Wedle wyroków twoich...

1984
1h 35m

ÉVALUATION IMDb

MA NOTE

Ajouter une intrigue dans votre langueAs the Germans invade Poland Jewish Ruth and her mother are trapped by the oncoming Nazis. When they are loaded onto a truck for transportation to a ghetto, Ruth is told by her mother to jum... Tout lireAs the Germans invade Poland Jewish Ruth and her mother are trapped by the oncoming Nazis. When they are loaded onto a truck for transportation to a ghetto, Ruth is told by her mother to jump from the truck at the first chance and to make her way to relatives in Warsaw. While the... Tout lireAs the Germans invade Poland Jewish Ruth and her mother are trapped by the oncoming Nazis. When they are loaded onto a truck for transportation to a ghetto, Ruth is told by her mother to jump from the truck at the first chance and to make her way to relatives in Warsaw. While the war progresses Ruth tries to survive and grow up.

Voir l’information sur la production à IMDbPro

ÉVALUATION IMDb

6,6/10

MA NOTE

1Commentaire d'utilisateur

Voir l’information sur la production à IMDbPro

Photos8

+ 3

Commentaires des utilisateurs1

6,684

Avis en vedette

7mpadjasek

A tense and moving Holocaust story about an ordeal of a Jewish girl in her fight for survival, created by the joint Polish/Jewish/German team

I saw "Wedle wyrokow twoich" (According to your judgements) on Polish TV and was attracted to it by many famous names of people who participated in its creation. And it included not only Polish names but also Jewish writers Artur Brauner and Paul Hennge and the German actor Mathieu Carriere, whom I remembered from the fine adaptation of Hans Fallada's bestseller "Ein Mann will nach oben". The plot is about the ordeal of the young Jewish girl Ruth (Sharon Brauner), and is loosely based on the memoirs of the writer and producer Artur Brauner (born in Lodz), who survived Holocaust. The film is well done, fast paced and with good acting, so I was gripped by its many dramatic scenes. But it is not as good as the best Holocaust movies from the 1980s, like "Sophie's Choice" or "Triumph of the Spirit". " According to your judgements" does not have the psychological depth of the mentioned-before masterpieces, and its characters are too conventional and a bit one-dimensional. The reason may be that director Jerzy Hoffman specialized more in action-packed blockbusters than psychological dramas. Nevertheless, it's a good movie. To me, the most remarkable thing about " According to your judgements" is how and when it was made. It was created at the time when the Iron Curtain still separated Europe and by the international Polish/Jewish/German team of people. So even then it was possible to get together and produce a good movie.