Wait, what? Who's this pretender Peter Turgeon? Who slipped us a bench-warming sub just as the story was building to a crescendo? Woodard and Burke were proving a winning team, and Gerringer so inhabited the character of Dr. Woodard it was mind boggling to think the producers canned him. Well, they did NOT can him. Turns out Bob Gerringer made a grandstand play, choosing to side with striking technicians rather than honor his commitment to the show, to his castmates, and to the fans. "He chose... poorly," to aptly quote a movie released the year Gerringer died.
Peter Turgeon stepped into an unenviable position and I gotta admit he did an admirable job, even if he's no Gerringer. I appreciated his attempts at aping Gerringer's vocal inflections (though nobody will say "Joolee-UH" quite like Bob did). And I'm sure Joan Bennett appreciated Turgeon's rescuing her from her flubbed line, missaying "situation" instead of "solution," which he seamlessly corrected.
Seeing Turgeon assume the mantle brought to mind earlier cast switcheroos, most notably Burke Devlin. I thought I'd never adjust to Anthony George in the part, and while Mitchell Ryan will always be the definitive Burke, George has settled into the role and made it his own. Who remembers the original Sam Evans and Willie Loomis? Or the original Dr. Woodard, Richard Woods?
The prime-time soaps faced the same struggles. I remember DYNASTY recasting both of the original Carrington kids, Steven and Fallon, and DALLAS bringing aboard Donna Reed to play Ewing family matriarch Miss Ellie for a single season before the original actress wanted back in.
I will miss Gerringer but will miss him less knowing the shortsighted reason for his quitting. Did he continue to watch the show and regret not completing the suspenseful story arc? Or was it just a job to him? Time has proven that any victory he felt he won over ABC was pyrrhic at best.
As for this episode 335, it coulda, woulda, shoulda been an 8-star episode but was dragged down by the recasting and--talk about choosing poorly--the dumb decision to include the anticlimactic and momentum-breaking discussion of Caleb Collins' will. Yawn. Still a strong episode boasting Turgeon's first appearance and the sole appearance by William Shust as the psychiatrist Dr. Fisher. I laughed at the parody of psychoanalysis, as Fisher, spouting impenetrable psychobabble, revealed just how wildly afield his interpretation of David's dream was. The woman with the medallion must be his mother, right? Uh, nope.
Fisher did drop the detail about fangs that gave Woodard his epiphany (a late-show Dracula movie should have done that months ago!). But what in that remark sparked Woodard to race back to the mausoleum and to leave Burke behind? I would sure want a friend along if I were confident my worst suspicions were about to be proven correct. And what a shock ending as Sarah appears to Woodard! Tune in Monday to hear Sarah say, "Where's my frikkin' flute, ya light-fingered Sawbones?"
Peter Turgeon stepped into an unenviable position and I gotta admit he did an admirable job, even if he's no Gerringer. I appreciated his attempts at aping Gerringer's vocal inflections (though nobody will say "Joolee-UH" quite like Bob did). And I'm sure Joan Bennett appreciated Turgeon's rescuing her from her flubbed line, missaying "situation" instead of "solution," which he seamlessly corrected.
Seeing Turgeon assume the mantle brought to mind earlier cast switcheroos, most notably Burke Devlin. I thought I'd never adjust to Anthony George in the part, and while Mitchell Ryan will always be the definitive Burke, George has settled into the role and made it his own. Who remembers the original Sam Evans and Willie Loomis? Or the original Dr. Woodard, Richard Woods?
The prime-time soaps faced the same struggles. I remember DYNASTY recasting both of the original Carrington kids, Steven and Fallon, and DALLAS bringing aboard Donna Reed to play Ewing family matriarch Miss Ellie for a single season before the original actress wanted back in.
I will miss Gerringer but will miss him less knowing the shortsighted reason for his quitting. Did he continue to watch the show and regret not completing the suspenseful story arc? Or was it just a job to him? Time has proven that any victory he felt he won over ABC was pyrrhic at best.
As for this episode 335, it coulda, woulda, shoulda been an 8-star episode but was dragged down by the recasting and--talk about choosing poorly--the dumb decision to include the anticlimactic and momentum-breaking discussion of Caleb Collins' will. Yawn. Still a strong episode boasting Turgeon's first appearance and the sole appearance by William Shust as the psychiatrist Dr. Fisher. I laughed at the parody of psychoanalysis, as Fisher, spouting impenetrable psychobabble, revealed just how wildly afield his interpretation of David's dream was. The woman with the medallion must be his mother, right? Uh, nope.
Fisher did drop the detail about fangs that gave Woodard his epiphany (a late-show Dracula movie should have done that months ago!). But what in that remark sparked Woodard to race back to the mausoleum and to leave Burke behind? I would sure want a friend along if I were confident my worst suspicions were about to be proven correct. And what a shock ending as Sarah appears to Woodard! Tune in Monday to hear Sarah say, "Where's my frikkin' flute, ya light-fingered Sawbones?"
Tell Your Friends