Aim/Purpose: Continuing low percentage of on-time-completion of doctoral studies suggest the expl... more Aim/Purpose: Continuing low percentage of on-time-completion of doctoral studies suggest the exploration of new approaches to the process is desirable. Background: PhD studies may be viewed as a project- it is a temporary endeavor undertaken to create a unique product. Project management practices have proven to be helpful in numerous domains. Methodology: Process analysis method will be applied, using: 1) semi-structured interviews with supervisors and supervisee, 2) data gathered by the school of advance graduate studies in higher education institute. Contribution: The research will explore the appropriated measurable indicators of successful PhD and identify project management practices that promote better process and outcomes of PhD studies. Impact on Society: Better and more efficient process will support lower individual and national spending on doctoral studies Future Research: Further research should explore relevance of the findings in various settings (characteristics of t...
This paper analyzes the factors involved in successful implementation of innovative pedagogical p... more This paper analyzes the factors involved in successful implementation of innovative pedagogical practices using ICT in ten Israeli schools. The research questions addressed are: 1. What is the configuration and intensity level of the various factors involved in the implementation of innovative pedagogical practices using ICT in schools? 2. Can a connection be identified between the level of intensity of the different factors affecting the innovation and the level of change in various domains of innovation (e.g., teacher role, student role, curriculum, and time and space configurations)? Data from ten case studies in Israeli schools were analyzed using the framework developed to measure the intensity of the factors involved in the innovation. Infrastructure, factors within the school, school climate and educational policy were found to be the most involved categories. These factors mostly affect aspects of the innovation related to teacher roles, instructional contents and teaching m...
The rapid and pervasive implementation of new information and communication technologies (ICT) in... more The rapid and pervasive implementation of new information and communication technologies (ICT) in the education system raises expectations regarding its potential for and contribution to the improvement of education. In spite of the accelerated implementation pace of ICT ...
Human Technology is an interdisciplinary, scholarly journal that presents innovative, peer-review... more Human Technology is an interdisciplinary, scholarly journal that presents innovative, peer-reviewed articles exploring the issues and challenges surrounding human-technology interaction and the human role in all areas of our ICT-infused societies. Human Technology is published by the Agora Center, University of Jyväskylä and distributed without a charge online.
ICT Innovations 2 For more than two decades systematic effort has been made by the Israeli Minist... more ICT Innovations 2 For more than two decades systematic effort has been made by the Israeli Ministry of Education and various educational agents to facilitate the nationwide implementation of information and communication technologies (ICT) in schools. In the last decade, two significant phases of this effort can be identified. The first, between the years 1993-1998, focused mainly on building the technological infrastructure within schools. The second stage (between the years 1998-2003) deal primarily with curricular and staff training aspects. This paper presents data collected between the years 1999-2000 for the OECD/CERI international research of ICT and Organizational Innovation in five Israeli schools that have widely implemented ICT in a way that has provoked substantial organizational change. In this paper we analyze the data collected from two perspectives: (a) using an innovation analysis framework for characterizing ICT-based educational innovations examining the levels of...
Purpose: The purpose of the present study is to explore the process, routines, and structuration ... more Purpose: The purpose of the present study is to explore the process, routines, and structuration at successful schools leading their students to high achievements. Method: The approach of building a theory from case study research together with process perspective and an organizational routines model were applied to analyzing seven successful Israeli high schools that bring their students to high academic outcomes. Findings: Five processes were found to operate cyclically during the school year: building a vision-oriented senior leadership team, enhancing students’ choice, developing a student-oriented class schedule, organizing an exam system, and mapping each student. Each process comprises several routines that present structuration by the alignment of their ostensive, performative, and artifact aspects. Research Limitations/Implications: The fact that the selected schools demonstrated extreme cases of high achievement limit the generalizability of the findings, but nonetheless i...
International Journal of Public Sector Management, 2008
PurposeInterorganizational cooperation (IOC) is like harnessing a swan, a crab, and a pike to a s... more PurposeInterorganizational cooperation (IOC) is like harnessing a swan, a crab, and a pike to a single wagon and still expecting it to go. One issue that appears significant under such conditions is building trust and inscribing it into the structure of IOC. The purpose of this study is to explore the relationships between trust and IOC structure.Design/methodology/approachTrust‐structure relationships are studied by drawing upon a case study of complex and effective IOC in The Early Childhood Center in Israel.FindingsThe analysis reveals several structural factors that support the building and maintenance of trust: choice of contribution, involvement in decision making, committee configuration, IOC culture, the director's role, and the representatives' high‐ranking positions and professional background.Research limitations/implicationsThree conditions help to inscribe trust into IOC structure: Low risk and minor expectations from the IOC, a leader willing to share informati...
The study reported here is based on the results of two international studies: IEA’s Second Inform... more The study reported here is based on the results of two international studies: IEA’s Second Information Technology in Education Study (SITES) Module 2, focusing on innovative pedagogical practices at the classroom level, and OECD/CERI Case Studies of ICT and Organizational Innovation, focusing on ICT related innovations at the school system level. In the paper we analyze the data collected in ten innovative schools in Israel which have incorporated ICT in unique ways and have succeeded in devising innovative classroom pedagogies and school system changes. The major research questions addressed are: (a) What levels of innovation were observed in the participant schools, and in which domains? (b) How does the level of innovation in the various domains vary among and within schools? (c) What correlation patterns among levels of innovation in the various domains can be identified? The results of ten comprehensive case studies of exemplary schools in Israel were analyzed by mean of the in...
ICT PEDAGOGICAL INNOVATIONS In the paper we analyze the data collected in ten schools in Israel w... more ICT PEDAGOGICAL INNOVATIONS In the paper we analyze the data collected in ten schools in Israel which have incorporated ICT in unique ways and have succeeded in devising innovative classroom pedagogies and changes in teachers and students roles and outcomes. The major research questions addressed are: (a) What levels of innovation were observed in the participant schools, and in which domains? (b) How does the level of innovation in the various domains vary among and within schools? (c) What correlation patterns among levels of innovation in the various domains can be identified? The results of ten comprehensive case studies of exemplary schools in Israel were analyzed by mean of the innovation analysis schema developed by us for characterizing ICT-based educational innovations. The findings indicate that most schools as such are in transition stage towards fully innovative pedagogical implementation of ICT; school activities are effected differentially by ICT, thus creating "i...
The study reported here is based on the results of two international studies: IEA’s Second Inform... more The study reported here is based on the results of two international studies: IEA’s Second Information Technology in Education Study (SITES) Module 2, focusing on innovative pedagogical practices at the classroom level, and OECD/CERI Case Studies of ICT and Organizational Innovation, focusing on ICT related innovations at the school system level. In the paper we analyze the data collected in ten innovative schools in Israel which have incorporated ICT in unique ways and have succeeded in devising innovative classroom pedagogies and school system changes. The major research questions addressed are: (a) What levels of innovation were observed in the participant schools, and in which domains? (b) How does the level of innovation in the various domains vary among and within schools? (c) What correlation patterns among levels of innovation in the various domains can be identified? The results of ten comprehensive case studies of exemplary schools in Israel were analyzed by mean of the in...
This symposium presents ten years of an Israeli laboratory school, which was established on resea... more This symposium presents ten years of an Israeli laboratory school, which was established on research and development (R & D) principles. First, David Chen presents four major requirements for R&D strategy: new theoretical foundation, educational research, laboratories schools and diffusion mechanisms. Second, Nir Chen presents the architectural perspective and describes ways by which school building promotes new pedagogy. Third, Yafa Ben-Amy explains how the school and, especially the "home" - the basic organizational unit, work. Finally, Dorit Tubin shows some of the evidence with regards to the schools success.
Introduction Over the past few years, as part of the Information and Communication Technology (IC... more Introduction Over the past few years, as part of the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) reform on the one hand, and the increased demands for school accountability on the other, more and more schools have launched a school website aimed at enhancing educational activities, supporting student-teacher communication, contributing to school marketing efforts, and fostering accountability to and collaboration with the school's constituency (Hesketh & Selwyn, 1999; Maddux & Johnson, 2006; Miodusar, Nachmias, Tubin, & Forkosh-Baruch, 2003). A large body of research on ICT-based pedagogical and educational websites (i.e., websites that focus on subject matters and learning activities) reveals the contributions of such websites to the schooling process (Kozma, 2003; Miodusar, Nachmias, Lahav, & Oren, 2000; Pelgrum & Anderson, 2001; Plomp, Anderson, Law, & Quale, 2003). However, the phenomenon of school websites, which serve the school organization in its entirety, remains rel...
The educational enterprise is one of the largest social organizations on earth. It encompasses ab... more The educational enterprise is one of the largest social organizations on earth. It encompasses about 50 million teachers, over a billion students, with teaching and learning in quite a universal mode called schooling. Knowledge, time and space are harnessed in a standardized pattern expecting an output of school graduates ready to be full participants in society, culture and the economy. Yet, at the entry of the third millennium, education has universally failed to come even close to fulfill its promises.
PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to present the successful school and principal (SSP) model, w... more PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to present the successful school and principal (SSP) model, which has developed over 13 years of Israeli involvement in the ISSPP study.Design/methodology/approachThis is a conceptual paper summarizing the findings of more than 20 case studies of successful, coasting and low-performing schools and their principals, into the SSP model. In all the cases, ISSPP protocols were used to collect the data, and the findings were analyzed in accordance with the organizational approach and organizational routine theory.FindingsThe explanatory SSP model comprises three cyclical phases that explain cause–effect relationships and presents intervention points for school improvement toward success. The first phase is an organizational restructuring of two core routines: the school schedule routine and the school tracking routine, which shape and affect school staff behavior. The second phase is the priorities and values revealed in these behaviors and which shape...
Aim/Purpose: Continuing low percentage of on-time-completion of doctoral studies suggest the expl... more Aim/Purpose: Continuing low percentage of on-time-completion of doctoral studies suggest the exploration of new approaches to the process is desirable. Background: PhD studies may be viewed as a project- it is a temporary endeavor undertaken to create a unique product. Project management practices have proven to be helpful in numerous domains. Methodology: Process analysis method will be applied, using: 1) semi-structured interviews with supervisors and supervisee, 2) data gathered by the school of advance graduate studies in higher education institute. Contribution: The research will explore the appropriated measurable indicators of successful PhD and identify project management practices that promote better process and outcomes of PhD studies. Impact on Society: Better and more efficient process will support lower individual and national spending on doctoral studies Future Research: Further research should explore relevance of the findings in various settings (characteristics of t...
This paper analyzes the factors involved in successful implementation of innovative pedagogical p... more This paper analyzes the factors involved in successful implementation of innovative pedagogical practices using ICT in ten Israeli schools. The research questions addressed are: 1. What is the configuration and intensity level of the various factors involved in the implementation of innovative pedagogical practices using ICT in schools? 2. Can a connection be identified between the level of intensity of the different factors affecting the innovation and the level of change in various domains of innovation (e.g., teacher role, student role, curriculum, and time and space configurations)? Data from ten case studies in Israeli schools were analyzed using the framework developed to measure the intensity of the factors involved in the innovation. Infrastructure, factors within the school, school climate and educational policy were found to be the most involved categories. These factors mostly affect aspects of the innovation related to teacher roles, instructional contents and teaching m...
The rapid and pervasive implementation of new information and communication technologies (ICT) in... more The rapid and pervasive implementation of new information and communication technologies (ICT) in the education system raises expectations regarding its potential for and contribution to the improvement of education. In spite of the accelerated implementation pace of ICT ...
Human Technology is an interdisciplinary, scholarly journal that presents innovative, peer-review... more Human Technology is an interdisciplinary, scholarly journal that presents innovative, peer-reviewed articles exploring the issues and challenges surrounding human-technology interaction and the human role in all areas of our ICT-infused societies. Human Technology is published by the Agora Center, University of Jyväskylä and distributed without a charge online.
ICT Innovations 2 For more than two decades systematic effort has been made by the Israeli Minist... more ICT Innovations 2 For more than two decades systematic effort has been made by the Israeli Ministry of Education and various educational agents to facilitate the nationwide implementation of information and communication technologies (ICT) in schools. In the last decade, two significant phases of this effort can be identified. The first, between the years 1993-1998, focused mainly on building the technological infrastructure within schools. The second stage (between the years 1998-2003) deal primarily with curricular and staff training aspects. This paper presents data collected between the years 1999-2000 for the OECD/CERI international research of ICT and Organizational Innovation in five Israeli schools that have widely implemented ICT in a way that has provoked substantial organizational change. In this paper we analyze the data collected from two perspectives: (a) using an innovation analysis framework for characterizing ICT-based educational innovations examining the levels of...
Purpose: The purpose of the present study is to explore the process, routines, and structuration ... more Purpose: The purpose of the present study is to explore the process, routines, and structuration at successful schools leading their students to high achievements. Method: The approach of building a theory from case study research together with process perspective and an organizational routines model were applied to analyzing seven successful Israeli high schools that bring their students to high academic outcomes. Findings: Five processes were found to operate cyclically during the school year: building a vision-oriented senior leadership team, enhancing students’ choice, developing a student-oriented class schedule, organizing an exam system, and mapping each student. Each process comprises several routines that present structuration by the alignment of their ostensive, performative, and artifact aspects. Research Limitations/Implications: The fact that the selected schools demonstrated extreme cases of high achievement limit the generalizability of the findings, but nonetheless i...
International Journal of Public Sector Management, 2008
PurposeInterorganizational cooperation (IOC) is like harnessing a swan, a crab, and a pike to a s... more PurposeInterorganizational cooperation (IOC) is like harnessing a swan, a crab, and a pike to a single wagon and still expecting it to go. One issue that appears significant under such conditions is building trust and inscribing it into the structure of IOC. The purpose of this study is to explore the relationships between trust and IOC structure.Design/methodology/approachTrust‐structure relationships are studied by drawing upon a case study of complex and effective IOC in The Early Childhood Center in Israel.FindingsThe analysis reveals several structural factors that support the building and maintenance of trust: choice of contribution, involvement in decision making, committee configuration, IOC culture, the director's role, and the representatives' high‐ranking positions and professional background.Research limitations/implicationsThree conditions help to inscribe trust into IOC structure: Low risk and minor expectations from the IOC, a leader willing to share informati...
The study reported here is based on the results of two international studies: IEA’s Second Inform... more The study reported here is based on the results of two international studies: IEA’s Second Information Technology in Education Study (SITES) Module 2, focusing on innovative pedagogical practices at the classroom level, and OECD/CERI Case Studies of ICT and Organizational Innovation, focusing on ICT related innovations at the school system level. In the paper we analyze the data collected in ten innovative schools in Israel which have incorporated ICT in unique ways and have succeeded in devising innovative classroom pedagogies and school system changes. The major research questions addressed are: (a) What levels of innovation were observed in the participant schools, and in which domains? (b) How does the level of innovation in the various domains vary among and within schools? (c) What correlation patterns among levels of innovation in the various domains can be identified? The results of ten comprehensive case studies of exemplary schools in Israel were analyzed by mean of the in...
ICT PEDAGOGICAL INNOVATIONS In the paper we analyze the data collected in ten schools in Israel w... more ICT PEDAGOGICAL INNOVATIONS In the paper we analyze the data collected in ten schools in Israel which have incorporated ICT in unique ways and have succeeded in devising innovative classroom pedagogies and changes in teachers and students roles and outcomes. The major research questions addressed are: (a) What levels of innovation were observed in the participant schools, and in which domains? (b) How does the level of innovation in the various domains vary among and within schools? (c) What correlation patterns among levels of innovation in the various domains can be identified? The results of ten comprehensive case studies of exemplary schools in Israel were analyzed by mean of the innovation analysis schema developed by us for characterizing ICT-based educational innovations. The findings indicate that most schools as such are in transition stage towards fully innovative pedagogical implementation of ICT; school activities are effected differentially by ICT, thus creating "i...
The study reported here is based on the results of two international studies: IEA’s Second Inform... more The study reported here is based on the results of two international studies: IEA’s Second Information Technology in Education Study (SITES) Module 2, focusing on innovative pedagogical practices at the classroom level, and OECD/CERI Case Studies of ICT and Organizational Innovation, focusing on ICT related innovations at the school system level. In the paper we analyze the data collected in ten innovative schools in Israel which have incorporated ICT in unique ways and have succeeded in devising innovative classroom pedagogies and school system changes. The major research questions addressed are: (a) What levels of innovation were observed in the participant schools, and in which domains? (b) How does the level of innovation in the various domains vary among and within schools? (c) What correlation patterns among levels of innovation in the various domains can be identified? The results of ten comprehensive case studies of exemplary schools in Israel were analyzed by mean of the in...
This symposium presents ten years of an Israeli laboratory school, which was established on resea... more This symposium presents ten years of an Israeli laboratory school, which was established on research and development (R & D) principles. First, David Chen presents four major requirements for R&D strategy: new theoretical foundation, educational research, laboratories schools and diffusion mechanisms. Second, Nir Chen presents the architectural perspective and describes ways by which school building promotes new pedagogy. Third, Yafa Ben-Amy explains how the school and, especially the "home" - the basic organizational unit, work. Finally, Dorit Tubin shows some of the evidence with regards to the schools success.
Introduction Over the past few years, as part of the Information and Communication Technology (IC... more Introduction Over the past few years, as part of the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) reform on the one hand, and the increased demands for school accountability on the other, more and more schools have launched a school website aimed at enhancing educational activities, supporting student-teacher communication, contributing to school marketing efforts, and fostering accountability to and collaboration with the school's constituency (Hesketh & Selwyn, 1999; Maddux & Johnson, 2006; Miodusar, Nachmias, Tubin, & Forkosh-Baruch, 2003). A large body of research on ICT-based pedagogical and educational websites (i.e., websites that focus on subject matters and learning activities) reveals the contributions of such websites to the schooling process (Kozma, 2003; Miodusar, Nachmias, Lahav, & Oren, 2000; Pelgrum & Anderson, 2001; Plomp, Anderson, Law, & Quale, 2003). However, the phenomenon of school websites, which serve the school organization in its entirety, remains rel...
The educational enterprise is one of the largest social organizations on earth. It encompasses ab... more The educational enterprise is one of the largest social organizations on earth. It encompasses about 50 million teachers, over a billion students, with teaching and learning in quite a universal mode called schooling. Knowledge, time and space are harnessed in a standardized pattern expecting an output of school graduates ready to be full participants in society, culture and the economy. Yet, at the entry of the third millennium, education has universally failed to come even close to fulfill its promises.
PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to present the successful school and principal (SSP) model, w... more PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to present the successful school and principal (SSP) model, which has developed over 13 years of Israeli involvement in the ISSPP study.Design/methodology/approachThis is a conceptual paper summarizing the findings of more than 20 case studies of successful, coasting and low-performing schools and their principals, into the SSP model. In all the cases, ISSPP protocols were used to collect the data, and the findings were analyzed in accordance with the organizational approach and organizational routine theory.FindingsThe explanatory SSP model comprises three cyclical phases that explain cause–effect relationships and presents intervention points for school improvement toward success. The first phase is an organizational restructuring of two core routines: the school schedule routine and the school tracking routine, which shape and affect school staff behavior. The second phase is the priorities and values revealed in these behaviors and which shape...
Uploads
Papers by Dorit Tubin