Abstract
While the recording industry continues to lobby for increasingly draconian laws to protect their interests, users of digital technology continue to share files and copy protected music. This paper considers the ethics of copying and argues that legal measures are unlikely to solve the music industry’s problems in the age of digital reproduction. It begins with a review of the legal arguments around copyright legislation and notes that the law is currently unclear and contested. Adapting the game “scruples” to questions of what is and is not considered theft, a qualitative study reflects on the ways that ethical positions around new media are reached and articulated. The findings relate ethical positions constructed around notions of resistance, intangibility and identity. It is argued that the global online population cannot be policed without consent and that mechanics of artist reimbursement must be developed that account for consumers’ technology scruples. File sharing is then considered not as a legal problem but as a design challenge and a strategy of enchantment is suggested. The design concept of a digital music box is outlined to illustrate strategies of enchantment rather than litigation and intimidation.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Spinello R, Tavani H (2001) The Internet, ethical values and conceptual frameworks: an introduction to CyberEthics. Comput Soc 31(2):5–7
Walton T (2003) Golden age of free music’ vs ‘copying is stealing’. The Register. Published Wednesday 6th August 2003
Rasch M (2003) Copying is theft—and other legal myths. The Register. Published Monday 28th July 2003
Lettice J (2004) Music biz in unauthorized downloads shock. The Register. Published Thursday 4th November 2004
Gilmour I (2004) Out of bounds reviewing the reading nation in the romantic period by William St Clair, vol 27, no. 2. London Review of Books, Cambridge
Vance A (2005) Music sales slide despite RIAA’s crushing blows against piracy. The Register. Published Saturday 31st December 2005 22:24 GMT
Teather D (2005a) Music industry victory will spark file-sharing lawsuits. The Guardian, 28th July 2005
Smith T (2005a) RIAA Aussie Kazaa users told to stop using Kazaa. The Register. Tuesday 6th December 2005
Woodworth GM (2004) Hackers, users, and suits: napster and representations of identity. Popular Music Soc 27(2):161–184
Foucault M (1991) In: Rabinow P (ed) The Foucault reader. Penguin books, London
Gross G (2005) New copyright protection bills likely in 2005. The Standard.com, Thursday, 27th of January, 2005
Jones S, Lenhart A (2004) Music downloading and listening: findings from the pew Internet and American life project. Popular Music Soc 27(2)
Adam A (2000) Gender and computer ethics. ACM SIGCAS Comput Soc 30(4), Special Issue: CEPE 2000, pp 17–24
Strauss A, Corbin J (1990) Basics of qualitative research: grounded theory procedures and techniques. Sage Publications, Newbury Park
Taylor AS, Harper R (2002) Age-old practices in the ‘new world’: a study of gift-giving between teenage mobile phone users. Proceedings of CHI 2002, Minneapolis, MN, pp 439–446
Willis P (1990) Common culture. Open University Press, Milton Keynes
Morson GS, Emerson C (1990) Mikhail Bakhtin: creation of a prosaics. Stanford University Press, Stanford
Bakhtin MM (1984) Problems of Dostoevsky’s poetics. University of Minnesota
Crowley T (1996) Language in history: theories and texts. Routledge, London
Vance A (2005b) Sue the reader of this file sharing book. Book Review. The Register. Published 22nd February 2005
Preece J, Rogers Y, Sharp H (2000) Interaction design: beyond human–computer interaction. Wiley, New York
Dourish P (2001) Where the action is: the foundations of embodied interaction. MIT Press, Cambridge
McCarthy JC, Wright PC (2004) Technology as experience. MIT Press, Cambridge
Norman DA (2004) Emotional design: why we love (or hate) everyday things. Basic Books, New York
Shneiderman B (2002) Leonardo’s laptop. MIT Press, Cambridge
Blythe M, Monk A, Overbeeke C, Wright PC (eds) (2003) Funology: from usability to user enjoyment. Kluwer, Dordrecht
McCarthy J, Wright P, Wallace J, Dearden A (2006). The experience of enchantment in human–computer interaction. Pers Ubiquitous Comput 10(6):369–378
Clarke AC (2000) Profiles of the Future: an inquiry into the limits of the possible, Millennium edn. Indigo, London
Kundera M (1991) Immortality. Faber & Faber, London, Boston, p 84
Stivers R (2001) Technology as magic: the triumph of the irrational. The Continuum, New York
Gell A (1992) The technology of enchantment and the enchantment of technology. In: Coote J et al (eds) Anthropology, art, and aesthetics. Clarendon, Oxford, pp 40–63
Adorno T (1991) The cultural industries: selected essays on mass culture. Routledge, London
Willis P (1978) Profane culture. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London
Brook T (2003) Position paper for a workshop on designing culturally situated technologies for the home. Proceedings of CHI 2003. ACM
Wallace J, Press M (2004) Craft knowledge for the digital age: how the jeweller can contribute to designing digital communication devices. Proceedings of the 6th Asian design conference, Japan
Wensveen S, Overbeeke K, Djajadiningrat T (2004) Freedom of fun, freedom of interaction. In: Blythe M, Hassenzahl M, Wright P (eds) More funology. Interact Mag 11.5:59–61
Pine and Gilmore (1999) The experience economy: work is theatre and every business is a stage. Harvard Business School Press, Boston
Falk J, Dirking L (1992) The museum experience. Whalesback Books, Washington DC
Wright PC, McCarthy JM, Meekison L (2003) A framework for analysing user experience. In: Blythe M, Monk A, Wright PC, Overbeeke C (eds) Funology: from usability to user enjoyment. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Schou S, Toft R (2005) A theoretical model for experience and social interaction in digitally enhanced environments. Proceedings of the 6th DAC conference IT university of Copenhagen 1st–3rd, pp 162–168
Jay M (2005) Songs of experience: modern american and european variations on a universal theme. University of California Press, California
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Blythe, M., Wright, P. Technology scruples: why intimidation will not save the recording industry and how enchantment might. Pers Ubiquit Comput 12, 411–420 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00779-007-0158-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00779-007-0158-z