Historical Firearms Book Club
This month the HF Book Club returns with its second edition. With reviews of Dr Stephen Bull's examination of trench warfare during the First World War, John Walter's authoritative look at handgun development and Norman Ferguson's collection of World War One trivia.
__________________________________________________________
Trench: A History of Trench Warfare on the Western Front, Stephen Bull, (2010)
Stephen Bull is a historian and archaeologist specialising in military history, his book Trench has recently been republished as an ebook (on which this review is based). Trench makes a chronological and thematic overview of life in the trenches examining everything from small arms to gas masks, from trench raiding to trench construction, how trench warfare began and the continuing attempts by both sides to break out of it.
Covering almost every conceivable aspect of trench warfare on the Western Front. While Bull’s main focus is on the British Army’s experiences he also provides valuable insight and context on the other major combatants often comparing British & Commonwealth tactics, equipment and strategy with that of their French and American allies and also with their German enemies.
Bull’s writing style is accessible with each chapter of the book broken up with primary source accounts from both sides of the conflict, contemporary trench maps, aerial photographs and case studies of individual actions, weapons and equipment. Bull also includes conclusions drawn from recent archaeological investigations made in France which provide an interesting insight into the current work being done.
In terms of primary and secondary source material suitable for academic use the book is excellent with a comprehensive bibliography and a wide use of contemporary accounts, reports and other source material as well as drawing on a wide range of academic secondary sources.
Bull’s overview of trench warfare’s evolution shows how the eventual break from trench warfare was not the result of any one new tactic or invention but rather the culmination of four years experience with the use of various weapons and tactics breaking the deadlock.
In all Trench offers an excellent thematic overview of the British Army’s experience on the Western Front which is informative and well worth reading if you are interested in the evolution and eventual resolution of trench warfare.
The First World War: A Miscellany, Norman Ferguson, (2014)
Norman Ferguson's First World War: A Miscellany is an ideal coffee table book. A book you can pick up and put down at will, browse at random, pull off the shelf and speed through.
The book takes a broadly chronological approach with facts, trivia and anecdotes grouped by year. Everything from trench slang to number of Zeppelins downed during the war, from the number of men killed in various major battles to the names of the last men to be killed during the war.
Ferguson's Miscellany brings together some well known facts and combines it with some lesser know trivia to create a book which can hold the attention of anyone from the novice to the academic. The bitesize nature of the Miscellany means it's easily accessible and while it doesn't always offer all the context you might like it often sparks interest and leads to further research on aspects of the Great War you'd never previously considered.
The Handgun Story, John Walter, (2008)
The Handgun Story is a valiant attempt at giving a concise history of the handgun. John Walter has written numerous books on firearms and wider military history, including the companion Rifle Story.
A true history of the handgun would be numerous volumes in size and Walter is mindful of this as he begins his work telling the reader "I have, I admit, dealt too concisely with pre-cartridge handguns" indeed he briefly summarises the development of the pistol from its advent to the invention of the percussion cap in a brief prologue. He instead focuses his attention on first the development of the revolver in both civilian and military use and then the history of the semi-automatic pistol. In this section of the book Walter examines the various claims of the earliest pistols which purport to be the first semi-automatic design. He then looks at the various strands of development as the pistols from various countries became serious options for the replacement of the military revolver at the turn of the century. With fascinating sections on the various trials held by both the US Army and it's European counterparts to select suitable automatic pistols.
He then charts the use of both pistols and revolvers during the two world wars and the inter-war period between. Much as with the early history of the handgun Walter skims over the general history of the handgun since 1950 with brief mentions of the Glock and various other designs. There is also a substantial, somewhat disproportionate, section of the final chapter dedicated to target pistols. Taken as a whole the book fails to adequately chart the 'story' of the handgun however, taken for its excellent focus on the development of the revolver and semi-automatic pistol during the 19th century Walter's clear passion and breadth of knowledge in this area is impressive.
Walter's style is fluid and engaging, his use of source material and anecdotal footnotes are excellent. The use of patent drawings and photographs of various handguns discussed illustrate the complex actions of the pistol's Walter describes. The Handgun Story is certainly worth reading if you have an interest in the design and development of revolvers and pistols and it has been a useful reference book when I've been writing.
_________________________________________________________
To see more books on my recommended reading list check out this page. If you’d like to submit a review of a book you’ve read, are reading or have just finished then feel free to submit (all opinions on books welcome). You can send it in a message here or email it to historicalfirearms@gmail.com, be sure to include your username.