A Lasting First Impression - Cast

Name	Known for
Kelly Mantle Charleigh Charleigh See fewer	The Browns (2020)
Chris Gaunt Max Max See fewer	Follow Her (2022)
Jeremiah Wenutu David David See fewer	Back to the Present!
Justin Senense Mylo Mylo See fewer	Howard (II) (2019)
Matthew Wilkinson Stella Progress Stella Progress See fewer	A Lasting First Impression
Jennifer Lefsyk Jess Jess See fewer	Romeo 3000 (2018)
James Shear Sheri Love Sheri Love See fewer	A Lasting First Impression
Timothy Coakley Musician Musician See fewer	Nothing but Blood (2016)
Maddy Mazzotta Singer / Musician Singer / Musician See fewer	Against the Ropes (2021)
Monroe Sedgwick Monroe Sedgwick Monroe Sedgwick See fewer	A Lasting First Impression
Frank Hillebrandt Amanda Love Amanda Love See fewer	A Lasting First Impression
Nash Johns Nashley Tisdale Nashley Tisdale See fewer	Friends Don't Let Friends Date Friends (2014)
Aldrin John Castillo Philly Pina Philly Pina See fewer	A Lasting First Impression
Quitman McBride Naomi Naomi See fewer	Imposter (I) (2018)
Dustin Crispell Dusty Boxx Dusty Boxx See fewer	A Lasting First Impression