Global Journal of Arts Humanities and Social Sciences
Vol.2,No.6, pp.44-52, August 2014
Published by European Centre for Research Training and Development UK(www.eajournals.org)
CONFESSIONAL POETRY OF EUNICE DE SOUZA AND SYLVIA PLATH: A
STUDY IN COMPARISON
Dr. Tanu Gupta
Associate Professor
Dept. of Mathematics and Humanities
M. M. University, Mullana (INDIA)
Anju Bala Sharma
Research Scholar
Dept. of Mathematics and Humanities
M. M. University, Mullana (INDIA)
ABSTRACT: Confessional poetry is the poetry of personal or ‘I’. It is the poetry which
springs from the personal life of the poet. Private experiences, alcoholism, masturbation,
and feelings about trauma, depression, relationship and suicidal attempts are expressed in
this poetry, often in an autobiographical manner. The poet reveals directly or indirectly his
or her own experiences, problems and psychological complex in his or her poetry. While
these poems frequently engage in what is repressed, hidden and falsified, defining them as
‘confessional’ undermines the creative ability of the writer to construct a persona or
imaginary scenario that is separate from their lives. The new poets adopted personal
history or autobiography as their central theme and direct expression as their method. The
confessional style of writing is associated with Robert Lowell, W. D. Snodgrass, John
Berryman, Anne Sexton, Sylvia Plath etc. In 1967, M. L. Rosenthal wrote: The term
‘confessional poetry’ came naturally to my mind when I reviewed Robert Lowell’s Life
Studies in 1959. He further said that because of the way Lowell bought his humiliation,
sufferings and psychological problems into the Life Studies, the word ‘confessional’ seemed
appropriate enough. (Qtd. in Hall, Barnard, 33).
KEYWORDS: Confessional poetry, Catharsis, Therapeutic value, Psychic relief.
INTRODUCTION
The confessional poetry of mid-twentieth century dealt with the subject matter that previously
had not been openly discussed in American poetry. But the confessional poets are not merely
interested in recording their emotions on paper; craft and construction are also extremely
important. The poet does not expect any redemption. It is just, that they naked their soul to
get a psychic relief. It is of some therapeutic value. They focus too exclusively upon the pain,
anguish and viciousness of life at the expense of its pleasure and beauty. Needless to say that
confessional poetry initiated a new direction in poetry, and influenced a good number of
young poets.
Like many Indian English poets of her generation, Eunice de Souza also draws heavily from
her personal life and she successfully manages to connect her personal life experiences to the
broader context of the cultural and political setting around her. Many poets use poetry as a
form of communicating to the world, use instances that take place in their personal life. After
44
ISSN: 2052-6350(Print), ISSN: 2052-6369(Online)
Global Journal of Arts Humanities and Social Sciences
Vol.2,No.6, pp.44-52, August 2014
Published by European Centre for Research Training and Development UK(www.eajournals.org)
Kamala Das’ bold confession and Imtiaz Dharker’s open challenge to the purdah-system,
Eunice de Souza, the Mumbai-based, Goan-origined poet offers a wide range of themes and
subject matter in her poetry. De Souza offers a range of highly volatile emotions with her
poems, changing direction and gaining effect from her inner contrasts, conflicts, ironies and
satires. Eunice de Souza belongs to that generation of Post-Independence women poets who
have given a convincing assurance that Indian English poetry matches the best everywhere.
In her poetry the directness of speech rhythm and colloquial language is an expression of
emotional involvement.
A comparative study of Sylvia Plath and Eunice de Souza reveals not only their achievements
as confessional poets but also the strength and weakness of this mode in addressing the
complexities of the modern life. Obviously, they are known for their confessional poetry for
the shocking disclosures of the most intimate and private experiences of physical type or
precisely their experiences as females. While this mode enables them to unburden their guiltridden self, they on their part, shape and perfect the mode, taking it to the utmost point. The
confessional mode achieves its most glorious form in their poetic exploits.
The flexibility and freedom offered by the confessional form of expression eventually enables
Plath and Eunice de Souza to give voice to the cries of their heart. Plath through her poems
relives her childhood guilt, her anguish suffered during the hospital days, during which she
sometimes imagines herself as the empress of the clinical world. It is this mode which
enables her to ventilate her predicaments as a daughter as well as a mother and wife.
In the same way Eunice de Souza also expresses her depression and inner feeling through this
confessional mode. She takes poetry as a medium to express her experiences of life. She
openly writes about her birth as an unwanted child, her father’s early death, her suicidal
attempt and other autobiographical facts in her poem Autobiographical:
Right, now here it comes
I killed my father when I was three.
I have muddled through several affairs
and always come out badly.
I’ve learned almost nothing from experience.
I head for the abyss with
monotonous regularity. (“Autobiographical” 1-7)
The confessional mode enables Plath to lay bare her guilt ridden consciousness burdened
with a self which holds itself responsible for the death of her father “Daddy, I have had to kill
you” (“Daddy” 6). This guilt consciousness is a complex emotion which cannot be articulated
by an objective or even by ordinary subjective forms. However Plath exorcises these ghosts
of memory with the help of her confessions in a poetic form recalling them repeatedly till
their fury is silenced and guilt consciousness is portaged. Poetry becomes an incantation as
well as a vehicle of catharsis to her. No wonder, it is not through psychiatry but poetry that
Plath regains her mental equilibrium and confidence in herself.
45
ISSN: 2052-6350(Print), ISSN: 2052-6369(Online)
Global Journal of Arts Humanities and Social Sciences
Vol.2,No.6, pp.44-52, August 2014
Published by European Centre for Research Training and Development UK(www.eajournals.org)
Interestingly, the confessional mode helps Sylvia Plath and Eunice de Souza to verbalize not
only their personal experiences but also their search for truth and the fulfillment of her social
commitments. Their aim as a poet is not merely to ventilate their pent-up feelings but to
reveal the emotional truth behind the factual truth or the experiences of their life. While
exploring their inner self, they want to produce the inward look of the psyche, which the
society does not want to acknowledge. Plath actually wants to show the ugly face of the
society, which is instrumental in causing individual and social sickness. She finds in
confessional poetry the form of her life that can record each and every moment of her
turbulent psychic self and poetize the quirks and qualms which quicken the pulse of her life.
In confessional strokes she peels off the multiple layers of herself which assumes a number of
roles both private and public.
Eunice de Souza, like Plath uses poetry as an instrument of catharsis or mental purgation, for
getting rid of her inhibitions and obsessions, which hinder the progress of life. To her, poetry
also becomes a vehicle of religious experience, which finds its outlet in the poems dealing
with the mythical love. Like Plath, De Souza finds confessional mode, a perfect medium for
ventilating her struggle, her suicidal instinct. But Plath’s wish of death is strong than De
Souza. Her life experiences produce in her an acute sense of depression, making her fed up
with life.
While expressing their inmost experiences in the confessional mode, De Souza and Plath go
on to shape it into a vehicle, capable of voicing the most secret motions and deepest emotions
of human psyche. In their hands this mode becomes a language of thousand moods ranging
from the depressions of the disturbed psyche and desperate cries of human heart and the
spiritual stirrings of the intoxicated soul. In their effort to expand the horizons of the
confessional mode, Plath and De Souza experiment with certain technical innovations to
make their poetry an instrument of social awaking, private and public catharsis and even
religious awakening. In their hands the most private mode assumes the form of a universal
mode capable of projecting the consciousness of two countries of different cultural
background and attitudes.
Plath and Eunice de Souza make confessionalism a mode of female emancipation and an
embodiment of truths, valid to all humanity. Social and universal strains mark the poetry of
Plath as well as of De Souza. In their poetic journey, they proceed from a purely personal to a
social stance. When they came to describe their mental anguish and acute manic depressions,
they assume a representative female voice. But very soon they came to realize that these
experiences were not individual but universal.
In her poems dealing with sexual experience with her husband, Plath seems portrays only the
most personal. In her poems Plath deals with the voice of all those women who are fed up
with life and who seek peace in the lap of the savage god i.e. death. In this way the
confessional mode, which they initially used to express their pent up feelings becomes a
powerful medium of inspiration to all women.
46
ISSN: 2052-6350(Print), ISSN: 2052-6369(Online)
Global Journal of Arts Humanities and Social Sciences
Vol.2,No.6, pp.44-52, August 2014
Published by European Centre for Research Training and Development UK(www.eajournals.org)
Sylvia Plath began to write the poetry as self-therapy. But when her psychiatrist told her that
her poetry might help others to recover from their mental imbalance, she began to write with
a social commitment and subsequently became the champion of the female cause.
Although confessionalism in itself is cathartic, but the element of catharsis found in old
confessionalism is rather of a religious kind, aimed at achieving an experience of conversion
or spiritual enlightenment or peace of mind with all passions spent. But Plath moulds the old
confessional mode to deal with the new psychological consciousness, revealed by the epochmaking researches of Freud and Jung. She invests her poetic confessionalism with the latest
insights provides by psychology and develops it as a powerful instrument. In many of her
poems she raises the mode to work as a recipe for erasing the memories of unpleasant
experiences. In doing so, she develops confessional poetry into a school of literary psychiatry
that can exorcise the memory lane and causing mental and physical disturbances.
Eunice de Souza makes also a tremendous effort to develop confessional mode as a sort of
poetic medicine to treat mental vacancy and even physical ailments. She wrote most of her
poetry, when she was undergoing mental and sexual suffering and, as she confessed several
times, an emotional volcano was building inside her. It was only poetry that gave her a
legitimate outlet to purge the fiery substance. Voicing her agonies through her poetry she
appeases the fury of the domestic, social and even female consciousness. Poetry for her
became just another branch of pathology.
Indeed, confessional mode suffers from suffocating solipsistic tendencies, mirroring all forms
of reality in the self of the poetic persona. But in the hands of Sylvia Plath and Eunice de
Souza, this mode develops as a technique to accommodate the external world in the form of
concrete imagery and symbolic representations of an objective type. The various forms of
embellishment used by these poets bring it closer to the external world.
With the use of objective imagery, Plath takes confessional poetry to the heights of an
unprecedented greatness and transcendence. Plath frequently objectifies her inner restlessness
with the image of sea and its immeasurable world inside. She uses most concrete images in
her poems. Likewise De Souza fortifies the confessional mode with physical and natural
imagery which externalizes her mental states of internal suffering. In her poem de Souza
Prabhu she objectifies her parents desire to get a male child and her birth as an undesired
child.
I heard it said
my parents wanted a boy
I’ve done my best to qualify.
I hid the bloodstains
on my clothes
and let my breasts sag.
Words the weapon
to crucify. (“de Souza Prabhu” 14-21)
47
ISSN: 2052-6350(Print), ISSN: 2052-6369(Online)
Global Journal of Arts Humanities and Social Sciences
Vol.2,No.6, pp.44-52, August 2014
Published by European Centre for Research Training and Development UK(www.eajournals.org)
There are strong autobiographical elements in the poems of both these poets. Plath claimed
that she had no sympathy for cries of the heart and merely these could not constitute good
poetry.
Plath’s poetry provides a wider spectrum. She is concerned not only about her own self-body
and mind, but also all those who are suppressed by the powerful elements of the world. In
Daddy she identifies with the Jews drives to concentration camps by the Nazis (her father and
husband) while in Lady Lazarus she talks about the physical exploitation of women in the
world ruled by men. The anger and promise of vengeance to herself which one finds in the
poems of Plath are also present in the poems of Eunice. Plath in Lady Lazarus promises
herself a grand and triumphant comeback:
Out of the ash
I rise with my red hair,
And I eat men like air. (“Lady Lazarus” 52-54)
Both these poets are angry with the society for trying to bind them through custom and
traditions or just attitudes. Plath feels exposed and unprotected “In my sleeveless summery
dress I have no protection, / And they are all gloved and covered, why did nobody tell me?”
(“The Bee Meeting” 3-4). Domesticity according to Plath means measuring the flour, cutting
off the surplus, and adhering to rules. She talks of herself comparing herself to other women
–
I stand in a column
Of winged, unmiraculous women,
Honey-drudgers.
I am no drudge
Though for years I have eaten dust
And dried plates with my dense hair.
And seen my strangeness evaporate. (“String” 20-26)
Plath never gives us the impression of being the battered woman feeling under the burden of
her womanhood. She searches for a place in this world not as a woman but as an individual.
Her failure to do so, manifested in her suicide in 1963, indicates the failure of a so called
advanced society to allow her to live as one.
However, the greatest contribution of Plath and Eunice de Souza in shaping and exploiting
the potentialities of confessional mode is undoubtedly their tremendous effort to develop it
into a vehicle of transcendental experience, which is the hallmark of great poetry. Indeed,
both Plath and De Souza are confessional poets of excellence. Through their path-breaking
poetry, they reveal the unrevealed i.e. the truth hitherto unknown to the common man. They
describe in the most aesthetic terms the agonies of the humiliated, guilt- ridden, bruised and
buried human psyche and human body. They sing of the female body with its moods and
cycles and seasons. They describe the marriage system and woman as a procreation machine.
48
ISSN: 2052-6350(Print), ISSN: 2052-6369(Online)
Global Journal of Arts Humanities and Social Sciences
Vol.2,No.6, pp.44-52, August 2014
Published by European Centre for Research Training and Development UK(www.eajournals.org)
CONCLUSION
Both these writers taken for study write not merely their biographies but create mythologies
of their self. With an imaginative mixture of fact and fiction, they develop and perfect the
confessional poetry, elevating it from a mere instrument of unfolding psychic history, to a
literary mode. Using all tricks of the poetic trade, assuming objective undertones, and they
ultimately flower it into a vehicle of cosmic and mystic experience.
Like other confessional poets Sylvia Plath and Eunice de Souza use poetry as a medium to
communicate to the world. They write in their poetry what they actually feel, use instances
that take place in their life. After reading their poetry, we came to know a lot about them and
what they have gone through in their life. After the thorough examination of the poetry of
these two confessional poets it has been found that these poets are still in the midst of
dualities, because of the dilemma between what they actually want to do and what they
expected to do.
The ensuing conflicts that arise in their unconscious minds result in the development of
depression and frustration in them. Although both the poets belong to two different countries
and cultures, yet they share the same dissatisfaction with the given world order, and their
inner desire of the need for the transformation in the state of women leaves them baffled and
perplexed. Both of them found themselves caught between the conflict of tradition bound self
and the self looking for the freedom. They reveal acute awareness of the tragic fate which
comes with the feeling of being born as a woman.
Their poetry reveals cultural presumptions of the people which identify home-making and
child bearing with femininity. The reality of marriage, wifehood and motherhood has been
expressed by these poets. Eunice de Souza has shown her resentment against the conventional
practices of marriage of her time which are in practice even today in some sectors of India.
But the desire for freedom from the existing social system has ultimately led to a conflict in
the minds of these poets. De Souza while defying the norms on one side has been found to be
suppressing her inner desires and trying to smile on the other hand.
One consequence of these poets is that they heightened the female frustration and depression
under the pressure of patriarchy in their poetry. The extent of the frustration of these women
with the existing social system can be judged by the fact that they do not even hesitate to
express it openly in their poetry. By using confessional mode of writing they not even express
their own feelings of the oppression and frustration but also the same feelings faced by the
women in society. We know that the creation of art is something creative by the whole
psyche, by the conscious and the unconscious and we accept that a temporary regression from
the world of rational consciousness may be a necessary moment in poetic creation. “An
oscillation between regression and full vigilance . . . results in a creative product” (Graziano
51).
Poets have used different ways to tackle the passivity imposed on them and ensuing
harshness in their tone. Both these poets taken for study have adopted irony and ordinariness
49
ISSN: 2052-6350(Print), ISSN: 2052-6369(Online)
Global Journal of Arts Humanities and Social Sciences
Vol.2,No.6, pp.44-52, August 2014
Published by European Centre for Research Training and Development UK(www.eajournals.org)
in their confessional mode of writing poetry to express their anger and dissatisfaction with
their lives. The anger and annoyance against the Goan-Catholic community emerge as one of
the distinct characteristics of De Souza’s poetry. It is the study of psychoanalytical feminism
which helps to understand the process of growth and development of a woman in the society,
and how the repressed unconscious desires affects her future life. It has shown that gender is
constructed; it is not wholly natural but produced.
Eunice de Souza also acknowledges that a woman “finally learn/to claim nothing” (“Aubade”
10-11). She now wants to give up her earlier resentment against all established orders of
society and wants to go with what her hair-dresser says, “take it as it comes” (“Bequest” 8).
This reflects loss of interest in life which has been perceived in her later poetry.
The themes of their poetry have related to life in all its aspects. The poetry has struggled to
break the boundaries of tradition while describing the conflict between the old and the new. It
has endeavoured to express the desire of a woman to break the bonds that have restricted her
since times immemorial. However, the problem she faces is that the entrenched patriarchal
structure is still controlling and restricting her life in one way or the other. It still considers
that she is someone’s daughter, wife or mother, minus her own identity. The poetry of Sylvia
Plath and Eunice de Souza also reveal the frustration which a woman faces because of the
patriarchal structure and the discrepancy between the way she wants to behave and the way
she is made to behave.
Thus they are found similar for several reasons. First, both were classified as confessional
poets, along with Robert Lowell and others, because they exposed intimate personal feelings
in their poetry. Second, both poets discussed common issues in their poetry like fatherdaughter relationship, their obsession with death, treatment of female in male-dominated
society, female exploitation etc. They used confessional poetry as a medium of
communication to the world.
However, in spite of the similarities between these two poets, each poet’s work remains
unique. Both the poets belong to different countries. There is difference of cultural
background. This is not to equate two poet’s achievements. In fact, Plath’s work, especially
her last poetry surpassing Eunice de Souza’s work. Plath became the first poet to win Pulitzer
Prize posthumously for The Collected Poems in 1982. The death drive is less in De Souza’s if
compared with Plath’s. Much of Plath’s poetry seeks the father’s power to advance her
ambitions, to accept her as an equal. It can be argued that Plath differs from De Souza in her
ability to confront the power of the symbolic father through negativity and abjection. Plath
was married to famous poet Ted Hughes while Eunice de Souza is unmarried. Plath
committed suicide in London on 11th Feb. 1963 by hailing the gas of oven and is buried in the
churchyard at Heptonstall, West Yorkshire while De Souza is still alive.
It is quite a coincidence that these two poets, with an age difference should make themselves
the subject matter of their poetry in such diverse cultural set-ups. The study of the impact of
culture on their lives especially because of the diversity in the cultural milieu to which the
two belong has been found very important. American society has always been considered
50
ISSN: 2052-6350(Print), ISSN: 2052-6369(Online)
Global Journal of Arts Humanities and Social Sciences
Vol.2,No.6, pp.44-52, August 2014
Published by European Centre for Research Training and Development UK(www.eajournals.org)
more advanced as compared to Indian society. With its famous practices of Sati and Child
marriage the Indian society seems to be traditional bound and backward. The effect of social
suppression on women in India has been quiet disastrous and Eunice’s poetry stands
testimony to this.
REFERENCES
Agarwal, Suman. (2003) Sylvia Plath, Northern Book Centre, New Delhi.
Alexander, Paul. (1991) Rough Magic: Sylvia Plath, Viking Penguin, New York. P.106, 338356
Butscher, Edward. (1977) Method and Madness, Dodd and Co., New York. P.11
Daruwala, K.N. (1989) “Confessional Poetry as Social Commentary: A View of Indian
Poetry in
English by Indian Women Poets”. Contemporary Indian English Poetry, Ed. Atma
Ram,
Writers Workshop, Calcutta.
De Souza, Eunice. (2009) A Necklace of Skulls: Collected Poems, Penguin Books Ltd., New
Delhi.
—.
( 1979) Fix, New Ground, Bombay.
—.
Ed. (1997) Nine Indian Women Poets: An Anthology, Oxford University Press, New
Delhi.
—.
(1990) Ways of Belonging: Selected Poems, Polygon, Edinburgh.
Fernandes, Keith. (1994) Introduction: Selected and New Poems by Eunice de Souza, St.
Xavier’s, Bombay.
King, Bruce. (1987) Modern Indian Poetry in English, Oxford Univ. Press, New Delhi. P.3
Kukil, Karen V. Ed. (2000) The Unabridged Journals of Sylvia Plath, Anchor Books, New
York.
Mehrotra, Arvind Krishna. Ed. (1990) Twenty Indian Poets, Oxford University Press, New
Delhi.
—.
Ed. (1992) Twelve Modern Indian English Poets, Oxford University Press, New
Delhi. P.114
Naik, M.K. (2006) Indian English Poetry from Beginning upto 2000, Pencraft International,
New
Delhi.
Philips, Robert. (1973) The Confessional Poets, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale.
Plath, Sylvia. (1971) Crossing the Water, Harper Perennial, London.
—.
(1998) The Colossus and other Poems, Vintage Books, New York.
—.
(1982) The Journals of Sylvia Plath, The Dial Press, New York. P.92
Plath, Sylvia. and Hughes Ted. (2008) The Collected Poems, Harper Perennial Modern
Classics, New York.
Rosenthal, M.L. (1959 ) “Poetry as Confession”. The Nation 19 Sept. P.154-155
Singh, Mina Surjit. (2003) Six Women Poets: A Cross Cultural Study, Prestige Books, New
Delhi.
Williams, H.M. (1976) Indo-Anglian Literature (1800-1970): A Survey, Orient Longman,
Bombay.P. 113
51
ISSN: 2052-6350(Print), ISSN: 2052-6369(Online)
Global Journal of Arts Humanities and Social Sciences
Vol.2,No.6, pp.44-52, August 2014
Published by European Centre for Research Training and Development UK(www.eajournals.org)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to thank my supervisor Dr. TANU GUPTA whose encouragement, guidance and
support from the initial to the final level enabled me to develop an understanding of the
subject. I also offer my regards and blessings to all of those who supported me in any respect
during the completion of this research paper.Above all, I express our gratitude to God, the
almighty, who aided me with his strength, gave me wisdom and patience to complete this
paper. Moreover, I am indebted to my husband, my daughter and other family members for
their help and supports.
ANJU BALA SHARMA
52
ISSN: 2052-6350(Print), ISSN: 2052-6369(Online)