American Pastoral

I really like the Fanning sisters so I'll basically watch anything with them. I was also curious about this film because its the directional debut of Ewan McGregor. I went in blind not knowing what the film would bring but it seemed to have a strong cast, and for the little buzz it generated it remained something that I really wanted to check out. I think its a solid debut for McGregor as a filmmaker but can't escape being too dull at times.

The film is based on a novel about a family with a daughter with a speech impediment. She witnesses a traumatic scene of the infamous monk setting himself on fire in television. After this childhood incident Merry (Fanning's character) becomes a radical opponent of war. She starts out vehemently opposing Lyndon Johnson and the war efforts but eventually becomes the culprit in a murder after a bomb goes off. Swede (Ewan McGregor) spends most of the film trying to find his estranged daughter and find out why she is the way she is.

I think the film has strong performances as you would expect from the cast of this caliber. You immediately see the disenchantment of youth in Fanning's character and understand how radical she is in her anti-war stance. Her pained relationship with her mother is stated quite well, and the uncomfortably in it drives her mother mad. I had no problems with the character interactions, however the film cannot escape feeling dull and prolonged. You don't care enough to follow Swede as he tries to find his daughter, and when you finally find her, its just very underwhelming.

Its hard to care for Fanning's character as she's unlikable from the get go. The film doesn't offer much else outside of a quest for a character you'd rather remain lost. The method of storytelling does not always prosper as it goes through periods of stalling and the payoff isn't really entertaining. It gets very lost in an antiwar shuffle and remains shallow despite trying to go deep. I'd say its exciting to see McGregor get behind the camera but his first adaptation does not have enough life.

6/10

Writer Philip Roth was the son of a Jewish family in New York and closely followed the post-World War II period, the Vietnam War and Nixon's Watergate case. A persistent observer, he distrusted the ideal of the American dream, one that was characterized by family harmony and, if there was also financial prosperity and portrayed a white republican couple, nothing could go wrong. With a fierce look and denouncing social ills, hypocrisy and stage games, he brilliantly wrote novels against the backdrop of this biography of the United States of America, complete with flying flags and everything else. Roth's book, published in 1997 and winner of the Pulitzer the following year, chronicled the end of the American dream in the 1960s, with anti-war protests, the civil rights movement and the riots in Newark that resulted in dozens of deaths. The richness of events, stitched together with insight into the fracture of the Levov family, is a creative mirror play of American society.

Seymour "Swede" Levov (Ewan McGregor) and his wife Dawn (Jennifer Connelly) live an idyllic existence in the 1960s in the United States, until the maturity of the couple's daughter, Meredith "Merry" Levov (Dakota Fanning), who will bear the sign of tragedy for the family. Philip Roth does nothing to build the foundations for the disaster: Merry is sexually attracted to her own father, Swede suffers constant pressure because of the racial and social unrest that plagues the surroundings of her glove company, and Dawn, from a woman who knows exactly what he wants, he becomes less faithful to his family. When Merry (Dakota Fanning) begins to suffer social problems in the school and academic environment, it is hell for the Levov family, as a childhood stutter to get her father's attention at the expense of her mother, her thirst for attention reaches political activism. Extremists. In fact, she participates in local terrorist acts, with lethal results, which will affect her family forever.

The novel on which "American Pastoral" was based won the Pulitzer - the "Oscar" of journalism - and the script for a film about the book had been shooting in Hollywood since 2006. Paul Bettany was cast as Swede, Jennifer Connelly as his wife and the couple's daughter would be actress Evan Rachel Wood, when the film adaptation project of the book began in 2004. But over the years, only Jennifer Connelly remained in American Pastoral. The film had its world premiere on September 9, 2016, at the 2016 Toronto International Film Festival, and was released in theaters in the United States on October 21, 2016 by Lionsgate.

The first half feels like McGregor tried to transpose a Douglas Sirk film - a saccharine mid-century suburban reverie with just the right amount of family conflict simmering beneath the surface - into a darker, almost David Fincheresque tone. But whereas Sirk was limited by the strict censors of his day, unable to emphasize the illicit and complex themes of infidelity, sexual misconduct, and classism that were buried in the subtext of his work, McGregor seems to face the reverse problem. He is liberal in showing sexuality, violence and psychological trauma on screen, but he is not very clear about what lies beneath the surface. Having never read Roth's novel, I can't speak to how well the film may have translated the work, thus being forced to judge it on its own merits. But I think I can safely say that the first half of his film is sorely lacking the kind of thematic subtext included in the literature, one that could propel the narrative more gracefully into its tumultuous second and third acts.

The only transparent thematic statement in the opening of "American Pastoral" is explicit, clichéd and a little disappointing - it comes when Seymour "Swede" Levov (McGregor) and his wife Dawn (Jennifer Connelly) are meeting with their daughter Merry's therapist. (Dakota Fanning), Dr. Smith. The psychologist (Molly Parker, from House of Cards) talks incessantly about Merry's apparent Electra complex, and the film immediately jumps to a camping trip with Swede and Merry (12 years old - played by Hannah Nordberg), where Merry essentially tries seduce your father. The camping scene is skillful, disturbing, and well-acted - and would have worked well enough on its own to establish the motivations behind Merry's character. But it's spoiled by the earlier inclusion of blatant exposition in the therapist's office. There are hints of other themes; the evils of perfectionism, the false burden of patriarchy, the misconceptions of fatherhood, etc... but aside from some much-appreciated critiques of the male-dominant nuclear family, these themes are kind of vague and nebulous, floating aimlessly in the background of the screen.

The scene in the therapist's office may serve as a paradigm for the flaws of "American Pastoral." It shines when McGregor allows the audience to connect with the narrative through the strong performances, or simply revel in the absolutely stunning image on screen. But when the film overloads itself with excessive thematization, or simply loudly states its premise in voice-over narration, it feels woefully unimpressive. David Strathairn plays Nathan Zuckerman, a friend of Swede's younger brother, and serves as our secondary source throughout the film. Swede's brother tells Zuckerman the whole story at his 45th high school reunion, turning the film into a framed tale told by two unreliable narrators. At least we don't see much of them, as the film moves away from its narration after the opening scene. However, whenever Strathairn intercedes, especially at the end of the film, he ruins the entire subtext - his narration is overly literal, painfully wordy (a trait explained by Zuckerman reminding us that he is "the famous writer" yawn), and totally unnecessary.

Roth's book is a little more complex than most accounts will tell you. After the first few chapters, in which Zuckerman relates what he personally knows about The Swede and the events of his life, the remainder of the book consists of material that Zuckerman admits to inventing about the man and his story. It's a form of metanarrative, and it goes a long way toward making sense of characters who actually make little sense in a realistic narrative. One such character is Rita Cohen, a young radical who comes into contact with The Swede after Merry runs away and tortures the decent man with radical rhetoric and vehement sexual games. Rita makes sense as a projection of Zuckerman: as a "real" character in this tragedy, she doesn't, but that doesn't stop Romano and McGregor from presenting her as such. (Valorie Curry, who plays the role, struggles to make her believable). When Rita appears, the fake notes begin to overwhelm the real ones. Like an argument between The Swede and Merry about politics, underscored by Buffalo Springfield's "For What It's Worth," a song that has now lost all meaning as a 60s beacon or anything else. Likewise, the film downplays the father-daughter relationship, playing out their verbal exchanges and signaling Merry's rebellion by having her play Jefferson Airplane records too loudly in her room. Romano's script gives Dawn's character more weight, but turns her into something of a hateful harpy in the process. People who accept the contemporary caricature of Roth as a misogynist may not believe it, but the book's portrayal of Dawn is both more sympathetic and more empathetic to her resentment of having been a beauty queen.

Screenwriter John Romano has the job of adapting this work, and "American Pastoral" is a novel that would need a radical makeover to work as a feature film (a short miniseries could have been interesting), but Romano plays it safe, albeit selectively. Its fidelity to the source material is suffocating, the script mimicking the form of Roth's text while abandoning its flow.

There are some strong scenes. The heated arguments between the Swede and his daughter before her disappearance are the closest the film comes to capturing the irreconcilable generational disagreements of half a century ago, with Ms. Fanning's icy tone of moral superiority echoing the extreme left-wing rhetoric of era. But the Vietnam War is just a footnote in a film so condensed that it resorts to the soundtrack's most tired cliché: Buffalo Springfield's "For What It's Worth" to evoke countercultural dissent. The main story line traces Swede's desperate search for Merry. When he is close to giving up hope, he is visited by Rita Cohen (Valorie Curry), a mysterious and sinister go-between for her daughter's revolutionary cell, who taunts him with the hope of seeing Merry, and then humiliates him by playing the temptress. Sadist. Their interactions momentarily set the film on fire.

Much of the book's power lies in Nathan's bitter retrospective dissections of the Swede. But without these complicated reflections, the film's intellectual substance is stripped away, leaving only bones, gristle, and a few fragments. Swede comes to life as a hurt father, but not as an idealist whose foundations of belief are shaken to the core. As the film gallops along at a pace that compresses most plot details into a scant 108 minutes, no time is allowed for the dark reflections that give the novel a tragic-comic dimension. It doesn't help that "American Pastoral" was filmed in Pittsburgh. The pedestrian cinematography and editing give it the look and feel of a bland television movie.

In the inadequate depiction of the riots that devastated Newark in the late 1960s, the violence was reduced to angry skirmishes in the streets. Archival footage of the actual riots barely scratches the surface of the events. "American Pastoral" is a film that raises awareness regarding the upbringing of our children as well as attention to the family, where a slight lack of care can generate catastrophic consequences. And it hurts your heart.

Greetings again from the darkness. Tackling one of the great American novels is a difficult challenge for even the most seasoned film directors … and a dubious undertaking (at best) for a first-timer. Philip Roth won a Pulitzer Prize for his 1997 novel "American Pastoral", and there have been rumblings of a Hollywood production for more than a decade. It's somewhat surprising that the screen version is directed by first time director Ewan McGregor … with the Scottish actor also taking on the lead role of local Jersey boy and sports hero Seymour "Swede" Levov.

The story examines the cracks behind the façade of a seemingly perfect family … the sports hero marrying the beauty queen. Of course, there is always more going on within a family than most care to admit (at least that was the case in the days prior to Facebook). There's an early scene where Swede has introduced Dawn (Jennifer Connelly) to his father (Peter Riegert), and the philosophical and religious differences perfectly capture the changing times and mores from one generation to the next. Never has this been more true than the late 1960's and early 1970's … political and social upheaval were daily occurrences – and sometimes quite violent.

The first half of the movie is exceptionally well done and captures the essence of why the second half feels like a total decimation of everything Swede thought he had. He and Dawn's daughter Merry is beautiful and feisty and stutters … something that only enhances the anger she expresses and anguish she causes for her parents. Her innocent questions as a young child evolve into radical political beliefs and affiliations as she grows up.

Merry (ironically named) is by far the most interesting character in the story, but with the focus on Swede, Dakota Fanning only has brief moments that are worthy of her talent, and Dawn has only a few emotional moments that allow Ms. Connelly to flash the acting depth she hasn't shown in years. So much time and attention is devoted to Swede that the second half is a bit of a letdown and leaves too many details and questions unanswered.

John Romano's (The Lincoln Lawyer) adaptation of the American classic took a different direction than we might have preferred, but it's a thankless job since so many have considered this as unfilmable. McGregor shows a good eye as a director, though it's obvious this material needed a more experienced filmmaker at the helm. The great Alexandre Desplat provides a classy score … the piano pieces are especially well suited. Supporting work is solid from David Strathairn as narrator Nathan Zuckerman, Rupert Evans as Swede's brother, Molly Parker as Merry's therapist, Uzo Aduba as Swede's employee, and Valorie Curry as a misguided revolutionary. It's a reminder that family dynamics may be the most complex organism, and when blended with the volatile times of the Vietnam War, a generational gap should be expected … even if it's difficult and emotional to accept.

"Why does everyone say she did it when she couldn't have done it? She's been tricked and abducted." Seymour (McGregor) was an All-American sports star that was the most popular kid in college. He married a beauty queen and has the perfect life. They are ecstatic when their daughter Merry (Fanning) is born. Little by little Merry becomes more and more radical and passionate about the polarizing politics of the 60's. After the local post office is blown up and someone winds up dead Merry is the lone suspect. Now, Seymour puts his life on hold to find Merry and discover the truth. This is a very very good move, but it is not for everyone. The pacing is just in that awkward spot where if you are interested in the movie you will stick with it and enjoy the events. If you are on the fence the pacing will be just slow enough that many may bail on this. As for the movie itself, its very artsy and deep and important. This is a great character study and features the best acting of McGregor's career. The movie is dark, very allegorical and deserves a bigger audience than it will get. Overall, a very deep and thought provoking movie that will either be liked or shut off before its finished, depending on the person. I give this a high B.

American Pastoral a fine flashback look at the 60s and how the events of the day affected one upper middle class family. The father is Ewan MacGregor the star athlete who married teen beauty queen Jennifer Connelly and looked like they were heading for the golden future. They're from Newark and MacGregor now manages the family business which is a leather goods factory in Newark. But they move out to the suburbs of Morris County.

First off it's a mixed marriage with Jewish MacGregory marrying a Shiksa in Connelly. They have one child a daughter Dakota Fanning who growing up in the 60s sees what's going on around her and gets into some truly radical politics. Her parents are traditional liberal Democrats.

Something she does makes her a fugitive. The rest of the film is MacGregor and Connelly's agonized family traditions are blown apart. They want to understand their child and want her back. But that can never be.

This film is adapted from a Philip Roth novel and Roth drew his characters well as this was an era he and I both grew up in.

Besides the main characters I would single out Peter Riegert's performance as MacGregor's father and Valerie Curry who has embraced totally Weatherman style radicalism. Her scenes with MacGregor who is trying to find his fugitive daughter just crackle with intensity.

A real portrait of an era in America we're still trying to understand.