317
1995–1996 19,056
2001–2002 25,905
2005–2006 27,268
2009–2010 33,158
Source: FPMU database, MOFDM
Net domestic
production
(thousand m.tons)
17,385
17,150
23,315
24,541
29,179
National
availability
(thousand m.ton)
18,714
19,373
25,006
27,105
32,492
Per capita
availability
kg./year gm/day
165.60
454
165.50
453
188.30
516
192.23
527
220.00
603
availability of food; with per capita availability of food grains increasing from
around 454 g to around 603 g per day during the period 1992–2010. Rice has contributed most to self-sufficiency in foodgrain, accounts for 94 % of the foodgrain
production. More than 95 % of the population consumes rice and it alone provides
76 % of calories and 66 % of total protein requirement of daily food intake (Bhuiyan
et al. 2002). Rice thus occupies the center stage of food security and continues to
draw major attention of the Government for further increasing the production.
In addition, the major food security goal of Bangladesh is to achieve self-sufficiency
in rice so that the country can meet its entire requirement from domestic production.
The concern has received added importance especially after the crisis that affected
the global food market in 2007–2008 (Table 1.1).
It has been evident that increased domestic production, supplemented by imports
and overall public food management contributed to relatively adequate availability
of food at national level over the recent past years. However, food security has
always been a nation priority for Bangladesh since liberation. High population
density (1,117/km2) and low GDP (US$1,900/year) put food security as one of the
key priorities for national development (Tandon 2012; Faisal and Parveen 2004).
In Bangladesh, the Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF), Ministry of Food
and Disaster Management (MoFDM) and Ministry of Agriculture (MoA) are the
key national actors in relation to addressing climate change, agricultural development
and food security. The National Food Policy 2006 and draft the National Agricultural
Policy 1999 promotes attaining food-grain self-sufficiency as well as a reasonable
non-grain sufficiency. In the recent years, Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy and
Action Plan (BCCSAP) 2009 put highest priority on food security. Among six
pillars of BCCSAP, the first pillars talks about food security that addresses the
development of climate change resilient cropping system (e.g. agricultural research
to develop crop varieties, which are tolerant of flooding, drought and salinity, and
based on indigenous and other varieties suited to the needs of resource poor farmers),
fisheries and livestock systems to ensure local and national food security.
Despite policies designed to increase rice production to assure self-sufficiency,
food insecurity at the household level remains widespread, although there are
considerable regional variations. Half of the populations have incomes below a
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
8
U. Habiba et al.
calorie-based poverty line (Del Ninno et al. 2005). Even when aggregate food
supplies are adequate, a number of factors in Bangladesh prevent poor households
from accessing food. These include: (i) low income; (ii) lack of land ownership;
(iii) shortage of assets or access to credit; (iv) inability to access outside public
assistance or in-kind or cash transfer programs to supplement food acquisition
capacity; and (v) rising food prices (World Food Program). Adding together, food
security in Bangladesh has been adversely affected by both disasters and recent
escalating food prices. The country’s food insecure (<2,122 kcal/person/day) population is now estimated at 65 million (nearly half or 45 % of the population) and
nearly one quarter are deemed severely food insecure (<1,805 kcal/person/day)
(Ibid.). Half of all rural children are reported as chronically malnourished and 14 %
suffer from acute malnutrition (IFAD 2012).
1.5
The Effects of Climate Change on Food Security
in Bangladesh
Bangladesh experiences the climate change impacts in the form of temperature
extremes, erratic rainfall, and increased number of intensified floods, cyclones,
droughts, and prevalence of rough weather in the Bay. These phenomena will
adversely affect the country’s food security in various ways (Fig. 1.2):
Climate
change
Temperature
Rainfall, Sea level
rise
Flood, Drought
Cyclone, Salinity
intrusion
Food Security
(Agriculture,
Fisheries &
Livestock)
Fig. 1.2 The effects of climate change on food security in Bangladesh
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
1
Introduction and Overview of Food Security and Risk Reduction Issues
1.5.1
9
The Effects of Temperature on Agriculture
Rice in Bangladesh is the main staple food that accounts for 92 % of the total food
production, is disastrously affected by the climate change impacts. World Bank
(2009) predicts that national rice production will decline under all of the Climate
Change Scenarios and that the annual growth rate will reduce from 2.71 % to 2.55 %
under the Average Climate Change Scenario during the period of 2005–2050.
Table 1.2 shows the impact of climate change on rice yield in Bangladesh. High
temperature reduces yields of high yielding varieties of aus, aman and boro rice in
all areas of Bangladesh in all season. Of the three varieties of rice grown in
Bangladesh, aus rice seems to be the most vulnerable.
Moreover, it is indicated by various studies that a rise of 1–2 °C in combination
with lower solar radiation causes sterility in the rice spikelet. Fluctuation of temperature anomalies will hamper the vegetative and reproductive growth of crop production. A temperature increase of 4 °C would cause significant decrease in
production: some 28 % for rice and 68 % for wheat. Depending on the IPCC Fourth
Assessment Report, conducted a study where they found that considerable yield
reductions (1.5 %, 2.5 %, 4.4 % and 5.4 % for the years of 2020, 2030, 2040 and
Table 1.2 Impact of climate change on rice yield in Bangladesh
Climatic zone
South
North
Northern part
North
South
South
Eastern
Eastern
of Northern
Western
Western
Western
Central
Zone
Zone
Region
Zone
Zone
Zone
Zone
Current rice yield (tons/hectare)
Aus
3.38
2.95
1.86
2.12
2.06
2.08
2.99
Aman
3.76
3.68
2.54
2.67
2.33
2.44
3.24
Boro
4.33
4.43
3.48
3.17
2.79
2.67
3.86
Expected % of change in 2030
Aus
(5.3)
0.8
0.6
(1.0)
(2.1)
(2.8)
(3.3)
Aman
(4.9)
1.1
1.3
0.4
(1.9)
(2.6)
(3.0)
Boro
(4.6)
1.5
2.0
0.6
(1.6)
(2.2)
(2.6)
Expected % of change in 2050
Aus
(10.3)
(1.5)
2.5
(2.7)
(5.8)
(6.2)
(7.1)
Aman
(9.5)
(0.8)
3.5
(2.3)
(5.3)
(5.6)
(6.8)
Boro
(8.5)
3.5
5.2
1.9
(4.6)
(4.9)
(6.4)
Expected % of change in 2080
Aus
(21.2)
(3.4)
4.2
(5.6)
(12.3)
(14.0)
(16.5)
Aman
(19.9)
(2.7)
5.5
(5.1)
(11.9)
(13.2)
(15.2)
Boro
(18.6)
6.4
7.3
3.6
(11.5)
(12.3)
(13.9)
Here () means negative
Source: Adopted from assessing the costs of climate change and adaptation in South Asia, Mahfuz
Ahmed and Suphachol Suphachalasai, June 2014
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
10
U. Habiba et al.
2050 accordingly) from the effects of temperature on the yield of boro rice. Likewise,
with the change in temperature by 2 °C and 4 °C, the prospect of growing wheat
and potato would be severely damaged. Production loss may exceed 60 % of the
achievable yields (Karim 1993). For wheat, grain weight declines by 16 % for every
5 °C increase beyond 25 °C temperature (Abrol et al. 1996). Higher temperature has
negative effect on soil organic matter also. Thus yield reductions under changed
climatic conditions could significantly affect food production and food security in
Bangladesh. As a result, food insecurity will occur.
1.5.2
The Effects of Rainfall on Agriculture
Crop production in Bangladesh is predominantly rainfed. Hence, the onset, duration,
amount and the periodic aberrations of rainfall dictate the nature and type of crops
to be grown and the sequence of farming activities. The uneven distribution of monsoon rains in space and time over different parts of the country may lead to periodic
drought and flood conditions. All crops have critical stages when it needs water for
their growth and development. It was found that for 1 mm increase in rainfall at
vegetative, reproductive and ripening stages decreased the Aman rice production by
0.036, 0.230 and 0.292 ton respectively. Decreasing trend of rainfall in winter and
pre monsoon reduce yields of both broadcast and transplanted Aman and delay the
sowing of pulses and potatoes. Boro, wheat and other crops grown in the dry season
are also periodically affected by this change of climate variables. Furthermore,
scarcity of water limits crop production while irrigation coverage is only 56 % as
delivered by the Bangladesh Agriculture Development Corporation (BADC). As a
result, it has a great negative impact on the food system of the country.
1.5.3
The Effects of Drought on Agriculture
Drought takes place in Bangladesh more frequently than the past because of climate
change (NDMC 2006) and it appears in this country in every 5 years. Each year 0.45
million ha of land is affected by very severe drought during the rabi season while
0.40 and 0.34 million ha are affected during the pre-kharif and kharif seasons,
respectively. Moreover, Tanner et al. (2007) mentioned that about 2.7 million ha of
land in Bangladesh are vulnerable to annual drought. It is a recurrent phenomenon
in some parts of the country, but the north-west region is mostly drought-prone area
because of high rainfall variability (Shahid and Behrawan 2008).
Drought of different intensities occurs in Bangladesh that has a significant impact
on agriculture and agricultural products. For instance, the consecutive drought of
1978 and 1979 directly affected 42 % of cultivated land and reduced rice production
by an estimation of 2 million ton (Brammer 1987). Likewise, the drought of 1994–1995
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
1
Introduction and Overview of Food Security and Risk Reduction Issues
11
led to a decrease in rice and wheat production of 3.5 × 106 tons (Rahman and Biswas
1995). On the other hand, drought in 1997 caused a reduction of around 1 million
ton of food grain, of which about 0.6 million ton were transplanted Aman rice.
In the recent years, data from 2006 indicated that drought caused 25 %–30 % crop
reduction in the northwestern part of Bangladesh (Rahman et al. 2008). Apart from
rice crop, drought affects other crops, such as jute, wheat, corn, potatoes, sugarcane,
different types of pulses and oilseeds, and vegetables and cause significant damage
in production where irrigation is limited (Banglapedia 2006).
1.5.4
The Effects of Sea Level Rise on Agriculture
Sea level rise would affect the southern part, about 47,000 km2 coastal areas of
Bangladesh that is equivalent to 32 % of total landmass (CEDR 2009). It affects the
agriculture in three ways, i.e., by salinity intrusion, by flooding and by increasing
cyclone frequency and its depth of damage. Combined effects of these three factors
decrease agriculture production in the coastal zone. However, the losses of total
land and agricultural land from possible rises in sea level are presented in Table 1.3.
It is apparent from Table 1.3 that a maximum sea level rise of 0.50 m by the year of
2030 might lead to 11 % loss of total landmass, which would submerge 215,000–
395,000 ha (hectare) agricultural land of the country. The situation might be worse
in 2100 for a continuous rise in sea level.
In addition to this, sea level rise cause inundation of more area which is already
reported by scientist. With the expected 1 m rise in sea level, it is predicted that
20 % of the southern Bangladesh will be under water and will displace 25–30 M
people (Habibullah et al. 1998; World Bank 2000; Agrawala et al. 2003; Faisal and
Parveen 2004; Ahmed 2006).
With this contrast, salinity intrusion due to sea level rise will decrease agricultural production by unavailability of fresh water and soil degradation (MoEF 2011).
There is growing evidence that high salinity levels have adverse effects on rice that
prevents growth, reduces germination, causes browning of rice fields (Gain 1995)
and decreases rice production (Ali 2006). Salinity has further caused increased
insect and disease infestation in the field crops in the coastal areas (Miah et al. 2004).
Table 1.3 Losses of total land and agricultural land from probable sea level rise
Year 2030
Characteristics
Minimum
Sea level rise (meter)
0.30
Share of area inundated (in %)
6
Loss of agricultural land (in 000 hectare) 215
Source: Adopted from Rashid and Islam (2007)
Maximum
0.50
11
395
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Year 2100
Minimum
1.00
17
610
Maximum
1.50
22
790
12
1.5.5
U. Habiba et al.
The Effects of Flood on Agriculture
Flood is a regular phenomenon in Bangladesh. It tends to occur between April and
May, and September to November (NAPA 2005). Higher discharge and low drainage capacity, in combination with increased backwater effects, would increase the
frequency of such devastating floods under climate change scenarios. Every year,
one fifth of the country is flooded and in extreme cases, two-thirds of the country
can be inundated (Mirza 2002). Recently, it has been estimated that about 7.2 Mha,
about half of the total land area are flood prone.
Floods cause colossal losses of crops, poultry and animals. The excessive monsoon rainfall (80 % of the total rainfall) occurs during July to September, causes
early, high and late floods and hampers crop production, since 60 % of the cereals
are produced during that period. Prolonged floods would tend to delay Aman plantation, resulting in significant loss of potential Aman production, as observed during
the floods of 1998. The 1988 flood caused reduction of agricultural production by
45 % (Karim et al. 1996). Different intensities of flood caused massive destruction
of the crop production as well as economy. Table 1.4 shows the adverse effects of
the major recent floods in Bangladesh.
1.5.6
The Effects of Cyclone on Agriculture
The impacts of cyclone in the coastal of Bangladesh are widespread. Climate change
increases the frequency and higher peak intensity of cyclones in the Bay of Bengal
during the month of April to May and Mid September to mid October. As a consequence of cyclone, an immense damage is occurred for crop production. Table 1.5
depicts the agricultural losses due to cyclone in different years.
As, rice the main food in Bangladesh, therefore, cyclone has devastating effects
on the rice production of the coastal area in Bangladesh. For instance, in November
2007, cyclone Sidr hit the southern region of Bangladesh affecting 33 districts with
an economic impact of $1.7 billion. Approximately 2.5 million acres of agricultural
land are damaged, including approximately 1 million tons of rice and 350,000 trees
were uprooted by the storm. FAO/GIEWS Global Watch (2007) reported that at the
Table 1.4 Comparison of losses resulting from recent large floods
Item
Inundated area of Bangladesh (percent)
People affected (million)
Livestock killed (Nos.)
Crops fully/partly damaged (million ha)
Rice production losses (million tons)
Total losses (in USD billion)
Source: World Bank (2007)
1988
60
45
172,000
2.12
1.65
1.4
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
1998
68
31
26,564
1.7
2.06
2.0
2004
38
36
8,318
1.3
1.00
2.3
2007
42
14
40,700
2.1
1.2
1.1
1
Introduction and Overview of Food Security and Risk Reduction Issues
13
Table 1.5 The crop losses due to cyclone in Bangladesh
Year
1970
1985
1986
1988
1989
1990
1991
1994
1995
1996
1997
2007
2009
Crops damaged fully (Acre)
3,350,000
39,500
17,800
2,316,042
38,712
171,099
133,272
23,986
2,593
2,431
254,755
461,819
350,000
Crops damaged fully (Acre)
–
86,590
84,837
1,597,780
38,629
242,897
791,621
57,912
42,644
4,933
59,788
1,027,399
–
time of the passage of cyclone, SIDR, the main 2007 “Aman” rice crop, accounting
for about 70 % of the annual production in the most affected area, was nearly to
harvest. According to the estimate by Department of Agricultural Extension of
Bangladesh, the loss in rice equivalent is found at 1.23 million tons, with 535,707
tons in the 4 severely affected districts, 555,997 tons in badly affected 9 districts and
203,600 tons in moderately affected 17 districts in Bangladesh. On the other hand,
cyclone Aila 2009 reasons for destruction over 350,000 acres of crop land.
Livestock
Livestock sector is largely affected by climate change variability. Its production is
also affected by the climate changes due to reduction in the quality and availability
of feed, water, increased diseases and other environmental stresses. Analytical evidence on the impacts of climate change on livestock is relatively scanty in
Bangladesh. Chowdhury and Karim (2009) indicated that livestock production
could be affected by the climate changes due to reduction in the quality and availability of feed and water, heat and other environmental stresses, and preponderance
of livestock parasites, pests, and diseases. The average temperature in Bangladesh is
18 °C in winter and 28 °C in the summer. If global warming causes Bangladesh
temperature to rise further 2 °C by 2050, together with relative humidity of 60–95 %,
all most all species of livestock will be under heat stress conditions. As a result of
heat stress, animals suffer from elevated body temperature, increased respiration
rates, increased maintenance energy requirement, increased feed nutrient utilization,
decreased dry matter intake, reduced milk production and hampered reproductive
performance. Heat stress reduces disease resistance and increases morbidity and
mortality of animal species. Reductions in milk production and reproductive performance are economic losses to cattle, goat and sheep producers.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
U. Habiba et al.
14
Fisheries
Climate change is likely to adversely affect both the fresh water and marine fishes
in Bangladesh. It affects habitat’s alteration, fish reproduction, fish migration, natural
fish breeding and fish biology. Fish reproduction, growth and migration patterns are
all affected by temperature, rainfall and hydrology (Ficke et al. 2007). Increased
salinity and change in water quality can prompt a change in species composition
and distribution especially in coastal areas. However, salinity intrusion threatened
fresh water fish production, at the same time, creating opportunities for catching and
cultivating brackish and marine species. In 2007, the cyclone Sidr caused damages
and losses of US$6.7 million to fisheries sectors. It is reported by Bangladesh
Fisheries Development Corporation (BFDC) that the fishery resources in the EEZ
area of the Bay of Bengal have declined by around 25–30 % over the last couple of
decades. Moreover, FAO (2009) reports that around 100 important fish species have
disappeared from the Bay of Bengal over the last few decades.
In recent years, natural fish stocks have declined due to natural and manmade
catastrophes, degradation of aquatic environments and reduction of many wetlands
and water areas. The flood plain fisheries are the main sources of fish resources of
Bangladesh. But due to erratic behavior of seasonal flood, these fish resources will
be worst hit. There is a considerable threat of losing over 4 million metric ton of
fisheries by the year 2030. Timing, extent and duration of rains and floods greatly
influence reproduction, migration and growth of fishes. Delay in onset of rains and
floods may affect the breeding and maturation success of fish, which in turn will
result in the reduced fish production from rivers and floodplain (NAPA 2005).
Moreover, increased aridity, reduced dry season precipitation and extended dry
spell, particularly in northwest region of Bangladesh, will lead to the drying up of
or retain too little water (not adequate for survival of fish) in floodplain fish pits,
depressions, ditches etc. As a flood plain area, inland open water fisheries of Dhaka
region is suffering from reduced fish production. Every year hundred of culture
ponds float due to floods resulting in loss of fish and poor fish farmers incur financial
losses. This effect of climate variability is posing a great threat to the substance of
pond fish culture as well.
The combined effect of all climatic impacts would have severe consequences on
the productivity of agriculture and thus the livelihoods of a large number of poor
people, especially those who are already food insecure and vulnerable.
1.6
Risk Reduction: The Promising Issue of Food Security
Since Bangladesh is expected to experience of climate related hazards on an unprecedented scale, it is necessary to scale up and accelerate efforts in both disaster risk
reduction (DRR) and climate change adaptation. It is widely accepted that DRR
directly contributes to climate change adaptation. The 2005 Hyogo Framework for
Action specifically identifies the need to “promote the integration of risk reduction
associated with existing climate variability and future climate change…”. Parties to
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
1
Introduction and Overview of Food Security and Risk Reduction Issues
15
the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change also stressed DRR
to advance adaptation in the December 2007 Bali Action Plan, which calls for
enhanced action on risk management and risk reduction. The Cancun Adaptation
Framework promotes enhanced adaptation on climate change related DRR
strategies, taking into consideration the Hyogo Framework for Action, early warning
systems, risk assessment and management, sharing and transfer mechanisms at
local, national, sub regional and regional levels, as appropriate.
According to IPCC’s prediction “by 2025 this country is on course to lose 17 %
of its land and 30 % of its food production and as a result poverty will increase”
(Planetizen 2008). Agriculture has considerable influence on food security, rural
livelihoods and thus, the overall growth of the country. Yet, the sector is extremely
vulnerable to disaster and climate induced risks. Flood, cyclone, drought, flash
flood and other disasters are the major setbacks for agriculture and its development
in Bangladesh. Climate change and its variability also pose great risk and negative
impacts on productivity. Thus, disaster and climatic risk management in agriculture
is a major challenge for Bangladesh in achieving sustainable development.
As, both disaster risks and climate change threaten food security, therefore, to
ensure food security, activities in the agriculture sector must be integrated with
DRR and CCA. At present, there are a number of areas where DRR and CCA naturally
converge. In their respective efforts to reduce exposure to hazards and decrease
vulnerability to long-term climatic changes, DRR and CCA both benefit from livelihood diversification and improved resource management practices that increase the
food security of at-risk populations. Additionally, both have an interest in minimizing loss and damages incurred through extreme weather events that are – through
short-term climate variability or more profound, slow onset processes – influenced
by climate change. The incorporation of DRR expertise in implementation could
help to increase the pace at which CCA efforts move from planning to action.
Meanwhile, DRR can also learn from the long-term perspectives of CCA in order
to ensure that DRR activities align with shifting climatic realities, and not just
historical experience.
Disaster risk reduction (DRR) in the form of prevention, mitigation and
preparedness can minimize the risk and vulnerability of the agricultural sector in
Bangladesh from the impact of natural disasters. DRR can also pave the way to
build the foundation for climate change adaptation (CCA). The types of issues
required for climate change adaptation – in other words, how to manage and cope
with increased variability and extremes of events – share a great deal with disaster
risk reduction measures. Therefore, strengthening DRR and CCA in agricultural
sector has emerged as important issue warranting strategic investment.
References
Agrawala S, Ota T, Ahmed AU, Smith J, Aalst MV (2003) Development and climate change in
Bangladesh: focus on coastal flooding and the Sundarbans. Organisation for Economic
Co-operation and Development, Paris
Abrol PY, Gadgil S, Plant GB (1996) Climate vulnerability and agriculture. Narosa Publishing
House, New Delhi
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
16
U. Habiba et al.
Ahmed UA (2006) Bangladesh: climate change impacts and vulnerability - a synthesis, Dhaka
Ali AMS (2006) Rice to shrimp: land use/land cover changes and soil degradation in Southwestern
Bangladesh. Land Use Policy 23:421–435
Bals C, Harmellng S, Windfuhr M (2008) Climate change, food security and the right to adequate
food. Germanwatch, Stuttgart
Banglapedia (2006) Drought in Bangladesh. http://banglapedia.search.com.bd/HT/D_0284.htm.
Accessed 5 Sept 2014
BBS (Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics) (2013) Planning Division, Ministry of Planning,
Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh. http://www.bbs.gov.
bd/WebTestApplication/userfiles/Image/BBS/GDP_2012_13.pdf. Accessed 12 Sept 2014
Bhuiyan NI, Paul DNR, Jabber MA (2002) FeedIng the extra millions by 2025: challenges for rice
research and extension in Bangladesh. In: Proceedings of the workshop on modern rice cultivation in Bangladesh, 29–31 Jan, pp 4–23
Brammer H (1987) Drought in Bangladesh: lessons for planners and administrators. Disasters
11(1):21–29
Bangladesh Agriculture Statistics (2013) Available at: http://www.agriculturebd.com. Accessed 27
Aug 2014
BBS (Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics) (2010) Planning division, Ministry of Planning, Government
of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh
CEDR (2009) EM-DAT international disaster database. Visited on 11 January 2010, Centre for
Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters, Brussels, Belgium. Available at: http://www.
emdat.be/database. Accessed 27 Sept 2014
Chowdhury SA, Karim Z (2009) Implication of climate change on livestock production of
Bangladesh. Submitted in Electronic Journal, Livestock Research for Rural Development
Del Ninno C, Dorosh PA, Subbarao K (2005). Food aid and food security in the short and long run
country experience from Asia and sub-Saharan Africa. http://siteresources.worldbank.org/
SOCIALPROTECTION/Resources/SP-Discussion-papers/Safety-Nets-DP/0538.pdf
Devereux S, Edwards J (2009) Climate change and food security. IDS Bulletin 35(3)
Faisal IM, Parveen S (2004) Food security in the face of climate change, population growth and
resource constraints: implications for Bangladesh. Environ Manage 34(4):487–498
FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization) (1996) Rome Declaration on World Food Security and
World Food Summit Plan of Action. http://www.fao.org/DOCREP/003/W3613E/W3613E00.
HTM. Accessed on 23 Sept
FAO/GIEWS Global Watch (2007) Livelihood of over 8.9 million people adversely affected by
Cyclone Sidr in Bangladesh. http://www.fao.org/giews/english/shortnews/bangladesh071221.
htm. Accessed 31 Aug 2012
FAO (2009). Building adaptive capacity to climate change. Policies to sustain livelihoods and
fisheries. New Directions in Fisheries – A Series of Policy Briefs on Development Issues.
No. 08. Rome. 16 pp.
Ficke AD, Myrick CA, Hansen LJ (2007) Potential impacts of global climate change on freshwater
fisheries. Rev Fish Biol Fish 17(4):581–613
Gain P (1995) Attack of the shrimps. TWR 59:18–19
Government of Bangladesh, Ministry of Environment and Forests, Department of Environment,
Climate Change Cell. Available at:http://www.climatechangecell/publications/06ccimpactvuln
erability.pdf. Accessed 30 Sept 2014
IFAD (2012) Rural poverty in Bangladesh. http://www.ruralpovertyportal.org/country/home
ILO (2007) Chapter 4. Employment by sector. In Key indicators of the labour market (KILM),
5th edition. www.ilo.org/public/english/employment/start/klim/download/kilm04pdf
Karim Z (1993) Preliminary agricultural vulnerability assessment: drought impacts due to climate
change in Bangladesh. IPCC Eastern Hemisphere
Karim Z, Hussain SG, Ahmed M (1996) Assessing impacts of climate change variations on
foodgrain production in Bangladesh. Water, Air Soil Pollut 92:53–62
Mirza MMQ (2002) Global warming and changes in the probability of occurrence of floods in
Bangladesh and implications. Glob Environ Chang 12:127–138
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
1
Introduction and Overview of Food Security and Risk Reduction Issues
17
MOEF (Ministry of Environment and Forest) (2009) National Adaptation Programme of Action.
MOEF and United Nations Development Programme, Dhaka
MoEF (Ministry of Environment and Forest) (2011) Climate Change and Agriculture in
Bangladesh, Information Brief, Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of the
People’s Republic of Bangladesh
Miah MY, Mannan MA, Quddus KG, Mahmud AM, Baida T (2004) Salinity on cultivable land and
its effects on crops. Pak J Biol Sci 7:8,1322–1326
National Adaptation Programme of Action (NAPA) (2005) Final report. Ministry of Environment
and Forest, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka
National Drought Mitigation Center (NDMC) (2006) What is drought? Understanding and
defining drought. http://www.drought.unl.edu/whatis/concept.htm
Planetizen (2008) Bangla Dommed? Available at: http://www.planetizen.com/node/33615.
Accessed 25 Aug 2014
Rahman A, Biswas PR (1995) Devours resources. Dhaka Cour 11(42):7–8
Rahman A, Alam M, Alam SS, Uzzaman MR, Rashid M, Rabbani G (2008) Risks, vulnerability
and adaptation in Bangladesh. Human Development Report 2007/08, Human Development
Report Office OCCASIONAL PAPER, 2007/13
Rashid MH, Islam MS (2007) Adoption to climate change for sustainable development of
Bangladesh agriculture. Bangladesh country paper for the 3rd session of Technical Committee
of Asian and Pacific Center for Agricultural Engineering and Machinery (APCAEM), 20–21
November 2007, Beijing
Schmidhuber J, Tubiello FN (2007) Global food security under climate change. Proc Natl Acad Sci
U S A 104(50):19703–19708
Shahid S, Behrawan H (2008) Drought risk assessment in the western part of Bangladesh. J Int Soc
Prev Mitig Nat Hazards 46:391–413
Tandon N (2012) Food Security, Women Smallholders and Climate Change in Caribbean SIDS,
International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth, Cape Town. www.ipcundp.org/pub/
IPCPolicyResearchBrief33.pdf. Accessed 21 Mar 2013
Tanner TM, Hassan A, Islam KMN, Conway D, Mechler R, Ahmed AU, Alam M (2007) ORCHID:
piloting climate risk screening in DFID Bangladesh. Detailed research report, Institute of
Development Studies, University of Sussex, Brighton, UK
United Nations (1975) Report of the world food conference, Rome, 5–16 November 1974,
New York
Viveros A (2012) Debt relief and development. World Bank, Washington, DC
World Bank (2007) Floods 2007 damage and needs assessment report, Dhaka
WFP (World Food Program) (2005) Bangladesh poverty Map 2005. Food Security at a glance: 7,
Food vulnerability. Available at: http://foodsecurityatlas.org/bgd/country/food-security-at-aglance#section-6. Accessed 17 Aug 2014
WFS (World Food Summit) (1996) Basic concepts of food security: definition, dimensions and
integrated phase classification. Available at: http://www.foodandenvironment.com/2013/01/
basic-concept-of-food-security.html (Accessed 24 Aug 2014)
World Bank (2009) Implication of climate change risks on food security in Bangladesh. South
Asian Region, 10 June 2009
World Bank (2000) Bangladesh: climate change & sustainable development, Report No. 21104
BD, Dhaka, Bangladesh
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 2
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure,
Demographic Changes, Urbanization
and Its Implication on Food Security
Sheikh M. Rafiqul Hasan and Umma Habiba
Abstract Geographical location along with overall economic status and huge
population, food security is a challenge for Bangladesh. Further different types of
natural disasters disrupts/undermine local food production every year contribute to
food insecurity, and create reliance on food aid. The link between population growth
and food security in the face of climate change is not limited to increased demand
for food. Population growth and urbanization also have serious blows on the food
supply and access for Bangladesh because of loss of agriculture land, fragmentation
of land and land development projects in fragile environments that unswervingly
affect food production. Therefore, this chapter focuses on the issues related to the
anthropogenic causes of food insecurity in the light of population growth, urbanization and socioeconomic paradigm.
Keywords Anthropogenic causes • Population • Urbanization • Food security •
Bangladesh
2.1
Introduction
The spectra of climate change, together with other global environmental changes
such as changes in water availability, and land cover, and altered nitrogen availability
and cycling (influenced by human activities), has increased concerns about achieving
food security, especially for the poor people (Gregory and Ingram 2000; Parry et al.
2001; Rosegrant and Cline 2003). In addition, according to Godfray et al. (2010)
S.M.R. Hasan
University of Dhaka, Dhaka, Bangladesh
U. Habiba (*)
Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture, Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: shimuagri@yahoo.com
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_2
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
19
S.M.R. Hasan and U. Habiba
20
population growth puts a pressure on food production, land availability, water use,
soil quality etc. There is also concern that meeting the global food demand due
to higher population and changing food preferences will further degrade the environment both through additional destruction of native vegetation and increased
intensification of cropped areas (Tilman et al. 2001). This may, in turn, further
undermine the food systems upon which food security is based.
By 2050 the world will need around 100 % more food than today. Urbanization
will be one of the most important demographic trends of the twenty-first century.
Indeed, virtually all the population growth expected during 2000–2030 will be
concentrated in the urban areas of the world. Growth will be particularly rapid in the
urban areas of the less developed regions, averaging 2.3 % per annum during 2000–
2030, consistent with a doubling time of 30 years. Although urban areas will encompass an increasing share of the world population, the proportion of people living in
very large urban agglomerate lived in cities of 10 million inhabitants or more.
Climate change will worsen the living conditions of the urban poor, farmers,
fishers and forest-dependent people who are already vulnerable and food insecure.
Hunger and malnutrition will increase. Urban poor communities, particularly those
living in already fragile environments/slums and squatters, face an immediate and
ever-growing risk of increased crop failure, loss of livestock, and reduced availability
of marine, aquaculture and forest products. More recurrent and more intense
extreme weather events will have bad impacts on food availability, accessibility,
stability and utilization, as well as on livelihood assets and opportunities in both
rural and urban areas. Poor people will be at risk of food insecurity due to loss of
assets and lack of adequate insurance coverage. Urban people’s ability to cope with
climate change impacts depends on the existing cultural and policy context, as well
as on socio-economic factors like gender, household composition, age, and the
distribution of household assets.
In the recent decades the agricultural sector including food security (production,
availability, and accessibility) faces many challenges stemming from growing
global populations, land degradation, and loss of agricultural land to urbanization.
Because of modern technology food production has been able to keep pace with
population growth on the global scale but there are serious regional deficits, and
millions of people are under threat of poverty related nutritional deficiencies
globally.
The first decade of the twenty-first century has seen quite a lot of indications of
a concerned future for global food security. The food price spike of 2008, with its
resulting food riots and consequential political changes in several countries, awoke
the world’s leaders to the re-appearance of this menace to human well-being and
social harmony.
Since the late 1980s, agricultural output has increased at rates and to levels that
are unprecedented in Bangladesh history. Much of the yield increase is attributed to
the breeding of high-yielding crop varieties, thorough use of inorganic fertilizers
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
2
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure, Demographic Changes, Urbanization…
21
and pesticides, spreading out of irrigation, and modern farm management. But since
the beginning of the 1990s yet another threat to agriculture has attracted much
attention. Many climatologists predict significant global warming in the coming
decades due to increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide and other trace gases. As a
result, major changes in hydrological regimes have also been predicted to occur.
The scale and geographical distribution of such climate-induced changes may affect
our ability to expand food production as required to feed a population of more
than 220 million people projected for the middle of this century. Climate change
could have sweeping effects on patterns of trade among nations, development, and
food security.
Away from what is known about greenhouse gases and the climate system,
however, lie great uncertainties: How much warming will occur, at what rate, and
according to what geographical and seasonal pattern? What secondary processes
will the warming trend induce, and what might be the physical and biological
impacts of such processes? Will some areas benefit while other areas suffer, and
who might the winners and losers are and if such damages are unavoidable, what
can be done to adapt or modify our systems so as to minimize or overcome them?
These are vital and intricate questions that have only begun to identify with them
and to build up methods for their analysis.
2.2
Anthropogenic Causes Related to Food Security
Bangladesh, one of the most densely populated countries in the world, has long
been suffering from food deficiency. Food crisis has become a vulnerable threat for
those people who live below the poverty line. Among all South Asian countries,
Bangladesh faces the most severe food crisis due to current food security challenges
resulted by climatic as well as anthropogenic causes. Among climatic factors,
changing monsoon, rising sea level, increasing temperature and climatic disasters
such as cyclone, flood, drought and salinity intrusion cause a substantial damage to
food production. According to the Ministry of Agriculture, the country loses about
80,000 ha of arable land due to the impact of climate change. On the other hand,
there are a number of anthropogenic factors that hamper to produce crop and impede
to attain food security. These include population growth, urbanization, loss of arable
land, lack of quality seeds, food habit of people (about 90 % is rice based),
inadequate credit support to the farmers, unfair pricing, insufficient investment in
agricultural research and agricultural mismanagement in terms of irrigation, use of
fertilizer and pesticides etc. These factors are severely affecting Bangladesh’s
agriculture, and its attempt to attain food security and self-sufficiency as well.
Therefore, the main anthropogenic factors that affect the food security in Bangladesh
are discussed under the following sub-headings:
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
22
2.2.1
S.M.R. Hasan and U. Habiba
Population
Bangladesh is one of the most densely populated countries in the world with a
population around 160 million and annual growth rate is estimated 1.6 % in the year
2012 (CIA The World Fact Book 2013). On the contrary, it is reported by Unnayan
Onneshan (2014), if the present trend of population growth of two million people
per year continues, Bangladesh will undoubtedly face far severe food shortages in
the next few years reaching a critical level by 2050 (Fig. 2.1). This figure demonstrates that population growth increases at a faster rate than food production from
2005 onwards. This is due to the increasing demand for additional food by the
middle-class people with rising income.
Half of the population in Bangladesh lives under poverty level and 30 % of the
population suffer from chronic malnutrition where children and women are the most
affected (Eminence 2013). Although government of Bangladesh is working towards
achieving Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and their priority is to eradicating
hunger and make Bangladesh food secure. According to the “National Food Policy
of Action 2008–2015” Bangladesh has achieved remarkable success in combating
food insecurity since 1990. Since then till 2004 the undernourished proportion of
the population has gone down from 40 % to 30 % but due to population growth the
actual number of people has increased from 39 to 44 million (NFPCSP 2008).
Bangladesh produces self-sufficient staple food mainly rice which is 94 % of all
food grain production rest of the food items are being mainly imported (NFPCSP
2008). Overpopulation in Bangladesh poses serious threat to food security leading
to large-scale food shortages. For example, over the last 50 years, Bangladesh did
not export rice except in 1974 because of the increase in population and overconsumption of food. Thus, to ensure the increase in rice production for feeding the
increased population is great challenge in Bangladesh.
Fig. 2.1 Projected amount of population and demand for rice (Adopted from Unnayan Onneshan
(2014))
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
2
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure, Demographic Changes, Urbanization…
2.2.2
23
Urbanization
As urbanization is a global phenomenon today, Bangladesh is experiencing a rapid
urbanization. Currently around 30 % of the population lives in urban settlement and
the trend show that it has increased steadily by 3.5 % annually. This rate might
increase rapidly due to the climate change and related hazards. The major reason for
urbanization today in Bangladesh because of climate related hazards like flood,
cyclones, river bank erosion etc. Therefore, people move to urban areas seeking
alternative livelihoods as they lacked job, land or any other earning options. Adding
together, due to rapid urbanization, cultivated lands are being filled with house
settlement, infrastructure and other related services to the meet of urban population.
Rising demands for energy, water, land and natural resources for rapid urban population have already posed a serious threat to the food security in the urban areas in
Bangladesh. For example, over extraction of ground water in cities has enhanced
risk of anthropogenic subsidence, exacerbating future food risks already set to
rise through climate change impacts and socio-economic changes. Moreover, the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) prediction stated that about
30 % of the land mass of Bangladesh can go under water if sea level rises. If the
effect of climate change worsens the country will face an extreme urbanization of
the internally displaced persons (IDP).
In urban and rural area, the main determinants of food are livelihood and nutrition security which is the same in Bangladesh. However, there is a wide variation in
the factors that affect these determinants. For example urban households in big
cities are more dependent on food purchase, which, if they have sufficient purchasing
power, can lead to a more varied diet and higher reliance on ‘ready-made’ and fast
foods, compared to rural households. Food access has a direct impact on dietary
diversity and has been seriously affected by rising food and fuel prices, conflict,
and the primary or secondary affect of natural disasters in urban areas across the
country- Bangladesh. Environmental issues (e.g., over-crowding, poor water and
sanitation, pollution, open sewerage and contamination) are most acute in
Bangladesh cities and exacerbated in slums and squatters.
Apart from that social networks in urban areas are based on political, religious,
economic and ethnic connections. Social support systems are weaker for the most
food insecure in urban areas, as they often do not have the same access to kin,
political or religious groups to offer and provide support as in rural areas. All of
which effects their social capital. On the contrary, migration between rural and
urban areas is two-way and often very context-specific depending on the economic,
social and political factors. It is essential to understand rural–urban linkages in analysis of the livelihoods and food security of the urban poor as there is a high level of
interdependency in many contexts and households may exploit opportunities for
seasonal migration to mitigate risk.
Adding together, significant challenges are faced in urban food security and
nutrition programming (by government, UN and (I)NGOs), beginning with assessment
and targeting issues when faced with a highly mobile, densely packed population,
where in- and out-migration is a constant feature. Although urban areas have
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
24
S.M.R. Hasan and U. Habiba
traditionally been considered better served in terms of healthcare, education and
sanitation, a closer look at the evidence reveals that proximity does not equate
to access. Both cost of services and urban livelihood strategies, including long
journeys to places of work and long working hours, limit access by the urban poor
to healthcare, community nutrition services or improved water sources. Further
climate change situation will just make the condition more critical for urban
food security.
The urban poor living in informal settlements and slums face a unique set of
challenges compared to their rural counterparts in the face of double dilemma
climate change and food insecurity. Almost exclusively dependent on the market for
food and other necessary items, slum dwellers are very vulnerable to price increases
and other market shocks and this will more challenging due to climate change in the
near future in Bangladesh. The population density of slums, in combination with
poor sanitation and limited access to clean water, also translates into high transmission risk for communicable diseases.
Urban areas are more complex than rural areas, at every level from governance
to nutrition and food security assessments, requiring strong urban platforms and
coordination at all levels. There is a need to work more closely to improve the
capacity of governments and national actors, as well as developing clearer ways of
working with the private sector for service delivery and programme scale up. Clear
urban strategies are required by governments, UN and (I) NGOs and these should
influence the emerging thoughts of donors on the development of comprehensive
urban funding strategies.
2.2.3
Loss of Cultivable Land
Rapid population growth, along with unplanned urbanization causes the areas of
cultivable land to be used for non-agricultural purpose, especially for building residence for increasing population. Statistics suggest that between the periods from
1961 to 2007, the agriculture experienced a two-fold reduction in the availability of
cultivable land. Production during this period increased due to mainly to the use of
input by the farmers at a higher rate on the same piece of land. For instance, 1 metric
ton of food was produced from 0.406 ha of land in 1961, whereas same production
was achieved from the land below 0.14 ha in 2007.
However, the loss of agricultural lands has become a major concern for food
security in Bangladesh. Almost one-third of the Bangladesh farmland have disappeared in the last 30 years because of unplanned urbanization and transfer of lands
to other uses, for example, human settlements and industrial purposes. Figure 2.2
shows the decreasing trend of net cultivable land in Bangladesh. Bangladesh is a
land-scarce country where per capita cultivated land is only 12.5 decimals. It is
claimed that every year about 1 % of the farmland in the country is being converted
to non-agricultural uses. According to the 2009 report of the Planning Commission,
80,000 ha of agricultural lands are being converted every year to non-agricultural
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
2
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure, Demographic Changes, Urbanization…
25
Fig. 2.2 Trend of loss in the availability of net cultivable land (Adopted from Unnayan Onneshan
(2014))
uses mainly for the expansion of housing facilities, and building infrastructures
such as roads, markets, educational institutions, electricity and industrial establishments. In 1980, Bangladesh had 9 million ha of farmlands, which were reportedly
reduced to about six million in 2012 (Rashid 2012). At present, the cultivable land
has been declining by almost 1 % per year, and everyday 325 bighas land are being
lost to other uses due to increased demand for habitation, industrial and commercial
establishments and transportation infrastructure that pose challenges to the country’s food security (Barua 2012). Bangladesh’s current population growth rate is
1.42 % against the decline of agricultural land area by 1 % annually. Experts warn
that at the rate that agricultural land declines against the growing population, it will
be very difficult to ensure food security after 10 years (Rashid 2012).
2.2.4
Soil Degradation
Soil degradation takes place in Bangladesh that is a major constraint to agricultural
production. It is estimated that some of 2 million metric tons of nutrients are
removed from Bangladesh soils annually. On the other hand, major food crops
remove about 2.98 million tons of nutrients annually against a total addition of 0.72
million tons. Unless compensated through balanced application of nutrients every
year. Declination of soil fertility, erosion and salinization affect 5.6–8.7 million ha,
5.3 and 3.05 million ha of land, accordingly. However, the fertility of land is
expected to decline and so will its productivity. According to appraisal report on
Bangladesh’s soil resources, soils on about 6.10 million ha contain low (less than
1 %) organic matter (OM), 2.15 million ha contain low (1–2 %) OM and the remaining contain high (more than 2 %) of OM. N deficiency has been observed all types
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
S.M.R. Hasan and U. Habiba
26
of soil and the deficiency of P, Zn, S, B is widespread. Moreover, it is predicted that
3 °C rise in atmospheric temperature would cause an 11 % decrease in soil OM to
30-cm depth, which will adversely affect plant growth and reduce crop yield.
2.2.5
Lack of Sufficient Fertilizer
About 60 % of arable lands of Bangladesh are deficient in N, P, and K. Organic matter
content of soils is much below the critical level of 1.5 % (Karim 1997). Farmers
normally use recommended doses urea in their agricultural land. Because of high
prices, they apply P and K fertilizers at the rates that are far below the recommended
amount. Chemical fertilizers are not normally integrated with organic manures. It is
thus evident that farmers virtually do not use balanced fertilizers that are necessary
for high productivity. Insufficient amount of fertilizers is severely damaging the
food production in Bangladesh (Mondal 2010). In the past, Bangladesh witnessed
fertilizer crisis in the years of 1974, 1984 and 1989. Recently, fertilizer crisis
occurred in the years of 2005, 2007 and 2008. Still the poor farmers do not have
access to the sufficient amount of fertilizers in sufficient for their agriculture
(Jaim and Akter 2012).
2.2.6
Inefficient Water Use
Water use efficiency in Bangladesh is extremely low. On the average, 25–30 % of
irrigation water is used by crops and the rest is lost due to faulty flood irrigation
system (Karim 1997). Conservation of rain water during monsoon is virtually nonexistent that could be utilized for irrigating crops during dry season. Studies show
that irrigation with surface water instead of underground water might reduce the
vulnerability to hazards of climate change. Irrigation cost in Bangladesh is relatively high due mainly to high price of diesel. It is to be mentioned that more than
80 % irrigation pumps in the country are diesel operated.
2.2.7
Pests and Diseases
The use of fertilizers, quality seeds and irrigation together cannot ensure sustainable
production unless timely and appropriate measures for the management of pests and
diseases are simultaneously pursued. It is important to note that the incidence of
diseases and pests has lately become very severe due to the adverse effects of
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
2
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure, Demographic Changes, Urbanization…
27
climate change, particularly rise in temperature (IPCC 2007). It is estimated that
4–14 % of rice yield in Bangladesh is lost every year by different insect pests.
Bacterial leaf blight (BLB) and nematode (ufra) are now the serious diseases in rice.
But the technologies resistant to pests and diseases are still very limited. Use of 1 PM
technology is limited to rice and few vegetables.
2.2.8
Lack of Quality Seeds
The demand for quality of seeds in Bangladesh is still weak because there is a lack
of costly seed preservation and processing facilities (Mondal 2010). Of the total
seed requirement, only about 6 % quality seeds were supplied in 2003–2004
(Huda et al. 2004) although seed as an input could increase crop production by
10–15 %. Contribution of private sector and NGOs to quality seed production is still
insignificant because they lack costly seed preservation and processing facilities.
The Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation (BADC) obtains subsidy
from the government which allows it to provide seeds at a lower cost. Poor farmers,
however, have less access to BADC seeds and thus they have to depend on private
sectors to purchase quality rice seeds at a high price. On the other hand, homegrown seeds produced by poor farmers are of inferior quality than that of BADC
research organization’s seed in terms of seed moisture, germination, and vigour and
seed health. In most of the cases, farmers do not adopt and apply recommended
packages such as the use of quality seeds, balanced fertilizers, isolation, rouging,
irrigation, plant protection and different postharvest activities for rice and wheat
seed production (Islam et al. 2010). The supply of the good-quality of seeds is only
40 % of its demand. Survey results have shown that 64 % of Bangladeshi farmers
use their own wheat seeds year after year. Twenty six percent of the farmers purchase from other farmers in local markets and only 10 % of the seeds are purchased
from the government’s seed suppliers (Banu et al. 2004).
2.2.9
Inadequate Credit Support to Farmers
About 90 % farmers of Bangladesh are small and marginal (below 2.5 acres). They
are very often constrained by finance and thus cannot afford high cost for management. They have very limited access to institutional credit because of collateral
requirement. At present, only 27 % of farmers receive institutional credit. The credit
amount again is quite inadequate and not advanced in time. They are also not eligible for microcredit of NGOs that deal mainly with landless farmers. The situation
compels these farmers to apply inputs, especially expensive P and K fertilizers far
below the recommended doses that finally result in low yield.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
28
2.2.10
S.M.R. Hasan and U. Habiba
Rising Food Price
The increasing level of food price is one of the major current challenges of food
security in Bangladesh. Since 2007, the food price of essential food commodities
has been rising rapidly, reaching to a peak in the 2008 worldwide food crisis.
The 2008 price hike went on to worsen the situation leading to the number of
food insecure people (less than 2,122 kcal/day) to increase by 7.5 million and the
number of severely food insecure people (less than 1,805 kcal/day) to increase by
6.9 million. If 2005 is taken as base year of food price hike, the increasing price of
foods in 2011 and 2012 is also a startling. The prices of coarse, medium and
fine rice have been nearly doubled in 2011 compared to those of 2005. During
2010–2011 period, price of rice in Bangladesh has increased by close to 30 %, flour
by 50 %, lentils by 15 % and chicken by 37 %. In 2011, the overall inflation rate was
10.70 %. Food inflation stood at 7.83 % in 2012 while it was 12.83 % in the previous
year. Food inflation rose to 7.33 % in December from 6.45 % in November 2012.
According FAO report, in 2012, food price was at record level, having risen
from 1.4 % in September following an increase of 6.0 % in July 2012 (Barua 2012).
This food inflation rate increased to 7.91 % in 2005 and at the same time nearly
0.2 million people lived under poverty line. Food inflation of 11.0 % (12-month
average) in April 2011 indicates that more people are likely to go under poverty line
in the upcoming years.
The poor are hit hardest during these price shocks as they spend more of their
income on food. The price of rice is mostly controlled by middle-men not by market
factors such as demand and supply. Moreover, the structure of domestic rice market
is very complex. The presence of restrictive business practices and other disruptive
actions (such as deliberate supply shortage) in the rice market contribute to a significant gap between farm-gate price and consumer price of rice. Therefore, international speculation helped business elements make possible to create an artificial
crisis in domestic rice market leading to a significant increase in food prices in
recent years. The rural households suffer mostly from increased food price because
they are net buyers of rice.
2.2.11
Food Adulteration
Food adulteration with poisonous chemicals has reached a dangerous proportion.
Food adulteration has been happening on a massive scale for the past half a decade
due to increased investment, an expanding market, and high consumer demand.
In food market, basic food items like rice, fish, fruits, vegetables, and sweetmeats
are adulterated with hazardous chemicals in an indiscriminate manner. In 2004, a
random survey conducted by Public Health Laboratory of Dhaka City Corporation,
reported that more than 76 % food items on the market were found adulterated.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
2
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure, Demographic Changes, Urbanization…
2.2.12
29
Poverty-Malnutrition Nexus
Bangladesh is one of the poorest countries in the world and despite its recent strides
in GDP growth it remains remarkably low when compared to the global scale.
Almost 40 % of people in rural Bangladesh live on less than $1.25 per day and 60 %
of that income is spent on food. Table 2.1 shows different aspects of poverty in
Bangladesh. Poverty and malnutrition appears to be largely a rural phenomenon in
Bangladesh and though huge difference exists across economic groups and gender.
Food insecurity is not only a result of insufficient food production and inadequate
distribution, but also of the financial inability of the poor to purchase sufficient
food. Bangladesh has made appreciable progress in reducing the percentage of
population living below 1.25$ a day from 59 % in 1991–1992 to 31.5 % in 2010.
However, more than 17 % of the population is still extremely poor. According to a
FAO 2012 report, more than 40 Bangladeshis are undernourished and don’t have
access to adequate amounts of safe, nutritious food to sustain a healthy and productive
life. Bangladesh is ranked 129th out of 169 countries in the 2010 Human development Index (HDI), and 68th in a list of 79 countries in the 2012 Global Hunger
Index (GHI). For those making less than US$1.25 a day, access to adequate food
from the market is often too costly. More than 90 % of rural Bangladeshis don’t get
sufficient level of dietary vitamin-A and iron. Annually, under-nutrition contributes
to more than a third of child deaths and to at least a fifth of maternal deaths in
Bangladesh. As a result, malnutrition in Bangladesh remains among the highest in
the world.
Malnourishment leads to poor health hence individuals fail to provide for their
families. Chronic hunger produces an array of outcomes that perpetuate malnutrition, reduce the ability of adults to work and to give birth to healthy children, and
erode children’s ability to learn and lead productive and healthy lives. Reduced
performance at professional level undermines a country’s real potential for socioeconomic development. The two main reasons why livelihood and food security
issues remain critical in Bangladesh are, (i) the heavy dependence of the majority of
the population on the agricultural sector for employment and (ii) the large number
of undernourished people, the majority of whom are below the poverty line and
Table 2.1 Poverty dynamics of Bangladesh
Year
1996
2000
2005
2010
Poverty headcount ratio at national poverty line
50.10
48.90
40.00
31.51
(% of population)
Poverty headcount ratio at $1.25 a day (PPP)
60.91
58.59
50.47
43.25
(% of population)
Poverty gap at $1.25 a day (PPP) (%)
19.93
18.61
14.17
11.17
Income share held by lowest 20 %
8.66
8.66
8.79
8.88
Gini index
33.46
33.36
33.22
33.12
Source: Adapted from World Bank report, Global Poverty Working Group. Data are based on
World Bank’s poverty assessments and poverty Reduction Strategies in Bangladesh
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
30
S.M.R. Hasan and U. Habiba
spend a considerable proportion of their total income on food. Increased food
productions alone never go to bring significant progress in combating hunger and
malnutrition if it is not combined with higher incomes and improved livelihoods for
the poorest.
2.2.13
Unemployment and Lack of Economic Growth
According to World Food Program (WFP), in recent years, devastating cyclones and
floods, the dramatic increase in food prices in 2008 and the global recession have all
impacted economic growth in Bangladesh. All of these factors in turn have led to a
deterioration of food security and nutritional situation in the country. The lack of
food security sometimes creates huge impact on the future of children, are being
taken out of school to engage in income-generating activities to meet sufficient food
supply. Male members are also migrating to cities in search of employment to cope
with the high price hike of food and to meet their basic demand of food.
2.2.14
Insufficient Investment in Research
Investment in agricultural research in Bangladesh now stands at only 0.20 of GDP
(Karim 1997) even though agriculture contributes to 19.10 % of GDP and employs
50.28 % of labour force. Low investment has resulted in the under functioning of
National Agricultural Research System (NARS). Scopes for promotion and training
of potential scientists in different fields are also limited due mainly to fund
constraint.
Apart from climate change, it can be said from the above discussion that there are
various anthropogenic factors that are interlinked with each other which ultimately
affect the food security in Bangladesh. The Fig. 2.3 highlights the anthropogenic
causes that are liable to boost up food insecurity in Bangladesh.
2.3
2.3.1
Government’s Initiatives on Food Security in Bangladesh
Level of Production Through Input Distribution Card
In 2012, the government of Bangladesh introduced an input distribution card to nine
million small and marginal farmers. The card is now used to obtain cash subsidies
for electricity and for fuel irrigation, for purchasing fertilizers at government fixed
prices and for other forms of government support. Now, yields are increasing as
more farmers adopt hybrid seeds varieties, invest in small-scale mechanization, and
use fertilizers and agrochemicals more efficiently.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
2
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure, Demographic Changes, Urbanization…
31
Fig. 2.3 Anthropogenic causes related to food security in Bangladesh
2.3.2
National Livestock Development Policy
In 2007, Bangladeshi government formulated a very comprehensive National
Livestock Development Policy (NLDP) to address the key challenges and opportunities for sustainable development of the livestock sub-sector and agricultural
production of Bangladesh.
2.3.3
Climate Change Strategic Action Plan
In 2009, the Prime Minister of Bangladesh adopted the Climate Change Strategic
Action Plan with 44 programs to develop capacity for meeting the impacts of
climate change of the next 25 years. The government also formed Multi-Donor
Trust Fund to attract the support of developed countries. Seventy four Prime
Minister has called for innovations to make crops adaptive to climate change and
has reaffirmed her commitment to make Bangladesh self sufficient in food.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
32
2.3.4
S.M.R. Hasan and U. Habiba
The National Food Policy Capacity Strengthening
Program (NFPCSP)
The government of Bangladesh launched the National Food Policy (NFP) in 2005
as well as Plan of Action (POA) in 2010. While the National Food Policy (NFP)
ensures sustainable food security for all in the country, the National Food Policy
Plan of Action calls for irrigation projects, the development of microfinance
associations, and specific indicators to measure the progress of certain programs.
The plan also recognizes agricultural issues with gender, climate and nutritional
issues (Loewenthal 2010). The government of Bangladesh initiated the National
Food Policy mainly for two objectives. These are:
• Adequate and stable supply of safe and nutritious food
• Increased purchasing power and access to food of the people
This POA has been taken by the government of Bangladesh with four major
goals such as food availability; physical and social access to food; economic access
to food; utilization of food for nutrition for the period of 2008–2015 (National Food
Policy Plan of Action 2008–2015). In 2010, it supported the formulation of a Food
Security Investment Plan to further strengthen the fight against hunger and malnutrition. The program was jointly implemented by the Food Planning and Monitoring
Unit under the Ministry of Food and Disaster Management of the government of
Bangladesh and the FAO. It receives financial support from the European Union
(EU) and the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). The
National Food Policy Capacity Strengthening Program helps build Bangladesh’s
institutional and human capacities to design, implement, and monitor food security
policies as well as to strengthen food security governance.
2.3.5
Duty Free Rice Import
To alleviate food shortage, the government has now allowed the import of food
products in most cases to be duty-free. For example, rice imports are currently
duty-free. There are also no quantitative restrictions on rice exports. It was in
May 2008, that Bangladesh imposed a ban on rice exports. The government has
taken action to make a balance between import and export of food products.
The ministerial decision was taken on 13 February, 2011.
2.3.6
Public Food Distribution System
Bangladesh is stepping up its efforts to address the seasonal food shortage particularly caused by flood, drought and other natural disasters. The Public Food
Distribution System (PFDS) is the government’s main mechanism for addressing
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
2
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure, Demographic Changes, Urbanization…
33
shortfalls in household food. The government initiated this program to increase
access to food for the vulnerable groups through price subsidies on food grain
and targeted income transfer. But the system was reported faulty because of
nepotism and corruption as well as high incidence of leakage and manipulation
in distribution.
2.3.7
National Climate Change Fund
The government of Bangladesh has recently established the National Climate
Change Fund (NCCF) which mainly focuses on adaptation. Bangladesh is also
going beyond its borders to try to find common causes with its neighbors to manage
climate change impacts through regional action plans. The country also seeks to
enhance cooperation with its neighbors on key issues (BCCSAP 2009).
2.3.8
Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper for Agriculture
and Rural Development
The government of Bangladesh has launched the Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper
(PRSP) in 2005 to create sustainable environment and to support transformation of
subsistence agriculture. The PRSP puts emphasis on achieving productivity and
profitability gains, broad-based support to agriculture, diversification and commercialization of agricultural enterprises. This strategy also stresses on agricultural
research and technology generation, farmers’ demand-led extension services,
energizing the agricultural marketing and agro-processing, land use and involving
women in agriculture (Ahmed 2010).
2.3.9
Open Market System Program
The government of Bangladesh has introduced the Open Market System (OMS)
program in order to ensure affordable food for people of low-income group.
The program launched the initiative of selling rice and wheat at lower prices for the
poor farmers. In this system, a consumer can buy either rice or flour or both the
items separately up to a maximum of 5 kg at a time from the designated OMS
truck dealers. According to the Department of Food, the country currently has now
1.2 million tons of rice and 0.25 million tons of wheat at the public warehouses
(Habib 2012).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
S.M.R. Hasan and U. Habiba
34
2.3.10
Agricultural Loan
The government of Bangladesh provides agricultural loan for the poor farmers.
In the 2010–2011 fiscal years, the Bangladesh Bank, the central bank of Bangladesh,
set a target of distributing US$1,616,113,744.075829 (taka 12,617 crore) that was
6 % higher than the previous fiscal years. On 28 July, 2012, the Bangladesh Bank
announced the agricultural loan policy for 2011–2012 fiscal years with a target to
disburse US$1,767,644,421.67 (taka 13, 800 crore) 9.4 % higher than the target of
previous fiscal year.
2.3.11
Agricultural Subsidy
The government of Bangladesh provides agricultural subsidies to the poor farmers
to ensure food production of the country. Bangladesh has started providing subsidies to the agricultural sectors since 2001. Government’s subsidies on agriculture
have substantially increased over the years though it slightly declined in 2009–2010
and 2010–2011 fiscal years.
2.3.12
Agricultural Input Assistance Card
The government of Bangladesh has prepared an “Agriculture Input Assistance Card
Program” to allow cash subsidies to the poor small and medium farmers and to
ensure self sufficiency in food. The program conducts smooth cash transfers and
reduces misappropriation of financial support. The card system is introduced, as the
subsidy provided by the government has not always reached the genuine farmers in
need. Middlemen or non-farmers embezzled a significant portion of the government
assistance. Of the total 18.2 million farmers in Bangladesh, 9.1 million marginal,
small and medium farmers will get the cash subsidy under the program. In this
system, farmers can receive incentives from banks through using the “Agriculture
Input Assistance Card” and for drawing subsidy and monetary transactions, and the
farmers need to open bank accounts for only US$ 0.128 (Taka 10). They do not need
any identification to open a bank account.
2.3.13
Vision 2021 for Climate Change Management
The government of Bangladesh has prepared a plan titled Vision 2021 regarding the
management of climate change. The foci of this program are to ensure food security,
eradicate poverty, increase employment opportunities, provide access to energy and
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
2
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure, Demographic Changes, Urbanization…
35
power, and to achieve economic and social wellbeing of all Bangladeshi citizens.
There are six pillars outlined in this program: (i) food security, (ii) comprehensive
disaster management; (iii) infrastructure development; (iv) research and knowledge
management; (v) mitigation and low carbon development; (vi) capacity building
and institutional development.
2.3.14
Master Plan for Southern Region of Bangladesh
Recently, the Bangladeshi government has started working on a Master Plan for the
South in order to address the key challenges of food security in the southern region.
The goal of this project is to improve the productivity of crops, livestock and fisheries in the coastal zone, especially in southern delta of Bangladesh. This master plan
also includes better use of technology, improved management practices with available knowledge in Bangladesh as well as from other countries.
In accordance with the Ministry of Agriculture, the government of Bangladesh is
planning a road map to support the integrated development efforts in the southern
region of Bangladesh. Considering the water crisis, the country is trying to map out
the areas for suitability of crops and use of surface water. The government foresees
the multipurpose Padma Bridge as a way of rapid transformation of the agriculture
sector in the concerned area. This initiative also focuses on higher crop productivity
less use of water and on controlling salinity intrusion into water sources. To ensure
continued inflow of fresh water for the southern region, including the Sundarban
forest and the production for agriculture, the government is currently working on
dredging of the Gorai River for steady inflow of water. The master plan also intends
to provide a road map for an integrated rehabilitation and development effort in
Bangladesh’s coastal zone aiming at sustainable food security, poverty reduction
and livelihood development for the poor.
2.3.15
Goal of Self-Sufficiency in Food Production
Since 2010, the local government of Bangladesh has been active in subsidizing
improved seed varieties and fertilizer, contributing to the record harvest of staple
rice. In 2011, Bangladesh has opened discussions with some African countries and
Cambodia with a view to leasing foreign land to grow food for import. At present,
the government now has a clear goal of self-sufficiency in food production. The
government has also given more attention on modernizing the country’s agriculture
system to ensure food security and attain self sufficiency in rice by 2013. The country
has also set the goal of ensuring food security through a plan of availability, accessibility and nutrition support by 2017 and to goal of becoming a middle-income
country by 2022.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
S.M.R. Hasan and U. Habiba
36
2.4
Conclusion
Food security in Bangladesh has become a challenging issue even in the age of
globalization. As its population increases day by day, the government of Bangladesh
as well as the governmental and nongovernmental organizations should be more
concerned about the current challenges of food security in the country. Food crisis
has become a dangerous challenge as thousands of its people suffer from scarcity of
nearly every basic need.
The projected demographic growth and anticipated socio-economic development
in Bangladesh would result in substantial increases in food requirements. Properly
targeted agricultural productivity investments can diminish the consequences of
anthropogenic factors and enhance sustainable food security in Bangladesh in the
near future. Increases in agricultural production are essential to meet the demand
from population and income. Area expansion for agriculture is not possible in
Bangladesh and further the possibility of negative environmental effects due to
expansion in the fragile area is significant. Agricultural productivity investments
may make it possible to meet that increased demand from existing agricultural
land resources, while reducing some of the environmental threats from increased
production must be ensured. The overall productivity increase will have the greatest
effect on human well-being, reducing the number of malnourished children in the
urban areas in Bangladesh.
Bangladesh needs to promote environmentally and socially sustainable agricultural development as a cornerstone for economic growth. Further, Fostering broad
based, sustainable agricultural and rural growth can help to ease food insecurity in
Bangladesh case. Addressing the entire rural space and looking beyond farming to
include off farm income opportunities can also impact on urban food security in
Bangladesh. Promoting not only productivity growth, but also resource access, land
tenure, returns to labor and education will also contribute to face the grim of urban
food insecurity. Tackling the unique factors behind increasing urban poverty and
improving food security in terms of availability and access, market development,
management of natural resources and access to basic services is very important for
achieving food security in the long run in a country like Bangladesh. In fact, national
and international policies and issues that affect implementation and impact should
not be ignored; these include public sector reform and decentralization, peace and
security, trade and macroeconomic policy reforms.
Determining how developing countries, particularly Bangladesh, can and will
respond to reduced yields and increased costs of food in the light of climate change
as well as anthropogenic factors to tackle the challenge of food insecurity is a critical
research need arising from this study. The study suggests that the worst situation
arises not only from scenario of severe climate change, but also low economic
growth, continuing large urban population increases, and little farm-level adaptation.
In order to minimize possible adverse consequences, like production losses, food
price increases, environmental stresses, and an increase in the number of people at
risk of hunger, the way forward is to encourage the agricultural sector to continue to
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
2
Anthropogenic Causes: Population Pressure, Demographic Changes, Urbanization…
37
develop crop breeding and management programmes for heat and drought conditions,
in combination with measures taken to conserve the environment, to use resources
more proficiently, and to slow the growth of the human population of the country.
References
Ahmed CQKM (2010) Agriculture in Bangladesh: present position, problems, prospects and policy,
power point presentation, Ministry of Agriculture. Available at: www.bpatc.org.bd/handouts/
Agriculture_Bangladesh.ppt. Accessed 23 Sept 2014
Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan (2009) Ministry of Environment and
Forests, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Banu SP, Duxbury JM, Lauren JG, Meisner C, Islam R (2004) Wheat seed quality – a study on
farmers’ seed. 4th International Crop Science Congress. http://www.cropscience.org.au/
icsc2004/poster/2/3/1169_banus.htm . Accessed 9 Sept 2014.
Barua GG (2012) Food security in Bangladesh. The Financial Express. Available at: www.thefinancialexpress-bd.com/index.php?ref=MjBfMTBfMjMTJfMV82XzE0Nzk1Mg. Accessed 14
Sept 2014
CIA The World Fact Book (2013) CIA The World Fact Book. https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/theworld-factbook/geos/bg.html. Accessed 23 Sept 2014
Eminence (2013) Eminence. http://www.eminence-bd.org/index.php?option = com_content&vie
w = article&id = 47 = &Itemid = 41. Accessed 28 Sept 2014
Godfray HCJ et al (2010) Food security: the challenge of feeding 9 billion. Science
327(5967):812–818
Gregory PJ, Ingram JSI (2000) Global change and food and forest production: future scientific
challenges. Agric Ecosyst Environ 82:3–14. doi:10.1016/S0167-8809(00) 00212–7
Habib TB (2012) Food stock sufficient Govt plans to reduce OMS rice price. The Financial
Express. http://www.thefinancialexpressbd.com/index.php?ref = MjBfMTJfMDhfMTJfMV85
MF8xNTI0NTE=
Huda N et al (2004) National seed management. Agricultural employees conference and technology fair. Ministry of Agriculture
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) (2007) Climate Change 2007: impacts,
adaptation and vulnerability. In: Parry ML, Canziani OF, Palutikof JP, van der Linden PJ,
Hanson CE (eds) Contribution of Working Group II to the fourth assessment report of the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Islam MN, Hossain SMA, Baksh ME, Rahman MA, Sarker MABS, Khan ST (2010) Studies on
policy option for quality seed production and preservation of cereal crops at farmer’s level for
the improvement of food security. National Food Policy Capacity Strengthening Programme,
USAID
Jaim WMH, Akter S (2012) Seed, fertilizer and innovation in Bangladesh. Industry and policy
issues for the future. International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington, DC
Karim Z (1997) Accelerated agricultural growth in Bangladesh. Seminar on agricultural research
on development in Bangladesh. BARC, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Loewenthal M (2010) U.S.-Bangladesh partnership advances food security. http://www.weeklyblitz.net/768/us-bangladesh-partnership-advances-foodsecurity. Accessed 14 Jan 2013
Mondal MH (2010) Crop agriculture of Bangladesh: challenges and opportunities. Bangladesh J
Agric Res 35(2):235–245
National Food Policy Plan of Action (2008–2015) Food Planning and Monitoring Unit (FPMU).
Ministry of Food and Disaster Management, Dhaka
NFPCSP (2008) The National Food Policy Plan of Action (2008–2015). Government of the
People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
38
S.M.R. Hasan and U. Habiba
Parry M et al (2001) Millions at risk: defining critical climate change threats and targets. Glob
Environ Chang 11:181–183. doi:10.1016/S0959-3780(01)00011-5
Rashid M (2012) Future of farming and farmers in Bangladesh. The Financial Express, 12 Sept
2012. http://www.thefinancialexpressbd.com/more.php?news_id=143792&date=2012-09-18.
Accessed 22 Nov 2012
Rosegrant MW, Cline SA (2003) Global food security: challenges and policies. Science 302:
1917–1919. doi:10.1126/science.1092958
Tilman D et al (2001) Forecasting agriculturally driven global environmental change. Science
292:281–284. doi:10.1126/science.1057544
Unnayan Onneshan (2014) Recent trends of growth in agriculture, industry and power. Bangladesh
Economic Update March 2014. vol 5, no 3
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 3
Natural Causes: Climate Change Implications,
Resource Management and Food Security
Sanjib Kumar Saha and Shampa Barmon
Abstract Bangladesh is one of the most disaster vulnerable countries and will
become even more so as a result of climate change. Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change Fourth Assessment Report (IPCC (2007a) Climate change, 2007:
the physical science basic. Contribution of working group 1 to the fourth assessment
report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change, Switzerland) indicates the
evidence of changes in global climate over the past century. Impacts of climate
change on food security are global concerns, but they represent a particular threat
for Bangladesh. Environment, agriculture are already under pressure mainly due to
an increase in demand for food, services and depletion of natural resources. In last
three decades the Government of Bangladesh has invested over $10 billion to make
the country resilient to natural disasters (MoEF 2009). Establishment of disaster
proof structures and the development of climate resilient crop varieties have led to
increased food security. The paper explicates the overall context, summarizes the
programmes being undertaken to address the issue of climate change and food
security and draws way forward.
Keywords Climate change • Food security • Impacts of climate change • Agriculture
• Natural resources • Disaster proof structures and climate resilient crops
S.K. Saha (*)
Comprehensive Disaster Management Programme (CDMP),
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: sanjib.saha@cdmp.org.bd
S. Barmon
Mission Jannat, House # 376, Road # 9/B, Block - D, Bashundhara R/A,
Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: shampab50@gmail.com
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_3
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
39
40
3.1
S.K. Saha and S. Barmon
Introduction
Ever since the global concerns have been raised about the adverse impact of climate
change, the international community has already recognized Bangladesh as one of
the most vulnerable countries. The reasons are obvious. It is highly vulnerable,
even under no-climate change, due to many factors including its disadvantageous
location, flat and low-lying topography, high population density, rampant poverty and
chronic inefficiency with regard to institutional arrangement and support system.
The magnitude of vulnerability would just increase manifold due to the impacts
induced by changing climate. Recent studies suggest that all such factors would
exacerbate the current vulnerability and may upset the food security situation of the
country (Huq et al. 1996; Warrick and Ahmad 1996).
Global climate change has direct and indirect impact on the natural resources and
food production of a particular area. Scientists throughout the world are paying
much effort to explore the relationship between irreversible climate change and its
impact on nature, food production and therefore, food security. With the improvement of calculation models they have found tacit relationship between climate
change, food production and food security. The unprecedented impacts of climate
change along with other environmental and geomorphologic changes make more
concerns over food security especially, for the poor and marginal population
(Gregory and Ingram 2000; Parry et al. 2001; Rosegrant and Cline 2003). It is found
that climate change is expected to decline rice production and wheat production of
Bangladesh again by 8 % and 32 % respectively affecting the food security severely
(IPCC 2007a).
In the recent decades global food production is increasing in line with and sometimes ahead of demand. FAO, however, projects that demand for cereals will be
increased by 70 % by 2050, and will be double in many low-income countries (FAO
2006). Increasing demand for food is an outcome both of larger populations and
higher per capita consumption among communities with growing incomes, particularly in Asia. But poor households’ inability to secure food through markets and
non-market channels may limit food security even where food is globally abundant.
For those who rely on subsistence agriculture, food security is strongly dependent
on local food availability, which is attributed to the support and management of the
ecosystem i.e. natural resources. The impacts of climate change on food security
therefore should consider both direct impacts on local food production and also the
interactions with the natural resources and their management (Ericksen et al. 2010;
Ingram et al. 2010; Liverman and Kapadia 2010).
3.2
Climate Change and Food Security: A Conceptual Basis
Climate change has got diverse interaction and bearing with natural resource management and food security. Figure 3.1 shows that natural resources, agricultural
production as impacted by climate change and it’s direct and indirect consequences
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
3 Natural Causes: Climate Change Implications, Resource Management…
41
Global Climate Change
Increased accumulation of Green House Gases
Changes in average temperature,
rainfall, sea level rise, glacial
Changes in
Atmosphere
Changes in
Biosphere
Impact on the
Natural
Resources
Implication on the food
distribution, access
Changes in
Hydrosphere
Changes in
Lithosphere
Impact in the
Agricultural
Impact on
Food Security
Fig. 3.1 Conceptual framework on climate change and food security (Source: Adapted from FAO,
NRCB)
largely determine the food security of the population. ‘Climate change and food
security: A conceptual basis’ presented here reveals the logical connection among
climate change, natural resource and the food security. Climate change, changes in
its different components induce interference in the entire biological and physical
systems and either control and/or influence the food production, distribution and
access. Within this phenomenon the natural resources possess enormous interaction
with the agricultural practices and at the same time as a system exert huge effect on
the food security (FAO 2008).
There are cohesion and divergence among the components of the framework and
yet the extent and intensity of interactions and inter-dependence are huge although
these are difficult to quantify and express. However, as it is portrayed here, the relationship and impacts herein are more or less obvious, every single unit is affected
and finally food security is always impacted, as demonstrated in the following
sections.
3.3
Food Security Situation in Bangladesh
According to the World Food Summit, “Food security exists when all people, at all
times, have physical and economic access to sufficient, safe and nutritious food
which meets their dietary needs and food preferences for an active and healthy life”.
Food security encompasses many issues ranging from food production, distribution
according to food preferences and food utilization including market and non-market
(natural) factors. The understanding of people of Bangladesh stands food security
means a stock of cereals that can be used to meet an unforeseen food crisis.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
42
S.K. Saha and S. Barmon
Food certainly is not cereal alone, neither its security is just a sufficient amount of
cereal stock. Food means balanced diet and its security refers to availability of such
diet at a reasonable price.
Ensuring food security has been one of the major goals of Bangladesh since its
independence in 1971 (IFAD 2012). With rapid economic growth in the recent
years, Bangladesh significantly improves its cropping practices and intensities with
a view to fulfill the food requirements for its vast population. Feeding such a huge
population is taking huge toll on croplands, private lands, pastures, fisheries
resources and forests. With intensification of agricultural production system to meet
the increasing demand of food there has been profound changes in the organization
in the food production system in Bangladesh. Despite significant achievement in
food grain production and food availability, food security at national, household and
individual levels remains a matter of major concern for the Government of
Bangladesh. Yet the entire production and distribution system have been under consistent change due to natural hazards and adverse impacts of climate change.
Bangladesh has achieved remarkable progress in increasing domestic production
of food commodities as the principal means to ensuring adequate food availability
for its people, especially the poor. The food production of the country (both rice and
wheat), was 10.46 million metric tons in the year 1971–1972. Bangladesh attained
self-sufficiency in food production in 2010–2011 with a gross production of rice
and wheat of 35.0 million metric tons (BER 2011). Food security situation in
Bangladesh has improved, especially on average per capita dietary energy supply
has improved from 1,800 kcal in 1970s to 3,055 in 2009 (BBS 2010). Food grain
production, particularly rice production has tripled in the last 40 years with the use
of Green Revolution technology (high yielding varieties, fertilizers, irrigation and
pesticide) coupled with growth of institutional infrastructure and a positive shift in
public policy and market forces. As a major staple, rice occupies 77 % of the gross
cropped area and accounts for over 95 % of food grain production (BARC 2011).
It provides about 75 % of the calorie and 55 % of the protein in the average daily
diet of the people (Hossain 2004). Rice thus occupies the center stage of food security and continues to draw major attention of the Government for further increasing
the production.
In 2001–2002, rice production was 24.30 million tons, which has steadily
increased to 33.54 million tons in 2010–2011 (Table 3.1). Wheat production also
decreased from 1.6 million tons in 2001–2002 to 0.97 million tons in 2010–2011.
Similarly, pulses and oilseed production steadily declined mainly because of the loss
of areas under these crops to Boro rice and other remunerative winter crops.
Production of vegetables and fruits has increased, but at a slow pace from 1.59 million tons and 1.47 million tons in 2001–2002 to 11.19 million tons and 3.56 million
tons in 2010–2011 respectively. Spectacular success has been achieved in the production of potato. It has made a quantum jump from 2.90 million tons in 2001–2002
to 8.30 million tons in 2010–2011 (Table 3.1).
Fish production increased from 1.89 million tons in 2001–2002 to 2.89 million
tons in 2010–2011 (Table 3.2). Meat, milk and egg production has also increased
significantly over the last 10 years (Table 3.2).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
43
3 Natural Causes: Climate Change Implications, Resource Management…
Table 3.1 Domestic production (gross) trend of food grains, potato, pulses, oilseeds, vegetables
and fruits (2001–2002 to 2010–2011) (Million MT)
Food grain
Years
Rice
Wheat
2001–2002
24.30
1.61
2010–2011
33.54
0.97
Sources: BBS, DAE (2011)
Potato
2.90
8.30
Pulse
0.35
0.72
Oilseeds
0.39
0.84
Vegetables
1.59
11.19
Fruits
1.47
3.56
Table 3.2 Fish, meat, milk and egg production trend
Years
Fish (MnT)
2001–2002
1.89
2010–2011
2.89
Sources: DLS, DoF (2011)
3.4
Meat (MnT)
0.78
2.95
Milk (MnT)
1.78
1.98
Egg (Million)
4,424
6,078
Natural Resource Management in Bangladesh
Natural resource management refers to the conservation, utilization and improvement of the natural resources of certain geographical area for the sustainable livelihood, food security of the community concerned and overall balance and
maintenance of the ecosystem. Restoring, managing and using the natural resources
in a judicial manner can therefore safeguard and sustain the production of food for
a growing population. An emerging body of evidence indicates that mismanagement of natural resource contributes to the vulnerability of human systems to disaster, and that enhanced management can provide a tool for vulnerability reduction
(Abramovitz 2001). If so, targeted conservation of particular natural buffer systems
will in many circumstances offer no-regrets adaptation opportunities. This can
facilitate and ensure food production and sustain the food security of the rural
population.
Bangladesh has a comparatively low natural resource base with a high growth
rate of population. The natural resource base is under serious threat, as many natural
resources are either being over-exploited or used sub-optimally. Besides the effects
of anthropogenic stresses, the low ‘land-man’ ratio in the country is often further
threatened by natural hazards. The complexity of natural resource, utilization
patterns of the resources and interaction with the changing climate has important
implications for the vulnerability and depletion of the natural resource base.
Environmental management and mismanagement are moving towards the center of
the adaptation debate. The Policymaker’s Summary of the Assessment Report Four
(IPCC AR4) states, “Policies that lessen pressures on resources, improve management
of environmental risks, increase food security and welfare of the poorest members
of society can simultaneously advance sustainable development and equity, enhance
adaptive capacity, and reduce vulnerability to climate and other stresses”.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
44
S.K. Saha and S. Barmon
Majority rural poor of Bangladesh depend on Natural Resources (NR) for their
food production, food security and livelihoods. Land, water, forests, and live stocks
are the sources of food security and livelihoods. The rural economy depends on
productivity of the natural resources. Small trade and manufacturing process can
not replace dependency over agricultural and natural resources. Consequently, no
process of food security and development can be conceived of without putting care
for environment and sustainable development at the center stage. On the other hand,
as the community people depend heavily on nature for their food and livelihood
security, their involvement for caring for environment becomes an extremely
critical.
Resources, natural resources in particular in Bangladesh are dependent on the
weather patterns and other natural elements and are thus predicted to be vulnerable
to climate change. Climate change induced natural hazards are potential threats to
natural resources and their integrity for human safety and security. Although the
extent of impacts are not shown and not known either with certainty, the diverse
natural ecosystem resources may be affected in various manners by elements of
climate change and its impacts. Exactly how the systems will be affected in future
due to climate change however is difficult to speculate at the moment because the
dynamics of the various ecosystems including the symbiosis among elements within
them and their interaction with anthropogenic factors are only poorly understood
right now.
Bangladesh is a signatory of the Multilateral Environmental Agreement by
which government is committed to undertake certain environmental management
actions which are largely beneficial to the general population and the poor in
particular. Operationally, environment and food security linkages are evident at two
levels – one is conservation of nature and natural resources for sustainable food
security while the other is controlling the resources as a buffer for over all human
security against any natural threat.
3.5
Climate Change and Its Impact on the Nature
and Food Production
There is a general agreement at international community working on climate change
projections that climate change may lead to significant reductions in agricultural
productivity in developing countries. Agricultural production in South Asia could
fall by 30 % by 2050 if no action is taken to combat the effects of increasing
temperatures and hydrological disruption (IPCC 2007b). Since temperature in the
South Asian continent is already reaching critical levels during the pre-monsoon
season, this further increment would reduce the yields of all crops, including rice
(Wasmann and Dobermann 2007). The impact is obvious on the food production and
thus ultimately on the food security of the people and poor people in particular.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
3 Natural Causes: Climate Change Implications, Resource Management…
45
Climate change is regarded as one of the several interacting factors that affect the
natural resources and food production in many ways. Agriculture, fisheries, livestock and biodiversity all are sensitive to climate change as their production system
are likely to be affected by climate change (Table 3.3). Other components, such as
soil, water, and other natural elements of ecosystem required for food production
are also impacted by climate change and climate variability. As the frequency and
intensity of climate induced severe weather increase, there is a growing risk of
damage to supporting systems like infrastructure, transport, market with consequent
disruption of food production and food security. For the sake of food security all
these are critical to consider in the formulation of adaptation strategies for people
who are currently vulnerable or who could become so within the foreseeable future
(FAO 2008).
The effect of Aila and Sidr is still there, reminding the misery that climate change
is for the people of Bangladesh. These events brought in unbearable distress for
common people and destroyed a huge amount of crops, which resulted into food
price inflation in 2007–2008. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
Change (IPCC), Bangladesh may experience 10–15 % more rainfall by 2030.
This excessive rainfall will result in crop failure and production decline. This again
will aggravate the present food security condition and will destroy many people’s
livelihoods and thus will drag them below poverty line. All three aspects of food
security (e.g. production, entitlement and nutrition) will have to face the brunt of
this unleashed monster.
Climate change and variability sway the nature and then crop production by
exerting primary, secondary and tertiary impacts through raise of temperature,
erratic rainfall, sea level rise etc. An account of recent study, research findings are
described below that portray how climate change re-shapes the resource management, whole food production and food security.
Impact of Temperature on Crop Production Temperature plays important role in
vegetative and reproductive growth and when temperature falls below the range or
exceeded the upper limit, crop production faces constraints. A study (Islam et al.
2008) found that 1 °C increase in maximum temperature at vegetative, reproductive
and ripening stages there was a decrease in Aman rice production by 2.94, 53.06
and 17.28 tons respectively. With the change in temperature (by 2 °C and 4 °C),
the prospect of growing wheat and potato would be severely impaired.
Impact of Rainfall on Crop Production Crop and plants have critical stages when
they require water for their growth and development. Excessive rainfall may cause
flooding and water logging condition that lead to crop loss. It is found that for 1 mm
increase in rainfall at vegetative, reproductive and ripening stages decreased the
Aman rice production by 0.036, 0.230 and 0.292 ton respectively. Scarcity of water
limits crop production while irrigation coverage is only 56 % as delivered by the
Bangladesh Agriculture Development Corporation (BADC).
Impact of Sea Level Rise on Crop Production Sea level rise affects agriculture in
three ways, i.e., by salinity intrusion, by flooding and by increasing cyclone frequency
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
46
Table 3.3 Physical vulnerability context
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Flood
River flood
+++
++
+
++
++
++
++
+
+
Flash flood
++
+
+
+
+
+
−
+
−
Cyclone and
storm surges
+++
+
+++
+
++
+
++
+++
+
Erosion
−
−
−
+++
−
−
−
+++
−
Sectoral
vulnerability context
Crop agriculture
Fisheries
Livestock
Infrastructure
Industries
Biodiversity
Health
Human settlement
Energy
S.K. Saha and S. Barmon
Sea level rise
Extreme
Coastal
Salinity
temperature
inundation
intrusion
Drought
+++
++
+++
+++
++
+
+
++
++
++
+++
+
+
++
−
−
++
+++
++
−
+++
+++
+++
+
+++
+
+++
++
−
−
−
−
++
+
−
+
Source: National Adaptation Programme of Action, Bangladesh
3 Natural Causes: Climate Change Implications, Resource Management…
47
and its depth of damage. Combined effects of these three factors decrease agriculture
production in the coastal zone. Salinity intrusion due to sea level rise will decrease
agricultural production by unavailability of fresh water and soil degradation (MoEF
2012). In addition to this, sea level rise cause inundation of more area which is
already reported by scientist. Therefore, damage of agricultural crops will be more
acute in future.
Impact of Flood on Crop Production Flood has most deleterious effect on crop
production of Bangladesh. The 1988 flood caused reduction of agricultural production by 45 % (Karim et al. 1996). Higher discharge and low drainage capacity, in
combination with increased backwater effects, would increase the frequency of
such devastating floods under climate change scenarios. Prolonged floods would
tend to delay Aman plantation, resulting in significant loss of potential Aman
production, as observed during the floods of 1998. Loss of Boro rice crop from flash
floods has become a regular phenomenon in the Haor areas over the recent years.
Impact of Cyclone on Crop Production Cyclone causes huge damage to production
of crop. FAO/GIEWS Global Watch (2007) reported that at the time of the passage
of cyclone, SIDR, the main 2007 “Aman” rice crop, accounting for about 70 % of
the annual production in the most affected area, was nearly to harvest. According to
the estimate by Department of Agricultural Extension of Bangladesh, the loss in
rice equivalent is found at 1.23 million tons, with 535,707 tons in the four severely
affected districts, 555,997 tons in badly affected 9 districts and 203,600 tons in
moderately affected 17 districts in Bangladesh.
Impact of Drought on Crop Production Due to Climate Change Drought mostly
affects Bangladesh in the pre-monsoon and post-monsoon periods. The drought
condition in North-Western Bangladesh in the recent decades had led to a shortfall
of rice production of 3.5 million tons in the 1990s. A severe drought can cause more
than 40 % damage to broadcast Aus. Each year, during the Kharif season, drought
causes significant damage to the T.Aman crop in about 2.32 million ha. In the Rabi
season, 1.2 million ha of cropland are facing droughts of various magnitudes.
Apart from loss to agriculture, droughts have significant effect on land degradation,
livestock population, employment and health (FAO 2007).
3.6
Initiatives and Institutions for Food Security
Food security is governed by several institutions and policies in Bangladesh.
In order to respond to the multidimensional nature of food security, various sectors
and disciplines are represented in the institutions, including agriculture, rural
development, women and children affairs, health, finance, commerce and disaster
management. National Agriculture Policy 2013, National Food Policy 2006, National
Environment Policy and Implementation Guideline 1992, National Plan for Disaster
Management 2010–2015 and other policy documents have mentioned importance
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
48
S.K. Saha and S. Barmon
of ensuring natural resource management and food security and categorically
emphasized the ways to combat climate change to secure food for the nation.
National Adaptation Programme of Action draws upon possible adaptation
measures where it mentions the food security and pro-poor safety-net programmes.
Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan (MoEF 2009) has re-affirmed
and included the food security as the first of the six pillars in the strategy. There are
44 programmes, 28 of those have specific relevance to food security and adaptation
which are organized under four major issues: (a) food security, social protection and
health, (b) comprehensive disaster management, (c) infrastructure, and (d) research
and knowledge management. The BCCSAP creates space to plan for a combination
of the two different approaches to adaptation, which has significant potential to
reduce adverse impacts in agriculture-based production system and thereby contribute
towards reducing overall food insecurity.
National Food Policy (NFP) 2006 has declared its overriding goal of ensuring a
dependable sustained food security system for all people of the country at all times
by ensuring availability of food, access to food and utilization of food. Three objectives of NFP are to ensure: (i) adequate and stable supply of safe and nutritious
food; (ii) accessibility to food through enhancing people’s purchasing power, and
(iii) adequate nutrition for all, especially women and children (MoFDM 2006).
Over the last three decades, the Government has invested more than US$10
billion to make the country more climate resilient and less vulnerable to natural
disasters. Climate change will severely challenge the country’s ability to achieve the
high rates of economic growth needed to sustain these development effort to ensure
food and nutrition security (MoEF 2009). On the whole the over-all food security
policy so far has revolved around raising production of staples leaving the other aspects
less attended to. But over time, the situation is being amended. The Government has
prepared a US$7.8 billion Food Security Investment Plan with far more attention to
the access and utilization aspects including the impacts of climate change as a
sequel to the G20 L’Aquila initiative in 2008. The contribution of foreign aid assistance is expected to be US$5.1 billion of which US$3.4 billion has been identified
as first priority requirements (GoB 2011).
Government of Bangladesh, under the Bangladesh Climate Change Trust Fund
Act 2010, created Bangladesh Climate Change Trust Fund worth US$100 million
dollar and has already allocated US$200 million or BDT14 billion for this trust fund
for undertaking projects related with climate change adaptation and mitigations
measures (MoEF 2010). Bangladesh has also created Climate Change Resilience
Fund where mainly funds from foreign sources are accumulated as developed countries have pledged to contribute $120 million. This fund has less national or local
control as this has to be used according to the guidelines of donor countries or
concerned institutions. This fund will be used in the implementation of six pillars of
Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan 2009.
Number of national and local level programmes and projects are getting
implemented that take care of climate change adaptation, food security and disaster
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
3 Natural Causes: Climate Change Implications, Resource Management…
49
risk reduction. Comprehensive Disaster Management Programme (CDMP), a GoB
and UNDP programme, has been implementing in almost every hazard prone
corners of Bangladesh. CDMP has been pursuing harmonization among the
programmes and project in Bangladesh with regard to disaster risk reduction and
climate change adaptation. With a view to integrate and mainstream the climate
change adaptation in the public domain CDMP has been improving the capacity of
the government both at local implementation and the national policy levels.
3.7
Challenges and Limitations to Ensure Food Security
Government of Bangladesh has been trying to integrate and address all the elements
associated with food security to achieve universal goal (MGD). However, there
remain certain challenges and limitations that constrain all efforts and initiatives.
A few of the factors are summarized here under.
Incapacity of the Institution Capacity of the Ministry of Food in assessing,
planning, monitoring and implementing the policy and development interventions
to effectively deal with the food security issues is relatively weak due to shortage of
skilled manpower. Inter-ministerial coordination and interaction with regard to
work on the issues of food security, related aspects like production, marketing,
distribution and regular coordination and collaboration with the research institutes,
private sectors and civil society are lacking.
Reduced Allocation and Funding Investment in agriculture (crops, fisheries and
livestock), in general, has been drastically reduced from last three decades. ADP
share has also declined from 5 % in 1981–1982 to less than 10 % in 2010–2011.
Donor funding in agriculture has also declined significantly, although one of the
conditions for attaining MDG is the commitment of extended donor support in
agriculture. Livestock sub-sector is affected most due to low budget allocation.
Limited Updated Information and Technologies Bangladesh as a developing
country has limitations to modern technology and updated information, data as an
adaptation response to climate change. Although there have been availability of
some modern technologies, varieties but in most cases these are limited to certain
geographical locations. On the other hand updated information and data on the
changing climate pattern and required knowledge on the appropriate application are
not available and accessible.
Chronic Socio-natural Poverty In some areas of the county where natural hazards
and related impacts are almost an annual phenomenon, the poor people are in constant dearth of resources to combat the situation. Required supports either from the
government and other sources like social safety-net or contingency are not adequate
and thus they remain in a regular misery.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
S.K. Saha and S. Barmon
50
3.8
Recommendations and Looking Forward
Climate change amplifies the environmental and socioeconomic drivers of food
insecurity, it is imperative to prioritize where, how and when to act. Over the course
of the twenty-first century, the world will need to produce significantly more food in
order to deliver a basic, but adequate, diet to everyone. The amount of food required
will be even greater if current trends in diets and the management of food systems
continue. It is urgent to make concerted efforts to establish climate-resilient agricultural production systems, make efficient use of resources and develop an effective
distribution mechanism to constitute a sustainable food security system. Following
recommendations may be put forward for further review and action as appropriate.
Mainstreaming Climate Change Issues in the Policies Climate change issues need
to be integrated in the current and upcoming policies and programmes with regard
to food security, agriculture and related disciplines.
Provisioning More Fund for Food Production More budget should be allocated in
the annual development plan so that the ministries, agencies are able to utilize
required fund for food production, availability and accessibility and contingency,
safety-nets.
Improving and Augmenting the Technology and Methods Invent and improve
climate and disaster resilient technologies (crop, animal, fish varieties), tools,
methods and process.
Generating and Disseminating Updated Information Invest time and resources to
collect, update and downscale climate change data and information. The data and
information are required to be packaged in an affordable and useful form for all
level users right from the policy makers to the local level users.
Creating and Applying a Shared Information System Creating a comprehensive,
easily accessible information system that foster easy access to information and thus
enable sharing and use at all levels.
Strengthening Capacity of Institutions and Communities There is a need to develop
the planning, coordination and monitoring capacity of the ministry, agencies and the
communities for better planning, coordination and implementation.
Integrating and Sustaining Social Protection Schemes In order to provide immediate
access to food, social protection schemes (safety nets) are required to safeguard
existing assets and human capital from shocks and disaster.
3.9
Conclusion
Climate change and related impacts are likely to reduce crop yields and exacerbate
the risk of food insecurity in Bangladesh. The changes may even affect the incomes
earned by the poor and raise food prices with the net effect on food security and
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
3 Natural Causes: Climate Change Implications, Resource Management…
51
the household’s livelihood strategies. It is worth to mention that although food
production in Bangladesh is increasing in line with its high population demand, the
scenario may change with the likely changes and outcomes of flood, drought, sea
level rise, saline intrusion, cyclones etc. The government needs to prioritize and
implement measures to advance agriculture production and sustainable natural
resources management to ensure food security for the people. The ‘business as
usual’ approach to tackle the climate change problem will not reduce the vulnerability
of food insecure people as this vulnerability is exacerbated by existing developmental challenges.
References
Abramovitz JN (2001) Unnatural disasters. Worldwatch paper 158, Worldwatch Institute,
Washington, DC
BARC (2011) Study on rural households’ food security in coastal region of Bangladesh Economic
Impact of Climate Change on Crop Production in Southern Zone of Bangladesh
BBS (2010) Statistical Yearbook of Bangladesh, Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics. Statistical
Division, Ministry of Finance and Planning, GoB, Dhaka
BER (2011) Bangladesh economic review. Bureau of Economic Research (BER), University of
Dhaka
Ericksen P, Stewart B, Ingram J, Dixon J, Barling D, Loring P, Anderson M (2010) The value of
the food systems approach. In: Ingram J, Ericksen P, Liverman D (eds) Food security and
global environmental change. Earthscan, London, p 352. ISBN 9781849711289
FAO (2006) The state of food insecurity in the world. Food and Agriculture Organization of the
United Nations, Rome
FAO (2007) Climate variability and change: adaptation to drought in Bangladesh. pp 66
FAO (2008) Climate change and food security: a framework document. Food and Agriculture
Organization of the United Nations, Rome
GoB (2011) Perspective Plan of Bangladesh 2010–2011. General Economics Division, Planning
Commission, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, July, 2012
Gregory PJ, Ingram JSI (2000) Global change and food and forest production: future scientific
challenges. Agric Ecosyst Environ 82:3–14. doi:10.1016/S0167-8809 (00) 00212-7
Hossain (2004) Food security and nutrition in Bangladesh: progress and determinants, a report
prepared for FAO, Rome
Huq S, Ahmed AU, Koudstaal R (1996) Vulnerability of Bangladesh to climate change and sea
level rise. In: Downing TE (ed) Climate change and world food security. Springer Verlag,
Berlin
IFAD (2012) Enabling poor rural people to overcome poverty in Bangladesh, Rome, p 7. Available
at http://www.ifad.org/operations/projects/regions/PI/factsheets/bd.pdf
Ingram J, Holmes J, Andersson J, Giller K, Bammer G, Brown M, Henrichs T, Jones JW,
Schilpzand, R. Schuttelaar and Partners, Young, J (2010) Engaging stakeholders at the regional
level. In: Ingram J, Ericksen P, Liverman D (eds) Food security and global environmental
change. Earthscan, London, p 352. ISBN 9781849711289
IPCC (2007a) Climate change, 2007: the physical science basic. Contribution of working group 1
to the fourth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change, Switzerland
IPCC (2007b) Climate change 2007: impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. Contribution of working group II to the fourth assessment report of the IPCC. In: Parry ML, Canziani OF, Palutikof
JP, van der Linden PJ, Hanson CE (eds). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, p 976
Islam MN, Baten MA, Hossain MS, Islam MT (2008) Impact of few important climatic parameters
on Aman rice production in Mymensingh District. J Environ Sci Nat Res 1(2):49–54
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
S.K. Saha and S. Barmon
52
Karim Z, Hussain SG, Ahmed M (1996) Assessing impacts of climate variations on foodgrain
production in Bangladesh. Water Air Soil Pollut 92:53–62
Liverman D, Kapadia K (2010) Food security and the global environment: an overview. In: Ingram J,
Ericksen P, Liverman D (eds) Food security and global environmental change. Earthscan,
London, p 352. ISBN 9781849711289
MoEF (2009) National Adaptation Programme of Action 2009. Ministry of Environment
and Forest, Dhaka
MoEF (2010) Bangladesh Climate Change Trust Fund Act 2010. Ministry of Environment
and Forest
MoEF (2012) Second National Communication under the United Nations Framework Convention
on Climate Change. Ministry of Environment and Forest
MoFDM (2006) National Food Policy, 2006. Ministry of Food and Disaster Management,
Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh
Parry M et al (2001) Millions at risk: defining critical climate change threats and targets.
Glob Environ Chang 11:181–183. doi:10.1016/S0959-3780(01)00011-5
Rosegrant MW, Cline SA (2003) Global food security: challenges and policies. Science
302:1917–1919. doi:10.1126/science.1092958
Warrick RA, Ahmad QK (eds) (1996) The implications of climate and sea – level change for
Bangladesh. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht/Boston/London, p 415
Wasmann R, Dobermann A (2007) Climate change adaptation through rice production in region
with high poverty levels. SATe-J 4:1–24
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 4
Social Issues: Occupation Change and Food
Security in Bangladesh
Abu Wali Raghib Hassan and Anil Kumar Das
Abstract Agriculture in Bangladesh is caught in a low equilibrium trap with
productivity of staples, supply shortfalls, high prices, low returns to farmer and area
diversification. All these factors can be threat to food security. The country has the
highest concentration of undernourished and poor people though Bangladesh has
established a food bank to meet the needs of food security. This is despite the felt
need of country to evolve mechanisms to make the Food security reserve operational. It is against this background that topic has been undertaken. Conducted in
collaboration with think tanks from country, it aims to identify social issues relating
occupational change and food security, the policy initiatives taken to tackle these
issues, evaluate these policies and suggest measures to overcome identified
constraints in order to improve the food security situation in the country under a
strategic plan giving importance to the agriculture sector.
Keywords Social issues • Food security • Sixth five years plan • Million development
goal (MDG) • Non-crop agriculture (NCA)
4.1
Introduction
Bangladesh has a primarily agrarian economy. Agriculture is the single largest
producing sector of the economy since it comprises about 19.28 % of the country’s
GDP and employs around 45 % of the total labor force. The performance of this
sector has an overwhelming impact on major macroeconomic objectives like
employment generation, occupation change, poverty alleviation, human resources
development and food security. In our subsistence agriculture the land less and
small farmers are very much vulnerable section of the society. Rural Bangladesh is
mainly dominated by agricultural society. Social life of the people is decorated with
A.W.R. Hassan (*) • A.K. Das
Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture, Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: hassan58_dae@yahoo.com
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_4
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
53
A.W.R. Hassan and A.K. Das
54
various cultural events relating the crop calendar of the year. Economic activities of
the country are still moving with the momentum of agro based occupations. On the
other hand this country is mainly alluvial plain divided into three zones namely hill,
terrace and flood plain based on geomorphology and physiographic point of view.
This land is frequently visited by natural hazards of which floods, cyclones with
accompany of storm surge; drought, tornadoes and river bank erosion are the most
disasters to mentions. All these issues very much concern to food security and mode
of occupation change in the rural Bangladesh.
4.2
Social Issues and the Strategic Plans
With a population of 160 million on a land mass of 147,000 km2, Bangladesh is
among the most densely populated countries on earth. Over three quarters of the
population lives in rural areas where agriculture is the mainstay of the rural economy. Society is mainly dominated by Agriculture. Over half of rural dwellers live
below the national poverty line, and over 40 million are classified as undernourished
(FAO 2006). Thus food security and poverty reduction are mainstays of government
development efforts. To achieve these goals, the government of Bangladesh prioritizes
diversified production, employment, and income generation on farms in its Poverty
Reduction Strategy Paper (Bangladesh Planning Commission 2005). Keeping in mind
the Poverty Reduction Strategy the sixth five years plan has been adapted.
Government recognizes that Bangladesh is still a low income country with
substantial poverty, inequality and deprivation. An estimated 47 million people are
living below the poverty line with a significant proportion living in households which
are female headed, in remote areas, and consisting of socially excluded and other
vulnerable people. Most of the labor force is engaged in informal low productivity
and low income jobs. The access to secondary and tertiary education is limited and
the quality of education at all levels is deficient. The poor group of the population is
severely disadvantaged in terms of ownership of assets and has inadequate access to
institutional finance as well as to basic services including quality education, healthcare, water and sanitation. These people, and among them especially women and
children, are also disproportionately affected by natural disasters and the adverse
effects of climate change. Despite expansion, publicly supported mitigating measures in the form of social protection programs are still inadequate. In recognition
of the long -term development challenges, the government adopted the Vision 2021.
The Vision 2021 and the associated Perspective Plan 2010–2021 have set solid
development targets for Bangladesh by the end of 2021. Those targets if achieved
will transform socio-economic environment of Bangladesh from a low income
economy to the first stages of a middle income economy. Along with higher per
capita income, Vision 2021 lays down a development scenario where citizens will
have a higher standard of living, will be better educated, will face better social
justice, will have a more equitable socio-economic environment, and the sustainability of development will be ensured through better protection from climate
change and natural disasters. The associated political environment will be based on
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
4
Social Issues: Occupation Change and Food Security in Bangladesh
55
democratic principles with emphasis on human rights, freedom of expression, rule of
law, equality of citizens irrespective of race, religion and creed, and equality of
opportunities. The Bangladesh economy will be managed within the two framework
of a market economy with appropriate government interventions to correct market
distortions, to ensure equality of opportunities, and to ensure equity and social justice for all. The implementation of Vision 2021 will be done through two medium
term development.
4.2.1
An Overview of Agricultural Growth in Bangladesh
Although the share of agriculture in gross domestic product (GDP) has declined
from over half at the time of independence to around one fifth currently, it remains
the predominant sector in terms of employment and livelihood, with about half of
Bangladesh’s workforce engaged in it as the principal occupation. Agriculture is the
principal source of food and nutrition. Therefore the level of farm production and
prices are a key determinant of poverty and human welfare. Agriculture also contributes significantly to export earnings of Bangladesh and agricultural output is
used as an important source of raw materials of many industries. Therefore, the
importance of agriculture sector in generating employment, alleviating poverty and
fostering growth is needless to mention. Agricultural growth has accelerated from
less than 2.0 % per year during the first two decades after independence to around
3.0 % during the last decade. Despite such a steady growth in agriculture as well as
in food production, Bangladesh has been facing persistent challenges in achieving
food security. This is mainly due to natural disasters and fluctuations in food prices
from the influence of volatile international market for basic food items. Sudden
increase of price of staple food such as rice and flour erode the purchasing capacity
of the poor people.
Access to food will continue to depend on comprehensive economic development including faster growth in industry and service sector of the economy. But since
almost half of the labor force still depend on the agricultural sector for employment,
growth of this sector and favorable terms of trade for agricultural commodities are
crucial for increasing incomes of the low-income people and to expand their capacity
for accessing food. A rapid agricultural growth will sustain high growth of the economy with better capacity to reduce poverty through enhancing rural wages, creating
synergies for diversifying the rural economy, and enabling the supply of low-cost
food to improve nutritional status and food security of the people.
Encouraging agricultural growth requires various policies ranging from applying
new technology and extension services to providing credit to small farmers. The
past growth in agriculture was helped by the new HYV (High yielding variety)
technology, particularly in rice, in which both the state and the market played
important roles. The Government would continue its pro-active role in delivering
key public goods in agriculture, particularly in improving the ability of farmers to
adopt new technology and providing appropriate mix of incentives to pursue
profitable operations. Efforts would be made to ensure preservation of indigenous
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
56
A.W.R. Hassan and A.K. Das
knowledge with respect to seeds, plants and herbs, where tapping the traditional
knowledge base of both rural men and woman would be important. Particular attention would be given to develop and adopt technologies and improved agricultural
practices in ecologically vulnerable areas such as saline prone areas and flood and
drought prone locations. In recognition to women’s various contributions in farm
productivity (fisheries, livestock, poultry etc.) and agricultural growth (pre and post
harvesting, field crop production) special measures would be taken to increase
women’s participation in these sectors.
Bangladesh has made significant progress in food grain and especially rice production but ensuring food security of the people of Bangladesh remains a daunting
challenge. The National Food Policy and its Plan of Action identify the objectives
to be fulfilled so as to ensure food security, extending the concept of food security
well beyond that of food availability. In this context, agriculture contributes to food
security by making enough varied and nutritious food available and by providing
employment thus ensuring economic access to food. “The 2011 Country Investment
Plan (CIP): A roadmap towards investments in agriculture, food security and nutrition” has been formulated within the context of the SFYP to help focus Government,
DP and non-Government interventions on priority areas.
4.3
Performance of Agriculture Sector
Agriculture sector is comprised of four sub sectors, e.g. crops, forestry, livestock
and fisheries with crop sub sector being the predominant one (Table 4.1). In spite of
the gradual decline of the relative importance of crop sector in agriculture and in
Table 4.1 Growth performances of agriculture sub-sectors
FY80-90
Growth as % change
Agriculture (A + B)
A. Agriculture and forestry
(i) Crops and horticulture
(ii) Animal farming
(iii) Forest and related services
B. Fishing
(Share as % of GDP)
Agriculture (A + B)
A. Agriculture and forestry
(i) Crops and horticulture
(ii) Animal farming
(iii) Forest and related services
B. Fishing
Source: BBS (2011)
FY91-00
FY00-05 FY05-09 FY10 FY11(P)
2.5
2.6
2.7
2.1
2.7
2.3
2.8
1.5
1.1
2.5
3.5
8.1
3.3
3.6
3.2
4.5
4.7
2.6
4.2
4.2
4.0
4.4
5.4
4.1
5.2
5.6
6.1
3.4
5.2
4.1
5.0
4.8
5.0
3.5
5.4
5.4
31.1
26.5
20.2
2.2
4.8
26.7
21.4
16.1
3.4
2.0
5.3
23.9
18.4
13.7
3.0
1.9
5.4
21.4
16.6
12.0
2.9
1.8
4.8
20.3
15.8
11.4
2.7
1.7
4.5
20.0
15.5
11.2
2.6
1.7
4.4
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
4
Social Issues: Occupation Change and Food Security in Bangladesh
57
national economy, it still has remained the most important sector of agriculture.
More importantly, the crop sector provides staple food such as rice and wheat, and
other daily necessities like pulses, oil, sugar, vegetables, spices, and fruits.
Non-crop agriculture (livestock, fisheries and forestry) also plays a significant
role in terms of employment generation and contribution to GDP. Although livestock accounts for only 3 % of total GDP, it employs about 20 % of rural labor force.
Fisheries sub-sector contributes about 5 % of total GDP and employs about 13 % of
rural labor force. Livestock sub-sector contributes output for both production and
consumption. However there exists a gap between requirement of livestock products
and their current levels of production and, this gap is expected to widen further due
to increase in per capita income and change in food consumption pattern.
Fisheries sector contributes 4.4 % of total GDP and 22 % of agricultural
GDP. The -scale open water capture fisheries which was dominant in the 1970s has
given way to close water culture fisheries, which is now playing an important role
in the development of the sub-sector.
Forestry sector contributes about 1.8 % of the total GDP. Forests also play an
important role in protecting watersheds, irrigation and hydraulic structure and also
in keeping the rivers and ports navigable and protect coastal areas from natural
calamities. The role of forest in protecting the environment from pollution and its
contribution towards bio-diversity is immense. In addition, the participatory social
forestry contributes towards rural poverty reduction. For example, in the last 3 years,
out of total sale proceeds of timber and fuel wood about 308 million taka has been
distributed to 23,561 participants.
Bangladesh has achieved remarkable progress in agriculture since her independence in 1971. Within crop sub-sector, food grain, particularly rice crop dominated
country’s agricultural scenario in terms of both cropped area and production,
claiming a share of 74 % and 54 % respectively in 1996/1997. There has, however,
been shift in the composition of agriculture over the past few years as indicated by
gradual decline in the share of crop agriculture and increase in the share of non-crop
agriculture (NCA).
In crop agriculture, Bangladesh has made steady progress in the post-independence
period. The cropping intensity increased from 148 % to 181 %. Food grain production
although increased substantially over the years, following the introduction of high
yielding varieties (HYV) and application of modern inputs like fertilizers and
pesticides; but its dependence on weather results in fluctuations in production.
Wide fluctuations in production leads to large instability in food grain prices
having serious implications for household food security and also for the welfare of
the people.
For over a decade, a wide range of policy reforms have been implemented.
Few of these are privatization of input distribution, input and food subsidy, import
liberalization and a of the scope of private investment in agriculture. In recent years,
the coverage of policy reforms in the agriculture sector has substantially expanded
to include minor irrigation equipment, agricultural machinery, seeds and agricultural trade.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
A.W.R. Hassan and A.K. Das
58
4.4
Key Challenges
The myriad of existing policies are generally compatible in terms of their avowed
goals of rapid poverty reduction, increasing productivity and profitability of farming,
creating income and employment opportunities, especially for the rural population.
The major thrusts of these policies are largely consistent with the MDGs as well as
the strategies and future policy priorities of agriculture and rural development
policy matrix suggested in the previous plan documents. However, there are some
generic areas of concerns. Those are as follows:
4.4.1
Dominance of Cereal Food Production
The National Agriculture Policy, 1999, National Agriculture Policy Plan of Action
2004, APB and other major crop sector policy documents mainly focus on food
production, especially rice production, giving lesser attention to non cereal crops
i.e. vegetables, fruits and flowers. As one would expect, policy prescriptions for
input distribution and input levels, extension services, credit delivery and output
marketing are directed to major cereal food crop, rice and not much to wheat.
4.4.2
Inadequate Progress with Diversification
and Commercialization
The policy documents mention diversification and commercialization of agriculture
as a common objective, but very little understanding is given with respect to relative
profitability of competing crops, physical and location specific conditions for
non-crop enterprise, supply chain of high value products and provision for processing,
storage and marketing activities.
4.4.3
Lack of Modernization of Soil and Water Tests
Soil tests for proper fertilizer use and water quality tests for fish culture are crucially
important interventions. The concerned policies mention these casually to imply
that the government should do these, but there does not seem to be much understanding of the recent trends that the private sector has already taken up soil tests
(with Catalyst support) and water test by as business ventures, for example by an
local NGO, Shushilon.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
4
Social Issues: Occupation Change and Food Security in Bangladesh
4.4.4
59
Lack of Modern Form of Production-Contract
Farming and Value Chain
The policies being reviewed conceive agriculture as individualistic production
system, although this is becoming economically and technically unfeasible for
increasingly large number of small and marginal farmers due to rapid decline in
average farm size. Increase in number of farms vis-à-vis rapid loss of cultivable land
is recognized in the documents, but there are no reflections on or contemplation
about the emerging new forms of farming e.g. contract farming by the private sector
for high value products like poultry, vegetables, aromatic rice, milk and so on.
4.4.5
Absence of Farm and Non-farm Linkages
The most conspicuous shortcoming of all the policy documents is their silence over
the growing non-farm sector development. Even the most recent policy documents,
e.g. APB, avoid any analysis of linking the growth of farm productivity with development of non-farm activities.
In addition to the above mentioned issues, some other constraints in this
sector are:
• Absence of demanding technologies to co-opt with climate change,
• Unstable market price of agricultural products, which is a barrier for farmers to
select crops for cultivation in the following season/year,
• Very little stress to agro-based industrialization,
• Depletion of soil health/soil fertility,
• Unusual depletion of underground water table,
• Unwise development of infrastructures (dams, roads etc.) blocking drainage,
• Non-zonal based cultivation and lack of development of market chain,
• Overlapping of irrigation units with less command area, causing huge loss of
underground water and resulting in depletion of ground water table.
• Overdose of chemical fertilizer by the farmer is a threat to soil health.
4.5
Employment and Occupations
Employment provides the key link between economic growth and poverty making
it the major instrument for poverty reduction in Bangladesh. Labour force (age 15+)
in Bangladesh increased from around 19.7 million in 1974 to 49.5 million in 2006,
the latest available year for Labour Force Survey (LFS). That gives an annual long
term trend growth rate of 2.9 %. The labour force growth rate was more expansive
in recent years owing to the changing demographic structure of higher share of
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
A.W.R. Hassan and A.K. Das
60
Table 4.2 Major occupations distribution in Bangladesh (percent)
Principal occupation
Crop agriculture
Non crop agriculture
Labor
Transport
Trading
Service
House work
Industry
Old age
Retired
Total
Source: Qusem (2009)
Metropolitan
30.00
0.70
12.00
3.30
30.70
14.00
0.70
0.00
4.70
4.00
100.00
Urban
42.70
2.0
4.70
4.00
24.00
10.70
3.30
0.70
3.30
4.70
100.00
Pre-urban
46.00
00.0
12.00
2.00
26.00
8.00
1.30
00.00
3.30
1.30
100.00
Rural
54.70
1.30
10.70
1.30
15.30
5.30
3.30
0.70
6.00
1.30
100.00
Total
45.30
1.00
9.80
2.70
24.00
9.50
2.20
0.30
4.30
2.80
100.00
population in the working age group as well as a rising female participation rate.
Thus, the average annual growth of labour force between 2000 and 2006 was 3.3 %.
As compared to labour force, employment grew at a slightly slower pace of 2.8 %
annually. As a result, the unemployment rate, traditionally defined, increased
modestly, 15 reaching 2.1 million people, which is about 4 % of the labour force.
This relatively modest unemployment rate, however, hides the true employment
challenge in Bangladesh. Like other poor agrarian economies, Bangladesh suffers
from what is known as the problem of “disguised unemployment” that is characterized
by the concentration of a large number of workers in low hours, low productivity,
and low income jobs. These disguised unemployed are engaged in agriculture and
informal services.
A field survey conducted by Qusem (2009) revealed the distribution of major
occupations in Bangladesh (Table 4.2). The total perspective has been differentiated
into metropolitan, urban, pre-urban and rural sectors. Nature of occupation varies
with the variations in occupational sectors. Metropolitan, urban, pre urban and rural
area is dominated by crop agriculture and trading. Total result also reflected the
similar trend in occupation. So agriculture is still playing a vital role in the distribution
of occupational variations. Crop agriculture in Bangladesh is, however, constrained
by a number of challenges.
The most important challenges are loss of arable land, population growth and
climate change effect on agriculture. Bangladesh has lost about 1 million ha of
productive arable land from 1983 to 1996 (BBS 1999). That is about 80,000 ha of
agricultural land per year are going out of crop production. Another major challenge
to agriculture is the increase in the growth of population. Population is increasing @
two million per year and total population would be around 233 million by 2050 if
current growth rate continues.
Climate change is another vital factor affecting the crop sector of Bangladesh.
As a result of climate change soil fertility, crop productivity, occupation of the rural
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
4
Social Issues: Occupation Change and Food Security in Bangladesh
61
people and food security would be seriously threatened. Is has also accelerated hunger,
poverty, malnutrition and incidence of diseases (IPCC 2007). This vulnerable
situation of the crop agricultural is directly concerned to the stability of the people
involved in crop agriculture.
4.6
Food Security Status
The Government of Bangladesh has identified Food Security as an important factor
contributing to its socio-economic stabilization and development. Food security
exists when all people, at all times, have physical, social and economic access to
sufficient, safe and nutritious food which meets their dietary needs and food preferences for an active and healthy life. To discuss food security, three important aspects
must be considered e.g. availability of adequate food, stability in food supplies,
access to food, and nutrition security. Bangladesh has made a steady progress in the
expansion of food production. But because of the increasing population pressure
there has been an extensive use of land to meet the growing demand for food.
Despite the growth in food production and its availability, food insecurity is still a
major problem mainly because of the lack of purchasing power and thus of access
to food, especially for the ultra poor community. A major portion of the rural population is landless, and as labors they depend on casual earning for their livelihood.
Due to the seasonal variation in agricultural employment and limited employment
opportunities in nonfarm sector, millions of people suffer from chronic and transitory
food insecurity. The average Bangladesh diet is deficit in energy by about 15 %. It is
seriously unbalanced with an inadequate intake of fat, oil, fish/animal protein, fruit
and vegetable.
The 1996 World Food Summit definition of food security is “food security exists
when all people, at all times, have physical and economic access to sufficient, safe
and nutritious food to meet their dietary needs and food preferences for an active
and healthy life”.
4.6.1
Food Security Status and Challenges
Food security situation in Bangladesh has improved, especially on the availability
side, and further improvements on access and utilization, to be sustainable and
large-scale, needs renewed efforts from the government, civil society (including
media) and the development partners. Records say in 1970s, 70 % people were
under the food consumption poverty line. Today this is down to under half of the
population. Today, though people are not dying, they are going hungry and becoming
stunted with reduced mental and physical capacity. They are suffering. The hungry
population of over 60 million people is larger than most other global cases- the
third largest poor population in any country after China and India. Nearly half of
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
62
A.W.R. Hassan and A.K. Das
Bangladesh’s children are underweight, making it one of the most severe cases of
malnutrition in the world. While Bangladesh has definitely got more food than it
had 30 years back, yet almost half of Bangladesh is still far from being food secure.
The World Bank and GoB-UN in their respective reports on MDGs, put the target
of 34 % children being underweight as non-attainable at present rates of progress.
Much will need to be done to achieve the 2015 MDG target of halving the proportion of people who suffer from hunger and malnutrition. Demographic changes
in upcoming years are likely to affect poverty and hunger in adverse ways. While
poverty is an overall denominator of this food insecurity in the country, the additional intensifiers are disability (gender, age, and physical challenge) and location
(disaster proneness, access to the market, etc.) as well as other aspects related to
utilization (education, awareness, cultural practices, etc.). Issues of governance and
accountability further thwart attempts at providing targeted safety nets and price
stabilization.
Access to food is very vital particularly in a country like Bangladesh where about
50 % of population lives below the poverty line. The income of the poor does not
permit them to have sufficient food intake. The strategic goal of the national policy
would be to improve the ‘access’ concerns for an effective food security situation in
the country. Increasing poor peoples’ access to food requires improvement of earning capacity of the poor and vulnerable section of the population and successful
implementation of the targeted food programs in a cost effective manner.
4.7
Conclusion
Agricultural development, perhaps more so in Bangladesh than in many other
places, is an essential part of reducing (mainly rural) poverty and improving food
security and occupation opportunities. The most direct role of the agricultural sector
relates to ensuring the availability of food and maintaining low prices in local
markets. However, the development of the agricultural sector with its high multiplier
effects, results in increased agricultural income which is, in turn, an important driver
of rural growth and thus key to improved access to food in rural areas. The agricultural sector plays a key role in addressing the need of ensuring a more balance diet
and food security in Bangladesh. This role entails improving the incentives for
producing non staple food, including vegetables, fruit, pulses, oils and animal food,
but also in increasing the nutrient density of rice. The employment opportunities
were mainly dominated by the agriculture sector. Due to diverse issues people
engaged in agriculture are moving to alternative occupations which ultimately influence
agricultural production and creating adverse effects on food security issues.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
4
Social Issues: Occupation Change and Food Security in Bangladesh
63
References
Bangladesh Planning Commission (2005) Unlocking the potential: national strategy for
accelerated poverty reduction. Published by Planning Commission, Government of People’s
Republic of Bangladesh
BBS (1999) Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistic and Information Division (SID), Ministry of
Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh
BBS (2011) Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Statistical pocket Book of Bangladesh-2011, Statistic
and Information Division (SID), Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of
Bangladesh
FAO (2006) The state of food insecurity in the world. FAO, Rome
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) (2007) Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability.
Report of working group-II, Cambridge, UK
Qusem Md, Abul (2009) Conversion of Agricultural Land to Non-agricultural Uses in Bangladesh:
Extent and determinants, Bangladesh Development Studies Vol. XXXIV, March 2011, No. 1
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 5
Livelihood Security: Implications
from Agriculture Sectors
Abu Wali Raghib Hassan and Rajib Shaw
Abstract The major livelihood strategy in rural Bangladesh is subsistence
agriculture either through agriculture production activities, agriculture labor or
both. On the other hand, agriculture plays a key role in economy due to its role in
food security, employment and livelihood. For increasing food production and
attaining food sufficiency, Bangladesh has achieved remarkable progress in agriculture
since its independence in 1971. Bangladesh has been one of the prime beneficiaries
of the global “Green Revolution” based on introduction of high yielding seeds, use
of chemical fertilizers, and irrigation of land for enhanced agricultural productivity.
It has been seen that food production has tripled from 10 million metric tons to
30 million metric tons over last three decades. Record amount of food produced in
1996–1997 which ultimately helped to attain self sufficiency. Despite tremendous
accomplishments related to food security, this chapter tries to give the insights of
livelihood security through the improvement of agriculture sector.
Keywords Green revolution • Agricultural production • Food security • Livelihood
security
5.1
Introduction
Bangladesh is predominantly an agrarian economy. It is one of the most densely
populated countries of the world with current population of more than 150 million
people in 147,570 km2 area with a population density of more than 1,100 people per
km2. By 2050, the population will have grown to more than 200 million, with almost
half of the people living in cities and towns.
A.W.R. Hassan (*)
Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture, Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: hassan58_dae@yahoo.com
R. Shaw
Graduate School of Global Environmental Studies, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
e-mail: shaw.rajib.5u@kyoto-u.ac.jp
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_5
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
65
A.W.R. Hassan and R. Shaw
66
The agricultural sector plays a vital role in the economy of Bangladesh in terms
of its contribution to GDP, employment generation, livelihoods and poverty alleviation. Agriculture sector is comprised of four sub-sectors, e.g. crops, forestry, livestock and fisheries. Crop sub sector being the predominant one still remains the
largest one in the economy although its share declines at around 50 % in agriculture
sector and in national economy. More importantly, the crop sector provides staple
food such as rice and wheat, and other daily necessities like pulses, oil, sugar,
vegetables, spices, and fruits. Non-crop agriculture (livestock, fisheries and forestry)
also has significant role in employment generation and contribution to GDP. Livestock
sub-sector employs about 20 % of rural labour force although it accounts for only
2.6 % of total GDP. Fisheries sub-sector currently contributes about 4 % of total
GDP and employs about 13 % of rural labor force. Forestry sector contributes about
1.7 % of the total GDP.
Crop is the major sub-sector in the agriculture sector and accounted for 13.44 %
of GDP. As about 47.5 % of the total labour force is engaged in agriculture (BBS
2012), the sector has an important role to play in supporting the rural population of
Bangladesh. Agricultural growth has accelerated from less than 2.0 % per year
during the first two decades after independence in 1971 to around 3.0 % during the
last decade. Despite such a steady growth in agriculture as well as in food production,
Bangladesh has been facing persistent challenges in achieving food security. This is
mainly due to natural disasters and fluctuations in food prices from the influence of
volatile international market for basic food items.
A large number of the population live below the poverty line in rural Bangladesh
due to an increase in the population, fragmentation and loss of land to other sectors
(less then 1 % annually), and limited job opportunities. As such the vulnerability of
the agriculture sector to climate change exacerbates poverty levels and undermines
efforts in poverty reduction.
5.2
Food Security and Livelihood Status
There exist no unique livelihood approaches to ensure food security. Sustainable
livelihood approaches are needed to ensure food security. Many risks in livelihood
approaches are location specific because of high geographical and natural vulnerability. For natural drawbacks such as- flood, drought, riverbank erosion, salinity
problem and tidal inundation food security is not ensured in these areas all over
the year.
Ability of people to acquire food depends upon their exchange entitlement. Poor
people achieve their exchange entitlement mainly from production (crops and
livestock) and own-labour (wages labour and professions) based entitlements. Poor
people could not ensure their food security when they loss these entitlements-loss of
crops, livestock, jobs and fall in wages. Mainly in times of disaster or shocks,
hardcore people loss their ability to acquire enough food. In times of shocks, ability
of people to cope up can be increased by some direct and indirect financial or
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
5
Livelihood Security: Implications from Agriculture Sectors
67
non-financial aids from outside. These supports can improve the livelihood
approaches so that hardcore state of livelihood of the people and food security
will improve.
Bangladesh has made a considerable achievement in food grain production and
ensuring this food security. Despite many challenges including scarcity of land,
climate change and high population growth, etc. attaining self sufficiency in rice
production in recent past has been a major achievement for Bangladesh. Over the
last three decades, cereal production has increased from about 10 million tons in
1970s to more than 30 million tons in 2008. Rice production tripled from 11 million
tons in 1972 to 32 million tons in 2009. During this time population doubled from
around 70–140 million. Per capita availability of rice increased from 140 kg in 1972
to 180 kg in 2008 (Alam and Islam 2013). Food security situation in Bangladesh has
improved, especially on average per capita dietary energy supply has improved
from 1,800 kcal in 1970s to 3,055 in 2009 (BBS 2010). Rice demand requirements
could be estimated just on the basis of population growth with base year consumption of 439.6 g/person/day. In 2030 will be 30.60 million tons. It is expected that
rice consumption will be 38.62 million tons for 2030 (and 32.56 million tons
for 2021).
Fisheries sector plays an important role in food consumption, nutrition, employment, export and the socio-economic development of Bangladesh. This sector has a
contribution in national GDP (3.74 %), foreign remittances (3 %) and in the national
animal protein consumption (58 %) (DoF 2010). It involves 1.4 million people in
full time employment and 11 million peoples in part time employment (Haque et al.
1991). Livestock plays an important role in the national economy of the country,
providing 15 % of total employment. About 12 % agricultural GDP comes from the
livestock sector and 10 million people are directly involved to this livestock sector
for their livelihood (Karim et al. 2010). Fish production increased from 1.89 million
tons (2001–2002) to 2.89 million tons (2010–2011) over the last 10 years. Meat
production from 0.78 million tons (2001–2002) to 2.95 million tons (2010–2011),
milk production from 1.78 million tons (2001–2002) to 2.89 million tons (2010–2011)
and egg production from 4,424 million (2001–2002) to 6,078 million (2010–2011)
has also increased significantly over the last 10 years (DoF, DoL 2011).
5.2.1
Climate Change and Livelihood in Bangladesh
Climate change is likely to have serious affect on agriculture (crops, livestock and
fisheries) due to variability of meteorological parameters (precipitation, temperature),
extreme events (floods, cyclones, and storm surges) and slow onset events (salinity
intrusion, drought). Although agriculture now accounts for 20 % of GDP around
55–60 % of people (MoF 2013) depend on agriculture directly or indirectly for their
livelihoods. The higher temperature and changing rainfall patterns, coupled with
increased flooding, rising salinity in the coastal belt and droughts are likely to
reduce crop yields and crop production, and expected to negatively impact food
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
68
A.W.R. Hassan and R. Shaw
security and livelihoods in the country. The Bangladeshi economy is not out of this
realm and prediction. The scientific evidence for climate change impacts is now real
for Bangladesh and scientifically, it is clear that changing climate patterns often
adversely affected the soil, water, plants, health, animals, agriculture and the economy (Al-Amin et al. 2010; Al-Amin and Filho 2011; Al-Amin and Alam 2011;
Lobell et al. 2011).
The impacts of climate change on agriculture are global concern but for
Bangladesh, where lives and livelihoods depend mainly on agriculture, are exposed
to a great danger.
Bangladesh is one of the most vulnerable countries to climate change because of
its disadvantageous geographic location; flat and low-lying topography; dense population; high levels of poverty; reliance of many livelihoods on climate sensitive
sectors, particularly crop agriculture and fisheries; and inefficient institutional and
poor infrastructure. Floods, cyclones, storm surges and droughts are expected to
become more frequent and severe in the coming years. The effects of climate change
on agriculture and other sectors are already evident. The agricultural sector is most
likely to face significant yield reduction in future due to climate variability (Islam
et al. 2011). Many of the anticipated adverse effects of climate change, such as
temperature, rainfall, humidity, day length etc. Production of crops, particularly
rice, is often constrained by different climatic hazards such as floods, droughts, soil
and water salinity, cyclones and water surges etc., will aggravate the existing stresses
that already impede development in Bangladesh.
Bangladesh, annually and inter-annually experiences floods, cyclone, droughts,
river bank erosion, salinity increase, tornados and other extreme natural events that
affect the development of the country in lost lives, agriculture, fisheries, other assets
and infrastructure (ADPC and BCAS 2008) resulting into food insecurity and poverty for millions of the affected people. The country has recently been facing
increased natural disasters and climatic extreme events like prolonged and repeated
floods in the northern and central parts along with river bank erosion; severe
cyclones, sea level rise and salinity in the coastal districts; erratic rainfall; and
drought in the northwest parts (BCAS 2008). The frequent devastating recent
cyclones Sidr (15 November 2007), Aila (April 2009), Nargis (2010, though affected
Bangladesh a little) and very recent Mahasen (19/20 May 2013) and series of prolonged flood of 2007 (two spells of flood) and 2009, beyond the devastating floods
of 1987, 1988, 1998 and 2004 have severely damaged our development efforts,
livelihoods (agricultural crops, fisheries, livestock), infrastructures etc. and killed
thousands of people.
According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC),
Bangladesh may experience 10–15 % more rainfall by 2030. This excessive rainfall
will result in crop failure and production decline. This again will aggravate the present food security condition and will destroy many people’s livelihoods and thus will
drag them below poverty line. Climate change contributes to increase frequency and
severity of disasters with adverse impacts on humans, natural ecosystem and quality
of human survival. The poor people suffer from malnutrition as they fail to procure
food due to crop loss/damage, high price of essentials, lack of job opportunity etc.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
5
Livelihood Security: Implications from Agriculture Sectors
69
for recurrent natural disaster. Deforestation, over fishing, over grazing, salt built up,
water borne diseases from irrigation, endangered wild life from loss of habitat, loss
of genetic diversity, water pollution, air pollution and climate change are related to
each other and having impacts on food production, lives and livelihoods on the
people of Bangladesh.
Intergovernmental Panel for Climate Change (IPCC) also projected that South
Asia will suffer most due to climate change as 22 % of world’s population (about
1.4 billion) including 40 % of world’s poor live of which more than half of the population is directly dependent on agriculture. It is also predicted that heat waves, heavy
precipitation events will become more frequent and crop yields could decrease up to
30 % in Central and South Asia by the mid-twenty first centuries. All of these would
contribute to increase the disaster events and Bangladesh would be the most vulnerable country to face climate induced disasters more frequently (Nasreen 2012).
The frequent devastating recent cyclones Sidr (15 November 2007), Aila (April
2009), Nargis (2010, though affected Bangladesh a little) and very recent Mahasen
(19–20 May 2013) and series of prolonged flood of 2007 (two spells of flood) and
2009, beyond the devastating floods of 1987, 1988, 1998 and 2004 have severely
damaged our development efforts, livelihoods (agricultural crops, fisheries, livestock),
infrastructures etc. and killed thousands of people.
Climate change contributes to increase frequency and severity of disasters with
adverse impacts on humans, natural ecosystem and quality of human survival.
Deforestation, over fishing, over grazing, salt intrusion, water borne diseases,
endangered wild life from loss of habitat, loss of genetic diversity, water pollution,
air pollution and climate change are related to each other and having impacts on
food production, lives and livelihoods on the people of Bangladesh. Climate change
has added a new dimension to the relational analysis from gender perspective
(Nasreen 2008).
Climate change induced disasters and food insecurity affect both women and
men but the burden of coping with disaster falls heavily on women’s shoulders in
Bangladesh. Women suffer more than men from poverty, hunger, malnutrition,
economic crises, environmental degradation, health related problems, insecurity
and become victim of violence and political crises. The gendered division of labour
becomes critical as gender roles are often reinforced and even intensified – due to
the additional work and changes in environment brought on by a disaster. It has been
argued that violation of women’s rights becomes more prominent during disaster.
People have to depend on relief to cope with disaster, however, relief do not reach
to those people who mostly need it. Women’s own adoptive techniques and initiatives become crucial for their family sustenance and ensuring food security (Nasreen
2008). The climate change is posing challenge to the livelihoods in different ways.
Livelihoods are either disrupted by the extreme weather events like cyclone, heavy
downpour, floods, erosion, storm surges, dense fogs, sea turbulence or by slow onset
disasters like salinization, dryness/drought, ecosystem degradation etc. (OXFAM 2009).
Women’s contribution to rural production activities include raising seedlings,
gathering seeds, post-harvesting, cow fattening and milking, goat farming, backyard
poultry rearing, pisciculture, agriculture, horticulture, food processing, cane and
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
A.W.R. Hassan and R. Shaw
70
bamboo works, silk reeling, handloom weaving, garment making, fishnet making,
coir production and handicrafts. It is evident that women’s own adoptive techniques
and initiatives become crucial for their family sustenance and ensuring food security (Nasreen 2012). People of coastal belt, char and haor areas in Bangladesh are
continuously fighting with impact of climate change. Climate change is forcing
people to take diversified occupation to maintain their livelihood.
Most of the people live in the countryside somehow depend on agriculture either
livestock or fisheries. Rural people are likely more engage themselves in livestock
farming for their livelihoods. It is always a matter to meet the protein demand in the
country where its population reaches to more than 160 million. Bangladesh livestock is the second largest sector after fisheries to meet the national protein demand
(BARC 2011). However, unfortunately the livestock is under threat due to the
climatic patterns.
Climate change has already impacted on the life and livelihoods of the people in
the coastal areas and in the arid and semi-arid regions of Bangladesh. In particular,
the effects of climate change on agriculture and other sectors are already evident.
The agricultural sector is most likely to face significant yield reduction in future
due to climate variability (Islam et al. 2011). Most importantly, crop agriculture is
the most vulnerable to climate change among different sectors of the Bangladesh
economy.
The impacts of salinity intrusion usually consider only the most important sector
namely shrimp cultivation. Natural populations of species which are affected by
salinization will adapt their lifestyle e.g. by migration to a more ideal habitat. This
influences the natural dispersion of species and where populations spawn, affecting
fisheries and aquaculture if they are dependent on such natural processes. The
impact of excessive salinization affects the bagda shrimp cultivation because it is
dependent of natural fry collection, which is declining due to a degrading environment, and unsustainable fry catching (Hoq et al. 2001). Bangladesh is very rich in
fresh water fisheries, which plays a vital role in nutrition, direct and indirect employment of about 12–13 million people, foreign exchange earnings and in other areas
of the economy of Bangladesh. The fisheries of Bangladesh are highly sensitive to
climate change and its impacts on captured fish production especially from floodplain fisheries might increase due to expansion of flooded area while culture fish
production (pond fish) would decrease due to overtopping of flood water. Capture
fisheries, especially overall floodplain fish production, may increase by 9 % under
the A2 emission scenario and 7 % under B2 emission scenario in 2050. On the other
hand, sea level rise could reduce habitat for fresh water fish in the delta. Therefore,
production of freshwater fisheries may be hampered as the species of fresh water
carp, catfish, perch etc. are highly susceptible to moderate level of salinity.
The increasing temperature and humidity due to climate change will make livestock, especially, cattle, vulnerable. Lower intakes of dry matter due to temperature
rise along with increasing humidity leads to body weight changes and other output
changes such as reduction in milk production, which may decrease by 2.5 %
annually by 2030. Milk output may further reduce by around 5 % in the 2050 the
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
5
Livelihood Security: Implications from Agriculture Sectors
71
highest reduction occurs during March–May. In the coastal area, livestock are most
vulnerable to cyclones and storm surges along with tidal flooding. About 20 % of
suitable area will be reduced in 2050 for livestock due to sea level rise.
By 2050 the reduction of rice production caused by climate variability will be as
high as 12.8 % of the production that would have been achieved without climate
variability. All rice, Aus, Aman and Boro are affected by climate change parameters. In Bangladesh climate variability will reduce long term rice production by an
average 7.4 % each year during 2005–2050, primarily by undermining production
of the Aman and Aus crop (World Bank 2009).
Overall, it is apprehended that crop production might be reduced by 30 % by the
end of the century, especially rice and wheat production might be reduced between
8 % and 32 % respectively by 2050 (FPMU 2013). In particular, winter crop production would be seriously hampered due to warmer and drier environment, while
moisture stress might force farmers to reduce the area under boro cultivation. Thus
climate change adaptation requires investments in agricultural research and extension with a particular emphasis on development and diffusion of stress resistant high
yielding varieties.
5.3
Resources Constraints in the Face of Changing Climate
In Bangladesh, ensuring food security has been one of the major national priorities
in last few decades but the target has always been interrupted by its resource constraints. Moreover, adverse climate change impact accelerated this constraints
affecting on natural resources and human livelihood. Major national resources constraints, which are facing to climate change way forwarding to the food security.
However, major constraints in terms of food security in Bangladesh attributed to
cultivable land scarcity, irrigation water scarcity in summer, lack of technological
knowledge, lack of climate adaptive crop variety, lack of institutions and professionals as well as social and cultural constraints is prominent (Anik et al. 2012).
5.3.1
Land Scarcity
Land resource is the fundamental natural resource that provides habitat and sustenance for living organisms, as well as being a major focus of economic activities.
Bangladesh is principally an agricultural country, characterized by rice paddy
agriculture dominated landscapes. So, land resource is the major asset contributing
wealth and livelihood in rural areas, although land-man ratio is very low in the
world, estimated to be 0.06 hectares (ha) per person (FAO 2013). Landlessness has
acute impact on national food production and ultimately threatens to go forward to
food security. Degradation of cultivable land added new dimension because it loses
potential production capability by decreasing soil quality as well as effective use.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
A.W.R. Hassan and R. Shaw
72
Table 5.1 Bangladesh
agriculture at a glance
Category
Amount
Total area
14.86 million ha
Forest
2.59 million ha
Cultivable land
8.52 million ha
Current fellow
0.26 million ha
Single cropped area
2.23 million ha
Double cropped area
4.10 million ha
Triple cropped area
1.48 million ha
Net cropped area
7.83 million ha
Total cropped area
14.94 million ha ton
Total food crop production
37.26 million metric ton
Source: Ministry of Agriculture (MoA) (2012)
Climate change impacts result such as cyclones, floods, salinity intrusion, sea level
rising enhance the threat in an alarming rate. Population of Bangladesh is already
too big by any standard compared to its total land. Increasing sea level rise and river
bank erosion are two most important reasons to lead the land shortage of the
country. According to Ministry of Agriculture, area of total cultivable land is
8.44 million ha (Table 5.1) (Anik et al. 2012).
5.3.2
Irrigation Water Scarcity
Water experts have sounded an alarm that within the next 25 years, half of the
population of the world could have trouble in finding enough fresh water for
drinking and irrigation (Khan 2009). Bangladesh is highly dependent on irrigation for
agriculture especially for summer and winter. This scenario is much more delicate
in North-Western and Southern part of the country. In the North-Western part of
the country, which experience droughts annually, are mainly results of adverse climate
change impact such as decreasing rainfall, huge temperature increase and other so
on. The situation is very critical both water for domestic use and for agriculture,
which comes mostly from ground water via deep tube well and shallow tube wells.
Climate change impact resulting drought and decreasing ground water level has
become a main concern to present agricultural activities in drought prone areas,
in northern part. In Southern part, saline water intrusion is the main concern for
agricultural production as well food security. Saline water intrusion in fresh agricultural land made the crisis more acute by decreasing soil fertility. The reason of this
production disparity is due to massive climate change impact on Southern and
North-Western region. Availability of both surface water and ground water is
therefore very critical for the habitation of these areas (Anik et al. 2012).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
5
Livelihood Security: Implications from Agriculture Sectors
5.3.3
73
Lack of Technological Knowledge
Technological adaptations can serve as a potent means of adapting to climate
variability and change. Innovative technologies can be developed to adapt to climate
change impact, and the transfer of appropriate technologies to the developing countries forms an important component of the UNFCCC (Mace 2006). Bangladesh like
other developing countries needs modern technology combating with adverse
climate change impact. Thus, technology transfer from the developed country to
developing country have become more vulnerable, indispensable and the most
discussing issue in any climatic conference. Bangladesh as a developing country
has limitations to introduce modern technology as an adaptation response to climate
change. Farmers in the rural area mostly practice traditional agricultural system
although the scenario has been changing rapidly for the last two decades. However,
present changing face of climate demands new agricultural pattern as well as
advanced technologies to support agriculture, develop innovative varieties of high
yielding crop which can adapt the changing impact of climate (Anik et al. 2012).
5.3.4
Inadequate Institutions and Professionals
Institutional and professionals strength are the important factors for food security in
the all regimes. Institutions comprises both rules and organisations which play
significant role for delivering rural services, supporting implementing project and
programme as well as strengthening marginal people rights and access to the
asset. When institutions are weak, they can hinder effective implementation of policies, but reform often goes beyond single policies and requires an understanding of
institutional structures as well as the way of change. In Bangladesh, institutional set
up perspective on account of the developing country is not satisfactory here. On the
other hand, Bangladesh has huge professional lacking as well as skilled professionals to lead the policies and project regarding fulfilling the national demand of agricultural production and food status. In Bangladesh, although a lot of government
and non-government project regarding food security have been implementing by the
means of rules and organisations, many cases have failed to achieve the goal.
Another significant challenge is lack of interest among the young professionals
in agricultural sector. Although present government has taken a lot of step to
accelerate agricultural sector focusing production increase and ensure food security
and improving livelihood but different barriers are there to interrupt the activities
(Anik et al. 2012).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
74
5.4
A.W.R. Hassan and R. Shaw
Coping Mechanism for Achieving Food Security
and Livelihood Security in the Face of Climate Change
Capacity building and strengthening coping strategies through awareness and
knowledge raising on the climate change impacts, risks and vulnerabilities for the
local communities, actors and stakeholders; partnership building and networking;
mainstreaming climate change into local, national, sectoral and institutional development policies and strategies; and strengthening coping strategies and advancing
adaptive livelihoods options of the communities in the changing environment and
climatic conditions by sectors and ecosystems. The patterns of livelihood and other
activities in case of Agriculture sectors vary according to nature of disasters induced
by climate change. The affected people are taking several strategies to cope with
extreme climatic variability.
Livelihood in drought, flood and saline affected region mostly depends on
agriculture for their subsistence. But, adverse impact of climate change collision
like flood, sea level rising, drought, saline intrusion, cyclones etc. make the overall
agriculture as well as livelihood in this area vulnerable. This section illustrates the
existing agricultural adaptation responses as well as livelihood of different levels
that are undertaken in the different vulnerable areas of Bangladesh.
National Agricultural Research System (NARS) Institutes have given special
thrust to develop different tolerant crop varieties suitable to cultivate in the region.
Bangladesh Rice Research Institute (BRRI) has already developed different
Climate resilient Rice verities.
• BRRI dhan 40, BRRI dhan 41 is saline tolerant rice varieties which grow during
Aman season. It can tolerate salinity up to 8 dS/m during its reproductive stage.
• BRRI dhan 47 is saline tolerant rice varieties which grow during Boro season.
It can tolerate salinity up to 14 dS/m during seedling stage and 6 dS/m during
other growth stage.
• BRRI dhan 55 can tolerate 8–10 dS/m (Fig. 5.1) and BRRI dhan 61 can tolerate
salinity 12–14 dS/m.
• BRRI dhan 53 and BRRI dhan 54 is also saline tolerant short duration Aman
season rice which can be harvested 12–41 days ahead of BR 41 variety. It can
also tolerate 8–10 dS/m during its reproductive stage.
• BRRI dhan 51 and BRRI dhan 52 are submergence tolerant varieties which can
sustain 12–14 days under water.
• Early harvest (short duration) rice varieties: BRRI dhan 33 (110–120 days),
BRRI dhan 39 (120 days), BINA dhan -7 (110–120 days). These varieties can be
harvested in 110–120 days instead of 140–150 days as required for traditional
varieties of paddy.
• BRRI dhan 24, BRRI dhan 42 and BRRI dhan 43 and BRRI dhan 57 (100–105
days) are medium heat tolerant Transplanting Aus rice varieties those can
tolerate medium range drought.
• BRRI dhan 44 can tolerate 50 cm high tidal non-saline water.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
5
Livelihood Security: Implications from Agriculture Sectors
75
Fig. 5.1 BRRI dhan 55 cultivation in saline prone areas
• BR 22, BR 23 and BRRI dhan 46 are late sowing Aman rice varieties which can
be sown after recede of flood water.
• BRRI dhan 36 is a cold tolerant rice variety which can tolerate cold during its
seedling stage.
Bangladesh Institute of Nuclear agriculture (BINA) has also developed different
Climate Resilience high yielding rice varieties. Binasail and Binadhan-8 have special
characteristics of coping with flood rehabilitation situation and salt tolerance.
Binasail is rice grown in Aman season and Binadhan-8 is for Boro season.
Late variety of T. Aman cultivation in flood prone area (Binashail, Nazirshail).
Binadhan 11 and Binadhan- 12.
5.4.1
Technology and Management Package Development
for Other Crops
• Bangladesh Agriculture research Institute and others research institutes has
develop different Climate resilience non-rice crops.
• Wheat BARI Gom 20, BARI Gom 21, BARI Gom 22, BARI Gom 23 and BARI
Gom 24 are identified as heat tolerant varieties. BARI gom-25 for both Saline
and Drought prone areas and BARI gom-26 for Drought prone areas.
• Mustard BARI Sharisha-11 and BARI Sharisha-16 both are Saline and Drought
tolerant variety.
• BARI Sharisha-10 can successfully be grown in saline area (up to 8 dS/m).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
76
A.W.R. Hassan and R. Shaw
• One potato variety named “Saikat” has been recommended for cultivation in
saline belt (up to 8 dS/m)
• Two sweet potato varieties named “BARI sweet potato-6 and BARI sweet potato
7” have yield range of 18–20 t/ha compared to 30–35 t/ha in the non-saline areas.
Moreover, 5 germ plasam have been identified which have salt tolerance levels
up to 8 dS/m.
• BARI Amra 1 and BARI Amra 2 can give satisfactory yield of fruits up to
8 dS/m.
• Heat and drought tolerant two tomato varieties named BARI hybrid tomato-3
and BARI hybrid tomato-4 have been released for cultivation in summer.
One summer brinjal named BARI brinjal 8 and one summer bean named
BARI seem-3 have been released.
• BARI Chola 5 is a drought tolerant chola variety grown well in the Barind area.
• BARI Barley 6 is a drought tolerant variety.
• Raised-bed and zero till are promising technology for crop production for wheat,
maize, pulses, sesame, etc.
• Sugarcane drought tolerant variety Iswardi-20, flood tolerant Iswardi-34 and
saline tolerant Iswardi-38, 39 and 40. Groundnut saline tolerant varieties are
Binachinabadam-1, Binachinabadam-2 by the research Institutes.
In the drought-prone areas, zero tillage, priming of seeds during sowing, mulching,
relay cropping, dry seeding, Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD) short duration
varieties (Fig. 5.2), rain water harvest (mini pond) (Fig. 5.3), Water Saving
Technologies: homestead gardening, etc. are the promising adaptation options.
Farmers in drought prone area have adopted diversified crops like sugarcane,
Fig. 5.2 Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
5
Livelihood Security: Implications from Agriculture Sectors
77
Fig. 5.3 Minipond for supplementary irrigation
Fig. 5.4 Floating vegetable cultivation
different type pulse and oil crops, vegetables and different fruit crops like mango,
jujube etc. in their cropping field to cope with drought.
In the flood prone areas, zero tillage (maize/potato, garlic), floating bed
(vegetables/vegetable seedlings) (Fig. 5.4), raised bed cropping (ditch and dyke or
sorjan system) (Fig. 5.5) and raised bed (vegetables) are identified as the potential
adaptive practices.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
A.W.R. Hassan and R. Shaw
78
Fig. 5.5 Sorjan method cultivation
The entire coastal area is suffering from salinity problem, where, except shrimp
cultivation, agricultural crop cultivation is very limited since crops don’t grow in the
land due to high level of salinity in the soil. Other then rice, adaptation options
like zero tillage (potato/maize), floating bed (vegetables/vegetable seedlings),
ditch-dyke system for crop and fish culture, homestead gardening, and utilization of
gher have been used as the potential adaptation options in the coastal areas.
In moderately saline area crops that are grown during rabi season include
mungbean, lentil, lathyrus, chickpea, cowpea, mustard, linseed, watermelon, chili,
wheat, sweet potato, sunflower, aroids, rabi vegetables and HYV and local boro.
Recently brackish water shrimp followed by transplanted aman are being practiced.
Creating water reservoir (ponds/canals) for irrigation by harvesting/preserving
rainwater and normal flood water has been a common adaptation practices in the
drought and coastal areas, mainly. Drip irrigation is also being used as adaptation
measures, mostly in the northern parts of Bangladesh, where rivers and canals are
very few, prone to drought and ground water level is a big problem. It is practiced
in different other parts of Bangladesh as well at small scale. The drip irrigation
technology is appropriate for small scale crop and vegetable cultivation.
5.4.2
Adaptation in Fisheries/Aquaculture
and Livestock Sector
Most of the coastal lands are not suitable for paddy farming due to high salinity.
People of these areas are traditionally farming brackish water shrimp and coastal
fishes in ghers since time immemorial and adapted to this sort of livelihood options
(Alauddin and Rahman 2013). Fishing provides employment on a full-time or part
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
5
Livelihood Security: Implications from Agriculture Sectors
79
time basis to a large number of households in the coastal region. Over 167,000
fishermen and support staff are employed in the marine sector. In addition, about
185,000 people are engaged in part time shrimp fry collection activities (FAO 2007).
Crab fattening has been a very profitable adaptive livelihoods measures in the
coastal areas due to its availability and low cost but the fattened crab with the good
market value. Raising hatchery to produce crab saplings is very important to facilitate this important adaptive livelihoods option for the poor coastal people.
Planned construction of embankment with appropriate drainage system, height
and width considering cyclone water level can only protect the aquaculture, livestock, agricultural crops and infrastructures as the effective adaptive measures in the
coastal areas. Rearing sheep (bhera) is a very potential livelihoods adaption option
in the coastal areas. Its growth is also very first.
The adaptation measures for fisheries may include: protection and improvement
of floodplain capture fisheries habitat; enhancement of culture fisheries by retaining
water for longer period through pond deepening. Culture of shallow water and
temperature tolerant fish species; cultivation of salt tolerant species in the coastal
area; promotion of marine fisheries for consumption beside fresh water fisheries;
encouragement of paddy-cum-fish polyculture; and encouragement of alternative
livelihood during fish breeding.
Tree plantation in the floodplains and drought prone areas around homestead;
social forestry along the roadsides and in fallow lands and afforestation outside
the embankment with community participation are the important mitigation and
adaptation practices to protect environment, houses and other infrastructures
(embankment, shelters and other livelihoods assets) from the disaster risks (cyclone,
flood, storm surge, etc.).
Bangladesh livestock is the second largest sector after fisheries to meet the
national protein demand (BARC 2011). However, unfortunately the livestock is
under threat due to the climatic patterns. In case of livestock the adaptation measures that can be undertaken are: increase of energy and protein intake for maintaining livestock health during hot summer; use of feeding management practices to
minimize the effects of heat stress and humidity; improvement of housing facilities
with adequate shade, cooling and ventilation to reduce the impact of heat stress;
raising platform/plinth level of housing/killa for livestock in coastal and flood prone
areas. Livestock rearing is an important source of income in all over the country.
Though, the affected people cannot rear poultry and layer due to lack of dry space, but
have taken livestock rearing as a main income earning source. For example, more
than 68 % household are now rearing livestock to meet their basic needs. Besides,
livestock rearing and sweet water fish cultivation are also found as important sources
of income and improving livelihood. Planned construction of embankment with
appropriate drainage system, height and width considering cyclone water level can
only protect the aquaculture, livestock, agricultural crops and infrastructures as the
effective adaptive measures in the coastal areas. Rearing sheep (bhera) is a very
potential livelihoods adaption option in the coastal areas. Its growth is also very
first. Besides agriculture and fisheries, there are people engaged in wood collecting
(bawalis), honey collecting (mouals) and salt farming. Some of them are part time,
some are seasonal and some are ecosystem specific.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
80
5.5
A.W.R. Hassan and R. Shaw
Conclusion
Climate induced changes both natural and man-made in agricultural productivity
will likely affect the incomes earned by the poor as well as food prices faced by poor
households along with the net effect on food security with a function of each household’s particular set of livelihood strategies. Different agricultural interventions for
a food secure economy are also pointed out as adaptation measures in the face of
climate change. Although food production in Bangladesh is increasing with its high
population demand, the scenario may change with a view to the adverse impact of
climate change collision like flood, sea level rising, drought, saline intrusion,
cyclones etc. Government and different development agencies should concentrate
their focus on the integrated way and to develop innovative location specific adaptation options/variety so that on growing national food demand can meet through
increasing production and adaptability against the adverse impact of climate change.
Development and Incorporation of applying effective livelihood adaptations measures
with a long-term planning can helps livelihoods to build resilience against climate
changes to reduce the vulnerability.
References
Anik S.I, Kabir H, Ray S (2012) Cimate Change and Food Security, 2012. http://www.unnayan.
org/documents/bookschapter/CLIMATE%20CHANGE%20AND%20FOOD%20
SECURITY%20_Livelihood%20&%20Food%20Security_uo.pdf. Accessed 4 Jan 2015
Al-Amin AQ, Alam GM (2011) The impacts of climate change on animal health and economy:
a way forward for policy option. Asian J Anim Vet Adv 6:1061–1068
Al-Amin AQ, Filho WL (2011) An overview of prospects and challenges in the field of climate
change in Malaysia. Int J Glob Warm 3:390–402
Al-Amin AQ, Jaafar AH, Siwar C (2010) Climate change mitigation and policy concern for
prioritization. Int J Clim Change Strategies Manage 2:418–425
Alam MS, Islam MA (2013) Long term assessment of rice production scenario in Bangladesh:
a macro dynamics. Bangladesh J Agric Res 38(2):257–269
Alauddin SM, Rahman KF (2013) Vulnerability to climate change and adaptation practices in
Bangladesh. J SUB 4(2):25–42
Asian Disaster Preparedness Centre, (ADPC) and Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies
(BCAS) (2008) Draft disaster management information link report, Comprehensive Disaster
Management Programme (CDMP), Component 5b, Ministry of Food and Disaster Management
(MoFDM). Government of Peoples Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka
Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies (BCAS) (2008) Community Risk Assessment (CRA)
of disasters and Risk Reduction Action Plan (RRAP) in Madhukhali Upazila, Faridpur,
CDMP/MoFDM. Government of Bangladesh
Bangladesh Ministry of Agriculture (MoA) (2012) Available at http://www.moa.gov.bd/statistics/
bag.htm. Accessed 03 Jan 2015
BARC (2011) Livestock and poultry research and development plan of BLRI-2021. Bangladesh
Agricultural Research Council Newsletter, vol 9, no 1. Jan–Mar, 2011
BBS (2010) Statistical yearbook of Bangladesh 2010. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Dhaka
BBS (2012) Statistical yearbook of Bangladesh 2012. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Dhaka
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
5
Livelihood Security: Implications from Agriculture Sectors
81
Department of Fisheries (DoF) (2010) Jatiyo Matsya Soptaho Sonkolon 2010, Ministry of fisheries
and livestock. The Government of Peoples republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka, 102 pp
DoF, DoL (2011) Department of Fisheries, Department of Livestock yearly report 2011
FAO (2007) Adaptation to climate change in agriculture, forestry and fisheries: perspective,
framework and priorities. Food and Agriculture Organization, Rome
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) (2013) Bangladesh: arable land and land under permanent
crops availability (ratio per person), FAOSTAT. http://faostat.fao.org/site/666/default.aspx.
Accessed Nov 2013
Food Planning and Monitoring Unit (FPMU) (2013) National food policy plan of action and country investment plan: monitoring report 2013. Food Policy Monitoring Unit, Ministry of Food,
Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka
Haque MZ, Rahman MA, Shah MS (1991) Studies on the density of rohu (Labeorohita)
fingerlings in polythene bags for transportation. Bangladesh J Fish 14(1–2):145–148
Hoq ME, Islam MN, Kamal M, Wahab MA (2001) Abundance and seasonal distribution of Penaeus
mono-don postlarvae in the Sundarbans mangrove, Bangladesh. Hydrobiologia 457:97–104
Islam MB, Ali MY, Amin M, Zaman SM (2011) Climate variations: farming systems and livelihoods in the high barind tract and coastal areas of Bangladesh. In: Lal R, Sivakumar MVK,
Rahman AHMM, Islam KR (eds) Climate change and food security in South Asia. Springer
Science+Business Media B.V, New York
Karim Z, Huque KS, Hussain MG, Ali Z, Hossain M (2010) Growth and development potential of
livestock and fisheries in Bangladesh. Bangladesh Food Security Investment Forum, Dhaka,
pp 1–22. http://bids.org.bd/ifpri/growth-dev4.pdf
Khan AM (2009) Water scarcity hampers development, The Daily Star [online] 4 July. Available
at: http://thedailystar.net/newDesign/news-details.php?nid=95284. Accessed 3 Aug 2012
Lobell DB, Schlenker W, Costa-Roberts J (2011) Climate trends and global crop production since
1980. Science 333:616–620
Mace MJ (2006) Adaptation under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change: the
international legal framework. In: Adger WN, Paavola J, Huq S, Mace MJ (eds) Fairness in
adaptation to climate change. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 53–76
MoF (2013) Bangladesh Economic Review, 2013. Ministry of Finance, Government of the
People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Nasreen M (1995) Coping with floods: the experience of rural women in Bangladesh. Unpublished
PhD dissertation, Messey University, New Zealand
Nasreen M (2008) Impact of climate change on food security in Bangladesh: gender and disaster
perspectives. Paper presented at the ‘International Symposium on Climate Change and Food
Security in South Asia’, Dhaka, 25–30 August 2008
Nasreen M (2012) Women and girls vulnerable or resilient. Institute of Disaster Management and
Vulnerability Studies, University of Dhaka, Dhaka
Nasreen M (2012) Women and girls vulnerable or resilient. Institute of disaster management and
vulnerability studies. University of Dhaka, Dhaka
OXFAM (2009) Disaster risk reduction, climate change and livelihood of the poor and marginalized people. A framework for Oxfam GB Bangladesh Society for Environment and Human
Development (SEHD) 2012, Bangladesh: Land, Forest and Forest People [online]. Available at
http://www.sehd.org/publications/adivasis-and-forests/29-bangladesh-land-forest-and-forestpeople. Accessed 3 Aug 2012
World Bank (2009) Implication of climate change risks on food security in Bangladesh. South Asia
Region, 10 June 2009
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 6
Livelihood Security: Implications
from Aquaculture Sectors
Mostafa A.R. Hossain, Humayun Kabir, Ali Muhammad Omar Faruque,
and Monjur Hossain
Abstract Both aquaculture and fisheries have long been an integral part of life of
the people of Bangladesh. The sector, second only to agriculture in the overall
economy of Bangladesh, contribute nearly 4.5 % to the gross domestic product
(GDP), 23 % of gross agriculture products and 2.46 % to the total export earnings.
It accounts for about 60 % of animal protein intake in the diet of the people of
Bangladesh with per capita fish consumption of 18.94 kg per annum. The people of
Bangladesh largely depend on fish to meet their protein needs in both the rural and
urban areas. In Bangladesh, to date about 20 finfish and a several crustacean species
have been domesticated, their breeding and rearing protocols have been developed
and now under nation-wide aquaculture. In addition to 1.32 million full time fishers,
14.7 million people have been involved in aquaculture in Bangladesh including fish
farmers and prawn/shrimp farmers. The value chain from pond/farm to plate/fork
and beyond the chain includes hundreds of stakeholders, whose livelihood fully
depends on aquaculture. The major stakeholders include fish farmer, prawn/shrimp
farmer, hatchery owner, nurserer, farm/hatchery technicians/workers, input (feed
ingredient, fertilizer, hormone, chemical, instrument etc.) importers/suppliers,
feed mill owners, homestead feed producer, fisher, fish processor, fish transporter,
wholesaler, exporter, retailer, consumer, technology provider (government and
non-government) and many more. Aquaculture has increasingly been playing a
major role in total fish production (3.26 million tons) of the country and presently
more than half of the total production (52.92 %) comes from aquaculture (1.73 million
tons). The sector provides living and livelihood for more than 11 % people of the
country. If the available resource are used sustainably with proper technological
M.A.R. Hossain (*)
Department of Fish Biology & Genetics, Bangladesh Agricultural University,
Mymensingh, Bangladesh
e-mail: marhossain@bau.edu.bd
H. Kabir • A.M.O. Faruque
Department of Fisheries, Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock,
Matshya Bhaban, Ramna, Dhaka 1000, Bangladesh
M. Hossain
PMTC (Bangladesh) Ltd., Dhaka, Bangladesh
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_6
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
83
84
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
assistance, fish produced from aquaculture would efficiently meet the protein
demand of growing population of the country, and will ensure, food and nutritional
security, employment generation and foreign exchange earning leading to shaping a
Bangladesh free of hunger, malnutrition and poverty.
Keywords Aquaculture • Bangladesh • Man-made and climate change impacts •
Implications • Livelihood • Adaptation • Mitigation measures
6.1
Introduction
In the globe, fish provides the best protein food rich in essential macro- and
micro-nutrient, vitamins and minerals, Fish farming and fishing create working
opportunity and income to millions of poor, and trade in fishery products play
important role in poverty alleviation and economic growth of nations.
The fisheries sector, in Bangladesh, plays a particularly crucial role among poor
as a main or additional source of employment, livelihood and income. The sector is
the second largest part-time and fulltime employer in rural areas. It provides a
crucial source of income and food to Bangladesh, and is second only to agriculture
in the overall economy of the country. Fish is a natural complement to rice in the
national diet, giving rise to the adage “Machhe-Bhate Bangali”, literally meaning –
‘fish and rice make a Bangladeshi’. Bangladesh produced 3.26 million tons of fish
during 2011–2012 from inland and marine water bodies and aquaculture contributed more than 50 % of the total production (Table 6.1). Fisheries accounts for
4.5 % of Bangladesh GDP, 23 % of agriculture sector and 2.46 % of total export
earnings. It also contributes 60 % of the animal protein intake in Bangladesh, and
even higher in populations living in the coast.
The overseas fish trade is an important source of foreign currency earnings for
the country and provides benefits at both the macro and microeconomic levels. Fish
is the third largest contributor to Bangladesh’s export earnings and is growing
annually by 5–8 %. Revenue from exports of non-fish agricultural goods is gradually
being outpaced by fish products, to the extent that fish has become the most important primary commodity that Bangladesh exports (Dey et al. 2008).
Bangladeshi people largely depend on fish to meet their protein needs. Until
1970s, there was an abundance of fish in the natural waters – the floodplain, rivers,
rivulets, beels, lakes, ditches and canals of the country to well-satisfy the demand of
fish. Presently, however, capture fish production has declined to about 50 %, with a
negative trend of 1.24 % per year. Despite the constant depletion of the natural
water bodies for years, Bangladesh, globally, still holds one of the most diverse
inland fisheries. However, the availability of many fish species has been drastically
declined, and many are either critically endangered or regionally extinct. Both
breeding and feeding migrations of the river and floodplain resident fishes of the
country have been drastically cut off due to flood protection embankment with
serious consequence on recruitment and production tonnage.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
85
Table 6.1 Fish production of Bangladesh from different aquatic resources in 2011–2012
Water resources
Capture – open waters
River and estuarine
Sundarbans
Beel
Kaptai lake
Floodplain
Culture – closed waters
Ponds & ditch
Seasonally cultured waters
Baor (Ox-bow lake)
Shrimp/prawn farm
Marine fisheries
Trawler
Aritasanal fisheries
Country total
Source: DoF (2013)
6.1.1
Water area (ha)
3,925,290
853,863
177,700
114,161
68,800
2,710,766
774,055
371,309
122,026
5,488
275,232
–
–
–
Production (MT)
957,095
145,613
21,610
85,208
8,537
696,127
1,726,067
1,342,282
1,822,930
5,186
196,306
578,620
73,386
5,052,343
3,261,782
Production (kg/ha) % Total
–
29.34
171
122
746
131
257
–
52.92
3,615
1,494
945
713
–
17.74
–
–
100
Background of Aquaculture in Bangladesh
Aquaculture, in simple sense, is the farming of fish and other aquatic organisms,
with ‘farming’ implying – some form of intervention to increase productions, and
some form of private rights of the stock under intervention (Beveridge and Little
2002). Although livelihood opportunities associated with aquaculture contribute to
the food security of large numbers of poor women and men, the direct effects of
consuming fisheries products are of even greater significance.
Aquaculture or fish farming has been the most rapidly growing agro-food sector
in the globe over the last four decades 1970 and 2010. Production of farmed finfish
and shellfish has been growing at a rate of 8.1 % per annum over this period.
The aquaculture industry employs 23.4 million full-time workers globally, with
Asia accounting for 92 % of jobs. Aquaculture now provides around half the fish for
direct human consumption and is set to grow further.
The origin and developmental background of aquaculture practices in Bangladesh
are not well documented. Historically, country’s natural water bodies were stocked
during the monsoon season through recruitment from natural spawning. Fish farming had been an age-old practice dating back a few centuries to when the country
was ruled by Hindu kings. Many of the kings used to construct ponds and tanks for
drinking, bathing and sometimes for small-scale irrigation, these ponds and tanks
were also used for rearing fish although more from a recreation point of view than
for commercial or nutritional purpose. Dr. Nazir Ahmed (1947–1960), the then
Director of East Pakistan Department of Fisheries laid the formal foundation for fish
culture in ponds and lakes in Bangladesh. He devotedly worked on the development
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
86
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
of carp farming in ponds and beels and during the time between late sixties and
early seventies considerable advancement were made in this area, eg., success in
induced breeding of indigenous carp with pituitary gland extracts. Over the last few
decades, however, fish habitats in Bangladesh have been degraded drastically by the
development of flood control measures which resulted in a decline in natural fish
production. As a result GOs, NGOs and private entrepreneurs have come forward
to develop improved fish farming techniques especially in ponds and floodplains
(FAO 2005).
There are two types of aquaculture practices are going on in Bangladesh –
freshwater and coastal aquaculture. There is no marine aquaculture currently
practiced in the country and no marine/coastal fin finfishes are farmed. Freshwater
aquaculture comprises mainly pond farming of carps – (indigenous and exotic),
Mekong pangasid catfish, tilapia, Mekong climbing perch and a number of other
domesticated fish though in lesser scale. Coastal aquaculture is comprised mainly of
shrimp and prawn farming in ghers (coastal pond or enclosures).
In Bangladesh, aquaculture production systems are mainly extensive and
improved extensive, with some semi-intensive and in very few cases intensive
systems. The present unit area aquaculture productions (MT/ha) are 3.6, 1.5, 0.95
and 0.71 for pond, seasonal waterbody, baor (oxbow lake) and shrimp gher, respectively. Inland pond culture represents the mainstay of aquaculture in Bangladesh,
accounting more than 80 % total recorded aquaculture production and presently
dominated by carps (indigenous and exotic), Mekong pangas and tilapia.
6.1.2
Domestication of Fish for Aquaculture
Domestication of wild fishes in most cases benefits both the fish farmer and
the environment (Hossain 2010). Investments in domestication have to pay off;
therefore, researches should take into account the biodiversity and production
scenario and overall socioeconomic and environmental outcome at a broader scale.
In Bangladesh, to date about 20 fish species have been domesticated and their breeding
and rearing protocols have been developed. Around 50 % of the domesticated fishes
are cypriniforms and now under nation-wide aquaculture (Table 6.2). Though there
is high possibility of working with reduced gene pool, it is optimistically believed
that the biodiversity of the domesticated fish are well-preserved.
6.1.3
Introduction of Exotic Fish in the Name of Aquaculture
All over the world the exotic species have been recognized as an agent of the loss of
indigenous biodiversity. Alteration of species and ecosystem caused by exotic invasive animals and plants influence the functioning and overall health of the affected
ecosystems (Ameen 1999).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
87
Table 6.2 The domesticated indigenous fishes of Bangladesh
Order
Cypriniformes
Fish
Catla catla
Labeo rohita
Labeo gonius
Labeo bata
Labeo calbasu
Cirrhinus mrigala
Cirrhinus reba
Tor putitora
Puntius sarana
Lepidocephalichthys guntea
Botia dario
Osteoglossiformes
Chitala chitala
Siluriformes
Ompok bimaculatus
Ompok pabda
Mystus vittatus
Mystus gulio
Clarias batrachus
Heteropneustes fossilis
Synbranchiformes
Mastacembelus armatus
Macrognathus aculeatus
Perciformes
Anabas testudineus
Colisa fasciata
Source: Hossain and Wahab (2009)
Culture status
Country-wide commercial
Country-wide commercial
Country-wide commercial
Country-wide commercial
Small scale, sporadic
Country-wide commercial
Small scale, sporadic
Breeding protocol developed
Small scale, sporadic
Breeding protocol developed
Breeding protocol developed
Small scale, sporadic
Small scale, sporadic
Small scale, sporadic
Small scale, sporadic
Breeding protocol developed
Small scale, sporadic
Small scale, sporadic
Breeding protocol developed
Breeding protocol developed
Breeding protocol developed
Breeding protocol developed
As a country of rivers and wetlands, Bangladesh is very rich in fish diversity.
Even then, over the last six decades a total of 24 fishes have been introduced
(Table 6.3). The invasive species rapidly spread over the wetlands as biological
explosives during the rainy seasons. Most of the introduced species were meant
only for captive cultivation in closed pond systems but nobody succeeded to maintain
the fish in captivity. During monsoon and/or flood the escapees easily found their
ways to the rivers and floodplains throughout the country. This posed one of the
major threats to the biodiversity of many indigenous fishes in this country.
Several introduced species are highly carnivorous and predatory and eat almost
everything including the small indigenous species of fish (SIS – which grow to a
maximum length of 5–25 cm) (Felts et al. 1996). Several exotic species also compete with the SIS and gradually occupy their niches. The ecological, economic and
biodiversity consequences of the introductions of exotic fish species have never
been taken into consideration. It is very unfortunate that the long-term, and even
short-term adverse effects were not considered while introducing the invasive species
in Bangladesh. The excessive fecundity and growth rate of these species created
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
88
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
Table 6.3 Exotic fishes introduced into the freshwaters of Bangladesh
Common name
Siamese gourami
Goldfish
Tilapia
Guppy
Common carp
Mirror carp
Scale carp
Leather carp
Grass carp
Silver carp
Nilotica
Thai sarpunti
Bighead carp
Black carp
African magur
GIFT (genetically
improved farmed tilapia)
Genetically improved
scale carp
Thai pangas
Giant pangas
Mosquito fish
Sucker mouth catfish
Scientific name
Trichogaster pectoralis
Carassius auratus
Oreochromis mossambicus
Poecilia reticulata
Cyprinus carpio
Cyprinus carpio var specularis
Cyprinus carpio var communis
Cyprinus carpio var nudus
Ctenopharyngodon idella
Hypophthalmichthys molitrix
Oreochromis niloticus
Barbonymus gonionotus
Hypophthalmichthys nobilis
Mylopharyngodon piceus
Clarias gariepinus
Oreochromis niloticus
Source
Singapore
Pakistan
Thailand
Thailand
India, Nepal
India, Nepal
India, Nepal
India, Nepal
Hong Kong
Hong Kong
Thailand
Thailand
Nepal
China
Thailand
Philippines
Year of
introduction
1952
1953
1954
1957
1960
1979
1965
–
1966
1969
1974
1977
1981
1983
1990
1994
Cyprinus carpio var communis
Vietnam
1995
Pangasius hypophthalmus
Pangasius gigus
Gambusia affinis
Hypostomus plecostomus
Thailand
Thailand
India
Hong Kong,
Singapore
Singapore
Singapore
1990
–
–
–
Red piranha
Pygocentrus nattereri
Pirapatinga
Piaractus brachypomus
Source: Modified from Rahman (2005)
2003
2003
pressure on the carrying capacity of the habitat, and the ecosystem balance itself by
reducing the indigenous species diversity and population. Some of the negative
impacts of exotic species on indigenous fishes are given in Table 6.4.
6.2
Present Status of Aquaculture in Bangladesh
An estimated 1.32 million people of Bangladesh are fishers and earn their livelihood
from fishing. A further 14.7 million people indirectly earn their livelihood from
fisheries and aquaculture and related activities, and employed in the backward and
forward linkages of the value chain such as the downstream activities of fish trading,
fish seed production, collection of shrimp and prawn seed, fish handling, processing
and marketing, net making, input supply and processing. The number of fish
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
89
Table 6.4 The negative impacts of exotic fishes on the indigenous fishes
Exotic fish
Tilapia
Impact
Their prolific breeding surpasses the carrying capacity of the waterbody
leading to stunting of tilapia and a number of SIS – mola (Amblypharyngodon
mola), dhela (Osteobrama cotio), anju (Danio rerio), darkina (Esomus
danricus), chela (Salmostoma spp.), punti (Puntius spp.), chapila (Gudusia
chapra), tengra (Mystus vittatus), bujuri (Mystus tengara), chanda (Ambassis
spp.), guchi (Macrognathus pancalus) etc.
Common carp
Destroy pond embankments, make water turbid by stirring up mud. Reduce
the water transparency and dissolved O2 in water. Destroy habitat of SIS
living closed to the pond dyke and loaches in the bottom
Grass carp
High feeding competition with many herbivorous small and large indigenous
fishes
Silver carp
Strong feeding and habitat competition with– catla in both captive condition
and in the wild
Thai sarpunti
Compete with local sarpunti for foods and space
African magur
Predation and voracity of this catfish is legendary, predate on almost all small
and medium fishes
Thai pangas
Natural diet is finfish, crustacean and insects, periphyton and benthos.
This predatory fish is the major cause of disappearance of SIS
from the pond system
Mosquito fish
They live in the littoral zone of the waterbody and compete with small fishes
for food and habitat
Suckermouth
One of the dangerous catfish, now found in floodplain allover country,
catfish
feeds on small crustaceans and fishes like loaches and freshwater eel
Red piranha
One of the most dangerous and aggressive species of piranha,
feeds on insects, worms and small and large fish. The cultured fish in the pond
system and escapees in the wild actively predate on the indigenous fishes
particularly SIS
Pirapatinga
Natural diet is terrestrial plants, fruits, insects and crustaceans,
however, in captivity where natural food is scarce pirapatinga compete
with SIS. The fish has strong, human like teeth to crush food items
Source: Hossain (2014)
farmers and shrimp/prawn farmers presently are 13.86 millions and 0.83 millions,
respectively. Among the people involved in the sector 10 % are women.
During 1960s, the inland capture fisheries contributed about 90 % of the country’s total fish production. Production from inland capture fisheries has declined
significantly over the years and in 2010–2011 it accounted only about 42 % (Fig. 6.1a).
During 1960s, production from inland capture fisheries was almost 20 times higher
compared to the then aquaculture production of the country (Fig. 6.1b). However,
aquaculture production both in fresh water and brackish water has significantly
increased during the last two and a half decades with development of technology.
Due to the rapid increase of aquaculture production and sharp decrease of capture
fishery production, in 2010–2011, the aquaculture contributed (about 53 %) more
than inland capture fisheries in total fish production of the country (DoF 2013).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
90
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
% contribution of inland capture in total
production
a
100
80
60
40
20
0
60-61 65-66 70-71 75-76 80-81 85-86 90-91 95-96 00-01 05-06 10-11
b
inland capture : Aquaculture ratio
20
16
12
8
4
0
60-61 65-66 70-71 75-76 80-81 85-86 90-91 95-96 00-01 05-06 10-11
Fig. 6.1 Trend of fish production in Bangladesh 1960–2011. (a) Contribution of inland capture
(%) in total fish production, and (b) Inland capture to aquaculture ratios (Source: Ali et al. 2009;
DoF 2013)
6.2.1
Aquaculture Growth
Over the last three decades aquaculture in Bangladesh has expanded rapidly.
Aquaculture has increasingly been playing a major role in total fish production
(3.26 million tons) of the country and presently more than half of the total fish
production (52.92 %) comes from aquaculture (1.73 million tons). Although farming of fish in this country, yet a low intensity semi-subsistence activity, rapid
commercialization, gradual intensification and specialization have taken place over
the last decade, leading to unprecedented expansion in production of farmed fish
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
91
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
(Belton and Azad 2012). Horizontal expansion of aquaculture has been taking place
on riverine floodplains which have been enclosed to facilitate the intensification of
production (Sultana 2012). Over the last couple of years, significant numbers of
crop farmers have been converting their land to fish ponds, mainly in Mymensingh
and Rajshahi, what many think a natural phenomenon related to ever decreasing
benefit-cost ratio farmers are receiving from paddy farming. Aquaculture production of 33,000 MT in 1960, increased to massive 1.73 million MT in 2012. Average
annual growth (%) of aquaculture is 10.81 ± 1.79 since 1990 to date. The annual
growth rate was only negative during 2003–2004 and so far highest in 1995–1996
and 2008–2009 (Fig. 6.2).
Production of aquacultured shrimp (Bagda, Penaeus monodon) and prawn
(Galda, Macrobrachium rosenbergii) also increased significantly from a mere
14,773 MT to 137,175 MT in 2011 (Fig. 6.3). The % contribution of farmed shrimp
a
Aquaculture production ('000 MT)
1600
1200
800
400
0
60-61 65-66 70-71 75-76 80-81 85-86 90-91 95-96 00-01 05-06 10-11
b
Annual growtrh rate (%)
30
28.17
27.21
20.02
18.16
20
19.56
18.31
10.78
10 7.52
10.38
6.32
11.12
8.45
0
4.80
8.94
6.74
6.03
3.20
8.05
5.69
1.13
-3.57
-10
91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11
Fig. 6.2 Aquaculture growth in Bangladesh. (a) The real value of aquaculture production
(‘000 MT) during 1960–2011. (b) Annual growth rate (%) of aquaculture during 1991–2011
(Source: DoF 2013)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Culture shrimp-prawn production (MT)
92
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
160000
120000
80000
40000
0
86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11
Fig. 6.3 Production of farmed shrimp and prawn in Bangladesh during 1986–2011
Table 6.5 Mode of shrimp culture in Bangladesh with production per unit area
Area under
culture (ha)
190,080
Species
Bagda
Mode of culture
Traditional
(extensive)
Bagda
Improved
extensive
25,380
Galda
Integrated
With rice, fish,
vegetables
Nearly 60,000
Management
PL stocking and water exchange
(A number of marine fish
in the gher)
Dyke elevation; healthy & virus
free PL stocking;
Supplemental feeding
Little or no management except
PL stocking, occasional feeding
Production
kg/ha
300
600–700
450–550
and prawn in total production is more than 60 % and in recent years the wild catch
has been gradually decreasing.
The unit area production of farmed shrimp (300–700 kg/ha), however, is very
low compared to fish produced in culture ponds. Mostly extensive form of culture is
practiced to produce shrimp in gher and very few farmers practice even improved
extensive method (Table 6.5).
6.3
Aquaculture Livelihood
As the fish production from aquaculture has increased remarkably over the last few
years, many poor and ultra poor of rural areas of Bangladesh received the opportunity of fulltime and parttime employment to earn extra income. About 11 % of the
people of the country now directly or indirectly depend on the fish sector for their
livelihood. Among the manpower associated with the fish sector, 10 % are women
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
93
(1 % of total population). Moreover, 80 % workers working for fish processing
plants and fish drying centers are women (DoF 2013; Hossain et al. 2013). Only
during last 4 years, about 0.6 millions poor people found the work opportunity in
the fish sector (DoF 2013). In Bangladesh, presently a total 14.7 million people have
been involved in aquaculture in Bangladesh including fish farmers and prawn/
shrimp farmers. The value chain from pond/farm to plate/fork and beyond the chain
includes hundreds of stakeholders, whose livelihood fully depends on aquaculture.
The major stakeholders include fish farmer, prawn/shrimp farmer, hatchery owner,
nurserer, farm/hatchery technicians/workers, input (feed ingredient, fertilizer, hormone, chemical, instrument etc.) importers/suppliers, feed mill owners, homestead
feed producer, fisher, fish processor, fish transporter, wholesaler, exporter, retailer,
consumer, technology provider (government and non-government) and many more.
6.4
Climate Change Impacts on Overall Setting
Bangladesh has been experiencing serious environmental degradation in recent
years. In many respects, the situation has reached crisis proportions. Several factors
make Bangladesh particularly vulnerable to environmental damage. There are many
dimensions of this environmental degradation. Ground water contamination,
surface water pollution, encroachment of rivers and water bodies, improper disposal
of industrial, medical and household waste, deforestation and loss of aquatic habitat
and bio-diversity are just a few examples. The fragile ecology, delicate flora
and fauna, alarming density of increasing population, reliance on foreign aid and
poverty of the masses are few such factors. Considerable damage has already been
done. With loss of wetlands and forests, Bangladesh is gradually losing its flora and
fauna. Many aquatic and terrestrial species are becoming rare; some have already
become extinct.
Bangladesh is most at risk from climate change. The country will face the
greatest danger from global warming in the next three decades. Poverty and large
low-lying coastal regions prone to annual floods and cyclones were among factors
making Bangladesh the number 1 exposed country to climate change. Other most
exposed countries in the continent are India, Nepal, Philippines, Afghanistan and
Myanmar.
6.4.1
Climate Change and Fish Sector
Climate change impacts gradually cover a wide range of livelihoods in a number of
aquatic settings (Fig. 6.4). Drought coupled with siltation and lowering water level
are reducing over wintering habitat for indigenous fish species resulting into less
recruitment into grazing field to grow inland fisheries. Reduced water flow in major
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
94
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
Physical
Temperature
Ecological
Species distributions
Fisheries
Productivity
pH
Timing of reproduction,
Distribution
Salinity
migration, abundance
Species availability
Dissolved Oxygen
Physiology - growth
Timing
Nutrients
Recruitment
Days at sea
Currents
Behaviour
Accidents, death
Sea level
Food chain
Loss of homes, common
Turbulence & mixing
Food and feeding habit
properties - infrastructure
Wind speed & direction
Sex ratios
Damage to productive
Cyclone - frequency &
Upwelling timing & latitude
assets – stock, boat, nets
intensity
Habitat loss
Livelihood diversification
Evaporation
Disease
Ability to plan seasonal /
Precipitation
alternative livelihood
Runoff
activities
Food and Nutritional
security
Fig. 6.4 Climate-induced changes in aquaculture and fisheries systems
rivers has resulted in a severe depletion of riverine fisheries. Due to decrease in
groundwater and surface water, extreme pressure has been exerted on floodplains to
convert them to crop filed, brick klin and other infrastructures, resulting in an alarming decline in fish diversity and production. Indeed, there may be nowhere in world
where effects of climate change and other activities on fish sector are more apparent
than in Bangladesh.
Bangladesh in 2009 witnessed the least rainfall in past one and half decade
(since 1994) with scientists attributing the unpredictable pattern to global climatic
change. During June–September, 2009, 47,447 mm rainfall was recorded compared
to 56,163 mm in the same period of 2008, 66,520 mm in 2007 and 60,551 mm in
2008. On the other hand, excessive rainfall in several parts of country affected
standing aman rice crops while less rainfall affected the major crop in some other
areas. Average temperature of the country has been increasing slowly (Fig. 6.5).
More and more intense and long droughts have been observed since 1970s in
almost all areas especially in northern Bangladesh. Water with poor quality and
less availability for aquaculture and reduced production of fish are very common.
Loss of both wild and farmed fish stocks has long been going on. There are
conflicts among different water users and irrigation to crop fields always gets
the priority.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
95
Fig. 6.5 Time series of all-Bangladesh annual mean temperatures during 1948–2007 (CCC 2009)
6.5
Direct and Indirect Impacts on Aquaculture
Impacts of climate change on aquaculture could occur directly and/or indirectly and
almost all components of climate change impact on aquaculture. Aquaculture practice,
like other farming practices, are defined spatially, temporally and based on size and
have a fair degree of maneuverability. Furthermore, fish farming concentrates in
certain climatic regions of the world and continents with a well defined concentration of the sectoral practices.
The major elements of climate change that have potential impact on aquaculture
production are regular events like temperature and sea level rise, change in monsoonal
rain patterns and water scarcity and extreme events like, tornados. Different elements
of climate change are likely to be manifested to varying degrees in different climatic
zones. Global warming and resulting increase in water temperature could impact
very negatively on aquaculture in temperate zones because such increases could
exceed the optimal temperature range of organisms currently under farming.
Diseases affecting aquaculture both in incidence and impact might increase in
freshwater and coastal farming systems.
In Bangladesh, more intense and longer droughts have been observed since
1970s in almost all areas particularly northwest region of the country – resulting
gradually poorer water quality and lower availability for aquaculture and reduced
production of freshwater fish. Loss of cultured stocks and conflicts among different
water users are increasing. Damage in aquaculture production and increased cost of
production are direct result of water shortage. Major impacts of cyclones and tornados are loss of human – fish farmers and others, severe loss of aquaculture stocks,
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
96
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
livelihood assets and biodiversity, communication disruption affect fish/input trade
used in aquaculture, damage and destruction of infrastructure, aquaculture facilities,
crafts and gears, and impacts on wild fish recruitment and environmental degradation results narrower gene pool used by for fish hatcheries. Salinity intrusion reduces
growth of farmed freshwater and coastal water fish and shellfishes, deteriorates
water quality and causes considerable loss of plants and vegetables on farm site.
Impacts of climate change on different aspects of aquaculture in Bangladesh are
summarized below.
6.5.1
Effect on Reproduction and Growth
The erratic rain, irregular rainfall as well as temperature change are affecting the
readiness of fishes for breeding. The abrupt changes in temperature and irregular
rainfall are making change in the physiology of maturation and sex ratios of fish
species, altered timing of spawning, migration and spawning seasons of farmed
indigenous and exotic carps, tilapia and other aquacultured species.
6.5.2
Effects on Species Composition,
Abundance and Distribution
Increased salinity and change in water quality instigates in change in species
composition, abundance and distribution the affected areas, particularly in coastal
areas. The change in fish composition in turn affects the fisheries in many coastal
areas. Due to prolonged drought, fish movement and migratory route within river,
from river to beel and floodplain and within floodplain have been blocked which
caused reduction of fish production in open water. Recruitment of new fishes is
going down every year. Some of the most impacted/damaged fish population are
mola (Amblypharyngodon mola), tengra (Mystus vittatus), bujuri (Mystus tengara),
batashi (Pseudeutropius atherinoides), shing (Heteropneustes fossilis), pabda
(Ompok spp.), gulsha (Mystus cavasius), air (Sperata aor), bheda (Nandus nandus),
rita (Rita rita), banshpata (Ailia spp.), ghagla (Hemibagrus menoda), kawajangi
(Gagata spp.), raek (Cirrhinus reba), sarpunti (Puntius sarana), jat punti (Puntius
sophore), bou (Botia spp.), magur (Clarias batrachus), chang (Channa gachua),
taki (Channa punctatus), shol (Channa striatus), gozar (Channa marulius),
baim (Mastacembelus armatus), guchi (Macrognathus pancalus), tara baim
(Macrognathus aculeatus) etc. Extinct or near extinct are kawajangi (Gagata spp.),
elong (Megarasbora elonga), rita (Rita rita), pabda (Ompok spp.), phasa (Setipinna
spp.), shilong (Silonia silondia), bacha (Eutropiichthys vacha) and gaura
(Clupisoma garua).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
6.5.3
97
Effects on Fish Propagation and Production
Areas for fish breeding, nursery and grazing are reducing at an alarming rate in
rivers and floodplains. Reduced number of naturally available broodfish has long
been observed due to reduced habitat. Gradual changing of fish breeding period,
reduction in breeding ground and declining spawning rate (lack of natural stimulation) is now well-evident. High mortality of spawn in openwaters and in captivity
has been reported from most parts of the country due to high fluctuation of daynight temperature. Low and delayed rainfall is causing decline in water flow and
change or disappearance of fish migratory route and shortening of fish growing
period both in aquaculture and in the wild. Brood quality is under risks in hatcheries
and open waters. Due to lack of water, hatchery owners are rearing brood stock in a
single or in a couple of ponds and risking the brood quality. Fish seed production
cost is getting higher due to water scarcity, temperature fluctuation and insufficient
supply of electricity in hatcheries. Aquacultured fishes breed late in the hatcheries
due to water scarcity and higher and lower temperature.
6.5.4
Effects on Fish Biology in the Hatchery
and Growout Level
Due to late monsoon and prolonged drought phases during breeding season, the fish
hatcheries are struggling. The eggs and spawn of bighead and silver carp and bata
start to die at high temperature. Tilapia stop spawning at lower temperate than 24 °C
and at higher temperature than 34 °C. Most of the time all the eggs/spawns in the
bottle jars die rapidly due to higher and lower temperature and rapid fluctuation of
temperature. As the rain water is not enough in many parts of the country and very
uncertain, and mostly absent in the time of need, huge quantity of water is needed
in the fish hatcheries are lifted by deep tube well. That increase the production cost
of fish seed significantly. In a normal condition with sufficient rain water from the
early monsoon, it is possible to produce 1 kg spawn from 2 to 3 fish, but now-a-days,
about 10 broodfish are needed to produce 1 kg spawn. Fish seed produced in govt.
hatcheries have high demand, but over the last few years, it has been becoming
increasingly impossible to fulfill the demand due to water scarcity and temperature
fluctuation. Management cost has increased more or less 20 % due to climate
change, followed by water and feeding cost (30 and 50 %). On the other hand,
spawn mortality has increased to 20 %.
Sometimes fish farmer collect expensive and good quality natural eggs and
spawns of carps at the early season. As there is very little and sporadic rain at
April-May, very few eggs and spawns can be collected from natural waterbodies,
accordingly these are very expensive and precious. However, due to hot temperature
and lack of water, nursing of these valuable spawns is very difficult. Even some of
the farmers/hatchery owners are able to nurse them, selling the fry is difficult as the
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
98
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
fish farmers cannot stock them because there is no water in their ponds. Therefore,
even after collecting and nursing the expensive and good quality spawns, due to lack
of customers, the hatchery owners/fish farmers can not make any profit rather
encounter huge loses.
Presently in the fish hatcheries, the following impacts are noticeable and of great
concern for the owners:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Fish do not ovulate in time or at all
Lower growth rate of brood
Fewer eggs
Eggs not fertilized
Deformity of fry
Lower survival rate
Lower hatching rate
Loss of yield
Lower survival rate
Less water availability
Mass mortality
Increased production cost
6.5.5
Effects on Overall Fish Growth and Fish Health
It is generally accepted that decreased body size of fish is a universal response to
increasing temperatures. Climate change might be responsible for stunting fish
growth in the ocean. Warmer ocean temperatures and less oxygenated water could
significantly reduce fish growth and make the fish undersized. The body sizes of
several marine species have decreased up to 29 % over a period of four decades
(Baudron et al. 2014). Climate change also impacts fish growth in culture ponds.
Extreme high temperature in summer and long duration cold wave in winter are
affecting fish growth in Barind tract and north-eastern haor basin of Bangladesh.
As most of the aquatic animals including fish are poikliothermic, their physiology
is directly affected by the ambient temperature. In general, the fish immune response
is in the perfect condition in species’ optimum temperature. The replication rate of
parasites and pathogens is also affected by temperature. At higher temperatures, the
generation time of most of the bacterial and fungal pathogen and other macro and
micro-parasites with direct lifecycles is shorter, whilst each virus has its own
optimal temperature range for replication. As a result there are optimal temperature
ranges for infection and disease; increasing or decreasing water temperatures may
shift the balance in favour of either the host or pathogen, changing the frequency
and distribution of disease. A clear conclusion is that increases in water temperature
and other changes in environmental water quality parameters, caused by climate
change, are likely to adversely affect the fish health. Change in temperature has long
been affecting farmed fish in Bangladesh by increasing risk of disease outbreak.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
99
In dry lands like Barind tracts, many fish farmers are loosing revenue because of
production loss due to fish disease. Fish farmer are struggling with higher production cost due to water scarcity, higher and lower temperature, day-night temperature
fluctuation and less productivity of ponds. Hatcheries production has also declined
due to water scarcity, abrupt temperature change and day-night temperature
fluctuation.
6.5.6
Effects on the Coastal Aquaculture
Due to climate change, several natural and manmade causes (normal events),
Sidr-2007 and Aila-2009 (extreme events), and resulting salinity intrusion, impacted
almost every stakeholder including shrimp and prawn farmers and thousands of
farm workers living in the coastal Bangladesh. Their effects are still being felt.
Aila destroyed freshwater wild and cultured fish stocks.
River and shrimp culture pond (gher) became heavily silted and water depth
decreased substantially. Salinity intrusion, siltation, ovefishing, decreased productivity and pollution were identified as key reasons for diminishing trends. Stocked
fish in ponds are not growing well. Farmers suffer from increasing input cost and
decreasing productivity/profitability from ghers/ponds. Frequency of shrimp viral
disease increased many folds.
6.5.7
Effects on Livelihood of the Root Level Stakeholders
Many fish farmers used to farm fish in leased jolmohals and privately owned ponds
now stopped farming because of ever increasing price of fish seed and other inputs,
mounting value of lease, and user conflict with rice farmers. About 15 % fishers
already left fishing and started other jobs like barber shop, furniture making, or
jewellery business. A few went to work for the garments factories in Dhaka. Kartik
to Falgun (October – February) is the most critical time for the fishers and poor fish
farmers and people who work as day laboures in the large fish farms. There is no
fish in the rivers, beels and floodplains and activities in the fish farms this time and
hardship begins. Almost all the fisher families including poor fish farmers and fish
farm labours reduce number and size of meal and go for cheaper foods as possible,
borrow money from local moneylenders, NGOs and wholesalers with high interest.
For example, when someone borrows 20,000 taka from an NGO, he/she starts paying
back the loan almost instantly from the first week of the loan, 500 taka/week for
11 months. Although he/she pays back 22,000 taka and interest seems only 10 % but
as the payment starts from the beginning the cumulative interest stands much higher.
In the coast, decreased access to drinking water and cooking fuels and salinization
of cropland are the major non-fish livelihood issues. Increasingly more selling and
less fish for family consumption due to less fish in the farming system and in the
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
100
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
open waterbodies and high price in the market – a troubling matter for nutritional
security in fisher households. Women and children in this area are forced to do hard
job like earth cutting and shrimp PL collection for long hour – day and night, for
very low wage. WorldFish (2007) summarized direct impacts of climate change on
aquaculture (Table 6.6).
Table 6.6 Ways in which climate change directly affect aquaculture production
Drivers
Higher water
temperatures
Changes in sea
surface temperature
Changes in
precipitation
quantity
Effects
Raised metabolic rates increase
feeding and growth if water
quality, DO and food supply are
optimum, otherwise reducing
feeding and growth. Potential for
enhanced primary productivity
Shift in location and size of range
for a given species
Reduced water quality, especially
DO. Changes in range/abundance
of pathogens, predators and
competitors. Invasive species
introduced
Changes in timing and success
of migrations and spawning
More frequent harmful algal
blooms. Less DO. Increased
incidence of disease and parasites
Longer growing seasons. Lower
natural mortality in winter.
Enhanced metabolic/growth rates
Enhanced primary productivity
Changes in timing and success
of migrations, spawning and peak
abundance, and sex ratios
Change in location and size
of range for particular species
Changes in fish migration and
recruitment patterns and in
recruitment success
Lower water availability for
aquaculture. Poor water quality
causing more disease. Increased
competition with other water users
Altered and reduced water supplies
with greater risk of drought
Implications for aquaculture
Possible benefits for aquaculture,
especially intensive and
semi-intensive pond systems
Aquaculture opportunities
both lost and gained
Altered culture species and
possibly worsened, losses to
disease (and so higher operating
costs) and possibly higher capital
costs for aeration
Impacts on seed availability
for aquaculture
Changes in infrastructure and
operating costs from infestations
of fouling organisms, pests,
and/or predators
Potential for increased production
and profit, especially for
aquaculture
Potential benefits for aquaculture
Impacts on seed availability for
aquaculture
Aquaculture opportunities both
lost and gained
Impacts on seed availability for
aquaculture
Higher costs of maintaining pond
water levels and from stock loss.
Reduced production capacity
Conflict with other water users.
Change of culture species
(continued)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
101
Table 6.6 (continued)
Drivers
Sea level rise
Effects
Loss of land
Changes to estuary systems
Salt water infusion into
groundwater
Loss of coastal ecosystems
such as mangrove forests
Increase in
frequency and/or
intensity of storms
Large waves and storm surges.
Inland flooding from intense
precipitation. Salinity changes.
Introduction of disease or predators
into aquaculture facilities during
flooding episodes
Drought
Poor water quality and low
availability for aquaculture.
Salinity changes
Implications for aquaculture
Reduced area available for
aquaculture
Shifts in aquaculture seed
Reduced freshwater availability
for aquaculture
Worsened exposure to waves and
storm surges and risk that inland
aquaculture become inundated
Loss of aquaculture stock and
damage to or loss of aquaculture
facilities and fishing gear. Higher
direct risk to fish farmers; capital
costs needed to design cage
moorings, pond walls, jetties, etc.
that can withstand storms;
and insurance costs
Loss of cultured stock.
Increased production costs.
Loss of opportunity
as production is limited
Source: Modified from WorldFish (2007)
6.6
Suggested Adaptive Measure
Catching of broodfish, eggs and spawns particularly shrimp/prawn post larvae from
open water needs to be fully stopped without any delay. Fish culture system with
irrigated water wherever possible should be established. Mono-culturing monosex
tilapia should be extended and promoted instead of mixed carp culture, because
tilapia can stand low water depth, adverse physico-chemical parameters and are
short-cycled compared to carps. Entrance of spawn-rich water or newly recruited
larva/fry should be allowed to beel through FFS like fish pass or fish ladder (Hossain
2010). Hatchery and nursery owners should be encouraged to recycle water in their
systems. As it suits better in the drought prone areas, hatchery and nursery owners
should be trained properly to rear over-wintered larger-sized fingerlings of carps to
reduce the production period and avoid the hazardous period of aquaculture. Shortcycled and tolerant species like sarpunti, tilapia, koi, magur and shing culture in the
draught areas should be extended through training and motivation by DoF and
NGOs. Like vegetables farming in green house, farmers whoever can afford, should
culture fish in more controlled condition during hottest and coolest month mainly
through controlling the water temperature and O2 supply. Cage and pen culture
should be introduced in the appropriate beels and floodplains. The approaches/
initiatives should be coordinated with all the departments concerned.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
102
6.6.1
Special Measures to Cope with Climate Change
in Haor and Floodplain Areas
Fish Culture/Stocking in Pens During monsoon, flood water enters in the different
parts of Haor areas. In many places, a small to large area goes under water such
a way that if 1–2 corners (5–10 m) are fenced with net or bamboo fence (bana),
a relatively large waterbody (10–100 dec or even larger) is created. Natural fish can
easily be preserved in this type of waterbodies. Fry of small fish caught at the onset
of the monsoon like koi (Anabas testudineus), shing (Heteropneustes fossilis),
magur (Clarias batrachus), tengra (Mystus vittatus), shol (Channa striatus), gozar
(Channa marulius), chitol (Chitala chitala), mola (Amblypharyngodon mola), dhela
(Osteobrama cotio) etc. can be reared in the pens for 4–5 months.
Stocking of Small Fish in Kua There are some small but deeper parts in the Haor
areas. These are known as Kua. The people living around the Kua can stock different
small fish and prawns for 6–8 months in the Kuas forming a group (community
based approach). During dry seasons, at least 1 m water should be maintained in the
Kuas instead of complete drying out. Using selective gear, all fish can be harvested
from Kuas leaving the brood and mature fish, so these fish breed in the following
years and provide sustainable recruitment.
Culture and Conservation of Small Fish in Backyard Small Ponds and Roadside
Ditches The backyard ponds and roadside ditches in the Haor areas can be used for
both natural fish conservation and stocking of fish fry brought/purchased from
outside. The fry that will be reared in the cages/Hapas will turn to fingerling within
1–2 months and those fingerlings can be stocked and reared in the waterbodies for
further 4–6 months.
6.6.2
Responsibilities Fish Farmers to Reduce
Climate Change Risks
All fish farmers should be aware about climate change and its impacts and share
with family and friends. All concerned should comply totally with fish act at all
level and all around the year. A complete and comprehensive cease of catching
brood fish, eggs and spawns should be ensured. Instead of putting excessive pressure
on the aquatic resources, fish farmers and farm labours should look for alternate
IGAs. Farmers should know the climate adaptive fishes and receive proper training
to culture short-cycled fish to ensure marketing within a short time. Salt and
temperature tolerant fish should get priority in faming system.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
103
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
6.6.3
General Features of Climate Change Adaptive Fishes
There are a number of fishes (Tables 6.7 and 6.8) that can be adaptive in climate change,
like tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus), koi (Anabas testudineus), shing (Heteropneustes
fossilis), magur (Clarias batrachus), Thai sarpunti (Barbonymus gonionotus),
Thai pangas (Pangasius hypophthalmus), galda (Macrobrachium rosenbergii) and
Table 6.7 Adaptive fishes in climate change scenario and the adaptation techniques
Climate induced
changes
High temperature
Cultivable fish
Tilapia, shing,
magur and koi
Low temperature
Tilapia, pangas
and koi
Fluctuation in
day-night temperature
Tilapia, shing,
magur, pangas
and koi
Adaptation techniques in culture
management
The fishes can be cultured during period of
high temperature. Following technologies
should be followed in farming system –
Fish should be provided with safe refuge by
covering 15–20 % of waterbody with water
hyacinth, so fish can take shelter from direct
sunlight during day time
10–15 % area of pond bottom should be
made 2 ft deeper than other areas, so fish can
take shelter in that part with comparatively
cooler water
If possible supply of cold water from
external sources
The fishes can be cultured during the period
of low temperature. The following
technologies should be followed in the
farming system –
Reduce the amount of feed and fertilizer
application
10–15 % area of pond bottom should be
made 2 ft deeper than other areas, so fish can
take shelter in that part with comparatively
hotter water
If possible supply of underground water
High fluctuation in day-night temperature
can also cause environmental stress for
farmed fish and reduce fish productivity. The
following technologies should be followed in
the farming system in this situation 10–15 % area of pond bottom should be
made 2 ft deeper than other areas, so fish can
take shelter in that part with comparatively
hotter water
If possible supply of relatively hotter water
during the end part of night
(continued)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
104
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
Table 6.7 (continued)
Climate induced
changes
Timing of rainfall,
pattern and fluctuation
Cultivable fish
Carp fingerlings
of large size
(150–200 g),
tilapia, sarpunti
and prawn
Water retention
capacity of
waterbodies and
shorter duration
of water holding
Carp fingerlings
of minimum size
(250–300 g),
tilapia, sarpunti
and galda
Change in physicochemical parameters
of water due to
pollution
Carp fingerlings
of minimum size
(250–300 g),
tilapia, shing,
magur and koi
Salinity (ppt)
15+ Bagda,
bhetki and parse
8–14 Bagda,
bhetki, parse,
pangas and tilapia
0–7 Bagda,
galda, bhetki,
parse, pangas
Adaptation techniques in culture
management
Fish farmers suffer due to Timing of rainfall,
pattern and fluctuation. Therefore,
considering the heavy downpour and drought
(lack of rain), following adaptive techniques
may be followed in fish farming
Stocking large sized fingerlings so fish can
be marketed within 3–5 months before the
onset of heavy downpour or drought
Regular application of fed and fertilizer to
ensure faster growth of fish
Based on the water retention capacity of
waterbodies and shorter duration of water
holding, most of the times waterbodies
become dry out. Considering this aspect,
following adaptive techniques may be
followed in fish farming
Stocking large sized fingerlings so fish can
be marketed within 3–5 months before the
onset of heavy downpour or drought
Regular application of fed and fertilizer to
ensure faster growth of fish
Pollution due to a number of reasons changes
the optimum water quality parameters that
hinder fish growth. Considering this aspect,
following adaptive techniques may be
followed in fish farming
Farming fish that can tolerate comparatively
harsh conditions
Farming fish with accessory air breathing
organs (jeol mach)
Stocking large sized fingerlings so fish can
be marketed within 3–5 months before the
onset of heavy downpour or drought
Provision of regular water exchange
Regular application of fed and fertilizer to
ensure faster growth of fish
Selected fish should be cultured with greater
importance considering the climate change
risk, in the areas where most of the times,
salinity is more than 15 ppt
Selected fish should be cultured with greater
importance considering the climate change
risk, in the areas where most of the times,
salinity is 8–14 ppt
Selected fish should be cultured with greater
importance considering the climate change
risk, in the areas where most of the times,
salinity is 0–7 ppt
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
105
Table 6.8 The fishes and their culture mode
Fish photos
Name of the fish
Tilapia
Culture mode
Tilapia monoculture
Tilapia mixed/poly culture
Tilapia cage culture
Tilapia culture in shrimp/prawn gher
Rohu
Large sized fingerling poly culture
Catla
Mrigal
Common carp
Silver carp
Grass carp
Sarpunti
Thai sarpunti poly culture with carps
Pangas
Pangas mono culture
Koi
Indigenous or Thai koi mono culture
Thai koi
Shing
Shing- magur culture
Magur
(continued)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
106
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
Table 6.8 (continued)
Fish photos
Name of the fish
Bhetki
Culture mode
Bhetki-parse culture in gher
Parse
Galda
Gher farming
Bagda
bagda (Penaeus monodon) and large sized carp fingerlings. The general features of
the fishes are described here –
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Fast growing (marketable in 3–4 months)
Can be cultured in low water depth
Can tolerate relative worse environment
Can tolerate temperature fluctuation
Can tolerate medium salinity level
Keep growing in relatively low dissolved O2
Good demand and market price
Fish seed and other ingredients needed to culture the fish are easily available
Easy culture method
6.6.4
Coping Mechanisms Fish Farmers Now Follow
to Sustain and Secure the Livelihood
Fish farmer, who can afford and have facilities, are trying to culture fish with
irrigated water. Many farmers in the north and north central part of the country are
mono-culturing monosex tilapia instead of mixed carp culture, because tilapia can
stand low water depth, adverse physico-chemical parameters and are short-cycled
compared to carps. The farmers apply commercial feed pellet for tilapia and once
the water turns to deep green, they release silver carp or raek (Cirrhinus reba).
In the changed scenario, this way many farmers are getting more profit than mixed
carp culture. High temperature tolerant species like tilapia (monosex) are stocked
in the culture ponds along with short cycled fish like Thai sarpunti and silver carp.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
107
Fish farmers in greater Rajshahi district are stocking 500–700 g carps and culturing
for a year or so. As rice mono-culture now-a-days gives very little profit, many
farmers are farming fish in irrigated rice field, wherever facilities are available to
minimize the cost of rice production.
6.7
Conclusion and Recommendations
The crucial step for Bangladesh now is to address and integrate natural disaster and
reduce risks into development plans and processes to safeguard the nation’s wellbeing
and to secure and sustain the livelihood of people for both present and future generations. This must be addressed systematically so that the country recognizes the
risks to development and change the way it plans to develop.
Climate changes are responsible for decreased production in all agricultural
sectors – crop, fisheries and livestock. In the past, most of the rivers and floodplain,
beels, canals were full of fish. Now almost all the water bodies are dead and largely
empty of fish. Monsoon duration in this country used to be for 6 months and with
regular rainfall and huge abundance of fish. Even during the lean period, in the
deeper part of the river, there was enough fish and fisher families sustained their
livelihood catching those fish. Presently, lack of rain in time and untimely downpour
both are harming the fisheries. Sudden flush flood damages fences and embankment,
inundates aquaculture systems and allows stocked fish to escape resulting huge loss.
All these are making the livelihood for fishers and fish farmers unsustainable.
Since the economic impacts of climate change will have to be borne by individuals,
communities and the government, there is a need for evolving climate resilient
development strategy involving all the relevant sectors including aquaculture.
Only eco-friendly, improved and innovative management practices with insights on
technological, environmental and socioeconomic concerns can mitigate the impact
of climate change on aquaculture of Bangladesh and ensure sustainable fish production. Aquaculture production in this part of the country need to be accelerated to
maximum sustainable production to meet the fish protein demand without disturbing
the nature.
To face the challenge of climate change on the overall aquaculture and fisheries
sector of Bangladesh, there is an urgent need to educate and to establish a greater
understanding and appreciation of Bangladesh’s water bodies, aquatic animals and
plants and innovative management practices to people from all strata to pave the
way of sustainable fisheries and aquaculture management.
The following recommendations are made in this regard• Undertake mass awareness programme on adverse impact of climate change in
aquaculture sector and the process risk reduction.
• Initiate capacity building activities for DoF and NGO officials on fisheries
climate change adaptation and farmers/fishers as well.
• Establish disaster risk reduction cell in DoF with functional core groups up to
divisional level.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
108
M.A.R. Hossain et al.
• Prepare a macro level Development Plan for DoF which will help to contribute
in preparing future programme planning and investment decision in the sector.
• Increase and strengthen inter-sectoral coordination for programme planning and
implementation
• Strengthening cooperation on other country’s emerging issues: such as sharing
of success stories in respect of aquaculture risk reduction and adaptation.
Climate changes in the form of – temperature fluctuations, erratic rainfall and
flooding, prolonged drought, sea level rise, salinity intrusion, frequent cyclones,
storms and tornado affect aquatic ecosystems and their productivity. Fish farming is
also threatened by the changes in ocean currents and precipitation that affects
wetland/floodplain levels and river flows, and increases storminess and extreme
floods and droughts. This makes farming fish extremely hazardous.
Greater climate variability and uncertainty complicate the task of expanding
aquaculture sustainably. Fish in Bangladesh can provide opportunities to adapt to
climate change by, for example, integrating aquaculture and agriculture, farming
more resilient and climate tolerant fish, shellfish and aquatic plant varieties which
can help farmers cope with drought while boosting profits and household nutrition.
Fisheries management must move from seeking to maximize yield to increasing
adaptive capacity. Research is needed to find innovative ways to further improve the
existing adaptability of fishers and aquaculturists.
References
Ali ML, Hossain MAR, Ahmed M (2009) Impact of sanctuary on fish production and biodiversity in
Bangladesh. Final project report. Bangladesh Fisheries Research Forum (BFRF), Dhaka, 80 pp
Ameen M (1999) Development of guiding principles for the prevention of impacts of alien species.
Consultative workshop in advance of the 4th meeting of SBSTTA to the CBD, IUCN
Bangladesh, Dhaka
Baudron AR, Needle CL, Rijnsdorp AD, Marshal CT (2014) Warming temperatures and smaller
body sizes: synchronous changes in growth of North Sea fishes. Glob Chang Biol
20(4):1023–1031
Belton B, Azad A (2012) The characteristics and status of pond aquaculture in Bangladesh.
Aquaculture 358–359:196–204
Beveridge MCM, Little DC (2002) The history of aquaculture in traditional societies. In: CostaPierce BA (ed) Ecological aquaculture: the evolution of the blue revolution. Blackwell Science,
Oxford, pp 4–29
CCC (2009) Characterizing long-term changes of Bangladesh climate in context of agriculture and
irrigation. Climate Change Cell, DoE, MoEF; Component 4b, CDMP, MoFDM, Dhaka, 104 pp
Dey MM, Bose ML, Alam MF (2008) Recommendation domains for pond aquaculture. Country
case study: development and status of freshwater aquaculture in Bangladesh, WorldFish center
studies and reviews no. 1872. The WorldFish Center, Penang, 73 pp
DoF (Department of Fisheries) (2013) Matshya Saptaha Saranika-2012. Department of Fisheries,
Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock. The Government of the Peoples Republic of Bangladesh,
Ramna, Dhaka, 144 pp
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
6
Livelihood Security: Implications from Aquaculture Sectors
109
FAO (2005) National aquaculture sector overview. Bangladesh. National aquaculture sector
overview fact sheets. Text by Gias, U.A. In: FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Department
(online). Rome. Updated 1 Jan 2005. Cited 8 May 2014. http://www.fao.org/fishery/countrysector/naso_bangladesh/en
Felts RA, Rajts F, Akhteruzzaman M (1996) Small indigenous fish species culture in Bangladesh.
Technical brief, EC & DoF, integrated food assisted development project, Gulshan,
Dhaka, 41 pp
Hossain MAR (2010) Inland fisheries resource enhancement and conservation in Bangladesh.
RAP Publication 2010/22. In: Miao W, Silva SD, Davy B (ed) Inland fisheries enhancement
and conservation in Asia, FAO Regional Office for the Asia and the Pacific, Bangkok. pp 1–17
Hossain MAR (2014) Habitat and fish diversity: Bangladesh perspective. In: Wahab MA, Shah
MS, Hossain MAR, Barman BK, Hoq ME (eds) Recent advances in fisheries of Bangladesh.
Bangladesh Fisheries Research Forum, Dhaka, pp 1–26
Hossain MAR, Wahab MA (2009) The diversity of cypriniforms throughout Bangladesh: present
status and conservation challenges. In: Tepper GH (ed) Species diversity and extinction. Nova,
New York, pp 143–182
Hossain MAR, Belton B, Thilsted SH (2013) Preliminary rapid appraisal of dried fish value chains
in Bangladesh. WorldFish Bangladesh, Dhaka, 41 pp
Rahman AKA (2005) Freshwater Fishes of Bangladesh. Zoological Society of Bangladesh,
Dhaka, 394 pp
Sultana P (2012) Implications of floodplain aquaculture enclosure. J Environ Plan Manag
55:1159–1174
WorldFish (2007) Fisheries and aquaculture can provide solutions to cope with climate change,
Issues brief. WorldFish Center, Penang, 4 pp
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related
Issues on Food Security
Md. Abu Syed
Abstract The member states of South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation
(SAARC) share similar food habits with staple food rice is facing two challenges
towards achieving food security and the promotion of regional trade. Trade engagement within South Asia, relative to Non-South-Asian countries, found to be low.
Bangladesh, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka trade more with other South Asian
countries compared to that among any two of them. The global food crisis 2007–
2008 sheds light on the discrepancies between SAARC’s supposed objective of
becoming an integrated economic community and its member countries’ continued
tendency to put national economic interests above regional solidarity. At regional
scale India contributes most in cereal production and export. However, to a large
extent, the way in the crisis was handled at the national level not only contributed to
further regional as well as global food price volatility, but also undermined the food
security situation in the region. Bangladesh could not get rice to purchase during
these critical days of 2007–2008 despite repeated attempts to pay as much as market
demands. The diverse capacity of SAARC member countries to produce food, store
and in distribution systems, food insecurity can be best tackled through a regional
approach with differentiated responsibility for member states. This is the area where
regional trade policy regimes need further integration so that it can withstand any
sudden shock. It appears that many commodity markets within the countries and the
South Asia region are not integrated. Integration of wheat and rice markets needs
attention and action within countries and in region. These may be attributed to the
lower number products of each country with surplus to export compared to Indian
capacity for production and export. This chapter will try to investigate regional
food trade (with some extent trade policies), barriers and opportunities and their
implications to the regional and national food security in SAARC region.
Keywords South Asia • Regional trade • Food security • Agriculture • Poverty
Md.A. Syed (*)
Remote Sensing, GIS and Modeling Division; NRM, Ecosystem Modeling
and Adaptation Division, Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies (BCAS),
House 10, Road 16A, Gulshan 1, Dhaka 1212, Bangladesh
e-mail: mabusyed@gmail.com
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_7
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
111
112
7.1
Md.A. Syed
Introduction
South Asia, home to 40 % of the world’s poor earning less than a dollar a day and
concentration of poverty even more than Africa. Though South Asia is home to
22 % of the global population, however generates less than 2 % of global income.
Most of the South Asian poor populations depend on agriculture for their livelihood.
UK Hunger Alliance (2011) opined that food prices are expected to stay high and
volatile for the foreseeable future and it’s the poorest that are being hit hardest.
Global Hunger Index published by International Food Policy Research Institute
(IFPRI) in 2011 GHI, globally only 15 countries and in South Asia only were able
to moved out of the bottom two categories–“extremely alarming” and “alarming”
food security situation particularly food production point of view. Nearly 50 % of
the labor force is engaged in agriculture in 2010 (WDR 2012) and the sector
accounts for about 20 % of national GDP. The region is dominated by small farmers
with an average holding size of less than 2 ha, who are net buyers of food. It is
therefore conceivable that food crises have a deep and lasting impact on the
well-being of the peoples in these countries. In this study we attempt to analyze the
food security scenario in each of the South Asian countries and the region as a
whole. We also assess the scope for regional integration and cooperation to attain
food security in the region.
In this chapter section a detailed analysis of the existing and potential supplydemand deficits for major commodities important from the point of food security
carried out. This is followed by an analysis of the agricultural trade policy and the
extent of agricultural trade engagement of each country in the South Asia region.
7.2
Agriculture in South Asia and Food Security
Agriculture contributes well over 20 % of national GDP in South Asia region and is
the key to secure food and livelihood security. Because agriculture is still the single
largest employment generation sector that engage rural labor force. Among full
time and seasonal labor force 50 % employment comes from agriculture and remains
as the mainstay of economic activities in the region. Agriculture in the region still
heavily dependent on nature for timely rainfall for irrigation and hence potentially
remain vulnerable to changes in natural climatic process including rainfall and other
forms of precipitation. However, it is important to note that gradual industrialization
and mechanization of agriculture, employment in the agriculture sector and its share
in national GDP is declining. Another transitional process going on in agriculture
sector is that it is getting more integrated into industrialization and economic growth
through gradual increase agro-industries development. Thus agriculture is increasingly influencing more the overall economic growth in the region. Gradual mechanization, required forward and backward linkage industries in the sector are also
contributing to the further integration of agriculture sector with the national and
regional economies in the region.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
113
Fig. 7.1 Agriculture value additions per worker in South Asian Countries (Source: World
Development Indicators (WDI), Development Data Group, World Bank)
Fig. 7.2 Percentage of irrigate land of total agricultural land (Source: World Development
Indicators (WDI), Development Data Group, World Bank)
The growth rates of agricultural value added per worker in during 2000–2009
period is substantially lower in most countries (Fig. 7.1). However, the growth rate
of per capita GDP is much higher during the same period in all the countries, except
Nepal, representing stagnation in the agricultural sector in South Asia region during
the last decades. The stagnation in agriculture led to rising inter-sectoral disparities
in the region. From Fig. 7.2, it is clear that the percentage of agricultural land to total
area is stagnant during the last decade showing that increasing area under agriculture
is not an option for increasing production in the region. However, Fig. 7.2 shows
that the percentage of irrigated land to total agricultural land is also almost stagnant,
showing absence of investment (mostly public) in a crucial input like irrigation.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Md.A. Syed
114
7.3
Supply-Demand of Agricultural Products
and Trade in South Asia
The supply demand scenario analysis was carried out for each country and the
region as a whole to assess the present scenario, indicators like production/
consumption ratio, import/consumption ratio, ending stocks/consumption ratio and
production instability index were computed for the triennium ending 2009. The
FAO Stats data were utilized to the analysis. However, these measures pertain to the
one time period and therefore do not completely inform us about the emerging
scenario. For example, a country may possess lower production in during 2007–2009
trienniums as compared to consumption. In such a case the production/consumption
ratio will be less than 100. However, if the production is growing much faster than
consumption, this ratio may rapidly increase and may even cross 100 in the near
future. To account for these dynamics, we have combined the present supplydemand scenario with the medium term growth rates (from 2001 to 2011) for each
commodity to draw conclusions about the potential surplus/deficit in the region.
Based on this analysis, the present supply demand scenario and future trends of
various commodities are as follows.
Rice
Production/Consumption Ratio is high in Pakistan, medium in India, Nepal, Sri Lanka
and Bangladesh whereas Production/Consumption Ratio is low in Afghanistan.
The ending stocks (Ending stocks/consumption ratio) are adequate in Pakistan,
India and but inadequate in Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Nepal and Sri Lanka. The
Production Instability Index is high for Afghanistan, medium for India, Nepal,
Pakistan and Sri Lanka. The Production Instability Index is low for Bangladesh.
As for emerging trends, in Afghanistan, the production growth rate is almost
equal to that of consumption. The yield growth rate is stagnant. It appears that
Afghanistan is largely self-sufficient in rice with no major deficits. In Bangladesh,
the growth rate of domestic production is greater than domestic consumption and
the growth rate of stocks is high. The yield growth rate is also impressive. Therefore,
there is some potential for export surpluses in this country. In India, production
growth rate much higher as compared to consumption. The growth rate of ending
stocks is also quite high. These, combined with positive growth rate of yield, show
that there is potential for export surpluses in India. In, the production growth rate is
negative and consumption growth rate is positive and the consequent supply-demand
gap is met through imports and drawing down the stocks. Imports show a high positive growth rate and ending stocks a high negative growth rate. The growth rates of
yield and area are negative (decline). All these trends indicate that major deficits for
rice may continue for some time. In Nepal, the domestic production growth rate is
much lower than that of consumption and the resulting supply-demand gap is met
manly through imports. There is no major stockholding in the country and the yield
growth is almost stagnant. All these trends indicate that there are major emerging
deficits in this country. In Pakistan, the production growth rate is much higher than
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
115
that of consumption. The import, export and stocks growth rates are also quite high.
These combined with high growth rates of area and yield show that there is large
potential for exports in Pakistan. In Sri Lanka, the production growth rate is much
higher than that of consumption. The stocks growth rates are also high leading to
high growth rate in exports. These trends, together with high growth rate of area
indicate that there is a definite potential for exports in Sri Lanka.
The broad inference is that there exists some export surplus in Pakistan and
India. There is potential for export surplus in Bangladesh and Sri Lanka while
Afghanistan and are in dire need of imports.
Wheat
The Production/Consumption Ratio is medium in Afghanistan, Bhutan, India,
Nepal and Pakistan. Low in Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and combined with high import/
consumption ratios. Ending stocks (Ending stocks/consumption ratio) are adequate
in Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Sri Lanka. All the major importers such as
Bangladesh and Sri Lanka hold high level of stocks showing predominantly precautionary/transactions motives of stockholding. The Production Instability Index is
high for all the countries except India, Nepal and Pakistan.
As for emerging trends, in Afghanistan, the production growth rate much less
than that of consumption. The resulting supply-demand gap is met mainly through
imports. In Bangladesh, the growth rate of domestic production is very much lower
than that of domestic consumption. The supply is augmented through imports.
These trends, together with the fact that area growth rate is negative (although the
yield growth rate is positive) show that the deficits are likely to continue for some
time. Bhutan has no domestic production of wheat and is completely dependent on
imports. In India, the production growth rate is slightly higher compared to consumption. The growth rate in imports is high. Although the growth rate in stocks is
high, the growth rates of area and yield are not significant. These trends indicate that
there is hardly any potential for export surpluses to emerge in India. In India the
production growth rate is higher than consumption growth rate. There is a decline in
imports and increase in exports. The growth rate of ending stocks is comfortable.
These emerging trends indicate that India is likely to be self-sufficient in wheat. In
Nepal, domestic production growth rate is almost equal to that of consumption.
There is no stockholding in the country. The area and yield growth rates are stagnant. The inference is that there are no major deficits presently but may emerge in
future. In Pakistan, production growth rate is higher than that of consumption. There
is steady growth in stockholding and exports. The growth rates of area and yield are
also satisfactory. These trends indicate that there is a definite potential for wheat
exports in Pakistan. In Sri Lanka, there is no wheat production and the country is
completely dependent on imports. The stocks are mainly held for precautionary
purposes. It appears that the deficits in Sri Lanka are likely to continue for a long time.
Overall, it appears that there is not adequate export surplus in the region to meet
the import requirements of Bangladesh, Sri Lanka. Afghanistan also needs stable
import supply.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
116
Md.A. Syed
Corn
The Production/Consumption Ratio is medium for Afghanistan, Bhutan, India,
Nepal and Pakistan. Ending stocks/consumption ratio is adequate for Pakistan and
but inadequate for all other countries. Production Instability Index is high for
Afghanistan, Bhutan medium for India and low for Nepal and Pakistan.
As for emerging trends, in Afghanistan, the supply is keeping pace with demand
entirely through domestic production with very little imports. Major part of the
growth in production is through yield increases. The broad inference is that this
country is largely showing self-sufficiency in corn. In India, the growth rate of
domestic production is higher than that of domestic consumption and the growth
rate of stocks is also comfortable. The exports are growing faster than imports.
Therefore, there is potential for exports from India. In, the production growth rate
very low compared to consumption. The deficit is mainly bridged through imports
(imports show high growth rate). There is very little prospect of self- sufficiency
with very low growth rate of yield. The broad inference for this country is that there
are emerging supply-demand deficits. Imports may be needed for a long time. In
Nepal, the production growth rate is only slightly less than consumption. However,
the growth rate of imports is high, mainly to build stocks. The growth rate of yield
is quite low. The deficits in Nepal may continue for some time. In Pakistan, the
domestic production and consumption are in balance. There is a high growth rate of
imports, mainly for re-exports. The growth rate of yield is high. The inference is
that there exists good potential for export surplus in Pakistan. Overall in the South
Asian region, the production growth rate is higher than that of consumption. The
import and export growth rates are high. The ending stocks not very high.
The broad inference is that there exists low exportable surplus of corn in the
region, except Pakistan and India. Some potential exists for trade between Pakistan
and India and Nepal.
Sugar
The sugar production/consumption ratio is medium for India and Pakistan and low
for all other countries. The import/consumption ratio is high for Bangladesh,
Maldives, Nepal and Sri Lanka. Production Instability Index is also high in all
countries. For sugar (centrifugal), the Production/Consumption Ratio is medium for
Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Nepal. The ratio is low for Afghanistan, Maldives
and Sri Lanka. The Ending stocks/consumption ratio is adequate in Bangladesh,
India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka.
As for emerging trends, in Bangladesh, the production growth rate is much lower
than that of consumption, indicating large potential deficits in future. In India, the
production growth rate is almost equal to that of consumption. This implies that
there could be no large potential deficits or surpluses in India. In the production
growth rate is much higher than that of consumption, pointing to a large potential
export surpluses in this country. There is no domestic production in Maldives and
the country is completely dependent on imports. In Nepal, the production growth
rate is higher than that of consumption, indicating potential export surplus.
In Pakistan, the production growth rate is much lower than that of consumption,
implying large potential deficits in future.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
117
In Sri Lanka, production growth rate is higher than that of consumption, showing
some potential for export. Overall, in South Asia the production growth rate is
almost equal to that of consumption showing no large potential deficits or surpluses
in the region. At the global level, the production growth rate is higher than that of
consumption, indicating some potential for export. Overall, it appears that presently
there is export surplus for sugar (refined) only in India. Large potential deficits are
emerging in Pakistan. Maldives is totally dependent on imports. In the case of sugar
(centrifugal) there is some trade potential from India and Pakistan to Afghanistan,
Maldives, and Bangladesh.
Pulses
As for emerging trends, in Bangladesh, the production growth rate is much lower
than that of consumption showing large potential deficits in future. In India, the
production growth rate is almost equal to that of consumption indicating no large
potential deficits or surpluses in the two countries. In Maldives, the production
growth rate is much lower than consumption showing large potential deficits in
future. In Nepal, the production growth rate is much lower than that of consumption
indicating large potential deficits. In Pakistan, the production growth rate is higher
than consumption showing some potential for export surplus. In Sri Lanka, the production growth rate is almost equal to that of consumption, indicating no large
potential deficits or surpluses. Overall, in South Asia, the production growth rate is
almost equal to that of consumption, showing that there are no large potential
deficits or surpluses. At the global level, also the production growth rate is almost
equal to that of consumption, showing that there are no large potential deficits or
surpluses.
The foregoing analysis indicates that slight potential for exports exists only in
Pakistan. All other countries in the region may face deficits or may attain
self-sufficiency.
Edible Oils
Palm Oil: All the countries are highly dependent on imports. Almost the entire
consumption is met through imports. As for emerging trends, in Afghanistan and
Bangladesh, there is no domestic production and the two countries are completely
dependent on imports. Imports and stocks are used to meet the production- consumption gap. It appears that these major deficits will continue in these countries.
In Sri Lanka, although the production is stagnant, no major deficits are likely to
emerge because of a declining trend in consumption. All the countries are highly
dependent on imports. Almost the entire consumption is met through imports.
Production/productivity and consumption trends indicate that these deficits are
likely to continue for some time.
Soybean Oil
The Production/Consumption Ratio is low for all the countries. The Ending stocks/
consumption ratio is adequate in Bangladesh and but inadequate in India an Pakistan.
The Production Instability Index is very high in the region in all the countries
compared to the world average but is low in Bangladesh and India when compared
to the South Asian average.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
118
Md.A. Syed
As for emerging trends, in Bangladesh, the production growth rate is much
higher than that of consumption. But the growth rate of stocks is negative. Therefore,
there is unlikely to be any exportable surplus but no major deficits are anticipated
either. The country is likely to remain self-sufficient. In India, the production growth
rate is much higher compared to consumption and there is consistent stock holding
(steady growth rate). The inference is that there is potential for export surplus in
India. These growth trends, together with reduced exports and large growth rate of
stocks, show that there is potential for export surplus in India. In Pakistan, there is
substantial decline in production. There is decline in consumption also but the
growth rate is much lower as compared to production indicating that major deficits
may emerge in Pakistan. Overall, in South Asia, the production growth rate is much
higher than that of consumption. The growth rate of stocks is positive. There is
potential for export surplus in the region. At the global level, the production growth
rate is almost equal to that of consumption. The growth in trade and stocks is almost
stagnant. These trends indicate that the supply and demand are just in balance
presently at the global level and deficits are likely to emerge in future.
The broad inference is that there is some exportable surplus in the region.
Production/productivity and consumption trends indicate that potential for selfsufficiency or slight export surplus exists in India, Bangladesh. Major deficits may
continue in Pakistan.
Sunflower Oil
The Production/Consumption Ratio is medium only in Pakistan. For all other countries, that is, India and the ratio is very low. The Ending stocks/consumption ratio is
adequate in India, but inadequate in Pakistan.
As for emerging trends, in India, the production growth rate is much lower compared to consumption. Imports and stocks are mainly used to meet the supplydemand gap and also for re-exports. The broad inference is that major deficits may
continue in India. In the region, the production growth rate is much lower compared
to consumption. Imports and stocks are used to meet the gap. The stocks are used
for precautionary purposes. All these trends indicate that the deficits in sunflower
oil may continue for some time. In Pakistan, the production growth rate is almost
equal to that of consumption. The growth rate of imports is negative. The stocks are
held mainly for transaction purposes. These trends indicate that Pakistan is largely
self-sufficient with no major surpluses or deficits. Overall, in the South Asian
region, the production growth rate is much lower than that of consumption, which
in turn, can lead to large potential deficits. At the global level, the production growth
rate is almost equal to that of consumption. These trends indicate that, at the global
level, the supply and demand are just in balance. Deficits are likely to emerge in
south Asia since export surpluses are not anticipated in the world market. Overall,
it appears that there is no exportable surplus in the region. The Production Instability
Index is also very high compared to world average. Production/productivity and
consumption trends indicate that major deficits may continue in the region for some
time. No exportable surplus in the region for any of the major edible oils, except
soybean oil. Al the countries are highly dependent on imports from the world
market. Production instability index is also very high.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
119
Countries: India and Pakistan are either self-sufficient or possess export surplus
in most commodities. Nepal, Maldives, Bhutan and Afghanistan are facing deficits
and rely on imports for most of the important commodities. Bangladesh shows
encouraging trends in commodities such as rice and potato. Increased production
compared to consumption lead to significant surpluses of potato in Bangladesh is an
increasing trend. Bangladeshi potato is mostly exported to Sri Lanka, Russia and to
extent North Eastern States in India. On the other hand from one of top exporter of
tea Bangladesh recently became net importer. This is caused by increased domestic
demand surpassed growth rate in production. Resulting gaps are fulfilled by imports
from India and Sri Lanka.
7.4
Agricultural Trade Policy and Trade Patterns
in South Asian Countries
Bangladesh
Bangladesh’s agricultural trade policy is often perceived as one of increasing
openness to imports, but with significant anti-export bias. In reality however, trade
policy has been actively used both on the side of imports for management of the
staple grains and the side of exports in promotion of the exports of locally produced
value added products. On the export side, the policy has been relatively consistent.
On the import side, the focus is to minimize the potential negative impacts of trade
on food security and as a result the interventions have been more ad- hoc in nature.
In practice, both exportable and importable have therefore been subject to the use of
instruments associated with trade promotion and trade restriction respectively.
Although a significant number of quantitative restrictions have been dismantled and
there has been a shift towards greater use of ad valorem tariffs, the average tariff has
is still high at 32 %.
Cereal trade faces relatively low tariffs in general, but supplementary duties are
significantly used when cheaper imports flow in from major exporters like India.
Bangladesh is a net importer of rice and wheat. After allowing private sector in 1993
to import food grains, private sector played a major role in the commercial imports
of food grains, particularly after the floods in 1998 and 2004. Despite zero or very
low import tariffs, Bangladesh has been facing problems in imports of rice and
edible oils mainly because of the restrictions on exports by India and Argentina
respectively. In recent times, Bangladesh has allowed limited export of rice
particularly aromatic varieties and restrictions temporarily used since 2007 to
manage domestic prices in conjunction with the management of food reserves.
The intervention in grains trade has increased significantly after the food rice crisis
in 2008, reflecting a change from the strategy of self-reliance that has been in place
since the early 1990s to one of self-sufficiency. Support to certain exportable also
appears to have had positive effects in terms of improving producer incomes, in
addition to their contribution to foreign exchange earnings. Dwelling on a bumper
yield and good stocks at home, Bangladesh government decided to export at least
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
120
Md.A. Syed
50,000-MT of rice, first of its kind since the independence in 1971, to Sri Lanka in
the fiscal year 2014–2015. First consignment of 12500 MT of it left Bangladesh
port for Srilnaka on December 27, 2014.
Bhutan
Bhutan farmers have traditionally practiced subsistence agriculture leading to selfsufficiency in food for a long time. However, with economic growth and population
increases, imports are becoming a necessity. India is the main trading partner for
Bhutan and is the main source of food imports. Bhutan imposes no tariffs or any
other form of non-tariff restrictions on food imports from India. India also exempted
Bhutan from rice export restrictions in 2008.
India
Since independence, India has virtually banned imports of all agricultural products
except basic foodstuffs like cereals, pulses and vegetable oils. After the introduction
of economic reforms in 1991–1992, the import policy was gradually liberalized, but
the restrictions on basic foodstuffs took longer to be phased out. Among the items
that were restricted in the pre-reform era, edible oils (other than coconut oil) were
the first to be liberalized in 1994. After 1994, edible oil imports were determined
mainly by tariffs. It was not until March 2002 that restrictions were phased out on
milk and milk products and on cereals.
In the early 1960s, imports, mainly of wheat from the USA under the food aid
programs, constituted a big proportion of domestic supplies, accounting for as much
as 42 %. After the government decision to go for self-sufficiency, import dependence rapidly declined. Except in period 1974–1976 and to some extent in 1983,
when large imports were made, the contribution of imports to domestic availability
was in no year more than 3 %. In the case of rice, import dependence was very low
right from the outset. Imports, as a percentage of domestic availability were never
in excess of 3 % even in the early 1960s, at the peak of India’s import dependence
for food grains. Since then imports have tapered off to negligible quantities. But
reliance on imports has been a feature of India’s edible oil economy. In the late
1970s imports increased and remained in the range of 36–47 % during the period
1976–1987. With the tightening of import restrictions in the following years import
dependence came down to 4 % in 1993. After liberalization in 1994, it rose steadily
so as to exceed 50 % since 2000. This was despite the fact that in case of soybean
oil there had been a substantial increase in domestic production.
Maldives
Though Maldives is heavily rely on imported foods; however it is also a major
exporter of marine products, mainly to countries outside SAARC Thailand, UK,
Japan, France and Pakistan. Their marine export within SAARC region is limited
mainly to Sri Lanka.
Nepal
Nepal followed a protectionist, import substituting regime between 1956 and 1986,
but the trade regime has since been much more liberal. Nepal is now a relatively
more open economy in the South Asian region with low average tariff rates, ranging
from 10 to 15 % and virtually no quantitative restrictions. The applied agricultural
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
121
tariffs are way below the WTO bound rates. Nepal also does not provide any explicit
export subsidies. The country is a net importer of cereals, particularly rice from
India, through formal and informal channels.
The liberal trade policy regime adopted since the 1980s focused primarily on
addressing the bias against exports, reducing distortions in domestic markets and
procedural and institutional reforms. The 1992 trade policy continued the same
thrust. However, the choice of policy instruments and pace of liberalization are
constrained by both formal and informal trade relations with India. As a result, even
the liberal trade policy could not produce the desired results in terms of agricultural
development, export growth and diversification and poverty reduction. The recent
policy thrust recognizes that export development is essential to sustained broadbased economic growth and poverty reduction in light of the small domestic market.
Although the policy recognizes the need to establish increased linkages of the export
sector with other sectors of the economy, it did not support explicitly the import
competing sectors.
The following issues remain important for trade policy in Nepal – trade relations
with India on agriculture products; the need for tariff rationalization for primary
agriculture products vis-à- vis processed agriculture products and other industrial
products; the need for support measures in agricultural products, in particular the
products identified by the 2009 trade policy for thrust areas; the role of exchange
rate regime in promoting agricultural exports; the role of international trade in
ensuring food security.
Pakistan
Pakistan is one of the pioneering members of the WTO and is an active member of
various groups and alliances. Pakistan has begun deregulation and liberalization of
agriculture in the 1980s – mainly under the advice of the International Financial
Institutions (IFI). Many non-tariff barriers have been removed and the list of negative import items has been greatly reduced. Pakistan has entered into Free Trade
Agreements (FTA) with China, Malaysia and Sri Lanka. Pakistan is a party to two
agreements for regional trade liberalization including the SAARC with India,
Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Bhutan, Nepal and the Maldives. Textiles dominate
Pakistan’s exports. Other major exports include rice, seafood and products. Major
agricultural imports include edible oils, cotton, sugar, pulses, tea, milk and milk
products, and dry fruits.
Sri Lanka
Tea is the major traditional export sub-sector of Sri Lanka, however rubber, coconut,
spices, and more recently some non-traditional products like fruits and vegetables
also showing promising trend. Rice also gradually evolving as dominating import
substitute or competing sub-sector but other crops, livestock and dairy products are
also showing encouraging trends. Policies for trade and price management in these
tow subsector have been historically different, which remains so till date.
Wheat flour is an essential commodity and second important staple food grain
after rice in Sri Lanka. Sri Lanka does not produce wheat domestically in the country and meet all their consumption requirements fully through imports. Trade and
pricing policies on wheat, apart from implications for wheat consumption, also have
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
122
Md.A. Syed
important implications for rice (Dayaratna-Banda et al. 2008). Particularly, the
reductions in wheat tariffs have been found to have suppressing effects on the farm
gate prices of rice. It is largely for this impact on rice that wheat policy becomes
important in Sri Lanka. This close cross-price effect was also observed in 2000
when the government introduced consumption subsidy in the form of reduced price
of wheat flour. Because of the effect, the subsidy was quickly withdrawn in 2001.
The government’s long term objective is to reduce the consumption of wheat to be
replaced by domestic rice. According to some reports the wheat imports have fallen
significantly, from around 120,000 tonnes a month about 5 years ago to around
80,000 tonnes per month in recent months (FAO 2011). National food security experts
have welcomed this. The Government of Sri Lanka (GoSL) continues to intervene
actively on a range of food products with a variety of trade and pricing policies.
The taxation of traditional exports has fallen from over 40 % during the 1960s
and 1970s to about 20 % in the 1980s and 1990s (Bandara and Jayasuriya 2009).
In contrast, importables generally enjoyed positive protection, ranging at modest
levels for rice to high levels for products like chilies, onions and potatoes, but also
for some other food products in recent years. The trade and pricing policies are
aimed at protecting farmers, containing retail prices and encouraging value addition. The use of one instrument (mainly price) for such varied objectives affects
different stakeholders in different ways.
Wheat flour, sugar and pulses are the major imports followed by milk, fruits,
onions and potatoes. Despite few measures to liberalize agricultural trade, the sector
remains highly protected. The bound tariff rates on agricultural products are in the
range of 100–300 % although the applied tariffs are much lower. There are also
quantitative restrictions (QR) and other non-tariff barriers for some agricultural
products.
The trade policy regime for rice has been guided principally by considerations of
domestic market price, raising tariffs when prices are lower and waiving duties
during shortages. Sri Lanka is a relatively high-cost rice producer in Asia and so the
rice sector would face stiff competition from lower-priced imports if trade is fully
liberalized. Price stability – especially avoiding the extremes of low and high
prices – will remain the primary goal and this implies that trade policy will continue
to be used for price stabilization as in the recent years.
7.5
Agricultural Trade Engagement of Countries Within
the South Asian Region
ASEAN Secretariat (2011a) has estimated that economies in Asia and Pacific would
lose 1.5 % point of GDP growths cumulative over 2011 and 2012 due to higher fuel
and food prices as compared to 2010. ASEAN Secretariat (2011b) has also estimated that additional 19.4 million people in the region remained in poverty due to
increased food and energy prices in 2010, and people in some South Asian countries
were amongst the most affected. The learning from this precarious situation
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
123
Fig. 7.3 Map shows sourcing of different commodities in South Asia region (Source: FAOSTAT
accessed April 2014)
member states have signed “Agreement on Establishing the SAARC Food Bank” in
New Delhi on April 3, 2007 by the member states. The top ten exports and imports
of each country are identified and the share of South Asian countries in the total
exports and imports is computed. It can be seen from Fig. 7.3 that Nepal, Sri Lanka,
Pakistan and Bangladesh source their imports from their South Asian neighbors
whereas on the side of exports, it is again Nepal, Pakistan and Bangladesh that
export most to the countries in the region. India’s engagement, in terms of percentage share of other South Asian countries, is low although in absolute terms it could
be much higher than other countries. It needs to be noted that India is the major
trading partner for almost all the countries on the import side and for most of the
countries on the export side.
The global food crisis 2007–2008 sheds light on the discrepancies between
SAARC’s supposed objective of becoming an integrated economic community and
its member countries’ continued tendency to put national economic interests above
regional solidarity. At regional scale India contributes most in cereal production and
export. However, to a large extent, the way in the crisis was handled at the national
level not only contributed to further regional as well as global food price volatility,
but also undermined the food security situation in the region. Despite being ready to
pay high price Bangladesh could not get rice to purchase during these critical days
of 2007–2008 despite repeated attempts to pay as much as market demands. In this
section, the trade engagement of a country with other South Asian neighbors is
assessed. The Table 7.1 illustrates the export import scenarios in south-Asian region.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
124
Md.A. Syed
Table 7.1 Exports and imports in South Asian region
Exports and imports in South Asian region
Imports
No of products with share
(out of top 10 products)
25– 50–
Country
<25 % 50 % 75 % >75 %
Bangladesh 6
1
1
2
India
10
Exports
Major trading partners
No. of products with share
(out of top 10 products)
Imports Exports
25– 50–
<25 % 50 % 75 % >75 %
7
1
2
India
India
9
1
Bangladesh,
Pakistan
9
1
–
Afghanistan
8
1
1
Maldives
7
2
1
Nepal
4
2
4
2
8
India
India
Pakistan
6
2
2
4
2
4
India
Afghanistan
Sri Lanka 5
2
3
8
1
1
India
India
Sources: Author’s calculations based on data from FAOSTAT, (Food and Agricultural Organisation
(FAO), Rome
In India, the share of imports from other countries in South Asia is very low.
However, the share of exports to South Asia is high in dry onions (58 %), cotton
(24 %), maize (21 %), rice (19 %), soybean cake (16 %) and tea (14 %). In Pakistan,
the share of imports from South Asia is high in onions (100 % – India 73 %,
Afghanistan 24 %, 3 %), soybean cake (99 % – India), chick peas (31 % India
23 %, 7 %), cotton lint (28 % – India 26 %) and tea (12 % – India 5 %, Bangladesh
4 %, Sri Lanka %). The share of exports to South Asia is high in hydrogenated
oil (99 % – Afghanistan), potatoes (97 % – Sri Lanka 37 %, 33 %, Afghanistan
27 %), wheat (89 % – Afghanistan 34 %, India 33 %, Bangladesh 19 %), dates
(88 % – India 86 %), cotton lint (40 % – Bangladesh 36 %, India 5 %), rice broken
(36 % – Afghanistan 25 %, 8 %) and rice miled (17–10 %, Afghanistan 5 %).
In Bangladesh, the share of imports from South Asia is high in soybean cake
(99 % – India), dry onions (100 % – India), maize (73 % – India), lentils (38 % –
India), cotton (21 % – India and Pakistan). The share of exports to South Asia is
high in tea (82–71 %, Afghanistan 11 %), nuts (76 % – India), jute (61 % – Pakistan
36 %, India 25 %), cotton waste (17 % – India).
In Sri Lanka, the share of imports from South Asia is high in onions (100 % –
India 94 %, Pakistan 6 %), chilies and peppers (97 % – India 96 %), soybean cake
(84 % – India), sugar refined (32 % – India), fatty acids (30 % – India) and lentils
(16 % – India 11 %, Nepal 5 %). The share of exports to South Asia is high in food
wastes (100 % – India 97 %) and nut dry (36 % – India 18 %, Pakistan 17 %). In
Nepal, the share of imports from South Asia is high in soybean cake (100 % –
India), jute (100 % – India), tobacco unmanufactured (100 % – India), rice milled
(81 % – India), food prep nes (40 % – India), rapeseed (29 % – India) and fatty acids
(17 % – India). The share of exports to South Asia is high in ginger (100 % – India),
nutmeg, mace and cardamoms (100 % – India), nuts (100 % – India), orange juice
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
125
(100 % – India), food prep nes (99 % – India), fruit juice nes (100 % – India), wheat
(96 % Bangladesh), tea (95 % – India), macaroni (74 % – India 70 %, Bhutan 4 %)
and lentils (65 % – Bangladesh). In Maldives, the share of imports from South Asia
is high in rice milled (89 % – India 65 %, Pakistan 20 %, Sri Lanka 4 %), wheat
flour (56 % – India 45 %, Sri Lanka 11 %). In, the share of imports from South Asia
is high in tea (86 % – Sri Lanka 57 %, India 29 %) and rice milled (38 % – Pakistan).
The share of exports to South Asia is high in apple juice (74 % – Afghanistan), fruit
juice (24 % – Afghanistan), dates (20 % – Pakistan 13 %, India 4 %, Afghanistan
3 %) and soybean oil (15 % – Afghanistan).
7.6
Regional Market Integration
South Asian countries share only 5 % their trade intra-regionally whereas this is
58 % in the EU, 52 % in the NAFTA region, and 26 % in the ASEAN zone (ASEAN
Secretariat 2011a, b). Non-tariff barriers to trade (NTBs) are primarily thought to be
the main obstacles in enhancing trades among SAARC countries. The also mentioned that complete elimination of tariffs under the South Asian Free Trade
Agreement (SAFTA) may increase intra-regional trade by 1.6 times. In the name
protecting other than tariffs different non-tariff barriers those affect free flow of
trade, come under the NTB umbrella. While protection is to an extent appropriate
given domestic economic priorities, including poverty reduction, South Asian trade
is hampered by excessive non-tariff barriers to trade. A large proportion of NTBs in
South Asia consist of technical barriers to trade and sanitary and phytosanitary
measures. The first are to do with labelling requirements, while the second are
regulations to ensure food security and prevent spreading of diseases. According
to a 2008 Asian Development Bank study, these and related measures made up
86.3 % of all NTBs in the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation
(SAARC) countries.
Inadequate infrastructure is one of the major NTBs borders between India and
Bangladesh especially for food grains. Different kinds of NTBs exist between
SAARC member states at all levels. For instance, if the existing border infrastructure
between Bangladesh and India’s Northeast is upgraded, trade volume can potentially go up by five to six times the current level. Short-term measures like setting
up markets (border haats) along the Indo-Bangladesh border as planned will boost
trade, though only to a certain extent and at the local level.
Trading on agriculture and agro based products is a sticking point in SAARC
region as we see it else where. Ad-hoc export prohibitions on agricultural goods are
put in place from time to time on top of export subsidies. For instance, Bangladesh
maintained a ban on the export of aromatic rice until recently and August 2014
Bangladesh decided for first ever export non aromatic rice to Sri Lanka thanks to
good production in last season and good stock of this staple food. Though it seems
difficult to remove agricultural NTBsin South Asia by not affecting the vast farming
population dependent on agriculture is a political imperative. NTBs can affect a
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
126
Md.A. Syed
range of other sectors. For instance, pharmaceutical trade between India and
Bangladesh is hampered as India has strict registration and packaging requirements,
customs clearances, and so on. Likewise, Sri Lankan processed food exporters to
India face non-tariff barriers under the Indo-Sri Lanka FTA because of customs
delays arising from testing and certifications.
Procedural issues linking code mismatches trade items on the positive list
between India and Pakistan is one of avoidable barriers which can be avoided by
harmonizing customs norms and standards. Easing transportation difficulties, especially for trade between India and Bangladesh and between India and Pakistan, is
important too. Access to third countries India or else or import/export ports particularly for Bangladesh to Bhutan and Nepal can bolster trade among three countries
while not affecting Indian trade regime negatively. India has list of goods those
cannot be traded through a particular land port or if there is no list some time periodical notices are issued. So that some particular products imports from Bangladesh
can be discouraged or controlled if not totally stopped. Pakistan also has a list of
goods that cannot be traded through a particular route (land or rail) for reasons that
are not known to the trading community. Improving transport and communication,
warehousing infrastructures along trading routes whether it is rail, road or water
were agreed upon by SAARC countries can be expedited for enhanced trading
among regional countries. The way forward for SAARC with respect to NTBs
should also include things like memoranda of understanding between custom
authorities, and providing seamless transit facilities.
7.7
Climate Change, Regional Trades and Food Security
Food security depends on robust food systems that encompass issues of availability,
access and utilization (not merely production alone), and the nature of trade, food
availability for consumption at household or individual level which again depends
on market price and accessibility or capacity to purchase and utilize food security
(schematically shown in Fig. 7.4). Climate change and increasing global food prices
have accentuated and complicated ascertaining whether there will be enough food
in the future to feed a growing world population. The Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change (IPCC) Fifth Assessment Report identified food insecurity as one
of the key risks of climate change, potentially affecting all aspects of food security
(ICIMOD 2014). Climate induced disasters (e.g., floods, droughts, cyclone, coastal
surges and storms) are among the main drivers of food insecurity. However, global
and regional market dynamics are very sensitive to climate induced extreme events
which really govern regional and global food prices (Fig. 7.5).
Food security issue is a fact of life for most of poor South Asian population
where the climate already experiencing changes and most people have access to
agricultural land, farming is carried out on small parcels of land excepts few cases
in India and Pakistan (Wickramasinghe 2009). South Asia reported to be one of the
most affected by climate induced extreme events like floods and droughts are
projected to impact food security in the region. The effects of climate change are
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
Cropping
systems
Crop stand
127
Food
systems
Farming
systems
Crop productivity
Crop production
Food trade
Climate change affects crop yields
Food security
Trade, supply, affordability and access
define food security
Fig. 7.4 Schematic diagram shows framework of food security issues and linkages among crop
production, climate change and regional trades
Availability
Resources
Production
Natural
Physical
Human
Food production
Imports
Market integration
External and
internal
Climate induced
risks
Degraded natural
resource base
Productive
environment lost
Loss of productive
assets
Access
Income
Purchasing power
Social safety nets
Food subsidies
Food-for-work
Community support
Market and
entitlement risks
Economic shocks
Deteriorating terms
of trade
Collapse of safety nets
Price hikes
Utilization
Consumption
Household level
distribution
Dietary practices
Nutrition
knowledge
Supplementary feeding
Absorption
Health
Sanitation
Safe water
Food quality
Nutrition and
health risks
Epidemics
Erosion of social
services
Fig. 7.5 Schematic diagram shows climate change may impact regional trade and food security
through its various components of a more complex system (Source: Adopted from FAO 2008)
compounded here due to particular socio-economic scenarios of South Asia: high
levels of poverty and high proportions of undernourished people, high dependence
on local agricultural productivity and depleted and poorly managed natural
resources, vulnerable supply lines and complicated logistics to external markets,
and poor infrastructure. Nearly one fifth (17.6 %) South Asian population remains
undernourished (FAO 2012). Ensuring food availability, regardless of whether the
concern is about households or localities, would require a combination of three
things: production, trade and assistance.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
128
7.8
Md.A. Syed
Domestic Market Integration in the Countries
of South Asia
The issue of agricultural market integration is central to many contemporary debates
on trade liberalization and price policy in the developing countries. One of the main
arguments against agricultural trade liberalization is that the markets in these
countries are not sufficiently integrated. Although there have been advances in
the methodology of market integration analysis, majority of the earlier studies in the
developing countries have used less-advanced methods like the bivariate correlation
coefficients or methods that remove the common integrating factor from the analysis such as co-integration. The present exercise attempts to address this shortcoming
by using a methodology that retains the common integrating factor (if any) and
analyzes the extent (number of markets integrated) of integration among major
markets for most of the important commodities in a country. The main objective of
the study is to assess the potential role of market in mitigating adverse effects of
supply shocks in the South Asian countries.
At the conceptual level, there are essentially two strands of thought in market
integration literature. In the first, mainly in the macroeconomics and international
economics literature, market integration implies tradability i.e. transfers of excess
demand from one market to another through actual or potential physical flows.
Positive trade flows are sufficient to demonstrate that markets are integrated and
prices need not equilibrate across markets. It is clear that this concept implies a
Pareto inefficient distribution (Barrett 2001). For this reason, we have adopted the
Enke-Samuelson-Takayama-Judge (ESTJ) spatial equilibrium model (Enke 1951;
Samuelson 1995; Takayama and Judge 1971) as the theoretical framework in this
exercise. In this framework, the dispersion of price in two locations for an otherwise
identical good is bound from the above by cost of arbitrage when trade is unrestricted and, from below when trade quotas exist.
We have used the Gonzalo-Granger (G-G) model to econometrically assess the
extent of market integration. The technical details of the method are provided in
the appendix at the end. To follow the analysis and discussion of the results,
understanding the technical details is not necessary. In this model, a market is said
to be integrated if there exists a single common factor (single linear combination
of a subset of prices). This implies that if n markets are integrated there are n-1
co-integrating vectors. The empirical estimation of the model is also relatively
simple. We can estimate the standard VECM model and then use those estimates to
determine the number of common factors and also identify the specific markets
influencing price formation (Gonzalez and Helfand 2001; Gonzalo and Granger
1995). For details see Gonzalo and Granger 1995; Gonzalez-Riviera and Helfand
2001 or Sekhar 2012). Standard VECM model of prices for each commodity has
been estimated after controlling for general movements in prices and seasonality of
agricultural prices.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
7.9
7.9.1
129
Recommendations
Regional Cooperation and Integration
Alleviation of poverty and attaining food security are important policy objectives of
all the countries in the region. The paths followed in achieving these objectives are
also broadly similar across countries, making it possible to identify areas of possible
collaboration. The geographical proximity can also be a facilitating factor in such
coordination. The promising areas of collaborative action, from the point of food
security, are the following:
• Collaborative agricultural research particularly on cereals, pulses and edible
oilseeds
• Coordination in devising pricing and trade policies to reap benefits of gains from
trade (Johnson 1975).
• Establishing common physical reserves for emergency relief and virtual reserves
to ward off speculative attacks in commodity markets
• Coordination and collaboration on improving health outcomes–IMR, CMR and
undernourishment
• Learning from success stories from other countries
• Instituting Early Warning Systems on natural calamities
• Judicious use of river waters
7.9.2
Collaborative Agricultural Research
Our results show that the region does not possess adequate surplus particularly in
wheat, edible oils and pulses. The production and productivity trends in the medium
term (2001–2011) are not encouraging vis-à-vis consumption. Therefore, it is
extremely important for these countries to rapidly increase domestic production.
As the scope for area increases is limited (Fig. 1.2a), the production increases
have to come through improvements in yield. The countries’ research systems need
to collaborate to develop appropriate technology for the region. The National
Agricultural Research Systems (NARS) in some of these countries, such as India,
Pakistan and Sri Lanka are fairly well developed. The cropping patterns in these
countries are dominated by rice and wheat for which generic research would be useful. The contiguous regions on two sides of the border between India, Pakistan and
Bangladesh have similar agro-climatic-ecological conditions and collaborative
efforts on crops and practices appropriate for these regions can benefit all the countries. Also, some of the countries in the region, such as India, have made significant
advances in biotechnology, tissue culture, plant genetics etc. Other countries in the
region can benefit from these advances.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
130
7.9.3
Md.A. Syed
Address Knowledge Gaps
There is still huge dearth understanding and knowledge about food production
systems, their efficiency, resilience, and capacity to support ever growing population
of South Asia. Policies and actions intended to improve food security in the region
need to be based on correct information about the food systems in the region.
There is currently a lack of adequate information about the basic elements of food
security – availability, access, use, and stability– in the region. A comprehensive
database on status and trends in order to prioritize areas, communities, and actions
efficiently will be of great help in this regard.
7.9.4
Attracting Youth in Farming
Almost 50 % of South Asian population is youth or below age. The demographic
changes in the region shows that the farming population is already dominated by
elders and fewer young people are engaged in traditional family farming. Different
incentives, insurance, training along with some resource support and market linking
programs for sustainable and climate-smart farming will encourage young people to
maintain and develop family or small farming systems which in future can be the
pillars in future sustainable food production for the region.
7.9.5
Coordination in Price and Trade Policies
Our results show that domestic market integration is low in most of the countries,
particularly in rice and wheat markets. There is a need to liberalize the domestic
trade policy framework and improve transport infrastructure to ensure better integration of domestic markets in each country, which is a prerequisite for external
(border) liberalization. Also, major countries like India, whose trade engagement
with other South Asian neighbors is low at present, need to engage in more agricultural trade within the region. The borders between India, Bangladesh and Nepal are
porous and therefore any effort to isolate the agricultural economies of these countries will only lead to distortions. These countries cannot pursue input or output
price policies disregarding their implications across borders. A mechanism for regular consultation on price policies may needs to be devised. As for trade policy, these
countries can mutually benefit by promoting preferential trade.
7.9.6
Establishing a Common Buffer Stock
Research has shown that stocks have a crucial bearing on prices in the short run
(Sekhar 2012). The SAARC Food Bank established as follow up of the decision of
14th SAARC Summit held in New Delhi in 2007 would supplement national efforts
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
131
to provide food security to the people of the region. As per this agreement, SAARC
Food Bank shall have a reserve of food grains to be maintained by each member
state consisting of either wheat or rice, or a combination of both as assessed share
of the country. Initially the stocks held under the Food Bank were 243,000 tons.
India has been making the highest contribution to the food bank with 153,200 tons
(62 % of the total reserve) whereas Pakistan and Bangladesh are contributing 40,000
tons each (17 % each). Nepal and Sri Lanka contribute 4,000 tons each (2 %),
followed by Afghanistan with 1,420 tons (0.6 %), Bhutan and the Maldives with
180 tons each (less than 0.1 %). Keeping in view the rising population and threat of
natural disasters, SAARC countries have agreed to double the food reserve in
SAARC Food Bank. The third meeting of the SAARC Food Board decided to
increase existing stock of 243,000–486,000 tons across the SAARC region. India’s
share of quantum of reserves has correspondingly been doubled from the existing
1,53,200–3,06,400 MTs.
However, it needs to be noted here that despite several attempts in different parts
of the world to institute regional food security programs, only few have been successful. The ASEAN Emergency Food Reserves arrangement is relatively successful but this success can be ascribed to two important conditions: increasing political
cohesion and economic coordination among the member countries; and much
greater complementarity in the food economy of ASEAN. There is a major food
surplus country (Thailand) and a major food importing country (Malaysia). These
conditions provide a strong ground for regional cooperation (Vyas 1990). In South
Asia both these conditions are more or less absent. In the absence of any country
with adequate food surpluses in the region, such an arrangement may be difficult to
sustain. A second problem is the paucity of resources for grains procurement and
storage. Notwithstanding these obstacles, attempts need to be made to develop
regional reserves. There is increasing evidence that speculative attacks were also
partly responsible for the food crisis witnessed in 2008. To avert such attacks, South
Asia may also evolve a mechanism of information sharing on market situation and
also a small fund to serve as virtual reserves to avert such attacks (IFPRI 2008).
7.9.7
Collaboration in Improving Health Status
As our foregoing analysis has shown, the health and food consumption indicators in
the South Asian region are way below the world average and are only marginally
better than the Sub-Saharan Africa region. There is an urgent need to improve these
outcomes. Even within the region, there is a lot of heterogeneity with countries like
Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Maldives showing much faster improvement than other
large countries like India and Pakistan. A collaborative effort is needed to improve the
health status, which along with its intrinsic importance, is also important for better
absorption of the food consumed. India and Pakistan may benefit by exploring the
possibility of replicating some of the successful practices followed in countries like
Sri Lanka and Bangladesh.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
132
7.9.8
Md.A. Syed
Early Warning Systems
South Asia shares many trans-boundary river basins with experiences of common
flood, droughts and flash flood. This trans boundary nature of this disaster needs
have influences in regional trades and commerce (Samuelson 1995). A regional data
sharing on natural disasters and climate induced events would help in an early warning
system based on regional needs. This can help in managing it regionally as well.
7.9.9
River Water Utilization
Efficient and sustainable use of natural resources is of paramount importance in this
resource-poor region. Proper and judicious use of river waters is the most important
in this context. Major rivers in the region flow across national borders. The countries in the region – whether located at the head reach or tail end of the river, should
be able to make the best use of these waters, which is possible only if the countries
can work collaboratively on this important issue. There are some encouraging
examples, such as, the Indo-Pak treaty on the Sindh river system and agreement on
use of Ganga waters at Farraka, which can be emulated. There should be regular
consultation and exchange of information among the water regulatory bodies of
different countries.
7.10
Conclusions
The economies of the region are predominantly driven by agriculture and still agriculture in major employer. The prospects for increasing agricultural production
through area expansion are bleak in these countries. The percentage of area under
cultivation is almost stagnant during the last two decades showing lack of scope for
area expansion. The declining investment in agriculture, particularly the public
investment, is reflected in almost stagnant percentage of area under irrigation.
Presently export surplus exists in the region only for rice and to a limited extent
for sugar. In wheat, corn, edible oils (except soybean oil) and pulses most of the
countries in the region are facing deficits and very few countries in the region show
export surplus present or potential. India and Pakistan are either just self-sufficient
or possess slight export surplus in most commodities. Nepal, Maldives, Bhutan and
Afghanistan are facing deficits and rely on imports for most of the important commodities. Bangladesh shows encouraging trends in commodities such as rice, potato
and similarly Sri Lanka intea. Pakistan, Nepal and Bangladesh export the most to
other South Asian countries. On the side of imports also, these three countries along
with Sri Lanka source their imports from within the region. India’s engagement, in
terms of other countries’ share in India’s imports or exports, appears very low as
compared to Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh or Sri Lanka. Results of market integration
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
7
Regional Analysis, Import-Export and Related Issues on Food Security
133
show that integration of important cereal markets– rice and wheat is a cause for
concern in most of the countries. Relatively, the rice markets (retail) are betterintegrated as compared to wheat markets.
The per capita food availability is almost stagnant in the region as the growth rate
of food production is just equal to that of the population growth. The levels of
undernourishment are much higher and the consumption of calories, protein and fat
in the region are much lower than the world average and only marginally better than
the Sub-Saharan Africa. The growth rate of consumption is much below compared
to Sub-Saharan Africa for calories and proteins, which is a cause for concern. India
and Pakistan have shown poor performance in reducing infant mortality rate (IMR),
child mortality rate (CMR) and increasing life expectancy, which is a cause for
concern. Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Maldives and have in general performed better in
terms of health indicators. As regards poverty, one worrying feature is that the rate of
decline in India is relatively much slower compared to other countries in the region.
Given the current and potential supply-demand scenario of food commodities,
extent of market integration, levels of poverty and health status in the countries
of the region, the following are the potential areas of collaboration in the region
from the point of food security. Collaborative agricultural research particularly on
cereals, pulses and edible oilseeds to increase production in the region coordination
in devising pricing and trade policies to reap benefits of gains from trade are needed.
Collaboration on improving regional connectivity and transport and other infrastructure to enhance domestic and regional market integration is of utmost importance. Further cooperation and constant consultation and data sharing on common
physical reserves for emergency relief and virtual reserves would help in ward off
speculative attacks in commodity markets. Instituting Early Warning Systems on
natural calamities and food shortage in the region is an imperative.
References
ASEAN Secretariat (2011a) ASEAN Integrated Food Security (AIFS) framework and strategic
plan of action on food security in the ASEAN region (SPA-FS) 2009–2013. Available at http://
www.aseansec.org/22338.pdf. Accessed 20 Feb 2014
ASEAN Secretariat (2011b) The roundtable meeting on strengthening ASEAN food security
information: rice information, 25 October 2011, Bangkok, Thailand
Bandara J, Jayasuriya S (2009) Sri Lanka. In: Anderson K, Martin W (eds) Distortions to agricultural incentives in Asia. The World Bank, Washington, DC
Barrett C (2001) Measuring integration and efficiency in international agricultural markets.
Rev Agric Econ 23:19–32
Dayaratna-Banda OG, Jayawickrama JMA, Ranathilaka MB (2008) Sense and nonsense of rice
price controls in Sri Lanka. Paper prepared for the Pathfinder Foundation, Colombo
Enke S (1951) Equilibrium among spatially separated markets: solution by electrical analogue.
Econometrica 19:40–47
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) (2008) Regional strategies and programme for food
security in the SAARC member states. Final report, August. Prepared by Food and Agriculture
Organization of the United Nations in collaboration with South Asian Association for Regional
Cooperation (SAARC), Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO),
Rome, Italy
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Md.A. Syed
134
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) (2011) Articulating and mainstreaming agricultural
trade policy and support measures. In: Sharma R, Morrison J (eds) Trade and markets division.
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), Rome
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) (2012) The state of food insecurity in the world undernourishment around the world in 2012. FAO, Rome
Gonzalez-Riviera G, Helfand SM (2001) The extent, pattern and degree of market integration: a
multivariate approach for the Brazilian rice market. Am J Agric Econ 83(3):576–592
Gonzalo J, Granger CWJ (1995) Estimation of common long memory components in cointegrated
systems. J Bus Econ Stat 13(1):27–35
ICIMOD (2014) The last straw, food security in the Hindu Kush Himalayas and the additional
burden of climate change. International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development
(ICIMOD), Kathmandu
IFPRI (2008) Physical and virtual global food reserves to protect the poor and prevent market
failure, Joachim von Braun and Maximo Torero, IFPRI Policy Brief 4, June 2008
Johnson, D. Gale 1975. World Agriculture, Commodity Policy, and Price Variability, American
Journal of Agricultural Economics, 57, December 1975, pp 823–28
Samuelson, P. 1995.Spatial price equilibrium and linear programming’, American Economic
Review, 42, 283–303
Sekhar, C.S.C. 2012.Agricultural Market Integration in India: An Analysis of Select Commodities,
Food Policy (Elsevier), Volume 37, Issue 3, June 2012, pp. 309–3220
Takayama T, Judge G (1971) Spatial and temporal price allocation models. North-Holland,
Amsterdam
Vyas VS (1990) Food policies and food security in Asia, with particular reference to South Asia.
In: Tyagi DS, Vyas VS (eds) Increasing access to food – the Asian experiences. Sage,
New Delhi
Wickramasinghe U (2009) Trade insight, Food Security Agenda for South Asia, Causes and
pathways out of food insecurity in South Asia 5(1):6–9
World Development Report (WDR)-Gender Equality and Development (2012) The international
bank for reconstruction and development. The World Bank, Washington, DC.
doi:10.1596/978-0-8213-8810-5
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions
of Food Security
Fazle Rabbi Sadeque Ahmed
Abstract Bangladesh Government initiated a consultative process of food security
policy reform since the World Food Summit of 1996. Through this initiative the
Government made a comprehensive food security policy framework such as
National Food Policy and programming document called National Food Policy Plan
of Action as well as an investment plan for food security known as Bangladesh
Country Investment Plan. Several institutions in Bangladesh are involved with food
security governance. To reflect the multidimensional nature of food security, various sectors and disciplines (ministries/department) are represented in these institutions. Four main bodies such as Food Planning and Monitoring Committee, Food
Policy Working Group, Food Planning and Monitoring Unit, Thematic Teams are
charged with formulating and implementing food security policies, in particular the
National Food Policy and its associated Plan of Action. There is lot of success due
to policy issues of food in Bangladesh, however, more specific policy issues need to
be incorporated in the design of the different policy documents such as an enabling
policy for fostering education both at a higher level for research purposes and a
professional level for extension workers. In addition, there should be easy access on
land, water resources and credit facilities for small and marginal farmers. Moreover,
the need for a more effective and better governed regulatory and quality control of
inputs to protect smallholders and enable them to invest in improved techniques and
inputs. The need to improve the nutrition outcome safety nets, extension activities
and others are essential to optimize their impact to ensure the food security of the
country. The difficult enforcement of some existing regulations and rules should be
addressed through empowering and disseminating information to communities and
grass-root level actors. Coordination of food security including food production,
safety nets and nutrition will be a challenge, in particular as it has to be inclusive of
non-government sectors and development partners.
Keywords National Food Policy (NFP) • National Food Policy Plan of Action •
Country Investment Plan • Ministry of Food • Food Planning and Monitoring Unit
F.R.S. Ahmed (*)
Deputy Secretary, Ministry of Public Administration, Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: frsa1962@yahoo.co.uk
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_8
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
135
136
8.1
F.R.S. Ahmed
Introduction
The Government of Bangladesh considers agricultural development a major priority
for ensuring the food and nutrition security of the country. While Bangladesh has
experienced steady advances in food availability and security, including the tripling
of its annual rice production during the past several decades, by overcoming a number of persistent and emerging challenges (Ahmed et al. 2011). Future agricultural
growth and food and nutrition security are threatened by population growth, decreasing soil fertility and health, deteriorating access to limited and scarce natural
resources, increasing pest and disease infestation and persistent poverty leading to
poor access to food (Asaduzzaman et al. 2010). In addition, the impacts of climate
change such as increase in the incidence of natural disasters, salinity intrusion,
erratic behavior of rainfall and climatic events may exacerbate food and nutrition
insecurity in the coming decades (BCCSAP 2009).
Food plays a crucial role in the agro-based economy of Bangladesh, where a
large proportion of the income of the population is allocated to food. The first and
foremost responsibility of the State is to ensure an uninterrupted supply of food to
all people at all time. According to the Article-15(a) of the constitution of
Bangladesh, it shall be a fundamental responsibility of the State to secure its citizens to the provision of basic necessities of food. As per Government’s Allocation
of Business, it is the duty of ‘Ministry of Food’ to establish a dependable food
security system for the nation. The Government of Bangladesh is firmly committed
to achieve food security for all, defined at the 1996 World Food Summit as: access
by all people at all times to the food needed for an active and healthy life. This provision is also reflected in all the development plans including sixth five year plan of
the Government (Ahmed et al. 2010).
Bangladesh is also a signatory of GATT Uruguay Round Agreement in 1994 at
which, among other issues, agricultural trade liberalizations was agreed. Following
the recommendation of the Bangladesh Development Forum, the process of consolidating the country’s food security program at a larger scale was started in 2000
through a task force document entitled “A Comprehensive Food Security Policy for
Bangladesh”. Meanwhile a high priority was given to further strengthen and harmonize government’s efforts to ensure food security for all. It was achieved through
revisiting all existing related policies and strategies. The goal of the first national
food policy, which was adopted in 1988, was to achieve food security for all people
by increasing food production and attaining self-sufficiency. However, many important aspects of food security remained unattended in the food policy of 1988 which
was based on availability of food grain alone. The present food policy was developed in the light of the Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper and also in a broader
perspective according to the definition of food security as adopted in the World
Food Summit (NFP 2006).
The Government of Bangladesh, in accordance with the World Food Summit
Declaration of 1996 has set its target at reducing the number of poor people to half
by the year 2015. Achieving this target will require addressing all aspects of food
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security
137
security: (i) greater efficiency of domestic agriculture and enhanced availability of
food, (ii) assistance to attain increased food access by the food insecure, (iii) sustained increase in the incomes of the poor and the distressed to enhance their access
to food, (iv) adequate supply of safe food, and (v) appropriate programs to reduce
malnutrition through increased effectiveness and proper utilization of the consumed food. To ensure overall food security and to implement national food policy
2006, the Ministry of Food is implementing its own programs; in addition, it is
trying to ensure and extend all out support to all concerned ministries and agencies
in implementing their own food-security related strategies and programs such as
National Food Policy Plan of Action (2008–2015) and country investment plan for
agriculture, food security and nutrition in Bangladesh. In this way, government of
Bangladesh is trying to attain food security through a coordinated implementation
of the programs of all concerned ministries and agencies (NFP 2006).
8.2
Ministry of Food
Ministry of food is responsible for making all kinds of policy framework linked
with food security. Vision of the ministry is to ensure a dependable food security
system for all people of the country at all times and its mission is to ensure adequate
and stable supply of safe and nutritious food, enhance purchasing power of the
people for increased food accessibility. According to the ‘Allocation of Business’
the key functions of the ministry is formulation, review and execution of legislation,
policies, plans, procedures, standing orders and guidelines relating to overall food
system, food policy; Establishment of a dependable national food security system;
Procurement, storage and movement of food-grains etc. in order to maintain an
adequate public food grain stock for national food security as well as for distribution through Public Food Distribution System (PFDS) as price incentive for domestic production and price support for consumers; Inspection, analysis and maintenance
of quality and standards of food grains imported or exported by this Ministry;
Stabilization of the price of food-grains; Encourage food-grains trade in the private
sector; Recommend development of market infrastructure, such as storage, transportation handling and marketing facilities to encourage and support private sector
food grains trade; Maintaining database on food production, food availability, food
accessibility, consumption pattern, food stock and food reserve and establishing
inventory control and food management information system; Food planning
research and monitoring; Import and export of food stuff and civil supplies;
Administration of proposed Food Safety Act, 2013; Monitoring of food supply
positions in the country; Rationing; Construction and maintenance of food godowns;
Liaison with regional and international organizations, and matters related to treaties
and agreements with other countries and world bodies.
Since 2012, Ministry of Food has been working as an independent ministry
headed by a Minister. Secretary of the ministry is functioning as Principal accounting
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
F.R.S. Ahmed
138
Officer of the ministry and also official head of the Ministry. Ministry of Food is the
sole body to formulate and execute overall food policy management of Bangladesh.
Directorate General of Food is the only core department under Ministry of Food and
sole implementing body, working directly under guidance and supervision of the
ministry. Director General of Food is the head of the department (NFP 2006).
8.3
Food Security Policy and Planning Frameworks
Since the World Food Summit of 1996, the Government of Bangladesh has undertaken an in-depth and consultative process of food security policy reform. This has
provided the Government with a comprehensive food security policy framework
“the National Food Policy – 2006” and programming document “the National Food
Policy Plan of Action (2008–2015)” as well as an investment plan for food security
and nutrition “the Bangladesh Country Investment Plan”.
8.3.1
The National Food Policy, 2006 (NFP 2006)
The National Food Policy of 2006 is Bangladesh’s main policy document on food
security. It is a comprehensive and integrated approach to food security, including
the availability, access and utilization dimension of food security. The NFP framework is articulated around three core objectives/outcomes and 12 more specific
objectives/strategic lines of action. They are as follows Objective 1: Adequate and Stable Supply of Safe and Nutritious Food
• Efficient and sustainable increase in food production
• Efficient food markets
• Non-distortionary food grain market intervention for price stabilization
Objective 2: Increased Purchasing Power and Access to Food of the People
• Transitory shock management
• Effective implementation of targeted food assistance program
• Employment generating income growth
Objective 3: Adequate Nutrition for All Individuals, Especially
Women and Children
•
•
•
•
•
•
Long-term national plan for ensuring balanced food in building a healthy nation
Supply of sufficient nutritious food for vulnerable groups
Balanced diet containing adequate micronutrients
Safe drinking water and improved sanitation
Safe quality food supply
Adequate health status
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security
8.3.2
139
Focus and Design
The National Food Policy emphasizes the important linkages between availability,
access, and nutrition outcomes, in line with the definition of food security adopted
by the World Food Summit of 1996. It also recognizes that a combination of measures is needed to effectively reduce hunger and malnutrition, e.g. providing immediate access to food to the most vulnerable and promoting agricultural development
and income growth.
The Policy addresses food security issue in a comprehensive manner and to fill
the gaps of previous food and nutrition policy frameworks. The goal of the National
Food Policy is to ensure, in coordination with partner ministries, development partners and NGOs, dependable and sustained food security for all people of Bangladesh
at all times.
NFP, 2006 represents a follow-up to the National Food Policy of 1988, the goal
of which was to ensure food security for all people by increasing food production
and attaining self-sufficiency. The focus was therefore nearly exclusively on maintaining a balance between aggregate supply and total requirements, overlooking the
other key facets of food security. The National Food and Nutrition Policy formulated in 1997 by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare was a first attempt to
address this shortcoming by including food diversification, health and nutrition as
key areas of intervention for the national food security system.
8.3.3
Thrusts and Priorities of NFP
The NFP has been developed with special reference to the Bangladesh Poverty
Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP) titled “Unlocking the Potential: National Strategy
for Accelerated Poverty Reduction” (General Economics Division 2005), which
was adopted in 2005 as the main umbrella framework for guiding and coordinating
medium-term efforts towards reducing poverty and achieving the MDGs.
Food security is identified as a key goal under PRSP strategic block on “Critical
sectors for pro-poor economic growth”. Under this block, the PRSP also underscores strengthening and consolidating on-going nutrition and fortification efforts.
Nutrition concerns are addressed more comprehensively under the health sector
strategy. The PRSP also gives prominence to the issues related to food safety, food
quality, healthcare, and safe water and sanitation for all, with special emphasis on
children’s needs.
As regards food availability and access dimensions, the policy thrust of the PRSP
is on ensuring affordable food supply through efficiency gains in agricultural production, distribution and trade as well as enhancing the purchasing power of the
poor, through diversifying and expanding income opportunities at large. PRSP prioritizes technology development and the creation of an enabling environment for
private sector participation along with efforts to improve coverage and effectiveness
of social safety nets.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
140
F.R.S. Ahmed
Food price stabilization policies have been, nonetheless incorporated under
PRSP Food Security Policy Matrix 8, which provides a basic roadmap for improving security, along the strategic lines defined in the Comprehensive Food Security
Report (July 2000). This includes creating an enabling framework for food security,
assuring low cost food supply, smoothing fluctuations in food consumption, increasing purchasing power and entitlement of the poor, ensuring better food utilization
and more nutritious food for all, particularly the poor.
In the long run, the NFP underscores:
(i) Linking agricultural productivity and diversification with improvements of
nutritional standards through a three-pronged approach: raising productivity
and efficiency of production for major cereals, diversifying into non-cereal
crops, including pulses, oilseeds and higher value horticultural crops such as
fruits, vegetables, spices as well as expanding fishery, livestock and poultry
production.
(ii) Improving productivity of smallholder agriculture, especially through enhancing access of small and marginal farmers to improved, demand-driven extension services, as well as irrigation, credit, and modern inputs.
(iii) Promoting sustainable agriculture practices with focus on expanding
Integrated Pest Management, use of bio-fertilizers, water conservation, soil
and water testing, greater use of surface water along with technological development to minimize salinity.
(iv) Promoting efficient food markets with focus on physical infrastructure development, marketing infrastructure; and the creation of an enabling regulatory
environment.
(v) Promoting non-farm activities that exhibit strong “agricultural linkages”, i.e.
agro-based/agro-processing industries.
(vi) Expanding income generating opportunities for women/female-headed
households and the disabled in agricultural activities as well as in rural
micro and small enterprise development, through enhancing their access to
productive assets.
(vii) Fostering skill and human development with focus on employability (marketdriven skill development)
(viii) Addressing instability inherent to agricultural and other rural activities
through strengthening disaster preparedness, improving early warning/monitoring systems for effective food planning, stock and trade management as
well as introducing risk management tools for small farmers and rural
micro-entrepreneurs.
(ix) Managing food price instability to preserve poor farmers’ incentives and the
purchasing power of poor consumers. Whilst underscoring the role for the
private sector in food security efforts, the NFP provides for timely price stabilization interventions and consumer price support along with an adequate
management of private food imports.
(x) Addressing immediate food security needs among all vulnerable groups and
areas by improving the targeting, coverage and effectiveness of food based
and non-food based targeted programs and other safety nets.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security
141
NFP also emphasizes:
(xi) Reducing malnutrition through integrated and multi-sectoral set of general
and targeted interventions, geared towards raising consumption of nutrientrich foods especially among vulnerable groups, promoting positive food habits
and appropriate food behaviour, promoting and protecting breast feeding,
improving infant and young child feeding practices and health, improving food
safety and hygiene, sanitation, improving access to safe drinking water as well
as addressing the threat of arsenic contamination of underground water and
improving overall access and coverage of women and children to sanitation
and health facilities. Acknowledging that women’s lack of knowledge about
right nutrition and child care strongly correlates with their educational levels,
the NFP also emphasizes strategies to support maternal education and literacy
as of paramount importance to ensuring good nutrition (FPMU 2008).
8.3.4
The NFP and the Millennium Development Goals
(MDGs)
Bangladesh has made remarkable progress towards reaching the Millennium
Development Goals (MDGs) by 2015, with indicators showing that Bangladesh is
“on track” to reach 100 % enrolment rates and gender equality in primary and secondary education and in significantly reducing child and maternal mortality.
Evidence suggests that food security and nutritional well being improves human
potential, and reduces poverty by boosting productivity throughout the life cycle
and across generations. Thus, the NFP agenda on sustainable and pro-poor agricultural and rural development, food diversification, women and vulnerable groups’
empowerment, skill development, sanitation, health and nutrition, is forcefully supportive of the overarching Millennium Development Goal on poverty and food
security (MDG1), and will clearly underlie progress towards many other Millennium
Development Goals.
In particular, efforts to improve smallholder agricultural productivity, strengthen
agricultural linkages within the rural economy will have direct impacts on the
incomes of the rural poor, whilst increased and more diversified food production
shall contribute to better diets and improvements of nutritional outcomes. The NFP
agenda on enhancing rural women’s participation in agricultural activities, promoting women’s entrepreneurship, is fully aligned with MDG3 (Promote gender
equality and empower women). Meanwhile, women and children represent the
key target groups of the overall NFP policy agenda on nutrition and utilization of
food, which, coupled to food diversification and income-generation efforts, will be
clearly instrumental for improving maternal health (MDG5), and reducing child
mortality (MDG4). Poor nutrition is implicated in more than half of all child deaths
worldwide and is intimately linked with poor health and environmental factors.
Targeting nutrition improvement actions for children particularly in the first year of
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
F.R.S. Ahmed
142
life is strategically important because malnutrition in infancy is the genesis of malnutrition in pre-school age and is also directly or indirectly associated with most
child deaths.
Also, efforts to enhance aggregate food supply and access coupled to more specific measures for empowering women and households, improving maternal and
child health and nutrition, shall together contribute to improving the chances that a
child will go to school, stay in school and perform, thereby supporting progress
towards MDG2 (Achieve universal primary education).
Finally, in line with MDG7 (Ensure environmental sustainability), environmental sustainability has been effectively mainstreamed into the NFP agricultural
policy agenda for enhancing food supply and also biodiversity (http://www.nfpcsp.
org/agridrupal/national-food-policy).
8.4
The National Food Policy Plan of Action (2008–2015)
To provide programmatic guidance in implementing the National Food Policy, the
Government formulated the National Food Policy Plan of Action (PoA). The PoA
translates the provisions of the NFP towards achieving its three core objectives into
26 strategic areas of intervention and priority actions that cover all dimensions of
food security. The Plan, which is in line with the Millennium Development Goals,
for over the period of 2008–2015.
Apart from providing immediate access to food to the most vulnerable households through targeted cash and food transfers, the Plan also includes actions aimed
at developing production capacity, income generation and nutrition through investments and accompanying policy measures. That means the Plan of Action adopts
diversified approaches to hunger reduction. The Plan of Action is a dynamic document that is adjusted based on the results of monitoring activities, the experiences
gained in the process of its implementation as well as possible changes in the key
factors impacting on the development prospects of Bangladesh.
To facilitate implementation and monitoring, the Plan of Action also identifies
responsible actors from both government and non-government and suggests a set of
policy targets and indicators to monitor progress. The document provides a set of
guidelines regarding inter-ministerial coordination, sectoral planning and budgeting
and includes an outline of the strategy for monitoring progress. Special care was
given to align the PoA with Bangladesh’s overall development strategy, thus making
it a suitable instrument to align donors’ interventions with government priorities.
The Plan establishes collaborative relationships with other monitoring initiatives
and sources of information related to food security, especially those linked to the
PRSP, the Sixth Five-Year Plan and the MDGs.
In line with the log-frame approach, the action agenda set forth under the 26
strategic areas of intervention identified in the PoA is linked with specific policy
targets and performance indicators, as well as a set of assumptions regarding factors
that may affect implementation effectiveness. The PoA Matrix thereby provides the
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security
143
basic framework for implementing, coordinating and monitoring of the NFP. Under
the three objectives of NFP, PoA identified 26 areas of intervention (such as agricultural research and extension, use and management of water resources, supply and
sustainable use of agricultural inputs, agricultural diversification, agricultural credit
and insurance, physical market infrastructure development, agricultural marketing
and trade, policy/regulatory environment, early warning system development, producer prize support, public stock management/prize stabilization, agricultural disaster management, emergency food distribution for public stock, enabling environment
for private food trade and stock, effectiveness of targeted food security programs
and other safety nets, income generation for woman and the disabled, agro-based/
agro processing/MSMEs development, market driven education skills and human
development, long term planning for balanced food, balanced and nutritious food
for vulnerable people, nutrition education on dietary diversification, food supplementation and fortification, safe drinking water and improved sanitation, safe, quality food supply, woman and children health) and priorities of action and responsible
ministries.
The PoA underscores coordinating with fellow implementing partners and agencies from the Civil Society and the private Sector, as well as Development Partners.
In particular, it underscores the role of the Economic Relation Division of the
Ministry of Finance in promoting the effective implementation of the PoA, through
coordinating and ensuring linkages between PRSP-related external assistance and
PoA external assistance requirements.
The PoA document also underscores establishing effective linkages between the
PoA targets/action agenda and line ministries/agencies’ strategic plans and related
budgetary frameworks, as well as with central planning and budgetary processes
under the Annual Development Program and the Medium Term Budget Framework
(MTBF). It also recommends overseeing of the above process by the Planning
Commission of the Ministry of Planning and the Finance Division of the Ministry
of Finance.
8.4.1
Monitoring Strategy Outline
The institutional monitoring strategy outlined in the PoA provides for developing
and implementing monitoring plan towards PoA policy targets and outcomes,
including data gathering, data analysis, organization of stakeholder consultations,
delivery and dissemination of monitoring reports and other outputs. It also underscores establishing collaborative relationships with other food-security relevant
monitoring initiatives and/or sources of information, especially those relating to the
monitoring of the PRSP and the MDGs, including the National Poverty Focal Point
under the General Economics Division and the Implementation, Monitoring and
Evaluation Division of the Ministry of Planning, as well as the Bangladesh Bureau
of Statistics.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
144
F.R.S. Ahmed
The document underscores continuous political commitment towards food
security and poverty reduction, adequate implementation and coordination capacities, enabling macro-economic and fiscal framework, including domestic and
external resource mobilization, continuous progress on PRSP agenda for local
governance, as key assumptions underpinning the effective implementation of the
NFP and its PoA.
8.5
The Bangladesh Country Investment Plan (CIP)
In June 2010 the Government of Bangladesh released the Country Investment Plan
to support the implementation of the National Food Policy and its Plan of Action.
The Country Investment Plan covers a 5-year period, is anchored in the existing
national framework and benefits from the Government’s strong political support.
Specifically, its purpose is to plan and invest resources that address the three dimensions of food security in a coordinated way; increase the convergence of Government
investment and external funding in order to avoid gaps and redundancies; mobilize
additional funds, including from external sources; monitor, evaluate and if necessary remedy investments in agriculture, food security and nutrition. The updated
version of CIP was released on June 2011.
CIP is a country led planning, fund mobilization and alignment tool. It supports
increased, effective pubic investment to increase and diversify food availability in a
sustainable manner and improve access to food and nutrition security. Its interventions also aim to mobilize investment by smallholders other private sector food
security actors. It is a comprehensive plan that aims to ensure sustainable food security. The CIP anchored in the policy, programmatic and financial framework of
Bangladesh (i) it is the investment arm of the National Food Policy (NFP 2006) and
its Plan of Action (PoA 2008); (ii) it reflects the food security content of the sixth
five Year Plan; (iii) it is a strong advocacy financial tool for increased resource allocation from the budget and Development Partners. The CIP is a living document its
updated version was developed through a wide process of consultation including
government agencies, private sector, farmers, academics, civil society, NGOs and
Development Partners. This process led to refined more accurately costed and prioritized CIP investment areas, the establishment of a results framework, guiding
principles to be applied during implementation and the identification of policy
implications to enable optimal effectiveness of interventions. The CIP provides a
coherent set of 12 priority investment programs to improve food security and nutrition in an integrated way. The total cost of the CIP is estimated at US$ 7.8 billion.
Of this, US$ 2.8 billion are already financed through allocated GOB budget
resources and contributions by development Partners (DPs). The financing gap is
therefore US$ 5.1 billion of which US$ 3.4 billion has been identified as first priority requirements (Bangladesh Country Investment Plan 2011).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security
8.5.1
145
Purposes of the CIP
The CIP provides a strategic and coherent set of 12 priority investment programs to
improve food and nutrition security in an integrated way. The CIP builds on the
existing solid national food security policy and programmatic framework. The CIP
is comprehensive in that it addresses the three dimensions of food security – availability, access and nutrition – in an integrated way. It aims at linking these three
dimensions, in particular by shaping food availability proposals (mostly related to
agriculture) so that they enhance access and improve nutrition of the most food
insecure and malnourished. However, it limits its scope by building on past and ongoing investment operations and actions, identifying gaps and needs for scaling up
and extension, and incorporates the current national priorities expressed by various
stakeholders, including the Government agencies, civil society organizations,
NGOs, the private sector and Bangladeshi farmers themselves.
The CIP is expected to serve four purposes:
• To plan and invest resources in a coordinated way, addressing the three dimensions of food security through an integrated approach;
• To increase convergence of domestic and external sources of funding in support
of agriculture, food security and nutrition. This requires a progressive alignment
of external sources of funds (from bilateral and multilateral donors) behind a
single, inclusive (but evolving) investment plan in order to increase cohesion,
coordination and avoid gaps and redundancies;
• To mobilize additional resources from the Government of Bangladesh budget
and from external partners, and to monitor commitments, pledges, expenses and
remaining gaps;
• To monitor and evaluate investments in food security and prescribe remedial
measures to activities that requires strengthening (Bangladesh Country
Investment Plan 2011).
8.5.2
CIP Follows the Existing National Framework
The CIP relies on the existing Government framework in its three dimensions: (i)
policy/institutional; (ii) planning / programmatic; (iii) financial and resource mobilization. The CIP builds on the very solid existing policies, strategies and plans in
support of food security in Bangladesh. In particular, the CIP aims to support implementation of the National Food Policy (NFP 2006) through a set of investment
programs that reflect key gaps identified by the Government and other stakeholders,
and their priorities to achieve the goals of the NFP. In other words, the CIP is the
investment arm of the NFP PoA.
The NFP and CIP build on key sectoral policy documents, such as the National
Seed Policy, Flood Action Plan, National Extension Policy, National Water Policy
(1999), Food and Nutrition Policy (1997), National Plan of Action for Nutrition
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
F.R.S. Ahmed
146
(1997) the Livestock Sector Road Map (2006), the Fisheries Sector Road Map
(2006), and the National Disaster Management Plan (2007–2015). The NFP and
CIP are consistent with the Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy and Action
Plan (2009).
The institutional, coordination and monitoring framework of the CIP is embedded in the existing framework of the NFP PoA. Monitoring activities relied on the
monitoring system currently in place as part of the national planning process. The
CIP also draws upon: (i) the Vision 2021 and the associated Perspective Plan 2010–
2021 of the Government, which provides the long-term vision of the current
Government; (ii) the election manifesto of the Government and relevant constitutional provisions.
8.5.3
Programmatic/Planning Mechanisms
The CIP is aligned with the Sixth Five-Year Plan (FYP) (2011–2015), a key planning document of the Government. The FYP outlines priority development interventions for Bangladesh. It holds that “strong agriculture remains fundamental to
poverty reduction as well as food security.” There is also broad support for safety
nets that will ensure access to as well as The CIP also relies on the planning process
set up by the Government to plan annual investment expenses. The Annual
Development Program (ADP) was used to identify and cost investment areas and
programs. Further, the CIP was developed in close link with the Planning
Commission. Utilization of the enhanced availability resulting from strengthened
agriculture. The CIP approach is in line with the FYP’s holistic approach to food
security. Throughout the process of the FYP, inputs have been taken from the CIP in
order to ensure further coherence.
8.5.4
Finance and Resource Mobilization
The CIP draws from the National Strategy for Accelerated Poverty Reduction II
(December 2009). Additionally, the aim of the CIP is to be integrated in to the
Medium Term Budgetary Framework which reflects the investment priorities of the
Government of Bangladesh.
The first CIP-2010 was used as a tool to develop the Country Partnership
Framework (CPF) as a living mechanism for alignment of DPs with the Bangladeshi
priority requirements outlined in the CIP. The CPF, can now be used by the
Government to mobilize additional resources from the DP community. To date, 8
DPs have signed the CPF. Finally, the CIP was developed with the close involvement of the Ministry of Finance, including its finance division for budget resource
mobilization and the Economic Relations Division (ERD) in view of its central role
for resource mobilization with DPs.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security
8.5.5
147
Guiding Principles
The CIP guiding principles define how the Government of Bangladesh and the
stakeholders involved in the Bangladesh food system will work together to achieve
the CIP food and nutrition security outcomes by 2015. The guiding principles such
as Policy and institutional coherence, Comprehensiveness and nutrition agenda,
Inclusiveness and participation, Targeting and Gender Considerations, Particular
attention should be paid to the Southern part of Bangladesh, Innovation and scaling
up, Partnership, Sustainability, with a particular focus on the environment have
emerged from the CIP consultation process and have been incorporated during the
CIP design process. They shall be systematically applied in the implementation
stage.
8.5.6
CIP Programs
This Chapter highlights the main features of the 12 CIP programs. Programs 1–5
contribute to the food availability component. Programs 6–9 contribute to the food
access component. Programs 10–12 contribute to the food utilization component.
Table 8.1 summarizes the focused and priority interventions of the 12 CIP programs
(Bangladesh Country Investment Plan 2011).
8.6
Food Security Institutional Setup
Food security is governed by several institutions in Bangladesh. In order to reflect
the multidimensional nature of food security, various sectors and disciplines are
represented in these institutions, including agriculture, rural development, women
and children affairs, health, finance, commerce and disaster management.
Four main bodies are charged with formulating and implementing food security
policies, in particular the National Food Policy and its associated Plan of Action:
Food Planning and Monitoring Committee, a cabinet-level committee that provides overall leadership and oversight in the formulation of food security policies. The Food Planning and Monitoring Committee (FPMC) is a cabinet-level
committee headed by the Minister of Food. Drawing on the work of the Food
Planning and Monitoring Unit, it provides overall leadership and oversight in
the formulation of food security policies. Along with four other ministers minister of food is the chair of the committee, seven other secretaries are the members
of that committee and DG FPMU are the member secretary of that committee.
Food Policy Working Group, an inter-ministerial coordination mechanism that
facilitates cross-sectoral participation in the implementation of the National
Food Policy and its associated Plan of Action. The Food Policy Working Group
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
148
Table 8.1 Priority interventions of Bangladesh Country Investment Plan (CIP)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Program title
Sustainable and
diversified agriculture
through integrated
research and extension
2
Improved water
management and
infrastructure for
irrigation purposes
3
Improved quality of input
and soil fertility
4
Fisheries and aquaculture
development
5
Livestock development,
with a focus on poultry
and dairy production
Proposed focus and priority interventions
Enhance research and knowledge generation and adoption to increase agricultural productivity and
diversity in a sustainable manner
Improve extension services to propagate knowledge and practices, supported by community based
experiments and learning and indigenous knowledge
Promote the development of responses to adapt agricultural systems to climate change
Improve water management in water distribution systems and at farm level
Improve and increase efficiency of surface water irrigation, in particularly the south
Reduce impact of saline water intrusion in the south
Facilitate access to credit and other financial services by smallholders and the rural poor
Enhance availability of agricultural inputs, tested and certified for quality of diversified crops
Develop public private partnerships in support of infrastructure and services development
Improve and increase sustainability of soil fertility management
Facilitate access to credit and other financial services by smallholders and the rural poor
Develop small scale agriculture, through access to quality inputs, advice and skills
Improve management of fisheries resources
Develop public private partnerships in support of infrastructure and services development
Promote production in the South through sustainable shrimp and prawn development and community
based co management of wetlands
Strengthen animal health services, including better diagnosis and surveillance systems to mitigate
disease outbreaks
Strengthen husbandry capacity at household level through community based improved knowledge and
advisory services
Improve availability and quality of inputs through public private ownerships
Research on livestock development, including genetic improvement
F.R.S. Ahmed
No Component
1
Food
availability
7
Strengthened capacities
for implementation and
monitoring of NFP and
CIP actions
8
Enhanced public food
management systems
9
Institutional development
and capacity
development for more
effective safety nets
10
Food
utilization
Community based
nutrition programs and
services
Orient food and nutrition
program through data
12
Food safety and quality
improvement
149
11
Proposed focus and priority interventions
Improve physical access to markets, facilities and information
Mobilize and promote producer and marketing groups for improved market access and knowledge
Develop adequate storage, processing and value addition and reduce waste through public-private
partnerships
Promote and assist the development of off farm activities and rural businesses
Strengthen capacities to implement, monitor and coordinate National Food Policy –Plan of Action and
CIP
Strengthen national capacities for design, implementation and monitoring of CIP operations
Strengthen capacities of civil society organizations to contribute to CIP development and
implementation
Enhance efficiency and effectiveness of public food management systems and improve its impact on
price stabilization
Build capacities of Ministry of Food and Disaster Management and Directorate of Food to better
manage the food system
Increase and modernize public storage and handling facilities, including in disaster prone areas
Strengthen institutional capacities to effectively to effectively operate social safety net programs and
formulate a new integrated strategy for social safety net programs to : (i) coordinate and streamline
them; (ii) enhance impact and targeting; (iii) improve governance
Investment in employment and income generation of social safety nets (including in ADP)
Community based nutrition programs, building on and linking to the National Nutrition Service (NNS)
Support community based efforts of homestead gardening, rearing livestock, aquaculture and awareness
building for improved nutrition
Link long term strategies and immediate treatment of acute malnutrition, in particular through
therapeutic and supplementary feeding
Undertake updated and comprehensive national service of food consumption and food composition
Undertake study of dietary, diversification and supplementation needs and develop advocacy, awareness
and educational materials to facilitate behavioral change in eating habit and practices
Strengthen national capacities in surveying and analysis to facilitate evidence based decisions
Improve surveillance system of food borne illnesses
Develop and enhance capacities of laboratories and systems for food quality assurance and safety
control of food
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security
Program title
Improved access to
markets, value-addition
in agriculture and to non
farm incomes
8
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
No Component
6
Food
access
150
F.R.S. Ahmed
(FPWG) is an inter-ministerial coordination mechanism to support the Food
Planning and Monitoring Committee. It focuses on strategic issues related to
food security, and coordinates the work of the Thematic Teams and cross-cutting
issues of food security. Along with 13 other members DG FPMU is the member
secretary of that committee.
Food Planning and Monitoring Unit (FPMU), a Government unit under the
Ministry of Food and Disaster Management that acts as a secretariat of the Food
Policy Monitoring Committee. The Food Planning and Monitoring Unit of the
Ministry of Food is the Government unit responsible for monitoring the food
security situation in Bangladesh and the implementation of related policies.
Activities include collecting, storing and disseminating information for food
security analysis and policy formulation, and delivering evidence-based policy
advice to the Government on issues relevant to food security – on its own initiative or on demand by the Government of Bangladesh.
The Unit provides secretarial support to the Food Planning and Monitoring
Committee (FPMC) and contributes to other Government committees relevant to
food security, such as the Early Warning Technical Committee or the Safety Net
Technical Committee. As the lead agency on food security issues in Bangladesh,
FPMU is also responsible for enhancing inter-ministerial collaboration for the
implementation of the National Food Policy and monitoring its Plan of Action. The
agency also has a pivotal role in coordinating, monitoring and evaluating interventions under the Country Investment Plan.
Activities of FPMU are divided into four directorates, three of which representing one specific dimension of food security (availability, access and utilization) plus
one that facilitates information exchange between FPMU and data providers:
• Directorate of Food Availability, dealing with all issues related to the domestic
supply component of the availability dimension of food security. It includes two
services: (i) domestic production; and (ii) early warning and agricultural
sustainability
• Directorate of Food Access, dealing with the physical, economic and social
access dimensions of food security. It includes two services: (i) physical and
economic access; and (ii) social access
• Directorate of Food Utilization, dealing with all issues related to the food utilization dimension of food security. It includes one service on food utilization and
nutrition
• Directorate of Management, Information and Communication, dealing with
all functions that need to be centralized for the overall operation of FPMU (e.g.
cooperation with Development Partners). It includes one service on management, information and communication.
For a more efficient, integrated and analytical support to the FPMC, the agency
has established an inter-ministerial coordination mechanism through a Food Policy
Working Group and Thematic Teams.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security
151
Thematic Teams – specialized inter-ministerial bodies led by the Food Planning
and Monitoring Unit that focus on each dimension of food security and facilitate
cross-sectoral collaboration. Thematic Teams are specialized inter-ministerial bodies led by each Directorate of the Food Planning and Monitoring Unit. They are thus
organized according to the three dimensions of food security (availability, access
and utilization), plus one team that facilitates information exchange between FPMU
and data providers.
Currently four Thematic Teams are working with the 6–7 members in each team,
the teams are thematic Team A: Food Availability; Thematic Team B: Food
Access; Thematic Team C: Food Utilization; Thematic Team D: Data Exchange.
8.7
Conclusion
Bangladesh has made substantial progress in enhancing food security by increasing
production of food grains, particularly rice, improving infrastructure, making food
delivery to the poor more efficient and liberalizing agricultural input and output
markets.
Rice has contributed most to self-sufficiency in food grain, currently accounting
for 71 % of the gross cropped area and for 94 % of the food grain production (BBS
2012). Rice production gains have been mainly driven by an increased use of irrigation water, expanded use of other agricultural inputs along with an increased coverage of high-yielding and modern rice varieties. However, the sustainability of
domestic food grain production remains an issue. Rice cannot be expected to experience the growth rate of the past without net technological breakthrough.
Furthermore, demographic pressures and increased urbanization have caused cultivated area to decline at a rate of 1 % per year, whilst cropping intensity has virtually
reached its limit.
Landholdings are small and scattered, and food grains continue, to a large extent,
to be cultivated for subsistence. Small and marginal farmers represent 80 % of all
farmers. Only a limited percentage of crops circulate through commercial channels.
This also results in a situation where, despite efforts, food grain procurement
remains prone to wide fluctuations and sizeable food grain imports are needed. In
the last 5 years, total annual imports of food grains have ranged between 2 and 3
million tons. Imports consist mainly of wheat, whose production has been continuously reducing over the past years, with rice accounting for about half million tons
per year.
Also, the emphasis placed on rice production has resulted in an increased dependency on imports for non food grain commodities, such as pulses, oilseeds and
fruits which remain unaffordable to many consumers, especially poor consumers.
For instance, 70 % of the pulses and 66 % of the edible oil requirements are currently imported (Mishra and Hossain 2005). Traditionally, the two most important
non-cereal foods for the poor were fish and pulses. Due to crop substitution, the
national supply of pulses decreased substantially, and the poor substituted cereals
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
152
F.R.S. Ahmed
for pulses with negative nutritional implications especially for children, pregnant
and lactating women. Furthermore, rice monocropping causes the nutrient depletion
of the soil.
Arsenic contamination has become a major concern for both agricultural sustainability and food safety (Heikens et al. 2007). Climate change poses an additional
burden on food security, especially in areas where agriculture and water resources
are already under stress due to adverse meteorological conditions and erratic behavior of climatic factors (BCCSAP 2009).
In this context, strengthened efforts to raise productivity and efficiency in food
grain production, to support agricultural commercialization and diversification, in
due consideration of environmental impacts, will be paramount. Actions are needed
on many fronts, including agricultural technology development, input (seeds, fertilizers, irrigation, machinery) supply and access expansion, and, critically, rural
financing, which currently stands far below rural producers’ needs, especially those
of small and marginal farmers. Renewed diversification efforts need to be backedup by clear understanding of the relative profitability of competing crops, physical
and location-specific conditions for non-crop enterprises, the supply chain of high
value products and provision for processing, storage and marketing activities, as
well as by a clear appraisal of international trade opportunities.
Still, many poor and vulnerable households, whether food producers or not, do
not have food security because they are unable to afford a minimum basket of food
items through their own food production, cash income, market purchases and other
resources necessary to acquire safe and nutritious food.
The contribution of agricultural sectors to the GDP in 2010–2011 was 20.33 %
at 1995–1996 constant prices, while they provided over 62 % of the total employment. About 80 % of the population lives in rural areas and continues to depend
largely, whether directly or indirectly, on agriculture for its livelihood. Many rural
areas lack education and health resources. They also lack of modern food and grain
storage facilities and adequate roads leading to larger market areas. Only 25 % of
rural homes have electricity.
Large segments of the population remain vulnerable to transitory food insecurity
caused by drought, floods, cyclones and other natural disasters, which, in many
instances, results in highly adverse adjustments to their means of livelihoods due to
the lack of coping capabilities. This highlights the need for strengthening risk reduction, disaster preparedness and management at all levels, including communities
and households. Furthermore, the seasonal food crisis that continues to occur,
before the harvest of aman rice each year in the northern region of Bangladesh,
despite safety net programs, is of particular concern and need to be remedied by
adequate interventions to address the shortage of employment/income-generating
opportunities during lean seasons.
Moreover, there is evidence that malnutrition prevalence in Bangladesh is not
confined to poorer households. Whilst child malnutrition is generally higher among
the poorest quintiles (46–50 %), it is also high among the richest income quintile
(33 %) (World Bank 2007). Thus, whilst many poor household are not able to access
a variety of (nutritious) foods, richer households tend to spend more on food, but not
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security
153
on more nutritious foods, which results in significant deficiencies in protein, Vitamin
A and iron (Helen Keller International and Institute of Public Health Nutrition
2006).
This implies that strategies to improve availability, supply and accessibility of
more diversified foods, although paramount, need to be complemented by a set of
non-income focused policy measures that promote the utilization of a diversity of
foods, including efforts to promote positive food behavior, access to clean water and
proper sanitation which are all intricately linked to sound nutrition. Differentials
within households as regards access to food, nutrition, health care and primary education determine to a large extent the differing nutritional status of individual household members. Where access to resources is more equally shared across sexes,
health and nutrition outcomes are significantly better. Moreover, some policy issues
need to be addressed such as:
Tenure of land and water resources. Land tenure is perceived as a major constraint particularly for the food insecure who, for a large part, do not own the land
that they work. They therefore have insecure, prohibitive and unstable access to
land through crop sharing arrangements which reduce both the impact of potential policy and investment interventions on household food security and the
incentive for these smallholders to invest as a result of uncertain access to land.
Surface water is leased to potential users with insufficient clarity and regulation,
leading to lack of incentive for sustainable use and investment in better practices.
This is a widespread concern amongst the farming community, Government
senior officials, NGOs and civil society;
Credit and other financial resources were often mentioned by the farming community, entrepreneurs and civil society as a major constraint for them to take
advantage of public investment to invest in productive assets. In their difficulties
to access the banking system, they point out the governance issue, the complex
procedures, the insufficient regulatory and policy mechanisms for agroprocessing; as well as excessive collateral and interest rates. In addition, smallholders mention the inadequacy of most of the current microfinance activities to
support investment activities.
Involvement of Private Sector – Immense scope for private investment in activities
and business in the food security sector, providing the adequate policy environment is put in place. Opportunities exist in agro-processing, in the milk and dairy
industry, better quality input supply business. Suitable deregulation has led to the
development of the small pump industry as a good contribution to cheaper investment by water users for irrigation benefiting from more accessible equipment.
Innovative entrepreneurs invest in contract farming, or new types of milk collection systems, both accompanied with services to the farmers.
However, to take full advantage of these opportunities, some policy elements
have to be more conducive. Some of the mentioned ones include fiscal incentives or
reduced interest rates to enable the development of infant and risky industries in the
agricultural sector; much stronger regulatory framework to allow the development
of secured contractual arrangements between actors along the food chain; some
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
154
F.R.S. Ahmed
revision in the tariff system which are unfavorable for local production; the reduction
of artificial support to state entities involved in business activities, resulting in unfair
competition and limiting private investment in these activities.
An enabling policy for fostering education both at a higher level for research
purposes and a professional level for extension workers is required. In addition, new
education curricula should be developed to ensure convergence of education programs in health, nutrition and food.
Policies should enable fair access to markets by farmers and consumers, particularly for some commodities key to food and nutrition security (e.g. milk), These
could include a more favorable tariff system for those imported items that could
be produced locally; interventions to avoid quasi monopolistic attitudes of some
market players; the promotion of marketing groups or associations to empower
smallholders access markets.
The need for a more effective and better governed regulatory and quality control
of inputs so as to protect smallholders and enable them to invest in improved techniques and inputs. A need to further clarify trade-offs between various uses of food
stocks (safety net to food insecure; price control purpose and emergency stocks) so
as to improve management of the PFDS and better evaluate needs for additional and
enhanced storage facilities. Better targeting of safety nets, extension activities and
others is essential to optimize their impact on the most food and nutritionally insecure in the country.
Government is planning to enact food safely act and food safety rules (2014) as
now a day’s contamination and adulteration of food is a major concern for all kinds
of food. Food policy, food policy program of action as well as country investment
plan all are primarily concerned for the cereal crops and it did not put enough
emphasis on other non cereal food crops like oil, pulse, vegetables, spices or other
important crops.
The difficult enforcement of some existing regulations and rules should be
addressed through empowering and disseminating information to communities and
grass-root actors. Coordination of food security actions such as food production,
safety nets and nutrition is a challenge, in particular as it has to be inclusive of nonstate actors and development partners.
References
Ahmed AU, Dorosh P, Shahabuddin Q, Talukder R (2010) Income growth, safety nets, and public
food distribution. Paper prepared for the Bangladesh Food Security Investment Forum, Dhaka,
26–27 May 2010
Ahmed AU, Aberman NL, Jabbar M, Akhtar N (2011) Policy perspective of the country investment
plan for food and nutrition security in Bangladesh. International Food Policy Research Institute,
Gulshan, Dhaka
Asaduzzaman M, Ringler C, Thurlow J, Alam S (2010) Investing in crop agriculture in Bangladesh
for higher growth and productivity, and adaptation to climate change. Background paper prepared for the Bangladesh Food Security Investment Forum, Dhaka
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
8
Policy Support and Institutional Dimensions of Food Security
155
Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) (2012) Statistics and informatics division. Government of
the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka
Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan (BCCSAP) (2009) Ministry of Environment
and Forests, Bangladesh (MOEF). Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka
Bangladesh Country Investment Plan (2011) A road map towards investment in agriculture, food
security and nutrition. Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh. feedthefuture.gov/
sites/default/files/country/resources/files/BangladeshCountryInvestmentPlanGovernmentof
Bangladesh_June2011.pdf
Food Planning and Monitoring Unit (FPMU) (2008) Ministry of Food and Disaster Management.
Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka
General Economics Division (GED), Planning Commission, Government of Bangladesh GOB
(2005) Unlocking the potential: national strategy for accelerated poverty reduction. Planning
Commission, Government of Bangladesh GOB, Dhaka
Heikens A, Panaullah GM, Meharg AA (2007) Arsenic behaviour from groundwater and soil to
crops: impacts on agriculture and food safety. Rev Environ Contam Toxicol 189:43–87
Helen Keller International and Institute of Public Health Nutrition (2006) Bangladesh in facts and
figures: 2005, annual report of the nutritional surveillance project. Hellen Keller International,
Dhaka
Mishra U, Motahar Hossain SAK (2005) Current food security and challenges- achieving 2015
MDG milepost. In: Proceedings of the national workshop on food security in Bangladesh,
Dhaka, 19–20 Oct 2005
National Food Policy (NFP) (2006) Ministry of Food and Disaster Management. Government of
the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka. http://www.mofdm.gov.bd/National%20
Food%20Policy%20_%20English%20Translation.pdf
National Food Policy Plan of Action (2008–2015) Food Planning and Monitoring Unit (FPMU).
Ministry of Food and Disaster Management. Government of the People’s Republic of
Bangladesh, Dhaka
World Bank (2007) To the MDGs and beyond: accountability and institutional innovation in
Bangladesh. Bangladesh development series, paper no 14. World Bank Office, Dhaka
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 9
People and Community Actions on Food
Security
Md. Anwarul Abedin and Umma Habiba
Abstract The global food crisis is exposing existing and potential vulnerabilities
of households, governments and the international system to food and nutrition insecurity. Most of the rural poor are smallholder farmers whose capacities to benefit
from high food prices are severely constrained by the lack of inputs, investment and
access to market. Similarly, in Bangladesh, community people are the frontline victims of all kind of natural disaster along with food security. Hence, community
people take different initiatives with the assistance of institutions to cope with food
insecurity. To cope with the situation community based food storage system may be
a crucial solution in addition to create income generation in non-formal sectors.
Marketing support is considered as an essential part in supporting and raising the
income of the target group because they usually do not get fair price of their artisan
works in the local markets. Therefore, this chapter focuses firstly about community
initiatives towards food security, problem associated community actions and finally
future guideline to overcome the barrier of community initiatives and actions on
food security that ultimately insure risk reduction of community people.
Keywords Community people • Barrier • Community initiatives • Food security
9.1
Introduction
According to the World Food Summit (1996), “Food security exists when all people, at all times, have physical and economic access to sufficient, safe and nutritious
food which meet their dietary needs and food preferences for an active and healthy
life”. Food security encompasses many issues ranging from food production, distribution and access to food preferences and health status of individuals. Community
people especially rural poor are the frontline sufferers of food security.
Md.A. Abedin (*)
Department of Soil Science, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh
e-mail: masumagriculture@yahoo.com
U. Habiba
Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture, Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: shimuagri@yahoo.com
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_9
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
157
Md.A. Abedin and U. Habiba
158
In twenty-first century, the world will need to produce significant amount of food
in order to deliver a basic, but adequate, diet to everyone. However, frequent natural
disasters due to changing climate and global warming make the global food security
system worse which is already in crisis to meet the basic demands. According to the
IPCC Fourth Assessment Report along with other scientific studies, it is clearly
understood that climate change has a direct impact on agriculture, livestock and
fishing, particularly in countries of topics and sub-topics, which will not only affect
local but the global food security (Bals et al. 2008). Natural disaster duet o climate
change increases the food crisis for most of the developing countries by affecting
the production and supply process (Tandon 2012).
In Bangladesh context, climate change induced extreme events such as floods,
droughts, cyclones, storm surges, sea level rise and salinity intrusion are likely to
reduce agricultural yield, reduce livestock productivity and increase livestock mortality. Increasing temperature with less rainfall has already affected biological and
physical ecosystems of Bangladesh. Degradation of productive lands due to different hazards namely floods, drought and salinity intrusion have direct effect on agricultural production. For example, the loss of rice production in a village of Satkhira
district was 1,151 metric tons in 2003 less than the year of 1985, corresponding to
a loss of 69 %. Out of the total decreased production, 77 % was found due to conversion of rice field into shrimp pond and 23 % was because of yield loss (Ali 2006).
The reason of this production disparity in southwestern region because of massive
salinity intrusion occurred through climate induced sea level rise. On the other
hand, in northwestern area, Habiba et al. (2011) found that the cultivated land is
now turning into fruit crop fields, like mango orchards due to drought. Moreover,
mango cultivated area has increased to 8,667 ha in 2011 compared to 4,650 ha in
2001. These community initiatives help to get immediate relief from the climate
change impacts, but these practices gradually cause decreasing of cultivated land,
particularly hinders rice production. However, to long run productivity of food
along with reduce the effect of climate change on food supplies, livelihoods and
economies; therefore, it is foremost important to scale up the effective community
initiatives that would help to sustain food security and finally reduce the vulnerability of the community people and enhances risk reduction process.
Bangladesh government has identified food security as an important factor contributing to its socio-economic stabilization and sustainable development. However,
Bangladesh has made a steady progress in the expansion of food production. But
because of the increasing population pressure there has been an extensive use of
land to meet the growing demand for food. Despite the growth in food production
and its availability, food insecurity is still a major problem mainly because of the
lack of purchasing power and thus of access to food, especially for the ultra poor
community. A major portion of the rural population is landless, and as labours they
depend on casual earning for their livelihood. Due to the seasonal variation in agricultural employment and limited employment opportunities in non- farm sector,
millions of people suffer from chronic and transitory food insecurity. Hence, community involvement through rural people actions regarding agricultural activities is
crucial for food security as they are the first and foremost affected victims. Therefore,
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
9
People and Community Actions on Food Security
159
this chapter tries to illustrate different community actions and initiatives that are
directly and or indirectly controlled food security issues at community level, the
focus then shifts on the problem associated with community actions and some possible directions to overcome the problems to sustain food security through community initiatives and finally concluding remarks.
9.2
Community Initiatives and Food Security
Community people are the front line victims to any kind of natural hazards or
extreme events. Hence, the community people themselves and/or with the association of different stakeholders they are trying to combat with such types of natural
disasters or extreme events. This section briefly illustrates the commonly available
community initiatives that are currently practices by the community people to cope
with natural hazards and sustaining food security.
9.2.1
Homestead Garden
Homestead gardening is one of the promising and suitable local practices in
Bangladesh to meet the household as well as community level demands of vegetables and nutrition. Though homestead gardening is individual efforts, however, it
shares and transfers the knowledge, technology and other logistics among the community to inspire the vegetable gardening into their homestead. Moreover, women
are responsible for maintaining the homestead garden for their own household food
security and get some financial solvency. Therefore, this approach provides other
family to nurture homestead gardening for their own food sufficiency, local demand
and urban market chain.
In Bangladesh, there is an estimated 15 million homesteads, of which two million are in urban areas. Of various crop production activities carried out in homesteads, vegetable gardening is the most prominent. Furthermore, about 15 % of the
homestead include vegetable gardens and a relatively greater percentage of the
landless (33 %) use their homestead activities. In Bangladesh, about 75 % of the
households have a homestead garden; yet a majority of them depend on the market
for their vegetables. The size of the home gardens in Bangladesh is similar, ranging
from 1.0 to 1.5 decimals and the varieties of vegetables grown in the gardens range
from 1.4 in Teknaf to 3 in Dumuria. The average monthly vegetable production per
household ranges from 0.3 kg in Madaripur Sadar to 8.6 kg in Sripur. The per capita
vegetable consumption by household members ranges from 69 g/day in Madaripur
Sadar to 112 g/day in Dumuria (Al-Hussainy 2006).
A majority of the farmers use their own stock as a source of seeds and seedlings
for gardening. The cultivated vegetables in a home garden can give an economic
return of Tk. 1776 per year, where the input cost is only Tk. 470. It also gives a
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
160
Md.A. Abedin and U. Habiba
yearly return of 611.3 kcal, 4133.8 mg vitamin “A” and 323.2 mg of vitamin “C”
along with other nutrients in considerable amounts. Nutrient deficiency is a common problem among most of the people in Bangladesh, especially among those
living in the villages. About 30,000 children become blind every year due to vitamin
“A” deficiency in their daily diet. Due to poverty, illiteracy and lack of knowledge
about food and nutrition, many farmers suffer from malnutrition, which especially
affects newly married, pregnant, or lactating women. On the other hand, most
households in the villages occupy some land surrounding their home, where they
can easily establish a homestead garden to supplement their nutritional requirements. These gardens involve “deliberate management of multipurpose trees and
shrubs in intimate association with annual and perennial agricultural crops and,
invariably, livestock, within the compounds of individual houses, the whole crop
tree animal unit being intensively managed by family labour”. These gardens often
feature low capital inputs and simple technology.
Scientists and development agents often ignore home gardens as an important
part of the traditional farming system due to their small size and apparent insignificance. But every farm unit should be considered as a specialized entity in itself
because the farmers who practice homestead gardening are guided, perhaps in the
absence of a unified set of expert recommendations, by their own perception and
conviction about species selection, admixture and management. Many studies have
reported the existence of home gardens in various regions of the world, but very few
studies have adequately analyzed the structure, species composition, diversity and
management aspects of the home gardens. In Bangladesh there is only scattered
information regarding nutrition gardening in homesteads.
In addition, home gardens are well established land use systems in Bangladesh
where different crops, including trees, are grown in combination with livestock and
fish. Most of the home gardens are rectangular in shape, built on mounds to raise
them above the water level during the annual floods, and usually fenced by trees or
shrubs. A typical home garden serves several houses in a cluster and has space for
vegetable gardens, a yard for threshing and communal activities, cattle sheds, ponds,
trees, shrubs and bamboo (Fig. 9.1). The most frequently harvested plants are generally grown in the back yard, at the pond side, and around the cow shed for the provi-
Fig. 9.1 Homestead garden
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
9
People and Community Actions on Food Security
161
sion of fruit/food, fuel wood, timber and fodder both for domestic use as well as
for cash.
Home gardens are more reliable from the physical and socioeconomic points of
view and are important sources of income for the farmers of Bangladesh. The poor
farmers are often forced to sell cropland to stave off poverty, but they tend to retain
the home gardens unless absolutely unavoidable. It was observed that the landless
farmers have their own home gardens where they grow essential commodities for
their subsistence. Home gardens in Bangladesh comprise different plants, vegetables and fruit plants along with domestic animals and poultry. There is a clear sharing of tasks between women and men for the management of home gardens.
Bangladesh women are mostly involved in the pre and postharvest work of vegetable production while men play a key role in rowing timber and fruit trees.
The farmers collect their seeds and seedlings from different sources to cultivate
vegetables in their home gardens. Primarily, homestead gardens are the source of
supplementary food for a family. Here capital input is low, simple techniques are
applied and the family members themselves participate as labor. The cultivated vegetables can also give an economic return when there is a surplus. When livestock is
reared in the homestead, it also becomes an important source of economic return. A
number of urban and rural households raise and sell livestock and produce different
items as an enterprise. Livestock, poultry, and milk and milk products produced in
rural and urban homesteads are comparable, but significant differences prevail
between rural and urban homesteads regarding production of meat, eggs, hides and
skins and bones, hoofs, horns, hairs, etc.
Different types of vegetables are produced in the home gardens in different seasons. Hence, the availability of different nutrients varies from season to season. In
Bangladesh, home gardens supplement the nutrient requirements for a farmer’s
family without negatively affecting the resource base. Moreover this practice
improves the resources of poor farmers and also meets several socioeconomic and
ecological conditions which contribute to their better living and sustainability.
9.2.2
Floating Garden
Floating gardens provide an alternative sustainable and suitable cultivation technique to grow vegetables on the floating bed by reducing pressure on the arable land
or by turning the flooded and waterlogged areas into productive lands. Therefore,
the community has developed and established this sustainable community-based
floating garden that helps to protect them from the devastating effects of floodwater
and waterlogging and allows farmers to grow crops in a floating platform. This cultivation technique also generates income for the rural poor, and also leads to significant and substantial increase of food production in that rural area.
‘Floating gardens’ also known as ‘Baira’ are one of the best known agricultural adaptation techniques in Bangladesh and are an ancient form of ‘hydroponics’
which means ‘growing plants in nutrient containing water but without soil’
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Md.A. Abedin and U. Habiba
162
Fig. 9.2 Vegetable production on floating water garden (Source: Golam Rabbani and author)
(Fig. 9.2). As more than two-thirds of Bangladesh consists of wetland areas and
seasonal flooding has covered large areas of land for centuries it is not surprising
that this traditional adaptation to seasonal flooding has developed in the south of
Bangladesh in Gopalganj, Pirojpur and Barisal Districts. Rice straw was the main
item for making a baira until 40 years ago but since then the water hyacinth plant
has taken its place. Initially a bamboo pole the length of the required floating garden
is places over a floating bed of water hyacinth, then more water hyacinth and other
rotting ‘aquatic plants’ or ‘plants that grow in water’ are pulled together, after a
week or so more decomposable plants like water hyacinth from the water bodies are
piled on top, bamboo poles are used to keep the baira in place, then later either a ball
or cushion made from aquatic plants or coconut husks are used to make a bed ready
for seed planting. Either summer vegetables or winter vegetable seedings are cultivated on baira for sale and they simply rise and sink along with floodwaters. When
finished with the material is used as compost. As floods are predicted to cover larger
areas on a more regular basis due to climate change this technique is now being
promoted outside the areas in which it originated (Irfanullah 2005).
9.2.3
Sorjon Cultivation
Community people are step ahead to combat with natural disasters to ensure food
security using their indigenous knowledge and local innovative technology with the
help of different stakeholders. Aside from floating garden, a further principal system for saline and non-saline areas vulnerable to water logging is the Sorjon or
‘raised bed’ system. Moreover, sorjon cultivation is one of the good practices that
are extensively used in southern Bangladesh to improve the people’s food security.
A system of raised beds 10 m long, 2 m wide and 1 m high, interspersed with
ditches 10 m long, 1.5 m wide and 1.5 m deep are constructed in the dry season,
with the topsoil replaced onto the top of the beds when finished (Fig. 9.3). Vegetables
and fruit can be cultivated on top of the bed, while trellis made with bamboo or
other materials can support creeper vegetables over the ditches and in the monsoon
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
9
People and Community Actions on Food Security
163
Fig. 9.3 Sorjon cultivation (a) Preparation of sorjon bed (b) Vegetable cultivation on sorjon bed
fish may even be cultured in the ditches (Miah 2010). Currently, sorjon cultivation
is very popular at the community level in the coastal region of Bangladesh. With the
application of sorjon method, coastal community improves their agricultural production, which enhances food security in the poor vulnerable people.
9.2.4
Vegetable Cultivation on Channel Embankment
Cultivation of high value vegetables and fruits on channel embankment is now a
very popular approach in the rural community to produce more vegetables and fruits
in a sustainable way to meet up demands of rural poor and urban market. This cultivation technique is the collective effort of advanced group of farmers. This technology is one kind of management practices in the embankments of the freshwater
sources or even low level of salinity water sources. Currently, due to the impact of
climate change, this cultivation procedure is very popular in the coastal communities. The Fig. 9.4 depicts the illustration of cultivation of vegetables on the channel
of embankment in the coastal region. This technique utilizes the freshwater from the
channel of the embankments or even water containing very low amount of salt.
Finally this cultivation procedure helps to meet the demands of household as well as
community people through the supply of local market.
9.2.5
Cultivation of Alternate and Promising Crops
Drought, insidious onset disaster, takes place in Bangladesh more frequently than in
the past because of climate change (National Drought Mitigation Center (NDMC)
2006). Hence, community people in the drought prone areas practices alternate crop
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Md.A. Abedin and U. Habiba
164
Fig. 9.4 Vegetable cultivation on channel embankment
Fig. 9.5 Mango garden in drought prone areas
cultivation procedure to minimize the gap of production failure, cost for the rural
poor, which ultimately helps to generate incomes and increase food security. Mango
and Jujube Ziziphus jujube, are alternative and promising crops to grow in drought
risk areas in western Bangladesh. Figure 9.5 shows the mango orchard in the
drought prone areas. Cultivation and maintenance procedures of mango and Jujube
orchards and management of market links is very difficult for a single farmer.
Therefore, farmers of the northern part of Bangladesh create community group for
production and marketing of products to get more financial benefits and logistics for
ensuring sustainability of the business. The northwest region is known for its quality
mango production and mango cultivation is increasing. The crop is drought resistant
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
9
People and Community Actions on Food Security
165
and many times more profitable than T.aman rice, while the inter-spaces in the
young mango plantations can be intercropped with T.aman and boro rice. Jujube is
a tropical fruit crop able to survive within a wide temperature range and is even
more tolerant of drought conditions. The crop can be cultivated successfully in dry
areas like the Barind Tracts with little irrigation and the Jujube can also be intercropped with T.aman rice (Selvaraju et al. 2006). Increasing the tree cover in this
way is also an adaptation that will benefit other crops in the area by increasing local
humidity levels and reducing evapo-transpiration and soil moisture loss due to
reducing wind flow across fields.
9.2.6
Grain Banks
The food banks concept has been successful in improving the access of the poorest
households to fill in their food gaps during times of shortages and has often saved
the members from falling to the clutches of indebtedness (Fig. 9.6). Furthermore,
public foodgrain stock plays an important role in responding to emergency food
situation in the country. Hence, grain bank is another important coping mechanism
at community level to ensure food security for the rural poor. In this connection, the
major problem of community and household level food security owes to the problem of lack of availability of food at local level even though there might be surplus
of food at the macro level or lack of access to food. At the time of harvesting, in
order to repay debts, the small and marginal farmers sell their produce, often at a
Fig. 9.6 Grain bank at
community level
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
166
Md.A. Abedin and U. Habiba
very low price and subsequently fall short of foodgrains later in the year. The numbers of months of food gaps are even higher in the areas where agriculture is rainfed and crop failure is recurring. Because of lack of food, the nutritional status of
these people is usually weak thus making them less productive or productive at the
cost of their health. To ensure reach of food grains by poor households, the concept
of grain bank has been promoted among the communities all over the country,
especially in the areas that are prone to crop failure and drought.
In most cases, the target groups for food bank are ideally a group of 10–15 land
less families. These families by definition are located in rain-fed regions, mostly
prone to drought and other natural disasters characterized by subsistence agricultural activities generating few wage employment opportunities. Such groups are
homogeneous in their economic profiles and are prone to endemic hunger. The food
bank is usually formed by such groups through the concept of small household
groups (SHGs), especially among women, with all the members of the groups having equal stakes in contributions and entitlements. The members of the SHGs put an
initial contribution of grains to the bank in amounts as decided by the SHG members. The amount of food contribution of the members is the basis for calculation of
the entitlement for withdrawal of food by the members at any given point of time.
Sometimes, the initial contribution for the seed capital is made on a matching basis
by external agencies or governments who are facilitating or promoting food bank in
a particular region.
9.3
Problem Associated Community Initiatives
Communities have very limited local support system, which might include
things such as financial resources or service networks, which diminish the possibilities for the initiative to make a difference in the community. Furthermore,
community people faces different barrier to implement any kind of measure for
ensuring food security in a sustainable way that ultimately hasten the risk reduction process in Bangladesh. Therefore, this section depicts some problems or
barriers associated different community initiatives implemented in the community level.
9.3.1
Income Level and Financial Assistance
Majority of the community people in Bangladesh lives below the poverty line.
Hence, level of income of the community people is very limited to meet the necessary demands of food purchase and supply to their households. On the hands, they
get very less chance to get financial support from various source of support
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
9
People and Community Actions on Food Security
167
organizations. Therefore, due to the lack of income generating power as well as support from various source they become vulnerable day by day which is threatened for
the food security and risk reduction phenomenon.
9.3.2
In Appropriate Markets, Infrastructure, and Institutions
Most of rural regions consisting primarily of poor and vulnerable people, including
small farmers, are often the last regions to get investments in infrastructure and,
partly for that reason, markets in these areas are poorly developed. Rural poor people, whether farmers or not, will not benefit if they are excluded from participation
or fair competition in the mainstream market economy.
9.3.3
Lack of Good Governance
The term ‘Good governance’ the rule of law, transparency, the elimination of corruption, sound public administration, and respect and protection for human rights—
supports efforts to achieve food security for all. In the past 20 years or so the role of
the public sector has shrunk while NGOs and business and industry have taken on
additional responsibilities. Although this shift may be appropriate, the for-profit
sector and NGOs have limitations in providing public goods, such as peace, the rule
of law, affordable access to clean water and electrical power, public health, public
research, and rural transportation infrastructure. Governments must also have the
political will to stamp out corruption and must persuade business and industry,
NGOs, and citizens to work to this end.
9.3.4
Lack of Natural Resource Management
Developing countries like Bangladesh, poverty, low agricultural productivity, and
environmental degradation interact in a vicious downward spiral, as desperately
poor farmers mine soil fertility and climb the hillsides in an effort to survive. Unless
properly managed, fresh water may well emerge as the key constraint to meeting
future food security, and needed reforms include providing secure water rights for
users and reducing or eliminating water subsidies. Low soil fertility and lack of
access to reasonably priced fertilizers constrain farmers in many countries. Policies
should encourage farmers to make appropriate use of organic and inorganic fertilizers and improved soil management.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Md.A. Abedin and U. Habiba
168
9.3.5
Lack of Intervention of Research, Knowledge,
and Technology
In the arena of biological sciences; technological developments, energy, and information and communications offer new opportunities that could benefit poor community people, their food security, and natural resource management. These benefits
will materialize only if policies are in place to guide technological developments
toward solving poor people’s problems.
9.4
Future Recommendation
Food security is an important dimension of human security and fundamental to
economic development for the community people. Therefore, this section tries to
deliver some basic recommendations that directly and indirectly help to sustain food
security for the community people.
9.4.1
Endorsement of Income for the Rural Poor
Ensuring level of income is the first steps for the rural community to maintain sustainable food security. Therefore, level of incomes of the poor and ultimately ensuring sustainable livelihoods, requires that their asset base be enhanced including
physical capital (e.g. infrastructure), natural capital (e.g. water resources delivered
through new infrastructure), human capital (through improved health and education), financial capital (through savings and credit programs); and social capital
(through training and income earning activities that increase connections among
people). Building such assets goes beyond current income, to enhance the productive
base and make households less vulnerable to income fluctuations in the future.
Furthermore, several programs viz. Food/Cash For Work (C/FFW), Vulnerable
Group Development (VGD), Cash/Food for Education (C/FFE) are designed to
increase the asset base of the poor and thus enhance their access to food. Foodbased interventions such as Food/Cash For Work (C/FFW) are designed to increase
access to food by providing employment while building infrastructure to support
rural development. Other programs, including Vulnerable Group Development
(VGD) are designed to augment participants’ incomes on a more sustainable basis
by providing training as well as short-term employment and food transfers. Cash/
Food for Education (C/FFE) aims to improve food security of the poor in the shortrun through direct transfers of food/cash, as well as enhancing future income
through developing human capital in the long-run. Likewise, the National Nutrition
Programme of Ministry of Health and family Welfare aims to increase sustainable
incomes of the poor by improving nutrition (thereby increasing labour productivity)
and small-scale household income earning activities.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
9
People and Community Actions on Food Security
9.4.2
169
Food Price Stabilization
The foodgrain prices are a crucial determinant of welfare for both producers and
consumers particularly for the poorest groups in Bangladesh. Instability in producer
prices of foodgrains increases farmers’ uncertainty and discourages much-needed
private investment in irrigation and agricultural machinery. Large increase in consumer price significantly lower real incomes of poor households, for whom
foodgrains account for over 70 % of their total spending. For the poorest, large price
increases force them to reduce their food consumption, threatening their lives.
Hence, stabilization of food price is another important aspect to ensure food security for the rural poor. In this connection, preventing large increases in market prices
through Open Market Sales (OMS) operation is an alternative mechanism for
increasing food security for these people.
9.4.3
Food Market Efficiency
Aside from income and food price stabilization, intervention of improved food market efficiency is another vital parameter for food security issue. For instance, there
are large number of buyers and sellers in the food market of Bangladesh. An efficient food market will ensure unhindered flow of goods and services across time
and space. But the dispersal of small producers over vast areas, lack of proper transport, storage and communication system, formal and informal restriction on movement of goods and faulty grading system seriously affect the competitive
environment. Bangladesh experiences two periods of price hike in rice, one during
September to November (before T. aman harvest) and the other during March and
April (before Boro harvest) as national stock goes down. During these periods, food
prices are at their highest level but agricultural wages are at their minimum. So, both
food availability and accessibility are worst during these periods, affecting the landless, marginal and even small farm families (who together constitute more than 60
% of the rural population). As a result, prevalence of malnutrition and other nutritional disorders rises also to the peak at these times of the year. Around 7.7 million
rural household are living virtually landless. They neither can produce adequate
food for themselves nor purchase the food they need. Hence, it is necessary to
improve food market efficiency to strengthen food security at the community level.
9.4.4
Improved Access and Distribution of Food
Improved access and proper distribution of available food plays a significant role on
food security at the community level. Furthermore, one important issue relating to
access to and consumption of food is the distribution of food among members of the
household. Even though households have enough food at their disposal, there is no
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
170
Md.A. Abedin and U. Habiba
guarantee that all individuals in the households have equal access to food.
Conventional food intake patterns suggest that women and children have less access
to food than adult males.
9.4.5
Efficient Food Safety Net Program
At the community level, many people live below the poverty line, who face seasonal
food insecurity, i.e. face hunger and deprivation during the lean season. Hence,
efficient implementation of food safety net program in cooperation with community
people helps to boost up the food security in the rural area.
9.5
Conclusion
Bangladesh experiences many types of natural disasters viz. Flood, cyclone, storm
surge, water logging, salinity intrusion, drought etc. and the impacts of climate change,
which often enhances to develop disaster. As a consequence, it not only has impacts
on physical, economic, and natural aspects of the country, but also has major implications on food security that hampers both lives and livelihood of community people
specially, rural poor. To cope with natural disasters for ensuring food security, a number of stakeholders viz government, NGOs, CBOs, development partners and communities are working at national to local level. Among them, community people pays
a leading role to ensure food security through different community initiatives. Adding
together, access to food is very vital particularly in a country like Bangladesh where
about 50 % of population live below the poverty line. The income of the poor does not
permit them to have sufficient food intake. Furthermore, the nutritional status of each
member of the household depends on several conditions being met: the food available
to the household must be shared according to individual needs; the food must be of
sufficient variety, quality and safety; and each family member must have good health
status in order to benefit from the food consumed.
Again, “Local people are the real experts” in terms of climate change, as they
know about any changes that are occurring best, as well as having traditional
responses to cope with many of them. Figure 9.7 tries to depicts the real scenario
among the interaction of climate change, natural disasters and food insecurities and
how different community initiatives and actions helps to improve food security at
the community level that finally proceed for risk reduction through diminishing
community vulnerability against food. It is true in a sense that, community initiatives and actions along cant able to attend food security completely, however, people and community actions may play a step ahead role to contribute for achieving
food security by meet up local needs and demands. On the other hand, government
interventions, cooperation and coordination at the community level also useful to
scale up of the community actions, which at the end enhance food security.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
9
People and Community Actions on Food Security
171
Fig. 9.7 Diagrammatic representation of climate change, community initiatives and food security
References
Al-Hussainy N (2006) Community based disaster preparedness and climate adaptation: local
capacity‐building in the Philippines. Disasters, Wiley Online Library
Ali AMS (2006) Rice to shrimp: land use/land cover changes and soil degradation in South western
Bangladesh, Land Use Policy 23: 421–435
Bals C, Harmellng S, Windfuhr M (2008) Climate change, food security and the right to adequate
food, German watch, Stuttgart
Habiba U, Shaw R, Takeuchi Y (2011) Socio-economic impact of droughts in Bangladesh.
Droughts in Asian monsoon region. In: Shaw R, Nguyen H (eds) Community, environment and
disaster risk management, vol 8. Bingley, UK, pp 25–48
Irfanullah H (2005) In: Ahmed R, Nishat A (eds) Baira: the floating gardens for sustainable livelihood. IUCN-The World Conservation Union Bangladesh Country Office, Dhaka
Miah MU (2010) Final report of UNEP/APFED project: field testing of innovative farming practices related to climate change in the vulnerable areas of Bangladesh. Bangladesh Centre for
Advanced Studies and United Nations Environment Programme, Dhaka. Available at http://
www.apfedshowcase.net/sites/default/file/Final%20Report%20of%20UNEP%20APFED%20
-BCAS.pdf. Accessed 10 June 2014
National Drought Mitigation Center (NDMC) (2006) What is drought? Understanding and defining drought. Retrieved from http://www.drought.unl.edu/whatis/concept.htm
Selvaraju R, Subbiah AR, Baas S and Juergens I (2006) Livelihood adaptation to climate variability
and change in drought prone areas of Bangladesh: developing institutions and options. Asian
Disaster Preparedness Centre, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome
Tandon N (2012) Food security, women smallholders and climate change in Caribbean
SIDS. International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth, Cape Town
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 10
Climate Change and Food Security
in Vulnerable Coastal Zones of Bangladesh
Md. Golam Rabbani, A. Atiq Rahman, Ishtiaque Jahan Shoef,
and Zoheb Mahmud Khan
Abstract Climate Change induced hazards, including cyclonic events, variations
in temperature and rainfall, drought and salinity intrusion in water resources and
soil are adversely affecting the agricultural production and food security in
Bangladesh. Much more alarmingly, it is expected that Sea Level Rise will further
deteriorate the agriculture sector in future. The fall of rice production in the coastal
zones already indicates a disturbing situation under the already changing climatic
elements. A number of studies have been under taken to explore the impacts, the
adaptation measures being taken and that can be taken, vulnerability of the people
living in these areas, and the loss and damages imposed upon the agricultural sector
in the coastal zones. Both quantitative and qualitative tools were applied to measure
agricultural productivity and vulnerability in the study locations. This paper is
mainly based on the review of such recent studies on climate change and agriculture
related issues in the coastal areas. It shows that cyclonic events (e.g. Cyclone Sidr
2007 and Cyclone Aila 2009) and the associated salinity intrusion have drastically
affected the agricultural production (mainly rice and vegetables) in most of the
coastal districts. According to a recent study, 86 % households believe that the local
rice production (aman) has decreased because of salinity intrusion in soil in the
study villages.
Keywords Cyclone Sidr • Cyclone Aila • Agriculture • Food security • Coastal zone
Md.G. Rabbani (*)
Environment and Climate Change Division, Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies
(BCAS), Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: golam.rabbani@bcas.net
A.A. Rahman • Z.M. Khan
Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies (BCAS), Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: atiq.rahman@bcas.net; zoheb.mahmud@bcas.net
I.J. Shoef
Data Management Division, Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies (BCAS),
Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: ishtiaque.shoef@yahoo.com
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_10
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
173
174
10.1
Md.G. Rabbani et al.
Introduction
Climate Change, and the variability issues associated with it, adversely affects the
water resources of Bangladesh, as it does in most countries, causing a dramatical
reduction of agricultural crops. This adversity is occurring almost all over the
country, including the coastal regions. The rural communities, especially the poor
farmers, may be the worst victims of such climatic phenomena. The impacts of
climate change on the food security of developing countries like Bangladesh may be
comparatively higher because of the dire dependency on agriculture for livelihood
earning, and low resilience to climate induced and other kinds of disasters, mainly
due to educational, economical and technological aspects.
Bangladesh has developed various cultivars in an attempt to become resistant to
a number of climate-induced hazards, including floods (submergence), drought and
salinity intrusion. However, all these new cultivars have only been able to adapt to a
certain level. For example, BINA 8 is the rice cultivar that can resist salinity levels
of 8–12 dS/m. This has been a blessing in disguise for the farmers of Bangladesh,
since many farmers had to suffer immensely right after Cyclone Sidr and Cyclone
Aila, before 2010, because of the lack of cultivars that could withstand moderate to
high levels of salinity (>8 dS/m).
This paper reviews a number of studies, conducted to explore impacts, adaptation and vulnerability in the agriculture, food security and other related issues in
the coastal zones. Sets of quantitative and qualitative tools were applied to measure
agricultural productivity and vulnerability in the locations that these studies were
conducted in. Secondary data and literature were also reviewed to complement
the findings of the field level studies. In these studies, the selected villages were the
most vulnerable and affected sub-districts in the coastal zones. The survey tool was
developed in consultation with relevant experts to make it consistent with the subject and local context. The qualitative tools including FGDs and in-depth interviews
helped to get details on the issues and verify the responses from the survey. However,
this paper reviews and focuses only on the agricultural and food security parts of
the studies.
10.2
Climate Change, the Coast and Agriculture
The coastal zone is under serious threat from climate change. It is evident that variations in temperature, erratic rainfall behavior (late onset, excessive rainfall over a
short period, lack of rainfall in particular times of the season, and so on), cyclonic
events, storm surge induced salinity intrusion and potential sea level rise (SLR) will
all affect the coastal zones in hostile ways. According to the National Adaptation
Programme of Action (MOEF 2005), Bangladesh could face a sea-level rise of
32 cm by the year 2050. The sea level at Hiron Point, near the Sundarbans, has been
rising at 5.3 mm a year over the period of 1977–2002 (CEGIS 2006). Other stations
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
10 Climate Change and Food Security in Vulnerable Coastal Zones of Bangladesh
175
along the Bangladesh coastline also show an increasing trend of sea levels (SMRC
2003). In the near future, low-lying coastal lands may well gradually inundate,
affecting all agricultural activities, wetlands ecosystems and other infrastructure,
unless they are solidly protected. Saline water intrusion stands as one of the major
physical impacts of sea-level rise on the coastal areas of Bangladesh. Salt water
is already intruding into fresh water sources and reservoirs in these areas, and
increasing the soil and water salinity levels in many districts in the southern part of
the country (Islam 2004). It has been found that the children living in 11 coastal
districts of Bangladesh have severe malnutrition, and their percentage is much
higher than that of the national average.
A recent World Bank report shows that Bangladesh will most likely face the
largest impacts due to SLR (World Bank 2007). Another report shows that 40 % of
the Sundarbans will be submerged if the sea level rises by 25 cm, and the whole of
the Sundarbans will disappear in the event of an SLR above 60 cm (Hare 2003).
Figure 10.1 shows that area likely to be affected by 1 m sea level rise in Bangladesh.
In fact, the SLR is likely to inundate the coastal wetlands, lowlands, and accentuate
coastal erosion. Furthermore, it may increase the frequency and severity of floods,
create drainage and irrigation problems and finally dislocate millions of people
from their homes and occupations (Rahman et al. 2007). An estimation, based on a
coarse digital terrain model and global population distribution data, shows that
more than 1 million people will be directly affected by SLR by 2050 in each of
the Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna deltas in Bangladesh (Ericson et al. 2006;
Cruz et al. 2007).
To add to this rather frightening scenario envisioned in these reports, salinity has
already become one of the major problems for the coastal zones of Bangladesh. The
assumptions that experts put to this are pointed at low flows of fresh water from the
Ganges and the ingress of salt water from Bay of Bengal. As mentioned before, this
is already affecting the production levels of rice and vegetables in these areas drastically, and the farmers are facing rather acute risks to their own food securities.
So, it can be said, with some level of certainty, that the compound effects of SLR
and salinity, in the not too distant future, may disrupt agriculture (e.g. reduction of
rice), mangroves including the Sunderbans and coastal wetland ecosystems, including
ponds that support supplementary small scale irrigation for farmers. The recent
reports also state that the coastal communities may suffer even more, with water
borne diseases and other physical problems (e.g. menstruation problems of the
women in these area, from drinking saline water) due to SLR and salinity intrusion
(Rabbani et al. 2012).
Generally, main crop agriculture, at the national level, includes Rice crops (Boro,
Aman and Aus), Jute, Cotton, Sugarcane, Pulses, and different types of Vegetables.
In the coastal zones, however, the main crops include rice (Boro and Aman),
Sugarcane, Pulses and Vegetables. Some other crops are being cultivated on a
smaller scale. At the national level, the agricultural sector contributes 43.6 % of the
total labour force. Although the contribution of the agricultural sector of the coast
to the GDP of the country is not known, the crop production, especially rice production in the coastal regions show a decreasing trend over the last several years.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Md.G. Rabbani et al.
176
Fig. 10.1 Area likely to be affected by 1 m sea level rise in Bangladesh
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Rice Production (Million Ton)
10 Climate Change and Food Security in Vulnerable Coastal Zones of Bangladesh
177
40
35
30
25
National Production
(Million T)
20
15
Coastal Production
(Million T)
10
5
0
2007
2008
2009
Year
2010
2011
Rate of change (%)
Fig. 10.2 Total production of rice at national level and coastal zone between 2007 and 2011
25
20
15
10
National Production
5
0
Coastal Production
2007
(Base
Year)
2008
2009
2010
2011
Year
Fig. 10.3 Rate of changes in rice production at national level and coastal zone in different years
(2008–2011)
According to agricultural statistics, Fig. 10.2 shows that the rice production at
the national level had increased from 27 Million tons in 2007 to over 33 Million tons
in 2011, while it increased only 7 Million tons to 8 Million tons in the coastal zone
in the respective years (BBS 2008, 2010, 2012; Huq and Rabbani 2011).
The rates of changes in rice production in different years at national level and in
coastal the zone show variations during 2007–2011. This indicates that the rate of
change in rice production at national level from 2007 (base year) to 2008 was about
6 % while it was less than 1 % in the coastal zones (Fig. 10.3). It also indicates that
the rate of change in rice production at the national level remained higher than that
of the coastal zones in each of the years from 2008 to 2011.
According to the farmers of some of the coastal districts e.g. Satkhira, the yield
of traditional cultivars has decreased and the Aus rice variety is gradually disappearing
from the mentioned district. This, quite obviously, is happening because of salinity
intrusion in both water and soil resources. The salinity intrusion caused by both rapid
onset events (e.g. cyclones and storm surges) and slow onset events (e.g. SLR) are
affecting agricultural land, resulting in reduction of crop yields (Rabbani et al. 2010).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
178
Md.G. Rabbani et al.
Area of crop damage (ha)
1200000
1000000
800000
600000
400000
Area of crop
Damage (ha)
200000
0
1985
1991
1994 1997
Year
1997
2007
Fig. 10.4 Area of crop damages due to major cyclonic events between 1985 and 2007 in the coast
The following Fig. 10.4, indicates the area of damage to crops due to different major
cyclones between 1985 and 2007. In 2007, the cyclone Sidr damaged crops over an
area of about 0.1 Million ha, 60 % higher than the total crop damaged area in 1991
(BBS 2012). It shows that the total damage of crops in terms of area due to Cyclone
Sidr in 2007 was much higher than that of the previous years.
10.3
10.3.1
Climate Change and Food Security Issues:
Observations/Evidences from Different Coastal
Districts of Bangladesh
Case Study-1
A study was conducted on the households of four villages in the Shyamnagar
Upazilla, under the Satkhira district in 2012. The total number of respondents for
the study was 360. This study found that about 27 % of households suffered from a
deficiency of food in the year before 2011 (Rabbani et al. 2013). In addition to this,
sea level rise cause inundation of more area which is already reported by scientist.
Therefore, damage of agricultural crops will be more acute in future (Anik and
kabir 2012).
Figure 10.5 shows that the population in the study areas suffers from food shortages more or less all around the year. It also clearly indicates that the food shortage
remains high in the months of August and September of the year, as related by 68 %
of the HHs. It is at the lowest in December (3 %). The farmers usually cultivate the
main rice crop (Aman) during monsoon to early winter (June–December).
The farmers also cultivate some other crops including rice and vegetables during
December–May. Incidentally, harvesting of Aman rice and vegetables in late post
monsoon and early winter (November/December) helps them to avoid food scarcity,
and they can continue living on the food stock that comes from this up till early
monsoon (June/July). However, other sources of income remain low during the
months of August–September, because this period actually relates to the profound
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Respondents ( %)
10 Climate Change and Food Security in Vulnerable Coastal Zones of Bangladesh
179
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Month
Fig. 10.5 Percentage of HHs facing food deficit during different months of the year
rainy season in the coastal zone. Among the study villages, Tengrakhali village was
found to be the worst victim of food shortages, as mentioned by 72 % of the study
HHs. Moreover, more than 80 % of the HHs mentioned that severe food crises have
affected them at least ten times in last 10 years. Many of the respondents mentioned
the low production of the rice due to the increased salinity in the soil, late rainfall,
seasonal drought and damage of crops and vegetables because of excessive rainfall
in short bursts. It was reported that the food shortage is becoming an increasingly
critical issue for the study areas.
10.3.2
Case Study-2
Cyclones have a devastating effect on the rice production in the coastal areas of
Bangladesh also. For example, in 2007, due to cyclone SIDR the cultivated area of
rice and consequent rice production declined at a great scale (Anik and Kabir 2012).
Another study was conducted in 16 villages of five Upazillas in five vulnerable
coastal districts in 2012. This study targeted 750 HHs from the respective villages
of five coastal districts in the south, which includes Satkhira (Shyamnagar Upazilla),
Bagerhat (Mongla), Patuakhali (Kalapara), Khulna (Koyra) and Cox’s Bazar
(Teknaf). According to the study, on average, 89 % of the respondents mentioned
that the disasters that are occurring are really affecting the damage of agriculture
production resulting in the food crisis in the villages (Fig. 10.6). The households of
Mongla remain the worst hit from food shortage as indicated by 99 % respondents
(highest), while the least affected people were found in Shyamnagar (71 %, lowest).
It was also found that damaged crops and livestock due to the last disaster
affected the communities. Most of the respondents (above 89 %) mentioned that
crop damage due to Cyclone Aila caused the food shortage in 2009/2010 in all of
the study locations (Fig. 10.7). Livestock was also hard hit in the study villages,
mentioned by 70 % of the respondents. It may be noted that poultry farming/rearing
is one of the most important livelihood options, especially for the women in the
rural areas.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Md.G. Rabbani et al.
180
100%
Respondents (%)
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
Mongla
Teknaf
Koyra
Kalapara
Shyamnagar
Study Upazilla
Respondents (%)
Fig. 10.6 Percentage of respondents on disaster and food security in study coastal districts
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
House
Crops
Livestock
Type of damaged item
Fig. 10.7 Percentage of respondents on the type of damaged assets due to last disaster in the study
coastal districts
Table 10.1 Food availability all around the year in the study locations
District
Bagerhat
Bhola
Lakshmipur
Coastal total
10.3.3
Upazila
Mongla
Rampal
Manpura
Kamal nagar
Is the quantity of produced food
sufficient to meet your needs?
(% said No)
64.0
54.7
43.4
56.0
53.6
Did you face food crisis
in the previous year?
(% said Yes)
88.0
78.7
91.8
82.7
85.5
Case Study-3
Table 10.1 provides the state of food availability in 22 hard to reach villages
(very remote areas) of five Upazillas in three coastal districts of Bangladesh.
A Two-stage-Cluster Sampling procedure was adopted in selecting samples for
the household study. The study considered the village under a union (lowest administrative unit of the country) as the first stage-cluster and the beneficiary household
as the ultimate sampling unit. The study covering 422 households found that the
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
10 Climate Change and Food Security in Vulnerable Coastal Zones of Bangladesh
181
Table 10.2 What type of damage did you incur in the last disaster faced by your HH?
Types of
damaged assets
House
Crops
Livestock
WatSan
Others
Total
% of HHs reported damage
in natural disaster
77
29
30
52
4
84
Avg. value (per reporting HH)
of the damaged assets (US$)
104
119
94
10
52
178
community suffers from food crisis in different months of the year. In fact, about
54 % of the study households (on average) mentioned that the food that they
produce do not nearly meet their needs. On an average, more than 85 % of the
respondents stated that they had to face food crisis in the year before (2011).
The study also indicated that the last disaster severely affected the communities.
According to the estimate by Department of Agricultural Extension of Bangladesh,
the loss in rice equivalent is found at 1.23 Million tons, with 535,707 tons in the four
severely affected districts, 555,997 tons in badly affected 9 districts and 203,600
tons in moderately affected 17 districts in Bangladesh. More than 29 % of the study
households were affected by the last disaster (Table 10.2). Average value per
reporting household of the damaged crops due to the last disaster was found to
be 119 US Dollars.
10.4
State of Adaptation on the Agricultural Sector
The Government of Bangladesh has introduced a set of crop cultivars that are resilient to climate-induced hazards like salinity. Three rice varieties are grown in three
different seasons: Aus, Aman and Boro (Rabbani et al. 2012). The season of Boro
refers to the cultivation that takes place in the months of December to May. In the
case of the cultivars that are farmed during this season, the seeds are sown first, and
then transplanted and the production has to be irrigated.
The season of Aus starts in April and ends in August. In Bangladesh, these
months are known for the monsoons, and the crops grown at Aus thus are rain fed.
June to December is known as the Aman season. This is the time of the year when
most natural, climate-related hazards hit the country, and harvests are often affected
as well. Productivity of Aman rice is particularly low in most of these coastal areas
because of excessive flooding (either partial or complete) and less adoption of suitable high yielding varieties (HYV) of rice (Rahman 2012). Some varieties of Aman
are scattered and raised, while others are transplanted. The yield of Aman is greater
than those grown in Aus and lower than those grown in Boro.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Md.G. Rabbani et al.
182
Rice Farmers Are Adapting with High Salinity in the Coastal Region
of Bangladesh!
Porimal Mondol (age ~40), a rice farmer of village-Harinagar, UnionMunshiganj, Upazilla-Shyamnagar, District Satkhira was struggling with
traditional rice varieties during early 2001. The BRRI 28 production was
constantly decreasing during 2001–2007. Mr. Mondal nearly tripled his rice
yields in 2008, In 2010, the latest saline tolerant variety BINA 8 was practiced
by only 4–5 farmers in the village. Two years later, about 150 farmers had
attempted to grow BINA 8. Porimal says, “we grow 4.7 to 4.9 tons of rice/ha
with BINA 8 now”.
A similar rate of production was obtained from BRRI 47 in the same area.
Mr. Modal says, “We prefer cultivation of BRRI 28 because it looks thin,
attractive, low duration and we are habituated with this kind of rice”.
But due to increase of salinity in the soil (above 4 dS/m) in some areas we
are practicing BRRI 47 and BINA 8 (Source: Field visit, 1 June 2012).
The Ministry of Agriculture, and associated Departments and Institutes are
implementing adaptation programmes to address climate change. In addition to the
Annual Development Programme (ADP), these organizations receive financial
support from the Bangladesh Climate Change Trust Fund (BCCTF) and Bangladesh
Climate Resilient Fund (BCCRF) to implement adaptation projects in the agricultural sector.
Seventeen rice varieties developed by the research institutes of the Government
of Bangladesh can withstand submergence (flood), drought and salinity (Table
10.3). Of them, nine varieties are resistant to various levels of salts, two varieties are
flood tolerant and the rest of the total is able to survive in drought conditions. Of the
total saline tolerant varieties, five are being practiced in different vulnerable areas
and the remaining two is said to be going to reach farmers soon (BRRI 53 and
BRRI). The following Table 10.3 shows the climate resistant rice varieties in
Bangladesh.
10.5
Conclusion
In order to mitigate the adverse impacts of climate change on food sector, we need
to analyze the possible options that could assist in increasing food security.
Therefore, adaptation in the agriculture sector must be well integrated with both the
broad national development goals and livelihood priorities at the local level.
The coastal zone is extremely vulnerable because of a number of climatic factors.
These include variations in temperature, erratic behavior of rainfall, cyclonic events,
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
10 Climate Change and Food Security in Vulnerable Coastal Zones of Bangladesh
183
Table 10.3 Climate related stress tolerant rice varieties developed by the BRRI and BINA for the
coastal region and Bangladesh
Climate tolerant
Growth
Average yield
rice variety
duration (days)
(ton/ha)
BRRI dhan 51
142–154
4
BRRI dhan 52
145–155
4.5
Salinity in soil, surface
BRRI dhan 40
145
4.5
and ground water
BRRI dhan 41
148
4.5
BR 10
150
5.5
BRRI 28
140
6.0
BR 23
150
5.5
BRRI dhan 27
115
4
BRRI dhan 47
152
6.0
BINA-8
130–135
5.0
BRRI 53 (proposed)
140
5.0
BRRI 54 (proposed)
140
5.0
Drought
BRRI dhan 55
145
7.0
(also saline tolerant)
BRRI dhan 57
100
4.0
BRRI dhan 42
100
3.5
BRRI dhan 43
100
3.5
BRRI dhan 33
118
4.5
BRRI dhan 39
122
4.5
Source: updated from Huq and Rabbani (2011), BRRI (2014), Mazumdar (2011), The Financial
Express (2011), Salam et al. (2011), and The Daily Star (2010)
Climate related stress
Flood (submergence)
droughts and salinity intrusion. The potential sea level rise, predicted to happen,
may aggravate the vulnerability of the local communities especially in the coastal
zones. Currently, the cyclones, accompanied by storm surges and increase of salinity intrusion in the water and soils of the area, are the major catastrophic phenomena
for the coastal communities.
The coastal region of Bangladesh is deprived of the technological advancement
in agriculture. Only very few agricultural technologies are suitable to adopt directly
in the coastal saline areas of Bangladesh. All these climatic hazards critically affect
the agricultural production, inevitably resulting in crisis of food in most of the
coastal districts. This in turn leads on to various other secondary impacts and it has
become absolutely necessary to strengthen the technological innovations that are
being used at present for agriculture and for adaptation, building of the capacities of
the local government officials and farmers to adapt and sustain agricultural practices
in these vulnerable coastal zones.
Baseline and Needs Assessment surveys need to be conducted in these areas,
with specific focus on the varying disasters and hazards like salinity, and diversified,
saline and flood resistant varieties of crops need to be introduced to them.
Furthermore, proper dissemination of information to the farmers of these areas
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
184
Md.G. Rabbani et al.
needs to be done, in order for them to be able to adapt to the new and varying
technology being introduced to them. Early warning systems, crop-based weather
and flood forecasting systems, improved drainage, and an immediate introduction
of technological innovations like floating agriculture need to be implemented in
these areas, not only to ensure the unimpeded development and food security of the
coastal zones, but also to ensure that the whole of Bangladesh continues to receive
the support that the coastal zone provides.
References
Anik SI, Kabir MH (2012) Climate change and food security, elusive progress: state of food
security in Bangladesh. Shrabon Prokashani, Dhaka, pp 7–12
Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (2008) Yearbook of agricultural statistics of Bangladesh. Statistics
Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of Bangladesh, Dhaka
Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (2010) Yearbook of agricultural statistics of Bangladesh. Statistics
Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of Bangladesh, Dhaka
Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (2012) Yearbook of agricultural statistics of Bangladesh. Statistics
Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of Bangladesh, Dhaka
BRRI (2014) BRRI’s 40 years achievements. Bangladesh Rice Research Institute. Accessed 15
July 2014. http://www.brri.gov.bd
CEGIS (2006) Impact of sea level rise on land use suitability and adaptation options. Report
prepared for the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of Bangladesh; Centre for
Environment and Geographic Information Services, Dhaka
Cruz RV, Harasawa H, Lal M, Wu S, Anokhin Y, Punsalmaa B, Honda Y, Jafari M, Li C, Huu Ninh
N (2007) Asia. In: Parry ML, Canziani OF, Palutikof JP, van der Linden PJ, Hanson CE (eds)
Climate change 2007: impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. Contribution of working group II
to the fourth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, UK
Cyclone Sidr (2007) Cyclone Sidr affected most of the coastal districts of Bangladesh on 15
November 2007
Cyclone Aila (2009) Cyclone Aila mostly affected South West coast of the country on 24 May
2009
Ericson JP, Vorosmarty CJ, Dingman SL, Ward LG, Meybeck M (2006) Effective sea-level rise and
deltas: causes of change and human dimension implications. Global Planet Change 50:63–82
Hare W (2003) Assessment of knowledge on impacts of climate change—contribution to the specification of article 2 of the UNFCCC: impacts on ecosystems, food production, water and socioeconomic systems. German Advisory Council on Global Change, Berlin
Huq S, Rabbani G (2011) Adaptation technologies in agriculture: the economics of rice-farming
technology in climate –vulnerable areas of Bangladesh. In: Christiansen L, Olhoff A, Traerup
S (eds) Technologies for adaptation: perspectives and practical experiences. UNEP, Roskilde
Islam MR (2004) Where land meets the sea: a profile of the coastal zone of Bangladesh.
The University Press Limited, Dhaka
Mazumdar MLH (2011) Adapting agriculture to climate change. The Daily Star of 1 Jan 2011.
http://archive.thedailystar.net/newDesign/news-details.php?nid=168249. Accessed 8 Sept 2013
Ministry of Environment and Forests (2005) National adaptation programme of action (NAPA):
final report. Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of the People’s Republic of
Bangladesh, Dhaka. http://www.moef.gov.bd/. Accessed 7 July 2014
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
10 Climate Change and Food Security in Vulnerable Coastal Zones of Bangladesh
185
Rabbani MG, Rahman AA, Islam N (2010) Climate change and sea level rise: issues and
challenges for coastal communities in the India Ocean region, published Stimson Centre
Publication, Washington. http://www.stimson.org/rv/pdf/Coastal_Zones_PDF/Coastal_ZonesChapter_2.pdf
Rabbani G, Rahman SH, Faulkner L (2012) Impacts of climatic hazards on the small wetland
ecosystems (ponds): evidence from some selected areas of coastal Bangladesh. Sustainability
5:1510–1521
Rabbani G, Rahman A, Mainuddin K (2013) Salinity-induced loss and damage to farming households in coastal Bangladesh. Int J Global Warm 5(4):400–415
Rahman MM (2012) Enhancement of resilience of coastal community in Bangladesh through crop
diversification in adaptation to climate change impacts. BRAC University, Dhaka, p 4
Rahman A, Alam M, Alam S, Uzzaman MR, Rashid M, Rabbani MG (2007) Risks, vulnerability
and adaptation in Bangladesh, a background paper prepared for UNDP Human Development
Report 2007
SAARC Meteorological Research Centre (SMRC) (2003) The vulnerability assessment of the
SAARC coastal region due to sea level rise: Bangladesh case, vol 3, SMRC. SMRC Publications,
Dhaka
Salam MA, Rahman MA, Bhuiyan MAR, Uddin K, Sarker MRA (2011) BRRI dhan 47: a salttolerant variety for the boro season. Plant Breeding Division; and R. Yasmeen and M.S. Rahman,
Plant Physiology Division, Bangladesh Rice Research Institute, Gazipur 1701, Bangladesh.
http://dspace.irri.org:8080/dspace/bitstream/10269/112/1/v.32%281%29Soil.pdf. Accessed 3
Sept 2011
The Daily Star (2010) Two salinity tolerant varieties of T-Aman paddy soon. 18 July 2010. http://
www.thedailystar.net/newDesign/news-details.php?nid=147255. Accessed 29 Aug 2013
The Financial Express (2011) BRRI releases 2 new stress-tolerant rice varieties. http://www.
thefinancialexpress-bd.com/more.php?news_id=132106&date=2011-04-10. Accessed 10 July 2013
World Bank (2007) The impact of sea level rise on developing countries: a comparative analysis,
World Bank policy research working paper 4136, World Bank, Washington, DC
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective
from Southwestern Coastal Region
of Bangladesh
Abu Zofar Md. Moslehuddin, Md. Anwarul Abedin, Mostafa A.R. Hossain,
and Umma Habiba
Abstract Bangladesh has a primarily agrarian economy. Agriculture is the single
largest producing sector of the economy. Soil is the predominant aspect for a successful crop production; whereas, good soil health is a prerequisite for sustainable
agriculture and food security. On the other hand, more than 30 % of the cultivable
land in Bangladesh is in the coastal area. Out of 2.86 million hectares (ha) of coastal
and off-shore lands about 1.056 million ha of arable lands are affected by varying
degrees of salinity. Hence, this chapter would deal with status of soil parameters
including soil salinity, its threat to sustainable crop production and food securities.
Then the focus shifts to find out possible ways and few recommendations towards
improving the soil health as well as reduction of the risk in southwestern coastal
region of Bangladesh.
Keywords Soil • Coastal belt • Bangladesh • Salinity intrusion • Crop production •
Livelihood • Adaptation • Mitigation measures
11.1
Introduction
Bangladesh, with a booming population of about 160 million, is one of the poorest
and globally number one vulnerable countries to climate change impacts and disaster. A number of natural hazards including floods, cyclone and storm surges, tidal
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin (*) • Md.A. Abedin
Department of Soil Science, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh
e-mail: abunazia@yahoo.com; masumagriculture@yahoo.com
M.A.R. Hossain
Department of Fish Biology & Genetics, Bangladesh Agricultural University,
Mymensingh, Bangladesh
e-mail: marhossain@bau.edu.bd
U. Habiba
Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture, Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: shimuagri@yahoo.com
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_11
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
187
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
188
surges and resulting intrusion of saline water, water logging, drought, river bank
erosion have long been affecting the country almost every year. These calamitous
events significantly hinder the agriculture sector of the country and its economic
and social development through two major ways- firstly, damaging the crops, livestock, fisheries and forestry, natural resources, production systems and infrastructures and secondly, pulling back the ongoing growth, developments and domestic
and transboundary trade.
In the light of coastal Bangladesh, people have been suffering from lack of food
security. Lower crop productivity and less cropping intensity are the main reasons
for increasing food insecurity in this region. Like other parts of the country, dominant land use in coastal Bangladesh is agriculture. The gross and the net area used
for crop farming in the coastal zone of Bangladesh is 144,085 and 83,416 ha,
respectively (Islam 2004). The net-farming area of coastal Bangladesh, however,
has been gradually decreasing over the years due to various reasons and the most
common one has been the land inundation and salinity intrusion by tidal water (Seal
and Baten 2012). Besides, there are many reasons such as increased salinity,
increased incidences of pests & diseases, erratic rainfall, higher temperature,
drought, tidal surges, cyclone, submergence, large fallow lands/water bodies, land
degradation, poor road network, poor marketing facilities and unemployment with
long-term cumulative effects of soil-related constraints, climate risks and socioeconomic problems those impede the food production and distribution in this region
(Rahman 2012). As most people in the coast have only seasonal employment and do
not have job opportunities round the year, crop farmers, fish farmers, fishers and
others suffer from the lack of alternative livelihood strategies and their food security
situation is vulnerable and is a matter of grave concern. Majority of the people in
coastal areas are involved in crop cultivation, fish farming and fishing and they
remain frequently unemployed due to tidal water surge and other natural disasters
resulting food insecurity in the entire coast.
However, Bangladesh has made a remarkable progress in the last three decades
towards achieving self-sufficiency in food grains due to substantial intensification
of cropping, introduction of high yielding crop varieties, expansion of irrigated
areas and increased use of chemical fertilizers. But recently, declining or stagnation
of major crop yields have been recorded due to cumulative effects of many soilrelated constraints and climatic risks viz. depletion of soil organic matter, imbalanced use of fertilizers, nutrient mining, degradation of soil physical and chemical
properties, erratic rainfall, temperature rise, droughts, floods, soil salinity, water
salinity, tidal surges, water logging, cyclone, scanty use of bio and organic fertilizers and poor management practices. The proportion of different nutrients used in
agriculture without soil testing in recent years is highly deleterious to soil
productivity.
Since crop production is a complex function of many factors like crop, soil, environment and production management practices. On the other hand, Bangladesh is
located in a climatically vulnerable position and is impacted by natural calamities.
Therefore, this chapter provides an overview of southwestern coastal Bangladesh. It
further depicts the status and extent of soil characteristics, the underlying causes
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
189
and how crop production is affected. Based on the findings, this chapter then
concludes and gives some recommendations to improve crop production as well as
to enhance food security of this region.
11.2
Linkage Between Soil Health and Food Security
There is a strong link between soil health and food safety. Soil contains a number of
minerals, usually in balanced amounts, providing essential nutrients for plants and
animals and eventually for humans. There are two scenarios in which this synergy
of plants, animals and humans lacks reasonable equilibrium. Firstly, soils may contain insufficiency in (too little) or surplus of (too much) nutrients, which eventually
reflect in the supply to, as well as health of plants, animals and humans. This is usually the outcome of inheritance from the parent rocks, which have released either
too much or too little of a particular component into the soil resulting imbalance in
nutrient supply. The situations can be a major setback for soil health and for all
those what/who live and rely on soil. Many of the soils that are subject to insufficiency/surplus problems globally are now reasonably fairly recognized and well
addressed, particularly in the developed nations.
A more significant difficulty arises when human misuse/abuse the soil leading to
pollution or contamination. Most of the problems relate to increased industrialization and urbanization, over the last several centuries in the developed world, when
much damage has been done to soils, leaving a legacy of pollutants and contaminants. In the present days, rapid industrialization in many developing countries is
unleashing the similar effect, with much pollution going unchecked, leading to
severe land degradation. Misuse of soil in this way interacts with the ability of soil
to meet safety standards and has jeopardized the crop production.
Now food safety and nutritional security is a major global issue. Soil has the
most crucial role in securing this food safety and security because it has many different functions, including adsorption of nutrients, filtering, leaching, flow control,
storage and amelioration. Many of these functions are imperative in planning food
security. Understanding of the properties of soils, the processes operating within
them, and their distribution in the landscape, is essential for the management of
contaminants and would-be soil pollutants in the soil system with respect to food
safety and security.
11.3
Scenario of Bangladesh Coast
The coastal area covers an area of 20 % of total Bangladesh. In terms of administrative consideration, 19 districts out of 64 are considered as coastal districts (BBS
2011; MoEF 2007). The country has coastline of about 710 km along the Bay of
Bengal (MoWR 2005). It extends inside up to 150 km from the coast. The country
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
190
Fig. 11.1 Map showing coastal area of Bangladesh
covers three discrete coastal regions – western, central, and eastern coastal zones
which are shown in Fig. 11.1.
The western part is known as Ganges tidal plain, comprises of semi-active delta
and is criss-crossed by innumerous channels and creeks. The topography is very low
and flat. Average land elevation is below 1.5 m MSL. The southwestern part of the
region is covered by the world’s largest mangrove forest (6,017 km2), popularly
known as Sundarbans. The mangrove forests act as barriers to the furiousness of
tropical cyclones and storm surges. Erosion is comparatively small in this region but
it suffers from salinity intrusion and tidal flooding (Karim and Mimura 2006). The
Sundarbans was declared by the UNESCO as a natural world heritage site in 1997
(Islam 2008). The central region is the most active one, and this area suffers from
continuous erosion and accretion (Karim and Mimura 2006). The very active
Meghna River estuary situates in this region. The combined flow of three powerful
rivers – namely, the Ganges, the Brahmaputra, and the Meghna, are commonly
called as the GBM river system and ranked as one of the largest river systems in the
world – discharges with the name as Lower Meghna into the northeastern corner of
the Bay of Bengal. This estuarial region suffers from the most disastrous effects of
tropical cyclones and storm surges in the world (Ali 1999; Karim and Mimura
2006). The GBM river systems carry 85 % of the total dry season flow passing
through the coastal zone of Bangladesh (Islam 2008) and carry an estimated annual
sediment load of about 2.5 million MT. The sediments are subjected to coastal
dynamic process and lead to recreation and erosion in the coastal area of Bangladesh.
This complex geographical phenomenon introduces rather slow mutative changes in
the coast; of various effects, new land formation is a significant factor in influencing
physical and socio-economic scenario of the coastal zone. Besides, the eastern
region has higher elevation and this zone is relatively stable part among other coastal
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
191
regions in the country. The world longest natural sand beach, Cox’s Bazar (120 km)
is situated in this region (Karim and Mimura 2006).
The coastline is involving coastal and island communities of about 50 million
people, nearly one-third of the total population of Bangladesh (Miyan 2009).
Fishing, agriculture, shrimp farming, salt farming and tourism are the main economic drivers in this area. The Sunderban is a major source of subsistence for
almost ten million people (Islam and Haque 2004). Main activities in Sunderban are
fishing, wood and honey collection. Almost 10,000 household in the area have neither homestead land nor cultivable land. On the contrary, more than one million
households in this area have only homestead but no cultivable land (Islam 2004).
However, people’s live and livelihood of this coastal area is frequently affected by
sea level rise induced disastrous hazards, e.g. cyclone and storm surge, flooding and
salinity intrusion. Most of the people of the coastal area lost their lives or injured in
cyclonic storms, primarily as a result of the water surges.
11.4
Status and Extent of Soil Condition
in Bangladesh Coast
As a deltaic country, over 30 % of the net cultivable area of Bangladesh is in the
coastal region. Out of 2.85 million ha of the coastal and off-shore areas, about 0.828
million ha of the arable lands, that constitutes about 52.5 % of the net cultivable area
in 64 upazilas (sub-districts) of 13 districts. A part of the coastal area, the Sundarbans,
the largest contiguous mangrove of the world is a reserve natural forest covering
about 4,500 km2. The rest of the coastal area is used in agriculture. The vast cultivable areas, however, are under severe threat of risks and vulnerabilities of the climate change and agricultural production has been rapidly declining due to climate
risk factors. Saline water intrusion, sea level rise, water logging, cyclone and storm
surges are some of the major climatic hazards affecting the low lying coastal areas
of the country.
11.4.1
Physiography
Tidal and estuarine floodplains cover almost 98 % of the coastal area of Bangladesh.
Only 2 % areas with river floodplains and peat basins is observed in the northern
part of the coast. Tidal floodplains occur in Satkhira, Khulna, Bagerhat, Pirozpur,
Jhalokhati, Barisal, Patuakhali, Chittagong and Cox’s Bazar district covering a total
of 1.865 million ha or about 65 % of the total coast. Estuarine floodplains occur in
Noakhali, Bhola and Patuakhali districts and in the north-western part of Chittagong
district with an area coverage of about 0.937 million ha or about 33 % of the coastal
area (Hauqe 2006).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
192
11.4.2
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
Land Characteristics
The coastal saline area lies about 1.5–11.8 m above the average sea level. The
Ganges river meander floodplain systems are standing higher than the adjoining
tidal plain. The tidal floodplain has a characteristic, almost level landscape crisscrossed by innumerable interconnecting tidal rivers, creeks and canals. The estuarine islands are continuously changing shape and position as a result of river erosion
and new alluvial deposition. Peat basins are located in some of the low lying areas
between the Ganges river floodplains and tidal floodplains occurring in the western
part of Khulna (Karim et al. 1982). The areas are subject to annual flooding in the
monsoon and water logging is common in parts of the basin areas in the dry season.
Tidal flooding through a network of tidal creeks and drainage channels connected to
the main river system inundates the soil and impregnates them with soluble salts
thereby rendering both the top and subsoil saline (Haque 2006).
11.4.3
Hydrology
The most important feature of hydrology in relation to agricultural development is
the seasonal shallow flooding (up to 90 cm) which affects about 64 % of the total
area. Flood water here recedes from October to late December. Depending on topographical position and drainage facilities, water recede from about 24 % area within
October, from about 53 % area by November and mid-December and from about
23 % area by late December (Haque 2006). The effect of the tides is manifested in
a regular fluctuation of rise and fall of the water level of the Bay of Bengal and the
estuarine/tidal channels and creeks. The high tide during summer rises up to 1.3 m
above the ground level. On the east coast of the Sundarbans, the highest tide could
inundate lands up to a depth of 2.0 m, where protective embankments are not
erected.
11.4.4
Nutrients in Saline Soils
Soil fertility is the most important factor for crop production. In general the coastal
areas of Bangladesh are rather low in soil fertility. Soil reaction values (pH) range
from 6.0 to 8.4 with the exception of Chittagong and Patuakhali, where the value
is slightly acidic and range between 5.0 s and 7.8. Most of the soils are moderate
to strongly alkaline, the pH values of the surface soils being lower than those of the
subsurface soils. In places with higher pH values as in coastal soils, micronutrients’
deficiencies are expected. The soils in the coast are in general poor in organic matter content. The organic matter content of the top soils ranges from less than 1 to
1.5 %. Presence of the low organic content indicates poor physical condition of the
coastal soils.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
193
The cation-exchange capacity (CEC) of the soils range from 9.4 to 40.6 m.e.%.
The higher CEC values of the soils Khulna and Bagerhat are due to finer texture and
higher organic matter contents. Soils with less than 15.0 m.e.% CEC below is
regarded as of poor status (Singaraval et al. 1996). The soils contain varying levels
of exchangeable bases, but a general characteristic is the higher Ca and K saturation
of the exchange complex compared to Na and Mg in most of the soils. The Na and
Mg saturation of the exchange complex is harmful because they harm the physical
properties of soil and offset plant nutrition. Magnesium has synergistic effect of
plant uptake of Na as well as the antagonistic effect on the uptake of Ca and K. The
total N contents of the coastal soils are generally low, mostly around 0.1 %. The low
N content may be attributed to low organic matter contents of most of the coastal
soils. Available P status ranges between 1 and 25 ppm. Soils with deficient levels of
P are also found in Chttagong, Barguna, Satkhira and Patuakhali districts.
Widespread Zn and Cu deficiencies have also been reported in the coastal regions
(Karim et al. 1990).
11.4.5
Ingression of Soil Salinity
Salinity ingress also causes an increase in soil salinity, especially when farmers
irrigate their lands with slightly saline surface water at the beginning of the low flow
period. SRDI (1997) reported that, soil salinity levels south of Khulna and Bagerhat
towns ranged between 8 and 15 dS/m during the low flow season. It is also reported
that, several subdistricts (such as Kachua, Mollahat, and Fultali) south of the
Sundarbans” known to be non-saline in the pre-Farakka period have began to
develop soil salinity during the low flow seasons of 1980s. The anticipated results
of salinity ingress will be, at a minimum, of the same order for climate change
induced low flow regime compared to similar effects shown by deliberate withdrawal of flows at Farakka barrage. The anticipated sea level rise would produce
salinity impacts in three fronts: surface water, groundwater and soil. Increased soil
salinity due to climate change would significantly reduce food grain production.
Even at present, some parts of coastal lands are not being utilized for crop production, mostly due to soil salinity; and this situation would aggravate further under a
climate change scenario. A modeling exercise has indicated that, under the changed
climate conditions, the index of aridity would increase in winter. Consequently,
higher rates of capillary action from an increased rate of topsoil desiccation would
accentuate the salinity problem.
11.4.6
Sea Level Rise and Salinity Intrusion
A direct consequence of sea level rise would be intrusion of salinity with tide
through the rivers and estuaries. It would be more acute in the dry season, especially
when freshwater flows from rivers would diminish. According to an estimate of the
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
194
Master Plan Organization, about 14,000 km2 of coastal and offshore areas have
saline soils and are susceptible to tidal flooding. If some 16,000 km2 of coastal land
is lost due to a 45 cm rise in sea level, the salinity front would be pushed further
inland. The present interface between freshwater and saline water lies around 120–
160 km inland in the southwest, and this could well be pushed northward as far as
central Jessore region in the event of a sea level rise.
11.4.7
Fertility Status of Coastal Soil
The systematic study on soil fertility status of Bangladesh including the coastal
region is scanty. During 1989–2002, Soil Resources Development Institute (SRDI)
of Bangladesh carried out the soil survey (with soil map). The surveys (1:50,000)
published sub-district (Thana/Upazila) wise Soil and Land Utilization Guide (in
Bengali) (SRDI 1989–2002).
A large number of soil samples were collected from each upazila representing
different soil series for soil fertility status. Values of different parameters for each
upazila including soil pH, Electric Conductivity (EC), organic matter content, and
available status of nitrogen (NH4–N) (or Total N in later reports), phosphorus (P),
potassium (K), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), sulfur (S), iron (Fe), copper (Cu),
manganese (Mn), zinc (Zn) and boron (B) for each of soil samples of a soil series
have been presented in separate tables. The district level data has been prepared
using combined average. Low to very low status of organic matter content indicates
poor status of soil health. Land area having low and very low levels of organic matter and nutrient status in soils (%) of nine coastal districts is presented in Table 11.1.
11.5
Impacts of Climate Change in Coastal Belt
The coastal belt is highly vulnerable due to the climate change. The intensity of
disasters like sea level rise, tidal surge, salinity intrusion and cyclone in coastal belt
is being increased. Among them, the salinity intrusion is a major factor which
impedes the crop production at large in the coastal belt. Water and soil salinity is a
common hazard in many parts of the coastal zone. Consequently, the crop area is
reducing and the cultivation of boro and aus rice, boro and other rabi crops are being
restricted.
According to BCAS’s report (2010), the coastal agriculture is being seriously
affected by different levels of climatic risks caused by integrated effects of the following factors: soil salinity, water salinity, sea level rise, tidal surge, cyclone, heavy
soils, soil wetness/water stagnancy, fallow/seasonal fallow land, incidence of pests
and diseases, poor marketing infrastructure, problem of agro-based industries, poor
health, livelihood, fishermen’s are jobless, migration to cities, unsafe drinking
water, etc.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Name of district
Area (ha)
Org M
Bagharhat
147,655
5.8
Barguna
107,459
51.0
Barisal
183,377
29.5
Bhola
143,404
59.6
Khulna
158,062
4.4
Patuakhali
190,203
48.4
Pirojpur
81,612
15.1
Satkhira
181,521
13.7
Jhalokathi
55,298
41.6
Total
1,248,591
29.0
Source: Data calculated from SRDI (1989–2002)
Ca
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.2
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.02
Mg
0.0
0.0
2.6
0.2
0.0
0.1
11.9
0.0
0.0
1.2
K
8.3
6.2
0.8
5.6
26.1
11.1
32.7
3.2
6.3
10.2
N
93.5
100.0
83.5
100.0
93.1
100.0
94.1
99.7
99.4
95.5
P
69.8
68.0
72.7
93.2
69.6
57.1
86.3
65.6
81.9
71.8
S
0.3
0.0
0.3
0.9
0.3
3.3
0.0
0.9
0.9
0.9
B
0.1
0.0
11.8
4.2
0.9
0.6
1.4
6.2
11.7
3.9
Cu
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
19.0
7.6
0.5
0.0
3.5
Fe
6.4
0.0
0.0
0.0
5.0
0.0
1.0
16.0
0.0
3.8
Mn
1.9
0.0
0.0
0.0
2.6
0.0
0.0
9.6
0.0
1.9
Zn
30.1
23.5
59.6
86.9
26.2
47.9
76.8
28.5
71.8
47.3
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
Table 11.1 Land area having low and very low levels of organic matter and nutrient status in soils (%) of nine coastal districts in Bangladesh
195
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
196
Climate change
risks
• High temperature,
•
•
•
•
•
•
erratic rainfall, late
monsoon and
drought
Sea level rise, tidal
surges
river erosion
Flooding and
intrusion of salt
water
Cyclone/ stormy
weather
Water logging
Incidences of pests
and diseases
Soil-related constraints
• Increasing soil salinity and
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
water salinity
Scarcity of quality irrigation
water during dry season
Heavy soil consistency due to
swelling/cracking clays
Problems of tillage operations
for land preparation
Soil wetness and late drainage
conditions in early dry season
Large fallow lands or water
bodies/seasonal fallow lands
Deficiencies of N,P,S and Zinc
Iron ( Fe) toxicity and arsenic
(As) contamination
Water-logging and drainage
congestion
Socio-economic
factors
• Poor marketing
infrastructure
• Problems of road
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
network and
communication
Problems of agrobased industries
Poor human health and
hygiene
Poor food and nutrition
security
Lack of employment
opportunities
Problems in fishing
activities
Population migration
Unsafe drinking water
Fig. 11.2 Impacts of impacts and vulnerability of coastal agriculture (Adopted from Rahman
2012)
BCAS (2010) also has drawn the long term impacts and vulnerability of coastal
agriculture. Based on their study, presently, coastal agriculture is being seriously
affected by cumulative effects of soil and water related constraints, climatic risks
and socioeconomic problems. These are shown in Fig. 11.2.
However, the major impacts of climate change in agriculture sector of coastal
area are described by BCAS (2010) that are as follows:
Utilization of land in crop agriculture and changes in crops/cropping patterns
Average cropping intensity in the coastal areas has not much increased during
1975–1976 to 2005–2006 and ranges from 155 to 181 % except Bhola and Noakhali
districts due to climate change.
Fallow lands
A sizeable amount of cultivable land (about 30–50 % of NCA of concerned districts) remains fallow in rabi and aus seasons. The main reasons of which are: soil
wetness/water stagnancy, tidal surges, late harvest of T. Aman rice, drought and
increased salinity, expansion of shrimp culture, poultry farm and brick field.
Yield reduction
Rice yield was reduced by 20–40 % in T. Aman season due to erratic rainfall,
increased intensity and frequency of drought, increased salinity, tidal surges,
floods, cyclone, use of local varieties, and increased incidences of pests and diseases. Total yield loss of T. Aman crop has been estimated to about 6.93 lakh ton
per year based on last 5–10 years of climate change scenarios. Similarly, average
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
197
yield level of Boro rice is being affected (30–40 % yield loss) by high temperature
(causing sterility) and increased salinity and that of Aus rice is being affected
(20–40 % yield loss) by tidal surges. Vegetables, pulses, oilseed and fruit crops
are being affected (20–40 % yield loss) by drought, increased salinity, soil wetness, excessive rainfall and water-logging and tidal surges in most coastal districts. BCAS (2010) reported that total crop loss for major crops (cereals, potato,
pulses, oil seeds, vegetables, spices and fruit crops) due to different climate risks
was about 14.05 lakh tons per year based on last 5–10 years of climate change
scenarios within the areas of ten coastal districts.
Changes in annual rainfall
Erratic nature of rainfall, number of days without rainfall and more rain is occurring
in short duration. Total rainfall in Kharif season is decreasing that affects the cultivation of rainfed crops in the coastal region. But the total rainfall during rabi season
is increasing in Noakhali, Cox’s bazaar and Khulna districts that affecting the cultivation of rabi crops.
Changes in temperature
Temperature is generally increasing in the monsoon, average monsoon maximum
and minimum temperatures showed an increasing trend annually 0.03 °C and
0.05 °C respectively. Level of maximum temperature in rabi season is increasing
compared to minimum temperature affecting winter crops.
Increasing soil salinity
There is an increasing trend of pH level due to increasing salinity. The salinity level
has increased almost doubled (EC: 2.8–18.5 to 4.0–42.8 dS/m) in Sharankhola
upazila of Bagerhat district, Dumuria upazila of Khulna district and Shyamnagar
upazila of Satkhira district. FAO (2007) in its research report on adaptation to climate change for sustainable development of Bangladesh agriculture mentioned that
tidal flooding during wet season (June-October), direct inundation by saline or
brackish water and upward or lateral movement of saline groundwater during dry
season (November–January) are the causes of soil salinity development in
Bangladesh. The severity of salinity problem in Bangladesh increases due to shortage of rainfall. Bangladesh has a coastal area of 2.5 million ha. Of which about 1.0
million ha, along the coastal belt, are under salinities of different magnitudes. It is
predicted that Bangladesh may lose a major portion of the coastal areas to sea.
Increasing salt affected areas
Salt affected areas were 750,350 ha in 1973, significantly increased to 950,780 ha
in 2009 (26.71 % increase).
Increasing river water salinity
There is an increasing trend of river water salinity (12.9–24.5 % increase) in
Bishkhali river at Pathorghata point, Andarmanik river at Kalapara point and Payra
river at Taltali point during 2001–2009.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
198
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
Groundwater salinity
There is an increasing trend of groundwater salinity (5.8–25.6 % increase) in
Pirojpur and Bhola districts during 2005–2009.
Increasing vulnerable areas of droughts, floods, river bank erosion and tidal
surges
The study report showed that the vulnerable areas of drought prone, flood prone,
river bank erosion and tidal surges have remarkably increased to 152,285, 114,365,
95,324 and 130,588 ha respectively, in 2008–2009 compared to 1975–1976 due to
climate change. Miah et al. (2004) mentioned that drought is a very well known
natural disaster to the people of Bangladesh. Every year, 3–4 million ha of land are
affected by drought of different magnitudes. Average rainfall becomes less during
the critical growth stages of crops and the crops suffered from soil moisture deficits.
During drought, a heavy loss to aman production affects the farmers’ economy.
About 5.0 million ha of lands are cultivated with aman rice, of which 4.2 million ha
of lands are prone to drought of different intensities.
11.6
Agriculture in Coastal Areas
A number of crops like rice, jute, sugarcane, pulses, oilseeds, spices, vegetables and
fruits are grown in the coastal saline soils, their contributions to cropping intensity
varies to a great extent with regions. Traditionally the farmers cultivate rice in the
Aman season, while multiple cropping is an opportunity in securing food sufficiency. Farmers mostly grow low yielding traditional rice varieties only during the
monsoon (Aman) season spanning July to December. Most of these lands remain
fallow in the dry (Rabi/Boro) and pre-monsoon (Aus) seasons because of perceived
high soil and water salinity and lack of good quality irrigation water (Karim et al.
1990). While farmers of the other parts of Bangladesh benefit from higher farm
productivity and have some option to cover their losses from more or less secure
high yields from Boro rice, about 1.6 million farm families in the coastal saline
areas of Bangladesh have very limited options as they continue to farm under rainfed condition and having above constraints. Crop yields, cropping intensity, production levels and peoples quality of livelihood are much lower in this region than in
other part of the country (BBS 2009). Improvement of Aman rice yields, crop intensification by adding either an Aus or a suitable non-rice crop before or a Boro rice
or a non-rice crop after Aman rice can improve productivity, farmers’ income, and
enhance their livelihoods.
Productivity of Aman rice is particularly low in most of these coastal areas
because of excessive flooding (either partial or complete) and less adoption of suitable high yielding varieties (HYV) of rice. Farmers rely on traditional rice varieties
that are tall, do not respond to inputs and have low yields of 2–2.5 t/ha. Farmers are
reluctant to use HYV because they are short stature, easily submerged and damaged
by tidal fluctuations. But the excess water could easily be drained out during low
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
199
tide through managing the sluice gates of the coastal polders constructed by the
Bangladesh Water Development Board (BWDB). Unfortunately many of the sluices
do not function properly and farmers do not have the knowhow to operate the sluices
properly. Improving drainage in the monsoon season would help in cultivation of
HYV Aman rice and also early establishment of rabi crops in the coastal areas of the
country.
11.7
Salinity: A Major Threat of Crop Production
in Southwestern Coast
In general, soil salinity is believed to be mainly responsible for low land use as well
as a root cause of poor cropping intensity (Rahman and Ahsan 2001). Figure 11.3
depicts how salinity affects on crop production. Since salinity affects certain crops
at critical stages of growth, which in turn reduces the yield substantially and in
Low water potentiality
of Plant
Osmotic Pressure
Poor plant growth
Root uptake
Salinity
Burnt leaves and
dead tissue at the
edge of leaves
Yield Loss
Specific ion effect
Direct foliar
absorption
Higher carbonate
and bicarbonate
Higher pH
Poor iron and
magnesium
Reduced micro
nutrient
availability and
sodium as
dominating ion
Deficiency disease
like lime-induced
chlorosis, an iron
deficiency disease
Fig. 11.3 Schematic diagram of impact of salinity present in irrigation water and soil on crop
production (Source: after Seal and Baten 2012)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
200
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
severe cases total yield is lost. In addition, fertility status of most saline soils range
from low to very low in respect to organic matter content, nitrogen, phosphorus
and micronutrients like zinc and copper. This is also true for the coastal soil of
Bangladesh, because salinity causes seasonal high content of salts in the root zones
of the soil that is the main obstacle to crop intensification and diversification in this
region. Salinity causes unfavorable environment and hydrological situation,
restricting the normal crop production throughout the year (Amin et al. 2008) and
few crops/cultivars can survive in severe saline soils. For example, Hannan (1980)
mentioned that the estimated agricultural production loss was 647,000 tons in
1976, of which the increased salinity-related loss was 21 %. A study conducted by
the World Bank (2000) shows that increased salinity from a 0.3 m sea-level rise
will alone reduce the net production of rice by 0.5 million metric tons. Another
study by BARC estimated that land degradation due to salinity itself causes a net
loss of 4.42 million ton of wheat per year, which is equivalent to US$ 587 million
(Sarwar and Khan 2007).
Furthermore, Ali (2006) investigated the loss of rice production in a village of
Satkhira district and found that rice production in 2003 was 1,151 metric tons less than
the year 1985, corresponding to a loss of 69 %. There is growing documentation on the
adverse effects of high salinity levels on rice; also high soil salinity prevents growth
(Tho et al. 2007), reduces germination (Khatun and Flowers 1995), causes browning of
rice fields (Gain 1995), and decreases rice production (Ali 2006). Already 19 of the 40
local rice varieties are extinct, and 4–5 varieties have become rare (Ahmed 2003).
Besides rice production, salinity declines the yields of vegetables, coconuts, betel nuts,
and fruit. Salinity also enhances food insecurity through the deterioration of milk productivity and reproductive health of cattle’s by the destruction of pasture land. In terms
fisheries, native fish species disappear. For instance, Miah et al. (2004) show that native
freshwater fish species, such as ruhi, katla, boal, tengra, koi, shing, etc., are disappearing gradually due to increased salinity.
On the contrary, people of coastal Bangladesh perceived that the impact of salinity intrusion is very evident in a number of aspects of crop farming in this region
(Seal and Baten 2012). Particularly, during the dry season, salinity is the most prevalent hazard for the coastal crop. People have been experiencing decline in the crop
production in the last 5–6 years. The salt intrudes in the crop land when farmers
irrigate their land. Because, crop farmers generally use water from their adjacent
water bodies like coastal rivers, canals and creeks that they collect by low lift pump
when tidewater comes during irrigation period. Yield reduction and decline in crop
size as impact of salinity were also reported by the coastal farmers. The yield loss,
however, was not consistent for all crops varieties. Different crops respond to salinity differently even at a same level. The threshold value for different crops in
response to salinity and their yield potentiality was described by FAO (2011) (Table
11.2). Threshold value can be defined as a value of soil salinity level at which plants
begin to experience the impact of salinity in terms of yield loss. Based on the tolerance limit of salinity, different crops have different threshold value. The higher the
threshold value, the more a crop is tolerant to soil salinity and the lower threshold
value indicates less tolerance to soil salinity.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
201
Table 11.2 The threshold value and percent reduction of some winter crops on different soil
salinity (FAO 2011)
Crop
Beans
Carrot
Onion
Pepper
Potato
Radish
Sweet potato
11.7.1
% yield reduction based on different soil salinity (EC in dS/m)
0%
10 %
25 %
1.0
1.5
2.3
1.0
1.7
2.8
1.2
1.8
2.8
1.5
2.2
3.3
1.7
2.5
3.8
1.2
2.0
3.1
1.5
2.4
3.8
Extents and Causes of Salinity
Of the 2.85 million ha of coastal areas (some 30 % of the total arable land of the
country), about 0.87 million ha are affected by different degrees of soil salinity.
Salinity affected areas (ha) under five salinity regimes in the coastal and offshore
regions of Bangladesh are presented in Table 11.3. Both water and soil salinity is a
common hazard in many parts of the coastal area in Bangladesh. Contrasting with
soil and water salinity, SRDI mentioned that salinity intrusion in soil is much higher
than water salinity and saline affected area has increased by 35,440 ha (3.5 %) during the last 9 years (2000–2009) whereas it has increased by 222,740 ha (26.7 %)
during the last 36 years (1973–2009) (The Daily Ittefaq 2011). However, the worst
salinity conditions are reported in Khulna, Bagerhat, Satkhira, and Patuakhali districts of southwestern Bangladesh (SRDI 2010).
Salinity gradually increased from south-eastern coastal belt to south-western
coastal belt, mainly due to very low flow of upstream water during November to May
because of commissioning of the disastrous Farraka Barrage on the Ganges River in
the west Bengal of India since 1974. Besides, the other contributing factors are tidal
floods during wet season (June–October), direct inundation by saline or brackish
water and upward or lateral movement of saline ground water during dry season
(November–May). It has been observed over the last few decades that due to increasing level of salinity in some coastal areas and expansion of salt affected area as a cause
of further intrusion of saline water, usual crop production is gradually becoming more
restricted. The crop area is reducing and the cultivation of aus (summer rice), boro
(dry season rice) and other rabi (dry season) crops are being restricted.
Coupled with other factors, shrimp cultivation plays a major role in increasing
salinity, particularly in the southwestern region of Bangladesh (Haque 2006).
Moreover, it has been reported by Islam (1999) that salinity in shrimp cultivating
areas may be 500 % higher than in nonshrimp cultivating areas. Therefore, this
practice is considered as one of the main reasons for increased soil salinity in
southern Bangladesh (Dutta and Iftekhar 2004; Fleming 2004). In 1983,
Bangladesh produced only 2,220 MT of shrimp from 52,000 ha coastal land.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
202
Table 11.3 Salinity affected areas (ha) in the coastal and offshore regions of Bangladesh under five salinity regimes (dS/m)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Description
Non-saline with very slightly saline
Total cultivated area (ha)
425,490
Very slightly saline with slightly saline
420,420
Slightly saline with moderately saline
257,270
Moderately saline with strongly saline
198,890
S4
(12.1–16.0)
0
S5
(>16.0)
0
0
0
25,870
(11 %)
55,130
(28 %)
2,650
(1 %)
32,750
(16 %)
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
Source: Soil Salinity in Bangladesh, SRDI (2010)
Saline area (ha)
1,15,370
(27 %)
3,09,190
(73 %)
2,40,220
(93 %)
1,98,890
(100 %)
Area of each salinity class (ha)
(dS/m)
S1
S2
S3
(2.0–4.0)
(4.1–8.0)
(8.1–12.0)
82,260
31,590
1,520
(72 %)
(27 %)
(1 %)
1,70,380
1,10,390
29,420
(55 %)
(35 %)
(10 %)
35,490
1,13,890
61,240
(15 %)
(47 %)
(26 %)
1,630
36,060
73,400
(1 %)
(18 %)
(37 %)
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
203
Table 11.4 District-wise shrimp and prawn farming areas 2010–2011
Districts
Khulna
Satkhira
Bagerhat
Chittagong
Cox’s Bazar
Others
Total
Source: DoF (2013)
Area (ha)
Bagda
36,557.18
60,348.00
47,900.00
2,070.91
62,907.00
3,834.2
213,617.29
Galda
13,960.42
7,664.00
18,556.06
–
–
22,696.68
62,877.16
Total
50,517.60
68,012.00
66,456.06
2,070.91
62,907.00
26,530.88
276,494.45
In 2011, however, the area coverage increased to more than fourfolds – 220,000 ha
and the production reached to 125,000 MT. District wise shrimp farming areas are
presented in Table 11.4.
11.7.2
Constraints of Agricultural Development in Saline Soil
Over the years, agricultural development in the coastal saline zone has been hindered by various physical, chemical and social factors. Often heavy monsoonal
downpour, sever flash flood and exposure to cyclones with saline water surges add
to the ongoing process of salinization in the coastal-belt.
• It has been found that constraints increased with increasing intensity of salinity.
Soil salinity is the most dominant limiting factor in the region, especially during
the dry season. It affects certain crops at different levels of soil salinity and at
critical stages of growth, which reduces yield and in severe cases total yield is
lost. A substantial area of land is tidally affected by saline water. Appropriate
management practice for crop production in this area is not available.
• Fertility status of most saline soils range from low to very low in respect to
organic matter content, nitrogen, phosphorus and micronutrients like zinc and
copper. The crop yields obtained in these soils are also low.
• Scarcity of quality irrigation water during dry season limits cultivation of boro
rice and rabi (winter) crops, and aus cultivation during kharif-1 (March–July)
season.
• Variability of rainfall, uncertain dates of onset and recession of seasonal floods
and risk of drought restrict cultivation of aus and aman rice. Uncertain rainfall
delays sowing/transplanting and flood damages aus and aman crops. Heavy
monsoon rainfall causes delay in transplanting of aman and sometimes flash
floods washes away the standing crop.
• Narrow technological and germplasm bases for salt tolerant crops limit crop
choices. On the other hand, due to extensive cultivation of a particular cultivar of
crop year after year makes the crop susceptible to pests and diseases attack. Pests
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
204
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
and diseases like hispa, leaf-hopper and tungro virus are prevalent in the region
and extensive damage is caused by these almost every year.
In the coastal saline belt with short winter season timely sowing/planting of rabi
(winter) crops is essential but this is restricted by late harvest of aman rice.
Presence of saline ground water table throughout the year within 1.0 m depth is
another factor affecting crop production in the saline belt.
Perennial water-logging due to inadequate drainage and faulty operation of
sluice gate facilities restricts potential land use of the low lands within the poldered areas.
Lack of appropriate extension programs for diffusion of modern technologies.
Extension personal trained in saline soil management is also inadequate. This
lacking retarded adoption of HYV technologies.
Big land ownership and unfavorable land tenure system and dominance of absentee farmers discourage adoption of modern technologies.
Difficult communication and remote marketing facilities also retard agricultural
development of the region.
Land preparation is very difficult as the soil dries out quickly due to the silt clay
or clay texture of most of the costal saline soils. Therefore, deep and wide cracks
develop and surface soil becomes very hard and it demands deep and rapid tillage operations.
A significant area of the coast is within the polders of different types. Soil salinity levels are rather high within the poldered areas and this seriously limits the
adoption of HYV Aman and Aus in these areas.
Scanty technological innovation and absence of germplasm bases of salt tolerant
crops restrict crop choices for the farmers. Moreover, extensive farming of a
particular cultivar of crop year after year makes the crop susceptible to pests and
diseases.
11.7.3
Strategy to Improve the Health of Coastal Saline Soil
Hypothetically, salinity in soil is not very difficult to manage. Leaching salt from
soil has long been a widely used and a common practice for soil salinity management which can be done either naturally or artificially. Naturally, during monsoon
rainfalls contribute to leach salt out from soil surface. However, in dry season when
rainfall is inadequate, the artificial process or irrigation needs to be applied. To control salinity, more water needs to be applied in addition to regular water requirement
of the crop. However, one needs to be careful as there is a high risk of increasing
salinity content at root zone in case of irrigation with saline affected water.
In case of higher concentration of salinity in root zone, deep-water irrigation is
necessary. If soil salinity is much higher than optimum level of a certain crop in its
root zone and the root is 30 cm deep, 15 cm of water is capable of leaching salinity
by 50 % and 30 cm of water is capable of leaching salinity by 80 % and 60 cm by
approximately 90 % (Amacher et al. 2000). Methods of irrigation method and pro-
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
205
vision of sufficient drainage facilities also significantly influence soil salinity management. Simple surface water run-off cannot leach soil salinity effectively; hence
water should be drained through the soil. Thus, deep tillage is needed to make sure
the internal drainage as it is crucial to break up the restraining layers that delay
water movement. In this regard, sprinkler irrigation provides a better control of
water application rates. Flood irrigation can also be applied successfully if the sites
are plain and water application is controlled.
The crops, which have higher threshold value to salinity, are likely to have lower
leaching requirements and therefore, will require a less amount of irrigation water.
On the contrary, low tolerance value requires high leaching that means that more
irrigation is needed to raise the yield potentiality which results into high production cost. Moreover, salinity in water also manipulates the soil salinity and its
pH. Higher pH in soil is likely to create a deficiency of nutrient like phosphorus,
iron etc. To retrieve these nutrients, appropriate fertilizer should be applied against
the deficiency of certain nutrient. High pH resulted from high salinity also causes
carbonate and bi-carbonate salt to be insoluble and therefore, creates calcium and
magnesium ion deficiency and sodium ion dominates. To address the issue, gypsum or calcium sulphate could be applied to release calcium ion and replaces
sodium ion (Gale et al. 2001).
Timing of irrigation is another key factor in managing soil salinity. A dry and hot
day is likely to evaporate more water from soil and therefore, cause more salt to be
concentrated in the root zone of plants. Therefore, a cool and humid weather or
night is preferable for irrigation. The frequency of irrigation should be increased in
case of hot and dry weather to protect crops from salinity stress.
Moreover, to reduce the future crop loss and to prevent the present loss, Hossain
et al. (2012) recommended the following adaptive techniques to manage salinity
that are:
Protective embankment
There is need for improving the management of coastal saline soils through protective embankment, proper sluice gate, land leveling and improved drainage systems.
Land may be protected from inundation of saline water through establishment of
embankment of suitable size. The recommended size should be about 1 m high
above the high tide level. There should be provision of sluice gates in the embankment system to remove excess water and also to prevent ingress of saline water
during high tide.
Leveling of land
Land should be properly leveled to prevent accumulation of water in the low-lying
patches with shallow ground water tables and to facilitate uniform drainage of
excess water. It will help to apply irrigation water uniformly in the field in rabi season, facilitate uniform germination of seeds and better growth of crops.
Storing of excess rainwater for irrigation
Part of the excess water stored in pond after meeting the requirements of the kharif
season can be utilized during the dry period for rabi crops.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
206
Selection of kharif rice variety
Even though the coastal area is relatively flat, there exist elevation differences in
areas, where depths of standing water ranges from 15 to 90 cm. Selection of right
kind of rice varieties (such as – BRRI dhan 23, 30, 40 and 41), available in the country taking in to account the standing water and extent of salinity in the field can
overcome the situation to a great extent.
Introduction of crop in rabi (winter) season
Cropping intensity can be increased in coastal soils with very slight (S1) and slight
salinity (S2) through adopting proper soil and water management practices with the
introduction of salt tolerant crop varieties.
Keeping land covered in winter and summer months
Ground water in the coast is saline and present at a shallow depth (about 1.0 m).
Keeping lands fallow turns the soil high saline due to evaporation of excessive soil
moisture. Therefore, it is recommended to avoid fallowing of lands during rabi season. Salt tolerant crops should be grown during rabi season. This will lower the
profile salinity.
Fertilization of crops
Since, soils in the coast in general are poor in fertility with low organic matter content, it is necessary to apply appropriate fertilizers to boost up crop production.
Potash fertilizer has an added advantage under soil salinity. It brings down Na
uptake by plants and increases K uptake. Thus K fertilization protects crops from
harmful effects of Na.
Provision of sub-surface drainage
In many parts of the coastal area, salinity is very high. To grow crops successfully
in those areas, it is essential to bring down the salinity by leaching the salts. It is also
necessary to lower down the water table and maintain it below the critical depth to
prevent salt effect on crops grown. To achieve the objective, a proper sub-surface
drainage has to be installed to keep the ground water at least 1 m below the soil
surface. This technology is effective but somewhat expensive.
11.8
11.8.1
Existing Adaptation and Mitigation Measures Towards
Soil Management in Southwestern Coastal Region
At Institutional Level
To cope with salinity as well as other natural hazards exists in coastal region; various organizations are working together on soil management to get more yield. For
instance, National Agricultural Research System (NARS) have given special thrust
to develop salt-tolerant crop varieties suitable to cultivate in this region. As a result,
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
207
Bangladesh Rice Research Institute (BRRI) and Bangladesh Institute of Nuclear
Agriculture (BINA) have developed some saline-tolerant rice varieties that perform
well in the coastal soil. Some of the rice varieties for boro season are BRRI dhan-47
and BINA dhan-8. On the other hand, BR- 23 and BRRI dhan-40, 41, 44, 53, and 54
are getting popular as aman varieties. BRRI dhan-55 is a newly developed variety
that can be grown in both aman and boro seasons. Apart from rice variety, Bangladesh
Agricultural Research Institute (BARI) has developed a number of crop varieties to
cultivate in Southern Delta. BARI-developed mung bean varieties like BARI Mug 5
and 6 are suitable to grow in this region. Oilseed Research Centre of BARI developed some other crop varieties of oil crops, soybean, and groundnut. BARI introduced maize, potato, and sweet potato varieties that are very popular in this region.
It also developed some fruits like hugplum (amra), coconut, guava (peyara), and
some vegetable varieties that are performing well in this region. BARI Halud is very
popular there. The different saline-tolerant varieties invented by the research institutes are presented in Table 11.5.
Even, different GO and NGOs have been developed a lot of production practices
for the region. Several promising adaptation practices are identified and documented
for sustainable agricultural production in the coastal region such as:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Sorjan system of year round vegetables,
Spices and fruits farming on raised beds
Creeper vegetables on bed edges making trellis on ponds
Ditches and fish farming in ponds during wet months in the water-logged areas
prone to tidal surge
Cultivation of maize, potato and garlic using zero tillage method
Farming of vegetables and vegetable seedlings on floating beds using water
hyacinth
Cultivation of water melon in ring method/Kalsi method
Use of cover crops in the rotation cycle
Table 11.5 Name of the saline-tolerant varieties introduced by research institutes
Sl. no.
1
No. name of the crop
Rice
2
Potato
3
Tomato
4
Sweet potato
5
Mustard
6
Wheat
7
Mung bean
8
Turmeric
Source: Habiba et al. (2013)
Name of the variety
BRRI dhan-47, BRRI dhan-53, BRRI dhan-54, BRRI
dhan-40, BRRI dhan-41, BINA-8, BINA-9
Saikat
BINA Tomato-6
BARI Sweet potato-6, BARI Sweet potato-7
BARI Sarisha-10
BAW-1059, BARI Triticale-1, BARI Triticale-2
BARI Mungbean
BARI Halud
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
208
11.8.2
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
At Individual and Community Level
A number of adaptive actions are taken by the individual and community to cope
with or overcome adverse effects of salinity on agriculture. At the level of agricultural farms, adjustments may include the introduction of new crop varieties or species, switching cropping sequences, sowing earlier, adjusting timing of field
operations, various fertilizer and pesticide use, conserving soil moisture through
appropriate tillage methods, and improving irrigation efficiency. Some options
such as switching crop varieties may be inexpensive while others such as introducing irrigation (especially high efficiency, water-conserving technologies) involve
major investments (Chhabra 1996). Bunds (dykes/embankment) of shrimp ghers
can be effectively utilized at individual and community level to grow seasonal
vegetables, fruits and spices. Promotion of integrated rice-fish culture is another
option to get befits from the land as well as soil. Compost making and use of composts and other organic manure in homestead gardening is widely used practices to
improve the soil health.
Due to high salinity levels, it is difficult to cultivate any high yield variety (HYV)
crops, such as HYV aman and HYV boro. To ensure food security, the farmers in
this area cultivate 13 local saline-tolerant varieties of rice that are especially suited
to the current circumstances of this area. These rice varieties include jotabalam,
ashfall, ghunshi, and benapol. Based on the land type and soil characteristics, some
of these local rice varieties are categorized for shrimp farms and for other agricultural land. For example, Jotabalam and Ghunshi varieties are selected for cultivation
in the shrimp farms. On the contrary, Ashfall and Benapol varieties are destined for
other agricultural farms. Aside from this, the communities have adapted special
mechanisms and raised their homestead to some extent and manage soil in a different way, such as mulching for vegetable growing and selecting salt-tolerant varieties. They utilize rainy seasons for vegetable cultivation and grow some selected
species, such as creepers (Puishak, Jhinge, guard, bitter gourd, etc.), ladies fingers,
chilies, cauliflowers, cabbages, radishes, etc. from July to March. They grow salttolerant tree species locally called rain trees such as babla, khoibabla, tentul, kewra,
coconut, koroi, khejur, paroshpipul, and a few mangrove species with fruit species
like sofeda and peyara.
11.9
Conclusions and Recommendations
As predicted by Fourth Assessment Report of the IPCC, marine and coastal ecosystems in South and Southeast Asia will be affected by sea-level rise as a consequence
of climate change (Parry et al. 2007). As a consequence, it not only increases the
intensity of disasters like sea level rise, tidal surge, cyclone in coastal belt, but also
increases the soil salinity, salt water intrusion. Therefore, slightly saline areas will
become moderate to highly saline and surface based irrigation will not be possible.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
209
Furthermore, MOEF (2006) in Bangladesh stated that the distance of the salinity
intrusion inland, as well as the extent of salinity in the coastal areas, is expected to
increase with rising sea levels. Among various hazards, salinity intrusion is increasingly becoming a severe problem in the coastal region of Bangladesh, particularly
in the southwestern part. Thus, salinity poses a great threat to the agricultural production, especially in coastal areas where agriculture and water resources are
already under severe stress due to adverse meteorological conditions. Consequently
it has substantial impact on food security.
As, global warming and climate change have a detrimental impact on soil fertility and crop productivity. The present challenges for plant nutrient management are
to maintain sustainable crop productivity to meet the growing demands for food and
raw materials and to enhance the quality of land and water resources. To date the
much emphasis placed on rice production has resulted in an increased reliance on
imports for non-food grain commodities such as pulses, oilseeds, spices and fruits
which remain unaffordable by poor and middle-class community, particularly the
people of the coastal region. In the changing scenario of the sea level rise, it has
been predicted that the increasing concentration of salinity will create more pressure to the farmer by reducing yield on one hand and threatening livelihood, income
generation and food security on the other hand. Since coastal area in Bangladesh
constitutes 20 % of the country of which about 53 % are affected by different
degrees of salinity. Agricultural land use in these areas is very poor. Declining land
productivity with shift towards negative nutrient balance is among the main concerns with food security problem in the country. Salinity problem received very
little attention in the past. Increased pressure of growing population demand more
food. It has become imperative to explore the possibilities of increasing potential of
these (saline) lands for increased production of food crops. Thus combating land
salinization problem is vital for food security in the country through adoption of
long-term land management strategy.
Based on the above discussion, however, some policy recommendations are
given below to improve agricultural production as well as food security for coastal
Bangladesh:
Dissemination and Extension of Climate Resilient Agricultural
Adaptation Options
Block farming year-round crop adaptation practices should be demonstrated to
develop climate resilient agricultural systems and to reduce risks of food security.
The viable adaptation options need to be tested and disseminated at pilot villages for
their acceptance. More study is needed for making location-specific production plan
for developing climate resilient coastal agriculture based on soil-crop-climate suitability through proper assessment of soil and water related constraints, climate risks
and socioeconomic problems presently affecting crop production systems and livelihood of the vulnerable people of the coastal region.
Water management infrastructures development and management
Water resources management infrastructures such as protective embankment, proper
sluice gate, canal excavation and re-excavation inside coastal polders for improved
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
210
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
drainage systems and for conservation of rainfall and fresh river water for irrigation
in the dry season is necessary for adopting climate resilient agriculture and in turn
food security of the coastal community. Therefore, water management infrastructures should be developed and maintained the existing structures focusing on the
consequences of climate change and agricultural requirements.
Adoption of stress-tolerant crops
Salinity, submergence and drought tolerant crops should be introduced to develop
climate resilient agriculture and also to reduce the risk of crop damage and improve
food security and livelihoods of the coastal communities of the country.
Capacity building
The farmers and the agricultural extension personnel should be trained on improved,
innovative and climate resilient adaptation practices for wider dissemination of the
technologies for food security of the expanding population.
Encourage Women Involvement in Agriculture
The participation of women in homestead farming, seed production & preservation,
compost making, agro- processing, fish and livestock production in the homestead
areas should be encouraged to further improve the climate resilience of the coastal
communities of Bangladesh.
Marketing infrastructures development
Road network, marketing infrastructures and agro-processing facilities should be
developed for ensuring price of the farm produce and also for fare access of the
agricultural input.
Coordinated Actions for Continuous Adaptation
Adaptation to reduce the vulnerability of agriculture and allied sectors to the impacts
of climate change requires coordinated actions, proper planning, financial resources
for implementation and community involvement for improving coastal agriculture.
Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the support from Ecosystem Services for Poverty
Alleviation (ESPA) program through the project “Assessing health, livelihoods, ecosystem services
and poverty alleviation in populous deltas” (NE-J002755-1) funded by the UK Department for
International Development (DFID), the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) and the
Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) to conduct this study.
References
Ahmed M (2003) Impact of shrimp farming on socio-economic, agriculture and environmental
conditions in Paikgacha of Khulna district. Ph.D. thesis, Bangabandhu Sheik Mujibur Rahman
Agricultural University
Ali A (1999) Climate change impacts and adaptation assessment in Bangladesh. Clim Res
12:109–116
Ali AMS (2006) Rice to shrimp: land use/land cover changes and soil degradation in Southwestern
Bangladesh. Land Use Policy 23:421–435
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
11
Soil Health and Food Security: Perspective from Southwestern Coastal Region…
211
Amacher JK, Koenig R, Kitchen B (2000) Salinity and plant tolerance, Utah State University. No
AG-S0-03
Amin M, Rahman MA, Zaman SM, Howlader MIA, Hossain MZ, Islam MI (2008) Cropping
system in coastal and barind area. Paper presented in national workshop on multiple cropping,
held at BARC, Farmgate, Dhaka on 23–24 April
BBS (Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics) (2009) Statistical yearbook of Bangladesh. Statistical
Division, Ministry of Planning, Dhaka
BBS (Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics) (2011) Bangladesh population and housing census 2011,
final result
BCAS (Bangladesh Center for Advanced Studies) (2010) Assessing long-term impacts and vulnerabilities on crop production due to climate change in the coastal areas of Bangladesh; final
report PR #10/08
Chhabra R (1996) Soil salinity and water quality. Rajuprimlani for Oxford and IBH Publishing Co.
Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi, pp 17–52
DoF (2013) National fish week compendium (in Bengali). Department of Fisheries, Ministry of
Fisheries & Livestock, Dhaka, p 144
Dutta AK, Iftekhar MS (2004) Tree species survival in the homestead forests of salt affected areas:
a perception analysis for Bangladesh. J Biol Sci 4:309–313
Fleming C (2004) Challenges facing the shrimp industry in Bangladesh. American International
School, Dhaka
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) (2007) Case study. Climate variability and change:
adaptation to drought in Bangladesh. A resource book and training guide. FAO of the United
Nations, Rome, Italy. An internet FAO Corporate Document Repository
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) (2011) Water quality for agriculture. www.fao.org/DOCREP/003/T0234E/T0234E02.htm
Gain P (1995) Attack of the shrimps. TWR 59:18–19
Gale J, Koenig R, Barnhill J (2001) Managing soil pH in Utah. Utah State University, no
AG-SO-07
Habiba U, Abedin MA, Shaw R, Hassan AWR (2013) Salinity-induced livelihood strees in coastal
region of Bangladesh. In: Water insecurity: a social dilemma, community, environment and
disaster risk management, vol 13. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Bingley, pp 139–165
Hannan A (1980) Impact of reduced low flow of the Ganges. Paper presented at the seminar
“Impact of low flow of major rivers of Bangladesh” organized by the Department of Water
Resources Engineering, Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology (BUET), 23
August, Dhaka, 23pp
Haque SA (2006) Salinity problems and crop production in coastal regions of Bangladesh. Pak J
Bot 38(5):1359–1365
Hossain L, Hossain MK, Salam MA, Rubaiyat (2012) Seasonal variation of soil salinity in coastal
areas of Bangladesh. Int J Environ Sci, Manag Eng Res 1(4):172–178
Islam MR (2004) Where land meets the sea: a profile of the coastal zone of Bangladesh. The
University Press Limited, Dhaka
Islam MSN (2008) Cultural landscape changing due to anthropogenic influences on surface water
and threats to mangrove wetland ecosystems: a case study on the Sundarbans, Bangladesh.
PhD thesis, Brandenburg University of Technology, Cottbus
Islam MS, Haque M (2004) The mangrove-based coastal and near shore fisheries of Bangladesh:
ecology, exploitation and management. Rev Fish Biol Fish 14:153–180
Islam MA, Sattar MA, Alam MS (1999) Scientific report on impact of shrimp farming on soil and
water quality of some selected areas in the Greater Khulna District. Research and Development
Collective (RDC), Dhaka, Bangladesh
Karim MF, Mimura N (2006) Sea level rise in the Bay of Bengal: its impacts and adaptations in
Bangladesh. Center for Water Environment Studies, Ibaraki University, Hitachi, Ibaraki, Japan.
Microsoft PowerPoint – Poster for IOC_02June06_Karim
Karim Z, Saheed SM, Salauddin ABM, Alam MK, Huq A (1982) Coastal saline soils and their
management in Bangladesh. Soils publication, vol 8. BARC, Dhaka, p 33
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
A.Z.Md. Moslehuddin et al.
212
Karim Z, Hussain SG, Ahmed M (1990) Salinity problems and crop intensification in the coastal
regions of Bangladesh. Soils publication, vol 33. BARC, Dhaka, p 17
Khatun S, Flowers TJ (1995) Effects of salinity on seed set in rice. Plant Cell Environ
18(1):61–67
Miah MY, Mannan MA, Quddus KG, Mahmud MAG, Baida T (2004) Salinity on cultivable land
and its effects on crops. Pak J Bot 7:1322–1326
Miyan MA (2009) Monsoon in Bangladesh, changes and adaptation: Asian monsoon years AMY6, Kunming, China, 30 November–01 December
MOEF (Ministry of Environment and Forest) (2006) Impact of sea-level rise on land use suitability
and adaptation options: coastal land zoning in the Southwest. Dhaka, Bangladesh
MoEF (Ministry of Environment and Forests) (2007) Bangladesh: national programme of action
for protection of the coastal and marine environment from land-based activities. http://www.
doebd.org/npadraft.pdf
MoWR (Ministry of Water Resources) (2005) Coastal zone policy. Government of the People’s
Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka
Parry ML, Canziani OF, Palutikof JP, van der Linden PJ, Hanson CE (eds) (2007) Climate change
2007: impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the fourth
assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge
Rahman MM (2012) Enhancement of resilience of coastal community in Bangladesh through crop
diversification in adaptation to climate change impacts. MS thesis, Postgraduate Programs in
Disaster Management BRAC University, Dhaka
Rahman MM, Ahsan M (2001) Salinity constraints and agricultural productivity in coastal saline
area of Bangladesh, soil resources in Bangladesh: assessment and utilization. Proceedings of
the annual workshop on soil resources, 14–15 February 2001. Soil Resources Development
Institute, Dhaka, pp 1–14
Seal L, Baten MA (2012) Salinity intrusion in interior coast: a new challenge to agriculture in
South Central part of Bangladesh. A working draft, Climate Change, Biodiversity and Disaster
Risk Reduction Unit, Unnayan Onneshan – The Innovators, enter for Research and Action on
Development, 47 p
Singaraval R, Balasundaram SK, Johnson K (1996) Physicochemical characteristics and nutrient
status of coastal saline soils of Tamil Nadu. J Ind Soc Coastal Agric Res 14(1&2):59–61
Sarwar GM, Khan MH (2007) Sea level rise. A threat to the coast of Bangladesh. Internationales
Asienforum 38(3–4):375–397
SRDI (1989–2002) Land and soil resources utilization guide (In Bengali). Respective Thana/
Upazila of nine districts. Soil Resource Development Institute, Krishi Khamar Sarak, Dhaka
SRDI (Soil Resource Development Institute) (1997) Soil salinity in Bangladesh, Farm gate, Dhaka,
Bangladesh
SRDI (Soil Resource Development Institute) (2010) Soil salinity report 2010 of Bangladesh. Soil
Resources Development Institute, Dhaka, Bangladesh
The Daily Ittefaq (2011) Retrieved from http://news.ittefaq.com.bd/newsview/61220/2011-12-11/1.
Accessed 20 Aug 2014
Tho N, Vromant N, Hung NT, Hens L (2007) Soil salinity and sodicity in a shrimp farming coastal
area of the Mekong Delta, Vietnam. Environ Geol 8:1739
World Bank (2000) Bangladesh: climate change & sustainable development. Report No. 21104,
BD, Dhaka
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 12
Role of Water Resource Management
in Ensuring Food Security
Rezaur Rahman and M. Shahjahan Mondal
Abstract Historically, the main focus of water resources management in
Bangladesh has been to increase rice production in order to ensure food security.
Since early 1960s there has been large scale development of flood control projects
which provide protection against repeated floods to safeguard standing rice crop.
There are different types of flood control projects providing protection against different types of floods with various degrees of success. Right now, almost all of flood
prone cultivable areas are protected from floods. Additionally, other aspects of flood
management have improved over the years, which are being observed to result in
higher rice production after flood. Since early 1980s, irrigation facilities have been
developed to supply water during dry season which has made it possible to grow
an additional rice crop during this season. By now, most of irrigable areas have
been brought under irrigation coverage by various modes of irrigation technologies.
This paper reviews the contributions of these two developments in water sector in
increasing rice production of the country.
Keywords Flood control • Irrigation development • Rice production • Bangladesh
12.1
Land, Water and People
Bangladesh is a small country with large population. It has a total land area of about
147,500 sq. km supporting a population of 153 million at a density of 1,034 people
per sq. km, among the highest in the world. The net cultivable area is 7.8 million ha
with a land availability of only 0.05 ha per person. Water availability is rather high
at 8,051 cubic meter per capita but with a large temporal and spatial variation.
Physiographically, Bangladesh is a floodplain country. About 80 % of the land
area is basically floodplain of the Ganges-Brahmaputra-Meghna (GBM) system.
Regular flood is therefore a basic feature of the country and in extreme years
R. Rahman (*) • M.S. Mondal
Institute of Water and Flood Management, Bangladesh University of Engineering &
Technology (BUET), Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: rezaur@iwfm.buet.ac.bd
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_12
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
213
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
214
Fig. 12.1 Area cultivated for different crops (Source: BBS 2011a)
two-thirds of the area may be flooded. While agriculture system is overwhelmed
during large floods, it is also stressed from water scarcity during dry season.
Bangladesh has abundance of crop varieties. More than 100 crops can be found
in the floodplain. However, due to favorable agro-ecological regime, rice has been
the principal crop. About 80 % of the cropped area is used for rice cultivation
(Fig. 12.1). Rice production constitutes 91 % of total food grain production, while
wheat contributes 3 % and maize another 6 %.
Rice is the staple food for a typical Bengali. It constitutes 40 % of food intake
and more than 90 % of total cereal intake. Therefore, production of enough rice has
been the main agenda of food security in Bangladesh. The country has made remarkable progress in recent years in ensuring this food security. Rice production alone
now stands at 34 million metric tons against a total food grain (rice, wheat and
maize) requirement of 30 million metric tons.
As rice is a water intensive crop, water resource management played a crucial
role in ensuring this food security. Water management during monsoon, in the form
of flood control in order to safeguard the monsoon rice crop was the first management
practice put in place in the early 1960s. In the early 1980s, the emphasis shifted towards
dry season water management in the form of development of irrigation facilities to
support the rapidly emerging practice of rice cultivation during the dry season.
12.2
12.2.1
Food Security
Food Habit
Traditionally, Bengalis are known to be rice and fish eating populace. The predominantly aquatic environment of the country favors production of these two food
items aplenty. The current food basket of an average Bengali is shown in Fig. 12.2.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
215
12 Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring Food Security
a
b
c
Rice
22.5%
2.9%
41.6%
4.9%
8.0%
45.7%
14.6%
6.7%
2.6%
Other cereals
13.3%
19.1%
1.5%
62.0%
2
Meat, eggs
8.4%
23.6%
Vegetables
Fish
10.7%
Other
4.8%
7.3%
Fig. 12.2 Food basket of a typical Bengali. (a) Food intake. (b) Calorie intake. (c) Protein intake
(Source of data: BBS 2011b)
It is seen that rice contributes 41 % to total food consumption of 1,000 gm/capita/day,
62 % of calorie intake of 2,318 calorie/capita/day and 46 % of protein intake of
66 gm/capita/day, way ahead of any other food item. Fish supplements more than
half of animal protein intake.
12.2.2
Food Security Policies
Rice being the staple food of the general population, the food security concern of
the country has always been equivalent to production of sufficient rice. Consecutive
floods in the 1950s and the consequent large scale damage to monsoon rice, namely
Aman which was basically the only rice type during that time, prompted the-then
Pakistan Government to formulate a water resources master plan for the-then East
Pakistan focusing on flood control to safeguard the flood season rice from such
repeated damages. The objective of the plan was to become self sufficient in rice
production within the plan period of 1965–1985. After the country became independent in 1971, it set attaining self-sufficiency in food grain (mainly rice) production
as the principal aim in the very first 5 year plan (1973–1978) of the country.
The focus on this food security was somewhat lost during the 1990s due to global
market and trade liberalization trends during that time. The food security issue
regained its focus after the world-wide food crisis in 2007 which occurred due to
widespread damage to food crops simultaneously in many countries from varieties
of natural disasters. Bangladesh itself suffered from two floods and a cyclone in that
year. The food security concern received added impetus as it was apprehended
during that time that such food crises due to natural calamities will become all the
more common in future due to climate change.
Despite many challenges including the challenge of scarce land, variable water
resources and high population growth, attaining self sufficiency in rice production
in recent past has been a major achievement for Bangladesh. Rice production
tripled from 11 million tons in 1972 to 32 million tons in 2009. During this time,
population doubled from around 70 million to 140 million. Per capita availability of
rice increased from 140 kg in 1972 to 180 kg in 2008 (Alam and Islam 2013).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
216
Fig. 12.3 Crop calendar for different varieties of rice in different land types (Adapted from Yu
et al. 2010)
Talukder (2005) estimates that with the stipulated food grain requirement criterion
of 454 gm (16 ounces/capita/day), Bangladesh became self-sufficient in food
grain production by year 2000 and by the year of 2005–2006, there was a surplus
production of more than one million ton.
12.2.3
Rice Production System
The agriculture system in Bangladesh is flood dependent and farmers’ choice of the
rice variety is based largely on normal flooding characteristics. The cultivable lands
are therefore classified according to average flood depth as shown in Fig. 12.3.
Highlands are considered to be flood free. Other land types – medium highland,
medium lowland, lowland and bottomland, are subject to various ranges of flooding
and together constitute more than 60 % of cultivable land.
There are three major rice types – Aman (flood season rice), Boro (dry season
rice) and Aus (inter-period rice). Aus is rarely damaged by flood, while Boro and
Aman are highly susceptible to flood damage. An early flood may affect harvesting
of Boro crop while it may cause delay in transplantation of Aman crop. The purpose
of the flood control projects was to transform, medium highlands and lowlands into
flood free highlands by the exclusion of external river flooding from protected areas.
This allowed replacement of lower yielding deepwater rice (broadcast Aman) by
high yielding variety (HYV) transplanted Aman on these flood free lands.
Figure 12.4 shows the changes in areas cultivated for different types of rice
over the years. Earlier Aman was the main crop as seen in the figure but later Boro
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
217
12 Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring Food Security
Cultivated Areas in million ha
7
6
Aman
5
Boro
4
3
2
Aus
1
2007
2009
2005
2003
2001
1997
1999
1995
1993
1991
1989
1987
1985
1983
1981
1979
1977
1975
1973
1971
0
Year
Fig. 12.4 Area under cultivation of different rice types
coverage increased sharply. Area under Aman cultivation has remained almost
unchanged over the years although much of the area has shifted from local to high
yielding varieties. Cultivation of Aus has declined in the mean time especially
after introduction of Boro since Aman-Boro cropping pattern is more productive
and leaves little room to cultivate inter-seasonal Aus rice which has the lowest
yield among the three types. Currently, the shares of Aman, Boro and Aus in total
rice cropped area of 11.48 million hectares (Mha) are 49 %, 41 % and 10 %,
respectively.
12.2.4
Water Resource Management
Water resource management in Bangladesh has traditionally been agriculture
focused. Flood control to manage monsoon excess and groundwater irrigation to
manage dry season scarcity have been the principal instruments of this management.
About 88 % of water use in Bangladesh is for agriculture while municipal water use
is 10 % and the rest 2 % is used for industrial purposes (FAO AQUASTAT 2011).
The IECO Master Plan (IECO 1964) was the first water resources management
plan for the country. The Plan was focused on flood control and it had a portfolio of
58 large scale public sector projects involving embankments for flood control, gravity
irrigation through canal system and pumping stations for drainage and irrigation.
Most of the projects under the plan have been implemented.
In the 1980s, groundwater irrigation in private sector took off which revolutionized
the dry season rice production system. This was facilitated by newer technology which
made small shallow pumps affordable for individual farmers and a government
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
218
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
policy which removed restriction on groundwater use (Hossain 2009). As a result,
the dry season irrigation has become heavily groundwater dependent.
National Water Management Plan (WARPO 2001) was formulated on the basis
of National Water Policy (MoWR 1999) which was holistic in nature. The Plan
therefore focused more on integrated management of water resources rather than for
traditional agricultural purposes. The Plan did not propose any new flood control
project rather it sets a program for rationalization of existing flood control infrastructure. Regarding irrigation, it promotes expansion of minor irrigation and use
of surface water over groundwater. National Agriculture Policy (MoA 2013) also
promotes use of surface water over groundwater.
12.3
12.3.1
Wet Season Water Resources Management
Flood History
Flood is a normal phenomenon in Bangladesh, which becomes devastating
occasionally. In a normal year, around 20–25 % of the area is flooded. Figure 12.5
shows year-wise flooding since mid 1950s. Due to construction of many flood control
projects, flood started declining after the 1970s as seen in Fig. 12.5. Most of the
flood prone areas where flood protection is practical have already been brought
under protection. According to Rahman and Chowdhury (1999) flood protected area
during the 30-year period of 1964–1993 increased at a rate of 120,000 ha per year
resulting in a reduction of flooded area at a rate of 80,000 ha per year. However, it
is seen that large floods have become more frequent such as in 1974, 1987, 1988,
1998, 2004 and 2007. There have been large scale crop damages from these floods
as presented in Table 12.1. The crop failure in 1974 created especially difficult
situation for a newly independent country leading to a famine causing death of more
than a million people.
Flood affected area (%)
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Year
Fig. 12.5 Chronology of flood
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
12 Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring Food Security
219
Table 12.1 Crop damages during major floods
Year
1974
1987
1988
1998
Inundated area (%)
36
39
60
68
Rice production losses (million tons)
2.00
0.80
1.65
2.06
Source of production loss data: Data for 1974 and 1987 are from Ahmad and
the rest are from Yu et al. (2010)
2004
2007
38
42
1.00
1.2
Ahmed (2003);
Fig. 12.6 Flood types in Bangladesh (Source: Brammer and Khan, 1991)
12.3.2
Types of Floods and Flood Control
There are four types of floods that occur in Bangladesh. These are monsoon flood,
flash flood, tidal flood and rainfall flood. The areas affected by these floods are
shown in Fig. 12.6. The monsoon flood is the main flood and occurs along the major
rivers. The flash flood occurs mostly in the hilly districts of north-eastern and eastern parts of the country. The coastal region suffers from regular tidal inundation.
The south-western and north-western parts of the country are vulnerable to rainfall
flood. Various types of flood control projects have been built over the years to
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
220
Fig. 12.7 Distribution of flood control projects in Bangladesh (Courtesy: Center for Environmental
and Geographical Information Services (CEGIS))
protect crop lands against different floods. Total flood protected area now stands at
6 Mha under 544 projects. The distribution of these flood control projects is shown
in Fig. 12.7.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
12 Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring Food Security
221
The monsoon flood is caused by overflowing water of the rivers of the GBM river
system. Origin of these flood flows is heavy rainfall in the GBM basin and mostly
beyond the borders of the country. The flood depth may be as high as 7.6 m, as in
1988 and the duration may be more than 2 months as in 1998. Aman crops are
damaged due to higher depth and longer duration of these floods. Farmers try to
recuperate from this flood by making a second transplantation if there is time
still available.
The most common strategy employed against monsoon flood is embankment
along the major rivers. The Brahmaputra Right Embankment is the largest project
of such type. The embankment is 220 km long along the right bank of the
Brahmaputra (Fig. 12.7) which protects 225,000 ha of land from flood of the
Brahmaputra.
The flash flood occurs during the pre-monsoon period due to heavy rainfall,
convective in nature. This shorter duration flood causes heavy damage to standing
Boro crops due to sudden onset and high velocity. Since Boro is the only crop in
the deeply flooded north-eastern basin, the impact of such floods on agricultural
livelihood is very high.
Submersible embankments are engaged to provide protection against flash
floods. These embankments are low height embankments giving protection against
pre-monsoon flood but not against very high monsoon flood on practical and
environmental grounds. The embankments therefore remain submerged during
monsoon. There are 1,155 km of such embankments under 31 submersible flood
control projects providing protection to 266,326 ha. These projects are situated in
north-eastern part of the country as shown in Fig. 12.7.
The coast suffers from regular tidal flooding. The flooding is short duration in
nature but the salinity causes damage to Aman crop. Against this tidal flooding,
another embankment based solution, polder which encircles an area, is engaged.
Since 1960s, 123 polders have been constructed in the coast with a total length of
embankments at 5,017 km providing protection to 800,000 ha of cultivable land.
Rainfall flooding occurs when internal rainfall is so high that it overwhelms the
drainage capacity of local rivers and channels. The resulting water congestion from
heavy rainfall can be very long, which may lead to abandonment of an entire crop
season. The south-west region is particularly vulnerable to such flooding. Resuscitation
of drainage channels and in few cases pumping, as in Meghna-Dhonagoda Irrigation
Project (see Fig. 12.7), are adapted to relieve drainage congestion.
12.3.3
Performance of Flood Control Projects
FPCO (1992) in their evaluation of 17 flood control projects found large increase in
monsoon paddy production. The increase in monsoon paddy production in cases
was as high as 2 tons/ha. This increase was achieved by the predictable shift of
cultivation to HYV transplanted Aman from deepwater Aman. MPO (1991) also found
similar shift in cultivation practice in their study of eight flood control projects.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
222
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
In Bangladesh, protection against tidal flooding in the coast and flash flooding in
the north-east region has been more successful than protection against major river
monsoon flood. Lack of drainage facilities and the risk of embankment breaches
and erosion are major limiting factors for protection works against major river
monsoon floods. Limiting factors for submersible embankments are the risk of early
overtopping and post-monsoon drainage facilities. The success of coastal polders
has mainly been due to their success in salinity exclusion. However, the drainage
congestion due to siltation of surrounding rivers as a result of extensive poldering
has become a major problem in the coast. In case of local flooding and internal
drainage basins, the main limitation is lack of sufficient drainage facilities, but problems of external impacts and public cuts (by outsiders and insiders) are particularly
acute in this project type.
12.3.4
Regional Impact of Flood Control Projects
Production ('000 ton)
1000
600
Aman
Flood protected area
500
800
400
600
300
400
200
200
100
0
2008
2002
2005
1999
1996
1993
1990
1987
1984
1978
1981
1975
1969
1972
1963
1966
1960
1957
1951
1954
1948
0
Year
Fig. 12.8 Growth of flood protected area and Aman production in Greater Khulna district
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Flood protected area ('000 ha)
While flood control projects protect the internal area from flood, it raises flood level
in the unprotected external area. As a result, the flood damage may rise in the unprotected area. The net effect on agricultural production may then be significantly less
than the effect within the project area. It is therefore necessary to look into the
impact of flood control projects on agricultural production in a regional scale also.
Figure 12.8 shows the result of an analysis of performance of flood control
projects in regional scale. It compares the year wise Aman rice production with the
growth of flood control projects in Greater Khulna district (Khulna, Satkhira and
Bagerhat districts in south-western region – see Fig. 12.7), one of the most intensely
flood protected area with more than 90 % of cultivable area under different polders
to protect Aman crop against tidal floods. It is reasonable to expect that Aman production will show an increase in proportion to the increase in flood protected area.
But from this graph it is difficult to discern any such relationship. So it can be said
223
12 Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring Food Security
that while individual projects might have had positive impact on crop production,
their net regional impact has been less. Such analyses were carried out by Rahman and
Chowdhury (1999) for other districts and similar conclusions were drawn raising
the efficacy issue of flood control projects in a floodplain environment.
On the other hand, submersible embankments in the north-east region which
gives protection to Boro crop against pre-monsoon flash floods have been rather
successful in regional scale. Saleh and Mondal (2009) found that collectively, the
submersible embankments have been able to raise Boro production in the northeastern region. Since the submersible embankment projects have less impact on
regional flood flow because they provide only partial flood protection, so their
impact on external flood is less and this can be considered as a major reason for
their success.
12.3.5
Flood Versus Flood Control
Year
Flood affected area
Aus
Aman
Fig. 12.9 Relationship between crop production and flood
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Boro
Total Production
Flood affected area (% of the country)
2010
2013
2007
2004
2001
1995
1998
1992
1989
1986
0
1983
10
0
1980
5
1974
20
1977
30
10
1968
15
1971
40
1965
50
20
1962
60
25
1956
30
1959
70
1953
80
35
1950
40
1947
Rice production (million tons)
While flood damages standing crops when it occurs, the crop production after the
flood usually more than compensates the loss during the flood. This is due to better
soil moisture condition, improved soil fertility and in recent times more effective
government support to farmers with inputs and logistics in subsequent crop seasons
after a flood (see Haruisha et al. 2005). The increase in rice production after recent
floods have been impressive as can be seen in Fig. 12.9. It is seen that after a major
flood (e.g. 1988, 1998, 2004, 2007) there has always been a leap in the rice production and most importantly this increase in rice production is retained over the
following years. It seems that flood almost acts as a trigger to reach next higher level
of rice production.
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
224
Based on preceding discussions, it can be argued that ironically flood has
been more instrumental in increasing crop production than flood control projects.
The need therefore is to take advantage of normal flood and control the damaging
flood. It requires a shift in water resources management tactics during monsoon
from flood control to controlled flooding. This shift in approach is already gaining
traction in the country (see Rahman and Salehin 2013).
12.4
Dry Season Water Resources Management
Bangladesh experiences a tropical monsoonal climate with distinct wet and dry
seasons. In the dry season, evapo-transpiration is much higher than the dependable
rainfall and consequently irrigation is required for cultivating crops. Irrigation
development in Bangladesh has been by a host of technologies – deep tube well
(DTW), shallow tube well (STW), low lift pump (LLP), manual lifting, traditional
equipment and diversion by gravitational flow. The country has witnessed a
phenomenal increase in its irrigated area. The total irrigated area was about 1.2 Mha
in 1972–1973, immediately after its independence in 1971, and such area increased
to about 6.6 Mha in 2010–2011 (Fig. 12.10). The average increase was about
145,000 ha per annum. The rate of increase in the total area has also grown over the
years due to changes in government policies. The time line of irrigation development in Bangladesh can be divided into three overlapping phases as discussed
below.
7.0
Irrigated area (Mha)
6.0
Total
DTW
STW
5.0
4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
2010
2006
2002
1998
1994
1990
1986
1982
1978
1974
1970
0.0
Year
Fig. 12.10 Time series of irrigation development in Bangladesh (Source of data: different statistical yearbooks of Bangladesh published by BBS; Total irrigated area in the figure indicates the
irrigation coverage by all modes using both surface and groundwater)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
12 Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring Food Security
12.4.1
225
Public Agency Managed Large-Scale Project
for Surface Water Development
The development of modern irrigation in Bangladesh started in 1950s with LLP
irrigation in Kishoreganj district in the north-eastern part of the country. However,
the farmers received the irrigation water first from a large-scale constructed facility
in 1962–1963 with the commencement of the Ganges-Kobadak Project (see Fig. 12.7),
the first irrigation project in the south-western part of the country. Since then a
number of projects with irrigation component including Chandpur Irrigation Project,
Dhaka-Narayanganj-Demra Project, Monu River Project, Meghna-Dhonagoda
Irrigation Project, Teesta Barrage Project and others were implemented in different
parts of the country.
These projects were large-scale, surface water based public undertakings in line
with the government strategy and plan for economic development during the 1950s
and 1960s. A large sum of foreign aid was made available to these projects through
the Asian Development Bank, the World Bank, the Canadian International
Development Agency, European Economic Community, etc. The major objectives
of these projects were to increase food production and to achieve self-sufficiency in
food grain production by reducing flooding, improving drainage, preventing overland seawater intrusion, or providing irrigation facilities. Though the earlier projects, such as the Ganges-Kobadak Project, were designed to provide supplementary
irrigation to Aman rice, the later projects were also designed to expand Boro rice
area in the dry period and to shift from the local varieties of rice to the high yielding
varieties.
The performance of these large-scale surface water projects in irrigation development has not been satisfactory (Lindquist 1989). The irrigation coverage by the
large-scale surface water projects with gravity flow has only been about 0.4 % of
the total irrigated area up to the year of 2010–2011 (BADC 2011). The large-scale
surface water project also supplies irrigation water with LLPs, the irrigation coverage of which is not available separately. Also, the irrigation coverage by the surface
water during the dry season has remained around 1 Mha throughout the last three
decades (Fig. 12.11).
The contribution of surface water to the total irrigation coverage has declined
over the years. The contribution during early 1980s was about 60 %, which has
decreased to about 20 % in recent years. Delays in project implementation, inadequate budgetary allocation for routine operation and maintenance and post-flood
rehabilitation, lack of sufficient water for irrigation during the dry season, lack of
adequate mechanism for agricultural development, poor inter-agency coordination
and inadequate consideration of socio-cultural complexities are among the major
factors for the poor performance of the large-scale projects. In addition, cost recovery
in this type of project has been very low.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
226
1400
70
1200
60
1000
50
800
40
600
30
20
400
area
200
10
coverage (%)
SW irrigation coverage (%)
SW irrigated area ('000 ha)
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
0
2010
2008
2006
2004
2002
2000
1998
1996
1994
1992
1990
1988
1986
1984
1982
0
Fig. 12.11 Time series of the surface water (SW) irrigated area and coverage as a percentage of
the total irrigated area (Source of data: BADC 2011)
12.4.2
Public Agency Managed Deep Tube Well Based
Groundwater Development
The use of groundwater for irrigation in Bangladesh began in the early 1960s with
the installation of DTWs in the northern district of Thakurgaon by the Bangladesh
Water Development Board (BWDB). These tube wells were heavily subsidized and
agency managed. Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation (BADC)
started exploitation of groundwater in similar time with the installation of DTWs in
Comilla area. These tube wells were rented against fixed yearly charges to the farmers’ cooperative societies (KSSs) organized by the Integrated Rural Development
Program (IRDP) of Comilla under the Thana Irrigation Program. The program was
thereafter expanded throughout the country by the Bangladesh Rural Development
Board (BRDB). The BWDB owned DTWs suffered major performance problems
(IIMI and BAU 1996) and the BRDB-KSS managed DTW schemes soon experienced a high drop-out due to the problem of cooperation amongst the KSS members
and between the KSS and non-KSS members (Mandal 1989).
From the late 1970s through the early 1980s, there was a continued effort to
decrease public involvement in minor irrigation. There was a move to discontinue
DTW and LLP rental programs and to sell both new and old DTWs and LLPs to
groups in the private sector. However, the Government maintained its control on
DTW siting and installation through the late 1980s and major donors continued to
support large subsidies throughout the 1980s despite the poor economic showing of
this technology.
A major change in groundwater irrigation governance occurred in 1989, when
the Government withdrew the installation, use and siting restrictions of minor
irrigation equipment by suspending the Groundwater Management Rules, 1987.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
12 Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring Food Security
227
BADC stopped DTW installation after 1989–1990 through its rental and sale
programs. Since 1990, the trend of irrigation development by DTWs has been
slightly higher than the past (Fig. 12.10). Currently, about 33,670 numbers of
DTWs are in operation, of which 13,830 numbers by BADC and 12,822 numbers
by BMDA. About 14 % of the irrigation coverage is presently by DTWs. It must
be noted here that the DTW growth has not shown itself to be sustainable in an
unsubsidized environment (Fig. 12.10).
12.4.3
Privately Owned Shallow Tube Well Irrigation
The IECO Master Plan of 1964 largely ignored minor irrigation development
through wells on the assumption that it would be costly. The tube well technology
did not spread rapidly during the 1960s and 1970s because of Government’s heavy
bias towards flood control, and lack of political and financial commitment to
alternatives (Hanratty 1983). The expansion of the tube well technology was also
constrained by the lack of comprehensive knowledge about groundwater resources.
In the early 1970s after liberation and following the Land and Water Resources
Sector Study (IBRD 1972), the Government’s main strategies for economic development were to take short gestation, low capital and quick yielding projects. These
were manifested in the country’s first 5 year plan (1973–1978), first 2 year plan
(1978–1980) and the second 5 year plan (1980–1985). A fundamental change in the
government policy occurred in the late 1970s with the adoption of the policy of
privatization of minor irrigation equipment along with the distribution of fertilizers,
seeds and pesticides.
Under the privatization program, STWs and DTWs were introduced in the late
1970s and early 1980s through the extended and liberalized credit policies. This
involved the selling of LLPs and DTWs as mentioned earlier, and the acceleration
in the sales of STWs by BADC either for cash or with BRDB loans advanced
through the KSSs. The sale of tube wells was also promoted through the liberalized
credit advanced from the commercial banks, of which the Bangladesh Krishi Bank
was the biggest lender. Irrigation related government institutions were restructured
at this time.
All these above changes led to a massive expansion in the tube well irrigation.
Figure 12.10 shows that the irrigation coverage in the country is increasing steadily
since early 1990s. This may be primarily in response to the suspension of the
Groundwater Management Rules in 1989, the removal of the ban on importation of
small diesel engines in 1987, and the elimination of import duties on irrigation
equipment and rescinding of regulations on engine standardization in 1988–1989.
The availability of water at shallow depth, comparatively low unit cost and relatively
easy sinking, operation and maintenance of the technology made rapid expansion of
STW irrigation in the country.
The number of operational STWs in the country in 1982–1983 was 0.09 million,
which increased to 1.55 million in 2010–2011. The irrigated area by STWs in 1982–1983
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
228
Table 12.2 Irrigation coverage by different modes
Mode of
No. of operational equipment
development
in rabi season of 2010–2011
DTW
33,670
STW
1,549,149
LLP
173,669
Gravity
n/a
Manual
n/a
Traditional
n/a
Source: BADC (2011)
Note: n/a is not available
Irrigated area (thousand ha)
in rabi season of 2010–2011
719.2
3,505.3
1,010.0
19.1
6.4
3.8
Irrigation
coverage (%)
13.7
66.6
19.1
0.4
0.1
0.1
Irrigated area (Mha)
6.0
5.0
Total
4.0
Aman
Boro
3.0
2.0
1.0
2011
2008
2005
2002
1999
1996
1993
1990
1987
1984
1981
1978
1975
1972
1969
0.0
Year
Fig. 12.12 Time series of irrigated rice areas in Bangladesh (Note: Total area in the figure includes
Boro, Aman and Aus rice irrigated areas)
was only about 0.4 Mha, which increased to 3.5 Mha in 2010–11. The contribution
of STW to total irrigated area currently stands at about 67 %. The recent irrigation
coverage by different modes of development is given in Table 12.2.
12.4.4
Challenges Ahead
Quality seeds, irrigation, fertilizers and pesticides are the major inputs for agricultural production. Increasing use of these inputs is contributing to the increasing
agricultural production. The Boro rice irrigation has increased rapidly since late
1980s (Fig. 12.12). However, the increase in the Aman rice irrigation has not been
much and the crop is still dominantly rainfed.
The use of chemical fertilizers increased rapidly up to the year of 1995–1996
(Fig. 12.13). However, it seems that the use of these fertilizers has stabilized since
then. The use of pesticides increased exponentially until very recently. Though it
appears that the use of both fertilizer and pesticide has stabilized, the production is
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
229
3500
60000
3000
50000
2500
Fertilizer
2000
Pesticide
40000
30000
1500
20000
1000
Pesticide use (t)
Fertilizer use ('000 t)
12 Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring Food Security
10000
500
0
1969
1971
1973
1975
1977
1979
1981
1983
1985
1987
1989
1991
1993
1995
1997
1999
2001
2003
2005
2007
2009
2011
0
Year
Fig. 12.13 Time series of fertilizer and pesticide use in Bangladesh
4.5
4.0
Yield (t/ha)
3.5
Aus
Aman
Boro
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
1947
1950
1953
1956
1959
1962
1965
1968
1971
1974
1977
1980
1983
1986
1989
1992
1995
1998
2001
2004
2007
0.0
Year
Fig. 12.14 Time series of rice yields in Bangladesh
still increasing (Fig. 12.9) due mainly to the increasing irrigation coverage and
continuous replacement of local rice varieties by the improved varieties. These contributed to the increases in yields of the Aus, Aman and Boro rice (Fig. 12.14) at the
rates of 12, 17 and 43 kg/ha-year, respectively. The contribution of the cropping
intensity has been minimal as it has not changed much since the early 1990s.
The population of the country is projected to be about 181 million by 2025
(WARPO 2000). To feed the ever increasing population, agricultural production,
especially food grain production, will have to be increased. According to WARPO
(2000), there would be a shortfall of 6.4 Mt of clean rice in 2025. The shortfall in
2050 is projected to be about 9.0 Mt. Though the present production level of rice is
adequate to meet the present demand and the demand in the near future, there are a
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
230
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
number of challenges in maintaining a production level which is commensurate to
the population growth.
Firstly, the cultivable area of the country is declining at a rate of 1 % per year
(MoA 2013) due mainly to increased settlement, industrial and commercial uses.
The land available for agriculture is likely to decrease to 7.0 Mha in 2025 from 8.4
Mha in 2000 (WARPO 2000). Moreover, about 30 % of the cultivable land in
Bangladesh is in the coastal and off-shore areas, of which about 37 % is affected by
varying degrees of salinity. Cropping and irrigation intensities are considerably
lower in the saline areas compared to the non-saline areas. Spatial extent of saline
area is increasing over time due to reduction in freshwater inflow into the rivers
from upstream, introduction of brackish water for shrimp cultivation, increase in
high tidal water level, cyclonic storm surge led inundation, etc. (SRDI 2012; Mondal
et al. 2013). Salt affected area in the country has increased by about 27 % between
1973 and 2009 (SRDI 2012). Unless the current trend of conversion of fertile agricultural land for non-agricultural uses is arrested with the introduction of land use
act, which is currently lacking, the food grain security of the country will be at risk.
Secondly, the availability of water, in terms of both quantity and quality, may
pose a constraint to agricultural expansion and intensification. In some areas, such
as Dhaka, Tangail, Rajshahi and Bogra, there is already evidence of groundwater
mining. Excessive groundwater withdrawal has affected drinking water supplies
using hand tube wells. The village ponds which are used by the local people for
bathing, cleaning, washing, cooking and subsistence aquaculture become dry in
many places during the critical dry period. The base-flow to the rivers, particularly
to the small and regional rivers, has reduced significantly and many rivers now
become dry during the dry months. This drying of local wells, ponds and rivers is
adversely affecting the lives and livelihoods of the rural people, particularly the
poor, women and children.
Surface and groundwater salinity is a major constraint to irrigation development
in the coastal region of Bangladesh. The situation is likely to aggravate with the
rising sea level induced by the global climate change, reduced freshwater flow due
to upstream diversion, increased groundwater withdrawal and extended brackish
water aquaculture. The groundwater of the shallow aquifer is arsenic contaminated
in major parts of the country. This contamination is often blamed to the exploitation
of groundwater for irrigation with STWs (GED 2011). Also, there is a general
concern that arsenic can enter the food chain, although the concern is not firmly
established (WARPO 2000).
In addition to the groundwater resource constraint, the surface water resource is
continuously decreasing and deteriorating. The water bodies of the country are being
continuously encroached upon and filled in illegally by the powerful section of the
society due to lax regulation and poor water and environmental governance (Mondal
et al. 2014). The water quality of the rivers near urban and industrial areas, particularly
surrounding Dhaka City, has deteriorated so badly that this water is not suitable
even for irrigation (Rahman and Mondal 2013). Also, there is a strong likelihood
that some water will be transferred to urban areas and industries from agriculture
with the increasing urbanization and industrialization trends of the country.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
12 Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring Food Security
231
All these will put the rice cultivation system with standing water under pressure
and maintaining rice self-sufficiency would be a challenging task. Also, there is
concern that too much reliance on rice cultivation in all seasons and areas has
restricted crop diversification and created problems of soil nutrient mining and pest
prevalence (Hasanuzzaman 2003). Mondal and Wasimi (2007) and Mondal et al.
(2010) have shown that Bangladesh is already facing a water shortage during the
critical months of March, April and May. For example, total demand for water in
March within the GBM basins in the country is estimated to be about 30 billion
cubic meters (BCM). The available supply from major and regional rivers, underground aquifer, static water bodies, etc., in the same month is about 25 BCM resulting in a demand–supply ratio of about 1.20 (Mondal 2011). This ratio would be
higher for the drought-prone west-central region due to higher evapo-transpiration
and lower rainfall compared to the rest of the country. This ratio would be even
further higher in the salinity-affected southern coastal region due to leaching
requirement for salts and physical scarcity of fresh water. Additionally, the water
security of the country will be at risk if a further diversion takes place in the upstream
co-riparian countries from the trans-boundary rivers, a worst possible climate
change occurs, or the groundwater becomes unsuitable for use due to arsenic
contamination.
Thirdly, though Bangladesh is currently self-sustaining in rice production due to
the favorable climate that has prevailed over the country since 2008 (except the
cyclone Aila in 2009), the sufficiency is likely to be at risk in the event of a largescale natural hazard such as flood unless buffer storage facility is created. The Aman
rice contributes about 38 % to the total current rice production which is vulnerable to
the monsoonal flooding and post-monsoonal cyclone, and the Boro rice contributes
about 56 % which is vulnerable to the pre-monsoonal flooding, cyclone, tornado and
drought. A good harvest of Boro can support the rice demand over a period of about
seven months from May to November. For the rice demand in the remaining five
months, the country also need a good harvest of Aman. If either of the two harvests
is affected significantly by a natural disaster, the country is likely to face a deficit
which is very likely under a future scenario of increasing climate variability and
change. Furthermore, it appears from the Fig. 12.9 that the country has reached
almost at its upper limit of rice production.
Fourthly, the net irrigable area of the country was about 7.56 Mha during the
mid-1990s. By the present time, that area has significantly reduced due to conversion of irrigable lands for non-agricultural uses. The recent irrigation coverage is
estimated to be about 6.15 Mha based on BBS (2012) data. Thus it appears that
there is not much scope for expansion of irrigation due to land constraint. There is
also evidence that people in some areas are reverting to non-rice crops from their
earlier practice of Boro rice due to unavailability of adequate irrigation water and
higher profitability of non-rice crops. Also, to discourage excessive groundwater
withdrawal for irrigation, the Government has recently reinstated the Groundwater
Management Rules of 1987 and imposed siting restrictions on tube wells.
It is thus likely that the irrigation sector will not get any significant increase in
freshwater supplies in future unless large-scale surface water development targeting
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
232
major rivers are undertaken. An initiative by BADC is now underway to develop
surface water in the south-central coastal region, but its success cannot be predicted
at this moment given the poor outcome of similar initiative earlier through the
Barisal Irrigation Project. The feasibility study of the proposed Ganges Barrage
Project is also now underway which may bring some more areas in the south-west
and south-central regions under irrigation once the project is implemented. The
Government policy also very recently has shifted towards surface water development (GED 2011; MoA 2013). Though the experience of the surface water based
large-scale projects in irrigation development has not been favorable, the move will
allow conjunctive use of surface and groundwater and provide long-term water
security which is particularly important to deal with the future climatic and upstream
diversion uncertainties and risks.
Bangladesh suffers from inefficiency in irrigation water use. On an average,
about 1,075 mm of water is used against a net irrigation requirement of about
370 mm to cultivate Boro rice in the country. The dominant practice in rice irrigation has been through the maintenance of standing water on a farm which increases
losses. The current irrigation efficiency of the country is about 34 % against the
potential of about 50 % (Alam 2011). To compare, the irrigation efficiency in India
is about 38 % (Planning Commission 2009) and that in China is about 48 %. Thus,
programs should be undertaken to increase irrigation efficiency and water productivity through improvement in distribution system, on-farm water management
practices, water pricing, etc. Low water demanding food and cash crops, which are
economically favorable and suited to local agro-ecological setting, deserve consideration (Karim and Hussain 2003). The investment in crop varietal improvement
targeting higher yield, shorter duration and hazard resiliency is likely to enhance
food security of the country.
12.5
Conclusions
In recent times, Bangladesh has achieved self-sufficiency in rice production.
The contribution of the large-scale flood control and irrigation projects to this
achievement can be contested. It is seen that groundwater based privately owned
shallow tube well technology has been most instrumental in dry season Boro rice
irrigation and thereby increasing rice production. However, excessive withdrawal
of groundwater for irrigation, increasing salinity in coastal region, arsenic contamination in upper aquifer, decreasing and deteriorating surface water, declining of
available land and future climate change pose potential risks in maintaining the food
security of the country with growing population and standard of living. Improvement
of irrigation efficiency and water productivity, conjunctive use of surface and
groundwater, stoppage of conversion of agricultural land for non-agricultural uses
through land use act and crop improvement through research and innovation should
be given priority to maintain the food security.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
12 Role of Water Resource Management in Ensuring Food Security
233
References
Ahmad QK, Ahmed AU (2003) Regional cooperation in flood management in the GangesBrahmaputra-Meghna Region: Bangladesh perspective. Nat Hazards 28:181–198
Alam ME (2011) Assessment of irrigation efficiency and techno-socio-economic opportunities for
its improvement in minor irrigation. PhD thesis, Institute of Water and Flood Management,
Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology, Dhaka
Alam MS, Islam MA (2013) Long term assessment of rice production scenario in Bangladesh: a
macro dynamics. Bangladesh J Agric Res 38(2):257–269
BADC (2011) Minor irrigation survey report 2010–11. Survey and Monitoring Project for
Development of Minor Irrigation, Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation, Ministry
of Agriculture, Dhaka
BBS (2011a) Yearbook of agricultural statistics of Bangladesh. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics,
Dhaka
BBS (2011b) Report of the household income and expenditure survey 2010. Bangladesh Bureau
of Statistics, Dhaka
BBS (2012) Statistical yearbook of Bangladesh 2012. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, Dhaka
Brammer H, Khan HR (1991) Bangladesh country study. In: Disaster mitigation in Asia and the
Pacific. Asian Development Bank, Manila
FAO AQUASTAT (2011) Bangladesh: water country brief. Food and Agriculture Organization
FPCO (1992) FAP 12 FCD/I agricultural study. Flood Plan Coordination Organization, Ministry
of Irrigation, Water Development and Flood Control, Dhaka
GED (2011) 6th five year plan FY 2011-FY 2015: accelerating growth and reducing poverty.
General Economic Division, Planning Commission, Dhaka
Hanratty M (1983) Minor irrigation in Bangladesh. USAID, Dhaka
Haruisha A, Jun M, Rahman R (2005) Impact of recent severe floods on rice production in
Bangladesh. Geogr Rev Jpn 78(12):783–793
Hasanuzzaman SM (2003) Impact of groundwater utilization on agriculture. In: Rahman AA,
Ravenscroft P (eds) Groundwater resources and development in Bangladesh: background to
the arsenic crisis, agricultural potential and the environment. The University Press Limited,
Dhaka, pp 161–185
Hossain M (2009) The impact of shallow tubewells and boro rice on food security in Bangladesh.
IFPRI discussion paper 00917, International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington, DC
IBRD (1972) Land and water sector study. International Bank for Reconstruction and Development
(The World Bank), Dhaka
IECO (1964) Master plan, vols I and II. East Pakistan Water and Power Development Authority
(Now Bangladesh Water Development Board), Dhaka
IIMI, BAU (1996) Study on privatization of minor irrigation in Bangladesh, final report.
International Irrigation Management Institute and Bangladesh Agricultural University, Ministry
of Agriculture, Dhaka
Karim Z, Hussain SG (2003) Harnessing water resources for Bangladesh agriculture. In: Rahman
AA, Ravenscroft P (eds) Groundwater resources and development in Bangladesh: background
to the arsenic crisis, agricultural potential and the environment. The University Press Limited,
Dhaka, pp 187–195
Lindquist AC (1989) Project aid in agriculture: major (surface water) flood control, drainage and
irrigation projects. Bangladesh agriculture sector review, compendium vol. III: land, water and
irrigation. UNDP, Dhaka, pp 1–41
Mandal MAS (1989) Market for and return from groundwater irrigation in Bangladesh. Bangladesh
agriculture sector review, compendium vol. III: land, water and irrigation. UNDP, Dhaka, pp 42–74
MoA (2013) National agriculture policy. Ministry of Agriculture, Dhaka
Mondal MS (2011) Review of regional water demand and resources in the Ganges-BrahmaputraMeghna basins. In: Proceedings of the 3rd international conference on water and flood management, Institute of Water and Flood Management, Dhaka, pp 359–370
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
234
R. Rahman and M.S. Mondal
Mondal MS, Wasimi SA (2007) Evaluation of risk-related performance in water management for
the Ganges Delta of Bangladesh. J Water Resour Plan Manag 133(2):179–187
Mondal MS, Chowdhury JU, Ferdous MR (2010) Risk-based evaluation for meeting future water
demand of the Brahmaputra floodplain within Bangladesh. Water Resour Manag
24(5):835–852
Mondal MS, Jalal MR, Khan MSA, Kumar U, Rahman R, Huq H (2013) Hydro-meteorological
trends in southwest coastal Bangladesh: perspectives of climate change and human interventions. Am J Clim Change 2(1):62–70
Mondal MS, Salehin M, Huq H (2014) Evaluation of institutional arrangements for governance of
rivers surrounding Dhaka City. In: Narain V, Goodrich CG, Chourey J, Prakash A (eds) Water
in a globalizing world: state, markets and civil society in south Asia. Routledge, New Delhi,
pp 273–291
MoWR (1999) National water policy. Ministry of Water Resources, Dhaka
MPO (1991) Evaluation of historical water resource development and implication for the national
water plan. Master Plan Organization (Now Water Resources Planning Organization), Dhaka
Planning Commission (2009) Report of the task force on irrigation. Government of India,
New Delhi
Rahman R, Chowdhury JU (1999) Macro impact of flood control projects on Aman rice production, Final report R 02/99. Institute of Water and Flood Management, Bangladesh University of
Engineering and Technology, Dhaka
Rahman M, Mondal MS (2013) Impact of the Bangshi river water quality on irrigated soil and rice
in Bangladesh. Asian J Water, Environ Pollut 10(1):129–139
Rahman R, Salehin M (2013) Flood risk and reduction approaches in Bangladesh. In: Mallick F,
Islam A, Shaw R (eds) Disaster risk reduction approaches in Bangladesh. Springer, Tokyo,
pp 65–90
Saleh AFMS, Mondal MS (2009) Impact of submersible embankment projects on Boro production
in haor areas. Bangladesh J Water Resour Res 21:55–77
SRDI (2012) Saline soils of Bangladesh. Soil Resource Development Institute, Ministry of
Agriculture, Dhaka
Talukder RK (2005) Food security, self Sufficiency and nutrition gap in Bangladesh. Bangladesh
Dev Stud 31(3&4):35–62
WARPO (2000) Draft development strategy, annex C: land and water resources. Water Resources
Planning Organization, Dhaka
WARPO (2001) National water management plan. Water Resources Planning Organization, Dhaka
Yu WH, Alam M, Hassan A, Khan AS, Ruane AC, Rosenzweig C, Major DC, Thurlow J (2010)
Climate change risks and food security in Bangladesh. Earthscan, London, p 11
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security
and Human Health: Cross-Cutting Issues
in Bangladesh
Gulsan Ara Parvin, Kumiko Fujita, Akiko Matsuyama, Rajib Shaw,
and Maiko Sakamoto
Abstract Climate change will affect all aspects of hydrological cycle. Frequent
and severe flood, cyclone and drought are already apparent in all over the world.
Climate change impact on natural disasters and agricultural system are the most
critical, since these two aspects are intimately associated with life, livelihood and
food security of both rural and urban community. Frequent climate induced disasters,
like floods, cyclone, storm surges, disruption of agricultural system and shortage of
food for growing population would have decisive impact on human health.
Bangladesh, which is one of the most vulnerable countries due to climate change,
suffers from floods almost every year. However, 70 % of its population depends on
agriculture and lives at the risk of flood. Food security and health of this large
segment of population are critical issues of development in present climate change
context. To face these critical issues climate change, flood, food security and human
health are the four associated vital issues that should be dealt together. This paper is
an approach to address these four issues with an interconnected dimension. It would
help to formulate comprehensive policy strategies and leading action plans for
climate change adaptation.
Keywords Climate change • Flood • Food security • Health • Bangladesh
G.A. Parvin (*) • K. Fujita • R. Shaw
Graduate School of Global Environmental Studies, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
e-mail: niruurp@yahoo.com
A. Matsuyama
School of International Health Development, Nagasaki University, Nagasaki, Japan
M. Sakamoto
Graduate School of Frontier Sciences, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_13
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
235
236
13.1
G.A. Parvin et al.
Introduction
Disaster is a critical issue in Bangladesh because of its topography and weather.
Almost every year, this country experiences disaster, such as tropical cyclones,
storm surges, coastal erosion, floods, and droughts. Bangladesh is a deltaic country
located at lower part of the basins of the three mighty rivers – the Ganges, the
Brahmaputra, and the Meghna (commonly known as the GBM river system and
ranking as one of the largest river systems in the world) (Fig. 13.1). Almost half of
the area is within 10 m above mean sea level (m.a.s.l.) and the flood plains make up
80 % of the country.
Humid, warm and tropical climate are also the triggers of flood. There are four
prominent seasons, namely, winter (December to February), Pre-monsoon (March
to May), Monsoon (June to early-October) and Post-monsoon (late-October to
November). Heavy rainfall is characteristic of Bangladesh. The annual rainfall is at
least 2,000 mm in most parts of the country excepting relatively dry western region
with annual rainfall about 1,600 mm. In addition to the rainfall in Bangladesh,
rainfall in India, Nepal, China and Bhutan drains into Bangladesh through three
mighty rivers, their tributaries and distributaries. As a result of monsoon and flat
topography, floods are annual phenomena and regular river floods affect about
20 % of the country during monsoon season.
Bangladesh generally experiences four types of flood, (i) Flash Flood, (ii) Rain
fed Flood, (iii) RiverFlood, and (iv) Flood due Cyclonic Storm Surges (WMO/GWP
2003). Area affected by these four types of flood is shown in Fig. 13.2.
Fig. 13.1 The Ganges, Brahmaputra and Meghna basins (Mirza 2002)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security and Human Health: Cross-Cutting Issues…
237
Fig. 13.2 Flood affected area (WMO/GWP 2003)
The flooding keeps the soil fertile because the rivers deposit silt, which forms
fertile soil each year. Rice is the staple of Bangladesh and the traditional rice agriculture is dependent on the monsoon rain and river flood. Rice cropping season
reflects climatic environment of tropical monsoon. There are three cropping season,
“Aus” farming (from April to August), “Aman” farming (from April to December)
in rainy season, and “Boro” farming (from December to April) in dry season.
Bangladesh farmers call the annual blessed rain-induced flood “Barsh”, and call
destructive flood “Bonna.” Thus, welcome “Barsh” flood secures the traditional
monsoon farming and fishing area also (Uchida and Ando 2003).
“Bonna” floods cause social disruptions and result in scarcity of drinking water
as surface water get contaminated by organic and inorganic substances. Cases of
diarrhea, cholera and other intestine diseases increase remarkably during and after
floods (Brouwer et al. 2007). The increased volume of rainfall caused by climate
change during the past decades has intensified the flood problem in Bangladesh
(Brouwer et al. 2007). Climate change adds a new dimension to risk. Climate change
is expected to increase the frequency and magnitude of many types of extreme
events, including floods, droughts, tropical cyclones and wildfires (IPCC 2007).
Developing countries are particularly affected by climate change because their basic
industries are in climate-sensitive sectors, such as agriculture and fisheries (Imanishi
2000). Food production is being disrupted by flooding more frequently and more
severely than before due to climate change (Douglas 2009).
Climate change is likely to pose problems for Bangladesh food supplies because
agriculture is so dependent on the monsoon (Shukla 2003). Climate change will
affect all aspects of hydrological cycle. Climate change impact on natural disasters
and agricultural system are the most critical, since these two aspects are intimately
associated with life, livelihood and food security of both rural and urban community.
Frequent climate induced disasters, like floods, cyclone, storm surges, disruption of
agricultural system and shortage of food for growing population of Bangladesh
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
238
G.A. Parvin et al.
would have decisive impact on human health. To face these critical issues climate
change, flood, food security and human health are the four associated vital issues
that should be dealt together. In this chapter, global and Bangladesh perspectives are
reviewed for four interconnected issues of climate change, flood, food security and
human health. This paper is an approach to address these four issues with an interconnected dimension. It would help to formulate comprehensive policy strategies
and leading action plans for climate change adaptation.
13.2
Climate Change and Flood
There is increasing evidence that disaster is a major factor in prolonging poverty; yet
the development community is only beginning to prioritize disaster risk management as an important component of international development and aid strategies,
as well as an important consideration in adapting to climate change (Amendola
et al. 2008). In this section, the relation of climate change and global flood risk
management and Bangladesh perspectives are reviewed.
13.2.1
Global Perspective
According to the Climate Change 2007: Synthesis Report by IPCC, warming of the
climate system is unequivocal, as is now evident from observations of increases in
global average air and ocean temperatures, widespread melting of snow and ice
and rising global average sea level (IPCC 2007). Climate change is likely to change
the nature of many types of hazards, not only hydrometeorological events such as
floods, windstorms, and droughts, but also events such as landslides, heat weaves
and disease outbreaks, influencing not only the intensity, but also the duration and
magnitude of these events (Kundzewicz et al. 2006). Figure 13.3 shows the number
of natural catastrophe loss events worldwide 1980–2013. The trend in total number
of events per year continues to rise. The trend in the number of hydrological events
(flood and mass movement) per year is also continues to rise.
Traditional flood management, which responded to a severe flood, was typically
an ad hoc reaction– the quick implementation of a project that considered both the
problem and its solution to be self-evident, and that gave no thought to the consequences for upstream and downstream flood risks. Thus, flood management practices have largely focused on reducing flooding and reducing the susceptibility to
flood damage (WMO 2009). Disaster risk management has traditionally involved
natural scientists and civil engineers and has concentrated on short-term single
stressor responses through structural measures, such as flood embankments, community shelters and more resistant buildings, which were intended to control natural
processes in a way that would either modify the threat or provide physical protection with regard to lives, property and critical infrastructure (Thomalla et al. 2006).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security and Human Health: Cross-Cutting Issues…
239
Fig. 13.3 Number of natural catastrophe loss events worldwide 1980–2013 (Source: Munich Re
Geo Risks Research 2014)
As a result, flood control measures are confined to major rivers in most of the Asian
countries. It has been witnessed that this approach is not effective to control large
magnitude floods (Dutta and Hearth 2004). Flood control efforts such as levee and
dam construction have led to more severe floods by preventing the natural dissipation
of excess water in flood plains. The cost of flood damage has increased as the flood
plains were developed by people who believed they are safe (Pahl-Wostl 2006).
In case of flood control, policy makers, resource managers and engineers underestimated the importance of feedback effects, non-linearities, time delays and changes
in human behavior as a consequence of policy interventions (Pahl-Wostl 2006).
The United Nations World Conference on Disaster Reduction held in Yokohama
in 1994 has contributed to a shift in disaster management towards a more comprehensive approach. It is recognized that to cope with increasing frequency of floods,
with high magnitudes, new and holistic approaches have to be adopted. As a result,
basin wide integrated flood management is considered to be the most suitable for
coping with new challenges in flood disaster mitigation (Dutta and Hearth 2004).
A river basin is a natural unit for integrated water resources planning and management.
Other terms that are used to describe a river basin are catchment area, catchment
basin, drainage area, drainage basin, watershed and so on. A river basin is a portion
occupied by a main stream and its tributaries separated from adjacent basins by
drainage divide. It sends all the water falling on the surrounding land into a central
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
240
G.A. Parvin et al.
river and out to the sea. As a result, within a river basin, surface and groundwater
interact with and to a large degree controls the extent of other natural components
such as soil, vegetation, and wildlife (Cai et al. 2003). Because of these backgrounds,
in a river basin, natural resources management in general, and water resources
management in particular, are currently undergoing a major paradigm shift
(Pahl-Wostl et al. 2006).
13.2.2
Bangladesh Perspective
Floods are annual phenomena in Bangladesh and floods occur during the months of
July and August. Regular river floods affect 20 % of the country increasing up to
two third in extreme years. After severe floods, flood management strategies have
been shifted. It can be divided in to four distinct phases of its development as
follows (modified WMO/GWP 2003).
Phase 1: 1960–1978
Phase 2: 1978–1996
Phase 3: 1996–2004
Phase 4: 2004–2014 onward
Phase 1
Flood management in Bangladesh has started 1960s. The Bangladesh government
has made considerable effort in the Flood Control, Drainage and/or Irrigation
(FCD/I) project. Water Development Master Plan was prepared in 1964. Since mid
1960s there has been a steady growth of flood control and drainage projects in
Bangladesh through the construction of embankments, drainage channels, and
sluices and regulations, with the total coverage area standing at 5.37 million ha
(Rahman and Salehin 2013). It is mainly focused on protecting the agricultural
lands because agriculture was the main industry. It gave high priority on structural
solutions having large project portfolios with large investments as well as longer
duration. Accordingly, Government started implementing large flood control projects for improving drainage and irrigation. While the projects yielded a number of
positive impacts such as increase in agricultural production, increase in economic
activities, reduction of damage to infrastructure inside protected area (Rahman and
Salehin 2013), it was time consuming, and during the implementation of these projects some medium scale flood occurred and caused lots of suffering to the people.
In addition, since those embankments disturbed local hydrological conditions, local
people destroyed some of them for their convenience. Moreover, because of the
poor operation and maintenance of the embankment, it caused depletion of fish
stocks and deposition of silt in the riverbed as well as on the agricultural lands.
As a result, non-structural measures were also considered as a means for mitigating
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security and Human Health: Cross-Cutting Issues…
241
flood damages, and as a non-structural measure, the Flood Forecasting and Warning
Center of Bangladesh Water Development Board was established in 1972, which is
responsible for making flood forecasts and flood warning during the flood season
(Rahman and Salehin 2013).
Phase 2
Though, the main objective of flood control projects was to protect the crop land
from flood damage, there occurred considerable crop damage even in years of
moderate flood because the embankments were also damaged (Rahman and Salehin
2013). Government also realized that water resources development should not be
focused only on agriculture rather it should take into account other sectors related to
water resources utilization and development for economic as well as public goods.
As a result National Water Plan (NWP) was formulated in 1982 and finalized in
1986, however it did not receive Government’s approval due to some of its drawbacks.
There were particularly catastrophic floods in 1987 and 1988, resulting in largescale destruction and loss of lives. In the aftermath, various studies were conducted
in the assessment of confining these floods and a strategy of “living with the floods”
was applied, which is the more traditional way of dealing with these floods in these
circumstances (Rahman and Salehin 2013). This concept led subsequently to the
implementation of the project entitled Flood Action Plan (FAP) from 1990 to 1996.
The concept of “living with flooding” for sustainable agricultural development has
become widespread through the FAP. Accordingly, it has been shifted from “flood
control” to “flood management”, that is, from structural solutions to combinations
of structural and non-structural measures. In addition to the structural solutions with
large investments as well as longer duration, Government opted for implementation
of small and medium scale FCD projects to provide early benefits.
Phase 3
There has been growing awareness of the need for a more integrated, multi-sector
approach to surface water management since the late 1980s. In addition, the earthen
embankment was unable to give protection against severe floods in 1998 and even
against some medium floods in 1991, 1993 and 1995 (Salehin et al. 2007). Then, at
the end of FAP studies, Government realized that all the issues concerning the water
resources development and utilization have not been addressed in the light of
Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM). A real start in the paradigm
shift in water resources management policy and practice towards “integrated” management took place with the preparation of the National Water Policy (NWP) in
1999 and subsequently the National Water Management Plan (NWMP) in 2001
(Rahman and Salehin 2013). The NWP makes clear the government’s intention to
pursue a policy of Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM) and further
pledges to take all necessary measures to manage the water resources of the country
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
G.A. Parvin et al.
242
in a comprehensive, integrated, equitable and environmentally sustainable manner.
The NWP specifically focuses on stakeholder participation at the service-delivery
level. This concern is evident in the directive that participation of all project- affected
persons, individually and collectively, is to be ensured in the planning, design,
implementation and operation and maintenance of publicly funded surface water
resources development plans and projects. NWMP is a framework plan for the
ministries to define strategies; agencies, department, and local bodies to prepare
projects.
Phase 4
In 2004, Bangladesh experienced one of the most devastating floods in nearly
50 years. About 38 % of the country went underwater (Disaster Management Bureau
2010). After one of the worst flood, occurred in 2004, Government reported that
Bangladesh clearly needs to improve disaster response and preparedness at local
level, with provision of immediate rescue resources, emergency funding mechanisms,
and better information management and contingency planning (DER Sub-Group
2004). Based on the lessons learnt from past water management and experience of
floods in 2004, 2007, 2010, 2012 and 2013, the participatory water management
approach is now considered an effective way to manage the complexity of water
management in Bangladesh. A paradigm shift in disaster management from conventional response and relief practice to a more comprehensive risk reduction culture is
slowly taking place (Zimmermann et al. 2010).
13.2.3
Challenges
Climate change is considered to change the nature of floods, influencing not only
the intensity, but also the duration and magnitude in the world, and Bangladesh
Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan (BCCSAP) 2009 also rightly weighted
the linkage of the climate change and disaster potentials. As same as the world perspective, the lessons learnt from the past water management in Bangladesh point out
that the focus of integrated water resources management must go beyond flood
control, drainage and irrigation. As a result, institutional frameworks for comprehensive disaster risk reduction have been established. The challenge now is all
stakeholders’ participation. Recently, community participation in water resource
management is being institutionalized. However, more attention must also be given
to the social dimensions that promote stakeholder participation and the transfer of
appropriate water management activities to the local communities. In addition to the
stakeholders’ participation, integrated river basin management is also the challenge
for Bangladesh flood management. Though the necessity of the integrated river
basin management is recognized in Bangladesh, it is not easy to establish institutional framework, since Bangladesh shares the river basins with upstream countries
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security and Human Health: Cross-Cutting Issues…
243
as Fig. 13.1 shows. However, one disaster in one country gives impacts on other
countries’ economy as a result of globalization. Linkage of river basin sharing countries is also considered as a climate change adaptation strategy for flood
management.
13.3
Climate Change and Flood-Impact on Food Security
Scholars claim that due to low GDP (US$ 1900/year) and high population density
(1,117/km2) food security has been considered as one of the key priorities for
national development of Bangladesh (Tandon 2012; Faisal and Parveen 2004).
Climate change has posed huge challenges to achieve this priority by declining
cultivated land and inaccessibility to fresh water, supply. At the same time climate
induced natural disasters, like flood, cyclone, and storm surges have increased the
vulnerability of the victims and increased their food crisis especially in the coastal
and rural Bangladesh (Raillon 2010). Among the various disasters flood is the most
common and frequent one (Rayhan 2010) and is considered to be one of the principal
threats of development in Bangladesh (Paul and Routray 2010).
Scientists’ projections of increasing precipitation and peak precipitation over
many areas, several unusual flood events have triggered discussions about a potential link between climate change and flooding (Van Aalst 2006). Further, researches
have predicted that climate change will lead intensification of global water cycle
with a consequent increase in flood risk (Cubasch 2001, cited in Milly et al. 2002).
Already in the world flood disasters have been increasing over the last 30 years. The
number of floods was 150 in 1980–1982 and it increased to 550 in 2004–2006
(Kobayashi et al. 2010). In Himalayan region, due to rising temperatures the rate of
melting of snow and glacier ice will be accelerated, which would increase seasonal
peak flows of rivers and it would lead to an increase of flooding in this region.
Particularly in South Asia Climate change is influencing the monsoon and tropical
cyclones, the two prime drivers of flood events (Douglas 2009).
Bangladesh is also facing this increasing trend of flood disasters. Studies using
climate model showed that the probability of extremely wet Asian monsoon seasons
would increase, with severe implications for flooding in Bangladesh (Van Aalst 2006).
These floods are disrupting food production more frequently and more severely than
before, due to climate change (Douglas 2009).
Since Bangladesh economy is still agrarian in nature, crop production and losses
of food crops during floods have always had severe impacts in its economy and food
security as well. In addition to the direct damage of food crop during flood, disruption of transport and communication system and storage facilities during flood
enhance the loss of food damage and adversely affect food supply and distribution
chain. Thus floods and food security is closely inter-linked in Bangladesh. Though last
three decades share of agriculture in GDP is declining 70 % of country population
still depends on agriculture for their livelihoods (Mirza 2002). These large segment
of population need to face crop damage, shortage of food supply, increase of food
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
G.A. Parvin et al.
244
price and loss of income and employment due to flood. Long back research warns
that crop damage and unemployment caused by floods will make an even larger section of population extremely vulnerable to starvation, malnutrition and even death
(Shahabuddin 2000). In fact, flood, crop damage, unemployment all of these situations threaten the food security, livelihoods and health of the poorest people of
Bangladesh, especially the women who the most vulnerable to disasters.
In Bangladesh, depending the extent and duration of flood, damage of crop is
different in different years. It is estimated that on average, yearly crop damage could
be about 0.5 million tons (Paul and Rasid 1993). But the floods like 1987, 1988 and
1998 caused higher magnitude of crop damages, which were estimated at 1.32, 2.10
and 3 million tons, respectively. Aman, which is one of the principal rice verities
of Bangladesh is highly sensitive to timely arrival of monsoons. Seed bed preparation, plantation and growth of Aman rice dependent on the normal rainfall and
non-occurrence of high floods. Further, it is noticed that high-yielding aman rice
varieties are very susceptible to floods as they are unable to keep up of flood water
(Mirza 2002).
Due to this close association of rice production and flood, all previous devastating
floods in Bangladesh had endangered food security of the country. Douglas (2009)
noted that in 1974 flood damaged about 0.6 million tones of crops and generated a
severe unemployment crisis for farm workers. Due to lack of food security the situation lead to a great famine in Bangladesh. During 1988 and 1998 floods in spite of
Government efforts to balance food demand and supply, food security at the household level could not be ensured. This serious problem will affect increasing numbers
of people living below the poverty line when bigger floods occur in future.
The scenario of flood induced food crisis has been shown in the following
section as a case study.
13.3.1
Food Consumption During Flood – An Evidence
from Rural Bangladesh
Through empirical study in one of the most flood vulnerable upazilas (sub-district)
of Bangladesh named GoalandaUpazilla (in Rajbari district) here in this section it
has been tried to examine the impact of flood on food consumption of rural poor
community. For household questionnaire survey total 120 households from different villages have been selected randomly. Recalling their every year’s experiences
related to food consumption during flood, especially the experiences of the severe
floods (in 1998, 2004 and 2007) people gave the answers related to the extent of
changes in their food consumption due to flood.
In this rural poor community overwhelming majority of the households are
landless and their income fall below the poverty line, which is less than 1 US$ per
day per person. About 63.3 % respondents claimed that during normal time they
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security and Human Health: Cross-Cutting Issues…
245
earn less than Tk. 3000 (US$ 38.6). About 53 % of the households are engaged
in agriculture, 21.7 % work as day laborers and another 22 % are engaged in
petty business.
Occurrence of flood is always a serious threat to the food security of the poor
households in Bangladesh. Flood reduces availability of food-grains by disrupting
the normal market flow and destabilizes the prices of food-grains. It also threatens
the prospect of a good harvest and increases the risk of future food crisis and limits
the access of poor to food due to loss of income and purchasing power. In addition
to this, during flood, the expense for food increased. Eventually this situation leads
the poor to have reduced quantity and frequency of meals with deteriorated quality.
Like other poor communities due to reduced incomes owing to losses of assets,
flood affected rural poor experience increased difficulty in food that create relentless health and nutrition problems (Gaillard et al. 2008). This study findings presented in Fig. 13.4 also denotes similar situation in the case of food habit during
flood. In this area as a preparation for flood a number of households (about 45 %)
store dry food such as chira, muri, gur, rice, pals, oil, salt etc. However, in most
cases the amount of stored food is not adequate enough to meet the whole time
period of flood. On the other hand, since majority are poor, 55 % of the households
cannot afford to store any food before flood.
From the field investigation it is found that households that cannot store food
before flood or those store small amount of food for flood usually experienced
increased difficulties in accessing food. Therefore, they had to change eating habit
according to their affordability during flood. The sequential measures they adopt to
cope with the situation are diet change, change in frequency of meal, reduce food
consumption, try to collect food from surrounding and finally if they fail in all other
steps they start to starve.
According to the respondents during normal time 91.7 % households took meals
three times a day. However, their flood experiences revealed that during flood time
only 15 % households could keep the number of meals same as normal time. More
than half of the households in the study area, had to take meals twice or once daily.
About one third of the household face very irregularities in having meal; they even
had to starve often. Households had to change frequency according to their vulnerable condition (Fig. 13.4).
Similar to the flood in other poor communities of Bangladesh, the respondents in
the study areas mentioned that not only the number of meal but also the food quantity and quality had to be changed due to flood. Consumption of variety of food
items reduced and many households passed days by eating rice with water and salt
in irregular manner. People had to change food habit and largely depend on dry food
namely chira(flat rice), muri(puffed rice), gur etc. Meat, milk, eggs and fruits were
consumed rarely and the amount of consuming fish and vegetable comparatively
increased. About 70 % households mentioned that the quantity of food consumption
highly reduced and 88.3 % of the households claimed that their food consumption
deteriorated.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
246
G.A. Parvin et al.
Before Flood
During Flood
3 times a day
15%
38.3%
3 times a day
2 times a day
15%
23.3%
1 times a day
2 times a day
8.3%
Irregular
Change in Frequency of Meals a Day
8.3 %
Adequate (85%)
Slightly Reduced
(8.3 %)
21.7 %
Reduced
55 %
Reduced
15 %
Highly Reduced
(70%)
Change in Quantity of Food Consumption
Normal Diet
(100%)
Rice
Vegetables
11.7 %
No Change
88.3 %
Deteriorated Diet
Rice/ Panta
Vegetables (Shak, Kochuetc)
Change in Quality of Food Consumption
Note: Terms regarding quality and quantity of food used are illustrated belowHighly Reduced
More than 50% less consumption of normal food quantity
Reduced
Upto 50% less consumption of normal food quantity
Slightly Reduced
Upto 25% less consumption of normal food quantity
Deteriorated
Worsen than normal food quality
Fig. 13.4 Food consumption pattern before and during flood (Source: Field survey)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security and Human Health: Cross-Cutting Issues…
247
Similar to the observation of Parvin and Ahsan, 2013, this study also noticed that
women were the most sufferers during flood in terms of all aspects specially taking
food during flood. They gave up food consumption for managing meals for other
members of the household. Women take fewer calories as reduced number of meal.
The frequency and quantity of meals for women reduced highly and simultaneously
the quality was highly deteriorated in general.
Changing of eating habits largely depended on income of household during
flood. Household having no income could afford meals one times a day or took meal
in irregular manner. Among them major portion of households (65 %) took meal in
irregular manner. Major portion of households having income above Tk. 1,000
(US$12.87) per month could afford meals two or three times a day that means the
quantity of food consumption of the households with comparatively higher income
during flood also slightly reduced.
At the time of flood, if there was no alternative means of managing food people
started to consume their productive assets, mainly poultry as their food. Another
reason behind this death of poultry was the most common matter during flood.
During flood along with modification of food habit, managing daily necessities
at less expense becomes also essential. Households limit purchasing of relatively
expensive goods during flood. Due to scarcity of daily necessities and lack of affordability people also had to bring change in their daily habits. Especially, consumption of toiletries and kerosene reduced to a great extent.
13.4
13.4.1
Climate Change and Human Health
Global Perspective
It has been widely acknowledged that climate change due to increasing energy use
by human activity and population growth has adverse impact on human health.
World Health Organization (WHO) warns that it will affect some of the most fundamental pre-requisites for good health: clean air and water, sufficient food, adequate
shelter and freedom from disease (WHO 2008).
In essence, there are several major threats to human health. First, extreme air
temperature and air pollution are hazardous to health. They are attributable to the
increased mortality and morbidity from cardiovascular, respiratory disease, and
pollen and other aeroallergens that trigger asthma. Second, flood, droughts and
contaminated water raise disease risk (McMichael et al. 2006). Lack of fresh water
compromised hygiene, thus increasing rates of diarrhoeal disease which is the third
major killer of the children under 5 years old, explaining 14 % of total deaths of
children under 5 years old (UN 2010). While extreme water scarcity results in
drought and famine, excessive water in the form of flood tends to contaminate
freshwater supplies and also creates opportunities for breeding of disease carrying
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
248
G.A. Parvin et al.
insects such as mosquitoes. Consequently, it leads to higher occurrence of malaria
which killed approximately 627,000 people in 2007 (WHO 2013). Third, climatic
effects on agriculture threaten increasing malnutrition. Malnutrition is a cause for
3.5 million deaths each year which is 35 % of the disease burden in children younger
than 5 years (Black et al. 2008), directly through nutritional deficiencies and indirectly by intensifying vulnerability to diseases such as malaria and diarroeal and
respiratory diseases. Fourth, expected increases in frequency and severity of flood
and storms will result in the destruction of homes, medical facilities and other
essential services, impacting particularly on people in slums and other marginal living conditions (WHO 2008). Fifth, Climate change brings new challenges to the
control of infectious diseases. Infections caused by pathogens that are transmitted
by insect vectors are strongly affected by climatic conditions such as temperature,
rainfall and humidity. These diseases include some of the most important current
killers: malaria, dengue and other infections carried by insect vectors, and diarrhea,
transmitted mainly through contaminated water (Black et al. 2008). However,
mechanism for occurrence of infectious diseases is complex, influenced by many
other social, economic, behavioural, and environmental factors. Caution to construct
a causal relationship between a single factor, climate change, and increased incidence
of infectious diseases is indicated (McMichael et al. 2006).
13.4.2
Bangladesh Perspective
Bangladesh is a country where natural hazards are part of their lives for the majority
of the population. Seventy percent of them live in flood-prone regions and 26 % are
affected by cyclones (DMB 2010). However, mortality and morbidity from these
natural disasters have fallen substantially in the past 50 years. Reported deaths were
declined from 500, 000 in 1970 to 3,300–4,234 in 2007 (Haque et al. 2012; Cash
et al. 2013). Such reductions are mainly explained by improved disaster management including cyclone shelters, early warning system, evacuation plans, coastal
embankments, reforestation schemes, and awareness of the community (Haque
et al. 2012). General activities for poverty reduction integrated into the disaster
management have been also identified as a significant contributor (Cash et al. 2013).
More importantly, achievement of general health over the decades through extensively provided public health interventions in a pluralistic health system with many
stake holders including government, NOGs, private sectors, and informal health
providers has played an important role in mitigation of the hazards (Cash et al.
2013; Ahmed et al. 2013). Some of the successful public health measures are family
planning, expanded program on immunization for children, oral rehydration therapy
for diarroeal diseases, maternal and child health program, early detection and
treatment for tuberculosis, vitamin A supplementation scheme for prevention of
malnutrition of children and pregnant women (Chowdhury et al. 2013). All of these
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security and Human Health: Cross-Cutting Issues…
249
Fig. 13.5 Life expectancy and various mortality rates in Bangladesh (1970–2010) (Source:
Chowdhury et al. 2013)
are responsible for substantial health advances, indicated by the steady decline in
child and maternal mortality during the past four decades (Fig. 13.5).
Overall health gain of Bangladesh might be partially attributed to womenfocused, equity-oriented, nationally targeted public health program (Chowdhury
et al. 2013; Adams et al. 2013). Further analysis, however, on who are the most
vulnerable groups at the time of natural disasters shows that it is women and children, particularly of the poor. During the cyclone in 1991, for example, the death
rate was 71 per 1,000 among women aged 20–44, as compared to 15 per 1,000 for
men in the same age group. Some of the reasons for this are likely to be based on the
different physiological capacities of women and men to run, swim, or hold on to
steady objects. Women may be more likely to be swept away by water of high
winds. In addition, Bangladeshi women face socially constructed, gender-specific
vulnerability including purdah restricting independent mobility and access to
information (Nahar et al. 2014). It is also the women, during the post-cyclone or
longer-term flood period, who suffer more as they may to take less food for managing meals for other members of the household (Shimi et al. 2010). Fetching safer
drinking water for longer distance during the post-cyclone or flood period as well
may have adverse health effects on women (Abedin et al. 2014).
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
G.A. Parvin et al.
250
For future issues, health programs such as diaarhoea, acute respiratory infection,
water and sanitation should be accelerated as an integrated part of disaster management.
Furthermore, there are a couple of areas, which require urgent attentions: threat of
rapid urbanization, long-term health effects such as mental health and intimate
partner’s or sexual violence, and saline contamination of drinking water. The urban
poor population has increased rapidly, 5–28 % in the past 40 years, with roughly
45 million people in urban areas (Afsana and Wahid 2013). Many of them are living
in already deteriorated environment with contaminated food and water supply, air
pollution, inadequate waste removal, and poor housing conditions. Slum dwellers
without basic amenities suffer from vicious circle of infections, malnutrition, and ill
health. Continuous inflow of migrants from rural areas including those from the
cyclone and flood affected regions seeking for employment would aggravate their
living conditions. They are also hard to reach population. Roughly 30 % of the slum
dwellers are highly mobile due to circular migration within urban slums, eviction,
and long or irregular work hours. It leads to incomplete coverage and follow-up for
essential health services (Afsana and Wahid 2013). In such urban circumstances,
natural disasters including flood put the urban poor at further risk of diseases and
malnutrition. Long-term health problems such as mental health and intimate partner’s
violence/sexual violence particularly when people stay in a crowded situation in
shelter are other public health challenges (Cash et al. 2013; Nahar et al. 2014).
Additionally, impact on climate change on water salinity and its effects on health
has been indicated (Abedin et al. 2014; Vineis et al. 2011; Khan et al. 2008).
Increased salinity of drinking water most likely adds risk to health such as hypertension.
It is particularly a serious health problem for pregnant women since hypertensive
disorder during pregnancy is reported as one of the five major causes for maternal
mortality (Say et al. 2014). It would also be related to the life-style related diseases
among rapidly growing middle-class population due to economic growth.
13.5
Conclusion
In Bangladesh food production, storage, distribution and consumption at every
stage that are related to food security of the people are largely dependent on the
topological, climatological and to some extent socio-economic and infrastructural
conditions. Bangladesh, which is one of the most vulnerable countries due to climate
change, suffers from floods almost every year. In this flood prone country 70 % of
its population depends on agriculture and lives at the risk of flood. For being a tropical
low-lying agricultural country food security of the large segment of the population
is determined by the nature and extent of flood in every year. In addition to this flood
vulnerability due to rapid growth of population and low level of GDP food security
has always been a nation priority since independence.
As discussed in previous section climate change, flood, food security and health
are closely associated and interlinked. Climate change, flood and food insecurity
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security and Human Health: Cross-Cutting Issues…
Four Key Concerning
Issues of Development
Impact
Mitigation/adaptation
•
Natural disaster, Water,
Agriculture
health
Climate
Change
Loss of lives and livelihood,
Crop damage
Water and food crisis
Health problem
Flood.
•
•
•
Food
insecurity
Health
Hazard
Malnutrition
Low productivity
Ill-health
Low productivity
Lack of income
Poverty and vulnerability
Low level of development
•
•
•
•
Climate change
mitigation and
adaptation,
Flood Management,
risk reduction,
Preparedness and
efficient early warning
Alternative livelihood
generation,
Awareness and
preventive measures
Efficient service
delivery
Public-Private
partnership
Community based
adaptation and
Community
empowerment
251
Outcome
Healthy
Community
for
Development
Fig. 13.6 Climate change, flood, food security and health- key concerning issues of
development
all these have severe adverse impact on human health. Researchers have already
identified different health impact of climate change. Climate change will affect all
the pre-requisite for good health. Among this air, food and water are the most fundamental pre-requisite. Especially in Bangladesh climate change induced natural
disasters like, cyclone and flood would have direct impact on food security and
human health.
It can be noticed that Government, national and international Non-Government
Organizations (NGOs), donors and all public and private sectors that are engaged
for the development of Bangladesh are directly or indirectly dealing with climate
change, flood, food security and health. Due to the relentless efforts of different
organizations, along with community Bangladesh has made remarkable progress in
flood management, food security and also to improve public health (PRSP 2013).
Climate change is also attaining significant attention and action by the both government and NGOs. In spite of all achievements and successes, there remain challenges
and limitations in the aspects of climate change, flood, food security and health-the
four key concerning issues of Bangladesh. Above section have highlighted a brief of
all successes and limitations in these four key issues. Though these key concerning
issues are closely associated (Fig. 13.6) and interlinked all these issues are addressed
in a segregated way. Therefore, association and interlink of these issues should be
examined and in order to build a healthy and productive nation all these issues
should be dealt together.
Acknowledgement The authors wish to thank Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
and Japan Science and Technology Agency (JST) for their support of SATREPS Project
“Research project on disaster prevention/mitigation measures against floods and storm surges
in Bangladesh”.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
252
G.A. Parvin et al.
References
Abedin MA, Habiba U, Shaw R (2014) Community perception and adaptation to safe drinking
water scarcity: salinity, arsenic, and drought risks in coastal Bangladesh. Int J Disaster Risk Sci
5:110–124
Adams AM, Rabbani A, Ahmed S, Mahamood SS, Ahme A-S, Rashid S, Evans TG (2013)
Explaining equity gains in child survival in Bangladesh: scale, speed, and selectivity in health
and development. Lancet 382:2027–2037
Afsana K, Wahid SS (2013) Health care for poor people in the urban slums of Bangladesh. Lancet
382:2049–2050
Ahmed SM, Evans TG, Standing H, Mahmud S (2013) Harnessing pluralism for better health in
Bangladesh. Lancet 382:1746–1755
Amendola, Aniello, Joanne Linnerooth-Bayer, Norio Okada, Peijun Shi (2008). “Towards
integrated disaster risk management: case studies and trends from Asia”. Natural Hazards.
Volume 44, Issue 2, pp 163–168.
Black RE, Bhutta ZA, Caulfield LE, De Onis M, Ezzati M, Mathers C, Rivera J (2008) Maternal
and child undernutrition: global and regional exposures and health consequences. Lancet
371:243–260
Brouwer R, Akter S, Brander L, Haque E (2007) Socioeconomic vulnerability and adaptation to
environmental risk: a case study of climate change and flooding in Bangladesh. Risk Anal
27(2):313–326. doi:10.1111/j.4539-6924.2007.00884.x
Cai X, Mckinney DC, Lasdon LS (2003) Integrated hydrologic-agronomic-economic model for
river basin management. J Water Resour Plan Manag 129(1): 4–17
Cash RA, Halder SR, Husain M, Islam MS, Mallick FH, May MA, Rahman M, Rahman MA
(2013) Reducing the health effect of natural hazards in Bangladesh. Lancet 382:1743–1745
Chowdhury AM, Bhuiya A, Chowdhury ME, Rasheed S, Hussain Z, Chen L (2013) The Bangladesh
paradox: exceptional health achievement despite economic poverty. Lancet 382:1734–1745
DER Sub-Group (2004) Monsoon floods 2004, post-flood needs assessment summary report,
30 Sept 2004, Bangladesh Disaster and Emergency Response Sub-Group
Disaster Management Bureau (DMB) (2010) Bangladesh, National plan for disaster management.
http://www.preventionweb.Net/English/professional/pocilies/v.php?id=16676. Accessed 21
Aug 2014
Douglas I (2009) Climate change, flooding and food security in south Asia. Food Secur
1(2):127–136
Dutta D, Hearth S (2004) Trend of floods in Asia and flood risk management with integrated river
basin approach. The 2nd international conference of Asia-Pacific Hydrology and Water
Resources Association, Singapore
Faisal IM, Parveen S (2004) Food security in the face of climate change, population growth and
resource constraints: implications for Bangladesh. Environ Manage 34(4):487–498
Gaillard J-C, Pangilinan RMM, Cadag RJ, Masson LV (2008) Living with increasing floods:
insight from a rural Philippine community. Disaster Prev Manag 17(3):383–395
Haque U, Hashizume M, Kolivras KN, Overgaard HJ, Das B, Yamamoto T (2012) Reduced death
rates from cyclones in Bangladesh: what more needs to be done? Bull World Health Organ
90:150–156
Imanishi H (2000) Natural disasters in Asia and the IDNDR Stimulus (in Japanese). Jpn Geotech
Soc 48–3(506):7–8
IPCC (2007) Climate change 2007: synthesis report. The fourth assessment report, IPCC
Khan A, Mojumder SK, Kovats S, Vineis P (2008) Saline contamination of drinking water in
Bangladesh. Lancet 371(9610):385
Kobayashi K et al (2010) Development of a framework for the flood economic risk assessment
using vector GIS data. J Disaster Res 5(6):657
Kundzewicz ZW, Radziejewski M et al (2006) Precipitation extremes in the changing climate of
Europe. Climate Res 31:51–58
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
13
Climate Change, Flood, Food Security and Human Health: Cross-Cutting Issues…
253
McMichael AJ, Woodruff RE, Hales S (2006) Climate change and human health: present and
future risks. Lancet 367:859–869
Milly PCD et al (2002) Increasing risk of great floods in changing climate. Nature 415, Macmillan
Magazines Ltd.
Mirza MMQ (2002) Global warming and changes in the probability of occurrence of floods in
Bangladesh and implications. Glob Environ Chang 12(2):127–138
Munich Re Geo Risks Research (2014) http://www.munichre.com/en/reinsurance/business/
non-life/natcatservice/index.html
Nahar N, Blomstedt Y, Wu B, Kandarina I, Trisnantoro L, Kinsman J (2014) Increasing the
provision of mental health care for vulnerable, disaster-affected people in Bangladesh. BMC
Public Health 14:708, http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/14/708
Pahl-Wostl C (2006) The implications of complexity for integrated resources management.
Ecol Soc 11(1):561–569
Paul SK, Routray JK (2010) Flood proneness and coping strategies: the experiences of two villages
in Bangladesh. Disasters 34(2):489–508
Paul, B.K., Rashid, H. (1993) Flood damage to rice crops in Bangladesh. The Geographical
Review 83(2):151–159
PRSP (2013) Bangladesh poverty reduction strategy paper. International Monetary Fund,
Publication Services, Washington, DC
Rahman R, Salehin M (2013) Flood risks and reduction approaches in Bangladesh. In: Shaw M,
Islam (eds) Disaster risk reduction approaches in Bangladesh. Springer, Tokyo, pp 65–90
Raillon. C. (2010) Humanitarian practice challenged by populations ‘resilience’. Available:
http://www.urd.org/IMG/pdf/Rapport_Final_Bangladesh_EN.pdf. Accessed on June 7, 2014
Rayhan MI (2010) Assessing poverty, risk and vulnerability: a study on flooded households in rural
Bangladesh. J Flood Risk Manag 3:18–24, Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Shahabuddin Q (2000) Impact of recent floods on agriculture: some suggested interventions.
Daily Star Features, Dhaka
Salehin M, Haque A, Rahman MR, Khuan MSA, Bala SK (2007) Hydrological aspects of 2004
floods in Bangladesh. J Hydrol Meteorol Nepal 4(1):33–34
Say L, Chou D, Gemmill A, Tunçalp O, Moller AB, Daniels J, Gülmezoglu AM, Temmerman M,
Alkema L (2014) Global causes of maternal death: a WHO systematic analysis. Lancet Glob
Health 2(6):323–33. doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(14)70227-X, Epub 5 May 2014
Shimi AC, Parvin GA, Biswas C, Shaw R (2010) Impact and adaptation of fold: a focus on water
supply, sanitation and health problems of rural community in Bangladesh. Disaster Prev Manag
19(3):298–313
Shukla PR (2003) Climate change and India. University Press India, Hyderabad
Tandon N (2012) Food security, women smallholders and climate change in Caribbean SIDS,
International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth, Cape Town. Available at: www.ipc-undp.org/
pub/IPCPolicyResearchBrief33.pdf. Accessed 21 Mar 2013
Thomalla F, Downing T et al (2006) Reducing hazard vulnerability: towards a common approach
between disaster risk reduction and climate adaptation. Disasters 30(I):41–43
Uchida H, Ando K (2003) Flood in Bangladesh: farmers’ adaptability and national policy -Asian
and African area studies 2003, 3:3–34 (in Japanese). http://hdl.handle.net/2433/80024
United Nations (2010) UN Millennium development report 2010, New York
Van Aalst MK (2006) The impacts of climate change on the risk of natural disasters. Disasters
30(1):5–18
Vineis P, Chan Q, Khan A (2011) Climate change impacts on water salinity and health. J Epidemiol
Glob Health 1(1):5–10
WMO (2009) Integrated flood management concept paper, World Meteorological Organization.
No. 1047: 9
WMO/GWP (2003) Integrated flood management case study -Bangladesh: flood management,
World Meteorological Organization and Global Water Partnership Associated Programme on
Flood Management
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
254
G.A. Parvin et al.
World Health Organization. World Malaria Report 2013. [Accessed 1 August 2014]. Available at:
http://www.who.int/malaria/publications/world_malaria_report_2013/en
World Health Organization (2008) Protecting health from climate change: world health day 2008,
Geneva
Zimmermann M, Glombitza K-F, Rothenberger B (2010) Disaster risk reduction programme for
bangladesh 2010–2012. Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC). http://www.
who.int/topics/millennium_development_goals/diseases/en/ Downloaded on 19 Aug 2014
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
Chapter 14
Future Approaches of Food Security,
Sustainable Development, Environment
and Resource Management and Risk
Reduction
Umma Habiba, Md. Anwarul Abedin, and Rajib Shaw
Abstract Globally, food security problem is identified that there is enough food in
the world, but the distribution is deficient. Food security is not only about having
enough production; it is also about having an equal chance of access to food for all.
The problem is similar in case of Bangladesh. Food security is hindered by various
climatic and anthropogenic causes. Taking account these issues, this chapter
attempts to incorporate climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction in the
field of food security. It further gives its focus on sustainable food security; therefore, it describes the concept, strategies and priority action areas of sustainable food
security. In conclusion, it provides an integrated approach to sustain food security that
not only secure the food for populations but also build resilience towards disaster
and climate change risk.
Keywords Food security • Disaster risk reduction • Climate change adaptation •
Sustainable food security • Integrated approach
14.1
Introduction
Over the course of the twenty-first century, the world will need to produce
significantly more food in order to deliver a basic, but adequate diet to everyone.
Since based on United Nations population data and projections (United Nations,
Development of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division 2009), the global
U. Habiba (*)
Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture, Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail: shimuagri@yahoo.com
Md.A. Abedin
Department of Soil Science, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh
e-mail: masumagriculture@yahoo.com
R. Shaw
Graduate School of Global Environmental Studies, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
© Springer Japan 2015
U. Habiba et al. (eds.), Food Security and Risk Reduction in Bangladesh,
Disaster Risk Reduction, DOI 10.1007/978-4-431-55411-0_14
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
255
U. Habiba et al.
256
population will be reaching 9.1 billion by 2050, an increase of 32 % from 2010.
At present globally 842 million people- 12 % of the global populations were unable
to meet their dietary energy requirements in 2011–2013, down from 868 million
reported for the 2010–2012 period in last year’s report. Thus around one in eight
people in the world are likely to have suffered from chronic hunger, not having
enough food for an active and healthy life. The vast majority of hungry people- 827
million of them-live in developing regions where the prevalence of undernourishment is now estimated at 14.3 %. However, most of the world’s undernourished
people are still to be found in Southern Asia, followed by Sub-Saharan Africa and
Eastern Asia. Among them, seven countries account for two-thirds of the world’s
undernourished population: Bangladesh, China, the Democratic Republic of Congo,
Ethiopia, India, Indonesia and Pakistan (FAO 2010).
According to the Global Food Security Index (2012), Bangladesh is the least
food-secure among the South Asian countries. Globally, Bangladesh ranked 81st in
terms of food security amongst 105 countries. Despite progress in growth of food
production and reduction of poverty level, widespread hunger exists in Bangladesh
because of the increasing population pressure, and the lack of purchasing power
among the ultra poor. About half of the population of Bangladesh still lives below
the food-based poverty. While availability of food has been increased, accessibility
remains a major challenge. Poverty, gender, disability, geographical location and
cultural practices are also important factors in shaping food security.
Among various grounds, natural disasters and climate change are a leading cause
of hunger in Bangladesh that affect all dimensions of food security including economic and physical access to food, availability and stability of supplies, and nutrition. With climate change impacts on agricultural production, areas suffering from
food insecurity are expected to experience disproportionately negative effects.
Already fragile food production systems and the natural resources on which they
depend, particularly those prone to degradation, desertification and water stress,
will undermine the capacity of people to take the needed preventative and protective
measures. Rain-fed agriculture and agro-pastoral systems are at particular risk.
Disaster-affected communities that suffer chronic and transient food insecurity may
also become acutely food insecure during disaster events. A lack of food or not
being able to afford or access food is one of the major impacts of disasters. Rates of
acute and chronic malnutrition are also expected to rise due to increased crop
failure, decreased fish stocks, and diarrheal disease caused by poor water quality.
The nutritional status of the poorest people, whose livelihoods depend on climatesensitive resources, will be deeply affected by changes in the climate. In addition,
their poor nutrition will impact on their health and ability to work, and will hinder
their capacity to adapt. These are already showing, with negative effects already on
chronic food insecurity and fragile livelihoods. To strengthen the populations’ resilience and strengthening the capacity of institutions, food security is becoming an
integral feature of climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction response.
In the past, food security during times of crisis was more or less equated with
food aid. More recently, the focus has shifted towards crisis prevention and mitigation,
i.e. take all necessary action to prevent food shortages or to at least limit their extent,
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
14
Future Approaches of Food Security, Sustainable Development…
257
with the aim of building local resilience against food crises and thereby reducing the
dependence on external food support. Thus, in the context of humanitarian aid, food
security is now moving closer to disaster risk reduction (DRR) in terms of its
approaches and issues and may even be regarded as an integral component of
DRR. In addition, both disasters – be they climate-induced or otherwise created –
and climate change impacts negatively affect development outcomes (Schipper and
Pelling 2006; IPCC 2012). Therefore synergies between disaster risk reduction and
climate change adaptation would be necessary not only to avoid duplicities and
derive optimal benefits from scarce resources but also to add value to the projects
through lessons learnt from the respective perspectives (Thomalla et al. 2006).
According to the above, this chapter attempts to provide reinforce sustainable
system for achieving food security, coupled with sound economic management for
sustaining growth and poverty reduction in the region. In conclusion, it highlights
an approach to sustain food security considering the challenges, climate change
adaptation, and disaster risk reduction nexus.
14.2
Nexus Among Disaster Risk Reduction,
Climate Change and Food Security
Disaster risk reduction (DRR), food security (FS) and climate change (CC) are relatively young concepts that continue to evolve. Global platforms, for example the
climate dialogues under the United Nations Convention on Climate Change
(UNFCCC), the FS dialogues driven by the Food and Agriculture Organization
(FAO), and the milestone Hyogo Framework for Action (HFA) on DRR, are setting
the course internationally. However, the dialogue is only now starting to move
towards identifying and acting on the multiple inter-linkages among DRR, FS and
CC. This is not easy because there are different sets of actors at global and regional
level, who seldom find each other at shared platforms and remain ignorant of the
nature and importance of this nexus.
The Fig. 14.1 simplifies the complex dynamics that characterize the DRR/FS/CC
nexus. The linkages (intersections in the diagram) sometimes operate in both directions. For example, agriculture (implied within the FS circle) is affected by climate
change, but it also contributes to global emissions of greenhouse gases, which
causes climate change. The diagram that shows the nexus between DRR, FS and CC
is not well understood or discussed and is poorly reflected in policies, planning and
programming, resulting in a lack of shared purpose and fragmented implementation. Climate change is changing the frequency, intensity and duration of disasters
and also the type (e.g. hailstorms where they never occurred before, changing and
unpredictable rainfall patterns). Disasters impact directly (production) and indirectly
(access to food) on food security. More gradual climate changes (e.g. warming) also
impact directly on food production by reducing and destabilizing yields of sensitive
crops. In the middle, where all three overlap, the overall impact on agriculture-based
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
U. Habiba et al.
258
Fig. 14.1 Disaster risk reduction, climate change and food security nexus
livelihoods becomes clear and shows the need for an integrated and long term
building of resilience, which could save millions of livelihoods.
Importantly, all three issues have component drivers that do not intersect with
one another: food insecurity (especially issues of access to food) is driven by numerous socio-economic factors and shocks to the food system; CC has causes and
impacts unrelated to DRR and FS; and DRR also includes non-climatic disasters,
such as earthquakes and tsunamis.
14.3
Concept of Sustainable Food Security
Food security is a complex topic in itself and sustainable food security (SFS) is even
more complex when economic, environment and social aspects of food security
are included. Sustainable food security can be explained as feeding all people at
present without compromising the need of the future generation and that is why
leaving a health ecological footprint is essential (International Development
Research Centre 1999). When food security remains a challenge, especially for the
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
14
Future Approaches of Food Security, Sustainable Development…
259
Fig. 14.2 Pillars of sustainable food security
developing countries, sustainable food security involves other issues like conserving
land, water management and also economic growths through food production
(Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations n.d.).
The challenges of Sustainable Food Security are increased population, decreased
nutritional security, economic inaccessibility to food, agricultural land reduced,
natural resource constrain such as water scarcity, soil pollution, climate change etc.
and human/animal/plants health (Jain et al. 2010).
FAOs sustainable development department has divided into four different pillars
to achieve goals Sustainable Food Security which are “People, institutions, knowledge
and environment”. FAO has described the pillars of Sustainable Food Security that are
the following way (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations n.d.)
(Fig. 14.2).
People
Majority of the developing countries population still lives in the rural areas and are
dependent on agriculture which does not generate a steady income. Including these
group of people and enhance their economic situation will play an important role in
end poverty. Women are the most vulnerable group that suffers from food insecurity,
a special attention needs toward this group to improve their rights such as education,
health, ownership of land etc.
Institution
By institution FAO means that a bottom up structure is needed to minimize the gap
between rural development and national development. Policy, laws and regulation
should be reflect the rural perspective and not the centralized view of the situation.
Governmental, public sector and civil society should be integrated for rural
development.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
260
U. Habiba et al.
Knowledge
Sharing of knowledge and technology is important to achieve food security
globally. Technology for improved food production and high yield crops is the key
for sustainable food security but currently many small scale farmers and poor cannot access these technologies because it is very expensive for them. The knowledge
about how to treat the land and environment and omit environmental pollution due to
agriculture, this needs to be sheared and learned. Another importance matter is the
knowledge about biodiversity and ecosystem and its function to be able to preserve it.
Through new types of global commitment to ensuring transfer of knowledge and
technology is a must and only by that global food security can be achieved.
Environment
Due to agriculture and food production soil pollution, water pollution, loss of biodiversity is a common phenomenon today. Feeding the world population in future will
increase these entire environmental problems and to mitigate it. there are already
many tools can be used to protect the environment, such as ecologically sound technologies are already being used in many areas and needs to be used and develop these
types of technologies. Resource constrain is going to be a challenge but sustainable
food security also needs to provide economic development that is why dialog with
the farmers are viable on resource management such as land use, water management,
soil management etc. and also provide other services to the farmers like education,
access to cash, increase budget in agriculture sector, monitoring environmental
issues are also necessary.
14.4
Challenges for Achieving Food Security in Context
of Bangladesh
It has been seen from the earlier chapters that climatic events as well as anthropogenic causes food insecurity in Bangladesh. Continuing population growth,
shrinking of arable land every year due to demand from housing and industries,
salinity intrusion due to sea level rise, declining soil fertility due to overexploitation
of soil and imbalanced use of fertilizers are main threats to achieving food security
in Bangladesh. While rice productions are largely sufficient in Bangladesh, selfsufficiency in other food items is still to be achieved. The salient features of major
challenges for achieving food security is summarized in the below Table 14.1.
14.5
Strategies for Sustainable Food Security
Food security requires more than good conservation programs, which can be – and
usually are – overridden and undermined by inappropriate agricultural, economic, and
trade policies. Nor is it just a matter of adding an environmental component to programs.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
14
Future Approaches of Food Security, Sustainable Development…
261
Table 14.1 Challenges and salient features of food insecurity in Bangladesh
Challenges
Population growth
Urbanization
Shrinking of
arable land
Soil fertility decline
Climate change
Poverty
Hike of food price
Salient features
The main challenge for achieving and sustaining food security comes
from continuing growth of population
The population is still increasing by 1.8 million every year which is
alarming to meet the food security
At present about 30 % of the population lives in urban settlement and
the trend show that it has increased steadily by 3.5 % annually
The main reason for urbanization today in Bangladesh because of
climate related hazards like flood, cyclones, river bank erosion etc.
Increasing demands for energy, water, land and natural resources for
rapid urban population have already posed a serious threat to the food
security in the urban areas in Bangladesh
The arable land has been shrinking by 1 % every year due to demand
from housing and industries, and infrastructure, as well as loss of land
from river erosion
Global warming and climate change, another one-sixth of the land
may be submerged with brackish water due to rising sea levels
Overexploitation of soil nutrients due to intensive cropping and
imbalanced use of fertilizers
The ground water aquifer has been going down from over-mining for
irrigating boro rice
An increasing trend of temperature annually 0.05 °C and 0.03 °C
respectively
Erotic rainfall behavior and increasing and decreasing rainfall pattern,
intensity and distribution of rainfall is also responsible for unrest
agricultural production
Bangladesh is one of the poorest countries in the world considering
GDP growth compared to the global scale
About 40 % of people in rural Bangladesh earned less than $1.25 per
day and 60 % of that income is spent on food
Financial inability of the poor to purchase sufficient food
The structure of domestic food market is very complex especially rice
The rural pro-poor suffer mostly from increased food price because
they are net buyers of rice
Food strategies must take into account all the policies that bear upon the threefold
challenge of shifting production to where it is most needed, of securing the livelihoods
of the rural poor, and of conserving resources.
14.5.1
Government Intervention
Government intervention in agriculture is the rule in both industrial and developing
countries. Public investment in agricultural research and extension services, assisted
farm credit and marketing services, and a range of other support systems have all
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
262
U. Habiba et al.
played parts in the successes of the last half-century. In fact, the real problem in
many developing countries is the weakness of these systems. However, intervention
has taken other forms as well. Many governments regulate virtually the entire food
cycle – inputs and outputs, domestic sales, exports, public procurement, storage and
distribution, price controls and subsidies – as well as imposing various land use
regulations: acreage, crop variety, and so on.
14.5.2
A Global Perspective
Shifting food production towards food-deficit countries will require a major shift in
trading patterns. Countries must recognize that all parties lose through protectionist
barriers, which reduce trade in food products in which some nations may have genuine
advantage. They must begin by redesigning their trade, tax, and incentive systems
using criteria that include ecological and economic sustainability and international
comparative advantage.
The incentive-driven surpluses in developed market economies increase pressures
to export these surpluses at subsidized prices or as non-emergency food aid. Donor
and receiving countries should be responsible for the impacts of aid and use it for
long-term objectives. It can be beneficially used in projects to restore degraded
lands, build up rural infrastructure, and raise the nutrition level of vulnerable groups.
14.5.3
The Resource Base
Agricultural production can only be sustained on a long-term basis if the land,
water, and forests on which it is based are not degraded. As suggested, a reorientation
of public intervention will provide a framework for this. But more specific policies
that protect the resource base are needed to maintain and even enhance agricultural
productivity and the livelihoods of all rural dwellers.
Land Use
Enhancing the resource base will be delineated broad land categories:
• enhancement areas, which are capable of sustaining intensive cropping and
higher population and consumption levels;
• prevention areas, which by common consent should not be developed for intensive agriculture or. where developed, should be converted to other uses; and
• restoration areas, where land stripped of vegetative cover has either totally lost
its productivity or had it drastically reduced
Identifying land according to ‘best use’ criteria requires information that is not
always available. Most industrial nations possess inventories and descriptions of
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
14
Future Approaches of Food Security, Sustainable Development…
263
their lands, forests, and waters that are detailed enough to provide a basis for
delineating land categories. Few developing countries have such inventories, but
they can and should develop them quickly using satellite monitoring and other
rapidly changing techniques.
Water Management
Improvements in water management are essential to raise agricultural productivity
and to reduce land degradation and water pollution. Critical issues concern the
design of irrigation projects and the efficiency of water use. Where water is scarce,
an irrigation project should maximize productivity per unit of water; where water is
plentiful, it must maximize productivity per unit of land. But local conditions will
dictate how much water can be used without damaging the soil. Salinization, alkalization, and water logging can be avoided by a more careful approach to drainage,
maintenance, cropping patterns, the regulation of water quantities, and more rational
water charges. In some areas excessive use of ground-water is rapidly lowering the
water table – usually a case where private benefits are being realized at society’s
expense. Where ground-water use exceeds the recharge capacity of local aquifers,
regulatory or fiscal controls become essential. The combined use of ground and
surface water can improve the timing of water availability and stretch limited
supplies.
Alternative to Chemicals
Chemical fertilizers and pesticides are heavily subsidized in many countries.
These subsidies promote chemical use precisely in the more commercially oriented
agricultural areas where their environmental damage may already outweigh any
increases in productivity they bring. Hence different regions will require different
policies to regulate and promote chemical use. Legislative and institutional frameworks for controlling agrochemicals must be greatly strengthened everywhere.
Industrialized countries must tighten controls on pesticide exports. Developing
countries must possess the basic legislative and institutional instruments to manage
the use of agricultural chemicals within their countries. They will need technical
and financial assistance to do so.
Forestry and Agriculture
Undisturbed forests protect watersheds, reduce erosion, offer habitats for wild
species, and play key roles in climatic systems. They are also an economic resource
providing timber, fuel wood, and other products. The crucial task is to balance the
need to exploit forests against the need to preserve them.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
264
U. Habiba et al.
Sound forest policies can be based only on an analysis of the capacity of the
forests and the land under them to perform various functions. Such an analysis
might lead to some forests being cleared for intensive cultivation, others for
livestock; some forestland might be managed for increased timber production or
agroforestry use and some left intact for watershed protection, recreation, or species
conservation. The extension of agriculture into forest areas must be based on scientific classification of land capacities.
Aquaculture
Fisheries and aquaculture are critical to food security in that they provide both
protein and employment. Aquaculture or ‘fish-farming’, which differs from conventional fishing in that fish are deliberately reared in controlled water bodies, can help
meet future needs. Yields from aquaculture have doubled during the last decade and
now represent about 10 % of world production of fishery products. A five- to tenfold
increase is projected by the year 2000, given the necessary scientific, financial,
and organizational support. Aquaculture can be undertaken in paddy fields, abandoned
raining excavations, small ponds, and many other areas with some water, as well as on
various commercial scales: individual, family, cooperative, or corporate. The expansion
of aquaculture should be given high priority in developing and developed countries.
14.5.4
Productivity and Yields
The conservation and enhancement of agriculture’s resource base will increase
production and productivity. But specific measures are required to make inputs
more effective. This is best done by strengthening the technological and human
resource base for agriculture in developing countries.
The Technical Base
Blends of traditional and modern technologies offer possibilities for improving
nutrition and increasing rural employment on a sustainable basis. Biotechnology
including tissue culture techniques, technologies for preparing value-added
products from biomass, micro-electronics, computer sciences, satellite imagery,
and communication technology are all aspects of frontier technologies that can
improve agricultural productivity and resource management.
To serve agriculture in these areas, research has to be less centralized and more
sensitive to farmers’ conditions and priorities. Scientists will need to start talking to
poor farmers and basing research priorities on growers’ priorities. Researchers
must learn from and develop the innovations of farmers and not just the reverse.
More adaptive research should be done right on the farm, using research stations for
referral and with farmers eventually evaluating the results.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
14
Future Approaches of Food Security, Sustainable Development…
265
Human Resources
The technological transformation of traditional agriculture will be difficult without
a matching effort to develop human resources. This means educational reforms to
produce researchers more attuned to the needs of rural peoples and agriculture.
Illiteracy is still widespread among the rural poor. But efforts to promote literacy
should focus attention on functional literacy covering the efficient use of land,
water, and forests. Despite women’s critical role in agriculture, their access to education and their representation in research, extension, and other support services is
woefully inadequate. Women should be given the same educational opportunities as
men. There should be more female extension workers, and women should participate in field visits. Women should be given more power to take decisions regarding
agricultural and forestry programs.
Productivity of Inputs
In traditional agriculture, local organic material provided farmers with sources of
energy, nutrients, and ways of controlling pests. Today, these needs are increasingly
met by electricity, petroleum products, chemical fertilizers, and pesticides. The cost
of these inputs forms a growing proportion of agricultural costs, and wasteful use
does economic and ecological harm.
One of the most important energy-related needs is mechanical power for irrigation. The efficiency of pumps could be greatly improved by providing appropriate
incentives for equipment producers and farmers, and through effective extension
work. Energy for irrigation pumps can also be provided by wind generators or by
conventional internal combustion engines running on biogas produced from local
biomass wastes. Solar dryers and solar coolers can save agricultural products.
These non-conventional sources should be promoted, particularly in areas poor in
energy resources.
Nutrients are lost when fertilizers are improperly applied. Often they leach away
with the flow of water in a field and degrade local water supplies. Similar problems
of waste and destructive side effects occur in the use of pesticides. Hence extension
systems and chemical manufacturers will need to give priority to programs to
promote careful and economical use of these expensive, toxic materials.
14.5.5
Equity
The challenge of sustainable agriculture is to raise not just average productivity and
incomes, but also the productivity and incomes of those poor in resources. Food
security is not just a question of raising food production, but of ensuring that the
rural and urban poor do not go hungry during the short term or midst a local food
scarcity. All this requires the systematic promotion of equity in food production
and distribution.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
266
U. Habiba et al.
Land Reforms
In many countries where land is very unequally distributed land reform is a basic
requirement. Without it, institutional and policy changes meant to protect the
resource base can actually promote inequalities by shutting the poor off from
resources and by favouring those with large farms, who are better able to obtain the
limited credit and services available. By leaving hundreds of millions without
options, such changes can have the opposite of their intended effect, ensuring the
continued violation of ecological imperatives.
Given institutional and ecological variations, a universal approach to land reform
is impossible. Each country should work out its own program of land reform to
assist the land-poor and to provide a base for coordinated resource conservation.
The redistribution of land is particularly important where large estates and vast
numbers of the land-poor coexist. Crucial components include the reform of
tenancy arrangements, security of tenure, and the clear recording of land rights.
In agrarian reforms the productivity of the land and. in forest areas, the protection
of forests should be a major concern.
Subsistence Farmers and Pastoralists
Subsistence farmers, pastoralists, and nomads threaten the environmental resource
base when processes beyond their control squeeze their numbers onto land or into
areas that cannot support them. The traditional rights of subsistence farmers, particularly shifting cultivators, pastoralists and nomads, must therefore be protected
from encroachments. Land tenure rights and communal rights in particular must be
respected. When their traditional practices threaten the resource base, their rights
may have to be curtailed, but only when alternatives have been provided. Most of
these groups will need to be helped to diversify their livelihoods by entering the
market economy through employment programs and some cash-crop production.
Research should give early attention to the varied requirements of the mixed
farming typical in subsistence agriculture. Extension and input supply systems must
become more mobile to reach shifting cultivators and nomads and priority given to
public investment to improve their cropland, grazing areas, and water sources.
Integrated Rural Development
Considerable effort has gone into creating strategies of integrated rural development, and the requirements and pitfalls are well known. Experience has shown that
land reform is necessary but alone is not enough without support through the distribution of inputs and rural services. Smallholders, including – indeed especially –
women, must be given preference when allocating scarce resources, staff, and
credit. Small farmers must also be more involved in formulating agricultural
policies.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
14
Future Approaches of Food Security, Sustainable Development…
267
Integrated rural development also requires resources to absorb the large increases
in rural working populations expected in most developing countries through nonagricultural work opportunities, which should be promoted in rural areas. Successful
agricultural development and the growth in incomes should open up opportunities
in service activities and small-scale manufacturing if supported by public policy.
Food Availability Fluctuations
Environmental degradation can make food shortages more frequent and more
severe. Hence sustainable agricultural development will reduce the season-toseason variability in food supplies. But such systems cannot eliminate it. There will
be weather-induced fluctuations, and the growing dependence on only a few crop
varieties over large areas may amplify the effects of weather and pest damage. Often
it is the poorest households and the ecologically disadvantaged regions that suffer
most from these shortages.
The food stocks of industrialized countries are essentially surpluses, and provide
a basis for emergency assistance, which must be maintained. But emergency food aid
is a precarious basis for food security: developing countries should build up national
stocks in surplus years to provide reserves as well as encouraging development of
food security at the household level. To do this, they will need an effective system of
public support for measures facilitating the purchase, transportation, and distribution
of food. The provision of strategically located storage facilities is critical both to reduce
post-harvest losses and to provide a base for quick interventions in emergencies.
14.6
Priority Actions for Food Security
Food insecurity and under nutrition, climate change, increasing demand competition for energy and water, degradation of land and biodiversity are the multiple
emergent challenges at the global level are connected in complex ways and demand
an integrated management approach. Based on robust scientific evidence, the
Commission on Sustainable Agriculture and Climate Change has identified critical
leverage points and high priority policy actions that help to achieve food security.
Moreover by these steps, it can deliver long term benefits to communities in all
countries. The recommended actions are in the following:
(i) Integrate food security and sustainable agriculture into global and national
policies
• Establish a work program on mitigation and adaptation in agriculture in
accordance with the principles and provisions of the United Nations
Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), based on Article 2,
as a first step to inclusion of agriculture in the mainstream of international
climate change policy.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
268
U. Habiba et al.
• Make sustainable, climate-friendly agriculture central to Green Growth
and the Rio + 20 Earth Summit.
• Finance ‘early action’ to drive change in agricultural production systems
towards increasing resilience to weather variability and shocks, while contributing significantly to mitigating climate change. This includes supporting national climate risk assessments, developing mitigation and adaptation
strategies, and program implementation.
• Develop common platforms at global, regional and national levels for
coherent dialogue and policy action related to climate change, agriculture,
crisis response and food security, at global, regional and national levels.
These include fostering country-level coalitions for food security and
building resilience, particularly in countries most vulnerable to climate
shocks.
(ii) Significantly raise the level of global investment in sustainable agriculture
and food systems in the next decade
• Implement and strengthen the existing G8 L’Aquila programs and commitments to sustainable agriculture and food security, including long-term
commitments for financial and technical assistance in food production and
to empower smallholder farmers.
• Enable UNFCCC Fast Start funding, major development banks and other
global finance mechanisms to prioritize sustainable agriculture programs
that deliver food security, improved livelihoods, resilience to climate
change and environmental co-benefits. Such programs should emphasize
improving infrastructure and land rehabilitation.
• Adjust national research and development budgets, and build integrated
scientific capacity, to reflect the significance of sustainable agriculture in
economic growth, poverty reduction and long-term environmental sustainability, and focus on key food security issues (for example, developing
nutritious non-grain crops and reducing postharvest losses).
• Increase knowledge of best practices and access to innovation by supporting
revitalized extension services, technology transfer and communities of
practice (for example, North-south, South-South, cross-commodity and
farmer-to-farmer exchanges), with emphasis on low to high-income countries
and on women farmers.
(iii) Sustainably intensify agricultural production while reducing greenhouse
gas emissions and other negative environmental impacts of agriculture
• Develop, facilitate and reward multi-benefit farming systems that enable
more productive and resilient livelihoods and ecosystems, with emphasis
on closing yield gaps and improving nutrition.
• Introduce strategies for minimizing ecosystem degradation and rehabilitating
degraded environments, with emphasis on community-designed programs.
• Empower marginalized food producers (particularly women) to increase
productivity of a range of appropriate crops by strengthening land and
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
14
Future Approaches of Food Security, Sustainable Development…
269
water rights, increasing access to markets, finance and insurance, and
enhancing local capacity (for example through farmer and communitybased organizations).
• Identify and modify subsidies (such as for water and electricity) that
provide incentives for farmers to continue agricultural practices that deplete
water supplies or destroy native ecosystems. Introduce compensation
schemes that target the poor.
• Couple economic incentives for sustainable intensification of agriculture
with strengthening governance of land tenure and land zoning to prevent
further loss of forests, wetlands and grasslands.
(iv) Develop specific programs and policies to assist populations and sectors that
are most vulnerable to climate changes and food insecurity
• Develop funds that respond to climate shocks, such as ‘index-linked funds’
that provide rapid relief when extreme weather events affect communities,
through public private partnerships, based on agreed principles.
• Involvement of private sector with other stakeholders to improve food
security related actions such as training, appropriate technology and
resource management practices in order to cope with climate change and
mitigate their risks in the face of high climatic and price volatility
• Moderate excessive food price fluctuations by sharing country information on
production forecasts and stocks, strengthening market databases, promoting
open and responsive trade systems, establishing early warning systems and
allowing tax-free export and import for humanitarian assistance. This includes
embedding safeguards related to import surges and trade distortions in
trade agreements.
• Create and support safety nets and other programs to help vulnerable populations in all countries become food secure (for example, cash and in-kind
transfers, employment guarantee schemes, programs to build resilience,
health and nutrition, delivery of education and seeds of quick growing
foods in times of famine).
• Establish robust emergency food reserves and financing capacity that can
deliver rapid humanitarian responses to vulnerable populations threatened
by food crises.
• Create and support platforms for harmonizing and coordinating global
donor programs, policies and activities, paying particular attention to
systematically integrating climate change risk management, adaptation and
mitigation co-benefits, and improved local nutritional outcomes.
(v) Reshape food access and consumption patterns to ensure basic nutritional
needs are met and to foster healthy and sustainable eating patterns
worldwide
• Address chronic under nutrition and hunger by harmonizing development
policy and coordinating regional programs to improve livelihoods and
access to services among food-insecure rural and urban communities.
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
270
U. Habiba et al.
• Promote positive changes in the variety and quantity of diets through
innovative education campaigns, which target young consumers especially,
and through economic incentives that align the marketing practices of
retailers and processors with public health and environmental goals.
• Promote and support a coherent set of evidence-based sustainability metrics
and standards to monitor and evaluate food security, nutrition and health,
practices and technologies across supply chains, agricultural productivity and
efficiency, resource use and environmental impacts, and food system costs
and benefits. This should include providing consumers with clear labeling.
(vi) Reduce loss and waste in food systems, targeting infrastructure, farming
practices, processing, distribution and household habits
• In all sustainable agriculture development programs, include research and
investment components focusing on reducing waste, from production to
consumption, by improving harvest and postharvest management and food
storage and transport.
• Develop integrated policies and programs that reduce waste in food supply
chains, such as economic innovation to enable low-income producers to
store food during periods of excess supply and obligations for distributors
to separate and reduce food waste.
• Promote dialogue and convene working partnerships across food supply
chains to ensure that interventions to reduce waste are effective and efficient
(for example, redirecting food waste to other purposes), and do not create
perverse incentives.
(vii) Create comprehensive, shared, integrated information systems that encompass human and ecological dimensions
• Sustain and increase investment in regular monitoring, on the ground and
by public domain remote sensing networks, to track changes in land use,
food production, climate, the environment, human health and well-being
worldwide.
• Support improved transparency and access to information in global food
markets and invest in interlinked information systems with common protocols that build on existing institutions.
• Develop, validate and implement spatially explicit data and decisionsupport systems that integrate biophysical and socioeconomic information
and that enable policy makers to navigate trade-offs among agricultural
intensification, nutritional security and environmental consequences.
14.7
Conclusion
It is reported by Allen and Ingram (2002), Lal et al. (2001a, b), McCarthy et al.
(2001), O’Brien et al. (2004), and Gosain et al. (2006) that the climate change is
surely creating grounds for newer and more severe risks of disasters in the region in
the coming years. This will have a big impact on food production and this might be
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
14
Future Approaches of Food Security, Sustainable Development…
271
one of the biggest challenges for food security in future (Lal et al. 2011). Climate
change not only causes more frequent rain, storm, flood even drought but also
directly affects local food security system (Busscher 2012). This might cause scarcity
of food locally which then will affect sustainable food security negatively.
It has been further noticed by several studies that climate sensitive agrarian economies of the region would be facing serious crisis unless the rising temperature of
the globe and the region are checked and new technologies, practices and life styles
are developed and adapted according to the changing climate scenarios (Richards
2003; Christoplos et al. 2001; Bruce et al. 1996). Many of the risk reduction measures particularly those related to hydro-meteorological disasters, such as drought
proofing, flood protection, saline embankment and bio-shields, alternative livelihood
development etc. have similarities with climate change adaptation (CCA) programs
(Lim and Spanger-Siegfried 2005). For the first time ever disaster risk reduction was
included as a tool for climate change adaptation, which will guide the negotiations
for a post Kyoto climate change agreement from 2012, This has opened up a range
of possibilities for integration of climate change adaptation in disaster risk reduction
strategies (UNISDR Report 2008). Likewise, climate change mitigation and adaptation have emerged as important tools for disaster risk reduction for all the countries
in the region. Since, it needs to incorporate measures to reduce disaster and climate
change risk in the main sectors of developmental and humanitarian intervention:
food security; livelihoods; natural resource management; water, sanitation and
hygiene (WASH); education; health; and protection (Turnbull et al. 2013).
In this regards, taking an approach to food security that incorporates disaster risk
reduction and climate change adaptation will sustain food security, increase the
resilience of at-risk populations to disaster and climate change risk, at the same time
protecting and enhancing local ecosystems and enhancing human resources needed
to reduce overall vulnerability. Figure 14.3 shows the overall the way how to sustain
food security.
Fig. 14.3 Integrated approach to sustain food security
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
272
U. Habiba et al.
References
Allen MR, Ingram WJ (2002) Constraints on future changes in climate and the hydrologic cycle.
Nature 419:224–232
Bruce JP, Lee H, Haites EF (1996) Climate change 1995: economic and social dimensions of
climate change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
Busscher W (2012) Spending our water and soils for food. J Soil Water Conserv 67(3):228–234
Christoplos I, Mitchel J, Liljelund A (2001) Re-framing risk: the changing context of disaster
mitigation and preparedness. Disasters 25(3):185–198
FAO (2010) The State of Food security in the world. Addressing food insecurity in protracted
crises. Publishing Policy and Support Branch, Rome
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (n.d.) Sustainable food security, the role
of FAO’s Sustainable Development Department. Available at: http://www.fao.org/sd/FSdirect/
FSintro.htm. Accessed 18 Sept 2014
Gosain AK, Rao S, Basuray D (2006) Climate change impact assessment on hydrology of Indian
river basins. Curr Sci 90(3):346–353
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) (2012) Managing the risks of extreme events
and disasters to advance climate change adaptation. A special report of Working Groups I and II
of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Field CB, Barros V, Stocker TF, Qin D,
Dokken DJ, Ebi KL, Mastrandrea MD, Mach KJ, Plattner GK (eds)]
International Development Research Centre (1999) For Hunger-proof-cities: sustainable urban
food systems. International Development Research Centre, Ottawa
Jain P, Hansra B, Chakraporty K, Kurup JM (2010) Sustainable food security. Krishan Mittal by
Mittal Publications, New Delhi
Lal M, Harasawa H, Murdiyarso D (2001a) Asia. In: McCarthy JJ, Canziani OF, Leary NA,
Dokken DJ, White KS (eds) Climate change 2001: impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability:
contribution of working group II to the third assessment report of the intergovernmental panel
on climate change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, pp 877–912
Lal M, Nozawa T, Emori S, Harasawa H, Takahashi K, Kimoto M, Abe-Ouchi A, Nkajima T,
Takemura T, Numaguti A (2001b) Future climate change: implications for Indian summer
monsoon and its variability. Curr Sci 81:1196–1207
Lal R, Sivakumar MVK, Faiz SMA, Rahman AHMM, Islam KR (2011) Climate change
and food security in South Asia. Springer, Dordrecht/Heidelberg/New York/London.
doi:10.1007/978-90-481-9516-9
Lim B, Spanger-Siegfried E (2005) Adaptation policy frameworks for climate change: developing
strategies, policies and measures. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, p 258
McCarthy JJ, Canziani OF, Leary NA, Dokken DJ, White KS (2001) Climate change 2001:
impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability: contribution of working group II to the third assessment
report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change, intergovernmental panel on climate
change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, p 1008
O’Brien K, Leichenko R, Kelkar U, Venema H, Aandahl G, Tompkins H, Javed A, Bhadwal S,
Barg S, Nygaard L, West J (2004) Mapping vulnerability to multiple stressors: climate change
and globalization in India. Glob Environ Chang 14:303–313
Richards M (2003) Poverty reduction, equity and climate change: challenges for global governance. Nat Resour Perspect 83. http://www.odi.org.uk/nrp/index.html. Cited 18 Jan 2007
Schipper L, Pelling M (2006) Disaster risk, climate change and international development: scope
and challenges for integration. Disasters 30(1):19–38
Thomalla F, Downing T, Spanger-Siegried E, Han G, Rockstrom J (2006) Reducing hazard vulnerability: towards a common approach between disaster risk reduction and climate adaptation.
Disasters 30(l):39
golam.rabbani@bcas.net
14
Future Approaches of Food Security, Sustainable Development…
273
Turnbull M, Sterrett CL, Hilleboe A (2013) Toward resilience: a guide to disaster risk reduction
and climate change adaptation. Practical Action Publishing Limited, Warwickshire
UN International Strategy for Disaster Reduction (UNISDR) (2008) Towards national resilience:
good practices of national platforms for disaster risk reduction. United Nations secretariat of
the International Strategy for Disaster Reduction (UN/ISDR), Geneva, p 72
United Nations, Development of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division (2009) World
population prospects: the 2008 revision, New York (Extended Dataset on CD-ROM, ST/ESA/
SER.A/283, Sales No. 09.XII.6)
golam.rabbani@bcas.net