User talk:Jedi3: Difference between revisions
cleanup Tag: Blanking |
→Be careful: new section |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Be careful == |
|||
At one page you created, [[Sikandar Butshikan]], you've added a false quote about Ferishta mentioning Martand and its destruction. However, there is no mentioning of any Martand by name in his work's translation. (https://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.501767/2015.501767.history-of#page/n505/mode/1up) Therefore, I had to remove your quote using translation of Ferishta's work as source. |
|||
While it mentions a temple by Raja Bulnath which I assume might be about Martand, it never once refers it as Martand Temple. Your source doesn't even cite any page number. I haven't found any 1981 version but regardless I haven't found Martand in any version of Ferishta's work anywhere. |
|||
Judging from you not even mentioning the page number where Martand is mentioned, I don't think you checked the source for Martand before adding the quote. Please be careful, and do not add something that is made up. If someone else made a notable claim it was there, then it may be added as disputed. But you only used the primary source ie. Ferishta himself who never mentions it. Making edits that are not in source is basically an unsourced edit. [[User:MonsterHunter32|MonsterHunter32]] ([[User talk:MonsterHunter32|talk]]) 22:35, 15 February 2018 (UTC) |
|||
Revision as of 22:35, 15 February 2018
Be careful
At one page you created, Sikandar Butshikan, you've added a false quote about Ferishta mentioning Martand and its destruction. However, there is no mentioning of any Martand by name in his work's translation. (https://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.501767/2015.501767.history-of#page/n505/mode/1up) Therefore, I had to remove your quote using translation of Ferishta's work as source.
While it mentions a temple by Raja Bulnath which I assume might be about Martand, it never once refers it as Martand Temple. Your source doesn't even cite any page number. I haven't found any 1981 version but regardless I haven't found Martand in any version of Ferishta's work anywhere.
Judging from you not even mentioning the page number where Martand is mentioned, I don't think you checked the source for Martand before adding the quote. Please be careful, and do not add something that is made up. If someone else made a notable claim it was there, then it may be added as disputed. But you only used the primary source ie. Ferishta himself who never mentions it. Making edits that are not in source is basically an unsourced edit. MonsterHunter32 (talk) 22:35, 15 February 2018 (UTC)