Complex Partial Status Epilepticus Presenting as
Gelastic Seizures: A Case Report
Jaga Nath Glassman, M.D. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
Resident in Psychiatry, Brown University Affiliated Hospitals
Donna Dryer, B.S.
Brown University Medical School, Providence, Rhode Island
James R. McCartney, M.D.
Psychiatrist-in-Chief and Assistant Professor, Department of Psychiatry, The Miriam Hospital, Providence,
Rhode Island zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
Abstract: A middle-aged man, who presented to the emergency
increasing interest in complex partial status epilep-
room because of bizarre outbursts of laughter, was found to be in
ticus [l-4]. There can be a broad spectrum of
partial complex status epilepticus. His seizure disorder had been
clinical behavior that may mimic psychotic behavmisdiagnosed, at various times, as a variety of “ ‘ functional”
ior.
psychiatric disorders. Despite proper diagnosis and aggressive
These behavioral manifestations must be distreatment, management was difficult, being complicated by
tinguished from those of other diagnostic entities.
postictal agitation and confusion, postictal psychosis, and interDissociative disorders such as prolonged psychoictal compulsive and paranoid personality features. This case is
genic fugues, derealization, and depersonalization
described, and issues of diagnosis and management in partial
can present with parallel symptoms, as can hyscomplex epilepsy are briefly discussed. The importance of not
terical pseudoseizures or even malingering. The
overlooking organic and especially epileptic factors, despite the
behavior in complex partial seizures is more sterpresence of prior psychiatric illness, psychologic contributors,
eotypic and repetitive than in these conditions.
and environmental stressors, is emphasized. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
A case of partial complex status epilepticus, presenting as gelastic seizures, illustrated quite vividly
some important clinical features of complex partial
epilepsy. Complex partial status epilepticus is often
difficult to diagnose. It can be mistaken for a variety
of other psychiatric illnesses. The patient to be described had been diagnosed at various times as
suffering from a Bipolar Affective Disorder-manic
phase, brief, Reactive Psychosis, and Conversion
Disorder, as well as a paranoid personality disorder. In addition, the difficulties in the clinical
management of the varied features of both complex
partial status and complex partial epilepsy in general were well illustrated in this case. There has been
General Hospital Psychiatry 8,614X
1986
0 1986 Elsevier Science Publishing Co., Inc.
52 Vanderbilt Avenue,
New York, NY 10017
One type of bizarre behavior rarely seen is epileptic laughter (gelastic epilepsy). Gelastic episodes
have been known to accompany the automatisms,
fugues, confusion, and psychotic behavior observed during complex partial status [5-71.
Case Report: M r. B
M r. B is a 55-year-old, right-handed, married, Caucasian male, currently on disability. He presented initially in the emergency room late in the afternoon on
5/l/84, brought by his wife because of strange outbursts of raucous laughter. These outbursts, very disturbing to his wife and daughter, seemed unrelated to
any external stimuli. The first such laughing episode
had occurred earlier that day while the patient was
attending an art class at a local college. For no apparent
61
ISSN 0163~8343/86/$3.50
J. N. Glassman,
D. Dryer, and J. R. McCartney
reason, he had started a deep, raucous laughing accompanied with a motion of pounding the desk with
his right fist, in a movement akin to a “slapping of the
thigh” often associated with laughter, this was quite
disruptive to the class, and Mrs. B. had to drive him
home.
At home, the laughter episodes continued intermittently, typically lasting for lo-30 seconds. Despite
Mrs. B’s repeated imploring of him to “tell me what
the joke is, so I can laugh too,” he remained strangely
non-communicative,
with only rare verbal responses.
The authors were called to consult in the emergency room after medical screening and neurologic physical examination
proved to be unremarkable.
The
nurses indicated that “he won’t talk but only laughs.”
He was lying supine on the gurney, a swarthy, grayhaired, bearded, middle-aged man with eyes closed
and a slight smile. Initially, he did not respond to
questioning at all; as we gently, but firmly, encouraged him to speak with us, he answered some questions appropriately
with nods of the head, then
opened his eyes, looked directly at us, and began to
answer some questions with brief verbal responses.
He would not answer simple mental status questions.
When asked if something disturbing had happened at
the art class, he seemed to become sad and averted his
eyes.
The past history is interesting and relevant. Although he was described as a somewhat suspicious,
compulsive, and rigid man, he had had no formal
psychiatric or neurologic history until 1980, when he
fell from an office chair, striking his forehead on the
desk and injuring his lower back. Four months later,
he was hospitalized at a local private psychiatric hospital for what was thought to be a manic episode. Increasingly restless and irritable while at home recuperating from his back injury, he was hospitalized
when he began screaming semicoherently in his yard
and threatening his neighbors. He was treated with
chlorpromazine
and gradually calmed. He had had
some bizarre laughing episodes during this hospitalization and an EEG was performed, showing some
occasional simple sharp waves in both temporal areas
with occasional two-to-three per second spikes in the
left mid to anterior temporal region. CT scan of the
head, with contrast, was normal. He was started on
carbamazepine
and phenytoin and responded well.
All anticonvulsants
were gradually stopped. Subsequently,
three EEG’s-all
with nasopharyngeal
leads-were
read as normal, although one showed
“rare theta activity in the left mid-temporal
area.”
Over the 4 years following his psychiatric hospitalization, he had had no further major psychiatric or medical problems, except for the development
of COPD.
It was unclear whether his behavior in the ER was
seizure activity, or possibly an unusual adjustment
reaction or brief psychotic episode in response to some
stressful situation, in a man with a somewhat para62
noid and compulsive premorbid personality. Encouraged by the fact that he seemed to respond to psychotherapeutic
intervention,
with reduction
in his
laughter outbursts, we suggested that the patient go
home and return to the office the next day for followup. The patient agreed with nods.
Early the next morning, his wife brought him back
to the emergency room. At 5 zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZ
A.M., he had walked into
his teenage daughter’s room and, seemingly in anger,
swept all the objects from her dresser with his arm,
and then proceeded to throw her stuffed animals at
the wall. On evaluation this second time, he seemed
more withdrawn, less able to be engaged, and angry.
He often stared at us, seeming to glower, and would
burst into his by now familiar raucous laughter in
bursts lasting lo-30 seconds, every 20-40 minutes. At
times, he would have two to four bursts of laughter in
succession.
There is no psychiatric or neurologic ward or service per se in the authors’ general medical and surgical
adult hospital. The Medicine Department was persuaded to admit the patient despite skepticism about
admitting such an obviously bizarre psychiatric patient. They were assured that Psychiatry would assist
in management.
An EEG with nasopharyngeal
leads
was done and showed a grossly abnormal record with
“a nearly continuous
discharge” of seizure activity
over both anterior temporal regions with occasional
lateralization to the right anterior temporal region.
The patient was presumed to have been in partial
complex status epilepticus since his initial presentation to the emergency room.
The patient was given intravenous phenytoin. In 12
hours, after receiving 900 mg of phenytoin in divided
doses, his status had markedly changed. The laughter
outbursts stopped, but he had become agitated, yelling loudly, with apparent auditory and/or visual hallucinations. He was given 10 mg of IV diazepam, and
within 5 minutes was calm, alert, and answering questions appropriately. Thirty minutes later, however, he
talked incoherently, seemed unaware of his surroundings, and began to manipulate the television switches,
the nurse call button, and tubing in a repetitive nongoal-directed manner. He tried to get out of bed repeatedly and did not respond at all to verbal intervention. He did not respond to further diazepam and soon
began swinging his arms at the nurses. After security
forcibly restrained him in bed, he calmed and eventually slept for about 2 hours. On awakening, he continued with this semi-purposeful,
confused, and occasionally agitated behavior that did not respond to
phenytoin, diazepem, lorazpam or haloperidol.
A second EEG, again with nasopharyngeal
leads
during this phase, showed a much changed pattern of
slow-wave activity anteriorly with some generalized
slowing as well. The ongoing seizure process had
stopped although there was some persistent left temporal sharp wave activity.
Status Epilepticus Presenting as Gelastic Seizures
By the next morning, he was calm, coherent, but
puzzled and suspicious. He knew he was in the hospital but had no idea why, could not remember anything
of the last 3 days, and did not know the day of the
week or the date. He admitted to one of the examiners,
in complete confidence, that he was convinced that
staff in the hospital were plotting against him, as part
tween two behavioral phases: 1) a continuous “ twilight state” with partial and amnesic responsiveness, interrupted by 2) an unresponsive,
speech-arrested state, with temporal lobe discharges on the EEG that are different from discharges during the “ twilight” state. Status can then
be
defined as continuously recurring cycles of these
of a global plot.
two
phases, without recovery between seizures,
By the following day, the suspiciousness had reand
without
residual deficits. In fact, Weiser resolved as well. In fact, he remembered nothing of
ported
the
transition
from discrete seizures, during
being suspicious, and was astounded by the assertion
which the patient remained fully conscious and
that he had indeed felt that there were conspiracies.
Both he and his wife felt that he was back to his usual
oriented, to a continuous epileptic clouded state
self. He had continued on phenytoin and was dis[2]. In 1979, Weiser also was able to elucidate the
charged on 300 mg of phenytoin b.i.d. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
complex relationship between clinical signs and
electrical findings, using surface and deep electrode
tracings to correlate EEG findings with interictal
Discussion
periods, ictal events, and prolonged local status.
Shuka et al. described an interictal confusional psyThis case exemplified the difficulties in diagnosis
chosis in those with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE)
and management of complex partial status epilepthat seemed to be precipitated by status epilepticus,
ticus. The patient’s psychiatric hospitalization for a
and was characterized by confusion, clouding of
“ manic episode” was, in retrospect, actually due to
sensorium, disorientation, and bizarre behavior [S].
partial complex seizure disorder. Upon his presenOnce the proper diagnosis was made, appropritation to the emergency room, we attributed his
ate treatment could be instituted. Still, manageunusual behavioral disturbance to functional
ment over the next 3 days was often difficult, with
causes, hypothesizing that the patient, with a rigid,
potential for physical harm to the patient and/ or
compulsive, and suspicious personality style, had
staff. The EEG seizure activity ceased after the padecompensated under some stress. A Brief, Reactient received phenytoin, and the gelastic episodes
tive Psychosis or Conversion Disorder seemed to be
likewise ended. The patient, however, became conthe most likely diagnostic possibilities. Several asfused, agitated, and combative, necessitating repects of his presentation contributed to the initia1
straints. Although it is known that efforts to reconsideration of a functional, nonorganic diagstrain a patient during the postictal state can
nosis: 1) He walked into the ER voluntarily and
provoke aggression, the patient’s aggressive beseemed to follow simple directions. 2) He was able
havior preceded staff efforts to restrain him. As is
to engage in intermittent conversation and at times
often the case, the restraints seemed to actually
his responses seemed coherent and relevant. 3) His
help him stay calmer and in control. This was follaughter, interspersed with apparently hostile
lowed by a brief period of suspiciousness and wellglowering, reinforced our speculation regarding
organized paranoid delusions. The EEG with
the existence of an affect-laden stressor. As the
nasopharyngeal leads during this period showed
cyclicity of the pattern continued with a “ twilight
only some generalized and focal slowing. These
state” of partial responsiveness alternating with
symptoms did not respond well to a variety of
bizarre behavior with verbal unresponsiveness, the
pharmacologic interventions, and physical rediagnosis of partial complex seizure was suspected
straints remained necessary.
and confirmed by an EEG with nasopharygneal
The occurrence of schizophrenic-like, interictal
leads. A normal EEG does not exclude complex
states in those with temporal lobe epilepsy has been
partial seizures. Activation techniques, such as
described previously [9- zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWV
111.Stoudemire and colsleep deprivation, a sleep EEG, and use of
leagues hypothesize that there may be a reciprocal
nasopharyngeal leads can increase the diagnostic
relationship between dopamine levels in the limbic
sensitivity.
structures and temporal lobe seizure activity and
Treeman and Degado-Escueta [2] have stated
recommend combined treatment with carbamazethat the essential distinguishing feature of complex
pine and haloperidol in these patients [3]. With this
partial status that allows differentiation from funcpatient and others with temporal lobe epilepsy, the
tional psychiatric disorders is the “ cyclicity of
agitated behavior and psychotic symptoms during
clinical behavior” 111, involving a fluctuation be63
J. N. Glassman, D. Dryer, and J. R. McCartney
derstanding and appreciation of the varied pheinterictal and postictal phases often do not respond
nomenology of partial complex seizures should
well to haloperidol or any other pharmacologic
lead to more sophisticated diagnosis and treatment.
treatment. The patient’s symptoms abated seemingly independently of any treatment save the ablation of his seizure activity. He then returned to his
References
baseline personality, which included obsessive and
1. Trimble MR: Disorders of the limbic system. Integr
paranoid features that predated the onset of his
Psychiatry 1:96-106, 1984
seizure disorder.
2. Treeman DM, De&ado-Escueta A: Complex partial
The relationship of temporal lobe epilepsy, and
status epilepticus. In Delgado-Escueta A, et al. (Eds),
epilepsy in general, with personality has been
Advances in Neurology, Status Epilepticus. New
much debated. Bear reports the development of
York. Raven, 1983
3. Stoudemire A, Nelson A, Houpt J: Interictal schizopersonality changes in those with temporal lobe
phrenia-like psychoses in temporal lobe epilepsy.
epilepsy but only after years of ongoing seizure
Psychosomatics 24:331-339, 1983
disorder [9]. Shuka also found a positive rela4. Weiser, HC: Temporal lobe or psychomotor status
tionship between
epilepsy
and personality
epilepticus: A case report. Electroencephalogr Clini
changes, related more to severity of epilepsy than
Neurophysiol48:558-572,
1980
Black D: Pathological laughter. J Neurosis Ment Dis 2,
to locus [8]. Reynolds, in contrast, refutes these
1982.
views. In a retrospective review of 666 patients with
Gasion GC, Lombrosco CT: Epileptic (gelastic laughtemporal lobe epilepsy, he found that only 6% had
ter). Epilepsid 12:63-76, 1971
severe psychosocial disorders [12]. It will be inDaly D, Mulder D: Gelastic Epilep NeurolI:189-192,
teresting to follow this patient’s progress over time.
1957.
Shuka GD, Strivastava ON, Kateyar BC, Joshi V,
He has had a temporal lobe seizure disorder for 4
Mohan PK: Psychiatric manifestations in temporal
years, with an ongoing rigid, perfectionistic, and
lobe epilepsy: A controlled study. Br J Psychiatry
suspicious personality style, but without apprecia135:411-417, 1979
ble changes in personality thus far. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
9. Bear D: Qunatitative analysis of interictal behavior in
Conclusion
As patients present in confused psychotic states,
one must be aware of the possibility of an organic
and epileptic basis for the presentation. One wonders how many “ non-phenothiazine-responding
and “ non-lithium-responding”
schizophrenic”
manic patients might prove to have abnormal EEGs
with nasopharyngeal leads. Unfortunately, unless
something different or bizarre arouses suspicion,
tests are not performed, diagnosis is not made, and
proper treatment is not instituted. Increasing un-
temporal lobe epilepsy. Arch Neurol 34:454-467,
1977
10. Slater E, Beard AW: Schizophrenia-like psychoses of
epilepsy. Br J Psychiatry X%95-105, I963
11. Pavinsky 0, Bear D: Varieties of aggressive behavior
in temporal lobe epilepsy. Am J Psychiatry 141:5,
1984
12. Reynolds EH: Interictal behavior in temporal lobe
epilepsy. Br Med J 286: 918-919, 1983
Direct zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIH
reprinf requesfs to:
James R. McCartney, M.D.
Department of Psychiatry, The Miriam Hospital
164 Summit Avenue
Providence, RI 02906