Dave Meltzer's "The Wrestling Observer Newsletter" gave the Sheepherders-Guerreros match, the Sheepherders-Rock N Roll Express match, the Fantastics-Anderson/Blanchard match, the Steve Williams/Terry Taylor-Russians match and the Ric Flair-Dusty Rhodes match each 3 1/4 stars, the Williams/Taylor-Bill Dundee/Buddy Landel and the Road Warriors-Midnight Express match each 3 1/2 stars, and the Sheepherders-Fantastics match the maximum possible 5 stars.
