Abstract
Vessel traffic services (VTS) are maritime traffic monitoring systems used in port approaches, confined or congested waters. VTS operators (VTSOs) monitor a specific geographical area and support and direct ships that sail through the area, primarily making the navigating officer or pilot of each ship aware of the current traffic situation, local weather and geographical conditions. We used an interactive mid-fidelity simulation as a knowledge eliciting tool to explore the work situation of VTSOs. During the simulation, VTSOs from a VTS centre in Sweden ran a scenario based on a normal traffic situation in their local fairway. Results indicate that the VTSOs, even though they are well aware of crucial events in the fairway, at times choose not to inform navigating officers or pilots of these safety aspects apart from when subject to protocol. The present paper put forward elements behind this form of miscommunication and presents results indicating that the major contributing factor is the VTSOs’ anticipation of negative attitudes between working groups participating in the VTS system and the lack of sufficient regulation with regard to the role and responsibilities of VTSOs.
Similar content being viewed by others
Explore related subjects
Discover the latest articles, news and stories from top researchers in related subjects.References
Belous I (2007) MAXQDA2007. http://www.maxqda.com/, Berlin, Germany
Billings CE, Cheaney ES (1981) Information transfer problems in the aviation system, vol NASA-TP-1875; A-8567. Ames Research Center, Washington
Bonini D (2005) A model of trust in the work of an air traffic controller. University of Dublin, Dublin
Brodje A, Lützhöft M, Dahlman J (2010) The Whats, Whens, Whys and Hows of VTS operators use of sensor information. In: Turan O, Bos J, Stark J, Colwell JL (eds) International conference on human performance at sea, Glasgow. University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, pp 161–172
Brodje A, Prison J, Jenvald J, Dahlman J (2011) Applied cognitive task analysis as a tool for analyzing work demands in a C4I environment: a case study using a mid-fidelity simulation. In: de Waard D, Gérard N, Onnasch L, Wiczorek R, Manzey D (eds) Human centred automation. Shaker Publishing, Maastricht, pp 313–326
Chang SJ (2004) Development and analysis of AIS applications as an efficient tool for vessel traffic service. In: OCEANS ‘04. MTTS/IEEE TECHNO-OCEAN ‘04, pp 2249–2253
Corbin JM, Strauss A (2008) Basics of qualitative research, 3rd edn. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks
Cummings ML, Marquez JJ, Roy N (2012) Human-automated path planning optimization and decision support. Int J Hum Comput Stud 70(2):116–128. doi:10.1016/j.ijhcs.2011.10.001
Dalinger E, Motz F (2010) Designing a decision support system for maritime security incident response. In: Turan O, Bos J, Stark J, Colwell JL (eds) International conference on human performance at Sea. University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, Glasgow, pp 181–188
Darbra RM, Crawford JFE, Haley CW, Morrison RJ (2007) Safety culture and hazard risk perception of Australian and New Zealand maritime pilots. Mar Policy 31(6):736–745. doi:10.1016/j.marpol.2007.02.004
Devoe DB, Royal JW, Abernethy CN (1979) New Orleans vessel traffic service watchstander analysis. Washington, DC, United States
Devoe DB, Royal JW, Abernethy CN (1980) Simulation of coast guard vessel traffic service operations by model and experiment. Transportation Systems Center, Cambridge
Grover MD (1983) A pragmatic knowledge acquisition methodology. In: Bundy A (ed) IJCAI-83, Los Altos. Morgan Kaufmann Publishers Inc., San Francisco, pp 436–438
Grundevik P, Hüffmeier J, Wilske E (2008) BaSSy—decision support tool för VTS operators (trans: Department SR). SSPA Sweden AB, Gothenburg
Harre I (2000) AIS adding new quality to VTS systems. J Navig 53(03):527–539
Harris D (2011) Human performance on the flight deck. Ashgate Publishing Limited, Farnhamn
Hill JH (1983) San Francisco vessel traffic service/maritime community interrelationship (trans: Center TS). U.S. Department of Transportation, Cambridge
Hoffman RR (1987) The problem of extracting the knowledge of experts from the perspective of experimental-psychology. AI Mag 8(2):53–67
Hopkin DV (1995) Human factors in air traffic control. Taylor & Francis, London
IALA (2008) IALA—vessel traffic services manual, 4 edn. International Association of Marine Aids to Navigation and Lighthouse Authorities, Saint Germain en Laye, France
Kharchenko V, Vasylyev V (2002) Application of the intellectual decision making system for vessel traffic control. In: Microwaves, radar and wireless communications, 2002. MIKON-2002. 14th international conference on, 2002, vol 632, pp 639–642
Kharchenko V, Vasylyev V (2004) Decision-making system for vessel traffic planning and radar control. In: 1st European radar conference EURAD, pp 61–64
Kidd JS, Boyes F (1959) Input distortion and observer overlap in decision-making. Manag Sci (pre-1986) 6(1):123
Krivonos PD (2007) Communication in aviation safety: lessons learned and lessons required. Paper presented at the 2007 Regional Seminar of the Australian and New Zeeland Societies of Air Safety Investigators, Wellington, New Zeeland, 9–10 June 2007
Midwood SA, Glenn IN, Tummala M (1998) A multi sensor data fusion algorithm for the USCG’S vessel traffic services system. In: ISCAS ‘98—IEEE international symposium on circuits and systems, pp 545–548
Militello L, Hutton R (1998) Applied cognitive task analysis (ACTA): a practitioner’s toolkit for understanding cognitive task demands. Ergonomics 41(11):1618–1641
Militello L, Hutton R, Pliske R, Knight B, Klein G (1997) Applied cognitive task analysis (ACTA) methodology. Navy Personnel Research and Development Center, San Diego
Mosier KL, Rettenmaier P, McDearmid M, Wilson J, Mak S, Raj L, Orasanu J (2010) Pilot/ATC communication conflicts: implications for nextgen. In: San Francisco, CA, 54th human factors and ergonomics society annual meeting 2010, HFES 2010, pp 1521–1525
Nuutinen M, Savioja P, Sonninen S (2007) Challenges of developing the complex socio-technical system: realising the present, acknowledging the past, and envisaging the future of vessel traffic services. Appl Ergonomics 38(5):513–524
Praetorius G, Bruno K, Lützhöft M (2010) The context matters: maritime safety in the vessel traffic service (VTS) domain. In: Reliability, risk and safety. Back to the Future (Proceedings of ESREL 2010)
Proceedings: symposium on piloting and VTS systems (1979). Symposium on Piloting and VTS Systems. National Academy of Sciences, Washington
Riveiro M, Falkman G, Ziemke T (2008) Improving maritime anomaly detection and situation awareness through interactive visualization. In: Proceedings of the 11th international conference on information fusion, FUSION 2008, Cologne
SAIB (2010) Rapport RS 2010:03 Grundstötning av fartyget Stena Danica efter närsituation med Tor Magnolia vid Gäveskär, O län, den 10 januari 2008 (trans: Department M). Swedish Accident Investigation Board, Stockholm, Sweden
Sonninen S, Nuutinen M, Rosqvist T (2006) Development process of the Gulf of Finland mandatory ship reporting system reflections on the methods
Swedish Transport Agency (2009) Transportstyrelsens föreskrifter och allmänna råd om sjötrafikinformationstjänst (VTS) och sjötrafikrapporteringssystem (SRS). TSFS 2009:56. Swedish Transport Agency, Norrköping, Sweden
Tsou MC, Hsueh CK (2010) The study of ship collision avoidance route planning by ant colony algorithm. J Mar Sci Technol 18(5):746–756
Warren WR, Igel G, Blickensderfer EL (2008) A survey of attitudes: air traffic controller and pilot teamwork. In: 2008 Florida student conference on human factors and applied psychology, Daytona Beach, FL, United States. Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University
Wever R, Van Es G, Verbeek M (2006) Air-ground communication safety: causes and recommendations, 1.1 edn (trans: DAP/SAF E). National Aerospace Laboratory NLR, Brussels
Wickens CD, Mavor AS, McGee JP (eds) (1997) Flight to the future: human factors in air traffic control. The National Academies Press, Washington
Wiersma E (2000) Situation awareness in vessel traffic service operation. In: Kaber DB, Endsely MR (eds) 1. Human performance, situation awareness and automation conference, Savannah, United States, pp 280–285
Wiersma E, Butter R (eds) (2002) Situation awareness in maritime traffic control: a comparison of two methods. Human Factors in Transportation, Communication, Health, and the Workplace. Shaker, Maastricht, The Netherlands
Wiersma E, Mastenbroek N (1998) Measurement of vessel traffic service operator performance. AI Soc 12:78–86
Wiersma E, Mastenbroek N, Wulder JH (eds) (1999) SATEST: the 1997 Rotterdam experiment on VTS operator performance. Analysis, design and evaluation of man-machine systems 1998. Elsevier Science Bv, Amsterdam
Wiersma E, Butter R, van’t Padje W (2000a) A human factors approach to assessing VTS operator performance. Paper presented at the TRAIL 6th Annual Congress, Delft, The Netherlands
Wiersma E, Jarvis D, Granholm G (2000b) VTS operator performance and acceptance of a short-term path prediction display in a low density traffic area. In: IEA 2000/HFES 2000, pp 136–139
Xie L, Chu X, Huang M, Yan Z (2011) Vessel traffic flow detection and tracking in river. In: Wuhan, 2011. 1st International conference on transportation information and safety: multimodal approach to sustained transportation system development—information, technology, implementation, ICTIS 2011, pp 1788–1797
Acknowledgments
The authors of this paper would specifically like to thank the VTSOs for their participation in this study as well as the VTS Manager for letting us borrow time and space from their valuable work. The authors would also like to express our gratitude to the Saab Transpondertech AB and the Swedish Maritime Administration for financing the study.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brodje, A., Lundh, M., Jenvald, J. et al. Exploring non-technical miscommunication in vessel traffic service operation. Cogn Tech Work 15, 347–357 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10111-012-0236-5
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10111-012-0236-5