Nothing Special   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

Academia.eduAcademia.edu

A comparative study on student perceptions of face-to-face learning and online learning

2007, 6th WSEAS International …

6th WSEAS International Conference on EDUCATION and EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY, Italy, November 21-23, 2007 ) * % " ! + + ! " ! # " $ " & "' " ( % ( ,--( + ! + + -.) - ,/ ( " " $ 0 " " " "1 " ( # "" ! ) " + 23 4( " " 0( ' ( " 4! ) "" "" / / ! ) 67 4( " " 0( ' ( " " ! 5 "" ! $0 8 " " ( # 0" 5 ( " " 6 " 5$ ' ) ( " (" " + ( )" # ! ( ( ( ) ( ( $ !! 0 0 " " ) ) 9: 7; 6<; / / " " =9; 79; ! " " " )# ( " " # ! ( / / ! )0 "") !$ # ) ( " " " )# " "( 0 ( ( ! 0 "") !$ > ?+:9@+ ( ( ( " " ( 0 ") "5 0 # ( ) ( "+ ( ! ! "> ! A" "@ 0( ( ! ( " "" " B 5 ( ( ! " # / ! ( " > ! < " "@ 0( ' " ( " # " ! "" " ) 0 ( ( " ) ) 3E <; 6A; ( ( ( ) ( ( $ !! 0 0 " ! "( " 5 0 ( " ( ! ! " ( 0 $" ( $ " ( " # " " 5 ") > F+:9@+ ! 5 "" ' " ( " ! ) /G ! $ ! ! ) / / " ( # " ( # " ! ! " ( " ! 5 ) ( " " "+ ! ! # ( ! ! ( )( " # ! " ( # ( ! ) $ 5 " # " / / ) 0 ' 0 ( " ") !!$ ! ! " ( " ( $ ! ! "" " A + B( ! $ ( " " ( ( # "" ! ! )0 ( ( / / ! ) " ( " ( # 1 " $") ( " ( " ( # ( ( ") " ( # "" ( / / ! ) / ! ! ) <+ ( ) 5 " " ( ( # # ") " 5 0 H " !" ! " " ( " / / " " 3/ AA + 0 # ( " " 0( ( ! ! ) " 5 # ( / / ! ) A< / A6 " " ( )" # ! ( / / ! ) " # ( ! ! ) AE / <: + ( " ' " ( ' ( ! "" / / ( # " $ " 6 # 0 ( "+ ( ( ! # ( ( " ( 0 " ' C D ! # + ( # 0 " "( ! " 41 " 0 $ ! !0 $" 5 ( )+ ( " 5 " ( " ( ( # # "" / / ! ) ! ) $ " !" " $ " " ( (" " " ( " ) !!$ ( H " !" " " <A + G ( " ( " C ) (" " " ( (" $ # ! $ !0 $" 5 ! ( " "+ ( $ ( 5 ! # ( " ( ") " 5 " " " )( " # ( " 5 ( (" $ " " ! ( ! " " # ! # " "" " << /I<3J+ "5 " H " !" " " ( ) H 5 ( ! ! " / / ! " " " 0 ( ! ( ( $ !! 0 + " $ 0( ( ( H " !" 0 ) " " " ( " 5 ( # "" " ( " " )( ) " " ( 5 "" / / ! ) ( ( ) ! 5 " "+ 0 " ( " $ ( ( H ) " ! " " ( ! " 6th WSEAS International Conference on EDUCATION and EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY, Italy, November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th WSEAS International Conference on EDUCATION and EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY, Italy, November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th WSEAS International Conference on EDUCATION and EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY, Italy, November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th WSEAS International Conference on EDUCATION and EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY, Italy, November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th WSEAS International Conference on EDUCATION and EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY, Italy, November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