EP1539950A1 - Rational directed protein evolution using two-dimensional rational mutagenesis scanning - Google Patents
Rational directed protein evolution using two-dimensional rational mutagenesis scanningInfo
- Publication number
- EP1539950A1 EP1539950A1 EP03748392A EP03748392A EP1539950A1 EP 1539950 A1 EP1539950 A1 EP 1539950A1 EP 03748392 A EP03748392 A EP 03748392A EP 03748392 A EP03748392 A EP 03748392A EP 1539950 A1 EP1539950 A1 EP 1539950A1
- Authority
- EP
- European Patent Office
- Prior art keywords
- protein
- amino acid
- activity
- proteins
- leads
- Prior art date
- Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
- Ceased
Links
Classifications
-
- C—CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
- C12—BIOCHEMISTRY; BEER; SPIRITS; WINE; VINEGAR; MICROBIOLOGY; ENZYMOLOGY; MUTATION OR GENETIC ENGINEERING
- C12N—MICROORGANISMS OR ENZYMES; COMPOSITIONS THEREOF; PROPAGATING, PRESERVING, OR MAINTAINING MICROORGANISMS; MUTATION OR GENETIC ENGINEERING; CULTURE MEDIA
- C12N15/00—Mutation or genetic engineering; DNA or RNA concerning genetic engineering, vectors, e.g. plasmids, or their isolation, preparation or purification; Use of hosts therefor
- C12N15/09—Recombinant DNA-technology
- C12N15/10—Processes for the isolation, preparation or purification of DNA or RNA
- C12N15/1034—Isolating an individual clone by screening libraries
- C12N15/1089—Design, preparation, screening or analysis of libraries using computer algorithms
-
- C—CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
- C07—ORGANIC CHEMISTRY
- C07K—PEPTIDES
- C07K14/00—Peptides having more than 20 amino acids; Gastrins; Somatostatins; Melanotropins; Derivatives thereof
- C07K14/435—Peptides having more than 20 amino acids; Gastrins; Somatostatins; Melanotropins; Derivatives thereof from animals; from humans
- C07K14/52—Cytokines; Lymphokines; Interferons
- C07K14/555—Interferons [IFN]
- C07K14/56—IFN-alpha
-
- C—CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
- C07—ORGANIC CHEMISTRY
- C07K—PEPTIDES
- C07K14/00—Peptides having more than 20 amino acids; Gastrins; Somatostatins; Melanotropins; Derivatives thereof
- C07K14/435—Peptides having more than 20 amino acids; Gastrins; Somatostatins; Melanotropins; Derivatives thereof from animals; from humans
- C07K14/52—Cytokines; Lymphokines; Interferons
- C07K14/555—Interferons [IFN]
- C07K14/565—IFN-beta
-
- C—CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
- C12—BIOCHEMISTRY; BEER; SPIRITS; WINE; VINEGAR; MICROBIOLOGY; ENZYMOLOGY; MUTATION OR GENETIC ENGINEERING
- C12N—MICROORGANISMS OR ENZYMES; COMPOSITIONS THEREOF; PROPAGATING, PRESERVING, OR MAINTAINING MICROORGANISMS; MUTATION OR GENETIC ENGINEERING; CULTURE MEDIA
- C12N15/00—Mutation or genetic engineering; DNA or RNA concerning genetic engineering, vectors, e.g. plasmids, or their isolation, preparation or purification; Use of hosts therefor
- C12N15/09—Recombinant DNA-technology
- C12N15/10—Processes for the isolation, preparation or purification of DNA or RNA
- C12N15/1034—Isolating an individual clone by screening libraries
- C12N15/1058—Directional evolution of libraries, e.g. evolution of libraries is achieved by mutagenesis and screening or selection of mixed population of organisms
Definitions
- Directed evolution refers to biotechnological processes devoted to the optimization of the protein activity by means of changes introduced into selected respective genes. Directed evolution includes the generation of a collection of mutated genes followed by the selection of mutants encoding proteins with desired features. These processes can be iterative when gene products having an improvement in a desired property are subjected to further cycles of mutation, selection and screening. The concept of mutant or mutation is used here in the wide sense of "change. " Directed evolution provides a way to adapt natural proteins to work in new chemical or biological environments, and/or to elicit new functions. Proteins intrinsically possess an enormous potential plasticity, which allows them to face new challenges, such as a new environment and a desired new or altered activity.
- random or stochastic approaches have also been employed.
- One random approach requires synthesis of all possible protein sequences or a statistically sufficient large number of proteins followed by the screening to identify proteins having a desired activity or property.
- Other random approaches are based on gene shuffling methods, such as, for example, PCR-based methods that generate random rearrangements between or among two or more sequence-related genes to randomly generate variants of the original gene.
- 2D rational mutagenesis scanning also referred to as 2D scanning.
- This method relies on an indirect search for protein improvement for a particular activity, such as increased resistance to proteolysis, based on a rational amino acid replacement and sequence change at single or a limited number of amino acid positions at a time.
- optimized proteins having modified amino acid sequences at some regions along the protein that perform better than the starting sequence are identified and isolated.
- Target amino acids are selected based on properties of the target polyeptide, including i) the particular protein properties to be evolved, ii) the protein's amino acid sequence, and Hi) the known properties of the individual amino acids, a number of target amino acid positions along the protein sequence are selected in silico for replacement.
- the target amino acid positions along the protein sequence selected in silico for replacement are referred to as "is-HIT target positions.”
- the number of is-HIT target position is generally selected to be as large as possible such that all reasonably possible target positions for the particular feature being evolved are included.
- the amino acids selected to replace the is-HIT target positions on the particular protein being optimized can be either all of the remaining 1 9 amino acids or, more frequently, a more restricted group of selected amino acids that are contemplated to have the desired effect on protein activity.
- all of the amino acid positions along the protein backbone can be selected as is-HIT target positions for amino acid replacement.
- Mutagenesis then is performed by the replacement of a single amino acid residue at one is-HIT target position on the protein backbone (e.g., "one-by-one, " such as in addressable arrays), such that each individual mutant generated is the single product of each single mutagenesis reaction.
- the single amino acid replacement mutagenesis reactions are repeated for each of the replacing amino acids selected at each of the is-HIT target positions.
- a plurality of mutant protein molecules are produced, whereby each mutant protein contains a single amino acid replacement at only one of the is-HIT target positions.
- Activity assessment then is individually performed on each individual protein mutant molecule, following protein expression and measurement of an activity, such as set forth in the Examples provided herein for the optimization of IFN -2b.
- the positions in polypeptides that contain modifications that lead to an alteration in the targeted protein activity are referred to as LEADs.
- FIGURES Figure 1 (A) shows a schematic of the initial step in the methods provided herein for 2D-scanning. Once the protein feature(s) to be optimized is (are) selected (indicated as "?"), diverse sources of information or previous knowledge (i.e., protein primary, secondary or tertiary structures, literature, patents) are exploited to determine those amino acid positions that may be amenable to improved protein fitness by replacement with a different amino acid.
- This step utilizes protein analysis "in silico." All possible candidate positions that might be involved in the feature being evolved are referred to herein as “in silico HITs" (“is-HITs”) .
- the collection (or library) of all is-HITs identified during this step represents the first dimension (target residue position) of the two-dimensional scanning methods provided herein. The first dimension is restricted because only aminoacids along the protein sequence that are the is-HITs.
- Figure 1 (B) shows a representation of the methods provided herein to identify a collection of LEAD candidates. A series of steps is conducted, in silico as in FIG1A, to identify all appropriate replacing amino acids expected to improve fitness when substituted at the is-HIT positions to form candidate LEADs.
- Figure 2 shows a representation of methods provided herein for identification of LEADs.
- a collection (library) of individual mutant molecules is produced (in vitro) such that the native amino acids at the is-HIT positions are replaced by other selected amino acids.
- the replacing amino acids are any of the remaining 1 9 amino acids so that all 20 natural amino acids are in the position, although typically they are a smaller group of selected amino acids with sets of properties appropriate to the evolving feature. Often only a subset of amino acids are used as a replacing amino acid so that the second dimension is restricted.
- mutant molecules or in silico candidate LEADS
- LEADs The collection of mutant molecules, or in silico candidate LEADS, is generated, tested and phenotypically characterized one-by-one, for example, in addressable arrays.
- Each individual mutant in the collection is designed and produced as the single product of an independent mutagenesis reaction.
- Mutant molecules are such that each molecule contains one and only one mutation. Those molecules displaying improved fitness for the evolving feature are called LEADs.
- Figure 3(A) shows a further step in the methods provided herein for rational evolution of peptides and proteins.
- a new collection of mutant molecules is obtained by combination of any two or more of the mutations present in the LEAD molecules.
- the collection of new mutant molecules is generated, tested and phenotypically characterized such as in the the one-by-one in addressable arrays exemplified in the Figure.
- Each individual mutant in the collection is designed and produced as the single product of an independent mutagenesis reaction.
- Mutant molecules are such that each molecule contains a variable number and type of LEAD mutations. Those molecules displaying further improved fitness for the evolving feature, are referred to herein as super-LEADs.
- Figure 3(B) shows an embodiment of the methods provided herein intended to redesign proteins such that they maintain levels and type of activity comparable to those of the native protein while their sequences are significantly changed by amino acid replacement.
- Pseudo-wild type amino acids are those amino acids that are different from the native amino acid at a given amino acid position and replace the native residue at that position without introducing any measurable change in protein activity.
- a population of sets of nucleic acid molecules encoding a collection of mutant molecules is generated and phenotypically characterized such that proteins with amino acid sequences different from the native ones but that still elicit the same level and type of activity as the native protein are selected.
- FIG 4 shows a schematic of the "Additive Directional Mutagenesis" (ADM) methods provided herein.
- ADM is a repetitive multi- step process such that at each step a new LEAD mutation is added onto the protein being evolved. The process is repeated as many times as necessary until the total number of desired mutations is introduced on the same molecule.
- the collection of new mutant molecules is generated, tested and phenotypically characterized one-by-one in addressable arrays. Each individual mutant in the collection is designed and produced as the single product of an independent mutagenesis reaction.
- FIG. 5 depicts different levels of biological activity of a protein, designated Rep protein, super-LEADs obtained by ADM.
- Rep protein is is involved in replication of Adeno associated virus (see, e.g. , copending U.S. application Serial No. 10/022,390, published as US-2003-01 29203- A1 ). It was used to exemplify the ADM method.
- Figure 6(A) displays the sequence of the mature IFN ⁇ -2b.
- Residues targeted by a mixture of proteases including ⁇ -chymotrypsin (F, L, M, W, and Y), endoproteinase Arg-C (R), endoproteinase Asp-N (D), endoproteinase Glu-C (E), endoproteinase Lys-C (K), and trypsin (K, and R), are underlined and in bold lettering.
- FIG 6(B) shows the structure of IFNt7-2b obtained from the NMR structure of IFN ⁇ -2a (PDB Code 1 ITF) in ribbon representation. Surface residues exposed to the action of the proteases considered in FIG6A are in space filling representation.
- Figure 7 depicts the "Percent Accepted Mutation" (PAM250) matrix. Values given to identical residues are shown in gray squares. Highest values in the matrix are shown in black squares and correspond to the highest occurrence of substitution between two residues.
- PAM250 Percent Accepted Mutation
- Figure 8 presents the scores obtained from PAM250 analysis for the amino acid substitutions (replacing amino acids on the vertical axis; amino acid position on the horizontal axis) aimed at introducing resistance to proteolysis into the IFN -2b at the protease target sequences.
- the two best replacing residues for each target amino acid according to the highest substitution scores are shown in black rectangles.
- Figure 9(A) depicts a zoomed portion of a tri-dimensional protein model. Both, a loop and a ⁇ -strand in the 3-dimensional (3D) structure of the protein appear to share the same neighborhood, displaying phenylalanine, cysteine and histidine residues (F, C and H in the one-letter code, respectively).
- Figure 9(B) shows the type of residue substitutions, namely F to C, H to C, and C to H, expected to allow the creation of a disulfide bond between two cysteines located in different portions of the protein. It is important to note that the sole replacement of phenylalanine by cysteine is not sufficient to form a disulfide bond due to the separating distance between replacing residues. Disulfide bonds bring rigidity to wobbling portions eventually permitting the protein to resist heating, i.e. , thermostabilizing the protein.
- Figure 10(A) depicts a zoomed portion of a tri-dimensional protein model.
- An ⁇ -helix and a loop are linked by both a hydrogen bond and a salt bridge (dotted lines) formed between serine-histidine (S and H in the one-letter code), and arginine-glutamate residues (R and E in the one-letter code), respectively.
- Figure 10(B) shows an example of the kind of residue substitutions, namely E to A, and H to A, expected to interfere with the formation of both the hydrogen bond and the salt bridge illustrated in FIG10A.
- the lack of this linking interaction would lead to a local wobbling of protein portions, which would increase exposure of otherwise less exposed epitopes.
- Figure 1 1 shows a tri-dimensional model of an amphipathic polypeptide: human R-defensin (PDB code 1 IJV) .
- PDB code 1 IJV human R-defensin
- Its amphipathic nature is defined by the presence of two different faces in a molecule (separated by a dotted line) composed of hydrophobic and cationic (positively charged) amino acids, respectively.
- the positive charges of the cationic face in these amphipathic peptides are functionally important and are mainly due to arginine and/or lysine residues.
- Figure 1 2 illustrates the two-dimensional (2D) matrix representation of a protein sequence, wherein the vertical axis represents the amino acid present at the corresponding position indicated on the horizontal axis and the horizontal axis represents the amino acid position along the length protein sequence (such that the first cell corresponds to amino acid position No. 1 , the second cell to amino acid position No. 2, etc.).
- the matrix always contains 20 cells in one direction (the amino acid type) and a variable number of position-cells depending on the size of the protein, the number of position-cells equaling the number of amino acids in the protein sequence.
- An exemplary protein sequence is shown above the matrix and within the matrix, such that those cells corresponding to the actual sequence of the protein are indicated with shaded squares.
- Figure 13(A) shows an amphipathic peptide in a 2D matrix representation, where residues in dark gray boxes and white lettering correspond to the amino acid sequence.
- the horizontal axis corresponds to the 37-residue sequence and the vertical axis includes the 20 amino acids in the one-letter code.
- a middle horizontal line separates uncharged and charged residues.
- the first step of one particular embodiment of the 2D-scanning methods provided herein to optimize the peptide traits also is schematized.
- amino acids at all positions along the peptide sequence are sequentially replaced by either lysine or arginine residues in an attempt to further cationize and improve the amphipathic feature of the peptide.
- the outcome of the "Lys/Arg- scanning,” herein represented by the substitutions in the black box and white lettering, is a collection of molecules including the optimized number and positions of positive charges.
- Figure 1 3(B) depicts of the hypothetical combined LEADs (in light gray boxes and black lettering) resulting from the "Lys/Arg-scanning" of the peptide sequence in FIG 13A.
- Figure 1 3(C) shows the next step in the 2D-scanning methods used herein to optimize the activity of the amphipathic peptide sequence in FIG13A.
- a systematic analysis corresponding to a first in silico PAM250- based analysis followed by in vitro synthesis and testing of the mutant molecules is undertaken involving each of the uncharged residues LEAD candidates (shown in black boxes and white lettering), which neighbor the previously obtained LEADs (shown in light gray boxes and black lettering).
- Figure 13(D) represents a hypothetical optimized amphipathic peptide sequence (in light gray boxes and black lettering) corresponding to a "super-LEAD" sequence, resulting from K/R scanning and mutagenesis followed by 2D-scanning (FIGS13B through C).
- Figure 14 shows the methods provided herein for "multi-overlapped primer extensions" used for the rational combination of mutant LEADs.
- the method allows the simultaneous introduction of several mutations throughout a small protein/region of known sequence.
- Overlapping oligonucleotides of about 70 bases are designed from the DNA sequence (gene) of interest in such a way that they overlap with each other on a region of about 20 bases.
- These overlapping oligonucleotides (which can include point mutations) act as both template and primers in a first step of PCR (using a proofreading polymerase, e.g., Pfu DNA polymerase, to avoid unexpected mutations) to create small amounts of full-length gene.
- a proofreading polymerase e.g., Pfu DNA polymerase
- the full-length gene resulting from the first PCR then is selectively amplified in a second step of PCR using flanking primers, each one tagged with a restriction site in order to facilitate subsequent cloning.
- flanking primers each one tagged with a restriction site in order to facilitate subsequent cloning.
- One multi-overlapped extension process yields a full-length (multi-mutated) molecule having multiple mutations therein.
- directed evolution refers to methods that "adapt" either natural proteins, synthetic proteins or protein domains to work in new or existing natural or artificial chemical or biological environments and/or to elicit new functions and/or to increase or decrease a given activity, and/or to modulate a given feature.
- two dimensional (2D) rational mutagenesis scanning refers to the process provided herein in which two dimensions of a particular protein sequence are scanned: ( 1 ) in one dimension specific amino acid residues along the protein sequence for replacement with different amino acids are identifed; these are referred to as is-HIT target positions; and (2) in the second dimension the amino acid type for replacing a particular is-HIT target is selected, these amino acids are referred to as the replacing or replacement amino acid(s).
- in silico refers to research and experiments performed using a computer. In silico methods include, but are not limited to, molecular modeling studies, and biomolecular docking experiments.
- is-HIT refers to an in silico identified amino acid position along a target protein sequence that has been identified based on i) the particular protein properties to be evolved, ii) the protein's amino acid sequence, and/or Hi) the known properties of the individual amino acids. These is-HIT loci on the protein sequence are identified without use of experimental biological methods.
- identifying is-HITs refers to an amino acid position on a target protein, based on in silico analysis, to possess properties or features that when replaced would alter the activity being evolved.
- high-throughput screening refers to processes that test a large number of samples, such as samples of test proteins or cells containing nucleic acids encoding the proteins of interest to identify structures of interest or the identify test compounds that interact with the variant proteins or cells containing them.
- HTS operations are amenable to automation and are typically computerized to handle sample preparation, assay procedures and the subsequent processing of large volumes of data.
- the term "restricted,” when used in the context of the identification of is-HIT amino acid positions along the protein sequence selected for amino acid replacement and/or the identification of replacing amino acids, means that fewer than all amino acids on the protein-backbone are selected for amino acid replacement; and/or fewer than all of the remaining 1 9 amino acids available to replace the original amino acid present in the unmodified starting protein are selected for replacement.
- the is-HIT amino acid positions are restricted, such that fewer than all amino acids on the protein-backbone are selected for amino acid replacement.
- the replacing amino acids are restricted, such that fewer than all of the remaining 1 9 amino acids available to replace the native amino acid present in the unmodified starting protein are selected as replacing amino acids.
- both of the scans to identify is-HIT amino acid positions and the replacing amino acids are restricted, such that fewer than all amino acids on the protein-backbone are selected for amino acid replacement and fewer than all of the remaining 1 9 amino acids available to replace the native amino acid are selected for replacement.
- candidate LEADs are mutant proteins that are contemplated as potentially having an alteration in any attribute, chemical, physical or biological property in which such alteration is sought.
- candidate LEADs are generally generated by systematically replacing is-HITS loci in a protein or a domain thereof with typically a restricted subset, or all, of the remaining 1 9 amino acids, such as obtained using PAM matrix analysis and the like.
- Candidate LEADs may be generated by other methods known to those of skill in the art tested by the high throughput methods herein (see FIG1 B).
- LEADs are “candidate LEADs” whose activity has been demonstrated to be optimized or improved for the particular attribute, chemical, physical or biological property.
- a “LEAD” typically has activity with respect to the function of interest that differs by at least 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 60%, 70%, 80%, 90%, 100%, 1 50%, 200% or more from the unmodified and/or wild type (native) protein.
- the change in activity is at least about 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 60%, 70%, 80%, 90% or 100%, of the activity of the unmodified target protein.
- the change in activity is not more than about 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 60%, 70%, 80%, 90% or 100%, of the activity of the unmodified target protein.
- the change in activity is at least ab ⁇ ut 2 times, 3 times, 4 times, 5 times, 6 times, 7 times, 8 times, 9 times, 10 times, 20 times, 30 times, 40 times, 50 times, 60 times, 70- times, 80 times, 90 times, 100 times, 200 times, 300 times, 400 times, 500 times, 600 times, 700 times, 800 times, 900 times, 1000 times, or more greater than the activity of the unmodified target protein.
- the desired alteration which can be either an increase or a reduction in activity, will depend upon the function or property of interest (e.g., ⁇ 10%, ⁇ 20%, etc.).
- the LEADs may be further optimized by replacement of a plurality (2 or more) of "is-HIT" target positions on the same protein molecule to generate "super-LEADs.”
- the term "super-LEAD” refers to protein mutants
- the phrase "proteins comprising one or more single amino acid replacements" encompasses any combination of two or more of the mutations described herein for a respective protein.
- the modified proteins provided herein having one or more single amino acid replacements can have can have any combination of 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 1 1 , 1 2, 1 3, 14, 1 5, 1 6, 1 7, 1 8, 1 9, 20 or more of the amino acid replacements at the disclosed replacement positions.
- the collection of new super-LEAD mutant molecules is generated, tested and phenotypically characterized one-by-one in addressable arrays.
- Super-LEAD mutant molecules are such that each molecule contains a variable number and type of LEAD mutations. Those molecules displaying further improved fitness for the particular feature being evolved, are referred to as super-LEADs.
- Super- LEADs may be generated by other methods known to those of skill in the art and tested by the high throughput methods herein.
- a super-LEAD typically has activity with respect to the function of interest that differs from the improved activity of a LEAD by a desired amount, such as at least 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 60%, 70%, 80%, 90%, 1 00%, 1 50%, 200% or more from at least one of the LEAD mutants from which it is derived.
- the change in activity is at least about 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 60%, 70%, 80%, 90% or 100%, of the activity of the unmodified target protein. In other embodiments, the change in activity is not more than about 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 60%, 70%, 80%, 90% or 100%, of the activity of the unmodified target protein.
- the change in activity is at least about 2 times, 3 times, 4 times, 5 times, 6 times, 7 times, 8 times, 9 times, 10 times, 20 times, 30 times, 40 times, 50 times, 60 times, 70 times, 80 times, 90 times, 100 times, 200 times, 300 times, 400 times, 500 times, 600 times, 700 times, 800 times, 900 times, 1000 times, or more greater than the activity of the unmodified target protein.
- the change in the activity for super- LEADs is dependent upon the activity that is being "evolved.” The desired alteration, which can be either an increase or a reduction in activity, will depend upon the function or property of interest.
- an exposed residue presents more than 1 5% of its surface exposed to the solvent.
- the phrase "unmodified target protein,” “unmodified protein” or “unmodified cytokine, " or grammatical variations thereof, refers to a starting protein that is selected for optimization using the methods provided herein.
- the starting unmodified target protein can be the naturally occurring, wild type form of a protein.
- the starting unmodified target protein may have previously been altered or mutated, such that it differs from the native wild type isoform, but is nonetheless referred to herein as an starting unmodified target protein relative to the subsequently modified proteins produced herein.
- existing proteins known in the art that have previously been modified to have a desired increase or decrease in a particular biological activity compared to an unmodified reference protein can be selected and used herein as the starting "unmodified target protein.”
- a protein that has been modified from its native form by one or more single amino acid changes and possesses either an increase or decrease in a desired activity, such as resistance to proteolysis can be utilized with the methods provided herein as the starting unmodified target protein for further optimization- of either the same or a different biological activity.
- the phrase "only one amino acid replacement occurs on each target protein” refers to the modification of a target protein, such that it differs from the unmodified form of the target protein by a single amino acid change.
- mutagenesis is performed by the replacement of a single amino acid residue at only one is-HIT target position on the protein backbone (e.g., "one-by-one" in addressable arrays), such that each individual mutant generated is the single product of each single mutagenesis reaction.
- the single amino acid replacement mutagenesis reactions are repeated for each of the replacing amino acids selected at each of the is-HIT target positions.
- a plurality of mutant protein molecules are produced, whereby each mutant protein contains a single amino acid replacement at only one of the is-HIT target positions.
- mutant amino acids in the context of single or multiple amino acid replacements, are those amino acids that are different from the native amino acid at a given amino acid position but can replace the native one at that position without introducing any measurable change (typically a change less than 10%, 5% or 1 %, depending upon the activcity) in a particular protein activity.
- a population of sets of nucleic acid molecules encoding a collection of mutant molecules can be generated and phenotypically characterized such that proteins with amino acid sequences different from the native ones but that still elicit the same level and type of desired activity as the native protein can be produced.
- biological and pharmacological activity includes any activity of a biological pharmaceutical agent and includes, but is not limited to, resistance to proteolysis, biological efficiency, transduction efficiency, gene/transgene expression, differential gene expression and induction activity, titer, progeny productivity, toxicity, cytot ⁇ xicity, immunogenicity, cell proliferation and/or differentiation activity, anti-viral activity, morphogenetic activity, teratogenetic activity, pathogenetic activity, therapeutic activity, tumor suppressor activity, ontogenetic activity, oncogenetic activity, enzymatic activity, pharmacological activity, cell/tissue tropism and delivery.
- output signal refers to parameters that can be followed over time and, if desired, quantified.
- Output signals include, but are not limited to, enzyme activity, fluorescence, luminescence, amount of product produced and other such signals.
- Output signals include expression of a gene or gene product, including heterologous genes (transgenes) inserted into the plasmid virus.
- Output signals are a function of time ("t") and are related to the amount of protein used in the composition. For higher concentrations of protein, the output signal may be higher or lower. For any particular concentration, the output signal increases as a function of time until a plateau is reached. Output signals may also measure the interaction between cells, expressing heterologous genes, and biological agents.
- the activity of an IFN ⁇ -2b protein refers to any biological activity that can be assessed. In particular, herein, the activity assessed for the IFNc-2b proteins is resistance to proteolysis, antiviral activity and cell proliferation activity.
- the Hill equation is a mathematical model that relates the concentration of a drug (i.e. , test compound or substa nee) to the response measured
- n the slope parameter, which is 1 if the drug binds to a single site and with no cooperativity between or among sites.
- a Hill plot is log 10 of the ratio of ligand-occupied receptor to free receptor vs. log [D] (M). The slope is n, where a slope of greater than 1 indicates cooperativity among binding sites, and a slope of less than 1 can indicate heterogeneity of binding.
- ⁇ is the potency of the biological agent acting on the assay
- K is the constant of resistance of the assay system to elicit a response to a biological agent
- e is the global efficiency of the process or reaction triggered by the biological agent on the assay system
- r is the apparent titer of the biological agent
- ⁇ is the absolute titer of the biological agent
- ⁇ is the heterogeneity of the biological process or reaction.
- e is the slope at the inflexion point of the Hill curve (or, in general, of any other sigmoidal or linear approximation), to assess the efficiency of the global reaction (the biological agent and the assay system taken together) to elicit the biological or pharmacological response.
- r apparent titer is used to measure the limiting dilution or the apparent titer of the biological agent.
- ⁇ absolute titer
- ⁇ heterogeneity
- a population of sets of nucleic acid molecules encoding a collection of mutants refers to a collection of plasmids or other vehicles that carrying (encoding) the gene variants, such that individual plasmid or other vehicles carry individual gene variants.
- Each element of the collection (library) is physically separated from the others, individually set in an appropriate format, such asn addressable array, and is generated as a single product of an independent mutagenesis reaction.
- a “reporter cell” is the cell that "reports,” i.e. , undergoes the change, in response to the treatment with for example a protein or a virus.
- reporter or “reporter moiety” refers to any moiety that allows for the detection of a molecule of interest, such as a protein expressed by a cell. Reporter moieties include, but are not limited to, for example, fluorescent proteins, such as red, blue and green fluorescent proteins; LacZ and other detectable proteins and gene products.
- nucleic acid encoding the reporter moiety can be expressed as a fusion protein with a protein of interest or under to the control of a promoter of interest.
- phenotype refers to the physical, physiological or other manifestation of a genotype (a sequence of a gene). In methods herein, phenotypes that result from alteration of a genotype are assessed.
- activity means in the largest sense of the term any change in a system (either biological, chemical or physical system) of any nature (changes in the amount of product in an enzymatic reaction, changes in cell proliferation, in immunogenicity, in toxicity, and the like) caused by a protein or protein mutant when they interact with that system.
- activity means in the largest sense of the term any change in a system (either biological, chemical or physical system) of any nature (changes in the amount of product in an enzymatic reaction, changes in cell proliferation, in immunogenicity, in toxicity, and the like) caused by a protein or protein mutant when they interact with that system.
- activity higher activity or “lower activity” as used herein in reference to resistance to either proteases, proteolysis, incubation with serum or with blood, means the ratio or residual biological (antiviral) activity between “after” protease/blood or serum treatment and "before” protease/blood or serum treatment.
- activity refers to the function or property to be evolved.
- An active site refers to a site(s) responsible or that participates in conferring the activity or function.
- the activity or active site evolved (the function or property and the site conferring or participating in conferring the activity) may have nothing to do with natural activities of a protein. For example, it could be an 'active site' for conferring immunogenicity (immunogenic sites or epitopes) on a protein.
- amino acids which occur in the various amino acid sequences appearing herein, are identified according to their known, three-letter or one-letter abbreviations (see, Table 1 ) .
- nucleotides which occur in the various nucleic acid fragments, are designated with the standard single-letter designations used routinely in the art.
- amino acid residue refers to an amino acid formed upon chemical digestion (hydrolysis) of a polypeptide at its peptide linkages.
- the amino acid residues described herein are presumed to be in the "L" isomeric form. Residues in the "D" isomeric form, which are so- designated, can be substituted for any L-amino acid residue, as long as the desired functional property is retained by the polypeptide.
- NH 2 refers to the free amino group present at the amino terminus of a polypeptide.
- COOH refers to the free carboxy group present at the carboxyl terminus of a polypeptide.
- amino acid residue sequences represented herein by formulae have a left to right orientation in the conventional direction of amino-terminus to carboxyl-terminus.
- amino acid residue is broadly defined to include the amino acids listed in the Table of Correspondence (Table 1 ) and modified and unusual amino acids, such as those referred to in 37 C.F.R. ⁇ ⁇ 1 .821 -1 .822, and incorporated herein by reference.
- a dash at the beginning or end of an amino acid residue sequence indicates a peptide bond to a further sequence of one or more amino acid residues or to an amino-terminal group such as NH 2 or to a carboxyl-terminal group such as COOH.
- nucleic acids include DNA, RNA and analogs thereof, including protein nucleic acids (PNA) and mixture thereof. Nucleic acids can be single or double stranded. When referring to probes or primers, optionally labeled, with a detectable label, such as a fluorescent or radiolabel, single-stranded molecules are contemplated. Such molecules are typically of a length such that they are statistically unique of low copy number (typically less than 5, generally less than 3) for probing or priming a library. Generally a probe or primer contains at least 14, 1 6 or 30 contiguous of sequence complementary to or identical a gene of interest. Probes and primers can be 10, 14, 1 6, 20, 30, 50, 1 00 or more nucleic acid bases long.
- test polypeptide may be defined as any polypeptide that is 90% or more identical to a reference polypeptide.
- the term at least "90% identical to” refers to percent identities from 90 to 100% relative to the reference polypeptides. Identity at a level of 90% or more is indicative of the fact that, assuming for exemplification purposes a test and reference polypeptide length of 1 00 amino acids are compared. No more than 10% (i.e., 1 0 out of 100) amino acids in the test polypeptide differ from that of the reference polypeptides. Similar comparisons may be made between a test and reference polynucleotides.
- differences may be represented as point mutations randomly distributed over the entire length of an amino acid sequence or they may be clustered in one or more locations of varying length up to the maximum allowable, e.g., 10/100 amino acid difference (approximately 90% identity) . Differences are defined as nucleic acid or amino acid substitutions, or deletions.
- a therapeutically effective dose refers to that amount of the compound sufficient to result in amelioration of symptoms of disease.
- a cell extract that contains the DNA or protein of interest should be understood to mean a homogenate preparation or cell-free preparation obtained from cells that express the protein or contain the DNA of interest.
- the term "cell extract” is intended to include culture media, especially spent culture media from which the cells have been removed.
- receptor refers to a biologically active molecule that specifically binds to (or with) other molecules.
- receptor protein may be used to more specifically indicate the proteinaceous nature of a specific receptor.
- recombinant refers to any progeny formed as the result of genetic engineering.
- a promoter region refers to the portion of DNA of a gene that controls transcription of the DNA to which it is operatively linked.
- the promoter region includes specific sequences of DNA that are sufficient for RNA polymerase recognition, binding and transcription initiation. This portion of the promoter region is referred to as the promoter.
- the promoter region includes sequences that modulate this recognition, binding and transcription initiation activity of the RNA polymerase. These sequences may be cis acting or may be responsive to trans acting factors. Promoters, depending upon the nature of the regulation, may be constitutive or regulated.
- operatively linked generally means the sequences or segments have been covalently joined into one piece of DNA, whether in single or double stranded form, whereby control or regulatory sequences on one segment control or permit expression or replication or other such control of other segments.
- the two segments are not necessarily contiguous.
- a DNA sequence and a regulatory sequence(s) are connected in such a way to control or permit gene expression when the appropriate molecular, e.g., transcriptional activator proteins, are bound to the regulatory sequence(s).
- a composition refers to any mixture of two or more products or compounds. It may be a solution, a suspension, liquid, powder, a paste, aqueous, non-aqueous or any combination thereof.
- a combination refers to any association between two or more items.
- substantially identical to a product means sufficiently similar so that the property of interest is sufficiently unchanged so that the substantially identical product can be used in place of the product.
- vector refers to a nucleic acid molecule capable of transporting another nucleic acid to which it has been linked.
- One type of vector is an episome, i.e., a nucleic acid capable of extra-chromosomal replication.
- Exemplary vectors are those capable of autonomous replication and/or expression of nucleic acids to which they are linked.
- Vectors capable of directing the expression of genes to which they are operatively linked are referred to herein as "expression vectors.”
- expression vectors of utility in recombinant DNA techniques are often in the form of "plasmids" which refer generally to circular double stranded DNA loops which, in their vector form are not bound to the chromosome. "Plasmid” and “vector” are used interchangeably as the plasmid is the most commonly used form of vector. Other such other forms of expression vectors that serve equivalent functions and that become known in the art subsequently hereto.
- vector also is used interchangeable with "virus vector” or “viral vector.”
- virus vector or "viral vector.”
- the "vector” is not self-replicating.
- Viral vectors are engineered viruses that are operatively linked to exogenous genes to transfer (as vehicles or shuttles) the exogenous genes into cells.
- transduction refers to the process of gene transfer and expression into mammalian and other cells mediated by viruses.
- Transfection refers to the process when mediated by plasmids.
- transformation refers to the process of gene transfer and expression into bacterial cells, mediated by plasmids.
- allele which is used interchangeably herein with “allelic variant” refers to alternative forms of a gene or portions thereof. Alleles occupy the same locus or position on homologous chromosomes. When a subject has two identical alleles of a gene, the subject is said to be homozygous for the gene or allele. When a subject has two different alleles of a gene, the subject is said to be heterozygous for the gene. Alleles of a specific gene can differ from each other in a single nucleotide, or several nucleotides, and can include substitutions, deletions, and insertions of nucleotides. An allele of a gene also can be a form of a gene containing a mutation.
- gene refers to a nucleic acid molecule comprising an open reading frame and including at least one exon and (optionally) an intron sequence.
- a gene can be either RNA or DNA. Genes may include regions preceding and following the coding region (leader and trailer).
- intron refers to a DNA sequence present in a given gene which is spliced out during mRNA maturation.
- nucleotide sequence complementary to the nucleotide sequence set forth in SEQ ID NO: refers to the nucleotide sequence of the complementary strand of a nucleic acid strand having the particular SEQ ID NO:.
- complementary strand is used herein interchangeably with the term “complement.”
- the complement of a nucleic acid strand can be the complement of a coding strand or the complement of a non-coding strand.
- the complement of a nucleic acid having a particular SEQ ID NO: refers to the complementary strand of the strand set forth in the particular SEQ ID NO: or to any nucleic acid having the nucleotide sequence of the complementary strand of the particular SEQ ID NO:.
- the complement of this nucleic acid is a nucleic acid having a nucleotide sequence which is complementary to that of the particular SEQ ID NO:.
- coding sequence refers to that portion of a gene that encodes an amino acid sequence of a protein.
- sense strand refers to that strand of a double-stranded nucleic acid molecule that has the sequence of the mRNA that encodes the amino acid sequence encoded by the double- stranded nucleic acid molecule.
- antisense strand refers to that strand of a double-stranded nucleic acid molecule that is the complement of the sequence of the mRNA that encodes the amino acid sequence encoded by the double-stranded nucleic acid molecule.
- an array refers to a collection of elements, such as nucleic acid molecules, containing three or more members.
- An addressable array is one in which the members of the array are identifiable, typically by position on a solid phase support or by virtue of an identifiable or detectable label, such as by color, fluorescence, electronic signal (i.e. , RF, microwave or other frequency that does not substantially alter the interaction of the molecules of interest), bar code or other symbology, chemical or other such label.
- the members of the array are immobilized to discrete identifiable loci on the surface of a solid phase or directly or indirectly linked to or otherwise associated with the identifiable label, such as affixed to a microsphere or other particulate support (herein referred to as beads) and suspended in solution or spread out on a surface.
- a microsphere or other particulate support herein referred to as beads
- a library of molecules is a collection of molecules; the terms are used interchangeably.
- a support also referred to as a matrix support, a matrix, an insoluble support or solid support
- a molecule of interest typically a biological molecule, organic molecule or biospecific ligand is linked or contacted.
- Such materials include any materials that are used as affinity matrices or supports for chemical and biological molecule syntheses and analyses, such as, but are not limited to: polystyrene, polycarbonate, polypropylene, nylon, glass, dextran, chitin, sand, pumice, agarose, polysaccharides, dendrimers, buckyballs, polyacryl-amide, silicon, rubber, and other materials used as supports for solid phase syntheses, affinity separations and purifications, hybridization reactions, immunoassays and other such applications.
- the matrix herein can be particulate or can be in the form of a continuous surface, such as a microtiter dish or well, a glass slide, a silicon chip, a nitrocellulose sheet, nylon mesh, or other such materials.
- the particles When particulate, typically the particles have at least one dimension in the 5-10 mm range or smaller.
- Such particles referred collectively herein as "beads,” are often, but not necessarily, spherical. Such reference, however, does not constrain the geometry of the matrix, which may be any shape, including random shapes, needles, fibers, and elongated. Roughly spherical "beads,” particularly microspheres that can be used in the liquid phase, also are contemplated.
- the “beads” may include additional components, such as magnetic or paramagnetic particles (see, e.g. , Dynabeads (Dynal, Oslo, Norway)) for separation ⁇ using magnets, as long as the additional components do not interfere with the methods and analyses herein.
- a matrix or support particles refers to matrix materials that are in the form of discrete particles.
- the particles have, any shape and dimensions, but typically have at least one dimension that is 100 mm or less, 50 mm or less, 10 mm or less, 1 mm or less, 1 00 ⁇ m or less, 50 ⁇ m or less and typically have a size that is 100 mm 3 or less, 50 mm 3 or less, 1 0 mm 3 or less, and 1 mm 3 or less, 100 ⁇ m 3 or less and may be order of cubic microns.
- Such particles are collectively called "beads.”
- the abbreviations for any protective groups, amino acids and other compounds are, unless indicated otherwise, in accord with their common usage, recognized abbreviations, or the IUPAC-IUB Commission on Biochemical Nomenclature (see, Biochem. , 1 1 :942-944, 1 972).
- Random mutagenesis methodology requires that the amino acids in the starting protein sequence are replaced by all (or a group) of the 20 amino acids. Either single or multiple replacements at different amino acid positions are generated on the same molecule, at the same time.
- the random mutagenesis method relies on a direct search for fitness improvement based on random amino acid replacement and sequence changes at multiple amino acid positions. In this approach neither the amino acid position (first dimension) nor the amino acid type (second dimension) are restricted; and everything possible is generated and tested. Multiple replacements can randomly happen at the same time on the same molecule.
- random mutagenesis methods are widely used to develop antibodies with higher affinity for its ligand, by the generation of random-sequence libraries of antibody molecules, followed by expression and screening using filamentous phages.
- Restricted random mutagenesis methods introduce either all of the 20 amino acids or DNA-biased residues, wherein the bias is based on the sequence of the DNA and not on that of the protein, in a stochastic or semi-stochastic manner, respectively, within restricted or predefined regions of the protein, known in advance to be involved in the biological activity being "evolved.”
- This method relies on a direct search for fitness improvement based on random amino acid replacement and sequence changes at either restricted or multiple amino acid positions, with the hope that a new, unpredictable amino acid sequence at specific regions would perform better than the starting sequence.
- the scanning can be restricted to selected amino acid positions and/or amino acid types, while material changes continue to be random in position and type.
- the amino acid position can be restricted by prior selection of the target region to be mutated (selection of target region is based upon prior knowledge on protein structure/function); while the amino acid type is not primarily restricted as replacing amino acids are stochastically or at most "semi-stochastically" chosen.
- this method is used to optimize known binding sites on proteins, including hormone-receptor systems and antibody-epitope systems. 3) Non-restricted Rational mutagenesis
- Rational mutagenesis is a two-step process and is described in co- pending U.S. application Serial No. 10/022,249. Briefly, the first step requires amino acid scanning where all and each of the amino acids in the starting protein sequence are replaced by a third amino acid of reference (e.g., alanine) . Only a single amino acid is replaced on each protein molecule at a time; while a collection of protein molecules having a single amino acid replacement is generated such that molecules are differentiated by the amino acid position at which the replacement has taken place.
- Mutant DNA molecules are designed, generated by mutagenesis and cloned individually, such as in addressable arrays, such that they are physically separated from each other and that each one is the single product of an independent mutagenesis reaction. Mutant protein molecules derived from the collection of mutant DNA molecules also are physically separated from each other, such as by formatting in addressable arrays.
- Activity assessment on each protein molecule allows for the identification of those amino acid positions that result in a drop in activity when replaced, thus indicating the involvement of that particular amino acid position in the protein's biological activity and/or conformation that leads to fitness of the particular feature being evolved. Those amino acid positions are referred to as HITs.
- HITs Those amino acid positions are referred to as HITs.
- a new collection of molecules is generated such that each molecule differs from each other by the amino acid present at the individual HIT positions identified in step 1 . All 20 amino acids (1 9 amino acids and the original) are introduced at each of the HIT positions identified in step 1 ; while each individual molecule contains, in principle, one and only one amino acid replacement.
- Mutant DNA molecules are designed, generated by mutagenesis and cloned individually, such as in addressable arrays, such that they are physically separated from each other and that each one is the single product of an independent mutagenesis reaction.
- Mutant protein molecules derived from the collection of mutant DNA molecules also are physically separated from each other and can be formatted in addressable arrays.
- LEADs LEADs
- 2-Dimensional Scanning Provided herein are 2-Dimensional rational scanning (or "2D- scanning") methods for protein rational evolution that are based on scanning over two dimensions: (1 ) one dimension is the amino acid position along the protein sequence to identify is-HIT target positions, and (2) the second dimension is the amino acid type selected for replacing the particular is-HIT amino acid position.
- a number of target positions along the protein sequence are selected, in silico, "as is-HIT target positions.” This number of is-HIT target positions is as large as possible such that all reasonably possible target positions for the particular feature being evolved are included.
- the amino acids selected to replace the is-HIT target positions on the particular protein being optimized can be either all of the remaining 1 9 amino acids or, more frequently, a more restricted group comprising selected amino acids that are contemplated to have the desired effect on protein activity.
- all of the amino acid positions along the protein backbone can be selected as is-HIT target positions for amino acid replacement.
- Mutagenesis then is performed by the replacement of single amino acid residues at specific is-HIT target positions on the protein backbone (e.g., "one-by-one" in addressable arrays), such that each individual mutant generated is the single product of each single mutagenesis reaction.
- Mutant DNA molecules are designed, generated by mutagenesis and cloned individually, in addressable arrays, such that they are physically separated from each other and that each one is the single product of an independent mutagenesis reaction.
- Mutant protein molecules derived from the collection of mutant DNA molecules also are physically separated from each other and can be formatted in addressable arrays. Thus, a plurality of mutant protein molecules are produced, whereby each mutant protein contains a single amino acid replacement at only one of the is-HIT target positions.
- Activity assessment then is individually performed on each individual protein mutant molecule, following protein expression and measurement of the appropriate activity, such as set forth in the Examples provided herein for optimization of IFNcr- 2b.
- the newly generated sequences that lead to an improvement in the protein activity are referred to as LEADs.
- This method relies on an indirect search for protein improvement for a particular activity, such as increased resistance to proteolysis, based on a rational amino acid replacement and sequence change at single or, in another embodiment, a limited number of amino acid positions at a time.
- optimized proteins having newly discovered amino acid sequences at some regions along the protein that perform better than the starting sequence are identified and isolated.
- a variety of protein properties and/or biological activities can be modified using the rational mutagenesis methods provided herein, such as an increase or decrease in protein stability, the optimal pH or pH-activity of a protein, protein digestibility, protein thermostablization, protein antigenicity, the amphipathic properties of a protein, ligand-receptor interactions of a protein.
- An advantage of the 2D-scanning methods provided herein is that at least one, and typically both, of the two dimensions for scanning (amino acid position and the replacing amino acid) are restricted. This means that fewer than all amino acids on the protein-backbone are selected for amino acid replacement; and/or fewer than all of the remaining 1 9 amino acids available to replace the original, such as native, amino acid are selected for replacement.
- the 2D-scanning methods provided herein are not limited to a restrictive number of selected target amino acid positions; instead the entire length of the protein is "scanned” or checked, in silico, to identify candidate amino acid positions amenable to improving the desired activity, wherein these positions are designated “in s/7/co HITs" ("is-HITs") .
- Each possible amino acid and amino acid position that might be involved in the feature being evolved is identified and referred to herein as "is-HITs.”
- the methods provided herein are not limited to only those amino acid positions that would be the preferred candidates based on either existing algorithms, previous knowledge or intuition (this would be purely predictive). Neither do the methods provided herein replace every amino acid position along the protein (this would be purely random or stochastic).
- the next step involves identifying the amino acids that will be used to replace them at the respective is-HITs in the natural unmodified sequence.
- the methods provided herein are not limited to a restrictive number of preferred replacing amino acids; instead all possible replacing amino acids are "tested" for each possible target position, or said the other way around, each is-HIT position is "scanned” for all possible candidate replacing amino acids.
- the methods are not restricted to only those amino acids that would be the preferred candidates based on existing algorithms, knowledge or intuition (this would be purely predictive). Neither do the methods provided herein replace every one of the remaining 19 amino acids as replacing amino acids (this would be purely random or stochastic).
- an amino acid-scanning step would be performed, in order to identify those amino acid positions (HITs) that would be involved in the determination of the optimal pH.
- suitable amino acids would have been identified such that when put at the HIT positions lead to a change in optimal pH.
- the is-HITs amino acid positions that may either affect optimal pH or are otherwise related to pH- activity are identified. This is done solely based on the primary amino acid sequence.
- the is-HITs will, in principle, be located at every position along the protein sequence where there is an amino acid susceptible to be either proton donor or proton acceptor. Each and every one of those amino acids is considered potentially involved in the determination of the optimal pH. No other assumptions are made. These is-HITs are chosen independently from any assumptions based on protein structure; the choice, in the example, is based only on intrinsic properties of the individual amino acids. These amino acids positions (target positions) are taken to the next step in the process as is-HITs.
- a collection of physical (i.e., this step is not "in silico") "candidate LEAD" mutant molecules is generated such that each candidate LEAD molecule differs from each other by the amino acid present at one or more is-HIT positions.
- all 20 amino acids may be introduced at each of the is-HIT positions; while each individual molecule contains, in principle, either only one or a few amino acid replacements at different is-HIT positions.
- only a restricted group of amino acids could be used to replace the original amino acids at the is-HIT positions.
- replacing amino acids are chosen based on their intrinsic properties: i.e., in our example of the optimal pH, the subset of replacing amino acids would be restricted to only those amino acids able to function as either a proton donor or a proton receptor.
- the 2D rational scanning methods provided herein still maintain the value of performing a "blinded" screening, that is observed in the other three approaches; although it is more conditioned by previous knowledge of amino acid properties, in the sense that it relies on a higher number of assumptions and hypotheses. This effect is partially countered by the fact that as many alternative is-HIT positions as possible, identified based on different criteria (helix-turn disruption, hydrophobicity, and other parameters), are covered.
- the number of different replacing amino acids is kept as large as reasonably possible, up to all the 20 amino acids (at each position), whenever appropriate.
- the 2D-scanning method provided herein is extremely rich in its potential for exploring unexpected and innovative amino acid sequences, while at the same time, being highly efficient in terms of attrition rate between mutants generated and LEAD molecules obtained.. Given the number of different candidate LEAD protein molecules that are generated (e.g., a few thousands per collection), a high-throughput screening is typically necessary. 1 ) Identifying In-silico HITs
- the 2D-scanning methods use the following two-steps.
- the first step is an in silico search on the particular protein's amino acid sequence to identify all possible amino acid positions that can potentially be targets for the activity being evolved. This is effected, for example, by assessing the effect of amino acid residues on the property or properties to be altered on the protein, using standard software.
- the particulars of the in silico analysis is a function of the property to be modified.
- the property improved is the resistance of a protein to proteolysis.
- amino acid residues that are potential targets as is-HITs in this example, all possible target residues for proteases are first identified.
- the 3-dimensional structure of the protein is the considered in order to identify surface residues. Comparison of exposed residues with proteolytically cleavable residues yields residues that are targets for change.
- is-HITs in silico HITs; FIG 1A
- silico HITs are defined as those amino acid positions (or target positions) that potentially are involved in the "evolving" feature, such as increased resistance to proteolysis.
- the discrimination of the is-HITs among all the amino acid positions in a protein sequence is made based on /) the amino acid type at each position in addition to, whenever available but not necessarily, ii) the information on the protein secondary or tertiary structure.
- silico HITs constitute a collection of mutant molecules such that all possible amino acids, amino acid positions or target sequences potentially involved in the evolving feature are represented. No strong theoretical discrimination among amino acids or amino acid positions is made at this stage.
- silico HIT positions are spread over the full length of a protein sequence.
- only one single is-HIT amino acid at a time is replaced on the target protein.
- a limited number of is-HIT amino acids are replaced at the same time on the same target protein molecule.
- the selection of target regions (is-HITs and surrounding amino acids) for the second step is based upon rational assumptions and predictions. No prior knowledge of protein structure/function is necessary.
- the use of the 2D-scanning methodology provided herein does not necessarily require any previous knowledge of the 3-dimensional conformational structure of the protein.
- cytokines e.g., IFN ⁇ -2b
- any other proteins that have already been mutated or optimized.
- a variety of parameters can be analyzed to determine whether or not a particular amino acid on a protein might be involved in the evolving feature. For example, the information provided by crystal structures of proteins can be rationally exploited in order to perform a computer- assisted (in silico) analysis towards the prediction of variants with desired features.
- a limited number of initial premises typically no more than 2 are used, to determine the in silico HITS.
- the number of premises used to determine the in silico HITs can range from 1 to 10 premises, including no more than 9, no more than 8, no more than 7, no more than 6, no more than 5, no more than 4, no more than 3, but are typically no more than 2 premises.
- the number of initial premises be kept to a minimum, so as to maintain the number of potential is-HITs at a maximum (here is where the methods provided are not limited by too much prediction based on theoretical assumptions).
- the first condition is typically the amino acid type itself, which is directly linked to the nature of the evolving feature. For example, if the goal were to change the optimum pH for an enzyme, then the replacing-amino acids selected at this step for the replacement of original sequence would be only those with a certain pKa value.
- the second premise is typically related to the specific position of those amino acids along the protein structure. For example, some amino acids might be discarded if they are not expected to be exposed enough to the solvent, even when they might have appropriate pKa values.
- each individual amino acid along the protein sequence is considered individually to assess whether it is a candidate for is-HIT.
- This search is done one-by-one and the decision on whether the amino acid is considered to be a candidate for a is-HIT is based on (1 ) the amino acid type itself; (2) the position on the amino acid sequence and protein structure if known; and (3) the predicted interaction between that amino acid and its neighbors in sequence and space.
- is-HITs can be readily identified on the remaining proteins within the particular family by identifying the corresponding amino acid positions therein using a structural homology analysis (see, co-pending U.S. application Serial No. 923, filed the same day herewith) .
- the is-HITs identified in this manner can then be subjected to the next step of identifying replacing amino acids and further assayed to obtain LEADs or super-LEADs as described herein.
- the next step is identifying those amino acids that will replace the original, such as native, amino acid at each is-HIT position to alter the activity level for the particular feature being evolved.
- the set of replacing amino acids to be used to replace the original, such as native, amino acid at each is-HIT position can be different and specific for the particular is- HIT position.
- the choice of the replacing amino acids takes into account the need to preserve the physicochemical properties such as hydrophobicity, charge and polarity, of essential (e.g., catalytic, binding, etc.) residues.
- the number of replacing amino acids, of the remaining 1 9 non-native (or non-original) amino acids, that can be used to replace a particular is-HIT target position ranges from 1 up to about 1 9, from 1 up to about 1 5, from 1 up to about 10, from 1 up to about 9, from 1 up to about 8, from 1 up to about 7, from 1 up to about 6, from 1 up to about 5, from 1 up to about 4, from 1 up to about 3, or from 1 to 2 amino acid replacements.
- Protein chemists determined that certain amino acid substitutions commonly occur in related proteins from different species. As the protein still functions with these substitutions, the substituted amino acids are compatible with protein structure and function. Often, these substitutions are to a chemically similar amino acid, but other types of changes, although relatively rare, also can occur.
- Amino acid substitution matrices are used for this purpose.
- amino acids are listed across the top of a matrix and down the side, and each matrix position is filled with a score that reflects how often one amino acid would have been paired with the other in an alignment of related protein sequences.
- the probability of changing amino acid A into amino acid B is assumed to be identical to the reverse probability of changing B into A. This assumption is made because, for any two sequences, the ancestor amino acid in the phylogenetic tree is usually not known.
- amino acid frequencies will not change over evolutionary time (Dayhoff et al. , Atlas of Protein Sequence and Structure, 5(3) :345-352, 1 978).
- amino acid substitution matrices including, but not limited to block substitution matrix (BLOSUM), Jones, Gonnet, Fitch, Feng, McLachlan, Grantham, Miyata, Rao, Risler, Johnson and percent accepted mutation (PAM) . Any such method known to those of skill in the art can be employed.
- PAM Percent Accepted Mutation
- PAM Percent Accepted Mutation
- PAM matrices were originally developed to produce alignments between protein sequences based evolutionary distances (see FIG7) . Because, in a family of proteins or homologous (related) sequences, identical or similar amino acids (85 % similarity) are shared, conservative substitutions for, or "allowed point mutations" of the corresponding amino acid residues can be determined throughout an aligned reference sequence.
- conservative amino acid substitutions are those substitutions that are physically and functionally similar to the corresponding reference residues, e.g ., that have a similar size, shape, electric charge, chemical properties, including the ability to form covalent or hydrogen bonds, or the like.
- Particularly suitable conservative amino acid substitutions are those that show the highest scores and fulfill the PAM matrix criteria in the form of "accepted point mutations.” For example, by comparing a family of scoring matrices, Dayhoff et al. , Atlas of Protein Sequence and Structure, 5(3):345-352, 1978, found a consistently higher score significance when using PAM250 matrix to analyze a variety of proteins, known to be distantly related.
- the PAM250 matrix set forth in FIG7 is used for determining the replacing amino acids based on "similarity" criteria.
- the PAM250 matrix uses data obtained directly from natural evolution to facilitate the selection of replacing amino acids for the is-HITs to generate conservative mutations without much affecting the overall protein function.
- candidate replacing amino acids are identified from related proteins from different organisms.
- Jones and Gonnet This method (see, e.g. , Jones et al , Comput.
- Fitch, J. Mol. Evol , 1 6(1 ):9-1 6, 1 966 used an exchange matrix that contained for each pair (A, B) of amino acid types the minimum number of nucleotides that must be changed to encode amino acid A instead of amino acid B.
- Feng et a J. Mol. Evol , 21: 1 1 2-125, 1 985, used an enhanced version of Fitch, J. Mol. Evol , 1 6(1 ):9-1 6, 1 966, to build a Structure-Genetic matrix.
- this method also considers the structural similarity of the amino acids.
- Rao Rao J. Pept. Protein Res. , 29:276-281 , 1 987, employs five amino acid properties to create a matrix; namely, alpha-helical, beta-strand and reverse-turn propensities as well as polarity and hydrophobicity. The standardized properties were summed and the matrix rescaled to the same average as that for PAM (Dayhoff et al , Atlas of Protein Sequence and Structure, 5(3) :345-352, 1978) .
- Risler 5 amino acid properties to create a matrix; namely, alpha-helical, beta-strand and reverse-turn propensities as well as polarity and hydrophobicity. The standardized properties were summed and the matrix rescaled to the same average as that for PAM (Dayhoff et al , Atlas of Protein Sequence and Structure, 5(3) :345-352, 1978) .
- BLOSUM blocks amino acid substitution matrix
- these matrices are directly calculated without extrapolations, and are analogous to transition probability matrices P(T) for different values of T, estimated without reference to any rate matrix Q.
- the outcome of these two steps set forth above, which is performed in silico is that: (1 ) the amino acid positions that will be the target for mutagenesis are identified; these positions are referred to as is- HITs; (2) the replacing amino acids for the original, such as native, amino acids at the is-HITs are identified, thus providing a collection (library) of candidate LEAD mutant molecules that are expected to perform better than the native one and that are assayed for the desired optimized biological activity.
- Mutant proteins typically are prepared using recombinant DNA methods and assessed in appropriate biological assays for the particular biological activity (feature) optimized (see, e.g. , Example 1 and FIG5) .
- An exemplary method of preparing the mutant proteins is by mutagenesis of the original, such as native, gene using methods well known in the art. Mutant molecules are generated one-by-one, such as in addressable arrays, such that each individual mutant generated is the single product of each single and independent mutagenesis reaction. Individual mutagenesis reactions are conducted such that they are physically separated from each other, for example, in addressable arrays.
- each set of nucleic acid molecules encoding a respective mutant protein is introduced into cells confined to a discrete location, such as in a well of a multi-well microtiter plate.
- Each individual mutant protein is individually phenotypically characterized and performance is quantitatively assessed using assays appropriate for the feature being optimized (i.e., feature being evolved). Again, this step can be performed in addressable arrays. Those mutants displaying a desired increased or decreased performance compared to the original, such as native molecules are identified and designated LEADs.
- each candidate LEAD mutant can be generated, produced and analyzed individually from its own address in an addressable array.
- Super-LEAD mutant proteins contain a combination of single amino acid mutations present in two or more of the respective LEAD mutant proteins.
- the LEAD mutant proteins can be generated by the 2D scanning methods provided herein or by other methods known to those of skill in the art.
- Super-LEAD mutant proteins have two of more of the single amino acid mutations derived from two or more of the respective LEAD mutant proteins.
- LEAD mutant proteins provided are defined as mutants whose performance or fitness has been optimized with respect to the native protein. LEADs typically contain one single mutation relative to its respective native protein. This mutation represents an appropriate amino acid replacement that takes place at one is-HIT position.
- Super-LEAD mutant proteins are created such that they carry on the same protein molecule, more than one LEAD mutation, each at a different is-HIT position (see FIG3A).
- super-LEADs can be generated by combining two or more individual LEAD mutant mutations using any method known in the art. These methods, include recombination, mutagenesis and DNA shuffling and any others known to those of skill in the art and/or provided herein, such as additive directional mutagenesis and multi-overlapped primer extensions.
- Additive Directional Mutagenesis Also provided herein are methods for assembling on a single mutant protein multiple mutations present on the individual LEAD molecules, so as to generate super-LEAD mutant proteins. This method is referred to herein as "Additive Directional Mutagenesis" (ADM; see FIG4).
- ADM comprises a repetitive multi-step process where at each step after the creation of the first LEAD mutant protein a new LEAD mutation is added onto the previous LEAD mutant protein to create successive super- LEAD mutant proteins.
- ADM is not based on genetic recombination mechanisms, nor on shuffling methodologies; instead it is a simple one- mutation-at-a-time process, repeated as many times as necessary until the total number of desired mutations is introduced on the same molecule.
- combinatorial is used here in its mathematical meaning (i.e., subsets of a group of elements, containing some of the elements in any possible order) and not in the molecular biological or directed evolution meaning (i.e., generating pools, or mixtures, or collections of molecules by randomly mixing their constitutive elements).
- super- LEAD mutant molecules A population of sets of nucleic acid molecules encoding a collection of new super-LEAD mutant molecules is generated, tested and phenotypically characterized one-by-one in addressable arrays, super- LEAD mutant molecules are such that each molecule contains a variable number and type of LEAD mutations. Those molecules displaying further improved fitness for the particular feature being evolved, are referred to as super-LEADs.
- Super-LEADs may be generated by other methods known to those of skill in the art and tested by the high throughput methods herein.
- a super-LEAD typically has activity with respect to the function or biological activity of interest that differs from the improved activity of a LEAD by a desired amount, such as at least 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 60%, 70%, 80%, 90%, 100%, 1 50%, 200% or more from at least one of the LEAD mutants from which it is derived.
- the change in activity is at least about 2 times, 3 times, 4 times, 5 times, 6 times, 7 times, 8 times, 9 times, 10 times, 20 times, 30 times, 40 times, 50 times, 60 times, 70 times, 80 times, 90 times, 100 times, 200 times, 300 times, 400 times, 500 times, 600 times, 700 times, 800 times, 900 times, 1 000 times, or more greater than at least one of the LEAD molecules from which it is derived.
- the change in the activity for super-LEADs is dependent upon the activity that is being "evolved.” The desired alteration, which can be either an increase or a reduction in activity, will depend upon the function or property of interest.
- the ADM method employs a number of repetitive steps, such that at each step a new mutation is added on a given molecule.
- new mutations e.g., mutation 1 (ml ), mutation 2 (m2), mutation 3 (m3), mutation 4 (m4), mutation 5 (m5), mutation n (mn)
- an exemplary way the new mutations can be added corresponds to the following diagram: ml ml +m2 m1+m2 +m3 ml +m2+m3 +m4 ml +m2 + m3 +m4+m5 ml +m2 +m3+m4+m5 + ...+mn ml +m2+ m4 m1+m2 +m4+m5 ml +m2 + m4+ m5 + ...
- Another method for generation of super leads is multi-overlapped primier extensions.
- This is a method for the rational evolution of proteins using oligonucleotide-mediated mutagenesis. This method is particularly useful for the rational combination of mutant LEADs to form super-LEADs (see FIG 14) .
- This method allows the simultaneous introduction of several mutations throughout a small protein or protein-region of known sequence (see, e.g., FIGS13A through D) .
- Overlapping oligonucleotides of typically around 70 bases in length are designed from the DNA sequence (gene) encoding the mutant LEAD proteins in such a way that they overlap with each other on a region of typically around 20 bases.
- overlapping oligonucleotides act as both template and primers in a first step of PCR (using a proofreading polymerase, e.g., Pfu DNA polymerase, to avoid unexpected mutations) to create small amounts of full-length gene.
- the full-length gene resulting from the first PCR then is selectively amplified in a second step of PCR using flanking primers, each one tagged with a restriction site in order to facilitate subsequent cloning.
- One multi-overlapped extension process yields a full-length (multi- mutated) nucleic acid molecule encoding a candidate super-LEADs protein having multiple mutations therein derived from LEAD mutant proteins.
- the length of additional overlapping oligonucleotides for use herein can range from about 30 bases up to about 100 bases, from about 40 bases up to about 90 bases, from about 50 bases up to about 80 bases, from about 60 bases up to about 75 bases, and from about 65 bases up to about 75 bases.
- typically about 70 bases are used herein.
- the length of other overlapping regions for use herein can range from about 5 bases up to about 40 bases, from about 10 bases up to about 35 bases, from about 1 5 bases up to about 35 bases, from about 1 5 bases up to about 25 bases, from about 1 6 bases up to about 24 bases, from about 17 bases up to about 23 bases, from about 1 8 bases up to about 22 bases, and from about 1 9 bases up to about 21 bases.
- typically about 20 bases are used herein for the overlapping region.
- the 2D methods provided herein are used to alter activity or physical or chemical property of a target polypeptide. Any characteristic
- the protein is selected and the property identified.
- the methods of 2-D scanning permit preparation of proteins modified for a selected trait, activity or other phenotype.
- modifications of interest for therapeutic proteins are those that increase protection against protease digestion while maintaining the requisite biological activity.
- Such changes are useful for producing longer-lasting therapeutic proteins.
- the delivery of stable peptide and protein drugs to patients is a major challenge for the pharmaceutical industry. These types of drugs in the human body are constantly eliminated or taken out of circulation by different physiological processes including internalization, glomerular filtration and proteolysis. The latter is often the limiting process affecting the half-life of proteins used as therapeutic agents in per-oral administration and either intravenous or intramuscular injections.
- the 2D-scanning process provided herein for protein evolution is used to effectively improve protein resistance to proteases and thus increase protein half-life in vitro and, ultimately in vivo.
- the methods provided herein for designing and generating highly stable, longer lasting proteins, or proteins having a longer half-life include: i) identifying some or all possible target sites on the protein sequence that are susceptible to digestion by one or more specific proteases (these sites are referred to herein as is-HITs); ii) identifying appropriate replacing amino acids, specific for each is-HIT, such that upon replacement of one or more of the original, such as native, amino acids at that specific is-HIT, they can be expected to increase the is-HIT's resistance to digestion by protease while at the same time, maintaining or improving the requisite biological activity of the protein (these proteins with replaced amino acids are the "candidate LEADs"); Hi) systematically introducing the specific replacing amino acids at every specific is-HIT target position to generate a collection of candidate LEADs containing the corresponding mutant
- mutant molecules also can be generated that contain one or more amino acids at one or more is-HIT sites that have been replaced by candidate LEAD amino acids.
- Those mutant proteins carrying one or more mutations at one or more is-HITs, and that display improved protease resistance are called LEADs (one mutation at one is-HIT) and super-LEADs (mutations at more than one is-HIT) .
- the first step of the process takes into consideration existing knowledge from different domains. Such knowledge includes:
- protease mixtures in the body are quite complex in composition, almost all the residues in a selected protein sequence potentialy could be targeted for proteolysis (FIG6A). Nevertheless, proteins form specific tri-dimensional structures where residues are more or less exposed to the environment and protease action. It can be assumed that those residues constituting the core of a protein are inaccessible to proteases, while those more "exposed” to the environment are better targets for proteases. The probability for every specific amino acid to be "exposed” and accessible to proteases can be taken into account to reduce the number of is-HITs. Consequently, the methods herein consider the analysis with respect to solvent "exposure” or "accessibility" for each individual amino acid in the protein sequence.
- fractional probabilities determined for an amino acid (i) found on the surface of a protein, which are based upon structural data from a set of several proteins. It is thus possible to calculate the solvent accessibility (A) of an amino acid (A(i)) at sequence position (i-2 to i + 3, onto a sliding window of length equal to 6) that is within an average surface accessible to solvent of > 20 square angstroms (A 2 ).
- protease accessible target amino acids along the protein sequence i.e., the amino acids to be replaced
- is-HITs silico HITs
- Amino acids at the is-HITs are then replaced by residues that render the protein less vulnerable or invulnerable to protease digestion while at the same time maintaining the biological activity of the protein.
- the choice of the replacing amino acids is complicated by (1 ) the broad target specificity of certain proteases and (2) the need to preserve the physicochemical properties such as hydrophobicity, charge and polarity, of essential (e.g., catalytic, binding, etc.) residues.
- amino acids can be selected by use of the "Percent Accepted Mutation” (PAM; (Dayhoff et al , Atlas of Protein Sequence and Structure, 5(3):345-352, 1978), FIGS7 and 8).
- PAM values originally developed to produce alignments between protein sequences, are available in the form of probability matrices, which reflect an evolutionary distance. Since, in a family of proteins or homologous (related) proteins, identical or similar amino acids (85% similarity) are shared, conservative substitutions for, or "allowed point mutations" of the corresponding amino acid residues can be determined throughout an aligned reference sequence.
- “conservative substitutions” of a residue in a reference sequence are those substitutions that are physically and functionally similar to the corresponding reference residues, e.g., that have a similar size, shape, electric charge, chemical properties, including the ability to form covalent or hydrogen bonds, and other propers.
- Conservative substitutions can be those that exhibit the highest scores and fulfill the PAM matrix criteria in the form of "accepted point mutations".
- the PAM250 matrix was selected for use.
- the PAM250 matrix is used, by learning directly from natural evolution, to find replacing amino acids for the is-HITs to generate conservative mutations without affecting the protein function.
- candidate replacing amino acids are identified from related proteins from different organisms.
- Rational Evolution of IFN -2b for Increased Resistance to Proteolysis IFN ⁇ -2b is used for a variety of applications. Typically it is used for treatment of type B and C chronic hepatitis. Additional indications include, but are not limited to, melanomas, herpes infections, Kaposi sarcomas and some leukemia and lymphoma cases. Patients receiving interferon are subject to frequent repeat applications of the drug.
- mutant variants of the IFN ⁇ r -2b protein that display (a) highly improved stability as assessed by resistance to proteases in vitro and by pharmacokinetics studies in mice and (b) at least comparable biological activity as assessed by antiviral and antiproliferative action compared to the unmodified and wild type native IFN -2b protein and to at least one pegylated derivative of the wild type native IFN .
- the IFN ⁇ -2b mutant proteins provided herein confer a higher half- life and at least comparable antiviral and antiproliferation activity (sufficient for a therapeutic effect) with respect to the native protein and to the pegylated derivatives molecules currently being used for the clinical treatment of hepatitis C infection.
- the optimized IFN -2b protein mutants that possess increased resistance to proteolysis and/or glomerular filtration would result in a decrease in the frequency of injections needed to maintain a sufficient drug level in serum; which should lead to i) higher comfort and acceptance by patients, ii) lower doses necessary to achieve comparable biological effects, and Hi) as a consequence of (ii), an attenuation of the (dose-dependent) secondary effects observed in humans.
- the half-life of the IFN ⁇ -2b mutants provided herein is increased by an amount selected from at least 10%, at least 20%, at least 30%, at least 40%, at least 50%, at least 60%, at least 70%, at least 80%, at least 90%, at least 100%, at least 1 50%, at least 200%, at least 250%, at least 300%, at least 350%, at least 400%, at least 450%, at least 500% or more, when compared to the half-life of native human IFN -2b in either human blood, human serum or an in vitro mixture containing one or more proteases.
- Two methodologies are provided herein to increase the stability of IFN ⁇ -2b by amino acid replacement: i) amino acid replacement that leads to higher resistance to proteases by direct destruction of the protease target residue or sequence, while either maintaining or improving the requisite biological activity (such as, for example, antiviral activity or antiproliferation activity), and/or //) amino acid replacement that leads to a different pattern of N-glycosylation, thus decreasing both glomerular filtration and sensitivity to proteases, while either improving or maintaining the requisite biological activity (such as, for example, antiviral activity or antiproliferation activity).
- the 2D-scanning methods provided herein were used to identify the amino acid changes on IFN -2b that lead to an increase in stability when challenged either with proteases, human blood lysate or human serum.
- Increasing protein stability to proteases, human blood lysate or human serum, and/or increasing the molecular size is contemplated herein to provide a longer in vivo half-life for the particular protein molecules, and thus to a reduction in the frequency of necessary injections into patients.
- the biological activities that have been measured for the IFN ⁇ -2b molecules are i) their capacity to inhibit virus replication when added to permissive cells previously infected with the appropriate virus, and //) their capacity to stimulate cell proliferation when added to the appropriate cells.
- IFN ⁇ -2b molecules Prior to the measurement of biological activity, IFN ⁇ -2b molecules were challenged with proteases, human blood lysate or human serum during different incubation times. The biological activity measured, corresponds then to the residual biological activity following exposure to the protease-containing mixtures.
- IFN ⁇ -2b molecules that, while maintaining the requisite biological activity intact, have been rendered less susceptible to digestion by blood proteases and therefore display a longer half-life in blood circulation.
- the method used included the following specific steps as set forth in Example 2:
- the 3-dimensional structure of IFN ⁇ -2b obtained from the NMR structure of IFN ⁇ -2a (PDB code 1ITF) was used to select only those residues exposed to solvent from a list of residues along the IFN ⁇ -2b sequence which can be recognized as a substrate for different enzymes present in the serum.
- Residue 1 corresponds to the first residue of the mature peptide IFNo--2b encoded by nucleotides 580- 1074 of sequence accession No. J00207, SEQ ID NO: 1.
- mutant IFN ⁇ -2b proteins that have increased resistance proteolysis compared to the unmodified, typically wild-type, protein.
- the mutant IFN ⁇ -2b proteins include those selected from among proteins containing more single amino acid replacements in SEQ ID NO: 1 , corresponding to: L by V at position 3; L by I at position 3; P by S at position 4; P by A at position 4; R by H at position 1 2; R by Q at position 1 2; R by H at position 1 3; R by Q at position 1 3; M by V at position 16; M by I at position 16; R by H at position 22; R by Q at position 22; R by H at position 23; R by Q at position 23; F by I at position 27; F by V at position 27; L by V at position 30; L by I at position 30; K by Q at position 31 ; K by T at position 31 ; R by H at position 33; R by Q at position 33; E by Q at position 41 ; E by H at position 41 ; K by Q at position 49; K by
- each individual IFN ⁇ -2b variant was assigned a specific activity. Those variant proteins displaying the highest stability and/or resistance to proteolysis were selected as LEADs. The candidate LEADs that possessed at least as much residual antiviral activity following protease treatment as the control, native IFN ⁇ -2b, before protease treatment were elected as LEADs. The results are set forth in Table 2 of Example 2.
- the following mutants selected as LEADs are provided herein and correspond to the group of proteins containing one or more single amino acid replacements in SEQ ID NO: 1 , corresponding to: F by V at position 27; R by H at position 33; E by Q at position 41 ; E by H at position 41 ; E by Q at position 58; E by H at position 58; E by Q at position 78; E by H at position 78; Y by H at position 89; E by Q at position 107; E by H at position 107; P by A at position 109; Lby V at position 1 10; M by V at position 1 1 1 ; E by Q at position 1 1 3; E by H at position 1 13; L by V at position 1 17; L by I at position 1 17; K by Q at position 1 21 ; K by T at position 121 ; R by H at position 1 25; R by Q at position 1 25; K by Q at position 1 33; K by T at position 1 33; and E by Q at position 1 59; E
- mutations that can have multiple effects.
- mutations described herein are mutations that result in an increase of the IFN -2b activity as assessed by detecting the requisite biological activity.
- IFN ⁇ -2b proteins that contain a plurality of mutations based on the LEADs (see Tables in the EXAMPLES, listing the candidate LEADs and LEAD sites), are produced to produce IFN ⁇ -2b proteins that have activity that is further optimized. Examples of such proteins are described in the EXAMPLES. Other combinations of mutations can be prepared and tested as described herein to identify other LEADs of interest, particularly those that have further increased IFN ⁇ -2b antiviral activity or further increased resistance to proteolysis. b. Rational Evolution of interferon ⁇ (IFN ?) for Increased
- interferon b Treatment with interferon b (IFN ?) is a well established therapy. Typically it is used for treatment of multiple sclerosis (MS).
- IFN ? mutant variants of the IFN/? protein that display improved stability as assessed by resistance to proteases (thereby possessing increased protein half-life) and at least comparable biological activity as assessed by antiviral or antiproliferation activity compared to the unmodified and wild type native IFN/? protein (SEQ ID NO: 499).
- the IFN ? mutant proteins provided herein confer a higher half-life and at least comparable biological activity with respect to the native sequence.
- protein mutants that possess increased resistance to proteolysis provided herein result in a decrease in the frequency of injections needed to maintain a sufficient drug level in serum, thus leading to, for example: i) higher comfort and acceptance by patients, ii) lower doses necessary to achieve comparable biological effects, and Hi) as a consequence of (ii), likely attenuation of any secondary effects.
- the half-life of each IFN/? mutant provided herein is increased by an amount selected from at least 10%, at least 20%, at least 30%, at least 40%, at least 50%, at least 60%, at least 70%, at least 80%, at least 90%, at least 100%, at least 150%, at least 200%, at least 250%, at least 300%, at least 350%, at least 400%, at least 450%, at least 500% or more, when compared to the half-life of native human IFN ? in either human blood, human serum or an in vitro mixture containing one or more proteases.
- the half-life of the IFN ? is increased by an amount selected from at least 10%, at least 20%, at least 30%, at least 40%, at least 50%, at least 60%, at least 70%, at least 80%, at least 90%, at least 100%, at least 150%, at least 200%, at least 250%, at least 300%, at least 350%, at least 400%, at least 450%, at least 500% or more, when compared to the half-life of native human
- mutants provided herein is increased by an amount selected from at least 6 times, 7 times, 8 times, 9 times, 10 times, 20 times, 30 times, 40 times, 50 times, 60 times, 70 times, 80 times, 90 times, 100 times, 200 times, 300 times, 400 times, 500 times, 600 times, 700 times, 800 times, 900 times, 1000 times, or more, when compared to the half-life of native human IFN ? in either human blood, human serum or an in vitro mixture containing one or more proteases.
- the 2D-scanning and 3D-scanning methods each were used to identify the amino acid changes on IFN/? that lead to an increase in stability when challenged either with proteases, human blood lysate or human serum.
- Increasing protein stability to proteases, human blood lysate or human serum is contemplated herein to provide a longer in vivo half-life for the particular protein molecules, and thus a reduction in the frequency of necessary injections into patients.
- the biological activities that have been measured for the IFN/? molecules are i) their capacity to inhibit virus replication when added to permissive cells previously infected with the appropriate virus, and ii) their capacity to stimulate cell proliferation when added to the appropriate cells.
- IFN/? molecules Prior to the measurement of biological activity, IFN/? molecules were challenged with proteases, human blood lysate or human serum during different incubation times. The biological activity measured, corresponds then to the residual biological activity following exposure to the proteolytic mixtures.
- the method used included the following specific steps as set forth in the Examples: For the improvement of resistance to proteases, by 2D-scanning, the method included:
- the rational mutagenesis methods provided herein also can be used to evolve proteins that are contained in agronomic consumables, crops or foodstuff, such that these proteins display either decreased or abolished secondary effects (such as toxic or allergenic effects) on the consumer.
- toxic or allergenic effects are attributable to a lack of (or incomplete) digestion of particular proteins in the gut.
- a similar approach to the methods provided herein for increasing protein stability can be used.
- s/7/co-HITs for the selected protease mixtures as well as the appropriate replacing amino acids can be identified according to the methods provided herein along a particular protein sequence using the PAM250 matrix analysis in such a way that the introduction of protease- specific target residues does not affect the protein's primary biological function in the agronomic consumable, crop or foodstuff. It has been established that physical stability increases the opportunity for a protein to be absorbed in the body and cause systemic effects such as toxicity or allergenicity (Cockburn, J. Biotechnol. , (in press), 2002) .
- protease-specific is-HIT target residues even in buried regions of the protein structure, is contemplated herein to increase the protein digestibility by a further rapid luminal protease attack (secreted and membrane-bound proteases), which would transiently yield smaller and less allergenic or toxic peptides in the gastrointestinal tract.
- These methods provided herein are useful in that they are contemplated to reduce the impact of safety and provide a security perspective for genetically modified food.
- methods are provided herein for designing and generating mutant proteins that have decreased stability, have increased digestibility, or a shorter lasting in serum or protease mixtures, or have a short half-life, compared to unmodified and/or wild type protein, wherein the methods comprise a first step of identifying some or all possible target sites on the protein sequence that are susceptible to be easily converted, by mutation, into target sites for one or more specific proteases (these sites are the is-HITs).
- the second step is identifying the appropriate replacing amino acids, specific for each is-HIT, such that if used to replace one or more of the native amino acids at that specific is-HIT, they can be expected to make the is-HIT susceptible to digestion by particular proteases while at the same time, maintaining or improving the desired biological activity of the protein (these replacing amino acids are referred to as "candidate LEADs") .
- the PAM250 matrix described in Example 2 is used.
- the specific replacing amino acids (candidate LEADs) are introduced at every specific is-HIT position so as to generate a collection containing the corresponding mutant molecules.
- Mutants are generated, produced and phenotypically characterized one-by-one, in addressable arrays, such that each mutant molecule contains initially amino acid replacements at only one is-HIT site.
- mutant molecules also can be generated such that they contain one or more amino acids at one or more is-HIT sites that have been replaced by candidate LEAD amino acids.
- Those mutant proteins carrying one or more mutations at one or more is-HITs, and that display improved protease sensitivity are called LEADs.
- thermostabilization of proteins based on the 2D-scanning described above, to develop proteins able to perform native functions at high temperatures.
- is-HITs are all amino acids that are located, on the 3-dimensional structure of the protein, in spatial positions such that they face another amino acid at a certain maximal distance.
- the two facing amino acids involved are considered to make part of a "stabilizing doublet. "
- the link can be comprised of H-bonds, + /- charge interactions, disulfide bonds.
- the second step comprises identifying the appropriate replacing amino acids, specific for each is-HIT, such that if used to replace one or more of the native amino acids at that specific is-HIT, generate a link or bridge in the protein structure while at the same time, maintaining or improving the requisite biological activity of the protein (these replacing amino acids are dubbed "candidate LEADs").
- the rationale behind these two steps is to increase protein stability by the introduction of additional linking structures such as disulfide bonds, salt bridges or hydrogen bonds in proteins at every single position where it is possible.
- the specific replacing amino acids (candidate LEADs) are introduced at every specific is-HIT position so as to generate a collection containing the corresponding candidate LEAD mutant molecules.
- Individual mutants are then generated such that, each contains only 2 amino acid replacements, involving a different "stabilizing doublet.”
- the introduction of additional disulfide bonds includes replacing one or two residues by cysteine along the protein sequence in such a way that their thiol groups remain closer than 2.1 A, in the tertiary structure of the protein (FIG9A through B).
- the introduction of salt bridges and hydrogen bonds includes replacements of native residues by either charged or polar amino acids, located at the appropriate positions on the protein tertiary structure such that their interaction with each other can generate a tighter structure.
- the method to thermostabilize proteins herein includes the replacement of all and every native amino acids located in surface loops of the 3-dimensional structure of the protein, into proline. Again, each initial individual mutant contains only one amino acid replacement at a time.
- the rationale behind this approach is based on the observation that proline substitutions in amino acid positions involved in 'loops' are less permissive to flexibility. Mutants are generated, produced and phenotypically characterized one-by-one, in addressable arrays, such that each mutant molecule contains initially amino acid replacements at only one pair of is-HIT sites. In subsequent rounds mutant molecules also can be generated such that they contain one or more amino acids at one or more pairs of is-HIT sites that have been replaced by candidate LEAD amino acids. Those mutant proteins carrying one or more mutations at one or more is-HITs, and that display improved resistance to heat are called LEADs.
- the phrase "at high temperatures” refers to at least 5 degrees, at least 10 degrees, at least 1 5 degrees, at least 20 degrees, at least 25 degrees, at least 30 degrees, at least 40 degrees, at least 50 degrees, at least 60 degrees, at least 70 degrees, at least 80 degrees, at least 90 degrees, up to at least 100 degrees, or more above the optimal temperature for the desired biological activity of the respective native protein.
- a previous knowledge on the 3-dimensional structure of the protein is necessary.
- Gly ⁇ Ala substitutions are considered regardless the location in the tertiary protein structure and, thus, knowledge of the 3-dimensional structure of the protein is not necessary.
- a long-lasting vaccine would be composed by viral proteins that have been evolved such that they would expose poorly uncovered epitopes, which could be recognized by antibodies leading thereby to the production of memory lymphocytes.
- Methods to locally destabilize structural regions of the evolving proteins include herein the use of the basic concepts defining protein stability.
- the methods include the substitution of Pro into Ala: the substitution of "(loop)-stabilizing" proline residues, at each position occupied by proline (is-HITs), by the replacing alanine amino acid. These sorts of mutations are expected to decrease rigidity at the level of proline-produced turns, resulting in loops that increase their "mobility” thereby uncovering new epitopes.
- the methods include the substitution of Gly into large side chains and high steric hindrance amino acids (F, W, and Y). These replacements are contemplated herein to disturb Gly-compatible turns and thereby lead to the exposure of new epitopes.
- a full length Proline-scan is conducted, which is a systematic replacement of native amino acids by proline, along entire length of the protein.
- the rationale is based on the reported ability of prolines to induce turns in loop regions and kinks in helices, thus leading to localized loss of protein structure.
- the methods include the substitution of Cys into Ser. Removing disulfide bonds by replacing cysteine residues by serine would lead to perturbations in the natural protein folding and stability, which is contemplated to herein to increase epitope exposure and immunogenicity.
- the replacement of residues involved in the formation of hydrogen bonds and salt bridges on the protein surface, by for instance hydrophobic amino acids, is expected to interfere with the hydrogen bond formation and lead to a local wobbling of protein regions, which would facilitate the presentation of previously covered epitopes (FIG10A through B).
- the second step is to identify the appropriate replacing amino acids, specific for each is-HIT, such that if used to replace one or more of the native amino acids at that specific is- HIT, they can be expected to expose new epitopes or to increase exposure of already exposed epitopes thus increasing immunogenicity of the protein; (these replacing amino acids are named "candidate LEADs") .
- the PAM250 matrix described in Example 2 can be used.
- mutant LEADs the specific replacing amino acids (candidate LEADs) are introduced at every specific is-HIT position so as to generate a collection containing the corresponding candidate LEAD mutant molecules.
- Mutants are generated, produced and phenotypically characterized one-by-one, in addressable arrays, such that each mutant molecule contains initially amino acid replacements at only one is-HIT site.
- mutant molecules also can be generated such that they contain one or more amino acids at one or more is-HIT sites that have been replaced by candidate LEAD amino acids.
- Those mutant proteins carrying one or more mutations at one or more is-HITs, and that display an improved immunogenicity are called LEADs.
- Also provided herein are methods for designing and generating highly antigenic proteins comprising performing a "proline-scan" on a particular protein.
- a collection of mutants is generated in which each individual mutant contains a single amino acid replacement such that each native amino acid is replaced by a proline.
- Mutants are generated, produced and phenotypically characterized one-by-one, in addressable arrays, such that each mutant molecule contains initially only one amino acid replacement by proline.
- mutant molecules also can be generated such that they contain one or more amino acid replacements by proline.
- Those mutant proteins carrying one or more mutations (replacements by proline) and that display an improved immunogenicity are called LEADs.
- Certain polypeptides are per se amphipathic molecules (i.e., one portion is water-soluble and the other part water-insoluble). Some other polypeptides adopt the amphipathic molecular design depending on the physicochemical conditions of the local environment (including pH, salinity, and temperature) or once a contact with biological membranes is established. For the amphipathic polypeptides or proteins, the amphipathic property is often at the basis of their biological role or activity (FIG 1 1 ) .
- amphipathic character arises from the presence of hydrophobic and charged (hydrophilic) clusters of amino acids disposed in such a way that two faces can be distinguished in the secondary or tertiary protein structure.
- cationic and anionic peptides presenting an amphipathic character are directly concerned.
- Methods are provided herein to optimize the biological roles or activities of polypeptides based on their amphipathic character, by performing a "scanning" of charged (i.e., arginine, lysine, histidine, glutamate and aspartate) and/or hydrophobic residues (e.g., valine, leucine, phenylalanine, tryptophan, glycine). Accordingly, depending on the amphipathic polypeptide, one or more of the above replacing residues will follow a sequential replacement of selected residues along the polypeptide sequence, in an attempt to optimize the position, number and nature (cationic or anionic) of charges and hydrophobic residues fitting to an optimized trait.
- charged i.e., arginine, lysine, histidine, glutamate and aspartate
- hydrophobic residues e.g., valine, leucine, phenylalanine, tryptophan, glycine
- FIGS13A through D present steps followed with an exemplary polypeptide, wherein a series of substitutions, after a "K/R scanning” and “hydrophobic scanning,” are intended to optimize its biological role or activity through its amphipathic trait.
- An innovative method provided herein referred to as “multi-overlapped primer extensions” was used to simultaneously introduce mutations in such short sequences as the one illustrated in FIGS13A through D.
- methods for designing and generating "highly amphipathic" proteins comprising a first step of identifying some or all possible target sites on the protein sequence that are susceptible to significantly change the amphipathic properties of the protein whenever the native amino acids at those sites are changed by other specific amino acids such as arginine or lysine; (these sites are the is-HITs) .
- the next step is identifying the appropriate replacing amino acids, specific for each is-HIT, such that if used to replace one or more of the native amino acids at that specific is-HIT, they can be expected to increase the amphipathic properties of the protein while at the same time, maintaining or improving the requisite biological activity of the protein (these replacing amino acids are referred to as the "candidate LEADs.”
- the PAM250 matrix described in Example 2 can be used.
- mutant LEADs the specific replacing amino acids
- mutant LEADs are introduced at every specific is-HIT position so that to generate a collection containing the corresponding mutant molecules.
- Mutants are generated, produced and phenotypically characterized one-by-one, in addressable arrays, such that each mutant molecule contains initially amino acid replacements at only one is-HIT site.
- mutant molecules also can be generated such that they contain one or more amino acids at one or more is-HIT sites that have been replaced by candidate LEAD amino acids.
- Those mutant proteins carrying one or more mutations at one or more is-HITs, and that display improved amphipathic properties are called LEADs.
- Also provided herein are methods for designing and generating highly amphipathic proteins comprising performing either an "arginine- scanning" or a "lysine-scanning" on the particular protein.
- a collection of mutants is generated in which each individual mutant contains a single amino acid replacement such that each native amino acid is replaced by either arginine or lysine.
- Mutants are generated, produced and phenotypically characterized one-by-one, in addressable arrays, such that each mutant molecule contains initially only one amino acid replacement by either arginine or lysine.
- mutant molecules also can be generated such that they contain one or more amino acid replacements by either arginine or lysine.
- LEADs Those mutant proteins carrying one or more mutations (replacements by either arginine or lysine) and that display improved amphipathic properties are called LEADs.
- LEADs Those mutant proteins carrying one or more mutations (replacements by either arginine or lysine) and that display improved amphipathic properties are called LEADs.
- Ligand-receptor Interactions The 2D-scanning methods provided herein also can be used to generate ligand agonists or antagonists (such as negative dominant mutant ligand proteins) for binding to their respective receptors. It is well known that the activity of receptor binding proteins is a direct function of their binding affinity for their respective receptors. For example, strong binding affinity leads to high activity; whereas in contrast, no binding results in the absence of activity.
- ligand protein mutants with enhanced affinity for their receptors while at the same time having an improved biological activity (agonists); as well as, in contrast, (2) dominant negative ligand protein mutants that bind to their receptors without inducing any cellular response (antagonists).
- the second step is identifying appropriate replacing amino acids, specific for each is-HIT, such that if used to replace one or more of the native amino acids at that specific is-HIT, they can be expected to increase binding affinity to the corresponding receptor while at the same time, either maintaining the desired biological activity of the protein (agonist protein) or abolishing the biological activity of the (antagonist) protein (these replacing amino acids are referred to as "candidate LEADs").
- replacing amino acids the PAM250 matrix described in Example 2 can be used.
- mutant LEADs are introduced at every specific is-HIT position so as to generate a collection containing the corresponding mutant candidate LEAD molecules.
- Mutants are generated, produced and phenotypically characterized one-by-one, in addressable arrays, such that each mutant molecule contains initially amino acid replacements at only one is-HIT site.
- mutant molecules also can be generated such that they contain one or more amino acids at one or more is-HIT sites that have been replaced by candidate LEAD amino acids.
- the first step comprises an amino acid-scanning (e.g., an alanine-scan) .
- the amino acid scanning is used to identify each and every target amino acid residue involved in the binding site(s) on the protein referred to herein as the HITs. This information would then be used, using the 2D-scanning approach and based on the 3-dimensional structure of the protein, to identify the replacing amino acids needed to generate antagonist mutants.
- the use of "amino acid scanning" to identify the residues involved in the interaction has higher information content than the sole conclusions, which derive from 3-dimensional structure of proteins.
- Protein Redesign Provided herein are methods for redesigning and generating new versions of native or modified proteins, such as IFN ⁇ -2b (see FIG3B).
- the redesigned protein maintains either sufficient, typically equal or improved levels of a selected phenotype, such as a biological activity, of the original protein, while at the same time its amino acid sequence is changed by replacement of up to less than 1 % (i.e., 1 , 2, 3 or more amino acid residues), at least 1 %, at least 2%, at least 3%, at least 4%, at least 5%, at least 6%, at least 7%, at least 8%, at least 9%, at least 10%, at least 12%, at least 14%, at least 1 6%, at least 1 8%, at least 20%, at least 30%, at least 40% up to 50% or more of its native amino acids by the appropriate pseudo-wild type amino acids.
- 1 % i.e., 1 , 2, 3 or more amino acid residues
- Pseudo-wild type amino acids are those amino acids such that when they replace an original, such as native, amino acid at a given position on the protein sequence, the resulting protein displays substantially the same levels of biological activity (or sufficient activity for its therapeutic or other use) compared to the original, such as native, protein.
- pseudo-wild type amino acids are those amino acids such that when they replace an original, such as native, amino acid at a given position on the protein sequence, the resulting protein displays the same phenotype, such as levels of biological activity, compared to an original, typically a native, protein.
- Pseudo-wild type amino acids and the appropriate replacing positions can be detected and identified by any analytical or predictive means; such as for example, by performing an Alanine-scanning.
- the methods provided herein for protein redesign of proteins are intended to design and generate "artificial" (versus naturally existing) proteins, such that they contain sequences of amino acids that differ from the naturally-occurring sequences, but that display biological activities characteristic of the original, such as native, protein.
- These redesigned proteins can be used to avoid potential side effects that might otherwise exist in other forms of proteins for treatment of disease.
- Other uses of redesigned proteins provided herein are to establish cross-talk between pathways triggered by different proteins; to facilitate structural biology by generating mutants that can be crystallized while maintaining activity; and to destroy an activity of a protein without changing a second activity or multiple additional activities.
- a method for obtaining redesigned proteins comprises i) identifying some or all possible target sites on the protein sequence that are susceptible to amino acid replacement without losing protein activity (protein activity in a largest sense of the term: enzymatic, binding, hormone, etc.) (These sites are the pseudo-wild type, ⁇ -wt sites); ii) identifying appropriate replacing amino acids ( ⁇ -wt amino acids), specific for each ⁇ -wt site, such that if used to replace the native amino acids at that specific ⁇ -wt site, they can be expected to generate a protein with comparable biological activity compared to the original, such as native, protein, thus keeping the biological activity of the protein substantially unchanged; Hi) systematically introducing the specific ⁇ -wt amino acids at every specific ⁇ -wt position so as to generate a collection containing the corresponding mutant molecules.
- Mutants are generated, produced and phenotypically characterized one-by-one, in addressable arrays, such that each mutant molecule contains initially amino acid replacements at only one ⁇ -wt site. In subsequent rounds mutant molecules also can be generated such that they contain one or more ⁇ -wt amino acids at one or more ⁇ -wt sites. Those mutant proteins carrying several mutations at a number of ⁇ -wt sites, and that display comparable or improved biological activity are called redesigned proteins or ⁇ -wt proteins.
- At least 1 %, at least 2%, at least 3%, at least 4%, at least 5%, at least 6%, at least 7%, at least 8%, at least 9%, at least 10%, at least 1 5%, at least 20%, at least 25%, or more of the amino acid residue positions on a particular protein, such as IFN ⁇ -2b are replaced with an appropriate pseudo-wild type amino acid.
- the first step is an amino acid scan over the full length of the protein. At this step, each and every one of the amino acids in the protein sequence is replaced by a selected reference amino acid, such as alanine. This permits the identification of "redesign-HIT" positions, i.e., positions that are sensitive to amino acid replacement.
- Amino acid replacement at the pseudo-wild type positions result in a non-change in the protein fitness (e.g., possess substantially the same biological activity), while at the same time to a divergence in the resulting protein sequence compared to the original, such as native, sequence.
- an Ala-scan was performed on the IFN ⁇ -2b sequence as set forth in Example 4. For this purpose, each amino acid in the IFN -2b protein sequence was individually changed to Alanine. Any other amino acid, particularly another amino acid that has a neutral effect on structure, such as Gly or Ser, also can be used. Each resulting mutant IFN ⁇ -2b protein was then expressed and the activity of the interferon molecule was then assayed.
- HITs These particular amino acid positions, referred to herein as HITs would in principle not be suitable targets for amino acid replacement to increase protein stability, because of their involvement in the recognition of IFN- receptor or in the downstream pathways involved in IFN activity.
- the biological activity measured for the IFN ⁇ -2b molecules was: i) their capacity to inhibit virus replication when added to permissive cells previously infected with the appropriate virus and, ii) their capacity to stimulate cell proliferation when added to the appropriate cells.
- the relative activity of each individual mutant compared to the native protein was assayed.
- HITs are those mutants that produce a decrease in the activity of the protein (in the example: all the mutants with activities below about 30% of the native activity.
- the Alanine-scan was used to identify the amino acid residues on IFN -2b that when replaced with alanine correspond to 'pseudo-wild type' activity, i.e., those that can be replaced by alanine without leading to a decrease in biological activity.
- Knowledge of these amino acids is useful for the re-design of the IFN ⁇ -2b protein.
- the results are set forth in Table 5, and include pseudo-wild type amino acid positions of IFN ⁇ -2b corresponding to SEQ ID NO: 1 , amino acid residues: 9, 10, 1 7, 20, 24, 25, 35, 37, 41 , 52, 54, 56, 57, 58, 60, 63, 64, 65, 76, 89, and 90.
- IFN -2b mutant proteins that contain one or more pseudo-wild type mutations at amino acid positions of IFN ⁇ -2b corresponding to SEQ ID NO: 1 , amino acid residues: 9, 10, 1 7, 20, 24, 25, 35, 37, 41 , 52, 54, 56, 57, 58, 60, 63, 64, 65, 76, 89, and 90.
- the mutations can be either one or more of insertions, deletions and/or replacements of the native amino acid residue(s) .
- the psuedo-wild type replacements are mutations with alanine at each position.
- the pseudo-wild type replacements are one or more mutations in SEQ ID NO: 1 corresponding to:
- the IFN ⁇ -2b alanine scan revealed the following redesign-HITs having decreased antiviral activity at amino acid positions of IFN ⁇ -2b corresponding to SEQ ID NO: 1 , amino acid residues: 2, 7, 8, 1 1 , 1 3, 1 5, 1 6, 23, 26, 28, 29, 30, 31 , 32, 33, 53, 69, 91 , 93, 98, and 101 .
- either one or more of insertions, deletions and/or replacements of the native amino acid residue(s) can be carried out at one or more of amino acid positions of IFN -2b corresponding to SEQ ID NO: 1 , amino acid residues: 2, 7, 8, 1 1 , 13, 1 5, 1 6, 23, 26, 28, 29, 30, 31 , 32, 33, 53, 69, 91 , 93, 98, and 101 .
- This method of structural homology analysis can be applied to proteins that are evolved by any method, including the 2D scanning method described herein. When used with the 2D method in which a particular phenotype, activity or characteristic of a protein is modified by 2D analysis, the method is referred to as 3D-scanning.
- structural homology analysis in combination with the directed evolution methods provided herein provides a powerful technique for identifying and producing various new protein mutants, such as cytokines, having desired biological activities, such as increased resistance to proteolysis.
- the analysis of the "structural homology" between an optimized mutant version of a given protein and “structurally homologous" proteins allows identification of the corresponding structurally related or structurally similar amino acid positions (also referred to herein as “structurally homologous loci”) on other proteins. This permits identification of mutant versions of the latter that have a desired optimized feature(s) (biological activity, phenotype) in a simple, rapid and predictive manner (regardless of amino acid sequence and sequence homology) .
- the two amino acids also are said to occupy "structurally homologous loci.”
- "Structural homology” does not take into account the underlying amino acid sequence and solely compares 3- dimens ⁇ onal structures of proteins.
- two proteins can be said to have some degree of structural homology whenever they share conformational regions or domains showing comparable structures or shapes with 3-dimensional overlapping in space.
- Two proteins can be said to have a higher degree of structural homology whenever they share a higher amount of conformational regions or domains showing comparable structures or shapes with 3-dimensional overlapping in space.
- Amino acids positions on one or more proteins that are "structurally homologous" can be relatively far way from each other in the protein sequences, when these sequences are aligned following the rules of primary sequence homology.
- structurally homologous proteins when two or more protein backbones are determined to be structurally homologous, the amino acid residues that are coincident upon three-dimensional structural superposition are referred to as "structurally similar” or “structurally related” amino acid residues in structurally homologous proteins (also referred to as “structurally homologous loci”) .
- Structurally similar amino acid residues are located in substantially equivalent spatial positions in structurally homologous proteins. For example, for proteins of average size (approximately 180 residues), two structures with a similar fold will usually display rms deviations not exceeding 3 to 4 angstroms.
- structurally similar or structurally related amino acid residues can have backbone positions less than 3.5, 3.0, 2.5, 2.0, 1 .7 or 1 .5 angstrom from each other upon protein superposition.
- RMS deviation calculations and protein superposition can be carried out using any of a number of methods known in the art.
- protein superposition and RMS deviation calculations generally can be performed on only a subset of the entire protein structure. For example, if the protein superposition is carried out using one protein that has many more amino acid residues than another protein, protein superposition can be carried out on the subset (e.g., a domain) of the larger protein that adopts a structure similar to the smaller protein. Similarly, only portions of other proteins can be suitable for superimposition. For example, if the position of the C-terminal residues from two structurally homologous proteins differ significantly, the C-terminal residues can be omitted from the structural superposition or RMS deviation calculations.
- Suitable amino acid replacement criteria such as PAM analysis, can be employed to identify candidate LEADs for construction and screening as described herein.
- homology between proteins is compared at the level of their amino acid sequences, based on the percent or level of coincidence of individual amino acids, amino acid per amino acid, when sequences are aligned starting from a reference, generally the residue encoded by the start codon.
- two proteins are said to be "homologous” or to bear some degree of homology whenever their respective amino acid sequences show a certain degree of matching upon alignment comparison. Comparative molecular biology is primarily based on this approach. From the degree of homology or coincidence between amino acid sequences, conclusions can be made on the evolutionary distance between or among two or more protein sequences and biological systems.
- Structural homology refers to homology between the topology and three-dimensional structure of two proteins. Structural homology is not necessarily related to "convergent evolution” or to "divergent evolution,” nor is it related to the underlying amino acid sequence. Rather, structural homology is likely driven (through natural evolution) by the need of a protein to fit specific conformational demands imposed by its environment. Particular structurally homologous "spots" or “loci” would not be allowed to structurally diverge from the original structure, even when its own underlying sequence does diverge. This structural homology is exploited herein to identify loci for mutation.
- amino acid sequence of proteins is usually represented as a sequence stream of letters or names, each representing one individual amino acid in the sequence.
- This type of linear representation is appropriate to make comparisons on amino acid sequence, homology/heterology, make co-linear representation with DNA nucleotides sequences (thus allowing to represent the genetic code from DNA to protein in a co-linear way).
- the information content and the analytical potential of this type of representation is limited and thus limits the scope and the perspective of the analysis on protein sequence/structure relationships that are based upon this type of linear amino-acid string representation.
- a method of representing the amino acid sequence of a protein e.g., protein sequencing
- a method for the notation of protein sequence are useful to facilitate the analysis of the relationships between protein sequence and structure, which is currently a bottle-neck for the further development of different fields of biology, including those of directed evolution.
- the method employs a two-dimensional (2-D) matrix representation of the of protein sequence, wherein the vertical axis represents the amino acid present at the corresponding position indicated on the horizontal axis.
- the horizontal axis represents the amino acid position along the length protein sequence (such that the first cell corresponds to amino acid position No.
- the matrix always contains 20 cells in one direction (the amino acid type) and a variable number of position-cells depending on the size of the protein, the number of position-cells equaling the number of amino acids in the protein sequence.
- FIG12 an exemplary protein sequence is shown above the matrix and within the matrix, such that those cells corresponding to the actual sequence of the protein are indicated with shaded squares.
- those cells corresponding to the actual sequence of the protein are indicated with either a different color or a sign that differentiates them from the cells not corresponding to the actual protein sequence.
- amino acid sequence AKRLSL
- a sign for the cell corresponding to position No. 3 and amino acid type "R” and so on.
- a 2-D matrix can be employed for representing the nucleotide sequence of a nucleic acid (e.g., nucleic acid sequencing), such as DNA or RNA, whereby the first vertical axis has 4 cells corresponding to nucleotides A, T, G, C; or A, U, G, C, respectively. H.
- nucleic acid sequencing such as DNA or RNA
- This example describes a plurality of chronological steps including steps from (i) to (viii):
- the IFN ⁇ -2b cDNA was first cloned into an mammalian expression vector, prior to the generation of the selected mutations. A library of mutants was then generated such that each individual mutant was created and processed individually, physically separated form each other and in addressable arrays.
- the mammalian expression vector pSSV9 CMV 0.3 pA was engineered as follows:
- the pSSV9 CMV 0.3 pA was cut by PvuW and religated (this step gets rid of the ITR functions) , prior to the introduction of a new EcoRI restriction site by Quickchange mutagenesis (Stratagene) .
- the oligonucleotides primers were:
- Seq Clal forward primer 5'-CTGATTATCAACCGGGGTACATATGATTGAC- ATGC-3' (SEQ ID NO: 184)
- Seq Xmnl reverse primer 5' ⁇ TACGGGATAATACCGCGCCACATAGCAGAA-C-3' (SEQ ID NO: 185)
- SSV9 is a clone containing the entire adeno-associated virus (AAV) genome inserted into the Pvull site of plasmid p ⁇ MBL (see, Du et al. (1 996) Gene Ther 5:254-261 )) to replace the corresponding wild-type fragment and produce construct pSSV9-2 ⁇ coRI.
- AAV adeno-associated virus
- the DNA sequence of the IFN ⁇ -2b cDNA carried by pDG6 was confirmed using a pair of internal primers.
- the sequences of the IFN ⁇ -2b-related oligonucleotides for sequencing follow:
- Seq forward primer 5'-CCTGATGAAGGAGGACTC-3' SEQ ID NO: 186)
- IFN ⁇ -2b 5' primer 5'-TCAGCTGCAAGTCAAGCTGCTCTGTGGGCTG-3' (SEQ ID NO: 188)
- IFN ⁇ -2b Xbal primer ⁇ '-GCTCTAGATCATTCCTTACTTCTTAAACTTTC- TTGCAAGTTTGTTGAC-3' (SEQ ID NO: 1 91 )
- the entire IFN ⁇ -2b cDNA was cloned into the pTOPO-TA vector (Invitrogen) . After checking gene sequence by automatic DNA sequencing, the Hin ⁇ -Xba ⁇ fragment containing the gene of interest was subcloned into the corresponding sites of pSSV9-2EcoRl to produce pAAV-EcoRI-INFalpha-2b (pNB-AAV-IFN alpha-2b).
- BL21 -CodonPlus(DE3)-RP ® competent Escherichia coli cells are derived from Stratagene's high-performance BL21 -Gold competent cells. These cells enable efficient high-level expression of heterologous proteins in E. coli. Efficient production of heterologous proteins in E. coli is frequently limited by the rarity, in E.coii, of certain tRNAs that are abundant in the organisms from which the heterologous proteins are derived. Availability of tRNAs allows high-level expression of many heterologous recombinant genes in BL21 -Codon Plus cells that are poorly expressed in conventional BL21 strains.
- BL21 -CodonPLus(DE3)-RP cells contain a ColE1 -compatible, pACYC-based plasmid containing extra copies of the argU and proL tRNA genes.
- PCR fragment was subcloned into pTOPO-TA vector (Invitrogen) yielding pTOPO-lFN cr-2b.
- the sequence was verified by sequencing.
- pET1 1 IFN ⁇ -2b was prepared by insertion of the Ndel-Bam HI (Biolabs) fragment from pTOPO-IFN ⁇ -2b into the Ndel-Bam HI sites of pET 1 1 .
- the DNA sequence of the resulting pET 1 1 -IFN ⁇ -2b construct was verified by sequencing and the plasmid was used for IFN ⁇ -2b expression in E.coli.
- Mutants E1 59H and E1 59Q were amplified using the following primers on reverse side (primer forward was the same than described above):
- Mutants were amplified with Pfu Turbo Polymerase (Stratagene) according. PCR products were cloned into pTOPO plasmid (Zero Blunt TOPO PCR cloning kit, Invitrogen). The presence of the desired mutations was checked by automatic sequencing. The Ndel + BamHI fragment of the pTOPO-IFNa positive clones was then cloned into Ndel + BamHI sites of the pET1 1 plasmid.
- a series of mutagenic primers was designed to generate the appropriate site-specific mutations in the IFNcr-2b cDNA. Mutagenesis reactions were performed with the Chameleon ® mutagenesis kit
- Each individual mutagenesis reaction was designed to generate one single mutant protein.
- Each individual mutagenesis reaction contains one and only one mutagenic primer.
- 25 pmoles of each (phosphorylated) mutagenic primer were mixed with 0.25 pmoles of template, 25 pmoles of selection primer (introducing a new restriction site), and 2 ⁇ l of 10X mutagenesis buffer (1 00 mM Tris-acetate pH 7.5; 100 mM MgOAc; 500 mM KOAc pH 7.5) into each well of 96 well-plates.
- PCR plates were incubated at 98 °C during 5 min and immediately placed 5 min on ice, before incubating at room temperature during 30 min. Elongation and ligation reactions were allowed by addition of 7 ⁇ of nucleotide mix (2.86 mM each nucleotide; 1 .43 X mutagenesis buffer) and 3 ⁇ of a freshly prepared enzyme mixture of dilution buffer (20 mM Tris HCl pH7.5; 10 mM KCI; 1 0 mM R-mercaptoethanol; 1 mM DTT; 0.1 mM EDTA; 50 % glycerol), native T7 DNA polymerase (0.025 U/ ⁇ l), and T4 DNA ligase (1 U/ ⁇ l) in a ratio of 1 : 10, respectively.
- nucleotide mix 2.86 mM each nucleotide; 1 .43 X mutagenesis buffer
- 3 a freshly prepared enzyme mixture of dilution buffer (20 mM Tris HCl
- Reactions were incubated at 37 °C for 1 h before inactivation of T4 DNA ligase at 72 °C during 1 5 min.
- 30 ⁇ l of a mixture containing 1 X enzyme buffer and 10 U of restriction enzyme was added to the mutagenic reactions followed by incubation at 37 °C for at least 3 hours.
- 90 ⁇ l aliquots of XLmutS competent cells (Stratagene) containing 25 mM /?-mercaptoethanol were place in ice- chilled deep-well plates. Then, plates were incubated on ice for 10 min with gentle vortex every 2 min.
- Transformation of competent cells was performed by adding aliquots of the restriction reactions (1 /10 of reaction volume) and incubating on ice for 30 min. A heat pulse was performed in a 42 °C water bath for 45 s, followed by incubation on ice for 2 minutes. Preheated SOC medium (0.45 ml) was added to each well and plates were incubated at 37 °C for 1 h with shaking. In order to enrich for mutated plasmids, 1 ml of 2 X YT broth medium supplemented with 100 ⁇ g/ml ampicillin was added to each transformation mixture followed by overnight incubation at 37 °C with shaking.
- Plasmid DNA isolation was performed by alkaline lysis using Nucleospin Multi-96 Plus Plasmid Kit (Macherey-Nagel) according to the manufacturer's instructions. Selection of mutated plasmids was performed by digesting 500 ⁇ g of plasmid preparation with 1 0 U of selection endonuclease in an overnight incubation at 37 °C. A fraction of the digested reactions (1 /10 of the total volume) was transformed into 40 ⁇ l of Epicurian coli XL1 -Blue competent cells (Stratagene) supplemented with 25 mM /?- mercaptoethanol. Transformation was performed was as described above.
- IFN ⁇ -2b mutants were produced in 293 human embryo kidney (HEK) cells (obtained from ATCC), using Dubelcco's modified Eagle's medium supplemented with glucose (4.5 g/L; Gibco-BRL) and fetal bovine serum (10%, Hyclone) .
- HEK human embryo kidney
- fetal bovine serum 10%, Hyclone
- Cells were transiently transfected with the plasmids encoding the IFN ⁇ -2b mutants as follows: 0.6 x 10 5 cells were seeded into 6 well-plates and grown for 36 h before transfection Confluent cells at about 70%, were supplemented with 2.5 ⁇ g of plasmid (IFN ⁇ -2b mutants) and 10 mM poly-ethylene-imine (25 KDa PEI, Sigma- Aldrich).
- IFN ⁇ -2b was measured on culture supernatants obtained 40 h after transfection and stored in aliquots at -80 °C until use.
- Supernatants containing IFN ⁇ -2b from transfected cells were screened following sequential biological assays as follows. Normalization of IFN ⁇ -2b concentration from culture supernatants was performed by enzyme-linked immunoabsorbent assay (ELISA) using a commercial kit (R & D) and following the manufacturer's instructions.
- ELISA enzyme-linked immunoabsorbent assay
- This assay includes plates coated with an IFN ⁇ -2b monoclonal antibody that can be developed by coupling a secondary antibody conjugated to the horseradish peroxidase (HRP) .
- IFNcr-2b concentrations on samples containing (i) wild type IFNcr-2b produced under comparable conditions as the mutants, (ii) the IFN ⁇ -2b mutants and (iii) control samples(produced from cells expressing GFP) were estimated by using an international reference standard provided by the NIBSC, UK. C.2 In bacteria
- a volume of 200 ml of culture medium (LB/Ampicillin/ Chloramphenicol) was inoculated with 5 ml of pre-culture BL21 - pCodon + -pET-IFN ⁇ -2b muta overnight at 37 °C with constant shaking (225 rpm).
- the production of IFN r-2b was induced by the addition of 50 ⁇ l of 2M IPTG at DO 600nm ⁇ O.6.
- the culture was continued for 3 additional hours and was centrifuged at 4°C and 5OOO g for 1 5 minutes.
- the supernatant (culture medium) was discarded and bacteria were lysed in 8 ml of lysis buffer by thermal shock (freezing - thawing: 37°C - 1 5 min; -8O°C - 1 0 min; 37°C - 1 5 min; -8O°C - 10 min; 37°C - 1 5 min).
- the supernatant soluble proteins fraction
- the precipitated material insoluble protein fraction containing the IFN a -2b protein as inclusion bodies
- antiviral and antiproliferation activities Two activities were measured directly on IFN samples: antiviral and antiproliferation activities. Dose (concentration) - response (activity) experiments for antiviral or antiproliferation activity permitted calculation of the 'potency' for antiviral and antiproliferation activities, respectively. Antiviral and antiproliferation activities also were measured after incubation with proteolytic samples, such as specific proteases, mixtures of selected proteases, human serum or human blood. Assessment of activity following incubation with proteolytic samples allowed to determine the residual (antiviral or antiproliferation) activity and the respective kinetics of half-life upon exposure to proteases. D.1 . Antiviral activity
- IFN ⁇ -2b protects cells against viral infection by a complex mechanism devoted to create an unfavorable environment for viral proliferation.
- Cellular antiviral response due to IFN ⁇ -2b was assessed using an interferon-sensitive HeLa cell line (ATCC accession no. CCL-2) treated with the encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV) .
- EMCV encephalomyocarditis virus
- Confluent cells were trypsinized and plated at density 2 x 10 4 cells/well in DMEM 5% SVF medium (Day 0). Cells were incubated with IFN ⁇ -2b (at a concentration of 500 U/ml) to get 500 pg/ml and 1 50 pg/well (100 ⁇ l of IFN solution), during 24 h at 37 °C prior to be challenged with EMCV (1 /1000 dilution; MOI 100). After an incubation of 1 6 h, when virus-induced CPE was near maximum in untreated cells, the number of EMCV particles in each well was determined by RT-PCR quantification of EMCV mRNA, using lysates of infected cells.
- RNA from cell extracts was purified after a DNAse/proteinase K treatment (Applied Biosystems) .
- the CPE was evaluated using both Uptibleu (Interchim) and MTS (Promega) methods, which are based on detecting bio-reductions produced by the metabolic activity of cells in a flourometric and colorimetric manner, respectively.
- a 22 bp DNA fragment of the capsid protein- cDNA was amplified by PCR and cloned into pTOPO-TA vector (Invitrogen) .
- RT-PCR quantification of known amounts of pTOPO- TA-EMCV capsid gene was performed using the One-step RT-PCR kit (Applied Biosystems) and the following EMCV-related (cloning) oligonucleotides and probe:
- EMCV forward primer 5'-CCCCTACATTGAGGCATCCA-3' SEQ ID NO: 1 93
- EMCV reverse primer 5'-CAGGAGCAGGACAAGGTCACT-3'
- Antiviral activity of IFN ct-2b was determined by the capacity of the cytokine to protect Hela cells against EMC (mouse encephalomyocarditis) virus-induced cytopathic effects.
- EMC mouse encephalomyocarditis
- the medium was aspirated and the cells were stained for 1 hour with 100 ⁇ l of Blue staining solutio to determine the proportion of intact cells. Plates were washed in a distilled water bath. The cell bound dye was extracted using 100 ⁇ l of ethylene- glycol mono-ethyl-ether (Sigma). The absorbance of the dye was measured using an Elisa plate reader (Spectramax) . The antiviral activity of INF r-2b samples (expressed as number of lU/mg of proteins) was determined as the concentration needed for 50% protection of the cells against EMC virus-induced cytopathic effects. For proteolysis experiments, each point of for the kinetic measurements was assessed at 500 and 1 66 pg/ml in triplicate.
- D.2 Antiproliferation activity of interferon ⁇ -2b was determined by the capacity of the cytokine to inhibit proliferation of Daudi cells.
- Daudi cells (1 x1 O 4 cells) were seeded in flat-bottomed 96-well plates containing 5O ⁇ l/well of RPMI 1 640 medium supplemented with 10% SVF, 1 X glutamin and 1 ml of gentamicin. No cell was added to the last row ("H" row) of the flat-bottomed 96-well plates in order to evaluate background absorbance of culture medium.
- the corrected absorbances ("H" row background value subtracted) obtained at 490nm were plotted versus concentration of cytokine.
- Mutants were treated with proteases in order to identify resistant molecules.
- D.4 Protease resistance - Kinetic analysis The percent of residual IFN ⁇ -2b activity over time of exposure to proteases was evaluated by a kinetic study using either (a) 1 5 pg of chymotrypsin (1 0% wt/wt), (b) a lysate of human blood at dilution 1 /100, (c) 1 .5 pg of protease mixture, or (d) human serum. Incubation times were: 0 h, 0.5 h, 1 h, 4 h, 8 h, 1 6 h, 24 h and 48 h.
- proteolytic sample proteolytic sample
- serum serum
- bnlood proteolytic sample
- IFN ⁇ -2b 1 500 pg/ml (500U/ml)
- 10 ⁇ l of anti-proteases mixture, mini EDTA free, Roche one tablet was dissolved in 10 ml of DMEM and then diluted to 1 /500
- Biological activity assays were then performed as described for each sample in order to determine the residual activity at each time point.
- IFN ⁇ -2b mutants selected on the basis of their overall performance in vitro were tested for pharmacokinetics in mice in order to have an indication of their half-life in blood in vivo.
- Mice were treated by subcutaneous (SC) injection with alicuots of each of a number of selected lead mutants. Blood was collected at increasing time points between 0.5 and 48 hs after injection. Inmediatedly after collection, 20 ml of anti- protease solution were added to each blood sample. Serum was obtained for further analysis. Residual IFN- ⁇ activity in blood was determined using the tests described in the precedent sections for in vitro characterization. Wild-type IFN a (that had been produced in bacteria under comparable conditions as the lead mutants) as well as a pegylated derivative of IFN a, Pegasys (Roche), also were tested for pharmacokinetics in the same experiments.
- IFN ⁇ -2b for increased resistance to proteolysis.
- IFN ⁇ r -2b is administered as a therapeutic protein in the blood stream
- a set of proteases was identified that were expected to broadly mimic the protease contents in serum. From that list of proteases, a list of the corresponding target amino acids was identified (shown in parenthesis) as follows: -chymotrypsin (F, L, M, W, and Y), endoproteinase Arg-C (R), endoproteinase Asp-N (D), endoproteinase Glu- C (E), endoproteinase Lys-C (K) , and trypsin (K and R) Carboxypeptidase Y, which cleaves non-specifically from the carboxy-terminal ends of proteins, was also included in the protease mixture.
- PAM250 matrix based analysis was used (FIG7).
- the two highest values in PAM250 matrix corresponding to the highest occurrence of substitutions between residues ("conservative substitutions" or "accepted point mutations") , were chosen (FIG8) .
- conservative substitutions or "accepted point mutations”
- the following higher value was selected and the totality of conservative substitutions for this value was considered.
- the replacement of amino acids that are exposed on the surface by cysteine residues (as shown in FIG8, while replacing Y by H or I) was explicitly avoided, since this change would potentially lead to the formation of intermolecular disulfide bonds.
- PROTEOL http://www.infobiogen.fr
- a list of residues along the IFN ⁇ -2b sequence was established, which can be recognized as a substrate for different enzymes present in the serum. Because the number of residues in this particular list was high, the 3-dimensional structure of IFN ⁇ -2b obtained from the NMR structure of IFN ⁇ -2a (PDB code 1 ITF) was used to select only those residues exposed to the solvent.
- the percent of residual (anti-viral) activity for the IFN -2b E1 1 3H variant after treatment with chymotrypsin, protease mixture, blood lysate or serum was compared to the treated wild-type IFN ⁇ -2b. Selected IFN ⁇ -2b LEADs are shown in Table 2.
- a top and side view of IFN ⁇ -2b structure in ribbon representation depict residues in "space filling” defining (1 ) the "receptor binding region” as deduced either by “alanine scanning” data and studies by Piehler et al , J. Biol Chem. , 275:40425-40433, 2000, and Roisman et al., Proc. Natl Acad.
- N-glycosylation sites on the protein was a second strategy that was used to stabilize IFN ⁇ -2b
- Natural human IFN ⁇ -2b contains a unique O-glycosylation site at position 129 (the numbering corresponds to the mature protein; SEQ ID NO: 1 ), however, no N- glycosylation sites are found in this sequence.
- ⁇ -glycosylation sites are defined by the ⁇ -X-S or ⁇ -X-T consensus sequences. Glycosylation has been found to play a role in protein stability. For example, glycosylation has been found to increase bioavailability via higher metabolic stability and reduced clearance.
- IFN ⁇ -2b In order to generate more stable lFN ⁇ -2b variants, the N-glycosylation consensus sequences indicated above were introduced in the IFN ⁇ -2b sequence by mutagenesis. Variants of IFN ⁇ -2b carrying new glycosylation sites were assessed as previously described.
- the structure of IFN ⁇ -2b is characterized by a helix bundle composed of 5 helices (A, B, C, D and E) connected with each other by a series of loops (a large AB loop and three shorter BC, CD, DE loops). The helices are joined together by two disulfide bridges between residues 1 /98 and 29/1 38 of SEQ ID NO: 1 .
- the loops are contemplated herein to represent preferential sites for glycosylation given their exposure.
- N-glycosylation sites (N-X-S or N-X-T) were created in each of the loop sequences (Table 3) . Selected LEADs and pseudo wild-type IFN ⁇ -2b mutants after screening for addition of glycosylation sites are shown in Table 4.
- the use of the protein redesign approach provided herein permits the generation of proteins such that they maintain requisite levels and types of biological activity compared to the native protein while their underlying amino acid sequences have been significantly changed by amino acid replacement.
- an Ala-scan was performed on the IFN ⁇ -2b sequence.
- each amino acid in the IFN ⁇ -2b protein sequence was individually changed into Alanine. Any other amino acid, particularly another amino acid that has a neutral effect on structure, such as Gly or Ser, also can be used.
- HITs amino acid positions that are sensitive to replacement by Ala, referred to herein as HITs would in principle not be suitable targets for amino acid replacement to increase protein stability, because of their involvement in the activity of the molecule.
- the biological activity measured for the IFN ⁇ -2b molecules was: /) their capacity to inhibit virus replication when added to permissive cells previously infected with the appropriate virus and, ii) their capacity to stimulate cell proliferation when added to the appropriate cells.
- the relative activity of each individual mutant compared to the native protein was assayed.
- HITS are those mutants that produce a decrease in the activity of the protein (e.g., in this example, all the mutants with activities below about 30% of the native activity) .
- the Alanine-scan was used to identify the amino acid residues on IFN -2b that when replaced with alanine lead to a 'pseudo-wild type' activity, i.e., those that can be replaced by alanine without leading to a decrease in biological activity.
- mutant molecules were generated and phenotypically characterized such that IFN ⁇ -2b proteins with amino acid sequences different from the native ones but that still elicit the same level and type of activity as the native protein were selected. HITs and pseudo wild- type amino acid positions are shown in Table 5.
- mutants with additional mutations to those selected by the rational mutagenesis were generated in the E. coli MutS strain and were detected by sequencing.
- the mutants were the following: E41 Q/ D94G SEQ. ID No. 1 99; L1 1 7V/ A1 39G SEQ.ID No. 204; E41 H/ Y89H/ N45D SEQ.ID No. 198; and K1 21 Q/ P109A/ K1 33Q/ G102R SEQ.ID No. 204.
- the cDNA encoding IFN ⁇ was cloned into a mammalian expression vector, prior to the generation of the selected mutations. A collected of predesigned, targeted mutants was then generated such that each individual mutant was created and processed individually, physically separated form each other and in addressable arrays.
- the mammalian expression vector pSSV9 CMV 0.3 pA was engineered as follows: The pSSV9 CMV 0.3 pA was cut by PvuW and religated (this step gets rid of the ITR functions), prior to the introduction of a new EcoRI restriction site by Quickchange mutagenesis (Stratagene) .
- Seq Clal forward primer 5'-CTGATTATCAACCGGGGTACATAT-
- GATTGAC-ATGC-3' (S ⁇ Q ID NO: 1 84)
- Seq Xmnl reverse primer 5'-TACGGGATAATACCGCGCCACATA- GCAGAA-C-3' (S ⁇ Q ID NO: 1 85) . Then, the Xmn ⁇ -Cla ⁇ fragment containing the newly introduced EcoRI site was cloned into pSSV9 CMV 0.3 pA to replace the corresponding wild-type fragment and produce construct pSSV9-2 ⁇ coRI.
- the IFN tf-cDNA was obtained from the plNF/?1 (ATCC) construct. The sequence of the IFN ?-cDNA was confirmed by sequencing using the primers below:
- Seq forward primer 5'-CCTGATGAAGGAGGACTC-3' (SEQ ID NO: 1 86)
- Seq reverse primer 5'-CCAAGCAGCAGATGAGTC-3' (SEQ ID NO: 1 87) .
- the verified IFN ?-encoding cDNA first was cloned into the pTOPO- TA vector (Invitrogen) . After checking of the cDNA sequence by automatic DNA sequencing, the Hind ⁇ -Xba ⁇ fragment containing the IFN cDNA was subcloned into the corresponding sites of pSSV9-2EcoRl, leading to the construct pAAV-EcoRI-INFbeta (pNB-AAV-IFN beta) Finally the fragment Pvu II of plasmid pNB-AAV-IFN beta was subcloned in Pvull site of pUC 1 8 leading the final construct pUC-CMVIFNbetapA called pNAUT-IFNbeta
- IFN ⁇ was produced in CHO Chinese Hamster Ovarian cells
- IFN /? produced from transfected cells were screened following sequential biological assays as follows. Normalization of IFN ⁇ concentration from culture supernatants was performed by ELISA. IFN ⁇ concentrations from wild type, and mutants samples were estimated by using an international reference standard provided by the NIBSC, UK. Screening and in vitro charaterizat ⁇ on of IFN ⁇ mutants Two activities were measured directly on IFN samples: antiviral and antiproliferation activities. Dose (concentration) - response (activity) experiments for antiviral or antiproliferation activity allowed for the calculation of the 'potency' for antiviral and antiproliferation activities, respectively.
- Antiviral and antiproliferation activities also were measured after incubation with proteolytic samples such as specific proteases, mixtures of selected proteases, human serum or human blood. Assessment of activity following incubation with proteolytic samples allowed to determine the residual (antiviral or antiproliferation) activity an.d the respective kinetics of half-life upon exposure to proteases Antiviral activity - measured by Cytopathic Effects (CPE)
- Antiviral activity of IFN ⁇ was determined by the capacity of the cytokine to protect Hela cells against EMC (mouse encephalomyocarditis) virus-induced cytopathic effects.
- EMC mouse encephalomyocarditis
- a 1 /1000 EMC virus dilution solution was placed in each well, except for the cell control row. Plates were returned to the CO 2 incubator for 48 hours. Then, the medium was aspirated and the cells were stained for 1 hour with 100 ⁇ l of Blue staining solutio to determine the proportion of intact cells. Plates were washed in a distilled water bath. The cell bound dye was extracted using 100 ⁇ l of ethylene-glycol mono-ethyl-ether (Sigma). The absorbance of the dye was measured using an Elisa plate reader (Spectramax).
- the antiviral activity of INF ⁇ samples was determined as the concentration needed for 50% protection of the cells against EMC virus-induced cytopathic effects. For proteolysis experiments, each point of the kinetic was assessed at 800 and 400 pg/ml in triplicate.
- Anti-proliferative activity of IFN ⁇ was determined by assessing the capacity of the cytokine to inhibit proliferation of Daudi cells. Daudi cells (1 x10 4 cells) were seeded in flat-bottomed 96-well plates containing 50 ⁇ l/well of RPMI 1 640 medium supplemented with 10% SVF, 1 X glutamine and 1 ml of gentamicin. No cell was added to the last row ("H" row) of the flat-bottomed 96-well plates in order to evaluate background absorbance of culture medium.
- the corrected absorbances ("H" row background value subtracted) obtained at 49Onm were plotted versus concentration of cytokine.
- the percent of residual IFN ⁇ activity over time of exposure to proteases was evaluated by a kinetic study using 1 .5 pg of protease mixture. Incubation times were: 0 h, 0.5 h, 2 h, 4 h, 8 h, 1 2 h, 24 h and 48 h. Briefly, 20 ⁇ l of each proteolytic sample (proteases, serum, bnlood) was added to 100 ⁇ l of IFN ⁇ at 400 and 800 pg/ml and incubated for variable times, as indicated.
Landscapes
- Chemical & Material Sciences (AREA)
- Life Sciences & Earth Sciences (AREA)
- Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
- Genetics & Genomics (AREA)
- Organic Chemistry (AREA)
- Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
- Zoology (AREA)
- General Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
- Biophysics (AREA)
- General Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
- Wood Science & Technology (AREA)
- Molecular Biology (AREA)
- Bioinformatics & Cheminformatics (AREA)
- Biochemistry (AREA)
- Biotechnology (AREA)
- Biomedical Technology (AREA)
- Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
- Toxicology (AREA)
- Crystallography & Structural Chemistry (AREA)
- Bioinformatics & Computational Biology (AREA)
- Gastroenterology & Hepatology (AREA)
- Plant Pathology (AREA)
- Proteomics, Peptides & Aminoacids (AREA)
- Microbiology (AREA)
- Medicinal Chemistry (AREA)
- Analytical Chemistry (AREA)
- Ecology (AREA)
- Peptides Or Proteins (AREA)
- Measuring Or Testing Involving Enzymes Or Micro-Organisms (AREA)
Abstract
Description
Claims
Applications Claiming Priority (5)
Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
---|---|---|---|
US41025802P | 2002-09-09 | 2002-09-09 | |
US410258P | 2002-09-09 | ||
US45706303P | 2003-03-21 | 2003-03-21 | |
US457063P | 2003-03-21 | ||
PCT/IB2003/004255 WO2004022747A1 (en) | 2002-09-09 | 2003-09-08 | Rational directed protein evolution using two-dimensional rational mutagenesis scanning |
Publications (1)
Publication Number | Publication Date |
---|---|
EP1539950A1 true EP1539950A1 (en) | 2005-06-15 |
Family
ID=31981644
Family Applications (1)
Application Number | Title | Priority Date | Filing Date |
---|---|---|---|
EP03748392A Ceased EP1539950A1 (en) | 2002-09-09 | 2003-09-08 | Rational directed protein evolution using two-dimensional rational mutagenesis scanning |
Country Status (4)
Country | Link |
---|---|
EP (1) | EP1539950A1 (en) |
AU (1) | AU2003267700A1 (en) |
CA (1) | CA2498284A1 (en) |
WO (1) | WO2004022747A1 (en) |
Families Citing this family (21)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
US7647184B2 (en) | 2001-08-27 | 2010-01-12 | Hanall Pharmaceuticals, Co. Ltd | High throughput directed evolution by rational mutagenesis |
AU2003263552A1 (en) | 2002-09-09 | 2004-03-29 | Nautilus Biotech | Rational evolution of cytokines for higher stability, the cytokines and encoding nucleic acid molecules |
WO2006076014A2 (en) * | 2004-04-30 | 2006-07-20 | Government Of The United States Of America As Represented By The Secretary Of The Department Of Health And Human Services | Interferon-alpha constructs for use in the treatment of sars |
US7597884B2 (en) | 2004-08-09 | 2009-10-06 | Alios Biopharma, Inc. | Hyperglycosylated polypeptide variants and methods of use |
MX2007002557A (en) | 2004-09-03 | 2007-10-10 | Creabilis Therapeutics Spa | Protease resistant human and non-human hmgb1 box-a mutants and their therapeutic/diagnostic use. |
US7998930B2 (en) | 2004-11-04 | 2011-08-16 | Hanall Biopharma Co., Ltd. | Modified growth hormones |
CN101304758B (en) | 2005-06-29 | 2013-08-21 | 维兹曼科学研究所耶达研究与发展有限公司 | Recombinant interferon Alpha2 (IFNAlpha2) mutants |
WO2007110231A2 (en) * | 2006-03-28 | 2007-10-04 | Nautilus Biotech, S.A. | MODIFIED INTERFERON-β (IFN-β) POLYPEPTIDES |
US8383388B2 (en) | 2006-06-19 | 2013-02-26 | Catalyst Biosciences, Inc. | Modified coagulation factor IX polypeptides and use thereof for treatment |
KR100944034B1 (en) | 2007-04-19 | 2010-02-24 | 한올제약주식회사 | Oral dosage formulations of protease-resistant polypeptides |
JP2011520472A (en) | 2008-05-29 | 2011-07-21 | ハナル バイオファーマ カンパニー リミテッド | Modified erythropoietin (EPO) polypeptide exhibiting increased proteolytic enzyme resistance and pharmaceutical composition thereof |
CN102574907B (en) * | 2009-10-19 | 2015-10-21 | 韩诺生物制药株式会社 | The human tumor necrosis factor receptor I polypeptide of modifying or its fragment and prepare their method |
EA201700111A1 (en) | 2011-10-28 | 2018-02-28 | Тева Фармасьютикал Австралия Пти Лтд | POLYPEPTIDE STRUCTURES AND THEIR APPLICATION |
US11117975B2 (en) | 2013-04-29 | 2021-09-14 | Teva Pharmaceuticals Australia Pty Ltd | Anti-CD38 antibodies and fusions to attenuated interferon alpha-2B |
UA119352C2 (en) | 2014-05-01 | 2019-06-10 | Тева Фармасьютикалз Острейліа Пті Лтд | Combination of lenalidomide or pomalidomide and cd38 antibody-attenuated interferon-alpha constructs, and the use thereof |
MX2017005481A (en) | 2014-10-29 | 2017-10-26 | Teva Pharmaceuticals Australia Pty Ltd | Interferon a2b variants. |
US12006354B2 (en) | 2017-05-24 | 2024-06-11 | Novartis Ag | Antibody-IL2 engrafted proteins and methods of use in the treatment of cancer |
US11208485B2 (en) | 2018-10-11 | 2021-12-28 | Inhibrx, Inc. | PD-1 single domain antibodies and therapeutic compositions thereof |
TW202021986A (en) | 2018-10-11 | 2020-06-16 | 美商英伊布里克斯公司 | 5t4 single domain antibodies and therapeutic compositions thereof |
CN113166261A (en) | 2018-10-11 | 2021-07-23 | 印希比股份有限公司 | B7H3 single domain antibodies and therapeutic compositions thereof |
EP3864045A2 (en) | 2018-10-11 | 2021-08-18 | Inhibrx, Inc. | Dll3 single domain antibodies and therapeutic compositions thereof |
Family Cites Families (3)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
US5223409A (en) * | 1988-09-02 | 1993-06-29 | Protein Engineering Corp. | Directed evolution of novel binding proteins |
WO2001061344A1 (en) * | 2000-02-17 | 2001-08-23 | California Institute Of Technology | Computationally targeted evolutionary design |
US7647184B2 (en) * | 2001-08-27 | 2010-01-12 | Hanall Pharmaceuticals, Co. Ltd | High throughput directed evolution by rational mutagenesis |
-
2003
- 2003-09-08 CA CA002498284A patent/CA2498284A1/en not_active Abandoned
- 2003-09-08 AU AU2003267700A patent/AU2003267700A1/en not_active Abandoned
- 2003-09-08 WO PCT/IB2003/004255 patent/WO2004022747A1/en not_active Application Discontinuation
- 2003-09-08 EP EP03748392A patent/EP1539950A1/en not_active Ceased
Non-Patent Citations (1)
Title |
---|
See references of WO2004022747A1 * |
Also Published As
Publication number | Publication date |
---|---|
AU2003267700A1 (en) | 2004-03-29 |
CA2498284A1 (en) | 2004-03-18 |
WO2004022747A1 (en) | 2004-03-18 |
Similar Documents
Publication | Publication Date | Title |
---|---|---|
US20060020396A1 (en) | Rational directed protein evolution using two-dimensional rational mutagenesis scanning | |
US8057787B2 (en) | Protease resistant modified interferon-beta polypeptides | |
WO2004022747A1 (en) | Rational directed protein evolution using two-dimensional rational mutagenesis scanning | |
US7610156B2 (en) | Methods for rational pegylation of proteins | |
JP3712255B2 (en) | Methods for generating polynucleotide and polypeptide sequences | |
US20050202438A1 (en) | Rational directed protein evolution using two-dimensional rational mutagenesis scanning | |
EP0192811B1 (en) | Cysteine-depleted muteins of biologically active proteins, their preparation, formulations containing them, and structural genes, vectors and organisms, and their production, suitable for use in the preparation of said muteins | |
JP2003501035A (en) | Cytokines modified for stability | |
JPS61501627A (en) | DNA encoding human erythropoietin | |
Endrizzi et al. | Genomic sequence analysis of the mouse Naip gene array | |
WO2007008951A1 (en) | Compositions and methods for design of non-immunogenic proteins | |
Ahlroth | The chicken avidin gene family: organization, evolution and frequent recombination | |
JP2002534089A (en) | G-CSF mutant-equivalent nucleic acids and proteins having granulocyte-forming activity | |
Daumy et al. | Reduction of biological activity of murine recombinant interleukin-1β by selective deamidation at asparagine-149 | |
CA2418913A1 (en) | Peptide mimetics | |
KR101752775B1 (en) | Method of searching permissive sites for protein design and method of producing modified protein | |
LT4012B (en) | Process for the preparation of polipeptides |
Legal Events
Date | Code | Title | Description |
---|---|---|---|
PUAI | Public reference made under article 153(3) epc to a published international application that has entered the european phase |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: 0009012 |
|
17P | Request for examination filed |
Effective date: 20050411 |
|
AK | Designated contracting states |
Kind code of ref document: A1 Designated state(s): AT BE BG CH CY CZ DE DK EE ES FI FR GB GR HU IE IT LI LU MC NL PT RO SE SI SK TR |
|
AX | Request for extension of the european patent |
Extension state: AL LT LV MK |
|
DAX | Request for extension of the european patent (deleted) | ||
111L | Licence recorded |
Free format text: 0101 CREABILIS THERAPEUTICS S.R.L. Effective date: 20080402 |
|
APBK | Appeal reference recorded |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSNREFNE |
|
APBN | Date of receipt of notice of appeal recorded |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSNNOA2E |
|
APAF | Appeal reference modified |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSCREFNE |
|
APBT | Appeal procedure closed |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSNNOA9E |
|
STAA | Information on the status of an ep patent application or granted ep patent |
Free format text: STATUS: THE APPLICATION HAS BEEN REFUSED |
|
18R | Application refused |
Effective date: 20090615 |