https://menj.journals.ekb.eg
Print ISSN: 2735-3974
Online ISSN: 2735-3982
DOI: --------------------
MNJ
Menoufia Nursing Journal
Faculty of Nursing
Menoufia University
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses'
Performance Regarding Care of Women Undergoing
Hysteroscopy
Neama Mahmoud Hassan Ali1, Dalal Mohamed Khalil Eshra2,
Howida Abo- Ellife Mohamed3
1
BNSc., Faculty of Nursing - Menoufia University
2
Professor of Maternal and Newborn Health
3
Assistant professor of Maternal and Newborn Health Nursing,
2,3
Faculty of Nursing, Menoufia University
Background: Hysteroscopy is one of the most common gynecological procedures, the
most accurate technique in order to visualize the endometrial cavity, diagnose and treat
the relevant pathologies. Purpose: To examine the effect of nursing interventions on
maternity nurses' performance regarding the care of women undergoing hysteroscopy.
Design: A quasi-experimental design was used. Setting: The Gynecological department
at Menoufia University hospitals. Sample: A purposive sample containing 45 nurses
for six months. Instruments: The instruments used for data collection were a
structured interview questionnaire sheet, and the nurses’ performance observational
checklist. Results: Nurses had higher level of knowledge on post -test related to
definition, indications, suitable time, complications, time needed for diagnosis, and
time needed for therapeutic or surgical treatment of hysteroscopy (100%) compared to
(2.2%) on pretest. Also they had higher level of performance on posttest (91.1%) than
pretest (13.3%) related to pre, intra, and post-operative preparation for women
undergoing hysteroscopy. The present study revealed that there was a high statistically
significance difference between the studied nurses' total knowledge score and their
residence, there was a high statistically significance relation between the studied
nurses' total practice level regarding the care of women undergoing hysteroscopy and
their socio-demographic characteristics in the residence. While there was a high
statistically significant positive correlation between the total knowledge score and the
total practice level of studied nurses. Conclusion: The studied nurses had poor
knowledge level and low level of performance regarding the nursing care provided for
women undergoing hysteroscopy procedure before introducing the nursing intervention
program. But after implementing the nursing program; the studied nurses' knowledge
and practice were improved. Recommendation: Continuous training programs
regarding hysteroscopy for maternity nurses to develop and improve their knowledge
and practice.
Key words: Hysteroscopy, Nurses’ Performance, Nursing Intervention.
MNJ, Vol. 8, No. 4, DEC 2023, PP: 227 - 241
227
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
Introduction
Hysteroscopy is a minimally invasive
technique for pathology assessment
and treatment of the uterus cavity.
While office hysteroscopy started in
the 1980s, the operation was originally
carried out in 1869. Technological
developments have made office
hysteroscopy possible as a smaller, less
expensive tools. Any pathology that is
seen can be treated by operational
hysteroscopy. The indications for both
surgical and diagnostic treatments
significantly overlap. As long as the
patient tolerates the procedure and
aberrant pathology is identified, the
"see and treat" strategy enables a
smooth transition from diagnostic to
surgical hysteroscopy (Zelivianskaia,
& Robinson, 2022).
Minor diseases can be treated using
hysteroscopy in an office setting. To
ensure optimal visibility, a distension
medium is required. These media
include liquid-based media like normal
saline and 1.5% glycine, which are
utilized for both diagnostic and
surgical hysteroscopy, as well as
gaseous media like carbon dioxide,
which are used for diagnostic
hysteroscopy. Every gynecologist's
toolkit should include a hysteroscopy
(Okohue 2020).
Hysteroscopy is the gold standard for
diagnosing
endometrial
polyps,
endometrial cancer, abnormal uterine
bleeding,
uterine
adhesions,
miscarriage
reasons,
intrauterine
device
location,
and
surgical
sterilization. Compared to endometrial
biopsy, blind dilation, and curettage,
hysteroscopy with tissues sample had
reduced rates of false positives and
228
false negatives. (Zelivianskaia, &
Robinson, 2022). Endocervical canal,
tubal ostia, and uterine cavity were all
examined and treated by hysteroscopy.
In comparison with other techniques
like hysterography, hysteroscopy may
provide a more accurate diagnosis, a
better foundation for therapy, or
confirmation of results (Soliman et al.,
2022).
Uterine cavity distension is required
for all hysteroscopy operations. For
uterine cavity distension during both
diagnostic and surgical hysteroscopy,
different media are used. the fluid is
also utilized, as are the gas media for
diagnostic hysteroscopy. The patient's
fluid intake and output during a
hysteroscopy should be observed by
perioperative
nurses.
Increased
systemic fluid absorption is a result of
higher distending media pressure, and
fluid overload can occur with any
distending media. The maximum safe
hydration deficit for each patient is
something that perioperative nurses
should also be aware of (Donan et al.,
2020).
Our daily lives have been continuously
revolutionized by the technical and
technological advances in gynecology.
Improved hysteroscopy knowledge and
performance among maternity nurses
can only be achieved via the use of the
nursing intervention program. The
maternity nurses' knowledge of how to
care for women having hysteroscopy
can be updated and improved with the
use
of
numerous
instructional
materials, including large posters,
pamphlets, and guided books (Campo,
et al., 2018).
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
According to WHO reports, (2020) in
Egypt stated that; nearly 808 per
100,000 women died every day due to
preventable causes of pregnancy and
childbirth, such as hemorrhage,
hypertension, infection and indirect
causes due to interaction between
preexisting medical conditions and
pregnancy. 94% of them are from low
and middle income countries. Another
meta-analysis study mentioned that the
incidence of maternal death globally
was 18.5 per 1000 live birth.
Maternity nurses
must
be a
knowledgeable about the techniques
and tools used in hysteroscopy. The
role of nurses in pre- and postoperative care for women having
hysteroscopy, as well as coordinators
of the treatment team (surgeon,
women's anesthesiologist) include
equipment preparation and storage. A
crucial part of streamlining the
hysteroscopy procedure is played by
maternity nurses, who provide
compassionate care, support for
women,
meticulous
planning,
acquisition of essential supplies, and
careful maintenance of ultrasound
equipment
Pregnancy,
severe
metrorrahagia, acute cervicovaginitis,
and pelvic inflammatory disease (PID)
are among the conditions that preclude
hysteroscopy (Oroomiechihia et al.,
2020).
Significance of the study:
One of the most important roles that
nurses play in hysteroscopy is before
having a hysteroscopy, patients are
educated about the many forms of the
procedure, its reasons, therapeutic
approaches, and the possibilities both
before and after the procedure.
Preparing and supporting the women;
providing care and education following
surgery; and, lastly, taking care of the
instruments and cleaning them
(Oroomiechihia et al., 2020). There are
little gynecological nursing researches
regarding hysteroscopy, which move
me to initiate like this research aiming
to increase the research area in the
gynecological field.
Purpose of the study
Examine the effect of nursing
interventions on maternity nurses'
performance regarding the care of
women undergoing hysteroscopy.
Research hypotheses:
1)
2)
Maternity nurses who receive the
nursing intervention program are
expected to have higher level of
knowledge about care of women
undergoing
hysteroscopy
on
posttest than pretest.
Maternity nurses who receive the
nursing intervention program are
expected to have higher level of
practice related to care of women
undergoing
hysteroscopy
on
posttest than pretest.
Operational definition of variables:
1) Nursing intervention: In this study, nursing intervention
refers to systematically developed
instructional
programs
using
instructional aids such as guided
brochures and big posters designed
to provide information concerning
the care of women undergoing
hysteroscopy.
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
229
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
2) Nursing performance: In this study, the studied nurses will
operationally apply their skills
regarding hysteroscopy technique, it
was assessed through instrument
two (the observation checklist).
Methods
Design:
A quasi-experimental (one group pre,
posttest and follow up) design was utilized
in this study.
Setting:
The study was conducted in Obstetrics
and Gynecological department at
Menoufia
University
hospital,
Menoufia Governorate, Egypt.
Sampling:
A convenient sample of all maternity
nurses' (45) who work in Obstetrics
and Gynecological department at
Menoufia University hospital was
recruited in the study.
Sampling size:
All nurses work in Obstetrics and
Gynecological department at Menoufia
University
Hospital
45
nurses
including word nurses, in addition to
scrapping, circulating and recovery
nurses. All nurses act as both scrapping
and circulating nurses. Also they as
assistant nurse, professional nurse and
nursing supervisor.
Instruments:
Two instruments were utilized for data
collection:
Instrument
one:
-
Structured
interviewing questionnaire:
The researcher developed after a
review of literature (Soliman et al.,
2022; Oroomiechiha et al., 2020) to
232
assess the effect of "nursing
intervention" on studied nurses’
knowledge and performance related to
hysteroscopy. It was distributed into
two parts:
Part
1:
Socio-demographic
characteristics
of
maternity
nurses as age, educational level,
years of experience, and the
previous training courses…..etc.
Part
2:
Maternity
nurses’
knowledge. It was developed to
assess knowledge of studied nurses
about hysteroscopy and its care. It
included many questions such as:
definition,
indications,
complications, and specific nursing
care of hysteroscopy that were
scored.
The total knowledge levels were
presented as the following:
Good: ≥ 75% of total knowledge
score.
Fair:
<75% - 50% of total
knowledge score.
Poor: if the percent score was less
than 50%.
Instrument
two:
Nurses’
performance observational checklist:
The observational checklist was
established by the researchers based on
review of literature (Janesh et al.,
2019). It was developed to examine the
studied nurses’ performance related to
hysteroscopy care. It contained thirty
statements to assess six essential
competencies such as; Preoperational
checklist (5 items) for each scrapping
and circulating nurse, checklist (5
items) for each scrapping and
circulating nurse intra-operatively and
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
another (5 items) for both recovery and
ward nurses at postoperative phase.
Scoring system:
Scoring system for done was 2 and 1
for not done. If total score was < 20
level of practice was low, if it ranged
between 20 to 30, level of practice was
considered moderate and if total score
was 30 to 40 level of practice was
considered high.
Validity of the instrument: The questionnaire was formulated and
cross-checked for its validity by five
qualified experts (four professors in
maternity nursing at Faculty of
Nursing and one of obstetric medicine.
They were asked to judge the items for
completeness and clarity and the
required modification were done
accordingly.
Reliability of the instruments: The researcher was assessed the
reliability using test-retest reliability
for testing the internal consistency of
the instruments. It was done through
the administration of the same
instruments to the same studied nurses
under similar conditions on two or
more occasions. Scores from repeated
testing were compared to test
consistency of the result over time.
Ethical consideration:
The researcher introduced herself to
the studied nurses and explained the
purpose of the study and its nature to
obtain their acceptance to be recruited
in the study in addition to gain their
cooperation. The studied nurses were
informed that the information collected
during the study will be kept
confidential and used only for
statistical purpose. Considering the
ethical aspects of scientific research,
respecting all cultural, spiritual and
religious
beliefs
for
nurses.
Maintaining the confidentiality and
dignity of the nurses. Avoiding any
harm to the nurses.
Pilot study:
Pilot study was carried out on 10% of
the studied nurses (5 nurses) from the
total number of (50) nurses for a period
of three weeks before the beginning of
data collection in order to evaluate the
study instruments according to the
simplicity, clarity, applicability. They
were also excluded from the main
study sample. Results of the piloting
study helped refining the interview
questionnaire and to schedule the time
framework. The required modifications
were done in form of clarification and
simplification of some sentences.
Procedure
An official letter was submitted from
the Dean of the Faculty of Nursing,
Menoufia University to the directors of
Menoufia University hospital. It
contained an explanation of the
purpose of the study and methods of
data collection 2The data was
collected in a period of six months,
from the beginning of October 2022 to
the end of March 2023. The researcher
began the study by visiting the
Obstetrics'
and
Gynecology
Department at Menoufia University
hospital twice per week (MondayWednesday) from 9AM - 1PM. Each
session included about 2-3 nurses. At
the beginning of interview, the
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
232
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
researcher greeted the maternity
nurses', introduced herself, explained
the purpose of the study and the nature
of the study, and took an oral consent
to participate in the study.
The
structured
interviewing
questionnaire was distributed between
nurses for obtaining the personal data
and collecting the studied nurses'
knowledge regarding hysteroscopy, the
time needed for completing the
structured interviewing questionnaire
was about 10 minutes. Then, the
researcher used the observational
checklist to assess nurses' performance.
The time needed to fulfill each
instrument by nurses was about 30
minutes.
Each nurse received three sessions.
First session included information
about Definition of hysteroscopy,
indications of hysteroscopy, and time
suitable for hysteroscopy. Second
session included complications of
hysteroscopy, time required for
diagnostic hysteroscopy, and time
required for curative hysteroscopy.
Third session was about hand washing,
preoperative
preparation,
intraoperative
manipulation
of
hysteroscopy,
and
postoperative
rehabilitation of studied nurses for
women undergoing hysteroscopy.
Methods of teaching included lectures
and group discussions. Teaching media
included posters and brochures. All
these steps were repeated for six
months until the needed sample was
obtained. The researcher assessed the
nurses' performance using the same
instruments
(pretest
(30min.)Intervention
(30min.)posttest
(30min.).
232
Posttest was conducted one week
following the educational nursing
intervention and follow-up test was
conducted 3 months later. Data
collection instruments which were used
in pretest were reused during post and
follow-up tests.
Statistical analysis:
The data collected was organized,
categorized, analyzed and tabulated
Statistical analysis was done using
SPSS version 22.0.Mean, standard
deviation (SD), frequency and
percentages were used for descriptive
data, Chi square test was used A
statistical significant difference was
considered if P ≤ 0.05. A highly
statistical significant difference if P ≤
0.01. A very highly statistical
significant difference was considered if
P≤ 0.001.
Results:
Table (1): shows distribution of
studied nurses according to their
personal data. As evident from the
table, about two thirds (66.7%) of the
studied nurses were 20 to less than 30
years old. While about 62.2% of them
had Technical Diploma of Nursing.
Additionally, more than one third of
them (42.2%) had Less than 5 years of
experience. In addition, approximately
three quarters of them (75.6%) were
assistant nurses. Moreover, 66.7% of
studied nurses were from rural area.
Only 8.9% had completed previous
training courses.
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
Table (2): shows distribution of
studied nurses according to their
knowledge about hysteroscopy on pre,
post and follow- up tests. An
improvement in nurses’ knowledge
was observed in post and follow-up
tests. So, there was a highly
statistically significant
difference
among pre, post and follow- up
interventions for the studied nurses
regarding their knowledge about
hysteroscopy.
Table (3): shows distribution of
studied nurses according to their preoperative practice about hysteroscopy
on pre, post and follow- up tests. There
was a highly statistically significant
difference among pre, post and follow
up interventions for the studied nurses
regarding all pre- operative preparation
of women undergoing hysteroscopy
except assuring bathing before
hysteroscopy technique, as there was
no statistically significant difference
among pre, post and follow up
interventions for the studied nurses.
Table (4): shows distribution of
studied nurses according to their intraoperative practice about hysteroscopy
on pre, post and follow- up tests. There
was a highly statistically significant
difference among pre, post and follow
up interventions for the studied nurses
regarding greeting the woman with
touch, identify the woman surgical
staff names and numbers and prepared
the equipment needed as doctor
ordered. There was a statistically
significant difference among pre, post
and follow up interventions for the
studied nurses regarding explain the
components of operation room. There
was
no statistically significant
difference among pre, post and follow
up interventions for the studied nurses
regarding and ensure signing the
informed
consent
and
explain
anesthesia types and its risks.
Table (5): Shows distribution of
studied nurses according to their postoperative practice about hysteroscopy
on pre, post and follow- up tests. There
was a highly statistically significant
difference (P= .001**) between pre,
post and follow up interventions for the
studied nurses regarding most of postoperative preparation of women
undergoing hysteroscopy. There was a
statistically significant
difference
among pre, post and follow up
interventions for the studied nurses
regarding assure the woman in the
recovery position. There was no
statistically significant
difference
among pre, post and follow up
interventions for the studied nurses
regarding
making
a
systemic
assessment of the woman, reporting
any abnormalities in vital signs to the
doctor, detecting, and managing the
early complication and endorsing to
the ward nurses.
Figure (1): demonstrates level of
knowledge of studied nurses about
hysteroscopy on pre, post, and followup tests. They had average score of
knowledge regarding hysteroscopy
pre- intervention (60%) but postintervention; the studied nurses had
good score of knowledge regarding
hysteroscopy post intervention (100%)
and in follow up had good score of
knowledge regarding hysteroscopy
post intervention (93.4%).
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
233
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
Figure (2): demonstrate level of
practice of studied nurses about
hysteroscopy on pre, post, and followup tests. The studied nurses had
unsatisfactory level of practice
regarding care of women undergoing
hysteroscopy pre intervention (86.7%)
but post intervention; the studied
nurses had satisfactory level of practice
regarding care of women undergoing
hysteroscopy post intervention (91.1%)
also in follow up; the studied nurses
had satisfactory level of practice
regarding care of women undergoing
hysteroscopy
post
intervention
(88.9%).
Table (6): clarifies the correlation
between the studied nurses' total
knowledge level and the total practice
level. There was a highly statistically
significant positive correlation between
the studied nurses' total knowledge
level and the total practice level. When
the knowledge increased, the practice
of the studied nurses improved.
Table (1): Distribution of Studied Nurses according to their Personal Data (N = 45)
Variables
Age
- 20 to less than 30
- 30 to less than 40
- More than or equal to 40
Educational level
- Diploma of nursing
- Technical diploma of nursing
- Bachelor degree
- Post- graduate (Master or PHD.)
Experience
- less than 5 years
- More than 5 and less than 10 years
- More than 10 years
Position Level of Work
- Assistant nurse
- Professional nurse
- Nursing supervisor
Residence
- Rural
- Urban
Previous training Courses
- Yes
- No
234
No.
%
30
9
6
66.7
20.0
13.3
9
28
6
2
20.1
62.2
13.3
4.4
19
15
11
42.3
33.3
24.4
34
8
3
75.6
17.8
6.6
30
15
66.7
33.3
4
41
8.9
91.1
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
Table (2): Distribution of Studied Nurses according to Their Knowledge about
Hysteroscopy on Pre, Post and Follow- up Tests. (N=45)
PrePostFollow up
Variables
intervention
intervention
No.
%
No.
%
No.
%
Pvalue
Definition of hysteroscopy
- Incorrect answer or (don’t know)
21
46.7
0
0
0
0
24
53.3
45
100.0
45
100.0
- Correct answer
Indications of hysteroscopy
- Incorrect answer or (don’t know)
28
62.2
0
0
0
0
- Correct answer
17
37.8
45
100.0
45
100.0
Suitable time for hysteroscopy
- Incorrect answer or (don’t know)
23
51.1
0
0
2
4.5
22
48.9
45
100.0
43
95.5
- Correct answer
Complications of hysteroscopy
- Incorrect answer or (don’t know)
2.3
20
44.4
0
0
1
97.7
- Correct answer
25
55.6
45
100.0
44
Time needed for diagnostic hysteroscopy
- Incorrect answer or (don’t know)
24
53.3
3
6.7
5
11.1
- Correct answer
21
46.7
42
93.3
40
88.9
Time needed for therapeutic or surgical
hysteroscopy
- Incorrect answer or (don’t know)
27
60.0
4
8.9
2
4.5
- Correct answer
18
40.0
41
91.1
43
95.5
Table (3): Distribution of Studied Nurses according to Their pre-operative practice about
Hysteroscopy on Pre, Post and Follow- up Tests. (N=45)
Variables
Greeting the woman
with touch.
Explain the procedure
(steps- time- persons
equipment)
Build a trusting
relationship using
primary explanation,
and active listening.
Take a complete history.
Perform a complete
physical examination.
Instruct her about
methods and exercises
that reduce stress and
anxiety related to
procedures
Pre intervention
(N=45)
Done
Not done
No.
%
No.
%
.001**
.001**
.001**
.001**
.001**
.001**
Post intervention
(N= 45)
Done
Not done
No.
%
No.
%
Follow up
(N=45)
Done
Not done
No.
%
No.
%
P
value
2
4.4
43
95.6
42
93.3
3
6.7
40
88.9
5
11.1
.001**
3
6.7
42
93.3
41
91.1
4
8.9
39
86.7
6
13.3
.001**
3
6.7
42
93.3
40
88.9
5
11.1
40
88.9
5
11.1
.001**
2
4.4
43
95.6
42
93.3
3
6.7
38
84.4
7
15.6
.001**
3
6.7
42
93.3
40
88.9
5
11.1
40
88.9
5
11.1
.001**
8
17.8
37
82.2
40
88.9
5
11.1
38
84.4
7
15.6
.001**
Provide instructions
regarding the operation for
both the woman and her
family.
7
15.6
38
84.4
40
88.9
5
11.1
38
84.4
7
15.6
.001**
Shaved the perineum.
3
6.7
42
93.3
42
93.3
3
6.7
40
88.9
5
11.1
.001**
Perform bathing before
surgery.
39
86.7
6
13.3
39
86.7
6
13.3
35
77.7
10
22.3
.368
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
235
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
Table (4): Distribution of Studied Nurses according to Their intra-operative practice
about Hysteroscopy on Pre, Post and Follow- up Tests. (N=45)
Variables
Greeting the patient with
touch
Explain the components
of operation room
Prepared the equipment
needed as doctor ordered.
Identify woman surgical
staff names and numbers
Describe anesthesia types
and its risks
Signed the informed
consent.
Pre intervention
(N=45)
Done
Not done
No.
%
No.
%
Post intervention
(N= 45)
done
Not done
No.
%
No.
%
Follow up
(N=45)
Done
Not done
No.
%
No.
%
P value
1
2.2
44
97.8
39
86.7
6
13.3
45
100.0
0
0
.000**
3
6.7
42
93.3
37
82.2
8
17.8
45
100.0
0
0
.030*
44
97.8
1
2.2
45
100
0
0
40
88.9
5
11.1
.001**
6
13.3
39
86.7
41
91.1
4
8.9
39
86.7
6
13.3
.001**
8
17.8
37
82.2
39
86.7
6
13.3
38
84.4
7
15.6
.105
44
97.8
1
2.2
44
97.8
1
2.2
41
91.1
4
8.9
.717
P value
Table (5): Distribution of Studied Nurses according to Their Post-Operative practice
about Hysteroscopy on Pre, Post and Follow- up Tests. (N=45)
Variables
Put woman in the
recovery position.
Assess the ABCs
(airway, breathing and
circulation).
Check the conscious
level.
Monitoring the vital
signs.
Make a systemic
assessment of the woman
Assess pain level.
Pre intervention
(N=45)
Done
Not done
No
%
No.
%
Post intervention
(N= 45)
Done
Not done
No.
%
No.
%
Follow up
(N=45)
Done
Not done
No.
%
No.
%
37
82.2
8
17.8
44
97.8
1
2.2
42
93.3
3
6.7
.008*
31
68.9
14
31.1
41
91.1
4
8.9
40
88.9
5
11.1
.002**
28
62.2
17
37.8
42
93.3
3
6.7
39
86.7
6
13.3
.002**
40
88.9
5
11.1
43
95.6
2
4.4
39
86.7
6
13.3
.001**
17
37.8
28
62.2
38
84.4
7
15.6
36
80.0
9
20.0
.156
17
37.8
28
62.2
39
86.7
6
13.3
35
77.8
10
22.2
.001**
Observe and record the
intake and output.
Reassure the woman and
keep empathy
Report any abnormalities
in vital signs to the
doctor
Detect and manage the
early complication
And endorse to the ward
nurse
10
22.2
35
77.8
41
91.1
4
8.9
39
86.7
6
13.3
.001**
24
53.3
21
46.7
43
95.6
2
4.4
39
86.7
6
13.3
.001**
41
91.1
4
8.9
44
97.8
1
2.2
44
97.8
1
2.2
.165
42
93.3
3
6.7
44
97.8
1
2.2
44
97.8
1
2.2
.368
44
97.8
1
2.2
44
97.8
1
2.2
40
88.9
5
11.1
.165
236
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
Figure (1): Levels of knowledge of studied nurses about hysteroscopy on pre, post, and
follow-up tests. (N=45)
Level of Knowledge
Poor
Average
Good
100%
93.4%
60%
37.8
2.2%
0
0%
0
6.6%
Pre- intervention
Post- intervention
follow up
Figure (2): Level of practice of studied nurses about hysteroscopy on pre, post, and
follow-up tests. (N-45)
Level of Practice
Unsatisfactory
86.7%
91.1%
Satisfactory
88.9
13.3%
8.9%
11.1
Pre- intervention
Post- intervention
follow up
Table (6): Correlation between the studied nurses' total knowledge level and the total
practice level (N=45)
r
Total knowledge
..566**
Total Practice Level
(N=40)
P value
.001**
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
237
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
Discussion
As regards the studied nurses’
knowledge about care of women
undergoing hysteroscopy, results of the
current study revealed that there was a
highly
statistically
significant
improvement in nurses’ knowledge
about hysteroscopy on post and followup tests compared to pretest. More than
half of study sample did not have
knowledge
about
definition,
indications, the duration of diagnostic
hysteroscopy,
the
duration
of
therapeutic hysteroscopy, and the
complications of hysteroscopy. This
result was similar to Elsayed et al.,
(2022) study findings proved nearly
two thirds of the studied nurses had
inadequate
knowledge
regarding
definition, preparation, proper time,
duration, methods of diagnosis, and
complications of hysteroscopy. This
could be attributed to lack of
continuing educational programs about
hysteroscopy nursing care.
On the other hand, findings were in
disagreement with Kandeel et al.,
(2019) who stated that about half of the
studied nurses had adequate correct
answers regarding knowledge about
hysteroscopy. According to the
researcher's point of view. However,
this difference could be attributed to
the previous in-service education
programs which were conducted for
these nurses.
Furthermore, results of the current
study revealed that there was a highly
statistically significant improvement in
nurses’ knowledge level about
hysteroscopy on post and follow-up
tests compared to pre-test. This result
238
was similar to Soliman et al., (2022)
who reported that after implementing
the educational program, more than
two thirds of the studied nurses had
improvement in their knowledge
regarding hysteroscopy field. This
could be attributed to maternity nurses
always need feeding information in
order to maintain, develop and update
their level of knowledge regarding
hysteroscopy.
Introducing
an
interventional program in simple
language, with different teaching
media, and at nurses’ places facilitate
utilizing knowledge and eliminate any
obstacles.
Regarding the relationship between the
studied nurses' total knowledge score
concerning the care of women
undergoing hysteroscopy and their
socio demographic characteristics. The
present study showed that there was no
statistical
significant
relationship
between nurses' knowledge and their
residence. These findings come in
contrast with El-Toukhy et al., (2019)
who mentioned that there was a
statistically
significance
relation
between the studied nurses' total
knowledge score and their residence.
Moreover, findings of the present study
showed that there was no statistically
significant
relationship
between
studied nurses' knowledge, age,
educational levels, occupation and
their years of experience. This finding
did not come in line with Mohamed et
al., (2020) who mentioned that the
majority of the studied sample had a
statistically significant relationship
between their knowledge, and years of
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
experience. It may be due to different
nursing samples that were used in their
studies, and in addition to different
universities policies in employing new
staff, such as following the rotation
policy may affect the nurses'
knowledge in accordance with years of
experience.
Concerning the statistical correlation
between the studied nurses' total
knowledge score and total practice
level; the present study demonstrated
that there was a highly statistically
significant positive correlation between
total knowledge score and total
practice level of the studied nurses.
When the knowledge increased, the
practice of studied nurses improved.
The study results were congruent with
Ali et al., (2019). An increase of the
studied nurses' knowledge is associated
or accompanied with improved
performance. An increase in the
studied nurses' practice was due to
improvement of knowledge utilized
methods of teaching, utilized media
and nurses desire to improve and
update
their
knowledge
and
performance, the need for maintaining
their jobs or their concept these
policies are changeable.
Furthermore; the present study
revealed that the studied nurses had
inadequate level of performance before
the program. But after introducing the
intervention program, the nurses'
performance improved. The current
study findings were similar to Ahmed
& Abdelhakm. (2017 who discovered
that, prior to intervention, the greatest
proportion of nurses lacked knowledge
After the intervention, the majority of
them had good knowledge. It may be
due to training sessions, using different
teaching media including group
discussion,
demonstration,
Redemonstration, posters and brochures
in introducing the study's nursing
intervention program. All of this
emphasized and achieved the first
study hypothesis, in which nursing
intervention program has a great role in
improving nursing knowledge and
practices.
Conclusion
Based on the results of the current
study; it was demonstrated that
majority of the studied nurses had lack
of knowledge regarding hysteroscopy
before introducing the nursing
interventions
program.
After
implementing the nursing intervention
program, the studied nurses achieved a
higher level of knowledge regarding
the care of women undergoing
hysteroscopy. On the other hand; level
of performance for studied nurses
regarding the care of women
undergoing
hysteroscopy
before
introducing the nursing intervention
program was inadequate. But after
implementing the nursing intervention
program, the studied nurses achieved a
higher level of performance regarding
the care of women undergoing
hysteroscopy and this result support
the second hypothesis.
Recommendations
In light of the findings of present study
the following recommendations are
suggested. Regular training programs
and orientation courses for maternity
nurses' working in the Gynecological
department regarding hysteroscopy
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
239
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
field based on their needs obtained.
Instructional booklets, posters and
brochures regarding hysteroscopy
should be prepared for maternity
nurses
at
all
Gynecological
departments about haw deal with
hysteroscopy devices, instruments,
cleaning, sterilization, storage, staff
manipulation, taking off as well as
communication and counseling skills
that should be provided. Additionally,
further research should be showed to
assessment
of
knowledge
and
performance for other Gynecological
procedures.
References
Ahmed, A, & Abdelhakm, M. (2017):
developing nursing management
protocol for maternity nurses
regarding emergency obstetric
care. American Journal of
Nursing Science, 6(5): 418-425
Ali, N, Mohamed, M., Abdel Gawad,
N., Said, S. (2019): Assessment
of nursing care for women
undergoing hysteroscopy, Master
Thesis, Faculty of Nursing,
Benah University, Egypt, pp. 2030.
Available at: www.medical journal of
Cairo University.net
Donan, P. C., Jr, Pace, K. A., Ruiz, C.
W., & Gracia, M. M. (2020).
Distending Media Used During
Hysteroscopy:
Perioperative
Nursing
Implications. AORN
Journal, 112(6),
634–648.
https://doi.org/10.1002/aorn.1324
6
Elsayed, L., Elfawal, M., Abdou, A., &
Alsowey,
A.
(2022).
Sonohysterography
Versus
242
Hystroscopy in Evaluation Of
Uterine
Cavity
Pathology. Zagazig
University
Medical Journal, 28 (2), 284-296.
doi:
10.21608/zumj.2021.60114.2110
El-Toukhy, T., Campo, R., Khalaf, Y.,
Tabanelli, C., Gianaroli, L.,
Gordts, S. S., Gordts, S.,
Mestdagh, G., Mardesic, T.,
Voboril, J., Marchino, G. L.,
Benedetto, C., Al-Shawaf, T.,
Sabatini, L., Seed, P. T.,
Gergolet, M., Grimbizis, G.,
Harb, H., & Coomarasamy, A.
(2016). Hysteroscopy in recurrent
in-vitro
fertilisation
failure
(TROPHY):
a
multicentre,
randomised
controlled
trial. Lancet
(London,
England), 387(10038),
2614–
2621.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S01406736(16)00258-0
http://www.who.int/reproductivehealth
/publication/monitoring/maternal
mortality2013/en.2014
Kandeel, M., Sayyed, T., Tharwat, A.,
Hamed, A.(2020). Hysteroscopy
versus transvaginal ultrasound in
infertile women prior intracytoplasmic sperm injection.
Menoufia Med J,33(2):400-404.
Available
from: http://www.mmj.eg.net/text
.asp?2020/33/2/400/287770
Mohamed, E., Muhammad, Z., Safwat,
A., Abd Elmohsen, S. (2020).
The
effect
of
Nursing
Intervention Protocol About
Laparoscopic Urological Surgery
on Nurse’s Performance and
Patient
Outcome. Assiut
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
Effect of Nursing Intervention on Maternity Nurses' Performance Regarding
Care of Women Undergoing Hysteroscopy
Scientific
Nursing
Journal,
8(20.0),
96-104.
doi:
Okohue J. E. (2020). Overview of
Hysteroscopy. West
African
Journal of Medicine, 37(2), 178–
182.
Oroomiechiha, M. (2020). The Role of
Nurse
in
Diagnostic
and
Operative
Hysteroscopy,
Gynecol. Obstet. Case Rep .,6
(3:22
Soliman, A., Sedek, A., and Mahmoud,
A.,
Aboelkheer,
(2022):
Comparative study between
hysteroscopy
and
threedimension
ultrasound
in
diagnosis of recurrent abortion,
European Journal of Obstetrics&
Gynecology and reproductive
biology, 90(4), 1029-1216.
10.21608/asnj.2020.88645
World health organization, (2020):
Trends in maternal mortality:
Accessed: November 14, 2020:
Available at:
Zelivianskaia, A., & Robinson, J. K.,
3rd (2022). Office Hysteroscopy:
Setting up Your Practice for
Success. Obstetrics
and
gynecology clinics of North
America, 49(2),
315–327.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ogc.202
2.02.011
Menoufia Nursing Journal, Vol. 8, No. 4, Dec 2023
242