Metacritic reviews

Ranks with the best of the bunch, given its spooky storyline that fuses religion with down-to-earth characters.

Less and less a skillfully creepy B-movie and more and more a plea for ecumenical reform.

Begins with a scene of mass repentance, but the real sin here is a profligate waste of talent.

There's not an authentically scary moment in it.

Busy, over-stylized mess of a movie.

Repeated lapses in continuity and common sense.

By the time the credits roll and a disclaimer informs us that there may, in fact, be a lost gospel of Jesus and that it is being suppressed by the Church, all we can think to say is, "Ah, shaudup!"

Can anyone but a lapsed Catholic possibly be interested in this unpleasant, anti-Papist creepshow?

Despite exposition delivered so redundantly and witlessly you think you're in a Kaplan class, Stigmata manages to be incoherent.

Tom Lazarus and Rick Ramage should be ashamed to have written such nonsense.