Shelterwood cutting

Preparatory cut

Preparatory cutting thins the stand removing species that are not desired so that they do not contribute seeds to the establishment cut. This also allows the remaining trees to grow faster and produce more seed. If the stand does not have many undesired species the preparatory cut is not necessary.^[2] This cut is also not needed if thinning has been implemented throughout the life of the stand, treatment which has the added benefit of building resilience to windthrow.^[5]

Establishment cut

Establishment cuttings removes enough trees to allow sufficient light into the stand for the desired regeneration while avoiding providing enough to encourage the growth of undesired vegetation.^[2] This added light also allows the remaining trees to increase their growth rates and seed production.^[3] It is done in a year when seed production is good. Only the best trees are left to seed the regeneration. In many cases the mineral soil is intentionally exposed by equipment allowing small-seeded species that require exposed soil to grow.^[2][6] Sometimes, the cut is followed by the use of herbicides or prescribed fire to suppress any undesired vegetation.^[2] Further, in some cases, trees are planted after the cut to increase species diversity, introduced improved stock, or create denser regrowth.^[4]

Removal cut

Removal cutting removes all of the mature trees that were left to seed the regeneration.^[2] This is to give more light to the established seedlings, allowing them to grow freely.^[3] Without this cutting, seedlings will stagnate as the crowns of the older trees grow.^[7] This unintentionally damages some of the regeneration which is sometimes desirable as it helps to thin the regrowth, increasing the growth rates of remaining trees.^[2][8] All the mature trees may be removed, or some may be left as reserves.^[4] These will continue to grow and may be harvested several decades later, or may be left to die of old age and contribute ecological values to the site.^[9] When a very shade-tolerant species is being regenerated this is the only cut needed.^[4]

Group shelterwood

Group shelterwood organizes cutting into concentric circles originating from the first cuts in the patch in the center of the circle.^[3] Eventually these concentric circles meet at which point the entire stand has been cut.^[5] Sometimes the first cut will simply release a patch of advanced regeneration that will serve as the center of the circle.^[2] Usually a third cut is not implemented in these systems since the trees on the sides of the cuts provide shade and a seed source.^[4] This has the advantage of eliminating the need to mark trees for removal as the entire overstory is removed in the second cut.^[10] It also eliminates the risk of damage to the regeneration from logging equipment.^[11]

Strip shelterwood

Strip shelterwood systems organize cuts into narrow strips.^[3] The main advantage of this variation is that it provides protection from blowdown.^[5] Cutting is conducted into the direction of the prevailing winds resulting in mature trees always being protected by younger trees from wind damage. In other situations the cuts are oriented to maximize or minimize exposure to sunlight to promote regeneration of the desired species^[3] Similarly to in group shelterwoods, when the strips are narrow enough, a total overstory removal during the second cut will often be conducted eliminating the need for a third cut.^[5]

Irregular shelterwood

Irregular shelterwood systems retain the trees left during the establishment cut for an extended period of time resulting in an uneven-aged stand with trees of multiple ages.^[11] It maybe done to get additional growth on the oldest trees to get extra-large diameters for wood.^[9] It also enhances the scenery, is important for some organisms, and creates old-growth characteristics.^[12][11] The irregular shelterwood system can be further divided into three variants:

• Extended irregular shelterwood involves treating the entire stand uniformly and performing the removal cut later than usual. This maintains a two-aged structure for at least 20% of the rotation length.^[11]
• Expanding gap irregular shelterwood functions similarly to group shelterwood with the difference that trees retained during the establishment cut are left in place.^[11]
• Continuous cover irregular shelterwood involves targeted group removals based on the needs of the individual species within the stand. For example, different species within the stand could be cut using different rotation lengths. This method allows for the maintenance of a more diverse forest and more continuous cover.^[11]

Shelterwood vs. seed-tree

Shelterwood is very similar to seed-tree as a regeneration method since both use natural regeneration to create an even aged stand. However, the seed-tree method retains fewer trees since it does not intentionally use tree cover to shelter the regrowth.^[2][13]