Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
LEVERAGING CROWDSOURCING PRACTICES IN
SMALL AND MEDIUM ENTERPRISES (SMEs)
Mohd Fitri Mansor, Universiti Sains Malaysia
Hasliza Abdul Halim, Universiti Sains Malaysia
Noor Hazlina Ahmad, Universiti Sains Malaysia
ABSTRACT
The growing Internet of Things (IoTs) and Technology Web 2.0 create a new business
landscape. Furthermore, the recent growth in Information Communication Technology (ICT) has
triggered SMEs to venture into crowdsourcing practices. Thus, the study attempts to explore the
crowdsourcing practices among selected Malaysian SME’s. The study employed qualitative
method by conducting interview session among SMEs business owners in order to validate the
benefits of crowdsourcing that has been practiced by the SMEs in their organizations. The
findings indicates that, leveraging crowdsourcing practices serves several benefits to SMEs such
as cost saving, brand visibility, problem solving, generate novel ideas and so forth. The study
contributes to the understanding of the crowdsourcing practices, add to the body of knowledge
on crowdsourcing and serves as a fundamental for future research. In terms of managerial
perspectives, the results could provide guidelines and promoting SMEs to embark the
crowdsourcing practices to seek for business efficiency and to enhance their business
performance. Lastly, to the policy makers, the study serves as source of valuable information and
inputs to strengthen the action plan and crowdsourcing programs in order to improve current
crowdsourcing practices particularly in the context of Malaysian SMEs.
INTRODUCTION
Nowadays, in order to sustain in a global business environment, many organizations
increasingly exploit collective wisdom and efficient cost control. Due to emerging of the Internet
and Technology Web 2.0 such as social media facilitate the organization to strengthen their
business strategy. Crowdsourcing allows organizations to obtain collective intelligence among
heterogeneous of crowds in diverse background and knowledge at different professional fields
and expertise (Lee et al., 2015).
The term of crowdsourcing is the combination from the words of crowds and outsourcing
represents the process of outsourcing to the crowds (Maiolini and Naggi, 2011). It is refers to the
act of organization or institution taking a function once performed by employees and outsourcing
it to an undefined group of people in the form of open call (Howe, 2006). Meaning that, the
SMEs outsource their tasks to an undefined group of crowds in the form of open call i.e. via
social media. The crowdsourcers could be company, institution or non-profit organization
proposes to an undefined group of crowdworkers such as individuals, formal or informal groups
or others companies the voluntarily undertaking of tasks presented in an open call and receive
rewards in return upon completion of tasks and fulfil the requirements by the organization
(crowdsourcer) (Blohm et al., 2013). Crowdsourcing practice helps the organization to solve the
problems, generate new ideas for innovation and accomplish the tasks effectively and efficiently
manner. Those activities can be performed via Technology Web 2.0 i.e. social media such as
Facebook, Website, Instagram and Twitter (Janom et al., 2014b). Therefore, the aim of this study
1
1528-2651-21-4-217
Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
is to investigate the leveraging of crowdsourcing practices and its benefits among Small and
Medium Enterprises (SMEs). It is because SMEs plays important roles in the development
agenda of most transition economies in developing countries and contributes to the growing
industrial sectors (Mutalemwa, 2015). On top of that, this study also analyzes the scenario of
crowdsourcing practices in Malaysia. Finally, discussion and conclusion of the study will be
adduced.
LITERATURE REVIEWS
Crowdsourcing Practices
Crowdsourcing was first coined by Jeff Howe in Wired Magazine article in June 2006.
The phenomenon of crowdsourcing is define the act of recruiting a large group of undefined
individuals from the community i.e. solvers or crowdworkers in order to complete organizational
tasks via internet based platforms (Howe, 2008). Meanwhile, based on Sykora (2016) has
integrated the definition of crowdsourcing is a type of participative online activity in which
individual, institution, non-profit organization or company proposes to a group of individuals
that is various knowledge, heterogeneity and number via a flexible open call or voluntary
undertaking the tasks. In return of tasks undertaking, complexity and modularity where the
crowds bring their work, money, knowledge or experience that entail mutual benefits. It is
relatively new phenomenon appeared a few years ago due to technological progress (Xu et al.,
2015) and crowdsourcing also considered as an important opportunity for businesses to obtain
external expertise and reduce manpower cost (Kietzmann, 2017). The organization (i.e. seekers
or crowdsourcer) hiring a large group of undefined individuals (i.e. solvers or crowdworkers)
that is refer to crowds, to work on organizational tasks via on line or off line based platforms
(Sivula and Kantola, 2016). It means that, the tasks can be performed whether off line or on line
and the crowdworkers have flexibility of doing works, locations and durations of their own
choices (Arshad et al., 2014). Due to innovation and talent management being major strategic
priorities for many companies the crowdsourcing practices may serves as a method to foster
organizational innovation through tapping external expertise’s knowledge and their creativity.
Even though, the crowdsourcing practice is a simple however it is a powerful concept
where it’s virtually everyone has a potential to contribute valuable information to crowdsourcer.
Surprisingly, the crowdsourcing practices become popular and increased drastically concurrent
with the development of internet technologies and Web 2.0 (Zhao and Zhu, 2014). Malaysia is
among the eight individual markets in Asia that uses social media extensively, with Facebook as
the top social media site (Edosomwan et al., 2011; Parveen, et al., 2016). In addition, the current
trend shows that the use of social media such as Facebook as a platform for business has a must.
The Internet World Statistics indicated that the growth of internet users in Malaysia from 2000 to
2010 stood at 356.8% (Internet Society, 2015). Out of the recorded 19 million internet users in
Malaysia, approximately 16 million are loyal to social media (We are social, 2013).
Approximately, 13.2 million Malaysian residents use the social platform, thereby contributing
towards its being the 18th most popular ranked site in the world (Socialbakers, 2012). In view of
that, it is an opportunity to the SMEs to adapt and leverage the crowdsourcing practices in their
business in order to enhance their business performance.
Nonetheless, the study of crowdsourcing requires further attention and need to be
explored further particularly in the context of SMEs (Mansor et al., 2018). Hossain (2015)
highlighted that many benefits related to the crowdsourcing practices are yet to be explored. It is
2
1528-2651-21-4-217
Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
because the reviews of crowdsourcing studies are crucial to gain comprehensive knowledge on it.
The study on these still in nascent stage and the scholars need to engage actively to enrich this
field. Although many researches on crowdsourcing are already accomplished, optimum
mechanisms of various types of crowdsourcing are still limitedly known. In addition,
crowdsourcing is still an amorphous activity that is not well understood by most businesses but
has proven to help some businesses (Warner, 2011).
Currently, Malaysia under government initiatives program called Digital Malaysia,
crowdsourcing industry has been identified as a potential industry to uplift the income of the
population in the bottom 40% (B40) household income with monthly income less than RM
2300.00 per month (Janom et al., 2014b). Under this program, crowdsourcing is intended to
provide opportunities and help these groups in order to earn additional income by performing
task available in the crowdsourcing industry. It is due to an increase of household expenses every
year as based Department of Statistic Malaysia so that Malaysian government believes by
introducing crowdsourcing, it would provide opportunities for this particular group (B40) to
increase and improve livelihood and their lifestyle. Again, the structure of the crowdsourcing
business process in Malaysia still at infancy stage and remain not been studied constructively
(Salleh et al., 2013). In addition, In view of the above gaps, it is very pertinent to study the
crowdsourcing practices in the context of SMEs in Malaysia.
Crowdsourcing practices in Malaysia
In Malaysia, crowdsourcing is limited understanding on the successful implementation.
Nonetheless, the crowdsourcing concept has seriously given attention in the year 2016 by former
Malaysia Prime Minister. He announced the budget provision for 2016 was RM 100 Million in
order to materialize crowdsourcing projects. This project was monitored and coordinated by
Malaysia Digital Economy Corporation (MDEC) to ensure the crowdsourcing practices
successfully introduced and implemented. By having this, it is expected to drives Malaysia to
embrace a vibrant digital economy and to ensure Malaysia successfully play a leading part in the
global digital revolution (MDEC, 2018).
There are numerous crowdsourcing platforms introduced by the government and nongovernment agencies via Erezeki platform such as Teknologi (M) Sdn. Bhd., Multi Media
Synergy Corporation Sdn. Bhd., Hot Bounty and many more in order to encourage the
individuals (B40) or SMEs to leverage the crowdsourcing practices in order to increase their
income and to increase the business performance via digital economy. These are the local
platforms where an online marketplace for individual to generate the income and for SMEs to
crowdsource their business activities across the web to generate quality leads through network of
others, in return for rewards. While the collaboration with international platform from Australia
such as Freelancer International Pty. Limited, Designhill.com, Upwork Global Inc. and so forth
to help our people and SMEs to connect more than 18 million employers and freelancers globally
from over 247 countries & regions (Erezeki 2017).
Furthermore, the SMEs may notify their business activities and generating new ideas for
the organizational innovation via those platforms. The common crowdsource activities that can
be crowdsourced by the SMEs are packaging, production or manufacturing, web development,
marketing, product repairing, website development, logistics, training, new product
development, product design, advertising and promotion, ideas generation, problem solving and
many more (Qin et al., 2016; Maiolini and Naggi, 2011; Xu et al., 2012; Schulze et al., 2011;
Jayanti, 2012; Saxton et al., 2013; Shaqrah and Noor, 2017; Schenk and Guittard, 2011; Ye and
3
1528-2651-21-4-217
Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
Kankanhalli, 2013). Those activities are more economical and cost saving whenever outsource to
external crowds rather than performing internally. Moreover, SMEs also could enhance the
creativity and organization innovation in order to obtain news ideas for new product
development and product improvement via crowdsourcing. These may foster organizational
innovation through tapping external expertise’s knowledge and their creativity (KPMG, 2016).
Moreover, SMEs may offer their products, services, skills, expertise or even the tasks or
projects from their business to the crowds in the community. The SMEs may hire part time
crowdworkers that possibly among graduates, expertise or a group of individual from
communities to complete the tasks. It is because crowdworkers in the crowdsourcing platform
consists of various amateurs from low skill to specialized skills (Ye and Kankanhalli, 2013). The
SMEs also may advertise or notify their business activities or services via social media or
crowdsourcing platform to the large organization or crowds in order to perform the tasks and
projects. Based on Hanefah et al. (2002) found that the production process of SMEs are usually
labor intensive and such firm usually serve as suppliers for the large manufacturing firms.
Therefore, the crowdsourcing practice is relatively significant to the SMEs business setting
rather than outsourcing to the defined consultants or professional bodies that would be incurred
extra operating costs to them.
Numerous crowdsourcing benefits has been discussed and recognized from these
practices. Among the advantages or benefits are discussed in the literatures are cost saving,
reduce delivery time (Ye and Kankanhalli, 2015), to cater problem on peak demand and
generating new ideas for innovation (Marjanovic et al., 2012), access to a multiplicity of
competences, ideas and resources (Schenk and Guittard, 2009), reduce the risks faced by
organization in the sense that the tasks not crowdsourced to a single provider (Maiolini and
Naggi, 2011) and many more. Crowdsourcing remains interesting either to entrepreneurs, or to
the public sectors. The positive features of crowdsourcing are ability to bring innovative
solutions to difficult problems in a short period of time at minimal costs and an ability to attract
brightest minds to the solution process. Another strong side of crowdsourcing is performing
simple tasks, which cannot be automated, at a very low cost, or even for free in the short-term
(Surowiecki, 2004). Hence, it is necessary and important to embark the study on leveraging
crowdsourcing practices and its benefits in the Malaysian SMEs perspectives.
Meanwhile, there are several factors motivate the organization to leverage
crowdsourcing. As evidenced in open innovation research by Von Hippel (2005), group and
open problem solving approaches encourage the organization to embark on crowdsourcing. It is
due to organization may produce better results than people working alone and cognitive diversity
(Page, 2007). Moreover, cost saving is also one of the motivation factors the organization
leverage the crowdsourcing in their organization. For example Gold Corp is the Gold producer
made its geographical databases available to the public and offered a prize to anyone who could
inform where to find the gold via crowdsourcing. Subsequently, the result of open call enables
the company to increase its production from 53,000 to 504,000 ounces per year and managed to
reduce production cost from $360 to $59 per ounce. In view of that, GoldCorp managed to
increase their income from $100 M to $ 9 B (Tapscott and Williams, 2008).
Nevertheless, there are several major problems on crowdsourcing practices need further
consideration and attention. The problem will occur if the motivation in crowdsourcing tasks is
not attractive may lead to the lower participation attention among potential crowdworkers. The
crowdsourcers need to contribute a lot of time waiting for a certain extent of innovation ideas to
solve the contingent problem (DiPalantino and Vojnovic, 2009). These result the problem on the
4
1528-2651-21-4-217
Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
number of registered teams unequal to the amount of innovative solutions received. Another
drawback of the crowdsourcing as explained by Archak and Sundrarajan (2009), the
crowdworkers may decide to quite their participation despite their registration which affect the
crowdsourcing companies tend to receive fewer quality solutions due to the lower participant’s
motivation in providing companies with innovative solutions (Lee et al., 2015). On top of that,
the solutions suggested by crowdworkers could not align to the companies’ objectives and
expectations. Consequently, the crowdsourcing company would not accept the proposal due to
unsuitability even the quality and ideas are excellent and unpredictable (Howe, 2008). In
nutshell, these major problems will generally avoid the company to adopt crowdsourcing
practices in their organization. However, these problems can be solved by proper planned,
organized and coordinated during crowdsourcing process (Lee et al., 2015).
METHODS
This study applied qualitative methods by conducting interview session. Purposive
random sampling has been used due to purposive (judgment) sampling technique is a nonprobability sampling technique in which the study selects the sample based on the judgment
about several appropriate characteristics required of the sample member (Zikmund et al., 2010).
The inclusion criteria of the study satisfies the following criteria; first, the respondents must
actively practice crowdsourcing and registered as small and medium Malaysian SMEs in order to
ensure the accuracy of the data. Second, the organization should fulfil the criteria of Malaysian
SME based on number of permanent employees and total annual sales turnover. The expert’s
opinion obtained from SMEs Owners/Chief Executive Officers (CEO) to validate the
crowdsourcing practices and its benefits. Initially, three SMEs Owners/CEOs were selected in
order to obtain preliminary ideas on how crowdsourcing being practiced and it benefits in the
SMEs. Finally, content analysis approach was used to analyze the findings from each expert
opinion.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Based on the above reviews, many crowdsourcing benefits can be obtained by the
companies. It is also not limit to the context of SME however there are numerous evidences and
studies have been conducted such as investigating organizational task crowdsourcing (Ye and
Kankanhalli, 2015); the effect of crowd voting on hotels; crowdsourcing business models
(Kohler, 2015), crowdsourcing business model for B40 income earners (Zakariah et al., 2016)
and so forth. On top of that, looking at the issues and problems faced by the SMEs somewhat
lacking compared to others developed countries (Hooi and Ngui, 2014), unable to achieving high
performance due to challenges faced in innovation and technology adoption, human capital
development, access to financing, market access, legal and regulatory environment and
infrastructure (World Bank Productivity and Investment). Furthermore, it is shows that the SMEs
went bankrupt within 5 years of commencement of their business and the failure rate of the
business is an estimated 60% (Ahmad and Seet, 2009) and they are vulnerable to local and global
competition (Magasi, 2016). In view of the above, this study propose the crowdsourcing
practices because this practice would be seen as one of the good business strategy to close the
above gaps mainly in the context of SMEs in Malaysia in order to enhance their business
performance.
5
1528-2651-21-4-217
Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
To materialize the current study and to validate the crowdsourcing benefits, a preliminary
study among three SMEs business owners were conducted. The findings and discussion are as
follows.
SME A: (Foods & Beverages, Crackers)
SMEs are a small enterprise and categorized as foods and beverages sector. A 38 years
old female CEO, hold the degree in International Business, employed 15 permanent employees
and hiring 5 to 10 crowdworkers depending on projects and tasks. The crowdsourcing activities
are packaging, production, filling, auditing, marketing, record keeping, IT (Blog development).
The CEO pointed out, crowdsourcing practices portray and introduce their brand image
to the outsiders via an assistant from the crowdworkers. It is because of marketing activities via
Facebook help their company to obtain an opportunity to market the products at the stores such
as Giant and Tesco by using Agromas brand. Other than that, CEO explained that leveraging
crowdsourcing practice in the company, the products brands can be introduced and visible to the
crowds/customers at lower cost, fast product delivery, enhance business rapport with external
crowds as well as increase their business performance. Furthermore, the CEO also highlighted
that the unique of crowdsourcing business model the company may reduce their operating cost. It
is clearly explained by the CEO.
“Crowdsourcing has reduced our operating costs. Interestingly, in some circumstances the tasks are
perform at their own premises or at home whereby the company unnecessary to invest in fixed costs such as to
provide building or workstation to them. We can’t afford to invest to all these since we’re lack of capital.”
(Translation).
In addition CEO agreed that, the crowdsourcing practices assist the company to minimize
the issue of marketing cost whereby the company would advertise and promote their products at
lower cost eventually increase their brand awareness of the products. In some circumstances, the
communities in persons (such as senior aunty) are better than permanent employees where they
are more experience and knowledgeable in the traditional foods and beverages. The company
used their specialized skill and knowledge to improve current product such as to improve product
taste and product quality. For example “bahulu and rempeyek” types of traditional Malaysian
crackers will be crispier and improve the taste by adding “X” ingredient during the process of
mixing of raw materials. This suggestion and new ideas given by crowdworkers that enables to
improve product taste, packaging, product shape, product color and etc. It is according to the
statement by the CEO.
“The external parties (crowdworkers) are very experienced and possessed very good skills and
knowledgeable in traditional foods and beverages. They are willing to share new ideas or input to improve our
product durability, taste and product appearance. I noticed that, our products quality are better and increase our
sales.” (Translation).
The CEO mentioned that, crowdworkers given several ideas to improve packaging
design, work process from manual to semi auto or fully auto in order to speed up production
process. Hiring crowdworkers from the communities, the company is able to solve problem on
product durability. For example the problems of our two products that are easily defect. This
problem can be resolved by crowdworker through formulating new ingredients consequently
improve the product durability. Moreover, the crowdworkers from universities students perform
the tasks during the semester break would improve the routine tasks such as systematic filling,
6
1528-2651-21-4-217
Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
billing, account and record keeping. For example, these crowdworkers help us to settle the
problem on administrative activities such as filling, record keeping, accounts checking and
auditing and to obtain certification purposes. Overall, CEO agreed that leveraging the
crowdsourcing practices able to resolve several problems on product durability and
administration activities from various inputs and ideas drives to increase their business
performance.
SME B: (Cookies and Biscuits)
SME B is a medium enterprise producing cookies and biscuits. A 58 years old female
CEO, hold the degree in Education, employed 75 permanent employees and hiring more than
100 crowdworkers depending on the demand of the products. The crowdworkers are the
individual from the communities, students from higher institutions, secondary school and
teachers. The crowdsourcing activities are packaging, production, transportation and marketing.
Leveraging crowdsourcing practices as explained by CEO, crowdsourcing promotes
product brands and create product awareness. Our product brands can be introduced to the
outsiders and increase product visibility among the customers. She also added that, hiring
crowdworkers help the company introduce the products to the external parties at various regions.
Crowdworkers hired from the community would recommend; introduce the products to their
relatives; friends and become an agents to the company. Interestingly, the power of crowds
“word of mouth” and social media significantly promote their product in the community and
minimize the issues of promotion activities such as extra efforts and budget. CEO agreed that via
crowdsourcing the products brands can be visible and introduce to the crowds/customers at lower
cost, within a short period of time, increase business networking and increase market outreach as
well as improve business performance. It can be demonstrated from the CEO statement.
“By engaging crowdsourcing, the crowdworkers help us to introduce our products to their relatives and
friends…then an advertisement via Facebook has increased our cookies and biscuits brand’s (brand visibility).
These reduced our marketing costs eventually increase our products demand…via crowdsourcing help us to solve
the issues of peak demand because we used external parties (crowdworkers) to help us to increase our production.
We cannot say “NO” to our customers when they need our products” (Translation).
CEO posited that, the crowdworker from the higher institution i.e. student’s contributes
to improve their existing packaging design. The crowdworkers outside the company also
contributes to the product improvement in term of product taste, product colour and design.
Those are the persons so call “expert” due to their experience and knowledge to a particular
product. Meanwhile, the crowdworker provides a good suggestion and solution to improve
production layout to be fully utilized and consequently save production space. Due to their
knowledge, skills and creativity the production space can be planned and arranged
systematically. In some circumstances, via crowdsourcing the crowdworkers would assist the
company to source the suppliers whenever the crowdsourcer supplier’s unable to deliver the raw
material. In short, CEO strongly recommended that SMEs should leveraging crowdsourcing in
order to access specialized skills and to improve daily operation activities. It is because the
company facing several constraints such as lack of skilled manpower, lack of financial and
inability to hire consultant or professional staffs due to expensive service charge.
7
1528-2651-21-4-217
Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
SME C: (Cosmetics and Household Items)
SME C is a medium enterprise producing cosmetics and household items for their own
customers and Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM). A 46 years old female owner-manager,
hold the degree in Accounting, employed 65 permanent employees and hiring 10 to 15
crowdworkers depends on the demand of the products. The crowdworkers among the individuals
from the communities. Among the crowdsourcing activities are packaging, production,
transportation, inventory, training and marketing.
The owner-manager explained that hiring crowdworker from the community helps the
company to promote their product brands at surroundings areas via the “words of mouth”.
Instead of using traditional “word of mouth”, the company also utilized the social media in order
to ensure their product visible to the crowds. The owner-manager mentioned that, the promotion
cost can be reduced by leveraging crowdsourcing practices. The owner-manager pointed that
their OEM customer’s has increase due increase because of increase brand awareness among
customers.
The owner-manager strongly agreed that crowdsourcing practice helps the company to
introduce the product brands and penetrate the market with minimum costs. It would reduce their
operating cost and create a better business performance. The owner-manager also emphasized
that, particularly during peak demand due to an increase in products order from OEM customers,
crowdsourcing practices is the best strategy to cater these problem. It is because, the company
cannot afford to hire many staffs due to budget constraints. Thus, crowdsourcing resolve the
problem of manpower shortage. In short, crowdsourcing provide many benefits to the company
and would minimize the problem on lack of skills and manpower.
Interestingly, the owner-manager also highlighted that via crowdsourcing practice the
company may resolve the issue on product fake via packaging techniques. These inputs and ideas
put forwarded by crowdworker’s from the university graduates. It is clearly stated from the
statement by the owner-manager.
“We have a problem on problem fake, there are many competitors started to imitate our products…thus we
generate ideas from universities graduates to help us to solve this problem. Finally, we’re able to solve this problem
via confidential code from packaging. All these are ideas obtained via crowdsourcing. (Translation).
On top of that, leveraging crowdsourcing practices the company may enhance idea
generation and innovation to the company via product improvement such as new material
formulation, feedback and suggestions received from the crowds. The issues of quality and waste
can be reduced since the crowdworkers will be paid based on the quantity and quality output.
Overall, the owner-manager agreed that crowdsourcing practices definitely serve various
advantageous such as resolve several business problems such as product fake, manpower
shortage, productivity and so forth. By having this, the company may enhance the business
performance. On top of that, the owner-manager also emphasized that using crowdworkers the
company may also reduce the labor cost and minimize the operating cost. It is clearly
emphasized by the owner-manager.
“Outsourced the tasks to the external parties may reduce our labor and operating cost. Tasks performed by
crowds (crowdworkers) are cheaper than perform internally because we only pay to the crowds based on the job
being done and the company not necessary to bear any extra compensation and benefit costs to the crowdworkers.”
(Translation).
8
1528-2651-21-4-217
Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
Summarily, based on the above findings it is proven that, all SMEs business owners
strongly agreed that by leveraging crowdsourcing practices serves numerous benefits such as
reduce operational cost, access to specialized talent, obtain new knowledge and experts from
large pool of crowds, reduce time product delivery, ideas generation and obtain feedback for
problem solution. Other than that, crowdsourcing practices may promote brand visibility in the
sense that increase the product and service awareness by using Technology Web 2.0 such as
social media. In view of the above, the advantages and benefits from the crowdsourcing practices
eventually boost their business performance.
LIMITATION AND FUTURE RESEARCH
In respect to the current study, the study only employed a qualitative approach to access
the crowdsourcing practices and its benefits. It is acknowledge that, the limited number of
respondents and this qualitative approach may limit the findings and generalization.
Consequently, a sophisticated and extended research model is needed to be developed and
empirically test by using quantitative approach. The study also recommends future studies to
include larger sample of SMEs operate in intense competition and dynamic environment. Last
but not least, future study also may integrate the legal and employment issues and extent to the
longitudinal study.
CONCLUSION
It is concluded that, crowdsourcing practice is a one of effective business model by
recruiting a large group of undefined individuals from the community i.e. solvers in order to
complete organizational tasks. Numerous advantages and benefits can be leveraged via
crowdsourcing practices particularly in the context of Malaysian SMEs. Amongst the benefits
i.e. cost saving, reduce time product delivery, overcome peak demand, organizational innovation,
brand visibility, access to specialize skills, solution diversity and many more. Based on the
qualitative data it is proven that, all SMEs business owners strongly agreed that crowdsourcing
contributes positive implication to their business. The study also contributes to both theoretical
and practical contributions such as to enrich the current literatures on crowdsourcing and
foundation for future research particularly in the context SMEs in Malaysia. Meanwhile, the
practical contributions to the policy makers could assist them formulating and enhancing the
effectiveness of current crowdsourcing programs. To an entrepreneurs the study enhance their
knowledge and understanding towards crowdsourcing practices and its benefits that positively
contributes to their business eventually promoting other SMEs to embark the crowdsourcing
business model in their companies.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We would like to thank Universiti Sains Malaysia for funding this project under the
Incentive GOT grant code no: 1001/PMGT/822110.
9
1528-2651-21-4-217
Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
REFERENCES
Ahmad, N.H., & Seet, P. (2009). Dissecting behaviors associated with business failure: A qualitative study of SME
owners in Malaysia and Australia. Journal of Asian Social Science, 5(9), 98-104.
Archak, N., & Sundararajan, A. (2009). Optimal design of crowdsourcing contests. ICIS 2009 Proceedings Paper,
200.
Arshad, N.H., Salleh, S.S., Janom, N., Syed Aris, S.R., & Mastuki, N. (2014). Issues and challenges in
crowdsourcing platform implementation in Malaysia. Applied Computational Science, 95-100.
Blohm, I., Leimeister, J.M., & Krcmar, H. (2013). Crowdsourcing: How to benefit from (too) many great ideas. MIS
Quarterly Executive, 4(12), 199-211.
DiPalantino, D., & Vojnovic, M (2009). Crowdsourcing and all-pay auctions. Proceedings of the 10th ACM
conference on electronic commerce, ACM, 119-128.
Edosomwan, S., Prakasan, S.K., Kouame, D., Watson, J., & Seymour, T (2011). The history of social media and its
impact on business. The Journal of Applied Management and Entrepreneurship, 16(3), 79-91.
Hanefah, M., Ariff, M., & Kasipillai, J. (2002). Compliance cost of small and medium enterprises. Journal of
Australian Taxation, 4(1), 73-79
Hooi, L.W., & Ngui, K.S. (2014). Enhancing organizational performance of Malaysian SMEs: The role of HRM and
organizational learning capability. International Journal of Manpower, 35(7), 973-995.
Hossain, M. (2015). A review of literature on open innovation in small and medium-sized enterprises. Journal of
Global Entrepreneurship Research, 5(6), 1-12.
Howe, J (2006). The rise of crowdsourcing. Wired Magazine, 14(6), 1-4.
Howe, J (2008). Crowdsourcing: Why the power of the crowd is driving the future of business. Crown Bus.
Retrieved from https://erezeki.my/ms/home-my/
Internet Society (2015) Internet society global internet report 2015: Mobile evolution and development of the
internet
Janom, N., Syazrah, W.N., Arshad, N.H., Salleh, S.S., Syed Aris, S.R., & Mastuki, N. (2014b). Investigating the
B40 crowd worker technology and knowledge readiness in Malaysia. Proceeding of Knowledge
Management International Conference (KMICe), 894-901.
Jayanti, E. (2012). Open sourced organizational learning: implications and challenges of crowdsourcing for human
resource development (HRD) practitioners. Human Resource Development International, 15(3), 375-384.
Kietzmann, J.H (2017). Crowdsourcing: A revised definition and introduction to new research, Business Horizon,
60(2).
Kohler, T (2015). Crowdsourcing-based business models: How to create and capture value. California Management
Review, 57(4), 63-84.
KPMG (2016). Global CEO Outlook.
Lee, C.K.M., Chan., C.Y., Ho. S., Choy, K.L., & Ip, W.H. (2015). Explore the feasibility of adopting crowdsourcing
for innovative problem solving. Industrial Management & Data Systems, 115(5), 803-832.
Magasi, C. (2016). Factors influencing business succession planning among SMEs in Tanzania. European Journal
of Business and Management, 8(3), 126-135.
Maiolini, R., & Naggi, R. (2011). Crowdsourcing and SMEs: opportunities and challenges. In: D'Atri A., Ferrara
M., George J., Spagnoletti P. (eds). Information Technology and Innovation Trends in Organizations,
Physica-Verlag HD, 399-406.
Mansor, M.F., Abdul Halim, H., & Ahmad, N.H. (2018). Exploring crowdsourcing practices and benefits:
Validation from small and medium enterprises (SMEs) business owners. Proceedings of the 2nd Conference
on Technology & Operations Management (2nd CTOM).
Marjanovic, S., Fry, C., & Chataway, J. (2012). Crowdsourcing based business models: In search of evidence for
innovation 2.0. Science and Public Policy, 39(3), 318-332.
MDEC (2018). Malaysia Digital Economy Corporation (MDEC).
Mutalemwa, D.K. (2015). Does globalization impact SME development in Africa? Journal of Economic and
Management Studies, 6(2), 64-182.
Page, S.E (2007).The difference: How the power of diversity creates better groups, firms, schools, and societies.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Parveen, F, Jaafar N.I., & Ainin, S. (2016). Social media’s impact on organizational performance and
entrepreneurial orientation in organizations. Management Decision, 54(9), 2208-2234.
10
1528-2651-21-4-217
Journal of Entrepreneurship Education
Volume 21, Issue 4, 2018
Qin, S., Van der Velde, D., Chatzakis, E., McStea, T., & Smith. N. (2016). Exploring barriers and opportunities in
adopting crowdsourcing based new product development in manufacturing SMEs' Chinese. Journal of
Mechanical Engineering, 22(3), 1-15.
Salleh, S.S., Arshad, N.H., Mastuki, N., Syed Aris, S.R., & Janom, N. (2013). Formulating cohesive digital
ecosystem of micro sourcing business process in Malaysia. Science and Information Conference 2013, 321327.
Saxton, G.D., Oh, O., & Kishore, R. (2013). Rules of crowdsourcing: Models, issues, and systems of control.
Information Systems Management, 30(1), 2-20.
Schenk, E., & Guittard, C. (2009). Crowdsourcing: What can be Outsourced to the crowd, and why? Working
Papers Series, HAL-CCSD.
Schenk, E., & Guittard, C. (2011). Towards a characterization of crowdsourcing practices. Journal of Innovation
Economics, 7(1), 93-107.
Schulze, T., Seedorf, S., Geiger, D., & Kaufman, N (2011). Exploring task properties in crowdsourcing-an
empirical study on mechanical turk. Proceedings of 19th European Conference on Information Systems,
Helsinki, Finland.
Shaqrah, A.A., & Noor, T.H. (2017). Towards a conceptual clarity model for integrating customer crowdsourcing
and social CRM. The International Journal of Management Science and Information Technology, (24), 116.
Sivula, A., & Kantola, J. (2016). Integrating crowdsourcing with holistic innovation management. International
Journal of Advanced Logistics, 5(3-4), 1-12.
Socialbakers (2012). Facebook statistics 2012.
Surowiecki, J (2004). The wisdom of crowds: Why the many are smarter than the few. London: Abacus.
Sykora, M (2016). Engineering social media driven intelligent systems through crowdsourcing: Insights from a
financial news summarization system. Journal of Systems and Information Technology, 18(3), 255-276.
Tapscott, D., & Williams, A.D (2008). GoldCorp’s crowdsourcing approach, Wikinomics: How mass collaboration
changes everything. Portfolio.
Von Hippel, E. (2005). Democratizing innovation. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Warner, J. (2011). Business Applications of crowdsourcing. Proceedings of the Northeast Business & Economics
Association.
We are social (2013). Social, digital and mobile in Asia, 2012.
Xu, C., Qin, S., & Xiao, Z. (2012). Crowdsourcing based product innovation design service model for small-and
medium-sized enterprises. Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Automation & Computing.
Xu, Y., Ribeiro-Soriano, D.E., & Gonzalez-Garcia, J. (2015). Crowdsourcing, innovation and firm performance.
Management Decision, 53(6), 1158-1169.
Ye, H., & Kankanhalli, A. (2013). Leveraging crowdsourcing for organizational value co-creation. Communications
of the Association for Information Systems, 33(13), 225-244.
Ye, H.J., & Kankanhalli, A. (2015). Investigating the antecedents of organizational task crowdsourcing. Information
& Management, 52(1), 98-110.
Zakariah, Z., Janom, N., & Arshad, D.D.N.H. (2016). Crowdsourcing business model for low income community:
conceptual model. SAI Computing Conference 2016.
Zhao, Y.C., & Zhu, Q. (2014). Effects of extrinsic and intrinsic motivation on participation in crowdsourcing
contest: A perspective of self-determination theory. Online Information Review, 38(7), 896-917.
Zikmund, W.G. (2010). Business Research Methods, 6th Editio. Orlando, F1: The Dryden Press.
11
1528-2651-21-4-217