Nothing Special   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

Battle of al-Harra: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
Ud817 (talk | contribs)
mNo edit summary
Tags: Visual edit Mobile edit Mobile web edit
restoring original version
(18 intermediate revisions by 17 users not shown)
Line 9:
| date = 26 August 683
| place = Harrat Waqim, northeastern outskirts of [[Medina]]
| coordinates = {{coordCoord|24|29|22|N|39|43|40|E|format=dms|type:event_region:SA-03|display=title,inline}}
| map_type = Saudi Arabia
| map_relief = yes
| map_size = 280
| map_caption = Location of the battle within modern [[Saudi Arabia]]
| result = [[Umayyad Caliphate|Umayyad]] victory
| combatant1 = Umayyads
*[[Bilad al-Sham|Syrian]] army
*[[Umayyad|Umayyad Army]]
*[[Umayyad dynasty|Banu Umayya]] of Medina
| combatant2 = People of [[Medina]]
* [[Ansar (Islam)|Ansar]]
* [[Muhajirun]] (including the [[Quraysh]])
| commander1 = {{Plain list|
* [[Muslim ibn Uqba]] <br />
* [[Marwan I|Marwan ibn al-Hakam]]
}}
| commander2 = [[Abd Allah ibn Hanzala]]{{KIA}} <br /> [[Abd Allah ibn Muti]] <br /> Ma'qil ibn Sinan al-Ashja'i{{executed}}
| commander2 = {{Plain list|
* [[Abd Allah ibn Hanzala]]{{KIA}}
* [[Abd Allah ibn Muti]]
* Ma'qil ibn Sinan al-Ashja'i
}}
| strength1 = 4,000–12,000
| strength2 = 2,000
| casualties1 = Unknown
| casualties2 = {{Plain list|
* 180–700 Ansar and Quraysh <br />
* 4,000–10,000 other Medinans after the battle
}}
| campaignbox = {{Campaignbox Second Fitna}}
}}
 
The '''Battle of al-Harra''' ({{lang-ar|يوم الحرة|translit=Yawm al-Ḥarra|lit=Day of al-Harra}}) was fought between the [[Bilad al-Sham|Umayyad]] army of the caliph [[Yazid I]] ({{reign|680|683}}) led by [[Muslim ibn Uqba]] and the defenders of [[Medina]] from the [[Ansar (Islam)|Ansar]] and [[Muhajirun]] factions, who had rebelled against the caliph. The battle took place at the [[lava field]] of Harrat Waqim in the northeastern outskirts of Medina on 26 August 683 and lasted less than a day.
 
The elite factions of Medina disapproved of the hereditary succession of Yazid (unprecedented in Islamic history until that point), resented the caliph's impious lifestyle, and chafed under Umayyad economic acts and policies. After declaring their rebellion, they besieged the [[Umayyad dynasty|Umayyad clan]] resident in Medina and dug a defensive trench around the city. The expeditionary force sent by Yazid and local Umayyads, who had since been released from the siege, encamped at Harrat Waqim, where the rebels confronted them. Despite an initial advantage, the Medinans were routed due to the defection of one of their factions, the Banu Haritha, which enabled Umayyad horse riders led by [[Marwan I|Marwan ibn al-Hakam]] to attack them from the rear.
 
Afterward, the army pillaged Medina for three days, though accounts of the plunder vary considerably. The Syrian army proceeded to besiege the rebel leader [[Abd Allah ibn al-Zubayr]] in [[Mecca]], though Ibn Uqba died en route. In contrast to Ibn al-Zubayr's call for a {{transl|ar|[[shura]]}} to decide the caliphate and his success in resisting the Umayyads, the rebels in Medina lacked a political program and military experience. The traditional Islamic sources list the Battle of al-Harra and its aftermath as one of the Umayyads' 'major crimes' and malign Ibn Uqba for his role in the plunder of Medina.{{sfn|Hawting|2000|pp=47–48}}
Line 38 ⟶ 49:
[[File:Basalt pavement in the Black Desert, eastern Jordan.jpg|thumb|left|upright=1|Basaltic stony ground of the eastern desert of modern [[Jordan]], characteristic of the wider region of {{transl|ar|[[Harrat al-Shamah|ḥarras]]}} that extend from the [[Hauran]] into western [[Arabia]]]]
 
The location of the battle was the lava field of Harrat Waqim, which straddles the eastern outskirts of [[Medina]] in the [[Hejaz]] (western [[Arabian Peninsula|Arabia]]).{{sfn|Smith|1994|p=110, note 534}}{{sfn|Vaglieri|1971|p=226}} It was named after the Waqim fortress of the [[Banu Qurayza]] tribe that had been resident in the area during the [[pre-Islamic Arabia|pre-Islamic period]] and was alternatively known as Harrat Bani Qurayza or Harrat Zuhra.{{sfn|Lecker|1985|p=44}} It formed part of the vast geological system of {{transl|ar|[[Harrat al-Shamah|ḥarras]]}} (basaltic deserts) which spanned the region east of the [[Hauran]] in [[Syria (region)|Syria]] southward to Medina's environs.{{sfn|Editors|1971|p=226}} As a result of the fame of the battle, Harrat Waqim was thenceforth referred to in Muslim sources as 'the Harra'.{{sfn|Vaglieri|1971|p=226}}
 
==Background==
Under the Islamic prophet [[Muhammad]], beginning in 622, and the first three caliphs, [[Abu Bakr]] ({{reign|632|634}}), [[Umar]] ({{reign|634|644}}) and [[Uthman]] ({{reign|644|656}}), Medina served as the capital of the [[Caliphate|early Muslim state]], which by Uthman's time came to rule over an empire spanning [[Arabia]], most of the Persian [[Sasanian Empire]] and the [[Byzantine Empire|Byzantine]] territories of [[Diocese of the East|Syria]] and [[Roman Egypt|Egypt]]. The capital was moved to [[Kufa]] in [[Sawad|Iraq]] by the fourth caliph, Muhammad's cousin and son-in-law [[Ali]] ({{reign|656|661}}), during the [[First Muslim Civil War]]. Ali's rival for the caliphate, the[[Mu'awiya]], governor of [[Bilad al-Sham|Syria]] [[Mu'awiya]], won the war and made [[Damascus]] capital of the [[Umayyad Caliphate]], which he founded in 661.{{citation needed|date=April 2023}}
 
===Political and pious opposition to Yazid===
The hereditary succession of Mu'awiya's son, [[Yazid I|Yazid]], in 680 was an unprecedented act in Islamic politics. It was a point of contention among the people of Medina, especially the eminent Muslim leaders of the Hejaz.{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|p=141–142}} One of them, [[Husayn ibn Ali|Husayn]], a son of Ali and grandson of Muhammad, left Medina to lead a revolt against Yazid in Iraq. He was slain alongside his band of about seventy followers at the [[Battle of Karbala]] by the forces of the Umayyad governor [[Ubayd Allah ibn Ziyad]]; Yazid is alleged to have put the head of Husayn on display in Damascus.{{sfn|Hawting|2000|p=50}}
 
In 680, Yazid dismissed his cousin [[al-Walid ibn Utba ibn Abi Sufyan]] from the governorship of Medina for having failed to prevent Husayn and the other major opponent to his rule, [[Abd Allah ibn al-Zubayr]], a grandson of Abu Bakr, from leaving Medina. Al-Walid's replacement, the Umayyad [[Amr ibn Sa'id al-Ashdaq]], failed to capture Ibn al-Zubayr, who took refuge in the [[Kaaba]] in [[Mecca]], or extract from him the [[bay'ah|oath of allegiance]] to Yazid. Al-Ashdaq mobilized a troop of Medinans enrolled in the army, as well as {{transl|ar|[[mawla|mawali]]}} (sing. {{transl|ar|mawla}}; non-Arab, Muslim freedmen or clients) of the Umayyad clan, to assault Ibn al-Zubayr, but many of the recruited Medinans were reticent to participate and paid others to fight in their place.{{sfn|Kister|1977|pp=34–35}} Ibn al-Zubayr defeated this force, and partly as a consequence, Yazid dismissed al-Ashdaq and reappointed al-Walid ibn Utba in August 681. Feigning an attempted reconciliation with the caliph, Ibn al-Zubayr requested that Yazid replace al-Walid ibn Utba with a milder governor. Yazid acceded, installing his young and politically inexperienced cousin [[Uthman ibn Muhammad ibn Abi Sufyan]] in December 682.{{sfn|Kister|1977|pp=35–36}}
 
Most of the Medinans, and many in the wider Muslim community, sympathized with Ibn al-Zubayr amid general uncertainty about the stability of Umayyad rule and the prospect of Ibn al-Zubayr coming to power.{{sfn|Kister|1977|pp=34–35}} Reports of impious behavior by Yazid, including entertainment by singing girls and a pet monkey, contributed to prevailing attitudes in Medina of his unsuitability as caliph.{{sfn|Hawting|2000|p=47}} The Medinans mainly consisted of the [[Ansar (Islam)|Ansar]] (native Medinans who had hosted and allied with Muhammad after his [[Hijrah|emigration from Mecca]] in 622) and the [[Muhajirun]] (Muhammad's early supporters who had emigrated with him). The Muhajirun were predominantly from the [[Quraysh]], the tribe to which Muhammad, Ali, and the Umayyads all belonged.{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|p=161}} At the time of the opposition to Yazid, the Medinans were mostly the children of these two factions, which collectively represented Islam's first military generation, and felt threatened at the potential loss of the inherited military pensions brought about by Umayyad fiscal reforms. The reforms called for pensions to be given only in exchange for active military service.{{sfn|Vaglieri|1971|p=226}}
Line 58 ⟶ 69:
 
==Prelude==
Uthman ibn Muhammad was unable to control the growing opposition to Umayyad rule.{{sfn|Vaglieri|1971|p=226}} According to the historian [[al-Mada'ini]] (d. 843), the inaugurating act of rebellion by the Medinans occurred during a gathering in the mosque where the attendees each tossed an article of clothing, such as a turban or a shoe, an Arab custom symbolizing a severing of ties, to renounce their allegiance to Yazid.{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|p=153}} According to the historian [[Abu Mikhnaf]] (d. 774), the first act of rebellion by the Medinans was giving allegiance to Ibn Hanzala.{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|pp=153–154}} Afterward, they assaulted the Umayyads and their supporters in the city, together about 1,000-strong, who fled to the quarter of their leading elder, [[Marwan I|Marwan ibn al-Hakam]].{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|p=154}} The latter sent urgent requests for assistance from Yazid,{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|p=154}}{{sfn|Vaglieri|1971|p=227}} who dispatched an army to suppress the opposition from both the Medinans and Ibn al-Zubayr.{{sfn|Hawting|2000|p=47}}
 
According to alternative accounts by al-Ya'qubi and [[al-Waqidi]] (d. 823), for up to a month leading to the battle, several attempts by the chief of Yazid's estates in Medina, Ibn Mina, to collect the crops for the caliph were disrupted by the estates' former owners, in particular from the Ansarite Balharith clan. Uthman ibn Muhammad responded by assigning a guard force to help Ibn Mina and his men gather the crops. They were met by a group of Ansar and Quraysh, who refused to allow the Umayyads' men to proceed with their work. Uthman ibn Muhammad then requested intervention by Yazid, who dispatched an expedition against the townspeople of Medina.{{sfn|Kister|1977|pp=38–39}} In these accounts, the Medinans expelled and pelted the Umayyads with stones in response to Uthman ibn Muhammad's rebukes to their leaders for barring the caliph's men from the estates.{{sfn|Kister|1977|p=38}}
Line 73 ⟶ 84:
The negotiations between Ibn Uqba and the Medinans faltered, and clashes ensued.{{sfn|Vaglieri|1971|p=227}} The Medinan horsemen marched against Ibn Uqba in the Harra,{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|p=155}} and may have advanced as far as Ibn Uqba's litter,{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|p=156}} from which he commanded his troops.{{sfn|Vaglieri|1971|p=227}} Upon their approach, Ibn Uqba confronted them on horseback and actively participated in the fighting.{{sfn|Vaglieri|1971|p=227}} The Medinans gained an early advantage,{{sfn|Vaglieri|1971|p=227}} but were ultimately overtaken by the Syrians and several Ansarite and Qurayshite notables were slain, including Ibn Hanzala, eight of his sons and a handful of other men from the Medinan elite.{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|p=156}}
 
Squadrons of Medinan {{transl|ar|mawali}}, fighting under the command of the {{transl|ar|mawla}} [[Yazid ibn Hurmuz]], defended a large section of the ditch, and held off an assault by the Syrians, refusing demands to surrender.{{sfn|Kister|1977|p=45}} The historians [[Wahb ibn Jarir]] (d. 822) and [[Ali ibn Ahmad al-Samhudi|al-Samhudi]] (d. 1533) held that Medinan lines were compromised by the defection of the Banu Haritha, whose members gave Marwan and his horse riders access through their quarter in Medina, enabling them to assault the Medinans at the Harra from the rear.{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|p=156}} The Quraysh under Ibn Muti fled the battlefield and headed for safety to Ibn al-Zubayr in Mecca.{{sfn|Vaglieri|1971|p=227}} According to al-Waqidi, the battle concluded on 26 August 683.{{sfn|Wellhausen|1927|p=156}} The fighting lasted less than a day.{{sfn|Kister|1977|p=49}}
 
==Aftermath==
Line 88 ⟶ 99:
 
==References==
{{reflistReflist|30em20em}}
 
==Sources==
* {{citeCite book |last1=Anthony |first1=Sean W. |editor1-last=Pomerantz |editor1-first=Maurice A. |editor2-last=Shahin |editor2-first=Aram A. |title=The Heritage of Arabo-Islamic Learning: Studies Presented to Wadad Kadi |year=2016 |publisher=Brill |location=Leiden and Boston |isbn=978-90-04-30590-8 |pages=3–27 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=sa-8CgAAQBAJ |chapter=The Meccan Prison of ʿAbdallāh b. al-Zubayr and the Imprisonment of Muḥammad b. al-Ḥanafiyya }}
* {{citeCite book |last1=Biesterfeldt |first1=Hinrich |last2=Günther |first2=Sebastian |title=The Works of Ibn Wāḍiḥ al-Yaʿqūbī (Volume 3): An English Translation |date=2018 |publisher=Brill |location=Leiden |isbn=978-90-04-35621-4 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=OHxTDwAAQBAJ }}
* {{EI2 |article=ʿAbd Allāh ibn al-Zubayr |last=Gibb |first=H. A. R. |authorlink=H. A. R. Gibb |volume=1 |pages=54–55}}
* {{The First Dynasty of Islam|edition=Second}}
* {{The History of al-Tabari |volume=19 |url={{Google Books |zubkdYvBJpIC |plainurl=y}}}}
* {{citeCite book |last=Kister |first=M. J. |authorlink=Meir Jacob Kister |editor=Myriam Rosen Ayalon |title=Studies in Memory of Gaston Wiet |year=1977 |publisher=Institute of Asian and African Studies |location=Jerusalem |chapter=The Battle of the Ḥarra: Some Socio-Economic Aspects |pages=33–49}}
* {{citeCite book |title=Islamic Revolution and Historical Memory: An Inquiry Into the Art of ʻAbbāsid Apologetics |first=Jacob |last=Lassner |publisher=American Oriental Society |year=1986 }}
* {{citeCite journal |last1=Lecker |first1=Michael |title=Muhammad at Medina – A Geographical Approach |journal=Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam |date=1985 |volume=6 |pages=29–62 }}
* {{citeCite book |last=Lecker |first=Michael |chapter=The Jewish Reaction to the Islamic Conquests |title=Dynamics in the History of Religions Between Asia and Europe: Encounters, Notions, and Comparative Perspectives |editor1-last=Krech |editor1-first=Volkhard |editor2-last=Steinicke |editor2-first=Marion |year=2011 |publisher=Brill |isbn=978-90-04-18500-5 |chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=kS1DNvzjO9sC&pg=PA179 }}
* {{EI2 |article=Ḥarra |volume=3 |pages=226 |ref=CITEREFEditors1971}}
* {{The History of al-Tabari |volume=14 |url={{Google Books |fRjsrA5tfLIC&pg=PA110 |plainurl=y}}}}
* {{EI2 |article=Al-Ḥarra |last=Vaglieri |first=L. Veccia |authorlink=Laura Veccia Vaglieri |volume=3 |pages=226–227}}
* {{The Arab Kingdom and its Fall}}
 
==Further reading==
* {{citeCite book |last1last=Bewley |first1first=Aisha |authorlink=Aisha Bewley |date=2000 |title=The Men of Madina by Muhammad Ibn Sa'd, Vol. 2 |datevolume=20002 |publisher=Ta-Ha Publishers |isbn=978-1897940907}}
 
{{authority control}}