Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
TRANSPORT DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES IN THE RURAL
AREAS OF THE STARA ZAGORA URBAN AREA IN BULGARIA
Kamen PETROV, Nikolay TSONKOV
University of National and World Economy – Sofia, Faculty "Management and Administration",
Department "Regional Development", Students Town, UNWE, Sofia 1700, Bulgaria, Phone:
+359 2 8195 647 , Email: petrovk@abv.bg, petrovkamen@abv.bg, kolio_tzonkov@abv.bg,
ntzonkov@unwe.bg
Corresponding author: petrovkamen@abv.bg
Abstract
The paper explores the possibility of transport development as a factor for the rural integration of a population of
over 100,000 using the example of the city of Stara Zagora in Bulgaria. The analysis showed that improving the
access of the rural population to the agglomeration areas can be done through the combination of inter-urban
transport that connects the villages with the nearby city The purpose of developing this process is to increase the
access of the rural population to the cities and, accordingly, to bring out the problems that the people of the villages
have in terms of urban transport. Based on a proposed methodology, we propose to highlight the main public
transport problems of the rural population. On the other hand, to propose different views and models to achieve
higher efficiency of urban transport and its implementation in rural areas. In this paper, quantitative and
qualitative analysis is used and the results are also used to assess the impact of price fluctuations on vegetable
marketing channels including vegetable processing enterprises. Data on vegetable prices were extracted from the
tempo on line database and the analysis was also based on interviews with key stakeholders in the vegetable
processing chain. The results reveal a high coefficient of variation at the farm gate stage, which is also transmitted
to the distribution and commercialization stage. The analysis was also carried out at the processing level and the
results also show a rather high coefficient of variation.
Key words: public transport, transport connectivity, suburban development, Stara Zagora municipality
INTRODUCTION
Nowadays, the linkages and interactions
between urban and rural areas have become
more intensive and an important component
of livelihoods and production systems.
The areas around urban centres or along the
roads out of such centres, which usually are
named "a peri-urban interface, have the
strongest connection with the cities, as the
rural population depends on urban centres for
access to work places, education units,
hospitals, banks, and other services. Also, a
part of the urban population prefer to live in
the surroundings of the cities where life is
closer to nature and far away from the
stressing cities [14].
In the proximity of the cities, non-farm
incomes represent "a large and growing
proportion of rural households’ incomes and
people's mobility is very intensive [15, 12].
The Covid19 pandemic has proved that the
rural localities surrounding the cities have
been a good place for spending safe week-end
short travels [11, 13].
Therefore, for a large range of reasons, roads
and rail infrastructure and transport network
have to be well developed to assure the
shortest travel time between a city and the
rural localities in its surroundings.
In this context, a good example is Stara
Zahora city in Bulgaria, whose role in urban
development and regional planning has
become very important and has different
territorial dimensions, based on the actual
assessed potentials and functions performed
as a city-center in the national urban model.
Transportation needs are one of the most
diverse aspects of human life. As planners
know well, public transit cannot be treated as
a one-size-fits-all endeavor. It’s especially
important to consider the different needs of
urban and rural populations when planning
643
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
out an appropriate transit system [8]. The
historically formed, preserved, and stimulated
connections of the city of Stara Zagora with
the surrounding settlements and territories are
conditioned.
Researched
and
proven
(theoretically and practically verified),
different in territorial scope and leading
functions zones of influence of the city,
formed by the degree of intensity and
diversity of connections with adjacent
territories.
The manifestation of the
organizing functions of the city. Stara Zagora
in its adjacent zones, in terms of economic
and transport connections, services, recreation
and administrative management activities. In
this regard, the strengths in the regional
context of the city are the city-center of urban
structures, of a high hierarchical level. In
practice, Stara Zagora is the nucleus of a large
agglomeration area, which makes it a
supporting center in the national settlement
network, and at the areal level - a city with
zoning functions, especially in the service of
the areal. The economic potential and the
degree of development of the social functions
and the related social infrastructure of the
town are also important in the city. Stara
Zagora gives a positive reflection on the main
parameters of the socio-economic complex
not only of the Stara Zagora district but also
of the South-Eastern planning region [4].
The region provides sufficient opportunities
for the realization of the functions necessary
for the city, which is facilitated by the wellstructured and developed connections
between the region and the city, the available
opportunities for the construction of at least
two
common
economic
zones,
the
opportunities for the development of new
economic clusters. The completion and
maintenance of the motorways and high-speed
roads, together with the modernization of the
railway lines along the identified routes, will
ensure a more rational spatial organization of
the national transport network, providing
connections between different European
countries, across the territory of the country,
Bulgaria's connections with neighboring
countries and connections between the main
urbanization centers, within the country and
644
its neighbors [5]. The location of the
municipality and of the settlements in Stara
Zagora also determine the opportunities for
improving transport accessibility by taking
targeted measures to develop and improve the
public transport service. The provision of a
more accessible suburban environment will
form a service to develop the socio-economic
potential of the suburban areas and improve
economic and transport connectivity across
the territory.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
For the study of the transport provision of the
extra-urban areas within the city of Stara
Zagora it is necessary to apply territorial and
network approaches due to the complexity of
the research field. The research object
combines the development of suburban areas
in Stara Zagora with the improvement of
transport connectivity, as well as the
development of public transport in the city.
The research field determines the main
objective of the authors: to analyze and
evaluate the possibilities of improving
transport connectivity in Stara Zagora through
the development of urban transport. Within
the framework of this defined objective, the
authors use geographical, demographic,
statistical and sociological research methods.
The main part of the research is the
development and implementation of a
sociological survey. Its main objective is to
assess the satisfaction and attitudes of the
inhabitants of the settlements (villages) within
the municipality of Stara Zagora regarding the
services offered by the municipal public
transport. In the period from 27 June to 06
July 2022. 41 mayors and deputy mayors of
the settlements in the municipality were
surveyed. In practice, the survey covered the
majority of the settlements, i.e. 41 out of 51
settlements in the municipality. The
sociological survey was carried out through
the telephone interview method, after which
the results were summarized. Software
products such as MS Excel and SPSS were
used to summarize and systematize the
collected data. Statistical methods such as
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
univariate distributions, correlation analysis,
regression analysis, and multivariate analyses
were also applied in processing the data and
drawing the main trends and conclusions [1].
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
Spatial Development and Assessment of the
Territory of Stara Zagora Municipality
Stara Zagora Municipality is in Southern
Bulgaria, part of the South-Eastern Planning
Region. It is one of the 11 municipalities of
the same name. Its area represents 0.96% of
the territory of Bulgaria, 5.4% of the territory
of the Southeast Region and 20.7% of the
territory of Stara Zagora District. The
municipality is located mainly on three
altitudinal belts - lowland (below 200 m),
hilly (between 200 and 600 m) and
mountainous (above 600 m). There is one
town in the municipality - Stara Zagora. Stara
Zagora Airport is located 2 km from the town
of Stara Zagora and 8 km from the Trakia
Motorway.
Stara Zagora Municipality is distant from
Plovdiv (80 km.), Burgas (152 km.), Sofia
(192 km.), Haskovo (62 km.), Sliven (63
km.), Kazanlak (29 km.) and Istanbul (308
km.), respectively. This shows that the city of
Stara Zagora is in a good spatial location in
our national space. In addition, the
municipality has 51 villages besides the town
of Stara Zagora, which occupy a significant
part of its territory. These settlements are
grouped according to the population indicator.
Thus, according to the population data, the
villages are grouped as very small (up to 200
inhabitants) - 19, small (between 200 and
1,000 inhabitants) - 28, and large (over 1,000
inhabitants) - 4. From the spatial point of
view, it is necessary to emphasize that the
settlements in Stara Zagora municipality
cover a total area of 68.9 km2, which makes
up 6.3% of the municipality's territory.
Considering the transport availability, it is
evident that 47 of the villages are very small,
which implies that public transport to them is
unlikely to be cost-effective. On the other
hand, in terms of local self-government, only
28 villages have mayors, the remaining
villages have deputy mayors. Five of the town
halls are close to the demographic minimum
(250 inhabitants), but in practice are in danger
of losing their status as self-governing
communities.
The economic outlook of the villages is
agricultural. Only 8 of all 51 villages have
functioning schools, and 29 villages have no
medical practices. A positive feature of the
commune is the complete electrification and
water supply to the villages. In terms of
accessibility and inter-village connections, the
villages can be divided into three main
groups. In the first group are the villages with
strong gravitational potential with the town of
Stara Zagora, which are located close to the
first-class road network. The second group
includes villages located in the southern
periphery, which in practice have some
difficulties using the first-class road network.
The third group of villages are in the northwestern periphery of the municipality. In this
part they have access to the lower quality
municipal road network [6]. On the positive
side for the settlements of Stara Zagora
municipality is the high degree of
accessibility to the central part within a
maximum 30 minutes by car (for 16 villages 10 minutes; for 14 villages - 11 to 15 minutes;
for 12 villages - 16 to 20 minutes and for only
8 peripheral villages - 21 to 30 minutes).
Untapped resources and significant potential
have the city of Stara Zagora as a center of
national importance for the territory of the
Southeast planning region and Southern
Bulgaria, which provides daily, periodic, and
episodic service to a significant contingent of
the population of the places (municipalities)
falling within its urban gravitational field and
in its zone of influence. This is primarily due
to the city's good geostrategic location and the
presence of two transport corridors, which are
seen as a major city-forming factor. This also
determines the existence of good accessibility,
and in addition - the city is rich in natural and
anthropogenic resources [2].
Stara Zagora transport connectivity
analysis
There are 52 settlements in Stara Zagora
municipality, including one town and 51
645
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
villages. To the south of the Sarnen, Sredna
Gora is the wide and flat Stara Zagora field,
with an altitude of 150-170 m, which covers
the eastern, south-eastern, and southern parts
of the municipality. Its lowest point - 136 m
above sea level - is located south of the
village of Kozarevets, on the border with
Dimitrovgrad municipality. If the whole
territory of Stara Zagora municipality has its
spatial planning and management, it should be
perceived as a territorial spatial system. Thus,
in spatial terms, the spatial transport
development of the territory must be
perceived as a system of measures, acts and
actions of a factual and legal nature, which
aim at creating balance and order in society
and the use of the environment - natural or
artificial, for the normal existence of man and
his life cycle. This is not a one-off act, but a
process that is continuous. According to the
modern understanding, it is a purposeful
impact on the natural environment, which
aims to encompass lands and territories within
the borders of a country. In this direction,
there is a need to build a homogeneous
transport environment that meets the needs of
the population of all settlements with urban
transport.
Shaping the image and structure of villages
suggests bringing to the fore the following
factors that can model the need for public
transport. These more important factors are:
- Cultural assets of the settlement, shaped by
the residential environment, and industries in
the broad range from arts to sports.
- Human infrastructure, defined by the
conditions for mobility, to those for start-up
development, healthcare, finance, etc.
- Network markets, which define the strength
of a locality in the community network.
- Architecture and planning of the settlement
space and its land.
- Building technical infrastructure (road,
bridges, rail, water, internet, education, social
and health);
- Formation of socio-economic infrastructure
(enterprises, agriculture, narco-op, etc.).
- Cultural exchange: travel and tourism, food,
and hospitality.
- Mobility, cars, cycling and transport.
646
The existing municipal road network, the
route schemes developed, the frequency of
inter-village transport routes and the time
required to travel the various distances
between the respective settlements form the
individual characteristics
of transport
accessibility for citizens living outside the
municipal center.
Depending on the degree of proximity
(distance) to the municipal center, the travel
time from a locality to the town of Stara
Zagora varies from 10 to 30 minutes per
direction. This circumstance determines the
travel time of buses on individual routes from
the villages to the municipality. As far as the
inter-rural lines are concerned, there is not
much delay as far as the journey to the city
itself is concerned. Delays are accumulated on
the journey into the city. It should also be
made clear that delays accumulate during
peak hours - morning and evening - when
people are going to and returning from work.
The average transport accessibility parameters
to the municipal center for a settlement are:
distance - 18.5 km on average.
one-way travel time - average 14.8 minutes
by car.
The degree of development of the municipal
transport network determines the mobility
possibilities of the population and the level of
access to services.
Because there are different distances of the
settlements to the municipality of Stara
Zagora and considering at which part of the
day (peak or off-peak hours) we have
different duration of each trip. It is normal for
long-distance trips to be longer, and they can
be as long as 40-50 minutes. Urban routes are
shorter, but they are more runs within
working hours, which can compensate for the
total mileage. In general, they are shorter, and
the duration is less, but it depends on whether
it is a peak or off-peak hour of the day. In
general, durations average between 20 and 37
minutes in off-peak and peak hours of the day.
The extended commute time zone begins at
7:00 am and continues until about 10:00 am.
In the evenings, the time zone with the
greatest concentration of commuters moving
from the workplace to home is 6:00-6:45 PM.
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
The extended commute-to-home time zone
starts at 4:30 p.m. and ends around 8:30 p.m.
Respondents cited traffic congestion, travel
time, transfers, irregular public transport, and
lack of parking spaces as the main problems
in getting to and from work in both directions.
Respondents felt that getting home takes
longer than getting to work. Travelling by car,
public transport and taxi are the biggest
causes of stress - around 70% of those
travelling by the listed means of transport feel
stressed to some extent by the journey. The
existing municipal road network, the route
schemes developed, the frequency of intermunicipal transport and the time taken to
travel the various distances between the
respective settlements, form the individual
characteristics of transport accessibility for
citizens living outside the municipal center
[10].
Table 1. Territorial access indicators
possibilities of the population and the level of
access to services.
As a physical structure, the settlement
network is well developed, balanced over the
entire territory of the municipality. The
imbalance is mainly due to the demographic
and functional characteristics of the
settlements. The differences between the
municipal center and the other urbanized areas
are very pronounced [17].
Table 2. Personal vehicles access to city center
Up to 10
minutes
travel
time
16 villages
11
–
15
minutes travel
time
14 villages
16
–
20
minutes
travel time
12 villages
21
–
30
minutes travel
time
8 villages
Bogomilovo
Future
Arnautito
Borilovo
Benkovski
Vodenicharovo
Zmeiovo
Kalitinovo
Kaloqnovetz
Kirilovo
Majerito
Small Vereq
Small
Kadievo
Mogila
Preslaven
Rakitnitza
Hristiqnovo
Gorno Botevo
Dalboki
Kolena
Lulqk
Lqskovo
Novo Selo
Orqhovitza
Borovo
Brothes
Kunchevi
Elhovo
Lovetz
Lozen
Mihailovo
Ostra Mogila
Ploska Mogila
Podslon
Kazanka
Kozarevetz
Pshenichno
Pastrovo
Samuilovo
Sladak Kladenetz
Up to 10
minutes
travel
time
14 villages
11
–
15
minutes travel
time
13 villages
16
–
20
minutes
travel time
12 villages
21
–
30
minutes travel
time
10 villages
0 – 12 km
distance
13 – 19 km
distance
20 – 25 km
Distance
26 – 35 km
Distance
Source: Stara Zagora municipality.
Bogomilovo
Elenino
Borilovo
Future
Benkovski
Vodenicharovo
Zmeiovo
Kalitinovo
Kaloqnovetz
Kirilovo
Majerito
Small Vereq
Small
Kadievo
Mogila
Preslaven
Rakitnitza
Hristiqnovo
Gorno Botevo
Dalboki
Kolena
Lulqk
Lqskovo
Novo Selo
Sulitza
Arnautito
Brothes
Kunchevi
Elhovo
Lovetz
Lozen
Orqhovitza
Ostra Mogila
Ploska Mogila
Podslon
Borovo
Streletz
Han Asparuhovo
Rumanq
Keeping the road network in good condition is
a prerequisite for its more efficient use.
Improving the quality and performance of a
range of infrastructure facilities will increase
throughput,
with
urgency
for
rail
infrastructure. Continuous and consistent
transport networks with uniform performance
characteristics need to be built to ensure the
rapid and safe transport of people and goods.
Increasing accessibility is essential to
strengthen the regional economy. Efforts
should focus on completing priority rail and
road routes and on promoting multimodal
transport by improving intermodal links [9].
There is also a need to ensure transport
efficiency and safety, while minimizing
negative environmental impacts. Untapped
resources and development potential also exist
along the TENT network. Transport policy is
important for territorial connectivity, for
access to important centers in the European
and national polycentric urban network, for
mobility and free movement. Transport
Hrishteni
Pamukchin
Peytrovo
Priporetz
Starozagorski
Bani
Kazanka
Kozarevetz
Pshenichno
Pastrovo
Samuilovo
Sladak Kladenetz
Mihailovo
Hrishteni
Source: Stara Zagora municipality.
The accessibility from small settlements to the
city of Stara Zagora, as a combination of
distance and frequency indicators, is shown in
Table 1.
The average values of transport accessibility
to the municipal center for a settlement are:
- distance - 18.5 km.
- one-way travel time - 14.8 min.
- daily round trips - 6 pcs.
The degree of development of the municipal
transport network determines the mobility
Pamukchin
Peytrovo
Priporetz
Starozagorski
Bani
Sulitza
Rumanq
Streletz
Han Asparuhovo
647
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
infrastructure is an important factor in
attracting investment, in reducing inter- and
intra-regional disparities and in ensuring
equitable access to services. Its construction
and maintenance depend on the characteristics
of the territory, on the possibilities of linking
up with Europe's transport networks and on
the potential for interaction between different
modes of transport [9].
Modern transport terminals require ever larger
areas to function properly and safely,
combining a variety of communication,
service, commercial, recreational, and social
functions. The objectives and priorities of
national transport policy are determined by
the strategic objectives and priorities of EU
transport policy, as set out in several key
documents. The 2011 White Paper "Roadmap
towards a Single European Transport Area Towards a competitive and resource efficient
transport system" is the main European
strategic document outlining the guidelines
for transport development [9]. Regulation
(EU) No 1303/2013 sets out the generally
applicable provisions for the "European
Structural and Investment Funds" (ESIF) [11].
Eleven thematic objectives are defined for the
ESF and an EU Common Strategic
Framework (CSF). The Connecting Europe
Facility 2 (CEF2) is expected to be a major
contributor to this objective, with a target of
60% of its budget to be spent on actions
contributing to climate objectives.
Spatial transport development of the territory
must be perceived as a system of measures,
acts, and actions of a factual and legal nature,
which aim at creating balance and order in
society and using the environment - natural or
artificial, for the normal existence of man and
his life cycle. This is not a one-off act, but a
process that is continuous. According to the
modern understanding, it is a targeted impact
on the natural environment, which aims to
encompass lands and territories within the
borders of a country. In this direction, there is
a need to build a homogeneous transport
environment that meets the needs of the
population of all settlements with urban
transport [11].
648
Assessment of the satisfaction and attitudes
of the inhabitants of the settlements
(villages) in the municipality of Stara
Zagora
For the municipality of Stara Zagora, it is
important to have optimal transport
accessibility for the citizens according to the
specific of the city territory and disparities. It
is important for the municipality to function
normally, as a system in which there is a
relative balance between its different
constituent elements, in this case the city and
the settlements. In this direction, it is
important to bring out the management vision
on the role and importance of public transport
for the development of the transport system
within the municipality of Stara Zagora.
In such studies it has been noticed that men
often do not fill in the questionnaires
correctly, unlike women who show more
diligence. In the case of Stara Zagora
municipality, we have a balance of the sample
of respondents, which is evenly distributed
between the two sexes, with a minimal
predominance of men, who are 22 people
(Figure 1), and 19 women respondents.
In fact, the distribution of the sample is in line
with the demographic picture in the
municipality
and
nationally.
Another
important aspect of participation in public
management is the age structure of the
management staff. Both the ageing of the
population and legislative changes in setting
age limits for retirement have an impact on
the population of working age and over [7].
The preponderance of managers shown in
Chart 1 and 2 in terms of their gender and age
structure suggests that we will have a more
conservative view in terms of change in the
development of public transport in Stara
Zagora municipality.
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
man
women
under 18
18 -30
30 - 40
40- 50
50 - 60
over 60
Fig. 1. Point your gender
Source: Own results.
Fig. 2. Point your age
Source: Own results.
Especially the age structure, which can be
seen in Figure 2, brings to the fore
management
staff
practically
around
retirement age. If we look carefully at the
reproduction of the working age population in
the municipality of Stara Zagora, we see that
it is characterized by the demographic
replacement rate, which shows the ratio
between the number of people entering the
working age (15-19 years) and the number of
people leaving the working age (60-64 years).
By 2022 in Stara Zagora this ratio is 68.5. For
comparison, in 2001, 100 people leaving
working age were replaced by 117 young
people.
The demographic profile of the respondents
shows that more than half of all respondents
are over 60 years old (51%), 34% are in the
age group 50-60, 12% of respondents are
between 40-50 years old and only 3% of
respondents are in the age group 30-40. This
suggests that the main trends are related to
other types of problems, mostly with the labor
market, rather than with the search for
solutions related to the level of labor
efficiency and creativity.
The ageing trend of the population is also
leading to changes in its basic age structure below, at and above working age. Both the
ageing of the population and legislative
changes in the setting of retirement age limits
have an impact on the working-age and overage population [5]. This process is changing
the philosophy and perceptions in society on
how to address groups of issues and pulling
public opinion in a different direction.
Another essential element in determining the
priorities of the settlements in the
municipality of Stara Zagora is the model of
perceived transport accessibility. Accessibility
is defined as the ability to get from one place
to another. In this context, accessibility refers
to the ease of reaching different destinations.
People who are in places that are more
accessible will be able to reach activities and
destinations faster than those in inaccessible
places. The latter will not be able to reach the
same number of locations in each period.
Mobility is the ability to move or be moved
freely and easily. Mobility can be seen as the
ability to move through different levels in
society or employment, for example. While
mobility focuses on moving people and goods
to and from different places, accessibility is
an approach or input that can be obtained or
achieved. Thus, the two forms -mobility and
accessibility rely on each other in some way,
depending on the scenario, but remain
separate entities [16].
A great example of improving accessibility
rather than mobility is the case of a rural
transport scenario, in which road means and
modes are pragmatically chosen to move the
population by rail and bus.
Within the municipality of Stara Zagora, apart
from bus transport, private transport is an
alternative, but it is not a good solution for
people under 18 and those over 65. This has
also brought to the fore the need to analyze
travel options within the settlements of Stara
Zagora municipality. This is because
accessibility in terms of geography is an
important element in the mobility of people,
649
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
goods, or information. Mobility is determined
by people and affects infrastructure, transport
policies and regional development.
The question posed to the representatives of
the local authorities, what do the inhabitants
of the villages in the municipality of Stara
Zagora use to get around, produced an
interesting result.
It can be seen from Figure 3 that the
respondents are almost equally distributed,
with own and public transport, with 40% of
respondents stating that residents use public
mass transport to reach Stara Zagora.
Stara Zagora, while another 33% stated that
they usually travel by their own car to the
municipal center. A small percentage of those
who say they travel to the town of Stara
Zagora. Stara Zagora by company car or other
means.
people who commute use their own cars. 15%
of the respondents commute to school. In fact,
it is normal for students to use public
transport, given the fact that they are provided
with discounted travel passes. 16% of all
travel to health facilities. For the most part,
these commuters are rural residents of
working age. This also means that they do not
commute daily to the city. And 7% travel to
the community center for leisure and
shopping, suggesting that they also rather use
their own transport.
Other
Fig. 4. How often the village citizens travel to the big
city during week time?
Source: Own research.
Use public transport
Use company transport
Private cars and I use it
0
10
20
30
40
50
Fig. 3. What do the residents from your locality use to
get to Stara Zagora usually?
Source: Own research.
In Figure 4 we can see the intensity of trips
from the villages to the city Stara Zagora.
33 of all respondents indicated in their answer
that they travel daily to Stara Zagora. Stara
Zagora. 7 of the respondents travel to the
municipal center several times a week during
weekdays.
The intensity of trips is directly related to the
purpose and destination of the trip from the
villages to the city of Stara Zagora (Figure 5).
31% indicated the workplace as their
destination. In fact, these villagers commute
daily, and it is important to establish what
proportion of them use inter-village transport
in the municipality. Due to the lack of public
transport accessibility to the industrial area of
the city, we could conclude that most of the
650
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
To work
place
To school To health To the
care
place for
utilities
fun and
shoping
Other
Fig. 5. Where are you travelling to?
Source: Own results.
yes
no
Fig. 6. Are you satisfied with the present timetables of
the bus lines?
Source: Own research.
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
The following Figure 6 provides information
on the proposed changes to the timetables of
the inter-suburban public transport lines in
Stara Zagora.
Responses to this question indicate that
people are generally happy with the timetable
and minimal changes should be made to
maximize their satisfaction.
Figure 7 shows the circumstances that would
affect a shift from the use of private cars to
public transport for the daily journeys of
residents of your locality to the town Stara
Zagora.
Unfortunately, 13% of respondents indicated
that they could not be motivated in any way to
leave the car to use public transport.
improved substantially, the public transport
fleet was upgraded, and public transport travel
times were reduced [3].
The issue of what matters most to rural
residents is extremely important. 8% say that
the ability to travel for free is paramount for
them. Another 19% indicate that the most
important thing related to public transport is
the affordability of fares (i.e., a change in
tickets and season tickets is needed). 17%
indicate that the quality and comfort of the
bus ride is most important. 15% said that the
most important thing for them is the shortness
of the journey. 19% of all respondents say that
the most important thing for them is the
intensity and frequency of public transport.
And as many as 24% say that the most
important thing for them is the improvement
of the transport service (punctuality, journey,
etc.).
Fig. 7. Please mark these circumstances which may
influence changing the way of travel - from personal
vehicle to public transport.
Source: Own research.
Fig. 8. What is the most important thing for you and the
residents when using public transport? Please choose
the three most important!
According to 6 % in the town the introduction
of some serious restrictions may motivate
commuters from the villages to the city to
leave the private car and start using public
transport. Such measures are - limited number
of parking spaces and introduction of parking
fees. 27% are ready to use public transport
due to objective reasons such as an increase in
fuel prices and all other costs. In today's high
inflation environment, a large proportion of
rural commuters (27%) are likely to switch
from private cars to public transport buses.
However, to this end, people in rural areas
should be offered flexible timetables. A
minimal number of respondents would switch
from car to bus if private car travel increased
disproportionately,
public
transport
accessibility related to timetable and timing
In connection with the optimization of the
transport
scheme
and
the
possible
commissioning of the two regional bus
stations in the eastern and western part of the
station, we asked the mayors of the villages in
the municipality of Stara Zagora whether they
agree to use these stations. Figure 9 also
shows the respondents' answers regarding
changes to public transport timetables and
routes. The responses are almost equally
distributed in the dichotomy of agreement and
disagreement for changes in public transport.
13 (32%) of respondents agreed that changes
should be made to public transport timetables
and routes. Conversely, 28 (68%) of
respondents disagreed that any changes to
public transport were necessary, citing a
variety of reasons. As many as 16 (39%) of
Source. Own Research.
651
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
those who disagreed felt that it suited and
suited them at present.
Fig. 9. Do you agree that a change should be made to
the bus route(s) to start stopping at the existing east and
west bus stations and that the public transport bus lines
in Stara Zagora should start from there?
Source. Own Research.
According to 2% (1 person) of the
respondents, they believe that enough has
been done and they are not comfortable with
changes. Another 10% (4 people) said they
disagreed because it would be difficult to
travel, and they are also used to the current
timetables and transport scheme. And 5% (2
people) say that more time will be wasted
travelling and are therefore reluctant to agree
to the proposed changes.
CONCLUSIONS
The main objective of this study is to
describe, analyze and, as far as possible,
present a quantitative overview of the need for
improvement of public transport within the
municipality of Stara Zagora, affecting mainly
the settlements within the municipality. Based
on a sound methodological approach,
empirical evidence and the results of a
questionnaire survey, the following results
were derived, which include intermodally
diverse environmental innovations. They
cover both freight and passenger transport.
Based on the findings of this survey,
recommendations and advice are given to
policy makers for the optimization and
development of public transport in the
municipality of Stara Zagora, which would
create conditions for connectivity and
development of peri-urban areas. The analysis
carried out shows that the density of the
652
transport network and the choice of public
transport routes and lines is influenced by
many factors, both specific and general. The
latter include the number of inhabitants.
The assessment and analysis of rural mayors
is an important argument for the definition of
transport policies and the implementation of
initiatives related to the management and
development of urban transport. The aim of
the study is to gain a better understanding of
the role and importance of public transport for
the regional development of municipalities.
This predetermines the arrangement of the
problems in the development of the urban
transport system on the principle of
innovation. Thus, first, the methodologies for
defining, grouping, and ranking innovative
cities and related territorial formations such as
municipalities, which are subject to targeted
transport policy, are characterized.
Trends show that there is a tendency towards
higher density in medium-sized cities such as
Stara Zagora, but an increase in population is
also visible in the municipality's villages.
On the other hand, the reforms that have taken
place since 1990 have sought optimization,
cost reduction, etc., which, however, largely
lead to impaired daily mobility, as well as
congestion at peak times.
In terms of accessibility and inter-village
connections, groups of 'privileged' and
'neglected' villages are emerging.
Those located along the first-class road
network are unproblematic, while connections
between villages south of Kaloyanovets and
those in the north-eastern region are severely
hampered by the poor condition of the roads.
Within the municipality of Stara Zagora, the
establishment of a functioning transport
system passes through the creation of several
transport schemes and plans of varying
degrees, as legal and sub-legal acts, through
which assumptions, forecasts, and future
actions to modify the existing environment
and management are legally anchored.
These activities are an important instrument
of public works, especially for municipalities
of the rank of Stara Zagora, and at the same
time they are an important instrument of
spatial planning and policy.
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
Through them, the goals, intentions, and
actions for building the physical living
environment of people and the possibilities
for
public
connectivity
within
the
municipality of Stara Zagora are defined.
The schemes, plans and transport lines
connecting the villages and the city of Stara
Zagora are important in several ways - they
implement the principles of territorial
connectivity, create conditions for continuity
in the development of the different territories,
in addition to creating a favorable living
environment within the agglomeration area.
Finally, the effect of coordination of common
transport policies between the competent
public authorities and the public is sought in
the development of a specific territory.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This publication is part of a study devoted to
regional development. It is part of the NID
NI-5-2022 project at UNSS.
REFERENCES
[1]Anselin, L., 2012, From spacestat to CyberGIS
twenty years of spatial data analysis software.
International Regional Science Review, Vol. 35(2),
131-157.
[2]Bugarinović, M., Dimitrijević, B., Bošković, B.,
2015, The missing component in rail charging
modeling-access
charges
principle
selection.
International Transactions in Operational Research.
Vol. 22(5), 841–859.
[3]Copus, A., Psaltopoulos, D., Skuras, D., Terluin, I.,
Weingarten, P., 2008, Approaches to Rural Typology
in the European Union. Luxembourg: Office for
Official Publications of the European Communities, pp.
47–54.
[4]Cromartie, J., 2015, Historical Development of ERS
Rural Urban Classifications Systems. Paper presented
at the Workshop on Rationalizing Rural Area
Classifications, April, National Academies of Sciences,
Engineering, and Medicine, Washington, DC.
http://sites.nationalacademies.org/,
Accessed
on
13.04.2023.
[5]Dantsis, T., Douma, C., Giourga, C., Loumou, A.,
Polychronaki, E.A., 2010, A methodological approach
to assess and compare the sustainability level of
agricultural plant production systems, Ecological
Indicators 10 (2010) 256–263
[6]Halfacree, K., 1993, Locality and social
representation: Space, discourse and alternative
definitions of the rural. Journal of Rural Studies, VOL.
9(1), 23-37.
[7]Kastreva, P., Patarchanova, E., 2021, Creating
Spatial Models of Demographic Processes Using
Cluster Analysis for Demographic Policy Planning in
Bulgaria. Journal of Settlements and Spatial Planning,
Vol. 12(2), 119-130, doi:10.24193/jssp.2021.2.05
[8]Kenyon, S., Rafferty, J., Lyons, G., 2003, Social
exclusion and transport in the UK: a role for virtual
accessibility in the alleviation of mobility-related
exclusion? Journal of Social Policy. 32:317.
[9]Mrksa, M., Gajic, T., 2014, Opportunities for
sustainable development of rural tourism in the
municipality of Vrbas. Ekonomika Poljoprivrede,
61(1), 163.
[10]Niikolova, Hr., 2015, Evaluating average external
costs of inland freight transport in South-Еastern
European countries: Policy implications - Economic
Alternatives, Vol. 3, 64-81.
[11]Pleşoianu, D. M., 2017, Development Strategies
for Rural Tourism in Dobrogea. Scientific Papers
Series Management, Economic Engineering in
Agriculture & Rural Development, Vol. 17(3), 301305.
[12]Popescu, A., 2013, Considerations on the main
features of the agricultural population in the European
Union, Scientific Papers Series Management,
Economic Engineering in Agriculture, Vol.13(4), 213220.
[13]Randelli, F., Romei, P., Tortora. M., 2014, The
evolution of rural tourism in Tuscany. Bollettino de la
Societ ═ Geografica italiana Roma, Serie XIII, Vol.
VII, pp. 375-389.
[14]Tacoli, C., 2003, The links between urban and
rural
development,
Environment
Urbanization,
Vol.15(1),
and
3-12,
https://www.iied.org/sites/default/files/pdfs/migrate/G0
0486.pdf, Accessed on May 10, 2023.
[15]Tacoli, C., 2017, Small towns, rural-urban linkages
and
regional
development,
URBANET,
https://www.urbanet.info/rural-urban-linkages/,
Accessed on May 10, 2023.
[16]Todorova, Sq., Rancheva, E., Petkov, T., 2018,
Invasion of Low-Cost Carriers on the Bulgarian Air
Market - Marketing and Branding Research 5111-5121,
www.aimijournal.com, Accessed on 18.04.2023.
[17]Weiss, J., Heinz-Fischer, C., 2022, The More Rural
the Less Educated? An Analysis of National Policy
Strategies for Enhancing Young Adults’ Participation
in Formal and Informal Training in European Rural
Areas, Young Adults’ Participation in Formal and
Informal Training in European Rural Areas, Youth
2022, 2, 405–421.
653
Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development
Vol. 23, Issue 4, 2023
PRINT ISSN 2284-7995, E-ISSN 2285-3952
654
View publication stats