Non-Intrusive methodologies for large area urban research
Rome Transformed conference
(1st – 2nd of July 2021)
Conference Abstracts
This conference is part of the Rome Transformed project that has received funding from the European Research
Council (ERC) under H2020-EU.1.1., the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (Grant
agreement No.: 835271)
Azzari M., V. Bologna, C. Pappalardo, C. Berti. A software for the Management and Analysis of
Stratigraphic Data from Different Sources in a 3D Environment
Universitá’ degli Studi di Firenze (Italy)
azzari@unifi.it
The aim of this paper is to describe the design of an efficient, flexible, and scalable tool to generate
Digital Terrain Models (DTM) related to the historical periods identified by the Rome Transformed
project, starting from the stratigraphic data produced by various survey methods.
The design and development of an ad-hoc software solution for the creation of a tool able to manage
stratigraphic data has been a crucial choice for the Rome Transformed project. After the evaluation of
the available technologies, it emerged the need of a specific tool that would allow the storage and
normalization of the data produced, their georeferencing and lemmatization, so as to flow in an orderly
and usable way in a geodatabase of an ArcGIS project.
The solution adopted was the creation of a "tailor-made" software, as suitable as possible for the
purposes of the research.
The main steps to build an ideal project workflow were obtained through continuous discussions with
all the specialist teams, in order to identify the best import and conversion tool for each category of
data to be implemented in the software: structural analysis, GPR, archival research and drilling.
The goal is to ensure the correct systematization of stratigraphies in the database, supported by
lemmatizations and generation of 3D GIS geometries to be associated to each dataset: PointZ,
MultiPointZ, PolygonZ. These 3D geometries are necessary data to generate a DTM in a GIS
environment.
Once the analysis and comparison process is completed, the import scripts and input forms are created
to populate the database. The database adopted to ensure these specifications is PostgreSQL with the
PostGIS extension that will be fully compatible with the GIS platforms used: QGIS and ESRI ArcGIS.
This paper describes the main features of the software created and the database schema developed to
ensure maximum compliance with each type of data needed for the generation of DTMs for each
historical period.
Bianchi E.1, A. Pansini2. Roman buildings on the western slopes of the Capitol. Investigations and new
approach technologies.
1
Sovrintendenza Capitolina ai Beni Culturali, Rome (Italy)
Universitá La Sapienza, Rome (Italy)
antonella.pansini@uniroma1.it
2
Following the demolition works carried out between 1929 and 1933 for the construction of Via del
Mare, a large Roman district emerged from the western slopes of the Capitoline Hill, near the
commercial area of the Forum Holitorium in Rome. The excavations, supervised by the archaeologist
A.M. Colini, discovered the remains of several multi-storey residential buildings, dating to the Imperial
age. Among them, only the Insula dell’Ara Coeli was preserved due to its exceptional state of
conservation; all the other buildings, known as Taberna delle Tre Pile, the Caseggiato dei Molini, the
Grande Insula, the Casa Cristiana and the Balneum, were instead razed to the level of the new Via del
Teatro di Marcello and were forever covered by the new development of the area. Beside the short
descriptions of the structures published by A. Muñoz in the volume Campidoglio (Rome, 1930), the
finds have never been thoroughly examined: the excavation works were done in a hurry and only a
synchronic plan, devoid of any interpretative element, was published.
In 2015 the Sovrintendenza Capitolina ai Beni Culturali launched a multidisciplinary project aimed at
the recovery and analysis of the structures and the study of the urban and architectural characteristics
of the district from the Republican age to the Middle Ages: it, also, provided for the collaboration of
various professional figures. As part of this project, it has been possible, after more than 80 years, to
access the surviving remains of the ancient buildings and to assess their current state of conservation.
The survey, conducted by the “Sapienza” University of Rome (Chair of Survey and Technical Analysis of
Ancient Monuments - Department of Antiquity Sciences) in collaboration with the association Roma
Sotterranea, was carried out with the most recent technologies, aimed at documenting the remains as
accurately as possible for the study and the development of a 3D model of the buildings. A series of
laser scanner surveys of the structures along Via del Teatro di Marcello and inside each underground
area has allowed the development of a unified point cloud model, making it possible, for the first time
ever, to view the buildings not only in their spatial relationship and in a two-dimensional and threedimensional way, but also in relation to the modern urban context.
The documentation produced constitutes an important starting point for the reconstruction of the
development of this ancient district of Rome.
Boschi F.1, E. Giorgi1, M. Silani2. Combining past, present, and future. Non-invasive mapping for the
urban archaeology of Ascoli Piceno (Italy).
1
2
Università di Bologna, Dipartimento di Storia Culture Civiltà (Italy)
Università della Campania Luigi Vanvitelli, Dipartimento di Lettere e Beni Culturali (Italy)
federica.boschi5@unibo.it
The Asculum Project started in 2012 as a collaboration between the University of Bologna, the
Soprintendenza per i Beni Archeologici delle Marche and the Municipality of Ascoli Piceno, primarily as
a project of urban and preventative archaeology in a long-lived city. Within this collaborative
framework, the project benefits a wide range of interests, helping to reconcile the needs of
preservation and research with a sustainable urban development.
The integration between new and old data from a variety of sources (geophysical and topographical
survey, archaeological excavations, geological and geomorphological analysis) is at the basis of the
research, towards the reconstruction of the ancient urban landscape and its transformations over the
centuries.
At Ascoli we have adopted an integrated approach to the assessment of complex deposits from longlasting contexts with non-destructive methodologies. The project has integrated the geophysical
investigation of the underground deposits with the 3D documentation of the surviving historic
buildings, using laser scanning and photogrammetry alongside the analysis of structural stratigraphy,
the study of the building techniques and of the artefacts. Important key studies have focused on the
main squares and open areas of the city, with their historical monuments (Piazza del Popolo, Piazza
dell’Arengo, Piazza Viola, Piazza San Gregorio Magno), allowing to see beneath the paved surfaces and
providing new insights to interpret the evolution of the buildings and the development of crucial sectors
of the Roman and of the Medieval cityscape. The exploration and the assessment of the buried
archaeological record is widely supported by the notable work of the archaeological units that are
routinely involved in the local rescue archaeology, as a result of a consolidated relationship of mutual
collaboration.
Beyond research, the project is also fostering knowledge outside the academic environment, focusing
on the city and on its social and cultural development. Fulfilling the University’s third mission, we have
offered talks, site visits and interactive visits to archaeological excavations, to those living in Ascoli and
those interested in the city’s history. These activities confirm the role of public engagement in raising
awareness on the contribution that modern methodologies and up-to-date technologies can make in
the protection of archaeological landscapes threatened by urban development, with undeniable
benefits and positive impacts on the daily life of the community now and in the future.
Campana S.1, S. Camporeale1, J. Tabolli1, R. Pansini1, S. Güzel1, G. Morelli3, F. Pericci4, M. Sordini4, L.
Gentili5, F. Gianni5, F. Vitali6, G. Carpentiero7, D. Barbagli8, SOS project: a new challenge for a novel
approach to the understanding of historical cities.
1
Universitá di Siena (Italy)
Soprintendenza per i Beni Archeologici della Toscana
3
Geostudi Astier Srl
4
ArcheoTech&Survey Ltd
5
LDP Ltd
6
University of Bologna (Italy)
7
Soprintendenza Archeologia Belle Arti e Paesaggio del Molise (Italy)
8
Comune di Siena (Italy)
2
stefano.campana@unisi.it
Recently a new research initiative has been launched under the title of SOS which is the international
call for help by ships and sailors at sea – ‘Save Our Souls’ but in our case the acronym means, SOtto
Siena (Beneath Siena). It is designed to undertake an innovative study of the urban archaeology of the
city based on three principal lines of research.
The first entails the creation of a WEB-based 3D Archaeological Information System for the subsoil of
the city. Alongside the development of this GIS a second line of research will entail the acquisition and
refinement of STREAM X GPR data for all of the public spaces such as streets, squares, courtyards and
gardens that are at least theoretically accessible within the city for the mapping of archaeological
features down to a depth of about 3 m and over an estimated 25 hectares of surveyable area. The third
element in the project will focus on identification of all existing archaeological, historical, and geological
information about the city and its representation in the WEBGIS platform; this element of the project
design will also be devoted to the development of interpretative frameworks for the radar data,
permitting its integration and progressive combination with the documentation and future results from
within the city.
Carboni F.1, E. D’Ignazio2, M. Serlorenzi3. Conducting archival research in an interdisciplinary context for
Rome Transformed.
1
Newcastle University (UK)
Pontificia Università Gregoriana, Rome (Italy)
3
Soprintendenza Speciale Archeologia, Belle Arti e Paesaggio di Roma (Italy)
2
francesca.carboni@ncl.ac.uk
Archival analysis is one of the tools exploited by the Rome Transformed project to carry out a
comprehensive survey of the Eastern Caelian, being part of that multidisciplinary approach which,
alongside scanning and architectural analysis, geophysical surveys and environmental analysis will bring
data together to reconstruct the evolution dynamics of this urban sector from the first to the eight
century CE.
The data obtained through this type of research contribute to assessing the archaeological and
architectural remains still visible in the area and provide evidence of the vestiges that
were destroyed or obliterated over the centuries. They play a crucial role in leading structural analysis
to a better reconstruction of the ground exposed structures and in giving clues for the interpretation
of the anomalies detected by geophysical prospections. Legacy data are also pivotal for defining
the reshaping of the landscape throughout the key periods covered by the project.
This paper aims to discuss the challenges encountered during the first phase of data capture from Rome
and Vatican historical archives and their comparison with the more recent records that populate
the ArcheoSITAR platform. We will describe the methodology used in recording extremely fragmentary
and heterogeneous documents, the preliminary interaction of these raw data with the results of other
non-invasive research methods, the complexity of extracting from them 3D information.
Dabas M.1, F. Blary2, G. Catanzarit3, The challenge of archaeologists using geophysics in urban areas.
1
CNRS, UMR8546, Ecole Nationale Supérieure, Paris (France)
CReA Patrimoine, ULB, Bruxelles (Belgium)
3
3DGeoimaging, Turin (Italy)
2
michel.dabas@ens.psl.eu
Geophysical prospecting, even if now used routinely for managing cultural heritage questions in open
areas, suffers in currently urbanized environment from various difficulties which makes its use nontrivial. A certain number of constraints in the urban environment are generally well known: presence
of mechanical vibrations, electromagnetic noise, presence of infrastructures, furniture, pedestrians,
cars above the surface, presence of underground modern services (water, gas, electricity, fibers, etc.),
and most obviously, presence of above ground structures which tend to fragment into small pieces the
areas that can be measured. Others like the very high heterogeneity of the subsoil (rubble and a highly
complex multi-phase stratigraphy) remains the biggest challenge for the geophysicists and ultimately
for archaeologists during the interpretation process. The very good results obtained over abandoned
roman towns for example are due to the conjunction of facts that are seldom encountered in today’s
city centres: low depth of structures (< 1 m); existence of some destruction phase that has cleared up
the rubbles and made apparent walls or their negative counterpart; existence of a single phase of
construction of the urban layout. The situation of today’s cities is closer to the one of “tells” in middleeast countries. If the first archaeo-geophysical surveys in cities were very ‘punctual’ and were often
limited to the study of religious buildings or parks, in recent years the appearance of new methods such
as the electrostatic method (also called CCR – Capacitively Coupled Resistivity) or motorized ground
radar (GPR) allow the investigation of very large areas. Two examples will be shown: the research
conducted in Alexandria during the 2000s and the one, coupled with 3D survey, carried out more
recently in Brussels. In both examples, several classes of geophysical methods are used simultaneously
to solve the archaeological questions: presence of the Heptastadium in Alexandria, presence of
medieval buildings in Brussels. The ancillary role of micro-topography will also be shown for both
studies. For both experiences, the role of the electrostatic method will be discussed in comparison to
other surveys. Processing of data and integration of all types of data is also a very important and
challenging part of the work. Several types of data processing for GPR and for CCR acquisition will be
shown and prove that our interpretation heavily relies on these processing workflows that can –and
should evolve during the interpretation process. It will be shown also that without extra information
like old plans and drawings, our geophysical interpretation may remain very poor. Finally, we can ask
ourselves what exactly is the role of geophysical information obtained in such contexts. Is it only useful
for archaeologists, or can we imagine a more integrated approach with geotechnical engineers,
network managers, urban planners? Can it be used blindly as in the case of an archaeological diagnosis
or does it have to answer a specific question?
Demetrescu E.1, C. Gonzalez Esteban2, S. Morretta3, R. Rea3. Methods and techniques for the
interpretation and reconstruction of the ancient landscape outside the Aurelian Walls.
1
CNR-ITABC, Istituto per le Tecnologie Applicate ai Beni Culturali, Rome (Italy)
University of Southampton (UK)
3
Soprintendenza Speciale Archeologia, Belle Arti e Paesaggio di Roma (Italy)
2
emanuel.demetrescu@cnr.it
With this contribution the authors offer an overview of the methodologies for landscape reconstruction
and interpretation applied in the past 15 years on the study of the area outside the Aurelian Walls in
Rome, between Porta Metronia and the Felice Aqueduct. We discuss the use of information provided
by core drilling, previous excavation documentation and cartography for the reconstruction of the
urban stratigraphy and focus on a specific case study: the virtual reconstruction based on stratigraphic
data of the Amba Aradam Metro station excavation.
The initial stage of the work focuses on reconstructing, sourcing, and visualising the remains of rooms
14 and 15 discovered during the excavation of the station. The narrow selection of contexts would work
as a test for the method proposed, while the process is modified and adapted according to the nature
of the site. Field data, such as the Harris matrix, plans, context sheets and photogrammetry, are used
as a base to develop the hypothesis for a virtual model. The model includes a reference to the several
sources (metadata) and processes (paradata) that led to its creation. This makes it possible to
summarise and converge a range of different data to a reasonable and organised interpretation of the
archaeological remains, by using the formal language of the Extended Matrix and by connecting
different software, such as yEd and Blender EMtool plug in. The final stage of the project is to create a
4D model of the excavated layers that were found on top of the reconstructed archaeological remains.
By doing this, we develop a full record of the site and of the processes that affected its development,
from its initial development to the moment of discovery. Once completed, the source-based model (the
virtual model and the source information integrated within) is added to the EMViq online service. This
software is a great tool for scientific research, as it allows to query, visualise, and interact with the
information on the screen and through Virtual Reality. This feature also makes it is a starting point for
an attractive outcome for public engagement.
The Amba Aradam case study reaffirms the benefits of the Extended Matrix as a standard middle
ground between archaeological excavation, virtual reconstruction and the sources involved in bridging
the gap between the two. In addition, it allows an easy and simple data sharing at international level.
This method represents a simple way of meeting and representing the links between archaeological
records, virtual reconstruction, and online dissemination.
De Santis, A., Bottiglieri, L., Colli, D. , Rosa, C., Solvi, M. The archaeological area of S. Croce in Jerusalem:
new data for the reconstruction of the ancient landscape.
Soprintendenza Speciale Archeologia, Belle Arti e Paesaggio di Roma (Italy)
anna.desantis-01@beniculturali.it
The archaeological area of S. Croce in Gerusalemme, an imperial residence during the Severan age and
during the Constantinian period, has recently undergone several restoration works and archaeological
investigations.
The evidence that emerged from these interventions, alongside a thorough data review from past
research, have allowed the re-assessment of the buildings that originally belonged to the imperial
complex, a new understanding of their building phases and of the residence’s original extent and
internal articulation.
The study of historical cartography and geognostic analyses have shown that in many cases the design
choices have been conditioned by the geomorphological conformation of the land, marked by deep
ditches and steep differences in height, that have constrained the positioning of the buildings in the
area.
We are trying to reconstruct the historic evolution of this area and, also through three-dimensional
graphic models, to suggest a new and in-depth reading of the complex, both from a structural and
chronological point of view.
Haynes I.1, T. Ravasi1, I. Peverett2, M. Grellert3, M. Simpson4. From interpretation to provocation and
back again: Rome Transformed SCIEDOC and the Ospedale di San Giovanni in Laterano.
1
Newcastle University, School of History, Classics and Archaeology (UK)
New Visions Heritage Ltd (UK)
3
Technische Universität Darmstadt (Germany)
4
Newcastle University, Research Software Engineering Team (UK)
2
thea.ravasi@ncl.ac.uk
Integral to the interdisciplinary dialogue that drives the interpretation of the complex urban deposits
encountered by the ROMETRANS project, is the notion of ‘provocation’. A range of 3D visualisations are
developed using architectural and landscape modelling software in order to make the team’s interpretative work
more tangible, accessible and contestable. This approach has the merit of forcing team members to address
issues that might be omitted from basic plans and textual narratives. Conscious of the concerns addressed by
the goals of the London Charter (2006) and Seville Principles (2011), these provocations are supported by
ROMETRANS SCIEDOC, a user-friendly system that allows all interested parties to explore the source materials
used to justify each element, thus creating an ongoing, open dialogue.
To illustrate the process, this paper takes the case study of the Late Antique domus discovered under Corsia
Mazzoni in the Ospedale di San Giovanni in Laterano (Rome).
Portions of the Late Antique Domus were excavated at four different times between sometime before 1944 and
1972. A joint team of Newcastle University (UK) and the University of Florence (Italy) carried out 3D data capture
and structural analysis of the structures as part of the San Giovanni in Laterano 2 project (Haynes et al. 2019;
Ravasi et al. 2020), later incorporated into the ERC funded Rome Transformed project (Haynes et al. 2020). The
domus belongs to a property dating to the imperial period that underwent successive transformations, to reach
its current visible state during the 4th century C.E., when a large portico with a fountain at the centre and lavish
floor and wall marble veneers were added to the residence. The interpretation of all the surviving structures
together with the analysis of unpublished archival information have allowed the development of four 3D
visualizations of the portico that have been made available to the wider community through a tailored version
of SCIEDOC.
SCIEDOC (www.sciedoc.org) was developed in 2016 in recognition of the London Charter (2006) and of the
Seville Principles (2011), with the aim of responding to the issues arising from the increasing body of research
that deal with 3D virtual reconstructions in the heritage sector and as a simple, cost-effective and intuitive tool
for researchers, to provide the evidence for and the argumentation supporting their decisions in the 3D
visualization process (Pfarr-Harfst, Grellert 2016).
Rome Transformed has adopted and adapted the Reconstruction Argumentation Method developed by
SCIEDOC, and over the course of 2020-2021 a team of archaeologists, architectural visualizers and software
engineers based at Newcastle University has adapted it to the needs of the project, developing a research tool
that will deal with natural and historical landscapes alongside large architectural complexes on an urban-scale
research area. Our approach to 3D visualization in the heritage sector recognises the need to develop a tool that
takes into consideration the possibility to create multiple variants of a single model and that addresses the issue
of probability in the development of visualizations (Grellert et al. 2018). We approach this issue by following the
principle that any visualization (our View/Variation) developed by our team and discussed through the
Reconstruction Argumentation Method does not necessarily constitute a “finished” product but rather a
“provocation”, used as a visual tool to engage the research community in a specialist discussion. The
visualization, searchable through specialist tags the argumentation, and the discussion, recorded on a thread,
allow for the development of successive modifications called “Iterations”. The creation of successive iterations
provides a potential response to the issue of how to ensure a transparent discussion over the 3D visualization
process, allowing the necessary space for an ongoing critical discussion.
References
Haynes, I., Liverani, P., Ravasi, T., Kay, S., and Peverett, I. (2019). The Lateran Project: Interim Report for the
2018–19 Season (Rome). Papers of the British School at Rome, 87, 318-322.
Haynes, I., Liverani, P., Kay, S., Piro, S., Ravasi, T., Carboni, F. (2020). Rome Transformed: researching the eastern
Caelian C1-C8 C.E. (Rome). Papers of the British School at Rome, 88, 354-357.
London Charter. 2006. Retrieved May 10, 2021 from http://www.londoncharter.org
Grellert, M., Apollonio, F.I., Martens, B. and Nußbaum, N. (2018). Working experiences with the Reconstruction
Argumentation Method (RAM) - Scientific Documentation for Virtual Reconstruction. Proceedings of the 23rd
International Conference on Cultural Heritage and New Technologies. CHNT 23, 2018 (Vienna 2019). Retrieved
May 10, 2021 from http://www.chnt.at/proceedings-chnt-23/
Pfarr-Harfst M., Grellert M. (2016). The Reconstruction – Argumentation Method: Proposal for a Minimum
Standards of Documentation in the Context of Virtual Reconstructions. In M. Ioannides, E. Fink, R. Brumana,
P. Patias, A. Doulamis and J. Martins (eds.), Digital Heritage. Progress in Cultural Heritage: Documentation,
Preservation, and Protection, Heidelberg/Berlin: Springer: 39-50.
Ravasi, T., Liverani, P., Haynes, I., & Kay, S. (2020). San Giovanni in Laterano 2 Project (SGL2). Papers of the British
School at Rome, 88, 350-354.
Seville Principles. 2011. Retrieved May 10, 2021 from http://sevilleprinciples.com
Kay S., E. Pomar, G. Morelli, Rome Transformed: a multiple method geophysical approach for the urban
investigations of the East Caelian.
The British School at Rome (Italy)
s.kay@bsrome
The large-scale geophysical surveys of the Rome Transformed project have the objective of supporting
the investigation of the Eastern Caelian from the first to the eight centuries CE. The methodology
combines the use of a number of geophysical prospection techniques with archival research, structural
analysis, 3D digital recording and sampling of deep sedimentary sequences. The study area covers
13.7km2 which includes deep stratigraphic contexts and a wide range of urban infrastructure including
tramlines, service pipes, roads and buildings.
The British School at Rome, together with the Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche and GeoStudi Astier
has used a combined approach of Ground-Penetrating Radar and Electrical Resistance Tomography.
The Sessorian Palace, the gardens of Villa Wolkonsky, the Basilica of Saint John Lateran and the
communal park alongside the Aurelian walls have been investigated with both techniques in order to
maximise the understanding of the sub-surface. The combined approach, together with high precision
geographical referencing, has allowed a detailed approach which will in turn inform the future deep
sedimentary cores.
Kay S., E. Pomar, P. Campbell and K. Vukovic. Integrated GPR and laser scanning of Piazza
Sant'Anastasia, Rome.
The British School at Rome (Italy)
s.kay@bsrome
The Basilica of Sant'Anastasia is one of the earliest churches in Rome, built around the time of Pope
Damasus I in the 4th century AD. It lies at the southwest corner of the Palatine hill on the edge of the
Circus Maximus and was built on a range of Roman structures which were used for the foundations.
Between 1857-63 a series of excavations were conducted under the church, revealing a series of shops
and warehouses dated to between the 1st and 4th centuries AD. The structures faced on to a paved
road which runs under the present right aisle of the basilica, parallel to the modern Via dei Cerchi. The
excavations indicate that the buildings continue to the northwest underneath the piazza in front of the
basilica.
The British School at Rome, in collaboration with the Parco Archeologico del Colosseo, has conducted
a non-invasive survey of Piazza Sant’Anastasia, with the aim of recording the continuation of the
buildings. The survey was carried out using Ground-Penetrating Radar with two antennas of different
frequencies (400MHz and 200MHz) in order to maximise the resolution of the survey at different
depths. Furthermore, the piazza and façade of the church were also recorded with a laser scanner to
generate a 3D point cloud, allowing in the first instance the creation of a Digital Surface Model (DSM)
to topographically correct the GPR data.
The results of the geophysical prospection and laser scanning were integrated in a shared 3D
environment, allowing the analysis of the GPR data together with the standing structures. This
methodology, when applied in a complex urban situation, allows for a greater understanding of the
subsurface features and their relationship with the local environment. The survey was successful in
recording features at different depths and revealed the continuation of buildings underneath the piazza
therefore challenging present assumptions about the urban nature of this area in the Imperial period.
Lagóstena L., J. A. Ruiz Gil, J. Pérez Marrero, P. Trapero, J. Catalán, I. Rondán, M. Ruiz Barroso.Three
coloniae and Three municipia: non-invasive exploration of urban contexts in Roman Hispania .
Departamento de Historia, Geografía y Filosofía, Facultad de Filosofía y Letras, Universidad de Cádiz
(Spain)
lazaro.lagostena@uca.es
Since 2016 our team has been developing non-invasive research methodologies applied to the study of
large archaeological areas corresponding to ancient cities in Roman Hispania.
In this paper we present the case studies represented by the Roman colonies of Hasta Regia (Mesas de
Asta, Jerez de la Frontera), Ilici (La Alcudia, Elche) and Libisosa (Lezuza, Albacete), and the Latin
municipalities of Balsa (Luz de Tavira, Tavira), Arva (Alcolea del Río) and Calduba (La Perdiz, Arcos de la
Frontera) located in the Roman provinces of Betica, Tarraconensis and Lusitania. These cities are
different from each other and offer a wide variety of examples in terms of topography, geography,
current land use, state of preservation and archaeological intervention. Therefore, research on each
site was approached by considering its peculiarities. We have always experimented with the most
appropriate investigation methodologies, mainly consisting in the use of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles
(UAVs), ground-penetrating radar (GPR), magnetometer and terrestrial Lidar.
The present paper discusses the different issues encountered during the entire research process and
the strategies applied, as well as the most relevant results for each case study as part of the conclusions
of this experience.
The large number of study sites, the length of the research period, the nature of the surfaces analysed
and the diversity of situations make this research experience unique among the non-invasive
investigations conducted so far in Spain.
Millett M.1, F. Vermeulen2, A. Launaro1, L. Verdonck2.Ground-penetrating radar survey as the linchpin
of a multidisciplinary approach to the study of two Roman cities in Lazio.
1
2
Faculty of Classics, University of Cambridge, UK
Department of Archaeology, Ghent University, Belgium
mjm62@cam.ac.uk
Frank.Vermeulen@UGent.be
al506@cam.ac.uk
Our understanding of Roman urbanism relies on evidence from a few extensively investigated sites,
such as Pompeii and Ostia, which are unrepresentative of typical Roman towns. Non-invasive survey
approaches on a multitude of abandoned ancient urban sites in Italy and elsewhere are now rapidly
changing our approach to the Roman city. This paper presents the outcome of the first high-resolution
GPR surveys of complete Roman towns in Italy, Falerii Novi and Interamna Lirenas.
We review the methods deployed and provide an overview of the results, including discussion of some
case-study areas within both towns. We demonstrate how this type of survey has the potential to
revolutionise archaeological studies of urban sites, while also challenging current methods of analysing
and interpreting large-scale GPR data sets.
Recent works have demonstrated the value of GPR survey on Roman urbanism, but these projects are
predominantly small scale, covering no more than a few hectares. Since 2015, however, we have
deployed GPR on a much larger scale to generate high-resolution images of these two complete
greenfield Roman towns in Lazio. Although such rapid data collection allows entire Roman cities to be
mapped at an unprecedented level of detail, interpretation of these large data sets still relies largely on
visual analysis and the manual digitisation of anomalies.
These traditional, time-consuming interpretative methods are no longer able to exploit fully the
potential of geophysical prospection, and here we propose possible ways forward. This includes first of
all the fusion of the GPR data with the data obtained from full scale geomagnetic prospection of both
towns, and the integration with traditional and more innovative topographic and archaeological
methods, such as surface survey, drone based 3D modelling and aerial and satellite photography.
Secondly, we propose computer-aided interpretation as a means of handling large data volumes in a
more efficient and objective way.
Finally, the presentation will also, in continuation of geophysical surveys carried out in recent years by
this Belgo-British team, discuss the current and future strategies for stratigraphic contextualisation,
focused chronometry, 3D-visualisation of the physical landscape, creation of a DEM, erosion modelling
and environmental reconstruction of both urban sites. A systematic coring program, targeted
excavation and test-pitting are some of the operations under development.
Moscatelli M.1, M. Mancini1, F. Stigliano1, M. Simionato1, C. Di Salvo1, G.P. Cavinato1, S. Piro2
Multidisciplinary approach for characterizing the shallow subsoil of the Central Archaeological Area of
Rome for geohazard assessment.
1
2
CNR-IGAG, Istituto di Geologia Ambientale e Geoingegneria, Rome (Italy).
CNR-ISPC, Istituto di Scienze del Patrimonio Culturale, Rome (Italy)
massimiliano.moscatelli@igag.cnr.it
In 2009, after declaring the state of emergency for the central archaeological area of Rome, following
the adverse weather conditions of November and December 2008, the Government Commissioner and
the Italian Department of Civil Protection (DPC) assigned the Institute of Environmental Geology and
Geoengineering (IGAG) of the Italian National Research Council (CNR) to evaluate the geohazard level
affecting the Central Archaeological Area of Rome (i.e., Palatine Hill, Roman Forum, and Colosseum).
Research activities started up in February 2009 and were concluded in February 2011, with the valued
contribution of the archaeological Superintendence.
The first two phases of the project (between February and December 2009) were carried out mainly
using available information from public Institutions and private companies. Three new thematic
maps - on a 1:1,000 scale - were produced at the end of the second phase: (i) a geological and
hydrogeological map with seven geological cross-sections, (ii) a susceptibility to instability map, and (iii)
a seismic amplification susceptibility map. The third and final phase allowed to perform new field
surveys and involved three CNR research Institutes (apart from IGAG, scientific coordinator,
the Institute for Technologies Applied to Cultural Heritage was involved) and University departments.
The new surveys were planned to achieve two main goals:
1) the characterisation of the archaeological layer, in order to (i) map the bottom surface of the
anthropic covering, and (ii) typify the archaeological layer in terms of physical and
mechanical properties.
2) the characterisation of the underlying geological bedrock, aimed to (i) map the geological units
and typify the recognised lithotypes in terms of physical and mechanical properties, (ii) detect
and monitor the water table position, and (iii) detect conditions potentially susceptible of
instability (i.e., landslides, cavity or chamber collapse, seismically induced settlements).
The subsoil setting of the study area (less than 1 km2) was preliminarily defined by means of already
available 200 geotechnical boreholes. By the way, a new drilling campaign was performed to better
investigate the geological and archaeological layers of Palatine hill and surrounding areas. Twenty-five
continuous coring vertical boreholes (total depth between 20 and 60 m) were drilled.
All the boreholes crossed the anthropic layer, which ranges in thickness between 1 meter (at the hilltop)
and 18 meters (along the slope and at the base of the rise). Several boreholes also crossed the network
of tunnels dug in the tuff rocks underling the anthropic layer.
Lithological and stratigraphic logs of boreholes, integrated with information from local archaeological
stratigraphy, allowed to strongly constrain (i) the bottom surface of the archaeological layer, and (ii)
the boundaries between geological units.
Because almost no direct observation either of the geological bedrock or of the preanthropic/anthropic contact is possible due to the thousand-year-old anthropic covering, an extensive
geophysical survey was than planned to extend correlations all along the study area, and
to characterise internal variability of subsoil units.
Twenty-four ERT were performed at the Palatine hill and the Roman Forum. Resistivity field data were
collected using different array configurations (Wenner-Schlumberger and Dipole-Dipole) and electrode
spacing (from 1 to 10 m), obtaining different investigation depth (from about 8 to 80 m). In all cases, the
resistivity values range from 10 to more than 1280 Ωm. As regards the archaeological layer, in general,
relatively high resistivity values (>400 Ωm) are associated to voids and/or cemented conglomeratic
walls, while low to moderate resistivity values (<400 Ωm) are related to anthropic silty sandy backfill
material.
With GPR method a high-resolution data acquisition technique was adopted to reconstruct a global
image of five areas. For the measurements, a 500 MHz bistatic antenna with constant offset, a 70 MHz
monostatic antenna and a 35 MHz monostatic antenna, were employed. The horizontal spacing
between parallel profiles at the site was 0.5 m, employing the 500 and 70 MHz antennas and 1
m, employing the 35 MHz antenna. Some signal processing and representation techniques were used
for data elaboration and interpretation. With the aim of obtaining a planimetric image of all possible
anomalous bodies detected in the ground, the time-slice representation technique was applied using
all field profiles. Amplitude of reflections recorded in the time-slices is mainly referable to the
distribution of archaeological structures. High amplitude reflections can be referred to archaeological
remains and, locally, to voids located in the anthropic layer. Low amplitude reflections can be related
to the anthropic backfill and, in few cases, to the geological bedrock.
All the previous and new geological, geotechnical, and geophysical data were stored in a geographic
information system (GIS) carried out by IGAG for the Italian Civil Protection in the framework of
the UrbiSIT project (www.urbisit.it).
Integration of the geophysical surveying methodologies with geotechnical boreholes allowed defining a
detailed geological model of the study area, in terms of buried topography, geometries of geological
and anthropic bodies, and lithotype distribution.
The geological and hydrogeological map, along with the geohazard susceptibility map were updated in
the light of the new data. Geological and hydrogeological data allowed reconstructing a preliminary 3D
model of the archeological area. This model helped to better understand the underground water
circulation to establish flood risk mitigation strategies for the defense of the archaeological heritage.
Moreover, geotechnical in situ and laboratory tests, active (Down-Hole, Cross-Hole, and MASW) and
passive (noise measurements) geophysical surveys allowed to define a subsoil model aimed at 1D and
2D numerical evaluation of the seismic response of the area. The main results of this study lie in a
seismic micro zonation map on a 1:2,000 scale and site-specific response spectra to be used for seismic
retrofitting of the monuments.
In conclusion, the main goals of the project were achieved at the end of the study. The application
clearly demonstrates the potential for full integration of geological, geophysical, and archaeological
methodologies to better characterise the geological and anthropic layers in archaeological areas. As a
matter of fact, results show that: 1) both buried topography and internal complexity of the
archaeological layer are detectable; 2) main boundary surfaces between geological units are laterally
traceable; 3) presence of voids in the geological bedrock, locally crossed by boreholes and constrained
by archaeological information, is presumable.
Piro S., D. Zamuner, T. Leti Messina, D. Verrecchia. Acquisition, integration, and interpretation of
multiple GPR data sets in urban area, as part of the ERC Rome Transformed project.
Istituto di Scienze del Patrimonio Culturale, ISPC CNR, Rome (Italy).
salvatore.piro@cnr.it
Important research and technical issues are related to the prospection in urban area to locate
subsurface cavities and/or archaeological remains and to produce hazard mapping. In many cases,
cavities, such as subsidence features, voids and collapses represent disruptions to the geometry of an
originally near-horizontal layered system. Geophysical techniques can be employed to identify the
feature geometries by contrasts in the physical properties but can be strongly conditioned by cultural
features that interfere with instrument measurements (utilities, structures, surficial debris).
The critical phase of the geophysical survey in urban area is the interpretation of the collected data and
the characterization of the degree of confidence in the interpretations.
The urban subsoil consists often of many layers documenting the history of a place, keeping records of
alternating phases of construction and destruction. The shallow subsurface of modern cities contains
reams of pipes, cellars, wells, cavities, tunnels, graves and foundation walls of former houses, churches
and town fortifications.
The most promising non-destructive geophysical prospection method for use in urban area is GPR
(ground penetrating radar). GPR measurements are less affected by the presence of metallic structures
compared to magnetometer prospection and they result in the largest amount of data of all commonly
employed near-surface geophysical methods, providing detailed three-dimensional information about
the subsurface (Trinks et al. 2009, Piro et al. 2020).
In the present paper the surveys made with GPR method to investigate different sites in the area of S.
Giovanni in Laterano, Scala Santa and Santa Croce in Gerusalemme, as part of the ERC funded Rome
Transformed project (2019-2024) are presented and discussed.
The aim of the GPR survey is to identify Roman and high-medieval age remains which could enhance
understanding of the ancient topography and the urban evolution of the study area.
For The measurements a GPR SIR3000 (GSSI), equipped with a 400 MHz (GSSI) bistatic antenna with
constant offset, a 70 MHz (Subecho Radar) monostatic antenna and a SIR4000 system equipped with
dual frequency antenna with 300/800 MHz were employed.
All the GPR profiles were processed with GPR-SLICE v7.0 Ground Penetrating Radar Imaging Software
(Goodman 2020). The basic radargram signal processing steps included: (i) post processing pulse
regaining; (ii) DC drift removal; (iii) data resampling; (iv) band pass filtering; (v) background filter and
(vi) migration. With the aim of obtaining a planimetric vision of all possible anomalous bodies, the timeslice representation technique was applied using all processed profiles showing anomalous sources up
to a depth of about 2.5 m (Goodman, Piro 2013; Piro, Goodman 2008).
With the aim of obtaining a planimetric vision of all possible anomalous bodies the time-slice
representation technique was applied using all processed profiles (Goodman, Piro 2013; Piro, Goodman
2008).
Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR) survey at the selected areas has produced significant and fruitful
results that will be discussed during the presentation.
References
I. Trinks, P. Karlsson, A. Biwall and A. Hinterlaitner, 2009. Mapping the urban subsoil using ground
penetrating radar – challenges and potentials for archaeological prospection, ArchaeoScience,
revue d’archeometrié, suppl. 33: 237-240.
D. Goodman, S. Piro, 2013. GPR Remote sensing in Archaeology, Springer, Berlin.
D. Goodman, 2020. GPR-Slice 7.0, Manual (http://www.gpr-survey.com). Accessed on 21/05/2021.
S. Piro S. and D. Goodman, 2008. Integrated GPR data processing for archaeological surveys in urban
area. The case of Forum (Roma, Italy), 12th International Conference on Ground Penetrating Radar,
June 16-19, 2008, Birmingham, UK. Proceedings Extended Abstract Volume.
Piro S., Zamuner D., 2016. Investigating the urban archaeological sites using Ground Penetrating Radar.
The cases of Palatino Hill and St John Lateran Basilica (Roma, Italy). Acta IMEKO, 5. 2: 80-85.
Piro S., Haynes I., Liverani P., Zamuner D., 2020. Ground Penetrating Radar Survey in the Saint John
Lateran Basilica. Bosman L., Haynes I.P., Liverani P. (eds.), The Basilica of Saint John Lateran to 1600,
Cambridge University Press: 52-70.
Ruiz Gil J.A., L. Lagóstena Barrios, J. Pérez Marrero, P. Trapero, J. Catalán, I. Rondán, M. Ruiz Barroso.
GPR survey in the Punic harbour of La Martela (El Puerto de Santa Maria, Spain) and the methodology
used for the processing and archaeological visualisation of the data.
Departamento de Historia, Geografía y Filosofía, Facultad de Filosofía y Letras, Unidad de Geodetección,
Análisis y Georreferenciación del Patrimonio, Universidad de Cádiz (Spain)
jantonio.ruiz@uca.es
The first example of city planning in Western Europe is located in Cádiz (Spain) where the Phoenician
colony of Gadir was founded. The city was interested by a long urbanisation process until Roman times.
Several historical settlements, with industrial and commercial function, integrated the territory of Cádiz
bay, as well as other life and burial places like the inland settlement of Castillo de Doña Blanca. This
population process was adapted to the marine landscape of the Bay, while itself caused the urban
transformation of the coastal environment of the medieval Cádiz Bay.
Since 2016 our research team has carried out a non-invasive study with the aim of safeguarding the
historic environment and advancing the research on the urban development. In this paper we show the
results of the GPR surveys conducted in La Martela, the Punic harbour of Castillo de Doña Blanca. This
is a Phoenician settlement known thanks to excavations carried out between 1979 and 2001 and the
non-invasive investigations conducted by our team, consisting of aerial and land photogrammetry and
geophysics surveys (with single and multi-antenna GPR system).
La Martela is located on the floodplain, at the foot of the Phoenician settlement of Castillo de Doña
Blanca, in a zone where there were no archaeological remains. A 6 hectares survey area was covered
with the GPR multichannel Stream X system, thus leading to the discovery of an archaeological site of
short-term phase. The orthogonal layout and the building types, with the elongated rooms of the
Phoenician and Punic 'warehouse' type, are a clue to date its last construction phase to the 3rd century
BC.
In this communication we present the proposed workflow for optimising the results of large area multichannel GPR surveys to obtain accurate urban cartography, enhancing the value of this method as a
research source.
Although geophysical techniques use interpolation as a mechanism to visualise data, these results
provide enough quality to map underground structures of archaeological interest with precision.
Ultimately, the floor plans obtained through geophysical techniques should be considered as valid as
the ones derived from a traditional survey of excavated archaeological remains.
Schmidt A.1,2, T. Sparrow2, C. Gaffney2, V. Gaffney2, A.S. Wilson2, R. A.E. Coningham1. 4D with Accuracy:
why bother?
1
2
Durham University, Department of Archaeology (UK)
University of Bradford, School of Archaeological and Forensic Sciences (UK)
A.Schmidt@GeodataWIZ.com
For the communication of archaeological and other Cultural Heritage results to the public, 3D
representations have long been very effective tools. In recent years, advances in information
technology even facilitated 3D time laps animations based on different phases of sites and monuments
(e.g. for the ship burial site in Gjellstad, Norway; https://www.gjellestadstory.no/). Although most such
representations are based on archaeological results, they do not require high fidelity as large parts of
such reconstruction models are hypothetical in any case. Would a full and accurate 4D recording (i.e.
3D with additional time dimension) of archaeological data provide additional benefits, given that
recording and data management would require more efforts and possibly even new work paradigms?
Inherently, all well-recorded archaeological data already contain 4D information, albeit in a
disaggregated form, consisting of map and section drawings, context identifications, and sequencing,
for example using the Harris matrix. During the post-excavation analysis these data are conceptually
assembled into a 4D record. Several groups have demonstrated clearly how 3D recording of all
excavation phases can be used to derive these conventional products (if desired), as well as forming
the basis of a complete 4D data set (Aspoeck & Fera 2015; Larsson et al. 2015; Schneidhofer et al. 2017).
We present here the benefits of compiling a 4D data set of all the physical evidence from a heritage
site. This is based on the combination of work from two projects: ‘Curious Travellers: Visualising
Heritage’ (http://www.visualisingheritage.org/CT.php) (Wilson et al. 2019) and ‘Reducing Disaster Risk
by Evaluating the seismic Safety of Kathmandu’s Historic Urban Infrastructure’ (Davis et al. 2019). One
of the heritage sites that was investigated in this joint effort is the historic centre of the city of Bhaktapur
in the Kathmandu valley, Nepal. Many of its temples were destroyed by the Gorkha earthquake in 2015
and some of them were rebuilt in subsequent years. Our data consist of photogrammetric
reconstructions of the centre before its destruction, using photographs taken by tourists and submitted
to the project; photogrammetric and scanning data collected after the rebuilding of some of the
temples; and of geophysical data from a detailed ground penetrating radar (GPR) survey of the
subsurface. Combining and manipulating these data sources proved to be challenging and new
approaches had to be developed, for example by using automated extraction algorithms for delineating
the GPR anomalies (Schmidt & Tsetskhladze 2013).
The reconstructed historic 3D data are important for conservators, architects and engineers during
their reconstruction and conservation activities and the 4D data set can be used for detailed
documentation and comparison of the historic monuments in their different architectural incarnations.
It also allows accurate measurements of individual monuments and of the relationships between
upstanding and subsurface remains, and as a source for derived visualisations for presentations to the
general public. The efforts of combining the heterogeneous data into one accurate 4D representation
are hence offset by the detailed analysis that is now possible.
References
Aspoeck, E. & M. Fera 2015. 3D-GIS für die taphonomische Auswertung eines wiedergeöffneten
Körpergrabes. AGIT - Journal für Angewandte Geoinformatik 1-2015: 2-8.
Davis, C., R. Coningham, K. P. Acharya, R. B. Kunwar, P. Forlin, K. Weise, P. N. Maskey, A. Joshi, I.
Simpson, D. Toll, S. Wilkinson, P. Hughes, V. Sarhosis, A. Kumar & A. Schmidt 2019. Identifying
archaeological evidence of past earthquakes in a contemporary disaster scenario: case studies of
damage, resilience and risk reduction from the 2015 Gorkha Earthquake and past seismic events
within the Kathmandu Valley UNESCO World Heritage Property (Nepal). Journal of Seismology 24:
729-751.
Larsson, L., I. Trinks, B. Söderberg, M. Gabler, N. Dell'unto, W. Neubauer & T. Ahlström 2015.
Interdisciplinary archaeological prospection, excavation and 3D documentation exemplified through
the investigation of a burial at the Iron Age settlement site of Uppåkra in Sweden. Archaeological
Prospection 22 (3): 143-156.
Schmidt, A., G. Tsetskhladze 2013. Raster was Yesterday: Using Vector Engines to Process Geophysical
Data. Archaeological Prospection 20 (1): 59-65.
Schneidhofer, P., E. Nau, J. Leigh McGraw, C. Tonning, E. Draganits, L. Gustavsen, I. Trinks, R. Filzwieser,
L. Aldrian, T. Gansum, J. Bill, W. Neubauer & K. Paasche 2017. Geoarchaeological evaluation of ground
penetrating radar and magnetometry surveys at the Iron Age burial mound Rom in Norway.
Archaeological Prospection 24 (4): 425-443.
Wilson, A. S., V. Gaffney, C. Gaffney, E. Ch’ng, R. Bates, G. Sears, T. Sparrow, A. Murgatroyd, E. Faber &
R. A. E. Coningham 2019. Curious Travellers: Repurposing imagery to manage and interpret
threatened monuments, sites and landscapes. In M. Dawson, E. James and M. Nevell (eds) Heritage
Under Pressure – Threats and Solutions: Studies of Agency and Soft Power in the Historic
Environment: 107-122. Oxford, UK: Oxbow Books.
M. Serlorenzi, A. Cecchetti,
A. D'Andrea, F. Lamonaca, G. Leoni, R. Montalbano, S. Picciola,
SITAR project. New approaches and methods for an open data archeology of Rome
Soprintendenza Speciale per i Beni Archeologici di Roma (IT)
mirella.serlorenzi@beniculturali.it
SITAR (Sistema Informativo Territoriale Archeologico di Roma - Archaeological Territorial Information System of
Rome) has been launched in 2008 by the Soprintendenza Speciale per i Beni Archeologici di Roma in order to
digitize and gather all the scientific data coming from the archaeological excavations and the geological research
surveys carried out within the territory of Rome and Fiumicino. Its goal is to ensure the visibility, transparency,
and dissemination of the scientific data on archaeological excavations in the city of Rome: a digital
registry dedicated to Rome’s heritage, free for all to access and consult.
Turner, A. Marvellous metadata: Managing metadata for the Rome Transformed Project.
Newcastle University (UK)
alex.turner@newcastle.ac.uk
This paper explores the use of an integrated approach to the use of an Access database and ArcGIS Pro
to manage the complex and varied metadata produced by Rome Transformed. It is often a failure of
many projects to properly record the full range of metadata available. This is largely due to
the perceived tedious nature of the metadata recording process and sometimes reinforced
by the impression that the data being recorded has no immediate clear and obvious benefit to the
overarching aims of that project. Often detailed metadata is only recorded to satisfy the requirement
of repositories like the Archaeological Data Service. Contrary to this notion, this paper will explore the
concept that by recording metadata in an easily accessible format and integrating it within the visual
spatial
data generated
by a
GIS,
it
is
possible to not
only produce
something
that provides immediately tangible
results but
also
produces the
means
by
which
a thorough exploration of data integrity can be easily achieved. The grading of data between that which
can be deemed empirically precise and that which could at best be described as ‘fuzzy’ plays an
important role in the successful integration of data from a wide-ranging set of disciplines. It is hoped
that this paper will show that by making the process of accessing and cross-referencing the metadata
from these disparate sources for specialist and non-specialist alike it is possible to holistically
substantiate arguments regarding the relative validity and value of data sources within the project.
Ullrich B., R. Freibothe, R. Kniess, H. Zoellner. Challenges and solutions of GPR-surveys in urban areas of
Rome, Jeddah and Athens.
Eastern Atlas Geophysical Prospection, Berlin (Germany)
b.ullrich@eastern-atlas.de
Impressive results from recent Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR) surveys show the great potential of this
geophysical survey method to detect subsurface remains of human activities in the past. Newly
available multi-channel and array technologies push the boundaries of spherical resolution and
efficiency of GPR surveys. They also produce huge datasets, which can be used for vivid virtual
reconstructions of detected buried remains. However, these sensational results are mostly achieved
under ideal circumstances in easy accessible, minimally disturbed, and golf course-like (or
archaeological park) environments. In contrast, GPR surveys of urban research areas pose great
challenges to the entire workflow from the geophysical and topographical survey and data processing
to the archaeological interpretation of data. This paper discusses these challenges and their specific
solutions, highlighting three recent GPR surveys carried out by Eastern Atlas in densely built modern
metropolitan areas in the Mediterranean and the Near East.
The Campidoglio project in Rome, directed by Prof. C. Parisi Presicce (Musei Capitolini) und Prof. Dr. O.
Dally (DAI, Rome) in cooperation with the Sovrintendenza Capitolina ai Beni Culturali started in 2018.
The GPR surveys aim to map the architectural remains of the sanctuary of Iuppiter Optimus Maximus
as well as the medieval use of the Capitoline hill after the sanctuary was abandoned. As everywhere in
the eternal city of Rome, these surveys examine an extremely heterogeneous underground. Various
phases of human impact altered the subsoil and with it the local physical properties – as is the case in
all here presented case studies. Furthermore, the varying surface conditions at the Campidoglio,
including asphalt roads, compacted gravel paths, and post-medieval parks affect ground coupling. The
wave propagation in the ground is influenced by recent pipes and supplies of variable depth, size and
materials as well as levelled topography of different parts of the natural hill.
The recent research project in Historic Jeddah, the Gateway to Makkah, is directed by Eng. S. Nawar
(MOC-Ministry of Culture, Kingdom of Saudi-Arabia) and focuses on the old town of Al Balad. The very
lively, densely built historic centre spreads out over 70ha and is characterized by more than 350 historic
buildings. The possibilities for large GPR-survey are severely limited by the irregular alleyways between
the high historic buildings. One of the greatest technical challenges is the positioning of the GPR-data,
as GNSS reception is not possible in the narrow streets. Therefore, alternative positioning systems using
robotic total station and survey wheel data have to be adopted to obtain cm-accuracy.
The new research project in Kontopigado, south of Athens (Greece), conducted by Dr. R. Jung and Dr.
E. Kardamaki (OREA-Institute for Oriental and European Archaeology, Vienna, Austria) in cooperation
with K. Kaza-Papageorgiouis focuses on a Mycenaean industrial area which was partly excavated before
the Athens metro station Alimos was built. GPR surveys were executed to gain information on the
surroundings of the known workshop area in sloping terrain. Here, too, the above-mentioned
challenges of variable surface materials were encountered on roads, unpaved areas and sportsgrounds.
Moreover, the reconstruction of the exact elevation levels of the detected remains is essential for a
precise interpretation of the workshop elements. The recognition of very shallow pits in 3d-datasets
incorporating several meters of topography requires a detailed reconstruction of ancient and modern
surface levels, combining all available data of the former excavations, new topographical surveys, and
the depth of processed GPR-data.
Wilson A. S.1, A. Walker2, C. Gaffney1, T. Sparrow1, J. Moore1, S. Simpson2, J. Ritchings2. Virtual Bradford.
1
2
University of Bradford, School of Archaeological and Forensic Sciences (UK)
City of Bradford Metropolitan District Council, Department of Place (UK)
T.Sparrow1@bradford.ac.uk
'Virtual Bradford' will be an open BIM LOD3.0 textured 3D model/ digital twin/ digital clone of the
historic inner city of Bradford, West Yorkshire.
It will provide accurate levels of detail for the built environment for use in various strategic priorities
for the Council, including urban/ civic planning; improve traffic management; support the modelling of
air quality, flood risk and noise pollution; contribute to disaster management planning; and to highlight
the heritage of the City and its benefit to enhancing education, tourism and in fostering civic pride. The
datasets will be captured using an inhouse multi capture backpack and trike system which uses a
combination of mobile laser scanning, GNSS, Structure from motion (SfM) and 360 video. These will be
integrated with existing datasets such as aerial lidar to produce a rich and accurate set of 3D geospatial
datasets.
These datasets will provide the framework and foundation for further digital documentation of
important historical sites, buildings, and artefacts, to open Bradford’s Heritage to the world (Bradford
2025 - City of Culture bid; linkage to Bradford UNESCO City of Film) through development and
promotion of virtual-tourism that explores our cultural value and allows us to connect the past with
future generations. This will create resilience around tourism in the district, including COVID recovery,
but also to irreparable damage such as fire (e.g., Notre-Dame, Glasgow School of Art). This is led by
Adrian Walker, Sydney Simpson and Joe Ritchings from Bradford Metropolitan District Council, as a
piece of collaborative research with Professor Andrew S. Wilson, Professor Chris Gaffney and Tom
Sparrow at the University of Bradford, using expertise in geospatial research, imaging and visualisation
developed within 'Visualising Heritage'. The work is linked to extant funded activity between the
University and Bradford Council through the EU SCORE project.