International Confernece Protection and Restoration of the Environment XIV
Proceedings (MEMORY STICK)
ISBN: 978-960-99922-4-4
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
PREFACE
“Protection and Restoration of the Environment” is a well-known series of international conferences,
organized jointly by one American and one Greek University every two years, in Greece. It started in
1992, in Thessaloniki. In 2018, the fourteenth Conference of the series has taken place in Thessaloniki
for one more time. It was jointly organized by: a) the Stevens Center for Environmental Engineering
of the Stevens Institute of Technology, USA and b) the Division of Hydraulics and Environmental
Engineering, and the Environment Council of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece.
Thessaloniki is an inspiring place for an environmental conference: It is a large city, facing many
environmental problems, but, at the same time, it is situated in the middle of an area of undisputable
beauty (including Chalkidiki and Mount Olympus), which exhibits the environmental quality that we
have to preserve for future generations.
Moreover, Thessaloniki is located in a rather small distance from Stagira, the birthplace of Aristotle
and from Mount Athos. Aristotle contributed decisively to the formation of scientific thought, while
Mount Athos represents the spirit and the moral discipline, which are indispensable for protection
and restoration of the environment.
The conference was timely, as well. It served as a reminder that protection of the environment is not
a luxury that could be temporarily disregarded under the pressure of financial crisis, but a basic
prerequisite for viable future.
Participation has been very encouraging. Almost 150 papers have been selected for oral or poster
presentation, covering a wide range of topics, which reflect the interdisciplinary nature of
environmental challenges. They have been classified in the following sessions:
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
Cultural and social issues
Environmental education
Environmental hydrology
Environmental law and economics
Ground water resources management
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
River and open channel hydraulics
Soft and renewable energy sources
Solid waste management
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
I
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Water resources management and contamination control
The conference hosted also a special session on Supporting Sustainable Development Goals
Implementation using research, organized by the Sustainable Development Solutions Network
(SDSN).
The editors would like to thank:
The authors of the papers, for contributing and sharing their own expertise.
The members of the organizing and the scientific committee, for their eager help.
The reviewers, for ensuring high scientific standards for the presentations.
The sponsors of the conference for their financial support.
All conference participants, for their active involvement in the exchange of knowledge, which
is the essence of a conference.
The editors
II
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
CONFERENCE COMMITTEES
CONFERENCE CHAIRMEN
Christodoulatos C., Stevens Institute of Technology, USA
Karpouzos D., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Koutsospyros M, University of New Haven, USA
Mallios Z., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Theodossiou N., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
ORGANIZING COMMITTEE
Christodoulatos C., Stevens Institute of Technology, USA
Fotopoulou E., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Hatzigiannakis E., Hellenic Agricultural Organization, Greece
Karpouzos D., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Katsifarakis K.L. Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece.
Koutsospyros M., University of New Haven, USA
Mallios Z., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Manakou V., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Papageorgiou A., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Petala M., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Raptou E., Dept. of Agricultural Development, Democritus University of Thrace, Greece
Theodossiou N., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Tsiridis V., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Vasileiou E., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Zafirakou A., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE
Anagnostopoulos P., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Antonopoulos V., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Arampatzis G., Hellenic Agricultural Organization, Greece
Baltas E., School of Civil Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece.
Benavente J., Faculta de Sciencias, Universidad de Granada, Spain
Bikas D. Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Boccia L., University of Naples Federico II, Italy
Braida W., Center for Environmental Systems, Stevens Institute of Technology, USA
III
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Chintiroglou Ch., Department of Biology, A.U.Th., Greece
Darakas E., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Dermatas D., School of Civil Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Dermisi S., University of Washington, USA.
Diamadopoulos E., Dept. of Environmental Engineering, Technical University of Crete
Doveri M., Institute of Geosciences and Earth Resources, National Research Council, Italy
Droege P., Liechtenstein Institute for Strategic Development, Liechtenstein
Efthimiou G., TEI of Sterea Ellada, Greece
Fatta-Kasinos D., Nireas International Water Research Center, University of Cyprus, Cyprus
Georgiou P., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Goyal Manish, Indian Institute of Technology, Guwahati, India.
Kalavrouziotis I., Hellenic Open University, Greece
Kanakoudis V., Dept. of Civil Engineering, University of Thessaly, Greece
Karambas Th., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Karatzas G., Dept. of Environmental Engineering, Technical University of Crete
Karatzas K., Dept. of Mechanical Eng., A.U.Th., Greece
Katopodes N., Dept. of Civil and Environ. Engineering, University of Michigan, USA
Kehagia F., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Kolokytha E., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Korfiatis G., Stevens Institute of Technology, USA
Kougias I., European Commission, DG JRC, Directorate for Energy, Transport and Climate, Italy
Koundouri Ph., Athens University of Economics and Business, Greece
Koutsoyiannis D., School of Civil Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Koveos D., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Krestenitis I., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Kungolos A.G., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Larabi A., Universite Mohammed V de Rabat, Morocco
Latinopoulos D., Dept. of Spatial Planning and Development, A.U.Th., Greece
Latinopoulos P., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Laudonia S., University of Naples Federico II, Italy
Liakopoulos A., Dept. of Civil Engineering, University of Thessaly, Greece
Lo Porto A., Institute of Water Research, National Research Council, Italy
Loukas A., Dept. of Civil Engineering, University of Thessaly, Greece
IV
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Loukogeorgaki E., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Lyberatos G., School of Chemical Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Mamassis N., School of Civil Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
de Marsily G., Université Paris VI- École des Mines-Académie des Sciences, France
Masciopinto C., Water Research Institute, CNR-IRSA, Italy
Melas D, Dept. of Physics, A.U.Th., Greece
Meng X., Center for Environmental Systems, Stevens Institute of Technology, USA
Miracapillo C., Dr, Switzerland
Moussiopoulos N., Dept. of Mechanical Eng., A.U.Th., Greece
Moustaka M., Dept. of Biology, A.U.Th., Greece
Moutsopoulos K.N., Dept. of Environmental Engineering, Democritus University of Thrace, Greece
Mylopoulos I., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Nikolaou K., Organization for the Master Plan and Envir. Protection of Thessaloniki, Greece
Panagopoulos A., Hellenic Agricultural Organization, Greece
Papamichail D., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Papanikolaou P., School of Civil Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Prinos P., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Psilovikos A., School of Agricultural Sciences, University of Thessaly, Greece
Rangel B., Dept. of Civil Engineering, University of Porto, Portugal
Rao M.C., Dept. of Civil Engineering, National Institute of Technology Jamshedpur, India.
Ripa N., University of Vitterbo, Italy
Robesku D., Faculty of Engineering, University Polytechnica of Bucharest, Romania
Sapountzis M., School of Forestry, A.U.Th., Greece
Scarlatos P.D., Chair & Professor Dept. of Civil, Environmental and Geomatics Engineering, Florida
Atlantic University, USA
Sidiropoulos E., Dept. of Rural and Surveying Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Skanavis C., Dept. of Environmental Studies, University of the Aegean
Tsakiris G., School of Rural and Surveying Eng, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Tsalikidis I., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Tsihrintzis V.A., School of Rural, Surveying Eng, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Tsikaloudaki K., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Tsilingiridis G., Dept. of Mechanical Eng., A.U.Th., Greece
Tsitsoni, Th. Dept. of Forestry and Natural Environment, A.U.Th., Greece
Vafeiadis M., Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
V
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Vagiona D., Dept. of Spatial Planning and Development, A.U.Th., Greece
Valyrakis M., Water Engineering Lab, University of Glasgow, UK
Villani P., Department of Civil Engineering, University of Salerno, Italy
Vokou D., Dept. of Biology, A.U.Th., Greece
Van der Kwast J., Water Science and Engineering Department, IHE Delft Institute for Water
Education Delft, The Netherlands
Voutsa D., Dept. of Chemistry, A.U.Th., Greece
Voudouris K.S, Dept. of Geology, A.U.Th., Greece
Yannopoulos P. C., University of Patras, Greece
Zagas Th., Dept. of Forestry and Natural Environment, A.U.Th., Greece
REVIEWERS
Anagnostopoulos P, Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Anagnostopoulou Ch., Department of Geology, A.U.Th., Greece
Antonopoulou E., School of Biology, A.U.Th., Greece
Aravantinos D., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Bagiouk S., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Baltas E., School of Civil Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Braida W., Center for Environmental Systems, Stevens Institute of Technology, USA
Christodoulatos C., Stevens Institute of Technology, USA
Darakas E., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Dimas A., Dept. of Civil Engineering, University of Patras, Greece
Fatta-Kasinos D., Nireas International Water Research Center, University of Cyprus, Cyprus
Katsifarakis K.L. Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Fragos V., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Gemizi A., Dept. of Environmental Engineering, Democritus University of Thrace, Greece
Georgiou P., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Goyal Manish, Indian Institute of Technology, Indore, India.
Hatzigiannakis E., Hellenic Agricultural Organization, Greece
Kanakoudis V., Department of Civil Engineering, University of Thessaly, Greece
Karambas Th., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Karatzas G., School of Environmental Engineering, Technical University of Crete, Greece
Karatzas K., Department of Mechanical Eng., A.U.Th., Greece
VI
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Karpouzos D., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Konstaninou Z., Department of Spatial Planning and Development, A.U.Th, Greece
Korfiatis G., Stevens Institute of Technology, USA
Kosmopoulos P., K-eco Projects
Kougias I., European Commission, DG JRC, Directorate for Energy, Transport and Climate, Italy
Kouloussis N., School of Agriculture, A.U.Th., Greece
Koutsospyros M, University of New Haven, USA
Kungolos A.G., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Latinopoulos D., Department of Spatial Planning and Development, A.U.Th., Greece.
Latinopoulos P., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Loukas A., Department of Civil Engineering, University of Thessaly, Greece
Loukogeorgaki E., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Lyberatos G., School of Chemical Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Makris Ch. Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Malea P., School of Biology, A.U.Th., Greece
Mallios Z., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Mamassis N., School of Civil Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Mavridou S., Thessaloniki Water Supply and Sewerage Company, S.A.
Moussiopoulos N., Department of Mechanical Eng., A.U.Th., Greece
Moustaka M., School of Biology, A.U.Th., Greece
Nikolaidou E., Hydromanagement LTD Greece
Papadopoulos A.I., School of Biology, A.U.Th., Greece
Papakostas K., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Papastergiadou E., Department of Biology, University of Patras, Greece
Papatheodorou E.M., School of Biology, A.U.Th., Greece
Patsialis Th., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Petala M., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Pisinaras V., Hellenic Agricultural Organisation, Greece
Prinos P., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Ramos E., aUnuversity of Valencia
Raptou E., Department of Agricultural Development, Democritus University of Thrace, Greece
Ripa M. N., Dept. of Agricultural and Forestry Sciences (D.A.F.N.E.), Tuscia University, Italy
Samaras A.G., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
VII
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Sapountzis M., Department of Forestry and Natural Environment, A.U.Th., Greece
Siarkos I., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Sofiadis I., School of Geology, A.U.Th., Greece
Stefanidou M., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Theodossiou N., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Thoidou E., Department of Spatial Planning and Development, A.U.Th., Greece
Tsan-Liang Su, Stevens Institute of Technology, USA
Tsikaloudaki K., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Tsilingiridis G., Department of Mechanical Eng., A.U.Th., Greece
Tsiridis V., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Vafeiadis M., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
Vagiona D., Department of Spatial Planning and Development, A.U.Th., Greece
Valyrakis M., Water Engineering Lab, University of Glasgow, UK
Zafeiriou E., Dept. of Agricultural Development, Democritus University of Thrace, Greece
Zafirakou A., Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th., Greece
VIII
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table of Contents
Water resources management and contamination control .................... 1
CLIMATE CHANGE EFFECTS ON THE AVAILABILITY OF WATER RESOURCES OF LAKE
KARLA WATERSHED FOR IRRIGATION AND VOLOS CITY URBAN WATER USE
A. Alamanos N. Mylopoulos, L. Vasiliades and A. Loukas ............................................................ 3
DEVELOPING AN INTEGRATED SURFACE WATER-GROUNDWATER
SYSTEM FOR UPPER ANTHEMOUNTAS BASIN, GREECE
MODELING
I. Siarkos, S. Sevastas, D. Botsis and N. Theodossiou .................................................................. 13
COMPARISON OF STOCHASTIC AND MACHINE LEARNING MODELS IN STREAMFLOW
FORECASTING
D. Botsis, P. Latinopoulos and K. Diamantaras............................................................................. 23
APPLICATION OF MODIFIED METAHEURISTIC METHODS TO IDENTIFY CRITICAL
AREAS IN WATER SUPPLY NETWORKS
D. Karakatsanis, N. Theodossiou ................................................................................................... 34
HORIZONTAL CONVECTION INDUCED BY ABSORPTION OF SOLAR RADIATION
V.C. Papaioannou and P.E. Prinos ................................................................................................. 44
SUPPORTING INTEGRATED WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT ON
ESTABLISHMENT OF THE MAXIMUM WATER LEVEL IN LAKE VEGORITIDA
THE
Ch. Doulgeris and A. Argyroudi .................................................................................................... 54
RAINWATER HARVESTING AS AN ALTERNATIVE SOURCE TO CONFRONT WATER
SCARCITY WORLDWIDE – CURRENT SITUATION AND PERSPECTIVES
S. Yannopoulos, I. Giannopoulou and M. Kaiafa-Saropoulou ...................................................... 64
MULTIOBJECTIVE OPTIMIZATION RAIN GARDENS USING HARMONY SEARCH
ALGORITHM
D. Karakatsanis and A. Basdeki .................................................................................................... 76
ESTIMATION OF WATER FOOTPRINT FOR A HOTEL UNIT
IX
Table of Contents
A.E. Chatzi and Ν.Ρ. Theodossiou................................................................................................. 83
SEDIMENT TRANSPORT CASE STUDY: NESTOS RIVER
S. M. Bagiouk,K. C. Anagnopoulos,S. S. Bagiouk, A. E. Agiou, A. S. Bagiouk ......................... 95
ASSESSMENT OF IRRIGATION WATER QUALITY IN ANTHEMOUNTAS BASIN, CENTRAL
MACEDONIA, GREECE
Hatzigiannakis, E., Tziritis, E., Ιlias, A., Arampatzis, G., Doulgeris, C., Pisinaras, V.
Panagopoulos, A. ......................................................................................................................... 104
GIS-BASED MULTI-CRITERIA DESIGN OF A HYDROMETRIC SYSTEM IN THE ATTICA
REGION
E. Theochari, E. Feloni, A. Bournas, D. Karpouzos, E. Baltas ................................................... 111
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built
environment ............................................................................................ 121
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF MODERN AND TRADITIONAL MASONRY MORTARS FOR
SUSTAINABLE CONSTRUCTION
A. Liapis, A. Karozou, A. Batsios, M. Stefanidou ....................................................................... 123
HAZARD ASSESSMENT AND VULNERABILITY REDUCTION IN THE MEDITERRANEAN
LANDSCAPE: THE CASE OF CRAPOLLA ARCHEOLOGICAL SITE IN THE SORRENTOAMALFI PENINSULA, ITALY
L. Boccia, A. Capolupo, M. Rigillo, V. Russo ............................................................................ 131
TERRACED LANDSCAPES LOCATED IN AREAS OF GREAT VALUE FOR TOURISTIC
PURPOSES AS AN IRREVERSIBLE PRACTICE
A. Capolupo and L. Boccia .......................................................................................................... 141
PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION OF THERMAL EFFECT IN STREET CANYONS
M.K. Stefanidou, E.S. Bekri, P.C. Yannopoulos ......................................................................... 151
IMPACT OF THE TUMULUS ON THE STABILITY OF MICROCLIMATE IN UNDERGROUND
HERITAGE STRUCTURES
V.Th. Kyriakou and V.P. Panoskaltsis......................................................................................... 158
COMPARING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS OF TWO OFFICE SEATING UNITS VIA LIFE
CYCLE ASSESSMENT
Merve Mermertas, Koray Ozsoy, Thomas P. Gloria, Fatos Germirli Babuna ............................. 169
REGENERATION AND PLACE-MAKING THROUGH HERITAGE: A CASE STUDY FROM A
HISTORIC BUILDING IN NORTHERN GREECE
S.M. Bagiouk, E. Sofianou, A.S. Bagiouk, S.S. Bagiouk ............................................................ 175
Environmental education ...................................................................... 187
RAISING AWARENESS ON CLIMATE CHANGE THROUGH HUMOR
L. Topaltsis, V. Plaka and C. Skanavis ........................................................................................ 189
EARLY CHILDHOOD ENVIRONMENTAL CAMP IN A GREEK PORT
G. Koresi, V. Plaka and C. Skanavis ........................................................................................... 199
IN SEARCH FOR AN ISLAND TO HOST AN ECOVILLAGE
M. Ganiaris, F. Zouridaki, V. Plaka, C. Skanavis, K. Antonopoulos and M. Avgerinos ............ 209
AUGMENTED REALITY PROVES TO BE A BREAKTHROUGH IN ENVIRONMENTAL
EDUCATION
P. Theodorou, P. Kydonakis, M. Botzori and C. Skanavis .......................................................... 219
RECYCLING AND EDUCATION THROUGH DIGITAL STORYTELLING IN THE AGE GROUP
“8-12” IN GREECE
X
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
P. Theodorou, K.C. Vratsanou, E. Moriki, M. Botzori, M. Karamperis and C. Skanavis ........... 229
SOCIAL EXPERIMENT IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL FIELD OF EDUCATION
S. M. Bagiouk, S. S. Bagiouk, A. E. Agiou, A. S. Bagiouk ........................................................ 240
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban
environment ............................................................................................ 249
SUSTAINABLE URBAN PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS: FROM THEORY TO
PRACTICE THROUGH INTERNATIONAL CASE STUDIES
E.K. Oikonomou and K. Kalkopoulou ......................................................................................... 251
A NOVEL METHOD FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT OF PLANNING
PROJECTS: THE CASE STUDY OF THE GENERAL LOCAL PLAN OF GJIROKASTRA
MUNICIPALITY, ALBANIA
E.K. Oikonomou and K. Kalkopoulou ......................................................................................... 262
ANALYSIS AND MODELLING OF BIOLOGICAL WEATHER DATA IN THESSALONIKI,
GREECE
Th. Kassandros, A. Tsiamis, A. Damialis, D. Vokou, N. Katsifarakis, K. Karatzas ................... 274
PM10 LEVELS OF THE CITY AND A SUBURB OF PATRAS, GREECE, DURING THE PERIOD
2013-2015
A. A. Bloutsos and P. C. Yannopoulos ........................................................................................ 284
SATELLITE DATA AS INDICATOR OF FOREST DIEBACK: THE STUDY CASE OF THE
PINEWOOD FOREST OF CASTELPORZIANO (CENTRAL ITALY)
F. Recanatesi, C. Giuliani, B. Cucca and M.N. Ripa ................................................................... 293
SURFACE TEMPERATURES AND THERMAL COMFORT CONDITIONS IN NORTHERN
GREECE
P. Kosmopoulos, A. Kantzioura. K. Michalopoulou ................................................................... 301
INVESTIGATION OF THERMAL COMFORT CONDITIONS IN URBAN CENTERS OF
NORTHERN GREECE
P. Kosmopoulos, A. Kantzioura, A. Moumtzakis ........................................................................ 310
Cultural and social issues ...................................................................... 321
REFUGEE CRISIS: GREEK RESIDENTS’ ATTITUDES TOWARDS WASTE MANAGEMENT
IN THEIR REGION
A. Kounani, C. Skanavis .............................................................................................................. 323
DEVELOPMENT AND EVALUATION OF A SMART APPLICATION FOR SUSTAINABLE
CROP PRODUCTION - CASE STUDY: COTTON (GOSSYPIUM SPP)
D. Arampatzis, C. Costopoulou, A. Efthymiou ........................................................................... 334
EXPLORING PUBLIC PREFERENCES AND PRIORITIES FOR CONTROLLING INVASIVE
MOSQUITO SPECIES: THE IMPLEMENTATION OF A WEB SURVEY IN GREEK
HOUSEHOLDS FOR THE CASE OF THE ASIAN TIGER MOSQUITO
K. Bithas, D. Latinopoulos, A. Kolimenakis, C. Richardson, K. Lagouvardos and A. Michaelakis
...................................................................................................................................................... 341
ENVIRONMENTAL CHALLENGES TO ACHIEVE THE SDG (11) FOR SUSTAINABLE CITIES
- CASE STUDY: TRIKALA, GREECE
M.E Chatzi, E. Kolokytha ............................................................................................................ 350
INVESTIGATING STAKEHOLDERS PRIORITIES FOR TRANSDISCIPLINARY COASTAL &
MARINE MANAGEMENT: THE CASE OF THERMAIKOS GULF
Z.I. Konstantinou and D. Latinopoulos........................................................................................ 360
XI
Table of Contents
Solid waste management........................................................................ 371
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES IN
CENTRAL MACEDONIA
M. Batsioula, G. Banias, Ch. Achillas, M. Lampridi, and D. Bochtis ......................................... 373
INNOVATIVE BIOGEOCHEMICAL SOIL COVER TO MITIGATE LANDFILL GAS
EMISSIONS
K. R. Reddy, D.G. Grubb and G. Kumar ..................................................................................... 383
CO2 SEQUESTRATION USING BOF SLAG: APPLICATION IN LANDFILL COVER
K. R. Reddy, G. Kumar, A. Gopakumar, R.K. Rai and D.G. Grubb ........................................... 392
RECYCLING OF CRT FUNNEL GLASS: A REVIEW OF ITS UTILIZATION IN
INTERLOCKING CONCRETE BLOCKS
G. Perkoulidis and N. Moussiopoulos ......................................................................................... 402
A SYSTEM DYNAMICS MODEL FOR SMALL HOUSEHOLD APPLIANCES’ WASTE
MANAGEMENT: A CASE OF TURKEY
A.Kemal Konyalıoğlu and İ.Bereketli Zafeirakopoulos .............................................................. 411
RAPID STABILIZATION OF MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE IN BIOREACTOR LANDFILLS:
PREDICTIVE PERFORMANCE USING COUPLED MODELING
G. Kumar and K. R. Reddy .......................................................................................................... 418
COLLECTION AND HANDLING OF SHIP WASTE AND CARGO RESIDUES IN GREECE:
PRESENT AND FUTURE
Th. Giantsi, S. Tsioupli, K. Flegkas, P. Koufos and J. Angelopoulos ......................................... 428
PASSIVE ACID MINE DRAINAGE REMEDIATION USING BOF STEEL SLAG AND
SUGARCANE BAGASSE
T.S. Naidu, L.D. Van Dyk, C.M. Sheridan, and D.G. Grubb ...................................................... 438
USE OF SOLID WASTES IN CEMENT PRODUCTS- A REVIEW
S. D. Mavridou ............................................................................................................................. 448
A WEB-BASED
MANAGEMENT
PLATFORM
FOR
LANDFILL
LEACHATE
ESTIMATION
AND
M. Kotsikas and K. Poulios ......................................................................................................... 459
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters ....... 471
SUSTAINABLE COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT OF STRYMONIKOS GULF –
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE D.P.S. FRAMEWORK FOR COASTAL ACTIVITIES
PRESSURES ANALYSIS
E. Yiannakopoulou and E.K. Oikonomou ................................................................................... 473
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE MULTICRITERIA METHOD AHP FOR THE EVALUATION OF
STRYMONIKOS GULF MANAGEMENT SCENARIOS WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF
INTEGRATED COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT
E. Yiannakopoulou and E.K. Oikonomou ................................................................................... 482
MODELLING THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON COASTAL FLOODING WITH THE
USE OF A 2DH BOUSSINESQ MODEL
A.G. Samaras and Th. V. Karambas ............................................................................................ 492
ON
THE
INTEGRATED
MODELLING
OF
WATERSHED-COAST
SYSTEMS:
CONSIDERATIONS FOR MORPHOLOGICAL MODELLING UNDER A CHANGING
CLIMATE
A.G. Samaras, Th.V. Karambas and C.G. Koutitas ..................................................................... 501
ASSESSING THE RESILIENCE OF THE RIA FORMOSA BARRIER ISLAND SYSTEM:
PRELIMINARY FINDINGS
XII
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
K. Kombiadou, A. Matias, A.R. Carrasco, S. Costas, O. Ferreira, T.A. Plomaritis and G. Vieira
...................................................................................................................................................... 511
EFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN THE PORT OF TRELLEBORG AND PROTECTIVE
MEASURES
A. S. Bagiouk, Th. V. Karambas, S. S. Bagiouk ......................................................................... 522
EVALUATION OF IMPACTS OF TORRENT CORRECTION WORKS AT FOURKAHALKIDIKI IN THE COASTAL ZONE OF FOURKA BEACH
V. Pavlidis .................................................................................................................................... 532
Environmental hydrology ...................................................................... 543
COMPARISON OF METEOROLOGICAL DROUGHT INDICES IN THESSALY WATER
DEPARTMENT, GREECE
T. Karampatakis, L. Vasiliades and A. Loukas ........................................................................... 545
RAINFALL TEMPORAL DISTRIBUTION IN THRACE BY MEANS OF AN UNSUPERVISED
MACHINE LEARNING METHOD
K. Vantas, E. Sidiropoulos and M. Vafeiadis .............................................................................. 555
DEVELOPMENT AND QUANTIFICATION OF VISUAL ANALYTICS ALGORITHMS FOR
INVESTIGATING EXTREME WEATHER EVENTS IN TIME-VARYING GEOGRAPHIC DATA
P. P. Giannopoulos and K. Moustakas ......................................................................................... 565
DEVELOPING FLOOD ACTION PLANS ON THE ADMINISTRATIVE LEVEL OF FARMERS’
ORGANIZATION
V. Pisinaras, G. Arampatzis and A. Panagopoulos ...................................................................... 574
MODERN MAPPING TECHNOLOGIES FOR MORPHOMETRY DYNAMICS OF KERKINI
RESERVOIR
I. Tsolakidis and M. Vafiadis ....................................................................................................... 584
Ground water resources management ................................................. 593
BUILDING GROUNDWATER CONCEPTUAL MODELS UNDER LIMITED INFORMATION
SUPPLY: A CASE STUDY ON AXIOS DELTA, NORTH GREECE
L. Kapetas, N. Kazakis, T. Spachos, K. Voudouris ..................................................................... 595
INVESTIGATING GROUNDWATER FLOW AND SEAWATER INTRUSION IN NEA
MOUDANIA AQUIFER UNDER VARIOUS MANAGEMENT SCENARIOS
I. Siarkos, M. Katirtzidou, D. Latinopoulos and P. Latinopoulos ............................................... 605
SPATIOTEMPORAL GEOSTATISTICAL MODELING OF AQUIFER LEVELS USING
PHYSICALLY BASED TOOLS
E.A. Varouchakis, P.G. Theodoridou and G.P. Karatzas ............................................................ 615
COST MINIMIZATION OF INTERMITTENT TRANSIENT GROUNDWATER PUMPING
Iraklis A. Nikoletos ...................................................................................................................... 622
STUDY ON GROUNDWATER NITRATES IN THE NORTHWEST OF THE THESSALONIKI
REGIONAL UNIT (GREECE)
A. Terzopoulos ............................................................................................................................. 631
SIMULATION OF WATER FLOW IN THE UNSATURATED SOIL ZONE TO ASSESS
IRRIGATION IN A MAIZE FIELD
Ch. Doulgeris, D. Voulanas, G. Arampatzis and E. Hatzigiannakis ............................................ 642
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures ............................. 651
XIII
Table of Contents
LAND-USE CHANGE ROLE IN CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION GOALS ACHIEVEMENT
V. Jurevičienė and R. Dagiliūtė ................................................................................................... 653
CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION STRATEGIES IN GREECE: RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
AND TRENDS
E.D. Thoidou and D.N. Foutakis ................................................................................................. 661
SPATIAL ANALYSIS FOR VULNERABILITY ASSESSMENT OF URBAN COASTAL AREAS
TO SEA LEVEL RISE
E.A. Stamatopoulou, G. Ovakoglou, T.K. Alexandridis, I.A. Tsalikidis .................................... 670
REFERENCE EVAPOTRANSPIRATION ASSESSMENT IN CHALKIDIKI REGION UNDER
CLIMATE CHANGE USING FOUR EARTH SYSTEM MODELS
P. Koukouli, P. Georgiou and D. Karpouzos ............................................................................... 678
ΑSSESSING THE TEMPERATURE CHANGES OVER EUROPE FOR THE 21ST CENTURY
USING A REGIONAL CLIMATE MODEL
I.Sofiadis, E.Katragkou, V.Pavlidis, S.Kartsios, K.Tsigaridis, Μ. Karypidou, D. Melas ........... 688
CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS ON THE COASTAL SEA LEVEL EXTREMES OF THE EASTCENTRAL MEDITERRANEAN SEA
C. Makris, P. Galiatsatou, Y. Androulidakis, K. Kombiadou, V. Baltikas, Y. Krestenitis and P.
Prinos ........................................................................................................................................... 695
Protection and restoration of ecosystems ............................................ 705
BIOFILM GROWTH IN DRINKING WATER SYSTEMS UNDER STAGNANT CONDITIONS
Erifyli Tsagkari and William T. Sloan ......................................................................................... 707
RESTORATION OF TWO GREEK LAKES (KASTORIA AND KORONIA): SUCCESS STORIES?
M. Moustaka-Gouni, M. Katsiapi, N. Stefanidou, E. Vardaka, S. Genitsaris, K. A. Kormas, F.
Georgoulis .................................................................................................................................... 718
EFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON GROUNDWATER NITRATE MODELLING
G. Tziatzios, P. Sidiropoulos, L. Vasiliades, J. Tzabiras, G. Papaioannou, N. Mylopoulos and A.
Loukas .......................................................................................................................................... 730
AN ASSESSMENT APPROACH TO INVESTIGATE CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS ΙN
CHANIA GROUNDWATER SYSTEM
D. Charchousi, Κ. Spanoudaki, A. Karali, A. Nanou-Giannarou, C. Giannakopoulos, M.P.
Papadopoulou ............................................................................................................................... 740
SALINITY EFFECTS ON DIFFERENT VARIETIES OF AMARANTUS SP.
G. Kacienė .................................................................................................................................... 748
“DIRTY” SEA PHENOMENON IN THESSALONIKI BAY: PLANKTON ABETTORS AND
PERPETRATORS
S. Genitsaris, N. Stefanidou, M. Moustaka-Gouni ...................................................................... 753
MONITORING THE MARINE ENVIRONMENT OF THERMAIKOS GULF
M. Petala, V. Tsiridis, I. Androulidakis, Ch. Makris, V. Baltikas, A. Stefanidou, S. Genitsaris, C.
Antoniadou, D. Rammou, M. Moustaka-Gouni, C.C. Chintiroglou and E. Darakas .................. 762
INVESTIGATION OF QUANTUM DOTS TOXICITY, GENOTOXICITY, CYTOTOXICITY,
AND UPTAKE IN RAINBOW TROUT ONCORHYNCHUS MYKISS LARVAE
Ž. Jurgelėnė, M. Stankevičiūtė, N. Kazlauskienė, D. Montvydienė, J. Baršienė, K. Jokšas, A.
Markuckas .................................................................................................................................... 775
ERYTHROCYTIC NUCLEAR ABNORMALITIES, DNA DAMAGE, BIOCONCENTRATION
FACTOR AND HEMATOLOGICAL CHANGES INDUCED BY METAL MIXTURE AT
ENVIRONMENTALLY RELEVANT CONCENTRATIONS IN RUTILUS RUTILUS
M. Stankevičiūtė, G. Sauliutė, A. Markuckas, T. Virbickas, J. Baršienė .................................... 785
XIV
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
GENO-, CYTOTOXICITY AND TOXICITY INDUCED BY SAPROLEGNIA PARASITICA AND
CADMIUM ALONE AND IN COMBINATION TO ONCORHYNCHUS MYKISS
M. Stankevičiūtė, Ž. Jurgelėnė, J. Greiciūnaitė, S. Markovskaja, N. Kazlauskienė, J. Baršienė 795
PHYSIOLOGICAL RESPONSE OF BARLEY AND BARNYARD GRASS TO INTERACTIVE
EFFECT OF HEAT WAVE AND DROUGHT
A. Dikšaitytė, G. Juozapaitienė, G. Kacienė, I. Januškaitienė, D. Miškelytė, and J. Žaltauskaitė
...................................................................................................................................................... 805
SOIL CARBON ACCUMULATION IN BARNYARD GRASS UNDER ELEVATED CO2 AND
SHORT-TERM HEAT WAVES AND DROUGHTS CONDITIONS
Dikšaitytė and G. Juozapaitienė ................................................................................................... 814
SHORT-TERM EFFECTS OF ELEVATED AIR TEMPERATURE AND ATMOSPHERIC CO2 ON
BELOW-GROUND CARBON ACCUMULATION IN HORDEUM VULGARE AND PISUM
SATIVUM
G. Juozapaitienė, A. Dikšaitytė, J. Aleinikovienė ....................................................................... 819
THE USE OF MODERN TECHNOLOGIES ΙΝ RECORDING AND MONITORING OF
RIPARIAN FORESTRY SPECIES IN GREECE. THE CASE OF CANKER STAIN DISEASE OF
PLATANUS ORIENTALIS L.
Grigorios Varras and Georgios Efthimiou ................................................................................... 826
STABLE ISOTOPE MASS BALANCE TO ASSESS CLIMATE IMPACT IN LAKE SYSTEMS
P. Chantzi and K. Almpanakis ..................................................................................................... 835
Soft and renewable energy sources....................................................... 847
A NUMERICAL TOOL FOR THE TIME-DOMAIN ANALYSIS OF FLOATING WAVE ENERGY
CONVERTERS
N. Mantadakis and E. Loukogeorgaki ......................................................................................... 849
OPTIMAL OPERATION SCHEDULING OF MULTIPURPOSE PUMPED STORAGE
HYDROPOWER PLANT WITH HIGH PENETRATION OF RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES
P.I. Bakanos and K.L. Katsifarakis .............................................................................................. 860
EVALUATION OF CYPRUS ENERGY RESOURCES IN THE FRAMEWORK
ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY USING A NOVEL SWOT-PESTEL APPROACH
OF
M. Tsangas and A.A. Zorpas ....................................................................................................... 871
BIOCLIMATIC HOUSE DESIGN BY APPLYING PASSIVE SYSTEMS AND GREEN ROOF
S. M. Bagiouk, S. S. Bagiouk, A. E. Agiou, A. S. Bagiouk ........................................................ 883
OPTIMIZATION OF SITE SELECTION OF AN ANAEROBIC DIGESTION PLANT FOR
TREATMENT AND VALORIZATION OF LIVESTOCK LIQUID MANURE WITH THE AID OF
GIS
E.K. Oikonomou, E. Tekidis and A. Guitonas ............................................................................. 894
DESIGN OF A GROUND SOURCE HEAT PUMP SYSTEM FOR A SCHOOL AND A HOTEL
OPERATING IN DIFFERENT SEASONS
S.A. Vlachos, F. Gaitanis and K.L. Katsifarakis ......................................................................... 905
FEASIBILITY STUDY OF A FLOATING OFFSHORE WIND FARM IN GREECE
V. Kafritsa and E. Loukogeorgaki ............................................................................................... 915
FLOATING PHOTOVOLTAIC POWER GENERATION SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT IN A LAKE
A. Zamanidou and E. Loukogeorgaki .......................................................................................... 925
MAXIMIZING THE BUILDING ENERGY PERFORMANCE WITH ADVANCED VENTILATED
FAÇADE SYSTEMS ON EXISTING STRUCTURES
D.K. Bikas, K.G. Tsikaloudaki, T.G. Theodosiou, D.C. Tsirigoti and S.P. Tsoka...................... 935
XV
Table of Contents
APPROPRIATE WIND FARM SITTING: THE CASE STUDY OF REGIONAL UNIT OF
MAGNESIA
A. Kouroumplis and D.G. Vagiona.............................................................................................. 943
HARNESSING THE BLUE RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES OF THE COASTAL
CEPHALONIA’S PARADOX AND THE EURIPUS STRAIT
A. Stergiopoulou, V. Stergiopoulos, G. Klironomos, E. Ververis, M. Syrganis, K. Papaioannou and
M. Theodoridou ........................................................................................................................... 953
A PANHELLENIC SURVEY (2017-2018)
P. Kosmopoulos. A. Kantzioura, I. Kosmopoulos, K. Kleskas, A. M. Kosmopoulos ................. 966
A TWO STEP PROCESS FOR THE ELECTROCHEMICAL CONVERSION OF CO2 TO
METHANOL
A. Schizodimou, I. Kotoulas and G. Kyriacou ............................................................................ 975
EFFECT OF SUCCESSIVE SMALL HYDROPOWER PLANTS ON WATER QUALITY
G. Kacienė .................................................................................................................................... 980
River and open channel hydraulics ...................................................... 987
DISCHARGE AND SEDIMENT TRANSPORT IN THE NESTOS RIVER BASIN, DOWNSTREAM
OF THE DAM OF PLATANOVRISI
G. Paschalidis, I. Iordanidis and P. Anagnostopoulos ................................................................. 989
URBAN STREAMS OF THESSALONIKI (GREECE): SPATIAL AND HYDRAULIC ASPECTS
S. Tsoumalakos and K.L. Katsifarakis ......................................................................................... 997
ON THE USE OF THE INTEGRAL MOMENTUM-BALANCE TO CALCULATE DRAG ON A
SQUARE CYLINDER IN A COMPOUND-CHANNEL FLOW
M. Gymnopoulos, P. Prinos, E. Alves and R. M.L. Ferreira ..................................................... 1005
A FUZZY MULTICRITERIA DECISION APPROACH TO SELECT THE OPTIMAL TYPE OF
SPILLWAY AT A SPECIFIC DAM
V. Balioti, C. Tzimopoulos and C. Evangelides ........................................................................ 1014
MODELLING ENVIRONMENTAL FLOWS WITH LAGRANGIAN PARTICLE MESH-FREE
METHODS
A. Liakopoulos, F. Sofos, T. Karakasidis .................................................................................. 1024
Environmental law and economics ..................................................... 1035
SPATIAL MULTI-CRITERIA DECISION MAKING MODEL FOR SUSTAINABLE COASTAL
LAND-USE AND DEVELOPMENT. THE CASE STUDY OF KALAMARIA-PILEA SEAFRONT
IN THESSALONIKI, GREECE.
S. Anastasiadis, A. S. Partsinevelou and Z. Mallios .................................................................. 1037
APPLYING THE CONTINGENT VALUATION METHOD TO ESTIMATE THE ECONOMIC
VALUE OF THE THESSALONIKI SUBURBAN SEICH-SOU FOREST AMENITIES
E.K. Oikonomou and A. Guitonas ............................................................................................. 1047
APPLYING A CONTINGENT VALUATION METHOD (CVM) FOR THE PRESERVATION
/RESTORATION OF THREE LAKES IN NORTHERN GREECE
Odysseas N. Kopsidas ................................................................................................................ 1059
EXAMINATION OF THE PROPOSAL FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A PIER AT NEW
WATERFRONT OF THESSALONIKI
E. I. K. Koutsovili, A. D. Kosta, Z. Mallios and T. Karambas .................................................. 1065
DRONES AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION LAW IN GERMANY AND GREECE
A.K. Douka ................................................................................................................................ 1076
XVI
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Water and wastewater treatment and management ........................ 1083
FROM WASTE TO ENERGY: OPTIMIZING GROWTH OF MICROALGAE SCENEDESMUS
OBLIQUUS IN UNTREATED ENERGETIC-LADEN WASTEWATER STREAMS FROM AN
AMMUNITION FACILITY FOR BIOENERGY PRODUCTION
A. RoyChowdhury, J. Abraham, T. Abimbola, Y. Lin, C. Christodoulatos, A. Lawal, P. Arienti, B.
Smolinski, and W. Braida .......................................................................................................... 1085
ELUTION HISTORY OF BASIC OXYGEN FURNACE SLAG TO PRODUCE AKLALINE
WATER FOR REAGENT PURPOSES
A. Caicedo-Ramirez1, M.T. Hernandez1, D.G. Grubb2, .......................................................... 1095
PHOSPHATE REMOVAL USING A REACTIVE GEOCOMPOSITE MAT PROTOTYPE
D.G. Grubb, A.S. Filshill, D.R.V. Berggren .............................................................................. 1104
UTILIZATION AND DESIGN OF FIRE SAFETY SYSTEMS WITH THE USE OF TREATED
WASTEWATER
M. G. Zerva and I. K. Kalavrouziotis ........................................................................................ 1112
CARBON NANOTUBES APPLICATION FOR HEXAVALENT CHROMIUM ADSORPTION
FROM CONTAMINATED GROUNDWATER
Thanasis Mpouras, Angeliki Polydera, Dimitris Dermatas ....................................................... 1121
THE USE OF NANOCRYSTALLINE TITANIUM DIOXIDE IN REMOVING HEAVY METALS
FROM WATER: A HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE OF SCIENTIFIC ADVANCEMENTS
G. P. Korfiatis, X. Meng and Q. Shi ......................................................................................... 1129
DEGRADATION OF 2,4-DINITROANISOLE (DNAN) IN AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS BY MGBASED BIMETALS
A. Mai, P. Karanam, E. Hadnagy, S. Menacherry, W. Braida, C. Christodoulatos, A. Koutsospyros,
T. S. Su ....................................................................................................................................... 1136
POTABLE WATER DISINFECTION WITH SILVER IONS DURING SPACE MISSIONS: THE
ROLE OF WATER TANK AND WATER SUPPLY MATERIALS
V. Tsiridis, M. Petala, I. Mintsouli,N. Pliatsikas, S. Sotiropoulos, M. Kostoglou, E. Darakas, T.
Karapantsios ............................................................................................................................... 1146
DETERMINATION OF AMMONIUM IN RECYCLED AND POTABLE WATER SAMPLES FOR
SPACE APPLICATIONS
G. Giakisikli, V. Trikas, Th. Karapantsios, G. Zachariadis, A. Anthemidis.............................. 1155
GIS’ CONTRIBUTION IN BIOLOGICAL PROCESSING OF WASTE WATERS IN SMALL
SETTLEMENTS. CASE STUDY BY USING AN ARTIFICIAL WETLAND SYSTEM.
S. Kariotis, E. Giannakopoulos and I.K. Kalavrouziotis ........................................................... 1165
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF FE-MN BIMETAL MODIFIED KAOLIN CLAY MINERAL
IN AS(III) REMOVAL FROM GROUNDWATER
R Mudzielwana, W.M Gitari and P Ndungu .............................................................................. 1172
REUSE POTENTIAL OF CATAPHORESIS WASTEWATERS IN AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY
P. Karacal, C. Aliyazicioglu Ozdemir, E. Erdim and F. Germirli Babuna ................................ 1184
XVII
Table of Contents
XVIII
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Water resources management and contamination
control
1
Water resources management and contamination control
2
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
CLIMATE CHANGE EFFECTS ON THE AVAILABILITY OF
WATER RESOURCES OF LAKE KARLA WATERSHED FOR
IRRIGATION AND VOLOS CITY URBAN WATER USE
A. Alamanos* N. Mylopoulos, L. Vasiliades and A. Loukas
Laboratory of Hydrology and Aquatic Systems Analysis, Dept. of Civil Engineering, University of
Thessaly (UTH), GR- 38334 Volos, Thessaly, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: alamanos@civ.uth.gr, tel: +302421074153
Abstract
Climate change and its potential impacts on water resources may have a large impact on water
resources and subsequent water resources management practices. Changes on future climate will
likely affect the fundamental drivers of the hydrological cycle, rainfall and temperature. The
Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs), which simulate future projections of GHG emissions
and atmospheric concentrations, are used to model future changes in these variables. The RCPs
include a stringent mitigation scenario, one intermediate scenario and one scenario with very high
GHG emissions until year 2100. Subsequent changes in rainfall and temperature are used to examine
climate change effects on two study areas; an agricultural watershed and an urban city, in Thessaly,
Greece. Lake Karla Watershed, a typical Mediterranean agricultural area with dry climate, and the
neighboring city of Volos are examined. The Water Evaluation And Planning (WEAP) modeling
system is used to simulate the water availability for historical and future periods and for various water
uses. More specifically, the water balance is simulated under the three extreme climate change
scenarios and current operational management practices. The two study areas are modeled separately
in the Baseline Scenario. In the future, when the new reservoir of the technical Lake Karla will
operate, 50 new drilling wells will also be used for the coverage of the urban water demand of Volos
city. Thus, the two areas are connected and modeled as an integrated system in the future scenarios.
Finally, a management scenario of irrigation and urban losses reduction is suggested and simulated
(for the current and for the future conditions) under the climate change scenarios. The results of the
water balances indicate the vulnerability of the study areas, especially of the agricultural watershed,
under the climate change, and the alteration the of current water resources management practices is
deemed necessary.
Keywords: water resources management, Water Evaluation And Planning system (WEAP), Lake
Karla Watershed, Volos city, climate change.
3
Water resources management and contamination control
1.
INTRODUCTION
Climate models project a reduction in annual precipitation and an increment in temperature, which
may sharpen water scarcity phenomena. Climate change has multiple and growing impacts on urban
and agricultural activities (Feilberg and Mark, 2016). These impacts have serious potential
consequences for every domain that is connected directly or indirectly with water resources (Molle
and Berkoff, 2009). The impacts of climate change on water resources availability are among the
most widely discussed environmental issues in the last decades (IPCC, 2014, OECD, 2015, IWA,
2015). In line with this, water resources management must consider long-term planning, and one of
its main aspects, is the changing climate (Russo, et al., 2014, Mourato et al., 2015). This paper
proposes a water demand management under climate change scenarios. Water demand management,
opposed to augmenting supply is increasingly proposed as a way of mitigating water-scarcity
problems (Gleick, 2003). A neglected area in the field of climate change studies is the combination
of different water uses, as the majority of the previous works has only focused on a specific water
use. A rural watershed and a city are examined in this paper, combining thus the agricultural and the
urban water use, in terms of simulation and modeling, under management and climate change
scenarios. The selected study areas are Lake Karla Watershed and the neighboring city of Volos, in
Thessaly (Central Greece). Industrial water uses of the watershed and Volos Municipality, as well as
the animal husbandry of Lake Karla watershed have been taken into account, to complement
agricultural and urban water demands which are the most important water uses. Furthermore, the
existing practices are examined and new policies are investigated to strengthen the management’s
adaptation plans to new climate conditions, especially in agricultural watersheds.
2.
STUDY AREA
Lake Karla Watershed is a representative agricultural watershed with limited water resources. The
climate of the wider area of Karla is characterized as Mediterranean with dry and hot summers and
cold and humid winters, with a mean annual precipitation of 451.13 mm and a mean annual
temperature of 15.2 °C (Hydromentor, 2015). The intense irrigation of water demanding crops
increased the pumping, with catastrophic results to the ecosystem, and especially to the aquifer
(Sidiropoulos, 2014). The water demand of the watershed is covered by the surface network Local
Administration of Land Reclamation (LALR) of Pinios River and mainly from the groundwater
aquifer. The lake was drained in 1962, for flood protection and for more agricultural land, but the
planned works were not constructed, creating thus, a number of environmental problems which led
to the reconstitution of the lake. To date all the reconstitution works have been completed and refilling
the lake with water from Pinios River continues to target the highest level, so the operation of
irrigation can start. The new reservoir’s operation is already delayed, causing further environmental
problems (Stamou, 2015).
Volos is the capital of the prefecture of Magnesia (Central Greece), in the South-East boarder of Lake
Karla watershed (Fig. 1), with a population of approximately 144,450 inhabitants. Volos occupies an
area of 387.1 km2. Its climate is characterized as Mediterranean with an average annual temperature
of 16.4°C and 504 mm of annual rainfall. The Municipal Water Utility of Volos is responsible for the
city’s water supply, as well as the Industrial Area (Fafoutis, 2008). The water needs are covered by 5
springs and 40 wells, and the water is collected in 8 reservoirs. The city faces water problems,
especially during summer, mainly due to the losses, which are estimated to be above the 40% of the
total supplied water, according to the Water Utility databases (Mylopoulos et al., 2017). Furthermore,
major environmental issues arose the last decades, such as, the systematically pumping and the
deterioration of the aquifer (Mylopoulos and Mentes, 2005).
4
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1. The broader study area.
When the Lake Karla reservoir will operate, significantly less water will be pumped from the
groundwater aquifer. Karla watershed’s area is 1663 km2 now, but after the completion of the
reservoir works its area will be 1171 km2 due to the new irrigation areas that will be serviced from
the reservoir’s surface water (Loukas et al., 2008). The complementary works that accompany the
reconstruction of the lake include the opening of 50 new wells to meet the water needs of the city of
Volos and the surrounding settlements, with 2.9 hm³ of water annually (Ministry of Environment,
2004). These wells will be distributed in the area of Stefanovikio up to Rizomylos, to 15 km 2
(Sidiropoulos et al., 2009). Of these 50 wells, the 10 are already operating on behalf of the Municipal
Water Utility of Volos, but they will be replaced from the new ones (Water Utility of Volos, 2011).
5
Water resources management and contamination control
3.
METHODOLOGY
The methodology is focused on simulation of water supply sources, and water demand and the
subsequent water balance estimation. Irrigation water needs were calculated with the software
CROPWAT (FAO, 2015) and the urban water demand was calculated with a simple MS Excel model,
given the quarterly consumption. The software WEAP (Water Evaluation And Planning system)
(weap21.org), was used for the simulation of the water balance. The nodes of the system were
schematized in WEAP. Figure 2 presents the positions of the supply sources, demand sites (nodes)
and the linkage connections among the nodes.
Figure 2. Water resources management system implementation for Lake Karla watershed
and Volos city
For higher precision and spatial integration of the results, the watershed was divided into different
zones (the demand nodes in Figure 2): North, South, Mountain, Surface Network of Pinios LALR,
five (5) zones for the aquifer and nine (9) zones for the reservoir future serviced areas. The separation
was based on common physical characteristics (e.g. soil) and common areas of administrative
boundaries (Alamanos et al., 2016, 2017). For the analysis’ needs the city of Volos was divided into
five (5) main sectors (Fig. 2 and 3); sectors 1, 2, 3 and 4 cover the urban area, while the fifth sector
covers the Industrial Area (Vagiona et al., 2005, Vagiona and Mylopoulos, 2009, Mylopoulos et al.,
2017).
6
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3. a) Lake Karla watershed divided into irrigation zones b) Volos city divided into
sectors
Four management scenarios were developed to better reflect technical (engineering) measures on the
efficient water use, as well as the future situation, and three climate change scenarios were developed
to examine their effect on the water balance, for each management scenario:
Scenario 1: The current situation, the BAU scenario. The Karla reservoir is not active yet and the
main supply sources are the groundwater aquifer and the river Pinios. The reservoir is expected to
operate, but until then, the already overexploited aquifer is giving water to all the areas around the
lake (Sidiropoulos, 2014). In the city of Volos the supply sources for the coverage of the urban water
needs are the 5 springs (from Mountain Pelion) and the 40 wells (from the groundwater of the plain
of Karla Watershed, from Nea Ionia and from the groundwater of Volos) (Mylopoulos et al., 2017).
Scenario 1a: Reducing water losses on Scenario 1. There are high evaporation losses in the open
irrigation channels of Pinios LALR surface network, especially during summer months, where the
water needs increase. There are also considerable leakages which aggravate water loss. The lack of
maintenance, leads to big water losses, too. This scenario was simulated by using a higher coefficient
for transfer efficiency equal to 0.75 instead of 0.4 used in the baseline scenario (for the surface
network) and 0.9 instead of 0.8 for the pipeline network (Hydromentor 2015, Alamanos et al., 2016,
7
Water resources management and contamination control
2017). Practically, this can be achieved by cleaning (from plants and rubbish) and maintaining the
irrigation network. The losses of the network of Volos are estimated to be above the 40% of the total
supplied water, and they can also be further reduced (Mylopoulos et al., 2017). In this scenario the
losses are considered to be 30% of the total supplied water.
Scenario 2: The future situation of Karla reservoir and new wells operation. The main difference,
compared to Scenario 1, is that the new irrigation areas that will be served from the reservoir, in the
baseline scenario were served by the underlying aquifer (Sidiropoulos, 2014) and the extra water
supply from the wells of Karla watershed will feed Volos (Ministry of Environment, 2004,
Sidiropoulos et al., 2009). Thus, this connection of the two areas is taken into account, providing the
overall results of the Volos’ water balance.
Scenario 2a: Reducing water losses on Scenario 2, with the same way that it was achieved in Scenario
1a.
All the above management scenarios were examined under three climate change scenarios using the
Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) as proposed by the IPCC in its 5th Assessment Report
(AR5) in 2014 (IPCC, 2014). For the development of these scenarios, the results of the program
CORDEX (cordex.org) were used for the RCP scenarios (Moss et al., 2008). Three RCPs are
examined (namely the RCP2.6, RCP4.5 and the RCP8.5) that are consistent with a wide range of
possible changes in future anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Their historic (baseline)
period was from 1960 until 1990. Changes of precipitation (P) and temperature (T) are based on the
ensemble mean of the 10 simulations of the RCMs based on five (5) different GCMs. The forecast
period is from 2006 until 2100 and the grid resolution is 0.11 degrees, about 10x10 km². For the data’s
statistical adjustment (correction) on the existing ones, the D-test was implemented, according to the
Equation (1). Thus, P and T have been downscaled by truncating their historical time series by the
monthly change of the RCMs’ results between the historical base period 1960-2005 and the future
periods (divided to 30year-periods until 2100) (Loukas, et al. 2008).
PC = [(RCPav – Hav) / Hav] ∙100
(1)
where: RCPav is the studied variable’s average from the RCPs, of all the available RCMs, Hav is the
studied variable’s average from the historic period 1950-2005, PC is the percentage of change of the
studied variables. The final P and T outputs (which will be used in the scenarios) are the estimated
future time series and used to develop three representative climate change scenarios. The observed
meteorological values are referring to time series of 1960-2009 (present period) for Lake Karla
watershed and for Volos is the period 2007-2012. The developed scenarios are:
The Mild (Conservative) Scenario, where annual temperature is increased by 6.39% and
precipitation is decreased by 3.82%
The Middle (Average) Scenario, where T is increased by 8.30% and P is decreased by 7.57%
The Worst (Extreme) Scenario, where T is increased by 8.86% and P is decreased by 10.56%
These scenarios caused an increased agricultural water demand and also an increased urban water
demand. The new water demand of the city of Volos was calculated using the demand elasticities on
P and T (Mylopoulos, 2015). The elasticities express the percentage that the studied variables affect
the water consumption.
The water supply from river Pinios, from Karla reservoir, from the aquifers and from Pelion springs,
are considered to be the same (as designed in the studies of their operation). Also, the results of the
study of Vasiliades and Loukas (2013) shows that the climate change does not affect the natural
aquifer of Lake Karla, in contrast to human exploitation which is quite intense and requires immediate
reassessment of water demands, before the situation becomes irreversible. The crop distribution can
change only after managerial measures that will take into account the climate change, but on behalf
of the farmers there cannot be such a prediction (as long as the consequences are not noticeable). So
the crop distribution will be considered stable in the climate change scenarios.
8
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The results of the simulation procedure described above, regarding the annual water balance, are
showing below (Table 1 and Figure 4). The results show that the water balance of Lake Karla
Watershed is negative, under every scenario, and this illustrates the reality of the watershed, meaning
its excessive irrigation water overexploitation and degradation of water resources. The water balance
of Lake Karla Watershed and of Volos, under the climate change scenarios becomes much more
negative. In Scenario 2 the Lake Karla Watershed is negative again, but less negative than in the BAU
scenario 1 (by 33.6%). This shows the importance and the need of the immediate operation of the
reservoir.
Table 1. The water balance for Lake Karla Watershed (LKW), under every management and
climate change scenario
Water Balance (hm3)
Management
Scenarios
Lake Karla
Watershed (L.K.W.)
LKW - milder
climate change
scenario
LKW - middle
climate change
scenario
LKW - worst climate
change scenario
Scenario 1
-186.9
-211.68
-225.94
-235.67
Scenario 1a
-87.6
-103.78
-113.19
-127.92
Scenario 2
-124.1
-145.10
-158.51
-171.96
Scenario 2a
-25.1
-36.33
-48.81
-55.14
The only complete study that examines the water balance of this watershed under climate change is
the research program “Hydromentor” (2015). The differences between the meteorological changes
are between 2.19% and 7.06%. Thus, the water balances of Lake Karla Watershed under the studied
climate change scenarios are a little bit more extreme, compared with Hydromentor’s results, as
presented in Tzabiras et al. (2016).
The major difference between these studies is the primary data used for the climate scenarios
development; the current study used the results from 10 simulations of the RCMs based on five (5)
different GCMs referring to the RCPs, while Tzabiras et al. (2016) used one GCM’s results referring
to the SRES scenarios.
The effort for a more representative illustration of the different possible futures, lead us to the use of
more meteorological models, which gives a wider uncertainty. Also in our study, eleven different
crops of the watershed were taken into account, while Tzabiras et al. (2016) used four main crops,
due to insufficient data. This fact also increases the uncertainties in the calculation of the irrigation
water requirements and thus, the water balance. The results also show the big uncertainty that
accompanies the climate change, and the difficulty to have accurate results, which is also a reality, as
it depends on the predictions.
The water balance of the city of Volos is slightly negative in the current situation, but with a 10%
losses reduction, becomes positive, showing thus, the big effect that proper network maintenance can
have on the coverage of the water needs. Volos’ water balance in Scenario 2 becomes positive, almost
as much as the extra water supply of the new wells from Karla. Of course, not all this water amount
is going to be used as an extra supply, but there will be a supply management. Lake Karla Watershed
is obviously much more vulnerable under climate change.
9
Water resources management and contamination control
Figure 4. The water balance for Volos city, under every management and climate change
scenario
5.
CONCLUSIONS
This paper has investigated the water availability in an agricultural watershed and a city, as a system,
under management and climate change scenarios. The current study was not specifically designed to
provide a new methodological framework, but it could be the basis for a better understanding of the
situation and a starting point for the authorities to turn to a more sustainable water demand
management. This work has proved once more that the agricultural areas, where the managerial
control is not as strict as the urban areas, are more vulnerable. Also, another important finding is that
the demand management has a bigger effect on the water balance, than the climate change, on the
watershed. This can be justified from the fact that the management Scenario 1a results a change of
53.11% and Scenario 2 results a change of 33.70% on Scenario’s 1 water balance, while the worst
climate change scenario results a change of 26.03%. On the other hand, in the city we observe the
opposite. However, Scenarios 1a, 2 and 2a result a positive water balance in Volos and in that case
the extra amount of water has to be preserved with a temporary pause of the operation of some of the
wells. Our investigations into this area are still in progress and seem likely to confirm these finding.
The continuation of the research includes the examination of more demand management scenarios,
technical, economic, social measures, and different water pricing policies.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank: Associate Prof. P. Zanis for providing immediate access to the
climate models results from the project ‘Application for Regional Climate Data Extraction’
http://meteo.geo.auth.gr:3838/#tab-6186-7 elaborated in Aristotle University of Thessaloniki; A.
Tsikerdekis, post-doctoral researcher in the same project, for his helpful advice on various technical
issues; A. Barcio and V. Ragazzi, under the Erasmus Internship of which the research topic was
conceived; Dr. G. Papaioannou for his assistance in the improvement of the maps and the figures.
10
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
References
1. Alamanos A., S. Xenarios, N. Mylopoulos, P. Stalnacke (2016) ‘Hydro-economic modeling and
management with limited data: the case of Lake Karla Basin, Greece’, European Water Journal,
54, pp. 3-18.
2. Alamanos Α., C. Fafoutis, G. Papaioannou and N. Mylopoulos (2017) ‘Extension of an integrated
hydroeconomic model of Lake Karla watershed, under management, climate and pricing scenario
analysis’ Sixth International Conference on Environmental Management, Engineering,
Planning and Economics (CEMEPE), June 25-30, 2017 Thessaloniki, Greece.
3. Fafoutis C. (2008) ‘Integrated approach to water demand management in the residential sector costing according to the full value’. PhD Thesis, University of Thessaly, Department of Civil
Engineering, Volos.
4. FAO (2015), Cropwat, http://www.fao.org/nr/water/infores_databases_cropwat.html
5. Feilberg M. and O. Mark (2016) ‘Integrated Urban Water Management: Improve Efficient Water
Management and Climate Change Resilience in Cities’, Sustainable Water Management in
Urban Environments, Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2016, pp. 1–32.
6. Gleick P.H. (2003) ‘Global freshwater resources: Soft-path solutions for the 21st century’,
Science, 302, pp. 1524–1528.
7. Hydromentor (2015) ‘Development of an integrated monitoring system and management of
quantity and quality of water resources in agricultural basins under climate change
conditions. Application in the basin of Lake Karla’ Research Program.
8. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Synthesis Report (2014) ‘Contribution of Working
Groups I, II and III to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
Change [Core Writing Team, R.K. Pachauri and L.A. Meyer (eds.)]. IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland,
151 pp.
9. International Water Association (IWA) (2015) ‘Cities of the future – water security for cities
through integrated design and water centric decision making’, http://www.iwanetwork.org/projects2/cities-of-the-future. Last day accessed 23 Nov 2015.
10. Loukas A., L. Vasiliades and J. Tzabiras (2008) ‘Climate Change Impacts on Drought Severity’,
Advances in Geosciences, 17, pp. 23-29.
11. Ministry of Environment (2004) ‘Study of the supplementary works for the water supply of
the area of Volos’, Athens, October 2004, pp. 72.
12. Molle F. and J. Berkoff (2009) ‘Cities vs. agriculture: A review of intersectoral water reallocation’, Natural Resources Forum, 33, pp. 6–18.
13. Moss R., M. Babiker, S. Brinkman, E, Calvo, T. Carter, J. Edmonds, I. Elgizouli, S. Emori, L.
Erda, K. Hibbard, R. Jones, M. Kainuma, J. Kelleher, J.F. Lamarque, M. Manning, B. Matthews,
J. Meehl, L. Meyer, J. Mitchell, N. Nakicenovic, B. O’Neill, R. Pichs, K. Riahi, S. Rose, P. Runci,
R. Stouffer, D. van Vuuren, J. Weyant, T. Wilbanks, J.P. van Ypersele and M. Zurek (2008)
‘Towards New Scenarios for Analysis of Emissions, Climate Change, Impacts, and Response
Strategies’, Geneva: Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 2008.
14. Mourato S., M. Moreira and J. Corte-Real (2015) ‘Water Resources Impact Assessment Under
Climate Change Scenarios in Mediterranean Watersheds’, Water Resources Management, 29,
pp. 2377–2391.
15. Mylopoulos N. (2015) ‘Assessment of urban water full cost under the conditions of an economic
crisis’, European Water Journal, 49, pp. 89-105.
16. Mylopoulos N. and A. Mentes (2005) ‘A sustainable framework for water resources management
in an urban watershed: the case of Volos, Greece’, Urban Water Journal, 2 (1), pp. 13-22.
11
Water resources management and contamination control
17. Mylopoulos N., C. Fafoutis, S. Sfyris and A. Alamanos (2017) ‘Impact of water pricing policy
and climate change on future water demand in Volos, Greece’ European Water Journal, 58, pp.
473-479.
18. Organizations for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) (2015) ‘Programme on
Water Governance’ http://www.oecd.org/env/watergovernanceprogramme.htm. Last day
accessed 23 Nov 2015.
19. Russo T., K. Alfredo and J. Fisher (2014) ‘Sustainable Water Management in Urban, Agricultural,
and Natural Systems’ Water Vol 6, pp. 3934 – 3956.
20. Sidiropoulos P. (2014) ‘Groundwater Resources Management under Uncertainty: The value of
information on environmentally degraded aquifers’, PhD Thesis, University of Thessaly,
Department of Civil Engineering, Volos.
21. Sidiropoulos P., N. Mylopoulos, A. Loukas (2009) ‘Simulation of the impact of the new wells on
Karla’s aquifer’, Common Conference: 11th of the Greek Hydro-technical Union (ΕΥΕ), 7th
of the Greek Committee of Water Resources Management (ΕΕΔΥΠ), Volos, Greece.
22. Stamou M. (2015) ‘Evaluation of the Environmental of the delay of Lake Karla reconstruction’,
Msc thesis, University of Thessaly, Department of Economics, Volos.
23. Tzabiras J., L. Vasiliades, P. Sidiropoulos, A. Loukas and N. Mylopoulos (2016) ‘Evaluation of
Water Resources Management Strategies to Overturn Climate Change Impacts on Lake Karla
Watershed’, Water Resources Management, 30, pp. 5819–5844.
24. Vagiona D. and N. Mylopoulos (2009) ‘Water Price Elasticity And Public Acceptability On
Conservation Options In The City Of Volos – Greece’ International Journal of Sustainable
Development and Planning, Vol 4, 4, pp. 322–332.
25. Vagiona D., N. Mylopoulos and C. Fafoutis (2005) ‘Water demand management aspects in the
residential sector. The city of Volos case, Greece’ Proc. 6th International Conference EWRA,
Menton, France, 2005.
26. Vasiliades L. and A. Loukas (2013) ‘An Operational Drought Monitoring System Using Spatial
Interpolation Methods for Pinios River Basin, Greece’ 13th International Conference on
Environmental Science and Technology (CEST 2013), 5-7 September 2013, Athens, Greece.
27. Water Evaluation And Planning System (WEAP), Stockholm Environment Institute (SEI) weap21.org.
28. Water Utility of Volos (2011) ‘The existing water supply situation in the new municipality Volos’,
Directorate Planning and Development, Planning and Development Department.
29. WCRP (2017) ‘Coordinated Regional Climate Downscaling Experiment’ (cordex.org).
12
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
DEVELOPING AN INTEGRATED SURFACE WATERGROUNDWATER MODELING SYSTEM FOR UPPER
ANTHEMOUNTAS BASIN, GREECE
I. Siarkos, S. Sevastas*, D. Botsis and N. Theodossiou
School of Civil Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, GR54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: sevastas@civil.auth.gr, tel : +302310326576
Abstract
The need of integrated surface water-groundwater management is well recognized, since this type of
management can provide a comprehensive and coherent understanding of the water cycle on
catchment-level, leading to the proper and efficient use of water. Moreover, integrated water
resources management (IWRM) is strictly imposed by the European Union Framework Directive
2000/60/EC and all relevant European and national legislation. An important role towards the
successful implementation of IWRM plays the application of numerical modeling, through the
coupling of hydrological models with groundwater flow models. Model coupling, even though it is a
complex procedure including a number of conceptual and computational challenges, is widely used
in modern IWRM. In this perspective, the present study investigates the interaction between surface
water and groundwater on catchment-level by developing an integrated modeling system consisting
of a hydrological and a groundwater model. The hydrological model was constructed within the
framework of the widely used software Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT), while the
groundwater model was formed applying the MODFLOW code, which has evolved into the
worldwide standard computer program used in groundwater modeling. The aforementioned models
were interlinked and applied for the combined simulation of hydrological processes and groundwater
flow in Upper Anthemountas basin. Moreover, a sensitivity analysis was performed in the case of
groundwater flow model in order to investigate the impact of various model parameters (e.g.
hydraulic conductivity, storativity, wells pumping rates, boundary conditions) on the model results
(hydraulic head), which will be helpful in the case of a future calibration of the model.
Keywords: integrated water resources management; hydrological modeling; groundwater modeling;
surface water-groundwater interactions; Upper Anthemountas basin
1.
INTRODUCTION
In various parts of the world, both surface water and groundwater resources are considered important
for the sustainability of local society and ecosystems, since they preserve life and cover the various
water needs (Shanafield et al., 2012; Simpson et al., 2013; Wu et al., 2015). For the better
management of water resources in those regions, which is based on the principles of integrated water
resources management (IWRS), a complete understanding and a thorough investigation of the
integrated surface water-groundwater system are required (Spanoudaki et al., 2005; Cho et al., 2009;
Wu et al., 2015). To accomplish this task, numerical modeling is usually implemented, through the
coupling of hydrological models with groundwater flow models. In this way, a spatially and
temporally detailed description of both the hydrological processes on basin level and groundwater
flow is achieved (Sophocleous and Perkins, 2000; Barthel, 2006; Wu et al., 2014; Wu et al., 2015).
13
Water resources management and contamination control
Even though numerical modeling is widely used in modern IWRM, the integration between
hydrological and groundwater flow models is considered to be a complex procedure, since the
interaction between the two regimes is influenced by a number of factors, such as subsurface
hydraulic properties, surface water and groundwater flow patterns, topography, and type of land use
(Sophocleous, 2002; Barthel, 2006; Chao et al., 2009). Taking the aforementioned factors into
consideration, it is important that the model system is able to investigate the hydrologic effects in
conjunction with the proper study of surface water-groundwater interaction. Moreover, with regard
to groundwater flow study, it is essential to simulate the spatial occurrence and distribution of return
flow (Kim et al., 2008). The combined use of SWAT - MODFLOW models is able to successfully
address these issues (Sophocleous and Perkins, 2000; Kim et al., 2008).
Within this context, in the present study an integrated modeling system applying the widely used
computer codes, SWAT and MODFLOW, and consisting of a hydrological and a groundwater model
was developed, in order to investigate surface water-groundwater interactions in the Upper
Anthemountas basin. The governing equations solved by SWAT and MODFLOW can be found in
Winchell et al. (2013) and McDonald and Harbaugh (1988) respectively. Regarding the simulation
of hydrological processes, a model developed in a previous study (Sevastas et al., 2017a) was used,
while concerning the groundwater flow simulation, a transient model was formed. This model was
based on both the aforementioned hydrological model and a calibrated steady-state model already
developed for the reference area (Sevastas et al., 2017b). The key point of the whole procedure is that
the outputs of the hydrological model in terms of water percolation are introduced as inputs to the
groundwater flow model, providing the aquifer recharge deriving from precipitation. Furthermore, a
sensitivity analysis regarding the groundwater flow model was conducted in order to: a) gain insight
into model behavior and b) identify those model parameters (e.g. hydraulic conductivity, storativity,
wells pumping rates, boundary conditions) that affect most the model results and, therefore, should
be taken seriously into account during a future model calibration (Carrera et al., 2010; Siarkos and
Latinopoulos, 2016).
2.
STUDY AREA
The Upper Anthemountas sub-basin, being the eastern part of the entire Anthemountas basin, is
located in Halkidiki Peninsula, Greece, south east of the city of Thessaloniki (Figure 1). The basin
covers an area of approximately 110 km2, and is bordered to the west by the Lower Anthemountas
basin and to the south by the Nea Moudania basin. The climate of the study area is typically
Mediterranean with relatively low annual precipitation (470 mm) and high temperatures during
summer (Latinopoulos, 2001; Sevastas et al., 2017a, 2017b).
The Upper Anthemountas basin is a typical rural area dominated by complex cultivation patterns
(wheat, corn, cotton, alfalfa and olive trees) and mixed forest (mainly various types of oaks along
with Platanus and Chestnuts trees). Water demand in the region is confined mainly to drinking and
irrigation, and is met respectively through few public supply wells and a large number of privately
owned irrigation wells. Moreover, there are few wells for both livestock and industrial purposes, as
shown in Figure 1. Currently water needs in the region are exclusively covered by a semi-confined
aquifer system, consisting of successive water-bearing layers without regular geometric growth,
separated by lenses of semi-permeable or impermeable materials. From hydrological point of view,
the catchment consists of a dense well-formed stream network. Most time of the year, surface flow
of the river is very limited due to low precipitation and to the fact that some upper geological layers
are comprised of semi-permeable soils. As a result, the river appears to have surface outflows only
for a short time after intense rainfall (Latinopoulos, 2001; Sevastas et al., 2017a, 2017b).
14
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1. Boundaries of the Upper Anthemountas basin and the aquifer under study, along
with the location of the operating wells per water use
3.
HYDROLOGICAL MODELING
For the purposes of the present study, a hydrological model previously developed by Sevastas et al.,
(2017a) was adopted and kept intact. In short, the vital input data used in this model are classified
into four major categories: i) topography (elevation), ii) land cover, iii) soil, and iv) climate data.
Specifically, a topographic map was created by digitizing contours from twenty three connected
Hellenic Military Geographical Service (HMGS) map sheets that cover the entire basin, with a scale
of 1:5000. The map was then transformed into a Digital Elevation Model (DEM) in order to delineate
the watershed. Multiple field inspections were performed in the study area so as to update the
available CORINE2000 land use map and produce a more accurate land cover status of the reference
area. A soil map was produced by collecting and analyzing thirty two soil samples from all over the
study area. Figure 2 depicts all input spatial layers imported to the model. In addition, a ten year
weather dataset (2002 to 2011) was applied for the simulation, containing precipitation and
temperature values, obtained from the National Agricultural Research Foundation (NAGREF)
climate station, which is located 15 kilometers away from the center of the basin. An in-depth
description regarding all the aforementioned essential input data is fully presented in Sevastas et al.
(2017a).
The model was run for a 10-year period, from 01/01/2002 to 31/12/2011, with a 2-year warm up
period (years 2002 and 2003) in order to define the initial conditions. Model outputs concerning
precipitation, evapotranspiration, recharge and surface runoff, were obtained on a monthly step for
eight years (2004 to 2011) and are presented in Figure 3. According to this figure, poor values of
surface runoff were generated. However, this is consistent with the fact that surface outflows in the
15
Water resources management and contamination control
basin emerge only for a short period of time and, mainly, after intense rainfall events. It should be
mentioned that the recharge values estimated were introduced as inputs to the groundwater model.
Figure 2: Input layers of the hydrological model adopted in this study (Sevastas et al., 2017a)
Figure 3: SWAT model results in Upper Anthemountas basin for years 2004 to 2011, in terms
of precipitation (PREC), evapotranspiration (ET), recharge and surface runoff (SURQ)
16
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4.
GROUNDWATER MODELING
4.1 Conceptual model development
A prerequisite for the development of the transient model is the development of the conceptual model
of the aquifer under study (Latinopoulos and Siarkos, 2014). In the present study, the conceptual
model formed by Sevastas et al. (2014) and improved in Sevastas et al. (2017b) was used, while
making certain modifications related to the nature of the problem under study (transient simulation).
These modifications were necessary since in the previous studies only steady-state simulations were
conducted, and they include:
Determination of the aquifer’s storativity which was based on values derived by previous research
conducted in the study area (Latinopoulos, 2001). According to this study, storativity values range
between 4.3*10-4 and 6.2*10-2. Since no reliable number of pumping tests exist and since they are not
properly distributed, thereby making it difficult to assign different storativity zones by applying the
Thiessen Polygon method (Sevastas et al., 2014), it was assumed that storativity: a) remains constant
throughout the whole study area and b) is equal to the mean value (3.1*10-2) of the aforementioned
value range.
Re-estimation of the equivalent pumping rate of irrigation wells, which is based on the total
amount of water used for irrigation purposes and the total number of irrigation wells existing in the
study area, since they operate only during the pumping/irrigation period (May-September, 5-month
irrigation period). With regard to the other well categories, i.e. domestic, livestock and industrial
wells, no re-calculation is required since it was considered that they operate during the whole year,
as it is in the case of the steady-state simulation. Furthermore, what is worth mentioning is that for
the calculation of the irrigation wells pumping rates, the total amount of irrigation water defined
during the calibration procedure of the steady-state model developed by Sevastas et al., (2017b), was
taken into consideration.
Re-calculation of the amount of water returning to the aquifer as irrigation return flow, based on the
total amount of irrigation water defined during the calibration procedure of the steady-state model
and assuming that 15% of irrigation water returns into the aquifer.
4.2 Transient model development
The groundwater flow simulation procedure involved the development of a transient model based on
the hydrological model described in Section 3 and a calibrated steady-state model developed in a
previous study (Sevastas et al., 2017b). As already mentioned, the outputs of the hydrological model
as far as the percolation values are concerned were introduced as inputs to the transient model to
obtain the aquifer recharge values resulting from precipitation. On the other hand, the values of
various parameters as they were set in the steady-state model (e.g. boundary conditions) or they were
adjusted during its calibration procedure (e.g. hydraulic conductivity), were assigned to the transient
model. With regard to other model parameters, such as storativity, irrigation wells pumping rates and
irrigation return flow, their values were based on the description made in Section 4.1. Furthermore,
the results of the steady-state model with regard to the hydraulic head distribution were introduced as
initial conditions to the transient model. Finally, the spatial discretization of the model was kept
identical to the steady-state one (Sevastas et al., 2017b), while an 8-year simulation period was
considered (2004-2011, equal to the simulation period of the hydrological model), which was divided
into 96 monthly stress periods. The purpose of this simulation is twofold: a) to get a generic image of
aquifer’s behaviour under certain recharge and discharge conditions, as well as of the temporal
variation of groundwater levels and b) to examine how the coupling between the hydrological and
the groundwater flow models works at an initial stage. Due to the aforementioned reasons, no
calibration of the transient model was performed.
The results of the transient simulation are expressed as water table contours maps and hydraulic head
evolution chart, along with mass water balances for the model domain. First of all, Figure 4 depicts
17
Water resources management and contamination control
the difference in hydraulic head distribution between the beginning (2004) and the end (2011) of the
simulation period. It is observed that in most parts of the region, with an exception of a part located
north-east of the study area (at a close distance to the eastern boundary), groundwater levels decrease
(hydraulic head at the beginning of simulation is higher than in the end).
Figure 4. Difference (in m) in hydraulic head distribution between the beginning (2004) and
the end (2011) of the simulation period.
Moreover, in Figure 5 the time variation of the hydraulic head (mean values) is illustrated. What is
worth mentioning is that hydraulic head follows a downward trend on annual base from the beginning
of the simulation (Jan-2004) until the end of the year 2009 (Dec-2009), and an upward trend from
this point until the end of the simulation period (Dec-2011). This is wholly attributed to the fact that
aquifer’s recharge values in years 2010 and 2011 are presented rather high in relation to previous
years as clearly displayed in Figure 3. Moreover, it should be noted that the largest hydraulic head
decline occurs during the irrigation period (May-September), when the irrigation wells are fully
operational leading to substantial increase of aquifer discharge.
Finally, Figure 6 shows the monthly distribution of the mean values of the water balance components
of the Upper Anthemountas aquifer. In this figure, the term “Recharge” refers to the water inflow into
the aquifer system, while “CHB” (Constant Head Boundaries) and “Wells” correspond to the outflow
from the system. Inflow to the system is also observed through the eastern aquifer boundary, but in
rather low quantities that cannot be depicted in the diagram. The main conclusion stemming from this
figure is that the water outflow is higher than the water inflow during the pumping season (MaySeptember), whereas the reverse occurs during the non-pumping season (October-April).
5. SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
After the development and application of the hydrological and groundwater flow models, as well as
their coupling procedure, a sensitivity analysis in the case of the transient groundwater flow model
was performed. The analysis aims to investigate the influence of the model’s input parameters upon
the results of the model, i.e. hydraulic head distribution, and identify those parameters that are most
sensitive and should be taken seriously into account during a future model calibration procedure. The
model parameters that were considered during the sensitivity analysis were hydraulic conductivity,
storativity, irrigation wells pumping rates, and boundary conditions, omitting aquifer’s recharge since
it derives from the hydrological model. The procedure was implemented by modifying only one input
18
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
parameter at a time while keeping the others constant (Don et al. 2005; Siarkos and Latinopoulos,
2016).
Figure 5. Time variation of hydraulic head (mean values) in the study area.
Figure 6. Monthly distribution of the water balance components (mean values) of the aquifer
under study.
Figure 7 presents the influence of the model parameters examined through the sensitivity analyis on
the hydraulic head (mean value) at the end of the simulation period (2011). The whole procedure
includes the estimation of the hydraulic head variation due to the modification of the parameters
examined for ±5, ±10, ±15 and ±20%. Based on Figure 7, the parameter of major influence on the
hydraulic head is the eastern boundary of the aquifer. With regard to the other parameters, pumping
rates of irrigation wells has remarkable influence on the hydraulic head values, while storativity is
19
Water resources management and contamination control
the parameter which is characterized by the smallest effect. Finally, it should be noted that increase
of the hydraulic head values assigned to both aquifer boundaries, as well as of the aquifer storativity,
results in groundwater levels increase in the study area. Higher increase is observed in the case of
modifying aquifer boundaries. On the contrary, increase of aquifer’s hydraulic conductivity and
irrigation wells pumping rates leads to hydraulic head decline.
Figure 7. Influence of the various model parameters (S - storativity, k - hydraulic
conductivity, EB - Eastern Boundary, WB - Western Boundary, Q - pumping rates) on the
hydraulic head (mean values) at the end of the simulation period (2011).
6.
CONCLUSIONS
In the present study, surface water-groundwater interactions in the Upper Anthemountas basin were
investigated through the development of an integrated modeling system consisting of a hydrological
and a groundwater flow model. In the first case, a hydrological model developed in a previous study
was adopted, while, in the second case, a transient groundwater flow model, based on a previously
developed steady-state model, was built. The two models were applied for a 8-year time period (20042011), while their connection was established through the introduction of the hydrological model
outputs, in terms of aquifer recharge, as inputs to the groundwater model. Finally, a sensitivity
analysis in the case of the groundwater model was carried out as an initial stage for a future model
calibration.
Regarding the results of the hydrological processes simulation, poor values of surface runoff were
produced, which is consistent with the fact that surface outflows in the basin emerge only for a short
period of time. Moreover, high recharge values were observed beyond the year 2010 in relation to
previous years, a fact which greatly affects the results of the groundwater flow model. Concerning
the groundwater model, the results indicate that, in general, groundwater levels decrease over time in
the study area mainly due to groundwater abstraction for irrigation purposes. The major decline of
hydraulic head is observed during the irrigation period (May-September), when irrigation wells start
operating. Finally, as far as the sensitivity analysis is concerned, results reveal that aquifer’s eastern
boundary is the most sensitive parameter considerably affecting the hydraulic head values in the study
area. Irrigation wells pumping rates is the second most sensitive parameter, while storativity appears
to have minimum influence on the model.
20
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
For future research, calibration of both the hydrological and the groundwater flow models has to be
conducted in order to improve the integrated modeling system and develop a reliable projection and
management tool for the area under study. In this case and as far as the groundwater flow model is
concerned, great caution regarding the definition of the aquifer’s boundary conditions and more
specifically the determination of the hydraulic head values assigned to them has to be given, since
they greatly affect model results.
References
1. Barthel R. (2006) ‘Common problematic aspects of coupling hydrological models with
groundwater flow models on the river catchment scale’, Advances in Geosciences, Vol. 9, pp.
63-71.
2. Carrera J., J.J. Hidalgo, L.J. Slooten and E. Vázquez-Suñé (2010) ‘Computational and conceptual
issues in the calibration of seawater intrusion models’, Hydrogeology Journal, Vol. 18, pp. 131145.
3. Cho J., V.A. Barone and S. Mostaghimi (2009) ‘Simulation of land use impacts on groundwater
levels and streamflow in a Virginia watershed’, Agricultural Water Management, Vol. 96, pp.
1-11.
4. Don N.C., H. Araki, H. Yamanishi and K. Koga (2005) ‘Simulation of groundwater flow and
environmental effects resulting from pumping’, Environmental Geology, Vol. 47, pp. 361-374.
5. Kim N.W., I.M. Chung, Y.S. Won and J.G. Arnold (2008) ‘Development and application of the
integrated SWAT – MODFLOW model’, Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 356, pp. 1-16.
6. Latinopoulos D. and I. Siarkos (2014) ‘Modelling the groundwater flow to assess the long-term
economic cost of irrigation water: application in the Moudania basin, Greece’, In: Giannino M.
(ed.), Drinking Water and Water Management: New Research, Nova Publishers, New York,
pp. 249-274.
7. Latinopoulos P. (2001) ‘Investigation and exploitation of the water resources in the basin of
Upper Anthemountas (in Greek)’, Research Project, Final Report prepared for: Municipality of
Anthemountas, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece.
8. McDonald M.G. and A.W. Harbaugh (1988) ‘A modular three-dimensional finite-difference
ground-water flow model’, U.S. Geological Survey, Techniques of Water-Resources
Investigation, Book 6, Reston, VA, 586 pp.
9. Sevastas S., I. Siarkos, N. Theodossiou and I. Ifadis (2014) ‘Simulating groundwater flow in
Upper Anthemountas basin in Chalkidiki applying Modflow and Geographic Information
System’, Proc. of Int. Conf. 10th International Hydrogeological Congress, Thessaloniki,
Greece, 8-10 October, 2010.
10. Sevastas S., I. Siarkos, N. Theodossiou, I. Ifadis and K. Kaffas (2017a) ‘Comparing hydrological
models built upon open access and/or measured data in a GIS environment’, Proc. of Int. Conf.
6th International CEMEPE & SECOTOX Conference, Thessaloniki, Greece, 25-30 June,
2017.
11. Sevastas S., I. Siarkos, N. Theodossiou and I. Ifadis (2017b) ‘Establishing wellhead protection
areas and managing point and non-point pollution sources to support groundwater protection in
the aquifer of Upper Anthemountas, Greece’, Water Utility Journal, Vol. 16, pp. 81-95.
12. Shanafield M., P.G. Cook, P. Brunner, J. McCallum and C.T. Simmons (2012) ‘Aquifer response
to surface water transience in disconnected streams’, Water Resources Research, Vol. 48,
W11510.
21
Water resources management and contamination control
13. Siarkos I. and P. Latinopoulos (2016) ‘Modeling seawater intrusion in overexploited aquifers in
the absence of sufficient data: application to the aquifer of Nea Moudania, northern Greece’,
Hydrogeology Journal, Vol. 24(8), pp. 2123-2141.
14. Simpson S.C., T. Meixner and J.F. Hogan (2013) ‘The role of flood size and duration on
streamflow and riparian groundwater composition in a semi-arid basin’, Journal of Hydrology,
Vol. 488, pp. 126-135.
15. Sophocleous M. (2002) ‘Interactions between groundwater and surface water: the state of the
science’, Hydrogeology Journal, Vol. 10, pp. 52-67.
16. Sophocleous M. and S.P. Perkins (2000) ‘Methodology and application of combined watershed
and ground-water models in Kansas’, Journal of Hydrology, Vol. 236, pp. 185-201.
17. Spanoudaki K., A. Nanou, A.I. Stamou, G. Christodoulou, T. Sparks, B. Bockelmann and R.A.
Falconer (2005) ‘Integrated surface water-groundwater modelling’, Global NEST, Vol. 7(3), pp.
281-295.
18. Winchell M., R. Srinivasan, M. Di Luzio and M. Arnold (2013) ‘ArcSWAT interface for
SWAT2012: User’s guide’, Texas Agrilife Research and USDA Agricultural Research Service,
Temple, Texas 76502, USA.
19. Wu B., Y. Zheng, Y. Tian, X. Wu, F. Han, J. Liu and C. Zheng (2014) ‘Systematic assessment of
the uncertainty in integrated surface water-groundwater modeling based on the probabilistic
collocation method’, Water Resources Research, Vol. 50, pp. 5848-5865.
20. Wu B., Y. Zheng, X. Wu, Y. Tian, F. Han, J. Liu and C. Zheng (2015) ‘Optimizing water
resources management in large river basins with integrated surface water-groundwater modeling:
A surrogate-based approach’, Water Resources Research, Vol. 51, pp. 2153-2173.
22
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
COMPARISON OF STOCHASTIC AND MACHINE LEARNING
MODELS IN STREAMFLOW FORECASTING
D. Botsisa*, P. Latinopoulosa and K. Diamantarasb
a
School of Civil Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki,
Macedonia, Greece,
b
Information Technology Department, A.T.E.I. of Thessaloniki, GR-57400 Sindos, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: jimbotsis@civil.auth.gr, tel : +306973822431
Abstract
One of the fundamental issues of hydrology is the rainfall-runoff relationship and streamflow
forecasting that plays an important role in water balance. Up-to-date a large number of models have
been developed to simulate the relationship of rainfall-runoff and forecasting the streamflow. In the
present study a comparison between stochastic and machine learning methods is performed with
respect to their forecasting capabilities and their performance and reliability in short term streamflow
forecasting is evaluated. For this purpose, five popular methods were employed, two stochastic
methods and three machine learning models, specifically Auto Regressive Moving Average
(ARMA), Auto Regressive Integrated Moving Average (ARIMA), Multilayer Feed-Forward
Artificial Neural Network (MFNN), Bayesian Neural Networks (BNN) and Ensemble methods
(Boosting). The daily rainfall and streamflow data of two mountainous watersheds were used as a
case study for developing the rainfall-runoff models. The performance and reliability of the models
were evaluated through three different criteria: correlation coefficient, root mean square error and
mean absolute error. Each criterion is represented by an efficiency indicator, estimated from the
comparison of predicted values and the measured targets that have been initially placed. The objective
of this paper is to illustrate the effectiveness of stochastic and machine learning models in streamflow
forecasting. Our results show that both the stochastic and machine learning models can successfully
approximate the rainfall-runoff relationship and efficiently estimate the resulting streamflow. The
results from the individual methods do not differ dramatically and by and large all models have good
performance and provide accurate predictions, but the best performing model is BNN.
Keywords: streamflow forecasting; ARMA; ARIMA; artificial neural networks, Bayesian neural
networks; boosting
1.
INTRODUCTION
Streamflow forecasting is very significant for watershed management. Planning and development of
many water management applications require reliable streamflow predictions. Water management
includes treatment and supply of drinking water, flood control works, water resources management,
hydropower generation, construction of complex hydraulic works, optimal environmental operations,
etc (Wang et al., 2009; Guo et al., 2011; Huang et al, 2014). A widespread technique used by many
researchers for hydrologic time-series modeling is stochastic hydrology, including autoregressive
moving average (ARMA) and autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) models (Valipour
et al., 2012, 2013). The key feature of these models is the assumed linearity of the relationship
between inputs and outputs. However, in real terms the relationship between rainfall and runoff is
nonlinear and, in addition, has a large degree of uncertainty.
23
Water resources management and contamination control
Machine learning methods are an alternative and complementary set of techniques to traditional
models. Since the early nineties extensive research has been devoted in the science of hydrology to
investigating the potential of Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) as computational tools that simulate
the nonlinear relationship of complex hydrological phenomena. Artificial neural networks have been
successfully used in hydrology-related areas, such as streamflow forecasting, groundwater modeling,
watershed management and rainfall-runoff simulation (ASCE Task Committee, 2000). In the last
decades many non-linear data-driven models, such as multilayer feed-forward Artificial Neural
Network (MFNN) (Zealand et al., 1999; Sahoo and Ray, 2006; Botsis and Latinopoulos, 2010; Botsis
et al., 2011), Bayesian Neural Networks (BNN) (Khan and Coulibaly, 2006; Humphrey et al., 2016),
and Ensemble methods (Boosting) (Erdal and Karakurt, 2012), have been proposed for rainfall-runoff
simulation and streamflow forecasting.
The present study aims to compare ΑRΜΑ and ARIMA models with machine learning methods,
based on streamflow forecasting. The autoregressive and machine learning models were programmed
in MATLAB software environment. The models were applied on data from two mountainous
catchments in Greece: 1) Venetikos river watershed with total area 491.9 m2 and 2) Kalarrytikos river
watershed with total area 103.7 m2.
2.
SIMULATION MODELS
2.1 ARMA and ARIMA models
The ARMA(p,q) is one of the most common methods in time series analysis and the assumed model
follows equation (1).
𝑦𝑡 = ∑𝑝𝑖=1 𝜑𝑖 ∙ 𝑦𝑡−𝑖 − ∑𝑞𝑖=1 𝜃𝑖 ∙ 𝜀𝑡−𝑖 + 𝜀𝑡
(1)
where y is the output (streamflow) at time t, p is the order of autoregressive model, q is the order of
moving average model, φ is the vector of autoregressive parameters, θ is the vector of moving average
parameters and εt is white noise (Wei, 2006). The ARIMA(p,d,q) model is defined by the expression
(2).
𝑦𝑡 = ∑𝑝𝑖=1 𝜑𝑖 ∙ 𝑦𝑡−𝑖 + ∑𝑑𝑖=1 𝛾𝑖 ∙ 𝑥𝑡−𝑖 − ∑𝑞𝑖=1 𝜃𝑖 ∙ 𝜀𝑡−𝑖 + 𝜉𝑡
(2)
where d is the differentiation order in the regular or nonregular part of the stationary series and γi is
the weight parameter of the exogenous input xt (rainfall). It should be noted that in equation (2) when
d = 0, the ARIMA model becomes ARMA (Wei, 2006).
2.2 Artificial Neural Networks
The most common neural network used in hydrology applications is the multilayer feed-forward
network, trained with the back-propagation algorithm (ASCE Task Committee, 2000). The backpropagation algorithm, introduced by Rumelhart et al (1986), is essentially a gradient-descent
technique that minimizes the network error function (Haykin, 1999, ASCE Task Committee, 2000).
The neural network employed in this investigation is the multilayer feed-forward model, trained with
back-propagation. For streamflow forecasting, a network with one hidden layer was trained. More
specifically, the networks were designed with thirteen inputs for the first watershed and seven inputs
for the second watershed, h neurons in the hidden layer (testing 2, 3, 4, 7, 8, 10, 20 and 50 neurons)
and one neuron in the output layer (the architecture of the neural network is shown in Figure 1).
24
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
(b)
(a)
Figure 1. (a) Architecture of Multilayer Feed-forward Neural Network (MFNN) for
Ventetikos watershed and (b) architecture of Bayesian Neural Network (BNN) for
Kalarrytikos watershed.
The Levenberg-Marquardt version of Back-Propagation was selected as the learning algorithm,
because it is faster and more reliable than any other back-propagation flavors (Jeong and Kim, 2005).
The computation of the local gradient for each neuron of the neural network requires knowledge of
the derivative of the transfer function associated with that neuron. For this derivative to exist, the
function should be continuous. In basic terms, differentiability is the only requirement that a transfer
function has to satisfy (Haykin, 1999). The transfer function should be differentiable, as most training
algorithms in multilayer networks are based on optimization methods that use first- and second-order
derivatives. In this study the hyperbolic tangent function (expression 3) is used, which is continuous,
differentiable, and monotonically increasing.
1−𝑒 −𝑥
𝑔(𝑥) = 1+𝑒 −𝑥
(3)
The output layer provides a linear activation function, so the output range is between -∞ and ∞. For
the early stopping of the training process the cross validation method was used, which sets an
acceptable error level for training and stops training when the mean square error reaches a minimum
in the validation phase.
2.3 Bayesian Neural Networks
When the neural network learning process is implemented in the Bayesian framework, the weights w
of the neural network are considered random variables (Foresee and Hagan, 1997). According to
Bayes theorem, the posterior probability distribution p(w│D) conditioned on the data set D is given
by the expression 4.
𝑝(𝑤|𝐷) =
𝑝(𝐷|𝑤)𝑝(𝑤)
(4)
𝑝(𝐷)
where p(D│w) is the data likelihood function, p(w) is the prior weight distribution, p(D) is a
normalizing factor known as the marginal distribution, which ensures that the total probability is
equal to unity (Bishop, 2005). The Bayesian Neural Network (BNN) employed here is a two-layer
feed-forward network trained with the Bayesian regularization back-propagation algorithm. More
specifically the networks were designed with thirteen inputs for the first watershed and seven inputs
for the second watershed, h neurons in the hidden layer (testing 2, 3, 4, 7, 8, 10, 20 and 50 neurons)
25
Water resources management and contamination control
and one neuron in the output layer (see Figure 1). The activation function used is the hyperbolic
tangent.
2.4 Boosting algorithm
Boosting algorithms for regression (Freund, 1995; Freund and Schapire, 1995) can reduce the error
rate, when a small number of big errors contribute a significant part of the mean squared error.
Avnimelech and Intrator (1999) proposed a boosting algorithm for forecasting optimization and in
this study one of the Boosting algorithms proposed by Avnimelech and Intrator was used.
The proposed boosting algorithm consists of three estimators trained in a hierarchical fashion. All
learners have the same BNN architecture described in Figure 1 with variable number of neurons in
the hidden layer. The first learner (L1) is trained and then simulated with the original data set (I,T).
Next, the errors (symbolized with “err”), which are the absolute value of differences between targets
T and outputs values y, were calculated. Then the γ parameter is used for error evaluation and for
forming the training data sets of the next two learners. After experimental tests it was found that the
optimum value of γ is 0.01.
Τhe next stage separates small and large errors based on the parameter γ. In particular, errors that are
larger than γ (errors> γ) are classified as “bad” while the errors that are smaller or equal to γ (errors≤γ)
are classified as “good”. The training data set of the second learner (L2) comprises 50% of patterns
whose errors are larger than γ (classified as “bad”) and the remaining 50% consists of patterns whose
errors are smaller or equal than γ (classified as “good”). The input data set of second learner are
symbolized with I2 and the corresponding target data set with T2.
The second learner (L2) was trained and simulated with the data set I2, T2 and the final output was
symbolized with y2. The errors (symbolized with “err2”) are the absolute values of differences
between targets T and outputs values y2. In the next stage the inputs and the targets of the third learner
are configured by selecting patterns that satisfy the following conditions: (1) the absolute value of the
error of the first learner (err) is larger than γ and the absolute value of the error of the second learner
(err2) is smaller or equal than γ, or (2) the reverse, that is the absolute value of the error of the first
learner (err) is smaller or equal than γ and the absolute value of the error of the second learner (err2)
is larger than γ or (3) the absolute value of the error of the first learner (err) is larger than γ and the
absolute value of the error of the second learner (err2) is larger than γ and the product of errors
(err*err2) is smaller than zero. The input data set of the third learner was symbolized with I3 and the
corresponding target data set with T3 and the final output is the median of the three sequential learner
outputs (y, y1, y3). Figure 2 shows the overall model and the flow diagram of the simulation process
of Boosting algorithm. The proposed boosting algorithm was tested using sixteen different learner
configurations (see Table 3)
Figure 2. Architecture of Boosting algorithm.
26
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3. EVALUATION OF PERFORMANCE
Four different evaluation criteria were used to measure the performance and reliability of the models.
Each criterion is represented by an efficiency indicator, estimated from the comparison of predicted
values and the measured targets.
The root mean square error (RMSE) is a measure of the differences between values predicted by a
model or an estimator and the values actually observed (expression 5).
1
2
𝑅𝑀𝑆𝐸 = √𝑁 ∑𝑁
𝑖=1(𝑥𝑖 − 𝑦𝑖 )
(5)
The mean absolute error (MAE) describes the average magnitude of the errors, without considering
their direction, i.e. a linear term that expresses that all the differences (errors) are weighted equally
(Anctil et al., 2008). The average absolute error is the average of the absolute values of differences
between prediction and actual observation of the sample of all the data under consideration
(expression 6).
1
𝑀𝐴𝐸 = 𝑁 ∑𝑁
𝑖=1|𝑥𝑖 − 𝑦𝑖 |
(6)
The correlation coefficient (R-value) is a measure of the linear regression between the predicted
values and the targets of models (expression 7).
𝑅=
∑𝑁
𝑖=1(𝑥𝑖 −𝑥)(𝑦𝑖 −𝑦)
𝑁
√∑𝑁
𝑖=1(𝑥𝑖 −𝑥)√∑𝑖=1(𝑦𝑖 −𝑦)
(7)
Finally, the Nash–Sutcliffe (NSE) efficiency coefficient was employed to estimate the accuracy of
the models (expression 8).
𝑁𝑆𝐸 = 1 −
2
∑𝑁
𝑖=1(𝑥𝑖 −𝑦𝑖 )
2
∑𝑁
𝑖=1(𝑥𝑖 −𝑥̅ )
)
(8)
In all equations above N is the number of samples, xi and yi are the target and predicted values for
i=1,….,n, and x and y are the mean values of the target and predicted data set, respectively.
A better agreement between target and predicted values is expressed by an R-value as close to unity
as possible. At the same time, RMSE, MAE and NS values close to zero show that predictions from
the models are more precise.
4.
DATA PREPARATION
For the Venetikos river watershed there are four rain gauging stations and one river stage gauging
station, placed on a bridge (Trikomo) at the exit of the watershed. Time series of daily precipitation
data were obtained for each rain gauging station, while time series of daily discharges were obtained
from Trikomo gauging station for a time period from 1/10/1996-30/9/2010. For the Kalarrytikos river
watershed the precipitation data were obtained from two meteorological stations and the river stage
data were obtained from the gauging in the Kipina bridge. The period for the precipitation and river
stage record is 1/10/1995-30/9/2010.
For the machine learning models the input data is the precipitation at times t, t-1 and t-2 as well as
the streamflow at time t-1 (t corresponds to days). For ARMA and ARIMA the same step was
followed, with the large history t-i in some cases. In all models the target is the streamflow at time t.
27
Water resources management and contamination control
The data are normalized in the range 0 to +1 and a regression analysis was carried out with the
measured data. After training the models, their outputs were denormalized and their corresponding
denormalized predicted data were obtained. The values of evaluation criteria were calculated from
denormalized data.
For the ANN models the data are randomly divided into three sets: training, testing, and validation.
While 70% of the data are used for training, 15% are used for validation and the rest 15% are used
for testing. An important concept in BNN is that, since the evidence can be evaluated using the
training data, Bayesian methods are able to deal with the issue of model complexity, without the need
to use cross-validation method (separation of training, validation and testing data). The BNN
automatically embodies Occam’s razor that penalizes over complex models and for this reason is too
difficult to get overfitting (Bishop, 2005). However each model or learner for ANN, BNN and
Boosting algorithm was executed 10 times and the average root mean square error and average
correlation coefficient were calculated in order to avoid either a very good or a very bad simulation.
For the ARMA and ARIMA models the 70% of the data were used for training and the 30% of data
were used for testing.
5.
RESULTS
Numerical values of the RMSE, R, MAE and NSE performance indexes for the 5 different models
(ANN, BNN, Boosting algorithm, ARMA, ARIMA) are shown in Tables 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5. From the
simulation results of ANN (Table 1) it is easily noticed that the architectures 7–10–1 for Venetikos
river and 7–20–1 for Kalarrytikos river were superior to all others. Respectively, from the simulation
results of BNN (Table 2) it is concluded that the architecture with 50 neurons in the hidden layer for
both watersheds was the best. For the Boosting algorithm, the values of the evaluation criteria indicate
that the best model has 50 hidden neurons for first estimator, 35 hidden neurons for the second one
and 15 hidden neurons for the third one for both watersheds. Finally, the best stochastic models are
the ARMA(3,3) and ARIMA(3,3,2) for the Venetikos river and ARMA(2,3) and ARIMA(3,3,3) for
the Kalarrytikos river. By comparing the models with each other, it turns out that the best, for both
watersheds, is the BNN. However, it should be noted that all machine learning and stochastic models
responded fairly well to the simulations and the differences between them are very small.
Table 1: Indicators of ANN models performance
ANN
architecture
Venetikos (13 inputs units)
RMSE
R
MAE
Kalarrytikos (7 inputs units)
NSE
RMSE
R
MAE
NSE
13 or 7 – 2 -1
0.12322 0.96802 0.06174 0.93589 0.10018 0.92084 0.05277 0.84762
13 or 7 – 3 -1
0.13132 0.96303 0.06145 0.92536 0.09999 0.92123 0.05245 0.84818
13 or 7 – 4 -1
0.12355 0.96755 0.06094 0.93551 0.09916 0.92258 0.05151 0.85069
13 or 7 – 7 -1
0.12435 0.96800 0.06412 0.93446 0.09904 0.92265 0.05127 0.85104
13 or 7 – 8 -1
0.12287 0.96816 0.06301 0.93615 0.09854 0.92365 0.05140 0.85255
13 or 7 – 10 -1
0.12036 0.96927 0.06009 0.93880 0.09912 0.92303 0.05219 0.85081
13 or 7 – 20 -1
0.12854 0.96675 0.07018 0.92950 0.09847 0.92359 0.04982 0.85277
13 or 7 – 50 -1
0.12453 0.96751 0.06183 0.93435 0.09870 0.92412 0.05160 0.85200
28
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 2: Indicators of BNN models performance
BNN
architecture
Venetikos (13 inputs units)
RMSE
R
MAE
Kalarrytikos (7 inputs units)
NSE
RMSE
R
MAE
NSE
13 or 7 – 2 -1
0.11225 0.97305 0.05671 0.94680 0.09893 0.92272 0.05061 0.85141
13 or 7 – 3 -1
0.10994 0.97416 0.05583 0.94895 0.09798 0.92424 0.04994 0.85423
13 or 7 – 4 -1
0.09695 0.97567 0.05479 0.95191 0.09725 0.92543 0.04972 0.85641
13 or 7 – 7 -1
0.09914 0.97902 0.05197 0.95850 0.09430 0.93004 0.04853 0.86497
13 or 7 – 8 -1
0.09800 0.97953 0.05180 0.95947 0.09382 0.93077 0.04833 0.86634
13 or 7 – 10 -1
0.09379 0.98126 0.05017 0.96286 0.09164 0.93406 0.04759 0.87247
13 or 7 – 20 -1
0.08087 0.98610 0.04514 0.97241 0.08663 0.94130 0.04525 0.88605
13 or 7 – 50 -1
0.05690 0.99316 0.03382 0.98633 0.07465 0.95676 0.04024 0.91538
Table 3: Indicators of Boosting algorithm models performance
Neurons
in
Venetikos (13 inputs units)
Kalarrytikos (7 inputs units)
hidden layer
L1
L2
L3
RMSE
R
MAE
NSE
2
4
8
0.10373 0.97703 0.05339 0.95459 0.09637 0.92683 0.04921 0.85899
3
7
12
0.09630 0.98024 0.05074 0.96086 0.09391 0.93067 0.04798 0.86609
4
9
15
0.09186 0.98204 0.04929 0.96438 0.09222 0.93322 0.04736 0.87087
5
10
7
0.09657 0.98013 0.05099 0.96064 0.09434 0.92999 0.04831 0.86487
7
3
9
0.09875 0.97921 0.05185 0.95884 0.09475 0.92937 0.04831 0.86369
7
12
22
0.08464 0.98477 0.04597 0.96976 0.09104 0.93495 0.04688 0.87411
8
4
2
0.10340 0.97718 0.05356 0.95487 0.09635 0.92688 0.04946 0.85905
8
11
6
0.09441 0.98102 0.05034 0.96238 0.09285 0.93227 0.04781 0.86909
10
6
3
0.09885 0.97917 0.05200 0.95875 0.09437 0.92995 0.04836 0.86477
12
5
10
0.09205 0.98196 0.04956 0.96424 0.09249 0.93282 0.04769 0.87010
14
7
5
0.09370 0.98131 0.04985 0.96294 0.09287 0.93223 0.04770 0.86903
15
25
40
0.06893 0.98993 0.03894 0.97995 0.08674 0.94111 0.04474 0.88565
16
10
8
0.08830 0.98342 0.04799 0.96710 0.09111 0.93486 0.04681 0.87395
20
10
30
0.07728 0.98732 0.04242 0.97479 0.08597 0.94223 0.04469 0.88776
25
30
15
0.07258 0.98882 0.04124 0.97775 0.08435 0.94444 0.04394 0.89195
50
35
15
0.06018 0.99234 0.03599 0.98470 0.08088 0.94904 0.04154 0.90064
29
RMSE
R
MAE
NSE
Water resources management and contamination control
ARMA(p,q)
(1,1)
(1,2)
(1,3)
(2,1)
(2,2)
(2,3)
(3,1)
(3,2)
(3,3)
ARIMA(p,d,q)
(1,1,1)
(1,1,2)
(1,1,3)
(1,2,1)
(1,2,2)
(1,2,3)
(1,3,1)
(1,3,2)
(1,3,3)
(2,1,1)
(2,1,2)
(2,1,3)
(2,2,1)
(2,2,2)
(2,2,3)
(2,3,1)
(2,3,2)
(2,3,3)
(3,1,1)
(3,1,2)
(3,1,3)
(3,2,1)
(3,2,2)
(3,2,3)
(3,3,1)
(3,3,2)
(3,3,3)
Table 4: Indicators of ARMA models performance
Venetikos
Kalarrytikos
RMSE R
MAE
NSE
RMSE R
0.17024 0.93846 0.07128 0.87769 0.12764 0.87267
0.16836 0.93925 0.07272 0.88038 0.12446 0.87675
0.16730 0.93974 0.07361 0.88188 0.12402 0.87715
0.17008 0.93866 0.07067 0.87791 0.12781 0.87350
0.16606 0.94031 0.07434 0.88363 0.12351 0.87754
0.16604 0.94031 0.07434 0.88365 0.12319 0.87781
0.16608 0.94029 0.07435 0.88359 0.12363 0.87725
0.16604 0.94030 0.07433 0.88365 0.12331 0.87776
0.16603 0.94032 0.07437 0.88366 0.12349 0.87755
Table 5: Indicators of ARIMA models performance
Venetikos
Kalarrytikos
RMSE R
MAE
NSE
RMSE R
0.16580 0.94119 0.07188 0.88399 0.12475 0.87845
0.16531 0.94134 0.07252 0.88468 0.12302 0.88029
0.16469 0.94159 0.07340 0.88553 0.12275 0.88043
0.16543 0.94132 0.07221 0.88451 0.12455 0.87879
0.16518 0.94139 0.07252 0.88485 0.12301 0.88031
0.16466 0.94160 0.07340 0.88558 0.12270 0.88040
0.16524 0.94141 0.07241 0.88477 0.12447 0.87889
0.16484 0.94154 0.07299 0.88532 0.12285 0.88051
0.16449 0.94169 0.07360 0.88581 0.12256 0.88060
0.16566 0.94120 0.07223 0.88419 0.12388 0.87699
0.16477 0.94147 0.07316 0.88542 0.12286 0.88032
0.16451 0.94165 0.07346 0.88578 0.12275 0.88042
0.16541 0.94134 0.07213 0.88453 0.12437 0.87951
0.16335 0.94224 0.07438 0.88740 0.12194 0.88066
0.16334 0.94225 0.07437 0.88741 0.12165 0.88095
0.16518 0.94145 0.07234 0.88485 0.12219 0.87984
0.16320 0.94236 0.07446 0.88759 0.12184 0.88089
0.16319 0.94237 0.07449 0.88761 0.12162 0.88102
0.16496 0.94138 0.07296 0.88516 0.12312 0.88021
0.16464 0.94151 0.07340 0.88560 0.12275 0.88019
0.16434 0.94171 0.07366 0.88602 0.12264 0.88037
0.16327 0.94231 0.07434 0.88750 0.12196 0.88060
0.16327 0.94230 0.07435 0.88750 0.12194 0.88065
0.16327 0.94230 0.07434 0.88750 0.12162 0.88099
0.16317 0.94240 0.07449 0.88763 0.12193 0.88066
0.16317 0.94239 0.07449 0.88764 0.12166 0.88107
0.16318 0.94237 0.07452 0.88763 0.12162 0.88104
MAE
0.05680
0.05844
0.05902
0.05596
0.05998
0.06083
0.06009
0.06045
0.06009
MAE
0.05505
0.05655
0.05689
0.05499
0.05656
0.05728
0.05522
0.05680
0.05753
0.05944
0.05671
0.05690
0.05489
0.05967
0.06025
0.06036
0.05962
0.06022
0.05629
0.05721
0.05723
0.05967
0.05969
0.06023
0.05966
0.06009
0.06025
NSE
0.75263
0.76480
0.76647
0.75198
0.76838
0.76957
0.76794
0.76914
0.76846
NSE
0.76373
0.77024
0.77121
0.76449
0.77025
0.77143
0.76476
0.77084
0.77195
0.76699
0.77081
0.77122
0.76513
0.77423
0.77532
0.77331
0.77462
0.77542
0.76985
0.77124
0.77164
0.77417
0.77424
0.77543
0.77428
0.77526
0.77542
The comparison of the prediction values against the observed data is presented in Figure 3 for
Venetikos river and in Figure 4 for Kalarrytikos river. The targets of the model are represented with
blue continues line and the prediction values of models are represented with different lines (colors
and shape). More specifically the ANN model is represented with red dashed line, the BNN model
30
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
with green dashed-dotted line, the Boosting model with purple dashed (large dashes) line, the ARMA
model with light blue dashed (small dashes) line and the ARIMA model with orange dotted line. The
very good performance of all models in both watersheds and for both the regular runoff and peak
flows is evident from these figures. Moreover, the models successfully predicted the extreme peak
streamflows which appeared at the time series. The successful prediction of extreme events is very
important for the streamflow prediction because they are the cause of floods.
Figure 3. Predicted streamflow compared with corresponding flows in Venetikos river.
Figure 4. Predicted streamflow compared with corresponding flows in Kalarrytikos river.
6.
CONCLUSIONS
In this study the application of three machine learning and two stochastic models for the streamflow
prediction in two mountainous watersheds was investigated. Results show that the BNN model
performed better than the other models, yet with very small differences. It is clear from the diagrams
of Figures 3 and 4 that the results of all models were satisfactory and the predicted values in all cases
31
Water resources management and contamination control
were very close to the observed data. Therefore, the most important conclusion that emerges from
this study is that there is no model that stands out for its very good or very poor prediction.
Consequently, both machine learning and stochastic models can be useful tools in simulating the
relationship of rainfall-runoff and in predicting watershed discharge.
The generalization capability of the machine learning and stochastic models is the biggest open
question in streamflow forecasting problem. Also it has been realized that the development of
effective forecasting models requires an exemplary combination of well measured data and input
parameters, which describe very well the variables of physical phenomena. In several cases, the
available data, combined with the particularities of each prediction method, can differentiate the
hierarchical classification of the models based on their performance.
References
1. Anctil, F., N. Lauzon and M. Filion (2008) ‘Added gains of soil moisture content observations
for streamflow predictions using neural networks’, Journal of Hydrology, Vol 359, p.p. 225234.
2. ASCE Task Committee (2000) ‘Artificial neural network in hydrology’, Journal of Hydrologic
Engineering, Vol 5 (2), pp. 124-144.
3. Avnimelech R. and N. Intrator, ‘Boosting regression estimators’, Neural Computation, Vol
11(2), p.p. 499-520, MIT Press.
4. Bishop C.M. (2005) ‘Neural networks for pattern recognition’, Clarendon Press, Oxford
University Press.
5. Botsis D. and P. Latinopoulos (2010) ‘Rainfall-runoff modeling and peak flow forecasting using
hydrologic and neural network modeling’. Proc. of Int. Conf. Protection and Restoration of the
Environment X, Corfu, Greece, 2010.
6. Botsis D., P. Latinopoulos and K. Diamantaras (2011) ‘Rainfall-runoff modeling using support
vector regression and artificial neural networks’. Proc. of 12th Int. Conf. on environmantal science
and technology (CEST2011), Rhodes, Greece, 2011.
7. Erdal H.I. and O. Karakurt (2012) ‘Advancing monthly streamflow prediction accuracy of CART
models using ensemble learning paradigms’, Journal of Hydrology, Vol 477, pp. 119-128.
8. Foresee, F.D. and M.T. Hagan (1997) ‘Gauss-Newton approximation to Bayesian learning’, in
Proc. IEEE International Conference on Neural Networks, pp. 1930-1935.
9. Guo J., J. Zhou, H. Qin, Q. Zou and Q. Li (2011) ‘Monthly streamflow forecasting based on
improved support vector machine model’, Expert Systems with Applications, Vol 38 (10), pp.
13073-13081.
10. Haykin S. (1999) ‘Neural Networks: A Comprehensive Foundation’, Macmillan, New York.
11. Huang S., J. Chang, Q. Huang and Y. Chen (2014) ‘Monthly streamflow prediction using
modified EMD-based support vector machine’, Journal of Hydrology, Vol 511, pp. 764-775.
12. Humphrey G.B., M.S. Gibbs, G.C. Dandy and H.R. Maier (2016) ‘A hybrid approach to monthly
streamflow forecasting: Integrating hydrological model outputs into a Bayesian artificial neural
network’, Journal of Hydrology, Vol 540, pp. 623-640.
13. Jeong, D. and Y. Kim (2005) ‘Rainfall-runoff models using artificial neural networks for
ensemble streamflow prediction’, Hydrological Processes, Vol 19, p.p. 3819–3835.
14. Khan M.S. and P. Coulibaly (2006) ‘Bayesian neural network for rainfall-runoff modeling’,
Water resources research, Vol 42 (7), W07409 doi:10.1029/2005WR003971.
32
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
15. Rumelhart D.E., G.E. Hinton and Williams R.J. (1986) ‘Learning internal representation by error
propagation. Parallel distributed processing: Explorations in the microstructure of cognition’,
Rumelhart D.E. and J.L. McClelland, eds., Vol. 1, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass., 318–362.
16. Sahoo G.B. and C. Ray (2006) ‘Flow forecasting for a Hawaii stream using rating curves and
neural networks’, Journal of Hydrology, Vol 317, pp. 63-80.
17. Valipour, M., M.E. Banihabib and S.M.R. Behbahani (2012) ‘Parameters estimate of
autoregressive moving average and autoregressive integrated moving average models and
compare their ability for inflow forecasting’, Journal of Mathematics and Statistics, Vol 8, pp.
330-338.
18. Valipour, M., M.E. Banihabib and S.M.R. Behbahani (2013) ‘Comparison of the ARMA,
ARIMA, and the autoregressive artificial neural network models in forecasting the monthly
inflow of Dez dam reservoir’, Journal of Hydrology, Vol 476, pp. 433–441.
19. Wang W.C., K.W. Chau, C.T. Cheng and L. Qiu (2009) ‘A comparison of performance of several
artificial intelligence methods for forecasting monthly discharge time series’, Journal of
Hydrology, Vol 374(3-4), pp. 294-306.
20. Wei W.W.S. (2006) ‘Time Series Analysis, Univariate and Multivariate Methods’, second
edition, Pearson Addison Wesley.
21. Zealand C.M., D.H. Burn and S.P. Simonovic, (1999) ‘Short term streamflow forecasting using
artificial neural networks’, Journal of Hydrology, Vol 214, pp. 32-48.
33
Water resources management and contamination control
APPLICATION OF MODIFIED METAHEURISTIC METHODS TO
IDENTIFY CRITICAL AREAS IN WATER SUPPLY NETWORKS
D. Karakatsanis*, N. Theodossiou
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Aristotle
University of Thessaloniki, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*Corresponding author: E-mail: dkarakat@civil.auth.gr, Tel +30 2310995660
Abstract
Recently, metaheuristic methods have actively been used to minimize the cost of water supply
networks. The algorithms of these methods search for optimal solutions using local searching
strategies, thus skipping the exhaustive search analysis. Brute-force searching methods are also used
and are typical for limited system sizes. However, brute-force is not commonly used in real-world
problems due to time limitations and scaling problems. though metaheuristic search is more common
for these case, they also have some limitations. Sufficiently large water supply networks or very small
size of the mesh are typical cases that make computational time very long so that these methods never
find the optimal solution. In this paper we try to overcome these limitations by applying a modified
metaheuristic method in order to identify critical clusters of water pipe networks.
Keywords: metaheuristic; water supply networks; harmony search algorithm; pipe networks; water
management
1.
INTRODUCTION
In recent years, many metaheuristic methods have been used to optimize hydraulic networks. The
vast majority of these methods implement novel bio-inspired strategies and use local searching in
order to find optimal solutions (minimize cost, maximize benefit etc). Water supply networks must
be computed in each step of these algorithms, thus leading to critical computational limitations as the
network size scales up. An alternative approach can be achieved by using metaheuristic methods in
order to find network communities. This way, the original problem is reduced to a community
detection problem. The members of each community are characterized by some similar properties
even ifthey are not directly connected with each other. For example, the Harmony Search Algorithm
can be modified to detect pipes with some critical cost or similar water velocity. These pipes are
treated as belonging to a community and are organized in a new cluster (subnetwork or subset of
pipes with the same properties) of the supply water network. These clusters result in a similarproperty network. If the property is the cost, then for example we can find the cluster whose members
have the critical cost. By applying thie technique we reduce the original network to a cluster cost
network. In our approach the pipes out of the cluster are ignored. Having reduce the original network
of pipes to a clustered network where pipes with similar properties are grouped together one can
overcome the aforementioned computational limitations. Furthermore, this new approach allows the
study of dependencies between the members of the network associated with the question property.
The topology is dependent on the question property. Thus, a family of clusters (cost, velocity, energy,
chloride etc) can be created in order to simplify the original network.
34
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.
OPTIMIZATION PIPE NETWORKS WITH HARMONY SEARCH ALGORITH –
CLASSIC APPROACH
2.1 Harmony Search Algorithm (HSA)
The Harmony Search Algorithm (HAS) was inspired by the improvisation process that a skilled
musician follows when playing in a music band. While performing the musician has one of the
following choices:
To play the famous tune, the melody that characterizes the music piece. This specific melody
is called “theme” in music. Obviously, every member of the band knows the theme and can
play it by heart. In other words, all musicians have this melody in their minds, stored in their
memory.
A common choice a musician has is to play something similar to the theme. Quite often,
musicians try to enrich a music piece by slightly changing or adjusting pitches of the
memorized theme. This way, the musicians are free to explore the theme and listeners hear its
new versions. Tasteless iterations of the same tune are avoided.
Other choice is to start an improvisation. This choice, which is very common in Jazz and folk
music, gives the musician the freedom to play random tunes, sometimes notes with very small
(or no) relation to the performed piece. The talent and the imagination of the performer, is
used to express new music worlds and refreshes the music material with new themes.
The Harmony Search Algorithm is a stochastic meta-heuristic method based on the sequential
production of possible solutions. It belongs to the category of “neighborhood meta-heuristics” that
produces one possible solution per iteration. This process is completely different from that of the
population methods that produce a number of possible solutions during every iteration (e.g. genetic
algorithms). Every possible solution consists of a set of values of the decision variables of the function
that needs to be optimized. Each one of these sets of values is called a “Harmony”. During the
optimization process, a number of “harmonies” equal to the “Harmony Memory Size” are stored in
the “Harmony Memory” (HM), a database that includes the produced set of solutions. Every
component of the new harmony chosen from HM, is likely to be pitch-adjusted, thus providing
neighboring values for some of the harmonies chosen from HM. The third choice is to select a totally
random value from the possible value range. Randomization occurs with very small probability and
increases the diversity of the solutions.
2.2 Optimization water pipe networks with HSA
In the classic network cost optimization approach with metaheuristic methods, the costs can be
considered as a function of the length and the diameter of the pipelines. However, in this paper, we
consider an objective function that includes the diameter and the length of the corresponding pipeline.
The objective function is shown in Equation 1
𝐹 = ∑ 𝐿𝑖 ∗ 𝐷𝑖
(1)
where Li is the length and Di is the diameter of the corresponding pipeline. The constraints are shown
in equation 2
Vmin ≤ Vi≤ Vmax
∑ Qi = 0
Di ≥ 0
(2)
where:
35
Water resources management and contamination control
vi the flow velocity for pipe i that must be between a minimum and a maximum
Qi water flow rate for node i
The HSA works as follows: First, a number of possible solutions is stored are in the “Harmony
Memory” (HM). Every solution is one-dimensional array vector filled with Di values. During the
optimization process, the algorithm creates new a solution called “New Harmony”. If the “New
Harmony” has good evaluation in the objective function, then it replaces the west vector of “Harmony
Memory” (HM).
When the network structure is not tree-like, but has loops, a water distribution software must be used.
In this paper we developed a MatLab script that connects HSA with EPANET. The linking between
EPANET and MatLab is described in Chapter 4. The full optimization process is presented in Figure
1.
Figure 1: The optimization progress
3.
LINKING MATLAB-EPANET
EPANET is a water distribution system modeling software package developed by the United States
Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Water Supply and Water Resources Division. EPANET
is freeware but not open source software. In order to use it in a loop progress a linking software must
36
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
be developed. The EPANET Programmer's Toolkit is a library (DLL, dylib, or .so) of API functions
that allows developers to customize EPANET's computational engine for their own specific needs.
The functions can be incorporated into applications written in any language that can call functions
from a C library, like native C/C++, MatLab, Python, Visual Basic, etc. Here we use MatLab script
to call the necessary functions.
loading 'epanet2.dll'code is:
o loadlibrary('epanet2.dll','epanet2.h')
the most frequently used functions EPANET TOOL KIT are:
Open the EPANET toolkit and hydraulics solver
calllib('epanet2','ENopen','input2.inp','report2.rpt','');
where 'input2.inp' is the initial water network
Setting the values (diameters) to the network
calllib('epanet2','ENsetlinkvalue', index ,paramcode ,value)
paramcode get values from Table 1
EN_DIAMETER
EN_LENGTH
EN_ROUGHNESS
EN_MINORLOSS
EN_INITSTATUS
EN_INITSETTING
EN_KBULK
EN_KWALL
EN_STATUS
EN_SETTING
Table 1: Values for the “calllib” function
0
Diameter
1
Length
2
Roughness coeff.
3
Minor loss coeff.
4
Initial link status (0 = closed, 1 = open)
5
Roughness for pipes, initial speed for pumps, initial setting for valves
6
Bulk reaction coeff.
7
Wall reaction coeff.
11 Actual link status (0 = closed, 1 = open)
12 Roughness for pipes, actual speed for pumps, actual setting for valves
Analyzing the pipe network
calllib('epanet2','ENsolveH');
calllib('epanet2','ENsolveQ');
calllib('epanet2','ENreport');
The original water supply network is included in the file 'input2.inp'. Calling: ENsetlinkvalue function
we set the Harmony Memory vectors (Di) and calculate the network calling: ENsolveQ function. The
objective function is the Equation 1.
4.
CASE STUDY
The case study we choose to present in this paper is a network with loop and branch network topology.
It is a Gravity-driven water flow network with a central tank. The branch (tree-like) parts represent
the pipeline system connecting different cities, while the loop parts at the periphery of the network
represent the water supply network around small cities.
37
Water resources management and contamination control
Each destination node of a branch part has “q” flow rate demand. For each network member the head
loss is estimated from the Equation 3.
8𝑓𝑖𝐿𝑖
ℎ𝑖 = 𝜋2 𝑔𝐷𝑖 4
(3)
The pipes are made by PVC and the maximum pressure design is 10 Atm. Table 2 presents the
available diameters and the costs, while figure 2 shows the cost function power fitting.
ID
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Table 2: Classes of pipe diameters
D(mm) Euro/m
ID
D(mm)
100
73
10
400
125
81
11
450
150
88
12
500
175
95
13
550
200
103
14
600
225
112
15
650
250
123
16
700
300
144
17
750
350
173
18
800
Euro/m
205
241
279
320
356
415
467
517
592
According to Mandry’s model the function that relates the cost with the internal diameter, reads:
δ = ΑDV
(4)
700
600
500
y = 0.4536x1.0416
400
300
200
100
0
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
Figure 2: Cost function
Figure 3 illustrates the pipeline network and Figure 4 the water flow of the network.
38
900
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3: The water supply network with tank
Figure 4: The water flow network
5.
MODIFICATION OF HAS
In order to simplify large water supply systems, the algorithm described in Fig. 1 is modified. Gravity
factors are defined using a) Equation 4 for all the pipes and b) the network betweenness centrality for
all the nodes. This way, the objective function includes the centrality of the nodes of the pipeline
network. The most central nodes receive a high weight factor as they are more indispensable for the
network. Otherwise the algorithm prefers nodes of low centrality because they are connected to lowcost (Eq 4) pipes. The weights of the link are not constant but change as the algorithm evolves. This
is due to the change in diameter and the cost. Figure 5 presents the network betweenness centrality.
39
Water resources management and contamination control
Figure 5 presents the network betweenness centrality
Figure 5 shows that the high centrality nodes are the nodes with the highest water supply and therefore
the most critical for the network. Thus, if two pipes have about the same length and same supply, the
algorithm will prioritize the critical centrality pipeline. Figure 6 presents the network’s gravity
factors.
Figure 6: Gravity factors of the network
40
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
6.
RESULTS
Figures 7,8,9 presents three implementations of the algorithm for different parameters of the HSA. In
conclusion, HSA algorithm always locates as critical areas the ones having large cross sections. This
happens because there are no alternative routes for the water and the factors of length and cross
section of the pipelines have a significant contribution to the total cost. The color of the nodes
represents the community that belong the pipes connecting them to the other nodes.
Figure 7: Critical nodes with HSA parameters (HM:30, HMCR:0.7, PAR:0.1,IN:1000)
Figure 8: Critical nodes with HSA parameters (HM:70, HMCR:0.9, PAR:0.05,IN:1000)
41
Water resources management and contamination control
Figure 9: Critical nodes with HSA parameters (HM:50, HMCR:0.5, PAR:0.2, IN:1000)
7.
CONCLUSIONS
The modification of the HSA simplifies the big water supply networks, since a large number of pipes
can be ignored. This method approaches the minimum network construction cost as accurately as the
full-network optimization, but in less computational time. The case study network is simplified as
shown above (fig. 7, 8, 9) and the minimum cost is close to the full-network optimum cost. Checking
the betweenness centrality of the network lets us know the important cost members which are
absolutely necessary for the network. The cost of these members is as much as the cost of the full
network. In order to estimate the cost of the full network we used method as shown on Fig 1.
References
1. Degertekin, S. O. (2012). Improved harmony search algorithms for sizing optimization of truss
structures. Computers & Structures, 92, 229-241.
2. Dorigo, M., Maniezzo, V., & Colorni, A. (1996). Ant system: optimization by a colony of
cooperating agents. Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, Part B: Cybernetics, IEEE Transactions
on, 26(1), 29-41.
3. Eberhart, R. C., & Kennedy, J. (1995). A new optimizer using particle swarm theory. In
Proceedings of the sixth international symposium on micro machine and human science
(Vol. 1, pp. 39-43).
4. Fesanghary, M., Mahdavi, M., Minary-Jolandan, M., &Alizadeh, Y. (2008). Hybridizing
harmony search algorithm with sequential quadratic programming for engineering optimization
problems. Computer methods in applied mechanics and engineering, 197(33), 3080-3091.
5. Geem, Z. W., Kim, J. H., & Loganathan, G. V. (2001). A new heuristic optimization algorithm:
harmony search. Simulation, 76(2), 60-68.
6. Geem, Z. W., Kim, J. H., & Loganathan, G. V. (2002). Harmony search optimization: application
to pipe network design. International journal of modelling & simulation, 22(2), 125-133.
7. Holland, J. H. (1973). Genetic algorithms and the optimal allocation of trials. SIAM Journal on
Computing, 2(2), 88-105.
42
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
8. Gholizadeh, S., & Barzegar, A. (2013). Shape optimization of structures for frequency constraints
by sequential harmony search algorithm. Engineering Optimization, 45(6), 627-646.
9. Kaveh, A., &Talatahari, S. (2009). Particle swarm optimizer, ant colony strategy and harmony
search scheme hybridized for optimization of truss structures. Computers & Structures, 87(5),
267-283.
10. Kirkpatrick, S., Gelatt, C. D., & Vecchi, M. P. (1983). Optimization by Simulated Annealing.
Science, 220(4598), 671-680.
11. Kougias, I., and Theodosiou, N. (2010). A new music-inspired harmony based optimization
algorithm: Theory and applications. In Proceedings of: International Conference on Protection
and Restoration of the Environment X, Corfu.
12. Kougias, I., Katsifarakis, L., & Theodossiou, N. (2012). Medley Multiobjective Harmony Search
Algorithm: Application on a water resources management problem. European Water, 39, 71-52.
13. Kougias, I., &Theodossiou, N. (2013). Multiobjective pump scheduling optimization using
harmony search algorithm (HSA) and polyphonic HSA. Water Resources Management, 27(5),
1249-1261.
14. Lee, K. S., & Geem, Z. W. (2004). A new structural optimization method based on the harmony
search algorithm. Computers & Structures, 82(9), 781-798.
15. Lee, K. S., Geem, Z. W., Lee, S. H., & Bae, K. W. (2005). The harmony search heuristic algorithm
for discrete structural optimization. Engineering Optimization, 37(7), 663-684.
16. Mahdavi, M., Fesanghary, M., & Damangir, E. (2007). An improved harmony search algorithm
for solving optimization problems. Applied Mathematics and Computation, 188(2), 1567-1579.
17. Maheri, M. R. & Narimani, M.M (2014). An enhanced harmony search algorithm for optimum
design of side sway steel frames. Computers & Structures, 136 (2014): 78-89.
18. Saka, M. P. (2009). Optimum design of steel sway frames to BS5950 using harmony search
algorithm. Journal of ConstructionalSteel Research, 65(1), 36-43.
19. Xenakis, I. (1992). Formalized music: thought and mathematics in composition (No. 6).
PendragonPress
43
Water resources management and contamination control
HORIZONTAL CONVECTION INDUCED BY ABSORPTION OF
SOLAR RADIATION
V.C. Papaioannou* and P.E. Prinos
Hydraulics Laboratory Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th, GR- 54006, Thessaloniki, Macedonia,
Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: vaspapa@civil.auth.gr, tel : +302310995856
Abstract
In the present study, the formation and development of horizontal convective currents between open
water and a shaded area are investigated numerically. Differential solar heating can result from
shading aquatic canopy, producing a temperature difference between the shaded and illuminated
region. The unsteady two-dimensional Navier-Stokes (NS) equations are used in conjunction with
the energy equation, where the latter accounts for the absorption of radiation through an additional
source term. The Boussinesq approximation is applied for taking into account the density difference
due to temperature difference in the buoyancy term. Two radiation models are being implemented,
one based on Beer’s law and the other on the Radiative Transfer Equation (RTE). Both models divide
the incoming radiation into three bands, each having a specific absorption coefficient. The RTE
incorporates the emission and scattering processes, besides the absorption term, while Beer’s law
model uses only the absorption term. The effect of Grashof number (Gr), ranging from 107 to 109, on
the characteristics of the convective currents are examined. The numerical results for the current
velocity and water temperature profile are presented and compared against available experimental
data.
Keywords: horizontal convection, absorption, radiation, Beer’s law, Radiative Transfer.
1.
INTRODUCTION
The horizontal convection is quite significant in various geophysical systems. This phenomenon has
been studied in the field, in lake systems, from several scientists because of its importance in the
transport of nutrients and other chemicals that determine, to a large extent, the ecosystem of an area.
In lake systems the part of the water body with aquatic vegetation, near the shore, presents very low
absorption of solar radiation, compared with the net water area [Lightbody et al., 2008] resulting in
the development of convective currents.
The laboratory study and analysis of convective currents has focused on (a) small scale reservoir with
horizontal and inclined section [Coates and Patterson, 1993; Lei and Patterson, 2002], (b) in the
presence of aquatic vegetation in part of the reservoir, with either a horizontal or sloping bed [Zhang
and Nepf, 2009] and (c) the effect of Rayleigh number (laminar and turbulent horizontal convection).
In the field, the morning heating and afternoon cooling (daily cycle) of water generates convective
currents. The daily difference in temperature results in convective flow, where the speed reaches the
3 cm/s in the morning hours and 11 cm/s at noon [Monismith et al., 1990].
The computational simulation of convective currents has several advantages, compared with the
laboratory investigation, in the use of different boundary conditions, changing radiation and heat
supply in general, and simulation in real conditions. Most computational studies focus on low
44
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Rayleigh numbers, [Mullarney et al., 2004] and recently with use of direct numerical simulation
turbulent convective currents for Rayleigh number up to 3*1011 [Shishkina, 2017] and 1012 [Griffiths
et al., 2013] have been simulated.
The effect of solar radiation and heat supply from the external environment in the water volume is
taken into account through a source term in the equation of energy (temperature). The numerical
calculation of radiation attenuation in water depends on (a) the three-band model of radiation [Hattori
et al., 2014], (b) the law of Lambert-Beer for the attenuation of radiation in water [Tsakiri and Prinos,
2015] and (c) the discrete radiation model [Siegel and Spuckler, 1994] that is further analyzed in other
papers [Kaluri and Dattarajan, 2010].
This paper focuses on the numerical simulation of convective currents due to solar radiation. An
evaluation of the radiation models is investigated, through the necessary comparison with
corresponding available experimental data [Coates and Patterson, 1993]. In addition, the effect of
Grashof number (Gr), ranging from 107 to 109, on the characteristics of the currents is investigated.
2.
COMPUTATIONAL MODELLING
2.1 Governing equations
The two-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations (1), (2) and (3) are solved in conjunction with the
energy equation (4) for unsteady, incompressible flow. The Boussinesq approximation is used, which
treats the density as constant in all equations, apart from the buoyancy term of the momentum
equation, in which it varies due to temperature difference.
u v
0
x y
(1)
2u 2u
u
u
u
1 p
u v
2 2
t
x
y
x
x y
(2)
2v 2v
v
v
v
1 p
u v
2 2 ga T To
t
x
y
y
x y
(3)
2T 2T
T
T
T
u
v
2 2 Sh
t
x
y
y
x
(4)
where u and v are the horizontal and vertical velocity components, T is the temperature, p = 101,325
Pa is the pressure (incorporating the hydrostatic pressure), g = 9.81 m/sec2 is the acceleration due to
gravity, and ν = 0.000001051 m2/sec, ρo = 998.2 kg/m3, a = 0.000207 K-1 and κ = 1.4924E-07 m2/sec
are the kinematic viscosity, density, coefficient of thermal expansion and thermal diffusivity of the
fluid at the temperature Tο = 294.55 K or 21.4 oC. Τhe source term Sh in Equation (4) is an internal
heating source, which represents the absorption of radiation by the fluid and is added in the energy
equation only in the open region of the tank. In the opaque region, it is assumed that the water does
not absorb any radiation. This internal heating source generates horizontal temperature gradients
between the open water and the shaded region and these gradients induce circulation.
2.2 Computational Domain-Case Studies
The computational domain includes a rectangular reservoir of height h = 0.3m and total length L =
0.6m = (l + lE), where l is the length of the opaque area and lE the length of the transparent area where
solar radiation penetrates water. The walls of the reservoir are considered to be adiabatic and the wall
properties are shown in Figure 1.
45
Water resources management and contamination control
y
Incoming radiation Io
opaque wall
u=w=0
u=w=0
and
and
u=w=0 and Τ=Το at to=0
h
𝑇 = 𝑇𝑜
l
u=w=0 and
𝑇 = 𝑇𝑜
lE
𝜕𝑇
𝜕𝑦
=0
(0,0)
x
Figure 1. Computational domain and boundary conditions.
The case studies are based on the experiments of Coates and Patterson [1993]. The surface radiation
intensity is equal to I0 [W/m2] which varies, as shown in Table 1, and hence the Grashof number
varies from 6.79*107 to 1.19*109. In the same table, the characteristic times tc, tE and tv which indicate
the times of the three characteristic regimes (inertial, energy limited and viscous) are shown together
with the scale velocity uE in the energy-limited regime.
Table 1. Case studies and characteristic parameters.
Grashof number
tc
tE
Incoming Radiation Io
2
(W/m )
(Gr)
(sec) (sec)
Case Studies
(CS)
tv
uE
(sec)
(mm/sec)
1
20
6.79*107
3.9
209
2040
1.43
2
127.5 (C.P. 1993)
4.33*108
1.6
113
2040
2.65
3
350
1.19*109
0.9
81
2040
3.71
2.3 The solar radiation model
The Fluent 15.0.7 CFD code, which uses a control volume technique, is applied for the numerical
computations. The computational domain is divided into discrete control volume on which the
governing equations are integrated. For the mesh generation, the Gambit program is used. The
segregated solution method is used and the velocity-pressure coupling is achieved with the SIMPLE
algorithm. For the discretization of the governing equations, the PRESTO scheme is used for the
pressure and the Second Order Upwind scheme is used for the momentum and the energy [ANSYS
Inc., 2013]. User Defined Functions (UDF), based on C++ code, is used for introducing the extra
source term Sh. The RTE model is already included in the FLUENT’s radiation panel. Two different
radiation models are considered in this work, one based on Beer's law and the other based on the
Radiative Transfer Equation [Modest M., 2013].
2.4 Beer's Law
According to Beer’s Law the radiation intensity, decreases with increasing water depth and the source
term is given by Equation (5).
Sh
1
CP
N
n I e
i 1
i
n i (h y)
(5)
i
where N=number of bands, Ii is the surface radiation intensity, ηi is the extinction coefficient, h is the
water depth and y is the distance from the tank bottom. In order to compute the Ii intensities the
blackbody radiation distribution must be taken into account. The lamps used in the experiments are
46
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
mostly of 3200 οK color temperature generating a surface radiation heat flux Io, which is divided into
i intensities based on the distribution of the spectral radiance as given in figure 2.
Figure 2. Spectral radiance distribution for the color temperature of 3200 K.
In fact, the extinction coefficient for the water depends on the wavelength of the radiation and the
turbidity of the water. In an analysis of 1-m deep solar pond, Rabl and Nielsen [1975] developed fourband model to quantify the variation of the intensity of the solar radiation. They concluded that the
absorption of the radiation passing a water column cannot be described by a single exponential,
because different wavelengths differ widely in their absorption coefficients. Coates and Patterson
[1993] developed a three-band model based on their temperature measurements in a 300-mm water
column and found that it accurately reproduced the observed data. Hattori and Patterson [2014]
divided the entire spectrum of the attenuation coefficient into N=50 wavebands of equal radiation
intensity and found that the variation between the N=50 waveband solution and the three-band model
solution is marginal. However, it is not uncommon to some limnological applications, that the
absorption coefficient is assumed to be characterized by a single bulk extinction coefficient [Tsakiri
and Prinos, 2016].
A three-waveband attenuation model is implemented in this paper, where the ni coefficients were
experimentally derived [Coates and Patterson, 1993], as shown in table 2. The thermistors were
located at fixed depths in order to obtain a good temperature profile. The temperatures were measured
after one hour of uniform surface heating of the tank to ensure that the deeper water was sufficiently
heated.
The absorption of light decreases with decreasing wavelength and reaches a minimum absorption for
blue [Hale and Querry, 1973] and then increases again in the ultraviolet (UV) region. According to
Wetzel [2001], about 53% of the total light energy is transformed into heat and absorbed in the first
meter of water.
Table 2. Three-band model characteristics [Coates and Patterson, 1993]
Wavelength Percentage total Experimental
Band
surface energy
(nm)
ni (m-1)
1
< 800
~20%
145
2
800-1200
~30%
15
3
> 1200
~50%
2.5
47
Water resources management and contamination control
2.5 Radiative Transfer Equation
The discrete ordinates (DO) radiation model solves the Radiative transfer equation (RTE) for finite
number of discrete solid angles, each associated with a vector direction s fixed in the global Cartesian
system (x, y, z). It transforms the RTE equation into a transport equation for radiation intensity in the
spatial coordinates (x, y, z). The DO model solves for as many transport equation a there are directions
s [Chui and Raithby, 1993]. The last term in Equation 4, using this model, is given by
4
1
1
Sh q r
a 4I b I r, s d
C p
0
C p
(6)
where λ is the wavelength, αλ is the spectral absorption coefficient, Ibλ is the blackbody intensity given
by the Planck function. The intensity Iλ at the position r in the direction s is obtained by solving the
RTE:
I r,s s a s I r,s a n 2 I b
s
4
4
I r,s ' s,s ' d '
(7)
0
where n is the refractive index, σs is the scattering coefficient, s ' is the scattering direction vector, Ω
is the solid angle and Φ is the phase function. Equation (7) is the generalized equation for absorbing,
emitting and scattering medium. In the present study scattering is ignored, as the experimental studies
on scattering of radiation in pure water, indicate that the scattering phase function Φ is highly forward
in nature [Kullenberg, 1968]. The scattered energy propagates in the direction of the beam. As
suggested by Cengel and Ozisik [1984] scattering can be neglected, since all non-absorbed energy
propagates in its original direction. Thus the additional source term in Equation 6 takes a much
simpler form:
1 N
Sh
4 ni T4 ni Gi
Cp
i 1
(8)
where Gi (W/m2) is the incident radiation of each band and σ is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant. Both
models are presented in figure 3, where the two radiation models are uniformly applied to the surface
of the laboratory tank [Coates and Patterson, 1993]. The numerical results are in an excellent
agreement with the experimental data. There is a slight difference between the two models on the top
and bottom of the tank. This is due to the additional emission term of the RTE model.
48
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3. Temperature increase with water depth after one hour of uniform heating.
3.
ANALYSIS OF RESULTS
In this section, numerical results from both radiation models (Beer’s law and DO model) are presented
and compared against experimental measurements and empirical relationships [Coates and Patterson,
1993]. In addition, numerical results are presented which show the effect of the Gr number on
characteristics of the convective currents. For the three Gr numbers, ranging from 107 to 109,
temperature increase and maximum velocity are presented.
Figure 4 shows the variation of temperature increase with time at four selected locations, within the
shaded area, for Gr number equal to 4.33*108 for which experimental data [Coates and Patterson,
1993] are also available. All locations are at a distance 20 mm from the top surface (y/h=0.93) and at
various distances from the light/dark interface (x/h=-0.07, -0.28, -0.50, -0.72).
49
Water resources management and contamination control
Figure 4. Temperature increase versus time.
At all locations the experimental measurements indicate that, after some time, the temperature
increases gradually with a maximum increase of 0.12~0.14 oC after 600 s at the two locations near
the shaded/open interface while, at the two remote locations, this increase is 0.09~0.11 oC after 600
s. The two models produce similar variations with temperature increase very close to the experimental
for a time of 500 s. The RTE model produces results closer to the experimental especially at the
locations x/h=-0.50 and -0.72. After 500 s both models compute much higher increased temperature
that that of the experiments due to the side wall effects.
Figure 5 and 6 show the effect of Gr number on the dimensionless temperature increase at a location
(x/h=-0.07) for t=200 s and 400 s. Both radiation models present the same behavior. As the Gr number
increases the convective current becomes larger in width and its temperature increases with increasing
Gr number.
Figure 5. Variation of dimensionless temperature increase with depth at 20 mm (x/h= -0.07)
from the light/dark interface (Beer’s law model).
50
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 6. Variation of dimensionless temperature increase with depth at 20 mm (x/h= -0.07)
from the light/dark interface (RTE model).
In the inertial regime, the velocity is expected to be linear with respect to t0.5 and the data of figure 7
show that the maximum velocities for each case do fall well on a straight line. This confirms that the
early stage of the flow is indeed inertial. The maximum horizontal velocities for all case studies are
plotted against (Grv3t/h4)0.5. In general, the Beer’s law model produces velocities higher than those
of the RTE model at all times. The figure 7 shows the straight line produced by the experimental
results of Coates and Patterson [1993] which is in very good agreement with the numerical results of
the Beer’s law model. The velocities of the RTE model are slightly lower and the straight line,
produced by these data, is slightly different.
Figure 7. Variation of dimensionless maximum velocity with time.
(The open and solid symbols refer to Beer’s law and RTE model respectively).
In figure 8 the maximum velocity, made dimensionless with the scale velocity uE, is plotted against
time after the inertial period. The time scales tE, calculated in Table 1 are lower than those of the
simulations but of the same order of magnitude. This is in accordance with the computation of the
51
Water resources management and contamination control
maximum velocity which is lower than the scale velocity uE. In the energy-limited regime the two
radiation models produce similar results with the Beer’s law model to show higher velocities than
those of the RTE model. The effect of Gr on the starting time of this regime, as well as on the velocity
magnitude, is very clear. The experimental results, for Gr equal to 4.33*108 also show velocities
lower than the scale velocity as well as lower than the computed ones.
Figure 8. The maximum velocity, scaled against the expected constant velocity uE versus time.
(The open and solid symbols refer to Beer’s law and RTE model respectively).
4.
CONCLUSIONS
An extended work was performed to assess the effectiveness of two radiation models (Beer’s law and
RTE model) in predicting the development of convective currents due to differential heating. Also,
the effect of Gr number on the characteristics of the convective currents was investigated. The
following conclusions can be derived:
a) Both modes adequately reproduce the temperature profile, when uniform heating is introduced on
the surface of the tank.
b) The numerical temporal evolution of temperature increase at various locations along the shaded
area was compared with available experimental measurements [Coates and Patterson, 1993] for
Gr=4.33*108. The comparison indicates a satisfactory agreement between experimental and
computational results for time up to 500 s. The RTE model gives better predictions than the Beer’s
law model, especially in the region far from the light/dark interface.
c) The investigation of the effect of Gr on characteristics of the convective currents indicates that the
width and the temperature of the current increase with increasing Gr number.
d) The variation of the maximum velocity, at the light/dark interface, with time indicates that, initially,
the velocity increases linearly with t0.5 (inertial regime) and becomes constant afterwards (energy
limited regime). The constant maximum velocity is less, but of the same order of magnitude, than the
scale velocity and its value depends on the Gr number.
References
1. Lightbody A. F., Avener M. E., and Nepf H. M. (2008). Observations of short-circuiting flow
path within a free-surface wetland in Augusta, Georgia, U.S.A. Limnology and Oceanography,
53 (3), 1040-1053.
52
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2. Coates, M. J., and Patterson, J. C. (1993). Unsteady natural convection in a cavity with nonuniform absorption of radiation, J. Fluid Mech., vol. 256, pp. 133-161.
3. Lei C., and Patterson J. (2002). Natural convection in a reservoir sidearm subject to solar
radiation: experimental observations, Experiments in Fluids, 32 (5), 590-599.
4. Zhang X., and Nepf H. M. (2009). Thermally driven exchange flow between open water and
aquatic canopy. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 632, 227-243.
5. Monismith S., Imberger J., and Morison M. L. (1990). Convective motions in the sidearm of a
small reservoir. Limnology and Oceanography, 35, 1676-1702.
6. Mullarney J. C., Griffiths R. W., and Hughes G. O. (2004). Convection driven by differential
heating at a horizontal boundary. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 516, 181-209.
7. Shishkina O. (2017). Mean flow structure in horizontal convection. Journal of Fluid Mechanics,
812, 525-540.
8. Griffiths R. W., Hughes G. O., and Gayen B. (2013). Horizontal convection dynamics: insights
from transient adjustment. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 726, 559-595.
9. Hattori T., Patterson J. C., and Lei C. (2014). Study of unsteady natural convection induced by
absorption of radiation model based on a three-wave-band attenuation model. Journal of Physics:
Conference Series, 530, 012036.
10. Tsakiri M., and Prinos P. (2015). Numerical simulation of thermally driven exchange flow
between open water and aquatic canopies. E-proceedings of the 36th IAHR World Congress
28 June - 3 July, The Hague, the Netherlands.
11. Siegel R., and Spuckler C. M. (1994). Effect of refractive index and diffuse or specular boundaries
on a radiating isothermal layer. Journal of Heat Transfer, 116, 787-790.
12. Kaluri R. S., and Dattarajan S. (2010). Numerical simulation of direct absorption of solar radiation
by a liquid. Tech. rep., Siemens Corporate Research & Technologies.
13. ANSYS Inc. (2013). ANSYS Fluent 15.0 User’s Guide, ANSYS Inc., USA.
14. Modest, F. M. (2013). Radiative Heat Transfer (Third Edition), Academic Press, Boston,
doi.org /10.1016/ B978-0-12-386944-9.50037-6.
15. Rabl, A., and Nielson, C. (1975). Solar ponds for space heating, Sol. Energy, 17, l-12.
16. Tsakiri, M., and Prinos, P. (2016). Microscopic numerical simulation of convective currents in
aquatic canopies, Procedia Engineering, vol. 162(C), pp. 611-618.
17. Halle G. M., and Querry M. R. (1973). Optical constants of water in the 200nm to 200μm
wavelength region. Appl. Optics 12, 555-563.
18. Wetzel, R. G. (2001). Light in inland water, In Limnology, 3rd ed. Academic Press.
19. Chui, E. H., and Raithby, G. D. (1993). Computation of Radiant Heat Transfer on a NonOrthogonal Mesh Using the Finite-Volume Method. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part B, 23:269288.
20. Kullenberg, G. (1968). Scattering of light by Sargasso Sea water. DeepSea Res., 15, 423–432.
21. Cengel, Y.A., and Ozisik, M.N. (1984). Solar radiation absorption in solar ponds, Sol. Energy,
vol. 33:6, pp 581-591.
53
Water resources management and contamination control
SUPPORTING INTEGRATED WATER RESOURCES
MANAGEMENT ON THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE
MAXIMUM WATER LEVEL IN LAKE VEGORITIDA
Ch. Doulgeris* and A. Argyroudi
Soil and Water Resources Institute-Dept. of Land Reclamation, Hellenic Agricultural Organisation,
57400, Sindos, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: chdoulgeris@gmail.com, tel : +302310798790
Abstract
Water is a key element in sustaining any environmental and socio-economic balance. With the current
context of rapid changes on hydrological and socio-economic patterns, water resources management
is facing a special challenge, which is no other than dealing with competing claims of various
stakeholders on water, or in other words, with water resource dilemmas, such as the determination of
the maximum water level in Lake Vegoritida (Northern Greece). The lake’s water level has undergone
great changes, throughout the last decades, caused by severe water abstraction directly from the lake
and its catchment. Along with the water level changes, it is not only the natural environmental
conditions that have adapted to a new status, but also the social and economic ones. Nowadays, a
discussion about the decision for the maximum water level in Lake Vegoritida becomes a source of
conflict among stakeholders who have different claims and interests around the lake. In this paper, an
outlining process is followed that includes the identification of stakeholders and the issues related to
lake’s water level, as well as the effects of alternative proposed scenarios of maximum water level on
the natural and socio-economic environment. The engagement of the identified stakeholders in a
management and decision-making process should be taken into account by the competent authorities
towards the establishment of an environmentally sustainable, socially equitable and economically
efficient maximum water level in Lake Vegoritida.
Keywords: lake level management; environmental aspects; socio-economic aspects; stakeholders;
IWRM
1.
INTRODUCTION
Despite the immense technological progress, societies still depend on the capacity of ecosystems to
produce goods and services which sustain social and economic development. Water is a key element
in sustaining any environmental and socio-economic balance. With the current context of rapid
changes on hydrological and socio-economic patterns, water resources management is facing the
special challenge to deal with competing claims of various stakeholders on water. Stakeholders hold
strong but divergent values and perceptions about what is at stake and a situation of complexity is
created through the way all interdependent, conflicting human activities adapt with changes on the
natural environment.
As the economy and society are dynamic and the natural environment is also subject to change, the
perspective of Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM) is lately highly embraced by
communities and researchers in the need to be capable of adapting to new economic, social and
environmental conditions and to changing human values (GWP, 2004). Special focus is nowadays
54
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
given in socio-hydrology, with a basic statement of the International Association of Hydrological
Sciences (IAHS) that co-evolution of hydrological and connected systems (including society) needs
to be recognized and modelled with a suitable approach, in order to predict their reaction to change
(Montanari et al., 2013). Usable science, as produced in a form that can be used by stakeholders in
their management and decision-making roles, becomes meaningful through building ongoing
relationships with stakeholders and ensuring their two-way communication (Meadow et al., 2015). A
recent example in literature of this successful exchange of knowledge between researchers and
research users has been explicit in the case of Upper Santa Cruz River basin in Arizona, where a
hydrological model has been used as a vehicle to link stakeholder engagement with groundwater
management (Eden et al., 2016).
Lake Vegoritida, one of the largest and deepest lakes in Greece, is just another example of a natural
system whose management cannot be separated from the public, as the decision for maximum water
level immediately becomes a source of conflict among stakeholders who have different claims and
income around the lake. The lake’s water level has undergone great changes caused by severe water
abstraction directly from the lake and its catchment; water level was around 525 m a.m.s.l in early
80’s and dropped down to 509 m in late 90’s whereas has partially recovered to around 518-519 m
during the last decade. Researchers have studied the energy and water budget of the lake (Gianniou
& Antonopoulos, 2007), or shown the inter-relations between the abiotic and biotic features of the
lake (Antonopoulos and Gianniou, 2003; Pirini et al, 2011; Stefanidis, 2012). Gianniou &
Antonopoulos (2014) have shown that significant changes on concentrations of phosphorus and
dissolved oxygen have been caused due to water depth and volume alterations during the years 19811983. Recently, an assessment of the environmentally minimum water level for Lake Vegoritida
reconciles the protection of lake ecosystems and the availability of water volume to meet the
economic activities (Doulgeris et al., 2017). Nowadays, that the severe water abstraction directly from
the lake has been ceased, the arising management question is ‘What would be the best maximum
water level of Lake Vegoritida’ for both nature and society?
This paper supports the idea of IWRM towards the establishment of a maximum water level in Lake
Vegoritida as a means to promote the coordinated management of water in a way that economic and
social activities may be carried out in an equitable manner without compromising the sustainability
of the lake’s ecosystem. The paper is an outlining process that includes (a) the identification of
stakeholders and the issues that arise through a potential establishment of a maximum water level and
(b) proposals of alternative scenarios of water level, considered as potential decisions of maximum
water level, as a means to raise a constructive discussion associated with the effects of these scenarios
on the dynamics between the natural and social environment. Furthermore, the perspective of
engaging all levels of stakeholders in a process of establishing a maximum water level in Lake
Vegoritida is discussed as a future potential approach in managing the lake’s water level.
2.
THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM OF LAKE VEGORITIDA
Lake Vegoritida is located in the water district of Western Macedonia in Northern Greece.The
hydrological catchment of the lake covers an area of 2,145 km2 and is drained by the streams Sklithro,
Amyntas and Pentavryso (or Soulou) and the Lakes Zazari, Cheimaditida and Petron. Key inflows in
Lake Vegoritida are the excess of surface water from Lake Petron, which is transferred to Vegoritida
through a tunnel, and runoff of Pentavryso subcatchment.
Lake Vegoritida has undergone great changes on its natural environment in the last decades as a result
of its water level alteration. Based on water level recordings from the 1980s’ and afterwards (Fig. 1),
the water level dropped from 525 m to 510 m a.m.s.l. circa in the early 2000s’, mainly due to water
abstraction by the Public Power Corporation (D.E.H.). During this period the lake has lost 45% of its
volume and 29% of its surface area. Ever since the abstraction ceased, the water level is rising and
nowadays varies around to 518.5 m. It should be mentioned that the water level recordings between
40’s and 60’s show that the water level was varying around 540 m a.m.s.l.
55
Water resources management and contamination control
Figure 1. Water level (a.m.s.l.) fluctuation in Lake Vegoritida for the period 1980-2015.
The shrinking lake had revealed some extraordinary fertile land, which was perceived as an excellent
opportunity of extra income for the local farmers. As it is shown in Fig. 2, part of the agricultural land
is now flooded because of the lake level rising at 518 m, which is now a threat to the farmers.
Meanwhile, if the water level exceeds the level of 519 m, the sewage treatment infrastructure, which
was built during the period of low water level, will be inundated. On the other side, fishery and the
tourist business, which are also part of the local community, seem pleased with a restoring lake. As
far as the Public Power Corporation is concerned, it appears that it no longer has any stake on the
lake as no more lake water is abstracted to supply a number of thermo-electrical and hydro-electrical
power stations. Nowadays, water demands for the operation of these power stations are covered by
water transfer from the neighboring hydrological catchment of Aliakmonas River.
Figure 2. Coastline of Lake Vegoritida for various water levels (a.m.s.l.)
56
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.
THE STAKEHOLDERS AROUND LAKE VEGORITIDA
To outline how stakeholders around Lake Vegoritida have constructed and defended their stakes, two
distinct processes were involved. The first process includes the identification of stakeholders and the
issues that emerge through a potential establishment of a maximum water level by creating the ‘real
picture’ of the stakeholders’ system and their interdependencies in regard with past experiences on
the lake’s water level fluctuation. The second process is an effort of the authors to create the
‘conceptual picture’ by proposing three different scenarios of water level, viewed as potential
decisions of maximum water level, and exploring their effects on the dynamics between the natural
and social environment.
3.1 Analysis of stakeholders and issues related to the maximum water level
Venn diagram (Fig. 3) was used to illustrate the extent to which stakeholders interact or overlap with
each other and the importance of each, in regard to the issue of determining a maximum water level
in Lake Vegoritida. Large circles represent powerful organisations, overlapping circles represent
interacting organisations and a small circle within a larger circle represents a component of that
organisation. Farmers and sewage treatment beneficiaries are directly concerned with a potential
flooding of their properties, whereas fishermen, recreation business are favored by the lake
expanding. The Organization for the Protection of Lake Vegoritida (OPLV) is a community group
that has emerged with the aim to prevent the loss of the lake’s water, as well as the degradation of its
ecosystem. OPLV and farmers are key stakeholders and their efforts may affect authorities towards
the determination of the maximum water level of the lake. Academics, researchers, consultants and
the public have an indirect involvement and influence on the water level determination, as their
livelihoods are not directly affected by a decision for a maximum water level; however, their input in
knowledge is essential. Governmental bodies (e.g. Water Directorate), policy makers and local
authorities are important in the process of establishing and maintaining the maximum water level,
due to their power of legitimizing any decision.
Figure 3. Identification, importance and interaction of the stakeholders who may be directly
or indirectly involved in the process of determining a maximum water level in Lake
Vegoritida.
57
Water resources management and contamination control
A rich picture (Fig. 4), as a mind-mapping tool, presents the plethora of natural, socio-economic and
institutional themes that need to be considered in the process of determining a maximum water level
in Lake Vegoritida. These themes represent possible issues that may emerge as components of the
natural and human environment around the lake and mapping the themes, in regard with the
determination of maximum water level, allows a better understanding of reality as well as of the
interdependencies that are created. Οnce a maximum water level is determined (central circle as a
starting point), emergent themes appear in a clear sequence of dependencies where a number of
activities, for example the economic, will be ‘re-arranged’, depending on the water level.
-
ELECTIONS/VOTERS
RESEARCHERS
WATER FRAMEWORK
DIRECTIVE 2000/60/EC
BIRDS DIRECTIVE
2009/147/EC
HABITATS DIRECTIVE
92/43/EEC
-
-
-
4-LAKES HYDROLOGICAL
CONNECTION
GROUNDWATER DRILLING
WATER LEVEL CHANGES IN
HYDROLOGIC BALANCE
POLLUTION LOADS (ON
WATER AND SOIL)
RECREATION
LIVELIHOODS
TENSION AMONG
DIFFERENT
VILLAGES
POLITICAL
TENSION
LEGAL/INSTITUTIONAL
CONTEXT
SOCIAL
MAX WATER LEVEL
OF VEGORITIDA
-
LOCAL
INCOME
ECONOMIC
ABIOTIC
NATURAL
INDUSTRY
-
EU SUBSIDIES
BIOTIC
CLIMATE CHANGE
-
EUTROPHICATION
BIRDFAUNA
LAKE BED VEGETATION
(REEDS)
MACROPHYTES
FISH
-
-
FISHING
FARMING
TOURISMRECREATION
SEWAGE
TREATMENT
ENERGY
CONSERVATION/MANAGEMENT
OF NATURA NETWORK
RESEARCH
COUNTERVAILING MEASURES
FOR FARMERS
Figure 4. A rich picture of the issues that are related to the determination of a maximum
water level in Lake Vegoritida
3.2 Dynamics of maximum water level scenarios
The identification and visualisation of alternative water level scenarios and their consequent effects
can be a useful tool for clarifying options among stakeholders with apparently diverging perspectives
on the maximum water level. Alternative proposed scenarios of a maximum water level may also
promote a collective learning process by bridging knowledge among scenarists and scenario users
and a meaningful discussion on the pros and cons of different scenarios while accounting for
uncertainties (e.g. rainfall patterns) and possible social and environmental consequences of current
watershed management.
Three scenarios of maximum water level for Lake Vegoritida are examined: Scenario 1 refers to a
maximum water level of 518 m, which is the recorded water level in the present time period (20162017). Scenario 2 refers to a maximum water level of 509 m, which is the water level experienced in
late 90’s. Scenario 3 refers to a maximum water level of 525 m, which has been experienced in early
80’s. In Table 1 are given the positively and negatively affected stakeholders and associated issues
arising at each scenario of maximum water level. If there was only one view of reality we would be
able to show the benefits and drawbacks of each scenario. However, in a system of stakeholders what
is beneficial for one group of stakeholders might be a threat to another and vice versa.
58
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1. Positively and negatively affected stakeholders and issues arising at each scenario of
maximum water level in Lake Vegoritida
Scenario 1
518
1,068
44
Scenario 2
509
825
38
Scenario 3
525
1,557
54
Local community
OPLV, Fishermen
Tourists, Birdwatchers,
Recreation business
Farmers who benefit
from an improved
irrigation status
Farmers
Local residents whose
income significantly
comes from farming
Local Authorities
Local community
OPLV, Fishermen
Tourists, Birdwatchers,
Recreation business
Farmers who benefit
from an improved
irrigation status
Local residents whose
income significantly
comes from farming
Local Authorities
Local community
OPLV, Fishermen
Tourists, Birdwatchers,
Recreation business
Farmers
Local residents whose
income significantly
comes from farming
Local Authorities
Sewage treatment
beneficiaries
Lake restoration
Not affected
Affected
Water quality
Affected
Affected
Available irrigation water
Currently ongoing
Will decrease
Will increase
Ecosystem functions
Have been restored
Habitat loss (birds, fish)
Macrophytes will be rearranged
Loss of bird populations
Bird habitats flooded
Fish spawning habitats
flooded
Macrophytes will be rearranged
New ecosystem balance
Business activities
(farming, fishing)
Farmers have lost land,
fish production and
quality improved
‘Farmland’ will be
revealed, unknown
fishing production
projections
More ‘farmland’ will be
lost
Not affected
Will be affected due to
ecosystem degradation
Possibly will be
improved
Not affected
Not affected
Sewage treatment plant
will no longer work
Currently existing
between farmers and
OPLV -fishers, but
conflicts have been
almost at halt, after
decision of Minister of
Environment
Conflicts for claiming
new property rights on
revealed land among
farmers of different
villages, conflicts
between farmers and
OPLV-fishers. Local
Authorities will need to
take sides
Conflicts among sewage
treatment beneficiaries,
farmers against fishers,
OPLV. Local
Authorities will need to
take sides
Water Level, a.m.s.l. (m)
Stored Volume (106 m3)
Surface Area (km2)
Positively affected
Stakeholders
Negatively affected
Stakeholders
Issues of interest
Recreation activities
(swimming, hunting,
birdwatching)
Sewage treatment
operations
Social conflicts
Back to older state,
unknown effects
Unknown effects,
probably deteriorated if
sewage treatment no
longer works
According to Table 1, three different ways of viewing Lake Vegoritida are outlined.
59
Water resources management and contamination control
Scenario 1: There has been enough tension accumulating between stakeholders, whose income comes
from tourism, fishing and recreation, and farmers who have been seeing their land being inundated.
It has not been until the Ministry of Environment had put a halt to this tension, through an immediate
intervention for stabilizing the water level at 518 m. Currently, the lake has been restoring at a great
extent, although water quality is still poor. Local community is pleased with the lake’s restoration,
even a group of farmers who are foreseeing an improved irrigation status.
Scenario 2: This is a water level scenario that benefits a portion of the local community; the farmers
who will regain their land as well as local authorities who will benefit from the farmers voting support.
However, this scenario reflects not only a completely degraded ecosystem and its functions (as
already experienced in the past), but also unresolved conflicts among local authorities, environmental
groups for the protection of the lake, and other people whose income comes from the tourist and
fishing business. An additional conflict among farmers emerges, as farmers from different villages
claim ‘property rights’ of the revealing land. The potential of a deterioration of the lake’s water
quality is prominent for this scenario, as non-point and point pollution loads will outflow to a lake
with a decreased water volume.
Scenario 3: Although this is a very optimistic scenario for groups of stakeholders with great
environmental concerns for the lake, as well as fisheries and recreation business, an increase of the
lake’s water at 525 m means that the sewage treatment, as well as other public or private infrastructure
that has been constructed over time will be inundated. It also remains unknown how the ecosystem
will respond to such a change, as the expanding of the lake will flood existing habitats for birds and
fish that have been re-adapted during the last decade. In such a case, any water level raise should take
place gradually and under careful monitoring of the natural environment.
3.3 Establishing a maximum water level in Lake Vegoritida under IWRM
According to the second principle of the Dublin Statement on water and sustainable development
(1992), on which IWRM is based, water development and management should be based on a
participatory approach, involving users, planners and policy-makers at all levels. The participatory
approach raises the importance of decision making at the lowest appropriate level, with public
consultation and involvement of users in the planning and implementation of water projects in the
context of IWRM.
Establishing the maximum water level of Lake Vegoritida, under an IWRM perspective, needs
therefore to be seen in the context of a participatory management process. The objectives of such a
management approach are related to the direct engagement of stakeholders in deciding about the
maximum water level of Lake Vegoritida. These objectives are:
To engage (rather than just inform) stakeholders in a participatory planning process, about the
maximum water level (Each stakeholder, from locals to authorities, business and scientists, has
to propose a maximum water level)
To bring together scientific knowledge and experiences of the local people, so as to initiate
processes of dialogue and learning from the stakeholders. (What have we learnt from water level
fluctuations all these years?)
To view scientists as ‘stakeholders’ and local people as ‘water experts’ (What kind of knowledge
can we make most of it and how, in order to decide for a maximum water level?)
To create the enabling institutional environment for establishing a water level, through
strengthening capacity of networks, rather than persons (Who has the responsibility/power for
making and implementing the decision? And in what way/extent have existing institutions
corresponded to the overall changes of the lake over time?)
The use of the proposed three water level scenarios could be seen not only as a vehicle for
stakeholders to recall their personal past experiences of the lake’s water level, but also as a new guide
60
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
to imagine potential future water level projections and their responses, throughout a participatory
management process.
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Lake Vegoritida is an interesting system to be studied under the umbrella of IWRM. The above review
of the current situation brings on surface some dilemmas that stem from the diverging interests that
various stakeholders have in regard with the lake’s water level. The lake has been restoring
throughout the last two decades, since water abstraction from D.E.H. has ceased. It now remains that
farmers demand back their ‘flooded’ land, while other stakeholders who earn income from the lake
(fishers, recreation business) or not (conservationists, local inhabitants) are opposed to that. However,
apart from the dilemma of “Flooded farmland vs. Restoring lake”, the present paper has revealed
some other dilemmas that lie in the reality of the stakeholders around and beyond Lake Vegoritida.
These include the following:
According to the Habitats Directive 92/43/EE, once special areas for conservation are designated, EU
countries must introduce appropriate conservation objectives and measures. They must do everything
possible to guarantee the conservation of habitats in these areas; avoid their deterioration and any
significant disturbance to species. EU countries must also encourage the proper management of
landscape features essential for the migration, dispersal and genetic exchange of wild species,
undertake surveillance of both habitats and species. Therefore, a dilemma is formed as ‘Is the lake
seen as part of an EU protected area, that has to fulfill certain requirements, or as a distinct part owned
only by stakeholders who use its water?’
Nature, economy and society constitute a system through which all water resources should be studied
and managed. In an attempt to skip the sense of conflict behind opposing activities of stakeholders
(such as farming and fishing), one can see that all kind of activities are part of the area’s economy
and culture, and people in the area have been adapting their economic activities and livelihoods along
with nature changes throughout the years. Therefore, a new dilemma is ‘Is the lake viewed only as
part of nature, or part of economy vs. is the lake part of a system (nature, economy, society)? At this
point of shaping a systemic view of the lake, the dimension of time is important, as both the historicity
and the sustainability related to the use of water in the basin should be taken in account.
Humans have always been adapting water management and practice to natural hydrologic variability.
However, it remains uncertain whether or not practices and activities designed with historical climate
variability will be able to cope with future variability caused by atmospheric warming (de Loë &
Kreutzwiser, 2010). Climate change projections in the Mediterranean come along with intensifying
human demands on water (surface and groundwater abstraction for irrigation, building infrastructure,
water pollution, population increase).
Finally, local authorities and decision makers have dealt with strong political tensions, due to the
lake’s water fluctuation associated with people’s income. Is the lake management a means for
politicians to exchange water services for votes and political support or a means for equity in water
governance?
Once the issues at stake have been identified and dilemmas have been clearly articulated, the three
potential scenarios proposed in this paper bring an answer to the question ‘At which state of the lake
do we want to move?’
The three scenarios form a conceptual route for a concrete visualisation of the lake’s future and reveal
the potential of embedding local know-how into future management strategies. Scenarios 2 and 3
have been experienced in the past, and their consequences may be seen as lessons learnt from
stakeholders. Engaging stakeholders in discussions and analyses of these past experiences can reveal
what kind of information is necessary to better prepare for future changes of water level, their costs,
and period of adaptation. Their involvement is also fundamental because they not only represent the
end users, but they also play a key role in implementing successful new management practices and
61
Water resources management and contamination control
effective local actions (Re, 2015). Moreover, by integrating local and scientific knowledge is a
process that can direct scientists towards new research questions that are relevant to stakeholders’
needs. A thoughtful design of stakeholder engagement process, elaborated by water scientists can
finally be seen as a powerful tool towards aiding water governance organisations in adaptive decision
making.
Usually, established water governance organizations and their key members take the initiative to
change the existing institutions (policies, laws and administration) on the basis of identified needs,
often based on their own interests. However, existing laws and procedures for sharing of water
resources among the different users may not be adequate in terms of present circumstances. The extent
and the character of an observed gap between declared rules and rules-in-use is a good indicator for
institutional change (Bandaragoda, 2000). Papageorgiou and Vogiatzakis (2006) have pointed the
need in Greece for greater realisation of integrated conservation which necessitates reforms in the
political culture, in terms of being more open and cooperative, and the setting up of a process to
facilitate public dialogue. The change in political culture could be enhanced following policy reforms
related mainly to sectoral legal frameworks and administrative structures as well as a stronger overall
political commitment.
In the case of Lake Vegoritida, every meter of water level has to be translated into ‘human behavior’,
in the process of reaching any optimal management state. This is due to the fact that networks of
relationships and the activities of the people that form them around the lake are so well embedded in
patterns of water use that imply difficulties in any long-term changes. In this work, the objectives of
establishing a maximum water level of Lake Vegoritida are outlined under the umbrella of IWRM,
and in particular under the potential engagement of all identified stakeholders in a participatory
management and decision-making process. Even if the water level remains as in current, the authors
suggest that whether this is the determined maximum water level or not, it has to be legitimized under
a change in the management paradigm with which the water of Lake Vegoritida has been managed
until now. Past experience of various water levels (empirical knowledge) during the last 30 years and
the existing research background (scientific knowledge) constitute a great opportunity on which a
change in the management process should be based. However, changes in water management
procedures should be supported by institutional reforms, even if that means accommodating the
principle of justice and equity in the process. Any water level scenario should be filtered through a
holistic approach- in that integrating all environmental, social and economic dilemmas of the
stakeholders, so that decision-making is participatory and finally enjoy a wide public acceptance and
unproblematic implementation.
References
1. Antonopoulos V. and S. Gianniou (2003) ‘Simulation of water temperature and dissolved oxygen
distribution in Lake Vegoritis, Greece’, Ecological Modelling, 160, pp. 39-53.
2. Antonopoulos V. and S. Gianniou (2014) ‘Primary production and phosphorus modelling in Lake
Vegoritis, Greece’, Advances in Oceanography and Limnology, 5, pp. 18-40.
3. Bandaragoda, J. (2000), ‘A framework for institutional analysis for water resources management
in a river basin context’, Working Paper 5. Colombo, Sri Lanka: International Water
Management Institute.
4. Doulgeris C., P. Georgiou, A. Apostolakis, D. Papadimos, D. Zervas, O. Petriki, D. Bobori, D.
Papamichail, V. Antonopoulos, C. Farcas and P. Stålnacke (2017), ‘Assessment of the
environmentally minimum lake level based on hydromorphological features’, European Water,
58, pp. 197-202.
5. Eden S., B. Megdal, E. Shamir, K. Chief and M. Lacroix (2016), ‘Opening the Black Box: Using
a Hydrological Model to Link Stakeholder Engagement with Groundwater Management’, Water,
8(5), pp. 216.
62
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
6. Gianniou S. and V. Antonopoulos (2007), ‘Evaporation and energy budget in Lake Vegoritis,
Greece’, Journal of Hydrology, 345(3), pp. 212-223.
7. Global Water Partnership (2004), ‘Catalyzing Change’, A handbook for developing IWRM and
water efficiency strategies, United Nations.
8. De Loë C. and D. Kreutzwiser (2000), ‘Climate Variability, Climate Change and Water Resource
Management in the Great Lakes’, Climatic Change, 45, pp. 163-179.
9. Meadow M., B. Ferguson, Z. Guido, A. Horangic and G. Owen (2015), ‘Moving toward the
Deliberate Coproduction of Climate Science Knowledge’, Weather, Climate, and Society, 7(2),
pp. 179-191.
10. Montanari A., G. Young, G. Savenije, D. Hughes, T. Wagener, L. Ren, D. Koutsoyiannis, C.
Cudennec, E. Toth, S. Grimaldi, G. Blöschl, M. Sivapalan, K. Beven, H. Gupta, M. Hipsey, B.
Schaefli, B. Arheimer, E. Boegh, J. Schymanski, G. Di Baldassarre, B. Yu, P. Hubert, Y. Huang,
A. Schumann, A. Post, V. Srinivasan, C. Harman, S. Thompson, M. Rogger, A. Viglione, H.
McMillan, G. Characklis, Z. Pang and V. Belyaev (2013), ‘Panta Rhei-Everything Flows: Change
in hydrology and society-The IAHS Scientific Decade 2013-2022’, Hydrological Sciences
Journal, 58(6) pp. 1256-1275.
11. Papageorgiou K. and I. Vogiatzakis (2006), ‘Nature protection in Greece: an appraisal of the
factors shaping integrative conservation and policy effectiveness’, Environmental Science and
Policy, 9, pp. 476-486.
12. Pirini C., V. Karagiannakidou and S. Charitonidis (2011), ‘Abundance, diversity and distribution
of macrophyte communities in neighboring lakes of different trophic states and morphology in
north-central Greece’, Archives of Biological Sciences, 63, pp. 763-774.
13. Re Viviana (2015), ‘Incorporating the social dimension into hydrogeochemical investigations for
rural development: the Bir Al-Nas approach for socio-hydrogeology’. Hydrogeology Journal,
23, pp. 1293-1304.
14. Stefanidis K. (2012), ‘Ecological Assessment of lakes of Northwestern Greece with emphasis on
the associations between aquatic macrophytes, zooplankton and water quality’, University of
Patras, Postdoctoral Thesis, pp. 272.
63
Water resources management and contamination control
RAINWATER HARVESTING AS AN ALTERNATIVE SOURCE
TO CONFRONT WATER SCARCITY WORLDWIDE – CURRENT
SITUATION AND PERSPECTIVES
S. Yannopoulos, I. Giannopoulou and M. Kaiafa-Saropoulou*
Faculty of Engineering, School of Rural and Surveying Engineering, Aristotle University of
Thessaloniki, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: minakasar@gmail.com
Abstract
Earth’s arid and semi-arid regions were always faced water scarcity problems due to the lack of
precipitation and its unpredictability. However, there is global pressure on available water resources,
which not only has demographic, economic and social causes, but also is connected with climate
change. Rainwater harvesting (RWH) is an alternative source of water applied since antiquity. The
practice is still in use in many areas throughout the world as it is adopted by many countries as a
viable decentralized water source. Rainwater collection, protection and re-use are a viable process
that can both significantly increase available water resources and reduce flood risks. The degree of
its modern implementation varies greatly across the world, often with systems that do not maximize
potential benefits. In recent decades, many countries are supporting updated implementation of such
practice so as to confront the water demand increase, which is related to the climatic, environmental
and societal changes. According to the current literature, RWH process belongs to a wider context
called Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDs). It can be applied additionally and designed
appropriately so as to reduce frequency, peak and volume of urban runoff. The above thoughts
motivate interest in considering the current situation and the perspective to further grow this method
worldwide. In the present paper, the current situation of rainwater harvesting as an alternative water
source to confront water scarcity around the world is studied. In particular, the paper presents: (a) the
causes of water shortage; (b) a brief historical overview of the temporal evolution of the RWH; (c)
the causes of the renewal of interest in the RWH technique; and (d) incentives for the spreading of
the RWH method in various countries worldwide.
Keywords: Rainwater harvesting, alternative water source, water shortage, arid and semi-arid areas
1.
INTRODUCTION
Water is an essential and irreplaceable element for the existence of all living beings and the ensuring
of the continuance of life on earth. Access to clean and affordable water is one of the fundamental
human rights, as water is the good that plays an important role in health, social and economic
development of a country, food production and environment.
Arid and semi-arid regions of the earth were always facing water scarcity problems due to the lack of
rainfall and its erratic pattern in spatial and temporal scales. Moreover worldwide, available water
resources undergo pressures, due to demographic, economic and social causes, the environmental
degradation and the impacts of climate change.
In this way, the population increase, the urbanization expansion and also the intensity of the
industrialization and the irrigated agriculture rise water requirements and, consequently, provoke
greater pressure on water resources. Between 2011 and 2050, the world's population is expected to
64
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
grow by about 33%, while the population that will be living in urban areas is estimated to grow by
72% (UNDESA, 2011). In general, rapid urbanization and improving living standards of urban
population contribute to increase of the overall demand for water in cities. By 2030, almost half of
the world's population will be living in areas of high water stress (UN Water, 2007).
By 2025, water withdrawals are predicted to increase by 50% in developing countries and 18% in
developed countries (WWAP, 2006), while nearly 1.8 billion people will be living in areas under
severe water stress and the meeting of the water requirements for different uses (agriculture, industry,
domestic purposes, energy and the environment, etc.) will be in the threshold (UN Water 2007).
Furthermore, it has to be noted that existing water resources are threatened by the sources' pollution,
which affects the inland and coastal aquatic ecosystems. Also, climate change due to global warming
can strongly affect the availability of water resources in a small or a wider region.
OECD Members enjoy high levels of access to networked systems of water supply and sanitation.
However, OECD (2009) strongly doubts whether its Members will be able to face the major water
and sanitation challenges even in urban areas due to the major investments required to repair and
replace ageing infrastructure and the cost associated with meeting more stringent environmental
requirements. For this reason, it recommends research on alternative sources in terms of water supply.
In particular, it recommends RWH, grey and reclaimed water as alternative water sources.
Regarding the physical alternatives to realize sustainable management of freshwater, there are two
solutions. The first one is to find alternative or additional water resources by using conventional
centralized systems, while the second is the limited use of available water resources in a more efficient
way. Till today, much attention has been paid to the first case. Due to the difficulty of developing
new freshwater resources, rainwater harvesting, water reclamation and reuse are important additional
water resources. Moreover, collection, protection and re-use of rainwater are a viable process that can
significantly increase available water resources and also reduce flood risks. Harvested rainwater is an
alternative source of water in many parts around the world.
The purpose of this paper is to investigate the current situation for rainwater harvesting as a tool to
confront water scarcity, as well as the prospects for the spreading of the method in the various
countries of the world.
2.
BRIEF OUTLINE OF THE HISTORY OF RAINWATER HARVESTING (RWH)
RWH is a very old traditional and sustainable practice that has been adopted in many regions of the
world as a water supply method both for potable and non-potable purposes. In many parts of the
world, archaeological findings confirm that ways and means of collecting and storing rainwater for
supplying water to human use, livestock farming and irrigation had been devised since antiquity. At
that time the method of rain collection was very simple, while the use of water was immediate without
any treatment. Probably, the first water collection system was a cavity either in a low permeability
soil or in the rock in which the runoff was captured from the upstream surfaces.
People in ancient communities, which were situated in arid and semiarid regions without an access
to springs, lakes, perennial rivers or other water sources had to cleverly manage the available water
resources, which were unfortunately deficient (Evenari et al., 1961). Rainwater was the main source
of water for potable and non-potable use, thus rainwater harvesting was extremely important for their
survival.
RWH was practiced about 4500 years ago by the people of the city Ur in the region of Sumer
(southern Mesopotamia, in modern-day Iraq) and later by Nabateans and other people of the Middle
East (Sivanappan, 2006). The concept of RWH must have been applied in China 6000 years ago
(TWDB, 2005). However, archaeological evidence in the Edom Mountains in southern Jordan
indicates the existence of water collection systems even 9000 years ago for agricultural purposes.
Evenari et al. (1961) described water collection systems in the Negev desert of Israel, which were
probably constructed about 4000 years ago (ca. 2000 BC), or more.
65
Water resources management and contamination control
During prehistoric times (ca. 3200-1100BC), large stone conduits with branches were used to supply
collected water to cisterns in different Minoan cities (Knossos, Phaistos, Tylissos, Zakros, etc.)
(Yannopoulos et al., 2017). Archaeological evidences show that in the Palace of Knossos owned a
sophisticated rainwater collection and storage system, which had been in use as early as 1700 BC.
Probably, this might be the first example of RWH in a building.
The cistern construction technology of the Minoans and Mycenaeans was improved by the ancient
Greeks during Archaic (c. 800-479 BC), Classical (478-323 BC), and Hellenistic (323-30 BC)
periods. Specifically, during Hellenistic era, in several Greek cities rainwater was harvested through
open spaces on the roofs, yards and other open spaces into covered cisterns for storage and future use,
so as to meet their daily water needs (Yannopoulos et al., 2017). Numerous cisterns have been found
in private or public buildings, quadrilateral, circular or bottle shaped. They were flat, pitched or
vaulted roofed, while many of them were multi sectioned for water’s filtration.
Afterwards, Roman private and public buildings included cisterns, usually under paved courtyards,
in order to collect rainwater and increase the water available from the city's aqueducts. Their
similarities with the rainwater tanks found in Minoan and Mycenaeans palaces or in
Classical/Hellenistic buildings, in their form and technical characteristics, and generally in the whole
technology related to their construction are more than obvious. The rectangular open space, called
compluvium, which was gathering the rainwater falling on the surrounding roof into a basin placed
below (Impluvium), so as to be available for household use, was a main architectural feature of Roman
villas and houses.
Collection and storage of rainwater in earthen tanks for domestic and agricultural uses was also very
common in India, where simple stone-rubble structures for impounding rainwater date back to the
third millennium BC. In China, the history of rainwater harvesting dates back to 4,000 years. The
RWH and management in the country included cisterns, roof open spaces, soil or rock pits, ditches
and micro-dams (Akpinar-Ferrand and Cecunjanin, 2014). There are, also, several archaeological
findings that suggest that RWH was common in many areas of the world, including Egypt, Thailand,
Mexico, Pakistan, Ethiopia, Jordan, Korea, Sardinia, etc.
3.
REVIVAL OF INTEREST FOR RAINWATER HARVESTING
As Fidelibus and Bainbridge (1995) reported, “like many great solutions to environmental problems
rainfall catchments (“water harvesting methods”) are a reinterpretation of ancient techniques
developed in the Middle East and Americas, but forgotten by modern science and technology”.
However, the increasing urbanization affected RWH practice which was reduced or even almost
abandoned because of: (a) the available technical means during the industrial era, which made the
water transfer from remote areas possible, through long and complex systems; (b) the ability to
withdraw water form deep aquifers, so as to ensure the supply of large quantities of water, for industry
and urban water demands; (c) the ability to manage large quantities of water and supply it constantly
and safely via organized networks.
During the 20th century, and specifically before 1950, very few activities had taken place on the
research and implementation of water collection techniques. In particular, farmers in Australia had
already begun collecting water for domestic use and livestock after World War I. During the World
War II, there has been some water harvesting activities on islands with high rainfall, as e.g. in Antiqua
(Prinz and Malik, 2003).
Interest in water harvesting, both at the research and application level, was renewed partly due to the
successful reconstruction of the water collection system for irrigation (1958 and 1959) by Evenari
and his colleagues in the Negev desert of Israel. Pacey and Cullis (1986) consider that the work of
Evenari et al. (1961) was of great significance due to the runoff farming models applied, the
completeness of the research they made and the historical sources of the models they used. Modern
water harvesting research was started in the 1950’s by H. J. Geddes, Professor of the University of
66
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Sydney in Australia, who, according to Myers (1961), gave the first definition of water harvesting, in
his attempt to differentiate "the collection end economic storage of farm runoff for irrigation" from
"normal farm water conservation to provide water for livestock or household purposes" in the context
of a project of the University of Sydney.
In the U.S.A. water harvesting begun during the 1940’s and was generalized in the early 1950’s when
several small catchments were built from small sheets of steel and concrete to provide drinking water
to animals and wildlife. Lauritzen in the 1950's had pioneered an innovative technique of constructing
catchments and reservoirs, that required the evaluation and use of plastic and artificial rubber
membranes.
In 1955, an important movement in research interest took place, when cooperative studies on the
collection of water for the livestock between the U.S. Department of Agriculture and the Utah
Agricultural Experiment Station started by using the soil itself as a catchment surface and by treating
it with waterproofing and stabilizing materials. In these studies, various soil cover materials were
evaluated, such as plastic vinyl films and polyethylene-butyl rubber sheets, asphalt-coated jute
fabrics, and chemical sealants (Lauritzen, 1960). Of these materials, plastic butyl films, when not
under tension, exhibited excellent wear resistance from exposure to solar radiation, and their
installation was relatively simple. However, many of these high cost structures, which were used only
by public authorities on public lands, failed within 5-10 years mainly due to strong winds, which
caused extensive damages. In 1960’s, systematic studies were initiated by various organizations
(governmental, private, and universities) in the U.S.A., as well as in other arid or semiarid countries
that concerned both the development and the assessment of new methods and materials to be used for
the construction of water collection systems at low installation costs and the improvement of system
reliability (Frasier and Myers, 1983).
Further incentives for investigating the possibilities of water collection to improve plant production
were provided due to the widespread droughts that occurred in the 1970's and 1980's in Africa and
their effects on crops. Much of the experience with rainwater harvesting was gained in Israel, U.S.A.
and Australia. However, this experience has limited relevance to resource-poor areas in the semi-arid
regions of Africa and Asia (Critchley and Siegert, 1991).
Moreover, interest in collecting and storing water for irrigation purposes was enhanced due to the
improvements of the earthmoving machinery and sealing soil materials, which were reducing the cost
and difficulty of preparing catchment for collecting water and they were improving the efficiency of
the collection system. In general, since the 1950's series of experiments developed the variety and
sophistication of the water harvesting technology.
In recent years, many countries have renewed their attention in water collection techniques, which
are regarded as a viable decentralized water source. The renewal of interest is also related to the role
that decentralized water collection systems can play to mitigate flood risks, etc. and because the
decentralized multi-purpose rainwater harvesting systems constitute useful infrastructures to mitigate
other water related disasters, such as sudden water break and fire events, especially in highly
developed urban areas. Nowadays, the art of collecting rainwater has received renewed attention and
interest in many countries of the world as a viable decentralized water source e.g. Germany, Italy,
Spain, France etc. in Europe; India, China, Malaysia, Japan etc. in Asia; Kenya, Ethiopia, Syria, etc.
in Africa; in several states of U.S.A. (Nevada, Utah, etc.), Canada in North America; Brazil in South
America; and Australia and New Zealand (Yannopoulos et al., 2017).
In the framework of the present study, RWH means the method by which rainfall that falls upon a
surface catchment area (roof, sidewalks, parking lots, landscape areas, etc.) is collected and routed to
a storage facility for direct or future use (domestic and agricultural use). It is noted that RWH does
not reduce the demand, but it can reduce the water abstraction needs.
67
Water resources management and contamination control
4.
EXAMPLES OF RWH AND UTILIZATION AROUND THE WORLD
In recent decades, the interest in rainwater harvesting for both developing and developed countries
(including several EU Member States) is growing. Notably, researches and applications have been
carried out at various levels on: (a) the use and management of RWH; (b) the quality of harvested
rainwater; and (c) hydrological or economic data for RWH.
In several countries, both governments and local / regional authorities have promoted measures to
install and use RWH systems, mostly under a legal framework, with financial incentives (subsidies,
reductions or tax refunds, etc.). For example, some form of RWH is mandatory for buildings and
houses in various cities and states of India (New Delhi, Indore, Chennai, Rajastan, etc.), Catalonia in
Spain, Flanders in Belgium, in new buildings of some states of U.S.A. (Tucson, Arizona, New
Mexico, etc.), in many Caribbean islands, in Germany (Hessen, Baden-Württemberg, Saarland,
Bremen, Thuringen, Hamburg, etc.) The same is true in some Australian States, such as South
Australia, New South Wales and Queensland, where regulations stipulate a new rainwater collection
system or alternative water source.
Meanwhile, manuals were developed about designing, constructing and managing of rainwater
harvesting systems e.g. in the U.K., Malaysia, Japan, India, Canada, etc. In U.S.A. rainwater
harvesting is not regulated by the federal government but rather it is up to individual States to regulate
the collection and use of rainwater. Some States including Georgia, North Carolina, Texas, etc., have
published manuals that provide information on the types of processing systems and components
needed for meeting specific water quality objectives. In addition, at municipal level, several major
cities, such as Los Angeles, San Francisco, Tucson, and Portland have issued guidelines and/or policy
documents on treatment and permitting requirements for rainwater collection systems (USEPA,
2013).
To the best of our knowledge, there is neither European nor national regulations on the definition of
quality standards for rainwater uses within the European Union. In several countries of the European
Union, such as France (Décret du 2 Juillet 2008), the United Kingdom (BS 815, 2009), some
standards have been proposed, which are merely guidelines (directives) focusing on domestic uses of
rainwater. In Spain, there is the Royal Decree 1620/2007 which establishes quality standards for
possible uses for recycled water (Llopart-Mascaró et al., 2010). However, there is a lot of interest for
rainwater harvesting in many European countries including Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Cyprus,
Malta, United Kingdom, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Portugal, etc.
RWH is not restricted in simple small-scale roof collection systems, but it is extended to: (a) larger
systems usually used for providing water for schools, stadiums, airports, etc.; (b) collection systems
for high rise buildings in urbanized areas; (c) land surface catchment systems, and stormwater
collection systems to prevent water sources’ pollution from roads, industrial sites, and agriculture.
Large-scale RWH systems exist: (a) in Germany, such as in Berlin the DaimlerChrysler Potsdamer
Platz and the building complex at Belss-Luedecke-Strasse; in Darmstadt the Technical University; in
Frankfurt the Airport, etc.; (b) in the U.K., such as in London the Millennium Dome, the Museum,
the Velodrome, etc.; in Manchester the Honda Dealership; in Bristol the Imperial Tobacco Head; (c)
in Singapore the Changi Airport; (d) in Japan, such as in Sumida city the Ryogoku Kokugikan Sumowrestling Arena, the Town Hall, etc.; in Tokyo the Rojison, the Sky Tower, etc.
In developed countries including Japan, Singapore, Belgium, France, Germany, U.S.A., etc. RWH is
mainly used to supplement conventional systems for non-drinking water use, while in Australia the
collected water has also potable use. In developing countries, such as Bangladesh, Botswana, India,
Kenya, etc. RWH is mainly used to address water shortages for both potable and non-potable use
(Lade and Oloke, 2015).
In several Latin American countries, such as Argentina, Brazil, Costa Rica, Chile, Mexico and Peru,
the RWH practice from roofs for domestic consumption is applied, while in the semi-arid areas of
68
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Argentina, Brazil and Venezuela, runoff collection from roads in drainage ditches and street gutters
is used, from which water is then transferred to cultivated areas for irrigation (Ringler et al., 2000).
In Australian cities, RWH is popular. In urban areas, RWH systems are used to complement the main
water system, whereas many rural and peri-urban communities completely rely on this. 30% of rural
Australians use RWH while in the capital cities the 7% use it. About 13% of all Australian households
(2.6x106 people) use RWH systems as a primary source of drinking water (Coombes, 2006). Local
authorities throughout Australia encourage the use of RWH systems in urban areas to supplement
main water supplies and to manage urban stormwater runoff. For this reason, the Australian, State
and local governments, adopted a wide range of policies including (subsidies and grants) so as to
provide the installation of rainwater tanks in houses. These incentives vary from State to State,
depending on the size of the water reservoir and the purpose of using the collected water. In South
Australia, almost 50% of the population lives in houses equipped with a rainwater tank. RWH is
mandatory for new homes in Queensland (CMΗC, 2013).
In the USA, rainwater harvesting has become an increasingly common practice. Since 2004, it is
estimated that about 100,000 residential RWH systems were in use in the USA and its territories
(TWDB, 2005). Some States and Territories (Hawaii, Kentucky, New Mexico, North Carolina, Ohio,
Oregon, Texas, Utah, Washington, etc.) consider RWH as a serious practice for protecting water
resources and also, for increasing available volume of water for potable use. However, even though
the major use of harvested rainwater is for landscape watering, flushing toilets, etc. there are a number
of systems that serve indoor uses as well. It is worth mentioning, that with proper design and
appropriate treatment, harvested rainwater is considered as a safe and dependable source of water for
potable uses, particularly in remote communities (Krishna, 2007).
In Bermuda, rooftop RWH is compulsory by law for all buildings and constitutes the primary source
of water for domestic supply. Public Health Act regulates the details for the maintenance and
conservation of the catchments, tanks, gutters, pipes, vents, and screens in order to be maintained in
good situation (Lo and Gould, 2015).
In Canada, most of RWH systems are for residential use in rural areas, where there is no access to
central public water supply systems. In cities, most cases relate to buildings that have been certified
according to one of the green building rating systems, in which the reuse of rainwater and the
reduction of runoff were taken into account (E.A., 2010). Since 2010 National Plumbing Code is in
force which permits the use of rainwater for toilet and urinal flushing, as well as subsurface irrigation.
In addition, it permits the use of rainwater, both for all indoor and outdoor, depending on the level of
treatment. RWH is mandatory for new homes in Queensland (CMΗC, 2013). In Ontario, several
municipalities recognize RWH as an important tool of confronting water resources management
problems. The City of Toronto and the Regional Municipality of Waterloo have been active in
promoting the technology through stormwater and green building policies (TRCA, 2010).
In Mexico, RWH can make a significant contribution to reduce the water supply shortage that occurs
in large areas of the country. In Guanajuato city of Central Mexico a project was conducted to harvest
rainwater using the roof areas of the houses in a community with an average annual rainfall of 455.3
mm and water storage tanks of a 2.5 m3 capacity were installed in roofs of 74 m2. Both in the City
and in rural areas hundreds of catchment systems have already been installed (Lizárraga-Mendiola et
al., 2015).
In Brazil, there is no legislation to cover the RWH at the federal level. Since 2007, NBR-15227 is in
force, which has normative character and regulates the use of rainwater for non-potable purposes in
urban areas. However, there are various cities and municipalities with laws that regulate the
catchment and storage of rainwater for non-potable uses. Since 2002, the city of Sao Paulo is pioneer
as it implemented the first law regulating these aspects. Thence, other major cities including Rio de
Janeiro, Curitiba, Paraiba, among others, have been implementing similar regulations. Due to the
large number of different laws and regulations in force in the different parts of the country it is
69
Water resources management and contamination control
difficult to assess the extent to which Brazil is implementing RWH as an alternative to the municipal
water supply systems (da Costa et al., 2017).
In African countries rainwater collection systems are increasingly adopted. However, despite the
rapid expansion of these systems progress is slow, because of: (a) the low rainfall and its seasonal
nature, (b) the small number and size of impervious roofs, (c) the high cost of constructing catchment
systems in relation to typical household incomes, (d) the lack of cement and pure graded sand in some
parts of Africa, and (e) the lack of sufficient water for construction industry, which burden the total
cost. However, RWH systems are increasingly expanding in Africa with works in Botswana, Mali,
Malawi, South Africa, Namibia, Zimbabwe, Tanzania, etc. (UN-HABITAT, 2005).
The effort to develop rainwater collection systems in Africa is led by Kenya, which has a very long
tradition in these systems through the centuries. Since late 1970s, interest in RWH has rapidly grown.
In different parts of the country, many RWH projects have been carried out, each one with their own
designs and implementation strategies, in an effort to provide long-term solutions to water resource
problems (UN-HABITAT, 2005). In the middle of the 20th century, the Government began to build
rock catchment systems that served communities in the semi-arid area of Kitui district (Lo and Gould,
2015). The variety of geographic and climatic conditions in the country has enabled the development
of a very wide range of RWH technologies for water supply, agriculture and livestock. In Nairobi,
there are several manufacturers of water tank from plastic, metal and other materials. These tanks are
sold everywhere in East Africa and beyond (Lo and Gould, 2015). In many parts of Kenya, the United
Nations Development Program and the World Bank consider rainwater storage tanks as an essential
part of their programs on water supply and sanitation (Liu et al., 2016). It is noted, although it is not
mandatory for institutional buildings to dispose RWH facilities, many of them especially in the rural
areas have those facilities. In 1994, the Kenya Rainwater Association was established, which is the
first national RWH association in Africa. Since then, tens of thousands of rainwater collection
systems have been built in Kenya by a wide range of organizations, as a result millions of people are
benefiting from these systems (Lo and Gould, 2015).
Japan is one of the developed countries in Asia, which has a strong international exchange of
experience on the use of RWH. Since the mid-80s, Tokyo and other Japanese cities, as well as most
municipalities and organizations of the country, have given particular importance to RWH so as to
safe water supplies to deal with emergencies, floods, rehabilitation of the natural hydrological cycle
and exploration of alternative water sources for non-potable use (König, 2001). Moreover, the
abnormal drought of 1994 and the Great Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake of 1995 highlighted the
importance of securing water supplies from the viewpoint of disaster preparedness. A large number
of municipalities re-evaluated the importance of RWH and tried to identify alternative water
resources, as a means to prevent urban flooding and to secure emergency water for disaster responses.
The issue was regulated by ordinance and guidelines according to the local conditions (Furumai et
al., 2008). According to the survey of the Association for Rainwater Storage and Infiltration
Technology held in April 2011, 208 Municipalities are implementing subsidy programs for
establishment of facilities for storing or filtration systems of rainwater and of these, 179 provide
subsidies for installation of rainwater tank. In April 2014, the Japanese Diet passed the Act to
Advance the Utilization of Rainwater, which went into force the May 2015. Under this Act,
Municipalities are obliged to do their best effort to define and work toward rainwater utilization
targets, while the national government is required to grant financial support for subsidy programs.
These arrangements are expected to provide a national mobilization to promote technical rainwater
use (JFS, 2014). On March 10, 2015 Japanese government, based on the above Act, approved the
wider usage of RWH systems in newly constructed buildings by the state government or incorporated
administrative agencies, aiming for a 100% installation rate (JFS, 2015).
In China, the growing interest for the RWH initiated in 1980s due to the widespread droughts of that
decade, which was followed by serious shortages of drinking water and crop failures (Li, 2003). RWH
practice and utilization is applied mainly in areas with the following types of water scarcity (Liu et
al., 2016): (a) In water deficient areas with a lack of water resources, such as Gansu and central
70
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Ningxia. (b) In areas with seasonal water deficit, such as Fujian, Guizhou and other hilly areas. (c) In
areas with water deficit, but also with difficulty in exploitation, such as the southwest mountainous
areas of the country. (d) In water deficient areas with poor water quality, e.g. brackish water, fluoride
water, high-arsenic water, etc. In these areas, authorities have constructed water cellars, tanks, ponds
and other miniature water conservancy projects as an effective solution to the problem of water
shortage. Unfortunately, there are still problems of water deficit. Seventeen provinces in the country
have adopted the RWH practice by building 5,600,000 tanks with a total capacity of 1.8x109 m3
supplying water about 15x106 people and supplemental irrigation of 1.2x106 ha of land (Lo and
Gould, 2015). RWH systems are also applied in provinces of Northwestern China (Ningxia Region,
Shanxi Shaanxi and the Inner Mongolia Region) as well as in Southwest and Southeast provinces of
the country (Guangxi Region and Guizhou Province). The implementation of rainwater collection has
a significant impact on the development of China's semi-arid rural areas and has practically solved
the drinking water problems of populations living in semi-arid mountainous areas of the country (Li,
2003).
In India, RWH was revived in the 1960s in response to declining groundwater availability caused by
the rapid expansion of irrigation pumping. Many Indian's cities have insufficient water supplies to
meet their needs. Urban development makes it both difficult and expensive to build dams, pipelines
and canals commonly used nowadays in order to supply water to cities. RWH was supporting
agriculture for many years in India, while there is a demand in urban areas for novel methods for
decentralized water supply systems. Since 2000 onwards, the legislation on RWH has been changed
in the various States and federal regions of the country and it is compulsory for the new buildings.
The rooftop RWH systems are mandatory for new buildings in 18 of the 28 States and 4 of the 7
Federal Regions of the country (MARWAS AG, 2010).
Germany has developed new and sophisticated RWH systems and techniques and is considered as
one of the leading countries in the world in this field. In particular, Germany has more than 1.5x106
integrated rainwater systems not only in homes for toilet use, but also for car washes and garden
irrigation and also, in service water demanding industries (Herrmann and Schmida, 1999). According
to the Environmental Agency (E.A., 2010), 35% of new buildings in the country are equipped with a
RWH system, and such new systems are installed every year from 50,000 (Nolde, 2007) to 80,000
(Partzsch, 2009). As Partzsch (2009) pointed out, in 2005, every third new building in Germany was
supplied with a rainwater storage tank. In Germany, the promotion of RWH in households became
widespread since the 1980s (Nolde, 2007).
In the U.K., the modern RWH systems have been introduced relatively recently (E.A., 2010), since
the interest in RWH research, technology, development and utilization has yet to mature, although
several initiatives are in place to promote RWH (Ward, 2007). The Code for Sustainable Homes,
which is in force in England, Northern Ireland and Wales, is supporting and encourages the promotion
of RWH systems installation in new houses. In particular, owners of new homes are encouraged to
save money and water resources by installing RWH systems for toilets, washing clothes, garden
watering and car washing. According to UKRHA (2006), approximately 100,000 RWH systems
already exist in the U.K. and approximately 4,000 systems per year are installed, which are commonly
internally plumbed to supply toilet flushing as well as garden irrigation.
In France, the interest in RWH for indoor and outdoor uses has increased and it constitutes serious
issue even in the urban areas. As Gerolin et al. (2013) pointed out "rainwater harvesting (RWH) has
known a revival of interest since the establishment in 2006 of a national tax credit for households
implementing a rainwater collection system". Since 2008, a decree (French Government Order of 21
August 2008) concerning RWH is in force. In reality, it is about regulations, which define better
management of the use of rainwater and the precise technical requirements to be met by the
components of the collection systems supplying both outdoor and indoor uses. Specifically, the
regulations prohibit the use of harvested rainwater for drinking, showering or bathing, but they allow
its use for toilet flushing, cleaning the ground and under certain conditions, washing clothes (Vialle
71
Water resources management and contamination control
et al., 2015). In France, according to a survey conducted in 2009, 15% of the population has a RWH
system in urban areas (Belmeziti et al., 2013).
Belgium has national legislation that supports RWH, which stipulates that all new constructions must
have a rainwater collection system, the water of which can be used for washing the toilet and for
external water uses. In Flanders, it is estimated that 10% of current household water consumption
comes from RWH, which could be increased to 25% by 2025. It is estimated that households account
for 72% of the total rainwater use in Flanders. (Campling et al., 2008).
In Portugal, the ERSAR (Water and Waste Services Regulation) guidelines allow the use of RWH
only for non-potable use and, in particular, for irrigation purposes. ANQIP (National Association for
the Quality of Building Installations), a nonprofit organization promoting water sustainability at
building level, published in 2012 a technical document (ETA 0701, 2012) describing the procedures
to be taken into account regarding installation of rainwater collection systems in Portuguese buildings
(Silva et al., 2015).
In Malta a significant proportion of 35.4% of households are currently using RWH, of which 33.6%
collect it in underground cisterns and a small percentage of 1.8% in plastic containers. Since 2004,
the exploitation of RWH in new constructions is regulated by plan of the MEPA (Malta Environment
and Planning Authority), which regulates the creation of water collecting surfaces on roofs, the
possible size and capacity of the tanks etc. (Reitano, 2011).
5.
CONCLUSIONS
One of the biggest challenges of the 21st century is tacking the growing water shortages worldwide.
The continued increasing demand for water from various competing users (domestic, agriculture,
industry, environment use, etc.) and also, urbanization, climate change, water pollution, etc. exert
pressures on the existing water resources. For these reasons, many countries are facing water shortage.
In general, the strategy, that they followed, was constructing of large-scale projects (dams, pipelines
of long length, pump stations, etc.). Nevertheless their construction has not been proven to be able to
meet water needs of the different users, while at the same time has significant social, economic and
environmental impacts, and requires significant investment. So, searching for alternative water
sources (grey water, desalination and RWH) has attracted worldwide interest. Rainwater harvesting
is seen as a more promising alternative or supplementary water resource due to minimal
environmental impact, the low treatment needs in comparison with other alternative water sources,
the benefits from flood mitigation, and many more.
RWH is not a new technique, since it has been a very old traditional practice, which has been adopted
in many regions of the world and is dated back several hundred years. In antiquity, the main uses of
harvested rainwater were for domestic, irrigation and livestock purposes. Nevertheless, RWH, which
was a worldwide technology, was neglected over the past 150 years due to the new technologies
which enable us to store, pump from deep groundwater and transport huge volumes of water (ground
and surface) via dams, pump stations and long length pipelines.
The literature reveals the interest and use of RWH systems, on a global basis, is increasing continually
about from the beginning of the second half of the previous century onwards. As Yannopoulos et al.
(2017) state: “Worldwide, rainwater harvesting has retrieved its importance as a valuable water
resource, alternative or supplementary, in conjunction with more conventional water supply
technologies. If rainwater harvesting is practiced more widely, many water shortages, actual or
potential, can be alleviated.”
Nowadays, many countries all over the world consider RWH as a viable decentralized water source.
However, a significant push to extend this technique is needed. Specifically, significant efforts are
still needed in research, investments, information, education of the public on the importance of
rainwater harvesting, economic incentives (subsidies and tax exemptions), suitable legislation and
regulations.
72
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Until today, two approaches have been applied concerning the extension of RWH, namely either
voluntary via incentive based programs or mandated regulations. In several countries the government
subsidies and rebate programs can be particularly effective in promoting RWH implementation. In
contrary to regulations that require compliance, subsidies target individuals with an appreciation for
RWH and provide an incentive for them to pursue adoption of this practice.
References
1. Akpinar Ferrand E. and F. Cecunjanin (2014) Potential of rainwater harvesting in a thirsty world:
a survey of ancient and traditional rainwater harvesting applications, Geography Compass, 8(6),
pp. 395–413.
2. Belmeziti A., O. Coutard and B. de Gouvello (2013) “A New Methodology for Evaluating
Potential for Potable Water Savings (PPWS) by Using Rainwater Harvesting at the Urban Level:
The Case of the Municipality of Colombes (Paris Region)”, Water, 5, pp. 312-326.
3. Campling P., L. De Nocker, W. Schiettecatte, A.I. Iacovides, T. Dworak, M.A. Arenas, C.C. Pozo,
O. Le Mat, V. Mattheiß and F. Kervarec (2008) “Assessment of the Risks and Impacts of Four
Alternative Water Supply Options”, European Commission – DG Environment.
4. CMΗC (Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation) (2013) “Collecting and Using Rainwater
at Home: A Guide for Homeowners”, CMHC, Canada.
5. Coombes P. (2006) “Guidance on the Use of Rainwater Harvesting Systems for Rain
Harvesting”, Available at: http://rainharvesting.com.au/wp-content/uploads/media_ Resea
rch_Assoc_Prof_Peter_Coomber_Expert_Report_for_Guidance_of_Rainwater_Harvesting_Syst
ems_2006.pdf (accessed January 20, 2017).
6. Critchley W. and W.K. Siegert (1991) “Water Harvesting: A Manual for the Design and
Construction of Water Harvesting Schemes for Plant Production”, AGL/MICS/17/91, Food
and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), Rome, Italy.
7. da Costa Pacheco P.R., Y. Dumit Gómez, I. Ferreira de Oliveira and L.C. Girard Teixeira (2017)
“A view of the legislative scenario for rainwater harvesting in Brazil”, Journal of Cleaner
Poduction, 141, pp. 290-294.
8. E.A. (Environmental Agency) (2010) “Harvesting Rainwater for Domestic Uses: An
Information Guide”, Environment Agency, Bristol, U.K.
9. Evenari M. L., L. Shanan, N. Tadmor and Y. Aharoni. (1961) “Ancient agriculture in the Negev”,
Science, 133, pp. 979-996.
10. Fidelibus M. W. and D.A. Bainbridge (1995) “Microcatchment Water Harvesting for Desert
Revegetation”, SERG Restoration Bulletin 5, San Diego State University, San Diego, CA.
11. Frasier G. W. and L. E. Myers (1983) “Handbook of Water Harvesting”, U.S. Department of
Agriculture, Agriculture Handbook No. 600.
12. Furumai H., J. Kim, M. Imbe and H. Okui (2008) Recent application of rainwater storage and
harvesting in Japan, 3rd IWA International Rainwater Harvesting and Management
Workshop as a part of IWA-Viena World Water Congress & Exhibition, 7pp., Vienna,
Austria.
13. Gerolin A., N. Le Nouveau and B. de Gouvello (2013) Rainwater harvesting for stormwater
management: example-based typology and current approaches for evaluation to question French
practices, 8ème International Conference, Novatech, 10 pp., Lyon, France.
14. Haque M.M., Α. Rahman and B. Samali (2016) “Evaluation of climate change impacts on
rainwater harvesting”, Journal οf Cleaner Productions, 137, pp. 60-69.
73
Water resources management and contamination control
15. Herrmann T. and U. Schmida (1999) “Rainwater Utilisation in Germany: efficiency,
dimensioning, hydraulic and environmental aspects”, Urban Water, 1, pp. 307-316.
16. JFS (Japan for Sustainability) (August 24, 2014) “Let's Use Rainwater! Recent Trends in
Rainwater Use in Japan”. Available at: http://www.japanfs.org/en/news/archives/
news_id035023.html (accessed January 20, 2017).
17. JFS (Japan for Sustainability) (May 25, 2015) “Cabinet of Japan Decide to Make Full Use of
Rainwater in Newly Constructed Buildings”,. Available at: http://www.japanfs.org/en/news/
archives/news_id035257.html (accessed January 20, 2017).
18. König K. (2001) “The Rainwater Technology Handbook” (1st ed.), Wilo-Brain.
19. Krishna, H.J. (2007) Development of Alternative Water Resources in the USA: Progress with
Rainwater Harvesting, 13th International Rainwater Catchment Systems Conference on Rainwater
and Urban Design, 8pp., Sydney, Australia.
20. Lade O. and D. Oloke (2015) “Modelling Rainwater System Harvesting in Ibadan, Nigeria:
Application to a Residential Apartment”, American Journal of Civil Engineering and
Architecture, 3(3), pp. 86-100.
21. Lauritzen C.W. (1960) “Ground Covers for Collecting Precipitation”, Farm & Home Science,
21(3), Utah Science, 21(3), Article 1, pp.66-67.
22. Li X.-Y. (2003) “Rainwater harvesting for agricultural production in the semiarid loess region of
China Food”, Agriculture and Environment, 1(3&4), pp. 282-285.
23. Lizárraga-Mendiola L., G. Vázquez-Rodríguez, A. Blanco-Piñón, Y. Rangel-Martínez and M.
González-Sandoval (2015) “Estimating the Rainwater Potential per Household in an Urban Area:
Case Study in Central Mexico”, Water, 7, pp. 4622-4637.
24. Llopart-Mascaró A., R. Ruiz, M. Martínez, P. Malgrat, M. Rusiñol, A. Gil, J. Suárez, J. Puertas,
H. del Rio, M. Paraira and P. Rubio (2010) Analysis of rainwater quality: Towards sustainable
rainwater management in urban environments -Sostaqua Project, NOVATECH 2010.
25. Liu, L.-S., L.-G. Liu, L.-X. Wu, L.-P. Wu and W.J. Huo (2016) “Problems and
countermeasures on the safety of rainwater harvesting for drinking in China”, MATEC Web
of Conferences 68, ICIEA 2016.
26. Lo A.G. and J. Gould (2015) Chapter 7. Rainwater Harvesting: Global Overview, in: Rainwater
Harvesting for Agriculture and Water Supply, Q. Zhu, J. Gould, Y.-H. Li and C.-X. Ma (eds.),
Springer, pp. 213-233.
27. MARWAS AG (2010) “Water & Water Treatment in India. Market Opportunities for Swiss
Companies”, Osec, Zurich, Switzerland.
28. Myers L. E. (1961) “Waterproofing soil to collect precipitation”, Journal of Soil and Water
Conservation, 16(6), pp. 281-282.
29. Nolde E. (2007) “Possibilities of rainwater utilisation in densely populated areas including
precipitation runoffs from traffic surfaces”, Desalination, 215, pp. 1-11.
30. OECD (2009) “Alternative Ways of Providing Water Emerging Options and Their Policy
Implications”, Advance copy for 5th World Water Forum. Available at
www.oecd.org/env/resources/42349741.pdf (accessed May 15, 2016).
31. Pacey A. and A. Cullis (1989) “Rainwater Harvesting: The collection of rainfall and runoff
in rural areas”, Intermediate Technology Publications, London, U.K.
32. Partzsch L. (2009) “Smart regulation for water innovation - the case of decentralized rainwater
technology”, Journal of Cleaner Production, 17, pp. 985-991.
74
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
33. Prinz D. and A.H. Malik (2003) “Runoff farming”, WCA, InfoNET
34. Reitano R. (2011) “Water Harvesting and Water Collection Systems in Mediterranean Area. The
Case of Malta”, Procedia Engineering, 21, pp. 81-88.
35. Ringler C., W. Mark, M.W. Rosegrant and M.S. Paisner (2000) “Irrigation and Water
Resources in Latin America and the Caribbean: Challenges and Strategies”, International
Food Policy Research Institute. Washington, D.C. U.S.A.. EPTD Discussion Paper No. 64.
36. Silva C.M., V. Sousa and N.V. Carvalho (2015) “Evaluation of rainwater harvesting in Portugal:
Application to single-family residences”, Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 94, pp. 2134.
37. Sivanappan R. K. (2006) Rain Water Harvesting, Conservation and Management Strategies for
Urban and Rural Sectors, National Seminar on Rainwater Harvesting and Water
Management, pp. 1-5, Nagpur, India.
38. TRCA (Toronto and Region Conservation Authority) (2010) “Performance Evaluation of
Rainwater Harvesting Systems, Toronto, Ontario. Sustainable Technologies Evaluation
Program (STEP)”, Final Report 2010 (revised June 2011). Available at:
www.sustainabletechnologies.ca (accessed January 20, 2017).
39. TWDB (Texas Water Development Board) (2005) “The Texas Manual on Rainwater
Harvesting” (3rd. ed.), Texas Water Development Board, Austin, Texas, USA.
40. UKRHA (United Kingdom Rainwater Harvesting Association) (2006) “Enhanced Capital
Allowance Scheme as it Applies to Rainwater Harvesting Systems”, The U.K. Rainwater
Harvesting Association, Industry Fact Sheet No 3.
41. UNDESA (United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs) (2011) “World
Urbanization Prospects: The 2011 Revision”, United Nations.
42. UN-HABITAT (2005) “Rainwater Harvesting and Utilisation”, Blue Drop Series, Book 2:
Beneficiaries & Capacity Builders, UN-HABITAT, Mtwapa, Kenya.
43. UN Water (2007) “Coping with water scarcity: challenge of the twenty-first century”,
Prepared for World Water Day 2007. Available at: http://www.unwater.org/wwd07/downloads/
documents/escarcity.pdf (accessed March 23, 2007).
44. USEPA (2013) Rainwater Harvesting: Conservation, Credit, Codes, and Cost Literature
Review and Case Studies”, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Office of Water,
Office of Wetlands, Oceans, and Watersheds. EPA-841-R-13-002.
45. Vialle C., G. Busset, L. Tanfin, M. Montrejaud-Vignoles, M.-C. Huau and C. Sablayrolles (2015)
“Environmental analysis of a domestic rainwater harvesting system: A case study in France”,
Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 102, pp. 178–184.
46. Ward S.L. (2007) “Rainwater Harvesting in the UK - Current Practice and Future Trends”,
Young Scientists Workshop, Amsterdam, Netherlands, April 1, 2007.
47. WWAP (World Water Assessment Program) (2006) “The State of the Resource, World Water
Development Report 2, Chapter 4”. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural
Organization, Paris.
48. Yannopoulos S., G. Antoniou, M. Kaiafa-Saropoulou and A. N. Angelakis (2017) “Historical
development of rainwater harvesting and use in Hellas: a preliminary review”, Water Science &
Technology: Water Supply, 17(4), pp. 1022-1034.
75
Water resources management and contamination control
MULTIOBJECTIVE OPTIMIZATION RAIN GARDENS USING
HARMONY SEARCH ALGORITHM
D. Karakatsanis * and A. Basdeki
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th, GR54124Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*Corresponding authors: e-mail: diamontkarakat@gmail.com
Abstract
The use of ecological rainwater management method and rain gardens in urban areas aims at: 1)
reduction of total rain water runoff and of its peak and 2) reduction of property damage and activity
disruption due to insufficient sewer network capacity. Rain Gardens cannot substitute by sewer
networks, but they can be used as integral parts of sewer systems in a cost-efficient way. In this paper
we apply and modify the Harmony Search Algorithm (HSA) in order to optimize the multi-objective
problem of rain gardens. A Matlab script that estimates Pareto front is developed for this purpose.
The HSA modification includes a gravity-factors system for every objective function. In conclusion
the Pareto front is calculated at four different sets of gravity factors.
Keywords: Rain garden, Optimization, Urban rainwater management, Harmony search algorithm,
Metaheuristic methods
1.
INTRODUCTION
The typical way to deal with rainwater in urban areas is construction of sewer networks, to achieve
its quick transfer away of the urban setting to sewage treatment facilities, exactly as it is done for
domestic sewage. Whenever, though, rain intensity and duration exceeds a certain threshold, sewer
networks fail to carry the required load and rainwater flows or stagnates on street surfaces, covers
sidewalks or, even worse, inundates shops and houses.
Integrated rainwater management combines the aforementioned classical approach with low impact
techniques (or sustainable management methods), such as rain gardens and green roofs. This type of
management is advantageous from the environmental aspect and could be prove more cost efficient
than sewer network upgrading.
These techniques promote an ecological growth pattern. The sustainable rainwater management
facilities are not substitutes to sewer networks, but they should operate in a complementary way with
the latter. These networks may fail to fully protect all parts of urban areas during heavy rain event, as
a result the use of street surfaces and sidewalks by pedestrians, due to water accumulating ,is a
challenging task and renders the car driving unsafe.
2.
DESCRIPTION OF RAIN GARDENS
Rain gardens can be constructed in many kinds of sites, such as pre-existing green spaces, stream
areas, squares, parking spaces, house yards, open spaces of building blocks, school and church yards,
along streets, etc.
A typical rain garden includes the following:
76
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
a) Ponding area: It is a natural or artificial ground depression. In rather flat areas it is constructed by
excavating soil from the ground surface. In sloping ground it is formed by soil excavation combined
with building of an earth berm at the down slope side, using excavation material. Surfaces with large
slope are not that suitable for rain garden construction.
The bottom of the rain garden is usually covered by a mulch layer, before constructing the top soil
layer. If water infiltration rate in the underlying strata is small, a gravel layer could be constructed on
the bottom of the ponding area. A perforated underdrain pipe could be used for the same reason.
b) Inflow structure, that directs rainwater from dounspouts or impermeable areas (streets, sidewalks)
to the ponding area
c) Overflow structure that allows water to exit the rain garden when the ponding are is full. This
structure is necessary in order to reduce erosion risk and to direct ouflowing water towards the desired
place (usually the sewer network).
3.
HARMONY SEARCH ALGORITHM
3.1 Relationship between music and mathematics
The relationship between music and mathematics has been close since the ancient times.
Mathematicians tried to interpret the governing rules of mathematics using the art of music. On the
other hand, composers tried to use mathematics in order to deeply understand music.
During recent times, since the Baroque period, this bond has been strengthened. Sometimes as a
conscious effort by musicians-composers and sometimes as part of a rumored and almost mystical
relationship, mathematics and music came closer. Iannis Xenakis represents a special example. His
deep knowledge both in mathematics and music is illustrated in his work on the use of mathematical
functions to compose music (1992) distinguishing him among the most eminent music figures of the
20th century.
3.2 Analysis of Harmony Search Algorithm (HSA)
3.2.1 The basic elements of the algorithm
The Harmony Search Algorithm is a stochastic meta-heuristic method based on the sequential
production of possible solutions. It belongs to the category of “neighborhood meta-heuristics” that
produce one possible solution (called “harmony”) in each iteration. Every possible solution consists
of a set of values of the decision variables of the function that needs to be optimized. During the
optimization process, a number of “harmonies” equal to the “Harmony Memory Size” are stored in
the “Harmony Memory” (HM), a database that includes the produced set of solutions. The
optimization process is completed as soon as the predefined total number of iterations has been
achieved (Geem, 2001).
3.2.2 Characteristics of the Harmony Search Algorithm
Following the definition of the decision variables, the Harmony Memory matrix is formulated.
Harmony Memory is m×n matrix, where m is the Harmony Memory Size and n, the number of
decision variables included in the objective function. Then, the algorithm begins producing and
evaluating new “Harmonies” through the application of HSA’s basic mechanisms:
1. Harmony Memory Consideration uses variables’ values already stored in the Harmony Memory.
This mechanism ensures that good solutions located during the optimization process will
contribute to the formation of even better solutions.
2. Some of the solutions selected by the Harmony Memory Consideration mechanism will be
slightly altered. This is the second mechanism of the algorithm named Pitch Adjustment and it is
performed by selecting a neighboring values of the decision variables
77
Water resources management and contamination control
3. The third mechanism is Improvisation, which introduces new, random elements to the solutions.
The probability of introducing such random values is (100-HMCR)%. In this way the variability
of solutions is enriched.
After the creation of a new “Harmony”, its performance is evaluated according to the corresponding
value of the objective function. If this performance is better than that of the worst “Harmony” stored
in the Harmony Memory, it replaces it. This procedure is repeated until the ending criterion, is
reached.
4.
OPTIMIZATION OF RAIN GARDENS
A typical cross section of a rain garden is presented in figure 4.1, consisting of two layers of different
granulometry soil materials with height d1 and d2 respectively. The free water surface in the garden
has height h, while at the bottom of the cross section there is a collecting pipe with cross section D.
There are two objective functions-goals for the cross section optimization. The first objective function
is defined as the sum of the thickness of each soil layer, which for economic reasons should be
minimum. The second objective function results from the maximization of the flow rate that can be
filtered in the cross section. Water infiltration from the rain garden surface to the deeper layers is
calculated using the Darcy law (equation 4.1)
𝑞 = 𝐴𝐾
ℎ
(4.1)
𝐿
Where:
q: infiltration flow rate per cross section meter
A: area of infiltration surface
K: equivalent conductivity for the two soil layers
h: hydraulic load equal to the depth of the two layers plus the depth of the free surface
L: flow length equal to the depth sum of the two layers.
Since the flow is vertical to the soil layers, the equivalent conductivity for the two soil layers with
conductivity K1 and K2 is resulting from the equation 4.2
𝛫=
𝑑1 +𝑑2
(4.2)
𝑑1 𝑑2
+
𝐾1 𝐾2
Therefore, the two objective functions of the problem are the equations 4.3
𝑉1 = 𝑑1 + 𝑑2 → 𝑀𝐼𝑁 (4.3.1)
𝑉2 = 𝐴
{
𝑑1 + 𝑑2 𝑑1 + 𝑑2 + ℎ1
→ 𝑀𝐴𝑋 (4.3.2)
𝑑1 𝑑2 𝑑1 + 𝑑2
+
𝐾1 𝐾2
For this specific multi-objective problem the two values of thickness and the type of soil layers are
considered as decision variables. Therefore, the decision variables are the following four: d1, d2, K1,
K2. The soil conductivity values are obtained considering the 7 soil classes shown at Table 4.
78
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 4: Soil classes-Conductivity
Soil Texture
Conductivity (m/s)
3×10-2
6×10-3
5×10-4
2×10-4
2×10-5
2×10-6
4.7×10-9
Gravel
Coarsesand
Mediumsand
Finesand
Silt, loess
Till
Clay
Figure 4.1: Cross section of a typical rain garden
In order to solve the problem and find the Pareto front we modify the typical algorithm of the
Harmony Search so that we can solve the multi-objective problem. Since one objective function is
minimized and the other one is maximized, we cannot compose the objective functions in one. Pareto
front is a curve where every solution has equivalent performance for both objective functions.
Therefore, the Pareto solutions cannot dominate one another. Finding the Pareto front (non-dominant
solutions) is a quite complex process and the simplest way to deal with is to consider gravity factors
for each objective function. Figure 4.1 presents the modification of the Harmony Search Algorithm
along with gravity factors for the objective functions. Two possibilities-gravity factors are defined in
this modification. The algorithm examines the objective function V1 with possibility p1 and function
V2 with possibility 1-p1.
Initialization Harmony
Memory
New Harmony from
HSA
p1-Evaluation New
Harmony from V1
1-p1- Evaluation New
Harmony from V2
Is better than the
worst value of
Harmony Memory
NO
P
YES
Figure 4.2: Application of Matlab programming language
79
Water resources management and contamination control
The process is organized in Matlab programming language with various values of possibility p1 in
order to find the Pareto front. A part of the code which presents the examination with gravity factors
of the two objective functions is presented in Figure 4.2.
Figure 4.3: The process in Matlab language
5.
RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS
The results for various values of gravity factors in objective functions are presented in Figure 5.1.
Figure 5.1: The results for various values of gravity factors
80
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Conclusions:
The p1 must be at least 50% in order to calculate the Pareto front. If p1 is less than 50%, then the
algorithm cannot estimate the curve accurately. The best approach of the Pareto front appears
when the p1 is between 60%-90%. Just a few values of Pareto fronts can be detected out of this
range.
In most cases the algorithm selects low values for depths d1 and d2 but high conductivity values.
At the most Pareto solutions the depth values range from 1 to 1.5 meter. On the other hand the
algorithm selects only high-conductivity soil classes. The solutions with low-conductivity soil
classes or high-value depths are always in the shadow of the front.
References
1. Degertekin, S. O. (2012). Improved harmony search algorithms for sizing optimization of truss
structures. Computers & Structures, 92, 229-241.
2. Dorigo, M., Maniezzo, V., &Colorni, A. (1996). Ant system: optimization by a colony of
cooperating agents. Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, Part B: Cybernetics, IEEE Transactions on,
26(1), 29-41.
3. Eberhart, R. C., & Kennedy, J. (1995). A new optimizer using particle swarm theory. In
Proceedings of the sixth international symposium on micro machine and human science (Vol. 1,
pp. 39-43).
4. Fesanghary, M., Mahdavi, M., Minary-Jolandan, M., &Alizadeh, Y. (2008). Hybridizing
harmony search algorithm with sequential quadratic programming for engineering optimization
problems. Computer methods in applied mechanics and engineering, 197(33), 3080-3091.
5. Geem, Z. W., Kim, J. H., &Loganathan, G. V. (2001). A new heuristic optimization algorithm:
harmony search. Simulation, 76(2), 60-68.
6. Geem, Z. W., Kim, J. H., &Loganathan, G. V. (2002). Harmony search optimization: application
to pipe network design. International journal of modelling & simulation, 22(2), 125-133.
7. Holland, J. H. (1973). Genetic algorithms and the optimal allocation of trials. SIAM Journal on
Computing, 2(2), 88-105.
8. Gholizadeh, S., &Barzegar, A. (2013). Shape optimization of structures for frequency constraints
by sequential harmony search algorithm. Engineering Optimization, 45(6), 627-646.
9. Kaveh, A., &Talatahari, S. (2009). Particle swarm optimizer, ant colony strategy and harmony
search scheme hybridized for optimization of truss structures. Computers & Structures, 87(5),
267-283.
10. Kirkpatrick, S., Gelatt, C. D., &Vecchi, M. P. (1983). Optimization by Simulated Annealing.
Science, 220(4598), 671-680.
11. Kougias, I., and Theodosiou, N. (2010). A new music-inspired harmony based optimization
algorithm: Theory and applications. In Proceedings of: International Conference on Protection
and Restoration of the Environment X, Corfu.
12. Kougias, I., Katsifarakis, L., &Theodossiou, N. (2012). Medley Multiobjective Harmony Search
Algorithm: Application on a water resources management problem. European Water, 39, 71-52.
13. Kougias, I., &Theodossiou, N. (2013). Multiobjective pump scheduling optimization using
harmony search algorithm (HSA) and polyphonic HSA. Water Resources Management, 27(5),
1249-1261.
14. Lee, K. S., &Geem, Z. W. (2004). A new structural optimization method based on the harmony
search algorithm. Computers & Structures, 82(9), 781-798.
81
Water resources management and contamination control
15. Lee, K. S., Geem, Z. W., Lee, S. H., & Bae, K. W. (2005). The harmony search heuristic algorithm
for discrete structural optimization. Engineering Optimization, 37(7), 663-684.
16. Mahdavi, M., Fesanghary, M., &Damangir, E. (2007). An improved harmony search algorithm
for solving optimization problems. Applied Mathematics and Computation, 188(2), 15671579.
17. Maheri, M. R. &Narimani, M.M (2014). An enhanced harmony search algorithm for optimum
design of side sway steel frames. Computers & Structures, 136 (2014): 78-89.
18. Saka, M. P. (2009). Optimum design of steel sway frames to BS5950 using harmony search
algorithm. Journal of ConstructionalSteel Research, 65(1), 36-43.
19. Xenakis, I. (1992). Formalized music: thought and mathematics in composition (No. 6).
PendragonPress
20. Basdeki, A.,Katsifarakis, L. and Katsifarakis, K.L., 2016. Rain gardens as integral parts of urban
sewage systems-A case study in Thessaloniki, Greece, Int. Conf. on Efficient & Sustainable
Water Systems Management toward Worth Living Development, 2nd EWaS 2016, Procedia
Engineering, 162, 426–432.
21. Katsifarakis, K.L. et al.,Guide for integrated rain water management,Final Report, Aristotle
University of Thessaloniki, 2013 (in Greek).
22. Katsifarakis,K.L.,Vafeiadis,M. and Theodossiou, N., 2015.Sustainable Drainage and Urban
Landscape Upgrading Using rain gardens. Site Selection in Thessaloniki, Greece,Agriculture
and Agricultural Science Procedia, 338-347.
23. Sebti, A., Bennis, S. and Fuamba, M., 2016. Optimization of the restructuring cost of an urban
drainage network.Urban Water Journal, 13(2), 119-132.
24. NY State Stormwater Management Design Manual (Chapter 9), available
from:http://www.dec.ny.gov/docs/water_pdf/swdmredevelop.pdf[Accessed
November
10,
2016].
25. Basdeki, A., Katsifarakis, L. and Katsifarakis, K.L., 2017, Design, calculations and performance
evaluation of rain gardens in an urban neighborhood of Thessaloniki,Greece, Desalination and
water Treatment Journal.
26. Trowsdale, S.A. and R. Simcock, R., 2011.
bioretention.Journal of Hydrology, 397(3-4), 167-174.
82
Urbanstormwater
treatment
using
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
ESTIMATION OF WATER FOOTPRINT FOR A HOTEL UNIT
A.E. Chatzi* and Ν.Ρ. Theodossiou
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering,Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th,GR54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author : e-mail: annaxatz28@gmail.com
Abstract
Some of the most important issues concerning water resources are reduction of extreme consumption
and protection of their quality. As time passes, researchers are trying to determine more effectively
water consumption and pollutant burden which ends up in water resources in order to manage and
protect them more appropriately. The constantly increasing water demand has currently led to global
problems of pollution and water scarcity. However, the necessity of improving water management
has led to the development and application of methods which aim to the extinction or at least the
limitation of these phenomena. A recent perception of simultaneously estimating water consumption
and water pollution is the concept of the water footprint, which was first introduced by Hoekstra in
2003. The water footprint concept comprises the efforts to identify freshwater consumption, not only
through direct but also through indirect use. It forms a volumetric measurement of water consumption
and water pollution while it also constitutes the base for local assessment of environmental, social
and economic impacts. In this paper, the water footprint of the hotel unit ‘Pantelidis’ in the town of
Ptolemaida, Greece, is analysed. Moreover, solutions that could reduce this footprint and make this
industry more environmentally viable, in terms of water use, are being investigated.
Keywords: Water footprint, Water scarcity, Water pollution, Water consumption, Water resources
management
1.
INTRODUCTION
In this paper the water footprint of a hotel unit is analysed. At first, indicators about water use
worldwide and the problems arising from the irrational and incorrect use of it, are presented. Then,
having introduced the concept of the water footprint, reference is made to the hotel on which the
methodology is applied. With the gathered information, the methodology, which has been applied
primarily to agriculture so far, is adjusted to a service of the tertiary sector, such as a hotel unit. After
the presentation of the results, the methods that are capable of converting the unit that is being
investigated to an environmentally friendly one, in relation to the management of freshwater
resources are suggested.
Water is a finite and unequally distributed natural resource. In the last century, the rise of living
standards of people, especially in the western world, was based on the industrial development. This
rise of living standards has led to an increase in demand for clean, potable water, while at the same
time created more sources of pollution. Urbanization, the concentration of large numbers of people
in specific urban areas, led to the depletion of their own natural resources and intensified the need of
transporting clean water from other distant regions, and thus, to the expansion of the problem. All
these activities, the new approaches in land exploitation, the new standards of life and the new habits,
had a series of effects in this finite resource, making it even more rare.
83
Water resources management and contamination control
Table 1: Water consumption in households per person and per day in European and other
counties (litres per day per person) [https://www.watersave.gr/files/PDF/1415ekp.pdf]
Consumption
Consumption
Country
Country
(Litres/day/person)
(Litres/day/person)
Belgium
108
Austria
131
France
147
Sweden
199
Germany
146
Switzerland
264
Denmark
194
Spain
158
Finland
156
Hungary
150
Britain
132
Greece
130
Italy
220
USA
300
Luxembourg
171
Africa
20-50
Netherlands
159
Palestine
20-30
Norway
175
Israel
170
Table 2: Water consumption in households in Greece
[https://www.watersave.gr/files/PDF/1415ekp.pdf]
Use
Litres
Large water bottles
Toilet
9 / time
6
Shower
15 / minute
100
Full bath
150
10
Washing the hands and face
30 / 2 minutes
20
Washing machine
150 / time
100
Dishwasher
50 / time
33
Washing fruits and vegetables
15 / minute
10
Washing dishes by hand
150 / day
100
The rapid population growth has as a consequence an increase in the needs for food supplies. The
increasing demand of water for food production, industry usage, and maintenance of urban and rural
populations has led to a growing shortage of fresh water (quantitative degradation) in many parts of
the world. In many areas, groundwater is pumped at a rate that exceeds the corresponding
replenishment, in a completely unsustainable manner. Likewise, the use of fertilizers and chemicals
to improve soil quality, as well as the removal and the deposition of waste, degrades the quality of
water supplies. Increasingly, therefore, natural resources are deficient both in quantity or quality.
Because of the rapid population growth on Earth, mass consumption, and misuse of natural resources,
the availability of drinking water cannot cover the needs of modern societies and is constantly
decreasing. For this reason, water is a strategic commodity throughout the world and has already
begun to be the cause for many political conflicts. Today an estimated 40% of people living on Earth
haven’t got enough water even for hygiene. More than 2,2 million people died in 2000 from diseases
related to the consumption of contaminated water.
84
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Water is consumed in various ways, and then a large percentage of the used water returns to nature,
significantly damaged by industrial or agricultural waste (fertilizers, pesticides etc.), sewage, waste
materials, and leachate from illicit or legitimate waste disposal areas. Around 90% of sewage and
70% of industrial waste water ends up in the environment without water purification [Bouguerra,
2005]. Tourism has a great impact on local environmental systems. A sector, directly stressed from
the tourist activities, is that of water resources. The seasonality of the tourist activities is undoubtedly
the most important factor that affects water recourses. The sharp increase in population in one place
for a certain time-period causes even greater increase in water consumption, since during holidays, a
reduction of the sense of water preservation from tourists, has been observed. This can result not only
in the enlargement of water problems during the touristic season, but also to more general problems
of water scarcity throughout the year, which affect the permanent population as well. Today it is
commonly accepted that the models of the water resources management followed so far, has not led
to the desired results, either due to defects of the models or, because of their misuse. The challenge
now is not only to meet the demand and increase the supply of water, but also to manage and reduce
the demand. New approaches refer to rational management of a finite social good, participatory
consultation, reduced consumption, protection from pollution, and reuse [Bouguerra, 2005].
More and more, governments, companies and communities are worried about future availability and
sustainability of water resources. The water footprint is a methodological tool for the rational
management of water resources, since, estimating the water footprint of a product can shape the
potentials of new policies in water resource management [Hoekstra, 2015].
2.
INTRODUCTION TO WATER FOOTPRINT
A relatively new concept in the simultaneous estimation of water consumption and water pollution is
the water footprint concept that was first introduced by Hoekstra (2003). Chapagain and Hoekstra
(2003, 2004) have shown that the visualization of water uses, hidden behind production processes,
can help in the understanding of the global freshwater consumption and to quantify its impact. In a
next stage, better and more rational management of the freshwater resources of the planet will be
possible, thus reducing the negative impacts of current practices mentioned in the previous chapter.
The water footprint can be identified as a volumetric index of the various types and quantities of water
which are used in the production chain of goods and is not just limited to the traditional concept of
water withdrawals. The water footprint consists of three components [Hoekstra et al, 2011]:
The blue water footprint refers to the consumption of surface and groundwater resources within
the production chain of a product.
The green water footprint refers to the rainwater stored as territorial moisture.
The grey water footprint, an indicator for pollution, is defined as the volume of water resources
required for the assimilation of the polluting load from the water body.
2.1
Analysis of the three components of the water footprint
Figure 1: Illustration of the three components of the water footprint [Hoekstra et al, 2011]
85
Water resources management and contamination control
2.1.1 Green water footprint
The green component refers to the rain which does not outflow on the surface nor replenishes the
groundwater. The volume of rain refers to the part which is stored in the ground or remains
temporarily on top of the soil or vegetation. Ultimately, this volume of water evaporates or is
transferred through plants into the atmosphere. A definition that could be given for the green water
footprint is the following: the green water footprint is the volume of rainwater consumed in the
manufacturing process of a product.
It is clear that the volume of green water footprint depends directly on the season to which we refer.
The volume of rainwater during the summer months is significantly smaller than that during the
winter months. It would be appropriate to mention that the volume of rain that reaches the earth is not
equal to the volume of rainwater consumed during the production process because, the water volume
vaporized and driven straight into the atmosphere must be removed. The contribution of the green
water footprint in irrigation procedures, whether they relate to agricultural or to garden watering for
aesthetic purposes, is particularly important. This consumption of green water in irrigation is
calculated from a set of empirical formulas and crop models, taking into account the
evapotranspiration that varies depending on the climate, the soil, the type and characteristics of the
irrigated area.
Green water footprint calculation: W.F.green = CWUg / Y
(1)
where CWUg : green water (rainfall) (m3/acre)
Υ : crop yield (ton/acre)
2.1.2 Blue water footprint
The blue component is the amount of surface or underground water consumed in a manufacturing
process of a product. This water is obtained by pumping water. Cases in which this water volume is
assumed to be consumed are the following:
Pumped water evaporates
It is finally integrated into the product
It does not return in the same catchment area from which it was pumped
It does not return at the same time during which it was abstracted
Through the blue footprint it is possible to estimate the amount of water available from water
resources for consumption over a specific time-period. The blue footprint represents a measurable
quantity, on the basis of which human actions can be regulated in order to balance the ecosystem.
There is of course a limit to the amount of water pumped from the surface as well as from
underground, as these waters with their flows contribute to a significant part to the water balance of
the aquatic system.
Blue water footprint calculation
W.F.blue = CWUb / Y
where: CWUb : blue water (irrigation) (m3/acre)
Υ : crop yield (ton/acre)
(2)
CWUb = Σub
where: ub : Blue monthly water use (mm/month)
(3)
ub= max (0, PETc – Peff) = Ir
where: PETC : evapotranspiration (mm/month)
Peff : beneficial rainfall (mm/month
(4)
86
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Ir : crop irrigation requirements
Ir = PETC– Peff + GW + SM + L
(5)
where: PETC : evapotranspiration requirements
Peff : beneficial rainfall
GW : groundwater contribution
SM : water stored in the root
L : Salt leaching factor
2.1.3 Grey water footprint
The grey component refers to the volume of freshwater that is required for the assimilation of the
polluting load caused by the manufacturing process of a product. The consumption of this water
volume continues to dilute the pollutants, until they become safe according to the water quality
standards of the region. The grey water footprint is an indicator of pollution of water expressed in
freshwater volume.
The grey water footprint depends on the quality of the waste resulting at the end of its own
management process. The ideal scenario is undoubtedly the zero outflow to the environment (zero
grey). The most popular methods serving the above-mentioned purpose are the following two
[Hoekstra et al, 2011]:
Water recycling (reuse water on-site to serve the same purpose)
Water reuse (reuse water to serve another purpose)
Grey water footprint calculation
The grey water footprint can be estimated through the application of the following equations.
Lcrit = R * (cmax –cnat)
(6)
where: Critical load (Lcrit) : the maximum pollution load that fully consumes the assimilation
capacity of the water body (mass/time)
R: runoff water body (mass/time)
Cmax: maximum acceptable concentration of pollutants – quality limit (mg/l)
Cnat: the physical concentration of pollutants without the influence of the human factor
(mass/volume)
(7)
where: L: the polluting load resulting from the production process (mass/time)
Effl: outflow volume
Ceffl: concentration of pollutants in waste water (mass/volume)
Abstr: volume of water that is eliminated
Cact: concentration of pollutants in water intake
2.2 Total water footprint
The sum of the above three components is the total water footprint, which we wish to minimize
W.F. = W.F.green +W.F.blue +W.F.grey
(8)
87
Water resources management and contamination control
2.3 Water footprint in Greece
The largest water related problem is, as expected, in the agricultural sector. This fact is justified by
the estimations of the water footprint of Greece. Particularly unfavorable is the country’s position
regarding the water consumption. With an average annual consumption of 2,389 cubic meters per
inhabitant, we have the second largest water footprint after the USA and twice the international
average (1,24 m3/year/inhabitant). Our large water footprint is due to increased water use for
agriculture (85%), to the losses of the obsolete irrigation and water supply networks of the country,
and to the overall mismanagement of water resources.
3.
PRESENTATION OF THE HOTEL UNIT “PANTELIDIS”
The next section presents the profile of the hotel unit, in which the implementation of the water
footprint methodology was assessed. The hotel complex "PANTELIDIS ' operates since 1989. It is
located in the prefecture of Kozani. The area where the business is located, has an altitude of about
640 meters and the surrounding areas are characterized as farming. There is no water source near the
hotel except for the aquifer, which lies at a depth of more than 40 meters.
3.1 Description of hotel unit
The hotel is located within an area of 45 hectares, 2 km from Ptolemaida. It's a classic 4 stars hotel.
It has a total of 88 rooms, with 188 beds while the average occupancy is estimated to 60%. The
following table shows the capacity of the hotel.
Table 3: The capacity of the hotel (room type, number of rooms, number of beds)
Type of room
Number of rooms Number of beds
Double
82
164
Quadruple
6
24
Total
88
188
3.2 Swimming pool
The hotel features an outdoor swimming pool with a total area of 660,75 m2. Its capacity is estimated
at about 1000 m3. The pool is filled in May and every day approximately 200 liters are removed and
replenished. The pool is emptied in September.
3.3 Garden
The surrounding area is characterized by extensive planting, flowerbeds with various kinds of plants
and lawns. The planting area is estimated at 3,371 m2. Besides the lawn, the following species of trees
and shrubs, which surround the hotel garden, can be found: plane trees, lindens, leilant.
Figures 2-3: The hotel's pool - Grass and trees in the restaurant
88
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The area’s rainfall is enough to meet the needs of plants. It should be noted that these species do not
require large quantities of rainfall for their preservation. At the summer season when the temperature
is high and the sunshine intense, an irrigation system is applied.
4.
WATER FOOTPRINT CALCULATION OF THE HOTEL UNIT
The hotel's activities that require water are listed below, as well as the way the people in charge secure
and store the water volume. Then, by categorizing these activities and with the help of some surveys
already carried out, the water consumption per person and thus the water footprint of the business
under investigation is calculated. The hotel ensures the freshwater volume required for the water
needs, through a borehole. The pumped water is directed through special filters in order to be ready
for any use by customers and staff. In order to apply the water footprint assessment methodology,
water consumption is categorized in the following:
Residence water footprint
Activities water footprint
Food water footprint
4.1 Residences water footprint
Refers to the fresh water consumed by customers to cover the majority of their needs. The following
table shows the average daily water consumption per resident in a four-star hotel.
Table 4: Percentage of water consumption and per resident water consumption in liters/day
per category of activities in hotels [Gössling et al., 2011]
Water
Activity
consumption
Garden watering
50% (465 l.)
Cleanliness
5% (47 l.)
Visitor’s hygiene
20% (186 l.)
Washing machines
5% (47 l.)
Restaurants
5% (47 l.)
Swimming pool
15% (140 l.)
The pool, the garden and the restaurants will be examined in the next category. According to the table
above, the water footprint of the hotel is 280 liters per person. As the owners referred, the average
occupancy is estimated to 60%. Considering that the rooms accommodate 188 beds, the average
number of individuals served daily by the unit is 113.
Therefore the water requirements are 113 * 280 = 31.640 litres/day.
The above water footprint ranks in blue, because it is acquired from the aquifer through pumping.
4.2 Activities water footprint
Refers to water that is consumed for the operation of the swimming pool and for the irrigation of the
garden.
89
Water resources management and contamination control
4.2.1 Swimming pool
The duration of operation of the swimming pool is 5 months (May-September). It is filled with 1000
m3 and daily 200 liters of water are removed and replenished. However, the consumption of this water
will be split evenly on every day of the year.
Therefore: (1000 * 1000) + (153 * 200) = 1.030.600 liters/year
1,030,600/365 = 2.823,56 liters/day
The above water footprint ranks in blue, because it is acquired from the aquifer through pumping.
4.2.2 Garden
The calculation of the requirements and, thus, the blue and green water footprint resulting from the
irrigation of the hotel garden was performed taking into consideration, the averages of the following
three parameters: average monthly temperature, average monthly temperature difference, average
monthly rainfall for the period between July 2009 and October 2017. Knowing the geographical
coordinates, the extraterrestrial solar radiation was estimated. In general, the calculation of the water
footprint ends up in water volume per product unit. If, for example, corn production was under
examination, then the performance of cultivation should be taken into consideration. However, in this
case the grass from which emerges no fruit is investigated. Thus, there is no connection with the
performance of cultivation and it is simply reduced to water per day. Therefore, from the garden
irrigation, the green water footprint was estimated to 348,95 liters/day and the corresponding blue, to
486,73 liters/day. It should be noted that the grey water footprint of garden irrigation is equal to zero,
as no fertilizers and chemicals are being used, which would contribute to the pollution of local water
resources.
4.3 Food water footprint
It refers to the water consumed by the customers of the hotel, both for the production of the products
that make up the diet and for the direct consumption of water by themselves. Reference is also made
to the volume of fresh water consumed in the restaurants.
4.3.1 Restaurant
Table 4 shows that the daily water consumption in the restaurant equals to 47 liters per day per
resident. It has also been calculated that on average 113 people per day are served.
Therefore 113 * 47 = 5311 litres/day.
The above water footprint ranks in blue, because it is acquired from the aquifer through pumping.
4.3.2 Direct water consumption
The amount of direct water consumption varies and depends on many parameters. However, studies
have resulted to an estimation of 3.18 liters/person as the average daily amount of total water
consumed for drinking.
Therefore 113 * 3,18= 359,34 liters/day. The above water footprint is also ranked in the blue category.
4.3.3 Indirect water consumption
It refers to the food that is consumed by the customers of the unit and either contain water or water
was used for their production. The daily diet of an average human being is estimated according to the
following diagram.
90
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 4: Percent food consumption of an average man
[https://www.nationalgeographic.com/what-the-world-eats/]
The official water footprint website (http://temp.waterfootprint.org/?page=files/productgallery) has
formed a product catalog which lists the liters needed to produce one kilogram of each product. The
percentages corresponding to blue, green and grey water footprint are indicated respectively. On the
basis of data reported and the diagram of figure 5, the following table configuration was formed,
which expresses the water footprint of an average human food – customer of the hotel unit.
Table 5: Water footprint of each food that composes a daily diet of an average human
91
Water resources management and contamination control
Table 6: Water footprint of each food that composes a daily diet of an average human
Dairy and eggs
15%
Grams
litre/kilo
Total water
footprint
Green water
footprint
Blue water
footprint
Grey water
footprint
Milk
13%
247
1020
251,94
214,15 (85%)
20,16 (8%)
17,64 (7%)
Eggs
1%
24
196
4,704
3,72 (79%)
0,33 (7%)
0,612 (13%)
Animal fats
1%
9
5553
49,977
42,48 (85%)
3,99 (8%)
3,5 (7%)
Sugar and fat
7%
Grams
litre/kilo
Sugar and sweeteners
Vegetables oils
Other oils
4%
2%
1%
66
32
19
920
3015
2854
Other
8%
Grams
litre/kilo
Total water
footprint
60,72
96,48
54,226
Total water
footprint
Green water
footprint
59,51 (98%)
79,11 (82%)
41,75 (77%)
Green water
footprint
Blue water
footprint
0,61 (1%)
16,4 (17%)
3,8 (7%)
Blue water
footprint
Grey water
footprint
0,61 (1%)
2,9 (3%)
8,77 (16%
Grey water
footprint
Alcoholic beverages
5%
102
436
44,472
31,13 (70%)
7,12 (16%)
6,23 (14%)
Miscellaneous
2%
22
528
11,616
11,12 (96%)
0,12 (1%)
0,35 (3%)
Pulses
1%
19
11397
216,543
216,54 (95%)
6,5 (3%)
4,33 (2%)
The sum of the columns of the above two tables resulted in the following results of the total green,
blue and grey water footprint of the human diet
Green water footprint: 1.976,176 liters/day/person
Blue water footprint: 284,189 liters/day/person
Grey water footprint: 247,298 liters/day/person
Considering the fact that 113 people are serviced daily:
Green water footprint: 223.307,888 liters/day
Blue water footprint: 32.113,357 liters/day
Grey water footprint: 27.944,674 liters/day
Table 7: Aggregated results of green, blue and grey water footprint of the hotel unit
Green (liters/day) Blue (liters/day) Grey (liters/day)
Accommodation
0
31640
0
Swimming pool
0
2823,56
0
Garden
348,95
486,73
0
Restaurant
0
5311
0
Direct water consumption
0
359,34
0
Indirect water consumption
223.307,888
32.113,357
27.944,674
Total
223.656,838
72.733,987
27.944,674
W.F. = W.F.green +W.F.blue +W.F.grey = 324.335 liters/day
92
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
5.
PROPOSALS TO IMPROVE THE MANAGEMENT OF WATER RESOURCES OF
THE HOTEL UNIT
At this point a simple report – summary of provisions and techniques for saving water in hotels is
made. The application of these proposals is expected to reduce the water footprint of the unit [Meras,
2014; Chatzi, 2018]
Biological cleaning installation..
Sensors in all taps for automatic closure. (An open tap consumes 9 liters of water per minute).
Installation of water consumption meters around the building, so the slightest leak can be
immediately repaired. One drop per second costs over 4 liters a day or else 1500 liters per year.
Water saving devices (hippo bags). The replacement of all hotel’s cisterns with new technology
is a highly expensive process. That is why there are special bags placed inside the muffler, saving
significant amounts of water. Even placing a bottle inside the muffler does the same job and is
estimated to save approximately a 10% water.
Collecting rainwater for watering the garden and cleaning the unit’s facilities.
Replacement of showers and water spray taps with air rates. The water runs with air rates, so as
to reduce the consumption of water.
Replacement of bathtubs with showers. Use of ecological and biodegradable detergents, in order
to recycle water from the kitchen, showers and washbasins for irrigation (grey water).
Adoption of an optional linen change process in guest rooms. Changing of the towels and bed
linen is only made on the suggestion of the tenant. This process has shown that it is particularly
acceptable to the tenants and highly efficient in saving water resources.
Recycling poll water.
Inform visitors about water saving effort through a prospectus, mounted in every room.
References
1. Anon (2011), What world eats, Available: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/what-the-worldeats/
2. Bouguerra M.L. (2005) Une economie au service de l’ homme: L’ eau sous la menace des
pollutions et des marches, pp 249-279.
3. Champagain, A.K. and Hoekstra A.Y. (2004), Water footprints of nations. Value of Water
Research Report Series 16, the Netherlands: UNESCO-IHE.
4. Champagain, A.K. and Hoekstra, A.Y. (2003), Virtual water flows between nations in relation to
trade in livestock and livestock products. Value of Water Research Report Series No. 13. Delft,
the Netherlands: UNESCO-IHE.
5. Chatzi, A. (2018), Assessment of the water footprint of the hotel unit “Pantelidis” in Ptolemaida,
Diploma thesis, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki
6. Gossling, S., Garrod, B, Aall, C. (2011), Food management in tourism: Reducing tourism’s
carbon footprint, Tourism management 32 (3), 534-543.
7. Hoekstra A. (2015), The Water Footprint: The Relation Between Human Consumption and Water
Use. In book: M. Antonelli and F. Greco-The water we eat. Combining Virtual Water and Water
Footprints, Springer water, p.35-48
93
Water resources management and contamination control
8. Hoekstra, A.Y. (2003), Virtual water trade: In: International Expert Meeting on Virtual Water
Trade, Delft, The Netherlands, 12-13 Dec. 2002, Value of Water Research Report Series
No.12, UNESCO-IHE, Delft, The Netherlands.
9. Hoekstra, A.Y., Chapagain, A.K., Aldaya, M.M., Mekonnen, M.M. (2011), The water footprint
assessment manual: Setting the global standard. London: Earthscan. p 203.
10. http://temp.waterfootprint.org/?page=files/productgallery
11. Meras V. (2014), Improvement of water resource management in urban hotels, Diploma Thesis,
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki
12. Michalis Hadjikakou, Jonathan Chenoweth et al, (2013), The electronic journal: Journal of
Environmental Management, Estimating the direct and indirect water use of tourism in the
eastern Mediterranean, pp 548-556.
13. Ogunjimi A. (2017) The Average Consumption of Water Per Day, Available at:
https://www.livestrong.com/article/338496-the-average-consumption-of-water-per-day/
94
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
SEDIMENT TRANSPORT CASE STUDY: NESTOS RIVER
1
1
S. M. Bagiouk*,2K. C. Anagnopoulos,2S. S. Bagiouk, 2A. E. Agiou, 1A. S. Bagiouk
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Aristotle
University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece,
2
Department of Civil Engineering, Democritus University of Thrace, 67131, Xanthi, Greece
*Corresponding author: 1E-mail: smpagiou@civil.auth.gr, Tel +30 2310 995893, +30 6944189218
Abstract
In the current paper are presented the results of a survey conducted in specific sections of the Nestos
river pointing out some of the basic features of the river behavior, in order to create a real data base
available to everyone who is interested in further study and research. It consists of two sections; the
first one is the calculation of suspended sediment and the second one the calculation of trolling matter.
Specifically, in the first part the flow rate and sediment transport were calculated, where it was
observed that the increase of flow rate resulted in the increase of sediment transport, which is fully
verified by the results of the research and it is concluded that the initiative assumptions were correct.
Moreover, in the second part, the transportation of the trolling matter on the field was initially
measured and then the same data were reevaluated using the Meyer-Peter and Müller equation, which
is one of the most reliable equations concerning the evaluation of trolling matter transport. In the end,
after a comparison of the results relative convergence was observed and the results are reliable for
use, expressing the basic characteristics of the Nestos river.
Keywords: Suspended sediment, trolling matter, flow rate, Nestos river, Meyer-Peter and Müller
equation
1.
INTRODUCTION
As load transport materials are characterized solids that are transported by water or deposited.They
are presented in the form of suspended, bottom or floating materials[5]. The suspended solids, which
are usually the bulk of the load transport material, are in static or dynamic balance with water and are
kept suspended by turbulence [2]. The bottom materials move on the bed or on the ground by sliding,
rolling or bouncing(trolling matter)[2]. The floating materials have usually organic origin, such as
e.g. aquatic plants, tree parts etc.and constitute 2 to 5% of the suspended materials.a Many times,
however, they prevent dams operation. Measurements [1] of load transport material are a prerequisite
in order to estimate the accumulation of sludge in riverbed and along the banks of rivers, sediment
deposition in natural and artificial lakes, the delta formed at the estuary of a river to the sea, quantity
of harmful substances (e.g. heavy metals that affect water quality) and finally the erosion of a
catchment area due to heavy rain and surface runoff [10]and for the application of appropriate
measures against corrosion. The delimitation between floating and bottom load transport materials
depends on the instantly state of transport such as the velocity of water[2]. For suspended material in
rivers with high velocity of water is sufficient the sampling in a single spot near the water surface in
the middle of the river. Generally, the determination of the amount of suspended materials is based
on the float rate [kg/s], float rate per width unit of the river[kg/(s.m)], floating load [t],the
concentration[g/m3] or content[ppm] or density [kg/m3]of suspended materials[3].For the bottom or
trolling materials, similar definitions apply, concerning the determination of the quantity of bed load
95
Water resources management and contamination control
transport [kg/s], the bed load transport per width unit [kg/(s ∙ m)] and the transport load of this bed[t]
[3]. The bed load material transport is taken per unit of width, if the weight of the ‘captured’ materials
is divided by the time of measurement and the width of the opening (of the gabion). The
measurements of the bed load transport are difficult due to the discontinuous movement of the bottom
materials in the form of sandblasts [1]. Such measurements are mostly made only on large rivers.
This paper describes the process of measuring the bed or sediment load transport of international
importance Nestos River and concerns the load of the bottom materials(or trolling matter) and the
load in suspension. These are the basis for the calculation of the quantity of sediments, in specific
time, which are transferred to the estuary of the river[7] to the sea, which constitutes a Wetland of
International importance and part of the National Park.
2.
MEASUREMENTS OF SUSPENDED LOAD TRANSPORT
Nestos River is one of the five largest rivers in Greece[7] and delineates the borders between
Macedonia and Thrace as well as the prefectures of Kavala and Xanthi. Five measurements were
performed between 17 – 30 of July 2015 in five different sections of the river in order to estimate the
suspended load transport[11]. These measurements took place in cross sectionsof the river which are
approximately 2 km from the village Kyrnos.
Measurements include the following sub – tasks:
Section selection and its division in subsections. In each section, separately, the depth of the river
and the flow rate were measured with a special rotational speed measuring instrument(current
meter, VALEPORT model BFM001).
Water sampling (1.5L volume) from each section. Laboratory processing of each sample to find
the net weight of sediment.
Estimation of surfaces of already separated sections.
Finding water flow in each subsection of the cross – section and estimation of suspended load
transport throughout the cross – section, with the following equations [6]:
Qi Vmi Ai
(2.1)
C Q
Q
(2.2)
ms Cs Qi
(2.3)
Cs
i
i
i
Where:
Vmi: average flow velocity in part i of the cross - section [m/s]
Ai:area of part i of cross – section [m2]
Qi: flow rate of part I of the cross – section [m3/s]
Ci:concentration of suspended matter in the part i of the cross – section [kg/m3]
Cs:concentration of suspended matter in the entire cross – section [kg/m3]
ms: total suspended load transport matter in the cross – section [kg/s]
96
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Below it is presented in detail the procedure[12] followed for the five measurements.It was
typicallychosen to be presented only the measurement process of the first measurement with the
stages, calculations and laboratory tests that took part.The remaining four measurements did not show
any difference in how they were applied and tested as they followed exactly the same procedure and
sequence of actions.
2.1 Procedure of the first measurement
The first measurement was performed on Tuesday 17 – 07 – 2015 and took place at a total cross –
section width of 18 m. Figure 1 shows the cross – section of Nestos river, where the first measurement
was made. The results of the flow rate measurements at a characteristic point of the cross – section is
shown in Table 1.
Figure 1: Graphic representation of the cross – section (1st measurement)
Table 1. Depth and flow velocity at a characteristic point of the cross – section (1st
measurement)
Depth
Velocity
Measurement
[cm]
[m/s]
1
75
0.778
2.2 Cross section area measurement
The cross – sectional area in which the first measurement was made is estimated by measuring the
surface width of the cross – section divided into subsections. In each section correspond two
trapezoids or a trapezoid and a triangle, which are on either side of each measurement position (Figure
1). The sum of the areas of subsections constitutes the total area of cross – section[2].
The measurements of all individual trapezoids and triangles givethe following results (Table 2):
Table 2. Area of individual trapezoids and triangles of cross – section (1st measurement)
Measurement
Α/Α trapezoid or triangle
Ε [m2]
1
0.53
2
1.78
3
2.05
1
4
1.40
5
0.95
6
1.48
7
0.49
2.3 Laboratory test on the water sample of the first measurement
The test was performed on a sample of water taken from the cross – section, located about 2km from
the village of Kyrnos with coordinates LL 40.99 – 24.75.
97
Water resources management and contamination control
The sample content in sediments was calculated with special retention filters. The retention filters
were weigh twice. The first weighing gave the filter weight and the second the weight of the
suspended material.
The test took place at the laboratory of the Environmental Engineering Department of DUTH. The
test results are summarized in Table 3
Table 3. Weight of suspended matter from the sample of the 1st measurement
Weight of suspended
Filter weight before
Filter weight after
matter inside water bottle
Sample
retention
retention
of 1lt
[g]
[g]
[g]
1
0.09293
0.09344
0.00102
2.4 Calculation of suspended load transport from the 1st measurement
In Table 4 below, it is shown in detail the calculation of the flow through the cross – section
considered. The same Table gives the concentration of suspended materials.
Table 4. Flow estimate (1st measurement)
Vm
A
Q
Cs
[m/s]
[m2]
[m3/s]
[g/lt]
0.778
8.68
6.753
0.00102
Position
1
The suspended load transport of the entire cross – section is calculated[6] according to equation 2.3:
ms = Cs*∑Qi=0.0069 kg/s=6.9 g/s
The suspended load transport per unit of river width is:
0.0069/18 = 0.000383 kg/s∙m
3.
PARTICLE SIZE ANALYSIS
In the bed of Nestos River[7], during the five measurements the load transport sediment was trapped
with a special landing net, with a specific square opening (7.5cm*7.5cm) at the back of which a net
for collecting sediments is attached.
The device was placed parallel to the stream for a period of one to five (1-5) minutes. Each sample
drained at a temperature of 105οCand then, in the laboratory of Hydraulic Sector of the Civil
Engineering Department of DUTH was performed the particle size analysis with sieves.
Table 5 below shows the particle analysis[4] of bed load transport samples of the first measurement,
which is representative of all other measurements, while in Figure 2 is given the particle size curve
of the first measure. The particle curves of the samples of other measurements employ identical
form[10].
98
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 5. Particle size analysis of 1st sample (1st measurement)
Particle size analysis with sieves
Date:17/07/2015
α/α
Sieve
number
Overall ground weight: 172.81g
Loop
size
Retained
ground
weight
Retained
percentage
Cumulative
retained
percentage
Percentage
thinner
[mm]
[g]
[%]
[%]
[%]
1
-
1.5
126
73
73
27
2
-
1
40.90
23.6
96.6
3.4
3
35
0.5
5.80
3.34
99.94
0.06
4
60
0.25
0.09
0.05
99.99
0.01
5
120
0.125
0.02
0.01
100
0.00
6
230
0.063
0.00
-
-
-
Figure 2. Particle size curve of 1st sample
4.
MEASUREMENTS AND CALCULATIONS OF LOAD TRANSPORT BED
4.1 Equation of Meyer – Peter and Müller
For the calculation of load transport rate of the river (due to sliding) a semi – imperial equation exist
that applies to certain values of hydraulic parameters of sediments. In the present paper Meyer – Peter
and Müller equation (1949) was used, which has a very good position between equations for
estimating the load bed [13]. This can be written:
3
8
1
8 F
1
2
m
(
gI
R
0
.
047
' gd
)
or mG
(4.1)
0 cr
g
g F w w
F
G
W
rS
W
m
F WW
99
Water resources management and contamination control
The introduction of the hydraulic radius Rs into equation (4.1) was made to take indirect account of
the roughness of the side walls of the open duct [4]. The Qs/Q ratio is often taken equal to 0.8
approximately or 1 in square conductors. The introduction of the Ir friction gradient was made,
because only one part of the available energy is consumed to move the weighed matter [5].
4.2 Calculation of Kst factor and his calibrated value
In order calculate Kst, all known parameters of the current test were replaced in formula (4.1),
according to the Meyer-Peter and Müller method [13]. Hence, having only the unknown size of the
Kst , the corresponding Kst was calculated each time. After the same procedure was followed for all
measurements, all the values of Kst factor were gathered and presented in table 6 and also their average
value.
Table 6.Values of Kstm1/3/s
Measurement
1
2
3
4
5
Kst
15.03
19.18
18.31
13.62
15.52
Average
16.33
4.3 First measurement of load transport bed
In this project, as it was mentioned before, a specific metal collector was used with a square opening
7.5cm x 7.5cm at the back of which a net for collecting sediments and trolling matter is attached. The
device was placed parallel to the stream for a period of one to five (1-5) minutes. The overall mass
of the captured matter of the sample during the first measurement was 172.81g or 0.17281kg.
For the measurement of sediment transport rate of the bed (table 7), the 0.17281 kg of sediment were
divided with the width of the opening of the device (0.075 m)and the time of collection (61 s).
mG=0.17281/(0.075 61)=0.03777 kg/(m.s)
Table 7. Measured sediment transport rate (1st measurement)
Sample mass
m= 0.17281 kg
Collector’s width
b= 7.5 cm
0.075 m
Collection time
t= 1.02 min
61 s
Sediment transport rate
mG= 0.03777 kg/(m.s)
4.4 Calculation of sediment transport rate for the data of the first measurement
The Meyer-Peter και Müller type in combination with Einstein and Barbarossa method, is now
applied in the data of the measurement in order to calculate the sediment transport rate of the bed
(table 8)[13].It is also noted that factor Kst is taken equal to 16.33 m1/3/s, exactly as it was calculated
from calibration procedure[2].
100
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 8. Data of first measurement and sediment transport rate calculation
Overall bed width
b= 18m
Depth of flow
h= 0.482m
Average velocity
Vm= 0.778 m/s
Bottom inclination
I= 0.005
Kst factor
Kst= 16.33m1/3/s
Characteristic particle diameter
d90= 0.00355m
Interstitial particle diameter
d50= 0.0021 m
ρF= 2650 kg/m3
Density of sample of suspended load
Gravity factor
g= 9.81 m/s2
Water density
ρw= 1000 kg/m3
Α=b h= 8.68m2
Wet section
Wet wall perimeter
UW=2 h= 0.964 m
Wet bed perimeter
Us=b= 18m
Average particle diameter
dm=d50= 0.0021 m
Calculation
ρ΄=(ρF-ρW)/ρF= 1.65
Kr= 66.57m1/3/s
Ir= 6.075 10-4
Rs= 0.453 m
Sediment transport rate mG= 𝟒𝟕. 𝟗𝟐 × 𝟏𝟎−𝟑 kg/(m.s)
After the same procedure was followed for the rest of the measurements, it was observed that there
is convergence in a great level between measured and calculated sediment transport rate of the bed in
most cases.
5.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
In order to provide some clear conclusions from the measurements and the calculations, which are
referred previously, a centralized statement [9] is made through two tables. Table 9 includes the flow
rate, concentration of suspended sediment and suspended sediment transport rate in every of the five
specific sections, as they emerged from the measurements, while table 10 includes the measured and
calculated sediment transport rate for each of the five sections.
101
Water resources management and contamination control
Table 9.Flow rate, concentration and transport rate of suspended sediment
Measure
Date
Flow
rate
[m3/s]
1
2
3
4
5
17.07.2015
21.07.2015
24.07.2015
27.07.2015
30.07.2015
6.753
2.418
11.022
9.284
9.01
Concentration
[g/lt]
0.00102
0.00146
0.00112
0.00106
0.00114
Suspended
sediment
transport rate
[g/s]
6.9
3.5
12.34
9.84
10.27
Suspended
sediment
transport rate
[kg/(m.s)]
0.000383
0.000304
0.000494
0.000502
0.000642
It is observed that the highest value of flow rate was measured during the third measurement, which
completely corresponds to the highest value of suspended sediment transport rate. Furthermore, the
lowest value of flow rate (second measurement) matches with the lowest value of suspended sediment
transport rate.
In the following table the measured and calculated sediment transport rate are presented during the
five measures in some sections of Nestos River.
Measure
Table 10.Calculated and measured sediment transport rate
Measured sediment
Calculated sediment
Date
transport rate
transport rate
.
[kg/(m s)]
[kg/(m.s)]
1
17.07.2015
0.03777
0.04792
2
21.07.2015
0.02658
0.004071
3
24.07.2015
0.05832
0.04691
4
27.07.2015
0.0854
0.1068
5
30.07.2015
0.10021
0.1225
As it is occurred from table 10, there is a relative deviation between the sediment transport rate that
was measured and the one that was calculated during the second measurement. This deviation was
probably the result of a random incident or a mistake in this specific measurement. As far as the rest
of the measurements are concerned, the deviations between measured and calculated sediment
transport rate of the section of Nestos River are under reasonable bounds.In conclusion, in the first
stage, in which there was calculation of the flow rate and sediment transport rate, the increase of the
flow rate resulted to the increase of sediment transport rate, which is a fact that can be fully confirmed
from the rest of the outcomes. Furthermore, we can conclude that the initial assumptions were correct
[2]. In the second stage the trolling matter transport rate was measured in the field and afterwards
with the same data there was again calculated the same rate but this time using the Meyer-Peter and
Müller equation [13], which is one of the most famous and reliable equations concerning the
102
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
evaluation of trolling matter transport rate. Thus, there was a comparison of the results [8] and it was
observed that there is a sufficient convergence between them. Finally, it became clear that these
results are reliable for further use, they express the basic features of Nestos River[5] and they
constitute a reliable data base for the future. It is worth to mention that is necessary, in order to avoid
mistakes and for more representative results of this kind of measurements, to have a more adequate
number of measurements, from which some extreme rates should not be taken under consideration
or, differently, lower importance to be given to them [9].
The creation of a real archive of measurements and data forms the basic purpose of this project as the
only goal is the possibility of using them for further study and research. Moreover, the potential
comparison and evaluation of new calculations, measurements and results and finally the designation
of the behavior and basic features of Nestos River.
References
1. Weiming Wu, 2007. Computational River Dynamics. CRCPress
2. Sakkas I.,1994 G.: "Technical Hydrology: Vol. I, Surface Waters Hydrology " Ekdosis Aivazi
, Xanthi.
3. Soulis I .,1999: "Open Duct Hydraulics", Ekdosis Aivazi, Xanthi.
4. Tsakiris G., 1995: "Water Resources: I. Technical Hydrology", Simmetria Publications,
Athens.
5. Chongas X, 1993: "River Engineering", Ion Publications, Athens.
6. Chrysanthou B., 1996: "River Hydraulics and Technical Works Notes", Department of Civil
Engineering, DUTH, Xanthi.
7. https://el.wikipedia.org/wiki/ (accessed October 21st, 2017)
8. Yu, K.K. and Woo, H.S. (1990) Comparative Evaluation of Some Selected Sediment Transport
Formulas. KSCE Journal of Korean Society of Civil Engineers, 10, 67-75.
9. Walter Hans Graf ,1984 .Hydraulics of Sediment Transport. Water resources publications.
10. Wilbert Lick, 2008. Sediment and Contaminant Transport in Surface Waters. CRC Press
11. Ellen Wohl,2014. Rivers in the Landscape: Science and Management. Wiley-Blackwell
12. Andre Robert, 2003. River Processes: An Introduction to Fluvial Dynamics.Taylor & Francis
13. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sediment_transport (accessed October 9th, 2017)
103
Water resources management and contamination control
ASSESSMENT OF IRRIGATION WATER QUALITY IN
ANTHEMOUNTAS BASIN, CENTRAL MACEDONIA, GREECE
Hatzigiannakis, E., Tziritis, E., Ιlias, A., Arampatzis, G., Doulgeris, C., Pisinaras, V.
Panagopoulos, A.
Soil and Water Resources Institute,
Hellenic Agricultural Organization-DG Research,
GR- 57400 Sindos, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: tziritis@gmail.com, tel : +302310798790
Abstract
This research focuses on the assessment of irrigation water quality in a cultivated basin
(Anthemountas Basin) of central Macedonia, Greece. Specifically, it was performed a risk assessment
of soil salinization or alkalization due to irrigation water quality, as well as an assessment of the
anticipated adverse effects and the potential toxicity in crops due to the presence of harmful
substances in irrigation water. In this context, 45 samples from irrigation boreholes were analyzed for
assessing electrical Conductivity (ECw), pH, Sodium Adsorption Ratio (SAR), Na, Ca, Mg, Cl and
B. Results revealed that regarding ECw, 71% of boreholes appeared to have values below 0.7mS/cm,
hence characterized as of negligible risk, and 29% of the boreholes had values between 0.781.1mS/cm, hence characterized as of small to medium risk. In respect to crop toxicity due to the
concertation of specific ions at soils, the risk due to sodium (Na) and Chlorides (Cl) appears to be
low; however, the risk due to boron (B) appears to be significant in a few cases accounting for
concentrations up to 2.87 mg/L in irrigation water. The pH values are within the acceptable range of
irrigation waters and the probability of irrigation system clogging due to salinization effects appears
to be low to negligible. Nevertheless, agricultural practices including the management of irrigation
water resources should be frequently monitored and managed rationally in order to maintain an
optimal quality status of water reserves and soils, hence contributing significantly to the sustainable
agriculture. Towards this direction, specific suggestions are given taken into account the specific
conditions and characteristics of the area.
Keywords: Irrigation water quality; salinization; alkalization; crop toxicity; Anthemountas basin
1.
INTRODUCTION
Water used for irrigation can vary greatly in quality depending upon type and quantity of dissolved
salts; salts are present in irrigation water in relatively small but significant amounts. They originate
from dissolution or weathering of the rocks and soil, including dissolution of lime, gypsum and other
slowly dissolved soil minerals (Singh, 2018). These salts are carried with the water to wherever it is
used. In the case of irrigation, the salts are applied with the water and remain behind in the soil as
water evaporates or is used by the crop.
The suitability of a water for irrigation is determined not only by the total amount of salt present but
also by the kind of salt. Various soil and cropping problems develop as the total salt content increases,
and special management practices may be required to maintain acceptable crop yields. Water quality
or suitability for use is judged on the potential severity of problems that can be expected to develop
during long-term use.
104
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The problems that result vary both in kind and degree, and are modified by soil, climate and crop, as
well as by the skill and knowledge of the water user. As a result, there is no set limit on water quality;
rather, its suitability for use is determined by the conditions of use which affect the accumulation of
the water constituents and which may restrict crop yield. The soil problems most commonly
encountered and used as a basis to evaluate water quality are those related to salinity, water infiltration
rate, toxicity and a group of other miscellaneous problems.
While the salinity tolerance of crops varies among species, all crops are negatively affected at some
point by increasing salinity levels of irrigation water (Western Fertilizer Handbook, 1995; Ayers and
Westcot, 1976; Buckman and Brady, 1967; Miller and Donahue, 1995; Pereira and Marques, 2017).
Use of salty irrigation water may lead to two major problems in crop production; salinity hazard and
sodium hazard (McFarland et al., 2002). When irrigation water is used by plants or evaporates from
the soil surface, salts contained in the water are left behind and can accumulate in the soil. These salts
create a salinity hazard because they compete with plants for water. Even if a saline soil is water
saturated, plant roots may be unable to absorb the water, and plants will show signs of drought stress.
Foliar applications of salty water often cause marginal leaf burn and, in severe cases, can lead to
defoliation and significant yield loss (McFarland et al., 2002). Higher electrical conductivity and
salinity in irrigation water cause an increase in soil solution osmotic pressure (United States
Laboratory Staff (USSLS), 1954). Excess soluble salts in the root zone restrict plant roots from
withdrawing water from the surrounding soil, effectively reducing the plant available water (Western
Fertilizer Handbook, 1995; Bauder, 2001; Bauder and Brock, 2001; Hanson et al., 1999; United States
Development Agency (USDA) Natural Resources Conservation Service, 2002).
The aim of the present study focuses on the assessment of irrigation water quality in a cultivated basin
(Anthemountas Basin) of central Macedonia, Greece. Specifically, it seeks to perform a risk
assessment of soil salinization due to irrigation water quality, as well as an assessment of the
anticipated adverse effects and the potential toxicity in crops due to the presence of harmful
substances in irrigation water.
2.
STUDY AREA DESCRIPTION
Anthemountas River basin is located in central Macedonia, Greece. It is the northwest part of the
Chalkidiki peninsula and covers 318 Κm2 approximately (fig. 1). It consists of two main sub basins,
namely Basilika (208 Km2) which occupies the lower parts and Galatista (110 Km2 ), which is
situated topographically higher.
A dense well-formed stream network drains the area while the geological features include a large
variety of different sediments combined with various geological formations. The hydrogeology,
consequently, presents complex features (Fikos et al., 2005). The sedimentary formations are the
hosts of confined and unconfined porous aquifers with variable morphological characteristics.
Fissured rock aquifers are developed in the crystalline and metamorphic rocks, whereas a karstic
aquifer is located in the carbonate rocks (Kazakis et al., 2016). A detailed description of these
aquifers’ characteristics can be found in previous studies (Kazakis et al., 2015).
The main crops of the area include weed (70%), followed (30%) by corn, cotton and vegetables. The
irrigation water is solely based upon the abstraction of groundwater resources by private boreholes.
The dominant irrigation method is drip irrigation accounting for the 85% of cotton, corn and
vegetables, followed by springler irrigation which accounts for 15% of the same crops, respectively.
Regarding weed crops, they are mainly rain-fed, and is rare episodes of extended drought, they are
irrigated once or twice by springler irrigation.
105
Water resources management and contamination control
Figure 1: Study area and borehole sites
3.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Totally 180 samples were collected from 45 irrigation boreholes of Anthemountas basin (fig. 1)
during 4 sampling campaigns (May 2010; August 2010; November 2010; January 2011), practically
covering an entire hydrological year. Samples were collected in 500ml polyethylene bottles; prior to
sampling, boreholes were operating for sufficient time (10 min) and bottles were rinsed three times
with borehole water. Electrical Conductivity (EC) and pH were measured in situ by portable means;
the collected battles were stored in refrigerators (≈4Co) and transported in the laboratory for further
analysis. Specifically, samples were analyzed for the following parameters (the analytical methods in
brackets):
Na (Flame Photometer)
Cl (Volumetrically)
B (UV-Vis in 420nm)
Ca, Mg (Atomic Adsorption AAS-flame)
Sodium Adsorption Ratio - SAR (calculated)
4.
RESULTS
Based on the measured values for all periods, the pH is slightly alkaline (median=7.7) ranging from
7.2 to 8.4. In respect to EC, irrigation water is not saline in general; however, few samples appear to
have values up to 1.28 mS/cm). Calcium (Ca) is the dominant cation (median=52.7 mg/L), with values
ranging from 1.1 to 142.5 mg/L, followed by Sodium (Na) ad Magnesium with median values of 37.7
and 24.6 mg/L, respectively. Chlorides (Cl) range from 7.1 to 187 mg/L (median=42.6) and Boron
(B) from 0 to 3.2 mg/L (median=0.08). Based on these values, the calculation of Sodium Adsorption
Ration (SAR) as defined by Reeve et al. (1954), gave values that ranged from 0.16 to 238, with a
median of 0.64
106
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1: Basic statistics parameters of irrigation water samples for all periods. Standard
deviation refers to average values
Variable
Minimum
Average
Median
Maximum
StDev
pH
7.20
7.5
7.7
8.40
0.25
EC (mS/cm)
0.30
0.63
0.64
1.28
0.16
Na (mg/L)
7.77
24.2
24.60
108.20
16.61
Ca (mg/L)
1.10
48.4
52.70
142.50
26.64
Mg (mg/L)
3.50
34.8
37.70
239
26.64
Cl (mg/L)
7.10
40.2
42.60
187
25.07
B (mg/L)
0.00
0.08
0.08
3.20
0.44
SAR
0.16
0.63
0.64
2.38
0.42
Figure 2: Temporal variations of the measured parameters in irrigation water
In respect to the temporal variations of the measured parameters during the 4 sampling periods (fig.2),
it is evident that the values fluctuate according to the dominant hydrological conditions (wet and dry
hydrological period), the followed irrigation practices, and secondary hydrogeological/
hydrogeochemical process triggered by water recharge/abstraction.
Specifically, the pH slightly decreases from the dry (May, Aug) to the wet (Nov, Jan) hydrological
periods, a general trend which is also followed by Boron. Variations of Chlorides and Sodium are
minor and practically their values are constant or slightly modified during the four sampling periods.
Similarly, Calcium remains constant during the dry periods and increases during the wet, during
which it remains practically stable. The same trend is also followed by Magnesium; however, a sharp
decrease is identified from November to January. The EC values are progressively decreasing from
107
Water resources management and contamination control
May to November, with a slight increase during January. Finally, the SAR values appear a slight
increase during the dry hydrological periods as expected, and eventually decrease towards the wet
period (Nov); nevertheless, a significant increase is observed from Nov to Jan, corresponding to an
increase of 20% for its value.
5. DISCUSSION
Regarding salinity risk assessment for the entire hydrological year, the collected samples may be
classified into two groups according to Ayers ad Westcot (1985): a) no risk (EC<0.7 mS/cm) and, b)
low to medium risk (0.7<EC<3 mS/cm). No sample of high risk (EC>3 mS/cm) was identified. The
first group contains 32 samples (71%), whilst the second one 13 (29%).
The infiltration of water in soils is chiefly dependent on the overall salinity of the irrigation water,
expressed by the SAR (fig.3) and EC values. Based on their compilation, the samples may be
classified in two groups: a) 0<SAR<3 and EC<0.7, corresponding to negligible risk (29% of samples),
and b) 0<SAR<3 and 0.7<EC<3, corresponding to low-medium risk (71% of samples). The use of
irrigation waters belonging to group “a” does not hider any risk for plots; whilst, for the second (b)
group, attention is needed in order to monitor regularly the SAR values or decrease of infiltration
capacity.
Figure 3: Spatial interpolation (IDW algorithm) of SAR values in the study area
Regarding the toxicity of other parameters to crops, there is negligible risk from sodium and chlorides,
apart from few boreholes (2 and 1, respectively) whose sample impose low to medium risk. In respect
to Boron, most of its values are low, thus toxicity risk is negligible; however, few values mainly at
the northwestern part are elevated (up to 2.87 mg/L), denoting a significant impact to crops, especially
to boron sensitive crops such as the vegetables and vineyards. The elevated values of Boron to
groundwater are likely to be attributed to geogenic factors related to the hydrothermal activity
(Tziritis et al., 2016) of the wider area. In respect to pH values, they do not have impact to crops when
considered individually, but jointly with other parameters. However, none of the samples appear to
have pH values which may under circumstances cause adverse effects to crops.
Accumulation of salts in soils is a relatively slow process, triggered mainly by two factors: a) salts
contained in the irrigation water which are accumulated in the upper soil horizon, and b) by salts
which are contained in a low-depth phreatic aquifer and are accumulated through hyporheic transport
or evaporation as the soil horizons. A supplementary factor is also the application of fertilizers, but
their impact is temporary. Nevertheless, when their use is excessive, fertilizers may cause salinization
impacts. In order to sufficiently manage irrigation water and minimize salinization risk, a frequent
108
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
monitoring scheme of critical parameters should be established. In this context, parameters such as
EC, SAR, ESP and pH should be closely monitored jointly with other critical external conditions
(such as precipitation), in order to deliver optimal irrigation practices intended to maximize
environmental protection and yield.
6.
CONCLUSIONS
Totally 45 samples from irrigation boreholes were analyzed for assessing electrical Conductivity
(ECw), pH, Sodium Adsorption Ratio (SAR), Na, Ca, Mg, Cl and B. Results revealed that regarding
ECw, 71% of boreholes appeared to have values below 0.7mS/cm, hence characterized as of
negligible risk, and 29% of the boreholes had values between 0.78-1.1mS/cm, hence characterized as
of small to medium risk. The temporal variations of ECw, probably reflect the impact of fertilization;
hence, elevated values of May are attributed as the direct impact of accumulated solids due to prior
fertilization practices.
Regarding crop toxicity, the risk due to sodium (Na) and chlorides (Cl) appears to be low. The
observed temporal variations are attributed to precipitation events during September, which
subsequently trigger soil leaching of solutes that slowly (depending on the infiltration conditions)
reach the uppermost aquifer with a time-lag following a relative dilution, probably in January.
Additionally, the risk due to boron (B) appears to be significant in a few cases accounting for
concentrations up to 2.87 mg/L in irrigation water. The temporal variations of boron values should
be probably attributed to changes in the hydrogeological conditions. Differentiation in recharge rate
that directly influence groundwater level, seem to chiefly impact boron leaching from the subsurface
strata. The pH values are within the acceptable range of irrigation waters and the probability of
irrigation system clogging due to salinization effects appears to be low to negligible. Nevertheless,
agricultural practices including the management of irrigation water resources should be frequently
monitored and managed rationally in order to maintain an optimal quality status of water reserves and
soils, hence contributing significantly to the sustainable agriculture.
REFERENCES
1. Ayers, R.S. and D.W. Westcot. 1976. Water Quality for Agriculture. FAO Irrigation and
Drainage Paper No, 29 (Rev 1), Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.
2. Ayers, R.S., and Westcot, D.W., 1985. Water quality for agriculture. F.A.O. Irrigation and
Drainage Paper 29:99-104, Rev.1.
3. Bauder, J. W. and T.A. Brock. 2001. “Irrigation water quality, soil amendment, and crop effects
on sodium leaching.” Arid Land Research and Management. 15:101-113.
4. Bauder, J.W. 2001. “Interpretation of chemical analysis of irrigation water and water
considered for land spreading.” Personal communication. Montana State University, Bozeman,
Montana.
5. Buckman, H.O. and N.C. Brady. 1967. The nature and properties of soils. The MacMillan
Company, New York, New York
6. Fikos, I., Ziankas,m G., Rizopoulou, A., Famellos, S. (2005) water balance estimation in
Anthemountas river basin and correlation with underground water level. Global nest Journal
7(3):354-359
7. Geogenic Cr oxidation on the surface of mafic minerals and the hydrogeological conditions
influencing hexavalent chromium concentrations in groundwater, Science of the Total
Environment, 514, 224-238.
8. Hanson, B., S.R. Grattan and A. Fulton. 1999. “Agricultural Salinity and Drainage.” University
of California Irrigation Program. University of California, Davis.
109
Water resources management and contamination control
9. Kazakis, N., Kantirais, N., Kaprara, M., Mitrakas, M., Vargemezis, G., Voudouris, K.,
Chatzipetros, A., Kalaitzidou, K., Filippidis, A. (2016) Potential toxic elemets (PTES) in ground
and sprig waters, soils and sediments: an interdisciplinary study in the Anthemountas basin, N.
Greece. Bulletin of the geological Society of Greece, vol.L, P.2171-2181
10. Kazakis, N., Kantiranis, N., Voudouris, K.S., Mitrakas, M., Kaprara, E. and Pavlou, A., 2015.
11. McFarland, M., Lemon, R., and Stichler, C., (2002). Irrigation water quality: Critical Salt
Levels for Peanuts, Cotton, Corn and Grain Sorghum, Texas Cooperative Extension, Texas.
12. Pereira, H., Marques, R.C. (2017). An analytical review of irrigation efficienvy measured using
deterministic and stochastic methods. Agricultural Water Management 185:28-35
13. Reeve, R. C.; Bower, C. A.; Brooks, R. H.; Gschwend, F. B. (1954). "A comparison of the effects
of exchangeable sodium and potassium upon the physical condition of soils". Soil Science Society
of America Journal. 18 (2): 130
14. Singh, A. (2018). Managing the salinization and drainage problems of irrigated areas through
remote sensing ad GIS techniques. Ecological Indicators 89:584-589
15. Tziritis, E., Tzamos, E., Vogiatzis, P., Matzari, C., Kantiranis, N., Filippidis, A., Theodosiou, N.,
Fytianos, K. (2016) Quality assessment and hydrogeochemical status of potable water resources
in a suburban area of northern Greece (Thermi Municipality, central Macedonia). Desalination
and Water Treatment 57:11462-11471
16. United States Development Agency Natural Resources Conservation Service. 2002. Soil
Conservationists. Salinity Management Guide - Salt Management. Available at http://
www.launionsweb.org/salinity.htm. 2002
17. United States Saline Laboratory Staff. (USSLS), (1954). Diagnosis and Improving of Saline
and Alkali Soils. United States Department of Agriculture, Washington: USA.
18. Western Fertilizer Handbook. 1995. Produced by the Soil Improvement Committee of the
California Fertilizer Association. Interstate Publishers, Inc., Sacramento, California, 1995.
110
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
GIS-BASED MULTI-CRITERIA DESIGN OF A HYDROMETRIC
SYSTEM IN THE ATTICA REGION
E. Theochari1, E. Feloni*1, A. Bournas1, D. Karpouzos2, E. Baltas1
1
Department of Water Resources and Environmental Engineering, School of Civil Engineering,
National Technical University of Athens, 5 Iroon Polytechniou, 157 80, Athens, Greece
2
Department of Hydraulics, Soil Science and Agricultural Engineering, School of Agriculture,
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, University Campus, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: feloni@central.ntua.gr, tel : +302107722413
Abstract
The lack of adequate hydrological data affects the ability to model, predict and take measures for
catastrophic events, such as floods and droughts, which have obvious negative impacts on public
health and socio-economic aspects. The collection of stream flow and stage-gauge measurements that
are accurate and representative for a watershed is necessary; however, it is difficult to decide for an
optimum stage-gauge station location. This research work presents a methodological framework
based on Geographical Information Systems (GIS) techniques and multi-criteria decision-making
(MCDM) for the optimal design of a Hydrometric Station Network. The implementation was held in
seven basins in Attica region, namely Sarandapotamos, Giannoula, Eschatia, Erassinos, Rafina,
Haradros and Rapendossa. These basins face an existing flood hazard, especially in the residential
areas. In the context of the optimal network design, different criteria, such as morphology, land cover,
network density, and general guidelines of the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) were
taken into consideration. The criteria weights were estimated with the use of Analytic Hierarchy
Process (AHP) and the final results, based on the Weighted Linear Combination (WLC), indicated
the optimal hydrometric stations locations for each basin. Furthermore, a sensitivity analysis on
factors weights was performed and presented indicatively for Eschatia basin.
Keywords: hydrometric station network; river monitoring; floods; GIS; MCDM
1.
INTRODUCTION
The collection of stream flow data that are accurate and representative of water resources is
considered necessary, since the lack of adequate hydrological data affects the ability to model, predict
and plan for catastrophic events such as floods and droughts which have obvious negative impacts on
public health and socio-economic aspects (Hong et al, 2016). The monitoring of the components of
the hydrological cycle including rainfall, groundwater characteristics, as well as water quality and
flow characteristics of surface waters is called Hydrometry (Boiten, 2008). The most widely used
monitoring tools to measure the river flow are the stream gauge stations. In order to correctly acquire
these measurements, a hydrometric station networks should be applied. The objective of setting a
hydrometric station network is to address all concerns in order to provide timely, quantitative and
comparable information, as well as, to design a comprehensive, comprehensible and effective
network that provides coverage in all river basins where flow data are required (Hong et al, 2016).
The extend and number of the hydrometric stations depends on the specific purpose of recording the
stream flow, such as the hydrological study of a region, the floods prevention and the proper technical
works design. The need to monitor river flow is also in line with the objectives of the European
policies, and particularly with the Directive 2007/60/EC (EU, 2007) on the assessment and
111
Water resources management and contamination control
management of flood risks. The configuration of this directive resulted as a need after devastating
flooding that struck Europe during the period 1998-2002. Since the hydrological and flood regime in
Europe varies, because of the high variability of the relief and the climate among different regions,
severe floods have been observed not only in residential areas but also in rural, cultivated land.
More specifically in Greece, due to the high spatial variability of hydroclimatic conditions and the
complex topography, flood events are one of the most frequent natural disasters. Particularly for the
Attica region, despite the dry climate, extreme rainfalls occurring in small time scales, show a rise
compared to other regions of the country, leading to an increasing number of flash-flood events.
Floods in Attica has cost more lives (182 people) during the last century (1887-2011) while the cost
in human lives due to flooding for the whole country during the same period has been 284 people
(Karagiorgos et al, 2012). It is a fact that flood risk is exacerbated by the extreme interference of the
anthropogenic environment into the natural characteristics of a basin, thus often leading to the
production of insoluble flood-related problems in order to management them (Diakakis, 2012; 2014).
The lack of stage gauge stations is one of the most decisive factors in the context of an integrated
system for the river monitoring and the civil protection warning in case of an emergency.
This study presents a method using Geographical Information Systems (GIS) with the aim of
designing an optimal Hydrometric Station Network according to a set of proposed geomorphogical,
technical and spatial criteria. A basic application of optimization in network design is to maximize
information with respect to minimizing cost (Mishra and Coulibaly, 2009). With respect to this scope,
the minimum number of station per watershed in combination with the optimal site selection are the
main objectives of the procedure. The proposed methodology is implemented in seven watersheds of
Attica. The entire procedure is treated as a multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) problem with the
scope of the best position determination, using the pairwise comparisons of the Analytic Hierarchy
Process (AHP) developed by Saaty (1977) as a way to estimate the factors weights and the Weighted
Linear Combination (WLC) to estimate the final scores (FS).
2.
STUDY AREA AND DATA USED
Seven watersheds in Attica region were selected for the implementation of the proposed method, as
they have an extensive natural hydrographic network, they morphologically diverse and face severe
flood problems after intense rainfall and most of them are ungauged. There watersheds are depicted
in Figure 1. Regarding the data used in the present study, seven layers were initially created:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
Digital Elevation Model (DEM) for the Attica region obtained by the National Cadastre
& Mapping Agency of Greece. The DEM has a pixel size of 5x5m, its geometric accuracy
RMSE is z ≤ 2,00m and the absolute accuracy ≤ 3,92 m for a 95% confidence level. This
raster layer has been used for the slope raster, flow accumulation raster and the river
network extraction, with the aid of the Surface and Hydrology Toolsets of ArcToolbox
(ESRI, 2010). Additionally, the layer of watershed has been created using this DEM.
Finally, a layer produced after this procedure is the confluence of stream branches.
Historic floods of the region. This layer is a combination of freely available data from the
Ministry of Environment and Energy and from geocoded data that correspond to the Fire
Service operations in flooded properties the last 15 years.
Land cover map from CORINE Land Cover (2012), for the extraction of the margins of
settlements.
The basemap of National Cadastre & Mapping Agency of Greece (Fig.1) for the
evaluation of the GIS-based river network extraction.
112
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: Study areas in Attica (Basemap ©National Cadastre & Mapping Agency of Greece).
3.
METHODOLOGY
The aim of this study is the optimal positioning of a Hydrometric Station Network as a proposed
methodology implemented in seven basins in Attica region. The methodology followed concerns a
multi-criteria GIS-based decision analysis. Generally, decision problems that include geographic data
are referred to as geographic or spatial decision problems (Malczewski 1999; 2004). These problems
often require that a large number of feasible alternatives must be evaluated on the basis of multiple
criteria. Consequently, many real-world spatial problems can lead to multi-criteria decision-making
(MCDM) based on the geographic information system (GIS). The problem addressed in this study is
a spatial decision problem as it includes a large number of geographic data and is also based on GIS
techniques for its solution. For this purpose, multi-criteria decisions were made, following the
methodology of the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP). In this framework, Multi-Criteria Decision
Analysis (MCDA) aims to develop standardized procedures that help decision-makers (i.e., station
network designers) to solve various problems (i.e., site selection) by linking factors (i.e.,
geomorphological, technical, etc.) associated with the problem. MCDA is a process that combines
and transforms geographic data (inputs) into a resulting decision (output), it defines a relationship
between "input maps" and "output maps". Geographic information can be defined as georeferenced
data processed in a form that is meaningful to the recipient. Data in the GIS are usually organized as
separate thematic maps referred to as ‘layers’. Firstly, the general problems as well as the individual
objectives are identified, criteria and alternatives are then identified. Criteria may be factors and
constraints related to the spatial problem. The second step of the analysis is related to the criteria
values standardization and constraints determination. Then, decision-makers should select the method
of composing the criteria and determining the relevant weights, in order to produce the final results
and any alternatives. Finally, the proposed solutions are based on the evaluation of alternative options
(Drobne and Lisec, 2009). There are many ways in which decision criteria can be combined into
MCDA. The Weighted Linear Combination (WLC) and its variants require an aggregation of the
weighted criteria. The Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) is used in WLC in the stage of factors’
weights estimation. AHP was proposed by Saaty (1977) and is based on the principle that, for making
a decision, decision maker's experience and knowledge is as important as the available data. This
technique was first developed with a variety of analytical resources, while the use of GIS techniques
113
Water resources management and contamination control
was first introduced by Rao et al. (1991). AHP method implementation is divided into the following
steps:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
Deconstruction of the problem studied in a hierarchical (or network) model, made up of its
basic components, allowing for pairwise comparisons.
Comparative assessment of each component - criterion.
Composition of the evaluated criteria in order to produce the final results.
Optimal position determination.
The application of the method therefore includes two general phases, the structure of the hierarchy
and the stage of evaluation of the individual criteria. The current application, which is based on the
idea of pairwise comparisons of different criteria according to the subjective (personal, empirical,
bibliographic, field research, etc.) view of the researcher, determines the relative significance by
comparing the criteria per two of them. These pairwise comparisons are based on the fundamental
comparison scale introduced by Saaty (1977) (Tab. 1).
Table 1: Scale for pairwise comparison (Data adopted by Saaty, 1977).
Numerical value
Description of importance
1
equal
2
equal to moderate
3
moderate
4
moderate to strong
5
strong
6
strong to very strong
7
very strong
8
very strong to extremely strong
9
extremely strong
In Saaty's technique, weights come from a series of operations of a matrix of comparable pairs among
the criteria. The comparisons concern the relative relevance of the two criteria related to the
determination of suitability for the intended objective. To assess the weight of each criterion, the
following procedure is followed:
1. Column values of each matrix of comparable pairs are assumed.
2. Division of each matrix element with the sum of its column previously found.
3. Calculation of the average of the data for each matrix sequence that occurred in the previous
step
The resulting averages are the weights of the criteria (Drobne and Lisec, 2009). A check follows in
the consistency of the comparison of the criteria and the severity factors that have emerged. The
consistency ratio (Eq. 1) should not overcome the value of 10% in order to consider the hierarchy and
the comparison between the primary factors and to accept the resulting weighting factors. Saaty
suggests that weights should be reassessed by changing uterine elements if the limit of CR ≤ 0.10
does not apply. The consistency ratio is calculated as:
𝐶𝑅 =
𝐶𝐼
𝑅𝐼
(1)
A further procedure is the standardization of the criteria by categorizing each of them into a single
grading scale (eg., between 0-1). This step aims to create comparable sizes for each criterion is order
114
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
to result in a final score (FS) of the same scale. Voogd (1983) reviewed a variety of standardization
processes, usually using minimum and maximum values as scaling points. The simplest way to
perform this standardization is by using a linear transformation as shown in Eq.2a when the maximum
value of the criterion corresponds to the best case and Eq.2b when it corresponds to the worst case.
(𝐹𝑉𝑖 −𝐹𝑉𝑚𝑖𝑛 )
𝑥𝑖 = (𝐹𝑉
𝑚𝑎𝑥 −𝐹𝑉𝑚𝑖𝑛 )
∙ 𝑆𝑅
(𝐹𝑉𝑖 −𝐹𝑉𝑚𝑖𝑛 )
𝑥𝑖 = 1 − (𝐹𝑉
𝑚𝑎𝑥 −𝐹𝑉𝑚𝑖𝑛 )
(2a)
∙ 𝑆𝑅
(2b)
The last step of the method involves creating and calculating the required level of information
regarding the suitability of the areas for the optimal positioning of a Hydrometric Station Network in
specific basins. Therefore, the suitability map should be developed. The WLC is incorporated into
the GIS environment through Raster Calculator (Map Algebra Toolset) and the FS is calculated then
as follows:
𝐹𝑆 = ∑ 𝑤𝑖 𝑥𝑖
(3)
In cases where the Boolean constraints also apply, the process can be modified by multiplying the FS
value with the product of constraints (ci):
𝐹𝑆′ = ∑ 𝑤𝑖 𝑥𝑖 ∙ ∏ 𝑐𝑖
(4)
The scores are calculated for all alternatives and the appropriate number of sites (i.e., these with the
highest FS) is all selected. The final number of stations per watershed was defined according to the
World Meteorological Organization (WMO, 2010) guidelines for the Hydrometric Station Network
density (Tab. 2).
Table 2: Density of Hydrometric Station Network (2010).
Type
Coastal
Mountainous
Hilly
Plains
Small islands (area<500km2)
Polar, arid
Density
1 station per 2750km2
1 station per 1000km2
1 station per 1875km2
1 station per 1875km2
1 station per 1985km2
1 station per 20000km2
For the implementation of the MCDM in the hydrometric station design, different criteria were
selected. The ideal gauge site satisfies the following criteria, many of which are defined in WMO
(2010):
I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
The general course of the stream is straight for about 10 times the stream width, upstream and
downstream from the gauge site.
The total flow is confined to one channel at all stages and no flow bypasses the site as
subsurface flow.
The stream-bed is not subject to scour and fill and is relatively free of aquatic vegetation.
Banks are permanent, high enough to contain floods, and are free of brush.
Upstream of the station location, a pool is formed in order to ensure a recording of stage at
extremely low flow, and to avoid high velocities at the stream ward end of stage recorder
intakes, transducers, or manometer orifice during periods of high flow. The sensitivity of the
control should be such that any significant change in discharge should result in a measurable
change in stage.
115
Water resources management and contamination control
VI.
The gauge site should be far enough upstream from the confluence with another stream or
from tidal effect to avoid any variable influence from another stream or the tide which may
affect the stage recording.
The site should be readily accessible for ease in installation and operation of the gauging
station.
VII.
According to the aforementioned criteria, in the present study the following were taken into account:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
The density of stations according to WMO guidelines,
Distance from settlements,
Distance from the flood-prone area,
Topographic slopes,
Distance from confluence with another stream.
For the estimation of the criteria’ weights, the QGIS plug-in Easy-AHP tool
(https://plugins.qgis.org/plugins/EasyAHP/) was used, which includes the Pairwise Comparison and
Weighted Linear Combination (WLC) analysis. As the tool operates in a GIS environment, it is
capable for land use, agricultural, disaster management, environmental resources and relevant
applications. The user-friendly interface makes the analysis easier by dividing operations to different
steps. According to the relevant significance of design criteria, slopes (C1) is the most important and
then the criteria of distance from confluence (C2), distance from settlements (C3) and distance from
flood-prone areas (C3) follow (Tab. 3). Accordingly, other spatial characteristics were considered as
constraints (ci). Table 4 summarizes the way that the eight factors were involved in the procedure.
Table 3: Pairwise comparison matrix and AHP results.
C1
C2
C3
C4
C1
1
0.33
0.25
0.142
Criteria
C2
C3
3.03
4
1
3.03
0.33
1
0.125
0.5
C4
7.042
8.0
2
1
Weights
AHP Indicators
λ
CI
CR
C1
C2
C3
C4
4.148
0.049
0.054
0.529
0.303
0.112
0.056
Table 4: Criteria and GIS-procedure.
Factor
Standardizatio
n procedure
2b
Constraints
Remarks
2b
Boolean Map ‘1’
(buffer 500m) ;
‘0’ (d<500)
3. Distance from
floods
2b
Boolean Map ‘1’
(buffer 1000m) ;
‘0’ (d<1000)
4. Distance from
confluence from
another stream
2a
Boolean Map ‘1’
(buffer 250m) ;
‘0’ (d<250)
7. Elevation
(station density)
Definition of
station number
-
Technical Criterion of maximum importance
Mosaic with “Euclidean distance”raster
Flow accumulation layer for the upstreamdownsteam identification
Based on the historic floods Mosaic with
“Euclidean distance”raster layer
Flow accumulation layer for the upstreamdownsteam identification
Technical Criterion
Point Feauture class of confluence sites
Mosaic with “Euclidean distance”raster layer
It is performed for the final selection of
stations. The number of stations per zone is
based on the values of Tab. 3.4 and positions
of maximum score are finally selected for
each basin.
8. River
-
Boolean Map ‘1’
(in channel) ; ‘0’
(out of channel)
(criterion/constraint)
1. Surface Slope
2. Distance from
settlements
116
-
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The implementation of the WLC per watershed provides different FS per grid along the mainstream
of the hydrographic network. Final scores vary significantly, and as a more representative way to
group the results, Fig. 2 shows the frequency (i.e., the normalised number of cells per basin) of FS in
five clusters. It should be noted that as the FS increases the number of cells decreases, as expected,
but some exceptions can also be found.
For Sarandapotamos basin, 7.8% of possible locations meet a final score of 90% or more. The
majority of the optimum proposed locations are seen in the western part.
For Erassinos basin, which is the only watershed with low slopes, a high number of locations
meet the applied criteria.
For Eschatia basin, only three locations can be characterized as satisfactory for a stage gauge
station installation (i.e., FS>90%). These positions marginally meet the proximity constraints.
Giannoula basin is also a complicated case as the topography of the watershed leads to low or
moderate values of FS. Only 15 locations are indicated as proper for a stage gauge installation
according to the methodology followed.
Haradros and Rapendossa basins are areas with historic floods and for this reason. For these
basins, the locations of two and one stations are proposed correspondingly. Erassinos generally
appears higher scores for longer distance along the mainstream, but, after the MCDM application,
only about 7% of this reaches a FS at least equal to 90%. The corresponding percentage for
Rapendossa basin is 3.7%.
Rafina basin appears a total of 296 locations with a score equal or lower to 60%. Instead, the
optimum proposed locations are only 6 with a score higher than 90%. For this basin, an evaluation
of the existing network was held and this indicated that two in three stations are in positions of
high score.
Cells of Main Stream percentage
SARANTAPOTAMOS
GIANNOULAS
ESXATIA
ERASINOS
RAFINA
RAPEDOSA
HARADROS
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
<50%
50-60%
60-70%
Grouped FS values (%)
70-90%
>90%
Figure 2: Grouped FS distribution per basin.
Among the positions that reach a FS>90%, these of highest score are selected as the optimal positions
(Fig. 3). Concerning the number of stations, which is one in most of the basins, the number derives
from the WMO guidelines (Tab. 2). Sarandapotamos basin is an exception, as the current design
considers a number of two stations because of the basin’s extent. Another exception is Haradros basin,
were the installation of two hydrometric stations is also proposed, due to the frequent flash-flooding
and the complexity of the basin. Finally, for Vravrona basin, where the archaeological site of
Vravrona is located at the plain, the proposed location is upstream enough, in order to operate as an
alarming indicator in case of flood occurrence. It should be noted that the installation strategy for a
117
Water resources management and contamination control
hydrometric network may differ based on the network design purpose. For instance, when focusing
on flood warning purposes, as in this study, a hydrometric station should be placed upstream critical
locations, such as settlement, while for water management purposes a hydrometric station should
always be installed on or near basin’s exit points to allow for rainfall-runoff studies.
Figure 3: Optimum recommended positioning sites for hydrometric stations at seven study
basins
After the proposed AHP procedure, a once-at-a-time sensitivity analysis was conducted by
performing an alteration of ± 5% on the weights of slope and flood distance criterion. These criteria
are the one of highest importance and the one of lowest importance, correspondingly. The alteration
in weights was performed separately and this change is added linearly in the other three criteria each
time, in order to quantify the criterion influence in the final results.
Indicatively, Figure 4 depicts two locations in Eschatia basin where the alterations affected
significantly the FS values.
Figure 4: Sensitivity analysis results by altering weights for stream slopes criteria (left panel)
and distance from floodplains (right panel). The case of Eschatia basin.
118
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
More specifically, in this figure one can compare the middle maps (left panel for the slope criterion
and right panel for flood distance criterion) with the upper and lower one. The middle named ‘Wopt’
correspond to FS values as resulted according to the proposed WLC, while the upper named ‘Wopt5%
’ (for a decrease of 5% in the criterion weight) and the lower one named ‘Wopt+5%’ (for an increase
of 5%). In the case where the weight of slopes was reduced by 5%, it is observed that two new proper
(FS>90%) locations were obtained; an expected result, as the resilience of the slope criterion
increased. Points of FS higher that 90% are marked with a dark circle. When the weight of slopes
increased by 5%, then the corresponding number of proposed locations was reduced compared to the
original ones (middle map) and the FS of the most locations decreases. In the case of a 5% reduction
in the weight of the flood criterion, the proposed locations meet a lower FS. When the flood weight
increased by 5%, a new extra optimal location emerged. In the case of the 5% weight increase, new
proposed locations are appeared as linearly the weight of the other three criteria are decreased.
5.
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE RESEARCH
In this research work, a methodology was developed for the optimal design of hydrometric stations
network in seven basins of Attica using GIS methods. The methodology was based on multi-criteria
analysis and particularly on the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP), which was implemented for
four criteria. These criteria concern the distance from settlements, the distance of river junctions along
the mainstream, the location of historic floods, and the slope along the mainstream. Several
constraints to the above criteria were implied, such as securing that the positions are located upstream
of settlements and historically flooded areas as well as being deployed in areas of mild slope and
away from river junctions. In addition, a sensitivity analysis was performed to evaluate the weight
factor of each criterion in the final score. Finally using GIS-based methods for the MCDM process,
the proposed hydrometric station positions for all seven basins were defined. The proposed positions
have been found to be appropriate for actual station installation. It should be noted however that when
designing an optimal hydrometric network station, one must choose between flood prevention and
early warning systems, as in this study, where upstream locations of settlements are ideal, and water
management purposes, where the exit point of a basins should be sought after for rainfall-runoff
studies.
Specific conclusions of this study are summarized as follows:
By setting a value of FS at least 90% as a satisfactory value, a large number of proposed
hydrometric site positions was derived.
The basin containing the most satisfactory station locations is the Erassinos basin, with a total of
644 suggested locations, while this with the less satisfactory station locations is the Eschatia basin,
with only three satisfactory locations.
From the sensitivity analysis performed for the Basin of Eschatia, it was observed that the most
sensitive criterion is the slope along the mainstream.
This study added a variety of findings and, in this framework, some suggestions for future research
are proposed.
The use of remote sensing data in similar applications for larger catchment areas is recommended.
In this case, there is no error of the digitization of the stream or of the DEM-based process for the
automatic extraction, since the actual position of the stream can be detected by remote sensing
applications.
A more detailed sensitivity analysis may be performed, in order to better evaluate the impact of
each criterion in the whole process.
119
Water resources management and contamination control
A different set of rules or new criteria can also be examined, based on the actual hydrometric
network purpose such as in cases of water resources management and rainfall-runoff studies
where the basin’s outlet is an ideal location.
REFERENCES
1. Boiten W., (2008), Hydrometry, Taylor and Francis
2. CORINE Land Cover (2012). ‘Land cover dataset for 2012.’ <https://land.copernicus.eu/paneuropean/corine-land-cover/clc-2012> (Aug. 12, 2017)
3. Diakakis M., S. Mavroulis and G. Deligiannakis (2012) ‘Floods in Greece, a statistical and spatial
approach’, Natural hazards Vol 62(2), pp.485–500.
4. Diakakis, M. (2014) ‘An Inventory of Flood Events in Athens, Greece, during the Last 130 Years.
Seasonality and Spatial Distribution’, Journal of Flood Risk Management, Vol 7(4), pp. 332–
343
5. Drobne, S., and A. Lisec (2009) ‘Multi-Attribute Decision Analysis in GIS: Weighted Linear
Combination and Ordered Weighted Averaging’, Informatica, 33(4), PAGE
6. ESRI R. (2010) ‘Arc GIS Desktop: Release 10’, Environmental Systems Research Institute,
2010
7. EU (2007) Directive 2007/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 October
2007 on the assessment and management of flood risk.
8. Hong N. T., P. T. T. Truc, N. D. Liem, and N. K. Loi (2016) ‘Optimal Selection of Number and
Location of Meteo-Hydrological Monitoring Networks on Vu Gia–Thu Bon River Basin using
GIS’, International Journal on Advanced Science, Engineering and Information
Technology, Vol 6(3), pp. 324-328.
9. Karagiorgos, K., M. Chiari, and J. Hübl (2012) ‘Flood hazard assessment validation based on the
Flood Risk Directive 2007/60/EC–a case study in Rafina (Attica, Greece) catchment’ Proc. Int.
Conf. 12th Congress INTERPRAEVENT, eds. G. Koboltschnig, J. Hübl and J. Braun.Grenoble,
France, 2012.
10. Malczewski, J. (1999) ‘GIS and multicriteria decision analysis’, John Wiley & Sons.
11. Malczewski, J. (2004) ‘GIS-based land-use suitability analysis: a critical overview’, Progress in
planning, Vol 62(1), 3–65.
12. Mishra, A. K., and P. Coulibaly (2009) ‘Developments in Hydrometric Network Design: A
Review’, Rev. Geophys, Vol 47, p.p. 1-24
13. Rao M. S. V. C., S. V. C. Sastry, P. D. Yadar, K. Kharod, S. K. Pathan, P. S. Dhinwa, K. L.
Majumdar, D. Sampat Kumar, V. N. Patkar and V. K. Phatak, (1991) ‘A weighted index model
for urban suitability assessment—a GIS approach’, Bombay Metropolitan Regional
Development Authority, Bombay.
14. Saaty T. L. (1977) ‘A Scaling Method for Priorities in Hierarchical Structures. Journal of
Mathematical Psychology, Vol. 15(3), pp. 234–281
15. Voogd, H. (1983) ‘Multicriteria evaluation for urban and regional planning’, London: Pion.
16. WMO) (World Meteorological Organization Manual on Stream Gauging-Volumn 1: Fieldwork,
Geneva, Switzerland: World Meteorological Organization, 2010.
120
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Sustainable architecture, planning and development Built environment
121
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
122
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF MODERN AND TRADITIONAL
MASONRY MORTARS FOR SUSTAINABLE CONSTRUCTION
A. Liapis*, A. Karozou, A. Batsios, M. Stefanidou
Laboratory of Building Materials, Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki,
Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: aliapisk@civil.auth.gr, tel : +302310995699
Abstract
Sustainability in construction has become even more essential over the past few decades, mainly due
to natural resources overexploitation, as well as an increasing rate at construction-related emissions
that contribute to major environmental issues, such as climate change. The rising demands in
affordable housing and in the utilization of environmentally efficient alternatives, led to the revival
of traditional building materials in modern construction. Clay and traditional materials in general, are
considered sustainable materials mainly because of the harvesting method that makes them easy to
produce. At the same time, these materials are being used in conservation and restoration of historic
buildings, not only for their compatibility with the existing structure, but also for their economic and
environmental benefits. For this paper, an effort is conducted to assess the environmental and
financial benefits of three of the most common traditional building materials used in the production
of masonry mortars: clay, lime and pozzolan. A cement-based mortar is also assessed, as a reference
mixture. The environmental assessment is conducted according to the Life Cycle Assessment
methodology, a comprehensive tool that is used extensively in construction applications. Along with
the environmental assessment, a cost estimation of the different scenarios presents their financial
profile and the potential for implementation in the construction industry. The results of the study
document the sustainability of the traditional materials and clarify, in a quantitative way, the
importance of the utilization of traditional materials in masonry mortars, leading to benefits for both
modern construction and conservation and restoration projects.
Keywords: Sustainability, traditional building materials, masonry mortar, life cycle assessment
1.
INTRODUCTION
The concept of sustainability, as it was defined by Brundtland in the much renowned report “Our
common future” [World Commission on Environment and Development, 1987] considers three areas
of interest: environment, economy and society. These areas don’t exist separately, but they need to
be regarded as a threefold system. Naturally, same rules apply in the field of constructions
diachronically: during the design of a construction project, the designer is first interested in the needs
and requirements of the people that will use the project, the society where the project will be placed
in. The cost is also an important factor that will determine the feasibility of the construction and use
of the project. However, these two areas will not result to a sustainable application, if the project
doesn’t consider the impact that the construction will have to the environment, not only in terms of
raw materials and fossil fuel consumption during the construction, but also due to emissions and
wastes throughout its life cycle. This environmental impact is the main subject of this study, along
with an estimation of costs, in an effort to approach sustainable thinking as much as possible. Due to
the complexity of the societal assessment, it is kept out of this study’s scope. These for-mentioned
123
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
values seem to be valid for ancient masons and they were consistent ethic rules that the masons were
following in their building technology [Papayianni et.al, 2007].
The materials that are assessed are utilized here in masonry mortars for traditional and modern
constructions. Traditional constructions include mainly restoration and renovation works in structures
of important cultural value. However, the sustainable thinking in constructions has led to the revival
of traditional building materials in modern structures. Clay, and earthen materials in general, have
been connected to human societies for centuries, from monumental structures and simple dwellings
to modern constructions of high performance and eco-efficiency [Pacheco Torgal and Jalali, 2012].
The reason for that is the numerous advantages of these materials: lower embodied energy, reduced
CO2 emissions during production, maximum use of locally sourced materials, provision of good
sound and thermal insulation, fireproof abilities, healthy living conditions. Under the light of
sustainability, earthen structures have been reconsidered and efforts are made for them to be restored
and revitalized with proper materials and techniques. On the other hand, there is a revival of the
interest on building with earth all over the world (i.e. France, Germany), due to the constructional,
economic and environmental benefits.
Moreover, the combination of lime with natural pozzolans rendered mortars of adequate resistance
and they formed a type of lime-pozzolan concrete. Many monumental structures of those historic
periods were constructed with this concrete, mentioned by many writers as “Roman cement”. Up to
19th century this lime-pozzolan concrete was the dominant material [Papayianni, 1994]. Under the
prism of sustainability, the understanding of the diachronic principles of constructions could
contribute to maximizing the effectiveness of the contemporary building materials and minimizing
their cost and environmental footprint.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The materials considered for this study are all coming from industries mainly located in Northern
Greece. Regionality holds an important part in the sustainable design of constructions, not only for
the reduction of emissions and costs due to shorter distance transportations, or the more accurate
monitoring of depletion of natural resources [Van den Heede & De Belie, 2012], but also for boosting
local economies by supporting local businesses. In Table 1, there is an overview of the distances from
the suppliers to the construction site, which for this study, is set at the Laboratory of Building
Materials, in Aristotle University of Thessaloniki.
Table 1. Distances from materials’ suppliers to construction site.
Material
Supplier
Distance (km)
Cement industry in Northern
Cement
12.1
Greece
Traditional building
Clay
materials’ supplier in
22.6
Northern Greece
Lime industry in Northern
Lime (hydrated)
17.8
Greece
Traditional building
Pozzolana
materials’ supplier in
22.6
Northern Greece
Traditional building
River Sand
materials’ supplier in
22.6
Northern Greece
In Table 2, the composition of the studied mixtures is being shown. The mixture design is based in
common practice as well as the existing experience of the Laboratory of Building Materials in
124
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
traditional and modern mortars. The workability achieved was according the regulations for structural
mortars based on EN196-1 [CEN, 2016] and EN1015-3 [CEN, 1999]. The cement mortar is coded as
CEM, the clay mortar as CLM and the lime-pozzolana mortar as LPM.
Table 2. Mixtures for masonry mortars.
Quantity (kg/m3)
Material
CEM
CLM
LPM
Cement CEM I 32.5N
470.5
-
-
Clay
-
398.5
55.1
Lime, hydrated
[Ca(OH)2]
-
-
183.5
Pozzolana
-
-
128.5
River Sand (0-4 mm)
1411.5
996.3
1101
Water
235.3
239.1
249.6
Regarding the environmental impact of the mixtures implementation, it is calculated using the Life
Cycle Assessment (LCA) methodology. The methodology is being used since the late 1960’s, gaining
constantly momentum in industrial, agricultural and other applications, where the environmental
burden of the production of goods and services is under study. In late 1990’s and early 2000’s the
International Organization for Standardization published the standards 14040 [ISO, 2006a] - 14044
[ISO, 2006b], where the LCA methodology is described and conducted by four main steps: goal and
scope definition, inventory analysis, impact assessment and finally interpretation of the results.
For the goal and scope definition, the aim of the study must be clearly stated. This is also the stage
where the boundaries, spatial and temporal, need to be set, along with all the assumptions being made
for the assessment, including the functional unit. The step of inventory analysis includes the detailed
recording of all the inputs (e.g. materials, energy, transportation, labor, land occupation etc.) and
outputs (products, by-products, emissions to air and/or wastes to water and soil) that participate in
the production phase of the studied product. The impact assessment step is the heart of the LCA. It
is the stage where all the recorded inputs and outputs are related to certain categories of environmental
impact categories, such as climate change, eutrophication, acidification, natural resources’ depletion
etc. The correlation is accomplished by multiplying the inventory analysis results with factors
(characterization factors) according to each one’s contribution to the environmental issue that is under
study. The interpretation of the results is the stage where the assessment is evaluated in terms of
fulfilling its goal, and the discussion of the outcome sets the frame for further study. This step is not
strictly placed at the end of the assessment, since it can play a monitoring part throughout the whole
assessment, evaluating each of the other steps.
3.
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT AND COST ESTIMATION
The calculations and the results of the environmental assessment are presented below, following the
four steps of the LCA methodology:
3.1 Goal and scope definition
The goal of this assessment is to measure and compare the environmental impact of the production
and implementation of three different masonry mortars. The first mortar, which is the reference
mixture, is a cement mortar, and is used in modern structures. The second mortar has clay as a binder
and is used in modern structures as well as in restoration works. The third mortar is a combination of
lime, pozzolana and clay and is used mainly in restoration works and traditional construction. As the
125
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
study is about masonry mortars, the functional unit, instead of being a unit regarding volume of mortar
mixture (e.g. 1 m3 of mortar), is set as 1 m2 of constructed masonry, which, in the writers’ opinion is
easier to comprehend by a wider audience. For the construction of the 1 m2 of brick wall, 80 solid
bricks are being used, with dimensions of 20x10x5 cm (width, depth, height), and the mortar is to be
applied in joints of 1 cm thick. Regarding the boundaries of the assessment, they are characterized as
“cradle to gate”, which means that the LCA includes the stages of raw material extraction, processing,
building materials production, mortar mixing and construction of 1 m2 of masonry. The stages of use
of the construction and its final disposal or recycling after its lifetime has ended, are not considered,
because they require data that go beyond the frame of this study.
3.2 Inventory analysis
As it is mentioned in a previous section, the materials (inputs) that are considered for this study are
all coming from industries located in the Northern Greece area. The same thing applies also for energy
consumption, meaning that, for instance, the electricity mix (sum of electricity that comes from
various sources, such as lignite combustion, renewable sources, etc) that was considered is that of the
Greek Electricity Industry. To be consistent with that choice, all the emissions and wastes (outputs)
had to come from Greek industries as well. However, this proved to be very difficult, because Greek
industries either don’t have detailed measurements, or if they do, they are not always eager to share
such sensitive data. After repeated communication with some of the largest industries of Greece, and
the use of literature referring to Greek reality, this obstacle was surpassed. For the few cases, where
data was impossible to acquire, the Ecoinvent [Frischknecht et.al., 2005] database was used, which
is a much renowned tool for LCA.
More specifically, the emissions for the cement production are a combination of data acquired by
Greek cement industries and from the Ecoinvent database, mainly for procedures regarding fuel
combustion. For clay, the data regarding materials and energy consumption along with emissions and
wastes refer to Greek industries, as they were recorded and presented by [Koroneos & Dompros,
2007]. For the hydrated lime, data where acquired from an industry near the city of Thessaloniki,
Greece, with the addition of data regarding energy consumption taken from literature [Moropoulou
et.al., 2006], that refer also to Greek industries. The emissions from the extraction of pozzolana and
aggregates (sand) are taken from Greek industries. Regarding the bricks, the Ecoinvent database has
been used, because a) the emission data are similar to [Koroneos & Dompros, 2007] and b) the bricks
are the same for all three scenarios, both in quantity and quality, so they don’t really contribute to the
variation of the results.
The cost estimation is conducted alongside the environmental assessment, using data from the Greek
market, as it was recorded in the second half of 2016, and the first half of 2017.
3.3 Impact assessment
The input and output data that were collected for the inventory analysis step, will now be related to
environmental impact categories. The main category that has been chosen for this study is the
contribution of the walls’ construction to climate change, through their Global Warming Potential
(GWP). Each recorded emission that contributes to the impact category is assigned with a
Characterization factor, which expresses the magnitude of the contribution compared to the
contribution of CO2. This way, all emissions are expressed in the same unit (kg of equivalent CO2 per
m2 of constructed wall - kg CO2 eq/m2) and can by summarized into one single result. For this study,
the assessment is based on the Characterization factors that are proposed by the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) [IPCC, 2013], for a 100-year time frame. The results can be seen
in Table 3, where they are sorted in three categories: materials, which includes all processes up to the
production of bricks and the materials used on site to produce the mortar mixture, transportation,
which refers to the transportation of the bricks and mortars’ materials to construction site and energy
which refers to the energy consumed (electricity) for mixing the mortar on site.
126
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 3. Global Warming Potential of the studied scenarios
CEM
CLM
LPM
Unit
kg CO2
eq/m2
kg CO2
eq/m2
kg CO2
eq/m2
Materials
47.7
38.8
42.1
Transportation
1.1
1.1
1.1
Energy
0.1
0.1
0.1
Total
48.9
40.0
43.3
Despite GWP, the assessed constructions have a contribution to other environmental impact
categories, as well. Some of them (abiotic depletion, acidification, eutrophication and ozone layer
depletion) are presented in Figure 1. The abiotic depletion impact category refers to the depletion of
natural resources due to extraction of minerals and fossil fuels, and it is expressed in kg of equivalent
Antimony (Sb) per m2 of wall. Acidification refers to the impact of acidifying substances to
ecosystems as well as constructions, and it is expressed in kg equivalent SO2 per m2 wall.
Eutrophication includes the environmental impacts caused by the emission of macro-nutrients in
excessive levels, into air, water and soil. It is expressed in kg equivalent PO4 per m2 wall. The last
category includes the impacts of increased UV-B radiation, due to ozone layer depletion, that affects
the health of ecosystems. The same rules as GWP apply in the assessment of all these impact
categories, with the Characterization factors following the CML impact assessment method [Guinee,
2002]. For the calculations, the LCA software SimaPro [Goedkoop et.al., 2004] was also
implemented.
Figure 1. Four impact categories for the construction of 1 m2 of brick wall, for the three
studied mortars.
127
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
For the cost estimation, results are shown in Table 4. For each scenario, the cost has been analyzed
into three categories: “materials”, which includes the costs for the purchase of the bricks and the
mortars’ constituents, “transportation”, which includes the costs for the transportation of the bricks
and the mortars’ constituents at the construction site, and “construction”, which includes the energy
costs for preparing the mortars along with the personnel costs for the construction of the 1 m2 wall.
Table 4. Cost estimation of the studied scenarios
CEM
CLM
LPM
Unit
€/m2
€/m2
€/m2
Materials
9
8,21
8,26
Transportation
0,36
0,35
0,35
Construction
4,01
4,01
4,01
Total
13,37
12,57
12,62
3.4 Interpretation of the results
The Life Cycle Assessment of the three different scenarios gives an interesting scope for the
environmental evaluation of the utilized building materials. Regarding the Global Warming Potential
impact category, the construction with cement mortar gives the highest environmental burden,
something that was expected considering the intensiveness of emission production during cement
manufacturing. The construction with clay mortar has the lowest burden, with lime-pozzolana mortar
being somewhere in the middle of the three. This is also expected, because other than some energy
consumption for drying and mixing/sorting, clay requires minimum industrial processing to be ready
to use. Whatever the distribution of total burden may be, between the three scenarios, the common
feature among them is that the materials’ production is dominating over the other stages.
The same conclusions apply also for the assessment of the other three environmental impact
categories (abiotic depletion, eutrophication, ozone layer depletion). The clay-mortar construction
shows the lowest contribution to these environmental issues, with lime-pozzolana following and the
reference cement mortar construction giving the higher environmental burden. However, the
construction that utilizes the lime-pozzolana mortar contributes most in acidification, mainly due to
higher SO2 emissions during lime production.
Clay shows also a slight advantage over lime-pozzolana when considering costs. Of course, the
differences between the three scenarios are minimum for such a small scale (1 m2 of constructed
wall), but the trend can be identified more clearly over larger constructions, where the choice for the
most efficient solution will be of great importance. As in LCA, the importance of materials in the
overall cost is also very distinct here.
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Sustainability in constructions is a diachronic principle which ancient masons followed unremittingly.
Nowadays, cement prevails in construction technology and it seems to be an energy and emissions
intensive material. This paper proves in a quantitative way the relation between traditional binders
and cement in terms of environmental impact and cost. Clay shows the best performance both in
environmental and economical assessment. Comparing to the reference mortar (cement) it improves
the environmental profile of the studied construction by a rate of 18%, regarding the contribution of
the process to climate change, and it is by 6% more cost efficient. In the other environmental impact
categories, clay mortar shows a better performance as well, in various rates. The lime-pozzolana
mortar is also more environmental and economical efficient than the reference mortar (11% and 5.6%
respectively), while in the other environmental impact categories it shows variances, with the
128
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
category of acidification being the one where the lime-pozzolana mortar contributes the most of the
three scenarios.
For this paper the boundaries of the assessment have been characterized as ‘cradle to gate’ and the
considered phases are extraction of the raw materials, production of building materials and
construction. However, it would be useful to consider the whole life of the project, meaning the stages
of use and final disposal or recycling, in the framework of future research, where data of durability
properties will be utilized. Overall cost is also very distinct here. Moreover, there is an evident need
for the composition of national, or even regional environmental databases for the stage of Inventory
Analysis, to have more comprehensive results. Academic and industrial research should work for this
purpose, within, of course, a national regulative frame.
Acknowledgements
Part of the research was developed within a scholarship, funded by the Act “Support of research
manpower, through the development of PhD research”, coming from resources of the OP “Human
Resources Development, Education and Lifelong Learning”, 2014-2020 with support from the
European Social Fund and the Greek Government. Also, Author Karozou A. would like to thank the
General Secretariat for Research and Technology (GSRT) and the Hellenic Foundation for Research
and Innovation (HFRI) for founding the research through the scholarship foundation program for PhD
candidates.
References
1. World Commission on Environment and Development. (1987) ‘Our common future’, Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
2. Papayianni I., Stefanidou M. (2007) ‘Durability Aspects of ancient mortars of the archaeological
site of Olynthos’, Journal of Cultural Heritage, Vol. 8, pp. 193-196.
3. F. Pacheco-Torgal and S. Jalali (2012) ‘Earth construction: Lessons from the past for future ecoefficient construction’, Construction and Building Materials, Vol. 29, pp. 512–519.
4. Papayianni I.(1994) “Durability lessons from the study of old mortars and concretes” P.K.
Mehta Symposium on Durability of Concrete, May, Nice, France pp.145-153.
5. Van Den Heede P. and N. De Belie (2012) ‘Environmental impact and life cycle assessment
(LCA) of traditional and 'green' concretes: Literature review and theoretical calculations’,
Cement and Concrete Composites, Vol. 34(4), pp. 431-442.
6. CEN (2016) Methods of testing cement - Part 1: Determination of strength, EN 196-1. European
Committee for Standardization (CEN), Brussels.
7. CEN (1999) Methods of test for mortar for masonry - Part 3: Determination of consistence of
fresh mortar (by flow table), EN 1015-3. European Committee for Standardization (CEN),
Brussels.
8. ISO (2006a) Environmental management – life cycle assessment – principles and framework, ISO
14040. International Organization for Standardization (ISO), Geneva.
9. ISO (2006b) Environmental management – life cycle assessment – requirements and guidelines,
ISO 14044. International Organization for Standardization (ISO), Geneva.
10. Frischknecht R., N. Jungbluth, H.-J. Althaus, G. Doka, R. Dones, T. Heck, S. Hellweg, R.
Hischier, T. Nemecek, G. Rebitzer and M. Spielmann (2005) ‘The ecoinvent database: Overview
and methodological framework’, International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, Vol. 10, pp.
3–9.
11. Koroneos C. and A. Dompros (2007) ‘Environmental assessment of brick production in Greece’,
Building and Environment, Vol. 42, pp. 2114-2123.
129
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
12. Moropoulou A., C. Koroneos, M. Karoglou, E. Aggelakopoulou, A. Bakolas, and A. Dompros
(2006) Life Cycle Analysis of Mortars and Its Environmental Impact, Materials Research
Society Symposia Proceedings, Vol. 895, pp. 145-150.
13. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, & IPCC. (2013) ‘IPCC Fifth Assessment Report
(AR5)’, WMO, IPCC Secretariat.
14. Guinée, J. B. (2002) ‘Handbook on life cycle assessment: Operation guide to the ISO
standards’, Dordrecht: Kluwer.
15. Goedkoop M., M. Oele and S. Effting, (2004) ‘SimaPro 6 Database Manual—Methods
library’, v. 2.0, PRé Consultants.
130
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
HAZARD ASSESSMENT AND VULNERABILITY REDUCTION IN
THE MEDITERRANEAN LANDSCAPE: THE CASE OF
CRAPOLLA ARCHEOLOGICAL SITE IN THE SORRENTOAMALFI PENINSULA, ITALY
L. Boccia*, A. Capolupo, M. Rigillo, V. Russo
University of Naples Federico II, Department of Architecture, Via Forno Vecchio,12- 80134,
Naples (NA), Italy
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: lorenzo.boccia@unina.it , tel : +39 0812539151
Abstract
The Crapolla Fiord, near to the Amalfi Coast, thanks to its special landscape, can be classified as an
example of a Mediterranean landscape, with exceptional cultural and natural scenic values, resulting
from its outstanding nature and historical evolution. The area hosts the archaeological site of the San
Pietro Abbey, built before the 12th century, and the so-called “monazeni”, vernacular constructions
used by local fishermen for boat sheltering. At present, the site has been just interested by a deep
research experience leaded by the Department of Architecture (DiARC) of the University Federico
II. The study, committed by the local Municipality of Massa Lubrense involved a range of specialized
knowhow represented by four different departments of the University of Naples Federico II, including
an important archaeological survey campaign. As part of the study, the analysis of the surface-water
hydrology has carried out at local scale, by the aim of assessing hazard potential for the site
conservation. The current land cover is bare soil on a specific rocky substratum, although traces of
terraces dating from the time of the Abbey activity are still recognizable. Taking into account the site
exposure (South), its land use, as well as the scenario of further climate change - consistent with the
A1B like scenario (IPCC, 2014) - the increase of site vulnerability is expected. Starting by these
assumptions, the study evaluates the hydrology hazard potential in estimating the variations in flow
rates at secondary auctions, comparing current Land Cover and the one at the time of Abbey activity,.
Due to both the reduced infiltration capacity and the local climate specific, the increase of hazard
potential is expected, as well as the rise of the site vulnerability, and the intensification of the values
exposed in terms of losses potential (the immaterial value of the cultural asset) and hence the increase
in overall site risk. The study quantifies the hazard potential and demonstrates that the introduction
of small interventions aimed at regenerating vegetation and/ or at increasing infiltration capacity,
would be justified and sustainable.
Keywords: Risk assessment, Cultural heritage, Climate change impact
1.
INTRODUCTION
World Cultural Heritage has been object of dedicated policies of conservation since 1972, when the
UNESCO underlined the importance to preserve it and forward it to future generations, enhancing
the ethical involvement of each State and each citizen [World Heritage Convention (WHC), Paris, 16
November 1972]. Therefore, the most important, and largely widespread, factors treating cultural and
environmental heritage have been investigated by scientists, in order to identify which initiatives have
to be undertaken to safeguard those vestiges. To meet that purpose, the key factors to be shifted
through are the climate change risk, and, in particular the water cycle [Cassar, 2005; Sabbioni et al.,
131
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
2008; 2009]. Indeed, the water cycle rules all the aspects related to the climate changes, such as flood
and drought, rainfall extreme events and heat waves, which strongly affect the human settlement and
tourism. Moreover, as shown by a research conducted by the Centre for Sustainability Heritage,
University College London, in cooperation with the Institute of the climate and atmosphere sciences
of the National Research Centre (CNR), “Southern Europe appears to be more vulnerable, although
the North Sea coast has a high exposure to flooding” [Sabbioni et al., 2009]. Consequently, climate
changes will have a great influence on Italian territory and, in particular, on Campania Region
(Southern Italy), characterized by a mild climate. Rainfall events drastically increase the run-off,
eroding the mountainside, from top to bottom [Campania Region, 2014]. The lack of vegetation,
caused by the several forest fires, occurred in the summer period, exacerbates the erosion process
[Campania Region, 2014]. Nevertheless, the Amalfi coast area is not extraneous at extreme rainfall
events, like that one occurred on 25th of October 1954, when 500 mm of rain fall occurred in 4 hours
causing life losses (318 people dead) and huge damages to the built environment [Caneva et al., 2007].
The detecting of some proper actions for conserving the huge cultural heritage and the great beauty
of Campania Region landscape, should be a priority for the Italian Government and the citizens.
Therefore, a correct management plan should be provided for considering the natural hazard potential
Natural hazard is here intended according to the United Nations definition (2004) as the probability
that a harmful occurrence happens. The vulnerability concept is closely linked to the natural hazard
notion, since it is related to its consequences, pondered in terms of damages and loses (Fuchs et al.,
2007). A synthetic definition of vulnerability was given in the glossary of IPPC 2014: “The propensity
or predisposition to be adversely affected. Vulnerability encompasses a variety of concepts and
elements including sensitivity or susceptibility to harm and lack of capacity to cope and adapt”.
Wilson et al., (2005) specify the main components of vulnerability. Wilson et al., (2005) described
the vulnerability as the combination of three elements: exposure, defined as the probability that a
damaging event occurred in a specific time, the impact, pinpointed as the consequences of a specific
harmful process on some peculiar features, and the intensity, indicated as the magnitude, the duration
and the frequency of a particular element. Hence, the need to forecast the risk potential starts in order
to properly evaluate hazard potential and its consequences. Further, natural hazard assessment is
largely influenced by the scale adopted for the analysis of the slope morphology and surface. So that
the scale of the study should be always adapted to the object under investigation [Capolupo et al.,
2015b].
The essential baseline for the morphological analysis is the Digital Elevation Model (DEM), as shown
by Florinsky, (1998). Therefore, the DEM resolution is an essential factor to be considered to improve
the hazard analysis: the highest the resolution is, the most accurate the natural hazard assessment is.
Several techniques have been introduced to generate more and more precise DEM over the years,
such photogrammetry or Laser Image Detection And Ranging (LIDAR).
The current paper aims at evaluating the potential natural hazard that could occur in the area of the
Fiord of Crapolla located in the Amalfi Coast, Campania Region). This area is worldwide famous for
its outstanding landscape and for the presence of historic and cultural goods, potentially subjected to
such as extreme rainfall events and land abandonment. Hence, an empirical analysis of the
vulnerability has also been introduced.
2.
MATERIAL AND METHOD
2.1 Study area
The study has done in the Fiord of Crapolla, an inlet of Sorrento Peninsula. Sorrento Coast is a
promontory, interposes between the Gulf of Naples and the Gulf of Salerno, in Campania Region
(Southern Italy) (Figure 1). The Peninsula of Sorrento covers an area of 121,14 km 2 and it includes
nine municipalities. Although differences in terms of vegetation between the bottom part,
characterized by the typical Mediterranean greenwood and scrublands, and the upper part, typified
by the temperate forest [Caneva and Cancellieri, 2007; Pindozzi et al., 2016] have found out. The two
132
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
sides of promontory have many characteristics in common, such as the presence of terraced
landscapes, featuring the local agricultural economy. Although, the area is distinguished by the
Mediterranean mild climate, the rainfall events are quite plentiful with not so rare catastrophic
showers, as that one above mentioned occurred on 25th of October 1954.
Figure 1: Area under investigation location: 1a) Campania Region location in Italy; 1b)
Location of Crapolla Fiord in Campania Region
The Fiord of Crapolla is inhabited since the Roman period, as testified by the archaeological ruins of
storage rooms and of other proofs found out on its territory. Its reputation has not been slackened off
over the years, indeed, an Abbey, which belonged to the Benedectine Order, was built before 12 th
century [Russo, 2014]. Unfortunately, the Abbey have been continuously pillaged and destroyed and
therefore, just few ruins have been survived (Figure 2). Moreover, that area have been intensely
inhabited over the last past years, as testified by the presence of some terraced landscapes, which
shape the slope from the top till the bottom [Caneva and Cancellieri, 2007]. Those terraces are
subjected to a quick downfall because of the abandonment of agricultural practise on their steps, due
to the difficulty of accessing and their inadequate competitiveness in terms of production efficiency
[Capolupo et al., under review; Capolupo et al., 2017; Capolupo et al., 2018b; Capolupo et al., 2018c].
Therefore, the terraces are already weakly recognized on the slope morphology (Figure 2).
Figure 2: Details of the study area
2.2 Data Sources
In order to meet the purpose of the research, the dataset refers to two data sources: the rainfall
information, provided by Italian National Hydrographic Service in the “Hydrological Annals”, and
the landform mapping, provided by the Digital Surface Model (DSM) and Digital Terrain Model
133
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
(DTM), both commissioned by the Department of Territorial Information System (SIT) of the “Città
Metropolitana di Napoli”.
The “Hydrological Annals” reports the hourly rainfall data for each year from 1928 until the end of
1990s. Those events are classified in five categories according to the duration of 1, 3, 6, 12 and 24
hours. The weather stations (Figure 3) useful for the investigations have been selected considering
two criteria: the distance between the weather stations and the study area and amount of available
data. As first, the stations located less than 20 Km and included in the areas territorial compatible
with the site under investigation (Figure 4) have been picked. Subsequently, they have been chosen
according to the continuity of the series of data. The weather stations used in the consecutive steps
are reported in Table 1.
Figure 3: Weather stations close to the study area, identified in the picture with a green circle
Figure 4 : Wheatear homogeneous areas
The DSM and DTM was obtained by a LIDAR survey in 2009 – 2012. Their resolution was equal to
1 m2 and the altitudinal range accuracy was of 0.15 m. They have been scanned using 4 points/m 2.
Since their raster cells could show some small imperfections, commonly called “pits”, which can
134
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
create discontinuities in the hydro-graphic scenes, both DTM and DSM have been pre-processed with
the ArcGIS’ hydrology tool (version 10.1) for filling the holes [Infascelli et al., 2013].
Table 1: The wheatear stations useful for the analysis
Weather station
Quota
Distance from Period of available
the study
data
area (km)
Piano di Sorrento San
309
5
1957-1996
Pietro
Piano di Sorrento Ist.
122
5.5
1950-1998
Nautico
Massa Lubrense Fraz
250
4
1977-1999
Turro
Number of
useful data
28
28
19
Positano
195
10
1928-1943
11
Agerola San Lazzaro
683
16
1928-1966
19
Ravello
315
21
1928-1995
30
Maiori
60
23
1928-1985
34
Cava de Tirreni – Badia
367
23
1955-1984
23
Cava de Tirreni – Ente
Turismo
199
21
1956-1996
21
2.3 Rainfall event identification
The rainfall event has been determined using the Gumbel theory, that is considered the most largely
widespread procedure for meteorological purposes [Nadarajah & Kotz, 2004]. Actually, this approach
is not able to describe the meteorological catastrophic events, like that one occurred in 1954.
However, it defines the meteorological probability curves for a specific return period for each class
of rainfall data of each selected weather station. It was applied in the current research because the
rainfall events considered have relatively short return period (T).
Therefore, the average (µ) and the Deviation Standard (DS) have been computed for each class of
information of each weather station. This step was essential since it allows to calculate the parameters
needed to describe the Gumbel probability distribution (α and u). The equation of the two parameters
are described in Equations 1 and 2, respectively:
π
α = DSx√6
(1)
u = µ − 0.45 x DS
(2)
Therefore, the rainfall intensity (h) has been computed for each data class of each weather station
using Equation 3. Subsequently, the results of each station have been averaged.
hij (T = 100) = uij −
1
αij
1
x ln[− ln(1 − T)]
(3)
where i is referred to the weather station considered and j to the data class considered.
135
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
Considering the limited extension of the mountainside (about 1500 m) and the difference in altitude
(about 500 m), a return period less than 1 hour was preferred for the current analysis. Therefore, it
was realistic to focus the attention on a return period equal to 0.5 hour. Consequently, the rain
intensity on T = 30 minutes was estimated using the formula of Bell (Equation 4) [Bell, 1969] and
not spatializing the rainfall events extracted from the weather stations.
h30’(T=100)= h1h(T=100)*(0,54*300,25-0,50)
(4)
2.4 Potential hazard assessment
Combining the identification of vegetated areas and the slope analysis allows to identify the flow
directions and, consequently, the water accumulated in two different points: the former corresponding
to the Fiord of Crapolla and the latter, related to the Abbey of Saint Peter at Crapolla. The vegetated
areas have been detected by subtracting the DSM and DTM, while the surface flow direction have
been carried out using the eight-direction flow model (D8), implemented in ArcGis (vers. 10.1), since
Wolock et al., (1995) and Beaujouan et al., (2001) showed that this approach was suitable for shaping
the micro-rill network at field scale. This procedure has been described more in details in Capolupo
et al., [2014; 2015a; 2018a]. An outlet has been located on the rill corresponding to the Fiord of
Crapolla and another on the micro-rill in the vicinity of the Abbey. Therefore, two basins have been
identified.
Thus, the flow rate has been calculated for both conditions by applying Equation 5:
Q= AxIxC
(5)
where A is the basin area, I is the rain intensity and C is the coefficient of run-off, which was defined
considering the texture and the type of soil. The most vegetated and cultivated areas were
characterized by a sandy loam soil, while the zone close to the Abbey is mainly rocky. Therefore,
according to the indication of the American Society of Civil Engineers, C was assumed equal to 0.8
for T = 100 and 0.5 for T = 1 for the rocky zone and, equal to 0.2 (T=100) and 0.15 (T=1) for the
sandy loam soil.
3.
RESULTS
3.1 Rainfall event
The rain intensity, considering a return period equal to 100 years (T=100), related to all the weather
stations suitable for the research, is reported in Table 2. The weather station of Massa Lubrense has
been the closest one to the site under investigation. It shows a very high value of rainfall, comparing
to the other stations. Indeed, for the examined cases (1h, 3h, 6h, 12h and 24h) the rainfall intensity is
equal to 130 mm, 139 mm, 142 mm, 151 mm and 158 mm, respectively; on the contrary, the station
of Ravello has a value equal to 54 mm, 81 mm, 124 mm, 153 mm and 180 mm, respectively; the
rainfall intensity is equal to 76 mm, 104 mm, 125 mm, 140 mm and 156 mm, respectively; the station
of Piano Sorrento (S. Pietro) is equal to 69 mm, 83 mm, 96 mm, 129 mm and 151 mm, respectively.
That situation depends on the discontinuity of the available data and on the presence of an exceptional
event occurred in 1992, that has a great influence on the final result. Therefore, that information is
not reliable and it was preferred to assume that the rain intensity varies between 70 and 130 mm in 1
hour, considering a return period equal to 100 years.
136
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 2 : Rain Intensity considering (T=100)
Weather stations
Rainfall intensity
(h) in 1h (T=100)
(mm)
Rainfall
intensity (h) in
3 h (T=100)
(mm)
Rainfall
intensity (h) in
6 h (T=100)
(mm)
Rainfall
intensity (h)
in 12 h
(T=100)
(mm)
Rainfall
intensity
(h) in 24 h
(T=100)
(mm)
Ravello
54
81
124
153
180
Piano Sorrento
(Istituto Nautico)
76
104
125
140
156
Piano Sorrento (S.
Pietro)
69
83
96
129
151
Massa Lubrense
130
139
142
151
158
Because of that variability of data, the rain intensity in 30 minutes was obtained using the Bell’s
equation. The results, for each weather station, are shown in Table 3. Therefore, the intensity of rain
is equal to 60 and 23 mm in 30 minutes, respectively taking into consideration a return period of 100
and 1 year.
Table 3 : Rain Intensity in 30 minutes ( T=100)
Weather stations
Rain intensity (h) in 30’ (T=100) (mm)
Ravello
41
Piano Sorrento (Istituto Nautico)
58
Piano Sorrento (S. Pietro)
52
Massa Lubrense
99
3.2 Potential hazard assessment
Figure 5 shows the vegetation distribution overall the study area, obtained from the subtraction of
DSM from DTM. The vegetation is rare around the archaeological ruins of the Abbey, while it is a
little bit more prominent along the steep mountainside. That situation is also visible in Figure 2, where
the site under investigation is depicted. That information is essential because it affects the flow
directions and, consequently, the flow accumulation in some specific zones.
Figure 5: Vegetated zone in Crapolla Fiord. The green square symbolizes the Abbey
Thus, combining it with the information related to the slope aspect, the identification of the basins is
carried out (Figure 6). Figure 5a shows the micro-basins in a close proximity of the Abbey, while
137
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
Figure 5b portrays the basin in the vicinity of the Fiord. The maximum flow rate is equal to 0.04 and
8.3 m3/s for the micro-basins (Figure 6a) and the basin (Figure 6b) respectively, taking into account
a rainfall event of 60 mm in 30 minutes (T=100); on the contrary, considering a rainfall event of 23
mm in 30 minutes (T=1), the flow rate is equal to 0.02 and 2.4 m3/s, respectively.
a
b
Figure 6: Micro - basins identified in the study area at slope (7a) and Fiord (7b) scale
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
The current research activity intends to assess the potential hazard and to consider the vulnerability
in an archaeological site of invaluable price in terms of cultural heritage and landscape. It is
characterized by the presence of the archaeological ruins of an ancient Abbey on the mountainside
and on some characteristics, called “monazeni” fishing houses in the inlet (Figure 2) [Russo, 2014].
Moreover, the steep mountain shows barely visible signs of old terraces, currently abandoned (Figure
2) [Russo, 2014].
The analysis has been carried out at two different levels: at basin scale, to evaluate the potential hazard
to which is subjected the Fiord, and at mountainside scale, to analyse the damages suffered by the
Abbey. The starting stages of the procedure were the same for both levels. They concern the
identification of the rainfall events and, consequently, the flow rate, weighing on the Abbey and on
the Fiord, respectively. The rain intensity was computed for each weather station separately. As
mentioned above, the meteorological station of Massa Lubrense, the closest to the study area, shows
an anomalous value of rainfall in 1 hour (130 mm), because of the presence of an extreme rainfall
events (1992). Therefore, the rain event in 30 minutes was calculated using the Bell’s equation and
not spatializing the meteorological data (Table 3). The rain intensity, on a period of 30 minutes, was
of 60 and 23 mm, considering a return time of 100 and 1 year, respectively. Those results and the size
of the basins, identified at the two considered levels, were set up in eq. 5 and the flow rate was
evaluated (Figure 6). Figure 6a describes the situation at slope aspect scale, while the Figure 6b
depicts the flow rate which damage the Fiord in case of the occurrence of the determined rain event.
As expected, the two flow rates are completely different, since the final result is strongly affected by
the coefficient of run-off and the basin size: the bigger the basin area is, the higher the flow rate is,
and consequently, the potential hazard. Hence, the potential hazard related to the archaeological ruins
is smaller than that one of the Fiord. Nevertheless, both flow rates show a value suitable for damaging
the Abbey and completely destroying the inlet and the fishing houses located in that zone (Figure 2).
138
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Not only the potential hazard but also the vulnerability assumes a different significance at the two
levels, since affected by the exposed value [Wilson et al., 2005]. The vulnerability includes the value
of “intangible assets”, as the historical landmark and the archaeological ruins, the infrastructures for
improving the accessibility, like, for instance, paths and stairways, and, finally, the human lives that
could be damaged. Even if the vulnerability assumes a different value at the two levels, it is pretty
high in both cases and consequently, some actions are required to mitigate the potential hazard.
Fragmenting the flow directions to minimize the flow rates looks a possible solution for reducing the
potential hazard. Clearly, the initiatives suggested for meeting the purpose are essentially different at
the two analysed scales. At Abbey scale, the actions should be focused on building a gutter at the
sides of the ladder, since it is the main direction that guide the flow on the archaeological ruins. On
the contrary, at mountainside level, it is necessary to preserve the vegetated and cultivated areas in
order to not change the permeability of the soil, which influence the coefficient of run-off. Indeed, a
change of soil from sandy loam to rocky will increase the run-off coefficient from 0.2 to 0.8 and
consequently, the flow rate will rise till 33 m3/s for T=100 and to 8 m3/s for T=1. Hence, the idea of
recovering the old terraced landscapes, currently barely visible on the ground, was born. Indeed, that
action is twofold: the potential hazard is minimized, as first, and the original landscape heritage in
the inlet is safeguarded, secondly.
References
1. IPCC, (2014): Annex II: Glossary [Mach, K.J., S. Planton and C. von Stechow (eds.)]. In: Climate
Change 2014: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Fifth
Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Core Writing Team, R.K.
Pachauri and L.A. Meyer (eds.)]. IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland, pp. 117-130.
2. Convention for the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage (Paris, 16 November
1972) (WHC), entered into force 17 December 1975.
3. Cassar M. (2005) Climate change and the historic environment. Centre for Sustainable Heritage,
University College, London
4. Sabbioni, C., Cassar, M., Brimblecombe, P., and R. A. Lefevre (2008). Vulnerability of Cultural
Heritage to Climate Change, Report for E. FERNANDEZ-GALIANO, Council of Europe
European and Mediterranean Major Hazards Agreement (EUR-OPA), 6 November 2008.
5. Sabbioni, C., Cassar, M., Brimblecombe, P., and R. A. Lefevre, (2009). Vulnerability of cultural
heritage to climate change. Pollution Atmospherique, 202, 157-169.
6. Regione Campania, Piano Regionale Triennale 2014-2016 per la Programmazione delle Attività
di Previsione, Prevenzione e Lotta Attiva Contro gli Incendi Boschivi available at
http://burc.regione.campania.it Carta pp.149-150, accessed 20.10.2016
7. Caneva, G., Cancellieri, L., Zivkovic, L., Grilli, R., Lombardozzi, V., and G.Salerno (2007). Il
paesaggio naturale ed il paesaggio culturale.
8. International Strategy for Disaster Reduction. (2004). Living with risk: a global review of disaster
reduction initiatives (Vol. 1). United Nations Publications.
9. Fuchs, S., Heiss, K., and J. Hübl (2007). Towards an empirical vulnerability function for use in
debris flow risk assessment. Natural Hazards and Earth System Science, 7(5), 495-506.
10. Wilson, K., Pressey, R. L., Newton, A., Burgman, M., Possingham, H., and C.Weston, (2005).
Measuring and incorporating vulnerability into conservation planning. Environmental
management, 35(5), 527-543.
11. Capolupo, A., Kooistra, L., Berendonk, C., Boccia, L., and J.Suomalainen (2015b). ″Estimating
plant traits of grasslands from UAV-acquired hyperspectral images: A comparison of statistical
approaches″. ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, 4(4), 2792-2820.
139
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
12. Florinsky I. V. (1998). Combined analysis of digital terrain models and remotely sensed data in
landscape investigations. Prog. Phys. Geogr. 22, 28.
13. Pindozzi, S., Cervelli, E., Capolupo, A., Okello, C., and L. Boccia (2016). Using historical maps
to analyze two hundred years of land cover changes: case study of Sorrento peninsula (south
Italy). Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 43(3), 250-265.
14. V. Russo (2014). Landscape as Architecture. Identity and Conservation of Crapolla Cultural Site,
V. Russo (ed.), Nardini, Firenze 2014.
15. Capolupo, A., Cervelli, E., Pindozzi, S., and L.Boccia (2017). Assessing volumetric and
geomorphologic changes of terraces in Amalfi Coast using photogrammetric technique. In:
“Biosystems Engineering addressing the human challenges of the 21st century”. Bari:
Università degli Studi di Bari Aldo Moro, ISBN: 978-88-6629-020-9, Bari - Italy, July 5-8, 2017
16. Capolupo, A., Kooistra, L. and L.Boccia (2018b). Geomorphological change detection and
historical evolution analysis of terraced landscapes, an old irreversible agricultural practice: the
case study of Minori, in Campania Region. Geophysical Research Abstracts, In Vol. 20,
EGU2018-18700, 2018, EGU General Assembly 2018. Vienna – Austria, 8-13 April, 2018.
17. Capolupo, A., Rigillo, M. and L. Boccia (2018c). Photogrammetric technique for analysing the
anthropization process in coastal areas: the case study of Minori. “Il Monitoraggio Costiero
Mediterraneo: problematiche e tecniche di misura" (Edition VII), Livorno - Italy, June 19-21,
2018.
18. Infascelli R, Faugno S, Pindozzi S, Boccia L, and P. Merot (2013). Testing different topographic
indexes to predict wetlands distribution. Procedia Environmental Sciences. 00, 000–000
19. Nadarajah, S., & Kotz, S., 2004. The beta Gumbel distribution. Mathematical Problems in
engineering, 2004(4), 323-332.
20. Bell, F. C. (1969). Generalized rainfall-duration-frequency relationships, J. Hydraul. Eng.,
95(HY1), 311-327.
21. Wolock D. M., and G. J. McCabe (1995). Comparison of single and multiple flow direction
algorithms for computing topographic parameters in TOPMODEL. Water Resour Res 31, 13151324.
22. Beaujouan V, Durand P, L. Ruiz (2001). Modelling the effect of the spatial distribution of
agricultural practices on nitrogen fluxes in rural catchments. Ecol Model 137, 93–105.
23. Capolupo, A., Kooistra, L. and L.Boccia, (under review). A novel approach for detecting
agricultural terraced landscapes from historical and contemporaneous photogrammetric aerial
photos. International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation.
24. Capolupo, A., Pindozzi, S., Okello, C., and L.Boccia (2014). ″Indirect field technology for
detecting areas object of illegal spills harmful to human health: application of drones,
photogrammetry and hydrological models″. Geospatial Health, 8(3), 699-707.
25. Capolupo, A., Pindozzi, S., Okello, C., Fiorentino, N., and L. Boccia (2015a). ″Photogrammetry
for environmental monitoring: The use of drones and hydrological models for detection of soil
contaminated by copper″. Science of the Total Environment, 514, 298-306.
26. Capolupo, A., Nasta, P., Palladino, M., Cervelli, E., Boccia, L., and N. Romano (2018a).
Assessing the ability of hybrid poplar for in-situ phytoextraction of cadmium by using UAV –
photogrammetry and 3D flow simulator. International Journal of Remote Sensing (TRES).
DOI: 10.1080/01431161.2017.1422876.
140
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
TERRACED LANDSCAPES LOCATED IN AREAS OF GREAT
VALUE FOR TOURISTIC PURPOSES AS AN IRREVERSIBLE
PRACTICE
A. Capolupo and L. Boccia*
University of Naples Federico II, Department of Architecture,Via Forno Vecchio,12- 80134, Naples
(NA), Italy
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: lorenzo.boccia@unina.it , tel : +39 0812539151
Abstract
Since Neolithic, terraced landscapes have been an essential element for moulding mountain or steep
slope into habitable arable areas. Over the last decades, they have been subjected to a quick
abandonment because of their inadequate economic competitiveness causing a gap in their
maintenance and, consequently, incrementing the hydrogeological instability of those areas. Minori
is a small municipality (256 ha), protected by UNESCO, located in Amalfi Coast. That area is well
known not only for the beauty of its territory but also for some catastrophic raining events, like in
1954 when a rain shower of 500 mm topped up to 24 hours. The current research work intends to
analyse the landscape changes in Minori over sixty year period (1956 - 2017) for assessing the new
values taken on the land use and the agricultural sites. A detailed orthophoto and a high resolution
Digital Elevation Model (DEM) of the study area have been reconstructed using the historical
photogrammetric photos of 1954, acquired by the Italian Military Geographic Institute (IGM), and
the aerial photogrammetric pictures of 2017, obtained by an own flight. DEM and orthophoto have
been reconstructed applying Agisoft Photoscan Professional. The resolution of the generated DEM is
equal to 0.48 and 0.1 m for 1956 and 2017, respectively. The orthophoto resolution is of 0.24 and
0.07 for 1956 and 2017, respectively. Comparing the generated products of the two periods, it is
pointed out that terraces extension has not been amended, while the amount of human constructions
have increased of about 800%. To give a first idea of the most vulnerable areas to be investigated
more in depth through simulation procedures, a first proposal of an expeditious index of vulnerability
(EVI) has been introduced and tested. It is based on the ratio between the amount of surface occupied
by buildings and the amount of areas subjected to a debris flow event. The increase of the
vulnerability, exposure values and probability of accident occurring involve a risk rise.
Keywords: Agricultural terraces, Risk assessment, Aerial photogrammetry, Historical series
1.
INTRODUCTION
Terraced landscapes are largely widespread in all Mediterranean area since Neolithic time. They have
been built to exploit the great fertility of the slope of the mountain, making them arable and habitable.
Indeed, that geomorphological element is recognized as the most significant human activity that
affected and transformed the Earth Surface. Unfortunately, over the last few years, they have been
quickly abandoned because of their scarce competitiveness in term of agriculture production [Tarolli
et al., 2014]. This caused a lack of maintenance of their retaining walls and, consequently, the boost
of hydrological instability, soil erosion, loss of agricultural lands and debris flow. Therefore, editing
a proper management plan to preserve the terraced landscapes looks essential and priority in all the
world, according also to the European Common Agricultural Policy (CAP). The situation becomes
more complex when the considered area is included in the UNESCO World Heritage List, like Amalfi
141
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
Coast (year 1997 n. 830). Since 1972, UNESCO have pushed their members to preserve and conserve
all the sites, involved in the World Heritage List, for present and future generation [“World Natural
and Cultural Heritage”, Paris, 16 November 1972]. Nevertheless, UNESCO does not provide any
models or indications regarding the management plans to be developed [Gullino et al., 2015].
Consequently, the necessity to define and implement a proper risk management program is still alive.
It should be edited considering the natural hazard to be opposed. As underlined by Fuchs et al., (2007),
natural hazard is a physical event which cause a catastrophic event in a defined time and space,
damaging the human being and their environment. More in general, the natural hazard has been
defined by United Nations (2004) as the “probability of the occurrence of a potential damaging
phenomenon”. The debris flow, triggered by rainfall, is recognized as the most common hazard for
terraced landscapes and, therefore, it needs a particular attention.
The vulnerability concept is directly connected to the natural hazard. It is defined as the probability
to be damaged following the occurrence of a determined event [Birkmann, 2006]. Nevertheless,
[Wilson et al., 2005] extended that definition, involving the three dimensions of vulnerability:
exposure, intensity and impact. It is expressed by an index which varies between 0 and 1, where 1 is
associated to a complete destruction while 0 is related to ability of the people, buildings and
infrastructures to not be damaged. Even if several indices have been developed and tested for
investigating the vulnerability of buildings and infrastructures, just few indicators have been
introduced to assess the vulnerability of the landscape. Nevertheless, each of them requires a
laborious and expensive procedure to evaluate the vulnerability in particular at detailed scale. Hence
the need to develop an expeditious indicator for assessing the vulnerability of the areas subjected to
a debris flow at detailed scale on terraces.
To fill that gap of knowledge, the information related to terraces position and status at detailed scale
are necessary. Capolupo et al., (in review) developed a novel approach for detecting terraced
landscapes at detailed scale, going beyond the limits of the traditional approaches. It was based on
the combination of photogrammetry and object-oriented analysis (OBIA) technique. The former is an
essential tool for generating high resolution Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) and orthophotos able
to describe the morphological surface of the Earth [Capolupo et al., 2015a; Capolupo et al., 2015b;
Capolupo et al., 2018a]. The latter, was preferred to the pixel oriented classification procedure
because it is able to take advantages of both spectral signature and morphological contribution.
The new abilities of territorial analysis and terraced landscapes detection constitute the
presuppositions to estimate the vulnerability at detailed scale. Indeed, the current research activity
aimed to introduce a first proposal of a morphological Expeditious Indicator of Vulnerability (EVI)
able to identify the most vulnerable areas, which need an analysis more in depth through simulation
procedures.
2.
MATERIAL AND METHOD
2.1 Study area
The research activity was conducted in Minori (40° 39’ 00” N, 14° 37’ 35” E), the most ancient
municipality of Amalfi Coast, in Salerno province (Southern Italy). Its territory extends over 2.56
km2 and, as underlined by Caneva and Cancellieri, (2007), it is well-known overall the world for
several aspects: the uniqueness of its landscape, modelled by human activities since 950 – 1025 AC,
the great variety of vegetation, the cultural heritage of great value, dating from Roman period, the
high quality farming products, such as chestnuts, lemons and grapes. Although the first two points
are getting prevalent in the last few years attracting more and more tourists, the agricultural was and
is the main source of income [Caneva and Cancellieri, 2007; Pindozzi et al., 2016]. Indeed, the
terraced landscapes construction started during the Middles Ages to increase the soil permeability
and reduce the slope gradients of mountains in order to make that area arable and habitable [Tarolli
et al., 2014]. Unfortunately, just traditional agricultural techniques can be adopted on terraced
landscapes because of their structures and locations. This involves that agriculture sector of that area
142
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
is not competitive anymore and, consequently, their abandonment has been getting more frequent,
focusing the local economy on the tourism branch. The climate is mainly Mediterranean in the lower
part of the municipality, while in the upper part, it is essentially temperate [Caneva and Cancellieri,
2007]. Usually, the annual rainfall average is higher than 1000 mm, even if the area has been subjected
to some catastrophic events, like the showers of more than 500 mm fallen in about four hours on the
25th of October 1954. Those events cannot be described using the Gumbel distribution, the most
widely applied for describing the meteorological problems, but by the Two Component Extreme
Value (TCEV) [Rossi and Villani, 1994].
2.2 Field data and photogrammetric aerial photos collection
The data sources of the current research activity involves:
the panchromatic historical series of the 13th of April 1956;
the RGB photogrammetric aerial photos of the 13th of March 2017;
the multispectral photogrammetric aerial photos of the 13th of March 2017;
162 Ground Control Points (GCPs).
The panchromatic historical series is composed by the three different frames (197-V-1811; 197-V1812; 197-V-1813) acquired at the quotas of 3900 m. They have been scanned using a
photogrammetric scanner by the Italian Military Geographical Institute (IGM). Their format is equal
to 230 x 230 mm.
The RGB and the multispectral photogrammetric aerial photos were instead acquired by an own flight
campaign, conducted under clear sky conditions at the altitude of 1000 m, using a Piper PA 18 Super
CUB-I-CGAO & I-NIKI (VFR). That airplane was chosen because of the presence of a trapdoor
located at the bottom of the chassis, where the cameras were placed. A Reflex Nikon D800e,
characterized by 36.3 Mp and a pixel size of 0.00487 mm, was used to acquire the RGB images. A
lens of 50 mm was mounted on it in order to adapt the final resolution to the size of the object under
investigation. Also an external Global Position System (GPS) was employed on the camera in order
to georeference the acquired pictures and to optimize the following metric reconstruction. A specific
external circuit, composed by Arduino components, was designed and built by the Landscape and
Rural Planning research unit (LARP) of the University of Naples Federico II to remotely control the
shutter camera. The Tetracam ADC Snap, characterized by 1.3 Mp and a pixel size of 0.005 mm, was
instead chosen to capture the multispectral photos. Its range of acquisition is comprised between 520
and 920 nm, corresponding to Red, Green and Near Infrared bands. Its internal timer was adequately
set to control the camera shutter and to acquire the image at a specific instant.
As suggested by Nex and Remondino, (2014), the GCPs were acquired to improve the accuracy of
the final metric reconstruction. Therefore, three field data campaigns were performed the 25th, 27th of
January 2016 and the 27th of April 2017 and 162 GCPs were acquired using a Differential Global
Position System (DGPS) Sokkia GRX1 in ETRF2000 Epoch 2008. Two different sub-datasets were
randomly generated extracting the GCPs from the original data source, as suggested by Höhle and
Höhle, (2009): the former was employed for the metric reconstruction; the latter for the accuracy
assessment.
2.3 Scene metric reconstruction and terraces classification
Each block of images has been separately processed in order to obtain the photogrammetric outcomes
from each of them. Before starting the metric reconstruction, two preliminary steps (quality check of
the photogrammetric pictures and the image orientation) were performed on the historical and on the
recent datasets in order to improve the final outcomes. In addition, also the laboratory camera
calibration was carried out for the RGB contemporaneous dataset using Agisoft Photoscan Lens
software (Agisoft LLC, St. Petersburg, Russia). That phase could not be applied on the historical
series and on the multispectral images since, in the first case, the interior parameters of the camera
143
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
were unknown while, in the second case, the dataset would be subjected to a specific procedure
applying PixelWrench2 software (Tetracam, inc, Chatsworth, Cal.).
The quality check was performed selecting the photos to be utilized during the reconstruction stage
through their visual inspection. The results of that phase were essentially different for the three data
sources: no defects were detected on the historical series; on the other hand, the 3% of RGB and
multispectral pictures were blurry, and, consequently, they were removed and not took into account
during the following procedures. That step has not affected the final results of the reconstruction
procedure because these frames had been acquired during the phase to achieve the flight quotas and
the first waypoints. Thus, the image orientation phase, consisting in the extraction of tie points and
pictures alignment, started in Agisoft Photoscan Professional environment (Agisoft LLC, St.
Petersburg, Russia). The deformation of the images blocks was minimized importing the subdataset
of GCPs suitable for the metric reconstruction in that environment. Two Digital Elevation Models
(DEMs) were extracted from the historical series and from the contemporaneous RGB dataset; on the
contrary, three orthophotos were generated from each data sources. All the details regarding the
photogrammetric process have been reported in Capolupo et al., (2014, 2015a, 2017).
Before starting the classification phase to identify and classify the terraces, the small discontinuities
in the two DEMs were removed applying ArcGis Hydrological tool of ESRI ArcGis Software, version
10.1 (Redlands, CA., USA) as reported in Infascelli et al., (2013). Moreover, all the obtained
photogrammetric rasters were purified from the sea and the border areas, since they were
characterized by a high error in terms of elevation caused by the lack of GCPs in that zones.
The photogrammetric results were subsequently processed in eCognition Developer 9 software
(TRIMBLE Germany Gmbh) in order to generate a binary map, in which the terraced and not terraced
landscapes were distinguished. An OBIA approach was preferred to the common pixel oriented
classification technique in order to exploit the advantages of multispectral images and DEM. That
procedure involved two different stages: the former, related to the segmentation phase, while, the
latter, regarding the construction of a proper classification model. Two different segmentation
algorithms, the “multiresolution segmentation” and the “spectral difference segmentation” were
performed to fit the size of the generated objects to the real - world elements under investigations
[Benz et al., 2004]. The second algorithm was applied only on the blocks of contemporaneous images
since the spectral signature was not available for the historical series. The parameters of the two
algorithms were set iteratively adapting them to the complexity and the heterogeneity of the study
area, as described in Capolupo et al., (in review). A specific tree-level hierarchical structure, based
on a proper rule – set, was built enhancing the contribution of each layer suitable for the terraces
detection. The weighs attributed to each layer and the indices chosen for optimizing the classification
have been reported and described in Capolupo et al., (in review). All the objects included in the
terraces class were, subsequently, merged and exported as a single layer.
The accuracy assessment phase was composed by two different aspects: the error analysis of the
photogrammetric products and of the detected terraced landscapes. The former was obtained
developing a specific code in R environment, which was based on the statistical approach reported
by Höhle and Höhle (2009). It considers the calculation of residuals between the estimated and
measured points. Therefore, the coefficient of determination (R2) and the Mean Error was examined
to analyse their spatial trend. On the contrary, the accuracy of the generated binary map was expressed
in terms of the percentage of terraced landscape correctly classified. It was assessed by comparing
the final outcome with thirty validation data, manually selected during an interpretation phase of the
generated orthophotos.
2.4 Landslide event and vulnerability indicator
The terraced landscapes largely widespread in the area under investigation have been subjected to a
quick abandonment because of their scarce competitiveness (Tarolli et al., 2014). This caused a lack
of maintenance of their retaining walls, which, consequently, are exposed to a high hazard for slope
failures, easily triggered by the particular climate conditions of Minori, prone to heavy showers, like
144
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
the event of the 25th of October 1954. The effects on the cultivations, buildings and safety of people
depends on the intensity and prevalence of the phenomenon. Catastrophic rainfall entail the landslides
of all the mountain slope, damaging the floodplain and destroying all the buildings. No actions could
be taken to prevent that situation. On the contrary, the landslide of a small piece of terrace damages
a defined area. That kind of incidents are more common, as shown by the bibliography [Crosta et al.,
2003; Del Ventisette et al., 2012], and, consequently, they are more interesting to investigate.
In particular, the morphological characteristics of Giampilieri area in Messina Province are similar to
that ones of Minori. Therefore, the seven debris flows occurred in Giampilieri on 1th of October 2009,
described by Del Ventisette et al., (2012), could be similar to the landslides could verify in the area
under investigation. In that case, they observed that the landslides volume of the seven debris flows
was comprised between 817 and 13507 m3.
In the current study, an hypothetical debris flow, which characteristics are similar to that ones of the
incident occurred in Giampilieri, was supposed and its effects were investigated. Its volume was
assumed equal to 1000 m3, corresponding to an area of 20 x 30 m2 with a depth of 1.5 m.
The pre-processed photogrammetric DEMs were separately processed in order to detect the slope
direction for each cell using the Surface Tool of ArcGis software. Therefore, for each direction a
travel distance (L) of the debris flow was computed using the Equation 1, introduced by Rickenmann
(1999):
L = 1.9 x V0.16 x H0.83
(1)
where V is the volume and H is the total fall height. Crosta et al., (2003) showed the efficiency of the
Equation 1 for describing the debris flow on terraced slopes.
The comparison between the travel distance and the length of the mountain slope gives an idea of the
debris flow hazard potential. Indeed, if L is smaller than the length of the mountain slope, the
underlying area will not be not reached by any debris and, consequently, it is not damaged. On the
contrary, if L is bigger than the other parameter, the underlying zones will be reached by the landslides
and the damages will be proportional to the travel distance and the speed of the flow. The bigger the
travel distance (L), the more vulnerable the underlying zone is. Therefore, on one hand the travel
distance is an empirical indicator of the debris flow hazard potential, as underlined by Rickenmann
(1999), on the other hand it allows to detect the vulnerable areas to be analyse more in depth.
Examining the bibliography [Crosta et al., 2003; Del Ventisette et al., 2012] and the geometry of
terraced landscapes, the overall conclusion is that the surface mainly interested by the debris flow on
the flat at the basis of the terraced landscapes is of the order of 25 m. Each identified zone is
characterize by a vulnerability value depending on the amount of buildings, historical ruins and the
quantity of people which live in that area. To be able to define an univocal vulnerability value adapted
to each area requires a laborious work based on the knowledge of each territorial element and the
exact trend of the debris flow through an expensive simulation process.
The assessment of the house volume (m3) in the detected vulnerable areas could be a first expeditious
indicator of the vulnerability value for each identified areas. Such justification shall demonstrate the
acronym Expeditious Vulnerability Index (EVI) (Equation 2). That index allows to minimize the
simulations by limiting them just to the areas managed by a high value of EVI.
EVI = Σ Vbi / AV
(2)
where Vbi is the volume of each building included in that area and Av is the area of the vulnerable
zone in question. EVI is expressed in term of percentage. Each building was detected by manually
interpreting the obtained orthophoto. The volume of each of them was calculated by multiplying the
surface occupied and its height.
145
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
3.
RESULTS
3.1 Scene metric reconstruction and terraces classification
Each block of images were separately processed to generate the photogrammetric outcomes. A high
resolution orthophoto was generated from the three data sources: block of 1956, RGB pictures of
2017 and multispectral photos of 2017. Their resolution (GSD) was equal to 240 mm, 7 mm and 15
mm, respectively. Instead, the DEMs were obtained only from the dataset of 1956 and the RGB
pictures of 2017. Their resolution was equal to 480 mm and 10 mm, respectively. Comparing the two
orthophotos show that the buildings have boosted of 800% in the last 60 years. The consecutive
procedure has led to generate a binary map, where the non terraced landscapes were distinguished
from the terraced landscapes, shown in Figure 1. The accuracy assessment of the two final binary
maps (Figure 1) was equal to 93% and 98% for the historical and the contemporaneous series, since
three points have not been recognized in the first one and just one in the second one. The not
recognized terraces have been marked with the yellow dots in Figure 1.
Figure 1: Validation of terraced landscapes for the dataset of 1956 and 2017, respectively. The
blue points are correctly recognized; while, the yellow points are not recognized
3.2 Vulnerability indicator
Nine slopes, corresponding to nine directions of flow have been identified on the two sides of the
mountains which go downs towards the municipality of Minori (Figure 2). For each of them the travel
distance have been computed and compared with the length of the considered slope in order to identify
the vulnerable areas. The results are reported in Table 1.
Table 4: Travel distance for each slope and the length of each of them
Slopes ID
Colour
Length of each
Travel Distance
Difference between
corresponding to
slope (m)
(L)(m)
the length of the
the slopes in
slope and L (m)
Figure 2
1
Red
222
1425
1203
2
Yellow
361
941
579
3
Green
288
751
463
4
Blue
310
933
623
5
Black
205
2768
2563
6
White
329
1305
977
7
Orange
118
4102
3984
8
Purple
269
74
-195
9
Pink
303
861
557
146
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The travel distance (L) (Equation 1) of the slope number 8 (the purple area in Figure 2) is smaller
than the length of the slopes, as shown in Table 1. Indeed, the difference between the length and the
travel distance is -195 m. Therefore, a landslide generated at the top of that slope is not dangerous
because the debris will not reach the underlying portion of municipality. Consequently, there is no
reason to investigate the vulnerability of that area more in depth. On the contrary, the highest debris
flow hazard potential is traced in the numbers 1, 5, 7 with a value of 1203 m, 2563 m and 3984 m,
respectively. The values identified was the same for both data sources.
Figure 2: Slope direction
Eight vulnerable areas with a thickness of 25 m have been inspected in correspondence of slopes 1,
2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9. In each of them, EVI have been computed and shown in Figure 3, where the colour
at each areas was assigned according to the vulnerability significance: green to the lowest value,
orange to the medium rate and red to the highest one. The higher the EVI, the more vulnerable the
area is. For the contemporaneous dataset, the highest value was detected for the slope number 5 with
the value of 75%, followed by the number 1 and 7 with the value of 45% and 44%, respectively. The
highest value of the dataset of 1956 (45%) has been identified in slope number 1. That slope shows
the same value for both periods since the area has not been subjected to any changes. On the contrary,
the remaining areas show a substantially lower value: the zones number 5 and 7 equal to 0%, the
number 6 equal to 1%, the number 4 equal to 5%, the numbers 9, 3 and 2 equal to 15%, 18% and
22% respectively.
Figure 3: Expeditious Index of Vulnerability for dataset of 1956 and 2017, respectively
147
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
The current paper was intended to develop an easy and quick methodology to detect and investigate
the vulnerable areas subjected to a debris flow caused on terraced landscapes slope. Indeed, in the
last few years, the abandonment of terraces is becoming a problem more and more evident due to
their scarce competitiveness. This phenomenon, in conjunction with the lack of knowledge related to
their position and conservation status (Capolupo et al., in review), caused a lack of maintenance of
those areas. Consequently, the possibility of occurrence of debris flows, triggered by rainfall, is more
and more frequent, damaging the underlying areas [Crosta et al., 2003; Del Ventisette et al., 2012].
In addition, those events are more recurring in Amalfi Coast because of difficult meteorological
situation, characterized by the occurrence of catastrophic event, like that one of the 25th of October
1954, when more than 500 mm fell in about four hours. That situation cannot be described using
Gumbel distribution [Rossi and Villani, 1994]. Analysing the status of Amalfi Coast terraces is even
more interesting since they have been included in the UNESCO World Heritage List (year 1997 n.
830). Preserving them is perfectly in line with UNESCO policy, expressed in the “World Cultural
and Natural Heritage” convention of 1972, in which is underlined that all the historical sites to be
protected and brought to the future generations. Therefore, Minori, the most ancient municipality of
Amalfi Coast, has been chosen as the study area of the current research activity.
The experiment was mainly composed by two steps. First of all, the position of terraced landscapes
in the area under investigation have been detected using the combination of aerial photogrammetry
and OBIA approach, as suggested in Capolupo et al., (in review). The generated binary maps show a
high accuracy equal to 93% and 98% for the historical and contemporaneous datasets (Figure 1). The
different result related to the accuracy assessment depends on the different resolution and the lack of
multispectral information for the data of 1956. Both results are satisfying since they are suitable for
describing complexity of territory at detailed scale. Moreover, the approach is really innovative and
it allows to go beyond the limits of the traditional methods. Moreover, that technique can be applied
at detailed scale. Moreover, it is based on an objectively classification approach and not an image
interpretation. Comparing both orthophotos (Figure 1), it is also possible to point out that Minori has
been subjected to an anthropization process: the amount of buildings have increased of about 800%
[Capolupo et al., 2018b; Capolupo et al., 20148c], while the extension of terraces has not changed.
That observation has been also confirmed by the results reported in Figure 2 and Table 1, related to
the length of the slopes and the travel distance of an hypothetical debris flow caused by a small portion
of terraces with a volume of 1000 m3. Those components have the same values both for the historical
and the contemporaneous series. Nevertheless, the EVI, an expeditious indicator of the vulnerability,
shows different values for the two investigated periods because of the anthropization process of the
municipality of Minori (Figure 3). Figure 3 underlines that the vulnerability of each area has been
subjected to an enormous rise.
The methodology introduced in the present paper looks promising because it allows to quickly
identify the priority areas to be investigated more in depth through the simulations of debris flow.
Indeed, the amount of buildings underlying the terraces is just one of the indicator to be considered
to define the most vulnerable areas, since, first of all, the travel distance of debris flow and the length
of the slopes of the mountains have to be investigated. Therefore, the EVI indicator looks an important
tool for the landscape planners.
Acknowledgement
It was financially supported by UniNA and Compagnia di San Paolo, in the frame of Programme
STAR, and by I.Z.S.Me/C.I.R.AM “Campania trasparente”.
148
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
References
1. Tarolli P., Preti F. and Romano N. (2014) “Terraced landscapes: From an old best practice to a
potential hazard for soil degradation due to land abandonment”. Anthropocene, 6, 10-25.
2. Capolupo A., Kooistra L. and Boccia L. (in review) “A novel approach for detecting agricultural
terraced landscapes from historical and contemporaneous photogrammetric aerial photos” .
International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation.
3. Gullino P., Beccaro G. L. and Larcher F. (2015) “Assessing and monitoring the sustainability in
rural world heritage sites”. Sustainability, 7(10), 14186-14210.
4. Fuchs S., Heiss K. and Hübl J. (2007) “Towards an empirical vulnerability function for use in
debris flow risk assessment”. Natural Hazards and Earth System Science, 7(5), 495-506.
5. United Nations: International Strategy for Disaster Reduction. (2004). Living with risk: a global
review of disaster reduction initiatives (Vol. 1). United Nations Publications.
6. Birkmann J. (2006) “Measuring vulnerability to natural hazards: towards disaster resilient
societies” (No. Sirsi) (i9789280811353).
7. Wilson K., Pressey R. L., Newton A., Burgman M., Possingham H. and Weston C. (2005)
“Measuring and incorporating vulnerability into conservation planning”. Environmental
management, 35(5), 527-543.
8. Capolupo A., Pindozzi S., Okello C., Fiorentino N., and Boccia L. (2015a) ″Photogrammetry for
environmental monitoring: The use of drones and hydrological models for detection of soil
contaminated by copper″. Science of the Total Environment, 514, 298-306.
9. Capolupo A., Kooistra L., Berendonk C., Boccia L., and Suomalainen J. (2015b) ″Estimating
plant traits of grasslands from UAV-acquired hyperspectral images: A comparison of statistical
approaches″. ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, 4(4), 2792-2820.
10. Capolupo A., Nasta P., Palladino M., Cervelli E., Boccia L. and Romano N (2018a) “Assessing
the ability of hybrid poplar for in-situ phytoextraction of cadmium by using UAV –
photogrammetry and 3D flow simulator”. International Journal of Remote Sensing (TRES).
DOI: 10.1080/01431161.2017.1422876.
11. Caneva G., Cancellieri L., Zivkovic L., Grilli R., Lombardozzi V. and Salerno G. (2007) “Il
paesaggio naturale ed il paesaggio culturale”.
12. Pindozzi S., Cervelli E., Capolupo A., Okello C. and Boccia L. (2016) “Using historical maps to
analyze two hundred years of land cover changes: case study of Sorrento peninsula (south
Italy)”. Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 43(3), 250-265.
13. Rossi F., and Villani P. (1994) “A project for regional analysis of floods in Italy”. In Coping
with floods (pp. 193-217). Springer, Dordrecht.
14. Nex F. and Remondino F. (2014) “UAV for 3D mapping applications: a review”. Applied
Geomatics, 6(1), 1-15. doi 10.1007/S12518-013-0120-x.
15. Höhle, J. and Höhle, M. (2009) “Accuracy assessment of digital elevation models by means of
robust statistical methods”. ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 64(4),
398-406. DOI: 10.1016/j.isprsjprs.2009.02.003
16. Capolupo A., Pindozzi S., Okello C. and Boccia L. (2014) ″Indirect field technology for detecting
areas object of illegal spills harmful to human health: application of drones, photogrammetry and
hydrological models″. Geospatial Health, 8(3), 699-707.
17. Capolupo A., Cervelli E., Pindozzi S. and Boccia L. (2017) “Assessing volumetric and
geomorphologic changes of terraces in Amalfi Coast using photogrammetric technique”. In:
Biosystems Engineering addressing the human challenges of the 21st century.
149
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
Bari:Università degli Studi di Bari Aldo Moro, ISBN: 978-88-6629-020-9, Bari - Italy, July 5-8,
2017
18. Infascelli R., Faugno S., Pindozzi S., Boccia L. and Merot. P. (2013) “Testing different
topographic indexes to predict wetlands distribution”. Procedia Environmental Sciences. 19,
733-746. Journel AG, Huijbregts CJ. Mining Geostatistics. Academic Press, New York, NY.
1978; pp 600.
19. Benz U.C., Hofmann P., Willhauck G., Lingenfelder I., Heynen M. (2004) “Multiresolution,
object-oriented fuzzy analysis of remote sensing data for GIS-ready information”. ISPRS J.
Photogr. Remote Sens. 58, 239e258.
20. Crosta G. B., Dal Negro P. and Frattini P. (2003) “Soil slips and debris flows on terraced
slopes”. Natural Hazards and Earth System Science, 3(1/2), 31-42.
21. Del Ventisette C., Garfagnoli F., Ciampalini A., Battistini A., Gigli G., Moretti S. and Casagli N.
(2012) “An integrated approach to the study of catastrophic debris-flows: geological hazard and
human influence”. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 12(9), 2907.
22. Rickenmann D. (1999) “Empirical relationships for debris flows”. Natural hazards, 19(1), 4777.
23. Capolupo A., Kooistra L., and Boccia L. (2018b) “Geomorphological change detection and
historical evolution analysis of terraced landscapes, an old irreversible agricultural practice: the
case study of Minori, in Campania Region”. Geophysical Research Abstracts, In Vol. 20,
EGU2018-18700, 2018, EGU General Assembly 2018. Vienna – Austria, 8-13 April, 2018.
24. Capolupo A., Rigillo M. and Boccia L. (2018c) “Photogrammetric technique for analysing the
anthropization process in coastal areas: the case study of Minori”. Conference on Il Monitoraggio
Costiero Mediterraneo: problematiche e tecniche di misura (Edition VII), Livorno - Italy,
June 19-21, 2018.
150
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION OF THERMAL EFFECT
IN STREET CANYONS
M.K. Stefanidou, E.S. Bekri, P.C. Yannopoulos*
Environmental Engineering Laboratory, Department of Civil Engineering,University of Patras, 265
04 Patras, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: yannopp@upatras.gr, tel : +302610996527
Abstract
Modern cities suffer from degraded air quality caused among others by the nature and the
characteristics of the urban infrastructure and the contemporary building types and construction
styles. Street canyons, created by continuous building alongside narrow or medium width streets, are
quite common in many cities. They have a negative effect on urban air quality and thermal comfort
conditions of city inhabitants. The aim of the present work is to simulate and predict flow fields at
street canyons, as well as to assess the resultant heat fluxes. It analyses the aforementioned
phenomenon under four scenarios changing the sources of heat fluxes. For this purpose a
computational fluid dynamic model is used. Based on the results, the most adverse effect is found at
about the middle of the building height, when considering as source of heat flux the building face,
where the maximum temperature near the building is found. The temperature at the intermediate
places of the city canyon remains, as expected, at lower levels than the temperature close to the heat
sources. It is of note that the warm air near the building faces will deteriorate the comfortable interior
room climatic conditions.
Keywords: street canyons, thermal effect, CFD, heat fluxes, room comfort
1.
INTRODUCTION
Air quality in urban areas is an important issue for the citizens’ health (Schwela, 2000). Many factors
affect urban air quality such as the shape and the size of the buildings, as well as the orientation and
the width of the main and secondary road network. In most modern cities, the structure of the
buildings has been developed into various patterns of urban grids which resulted to the formulation
of the so-called street canyons. Urban street canyon is a principal structure that characterizes the form
of a whole city. It is built by continuous buildings on both sides of a narrow street (Zakaria et al,
2015).
In recent years, the impact of street canyons on the quality of residents’ life, including their effect,
firstly, on the energy potential accumulated in the city, secondly, on the energy performance of
buildings and, thirdly, on the diffusion of air pollutants, has gained an increased scientific interest.
Several studies have focused on the environmental effect to the building urban areas (De Lieto
Vollaro et al, 2013; Memon et al, 2009) and more precisely to the indirect effect on the energy
efficiency due to urban thermal field variations (De Lieto Vollaro et al, 2015a, b). The variation of
the urban fabric caused by the rapid urbanization of cities leads to the flow and thermal field with a
direct effect on the city environment.
Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) may be used to analyze the thermal flow field condition around
the buildings in order to investigate the temperature effects inside and above urban canyons (Li et al,
2012; Battista and Mauri, 2016), considering an idealized two-dimensional model.
151
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
To the best of our knowledge, there have been few studies that investigate the flow temperature field
of street canyons due to the thermal effects in calm conditions.
Τhe present work studies numerically the heat transfer by buoyancy within and above a street canyon,
which is caused by the solar heating of road and building surfaces in a calm atmosphere.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Model description
In order to conduct the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation, the ANSYS® Fluent 19
software has been used, based on a two-dimensional model, as shown in the schematic representation
in Figure 1. The geometry of the model was prepared using the software ANSYS® Design Modeler.
More specifically, the street canyon is simulated as a 0.4 m wide slot, having 1 m high side walls,
which was placed 0.20 m above the road in order to allow air inlet. In this way, the air entered by the
cross roads is simulated in the present two-dimensional model. The simulated canyon is placed in a
wider test computational space of total dimensions of 6 m wide and 4.60 m high. The test space has
two inlets of 0.20 m at the side walls near the bottom to allow the entrance of 20oC ambient air and
other two outlets near the top of side walls to allow exit of the air. The temperature of the ambient air
was set to 20oC. The duration of the numerical experiment was approximately two minutes so that to
prevent air recirculation and stratification. In this sense the phenomenon may be considered quasi
steady-state.
Figure 1: Configuration of the 2D flow field due to heat fluxes coming from road and building
walls within and above a street canyon, simulated in an ample computational domain.
Our study analyses the aforementioned phenomenon of a street canyon under four scenarios
concerning the sources of heat fluxes: Scenario I- road heat flux; Scenario II- building walls heat
fluxes; Scenario III- road and left building wall heat fluxes; and Scenario IV- road and building walls
heat fluxes.
152
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.2 Model set-up
The model domain was discretized using rectangular cells. For greater accuracy, the mesh has been
refined in the focused area that includes the road and the walls of the buildings up to the top of the
computational domain.
The software was set-up by using 2D double precision, to reduce the error of numerical calculation,
pressure-based version and the unsteady Reynolds-Averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) equations have
been solved in combination with the standard k-ε turbulence model.
The governing equations of the phenomenon are RANS equations with a Boussinesq assumption for
buoyancy effects:
Continuity equation
w u
0
y x
(1)
y-momentum equation
2w 2w
p
w w 2 w 2
wu wu
gaT T0
2 2
t
y
x
0 y
x
y
(2)
x- momentum equation
2u 2u
p
u wu wu u 2 u 2
2 2
t
y
x
0 x
x
y
(3)
Energy equation
2T 2T
T wT wT uT u T
J
2 2
t
y
x
x 0 C p
y
(4)
where w is the axial mean velocity component, u is the transverse mean velocity component, w' and
u' are their corresponding fluctuations due to turbulence, g is the gravity acceleration, p is the
pressure, 0 a 0 T T0 is the local density of air, ρ0 and T0 are the reference density and
temperature, a is the thermal expansion coefficient, κ is the thermal diffusivity of air, Cp is the isobaric
heat capacity, J is the rate per unit volume heat production, w'2, w'T', u'T' are the local mean axial
velocity and tracer fluxes due to turbulence fluctuations of w, u and T.
The following boundary conditions were assigned: No-slip velocity on the road surface, building
walls and on the bottom and side boundaries of the domain, while symmetry conditions are assigned
on the top boundary. The temperature of air entered the computational domain was set to 20oC. A
300 W/m2 heat flux is considered to come out from the road during the midday hours for Scenarios
I, III and IV, in combination with a 100 W/m2 heat flux coming out from the left building wall for
Scenario III and from both side walls of the canyon for Scenario IV. No heat flux is considered to
come out from the canyon side walls for Scenario I, from the road for Scenario II or from the right
building wall for Scenario III. Initially, zero velocity value was assigned at the entire computational
domain.
153
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSION
3.1 Axial velocity and temperature on the canyon centreline
The axial velocity and temperatures of the simulated canyon calculated on its centreline are shown in
Figure 2 for the four simulated scenarios. Paying attention on the Figure 2(a), it is observed that the
velocities inside the city canyon are linearly increased with the height from the road surface until y =
0.3h taking values from 0 to 0.20 m/s for Scenarios I, III and IV, while Scenario II has given
somewhat greater values (0 to 0.26 m/s). This increase is a result of the accelerating air masses due
to the thermal buoyant forces. In the centreline region from y = 0.3h and up to the top of the buildings
(y = 1.2h) the axial velocities are decreased up to values in the range (0.12 – 0.15 m/s) mainly due to
the friction effects of the building walls. In the free space above the city canyon, due to thermal
buoyancy, the centreline axial velocities are increased up to a value of 0.3 m/s for Scenario I and up
to 0.44 m/s for Scenario II, while for Scenarios III and IV the values reach 0.4 m/s.
The heat sources of Scenario III are non symmetrical; thus, the centreline axial velocities vary in the
range (0.3 – 0.4 m/s) in the region above the height y = 2h and up to y = 4h, while Scenarios I and IV
give approximately constant axial velocities in this region. This behaviour is characteristic in twodimensional plume flows (Yannopoulos, 2006). In further heights the centreline axial velocities are
decreasing as the flow is approaching to the ceiling of the computational space.
Figure 2: Variation with height of: (a) axial velocities; and (b) temperatures, for Scenarios I,
II, III and IV simulated.
154
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The variation of the air temperature along the city canyon centreline is shown in Figure 2(b). The
temperature starts from 24 – 26°C at the road heat source (Scenarios I, III and IV) and from 20°C
(ambient air temperature), when the heat source is only at the side walls. For Scenarios I, III and IV,
the temperature is decreasing with about the same rate and reach the value of 22°C at the height region
from y = 0.4h up to y = 0.8h, while for Scenario II the temperature is increasing due to the wall thermal
influence. This is also evident if paying attention on the temperature variation in further heights for
Scenarios III and IV, which show a temperature increase from y ≈ 0.4h up to y = 2h, due to wall
thermal plumes, while there is a gradual decrease for Scenario I, which has only a road heat source.
In the height y ≈ 2h the temperature takes a maximum value of 23°C, 22.5°C and 21.8°C for Scenarios
IV, III and II, correspondingly. Above this height there is a gradual decrease of temperature for
Scenarios I, II and IV of symmetrical heat sources.
3.2 Transverse profiles of axial velocity and temperature
The transverse profiles of axial velocity at several heights above the road of the city canyon are shown
in Figure 3 for the four scenarios simulated. The velocity profiles are shown in Figures 3(a), (b) and
(d) for Scenarios I, II and IV of symmetrical heat sources, correspondingly. Therefore, the velocity
profiles are symmetrical as expected, while the profiles of Scenario III, which has non symmetrical
heat sources, are non symmetrical as well. The maximum value of axial velocity near the building is
found at about the half building height (y ≈ 0.7h) for Scenarios II, III and IV and is varied in the range
Figure 3: Transverse profiles at several heights of axial velocities for the simulated: (a)
Scenario I; (b) Scenario II; (c) Scenario III; and (d) Scenario IV.
155
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
(0.17 – 0.2 m/s). The maximum axial velocity calculated is 0.44 m/s which is in the range of velocities
measured in a calm atmosphere.
The transverse profiles of temperature at several heights above the road of the city canyon are shown
in Figure 4 for the four scenarios simulated. The temperature profiles are shown in Figures 4(a), (b)
and (d) for Scenarios I, II and IV of symmetrical heat sources, correspondingly. Therefore, the
temperature profiles are symmetrical as expected, while the profiles of Scenario III, which has non
symmetrical heat sources, are non symmetrical as well. The maximum value of temperature near the
building is found at about the half building height (y ≈ 0.7h) for Scenarios II, III and IV and is varied
in the range (27 – 28°C or a bit higher). As expected, the temperature at the intermediate places of
the city canyon is kept at lower levels than the temperature near the heat sources. It is interesting to
note that the warm air near the building faces will deteriorate the comfortable interior room climatic
conditions. The most adverse effect is found at about the middle of the building height for Scenarios
II, III and IV, which assume that the building face is a source of heat flux.
Figure 4: Transverse profiles at several heights of temperatures for the simulated: (a)
Scenario I; (b) Scenario II; (c) Scenario III; and (d) Scenario IV.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
For the four scenarios examined numerically regarding the thermal effects in a city street canyon due
to heat fluxes originated from either the road (300 W/m2) or/and the side building faces (100 W/m2),
the following conclusions are drawn:
156
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The axial velocities increase linearly initially up to about 0.3h taking values from 0 to 0.26
m/s and then decrease to 0.12 – 0.15 m/s up to the top of the buildings. The axial velocities
near the faces of the buildings take values up to 0.20 m/s.
The temperature at the street canyon centerline is about 24 – 26°C near the heat flux sources
and initially starts decreasing linearly up to about 0.3h taking values around 22°C and then is
kept nearly constant up to the top of the buildings. Near the faces of the buildings, when heat
sources are considered, the temperature reaches 28°C or may be higher in the lower half of
the building height that may affect adversely the comfort of room climatic conditions.
Over the buildings height, the air velocities are increasing up to a maximum value of 0.44 m/s, which
characterizes a calm atmosphere. The temperature remains also at a level of 21 – 23°C.
References
1. Battista G. and L. Mauri (2016) ‘Numerical study of buoyant flows in street canyon caused by
ground and building heating’, 71st Conference of the Italian thermal Machines Engineering
Association, AT12016, 14-16 September, Turin.
2. De Lieto Vollaro A., Galli G. and A. Vallati (2015a) ‘CFD Analysis of Convective Heat Transfer
Coefficient on External Surfaces of Buildings’, Sustainability, Vol. 7, pp. 9088-9099.
3. De Lieto Vollaro A., Galli G., Vallati A. and R. Romagnoli (2015b) ‘Analysis of thermal field
within an urban canyon with variable thermophysical characteristics of the building's walls’,
Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 655, 012056.
4. De Lieto Vollaro R., Vallati A. and S. Bottillo (2013) ‘Differents Methods to Estimate the Mean
Radiant Temperature in an Urban Canyon’, Advanced Materials Research, 650, pp. 647-651.
5. Li L., Yang L., Zhanh L.J. and Y. Jiang (2012) ‘Numerical Study on the Impact of Ground Heating
and Ambient Wind Speed on Flow Fields in Street Canyons’, Advances in Atmospheric
Sciences, 29(6), pp 1227-1237.
6. Memon R.A., Leung D.Y.C. and C. Liu (2009) ‘An investigation of urban heat island intensity
(UHII) as an indicator of urban heating’, Atmospheric Research, Vol. 94 pp. 491–500.
7. Schwela D. (2000) ‘Air Pollution and Health in Urban Areas’, Reviews on Environmental
Health, Volume 15, Issue 1-2, pp. 13–42.
8. Yannopoulos P. (2006) ‘An improved integral model for plane and round turbulent buoyant jets’,
J. Fluid Mech, Vol. 547, pp. 267-296.
9. Zakaria M., Abu Bakar M., Ridhwan J., Mohd and M. Hanafi (2014) ‘CFD analysis of flow,
pollutant dispersion and thermal effect in street canyons’, Journal of Engineering and
Technology, Vol.5 No.1, pp. 99-120.
157
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
IMPACT OF THE TUMULUS ON THE STABILITY OF
MICROCLIMATE IN UNDERGROUND HERITAGE
STRUCTURES
V.Th. Kyriakou* and V.P. Panoskaltsis
Department of Civil Engineering, Demokritos University of Thrace, University Campus XanthiKimmeria, Xanthi, 67100, GREECE
*
Corresponding author, e-mail: vanta.kiriakou@gmail.com, tel: +30 6945380388
Abstract
After having scientific documentation of the variations of temperature and relative humidity inside
three Macedonian tombs excavated in the area of Pella and Agios Athanasios, comparative analysis
of the data was conducted. The analysis of the hydrothermal behavior of these underground chambers
showed that the tumulus protected the tombs and their treasures against the deterioration processes.
The tumuli over tombs in north Greece named “Macedonian tombs” were constructed in ancient times
as “far seen signs” of important persons’ burials. Structurally, the tumulus is a big mass of artificial
earth, covering monumental tombs which are dated between the 4th and 2nd century B.C. Its
construction is the artificial packing of different layers of earth, with different consistency. These
layers created a perfect drainage system. This way, the rain water was directed to the periphery of the
cone-shaped tumulus and not inside the tombs. Because of the thermal inertia of the surrounding soil,
fluctuations of temperature were of less width inside the tombs than outside. The tombs were
preserved under stable microclimatic conditions in a very good state.
This study shows that the tumulus is a very important technical achievement for its era, not only due
to its great mass -sometimes 12 m. high, but due to its construction and the impact to the protection
of the underneath tombs, which are significant heritage structures. Other factors that affected the
microclimate stability inside the tombs were the volume of the interior space, the rate of exposure to
the external climate and the protection measures after the excavation. Estimations according to the
analysis are presented in this paper.
Keywords: Microclimate, Hydrothermal performance, Heritage structures, Macedonian tombs,
Tumulus
1.
INTRODUCTION
An important feature of the Macedonian tombs is their artificial sedimentation with soil, in the shape
of a conical tomb, the reason for its creation may have been local religious beliefs and burial customs.
[Gossel, 1980] The result was that these monumental graves remained completely unseen, destined
exclusively to the dead and the goddesses, according to the metaphysical beliefs of the ancient
Macedonians.
Although up to now more than 100 tombs have been excavated throughout Macedonia, archaeological
interest has been traced to the importance of the Macedonian tombs revealed and no systematic
research has been done on the tumulus itself, the way it was constructed and the significance of
existence and preserving it.
158
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
References are only made to archaeological announcements, but they are always fragmentary and
short. Manolis Andronikos, the archaeologist who supervised the excavation of the royal tombs of
Vergina, wrote that the tumulus is a "monument of a significant burial", meaning that the artificial
embankment is a "monument" itself. At the same time, he noticed that it is not a simple build-up of
soil but has a specific structure.
P. Harisis wrote in 1978 his first technical essay, titled "Rules for the Construction of Burial Tumuli",
where he tried to analyze the tumulus as a geometric solid and to explain its static structure [Harisis,
1978].
During the last decade, archaeologists who excavated Macedonian tombs have made simple
references to the construction of the tumuli. There have been designed depictions of the stratigraphic
sections, but no further research has been done on the structure and the reason for the existence of the
tumulus. It is still treated as a mass of soil, which should be removed during the excavation in order
to reveal the hidden treasure.
The present work is a first attempt to decode this huge technical work, not only in terms of its
construction, but mainly in terms of its operation in relation to the tombs underneath. The 3-year
study of Macedonian tombs in the area of Pella and Agios Athanasios, with continuous measurements
of the microclimatic conditions in these monuments, revealed the direct correlation of the volume of
the tumulus with the hydrothermal conditions in the tombs and the subsequent damage to their
building materials.
2.
THE TUMULUS
2.1 Origin - Geographical location
The practice of building mounds as burial marks has a long-standing presence in the area of the
Balkan Peninsula. Tombs clusters have been identified in ancient Thrace as well as in ancient Illyria.
In Greece, the most representative example is the necropolis in Vergina, with tombs dating back to
1000-700 B.C. until the 2nd century B.C. Some interaction between the three areas must be
considered certain and expected. It is very difficult to determine when, under what conditions and
from which geographic area it began and how the practice of mound building was adopted by
Macedonia [Gurova, 1999]. Apart from the Balkan region, similar burial monuments have been
studied all over the world, concerning their hydrothermal performance. In the international literature,
we can find references to the Etruscan tombs in Tarquinia - Italy, the massive burial tombs in Turkey,
the graves of Japan emperors, the tombs in Valley of the Kings - Egypt.
2.2 Reasons for constructing the tumulus in the ancient era
According to Homer, the tumulus is a "far seen sign" (the sign that appears from a distance) and
according to Manolis Andronikos it is the "tombstone" of a significant burial. It is not yet confirmed
whether tombstones were placed at the top of the tumulus, although it was enough to mark the site of
burial. Apart from the operation of the sign, there were definitely and practical reasons that led to the
construction of the artificial tumulus. These reasons are:
1. to protect the grave and valuable burial offerings from the tomb thieves, and
2. to protect the structural materials of the tomb from deterioration due to environmental conditions.
Therefore, with the construction of the tumulus, the ancient technicians aimed to protect the burial of
desecration and the tomb from deterioration.
2.3 The tumulus as a technical project
The tumulus must be considered as a technical achievement for that era, taking into account the huge
quantities of soil that had to be transported and spread, with the use of transport means, lifting
machines and the laborious work of hundreds of people. Ancient builders knew very well the
characteristics of the soil and its layering. Observations on how the tumulus was built, lead to the
159
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
conclusion that it is not just a random build-up of soil but it is a properly designed work with structural
consistency to withstand time and stratification to ensure water runoff to its periphery so as little as
possible water retention and minimal inflow to the grave. (Fig.1)
This is accomplished by alternating successive layers of chopped and coarse material. The condensed
fine-grained layer has a low degree of water permeability; therefore it does not allow rain water to
penetrate deep so that it concentrates on its upper surface. The layer of coarse material allows the free
flow of water, which before it would penetrate into the lower layers, flows, due to the slope, to the
perimeter of the tumulus, away from the tomb [Harisis, 1978]. In addition, the volume of accumulated
soil with its high heat capacity ensures temperature stability and relative humidity inside the
monument, since it isolates it from the climate conditions.
Figure 1: Representation of the water fluxes due to the different construction layers of the
tumulus [Harisis, P., 1978. Computer coloring by authors]
2.4 Discussion about how the tumulus was constructed
The excavation process which has been applied and continues to be the accepted method of
exploration in the tombs of the Macedonian tombs, led to the complete demolition of the tumulus,
often without being previously designed. Until now, as far as is known from the literature, detailed
research on the layering of the tumulus has not been mentioned. Technically, the way that the tumulus
was built remains unknown. No evidence has been found of the methods of construction. Evidently,
certain tools and machines were used for the elevation of the soil, the layering, the condensation of
the layers, the achievement of the geometry of the conical shape as a one.
2.4.1 The example of modern constructions
The technology of our times is far from that of our ancient ancestors. But there are some elements in
practical methodology that are so basic, that they may not have changed much since antiquity. If we
observe the construction of circular buildings today, beyond the image of modern materials and
machinery, we can see that it is based on reference to the center of the base circle and the vertical
axon. (Fig.2a) A crane machine is placed at the center point and the construction is raised
parametrically, from the bottom to the top. The rationale is very simple and leads to the question: was
the tumulus built in a similar way?
160
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figures 2-3: Circular modern buildings [Photo by authors] - Traditional circular clay
buildings [Pearlmutter, D., 1992]
2.4.2 The example of traditional circular clay buildings
Corresponding building styles can be found in traditional architecture, with dome construction. A
central vertical guide serves as a reference (Fig.2b) while its horizontal stem ensures proper layering
[Pearlmutter, 1992].
2.4.3 An example from the excavation of a Phrygian tumulus
The only example of a detailed excavation of a tumulus has been reported in the case of the Tomb in
Gordion, Phrygia, where the excavation reveals the existence of a wooden vertical guide in the center
of the tumulus [Young, 1981].
2.5 Hydrothermal behavior and water-proofing
An underground construction is influenced by seasonal cycles but not by daily ones. The hydrothermal evolution within this interior is related to the following factors:
1. The thermal energy transferred through the soil to the building elements (floor, walls, roof) and
then through the building elements to the air of the interior. This thermal energy is associated with
daytime and seasonal cycles.
2. Water exchanges at all concentration stages, in a similar way between soil and indoor air. These
latter, moreover, are in close connection with the exchanges of thermal energy [Massari, 1993]. In
literature, there are reports of methods of waterproofing tombs, not only to the ancient Macedonians.
Characteristic is the case of the Tomb in Gordion, Phrygia, where a layer of clay carefully compressed
and polished over the wooden grave was able to keep its shape even after the tomb roof collapsed
[Young, 1981] The use of this material is attributed to the intention of waterproofing the tomb, but
also to the static reinforcement of the roof (Fig.3).
Figure 4: Exchanges of air and humidity between interior and the surroundings. [Authors]
161
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
Observations on the layering of the tumuli in various Macedonian tombs are presented. The
construction with alternating layers is evident in the vertical slopes of the excavated tumuli. In the
tomb of Agios Athanasios, there was observed the existence of a layer of solid clay just above the
arc-like roof of the tomb. The same layer of clay was also found above the roof-arch in the tomb of
Langada. (Fig.4)
Figures 5 - 6: Macedonian tombs in Agios Athanasios and Langada
3.
THE RESEARCH
3.1 Location and climate conditions
The monuments studied are located geographically at the plain of Thessaloniki, NW from the present
bay of Thermaikos gulf. The local climatic conditions present the characteristics of the Mediterranean
climate. The air temperature during the year shows a simple fluctuation, with a maximum in July and
a minimum in January. Rains usually fall late in autumn and spring. Thus, in the winter and spring
months there is excess water and high humidity, while in the summer there happens a very intense
evaporation.
3.2 Tombs of Pella
Sixteen burial tombs are located in the area of Pella. [Chrysostomou, 1987, 1994] Two of them were
the subject of this research.
A. The tumulus D’, at the eastern cemetery of Pella has a diameter of 60m and a height of 9 m. A
two-chamber burial structure with a Doric facade was found at the south part of the tumulus, at a
depth of 4.30 counting from the top. The tomb dates back to the end of the 4th century B.C.
B. The tumulus C’ of the cemetery of Pella, located south of the road of Thessaloniki - Giannitsa, 3.3
km away from it. Tomb dimensions: 5m height and a diameter of 35m. A two-chamber burial building
with Ionic facade and “road” (dromos) was found, under the 5m tumulus. The orientation of the facade
is towards the east. The tomb dates back to the beginning of the 3rd century B.C.
3.3 Tombs of Agios Athanasios, Thessaloniki
The cemetery at Agios Athanasios is related to the settlement in the neighboring tumulus Topsin, on
the east bank of Axios river, where there are indications of habitation from the Neolithic to the late
Hellenistic period, which likelihood can be identified with the ancient city Halastra. The big tumulus
is 100m in diameter and 18m height [Tsimbidou, 1993, 1994]. After an excavation survey in the
tumulus, two important tombs were found:
a monumental box-shaped tomb, having internal dimensions of 2.00 x 1.45m and a height of about
1.50 m. It dates back to the late 4th or early 3rd century B.C.
162
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
a Macedonian tomb with a painted facade. It is dated in the 4th century B.C. It is characterized
by frescoes on the façade, an important example of painting in Macedonia.
Figures 7 - 8 : Horizontal and vertical cross-sections of three tumuli [Authors] - Comparative
sections of four tumuli [Authors]
3.4 Recording the microclimate in the tombs
The precise hydrothermal state of the structure had to be studied after recording of the surface
temperatures on the interior walls in contact with the soil, the façade wall exposed to the external
climate, as well as in the air of the interior space. In particular, changes in the thermal status of the
monuments were recorded on a daily and annual basis, with reference to the horizontal direction
(façade-antechamber-chamber) and the vertical direction (floor - middle level - arch). Recordings
were made in two ways (Fig.6) :
1. Instantaneous recordings once a month, all over the inner surface of the monuments and on the
facade, with a simple temperature display.
2. Continuous electronic recording with sensor placement at specific points of the walls, with an
hourly step.
Figures 9 – 10 - 11: Electronic data were obtained inside the tomb D and on the surface of the
tumulus [Source: Authors]
4.
DIAGRAMS – OBSERVATIONS
Observations on the recordings in the four monuments over three years, led to stating the following:
1. All tombs present reduced range of temperature and relative humidity in their interior space and
phase delay in relation to external environmental conditions, due to the increased heat capacity of
their construction materials and the embankment of the tumulus.
163
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
2. The most stable state of the microclimate prevails in the Doric tomb of Pella. Compared to the rest
of the tombs, it is the largest in size and is covered by the second in size tumulus. The revelation of
his structural body has only been made at the level of the facade.
3. The second tentacle of stability is the Ionic tomb of Pella. It is the second in dimensions and is
covered by the smallest tumulus. The revelation of his structural body has only been made at the level
of the face.
4. The third is the Macedonian tomb of Agios Athanasios. It is the third largest in size and is covered
by the largest tumulus. A large part of the building structure was exposed to the environment, since,
due to the poor static view of the arched state, a large part of the tumulus was disembarked over it.
Thus, in addition to the facade, most of the roof remained unprotected. To protect it was made a
wooden enclosure with sheets and nylon, which later was strengthened with double entry and stylized,
with obvious results in the reduction of the range of fluctuations.
5. The box-shaped tomb has the smallest size and is covered by the largest tumulus. It shows the
greatest instability of environmental conditions. The revelation of his structural body has been made
only at the level of the facade.
Figures 12 - 13: Diagrams of temperature and relative humidity. Relationship between the
three tombs and the environment [Authors]
5.
CALCULATIONS
Calculations have been done with the use of the software WUFI pro, on moisture transfer and
moisture content in the building elements. Equations - The Calculation Model
5.1 Moisture Transfer
In porous building materials the predominant moisture transport mechanisms are vapor
diffusion, surface diffusion and capillary conduction. Other transport phenomena, for example
seepage flow through gravitation in non-saturated pore spaces or migration of water molecules due
to electric fields or osmotic pressures, cannot yet be computed in a satisfactory way. However, since
they only play a major part in exceptional cases, they are not further considered here. Convection
effects, for example moist interior air permeating building components because of pressure
differentials between the interior and the exterior side, are ignored as well. Since airtightness is an
essential property of a building wall, air convection is in practice only found in unplanned cases of
defective parts or inappropriate building components. It is therefore difficult to quantify beforehand
and could also only be realistically determined by three-dimensional fluid dynamical simulation
programs. The driving force for surface diffusion is therefore relative humidity and not vapor
pressure. Thus under the boundary conditions, vapor diffusion and surface diffusion go in opposite
directions. Surface diffusion must therefore be regarded as a type of liquid transport, not a type of
vapor transport in the gas phase.
164
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
5.2 Hygrothermal Material Properties
In general, the following material properties are necessary for the non-steady computation of the
temperature fields:
bulk density ρ of the dry material, specific heat capacity c, thermal conductivity λ
The hygric properties that need to be known for all (i.e. also for non-hygroscopic) materials are:
Water vapor diffusion resistance factor µ (µ-value)
Porosity ε (as a measure of the maximum possible water content wmax)
If the behavior of hygroscopic, capillary active materials is to be simulated correctly, the moisture
storage function and the moisture-dependent liquid transport coefficients are also needed.
5.3 Climate Conditions and Surface Transfer
Through its surfaces, every building component is undergoing hygrothermal interaction with its
surroundings. The surroundings are affecting the component and the component is affecting its
surroundings, for example by releasing stored heat or by sorption of indoor air humidity. Basically,
three types of boundary conditions must be distinguished: the exterior ambient conditions above and
below the ground and the indoor conditions. In all three cases, different surface transfer conditions
have to be employed, due to the different exchange processes involving convection and radiation or
conduction and diffusion.
5.4 Hygrothermal conditions below ground
Below ground, the variations of the exterior air temperature only propagate strongly damped. A study
show that at a depth of 1m below the surface the damping eliminates all daily variations. Furthermore,
there is a phase shift of several weeks with respect to the air temperature which is most noticeable in
spring and in autumn. The humidity in the ground usually lies between 99% and 100% RH if
vegetation is present, since plants cannot extract moisture from the ground at lower humidities. This
also applies to substrate layers in planted roofs, although at different temperature levels.
5.5 Equations - The Calculation Model
A number of hygrothermal simulation models which provide reliable results has been developed in
different countries. The following description discusses the model which forms the basis for the PC
program WUFI (Wärme- Und Feuchtetransport Instationär) [Künzel, 1994]. In this model the nonsteady heat and moisture transport processes in building components are described by the following
coupled differential equations:
Heat transport
Moisture transport
DW [m²/s] : Liquid transport coefficient
H[J/m³] :
Enthalpy of moist building material
hv [J/kg] :
Evaporation enthalpy of water
p [Pa] :
Water vapor partial pressure
u [m³/m³] : Water content
δ [kg/msPa] : Water vapor diffusion coefficient in air
[°C] :
Temperature
λ [W/mK] : Heat conductivity of moist material
165
(1)
(2)
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
μ [-] :
Vapor diffusion resistance factor of dry material
ρw [kg/m³] : Density of water
φ [-] :
Relative humidity
6.
DISCUSSION
6.1 Exposure to the external environment, evaporation, condensation and water content
Periods with open entrance to the tomb, cause great intensity of the phenomenon of evaporation,
especially during the midday and afternoon hours. It is characteristic that the excavation and opening
of the tombs took place between April and June, precisely during the less appropriate period of the
year. For the parts of the structure that have been excavated, the condensation conditions are different.
Thus, condensation may occur on the internal surfaces of the exposed walls or within their mass. This
phenomenon may occur during winter or at night in the summer and if the relative humidity of the
indoor air is high.
Figures 14 - 15: Water content in three different layers of the facade during one year Temperature and dew point inside the stone mass, in one year period [Authors]
Figure 16: Temperature inside the stone mass of the facade during one year, at different
positions of a cross section [Authors]
6.2 The type of the shelter
The construction of a closed shelter aimed to reduce to a greater extent the air exchanges and the
better guarding of the monument, but not a complete protection from the weather changes, due to the
absence of thermal insulation.
166
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
6.3 Human interventions
Generally, the relative humidity increase, happened in the indoor air of the monuments due to human
presence, as well as due to the movement of air layers, resulting in evaporation from interior walls.
Air currents may be caused by a rise in pressure in front of the entrance of the tomb. When it becomes
greater than the pressure inside, it causes air to move out, due to a pressure difference.
6.4 Excavation period
An important outcome seems to be the diagrams showing the total water content in three different
hypothetic excavation periods. The opening of the tomb is supposed to have started in case 1 at the
1st of April, in case 2 at the 1st of September and in case 3 at the 1st of January.
Figure 17: The water content in the tomb’s façade, in relation to the excavation period.
Comparison between April, September and January [Authors]
The comparison between the three situations gives the following results: the building component of
the tomb’s façade, that is mainly exposed after the excavation to the outdoor climatic conditions, is
getting dry immediately. The drying period is one month during April and September, in cases 1 and
2. The drying period is more extended in case 3, when the hypothetic excavation begins in January.
The building component of the tomb’s façade is getting dry after three months. (Fig. 10)
7.
CONCLUSIONS
The tumulus must be subject of great attention and thorough investigation. The disturbance of the
constructional balance of the tumulus as a natural solid shape with internal retaining forces, as well
as the exposure of the slopes of the excavation to the devastating effect of the environment (rains,
winds, solar radiation, wetting-drying procedures), are serious risks for future gradual collapse and
total loss.
The materials of Macedonian tombs easily absorb moisture due to their porous composition and easily
dry by evaporation to the environment. Generally, they are subjected to an annual cycle of wettingdrying. The same cycle is created on a daily basis to the parts of the tomb that remain exposed to
changes in climatic conditions and have a higher intensity over specific periods of time, mainly during
summer and less during winter. Evaporation is especially favored during the summer and only in
167
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
special conditions until late autumn. The phenomenon of condensation mainly takes place in spring,
but it can occur occasionally in winter under special conditions. Generally the greatest intensity of
the phenomena occurs in the exposed parts of the walls. Deterioration of wall paintings occurs mainly
during the evaporation phase. Reconsidering the prevailing practices regarding excavation activity on
tumuli, in connection with the final formation of the microclimate in the tombs, one can draw
conclusions about the human interventions that lead to the deterioration of the monuments.
Simulation of the opening of the tomb in three different hypothetic excavation periods, leads to a
drying period of one month during April and September and three months when the excavation begins
in January. So the most dangerous period is between April and September. Late autumn, and winter
is the best time for excavation activity. In the future, the excavation process should be planned
according to the dehumidification of the building components, in order to protect the important wall
paintings.
References
1. Accardo, G. - Cacace, C. - Rinaldi, R., “La Tomba dei Rilievi in Cervetery: Applicazione della
Metodologia Climatica”
2. Gossel, Β., 1980 “Makedonische Kammergraber”, Doctoral thesis, Berlin
3. Harisis P., 1978 "Rules for the Construction of Tumuli of Burials" publication of the EHS Hepiros Studies Company (in Greek)
4. Gurova, N., 1999 «Kimerios Vosporos. The big Tumuli», Journal Corpus – Archaeology and
History of Cultures, Vol.7, p.48-59
5. Pearlmutter, D., 1992 “The Thermal Performance of Vaulted Roofs in Hot Arid Zones” 3rd
International Conference Energy and Building in Mediterranean Area, p.295-302, April 810, Thessaloniki, Greece
6. Young, S.R., 1981 “Three great early Tumuli”, The Gordion Excavations. Final Reports. Volume
I. The University Museum, Pennsylvania
7. Massari, G., Massari, I., 1993 “Damp Buildings, Old and New”, Rome
8. Chrysostomou, P., 1994 «Excavation research of Macedonian Tombs at Pella during 1994»
Archaeological Works at Macedonia and Thrace, Νο 8, 1994, p.53 (in Greek)
9. Chrysostomou, P., 1987 «New tumuli in the land of Pella» Archaeological Works at Macedonia
and Thrace, n. 1, 1987, σελ.147-157 (in Greek)
10. Tsimbidou, M., 1993 «Burial tumulus at Agios Athanasios in Thessaloniki: Complete of the
research», Archaeological Works at Macedonia and Thrace, n. 7, 1993, σελ.251-259 (in
Greek)
11. Tsimbidou, M., 1994 «Agios Athanasios 1994. The chronicle of a reveal», Archaeological
Works at Macedonia and Thrace, n. 8, 1994, p. 231 (in Greek)
12. Künzel H.M., 1994 Verfahren zur ein- und zweidimensionalen Berechnung des gekoppelten
Wärme- und Feuchtetransports in Bauteilen mit einfachen Kennwerten; Dissertation Universität
Stuttgart
168
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
COMPARING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS OF TWO OFFICE
SEATING UNITS VIA LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT
Merve Mermertas1, Koray Ozsoy2, Thomas P. Gloria3, Fatos Germirli Babuna*1
1
Environmental Engineering Department, Istanbul Technical University, Maslak 34469, Istanbul,
Turkey
2
Koleksiyon Furniture Ltd. , Istanbul, Turkey
3
Division of Continuing Education, Harvard University, Cambridge, United Kingdom
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: germirliba@itu.edu.tr, tel: +9053240903555
Abstract
This study aims to compare the environmental impacts of two office-seating units via life cycle
assessment (LCA) methodology. The system boundary covers raw material extraction and preprocessing, transportation, manufacturing, distribution and usage and end of life stages. Therefore,
the results are obtained on the whole life cycle. The evaluated impact categories are as follows: Global
warming potential (GWP), acidification potential (AP), eutrophication potential (EP) and
photochemical ozone creation potential (smog) (POCP). This study is a pioneering one conducted on
the Turkish furniture industry. For both of the seating units under investigation raw material
extraction and pre-processing stage have the highest share in all impact categories. Considerable
differences in impacts are observed for the two seating units evaluated.
Keywords: environmental impact; life cycle assessment; furniture; office seating; sustainability
1.
INTRODUCTION
Life cycle assessment (LCA) is the most commonly used tool to find out the environmental impacts
of services, products and processes in a holistic point of view. While indicating the environmental
burdens of various products, it grounds a very beneficial platform for comparing the products
designated to fulfil the same function, and/or improving diverse stages of
production/transportation/end of life to achieve sustainability.
Up to now inadequate number of LCA studies are conducted in Turkey by considering the site specific
issues (Atmaca, 2016; Atilgan and Azapagic, 2016; Ozkan et. al., 2017; Gunkaya et. al., 2016;
Demirel and Erkayaoglu, 2016).
The furniture industry is one of the emerging sectors in Turkey. The firms range from large scale that
manufacture by automated mass-production techniques to small workshops. The large ones mainly
produce for exporting the goods to different parts of the world. An accelerating trend in exports is
observed in the last decade reaching to US $ 2,2 billion in 2015 (MoE, 2016).
One can find LCA studies concerning the furniture industry in literature (Iritani et. al., 2015; Cordella
and Hidalgo 2016; Kouchaki-Penchah et. al., 2016; Piekarski et. al., 2017; González-García et. al.,
2012; Mirabella et. al., 2014). However, Turkish furniture industry is not studied through LCA
methodology based on country specific data.
In this context, the objective this study is to compare the environmental impacts of two office-seating
units through LCA approach. A cradle to grave scope covering the whole life cycle is adopted.
Inventory data is collected from a large scale Turkish furniture manufacturer.
169
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The scope of LCA is from cradle to grave. Therefore, the system boundary covers raw material
extraction and pre-processing, transportation, manufacturing, distribution and usage and end of life
stages.
The following assumption is made about the end of life stage: 80 % of the product (by mass) is sent
to a landfill area and the rest is directed to incineration.
The functional unit is one unit of seating to be used by one individual, maintained for a 10 year period
of time.
Global warming potential (GWP), acidification potential (AP), eutrophication potential (EP),
photochemical ozone creation potential (smog) (POCP) and ozone depletion potential (ODP) are the
investigated impact categories.
Data is collected for 12 consecutive months from the actual furniture manufacturing plant. Fabric
manufacturing and the distribution are not take place in Turkey.
The LCA study analysis is realized by following the Product Category Rule (PCR) (BIFMA PCR for
Seating: UNCPC 3811) (NSF, 2018), in accordance with ISO 14040 series standards (ISO, 2006).
GaBi DB Version 6.115 software system is used for modelling. TRACI 2.1 Impact Categories are
adopted.
The energy is allocated by considering the total annual amount of energy consumed in the facility
during manufacturing of the seating units and the total number of seating units produced.
During the packaging of the final product 50 staples are assumed to be used.
The company has no data on the type of trucks used for the transportation of some materials.
Therefore, 18.4 payload capacity trucks are assumed to be used for this type of transportation.
Cargo aircrafts are used for transportation to US and Europe. A road transportation of 32 km’s (by
trucks) is considered for reaching the end of life facilities (as given in US EPA Waste Reduction
WARM Model) (US EPA 2018).
3.
PRODUCTION OF THE SEATING UNITS AND PRODUCT SPECIFICATIONS
The investigated office seating units are illustrated in Figure 1. The production flowcharts are given
in Figure 2.
Seating unit A has a length of 745 mm and a height of 1127 to 1247 mm. On the other hand, product
B has a length of 728 mm and a height of 1120 mm. Both of the units are covered with fabric.
(A)
(B)
Figure 1: Office seating units A and B
170
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Quite a similar manufacturing scheme is applied for both of the seating units. As the first step, the
polyurethane rigid foam base of seating units A and B is subjected to manual sanding to get a smooth
surface for fixing the upholstery. The cut fabric is sewed and cladded on the foam base. Cut and
shaped sheet iron are used for various parts of the seating unit such as legs and accessories. Painting
is applied on legs of seating unit B. Parts are get together in montage step and the packaging is applied.
(A)
(B)
Figure 2: Production flowcharts of A and B
For both of the products cardboard, polypropylene and polyethylene are the used materials for
packaging. The packaging materials are easily separable. Most of the packaging materials are
collected, sorted and recycled.
The wastes arising from the manufacturing of seating unit A and B is textile scraps, packaging
materials and scraps of iron. Apart from these paint wastes are also generated during the production
of seating unit B. All these wastes are sent to recycling facilities.
4.
RESULTS
4.1 Life Cycle Inventory (LCI)
The data collected per one seating for both of the seating units are presented in Table 1, 2 and 3.
Table 1: Raw materials for seating unit A and B
(A)
(B)
171
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
Table 2: Auxiliary materials for seating unit A and B
(A)
(B)
Table 3: Packaging materials for seating unit A and B
(A)
(B)
4.2 Environmental Impacts
The obtained environmental impacts of seating unit A and B are summarized in Table 4. The resource
use for both of the products are given in Table 5.
Table 4: Environmental impacts of seating unit A and B
(A)
(B)
172
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 5: Resource use for seating unit A and B
(A)
(B)
The relative contribution of various phases in life cycle for both of the products are presented in
Figure 3.
(A)
(B)
Figure 3: Contribution of various phases for seating unit A and B
5.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
All the environmental impacts are higher for the seating B. This elevation can be as much as 94 % in
EP, 73 % in AP, 65 % in POCP and 22 % in GWP. This result indicates the importance of product
design.
For both of the seating units, raw material extraction and pre-processing stage is the highest
contributor to all impact categories. The used aluminum for the mechanic parts and leg, rigid
polyurethane foam and the textile are the main contributors to this stage in seating A. The impacts
arise from transportation stage is due to cargo aircraft usage. For both of seating units, impacts due
to distribution and usage stage are generated because of sending paper wastes to landfills. Waste
cardboard, nylon and paper used in packaging are the contributors of manufacturing process. While
the highest impact is generated from sending the obsolete seating units to landfills.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors would like to sincerely thank Koleksiyon Ltd. for their valuable contribution. The
prominence of this study is supported by Koleksiyon Ltd’s decision to publish all findings
transparently in the public domain.
173
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
References
1. Atmaca, A. (2016) Life cycle assessment and cost analysis of residential buildings in south east
of Turkey: part 1—review and methodology, The International Journal of Life Cycle
Assessment, 21:831–846, 2016.
2. B. Atilgan and A. Azapagic. (2016) Renewable electricity in Turkey: Life cycle environmental
impacts, Renewable Energy, 89, 649-657, 2016.
3. E. Ozkan, N. Elginoz and F. Germirli Babuna. (2017) Life cycle assessment of a printed circuit
board manufacturing plant in Turkey, Environmental Science and Pollution Research, DOI:
10.1007/s11356-017-0280-z, 2017.
4. Gunkaya, Z, Ozdemir, A, Ozkan, A and Banar, M (2016) Environmental Performance of
Electricity Generation Based on Resources: A Life Cycle Assessment Case Study in Turkey,
Sustainability, 8(11), Number: 1097, DOI: 10.3390/su811109
5. Demirel, N.; Erkayaoglu, (2016) M. Sustainability Comparison of Mining Industries by Life
Cycle Assessment for Turkey and European Union, 16th International Symposium on
Environmental Issues and Waste Management in Energy and Mineral Production (SWEMP) /
International Symposium on Computer Applications (CAMI), Istanbul, Turkey.
6. MoE, (2016) Ministry of Economy, Republic of Turkey, Industry– Furniture.
https://www.economy.gov.tr/portal/content/conn/UCM/uuid/dDocName:EK-021146
7. D. R. Iritani, D.A.L.Silva, Y.M.B.Saavedra, P.F.F.Grael, A.R.Ometto, (2015) Sustainable
strategies analysis through Life Cycle Assessment: a case study in a furniture industry. Journal
of Cleaner Production, 96(1), Pages 308-318.
8. Mauro Cordella, Carme Hidalgo. (2016) Analysis of key environmental areas in the design and
labelling of furniture products: Application of a screening approach based on a literature review
of LCA studies. Sustainable Production and Consumption, 8, 64-77.
9. H. Kouchaki-Penchah, M. Sharifi, H. Mousazadeh, H. Zarea Hosseinabadi. Life cycle assessment
of medium-density fiberboard manufacturing process in Islamic Republic of Iran. Journal of
Cleaner Production, 112:351-358, DOI10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.07.049, 2016.
10. C. M. Piekarski, A. Carlos de Francisco, Antonio Carlos de Francisco Leila Mendes da Luz,
Diogo Aparecido Lopes SilvaDiogo Aparecido Lopes Silva (2017). Life cycle assessment of
medium-density fiberboard (MDF) manufacturing process in Brazil. Sci Total Environ.
1;575:103-111. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.10.007, 2017.
11. .I. González-García, García Lozano R, Moreira MT, Gabarrell X, Rieradevall i Pons J, Feijoo G,
Murphy RJ (2012).Eco-innovation of a wooden childhood furniture set: an example of
environmental solutions in the wood sector. Sci Total Environ. 426:318-326. doi:
10.1016/j.scitotenv.2012.03.077, 2012.
12. Nadia Mirabella, Valentina Castellani, Serenella Sala. (2014) LCA for assessing environmental
benefit of eco-design strategies and forest wood short supply chain: a furniture case study. The
International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 19:1536-1550, DOI 10.1007/s11367-0140757-7, 2014
13. NSF, 2019. International, National Center for Sustainability Standard (valid through September
30, 2019) . Product Category Rule for Environmental Product Declarations. BIFMA PCR for
Seating: UNCPC 3811 Version. https://www.nsf.org/newsroom_pdf/seating_pcr-new.pdf
14. ISO 14040 (2006) Environmental management -- Life cycle assessment -- Principles and
framework. https://www.iso.org/standard/37456.html
15. US EPA (2018) Waste Reduction WARM Model. https://www.epa.gov/warm
174
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
REGENERATION AND PLACE-MAKING THROUGH
HERITAGE: A CASE STUDY FROM A HISTORIC BUILDING IN
NORTHERN GREECE
S.M. Bagiouk1, E. Sofianou2*, A.S. Bagiouk3, S.S. Bagiouk4
1,3
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering,
2
Division of Transport and Project Management,
Dept. of Civil Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki,
Macedonia, Greece,
4
Dept. of Civil Engineering, Democritus University of Thrace, GR - 67131 Xanthi, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: sofianou@civil.auth.gr
Abstract
Cities are entering a new era underpinned by theoretical notions concerning their role as nodes in a
global competitive network. Urban areas of historical value are spatial structures that express the
evolution of the local society and its identity. Urban building stock with its connotative meanings is
an important part of the city as historical and cultural evidence. Within this framework, urban
regeneration is encouraged by local authorities to attract people. Rapid transformation of urban
buildings of historical significance, urban area revival and aesthetic investments are some of the
regeneration strategies towards revenue-generating potential and more sustainable urban forms.
Contemporary urban regeneration projects aim to plan creative spaces by reintegrating historic
complexes and buildings in the city and by creating distinctive urban areas with various functions and
a sense-of-place. Placemaking is an inherently collaborative and inclusive planning approach
compared to the envisaged planning model. As a concept it refers to the process of place production
with the aim to advance the living quality of a space. People are attracted to places which can become
focal points of economic, social activity and attractiveness including various functions.
This paper faces an important challenge in the field of urban heritage regeneration towards the
sustainable city. The paper focuses on a listed building of the rich historical building stock of
Thessaloniki in Northern Greece, the Branch of the 1st Secondary School (former Josef Modiano
Mansion). In particular, through this case study, the paper explores a series of issues associated with
the rehabilitation of abandoned historical buildings and their reintegration in the modern city through
placemaking strategies. The ultimate goal is to propose new aspects of urban building upgrade
through new creative uses and introduce a community based regeneration methodology.
Keywords: Urban regeneration; cultural heritage; place-making; historical buildings; sustainable city
1.
INTRODUCTION
Heritage is one of the important elements which create character, identity and image of the city
concerning the past, present and future. Built cultural heritage is a dominant component and an
important means of historical, economic and social development. However, technology, demographic
and economic changes and lack of systematic assessment methodologies for adequate consideration
of the divergence between sustainable urban development and the protection of cultural heritage, have
put pressures on the built urban assets. Viable strategies combined with architectural intervention and
175
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
conservation methods of built heritage are needed for the reintegration of such assets in the city and
the improvement of living conditions and microclimate.
Today there is an increasing interest towards more sustainable city forms and local community
participation in policy making. When a person or group links a space to their own personal
experiences, cultural values and social meanings, it is transformed into a place for them (Hunziker,
et al., 2007). The increased participation of citizens is important for the integration of cultural assets
into urban development strategies. Within this framework the notion of placemaking tends to be used
to refer to a specific approach to ‘revitalising, planning, designing and managing public spaces’
(Stewart, 2010). Placemaking is the process of place production and a collective process of space
arrangement with the aim to advance the usage and living quality of a space.
Thessaloniki in Northern Greece presents rich built heritage however, large part of the urban building
stock remains untapped. In the present paper, the aim is to explore the potentials of heritage revival
of the Branch of 1st Secondary School through social participation and placemaking. Using empirical
data from the area and through structured planning methods are investigated the factors that hinder
or promote sustainable development planning strategies. The aim is to develop a holistic methodology
to cover the gap between sustainable development and reuse of historical built resources and to assess
local communities' performance concerning sustainable strategies for urban regeneration through
creativity and placemaking strategies.
2.
LINKS BETWEEN SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT AND CULTURAL HERITAGE
WITHIN THE URBAN CONTEXT
2.1 Built heritage and urban regeneration
For a city to be sustainable, economic and social benefits need to be maximized in order to enhance
living standards as far as the city target is sustainable in terms of environmental limitations and
socioeconomic equity (Mori & Yamashita, 2015). One of sustainable development’s principals is the
protection and promotion of heritage and conservation of identity. Each place has a meaning, mostly
defined by the environment and human activity. Urban areas of historical significance are spatial
structures that express the evolution of local society and its cultural identity. These areas consist of
tangible (urban and architectural elements, open air spaces, buildings and landmarks) and intangible
elements (functions, activities, memories, traditions). They are an integral part of a broader natural
or manmade context and the two must be considered as inseparable.
Heritage is referenced in the international agenda for sustainability and for its role in defining the
distinctiveness of cities and improving their competitiveness. And vice versa urban competitiveness
regards culture as capital, so it is important to consider heritage as an essential resource of the urban
ecosystem. Sustainability in the redevelopment of historic city centers is innovative and necessary as
it contributes to the objectives of environmental reevaluation, economic and social regeneration and
durable development in the sense of protection of environmental resources for future generations
(Minetto, et al., 2011).
Built heritage conservation carries benefits in many areas of the urban environment (Vicente, et al.,
2015), however, the protection and reintegration of architectural heritage into modern urban
landscape is a complex procedure with many aspects. The continuous degradation of the urban
environment and the emerging problems caused during the last decades, are the major menace of
historic centers and monuments.
The term regeneration includes the sense of transformation, i.e. of a place with specific or mixed uses
(residential, commercial, educational), that through time and mainly due to lack of political initiatives,
shows signs of degradation (social, economic and environmental and can affect specific or wider
areas of the city). Upgrading the built environment, social fabric and urban spaces, contributes to
176
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
increasing their adoption as places for public congregation and activity, consequently increasing
social interaction and cohesion between citizens (Elnokaly & Elseragy, 2011).
2.2 New culture-based urban models
National governments and European institutions increasingly recognize the value of cultural heritage
(Tweed & Sutherland, 2007). In modern economies appears the ‘cultural turn’ in the positioning and
marketing of towns and cities, as a response to the profound implications for how cities work and
survive (Rodwell, 2013). Cultural resources, amenities, facilities etc, are considered nowadays as
strategic tools for the new economy. The ability of cities to integrate the conservation of urban
resources and to monitor impacts of development requires the recognition of heritage values (e.g.
historic, social, economic) and heritage-designated attributes (tangible and intangible).
Urban conservation is now considered as a dynamic process within an urban system aimed at
enhancing cultural values and managing change (United Nations, 2015). Urban regeneration aims to
renew areas in decline (Bassett, 2013), and this decline could be in the form of physical, social and/or
economic functions in the urban fabric (Chohan & Ki, 2005). Heritage is a catalyst for sustainable
urban regeneration and a comprehensive policy for identity conservation by involving the community
as a partner. Integrating the heritage conservation in the process of urban regeneration can lead a way
to sustainable development (Chohan & Ki, 2005).
Cultural infrastructures can become social spaces for interconnection and knowledge of local identity.
Safeguarding and promoting culture at the local level is a way to develop endogenous resources and
create conditions for sustainable revenue generation (United Nations, 2015). Furthermore, there are
many different sites of historical significance and attraction (i.e. archaeological sites, museums,
architecture and art landmarks, local tradition activities, festivals), that could be included in
programmes linking history, humanity and tourism.
3.
PLACEMAKING AS A MEANS OF URBAN REGENERATION
3.1 The notion of placemaking
The link between heritage as a consumable experience and urban regeneration as an economic
development activity is potentially attractive, widely exploited, can be assumed to be self-evidently
symbiotic but conceals the different motivations and aspirations of different stakeholders
(Pendlebury, 2002). The instrumental use of heritage in regeneration is a global phenomenon, often
linked into both strategies seeking to develop so-called cultural industries and a process of ‘placemaking’, a term variously used by urban designers in establishing attractive physical locales as part
of the backdrop of successful social space and, more critically, to be synonymous with place-branding
(Pendlebury & Porfyriou, 2017).
Culture and creativity have increasingly been incorporated into urban strategies aimed at supporting
the economic vitality of city-regions, and especially the ability of cities to compete for resources in
the context of globalization and intensified inter-urban competition (Evans, 2009). Placemaking can
trace its roots back to the seminal works of urban thinkers who, beginning in the 1960s, espoused a
new way to understand, design and program public spaces by putting people and communities ahead
of efficiency and aesthetics (Silberberg, et al., 2013). Urban author and visionary Jane Jacobs (as
cited in Baeker & Millier, 2013) sums up much of the logic of creative placemaking with the phrase:
“New ideas need old buildings”.
More recently introduced is the term “creative placemaking” which is decidedly 21st century-esque
(Salzman & Yerace, 2017). Creative placemaking is a skill that identifies and catalyzes local
leadership, funding, and other resources. As a bottom-up approach empowers and engages people in
ways that traditional planning processes do not and draws on the assets and skills of a community,
rather than on relying solely on professional “experts” (Project for Public Spaces, 2012). Initiatives
177
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
that are used to shape the social and physical character of a place, including contexts like health,
transport or education, has become increasingly popular (Oakley, 2015).
3.2 Urban heritage regeneration through placemaking
Cities are the places where different people and cultures mix and creativity is the lever for new ideas,
artefacts and institutions. In the long history of human settlement, public places have reflected the
needs and cultures of community; the public realm has long been the connective tissue that binds
communities together (Silberberg et al., 2013). For cities seeking to enhance their competitive
position, the use of heritage as a driver for economic growth is now an established feature of the
policy agenda. In addition to generating income and employment, their tendency to cluster within
rundown inner city districts often provides opportunities for area revitalization and regeneration
(Bayliss, 2007).
Placemaking is the process of creating quality places that people want to live, work, play and learn in
(Wyckoff, 2014). Successful placemaking initiatives create places active, interesting, visually
attractive, often with public art and creative activities, people-friendly, safe, and walkable with mixed
uses. Placemaking serves livability and social cohesion through heightened public safety, local
identity and environmental protection initiatives. It results in a place where the community feels
ownership and engagement, and where design serves function.
Placemaking embodies the common sense approach that guided how most historic places were
created, as people worked together over decades to create buildings, streets and public spaces that
would fulfill social, economic and political needs in their communities. Placemaking helps expand
the impact of preservation projects, as preserving historical places protects them from physical
destruction, but also, by embracing a community-oriented vision that draws upon local knowledge
and assets, preservationists can create places of long-lasting value (Project for Public Spaces, 2010).
The placemaking process is defined by the recognition that when it comes to public spaces, the
community is the expert and follows that strong local partnerships are essential to the process of
creating dynamic, healthy public spaces that serve citizens. Many creative placemaking efforts
address specific neighborhoods, including downtowns and residential and industrial areas that offer
under-utilized private and public capacity ripe for human ingenuity (Markusen & Gadwa, 2010).
Placemaking projects celebrate history and distinctive culture, add layers of meanings and create a
common vision for the community (Redaelli, 2018). They also generate economic returns in multiple
ways as cultural investments help a locality capture a higher share of local expenditures from income.
Furthermore, instead of traveling elsewhere for entertainment and culture, residents spend more on
local venues, money that re-circulates at a higher rate in the local economy. Another potential benefit
is the higher project value, as uniqueness of a place and innovative mixed-use project design may
establish premium value. As well as enhanced branding and market recognition feature as new
opportunities than the outcomes of budgeted marketing activities (Hardy, 2016).
Creative placemaking animates public and private spaces, rejuvenates structures and streetscapes,
improves local businesses viability and public safety, and brings diverse people together to celebrate,
inspire, and be inspired (Markusen & Gadwa, 2010). As far as it concerns the building stock, the
physical atmosphere of historic buildings contributes to placemaking at the site scale. Retaining
original features of the buildings serves as a physical reminder of what the building once was, making
the space unique in comparison to newly constructed spaces (Chan, 2011).
Restoration and rehabilitation of traditional buildings can favor the accommodation of various uses.
By using vacant and underutilized land, buildings and infrastructure, investments increase their
contribution to the public good and private sector productivity. Sales, income and property tax
revenues paid to local governments, rise enabling better maintenance and additions to public
infrastructure. Also, additional jobs and incomes are generated in construction, retail businesses, and
arts and cultural production (Markusen & Gadwa, 2010).
178
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4.
REGENERATION OF INNER-CITY AREAS: THE CASE OF THE 1ST SECONDARY
SCHOOL BRANCH (FORMER JOSEF MODIANO MANSION)
Thessaloniki is a 2300-year-old city and a contemporary metropolitan center of Northern Greece.
Thessaloniki started to grow as a commercial and geopolitical node of multicultural character. The
city’s traditional structure lost its oriental character and gradually became Europeanized. Today, the
metropolitan area of Thessaloniki looks like a puzzle of varied uses and a mixture of irregular
elements. However, within the densely built centre can still be found unique tangible and intangible
cultural resources. There are numerous historic monuments many of them still untapped, traditional
buildings representing folk architecture, modern landmarks and open air spaces of significant value.
There are also exquisite neoclassical buildings, most of them built as residences of the wealthy society
during the late 19th century.
The study area provides opportunities for urban revival as a significant historical and cultural asset
within the modern urban fabric. It is a place of traditions, cultures, specific activities, which can be
preserved and enhanced, through actions for sustainability. The neoclassical buildings found in the
dense urban fabric of this central study area are the main architectural assets that may be regenerated
and rehabilitated towards sustainable patterns. The majority of them are characterized by small,
usually two-storey residences often with a private open space. In some cases the streets are very
narrow prohibiting physical solar access and ventilation. Some buildings have been restored and
house municipal facilities and services, for instance, educational buildings, or they are used for
recreation, leisure and service facilities. The reuse of buildings is a solution to avoid constructing new
buildings in the constricted urban built space. Furthermore, the building-monument may be involved
in a perpetual dialogue with the space and the visitor.
4.1 Aims of the present research
As mentioned above, the paper focuses on a historical building, which for many years remained
abandoned. The case study building is located in the eastern extend of Thessaloniki’s city centre, an
area with rich historical and architectural assets. The building’s restoration project was conducted by
Angelos Vacalopoulos’ architectural firm for the Region of Central Macedonia. The architects and
planners of the team were: A. Vacalopoulos, St. Koukopoulos, A. Mitropoulos, G. Papadimitriou, A.
Stergiannis. S. Bagiouk and Z. Al Saayyah, associate architects and A. Manousi-Vacalopoulou and
K. Stylianidis, engineers – consultants. Especially in the second phase of the restoration project and
more specifically, the internal décor restoration study – which was a great task for this project – the
team joined St. Papanikolaou, A. Fostiridou and D. Kapizonis, conservators of antiquities and works
of art.
Part of this project conducted by Vacalopoulos and Associates Architectural firm in the early 2000’s
is analysed below, giving a sign of the extended survey and sustainable methods of regeneration
proposed, which can be adapted in other building rehabilitation cases. The information provided in
this paper, as well as the underlying material (plans and photographs) are from the personal archive
of A. Vacalopoulos and S. Bagiouk. Within this framework, the present paper focuses on this project
to provide guidelines for other rehabilitation projects for cultural or educational uses and help local
communities create a dialogue with the buildings and their history.
4.2 Brief historical overview of the case study building
Based on the technical report of the building’s current situation analysis, conducted by Angelos
Vacalopoulos, Samir Bagiouk and Zahi Al Saayyah, in 1899, in the location Tzanlik of the eastern
side, Josef Isaak Modiano bought an area of 3.040sq.m. at 48 ‘Allatini Degirmeni’ (Allatini Mill)
street, today 5 Vas. Olgas avenue. At the beginning, Modiano built a sericulture mill and later his
residence to house his family coming from Italy. Modiano and Allatini family created the most
important commercial Houses of Thessaloniki, including cereal, silk, cocoon, textile commerce etc.
179
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
After his death the building became property of this family. His son Jiomtov Josef Modiano, bought
his mother’s and sister’s shares. In 1931 sold his share to at commerce man Jacob I. Molho, which
past after his death in 1940 to his wife and daughters. The rest 70% which remained at the Modiano
family, was obtained after the World War II by the close relatives of the Modiano family.
Later on, the property was committed by the Greek State and more specifically, its’ operation was
managed by the Exchangeable Holdings Service. At this time it housed 22 families and individuals.
In the period 1946-58 at the residence lived 15 families and 6 more at the factory. In 1960, part of the
property was transferred to the Ministry of Education and Religion in order to operate as the Branch
of the 1st Secondary School. Ιn 1984, the Departmental Fund (successor of the School Building
Organisation) bought 18% and the for joint State’s share (Exchangeable Holdings Service, Land
Registry, School Building Organisation), became 90,7% of the total property.
4.3 Main tasks of the building regeneration project
The plot is located in a densely built area, dual-aspect between the Vas. Olgas and Spartis streets,
covering a total area of 3484,41 sq.m. The study building is listed and it houses educational uses. At
the west side of the plot the former 1st Male Secondary School was restored in 1990 and today it
operates a Secondary School, the small building (part of the former silk mill), gymnasium hall, and
the Branch of the school, abandoned building since 1978 and in bad condition. The buildings and
their surrounding space, were listed as protected by the Ministry of Environment.
The higher level from the Vas. Olgas part, the high pines, the old hoardings constitute with the
buildings, an exquisite ensemble for the area’s environment with a strong historical identity, as an
important pole of attraction. The building extends on three levels and despite the damages, large parts
of its’ structure and form was preserved. Within the framework of the building’s regeneration and
rehabilitation with educational uses, the regeneration project focused on the reinforcement of the
bearing structure, its’ functional reintegration into the modern city and highlighting of its rich
architectural mouldings, which were of historical significance.
The study focuses on the restoration of the Branch and its rehabilitation as an educational building.
The study’s goal is to investigate the potentials created after the building’s regeneration and the
dialogue created between the 100 year-old construction and the local society. The presented
methodology’s main aim was to serve as a tool for guiding urban planning and intervention, with
particular importance from the building rehabilitation point of view for buildings in urban and
historical centres, and also in the definition of maintenance priorities. There was no standard model,
but general principles and major steps, so this methodology needs to be adapted in different urban
characteristics and features. It intended to present an important contribution to urban strategies in the
extent of rehabilitation of the buildings of old historical city centres, with the sense of creativeness
and culture.
At the first stage, an analytical survey of the current situation about the building and the wider area
was conducted, using mostly historical testimonies and plans, and on site survey. The preliminary
report was the main product of this stage including the technical reports and plans of the current
situation, the building’s condition and a risk assessment. Through this analysis, a qualitative and
quantitative characterization of several elements and aspects of the building were recorded (second
stage). These two initial stages were the basis of the process, in order to acknowledge all variables
and sensibilities involved.
180
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Secondary School
(restored in 1990s)
Branch of 1rst Secondary School
(case study)
Picture 1: Topographic plan of the plot and its’ buildings (Vacalopoulos et al., 2000).
The main aim of the project was the regeneration of this cultural asset and reintegration into the urban
fabric, as a node of social expression and interaction. The third stage proposes uses focused mainly
on educational but also, on other cultural and leisure activities with respect to the building and the
wider area. All the information, observed and recorded for the building and the neighborhood in the
formed database, is a tool to promote the development of future rehabilitation projects, in point
interventions or in a larger scale (city block projects).
Picture 2: The building before its restoration (Vacalopoulos et al., 2000).
According to the needs of contemporary planning based on creativity and placemaking, vacant
buildings are proposed to house uses connected to education and arts in order to create a dialogue
between the building and the local society. Taking into consideration creativity principals and the
building’s history, typology, size and structure of spaces, its main phases and the surrounding area’s
characteristics, was proposed the reconstruction and rehabilitation of the building as a multifunctional
educational space with respect to its historical character. The main aim was to promote a regenerated
space for education and creativity.
181
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
Among the main uses proposed by the project are classrooms, creative spaces for educational needs,
and potentials of education through new technologies. Among the project’s main goals were the
restoration and highlighting of the rich architectural décor, the reconstruction through environmental
planning methods and the provision for people with special needs. The ultimate goal was to
reintegrate this historical building into the urban fabric and create a space of education accessible to
the local community and getting in touch with the local history.
Picture 3: The building after the restoration programme (authors’ archive).
Picture 4: Aspect from the first floor’s interior (authors’ archive).
Picture 5: Restoration of the magnificent ceilings was a main goal of the project (authors’
archive).
According to the building’s restructuring programme, the proposed uses by floor include:
1st floor: Principal’s office, educational offices, parent’s association office, auxiliary spaces.
Ground floor (main educational spaces): four classrooms, teacher’s office, central and secondary
staircases.
Underground level (main educational spaces): classrooms of informatics, classroom of
technology, teacher’s office, pupils’ space, storage, staircases.
Special attention was paid to the restoration of the building’s décor as an element of historical and
architectural significance. The damage of the floors and the collapse of parts of the roof causing
detachment of parts of the ceilings, were key elements of the restoration programme. In addition,
interventions of environmental character were another important goal of the project. The ensure of
enough solar access and physical ventilation was obtained through detailed planning and choice of
adequate materials and frames.
182
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
5.
FURTHER DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Creative placemaking is a geographically targeted urban revitalization strategy (Forman & Creighton,
2012). Evidence has demonstrated that creative placemaking has resulted in a wide range of positive
outcomes, including strengthening networks and building social capital and community capacity,
among others (Baeker & Millier, 2013). Building on uniqueness of place and community practices is
a strong predictor of success (Markusen & Gadwa, 2010).
Governments have developed programs to fund arts, education, turn vacant properties into
community cultural centers, and stimulate interest in local heritage and culture (Kratke, 2011).
Thessaloniki’s urban fabric and the structure of buildings demand skills on appropriate traditional
refurbishment and restoration methods that are crucial for upgrading the area. Moreover, the city’s
rich cultural built heritage should prioritize the marriage of building regeneration with local
community and economy. The restoration and rehabilitation of historic buildings is not only an
important end in its own right. Each building can provide a stimulus and focal point for regeneration
schemes creating more jobs.
The regeneration of the Secondary School Branch (of educational and creativity uses), was an
innovative project. The main aim of the project was to create a space of education and interaction
with respect to the building’s history and typology, as well as to local identity. As an example of
inner-city regeneration using sustainable planning methods, the main scope was to promote the city’s
tradition and citizen participation and to create a local and regional node of heritage.
The architects and planners created a new space for education enhancing the architectural character
of the building and bringing together local community with its’ history. The project puts heritage at
the heart of placemaking as it shows that this historic building provides a focal point for vibrant
development by finding a long-term use within the context of a successful commercial and
community development. The visitors can move in a space that is their everyday life environment
and act as researchers, collaborators, and facilitators. People of all ages can use this new space and
develop educational activities or other artistic activities.
The surrounding space of the building was upgraded and became a beautiful garden and an open air
space within the dense urban fabric. Moreover, the revival of the space provides now a sense of safety
to the neighbors, as it has wed out any ‘intruders’, who entered into the abandoned building and with
the new lighting of its open space, especially at night.
Also, the secure rehabilitation of the building through the reconstruction and reinforcement of the
load-bearing structure is an important benefit. The building was vacant for many years, becoming a
dark hole for the neighborhood. After its’ restoration the building opened its doors to the public,
enhancing the building’s history and architectural character. All the interventions were formed to
integrate to the building’s current structure with respect to its historical character and according to
the legal framework of listed buildings’ protection.
Furthermore, retaining original features of the buildings serves as a physical reminder of what the
building once was, making the space unique in comparison to newly constructed spaces. In this case,
the past comes alive for kids in the new classrooms, as they get in touch with the building’s and the
city’s history on a daily basis. The form of the suggested revival project is designed to be implemented
in various heritage regeneration cases. The project’s results demonstrate the power of regeneration
projects to bring communities together with their heritage and identity through educational uses.
The aim of this paper is to highlight the benefits of this regeneration project, as a paradigm for new
aspects of building upgrade through creative uses and introduces a community based regeneration
example through strengthening public participation and increasing local residents' sense of belonging.
The investigation of this project shows the way in which place-based cultural policy paradigms are
based on a conceptual shift in the regeneration of vacant and abandoned buildings and the
establishment of uses for the public promoting arts, education, cultural activities.
183
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
References
1. Baeker, G., & Millier, L. (2013). Creative Placemaking. Municipal World, (February), 9–10.
2. Bassett, S. M. (2013). The Role of Spatial Justice in the Regeneration of Urban Spaces.
Rijkuniversiteit Groningen, (May).
3. Bayliss, D. (2007). The Rise of the Creative City: Culture and Creativity in Copenhagen.
European Planning Studies, 15(7), 889–903. http://doi.org/10.1080/09654310701356183
4. Chan, R. C. (2011). Old Buildings, New Ideas : Historic Preservation and Creative Industry
Development as Complementary Urban Revitalization Strategies. University of Pennsylvania.
5. Chohan, A. Y., & Ki, P. W. (2005). Heritage Conservation a tool for Sustainable Urban
Regeneration : A Case study of Kaohsiung and Tainan , Taiwan. In 4th ISoCaRP Congress.
6. Elnokaly, A., & Elseragy, A. (2011). Sustainable Urban Regeneration of Historic City Centres –
Lessons Learnt. In World Sustainable Building Conference. Helsinki. Retrieved from
http://eprints.lincoln.ac.uk/8490/1/SB2011-2 historic Regeneration V3.pdf
7. Evans, G. (2009). Creative Cities, Creative Spaces and Urban Policy. Urban Studies (Vol. 46).
http://doi.org/10.1177/0042098009103853
8. Forman, B., & Creighton, T. (2012). Building vibrancy : Creative placemaking strategies for
gateway city growth and renewal. The Massachusetts Institute for a New Commonwealth.
Massachusetts: Massachussets Institute.
9. Hardy, J. (2016). Growing Value through Creative Placemaking. Urban Land. Retrieved from
https://urbanland.uli.org/industry-sectors/growing-value-creative-placemaking/
10. Hunziker, M., Buchecker, M., & Hartig, T. (2007). Space and Place - Two Aspects of the Humanlandscape Relationship. In F. Kienast, O. Wildi, & S. Gosh (Eds.), A Changing World Challenges for Landscape Research (pp. 47–62). Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands.
http://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4020-4436-6
11. Kratke, S. (2011). The creative capital of cities: Interactive knowledge, creation and the
urbanization economies of innovation. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.
12. Markusen, A., & Gadwa, A. (2010). Creative Placemaking. City Design Initiative. Washington.
Retrieved from http://www.planning.ri.gov/documents/comp/CreativePlacemaking.pdf
13. Minetto, F., Pirlone, F., & Tomasoni, L. (2011). Proposal of a methodological approach for
sustainable regeneration in the historical centers of the Mediterranean Basin. Procedia
Engineering, 21, 1015–1022. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.proeng.2011.11.2107
14. Mori, K., & Yamashita, T. (2015). Methodological framework of sustainability assessment in
City Sustainability Index (CSI): A concept of constraint and maximisation indicators. Habitat
International, 45(P1), 10–14. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.habitatint.2014.06.013
15. Oakley, K. (2015). Creating Space: A re-evaluation of the role of culture in regeneration. Leeds.
16. Pendlebury, J. (2002). Conservation and regeneration: Complementary or conflicting processes?
The case of grainger town, Newcastle upon Tyne. Planning Practice and Research, 17(2), 145–
158. http://doi.org/10.1080/02697450220145913
17. Pendlebury, J., & Porfyriou, H. (2017). Heritage, urban regeneration and place-making. Journal
of Urban Design, 22(4), 429–432. http://doi.org/10.1080/13574809.2017.1326712
18. Project for Public Spaces (2010). Placemaking meets preservation. Retrieved from
https://www.pps.org/article/placemaking-meets-preservation
184
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
19. Project for Public Spaces (2012). Placemaking and the Future of Cities (Draft), 35. Retrieved
from http://www.pps.org/reference/placemaking-and-the-future-of-cities/
20. Rodwell, D. (2013). Heritage as a driver for creative cities. In D. Wiktor-Mach & P. Radwanski
(Eds.), The idea of creative city/The urban policy debate (pp. 11–26). Cracow: European
Scientific Institute.
21. Salzman, R., & Yerace, M. (2017). Toward understanding creative placemaking in a sociopolitical
context.
City,
Culture
and
Society,
(February).
http://doi.org/10.1016/j.ccs.2017.10.004
22. Silberberg, S., Lorah, K., Disbrow, R., & Muessig, A. (2013). Places in the Making: How
placemaking builds places and communities, 63.
23. Stewart, A. (2010). Place-making and Communities: A review of concepts, indicators, policy and
practice. Forest Research, Edinburgh.
24. Tweed, C., & Sutherland, M. (2007). Built cultural heritage and sustainable urban development.
Landscape and Urban Planning, 83(1), 62–69. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.landurbplan.2007.05.008
25. United Nations. (2015). (H3)Urban Culture and Heritage. Habitat III, 2015(May), 0–8.
26. Vacalopoulos, A., Koukopoulos, S., Mitropoulos, A., Bagiouk, S., Saajach, Z., & Kotroni, T.
(2000). Restoration of First Secondary School Branch project. (A. (consultant) ManousiVacalopoulou, Ed.). Technical report, Thessaloniki.
27. Vicente, R., Ferreira, T. M., & Mendes da Silva, J. A. R. (2015). Supporting urban regeneration
and building refurbishment. Strategies for building appraisal and inspection of old building stock
in
city
centres.
Journal
of
Cultural
Heritage,
16(1),
1–14.
http://doi.org/10.1016/j.culher.2014.03.004
185
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Built environment
186
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Environmental education
187
Environmental education
188
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
RAISING AWARENESS ON CLIMATE CHANGE THROUGH
HUMOR
L. Topaltsis, V. Plaka* and C. Skanavis
Research Center of Environmental Communication and Education, Dept. of Environment,
University of the Aegean, GR- 81100 Mytilene, Lesvos, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: plaka@env.aegean.gr, tel: +302251036234
Abstract
Environmental awareness, for issues like climate change, is on top of the list with the concerns,
humanity is facing. We are being exposed to a gigantic number of environmental messages but still
we haven’t reached the optimum level of environmental sensitivity.
Most of the climate change awareness campaigns use fearful stimuli such as scary titles, and images
of catastrophes and uncertain futures. That kind of campaigns create emotions like fear, anxiety and
worry to the public. That’s an explanation why lots of people ignore climate change and deny its
importance. According to various researches, humor can boost successfully educational and
communication processes at stake. Participants being confronted with pleasant approaches have
responded positively to the new information and their intention to retain longer their behavioral
change has been recorded.
Through a quality process, this study aims to study the importance of humor, and how it can be used
in climate change awareness campaigns in a way that will influence public’s attitudes and behavior,
so that a positive response will be created.
Keywords: Climate change, Humor, Environmental awareness, Environmental communication
1.
INTRODUCTION
Climate change and global warming are a growing problem in the world at this present time and the
future as well (IPCC, 2007). The first legally binding national commitment to greenhouse gas (GHG)
emissions reduction was through the Kyoto Protocol, adopted in 1997 and entered into force in 2005
(O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole, 2009). However, in 2007, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
Change suggests that actions are quickly needed to reduce global climate change (IPCC, 2007). The
human cause of global climate change has been identified as increasing levels of greenhouse gases:
for example, carbon dioxide (CO2) emitted by burning fossil fuels for transport and heating; and
methane emitted by cattle raised for the meat industry (Parant et al., 2017). Within the European
Union (EU), a target has been set to reduce greenhouse gases by at least 20% by 2020 compared with
the 1990 level (European Commission, 2011). The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
stated in its most recent report that warming of the climate system is “unequivocal (IPCC, 2007).
Impacts of climate change are projected to be many and varied, ranging from changes in ecosystems
(e.g., LeemansandEickhout, 2004), to impacts on human systems such as water resources (Arnell,
1999), to potential forced human migrations (e.g.,Barnett andAdger,2003), to widespread
acidification of the oceans (e.g., Caldeira and Wickett, 2003), to insurance and reinsurance difficulties
(e.g., Munich Re, 2004). Both mitigation and adaptation are needed to appropriately manage the
challenge of climate change (O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole, 2009) and global efforts have so far tended
to concentrate on the mitigation of GHG emissions (O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole, 2009).
189
Environmental education
Nowadays, many environmental campaigns appear to be based on the presumption that people need
more information to behave pro-environmentally (Howell, 2014). In recent years, governments,
nongovernmental organizations, and individuals have all been involved in creating “climate change
communications” aimed at changing public attitudes and behavior related to climate change. These
include leaflets and flyers, billboard, press and television advertisements, movies, and publications
of many kinds are disseminated to the population (Parant et al. 2017).
Also, there is a growing consensus that we must engage publics in scientific dialogue (House of
Lords, 2000). Scientists are increasingly expected to become prominent actors in communicating
science to the lay public (Bentley and Kyvik, 2011; Dudo, 2012; Trench and Miller, 2012).One of the
reasons this need arises is based on the fact that scientific knowledge is at the core of many of the
issues that society faces today (Poliakoff and Webb, 2007). However, the approach in terms of
“information-deficit” has been widely criticized as being inadequate to promote behavioral change
(Kellstedt, Zahran and Vedlitz, 2008; Ockwell, Whitmarsh, and O’Neill, 2009; Schultz,
2002).Organizations such as Futerra (2005) and the Institute for Public Policy Research (Ereaut and
Segnit, 2006), and academics such as Kloeckner (2011),Pooley and O’Connor (2000), and Moser
(2007) advise that environmental messages should appeal to the emotions rather than simply
providing factual information, to be more engaging.
1.1 Fear is no productive
Climate change communications frequently use disaster framing to create a fear appeal intended to
motivate mitigation action (Howell, 2014). Fear appeals in climate change are prevalent in the public
domain, with the language of alarmism appearing in many guises (O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole,
2009). The literature that does exist suggests that using fearful representations of climate change may
be counterproductive (Moser and Dilling, 2004). Current climate change discourses are often
characterized by fear and catastrophe narratives (Doulton and Brown, 2009; Hulme, 2008).
For example, the U.K. government talks of “dangerous climate change” (Conference on Dangerous
Climate Change, 2005), the media of a “climate of fear” (Bonnici, 2007) and NGOs of “climate
chaos” (Stop Climate Chaos,a U.K. coalition for action on climate change). Even so, Ereaut and
Segnit (2006) state that the alarmist climate repertoire is characterized by an inflated or extreme
lexicon, with an urgent tone: It is a terrible, immense, and apocalyptic problem, beyond human
control. They find alarmist climate messages employ narratives of doom, death, judgment, and heaven
and hell (Ereaut and Segnit, 2006). Fear is also strongly apparent in the kinds of imagery used in
association with climate change more broadly (O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole, 2009). The U.K. Green
Party used an image of a catastrophically flooded and drowned “British Isle [sic]” to campaign in the
2005 national elections (Wootton, 2005). Images of polar bears stranded on ice floes have become
iconic of climate change (O’Neill, 2008), and those depicting human struggle are evident in the
famine and water shortages depicted in the climate campaign literature of charity Christian Aid
(2008).
The mediation of fear messages is illustrated in Hulme (2007). The researcher conducted a study into
the coverage of the IPCC Working Group I report in 10 major U.K. national newspapers. Only one
newspaper did not run a story on the IPCC report. The other nine, all ran articles introducing the
adjectives catastrophic, shocking, terrifying, or devastating. Yet none of these words were present in
the original IPCC document. Weingart, Engels, and Pansegray (2000) offer some explanation that
newsworthiness increases if identifiable events can be linked to a threat to human life, and in order
to do this levels of alarm are often magnified (Joffe, 1999). Accordingly, some authors report that
climate change is most commonly communicated in the media in the context of dramatic
climaterelated events (e.g., Carvalho and Burgess, 2005).
Furthermore, in their research O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole (2009) argued that “fearful” and
“shocking” representations of climate change are “likely to distance or disengage individuals from
climate change, tending to render them feeling helpless and overwhelmed when they try to
comprehend their own relationship with the issue”. However, they can also act to distance and
190
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
disempower individuals in terms of their sense of personal engagement with the issue (O’Neill and
Nicholson-Cole, 2009). This research has shown that dramatic, sensational, fearful, shocking, and
other climate change representations of a similar ilk can successfully capture people’s attention to the
issue of climate change and drive a general sense of the importance of the issue.
Although shocking, catastrophic, and large-scale representations of the impacts of climate change
may well act as an initial hook for people’s attention and concern, they clearly do not motivate a sense
of personal engagement with the issue and indeed may act to trigger barriers to engagement such as
denial and others (Lorenzoni et al., 2007; O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole, 2009). All of these which
presented here certainly demonstrate that on a standalone basis fear, shock, or sensationalism may
promote verbal expressions and general feelings of concern but that they overwhelmingly have a
“negative” impact on active engagement with climate change (O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole, 2009).
The “wicked” nature of climate change makes it, for many people, an impersonal and distant issue
(Lorenzoni et al., 2006). A further consequence of long-term reliance on fear appeals, as stated by
Hastings et al. (2004), is that it is possible that a law of diminishing returns may exist. If this exists,
fear approaches need to be made more intense as time goes by because of repeated exposure to
threatening information in order to produce the same impact on individuals.Linville and Fischer’s
(1991) “finite pool of worry” effect is also worthy of note here.
An ill-considered fear approach may damage (or further damage) the reputation of the communicating
organization and the ability of that organization to attempt further engagement approaches. This is
key when considering the need for sustained and consistent messages to communicate climate risks
(Futerra, 2005). The continued use of fear messages can lead to one of two psychological functions.
The first is to control the external danger, the second to control the internal fear (Moser and Dilling,
2004). If the external danger—in this case, the impacts of climate change—cannot be controlled (or
is not perceived to be controllable), then individuals will attempt to control the internal fear. These
internal fear controls, such as issue denial and apathy, can represent barriers to meaningful
engagement.
Lorenzoni et al. (2007) divide the barriers to engagement with climate change, into two types,
individual-level and social-level barriers. Of particular consequence for this discussion of fear appeals
are the barriers acting individually to inhibit engagement with climate change. Although hoping that
climate change would not affect them, three participants in the imagery study specifically noted that
thinking about climate change made them feel so scared and depressed that they purposefully did not
think about it. Fear appeals may act to increase this response, leading to denial of the problem and
disengagement with the whole issue in an attempt to avoid the discomfort of contending with it
(O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole, 2009).
1.2 Humor versus fear
Using humor in environmental communication can help communicators avoid overwhelming
audiences with feelings of fear, helplessness, and guilt, which may otherwise discourage them from
taking action against climate change (O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole, 2009). Similarly, Howell (2014)
states that fear appeals about climate change need to be combined with discussion of how to avoid
the threat in order not to trigger maladaptive defensive responses. Fear appeals need to be combined
with high-efficacy messages (useful information about how to avoid the threat) in order not to trigger
maladaptive defensive responses (Lewis, Watson and White, 2010; Moser, 2007). However, O’Neill
and Nicholson-Cole (2009) found that fear-based climate change representations do not motivate
personal engagement with the issue, while Spence and Pidgeon (2010) found that positive framing
produced attitudes toward climate change mitigation that were significantly more positive than those
produced by loss frames. Morton, Rabinovich, Marshall, and Bretschneider (2011) found that positive
framing combined with higher uncertainty about outcomes increased individuals’ intentions to
mitigate climate change, compared with negative framing.
191
Environmental education
In a meta-analysis on the use of fear appeal in health prevention, Peters, Ruiter, and Kok (2013)
confirm the link between threat and efficacy in initiating positive behaviors. However, they underline
that “a potent efficacyenhancing element” is required in the intervention to increase positive outcomes
(Peters et al., 2013; Parant et al., 2017). In a binding communication paradigm, it is possible to reduce
the potential drawbacks from fear appeals when the preparatory act includes solutions for the issue at
hand (Parant et al., 2017). Even if movies are able to present information and have been shown to
engage their audience emotionally, our data suggest that fear appeal-based movies could be inefficient
if not accompanied by concrete solutions (Parant et al., 2017).
2.
METHODOLOGY
Through a qualityassessment process, this study aims to emphasize the importance of humor, and
point out how it can be used in climate change awareness campaigns, in a way that will influence
public’s attitudes and behavior to a positive response. Also, this study examines if stand-up comedy
is a successful alternative way to communicate about climate change through raising environmental
awareness.
3.
HUMOR: ΑΝALTERNATIVE WAY IN CLIMATE CHANGE COMMUNICATION
Although the definitions of humor vary, there is widespread agreement among scholars that humor
involves the communication of multiple, incongruous meanings that are amusing in some manner
(Martin, 2007). Humor is not a common tool scientists use to communicate, but there are nevertheless
several examples of comedy in scientific academia (Pinto et al, 2015). Humor is sometimes argued
to be an effective way of communicating science (Bultitude, 2011). Also, it requires a coordinated
network of responses involved in generating expectations and associations, perceiving incongruities,
and revising these expectations, resulting in affective and expressive responses of mirth and laughter
(Robert et al., 2011).
In evaluating over 40 years of research on humor and education, general conclusions about the effects
of instructional humor as well as directions for future research can be reached (Banas et al., 2011).
The use of humor is a prevalent communication behavior in pedagogical settings and serves different
purposes. On Banas et al. (2011) research, the clearest findings regarding humor and education
concern the use of humor to create learning environment. The use of positive, nonaggressive humor
has been associated with a more interesting and relaxed learning environment, higher instructor
evaluations, greater perceived motivation to learn, and enjoyment of the course. Conversely, the use
of negative or aggressive humor aimed at students has been associated with many of the opposite
outcomes, including a more anxious and uncomfortable learning environment, lower evaluations of
instructors, increased student distraction and less enjoyment of class (Banas et al., 2011).
3.1 Satire
Satire uses humor as a weapon, attacking ideas, behaviors, institutions, or individuals by encouraging
us to laugh at them (Bore and Reid, 2014). It may be gentle or hostile, clear-cut or ambiguous, aimed
at “us” or “them” - or it may oscillate between different approaches, remaining flexible and surprising
(Bore and Reid, 2014).
First, satire can facilitate audience reflection, investigation, and action (Bore and Reid, 2014). Second,
the use of humor can help audiences manage feelings of fear, helplessness, and guilt, which may
otherwise prevent them from taking action (Bore and Reid, 2014). However, as Herr (2007) notes, a
key critical dilemma associated with theatrical satire is the belief that “the presence of human actors
on stage fosters sympathy”. While such sympathy can help the satirist by encouraging audience
members to recognize themselves in the characters’ portrayed, it also undermines “the possibility of
sardonic detachment.” Herr suggests that this conundrum is often resolved “by tempering the
192
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
bitterness of the attack.” He describes it as “instructing through laughter rather than punishing through
scorn”.
As Spicer (2011) notes, “Satire is a slippery customer. It weaves in and out of reality and makes itself
accessible enough for the instantaneous laughter while it is just tricky enough not to be pinned down.
Also, Bore and Reid (2014) claim that the first key benefit associated with the use of satire on climate
change communication is that the satirical mode can promote active engagement with climate change
by encouraging reflection, investigation, and action. The second significant benefit associated with
the use of satire on climate change communication is that a humorous tone can help promoting a
positive engagement with climate change (Bore and Reid, 2014).
While satire can encourage positive engagement with climate change, communicators need to take
measures to avoid confining their engagement with climate change issues to the realm of humor, so
that they can make productive proposals to climate change debates (Bore and Reid, 2014).While the
distinction between the realm of humor and the realm of seriousness is analytical and it is clearly
possible to make fun of climate change while remaining committed to taking action against it, it is
important that the use of humorous distance does not discourage citizens’ action (Bore and Reid,
2014). Nisbet and Scheufele (2009) have called for further research “on the potential for using this
style of humor [satire] as a tool for public engagement on science”. They believe that satire could be
developed as a tool to make science more accessible for nonelite audiences, particularly young
people.
3.2 Stand-Up Comedy
Among the different genres of humour, stand-up comedy is one of its most recent forms and can be
described as a performer standing on a stage and speaking to an audience with main purpose making
people laugh (Pinto et al, 2015). However, some comedians can seek a reaction that is not necessarily
laughter, but instead invites the audience to think about certain issues (McCarron and Savin-Baden,
2008). The performances are composed of a succession of funny stories, one-liners or short jokes,
and anecdotes, in which each “bit” usually has a set-up (that establishes the context of the joke and
introduces necessary background of information to prepare the audience for the punchline, which is
the joke about that subject (Greenbaum, 1999; Schwarz, 2010).
The application of stand-up comedy to science communication is still uncommon but has been
gaining momentum in recent years in the United States of America and the United Kingdom (Pinto
et al, 2015). Probably the most well-known example is the US former scientist Brian Malow (selfproclaimed Earth’s Premier Science Comedian), who develops several activities as a science
communicator, not only acting in comedy clubs, conferences and other venues, but also teaching other
scientists to better express themselves through the use of comedy (Malow, 2010; Pilcher, 2010). Other
examples include US biologist Tim Lee (Chang, 2009), with performances that are usually a parody
of science seminars, and the UK mathematician Matt Parker, who does stand-up comedy in clubs,
science and comedy festivals, as well as presentations about mathematics in schools (Parker, 2013).
Other professional comedians such as Ricky Gervais and Tim Minchin have also adopted themes
concerning science in recent years, which is indicative that this humor format has the potential to be
used in science communication (Gunderson, 2006; Chang, 2009; Pilcher, 2010).
In their research with students, Robert et al. (2011) investigated neural activation underlying humor
specifically as it applies to a naturalistic, dynamic social interaction, addressing the puzzling lack of
evidence for mesolimbic responses using such dynamic stimuli. The study examined the neural
activation associated with watching stand-up comedians, specifically contrasting high- and lowamusing skits of the same comedians, as selected based on prating made by a sample of raters from
the same student population. Although stand-up comedy is certainly still a performance art, it
simulates the joke-telling experience in everyday life, where one person surrounded by others
captures the attention of the group and delivers the necessary cognitive structure and elements to
produce a mirth response and receive the social capital that comes with it(Robert et al., 2011). This
may be the case because when instructors enact successful humor, their students enjoy their
193
Environmental education
educational experiences and learn more (Booth-Butterfield and Wanzer, 2010; Chesebro and Wanzer,
2006).
4.
DISCUSSIONAND CONCLUSIONS
Global issues, like climate change is a growing problem, which concerns everyone about a sustainable
future. But communication and education about climate change are on the topic last years, such as
directly and interactive tools. Developing ways of communicating complex messages and
implementing science-policy interface mechanisms are not ends in themselves. Collating, interpreting
and disseminating information on climate impacts has as a long-term goal to wisely use scientific
information in policy and decision-making in order to plan and manage communities accordingly
(Skanavis et al., 2018).
Through humor in environmental communication, communicators avoid overwhelming audiences
with feelings of fear, helplessness, and guilt, which may otherwise discourage them from taking
action against climate change (O’Neill and Nicholson-Cole, 2009). The reward is a central
mechanism of humor, motivating a process of debugging inferential errors in our comprehension of
the world that is essential for smooth cognitive functioning (Hurley, Dennett, and Adams, 2011).
Humor can thus serve as a means of assessing the shared underlying knowledge, attitudes, and
preferences of others and “works, in a sense, as a mind reading spot-check, ‘pinging’ various minds
in the environment and discovering those which are most compatible” (Flamson and Barrett, 2008).
This confirms that climate change communicators need humor as a good vehicle for awareness.
Professional comedians have adopted themes concerning science in recent years, which is indicative
that this humor format has the potential to be used in science communication (Gunderson, 2006;
Chang, 2009; Pilcher, 2010). Comedians can seek a reaction that is not necessarily laughter, but
instead invites the audience to think about certain issues (McCarron and Savin-Baden, 2008). The
application of stand-up comedy to science communication is still uncommon but has been gaining
momentum in recent years in the United States of America and the United Kingdom (Pinto et al,
2015).
Although stand-up comedy is certainly still a performance art, it simulates the joke-telling experience
in everyday life, where one person surrounded by others captures the attention of the group and
delivers the necessary cognitive structure and elements to produce a mirth response and receive the
social capital that comes with it (Robert et al., 2011). This may be the case because when instructors
enact successful humor, their students enjoy their educational experiences and learn more (BoothButterfield and Wanzer, 2010; Chesebro and Wanzer, 2006). The use of humor is a prevalent
communication behavior in pedagogical settings and serves different purposes (Banas et al., 2011).
The clearest findings regarding humor and education concern the use of humor to create a learning
environment. The use of positive, nonaggressive humor has been associated with a more interesting
and relaxed learning environment, higher instructor evaluations, greater perceived motivation to
learn, and enjoyment of the course (Banas et al., 2011). Specifically, instructor’s humor increases
student performance on exams, especially on knowledge and comprehension items (Hackathorn,
Garczynski, Blankmeyer, Tennial, and Solomon, 2011), recall of information (Garner, 2006), and
final examination scores (Ziv, 1988). Humor, therefore, guarantees or makes highly likely that
specific, hidden knowledge was necessary to produce the humorous utterance, and that the same
knowledge is present in anyone who understands the humor (Flamson and Barrett, 2008). Similarly,
Martin (2007) argued that the positive emotions aroused by instructional humor may become
associated with learning.
References
1. Arnell N. W. (1999). Climate change and global water resources. Global Environmental
Change, Vol 9, S31-S49.
194
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2. Banas J. A., Dunbar N., Rodriguez D. and Liu S. J. (2011). A Review of Humor in Educational
Settings: Four Decades of Research. Communication Education, Vol 60 (1), pp. 115-144.
3. Barnett J. and Adger W. (2003). Climate dangers and atoll countries. Climatic Change, Vol 61,
pp. 321-337.
4. Bentley P. and Kyvik S. (2011). Academic staff and public communication: A survey of popular
science publishing across 13 countries. Public Understanding of Science, Vol 20(1), pp. 48-63.
5. Bonnici T. (2007). Climate of fear: Stark warning. The Sun, pp. 26.
6. Booth-Butterfield M. and Wanzer M. B. (2010). Humor and communication in instructional
Contexts: Goal-oriented communication. In D. L. Fassett and J. T. Warren (Eds.). The SAGE
handbook of communication and instruction, pp. 221-239, Los Angeles: Sage.
7. Bore I. L. K. and Reid G. (2014). Laughing in the Face of Climate Change? Satire as a Device
for Engaging Audiences in Public Debate. Science Communication, Vol 36 (4), pp. 454-478.
8. Bultitude K. (2011). The why and how of science communication. In: Rosulek P (ed.) Science
Communication. Pilsen: European Commission, pp. 1-18.
9. Caldeira K. and Wickett M. E. (2003). Anthropogenic carbon and ocean pH: The coming
centuries may see more ocean acidification than the past 300 million years. Nature, Vol 425, pp.
365.
10. Carvalho A. and Burgess J. (2005). Cultural circuits of climate change: An analysis of
representations of “dangerous” climate change in the UK broadsheet press 1985-2003. Risk
Analysis, Vol 25, pp. 1457-1469.
11. Chang K. (2009). Did you hear the one about the former scientist?. The New York Times, 14
December. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/15/science/15comic.html/
12. Chesebro J. L. and Wanzer M. B. (2006). Instructional message variables. In T. P. Mottet, V. P.
Richmond and J. C. McCroskey (Eds.). Handbook of instructional communication: Rhetorical
and relational perspectives, pp. 89-116, Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
13. Christian Aid. (2008). The issues: climate change, Retrieved August 14, 2008, from
http://www.christianaid.org.uk/issues/climatechange/index.aspx
14. Doulton H. and Brown K. (2009). Ten years to prevent catastrophe? Discourses of climate change
and international development in the UK press. Global Environmental Change, Vol 19, pp. 191202.
15. Dudo A. (2012). Toward a model of scientists’ public communication activity: The case of
biomedical researchers. Science Communication, Vol 29, pp. 413-434.
16. Ereaut G. and Segnit N. (2006). Warm words: How are we telling the climate story and can
we tell it better? London, England: Institute for Public Policy Research.
17. European Commission. (2011). A roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy
in 2050 (Article No. 52011DC112). Retrieved from http://eur-lex. europa.eu/legalcontent/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:52011DC0112
18. Flamson, T. and Barrett H. C. (2008). The encryption theory of humor: A knowledge-based
mechanism of honest signaling. Journal of Evolutionary Psychology, Vol 6, pp. 261-281.
19. Flamson, T. and Barrett H. C. (2008). The encryption theory of humor: A knowledge-based
mechanism of honest signaling. Journal of Evolutionary Psychology, Vol 6, pp. 261-281.
20. Futerra. (2005). The rules of the game: Principles of climate change communication. London,
England: Futerra.
195
Environmental education
21. Garner R. L. (2006). Humor in pedagogy: How ha-ha can lead to aha!. College Teaching, Vol
54, pp. 177-180.
22. Greenbaum A. (1999). Stand-up comedy as rhetorical argument: An investigation of comic
culture. Humor, Vol 12(1), pp. 33-46.
23. Gunderson L. (2006). Science plays come of age. The Scientist, 28 July. Available at:
http://www.the-scientist. com/?articles.view/articleNo/24219/title/Science-plays-come-of-age/
24. Hackathorn J., Garczynski A. M., Blankmeyer K., Tennial R. D. and Solomon E. D. (2011). All
kidding aside: Humor increases learning at knowledge and comprehension levels. Journal of the
Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, Vol 11, pp. 116-123.
25. Hastings G., Stead M. and Webb J. (2004). Fear appeals in social marketing: Strategic and ethical
reasons for concern. Psychology and Marketing, Vol 21, pp. 961-986.
26. Hauke R. (2015). Why did the proton cross the road? Humour and science communication. Public
Understanding of Science, Vol 24 (7), pp. 768-775.
27. Herr C. J. (2007). Satire in modern and contemporary theater. In R. Quintero (Ed.). A companion
to satire, pp. 460-475, Malden, MA: Blackwell.
28. House of Lords. (2000). Science and society: Third report. London, England: Her Majesty’s
Stationery Office.
29. Howell R. A. (2014). Investigating the Long-Term Impacts of Climate Change Communications
on Individuals’ Attitudes and Behavior. Environment and Behavior, Vol 46(1), pp. 70-101.
30. Hulme M. (2007). Newspaper scare headlines can be counter-productive. Nature, Vol 445, pp.
818.
31. HulmeM. (2008). The conquering of climate: Discourses of fear and their dissolution.
Geographical Journal, Vol 174, pp. 5-16.
32. Hurley M. M., Dennett D. C. and Adams R. B. Jr. (2011). Inside jokes: Using humor to reverseengineer the mind, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
33. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. (2007). Climate change 2007— Summary for
policymakers: Working Group II report: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability, Available
from http://www.ipcc.ch
34. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. (2007). Climate change 2007: Synthesis report.
Summary for policymakers. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
35. Joffe H. (1999). Risk and “the other.” Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
36. Kellstedt P. M., Zahran S. and Vedlitz A. (2008). Personal efficacy, the information environment,
and attitudes toward global warming and climate change in the United States. Risk Analysis, Vol
28, pp. 113-126.
37. Kloeckner C. A. (2011). Towards a psychology of climate change. In W. L. Filho (Ed.). The
economic, social and political elements of climate change, pp.153-173, Berlin, Germany:
Springer-Verlag.
38. Leemans R. and Eickhout B. (2004). Another reason for concern: Regional and global impacts on
ecosystems for different levels of climate change. Global Environmental Change, Vol 14, pp.
219-228.
39. Lewis I. M., Watson B. and White K. M. (2010). Response efficacy: The key to minimizing
rejection and maximising acceptance of emotion-based anti-speeding messages. Accident
Analysis and Prevention, Vol 42, pp. 459-467.
196
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
40. Linville P. W. and Fischer G. W. (1991). Preferences for separating and combining events: A
social application of prospect theory and the mental accounting model. Journal of Personality
and Social Psychology, Vol 60, pp. 5-23.
41. Lorenzoni I., Jones M. and Turnpenny J. (2006). Climate change, human genetics and
postnormality in the UK. Futures, Vol 39, pp. 65-82.
42. Lorenzoni I., Nicholson-Cole S. A. and Whitmarsh L. (2007). Barriers perceived to engaging with
climate change among the UK public and their policy implications. Global Environmental
Change, Vol 17, pp. 445-459.
43. Malow B. (2010). About Brian. Brian Malow: Earth’s Premier Science Comedian. Available
at: http://www. sciencecomedian.com/
44. Martin R.A. (2007). The psychology of humor: An integrative approach, Oxford: Elsevier
Academic Press.
45. McCarron K. and Savin-Baden M. (2008). Compering and comparing: Stand-up comedy and
pedagogy. Innovations in Education and Teaching International, Vol 4 (4), pp. 355-363.
46. Morton T. A., Rabinovich A., Marshall D. and Bretschneider P. (2011). The future that may (or
may not) come: How framing changes responses to uncertainty in climate change
communications. Global Environmental Change, Vol 21, pp. 103-109.
47. Moser S. C. (2007). More bad news: The risk of neglecting emotional response to climate change
information. In S. C. Moser and L. Dilling (Eds.). Creating a climate for change:
Communicating climate change and facilitating social change, pp.64-80, New York, NY:
Cambridge University Press.
48. Moser S. C. and Dilling L. (2004). Making climate hot. Environment, Vol 34, pp. 32-46.
49. Munich Re. (2004). Megacities-megarisks. London:Author.
50. Nisbet M. C. and Scheufele D. A. (2009). What’s next for science communication? Promising
directions and lingering distractions. American Journal of Botany, Vol 96, pp. 1767-1778.
51. O’Neill S. and Nicholson-Cole S. (2009). “Fear won’t do it”: Promoting positive engagement
with climate change through visual and iconic representations. Science Communication, Vol 30
(3), pp. 355-379.
52. O’Neill S. J. (2008). An iconic approach to communicating climate change. Unpublished PhD
thesis, School of Environmental Sciences, University of East Anglia, UK. Accessed 9 December
2009 from: www.cru.uea.ac.uk/~saffron
53. Ockwell D., WhitmarshL. and O’Neill S. (2009). Reorienting climate change communication for
effective mitigation: Forcing people to be green or fostering grass-roots engagement?. Science
Communication, Vol. 30, pp. 305-327.
54. Parant A., Pascual A., Jugel M., Kerroume M., Felonneau M. L. and Guéguen N. (2017). Raising
Students Awareness to Climate Change: An Illustration With Binding Communication.
Environment and Behavior, Vol 49 (3), pp. 339-353.
55. Parker M. (2013). Matt Parker. Matt Parker: Stand-up Mathematician. Available at:
http://www.standupmaths.com/
56. Peters G. J. Y., Ruiter R. A. and Kok G. (2013). Threatening communication: A critical reanalysis and a revised meta-analytic test of fear appeal theory. Health Psychology Review,
7(Suppl. 1), S8-S31.
57. Pilcher H. (2010). Communication: A better class of heckle. Nature, Vol 467, pp. 530.
197
Environmental education
58. Pinto B., MarçalD. and Vaz S. G. (2015). Communicating through humour: A project of standup comedy about science. Public Understanding of Science, Vol 24(7), pp. 776-793.
59. Poliakoff E and Webb TL (2007). What factors predict scientists’ intentions to participate in
public engagement of science activities?. Science Communication, Vol 29, pp. 242-263.
60. Pooley J. A. and O’Connor M. (2000). Environmental education and attitudes: Emotions and
beliefs are what is needed. Environment and Behavior, Vol 32, pp. 711-723.
61. Robert G., Franklin Jr., Reginald B. and Adams Jr. (2011). The reward of a good joke: neural
correlates of viewing dynamic displays of stand-up comedy. Cogn Affect BehavNeurosci, Vol
11, pp. 508-515.
62. Schultz P. W. (2002). Knowledge, information and household recycling: Examining the
knowledge deficit model of behavior change. In T. Dietz and P. Stern (Eds.). New tools for
environmental protection: Education, information, and voluntary measures, pp. 67-82,
Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
63. Schwarz J. (2010). Linguistic Aspects of Verbal Humor in Stand-up Comedy. Göttingen:
Sierke-Verlag.
64. Skanavis C., K. Antonopoulos, V. Plaka, S.P. Pollaki, E.Tsagaki-Rekleitou, G. Koresi and Ch.
Oursouzidou. (2018). Linaria Port: An Interactive Tool for Climate Change Awareness in Greece.
In Second World Symposium on Climate Change Communication. Graz, Austria.
65. Spence A. and Pidgeon N. F. (2010). Framing and communicating climate change: The effects of
distance and outcome frame manipulations. Global Environmental Change, Vol 20, pp. 656667.
66. Spicer R. N. (2011). Before and after The Daily Show: Freedom and consequences in political
satire. In T. Goodnow (Ed.). The Daily Show and rhetoric: Arguments, issues, and strategies,
pp. 19-41, Lanham, MD: Lexington.
67. Trench B. and Miller S. (2012). Policies and practices in supporting scientists’ public
communication through training. Science and Public Policy, Vol 39, pp. 722-731.
68. Weingart P., Engels A. and Pansegray P. (2000). Risks of communication: Discourses on climate
change in science, politics and the mass media. Public Understanding of Science, Vol 9, pp.
261-283.
69. Wootton M. (2005). Green Party 2005 election communication: National campaign,
Northampton, UK: Centreweb.
70. Ziv A. (1988). Teaching and learning with humor: Experiment and replication. Journal of
Experimental Education, Vol 57, pp. 5-15.
198
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
EARLY CHILDHOOD ENVIRONMENTAL CAMP IN A GREEK
PORT
G. Koresi, V. Plaka* and C. Skanavis
Research Center of Environmental Education and Communication, Dept. of Environment,
University of the Aegean, GR-81100 Mytilene, Lesvos, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: plaka@env.aegean.gr, tel: +302251036234
Abstract
In Greece, the Port of Skyros Island has established an environmental campaign in its area, which is
running for the last three years. The name of the above campaign is “SKYROS Project”. It is a
cooperative project between the University of the Aegean and the Skyros Port Fund. Since 2015,
every summer, academic students and researchers of the Research Center of Environmental Education
and Communication of the Department of the Environment of the University of the Aegean are
visiting the Island of Skyros in the spectrum of their internship requirements. The environmental
communication tasks of SKYROS Project include a variety of different environmental actions. One
of them is the Environmental Kids’ Camp, in which children 6 to 13 years old are participating in
environmental education programs. They are being educated in a specially designed area, on how to
take care, respect and protect the environment. The ultimate goal is to create environmentally active
citizens with a responsible behavior. So, the main object of this research is to create a program
complementary to the one already existing, based on environmental education guidelines for early
childhood. For the first time, this summer of 2018, the research team of SKYROS Project will attempt
to involve kids of early childhood age as well.
This program provides the opportunities for young children of locals and tourists to participate in a
variety of eco-social interactions, including playing and exploring the outdoors. Based on a quality
assessment process, this paper will present the benefits of environmental education in early childhood
in outdoors places, like a port. The extension of the environmental camp would be based on the
Guidelines for Excellence of the North American Association of Environmental Education. The
overall goal of these guidelines is to chart an appropriate and positive process whereby educators can
start young children on their journey towards becoming an environmentally responsive youth and
later on adults. Environmental education in early childhood is a holistic concept that encompasses
knowledge of the natural world strengthening this way environmental literacy for all.
Keywords: Environmental education, Environmental camp, Early childhood, Outdoor activities,
Environmental responsible behavior
1.
INTRODUCTIΟΝ
Environmental Education (EE) was born in the middle of the previous century amid a generalized
concern that was developed within the modern environmental movement (Flogaitis et al, 2005).
According to the definition, given by UNESCO (1978) at the Conference in Tbilisi, EE is the process
of shaping a global population, which should be informed, interested in the environment and its
issues, and have the knowledge, skills, attitude and will to work, alone and collectively, on solving
the current environmental issues and preventing the appearance of new ones.
199
Environmental education
The Tbilisi Declaration identified that humans and the environment were interdependent on each
other and governments should consider both the needs of the present and the needs of the future
generations in their policies. It emphasized that for significant change to happen, countries had to
engage on environmental education for people of all ages both in formal and informal settings in
order to handle the problems affecting the quality of this planet (Croft, 2017).
The main purpose of environmental education is to give every individual the opportunity to express
a positive environmental attitude and responsibility towards the environment they live (Sabo, 2010).
Environmental education is a way to reach an understanding of the relationship between humanity
and the living environment. Young children are active and inquisitive (NAAEE, 2000). The curiosity
that is a common stake of children is the way to make them interested to explore nature and learn
about life in general. Everything is worth exploration for them and all their senses are involved in the
understanding of how the environment is built. Children from early age are interested to connect with
others and experience both indoors and outdoors environments. Outdoors Environmental Education
(OEE) is one of the most successful ways to lure children towards building a solid succeeding
environmental literacy (Okur-Berberoglu et al, 2014).
1.1 Environmental education in coastal areas
To sustainably manage coastal areas and conserve coastal biodiversity, the participation of local
residents and other stakeholders is indispensable (Sakurai et al, 2017). Sustainable management of
coastal biodiversity as well as conservation of coastal and marine areas were declared as important
goals for the Aichi Targets, which all countries and stakeholders need to pursue (Sakurai et al, 2017).
Researchers in various fields have tested and explained factors that affect people's willingness to
behave in an environmentally friendly manner (Zanetell and Knuth, 2004; Sakurai et al, 2015).
Previous studies have identified that people's sense of place could affect their willingness to conserve
the coastal area (Sakurai et al, 2017). Several studies have suggested that sense of place can include
place attachment, which is the strength of the bond between a person and place. The place meaning,
is the symbolic meaning people attribute to a place (Halpenny, 2010). Although sense of place has
been discussed and acknowledged by many researchers as an important concept, affecting people's
willingness to take care of a place, conceptualizing and quantitatively identifying this framework has
been challenging (Stedman, 2002).
Environmental education is a field that aims to encourage people to adopt more sustainable lifestyles
through 1) acquiring awareness, 2) developing knowledge, 3) acquiring attitudes, 4) acquiring skills,
and 5) encouraging participation (Jacobson, 2009). One of the most important goals of environmental
education is to understand the relationship between current and future generations (specifically, the
importance of protecting the natural environment and resources for future generations), which could
be regarded as directly connected to two environmental education aims: acquiring awareness and
positive attitudes (NAAEE, 2009; Japanese Society of Environmental Education, 2012).
The importance of developing conservationist attitudes with regard to future generations can also be
explained in the context of a major environmental worldview (Sakurai et al, 2017). The stewardship
worldview assumes that we (human beings) are borrowing the earth's natural capital from future
generations, and therefore, we have an ethical responsibility to leave the earth in a healty condition
for the generations to come (Miller and Spoolman, 2015).
1.2 Environmental Education at the Port of Skyros Island: Daily Environmental Kid’s Camp
In Greece, Linaria Port of Skyros Island is famous for the innovative approaches enacted by the
specific Port Authority. Since 2015, a worldwide environmental campaign, under the brand name
“SKYROS Project”, has launched there, presenting an innovative cooperation with the University of
the Aegean and the Skyros Port Authority. University students, locals and visitors become the
decision makers for environmental issues taking in their hands environmental planning and
management of the specific port area (Skanavis et al, 2018). However, this approach in terms of
“information-deficit” has been widely criticized as being inadequate to promote behavioral change
200
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
(Ockwell et al, 2009 Skanavis & Kounani 2017). To tackle such concern, the SKYROS Project,
taking off in 2015, established at Linaria port an interactive lab which included the port as a way of
promoting environmental issues awareness through hands on experience (Skanavis et al, 2018).
Significant environmental actions that were implemented were an Environmental Kid’s Camp,
Tourist Observatory, Maritime Tourism Observatory and a Summer Academy for Environmental
Educators (Plaka et al, 2017). This project was recognized at national and international competitions
as one that excels on environmental awareness (Plaka et al, 2017 and Antonopoulos et al, 2017a).
2.
METHODOLOGY
2.1 Study Area
Skyros Island belongs to a complex of islands, which is called Sporades. The importance of this island
is considered huge not only because it is placed in the center of the Aegean Sea, but also because it
connects many destinations (Antonopoulos et al, 2017a). In Linaria, the Port Authority
Administration has adopted an environmental and sustainable agenda. Delivered at the port, a series
of innovative environmental education projects that could promote environmentally responsible
behavior for both visitors and residents (Antonopoulos et al, 2017b) proved to be a breakthrough in
the promotion of responsible environmental behaviors. This port has been distinguished as a unique
one for the whole country (Antonopoulos et al, 2015). Furthermore Linaria as a community has been
characterized as an environmentally sustainable one (Antonopoulos et al, 2016).
The last six years, this small port constantly implements interesting ideas, such as the construction of
seadromes, the use of electric scooters, the PV panels, a gas station and the cooperation of the Port
Authority of Skyros with the University of the Aegean’s Department of Environment, known as
SKYROS Project. These actions have attracted the interest and respect of travelers from around the
world (Antonopoulos et al, 2016). Environmental actions at no cost for users, gradually formed
conscious citizens at the island and encouraged visitors to become environmentally sensitive (Plaka
et al, 2017). United Nations during the Climate Change Summit of 2016, recognized the Linaria Port
as “the blue port with a shade of green” (Skanavis et al, 2018).
2.2 Planning and implementation
The Environmental Kids' Camp has been offered every summer for the last four years. The ages of
the participants range between 6-13 years old. This coming summer, pre-school children (ages 3-6)
will be welcomed. Environmental education in early childhood is a holistic concept that encompasses
knowledge of the natural world, strengthening appropriate code of ethics and promoting
environmental literacy for all.
This paper is based on a qualitative study, presenting the benefits of environmental education at early
childhood in outdoors places, like a port. Having a high quality educational program tailored to the
participants’ interests and being inspired by familiar surroundings is very important for practicing
theory in real time conditions (Skanavis et al., 2018). The objectives of the summer environmental
camp at Skyros Island were related to the dissemination of environmental education to children and
to the promotion of their responsible environmental behavior through theory and hands on experience
in an outdoors set up (Skanavis and Kounani 2017).
The environmental camp set up is based on the “Guidelines for Excellence” of the North American
Association of Environmental Education (NAAEE 2017). The main goal behind the specific
quidelines is to chart an appropriate and positive process whereby educators can start young children
on their journey towards becoming an environmentally responsive youth and later on adults.
This research focuses on the part of preschool kids environmental education through their interaction
with a port. The plan for this program is to use procedures, which will be easy to comprehend from
participating kids of very young ages (3-6 years old). An environmental awareness approach may be
best handled through interaction with nature, excursions and camps (Sabo, 2010). Early childhood
environmental educators need to create a climate in which children are motivated to learn about and
201
Environmental education
explore the environment and practice their developed skills with procedures based on a basic
understanding of the goals, theory, practice, and history of the field of environmental education
(NAAEE, 2000).
3.
THE MAGNITUDE OF ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION IN EARLY CHILDHOOD
Environmental education is becoming an increasingly important learning area in early childhood
education (Pearson & Degotardi, 2009). The approach to environmental education for early childhood
learners is less about organization of graduated achievements and more about free discovery on each
child’s own terms (NAAEE 2000). The preschoolers get their first exposure to the worldwide profile
of the environmental issues, and the destructive potential of individuals to nature (Sabo, 2010).
Wilson (2012) outlines how the early childhood years are fundamental in developing ‘’ environmental
attitudes and a commitment to caring for the Earth’’. The natural world can give children instant
responses to their curiosity through all of their senses as they touch, taste, smell, see and hear what is
going around them. Early Childhood Environmental (ECE) programs are expected to foster the
physical, mental, and social- emotional development of children, and, increasingly, to address an
array of the threats to children’s health and wellness (Cooper, 2015). In early childhood, it is
important to concentrate on building a foundation that will allow for positive examination of issues
and appropriate action later in life (NAAEE 2000). Children are the future guardians of earth. Thus,
studies on children’s environment from children’s perspective are vital because the environment
shapes children’s attitude and behavior as children and later on as adults (Mustapa et al, 2015).
3.1 The relationship between young children and nature
The task of environmental education for young children is to forge the bond between children and
nature (NAAEE, 2000). Connection to nature during childhood has a significant impact on attitude
and behavior towards nature in later life (Mustapa et al, 2015). Research by Fjortoft (2001, 2004)
found young children playing in a natural environment had a greater increase in gross motor skill
development, motor fitness, balance, and coordination than their peers in a traditional playground
setting (Ernst and Tornabene, 2012). Freeman and Tranter (2011) also categorized the experience in
nature in three types: direct, indirect and observing without contact (Mustapa et al, 2015).
Providing high-quality early childhood programs, and allowing children to follow their curiosities
about their word and what nature has to offer, can bring incredible richness to their lives (NAAEE
2000). Direct experiences in nature encourage connection and increase children’s affinity towards
nature (Mustapa et al, 2015). Children, who participated in a nature camp with and without
environmental education showed an increase in their affinity towards nature, ecological beliefs and
environmental behavior (Collado et al, 2013).
Experience in nature increases their score on eco-affinity, eco-awareness and environmental
knowledge (Larson et al, 2009). They are learning how to explore and use tools of exploration such
as magnifying glasses and pop sickle sticks (NAAEE, 2000). Moreover, time spent in nature is found
to be an indicator on environmental attitudes (Mustapa et al, 2015). Children are watching plants and
animals change through their life cycles, and learn how to respect the natural world and living things
(NAAEE, 2000). Experience in nature for prolonged time has been found to be an indicator on
positive environmental attitude resulted from the connection and the empathy feelings associated with
it (Stern et al, 2008). The interest and curiosity that young children typically show for plants, animals,
water, clouds, rocks, and other natural phenomena are the basis for environmental educators’ work
(NAAEE, 2000).
Indirect experience in nature is also associated positively to children’s affinity and environmental
attitude and behavior. Children involved in an environmental club showed positive attitudes toward
the natural environment compared to children who had not joined the club (Mcallister et al, 2012).
Children who respect the environment feel an emotional attachment to the natural world, and deeply
understand the link between themselves and nature. They will eventually become environmentally
202
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
literate citizens (NAAEE, 2000). Children with lack of experience and exposure to nature will see
themselves separated from the natural world (Mustapa et al, 2015).
3.2 The role of play
As a natural and compelling activity, play promotes cognitive, physical, social, and emotional well
being, offering the necessary conditions for children to thrive and learn (Bento and Dias, 2017). Wood
and Attfield (2005) argue: Play cannot be easily defined or categorized because it is always context
dependent, and the contexts can vary. There are many different forms of play including: role play,
imaginative play, socio-dramatic play, heuristic play, constructive play, fantasy play, free-flow play,
structured play, rough and tumble play, all of which involve a wide range of activities and behaviors
and result in varied learning and developmental outcomes (Mackenzie and Edwards, 2013).
Through play, the child can experiment, solve problems, think creatively, cooperate with others, etc.,
gaining a deeper knowledge about his/her self and the world (Bento and Dias, 2017). This way of
thinking about play has contributed on the learning and teaching approaches of environmental
education at early childhood because it allows the value of experience (including values and action)
and engagement with the sources behind the theoretical knowledge (Mackenzie and Edwards, 2013).
From an early age, the possibility to experience during the unstructured play, in which the child can
decide what to do, with whom and how, promotes positive self-esteem, autonomy, and confidence
(Bento and Dias, 2017). Children communicate with peers and develop friendship when playing in
the natural environment. They learn social skills such as manners, how to behave and interact with
peers, confidence and work ethics (Laaksoharju et al., 2012).
Play and exploration promote physical development, are soothing and reduce stress, and help to
restore attention. An enjoyable task has a tremendous potential for promoting creativity, helping
children construct an understanding of their world, and facilitates learning in many different areas
(NAAEE, 2000). Play and experience in nature, highly contributes to children’s cognitive, physical
and social development, restores positive emotion, develops sense of place, empathy and care for
nature, as well as, associates positively with environmental attitude and behavior (Mustapa et al,
2015).
3.3 Play in outdoors places
The outdoors can be described as an open and constantly changing environment, where it is possible
to experience freedom, gross and boisterous movements, and contact with natural elements (Bento
and Dias, 2017). Outdoor play provides learning opportunities for infants and toddlers that they
cannot get elsewhere (NAAEE, 2000). While playing outside, children benefit from being exposed
to sunlight, natural elements, and open air, which contributes to bones development, stronger immune
system and physical activity (Bento and Dias, 2017).
Early-learner programs provide opportunities for young children to participate in a variety of social
interactions, including play and exploration in the outdoors that allow them to grow as contributing
members of their community (NAAEE, 2000). The need to be physically active from an early age is
particularly relevant if we consider the concerning growth of children’s obesity and overweight
(Bento and Dias, 2017). Nutrition is improved since children who get engaged into grow food are
more likely to eat fruits and vegetables (Bell and Dyment, 2008). Gardens that support children’s
engagement with vegetables and fruits and increase frequency of consumption are associated with
acceptance of diverse tastes (Cabalda et al, 2011) as a positive strategy to support healthy eating
(Meinen et al 2012). Thus, it is important to understand benefits of the nature and environment on
children’s developmental needs in order to create an environment that meets the quality standards
(Mustapa et al, 2015).
Because injuries can take place in outdoor play areas, safety is a major consideration (NAAEE, 2000).
Three basic safety rules are as follows:
203
Environmental education
1. Provide soft, level surfaces with good drainage. Grass is best for toddling and crawling; wood,
mulch, or rubber mats work well under “fall zones.”
2. Eliminate possibilities for entrapment.
3. Provide watchful maintenance for items dangerous for babies to put in their mouths. Remove
items that are a choking hazard.
Through outdoor play and the exploration of natural elements, it is possible to promote education in
its broadest sense. Activities related to playing with soil and water can serve as examples of learning
opportunities in which concepts related to mathematics, science or language were promoted in an
integrated way (Bento and Dias, 2017).
3.4 Places and spaces
Early childhood environmental education programs provide places and spaces, both indoors and out,
that are safe, enticing, comfortable, and enhance learning and development across all learning
domains; and provide opportunities for development across social, emotional, physical, and cognitive
development domain. Helping children to look more closely, listening more carefully, and
understanding the natural world in rich and varied ways by providing opportunities for children to
marvel in the beauty of nature are important reasons to invest in outdoors environmental education
(NAAEE, 2000).
Today’s society often neglects the importance of risk in children’s learning agenda and developmental
approaches (Bento and Dias, 2017). The integration of natural components throughout places and
spaces is essential if learning opportunities and development are to be maximized (NAAEE, 2000).
A culture of fear lead us to underestimate what children are capable to do, creating an even more
“dangerous” learning environment, where children do not have the possibility to learn, by experience,
how to stay safe (Bento and Dias, 2017). In the outdoor environment, opportunities to exceed personal
limits often emerge in situations like climbing up a tree or using a tool (Bento and Dias, 2017).
In risky play, the adult should interpret the signs of the child, giving the necessary support or space
that he or she needs. From experts experience and relevant studies in this area, it is possible to state
that risky play promotes important skills related to persistence, entrepreneurship, self-knowledge and
problem solving. During outdoor play, children should have the opportunity to experiment moments
of failure and success, learning by trial and error. If we try to prevent all risky situations, children
will not know how to deal with unpredictable environments and will lack the necessary confidence
to overcome challenges in an autonomous way (Bento and Dias, 2017).
To develop quality outdoor practices, that can have a positive impact ion children’s health and
development, it is fundamental to promote conditions for adults to feel comfortable and motivated
during the time the children spent outside. Often educators are concerned about keeping children
together outdoors in order to keep them safe, away from streets, and to prevent them from getting lost
(NAAEE, 2000). It is important not to forget that most families just want the best for their children
and it is the job of professionals to help them achieve this goal (Bento and Dias, 2017).
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSSIONS
Environmental education often begins close to home, encouraging learners to understand and forge
connections with their immediate surroundings. The environmental awareness, knowledge, and skills
needed for this localized learning provide a foundation for moving out into larger systems, broader
issues, and a more sophisticated comprehension of causes, connections, and consequences (NAAEE,
2000). Young individuals should experience the power, fragility, interconnectedness and awe of
nature, so they can become environmental stewards of the future (Plaka and Skanavis, 2016).
Linaria is characterized as an environmentally sustainable small port community (Antonopoulos et
al, 2016). Through various case studies, research has identified that people's sense of place could play
an important role in motivating place-protective behavior (Halpenny, 2010; Tonge et al, 2014;
Sakurai et al, 2016). Environmental Education in a port which has adopted a sustainable agenda
204
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
strengthens the above mentioned feeling. The action of Environmental Camp of SKYROS Project at
the Port of Skyros Island is internationally unique (Plaka et al, 2017). The variety of free
environmental actions which are being held at this port, gradually transform participating kids to
conscious citizens (Plaka et al, 2017). In order to achieve a satisfying deepening in environmental
education, it is necessary to connect it to all three forms of education (Aposotolopoulou et al, 2016)
something that been done successfully at Linaria Port.
Most environmental education, outreach, and communication programs are designed to help people
understand their impact on future generations and how we need to take care of resources so that future
generations can use them as well (Jacobson, 2009; NAAEE, 2009; Japanese Society of Environmental
Education, 2012). However, there has not been much systematic and scientific research to understand
what actually affects people's attitudes regarding future generations (Sakurai et al, 2017). This could
be an interesting quantitative assessment project about an environmental education program at a port.
Youth must be educated, in and out the classrooms, in how to take care, respect and protect the
environment. Promoting sustainable development should be a priority in the school system’s
educational agenda. The way to reach this state of excellence is through environmental education
from an early age. Early learning programs provide children with opportunities to develop curiosity,
ask their own questions, and be able to develop reasoning and problem-solving skills (NAAEE, 2000).
Young people, by all available means, must learn to care for the planet, be familiar with nature and
be a part of an environmentally active community (Plaka and Skanavis., 2016).
Connection to nature during childhood has a significant impact on attitude and behavior towards
nature in later life (Mustapa et al, 2015). Providing high-quality early childhood programs, and
allowing children to follow their curiosities about their word and what nature has to offer, can bring
incredible richness to their lives. In early childhood, it is important to concentrate on building a
foundation that will allow for positive examination of issues and appropriate action later on in life.
Children are the future guardians of earth. Thus, studies on children’s environmental perceptions from
the children’s perspectives are vital because the environment shapes children’s attitude and behavior
(Mustapa et al, 2015). The integration with natural components throughout places and spaces is
essential if learning opportunities and development potential are to be maximized (NAAEE, 2000).
Nevertheless, the ultimate goal of Environmental Education is the development of an environmentally
literate citizenry (NAAEE, 2000). As Skanavis et al. (2005) indicate “our youth is the most precious
asset. Supporting their environmental conscious, would later on enable them to actively participate in
the environmental decision making. As children explore their environment, they begin to develop
understandings of how the world works (NAAEE, 2000). When environmentally educated young
individuals grow up, as residents they would willingly participate in a societal movement, especially
when they observe that their way of life is endangered” (Nastoulas et al, 2017).
References
1. Antonopoulos K, C. Skanavis and V. Plaka. (2015). ‘Exploiting futher potential of Linaria PortSkyros: From vision to realization’ (in Greek). In Proceedings of the First Hellenic Conference
on Tourist Port, Marinas, eds. Athens, Greece, Laboratory of Harbour Works, N.T.U.A pp. 101111.
2. Antonopoulos K., V. Plaka and C. Skanavis. (2016). ‘Linaria port, Skyros: An environmentally
friendly port community for leisure crafts’. Proc. of Int. Conf. Protection and Restoration of
the Environmental island, Greece, 2016.
3. Antonopoulos K., V. Plaka, A. Barbakonstanti, D. Dimitriadou and C. Skanavis. (2017b). ‘THE
BLUE PORT WITH A SHADE OF GREEN: The case study of Skyros Island’. Proc. Int.Conf.
Proceedings of the 7th Health and Environment, Innovation Arabia Conference, Dubai,
Unated Arab Emirates, pp. 175-187.
205
Environmental education
4. Antonopoulos K., V.Plaka and C. Skanavis. (2017a). ‘INNOVATIVE IMPLEMENTS TO
COLLECT INFORMATION: EFFECTIVENESS AND SAFETY IN LINARIA PORT,
SKYROS’. In Seventh Hellenic Conference Management and Improvement of Coastal
Zones. Athens, Greece.
5. Apostolopoulou S., G. Grigoroglou, M. Karamperis, C. Skanavis and A. Kounani. (2016).
‘Environmental Summer Camp in a Greek Island’. In Thirteenth Int. Conf. Protection and
Restoration of the Environment, Mykonos Island, Greece.
6. Bell, Anne C., and Janet E. Dyment. (2008). ‘Grounds for movement: green school grounds as
sites for promoting physical activity’. Health Educ. Res. (2008), Vol. 23(6), pp. 952-962.
7. Bento G. and G. Dias. (2017). ‘The importance of outdoor play for young children’s healthy
development’. Porto Biomedical Journal, Vol. 2(5), pp. 157-160.
8. Cabalda A., P. Rayco-Solon, J.A. Solon and F. Solon. (2011). ‘Home gardening is associated with
Filipino preschool children’s dietary diversity’. J Am Diet Assoc, Vol 111 pp.711-715.
9. Collado S., H. Staats and J. A. Corraliza. (2013). ‘Experiencing nature in children’s summer
camps: Affective, cognitive and behavioural consequences’. Journal of Environmental
Psychology, 33, pp. 37–44.
10. Cooper A. (2015). ‘Nature and Outdoor Learning Environment: The Forgotten Resource in Early
Childhood Education’. National Wildlife Federation, Vol. 3(1), pp. 85.
11. Croft A. (2017). ‘Learning the change toward education for sustainability in early childhood
education’. New Zealand Tertiary College.
12. Cutter-Mackenzie A. and S. Edwards. (2013). ‘Toward a Model of Early Chilhood Environmental
Education: Foregrounding, Developing, and Connecting Knowledge Through Play- Based
Learning’. The Journal of Environmental Education, Vol 44(3), pp. 195-213.
13. Ernst J. and L. Tornabene. (2012). ‘Preservice early childhood educators’ perceptions of outdoor
settings as learning environments’. Environmental Education Research, 18(5), pp. 643 664.
14. Fjortoft I. (2001). ‘The natural environment as a playground for children: The impact of play
activities in pre-primary school children’. Early Childhood Education Journal, Vol. 29(2), pp.
111–7.
15. Fjortoft I. (2004). ‘Landscapes as playscape: The effects of natural environments on children’s
play and motor development’. Children, Youth and Environments, Vol. 14(2), pp. 21–44.
16. Flogaitis E., M. Daskolia and E. Agelidou. (2005). ‘Kindergarten Teachers’ Conceptions of
Environmental Education’. Early Childhood Education Journal, Vol. 33(3) pp. 125-136.
17. Freeman C. and P. Tranter. (2011). ‘Children & Their Urban Environment’. Earthscan.
18. Halpenny E.A. (2010). ‘Pro-environmental behaviours and park visitors: the effect of place
attachment’. J. Environ Psychol, 30, pp. 409–421.
19. Japanese Society of Environmental Education. (2012). Environmental Education. KyoikuShuppan, Tokyo, Japan (in Japanese).
20. Laaksoharju T., E. Rappe and T. Kaivola. (2012). ‘Garden affordances for social learning, play,
and for building nature–child relationship’. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, Vol. 11(2), pp.
195–203.
21. Larson L.R., G. T. Green, and S. B. Castleberry. (2009). ‘Construction and Validation of an
Instrument to Measure Environmental Orientations in a Diverse Group of Children’.
Environment and Behavior, Vol 43(1), pp. 72–89.
206
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
22. Jacobson S.K. (2009). ‘Communication Skills for Conservation Professionals’. Island Press,
Washington, D.C.
23. Mcallister C., J. Lewis and S. Murphy. (2012). ‘The green grass grew all around: rethinking urban
natural spaces with children in mind’. Children Youth and Environments, Vol. 22, pp. 164–
193.
24. Meinen A, B. Friese and W. Wright. (2012). ‘Youth gardens increase healthy behaviors in young
children’, J Hunger Environ Nutr, Vol. 7, pp. 192-204.
25. Mille, G.T. and S.E. Spoolman. (2015). ‘Living in the Environment’. Eighteenth eds. Cengage
Leaning, Connecticut.
26. Mustapa N.D., Z. Maliki and A. Hamzah. (2015). ‘Repositioning Children’s Developmental
Needs in Space Planning: A Review of Connection to Nature’. Procedia- Social and Behavioral
Sciences, Vol. 170, pp. 330-339.
27. Nastoulas I., K. Marini and C. Skanavis ‘Middle School Students’ Environmental Literacy
Assessment in Thessaloniki Greece’ In. Proceedings of the 7th Health and Environment,
Innovation Arabia Conference pp. 198-209. Dubai, Unated Arab Emirates.
28. North American Association for Environmental Education (NAAEE). (2009). ‘Environmental
Education Materials: Guidelines for Excellence. North American Association for Environmental
Education’. Washington, DC.
29. North American Association for Environmental Education (NAAEE). (2017). ‘Professional
Development of Environmental Educators: Guidelines for Excellence’. Washington.
30. Ockwell D, WhitmarshL,O’Neill S. (2009). ‘Reorienting Climate Change Communication for
Effective Mitigation:Forcing People to be Green or Fostering Grass-Roots Engagement?’.
Science Communication, Vol. 30(3), pp. 305-327
31. Okur-Berberoglu E., Ozdilek H.G., Yalcin- Ozdilek S., Eryaman M. Y. (2014). ‘The Short Term
Effectiveness of an Outdoor Environmental Education on Environmental Awareness and
Sensitivity of In-service Teachers’. International Electronic Journal of Environmental
Education, 5 (1), 1-20.
32. Pearson E. and Degotardi S. (2009). ‘Education for sustainable development in early childhood
education: A global solution to local concerns’. International Journal of Early Childhood, 419,
pp. 97–111.
33. Plaka V., Tsagaki-Rekleitou E. and Skanavis C. (2017). ‘Creation of an environmental
educational kit: the port as an interactive tool’. In Seventh Hellenic Conference Management
and Improvement of Coastal Zones. Athens, Greece.
34. Sabo H.M. (2010). ‘Why from early environmental education’. US- China Foreign Language,
Vol. 8(12), pp. 57-61.
35. Said I. (2012). ‘Affordances of Nearby Forest and Orchard on Children ’ s Performances’.
Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, Vol. 38, pp. 195–203.
36. Sakurai R., H. Kobori, M. Nakamura and T. Kikuchi. (2016). ‘Influence of residents' social
interactions in and affections toward their community on their willingness to participate in
greening activities’. Environ. Sci. Vol. 29 (3), pp. 137–146.
37. Sakurai R., T. Ota and T. Uehara. (2017). ‘Sense of place and attitudes towards future generations
for conservation of coastal areas in the Satoumi of Japan’. Biological Conservation, Vol. 209,
pp. 332-340.
207
Environmental education
38. Sakurai, R., H. Kobori, M. Nakamura, and T. Kikuchi. (2015). ‘Factors influencing public
participation in conservation activities in urban areas: a case study in Yokohama’ Japan. Biol.
Conserv. 184, pp. 424–430.
39. Skanavis C. and A. Kounani. (2017). ‘Children Communicating on Climate Change: The Case of
a Summer Camp at a Greek Island.Leal-Filho W’, eds. Manolas E, Azul AM, Azeiteirou, Elsevier,
Amsterdam, Handbook of Climate Change Communication.
40. Skanavis C., K. Antonopoulos, V. Plaka, S.P. Pollaki, E.Tsagaki-Rekleitou, G. Koresi and Ch.
Oursouzidou. (2018). Linaria Port: An Interactive Tool for Climate Change Awareness in Greece.
In Second World Symposium on Climate Change Communication. Graz, Austria.
41. Stedman R.C. (2002). ‘Toward a social psychology of place: predicting behavior from place based
cognitions, attitude, and identity’. Environ. Behav. 23 (5), 561–581.
42. Stern M.J., R.B. Powell and N.M. Ardoin. (2008). ‘What Difference Does It Make? Assessing
Outcomes From Participation in a Residential Environmental Education Program’. The Journal
of Environmental Education, Vol. 39(4), pp. 31–43.
43. Tonge J., M.M. Ryan, S.S. Moore, L.E. Beckley. (2014), ‘The effect of place attachment on proenvironment behavioral intentions of visitors to coastal natural area tourist destinations’, J. Travel
Res. 1–14.
44. UNESCO. (1978). ‘The Tbilisi Declaration Intergovernmental Conference on Environmental
Education’. 14 - 26 October.
45. Wilson R. (2012). ‘Nature and young children: Encouraging creative play and learning in natural
environments., New York, NY: Routledge.
46. Wood E. and J. Attfield. (2005). ‘Play, learning and the early childhood curriculum 2nd ed.’.
London, UK: Sage.
208
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
IN SEARCH FOR AN ISLAND TO HOST AN ECOVILLAGE
M. Ganiaris, F. Zouridaki, V. Plaka*, C. Skanavis, K. Antonopoulos and M. Avgerinos
Research Center of Environmental Education and Communication, Dept. of Environment,
University of the Aegean, GR- 81100 Mytilene, Lesvos, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: plaka@env.aegean.gr, tel : +302251036234
Abstract
Creativity has come to be viewed as a source of competitive advantage in social life, emerging from
a set of financial and social concerns affecting daily routine in our days. This research proposes the
operation of an ecovillage, where responsible environmental behaviors will be enforced through
“creative tourism”. Researchers show that creative tourism makes available to visitors the chance to
develop their creative skills through active participation in learning experiences.
The proposed Ecovillage in Skyros Island, Greece, will be accessible to families who wish to spend
their vacation time in environmentally inspired set ups and use the opportunity to personally
contribute to environmental protection as well as expose their children to ways to actively object to
environmental issues of concern. Also, it refers to groups of people who don’t have to be physically
at work, like digital nomads, who choose as living set up an environmental awareness type of
community. Specifically this study attempts to assess all activities, educational and empirical, which
will be offered to visitors/residents of an “ecovillage”. A complete search of related literature guides
the tasks and services that would be offered to those spending their vacation time at the proposed
ecovillage. In detail the participants would be active operators of the sustainable living structure and
their needs will be based on the concepts of environmental conservation and protection in order to
minimize the consequences that affect irreversibly nature and human life. Through their daily
involvement at this chosen vacation format, environmental awareness will be accomplished in a
successful manner. For the young ones the ecovillage will hold a daily environmental camp tailored
to the needs of the participant children.
Keywords: Ecovillages, Circular economy, Creative tourism, Environmental education
1.
INTRODUCTION
Such factors as globalization of trade, accelerated environmental degradation, the rise of information
technology, and the changes that have resulted from these, have radically altered our perception of
space and place [Putnam, 2000]. The ecovillage movement is a worldwide phenomenon that has
arisen in response to the effects of the modern lifestyle on both our social and ecological
environments. The ecovillage, a term that came into common usage in the early 1990s, is a specific
form of intentional community [Global Ecovillage Network, 2002]. “An ecovillage is an intentional
or traditional community using local participatory processes to holistically integrate ecological,
economic, social, and cultural dimensions of sustainability in order to regenerate social and natural
environments”. At the core of an ecovillage lies the intention of its inhabitants to design their own
pathway into the future [GEN, 2015].
The search for a sustainable lifestyle, combined with the reduction and the solution of environmental
problems is a field of research of scientific community and an aim to be reached for governments and
209
Environmental education
societies. The adoption of responsible environmental behavior of all stakeholders (society,
individuals, organizations, governments, etc.) is one of the key solutions [Andriopoulos et al, 2017].
The ecovillage, with their principles and values, is an example of responsible environmental behavior,
a remarkable issue for scientific research. At the same time there has been an increasing sense of the
breakdown of community principles as modern life has become even more segmented. This has
resulted in feelings of isolation and disconnectedness, and further withdrawal from traditional forms
of political and social participation [Putnam, 2000].
1.1 What is an Ecovillage
Ecovillages aim at “helping our society to get closer to nature again and to develop new ways of
living together on the land in a genuinely more sustainable way” [Kovasna, 2012]. Furthermore they
are known for aspects as “ecological sustainability through such practices as generating solar energy,
raising animals, and growing their own food” [Meijering, 2012]. Theseare done through the
ecovillage promotion concept, which is seen as an innovation offering solutions to problems related
to the distribution of resources, climate change, and the social life in the region. Ecovillages are
presented as “an alternative to the individualistic, consumerist, and commoditized systems many
cities represent” [Kovasna, 2012]. Besides ecological sustainability, the communities also strive for
communal sustainability, which refers to sharing one’s life with other people and practicing a
common ideology together [Meijering, 2012].
Based on a review of literature, there are ten basic features of the Ecovillages [Kanaley, 2000; Gaia
Education, 2009; Kasper, 2008; Joseph & Bates, 2003; Sevier, 2008; Jackson, 2004; Jackson &
Svensson, 2002], which are essential for a successful ecovillage application. One of the most familiar
and straightforward ways of aligning people’s behavior with community goals is to establish rules.
Every ecovillage has a specific set of policies that govern everyday life in its premises.
Such communities have developed over time an astonishing array of internal democratic governance
systems and low impact/high quality lifestyles. They have been proven to successfully empower,
sustain and promote truly sustainable ways of living, both in rural and urban settings [GEN, 2015].
Together, they aim to build a world living within its own means, and a world at peace with itself.They
know that innovation, creativity and the wise use of modern technology and resources, when
combined with traditional heritage and wisdom, can massively contribute to addressing global issues
of poverty and environmental destruction [GEN, 2015].
Some of the most important aspects of ecovillage planning involve identifying zones for agriculture,
commerce, and high and low density building clusters [Kasper, 2008]. Clustering buildings (including
workspaces, residences, and community buildings) is a way to minimize a community’s physical
footprint, while maximizing privacy, opportunities for work, and social interaction. The human home,
however, remains an important aspect of the physical environment, and one in which prospective
residents and people curious about ecovillages seem to be most interested. One of the most striking
features among all of the communities is the architectural diversity. The latter approach to
construction focuses on minimizing site disturbance and waste, while maximizing energy efficiency.
Characterized by their uses of high tech insulation, wall building techniques, window glass, and
heating and cooling systems, “green homes” tend to resemble more conventional residences.
Ecovillages are also thoughtfully organized to promote social interaction, another important means
of reinforcing an alternative way of thinking [Kasper, 2008].
In a recent review of ecotourism research, Weaver and Lawton [2007] maintain that ecotourism
satisfies three “core criteria” namely, (1) attractions should be predominantly nature-based, (2) visitor
interactions with those attractions should be focused on learning or education, and (3) experience and
product management should follow principles and practices associated with ecological, socio-cultural
and economic sustainability. In a similar fashion, Donohue and Needham [2006] identify six “key
tenets” of ecotourism: (1) nature-based, (2) preservation/ conservation, (3) education, (4)
sustainability, (5) distribution of benefits and (6) ethics/responsibility/awareness.
210
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Opportunities for visitor participation in habitat restoration and other environmental conservation
activities are also important [Walter, 2009]. Members of Global Ecovillage Network (GEN) have
recently coined the phrase, “ecovillage tourism” to denote “a new type of green travel, whereby
people visit ecological communities around the world to experience low-impact living and
community”. GEN has formally designated some sites devoted to these activities as “living and
learning centers” [GEN, 2015].
According to Kasper [2008] and Zeppel [2006], the principles that should govern Ecovillage based
tourism are mainly characterized with the following features:
They are sustainable settlements that integrate the tourism services into the activities necessary to
reachtheir main goals.
The agricultural activities are necessarily environmentally friendly.
The tourism activities are considered to be an economic option to provide financial support and
employment facilities for the villagers.
Tourists can pay a certain accommodation fee, or contribute to the villagers by means of physical
participation in the village works to substitute the accommodation fee.
They can offer the customers with the accommodation, meal-drink and bed facilities as well as
introduction and practical application of production activities, civil and garden works, harvesting,
traditional handicrafts, preparation of specific regional foods, animal care and similar Ecovillage
activities.
Furthermore, if the idea of well-being is to be introduced as the overarching objective in society, the
more open-minded next generation of adults would be the easiest segment of the population to start
with [Grinde, 2009]. As children gather together at kindergartens, schools and youth clubs, promoting
a focus on well-being this may not just be beneficial to achieving a higher level of well-being, but
also socio-economically efficient in reducing social costs and the economic waste of creating
maladjusted citizens. Thus, caring for the development of children’s emotional wellbeing is an
important cross-cutting issue for any national wellbeing strategy [Grinde,2009]. Children’s contact
with their parents in workplaces is more frequent than what can be expected in urban environments.
Ecovillages, many times with car-free environments, encourage smaller children to move freely
around in the settlement, from home to workplaces and other social venues.
1.2 Circular Economy and Ecovillages
It is in this context,that a new approach to sustainability, the ‘Circular Economy’, is being examined.
This economy is emerging as a possible strategy, that companies of all sizes might adopt in order to
deal with the environmental challenges. However, as the circular economy concept is relatively new
in its conceptualization and implementation, there may also be tensions and limitations inherent in its
appropriation and application [Murray et al, 2015]. Greyson [2007] claims that Kenneth Boulding
[1966] was the originator of the term when he wrote: “man must find his place in a cyclical ecological
system which is capable of continuous reproduction of material form even though it cannot escape
having inputs of energy”. More recently, Mathews and Tan [2011] suggested that “the goal of the
eco-initiatives is to eventually establish a so-called circular economy, or what is otherwise known as
a ‘closed-loop’ economy”, while Yang and Feng [2008] called the Circular Economy an
“abbreviation of Closed Materials Cycle Economy or Resources Circulated Economy”.
The term linear economy was brought into popular use by those writing on the Circular Economy and
related concepts [Murray et al, 2015]. The word circular has a second, inferred, descriptive meaning,
which relates to the concept of the cycle. There are two cycles of particular importance here: the
biogeochemical cycles and the idea of recycling of products. Recycling has been a significant part of
sustainable practice for many years, and it is fundamental to the Circular Economy. The circular
economy is ultimately linked to resource cycling. These ideas are further developed in industrial
symbiosis, where firms use each other’s waste as resources, and in the service economy, where work
211
Environmental education
is done to slow down cycles of use, in order to delay waste output. The model character of the planned
village consists of the comprehensive attempt to integrate all spheres of life (home life, work,
provision, free time) as part of an ecological circular economy.
The Circular Economy represents the most recent attempt to conceptualize the integration of
economic activity and environmental wellbeing in a sustainable way. These include an absence of the
social dimension inherent in sustainable development that limits its ethical dimensions, and some
unintended consequences. This leads us to propose a revised definition of the Circular Economy as
“an economic model wherein planning, resourcing, procurement, production and reprocessing are
designed and managed, as both process and output, to maximize ecosystem functioning and human
well-being” [Murray et al, 2015].
1.3 Creative Tourism and Ecovillage
At the same time, creativity has been seen as a source of competitive advantage in social life, evolving
from a series of economic and social problems that affect daily routine nowadays. The cyclical
economy, a necessary perception, comes to revitalize creativity by promoting new environmental
actions. Researchers have been shown that creative tourism is “tourism which offers visitors the
opportunity to develop their creative potential through active participation in learning experiences
which are characteristic of the holiday destination where they are undertaken” [Richards & Raymond,
2000].
Lifestyle travel is a phenomenon that illustrates a de-differentiation of everyday life and tourist
experiences, a process that Uriely [2005] identifies as characteristic of tourism in late modernity. In
this consideration local people may become more environmentally aware because of their
participation in ecotourism in the connection with the activities of visitors. Ecotourism guides also
teach visitors about local plants, wildlife, forest, history and cultural attractions [Uriely, 2005].
Tourism brings together very diverse people and nationalities that influence the process of cultural
development in a destination. This brings new ideas that combined with innovation can become a
unique asset to the destination [OECD, 2014].
2.
PROPOSING ACASE STUDY OF AN ECOVILLAGE
Without any doubt the road to sustainable development goes through environmental protection and
sustainable management of local natural resources [Andriopoulos et al, 2017]. The aim of this
research is to propose a geographical location to establish an ecovillage, in which all the principles
of an ecovillage will be established while adhering to the concepts of circular economy and creative
tourism. The proposed location in a Greek island, Skyros Island, with environmental infrastructures
and influences, where our research center has set up a satellite unit.
2.1 Choosing the Right Location
In Greece there are more than 2.500 islands, of which only 227 are inhabited [European Union, 2015].
In the heart of the Aegean Sea, Skyros Island is unique about its environmental characteristics.The
island of Skyros has been chosen as a study area, due to its remarkable characteristics [Andriopoulos
et al., 2017].This proposed Ecovillage Project at Skyros Island will be assessed. This project will be
based on preset criteria and principles. The visitors will be accommodated in tents, in a specially
designed area in Acherounes Village (Figure 1). The locals who until a few years ago lived in perfect
harmony with the natural environment, can provide a great baseline, while at the same time they have
the opportunity to find new pathways towards sustainable development, preserving this way the
unique natural environment of the island [Andriopoulos et al, 2017]. So, the Skyros Ecovillage Project
proposes the operation of an ecovillage where responsible environmental behavior will be imposed
through "creative tourism". In other words, these two concepts, creative tourism and the circular
economy in the context of ecovillage are the ones this research aims to incorporate.
212
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: Skyros Island: Linaria Port and Location of Ecovillage Project (Source: Google
maps)
Skyros Island (Figure 1) has well defined hiking paths and is known for a unique wildlife sanctuary.
At its Port, named Linaria, the well-known “SKYROS Project” is involved with various
environmental actions. The island’s morphology and biodiversity have raised interest from the
scientific community. The Hellenic Ornithological Society organizes actions for the protection of rare
birds on the island and many Universities have been coming to Skyros to perform specific ecological
research. In 2015, the University of the Aegean initiated the collaboration with the Skyros Port
Authorityon running an environmental campaign under the brand name “SKYROS Project”.
The Authority of Linaria Port has implemented a new sustainable agenda, since 2010. In a short time
the port of Skyros, Linaria Port, has succeeded to attract tremendous publicity and has been recorded
as the fuller and friendliest public port of Greece [Antonopoulos et al., 2015], with the arrivals
reaching an increase of 975%. Linaria Port serves as an interactive lab. University students, locals
and visitorsare trainedtobecome the decision makers for environmental issues taking initiatives on
environmental planning and management of the specific port area. This state of art educational
approach has secured the success of SKYROS Project [Antonopoulos et al. 2017a]. The above Project
is a paradigmatic cooperation of two public sectors, the Research Center of Environmental
Communication and Education of the Department of Environment of University of the Aegean with
the Skyros Port Authority. The enthusiastic students through their daily environmental investment in
the area led the way to a permanently established remote training site that invests into environmental
research and education practices [Antonopoulos et al, 2017b]. Worthwhile accomplishments include
the establishment of the tourism observatory anda marine one, both located at Linaria Port of Skyros
Island. Also a free of charge kids’ camp was established at the same port.
2.2 Design the Appropriate Environmental Activities
Without any doubt the road to sustainable development goes through environmental protection and
sustainable management of local natural resources. Skyros Island due to its unique environmental
213
Environmental education
characteristics is considered to be the ideal place for such activities, in which families will be come
together.
Skyros is one of the richest Islands in biodiversity of Aegean Sea with special ecological importance.
Especially the southern part of the island, Mount Kohilas, the surrounding islands and the remaining
wetlands of the island are important regions for birds especially migratory while have been recorded
important species of bats in the area. Also, the island is the natural habitat of "Equuscaballus
skyriano". It's an old breed of semi-savage horses, with roots in the Classic period, or even the
Prehistoric period, the origin of which can be lost in the depths of the Geological centuries. The
unique, world-wide, small horse of the breed of Equus caballus lives in the natural environment of
Skyros, in the area of the "Mountain" which is in the south-east part of the island [Andriopoulos et
al., 2017]. There are farms, where the visitors are able to work in and care or feed these endangered
species.
The southern part of Skyros is a unique area of biodiversity observation for the visitors. There are
safety pathways, where families will be able to walk in the area around Mount Kohilas (the highest
mountain on the island with 792m altitude), which is included in the European Natura 2000 network
and where the Bantam breed Skyros horse (race Equus caballus), one of the rare breeds horses in the
world, is living today. In this area there are many kinds of rare and endemic plants, some of which
have been included in the Red Book of Rare and Threatened Species of Greek Flora. In the same area
there are maple clusters, an important habitat for local biodiversity unique in the Aegean region,
especially for birds that nest and shelter there. In the Island, is also living a native kind of lizard, while
the Mediterranean seal Monachus monachus is frequently found in caves of the island. Finally, there
are several important species of flora and a significant number of endemic and endangered plant
species [Andiopoulos et al., 2017].
The accommodation, in Acherounes Village will be provided by the SKYROS Project. There, while
the kids staying in will participate in environmental actions designed for the young ones, the adults
will be involved is a variety of environmental activities.These will include but not limited to getting
their hands dirty in collecting trash, growing organic food, recycling and reusing materials and the
conservation of energy. Skyros Ecovillage Project would provide a shining example of sustainable
development approach.
This Ecovillage Project attempts to assess all activities, educational and empirical, which will be
offered to visitors/residents at Skyros Island. A complete search of related literature guides the tasks
and services that would be offered to those spending their vacation time at the proposed ecovillage.
In detail the participants would be active operators of the sustainable living structure and their needs
will be based on the concepts of environmental conservation and protection in order to minimize the
consequences that affect irreversibly nature and human life. Through their daily involvement at this
chosen vacation format, environmental awareness will be accomplished in a successful manner.
Outdoor environments can enhance mental health of participating students, contribute to students’
intellectual and emotional development, support their environmental awareness and can give them
opportunities to play and get involved in creative activities as well as connect directly with nature
[Plaka & Skanavis, 2016]. Children who participated in Ecovillage Project have the opportunity to
join in Daily Environmental Camp in Linaria port, an action of Skyros Project. Since 2015, the
Environmental Camp for children offers to the local community’s children and the visitors a high
quality educational program tailored to the participants’ interests, being inspired by the familiar port
surrounding. The objectives of the summer environmental camp at Skyros Island are focusing on the
dissemination of environmental education to children and to the promotion of their responsible
environmental behavior through practicing theory in real time conditions and hands on experience in
an outdoors set up [Skanavis & Kounani 2017]. A research group of SKYROS Project, specifically
handling educational approaches for the young, has created this well-prepared educational program
[Skanavis et al., 2018], based on the North American Association for Environmental Educators’
214
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
(NAAEE) Guidelines for Excellence [NAAEE, 2017] and the basic principles of Environmental
Education [UNESCO, 1978].
A characteristic day for the adults (Table 1) and for the children (Table 2) at the ecovillage includes:
Table 1: A characteristic day for the adults at the ecovillage
08.00 – 10.00 Daily workout and hiking in NATURA area, Daily workout and farming.
10.00 – 13.00
Participation in Summer Academy of Environmental Educators, in which they
will educate to communicate the environmental protection message.
13.00 – 15.00
Break for lunch with organic food.
15.00 – 19.00
Training seminar for cleaner beaches, participation in environmentally friendly
sea sports like scuba diving in beaches of Skyros Island, seminars on cultivation
organic food, biodiversity observation.
19.00 – 20.00
Break for diner with organic food.
20.00 – 22.30
Outdoors cinema (environmental films and documentaries), outdoor mental
activities
08.00 – 10.00
3.
Table 2: A characteristic day for the children at the ecovillage
Daily workout and hiking in NATURA area, Daily workout and farming.
10.00 – 13.00
Participation in Daily Environmental Camp of Skyros Port, in which they will
educated to communicate the environmental protection message and will be
environmental active future citizens. Topics: Biodiversity Conservation,
Climate Change, Sea Pollution, Clean Water, etc.
13.00 – 15.00
Break for lunch with organic food.
15.00 – 19.00
Training seminar for cleaner beaches, participation in environmentally friendly
sea sports like scuba diving in beaches of Skyros Island, seminars on cultivation
organic food, biodiversity observation.
19.00 – 20.00
Break for diner with organic food.
20.00 – 22.30
Outdoors cinema (environmental films and documentaries), outdoor mental
activities
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
The Skyros Ecovillage Project is a proposal for establishing a vacationing site for those interested to
actively participate in the environmental protection and sustainable living. This Project will be an
action of Skyros Project, of Skyros Port Fund and University of the Aegean, as a prerequisite to be
part of an economic funding. Then, this Ecovillage Project will serve as a meeting point for local
families, members of scientific groups andvisitors of the island interested in getting involved in
environmental protection activities in real time conditions. The local community, which until a few
years ago lived in perfect harmony with the natural environment, can provide in a great impulse in
the preservation of the uniqueness of the natural environment of Skyros Island [Andriopoulos et al,
2017].
In a holistic approach, families who experience the ecovillage lifestyle will be communicating this
experience to others who are in search for a new sustainable way of living. Contemporary tourists are
more in demand of selecting their holiday destinations and activities. Therefore, “destinations are
increasingly facing a challenge to develop new ― place/product combinations which are competitive,
unique and attractive for special interest or niche markets that want specific products and
215
Environmental education
environmental experiences” [Fernandes, 2011]. This is especially important for small and distant
destinations with poor tourism resources, because when applying creative thinking, an interesting
tourism product can be developed in any environment [OECD, 2014].
The adoption of responsible environmental behavior of all stakeholders (individuals, organizations
etc.) is one of the key solutions for all modern societies and governments. The ecovillages with their
principles and values are examples of responsible environmental behavior, a remarkable issue for
scientific research. The philosophy behind the understanding of life and society, through the four
dimensions (social, ecological, spiritual, economic) which are basic principles-values of ecovillages,
can form the fundamental core of responsible environmental behavior as a response to environmental
problems and distortions of local communities [Andriopoulos et al, 2017].
The successful relationship with nature is not just a pleasant task, but it is an essential component of
the human wellbeing general goal [Plaka & Skanavis, 2016]. It is of paramount importance to
understand children’s perspectives, since the young ones both now and in the future will influence
and be influenced by environmental issues in many ways [Skanavis & Manolas, 2015]. The concept
is to begin at early childhood, the environmental awareness. We are suiting for a more open-minded
generation of adults, who by participating in this Project, would useit as a tool to connecting people
and also kids to a common vision. This is a way to promote a new sustainable lifestyle.
References
1. Putnam, R. D. (2000). Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community.
2. Global Ecovillage Network. (2002). http://gaia.org/ (accessed January 10th, 2018).
3. Global Ecovillage Network (GEN). (2015). GEN Ecovillage Transition Strategy 2015-2020
https://ecovillage.org/(accessed January 7th, 2018).
4. Andriopoulos C., E. Avgerinos, and C. Skanavis. (2017). Is an Ecovillage Type of Living
Arrangement a Promising Pathway to Responsible Environmental Behavior?
5. Kovasna, A. (2012). ‘Collaborative Research: Examples and Lessons from a Baltic Sea
Project’,eds. M.Andreas and F.Wagner, Munich, Germany, 2012.
6. Meijering, L., (2012). ‘Ideals and Practices of European Ecovillages’, eds. M.Andreas and
F.Wagner, Munich, Germany, 2012.
7. Kanaley, D. (2000). Ecovillages; A Sustainable Lifestyle, A Report For Byron Shire Council,
Australia, Mullumbimby.
8. Gaia Education. (2009). Ecovillage Design Education Curriculum, Scotland, Findhorn,
http://gaia.org/global-ecovillage-network/ecovillage/
9. Kasper, D. V. S. (2008). “Redefining Community in the Ecovillage”, Human Ecology Review,
Vol. 15, No. 1, pp.12-24.
10. Joseph, L. and Bates, A. (2003). “What is an Ecovillage”, Communities Magazine, Issue 117,
pp. 1-3.
11. Sevier, L. (2008). “Ecovillages: A Model Life”, Ecologist, May 2008, pp. 36-41.
12. Jackson, R. (2004). “The Ecovillage Movement”, Permaculture Magazine, No. 40, pp. 25-30.
13. Jackson, H. and Svensson, K. (2002). Ecovillage Living: Restoring the Earth and Her People,
UK, Devon.
14. Weaver D. B. and Lawton, L. J. (2007). Progress in tourism management. Twenty years on: the
state of contemporary ecotourism research. Tourism Management, 28,1168e1179.
216
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
15. Walter, P. (2009). Local knowledge and adult learning in environmental adult education:
community-based ecotourism in southern Thailand. International Journal of Lifelong
Education, 28(4), 513e532.
16. Zeppel, H. (2006). Indigenous Ecoturism: Sustainable Development and Management,
Trowbridge.
17. Grinde, B. (2009). An evolutionary perspective on the importance of community relations for
quality of life. The Scientific World Journal, 9, 588–605.
18. Murray, A., K. Skene, K. Haynes (2015), The Circular Economy: An Interdisciplinary
Exploration of the Concept and Application in a Global Context.
19. Greyson, J. (2007). An economic instrument for zero waste, economic growth and sustainability.
Journal of Cleaner Production, 15(13– 14), 1382–1390. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2006.07.019.
20. Mathews, J. A., & Tan, H. (2011). Progress towards a circular economy in China: The drivers
(and inhibitors) of eco-industrial initiative. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 15, 435–457.
21. Yang, S. and Feng, N. (2008). A case study of industrial symbiosis: Nanning Sugar Co., Ltd. in
China. Resources. Conservation and Recycling, 52, 813–820.
22. Richards, G. and C.Raymond (2000) “Creative tourism”. ATLAS NEWS, 23, 16-20.
23. Uriely N. (2005). “Theories of Modern and Postmodern Tourism”, Annals of Tourism
Research, 24 (1997), pp. 982-984.
24. OECD, 2014. “Tourism and the Creative Economy” OECD Studies on Tourism, OECD
Publishing, 2014, http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264207875-en
25. European Union. 2015. European countries - Greece. http://europa.eu/abouteu/countries/member-countries/greece/index_el.htm(accessed August 1st, 2015).
26. Antonopoulos K, C. Skanavisand V. Plaka. (2015). ‘Exploiting futher potential of Linaria PortSkyros: From vision to realization’ (in greek) In. Proceedings of the First Hellenic Conference
on Tourist Port, Marinas, eds. Athens, Greece, Laboratory of HarbourWorks, N.T.U.A pp. 101111.
27. Antonopoulos K., V. Plaka, A .Barbakonstanti, D. Dimitriadou and C. Skanavis. (2017a). ‘THE
BLUE PORT WITH A SHADE OF GREEN: The case study of Skyros Island’, Proc. Int.Conf.
Proceedings of the 7th Health and Environment, Innovation Arabia Conference, pp. 175187. Dubai, United Arab Emirates.
28. Antonopoulos K., Margariti A, Marini K, Skanavis C. (2017b). The case of the port of LinariaSkyros, Greece: the human factor as the main dimension of impression and other findings in the
GUESTBOOK tourists’ evaluation. Journal of Psychology Research (in submission process).
29. Plaka V. and Skanavis C. (2016). The feasibility of school gardens as an educational approach in
Greece: a survey of Greek schools. International Journal of Innovation and Sustainable
Development 10(2):141-159.
30. Boulding K. (1966). The Economics of the Coming Spaceship Earth. Jarett H. (ed), MD:
Resources for the Future/ Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, Environmental Quality
in a Growing Economy.
31. Skanavis C. and Kounani A. (2017). Children Communicating on Climate Change: The Case of
a Summer Camp at a Greek Island. Leal-Filho W, Manolas E, Azul AM, Azeiteiro U (ed) Elsevier,
Amsterdam, Handbook of Climate Change Communication (In Press)
32. Skanavis C., Antonopoulos K., Plaka V., Pollaki S.P., Tsagaki-Rekleitou E., Koresi G. and
Oursouzidou Ch. (2018). Linaria Port: An Interactive Tool for Climate Change Awareness in
Greece. In Second World Symposium on Climate Change Communication. Graz, Austria.
217
Environmental education
33. North American Association for Environmental Education (NAAEE). (2017). Professional
Development of Environmental Educators: Guidelines for Excellence, Washington.
34. UNESCO. (1977). Final Report: Intergovernmental Conference on Environmental Education.
UNEP: Tbilisi.
35. Fernandes, C. (2011). “Cultural planning and creative tourism in an emerging tourist destination”,
International Journal of Management Cases, 13, no. 3 (2011): 630.
36. Skanavis C. and Manolas E. (2015). School Gardens and Ecovillages: Innovative Civic Ecology
Educational Approaches at Schools and Universities. Transformative Approaches to Sustainable
Development at Universities. World Sustainability Series, Springer International Publishing
Switzerland doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-08837-2_37.
218
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
AUGMENTED REALITY PROVES TO BE A BREAKTHROUGH
IN ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION
P. Theodorou*, P. Kydonakis, M. Botzori and C. Skanavis
Research Center of Environmental Communication and Education, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: ptheod@env.aegean.gr
Abstract
This paper deals with the implementation of augmented reality technology as a means of
communicating environmental issues and boosting environmental education for 241 school students
in the 4th, 5th, 6th classes of two primary schools in Athens, during the course of Computer Science.
Specifically, an early version of two augmented reality applications for android mobile devices were
designed and deployed. Two activities combining this technology were designed in order to address
environmental learning goals concerning climate change concepts and fundamental aid in the
understanding of renewable energy resources. The study assessed whether the students liked the
applications and the rate of knowledge change, driven by pre-post questionnaires, which were given
both at the start and at the end of the implementation. The results showed that the implementation of
Augmented Reality applications for environmental educational concepts have a significant
supplemental learning effect as a mobile-assisted learning tool. Finally, the paper concludes with
future guidelines in the field of other environmental issues of great importance.
Keywords: augmented reality; environmental education; mobile education; climate change;
renewable energy sources
1.
INTRODUCTION
Today, we increasingly live between the analogue and the digital, the physical and the virtual world.
The emerging digital systems offer new dimensions and innovative ways to challenge the
transformation of experiences and the creation of new opportunities for interactivity.
Many emerging technologies have been explored and proposed in an effort to optimise teaching
methods and enhance learning experience. Augmented Reality is a relatively new technology
promising a great tool for communicating concepts and ideas about environmental issues. Although
AR applications for education have been implemented, their impact on learning is just beginning to
be explored (Medicherla et al, 2010).
2.
BACKGROUND - LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Environment / Environmental communication
Εnvironmental communication has many branches and has become an increasingly important area of
study (Alison, 2015). Both citizens, corporations and civil servants, journalists and environmental
groups are seeking to influence decisions that have a direct impact on the planet. (Cox, 2012).
With the development of environmental studies, educational and professional opportunities, which
recall the role of human communication and the affairs in environmental issues, have been created
(Pedelty, 2015).
219
Environmental education
Steve Depoe (1997), argued that environmental communication is the combination of "relationships
between our speech and our experiences from our natural environment".
Environmental communication is of great importance to environmental issues as it is "a pragmatic
and structured way to understand the environment and our relationship to the natural world" (Cox
and Pezzullo, 2015). Essentially, environmental communication is much more than the discussion of
the different social, cultural, political, economic, and linguistic settings of the environment, but it is
the deep understanding of the environment as well as the building of strong relationships with the
natural world, which is the focus of environmental science (Platonova, 2016).
2.1.1 Climate change education
Teachers, considering the complex nature of climate change education, are required to simplify the
complexity that lies at the science core in order to provide a more reachable way. In addition, it should
be ensured that the simplifications remain faithful to the science, while not overwhelming the students
(Oversby, 2015).
2.1.2 Energy - Communication
Τhe advent of several new approaches that are emerging in the field of renewable energy education
and communication are due to the globally recognized need for education and training in this field
(Kandapal et al, 2014; Jennings, 2009). Τhe creation of responsible energy consumers in the future
will contribute to the promotion of environmental awareness (Liarakou et al., 2009). Education may
be an important factor in the instillation of the youth and in the empowerment of their morality in
order to understand and solve energy-related environmental problems (Jennings et al, 2001). For the
acquisition of knowledge and the formation of basic values except for school and family, media and
technology are the most important influences today (Halder et al, 2011).
2.2 Augmented reality
Augmented Reality can be defined as something that combines real and virtual objects in the same
space. It is also interactive in real-time and it is registered in three-dimensions (Azuma, 1997).
Computer interfaces can be represented as a continuum between real and virtual environment
(Milgram et al, 1994). Starting from left to right and moving away from reality, there is an increase
in virtual content (Figure 1). Augmented Reality can be seen as a "mixed reality" state in which
computer-generated content is laid on top of the real world to augment the world with additional
information.
Figure 1. Reality-Virtuality Continuum (Milgram et al, 1994)
Virtual objects used in Augmented Reality can be any computer-generated data like text, images,
video, audio, 2-dimensional or 3-dimensional models and animations. Unlike Virtual Reality, AR
supplements reality rather than replaces it (Bower et. al, 2013).
2.3 Mobile augmented reality
Over the last decade, technology has massively evolved. While the main concept of AR has not
changed, the ways in which it can be accessed have been advanced. In recent years, Augmented
220
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Reality applications tend to run on mobile or wearable devices. A Smartphone consists of all hardware
requirements of augmented reality. This means that the hardware required to implement an AR
application is wearable (Craig, 2013).
The technological demands for a mobile AR application consist of the following characteristics: the
input, either a camera or sensors such as gyroscope or accelerometer, the processing, to specify the
type of information that is going to be displayed in the screen and the display, either a monitor, a
handheld device, eyeglass or Head Mounted Displays (HMD) (Chatzopoulos et al, 2017).
2.4 Augmented reality types (How it works)
Munnerley et al (2012), refer to two main types of mobile AR applications: artefact-based (or markerbased) and geolocated (or location-based).
Artefact-based AR is based on image recognition. Virtual objects are assigned to identify visual
markers or objects, such as QR codes or bar codes (Figure 2). Though, recent technological advances
have enabled the use of any kind of image within the AR technology (FitzGerald et al, 2013).
Additionally, the markers can be located by the device camera. Once a marker is detected, the
application displays a three-dimensional model, animation or video on the screen. The orientation of
the AR object depends on the position of the marker. When you are moving the marker, the displayed
model or animation is transformed accordingly. This technique allows the use of virtual objects, such
as 3D models and other media displayed together with real world scenery (Figure 3) (Otilia Pasareti
et al, 2011).
Figure 2. AR Marker (QR code)
Figure 3. Marker-based AR Application
Geolocated AR don’t need markers, instead, they use Global Positioning Systems (GPS) and other
position detectors (digital compass, velocity meter, or accelerometer), which are integrated in the
mobile device. They are usually used for displaying directions, locating nearby businesses, and other
mobile navigation applications (FitzGerald et al, 2013).
2.5 Augmented Reality in education
Several researchers (eg Billinghurst & Duenser, 2012; Johnson, Adams & Cummins, 2012; Chen &
Tsai, 2012; Dede, 2009; Dunleavy, Dede, & Mitchell, 2009; Squire & Jan, 2007; Squire & Klopfer,
2007; Kaufmann & Schmalstieg, 2003; Shelton, 2002) argued that AR technology in education could
be identified as the most exciting and interesting teaching method. This technology has been used in
many lessons, some of which are mathematics in geometric courses, 3D imaging of cells in biology
221
Environmental education
(Fugger et al) and molecular structure exhibiting in chemistry (Asai, 2005). In that way each issue
has the potential to include more color and be more interactive for participants (Pasareti et al, 2011).
AR allows students to challenge the limitations they have enables students to access inaccessible
positions by giving them the possibility to have a different viewpoint. AR combines both pedagogical
and technological additions to teaching and learning (FitzGerald et al, 2013).
AR has more advantages compared to the traditional teaching methods. One of these advantages is
that it activates many senses such as touch, hearing, and vision at the same time. In this way, students
have an active participation in learning and teaching (Kaufmann, 2003).
Additionally, AR allows access to learning content in three-dimensional perspectives. 3D offers the
possibility of ubiquitous learning and makes learners more cooperative. It gives users a sense of
presence and immediacy with the object of exploration. It does something that is invisible to be visible
(Wu et al, 2013).
More recently, researchers (Azuma et al, 2011; Martin et al, 2011) have turned their attention to the
AR applications on mobile devices such as mobile phones (Lin et al, 2013). According to the Horizon
2013 report (Johnson et al, 2013), in iTunes, educational mobile applications (including Enhanced
Reality) targeting children was the second popular category of entertainment and business
applications (Shuler et al, 2012).
This combination of a mobile device and an application allows to digital objects to superimposed
within real-world environments and bridges contexts for formal and informal learning (Wu et al,
2013). Τhe concern about AR is that learning may not be driven by pedagogy but most of the
advantages and weaknesses of AR tools (FitzGerald et al, 2013).
3.
METHODOLOGY
3.1 Sample
The study was conducted in two primary schools of Athens city in Greece, during the course of
Computer Science. Both selected schools had a medium socio-economic background. Τhese schools
were chosen because one of the researchers worked there as a teacher at the same period, so the access
was easier. This study involved in total 241 students in the 4th, 5th, 6th classes, including 122
(50.6%) girls and 119 (49.4%) boys. In the 4th grade females were 51.9% and males 48.1%. In the 5th
grade, the sample consisted of 45.8% females and 54.2% males. Finally, in the 6th grade the sample
consisted of 54.5% females and 45.5% males. The students were in the age group of 9 to 12 years of
age.
Figure 4. Gender of 4th, 5th and 6th grade
3.2 Questionnaires
The particular implementation lasted two teaching hours depending on the level of the class and/or
the perceived attention that students showed during the elaboration of the implementation. The role
222
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
of the teacher was directive and accommodative. Specifically, a pre test questionnaire was given to
the students to examine their former knowledge on climate change and renewable energy sources.
This pre-test consisted of thirteen multiple choice text-based questions, as it can be seen in the
following table, where nine of them were concerned environmental topics and four of them are related
to their experience with AR application. Afterwards, the same questionnaire was given for the second
time. Moreover, the results were not announced to the students, unless they requested their evaluation.
The statistical analysis is conducted with the tool of Excel 2016 of Microsoft Office.
Table 1: Questionnaires
No:
Questions:
Answers:
1
Do you think that the average temperature of the earth has increased?
❏ Yes
❏ Nο
2
Do levels of sea-level rise because of the overheated Land?
❏ Yes
❏ Nο
3
Τhe more trees we have, the more oxygen and less carbon dioxide (CO2) is
produced.
❏ Correct
❏ Wrong
4
Recycling helps in the reduction of carbon dioxide (CO2).
❏ Very
❏ Little
❏ No
5
Do human activities affect the rates of carbon dioxide (CO2) in the
atmosphere?
❏ Very
❏ Little
❏ Not
6
Can LED lamps help in the conserving of energy?
❏ Yes
❏ Nο
7
Geothermal energy comes from a renewable energy source.
❏ Correct
❏ Wrong
8
Wind power converts the energy to electricity.
❏ Correct
❏ Wrong
9
What are the main fossil fuels that are used to produce energy?
(You can select MORE THAN ONE answer)
❏ Carbon
❏ Gas
❏ Diesel
fuel
❏ Water
10
Did you like the application?
❏ Yes
❏ Nο
11
Do you think that the application has helped you implement to understand better the
environmental issues?
❏ Yes
❏ Nο
12
Do you think that the audio narrative makes is more interesting?
❏ Yes
❏ Nο
13
Would you like to have other courses with this application?
❏ Yes
❏ Nο
*Pre and post questionnaire were the same.
223
Environmental education
3.3 Application design and development
This study demonstrates the teaching and understanding of environmental education concepts of great
difficulty, such as Energy Sources (Renewable and Nonrenewable-fossil fuels) and Climate Change
(causes, effects and solutions). Specifically, it explains these concepts with the use of Augmented
Reality technology.
Both Augmented Reality applications were designed and developed to be deployed on an Android
mobile device. For the development of the applications two tools were used, Unity3D and Vuforia.
Unity3D is a game engine or a game authoring instrument that is used to develop both 3D and 2D
games and deploy them across different platforms. For the creation of Augmented Reality
applications, the system needs an external SDK. Vuforia is an external SDK that enables Unity3D
developers to create Augmented Reality applications on mobile devices using as targets, images or
QR codes that can detected and tracked. (Diaz et al, 2016).
The user activates the application and points the camera to the image target. The application then
captures the target and recognizes it. If the recognized image matches the image target, specified 3D
models will be loaded and displayed on the screen. The movement of the target is being tracked by
the camera and adjusts the size of the image according to the movement (Parvathy et al, 2016).
In the case of our applications we choose to use QR codes as image targets. These applications require
only a smart mobile device with a camera, and the image targets printed on a piece of paper. In both
applications, three-dimensional animated models and sound were used.
The focus of the script was the students. Students are divided into groups and learn to use AR on their
own. Students should explore and achieve results through team effort not being benefited from the
presence of the teacher in the classroom. Τhe applications had a duration of about two minutes each.
For the first application were used two image targets (Figure 5).
Figure 5. Energy Source application workflow
The first image target presents the renewable energy sources, such as solar power, geothermal power
and wind power, while the second presents the fossil fuels (coal, oil and natural gas). The result is
shown in Figure 7.
For the second application were used only one image target (Figure 6).
Figure 6. Climate Change application workflow
224
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The second application deals with the phenomenon of climate change. At first, we present the causes
of temperature increase, such as deforestation and burning fossil fuels that increase CO2 emissions,
then we show the impact of the above, such as ice melting, sea level rise and desertification. Finally,
we propose various practices to reduce the progress of climate change such as recycling, energy
saving and reduce car usage. A screenshot is shown in Figure 8.
Figure 7. Wind Power
Figure 8. Climate Deforestation
Both applications are tested on Android smartphone Xiaomi Redmi 4A with Qualcomm Snapdragon
425 Quad-core 1.4 GHz.
4.
RESULTS
This study correlated on the supplemental learning effect of AR-based learning tools in a course
teaching environmental concepts as climate change and renewable energy resources.
The results recorded after the conduction of the questionnaires are divided into two categories. The
first concerns the level of change of knowledge by the students and the second concerns the students'
opinion about the learning experience with the AR application. Tables 2 and 3 show the comparison
between the grade obtained by the students when they performed the pre-test and the post-test. Pretest scores will represent students’ learning outcomes before, and post-test scores will represent
students’ learning outcomes after using the AR applications.
Τhe results showed that the change of knowledge for the 4th grade was 29.5%, the change for the 5th
grade was 25.6% and the change for the 6th grade was 21.7%. The next factor that is examined is the
change of learning experience that was 38% for the 4th grade, 32.3% for the 5th grade and 26.9% for
the 6th grade.
225
Environmental education
Table 2: The results of questions about knowledge change
Table 3. The results of questions about learning experience
5.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Due to the widespread Internet access and the increased use of laptops, Augmented Reality (AR) is a
phenomenon that over time has seen an increase in mobile devices (FitzGerald et al, 2013). This study
attempted to demonstrate the state of the art in innovative means of technology such as Augmented
Reality were effective in teaching environmental issues.
Our results verify that the cognitive performance of students in primary schools is reinforced by the
AR tool according to the study. In addition, students opposed to the tool of AR are receptive and have
a positive attitude as they enjoy the exploration experience.
In total, the change of knowledge for all grades was 25.6%, while the change of learning experience
was 32.4% on average of all grades. The best rate was achieved on learning experience with 32.4%
total change, which can be said that was expected based on previous studies.
The future objective is to conduct an experimental test involving more students and include other
environmental topics. Furthermore, we want to observe how this AR tool compares with other
learning software beyond traditional teaching methods. Finally, οne difficulty we faced was that in
primary schools is forbidden to use mobile phones.
References
1. Anderson, A. (2015) ‘Reflections on Environmental Communication and the Challenges of a
New Research Agenda’, Environmental Communication, Vol 9. No. 3, pp. 379-383
2. Asai, K., Kobayashi, H., Kondo, T. (2005) ‘Augmented instructions - a fusion of augmented
reality and printed learning materials’, Fifth IEEE International Conference on Advanced
Learning Technologies (ICALT'05), pp. 213-215, Kaohsiung, Taiwan
3. Azuma, R. (1997) ‘A Survey of Augmented Reality’, Presence: Teleoperators and Virtual
Environments, Vol. 6. No. 4, 1997, pp. 355-385.
4. Azuma, R., Billinghurst, M., & Klinker, G. (2011) ‘Special Section on Mobile Augmented
Reality’, Computers & Graphics, Vol 35(4), pp. vii-viii
226
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
5. Billinghurst, M. and A. Duenser (2012) ‘Augmented Reality in the classroom’, Computer,
45(7), pp. 56-63
6. Bower, M., Howe, C., McCredie, N., Robinson, A. and D. Grover (2013) ‘Augmented reality
in Education: Cases, places, and potentials’, 2013 IEEE 63rd Annual Conference
International Council for Education Media (ICEM), Singapore, Singapore pp. 1-11
7. Chatzopoulos, D., Bermejo, C, Huang, Z., Hui, Z. (2017) ‘Mobile Augmented Reality Survey:
From where we are to where we go’, IEEE Access, Vol. 5, pp. 6917-6950
8. Chen C-M and Y-N Tsai (2012) ‘Interactive augmented reality system for enhancing library
instruction in elementary schools’, Computers & Education, Vol. 59 No. 2, pp. 638-652
9. Cox, R. and P.C. Pezzullo (2015) ‘Environmental communication and the public sphere
(4th ed.)’, SAGE Publications
10. Cox, R. (2012) ‘Environmental communication and the public sphere (3th ed.)’, SAGE
Publications
11. Craig, B. A. (2013) ‘Understanding Augmented Reality: Concepts and Applications’,
Morgan Kaufmann, pp. 209-220
12. Dede, C. (2009) ‘Immersive interfaces for engagement and learning’, Science, Vol 323(5910),
pp. 66-69
13. Depoe, S. (1997) ‘Environmental studies in mass communication’, Critical Studies in Mass
Communication, Vol. 14, pp. 368–372
14. Diaz, C., Hincapié Montoya, M. and Moreno Lopez, G. (2015) ‘How the Type of Content in
Educative Augmented Reality Application Affects the Learning Experience’, Procedia
Computer Science, Vol. 75, pp. 205-212
15. Dunleavy, M., Dede, C. and Mitchell, R. (2009) ‘Affordances and limitations of immersive
participatory Augmented Reality simulations for teaching and learning’. Journal of Science
Education and Technology, Vol 18(1), pp. 7-22
16. FitzGerald, E., Ferguson, R., Adams, A., Gaved, M., Mor, Y., Thomas, R. (2013) ‘Augmented
reality and mobile learning: The state of the art’ International Journal of Mobile and
Blended Learning Vol 5(4), pp. 43-58
17. Fugger T., Hornung N. and F. Koller, ‘The herbarium:An interactive augmented book of
trees’
18. Halder, P., Nuutinen, S., Pietarinen, J., Pelkonen, P. (2011) ‘Bioenergy and the youth:
analyzing the role of school, home, and media from future policy perspectives’, Journal of
Applied Energy, Vol 88 No 4, pp. 1233-1240
19. Jennings, P., & C., Lund (2001) ‘Renewable energy education for sustainable development’,
Journal of Renewable Energy, Vol. 22, pp. 113
20. Jennings, P. (2009) ‘New directions in renewable energy education’, Renewable Energy,
Vol. 34(2), pp. 435-439
21. Johnson, L., Adams Becker, S., Cummins, M., Estrada, V., Freeman, A., H. Ludgate (2013)
‘NMC Horizon Report: K-12 Εdition’. The New Media Consortium, Austin, Texas
22. Johnson, L., Adams Becker, S., and M. Cummins (2012) ‘NMC Horizon Report:K-12
Edition’, The New Media Consortium, Austin, Texas
23. Kandpal T. C. and L. Broman (2014) ‘Renewable energy education: A global status review’,
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 34, pp. 300-324
227
Environmental education
24. Kaufmann, H., and D. Schmalstieg (2003) ‘Mathematics and geometry education with
collaborative augmented reality’, Computers & Graphics, Vol 27(3), pp. 339-345.
25. Kaufmann, H. (2003) ‘Collaborative augmented reality in education’, Institute of Software
Technology and Interactive Systems, Vienna University of Technology
26. Liarakou, G., Gavrilakis, C. and E., Flouri (2009) ‘Secondary school teachers' knowledge and
attitudes towards renewable energy sources’, Science Education and Technology, Vol.
18(2), pp. 120-192
27. Lin, T.J., Duh, H.B.L., Li, N., Wang, H.Y., Tsai, C.C. (2013) ‘An investigation of learners'
collaborative knowledge construction performances and behavioral patterns in an augmented
reality simulation system’, Computers & Education, Vol. 68, pp. 314–321
28. Martin, S., Diaz, G., Sancristobal, E., Gil, R., Castro, M., & Peire, J. (2011) ‘New technology
trends in education: Seven years of forecastsand convergence’, Computers & Education,
Vol .57 No. 3, pp. 1893-1906
29. Medicherla, S. P. & Chang, G. and P. Morreale (2010) ‘Visualization for increased
understanding and learning using augmented reality’ MIR '10 Proceedings of the
international conference on Multimedia information retrieval, pp. 441-444
30. Milgram, P., Takemura, H., Utsumi, A. and F. Kishino (1994) ‘Augmented Reality: A class
of displays on the reality-virtuality continuum’, In Proceedings of Telemanipulator and
Telepresence Technologies, pp. 2351–2334
31. Munnerley, D., Bacon, M., Wilson, A., Steele, J., Hedberg, J., & Fitzgerald, R. (2012)
‘Confronting an augmented reality’, Research in Learning Technology, Vol. 20, pp. 1–10
32. Oversby, J. (2015) ‘Teachers’ Learning about Climate Change Education’, Procedia - Social
and Behavioral Sciences, Vol. 167, pp. 23-27
33. Parvathy, K.R., McLain, M.L., Bijlani, K., Jayakrishnan R. and R.R. Bhavani (2016)
‘Augmented Reality Simulation to Visualize Global Warming and Its Consequences’,
Emerging Research in Computing, Information, Communication and Applications, pp.
69-78, India
34. Pasaréti, O., Hajdin, H., Matusaka, T., Jambori, A., Molnar, I., and M. Tucsányi-Szabó
(2011), ‘Augmented Reality in education’ INFODIDACT 2011 Informatika
Szakmódszertani Konferencia
35. Pedelty, M. (2015) ‘Environmental communication and the public sphere’, Environmental
Communication, Vol. 9(1), pp.139-142
36. Platonova, M. (2016) ‘Applying Emotive Rhetorical Strategy to Environmental
Communication in English and Latvian’, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, Vol.
236, pp. 107-113
37. Shuler, C., Levine, Z. and J. Ree (2012) ‘iLearn II: an analysis of the education category of
Apple’s app store’. Joan Ganz Cooney Center at Sesame Workshop
38. Squire, K. and M. Jan (2007) ‘Mad City Mystery: Developing scientific argumentation skills
with a place-based augmented reality game on handheld computers’, Journal of Science
Education and Technology, Vol 16(1), pp. 5-29
39. Squire, Κ. and Ε. Klopfer (2007) ‘Augmented reality simulations on handheld computers’,
Journal of the Learning Sciences, Vol 16, pp. 371-413
40. Wu, H.-K., Lee, S. W.-Y., Chang, H.-Y. and J.-C. Liang (2013) ‘Current status, opportunities
and challenges of augmented reality in education’, Computers & Education, 62, 41-49
228
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
RECYCLING AND EDUCATION THROUGH DIGITAL
STORYTELLING IN THE AGE GROUP “8-12” IN GREECE
P. Theodorou*, K.C. Vratsanou, E. Moriki, M. Botzori, M. Karamperis and C.
Skanavis
Research Center of Environmental Communication and Education, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: ptheod@env.aegean.gr
Abstract
In this study, primary school students were assessed on their environmental knowledge on recycling,
upcycling, their attitudes and willingness to change behavior, after their exposure to digital social
stories. Specifically, we propose the creation and the application of particular teaching interventions
in classes of primary school of Greece. This implementation concerns the use of a web tool, Pixton,
to educate students on the process of recycling, reusing and reducing. Specific digital stories with
recycling content were created by the participant students under given guidelines, developing their
own stories. In order to conduct the survey, 689 students participated from both urban and rural
regions. The results have shown that the implementation with Pixton tool has influenced the level of
knowledge, attitude and willingness to change behavior of the students.
Keywords: Recycling, Digital storytelling, Environmental attitude, Willingness to change behavior,
Education awareness, Learner-generated comics
1.
INTRODUCTION
The most effective way to reduce waste is to not create it in the first place. A lot of materials and
energy is required in order to make a new product. As a result, reduction and reuse are the most
effective ways you can save natural resources, protect the environment and save money (EPA, 2018).
These three concepts, in combination, could make society adopt a greener, environmentally friendly
behavior (EPA, 2018).
According to several studies affective factors, such as emotional affinity, empathy, and sympathy are
of greatest importance in the procedure of predicting pro-environmental behaviors (Allen & Ferrand,
1999; Geller, 1995; Kals, 1999; Mayer & Frantz, 2004). The emotional status seems to be the key
factor for the children's attitude toward environment, but the investigation about the reasons behind
environmental behavior of children surfaced supplementary outcomes. Another stated factor that
influences pro environmental behavior is the connection to nature (Cheng & Monroe, 2010).
Additionally, being environmentally educated from an early age has the consequence that people, by
all available means, learn to care for the planet, be familiar with nature and be part of an
environmentally active community (Plaka & Skanavis, 2016). Briefly, the more experiences
individuals have in their childhood, including school and family activities, the more likely it is to
have an environmentally friendly behavior when they grow up (Plaka & Skanavis, 2016).
Recent years have seen the need to transform environmental education from passive knowledge into
active action through the expression and the communication of students’ own ideas with the use of
activities like storytelling, photography and environmental drama (Tsevreni, 2011). Each of these
activities has been recorded as helping children understand better reality, become active members of
the community they belong to and develop decision making skills (Tserveni, 2011).
229
Environmental education
Children should be encouraged to be involved, by expressing and communicating their experiences,
ideas and emotions about their environment and their everyday life (Barratt et al., 2007). The aim of
this study is to examine how environmental concepts of Recycling, Reducing and Re-using can be
transmitted and transmigrated through the expression and the communication of students’ own ideas.
Taking the above into consideration, in this research, an attempt was made to comprehend the impact
on students’ knowledge, attitude and willingness to change behavior using a lecture in recycling
concept and DST (Digital Storytelling).
The fundamental issues of this study are briefly presented including the concepts of environmental
education and in particular the related concerns based on Recycling, Reducing and Re-using.
Subsequently, Digital Storytelling and the Pixton tool are described. The results from this research,
showed that after class implementation based on addressed tools, students were more aware of
recycling and upcycling. This in turn affected significantly their opinions and later on their attitudes
and willingness to change behavior towards the mentioned practices.
2.
BACKGROUND AND LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Environmental Education (EE)
Environmental education is considered to be the best way to create citizens with environmental
conscientiousness (Nicolae, 2005), but it is also directly linked to environmental protection behavior
as well as greener life choices (Schauer, 2006).
Environmental Education programs influence positively students' environmental beliefs, attitudes and
behavior (Ballantyna et al., 2001), (Dresner & Gill, 1994). Particularly, educational interventions in
field trips and other school-based programs with the aid of technology indoors affected the
environmental knowledge and attitudes of students and in some cases their behavior (Rickinson,
2001). However, Rickinson (2001) supports “The field of EE research lacks evidence that EE
promotes long-term behavioral changes”.
Environmental education can be defined as the process through which the knowledge and experience
of environmental problems are the keys to the creation of environmentally sensible people with
perceived environmental behavior and with an ultimate goal for a positive attitude towards the
physical world, its preservation and its protection (Rakotomamonjy et al., 2014). In other words, it is
considered to be the most powerful tool to make young people think and act greener and more
environmentally friendly (Schauer, 2006).
Especially, environmental education referring to the children/students, shapes the citizens of the
future. In this way, our society is improving by people who are more environmentally aware with a
deep respect for the environment (Varga et al., 2007), (Cheong, 2005).
2.2 Recycling, Reducing and Re-using
One of the most extended environmental problems humanity is confronted with is solid wastes. The
strongest and most successful solution is recycling (Jekria & Daud, 2015). According to the United
States Environmental Protection Agency, recycling is the procedure of collection and selection of
materials that otherwise would be considered garbage and turn them into new products after being
processed (EPA, 2018).
The more people that are involved in recycling, the more willing they are to be engaged in these
practices (Barr, 2007). Some of the benefits of the recycling for the society as total and earth as well,
include the decrease of contamination from poisonous gasses, the protection of regular assets and
vitality, the incitement of financial and innovative advancement and the safeguarding of assets
(Prestin & Pearce, 2010).
230
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.3 Digital storytelling
Fletcher and Cambre (2009) have found that digital storytelling can be a dynamic classroom practice
when used “as a pedagogical tool that brings the creator/student and the viewer together in a dialogue
around nature based on representation, meaning, and authority embedded in imagery and narrative”.
According to Robin B. R. (2016. p.18) Digital Storytelling:
“…consolidates the craft of recounting stories with advanced media, including a mixture of content,
pictures, recorded sound portrayal, music and video. These multimedia elements are blended together
using computer software, to tell a story revolving around a specific theme or topic and containing a
particular point of view. Most digital stories have the short length between 2 and 10 minutes, and are
saved in a digital format that can be viewed on a computer or other device capable of playing video
files…”
2.4 The tool of Pixton
Pixton belongs to the category of learner-centered tools, shifting the focus from teaching to learning
(Azman et al ,2016). That means that Pixton gives all its priorities to personalized, differentiated and
empowered learning. Opportunities provided to students focus on sharing comics, collaboration on
projects with other students and commenting on each other's work, contributing to a high value
involvement (Anderson, 2008).
Pixton is accessible through web browser and from smartphones, tablets, and computers. Τhere are
three different types of user accounts, Pixton for Fun, Pixton for School, and Pixton for Business.
Pixton for Fun offers limited options to users, such as the ability to share and remix content with
others. Additional options are only available to users who sign up to Pixton for School. Pixton for
School allows teachers to create classroom and individual accounts, in order to assign activities to
students and rate them at the end (Pixton, 2018).
Pixton can be integrated into the classroom and across the curriculum over different educational
modules and subject areas such as Computer and Technology, History and Social Studies, Science,
World Languages, Fine and Performing Arts, Mathematics, Special Education, Economics and
Health Education (Pixton Lesson Plans, 2018).
3.
METHODOLOGY
In the context of the survey, students were given lectures on recycling in combination with comics
created by them through the Pixton app. In particular, the students received a pre-assessment
questionnaire to assess their existing knowledge, behavior and attitude in relation to recycling.
Afterwards, researchers delivered a short lecture based on a PowerPoint 2016 presentation in order
to impart concepts about recycling like the practice of reusing something for its original purpose
(conventional reuse) or fulfilling a different function (creative reuse or repurpose).
In addition, the presentation included visual means (multimedia) explaining recycling, reusing and
reducing concepts. Then, students, following specific instructions, developed their own storyboards
and T-chart using the Pixton tool. Afterwards, participants were given the same questionnaire as a
post-test, with the exception of the four questions concerning willingness to change behavior. After
implementation, the students continued their course in the respective disciplines.
3.1 Sample
The selected schools had all an average common socio-economic background. The reason the
particular schools were chosen, was based on the provision that there was parental consent.
In the 3rd grade, the respective students were 113 (17%) from urban areas; female 45% and male
55%. In the 4th grade, the sample consisted of 133 (19%) students from urban areas; female 47% and
231
Environmental education
male 53%. In the 5th grade, the sample consisted of 120 (18%) children from urban areas; female
46% and male 54%. Finally, in the 6th grade the sample consisted of 110 (16%) children from urban
areas; female 45% and male 55%.
Concerning rural areas, in the 3rd grade, the respective students were 37 (5%); female 51% and male
49%. In the 4th grade, the sample consisted of 36 (5%) children; female 58% and male 42%. In the
5th grade, the sample consisted of 54 (8%) children; female 52% and male 48%. Finally, in the 6th
grade the sample consisted of 86 (12%) children; female 56% and male 44%. The students were in
the age group of 9 to 12 years of age. In total, 689 students took part in this study, 355 (52%) female
and 334 (48%) male.
Figure 1 & 2: Total students of urban and rural region - Gender of urban and rural schools
3.2 Questionnaire
The questionnaires regarding recycling were consisted of 22 questions. The study took place during
autumn of 2017. This survey had to be fulfilled within 2 or 3 teaching hours of 45-min school time
period. External variables causing delays had to do with attention span of students and their level of
understanding related issues as well as bureaucratic obstacles on the permission given to enter the
classroom. Questionnaires were anonymous. Knowledge, attitude and willingness to change behavior
were assessed by this survey. There were 8 questions on the knowledge of respondents and 4
questions that were associated with attitude. Furthermore, there were 6 questions that were dealing
with the willingness to change behavior regarding recycling concepts. A pre and post questionnaire
was given to the students. The two questionnaires were identical, concerning the parts of knowledge
and attitude. The parts with enquiries of willingness to change behavior were altered to the post
questionnaire. Moreover, the results were not announced to the students, unless they requested them
for their own assessment.
3.3 Learning tool (Pixton) and activities
The implementation of the above activity is achieved with Pixton web software. At this stage, students
were invited to create a timeline that reflected the lifetime of an object of their everyday life
depending on the material that was made from. Once the scheduled timetable had been completed,
students were asked to create an illustrated story of a character (student) presenting 3 different
activities mentioned in the above practices (reusing – recycling – reducing) to be implemented at
school (eg. material recycling, use of reusable utensils, water conservation, electricity, etc.). In the
evaluation phase students were asked to create a mind map with Pixton that illustrated a variety of
activities of 3R’s that they could perform in their daily lives. This would show whether the students
have achieved the objectives set out from the beginning and acquired the new knowledge from the
activities that preceded them. In this activity, students learned how to find useful information on the
Internet. This tool helps them to successfully use the creation of alternative and more attractive
representations of teaching material by teachers who have no specialized knowledge about painting
or comic design (Lazarinis et al., 2015).
232
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1: Questionnaire
QstN
Type
Topic
Q1
Profile
Gender
Q2
Profile
Age
Q3
Profile
Class
Q4
Profile
Where are you from?
Q5
Willingness
I am not willing to separate my family’s trash so that I can recycle
Q6
Willingness
I am willing to go from house to house and ask people if they recycle
Q7
Attitude
It makes me happy when people recycle used plastic bottles paper and aluminum
cans
Q8
Attitude
It troubles me when I think how much things people are throwing away that could
be recycled
Q9
Attitude
I have asked my family to recycle things we use
Q10
Knowledge
In comparison with normal paper the recycled paper
Q11
Knowledge
Where do most trashes go after they are thrown in garbage trucks?
Q12
Knowledge
The main problem with landfills is that
Q13
Knowledge
Pre-recycle means that
Q14
Knowledge
Objects that cannot be recycled and used again are
Q15
Knowledge
How important is recycling for the conservation of natural resources
Q16
Knowledge
How important is recycling as a component of solid waste management
Q17
Willingness
Do you recycle at your house?
Q18
Attitude
In the future you are going to
Q19
Knowledge
I recycle to preserve natural resources
Q20
Willingness
I recycle for charitable purposes
Q21
Willingness
I recycle so that I can make money
Q22
Willingness
I recycle because it seems like the right thing to do
Below, the scenario is described:
Α. In the first activity the students create a timeline that will display the maximum lifetime of every
object-material that we throw in trash (from least to bigger). Each panel should include description
with the estimated decomposition lifetime, an appropriate picture and include an appropriate
description for each object-material.
Β. In the second activity the students create a storyboard that present a student and depicts three
activities; each one will also refer to a different practice, which can be implemented at school. One
will refer to reducing, one to recycling and one to reuse. The activity was identified, by including
233
Environmental education
appropriate description, a dialogue that describes the activity and a corresponding image for each
table.
Figure 3: Second activity – Storyboard
C. In the third activity the students create, a mind map that illustrates a variety of activities for
reducing, reusing and recycling. Each panel should include a title, an appropriate picture and a
detailed description.
Figure 4: Third activity - Mind Map
4.
RESULTS
Regarding total result of urban and rural region concerning knowledge, the change for the 3rd grade
was 48.9%, the change for the 4th grade was 56.8%, the change for the 6th grade was 65.5% and the
change for the 6th grade was 74.1%. The category of attitude gave us results such as 57.7% for the
3rd grade, 56.6% for the 4th grade, 56.9% for the 6th grade and 59% for the 6th grade. For all these
234
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
questions concerning willingness to change behavior, it was recorded that the change was 59.3% for
the 3rd grade, 51.3% for the 4th grade, 52.9% for the 5th grade and 54.6% for the 6th grade.
Specifically, from the questions concerning knowledge in urban region, the change for the 3rd grade
was 39.2%, for the 4th grade, 46.1%, for the 5th grade 39.4% and for the 6th grade was 54.6%. The
change of attitude category in urban was 47.6% for the 3rd grade, 45.3% for the 4th grade, 36.8% for
the 5th grade and 44.4% for the 6th grade. The category willingness to change behavior of the
participants in urban region was 46.8% for the 3rd grade, 45.3% for the 4th grade, 42.4% for the 5th
grade and 40.7% for the 6th grade.
Particularly, for all the questions concerning knowledge in rural region, 10% was the change for the
3rd grade, 10.6% for the 4th grade, 24.8% for the 5th grade and 19.2% for the 6th grade. The change
of attitude category in rural region was 11% for the 3rd grade, 11.3% for the 4th grade, 25.1% for the
5th grade and 14.6% for the 6th grade. The change in the willingness to change behavior of the
participants in rural areas was 9.6% for the 3rd grade, 5% for the 4th grade, 12.7% for the 5th grade
and 13.8% for the 6th grade.
In urban, in 3rd, 4th, 5th and 6th grade, the willingness to change behavior was 53.8%, 31.9%, 47.4%
and 51.4%. Whereas, in rural the 3rd, 5th and 6th grade had a change of 17.8%, 7.3%, 21.1% and in
the 4th grade the change was 4%.
The most remarkable observations concern the questions with the greatest differences in the
percentages, being the 13th and 14th questions. In particular, in the 6th grade of the urban region, it
was recorded that in total, there was the biggest change of 64% and in the 14th question, there was
also the biggest change of 64.6% compared to other school classes of the urban and rural regions. In
attitude category of the urban and rural region, the 3rd grade has increased a level of 57.7%,
respectively in fourth grade, the increment percentage was 56.6%, in the fifth grade was 56.9% and
in the sixth 59%. As for the question 8 that delineates also attitude, there were observed larger changes
on average in all classes of urban, from 25.5% to 45.5%, except at 5th grade of the urban area that
the students' answers showed a 15.7% increase after the intervention.
Notably, in question 8 at rural region in the 3rd grade the change was 15.1%, in the 4th grade 9.2%,
in 5th grade (bigger of other classes) 30.3% and in the 6th grade 13.1%. It was remarkable that in the
sixth grade of primary school concerning question 18 of the attitudes group, there was the highest
success rate of 64%. Of course, there is an exception at the fourth grade of rural areas whose
environmental attitude was improved only by 11.2%.
Another noticeable question was 22. The change in urban areas was from 32.5% to 49.1%, whereas
in the rural areas the change was from 4% to 39.5%. Taking into consideration the questions
concerning willingness to change behavior, it is observed that there is a stable total change in all the
grades of urban and rural areas from 47.2% to 140.1%.
Table 2: Total changes in 3rd 4th 5th and 6th grade of Urban Region
Table 3: Total changes in 3rd 4th 5th and 6th grade of Rural Region
235
Environmental education
Table 4: Total changes in 3rd 4th 6th and 6th grade of Urban and Rural Region
5.
DISCUSSION
Understand what shapes the children’s attitude toward the environment is of vital importance if one
wishes to administer the necessary skills to face the environmental problems of our society in their
adulthood (Cheng & Monroe, 2010). In Greece, formal environmental education in the mandatory
part of the school system (primary and secondary) has not fully reached the desired results on a
responsible environmental behavior of participating students (Karamperis et al., 2016).
The formulation of environmental knowledge, attitude and behavior from young ages play a crucial
role in recycling and reusing campaigns, especially when complex solutions are applied. In order to
succeed a satisfying deepening in environmental education, it is necessary to associate it to all three
forms of education (formal, non formal, in formal) from an early age (Plaka & Skanavis, 2016). While
there are numerous technical policies and solutions for transmitting environmental concepts like
recycling, changing the behavior of individuals from an early age will be the most critical component
of the process (Vaughter, 2016). This paper’s results are in alignment with results from prior research
projects.
The results strongly suggest that the production of digital stories can improve students’ knowledge,
attitude and willingness to change behavior about recycling. This confers to the main goal of
environmental education that aims to ameliorate the knowledge of people on the subject, restructure
the assertive attitude towards the environment within a contiguous positive behavior (Jensen &
Schnack, 1997). In particular, the total results regarding knowledge showed that the proportions were
modified before and after the implementation. Comparatively, it is recorded the total knowledge of
urban and rural region the 3rd grade was increased in a level of 48.9%, respectively in fourth, the
growth percentage was 56.8%, in the fifth grade was 65.5% and in the sixth 74.1%.
In fact, the national Greek curriculum shows that environmental education is being taught only up to
the fourth grade of primary school. After this grade, scattered topics are concluded in biology,
geography, physics and chemistry subjects. Students also amply demonstrated that educational,
digital comics could assist them to understand difficult technical and scientific content. These
findings align with prior claims that comics were able to assist students’ comprehension (Mallia,
2007) (Recine, 2013) (Yıldırım, 2013).
A remarkable observation with recorded big changes in the percentages concerns question 5 that
represents the willingness of the respondents to change their behavior. In these questions there was a
difference between classes, depending on the region. This asserts the few studies that have been
conducted into the impact of environmental education on children and youth which show that the
level of environmental awareness is relatively low and the willingness to change behavior differs
depending on the region, type of area (urban/rural) and school (Domka, 2001).
In sum, DST is time-consuming and some educators believe that it is an effort that is tedious
(Theodorou et al., 2017). That is, because it may take students several attempts at creating digital
stories before they demonstrate proficiency in technology and knowledge on the topic (Dogan &
Robin, 2017). As with all new instructional methods, students will need time to learn using DST
(Dogan & Robin, 2017). During the research, relative inefficiencies were identified concerning
mostly technical problems. Another barrier that appeared in this particular research was the slow
internet connection that caused problems to the speed and the quality of the process. In addition, the
236
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
hours that primary school teachers offered were limited and that created difficulties in the overall
completion of the process.
6.
CONCLUSION
Future implications of this study would involve the improvement of the particular programs in order
to stabilize the role that students can acquire as dominants and leaders of environmental knowledge,
attitude, as well as the appropriate behavior in both family and community through educational
constructivist methods such as the applications of DST.
Although there are no similar surveys on the use of DST in the environmental education in Greek
primary schools, it is clear from our results that DST can be a very useful tool in the field of
environmental education, and more specifically in the teaching process of recycling concepts. The
findings of the research could be a starting point for a series of studies that would further analyze the
use of DST in other environmental issues in education. It’s also very important to mention that the
use of DST in the classrooms gives students the opportunity to become familiar with technology and
to include it more easily into the learning process.
From the above, it can be seen that, this research provides us with a lot of interesting and enlightening
data while presenting the possibilities for far-reaching research as well as the systematic use of DST
for environmental education. Having already shown the positive results that can arise from the use
of digital tools such as Pixton in environmental education, a next step would be to explore the effects
of using other similar tools such as WebQuest with the content of environmental education.
References
1. Anderson T. (2008). ‘Towards and theory of online learning’. Athabasca University.
2. Azman F., S. Zaibon, and N. Shiratuddin. (2016). ‘Pedagogical analysis of comic authoring
systems for educational digital storytelling’. Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information
Technology, 89(2), pp. 461-469
3. Allen, J. and J. Ferrand. (1999). ‘Environmental locus of control, sympathy, and
proenvironmental behavior’. Environment and Behavior, 31, pp.338-353.
4. Ballantyna, R., Fien, J. and J. Packer. (2001). ‘Intergenerational influence environmental
education: A quantitative analysis’. Australian Journal of Environmental Education, 17, pp.
1-7.
5. Barr S. (2007). ‘Factors influencing environmental attitudes and behaviors: A U.K. case study of
household waste management’. Environment and Behavior, 39(4), pp. 435-473.
6. Barrat H.E., Barrat R. and W. Scott. (2007). ‘Engaging children: research issues around
participation and environmental learning’. Environmental Education Research,13(4). pp. 529544.
7. Cheong I.P.A. (2005). ‘Educating pre-service teachers for a sustainable environment’. AsiaPacific Journal of Teacher Education, Vol 33(1), pp. 97-110.
8. Dogan B. and R.B. Robin. (2017). ‘Climate Change Education From Critical Thinking to
Critical Action’. Institute for the Advanced Study of Sustainability.
9. Dresner M. and M. Gill. (1994). ‘Environmental education at summer nature camp’. The
Journal of Environmental Education, 25(3), pp. 35-41.
10. Fletcher C. and C. Cambre. (2009). ‘Digital storytelling and implicated scholarship in the
classroom’. Journal of Canadian Studies, 43(1), pp. 109-130.
11. Geller, E. (1995). ‘Actively caring for the environment: An integration of behaviorism and
humanism’. Environment and Behavior, 27, pp.184-195.
237
Environmental education
12. https://www.epa.gov/education/what-environmental-education (accessed January 7th, 2018).
13. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/322245683_Children_Communicating_on_Climate_C
hange_The_Case_of_a_Summer_Camp_at_a_Greek_Island (accessed Febuary 27th, 2018).
14. Jekria N. and S. Daud . (2016). ‘Environmental Concern and Recycling Behaviour’. Procedia
Economics and Finance, 35, pp. 667-673.
15. Jensen B. and K. Schnack. (1997). ‘The action competence approach in environmental education’.
Environmental Education Research, 12(3–4), pp. 471–486.
16. Cheng J.C.H and M.C. Monroe. (2010). ‘Connection to Nature: Children’s Affective Attitude
Toward Nature Environment and Behavior’. Environment and Behavior,44,pp.31-49.
17. Kals E., D. Schumacher, and L. Montada. (1999). ‘Emotional affinity toward nature as a
motivational basis to protect nature’. Environment and Behavior, 31, pp. 178-202.
18. Karamperis M., S. Apostolopoulou, G. Grigoroglou, C. Skanavis and A. Kounani. (2016).
Environmental Summer Camp in a Greek Island, International Conference on Protection and
Restoration of the Environment, pp. 1024-1030, Mykonos Island, Greece.
19. Lazarinis F., A. Mazaraki, V.S. Verykios and C. Panagiotakopoulos. (2015). E-comics in
teaching: Evaluating and using comic strip creator tools for educational purposes. International
Conference on Computer Science & Education, pp. 1023-1041, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
20. Mayer F. and C. Frantz. (2004). ‘The connectedness to nature scale: A measure of individuals
feeling in community with nature’. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 24, pp. 503-515.
21. Mallia G. (2007). ‘Learning from the sequence: The use of comics in instruction’. Imagetext:
Interdisciplinary Comics Studies, 3(3), pp. 1-10.
22. Nicolae L. (2005). ‘Council of Europe Plenary Session: Youth Education for Sustainable
Development’.
23. Plaka V. and C. Skanavis. (2016). ‘The feasibility of school gardens as an educational approach
in Greece: a survey of Greek schools’. International Journal of Innovation and Sustainable
Development, 10(2), pp. 141.
24. Plaka V. and C. Skanavis. (2016). ‘The feasibility of school gardens as an educational approach
in Greece: a survey of Greek schools’. International Journal of Innovation and Sustainable
Development, 10(2), pp. 141.
25. Prestin A. and E.K Pearce. (2010). ‘We care a lot: Formative research for a social marketing
campaign to promote school-based recycling’. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 54,
pp.1017-1026.
26. Rakotomamonjy S. N., J. P. G. Jones, J. H. Razafimanahaka, B. Ramamonjisoa and S. J. Williams.
(2015). ‘The effects of environmental education on children's and parents' knowledge and
attitudes towards lemurs in rural Madagascar’. Animal Conservation, 18(2), pp. 157–166.
27. Rickinson M. (2001). ‘Learners and Learning in Environmental Education: A critical review of
the evidence’. Environmental Education Research, 7(3), pp. 207-320.
28. Recine D. (2013). ‘Comics aren’t Just For Fun Anymore: The Practical Use of Comics by TESOL
Professionals’. University of Wisconsin River Falls.
29. Bernard R. (2016). ‘The Power of Digital Storytelling to Support Teaching and Learning’. Digital
Education Review, 30, pp. 17-29.
30. Schauer T. (2006). ‘EU Strategies and the Role of Education for Sustainable Development’.
Vienna: The Club of Rome – European Support Centre.
31. Skanavis C. (2004). ‘Environment and Community’. Kalidoskopio, Athens.
238
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
32. Tserveni I. (2011). ‘Towards an environmental education without scientific knowledge: an
attempt to create an action model based on children's experiences, emotions and perceptions about
their environment’. Environmental Education Research,17(1), pp. 53-67.
33. Theodorou V., K. Vratsanou, H. Nastoulas, E.S. Kalogirou and C. Skanavis. (2017). Climate
change Education through DST in the age group “10-13” in Greece. World Symposium On
Climate Change Communication.
34. Varga A., M.F. Koszo, M. Mayer and W. Sleurs. (2007). ‘Developing teacher competences for
education for sustainable development through reflection: The environment and school initiatives
approach’. Journal of Education for Teaching, 33(2), pp. 241-256.
35. Vaughter P. (2016). ‘Climate Change Education From Critical Thinking to Critical Action’.
United Nations University Institute for the Advanced Study of Sustainability, 4, pp. 4.
36. Yıldırım A.H. (2013). ‘Using graphic novels in the classroom’. Journal of Language and
Literature Education, 8, pp. 118-131.
239
Environmental education
SOCIAL EXPERIMENT IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL FIELD OF
EDUCATION
1
1
S. M. Bagiouk*, 2S. S. Bagiouk, 2A. E. Agiou, 1A. S. Bagiouk
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Aristotle
University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece,
2
Department of Civil Engineering, Democritus University of Thrace, 67131, Xanthi, Greece
*Corresponding author: 1E-mail: smpagiou@civil.auth.gr, Tel +30 2310 995893, +30 6944189218
Abstract
Climate change that has taken place over the last few decades requires a different approach of the
environment. For this reason, a different philosophy and behavior of citizens is needed, characterized
by respect and proper use of the environment, stimuli acquired mainly through education. The aim of
this paper is to identify the problems and the dissuasive trends as well as to highlight actions and
motivations for environmental awareness and activation, in order to show and build an innovative
and efficient model of education and mobilization. This research was carried out using the
"questionnaire" method, as well as the statistical analysis and the statistical sample came from
students of secondary and tertiary education in Northern Greece. In particular, it focused on the active
population of society so as to have on the one hand the necessary maturity required for the problems
to be taken into account and on the other hand the potential for immediate activation.
Keywords: Environment, Education, Innovation, Action, Questionnaire
1.
INTRODUCTION
The education comes from the verb educate, which means raise, form, edify. It is the process of
acquiring knowledge, developing skills and competencies, and forming values. As far as
Environmental Education is concerned, it is the education about the environment that places it as an
area of our daily life and contributes to the development of knowledge, attitudes, abilities and action
for its preservation, protection and restoration. Its aim is to raise awareness of environmental issues
and on these issues by social groups and citizens. The definitions for Environmental Education are
varied and have been given from time to time by various operators and environmentalists. The first
definition of Environmental Education was given by the International Union for the Conservation of
Nature organization in 1970 [17], although along the way the most acceptable definition was given
by UNESCO in 1977 [17] in Tbilisi of the former Soviet Union. All the definitions that have been
expressed and formulated have as a common denominator the responsible and harmonious
relationship between the man and the environment. Environmental education is governed by three
dimensions [17], [Figure 1]. The Education around the Environment on the accumulation of
knowledge about the biophysical dimensions of the environment, the Education in the Environment
that highlights the beneficial effect of the person's contact with nature and finally the Education for
the Environment which introduces the notion of citizen responsibility for the fate of the environment
in which two trends have been formed, the technocratic, which claims that technology has the
potential to provide solutions to environmental issues, and the ecocentric, which considers that
science and technology can not by themselves provide solutions. These three dimensions are not only
not contradictory, but instead complement one another, and in combination they all define the modern
concept of Environmental Education, that is, an Education that meets the needs of modern times and
240
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
builds a constructive relationship between the man and the nature. In general, Environmental
Education (EE) has been progressively developed since the 1960s in America and Europe [13] with
the aim of raising environmental sensitization of citizens and the prospect of opposing the widespread
perception that considers man as the sovereign of the nature. Particularly important was the first
international working meeting in Carson City, Nevada, USA, [6] in 1970, on EE where the term
‘’Environmental Education’’ was introduced in international vocabulary. At the Stockholm
Conference (1972), the role of EE is recognized for environmental protection and the results of the
conference include the establishment of the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) and the
expansion of new ministries of the environment worldwide [3]. During the 1980s, the new notion of
'Sustainable Development' is changing the environmental data [13]. Specifically, it is introduced in
1987 with the publication of the Brundtland report by the World Commission on Environment and
Development and it is adopted by the Rio International Conference [15] on Environment and
Development in 1992 and by the Thessaloniki Conference (1997) [9] [10]. Sustainable Development
is a development that meets today's needs without limiting the potential of future generations to cover
their own needs. UNESCO (2005) declares an Implementation Plan [16] that concerns Education for
Sustainable Development in the Decade of Education (2005-2015) so that its principles and
characteristics can be reformed. Today Education for Sustainable Development is considered to be a
stage of Environmental Education as Environmental Education evolves continuously with the sole
purpose of shaping responsible citizens actively involved in socio-environmental issues. The present
paper aims at the emergence of an innovative model of education that puts the trainee rather than the
trainer in the centre, free of using rote memory as a learning technique, but instead linked to modern
educational techniques that focus on practice rather than theory. The paper was based on the
"questionnaire" method introduced to secondary and tertiary education students in Northern Greece
and on the results and conclusions that resulted, in bibliographic research as well as in interviews
with secondary and tertiary teachers.
The Education around
the Environment
ENVIRONMENTAL
EDUCATION
The Education in the
Environment
The Education for the
Environment
Figure 1: The three dimensions that govern Environmental Education
2.
THE SURVEY
2.1 The aim
The survey put young people in the lead as pupils and students constitute and represent the active
population and the future of the country. The aim of this research is to put the trainee in focus and to
formulate the trainers' stimuli, pulse, needs, crisis and suggestions. This endeavor does not follow
and does not identify with traditional education but opposes and conflicts with it. It does not
241
Environmental education
marginalize the pupil's - student's needs, requirements and necessities as he embraces and assimilates
them [8]. It does not begin in order to end up with the trainee as a conservative package of education
and knowledge which while it is referring to him and it is determined for him not only does not give
him the maximum weight required to reform the education system but does not even take his or her
opinion into account for this equation. Instead, the innovative education model proposed is started by
the trainee so as to end up with him. Today's era sets a different approach to the environment more
timely than ever, which couldn't not start from the classrooms. Thus this innovative model of
education sets its foundation in the first stages of education but with its heart beating at secondary
education, since should children have built the appropriate environmental background in previous
classes, they will be able with the appropriate maturity to apply what they were taught, to take
initiatives and to coordinate and take the lead in more actions [14] in their future life, such as in higher
education, in which they may continue. It will also contribute to the creation of radical change
concepts body that will reschedule organizational structures, build an environmentally responsible
and active citizen, a person in direct contact with the environment, promote a new concept and
philosophy for the environment, and emphasize the position and the role of the man in this [12]. It
will also emphasize the need to face the ecological crisis and the demands of the ecological movement
in order to create conditions that will prevent the emergence of similar crises in the future. Hence, the
aim of this paper is the education model [7] proposed to constitute the vehicle for challenging and
introducing changes in traditional education through the use of innovative approaches to reality, the
opening of the school to life, the resolution of real problems and the learner's active participation [5]
in the learning process with modern educational methods and techniques.
2.2 The method
The survey was carried out with the help of a questionnaire, which was distributed to pupils of
secondary education and to students of higher education, schools and universities of Northern Greece
respectively. No specific place or school or university was selected so that the sample would be more
representative and reliable. In particular, 368 questionnaires were distributed and 309 completed in
October-November 2016. The data after being collected were put for statistical analysis and for
conclusions. The questionnaire was formed in full association with the objectives, the research goals,
the age, the stimuli and the psychology of the participants on the basis of the relevant
literature[3][7][1]. In all questions the children were asked to answer on a five-level scale where 1
was identified with "not at all" and 5 with "very strong" as well as optionally with the addition of a
comment or a detailed answer. In particular, it included questions in which respondents identify
problems and deterrents and assess the impact of each individually on the concept of environmental
consciousness [2]. The questionnaire was also enriched with questions about the emergence of
solutions, proposals and actions to achieve an environmentally friendly behavior, environmental
sensitization and activation [14]. At the end of the questionnaire, there are questions about the sociodemographic details of the person completing it, which relate to gender, age, class or year, and the
type of study respectively, as well as the place of origin and the activities the person maintains.
2.3 The sample of the survey
The young people's view, coming from the answers given by pupils and students to the specific
questionnaire adapted to the psychology of age, knowledge, stimuli, experiences and the other
characteristics that govern them [1], was imprinted, analyzed and expressed with statistical accuracy,
with observations and fruitful conclusions. Specifically, 78% of the pupils and 83% of the students
answer that the environmental education learning techniques and how they are taught are not
attractive and do not cause interest. Then 68% of the boys as well as 76% of the girls paint as the
main disincentive of the environmental process, the non-active attitude of the state combined with a
simple theoretical approach to the environmental crisis as dissatisfaction to inertia, procrastination,
distraction from actions, social events, the promotion of environmental awareness and radical changes
to the curriculum that has never been applied, was developed. Another analgesic factor that was
determined by almost the entire sample with 92% was the predominant position of memorization and
242
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
rote memory. Questions related to the offer and activity so far have shown that students with artistic
activities and students of social sciences (psychology, special education, etc.) have developed to a
greater extent the feeling of volunteering. It has also been recorded that children from rural areas in
relation to children living in urban centers as well as those engaged in sports directly related to nature
and to environment, have shown greater interest in recycling and similar actions. Moreover, the age
factor was considered at many points crucial as the 19-year-olds (19) seemed to be more mature and
more aware of the importance of the problems faced and studied by environmental education. While
in the process of identifying problems and dissuasive trends pupils of theoretical direction and
students of theoretical sciences showed greater ability and intent to identify them, but in the process
of highlighting actions and proposals they came second since students of positive direction and
students of natural science and Polytechnical Universities have shown greater readiness, willingness
and ability to propose solutions, organize and coordinate actions as well as to work on innovative
programs. Some of their suggestions were the use of models and software as well as the wider use of
technology and the internet, such as the use of the latter as a mechanism for promoting and raising
awareness and developing broader partnerships. In the question of what are the main components for
finding solutions and developing actions, the dominant responses were motivation and dialogue as
they were not selected only by the small percentage of 7%, while in the question of whether the
institution of the group, by using learning methods centered in this, would help the educational
process, 86% responded positively. Finally, in the crucial and all-important question whether it is
feasible and profitable to make radical changes in environmental education and education in general,
almost the whole sample with the percentage touching the absolute and specifically with the
overwhelming percentage of 98% answered ''Yes'', [Figure 2].
100
90
80
70
60
50
98
40
30
20
10
2
0
YES
NO
Figure 2: The statistical representation of the sample according to whether they want changes
in the form of the current Educational System.
Analytically, young people are looking for new learning techniques and methods, learner-centered,
focusing on example, experiment, application, and more generally on the practical part [4]. In those
that provide appreciable motivation to the apprentice and not to the techniques being a consequence
of existing traditional education that puts the focus on sterile memorization and rote memory. An
experiential education that in addition to the essential and necessary knowledge will provide the
student with the power of discernment as well as the necessary tools that will shield him for tomorrow.
The sample of the survey as far as the teachers views is concerned, that were elicited through the
interviews, harmonizes and moves in a very large part of it in the same context while it opposes to
very few individual views that were adopted and supported by the teacher-centered method.
243
Environmental education
3.
INNOVATIVE TECHNIQUES OF AN EXEMPLAR EDUCATION SYSTEM
3.1 The model
Taking into account the sample of research, ie the results and conclusions that have been reached,
bibliographic research [2], interviews with secondary and tertiary educators, psychology and the
needs of youth [1] as well as the technological and scientific evolution of the era, a study and research
was carried out to build an innovative model of education that promotes learning techniques tailored
to the occasional learning level of each era starting from primary or even pre-primary education and
ending with tertiary education and its extensions.
A model of education not moving within traditional education [10] but introducing a new form of
learning that will be experiential and more effective [12]. A learner-centered learning with high
interactivity, communication and participation that pulls the learner out of the background and puts
him at the forefront giving him a leading role [5]. An education that hears and respects his voice and
his opinion [8], which allows him to experience and even lapse into errors without, of course,
affecting the respect and dignity of each individual as the error will be an opportunity for
improvement and the starting point for a set of actions that will evolve him and complete him as a
person and personality.
The instructor's monologue is replaced by the discussion and the direct and universal participation of
apprentices with new radical methods and innovative education techniques aimed at utilizing all the
senses so that new knowledge can be easily and more efficiently engraved in memory. For example,
if the knowledge ends up to the trainee visually and verbally, then since people use two sensory
organs, there are now two ''ways'' to retrieve this information from their memory in the near future.
Through this the trainee is not trying to acquire a conservative and impersonal knowledge package
but to acquire and build a philosophy of thinking that will accompany him to the environmental
problems and dilemmas and to his everyday life in society. More simply, a way of thinking and acting
that perceives situations and stimuli him correctly and through specific stages and a large scale of
practical knowledge and skills not only leads him to a solution but to a range of solutions through
which the student may choose the best [11].
This process, ie algorithmic thinking and action [Figure 3], which is proposed in the current education
model for the learner, follows a sequence of things and events starting from the perception and
diagnosis of a problematic situation. Then create scenarios and set goals. Afterwards, the trainee
continues collecting, organizing and coordinating information and data in order to arrive at a range
of possible solutions. Having the right knowledge base he defines the criteria for choosing an
appropriate solution and chooses the most appropriate. By completing this logic, the trainee creates
an action plan based on the best solution and achieves his purpose. Of course, at the end of each such
act, he enters the evaluation process with the goal of self-improvement and the achievement of better
results in the future.
DIAGNOSIS
DATA
COLLECTION
PROCESSING
POSSIBLE
SOLUTIONS
BEST
SOLUTION
Figure 3: Algorithmic thinking
244
ACTION
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.2 The trainer's role
The trainer's role is of crucial importance as he is the one who will apply these techniques and
methods, educate young people and try to lead them to their original goals [11]. In the context
proposed, the role of the trainer does not endorse the dominant role adopted in traditional education
[10] but introduces a new aspect that makes him co-star with the learner, having as his sole concern
the active involvement of the young and his goals achievement. In particular, he is the one that will
provide the knowledge, stimulate the learner's interest and introduce him / her into the educational
process with the element of challenge, not by leaving him as a mere observer and passive recipient
[5] [1]. In this model, the trainer's duties do not only not decrease but instead increase as we speak of
a much more demanding process. . Specifically, the trainer is asked to effectively organize and plan
the teaching before practicing it and additionally while he is supervising the work of the students,
providing support and guidance, encouraging and puzzling the young. Even to provide, if necessary,
feedback on the young, to lead him to consciously work, to keep children at a desired pace, to identify
the advantages and disadvantages of their work and to control the process. He also links teaching with
pre-existing knowledge, provides a wealth of sources of knowledge, aims at high interactivity,
communication and feedback, teamwork, research, cooperation, uses participatory strategies [4] [11],
constitutes a role model, spares time to propose alternative solutions for the best result, to give the
appropriate instructions and to advise thoroughly. Finally, to ensure everyone's involvement and the
right approach to the problem concerned. It is understood that all of these methods are not only
teacher-centered and do not follow the beaten track but instead collide frontally with traditional
education. Thus, the trainer simply acquires a coordinating, organizational and counseling role, that
is, more limited, giving space and time to the apprentice with the sole aim of his spiritual shielding
as well as his independence.
3.3 Techniques - Methods
Techniques and methods [4][14] designed to frame this innovative environmental education model
place the learner in the center and all the rest around him. They aim at applying and acting to
meaningful understanding rather than sterile memorization and rote memory. They relieve the trainee
from a passive receiver and place emphasis on high interactivity, collaboration, technology, science
advances, and effective strategies [5]. Below, a range of techniques, methods and teachings are
presented that could be used for more efficient and up-to-date education [11]. For a better illustration
of the concept, the content and the correlation of the techniques and methods were grouped together.
This, in any case, does not imply that techniques that are not placed in the same group are strange to
each other and that when applied one another cannot work complementarily. They all adopt features
that make them attractive, appropriate and efficient, but a number of criteria highlight which one or
which ones are the most appropriate.
Group 1
Problem Solving
Decision-making Method
Group 2
Debate
Avalanche
Brainstorming
Questions and discussion inspired by Socrates method (maieutics) [18]
Group 3
The Jigsaw Method
245
Environmental education
Teams, Expert Groups
Games, Role playing
Project Method, Interdisciplinary teaching
Case study
Dramatization
Group 4
Experiment
Models-Modeling -Using software in teaching
Multimedia presentation
Group 5
Learning Stations
Educational Visits, Theater-Cinema
Group 6
Demonstration
Description and explanation
Concept maps - Virtual representation
Fairy tale
The choice of the appropriate method depends on the age, the stimuli, the knowledge and the
background [1] of the learners, the goals and the strategies [11] of the teaching, the content and the
objectives set for the environmental education, the trainer's judgment, the time available and
infrastructure.
4.
CONCLUSIONS – DISCUSSION
Based on the findings of the research in which the apprentice starred, the weaknesses, concerns and
dissuasive tendencies in environmental education were perceived and his intentions, needs, attitudes
and perceptions were clarified. In addition, solutions and suggestions for action and mobilization
were expressed, but most important the main request of young people for radical changes in teaching,
methods and learning techniques was expressed and depicted [11] [4]. As a result of all this, an
innovative model of education that respects the apprentice is designed and characterized as a learnercentered model which focuses on application, motivation, action, inspired and based on efficient
strategies [14]. Subsequently, on this model a range of methods and techniques was presented
distinguished by high interactivity, participation, use of groups, dialogue, actions and use of
technology. In the effort to choose the most appropriate one at a time, the question of which is the
best is also addressed. The answer is that there is no good or bad method, because in each individual
case some method will be seen as the most suitable. For example in preschool and small classes of
elementary education and environmental education, is singled out and recommended by group 6 the
teaching through fairy tale, games and multimedia, while in larger classes of primary schools through
Learning Stations, Experiment and Project Method. Moreover, for the first classes of the secondary
education, the Decision Making Method, the Jigsaw Method, Dramatization and the Method with
questions and discussion inspired by Socrates method (maieutics) [18] stand out. While in larger
classes that children have developed a good level of maturity and knowledge, methods of the second
group can be approached, such as Debate, Interdisciplinary Teaching, Brainstorming and Avalanche.
246
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Finally, the Problem Solving, Expert Groups, Case Study and the use of modeling (modeling) and
software, which is a basic tool in scientific research, are particularly recommended in higher
education, especially when the representation and study with the use of real objects seems impossible.
Such an integrated and innovative model of education offers many opportunities and resources to
young children and, at the same time, good coordination and good organization makes it capable of
approaching in an alternative and efficient way Environmental Education, Environmental awareness
and Ecological education so as to provide the best strong results for the environment as well as for
the whole society.
References
1. Dietz, T., Stern, P.C. and Guagnano, G. A. (1998). ΄Social structural and social psychological
bases of environmental concern΄. Environment and Behavior, 30 (4), 450–471.
2. Flogaiti E. (1993). ‘Environmental Education’, Ellinikes Panepistimiakes Ekdoseis (Greek
Academic Publications).
3. Flogaiti, E. ( 2006). ‘Education for the Environment and Sustainability’. Ellinika Grammata.
4. Georgopoulos A., Tsaliki E. (1993). ‘Environmental Education (Principles, Philosophy,
Methodology, Games and Exercises)’, Gutenberg.
5. Hart, R. (2011). ‘The children participate’, (assiduity K. Tamoutseli), Epikentro.
6. IUCN. (1970). International Working Meeting on Environmental Education in the School
Curriculum. Carson City, Nevada, USA.
7. Kousouris Th., Athanasakis A. (1994). ‘Environment, Ecology, Education’, Savalas.
8. Maloney, M.P. and Ward, M. (1973). ‘Ecology: Let’s hear from the people’. American
Psychologist, 28 (7): 583-586.
9. Manual for Environmental Education. (1992). Ministry of National Education and Religious
Affairs - U.N.E.S.C.O. , Athens.
10. Papadimitriou B. (2006). ‘Environmental education in the school. A timeless view’,
G.Dardanos Publications.
11. Pressley, M., Harris, K.R., & Marks, M.B. (1992). ‘But good strategy instructors are
constractivists’. Educational Psychology Review, 4, 3-31.
12. Shallcross,T.,Robinson,J.,Pace,P.,Tamoutseli,D. (2004). ‘The role of Students’voices and their
Influence on Adults in Creating more sustainable Environments in three schools’. Improving
Schools,Vol10: 72-85.
13. Skanavis, K. (2004). ‘Environment and Society: A Relationship in Continuous Evolution’,
Kaleidoscope Publications.
14. Steg, L., Perlaviviute, G., Werff, E. and Lurvink J. (2012). ΄ The Significance of Hedonic Values
for Environmentally Relevant Attitudes, Preferences and Actions΄. Environment and Behavior,
46 (2): 163-192.
15. UN. (1992). Report of the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development, Rio de
Janeiro: UN editions.
16. UNESCO. (2005). UN Decade of Education for Sustainable Development 2005-2014:
International Implementation Scheme – Draft, Paris.
17. https://el.wikipedia.org/wiki/ Environmental education (accessed September 5th ,2017).
18. http://old.primedu.uoa.gr/sciedu/new_ant/new_ergal.htm (accessed October 1st , 2016).
247
Environmental education
248
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Sustainable architecture, planning and development Urban environment
249
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
250
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
SUSTAINABLE URBAN PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPACTS: FROM THEORY TO PRACTICE THROUGH
INTERNATIONAL CASE STUDIES
E.K. Oikonomou* and K. Kalkopoulou
Department of Transportation and Hydraulic Engineering, Faculty of Rural & Surveying
Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Hellas
*Corresponding author: e-mail: eoikonom@topo.auth.gr, tel: +30 2310 994360
Abstract
It is widely recognized that there is a strong relation between planning, sustainable development and
environmental management: planning is an essentially collective, public interest activity, which
operates to secure the efficient and effective development and use of land (in the public interest), and
today a planning system should aim at guiding policy formulation and decision making towards the
goal of sustainable development. In most developed countries, the planning system is seen as a key
instrument in the delivery of sustainable development. Effective use of resources and materials,
energy efficiency, sustainable water resources management, atmospheric conditions and climate
factors and effective waste management towards a cycle economy reflect some crucial parameters
that can be related to planning in the 21st century.
In the present paper, examples of how sustainable planning strategies are implemented in several
urban areas internationally, are presented and conclusions are reached towards the target of
sustainable communities and high quality of life in urban areas. Furthermore, it is examined whether
and how the new Hellenic planning framework, as described by the Law 4447/2016, is capable of
establishing a stronger connection between future planning projects and sustainable development in
communities and urban areas. Special focus is placed on Local Spatial Plans, which reflect the new
key instrument for sustainable planning of Hellenic municipalities, while only predictions can be
made, as the new planning framework has not yet been implemented in practice: the technical
requirements of the new planning projects have just been enacted in June 2017 (Ministerial Decision
27016/2017). Therefore, assumptions can be made, based on similar planning projects’ experience,
on the efficiency of the new tool in promoting sustainable urban planning, diminishing the urban
‘footprint’ of Hellenic municipalities and dealing successfully with bureaucratic processes in
planning projects until their final approval by the necessary Presidential Decree. It is predicted that
Local Spatial Plans of the new Law 4447/2016 will be more effective in protecting ecologically
sensitive areas, promoting more effective waste management and sustainable transport mobility;
however, they will demand a great effort and extended time to be finally, approved by a Presidential
Decree.
Keywords: Sustainable urban planning, General Local Plans, Local Spatial Plans, The Law
4447/2016
1.
INTRODUCTION
Planning, as a system or an essentially collective, public interest activity, is regarded as a key issue
towards sustainable development, for many reasons: in most developed countries development plans
may include specific ‘green’ measures; secondly, environmental subjects may be placed at the front
251
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
of the plans, affecting the strategic options of the plans in other issues; and thirdly, development plans
may use sustainability criteria in all of their proposed development policies. Thus, land-use planning
is expected to meet the most critical objectives of sustainable development, such as economic
competitiveness, urban regeneration, rural diversification, sustainable transport and mobility
schemes, social inclusion, health and safety, and creation of sustainable communities. In order to
meet such targets, the planning system may: develop policies related to renewable energy supply and
use; promote sustainable transport by reducing traffic volumes, especially in cities, and encouraging
cycling and walking; develop waste management practices based on the implementation of recycling
and waste minimization methods; protect habitat, ecologically sensitive areas and wildlife sites, as
well as cities’ green space; and, finally, protect surface and ground water bodies, as well as minimize
air pollution, especially in cities and industrial areas [1]. As a result of this, General Local Plans, as
planning projects at municipality level, aim at promoting sustainable economic development,
encouraging and supporting of regeneration and social justice, and maintaining and enhancing of the
natural heritage and built environment quality [2]. General Local Plans influence economic
development and environmental protection by four main means: they offer inspiration, commitment,
guidance and control [3]. However, planning entails a participative democratic political system in
order to be considered as an effective tool for the conservation of resources and the control of
pollution and therefore, a necessary condition for the achievement of sustainable development [4].
Simultaneously, the notion of sustainable communities is in the center of planning attention, followed
by the ideas and values of democracy, public participation, social and ecological harmony, and social
cohesion [2]. And sustainable communities include the flexibility to adapt to new conditions, in order
to cover the economic and social needs of their members, as well as enhance a high-quality
environment [5]. Therefore, sustainable communities are based on: professionals that support with
their knowledge all other community members; community problems identification by all members’
participation; solutions to problems deriving from community members; introduction of sustainability
issues and indices to all community activities; public participation and consultations at all levels of
decision-making; and finally, social and cultural development by contribution of all community
members [6]. Major sustainability criteria for such communities and urban areas refer to issues of
local governance, urban design, innovation and competitiveness, consumption patterns, resources
management, global change impacts, urban transport and mobility, public space, spatial development,
etc. [7]. Especially for cities in developed and high-industrialized countries, the environmental targets
are set towards: minimization of per capita energy consumption and air emissions; minimization of
impacts to natural resources and ecosystems; use of renewable resources, replacing fossil fuels;
minimization of use of toxic substances and materials with substantial ecological footprint; and urban
design enhancing high quality of life through citizens’ health protection [8]. For this reason, the idea
of urban ecology has also been developed since the 1990s, which regards urban areas as ecosystems,
concentrating its efforts in assessing the urban environment and its biodiversity, in order to ensure
better quality of life and high standards for their citizens [9]. Eco-cities show major emphasis on their
structure, by copying the structure of the nature, while they include mostly two strategic goals:
sustainable urban mobility and urban biodiversity conservation [10].
2.
PLANNING PARADIGMS TOWARDS SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES
Following the trend of the 1980s and 1990s, related to the strong relation between planning and
environmental sustainability through the urban environment, many examples can be found in
European cities:
In Berlin, Block 103 is mentioned as an example of successful urban and social regeneration by
transforming old buildings, occupied by several citizens (squatters), to modern ecological
buildings, using new materials for energy efficiency, and showing emphasis on water resources
consumption and green space available. After the regeneration project, the squatters were offered
the opportunity to own the apartments they occupied. In Berlin, in the area Mitte another
252
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
regeneration project took place in the 2000s, as an effort to make the capital of Germany cleaner,
‘greener’ and ‘friendlier’ [11].
In Manchester and Glasgow, major urban regeneration projects took place in the city centers
(roads “Crown” and “Merchant City” in Glasgow and “Hulme” and “Whitworth” in Manchester),
by enhancing housing activities in the city centers, as well as cultural projects e.g. the Museum
of Science and Industry in Manchester and Glasgow Royal Concert Hall, as an effort to ‘revive’
the central urban areas [12]. The ‘Manchester 2020’ plan involved an effort to change and
ameliorate the urban environment, by: conservation, restoration and protection of the natural
environment, farmland and assets critical to public health and safety; conservation, restoration
and protection of cultural and historic resources; redevelopment of commercial centers and areas
with mixed land-uses; concentration of development around transportation nodes and major
transportation corridors; and expansion of housing opportunities and design choices in several
housing types. The plan also set a number of specific goals and targets e.g. for less ‘greenhouse’
gases emissions, less energy consumed, less traffic loads in urban areas, more green space in
urban areas, introduction of renewable energy resources and more jobs related to environmental
protection and management [2].
In Parma, plastic wastes are transformed into building material and in Rimini, an eco-station was
created for waste management by former drug addicts. The Oeiras project, a successful program
in the metropolitan area of Lisbon, reduced the amount of wastes disposed in the landfill, offering
also the inhabitants the possibility to produce a high-quality fertilizer for their gardens [11].
In many European cities programs for minimization of the use of vehicles in the city centers were
implemented: Naples and Perugia historic centers are no more accessible by vehicles; Amsterdam
is the capital city of the bicycle; in Copenhagen and Münster approximately 35% of all trips are
done by bicycles; in Zurich and La Rochelle bicycles are offered for free to inhabitants and
visitors; in many European cities the trams are important factors of the transport systems; in
Heidelberg, Freiburg, Basil there are areas of low noise; and in many Danish cities, in Paris,
Barcelona, Maastricht programs for road accidents minimization were implemented, as well as,
efforts to enhance the social bonds of the citizens [11].
Almere and Milton Keynes are two cities in the Netherlands and Britain, both designed in the 1970s,
for a population of around 200,000 inhabitants; however, they are mentioned as a typical example of
how urban planning affects urban mobility, which is related to major environmental impacts. The
different philosophy in urban design between the two cities led to five times more use of the bicycle
in Almere, although the average trip distances in both cities are almost the same (around 7 km), while
local trips are 20% more in Almere, reflecting the notion of its inhabitants to support local markets.
On the other hand, for this average trip of around 7 km in both cities, the time needed is 30% more
in Milton Keynes, which reflects worse traffic conditions than in Almere, with negative impacts in
energy (fuel) consumption for transport and air pollution [2].
Table 1: Basic urban transport characteristics for Almere and Milton Keynes, both designed
for a population of around 200,000 inhabitants
Basic urban transport characteristics
Almere
Milton Keynes
Percentage of trips by private vehicles (%)
43.1 %
65.7 %
Percentage of trips by bicycle (%)
27.5 %
5.8 %
Average distance travelled per trip (km)
6.85 km
7.18 km
Average trip duration (minutes)
11.0 min.
14.5 min.
74 %
60 %
Percentage of local trips
253
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
In Swansea, after the industrial decline of the second half of the 20th century, the urban
regeneration project led to: the Enterprise Zone in 1981, the first and largest in Britain, which
contributed to physical and economic inner city regeneration; the Maritime Quarter
redevelopment comprising the old docklands of the city offered physical and economic benefits
to the waterfront; and promotion of housing in the city center by expanding the residential
function in inner city area, bringing back people to the center [13].
In Greenpoint-Williamsburg of Brooklyn, New York, one of the poorest and degrades urban area
of the city, a program of environmental benefit was implemented, in cooperation with the
Municipality and local people; the aim was environmental monitoring by local people, in order to
reveal pollution sources and environmental problems, so as to be dealt successfully, early as
discovered. This program enhanced social cohesion and the development of trust and cooperation
between the local people [2].
In Singapore and Hong-Kong an excellent public transport system was developed, especially by
using modern electric trains and small, flexible buses. Apart for pedestrianization schemes and
many new bicycle routes, Singapore imposed taxes on citizens for their private vehicles. Finally,
a major parameter in Singapore was also the use of technology in planning, e.g. by enforcing ecommerce, while the government was committed to offer innovative and transparent policies and
guarantee for security in the urban area and political stability. Singapore is now considered as a
‘smart’ city for the effective transport system.
In Frankfurt, the major business and economic European center. a roadmap for a 100% renewable
energy supply was set in 2008, defining the main strategies and instruments to achieve this goal
by 2050. This master plan for 100% climate protection involves 50% reduction of energy
consumption, which will be achieved by energy savings and energy efficiency. Energy will be
produced 50% in Frankfurt and the rest in the Region of Rhine-Main. Another strategic plan of
the city in 2010 is related to noise reduction, by new green belts with bicycle lanes only, upgrade
of rail infrastructure and the use of new materials in road construction. During the period 19902010, water consumption by households and small enterprises was reduced by 14% and the
surface of green space and recreational areas was increased by 16.5% [14].
Curitiba, the 7th in size city of Brazil, is well known for its public urban transport generated in the
1980s, its integrated urban planning and the less number of accidents per 1,000 vehicles in Brazil.
City expansion to cover vast housing needs was followed by commercial activities and several other
services developed in new urban areas, while major pedestrianization schemes were implemented in
the city center, together with a renovation program of historic buildings. The result was not only to
make the city center accessible, eco-friendly and attractive to citizens, but also to attract various
cultural activities too. The urban public transport system serves more than 1,9 million inhabitants
daily, by the use of 2,160 buses. Bus lanes and traffic management succeeded in cutting down
economic expenses; consequently, it was realistic to implement an economic transport policy, which
was in favor of many inhabitants with low annual income. The bicycle network includes more than
120 km of bike lanes, mostly leading also to parks and recreational sites (Figure 1). In urban planning,
the period 1960-1980 was characterized by successful cooperation between the central government
and local stakeholders, while flexibility in solving quickly urban problems and public participation
in decision-making were in the center of its attention. Nowadays, Curitiba is believed to be the
ecological capital of Brazil with 28 parks and forest areas in the city, with an average surface of 52
m2 per inhabitant. Ecoville is famous for its high buildings surrounded by dense green space in
between them (Figure 2). The mobilization of local people in environmental management issues was
catalytic in enhancing green space, in waste management issues, such as recycling of several waste
streams as well as organic wastes (Figure 3). Social issues were also dealt with success: social housing
was constructed for citizens with very low income; the ‘Lighthouses of Knowledge’ project in the
1990s constructed 50 small buildings in the city, offering books and internet access to citizens, as
well as organizing several cultural activities (Figure 4); 40 special social centers offer for free food
254
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
and education to homeless children, while industries, which reflect a major economic activity in
Curitiba, cooperate in the project for homeless children, offering them the opportunity to work in
some special jobs like gardening or even office work; and two small buildings, located in two major
road corridors, . The industrial activities in the city area diminished their environmental impacts by:
using heat produced as by-product for heating purposes of communities; re-using and recycling of
wastes; and implementing the basic principles of industrial ecology. The example of Curitiba is
strongly related to a multi-level successful cooperation between the municipality, several
stakeholders and local people [15].
Figures 1 and 2: Bicycle lanes in Curitiba of the 120 km network and the area Ecoville with
high buildings and much green space in between them
Figures 3 and 4: Effective urban waste management and a ‘Lighthouse of Knowledge’
building
Ljubljana, the capital city of Slovenia, is also famous for its environmental performance. The
surface of green space in the city represents approximately the 2/3 of the total urban area, which
reflects an index of 560 m2 per inhabitant, including parks, forest areas, farmland and protected
natural areas, as a result of a rehabilitation program of brownfields. “Natura 2000” protected areas
represent more than 20% of the surface of the urban area. The bicycle lane network, a network to
rent a bicycle, a monthly card for public transport system that offers a transfer trip for free for the
first 90 minutes and a small number of electric vehicles reduced traffic loads in the city center, as
well as air pollution. In 2007 an ecologic zone in the city center was introduced, where vehicles
are not allowed to enter, and in 2013 it was expanded. The last decade there is a major program
for public buildings, in order to reduce energy consumption mostly in schools, nurseries and in
sport centers. In the city center, the urban waste disposal network is underground and a program
for waste minimization was implemented; as a result of this, the annual average amount of waste
disposed per capita was diminished by 52 kilos in three years, from 2009 to 2012. A major
strategic goal is also set: to inform citizens and professionals on innovative projects, activities,
255
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
competitions, issues and problems, which are related to the environment, so as to participate in
decision-making or expand their professions [16].
In Vancouver, the Canadian city with the smallest footprint in per capita CO2 emissions of all
cities in North America, the Greenest City Action Plan aims at a strong local economy, inclusive
and vibrant neighborhoods, and an internationally recognized city that meets the needs of future
generations. An important role is identified in local people, governmental institutions and private
stakeholders, which need to cooperate effectively to take initiative and action to make change
possible. In the economic sector, ‘green’ professions are enhanced, as well as ‘green’ economy in
general, including ‘green’ technology, products, construction, urban transportation, waste
management, etc. A good example is the Olympic Village, which was constructed in 2010 for the
Winter Olympic Games and used methods for energy efficiency and reduction of energy
consumption produced by fossil fuels, while today the area is used as a residential area, mixed
with commercial land-uses, services and recreational parks. In the transport sector, walking and
cycling were increased from 18% to 22% of total trips, while with the Program ‘Share the Road’,
in four neighborhoods for some hours every day, vehicles were not allowed to enter and roads
were transformed to playgrounds. In waste management, the ‘zero-waste’ production was set,
including waste minimization, recycling and reuse, and the Vancouver Tool Library was invented,
in order to share several tools for do-it-yourself and gardening. Finally, the Program ‘Our
Welcoming Community’ aims at social inclusion of any vulnerable citizens or groups, so as to
help them and support them with their problems [17].
In Hellas, the example of the village Anavra should be mentioned as a vey interesting example of
building sustainable communities. Anavra, a small mountainous village in Thessaly Region, Regional
Department of Magnesia, seemed to be a typical Hellenic mountainous village, difficult to access,
with poor infrastructure in terms of road, social aspects, and environmental management, and its
economy was based on livestock farming. In the 1990s a major change took place, by implementing
a scheme of redevelopment in terms of infrastructure projects and economic activities, as well as
environmental protection: all livestock farms were transferred to three new livestock parks, wellorganized, with freshwater installation and waste management techniques; pasture areas were made
accessible by new roads and water infrastructure; organic farming was set as an important target in
the primary sector; seminars and education programs were organized for the farmers; the road
network was reconstructed, as well as the water supply network, and a sanitary landfill was
constructed in 1994; regeneration of public space took place by several projects for pedestrian roads,
parks, car parking and appropriate lighting; new buildings were constructed for the kindergarten, the
primary school, the athletic center and housing for the teachers to cove their needs for free; a folklore
museum was opened, a community library was organized and a cultural center was built to support
several events, conferences, etc.; energy is produced by anaerobic digestion of livestock wastes,
which is used to heat water from a central boiler and heat all houses in the village; the Environmental
– Cultural Park was established in the natural environment nearby. Sustainable economic activities
provide jobs for all citizens and zero unemployment is identified, when in Hellas unemployment rates
are more than 25% the last years of the economic crisis. Anavra community was funded by some
economic resources deriving from a private investment of a wind-energy park, located in the
mountainous next to the village and this is how it was possible to support such development and
social projects. Apart from funding, there was a Mayor with a vision, looking for the change and local
people who were happy to participate in this project. Now the “miracle” of Anavra is fading away:
since 2011 Anavra has been part of the Municipality of Almyros, with 43 settlements and 18,614
inhabitants (census 2011); thus, the economic resources from the wind farm are now available to the
whole municipality and not the Anavra community only.
256
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.
PLANNING PROSPECTS IN HELLAS: IS IT POSSIBLE TO MAKE IT HAPPEN?
3.1 The past experience
Sustainable communities, ‘smart’ cities and many other titles are given to efforts to make urban areas
sustainable in terms of energy, transport, waste management, social inclusion, economic
development, etc. In European cities, as well as many other cities all over the world, many examples
can be found towards these goals and targets, while local authorities and citizens offer their
commitment to ameliorate the quality of life in urban areas and leave a better world to future
generations. However, in Hellas, many cities are still one or two steps backwards and very few
examples can be found, describing environmental planning activities. This may be explained by
looking briefly at the history and experience of planning in Hellas.
Although town planning legislation in Hellas has existed since 1923 (a Decree about Town Plans), it
took 60 years to establish technical requirements for urban and local planning projects at the level of
each community administrative boundaries (Law 1337/1983 “On the Extension of Cities and Towns,
Urban Development and Associated Arrangements”), while in the 1980s the Urban Reconstruction
Operation was responsible for many Community Local Plans and many urban plans all over the
Hellenic Territory, aiming at covering future housing needs in many settlements and controlling
unauthorized urban sprawl [18]. It is worth mentioning that the Law 1337/1983 dealt only with urban
areas, areas within their town limits, and there was no provision for rural areas, all areas in-between
urban areas; thus, there was no control of land-uses leading to conflicts in land-use patterns, which
were defined according to private investments.
It is not until the late 1990s that the Law 2508/1997 “Sustainable Urban Development of Cities and
Towns of Greece and Associated Arrangements” and the Law 2742/1999 “Regional Spatial Planning
and Sustainable Development”, try to keep up with European planning policies, covering spatial
development at urban, regional and national level and completing the institutional framework of the
contemporary planning system in Hellas [19]. The Law 2508/1997 regulates spatial planning at the
municipality level (General Local Plans, GLPs), which involves many settlements and their inbetween rural areas. It is an important law, bringing together environmental issues, sustainable
development and planning at a local level, as it clarifies that: GLPs are obligatory for all
municipalities and so land-use maps are produced, for the Hellenic territory; regeneration and
rehabilitation schemes of declining urban areas are in the center of attention of planning; there are
specific implementation mechanisms (urban planning studies) that are part of the whole planning
process; and, each GLP deals with the definition not only of land-use patterns within urban areas of
all of its towns, but also of the whole area of the municipality (urban and suburban land, agricultural
land, forests, etc.). Finally, UPSs are conducted in order to implement GLPs’ proposals, defining new
building areas, new streets, open green space and space for social facilities, building regulations, etc.
and the whole planning process is terminated by the Implementation Plan, which is officially recorded
in the appropriate Land Registration Office. The Law 2742/1999 provides with all necessary
regulations in relation to the targets and the principles of planning [20]. It is the first legislative
document introducing the environmental dimension in planning and this is proved by: firstly, the
adoption of the concept of sustainability, as perceived in the European Union, in regional planning;
and, secondly, there is an extensive reference on the protection of nature (article 15) and on the
necessary requirements in order to create managing authorities of the protected areas.
Planning in practice suffers from many deficiencies: it takes 5-10 years for the approval of a GLP by
the competent public authorities and 10-20 years for the approval of urban planning studies by
Presidential Decrees, as the State Court interferes in the approval process; public participation is
generally weak; bureaucracy and excessive regulation, as well as too many petitions for annulment
of administrative acts and administrative judges in Hellas, producing too many norms and principles
in spatial planning and a failure in successful decentralization of spatial planning responsibilities, as
discussed by Oikonomou (2013) [21]. Therefore, some new legal framework has been established
257
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
since 2014, making changes in the “heart” of the planning system in Hellas, in an effort to tackle the
deficiencies recognized by many authorities and practitioners.
3.2 The new legal framework
The Law 4269/2014 “Spatial and urban planning reform – Sustainable development.” was enacted in
the 28th June 2014: in Part A the new planning system and its tools are described, as well as the basic
processes for planning at all levels; and in Part B the new categorization of land uses is set, by
changing completely the old Presidential Decree for land uses of 1987. The latter was very useful and
important because since 1987 many new economic activities and land uses have risen, as well as
activities related to environmental management and protection, such as wastes recycling, composting,
etc. or renewable energy resources infrastructure, complex touristic development, technology parks
and industrial activities related to innovation, etc. However, there was not enough time for ministerial
decisions to be enacted in order to define some necessary details and technical requirements of the
new planning tools and projects, since elections took place in Hellas in January 2015 and the new
government elected abolished this law.
The Law 4447/2016 “Spatial planning – Sustainable development and other provisions.” was enacted
in the 23rd December 2016, replacing the abolished Law 4269/2014, at least the Part A, because the
issue of a new framework for up-to-date land uses is not included in the new legislation. Its most
important aspects are briefly mentioned below: in Part A all new definitions are described, as well as
the major parameters of the new planning system; Part B is related to Strategic Spatial Planning (SSP),
by describing the tools of Special Planning Frameworks and Regional Planning Frameworks; Part C
is dedicated to Regulatory Spatial Planning and refers to the Local Spatial Plans (LSP), the Special
Spatial Plans (SpSP) and Urban Implementation Plans; and several other provisions are mentioned in
the rest of the Law e.g. aspects of waste management and recycling issues (green points).
The Law 4447/2016 is important as it introduces a completely new planning system with novel
planning tools, especially at municipality level with Local Spatial Plans and Urban Implementation
Plans, as well as Special Spatial Plans aimed at spatial development mostly of public parcels of large
areas for touristic or other exploitation and development. The past planning system with General
Local Plans and Urban Planning Studies needed an average period of 15 – 30 years in order to be
approved and implemented; however, the Law 4447/2016 defines that Local Spatial Plans include all
aspects of the abolished General Local Plans, but also the regulatory framework of the Urban
Planning Studies as well and this is the reason why the planning projects are approved by Presidential
Decrees. More specifically, Local Spatial Plans define all land uses in the municipality area and in
detail in every town and settlement of the municipality, while they also define land use patterns in
each town area, as well as possible urban expansions to cover housing needs or specific future
economic activities. They also define the building regulations that are enacted in each urban area,
within its town limits. Thus, the new planning framework sets a target of planning at municipality
and town level simultaneously and this way, it seems that new planning proposals will be easier
implemented in less time than in the past. Planning projects of all levels are also followed by
environmental appraisal by Strategic Environmental Assessment, as described by the Ministerial
Decision 107017/2006. Two Ministerial Decisions 27016/2017 “Technical requirements of the Local
Spatial Plans” and 27022/2017 “Technical requirements of the Special Spatial Plans” define the
details of these planning tools. The technical requirements are quite detailed, however, there are
questions to be answered when the first planning projects will be assessed and implemented. The
Ministry of Environment and Energy is currently seeking for funding, in order to commence Local
Spatial Plans in municipalities in all Hellenic Regions and a possible solution could be to exploit EU
funding of the Programming period 2014-2020. When the first pilot Local Spatial Plans begin,
planners and all teams participating in the problems will face up difficulties and problems related to
technical and procedural issues mostly.
258
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
After presenting successful planning examples of cities all over the world, towards sustainable urban
development and commenting on the immaturity of the planning system in Hellas, since the early
1980s, some conclusions may be reached related to the new planning framework that has been
enacted since 2016, which seems to be some steps forward than the planning framework of the past,
offering an opportunity to propose, approve and implement planning projects of several levels quicker
than before. It could also be criticized that the new planning system, in terms of technical
requirements, is in favor of the use of modern tools, such as Geographic Information Systems, digital
spatial data available, etc. More specifically, the strengths of the new planning system can be
summarized as follows:
It offers the idea to municipalities of “one stop shop”, meaning that with just one planning project
(Local Spatial Plan) the municipality will be able to set all necessary planning and building
regulations, measures to protect the natural, cultural and built environment, proposals to enhance
sustainable economic development and social inclusion. Municipalities will have the opportunity to
plan starting from a more strategic level to a more detailed level, solving problems arising from the
implementation General Local Plans approved from 2000 up until now, as well as several
environmental issues, such as waste management, water resources management flood risk
minimization programs, etc.
The technical requirements of the Local Spatial Plans imply the use of modern tools and
technology aspects e.g. the use of Geographic Information Systems, satellite spatial data and
satellite images, data from the operating cadastral offices related to the properties of all land
parcels, data from the operating Forest Cadastre to define officially forest areas in the
municipality, etc.
By using digital spatial data and Geographic Information Systems, Local Spatial Plans will be
more flexible, easier to organize and present the necessary and available data in maps and the
aftermath, after their final approval by a Presidential Decree, will be related to the fact that the
LSP will be a valuable tool for the municipalities to be used for land uses monitoring in the future,
etc. Consequently, LSPs will add value to the municipalities and they will be used as a valuable
tool from several municipal authorities for many purposes. They may well contribute to
implement e-governance at local level, with all advantages related to the establishment of
transparency and democracy through participatory in decision-making.
It is also an excellent opportunity to organize effectively all data used in the LSP in appropriate
data bases and for this reason, all data will be assessed for its quality and reliability, consequently,
there will be references for the data used, affecting positively the quality of the LSP. Thus, the
GIS will be able to support municipal authorities even after the LSP is approved.
LSPs, as being approved by Presidential Decrees, will have the opportunity to change any other
plan of the past, “correcting” it, in favor of environmental protection and generally, local
communities. It is underlined that urban legislation in Hellas seems to be a “labyrinth”, since the
1980s, as many important issues defined in laws, ministerial decisions, etc. have been “blocked”
by the State Court several years after they have been enacted. By this way, it was impossible for
many planning projects to be implemented by local authorities. Such deficiencies may be dealt
with successfully by LSPs because before being approved by Presidential Decrees, they will be
examined by the Law Department of the State Court, controlling whether all proposals are
compatible with every piece of urban legislation.
Although the new legislative framework reflects a major “step” forward for planning in Hellas, there
are some questions still waiting for an answer:
First of all, digital spatial data in Hellas is still missing: only a small percentage of Hellenic
territory is covered by the cadastre, the forest cadastre; especially in rural territories cadastre is
259
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
more missing, because emphasis was shown in urban areas; and much other spatial data, such as
town limits, “Natura 2000” area limits, etc. exist in digital form, but their reliability is doubtful,
while this is the most important parameter. It is easy to have access to a polyline in its digital
form, but it is very difficult to find a “reliable” digital polyline. Consequently, LSPs will have to
struggle with this issue, unless they stay “inactive” until the projects of cadastre and forest
cadastre are finished. However, this could not be the proper solution; on the other hand, data used
in LSPs has to be reliable also because such studies are approved by Presidential Decrees and
mistakes are not “forbidden”.
Secondly, the total time needed from the beginning of a LSP Study to the final approval by
Presidential Decree is estimated in at least 10 years, taking into consideration the past experience
of the Urban Planning Studies, as the planning process is almost the same. Approval by
Presidential Decree means that at the end of the whole process of planning, the outcome as well
as some other crucial parameters e.g. the results of public consultations and participation are
submitted to the Ministry of Environment and Energy; then the whole process is checked and the
proposed plan is finally examined by the Law Department of the State Court – all proposed plans
of all Hellenic municipalities will have to pass this final legal control, which will result in great
delays.
Thirdly, delays in time needed for the final approval of LSPs by Presidential Decree may bring
more delays and the need to change some planning proposals of the LSPs. For example, the
Special Framework of Spatial Planning and Sustainable Development for Tourism was enacted
for the first time in Hellas in 2008 and in 2013 a new Framework was enacted in order to include
complex and major investments in tourism. However, sometime in 2015 the State Court decided
that the Special Framework of 2013 was not compatible with Hellenic Constitution and few
months later the same decision affected the Framework of 2008; Hellas has no more a strategic
plan for tourism! And GLPs needed to alter many of the proposals each time there was a new
decision of the State Court related to the Framework of Tourism. This is an example of how more
delays may be introduced in the whole planning process.
Finally, and most important, it is not at all obvious how such LSP Studies may introduce
sustainable criteria in environmental management, economic development and social inclusion or
how they can enhance initiatives and projects like the ones described in paragraph 2. Past
experience has shown that municipalities and local people are willing in promoting their own
interests, while many times environmental protection is regarded as an obstacle to their targets.
Although LSPs will be approved by Presidential Decrees, this does not guarantee that the plans
will include such proposals in order to promote “smart” cities, sustainable communities, etc., but
they only guarantee that the plans will be 100% compatible with all urban legislation in action.
To sum up with, there are many reasons to be optimistic about the new legal framework for planning
and the new planning system that is introduced. New procedures need to be implemented and public
participation should be enhanced in order to succeed in producing the best possible plans for local
people. However, it would be of great benefit to planning, if all legislation related to spatial and urban
planning could be simplified and if more tools related to e-governance were introduced in the new
planning process.
References
1. Selman P.H. (1996). ‘Local Sustainability: managing and planning ecologically sound
places.’ Paul Chapman Publishing.
2. Smith M., Whitelegg J. and N. Williams. (1998). ‘Greening the Built Environment.’ Earthscan
Publications Ltd.
3. Davidson F. (1996). ‘Planning for performance: requirements for sustainable development.’.
Habitat International, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 445-462.
260
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4. Blowers A. (1992). ‘Sustainable Urban Development: the Political Prospects.’ in: Sustainable
Development and Urban Form, (ed. M.J. Breheny), Pion Limited.
5. Roseland M. (2000). ‘Sustainable community development: integrating environmental,
economic, and social objectives.’ Progress in Planning, vol. 54, pp. 73-132.
6. Hautekeur G. (2005). ‘Community development in Europe.’. Community Development Journal
vol. 40, no. 4, pp. 385-398.
7. McCormick K., Anderberg S., Coenen L. and L. Neij. (2013). ’Advancing sustainable urban
transformation.’. Journal of Cleaner Production vol. 50, pp. 1-11.
8. Jepson E. and M. Edwards. (2010). ‘How Possible is Sustainable Urban Development? An
Analysis of Planners' Perceptions about New Urbanism, Smart Growth and the Ecological City.’.
Planning Practice & Research, vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 417-437.
9. White R.R. (2002). ‘Building the Ecological City.’ UK: Woodhead Publishing.
10. Register R. (2002). ‘Ecocities. Building Cities in Balance with Nature’ Berkeley: Berkeley
Hills Books.
11. Mega V. (2000). ‘Cities inventing the civilization of sustainability: an odyssey in the urban
archipelago of the European Union.’. Cities, vol. 17, no. 3, pp. 227-236.
12. Seo J-K. (2002). ‘Re-urbanisation in Regenerated Areas of Manchester and Glasgow’. Cities, vol.
19, no. 2, pp. 113-121.
13. Tallon A.R., Bromley R.D.F. and C.J. Thomas. (2005). ‘City profile Swansea’. Cities, vol. 22,
no. 1, pp. 67-76.
14. https://frankfurt-greencity.de (assessed February 2nd 2018).
15. Macedo J. (2004). ‘City profile Curitiba.’. Cities, vol. 21, no. 6, pp. 537-549.
16. Nastran M. and H. Regina. (2016). ‘Advancing urban ecosystem governance in Ljubljana.’.
Environmental Science & Policy, vol. 62, pp. 123-126.
17. Holden M. and A. Scerri. (2013). ‘More than this: Liveable Melbourne meets liveable
Vancouver.’ Cities, vol. 31, pp. 444-453.
18. Serraos K., Gianniris E. and M. Zifou. ‘The Greek spatial and urban planning system in the
European context.’ Available at: http://courses.arch.ntua.gr/106909.html (accessed February 2nd
2018).
19. Yiannakou A. and A. Tasopoulou. (2012). ‘Sustainable development, planning integration and
spatial plans in Greece: from the institutional framework to planning practice.’. Proc. 26th
Annual Congress of the Association of European Schools of Planning, eds. M. Blamir et al.,
Ankara, Turkey.
20. Christofilopoulos D.G. (2002). ‘Cultural Environment – Spatial Planning and Sustainable
Development.’, Economy & Law, P.N. Sakkoulas (in Greek).
21. Oikonomou E.K. (2013). ‘Planning for performance in Greece: the challenges and opportunities
ahead for development and environmental protection’. Proc. 4th Int. Conf. Environmental
Management, Engineering, Planning and Economics (CEMEPE 2013) and SECOTOX
Conf., eds. A. Kungolos, K. Aravossis, A. Karagiannidis, P. Samaras and K.W. Schramm,
Mykonos Island, Hellas, pp. 994-999.
261
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
A NOVEL METHOD FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL
ASSESSMENT OF PLANNING PROJECTS: THE CASE STUDY
OF THE GENERAL LOCAL PLAN OF GJIROKASTRA
MUNICIPALITY, ALBANIA
E.K. Oikonomou* and K. Kalkopoulou
Department of Transportation and Hydraulic Engineering, Faculty of Rural & Surveying
Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: eoikonom@topo.auth.gr , tel: +30 2310 994360
Abstract
The planning system is Albania is currently under reform, while in many municipalities General Local
Plans (GLPs) are conducted, with the aim of environmental protection of ecologically sensitive areas,
housing needs definition, new technical infrastructure identification, future development action
prediction and new building regulations’ formulation for urban areas. Within the planning process,
there is an effort to enhance public participation, through specific procedures with public hearings
and specialists’ meetings, promoting publicity and thus, transparency. As part of the planning process,
Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) studies are also conducted as necessary environmental
appraisal studies of the strategic proposals of the GLPs. Such planning and environmental projects
include several difficulties related to: lack of experience from public authorities; possible weak public
participation and consultation; and expectations from municipalities that may not be met, etc.
A novel method for strategic impact assessment is described in the present paper, reflecting a threelevel assessment with the aid of the tool of matrices, which are used in the first step of impact
identification, then in the second step of impact prediction and then in the last step of impact
evaluation. The purposes of the implemented method are: to be effective in strategic impacts
assessment of the GLPs’ proposals; to be easy to be used in several SEA studies for GLPs and not
just one specific study; to be comprehensive to the public authorities in Albania, which probably do
not have much experience in such environmental studies; and finally, to be simple and comprehensive
as well, for stakeholders and local people, so as to participate in public hearings and affect positively
the process of environmental appraisal of planning projects. The findings of a case study of the SEA
Study of the GLP of Gjirokastra Municipality are presented, showing great results and success in the
implementation of the tool of matrices in the three-level impact assessment.
Keywords: Strategic environmental assessment, General Local Plan, Matrix, Identificationprediction-evaluation
1.
INTRODUCTION
Strategic Environmental Assessment is an impact assessment tool, a systematic process for evaluating
environmental consequences of proposed policies, plans and programs – PPPs. SEAs are
implemented in PPPs, and their results affect Environmental Impact Assessment studies (EIAs) at the
project level [Arce R. and N. Gullón N. (2000)]. According to the definition for SEA, provided by
Therivel et al. (1992), it refers to “the formalized, systematic and comprehensive process of
evaluating the environmental effects of a PPP and its alternatives, including the preparation of a
written report on the findings of that evaluation, and using the findings in publicly accountable
262
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
decision-making” [Therivel R., Wilson E., Thompson, S., Heany, D. D. and Pritchard (1992)]. The
international regulatory framework for SEA is set by the European Directive 2001/42/EC and the
Kyiv SEA Protocol. The former defines a general framework for the environmental assessment of
proposed plans and programs prepared for agriculture, forestry, fisheries, energy, industry, transport,
waste management, water management, tourism, town and and land use planning, precluding proposed
policies, even if they set the framework for lower tiers, as well as excluding plans and programs related
to issues of national defense and civil emergencies [Directive 2001/42/EC of June 2001]. It is underlined
that the SEA Directive involves general requirements that do not pose restrictions to the Member States,
but it leaves space for them to formulate their own procedures in terms of scoping, screening, public
participation and consultation, etc. [Risse N., Crowley M., Vincke P. and J.-P. Waaub (2003)] The Kyiv
SEA Protocol to the Convention of Environmental Impact Assessment in a transboundary context,
prepared by the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe in 2003, is similar to the European
Directive, but also includes environmental assessment of proposed policies and legislation proposals; it
also shows more emphasis on health issues, impacts of proposed PPPs on human health [United Nations
Economic Commission for Europe (2003]. The tool of SEA has also been implemented by several
international organizations e.g. the UN Development Program, the UN Environment Program, the
USAID, the World Bank, the OECD Development Assistance Committee, etc., in order to offer
financial assistance to initiatives deriving from strategic policies, plans and programs that are
environmentally evaluated in terms of their possible impacts [Chaker A., El-Fadl K., Chamas, L. and
B. Ηatjian (2006)].
The main steps on SEA studies involve: screening, by determining the need for SEA, usually from a
mandatory list; identifying the necessity and goals of the PPP examined, as well as its relation with
other PPPs in force; setting objectives and targets, and establishing indicators; describing the major
parameters and aspects of the PPP that are predicted to provoke the most significant environmental
impacts; setting the environmental baseline and describing the environmental parameters that are
expected to be mostly affected by the proposed PPP; identifying, predicting and evaluating impacts
of the proposals and comparing alternative options; seeking mitigation measures to tackle the impacts
and describing the necessary monitoring system to be established; organizing public participation and
consultations; conducting the final report on SEA; and decision-making on both SEA and PPP
examined. These steps are described in the SEA Directive and are included in all relative legislation
of Member States, more or less, with minor modifications, as also in Hellas and Albania. Specific
issues that are mostly procedural and bureaucratic are considered of less importance and not further
discussed for this reason. The SEA process (Figure 1), as described in Hellenic Ministerial Decision
107017/2006, involves the following steps: the competent authority (CA), responsible to prepare a
SEA study for the proposed Plan or Program, submits the SEA preliminary report to the responsible
for approval authority (RAA); RAA organizes consultation and public participation process; CA
organizes one public presentation of the SEA preliminary report and makes it publicly available for
45 days; the findings of the consultation and participation process are taken into consideration for the
approval of the SEA by the RAA, otherwise CA is asked to alter the SEA and possibly the proposed
Plan, according to these findings and resubmit it to RAA for the final approval. Planning projects and
SEA studies are either approved by the Ministry of Environment and Energy or by the Decentralized
Authority: in many cases bureaucratic problems arise when the planning project is municipal e.g. a
General Local Plan, approved by the Decentralized Authority, while its SEA study is approved by
the Ministry because within the municipal boundaries there is a “Natura 2000” protected area.
A similar SEA process exists in Albania. First of all, Albania is part of the Stabilization and
Association Process, announced for five Eastern European countries at the Zagreb Summit in 2000,
while in order to become an EU Member State, the criteria established in the Copenhagen European
Council in June 1993 must be met. Since then, Albania has adopted much European legislation in its
national legislation, while the National Plan for European Integration was synchronized with the
National Strategy for Development and Integration 2014-2020. Albania has introduced policies
through legislation for sustainable waste, wastewater and water management, sustainable planning at
263
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
national and municipal level, environmental impact assessment of projects, strategic environmental
assessment of plans and programs, and protection of ecologically sensitive areas and nature. SEA was
introduced in February 2013 by the Law 91/2013 (on SEA), while EIA was introduced in July 2011
by the Law 10440/2011 (on EIA) and planning projects at municipal level supported the reform of
Albania by the Law 107/2014 (on development of the territory). The Albanian SEA process is
considered to be simpler and more clarified than the Hellenic one: the competent authority (CA) sends
a notification to the Ministry (the one and only responsible for approval authority), including some
general information on the proposed plan, the environmental parameters expected to be affected, as
well as the need to conduct a SEA study; the Ministry approves the commencement of the process
and informs the public about it by a preliminary declaration within 30 days; the CA organizes a
preliminary public hearing and consultations with regional authorities in case of a municipal plan, in
order to conclude of people’s and authorities’ opinions related to the most crucial environmental
parameters, the opportunities for sustainable environmental management, the environmental factors
that may be affected by the proposed plan, etc.; the CA prepares the preliminary SEA report and
makes it available for a public hearing as well as consultations with regional authorities; the final
SEA report is prepared and the total SEA (SEA report and a report with all opinions of stakeholders,
public authorities and institutions participated in the consultations) are submitted to the Ministry for
the final approval (environmental declaration).
Figure 1: The SEA process, as described in the Hellenic Ministerial Decision 107017/2006
2.
COMMENTS ON STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
First of all, the necessity for SEA is based on two major aspects: it counteracts some of the limitations
of EIAs, such as additive effects of many small projects (cumulative impacts), indirect impacts and
synergistic impacts deriving from different projects in the same geographical area; and it may
promote sustainable development by introducing early in strategic planning decision-making process
sustainability criteria or more generally, environmental parameters and issues to be dealt with
[Therivel R. and Partidario (1996)]. Consequently, its major advantages refer to: taking into
consideration environmental issues and aspects while forming strategic action through PPPs; the
capability of dealing with cumulative and synergistic impacts, not able to be dealt with by EIA at a
project level; promotion of PPPs alternatives; and incorporation of environmental and sustainability
aspects in strategic decision-making [Therivel R. (2004)]. What is underlined by Noble (2000) is
characteristic: EIA is reactive as it reacts or assesses a particular option, a specific project, while SEA
is proactive, by examining alternative options and focusing on alternatives, opportunities, regions and
264
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
sectors [Noble B.F. (2000)]. In its worldwide implementation the last 20 years, SEA may be organized
in several different ways: firstly, SEA may be introduced as EIA-based, following the requirements
of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) legislation (uses similar tools for impact assessment);
secondly, the SEA process runs parallel but independently from the planning process; thirdly, SEA
is part of the planning process; and finally, the SEA framework is defined by the planning process,
according to its level of requirements. However, what is really important, reflects the following
issues: if SEA is sustainability-led, using sustainability criteria to assess possible significant
environmental impacts of proposed PPPs; the extent to which SEA will be accepted, adopted and
implemented; the effectiveness in public participation, as a means of increasing transparency of
planning and decision-making; the objectivity of the SEA process; and its effectiveness in shaping
public decision-making [United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (2003)].
Apart from strategic impact identification and evaluation, the importance of public participation in
the SEA process is widely recognized: it can provide valuable information on the proposed PPP and
the SEA study, and contribute to identify weaknesses in the study; it can show how groups and
stakeholders are affected by the impacts identified by the SEAs; it may reduce the danger of later
delays by protest actions against proposed projects and actions; it may help in viable suggestions for
mitigation measures and alternative scenarios; it may contribute positively to public awareness, by
making citizens more interested in public affairs and more environmentally responsible; and it may
reduce time needed for public participation in EIAs, at the project level [Seht von H. (1999)].
However, it is also underlined that: political systems are traditionally based on closed and limited
participation procedures; and public participation depends on pluralistic and democratic structures in
several countries that are implemented. It is also believed that the SEA Directive requires that the
public is involved too late in the decision-making process when alternatives and preferences have
already been defined [Kornov L. (1997)].
SEA has also disadvantages, related to the fact that it adds extra cost and time needed for plans and
programs approval, and deals with much complexity, as there is an interaction and relevance between
many plans and programs between them, which must also be taken into consideration. It is also
believed that SEA has generally focused on impact assessment and its proactive role in strategic
decision-making, thus leaving implementation of SEA (follow-up) aside [Gachechiladze-Bozhesku
M. and T.B. Fischer (2012)]. This may be due to: lack of legislated requirements for SEA follow-up;
non-suitable existing monitoring systems that cannot contribute to SEA follow-up; vague follow-up
goals as described in the monitoring program of the SEA study; costs of implementing a monitoring
program or unavailability of skills or resources, etc.
It should be underlined that it is not easy to conclude on the quality and effectiveness of SEA,
implemented in many countries the last 20 years or more. Firstly, quality refers to all SEA process,
including the assessment methods, the institutional arrangements, the whole procedure with public
participation and consultations: thus, the quality of information used in SEA, analysis and synthesis
of different opinions of stakeholders, technical validity and credibility affect the idea of quality.
Secondly, effectiveness refers to the output of the quality of the SEA and to the SEA follow-up, which
are related to the achievement of the environmental goals set by the SEA, the realization of the
impacts predicted and evaluated, the successful implementation of mitigation measures, the
effectiveness of the SEA monitoring system and the influence of SEA on the project-level EIAs that
are related to the PPPs examined by the SEAs [Gachechiladze-Bozhesku M. and T.B. Fischer (2012)].
Van Doren et al. (2013) refer to the quality of SEA as “procedural effectiveness” and to the
effectiveness of SEA as “substantial effectiveness”, while criteria are set in order to evaluate the
substantial effectiveness of SEA: acquaintance (planners consult the SEA), consideration (SEA is the
reason to review and develop further the PPPs), consent (proposed PPPs are altered according to the
SEA results), formal conformity (the PPPs become environmentally friendlier due to the SEAs),
behavioral conformity (the PPPs affect follow-up tiers e.g. other plans and programs or projects) and
final conformity (environmental protection, proved by several environmental indicators and quality
standards) [Van Doren D., Driessen P.P.J., Schijf B. and H.A.C. Runhaar (2013)]. The general factors
265
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
influencing the success of SEA are summarized by Zhang et al. (2013), who found that the
communication and interaction between several stakeholders are important factors for SEA
implementation, as communication is responsible for acceptance of the SEA and also values its
results. PPPs are sometimes vague and abstract, limiting communication and coordination, while
affecting transparency too. Other important factors include: resources related to available time and
money, factors that affect both participation and the quality of the assessment; timing and
organization e.g. planning and SEA may be interacting and parallel or SEA may be adapted to existing
planning procedures; and political will and trust between stakeholders and other participants that
affects also transparency and implementation of SEA. The results, related to how several scientists
and stakeholders regard SEA, are also interesting: some planners see SEA as “more of the same”;
developers regard SEA as one more administrative obstacle; environmentalists may see it as a
bureaucratic process with no practical influence on the proposed PPP; and SEA practitioners have a
weak understanding of strategic decision making [Zhang J., Christensen P. and L. Kornov (2013)].
On the contrary, Noble’s research on SEA studies reached the conclusion that many of them are
labelled as “SEA”, but they are in fact non-strategic assessments, as they are not focused on
alternative options, they do not examine broader visions, goals and objectives, but they rather assess
impacts of predetermined options [Noble B.F. (2000)].
Chaker et al. (2006) examined the SEA systems in 12 developed countries all over the world in terms
of legislation, responsible authorities, screening, scoping, types of impacts considered, public
participation, alternatives and mitigation of impacts. It was concluded that a SEA system should draw
special attention to: early consideration of significant impacts, including synergistic and cumulative
impacts (this is an opportunity for SEA, while EIA is difficult to identify, predict and evaluate such
impacts of proposed projects); formulation of better alternative scenarios of the proposed PPPs; public
participation and effective stakeholder involvement for transparency and effectiveness of the SEA;
and finally, the efficiency of strategic decision-making [Risse N., Crowley M., Vincke P. and J.-P.
Waaub (2003)]. However, the methodologies/tools used for impact assessment were not examined
and compared between the different SEA systems, although the use of such tools is considered to be
important. Von Seht underlines correctly that the closer the policy, plan or program is to the following
project stage, the more detailed the environmental assessment of the SEA should be and at the end,
at the project level, EIA should include the most detailed assessment [Noble B.F. (2000)]. As a result
of this, it is obvious that the more detailed the environmental assessment is in a SEA, the more detailed
will be the mitigation measures of the expected impacts, as well as the environmental indices for the
monitoring program.
In Hellas, experience on SEA, as implemented in National, Regional and Municipal Plans, in
Sectorial Plans for Industry, Tourism, Fisheries, Renewable Energy, in the Regional Operational
Programs 2007-2013 and 2014-2020, necessary for the EU Funds, and in several private planning
projects, shows that in terms of the impacts assessment methods used, there is not much variety: in
many SEA studies the methodology is similar to the one used in the Handbook on SEA for Cohesion
Policy [Helander E. and G. Lawrence (2006)]. The tool of matrix is used for impacts assessment and
therefore, simple matrices are used, together with the symbols proposed in the above-mentioned
handbook, usually one matrix per environmental factor, followed by the necessary text that presents
arguments about the characterization of environmental impacts. The assessment is done in one level;
there is only qualitative evaluation of impacts, while the steps of impacts identification and prediction
are not included, as proposed in methodologies for EIA studies [Glasson J., Therivel R. and A.
Chadwick (2012)]. It should be underlined that no specific technique for impact assessment is
proposed by the Ministerial Decision 107017/2006.
3.
THE SEA OF THE GENERAL LOCAL PLAN OF GJIROKASTRA MUNICIPALITY
3.1 The area of study and the proposed General Local Plan
Gjirokastra Municipality is located in the southwest part of Albania, including an area of 469 km2,
with a population of around 29,000 inhabitants. The city of Gjirokastra (20,000 inhabitants), known
266
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
as the “city of stone”, is built in the eastern side of the Mount Gjerë and its old part of the city has
been in UNESCO World Heritage since 2005 for the famous old castle – the biggest in Albania, with
the Museum of Weapons inside – and the traditional buildings. The city was built in the 4th century
and was named Argyrokastro (Hellenic name) in 1336, while in 1417 it was conquered by the
Ottoman army. The characteristics of old traditional houses – some of them newly restored (e.g. the
house where the famous writer Ismail Kadare was born) – with the fortress look, the streets of
cobblestone, the National Folk Festival (in the house of dicator Enver Hoxha was born), the
Ethnographic Museum, the Old Bazaar, the archaeological park of Antigone (ancient town found by
King Pyrrus of Epirus in 295 B.C. with a 4 km fortification around it), 14 km away from Gjirokastra,
the many Byzantine churches in the municipality (the oldest and most beautiful St Mary in the village
of Labove e Kryqit), the ancient theater of Hadrianopolis with a capacity of 4,000 seats and the ancient
settlement of Paleokaster are some major parameters for tourism attraction, bringing a special color
in the area. Gjirokastra, located between the lowlands of Western Albania and the highlands of
Central Albania, is characterized by a Mediterranean climate, with warm summer (average high
temperature 34oC in August) and heavy rainfall during the period November – February (total 1.800
mm annually). The natural environment of the municipality is characterized by: the River Drino and
its small productive valley, tributary of the River Aoos, with source in Epirus Region of Hellas, total
length of 85 km and basin size of 1,320 km2, contributing to a small productive valley with
opportunities for irrigation; the strict protected area of Kardhiq (Natura 2000); the natural monument
of Zheji (proposed as a Natura 2000 area); and the natural park Rrëzomë of 1,400 Ha with important
biodiversity.
Figures 2 - 3: Part of the old traditional urban area of Gjirokastra and part of the castle
[photos by co-authors]
The General Local Plan of Gjirokastra Municipality was conducted in three phases: the first phase
was the analysis of existing situation, covering all aspects of population and demographic issues,
cultural aspects, urban characteristics and land-uses in all settlements, all parameters of the natural
environment, covering issues in geology, water, wastewater and waste management, natural protected
areas and characteristics of flora and fauna, climate conditions, etc., current technical infrastructure,
landscape and morphology of the area, economic issues for professional activities and investments,
environmental and other problems, sources of pollution, etc.; the second phase included the proposals
for the territorial strategy, proposals for every system (natural, water, urban, infrastructural and
agricultural) together with SWOT analysis, the vision of the strategy, the strategic objectives and the
priority axes for each strategic objective, and finally, the action plan for all proposed projects with
emphasis on priority projects and pilot projects; the third phase of the General Local Plan involved
detailed land-use patterns for all settlements and all municipal territory, detailed proposals on building
regulations in every settlement and the action plan of the second phase in its final form. It is worth
noticing that the SEA was conducted simultaneously with the third phase of the General Local Plan,
assessing the impacts of the strategic proposals of the second phase (objectives and priority axes).
267
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Figures 4 - 5: River Drino in the summer and old traditional bridge [photos by co-authors]
3.2 The three-level impact assessment of the SEA
It was chosen to assess environmental impacts of the GLP’s proposals by a three-level impact
assessment, using the simple tool of matrix, in variations, in order to identify, predict and evaluate
the environmental impacts. The notion of this three-level impact assessment derives from EIA
international literature and not EIA practice – as it is concluded EIA studies do not include such a
detailed assessment. The methodology is detailed but simple to present, easy to explain, both to public
authorities, regional institutes and authorities as well as to the Ministry, responsible for the approval
of the SEA. The methodology was also proved to be satisfactory in terms of scientific cooperation
between all members of the SEA study, as it offered clarification to many issues related to expected
impacts and their significance. As proposed by the Hellenic and Albanian SEA legislation (and the
Directive 2001/42EC), the impacts are examined in the fields of soil, air, climatic factors, water,
biodiversity, wastes, noise, material assets, cultural heritage and landscape.
The first step of this impact assessment methodology is identification of potential impacts of the
General Local Plan on the environment. Therefore, the following simple matric is formed with all
proposed priority axes (PA) in the first column and all environmental parameters examined in the
next columns. If a significant effect between a priority axis and an environmental parameter is
identified, the symbol “√” is used, otherwise, if no effect is identified, the symbol “X” is used (Table
1). The simple matrix, is further explained and justified in the SEA study of Gjirokastra Municipality
General Local Plan by helpful text with arguments on how an effect may be expected or not between
each priority axis and all the environmental parameters examined – however, it is not possible to
include these arguments in this paper. It is worth noticing that these arguments have been accepted
by all authorities and stakeholders, participating in the SEA process, either in the consultation stages
or in the final approval stage.
The second step of this impact assessment methodology is prediction of potential impacts of the GLP
on the environment: for this reason, the same simple matrix is used, as follows, by using colours,
instead of symbols, with two variations of green expressing a positive impact, yellow and red a
negative impact and grey expresses that there is no impact identified (Table 2). In Table 2 it is worth
noticing that in some cases, inside a cell, two different colours may be seen e.g. in PA 11 “Use of
Renewable Energy Resources” it is believed that it may have negative impacts on water if small
hydropower stations may be constructed in the future and if they do not operate with sustainable
criteria in terms of water management; the same PA is believed to have very negative impacts on
landscape if wind farms may be constructed in the future next to several traditional settlements or in
the top of mountainous areas, depending on their visibility to many people; however, some people
find wind farms “attractive” because they are a symbol of “green” energy.
268
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Landscape
Cultural
Heritage
Material
Assets
Noise
Wastes
Biodiversity
Water
Climatic
factors
Air
Soil
Table 1: The simple matrix used for environmental impact identification
Strategic Objectiv 1: Strengthening the key position of the Municipality as a southern gateway of Albania,
while strengthening the role of Gjirokastra as a regional tourism center.
PA 1: Improve and strengthen the national
√ √
√
Χ √ Χ √
√
√
√
transport infrastructure
PA 2: Monitoring system of land-use changes in
Χ Χ
Χ
Χ Χ Χ Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Gjirokastra Region
Strategic Objectiv 2: Protecting and promoting the cultural environment of the Municipality and its cultural
heritage.
PA 3: Promotion of archaeological / cultural
monuments and traditional buildings of the Χ √
Χ
Χ Χ Χ √
√
√
√
Municipality.
PA 4: Strengthening the tourist activity and
√ √
Χ
√ Χ √ √
√
√
√
development of alternative forms of tourism.
Strategic Objectiv 3: Economic revitalization of the area led by the principles of sustainable development,
through the expansion of production base and balanced development of the three production sectors.
PA 5: Strengthening tertiary activities in
Gjirokastra (additional public services, trade, Χ Χ
Χ
√ Χ √
√
√
√
√
tourism) in order to create new jobs.
PA 6: Enforcement of the secondary production
Χ Χ
Χ
√ Χ √
√
√
√
Χ
sector.
PA 7: Strengthening local economy through
√ Χ
Χ
√ Χ Χ X
Χ
√
Χ
employment opportunities in the primary sector.
Strategic Objectiv 4: Protection and sustainable management of the natural environment by emphasizing
and promoting the strong points of the Municipality.
PA 8: Protection and sustainable management of
√ Χ
Χ
Χ √ √ Χ
√
Χ
√
natural resources.
PA 9: Protection and sustainable management of
√ Χ
Χ
√ √ Χ Χ
√
Χ
√
water resources.
PA 10: Protection of cultivated land and
√ Χ
Χ
√ Χ √ Χ
√
Χ
√
agricultural space.
PA 11: Use of Renewable Energy Resources.
√ √
√
√ √ Χ √
√
Χ
√
Strategic Objectiv 5: Improving the quality of life of the inhabitants by completing the technical
infrastructure and creating a high level of social infrastructure.
PA 12: Improvement of urban public utility
networks (water supply, sewage, energy, waste √ √
Χ
√ √ √ Χ
√
Χ
Χ
management) in the city and other settlements,
PA 13: Improving social infrastructure
Χ Χ
Χ
Χ Χ Χ Χ
√
Χ
Χ
(education and health).
PA 14: Urban renovation and planning in
√ √
√
√ Χ Χ √
√
√
√
settlements.
PA 15: Improving mobility and public transport
Χ √
√
Χ Χ Χ √
√
√
√
at the municipal level.
PA 16: E-government and the improvement of
Χ √
Χ
Χ Χ √ √
√
√
Χ
electronic infrastructure.
PA 17: Strengthening the role of the University. √ Χ
Χ
√ Χ √ Χ
√
√
√
269
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Landscape
Cultural
Heritage
Material
Assets
Noise
Wastes
Biodiversity
Water
Climatic
factors
Air
Soil
Table 2: The simple matrix used for environmental impact prediction
Strategic Objectiv 1: Strengthening the key position of the Municipality as a southern gateway of Albania,
while strengthening the role of Gjirokastra as a regional tourism center.
PA 1: Improve and strengthen the national
transport infrastructure
PA 2: Monitoring system of land-use changes in
Gjirokastra Region
Strategic Objectiv 2: Protecting and promoting the cultural environment of the Municipality and its cultural
heritage.
PA 3: Promotion of archaeological / cultural
monuments and traditional buildings of the
Municipality.
PA 4: Strengthening the tourist activity and
development of alternative forms of tourism.
Strategic Objectiv 3: Economic revitalization of the area led by the principles of sustainable development,
through the expansion of production base and balanced development of the three production sectors.
PA 5: Strengthening tertiary activities in
Gjirokastra (additional public services, trade,
tourism) in order to create new jobs.
PA 6: Enforcement of the secondary production
sector.
PA 7: Strengthening local economy through
employment opportunities in the primary sector.
Strategic Objectiv 4: Protection and sustainable management of the natural environment by emphasizing
and promoting the strong points of the Municipality.
PA 8: Protection and sustainable management
of natural resources.
PA 9: Protection and sustainable management
of water resources.
PA 10: Protection of cultivated land and
agricultural space.
PA 11: Use of Renewable Energy Resources.
Strategic Objectiv 5: Improving the quality of life of the inhabitants by completing the technical
infrastructure and creating a high level of social infrastructure.
PA 12: Improvement of urban public utility
networks (water supply, sewage, energy, waste
management) in the city and other settlements.
PA 13: Improving social infrastructure
(education and health).
PA 14: Urban renovation and planning in
settlements.
PA 15: Improving mobility and public transport
at the municipal level.
PA 16: E-government and the improvement of
electronic infrastructure.
PA 17: Strengthening the role of the University.
Consequently, in order to deal with the vague character of the GLP and its impact on the SEA study,
scenarios can be developed in some cases and inside a cell, two different colours may be used to
express these two different scenarios. Another example may be the development of the primary
270
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
sector: it may cause negative impacts on soil, if many agrochemicals are used to increase production,
but if organic farming is developed, then impacts on soil may be positive.
Finally, the third step of this impact assessment methodology is evaluation of potential impacts of the
General Local Plan on the environment: for this reason, many simple matrices are used, as follows,
one matrix for each environmental parameter, by using the symbols (enriched) of the Handbook on
SEA for Cohesion Policy 2007-2013 [Helander E. and G. Lawrence (2006)]. These symbols are
presented in Table 3:
Table 3: Assessment Legend (third step – evaluation)
Impact character
Probability
Scale
Frequency/Duration
Reversibility
Transboundary dimension
Uncertainty
Sequence
Interoperability
Symbols
!!
!
0
++
+
0
–
––
>>
>
0
IR
R*
R
TR
0
?
P
S
C
SI
0
Explanation
Very probable
Probable
Not probable
Large-scale positive
Positive
Neutral
Negative
Large-scale negative
Frequent to constant / Long-term to permanent
Occasional / Short-term
Not viable
Irreversible
Reversible under mitigation measures
Reversible
Possible transboundary effect
Not transboundary effect
Possible impacts depend on implementation of the GLP
Primary impact
Secondary impact
Cummulative impact
Synergistic impact
Not influence with other parameters / impacts
As it is not possible to present all matrices used in the third step of this impact assessment
methodology, let us refer to an example, the matrix of the environmental parameter of water. In the
first left column of the matrix, all priority axes that are identified and predicted to have a negative or
positive impact on water are presented and then the characteristics of these impacts are described by
using the symbols of Table 3. Each simple matrix for each environmental parameter, as the one
presented in Table 4, is followed by arguments presenting and explaining the character of impacts
expected. It should be underlined that reversibility of possible impact is only examined for negative
impacts; when there is uncertainty, then this impact character affects also “scale”, by using both
“negative” and “positive” symbols.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
A novel approach of three-level impact assessment is presented, as used in SEA study of Gjirokastra
Municipality GLP. This new methodology is believed to offer specific advantages in the SEA process,
for all stakeholders:
271
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
First of all, it made it easier for all participants in the SEA study (group of scientists preparing the
draft and final report) to organize better impact assessment, by making for themselves the process
of impact assessment clearer and more specific. It was also easier for them to communicate,
cooperate and discuss some issues with the planners working on the GLP project of Gjirokastra
Municipality.
Interoperability
Frequency/
Duration
PA 9: Protection and sustainable management of
water resources.
!!
++
>>
P
PA 10: Protection of cultivated land and
agricultural space.
!!
++
>>
S
PA 12: Improvement of urban public utility
networks (water supply, sewage, energy, waste
management) in the city and other settlements.
!!
++
>>
P
PA 14: Urban renovation and planning in
settlements.
!!
+
>>
P
PA 17: Strengthening the role of the University.
!
+
>>
S
PA 4: Strengthening the tourist activity and
development of alternative forms of tourism.
!!
–
>>
R
0
P
0
PA 5: Strengthening tertiary activities in
Gjirokastra (additional public services, trade,
tourism) in order to create new jobs.
!!
–
>>
R
0
P
0
PA 6: Enforcement of the secondary production
sector.
!!
–
>>
R
0
P
0
PA 7: Strengthening local economy through
employment opportunities in the primary sector.
!!
–
>>
R
0
P
C
PA 11: Use of Renewable Energy Resources.
!
+/–
>>
R/IR
0
P
0
?
Sequence
Scale
Transboundary
dimension
Uncertainty
Priority Axes with negative or positive impacts on
water, according to the findings of Table 1 and
Table 2.
Probability
Reversibility
Table 4: The evaluation of impacts of the General Local Plan of Gjirokastra Municipality on
water
Impact character
Secondly, as a more detailed impact assessment methodology, it seems that it helped local
authorities, regional authorities, local people, any stakeholders participating in the consultation
phase, to understand in depth how a SEA assesses impacts of a GLP in a strategic level. This was
very useful, because in Albania there is not much experience in SEA studies and it had to be clear
that SEA does not deal with projects and details but evaluates impacts in a strategic level,
proposing mitigation measures at a “parallel” strategic level, as well as a monitoring system with
more vague and strategic indicators.
Thirdly, the results of the consultations and opinions of public authorities and stakeholders
showed that only minor revisions were made to the draft SEA report, the final SEA report was
272
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
accepted by the Ministry without any comments and the environmental declaration (the official
acceptance of the SEA by the Ministry) was issued in less than five months from the beginning
of the SEA process.
In conclusion, the three-level impact assessment methodology, as presented, is proposed to be the
best available technique to identify, predict and evaluate environmental impacts of GLPs at municipal
level, as advantages are identified for all parties of the SEA process (scientists preparing the SEA
reports, public authorities, local people, stakeholders, regional authorities, ministry, etc.).
References
1. Arce R. and N. Gullón N. (2000) ‘The application of Strategic Environmental Assessment to
sustainable assessment of infrastructure development.’ Environmental Impact Assessment
Review, Vol. 20, pp. 393-402.
2. Therivel R., Wilson E., Thompson, S., Heany, D. D. and Pritchard (1992) ‘Strategic
Environmental Assessment’, Earthscan Publications Ltd.
3. Directive 2001/42/EC of June 2001 on ‘the assessment of the effects of certain plans and programs
on the environment.’, Official Journal of the European Communities, L 197, p. 30.
4. Risse N., Crowley M., Vincke P. and J.-P. Waaub (2003) ‘Implementing the European SEA
Directive: the Member States’ margin of discretion.’, Environmental Impact Assessment
Review, Vol. 23, pp. 453-470.
5. United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (2003) ‘Protocol on Strategic
Environmental Assessment to the Convention on Environmental Impact Assessment in a
Transboundary Context’. Available at: www.unece.org (accessed February 12th 2018).
6. Chaker A., El-Fadl K., Chamas, L. and B. Ηatjian (2006) ‘A review of strategic environmental
assessment in 12 selected countries.’, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, Vol. 26, pp.
15-56.
7. Therivel R. and Partidario (1996) ‘The practice of Strategic Environmental Assessment.’,
Earthscan Publications Ltd.
8. Therivel R. (2004) ‘Strategic Environmental Assessment in Action’, 1st ed. Earthscan.
9. Noble B.F. (2000) ‘Strategic Environmental Assessment: what is it? And what makes it
strategic?’, Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, Vol. 2, No. 2, pp.
203-224.
10. Seht von H. (1999) ‘Requirements of a Comprehensive Strategic Environmental Assessment
System.’ Landscape and Urban Planning, Vol. 45, pp. 1-14.
11. Kornov L. (1997) ‘Strategic Environmental Assessment.’ European Environment, Vol. 7, pp.
175-180.
12. Gachechiladze-Bozhesku M. and T.B. Fischer (2012) ‘Benefits of and barriers to SEA follow-up
– Theory and practice.’, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, Vol. 34, pp. 22-30.
13. Noble B.F. (2003) ‘Auditing Strategic Environmental Assessment practice in Canada.’, Journal
of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, Vol. 5, No. 2, pp. 127-147.
14. Van Doren D., Driessen P.P.J., Schijf B. and H.A.C. Runhaar (2013) ‘Evaluating the substantive
effectiveness of SEA: towards a better understanding.’ Environmental Impact Assessment
Review, Vol. 38, pp. 120-130.
15. Zhang J., Christensen P. and L. Kornov (2013) ‘Review of the critical factors for SEA
implementation.’, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, Vol. 38, pp. 88-98.
16. Helander E. and G. Lawrence (2006) ‘Handbook on SEA for Cohesion Policy 2007-2013.’
Available at: www.ec.europa.eu (accessed February 12th 2018).
17. Glasson J., Therivel R. and A. Chadwick (2012) ‘Introduction to Environmental Impact
Assessment.’, 4th edition, Routledge.
273
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
ANALYSIS AND MODELLING OF BIOLOGICAL WEATHER
DATA IN THESSALONIKI, GREECE
Th. Kassandros1, A. Tsiamis1, A. Damialis2,3, D. Vokou3, N. Katsifarakis1, K.
Karatzas*1
1
Environmental Informatics Research Group, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Aristotle
University, Thessaloniki, Greece,
2
Chair and Institute of Environmental Medicine, UNIKA-T, Technical University of Munich,
Augsburg, Germany,
3
Department of Ecology, School of Biology, Aristotle University, Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: kkara@auth.gr, Tel +30 2310 994176
Abstract
We study the levels and the profile of aeroallergens (pollen and fungal spores), which constitute
biological weather parameters affecting health and quality of life, in the city of Thessaloniki, Greece.
We employ a data-driven approach with the aim to investigate the relationships between aeroallergen
parameters as well as meteorological conditions that may dictate biological weather patterns and
levels. A number of computational experiments are performed to assess the ability and performance
of various statistical and machine learning methods including linear regression, artificial neural
networks, decision trees and ensemble-based approaches. Results suggest that it is possible to
properly describe the behaviour of the aeroallergens and thus to operationally forecast their levels.
The latter is expected to have a direct positive impact of the quality of life of aeroallergen sufferers
in the area of study.
Keywords: Aeroallergens, Computational intelligence, Regression
1.
INTRODUCTION
Allergies are caused by the interaction between the human immune system and various exogenous
(environmental) parameters. When the latter consist of airborne biological agents (like pollen and
fungal spores) they are called aeroallergens and are affecting more than 20% of the population in
Europe [Bousquet et al., 2007, Eder et al., 2006]. Important allergenic plants are grass and birch
which affect about 65% and 30% of all hay fever sufferers in Europe, respectively. In the Southern
parts of the continent, the second most-important allergenic plant after grass is olive, with up to 70%
of allergy patients sensitive to it, this being also true for the Thessaloniki area [Gioulekas et al. 2004].
Fungal spores have also been found to generate allergic reactions in Thessaloniki, Greece [Gioulekas
et al., 2004]. It is therefore evident that allergic rhinitis (hay fever) as well as other allergic
manifestations depend on aeroallergen levels and have an impact on the overall Quality of Life (QoL).
For this reason, the analysis and modelling of biological weather data (i.e. data describing the
meteorological, air pollution and aeroallergen levels in the atmosphere as described in Klein et al.,
2011) contributes to the understanding and improvement of the QoL of sensitive parts of the
population. In the rest of the paper we present the biological weather data and the methods and tools
employed in their analysis and modelling (chapters 2 and 3). Results follow in chapter 4, and we then
draw our conclusions and state future research directions (chapter 5).
274
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.
MATERIALS
2.1 Area of study
The Greater Thessaloniki Area (GTA) is the largest urban agglomeration in Northern Greece with
more than 1,000,000 inhabitants. Traffic and industrial activities constitute the main sources of air
pollution. The city of Thessaloniki is located in the inmost part of the Thermaikos Bay, bounded to
the North by the Hortiatis Mountain. Residential areas are found in the periphery of the city and an
industrial zone is situated to its north-west side. The climate of the area is Mediterranean with hot
and dry summers and mild winters.
2.2
Biological weather data
2.2.1 Pollen Data and associated meteorological data
Airborne pollen in Thessaloniki is monitored with the aid of a 7-day recording Burkard volumetric
trap. The trap is placed on the roof of a University building in the city centre approximately 30m
above ground level. The measurements are based on the trapping of air particles on an appropriate
tape surface. Once every week dedicated personnel collects the sampling tape, brings it to the Lab,
and with the aid of a microscope the pollen grains are identified and counted (categorized per taxon).
The pollen types addressed in this paper are Cupressaceae, Oleaceae and Poaceae while the study
period covers years 1987–2016 with a time resolution of one day. The overall procedure is described
in detail in Damialis et al., 2010, and is characteristic of pollen measurements in many countries. On
this basis, the collection of pollen concentration data is characterized by a 7-day cycle. Therefore, in
order to build operational models, this cycle should be taken into consideration.
Meteorological data associated with pollen counts come from the International Thessaloniki Airport
monitoring station, made freely available via the www.wunderground.com and consist of daily
minimum, maximum and mean of the following parameters: temperature (in oC), pressure (in hPa)
wind speed (in m/s), wind direction (in degrees) and relative humidity. The aforementioned data are
considered to represent the mean meteorological conditions of the GTA and are rendered as
appropriate to be included in the analysis of pollen data. Descriptive statistics of the meteorological
data, accompanied by relevant pollen data (i.e. a total of 16 parameters), are presented in Table 1.
2.2.2 Fungal Spore Data and associated meteorological data
Airborne fungal spores in Thessaloniki are monitored by the same Burkard volumetric trap located
on the roof of a 30m university building, in the centre of Thessaloniki. The study period covers years
1987–2004 (with the exception of years 2001-2002). Counts are expressed as mean daily spore
concentrations (number of spores per m3 of air), as described in [Damialis et al., 2015]. In this study
we chose the three spore types summing up the largest percentage of the overall yearly concentrations,
namely Alternaria, Cladosporium and Ustilago.
As fungal spores were available for a different time period in comparison to pollen, we wanted to
make use of meteorological data that actually matched the spore count period. For this reason we
included in the analysis meteorological data which were recorded by the station operating within the
central Aristotle University campus and consist of minimum temperature (in oC), relative humidity,
solar radiation and rainfall daily (in mm). Descriptive statistics of the meteorological data,
accompanied by relevant spore data (i.e. a total of 7 parameters), are presented in Table 2.
275
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Table 1: Descriptive Statistics for 13 meteorological parameters and 3 Pollen taxa
Parameter
min
max
mean
std
Meantemp
-4.00
34.00
15.92
8.07
Meanpressure
989.53
1036.44
1016.07
6.69
Meanwindspd
0.00
52.00
8.80
6.14
Meanwdird
-1.00
360.00
221.51
90.50
Meanhumidity
30.00
100.00
65.80
13.95
Maxtemp
-2.00
44.00
20.51
8.99
Mintemp
-10.00
27.00
11.29
7.53
36.00
100.00
83.07
12.03
Maxhumidity
Minhumidity
6.00
96.00
44.61
17.24
Maxpressure
995.00
1040.00
1018.29
6.49
Minpressure
982.00
1036.00
1013.91
7.00
Maxwspd
0.00
224.00
23.54
12.95
Minwspd
0.00
41.00
0.97
3.58
Cupressaceae
0.00
2626.98
11.36
76.72
Oleaceae
0.00
452.07
2.21
10.35
Poaceae
0.00
76.34
1.51
4.52
Table 2: Descriptive Statistics for 4 meteorological parameters and 3 Fungal Spore types
Parameter
mean
max
min
std
RelativeHumidity
0.68
1.00
0.20
0.14
Rainfall
1.13
60.70
0.00
3.94
359.00
884.00
4.00
210.25
MinTemperature
11.41
26.20
-8.20
7.18
Alternaria
28.39
561.00
0.00
44.52
203.48
11991.00
0.00
429.70
22.46
2094.00
0.00
69.36
SolarRadiation
Cladosporium
Ustilago
3.
METHODS
3.1 Correlation analysis
The first step of our analysis aimed at the identification of relationships between parameters of the
pollen as well as of the spore’s data spaces. For this reason, the Pearson correlation coefficient was
employed, as a relative measure of association, calculated according to the following formulae:
𝑟=
∑𝑛
𝑖=1(𝑥𝑖 −𝑥)(𝑦𝑖 −𝑦)
𝑛
2
2
√∑𝑛
𝑖=1(𝑥𝑖 −𝑥) √∑𝑖=1(𝑦𝑖 −𝑦)
(1)
Here 𝑥𝑖 and𝑦𝑖 represent the two parameters studied for association while n is the number of available
data records. Results are presented and discussed in the relevant sections of this paper.
276
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.2 Further data association analysis
In a next step, we aimed at identifying inter-dependencies among data parameters which are not well
depicted by the (linear in its nature) Pearson correlation coefficient. For this reason, we applied the
Self-Organizing Maps (SOMs) method, which makes use of the Artificial Neural Networks main
constituents, i.e. neurons. SOMs are composed of lattice-oriented neurons which aim to represent
multidimensional data sets via their weights, in a topological manner. As the neural network is
exposed to data points, the latter are represented via winning neurons causing the network topology
to adjust and eventually form clusters on the basis of a similarity criterion (usually the Euclidian
distance within the initial data space). The method is agnostic of the structure or of the content of the
data and can deal with missing values. Neurons are arranged grids (usually 2-D but also 3-D).
Eventually similar neurons are topologically grouped in similar areas of the constructed “maps”
[Kohonen et al., 1997].
3.3 Features
Both datasets presented here where handled in a similar manner in terms of modelling. Due to the
way that data are collected (daily values made available every 7 days) and taking into account that
persistence is a main characteristic of aeroallergen as already indicated by Voukantsis et al., 2010, a
lag of up to 7 days has been chosen to be applied in our study. We therefore indicate as 𝑑0 (zero day)
the day for which we aim to develop a model for any one of the three pollen taxa studied. Then, we
indicate as 𝑑1 (lag1 day) the day before, and so on. As a result and for each one of the three pollen
taxa, we generate a total of 13 ∑𝑖=7
𝑖=0 𝑑𝑖 (meteo)+7(target pollen taxa)+2(other pollen taxa) = 113
features for their concentration levels. Similarly, and for each one of the three spore type, we generate
a total of s and 4∑𝑖=7
𝑖=0 𝑑𝑖 (meteo)+7(target taxa)+2(other taxa) = 41 features for the modelling of their
concentration levels. Due to the large number of features, we additionally aimed to identify which of
those are the most important in terms of their ability to lead to improved model results in either
nowcasting or forecasting mode. Among the many methods available, we chose to make use of a
Computational Intelligence algorithm in order to rank the features according to their “modelling”
effectiveness. More specifically, we employed the Random Forest [Breiman, 2001] method, which
consists of a population of decision trees. At each node of each tree, a condition is applied based on
a single feature that actually splits the tree in two. The optimal condition by which the split is made
locally at each node is called impurity, and for regression problems this is the variance, the average
of which can be calculated for all nodes and trees involved in the modelling procedure. This means
that when each tree is trained, there is a criterion which may be used to calculate how much each
feature contributes to the decrease of its impurity. This is the feature importance measure included in
the Python data mining Random Forest implementation used in this paper (available at http://scikitlearn.org). In all regressors the dataset was split in a training and a testing set with a ratio=3/4 for
fungal spores and a ratio=2/3 for pollen taxa on the basis of preliminary computational experiments
and in order to avoid over fitting.
3.4 Modelling algorithms
Modelling focused of three pollen taxa (namely Cupressaceae, Oleaceae and Poaceae) and three
fungal spore types (Alternaria, Cladosporium, Ustilago). Each parameter served as a target parameter
and all other data available served as the initial feature space. Modelling focused on the nowcasting
of the parameter of interest (i.e. estimation of its level based on features from the same day) as well
as on forecasting (i.e. making the same estimation but now using features from previous days). The
following algorithms were used in both modelling approaches.
3.5 Linear Regression
Linear Regression is the oldest and most frequent technique for regression. The relationships between
the features and the target parameter are modelled using linear predictor functions. The model is
277
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
developed using the least square approach, in order to minimize the mean squared error between the
predicted values and data.
3.6 Random Forest
Random forests consist of a population of trees (forest) which are trained and then used as an
ensemble, i.e. each tree via weighted voting contributes to the final result. In random forests each tree
in the ensemble is built from a sample drawn with replacement from the training set. In addition,
when splitting a node during the construction of the tree, the split that is chosen is no longer the best
split among all features. Instead, the split that is picked is the best split among a random subset of the
features. Because of this randomness, the bias of the forest usually slightly increases (with respect to
the bias of a single non-random tree) but, due to averaging, its variance also decreases, usually more
than compensating for the increase in bias, hence yielding an overall better model.
3.7 Neural Networks
In the current work a Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) is used as described in Voukantsis et al., 2010.
A MLP network consists of at least 3 hidden layers. Each node is a neuron that takes as input the
weighted sum of all neurons from the previous layer. Then the neuron uses an activation function,
usually the sigmoid, to produce a signal in the range of (-1,1), which is then used to produce the signal
for the neurons of the next layer. The goal of the training is to adjust the weights of each neuron to
accomplish the minimization of the error between training and predicted values, using a technique
called back propagation.
4.
RESULTS
4.1 Correlation Coefficient and SOMs
In Tables 3 and 4 the Pearson correlation coefficient between the target variables and all the available
ones, are presented. Concerning pollen, the highest correlation is observed between Oleaceae and
Poaceae (0.46). In addition, both Oleaceae and Poaceae demonstrate a loose correlation to
temperature. On the other hand, Cupressaceae doesn’t seem to correlate with any of the available
features. Within the fungal spores dataset, the highest correlation is observed between Cladosporium
and Alternaria (0.59). In addition, those two spore types correlate strongly to minimum temperature
and solar radiation. Ustilago correlates loosely to minimum temperature, solar radiation and
Clasosporium.
Table 3: Correlation Coefficient Matrix for Pollen taxa
Meantemp Meanpressure Meanwindspd Meanwdird Humidity Maxtemp
Mintemp Maxhumidityy
Cupressaceae
-0.08
-0.05
0.04
-0.01
0.02
-0.08
-0.09
0.04
Oleaceae
0.09
-0.06
-0.03
0
-0.05
0.1
0.08
-0.01
Poaceae
0.22
-0.07
-0.02
0
-0.14
0.23
0.2
-0.1
Minhumidity Maxpressure Minpressure Maxwspd Minwspd Cupressaceae Oleaceae Poaceae
Cupressaceae
-0.01
-0.03
-0.06
0.06
0
1
0.01
0
Oleaceae
-0.08
-0.07
-0.05
0.01
-0.04
0.01
1
0.46
Poaceae
-0.15
-0.09
-0.06
0.04
-0.05
0
0.46
1
The SOMs created for the pollen taxa (and their associated meteorological parameters) are presented
in Fig. 1. Overall, it is evident that Oleaceae and Poaceae demonstrate a similar pattern. They show
a relationship to mild and high temperatures, verifying that their flowering occurs in late spring and
summer periods. Logically, they both indicate a repellent behaviour concerning humidity.
Cupressaceae seems to be related with low atmospheric pressure, high wind speed and northerly
winds in terms of wind direction. This suggests that possibly the specific pollen taxa enter the city
centre during winter periods as reported by Galan et al., 1998, for the Cypresae pollen season in
Spain, transferred from the northern part of the GTA (where some tree areas exist).
278
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Concerning Fungal Spores, Alternaria and Cladosporium seem to be related with each other. Also,
solar radiation and minimum temperature seems to influence all the studied spore types.
Table 4: Correlation Coefficient Matrix for Fungal Spores
RelativeHumidity Rainfall SolarRadiation
MinTemperature
Alternaria Cladosporium Ustilago
Alternaria
-0.18
-0.07
0.39
0.54
1.00
0.59
0.23
Cladosporium
-0.13
-0.03
0.31
0.38
0.59
1.00
0.27
Ustilago
-0.08
-0.03
0.17
0.19
0.23
0.27
1.00
Figure 1: SOM for Pollen taxa and related meteorological parameters
4.2 Variable Importance
The procedure for evaluating the importance of the features described in section 3.3, was
implemented for both pollen and fungal spore analysis. The most important features were found to
be the lagged values of the target aero-allergen. These results confirm the persistence of the
phenomenon. Also, in relevance with the results of section 4.2, other aeroallergens within the studied
datasets were found to contribute importantly.
4.3 Predictive Models
In this section the prediction of the daily pollen and spore concentrations is approached in a twofold
manner: on the basis of the results already presented in previous sections, various models where
developed and applied using different set of features in a series of computational experiments.
279
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Figure 2: SOM for Fungal Spores and related meteorological parameters
4.4.1 Nowcasting
When referring to nowcasting we should take into account that all features are considered to be
available, including the ones of day being modelled, with the exception of the target parameter. On
the basis of computational experiments, it was decided to use a set of features which includes the
meteorological data from lag0 to lag1, the target pollen taxa or spore type of lag1 and all the other
available taxa/types of lag0. An indicative set of worst and best performance model is presented in
Figure 3. The negative values that appear in the graphs in both linear regression and ANN models
result from the effort made by the models to depict the actual values as well as the fluctuations of
aeroallergen measurements. Since aeroallergen concentration cannot take negative values, those
results should be interpreted as very low concentrations (or zeros for simplicity). The Pearson
correlation coefficient as well as the mean absolute error between modelled and actual values is
presented in Figure 4.
Figure 3: A representative example for the best (left) and worst (right) nowcasting outcome
among models developed and tested. Model algorithm and aeroallergen type are indicated in
the graph. Values are in pollen/spores per cubic meter
280
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 4: Comparison of the Pearson Correlation Coefficient (up) and the mean absolute
error (down) between the different models used for nowcasting
4.4.2 Forecasting
When referring to forecasting we should take into account that only features which are already known
at the day of the forecast are used.
Models for the forecasting of Pollen taxa: The set of features includes the meteorological data from
-1day to -2day and the target pollen taxa or spore type of -1day.
Models for the forecasting of Fungal Spore type: The set of used features includes the
meteorological data from -1day to -7day the target pollen taxa or spore type from -1day to -7day.
An indicative set of worst and best performance model is presented in Figure 5. The Pearson
correlation coefficient as well as the mean absolute error between modelled and actual values are
presented in Figure 6.
Figure 5: A representative example for the best (left) and worst (right) forecasting outcome
among models developed and tested. Model algorithm and aeroallergen type are indicated in
the graph. Values are in pollen/spores per cubic meter
281
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Figure 6: Comparison of the Pearson Correlation Coefficient (up) and the mean absolute
error (down) between the different models used for forecasting
5.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
The analysis of the correlation and the dependencies between pollen data and meteorological
conditions as well as fungal spores and meteorological conditions suggests that there are specific
inter-relationships which may be identified, both in terms of aeroallergen as well as in terms of
meteorology. The use of the SOMs method provides with additional insights, that allow for the
identification of behavioural patterns of the aeroallergens under study like in the case of the possible
winter appearance of Cypresae originating from the northern part of the GTA,
Concerning the modelling approach, it is evident that both pollen as well as spores models
demonstrate a high correlation coefficient for nowcasting, regardless of the modelling approach used,
with r values ranging from approx. 0.5 for Cypressacaeae up to more than 0.83 for Alternaria. The
mean absolute error varies considerably, with Cladosporium demonstrating the highest values, and
thus jeopardising the good correlation coefficient achieved in terms of practical model
implementation.
In the case of forecasting, pick values are harder to depict, this being the main reason for lower
correlation coefficient values. For this reason and in the case of the three pollen taxa included in this
study the 7-day ahead forecast achieves a low correlation coefficient that surpasses 0.5 only in the
case of Oleaceae for a linear regression model. On the contrary, Voukantsis et al. in 2010 have reaches
a correlation coefficient of 0.75 with similar models, yet with differences in the feature space,
including more meteorological parameters. When coming to fungal spore forecasting 7-day ahead,
the correlation coefficient is much better, ranging from 0.41 for Ustilago to 0.71 for Alternaria,
accompanied by low mean absoluter error values. This indicates that our approach is capable of
supporting operational spore level forecasting for the GTA regardless of the low dimensionality of
the feature space used.
A general pattern that can be seen in all models, depending on the regression approach, is that random
forests are more effective for nowcasting, while linear regression for forecasting. But for a more
reliable result, a validation method (i.e. k-fold cross-validation) should take place.
282
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Future research should include the investigation and use of a feature space of higher dimension,
complemented by a more advanced and sophisticated method for feature identification, prioritisation
and selection. In addition, we should develop models focusing on specific aeroallergen periods, which
is still an open issue for Fungal spores, but have already been suggested for pollen [Pfaar et al. 2017].
References
1. Bousquet J., Dahl R., Khaltaev N. (2007), Global alliance against chronic respiratory diseases,
Allergy, 62 (3), pp. 216-223
2. Eder W., Ege M.j., von Mutius E. (2006), The asthma epidemic, N. Engl. J. Med., 355, pp. 22262235
3. Gioulekas D, Papakosta D, Damialis A, Spieksma F, Giouleka P, Patakas D. (2004), ‘Allergenic
pollen records (15 years) and sensitization in patients with respiratory allergy in Thessaloniki,
Greece’, Allergy, 59, pp. 174–184
4. Gioulekas, D., Damialis, A., Papakosta, D., Spieksma, F. T. M., Giouleka, P. and Patakas, D.
(2004), ‘Allergenic fungi spore records (15 years) and sensitization in patients with respiratory
allergy in Thessaloniki‐Greece.’, J. Investig. Allergol. Clin. Immunol., 14, pp. 225–231.
5. Κlein Τh., Kukkonen J., Dahl Å., Bossioli E., Baklanov A., Fahre Vik Α., Agnew P., Karatzas,
K., and Sofiev M. (2011) ‘Interactions of physical, chemical and biological weather calling for
an integrated assessment, forecasting and communication of air quality’, Ambio, 41(8), 851-864
6. Dimitris Voukantsis, Kostas D. Karatzas, Athanasios Damialis, and Despoina Vokou ‘Forecasting
Airborne Pollen Concentration of Poaceae (Grass) and Oleaceae (Olive), using Artificial Neural
Networks and Genetic Algorithms, in Thessaloniki, Greece’, The 2010 International Joint
Conference on Neural Networks (IJCNN), Barcelona, Spain.
7. Athanasios Damialis, Despoina Vokou, Dimitrios Gioulekas, John M. Halley (2015), ‘Long-term
trends in airborne fungal-spore concentrations: a comparison with pollen, Fungal Ecology’,
Fungal Ecology,13, pp. 150-156.
8. Kohonen, T., (1997). ‘Self-Organizing Maps, 2nd edition.’ Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg,
Germany
9. Voukantsis D., Niska H., Karatzas K., Riga M., Damialis A. and Vokou D. (2010), ‘Forecasting
daily pollen concentrations using data-driven modeling methods in Thessaloniki, Greece’,
Atmospheric Environment, 44(39), pp. 5101-5111
10. Breiman, L. (2001), ‘Random Forests.’, Machine Learning, 45(1), pp. 5-32
11. Carmen Galán,Maria José Fuillerat,Paul Comtois,Eugenio,Domínguez,(1998),’A predictive
study of cupressaceae pollen season onset, severity, maximum value and maximum value date,
’Aerobiologia, 14, pp. 195.
12. Pfaar O, Bastl K, Berger U, Buters J, Calderon MA, Clot B, Darsow U, Demoly P, Durham SR,
Galán C, Gehrig R, Gerth van Wijk R, Jacobsen L, Klimek L, Sofiev M, Thibaudon M, Bergmann
KC. (2017) ‘Defining pollen exposure times for clinical trials of allergen immunotherapy for
pollen-induced rhinoconjunctivitis – an EAACI Position Paper’. Allergy, 72, pp.713–722.
283
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
PM10 LEVELS OF THE CITY AND A SUBURB OF PATRAS,
GREECE, DURING THE PERIOD 2013-2015
A. A. Bloutsos and P. C. Yannopoulos*
Environmental Engineering Laboratory, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Patras,
265 04 Patras, Greece
*Corresponding author: E-mail: yannopp@upatras.gr, Tel +30 2610 996527, Fax: +30 2610 996573
Abstract
The present work deals with the concentration levels of air-borne particulate matter of diameter less
than 10 μm (PM10) of the area of the city of Patras and of the University of Patras Campus during the
period of 2013 - 2015. The stationary air pollution monitoring station of the Environmental
Engineering Laboratory (EEL) of the Civil Engineering Department of the University of Patras is
operating continuously since 2012. The sampling site is in a suburb. Additional PM10 data are
obtained from the “Greek National Monitoring Network of Atmospheric Pollution (GNMNAP)” for
two air quality stations, which are installed in Patras downtown and have operated intermittently since
2001.
The monthly variation of PM10 concentration for the time period 2013 -2015 is presented at each
station. Calculating Spearman’s correlation factor, the correlation among stations’ measurements is
significant at 0.01 or 0.05 levels, but there is no correlation between EEL’s data and warm or cold
period. On the contrary, there is rather strong correlation between downtown data and warm or cold
period. In addition, the monthly average values of a typical year are presented for both stations.
Finally, the yearly variations of mean monthly values are shown and the influence of warm or cold
period is examined.
The aim of this project is to derive implications from the PM10 levels of the air of both the University
of Patras Campus and the city of Patras. The statistical analysis of such a program of continuous
measurements of air quality may provide a cost-effective strategy for air quality monitoring.
Keywords: Air pollution, air quality, PM10, suburban concentration, suburban
1.
INTRODUCTION
The airborne particulate matter (PM) is one of the most significant air pollutants [1, 2]. They consist
of a mixture of solid particles and liquid droplets that are suspended in air with a wide range in size
and chemical composition. Human health is affected mainly by the “inhalable particles” of a diameter
less than 10μm (PM10), and more specifically by the “fine particles” of diameter less than 2.5μm
(PM2.5). PM is originated by anthropogenic combustion and non-combustion sources as well as by
natural sources, like sea salt emissions, re-suspended dust and transported Saharan dust [3].
The existence of particle pollution affects both health and the environment. Health effects of short or
long term exposure to PM may be the appearance or aggravation of cardiovascular and respiratory
diseases. The correlation between PM and mortality is also significant. The environmental impact
may be assessed by the temporary occurrences of PM that affect visibility, climate and vegetation. In
addition, building materials do not remain unaffected due to exposure to particulate pollution [1, 3,
4]. Air quality standards by European Environment Agency (EEA) [2] and US Environmental
284
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Protection Agency (US-EPA) [4] and Guidelines by World Health Organization (WHO) [1], which
are given in Table 1, are continuously updated according to the progress of research data.
Table 1
Air Quality Standards and Guidelines for PM10
Annual Mean (μg m-3)
40
20
European Union (EEA)
US Environmental Protection Agency (US-EPA)
World Health Organization (WHO) Guidelines
1
Not to be exceeded on more than 35 days per year
2
Not to be exceeded more than once per year on average over 3 years
3
99th percentile (3 exceedances permitted per year)
Daily Mean (μg m-3)
501
1502
503
There are several studies regarding PM10 measurements in Patras area, which give also mean monthly
values for time intervals of the period from January 2004 up to April 2014. More precisely, the
following intervals have been covered: January – December 2004 [13], December 2005 – March 2006
[14], 2008 – 2011 [15], 2009 and 2010 PM10 episodes [16], July 2012 [17], Winter periods of 2012
and 2013 [18] and January 2012 – April 2014 [19]. Exempting the four studies [14, 17, 18, 19], which
have conducted their own PM10 mass concentration measurements, all the rest studies have used the
PM10 data monitored by the Department of Environment & Planning of the Region of Western
Greece.
The University of Patras Campus (UPC) occupies an area of 2.66 km2, 12 km NNE of the city center,
adjacent to Rion and at the foot of Panachaicon Mountain. It has 23 Departments with a total
population of 30,000 approximately, including the University Hospital of Patras, where e xtensive
infrastructure works, sports facilities, agricultural and other significant activities take place (Pappas, 2011). The
present study deals with the presentation of PM10 concentrations measured by the Environmental
Engineering Laboratory (EEL) of the Civil Engineering Department of the University of Patras during the period
01/01/2013 - 31/12/2015. The monthly average values, as well as the average values of the cold and warm
period have been calculated and used herein. Several pertinent characteristics of PM10 are compared
to the corresponding measurements available by the Department of Environment & Planning of the
Region of Western Greece and useful implications are drawn.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Description of sampling area
The position of the air quality monitoring EEL station is shown in Figure 1. It is located at the western
parking lot of the Building of the Department of Civil Engineering (geographical longitude
21º47´22´´, geographical latitude 38º17´22´´ and 60.60 m altitude above sea level). At this area the
inclination is 4-5% toward NW. Apart from asphalt-covered streets, the major area consists of natural
soil with low vegetation, bushes, and sporadic trees, mainly pine and olive trees. The EEL station is
settled at a distance more than 15 m W from the 3-storey building of the Civil Engineering
Department, while all other buildings are even further away. The old National Road and the new
National Road Korinthos – Patras (E65) are 0.7 km far N, approximately. At the same direction and
at a distance 2.2 km, the local ferry port of Rion – Antirrion is located. The Patras By-Pass (E55) is
285
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Figure 1: General view of Patras area and air quality monitoring locations
1.2 km SE away from the EEL station. The University Hospital of Patras is located 1.5 km NE it.
Also, more than 2 km toward NE, there is a limited number of industrial activities of moderate size.
The EEL station is free from nearby objects of any kind from the NE to SE wind sectors (i.e., for an
angle of at least 247.5°). The EEL air pollution originates from classic sources of a suburban- rural
area, augmented by emissions due to central heating during winter and additional emissions from
aforementioned activities and a cement factory operating 2-3 km NE of the UPC. The Station is
classified as “Suburban – background station”. More details about the location of the monitoring EEL
station are given in the literature [6].
At Patras downtown, the Department of Environment & Planning of the Region of Western Greece
is responsible for the operation of two air quality stations (ST 1 and ST 2, Figure 1) that have been
installed and operated since 2001 in the frame of integration of “Greek National Monitoring Network
of Atmospheric Pollution (GNMNAP)” [7]. The city is settled at the foot of Panachaicon Mountain
extending mainly along the seashore of the NE Patraikos Gulf. Until July of 2014, the center was
affected by the traffic load directed to the New Port through the city as the latter was not connected
to the National Road. Since then, the traffic load due to heavy vehicles and cars is reduced,
decongesting downtown Patras. A general view of Patras downtown and suburban areas is shown in
Figure 1. Location of ST 1 is at Drosopoulou Sq., 180 m E of the nearest shoreline (harbor docks).
ST 1 is characterized as an urban traffic oriented station. Location of ST 2 is at the E corner of King
George A΄ Sq. [11], 400 m SE of the nearest shoreline (harbor docks). Both monitoring stations are
characterized as urban traffic oriented stations [11]. More details about the city of Patras and these
two locations are given in the literature [7, 8, 9].
2.2 Sampling Equipment
The EEL station includes an automatic analyzer of PM10 (model Grimm 180) based on the 90°
scattering light measurement principle. The analyzer provides data records of mean values every five
minutes. At the roof of the station, a weathering station is located. Downtown Patras, the air quality
monitoring stations (ST 1 and ST 2) are equipped with continuous operation beta-attenuation
286
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
analyzers (FH 62 I-R, Thermo Electron Corp., USA) for PM10 measurements. More details about this
sampling equipment are given in the literature [6, 7, 10].
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
In Figure 2, PM10 monthly average concentrations (Sites EEL, ST 1, ST 2) for the specific monitoring
period are presented. The monthly PM10 concentrations at location of EEL station (suburban area)
ranged from 5.7 to 24.7 μg m-3 with an average value of 13.7±3.9 μg m-3. From GNMNAP’s database
[11], the monthly PM10 concentrations at locations of ST 1 and ST 2 (urban-traffic) ranged from 26.3
to 51.8 μg m-3 and from 29.6 to 58.5 μg m-3, respectively, with corresponding mean values 40.4±7.7
μg m-3 and 39.5±7.6 μg m-3 (Table 2). It must be noticed that the data completion at EEL station, ST
1 and ST 2 is 100.0%, 27.8% and 100.0%, respectively. As expected, the concentrations at the
suburban monitoring EEL station found less than those at urban-traffic areas (ST 1 and ST 2). It is
noticed that PM10 concentrations at EEL station were 62.7% and 65.4% lower than those at ST 1 and
ST 2, respectively. At cold period (October - March), EEL’s levels were 67.0% and 68.1% lower than
those at ST 1 and ST 2, respectively. Also, at warm period (April – September) EEL station’s levels
were 59.8% and 62.5% lower than those at ST 1 and ST 2, respectively. Additionally, the average
ratio of PM10 concentrations of warm over cold period is 1.05, 0.79 and 0.88 for EEL, ST 1 and ST
2, respectively, indicating that the influence of cold or warm period at EEL station (suburban area) is
weaker compared to stations ST 1 and ST 2. It must be noticed that the latter results obtained from
ST 2 for warm and cold periods are indicative but not representative due to low percentage of recorded
data completion.
The values of the Spearman’s correlation factor r among stations measurements were calculated using
SPSS® statistical software (IBM SPSS Statistics 24) with 0.01 or 0.05 significance levels. There is
no correlation between EEL station’s data and warm or cold period, while there is rather strong
correlation between downtown data and warm or cold period (Table 3a).
From the daily PM10 concentrations recorded at Locations EEL, ST 1 and ST 2 the monthly variations
of a typical year is calculated and shown in Figure 3. It is obvious that the variation of EEL’s PM 10
concentration is shifted down in comparison to corresponding variations of monitoring stations ST 1
and ST 2.
Figure 2: Monthly averaged PM10 concentrations at EEL station (suburban) in comparison to
the corresponding PM10 concentrations at Locations of ST 1 and ST 2 (urban-traffic) during
2013-2015
287
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Table 2: Statistical analysis of monthly PM10 concentrations (μg m-3) during 2013-2015 at the
monitoring stations EEL, ST 1 and ST 2 plus supplementary data
Distance
Elevation
Cold
PM10
Month
Warm Period
from
above sea
Period
shoreline (m)
(m)
Monitoring EEL Station, University of Patras Campus
(geographical longitude 21º47´22´´; geographical latitude 38º17´22´´)
Range (μg m-3)
5.7 – 24.7
5.7 – 18.5
7.5 – 24.7
Average (μg m-3)
13.7
13.3
14.0
St. Dev. (μg m-3)
3.9
3.4
4.4
Completion (%)
100.0
100.0
100.0
1900
61
Monitoring ST 1 Station, Drosopoulou Sq.
(geographical longitude 21º44´18.35´´; geographical latitude 38º15´11.15´´)
Range (μg m-3)
26.3 – 51.8
42.8-51.8
26.3-47.5
Average (μg m-3)
40.4
46.2
36.6
St. Dev. (μg m-3)
7.7
4.0
7.3
Completion (%)
27.8
22.2
33.3
180
16
Monitoring ST 2 Station, King George A΄ Sq.
(geographical longitude 21º44´09.23´´; geographical latitude 38º14´45.51)
Range (μg m-3)
29.6 – 58.5
30.6 – 56.7
29.6 – 58.5
Average (μg m-3)
39.5
42.1
37.0
St. Dev. (μg m-3)
7.6
7.3
7.2
Completion (%)
100.0
100.0
100.0
400
19
Table 3: Spearman’s correlation factor r for (a) monthly data during 2013 – 2015, and (b)
monthly data of a typical year, among monitoring stations EEL, ST 1 and ST 2
EEL
ST 1
ST 2
Warm/Cold Period
(a)
EEL
1.000
ST 1
0.7451
0.6432
0.048
1.000
0.867
2
0.6401
1.000
0.4011
ST 2
Warm/Cold
Period
1.000
(b)
EEL
ST 1
ST 2
EEL
1.000
0.624
0.6081
1.000
0.7942
ST 1
ST 2
1
1.000
2
Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level
288
Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3: Monthly variations of PM10 concentrations at EEL (suburban) in comparison to the
corresponding PM10 concentrations at Locations of ST 1 and ST 2 (urban-traffic) during 2013
- 2015
It is noticed that PM10 range during a typical year is much less significant at EEL station compared
to the corresponding range at downtown monitoring stations. Except that, the variation is similar at
the monitoring stations; higher PM10 levels are recorded during cold and at early warm period where
increased demands on heating purposes [11] and Saharan dust effects [12] occurred. Table 3b shows
Spearman’s correlation factor among EEL, ST 1 and ST 2 for monthly data of a typical year. There
is strong correlation (at 0.05 significance level) between EEL and ST 2. Analogous correlation is
found between EEL and ST 1, but the rather low percentage of completion of ST 2 data prevents safe
conclusions.
In Figure 4, PM10 yearly average concentrations from monthly values (Sites EEL, ST 1, ST 2) for the
specific monitoring period are presented. The monthly PM10 levels at EEL location (suburban area)
ranged from 5.7 to 24.7 μg m-3 (2013), 12.4 to 18.5 μg m-3 (2014) and 9.0 to 17.4 μg m-3 (2015). The
yearly average PM10 concentrations were 13.9±6.0 μg m-3, 14.7±2.0 μg m-3 and 12.5±2.3 μg m-3,
correspondingly. From GNMNAP’s database [11], during 2013, PM10 levels at ST 1 location (urbantraffic) ranged from 26.3 to 51.8 μg m-3. During the warm period of 2013 monthly values ranged from
26.3 to 47.5 μg m-3, while at cold period ranged from 42.8 to 51.8 μg m-3. The corresponding mean
values were 40.4±7.7 μg m-3, 36.6±7.3 μg m-3 and 46.2±4.0 μg m-3. No data are available during 2014
- 2015 at GNMNAP’s database for ST 1. The monthly PM10 concentrations at ST 2 location (suburban
area) ranged from 30.4 to 58.5 μg m-3 (2013), 30.3 to 49.3 μg m-3 (2014) and 29.6 to 56.7 μg m-3
(2015). The yearly average PM10 concentrations were 40.6±8.1 μg m-3, 39.4±6.0 μg m-3 and 38.7±9.1
μg m-3, correspondingly, showing a slight reduction.
Table 4 summarizes statistical results for PM10 annual values during 2013 – 2015. Additionally,
relative results are presented separately for both warm and cold period for each year. It is clearly
shown that the air quality at the UPC suburban area and the entire area is rather insignificantly
affected by seasonal factors that influence PM10 concentration levels. On the other hand, the increased
concentrations that appear at downtown area during the cold period show that central heating sources
also contribute to PM10 levels. Annual PM10 concentration levels at UPC are below the EEA’s and
US-EPA’s Limits and also the stricter WHO’s Guidelines (Table 1). On the other hand, the air quality
289
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
at Patras downtown seems rather aggravated by PM10 concentrations during 2013 - 2015. At that
period, the annual PM10 levels at UPC remained practically constant, while the corresponding levels
in Patras downtown show a somewhat decrease, as it is deduced by ST 1’s data. Cold’s period PM10
levels were higher than warm’s period.
Table 4: Statistical analysis of annual PM10 concentrations (μg m-3) during 2013-2015 at the
monitoring stations EEL, ST 1 and ST 2
Period
Range (μg m-3)
Average ± St. Dev (μg m-3) Completion (%)
2013
2014
2015
2013
2014
2015
Monitoring EEL Station, University of Patras Campus
Year
5.7 – 24.7
13.9 ± 6.0
Warm
7.5 – 24.7
15.2 ± 7.2
Cold
5.7 – 18.4
12.5 ± 4.8
Year
12.4 – 18.5
14.7 ± 2.0
Warm
13.2 – 18.5
15.1 ± 1.9
Cold
12.4 – 18.5
14.3 ± 2.2
Year
9.0 – 17.4
12.5 ± 2.3
Warm
10.4 – 12.9
11.7 ± 1.0
Cold
9.0 – 17.4
13.2 ± 3.1
Year
Warm
Cold
Year
Warm
Cold
Year
Warm
Cold
Year
2013
Warm
Cold
Year
2014
Warm
Cold
Year
2015
Warm
Cold
n/a: Not available data
4.
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
Monitoring ST 1 Station, Drosopoulou Sq.
26.3 – 51.8
40.4 ± 7.7
26.3 – 47.5
36.6 ± 7.3
42.8 – 51.8
46.2 ± 4.0
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
83.3
100.0
66.7
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
Monitoring ST 2 Station, King George A΄ Sq.
30.4 – 58.5
40.6 ± 8.1
30.4 – 58.5
39.6 ± 10.4
31.9 – 47.3
41.5 ± 5.8
30.3 – 49.3
39.4 ± 6.0
30.3 – 41.7
37.7 ± 4.3
30.6 – 49.3
41.0 ± 7.3
29.6 – 56.7
38.7 ± 9.1
29.6 – 43.9
33.6 ± 5.3
31.2 – 56.7
43.9 ± 9.5
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
CONCLUSIONS
Analyzing PM10 concentrations for three monitoring stations in major Patras area during a three years
period, we may conclude that Patras air quality depends on the city’s activities. Low annual levels of
concentrations occur at the suburban area, below the limit values of EEA and US-EPA, as well as the
WHO guidelines, while higher PM10 concentrations are recorded at Patras downtown. Continuous
maintenance of GNMNAP’s monitoring stations is great importance as the poor data completion of
ST 1 prevents safe conclusions. Relocation and redesign of the GNMNAP’s stations may be
290
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
necessary, especially for the monitoring station ST 1, as its values are overlapped by the other station
(ST 2) at the city center, while there are other more critical areas of Patras needing air pollution
monitoring.
Figure 4: Yearly variations of mean monthly PM10 concentrations at EEL (suburban) in
comparison to the corresponding PM10 concentrations at Locations of ST 1 and ST 2 (urbantraffic) for warm and cold period during 2013 - 2015
References
1. World Health Organization (2006). “Air Quality Guidelines - Global Update 2005”, ISBN 92
890 2192 6.
2. European Environment Agency (2012). “Air Quality in Europe – 2012 Report”, ISBN 978 92
9213 328 3 doi:10.2800/55823
3. European Environmental Agency (2013). “Air Pollution Fact Sheet 2013. European Union”,
(EU-27).
4. US-EPA (2009). “Integrated Science Assessment for Particulate Matter”, EPA/600/R08/139F
5. Pappas V. (2011). “The master plan of the University of Patras Campus”, Chorographies 2 (1):
13-20, ISSN 1792 3913 (in Greek)
6. Yannopoulos, P.C. and Bloutsos, A. A. (2014). “Monitoring Air Pollution in the University of
Patras Campus, Greece, and Data Evaluation for the period 2012-2013”. LAP Lambert
Academic Publishing - ISBN: 978-3-659-64074-2
7. http://www.ypeka.gr (accessed November 1st, 2017, in Greek)
8. Yannopoulos, P.C. (2008). “Long-term assessment of airborne particulate concentrations in
Patras, Greece”, Fresenius Environmental Bulletin, 17 (5), pp. 608-616.
291
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
9. Yannopoulos, P.C. and Skokaki, G. N. (2003). “Particulate and sulfur dioxide concentration
measurements in Patras, Greece”, Air and Waste Management Association, 53, 957-970.
10. Bloutsos A.A. and Yannopoulos P.C. (2017). “Monitoring Particulate Pollution in the University
of Patras Campus, Greece”. In: Karacostas T., Bais A., Nastos P. (eds) Perspectives on
Atmospheric Sciences. Springer Atmospheric Sciences. Springer, Cham. ISBN 978-3-31935095-0
11. Yannopoulos P.C. (2014). “A cost-effective methodology for spatial concentration distributions
of urban air pollutants”, Water, Air, & Soil Pollution, 225:1989 (doi: 10.1007/s11270-0141989-7).
12. Bloutsos, A. A. and Yannopoulos, P. C. (2014). Atmospheric pollution at the University of Patras
Campus during fire events. Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Meteorology,
Climatology and Atmospheric Physics (COMECAP 2014), 28-31 May, Heraklion of Crete
Island, Greece.
13. Pikridas, M., Tasoglou, A., Florou, K. and Pandis, S. N. (2013). “Characterization of the origin
of fine particulate matter in a medium size urban area in the Mediterranean”. Atmospheric
Environment, 80, 264–274.
14. Maraziotis, E., Sarotis, L., Marazioti, C. and Marazioti, P. (2008). “Statistical analysis of
inhalable (MP10) and fine particles (PM2.5) concentrations in urban region of Patras, Greece”.
Global NEST J., 10, 123–131.
15. Karagiannidis, A., Poupkou, A., Giannaros, T., Giannaros, C., Melas, D. and Argiriou, A. (2015).
“The Air Quality of a Mediterranean Urban Environment Area and Its Relation to Major
Meteorological Parameters”. Water Air Soil Pollut, 226:2239 (doi: 10.1007/s11270-014-22398).
16. Matthaios, V. N., Triantafyllou, A. G. and Koutrakis, P. (2017). “PM10 episodes in Greece: Local
sources versus long-range transport—observations and model simulations”. J. Air Waste
Manage. Assoc., 67(1):105–126 (doi: 10.1080/10962247.2016.1231146).
17. Tsiflikiotou, M. (2014). “Spatial distribution of summertime particulate matter and its
composition in Greece”. Master Thesis in Chemical Engineering, Energy & Environment,
University of Patras, Patras, Greece.
18. Valavanidis, A., Vlachogianni, T., Loridas, S. and Fiotakis, C. (2015). “Atmospheric Pollution in
Urban Areas of Greece and Economic Crisis. Trends in air quality and atmospheric pollution data,
research and adverse health effects”.
19. http://www.chem.uoa.gr/wp-content/uploads/epistimonika_themata/atmosph_pollut_greece.pdf
20. (accessed April 12, 2018).
21. Manousakas, M.-I. G. (2014). “Study of the effect of anthropogenic and natural sources in
the concentration of Airborne Particulate Matter PM10 and PM2.5 in urban and industrial
areas”. Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Chemistry, University of Patras, Patras (in Greek).
292
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
SATELLITE DATA AS INDICATOR OF FOREST DIEBACK: THE
STUDY CASE OF THE PINEWOOD FOREST OF
CASTELPORZIANO (CENTRAL ITALY)
F. Recanatesi*1, C. Giuliani2, B. Cucca1 and M.N. Ripa1
1
Department of Agricultural and Forestry Sciences (D.A.F.N.E.) University of Tuscia, Viterbo
(Italy),
2
PhD student in Landscape and Environment. Sapienza University, Rome (Italy)
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: fabio.rec@unitus.it
Abstract
Mapping forest health condition, especially in protected areas, is a major concern for forest planning,
biodiversity assessment and for understanding the potential impacts of antropic activities on natural
ecosystems. In this context, at wide scale, remote sensing of satellite data is one of the most important
data sources for monitoring health state of forest stand. Till now, many satellites and sensors with
different resolutions suitable for variety of land cover monitoring tasks have been launched. Within
all these sensors, those with high temporal and spatial resolution play an important role especially in
mediterranean environment where high landscape fragmentation and spatial distribution of stand
forest represent a limiting factor in vegetation analysis.
The current work deals with the use of the Sentinel-2 images to produce long-term monitoring system
based on the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI). The study area is represented by the
pinewood forest of Castelporziano, a protected area located in the metropolitan area of Rome (Central
Italy), recently involved in a quick decline of vegetative condition due to a scolytidae (Tomycus
destruens Mill.) pest propagation.
Keywords: Remote sensing, NDVI, Sentinel-2, GIS, Mediterranean pinewood, Insect infestation
1.
INTRODUCTION
Landscape fragmentation characterizes Mediterranean regions and causes an increase in
environmental vulnerability, especially due to the antropic activities. As a consequence, many
protected areas located in urban or peri-urban environments today are highly vulnerable towards
landscaping changes that, in most cases, cause a decline of environmental quality and cultural
heritage. In this context, monitoring forest health is a key indicator of environmental ecological
conditions and, in particularly, for those performing an essential role in maintaining the ecological
balance in vulnerable territories.
Indeed, forestry ecosystems play a significant social, economic and environmental impact and
nowadays they are considered a source of ecosystems services especially in peri-urban territory
characterized by high population density.
In this topic, the availability of high-frequency remote sensing time series represents an efficient tool
in monitoring the evolution of an ecosystem to be assessed at different temporal and spatial scales.
Among modern methods to monitor terrestrial ecosystems, remote sensing of multispectral satellite
images is of primary importance thanks to its capability of providing synoptic information over wide
areas with high acquisition frequency [Frampton et al., 2013; Sheeren et al., 2016; Topaloglu et al.,
293
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
2016; Lia et al., 2017]. For this reason, scientists working in this field have developed vegetation
indices (VI) for qualitatively and quantitatively evaluating vegetative cover using multi-spectral data.
In fact, over forty vegetation indices have been developed during recent decades, amongst which the
Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) is the most widely used in monitoring the health
conditions of forest surfaces [Bannari et al., 1995]. In fact, the degree of vigor in forest vegetation
cover can be classified according to its spectral response, which in the red (630-690 nm) is strongly
correlated with chlorophyll concentration, while the spectral response in near infrared (760-900 nm)
is correlated by the leaf area index and green vegetation density. Thanks to these properties, NDVI
can be utilized as an indicator of possible vegetation stress, particularly that due to water shortage or
pest diffusion [Maselli 2004; Gooshbor et al., 2016].
In the present research, we have developed a monitoring system to map crown dieback of a coastal
pinewood forest located in a protected area in the metropolitan area of Rome and that, in 2016,
declined by a sudden diffusion of bark beetle (Tomicus destruens Mill.). To achieve this goal, we
used a time series data set from 2015 to 2017, which is offered by Sentinel-2 satellite, provided by
the European Space Agency (ESA) and processed according to NDVI index in a Geographic
Information Systems (GIS) environment. Due to its high fragmentation, the pinewood stand has been
previously determined, at the scale of forest unit, using a supervised classification of multispectral
images and data fields.
In order to correlate the various levels of NDVI decrease in risk classes, a campaign of field surveys
was carried out in 2017 to correlate data acquired to vegetative vigor of pinewood.
The results of this research allowed us to separate with high precision the pinewood canopy by the
rest of the forest and, in this way, to diachronically analyze the vegetative vigor by using NDVI index
in an accurate way.
2.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The study area is represented by the pinewood forest of Castelporziano, a State Nature Reserve
located in a peri-urban area of the municipality of Rome, figure 1. Castelporziano has a total surface
area of 6.000 ha and its land use is characterized mainly by forest and to a lesser extent by agricultural
activities.
This territory is the last remnant of the ancient Mediterranean coastal forest, in which the predominant
species are broadleaf oaks (4.000 ha) and pinewood (900 ha) mainly characterized by Pinus pinea L.
In particular, the pinewood forest of Castelporziano, with numerous trees aging over one hundred
years or more, is the last remaining example today of mature pinewood forest along the Tyrrhenian
coast after the recent fire, which occurred in August 2017, causing huge damage to the neighboring
ancient pinewood forest of Castelfusano. For these reason, the territory of Castelporziano can be
considered as a unique environment in terms of natural and cultural values [Recanatesi et al., 2013;
Recanatesi 2014]. Furthermore, it is listed in the Habitat Directive with two Sites of Community
Importance (SCI) and the whole territory is classified as a Special Protection Area (SPA).
In October 2016, the ongoing environmental monitoring program in the Castelporziano pinewood
forest, carried out by remote sensing of multispectral Sentinel-2 images, allowed the detection of a
diffuse crown dieback in several areas due to a sudden infestation of Tomicus destruens Woll,.
Before applying NDVI index, a preliminary classification of pinewood canopy, at forest unit scale,
was required. Indeed, Castelporziano pinewood forest, at unit forest scale, especially along the shore,
presents an heterogeneous distribution on the territory and, often, consociated with other species or,
in other cases, with mediterranean macchia.
294
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: Nature State Reserve of Castelporziano (41°42’50’’N - 12°24’03’’E) and the
metropolitan area of Roma
Referring to resolution satellite data used, these characteristics represent a limiting factor in
monitoring NDVI difference at unit forest scale. For this reason, using Quickbird satellite
multispectral images (year 2002; 0.7m resolution) and Maximum Likelihood algorithm, a supervised
classification of pinewood forest was conducted using over 150 points of training set derived by aerial
photo interpretation and field investigations. Figure 2 shows an example of classification for a forest
unit where pinewood canopy is classified and separated by other land cover stands.
Once defined the canopy layer of pinewood forest for Castelporziano, a series of georeferenced
Sentinel-2 images (06/21/2015; 06/08/2016; 06/06/2017), provided by the ESA, were analyzed to
map forest decline using NDVI index.
The Pinewood forest was assumed to be relatively healthy in 2015 and therefore the data relating to
this period served as reference in this research. According to Richter’s atmospheric correction method
(Richter et al., 2011), the selected images were corrected with the Sentinel Application Platform
(SNAP) program running in Sen2Core. This performs the atmospheric, terrain and cirrus correction
of Top-Of- Atmosphere Level 1C input data. Geometric distortion of the analyzed images was
corrected with the rectified 10 m Digital Terrain Model (D.T.M.) provided by the Italian Ministry of
Environment.
The forest inventory data were acquired from the Mediterranean Ecosystem Observatory Office of
Castelporziano in a GIS resource. This data base contained spatial information of individual stands,
topographic features, species composition and biophysical information such as tree age, basal area
and site index for each forest stand. In the present research all land use except pinewood forest were
treated as non-forest and were excluded in the following analysis.
295
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Using the NDVI image in 2015 as a reference, the 2016 and 2017 NDVI images were normalized by
means of histogram match. The differential NDVI (∆NDVI) could then be calculated as:
∆𝑁𝐷𝑉𝐼(𝑡−𝑡+1) =
𝑁𝐷𝑉𝐼(𝑡+1) −𝑁𝐷𝑉𝐼(𝑡)
(1)
𝑁𝐷𝑉𝐼(𝑡)
The histograms of the 2016 and 2017 NDVI images are characterized by an approximately standard
Gaussian distribution, centered at approximately ∆NDVI = 0. In accordance with the interpretation
used by Wang (Wang at al., 2007; Wang et al., 2008), negative ∆NDVI in the left tail of the histogram
reveals pinewood crown dieback and tree mortality attributed from loss of leaf moisture content.
Positive ∆NDVI, in the right tail, of the histogram represents crown recovery of the pinewood. To
create a map of the risk, a field survey was carried out in summer 2017 to define the risk classes based
on ∆NDVI percentage values. To this aim, according with the methodology proposed by Ogaya
[Ogaya et al., 2015] a conspicuous number of pine trees with different ∆NDVI was examined so as
to classify them in different thresholds of decline as reported in Table 1. In this phase we visually
determined the percentage of dead vegetative apices for sampled trees and stand canopy density.
Once the risk classes had been defined and validated in the field, a preliminary analysis was conducted
to correlate the risk classes to dendrometric variables, such as volume and age. To do this we matched
map risk class information with volume and age layers detected at the scale of forest parcel. No
environmental variable, such as slope, aspect or elevation, was considered in this study because the
territory analyzed is mainly flat, being located in a coastal area.
Table 1: Risk classes and relative ∆ NDVI (2015-2017) percentage value
∆ NDVI
Risk classes
Strong Recovery
3.
from +5 to +20%
Neutral Recovery
from -5% to just less than +5%
Low Decline
from -5% to just less than -15%
Medium Decline
from -15% to just less than -25%
High Decline
from -25% to just less than -45%
Dead Plants
-100%
RESULTS
The supervised classification of Quickbird images performed for the determination of pinewood
canopy has resulted very efficient. Through a check carried out with over 70 control points, a Kappa
Index of Agreement (KIA) of 85% was found.
In the observation period 2015-2017, based on the classes risk reported in Table 1, in terms of
pinewood decline four levels of forest change were identified from the ∆NDVI images: low decline,
medium decline, high decline and dead plants respectively with 10, 17, 21 and 5% of the whole
surfaced analyzed, the remaining surface (47%) was classified as strong recovery or, weak recovery.
In figure 3 the risk assessment of the whole territory is reported and an example of methodology used
is shown in the different steps: unit forest, the pinewood canopy layer extracted by supervised
classification, the NDVI index applied to determine the risk classes calculated as difference for the
observed period.
296
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2: Pinewood forest canopy. From the top to bottom: Unit Forest pinewood (green
dashed line); canopy cover derived by supervised classification of Quickbird images;
Corresponding cells of the Sentinel-2
297
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Figure 3: On the left: Castelporziano Nature Reserve zoning of the pinewood according to the
identified risk classes shown in Table 1. On the right, an example of the methodology used:
Forest Unit; Pinewood canopy layer; NDVI index for 2015, 16 and 17 with the classification in
risk classes
To determine/find out the effect of biological variables on the pinewood decline, we compared the
occurrence rate for the class “high decline” (∆NDVI from -25% to just less than -45%) with volume
and age. For the latter, the correlation occurred just for that forest units in which the age was known.
Nonetheless, from the results obtained and considering the observed parameter, it emerges that a
strong correlation exists between age and pinewood decline (R2=0.6), as shown in figure 4. On the
contrary, only a weak correlation was observed between volume and pinewood decline (R2=0.3), as
shown in figure 5. Regarding the role played by volume in causing pinewood decline, it was observed
that a significant increase in decline occurred starting from 350 m3/ha.
Figure 4: Comparison between pinewood age (years) and occurrence of the risk class - high
decline
298
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 5: Comparison between pinewood volume (m3/ha) and occurrence of the risk class high decline
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
The high resolution classification concerning the canopy of Castelporziano pinewood today
represents, in the medium and long term, a strategic tool in monitoring vegetation health condition
by remote sensing data and Sentinel-2 multi-spectral images used in the environmental monitoring of
the protected area of Castelporziano and has be proven to be both accurate and efficient in monitoring
the health conditions of vegetation, by application of the NDVI index.
Figure 6: Pinewood forest of Castelporziano and Dead pines detected by NDVI index. Photo
images shows the consequent forest thinning action occurred in April 2017
The calibration of the NDVI values in risk classes allowed us to zone the whole territory in terms of
pinewood crown decline rate and consequently to plan efficacious measures to mitigate the spread of
Tomicus in Castelporziano. In this way, from the first observation of Tomicus in the pinewood of
299
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Castelporziano, which occurred in October 2016, a program of forest harvesting was promptly
planned to mitigate the diffusion of pest in the rest of the Castelporziano pinewood. Thus, in just four
months, almost 60 ha were subjected to forest thinning and, by 2018, another 100 ha will have been
thinned as shown in figure 6 that shows the areas of decline detected by the NDVI index application
and the consequent forest thinning measures already implemented.
References
1. Bannari A., Morin D., Bonn F. (1995). A review of vegetation indices. Remote Sensing Reviews,
Vol. 13, pp. 95-120
2. Frampton W. J., Dash J., Watmough G., Milton E. J. (2013). Evaluating the capabilities of
Sentinel-2 for quantitative estimation of biophysical variables in vegetation. Journal of
Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 82 (2013) 83–92
3. Gooshbor L., Pir Bavaghar M., Amanollahi J., Ghobari H. (2016). Monitoring Infestations of Oak
Forests by Tortrix viridana (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) using Remote Sensing. Plant Protect. Sci.
Vol. 52, 2016, No. 4: 270–276, doi: 10.17221/185/2015-PPS
4. Lia F., Songa G., Liujunb Z., Yanana Z., Dia L. (2017). Urban vegetation phenology analysis
using high spatio-temporal NDVI time series. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening. Vol.25,
pp.43–57
5. Maselli F. (2004). Monitoring forest conditions in a protected Mediterranean coastal area by the
analysis of multiyear NDVI data. Remote Sensing of Environment. Vol.89, pp. 423–433
6. Ogaya R., Barbeta A., Başnou C., Peñuelas J. (2015). Satellite data as indicators of tree biomass
growth and forest dieback in a Mediterranean holm oak forest. Annals of Forest Science, Vol.72,
pp.135–144
7. Recanatesi F., Tolli M., Ripa M.N., Pelorosso R., Gobattoni F., Leone A. (2013). Detection of
Landscape patterns in airborne LIDAR data in the Nature reserve of Castelporziano (Rome).
Journal of Agricultural Engineering. Vol.XLIV, pp. 472-477
8. Recanatesi F. (2014). Variations in land-use/land-cover changes (LULCCs) in a peri-urban
Mediterranean nature reserve: the estate of Castelporziano (Central Italy). Rend. Fis. Acc. Lincei
DOI 10.1007/s12210-014-0358-1
9. Richter, R., Wang, X., Bachmann, M., and Schlaepfer, D., "Correction of cirrus effects in
Sentinel-2 type of imagery", Int. J. Remote Sensing, Vol.32, 2931-2941 (2011).
10. Sheeren D., Fauvel M., Josipovic ́ V., Lopes M., Planque C., Willm J., Dejoux J. F. (2016). Tree
Species Classification in Temperate Forests Using Formosat-2 Satellite Image Time Series. 8,
734; doi:10.3390/rs8090734
11. Topaloglu R. H., Sertel N., Musaoglu N. (2016). Assessment of classification accuracies of
sentinel - 2 and Landsat (for land cover/use mapping. The International Archives of the
Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLI-B8, 2016
XXIII ISPRS Congress, 12–19 July 2016, Prague, Czech Republic
12. Wang C., Lu Z., Haithcoat T.L. (2007). Detection forest dynamics responding to oack dieback in
the Mark Twain National forest, Missouri. Forest Ecology and Management. 240, pp70-78.
13. Wang C., He H. S., Kabrick J. M. (2008). A remote sensing-assisted risk rating study to predict
oak decline and recovery in the Missouri Ozark. GIScience & Remote Sensing. Vol.45, n.4,
pp.406-425.
300
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
SURFACE TEMPERATURES AND THERMAL COMFORT
CONDITIONS IN NORTHERN GREECE
P. Kosmopoulos1, A. Kantzioura1. K. Michalopoulou1
1
K-eco Projects
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: pkosmos@env.duth.gr
Abstract
This paper aims, through research and field measurements in open urban spaces, to study the behavior
and effect of coating materials to the urban microclimate and to draw conclusions regarding the
factors that affect the thermal comfort conditions.
The study attempts to benchmark the effect of design parameters of outdoor urban spaces to the
microclimate and the comfort conditions. Two urban areas in different urban centers, Thessaloniki
and Kastoria in Northern Greece, are investigated. Considering the analysis of the design parameters
and the effects of design interventions to the microclimate, it focuses on thermal indices expressing
the conditions of thermal comfort of the users of urban spaces.
Keywords: Thermal comfort, PMV, Urban Open Spaces
1.
INTRODUCTION
The covering and construction materials in the contemporary cities and the urban geometrical
characteristics affect the microclimatic conditions inside the urban centers (Lau et al, 2011). The
radiant balance of the urban space, the convective heat exchange between the ground and the surfaces,
the air flowing above the urban area and the heat generated within the city (Mihalakakou et al, 2002),
(Santamouris et al, 1999) increase the air temperature in the city. The city has the capacity to modify
local climate, and even creats environmental conditions that could be regarded as urban microclimate
(Gago et al, 2013), (Giridharan et al, 2004). The urban microclimate affects the thermal comfort
conditions in the city.
In the present study two central open areas, a crossway and a square, are selected. The study areas
are located in Northern Greece, Thessaloniki and Kastoria. A number of experimental procedures
were carried out, in order to measure the surface temperature of asphalt, concrete and stones and to
evaluate by using appropriate software the thermal comfort conditions in the study areas. Also,
alternative proposals for upgrading are suggested.
2.
METHODOLOGY
The field surveys involve surface temperature measurements by a thermal camera and microclimatic
monitoring with portable mini-weather stations.
The study areas are located in North Greece, Thessaloniki and Kastoria. The measurements took place
during the summer period.
301
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Figure 1: The two Urban Centers in North Greece
The area in Thessaloniki is a central crossway, Metropoleos and Agias Sofias Street (Figure 2), and
it consists of high building blocks (Table 1). Data from different measurement points along the streets,
from different heights and orientation were collected.
Table 1. Geometric Characteristics of streets, Thessaoloniki
Av. Height
Str Length,
Av Str Width,
H (m)
L (m)
W (m)
West
23
60
12.5
1.8
North
21
70
14
1.4
East
21
100
14
1.5
South
18
50
14
1.3
Orientation
H/W
The area in Kastoria is the Dolcho Square, which occupies an area of about 1075m2. The height of
the surrounding buildings is 3, 6 and 9m. The width of the northern road is about 8m, of the southern
road is 6m, of the west side 9 m and of the east side 7-20m. On the other hand, the park is covered by
stone plates and there are a few trees.
302
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2: Study areas in Urban the Centers, Norh Greece
3.
ANALYSIS
3.1 The crossway
In the crossway the horizontal surface temperatures of asphalt were measured by a thermal camera.
In Figure 3, both the observed and the simulated horizontal surface temperature for the crossway are
presented, with the use of an ENVI-met model. The average deviation percentage between field
measurement data and simulation result data, is about 5-8% for every street. The simulation model
calculates greater horizontal Tsurf than the measured values.
The Envi-met model were used to simulate the microclimatic conditions and the surface temperatures.
The calculated values were close to measured data. The accuracy of the calculated data permit the
simulation of the thermal comfort conditions.
Figure 3: Horizontal surface temperatures in the crossway
According to the ENVI-met simulation results, the maximum horizontal surface temperature is
observed at 13:00 pm at the streets located on the North-South axis, while at 15:00 pm at the EastWest axis. The maximum calculated temperature approximates 52.20°C, in South Street (Figure 4).
In Table 2 the temperature fluctuations of horizontal surfaces at 13:00 and 15:00pm, according to the
simulation model are presented.
303
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Table 2: Temperature fluctuation of horizontal surfaces by simulation model, crossway
15 15
N
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
15
Tree
15
15
M1
Building
Street
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
40
39
38
37
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
6
M1
6
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
6
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
23
24
25
32
33
22
xx
21
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
M1
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
M1
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
M1
15
20
19
15
15
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
xx
xx
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
xx
xx
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
xx
xx
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
31
23
xx
M1
M1
6
M1
30
xx
M1
M1
6
M1
29
6
M1
6
M1
28
6
M1
6
M1
27
6
M1
6
M1
26
6
M1
6
M1
M1
22
6
M1
6
6
34
35
M1
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
xx
xx
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
xx
xx
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
6
6
6
6
6
6
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
3
3
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
xx
xx
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
xx
xx
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
xx
xx
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
3
3
3
3
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
xx
xx
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
3
3
3
3
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
xx
xx
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
xx
xx
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
M1
M1
6
6
6
xx
xx
xx
M1
M1
M1
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
15
77
78
79
80
6
M1
1
24
M1
M1
6
M1
M1
M1
M1
15
15
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
M1
36
6
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
15
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
15
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
18
17
16
15
14
13
12
11
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
15:00
13:00
The Figure 4 we present a comparison of the variation of thermal comfort index PMV with the
temperature variation of the Tsurf. The index PMV is increasing from 8:00am until midday. The
increasing of surface temperature is continuing for two more hours. The decreasing of index PMV
(reinstatement of thermal comfort) begins two hours earlier than the decreasing of Tsurf (except of
the south orientated road).
So, while the feeling of thermal comfort is gradually restored, the surface temperature of the materials
remains in high levels. The maximum PMV is approximately 2.5 and displayed at 13:00 to 16:00pm.
Figure 4. The PMV index and the Tsurf, in each of the four differently orientated streets of
the crossway
304
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.2 The Square
In Figure 5, the surface temperatures of the covered materials in the square is presented.
Figure 5: Surface Temperatures of covering and other materials
Figure 6: Surface Temperature, Air Temperature (Tair), Black Ball Temperature
In Figure 7 the surface temperatures of covering materials in Square and the Tair over specific
materials on height of 1.20 to 1.50m are observed (Kosmopoulos, 2017). The Pv studio, Weather data
analysis and Ecotect analysis are used in order to simulate the conditions.
305
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Figure 7: Surface Temperature, Black Ball Temperature
Figure 8: Direct and Diffuse Radiation at the open space.
In the questionnaires gathered, the thermal comfort conditions during morning, noon and afternoon
time are investigated. A five-point scale has been used (very cold, cold, neutral, hot, very hot) in order
to study the subjective comfort conditions. In Figure 9 the comfort conditions of Doltso Square are
observed, during 12-17 July.
306
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 9: Subjective comfort conditions in square, 42 persons
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
In this paper, we have presented data gatered from two central areas in two cities in Northern Greece.
Although different measuring approaches have been used, very useful conclysions have been
extracted regarding the thermal comfort conditions at the height of 1,20 to 1,50 m from the ground,
which affect the persons that are walking or are sitted.
Unfortunately, most of the open spaces of Hellenic cities, have been covered with “hot” materials and
also suffer from lack of green (trees, grass tec) Thus, we may cloncluded our remarks as follows:
After the analysis of Surface temperatures, air temperature, black ball temperature and the existing
thermal comfort conditions intervention, proposals for the upgrading of the comfort conditions are
wing.
The replacement of the asphalt (tar) with perforated cement blocks over natural grass, and/or simply
grass areas, and specific kinds of trees planted around the study area were analyzed. The improvement
of the sensation of thermal comfort is presented in Table 3.
307
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Table 3: Tmrt thermal index before and after the interventions
EXISTING MATERIALS
Tmrt
PROPOSED MATERIALS
Tmrt
White cement stone plates
Perforated stones
65,9
63,4
Grass-Planted areas
Stone plaques
65,2
White marble
63,8
Grass or perforated cement plaques
at the parking places
68,3
Tar
64,5
Large trees
66,3
62,4
By comparing all the data gathered, it has been concluded that the replacement of the usually used in
Greece open spaces materials (asphalt, concrete, stones) with perforated materials or grass, and the
plantation of specific kinds of trees, improves largely the thermal comfort conditions of the urban
microclimate.
This research project has studied in two urban centers the thermal comfort conditions in open spaces
with on site measurements, questionnaires and the use of software. The covered open areas by asphalt,
concrete and stones is characterized by high temperatures that lead to the degradation of urban
microclimate and the deterioration of thermal comfort conditions. The paper has led to conclusions
and proposals towards the improvement of thermal conditions in urban centers and the optimization
of urban environment.
References
1. Gago E.J., Roldan J., Pacheco- Torres R., Ordóñez J., The city and urban heat islands: A review
of strategies to mitigate adverse effects, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Volume
25, (2013), pp.749–758
2. Giridharan R, Ganesan S, Lau S.S.Y., Day time urban heat island effect in high- rise and highdensity residential developments in Hong Kong. Energy and Building, Volume 36, (2004), pp.
525–34.
3. Kosmopoulos P., Michalopoulou K., 2017, Comfort Conditions and microclimate in open urban
areas, University Studio Press, Thessaloniki
308
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4. Lau, S. S. Y., Yang, F., Tai, J., Wu, X. L., & Wang, J., (2011), The study of summer-time heat
island, built form and fabric in a densely built urban environment in compact Chinese cities: Hong
Kong, Guangzhou. International Journal of Sustainable Development, Vol. 14(1-2), pp. 3048
5. Mihalakakou, P., Flocas, H.A., Santamouris, M., Helmis, C.G., (2002), Application of neural
networks to the simulation of the heat island over Athens, Greece, using synoptic types as a
predictor. Journal of Applied Meteorology, Vol. 41 5, pp. 519–527.
6. Santamouris, M., Mihalakakou, G., Papanikolaou, N., Assimakopoulos, D.N., (1999), A neural
network approach for modeling the heat island phenomenon in urban areas during the summer
period. Geophysical Research Letters, Vol. 26 3, pp. 337–340.
309
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
INVESTIGATION OF THERMAL COMFORT CONDITIONS IN
URBAN CENTERS OF NORTHERN GREECE
P. Kosmopoulos1, A. Kantzioura 2, A. Moumtzakis2
1
Κ-eco Projects co, f. Director of the Laboratory of Environmental and Energy Design of Buildings
and Settlements, DUTH,
2
Laboratory of Environmental and Energy Design of Buildings and Settlements, Democritus
University of Thrace, Department of Environmental Engineering, Xanthi, Greece
*Corresponding author: E-mail: pkosmos@env.duth.gr
Abstract
This study investigates the thermal comfort conditions during the summer period in a central area of
Northern Greece, Thessaloniki. In the study area takes place a large number of financial and social
activities of the inhabitants.
A number of in situ experimental procedures were carried out. Surface temperatures, microclimatic
data and urban morphology data were gathered. Also, simulation models have been used to calculate
the outdoor thermal comfort sensation. The thermal comfort indices which have been used is the
Predicted Mean Vote, (PMV) which provides the average response of a large sample of individuals,
the Predicted Percentage Dissatisfied, (PPD) which provides the percentage of people in a large
sample who do not feel comfortable in a space, and the Standard Effective Temperature, (SET).
Keywords: Thermal comfort, PMV - PET - SET
1.
INTRODUCTION
The covering and construction materials in contemporary cities and the urban geometrical
characteristics affect the microclimatic conditions inside the urban centers (Lau et al, 2011). The
thermal comfort and energy efficiency of cities are largely determined by urban climatology, which
in turn is influenced by the thermo-electric mechanisms of the structured environment and especially
by atmospheric transport phenomena (Steemers, 2003). The most important parameters determining
the degree of environmental stress as well as the energy losses of the built environment are the
geometry of the buildings - open spaces, the vegetation rate, the building materials and ventilation of
the urban spaces, as it results from the thermomechanical behavior of the surrounding atmosphere in
relation to the urban terrain (Santamouris et al, 2001).
The high UHI has a strong negative effect on thermal comfort of humans. In addition, higher
temperatures in urban sections have led to an increase in peak and total energy demand (Golden,
2004), (Oxizidis and Papadopoulos 2013). Strategies which include items such as shading, increased
cooling from tree shading and building ventilation, as well as permeable pavements and higher
reflecting surface materials could improve the thermal comfort sensation. Results from this and other
similar studies, should nonetheless be utilized to determine the ideal and sustainable urban design for
outdoor human comfort and heat mitigation (Hedquist and Brazel, 2014).
310
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.
CLIMATE ANALYSIS IN THESSALONIKI
The climate in the region of Thessaloniki can be considered as Mediterranean, with a strong
continental influence in the different seasons. The temperature has the highest average in July and the
lowest in January, the annual temperature range is close to 20 ° C, while in the cold season very cold
air masses blow over and often frost the liquid. The average annual air temperature is around 16 ° C,
the lowest average temperature (January) around 6 ° C while the highest (July) around 26 - 26,50 °
C. The annual rainfall is around 500 mm. Snow is not a rare phenomenon. The winds are different in
seasons: in the winter prevail North winds from the valley of Axios (Vardaris), and less the western
ones, in the spring the more frequent are the southwest, in the summer the northern and southwest
dominate while in September the Southwest is diminished and in November the northern and the
western dominate again at the region.
3.
METHODOLOGY
The research is concluded by 3 different measurement and analysed cycles.
During the first, a number of experimental procedures were carried out in order to investigate the
effect of urban planning on microclimatic conditions. The study area is located in the urban center of
Thessaloniki, Greece (Figure 1) in the crossway Metropoleos and Agias Sofias Street, and it consists
of high building blocks. Data from different measurement points along the streets, from different
heights and orientation were collected. The data gathered investigate the variation of Surface
Temperature (Tsurf) on a 24 hours basis and Air Temperature (Tair). The measurements took place
during summer. The field surveys involve surface temperature measurements by a thermal camera
and microclimatic monitoring with portable mini-weather stations. The geometric characteristics of
the streets and the observations for the measurement points are given in Table 1.
Figure 1: Study area in Urban Center of Thessaloniki, Greece
311
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
Table 1: Geometric Characteristics of streets
Orientation
West
North
East
South
Av. Height
H (m)
23
21
21
18
Str Length,
L (m)
60
70
100
50
Av Str Width,
W (m)
12.5
14
14
14
H/W
1.8
1.4
1.5
1.3
Also, a simulation model ENVI-met is used in order to investigate the thermal comfort conditions in
the study area. The gathered data for temperatures of vertical and horizontal surfaces and
microclimatic data (Air temperature, Wind Speed, Wind Direction) from Masurement Points located
in different places along the streets and on different heights is used (Kosmopoulos and Kantzioura,
2014). The simulation results were compared with measurement data and the deviation was about
8%, which is regarded satisfactory.
During the second cycle, 28 points examined in Aristotelous’ square, in order to analyze the buildings
and the existing vegetation at the level of annual shading. Data collection have been made with a
specialized instrument in the study area while measurement system analysis lead and modeling data
using appropriate software (Solar Pathfinder - SketchUp). Measurements took place during the day,
when the less traffic volume prevailed, to achieve an accurate representation of the obstacle mask.
Humidity, wind speed, and temperature measurements were also performed to analyze and simulate
the characteristics of the area. The data analyzed by software (RayMAN) to extract thermal comfort
indicators (Matzarakis et al, 2007).
The paper refers to two open spaces in urban centers, in a city at Northern Greece. In these areas a
large number of social and commercial activities take place. So, the study of the thermal comfort
conditions is a very interesting subject. The size of the two areas is about 500 square meters but the
two open spaces have different geometric characteristics. The one is a square and the second a
crossway.
We consider that the choice of these indexes describes optimal the conditions in the two open spaces,
which are characterized by different geometrical characteristics.
4.
ANALYSIS
4.1 Central crossway
According the Vertical surface temperatures, the road located on the North-South axis appears
different thermal behavior according to the orientation of each side of the road. The vertical surfaces
of buildings’ façade on west side develop high temperature during morning time, while on east side
at the afternoon. Greater Tsurf is observed at west side. On West-East axis road, the maximum surface
temperature is observed mainly during evening hours. The orientation of each side of the road doesn’t
affect the thermal behavior of the surfaces, as observed in the North-South axis (Kantzioura and
Kosmopoulos, 2016).
312
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2: Temperature varation of vertical surfaces
In order to investigate the Thermal comfort conditions in the central crossawy, the index PMV is
calculated on pedestrian’s level, on 1.20-1.50m height. The 1.5m height is considered as
representative pedestrian’s level of adults and children, seating and passing passengers
(Kosmopoulos, 2017).
The simulation model and the corresponding measurement data is referred in 21 July, the day of the
maximum Tair in 24h basis in Thessaloniki, according to the Technical Guidelines of the Technical
Chamber of Greece (TOTEE).
The simulation time step is 1h, from 6:00 a.m. to 20: 00pm. The start time of the simulation model
was set 2 hours earlier than the first in situ measurement (8:00 a.m.), in order to achieve the optimal
predictive accuracy.
The thermal comfort scale used is from -3 to +3 (Very Cold, Cool, Slightly Cool, Comfort, Slightly
Warn, Hot, Very Hot).
Table 2: Depiction of Thermal comfort index at 12:00pm
12:00
313
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
In Figure 3, the PMV index and the Tair on pedestrian’s level, for each of the different orientated
streets are observed.
Figure 3: The PMV index and the Tair, in each of the four different orientated streets, on
pedestrian’s level.
The feeling of thermal comfort starts from "comfort" in the morning (8:00 to 10:00) and gradually
deteriorates in “very hot” at 14:00 pm-16: 00pm. In the afternoons, the PMV decreases gradually and
restored the sensation of "comfort". The index PMV and the Tair have the same fluctuation during
the day, especially in west oriented urban canyon.
Increasing of Tair followed by an increase of thermal comfort index PMV, as well as decreasing of
Tair leads to a decrease in the PMV (Figure 4).
Figure 4: Fluctuation of index PMV and Tair
The Figure 5 comparing the variation of thermal comfort index PMV with the temperature variation
of the horizontal surfaces Tsurf. The index PMV is increasing from 8:00am until midday. The
increasing of surface temperature is continuing for two more hours (Figure 5). The decreasing of
index PMV (reinstatement of thermal comfort) begins two hours earlier than the decreasing of
314
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
horizontal surface temperature (except of the south orientated road). The maximum PMV is
approximately 2.5 and displayed at 13:00 to 16:00pm.
Figure 5: The PMV index and the Horizontal Tsurf, in each of the four differently orientated
streets
In Figure 6, the correlation coefficient p between the thermal comfort PMV, the air temperature at
pedestian’s level and surface temperature of the horizontal surfaces is calculated. The correlation
between the PMV and Tair is about 0.7, and between the PMV and Tsurf is about 0.8-0.9.
It is concluded that there is satisfactory correlation and the thermal comfort conditions are affected
by the air temperature and the horizontal surface temperature.
Figure 6: Correlation coefficient between PMV and Tair, and between PMV and Tsurf.
315
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
4.2 central square
The square's area comprises to the left and right large high-rise buildings that shade a large part of
the open space during the day, resulting in the drop-in temperature values at single points.
Table 3: Annual rate of shadow at the square.
MONTH
PERCENTAGE% UNSHADED SOLAR
AREA
KW/m2/day
JANUARY
FEBRUARY
MARCH
APRIL
39,97%
50,23%
58,96%
65,07%
0,71
1,46
2,35
3,19
MAY
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER
67,78%
69,50%
68,40%
65,11%
59,60%
51,72%
42,77%
35,59%
4,08
4,93
4,82
4,06
2,84
1,64
0,84
0,54
RADIATION,
The results of the shading models presented in Table 3 show the difference in energy load and solar
input rate generated during the year in the square area. It is observed that there is an increase of the
solar load and expansion of the solar space during the summer period (Fig.7). The requirements for
shading in the summer affect the levels of thermal comfort, resulting in the adaptation of the planning
strategies. The vegetation in the space and reaching levels of thermal comfort is a powerful planning
tool aimed at the decisive intervention of the engineer in the field. An important factor is also the
materials of the square, the main part of which is made of granite, asphalt and marble resulting in the
high density of the material, which works in relation to the large area of coverage as a large heat
storage in the summer (Kosmopoulos, 2008).
Figure 7: 21/6, shading model in summer season.
An important element on the record of data in the study area is the dynamic movement of the wind
and the pressure around the Aristotle square which is under consideration. The wind analysis
represents graphically (Fig. 8,9) those points that develop high velocities between the obstacles in the
space as well as in the hidden places where the wind remains stationary. The modeling of velocity
316
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
and wind direction in the Aristotle square area uses a wind speed model of 3 m/s for average values
as well as 7.5 m/s, which is the average of maximum values. The models were reviewed for the
summer of 1 June - 31 August.
Figure 8: North Wind 3m/s.
Figure 9: Pressure of N. Wind.
The wind movement is a key factor in creating thermal comfort which is used to increase comfort
levels when high outdoor temperatures prevail during the summer period. In order to achieve upgrade
levels, changes to the direction and reduction of the speed in specific parts of the study area should
be considered. The graphical of wind velocity gradient as shown in Figures 8 and 59 is an important
information that explains the way in which the square's behaviorand the thermal comfier conditions
will improve.
Modeling of trees in the field of study was carried out in order to analyze the behavior of the area
during the day. Trees which have been recorded are evergreens, bitter oranges, and coconut trees. The
ave height of the bitter oranges is about 6 meters long and the average height of the palm trees at 912 meters (Moumtzakis, 2013).
Table 4: Length of shadow related to the type of vegetation.
Month - Hour
21 June - 09:00
21 June - 12:30
21 June - 15:00
21 June - 18:00
21 June - 09:00
21 June - 12:30
21 June - 15:00
21 June - 18:00
Type of vegetation
Bitter orange
Bitter orange
Bitter orange
Bitter orange
Palm tree
Palm tree
Palm tree
Palm tree
Height
5.569 m
5.569 m
5.569 m
5.569 m
11.735 m
11.735 m
11.735 m
11.735 m
Length of shadow
6.644 m
1.834 m
5.305 m
15.469 m
14.959 m
7.253 m
11.300 m
33.529 m
The RAYMAN software evaluates the comfort conditions in the study area, analyzes the input data
and informs the user of the thermal indices prevailing at the reference point. The indicators are PET
that examines the human energy balance (Matzarakis et al, 2007), PMV, which is the average vote of
a set of people expressing their reaction to thermal sensation under different environmental
conditions, on a scale ranging from -3 to +3, and SET which provides a reasonable basis for measuring
the equivalence of any combination of environmental factors, clothing, and metabolic rate (Guodong
et al, 2003).
The research based on the work of two basic scenarios. The first scenario estimates at the existing
situation while the following scenario attempts to improve the conditions that exist by adding
vegetation components to the site. The inputs are a) temperature b) humidity c) wind speed d) activity
data and clothing. The temperature factor analyzed in two phases 1) in the set of maximum averages
317
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
and 2) in the average set, thus an unfavorable scenario can be evaluated, while in the second case a
regular one can be studied.
Figure 10: Simulation models. 1st scenario, with vegetation in the present situation
Figure 11: Thermal comfort indicator points. 2nd scenario with vegetation in the summer
Analyzing the results of a survey (Table 5), observed a significant reduction in thermal comfort
indicators. The intervention - outdoor upgrade is effective during the summer months.
318
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 5: Thermal Comfort Indices
CURRENT SITUATION
SUMMER UNPLEASANT
SCENARIO CENTRAL PART
PMV
PET
SET
2,9
35,2
27,6
Hot
Hot
Warm
SUMMER MILD
SCENARIO-CENTRAL PART
BIOCLIMATIC DESIGN
SUMMER UNPLEASANT
SCENARIO CENTRAL PART
PMV
PET
SET
1,9
28,7
21,2
Warm
Warm
Slightly cool
SUMMER MILD
SCENARIO-CENTRAL PART
PMV
PET
SET
1,0
26,6
19,1
Slightly
Slightly
Slightly cool
warm
warm
SUMMER UNPLEASANT
SCENARIO SOUTH PART
PMV
3,2
Very Hot
PET
36,6
Hot
SET
28,9
Slightly
warm
5.
PET
28
Slightly
warm
PET
20,8
Comfortable
SET
12,4
Cold
SUMMER UNPLEASANT
SCENARIO SOUTH PART
PMV
2,2
Warm
PET
30,9
Warm
PMV
0,3
Comfortable
PET
22,3
Slightly
cool
SET
26
Slightly
warm
SUMMER MILD SCENARIO
SOUTH PART
SUMMER MILD
SCENARIO-SOUTH PART
PMV
1,2
Slightly
warm
PMV
-0,1
Comfortable
SET
20,4
Slightly cool
SET
14,8
Cool
CONCLUSIONS
The urban geometry and vegetation influences the surface temperatures, the microclimatic parameters
in the urban centers and configures the conditions inside the urban canyons.
The present study indicates that the thermal behavior of buildings’ envelope is affected by the urban
geometry, the measurement height, the orientation, the position of the measurement points along the
street. Also concluded, that there is a correlation between the surface temperatures and air
temperatures on pedestrian’s level. This correlation affects the microclimatic conditions and the
thermal comfort sensation in outdoor spaces.
The present study should help effectively in improving the urban microclimatic conditions and in
energy efficiency design of buildings, according to the specificities of each position in the built
environment.
References
1. Hedquist, B.C., Brazel, A.J., (2014), Seasonal variability of temperatures and outdoor human
comfort inPhoenix, Arizona, U.S.A., Building and Environment, 72, pp. 377-388.
2. Golden J.S., (2004), The built environment induced urban heat island in rapidly urbanizing arid
regions: a sustainable urban engineering complexity, Environ Sci, 1 (4), pp. 321–349
3. Guodong, Y., Changzhi, Y., Youming, C., Yuguo, 2003, ‘’A new approach for measuring
predicted mean vote (PMV) and standard effective temperature (SET*)’’, Building and
Environment, 38, pp.33 – 44.
4. Kantzioura A., Kosmopoulos P., Research on how buildings and covering materials affect
microclimate conditions: Case study the center of Thessaloniki, 13th International Conference
319
Sustainable architecture, planning and development - Urban environment
on Protection and Restoration of the Environment, Mykonos island, Greece, 3rd to 8th
of July, 2016
5. Kosmopoulos P., Kantzioura, A., 2014, Effects of urban development in microclimatic conditions
in Thessaloniki, Global Nest Journal, 16 (5), pp. 840-855.
6. Kosmopoulos P., Michalopoulou K., 2017, Comfort Conditions and Microclimate in open urban
areas, University Studio Press, Thessaloniki
7. Kosmopoulos, P., 2008, Buildings Energy And The Environment, University Studio Press,
Thessaloniki, GR.
8. Lau, S. S. Y., Yang, F., Tai, J., Wu, X. L., & Wang, J., (2011), The study of summer-time heat
island, built form and fabric in a densely built urban environment in compact Chinese cities: Hong
Kong, Guangzhou. International Journal of Sustainable Development, Vol. 14(1-2), pp. 3048
9. Matzarakis, A., Rutz, F., and Mayer, H., 2007, ‘’Modelling radiation fluxes in simple and
complex environments — application of the RayMan model’’, Int J Biometeorol, 51, pp. 323 –
334,.
10. Moumtzakis, A., 2013, “Integrated Environmental Design of Energetically Autonomous
Building’’, MSc. Thesis, Democritus University of Thrace, Xanthi, Greece.
11. Oxizidis, S., Papadopoulos, A., (2013), Performance of radiant cooling surfaces with respect to
energy consumption and thermal comfort, Energy and Buildings, Volume 57, pp. 199-209
12. Santamouris, Μ., Papanikolaou, Ν., livada, Ι.Koronakis, Ι., Georgakis, Argiriou, Α., and
Assimakopoulos, D.N., 2001, “On the impact of urban climate on the energy consumption of
buildings’’, Solar Energy, 70(3), pp. 201–216.
13. Steemers, K., 2003, “Energy and the city: density, buildings and transport’’, Energy and
Buildings, 35, pp. 3-14.
14. Solar Pathfinder Manual. http://www.solarpathfinder.com (8 Νοεμβρίου 2014).
320
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Cultural and social issues
321
Cultural and social issues
322
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
REFUGEE CRISIS: GREEK RESIDENTS’ ATTITUDES
TOWARDS WASTE MANAGEMENT IN THEIR REGION
A. Kounani*, C. Skanavis
Department of Environment, University of the Aegean, University Hill, 81100, Mytilene, Greece
*Corresponding author: E-mail: kounani@env.aegean.gr, Tel +30 2321047710
Abstract
Todays’ refugee crisis is considered an unceasing challenge of the current century, since the mass
exodus of people from their own country has exponentially increased. The consequences of this
worldwide phenomenon are much bigger than the actual issue itself. Migrants and refugees flocking
into Europe from the Middle East, South Asia and Africa, have presented European leaders and
policymakers with a heavy task since the debt crisis. Syria is presenting the biggest humanitarian and
refugee crisis of recent years, a continuing cause of suffering for millions of people. This massive
immigration is known as the “Middle East Refugee Crisis”, and obviously it has affected all the
neighboring to Syria, countries including Greece. Refugee movements in such astonishing numbers
are prospective to produce rampant, quotidian effects on social, environmental and political sector of
the receiving and hosting regions’ local community.
The purpose of the present research was to explore the knowledge, awareness and attitudes towards
waste management and “special waste” management of residents in Lesvos Island, a migrant
receiving community. As “special waste” are considered the life jackets, rubber dinghies and
fiberglass boats. In the spring of 2017, a questionnaire-based survey was administered on Lesvos
Island. Furthermore, the findings revealed the locals’ total environmental awareness as well as their
perceptions towards refugee crisis that Greece is being confronted with. The issue of waste
management is vital in receiving and hosting regions, since the settlement of refugees in regions that
don’t have the capacity to absorb the pressure of huge influxes is expected to cause social instability
and pose a threat to national security.
Keywords: Syrian Refugee Crisis; Waste Management; Environmental Awareness; Special Wastes;
Lesvos; Greece
1.
INTRODUCTION
Living in a world where nearly 20 individuals are forcibly displaced every minute as an outcome of
environmental disasters, persecutions or conflicts, every human being on this planet is witnessing the
highest refugee movement ever recorded. According to UNHCR an unprecedented 65.6 million
people around the world have been forced to leave home at the end of 2016, while almost the 22.5
million are refugees, over half of, whom are under the age of 18 (UNHCR 2018).
Today, undeniably, migration is being exploded in a number of ways: in coverage, in politics and as
an area of academic inquiry. In 2015, Global Risk Reports have recognized water as the most
significant challenge globally, and the principal economic and societal jeopardy for the years to come.
Although the world as a whole has plentiful freshwater resources, seasonal scarcity as well as spatial
discrepancy of freshwater, aggravated by climate change, is developing as a critical peril for
numerous areas worldwide (Zhang 2015).
323
Cultural and social issues
One of the foremost phenomena challenging the countries influenced by immigration are refugee
camps where huge numbers of displaced people settle down at places that were not prepared for such
enormous influx (Braun et al. 2016). Host countries, due to the spontaneous nature of migration, often
lack the means to plan effective camp constructions. Despite the fact, both refugees and the host
populations could benefit from a strategic plan of infrastructure and social services by UNHCR or
the non-governmental organizations (Braun et al. 2016; Perouse de Montclos and Kagwanja 2009).
Furthermore, the particular numbers of dwellings, people who live in them, the size of the camp and
the conditions of the surrounding areas need to be estimated. Ιt is quite obvious that large camps
accelerate land degradation (Braun et al. 2016).
Evidently, whenever refugees settle in a specific area, it is proven that they will affect the social,
environmental and political sector of the hosting region. Due to lack of appropriate planning and
anticipation for such an intense increase of people arriving, specifically when the hosting nation does
not have sustainable and integrated management plans, the problems that are caused are unaffordable
(Kherfan 2016).
The aim of the research was to explore the knowledge, awareness and attitudes towards waste
management and “special waste” management of residents in Lesvos Island, a migrant receiving
community. The findings revealed the locals’ total environmental awareness as well as their
perceptions towards refugee crisis that Greece is being confronted with.
2.
THE SYRIAN CIVIL WAR
In early 2006, Syria and The Fertile Crescent experienced the worst 3-year drought ever recorded
there. The drought exacerbated existing water and agricultural insecurity and caused massive
agricultural failures and livestock mortality. The most significant consequence was the migration of
as many as 1.5 million people from rural farming areas to the peripheries of urban centers.
Government agricultural policy is prominent among the many factors that shaped Syria’s
vulnerability to drought. De Chatel (2014) explains how the 2006-2010 droughts in Syria led to the
uprising increase of emigrants that followed the years after. She particularly argues that it was not the
drought per se that generated a conflict and produced millions of refugees but the government’s
failure to respond to humanitarian needs affected by environmental reasons (Kelley et al. 2015).
With poor governance and unsustainable agricultural and environmental policies, the drought led to
environmentally-induced migration from rural Syria to urban. Subsequently, the greater population
density in cities and the increased unemployment contributed to people’s frustration with the
governmental and political unrest being at state. In 2011 this unrest was further triggered by the Arab
Spring, which led to the Syrian civil war (Kelley et al. 2015). Pro-democracy protests, all-over the
country, stood against President Bashar Al Assad’s, who was characterized by authoritarianism,
political corruption and human rights violation. Protesters were armed with the help of opposition
militias who were fighting against governmental forces. At 2012 the conflict has erupted in a fullgrown civil war between the pro government ones against the ones opposing to it (Holliday 2013).
This ongoing war causes massive migration of people from Syria and the surrounding countries to
Europe (Skanavis and Kounani 2016).
3.
THE IMPACTS OF REFUGEE CRISIS IN GREECE
Greece has faced immense challenges under the pressure of the ongoing “European refugee crisis”.
Still covering from the 2008 financial crisis, Greece was not prepared to deal with such a massive
migration flow (Skanavis and Kounani 2016). The Greek islands close to the Turkish borders were
affected the hardest by the refugee crisis and while the political and humanitarian challenges of the
migration flow were immense and gained precedence in the global media, the environmental
challenges were over looked.
324
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Many of refugees made their way through Turkey to Greece, and eventually to other European
countries. According to the UNHCR, since 2014 more than one million refugees have crossed over
the Aegean Sea from Turkey to Greece in order to reach European soil (UNHCR 2017a). Greece
became a major migration route and while most of the people arriving in Greece were from Syria, the
country saw also an unprecedented number of migrants from other countries such as Afghanistan and
Iraq, as well as smaller numbers from countries such as Eritrea, Somalia and Sudan (UNHCR 2015).
In 2015, and the years before, the refugees and migrants traveled through the Greek islands and
quickly continued their journey to Athens and onwards to other European countries. But as the Balkan
countries built fences and closed their borders, refugees got stranded, at the borders and in all of
Greek mainland. With an unambiguous departure date many of the refugees in Greece today are
trapped (Skanavis and Kounani 2016). Greek islands in particular were intended as transition routes,
but have now become migrant host communities. For instance, on the island of Lesvos just 8 to 10
km off the Turkish coast, the local population saw unprecedented numbers of migrants arriving in
2015 and early 2016. While the numbers of sea arrivals have decreased and people have been
transferred further on to mainland Greece, there are still an estimated 5,000 migrants and refugees
residing on the island (UNHCR 2017b). This is a nearly 6% increase of Lesvos’ local population of
86,436 residents, a percentage which takes its toll on an island community (Hellenic Statistical
Authority 2014)
The environmental effects of mass migration movements on host environments are alike to those of
overpopulation (Lee 1995). On the Greek islands in particular, these impacts included pressure on
water and energy demand, soil destruction, air pollution, deforestation and increased waste
production. Especially, the enormous amounts of waste from the life jackets and rubber dinghies that
the migrants used to cross the sea pose a massive challenge to the Greek islands. However, with
inadequate landfill capacity and no facilities in Greece to recycle these materials from the life jackets
in particular, the islands are not only being confronted with the challenges of refugees but also the
ever increasing amounts of waste (Skanavis and Kounani 2016).
To conclude with, the refugees’ footprint can be summarized as: pressure on water and energy
demand, soil destruction, air pollution, deforestation, waste production. However, every refugee crisis
is unique and needs to be observed and managed as an individual condition (UNHCR 2011).
Therefore, overpopulation of Greek islands is projected that it causes significant environmental
degradation. Greece was not well organized to deal with the refugee flow while being in a harsh
economic crisis (Skanavis and Kounani 2016).
4.
THE CASE OF LESVOS ISLAND
The island of Lesvos, located in the North-Eastern Aegean Sea, has a coastline of 370 km and is
separated from the Asia Minor coast, to which it is geologically related, by two shallow channels
ranging from 6 to 14 miles (10 to 23 km) wide, the Muselim (north) and the Mitilini (east), which
join at the apex of the triangular island, forming the entrance to the Turkish Gulf of Edremit
(Encyclopaedia Britannica 2017).
The Municipality of the island of Lesvos consists of 13 sections and 190 villages with a total
population of 85,412 residents (Hellenic Statistical Authority, cited in Skanavis and Kounani 2016).
4.1
Municipal solid waste (MSW) production and environmental management of Lesvos
Island
According to receiving data from the “Service of Planning Department, Cleanliness, Recycling,
Waste Collection” of the Municipality of Lesvos the amounts of MSW on the island is about 100
tones/day in winter and ranges from 120-130 tones / day in the tourist season. Specifically, the amount
of unsorted waste and the recyclables in years 2013 to 2016 are depicted in Table 1.
325
Cultural and social issues
Year
Table 1. The amount of produced solid wastes
Total Amount of
Total Amount of
Total amount of
Municipal Solid Waste
Recyclables
Produced waste
(tones/year)
(tones/year)
(tones/year)
2013
33,228.93
-
33,228.93
2014
37,146.39
1,285
38,431.39
2015
36,322.14
2.186
38,508.14
2016
38,056.71
2,844
40,900.71
2017
39,108.72
3,322.1
42,430.82
(Municipality of Lesvos 2018)
The responsibility of uploading, disposal and recovery of wastes is placed on the Municipal Waste
Management and Environmental Development Company of Lesvos. Sorting, compression, and sale
of recyclables is occurred in a private center, the Recycling Sorting in Moria area, run by the company
“Sea-Lesvos Foundries Recycling SA” (Skanavis and Kounani 2016).
4.2 Management of “special wastes”
The major waste problem the island of Lesvos is being confronted with, due to refugees’ inflows, is
the disposal of plastic from their life jackets and inflatable crafts, which remain behind upon their
arrival to the island. Plans have been proposed in order to deal with the issue. Moreover, landfill
capacity is not adequate for the unexpected inflow of people in the islands where refugees arrive. The
volume of lifejackets and boats collected until December 2017 was about 20,000 cubic meters. This
type of waste has been collected and transferred to 3 municipal stations, in an effort to find a way to
recycle it. The materials, though, the life jackets are made from, cannot be recycled in Greece
(Skanavis and Kounani 2016).
5.
METHODOLOGY
In May 2017, a questionnaire-based research was conducted in order to evaluate Lesvians’ attitudes
towards the waste management of their region, the management of “special” waste, as well as their
awareness towards environmental issues.
5.1 Research area
The research area was the island of Lesvos.
5.2 Research instruments
The implementation of the questionnaire was on a door-to-door basis. The questions, the total
numbers of which were 35, were derived from other research projects and were divided into 4 groups.
The first group of 6 questions inquired demographics information. The second group of 6 questions
provided data towards the perceptions of the participants on general environmental issues. The third
group of 18 questions supplied information according to the knowledge, perceptions and willingness
to behave towards the MSW management and the management of the “special” wastes produced by
the refugees. The final group of 5 questions provided data towards their perceptions on refugee crisis
Greece is confronting
For the statistical analysis of the received data, SPSS was used.
326
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
5.3 Research sample
The research sample was composed of the inhabitants of Lesvos Islands, the total number of whom
were 140. Τhe sample was a random selection of residents of the specific island, during the summer
months of 2017. The age of the participants and their gender are presented in Figures 1 and 2.
32.90%
27.90%
24.30%
40%
30%
20%
44.30%
55.70%
15%
men
women
10%
0%
18-25 26-35 36-45 46-65
Figure 2. Inhabitants’ gender
Figure 1. Inhabitants of Lesvos age groups
The marital status of the participants and their number of children are shown in Figures 3 and 4.
47.10%
50.00%
39.30%
40.00%
30.00%
20.00%
11.40%
10.00%
2.10%
0.00%
single
married
divorced
widowed
Figure 4. Participants’ number of children
Figure 3. Marital status of Lesvos
inhabitants
Their educational level and professional condition is presented in Figures 5 and 6.
Master's
Degree,
12.90%
Ph.D.,
1.40%
Primary
School,
2.90%
High
school,
2.90%
retired
householding
unemployed
Universit
y
graduate,
40%
Lyceum
graduate,
40%
employed
Figure 5. Educational level of Lesvos’
residents
6.
2.10%
1.40%
15.70%
80.70%
Figure 6. Professional condition of Lesvos’
participants
RESULTS
The questions of the questionnaire were divided into four groups. The results are presented in a similar
way.
327
Cultural and social issues
6.1 Participants’ Total Environmental Awareness
First of all, most of the participants (87.1 %) considered themselves as environmentally aware
individuals, while the 10.7% were apathetic and the 2.1% weren’t aware. Moreover, the 92.9%
appeared to worry about the environment of their region, whilst the 5.7% were not perturbing and the
1.4% had no worries.
At the same time, Lesvians’ aspects about the weightiness of the following environmental challenges
for Greece, on a scale of 1 (not serious at all) to 5 (extremely serious) are depicted in Table 2.
Table 2. Lesvos residents’ aspects about the weightiness of the following environmental
challenges for Greece, on a scale of 1 (not serious at all) to 5 (extremely serious)
N
Mean
SD
Min
Max
Environmental- Climate Refugees
140
4.11
1.09
1
5
Water pollution
140
4.02
0.96
1
5
Increase in Municipal Solid Waste Production
140
4.00
0.94
1
5
Deforestation
140
3.85
1.09
1
5
Climate change
140
3.83
1.17
1
5
Air pollution
140
3.78
1.00
1
5
Ozone depletion
140
3.52
1.20
1
5
Endangered species
140
3.32
1.26
1
5
Valid N (listwise)
140
(N= sample size, Mean= mean, SD= standard deviation, Min=Minimum, Max= maximum)
Lesvos residents’ Attitude towards Waste Management and management of “special”
wastes
Concerning the management of MSW, the residents’ of Lesvos Island were asked some questions in
order to be assessed for their knowledge on the particular issue. Most of them (90%) appeared to be
aware of “who collects the MSW of their region”, while the 80.7% were knowledgeable “where the
collected waste is taken for final disposal”, and the 72.1% knew about “the bad effects of ill-treated
solid waste”.
6.2
In the sequel they were asked some questions in order to be assessed about their attitudes towards the
waste management. So, most of them appeared to worry (94.3%) about whether the final disposal of
MSW is environmentally secure.
Regarding Lesvian participants’ perceptions on the issue of “special” waste that their region is being
confronted with, are presented in Table 3.
Table 3. Lesvos residents’ attitudes towards “special” waste issue [On a scale of 1 (strongly
disagree) to 5 (strongly agree), they agree with the following statements]
N
140
140
140
140
Mean
4.42
4.26
4.25
4.23
SD
0.86
0.77
0,67
0.80
Min
1
1
2
1
Max
5
5
5
5
Worry about the collection and disposal of "special" waste
140
The solution in refugees' crisis will solve the problem of "special" waste
140
Using the process of combustion could solve the problem of "special" waste
140
Valid N (listwise)
140
(N= sample size, Mean= mean, SD= standard deviation, Min=Minimum, Max= maximum)
3.92
3.86
2.54
0.88
1.20
1.26
1
1
1
5
5
5
Inadequate "special" waste collection and disposal influences tourism
Inadequate "special" waste collection and disposal influences public health
The management of "special" waste is urgent
Recycling infrastructure is needed to solve the "special" waste problem
328
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Finally in Figure 7 are shown Lesvians’ points of view towards the municipality’s way of waste
collection in their region.
very satisfied,
0.71%
very disappointed,
3.57%
disappointed,
25.00%
satisfied, 26.43%
indifferent,
44.29%
Figure7. The extend of Lesvians’ satisfaction towards the waste collection of their region
Finally, the residents of Lesvos appeared to have the willingness “to participate in protests” in a
percent 54.3 %, “to inform the mass media for the condition in MSW management of their region”
in a 38.6%, “to support an NGO in order to put pressure on local authorities and government” in a
portion of 30.7 %, “to pay for waste management” in a percent 18.6 %, “to do nothing” in a percent
17.1% and “to move to another Greek region due to the environmental degradation” in a small quota
(5.7%).
6.3 Residents’ Attitude towards the refugees’ mass arrivals in their region
Firstly Lesvos’ inhabitants were asked in what extent they worry about the refugee crisis and their
perceptions are depicted in Figure 8.
not at all, 5%
a little, 6.40%
extremely,
45%
enough, 20%
a lot, 23.60%
Figure 8. The extend of Lesvians’ worry towards refugee crisis
Concerning Lesvians’ options towards the refugees’ mass arrivals in Greece are depicted in Table 4
and their perception towards the way Greece dealt with refugee crisis.
329
Cultural and social issues
Table 4. Lesvos residents’ perception towards refugees mass arrivals
[On a scale of 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree), how much do you agree with the
following statements]
N
Mean
Inadequacy of the state mechanisms causes environmental pressure
140 4.3357
Mass refugees influx causes environmental pressure in receiving regions
140 4.1714
Refugees’ arrivals could cause conflicts between the inhabitants of receiving
140 4.1357
region and refugees, due to the competition in natural resources
Valid N (list wise)
140
(N= sample size, Mean= mean, SD= standard deviation, Min=Minimum, Max= maximum)
SD
Min
Max
0.7158
0.8562
2
1
5
5
0.7885
1
5
Table 5. Lesvians’ perception towards the way Greece dealt with refugee crisis
[On a scale of 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree), how much do you agree with the
following statements]
N
Due to the economic crisis, Greece hasn’t had the appropriate infrastructure to deal
140
with the consequences of refugees inflows.
Greece was ready to deal with refugees influxes
140
The way in which the refugee crisis has been addressed in Greece, is satisfactory
140
Valid N (list wise)
140
(N= sample size, Mean= mean, SD= standard deviation, Min=Minimum, Max= maximum)
Mean
SD
Min
Max
4.1286
1.137
1
5
1.5643
1.7643
1.0051
0.9642
1
1
5
5
Regarding Lesvians’ perceptions on how it would be more appropriate to address the refugee issue
the 48% answered through “repatriation of refugees”, while the 51.4% said “the resettlement in other
European areas”. Finally, only a portion of 8.6%, proposed as a solution “ the resettlement of refugees
in other Greek areas”.
7.
DISCUSSION
Studying the results of the conducted research it is preferable to deal with each group of questions
separately in order to acquire a holistic perception of the issue at stake.
7.1 Total Environmental Awareness
Most of Lesvos’ dwellers (87, 1%) considered themselves as environmentally aware and appeared to
worry about the natural environment of their region. This increased proportion of environmentally
aware citizens is most likely due to the fact that the Department of Environment of the University of
the Aegean is based at Lesvos Island, which means that locals are more often, environmentally
confronted, with generated information. Furthermore, concerning the general environmental issues
(Table 3), as they reside in an area that is the receiving point of refugees’ mass inflows, it appears
that “Environmental-Climate Refugees” were the most serious environmental challenge that Greece
is facing (mean= 4.11).
7.2 Attitude towards waste management and management of “special wastes”
Locals of the island (90%) appeared to be aware who collects the MSW in their region, and 80.7% of
them even knew the place the collected MSW are being transferred to for their
final
disposal.
Moreover, a percentage of 72.1 the inhabitants were mindful of the negative effects of ill-treated solid
waste. And the vast majority appeared to worry about the environmental security of the MSW’s final
disposal.
Referring to the management of “special wastes”, as it is depicted in Table 3, the citizens worried
about the collection and disposal of “special” wastes since they believed that the inadequate collection
and disposal would influence tourism and public health. These reactions are justified, since
inadequate waste collection results in indiscriminate waste disposal in any available land and into
surface water bodies, causing water and soil pollution with series of environmental and human health
330
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
risks (Onu et al 2014). Furthermore, surveys on tourism sector have revealed that it can be seriously
influenced by the poor solid waste disposal, although it is also a generator of solid wastes as well
(Bashir and Goswami, 2016). This way the locals perception that the “special waste” management
issue is an urgent one for Lesvos connecting it with the refugee crisis issue, finds grounds to be
supported.
7.3 Residents’ Attitude towards the refugees’ mass arrivals in their region
As the literature refers, poor host countries’ fear of letting refugees put further strain on the already
scarce resources of theirs and cause instability in the country, making them to want to only offer
impermanent settlement in refugee camps as an alternative of letting them integrate (Dyrholm and
Lindholm Mikkelsen 2013). The integration of refugees is contingent on the tolerance of host
communities. Where the activities of refugees threaten the social system of the host population,
peaceful coexistence is likely to be a problematic one (Miledzi Agblorti and Awusabo-Asare 2011).
The findings of the specific research revealed the same situation in Lesvos Island. So, Lesbians
appeared to worry “extremely” (45%) and “a lot” (23, 6%), while at the same time, they strongly
agreed that mass refugees influxes could cause environmental pressure in receiving and hosting
regions (M=4.17) and the inadequacy of the state mechanisms could contribute negatively in that
pressure (Mean=4.33). Also, the inhabitants maintained that refugees’ mass arrivals could cause
conflicts among locals and refugees due to the competition in natural resources.
Οn the issue of how Greece has tackled the refugee crisis, the locals of Lesvos expressed that Greece
was not ready to deal with refugees’ influxes, while at the same time it was facing an economic crisis
that hasn’t been handled in a satisfactory way. Finally almost half of them proposed as a solution “the
repatriation of refugees” and the transfer and resettlement of refugees in other European countries.
8.
CONCLUSIONS
Syrian war has all the characteristics to be considered as a climate induced war, since the impacts of
climate change had caused environmental and economic instability, facts that in the sequel posed
social and political instability and triggered conflicts. Syrian refugees undoubtedly should be
considered as environmental refugees, though they are supposedly individuals that fled from their
homes for the fear of war. In the matter of fact, the environmental degradation of the region caused
by war, would end being in such extent, that they will not be able to return to their homeland after the
war’ s ending, as they won’t have access to healthy natural resources.
Greece, the main transit point for refugees who arrive on European shores, is among the countries
that are less financially able to handle the influx. The Greek economy is still reeling from the
economic crisis and the massive austerity measures required by the three international bailouts from
2010 onwards. There are fears that unabated refugee flow and its impact on the economy create the
risk of adding xenophobic elements in the country. Initially the locals have welcomed the refugees
with open arms. However, later on they have begun to dislike having an international community for
which too many resources are being spent for helping out refugees, while ignoring the economic
plight of Greece, which the refugee crisis has intensified.
The displaced people who are not resettled and rehabilitated in a sustainable way, after the
degradation they cause to the region, they will soon become environmental refugees, not only trying
to find a safer place to go on in life, but are also in search for a place to secure their survival, based
on basic human rights like food, water and sanitation availability. The same environmental problems
will become a nightmare for the residents of Lesvos due to the intense environmental impact.
The current migrant situation in Europe and Greece in particular, is referred to as the “European
refugee crisis”. Europe is awed by the massive flow of migrants and refugees crossing its borders and
hasn’t responded in a satisfactory way. Having in mind climate change and the massive numbers of
migrants expected to be mobilized by the impacts of climate change, it is obvious that measures to
331
Cultural and social issues
deal with the migration flows are needed. At the governmental level the migration crisis will be dealt
with through border control, security measures, and integration policies as appropriate to the specific
laws and interest of the country. However, what is frequently ignored is the environment. Therefore,
there is a necessity for measures to confront the environmental impacts in a localized manner and to
build environmental resilience in zones prone to climate migration.
Acknowledgments
We would like to express our appreciation to Mrs. Georgia Bletsa, Head of Service of Planning
Department, Cleanliness, Recycling, and Waste Collection of the Municipality of Lesvos for the
supplied data.
References
1. Bashir S. and S. Goswami (2016) ‘Tourism induced Challenges in Municipal Solid Waste
Management in Hill Towns: Case of Pahalgam’, Procedia Environmental Sciences, 35, pp. 77
– 89.
2. Braun A., Lang S. and V. Hochschild (2016) ‘Impact of Refugee Camps on Their Environment
A Case Study Using Multi-Temporal SAR Data’, Journal of Geography, Environment and
Earth Science International, 4(2), pp.1-17.
3. Dyrholm L. and L.M. Lindholm Mikkelsen (2013) ‘Finding global solutions: Alternatives to longterm encampment of refugees, 1st master module on Global Studies’, ROSKILDE UNIVERSITE,
p. 64velopment Review 69 (1), p.160. doi:10.2307/1972177.
4. de Chatel F (2014) ‘The role of drought and climate change in the Syrian uprising: Untangling
the triggers of the revolution’. Middle East Stud, 50(4), pp. 521–535.
5. Encyclopedia Britannica, 2017, https://www.britannica.com
6. Hellenic Statistical Authority, 2014.Amendment of Decision No 6519 / 31.07.2012 (Government
Gazette 2230 / Β / 31.07.2012)"Results of Population-Housing Census 2011 related In the Legal
Population (citizens) of the Country"
7. Holliday J (2013) ‘The Assad Regime: From Counterinsurgency to civil war’, MIDDLE EAST
SECURITY REPORT 8. Institute for the Study of War, Washington, 42 Available at:
http://www.understandingwar.org/sites/default/files/TheAssadRegime-web.pdf [Accessed: 20th
February 2018]
8. Kelley C.P., Mohtadi S., Cane M.A., Seager R., and Y. Kushnir (2015) ‘Climate Change in the
Fertile Crescent and Implications of the Recent Syrian Drought’, Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences, 112 (11), pp.3241–46. doi:10.1073/pnas.1421533112.
9. Kherfan R.A. (2016) ‘What are the most pressing environmental concerns of refugee camps in
conflict-zones?, American University of Beirut, Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of
Environmental Health, p.14. DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.1.3245.4162
10. Kreibaum M. (2016) ‘Their Suffering, Our Burden? How Congolese Refugees Affect the
Ugandan Population’, World Development, 78, pp.262–287
11. Lee S. (1995) ‘When Refugees Stream: Environmental and Political Implications of Population
Displacement’, In Environmental Impact of Sudden Population Displacements - Expert
Consultation on Priority Policy Issues and Humanitarian Aid. ECHO/CRED/UCL.
12. Miledzi Agblorti S.K. and K. Awusabo-Asare (2011) ‘Refugee-Host Interaction in the Krisan
Refugee Settlement in Ghanam Ghana’, Journal of Geography, l (3), pp.35-59
13. Mynicipality of Lesvos, (2018). Waste production in Lesvos Island, Data provided by email.
332
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
14. Onu B., Surendran S.S, T. Price (2014) ‘Impact of Inadequate Urban Planning on Municipal Solid
Waste Management in the Niger Delta Region of Nigeria’, Journal of Sustainable
Development, 7(6), pp.27-45. doi:10.5539/jsd.v7n6p27.
15. Perouse de Montclos M. and P. Kagwanja (2009) ‘Refugee Camps or Cities? The
socio-economic dynamics of the Dadaab and Kakuma Camps in Northern Kenya’,
Journal of Refugee Studies, 13(2), pp. 205–222. DOI: 10.1093/jrs/13.2.205
16. Skanavis C., and A. Kounani (2016) ‘The Environmental Impacts of the Refugees’ Settlements
at Lesvos Island’, 13th International Conference on Protection and Restoration of the
Environment, Mykonos island, Greece, 3rd to 8th of July 2016, pp.996-1003.
17. UNHCR (2011) ‘Convention and Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees’. Published by:
UNHCR, Communications and Public Information Service, P.O. Box 2500 1211, Geneva,
Switzerland.
18. The United Nations Refugee Agency (UNHCR) (2015) ‘The Sea Route to Europe : The
Mediterranean Passage in the Age of Refugees’.
19. http://www.unhcr.org/protection/operations/5592bd059/sea-route-europe-mediterraneanpassage-age-refugees.html.
20. UNHCR (2017a) Operational portal: refugee situation (Mediterranean situation: Greece), Source:
http://data2.unhcr.org/en/situations/mediterranean?id=58&country=83®ion=43 Access: 1612-2017
21. UNHCR (2017b) Europe Refugee Emergency Daily map indicating capacity and occupancy
(Governmental figures) (Greece), Sourcehttps://data2.unhcr.org/en/documents/download/54465
Access: 16-12-2017
22. UNHCR (2018) Figures at a glance, http://www.unhcr.org/figures-at-a-glance.html
23. Zhang H. (2015), Sino-Indian water disputes: the coming water wars?, WIREs Water, 3, pp.
155–166. doi: 10.1002/wat2.1123
333
Cultural and social issues
DEVELOPMENT AND EVALUATION OF A SMART
APPLICATION FOR SUSTAINABLE CROP PRODUCTION CASE STUDY: COTTON (GOSSYPIUM SPP)
D. Arampatzis*, C. Costopoulou, A. Efthymiou
Informatics Laboratory, Department of Agricultural Economics and Rural Development,
Agricultural University of Athens, 118 55 Athens, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: arampatzis.d@hotmail.com, tel : +30 210 5294183
Abstract
The constant evolution of current technologies widens the horizons of practices concerning a number
of different environmental sectors. Thus, nowadays it can be possible to implement “smart
applications” in micro - managing and improving cultivations to verify the successful outcome of the
crops produce. The current environmental situation (climate change, extreme weather conditions,
destruction of ecosystems, etc.) calls for the implementation of such methods, in order to protect and
insure a framework for sustainable environmental development. The purpose of this paper is to review
the present situation of mobile applications which are associated with field crops such as cotton
(Gossypium spp) and possibly expand the used methodology in other species, in order to provide
adaptable plants in the wider spectrum of sustainable production. An application named ‘Cotton
Diseases’ was developed via App Inventor 2 an open - source web application, provided by
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), to provide educational and scientific content on cotton
diseases and parasites. Whereas, an evaluation was conducted through questionnaires directed to
students of Agriculture University of Athens and agriculturalists for the usage of said application.
Finally, the research provided a number of conclusions, as well as suggestions to better bridge the
gap between technology and environment for a common purpose.
Keywords: Mobile application, Agricultural sector, Environmental sustainability, Technology,
Cotton
1.
INTRODUCTION
The global increase of population, the stronger demands for food, the climate change and the struggle
to maintain or increase the number of crop yields leads to discover new ways to cover the existence
needs. Researches show that one out of nine people suffers from chronic hunger and 12.9% of the
population in developing countries is undernourished (World Bank, 2012). Thus, technology could
be one of the solutions to meet the needs as well as to improve the environmental sustainability.
On the other hand, the widespread use of smartphones, tablets and plethora of existing mobile
applications have brought significant changes in the everyday life of people in various sectors. The
term ‘mobile application’ or ‘mobile app’ refers to a type of application software designed to run on
a mobile device, such as a smartphone or tablet. Mobile apps frequently serve to provide users with
similar services to those accessed on PCs. They are generally small, individual software units with
limited function. The diversity of mobile apps is the most important asset which explains their
popularity and enormous usage. Users are able to communicate, entertain, and get informed about
topics of interest such as work, education, lifestyle and scientific context. Mobile apps are particularly
easy to use as they are accessible for all ages and regardless of the educational level. An additional
334
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
advantage is the technological features of the mobile devices (e.g. smartphones, tablets), such as easy
internet access, geographic positioning system (GPS) which supports specialized navigation services
and the ability to storage large amount of data base.
Initially, mobile apps were designed to fulfill users' daily needs, such as email, weather, and calendar.
In recent years, rapid technological development has contributed to the development of apps with
specialized content (Arampatzis, 2017). For instance, mobile apps cover the entire productive
spectrum of an enterprise or organization and provide general and specialized information in the
scientific field. Agriculture is one of the most important sectors for both the economy and the
environmental sustainable development worldwide. However, the development of agricultural mobile
apps is still in its infancy. Already existing agricultural mobile apps (about 1,300 apps) mostly offer
agricultural news, agricultural activities, management of irrigation systems, management of crop
sensors, productions of yield forecasting and registration of soil types and are related to the needs of
the farmers and agricultural businesses (Ntaliani et al., 2008; Karetsos et al., 2014; Costopoulou et
al., 2016).Moreover, there is a small number of agricultural mobile apps related to the environmental
impact of agricultural practices.
Bridging the gap between intelligent technology and agriculture, could be achieved through the
deployment of specific applications regarding traditional cultivation of each country. In particular,
Greek agricultural history is linked to the cultivation of cotton. Cotton products are widely used, both
in the industry (e.g. textile, fiber, feed) and have an important place in the economy. The largest
cotton production comes from India, China, the USA and Pakistan. Greece holds the 13th place in the
world cotton production and the 7th place in the world cotton exports (World Cotton Production and
Exports, 2018). In this light, the objective of this paper is two-fold: firstly, to investigate the current
situation of mobile apps for cotton production and its diseases and natural enemies; and secondly, to
develop a pilot mobile app for cotton diseases and natural enemies for agricultural educational
purpose. The structure of the paper is as follows: Section 2 provides an overview of mobile apps for
sustainable production on field crops such as cotton (Gossypium). Section 3 describes the modeling
and the development of a mobile app entailed ‘Cotton Diseases’ app. In addition, the results of a
questionnaire survey conducted for evaluating the proposed app are presented. The participants in the
survey were students by the Agricultural University of Athens and agriculturalists. The last section
provides the conclusions and possible directions for a better relationship between mobile apps,
agriculture and environment in the future.
2.
A SURVEY ON COTTON MOBILE APPS
Mobile technology is a sector with the fastest growth and high rates of increase worldwide. This rising
digital culture consist of developers, software platforms and thousands of users. Innovations in this
technology are expanding not only for what can be done with mobile apps but also making these apps
more accessible to a larger number of users. Mobile apps are accessible through distribution
platforms, known as app stores and the most known are Apple App Store, Google Play Store and
Windows Phone Store. Moreover, in 2016, consumers downloaded 149.3 billion mobile apps and it
is predicted that in 2021, 203.6 billion more mobile apps will be downloaded (Statista, 2016). In
addition mobile apps show a noteworthy prospect of innovation in the agricultural sector and may
bridge the gap between technology and the environment. Prospects are auspicious, as they can boost
farm income, ensure optimal quality characteristics in the production, and use lower inputs during the
growing season and agricultural practices. According to the World Bank the benefits of these apps in
the development of the agricultural sector could be achieved through the following ways:
Provision of better access to information: By providing to producers immediate access to valid
information relating to weather, pests and diseases, better environmental management as well as
to market information and increased demand.
335
Cultural and social issues
Provision of better access to agricultural extension services: Valid information and counseling for
good agricultural practices can be given.
Provision of better connection with the market and networks: Helping producers, suppliers and
buyers be more efficient and less manipulated.
In order to identify mobile apps regarding cotton production, in Apple App Store, Google Play Store
and Windows Phone Store, a survey based on particular characteristics has been carried out
(Costopoulou et al., 2016). The characteristics are as follows:
Logo: the graphic mark of app;
Title: the name of app;
Category: the agricultural topic or task covered by the app;
Language: available languages;
Geographical coverage: the country or countries in which the app can be used;
Date: the release date of the app or the date the app has been updated;
Cost: the cost for acquiring the app (e.g. free, subscription or one-off payment);
Rating: evaluation of the app from the users;
Support: operating system and devices that support the app.
The survey has been conducted during November 2016 till January 2017. Twenty six mobile apps
have been identified, and have been described according to the aforementioned characteristics. The
analysis of the survey per characteristic has shown the following results:
Category: Agricultural information on variety topics (8%), weather forecast(8%), tools and GIS
(8%), calculators (4%), agricultural management(42%), productivity(11%), education
(19%) (Figure 1a).
Language: 70% of the apps support only the English language, 22% of the apps support two
languages i.e. English and a second language, and 8% support more than two languages.
Geographical coverage: 33% of the apps have limited geographic coverage and 67% have global
geographical coverage
Date:
30% of the apps were released in 2016, 22% of the apps in 2015, 26% of the apps in 2014
and 22% of the apps were released between 2010 and 2013.
Cost:
94% of apps were purchased free and 4% of apps required payment for download.
Rating:
The rating was fairly low.
Support:
42% of the apps are supported by iOS, 27% are used by Android, 23% of the apps are
supported by Android and iOS, 4% for Android, iOS and Windows and 4% for Android
and Window (Figure 1b).
3.
THE COTTON DISEASE MOBILE APP
This section presents the development and the evaluation of the proposed mobile app for cotton
diseases. In particular, the deployment of this app has been chosen for the following reasons: Firstly,
cotton is one of the traditional cultivations of Greek agriculture. Greece is the main cotton producer
country of the European Union (Papakosta, 2013). In particular, cotton is produced mainly in two
Member States on around 300.000 ha. Greece is the main cotton grower, with 80% of European
cotton area, followed by Spain with a share of 20%. Also, cotton production can be considered as a
pillar of economic growth for Greek agriculture. Secondly, the cultivation of cotton is characterized
336
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
as a demanding cultivation because of the agricultural techniques that are used, such as fertilization,
pesticides, irrigation and herbicides. Third, the quality criteria for cotton fibers are very strict and
Greek production manage to fulfill them. Finally, Greek cotton producers as well as agriculturalist
students need specific knowledge, such as valid information about various practices for different
diseases and parasites of cotton to intend a sustainable production and eco-friendly practices.
Figure 1: a) Mobile apps categories, b) Mobile apps operating systems
3.1 App development
The proposed app entitled ‘Cotton Diseases’app has been developed for the Android operating system
(OS) for smartphones. It uses App Invertor 2, an open - source web application, provided by
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) that creates software applications for the Android OS.
It uses a graphical interface, which allows users to drag-and-drop visual objects to create an
application that can run on Android devices. The decision of using Android OS is based on the
rationale that this OS has greater freedom in its development program. The development was based
on the "drag-and-drop building blocks" system (Figure 2), which signifies that the assignments were
already made and the user could transfer them to specific blocks (Pokress and Veiga, 2013).
The key functionality of the app includes a front screen comprising three options (buttons) namely
bacterial disease, fungal diseases and natural enemies, such as Heliocoverpa armigera, Pectinofora
gossypiella (Ioannou, 1988). Touching on the first option certified content about a bacterial disease
as well as images of the symptoms is revealed. The second option provides data and information
about fungal diseases and images with the symptoms (Figure 3), and the last option information about
different parasites, which are the most dangerous for Greek cotton production. The ‘Cotton Diseases’
app provides educational and certified content (in Greek) on cotton diseases and parasites and is
directed mainly to Greek cotton producers and students. It could be purchased free of charge through
Google Play and is able only for Android devices.
3.2 App evaluation
A questionnaire survey has been conducted in order to evaluate the proposed app. The survey has
been conducted during February 2017 and the sample consists of 59 participants. 36 participants were
students of the Agricultural University of Athens and 23 participants were agriculturalists (Table 1).
The initial version of the questionnaire was pre-testes by two volunteers so as to be checked for its
clarity. The online version of the questionnaire is based on the Google Forms and includes 18
questions about demographic characteristics, the usage of agricultural mobile apps and the benefits
of "Cotton_Diseases" app during the yield practices. Indicative examples of questions are "Did you
find the app useful for recognizing any symptom?" or "Would you like to use this agriculture app or
any other?"
337
Cultural and social issues
Figure 2 & 3: A screen of ‘Cotton Diseases’ App Inventor 2 - A screen of cotton symptoms
Table 1: Sample Demographics
Profile of Respondents
Frequency
Percentage (%)
Male
Female
36
23
61
39
18-25
26-35
36-45
46-55
36
10
6
7
61
17
10
12
AUA students
Producers
36
23
61
39
Gender
Age (yrs.)
Educational level
The evaluation of the app was divided into two parts, namely the evaluation by the students referring
to the participants of the age group 18-25 years old, and the evaluation by the agriculturalists referring
to the participants of the age group of 26-35, 36-45 and >45 years old. The evaluations is as follows.
3.2.1 Evaluation of the app by students
The analysis results shows that most of the students use smartphone (56%) and 44% use both
smartphone and tablet. None of the participants uses a tablet only. As far as students' mobile device
software is concerned, 50% of them are Android based, 33% are iOS based and 17% are running
Windows. All of the participants use mobile apps mainly for social networking (facebook, whatsapp,
viber, instagram, twitter, snapchat) as well as for games and educational applications. For the ease of
use of the ‘Cotton Diseases’ app, 11% of the responders found it difficult to moderate, 47% somewhat
easy, while 42% very easy to use. Regarding the ease of finding information, 3% answered that it was
a bit easy, 8% moderate, 53% fairly easy and 36% very easy. For the information structure, 0% found
the organization chaotic, 2.8% almost chaotic, 2.8% said the organization was moderate, 13.9%
considered the organization good, 50% fairly organized and 30.5% organized. The screen switching
was characterized by 8% of the students as modest, 39% as helpful and 53% as very helpful. 84% of
the students answered that they would use the app and 16% would not. 56% responded that they
would pay for the app while 44% responded negatively. Considering ‘Cotton Diseases’ app in general
terms, 5.6% rated it moderate, 16.7% good, 41.7% satisfactory, and 36% fully satisfactory. 83.3%
would suggest applying to other users, while 16.7% would not suggest it. Regarding improvements
338
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
to the ‘Cotton Diseases’ app, 33% suggests improved information, 39% improvements in images, and
28% do not consider the need for further improvements.
3.2.2 Evaluation of the app by producers
According to the educational level of the producers, 39% of them are graduates of high school, 18%
have higher education (IEK etc), 22% holds university degree, 21% hold a postgraduate or a PhD.
39% of the responders has only a smartphone and 61% have both devices (smartphone and tablet).
52% of the producers holds Android mobile device, 26% iOS mobile device and 22% Windows
mobile device. Furthermore, 91% use daily various types of mobile apps and 9% does not have any
apps in their mobile devices. Concerning the type of the apps that they already use, 61% of the
responders use informative apps, 17% games, 13% social networking apps, 4% educator and 5% other
type. For the ease of use of the app, 9% found the difficulty level to be moderate, 43% somewhat
easy, while 48% very easy to use.Regarding the finding of information, 22% answered that it was a
bit easy, 48% fairly easy and 30% very easy.As for the information structure, none of the found the
organization chaotic, 13% said the organization was moderate, 9% considered the organization good,
52% fairly organized and 26% organized.Regarding the question of whether the texts presented are
informative, 9% responded almost not as well as little informative, 22% responded moderately, 52%
found it quite explanatory and 17% very informative.74% responded that they would pay for the app
while 26% responded negatively.Considering ‘Cotton Diseases’ app in general terms, 4% rated it
moderate, 18% good, 52% satisfactory, and 26% fully satisfactory. 96% of the participants would
suggest this app to other users, while 4% of them would not suggest it. 30% of the responders believes
that the provided information could be improved, 22% the provided images, 5% the switching of
monitors can be improved and 43% do not suggest any changes neither for information, images or
switching of monitors. It is worth noting that all of the producers willing to use the app during the
growing season.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
Recent technological advances, new mobile products and the strong demand of the agricultural
stakeholders as well as consumers has resulted in the notable need to develop agricultural mobile
apps to support various kinds of services, such as weather forecasting, eco-friendly managements and
to insure easy access to valid agricultural information, communication between producers etc. It has
been observed that in the mobile agricultural app market, the number of displayed apps is around
1.300, which reflects a small number in relation to the importance of agriculture in global
environmental issues, such as climate change, as well as in the economy and business sectors. For
this study, twenty six mobile apps regarding cotton production were studied based on their
technological characteristics and their provided content. The majority of the selected apps are free of
charge to download, 96% and 4% were on payment. iOS is the main platform among the publishers
for mobile agricultural apps (42%), closely followed by Android (27%). In addition, Windows
platform offers a few mobile agricultural apps. However must be mentioned that 31% of the selected
apps could be purchased by all the platforms. In addition, most apps' primary language is English. As
far as the usage of agricultural mobile apps by Greek producers and students, the results show that a
very small amount of people take advantage of the technology and more specifically from the mobile
apps. The explanation of this phenomenon could be the absence of agricultural apps with Greek
content, poor explanatory information or scientific advices for the Greek environmental conditions,
lack of awareness of the app beneficial outcomes in the agricultural practices, and minor usage of
apps by important stakeholders. It is noteworthy, that in the age group above 45 years old, technology
does not have an important factor in their daily life; participants in that age group did not own any
technological product, such as smartphones or tablets. The advantages of agricultural mobile apps
may be important but the development of these kind of apps presents a lot of challenges, described
as follows:
339
Cultural and social issues
For the development of mobile agricultural applications, the contribution of stakeholders from
different sectors is important, such as producers, agronomists, agriculturalists, programmers,
mathematicians and meteorologists.
The development of agricultural mobile apps should provide information on crop cultivation
techniques and its needs, aiming at economic and predominantly environmental sustainability.
Agricultural mobile apps should be developed for different geographic locations, as each area is
characterized by different soil and climate conditions. In plants with high requirements in
cultivation techniques, the development of agricultural apps is necessary for low risk
management.
Seminars could be organized to inform the producers for the benefits of the apps usage and
universities should include specialized lectures for students.
Agricultural stakeholders should be appropriate informed, educated and persuade producers to
use agricultural mobile apps.
References
1. Arampatzis, D. (2017). ‘Developmentand evaluation of a mobile application for cotton
diseases and pests’. MSc Thesis, Agricultural University of Athens. (in Greek).
2. Costopoulou C., M. Ntaliani, S. Karetsos. (2016). ‘Studying Mobile Apps for Agriculture.
IOSR Journal of Mobile Computing & Application 3(6), Issue 6 (Nov. - Dec. 2016), pp. 44-49.
3. Ioannou D. (1988). ‘Cotton: Enemies, Diseases, Weed’. Stamoulis Edition, Athens. (in Greek).
4. Karetsos S., C. Costopoulou and A.Sideridis. (2014). ‘Developing a smartphone app for mgovernment in agriculture’. Journal of Agricultural Informatics, 5(1),2014, pp. 1-8, 2014.
5. Ntaliani, M., C. Costopoulou, S. Karetsos. (2008). ‘Mobile government: A challenge for
agriculture’. Government Information Quarterly, 25(4), pp. 699-716.
6. Papakosta-Tasopoulou D. (2013). ‘Industrial Crops’. Athens: Modern Education Edition. (in
Greek).
7. Pokress, S. C., Veiga, J. J. D. (2013). MIT App Inventor: Enabling personal mobile
computing. arXiv preprint arXiv: 1310.2830.
8. Statista. (2016). Available: https://www.statista.com/statistics/271644/worldwide-free-and-paidmobile-app-store-downloads/ [Accessed: 26-01-2018] .
9. World Bank. (2012). Mobile applications for agriculture and rural development. Washington,
D.C.:WorldBankGroup.http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/167301467999716265/Mobi
le-applications-for-agriculture-and-rural-development [Accessed: 24-01-2018] .
10. World Cotton Production and Exports. (2018). World Cotton Production
http://www.cottoninc.com/corporate/Market-Data/MonthlyEconomicLetter/pdfs/English-pdfchartsand-tables/World-Cotton-Production-Bales.pdf
340
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
EXPLORING PUBLIC PREFERENCES AND PRIORITIES FOR
CONTROLLING INVASIVE MOSQUITO SPECIES: THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF A WEB SURVEY IN GREEK
HOUSEHOLDS FOR THE CASE OF THE ASIAN TIGER
MOSQUITO
K. Bithasa, D. Latinopoulosb,*, A. Kolimenakisa, C. Richardsona, K. Lagouvardosc and
A. Michaelakisd
a
University Research Institute of Urban Environment and Human Resources, Panteion University,
b
School of Spatial Planning and Development, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece,
c
National Observatory of Athens/Institute for Environmental Research, Athens, Greece,
d
Benaki Phytopathological Institute, Department of Entomology and Agricultural Zoology, 14561,
Kifissia, Greece
*Corresponding Author: email: dlatinop@plandevel.auth.gr, tel. +302310994248
Abstract
The introduction of invasive mosquito species in the Mediterranean area along with intense
urbanization poses new challenges for both scientists and policy makers. The last decade has seen the
wide spread of the invasive Asian tiger mosquito Aedes albopictus in various urban ecosystems of
Greece. Compared to native species, Asian tiger mosquitoes are accompanied by greater risks of
infectious diseases, higher nuisance levels, and increased expenses for their confrontation.
Consequently, future decisions on mosquito control should take these risks into consideration. Public
perceptions and preferences regarding these risks are crucial in order to make decisions more
responsive to citizens’ needs and thus more effective. The aim of this paper is to investigate various
socio-economic aspects of the Asian tiger mosquito problem, through a web-based questionnaire. The
survey was conducted nationwide, aiming to record (a) the impact of invasive mosquito species in
Greek households, (b) associated costs and perceived risks, and (c) priorities and policy directions in
mosquito control. The results indicate that citizens are highly concerned with the health risks
associated with the new mosquito species and consider public prevention strategies highly important
for the confrontation of the problem. The spatial patterns of these results are further investigated
aiming to identify regions with different levels of risk and/or policy priorities.
Keywords: urban ecosystems; Asian tiger mosquito; web survey; infectious diseases; citizens'
preferences
1.
INTRODUCTION
In recent years, concern has arisen over the threatened increase in mosquito-borne diseases in the
Mediterranean region as new sanitary and environmental risks emerge, including the appearance of
chikungunya, dengue and West Nile viruses, calling for the adoption of specific measures and
strategies by both policy makers and scientists. These public health challenges are associated
particularly with the presence of the Asian tiger mosquito (Aedes albopictus), an invasive mosquito
species implicated in the transmission of a wide range of human pathogens. The first presence of the
Asian tiger mosquito in Greece (in north-western prefectures) is dated back to 2003 [SamanidouVoyadjoglou et al., 2005], and it was confirmed for the first time in Athens (Attica Region) in 2008
341
Cultural and social issues
[Koliopoulos et al., 2008]. The mosquito problem in Greece, as in other parts of Europe, has recently
intensified and is favoured by both the geographic position and climatic conditions of Greece.
The invasive mosquito species (IMS) problem can affect the economy and society in various ways,
through impacts on human and animal health, as well as on various services and activities. These
impacts generate certain economic costs related to control strategies, public health expenses, illness
treatments, productivity losses, information and awareness campaigns, and economic losses in
tourism and other sectors. Economic impacts can be direct or indirect. Direct economic impacts are
represented by the net increase in spending as a result of the appearance of IMS and include, for
example, control-and-surveillance programmes, private expenditures and direct medical costs. These
are the most clearly defined impacts as they can be expressed explicitly and immediately in monetary
values. Indirect impacts include effects on residents’ quality of life, impacts on public health, costs
associated with new research and management services (in both the public and private sectors of the
economy), effects on tourism, and so on. Indirect effects are often difficult to evaluate as they cannot
be expressed easily in monetary terms. Various valuation techniques are usually applied, such as
stated preference methods (e.g. the contingent valuation method, choice experiment method, etc).
Studies conducted in Europe and the USA have examined the socioeconomic benefits and costs
associated with the overall mosquito problem [e.g. John et al., 1992; von Hirsch and Becker, 2009;
Dickinson and Paskewitz, 2012; Halasa et al., 2014; Brown et al., 2015; Bellini et al., 2014;
Kolimenakis et al., 2016; Bithas et al., 2018]. Most of these studies conclude that the perceived
benefits that arise from the reduction of nuisance levels and health threats exceed the costs of
prevention and control strategies against various mosquito species. Some of these studies have
focused on the assessment of the non-market benefits of mosquito control programs [e.g. John et al.,
1992; von Hirsch and Becker, 2009; Dickinson and Paskewitz, 2012; Halasa et al., 2014; Bithas et
al., 2018]. The present study aims to enrich the existing literature by investigating: (a) the impact of
invasive mosquito species on Greek households, at the national level, (b) the associated costs and the
perceived risks, (c) the priorities and policy directions in mosquito control from a citizen's
perspective, and (d) the spatial variation in these results.
2.
METHODS
The implementation of a web questionnaire followed a process of surveys and evaluations
[Kolimenakis et al., 2016; Bithas et al., 2018] aiming to elicit citizens' preferences for mosquito
control strategies as well as to evaluate the effectiveness level of prevention programs in Greece. The
present study was designed to address qualitative dimensions not previously recorded in the surveying
processes and to extend the sampling of answers at the national level, using a web questionnaire in
order to save costs. For this purpose collaboration was established with a web meteorological platform
of high visiting frequency (www.meteo.gr) in order to increase the geographical dispersion of the
sample. It should be noted that the specific web platform had already implemented a real time
monitoring application for the identification of mosquito presence, covering the whole of Greece.
The questionnaire was specifically designed to elicit citizens' opinions regarding certain socioeconomic aspects of the mosquito problem. The overall aim was to examine and then to validate at
the national level a set of parameters related to private prevention costs for IMS and to investigate
individual preferences between various mosquito control programs. The questionnaire contained an
introductory page explaining the purpose of the study and some general information about the Asian
tiger mosquito and its associated health risks. The first questions focused on the respondents’
knowledge of the Asian tiger mosquito. The next questions concerned: (a) the current perceived level
of nuisance during the day and separately at night (rated using a 5-point Likert scale), (b) the portion
of the year (months) with significant mosquito nuisance, (c) the monthly household expenditure for
private prevention measures, and (d) the main reasons for taking individual prevention measures (i.e.
they had to choose between health risk reduction and nuisance reduction). Subsequently, participants
were asked about the importance of taking further public measures for mosquito control (using a 5342
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
point Likert scale) and further questions were included to identify the main targets of future public
control measures/programs. The final section of the questionnaire focused on participants’
demographics (age, residence area, family status).
For the purpose of our survey, a special banner appeared on the home page of the host web platform
from which visitors followed a link to the web survey. The banner appeared randomly to visitors, but
a selection bias could arise due to (i) the non-representative nature of the internet population in general
and users of meteo in particular, and (ii) self-selection of participants - the `volunteer effect'
[Eysenbach, 2004] which was possibly related to their interest in mosquito control. The survey took
place in September and October 2016 with a total of 1,204 responses from all over the country. The
regional distribution of the final sample is presented in Table 1. This distribution is quite
representative of the population (see Table 1) but it is also a first indicator of regional differences in
people’s attitudes and experience of mosquito-associated problems.
Table 1. Sample distribution per region
Sample
Population1
Frequency Percent
Residents Percent
Attica
664
55.1%
3,827,624
35.39%
Central Greece
43
3.6%
547,390
5.06%
Central Macedonia
131
10.9%
1,881,869
17.40%
Crete
57
4.7%
623,065
5.76%
Eastern Macedonia and Thrace
49
4.1%
608,182
5.62%
Epirus
35
2.9%
336,856
3.11%
Ionian Islands
33
2.7%
207,855
1.92%
North Aegean
12
1.0%
199,231
1.84%
Peloponnese
49
4.1%
577,903
5.34%
South Aegean
26
2.2%
308,975
2.86%
Thessaly
60
5.0%
732,762
6.78%
Western Greece
38
3.1%
679,796
6.29%
Western Macedonia
7
0.6%
283,689
2.62%
1 Data
3.
from population census in Greece, conducted by the Hellenic Statistical Authority (2011)
RESULTS
Most of the respondents to the web questionnaire (89.5%) already knew of the Asian tiger mosquito
and health risks before the survey. About 66% of the respondents reported that the Asian tiger
mosquito is established in their residence area. Regional differences in this response are relatively
small (ranging from 55% to 71%) and are not significantly correlated with the actual detection of this
mosquito species over Greece [Badieritakis et al., 2018]. Therefore, public perception cannot safely
be used as an indicator of the presence of Aedes albopictus in an area.
In contrast to the study of Bithas et al. (2018), which reported a higher nuisance during the night than
the day in the region of Attica, we found that nationally night nuisance levels are almost identical
with the daytime levels, with a mean value of 3.6 on the 5-point Likert scale (indicating a nuisance
level between average and high). Figure 1 presents the distribution of the perceived nuisance level at
night, as well as the regional variation of the mean nuisance value. Figure 2 presents the
corresponding perceived nuisance levels during the day, which can be taken as an indication of the
nuisance caused by the Asian tiger mosquito (which, unlike native mosquitoes, causes biting nuisance
b). According to these results it can be concluded that respondents living in the regions of Eastern
Macedonia and Thrace, Peloponnese, Central Greece and Western Greece experience a higher
daytime biting nuisance which can be attributed to the presence of the Asian tiger mosquito.
343
Cultural and social issues
Response frequencies
↑
Regional map (average values)
Figure 1. Nighttime nuisance (Likert scale 1-5: 1= no nuisance, 5= intolerable nuisance): mean
nuisance by region and distribution of individual responses
Response frequencies
↑
Regional map (average values)
Figure 2. Daytime nuisance (Likert scale 1-5: 1= no nuisance, 5= intolerable nuisance): mean
nuisance by region and distribution of individual responses.
As shown in Figure 3, the average “nuisance period” according to the survey respondents follows an
approximately normal distribution and lasts 5.7 months on average approximately. The regional
variation of this period is depicted in the corresponding thematic map (Figure 3), revealing a longer
nuisance period in South and South-eastern regions.
344
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Concerning the private prevention costs, it was found that households are paying on average 17.6 €
per month when mosquitoes are active. This estimate is much higher than that found by Bithas et al.
(2018) in the Attica Region (6.6 €/month). This difference may be attributed to the self-selection of
participants, which is likely to be related to their interest in mosquito control, which in turn may
depend on the nuisance level. Therefore, these results are likely to be overestimates, but can be used
in order to explore the regional variation in prevention costs. In order to do so, we estimated the
annual prevention costs by multiplying the monthly costs by the nuisance period. The average annual
cost in our sample was found to be 100.1€/household. Significant spatial variations were observed in
these estimates (Figure 4), as annual costs ranged from below 80€ in some regions (e.g. Thessaly and
the North Aegean) to over 125€ in others (e.g. Eastern Macedonia and Thrace, and Central Greece).
This variation may be an indirect indicator of the magnitude of the mosquito problem, which is
strongly associated with the nuisance conditions in each area. It should be also noted that this revealed
behavior concerning prevention can be used as a proxy of individuals’ potential benefits from
improved control measures in each region.
Figure 5 shows which of health and nuisance appears to be the respondents’ main reason for taking
individual prevention measures. Nuisance seems to be the main reason in about 73% of respondents,
while health risks are stated as the main reason in only 27% of the sample. It should be also noted
that: (1) nuisance was considered more important than health risks in all regions, and that (2) the two
regions where health risks appear to be more related with individual prevention strategies (costs) are
those of Central Greece and Western Greece. This result partly contradicts the findings of Bithas et
al., (2018), who found health to be the main prevention priority for citizens of the Athens metropolitan
area, but on the other hand is in accordance with the findings of most of the recent literature. However,
as will be seen below, when expenses are viewed from the point of view of a public good, citizens
are more concerned with the threats to health than with nuisance.
Response frequencies
↑
Regional map (average values)
Figure 3. Nuisance period (months): mean values by region and distribution of individual
responses.
345
Cultural and social issues
Response frequencies
↑
Regional map (average values)
Figure 4. Annual prevention costs (€/year/household): mean by region and distribution of
individual responses.
Figure 5. Main reason for taking individual prevention measures, by region.
Finally, the web survey attempted to gather information regarding the preferences of individuals for
the various mosquito control programs, and particularly about the importance of taking further public
measures for mosquito control, as well as about the main targets of future public control measures
and programs. Overall, 83% of the survey respondents believed that the current prevention and
control measures are insufficient or inadequate for dealing with the mosquito problems and therefore
there is scope for further measures to be taken. Concerning the main targets of these measures (Table
2), health impacts were considered to be more important than nuisance impacts, confirming the
findings of previous surveys in Greece [Kolimenakis et al., 2016; Bithas et al., 2018]. Furthermore,
as in those two studies, transmission of disease from invasive species was considered to be a serious
threat. On the other hand, nuisance levels and the financial burden on households for mosquito control
were also rated highly, thus constituting them as important additional decision factors.
346
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Finally, an important finding of this survey was that citizens seem to be aware of the environmental
consequences of mosquito control measures. In particular, 74% of the sample stated their
disagreement with measures that may potentially affect the physical environment and the ecosystems.
Table 2. Individuals’ rating of the objectives of mosquito control programs (web survey
results)
Reduction of mosquito-borne
disease risks
Reduction of nuisance
Low cost to
households
From native
species1
73.2%
From invasive
species2
76.7%
From native
species3
47.1%
From invasive
species4
39.5%
From future
control programs
26.8%
Important
19.1%
15.9%
32.3%
25.3%
17.8%
Neutral
5.4%
5.6%
15.7%
20.2%
26.5%
Less important
1.6%
1.2%
4.0%
10.3%
17.4%
Non important
0.7%
0.6%
0.9%
4.7%
11.6%
Highly important
1
for example: malaria, West Nile Virus
for example: chikungunya, dengue, Zika Virus
3
Nighttime nuisance
4
Daytime nuisance
2
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
The present paper aims to provide an overview of citizens’ perceptions and attitudes towards the
problem of invasive mosquitoes, as well as towards the future targets of mosquito control programs.
In this framework a web based survey was designed and implemented at the national level in Greece.
The results show that nuisance from mosquitoes: (a) is significant all over the country, although
showing some regional differences, thus indicating areas of higher priority for future policy actions;
(b) is similar for both invasive and native species; and (c) is the main reason for taking individual
prevention measures. The cost of individual prevention measures was estimated to be quite high
(about 100€/household/year), which could be the result of the selection bias (i.e. the volunteer effect)
due to the survey mode (web). However, regional variation in this cost may be an indirect indicator
of the magnitude of the mosquito problem, which is strongly associated with the nuisance conditions
in each area. Furthermore, this revealed behavior concerning prevention can be used as a proxy of
individuals’ potential benefits from future improved control programs in each region.
One of the most important findings of the present study is that citizens perceive the protection from
mosquito-borne diseases as an important public good which should be funded by public expenses.
The results of our study indicate that, on the one hand, citizens are more willing to incur personal
expenses against daily nuisance from mosquito species and, on the other hand, they are willing to pay
for an improved control program against disease threats when implemented by public authorities.
Therefore, to a certain extent, citizens seem to transfer the responsibility of health related protective
measures onto experts and public health practitioners. This might imply that they feel rather insecure
with regard to the efficiency of their personal measures against the various mosquito-associated
diseases. However, similar a case in the Mediterranean [Carrieri et al., 2011] indicates that citizens'
participation is also highly important especially in the monitoring and control of invasive mosquito
species. Regarding the Greek case, a certain lack of information from public authorities may increase
both the insecurity and lack of awareness of citizens concerning the particular problem. However,
there are recent ongoing initiatives funded by the EU (LIFE CONOPS) which enhance public
information and lead to collaboration between the scientific community, public authorities and
citizens. It should be noted that citizens' participation in many cases is stimulated by the appearance
of disease outbreaks as in the case of the 2007 Chikungunya outbreak in the Italia Region of Emilia
Romagna. In any case the level of citizens' participation in public policy decisions might also be
associated with socio-cultural traits and might differ if examined in diverse contexts and countries.
347
Cultural and social issues
Another important outcome of the present study is the examination of citizens' perception of the
ecosystemic threats associated with mosquito control, an issue not well examined so far in the recent
bibliography. While citizens appear to be sensitive to the environmental consequences associated
with the mosquito abatement methods, they also seem to have difficulty in identifying the
environmental consequences of mosquito control methods. This raises the complexity of the issue at
hand when trying to discern the possible level of citizens' participation in public decision making for
similar problems. The fact that climate change trends may worsen the mosquito problem and increase
the risks of transmitting new diseases (e.g. Zika virus), making the prevention and control methods
even more sophisticated, increases even more the complexity of citizens' participation and the
associated dilemmas (e.g. human health versus environmental consequences). The interrelation of a
wide set of parameters and multiple public decisions associated with the problem of invasive
mosquitoes renders necessary the examination of the ecosystemic dimension of the particular issue
from a rather holistic point of view.
Funding
Part of this research was co-financed by the European Union (EU Environmental Funding Programme
LIFE+ Environment Policy and Governance) and Greek national funds through the LIFE CONOPS
project ‘Development & demonstration of management plans against the climate change enhanced
invasive mosquitoes in S. Europe’ (LIFE12 ENV/GR/000466).
References
1. Samanidou-Voyadjoglou A., E. Patsoula, G. Spanakos and N.C. Vakalis (2005) ‘Confirmation of
Aedes albopictus (Skuse) (Diptera: Culicidae) in Greece’, European Mosquito Bulletin, 19, pp.
10-12.
2. Koliopoulos G., I. Lytra, A. Michaelakis, E. Kioulos, A. Giatropoulos and N. Emmanuel (2008)
‘Asian tiger mosquito. First record in Athens’, Agriculture Crop and Animal Husbandry, 9,
pp. 68-73 [in Greek].
3. John K.H., R.G. Walsh and C.G. Moore (1992) ‘Comparison of alternative nonmarket valuation
methods for an economic assessment of a public program’, Ecological Economics, 5 (2), pp. 179196.
4. von Hirsch H. and B. Becker (2009) ‘Cost-benefit analysis of mosquito control operations based
on microbial control agents in the upper Rhine valley (Germany)’ European Mosquito Bulletin,
27, 47-55.
5. Dickinson K. and S. Paskewitz (2012) ‘Willingness to pay for mosquito control: how important
is West Nile virus risk compared to the nuisance of mosquitoes?’ Vector Borne and Zoonotic
Diseases, 12, pp. 886–892.
6. Halasa Y.A., D.S. Shepard, D.M. Fonseca, A. Farajollahi, S. Healy, R. Gaugler, K. Barlett-Healy,
D.A. Strickman and G.G. Clark (2014) ‘Quantifying the impact of mosquitoes on quality of life
and enjoyment of yard and porch activities in New Jersey’, PloS One, 9(3), e89221.
7. Brown Z., K. Dickinson and S. Paskewitz (2015) ‘A generalized latent class logit model of
discontinuous preferences in repeated discrete choice data: an application to mosquito control in
Madison, Wisconsin’, 2015 AAEA & WAEA Joint Annual Meeting, July 26-28, San Francisco,
California.
8. Bellini R., M. Calzolari, A. Mattivi, M. Tamba, P. Angelini, P. Bonilauri, A. Albieri et al. (2014)
‘The experience of West Nile virus integrated surveillance system in the Emilia-Romagna region:
five years of implementation, Italy, 2009 to 2013’, Euro Surveill,19, no. 44.
9. Kolimenakis A., K. Bithas, C. Richardson, D. Latinopoulos, A. Baka, A. Vakali, C.
Hadjichristodoulou, S. Mourelatos, S. Kalaitzopoulou, S. Gewehr, A. Michaelakis and G.
Koliopoulous (2016) ‘Economic appraisal of the public control and prevention strategy against
348
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
the 2010 West Nile Virus outbreak in Central Macedonia, Greece’, Public Health, 131, pp. 6370.
10. Bithas K., D. Latinopoulos, A. Kolimenakis and C. Richardson (2018) ‘Social benefits from
controlling invasive Asian tiger and native mosquitoes: a stated preference study in Athens,
Greece’, Ecological Economics, 145, pp. 46-56.
11. Eysenbach G. (2004) ‘Improving the quality of Web surveys: the Checklist for Reporting Results
of Internet E-Surveys (CHERRIES)’, Journal of Medical Internet research, 6(3).
12. Badieritakis, E., D. Papachristos, D. Latinopoulos, D. Stefopoulou, A. Kolimenakis, K. Bithas,
E. Patsoula, S. Beleri, D. Maselou, G. Balatsos and A. Michaelakis (2018) ‘Aedes albopictus
(Skuse, 1895) (Diptera: Culicidae) in Greece: 13 years of living with the Asian tiger mosquito’,
Parasitology Research, 117 (2), pp. 453-460.
13. Carrieri M., A. Albieri, P. Angelini, F. Baldacchini, C. Venturelli, S.M. Zeo and R. Bellini (2011).
Surveillance of the chikungunya vector Aedes albopictus (Skuse) in Emilia-Romagna (northern
Italy): organizational and technical aspects of a large scale monitoring system. Journal of Vector
Ecology, 36(1), 108-116.
349
Cultural and social issues
ENVIRONMENTAL CHALLENGES TO ACHIEVE THE SDG (11)
FOR SUSTAINABLE CITIES - CASE STUDY: TRIKALA,
GREECE
M.E Chatzi*, E. Kolokytha
Department of Civil Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124, Thessaloniki, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: mmchatzi@hotmail.com
Abstract
Nowadays, over half the world‘s population lives in urban areas, whereas in Europe, by 2020, it is
estimated by the EEA, that almost 80% of EU citizens will be living in cities. This unprecedented
urban growth has brought enormous challenges concerning clean water, pollution, greenhouse gas
emissions, ecosystem degradation, waste management, security from extreme natural events, health
issues and many others.
This paper introduces the concept of urban sustainability and explores the characteristics of the
Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 11, concerning sustainable cities and communities. Measuring
sustainability is a complex issue and in the case of a city, is mainly depending on local conditions, as
each city operates within a specific ecosystem and a socio-cultural context. Urban sustainability of
the city of Trikala, in Greece is tested by analyzing major domains such as water resources, energy
sector, transportation systems, waste management, urban green spaces and air quality, whereas, given
that cities are hubs for social and human development as well, the cultural heritage is also taken into
account. The DPSIR model is used as an analytical framework, through the use of indicators, for the
assessment of the current situation. In parallel, a survey to more than 300 citizens of the city of Trikala
was conducted in order to identify priorities and values, as well as what is considered most important
when it comes to decision making, in order to make life in the city more sustainable. Finally, a number
of conclusions and suggestions derived, on the changes that could be made and the actions that should
be taken, in order for Trikala to strive for sustainable development.
Keywords: SDGs, sustainable cities, sustainable development, environmental protection, Trikala
1.
INTRODUCTION
The SDGs, also known as Global Goals, build on the success of the Millennium Development Goals
(MDGs) (UN, 2018) and aim to go further to end all forms of poverty, while being unique in that they
call for action by all countries, poor, rich and middle-income to promote prosperity while protecting
the planet. They recognize that ending poverty must go hand-in-hand with strategies that build
economic growth and addresses a range of social needs including education, health, social protection,
and job opportunities, while tackling climate change and environmental protection. While they are
not legally binding, governments are expected to take ownership and establish national frameworks
for the achievement of the 17 Goals. Countries have the primary responsibility for follow-up and
review of the progress made in implementing the Goals, which will require quality, accessible and
timely data collection Cities are hubs for ideas, commerce, culture, science, productivity, social
development and much more (UN, 2018).
Measuring sustainability is a complex issue and in the case of a city, is mainly depending on local
conditions, as each city operates within a specific ecosystem and a socio-cultural context. A
350
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
sustainable city is considered to be a place where achievements in social, economic and
environmental development are robust, provide security and ensures the well -being of its citizens.
The question of how to promote sustainable cities and indeed sustainable urbanization though, cannot
be isolated from the global economy and the way it affects the relationships between people,
environment and development (OECD, 2003).
This paper, explores the characteristics of the Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 11, concerning
sustainable cities and communities, by applying the DPSIR framework, using indicators of
sustainable development, in the small city of Trikala in order to identify potential changes which
should be encouraged towards urban sustainability to promote sustainable development and
environmental protection. Remarkable findings from a citizens’ survey coupled with data analysis
from relevant agencies lead to interesting conclusions.
2.
THE AREA UNDER STUDY
Trikala is a city in northwestern Thessaly (Figure
1), Greece. Based on Hellenic Statistical
Authority (2011) census data, the Municipality of
Trikkai counts 608,485 km2 of land and 81,355
permanent residents, with a population density of
133.7 inhabitants per km2. The Trikala Municipal
Area, which is also the urban center of the city of
Trikala, has an area of 70,100 km2 and 62,154
inhabitants, with a population density of 886.6
inhabitants per km2, making it the most densely
populated area of the Municipality (Strategic
Planning of Municipality of Trikala, 2014-2019).
3.
Figure 1: The city of Trikala, Greece
METHODOLOGY AND DATA
The DPSIR framework is a systems-thinking framework that assumes cause-effect relationships
between interacting components of social, economic, and environmental systems. According to this
framework, social and economic developments or (D)rivers, exert pressure (P) on the environment
and, as a consequence, the state (S) of the environment changes, as ie. in the provision of adequate
conditions for basic needs such as health, resource availability, and/or biodiversity. In turn, (I)mpacts
are the ways in which changes in state influence human well-being. Whereas (R)esponses generally
refer to efforts to address changes in state, as prioritized by impacts and provide action to correct or
improve the situation (EEA, 2009, Kristensen 2004).
Sustainable development indicators should reflect all elements of the causal chain that link human
activities to their environmental impacts and the responses of the society to these impacts (CIDA,
2012). The DPSIR framework is useful in describing the relationships between the origins and
consequences of environmental problems; however, in order to understand their dynamics, it is also
useful to focus on the links between DPSIR elements (WWF, 2015).
The application of DPSIR in this case, for the assessment of sustainability issues in Trikala city, is
coupled with the aggregated impacts of local responses on drivers, pressures and states being
evaluated by the answers of the surveys’ respondents. In this study, indicators of all categories were
selectively used, as shown below (Table 1).
351
Cultural and social issues
Table 1: Major domains and selected indicators for the area under study
Data to support the indicators were collected from relevant agencies, such as the Technical Service,
the Department of Greening and Gardening, the Department of Urban Applications, the company
Urban KTEL SA, as well as the Municipal Water Supply and Sewerage Company and the Traffic
Department of Trikala. Furthermore, data from the city's strategic planning report (2014 – 2019) were
also taken into consideration, as well as other related studies on the matter.
3.1 Water resources & sanitation
In order to determine the current conditions of the city, a number of indicators were used, concerning
the water resources and sanitation of the city with respect to climate change, imprudent water use, the
possibility of water scarcity in the future and possible flood risks. Water resources, according to the
DPSIR model, are part of the pressures and state, its poor management constitutes an impact and its
proper management is part of the responses.
The area of the Municipality of Trikkai belongs to the catchment area of Pinios (Figure 2).
The water quality characteristics of the rivers
are good, plus there is aquatic and riparian
vegetation developments on their banks. The
water table in most flat areas is generally quite
high, during the winter it reaches approx. 3
meters. Within the urban fabric of the city,
there are no floods that can pose a risk of
damage or disasters/human lives, however
during the summer months, short-range
rainwater projects are being carried out mainly
in drains, to protect. The water supply of the
Municipality comes from groundwater
Figure 2: Thessaly: Pinios river basin
352
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
is pumped through 56 boreholes. After the chlorination process, the water is led to the water supply
network. Based on official data, the total water supply network covering the needs of the Municipality
is about 767km.
Frequent checks are conducted to monitor network conditions and consumption, especially during
periods of water scarcity. According to data analyzed, there is a significant decrease on water
consumption of the city of Trikala, in the past ten years due to public awareness on rational water
use, and the effectiveness of existing pricing policy (1m3 = 0,49 euros). The quality of the drinking
water of the city of Trikala is controlled by the Municipal Water Quality Laboratory where daily
chemical and microbiological analyzes are carried out according to the European Specifications. The
drainage structures of the city of Trikala include a pipeline network of approximately 200km before
reaching the waste water treatment plant.
3.2 Energy sector
The energy sector is part of both pressures and state, according to the DPSIR model, while its
efficiency is part of the responses. The relationship between the driving forces and the pressure from
economic activities is a function of the eco-efficiency of the technology, with less pressure coming
from more driving forces, if eco-efficiency is improving. Monitoring energy use, electricity
consumption and use of renewable energy sources, are of major importance when it comes to
sustainability and striving to achieve a “green” status in city. By participating in innovative research
programs, in an effort to reduce power consumption, the municipality has completed a study to
upgrade the lighting system of municipal streets, by replacing it with new LED technology, whereas,
a Smart Lighting System is implemented in order to monitor and manage it. It is estimated that more
than 60% of energy will be saved. In order to reduce CO2 emissions, the municipality has decided to
proceed to an energy upgrading of municipal buildings by linking them to the natural gas network.
The final link list includes a total of 64 buildings, with a total heat output of 16,823,700 (kcal/h).
According to data from the Municipal Council, approximately 250 connections for photovoltaic roofs
of up to 10Kw and about 30 photovoltaic connections by farmers up to 100KW have been activated.
Apart from photovoltaic installations, no other power plants such as urban turbines and wind turbines
are used in the area, and there is no record of the use of either open or closed circuit geothermal
systems.
3.3 Transportation systems
A sustainable city is also defined by green, accessible and safe transportation, road safety, extensive
pedestrian areas and cycle tracks that insure air quality and easy mobility for its citizens. Such
indicators will provide a plethora of information that could also determine essential planning changes
and proper management to the local administration. The transportation system is a part of drivers,
pressure and state, according to DPSIR model, while its efficiency and management is part of the
responses.
The main road network of the city of Trikala is radial. For the most part, the road network is a oneway street. The main existing roads (those that receive the largest volume of traffic) are two-way.
The pedestrian roads are concentrated mainly in the center of the city, however they are not organized
and continuous, while the area in use is not officially recorded by the municipality. Due to its
geography, the city provides the possibility of easy bicycle travel. The total length of the city's bicycle
paths is estimated to be 14.5 km long, relatively continuous in the city center. With regard to air
quality, the Municipality of Trikala, in collaboration with Space Hellas and Cisco, will set up an
environmental monitoring system. Using special environmental measurement devices for the
collection of particulate and noise emissions, it will assess the quality of the atmosphere in order to
review the impact on public health. The private company "Urban KTEL Trikalon SA" carries out
daily local trips to the city of Trikala and to the local communities of the Municipality, with a fleet
of 17 petrol running buses.
353
Cultural and social issues
3.4 Waste management
The volume and type of waste is directly related to the living standards of a city, and their method of
managing, depositing and processing controls the correctness and efficiency of practices based on the
envisaged regulations at national and European level, while reflecting attitudes of citizens towards in
the current situation. When it comes to waste management, sustainability can be achieved through
proper hazardous waste management, recycling, urban waste water quality control and drafting a
management plan for solid waste.
It is estimated that the per capita production of municipal solid waste in the municipality of Trikala
amounts to 336.77 kg per capita/year. The collection, transport and disposal of waste is the
responsibility of the Department of Waste Management of the Operational Project Directorate, which
uses 21 fitting waste trucks. When it comes to recycling, according to data provided, from 2010 up
to today, there is generally a significant reduction in waste. Between 2010-2011 there was a decrease
of 5,43%, a decrease of 8,32% in 2011-2012, a decrease of 2,98% in 2012-2013 and finally, between
2013-2014 an increase of +2,15%. These percentages relate to municipal waste and entering the
Recycling Sorting Centers.
3.5 Urban green spaces
Proper management of green areas within a city is not only about large areas, but also about treestands, small parks and free spaces. It can effectively change the way of life of the inhabitants
providing a range of health benefits by improving the quality of life of those who live in densely built
areas and influencing positively the quality of the air. Environmental benefits include reducing the
temperature during the summer, absorbing the flowing water after severe weather events, increase
percolation of surface water into the ground and improving the aesthetics of the landscape, as well as
supporting the biodiversity and carbon capture. Economic benefits include regeneration and attracting
new services. Measuring, managing and protecting the urban green spaces, is part of DPSIR
pressures, state, impact and response.
The city is considered to be one of the most "green" in the country. This fact mainly is due to the
existence of the river of Lethaios that crosses Trikala from side to side. The total area of the cultivated
green area of the Trikala Municipal Unity is approx.530 acres. This area includes neighborhood tree
trunks, small squares and large green areas near the riverbanks, as well as the recorded urban parks.
From time to time, the municipality has proceeded to plantings to the whole extent of the city.
According to the World Health Organization and SDGs 11.7, which promotes safe and universal
access to public and green spaces for all, urban centers must provide 9 m2 to each resident within 15
minutes of their residence (Pafi et. al, 2016). Based on the data above and the population of the city
of Trikala, it is estimated that approximately 8.10 m2 corresponds to each inhabitant of the city. For
the management of the green areas in the city, the municipality has a staff of 40 people.
3.6 Cultural heritage
The cultural heritage of a city provides its foundation, identity and character, while often constitute a
pole of attraction for visitors, thus driving the local economy. The concept of sustainability does not
limit itself strictly to the environment, ecology, energy or water, but it is a wider concept, which
incorporates civilization and culture. For this reason, an urban sustainability research could not
exclude the investigation of indicators that review the citizens' perception and reaction to culture as
part of their reality and life. Cultural identity and heritage is part of DPSIR drivers and pressures and
lack of management is part of impacts.
There are many different places of significant historical importance throughout the city. From the
first “hospital” of the Hellenistic period and the Ottoman built Castle that was erected over the ancient
citadel, to the Ottoman Mosque and the historical - Matsopoulos Industrial Park that housed the first
roller mill ever built in Greece, to the newly founded Research Center – Tsitsanis Museum that resides
in the formerly used prisons in honor of the city’s music artists. All venues are managed by either the
Municipality or the Ephorate of Antiquities of Trikala and are used by the local community as venues
354
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
for cultural events, conferences, exhibitions, concerts and school trips. The execution of the projects
are carried out following a tendering procedure (by auction) and are funded by the European Regional
Development Fund.
4.
THE SURVEY
About 307 questionnaires were collected altogether from the city’s citizens, representing a 5 per
thousand of the city's population. Sampling was performed by the random sampling method, where
there is a known probability that each unit is selected as the unit of the sample.
Through 26 questions, concerning urban green, water, energy, transport, recycling and cultural issues
of the city were formulated. The objective was to evaluate the citizens' view and ability to identify
priorities and values, as well as what is considered most important when it comes to decision making,
in order to make life in the city more sustainable.
For the output of the results, the process of encoding the questionnaire elements is followed in a table,
which assigns each question to the questionnaire in a variable. Variables receive different values.
This creates a data file where variables and attributes are defined and which results in a series of
commands. Processing took place on two levels. Initially, a descriptive statistical analysis was
presented, showing the frequency distributions of the variables as well as the central phase indicators,
followed by inductive statistical analysis to check empirically the existence or not of statistically
significant variations in the fluctuation of the averages of the research variables and to check the
research questions that have been formulated. Because the 62 research variables are categorical, either
as dependent or as independent, the appropriate statistical criterion for the above test is the x2 Test.
At the same time, the Monte Carlo simulation was used because the sample (307) is greater than 250
to overcome the limitation of the x2 Test application. SPSS was used for the analysis of the findings.
The “identity” of the survey comprises of 42.7% men and 57.3% women. The 28.3% were citizens
between 18-25 years olds followed by a 44% belonging to the 26 - 40 age group, 25% are between
41 – 65 years old and 2.6% are over 65. In terms of education, 52.8% are university graduates, 17%
hold postgraduate degrees (MSc / MA/PhD), 25% are high school graduates, and the rest 5,2% were
priests, military men etc. Responses were taken from all neighborhood areas within the city to allow
for an objective representation of the sample.
Transportation systems
Should cars be allowed in the city
centre?
(Positive Responces)
9.7
0.7
16.7
24.9
18 to 25
Figure 3:
Infrastructure adequacy
26 to 40
41 to 65
65 plus
Figure 4:
Prohibit the moving of cars in the city center
According to the results of the survey, 88% (Figure 3) of the respondents claim that current
infrastructure is inadequate to support a ban on cars in the city center, whereas, most young people
(Figure 4), would prefer for the city center to be accessible only by foot. More than half of the
respondents (62%) choose to move with a car or motorcycle to and from their workplace, while the
option of more environmentally friendly transportation means, such as bicycle, public transportation
and walking, are of low preference, despite the fact most distances are not long. Furthermore, the
355
Cultural and social issues
survey showed that the citizens of Trikala do not feel safe either by walking (36%) or by using the
bicycle (68%), although data on deaths and accidents, provided by the Hellenic Department of Traffic
Police, are reported to be lower in the last 5 – 8 years.
Waste management /Recycling
More than 50% of the respondents tend to recycle mostly paper (28%) and plastic (30.3%) given that
those are most commonly used, whereas those who do so, do it frequently (Figure 5). Furthermore,
the survey showed that citizens seem fairly satisfied (74,3%) by the recycling methods provided
(Figure 6).
Recycling frequency
Γενικός τύπος
Γενικός τύπος
Citizen Satisfaction of Recycling
Methods
Γενικός
Γενικός Γενικός τύπος
Γενικός
Γενικός τύπος τύπος τύπος
τύπος
5.2
Γενικός τύπος
20.5
74.3
Poor
Figure 5:
Recycling frequency of all materials
Fair
Good
Figure 6:
Satisfaction of recycling methods used
Water issues
The city's water quality is checked daily by appropriate tests on the basis of European criteria and its
quality is found excellent, so, as expected, 85% of citizens use tap water provided by the Water Supply
Network. However, a high 15% prefer to drink bottled water on a permanent basis. The relationship
between trust of tap water and bottle water showed a statistically significant difference.
The majority of the respondents are aware of the global water scarcity problem and almost 60% are
willing to change their water habits even though at the moment the city does not face intensive water
issues. They do keep using water, for purposes other than the usual household standard use (60%)
though, such as car washing and gardening (Figure 7).
Water consumtion for secondary uses
Γενικός τύπος
Γενικός τύπος
Γενικός τύπος
Not at all
Moderately
Extremely
Figure 7:
Non-household water consumption frequency
Cultural heritage
Almost 71% or the respondents are willing to financially contribute to promote and preserve their
cultural heritage.WTP shown in figure 8 reveals that 4 out of 10 can give up to 20 euros per year,
which indicates the important role the culture plays in their quest of a sustainable city.
356
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
WTP (€) per year to promote and preserve cultural heritage
11.5
23
5.9
26.8
18
14.8
None
Other
3 EUR
5 EUR
10 EUR
20 EUR
Figure 8: Willingness to contribute financially in order to support the local cultural identity
Urban green spaces
Despite living in a smaller city, with it being closer to nature, citizens, seemed to value and make use
of organized green sites such as urban parks for both walks and sports, as well as other activities,
most of them regularly (45% do so once a week) as seen in figure 9 whereas most of them are women
(57,3%).
How often you use the urban parks ?
15.6
3.3
45
9.1
27
Rarely
Once a year
Once every six months
Once a month
Once a week
Figure 9: Use frequency of urban parks in Trikala
Energy
The survey showed that most people (90%) do not use Renewable Energy Sources for electricity
purposes in their homes (Figure 10), however half of them are willing to use conservation methods
to reduce energy consumption and they welcome the municipality’s efforts in promoting such
innovative methods.
Use of RES in houses of Trikala
9.4
90.6
Figure 10: Current use of RES in the cities’ housing
357
Cultural and social issues
5.
CONCLUSION-DISCUSSION
According to the combined results through the analysis of data and the respondents’ answers, Trikala
city has the potential to become a sustainable city, but there is still much to be done.
The structure of the agencies and services of the public sector are inadequately organized, which
made data collection particularly difficult. The fragmentation of competences into different agencies
and the lack of synergies between competent bodies, which is essential for achieving sustainable
management in the context of sustainability, reveal the extent of the problem.
In transportation, lack of security and respect towards cyclists, prevent aspiring cyclists to move
around, despite the limited, but existing, bicycle path network.
The lack of organized pedestrian areas does not affect those who choose to move on foot, however,
there is a strong sense of insecurity, due to the increased use of cars in the city center.
As far as water resources and sanitation is concerned, water quality and water resources management
are satisfactory, although there is quite a significant percentage of respondents who use bottled water
on a permanent basis. People seems to be aware of the global water problem and claim to be ready
to accept water conservation measures and change the way they think and act, even though there is a
large percentage of those who keep using water in an unscrupulous way.
When it comes to recycling there seems to be a good management plan at hand by the authorities,
which is confirmed by the citizens satisfaction of the means used. On their part, numbers showed that
citizens have embraced the idea and practice of recycling avidly.
Innovation and technological advances, capable to improve life as a whole are improving the current
situation and lead the way to implement sophisticated technology to facilitate changes when it comes
to the energy sector and the decrease of the ecological footprint.
Changes that could possibly improve the well-being of the city’s inhabitants and could be
implemented are:
Importance should be given to official data recordings that can lead to the creation of data platforms
accessible to operators and citizens both, by making use of their network and capabilities.
Link bicycle routes to urban and suburban parks inside and outside the city for safe and easy access
for all.
Redesigning and shaping the flowerbeds and small squares with emphasis put on using suitable
species that can limit the phenomenon of the urban heat island, will act as windbreakers during the
winter, improve the air quality and ameliorate the overall aesthetics.
Promoting green and sustainable practices in their home, might interest citizens in taking part in
national and union financial programs that will improve their lifestyle, when it comes to energy.
Developing alternative forms of tourism, such as ecotourism, agrotourism or religious tourism that
could probably attract global interest, making the city an attractive destination for everyone.
Setting up an information platform online for the many places of historical and cultural importance,
such as sights, museums, churches etc. of the area, using the power of the internet to attract visitors.
These changes are targeted to better the municipality’s resource management, in order to provide
social benefits (better organized green spaces, recycling etc.), improve the quality of life of the
citizens (clean air, organized transportation and sense of security), decrease the environmental impact
(waste management, energy efficiency), boost the local economy by promoting the comparative
advantages of the city and strengthen their cultural identity and heritage. The major responsibility in
implementing those changes lays on the municipality, according to the citizens input – as presented
in the survey conducted – however it is of upmost importance to support groundbreaking initiatives
358
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
and provide means in communicating and disseminating the benefits to the local community in order
to strive for essential sustainability.
References
1. CIDA, 2012. Indicators for Sustainability: How Cities Are Monitoring and Evaluating Their
Success. The Canadian International Development Agency, Ottawa, Canada.
2. Kristensen, P., 2004. The DPSIR Framework. Paper presented at the 27-29 September 2004
workshop on a comprehensive / detailed assessment of the vulnerability of water resources to
environmental change in Africa using river basin approach, UNEP Headquarters, Nairobi, Kenya.
3.
Piante C., Ody D.,2015. Blue Growth in the Mediterranean Sea: the Challenge of Good
Environmental Status. MedTrends Project. WWF-France. Pages 14-15.
Pafi M., Siragusa A., Ferri S., Halkia M., Measuring the Accessibility of Urban
4. Green Areas. A comparison of the Green ESM with other datasets in four European cities; EUR
28068 EN;
5. Science for Environment Policy (2015) Indicators for sustainable cities. In-depth Report 12.
Produced for the European Commission DG Environment by the Science Communication Unit,
UWE, Bristol Urban green spaces and health. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe,
2016.
6. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (2003) Environmental Indicators:
Development Measurement and Use, Reference Paper, OECD, Paris
7. Hellenic Department of Traffic Police - 23/10/2017
8. https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/signals-2009 (accessed March 15th 2018)
9. http://trikalacity.gr/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/stratigikos-sxediasmos.pdf(accessed March 6th
2018).
10. https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/sdg11 (accessed February 2nd 2018)
11. http://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/development-agenda/ (accessed February 23rd 2018)
359
Cultural and social issues
INVESTIGATING STAKEHOLDERS PRIORITIES FOR
TRANSDISCIPLINARY COASTAL & MARINE MANAGEMENT:
THE CASE OF THERMAIKOS GULF
Z.I. Konstantinou* and D. Latinopoulos
School of Spatial Planning and Development, Faculty of Engineering, Aristotle University of
Thessaloniki,GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: zkon@civil.auth.gr, tel.: +306977960420
Abstract
Aim of this work is to investigate institutional stakeholders’ priorities, regarding transdisciplinary
coastal and marine management in Thermaikos Gulf. The targeted coastal and marine area is shared
by four Greek regional units, hosting a variety of human activities such as intense urban development,
agriculture and husbandry, industry, mussel-culture, fisheries, tourism, etc. There are more than 90
entities which have some kind of jurisdiction or stake in the management of the coastal and marine
area of the Gulf, the majority being sectoral public administration agencies. To cover their range of
opinions, we developed and distributed a questionnaire focused in identifying the most important
management issues in the area, as well as the main reasons behind the possible management failures
until know. To test the questionnaire, we contacted a series of interviews with selected representatives
of key management authorities, assisting also to acquire a deeper understanding of the current
management regime in the area. Through the results we will: a) attempt a preliminary evaluation of
stakeholders’ willingness to participate in Science-Policy-Society collaboration processes; b) identify
the management issue(s) with the highest importance for the local stakeholders and c) investigate
deeper the relationship between key local socio-ecological problems and the current institutional and
legal status regarding coastal and marine management.
Keywords: stakeholders’ engagement, integrated coastal and marine management, transdisciplinary
approaches, Thermaikos Gulf
1.
INTRODUCTION
Coastal and marine environments are paramount to the socio-economic performance and well-being
of societies. Under the current global social-ecological conditions and especially in countries as
Greece, phasing extreme financial challenges, coastal and marine resources become even more
important for prosperity and more prompt to overexploitation and mismanagement. To remediate or
even try to prevent poor coastal and marine management decisions, knowledge-based, participative
and transdisciplinary management is necessary [Tett et al., 2011]. This type of management requires
an organised Science-Policy-Society integration and the use of novel scientific tools [Cornell et al.,
2013]. One of the greatest challenges in such an approach is to design a process, which will include
a wide range of stakeholders, at different times and with different levels of involvement. In this
process, stakeholders’ priorities and concerns should be placed in the centre of any management
attempt and their collective knowledge should be utilised alongside scientific findings. Involving
stakeholders in coastal and marine management assists greatly with the effective implementation of
relevant plans [Buanes et al., 2005], hand-by-hand with the development of a sound legislative basis,
which is another essential prerequisite for efficient management [McKenna et al., 2008]. In order to
determine stakeholders’ priorities related to Integrated Coastal Management (ICM) and Marine
360
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Spatial Planning (MSP), especially in areas where participative processes are not yet well accustomed
practices, interviewing and questioning key institutional stakeholders is a commonly adopted
technique [Villares et al., 2006; Fletcher et al., 2007]. Such approaches will be the base to support
further and more complex participative processes of Science-Policy-Society integration, as is the codevelopment of integrated tools to support management [Voinov et al., 2016].
Thermaikos Gulf is a large coastal and marine area in Northern Greece, shared by four Regional Units
(Thessaloniki, Imathia, Pieria and Chalkidiki) and hosting a variety of intense human activities, such
as urban development, agriculture and husbandry, industry, mussel-culture, fisheries, tourism, etc.
The coastal area also hosts the second largest city of Greece (Thessaloniki), as well as a Ramsar
wetland of international importance (Axios Delta).
2.
METHODOLOGY
To investigate the stakeholders’ priorities, regarding transdisciplinary coastal and marine
management in Thermaikos Gulf, a questionnaire was developed, comprising of four parts, targeted
in collecting information relevant to the subject. It was accompanied by an introductory part which
explained the overall research goals, i.e. (a) the identification of the most important management
issues for the area, (b) the development of management procedures and tools that will support
efficient resource management, as well as (c) the development of robust social-ecological policies.
The first part of the questionnaire was devoted to general information, information on the entity that
each respondent represents as well as on their specific jurisdiction or stakes in the coastal and marine
area of the gulf. The second part attempted to investigate the knowledge of respondents regarding the
European and Greek legislation on ICM and MSP, as well as their opinion on the coherence and
effectiveness of this legislation and the manner in which the existing environmental legislation affects
their work and responsibilities.
The third part of the questionnaire aimed in determining the stakeholders’ priorities regarding the
coastal and marine management of the area of Thermaikos gulf. Eleven key and known management
issues were preselected so that the respondents could evaluate their importance for the area in a 5point Likert-type scale ranging from 1, not important, to 5, very important (respondents could also
declare that they have no knowledge regarding the importance of the issue). The following issues
were explored: a) Management of point and non-point land inputs/Pollution; b) Fisheries
management, including fleets, fish stocks, etc.; c) Management of coastal/marine tourism activities;
d) Management of port and other navigation activities; e) Management of urban and peri-urban
development at the coastal zone; f) Management of aquaculture activities; g) Management of the
protected areas; h) Management of existing or potential conflicts between tourism and other activities
(o.a.); i) Management of existing or potential conflicts between fisheries and o.a.; j) Management of
existing or potential conflicts between port activities and o.a.; k) Management of existing or potential
conflicts between aquaculture and o.a. Participant were also informed that the list was not exhaustive,
so they could determine other management issues as well. The next question aimed to determine the
stakeholders’ opinions on the nature of the impact of the aforementioned management issues
(including the ones they may have suggested) to the social-ecological system of Thermaikos gulf.
The respondents could select one or more impacts (economic, social, environmental, on lawful
operation) but they could also declare that they have no knowledge on the issue or that they do not
consider it of sufficient importance.
By the same rationale, the following question aimed to determine their opinion about the causal factors
of these issues. The respondents could select between the following options: a) lack of
knowledge/technology/infrastructure; b) lack of adequate legal framework; c) inability to implement the
existing legal framework (caused by institutional deficiencies, lack of resources, etc.); d) lack of political
will; and e) overexploitation of available resources/illegal activity. They could once again declare
lack of personal knowledge or insufficient importance of the issue. For both questions the respondents
were given space and opportunity to declare additional impacts and causal factors, should they
361
Cultural and social issues
consider something was missing. Finally, the last set of questions aimed to determine the top
stakeholders’ priority for the area, thus asked for the selection of the issue that was considered as the
most crucial and urgent for Thermaikos gulf. Since the area is large and with spatial variability, the
respondents were asked to determine in which areas did they believe that their selected issue was
more prominent (see also Figure 6), as well as to determine more specific environmental, social and
economic impacts of this issue.
The final part of the questionnaire asked for personal information, on a volunteer basis, and
investigated the respondents interest to participate to potential future efforts of collaboration between
the research team and the area’s stakeholders.
The stakeholders’ pool targeted for this study was selected aiming to capture the opinions of
representatives working in public, semi-public or private entities with varying levels of jurisdiction,
responsibilities or stakes in the coastal and marine area of Thermaikos gulf [Konstantinou et al.,
2017]. The selection included representatives of various ministry directorates with direct jurisdiction
on the selected area; departments of the two branches of regional government (elected and decentralised) with either environmental responsibilities or responsibilities in the fields of fisheries,
aquaculture, tourism, etc; coastal municipalities; organisations (e.g. Thessaloniki’s Water and Waste
Company and Thessaloniki’s Port Authority); environmental NGO’s; as well as major research and
education institutes which have conducted studies in Thermaikos gulf.
In order to initially test the way that the questionnaire was perceived by respondents and then to adjust
any parts which may not be clear, 9 interviews (10 planned, 9 executed) with selected respondents
were conducted. The interviewees were selected in a way to represent: the regional level of
governance (covering all the Regional Units), the national level of governance (Ministry of the
Environment), the NGOs and the research institutes. The interviews allowed for deeper understanding
of the governance regime in the area, as well as for the identification of further representatives of
authorities with relevant responsibilities in Thermaikos gulf. As a result of these interviews, the
language used in the questionnaire was slightly modified, to facilitate clarity. The questionnaires were
distributed to the identified authorities through e-mail. During two and a half months, the
questionnaire was repeatedly sent to the selected respondents, at least once a week (maximum 3 times
a week), while when possible phone calls were also made.
3.
RESULTS
3.1 General information
A total of 97 authorities, organisations and key stakeholders were contacted repeatedly, during a
period of 75 days. Among them, 66 were governance and management authorities, on local, regional
or national level of jurisdiction, 4 were research and education bodies, 14 were environmental NGOs
and 13 were private or semi-private organisations, such as professional associations, semi-private
management authorities, etc. 20 responses were collected in total, 9 of them through face-to-face
interviews and 11 through e-questionnaires. 17 of these responses corresponded to personnel of public
authorities (25.75% response rate), 1 response was collected from professionals in research and
education (25% response rate), 1 from an NGO representative (7.1% response rate) and 1 from a
representative of a private association (7.7% response rate). The 9 initial interviews were contacted
during the first 10 days of the study, while the rest of the responses where provided during the
remaining period of time, after multiple contacts. It should be noted that all the responders were
higher education graduates, with the majority of them holding an MSc qualification (55%), while
30% of them also hold a PhD, mainly in environmental related fields. Regarding the spatial
distribution of responders, based on the area where they are active, 35% of them are active at the
Regional level (Region of Central Macedonia), 30% are active in the Regional Unit (R.U.) of
Thessaloniki, 15% in the R.U. of Pieria, 10% in the R.U. of Imathia, while only one person is active
specifically in the R.U. of Chalkidiki. Finally, 10% of the interviewees are active at the national level.
362
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
More than half of the responders identified themselves as personnel of public authorities with
management jurisdiction in the area of interest, in and around Thermaikos gulf, while 20% were
identified as personnel of authorities with other jurisdiction in the area. A single respondent identified
himself as working in research (although at the moment is also leading an organisation with very
crucial management responsibilities for the area) and a single respondent identified himself as
working in the tourism sector (although working for a regional level public authority). Finally, out of
the four responders which identified themselves as working in another sector, one was identified as
NGO personnel, one as private organisation personnel while two of them were identified as working
for authorities of the regional government.
3.2 EU and Greek legal framework regarding ICM and MSP
The evaluation of the legal framework knowledge, understanding and use, took place through
different clusters of questions. The participants were asked to determine their level of knowledge
regarding the EU and Greek legislation related, directly or indirectly, to ICM or MSP. The majority
of the respondents claimed no, little or medium level knowledge of the respective legal framework
(80% regarding the EU legislation and 75% regarding the Greek legislation; Figure 1). Only one
respondent declared to have excellent knowledge of the EU legal framework, while two respondents
declared to have excellent knowledge of the Greek legal framework regarding the relevant topics.
Figure 2: Self-evaluation of the knowledge of the legal framework regarding ICM and MSP.
Regarding the efficiency of the EU and Greek legal framework to create and regulate the conditions
for ICM and MSP, 40% of the respondents declared that the European legislation presents medium
efficiency, 25% declared no knowledge to support an evaluation, while the rest of the respondents
were divided between “full efficiency” and “no efficiency”, with the latter being supported by fewer
respondents (Figure 2). Regarding the Greek legal framework on ICM and MSP, 35% of the
respondents declared medium efficiency, 25% little efficiency and the rest were divided equally
between “no efficiency” and “sufficient efficiency”. No respondent declared either “no knowledge”
or full efficiency” of the legal framework.
When asked to evaluate the level of support that the Greek environmental legal framework provides
to their everyday activity (related to the coastal and marine management of Thermaikos gulf), 40%
of the respondents declared that the existing framework provides medium support on their activity,
10% declared that their activity is fully supported by the existing legal framework, while the rest were
equally divided between “little support” and “good support”. It should be mentioned that no
respondent declared that the existing environmental framework does not provide any support for their
activity
363
Cultural and social issues
Figure 3: Evaluation of the efficiency of the legal framework
3.3 Evaluation of management issues
The evaluation of the selected management issues is presented in Figure 3. As shown, all issues are
perceived as very important. However, the Land input management and the associated pollution of
the coastal and marine waters, is evaluated by the majority of respondents as very important. Other
issues that come forward as important/very important are the Protected area’s management and the
Management of urban and peri-urban development. The Management of aquaculture activities in the
area is also conceived in a spectrum from medium to very important, with some respondents to
comment that they are reluctant to characterise it as very important for the gulf due to the localised
character of the activity. From Figure 3 it is also obvious that the existing or potential conflicts
between activities are conceived as less important compared to the rest of the management issues.
As the respondents were able to also determine other management issues of importance, a number of
suggestions were received. Nevertheless, in their majority these issues were directly linked to the
defined management issues, if only more thematically or spatially determined. The only proposed
issue that could be considered completely autonomous, was the Management of Marine Litter, linked
only indirectly with the management of tourism activities.
The identification of the nature of impacts (environmental, social, economic, impacts on lawful
operation) in either local or regional level is presented in Figure 4, which demonstrates that
stakeholders’ perception varies sufficiently depending on the issue at hand. The issue of Land input
management, and thus pollution, is perceived by all the respondents as having an impact in the
environmental state of the gulf, but only half of the respondents believe that this degradation causes
economic impacts and even less that it causes impacts in the social coherency or in the lawful
operation of society. Issues such as the Management of urban/peri-urban development and the
Protected area management, although also perceived as mainly having environmental impacts, are
almost equally perceived as having economic impacts as well, while in both cases either impacts on
lawful operation or in social coherency are considered significant from a considerable number of
respondents. It is mainly in the Management of human activities (fisheries, tourism, navigation,
aquaculture) that the environmental, social and economic impacts are equally identified as important,
while the Management of conflicts is perceived as mainly having economic and social impacts and
not so much environmental ones.
364
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 4: Evaluation of the importance of the pre-selected coastal and marine management
issues for the case of Thermaikos gulf.
Figure 5: Identification of the nature of impacts of the selected management issues for the
case of Thermaikos gulf
The identification of the causal factors of the management issues, as perceived from the stakeholders,
is very crucial in better understanding the nature of these issues and in identifying management
actions, procedures and tools to remediate them. The responding stakeholders perceive that, with the
exception of the Protected area management, the major causal factor for all the management issues is
the inability to implement the existing legal framework, due to institutional deficiencies, lack of
resources, etc. Regarding the Protected area management, the lack of adequate legal framework is
perceived as a more important causal factor, but the inability for implementation is still the second
more important one. The potential lack of knowledge, technology and infrastructure is perceived as
significant regarding the Land input management, while it is considered a rather secondary causal
365
Cultural and social issues
factor for most issues. Lack of political will (to identify and implement solutions) is considered as a
high ranking causal factor for the issues of Land input management, Tourism management,
Management of urban/peri-urban development and Protected area management, while the
overexploitation of resources/illegal activity is perceived as an important causal factor for
Aquaculture management, Management of urban/peri-urban development, Tourism management,
Fisheries management and Land input management.
When the respondents were asked to identify the sole most important management issue in
Thermaikos gulf, 55% choose Land input management, while 25% declared the Management of
urban/peri-urban activity. The respondents were additionally asked to determine the importance of
the most important management issue on a spatial level. According to their answers, the areas of the
Gulf of Thessaloniki and the Axios-Loudias-Aliakmonas estuaries, were determined as the areas of
highest interest (Figure 6).
Figure 6: Identification of causal factors for the selected management issues in the case of
Thermaikos gulf.
4.
DISCUSSION
The most important finding of this paper is connected to the willingness of Greek stakeholders to
participate to Science-Policy-Society collaboration efforts. Only 20% of the intended targets replied
to the survey. Answering an e-questionnaire is probably the less engaging, less time-consuming and
less personal way to participate in such efforts. Nevertheless, only a small portion of the invited
stakeholders choose to participate and this participation was provoked after numerous reminders and,
in some cases, phone calls. In at least 20 cases, stakeholders where contacted in a personal level,
based either in previous collaborations or the interference of a common acquaintance, acting as a
liaison between the researcher and the potential respondent, and still the stakeholders did not engage
to the survey (besides the fact that many of them declared that they will).
Additionally, numerous stakeholders which were contacted in the framework of this survey, believed
firmly that they didn’t have the adequate background or jurisdiction to answer the survey. Authorities
with environmental responsibilities or responsibilities connected to productive activities (fisheries,
aquaculture, tourism, etc.) claimed, through email or phone calls, that they don’t perceive their field
of expertise as relevant to the research, proposing at the same time individuals in other organisations
366
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
as potential respondents. When informed that the proposed organisations were also contacted, but
that their input would still be useful, most of them declared unavailability or unwillingness to respond.
Similar considerations where expressed also from interviewees and respondents; some of them also
insisted in not declaring themselves as “representatives” of their authority or organisation but only as
“personnel, providing an educated opinion”.
Figure 7: Coastal and marine areas of Thermaikos gulf, identified from the responders as the
most crucial regarding the Land input management in connection to pollution.
These behaviours are indicators of the infantile level that Science-Policy-Society collaboration efforts
are in Greece [Koutrakis et al., 2010; Apostolopoulou et al., 2012; Konstantinou et al., 2013]. In
other words, many stakeholders do not perceive science as a means which can provide tangible,
efficient solutions for persistent social-ecological problems and thus are reluctant to invest their time
in this procedure. Even for the case of stakeholders who believe in the capacity of such efforts to
produce results, considerable doubts have been expressed as to whether such solutions can find their
way to implementation in policy development and governance, thus again making their engagement
futile or treat them purely as “scientific exercises” which in the end will benefit science, but neither
policy or society [Glenn et al., 2012]. At the same time, the structure of the governance, with multiple
authorities holding fragments of jurisdiction, creates a public regime where responsibility is an
elusive concept and in which authorities are invested only in the small part of their jurisdiction,
ignoring thus what happens beyond their circle of influence. As a result, the concept of integrated
(and transdisciplinary) management of the environment and its resources becomes impossible to
approach: jurisdiction and authority is divided to everyone and thus to no-one, resulting in ineffective
national, regional and local administrative structures, weak enforcement, and no policy integration
[Trumbic, 2008].
The obstacles in approaching a more integrated and transdisciplinary approach in coastal and marine
management are also evident in the limited knowledge of EU and Greek legislation regarding ICM
and MSP, as also identified in other previous studies [Koutrakis et al., 2010]. The low percentage of
institutional stakeholders having a good or excellent knowledge of the specific EU legal provisions,
but also of the much wider way in which European legislation is ratified into different Greek laws
and legal documents, is indicative of the lack of central integrated management mentality in Greek
governance. Each sectoral jurisdiction is focused in the part of the legislation, which is absolutely
necessary to know in order to take specific decisions; outside this spectrum the responsibility is
transferred to other authorities and no knowledge is required. At the same time, this specific legal
367
Cultural and social issues
framework isn’t perceived even indirectly connected to approaches as ICM or MSP. Nevertheless,
when asked to evaluate the environmental related legal framework which they work with, the
respondents were much more confident to provide opinion and to comment on it with specificity.
They underlined the fragmentation of jurisdiction, gaps and overlaps, as well as the absence of clear
legal guidelines for specific issues (e.g. protected area management/Natura 2000 sites). On the other
hand, they also comment that the existing legal framework, even if not perfect, is the only existing
tool to achieve some level of (social-ecological) management (mainly in terms of managing
productive activities).
The stakeholders’ priorities are revealed clearly through the results. Namely, the issue of Land inputs
management, and thus the pollution caused in the coastal and marine areas of the gulf, is definitely a
leading priority for the majority of the respondents. The evaluation of different management issues
as of high importance for the area, reveals their general concerns, as well as an understanding that
when discussing social-ecological management, especially in coastal and marine areas, a certain level
of interconnection between different policy issues is to be expected. It is interesting to observe, that
the respondents seem to view the management of productive activities as issues with various impacts
for the area (environmental, social, economic, legal). On the contrary, Land inputs management was
mainly considered as an environmental issue, despite the fact that these inputs are mainly
anthropogenic, have an impact on a number of other activities (aquaculture, tourism, etc.) and can be
the product of illegal activity (e.g. unregulated waste disposal and agricultural inputs).
Finally, another interesting observation on the results of this survey is related to the most prominent
causal factor of the identified management issues, which is the inability to implement the existing
legal framework due to a number of institutional deficiencies. Again, it is necessary to underline that
the majority of respondents are institutional stakeholders, thus they represent the bodies which should
or could implement the existing legal framework to enable better environmental management. The
identification of institutional deficiencies as major causal factor of inadequate management, even
when referring to lack of resources (human and financial) is a strong indicator pointing towards the
need for re-thinking and re-structuring of the legal framework (including the governing structures
which implement it). Re-structuring of the legal and institutional brunches of the management process
could have a positive output to at least two other important causal factors, according to the survey:
the lack of adequate legal framework and the overexploitation of resources/illegal activities, which
are, in a way, different expressions of the same problem.
5.
CONCLUSIONS
The Greek stakeholders’ reluctance to participate on a quite simplified, impersonal and preliminary
effort for Science-Policy-Society interface is a discouraging, yet expected result. Even in societies
where such efforts are more accustomed and better integrated in the social structure, engagement can
be a challenging task [Fletcher et al., 2007]. Nevertheless, this output is also an indicator that
corrective actions need to be taken in order for such processes to be more meaningful and successful
in the future. Part of these actions should target the increase of trust in the claim that science can
provide knowledge-based, efficient and ethical tools to support fair and sustainable policy
development and governance [Glenn et al., 2012].
Although through a limited, yet varying sample, the stakeholders’ priorities regarding the coastal and
marine management of Thermaikos gulf are clear and coherent: the most important issue is Land
input management in association with pollution. This issue is highly complicated and challenging, as
well as spatially varying in the gulf. Our goal, through the next steps of this research, is to develop
transdisciplinary processes and tools which will make its management more efficient and successful.
These tools will aim: a) to increase the knowledge (scientific and other) on the issue and b) to identify
and propose solutions for the institutional deficiencies. To achieve that in detail, the focus of future
work should be placed in those areas which were identified as more affected by the management
issue.
368
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work is realised as part of a post-doctoral grand, funded from the Greek State Scholarships
Foundation, under the framework of the action “Post-doctoral Researchers Support” (MIS: 5001552)
of the operational programme “Human Resources Development, Education and Life Long Learning”
– NSRF 2014-2020.
References
1. Tett, P., Mette, A., Sandburg, A. & Bailly, D. (2011) 'The Systems Approach', in Sustaining
Coastal Zone Systems (eds. Tett, P., Sandburg, A. & Mette, A.) Dunedin Academic
Press,Edinburgh, Scotland., 2011.
2. Cornell, S., Berkhout, F., Tuinstra, W., Tàbara, J. D., Jäger, J., Chabay, I., de Wit, B., Langlais,
R., Mills, D., Moll, P., Otto, I. M., Petersen, A., Pohl, C. & van Kerkhoff, L. (2013) 'Opening up
knowledge systems for better responses to global environmental change', Environmental
Science and Policy, 28, 60–70.
3. Buanes, A., Jentoft, S., Maurstad, A., Søreng, S. U. & Runar Karlsen, G. (2005) 'Stakeholder
participation in Norwegian coastal zone planning', Ocean and Coastal Management, 48, 658–
669.
4. McKenna, J., Cooper, A. & O’Hagan, A. M. (2008) 'Managing by principle: A critical analysis
of the European principles of Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM)', Marine Policy, 32,
941–955.
5. Villares, M., Roca, E., Serra, J. & Montori, C. (2006) 'Social Perception as a Tool for Beach
Planning: a Case Study on the Catalan Coast', Journal of Coastal Research, 118–123.
6. Fletcher, S. & Pike, K. (2007) 'Coastal management in the Solent: The stakeholder perspective',
Marine Policy, 31, 638–644.
7. Voinov, A., Kolagani, N., McCall, M. K., Glynn, P. D., Kragt, M. E., Ostermann, F. O., Pierce,
S. A. & Ramu, P. (2016) 'Modelling with stakeholders - Next generation', Environmental
Modelling and Software, 77, 196–220.
8. Konstantinou, Z. I. & Latinopoulos, D. (2017) 'Trandisciplinary ICM and MSP in thermaikos
gulf', in 13th International MEDCOAST Congress on Coastal and Marine Sciences,
Engineering, Management and Conservation, MEDCOAST 2017, 1, 2017.
9. Koutrakis, E. T., Sapounidis, A., Marzetti, S., Giuliani, V., Martino, S., Fabiano, M., Marin, V.,
Paoli, C., Roccatagliata, E., Salmona, P., Rey-Valette, H., Roussel, S., Povh, D. & MalváRez, C.
G. (2010) 'Public stakeholders’ perception of ICZM and coastal erosion in the mediterranean',
Coastal Management, 38, 354–377.
10. Apostolopoulou, E., Drakou, E. G. & Pediaditi, K. (2012) 'Participation in the management of
Greek Natura 2000 sites: Evidence from a cross-level analysis', Journal of Environmental
Management, 113, 308–318.
11. Konstantinou, Z. I. & Krestenitis, Y. N. (2013) 'An Overview of the Implementation of SAF
Methodology Regarding the Stakeholder Response, in the Mussel-Farming Area of
Chalastra, Thermaikos Gulf', Global Challenges in Integrated Coastal Zone Management
2013.
12. Glenn, H., Tingley, D., Sánchez Maroño, S., Holm, D., Kell, L., Padda, G., Runar Edvardsson, I.,
Asmundsson, J., Conides, A., Kapiris, K., Bezabih, M., Wattage, P. & Kuikka, S. (2012) 'Trust
in the fisheries scientific community', Marine Policy, 36, 54–72.
13. Trumbic, I. (2008) 'New protocol on Integrated Coastal Zone Management', Environmental
Policy and Law, 38, 145–153.
369
Cultural and social issues
370
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Solid waste management
371
Solid waste management
372
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT OF MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT PRACTICES IN CENTRAL MACEDONIA
M. Batsioula1, G. Banias2*, Ch. Achillas2,3, M. Lampridi2, and D. Bochtis2
1
International Hellenic University, School of Economics and Business Administration, GR-57001
Thermi, Greece
2
Centre for Research and Technology-Hellas, Institute for Bio-economy and Agritechnology, GR57001Thermi, Greece
3
Technological Educational Institute of Central Macedonia, Department of Logistics, GR-60100
Katerini, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: g.banias@certh.gr, tel : +302311257650
Abstract
The continuously expanding amounts of waste produced in the EU constitute a major concern at a
European level. Municipal waste management represents one of the most critical problems that need
to be addressed in Greece, because of the lack of available funds due to the financial crisis. To date,
several illegal landfills still pollute the environment, with Greece being penalized by the European
Court of Justice for several cases since 2005. On this basis, the development of an optimal waste
management strategy, exploiting all available technologies and taking into account all waste streams
is more than critical at a national level. In this work, we focus on the Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)
of different scenarios of municipal solid waste management practices in an effort to estimate
quantitively their environmental impacts. The work is conducted for the Region of Central
Macedonia, Greece.
Keywords: waste management; municipal solid waste; life cycle analysis; Region of Central
Macedonia.
1.
INTRODUCTION
The world population is constantly growing and lifestyles and trends are changing rapidly. Increasing
quantities of municipal waste is a key issue in modern cities worldwide, and one of the major
challenges for municipalities is the collection, recycling, treatment and disposal of solid waste
(Cherubini, Bargigli and Ulgiati, 2009). In European Union, Waste Framework Directive
(2008/98/EC) and Landfill Directive (1999/31/EC), it is set the regulatory framework within which
member states should adopt more environmental options, based on the “Waste Hierarchy” concept,
which includes the ideas of reduce, reuse, recycling/compost and energy recovery from waste, thereby
aiming at waste prevention and landfill minimization.
Consequently, there has been a growing interest in sustainable management of MSW, which covers
generation, collection, transfer, sorting, treatment, recovery and disposal of waste. On this basis, it
has been done much research on integrated solid waste management systems, which include various
options like materials recycling, biological treatment of biodegradable fractions, composting or
thermal treatments with energy recovery. Several publications have appeared evaluating several
MSW management strategies at local, regional and national level. Different practices on waste
management have been reviewed for countries such as: Germany, Denmark, Greece and other
European countries (Bassi et al., 2017; Gentil et al., 2009), for regions: Lombardia, Italy (Rigamonti
373
Solid waste management
et al., 2013), for cities: Niš, Serbia (Milutinović et al., 2017), Porto, Portugal (Herva, Neto and Roca,
2014), Naples, Italy (Hornsby et al., 2017).
However, limited amount of publications can be found in the literature that discuss the issue of
municipal waste management in Greece, despite the fact that Waste Framework Directive is poorly
implemented, with the country being penalized by the European Court of Justice since 2005. Trends
and patterns of solid waste generation and waste composition (Papachristou et al., 2009), challenges
of waste management (Erkut et al., 2008), dynamics, comparison and evaluation of waste policies
and treatment methods (Koroneos and Nanaki, 2012; Karagiannidis et al., 2013; Minoglou and
Komilis, 2013; Koufodimos and Samaras, 2002) have been reviewed for the city of Thessaloniki.
Nevertheless, most of the previous studies do not take into account the revised Regional Waste
Management Plan (RWMP) for the Region of Central Macedonia (RCM).
On this basis, the development of an optimal waste management strategy is more than urgent in the
area. The current study focuses on the environmental impacts caused by the existing waste
management system in the RCM and the comparison of alternative scenarios regarding MSW
management in the RCM. LCA is adopted to benchmark the alternative practices on the basis of
specific environmental indicators that were considered important for the environment and human
health.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Municipal solid waste management in the Region of Central Macedonia
Greece consists of 13 administrative regions, which are further subdivided into 54 prefectures. This
paper is focused on the management of municipal waste in the RCM, which is located in North Greece
and consists of the central part of the geographical region of Macedonia. The region has the largest
surface area (18.811km2) among all regions, and it is divided into seven prefectures: Thessaloniki,
Imathia, Pella, Kilkis, Pieria, Serres and Chalkidiki. Additionally, it is the second most populous
region after Attica, with intense urbanization and a high density of inhabitation, especially in
Thessaloniki and its metropolitan area, which is the capital of the region.
In the Region of Central Macedonia 842.490 tons/year of waste generated in 2014, according to upto-date Regional Waste Management Plan (RWMP) (RWMP,2016), from which 82% ended up to
Sanitary Landfills. In general, the composition of MSW depends on the socioeconomic conditions
and the various consumption patterns in the RCM. However, within the context of this study, a typical
average composition of the waste is used, in accordance with the data available in RWMP (Batsioula,
2018). The fractions of MSW included in the study are: (i) total amount of household organics, (ii)
paper, (iii) plastic, (iv) metals, (v) glass, (vi) wood, (vii) other recoverable such as batteries and
household appliances, as well as other unclassified materials including also hazardous waste like
textiles, inks, medicine. The composition of total municipal waste in the RCM is illustrated in Figure
1.
Municipal Solid Waste
4%
4%
2%
5%
Organics
Paper
5%
Plastic
44%
14%
Metal
Glass
Wood
22%
Other Recoverables
Others
Figure 1: Typical composition of total MSW in Region of Central Macedonia (RWMP, 2016).
374
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
According to the RWMP, except for sorting at the source of packaging waste and some other streams
such as batteries and Waste Electrical & Electronic Equipment (WEEE), all municipal waste of the
RCM is disposed to landfills. More specifically, 82% of MSW are disposed directly to landfills,
whereas only 12% are sorted at the source. RCM still has not implemented a MSW system which
includes advanced waste treatment methods. RCM’s waste management policy involves mainly the
collection and disposal of waste in the landfill. The current situation in the prefectures of the region
is such that initially, municipal waste, that are temporarily storaged into bins or containers, are
collected by a public company using waste collection vehicles and then transported in Waste Transfer
Stations (WTSs). At the same time, waste streams such as paper, glass and packaging waste, are
separately collected in special bins and collection vehicles transport them in Material Recycling
Facilities (MRFs) (RWMP, 2016).
With respect to bio-waste, no separate collection program is implemented in the RCM, with the
exception of diversion in rural areas for the purpose of animal feeding and on-site composting, as
well as pilot composting programs and programs for the collection of cooking oil and grease waste
in some schools of the region, that send it in a recycling company which converts it into an alternative
fuel, biodiesel. Also, WEEE in almost all municipalities, are collected by private companies and led
to processing plants. Moreover, bulky waste is collected by the Municipalities' Cleanup Department.
In the majority of the municipalities of RCM, after the collection, it is sent mainly direct or after
shredding disposal in landfills or dispatch to private companies. Similarly, management of garden
waste includes segregation and disposal in landfills, since in most of the municipalities of RCM there
is not organized system for collection and management of green waste (RWMP, 2016).
2.2 LCA method
The goal of this study is to analyze and compare different MSW management strategies that can be
implemented in the RCM from an environmental point of view. Therefore, different treatment
methods were investigated and alternative MSW management systems were compared (Batsioula,
2018). More specifically, three (3) alternative scenarios have been compared regarding the
management of MSW generated in the RCM. Each scenarios consists of the storage and collection of
MSW in bins, both mixed bins and those for separately sorting of recyclable fractions at the source,
the gathering of municipal waste and their transport by collection vehicles to the WTS. Besides that,
the alternatives include the main treatment available in each scenario such as the mechanical
separation of the waste, recycling or composting, and the final disposal of the residues of those
processes in a landfill site. The LCA methodology was used in order to choose the optimal MSW
management system. The application of LCA was carried out with the use of SimaPro software, which
enables the evaluation of environmental impacts for all alternatives for the waste management by
using specific environmental impact indicators that will be further analyzed in the following sections.
Within the framework of this study, the functional unit is defined equal to the reference flow. More
specifically, this is the whole amount of municipal solid waste generated in the RCM over a period
of one year (842.490 ton). The choice to use the entire amount of waste produced as a functional unit
may limit the ability to draw general conclusions for regions and municipalities. However, it was
considered more relevant than to select a standard unit like 1 ton of waste, since the current study
attempts to define the situation as it is in the RCM.
The system under study is defined as an integrated waste management system for 842.490 tons of
MW. Its boundaries involve the final stage of the life cycle of the waste generated in the RCM. More
specifically, the system boundaries include all processes from the moment the waste is collected until
it leaves the system either as an emission or as a secondary raw material, biogas or energy (Figure 2).
MW enters the system after been discarded either as mixed waste or as source-segregated streams
which are separately collected. The system covers waste collection from bins, transport, mechanical
separation, when is available, recycling or other waste treatment, and finally disposal in a landfill.
Also, within the system boundaries, besides the main treatment of MSW, the required fuels for the
375
Solid waste management
transport, as well as energy for both the operation and construction of all required facilities are
included.
Figure 2: Schematic Flowchart of System’s Boundaries (Batsioula, 2018).
2.3 Scenarios description
With the intention to examine and outline the benefits and drawbacks of the techniques used on
municipal solid waste management, diverse MSW strategies have been analyzed. The differentiation
of the proposed strategies is based on the variations of the waste flows in comparison to the different
waste control methods, such as landfill, recycling, composting and others. With the core of
conventional waste treatment methods and the final disposal in landfills, the different proposed
strategies focuse on reuse and recycling most of MSW, as well as on energy recovery are following:
Scenario 0: the main treatment of this scenario is landfilling without energy recovery,
Scenario I: the main treatment of this scenario is landfill with energy recovery, and except for
landfilling includes small percentages of recycling of some MSW fractions,
Scenario II: the main waste treatment of this scenario is recycling and material recovery, thus it
incorporates the future targets that must be completed according to the European Directive.
Scenario 0: represents the most common until recently waste treatment method in Greece, landfilling.
It assumes that the all the municipal waste generated is collected and transferred to WTS. Then,
without a process of separation of the produced waste, MSW are disposed to regional landfill sites,
where they are disposed without energy recovery to take place (Figure 3).
Figure 3: Mass balance flow chart for Scenario 0 in the RCM (Batsioula, 2018).
Scenario I: models the basic scenario that corresponds to the present situation in the RCM. Figure 4
illustrates the flowchart of Scenario I. 694.873 tons (82%) of municipal waste are sent to landfills,
whereas only 147.617 tons (18%) of waste are separated collected as shown in Table 1. According to
RWMP and the existing recycling facilities, recyclable waste fractions in the amount of 103.213 tons
(12% of the total waste amount) are recycled, around 5% of the waste sorted at the source are
composted at home facilities, and 1% is sent for reuse.
376
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 4: Mass balance flow chart for Scenario I in the RCM (Batsioula, 2018).
Table 1: Current waste management system in RCM (Scenario I) (RWMP, 2016).
MSW Fraction
Organics
Paper
Plastic
Metal
Glass
Wood
Other recoverables
Others
Total MSW
Total amount
generated
373.224
187.033
117.107
32.857
36.227
38.753
13.480
43.809
842.490
Mixed collection
(tons / % of the total)
338.481
91%
Sorting at the source
(tons / % of the total)
34.743
9%
270.011
72%
103.213
28%
36.760
5.811
43.809
694.872
95%
43%
100%
82%
1.993
7.669
0
147.618
5%
57%
0%
18%
Scenario II: describes the future waste management plan for 2020 as it is defined by the reviewed
RWMP. This scenario emphasizes on reuse and recycling of all fractions of waste generated in RCM,
while minimizing the amounts of waste that are sent directly to landfill sites. Particularly, according
to the RWMP, 74% of the total municipal waste must be recovered whereas only 26% of the aggregate
MSW quantities should be disposed in the regional landfill sites (Table 2). Figure 5 illustrates the
flowchart of Scenario II.
Table 2: Future waste management system in the RCM (Scenario II) (RWMP, 2016).
MSW Fraction
Organics
Paper
Plastic
Metal
Glass
Wood
Other
recoverables
Others
Total MSW
MSW
generated
Sorting at source
(tons / % of the total)
Mixed collection
Recovery at WTP
Landfilling
(tons / % of the total)
(tons / % of the total)
373.224
187.033
117.107
32.857
36.227
38.753
149.290
110.323
79.617
25.293
27.362
19.377
40%
59%
68%
77%
76%
50%
149.290
18.729
11.727
4.935
1.983
11.626
40%
10%
10%
15%
5%
30%
74.644
57.981
25.763
2.629
6.883
7.751
20%
31%
22%
8%
19%
20%
13.480
9.436
70%
674
5%
3.370
25%
43.809
842.490
0
420.698
0%
50%
0
198.964
0%
24%
43.809
222.830
100%
26%
377
Solid waste management
Figure 5: Mass balance flow chart for Scenario II in the RCM (Batsioula, 2018).
2.4 Life cycle inventory
In the LCA, an inventory was created for the proposed alternative scenarios. The selected inventory
was based on those available in the Ecoinvent database v2.2. Due to the complexity that an integrated
MSW management system has, several reasonable assumptions are required in order to simplify
complex calculations and overcome the problem of lack of data, so as to comply with the requirements
of the SimaPro software and result in a proper comparison between the different scenarios. The
summary of the main assumptions, as well as the major data used in the modeling of the alternatives
are the following:
In order to export valid results, and given the lack of information regarding the management
practices, waste treatment techniques included in the SimaPro software was performed.
The collection type is assumed curb collection and consists of the gathering of municipal waste
in bins from various locations in the municipalities of the RCM. Besides that, closed-body
vehicles also are considered as part of the collection system. The type of the collection vehicles
that is assumed to be used is “Transport, municipal waste collection, lorry 21t”, as appeared in
Ecoinvent database. Nevertheless, only the environmental impacts from waste transportation with
collection vehicles and not those of raw material and manufacture of bins are taken into
consideration.
Due to software restrictions, the environmental impacts of the energy (biogas collection, as well
as electricity generation and consumption during the operation phase for mechanical separation
and energy recovery when is available) are not taken into consideration. Similarly, the
construction of new facilities, in Scenario II, is not taken into consideration as well.
Since the quantities of WEEE that are separately collected and sent for reuse are small (< 1% of
the total MSW generated), and due to lack of information regarding their treatment, it is assumed
that WEEE amounts are sent for recycling.
Transport to the various waste management facilities was entered on the software according to
the following assumptions. Initially, the required total distance for waste collection is comprised
of the distance between the capital city of each prefecture and the final management point. Also,
the distance calculations are made on the basis of the assumption that empty-collection vehicles
returns are also included. Besides that, regarding the new waste facilities that are established in
Scenario II, the required distance for transportation are calculated based on data provided by
RWMP.
2.5 Life cycle assessment
Life Cycle Assessment data was mainly compiled from the SimaPro (Ecoinvent) databases, from the
bibliography, as well as from the inventory of current waste management system in RCM as described
378
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
in the latest RWMP. For the Life Cycle Impact Assessment, which based on the outcomes of the
inventory, both Eco-indicator 99 and CML 2001 methods were utilized.
According to CML 2001 Method, the emissions from the alternative scenarios studied are classified
to the following impact categories: Abiotic Depletion Potential (ADP, kg Sb eq), Global Warming
Potential (GWP, kg CO2 eq), Human Toxicity Potential (HTP, kg 1,4-DCB eq), Acidification
Potential (AP, kg SO2 eq), Eutrophication Potential (EP, kg PO4 eq), Ozone Layer Depletion Potential
(OLD, kg CFC-11 eq), Photochemical Ozone Creation Potential (POCP, kg C2H4). On the other side,
Eco-indicator 99 is a damage-oriented method which classifies the various impact categories and the
damages caused into three damage categories: Damage to Human Health, Damage Ecosystem Quality
and Damage to Resources.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The environmental burdens of each practice were calculated with both selected Methods (CML 2001,
Eco-indicator 99) and graphically, presented in Figures 6 and 7 respectively. Taking into
consideration CML 2001 methodology’s results from Figure 6, it is obvious that an integrated waste
management system can minimize significantly the environmental impacts caused by municipal
waste generated. Application of sustainable practices and treatment methods such as sorting at the
source, recycling and composting lead to the reduction of waste disposal.
In accordance to the results of life cycle impact assessment, Scenario 0, and its main waste treatment
method, landfilling, results the worst performance for all the indicators analyzed. This high level of
environmental burdens in all of the impact categories, compared with the other management systems,
is due to the lack of reuse and the disposal of all waste generated in sanitary landfills. Besides that,
findings show that the Scenario II contributes to savings in many impact indicators. The replacement
of primary products with products which come from the waste treatment recompenses the impacts
caused by the actual process of the treatment, thus Scenario II which corporate high rates of recycling
and composting is advantageous to most of the impact categories.
However, the status in cases of global warming and eutrophication indicators is different. Global
warming potential has positive values for all Scenarios. Scenario 0 has the higher contribution for
global warming because of the very low level of separate collection. As a result, all waste sent to
landfills and many CO2 and CH4 emissions are released. On the other hand, Scenarios I and II results
positive values for GWP100 indicator, which are associated with the CO2 and CH4 emissions emitted
in the landfill and are not captured by the landfill gas control system. Moreover, all alternatives have
positive sign of Eutrophication indicator, as they are leachable from landfill, although they are treated
in wastewater facilities, releasing NO3- and NH3. Thus, in all three alternative management systems,
those emissions represent the biggest contribution to eutrophication. Even in Scenario II, which has
generally the most beneficial performance, this indicator shows positive value.
Comparing the three scenarios | Method: CML 2001 V2.05 / World, 1995 / Characterization
150%
100%
50%
Scenario 0
0%
Scenario I
Scenario II
-50%
-100%
-150%
ADP
AP
EP
GWP
OLD
HTP
POCP
Figure 6: Comparison of the proposed scenarios for the seven categories of impact (CML
2001).
379
Solid waste management
With respect to the results from Eco-indicator 99 methodology is concerned, from the single score
that is illustrated in Figure 7 - It is clear that Scenario 0 is the worst waste management system that
can be implemented in the RCM. Its environmental burden is significant, according to both
methodologies used. Similarly with CML 2001, results for Eco-indicator 99 methodology indicates
that the main impacts caused by landfilling treatment process and the huge amount of waste that is
disposed (Scenarios 0 and I). Furthermore, the environmental benefits that derive from the
replacement of primary products with recycled ones are significant (Scenario II). As Figure 7
illustrates, savings of the resources are more advantageous when high rates of sorting collection,
recycling and composting are implemented.
Comparison of the three scenarios | Method: Eco-indicator 99 (H) V2.08 / Europe EI 99 H/H / Single score
3.00E+07
Single score (Pt)
2.00E+07
Human Health
1.00E+07
Ecosystem quality
0.00E+00
Resourses
-1.00E+07
-2.00E+07
-3.00E+07
Sceario 0
Scenario I
Scenario II
Figure 7: Comparison of the proposed scenarios (Single score of Eco-indicator 99
methodology).
Overall, taking into consideration the final results of the two methods (Table 3, Figure 8), it becomes
clear that Scenario II is the best waste management practice, due to high environmental benefits
derived from the recycling of waste streams, as well as the small environmental burden from waste
disposal, because of the comparatively less amounts of waste sent to landfill sites. On the other hand,
landfilling of municipal waste, as it has already be mentioned in the literature, is thought to be the
worst method from the treatment of waste generated. That is because of the significant impacts this
process has both to the environment and human health. As a final consideration on the results, the
uncertainty of such studies is a significant factor that should be taken under consideration. However,
due to lack of time, the analysis of uncertainty does not included in the scope of this study, and thus
will not be presented.
Table 3: Final normalized results of CML 2001 and Eco-indicator 99 methodologies.
Scenario 0
Scenario I
Scenario II
Scenario 0
Scenario I
Scenario II
ADP
1,72E-06
-3,4E-06
-1,6E-05
AP
9,83E-07
-5,3E-07
-4,6E-06
Human Health
8,63E+04
6,53E+04
-3,95E+02
CML 2001
EP
GWP100
ODP
1,67E-05
9,96E-06
1,21E-08
1,39E-05
7,32E-06
5,27E-09
3,2E-06
7,43E-07
-1,5E-08
Eco-indicator 99
Ecosystem Quality
2,02E+04
1,52E+04
3,79E+03
380
HTP
6,01E-06
1,69E-06
-8,6E-06
POCP
1,24E-06
8,22E-07
-2,2E-07
Resources
1,03E+04
-1,45E+04
-7,51E+04
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 8: Network chart flow for: (a) Scenario 0, (b) Scenario I and (c) Scenario II, which
refers to single score as resulted from Eco-indicator 99 method.
4.
CONCLUSION
The aim of this study was the development and application of a life cycle methodological framework
in order to compare the different management practices and select the optimal and most sustainable
integrated waste management system from an environmental point of view. According to all
indicators examined, waste management practices that involve either wholly or partial disposal in
landfill sites have the worst performance. The parameters that contribute to these negative results are
the large quantities of untreated municipal waste that are disposed in landfill and the low rates of
landfill gas collection. It should be highlighted that the alternative management practice of municipal
waste, which combines the recycling of metals, glass, plastics and paper, with the composting of
organic fractions of MSW after the separately collection at source, is the best solution. And that is
because, in this scenario the rate of untreated waste which is sent to landfill sites is significantly low,
and at the same time the material recovery offers many environmental benefits. However, it should
not be forgotten that alternative waste treatment methods such as recycling do have negative
environmental impacts, and these loads do not overshadow the environmental benefits of material
recovery.
Taking into consideration the results of the LCA analysis, it has been found that the implementation
of an integrated waste management system is important to the sustainable management of municipal
waste. Nevertheless, this system may not be effective if there is no efficient sorting of waste streams
at the source. Overall, a significant percentage of municipal waste can be treated in various ways,
recycled or reused before disposed in a landfill site, thus minimizing environmental impacts of the
continuously expanding amounts of waste produced nowadays.
References
1. Andreasi Bassi, S., Christensen, T. and Damgaard, A. (2017). Environmental performance of
household waste management in Europe - An example of 7 countries. Waste Management, 69,
545-557.
2. Batsioula M. (2018). Environmental impact assessment of municipal solid waste management.
Master dissertation. International Hellenic University, School of Economics and Business
Administration.
3. Cherubini, F., Bargigli, S. and Ulgiati, S. (2009). Life cycle assessment (LCA) of waste
management strategies: Landfilling, sorting plant and incineration. Energy, 34(12), 2116-2123.
4. Council Directive 1999/31/EC of 26 April 1999 on the landfill of waste, Official Journal of the
European Union, L 182, 1–19.
5. Directive 2008/98/EC on waste and repealing certain Directives, Official Journal of the
European Union, L 312, 22.11.2008, p. 3–30.
381
Solid waste management
6. Erkut, E., Karagiannidis, A., Perkoulidis, G. and Tjandra, S. (2008). A multicriteria facility
location model for municipal solid waste management in North Greece. European Journal of
Operational Research, 187(3), 1402-1421.
7. Gentil, E., Clavreul, J. and Christensen, T. (2009). Global warming factor of municipal solid
waste management in Europe. Waste Management & Research, 27(9), 850-860.
8. Herva, M., Neto, B. and Roca, E. (2014). Environmental assessment of the integrated municipal
solid waste management system in Porto. Journal of Cleaner Production, 70, 183-193.
9. Hornsby, C., Ripa, M., Vassillo, C. and Ulgiati, S. (2017). A roadmap towards integrated
assessment and participatory strategies in support of decision-making processes. The case of
urban waste management. Journal of Cleaner Production, 142, 157-172.
10. Karagiannidis, A., Kontogianni, S. and Logothetis, D. (2013). Classification and categorization
of treatment methods for ash generated by municipal solid waste incineration: A case for the 2
greater metropolitan regions of Greece. Waste Management, 33(2), 363-372.
11. Koroneos, C. and Nanaki, E. (2012). Integrated solid waste management and energy production
- a life cycle assessment approach: the case study of the city of Thessaloniki. Journal of Cleaner
Production, 27, 141-150.
12. Koufodimos, G. and Samaras, Z. (2002). Waste management options in southern Europe using
field and experimental data. Waste Management, 22(1), 47-59.
13. Milutinović, B., Stefanović, G., Đekić, P., Mijailović, I. and Tomić, M. (2017). Environmental
assessment of waste management scenarios with energy recovery using life cycle assessment and
multi-criteria analysis. Energy, 137, 917-926.
14. Minoglou, M. and Komilis, D. (2013). Optimizing the treatment and disposal of municipal solid
wastes using mathematical programming - A case study in a Greek region. Resources,
Conservation and Recycling, 80, 46-57.
15. Papachristou, E., Hadjianghelou, H., Darakas, E., Alivanis, K., Belou, A., Ioannidou, D.,
Paraskevopoulou, E., Poulios, K., Koukourikou, A., Kosmidou, N. and Sortikos, K. (2009).
Perspectives for integrated municipal solid waste management in Thessaloniki, Greece. Waste
Management, 29 (3), 1158-1162.
16. Regional Waste Management Plan (RWMP) of Central Macedonia (2016). Solid Waste
Management Association of Central Macedonia (FODSA), Thessaloniki, url:
https://fodsakm.gr/site/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/PESDA_KM-1.pdf (In Greek)
17. Rigamonti, L., Falbo, A. and Grosso, M. (2013). Improving integrated waste management at the
regional level: The case of Lombardia. Waste Management & Research, 31(9), 946-953.
382
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
INNOVATIVE BIOGEOCHEMICAL SOIL COVER TO MITIGATE
LANDFILL GAS EMISSIONS
K. R. Reddy1,*, D.G. Grubb2 and G. Kumar1
1
University of Illinois at Chicago, Department of Civil & Materials Engineering, 842 West Taylor
Street, Chicago, IL 60607, USA 2Phoenix Services, LLC, 148 West State Street, Suite 301, Kennett
Square, PA 19348, USA
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: kreddy@uic.edu, tel : +13129964755
Abstract
The municipal solid waste (MSW) in landfills undergoes anaerobic decomposition to produce landfill
gas (LFG), which predominantly consists of methane (CH4) and carbon dioxide (CO2). Fugitive LFG
emissions which are otherwise not targeted by gas collection system escape into the atmosphere,
forming one of the largest anthropogenic sources of CH4 and CO2 emissions in the United States. The
landfill cover soil plays an important role in mitigating the LFG emissions by microbial oxidation of
CH4 to CO2 thereby reducing the CH4 emissions to atmosphere. Several researchers have investigated
the addition of organic amendments to the cover soils in order to enhance microbial oxidation of CH4
in landfill covers. In recent years, biochar as an organic amendment has shown promise in enhanced
microbial oxidation due to its inert/stable chemical nature to degradation, high surface area, high
internal porosity, and high moisture holding capacity. However, in all these efforts there is no regard
given to the CO2 that still escapes into the atmosphere in undesirable amounts. Steel slag, a product
from steel making industry, due to its high alkaline buffering capacity, high carbonation potential,
and its unique cementitious properties has found numerous applications in civil and environmental
engineering. But, until now there has been no study on the potential use of steel slag in landfill covers
to sequester the CO2 emissions. Ongoing research study, funded by the U.S. National Science
Foundation, explores the use of BOF steel slag in conjunction with biochar amended cover soil so as
to first convert CH4 to CO2 by microbial oxidation and thereafter sequester the resulting CO2 from
CH4 oxidation and the prevailing CO2 from anaerobic decomposition together by steel slag, thereby
significantly mitigating the LFG emissions from landfills. In this paper, a review on the current
applications and carbon sequestration mechanisms of BOF steel slag is presented. Finally, the
proposed concept of the biogeochemical soil cover for mitigation of LFG emissions and some of the
results from a preliminary investigation indicating the CO2 sequestration potential by steel slag are
discussed.
Keywords: MSW landfills, landfill cover; landfill gas; bio-geochemistry; BOF steel slag; biochar;
carbonation
1.
INTRODUCTION
The global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions including the methane (CH4) and carbon dioxide (CO2)
have been rapidly increasing due to population growth and the corresponding energy and resource
consumption across the globe. This has contributed significantly to global climate change. Although
landfilling of waste is considered an unsustainable option, it still remains the primary waste
management technique in the US and many other countries. According to United States
Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) out of the 258 million metric tons of MSW generated in
2014, about 136 million metric tons of MSW was landfilled (USEPA 2016). The MSW placed in
383
Solid waste management
landfills undergoes anaerobic decomposition producing the landfill gas (LFG) which predominantly
consists of CH4 and CO2. MSW landfills are regarded one of the largest anthropogenic sources of
CH4 and CO2 emissions into the atmosphere in U.S. In this regard, the U.S. regulations mandate the
installation of active gas extraction systems to substantially minimize the emission of LFG and other
non-methane organic compounds into the atmosphere. However, fugitive emissions persist as they
are otherwise not targeted by the gas extraction systems.
Several researchers have demonstrated the limited oxidation of CH4 into CO2 in the soil naturally due
to methanotrophic bacteria in the landfill cover soils (Whalen et al. 1990; Hilger et al. 2000). In order
to enhance the microbial oxidation of CH4 in landfill cover, biocovers were introduced that involved
amending the cover soil with organic material to promote the microbial growth. Several organic
amendments such as compost, manure, biosolids, and digested sludge which could be used to enhance
microbial activity, had several limitations. Compost or sewage sludge, if it is not substantially
degraded, can undergo anaerobic decomposition producing CH4 and CO2 itself, thus exacerbating
emissions.
Recent lab-scale investigations and field pilot tests have demonstrated that biochar shows good
performance as an organic amendment for enhanced microbial oxidation of CH4 in landfill covers
(Yargicoglu and Reddy, 2017a, b, 2018). Biochar is a solid byproduct derived from gasification or
pyrolysis of biomass under anoxic or low oxygen conditions (Reddy et al., 2014). Biochar with its
high porosity and large specific surface provides favorable environment for the methanotrophs to
proliferate and thrive in the cover soil thereby facilitating the CH4 oxidation (Yargicoglu et al., 2015).
Although the biochar-amended soil cover system mitigates the CH4 emissions into the atmosphere, it
can only oxidize CH4 into CO2, leading to continued emission of CO2 into the atmosphere in
undesirable amounts. Hence, it is desirable to develop a cover system that can minimize both the CH4
and CO2 emissions into the atmosphere.
Mineral sequestration of CO2 by carbonation using steel slag is proposed to be an effective approach
to substantially alleviate CO2 emissions into the atmosphere (Huijgen et al., 2005, 2006). Steel slag
is a product generated during the steel making process. There are several studies in the literature that
have investigated the potential use of steel slag for CO2 sequestration. Most of the studies focused on
CO2 sequestration for slag pre-treatment (for pH reduction) in civil engineering applications such as
its use as aggregates in concrete, base layer in roadways and pavements, railroad ballasts thereby
preserving the virgin materials. There are a few studies that investigated the utilization of steel slag
in landfill covers as hydraulic barrier material. However, there has been no study on the use of steel
slag in landfill cover systems specifically for CO2 sequestration. This paper discusses steel slag and
its unique characteristics that aid in CO2 sequestration. Thereafter, the geochemistry of mineral
sequestration of CO2 by carbonation is presented. A review of typical applications of steel slag
leveraging the process of carbonation is also presented. Finally, the paper proposes the concept of
zero emission from landfills to investigate the use of biochar and steel slag amendments to soil in the
landfill cover system to sequentially mitigate both CH4 and CO2 emissions from landfills.
2.
STEEL SLAG
Steel is one of the most used materials on earth. The global annual steel production in the year 2016
reached 1.63 billion metric tons and 78.5 million metric tons of which was produced in U.S. (World
Steel Association, 2017). Steel slag is a product obtained from the iron and steel making process. It
originates as a molten liquid melt while impurities are being separated from molten steel and is a
complex solution of silicates and oxides that solidifies upon cooling. The amount of steel slag
produced depends on both the feed and the type of furnace used, but typically 0.2 ton of steel slag is
produced per ton of steel. The steel making industries in U.S. generate approximately 10-15 million
tons of steel slag every year (Yildirim and Prezzi, 2011).
There are three principal types of slag based on the type of furnace used for steel production namely,
(i) Basic Oxygen Furnace (BOF) Slag, (ii) Electric Arc Furnace (EAF) Slag, and (iii) Ladle Furnace
384
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
(LF) Slag. A detailed explanation of the production process in each of the furnaces and the typical
chemical composition of different slag types can be found in Shi (2004), Pan et al. (2016) and
National Slag Association, (2013). The composition of furnace charges, grades of steel produced, rate
of slag cooling and furnace operating practices also influence the composition and properties of steel
slag. The typical composition of steel slag mainly comprises of calcium silicates, calcium
aluminoferrites, and fused oxides of calcium, iron, magnesium, manganese and trace heavy metals.
There also exists approximately 10 to 15% free lime in steel slag based on the operating conditions
employed for steel making and the steel making process. The pH of the fresh steel slag is usually
similar to lime products or up to 12.5.
The steel slag generated at the steel plants is initially stockpiled at the plant and eventually sent to
slag disposal sites, if there is no use or market for it. In this regard, several researchers have studied
the use of steel slag in order to reduce its disposal in landfills and also preserve the natural resources.
Steel slag exhibits some unique characteristics that make it suitable for its use in many civil and
environmental applications. Moist or wet steel slag has a high affinity for atmospheric CO2. The lime,
Portlandite and several Ca silicates in steel slag undergo dissolution in the presence of moisture to
react with CO2 and precipitate as carbonates. This results in increased physical stability, strength and
compressibility characteristics due to the binding nature of the carbonate precipitates. A detailed
explanation on the carbonation mechanisms and some of the important factors influencing the process
is discussed in the following section.
3.
CARBONATION IN STEEL SLAG
The fundamental mechanism behind the carbonation of steel slag is to allow for the reaction between
cations (Ca2+, Mg2+) in the presence of moisture and CO2 to form thermodynamically stable and
insoluble carbonates. BOF steel slags are ideal minerals for carbon sequestration as they are low-cost,
with high CaO content (Pan et al. 2016). Various studies have demonstrated that the accelerated
carbonation of steel slag is an effective technique to stabilize the alkaline mineral while
simultaneously fixing the CO2 (Pan et al. 2016; Olajire 2013).
Carbonation of alkaline solid wastes (e.g. steel slag) may occur in two ways: (a) direct carbonation
(one step process), and (b) indirect carbonation (two or more step process). Moreover, the direct
carbonation could be classified as dry or aqueous based on the liquid-to-solid ratio. The direct reaction
of gaseous CO2 with solid mineral or alkaline waste is the most straight forward mineral carbonation
route. However, the reaction rate of dry carbonation is very slow and carbonate conversion is low.
The dry carbonation of Ca silicate minerals can be generalized as in Eq. 1.
Ca-silicate(s) + CO2(g) CaCO3(s) + SiO2(s)
(1)
Aqueous carbonation is faster and results in higher carbonate formation than dry carbonation. Direct
aqueous carbonation involves three coexistent mechanisms based on the minerals available. First,
dissolution of lime and portlandite takes place to readily produce Ca2+ ions as shown in Eq. 2 and 3.
Then, carbon dioxide dissolves in water resulting in an acidic environment and CO32- ions species as
shown in Eq. 4.
CaO+H2O Ca(OH)2
(2)
Ca(OH)2 Ca+ + 2OH-
(3)
CO2(g) + H2O(l) H2CO3(aq) 2H+(aq) + CO32-(aq)
(4)
Ca2+ leaches from the mineral matrix (larnite), facilitated by the protons present as shown in Eq. 5.
(Ca)-silicates(s) + 2H+(aq) Ca2+(aq) + SiO2(s) +H2O(l)
385
(5)
Solid waste management
Finally, calcium carbonate precipitates as shown in Eq. 6
(Ca)-silicates(s) + CO32-(aq) CaCO3(s)
(6)
Hence, the fundamental mechanism of direct carbonation reaction in steel slag involves (1) the
leaching of alkaline mineral metal from the mineral matrix (predominantly Ca), (2) dissolution of
gaseous CO2 into aqueous phase followed by conversion of carbonic acid to carbonate ions, and (3)
consequent precipitation of stable carbonates from Ca silicates (Pan et al. 2016). A schematic of the
direct carbonation is shown in Fig. 1.
Steel Slag
(Alkaline mineral)
Direct Carbonation
(One Step)
Cemented
Material
Carbonates
Carbonation
Figure 1: Direct Carbonation
Indirect carbonation is the process where reactive alkaline earth metal is first extracted from the steel
slag using chemical extractants (e.g. acetic acid) and subsequently carbonated which is given by the
chemical reactions in equations 7 and 8 below. This method is usually employed in commercial
manufacturing of carbonates.
CaSiO3(s) + 2 CH3COOH(aq) Ca2+(aq) + 2 CH3COO- (aq) + SiO2(s) + H2O (aq)
(7)
Ca2+(aq) + 2 CH3COO-(aq) + CO2 (g) + H2O (aq) CaCO3 (s) + 2 CH3COOH (aq)
(8)
The mechanism of carbonation in steel slag can vary based on the composition of steel slag. A detailed
explanation on each of the carbonation approaches is presented by Pan et al. (2016) and Olajire
(2013). In this study, the concept that is of relevance is the direct carbonation of steel slag to realize
CO2 sequestration by forming stable and insoluble carbonates. The various advantages/benefits of
carbonation of steel slag and its application in civil and environmental engineering is discussed briefly
in the following section.
4.
BENEFICIAL USES AND APPLICATIONS OF STEEL SLAG
BOF steel slag has been predominantly used as a construction material in asphalt paving, unpaved
roads, agricultural lime, acid mine drainage remediation, manufacture of cement all of which can be
ascribed towards its enhanced mechanical and pozzolanic properties resulting from carbonation. In
addition to its use as a construction material, several researchers assessed the use of steel slag for
environmental remediation applications, especially phosphorous removal (e.g., Drizo et al., 2006).
BOF steel slag has been used as base and subbase layers in pavements in addition to its use as coarse
aggregates in surface layers of pavements, mainly due to its high strength, high binding capacity with
386
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
high abrasion and high frictional resistance. Due to their high density, strength, rough texture and
durability, they can be processed as high-quality aggregates, comparable with natural aggregates.
Relevant to this study is the work of Herrmann et al. (2010), who investigated the potential use of
EAF slag and Ladle slag (LS) as a barrier material in landfill cover. Surprisingly, these slags
possessed very low hydraulic conductivity. Field investigation using ten lysimeters confirmed that
the leachate collected at the base of the cover is well below the regulatory criterion and can potentially
be used as a barrier material in landfill covers.
Diener et al. (2010) studied the stability of steel slag (mixture of EAF and LS) by performing long
term laboratory tests to understand the leaching behavior, acid neutralization capacity and mineralogy
of steel slag using multivariate data analysis. The researchers investigated the effect of CO2 content
in the atmosphere, relative humidity, aging time, temperature and water quality on the accelerated
aging in steel slag. It was observed that the aging time and the CO2 content in the atmosphere were
the prime factors that had a significant effect on long term stability of steel slag. Mineralogical
changes during the aging process showed the formation of calcite which was confirmed using XRD.
A review on several other applications of steel slag can be found in Pan et al. (2016), Olajire (2013)
and Yi et al. (2012).
In all of the literature on applications of steel slag, it has been used as a construction material or as a
hydraulic barrier material in the final cover in landfills. However, to date, there has been no study on
the use of steel slag for the sequestration of CO2 emissions from the MSW landfills. This study
proposes to utilize the carbonation and other mechanisms associated with CO2 sequestration in steel
slag and thereby mitigate the CO2 emissions released into the atmosphere from the landfills. A new
concept of “Zero Emissions Cover System” is proposed as detailed in the following section.
5.
BIOGEOCHEMICAL SOIL COVER SYSTEM
There are several studies in the literature that have looked at the potential use of steel slag in carbon
sequestration using the carbonation process. However, there has been no investigation on the use of
steel slag as a cover soil amendment in landfills to sequester CO2 emissions. A new research project
funded by the U.S. National Science Foundation is currently in progress to fully explore the
fundamentals and practical aspects of an innovative, low-cost landfill cover system consisting of steel
slag in combination with biochar which can mitigate the CH4 and CO2 emissions from MSW landfills.
In a previous investigation at UIC, biochar-amended soil cover was conceived and developed as an
effective sustainable biocover for CH4 oxidation. A systematic and comprehensive study was
performed involving material characterization, batch tests, and lab-scale column experiments to
investigate the adsorption and transport mechanisms associated with biochar amended cover soil
systems. Microbial characterization was also performed to identify the specific methanotrophs that
were involved in CH4 oxidation. A full-scale field demonstration was also implemented to evaluate
the performance of biochar-amended soil cover at a landfill exposed to variable environmental
conditions. This research work advanced the knowledge on the fundamental processes and system
variables responsible for enhancing the methanotrophic activity by providing a favorable
environment for the methanotrophs to proliferate and thrive in the cover system. Unfortunately, such
a biocover system can only microbially oxidize CH4 into CO2, leading to continued emission of CO2
into the atmosphere.
It is essential to develop a cover system that can minimize both the CH4 and CO2 emissions into the
atmosphere. It is hypothesized herein that biochar and steel slag amended soil cover systems can
eliminate both CH4 and CO2 emissions via biochar-aided methanotrophic oxidation of CH4 into CO2
and subsequent or simultaneous slag-aided carbonation/sequestration of all of CO2, thus ideally
eliminating the LFG emissions from the landfills. This concept of “Zero Emissions Cover” is a
transformative approach to substantially mitigate, if not eliminate, the carbon footprint associated
with LFG emissions. The concept of biochar and steel slag amended soil cover system to achieve
zero emissions is shown schematically in Fig.2. As shown in Fig.2, the proposed biogeochemical
387
Solid waste management
cover system also has the potential to mitigate hydrogen sulfide (H2S) if present in the landfill gas,
due to co-disposal of construction and demolition (C&D) waste with MSW.
- Mineral dissolution
- Elevated pH
- CO2 absorption
- H2S absorption
- Carbonation reaction
- Gypsum reaction
- Methanotrophic action
- CH4 oxidation
- Increase of CO2
- Free-phase for the gases
- No reactions
- CO2 (~50%) &CH4(~50%)
- H2S (~3% if present)
Figure 2: Concept of Biochar Steel Slag amended Soil Cover System for Zero Emissions
The combination of steel slag and biochar with their inherently distinct properties has several
characteristics that are highly desirable in a landfill cover system. These include: (a) preferential
adsorption of CH4 by biochar thereby increasing its bioavailability for oxidation; (b) strong alkaline
buffering capacity of steel slag which results in CO2 absorption, and (c) increased physical stability,
strength and compressibility characteristics due to the pozzolanic nature and angularity of steel slag.
In addition, biochar and steel slag fines are very inexpensive, sustainable and practical to employ in
field. Although there are numerous benefits identified with the use of these materials, it is of utmost
importance to delineate the complex fundamental coupled biogeochemical processes that dictate the
transport, adsorption, microbial oxidation, and carbonation of LFG. Moreover, it is important to
assess the influence of various factors – including moisture, pH, LFG composition, loading rates,
flow rates, particle size, steel slag and biochar source and composition, and several others – on the
fundamental processes that occur in the proposed “zero emissions” cover system.
6.
PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION
In order to evaluate the potential for carbonation in steel slag, a preliminary experimental study was
conducted at UIC to examine the ability of steel slag to sequester CO2 at normal atmospheric
conditions. A BOF steel slag sample was obtained from the Indiana Harbor East (IHE) steel plant,
the cover soil from Zion Landfill, IL, and the biochar produced from gasification of wood pellets
(which was used in a previous biochar study at UIC). The soil, biochar and steel slag were first
characterized for their physical and geotechnical properties following relevant ASTM standards and
the results are shown in Table 1.
A series of batch tests were conducted using these samples individually as well as in combinations of
these materials in different proportions. The combinations of materials tested were: soil and biochar
(S/BC); soil and slag (S/SL); slag and biochar (SL/BC); soil, biochar and 10% of slag by weight
(S/BC/SL 10%); soil, biochar and 5% of slag by weight (S/BC/SL 5%); and soil, biochar and 2% of
slag by weight (S/BC/SL 2%). The biochar content was 10% by weight in all of these combinations.
388
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The samples were prepared in glass 125 ml vials at the same moisture content of 10% by weight and
analyzed at room temperature. All the samples were tested in triplicate to ensure repeatability. The
samples were injected with 12 ml of synthetic landfill gas mixture (50% CH4 – 50% CO2) and
analyzed using a Gas Chromatograph (SRI 9300B) immediately after the injection of gas into the vial
(Time 0) and after 24 hours from the injection (Time 24) according to the headspace sampling
methodology. The preliminary investigation based on these batch tests showed complete depletion of
CO2 in all steel slag containing samples after 24 hours. Fig. 3 summarizes the results obtained the
preliminary batch tests.
Table 1: Properties of Cover Soil, Biochar and Slag
Properties
Cover Soil
Biochar
Organic Content (%)
3.10
63.7
Organic Carbon Content (%)
0.52
32.0
pH
5.3
8.7
Specific Gravity
2.65
0.81
Atterberg Limits:
Liquid Limit (%)
31
Plastic Limit (%)
19
Non-Plastic
Plasticity Index (%)
12
Grain Size Distribution:
Gravel (%)
0.0
67.8
Sand (%)
8.35
31.4
Fines (%)
91.6
0.0
-9
Hydraulic Conductivity (cm/s)
4.3x10
1.2x10-2
300
400
CH4
CO2
300
200
200
200
100
100
100
15.78
76.42
7.8
3.9x10-4
Total Depletion after 24 hrs
CH4
CO2
100
80
60
40
0
0
B
SL
S
BC
Depletion (mg/kg)
400
300
0
B
SL
S
300
0
B
BC
400
CH4
CO2
20
SL
S
BC
400
CH4
CO2
300
200
200
200
100
100
100
CH4
CO2
100
80
60
40
0
0
L
C
BC /S
0% L5% L2%
S
/ B L1
S/
/S
/S
SL
/S
C
BC /BC
B
S/
S
S/
% CO2 Depletion
Depletion (mg/kg)
300
Time 24
400
CH4
CO2
Non-Plastic
L
C
BC /S
0% L5% L2%
S
/ B L1
S/
/S
/S
SL
/S
C
C
BC S/B S/B
/
S
% CO2 Depleted
Time 0
400
Steel Slag
0
0
12.3
3.04
20
0
0
L
C
BC /S
0% L5% L2%
S
/ B L1
S/
/S
/S
SL
/S
C
BC /BC
B
S/
S
S/
Figure 3: CO2 and CH4 Uptake in Samples with Soil (S), Biochar (BC) and Slag (SL)
(B-Blank, S-Soil, BC-Biochar, SL-Steel Slag)
These preliminary results (SL/series results) clearly demonstrate that the CO2 sequestration by slag
can be rapid and substantial under normal landfill conditions. In addition, the CH4 depletion in
samples containing biochar and slag was observed (SL/BC data), indicating the removal of CH 4.
However, the relative contributions of microbial oxidation or adsorption have not been established.
389
Solid waste management
Therefore, there is still a need for extensive analysis of the carbonation potential of steel slag under
various conditions including moisture, temperature, CO2 loading, and particle size. It is also essential
to investigate the effects of highly alkaline pH on the growth and activity of methanotrophs in cover
soil and biochar. Some methanotrophs are found to be sensitive to pH, while others such as
extremophile methanotrophs are shown to be resilient to high pH conditions (Trotsenko and
Khmelenina, 2002; Saari et al., 2004; Roadcap et al., 2006). In addition, the individual mechanisms,
reaction kinetics and interdependency of the microbial oxidation and carbonation must be quantified.
All of these aspects are being investigated in our ongoing study.
7.
ONGOING RESEARCH
It is anticipated that this innovative, low-cost, feasible and sustainable cover system will help in
realizing the overarching goal of eliminating the LFG emissions from landfill into the atmosphere. In
order to achieve this goal sequentially or simultaneously, it is essential to investigate the fundamental
coupled biogeochemical processes involved in CO2 sequestration by BOF steel slag and biochar/steel
slag amended soils and optimize the cover system to achieve maximum CH4 oxidation in biochar and
at the same time maximize the CO2 sequestration in steel slag. Fundamental questions that need to be
addressed include: interactive geochemical changes due to the presence of slag and biochar together;
survival and growth of methanotrophs; carbonation mechanisms and moisture and porewater
composition impacts; clogging of pores and long-term permeability of the materials, among others.
In the ongoing research, we are focused on quantifying the physical, chemical and geotechnical
characteristics of different types of slag including their leachability and surface characteristics.
Thereafter, a detailed experimental investigation involving bench-scale testing and column
experiments will be performed to identify the extent of carbonation in steel slag under varying
environmental conditions including moisture, LFG composition, particle size, slag types among
others. One of the important aspects of the conceptualized biochar-slag amended cover system is to
determine the synergistic effects of having both biochar and steel slag in the cover system. It is
essential to determine the extent of carbonation, microbial oxidation and the microbial activity in the
cover system. Furthermore, long term column tests using large columns simulating typical landfill
cover systems will be carried out to assess the simultaneous interactions of transport, adsorption,
oxidation and carbonation for various simulated biochar, soil and steel slag cover systems under the
influence of transient and dynamic changes in gas flow and environmental conditions. Microbial
analysis of the selected tested samples will be to ensure there is adequate biological activity in the
cover system for microbial oxidation of methane. Additional analysis involving the quantification of
the extent of carbonation and the mineralogy of the carbonated samples will be performed using
appropriate methods (SEM and XRD). Finally, based on the observations from the large-scale column
experiments, few selected profiles will be tested for their performance at a landfill under realistic gas
production and environmental conditions.
Acknowledgements
This project is funded by the U.S. National Science Foundation (CMMI # 1724773), which is
gratefully acknowledged.
References
1. Herrmann, I., Andreas, L., Diener, S., and Lind, L. (2010). ‘Steel slag used in landfill cover liners:
laboratory and field tests’. Waste Management & Research, Vol. 28(12), 1114-1121
2. Hilger, H. A., Cranford, D. F., and Barlaz, M. A. (2000). ‘Methane oxidation and microbial
exopolymer production in landfill cover soil.’ Soil Biology and Biochemistry, Vol. 32(4), 457467.
3. Huijgen, W. J., Witkamp, G. J., and Comans, R. N. (2005). ‘Mineral CO2 sequestration by steel
slag carbonation’. Environmental Science & Technology, Vol. 39(24), 9676-9682.
390
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4. Huijgen, W. J., and Comans, R. N. (2006). ‘Carbonation of steel slag for CO2 sequestration:
leaching of products and reaction mechanisms’. Environmental Science & Technology, Vol.
40(8), 2790-2796
5. National Slag Association (NSA). (2013). http://www.nationalslag.org/steel-furnace-slag
6. Olajire, A. A. (2013). ‘A review of mineral carbonation technology in sequestration of CO2.’
Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, Vol. 109, 364-392
7. Pan, S. Y., Adhikari, R., Chen, Y. H., Li, P., and Chiang, P. C. (2016). ‘Integrated and innovative
steel slag utilization for iron reclamation, green material production and CO2 fixation via
accelerated carbonation’. Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 137, 617-631
8. Reddy, K.R., Yargicoglu, E.N., Yue, D., and Yaghoubi, P. (2014). ‘Enhanced microbial methane
oxidation in landfill cover soil amended with biochar.’ Journal of Geotechnical and
Geoenvironmental Engineering, ASCE, Vol. 140(9), 04014047
9. Roadcap, G. S., Sanford, R. A., Jin, Q., Pardinas, J. R., and Bethke, C. M. (2006). ‘Extremely
alkaline (pH> 12) ground water hosts diverse microbial community.’ Groundwater, Vol. 44(4),
511-517.
10. Saari, A., Rinnan, R., and Martikainen, P. J. (2004). ‘Methane oxidation in boreal forest soils:
kinetics and sensitivity to pH and ammonium’. Soil Biology and Biochemistry, Vol. 36(7), 10371046
11. Shi, C. (2004). ‘Steel slag—its production, processing, characteristics, and cementitious
properties.’ Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, Vol. 16(3), 230-236.
12. Trotsenko, Y. A., and Khmelenina, V. N. (2002). ‘Biology of extremophilic and extremotolerant
methanotrophs’. Archives of Microbiology, Vol. 177(2), 123-131
13. Whalen, S. C., Reeburgh, W. S., and Sandbeck, K. A. (1990). ‘Rapid methane oxidation in a
landfill cover soil.’ Applied and Environmental Microbiology, Vol. 56(11), 3405-3411.
14. Yargicoglu, E., Sadasivam, B.Y., Reddy, K.R. and Spokas, K. (2015). ‘Physical and chemical
characterization of waste wood derived biochars.’ Waste Management, Vol. 36(2), 256-268
15. Yargicoglu, E.Y., and Reddy, K.R. (2017a). ‘Microbial abundance and activity in biocharamended landfill cover soils: Evidences from large-scale column and field experiments’ Journal
of Environmental Engineering, Vol. 143(9), 04017058
16. Yargicoglu, E.Y., and Reddy, K.R. (2017b). ‘Effects of biochar and wood pellets amendments
added to landfill cover soil on microbial methane oxidation: A laboratory column study’ Journal
of Environmental Management, Vol. 193, 19-31
17. Yargicoglu, E.Y., and Reddy, K.R. (2018) ‘Biochar-amended soil cover for microbial methane
oxidation: Effect of biochar amendment ratio and cover profile.’ Journal of Geotechnical and
Geoenvironmental Engineering, ASCE, Vol. 144(3): 04017123
18. Yi, H., Xu, G., Cheng, H., Wang, J., Wan, Y., and Chen, H. (2012). ‘An overview of utilization
of steel slag’. Procedia Environmental Sciences, Vol. 16, 791-801
19. Yildirim, I. Z., and Prezzi, M. (2011). ‘Chemical, mineralogical, and morphological properties of
steel slag.’ Advances in Civil Engineering, Article ID 463638, 13 p.
20. USEPA (2016). ‘Advancing Sustainable Materials Management’, 2014 Fact Sheet
21. World Steel Association (2017). ‘World Steel in Figures 2017’, Retrieved from
https://www.worldsteel.org/en/dam/jcr:0474d208-9108-4927-ace84ac5445c5df8/World+Steel+in+Figures+2017.pdf (Accessed on January 18, 2018)
391
Solid waste management
CO2 SEQUESTRATION USING BOF SLAG: APPLICATION IN
LANDFILL COVER
K. R. Reddy1,*, G. Kumar1, A. Gopakumar1, R.K. Rai1 and D.G. Grubb2
1
University of Illinois at Chicago, Department of Civil & Materials Engineering, 842 West Taylor
Street, Chicago, IL 60607, USA 2Phoenix Services, LLC, 148 West State Street, Suite 301, Kennett
Square, PA 19348, USA
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: kreddy@uic.edu, tel : +13129964755
Abstract
Fugitive methane (CH4) and carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions at municipal solid waste (MSW)
landfills constitute one of the major anthropogenic sources of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions to
the atmosphere. In recent years, biocovers involving the addition of organic-rich amendments to
landfill cover soils is proposed to promote microbial oxidation of CH4 to CO2. However, most of the
organic amendments used have limitations. Biochar, a solid byproduct obtained from gasification of
biomass under anoxic or low oxygen conditions, has characteristics that are favorable for enhanced
microbial oxidation in landfill covers. Recent investigations have shown the significant potential of
biochar-amended cover soils in mitigating the CH4 emissions from MSW landfills. Although the CH4
emissions are mitigated, there is still considerable amount of CO2 that is emitted to the atmosphere
as a result of microbial oxidation of CH4 in landfill covers as well as the CO2 derived from MSW
decomposition. Basic oxygen furnace (BOF) slag is a product of steel making has great potential for
CO2 sequestration due to its strong alkaline buffering and high carbonation capacity. In an ongoing
project, funded by the U.S. National Science Foundation, the potential use of BOF slag in landfill
covers along with biochar-amended soils to mitigate both CH4 and CO2 emissions is being
investigated. This paper presents the initial results from this study and it includes detailed physical
and chemical and leachability characteristics of BOF slag, and a series of batch tests conducted on
BOF slag to determine its CH4 and CO2 uptake capacity. The effect of moisture content on the
carbonation capacity of BOF slag was also evaluated by conducting batch tests at different moisture
contents. In addition, small column experiments were conducted to evaluate the gas migration,
transport parameters and the CO2 sequestration potential of BOF slag under simulated landfill gas
conditions. The result from the batch and column tests show a significant uptake of CO2 by BOF slag
for the tested conditions and demonstrates excellent potential for its use in a landfill cover system.
Keywords: CO2 sequestration; BOF slag; biochar; carbonation; MSW landfills; landfill cover;
landfill gas
1.
INTRODUCTION
Global climate change and the rapidly increasing global population are currently some of the major
concerns of the modern world. This has led to depletion of natural resources and increased generation
of waste. In the U.S., landfills are the most dominant method of managing MSW. The MSW in
landfills undergoes anaerobic decomposition to generate landfill gas that predominantly consists of
methane (CH4) and carbon dioxide (CO2). The landfill gas (LFG) emissions are estimated to be one
of the largest sources of greenhouse gas emissions into the atmosphere.
According to Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) Subtitle D regulations, all new
landfills are required to have active gas extraction systems to collect the LFG and prevent it from
392
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
releasing into the atmosphere. In addition, a final cover with specific design requirements is made
essential to minimize the infiltration into the waste as well as limit the escape of landfill gas into the
atmosphere. However, the gas collection systems do not perform with 100 percent efficiency due to
the limited radius of influence of each extraction well. Thus, there are always some fugitive emissions
that cannot be targeted by the gas extraction systems. While serving the intended purpose, landfill
covers also aid in reducing the fugitive emissions of LFG into the atmosphere to a certain extent by
microbial oxidation of CH4 to CO2 in the presence of methanotrophs that naturally exist in the soil
cover. But, the proliferation of these methanotrophs is limited and is not very effective in oxidizing
large amounts of CH4 emissions from the landfills.
In this regard, alternative covers called biocovers, involving the addition of organic amendments to
the soil have gained great attention in the recent past. The addition of organic rich matter such as
compost, digested sludge, biosolids, and peat moss enhances the microbial activity by providing the
nutrients and microbial inoculums to the soil. But, the use of these materials has some limitations.
For example, compost, dewatered sludge and biosolids like materials may themselves undergo
anaerobic degradation adding to the already existing CH4 and CO2 emissions rather than reducing
these emissions. Biochar is a promising material as an organic amendment in soil cover because of
its unique characteristics (Reddy et al., 2014). Biochar is a solid byproduct derived from gasification
or pyrolysis under low oxygen conditions. Biochar exhibits high internal porosity and high specific
surface area which provides favorable conditions for microbial colonization and proliferation
(Yargicoglu et al., 2015). In addition, it consists of stable organic carbon and doesn’t undergo any
degradation. Recently, an extensive investigation involving lab-scale testing and field demonstration
of the efficacy of biochar-amended soil cover system was performed (Sadasivam and Reddy, 2015;
Yargicoglu and Reddy, 2017a, b, 2018). These studies confirmed the use of biochar as a potential
organic amendment to mitigate CH4 emissions from landfills quite successfully. However, one of the
major limitations of the biochar amended soil cover system is that it does not address the fate of CO2
which continues to be emitted into the atmosphere in undesirable amounts. In order to alleviate the
problems from GHG emissions it is desirable to mitigate the CO2 emissions as well.
The current study focuses on an innovative concept to mitigate both CH4 and CO2 emissions from
MSW landfills by leveraging BOF slag. BOF slag is a product of the steel making process and it is
known to possess unique characteristics suitable for CO2 sequestration. Several different types of
steel slag are obtained based on the steel type and steel making process (Shi, 2004). Currently, the
coarser (larger aggregate sized) BOF slag material is utilized in asphalt paving due to its strong rutting
resistance and durability, while the BOF slag fines are still largely stockpiled at steel plants. The BOF
slag which has high alkaline buffering capacity can react with CO2 in the presence of moisture to
sequester CO2 in the form of stable and insoluble carbonates. This process is generally known as the
carbonation process.
In this study, a series of batch experiments were performed to estimate the carbonation capacity of a
BOF slag. In addition, the effect of varying moisture contents on the carbonation capacity of the BOF
slag was also studied. Furthermore, small column experiments were performed to evaluate the
carbonation capacity of BOF slag under a continuous supply of simulated LFG emission conditions.
The rate of carbonation and the breakthrough time are estimated based on the column experiments.
The results show a substantial carbonation capacity of BOF slag and favor its use as a potential
amendment in landfill cover system to mitigate CO2 emissions.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Steel Slag Characterization
Basic Oxygen Furnace (BOF) slag is produced when molten iron from blast furnace mixes with the
fluxing agents (calcium oxide and dolomite) in the presence of 10-20% scrap steel melt and 99% pure
oxygen blown at supersonic speed (National Slag Association 2013). According to U.S. Geological
Survey, every year almost 15-20 million tons of ferrous slag and about 10-15 million tons of steel
393
Solid waste management
slag is produced. The BOF slag was collected from the Phoenix Services LLC facility at the Indiana
Harbor East Steel Mill. BOF slag contains minerals that contain divalent cations of calcium,
magnesium and iron that carbonate with time in the open environment. The mineral carbonation
reaction of metal oxides (MO) can be simplified as:
𝑀𝑂 + 𝐶𝑂2 → 𝑀𝐶𝑂3 + 𝐻𝑒𝑎𝑡
The mineral carbonation also results in the production of thermodynamically more stable products
(carbonates). The natural mineral carbonation process could be accelerated and technologically viable
in the presence of moisture and abundant availability of the minerals such as in BOF slag. The calcium
silicates (and other silicates and aluminates) in the presence of moisture contributes to CO2
sequestration (Huijgen et al., 2005) by the following chemical reactions.
𝐶𝑂2 (𝑔) + 𝐻2 𝑂(𝑙) → 2𝐻 + (𝑎𝑞) + 𝐶𝑂32− (𝑎𝑞)
𝐶𝑎𝑆𝑖𝑂3 (𝑠) + 2𝐻 + (𝑎𝑞) → 𝐶𝑎2+ (𝑎𝑞) + 𝑆𝑖𝑂2 (𝑠) + 𝐻2 𝑂(𝑙)
𝐶𝑎2+ (𝑎𝑞) + 𝐶𝑂32− (𝑎𝑞) → 𝐶𝑎𝐶𝑂3 (𝑠) ↓
In order to put BOF slag for beneficial use efficiently in a landfill cover system, it is necessary to
understand its chemical, physical and geotechnical properties. Hence, a detailed characterization of
the BOF slag was performed.
The elemental and mineralogical composition of the BOF slag was evaluated by XRF and quantitative
XRD analysis (Grubb, 2017). In order to evaluate the potential toxicity of the use of BOF slag from
leaching of toxic metals, both Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (TCLP) and Synthetic
Precipitation Leaching Procedure (SPLP) leaching tests were conducted as per the laboratory
procedures established by United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) under SW-846
(Grubb, 2017). Table 1 provides the mineralogy of BOF slag used in this study. The TCLP and SPLP
leaching test results of BOF slag are summarized in Table 2. Further, the basic chemical
characteristics of the BOF slag were determined by measurement of pH, redox potential and electrical
conductivity. The BOF slag used consisted majorly of oxides of calcium and iron. The leaching test
results as shown in Table 2 shows that the constituents leached from the material are within the
regulatory limits.
The results indicated that the BOF slag was highly alkaline with pH in the range of 11.7-12.1. This is
due to the presence of basic oxides like CaO, MgO and FeO in BOF slag. The specific gravity of the
BOF slag was found to be 3.04 which is within the reported range of 3.0-3.46 in literature
(Malasavage et al. (2012). The samples were analyzed for their particle size distribution (ASTM
D422) and classified as poorly-graded sand. The hydraulic conductivity of the material was tested as
per ASTM D2434 with a rigid wall permeameter. The hydraulic conductivity was evaluated to be in
the order of 10-4 cm/s. The sample was also tested for its moisture retention capacity using the
procedure described in Kinney et al. (2012). The physical, chemical and geotechnical properties of
the BOF slag are shown in Table 3.
394
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1: Typical Mineral Composition of BOF Slag
Mineral
Mineral
Percent Weight
Formula
Larnite
Ca2SiO4
20.6
Srebrodolskite
Ca2Fe2O5
10.4
Iron Magnesium Oxide FeO.76MgO.24O
6.7
Brownmillerite
Ca4Al2Fe2O10
5.8
Wuestite
FeO
5.4
Lime
CaO
4.1
Portlandite
Ca(OH)2
6.5
Periclase
MgO
3.1
Magnetite
Fe3O4
3.0
Mayenite
Ca12Al14O33
2.7
Quartz
SiO2
0.5
Iron
Fe
0.3
Amorphous Material
31.1
Total
100.0
Constituent
Aluminum
Antimony
Arsenic
Barium
Beryllium
Boron
Cadmium
Calcium
Chromium
Cobalt
Copper
Iron
Lead
Magnesium
Manganese
Mercury
Nickel
Potassium
Selenium
Silver
Sodium
Thallium
Vanadium
Zinc
Table 2: Results from TCLP and SPLP Leaching Tests
RCRA Allowable Limit
TCLP Result
Symbol
(mg/L)
(mg/L)
Al
0.62
Sb
<0.00031
As
5
0.00087
Ba
100
0.14
Be
<0.00025
B
0.12
Cd
1
<0.00028
Ca
2300
Cr
5
0.011
Co
0.0034
Cu
<0.005
Fe
0.031
Pb
5
<0.00041
Mg
0.077
Mn
0.005
Hg
0.2
<0.00005
Ni
0.036
K
0.76
Se
1
0.0047
Ag
5
<0.00025
Na
6.4
Tl
<0.00025
V
0.0058
Zn
0.035
395
SPLP Result
(mg/L)
0.16
<0.00016
0.00029
0.12
<0.00013
0.027
<0.00015
800
0.002
0.0013
<0.0025
0.011
<0.00020
<0.050
0.00072
<0.00005
0.013
0.66
0.0019
<0.00013
4.8
<0.00013
0.00078
0.024
Solid waste management
Table 3: Physical, Chemical and Geotechnical Properties of Soil, BOF Slag and Biochar
Properties
Method
Soil
BOF Slag
Biochar
Physical
Color
Visual
Brown,
Brownishgrey, Grey
Grey
Black
Odor
Visual
Trace odor
Odorless
Odorless
Redox Potential (mV)
ASTM D4972-01
-37.7
-317.9
-6.3
Conductivity ( S/cm)
ASTM D4972-01
0.5
0.2
0.8
pH
ASTM D4972-01
7.04
11.7
6.5
(w/w)
Kinney et.al.
(2012)
45.93
40.54
51.55
Organic Content (%)
ASTM D2974-14
4.47
NA
96.71
Specific Gravity
ASTM D854-14
2.65
3.04
0.65
Non-Plastic
Non-Plastic
12
0
45
7
90.5
54
Fines (%)
81
9.5
1
Classification
CL
SP type
SP Type
Hydraulic Conductivity
(cm/s)
2.75 x 10-8
4.2 x 10-4
2 x 10-4
@ 2.11 g/cc
@ 1.32 g/cc
@ 1.15 g/cc
Chemical
Geotechnical
Water Holding Capacity
Atterberg Limits:
Liquid Limit (%)
Plastic Limit (%)
35.0
ASTM D4318-10
20.34
14.66
Plasticity Index (%)
Grain Size Distribution:
Gravel (%)
Sand (%)
ASTM D422-63
ASTM D2434-68
2.2 Batch Tests
The BOF slag was evaluated for its CO2 sequestration capacity by conducting a series of batch
experiments. The batch tests were conducted to evaluate the effect of moisture conditions as moisture
is an essential component in the carbonation process. In addition, these experiments were aimed at
determining if there is any optimum moisture content for maximum amount of carbonation to occur
in BOF slag. Since, the landfill covers predominantly remain under unsaturated conditions most of
its lifetime, the water content range is selected such that lower limit is zero and the higher limit is the
water holding capacity of the material. Also, all the tests were conducted under atmospheric
temperature and pressure.
The BOF slag sample was dried at 100-110°C for 24 hours before it was used to conduct batch tests.
The batch tests were conducted at 0%, 10%, 20%, 30% and 40% moisture content. To obtain the
396
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
required water content, 1 g of the dried sample was mixed with 0g, 0.1g, 0.2g, 0.3g and 0.4g of
distilled water separately and transferred to five separate 125 ml glass vials. Each vial was then purged
completely with a synthetic landfill gas mix containing 50% CH4 and 50% CO2 by volume and closed
with rubber septa and secured tightly with a metal crimp cap. For each of the water contents evaluated,
the tests were conducted in triplicates. The samples were shaken vigorously before sampling the gas
from their headspace. Gas samples were taken and analyzed using a gas chromatograph (SRI 9300
GC) equipped with a thermal conductivity detector (TCD) and CTR-1 column capable of separating
N2 and O2 for simultaneous analysis of CO2, CH4, O2 and N2. Each 1ml of gas sample withdrawn
from the vial was then reduced to 0.5ml sample volume before injection into the GC. This ensured
the sample volume was within the acceptable limit for the GC and in equilibrium with the atmospheric
pressure. A 3-point calibration curve was constructed for the GC using standard gas mixtures of 5%,
25%, and 50% methane.
2.3 Column Experiments
After the batch tests, long term column experiments were conducted to study the cumulative
carbonation (CO2 uptake) capacity of the BOF slag with continuous flow of the synthetic landfill gas
(50% CH4 and 50% CO2) through the BOF slag packed in a small glass column with inlet and outlet
ports. A schematic of the column experimental setup is shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2: Schematic of Column Experimental Test Setup
An acrylic glass column of 30 cm height and 2.5 cm inner diameter was used. The column was filled
with the BOF slag at 10% moisture up to its full length in two layers of 15 cm each with light tamping.
It was secured with bed support mesh screen, end connections and screw caps at both ends. PTFE
tubing was used to connect all components in the setup. Flow meters were installed at both ends of
the column to control the influent gas flow rates and monitor the effluent flow rates. Gas samples
were collected from both influent and effluent sampling ports at different time intervals until the
breakthrough condition (where the inlet and outlet concentration of the gas becomes equal) was
established.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Composition and Properties of BOF Slag
The chemical, physical and geotechnical properties of the BOF slag are favorable for its use in a
landfill cover. The hydraulic conductivity of the BOF slag is in the order of 10 -4 cm/s which is
397
Solid waste management
comparable with the hydraulic conductivity of biochar (10-4 cm/s). Due to the high hydraulic
conductivity, the BOF slag and the biochar materials tested may not qualify as a barrier material.
However, these materials could be used as individual thin layers in the cover soil or mixed with the
cover soil for use in the landfill cover system. One of the characteristics that is unique to BOF slag is
its high pH. The results from TCLP and SPLP confirmed that BOF slag is not a material of concern
from the environmental risk standpoint as the results were found to be well within the regulatory
limits (Table 1). Hence, the BOF slag is not hazardous and can be used as a cover material in landfills.
The water holding capacity of BOF slag (40%) was comparable to that of the typical cover soil
material (46%) indicating that the impacts of evaporative losses from landfill cover soils (such as
desiccation cracking) could be minimum. BOF slag will not cause an additional odor since it does not
contain any biodegradable material or sulfur and is characteristically odorless. Malasavage et al.
(2012) conducted isotropically consolidated undrained triaxial shear tests on steel slag fines and
reported a friction angle of 45.7° and cohesion of 48 kPa, while studying its geotechnical performance
as synthetic fill materials. These high shear strength parameters of steel slag can as well enhance
slope stability of a landfill cover. Additionally, the high specific gravity of BOF slag could also act
as a factor that enhances the slope stability and reduces loss of material due to erosion.
3.2 Effect of Moisture Content on Carbonation of BOF Slag
Most of the previous studies that discuss the use of BOF slag for CO2 sequestration focus on its
industrial applications and involves carbonation of BOF slag under slurry conditions. This condition
rarely exists in a landfill cover. The batch tests conducted at low moisture contents below saturation
levels showed that substantial carbonation does takes place at moisture levels below saturation water
content (Figure 3).
Carbon Dioxide Uptake by Slag
at Different Moisture Content
2D Graph 3
80
80
1 hr
7 hr
24 hr
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
60
CO2 Uptake (mg/g)
CO2 Uptake (mg/g)
60
40
40
20
20
0
0
-20
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Time (hr)
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
Moisture Content
(a)
(b)
Figure 3: Carbon Dioxide uptake by BOF Slag for Different Initial Moisture Contents
The results from the batch tests showed carbonation in the range of 53-68 mg of CO2 per gram of
BOF slag in 24 hours, with the maximum uptake of 68 mg/g. Figure 3a shows that the amount of
CO2 sequestered increased with time. However, the CO2 uptake curve shows two distinct regions
with different slopes indicating an initial rapid carbonation for a short period of time. The initial rapid
carbonation could be due to the readily available free-lime and portlandite (Ca(OH)2) in fine particles.
The region of slow rate of carbonation for the rest of the time period could be from the lime diffusing
out of larger particles. It could also be attributed to the limited access of CO2 to the minerals due to
the formation of carbonate precipitates over the mineral surface. A negligible amount of carbonation
was observed in the absence of water as shown in Figure 3b. In addition, it was observed that there
was no specific trend in the CO2 sequestration with the moisture content and the CO2 uptake was
rather high and similar for all the moisture contents tested. This indicates that even moisture content
398
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
as low as 10% could lead to substantial carbonation and is not significantly affected by the amount
of moisture available in the system.
3.3 Gas Transport and CO2 Uptake Capacity of BOF Slag
The breakthrough curve for CO2 uptake with respect to time and pore volume of simulated LFG is
shown in Figure 4. The breakthrough was obtained between 800-1,500 min and Cout ≥ Cin was
achieved after 18,000 min. The cumulative uptake of CO2 in the column test after 24 hours was in the
same range as that of the 24 hour uptake in batch tests (see Figure 5). The breakthrough curve was
also plotted with respect to pore volume of gas for better understanding of CO2 uptake in a large scale
application. Accordingly, the breakthrough curve was obtained between 100-350 pore volumes (PV)
of simulated LFG and the equilibrium was achieved at around 1,900 PV of gas. For the initial 100
PV the CO2 was completely removed by the BOF slag. The breakthrough was achieved at around 100
PV after which the CO2 uptake diminished rapidly, until a plateau was achieved at 350 PV where
Cout/Cin was around 0.81. The curve maintained this ratio until there was no more uptake after 1,800
PV of CO2 flow through the system.
The initial reaction is attributed to the chemical reaction between the available free-lime and
Portlandite in the material (which was ~4% and 6.5% respectively, see Table 2) with the CO2 in the
presence of moisture. After the exhaustion of the free lime, the reaction with other minerals such as
calcium silicates (Ca2SiO4) could have been the source of continued uptake until the breakthrough.
The adsorption and reaction with the interstitial minerals and other less reactive oxides and silicates
that release calcium and/or portlandite could have led to the decent in the further reaction with CO2
thus leading to the completion of the breakthrough curve. The lower reaction rates could also be
attributed to the exhaustion of the limited moisture available in the system which was not replenished.
Moisture plays a vital role in the carbonation reaction. It helps in dissolution of gas as well as
interstitial CaO. Hence, the availability of persistent moisture on an actual landfill site could have
higher capacity to capture more CO2 during its lifetime. Also, the spreading of BOF slag over a larger
area could generate more surface area allowing more interaction between gas and moisture leading
to higher CO2 sequestration.
In addition, a crust of carbonate precipitates was observed around the BOF slag material inside the
glass column surface during the experiments which almost certainly limited mass transfer and
reaction rates.
Breakthrough Curve for Carbon Dioxide
1.2
1.0
1.0
0.8
0.8
Cout/Cin
Cout/Cin
Breakthrough Curve for CO2
1.2
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.0
1e+0
1e+1
1e+2
1e+3
1e+4
1e+5
Time (min)
1 PV = 82.4 ml
0.0
1e+0
1e+1
1e+2
1e+3
1e+4
Pore Volumes
(a)
(b)
Figure 4: Breakthrough Curve of Carbon Dioxide in Small Column Experiment with respect
to (a) Time and (b) Pore Volumes
399
Solid waste management
160
160
140
140
Cumulative CO2 Uptake (mg/g)
Cumulative CO2 Uptake (mg/g)
2D Graph 1
2D Graph 2
1 PV = 82.4 ml
120
120
100
100
80
60
40
80
60
40
20
20
0
0
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
18000
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
Pore Volumes
Time (min)
(a)
(b)
Figure 5: Cumulative Uptake of Carbon Dioxide in Small Column Experiment with respect to
(a) Time and (b) Pore Volumes
4.
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
BOF slag has been extensively investigated for its potential use in different civil and environmental
applications with the aim of preserving the natural resources and aim of mitigating the global CO 2
emissions (Motz and Geiseler, 2001) These studies have been useful in reducing the use of natural
resources by replacing it with steel slag in various forms, alleviating the amount of steel slag
stockpiling at the steel plants. There have been recent efforts at the potential use of steel slag in
landfills, but as a drainage material in the landfill covers. This study explores the use of BOF slag to
mitigate the CO2 emissions from MSW landfills by leveraging the mineral carbonation process of
BOF slag. In this regard, a series of batch tests were conducted to evaluate the amount of CO2 that
can be sequestered by the BOF slag. Furthermore, the carbonation and CO2 sequestration under
varying moisture contents was conducted to evaluate the effect of moisture content on the carbonation
capacity of the BOF slag. Small column experiments simulating the flow of landfill gas through BOF
slag were conducted with the optimum moisture content as derived from the batch test results.
Following conclusions could be drawn from this study.
The BOF slag was found to have characteristics suitable for its use in a landfill cover based on
the physical, chemical and technical characterization performed. The BOF slag used was
classified as non-hazardous based on the TCLP and SPLP test results.
The results from the batch tests showed that the carbonation capacity (CO2 uptake) of the BOF
slag was about 68 mg/g within 24 hours. It was also observed that, for the range of moisture
content tested, the CO2 uptake in 24 hours from the batch tests was comparable to the cumulative
uptake of CO2 in column test.
The cumulative uptake of CO2 from the column experiments is a conservative estimate since
there was an exhaustion of the moisture available in the system for carbonation reaction over the
course of the column test. The limited moisture availability in a continuous gas flow system could
hinder the maximum possible carbonation of the BOF slag used in the column.
Further studies are being performed to analyze the carbonation mechanism and evaluate the
effects of various system parameters on carbonation capacity of BOF slag, including field landfill
gas flow and environmental conditions.
400
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Acknowledgements
This project is funded by the U.S. National Science Foundation (CMMI # 1724773), which is
gratefully acknowledged.
References
1. Grubb, D.G. (2017). Personal Communication.
2. Huijgen, W. J., Witkamp, G. J., and Comans, R. N. (2005). ‘Mineral CO2 sequestration by steel
slag carbonation.’ Environmental Science & Technology, Vol. 39(24), 9676-9682
3. Kasina, M., Kowalski, P. R., and Michalik, M. (2015). ‘Mineral carbonation of metallurgical
slags.’ Mineralogia, Vol. 45(1-2), 27-45
4. Kinney, T. J., Masiello, C. A., Dugan, B., Hockaday, W. C., Dean, M. R., Zygourakis, K., and
Barnes, R. T. (2012). ‘Hydrologic properties of biochars produced at different
temperatures.’ Biomass and Bioenergy, Vol. 41, 34-43
5. Malasavage, N. E., Jagupilla, S., Grubb, D. G., Wazne, M., and Coon, W. P. (2012). ‘Geotechnical
performance of dredged material—steel slag fines blends: laboratory and field evaluation.’
Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, Vol. 138(8), 981-991
6. Motz, H., and Geiseler, J. (2001). ‘Products of steel slags an opportunity to save natural
resources.’ Waste Management, Vol. 21(3), 285-293.
7. National Slag Association (NSA). (2013). http://www.nationalslag.org/steel-furnace-slag
8. Reddy, K.R., Yargicoglu, E.N., Yue, D., and Yaghoubi, P. (2014). ‘Enhanced microbial methane
oxidation in landfill cover soil amended with biochar.’ Journal of Geotechnical and
Geoenvironmental Engineering, ASCE, Vol. 140(9), 04014047
9. Sadasivam, B.Y., and Reddy, K.R. (2015). ‘Engineering properties of waste-wood derived
biochars and biochar-amended soils.’ International Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, Vol.
9(5):521-535
10. Shi, C. (2004). ‘Steel slag—its production, processing, characteristics, and cementitious
properties.’ Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, Vol. 16(3), 230-236.
11. U.S. Geological Survey. (2015). ‘Mineral Commodity Summaries’ Retrieved from
https://minerals.usgs.gov/minerals/pubs/commodity/iron_&_steel_slag/
12. Yargicoglu, E., Sadasivam, B.Y., Reddy, K.R. and Spokas, K. (2015). ‘Physical and chemical
characterization of waste wood derived biochars.’ Waste Management, Vol. 36(2), 256-268
13. Yargicoglu, E.Y., and Reddy, K.R. (2017a). ‘Microbial abundance and activity in biocharamended landfill cover soils: Evidences from large-scale column and field experiments’ Journal
of Environmental Engineering, Vol. 143(9), 04017058
14. Yargicoglu, E.Y., and Reddy, K.R. (2017b). ‘Effects of biochar and wood pellets amendments
added to landfill cover soil on microbial methane oxidation: A laboratory column study’ Journal
of Environmental Management, Vol. 193, 19-31
15. Yargicoglu, E.Y., and Reddy, K.R. (2018) ‘Biochar-amended soil cover for microbial methane
oxidation: Effect of biochar amendment ratio and cover profile.’ Journal of Geotechnical and
Geoenvironmental Engineering, ASCE, Vol. 144(3): 04017123
401
Solid waste management
RECYCLING OF CRT FUNNEL GLASS: A REVIEW OF ITS
UTILIZATION IN INTERLOCKING CONCRETE BLOCKS
G. Perkoulidis* and N. Moussiopoulos
Laboratory of Heat Transfer and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering,
A.U.Th, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: gperk@auth.gr, tel : +302310996060
Abstract
CRT monitors are evacuated glass envelopes containing an electron gun and a fluorescent screen and
when they are dismantled, glass is separated into: (a) nonhazardous panel and (b) funnel with lead
(Pb). The utilization of cathode-ray tube funnel glass has been promoted as a substitute for sand,
while recent studies were focused on the mechanical and durability properties of concrete containing
such glass as aggregate. Future products such as precast concrete structural interlocking blocks could
contain cathode-ray tube funnel glass aggregate and in case their lead content is high, then they could
be classified as hazardous waste.
The aim of the present manuscript was to review the methods of cathode-ray tube glass recycling and
to evaluate the potential risks for the utilization of funnel glass in interlocking concrete blocks. The
critical evaluation of published literature data will help the development of new product methods
through recycling.
Keywords: cathode-ray tube; funnel glass; waste recycling; concrete block
1.
INTORDUCTION
Electrical and electronic equipment (EEE) falling within the scope of the Waste from Electrical and
Electronic Equipment (WEEE) Directive was currently classified under 10 “product - oriented”
categories (European Commission, 2017): 1) large household appliances, 2) small household
appliances, 3) Information Technology (IT) and telecommunications equipment, 4) consumer
equipment, 5) lighting equipment, 6) electrical and electronic tools, 7) toys, leisure and sports
equipment, 8) medical devices, 9) monitoring and control instruments, 10) automatic dispensers.
From 15 August 2018, EEE will be classified under 6 “collection - oriented” categories (European
Commission, 2017): 1) temperature exchange equipment; 2) screens, monitors and equipment
containing screens with a surface greater than 100 cm2; 3) lamps; 4) large equipment (any external
dimension greater than 50 cm); 5) small equipment (no external dimension greater than 50cm); 6)
small IT and telecommunications equipment (no external dimension greater than 50cm). Old monitors
will belong to “collection - oriented” category 2 from 15 August 2018, as has already been mentioned
above.
The sections from CRTs were characterized by the neck, the funnel, and the face panel, as shown in
Figure 1 (Musson et al., 2000).
402
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1. Funnel and other parts of a CRT (Mousson et al., 2000).
The most significant quantities of lead were obtained from the funnel portion of the CRTs at an
average lead concentration of 75.3 mg/L, while the major source of lead in the funnel was the frit seal
of color CRTs (Table 1).
Table 1. Lead content in various CRT glass components by mass (Microelectronics and
Computer Technology Corporation, 1994, Musson et al., 2000).
Glass Color CRT
Monochrome
Glass Color CRT (%)
Monochrome
(%)
CRT (%)
CRT (%)
Panel
0-3
0-3
Funnel
24
4
Neck
30
30
Frit
70
N/A
Leaded glass was used in cement mortar by using recycled beverage and CRT funnel glass as fine
aggregate in dry-mixed concrete paving blocks (Ling and Poon, 2014; Yu et al., 2016; Lee et al.,
2012; Ling and Poon, 2012a; Sikora et al., 2015). Some of the advantages of using large precast
concrete block systems for retaining structures included (Elite precast concrete limited, 2017): (a)
relatively low cost, (b) simple and quick to build, while dry laid ensured that structure could be loaded
without waiting for concrete/mortar to set, (c) durable with low on-going maintenance costs and (d)
re-usable structures that could be readily dismantled and reused elsewhere. Different organisations
could be responsible for the design, manufacture, installation and maintenance of the retaining wall,
such as (Elite precast concrete limited, 2017): (i) design – professionally qualified civil, structural or
geotechnical engineer, (ii) third- party engineer to perform a design check, especially for road and
rail infrastructure projects, (iii) a precast concrete manufacturer, (iv) a civil/building contractor or
specialist earthworks sub-contractor and (v) an owner/operator of the infrastructure or storage facility.
Walls formed from interlocking concrete blocks were, defined in BS 8002:2015 as gravity walls (Elite
precast concrete limited, 2017): “Gravity retaining walls are earth retaining structures that depend
primarily on their own self-weight (and that of any enclosed material) to support the retained ground
and any structures or loads placed upon it”.
From the other hand, precast concrete structural interlocking blocks that were imported from
Netherlands to UK, contained high lead concentration, and in accordance with Parker (2014), that
recycled glass aggregate had to be reclassified as hazardous waste. The suspect blocks had come into
the UK from 2010 to 2014, and the Environment Agency stated that the producer had failed to provide
evidence that it complied with environmental protection regulations. The producer had to demonstrate
that the “processed substance” could be used in the same way as a non-waste, and could be stored
and used with no worse environmental effects. Reclassifying the giant Legioblocks, which were dry-
403
Solid waste management
stacked to form retaining walls, storage bays and firewalls, would had serious implications for those
who had purchased them in good faith.
The aim of the present manuscript was to review the methods of cathode-ray tube glass recycling and
to evaluate the potential risks for the utilization of funnel glass in interlocking concrete blocks. The
critical evaluation of published literature data will help the development of new product methods
through recycling.
2.
METHODS AND MATERIALS
2.1 Utilization of CRT funnel glass
Cathode ray tube (CRT) funnel glass had been used for monitor displays for decades. It was classified
as hazardous waste, which could not have been buried without treatment of contained lead (Lv et al.,
2016). From the other hand, using recycled cathode ray tube funnel glass as a substitute for sand
contributed to both reducing natural aggregate consumption and CRT funnel glass disposing (Liu et
al., 2017).
Various studies had been carried out to solve the discarded CRT waste problem, particularly with
methods to reuse leaded funnel glass as it contained a large amount of lead (Table 2).
Νο
Table 2. Studies for solving the CRT waste problem.
Recycled materials
Utilized as…
Final product
1
CRT funnel glass
2
CRT funnel glass and recycled Fine aggregate
beverage
Cement mortar
2
Recycled glass from CRT
Fine aggregate
Dry-mixed concrete paving
blocks
[7]
3
CRT funnel glass
Raw material
Crystal
[3]
4
CRT funnel glass
Processed
substance
Precast concrete structural
interlocking blocks
[8]
5
Waste lead glass
Wollastonite
synthesis
Wollastonite
[9]
Substitute for sand Concrete structures
Source
[1]
[2-6]
[1]: Liu et al., 2017; [2]: Ling and Poon, 2014; [3]: Yu et al., 2016; [4]: Lee et al., 2012; [5]: Ling and Poon, 2012a; [6]
Sikora et al., 2015; [7]: Ling and Poon, 2014; [8]: Parker, 2014; [9]: Erzat and Zhang, 2014.
Laboratory of Heat Transfer and Environmental Engineering (LHTEE), Mechanical Engineering
Department, Aristotle University Thessaloniki, Greece, presented the benefits from using CRT glass
in the ceramic industry (LIFE-CLAYGLASS) (Malamakis et al., 2016). The main objective of the
project was to reduce the environmental impact in the structural ceramic industry by including CRT
glass, as a flux, in the ceramic mass. During the industrial pilot test, six (6) different clay mixtures
were used. Two different clay types, namely Segovia and Blanca, with two different CRT glass types
(funnel and panel) and two possible glass percentages (5% and 10%). For each combination of clay
and glass, 300 thousand bricks were produced in the industrial gas-fired oven of MORA, which was
a brick manufacture with more than 50 years on the ceramic industry. The number was selected to
produce one full batch of each type (Laboratory of Heat Transfer and Environmental Engineering,
2017). In the frame of LIFE-CLAYGLASS, a new stoneware production using recycled glass
demonstrated which leaded to (Malamakis et al., 2016): (a) the commercial use of difficult-to-recycle
glass that was land-filled, (b) reduced demand for natural resources in clay tile production, (c) energy
savings of 10-15%, (d) a reduction of about 2,000 t of CO2 emissions per year for a medium-size
factory (brick production capacity of 300 t per day), (e) a reduction in the cost of producing clay tiles.
404
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.2 Precast concrete structural interlocking blocks
An example of precast concrete structural interlocking blocks was given by Elite precast concrete
limited (2017), but without the use of CRT funnel glass (Figure 2). The design shear resistance, Rd,
was calculated taking account the vertical design action, Vd, and the angle of interface friction, . At
the interface between the base and the bottom layer of blocks, there were no interlocking ‘nibs’, so
was based upon the friction angle between two concrete surfaces, conc. For the block-block
interfaces, the effect of the interlocking nibs was to increase the shear resistance. This might be
expressed in terms of an enhanced friction angle along a smooth horizontal surface, interlock.
However, the interlocking shear resistance was limited to a maximum value, Rd; Max, based upon
the characteristic shear strength of the concrete and the size and number of interlocking nib elements.
The base layer shear resistance and the base layer shear resistance were given by equations (1) and
(2).
Rd - base = Vd - base. × tan conc;d:
(1)
Rd – Layer n = (Vd – layer n. × tan interlock ;d ) ≤ Rd; Max
(2)
Figure 2. Standard block: (a) dimensions (mm), (b) sliding resistance, and (c) wall constructed
with inclined front face (Elite precast concrete limited, 2017).
2.3 Use of CRT funnel glass in concrete blocks
In 2008, in collaboration with the Hong Kong Polytechnic University, the Environmental Protection
Department (EPD) developed a recycling process for CRT recycling. Treated Funnel Glass (TFG)
rendered as non-hazardous material according to the Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure
(TCLP) test results after an acid washing process [Nitric Acid 5% (w/w) solution to extract lead from
the crushed glass surface for 3h], soaking tap water and rinsing (to remove the remaining acid)] (Ling
and Poon, 2012b).
Ling and Poon (2014) studied the use of CRT funnel glass in concrete blocks prepared with different
aggregate-to-cement (A/C) ratios. Their experimental results showed that due to the impermeable
nature of TFG, the produced concrete blocks were more resistant to water penetration and had lower
drying shrinkage. Based on the findings, they concluded that it was possible to utilize high
percentages of TFG in concrete blocks if a proper A/C ratio and appropriate casting method were
used. CRT funnel glass had been studied as a replacement for natural sand as fine aggregate in mortar
or concrete by many researchers (Ling and Poon, 2012c, 2012b, 2013; Kim et al., 2009). Zhao et al.
405
Solid waste management
(2013a) reported that the replacement of sand with CRT funnel glass had a positive effect on the
fluidity of mortar, which was attributed to the smooth surface and low water absorption of CRT glass.
On the contrary, Sua-iam and Makul (2013) found that the flowability of mortar decreased with the
replacement ratio of CRT glass, which was associated with the poor geometry of CRT glass particles.
Ling and Poon (2011, 2012a) carried out experimental studies to demonstrate that it was feasible to
use TFG (100%) as a fine aggregate to replace natural river sand to produce cement, mortar and
concrete. However, the design concept to manufacture a dry mixed concrete block was in contrast to
conventional wet-mixed concrete, which mainly adopted a low water-to-cement ratio and high
compaction method. Therefore, it was expected that the change of these parameters could have a
significant influence on the properties of concrete, particularly alkali-silica reaction (ASR) behavior
and the potential risk of lead (Pb) leaching. No study has been done on the feasible use of TFG in
dry-mixed concrete blocks, which were produced with very different aggregate-to-cement ratios and
casting methods. Ling and Poon (2014) presented the work flow of recycling the TFG in pre-cast
concrete blocks and the testing methods used to identify applicability, quality of product and impact
on the environment (Figure 3).
Figure 3. Work flow for moulded concrete block and testing methods (Ling and Poon, 2014).
In 2016, Meng et al. studied a variety of new methods in laboratory. They introduced several
advanced methods such as high temperature separation and hydrometallurgical leaching. Bursi et al.
(2017) found that chemical pretreatment was necessary for use of CRT glass in cementitious
composites. Aim of their work was to investigate the effect of a mild chelating agent treatment based
on nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) on the reactivity of funnel glass to be used in cement mortars as
supplementary cementing material (SCM) and as fine aggregate.
Yu et al. (2016) showed that crystal could be made from waste CRT funnel glass. The lead quantity
in waste CRT glass and in lead crystal glass (PbO ≥ 24%) were almost the same, therefore, it was
found a way to use of waste CRT funnel glass as the raw material of crystal products. In the process
of producing crystal, the addition of lead oxide took place to increase the product material properties.
The production of one ton of crystal glass products could reduce the use of 0.2 tons of lead oxide by
using funnel glass.
3.
RESULTS
The results of the chemical analyses from the literature review were the following (Table 3):
A higher percentage of CRT glass (up to 100%) could be incorporated in the blocks if alternate
block forming and compaction methods were used to reduce the fragmentation of the incorporated
CRT glass. The experiment showed that the material was not dangerous (No. of test 1, Table 3).
406
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The addition of limestone powder in the CRT waste glass reduced Pb immobilization. TCLP test
results were below the US EPA Pb limit of 5 mg/L. The experiment showed that the material was
not dangerous (No. of test 2, Table 3).
The Synthetic Precipitation Leaching Procedure (SPLP) analysis was used. A cross-linked
biopolymer had a large impact on reducing the amount of lead that leached from the samples and
ultimately yielded results in which up to 20% CRT can be substituted into the concrete and still
be below the drinking water limits. The experiment showed that the material was not dangerous
(No. of test 3, Table 3).
Incorporating CRT glass in cement mortar successfully prevented the leaching of lead. Mortar
mixes contained 0 - 100% of CRT glass, with a step change of 25%. The experiment showed that
the material was not dangerous (No. of test 4, Table 3).
Funnel glass were heated to 1,480 oC in an electric furnace for 1.5 h at a heating rate of 5 oC/min
to produce cement clinker. The samples contained 10 -50 wt % of CRT funnel glass ground to
less than 75 mm (No. of test 5, Table 3).
Six mortar mixes were analyzed, which used from 0% to 100% CRT glass for replacing river
sand. Also, fly ash (F) and ground granulated blast-furnace slag (GGBFS) were used as a mineral
admixture (No. of test 6, Table 3).
Table 3. The results of the chemical analyses from the literature review.
No. of test
% of CRT
funnel
glass
Leaching
Procedure
Treated funnel glass
with…
Results
1.
Dry-mixed
concrete
paving
blocks
2. Concrete
25% <
TCLP
Acid
Nonhazardous
material
[1]
40% <
TCLP
Nonhazardous
material
[2]
3. Concrete
20%<
0 - 100%
5. Cement clinker
10 – 50%
X-ray
techniques
6. Use in the mortar
as natural river sand
fine
aggregate
replacement
CRT glass
as
fine
aggregate
with
natural
river sand
-
Nonhazardous
material
Nonhazardous
material
Maximum
PbO
encapsulation
in 10% funnel
Mortar with
larger
ASR
expansion
values
than
that of river
sand
[3-4]
4. Cement mortar
SPLP,
EPA
Method 1312
TCLP
Limestone powder
(5, 10 and 15% by
weight)
Biopolymers
Acid
Samples of cement
raw material were
heated to 1480 oC in
an electric furnace
CRT
glass
was
utilized to replace
river sand as fine
aggregates in the
mortar
Source
[5]
[6]
[7]
[1]: Ling and Poon, 2014; [2]: Sua-iam and Makul, 2013; [3]: Romero et al., 2013; [4]: USEPA, 1994;
[5]: Ling and Poon, 2011; [6]: Lairaksa et al., 2013; [7]: Hui and Sun, 2011.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
In the case of concrete with the same A/C ratio, the water absorption shrinkage values decreased with
the incorporation of TFG due to the near-zero porosity of TFG aggregate. The lead leaching behaviour
of concrete blocks was greatly affected by the TFG content, A/C ratio and casting method. Decreasing
the A/C ratio (with a higher cement content) maintained a high alkaline environment and a strong
cement matrix to stabilize and solidify the TFG in the concrete blocks. In addition, using mechanical
407
Solid waste management
compression only (without vigorous manual compaction) minimized the fragmentation of the TFG
and hence reduced the risk of lead leaching from the broken TFG. Thus, the research results showed
that it was feasible to utilize a high percentage of TFG in concrete blocks if a proper A/C ratio and
appropriate casting method were used.
Pretreatment methods could effectively improve the lead leaching effect from the glass, but they had
their disadvantages. The consumption of alkali, energy and operation costs were high. In the case of
chemical pretreatment of funnel glass, the NTA treated glass became less soluble because of Pb
depletion and the risk of pollution from leaching was reduced. Even though the NTA treatment
decreased the pozzolanic activity of the glass, making it a filler material rather than SCM, NTA
treatment allowed its use as fine aggregate in substitution of natural sand suppressing ASR reactions.
Thus, this application was environmentally preferred since it reduced the costs of strong milling
process.
The densities of concrete blocks made with TFG were higher than those of traditional control blocks,
making it suitable for use as a shielding material for medical and diagnostic room construction as it
was shown in the x-ray shielding experiment.
Finally, the recycling of CRT funnel glass seemed that had interest for many researchers; their results
by various analyses showed that funnel glass could be characterized as nonhazardous material and
that it could be utilized to produce dry-mixed concrete paving blocks, cement mortar and clinker. The
only case, where negative comments were reported, it was the case where unknown composition of
processed substance from CRT funnel glass, was utilized in interlocking concerned blocks.
As far as the possibility of utilizing CRT in dry-mixed concrete paving blocks in Greece, essays with
known CRT funnel glass composition should be prepared, and then leaching procedures should be
applied to assess their lead (Pb) leachability.
Aknowledgments
The authors would like to acknowledge the company Konstantinidis Bros S.A. for funding the
presented research. Konstantinidis Bros S.A. was the first company in Northern Greece, which started
the recycling of waste electrical and electronic equipment.
Acronyms
A/C: Aggregate-to-Cement ratio
ASR: Alkali-Silica Reaction
ASTM: American Society for Testing & Materials
C&D: Construction and Demolition
CRT: Cathode Ray Tube
EEE: Electrical and Electronic Equipment
EPD: Environmental Protection Department
IT: Information Technology
NTA: Nitrilotriacetic Acid
OPC: Ordinary Portland Cement
RCA: Recycled Coarse Aggregate
RFA: Recycled Fine Aggregate
SCM: Supplementary Cementing Material
TCLP: Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure
408
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
TFG: Treated Funnel Glass
WEEE: Waste from Electrical and Electronic Equipment
References
1. Bursi E., Lancellotti I., Barbieri L., Saccani A. and M. C. Bignozzi (2017), ‘CRT glass
management: chemical pretreatment for use in cementitious composites’, Proc. of 5th
International Conference on Sustainable Solid Waste Management, Athens, Greece, 21-24
June 2017.
2. Chen M.J., F.-S. Zhang and J.X. Zhu (2010), ‘Effective utilization of waste cathode ray tube
glass–crystalline silicotitanate synthesis’, Journal of Hazardous Materials, 182(1–3), pp. 45–
49.
3. Chen M.J., Zhang F.-S. and J.X. Zhu (2009a), ‘Lead recovery and the feasibility of foam glass
production from funnel glass of dismantled cathode ray tube through pyrovacuum process’,
Journal of Hazardous Materials, 116(2–3), pp. 1109–1113.
4. Chen M.J., Zhang F.-S. and J.X. Zhu (2009b), ‘Detoxification of cathode ray tube glass by selfpropagating process’, Journal of Hazardous Materials, 165(1–3), pp. 980–986.
5. Elite precast concrete limited (2017), ‘Reference guide for designing retaining walls using
interlocking concrete blocks’, Document No. EPCL-2017-RWRG-01 – P01, June.
6. Erzat A. and F.-S. Zhang (2014), ‘Detoxification effect of chlorination procedure on waste lead
glass’, The 8th International Conference on Waste Management and Technology (ICWMT) 2013,
Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 16, pp. 623–628.
7. European Commission (2017), ‘Re-examination of the WEEE recovery targets, on the possible
setting of separate targets for WEEE to be prepared for re-use and on the re-examination of the
method for the calculation of the recovery targets set out in Article 11(6) of Directive 2012/19/EU
on WEEE, Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council,
COM(2017) 173 final, Brussels, 18.4.2017.
8. Kim D., Quinlan M. and T. F. Yen (2009), ‘Encapsulation of lead from hazardous CRT glass
wastes using biopolymer cross-linked concrete systems’, Waste Management, 29(1), pp. 321328.
9. Laboratory of Heat Transfer and Environmental Engineering (2017), ‘Sustainability Dimensions’,
Annual Report, Mechanical Engineering Department, Aristotle University Thessaloniki, Greece.
10. Lee C.-H. and C.-S. Hsi (2002), ‘Recycling of scrap cathode ray tubes’, Journal of
Environmental Science Technology, 36(1), pp. 69–75.
11. Lee J.-S., Cho S.-J., Han B.-H., Seo Y.-C., Kim B.-S. and S. P. Heo (2012), ‘Recycling of TV
CRT Panel Glass by Incorporating to Cement and Clay Bricks as Aggregates’, Advances in
Biomedical Engineering, Vol 7, p. 257.
12. Ling T. C. and C. S. Poon (2011), ‘Utilization of recycled glass derived from cathode ray tube
glass as fine aggregate in cement mortar’, Journal of Hazardous Materials, Vol 192, pp. 451456.
13. Ling T. C. and C. S. Poon (2012a), ‘Feasible use of recycled CRT funnel glass as heavyweight
fine aggregate in barite concrete’, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol 33, pp. 42-49.
14. Ling T. C. and C. S. Poon (2012b), ‘Development of a method for recycling of CRT funnel glass’,
Environmental Technology, Vol 22, pp. 2531-2537.
15. Ling T. C. and C. S. Poon (2012c), ‘A comparative study on the feasible use of recycled beverage
and CRT funnel glass as fine aggregate in cement mortar’, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol
29, pp. 46-52.
409
Solid waste management
16. Ling T. C. and C. S. Poon (2014), ‘Use of CRT funnel glass in concrete blocks prepared with
different aggregate-to-cement ratios’, ICE- Green Materials, 2(1), pp. 43-51.
17. Ling, T. C. and C. S. Poon (2013), ‘Effects of particle size of treated CRT funnel glass on
properties of cement mortar’, Materials and Structures, 46(1-2), 25-34.
18. Liu T., W. Song, D. Zou and L. Li (2017), ‘Dynamic mechanical analysis of cement mortar
prepared with recycled cathode ray tube (CRT) glass as fine aggregate’, Journal of Cleaner
Production, 10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.11.057.
19. Lv, J., H. Yang and Z. Jin (2016), ‘Feasibility of lead extraction from waste Cathode-Ray-Tubes
(CRT) funnel glass through a lead smelting process’, Waste Management, Vol 57, pp. 198-206.
20. Malamakis A., S. Kontogianni, G. Perkoulidis, N. Moussiopoulos, J. Velasco and A. Perez
(2016), ‘Environmental protection through utilization of recycled glass as fluxing agent in the
structural ceramics industry’, 4th International Conference on Sustainable Solid Waste
Management, CYPRUS 2016, 23 - 25 June, Limassol, Cyprus.
21. Microelectronics and Computer Technology Corporation (1994), Electronics Industry
Environmental Road map, 1994.
22. Musson T., Y.-C. Jang, T. G. Townsend and I.-H. Chung (2000), ‘Characterization of Lead
Leachability from Cathode Ray Tubes Using the Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure’,
Environmental Science & Technology, Vol 34, pp. 4376-4381.
23. Parker D. (2014), ‘Fears emerge that imported Dutch precast concrete blocks could be hazardous
waste’, New Civil Engineer (https://www.newcivilengineer.com/fears-emerge-that-importeddutch-precast-concrete-blocks-could-be-hazardous-waste/8672933.article, 25/12/2017).
24. Romero D., J. James, R. Mora and C. D. Hays (2013), ‘Study on the mechanical and
environmental properties of concrete containing cathode ray tube glass aggregate’, Waste
Management, Vol 33, 1659–1666.
25. Sikora P., E. Horszczaruk and T. Rucinska (2015), ‘The effect of nanosilica and titanium dioxide
on the mechanical and self-cleaning properties of waste-glass cement mortar’, Procedia
Engineering, Vol 108, 146-153.
26. Sua-iam, G. and N. Makul (2013), ‘Use of limestone powder during incorporation of Pbcontaining cathode ray tube waste in self-compacting concrete’, Journal of Environmental
Management, Vol 128, pp. 931-940.
27. U.S. EPA (1996), ‘Test Methods for Evaluating Solid Waste’, SW-846, 3rd ed., Office of Solid
Waste, Washington, DC.
28. Yu M., L. Liu and J. Li (2016), An overall solution to cathode-ray tube (CRT) glass recycling,
The Tenth International Conference on Waste Management and Technology (ICWMT), Procedia
Environmental Sciences, Vol 31, 887 – 896.
29. Zhao H., C. S. Poon and T. C. Ling (2013a), Properties of mortar prepared with recycled cathode
ray tube funnel glass sand at different mineral admixture, Construction and Building Materials,
Vol 40, pp. 951-960.
410
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
A SYSTEM DYNAMICS MODEL FOR SMALL HOUSEHOLD
APPLIANCES’ WASTE MANAGEMENT: A CASE OF TURKEY
A.Kemal Konyalıoğlu* and İ.Bereketli Zafeirakopoulos
Department of Industrial Engineering, Galatasaray University, Istanbul, Turkey
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: konyalioglua@itu.edu.tr
Abstract
Nowadays sustainability is one of the most important subjects in the developing world. Thanks to
sustainability, waste management also gains more importance. Waste management is composed of
many sub-areas in which liquid, gas or solid wastes are treated. The waste category that will be studied
in this paper is waste of electric and electronic equipment (WEEE) under solid wastes. Turkey is a
country whose household appliances sector is outstandingly large. Furthermore, many small
household appliances are thrown away or destroyed due to end of life or quality issues. Most of those
wastes do not go through any treatment process even if Turkey has collection and recovery targets
for all WEEE categories. As they are not properly treated, the process to destroy without reusing or
recycling them causes environmental damage.
The aim of this paper is to put forward a system dynamics model for increasing recovery options of
waste of small household appliances in electric and electronic sector, which is not treated in an
environmentally friendly way. The proposed model provides decrease in environmental damage.
In this model, Anylogic program will be used for the simulation of the proposed system dynamics
model. Different scenarios will be conducted to give recommendations on how the whole system
works in the case of Turkey.
Keywords: Waste management, System dynamics, WEEE, Sustainable supply chain management
1.
INTRODUCTION
Waste management, which effects on sustainability in every aspect, is an important topic in the world.
Sustainability can be taken into consideration in three main areas which include economic, social and
environmental dimensions [Dyllick and Hockerts, 2002]. Waste management is particularly included
in environmental sustainability. For pursuing a “sustainable” policy, each waste has an important
topic to investigate and one of them is Waste of electric and electronic equipment (WEEE). As the
number of households using electric and electronic equipment increases and technological
improvements go further year by year, management of WEEE becomes more important. This
equipment can be classified as large household appliances and small household appliances on which
Turkey has recycling and recovery targets according to the WEEE Regulation which was published
in 2008 (URL1). Furthermore, recovery and recycling targets are qualified based on the types of
wastes which can be taken into consideration by collecting, economic and technical dimensions
(Fischer, 2011).
In Turkey, electric and electronic sector is sharply growing thanks to technological improvements
and needs. Thus, environmental perspective is dependently changing since production and
consumption of this equipment causes an increase in pollution and decrease in resources. To avoid
these damages, Turkish government and enterprises in Turkey developed regulations to enable reuse
or recycling of the electric and electronic equipment. One of those fields is white good sector
411
Solid waste management
including small household appliances. There are humble eco-design efforts for small household
appliances in Turkey however unless there is a strict waste management policy those efforts will not
be sufficient. To have a holistic environmental sustainability, not only production process but also
recovery processes for end-of-life products are important. This can be perceived as a whole system
or process because in the whole system, each detail matters from suppliers to the recycling facility.
[Jie and Buekens, 2014].
The aim of the study is to recommend a system dynamics model for minimizing wastes of small
household appliances in Turkey and maximizing recovery applications instead of disposing them.
The study will also help to understand how environmental sustainability concept works in Turkey.
There exists a lot of studies about wastes of electric and electronic equipment in Turkey but there are
not many especially focusing on waste management of small household appliances by using a system
dynamic model.
The study includes four main parts: introduction, background, methodology and modeling which
includes system dynamics and waste management of small household appliances’ model, and finally
conclusion and future studies.
2.
BACKGROUND
Building a system for waste management is seen as one of the most crucial parts in terms of
environmental waste management. A waste management system mainly describes the management
of all tasks including responsibilities, routines, actions, measures and resources building a system
which intends to manage wastes and abides by regulations. Besides, waste management is an
important part in terms of economy and society. All countries, which are currently developing or
developed, produce many types of wastes.
Furthermore, choosing the option between reusing, recycling and waste energy utilization, collection
and processing without discounting the lowest total (social) cost and deciding the value obtained by
selling the collected materials, will be of social benefit. [Inghels et al., 2011]. Effective solid waste
management systems, which must be sustainable in nature and economics, are needed to provide
better human health and safety [Saxena et al, 2010].
The amount of wastes has been increasing because of growing population and increasing needs for
raw materials in a range including usual wastes and wastes of electric and electronic equipment
(WEEE) [Takiguchi, 2016]. WEEE can be defined as an electrically operated device that no longer
satisfies the user or manufacturer for a specific purpose. (Sinha-Khetriwal et al, 2005). If WEEE is
mismanaged; these wastes can clearly affect the environment and the human health. Environmental
regulatory agencies; electronic equipment manufacturers, retailers and non-governmental
organizations are quite concerned with the updated statistical data to which WEEE is produced,
stored, recycled, or discarded [Jang, 2010]. With the rapid development and use of electronic devices,
the WEEE problem is growing rapidly in all countries. WEEE wastes appear many times in
developing or emerging countries which cannot have any important infrastructure to manage WEEE
problems. [Safdar et al., 2015]. On the other hand, in developed countries, for example in EU
countries, it is expected that the EU will reduce its long-term differences in the level of recycling by
linking its minimum recycling targets. In the last 15 years, the EU Member States have been able to
change their perception of waste management. In the mid-1990s, EU member states have been able
to gain more wastes and recycled them. They have made a very good start, although they need to do
more things [Fischer, 2011]. In addition to developed countries, not only managing WEEE or
associated researches but also legal arrangements have sped up in recent years with its conduction by
Special Wastes Management Department at Waste Management Department. Collection of e-waste
in Turkey, transports, recoveries are carried out by companies which the Ministry of Environment
and Urbanization approves. When the E-device category and tags are placed; compliance documents
are also given for collection, separation and reusing by the same Ministry [Öztürk, 2015].
412
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
There are many models to suggest new options of how to manage wastes. One of them is system
dynamics modeling.
3.
METHODOLOGY AND MODELLING
3.1 System dynamics
As a definition, system dynamics makes possible to understand and improve system thinking and
operations management systems. After all, as a first step, we have to deal with the real world in many
steps. It is possible to define system dynamics by better understanding equations of a model,
simulation to understand dynamic behaviors, evaluation of other alternatives, selection and
implementation of a better method. [Forrester, 1994] In this case, Al-Khatib et al. (2016) suggested
a more understandable and sophisticated simulation method for hospital waste management by using
system dynamics model. Also, Lee et al. (2015) proposed a system dynamics approach based on
functional dynamics to evaluate product-service systems. In the production area, system dynamics is
again used by Greasley (2005) to provide a discrete-event simulation method. Botha et al.(2017),
used system dynamics modeling to compare three inventory management methods for theoretical and
actual, daily data set by comparing the parameters of stock target settings.
System dynamics model is not only used in production field. For example, in financial field, Nair and
Rodrigues (2013) explained financial parameters during production expansion by using system
dynamics. . On the other hand, in management area, Barnabè (2011) suggested a balanced scorecard
method based on system dynamics to evaluate strategic decision making. In education field,
Pedamallu (?) applied a system dynamics model to evaluate educational infrastructure based on the
quality of primary school of a developing country. As well, in health area, Devi et al. (2010) studied
system dynamics modeling for the waiting list of corneal transplants patients.
Aside from many areas, also about WEEE, system dynamics models can be proposed. For example,
Ghisolfi et al. (2016) presented a system dynamics model to investigate legal bargaining power and
incentives for the waste pickers of desktops and laptops measured by the volume of wastes.
Furthermore, to mention Anylogic simulation program, it can be said that Anylogic is a simulation
program used for mainly discrete event, agent-based simulation and system dynamics. Also, by the
program, some graphs resulting from the simulation can be obtained (URL4).
3.2 Model for the waste management of small household appliances
In this study, recycling and recovery targets and total number of small household appliances in Turkey
will be used. The proposed model, given in Figure 1, aims to increase recovery options for decreasing
environmental damage by decreasing CO2 emission and increasing recovery options. The model runs
without any error by using simulation software; Anylogic. According to GFK’s press release (URL2),
the number of small household appliances sold out in Turkey is estimated to 17, 3 million (2017).
The supply chain starts from suppliers, which provide raw materials for production. According to Lu
(2011), a supply chain can basically be defined as a group of independent establishments which are
connected to each other by products and services that are collectively adding value to transmit them
for final consumer. In the model, three suppliers have been taken into consideration as representative.
These three suppliers defined as stock variable, provide raw materials for production process. The
production process which is in the model is hereby considered as a total amount of all small household
appliances’ companies in Turkey. As there is noeffective and real data, system dynamics model has
been constructed by using the total sold small household appliances in Turkey and 2018 target.
Besides, after the main distributor, there are 3 sub-distributors to reach end consumers. End
consumers are assumed to change their products intentionally or at the end of life cycle in the model.
The used products are collected in general waste collection centers or municipality waste collection
centers. For attracting wastes and increasing social benefit, municipalities can apply a campaign or
inform public to create awareness. In this case, small household appliances are collected to be
recycled, incinerated or be thrown away.
413
Solid waste management
Figure 1: System dynamics model of small household appliances’ waste management in
Turkey
In Figure 2, the relationship between production and waste amount is given. The amount of
production and waste is directly proportional. The decreasing point of production is explained as the
raw material taken from suppliers is a dynamic variable. It seasonally changes according to the
demand. Besides, as production increases, wastes also increase. Wastes thereby change and
sometimes have different increasing and decreasing points. Model has been simulated for nearly 65
years and the result is in Figure 2.
Amount (million ton)
Figure 2: The relationship between wastes and production amounts
It is assumed that 50% of small household wastes in Turkey are going to be recycled by 2018
according to the recycling target of small household appliances which was published in the Official
Gazette of Turkey in 2012 (URL3). All assumptions are based on this official target. Hence, in this
model, 50% of total expired, broke-down and intentionally changed products go into recycling
process. The proposed model has two main recycling collections’ locations: a municipality collection
center and a waste collection center. According to the official Gazette (2012), municipality collections
have different targets from city to city.
Municipalities can use a campaign to increase public awareness for bringing expired, break-down of
changed small household appliances to municipalities’ recycling centers. In this model, it is used as
a motivating and positive factor affecting municipality collection amounts.
414
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Generally, all appliances are collected in waste collection centers in the model. The quantity of small
household appliances gone into waste centers is assumed according to the target of 50% and
proportionally, expired, broken or changed products are distributed accordingly. In Turkey, some
electronic equipment companies have their own recycling centers. However, only one of these
companies is put in the model as representative. Government or municipalities can sell the products
to be recycled to electronic companies and these companies can use campaigns to attract appliances
to their recycling centers. Companies can use these appliances in favor of their own companies or sell
to public or governments after recycling or during recycling process. As indicated in the model,
appliances recycled by government or companies can directly go into production processes. On the
other hand, the rest of appliances which is not recycled, named as garbage, cannot be in the production
process again. They can be incinerated or thrown away, not be reused. In this case, government and
companies can make campaigns to create public awareness. In Turkey, some companies exchange
old appliances with new ones, in order to recycle them.
Furthermore, it is obtained that Incineration-Garbage rate decrease while recycling amount increases
as given in Figure 3. This relationship shows that as the amount of small household appliances thrown
away or incinerated decreases due to the campaign effects and awareness.
In this model, there are three additional effects that are used. These effects are assumed constant
numbers and while running the model, it is seen that they have a positive and enhancing effect on
waste collection amount and recovery options.
These effects can be explained as:
1. Campaign Effect: This effect considers “bring the old one and take the new one” situation, which
means consumers can pay a lower price for a new appliance. From the producers’ point of view,
it means reaching governmental target by collecting appliances.
2. Company Effect: This effect includes the governmental effect that provides the company,
government support if they encourage recycling and recycling centers.
3. Municipality Campaign Effect: Consumers sometimes do not prefer to bring their old small
household appliances to companies or private recycling centers. In other words, they can bring
their appliances to municipality recycling centers. Municipalities can provide public awareness
by campaigns about environmental protection.
In the model, carbon emission and social factor are also accounted. The carbon emission has been
affiliated by the number of appliances brought to waste collection center.
Garbage and Incineration rate over production
Figure 3: Relationship between recycling and Incineration-Garbage Rate
415
Solid waste management
4.
CONCLUSION AND FUTURE STUDIES
In this study, a system dynamics approach has been studied for small household appliances’ waste
management in Turkey. The model was run by using Anylogic simulation program. The study mainly
shows that the proposed model can support a more effective and enhanced view about small
household appliances’ waste management. Developed and supported waste collection centers by
municipalities, government or companies provide a more intensive and increased recovery option,
while it decreases garbage and incineration rate. In the model, several factors have been considered
in order that recycled products can be added to production line according to the target of Turkey. The
real data of the proposed system is limitedly used, because of lack of data, but main future targets
have been put in the model. The system dynamics model at this point suggests also that campaign
effects and company effects are outstandingly important in order to bring wastes to waste centers and
to inform public or increase public awareness about recycling. It has also been obtained that carbon
emission decreases and social factor increases when the system works without any errors. The model
also calculates how many of small household appliances in Turkey will be in process of recycling in
order to reach the target of Turkey by 2018.
For future studies, the real data should be used for all variables mentioned in the model and if the
data of companies can be obtained, the model can be revised.
References
1. Al-Khatib, I. A., Eleyan, D., & Garfield, J. (2016). A system dynamics approach for hospital
waste management in a city in a developing country: the case of Nablus,
Palestine. Environmental monitoring and assessment, 188(9), 503.
2. Barnabè, F. (2011). A "system dynamics-based balanced scorecard" to support strategic decision
making. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 60(5), 446473. http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/17410401111140383.
3. Botha, A., Grobler, J., & Yadavalli, V. S. (2017). System dynamics comparison of three inventory
management models in an automotive parts supply chain. Journal of Transport and Supply
Chain Management, 11(1), 1-12.
4. Buekens, A., & Yang, J. (2014). Recycling of WEEE plastics: A review. The Journal of
Material
Cycles
and
Waste
Management, 16(3),
415-434.
doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10163-014-0241-2
5. Devi, S. P., Rao, K. S., Krishnaswamy, S., & Wang, S. (2010). System dynamics model for
simulation of the dynamics of corneal transplants. Opsearch, 47(4), 284-292.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s12597-010-0023-0
6. Dyllick, T., & Hockerts, K. (2002). Beyond the business
sustainability. Business Strategy and the Environment, 11(2), 130.
case
for
corporate
7. Fischer, C. (2011). The development and achievements of EU waste policy. The Journal of
Material Cycles and Waste Management, 13(1), 2-9. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10163010-0311-z
8. Forrester, J. W. (1994), System dynamics, systems thinking, and soft OR. Syst. Dyn. Rev., 10:
245–256. doi:10.1002/sdr.4260100211
9. Ghisolfi, V., Chaves, G. D. L. D., Siman, R. R., & Xavier, L. H. (2017). System dynamics applied
to closed loop supply chains of desktops and laptops in Brazil: A perspective for social inclusion
of waste pickers. Waste Management, 60, 14-31.
416
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
10. Greasley, A. (2005). Using system dynamics in a discrete-event simulation study of a
manufacturing plant. International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 25(5),
534-548. Retrieved from http://160.75.22.2/docview/232358137?accountid=11638
11. Inghels, D., & Dullaert, W. (2011). An analysis of household waste management policy using
system dynamics modelling. Waste Management & Research, 29(4), 351-370.
12. Jang, Y. C. (2010). Waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE) management in Korea:
generation, collection, and recycling systems. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste
Management, 12(4), 283-294.
13. Lee, S., Han, W., & Park, Y. (2015). Measuring the functional dynamics of product-service
system: A system dynamics approach. Computers & Industrial Engineering, 80, 159.
Retrieved from http://160.75.22.2/docview/1649225891?accountid=11638
14. Lu, D. (2011). Fundamentals of supply chain management. Bookboon.
15. Nair, G. K., & Raj Rodrigues, L. L. (2013). Dynamics of financial system: A system dynamics
approach. International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, 3(1), 14-n/a. Retrieved
from http://160.75.22.2/docview/1266465919?accountid=11638
16. Öztürk, T. (2015). Generation and management of electrical–electronic waste (e-waste) in
Turkey. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 17(3), 411-421.
17. Pedamallu, C., Ozdamar, L., Ganesh, L., Weber, G., & Kropat, E. (2010). A system dynamics
model
for improving primary education
enrollment in
a developing
country. Organizacija, 43(3), 90. http://dx.doi.org/10.2478/v10051-010-0010-5
18. Safdar Shah Khan, Suleman A. Lodhi, Faiza Akhtar, (2015) "Sustainable WEEE management
solution for developing countries applying human activity system modeling", Management of
Environmental Quality: An International Journal, Vol. 26 Issue: 1, pp.84102, https://doi.org/10.1108/MEQ-05-2014-0072
19. Saxena, S., Srivastava, R. K., & Samaddar, A. B. (2010). Towards sustainable municipal solid
waste management in Allahabad City. Management of Environmental Quality: An
International Journal, 21(3), 308-323.
20. Sinha-Khetriwal, D., Kraeuchi, P., & Schwaninger, M. (2005). A comparison of electronic waste
recycling in Switzerland and in India. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 25(5), 492504.
21. Atık Yönetimi Eylem Planı: 2008-2012. (2008, May). Retrieved from: http://www.cygm.gov.tr/cygm/files/eylemplan/atikeylemplani.pdf
22. Küçük Ev Aletleri Yeni Trendlerle Büyüyor. (2017, July 19). Retrieved from:
http://www.gfk.com/en-gb/insights/press-release/kuecuek-ev-aletleri-yeni-trendlerle-bueyueyor/
23. Resmi Gazete-Official Gazette (2012, May 22) Retrieved from: http://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2012/05/20120522-5.htm
24. Anylogic simulation (2017, May 3) Retrieved from: https://www.anylogic.com/
417
Solid waste management
RAPID STABILIZATION OF MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE IN
BIOREACTOR LANDFILLS: PREDICTIVE PERFORMANCE
USING COUPLED MODELING
G. Kumar and K. R. Reddy*
University of Illinois at Chicago, Department of Civil & Materials Engineering, 842 West Taylor
Street, Chicago, IL 60607, USA
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: kreddy@uic.edu, tel : +13129964755
Abstract
Municipal solid waste (MSW) landfills are one of the major and most preferred waste management
options in the United States and many other countries across the globe. The waste in conventional
MSW landfills undergoes very slow decomposition due to limited amount of moisture. In this regard,
the bioreactor landfills have emerged as an effective waste management option, wherein leachate
recirculation/injection is carried out to enhance the moisture levels within the waste thereby
facilitating rapid waste decomposition and leading to early waste stabilization. However, in practice
the performance of bioreactor landfills has remained inconclusive due to the lack of sound basis for
effective design and operation of such landfills. This further stems from the fact that there is a limited
understanding of the physical, chemical and biological processes and their coupled interactions on
the MSW behavior in landfills. Hence, it becomes imperative to understand the influence of the
coupled processes on the overall performance of bioreactor landfills. Several researchers have
developed numerical models to simulate landfill systems but only a few models have considered the
simultaneous interactions of hydraulic, mechanical, and biological processes in the landfill. In this
study, newly developed numerical framework incorporating coupled thermo-hydro-bio-mechanical
processes is presented. The numerical model has the ability to predict the spatial and temporal
variation of waste temperatures, moisture distribution, gas generation, pore pressures, waste
settlement, waste slope stability, and interface shear response in the landfill liner system. The
numerical model has been validated with lab-scale and field-scale experiments and could be used to
design and operate stable and effective bioreactor landfills.
Keywords: Solid waste management; bioreactor landfills; leachate recirculation; coupled processes;
numerical modeling
1.
INTRODUCTION
Landfilling of municipal solid waste, although being the least preferred option, is the most dominant
method of managing waste in U.S. and many other countries across the globe. In the light of steady
increase in the population and rapid urbanization, the amount of waste produced is also increasing
considerably. According to United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), about 254
million tons of MSW was produced in 2014 of which 136 million tons was landfilled (USEPA, 2016).
The current practices for construction of traditional engineered landfills that just serve as waste
containment systems are well established. This isolated system primarily contains the landfilled MSW
in a relatively dry state and is designed with cover systems to prevent infiltration of water from the
precipitation and with leachate collection and removal systems to remove any leachate accumulated
over the bottom liner system. This in turn results in a very dry condition within MSW and
consequently slow decomposition of the organic matter (biodegradable constituents) within the waste
418
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
due to the lack of adequate moisture. The slow decomposition of waste leads to several problems
such as low gas generation rates, prolonged waste stabilization periods, increased post-closure
monitoring requirements, increased leachate treatment and disposal costs, and a long-term liability of
the land use with no beneficial purpose.
In recent years the idea of bioreactor landfills has gained wide attention because of its numerous
benefits that can lead to sustainable waste management. A schematic of the operation of bioreactor
landfill is shown in Fig. 1. The bioreactor landfill uses the concept of an anaerobic digester, wherein
the favorable conditions for rapid biodegradation of organic matter within the waste are maintained
to accelerate the waste stabilization. In the field, these favorable conditions are achieved by
recirculation of leachate and other permitted liquids along with supplemental nutrients and/or
inoculum of microbes, thus enhancing the moisture levels essential for rapid waste decomposition.
Thus, bioreactor landfills offer several benefits such as rapid waste decomposition, increased gas
generation rates, high settlement rates and early waste stabilization. In addition, there are other
secondary benefits such as reduced post-closure monitoring cost, reduced leachate treatment and
disposal costs, and landfill space reclamation. Several laboratory studies and field-scale pilot tests
have been performed confirming the enhanced decomposition of MSW with leachate recirculation
into the waste mass. Although the leachate recirculation seems to be a viable concept, there are no
established design practices for leachate recirculation, mainly due to the inherent heterogeneity and
anisotropy associated with the MSW. Unlike conventional landfills where leachate generation is
limited, bioreactor landfills operate on leachate recirculation and if the leachate levels and pore
pressures induced by recirculation are not properly managed, it may cause instability in landfill.
Figure 1: Schematic of Bioreactor Landfill and its Fundamental Operations
In this regard, several numerical modeling efforts were carried out, to investigate the effectiveness of
different leachate recirculation systems (LRS) in various configurations for uniformly distributing
the injected leachate while maintaining the stability of landfill slopes under pressurized leachate
injections (see Reddy et al. 2017a). However, most of these studies neglected the effects of
biodegradation and its consequent effects from settlement and gas generation on the fluid flow within
the waste. The overall performance of a bioreactor landfill is influenced by several interdependent
processes including the leachate flow and distribution, waste settlement due to the overburden stress
and mass loss induced by waste decomposition, changes in the shear strength of the waste with
degradation, and changes in temperature and heat generated from waste decomposition. Thus, there
exists a complex system of simultaneously occurring and interdependent processes within the waste
mass. There have also been several numerical investigations that looked at the coupled behavior of
MSW accounting for the hydraulic, biochemical and mechanical behavior of MSW into a numerical
model to simulate the coupled hydro-bio-mechanical response of MSW in landfills. But these models
do not holistically assess the influence of the coupled processes on the performance of other
engineered components of a landfill in terms of their stability and integrity within the landfill. In
419
Solid waste management
addition, most of the studies did not account for the heat generation and thermal behavior within the
landfill and furthermore, if they did incorporate the effects of heat generation on the transient
temperature distribution its influence on the biodegradation of waste mass was not accounted.
In this study a mathematical framework is formulated that can holistically assess the overall
performance of the landfill by accounting for the interdependency of hydraulic (fluid flow and pore
fluid pressure distribution), mechanical (stress and deformation, waste settlement and slope stability),
biological (waste decomposition and gas generation) and thermal (heat generation and temperature
distribution) processes within the MSW. A brief review of literature on the attempts to model MSW
behavior in bioreactor landfills is presented and some of the major challenges associated with
numerical modeling of MSW behavior in such landfills are presented.
2.
COUPLED PROCESSES IN MSW LANDFILLS
Municipal solid waste is a highly heterogeneous porous media with its properties (physical,
mechanical and biological) varying spatially across the landfill due to inherent differences in waste
composition. In addition, the rapid decomposition of the waste under leachate recirculation further
exacerbates the situation by causing temporal changes in the waste properties. Thus, the overall
performance of a bioreactor landfill is dictated by the combined effect of several interdependent
system processes including hydraulic, mechanical, biochemical and thermal processes. A detailed
explanation of each of the system processes and their interactions with one another is explained in
this section. A schematic of the major system processes and their interactions within the MSW
landfills is shown in Fig. 2.
Figure 2: Major Processes and their Coupled Interactions in MSW Landfills
The hydraulic processes within the bioreactor landfills include the fluid flow (leachate flow) and the
resulting distribution of moisture and pore-fluid pressures (liquid and gas phase). Due to the relatively
low moisture availability in the MSW pore spaces, the fluid flow is generally and suitably assumed
to follow unsaturated fluid flow behavior. Moreover, the decomposition of waste generates landfill
gas (predominantly methane and carbon dioxide) leading to the gas flow and development of pore
gas pressures within the MSW pore space that can have a great influence on the transient leachate
420
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
flow and distribution. Thus, a two-phase flow (essentially a multi-phase flow) behavior can be used
to adequately simulate the unsaturated fluid flow within the waste mass.
The mechanical behavior of the waste is influenced by the overburden stress from the overlying waste
layers and this differs spatially based on the landfill geometry and the spatially varying waste
properties. The deformation and consequently the settlement of the waste is partially influenced by
the mechanical properties of the waste (e.g. stiffness or modulus, strength parameters). However, the
mechanical properties of the waste change temporally as the waste degrades and hence the settlement
of the waste induced by overburden stress. In addition to this, a significant amount of the waste
settlement is borne out of the mass loss (conversion of biodegradable solids to landfill gas) resulting
from the periodic increase and decrease in void spaces within the waste. This contributes to the
majority of the waste settlement in MSW landfills.
The biochemical behavior of the waste is mainly dependent on the waste composition. Typically,
most of the readily degradable matter is found to be cellulosic and hemi-cellulosic in nature and it
contributes the most to the total landfill gas production. A majority of the biodegradation takes place
anaerobically due to oxygen deprived conditions within the waste mass. The major biochemical
reactions leading to the landfill gas production are hydrolysis involving the breakdown of higher
molecular weight organic compounds to easily degradable monomers, followed by acid production
(typically acetic acid) by microbially aided acidogenesis through fermentative bacteria, and finally
the generation of methane by methanogenic bacteria. In all of this, the leachate chemistry and the
biochemical reaction kinetics dictate the generation of landfill gas. Moreover, the biodegradation
process is influenced by many factors including, temperature, pH, and moisture among others.
The anaerobic biodegradation of organic matter in the MSW releases heat which influences the
temperature within the waste mass. Furthermore, the resulting temperature in turn dictates the
biodegradation of waste mass since the optimum degradation of waste occurs only at a certain
temperature range. In addition, the overall spatial and temporal distributions of temperatures within
the waste are influenced by the seasonal temperature changes as well. Thus, understanding the
thermal behavior of MSW and incorporating its influence on the other system processes in a landfill
plays a significant role in a better prediction of the overall performance of the landfill.
Each of the above-mentioned processes occur and interact simultaneously influencing the overall
behavior of MSW. For example, the fluid flow (leachate and gas) within the MSW is dictated by the
porosity, available moisture and the permeability of waste for the fluids. However, the decomposition
of waste that occurs simultaneously as the fluid flows through the MSW causes the mass loss resulting
in changes in the void spaces (porosity) and in turn influences the fluid flow thereafter. In addition,
the increase in the void spaces can cause the waste to settle under the overburden stresses causing
changes in the pore fluid pressures. Furthermore, the changing void space (void ratio) alters the
moisture availability in MSW across the landfill, consequently influencing the biodegradation rates
of MSW at different locations in the landfill. The temperature dependent heat generation constantly
influences the biodegradation of MSW and thereby the other processes impacted by the
biodegradation of waste. It is quite evident that the landfill system is a unique and complex multiphase
system with several processes occurring simultaneously in a coupled manner. It is of utmost
importance to understand the individual system processes and their coupled interactions accurately
to have a good prediction on the performance of a landfill system thereby enabling safe and effective
construction and operation of bioreactor landfills.
3.
PREVIOUS INVESTIGATIONS ON BIOREACTOR LANDFILLS
Over the past few years a comprehensive research has been performed at the University of Illinois at
Chicago (UIC) on bioreactor landfills involving field investigations, laboratory tests on MSW
samples and numerical modeling of MSW behavior based on the characteristics of MSW as observed
from the experimental studies. A list of all the previous studies on bioreactor landfills performed at
UIC is shown in Table 1. A thorough field investigation was performed to determine the variation of
421
Solid waste management
in-situ moisture and density variation with depth and leachate injection were monitored to
characterize the field waste. In addition, geophysical testing was performed to determine other
dynamic and mechanical properties of waste. Several laboratory investigations were performed which
involved testing of field MSW samples from a leachate recirculation landfill for their geotechnical
properties such as the compressibility, shear strength, hydraulic conductivity, specific gravity, unit
weight and other crucial properties. These properties were further evaluated at different stages of
waste degradation to determine the effect of degradation on waste properties. In addition, biochemical
testing was performed on the field MSW samples to determine the biochemical properties of MSW.
All of the tests performed on field MSW samples were also performed on synthetic waste to have a
control on the degradation and thereby evaluate the variation in waste properties with time.
Table 1: Previous Research on Bioreactor Landfills at UIC
Research
Type
Field
Investigation
Laboratory
Investigation
Numerical
Modeling/
Simulation
Topic of the Study
Reference
In-situ properties of MSW at a leachate
recirculating landfill
Grellier et al. (2006, 2007)
Geophysical testing for evaluating dynamic
properties of MSW
Carpenter et al. (2013a,b)
Field Monitoring and performance assessment of
bioreactor landfill
Reddy et al. (2009a)
Laboratory testing of geotechnical properties
(compressibility, shear strength, hydraulic
conductivity, etc.) of field and synthetic waste
samples
Reddy et al. (2009b,d,e);
Reddy et al. (2009b);
Settlement modeling
Babu et al. (2010, 2011)
Modeling single phase (liquid) fluid flow in
bioreactor landfills to evaluate the moisture
distribution by different leachate injection systems
Reddy et al. (2011);
Reddy et al. (2015a)
Kulkarni and Reddy (2012);
Reddy et al. (2013a,b);
Reddy et al. (2014);
Giri and Reddy (2014a);
Reddy et al. (2015b,c)
Slope stability under pressurized leachate injection
Giri and Reddy (2014b,c);
Giri and Reddy (2015a)
Modeling of coupled hydro-mechanical processes
Giri and Reddy (2015d)
Modeling of coupled hydro-bio-mechanical
processes
Reddy et al. (2017a,b);
Reddy et al. (2018a,b)
Numerical modeling techniques are a great tool in simulating the coupled processes within MSW. It
has been extensively used in order to understand the behavior of MSW and the influence it has on the
performance of different components of a landfill. It is quite essential to maintain the integrity and
stability of landfill components such as the liner and cover systems along with the stability of landfill
slopes for a holistic assessment of the performance of a landfill system. In the recent years, a
progressive modeling effort has been laid on trying to accurately simulate the different processes and
their interactions. Most of the initial numerical studies on bioreactor landfills performed in this regard
neglected the combined effects of different processes and mainly focused on the hydraulic aspects of
bioreactor landfills (e.g. moisture and pore pressure distribution). Some of the studies evaluated the
effectiveness of different subsurface leachate recirculation systems (horizontal trenches, vertical
422
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
injection wells, drainage blankets) in uniformly distributing the injected leachate (Kulkarni and
Reddy 2012; Reddy et al. 2013a,b; Reddy et al. 2014; Giri and Reddy 2014a; Reddy et al. 2015b,c).
Thereafter, the study was focused on evaluating the stability of landfill slopes under different injection
pressures or flow rates (Giri and Reddy 2014b,c; Giri and Reddy 2015a). Design recommendations
were developed based on these investigations suggesting the safe injection pressures and setback
distance for locating the injection system from the landfill slope that needs to be followed.
Recently, there have also been efforts to incorporate the coupled interactions between hydraulic,
mechanical and biological processes into the numerical model to predict the MSW behavior in
landfills (Reddy et al. 2017a). These studies focused on simulating the coupled hydro-bio-mechanical
processes to try and understand the complexity associated with the MSW behavior within the landfill
and how it affects the holistic performance of a bioreactor landfill. In this regard a mathematical
modeling framework that incorporates the coupled hydro-bio-mechanical processes and its impacts
on the stability and integrity of the landfill system has been formulated. In particular, this
mathematical framework integrates a two-phase flow hydraulic model, a 2-D plain strain mechanical
model, and a first order decay biodegradation model. The entire mathematical framework is
implemented in a commercial software named FLAC.
The two-phase flow model built-in FLAC simulates the saturated-unsaturated fluid flow based on the
Darcy’s law. The hydraulic conductivity of the fluids under unsaturated conditions is given by the
relative permeability functions of the van Genuchten form (van Genuchten, 1980). The mechanical
model for MSW involves the 2-D plain strain formulation of Mohr-Coulomb constitutive law to
simulate the stress-strain behavior of MSW. The biodegradation of waste is simulated using the first
order decay kinetics. The gas generation from waste degradation is similar to the USEPA’s LandGEM
model. However, the biodegradation model formulated in this study incorporates the effect of
changing moisture as fluid flows through the MSW on the rate of biodegradation of waste. The extent
of waste degradation at a location in the landfill is derived from the gas produced and the biochemical
methane potential of the waste. Meanwhile as the biodegradation takes place the waste properties also
change as per the correlations developed between the extent of degradation and the geotechnical
properties of the waste from previous experimental investigations on field MSW samples, thus
simulating a transient coupled hydro-bio-mechanical behavior of MSW. A detailed explanation of
the entire numerical framework and simulations performed using the abovementioned numerical
framework is presented in Reddy et al. (2017b). Some of the results obtained from these numerical
simulations performed using the numerical framework is presented in this study.
Fig. 3a shows the comparison of the variation of surface settlement with time for a conventional and
bioreactor landfill. It can be observed that total settlement in both the cases is the same due to the
same amount of waste and its composition in both conventional and bioreactor landfill simulation.
However, the time it takes for attaining the total settlement in a bioreactor landfill is significantly less
than the conventional landfill. This is mainly because of the higher rates of biodegradation in
bioreactor landfill due to the availability of moisture. Thus, the numerical model could simulate the
different landfill settlement behavior with and without recirculation reasonably well. Likewise, three
numerical simulations of a landfill with the same waste conditions and landfill geometry were carried
out. However, each of the three simulations incorporated different system processes. The first
simulation represented a bioreactor landfill (with leachate injection) but neglected the effect of
biodegradation on the MSW behavior (coupled hydro-mechanical simulation). The second simulation
represented a conventional landfill (with no leachate injection) and the third simulation represented a
bioreactor landfill (with leachate injection) but incorporated the effect of biodegradation on MSW
behavior. The three landfill models were evaluated for their slope stability under different simulated
conditions. For the coupled hydro-mechanical simulation the factor of safety (FOS) against slope
stability decreased continuously with increasing pore pressures from leachate injection (see Fig. 3b).
For the coupled bio-mechanical simulation, there were no excess pore pressures as such in the system
due to the absence of pressurized leachate injection. Thus, the FOS values almost remained constant
over the entire simulation. However, for the coupled hydro-bio-mechanical simulation resulted in an
423
Solid waste management
initial decrease in the FOS values until certain time where the effect of increasing pore pressures was
dominant. Meanwhile the changes in the waste properties (increasing unit weight, increasing cohesive
strength of waste) resulted in an overall increase in the slope stability as indicated by the increase in
FOS values. In the long-term with substantial settlement and dissipated pore water pressures and
limited changes in the waste properties the FOS values reached equilibrium. Hence, incorporating the
effects of biodegradation along with other processes is essential for accurate prediction of the stability
of a bioreactor landfill.
3
5
Bioreactor Landfill
Conventional Landfill
5
Factor of Safety
Surface Settlement (m)
4
6
7
8
9
4
Coupled Hydro-Mechanical Simulation
Coupled Bio-Mechanical Simulation
Coupled Hydro-Bio-Mechanical Simulation
3
10
2
11
12
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
0
Time Duration (Years)
10
20
30
40
50
60
Time (Years)
Fig. 3: (a) Variation of Surface Settlement in Conventional and Bioreactor Landfill; (b)
Variation of Factor of Safety of Landfill Slope with Elapsed Time for coupled hydromechanical, coupled bio-mechanical and coupled hydro-bio-mechanical simulation
4.
SUMMARY AND ONGOING RESEARCH
Bioreactor landfills are an attractive option for effective and efficient management of waste. They
offer numerous advantages over the traditionally constructed and operated landfills in several aspects.
Moreover, in the light of sustainable development, bioreactor landfills prove to be an ideal concept
of waste management. However, there are no rigorous procedures or guidelines for safe design of
such landfills. Unlike conventional landfills, the construction and operation of bioreactor landfills
require adequate knowledge and accuracy on the required moisture levels within the landfill, the
injection pressures and flow rates all of which depends on a good estimation of the properties of
waste. One of the major concerns in leachate recirculating landfills is to ensure uniform distribution
of moisture across the landfill space, which is hindered by the lack of understanding of the hydraulic
behavior in MSW. In addition, the biodegradation of MSW makes the understanding of the landfill
system quite complex due to the interdependency of the hydraulic flow, mechanical response and
biodegradation on one another. Thus, understanding these individual processes and their interactions
will aid in simulating this behavior mathematically thereby allowing us to design safe and effective
bioreactor landfills.
Several researchers have performed numerous studies to numerically simulate the coupled processes
and evaluate the performance of the landfill system. However, these studies do have some limitations
from the simplification made in simulating the hydraulic, mechanical and biochemical processes. The
current research at UIC is focused on addressing the research challenges pertaining to adequate
mathematical description and accurate simulation of the biochemical reactions and their kinetics
within the MSW. None of the existing coupled models account for the influence of heat generation
and temperature distribution within the landfill on the biodegradation of MSW. Thus, numerical
424
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
modeling of temperature distribution and heat generation within the landfill is currently being carried
out to have an accurate description of the biodegradation of MSW. In addition, accurate simulation
of the mechanical response of the waste undergoing degradation is another important ongoing
research topic at UIC. Understanding the mechanical behavior of waste has always been a challenging
task and requires adequate experimental investigation to delineate the constitutive behavior and to
formulate mathematical description that can simulate the experimental behavior. Finally, integration
of all these different aspects into a comprehensive coupled model is crucial to predict overall
performance of a bioreactor landfill.
Acknowledgements
This project is funded by the U.S. National Science Foundation (CMMI # 1537514), which is
gratefully acknowledged
References
1. Carpenter, P.J., Reddy, K.R., and Thompson, M.D. (2013a) ‘Dynamic properties of municipal
solid waste in a bioreactor cell at orchard hills landfill, Illinois, USA’ 7th International
Conference on Case Histories in Geotechnical Engineering, Wheeling, IL, USA
2. Carpenter, P.J., Reddy, K.R., and Thompson, M.D. (2013b). ‘Seismic imaging of a leachate
recirculation landfill: Spatial changes in dynamic properties of municipal solid waste’ Journal of
Hazardous, Toxic, and Radioactive Waste, Vol. 17(4), 331-41
3. Giri, R.K., and Reddy, K.R. (2014a). ‘Design charts for selecting minimum setback distance from
side slope to horizontal trench system in bioreactor landfills’ Geotechnical and Geological
Engineering Journal, Vol. 32(4), 1017-1027
4. Giri, R.K., and Reddy, K.R. (2014b). ‘Slope stability of bioreactor landfills during leachate
injection: Effects of unsaturated hydraulic properties of municipal solid waste’ International
Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, Vol. 8(2), 144-156
5. Giri, R.K., and Reddy, K.R. (2014c). ‘Slope stability of bioreactor landfills during leachate
injection: Effects of heterogeneous and anisotropic municipal solid waste’ Waste Management
& Research, Vol. 32(3), 186-197
6. Giri, R.K., and Reddy, K.R. (2015a). ‘Slope stability of bioreactor landfills during leachate
injection: Effects of geometric configurations of horizontal trench systems’ Geomechanics and
Geoengineering, Vol. 10(2), 126-138
7. Grellier, S., Reddy, K., Gangathulasi, J., Adib, R., and Peters, C. (2006). ‘Electrical resistivity
tomography imaging of leachate recirculation in orchard hills landfill’ SWANA Conference,
Charlotte, 7p.
8. Grellier, S., Reddy, K.R., Gangathulasi, J., Adib, R., and Peters, C. (2007). ‘US MSW and its
biodegradation in a bioreactor landfill’ Sardinia 2007, 11th International Waste Management
and Landfill Symposium, S. Margherita di Pula, Cagliari, Italy, 10p
9. Kulkarni, H.S., and Reddy, K.R. (2012). ‘Moisture distribution in bioreactor landfills: A review’
Indian Geotechnical Journal, Vol. 42(3), 125-149
10. Reddy, K.R., Gangathulasi, J., Parakalla, N., Bogner, J., Carpenter, P., and Lagier, T. (2009a).
‘Field monitoring and performance assessment of Orchard Hills bioreactor landfill’ NSF
Engineering Research and Innovation Conference, Honolulu, HI, 13p
11. Reddy, K.R., Hettiarachchi, H., Gangathulasi, J., Parakalla, N., Bogner, J.E., and Lagier, T.
(2009b). ‘Compressibility and shear strength of municipal solid waste under short-term leachate
recirculation operations’ Waste Management & Research, Vol. 27(6), 578-587
425
Solid waste management
12. Reddy, K.R., Hettiarachchi, H., Gangathulasi, J., Bogner, J.E., and Lagier, T. (2009c).
‘Geotechnical properties of synthetic municipal solid waste’ International Journal of
Geotechnical Engineering, Vol. 3(3), 429-438
13. Reddy, K.R., Hettiarachchi, H., Parakalla, N., Gangathulasi, J., Bogner, J.E., and Lagier, T.
(2009d). ‘Hydraulic conductivity of MSW in landfills’ Journal of Environmental Engineering,
Vol. 135(8), 677-683
14. Reddy, K.R., Hettiarachchi, H., Parakalla, N.S., Gangathulasi, J., and Bogner, J.E. (2009e).
‘Geotechnical properties of fresh municipal solid waste at Orchard Hills landfill, USA’ Waste
Management Journal, Vol. 29(2), 952-959
15. Reddy, K.R., Hettiarachchi, H., Gangathulasi, J., and Bogner, J.E. (2011). ‘Geotechnical
properties of municipal solid waste at different phases of degradation’ Waste Management, Vol.
31(11), 2275-2286
16. Reddy, K.R., Hettiarachchi, H., Giri, R.K., and Gangathulasi, J. (2015a). ‘Effects of degradation
on geotechnical properties of municipal solid waste from Orchard Hills Landfill, USA’
International Journal of Geosynthetics and Ground Engineering, Vol. 1(3), 1-14
17. Reddy, K.R., Kulkarni, H.S., and Khire, M.V. (2013a). ‘Two-phase modeling of leachate
recirculation using vertical wells in bioreactor landfills’ Journal of Hazardous, Toxic and
Radioactive Waste, Vol. 17(4), 272-284
18. Reddy, K.R., Kulkarni, H.S., Srivastava, A., and Sivakumar Babu, G.L. (2013b). ‘Influence of
spatial variation of hydraulic conductivity of municipal solid waste on performance of bioreactor
landfills’ Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, Vol. 139(11), 1968–
1972
19. Reddy, K.R., Giri, R.K., and Kulkarni, H.S. (2014). ‘Design of drainage blankets for leachate
recirculation in bioreactor landfills using two-phase flow modeling’ Computers and
Geotechnics, Vol. 62, 77-89
20. Reddy, K.R., Kulkarni, H.S., and Giri, R.K. (2015b). ‘Design of horizontal trenches for leachate
recirculation in bioreactor landfills using two-phase modeling’ International Journal of
Environment and Waste Management, Vol. 15(4), 347-376
21. Reddy, K.R., Kulkarni, H.S., and Giri, R.K. (2015c). ‘Design of vertical wells for leachate
recirculation in bioreactor landfills using two-phase modeling’ Journal of Solid Waste
Technology and Management, Vol. 41(2), 203-218
22. Reddy, K.R., Kulkarni, H.S., and Giri, R.K. (2015d). ‘Modeling coupled hydro-mechanical
behavior of landfilled waste in bioreactor landfills: Numerical formulation and validation’
Journal of Hazardous, Toxic and Radioactive Waste, ASCE, Vol. 21(1), D4015004
23. Reddy, K.R., Kumar, G., and Giri, R.K. (2017a). ‘Modeling coupled processes in municipal solid
waste landfills: An overview with key engineering challenges’ International Journal of
Geosynthetics and Ground Engineering, Vol. 3(1), 6
24. Reddy, K.R., Kumar, G., and Giri, R.K. (2017b). ‘Influence of dynamic coupled hydro-biomechanical processes on response of municipal solid waste and liner system in bioreactor
landfills’ Waste Management. Vol. 63, 143-160
25. Reddy, K.R., Kumar, G., and Giri, R.K. (2018a). ‘System effects on bioreactor landfill
performance based on coupled hydro-bio-mechanical modeling’ Journal of Hazardous, Toxic
and Radioactive Waste, ASCE, Vol. 22(1), 04017024
26. Reddy, K.R., Kumar, G., Giri, R.K. and Basha, B.M. (2018b). ‘Reliability assessment of
bioreactor landfills using Monte Carlo simulation and coupled hydro-bio-mechanical model’
Waste Management, 72:329-338. (10.1016/j.wasman.2017.11.010)
426
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
27. Sivakumar Babu, G.L., Reddy, K.R., Chouskey, S.K., and Kulkarni, H.S. (2010). ‘Prediction of
long-term municipal solid waste landfill settlement using constitutive model’ Practice Periodical
of Hazardous, Toxic, and Radioactive Waste Management, Vol. 14(2), 139-150
28. Sivakumar Babu, G.L., Reddy, K.R., and Chouskey, S.K. (2011). ‘Parametric study of MSW
landfill settlement model’ Waste Management Journal, Vol. 31(6), 1222-1231
29. USEPA (2016). ‘Advancing Sustainable Materials Management: 2014 Fact Sheet’
427
Solid waste management
COLLECTION AND HANDLING OF SHIP WASTE AND CARGO
RESIDUES IN GREECE: PRESENT AND FUTURE
Th. Giantsi*, S. Tsioupli, K. Flegkas, P. Koufos and J. Angelopoulos
Regulatory Authority for Ports, GR- 185 35 Gr. Lambraki 150, Piraeus, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: thegiant@raports.gr
Abstract
Waste streams generated on board ships en route and during cargo operations are governed by the
MARPOL 73/78 waste/residues UN Convention; their efficient delivery at shore and final disposal is
a Member States obligation. In order to ensure availability and safe delivery to the Port Reception
Facilities (PRF), the European Parliament and the European Council adopted the Directive
2000/59/EU on for ship-generated waste and cargo residues, taking into account International
Maritime Organization (IMO) measures. The main difference between the MARPOL 73/78
Convention and the 2000/59/EU Directive is that the former focuses mainly on board operations,
whereas the Directive regulates shore side activities. Implementation of the MARPOL 73/78
waste/residues Convention and of the Directive 2000/59/EU in Greece, was implemented by the
Common Ministerial Decision 8111.1/41/2009; both Directive and Decision are currently under
revision. A proposal for a new Directive has been published in January 2018.
The recent EU Regulation 2017/352 establishes a framework for the provision of port services and
common rules on the financial transparency of European ports, affecting as well the ship waste
handling sector. In Greece, the regulator that ensures application of the regulation in the domain of
ports is the Regulatory Authority for Ports (RAL).
The main targets of this work include the presentation of a) the existing state of delivery and shoreside management procedure for ship waste in Greece, b) the service provision market challenges, c)
the assessment of environmental friendly processes and d) the regulatory aspects.
Keywords: ship waste; cargo residues; ports; regulation; port reception facilities; MARPOL 73/78
1.
INTRODUCTION
In the domain of the International Agreements, Conventions constitute documents are signed by
Member States of International Organizations and then implemented within Member States through
their adoption by National Legislative Frameworks. In the case of European Union (EU), an
additional step can be required, involving the adoption of the Agreement by the EU legislative system
itself. In Greece, us a member state of E.U., the hierarchical implementation steps include:
International Convention, EU legal acts (such as Regulation, Directive, or Decision) and, finally,
national legal acts as Law, or Presidential Decree or (Common) Ministerial Decision or combination
of the above. In the case of ship waste legislation, the procedure is more complicated due to the fact
that, the management of waste on board ships is under the conventions of International Maritime
Organization (IMO), until their shore-side delivery, where other Conventions or Legislative acts are
set in force.
Despite the focus of the European Union on the environmental issues, several waste management
related issues are still unresolved, including different definitions for the same or similar terms, (e.g.
definition of MARPOL, for residues/wastes versus the Directive’s ship –generated waste) which
428
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
causes problems to the complicated procedure of the treatment and the disposal of all kinds of wastes
in the EU. The lead time between transitions of measures from one legal system to another contributes
to missing or newly added clauses and procedures, resulting to amendments and delays, rendering
some measures obsolete. Implementation differences between Member States add additional
complexity and confusion. The current standards set by the European Maritime Policy for the good
environmental status of the marine waters are high, resulting to minimization of waste disposal.
In the case of Greece, an additional factor of complication for waste and cargo residue management
is posed by the complexity of its National Port System: Due to the geomorphology of the country,
where more than 3.000 islands exist and more than 1.000 registered port facilities operate, the
adoption, implementation and surveillance of a system for the collection handling, treatment and final
disposal of ship waste is a very difficult procedure, involving many stakeholders including local /
municipal authorities, prefectures, ministries and one regulator, the Regulatory Authority for Ports.
In this paper a succinct description of the Greek Port System is presented, including the primary
responsibilities of Regulatory Authority for Ports. The rapidly evolving International, European and
National Legal frameworks, concerning the ship waste are also presented. The structure of the Greek
Market at the field of ship waste handling is described and compared to other European practices.
The European market of ship waste services faces new, regulatory challenges. The Greek State has
the opportunity to legislate appropriately to the benefit of market stakeholders, service providers and
end-users alike.
2.
THE GOVERNANCE OF THE GREEK PORT SYSTEM
2.1 Greek Port System
As of 2018, more than 1.060 port facilities operated in Greece, managed by 97 Port Authorities
(Giantsi, 2016). The role of Port Authorities is fulfilled by four different institutional frameworks i.e.
Port Authorities S.A., as private enterprises, Public Port Funds, Public Port Offices, and Municipal
Port Funds as public enterprises. Notwithstanding, a large number, approximately 240, of port
facilities do not belong to any managing body.
With respect to their significance, Greek Ports are divided in four main categories: a) ports of
international significance (16), b) Port of national significance (16), c) ports of major interest (25)
and d) local ports (~1000). Categorization according to their major six uses include: a) Commercial
/ Freight ports, b) Passenger ports, c) Tourist Ports, d) Fishing Ports, e) Multipurpose Ports, and f)
Special Purpose Ports (e.g. military ports, shipyards); this allocation is in Figure 1. The majority
(42%) of the Greek Port Facilities is comprised by small fishing ports; 18% are multipurpose, 15%
are commercial, 15% are Tourist. Only 5% are passenger ports, and the last 5% corresponds to special
purpose ports.
Tourist ports are licensed and supervised by the Ministry of Tourism, while the rest categories by the
Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Insular Policy. Furthermore, Tourist Ports are divided in 3
categories: Marinas, Shelters and Moorings.
25 Greek Ports have joined the Trans European Transport Network (TEN-T), 5 of which belonging
to the core network and 20 to the comprehensive network. The allocation of these 25 ports is presented
in Figure 2.
Due to the privatization of the biggest Greek Ports, (Piraeus and Thessaloniki) a new entity, (the
Public Port Authority), subject to the Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Insular Policy, was established
to take over the administrative responsibilities of the Greek State that cannot be delegated to private
entities. At the same time, the Regulatory Authority for Ports was established, in order to regulate
port services and oversee concession agreements, as an independent regulator, subject only to the
Greek Parliament.
429
Solid waste management
TOTAL
Greek SeaPorts at TEN-T
Special
Purpose
5%
12
10
8
Ports
Multipurpose
18%
Tourist Ports
15%
6
4
Fishing Ports
42%
2
0
International
Passenger
Ports
5%
Commercial
Ports
15%
Core
Figure 1: Distribution of Greek Ports per
use
National
Major Int.
Comprehensive
Figure 2: Distribution of TEN-T Greek Ports
2.2 The Regulatory Authority for Ports
The Regulatory Authority for Ports was initially established in May 2014 pursuant to the Laws of
4150/2013, 4254/2014 and 4258/2014 as an Independent Public Authority, subject to the Ministry of
Shipping and the Aegean, with administrative and financial autonomy. Pursuant to the Law
4389/2016, (G.G., Α' 94/27.05.2016) in May 2016 it was transformed into an Independent Authority,
subject to the Greek Parliament. The mission of the Authority includes overseeing, regulating and
catering for the legality of relations between public and private entities in the national port system.
Emphasis is given to contractual compliance and the application of competition law in the port
industry. Responsibilities of the Authority include:
issuing of regulatory, directly enforceable regulatory and advisory decrees,
overseeing the level of service, the compliance of stakeholders with competition law and the
accomplishment of the financial objectives in ports under concession contracts,
exercising of the contractual rights of the Hellenic Republic in ports under concession contracts,
resolving differences between ports operators and port users,
establishing of port charging methodologies,
deciding for provisional measures in emergency situations and inspections, in cooperation with
judicial bodies and
advisory support to the Greek state with respect to the organization and legislative framework of
the national port system, port services and port planning.
The Regulatory Authority for Ports supervises commercial methods and practices of port service
providers and enforces regulatory measures, ensuring the unobstructed provision of port services to
users, and access to port services.
The deliveries of Regulatory Authority for Ports, as an Independent Authority from May 2016 until
today, includes the completion of 79 case requests and complaints with respect to port services, port
infrastructure charges, port service contracts and dredging services.
The main arguments for the creation of the Regulatory Authority for Ports include: a) the need to
monitor, control and enrich European experience with respect to total concessions of public ports and
port authorities, b) the need to reduce uncertainty and enhance management consistency and
continuity in the management, by monitoring of total concession contracts, sub-concessions of port
infrastructure and the rendering of certain port services from the Greek State, c) the need to regulate
430
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
port access, charging and performance in relation to the required level of service for port service
users, d) the need for specialized, multilevel knowledge (economic, technical and legal knowledge)
and a focus on: i) the ex-ante regulation of the port services market, the advice on more specific issues
for port services and the prevention of market failures without excessive interference, and ii) the expost investigation of competition issues deriving from breach of the legal and contractual obligations
of port operators and port services market distortions.
Apart from Greece, rapid developments in the international and European port industry are taking
place in the recent years, and the formation of alliances between international port terminal
management companies (global operators), large shipping companies and logistics companies (mega
carriers) are blurring the distinction between the port industry, shipping, transport and logistics,
developing a so-called post-globalized framework (Angelopoulos et al,. 2018). This framework calls
for novel aspects of regulation at a transnational, European and global level, and to this end the
establishment and operation of institutions similar to the Regulatory Authority for Ports.
3.
LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK
3.1 MARPOL73/78 Convention
In order to prevent the pollution from ships, IMO set in force the MARPOL 73/78 waste/residues UN
Convention (IMO, 2017), in 1973 for the first time. A large number of amendments have been
incorporated in the initial edition. New amendments are also expected to be set into force in the near
future.
All waste streams generated on board ships during normal operations and during cargo operations are
to be treated and final disposed under a clear procedure, according to the MARPOL Convention.
Regulations for management of waste and residues are divided within six Annexes:
Annex I: Regulations for the Prevention of Pollution by Oil
Annex II: Regulations for the Control of Pollution by Noxious Liquid Substances in Bulk
Annex III: Regulations for the Prevention of Pollution by Harmful Substances Carried by Sea in
Packaged Form
Annex IV: Regulations for the Prevention of Pollution by Sewage from Ships
Annex V :Regulations for the Prevention of Pollution by Garbage from Ships
Annex VI :Regulations for the Prevention of Air Pollution from Ships
According to MARPOL 73/78, garbage is categorized as follows:
a) Plastics, b) Food wastes, c) Domestic wastes (e.g., paper products, rags, glass, metal, bottles,
crockery, etc.), d) Cooking oil, e) Incinerator Ashes, f) Operational wastes, g) Cargo residues, h)
Animal Carcass(es), i) Fishing gear.
Efficient delivery of MARPOL wastes / residuals at shore, treatment and final disposal are obligations
of Member States.
A so-called Waste Reception and Handling Plan is required by the managing bodies of the port. In
order to ensure compliance with MARPOL, IMO published the Circular MEPC/834 Consolidated
Guidance for Port Reception Facility Providers and Users (IMO, 2014).
3.2 European legislative framework
Traditionally, EU has been very sensitive with respect to environmental issues. A litany of
Regulations, Directives and Decisions has been entered in force in order to ensure high environmental
standards. The impact of the implementation of each legal act is always under examination, and when
new legal acts are adopted, the old ones are amended or repealed and Member States are obliged to
implement the new acts to their legislative system.
In order to reduce the discharges of ship-generated waste and cargo residues, the European Parliament
and the European Council adopted the Directive 2000/59/EU (OJEC, L 332/28.12.2000)- currently
431
Solid waste management
under revision-, in accordance with the MARPOL Convention. In order to facilitate Member State
implementation of the Circular MEPC/834 and based on the experience gained from monitoring and
assessing the implementation of Directive 2000/59/EC during the past 15 years, the Commission has
decided to clarify some of the key provisions of the Directive via a Commission’s Notice (2016/C
115/05) entitled Guidelines for the interpretation of Directive 2000/59/EC. (OJEC, 2000)
The Directive 2000/59/EU refers only to Annexes I, IV and V to MARPOL 73/78 waste and residues
and applies to “a) all ships, including fishing vessels and recreational craft, irrespective of their flag,
calling at, or operating within, a port of a Member State, with the exception of any warship, naval
auxiliary or other ship owned or operated by a State and used, for the time being, only on government
noncommercial service; and (b) all ports of the Member States normally visited by ships falling under
the scope of point (a).”
Waste and residues from other Annexes are treated differently according to other EU directives and
regulations. The obligation for the development of a Waste Reception and Handling Plan (WRH) is
included within the Directive. Pursuant to the Directive, these WRH Plans are to be revised every
three years.
A study has been conducted for the European Commission by ECORYS (2017), assessing the impact
and challenges of the 2000/59/EU Directive implementation. Two main problems were identified,
namely: a) waste discharged at sea and b) administrative burden.
The first problem was attributed to the significant difference between volumes of waste produced on
board, and waste delivered at shore. A significant amount of Ship Generated Wastes (SGW) are being
discharged at sea, under the permission of MARPOL and constitute a negative impact for the marine
environment. Significant volumes of waste are believed to be discharged illegally, resulting also in a
serious negative impact; finally, a non documented sufficiently yet volume of wastes is being treated
on board. A review of present technologies and methods being used to reduce SGW, is presented by
a study conducted by CE Delft, for the European Maritime Safety Agency (EMSA, 2017). To
eliminate the discharge of waste at sea, several new measures are proposed. One of these measures
includes the elimination of the direct and indirect cost of the delivery at shore, the treatment and the
final disposal of the wastes. Increase of the waste treatment on ship is also another measure.
The marine environment is also protected with several other EU legislative acts:
a) the Directive 2008/98/EC, (OJEC, 2008), of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19
November 2008 on waste and repealing certain Directives b) the Directive 2008/56/EC, (OJEC,
2008a) of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 June 2008 establishing a framework for
community action in the field of marine environmental policy (Marine Strategy Framework
Directive), c) the Regulation (EC) 1069/2009, (OJEC, 2009) of the European Parliament and the
Council of 21 October 2009 laying down health rules as regards animal by-products and derived
products not intended for human consumption and repealing Regulation (EC) 1774/2002, d) the
Directive 2009/16/EC, of the European Parliament and the Council of 23 April 2009 on port state
control and, finally, e) the Regulation (EU) 2017/352 (OJEC, 2017) of the European Parliament and
of the Council of 15 February 2017 establishing a framework for the provision of port services and
common rules on the financial transparency of ports.
The Regulation (EU) 2017/352 applies to seven port services, including the collection of shipgenerated waste and cargo residues and applies also to all maritime ports of the Trans-European
Transport Network (TEN-T), as listed in Annex II to Regulation (EU) 1315/2013, (OJEC, 2013).
Regulation 2017/352 is dealing with the following issues: a) minimum requirements for the provision
of port services, b) limitations on the number of providers, c) public service obligations and d)
restrictions related to internal operators.
Finally, the Proposal for a Directive on port reception facilities for the delivery of waste from ships,
repealing Directive 2000/59/EC and amending Directive 2009/16/EC, (OJEC, 2009) and Directive
2010/65/EU, (OJEC, 2010) is published in January 2018, (EC, 2018).
432
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Another important parameter is that the procedures for reception, collection, storage, treatment and
disposal should always conform to European Environmental Policy.
During the consultation for the revision of the Directive, four Policy Options were examined: 1)
Baseline, 2) Minimum revision, 3) MARPOL alignment, 4) EUPRF regime for all discharges; and
variant options 3b and 4b on Marine Litter. The 3b option was selected, targeting to: a) clarify the
relationship with the MARPOL Convention, b) simplify the legislative framework and c) reduce
administrative burden.
Key changes on the proposal for the new Directive include:
a) The Annexes I, II, IV, V and VI are included at the proposal (The Annexes II and VI were not
included in Directive 2000/59/EU.)
b) Changes in definitions - terms, in accordance with IMO
c) Directive Annexes (forms) changes, in compliance with IMO forms
d) The new Directive shall apply to all ports and not just to the selected ones, based on criteria
imposed by each Member State (e.g. magnitude of port facility)
e) Shipyard wastes are excluded from the Directive proposal
f) Inspection changes are proposed
g) Fees replaced by the cost recovery schemes
Changes a) and d) above may increase both administrative burden and the infrastructure cost.
3.3 Greek legal compliance
Implementation of Directive 2000/59/EU in Greece was conducted mainly by the Common
Ministerial Decision 8111.1/41/2009 (G.G., 412 B/06.03.2009).
All major ports of the country (international, national and of major interest), including touristic ports,
are required to have waste reception facilities, in order to collect waste and cargo residues produced
by all kinds of ships normally using the port, including fishing vessels and recreational crafts. To
achieve this objective, a WRH Plan must be developed by the Port managing bodies to ensure the
effectiveness of the service provided. These Plans, according to the Directive 2000/59/EU can be
regional, incorporating many Ports under the same Plan, distinguishing the involvement of each port
and the availability of the reception facilities of each port. The duration of WRH Plans is set to three
years; they are validated by the Ministry of Maritime Affair and Insular Policy, and evaluated by the
Ministry of Environment and Energy. To maximize the quality of the services, the managing bodies
of the Ports, in most cases, provide these services via private companies with expertise in the specific
domain.
Wastes are divided in two categories: a) liquid and b) solid waste. Initially, service providers bid for
each waste category separately and only one provider per port was permitted to operate per waste
category. Before the publication of Regulation (EU) 2017/352, the Regulatory Authority for Ports
issued 3/2017 advisory decree entitled Providers in the Hellenic Ports for Waste Management, in
order to clarify the procedure.
Just before 2018, Law 4504/2017 (G.G., 184 A/29.11.2017) entered into force. In article 105, core
principles and articles of Regulation (EU) 2017/352 with respect to waste management of ships and
cargo residues are incorporated to the Greek legislation. Despite that Regulation (EU) 2017/352
applies only to TEN-T ports (with only 25 Greek Ports having the obligation to comply), signaling a
policy choice focusing on environmental protection by imposing higher standards nationwide. Article
105 provides the procedure of port reception services and waste management, by opening the market
imposing at least two providers per service for private managing bodies (total concession). One more
important change can be observed in the new law: a 5-year duration of the WRH plans. The no.
3/2017 RAL advisory decree was in turn repealed, in order to be in conformity to the new Law
4504/2017.
433
Solid waste management
Currently a proposal for the revision of the CMD 8111/49/2009 is under consultation. However, it is
based on the Commission’s Notice (2016/C 115/05) and not on the proposal of the new Directive.
Another significant issue seems to be the transmission of the waste from the port area to the inland
facilities for treatment, where other legislative acts are in force and the waste by MARPOL’s Annexes
must follow the European List of Waste procedure.
4.
SHIP WASTE DELIVERY AND RECEPTION IN GREECE
4.1 Waste Reception and Handling Plans
In most cases, WRH Plans in Greece are regional, incorporating neighboring smaller port facilities in
the vicinity of the main port, even not managed by the same managing body. As a result, ships can
deliver waste at many port facilities in Greece. 57 ports are obliged to develop WRH Plans (ports of:
international importance, national importance, and major interest), including approximately 50
Tourist Ports (Marinas) and 60 private port terminals / facilities; a total of 167. Several of these
facilities are incorporated in the same WRH Plan.
Private Ports
Private Ports
Marinas
Marinas
Minicipal Port Funds
Public Port Funds
Public
Authorities
Port Authorities
0
10
0
20
WRH Plans
Figure 3: WRH Plans per managing body
category
20
WRH Plans under revision
40
Figure 4: WRH Plans under revision per
managing body category
As of 2018, 44 WRH Plans are in force and 62 are under revision in Greece. Figures 3 and 4 present
WRH Plans per managing body type and under revision respectively. All Port Authorities and the
majority of private ports / facilities have developed WRH Plans. Notwithstanding, several Port Funds
have not complied with the law.
4.2 Port Reception Facilities
According to the proposal of the new Directive the definition of port reception facilities, (P.R.F.) is:
any facility, which is fixed, floating or mobile and capable of receiving the waste from ships. In most
cases all three types of facilities or combination of them are used for each Greek port. Quantities,
required capacity and the quality are set in the WRH Plans. In most cases, shore-side facilities especially for liquid waste, are situated within the port area and owned by the managing body of the
port. In some Port Authorities (e.g. Piraeus Port Authority), construction and operation of P.R.F. has
been assigned to a provider through a sub-concession.
Floating and mobile facilities can be either private or owned by the public managing body of the port.
In both cases, mobile facilities must be licensed for the specific operation.
No obligation for separation of garbage is recognized within the Greek Legal system; therefore solid
waste services providers, do not separate waste (mainly from Annex V), thus lowering national
recycling indicators.
4.3 The market of waste reception services in Greece
The Greek system for the collection and handling of the ships waste is based on a bidding procedure.
The lowest bidder and the managing body sign a sub-concession contract for a specific amount of
434
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
money estimated as the income from the provided services for a period no longer than 3 years. After
the end of the contract, a new contest procedure and a revision of WRH Plan are conducted. It is a
tough and long procedure. Due to the delays in the contest procedure, services can be provided by the
incumbent provider under an expired WRH Plan. As RAL is the responsible authority for the
resolution of the differences between port managing bodies and stakeholders, a lot of complaints
arrive at RAL, during the contest procedure.
The Greek market appears to have the characteristics of an oligopoly: As of 2018, four major waste
service providers are active; one is specialized in liquid waste, two in solid waste and one in both.
In contrary, most of European Ports have more than one provider collecting the waste for each
MARPOL’s Annex. In Table 1 the number of providers involved in the collection of waste at several
European Ports is presented.
Table 1: Number of ship waste collection services Providers per MARPOL Annexes for
selected European Ports1.
PORT→
Rotterdam Antwerp LeHavre Valencia Trieste Piraeus
ANNEX↓
1
17
16
6
2
5
I
1
13
12
4
II
1
III
1
10
11
5
3
3
IV
1
5
12
4
4
3
V
1
9
2
3
VI
Waste from Annex III, is subject to the ship’s captain choice to be delivered at shore. Only the Port
of Piraeus gives this option to clients. Although collection of Annex II and VI wastes is not included
in the Directive 2000/59/EU, these services are provided by major European Ports.
5.
EXPECTED IMPACTS FROM THE NEW LEGISLATION IN THE GREEK MARKET
The existing legal framework faces challenges both in Greece and the rest of EU Member States. An
update of the existing legislative framework is a requirement; currently under consultation.
A new, amended Common Ministerial Decision is the next necessary step for the Greek legal system,
incorporating, among others, the obligation to all ports to develop WRH Plans and receive waste from
MARPOL’s Annex VI; the current proposal for the new directive includes also waste from
MARPOL’s Annex II. The proposal of the new Directive is on the right direction, oriented to IMO
principles, facilitating ships with respect to the shore-side waste delivery procedure. Alignment with
MARPOL is expected to lead to reduction of administrative burden. On the other hand, the obligation
to maintain reception facilities for all ports, is expected to increase administrative burden and
infrastructure costs, to the benefit, however, of additional investments and creation of new jobs, not
neglecting the environmental profit.
With respect to WRH Plans, the introduction of Annex II and Annex VI wastes will result to revision
requirements; at the same time, expansion of their duration from 3 years to 5 years, will reduce
administrative burden.
Finally, the proposed cost recovery systems, introducing an indirect and a direct fee for the reception
and ship-side treatment of waste -excluding the cargo residues from this obligation-, is expected to
increase volumes of shore-side waste deliveries.
1
Data collected by the official port’s websites, as of 12.2017
435
Solid waste management
Two issues appear to persist in the Greek market: The current low levels of market competition, and
the environmental target of recycling. Some entry barriers still remain. They strangle of competition
and at the same time mitigate the environmental profits.
6.
CONCLUSION
The procedures for reception, collection, storage, treatment and disposal of ship wastes and cargo
residues are part of a robust industry in Greece; however, they have characteristics of an oligopoly.
The proposed National and European legislative acts are expected to reinforce the sector, offering
more jobs and better quality for the marine environment. Still they remain entry barriers in the Greek
market.
Issues to be solved in Greece are the number of providers for waste collection services, the separation
of garbage etc.
The decision of the E.U. to align the procedure with IMO principles is to the right direction.
Clarification of the terms, matching of the waste categories between MARPOL’s Annexes and
European List of Waste and simplification of the procedures are needed to empower the ship - waste
management services.
Even those, in Greece more interventions are needed to strengthen competition in the market and to
facilitate the waste management. The upcoming legislative acts, could transform the new challenges
to the booster of the market and the Greek Market can benefit from them.
We are in a transitional period and based on the experience obtained, we expect a healthy and strong
market in the near future at the waste reception and handling sector of port services.
References
1. Angelopoulos J., C. Chlomoudis and T. Styliadis (2017) ‘Effect of Global Supply Chain
Developments on the Governance of Port Regulation’, in Pettit, S. & Beresford, A. (Eds.). Port
Management: Cases in Port Geography, Operations and Policy (pp. 62-93), Kogan Page
Publishers.
2. EMSA (2017) ‘The Management of Ship-Generated Waste On-board Ships’, Delft, by CE
Delft.
3. European Commission (EC) (2018) ‘Proposal for a DIRECTIVE OF THE EUROPEAN
PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL on Port Reception Facilities for the Delivery of
Waste from Ships, repealing Directive 2000/59/EC and amending Directive 2009/16/EC and
Directive 2010/65/EU’, Strasburg
4. ECORYS (2017) ‘Supporting Study for an Impact Assessment for the Revision of Directive
2000/59/EC on Port Reception Facilities’, Final Report, European Commission.
5. Giantsi Th. (2016) ‘Effective Port Governance and Management. The Case of East-Central
Greece’, Master Thesis, University of Piraeus.
6. Government Gazette, (G.G.) (2017) 184 A / 29.11.2017, Law 4504/2017.
7. G.G., (2016) 94 A/27.5.2016, Law 4389/2016.
8. G.G. (2009) 412 B / 6.3.2009, Common Ministerial Decision 8111.1/41/2009.
9. IMO (2017) MARPOL Consolidation Edition 2017
10. IMO (2014) MEPC/834 “Consolidated Guidance for Port Reception Facility Providers and
Users”.
11. Official Journal of the European Communities (OJEC) (2000) ‘Directive 2000/59/EU on Port
Reception Facilities (PRF) for ship-generated waste and cargo residues’.
436
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
12. OJEC (2008) ‘Directive 2008/56/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17
June 2008 establishing a framework for community action in the field of marine
environmental policy (Marine Strategy Framework Directive)’.
13. OJEC (2008b) ‘Directive 2008/98/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19
November 2008 on waste and repealing certain Directives’.
14. OJEC (2009) ‘Regulation (EC) 1069/2009 of the European Parliament and the Council of 21
October 2009 laying down health rules as regards animal by-products and derived products
not intended for human consumption and repealing Regulation (EC) 1774/2002’.
15. OJEC (2009b) ‘Directive 2009/16/EC of the European Parliament and the Council of 23
April 2009 on port state control’.
16. OJEC (2017) ‘Regulation (EU) 2017/352 of the European Parliament and of the Council of
15 February 2017 establishing a framework for the provision of port services and common
rules on the financial transparency of ports’.
17. OJEC (2016) ‘Commission Notice (2016/C 115/05) Guidelines for the interpretation of
Directive 2000/59/EC on port reception facilities for ship generated waste and cargo
residues’.
18. OJEC (2013) ‘Regulation (EU) No 1315/2013 Of the European Parliament and of the
Council, of 11 December 2013, guidelines for the development of the trans-European
transport network and repealing Decision No 661/2010/EU’.
19. OJEC (2010) ‘Directive 2010/65/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20
October 2010 on reporting formalities for ships arriving in and/or departing from ports of
the Member States and repealing Directive 2002/6/EC.
437
Solid waste management
PASSIVE ACID MINE DRAINAGE REMEDIATION USING BOF
STEEL SLAG AND SUGARCANE BAGASSE
T.S. Naidu1*, L.D. Van Dyk1, C.M. Sheridan1, and D.G. Grubb2
1
Faculty of Engineering and Built Environment, Richard Ward Building, University of the
Witwatersrand, 1 Jan Smuts Avenue, Johannesburg, RSA 2000,
2
Phoenix Services LLC, 148 W. State Street, Suite 301, Kennett Square, PA 19348 USA
Corresponding author: *E-mail: tsnaidu@live.co.za, Phone: +27 827715880
Abstract
This research incorporates the use of two regionally available industrial byproducts produced close
to the coal mining region in Eastern South Africa to treat acid mine drainage (AMD): steel slag and
sugarcane bagasse, i.e., the shredded cane stalk residual after sugar extraction. Basic oxygen furnace
(BOF) slag is regionally produced in Newcastle in large quantities and its high alkalinity makes it
ideal for neutralizing acids. Kwa-Zulu Natal is home to the South African sugar industry and the high
surface area, polysaccharide content and slow breakdown via acid hydrolysis of sugarcane bagasse
makes it an ideal host media for sulfate reducing bacteria (SRB). Accordingly, this research explores
the viability of remediating AMD in a two-step continuous process combining both materials. BOF
slag eluate (generated from a recycle loop) contacted with raw AMD at an Eluate:AMD ratio of 20:1
was used to initially buffer the AMD solution (pH) and precipitate heavy metals in a sedimentation
tank to avoid toxic shocking the SRBs in the sugarcane bagasse bioreactor. Overflow from the
sedimentation tank was then passed through a packed bed containing sugarcane bagasse inoculated
with SRBs as a polishing step to remove sulfate, precipitate metal sulfides and elevate pH to near
neutral pH conditions based on a 16.46 h residence time. A portion of the effluent (95%) was recycled
through a packed bed of BOF slag to create the eluate for pre-treatment of the raw AMD solution.
The AMD used in these experiments was characterized by: pH 2.4; 388 mg/L Al, 4256 mg/L Fe, 426
mg/L Mg, 96 mg/L Mn, 418 mg/L Ca and 15995 mg/L SO42-. Operation of the designed process at
a laboratory scale treating 1 L/day, has confirmed the buffering of the AMD solution to a pH of
between 7 and 8, and the removal of heavy metals and sulfate to levels of below 10 mg/L for Al, Fe,
Mg, Mn and <200 mg/L for sulfate. The bench scale system is currently being scaled up for a pilot
treatment system to be deployed in February 2018 near Emalahleni, South Africa, about 150 km due
East of Johannesburg.
Keywords: BOF slag, Acid mine drainage (AMD), sugarcane bagasse, sulfate reducing bacteria
(SRBs)
1.
INTRODUCTION
Mining activity has been an important element in the development and advancement of the South
African economy for over a century [Durand, 2012], with mineral extraction occurring at numerous
industrial sites across the country. Although much wealth has been generated because of the gold,
coal, iron ore and copper mining industries, mining activities have also resulted in detrimental
ecological problems that have had adverse effects on both the environment and the population of
South Africa. One such problem is that of Acid Mine Drainage (AMD) or Acid Rock Drainage (ARD)
[Mccarthy et al. 2011].
438
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
AMD is formed when rocks and waste mine materials that contain sulfide components, oxidize on
exposure to water or air [Naicker et al. 2003]. Pyrite, the main component that contributes to the
formation of AMD, is found largely in both coal and gold mining sites, but it is also found in smaller
quantities in other metal ores. Waters that have been contaminated with AMD are characterized by
a low pH, high acidity and high concentrations of sulfates and metals [Feng et al. 2004]. Water
scarcity issues (both surface and groundwater impacted by AMD) serve as a major motivation to
address point and non-point sources of AMD in north and north-eastern South Africa (Gauteng,
Mpumalanga and Limpopo), where polluted water is generated at multiples coal field sites in the
volumes of tens of ML/day. Research into treatment and prevention methods is thus relevant in South
Africa and other countries with similar socio-economic situations.
Fortuitously, two industrial by-products are regionally available in large volumes with the potential
to passively remediate AMD: Basic Oxygen Furnace (BOF) Slag and sugarcane bagasse, i.e., the
shredded cane stalk material remaining after sugar extraction [Ziemkiewicz 1998; Grubb et al. 2000;
Ziemkiewicz et al 2003; Skousen & Ziemkiewicz 2005]. The BOF slag with 10-15 wt%
lime/portlandite and various alkaline silicates and oxides, is able to generate highly alkaline solutions
and can be used to buffer and elevate the pH of AMD [Roadcap et al. 2005; Riley & Mayes 2015].
As pH rises, a substantial portion of metals precipitate out of solution in the form of oxides,
hydroxides and sulfates, lowering the metal content of the water and making the AMD solution more
amenable to biological treatment by Sulfate Reducing Bacteria (SRB) cultures. SRB is able to reduce
sulfates to sulfides via dissimilatory sulfate reduction (DSR), promoting more metal and sulfate
removal by means of metal sulfide precipitation. SRB need a substrate to function and sugarcane
bagasse has shown potential in this regard [Hussain & Qazi 2016; Grubb et al, in press]. If a process
using the abovementioned methods and industrial by-products is optimized and implemented
successfully, areas affected by AMD pollution could be restored and the water quality could be
improved to acceptable grey water standards.
This paper reports on the research and the implementation of such a process at a laboratory scale
which comprises of two main steps, neutralisation and sulfate reduction. It aims to incorporate slag
and sugarcane bagasse to treat severely polluted mine drainage which is continuously produced from
a mine in Mpumalanga, South Africa.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Materials
Basic oxygen furnace (BOF) slag was sourced from Phoenix Slag Services based in Newcastle,
Kwazulu Natal, South Africa. The sugarcane bagasse was collected from Illovo’s sugar plant in
Eston, Kwazulu Natal, South Africa. The bagasse was transported loosely in plastic bags and stored
in a temperature controlled room at 25 °C before use in the process.
The acid mine drainage (AMD) was obtained from a mine tailings dam in Emalahleni, Mpumalanga,
South Africa and was stored away from direct contact with sunlight before use. The elemental
composition and other chemical and physical properties of the AMD as collected from the site are
provided in Tables 1 and 2 respectively. This initial quality of water is typically what the treatment
regime aims to remediate (the treatment facility is currently being upscaled to a pilot plant system to
be constructed at site).
439
Solid waste management
Table 1: Elemental composition of AMD
Concentration
Concentration
Element
Element
(mg/L)
(mg/L)
S
11182.500
Ga
2.160
Fe
7432.500
Hg
1.840
Ca
1395.000
Co
1.749
Mg
795.000
Ni
1.514
Y
219.300
Pb
1.156
Mn
133.200
Sr
0.941
Ir
48.900
Na
0.863
Li
37.800
Ag
0.803
Zn
13.800
V
0.627
Si
11.320
U
0.571
Te
10.560
Ge
0.499
Sn
10.080
Ti
0.243
Ce
8.240
Cd
0.199
Cu
5.980
W
0.171
Gd
4.300
Be
0.073
K
3.074
Eu
0.053
Table 2 shows that the sulfide content was 0.019 mg/L, which suggests an existing SRB presence
within the dam, or unreacted sulfides present in the AMD. Concentrations measured at the time of
commencement of experimentation differ to the concentrations obtained at time of collection, due
precipitation that occurred because of the highly saturated nature of the AMD and the stagnant storage
conditions. At the mine site, water is continuously recycle and pumped into the mine tailings dam,
creating agitation that prevents precipitation. The performance of the treatment facility was assessed
based on initial concentrations of the liquid entering the setup.
Table 2: Selected chemical and physical properties of AMD
Parameter
Value
Redox Potential (mV)
391
Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L)
2.5
Total Dissolved Solids
29112
Sulfide (mg/L)
0.019
Conductivity (mS/M)
1300
pH
2.38
Total Suspended Solids
290
+
Acidity (H )
362
Turbidity
54
Total Organic Carbon (TOC)
<0.1
Sulfate (mg/L)
20146
Hydroxypropyl cellulose
<1
440
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.2 Experimental setup and procedure
A laboratory scale AMD treatment facility was designed and constructed (Figure 1) to study the
effectiveness of a process which combines the use of BOF slag and sugarcane bagasse to treat AMD.
Results from initial test work (not discussed here) were used as a basis for the process configuration
and control scheme, as well as the optimum process parameters and conditions.
The remediation setup (Figure 1) comprises of two pumps and a number of process vessels (an AMD
feed tank, two slag vessels, a sedimentation vessel, primary and secondary DSR vessels, a water
reservoir and an outlet storage tank) which were sealed and anaerobic. The sample points are
numbered on the diagram. Movement of the liquid between tanks is achieved via gravity flow.
Figure 1
Laboratory scale passive AMD remediation setup
The setup was operated for 32 days in continuous mode by constantly filling the feed tank with AMD.
Samples were taken at all sample points and analysed for pH, redox potential, sulfate, dissolved and
precipitated iron, manganese, aluminium, calcium and magnesium.
Specifically, AMD was fed into a sedimentation vessel where it was mixed with an alkaline solution
from the slag vessels. The pH of the mixture was controlled at 9 by adjusting the feed rate of the
AMD versus of the BOF slag eluate addition rate. Metal oxides, hydroxides and sulfates precipitated
out of solution and settled at the bottom of the vessel which was occasionally opened to remove
sediment. The partially treated AMD solution then flowed to the primary DSR vessel (DSR V1).
This vessel contained 600g of bagasse inoculated with SRB cultures. The AMD promoted hydrolysis
of the bagasse to release sugars and organic acids which served as the substrate for the subsequent
DSR by the SRBs with end products including precipitated metal sulfides or H2S.
Preliminary experiments showed that DSR occurs faster when the liquid and bacteria are no longer
in direct contact with the organic substrate and a secondary DSR vessel (DSR V2), not containing
bagasse, was used for this purpose. Accordingly, effluent from DSR V2 served the dual purpose of
being the treated water for potential release and feedstock for stripping alkalinity from the BOF slag
vessels (at 17 mL/min). The BOF slag vessels contained 5 kg each of 10 mm minus BOF slag
particles. In the slag vessels, water leaches hydroxides from the slag and become alkaline. This
441
Solid waste management
alkaline solution is fed to the sedimentation vessel as previously mentioned. The remainder of water
in the water reservoir flows to a water storage tank.
2.3 Analytical methods
The metal concentrations of aluminium, calcium, iron, magnesium and manganese were measured
with an Agilent 2000 series atomic spectrometer. Redox potential and pH were measured using a
combined pH and ORP meter. Sulfate was measured using turbidimetric spectrophotometric sulfate
tests [Center for bioprocess engineering research, 2016; American Public Health Association , 1975].
Standard concentration solutions were used for each test to obtain relevant calibration equations.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Samples were taken from the process sample points (S1-S6, Figure 1) every two days over the 32 day
operational period. The samples were analyzed for pH, redox potential, sulfate, dissolved and
precipitated iron, manganese, aluminium, calcium and magnesium. Sulfide analysis was done 4 times
over this period on samples taken from the bagasse chamber to ensure DSR was occurring. A
selection of the results is presented here to show the functioning and synergy between each section
of the laboratory AMD treatment setup.
The purpose of the slag vessels is to house the slag and allow enough time for the water entering the
vessels to gain sufficient alkalinity. Water exiting the water reservoir is either allowed to flow into a
storage vessel or is recycled back into the system via the slag vessels, where a rise in pH and alkalinity
occurs. This is essential for system performance as the pH of the slag vessel outlet stream will directly
affect the pH of the sedimentation vessel. The largest proportion of metal and sulfate removal occurs
in the sedimentation vessel (due to pH adjustment), which avoids toxic shocking the SRBs which
then, in turn, remove sulfate.
It can be seen from Figure 2 that the pH of the recycled water increases from 7-8 to 11-12 and remains
relatively constant over the 32-day period. The alkalinity and pH generation in the BOF slag vessels
can generally be attributed to two processes: (i) the rapid hydration and dissociation of
lime/portlandite, and (ii) the additional dissolution of Ca-silicate minerals (like rankinite, larnite and
akermanite) [Gomes et al 2016]. The data from the BOF slag vessel inlet and outlet streams (Figure
2) confirms this as the pH increase occurs in conjunction with an increase in dissolved calcium in the
liquid. The magnesium content also increases by 39.6 % over the slag vessel. The reactor ran for
only 32 days (not including start up), and thus the slag was deemed insufficiently depleted to allow
for the dissolution of casilicate minerals. The presence of other oxides within the slag does not affect
the pH rise, as the data showed that there was no increase in concentrations of iron, aluminium or
manganese. The outlet of the slag vessel entered the sedimentation vessel, along with untreated, raw
AMD.
The Sample 3 location (sedimentation tank effluent) concentrations are shown in Figure 3. Sulfate
concentrations varied between 70 and 340 mg/L, versus the AMD (S1) concentration of
approximately 15995 mg/L. On average, the metals removal rate from the AMD was: Al (99.09%),
Ca (78.06%), Fe (99.85%), Mg (96.33%) and Mn (94.77%). It should be noted that this decrease in
concentration of contaminants is not only due to the induced precipitation of the metals due to higher
pH conditions, but also in part due to the dilution factor between the AMD inlet and the recycle inlet.
Chemical precipitation commonly occurs in AMD, even without the onset of remediation
[Lottermoser 2007], however the amount and rate of precipitation can increase with increasing pH
[Plasari & Muhr 2007]. The increase in pH is connected with metal precipitation in the form of
hydroxides [Balintova & Petrilakova 2011], oxyhydroxides or oxyhydroxysulfates [Lottermoser
2007]. Due to the large decrease in dissolved sulfate, the counter-ion consumed by the metal ions
during precipitation, in conjunction with the hydroxyl groups, was probably sulfate.
442
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2: Calcium content and pH of slag vessel inlet and outlet over time
Figure 3: Metal and sulfate concentration in sedimentation vessel outlet
The water exiting the sedimentation vessel entered the primary DSR vessel (DSR V1) where DSR
occurred under the action of SRB. The decrease in dissolved sulfate over this vessel is shown in
Figure 4. On average a decreased of 36.25% in sulfate was achieved across this reactor. This is
similar to findings in the preliminary experiments where a sulfate reduction of 33.6 % was achieved
under similar conditions. Since SRB are sensitive to pH [Janyasuthiwong et al., 2016], it was initially
443
Solid waste management
theorized that a fluctuation in pH as well as the high pH entering the DSR V1 may be inhibiting SRB
performance. However, as shown in Figure 4, the pH exiting the vessel remained fairly constant,
with an average pH of 7.2 – very close to the ideal pH for SRBs. The pH entering DSR V1 remained
fairly constant at an average of 9.2.
Figure 4: Sulfate concentration and pH in primary DSR (DSR V1) inlet and outlet
The difference in pH levels across DSR V1 could potentially confirm SRB functioning, as a drop in
pH is most likely due to the breakdown and release of organic acids from the sugarcane bagasse (this
breakdown is attributed to the SRB using the substrate). Another confirmation of SRB activity is the
presence of sulfide, which was measured in the outlet and averaged at 12.47 mg/L. A 2% drop in
manganese, an 84% drop in magnesium, a 6% drop in calcium and a 27% average drop in iron was
measured over DSR V1.
There was also a large drop in the proportion of precipitated metals found in the liquid sample (S4),
however, this may be due reactions within DSR V1 or through gravitational settling within the vessel.
The metals likely precipitated out of the solution as metal sulfides and adhered to the surface of the
bagasse.
The outlet of DSR V1 fed directly into the secondary DSR vessel (DSR V2) which did not contain
sugarcane bagasse. Only manganese, magnesium and calcium decreased in concentration in DSR
V2, with all other metals increasing in concentration. Sulfate decreased over DSR V2 on average by
approximately 24.32 %, giving an average final concentration of 116 mg/L. The overall percentage
change in concentrations for aluminium (from 388 mg/L to 6 mg/L), calcium (from 418 mg/L to 95
mg/L), iron (from 4256 mg/L to 18 mg/L), magnesium (426 mg/L to 5 mg/L), manganese (from 96
mg/L to 5 mg/L) and sulfate (from 15995 mg/L to 116 mg/L) over the entire process is shown in
Figure 5.
444
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 5: Concentration of metals and sulfates in inlet and outlet of entire system
A significant change in colour of the untreated AMD could also be observed (Figure 6) which could
be attributed to the removal of metal and sulfate by the process. The initial pH of the system was
2.38 and a final pH of 7.66 was measured for the outlet. These conditions changed slightly after
storage in the water reservoir due to exposure to oxygen, but the quality of the water remained fairly
constant. Over the 32 day period, approximately 30 L of AMD was treated.
Figure 6: Image of untreated AMD (left), partially treated AMD exiting sedimentation vessel
(middle) and remediated AMD (right) exiting secondary DSR vessel (DSR V2)
4.
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The AMD was remediated to a pH of between 7 and 8, and heavy metals and sulfate to levels of
below 10 mg/L for Al, Fe, Mg, Mn and <200 mg/L for sulfate. Thus, the system showed promising
results. However, the recycle rate was high (95 %) due in part to lack of automated pH controls on
the sedimentation tank which lead to very high pH. Future work will focus on lowering the pH of the
445
Solid waste management
sedimentation tank into the 5-6 pH range which will also aid in optimizing the ability of the SRBs to
achieve sulfate removal and metals precipitation.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank Phoenix Slag Services, Illovo Sugar and our mining partner for their
support. We would also like to thank the Water Research Commission (WRC) of South Africa for
their financial contribution through project K5/2757.
References
1. Durand, J. (2012) ‘The impact of gold mining on the Witwatersrand on the rivers and karst system
of Gauteng and North West Province, South Africa’ Journal of African Earth Science, 68, pp.
24-43
2. Mccarthy, T.S., Africa, S. & Africa, S. (2011) 'The impact of acid mine drainage in South Africa'
South African Journal of Science, 107(5/6), pp.1–7.
3. Naicker, K., Cukrowska, E. & Mccarthy, T.S. (2003). 'Acid mine drainage arising from gold
mining activity in Johannesburg', South Africa and environs. 122, pp.29–40.
4. Feng, D., Deventer, J.S.J. Van & Aldrich, C. (2004) 'Removal of pollutants from acid mine
wastewater using metallurgical by-product slags' Seperation and Purification Technology. ,
40(1), pp.61–67.
5. Ziemkiewicz, P. (1998) Steel Slag: Application for AMD control. Conference on Hazardous
Waste Research, (304), pp.44–62.
6. Grubb, D.G., Landers, D.G. & Hernandez, M. (2000) 'Utilization of Sugarcane Bagasse to Treat
Acid Mine Drainage' GeoEng, 355, pp.19–24.
7. Ziemkiewicz, P., Skousen, J., Simmons, J. (2003) 'Long-term performance of passive acid mine
drainage treatment systems' Mine Water and the Environment, 22, pp. 118-129
8. Skousen, J.G., Ziemkiewicz, P. (2005) 'Performance of 116 passive treatment systems for acid
mine drainage' National Meeting of the American Society of Mining and Reclamation.
Breckenridge, Colorado, pp. 1100–1133
9. Roadcap, G., Kelly, W. & Bethke, C. (2005) 'Geochemistry of extremely alkaline (pH>12) ground
water in slag-fill aquifer' Groundwater, 43, pp.806–816.
10. Riley, A.L. & Mayes, W.M. (2015) 'Long-term evolution of highly alkaline steel slag drainage
waters' Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 187, pp. 1-16
11. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10661-015-4693-1.
12. Hussain, A. & Qazi, J.I. (2016) 'Application of sugarcane bagasse for passive anaerobic
biotreatment of sulphate rich wastewaters' Applied Water Science, 6(2), pp.205–211. Available
at: http://link.springer.com/10.1007/s13201-014-0226-2.
13. Grubb, D.G. & Hernandez, M (In Press) 'Sugarcane Bagasse as a Microbial Host Media for the
Passive Treatment of Acid Mine Drainage' Journal of environmental engineering
14. Center for bioprocess engineering research (2016). 'CeBER laboratory methods manual' CeBER
15. American Public Health Association (1975) 'Standard methods for the examination of water
and wastewater' 14th Editi., New York: APHA.
16. Gomes, H. I., Mayes, W. M., Rogerson, M., Stewart, D. I., Burke, I. T. (2016) 'Alkaline residues
and the environment: a review of impacts, management practices and opportunities' Journal of
cleaner production, 112, 3571-3582
446
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
17. Lottermoser, B. (2007) 'Mine Wastes: Characterization, Treatment and Environmental
Impacts' 2nd ed., Springer Science & Business Media.
18. Plasari, E. & Muhr, H. (2007) 'Developments in precipitation engineering for the process
intensification in the environmental protection and other purification industrial activities'
Chemical Engineering Transactions, 11, pp.65–70.
19. Balintova, M. & Petrilakova, A. (2011). 'Study of pH influence on selective precipitation of heavy
metals from acid mine drainage' Chemical Engineering Transactions, 25, pp.345–350.
20. Janyasuthiwong, S. et al. (2016) 'Effect of pH on the Performance of Sulfate and Thiosulfate-Fed
Sulfate Reducing Inverse Fluidized Bed Reactors' Journal of environmental engineering,
142(9).
447
Solid waste management
USE OF SOLID WASTES IN CEMENT PRODUCTS- A REVIEW
S. D. Mavridou*
Division of Technical Works, Thessaloniki Water Supply & Sewerage Co. S.A (EYATH S.A.),
GR- 54622 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: smavridou@eyath.gr, tel : +30-2310-966933, +30 6979248470
Abstract
Waste management is a major concern towards sustainable development and natural resources
savings. In particular, the objectives of worldwide environmental policy are to preserve, protect and
improve the quality of the environment, to protect human health and to utilize natural resources
prudently and rationally, by retrieving valuable secondary raw materials. Worldwide, researchers are
examining the possible utilization of various materials such as End of Life (EOL) Tires, C&D
(Construction and Demolition) Wastes and WEEE (Wastes from Electrical and Electronic
Equipment), in many applications. Civil Engineering sector can utilize, under specific circumstances,
many of those secondary materials for the production of new mixtures based on cement, asphalt or
soil either as alternatives to natural aggregates or as additives to the mixtures. Moreover, legislation
in force, concerning alternative management of wastes, makes these efforts more urgent, since all
European Countries should comply with its demands as far as quantitative and chronicle targets are
concerned.
Current paper monitors and evaluates technical knowhow on basic properties of cement products with
EOL Tires, C&D Wastes and WEEE gained during the last 24 years worldwide. Properties discussed
are workability, specific weight, air content and compressive strength. Laboratory experiments certify
that addition of wastes in the production of cement mortars is possible, leading to mixtures with
satisfactory characteristics as far as strength and durability is concerned. At the same time
environmental protection is achieved by decreasing the huge amount of wastes generated and by
increasing natural resources savings.
Keywords: Solid wastes, EOL Tires, C&D Wastes, WEEE, Cement products, Legislation, Strength,
Recycling
1.
INTRODUCTION
Economy growth depends strongly on the infrastructure of the cities mainly composed by buildings,
roads and geotechnical projects either in the stage of construction or in the stage after the end of their
life cycle. More frequently used building material is concrete. Given on the one hand that cement and
aggregates- main constituents of concrete products- play an important role in mixtures properties
since they occupy the larger volume of about >90% of total one and legislation in force on the other
hand, alternative management of various wastes in civil engineering applications and especially for
the production of cement based products is of crucial importance.
Huge amounts of wastes are generated annually worldwide. As a result, in force legislation demands
alternative management of either solid or liquid wastes, so civil engineering applications can be the
solution, since various wastes can be utilized for the production of green concrete products.
Secondary materials such as tire rubber from EOL Tires, recycled aggregates from Construction and
Demolition wastes and plastic particles from Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment, after special
treatment and in appropriate gradation and percentage, can be reused either as substitute for cement,
448
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
when performing pozzolana properties, leading to energy consumption savings, or as aggregates,
since many of these wastes comply with specifications for their use as such.
So, current review includes brief information regarding up to date situation concerning quantities and
law demands, as well as regarding the effect of wastes’ addition in cement based products, while
conclusion section focuses on suggestions for future/additional research.
2.
LEGISLATION CONCERNING WASTE MANAGEMENT
2.1 End of Life Tires
Most of tires are derived from land based vehicles (eg cars, trucks) and are constituted by natural
/synthetic rubber, carbon black, steel cord, polyester, nylon, steel bead wire and other chemicals. EOL
Tires pose a major environmental issue, since their often illegal disposal affects negatively the
environment and public health; discarded stockpiles can promote mosquitos development, fire
hazards, while leaching effects can pollute surface and sub-surface water and soils.
Since 2000, landfilling of end-of-life tires is banned in all European countries as a result of the
European Directive 1999/31/EC. As far as Greece is concerned, current relevant Presidential Decree
109/04 demands that by 31/7/2006, utilization of EOL Tires should be at least 65%, while recycling
should come up to at least 10%. Ecoelastika is the only legislated system responsible for the collection
and valorization of EOL Tires, aiming at their alternative management taking into account
environmental and economic criteria and the law. Data related to EOL Tires amount as well as on
their alternative management in Greece can be found on figures 1,2 and 3, respectively
(http://ecoelastika.gr).
Figure 1: New tires (first green column) and collected (second blue column) EOL Tires in
Greece
Figure 2: Energy recovery (in red) and recycling (in green) of EOL Tires in Greece
449
Solid waste management
Figure 3: EOL Tires in Collective spaces (in red), in processing units (in green) and total
quantity (blue line) in Greece
2.2 Construction and Demolition Wastes (C&DW)
Construction and demolition wastes (C&DW) is one of the most voluminous waste streams generated
worldwide from activities such as the construction and/or total or partial demolition of buildings and
civil infrastructure after their reach the end of their life cycle, road planning and maintenance actions.
Especially for Europe, it accounts for approximately 25% - 30% of all waste generated in the EU and
consists of materials such as concrete, bricks, wood, glass, metals, plastic, solvents, asbestos and
excavated soil. There is a high potential for recycling and re-use of C&DW, since some of its
components have a high resource value (eg concrete, bricks and metals). In particular, there is a reuse market for aggregates derived from C&DW waste in construction projects based on cement,
asphalt and soil. Technology for the separation and recovery of construction and demolition waste is
well established and easily accessible http://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/studies/deliverables/CDW_Greece_Factsheet_Final.pdf.
One of the objectives of the “Regulating issues of the Ministry of Environment, Energy and Climate
Change” Directive (2008/98/EC) is to provide a framework so Member States shall take the necessary
measures designed to achieve that by 2020 a minimum of 70% (by weight) of non-hazardous
construction and demolition waste excluding naturally occurring material defined in category 17 05
04 in the List of Wastes shall be prepared for re-use, recycled or undergo other material recovery"
(including backfilling operations using waste to substitute other materials).
Table 1: Quantities and % recycling of generated CDW in different EU member states in
2006
Source: http://ec.europa.eu/dgs/environment/index_en.htm
According to Table 1, the recycling rate for C&DW in Denmark, Estonia, Germany, Ireland and the
Netherlands is very high >70%, so the 70% of 2020 EU recycling target is already exceeded. The
450
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
major part of the C&DW is mineral waste (concrete waste, bricks) which is currently used as
aggregate in roads, parking areas or in embankments. However, there are other countries, including
Greece, that recycle much smaller amounts of wastes.
The management of Construction and Demolition Waste in Greece faces several challenges and
appears to be significantly underperforming, despite the existing quite rich legislative framework
concerning the management of C&DW which is in place since 2010 with several new legislation,
regulations and amendments following up since then. In particular, the legislative framework for
waste management in Greece is defined by Law 4042/2012-“Penal protection of the environment”,
which complies with Directives 2008/98/EC and 2008/99/EC “Framework for waste generation and
management”. Further legislation, regulations and guidelines concerning C&DW in Greece includes
mainly the Joint Ministerial Decision (JMD) 36259/1757/E103 of 2010 stipulating measures,
conditions and programmes for the alternative management of excavation, construction and
demolition waste (ECDW), Law 4030/2011 and especially article 40, which describes permit issuing
provisions for C&DW treatment facilities in inactive quarries and the rules for accepting and
managing CDW in these treatment facilities, Law 4067 of 2012, where Article 17 stipulates that for
the construction of any building and the landscaping of the building surroundings, the provisions of
the relevant legislation for alternative management of waste from excavation, construction and
demolition waste should be applied, Circular 13 of the Ministry of Environment, Energy and Climate
Change No. 4834 of 25 January 2013 with subject the ‘Management of excess excavation materials
from Public Works - Clarifications on the requirements of the JMD 36259/1757/E103/2010’,
exempting the management of excess materials from excavation activities during public works
through the certified systems of alternative C&DW management, as long as the excess material is
handled in sound environmental manner, Commission Decision 2011/753/EU establishing rules and
calculation methods for verifying compliance with the targets set in Article 11(2) of Directive
2008/98/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council14.
Quantitative data concerning 2012, indicates that about 815 thousand tonnes of C& DW was
generated, of which only 2.7 was recovered (including backfilling), while the rest was sent to landfills.
C&DW generation is decreasing steadily since 2010, due to the significant slowdown in the
construction sector; however, given that many building and infrastructure projects are reaching the
end of their life cycle, these amounts are expected to be increased in the future.
Additionally, preliminary data for 2014, estimates that the actual C&DW recovery performance of
Greece lies approximately between 12-15%. However, those data are relative, since large quantities
of C&DW are illegally managed, through landfilling/ illegal deposit in natural sites preferably in
remote locations which are difficult to be detected http://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/studies/deliverables/CDW_Greece_Factsheet_Final.pdf.
2.3 Waste of Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE)
Waste of Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) is one the fastest growing waste streams in
the EU, with approximately 9 million tonnes generated in 2005, and expected to grow to more than
12 million tonnes by 2020. Such wastes include Tv’s, fridges, cell phones, cables electric
switchboards, distribution boards, circuit breakers and disconnects, electricity meter, transformers
etc. Main characteristic of some of those devices is their hazardous content, which if not properly
managed, can cause severe environmental and health issues. This is also why this sort of waste should
be separated collected.
The relevant Directive (WEEE Directive) is the European Community Directive 2012/19/EU
on Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) which followed Directive 2002/96/EC and is
in accordance with RoHS Directive 2002/95/EC. The legislation requires heavy metals such as lead,
mercury, cadmium, and hexavalent chromium and flame retardants such as polybrominated biphenyls
(PBB) or polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDE) to be substituted by safer alternatives. From 15
August 2018 onwards the scope of the Directive is widened to include all EEE. The Directive aims
to prevent or reduce the negative environmental effects resulting from the generation and
451
Solid waste management
management of WEEE and from resource use. As reflected in the Directive’s recital 6, its key purpose
is to contribute to sustainable production and consumption by, as a first priority, the prevention of
WEEE and, in addition, by the re-use, recycling and other forms of recovery of such wastes. The
Directive thus incorporates the waste hierarchy as established in Article 4 of Directive 2008/98/EC
on waste (http://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/weee/index_en.htm).
The new WEEE Directive (2012/19/EU of the European Parliament and the Council of 4 July 2012
on waste electrical and electronic equipment) introduces a collection target of 45% of electronic
equipment sold that will apply from 2016 and, as a second step from 2019, a target of 65% of
equipment sold, or 85% of WEEE generated. The new collection targets agreed will ensure that
around 10 million tons, or roughly 20kg per capita, will be separately collected from 2019 onwards.
Article 11 (in combination with annex V) sets the recycling targets for the different product
categories.
Regarding Greece, approximately 80 to 115 million tonnes of WEEE are estimated to be generated
annually. Those wastes are classified of high priority, because of their hazardous content, of their
continuously increase and of their negative effect on the environment.
The only legislated system for the proper management of all categories of WEEE is Recycling of
Devices, which is responsible since 2004 (MD 105134/2004) and till 2018 (https://www.eoan.gr).
As far as quantitative targets set by legislation (JMD 23615/2014), a minimum of 50-55% of total
WEEE shall be recycled and 70-75% shall be recovered. However, these percentages vary for
different materials which are included in Annexes I, II and III of the law.
3.
CEMENT PRODUCTS WITH WASTES
Studies on the use of secondary materials-from wastes- either as coarse or fine aggregates in concrete
and cement mortars is possible, when such particles are used with the appropriate method and in the
appropriate gradation and percentage. Main research has been focused on the production of new
concrete mixtures with the use of various wastes, in order to examine the effect of their gradation to
the mixtures properties, while only few studies include examination of this effect on cement mortars.
Following, indicative laboratory results are briefly presented. These results examine the sole or
combined use of EOL Tires, C& DW and Electrical and Electronic Equipment for the production of
new cement based concrete and mortars.
3.1 Properties of cement products with EOL Tires in fresh and hardened state
Workability is defined as the mixture’s property to be properly managed in fresh state. Addition of
coarse rubber particles results in mixtures with increased workability, while addition of fines has an
opposite effect (Khatib and Bayomy, 1999). However, addition of rubber particles even coarse ones
in more than 40% per volume gives mixtures with zero workability, so the mixture is not at all
workable. This fact is attributed to the high viscosity of aggregates, given the increased friction
between tire rubber particles and the rest of the mixture as well as on the decreased mixtures’ density.
As far as cement mortars is concerned, according to Raghavan et al (1998), performance of mortars
with tire rubber is better or similar to the one of reference mixture, while use of rubber particles as
substitutes for fine ones at 100%, results in a decrease of workability up to 17% (Mavridou, 2010).
Specific weight of rubberized concrete (rubcrete) decreases by the increase of rubber substitute’s
percentage. This is mainly due to the lower specific weight of rubber compared to the one of natural
aggregates, occupying, especially when used as fines, at the same time more volume (El-Dieb et al,
2001). According to Eldin and Senouci (1993) the decrease in specific weight comes up to 25% with
fully substitution of coarse aggregates and to 10% when 33% of fines are replaced with rubber (Li et
al, 1998). As far as cement mortars is concerned, use of tire rubber particles as substitute for cement
causes decrease in specific weight of the mixture (42% for 50% substitution of cement by rubber
452
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
according to Benazzouk et al, 2007, while for 100% substitution of the sand the decrease comes up
to 46% (Mavridou, 2010).
Air content: addition of rubber particles in concrete results in an increase of air content, even when
air additive is not used (Siddique and Naik, 2004). Gradation of rubber particles plays a significant
role on air content, since fine rubber particles leads to a higher increase of air content as compared to
coarse ones for percentages of >20% (Khatib and Bayomy, 1999). This can be attributed to the trend
of rubber particles to repel water and to include air in their tough surface. As far as cement mortars
is concerned addition of tire rubber caused a negligible increase of 2% in air content.
Compressive strength: Addition of rubber particles in concrete may cause a significant decrease in
compressive strength when added in high percentages >5% (Li et al, 2004; Τuratsinze et al, 2005;
Ganjian et al, 2009; Blessen and Gupta, 2016). However, regarding strength development, rubber
seems to increase prime strength, while decreasing strength at 28 days and for addition of rubber
particles more than 20 per volume (Khatib and Bayomy, 1999). Strength decrease can be attributed
to three reasons: first of all, rubber is a material with increased elasticity compared to the rest of the
mixture, so developed cracks are monitored peripheral to rubber particles leading to failure at a lower
load. Secondly, rubber particles can act as voids, so mixture’s structure is weaker. Finally, strength
of concrete is mainly based in the shape, density and hardness of coarse aggregates, so when those
are replaced with ones of lower hardness, a strength loss is the result (Mehta and Monteiro, 1993). In
particular, factors such as percentage, gradation, way of mixing and surface of rubber particles may
cause strength’s loss, while this loss is higher when coarse aggregates are replaced (Topçu, 1995).
Optimum percentage of rubber particles used is 50% and 25% per volume for fines and coarse ones,
respectively (El-Dieb et al, 2001), while decrease comes up to 85% and 65%, with fully replacement
of coarse and fines respectively (Eldin and Senouci, 1993).
Moreover, particles surface plays an important role on strength’s development, since their surface is
strongly related to the bonding between particles and the rest of the mixture, leading to increased
strength (Nehdi and Khan, 2001). Many researchers examined ways of changing particles surface.
Means for this change can be by rinsing with water, with saturated NaOH solution [rubber includes
zink stearate which causes strength’s loss, so by rinsing with NaOH, zink is removed and
homogeneity is increased (Segre et al, 2002)]; with HNO3 and H2SO4 solution, by the use of coupling
agents, etc (Siddique and Naik, 2004).
According to Rostami et al, 1993, concrete with rinsed with water rubber particles shows improved
strength by 16%, while the increase by the use of solvent can come up to 57%. Moreover, addition of
latex can cause improvement of the bonding between rubber particles and the rest of the mixture, so
strength is increased (Lee et al, 1998).
As far as cement mortars is concerned, 30% replacement of fines causes a decrease in strength up to
55-80%, for different water to cement ratios (Turatsinze et al, 2006, Mavridou 2010). Furthermore,
mortars with rinsed rubber particles- either with water or NaOH causes an increase in strength up to
19%, while addition of latex and bitumen anionic emulsion increased strength ranging between 10
and 21%, respectively (Mavridou, 2010).
3.2 Properties of cement products with C& D Wastes in fresh and hardened state
Recycled aggregates (REC) can be used for the production of new concrete mixtures and cement
mortars, respectively with quite satisfactory characteristics (Dapena et al, 2011). However, often,
C&D Waste’s composition is not steady, while there is no CE for those materials, so since they may
generate from buildings of different age, different concrete category etc, the recycled C& DW at the
output of the recycling process should comply with standards and must have technical criteria similar
to that of the natural products in order to be used for construction activities.
Main problem of recycled aggregates (REC) is related to the increased water absorption (Poon et al,
2004), which is due to the cement paste attached in recycled aggregate’s surface. This fact results in
453
Solid waste management
decreased mechanical strength, since for specific w/c ratio, recycled aggregates absorb significant
water content, so cement’s hydration is limited.
Researches on conventional concrete with recycled aggregates lead to the following results:
A decrease in workability, an increase in air voids, as well as a decrease in compressive strength
has been monitored (Khatib 2005; Xiao et al, 2018). This decrease is influenced by recycled
aggregates gradation and is higher for fine aggregates substitution by recycled ones (Evangelista
and de Brito, 2007).
However, concrete mixture with recycled coarse aggregates and conventional fines, can have a
slightly higher compressive strength compared to conventional one by up to 5% (~47MPa), which
indicate that the use, mainly of coarse aggregates, has potential and can lead to mixtures with
satisfactory characteristics and similar to the ones of mixtures with natural aggregates. Moreover,
such mixtures can be cost effective. In particular, when recycled coarse aggregates substituted
natural ones of the same gradation, the price of concrete mixture came up to 55.05€/m3, while
conventional mixture costs 55.65€ (Mavridou and Oikonomou, 2009). This difference in cost can
be increased by the wider use of recycled aggregates in public and private construction projects,
so secondary’s material cost will be decreased.
As far as self compacted concrete is concerned, the optimum percentage of substitution of fines by
recycled aggregates has been found to be 30% w/t of the aggregates (fine and coarse ones) while
compressive strength of the mixture came up to 28.48MPa with a cost of 66.58€/m3 (Mavridou et al,
2013).
Moreover, light transmitting concrete with recycled aggregates has also been examined. REC
replaced natural aggregates. According to laboratory results, transparent concrete with plastic optical
fibres and recycled aggregates show satisfactory characteristics, while compressive strength at 28
days can come up to 22MPa for percentage of optical fibres 1.04v/v (Mavridou et al, 2018).
Regarding cement mortars, recycled aggregate- recycled sand (RS) - can replace part of the fine
aggregate fraction (Neno et al, 2014). However, due to the high demand of RS for water, as expected,
mixtures are of worse mechanical strength and of lower workability (Westerholm et al, 2008). For
replacement of standard sand by 50% of recycled sand, compressive strength is found to decrease by
47%. As far as workability is concerned, it can be improved by the addition of superplastisizer at a
percentage of 1.25% for RS replacement of 50 and 75% of sand (Ferro et al, 2015). Another research
of Behera et al, 2014, examined the effect of washed recycled sand in mortars properties. According
to laboratory results, washing and sieving of the recycled aggregates can give mixtures with
satisfactory and even equal to reference mixture’s characteristics given that an additional amount
(1%) of super plasticizer is added.
3.3
Properties of cement products with Wastes from Electrical and Electronic Equipment in
fresh and hardened state
There are quite few studies on the use of WEEE in cement based products (Mahdi 2017; Vishwakarma
and Ramachandran, 2018). However, preliminary studies include WEEE’s use as alternative to
conventional aggregates or as additives to the cement products.
An experimental study has been made on the utilization of E-waste particles as fine and coarse
aggregates in concrete with a percentage replacement up to 30% by weight of cement on the strength
criteria of M20 Concrete (design compressive strength of 20MPa). Addition of e-waste plastic was
found to decrease mixtures’ workability, density and compressive strength by increasing plastic
percentage, while strength’s value reached 44MPa for 10% addition of e- waste plastic. Moreover, in
such mixtures, given the weak bonding between plastic aggregates and cement paste, the effect of
water to cement ratio is not prominent. Furthermore, addition of plastics in concrete tends to make
concrete ductile, hence increasing the ability of concrete to significantly deform before failure,
454
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
increasing mixtures’ durability against harsh weather such as expansion and contraction, or freeze
and thaw (Aswini Manjunath 2016).
Subramani and Pugal (2015) examined the suitability and advantages of the use of recycled plastics,
and especially of Polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB) as coarse aggregates in concrete. Plastic has replaced
coarse aggregates by 5-15% wt of the aggregates leading to mixtures with strength comparable to the
one of the reference mixture (~25MPa). However, in percentages >20%, plastic was found to have
detrimental effect on mixtures strength.
Another research of Lakshmi and Nagan (2010) for the replacement of up to 30% of coarse aggregates
by e-waste ones lead to concrete with good strength gain for relatively low percentages (<4%) of
plastic (~20MPa), while Prasanna and Rao (2014) found that compressive strength of concrete was
optimum when coarse aggregate is replaced by 15% with E-Waste reaching a value of ~31 MPa.
These differences in strength for various e-wastes percentages are attributed to raw materials
properties- eg chemical composition, gradation-, to water to cement ratio as well as to the treatment
method of e-waste.
The usage of e-waste to make Green Concrete can reduce the land-filled or disposal problems of the
E-waste materials. Especially, plastics can be used to replace some of the aggregates in a concrete
mixture, contributing mainly to reducing the unit weight of the concrete. This is useful in applications
requiring non-bearing lightweight concrete, such as concrete panels used in facades.
3.4
Properties of cement products with the combined use of EOL Tires, C& D Wastes and
WEEE in fresh and hardened state
Even though there are many studies on the sole use of wastes in cement based products, there is only
little on the combined use of solid wastes. In Greece, recent laboratory experiments have been
conducted on the combined use of such materials (both recycled aggregates and rubber tire, or
recycled aggregates, rubber tire and plastic from EEE) for the production of cement mortars. First
step was the examination of basic properties such as gradation curve, water absorption and sand
equivalent of raw materials according to European Specifications. Following, cement mortars have
been produced and examined as far as their properties in fresh and hardened state are concerned.
Fresh state properties included workability, specific weight and air content, while in hardened state
tests on specific weight, flexural and compressive strength and water absorption have been conducted.
According to laboratory results, addition of recycled aggregates at percentage up to 40% w/t of the
sand and tire rubber at a percentage of 2,5% w/t of the sand results in a decrease on the strength of
the mixtures. Moreover, as expected, both recycled aggregates and tire rubber gave mixtures with
decreased workability and strength (~25MPa). However, mixture including all three wastes resulted
in compressive strength of more than 20MPa, value quite high for cement mortars.
4.
CONCLUSIONS- FUTURE RESEARCH
Waste streams such as EOL Tires, C&D Wastes and WEEE pose a significant health and
environmental concern if not recycled and/or discarded properly. Management issues of such wastes
are relatively complicated; on the one hand the high availability of conventional raw materials, while
on the other hand the recent legislation, which public organizations and construction involved people
are not so familiar to, makes the problem more difficult to deal with.
All wastes may have many secondary uses; EOL Tires can be a low cost source of fuel in power
plants, while they can be used in a variety of civil engineering projects such as embankments, backfill
for walls, for the production of rubber-modified asphalt (resulting in reduced traffic noise),
lightweight concrete, sports fields, ground cover in playgrounds etc. Their characteristics (light
weighting, permeability, insulating properties, shock and noise absorbing) make them excellent
materials for these uses. Furthermore, all waste streams are a resource that can be used as substitutes
for natural aggregates, reducing resource depletion and lowering environmental costs associated with
455
Solid waste management
natural resource exploitation. So, over the years, more and more researchers examine the possible use
of these wastes in various applications and especially into concrete products.
This review summarizes the main advances in the use of EOL Tires, C&D Wastes and WEEE in
concrete and cement mortars. The general findings monitored in current paper may vary from others,
since any change in materials characteristics, proportions of the ingredients, mixing and curing
procedure as well as use of admixtures or additives may lead to slightly different conclusions.
In general, and in most of the cases addition of wastes, especially in fine gradation and in relatively
high percentage, in cement based products, may result in the production of mixtures with decreased
workability, increased air content, decreased specific weight and compressive strength.
Modified with wastes cement products can be advantageous for special applications where the main
request is not for mechanical properties. Such applications are in the production of sound barriers, of
pedestrian and cement blocks, as lightweight concrete walls, in stabilized base layers in flexible
pavements, building facades and architectural units as well as in structures exposed to aggressive
environments where high resistance to chloride ions penetration is required.
The use of such wastes, even in small percentages, in concrete can have additionally
numerous indirect benefits such as reduction in landfill cost, saving in energy, and protection of
the environment from possible pollution effects, while at the same time, cement products with
satisfactory characteristics are provided.
However, further researches should focus on the improvement of the bonding between the wastes and
the rest of the mixtures, so as to give mixtures with both increased mechanical characteristics and
improved durability performance. This improvement may be achieved by the use of appropriate
chemicals/ additives, by cleaning secondary materials, by modifying their surface as well as by
combining appropriate percentage and gradation of wastes included.
References
1. Presidential Decree No.109. (2004). ‘Means and terms for alternative management of worn
mobile tires’. Program for their alternative management, 5th March 2004, Paper of Government
of Hellenic Democracy, 1st Part.
2. http://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/studies/deliverables/CDW_Greece_Factsheet_Final.pdf.
(accessed April 3rd 2018).
3. Joint Ministerial Decision (JMD) 36259/1757/E103. (2010). ‘Measures, terms and program for
the alternative management of waste from excavation, construction and demolition (ECDW)’.
4. Directive 2012/19/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 July 2012 on waste
electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE).
5. https://www.eoan.gr (accessed April 3rd 2018).
6. JMD 23615/2014, ‘Measures, terms and conditions for the alternative management of waste
materials of electrical and electronic equipment’.
7. Khatib Z.K. and F.M. Bayomy. (1999). ‘Rubberized Portland cement concrete’. ASCE Journal
of Materials in Civil Engineering 11 (3), pp.206-213.
8. Raghvan D., H. Huynh, C.F. Ferraris. (1998). ‘Workability, mechanical properties and chemical
stability of a recycled tire rubber-filled cementitious composite’. Journal of Materials Science
33 (7), pp.1745–1752.
9. Mavridou S. (2010). ‘Utilization of recycled tire rubber form automobiles in special cement
of asphalt based mortars and concrete’, Ph.D. thesis, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki,
Greece.
456
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
10. El-Dieb A.S., M.M Abdel-Wahab and M.E. Abdel-Hameed. (2001). ‘Concrete using rubber tyre
particles as aggregate’. In: Dhir, R.K. (Ed.), Proceedings of the International Symposium
organized by the Concrete Technology Unit, University of Dundee, UK, pp.251-259.
11. Eldin N.N. and A.B. Senouci. (1993). “Rubber-tire particles as concrete aggregates”. ASCE
Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering 5 (4), pp.478–496.
12. Li Z, Li F and Li JSL. (1998). ‘Properties of concrete incorporating rubber tyre particles’.
Magazine of Concrete Research, Vol.50, No 4, Dec 1998, pp.297-304.
13. Benazzouk A, Douzane O, Langlet T, Mezreb K, Roucoult JM, Quéneudec M. (2007). ‘Physicomechanical properties and water absorption of cement composite containing shredded rubber
wastes’. Cement & Concrete Composites, 29, pp.732-740.
14. Siddique R., R.T. Naik. (2004). ‘Properties of concrete containing scrap-tire rubber-an overview’.
Waste Management 24, pp.563-569.
15. Rostami H, Lepore J, Silverstraim T, Zundi I. (1993). ‘Use of recycled rubber tires in concrete’.
In: Dhir, R.K. (Ed.), Proceedings of the International Conference on Concrete 2000,
University of Dundee, Scotland, UK, pp.391–399.
16. Li G, Stubblefield MA, Garrick G, Eggers J, Abadie Ch, Huang B. (2004). ‘Development of waste
tire modified concrete’. Cement and Concrete Research 34, pp.2283-2289.
17. Turatsinze A, Bonnet S, Granju J-L. (2005). ‘Mechanical characterization of cement-based mortar
incorporating rubber aggregates from recycled worn tyres’. Building and Environment Vol.40,
pp. 221-226.
18. Ganjian E, M. Khorami and A.A. Maghsoudi. (2009). ‘Scrap- tyre- rubber replacement for
aggregate and filler in concrete’. Construction and Building Materials, 23, pp.1828-1836.
19. Blessen S. T. and Gupta R. Ch. (2016). ‘A comprehensive review on the applications of waste
tire rubber in cement concrete’. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 54, pp.13231333.
20. Mehta P K and Monteiro P J M. (1993). ‘Concrete, Structures, Properties and Materials’, 2nd
Edition, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
21. Topçu IB. (1995). ‘The properties of rubberized concrete’. Cement and Concrete Research 25
(2), pp.304–310.
22. Nehdi M. and A. Kan. (2001). ‘Cementitious Composites Containing Recycled Tire Rubber: An
overview of Engineering Properties and Potential Applications’. Cement, Concrete and
Aggregates, CCAGDP, Vol.23, No1, pp. 3-10.
23. Lee HS, H. Lee, J.S. Moon and H.W. Jung. (1998). ‘Development of tire- added latex concrete’.
ACI Materials Journal, 95, (4), pp.356-364.
24. Turatsinze A, J-L Granju and S. Bonnet. (2006). ‘Positive synergy between steel-fibres and rubber
aggregates: Effect on the resistance of cement-based mortars to shrinkage cracking’. Cement and
Concrete Research, 36, pp.1692-1697.
25. Shi-Cong, K. and Chi-Sun, P. (2009). ‘Properties of concrete prepared with crushed fine stone,
furnace bottom ash and fine recycled aggregates as fine aggregates’. Construction and Building
Materials 23, pp.2877–2886.
26. Dapena, E., P. Alaeyos, A. Lobet and D. Pérez. (2011). ‘Effect of recycled sand content on
characteristics of mortars and concretes’. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering 23, pp. 414422.
457
Solid waste management
27. Poon C.S, Z.H. Shui, L. Lam, H. Fok, S.C. Kou. (2004). ‘Influence of moisture states of natural
and recycled aggregates on the slump and compressive strength of concrete’. Cement and
Concrete Research, 34 (1), pp. 31-36.
28. Khatib, J.M. (2005). ‘Properties of concrete incorporating fine recycled aggregates’. Cement and
Concrete Research 35, pp. 763–769.
29. Xiao J., Z. Ma, T. Sui, A. Akbarnezhad and Z. Duan. (2018). ‘Mechanical properties of concrete
mixed with recycled powder produced from construction and demolition waste’. Journal of
Cleaner Production, 188, pp.720-731.
30. Evangelista, L. and J. de Brito. (2007). ‘Mechanical behaviour of concrete made with fine
recycled concrete aggregates’. Cement and Concrete Composites 29, pp. 397-401.
31. Mavridou, S. and N. Oikonomou. (2009). ‘Experimental approach of using recycled aggregate
from industrial processing in the production of new concrete’. Part II, Electronic Proceeding of
the 16th Concrete Conference. Paphos, Cyprus.
32. Mavridou S., N. Oikonomou and E. Kaisidou. (2013). ‘Utilization of construction and demolition
wastes (C&D W) for the production of new concrete mixtures’. In abstract Proceedings of the
CEMEPE/SECOTOX 2013 Conference. Mykonos, Greece.
33. Mavridou S, A. Savva and N. Trochoutsou. (2018). ‘Compressive strength in regular and high
temperatures of light transmitting concrete with conventional and recycled aggregates’. Proc.
Pan-Hellenic Concrete Conference. Technical Chamber of Greece, Athens, Greece.
34. Neno, C., J. de Brito and R. Veiga. (2014). ‘Using fine recycled concrete aggregate for mortar
production’. Materials research 17, pp.168-177.
35. Westerholm, M., B. Lagerblad, J. Silfwerbrand, E. Forssberg. (2008). ‘Influence of fine aggregate
characteristics on the rheological properties of mortars’. Cement and Concrete Composites 30,
pp.274–282.
36. Ferro G.A, C. Spoto, J.M. Tulliani, L. Restuccia. (2015). ‘Mortar made of recycled sand from
C&D’, in XXIII Italian Group of Fracture Meeting, Procedia Engineering 109, pp.240-247.
37. Behera M., S.K. Bhattacharyya, A.K. Minocha, R. Deoliya, S. Maiti. (2014). ‘Recycled aggregate
from C&D waste & its use in concrete- A breakthrough towards sustainability in construction
sector: A review’. Construction and Building Materials, 68, pp.501-516.
38. Mahdi I. (2017). ‘Environmental impacts and benefits of state-of-the-art technologies for E-waste
management’. Waste Management 68, pp.458-474.
39. Vishwakarma V. and D. Ramachandran. (2018). ‘Green concrete mix using solid waste and
nanoparticles’. Construction and Building Materials, 162, pp.96-103.
40. Aswini Manjunath B.T. (2016). ‘Partial replacement of e-plastic waste as coarse aggregate in
concrete’. Procedia Environmental Sciences, Vol35, pp.731-739.
41. Subramani T. and V.K. Pugal. (2015). ‘Experimental Study on plastic waste as a coarse aggregate
for structural concrete’. International Journal of Application or Innovation in Engineering &
Management, Vol 4 (5), ISSN 2319-4847.
42. Lakshmi R. and S. Nagan. (2010). ‘Studies on concrete containing E plastic waste’. Int. J.
Environ. Sci. 1 (3), pp. 270-281.
43. Prasanna K. and M. K. Rao. (2014). ‘Strength variations in concrete by using E-waste as coarse
aggregate’. IJEAR 4 (2), pp.82-84.
458
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
A WEB-BASED PLATFORM FOR LANDFILL LEACHATE
ESTIMATION AND MANAGEMENT
M. Kotsikas and K. Poulios*
Regional Association of Solid Waste Management Agencies of Central Macedonia, GR- 54626
Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: kpoulios@civil.auth.gr, tel : +302310508800
Abstract
The water balance method was used to develop a landfill leachate management and monitoring
software, on behalf of the Regional Association of Solid Waste Management Agencies of Central
Macedonia (RAACM). The aim of the software is to monitor and estimate the leachate generation
rate in each landfill operating in the region. It can be used retrospectively where no direct flow
measurement is possible, and also as a design tool for future leachate management works under
different scenarios. A web-based application was selected, since large spreadsheets can be error
prone, and to overcome difficulties arising from the large geographical dispersion of the landfills. A
monthly step is used for the estimation of the generation rate and the performance of each wastewater
treatment plant (WWTP) is evaluated by modeling the hydrologic and hydraulic conditions in each
landfill. The innovation of this software is that it estimates leachate generation for landfills that are
in operation, when most of the existing tools (e.g. HELP) are for inactive sites.
During the development of the software, a group of assumptions were tested for their influence in the
leachate generation rate. According to the results of water balance that was applied to Mavrorachi
landfill for the period 2008-2017, separating the landfill in lifts results in leachate generation rates
that differ up to 22% from those calculated without separating it. Nevertheless, other parameters, such
as the precipitation distribution between different lifts, that are difficult to estimate or collect monthly,
affect the calculation of leachate generation rate very little (1-5%).
Keywords: Sanitary landfill, Water balance, Leachate management, Environmental tools, Solid
waste management
1.
INTRODUCTION
Landfills still constitute an important part of any waste management system and will continue to do
so in the foreseeable future, as final sinks for non recyclable or hazardous materials (Brunner, 2013;
Kral & Brunner, 2014; Scharff, Hansen, & Thrane, 2014). Despite efforts to the contrary, in Greece
an average of ca. 82% of Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) were still landfilled in 2016 (Brennan et al.,
2016; EUROSTAT, 2018). One of the most significant environmental impacts of landfills, emanating
inter alia from the long operational periods and even longer aftercare and final stabilization times, is
leachate generation (Christensen, 2010; Scharff et al., 2013). When designing leachate management
works, such as WWTPs, estimating and predicting accurately the leachate generation rate has many
environmental and economic benefits. A large underestimation of landfill’s leachate generation rate
could result in many WWTP operation failures and severe environmental impacts. On the other hand
overestimation of landfill’s leachate generation rate results in oversized and unnecessary WWTPs
with large investment and operating costs.
459
Solid waste management
The RAACM operates ten active MSW landfills and two sites under aftercare, along with their
corresponding WWTPs. Through the years the landfills continuously receive waste, so their capacity
and the leachate generation rate are raised. Correspondingly, the leachate management works need
upgrades which are designed by estimating the leachate generation rate.
In order to optimize the estimation, a platform is developed where landfill data are input, and through
a complex algorithm that uses the water balance method the leachate generation rate is calculated.
The water balance method used in its analytical form, as presented by (Tchobanoglous et al, 1993)
separating the landfill in lifts. Available tools such as HELP (Schroeder et al, 1994) are less suited
for use on landfills in operation (Athiniotou et al, 2012).
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Theoretical background
The most common method for estimating the leachate generation rate in landfills is the water balance
method. This method takes into account all the water inflows in the landfill and subtracts the water
losses (Figure 1). The most significant inflow parameters are the amount of precipitation that is
infiltrated, the moisture from fresh MSW and leachate recirculation. The losses are due to landfill gas
formation (a part is consumed during biodegradation and another escapes as vapor with landfill gas).
Another very important parameter is the field capacity of MSW, since it determines the amount of
leachate generated from each lift and finally onto the Leachate Collection and Removal System
(LCRS), as generally reported in the literature (Frikha et al, 2017), and demonstrated in this study.
Figure 1: Water balance applied in a sanitary landfill
2.2 Infiltration
The infiltration is the amount of precipitation that falls on the landfill and passes through the daily
cover. It can be estimated by the following equation:
PERSW = P – R – ET -ΔSw
(1)
Where:
PERSW = amount of water percolating through the unit area of landfill cover into compacted
solid waste (mm)
P= amount of precipitation per unit area, (mm)
460
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
R= amount of runoff per unit area (mm)
ΕΤ= amount of water lost through evapotranspiration per unit area (mm)
ΔSLC = change in the amount of water held in storage in a unit volume of landfill cover (mm)
Precipitation (P): Precipitation can be estimated from data obtained from weather stations inside or
near the landfill area. In case of weather stations not inside the landfill area, the data are adjusted
according to the altitude difference.
Evapotranspiration (ΕΤ): Evaporation is the process where liquid water is converted to vapor and
escapes from the evaporating surface. Transpiration consists of the vaporization of liquid water to the
atmosphere via plant roots.
In order to estimate the ET from landfill cover the Potential ET (PET) is calculated. PET is considered
as the amount of ET when there is excess of water in the landfill cover. The most widely used
equations for estimating PET are Penman-Montheith and Thornthwaite’s. The first is more accurate
but needs more data such as mean temperature, wind speed, humidity and solar radiation.
Thornthwaite’s equation is simpler because it requires only the mean temperature as input. For the
development of software the Thornthwaite’s equation is used because it is the simplest one and the
differences in the leachate generation estimation are small.
Mean temperature can be estimated from data obtained from weather stations inside or near the
landfill area. In case of weather stations not inside the landfill area, the data are adjusted according to
the altitude difference, as with precipitation.
Run-off (R): Run-off is the amount of precipitation that flows in the surface of landfill cover, is
collected from the perimeter drainage trench and is not infiltrated inside the landfill body. Run-off is
the most difficult parameter to estimate in active landfills because the hydraulic characteristics of
surface area change dynamically. So, to calculate the water balance, in short time periods, ideally per
month, the landfill must be divided into segments with common hydraulic characteristics.
Run-off is calculated as a percentage of the precipitation, according to the following equation:
R = C R.P
(2)
Where:
CR = run-off co-efficient (dimensionless)
Run-off co-efficient is an empirical dimensionless constant with values between 0 (no run-off) and 1
(100% run-off). For landfill applications, the value of CR depends on landfill cover’s slope and soil
composition.
Figure 2 presents a hypothetic and quite simple landfill state where Α1 represents the part of landfill
that has no waste in place yet, and Α2 and Α3 represents the parts that are filled with MSW. The slope
of the bottom is towards A3. Each part has a different hydraulic behavior which is described as
follows:
Part Α1: Precipitation that falls on part A1 area flows directly onto the drainage layer of the (LCRS)
and ends up to the lowest point of the landfill where leachate is collected. In this part there is no
amount of precipitation that is drawn away to the perimeter drainage trench and run-off equals 0.
Evapotranspiration also equals 0 because the water is quickly infiltrated through the drainage layer
to the lowest point of the landfill.
Part Α2: Precipitation that falls on part A2 flows at A1 area and run-off have the same behavior with
Part A1. Evapotranspiration is normally calculated because precipitation falls in the cover of landfill
where the infiltration is slow.
Part Α3: Precipitation that falls on part A3 flows over the landfill cover to the perimeter drainage
trench T. Both run-off and evapotranspiration are normally calculated. In this case part A3 is further
461
Solid waste management
divided in two parts, one part where the cover has high slope and run-off co-efficient and one part
where the cover has low slope and run-off.
Figure 2: Hypothetic scenario of a landfill’s operating state
2.3 Recirculation
Recirculation is the process where leachate is returned into the landfill body in order to keep the
moisture of the MSW in a desired level to accelerate waste settlement, stabilize the waste mass and
also accelerate the start of methanogenesis and gas generation. If there are no flow meters in the
recirculation pumps of the WWTP a mass balance approach has to be used.
2.4 MSW moisture – field capacity
MSW moisture is one of the most important parameters of leachate generation. Moisture is related to
the organic fraction that is contained in MSW. The amount of water that compacted MSW can retain
is known as field capacity and depends on compaction due to overburden mass.
Field capacity can be estimated as percentage of the dry weight of the MSW in landfill from the
following equation (Tchobanoglous & Kreith, 2002):
FC = 0.6 – 0.55.W / (5.44 + W)
(3)
Where:
FC = field capacity of waste as fraction of dry weight (%)
W = the overburden weight at the mid height of the waste per surface unit (tn/m2)
The amount of water the can be retain in waste is:
WH = FC.Wdry
(4)
Where Wdry = dry waste weight (tn)
462
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.5 Leachate losses
There are two main processes in landfill that contribute to water losses: formation of landfill gas and
escape as water vapor.
Formation of landfill gas. Leachate is consumed during the anaerobic decomposition of the organic
constituents in MSW. The amount of water consumed by the decomposition reaction can be estimated
per cubic meter of gas produced and is in the range from 0,192 to 0,24 kgr H2O/m3.
Water vapor. Landfill gas usually is saturated in water vapor. The quantity of water vapor escaping
the landfill is determined by assuming the landfill gas is saturated with water vapor. The numerical
value for the mass of water vapor contained per cubic meter of landfill gas at 32,2°C is about 0,0352kg
H2O/m3 landfill gas.
Both leachate losses are calculated as fraction of the landfill gas produced. Landfill gas generation is
estimated using LandGEM software methodology. Methane generation rate is calculated considering
that the biodegradation process follows first order kinetics.
A M (tn) mass of MSW in landfill, produces landfill gas according to the equation:
QCH4 = k.L0.M.e-kt
(5)
Where:
QCH4 = methane generation rate per year (m3/yr)
k = methane generation rate co-efficient ( = 0,05yr-1)
L0 = potential methane generation per MSW mass (=170m3/tn)
t = time passed from the disposal of MSW (yr)
Landfill gas contains approximately 50% methane so it is easy to be calculated when methane
generation is known.
2.6 Water balance algorithm
The water balance method is applied in each landfill lift separately in order to calculate the leachate
generation. The step by step algorithm is described as follows:
Step 1. The infiltration rate is calculated from the landfill cover to the upper lift of wastes.
Step 2. Starting from the upper waste lift of landfill, the outflow is calculated with the following
equation:
Wbl = War + Wsl - Sw - Wg
(6)
where:
Wbl = outflow from the upper waster lift to lower (m3)
War = water entering from the upper of the lift (m3) = PERsw
Wsl = moisture of new waste disposed (m3)
Sw = water that can be retained in the waste due to field capacity (m3)
Wg = water losses due to gas formation
Step 3. Equation (5) is used to solve all lifts from upper to the bottom taking into account that:
Wbl,i-1 = War,i
(7)
Where i refers to the waste lift located bellow lift i-1.
Step 4. The leachate outflow from the last waste lift (Wbl,0), the lowest lift at the landfill is the leachate
generation rate of the landfill that can be collected through the leachate collection system to WTP.
463
Solid waste management
2.7 Software requirements and development
Since the RAACM owns and operates a large number of sites with a significant geographical
dispersion, there is a need for many users to enter a lot of data from many different locations, in order
to estimate leachate generation on site, for each site. Furthermore, large spreadsheets can be error
prone and difficult to manage and maintain.
Therefore, software was developed to work as a web-based application, allowing remote access. Its
goal is to serve as a management and decision support tool. All data is stored in a database which has
been built using MySQL. The water balance calculation has been developed in PHP, a widely-used
open source scripting language that is especially suited for web development and can be embedded
into HTML.
The front-end environment for entering data, results and diagram presentations, was developed with
Javascript, CSS and HTML.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Evaluation of assumptions
Many parameters or data that need to be input to the water balance can be difficult to measure or
estimate. Their influence on the results is evaluated below.
Separating the landfill in lifts. When MSW is disposed in a landfill, they are placed in lifts. To
calculate the water balance for each lift, many parameters need to be monitored (area, weight, MSW
disposals etc). A more simplified assumption that is widely used in landfill design is to consider the
landfill as a single rectangular mass (Figure 3).
Figures 3-4: Simplified shape of landfill - Shape of landfills with lifts
Rain distribution in each lift. When the rain is falling onto the landfill cover, each lift receives an
amount of rainwater that is related with its exposed area. Although this reflects reality better, it is
difficult to estimate the exposed area of each lift, especially when the landfill has many lifts and water
balance is applied monthly. In this case, a simplifying assumption is to consider that all the rain is
falling and infiltrated in the cover of the top most lift (Figure 4).
Figure 5-6: Rain falls only in the upper lift of landfill - Rain divided according to the exposed
area of each lift
464
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Conditions in the area where landfill’s cells are in contact. Large landfills are often designed with
multiple disposal sites (cells) to minimize the catchment area of the MSW disposal. When a cell is
filled with MSW to capacity, a new cell opens to receive waste. The lifts, as they develop vertically,
always lean to the old cell, so for some years they behave as one cell (Figure 5). In order to apply the
water balance, two different assumptions can be considered, none of which reflects reality 100%.
Assumption 1. The water balance is applied separately for each cell, considering that there is no
hydraulic connection between them. This assumption has two major problems: (a) the weight of one
basin’s lifts (e.g. TB3 in Figure 5) is not taken into account while the water balance is applied to the
other cell (e.g. TA3 in Figure 5) and (b) it is considered that leachate produced in cell A does not leak
into cell B.
Assumption 2. It is considered that there is no hydraulic separation between the cells and the new one
is an extension of the old one, e.g. lift TB1 is actually the extension of lift TA1 (Figure 5). The main
problem of that assumption is that when a new lift is placed, e.g. TB3, its area is increased and
according to equation (3) the field capacity of the waste in lift TA3 (+TB3) is raised, affecting the
leachate generation rate.
Figure 7: Typical landfill cross section with two waste disposal basins
3.2 Application results
The landfill at Mavrorachi is chosen to apply the water balance method and evaluate how the
assumptions affect the leachate generation. Mavrorachi landfill is located in municipality of Lagadas
and accepts the MSW from all the Prefecture of Thessaloniki, about 450.000 tn/yr. All available data
is used for the years 2008 (opening date) to 2017.
The evaluation criterion that is chosen is the cumulative leachate generation and the mean leachate
generation rate per year. The results of the evaluation for each of the assumptions is presenting below.
Separating landfill in lifts. Water balance was applied for the period 2008 – 2017. The mean leachate
generation rate when the landfill’s shape is simplified differs up to 22% (Table 1) from the scenario
where the landfill is divided in horizontal lifts. The cumulative leachate generation has large
differences in the beginning of operation but through the years it is stabilized around 3%. However,
when a new waste disposal cell started to operate (2015), it affects the difference and raised it to 510% (Figure 6). The peak of approximately 80% difference in cumulative leachate generation
happens because in the beginning of the operation of landfill the first lift was small (two month
disposal), so the overburden weight of the second lift causes a high reduction of waste field capacity.
465
Solid waste management
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Jun-08
Oct-09
Feb-11
Jul-12
Nov-13
Apr-15
Aug-16
Dec-17
Figure 6: Difference in cumulative leachate generation when landfill lifts is not taken into
account
Table 1: Comparison between dividing the landfill in lifts and not dividing
Mean leachate generation rate
(m3/d)
Year
Difference
(%)
Landfill with lifts
Landfill without
lifts
2008
173,1
179,4
3,64%
2009
288,1
295,5
2,57%
2010
298,9
299
0,03%
2011
202,6
198,4
2,07%
2012
222,2
245,6
10,53%
2013
281,7
240
14,80%
2014
250,2
250,3
0,04%
2015
374,3
324,7
13,25%
2016
347,3
372,2
7,17%
2017
253,5
309,3
22,01%
Rain distribution in each lift. Water balance applied for the period 2008 – 2013 because it was
difficult and time consuming to estimate and collect data for the area of exposed in rain from each
liftr of landfill. In this case the difference between simplified and analytic assumption where very
small. The mean leachate generation rate difference in all these years where <3% (Table 2) and the
cumulative leachate generation has a peak (6,72%) at the beginning of the operation of landfill but it
stabilizes through the years around 1% (Figure 7).
466
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
8.00%
7.00%
6.00%
5.00%
4.00%
3.00%
2.00%
1.00%
0.00%
Jun-08
Oct-09
Feb-11
Jul-12
Nov-13
Figure 7: Difference in cumulative leachate generation when the rain is not distributed in
each lift
Table 2: Comparison between simplified and analytical distribution of rain
Mean leachate generation rate
(m3/d)
Year
Difference
(%)
Simplified
distribution
Rain distribution
per lift
2008
101,24
100,72
0,51%
2009
268,12
264,19
1,49%
2010
269,88
276,94
2,55%
2011
198,10
195,28
1,45%
2012
231,62
238,65
2,95%
2013
265,35
262,98
0,90%
Conditions in the area where landfill’s cells are in contact. The time period when a new cell started
to operate at the landfill was in 2015. So, the comparison period was 2015-2017 and the year 2018
added not using real data, but estimated data. As is shown to Table 3, for years 2015 – 2017 the
difference between Assumption 1 and Assumption 2 in mean leachate generation rate is 3,55% 13,78%. Moreover in year 2018, when estimated data are used the difference is raised to 29,64%. It
is noteworthy that none of the assumptions reflects 100% reality.
Table 3: Comparison between simplified and analytical distribution of rain
Mean leachate generation rate
Difference
(%)
(m3/d)
Year
Assumption 1
Assumption 2
2015
352,8
374,3
5,74%
2016
359,6
347,3
3,55%
2017
288,4
253,5
13,78%
2018
317,0
244,55
29,64%
467
Solid waste management
4.
CONCLUSIONS
In this paper the water balance method is presented as it is applied for the development of a webbased application to be used for monitoring multiple sites. Furthermore, the most significant
assumptions’ evaluation is presented concerning their influence in leachate generation rate. The
results of the evaluation show that:
1. Simplifying the calculation of water balance and considering that landfill is a single rectangular
mass has significant difference in estimation of leachate generation rate. So it is suggested to
calculate water balance for each lift.
2. Distributing precipitation in each lift, proportional to the exposed area, only affects the leachate
generation by a small percentage, so the error is negligible (<3%).
3. Water balance is difficult to be calculated in the situation where two or more waste disposal cells
come in touch. There are two assumptions that can be made and each one has some disadvantages.
The leachate generation is calculated for both assumptions and its difference reaches 29,64%.
Field capacity of MSW is the most significant parameter of water balance model. As shown in Figure
8, when the new waste disposal cell started to operate (Feb 2015), the total field capacity of the landfill
is affected less and is more stable in assumption 1. So this is the assumption chosen for the software
developed. There is a need for further study in this direction.
Figure 8: Holding capacity of MSW in landfill for two different assumptions
References
1. Brunner, P. H. (2013). Cycles, spirals and linear flows. Waste Management and Research,
31(10 SUPPL.), 1–2.
2. Kral, U., & Brunner, P. H. (2014). The incorporation of the “final sink” concept into a metric for
sustainable resource management. Sustainable Environment and Resources, 24(6), 431–441.
3. Scharff, H., Hansen, J. B., & Thrane, J. (2014). Key Issue Paper The Role of Landfills in the
Transition toward. International Solid Waste Association.
4. Brennan, R. B., Healy, M. G., Morrison, L., Hynes, S., Norton, D., & Clifford, E. (2016).
Management of landfill leachate: The legacy of European Union Directives. Waste
Management, 55, 355–363.
468
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
5. EUROSTAT. (2018). Municipal waste generation and treatment, by treatment method.
Retrieved May 4, 2018, from http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/waste/municipal-wastegeneration-and-treatment-by-treatment-method
6. Christensen, T. H. (Ed.). (2010). Solid Waste Technology & Management. Chichester: John
Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
7. Scharff, H., Crest, M., Lanner, D., Greedy, D., Kallassy, M., & Milke, M. (2013). Landfill
Aftercare. International Solid Waste Association, 6.
8. Tchobanoglous, G., Theisen, H., & Vigil, S. (1993). Integrated solid waste management:
engineering principles and management issues.. McGraw-Hill.
9. Schroeder P.R., Dozier T.S, Zappi P.A., McEnroe B.M., Sjostrom J.W. and Peyton R.L. (1994)
‘Hydrologic Evaluation Of Landfill Performance (H.E.L.P.) Model – Engineering
Documentation for v.3’, Environmental Laboratory - U.S. Army Corps of Engineers - Waterways
Experiment Station.
10. Athiniotou A., Papaspyros I. and Komilis D. (2012) ‘Modeling Leachate Generation From An
Active Sanitary Landfill’, Proceedings of the 4th WSWMA International Conference.
11. Frikha, Y., Fellner, J., & Zairi, M. (2017). Leachate generation from landfill in a semi-arid
climate: A qualitative and quantitative study from Sousse, Tunisia. Waste Management and
Research, 35(9), 940–948. https://doi.org/10.1177/0734242X17715102
12. Tchobanoglous, G., & Kreith, F. (2002). Handbook of Solid Waste Management, 2nd edition,
McGraw Hill.
469
Solid waste management
470
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open
sea waters
471
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
472
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
SUSTAINABLE COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT OF
STRYMONIKOS GULF – IMPLEMENTATION OF THE D.P.S.
FRAMEWORK FOR COASTAL ACTIVITIES PRESSURES
ANALYSIS
E. Yiannakopoulou and E.K. Oikonomou*
Department of Transportation and Hydraulic Engineering, Faculty of Rural & Surveying
Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Hellas
*Corresponding author: e-mail: eoikonom@topo.auth.gr, tel: +30 2310 994360
Abstract
Sustainable management of coastal areas strives for the maximum long-term societal good, including
environmental, economic, social and cultural considerations. Coastal zones, as ecologically sensitive
areas, are considered as the main location of residential, economic, industrial and touristic
development, due to their natural characteristics and the high aesthetic value of their landscape.
However, they are vulnerable to pollution by large quantities of organic load, fertilizers and
pesticides, urban and industrial wastewater, which eventually end up in the sea, through the aquatic
recipients. The application of the D.P.S. (Driving Forces-Pressures-State) Framework, which is a
subsystem of the D.P.S.I.R. Framework (Driving Forces – Pressures – State – Impacts – Response),
is proposed to the coastal zone of Strymonikos Gulf. It focuses on the identification, assessment and
evaluation of potential impacts of coastal activities, such as tourism, industry, agriculture, fishery,
etc., by using the appropriate economic, environmental and social indicators, in the context of
sustainable coastal zone management. As a result, it is obvious that there is a growing need for the
application of such a framework in a coastal zone, which can be used to organize research that
increases understanding about interaction between environmental and societal processes, in order to
help understand and support as well, sustainable coastal zone management scenarios.
Keywords: D.P.S. framework, Evaluation, Coastal zone sustainable management, Strymonikos Gulf
1.
INTRODUCTION
From a human history perspective, the characteristics of coastal zones have made them preferential
sites for human occupation and, consequently, intense areas of development. A direct consequence
of human occupation of these coastal areas is that coastal zones rank among the environments most
affected by human presence and activities. The coastal area includes a wide range of economic
activities. The main uses, located on coastal areas, are: urban settlements, tourism and recreation
activities, industrial sites, fisheries, energy production industries, transportation infrastructure,
agricultural activities and forestry. The concentration of significant economic activities on the coastal
zone is responsible for: marine, freshwater and air pollution, degradation of sensitive marine and
terrestrial ecosystems, loss of land resources, loss of historic resources, as well as noise and
congestion. The fast expansion over the last decades of socio-economic activities on coastal and
estuarine areas made management tasks much more complex. In recent years, there has been a
growing concern to maintain a steady growth in economic activities and social development in
estuarine areas, while preserving their natural features and ecological service [1]. The area of study
is the coastal zone of Strymonikos Gulf, where human activities include mass tourism, house
473
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
construction, industries, fishing, aquaculture, agriculture and farming. These activities are not always
practiced wisely, leading to increasing environmental problems, such as pollution and landscape
deterioration. In this study, the application of the D.P.S. (Driving Forces-Pressures-State) framework
is proposed, which is a subsystem of the D.P.S.I.R. framework (Driving Forces – Pressures – States
– Impacts – Responses), to the coastal zone of Strymonikos Gulf. It focuses on the identification,
assessment and evaluation of potential impacts of coastal activities, by using the appropriate
economic, environmental and social indicators, in the context of sustainable coastal zone
management.
2.
SUSTAINABLE COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT
Coastal zones are recognized to be areas of high ecological and economic value. Coastal and marine
ecosystems provide a wide range of services to human beings. These include provisioning services
such as supply of food, fuel wood, energy resources and natural products; regulating services, such
as shoreline stabilization, flood prevention, storm protection, climate regulation, nutrient regulation,
detoxification of polluted waters, and waste disposal; cultural and amenity services such as culture,
tourism, and recreation; and supporting services such as habitat provision, nutrient cycling, primary
productivity, and soil formation. These services are of high value, not only to local communities
living in the coastal zone, but also to national economies and global trade as well [2]. As a majority
of human settlements and towns lie in or are close to the coastal zone, the intense demand on coastal
resources to support economic activities provokes adverse effects on the coastal ecosystems. It is
worth mentioning that more than half the world’s population today lives within 60 kilometers of the
shoreline. While it is easy to take a biased view and support either economic development or
ecological preservation, the challenge in sustainable development lies in fostering measured socioeconomic growth, which does not compromise the ecological integrity and value of the area [3].
The concept of sustainable development acknowledges the principle that economic well-being, social
justice and environmental objectives cannot be decoupled, but are inherently interdependent over the
long run. Sustainable management of coastal areas strives for the maximum long-term societal good,
including environmental, economic, social and cultural considerations. It strives to promote social
equity through the fairer distribution of opportunities both within the present population, and between
present and future generations. Within a sustainability framework, it is important, at a minimum, to
ensure that the process of tradeoffs is disciplined such that economic, environmental and social
objectives are all met at some “threshold level”, even in the short-run. Furthermore, since the coastal
resource is finite in physical and spatial terms, certain short-term decisions may permanently destroy
resources for the future. One of the goals of sustainable development must therefore be to ensure that
present decisions do not foreclose future options, what is often recognized as intergenerational equity
[4].
3.
THE P.S.R. AND D.P.S.I.R. FRAMEWORKS
The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) created the ‘‘Pressure–
State–Response’’ (P.S.R.) Model in 1993 to help model the cause and effect relationship between
human activities and the environment [5]. The P.S.R. model considers that: human activities exert
pressures on the environment and affect its quality and the quantity of natural resources (“state”);
society responds to these changes through environmental, general economic and sectoral policies,
and through changes in awareness and behavior (“societal response”). It highlights the cause-effect
relationships between economic activities, environmental and selected social conditions, and helps
decision-makers and the public to deal with environmental and economic issues as interconnected. It
thus provides a means of selecting and organizing indicators in a way, which is useful for decisionmakers and the public. The P.S.R. Model has the advantages of being one of the easiest frameworks
to understand and use; and of being neutral in the sense that it shows which linkages exist, and not
whether these have negative or positive impacts. This should however not obscure the view of more
474
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
complex relationships in environment-economy and environment-society interactions. Depending on
the purpose for which the P.S.R. Model is used, it can be easily adjusted to account for greater details
or for specific features. Examples of adjusted versions are the Driving force – State – Response
(D.S.R.) model used by the U.N.C.S.D. in its work on sustainable development indicators, the
framework used for O.E.C.D. sectoral indicators and the Driving force – Pressure – State – Impact –
Response (D.P.S.I.R.) Model used by the European Environment Agency [6].
Figure 1: The Pressure – State – Response (P.S.R.) Model presented in a diagram
The D.P.S.I.R. (Driving forces – Pressures – States – Impacts – Responses) framework usually
represents the systems analysis and the assessment of the relation between human activities and the
environment. According to this systems analysis view, social and economic development (D) exert
pressure on the environment (P) and, as a consequence, the state of the environment changes (S). This
leads to impacts on e.g. human health, ecosystems and materials (I) that may elicit a societal response
(R) that feeds back on the driving forces, on the pressures or on the state or impacts directly, through
adaptation or curative action by mitigation measures. Indicators for Driving Forces describe the
social, demographic and economic development in societies, and the corresponding changes in
lifestyles, overall levels of consumption and production patterns. Pressure indicators describe
developments in release of substances (emissions), physical and biological agents, the use of
resources and the use of land by human activities. The pressures exerted by society are transported
and transformed in a variety of natural processes to manifest themselves in changes in environmental
conditions. State indicators give a description of the quantity and quality of physical, biological and
chemical phenomena (such as atmospheric CO2 concentrations) in a certain area. Impact indicators
are used to describe changes in these conditions. It is the change in the availability of species that
influences human use of the environment. In the strict definition, impacts are only those parameters
that directly reflect changes in environmental use functions by humans. As humans are a part of the
environment, impacts also include health impacts. Response indicators refer to responses by groups
(and individuals) in society, as well as government attempts to prevent, compensate, ameliorate or
adapt to changes in the state of the environment Examples of response indicators are the relative
number of cars with catalytic converters and recycling rates of domestic waste [7]. The D.P.S.I.R.
framework has increasingly become accepted and applied to different case studies, in order to aid
problem solving that involves a range of coastal marine environments including estuaries, coastal
lagoons and coastal areas. In many cases this framework has been complemented with use of
475
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
numerical models, which have been increasingly becoming indispensable tools in management
decisions [1].
4.
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE D.P.S. FRAMEWORK IN STRYMONIKOS GULF
4.1 The area of study
The area of study involves the coastal zone of Strymonikos Gulf, which is a semi-enclosed coastal
water body in North Aegean Sea in Central Macedonia Region, Hellas, located in east of
Thessaloniki, 50 km away. It is defined by an imaginary line that connects the capes of Eleftheras
(Halkidiki) and St.Dimitriou (Kavala). The coastal zone is rich in natural resources, landscapes and
cultural features. More specifically, the most significant environmental parameters of the area include
Lake Volvi, Rentinas narrows, Strymonas and Rihios river estuary and Stratonikos mountain.
Figure 2: The area of study, the coastal zone of Strymonikos Gulf
Human activities in the area include mass tourism, house construction, industries, fishing,
aquaculture, agriculture, farming, etc. These activities are not always practiced wisely and in
harmony, leading to increasing environmental problems, such as pollution and landscape
deterioration, which is expected to become by far more serious in the next decades [8].
Sustainable development is based on a balance between the components of economic prosperity,
social justice and environmental conservation. Accordingly, the criteria that are chosen in the
proposed methodology for the evaluation of all coastal activities of the Strymonikos Gulf, are
economic, social and environmental. Then, those criteria are divided to sub-criteria, in order to reduce
the complexity of activities pressures analysis. Criteria and sub-criteria used in the case study are
presented in Table 1.
4.2
Implementation of the D.P.S. framework for Strymonikos Gulf activities pressures
analysis
An economic, social and environmental pressures analysis is held for better understanding of the
pressures of Strymonikos Gulf activities with the implementation of the D.P.S. (Driving forces –
Pressure – State) framework, which is a subsystem of the D.P.S.I.R. framework. According to the
framework, human activities are considered as Driving Forces. In the case study, the major economic
activities of the Strymonikos Gulf are examined and more specifically, tourism, agriculture, farming,
476
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
industry, fisheries and aquaculture. The economic, social and environmental pressures analysis results
are presented in Tables 2, 3 and 4.
Table 1: Proposed criteria and sub-criteria of Strymonikos Gulf activities pressures analysis
Criteria
Economic
Social
Environmental
Economic growth Reduction of
Surface- Underground water
Land use
unemployment
quantity
Implementation
Social acceptance
Surface- Underground water quality
cost
Quality of life – Health
Land quality
Protection of cultural
Erosion
Subheritage
Air quality
criteria
Noise pollution
Ecosystems –Biodiversity
Climate change
Natural resources consumption
Environmental quality
Table 2: Implementation of the D.P.S. framework for economic pressures
DRIVING FORCES
PRESSURE
STATE
Tourism
Services and settlements production
Agriculture
Agricultural products
Farming
Farming products
Industry
Industry products
Economic growth
Manufacturing units
Product production
Fisheries
Fisheries products
Aquaculture
Aquaculture products
Tourism
Industry
Land demanding
Land use
Agriculture
Tourism
Accommodation and infrastructure
Implementation cost
Industry
Facilities
Table 3: Implementation of the D.P.S. framework for social pressures
DRIVING FORCES PRESSURE
STATE
Tourism
Industry
Agriculture
Reduction of
Farming
Jobs
unemployment
Manufacturing units
Fisheries
Aquaculture
Seasonal population increase, noise, pollution
Tourism
of the environment, Jobs
Social acceptance
Industry
Pollution of the environment, Jobs
Solid wastes - domestic wastes, working
Tourism
conditions, coastal landscape quality
Quality of life – Health
Agriculture
Solid wastes, working conditions, air pollution
Industrial wastes, noise, working conditions,
Industry
coastal landscape quality, air pollution
Protection of cultural
Tourism
Uncontrollable development
heritage
477
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
Table 4: Implementation of the D.P.S. framework for environmental pressures
DRIVING FORCES PRESSURE
STATE
Agriculture
Water consumption, irrigations
Tourism
Surface- Underground
water quantity
Farming
Water consumption
Industry
Manufacturing units
Tourism
Tourism facilities sewage
Pesticides, fertilizers and nutrients discharges,
Agriculture
use of insecticides
Liquid waste disposal, nitrogen and phosphorus Surface- Underground
Farming
discharges
water quality
Industrial waste disposal, industrial emissions (eutrophication,
Industry
of nitrogen and phosphorus
salinization)
Manufacturing units
Wastewater, gas emissions
Fisheries
Oil from intensive fishery
Aquaculture
Wastewater
Tourism
Solid wastes, απορρίμματα
Agriculture
Agricultural waste, nutrient runoff through rain
Land quality
Industry
Industry waste
Manufacturing units
Solid wastes
Tourism
Facilities (hotels, restaurants)
Farming
Overgrazing
Erosion
Agriculture
intensive agricultural uses
Industry
Industrial facilities
Agriculture
Agricultural emissions (use of chemicals)
Tourism
Polluting gas emission
Polluting gas emissions (CO2, NOx, SO2), Air quality
Industry
emissions of particulate matter - dust
Engine exhaust gas (Polluting gas emission
Transport
CO2, NOx, VOCs)
Tourism
Entertainment and recreation centers
Industry
Industrial noise from factories
Noise pollution
Transport
Great number of vehicles
Losses of agricultural nutrients-use of
Agriculture
fertilizers, pesticides, air pollution
Building- service facilities for the tourists,
Tourism
Ecosystems
–
population growth, tourism activities
Biodiversity
Industry
Building -waste disposal, air pollution
Fisheries
Intensive fishery
Aquaculture
Wastewater
Industry
Greenhouse gas emissions
Climate change
Transport
478
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
DRIVING FORCES
Farming
Tourism
Industry
Agriculture
Tourism
Industry
Agriculture
PRESSURE
STATE
Overexploitation of water
Increased use of power, water and raw materials Natural
resources
consumption
Overexploitation of water
Unregulated building (hotels, restaurants,
refreshment rooms)-increased use of natural
recourses-household waste, urban wastewater
Environmental quality
Building-solid waste
Alternating agricultural landscapes
4.3 Discussion
From the analysis presented in Tables 2, 3 and 4, it is possible to evaluate the economic, social and
environmental pressures of the Strymonikos Gulf activities, in order to be used for the comparison of
any future proposed coastal zone management plans.
Consequently, tourism development will introduce the new services and settlements (hotels,
recreation settlements, commercial activities), which will attract tourists and will help with the
economic growth of the area. The development of primary and secondary sector of production will
increase the production of the corresponding products and therefore, the economic growth of
Strymonikos Gulf. On the other hand, the development of agriculture and industry increases land
demand, which leads to land-use conflicts. Both tourism accommodations with the necessary
infrastructure, and industrial facilities lead to the increase of the implementation cost.
The development of Strymonikos Gulf economic activities leads to jobs creation and consequently,
to the reduction of unemployment. However, tourism and industrial development, except for job
creation, put pressure on the natural environment, which makes it difficult for people to approve any
management plans of the area of study and accept severe environmental impacts. Also, the
development of tourism, agricultural and industrial activities leads to pressures to the environment
due to solid wastes, air emissions and noise, which cause the degradation of the quality of life and
health of the people leaving in the coastal zone of Strymonikos Gulf. At the end, uncontrollable
development of tourism may provoke impacts on their cultural heritage and archaeological sites.
According to Table 4, in agriculture and more specifically, in irrigation over-pumping of both surface
and ground water and therefore, reduction of the water quantity may be a serious problem. Also,
development of tourism, agriculture, industry and farming may increase greatly water demand. The
development of agriculture influences the quality of both surface and ground water, through
eutrophication (water acidification) and salinization. Whereas, farming influences the quality of water
directly with wastewater disposal and indirectly, with nitrogen and phosphorus discharges into the
coastal zone. The development of industry and manufacturing, also, influences water quality of
Strymonikos Gulf, though waste disposal around industrial facilities and gas emissions (nitrogen and
phosphorus). Tourism facilities, mostly from sewage, lead to water pollution and degradation of
coastal water quality. Also, the coastal waters are polluted from intensive fisheries, due to oil residues
dumping and from aquaculture, because of the wastewater, which is rich in nutrients.
Land quality is influenced by the solid waste disposal from industrial facilities and manufacturing
units and by the agricultural waste and nitrates emissions, which run off to the soil through rain.
Tourism development has a negative influence to land quality, because of possible uncontrolled waste
disposal from tourists and solid waste from hotels and restaurants. Except from land quality, industrial
facilities and infrastructures raise the possibility of erosion. Also, because of the construction of
facilities for the tourists (hotels, restaurants, recreation, organized beaches), there is great possibility
of coastal erosion. Furthermore, the intensive agricultural uses rise the sensitivity of coastal land to
erosion.
479
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
Agriculture and more specifically, the use of chemicals (air sprays) cause atmosphere pollution. Also,
chemical substances emissions from combustion, which takes place at industry facilities, as well as
emissions of particulate matter and dust coming from industrial activities, constitute of important
pressures that configure the state of the air quality. Tourism development pollutes the atmosphere as
much from the tourists’ facilities gas emissions as from the increase of traffic.
Tourism, also, can cause noise pollution because of the density of settlements, the entertainment and
recreation centers and the great number of vehicles. Noise pollution is also caused by the industrial
noise from factories.
Agricultural uses, because of the losses of agricultural nutrients play a very important role to the
condition of biodiversity. Also, the overuse of pesticides and fertilizers in agriculture constitutes a
threat to the biodiversity. A major threat to biodiversity and ecosystems is the development of
tourism, because of service facilities for the tourists (hotels, restaurants, night clubs), seasonal
population growth and tourism activities. Many changes in the state of biodiversity come from
industrial development, due to industrial facilities construction, sewage and air pollution.
Furthermore, intensive fisheries and aquaculture influence biodiversity as they reduce marine life.
Tourism and industrial development as well as the increase of transport leads to release to the
atmosphere of great amounts of CO2 (the most important greenhouse gas) as a result of the burning
of fossil fuel such as carbon, oil and natural gas, and as a consequence to climate change. The second
more important greenhouse gas is methane, which is produced mostly through farming, which also
contributes to the climate change. The development of tourism and agriculture change the amount of
natural recourses because of the overexploitation of water. The amount of natural resources is also
changed by the increased use of power, water and raw materials from industrial facilities. The
environmental quality is negatively influenced both from the development of tourism through
facilities unregulated building (hotels, restaurants, refreshment rooms), household waste (plastic
boxes, glass bottles, etc.) and increased use of natural recourses, and from the development of industry
because of land clearing for factories construction and solid waste disposal. Agriculture, on the other
hand has a positive influence to the quality of environment, because of alternating agricultural
landscapes.
5.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Sustainable coastal zone management is a broad, multi-purpose effort, aimed at improving the quality
of life of the communities dependent on estuarine resources and helping local decision makers to
achieve sustainable development of estuarine areas, from the headwaters of coastal watersheds to the
outer marine areas. As such, sustainable coastal zone management approaches are required, in order
to combine all aspects of the human, physical and biological aspects of the coastal zone within a
single management framework. It is imperative to address the ecological and socio-economic links
in the management of dynamic systems, such as estuaries and coastal areas. As a result, it is obvious
that there is a growing need for the application of such a framework in coastal zones, which can be
used to organize research that increases understanding about interaction between environmental and
societal processes, and help understand and support as well sustainable coastal zone management
scenarios. In many cases the DPSIR framework has been used as a base for coastal zone
environmental management allowing the linkage between environmental and economic models,
making it possible to integrate the conservation functions (biodiversity and ecological) with socioeconomic development [9]. Examples could be: EEA (1999) [10], Elliott (2002) [11], Picollo et al.
(2003) [12], Cave et al. (2003) [13], among others. In this study, it is obvious the need for the
application of the D.P.S. framework in coastal zones, in order to promote sustainable development
taking into account environmental, social and economic factors. The D.P.S. framework could be
easily applied to other catchment/coastal zone systems, which have experienced human interventions
during past decades. This would help in the identification and assessment of socio-economic drivers,
pressures, economic, social and environmental state, in the long term, thus providing a holistic and
480
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
comprehensive approach on issues, pertaining to environmental protection and the sustainable
management of natural resources. Moreover, the ability to apply future scenarios enlarges the use of
D.P.S. to a robust and reliable management tool. Natural scientists, stakeholders, and policy makers
would all benefit from such integrated coastal activities pressures analysis.
References
1. Campuzano F., M. Mateus, Paulo Leitão, Pedro Leitão, V. Marín , L. Delgado, A. Tironi, J.
Pierini, A. Sampaio, P. Almeida, R. Neves. (2011). ‘Integrated coastal zone management in South
America: A look at three contrasting systems.’. Ocean & Coastal Management, Elsevier Ltd.
2. UNEP. (2006). ‘Marine and coastal ecosystems and human wellbeing: A synthesis report
based on the findings of the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment’, UNEP, pp.76.
3. Varghese K., Ganeshb L., Manic M., Anilkumara P., Murthyd R. & B. Subramaniamd. (2008).
‘Identifying critical variables for coastal profiling in ICZM planning - A systems approach.’.
Ocean & Coastal Management, vol.51, 2008, pp.73–94, Elsevier Science Ltd.
4. European Commission. (1999). ‘Towards a European Integrated Coastal Zone Management
(ICZM) Strategy: General Principles and Policy Options.’, A reflection paper, DirectoratesGeneral Environment, Nuclear Safety and Civil Protection, Fisheries & Regional Policies and
Cohesion.
5. Bowen R. & C. Riley. (2003). Socio-economic indicators and integrated coastal management.
Ocean & Coastal Management, vol.46, 2003, pp.299-312, Elsevier Science Ltd.
6. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development. (2000). ‘Towards Sustainable
Development: Indicators to measure progress.’. Proc. of the OECD Rome Conference.
7. European Environment Agency. (2003). ‘Environmental Indicators: Typology and Use in
Reporting.’, Peder Gabrielsen and Peter Bosch, EEA, Technical report No 25, August 2003.
8. Koutrakis E., Lazaridou T. and M. D. Argyropoulou. (2003). ‘Promoting integrated management
in the Strymonikos coastal zone (Greece): a step-by-step process.’. Coastal Management, vol.
31, pp. 195–200.
9. Caeiro S., Mourão I., Costa M., Painho M., Ramos T. and S. Sousa. (2004). ‘Application of the
DPSIR model to the Sado Estuary in a GIS context – Social and Economical Pressures.’ In
Seventh AGILE Conference on Geographic Information Science 29 April-1May 2004,
Heraklion, Greece Parallel Session 4.3- “Environmental / Social Modelling”.
10. EEA. (1999b). ‘State and Pressures of the Marine and Coastal Mediterranean
Environment.’ Environmental Assessment Series. European Environment Agency, Copenhagen,
Denmark.
11. Elliott M. (2002). ‘The role of the DPSIR approach and conceptual models in marine
environmental management: an example for offshore wind power.’. Marine Pollution Bulletin
vol. 44, pp. 3-7.
12. Picollo A., Albertelli G., Bava, S. and S. Cappo. (2003). ‘The Role of Geographic Information
Systems (GIS) and of DPSIR Model in Ligurian Coastal Zone Management.’ Proceedings of 5th
International Symposium on GIS and Computer Cartography for Coastal Zone
Management. GISIG/ICOOPS, Genoa, Italy, pp. 1 – 5.
13. Cave R.R., Ledoux L., Turner K., Jickells T., Andrews J.E. and H. Davies. (2003). ‘The Humber
catchment and its coastal area: from UK to European perspectives.’. Science of The Total
Environment, vol. 314–316, pp. 31–52.
481
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE MULTICRITERIA METHOD AHP
FOR THE EVALUATION OF STRYMONIKOS GULF
MANAGEMENT SCENARIOS WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF
INTEGRATED COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT
E. Yiannakopoulou and E.K. Oikonomou*
Department of Transportation and Hydraulic Engineering, Faculty of Rural & Surveying
Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Hellas
*Corresponding author: e-mail: eoikonom@topo.auth.gr, tel: +30 2310 994360
Abstract
Integrated Coastal Zone Management contributes towards maximizing the environmental, economic
and social benefits provided by coastal zones, while minimizing all potential negative impacts of
activities upon each other. Coastal areas are of particular interest as they usually include a wide
variety of habitats and ecosystems, as well as many important human/economic activities. Human
coastal population increases continually and consequently, there is much stress from all settlements
and economic activities to coastal zones. A proposed methodological approach for management plans
evaluation, in the context of Integrated Coastal Zone Management, is described. Therefore,
alternative management scenarios for the examined area of the coastal zone of Strymonikos Gulf, are
presented. The selection of the prevailing alternative proposal is made through the process of multicriteria analysis. More specifically, the method of Analytical Hierarchical Process is applied, so that
the suggested alternative solutions are estimated and classified by using economic, ecological and
social criteria, in order to contribute positively to Coastal Zone Integrated Management towards
sustainability.
Keywords: Multicriteria analysis, AHP, Integrated Coastal Zone Management, Management plans
evaluation
1.
INTRODUCTION
Coastal ecosystems are one of the most productive natural systems in the world [1]. They provide a
wide range of services to human beings: “provisioning services”, such as food supply, fuel wood and
energy resources; “regulating services”, such as shoreline stabilization, flood prevention, storm
protection, hydrological services and nutrient regulation; “cultural and amenity services”, such as
culture, tourism and recreation; and finally, “supporting services”, such as habitat provision, nutrient
cycling, primary productivity [2]. These services are of high ecological, social and economic value,
not only to local communities living in the coastal zones, but also to national economies and global
trade. Several threats on coastal systems are discussed in the scientific literature. The most important
and crucial are industrialization and urbanization, sea-level-rise, increase of carbon dioxide and
greenhouse gases, deposition of agricultural substances, fisheries and aquaculture development, etc.
As a consequence, approximately 70% of the European coastal ecosystems are highly threatened, in
relation to their biological productivity [3].
Integrated sustainable planning for coastal areas (including land-use, resources and pollution control
management) is needed in order to resolve competition and conflict that occur frequently among
residential, tourist, commercial, industrial, transportation, recreational and agricultural activities,
482
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
competing usually within limited space. Certain sectoral-oriented land-uses might coexist in a
multiple land-use approach, while others might not or would have to be severely restricted from
coastal areas. Integrated Coastal Zone Management's role is to sort out the appropriate land-use
patterns and recommend the optimal mix, while meeting effectively environmental, economic and
social criteria. A number of methods have been, for that reason, researched, tested and applied, in
order to support decision makers. One of them is Analytical Hierarchical Process (AHP), which was
selected by the authors, to resolve the problem of sustainable development of the coastal zone of
Strymonikos Gulf, in the context of Integrated Coastal Zone Management.
Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM) is also known under a variety of different names, such
as Integrated Coastal Area Management (ICAM), Integrated Coastal Management (ICM) and
Integrated Marine and Coastal Area Management (IMCAM). Although there are many different
definitions of ICZM, the actual differences amongst them are minor. Most definitions recognize that
ICZM is a dynamic, continuous and iterative process, designed to promote sustainable management
of coastal zones. Most definitions also taken into consideration that the goals of ICZM have to be
achieved within the constraints of physical, social, economic, and environmental conditions, as well
as within the constraints of legal, financial and administrative systems and institutions [4].
It is also important to underline that in Greece, with a total shoreline of 16,500 km, respectively the
25% of the European shoreline, there are no specific instruments or methodologies for ICZM
Programs, while the Special Framework for Spatial Planning & Sustainable Development of coastal
areas and islands has never been enacted: after consultations had taken place, the project was
withdrawn. Oikonomou and Kalkopoulou (2009) commented on the fact that only General Local
Plans in Greece (planning projects at municipal level) contribute to ICZM. However, it is concluded
that: the majority of these General Local Plans have been excluded from Strategic Environmental
Assessment, mostly due to bureaucratic reasons (GLPs were introduced for the first time in 1997,
while the Ministerial Decision 107017/2006 about Strategic Environmental Assessment was enacted
almost 10 years later); by examining four GLPs in coastal areas all over Hellas, it was concluded that
they do not show any special concern about coastal areas and marine space, but they define land-use
patterns, as well as future infrastructure projects needed to support future economic activities, without
any environmental appraisal [5].
2.
INTEGRATED COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT
2.1 The necessity for ICZM
Almost all coastal and marine areas produce or support multiple products and services. Sectoral
solutions usually “transfer” the problem between resources, products and services. Tourism will not
flourish if the area loses its attraction to visitors; fisheries are usually on the receiving end of everyone
else’s problems. Industry and energy facilities may degrade the environment for all other activities.
There is, therefore, a need to bring sectoral activities together, in order to achieve a commonly
acceptable coastal management framework. ICZM attempts to avoid this, by broad multiple-sector
planning and integrated project development, by future-oriented resource analysis and by applying
the test of sustainability to each development initiative.
Coastal zone management is also a critical issue in many countries with a high intensity of marine
and coastal resource use. Managing complex systems, such as coastal areas, requires an integrated
approach, capable of coordinating the implementation of all three major objectives/components of
sustainable development (environmental, social and economic) and bringing together the multiple,
interwoven, overlapping interests in the coastal area in a coordinated and rational manner, harnessing
coastal resources for optimum social and economic benefit, for present and future generations as well,
without prejudicing the resource base itself, while maintaining the security of ecological processes.
483
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
2.2 Designing an Integrated Coastal Zone Management program
Every country, evaluating the potential of an ICZM-type program, will have its own special approach
to conservation of resources and will be facing its own distinct array of coastal issues. The particular
form of any ICZM program will depend upon the national and regional issues it is meant to address.
No two countries would be expected to have identical programs. While each country's program will
be unique, there are several basic stages in the generation of an ICZM program that will be found to
be common to all, in one form or another. These stages are presented briefly as follows:
Stage A – Policy Formulation. Creation of a policy framework to establish goals, and to authorize
and guide the ICZM program, accomplished by executive and legislative action.
Stage B – Strategy Planning. Sometimes called Preliminary Planning, this is the stage at which
the potential impacts of the ICZM policy action are explored, while expected benefits are
evaluated, a wide array of data is accumulated and organized, a general strategy is created and
recommendations are made for organization and administration of the ICZM program.
Stage C – Program Development. Once the Strategy Plan is accepted by policy makers,
development of the ICZM program can commence and a detailed Master Plan for its
implementation may be proposed.
Stage D – Implementation. Once the Master Plan is approved and budget and staff are authorized,
the Implementation Stage may commence.
In practice, the above stages are not so discrete and linear as theory suggests. Instead, there will be
feedback and revisions of earlier stages, as new facts and opportunities come to light in later stages.
For example, there will certainly be the need for policy revision and strengthening, as a result of
findings and recommendations from Stages B and C. Therefore, the whole program must be flexible
and adaptable [6].
3.
THE ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS
The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is one of the most popular Multicriteria Decision Making
(MCDM) tools for formulating and analyzing decisions. The technique is employed for ranking a set
of alternatives or for the selection of the best in a set of alternatives. The ranking/selection is done
with respect to an overall goal, which is broken down into a set of criteria [7]. The AHP enables the
decision maker to structure a complex problem in the form of a simple hierarchy and to evaluate a
large number of quantitative and qualitative factors in a systematic manner, under conflicting multiple
criteria [8]. AHP can deal with qualitative and quantitative factors of the decision-making process,
and it is practical, systematic and terse. It determines the relative importance, or weight, of the
alternatives in terms of each criterion involved in a given decision-making problem [9]. Application
of AHP to a decision problem involves four steps: a) structuring of the decision problem into a
hierarchical model; b) making pair-wise comparisons and obtaining the judgmental matrix; c)
obtaining the local priorities and consistency of comparisons; and d) aggregation of weights across
various levels to obtain the final weights of alternatives. The first two steps involve the decision
maker’s opinion, whereas the last two are strictly computational.
The first step includes decomposition of the decision problem into elements, according to their
common characteristics, and the formation of a hierarchical model, having different levels [10]. Each
level in the hierarchy corresponds to the common characteristic of the elements in that level. The
topmost level corresponds to the ‘focus’ of the problem. The intermediate levels correspond to criteria
and sub-criteria, while the lowest level contains the ‘decision alternatives’ (Figure 1).
In the second step, the elements of a particular level are compared pair-wise, with respect to a specific
element in the immediate upper level. A judgmental matrix is formed and used for computing the
priorities of the corresponding elements. First, criteria are compared pair-wise with respect to the goal
already set. A judgmental matrix, denoted as “A”, will be formed using the comparisons. Each entry
484
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
“aij” of the judgmental matrix is formed comparing the row element “Ai” with the column element
“Aj”. Saaty (2000) suggests the use of a 9-point scale to transform the verbal judgements into
numerical quantities, representing the values of aij.
In the third step, once the judgmental matrix of comparisons of criteria with respect to the goal is
available, the local priorities of criteria are obtained and the consistency of the judgements is
determined.
At last, in fourth step, the local priorities of elements of different levels are aggregated, in order to
obtain final priorities of the alternative scenarios.
Figure 1: Hierarchic structure of a decision problem
Table 1: The fundamental scale used in AHP
Intensity of
importance
Description
1
Equal importance
Elements Ai and Aj are equally important
3
Weak importance of Ai over Aj
Experience and Judgement slightly favour Ai
over Aj
5
Essential or strong importance
Experience and Judgement strongly favour Ai
over Aj
7
Demonstrated importance
Ai is very strongly favored over Aj
9
Absolute importance
The evidence favoring Ai over Aj is of the
highest possible order of affirmation
Intermediate
When compromise is needed
2, 4, 6 , 8
4.
Definition
IMPLEMENTATION OF AHP IN THE COASTAL ZONE OF STRYMONIKOS GULF
4.1 The area of study
The area of study includes the coastal zone of Strymonikos Gulf, which is a semi-enclosed coastal
water body in the North Aegean Sea in Central Macedonia Region, Hellas, located in east of
Thessaloniki, 50 km away. It is defined by an imaginary line that connects capes of Eleftheras
(Halkidiki) and St.Dimitriou (Kavala). The coastline is 75 km long and communicates with North
Aegean through an opening in its east side. Strymonikos Gulf belongs expands geographically to four
Regional Departments: Kavala, Serres, Thessaloniki, and Halkidiki. The Kavala Regional
485
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
Department is part of the East Macedonia & Thrace Region, while the other three Regional
Departments are part of the Region of Central Macedonia, Hellas.
The coastal zone of Strymonikos Gulf is rich in natural resources, landscapes and cultural elements.
More specifically, the most significant environmental parameters of the area include Lake Volvi,
Rentinas narrows (also known as the Valley of Macedonian Tembi), Strymonas and Rihios river
estuary and Stratonikos mountain. For the purposes of this paper, the boundaries of the coastal zone
of Strymonikos Gulf were defined, as shown in Figure 2, taking into account the morphology ant
topography of the area, land-uses and the nearby watersheds. So, the area of study includes the sea
area of Strymonikos Gulf and the land area of the coastal zone, which was defined based on the water
bodies, the significant coastal ecosystems (Lake Volvi, Rentinas narrows, Strymonas river estuary
and Stratonikos mountain, etc.) and in few cases the administrative boundaries (boundaries of the
municipalities). In Figure 2, different colors represent different proposed land-use patters from
General Local Plans, with the dark green representing forest areas, light green agricultural land, in
blue color some industrial sites and in magenta color some touristic zones.
Figure 2: The area of study, the coastal zone of Strymonikos Gulf
4.2 Structuring of the decision problem into a hierarchical model
At this point, the decision problem is structured, according to the formation of the Analytical
Hierarchical Process (ΑΗΡ). So, at first, the decision problem is analyzed into a hierarchical model.
At the topmost level, the Focus of Goal is set, which in the case study refers to sustainable
development of the coastal zone of the Strymonikos Gulf. The lowest level contains the alternative
scenarios. It is obvious that we cannot compare the alternative scenarios to such a general and
strategic goal. Therefore, the goal is analyzed into sub-goals (criteria), which are then analyzed based
on the hierarchical model, in a way that can be used efficiently for the comparison of alternative
scenarios. Sustainable development is based on the balance between the components of economic
prosperity, social justice and environmental conservation. Accordingly, the criteria that are chosen,
for the evaluation of the alternative scenarios, are economic, social and environmental. Then, those
486
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
criteria were divided to sub-criteria, in order to reduce the complexity of the problem dealt with. At
last, the alternative development scenarios were defined for the area of study, which represent the
lowest level of hierarchy. Three alternative scenarios were introduced, which are hypothetical and
they are based on proposed by General Local Plans land-use patterns for each municipality.
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT OF THE COASTAL
ZONE OF THE STRYMONIKOS GULF
SOCIAL
ECONOMIC
Reduce of unemployment
Economic growth
Social acceptance
Land use
Quality of life - Health
Implementation cost
Protection of cultural heritage
ENVIRONMENTAL
Surface-Underground
Water
quantity
Surface-Underground
Water
quality
Land quality
Erosion
Air quality
Noise pollution
Ecosystems -Biodiversity
Climate change
Natural resources consumption
Environmental quality
SCENARIO 1
Emphasis on the development
of tourism, trade, primary and
secondary sector of production
SCENARIO 2
SCENARIO 3
Emphasis
on
the
Combination of the two other
development
of
scenarios
alternative forms of
tourism and in organic
production in agriculture
Figure 3: Hierarchical analysis of the decision problem
In the first proposed scenario, major parameters are: the development and growth of the primary
sector of production in agricultural areas, with agricultural and farming settlements, houses for
farmers and infrastructure networks; in forest areas the promotion of forest exploitation facilities and
beekeeping is proposed; for the development of the secondary sector of production, the creation of
industrial areas is proposed in three areas, north of the road to Vrasna, west of Olympiada and parallel
to the Nea Madytos-Varvara road; in non-forest areas small industries related to the local forest,
agricultural production and livestock farming, beekeeping, the production of local goods and also
showrooms and selling places for the above products are proposed; the development of tourism and
leisure activities is proposed in coastal areas and more specifically, in Asprovalta, Ofrynio beach and
Karianni with the development of hotels up to 150 beds, tourism settlements, organized camping and
shopping centers are proposed. Special tourism settlements (conference centers, athletic tourism
centers, etc.) and swimming service settlements in Ofrynio beach and a tourism port in Asprovalta
are also proposed. At the end, in protected areas light infrastructure settlements, such as guardhouses,
scientific equipment, wooden sits, observatories, etc. are proposed. The use of ecosystems as fisheries
and the function and maintenance of the current fish-capture settlements in Rihios River are also
proposed. At the end, small units of aquaculture, agricultural products, sustainable farming units, as
well as camping and outdoor sport grounds near Nea Apollonia and near Rentina are proposed.
487
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
In the second scenario, alternative forms of tourism are proposed in the municipality of Arethousa.
In forest areas not-permanent settlements (wooden kiosks, pathways, observatories, etc.) for the
development of exploring and archeological tourism are proposed. In non-forest areas agrotourism
settlements up to 80 beds, other tourism settlements and eating and leisure spaces are proposed. An
archeological route with a watercraft in Strymonas River, begging from the estuary and the seaport
to the Amfipolis archeological site is also designed. In the primary sector, alternative forms of
production in agricultural areas, such as biological production, are proposed. The integrated
management of wastes and the biological production of honey are also proposed. In protected areas
the same proposals with those of the first scenario are generally proposed, in addition to the lake
Volvi biological aquiculture, biological aquiculture and biological holdings in small units at Rihios
River and at forest areas beekeeping and production of biological honey.
The third scenario combines the proposals of the other two scenarios. So, it suggests a light
development of primary and secondary sector of production, whereas it focuses on the integrated
development of tourism and promoting alternative tourism in highlands. Therefore, it respects the
environment and the sensitive ecosystems of the area of study.
4.3 Making pair-wise comparisons
Once the decision problem is analyzed into a hierarchical model, as shown in Figure 3, the pair-wise
comparisons and the formation of the judgmental matrices should be made. So, at first, the criteria
are evaluated with respect to the goal, next the sub-criteria with respect to the criteria and at the end,
the alternative scenarios with respect to the sub-criteria, according to how much more important is
one element to another. The evaluation is based on the fundamental scale of values of Saaty, as shown
below:
Ρ = {1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 1/2, 1/3, 1/4, 1/5, 1/6, 1/7, 1/8, 1/9}
(1)
where: 1 = equal importance, 3 = moderate importance, 5 = strong importance, 7 = very strong
importance, 9 = extreme importance – 2, 4, 6, 8 = intermediate values. The reciprocals of the above
judgments represent the reverse preferences of the decision maker.
4.3.1 Comparison of criteria (and sub-criteria) with respect to the goal
Primarily, the criteria are compared pair-wise, with respect to the upper goal, which in the case study
is sustainable development of the coastal zone of the Strymonikos Gulf. It is assumed that the
participation of criteria in the achievement of the upper goal is the same, so they were evaluated with
number 1. Then, in the next level of hierarchy, sub-criteria are compared pair-wise, with respect to
criteria, which are social, economic and environmental, the three aspects of sustainable development.
The evaluation is made using the following question: “Of the two sub-criteria (row and column),
which is more important with respect to the criterion set?”.
4.3.2 Comparison of alternative scenarios with respect to criteria
Next, in the lowest level of hierarchy, alternative scenarios are compared pair-wise, with respect to
the sub-criteria in the immediate upper level. The evaluation is made using the following question:
“Of the two alternative scenarios (row and column), which is more important with respect to the subcriterion?”. The answer to the question in the case study is based on the opinion of the researcher.
However, in a ‘real’ case study, ICZM Program, many researchers and generally, stakeholders may
answer such question, supporting many and maybe different opinions and evaluations. In the
following tables representative examples of judgmental matrices of scenarios with respect to some
sub-criteria are shown:
488
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 2: Judgmental matrix of scenarios with respect to sub-criterion “Social acceptance”
SOCIAL ACCEPTANCE Scenario 1
Scenario 2
Scenario 3
Scenario 1
1
1
1/4
Scenario 2
1
1
1/4
Scenario 3
4
4
1
Table 3: Judgmental matrix of scenarios with respect to sub-criterion “Economic growth”
ECONOMIC GROWTH Scenario 1
Scenario 2
Scenario 3
Scenario 1
1
4
2
Scenario 2
1/4
1
1/4
Scenario 3
1/2
4
1
Table 4: Judgmental matrix of scenarios with respect to sub-criterion “Water quantity”
WATER QUANTITY
Scenario 1
Scenario 2
Scenario 3
Scenario 1
1
1/3
1/2
Scenario 2
3
1
2
Scenario 3
2
1/2
1
4.4 Discussion
The final results of the comparison of alternative scenarios are obtained with the application of the
two last steps of the Analytical Hierarchy Process method, which are strictly computational. The last
two steps were calculated with a program that was made in a programming language called “Visual
C# (sharp)”. The purpose of the program is to reduce the large number of calculations that are needed
for the estimation of the final results, which increase as the number of criteria and alternative
scenarios increases and the whole process becomes an exhausting, for the decision maker, process. It
is also useful in forming an ICZM Program, because throughout the process, more parameters, new
assumptions, other proposals may be described. More specifically, through the program, at first the
priorities of the alternative scenarios with respect to criteria, as shown in Figure 4, were calculated.
and then, the final priorities of the alternative scenarios, as shown in Figure 5.
SCENARIO 1
SCENARIO 2
SCENARIO 3
SOCIAL
ECONOMIC
ENVIRONMENTAL
Figure 4: Priorities of alternative scenarios with respect to criteria
As shown in Figure 4, the first scenario is better than the other two with respect to economic criteria,
the second scenario is better with respect to environmental criteria and the third one is better with
respect to social criteria. The third scenario, which combines development and protection and
489
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
restoration of the environment, is better than the other two, with respect to social criteria. The first
scenario, which focuses on the development and growth of all three sectors of production, is better
than the other two, with respect to economic criteria, then, the third scenario, that proposes a more
‘light’ development, follows, whereas the second scenario, that provides alternative forms of tourism,
comes last. As it is also expected, the second scenario is much better than the other two with respect
to environmental criteria.
Finally, in Figure 5 the classification of the alternative scenarios is presented, as they came up from
the software used, in the following order of preference, and their final results. The most applicable
alternative scenario is the third one, which is a combination of the other two scenarios, with ‘light’
development of tourism and industry and promotion of the primary economic sector with emphasis
on organic production. Then the second scenario comes, which emphasizes on the development of
alternative forms of tourism and on organic production in agriculture, and the last one is the first
scenario, which emphasizes greatly on economic development and growth of the area of study.
FINAL RESULTS
0.4
0.2
0.291
0.349
0.36
Scenario 2
Scenario 3
0
Scenario 1
Figure 5: Final Results: Priorities of alternative scenarios with respect to the Goal
5.
CONCLUSIONS
The problem of the evaluation and the selection of an alternative scenario, which adjusts sufficiently
to the data and input parameters of each area of study, is a crucial matter, as well as the parameters
that must be taken into consideration for sustainable development, which are many and
multidimensional. In the case study presented, the use of AHP for the selection, between three, of the
best management scenario in Strymonikos Gulf, was examined, in order to be objective, even though
the evaluations are subjective. A research with questionnaire surveys in the area of study may be
conducted, in order to determine the weight that local people and stakeholders attribute to the three
dimensions of sustainable development, as it is not a fact that they have the same weight, as assumed
in the case study and the model used.
In the case study the choice of the best alternative was investigated, from three alternative scenarios.
Analytical Hierarchy Process may be also used for the ranking of the alternatives from the best one
to the worst one, or even for the sorting of alternatives in pre-defined categories. This possibility is
very important in practice. When a number of scientists cooperate for the solution of a coastal zone
management problem, the alternative scenarios that will come up are many. This large number of
data can be processed with Analytical Hierarchy Method, in order to have a ranking of alternatives,
according to several criteria.
To summarize, it is concluded that the method presented, with its simplicity and its explicitness, and
also with the many possibilities that offers to the user, is a valuable tool for a “good” decision making
process and can be used efficiently for the purposes of Integrated Coastal Zone Management.
490
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
References
1. European Environment Agency. (2006). ‘The changing faces of Europe's coastal areas’, EEA
report No 6/2006, Copenhagen.
2. United Nations Environmental Program. (2006). ‘Marine and coastal ecosystems and human
wellbeing: A synthesis report based on the findings of the Millennium Ecosystem
Assessment’, UNEP.
3. EUCC – The Coastal Union. (2006). Integrated coastal management – do we really have a
choice?. Coastline Special on Integrated Coastal Management, vol. 15, no 2006-1/2.
4. Nandelstädt T. (2008). ‘Guiding the coast - Development of guidelines for ICZM in
Germany’, IKZM-Oder Berichte 44, Technical University Berlin, Germany, March 2008.
5. Oikonomou E.K. and K. Kalkopoulou. (2009). ‘The contribution of General Local Plans in
Coastal Zone Management’. Proc of Conf. Integrated Water Resources Management under
Climate Change Conditions, eds. A. Liakopoulos, V. Kanakoudis, E. Anastasiadou-Partheniou
and V. Tsihritzis. Volos, Hellas (in Hellenic).
6. Clark J.R. (1996). ‘Coastal Zone Management Handbook’ Lewis Publishers, pp. 694.
7. Ramanathan R. (2006). Data envelopment analysis for weight derivation and aggregation in the
AHP. Computers & Operations Research, vol.33, pp. 1289–1307, Elsevier Ltd.
8. Kubde R.A. and S.V. Bansod. (2012). ‘The Analytic Hierarchy Process Based Supplier Selection
Approach for Collaborative Planning Forecasting and Replenishment Systems.’. International
Journal of Engineering Research & Technology, vol. 1 (7), pp. 1-11.
9. Hongmei L., Fuijan N., Dong Q. and Y. Zhu. (2017). ‘Application of analytic hierarchy process
in network level pavement maintenance decision-making.’. International Journal of Pavement
Research and Technology, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijprt.2017.09.015.
10. Gunasekaran A., Jabbour C. & A. Jabbour. (2014). ‘Managing organizations for sustainable
development in Emerging countries: an introduction.’. International Journal of Sustainable
Development & World Ecology, vol. 21 (3), pp. 195-197.
491
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
MODELLING THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON
COASTAL FLOODING WITH THE USE OF A 2DH
BOUSSINESQ MODEL
A.G. Samaras* and Th. V. Karambas
Department of Civil Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124, Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: asamaras@civil.auth.gr
Abstract
In the present work, an advanced numerical model based on the solution of the higher-order
Boussinesq-type equations for breaking and non-breaking waves is applied in order to simulate the
impact of climate change on coastal flooding. The model is tested against two-dimensional (crossshore) experimental data by Roeber at al. (2010), and is afterwards applied to the area of the Bay of
Thessaloniki (northwestern Aegean Sea, Greece) for representative scenarios of climate changeinduced wave and storm surge events. Results highlight the model’s capabilities and set the basis for
a comprehensive evaluation of the use of advanced modelling tools for the design of coastal protection
and adaptation measures against future climatic pressures.
Keywords: climate change, coastal flooding, numerical model, Boussinesq equations, wave
modelling
1.
INTRODUCTION
Climate change is expected to have significant effects on the intensity and frequency of occurrence
of extreme weather events, consequently affecting sea levels, circulation patterns, currents and waves
in oceans and seas around the world (Mentaschi et al., 2017; Vousdoukas et al., 2017). Moving from
the open sea to the densely populated coastal zones, more frequent storm surges and higher waves
will be experienced through a number of impacts such as beach/dune erosion and inundation of lowlying areas, leading to increased flooding risks and dictating the need for effectively designed coastal
protection and adaptation measures (Wong et al., 2014). Numerical models are indispensable tools
for the above purpose, as they allow the quantification of the above risk through the analysis of
simulations for multiple scenarios of combinations of projected climatic pressures.
In the following, the impact of climate change on coastal flooding is modelled with the use of an
advanced numerical model based on the solution of the higher-order Boussinesq-type equations. The
theoretical background and structure of the model is presented in detail in Section 2; the model
capabilities are validated through comparison with the experimental data by Roeber et al. (2010) in
Section 3; model applications for the area of the Bay of Thessaloniki (northwestern Aegean Sea,
Greece) are presented and discussed in Section 4, while Section 5 presents the conclusions drawn
from this work.
2.
COASTAL FLOODING MODELLING
Coastal flooding is modelled in this work using, in sequence, a storm surge model and an advanced
nearshore wave propagation model. The first model estimates storm surge levels due to wind effects;
492
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
these are used as offshore boundary conditions for the second model, which estimates wave runup on
beaches.
2.1 The storm surge model
The storm surge model is based on the depth-averaged wind-induced circulation equations, following
Koutitas (1988):
ζ Uh Vh
0
t
x
y
(1)
sx bx
U
U
U
ζ 1 U 1 U
U
V
g
νh h
fV
νh h
t
x
y
x hx
x h y
y
h h
sy by
V
V
V
ζ 1 V 1 V
U
V
g
νh h
fU
νh h
t
x
y
y hx
x hy
y
h h
(2)
(3)
where ζ is the water surface elevation above the mean water level, d is the still water depth, h is the
total water depth (h = d + ζ); U, V are the depth-averaged velocity components along the x- and ydirections respectively, g is the gravitational acceleration, νh is the horizontal eddy viscosity
coefficient, f is the Coriolis coefficient and ρ is the water density The terms τsx, τsy are the shear stress
components at the water surface along the x- and y- directions respectively, which represent the
vertical boundary condition, expressed as:
τ sx =ρkWx Wx2 Wy2
(4)
sy kWy Wx2 Wy2
(5)
where k is the surface friction coefficient (in kg/m3, typically of the order of 10-6; here we assume
k = 10-6 3∙10-6), and Wx, Wy are the wind speed components along the x- and y- directions (in m/s)
respectively. The bed friction terms (τbx, τby) are also expressed by quadratic forms, following
Karambas and Karathanassi (2004).
The horizontal eddy viscosity coefficient is expressed by the well-known Smagorinsky model, used
for the representation of the damping by eddies smaller than the computational grid size, as:
1/2
2
2
2
V 1 U V
2 U
h
x y 2 y x
where
(6)
is the mixing length, approximated as equal to half the grid cell size Δx (Madsen et al., 1988).
Differential Equations 1, 2 and 3, are approximated by finite difference equations according to the
explicit scheme developed by Koutitas (1988). Land in the model is represented as a total reflection
boundary, where U = 0, V = 0 and ζ/n = 0, n being the unit vector normal to the boundary.
2.2 The advanced nearshore wave propagation model
Over the years, the classical Boussinesq equations have been extended so as to be able to include
higher order nonlinear terms, which can describe better the propagation of highly nonlinear waves in
the shoaling zone. The linear dispersion characteristics of the equations have been improved as well,
in order to describe nonlinear wave propagation from deeper waters (Zou, 1999).
493
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
Based on the aforementioned velocity profile, the following higher order Boussinesq-type equations
for breaking and nonbreaking waves can be derived (Zou, 1999; Karambas and Koutitas, 2002;
Karambas and Karathanassi, 2004):
ζ t hU 0
(1)
1
1
1
1
1
Ut M u U(Uh) g G h dUt h 2 Ut d 2 Ut g
h
h
2
6
30
τ
1
d 2 Ut gd 2 d ( U)t - b E
30
h
(2)
where Mu is defined as:
M u d uo2 c 2 uo2
(3)
and G as:
1
1
2
1
G d 2 U U 2 U 2 U U ζ dUt
3
10
2
(4)
In Equations. 1 to 4 the subscript “t” denotes differentiation with respect to time, d = still water depth,
U = horizontal velocity vector U = (U,V) with U and V being the depth-averaged horizontal velocities
along the x- and y- directions respectively, ζ = surface elevation, h = total depth (h = d + ζ), g =
gravitational acceleration, τb = (τbx , τby) = bottom friction term (shear stress components
approximated by the use of the quadratic law according to Ribberink, 1998), δ = roller thickness
(determined geometrically according to Schäffer et al., 1993), E = eddy viscosity term (according to
Chen et al, 1999), and uo = bottom velocity vector uo = (uo, vo) with uo and vo being the instantaneous
bottom velocities along the x- and y- directions respectively.
The Boussinesq-type equations with the improved nonlinearity and linear dispersion characteristics
in deeper water, are accurate to the third order O(ε2,εσ2,σ4) (Zou, 1999); the nonlinearity and
dispersion parameters are defined as ε = Α/d and σ = d/L0 respectively, where A = characteristic wave
amplitude and L0 = characteristic wave length.
The numerical solution of the Boussinesq-type equations is based on the accurate higher-order
numerical scheme of Wei and Kirby (1995), with the respective scheme consisting of the third-order
in time explicit Adams–Bashford predictor step and fourth-order in time implicit Adams–Bashford
corrector step (Press et al., 1992; Wei and Kirby, 1995).
Finally, regarding coastal flooding, the process is simulated using the “dry bed” boundary condition
which, according to Militello et al (2004), can be written as the following set of pairs of conditions
for any given grin point (i,j):
if (d+ζ)i,j > hcr and (d+ζ)i-1,j ≤ hcr and
if (d+ζ)i,j > hcr and (d+ζ)i,j-1 ≤ hcr and Vi,j > 0 → Vi,j = 0
Ui,j
if
(d+ζ)i,j
≤
hcr
and
(d+ζ)i-1,j
if (d+ζ)i,j ≤ hcr and (d+ζ)i,j-1 ≤ hcr → Vi,j = 0
≤
hcr
if (d+ζ)i,j ≤ hcr and (d+ζ)i-1,j > hcr
if (d+ζ)i,j ≤ hcr and (d+ζ)i,j-1 > hcr and Vi,j < 0 → Vi,j = 0
and
Ui,j
494
>
0
→
<
→
Ui,j
Ui,j
0
→
=
=
Ui,j
0
0
=
0
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
where ζ is the mean water surface elevation and hcr is a terminal depth below which drying is assumed
to occur (here this depth is set to hcr = 0.001 m).
3.
MODEL VALIDATION
The capability of the presented model in the representation of coastal flooding was validated through
the comparison with the two-dimensional (cross-shore) experimental data by Roeber at al. (2010),
who tested wave transformation over idealized fringing reefs, carrying out a series of experiments in
two flumes at the O.H. Hinsdale Wave Research Laboratory of Oregon State University.
Figure 1: Surface profiles of solitary wave transformation over a dry reef flat with A/d = 0.5
and a 1:5 slope. Solid lines denote the results of the presented model and circles denote the
measurements of Roeber et al. (2010)
495
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
Figure 2: Surface profiles of solitary wave transformation over an exposed reef crest with A/d
= 0.3 and a 1:12 slope. Solid lines denote the results of the presented model and circles denote
the measurements of Roeber et al. (2010)
The experimental setup in the first – 48.8 m long, 2.16 m wide and 2.1 m high – flume, included a
steep 1:5 slope starting at x = 17.0 m, followed by a reef flat up to the flume’s rigid wall at
x = 45.0 m (x being the direction along the flume). The test in this flume regarded a steep solitary
wave of A = 0.5 m and a water depth of d = 1.0 m, resulting in A/d = 0.5 and an initially dry reef flat.
Figure 1 shows the comparison between measurements and model results for this test, as a series of
snapshots of surface profile evolution. Measured and computed data are in very good agreement at
all transformation stages. The model successfully captures the wave’s skewness as it propagates
496
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
across the toe of the slope, the formation of its steep front over the steep slope, and its eventual flow
transition from sub- to super-critical as it surges over the reef flat.
The experimental setup in the second – 104.0 m long, 3.66 m wide and 4.57 m high – flume, included
a fore reef slope of 1:12 starting at x = 25.9 m, a 0.2 m reef crest and a reef flat behind it up to the
flume’s rigid wall at x = 83.7 m (x being the direction along the flume). The test in this flume regarded
a steep solitary wave of A = 0.75 m and a water depth of d = 2.5 m (A/d = 0.3), initially exposing the
aforementioned reef crest by 0.06 m and submerging the reef flat with 0.14 m of water. Figure 2
shows the comparison between measurements and model results for this test, as a series of snapshots
of surface profile evolution. Again, as for the first test, measured and computed data are in very good
agreement at all transformation stages. The model successfully captures wave shoaling over the
relatively gently slope, wave breaking on top of the reef crest, as well as the propagation of the wave
bore (clearly identified by the bore front) over the reef flat.
4.
MODEL APPLICATIONS
The presented model was applied to the area of the Bay of Thessaloniki, i.e. the northern part of
Thermaikos Gulf, located in northwestern Aegean Sea, Greece. Figure 3 shows the geographic
location and a satellite image of the study area.
The model domain was bounded to the south by the virtual East-West line connecting the Mikro
Emvolo Cape to the western coast of the Bay (see Figures 4 and 5). The intermittently dry/wet area
at the western part of the Bay (green dotted area in Figures 4 and 5) was modelled as a dry flat for the
scenarios run in this work; this is justified by the consideration that the specific area – even when wet
at highest tide – is covered by no more than a few centimetres of water. The domain also included the
projected final geometry of the 6th pier of the Port of Thessaloniki (grey crossed area in Figures 4
and 5), while it should also be noted that the artificial coast of the Bay of Thessaloniki (Port of
Thessaloniki and waterfront eastwards of the Port up to the Mikro Emvolo Cape) was modelled as a
solid boundary (i.e. no flooding allowed).
Figure 3: Geographic location and satellite image of the study area (Google Earth, 2018;
privately processed)
The model was run for a/two representative scenarios of climate change- induced wave and storm
surge events. The first scenario (henceforth denoted by S1) regarded a southern wave of significant
497
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
wave height Hs = 1.58 m and peak period Tp = 4.60 sec. The second scenario (henceforth denoted by
S2) regarded the same wave combined with a storm surge of height SSH = 0.50 m.
Figure 4 shows model results for scenario S1, indicating the flooded area at the western coast of the
Bay of Thessaloniki; Figure 5 shows the respective results for scenario S2. The model performed
satisfactorily in both cases, resulting in smooth flooding contours that follow the modelled
topography. For scenario S1 the flooded area mainly covers parts of the aforementioned dry flat
(flooded area approximately equal to 2.5 km2), while for scenario S2 the flooding covers most of the
dry flat and extends to the low-lying coastal areas of the Bay as well (flooded area approximately
equal to 6.3 km2).
5.
CONCLUSIONS
Knowledge of the flooding extent is critical in relevant studies, as it allows the direct quantitative
assessment of the impact of climate change on coastal areas, using the projected flooded area as the
basis for the evaluation of the respective damage and adaptation costs (Hinkel et al., 2014). The use
of advanced numerical models in the above context has certain advantages over estimates of the
flooded area from simple superelevations of the water surface or from the spatial extension of crosssectional run-up results, as such models are able to simulate the inundation over complex natural
and/or artificial topographies, resulting in more accurate, case-specific results, suitable for detailed
coastal flooding risk assessment and mitigation.
Following this rationale, this work presents a coastal flooding model consisting of a storm surge
model and an advanced nearshore wave propagation model based on the solution of the
Figure 4: Model results indicating the flooded area for scenario S1
498
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 5: Model results indicating the flooded area for scenario S2
higher-order Boussinesq-type equations for breaking and non-breaking waves. The model was
validated through the comparison with two-dimensional experimental data of wave transformation
over idealized fringing reefs (Roeber et al., 2010), and was afterwards applied in order to simulate
the effect of two representative scenarios of climate change- induced wave and storm surge events on
coastal flooding for the area of the Bay of Thessaloniki, in Greece. The presented model performed
well overall, highlighting its capabilities and setting the basis for a comprehensive evaluation of
similar models’ use in the above context.
References
1. Chen Q., R.A. Dalrymple, J.T. Kirby, A.B. Kennedy and M.C. Haller (1999) ‘Boussinesq
modeling of a rip current system’, Journal of Geophysical Research: Oceans, Vol 104(C9), pp.
20617-20637.
2. Google Earth (2018) Image ©2018 TerraMetrics, Data SIO, NOAA, U.S. Navy, NGA, GEBCO.
3. Hinkel J., D. Lincke, A.T. Vafeidis, M. Perrette, R.J. Nicholls, R.S.J. Tol, B. Marzeion, X.
Fettweis, C. Ionescu and A. Levermann (2014) ‘Coastal flood damage and adaptation costs under
21st century sea-level rise’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United
States of America, Vol 111(9), pp. 3292-3297.
4. Karambas T.V. and E.K. Karathanassi (2004) ‘Longshore sediment transport by nonlinear waves
and currents’, Journal of Waterway, Port, Coastal and Ocean Engineering, Vol 130(6), pp.
277-286.
5. Karambas T.V. and C. Koutitas (2002) ‘Surf and swash zone morphology evolution induced by
nonlinear waves’, Journal of Waterway, Port, Coastal and Ocean Engineering, Vol 128(3),
pp. 102-113.
6. Koutitas C.G. (1988), ‘Mathematical models in coastal engineering’, Pentech Press: London.
499
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
7. Mentaschi L., M.I. Vousdoukas, E. Voukouvalas, A. Dosio and L. Feyen (2017) ‘Global changes
of extreme coastal wave energy fluxes triggered by intensified teleconnection patterns’,
Geophysical Research Letters, Vol 44(5), pp. 2416-2426.
8. Militello A., C.W. Reed, A.K. Zundel and N.C. Kraus (2004), ‘Two-Dimensional DepthAveraged circulation model M2D: version 2.0, Report 1, Technical Documentation and
User's Guide’, Report ERDC/CHL TR-04-2, US Army Corps of Engineers, Engineering
Research and Development Center: Washington, DC, USA.
9. Press H.W., S.A. Teukolsky, W.T. Vetterling and B.P. Flannery (1992), ‘Numerical Recipes in
Fortran 77’, Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK.
10. Ribberink J.S. (1998) ‘Bed-load transport for steady flows and unsteady oscillatory flows’,
Coastal Engineering, Vol 34(1–2), pp. 59-82.
11. Roeber V., K.F. Cheung and M.H. Kobayashi (2010) ‘Shock-capturing Boussinesq-type model
for nearshore wave processes’, Coastal Engineering, Vol 57(4), pp. 407-423.
12. Schäffer H.A., P.A. Madsen and R. Deigaard (1993) ‘A Boussinesq model for waves breaking in
shallow water’, Coastal Engineering, Vol 20(3–4), pp. 185-202.
13. THALIS - CCSEWACS ‘Estimating the effects of climate change on sea level and wave climate
of the Greek seas, coastal vulnerability and safety of coastal and marine structures’, http://thalisccseawavs.web.auth.gr/en/ (accessed February 1st, 2018).
14. Vousdoukas M.I., L. Mentaschi, E. Voukouvalas, M. Verlaan and L. Feyen (2017) ‘Extreme sea
levels on the rise along Europe's coasts’, Earth's Future, Vol 5(3), pp. 304-323.
15. Wei G. and J. Kirby (1995) ‘Time-Dependent Numerical Code for Extended Boussinesq
Equations’, Journal of Waterway, Port, Coastal, and Ocean Engineering, Vol 121(5), pp. 251261.
16. Wong P.P., I.J. Losada, J.-P. Gattuso, J. Hinkel, A. Khattabi, K.L. McInnes, Y. Saito and A.
Sallenger. (2014), ‘Coastal systems and low-lying areas’, Climate Change 2014: Impacts,
Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Part A: Global and Sectoral Aspects. Contribution of
Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change, eds. C.B. Field et al., Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK and New
York, NY, USA.
17. Zou Z.L. (1999) ‘Higher order Boussinesq equations’, Ocean Engineering, Vol 26(8), pp. 767792.
500
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
ON THE INTEGRATED MODELLING OF WATERSHED-COAST
SYSTEMS: CONSIDERATIONS FOR MORPHOLOGICAL
MODELLING UNDER A CHANGING CLIMATE
A.G. Samaras*, Th.V. Karambas and C.G. Koutitas
Department of Civil Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124, Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: asamaras@civil.auth.gr
Abstract
The term Watershed-Coast Systems (WACS), coined by Samaras and Koutitas (2014a), refers to the
entities consisting of watersheds of rivers/natural streams and the areas adjacent to their outlets where
sediment delivery from the upstream is critical for the balance of the coastal sediment budget, thus
playing a key role in long-term evolution of coastal morphology. In the present work, a concise critical
review of the existing knowledge on the integrated modelling of WACS’ morphodynamics is
presented, along with considerations regarding the introduction of the impact of climate change in
the above context. This work systemises the theoretical background of this emerging scientific field
and highlights the major challenges ahead, setting the basis for a comprehensive evaluation of the
methodological approaches used in relevant research with a clear focus on their applicability.
Keywords: Watershed-coast systems, integrated approaches, morphological modelling, climate
change
1.
INTRODUCTION
Climate change is an issue of major concern nowadays. Its impact on the natural and human
environment is studied intensively, as the expected shift in climate will be significant in the next few
decades (IPCC, 2013). Located at the land-sea interface, coastal areas are subject to a wide range of
natural- and human- induced pressures. Inhabited by almost two thirds of the world’s population, it
goes without saying that the impact of climate change will extend from morphological implications
(i.e. erosion, flooding) to significant socio-economic ones, threatening not only settlements and
infrastructure, but human life as well. Moreover, the connection of coastal areas to upstream
watersheds through water and sediment transport in estuaries extends the spatial scale of climate
change effects in watersheds to coastal areas as well.
The term Watershed-Coast Systems (WACS), coined by Samaras and Koutitas (2014a), refers to the
entities consisting of watersheds of rivers/natural streams and the areas adjacent to their outlets where
sediment delivery from the upstream is critical for the balance of the coastal sediment budget, thus
playing a key role in long-term evolution of coastal morphology. Given the fact that the connection
of these two fields is self-evident, it is deduced that climate change will not only impact coasts through
affecting sea levels, currents and waves but also through its effects in watersheds (Li and Fang, 2016)
that will “travel” downstream contributing to a series of coastal processes, from the disturbance of
the stability of estuaries to wide-scale morphodynamic changes.
The objective of this work is to provide with a concise overview of the theoretical background of
coastal evolution modelling, leading through a critical review of its strengths and weaknesses to a
comprehensive evaluation of: (a) the advances and gaps in the modelling of WACS; (b) the
introduction of climate change in the above context; and (c) the major challenges ahead in this
501
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
emerging scientific field. Fundamental concepts of coastal evolution understanding and modelling
are presented in Section 2; advances in the integrated modelling of WACS are presented in Section
3, including considerations for such modelling attempts under a changing climate; Section 4 presents
the major challenges ahead towards the effective implementation of relevant methodological
frameworks for watershed/coastal management and engineering purposes, while Section 5
summarises the conclusions drawn from this work.
2.
COASTAL EVOLUTION: CONCEPTS AND MODELLING
The evolution of coastal morphology has been studied extensively over the years, starting from purely
theoretical concepts for the systemisation of empirical knowledge and observational understanding,
up to entire methodological frameworks for the implementation of modelling tools of varying types
and complexity in order to simulate natural and human induced geomorphic processes at different
scales in space and time.
The above are intermittently organized and presented in various review papers. However, not many
of them are truly insightful, ending up being repetitive and overcomplicated due to: (a) the tendency
to amass references rather than classify and highlight the most important of them, and (b) lack of
focus of their review thesis. The above do not help in resolving a series of ambiguities on issues
ranging from the terminology used for relevant geomorphic systems and processes, to the
applicability of the proposed methodologies in order to effectively address “real-world” problems in
watershed/coastal management and engineering.
This work aspires to set a new paradigm in relevant research, limiting the amount of excessive
references and setting its focus on the dynamics of Watershed-Coast Systems (see Section 3).
Furthermore, being the first step towards an extended critical review by the authors, in its present
form it is intentionally self-constrained to the presentation and brief analysis of only a few works that
– in the authors’ view – stand out in literature.
2.1 The coastal tract concept
Building essentially on the fundamental “coastal sediment budget” concept, Cowell et al. (2003a), in
a landmark work, devised and presented three related concepts: (a) the coastal tract; (b) the coastaltract cascade; and (c) coastal-tract templating (see Figure 1). The coastal tract was defined by the
authors as “a spatially contiguous set of morphological units representative of a sediment-sharing
coastal cell”. Its composite nature implies that its actual form can vary geographically and, therefore,
any individual coastal tract has meaning only in the context of analysing a specific problem, for a
specific site, on an associated time-scale. The coastal-tract cascade was introduced as the means in
order to separate low-order coastal change from morphodynamics on smaller space and time scales,
with contiguous morphological units being associated with intermediate morphodynamic scales in
the cascade hierarchy in the way presented in Figure 2b. Finally, coastal-tract templating was
introduced as a protocol for the design of numerical modelling experiments (definition of boundary
conditions and extent of coastal cell, data transformation, etc.), which would also be able to clarify
significant processes for each such experiment.
Regardless of its limitation with respect to the study of WACS that are briefly analysed in Section 3,
it is true that the coastal tract concept as a whole set the precedent for a series of studies on
502
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: (a) Physical morphology encompassed by the coastal tract; (b) coastal-tract cascade;
(c) nested systems of the coastal-tract cascade (figures adopted from Cowell et al., 2003a).
coastal evolution modelling, and “traces” of its constituent concepts can be identified in most of the
studies that succeeded it.
2.2 The CSDMS approach
The Community Surface Dynamics Modeling System (CSDMS; Peckham et al., 2013) proposes a
component-based approach to integrated modelling, aiming to simulate the full range of Earth-surface
processes on time scales ranging from individual events to millions of years. This NSF-funded
international and community-driven effort essentially works towards founding a new paradigm in the
modelling of earth-surface dynamics, adopting a component-based software development framework
and creating a suite of modular open-source numerical models that can be used to perform coupled
simulations at various scales of interest in space and time.
Using CSDMS one could, ideally, simulate the entire water cycle and its effect on landscape
evolution, by coupling climate, atmospheric, hydrological, terrestrial, ocean and coastal models, with
the potential to represent all involved processes. However, it is even intuitively deduced that such a
complicated task also involves a large number of problems and uncertainties. These range from mere
computational issues (computational time, input/output models’ interface, data formats’
compatibility, etc.) to issues regarding the essence of attempting to couple models that come from
different scientific disciplines, that are built to operate at different scales and that focus on different
aspects of the natural world (see discussion in French et al., 2016). The limitations of the
implementation of this approach regarding the subject of this work are briefly analysed in Section 3.
2.3 The iCOASST Project
The NERC-funded project iCOASST (integrating COASstal Sediment sysTems) focused on the
simulation of decadal coastal morphodynamics, in order to achieve a breakthrough in the prediction
of coastal behaviour under conditions of change. A number of conceptual and applied works that
resulted from this project stand out in literature. However, special reference should be made to:
503
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
Figure 2: The modelling approach of CoastalME (adopted from Payo et al., 2016)
French et al. (2016), who provide with a thorough and insightful assessment of the appropriate
complexity for the prediction of mesoscale coastal and estuarine behaviour; van Maanen et al. (2016),
who presented a new framework for decadal coastal management, integrating a series of
complimentary modelling approaches ranging from reduced complexity models to qualitative
conceptual models; and Payo et al. (2017), who presented Coastal Modelling Environment version
1.0 (CoastalME), a framework for integrating landform-specific component models and applied it, as
a proof-of-concept, for representative geomorphic systems.
The modelling approach of CoastalME is based on dynamically linking line and raster objects in order
to simulate coastal evolution, and is schematically represented in Figure 2. The middle panel shows
how a real-world geometry (top panel) is conceptualized as three distinct types of elements, namely:
shorelines, shore-face profiles and estuaries. All three fundamental elements can share sediment
among them, while the shore face (bottom panel) comprises both consolidated and non-consolidated
material, the former adding to the drift material depending on sea level and wave energy constraints.
Eventually, the large-scale coastal behaviour models integrated in CoastalME predict morphology
evolution as the combined change in the aforementioned constituent elements.
3.
ON THE INTEGRATED MODELLING OF WACS AND CLIMATE CHANGE
IMPACT
3.1 The physical problem in question and the limitations to its study
Coastal morphology evolves as the combined result of both natural- and human- induced factors that
cover a wide range of spatial and temporal scales of effect. Areas in the vicinity of river and natural
stream mouths are of particular interest, as the direct connection with the upstream watershed extends
the search for drivers of morphological evolution from the coastal area to the inland as well, especially
504
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
considering that the terrestrial field contributes approx. 90% of the sediment entering the global ocean
(Syvitski et al., 2003).
However, despite the fact that the connection of the terrestrial field and the coastal field – as well as
their behaviour as a spatiotemporal entity – is self-evident, literature lacks of references that study
their dynamics concurrently and under the perception of an integrated morphodynamic system. The
impact of watershed management (dams, regulation works, land use changes, etc.) on coastal
dynamics has been studied to some extent, but this was mostly done either qualitatively, or
identifying/surveying the impact without modelling the dynamics, or using data at the watershed
outlet without them being subject to evaluation and further examination (e.g. Luan et al., 2016). The
introduction of the impact of climate change imposes an additional challenge to be met, as climate
pressures have to be added to the aforementioned system, affecting not only the dynamics in the
watershed and the coast, but their interaction as well.
Samaras and Koutitas (2014) coined the term Watershed-Coast Systems (WACS), in order to describe
the entities consisting of watersheds of rivers/natural streams and the areas adjacent to their outlets
where sediment delivery from the upstream is critical for the balance of the coastal sediment budget.
In this context, the physical problem in question under our changing climate can be divided into four
basic components: (A) climate change; (B) watershed dynamics; (C) coastal dynamics; and (D)
integration of the WACS (Figure 3). Components (B) and (C) have been extensively studied over the
years; the last few decades so are (A) and, to a lesser extent, the impact of (A) on (B) and of (A) on
(C). The most important component, though, the integration of the watershed-coast system (D) –
which independently of (A) defines the essence of the WACS concept – has not been analysed to the
extent one would expect to considering its importance for coastal evolution modelling.
The works presented in Section 2, as already mentioned, stand out in literature. Nevertheless, they do
all present specific limitations regarding the integrated modelling of WACS. The two most essential
limitations are briefly presented in the following; it is noted that, in the context of this work, they
should be examined along with the issues listed in Section 4.
The first and most important limitation in many relevant approaches is the not-integrated study of the
terrestrial and coastal fields as an entity; this applies to the coastal tract and iCOASST project
Figure 3: The physical problem in question (SWFWMD, 2014; privately processed).
approaches in the previous. Limiting the study of coastal morphology evolution at the outer (or at
most the inner) estuary, i.e. using flow rate and sediment discharge as inputs from other individual
studies, limits the capability of better understanding the dynamics of the system as it hinders the
understanding of its evolution up to now, and therefore of its projected future behaviour. Given that,
505
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
historically, natural- and human- induced factors have combined to not only shape the Earth’s surface
but also affect and/or dictate changes in watersheds (e.g. from changes in cultivation practices, to
technical interventions and up to population movements), it is counter-intuitive to leave watershed
dynamics out of the study of coastal morphodynamics. As an example regarding the modelling of
WACS under future climate scenarios, one should think about how accurate a projection about coastal
morphology evolution could be if, let’s say, the effect of increased drought in watershed dynamics
(i.e. alteration of cultivation processes leading to a decrease in overland erosion resulting in
subsequent decrease in sediment delivery to the coast) was not to be studied and taken into account
for the definition of the morphodynamic system’s forcings. This is one aspect of what component (D)
in the previous is about.
The second limitation regards the scales in space and time at which relevant approaches have been
successfully implemented, as well as how these scales relate to actual case-studies of importance for
watershed/coastal management and engineering purposes. This is another aspect of what component
(D) in the previous is about. This second limitation applies to the coastal tract approach, which is
subject to the first limitation too, but also to the CSDMS approach which does study WACS as
entities. Following the coastal tract approach, Cowell et al. (2003b) modelled coastal change for four
case studies of actual contrasting continental margins around the world, limited however to time
scales of 102 to 103 years. Following the CSDMS approach, Ashton et al. (2013) used the modelling
system’s capabilities to couple watershed and coastal dynamics, but only to simulate the evolution of
an idealized WACS under scenarios of changes solely in climatic pressures and for over 103 years, a
research attempt applicable to the study of the emergence of landforms rather than that of mesoscale
coastal evolution.
3.2 Towards the integrated modelling of WACS for management and engineering purposes
Approaches that have attempted to overcome the basic limitations described in the previous have
been presented by Samaras and Koutitas (2012) and Duong et al. (2016).
Samaras and Koutitas (2012) proposed an integrated approach to study the impact of watershed
management on coastal morphology through numerical modelling. Its essence refers to a coupledcalibration approach of the models in the watershed and the coast, which incorporates three scenarios
of data availability regarding the parameters of interest in both fields (overland sediment transport
and coastal sediment transport and morphology). The specific approach is divided in three discrete
stages, namely: (a) the stage of preliminary operations, (b) the stage referring to the preparation for
the applications of the numerical models and (c) the stage comprising the final applications of the
numerical models. Its flowchart is presented in Figure 4 and its detailed analysis in the original
publication; it is essential to underline, though, the role of the sediment discharge at the watershed
outlet (denoted by qS in Figure 4) in the entire extent of the methodological approach, operating as
the quantitative link between the models in the watershed and the coast during simulations. Samaras
and Koutitas (2014a) presented the successful implementation of their approach for the study of a
WACS in North Greece, where severe erosive phenomena in the vicinity of a small watershed outlet
were attributed to extensive land-use changes in the watershed over a couple of decades’ time. In a
follow-up work (Samaras and Koutitas, 2014b), the authors presented a first attempt on the
introduction of climate change in the integrated study of WACS, through the study of distinct
scenarios that dictated changes in specific weather/climate characteristics, in accordance with basic
IPCC projections.
This body of work as a whole (both conceptual and applied parts) does present certain advantages for
the study of WACS, such as: (a1) its focus and applicability to scales suitable for
506
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 4: Flow chart of the methodological approach of Samaras and Koutitas (2012).
watershed/coastal management and engineering purposes; (a2) its applicability to data poor
environments; (a3) its focus on the relative impact of changes in watershed management and climate
pressures on coastal morphology evolution in order to study case-specific phenomena; and (a4) its
flexibility in the study of climate change impact on WACS dynamics through a scenario-based
approach, which allows for the simulation of multiple potential future states with limited
computational effort. Nevertheless, there is still ground to cover, regarding: (b1) applications to
WACS of varying characteristics and dynamics and (b2) the approach’s connection to climate change
models, as well as the general major challenges presented in the following section.
Building on the conceptual modelling framework set by Ruessink and Ranasinghe (2014) and
Ranasinghe (2016), Duong et al. (2016) presented a thorough analysis on assessing climate change
impacts on the morphological stability of small tidal inlets. The modelling framework presented in
Figure 5 does retain the WACS approach discussed in the previous (proposing the concurrent
modelling of both watershed and coastal dynamics; see also Figure 3), while it also formally defines
the steps needed in order to incorporate climate change into the problem in question through ensemble
modelling. Particularly regarding climate change impacts on coastal change, the authors suggest that
they could be evaluated through the analysis of sets of “strategic snap-shot” (~ 1year) simulations for
future forcings, which should be run for desired future times (e.g. 2050, 2100). Duong et al. (2017,
2018) applied this approach to three case study sites along the southwest coast of Sri Lanka, the first
study perceiving them as data poor environments and the second one as the data rich environments
they actually represented.
Again, this body of work does present certain advantages for the study of WACS. These include (a1)
and (a2) described in the previous but also extend to: (a5) the incorporation of the study of climate
change impacts through ensemble modelling; and (a6) the adaptation and testing of 2D coastal
evolution modelling to the above framework. However, limitations do exist in this approach as well,
regarding: (b3) the inherent difference between estuaries in general and small tidal inlets this
approach refers and was applied to; (b4) the uncertainty regarding how “snap-shot” simulations
507
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
Figure 5: The modelling framework applied by Duong et al. (2016) in order to study climate
change impact on the stability of small tidal inlet (figure adopted from Ranasinghe, 2016).
could actually be useful in the process of strategic planning in WACS; and (b5) the unclarity of how
watershed modelling was actually applied in the three cases studies (Duong et al., 2017, 2018), since
this aspect, according to the authors, was studied by previous researchers and not during studying the
dynamics of the specific systems as entities. The general major challenges presented in the following
section apply to this approach as well.
4.
MAJOR CHALLENGES AHEAD
As seen from the previous, the integrated modelling of WACS has come a long way over the years,
with several important research attempts laying the ground towards a better understanding of how
watershed and coastal processes are intertwined into a web co-dependencies regarding coastal
morphology evolution, how future climate change would affect such systems, and, eventually, how
scientists could be able to describe the above through numerical modelling in order to plan climate
change adaptation in coastal areas. Conclusively, major challenges ahead can be coded into the
following issues, moving from general to specific ones:
(1) Setting the framework for resolving long-standing issues on the mutual understanding of essential
processes in the study of WACS between different disciplines, which – although trivial in essence –
are still hindering transcendence between scientific fields.
(2) Conceptualizing and defining what should be considered as a “satisfactory representation” of
coastal change in the study of WACS (i.e. in terms of morphological features evolution/analysis and
resolution in space and time).
508
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
(3) Integrating the concurrent study of climate change and watershed/coastal dynamics into a robust
framework and a respective modelling system that will be suitable for management and engineering
purposes (and will be properly tested in successfully doing so).
(4) Resolving the issue of identifying and adequately representing co-dependent processes in WACS
whose temporal evolution varies interanually and/or over annual/decadal scales as, simply put,
significant events won’t happen at the same time or time frame in the terrestrial and the coastal fields
(this applies to modelling WACS under climate change as well).
(5) Defining modelling parameters that can act as “quantitative links” between watershed and coastal
processes that are co-dependent for the evolution of coastal morphology.
(6) Identifying the suitable complexity for riverine sediment input analysis, with regard to how this
input to the coastal environment should be modelled.
The in-depth analysis of the above issues is understandably quite complicated and will be the subject
of a future extended version of this work.
5.
CONCLUSIONS
This work presents a concise critical review of the existing knowledge on the integrated modelling of
Watershed-Coast Systems’ (WACS) morphodynamics, along with considerations regarding the
introduction of the impact of climate change in the above context. Through the theoretical background
of conceptualizing and modelling coastal evolution, as well as the recent advances in the study of
WACS under a changing climate (along with the analysis of their strengths and limitations), major
challenges ahead are identified and coded into six main issues. These issues encompass the essence
of the authors’ view on how to move forward towards a better understanding and simulation of such
systems in order to plan climate change adaptation in coastal areas.
References
1. Ashton A.D., E.W.H. Hutton, A.J. Kettner, F. Xing, J. Kallumadikal, J. Nienhuis and L. Giosan
(2013) ‘Progress in coupling models of coastline and fluvial dynamics’, Computers and
Geosciences, Vol 53, pp. 21-29.
2. Cowell P.J., M.J.F. Stive, A.W. Niedoroda, H.J. de Vriend, D.J.P. Swift, G.M. Kaminsky and M.
Capobianco (2003a) ‘The Coastal-Tract (Part 1): A Conceptual Approach to Aggregated
Modeling of Low-Order Coastal Change’, Journal of Coastal Research, Vol 19(4), pp. 812-827.
3. Cowell P.J., M.J.F. Stive, A.W. Niedoroda, D.J.P. Swift, H.J. de Vriend, M.C. Buijsman, R.J.
Nicholls, P.S. Roy, G.M. Kaminsky, J. Cleveringa, C.W. Reed and P.L. de Boer (2003b) ‘The
Coastal-Tract (Part 2): Applications of Aggregated Modeling of Lower-Order Coastal Change’,
Journal of Coastal Research, Vol 19(4), pp. 828-848.
4. Duong T.M., R. Ranasinghe, M. Thatcher, S. Mahanama, Z.B. Wang, P.K. Dissanayake, M.
Hemer, A. Luijendijk, J. Bamunawala, D. Roelvink and D. Walstra (2018) ‘Assessing climate
change impacts on the stability of small tidal inlets: Part 2 - Data rich environments’, Marine
Geology, Vol 395, pp. 65-81.
5. Duong T.M., R. Ranasinghe, D. Walstra and D. Roelvink (2016) ‘Assessing climate change
impacts on the stability of small tidal inlet systems: Why and how?’, Earth-Science Reviews,
Vol 154, pp. 369-380.
6. French J., A. Payo, B. Murray, J. Orford, M. Eliot and P. Cowell (2016) ‘Appropriate complexity
for the prediction of coastal and estuarine geomorphic behaviour at decadal to centennial scales’,
Geomorphology, Vol 256, pp. 3-16.
509
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
7. IPCC (2013) ‘Summary for Policymakers’, Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis.
Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel
on Climate Change, eds. Stocker T.F., et al., Cambridge University Press.
8. Li Z. and H. Fang (2016) ‘Impacts of climate change on water erosion: A review’, Earth-Science
Reviews, Vol 163, pp. 94-117.
9. Luan H.L., P.X. Ding, Z.B. Wang, J.Z. Ge and S.L. Yang (2016) ‘Decadal morphological
evolution of the Yangtze Estuary in response to river input changes and estuarine engineering
projects’, Geomorphology, Vol 265, pp. 12-23.
10. Payo A., D. Favis-Mortlock, M. Dickson, J.W. Hall, M. Hurst, M.J.A. Walkden, I. Townend,
M.C. Ives, R.J. Nicholls and M.A. Ellis (2017) ‘Coastal Modelling Environment version 1.0: a
framework for integrating landform-specific component models in order to simulate decadal to
centennial morphological changes on complex coasts’, Geoscientific Model Development, Vol
10(7), pp. 2715-2740.
11. Peckham S.D., E.W.H. Hutton and B. Norris (2013) ‘A component-based approach to integrated
modeling in the geosciences: The design of CSDMS’, Computers & Geosciences, Vol 53, pp.
3-12.
12. Ranasinghe R. (2016) ‘Assessing climate change impacts on open sandy coasts: A review’,
Earth-Science Reviews, Vol 160, pp. 320-332.
13. Ruessink B.G. and R. Ranasinghe (2014) ‘Beaches’, Coastal environments and Global change,
eds. Masselink, G. and Gehrels, R., Wiley.
14. Samaras A.G. and C.G. Koutitas (2012) ‘An integrated approach to quantify the impact of
watershed management on coastal morphology’, Ocean and Coastal Management, Vol 69, pp.
68-77.
15. Samaras, A.G. and C.G. Koutitas. (2014a) ‘The impact of watershed management on coastal
morphology: A case study using an integrated approach and numerical modeling’,
Geomorphology, Vol 211, pp. 52-63.
16. Samaras A.G. and C.G. Koutitas (2014b) ‘Modeling the impact of climate change on sediment
transport and morphology in coupled watershed-coast systems: A case study using an integrated
approach’, International Journal of Sediment Research, Vol 29(3), pp. 304-315.
17. SWFWMD - Southwest Florida Water Management District (2018) http://swfwmd.state.fl.us
(accessed Feb 5th, 2018).
18. Syvitski J.P.M., S.D. Peckham, R. Hilberman and T. Mulder (2003) ‘Predicting the terrestrial flux
of sediment to the global ocean: A planetary perspective’, Sedimentary Geology, Vol 162(1-2),
pp. 5-24.
19. Van Maanen B., R.J. Nicholls, J.R. French, A. Barkwith, D. Bonaldo, H. Burningham, A. Brad
Murray, A. Payo, J. Sutherland, G. Thornhill, I.H. Townend, M. van der Wegen and M.J.A.
Walkden (2016) ‘Simulating mesoscale coastal evolution for decadal coastal management: A new
framework integrating multiple, complementary modelling approaches’, Geomorphology, Vol
256, pp. 68-80.
510
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
ASSESSING THE RESILIENCE OF THE RIA FORMOSA
BARRIER ISLAND SYSTEM: PRELIMINARY FINDINGS
K. Kombiadou*, A. Matias, A.R. Carrasco, S. Costas, O. Ferreira, T.A. Plomaritis and
G. Vieira
Centre for Marine and Environmental Research (CIMA), University of Algarve, 8005-139, Faro,
Portugal
*Corresponding author: e-mail: akompiadou@ualg.pt
Abstract
The aim of the present paper is to analyse the recent morphological evolution of the sandy barriers of
Ria Formosa, a multi-inlet system located in South Portugal, to assess evolution regimes and related
controlling factors and to identify resilience mechanisms in response to natural and artificial drivers
of change. The data collected comprise aerial photographs and wave buoy and hindcast time-series,
covering the period from the 1950s to 2014. The results show that the barriers have either been
growing, or remaining stable. The growth patterns were either promoted by natural mechanisms, or
triggered by stabilization works and supported by natural factors (e.g. longshore transport, shoal
attachment). The presence of a broad marsh platform in the backbarrier was found to promote barrier
stability, while the sustainance of transgressive barriers is advocated by frequent overwash, combined
with low depths in the backbarrier lagoon and localised replenishment of sand. These long-term
evolution regimes and their relation to artificial and natural factors show that the barriers of Ria
Formosa have been resilient during the time-frame of the study, either absorbing disturbances
(Armona and Tavira), or adapting to change while maintaining their functions (rest of the barriers).
Keywords: Geomorphology, remote sensing, multi-decadal analysis, ecological resilience
1.
INTRODUCTION
Ria Formosa is a roughly triangularly-shaped multi-inlet barrier island system (Figure 1) in southern
Portugal, with a total extension of around 55 km, and expanding at a maximum distance of 6 km from
mainland (at Cape Santa Maria). At present, it consists of two peninsulas and five islands, developed
along two flanks, while the connection between the tidal lagoon and the ocean is performed through
six tidal inlets. The more energetic western flank is impacted by frequent (71% occurrence) waves
originating from W-SW and the longer, eastern, flank is exposed to E-SE waves (23% occurrence)
[Costa et al., 2001]. The tidal regime is semi-diurnal, with average amplitudes of 1.3 and 2.8 m for
neap and spring tides, respectively, while maximum spring tides can reach 3.5 m. The wave climate
is moderate, with average annual offshore significant wave heights of 1.0 m and peak periods of 8.2 s
[Costa et al., 2001]. The area, declared a Natural Park, is of high ecological and socio-economic
significance [Guimarães et al., 2012]; it is the most important wetland in South Portugal, supporting
a variety of diverse habitats and species (e.g. dunes, marshes, seagrasses, etc.), as well as various
anthropogenic activities (e.g. fisheries, tourism, bivalve gathering, etc.). Still, the crucial importance
of the sandy barriers themselves to the existence and persistence of the entire system and the
supported habitats is often overlooked.
The aim of the present paper is to investigate the recent (past 60 years) long-term morphological
evolution of the barriers of Ria Formosa in the presence of human interventions and natural processes
511
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
(i.e., storms), to identify the main drivers of change for each barrier and, based on those results, to
gain insights on the major mechanisms promoting resilience.
Figure 1: The Ria Formosa barrier island system; the location of the Faro buoy and the Santa
Maria Cape are noted on the map, as well as the names of islands, peninsulas, inlets and the
division of Armona to W and E.
2.
DATA AND METHODS
The morphological evolution analysis was based on aerial photographic data that cover the period
from 1947 to 2014. Aerial photographs were georeferenced using the orthophotography of 2002
(oldest available orthorectified photos) as the basis for a backwards-in-time process. The available
flights, related characteristics of the rasters and the RMSE related with the georeferencing process
are given in Table 1; the average Residual (Res.) RMSE refers to the error remaining after
rectification, while the average Accumulated (Acc.) RMSE refers to the error that can cumulate due
to the backwards-in-time georeferencing (assessed comparing each flight with the 2002 orthophotos).
The average Res. RMSE ranges from 0.6±0.2 m for the most recent, high-resolution, flights, to
1.6±0.6 m for the oldest ones. The Acc. RMSE is also low, between 0.6 and 1.1 m for high-resolution
flights and reaches 2 m for low-resolution aerial photographs.
To assess the barrier evolution, the wet-dry line was digitised, as a shoreline proxy in the ocean side
and the limit of upper-mash vegetation, or the debris line (MHWL) was digitised, as a coastline proxy
for the lagoon side. It is noted that the wet-dry line includes a high variability due to the tidal level
and swash runup at the time of the flight. Weighted Linear Regression (WLR) analysis was performed
on the entire dataset, using the Digital Shoreline Analysis Tool [Thieler et al., 2009]. The uncertainty
values used were taken equal to the total shoreline position error [Morton et al., 2004], calculated
from the rectification and digitizing errors. The former was defined as the total Acc. RMSE for each
island and the latter was related to the image cell size [Jabaloy-Sánchez et al., 2014].
In terms of forcing, significant wave heights from the Faro buoy were used; the insitu data cover the
period from 1993 to 2014 and was complemented with hindcasting results (SIMAR; Spanish State
Port Authority) for the period 1958-1992. The storm thresholds considered are 2.5 m for significant
wave height and 6 hours for storm duration [after Oliveira et al., 2018]. Only waves incident to the
coast were taken into account for each flank (e.g. for E flank only waves from the SE sector: E to S).
512
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1: List of available rasters, including year, resolution, bands (1: BW, 3: RGB, 4:
RGB+NIR), average Residual (Res.) RMSE and Accumulated (Acc.) RMSE. Datasets prior to
2001 are orthoimages.
Year Resolution Bands
3.
Res.
Acc.
Res.
Acc.
Year Resolution Bands
RMSE (m) RMSE (m)
RMSE (m) RMSE (m)
2014
0.7m
4
-
-
1989
1:8000
3
1.0 ± 1.0
1.4
2009
0.5m
3
-
-
1986
1:8000
3
0.7 ± 0.4
1.1
2008
0.7m
4
-
-
1985
1:15000
1
1.2 ± 1.6
1.3
2005
3.5m
3
-
-
1980
variable
1
1.0 ± 1.9
1.6
2002
3.5m
3
-
-
1976
1:30000
1
1.1 ± 1.6
1.8
2001
1:8000
3
0.6 ± 0.2
0.6
1972
1:6000
1
0.8 ± 0.5
1.1
2000
1:8000
3
0.7 ± 0.6
0.8
1969
1:25000
1
1.1 ± 0.6
1.5
1999
1:8000
3
0.6 ± 0.2
0.8
1958
1:26000
1
1.1 ± 0.7
2.1
1996
1:8000
3
0.8 ± 1.0
1.0
1952
1:20000
1
1.1 ± 0.6
1.7
1989 1:10000
1
0.7 ± 0.2
1.2
1947 unknown
1
1.6 ± 0.6
2.0
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Linear regression analysis
The results of the long-term morphological analysis of the barriers are given in Figures 2 and 3 for
the western (Ancão Peninsula and Barreta and Culatra Islands) and for the eastern (Armona, Tavira
and Cabanas Islands and Cacela Peninsula) part of Ria Formosa, respectively. To show the main
evolution patterns and to facilitate interpretation of WLR rates, indicative digitised shorelines (1950s,
1980s and 2014) are also presented. For Cabanas-Cacela 1996 is the last flight examined. Given that
natural inlets are highly energetic environments, with temporal scales of change much smaller than
the frame of study, the WLR rates presented and discussed focus mainly on the areas of the barrier
not the directly affected by inlets.
The evolution of the Ancão Peninsula is dominated by longshore sediment transport and the eastward
migration of the Ancão Inlet [Vila-Concejo et al., 2002]. As seen in Figure 2a, the backbarrier is
generaly stable, with low rates of -0.2 to +0.4 m/yr, while, in the oceanfront, retreating shoreline
tendencies prevail in the western part and accretive in the eastern, ranging within ±0.8 m/yr. In the
inlet-affected eastern part of the barrier the variability increases in both margins. In Barreta Island
(Figure 2b), the beach is dominated by strong progradation, with rates that reach 6 m/yr in the Santa
Maria Cape and range from +2.4 to +3.5 m/yr in the rest of the coast of the western flank. The
southward expansion of the island (maximum shoreline progression of 350 m between 1952 and 2014
at the Cape) is due to the stabilisation of the Faro-Olhão (hereafter F-O) Inlet that enabled the
entrapment and accumulation of longshore sediment drift. In the vicinity of the F-O Inlet, erosive
tendencies that reach -1.0 m/yr are observed, possibly due to local flow conditions near the western
513
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
jetty. In the leeside, the coast is very stable, with near-zero rates, mainly due to the presence of a
broad, mature marsh. The evolution of Culatra Island (Figure 2c) is dominated by the rapid eastward
elongation of the island, also initiated by the stabilisation of the F-O Inlet. The stabilisation caused
sediment starvation to the western shore, with recession rates of -0.5 to -2.0 m/yr, and a decrease in
the tidal prism of the downdrift Armona Inlet [Pacheco et al., 2010] that resulted to the attachment of
the ebb delta shoals to Culatra and accretion of the eastern part of the island, with rates that reach
22 m/y. The island tip progressed eastwards by an average of 3.2 km between 1952 and 2014. The
backbarrier area of the island is relatively stable, with low rates of ±0.5 m/yr in the western, oldest
part and with slighly higher variability and erosive tendencies of, on average, -0.6 m/yr in the eastern,
recently formed, part.
Figure 2: WLR values (in m/yr) for Ancão Peninsula (a) and Barreta (b) and Culatra (c)
Islands, presented as coloured dots along the ocean and lagoon-side baselines (erosive rates:
red-yellow; accretive rates: green-blue-purple, with reference to the horizontal colour-bar);
indicative shorelines are presented and the location of the area is noted on the (top-left) map.
514
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Armona Island (Figure 3a), also impacted by the reduction of the tidal prism in the updrift Armona
Inlet, grows towards the NW near the inlet, with average shoreline progradation of 470 m during the
study period, significantly lower than the one of Culatra. The related rates in the area are of the order
of +5.5 to +15.5 m/yr. These accretive tendencies extend along the ocean side until the middle of the
island, with decreasing rates towards the east (average of +0.6 m/yr) and turn erosive near the Fuzeta
Inlet, ranging from -0.2 to -1.6 m/yr. The island has an extensive backbarrier and the lagoon-side
coastline is stable, apart from the areas near the inlets, where rates can reach -6.8 and +9.6 m/yr.
Tavira Island also possesses a mature and extensive marsh in the backbarrier and, thus, the rates in
the related coastline are near-zero. In the ocean side, the shoreline is accreting near the Tavira Inlet
(up to 3 km from the jetty, updrift), on average by 1.5 m/yr and by a maximum of +4.8 m/yr, and
retreating in the central part, with an average rate of -0.8 m/yr. For Cabanas Island and Cacela
Peninsula, hereafter referred to as C-C for brevity, the analysis extends only up to 1996, due to
extensive nourishment in the area, implemented in 1997 (around 48·104 m3) [Vila-Concejo et al.,
2002]. Thus, extending the analysis beyond this date would make it impossible to distinguish natural
from artificial evolution. As shown in Figure 3c, the entire subsystem presents strong regressive
behaviour. Maximum erosion trends are identified in the central part (2.5 to 6.5 km downdrift from
the Tavira jetty) and range from -5 to -10 m/yr, with an average of -6.4 m/yr. Coastal retreat decreases
towards the SW and NE parts of C-C, due to frequent small scale nourishment with dredged material
from the channel (unrecorded) near the Tavira jetty, for the former, and the attachment to the
mainland, for the latter. The backbarrier is also migrating landwards by an average of 3.3/yr and local
maximum rates of 8.5 m/yr. The low depths of the backbarrier bay have enabled the transgression of
C-C, through frequent overwashes [Matias et al., 2008] that move sediment towards the mainland,
thus allowing the barriers to shift their position landwards under storm waves.
3.2 Barrier morphological evolution trends
To analyse the evolution of the barriers in relation with the wave activity and human interventions,
the total area of the barriers was calculated and is presented in Figure 4 for each flank, as change
relative to the first available recording (1952), along with the average annual significant storm wave
height and total annual storm duration. Significant interventions in the area are also noted in the
timeline, along with breaching events in each flank.
In the west flank (Figure 4a&b), it can be noted that the evolution of Ancão and Barreta is highly
interlinked, with the growth of one barrier to be largely followed by a reduction of the other. Ancão
presents accretion in the period of 1952 to 1972, related with the eastward migration of the Inlet. In
the same period, Barreta is growing southwards due to the stabilization of the downdrift F-O Inlet.
The storms of 1973 caused the breaching of a second inlet in the peninsula [Vila-Concejo et al.,
2002], initiating losses for Ancão and corresponding gains for Barreta. From 1976, the inlet started
an eastward migration cycle, reaching its eastmost position in 1996, which is reflected in the growth
of Ancão and the reduction of Barreta barrier areas following 1985. The reduction in Ancão between
1972 and 1985 is attributed to the construction of the Vilamoura jetties, around 10 km west (updrift;
location shown in embedded map of Figure 1) from the Peninsula, that reduced the longshore drift
reaching Ancão [Ferreira et al., 2006]. In June 1997, extensive coastal management work was
performed in Ria Formosa, including the relocation of Ancão Inlet [Vila-Concejo et al., 2002]. This
is reflected in the evolution of Ancão and Barreta, with significant drop to the former and related
increase to the latter that lasted up to 2002, where the inlet reached its westernmost point.
Subsequently, a new eastward migration cycle started, coincident with beach nourishment projects in
Ancão (2.65·106 m3 distributed in Ancão, Armona, Tavira and Cabanas) [Dias et al., 2003] and in the
updrift coastal zone (1998, 2004 & 2010) [Oliveira et al., 2008] that increased sediment availability
in the area and halted coastal retreat in Ancão. From 2002 onwards, Ancão and Barreta showed only
small-scale changes (within ±5%). Taking into account that longshore sediment transport is directed
eastwards and assuming that the sediment bypassing the F-O jetties is low, the summation of the area
515
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
of the two barriers (dashed blue line in Figure 4a) can reveal the direct impacts of the F-O stabilisation
to the sediment balance of the western flank. The curve shows that the accumulation of sand initiated
by the F-O jetties was intense up to 1972, reaching 18% in 20 years. The growth was slower up to the
early 2000s, with a further increase of around 8% in 30 years, which appears to have stabilised; at
present, the width of Barreta has reached the width of the jetty (grey-filled curve in Figure 2b) and
accumulation is occurring as submerged sand banks in front of the island [Pacheco et al., 2008].
Figure 3: WLR values (in m/yr) for Armona (a) and Tavira (b) Islands and Cabanas IslandCacela Peninsula (c), presented as coloured dots along the ocean and lagoon-side baselines
(erosive rates: red-yellow; accretive rates: green-blue-purple, with reference to the horizontal
colour-bar); indicative shorelines are presented and the location of the area is noted on the
(top-left) map.
In the eastern flank, Culatra and Armona present a growing tendency almost throughout the study
period. This growth is also attributed to the stabilisation of F-O that, as mentioned previously, induced
the reduction of the tidal prism of the in-between Armona Inlet. The growth of Armona is also affected
by the eastward migration of the Fuzeta Inlet, migration that also impacts the downdrift barrier of
Tavira. To elucidate the evolution of the barriers and the ‘net’ contribution of the stabilisation works
(F-O and Tavira jetties), Armona was split in two parts, W and E (see Figure 1 for location), which
were added to each neighbouring barrier, assimilating, in this manner, the short-term, strong
516
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
morphological changes due to the Fuzeta Inlet movement. Thus, the joined barrier evolution of
Culatra and west Armona (Culatra+Armona W in Figure 4c) and of east Armona and Tavira (Armona
E+Tavira in Figure 4c) can be studied; given that the margins of these two groups correspond to
stabilised inlets (F-O to the W and Tavira to the E), the ocean-side longshore gains and losses of the
total area can be omitted. As shown by the evolution of Culatra and Armona W, the area is growing
continuously throughout the study period, with a linear trend of 3.1·104 m2/yr (R2=0.97), reaching an
increase of 40% in 2014, compared to 1952. Small-scale shifts to the relative change of the
accumulated sand area are attributed to storm events (e.g. trend reduction between 1980-85, due to
the intense wave activity of 1983). The evolution of Tavira shows reduction in total area, however,
after the addition of Armona E the curve shows low variability, within ±5% (orange solid vs. dashed
lines in Figure 4c); it, thus, becomes evident that the reducing trend in the area of Tavira is due to the
migration of Fuzeta and not to storm impacts. The extension of the Tavira jetties in 1985 seems to
invoke sediment accumulation that lasts up to 1997, after which, slightly decreasing trends are
observed, most likely related to the highly energetic storms and to long-lasting events (Figure 4d).
The beach nourishment of 1999-2000 in Tavira and Armona [Dias et al., 2003] caused limited
changes in the barrier area evolution. The C-C barriers present relative stability in total area, with the
values to fluctuate between -10 and +7%, mainly due to storms and overwash events. The average
roll-over of the system between 1947 and 1996 is of the order of 150 to 200 m in the west-central part
and reduces to 80 m in the eastern part (east from the 1995-6 breach, see Figure 3).
3.3 Evolution regimes and resilience mechanisms
The main long-term barrier evolution trends for the period of 1952-1996 for C-C and 1952-2014 for
the other barriers, identified in Ria Formosa, are summed-up in Figure 5 and the related major
evolution regimes and corresponding drivers of change (artificial triggers and natural mechanisms
that sustain these regimes) are summarised in Table 2. Human pressures such as intense occupation
(e.g. Ancão and Culatra) and frequent dredging of backbarrier channels (e.g. Ancão and Tavira) to
ensure navigability are not considered in the analysis, since they generate changes at shorter spatialtemporal scales and can be omitted for the ones considered in the study.
Apart from the presence of the Vilamoura jetties, inlet relocations and beach-dune nourishments that
are the main artificial factors in the area, the evolution of the Ancão Peninsula is largely dominated
by longshore sediment transport, promoting its elongation and the eastward migration of the Ancão
Inlet. The stabilisation of F-O Inlet played a decisive role to the evolution of Barreta, Culatra and
Armona W, generally promoting growth in all cases (apart from localised erosion in Culatra directly
downdrift from the jetty). For Barreta, it caused strong southward accretion by trapping sediments
from longshore drift and by changing local circulation patterns around the western jetty. For Culatra
and Armona W, the mechanism boosting this growth (and the narrowing of the in-between inlet) was
the increase of the tidal flow through F-O and the corresponding loss of hydraulic efficiency in
Armona after the stabilisation. Excluding the changes due to the eastward migration of Fuzeta,
Armona E and Tavira W are relatively stable, supported by broad backbarrier zones. The stabilisation
of the Tavira Inlet induced accumulation immediately updrift (east Tavira) and lack of sediment to
the downdrift Cabanas Island, contributing to the generic erosive trend at C-C. Losses in W Cabanas
are replenished using dredged matter (unrecorded), sustaining a ‘forced’ stability of the area. C-C are
at a transgressive state, fed by frequent overwash and the shallow depths of the backbarrier lagoon,
while largely retaining the total barrier area.
517
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
Figure 4: Evolution of total barrier area, relative to 1952, and average storm significant wave
height for the western (a, b) and eastern flank (c, d). Wave data include average significant
storm wave heights (bars, with reference to the left axis) and total annual storm duration
(scatter-points, with reference to the right axis) at the location of the Faro buoy (Figure 1);
data after 1993 are buoy records and older ones are SIMAR hindcasting data (Spanish State
Port Authority). Human interventions (grey and black arrows: W from the area) and Inlet
breaching events (arrows coloured as the related island) are noted.
518
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 5: Schematic representation of the multi-decadal morphological response of the
barriers of Ria Formosa. The major trends are noted as arrows (orange for shoreline and
blue for Inlets) on the 2014 map.
The evolution regimes identified (Table 2) include: a) natural growth, limited by artificial factors
(Ancão), b) artificially triggered growth, promoted by natural factors (Barreta, Culatra and Armona
W), c) stability, promoted by natural (Armona E) and artificial factors (Tavira) and d) transgression
triggered by artificial factors and supported by natural and artificial factors (C-C). Therefore,
accepting the definition of ecological resilience as ‘the capacity of a system to absorb disturbances
or shocks, re-organize and adapt to change, while retaining its structure, identity and feedbacks’
[Folke, 2006], it can be deduced that the barriers of Ria Formosa appear resilient to natural (i.e.,
storms) and human disturbances. The barriers have either absorbed disturbances, remaining
practically unchanged (Armona and Tavira), or adapted to the changing conditions while maintaining
their main functions (rest of the barriers).
Table 2: Morphological evolution of barriers, related main artificial and natural drivers of
change, triggering and/or supporting evolution, and resilience mechanisms (NR:
Nourishment; LST: Longshore Sediment Transport; SBL: Shallow Backbarrier Lagoon).
Evolution Regime
Growth
Position
growing (SE)
stable
Ancão
growing (S)
stable
Barreta
growing (NE)
stable
Culatra
stable
W growing (SW)
Armona
stable
stable
E
stable
stable
Tavira
stable
retreating
C-C
Barrier
4.
Limiting/Promoting Factors
Artificial
Natural
Vilamoura jetties, NR
LST
F-O jetties
LST
F-O jetties
Armona ebb shoals
F-O jetties
Armona ebb shoals
broad backbarrier
Tavira jetties
broad backbarrier
Tavira jetties, NR
SBL, overwashes
Resilience
Mechanism
adaptation
adaptation
adaptation
adaptation
absorption
absorption
adaptation
CONCLUSIONS
Raster datasets from the last 60 years (1947-2014) were used to define ocean and lagoon-side
coastlines and to analyse the multi-decadal morphodynamic changes of the Ria Formosa barriers.
With the exception of Cabanas-Cacela, the analysis showed overall low rates in the backbarrier
coasts. In the ocean side, the shoreline in the Ancão Peninsula presents erosive tendencies in the west
519
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
part that turn accretive towards the east (-0.8 to +0.8 m/yr). In Barreta, there is a generalised tendency
for shoreline progradation that peaks in the Santa Maria Cape (+6 m/yr) and extends to the rest of the
west flank (+2.4 to +3.5 m/yr), while localised erosion is identified near the Faro-Olhão jetty. In
Culatra, the shore downdrift from the jetty (up to 3.5 km from it) is receding (-0.5 to -2 m/yr), while
strong accretion rates prevail in the rest of the island (maximum: +22 m/yr). The shoreline in Armona
is accreting in the west part, with highest rates near the inlet (+5.5 to +15.5 m/yr), and showing limited
erosive tendencies in the east part (-0.2 to -1.6 m/yr). The shore in east Tavira, and up to 3 km west
from the jetty, is prograding (on average by +1.5 m/yr) and turns retreating in the central-western part
(on average by -0.8 m/yr). In Cabanas-Cacela, both barriers are migrating landwards, with peak rates
in the central part (ocean-side: -5 to -10 m/yr; lagoon-side: -3.3 to -8.5 m/yr).
Regarding existing morphological evolution regimes, the related promoting factors and the resilience
of the barriers of Ria Formosa, the investigation showed:
1. The existence of two main barrier evolution patterns in the area: growth and stability.
2. The decisive contribution of jetty construction to the recent evolution of the majority of the
barriers; barrier growth has been largely triggered by such interventions and, consequently,
fuelled by natural processes (e.g. longshore sediment transport). For example, the stabilisation of
the Faro-Olhão Inlet resulted to an increase in total barrier area of the west flank by 25% and of
the affected barriers of the east flank by 40% (corresponding to an overall increase of the entire
east flank by 8%), between 1952 and 2014.
3. The long-term resilience of the barriers to artificial (stabilisation works) and natural (storms)
stressors is demonstrated through two main mechanisms: adapting to change (either growing, or
transgressing landwards), or absorbing shocks while remaining stable in terms of position and
area (observed in barriers with broad salt marsh platforms in the backbarrier).
The assessment of resilience indicators and the evaluation of future scenarios for barrier island
evolution will be the next steps of the research.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The work was implemented in the framework of the EVREST project (PTDC/MAR-EST/1031/2014),
funded by FCT, Portugal. A. Matias was supported by the contract IF/00354/2012, S. Costas by the
contract IF/01047/2014 and A.-R. Carrasco by the grant SFRH/BPD/88485/2012, all funded by FCT.
References
1. Costa, M., Silva, R. & Vitorino, J. (2001) 'Contribuição para o Estudo do Clima de Agitação
Marítima na Costa Portuguesa (in Portuguese)', in 2as Jornadas Portuguesas de Engenharia
Costeira e Portuária, AIPCN/PIANC Secção Portugal, 2001.
2. Guimarães, M. H. M. E., Cunha, A. H., Nzinga, R. L. & Marques, J. F. (2012) 'The distribution
of seagrass (Zostera noltii) in the Ria Formosa lagoon system and the implications of clam
farming on its conservation', Journal for Nature Conservation, 20, 30–40.
3. Thieler, E. R., Himmelstoss, E. A., Zichichi, J. L. & Ergul, A. (2009) 'The Digital Shoreline
Analysis System (DSAS) version 4.0—an ArcGIS Extension for Calculating Shoreline
Change', 2009.
4. Morton, R. A., Miller, T. L. & Moore, L. J. (2004) 'National assessment of shoreline change: Part
1: Historical shoreline changes and associated coastal land loss along the US Gulf of Mexico',
U.S. Geological Survey Open-file Report 2004-1043, 45.
5. Jabaloy-Sánchez, A., Lobo, F. J., Azor, A., Martín-Rosales, W., Pérez-Peña, J. V., Bárcenas, P.,
Macías, J., Fernández-Salas, L. M. & Vázquez-Vílchez, M. (2014) 'Six thousand years of
coastline evolution in the Guadalfeo deltaic system (southern Iberian Peninsula)',
Geomorphology, 206, 374–391.
520
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
6. Oliveira, T. C. A., Neves, M. G., Fidalgo, R. & Esteves, R. (2018) 'Variability of wave parameters
and Hmax/Hs relationship under storm conditions offshore the Portuguese continental coast
(under revision)', Ocean Engineering, 153, 10–22.
7. Vila-Concejo, A., Matias, A., Ferreira, Ó., Duarte, C. & Dias, J. M. A. (2002) 'Recent Evolution
of the Natural Inlets of a Barrier Island System in Southern Portugal', Journal of Coastal
Research, 36, 741–752.
8. Pacheco, A., Ferreira, Ó., Williams, J. J., Garel, E., Vila-Concejo, A. & Dias, J. A. (2010)
'Hydrodynamics and equilibrium of a multiple-inlet system', Marine Geology, 274, 32–42.
9. Matias, A., Ferreira, Ó., Vila-Concejo, A., Garcia, T. & Dias, J. A. (2008) 'Classification of
washover dynamics in barrier islands', Geomorphology, 97, 655–674.
10. Ferreira, Ó., Garcia, T., Matias, A., Taborda, R. & Dias, J. A. (2006) 'An integrated method for
the determination of set-back lines for coastal erosion hazards on sandy shores', Continental
Shelf Research, 26, 1030–1044.
11. Dias, J. A., Ferreira, Ó., Matias, A., Vila-Concejo, A. & Sá-Pires, C. (2003) 'Evaluation of Soft
Protection Techniques in Barrier Islands by Monitoring Programs: Case Studies from Ria
Formosa (Algarve-Portugal)', Journal of Coastal Research, 117–131.
12. Oliveira, S., Catalão, J., Ferreira, Ó. & Alveirinho Dias, J. M. (2008) 'Evaluation of Cliff Retreat
and Beach Nourishment in Southern Portugal Using Photogrammetric Techniques', Journal of
Coastal Research, 4, 184–193.
13. Pacheco, A., Vila-Concejo, A., Ferreira, Ó. & Dias, J. A. (2008) 'Assessment of tidal inlet
evolution and stability using sediment budget computations and hydraulic parameter analysis',
Marine Geology, 247, 104–127.
14. Folke, C. (2006) 'Resilience: The emergence of a perspective for social–ecological systems
analyses', Global Environmental Change, 16, 253–267.
521
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
EFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN THE PORT OF
TRELLEBORG AND PROTECTIVE MEASURES
A. S. Bagiouk1*, Th. V. Karambas1, S. S. Bagiouk2
1
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Aristotle
University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece,
2
Department of Civil Engineering, Democritus University of Thrace, 67131, Xanthi, Greece
*Corresponding author:E-mail: mpagiouka@civil.auth.gr, Tel +30 2310 300918, +30 6979206060
Abstract
This paper refers to the effect of climate change on the rise of the sea level, particularly in the southwestern Baltic region, at the port of Trelleborg. The port of Trelleborg from 1862 till present has
changed and has expanded in terms of its area of activity and in terms of its size, being the second
largest port in Sweden and the largest Ro-Ro Port in Scandinavia. Addressing climate change aims
to deal with the upcoming ecological disruptions. Although the results of climate change are
unknown, potential future climates based on natural principles and greenhouse gas emission scenarios
can be projected. Satellite measurements show that the sea level is rising at a steady pace worldwide.
In the case of this study, for the mean wave height it was assumed that there would be a greater
increase due to the uncertainty about the direction of the waves in the prediction models and the
maximum wave height was considered as high due to the more frequent occurrence of extreme
phenomena than in the past. The WAVE-L model was used to study 7 possible solutions in order to
protect the harbor from the rise of the sea level and to ensure resting conditions. The solutions focus
on the number, position and length of floating breakwaters. The choice of the floating breakwater
was made as it is a mild method of protection with environmentally friendly character and ability to
move and rearrange. Finally, by comparing the individual results for mid and extreme waves, the
optimal solution is chosen to adequately protect the port.
Keywords: Trelleborg Port, Climate change, Sea level
1.
INTRODUCTION
In the coastal zone, the seaports and the transnational links are key types of infrastructure that support
the global supply chain and provide regional economic activity, local transport services and jobs. The
protection of coastal projects and ports is taken for granted during a prolonged period of climate
stability. However over the last few years the forecasts for a new period of climate change and severe
weather have been predominant and most of the existing projects are not ableto deal with them
successfully. The port of Trelleborg belongs to the Baltic Sea segment, which is expected to show
changes because of its geographic location. Over the past hundred years, the Baltic Sea level has been
raised by 20 centimeters, which was a precursor to imminent disasters of coastal structures. This
abstract aims at assessment of the evolution of the port over time, analyzing the impact of climate
change on it and proposing solutions for its protection.
2.
THE PORT OF TRELLEBORG
Trelleborg is a city in Sweden with 28,290 inhabitants according to a record made in 2010. It is the
southernmost city in Sweden and it is one of the most important cities that have a port in Scandinavia
522
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
as well as across the Baltic Sea. The port has a very strategic location. The first link with Germany
was opened in 1897. Later it was replaced by a railway to Sabnitz in 1909 as part of the Malmo Berlin line. During the time of the German Democratic Republic, a larger line of coastal lines was
opened for Travemünde (which can be said to be the "modern harbor" of the historically important
Lubeck, initially as a line belonging to the Swedish national railways (SJ ) since 1962. After the fall
of the Berlin Wall in 1989, many new lines and routes were opened. The Trelleborg municipality
created a ferry terminal for all services, known as the "Kontinentbron" or "the Continental Bridge."
From 2015, the Shipping Lines and routes that are in operation are TT-line, Unity line and Stena line.
Most of the ferry services are trucks, which makes the port of Trelleborg the largest in Sweden,
regarding to goods by weight-criteria. In 2005, 11 million tonnes of merchandise passed through the
port (along with nearly 2 million passengers). (TrelleborgsHamn AB).
3.
CLIMATE CHANGE
Addressing climate change is the process of adapting to the real or expected climate and its impacts
in order to deal with the imminent ecological disruptions and exploit the beneficial opportunities for
social and environmental systems. Although the magnitude of the change is not known, possible
future climates based on natural and greenhouse gas scenarios can be projected. It is notonly the
climate change, but there are alsoother environmental or social changes that are expected to come to
the fore in the course of years. The predicted climate change in the Baltic Sea region can be divided
into immediate and indirect changes:
DIRECT CHANGES:
The rise in temperature will be significant in the coming decades, with the biggest changes
occurring in the winter and in the northeast part.
Short-term temperature limits will change more than long-term averages.
Extreme cold temperatures will be unusual, while hot summers are expected.
Winter rains are projected to increase throughout the whole region.
Scenarios and assumptions about summer rainfall are less likely, and most rainfall appears to be
concentrated in the north and there may be minor changes or declines in the south part.
Extreme rainfall is expected to be more frequent even in areas likely to experience a general
reduction in average rainfall.
Possible scenario is to exacerbate extreme precipitation for a long time (eg hours, days, weeks).
In terms of wind speed, the majority of scenarios show an increase in average speed but with great
uncertainty of relative prediction. Also the extreme wind conditions remain uncertain, but it is
likely a slight upward trend in the south and a decline in the north.
INDIRECT CHANGES:
Reduce of the amount of snow, the duration of snow cover and the appearance of sea ice.
The average annual flow of the river is expected to be much increased in the northern parts of the
basin. The total discharge of rivers in the Baltic Sea, is expected to increase, which can reduce
and affect the salinity of the sea.
General trends show increases in river flow in winter combined with lower and earlier peak flows
during spring due to changes in snow cover.
The waves of the Baltic Sea are changing as a result of large-scale atmospheric traffic. Some
model simulations in the Baltic Sea show an increase in maximum wind speed and frequency of
extreme events.
4.
BALTIC SEA
Baltic Sea is a semi-enclosed sea characterized by complex coastline and bathymetry, by the presence
of seasonal sea ice and by the high variability of wind fields in its various sub-basins. These factors
523
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
strongly affect the wave conditions in the sea area. Being aware of the wave climate is important as
waves have a major impact on coastal and offshore activities such as coastal infrastructure, port
operations, shipping, offshore platforms and people's safety. Changes in long-term wind and sea ice
conditions may also cause changes at the waves’ climate and can strongly affect the public and
economic sectors. Future climate changes simulations generally provide higher wavelengths for the
most areas except from the northern part.
Average waves show time and space changes over continual changes, while extreme waves show
much greater variability depending on the simulations. Analyzing four scenarios of possible
emissions of carbon dioxide, methane and nitrogen dioxide over a long term reaching the end of the
21st century across the Baltic Sea, it is concluded that significant changes were limited to some areas
that were heterogeneously distributed in each scenario. Changes in the average annual wind speed
through 30 years showed a decrease in all cases at the parts of the northern Baltic Sea and an increase
at the most parts of the southern Baltic Sea. These changes in the wave fields result not only from the
higher wind speeds but also from the possible shift to the western winds, which lead to different
expansions and also to a different wave height and direction. However, the direction of the wind is a
very important unpredictable and unstable parameter whose effects are controversial among the
models and therefore it is a factor for which there are no reliable predictions. For this reason, this
parameter should also be taken under account at the wave height which is used at our model. The port
area of Trelleborg is located southwest in the Baltic Sea.
Previous and present wave conditions have been well explored over the last few decades by analyzing
observations and numerical simulations. Among several other studies, wave velocity was analyzed in
the south-western Baltic and northern Baltic. All surveys show the high time variability (seasonal and
annual) due to the ice and wind variability. The maximum observed significant wave heights varies
between 4.46 m in the south-west Baltic Sea and 7.7 m in the northern Baltic.
All the four climatic cases demonstrated a slight increase in wind speed in most areas, especially at
the end of the 21st century, which was rarely above 5% of the reference values for the period 19611990. In preliminary analysis, changes in wind speed cannot be linearly transferred into wave
changes, so in some scenarios the expected increase in significant wave height is often over 5%,
sometimes reaching 15%. In addition, the decline in Baltic ice cover in the northern part of the sea
caused larger wave changes. In particular, the average annual increase in wave height over the next
30 years is justified by the decline in ice.
The analysis of routine climatic changes in all the under consideration scenarios emphasized the
increase in the average wave height of more than 5% for most of the Baltic Sea area. Of course, the
significant wave height has increased, reaching more than 5% in the eastern Kattegat, along the coasts
of Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia, and in the Gulf of Finland. In some parts of the Baltic Sea, especially
to the east of the coast, there was a decrease not exceeding -5% compared to the reference values.
These results are in agreement with those who pointed to changes on Estonian western coasts in a
possible hypothetical change. For this region an increase of between 5% and 20% was found on the
west coast and a decrease on the east coast.
The analysis of the variation of waves due to climate change over the decades over 140 years of
simulations has shown different characteristics depending on the position of the Baltic study point
and 3 spatial parameters of the distributions. The analysis over the decades has shown that the average
annual wave height has increased beyond the confidence interval according to the reference period
for all positions and the simulations at the end of the 21st century. The maximum annual wave height,
the confidence interval of the reporting period was much broader, and the changes over the confidence
interval beyond the confidence interval were well above 5% and occurred in some scenarios of
climate change. This demonstrates the high degree of uncertainty of the changes in extreme waves.
Analysis of the wave direction change showed a change of frequencies to an increased wave
frequency in the eastern directions, which is in line with the increase in frequencies of strong western
winds as analyzed by the North Sea and a positive North Atlantic oscillation. Using the same
524
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
atmospheric data, it also showed a trend towards the western winds in the southwest Baltic Sea. Also,
the trend towards the most western winds has also emerged in more modern studies. The effects of
wave changes are quite significant as stereo transfer as demonstrated by Dreier et al. (2011). In
addition to the limitation due to the use of only one model, temporal and spatial differences in wave
height and wave direction indicate the uncertainties due to different scenarios of emission and original
conditions, and therefore there is internal variability. However, the four situations of a potential future
wave change in the climate field have shown an increase in wave height in the Baltic Sea. Changes
in maximum extreme waves were smaller and more uncertain than in the mean. Changes in the
direction of the waves indicated more (less) frequent waves that were directed east (west). Changes
in wave directions may also explain the variations between small but homogeneous variations in wind
velocity and larger but more heterogeneous wave height changes as the effects of waves growth are
related to Baltic Sea composite bathymetry.
5.
APPLICATION OF THE WAVE-L MODEL IN THE TRELLEBORG NEW PORT
The WAVE-L model is a linear wave transmission model applied to medium and small scale coastal
areas. The equations that are solved are excessive and result from the replacement of the pressure and
velocity distribution, from the linear wave ripples to the linearized Navier-Stokes equations and thus
have the ability to describe the transmission of simple harmonic linear waves to any depth of mild tilt
(combination of diffraction, diffraction, reflection and shallow).
The above described model has been applied to simulate wave propagation in the new Port of
Trelleborg.
The time discretisation step is taken equal to: t = 0.025 sec
(1)
y
The space discretisation steps are taken as: x = =2.5 m
(2)
Thus the computational domain consists of 2600x1600 grids or an area 5500 m x 4000 m.
The rubble mound slopes (which reduce the wave reflection) are represented in the model by adopting
the technique proposed by to Karambas and Bowers (1996). The values of the reflection coefficients
Rs, are estimated using the formula proposed by Zanuttigh and van der Meer (2008):
Rs= tanh(αξbo)
(3)
where a and b are coefficients given by Zanuttigh and van der Meer (2008) (a=0.12, b=0.87) and o
is the Iribarren number.
The wave conditions which were studied concern the port's response to an imminent change.
Therefore, the wave height and wave conditions in the port were studied at an increase in the height
of the waves due to climatic conditions. The two wave conditions are WC1 and WC2. The first is the
average wave height while the second is the maximum. The WC2 case was made only for the most
prevalent solutions between the results given by WC1 as average wave height is the basic design
parameter. For each condition, significant wave height, peak period and incidence angle have been
calculated by applying a SWAN model. The above characteristics are given in Tables 6.1 and 6.2.
The Trelleborg harbor as it is located in the southwest of the Baltic will face an imminent increase in
the mean and extreme wave heights. The proliferation factor in the event of extreme events is from 5
to 10 and a predicted rise in the climatic conditions is estimated at 0.4 m as described in Chapter 2.
The calculated current average wave height in this area without taking into account the climatic the
change is 3.4 while the extreme height is 4.4m. For the model's requirements, an increase in the height
of the waves of 15%, which means an average height of 3.91 m (increase of 0.51 m till 2100) and
maximum height = 5.06 m, was considered. (an increase of 0.66 to 2100). For the mean wave height,
it was assumed that there would be a larger increase due to the uncertainty that exists about the
direction of the waves generally in the prediction models. For the maximum wave height, it was
525
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
thought to be equally large due to the more frequent occurrence of extreme phenomena than in the
past, which makes its observation more important.
The basic solution the protection of the port was based on the use of floating breakwaters. This choice
was made because the advantages of floating breakwaters are multiple, with respect to the following:
The ecological advantage of seawater renewal, biological exchange, sediment transport under
their structure and the development of marine ecosystems.
The cost of classic fixed breakwaters increases rapidly depending on the depth of water, as
opposed to floating breakwaters that offer a cheaper solution.
Construction speed and construction period are much shorter than the fixed breakwater
Possibility of future expansion and rearrangement since the position of floating waves can be
easily changed. In a protection project based on a probabilistic scenario, the variability of the size
and location of the project is very important as the waveguide factor can be introduced later and
integrated into each solution without being bound.
In order to protect the construction from the stresses and to have calm conditions in the port, the
following cases were specifically considered as possible solutions. The difference between the
solutions is the quantity of the constructions and if they will be located near or far of the coast. The
cases that have been studied are:
EXISTING CASE: Response of an existing port without any intervention
CASE 1: Port with two floating breakwaters (200m long) at a distance of 330m. from the entrance
of the harbor.
CASE 2: Port with two floating breakwaters (200m long) at a distance of 200m. from the entrance
of the harbor.
CASE 3: Harbor with a floating breakwater (200m long) at a distance of 330m. west of the harbor
entrance.
CASE 4: Port with a floating breakwater (200m long) at a distance of 200m. from the entrance of
the harbor
CASE 5: Harbor with a floating breakwater (360m long) at 1000m. west of the harbor entrance
CASE 6: Port with a floating breakwater (360m long) at a distance of 700m. west of the harbor
entrance
CASE 7: Port with a floating breakwater (360m long) at a distance of 480m. west of the harbor
entrance
Table 1: Wave characteristics for scenario WC1
Wind velocity (m/s) Wave heightHs (m) Wave direction
Tp (sec)
T (sec)
20
5.2
3.91
206.5
8.5
Table 2: Wave characteristics for scenario WC2 (100yr)
Wind velocity (m/s) Wave height Hs (m) Wave direction
Tp (sec)
31.6
6.
5.06
202.9
10.3
T (sec)
5.7
RESULTS
At the Figure 1 it is shown how the port will face the imminent rise of 15% of the wave height. The
average height of the waves is estimated to reach 3.91m and it is obvious that the desired conditions
do not exist.
526
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The problem is intensified in the case of the occurrence of the hundred-year wave. Although this is
an extreme ripple with a chance of recurrence once a hundred years, and planning will not be based
on it, it should nevertheless be taken into account so that the consequences are not disastrous. Indeed,
due to the instability of climatic conditions in recent years, which is going to be intensified due to the
imminent climate change, the prediction of extreme phenomena and ripples becomes more important.
Figure 1: Wave height without any structural intervention in the existing structure, taking
into account the factor of climate change
Figure 2: Wave height (hundred-year wave) without any structural intervention in the
existing structure, taking into account the factor of climate change
527
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
From the results analysis for all scenarios it is clear that Case 5 and Case 6 are the best solutions. It
means that installing a single breakwater westwards at a distance slightly further from the port
entrance, between 700-1000 meters offers greater protection and maintains resting conditions. The
most prevalent solutions will also be exported by their behavior in a hundred-year wave.
Figure 3: Wave height at the port with a floating breakwater (360m long) 1000m. west of the
harbor entrance
Figure 4: Wave Height at the port with a floating breakwater (360m long) 700m. west of the
harbor entrance
528
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 5: Wave height (hundred wave) at the port area with a floating breakwater (360m
long) at 1000m. west of the harbor entrance
Figure 6: Wave height (hundred wave) at the port area with a floating breakwater (360m
long) at 700m. west of the port entrance
Therefore, it is estimated that the case 6 responds best in both cases compared to case 5.
529
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
7.
CONCLUSIONS
In this abstract through mathematical, hydrodynamic and morphodynamic simulation models, it is
investigated the effectiveness of floating breakwaters as a means of protecting the port from elevation
and the more frequent occurrence of extreme waves.
For this purpose, it was chosen a floating breakwater. The floating breakwater is a mild method of
protecting coasts from erosion and it is increasingly used as an environmentally friendly alternative
method. Their main advantages are the speed of their construction, the allowance of interventions to
them, the ability to allow the renewing of the water and also the low cost compared to the conventional
constructions.
A further advantage of the use of floating breakwater is their ability to move so as to be re-routed in
the direction of the winds. This feature is necessary because the wind direction factor is important
and unpredictable and cannot be accurately calculated by using computational models.
The possible proposed solutions varied in terms of their length and their distance from the shore
where they be placed. As it is assumed from the results, the location of the breakwater installation is
particularly important. Cases 1 and 2 using 200m length breakwaters in the distance of 330 meters
and 200m respectively from the coast, gave similar results with Cases 3 and 4, which differ only in
the doubling of the breakwaters. Cases 5, 6 and 7 are based on the use of a united breakwater with
the length of 360 meters and they vary in their position, being in the distance of 1000m, 700m and
480m respectively from the coast.
The best results were observed in Case 5 and 6, showing that at a greater distance from the coast there
is better port protection. Among these two main scenarios, the performance of the floating
breakwaters at extreme wave height was examined. Case 6 gave the best results in both situations
with small differences from Case 5. In conclusion, it is proposed to use a united breakwater at a
distance varying between 700 and 1000 meters from the coast.
References
1. Baltadapt (2012). Baltadapt Strategy for adaptation to climate change in the BalticSea
region. A proposal preparing the ground for political endorsement throughout theBaltic Sea
region
2. Bank of Greece (2011). Changes in sea level and impacts on coasts. Athens (ingreek)
3. European Environment Agency. https://www.eea.europa.eu/ (accessed September27, 2017)
4. JochenHinkel et al. (2015), ‘Sea-Level Rise Scenarios and Coastal RiskManagement’,Nature
Climate Change 5’, no. 3
5. Karambas, Th. V. and Bowers E. C. (1996). Representation of partial wave reflection and
transmission for rubble mound coastal structures, Hydrosoft 96, Malaysia.
6. KristerNordland (2015).Real-time information in the port of Trelleborg WorkshopRostock,
2015-01-22
7. M. Mokrech et al. (2014), ‘An Integrated Approach for Assessing Flood Impacts dueto
Future Climate and Socio-Economic Conditions and the Scope of Adaptation
inEurope’,Climatic Change 128, no. 3–4
8. Ralf Weisse et al. (2014), ‘Changing Extreme Sea Levels along EuropeanCoasts’,Coastal
Engineering, Coasts@Risks: THESEUS, a new wave in coastalprotection, 87
9. Robert E. Kopp et al. (2014), ‘Probabilistic 21st and 22nd Century Sea-LevelProjections at a
Global Network of Tide-Gauge Sites’,Earth’s Future 2, no. 8
530
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
10. S. Brown et al. (2011),‘The Impacts and Economic Costs of Sea-Level Rise in Europeand the
Costs and Benefits of Adaptation’. Summary of Results from the EC RTDClimateCost Project,
The ClimateCost Project, Technical Policy Briefing Note 2,Stockholm
11. TheophanisV. Karambas, EkateriniKriezi, Simulation of wave propagation in the new
Trelleborg port, Thessaloniki
12. Trelleborg Marine Systems (2012). Design Manual. Trelleborg
13. Trelleborg Marine Systems (2012). Port of the future. Trelleborg
14. TrelleborgsHamn AB (2012). 150 years with the Port of Trelleborg. Trelleborg
15. TrelleborgsHamn AB (2015). The most efficient, friendliest and most environmental friendly
port in the Baltic Sea. Trelleborg
16. TrelleborgsHamnAB. www.trelleborgshamn.se (accessed September 2,2017)
17. Zanuttigh B. and J. W. van der Meer (2008). Wave reflection from coastal structures in design
conditions. Coastal Engineering, Vol. 55, 771-779
18. Ü. Suursaar, T. Kullas, and R. Szava-Kovats (2009), ‘Wind and Wave Storms, StormSurges
and Sea Level Rise along the Estonian Coast of the Baltic Sea’,WITTransactions on Ecology
and Environment 127, 149–60
531
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
EVALUATION OF IMPACTS OF TORRENT CORRECTION
WORKS AT FOURKA-HALKIDIKI IN THE COASTAL ZONE OF
FOURKA BEACH
V. Pavlidis
Civil Engineer, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki (A.U.Th.)
Alexandrou Moraitidi 6, Kifissia,
GR- 54655 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: vasileiospavlidis@gmail.com, tel : +306909701698
Abstract
The major characteristic of the torrent of Fourka-Halkidiki, one of the most devastating streams of
Kassandra peninsula, is the intense flooding behaviour in conjunction with the production and
transportation of huge, for its size, sand-composed debris. The formation of Fourka sandy beach,
which is a tourist attraction pole, is mainly ought to the stereo-transportation of Fourka stream. The
continuous, during the stage of increased supplies, accumulation of sand from Fourka stream
combined with the sea-waving, drifting of sand towards the axis of Fourka (NW) → Poseidi (NE)
form the shaping causes of Fourka beach. Until recently, in 2010, these two opposite-functioning
phenomena (accumulation of sand from the Fourka stream and abduction of sand form the coastal sea
sea-waving Fourka → Poseidi), were relatively balanced. After the devastating floods of 1990 and
2006 and the implemented stream correction works, the sand accumulations have been interrupted
(practically eliminated) a fact that resulted to the destabilization of existing balance among each other
and the shrinkage of coastal zone. In the present paper are recorded and evaluated the impacts of the
implemented anti-flood correction works of Fourka’s stream upon the movement of the produced
sand and the destabilization of the coastal zone at Fourka beach.
Keywords: Fourka stream, stereo-transportation of Fourka stream and flood genesis, sandaccumulation of beaches, Fourka beach
1.
INTRODUCTION
The Greek space is characterized by the vital presence of sea, the complicate-shaped coastline, the
extensive or bay-shaped sandy beaches, interchanged by steep rocky parts and sea caves. The
morphology of the Greek coastline with the sandy beaches and the combination of sea and sun
constitute the major cause of the development of its summer tourism. A determinant element of the
summer tourism is the geometry, the quantity, the rating and the quality of sandy beaches
The creation and stability of sandy beaches is ought to the balance of sand adduction (inputs) and
sand abduction (outputs) mechanisms. Usually, it prevails a steady small-changeable but rapidly
restored balance between the adduced and the abducted sand debris, with most common case small
seasonal deviations of the coastline. These increasing-decreasing incidents are ought to an elevationactivation of sand adducing or abduction mechanisms. An increase of sandy coastline is recorded in
cases of increased accumulations from flood-stereo-loads of streams and rivers, from increased
marine waving of adducing sand or reduced carrying-away capacity. In opposition to this, a decrease
is recorded due to intensification of the abduction mechanism or reduction of adducing sand. In both
cases the equilibrium of inputs-outputs is disturbed positively or negatively with a respective increase
532
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
or decrease of the sandy coastline. Phenomena of steady shrinkage (Pefkofyto beach, Photo 1a) or
expansion of sandy coastline (Glarokavos, Photo 1ab), are rarely observed.
α
β
Photo 1ab: a) General view of beach shrinkage at Pefkofyto Kassandra and of transportation
of sand to the area of Glarokavos bay, blocking its entrance. b) the sandy alluviums in the
coastline area at Glarokavos Kassandra where, in order to maintain the opening of
Glarokavos bay, continuous sand-takings are taking place.
The streams, by carrying out sandy debris materials, create qualitative sandy coasts in their delta
space. Torrents, stream-rivers and rivers, with muddy air-transport, expand on one hand, but on the
other they deteriorate the quality of their estuary beaches and consequently the provided tourist
product. The most beautiful Greek beaches are met at discharge points of streams carrying out sandy
debris or eroded sandy sea slopes. Such an example, are the sandy neo-genic formations at Kassandra
and the de-flaky granites and gneiss at Sithonia (Photo 2a,b), whereas the clay formations at
Kallikrateia-Moudania (Photo 2c) discharge sandy debris, but also encompasses plenty of clay
sediment that was deposited from suspension, leading to the downgrading of the beaches.
α
β
γ
Photo 2abc: Views of a) eroded sandy-composed neogenic formations at Fourka-Kassandra
stream, b) decomposed marble granites and gneiss at Sithona and c) the clay-composed neogenic formations at Kallikrateia - Moudania.
2.
STUDY AREA
The research area is the coast and the torrent of Fourka. The location of Fourka’s torrent watershed
within the aquatic division of Central Macedonia, prefecture of Halkidiki, peninsula of Kassandra, is
given in Fig. a,b,c.. Its watershed, the hydrographic network and the central bed with W, SW course
discharging to Fourka beach, is given in Fig. 2a,b.
The Fourka’s stream, the biggest and most disastrous stream at Kassandra peninsula, has a rich
flooding background with main feature the production and movement of bulky, sandy stereotransportation which has shaped the extensive sandy plain area of Kassandrinos - Fourka. Upon this
area have occurred successive phenomena of erosions and alluviums of the sandy beds and slopes of
the stream (Photo 3a,b) resulting to the thin-grained sandy stereo-transportation in the estuary of the
Fourka Beach stream.
533
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
a
b
c
Fig. 1abc: The position of Fourka’s torrent a) in the Central Macedonia, b) in the prefecture
of Halkidiki and c) in the Kassandra peninsula.
a
b
Fig. 2ab: Watershed and hydrographic network a) of Fourka’s torrent and b) of its upper
mountainous watershed, consisting of Kassandrino and Zografitiko Lako branches.
a
b
Photo 3ab: Views of intense slope erosions and b) depositions 2-8m high in the estuary bed of
Fourka’s torrent, associated with the expansion of the coast (Pavlidis Th. 1991).
To the formation of Fourka’s coast, concurrently with the adduction of sand, it was also acting a
coastal carrying-away marine waving of sand abduction with a SE direction. Until 1970, that
agriculture was the main activity of local people, the ploughing of sandy fields resulted to the
transportation of additional increased sand amounts towards Fourka Beach with a small positive
equilibrium of the adduced sand. At the same time, the good quality sand of the stream’s watershed
534
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
soils (Photo 4a) has led to their exploitation for construction use and cement preparation (Pavlidis Th.
1998).
A significant fact for the evolution of Fourka Beach were the arriving, during the flooding
phenomena, huge amounts of sand resulting to the extensive expansion of the beach towards the sea.
Eventually, until the arrival of new flooding sandy stereo-loads, the carrying-away marine mechanism
has gradually eroded the alluvial seashore, bringing it back to its almost initial condition. The photo
4b provides the extensive, during the big flood on 2.3.4/12.1990, pushing forward per 170m of the
alluvial discharge front of Fourka’s stream towards the sea (Pavlidis Th. 1991).
a
β
Photo 4ab: Views a) of the vulnerable sandy soils of Fourka’s stream, b) of pushing forward
per 170m to the seashore of Fourka during the flood of 1990.
By the abandonment of cultivations within the stream watershed and their coverage by compact
protective natural vegetation the sand equilibrium at Fourka beach became marginally negative. After
the recent works of layering gabions and gabion mattresses as a protective measure to the central bed,
the adduction of sand into the Fourka beach has ceased, leading to the shrinkage of coastal zone and
the deterioration of the beach. Until the completion of gabion’s gaps takes place (Photo 5), in the
coastal line - area of Fourka beach, it only functions the marine carrying-away mechanism, shrinking
the sandy beach. The phenomenon will continue until the completion of all gabion gaps (Fig. 3) and
the arrival of new sand loads to the beach. Therefore, this fact constitutes to the biggest threat for the
tourism since the quality of the sandy beach is not as it used to be.
Photo 5: Views of gabions used for covering the central bed of Fourka’s stream (Fig. 3) and
the covering of gaps at the initial part downwards of Kassandrino.
Fig. 3. The coated with wire-constructions central bed of Fourka’s stream.
3.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The research method in the present paper is as follows:
We looked up in local authorities and Services (Forest Office, Region of Central Macedonia,
Municipality of Kassandra, I.G.M.R., etc.) for papers, projects, reports and accomplished or under
535
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
construction works of anti-flood stream correction, dealing with background information about the
torrential environment of Fourka.
We approached and analyzed the factors of the torrential environment (climate, relief, geo-deposit,
vegetation) as much as for the entire stream watershed, as well as for the upper mountainous
watershed (Fig. 2a,b), downwards of which, has been implemented the major part of the correction
works. The calculation was done according to the applied methods in the hydronomics science
(kotoulas D. 2001, Pavlidis Th. 2007).
It was delimitated on map of Hellenic Military Geographical Service (HMGS), scale 1:50.000 and
1:5.000, the watershed of the stream and the upwards watershed of the corrected, with gabions and
gabion mattresses, parts (Kassandrino-Fourka-Fourka beach) (Fig. 2b.)
We calculated the conditions of the torrential environment (morphometry-relief, climate, geology,
vegetation). Specifically, we calculated the hypsometry of the watershed, the length of central bed,
the average slope of bed and watershed, the density of the hydrographic network, the degree of roundshape form, the form of relief and the orographic coefficient of the stream watershed (Moulopoulos
Chr. 1968, Tsakiris G. 1996, Kotoulas D. 2001, Pavlidis Th. 1998).
The maximum water-supplies, stereo-supplies and water-stereo-supplies of Fourka’s stream (total
and upper mountainous watershed Fig. 2a,b), were taken from the thesis of Pavlidis (Pavlidis V.
2012), with the maximum water-supply resulting from the equation of rational method (Equat. 1.1)
and the maximum stereo-supply by the formula of Stiny-Hercheulidze (1.2)
Rational method:
maxQ100=0,278*c*maxi100*F
Stiny – Hercheulidze: maxG100={Pn*m/Yn* (100-Pn)}*maxQ100
1.1
1.2
The gathering time tc was calculated by the formula of Giandotti (Equat. 1.3):
tc=[(4*F1/2)*(1,5Lk)] / [0,8*(Hm-Hmin)1/2]
1.3
Where: tc= time of gathering (hours)
maxQ100, maxG100=the maximum water-supply and stereo-supply (m3/s),
F=surface of watershed (Km2),
c=runoff coefficient,
maxi100=average intensity of rain of maximum rainfall with a duration equal to tc,
Hm, Hmin=average and minimum altitude of stream (m),
Lk=length of central bed (Km),
Pn, m, Yn=coefficients of inclination Pn, torrentiality m, special gravity of debris Yn
From the report «Study of immediate anti-flooding protection works in the area of the stream estuary
Fourka-Kassandrino», conducted by Gaia S.A. Projects in 2008, there have been taken the details of
the coated central bed of Fourka’s stream (Fig. 3). By in situ research it was measured the average
porous of the solid-stone-layer the average thickness of which was 1,40m.
The period 07.2009-06.2013, it was measured the alluvium of the coated bed (Photo 7b), the sandy
debris of which originated from the upwards watershed (Fig. 2b). The deposited debris load was
536
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
considered as equal to the sum of alluvium of the upwards non-coated bed and the bulk of the gaps
of the alluvial section of wire-made constructions. By the above alluvium it was resulted the average
annual alluvium of the period and was estimated the completion time of the total coated bed so that
the sand starts to flow towards the Fourka beach.
From the local people we gathered data of the loss of Fourka beach and the timeless changes after the
flood of 1990 and after the full coverage of the bed with stone-layers. From the collected data we
have approached the average annual abducted amount of sandy debris of the Fourka Beach and
estimated the course of its degradation for the required period up to the full alluvial process of wirelayers by the stream’s debris materials.
9. The research proceeded to the investigation of the activation potentials of the stream in respect of
moving sand towards the Fourka coast, before the full alluvium of stone-layers, so that Fourka Beach
is maintained at a tolerable level.
4.
RESULTS
4.1 CONDITIONS OF TORRENTIAL ENVIRONMENT
The results of the morphological-hydrographic research for Fourkas stream, the watershed and the
hydrographic network of which is given in Fig. 3, are shown in Table 1.
Table 1: Morphometric, hydrographic data of Fourka’s stream and its upper watershed (Fig.
2a,b)
Upper watershed of Fourka
Size Symbol Unit
Fourka
stream
1. Watershed surface F, Km2
25,30
36,94
2. Water-table perimeter Π, Km
24,01
31,61
3.Watershed hypsometry
i) maximum elevation Ηmax, m
350
350
ii) minimum elevation Ηmin, m
65
0
iii) average elevation Ηm, m
183
163
4. Watershed hydrography
i) length of central bed Lκ, Km
8,96
14,45
ii) average slope of central bed JLK, (%)
2,51
2,01
iii) density of hydrographic network (D=SL/F)
D,(Km/Km2)
3,28
3,22
5. Watershed relief
i) average slope of watershed, JF=(Hd*ΣS*100)/F JF,
(%)
26,34
26,64
ii) hypsometrical development ΔHi=Hi-Hmin
α) maximum (ΔHmax=Hmax-Hmin) ΔHmax, m
285,0
350,0
β) average (ΔHm=Hm-Hmin) ΔHm, m
117,6
163,4
iii) degree of relief (Αh =ΔH/SLκ)
α)maximum (Αhmax =ΔHmax/SLκ) Ahmax
34,46
26,53
β) average (Αhm =ΔHm/SLκ) Ahm
14,22
12,39
iv) round-formity degree
α) Gravelius index (ΚF=Π/ΠF=0,282Π/F1/2) ΚF
1,35
1,47
β) watershed form index (Jf=F/S2F) Jf
0,33
0,28
γ) circularity index (RF=4πF/Π2) RF
0,55
0,46
v) horographic coefficient (CF=H2/1000F)
α) maximum (CFmax=H2max/1000F) CFmax
4,84
3,32
β) average (CFm=H2m/1000F) CFm
1,32
0,72
537
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
The climate data of the stream were taken from the M.S. of Kassandria, a few kilometers away from
the center of watershed. The results from the research are shown hereunder in Table 2.
Table 2: Average monthly and average annual air temperatures and rain heights at the M.S.
of Kassandria-Halkidiki (period 1978-1990)
Ι
F
Μ
Α
Μ
J
J
Α
S
Ο
Ν
D
Year
Air temperatures oC
7,38 7,92 10,31 14,16 18,85 24,04 26,11 25,59 22,37 17,57 11,82 9,02 16,3
Rain height mm
60,5 60,4 54,6 40,1 32,3 20,5 20,5 22,1 24,6 77,4 92,3 96,5 601,7
By the results of the geology and vegetation of the under research area (Fig. 4b,c, Tab. 3, Photo 6), it
arises that the neo-genic formation is the dominant one whereas the flat area around the central bed
is dominated by the alluvial one (Fig. 4b). By Fig. 4c, Photo 6a,b and Table 3 it arises that the
dominant species around the Fourka’s stream are Aleppo Pine (P. halepensis) forests (59,4%)
followed by the farming lands with 11,67km2 (31,59%). The cultivated soils are vulnerable during
the stage of ploughing (Photo 2a) and become an ‘easy prey’ to strong rainfalls resulting to the large
transportation of sandy debris. Thus, it came out the alluvial-borne area downwards Kassandrino
village and the sand seashore of Fourka beach. On the contrary, the abandoned fields that were firmed
with natural herbaceous vegetation produce very small amounts of sand.
α
β
γ
Fig. 4abc: a) Hydrological map (the coated bed upwards of the watershed is colored green b)
Geological map and c) Vegetation map of watershed of Fourka’s stream.
Land
use
Table 3: Vegetation forms grown in Fourka’s stream watershed
Km2 %
Land use
Km2 %
Land use
Km2
Olive
2,36
orshards
Farms
6,40
Aleppo
pine
11,67 31,59 BareBarren
Soils
%
21,94 59,40 EvergreensBroadleaves
0,10
0,27
0,49
0,37
1.01
Total
1,33
Settlements
36,94 100,00
α
b
Photo 6ab: Forest a) evergreens-broadleaves and b) Aleppo pine (P. halepenesis)
538
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4.2 STREAM HYDROLOGY, DEBRIS MATERIAL, ALLUVIAL DEVELOPMENT
The maximum water-supply, stereo-supply and the gathering time tc, of the upper and total watershed
of Fourka’s stream, are as follows (Tables 4, 5).
Table 4: Maximum water-supplies (maxQ100) of the upper and total watershed of Fourka’s
stream (Fig. 4a) by the rational method (maxQ100=0,278*c*maxi100*F)
Watershed Surface F, Km2 c
maxi100 (mm/h) Maximum water-supply (maxQ100) (m3/s)
Upper
F1 =25,30
0,453 20,89
66,56
Total
F =36,50
0,428 19,40
84,25
Table 5: Gathering times tc, maximum stereo-supplies (maxG100) and water-stereo-supplies
{max(Q+G)100), of the upper and total watershed of Fourka’s stream
Gathering times tc=[4*(F)1/2+1,5Lk]/0,8(Hm-Hmin)1/2, maximum stereo-supplies (maxG100), and
water-stereo-supplies [max(Q+G)100], of the upper and total watershed of Fourka’s stream
F
Watershed Km2
Lk
Hm Hmin
(m) (m)
(km)
tc
Special (maxG100) max(Q+G)100
gravity
(m3/s)
3
Pn
m
(m
/s)
(m3/s)
Yn (t/m3)
maxQ100
(h)
Upper
25,30 183 65
8,96 3,862 66,56
20 1,01 2,34
7,18
73,74
Total
36,50 163 0,0 20,89 4,502 84,25
20 1,01 2,32
9,17
93,41
By the papers of Pavlidis Th. (Pavlidis Th. 1999a), Gaia S.A. Projects (2008) and Pavlidis V. (Pavlidis
V. 2012) and the conducted plotting, the following data in respect of the coated bed, were acquired
(Fig. 2ab and 3, Photo 5ab and 7ab):
Total length of coated plotted bed L=9.320m
Covered surface Ε=214.360m2
Average thickness of bottom solid-stone-layering Tx = 1,40m
Total bulk of bottom layering (it refers only to the bottom and not the slope) V= E .Tx = 214.360 x
1,40 = 300.104m3
Average porous stone-layer 32,80% (Pavlidis V. 2012)
Based on the above data, the porous state of the entire wire-stone-layer of the stream, amounts to:
ΣVporous= 300.104m3 x 0,328 = 98.434,11m3
Based on the alluvium of a) Εεπ.=6.840m2 (Photo 9b), the coated bed downwards the confluence of
the branches Kassandrino S. and the Εαν=16.250m2 (Photo 9a) of the non-coated section of
Kassandrino S. branch, it arises that the deposited debris for the under consideration 4-year period
(01.07.2009 – 31.06.2013), have alluvial a total bulk amounting to:
Bulk of alluviums upwards of the non-coated alluvial bed:
Vnon-coated = Εαν.x hnon-coated = 16,250 x 0,34= 5.525,00m3
Bulk of alluviums in the coated alluvial surface:
Vcoated = Εεπ x hcoated = 6.840 x (0,32 x 1,40) = 3.064,32m3
Total alluvial bulk of a 4-year period:
ΣV=Vαν+Vεπ=5.525+3.064,32=8.589,32m3
539
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
Therefore, the average arrived bulk during the 4-year period 01.07.2009 – 31.06.2013, from the
watersheds of the branches Zografitiko S. and Kassandrino S., amounts to:
Vm (4-year period) = 8.589,32/4= 2.147,33m3/year
This amount produced by a surface F=25,30Km2 (branches Kassandrinos S. And Zografitiko S.),
conversed to an average annual deposited load of debris in this location, amounts to:
w=2.147,33/25,30=84,875m3/Km/year. This load corresponds to an average annual arrived (not
produced) to the measuring location downgrading amount wΤ= 84,875mm/year.
α
β
Photo 7ab: Views of depositions a) of non-coated and b) coated bed. The non-coated bed
upwards of the coated one was paved later in 2013-2014).
By the acceptance that the average annual amount of debris of wΤ=84,875m3/Km/year constitutes the
average annual amount of the total surface F=36,50Km2 of the stream’s watershed, the average annual
arriving and deposited amount of debris into the central bed of the stream, amounts to:
W = wΤ x F = 84,875 x 36,50 = 3.097,93m3/year
By the average annual adducing amount of debris of 2.654,65m3/year and the total bulk of porous of
the wirenet-stone-coated bed which was found to be equal to:
Vporous=98.434,11m3
It arises that the full alluvium of the porous of wirenet-stone-coated central bed of the stream will
take place at a time:
Τ= 98.434,11m3 / 3.097,93m3/year = 31,774= 31,8 years
5.
CONCLUSIONS, PROPOSALS
Briefly, the results of the research, are as follows:
The Fourka’s torrent is considered as the most dangerous stream in the Kassandra peninsula with a
rich flooding background. Within the frames of providing anti-flood correction, the entire bed of the
stream was paved from the point of Kassandrino up to Fourka Beach at a length L=9.320m. A major
characteristic of the torrent is the big moving-out sand stereo-supply which contributes to the flooding
riskiness of the stream and arriving to the discharge place of the stream that has shaped the Fourka’s
sandy Beach. A physical phenomenon which constitutes the main cause of the tourist development
of the area.
The Fourka Beach is the functional print of two opposite acting mechanisms, one depositional
(Fourka stream) and one carrying-away (coastal transporting with S, SE movement). Until the
decrease of cultivated lands in 1970, which through the ploughing have provided great amounts of
sand that were transported by the stream and deposited on Fourka Beach, the adduction of sand was
much bigger than the abduction, with a slightly positive balance, resulting to a very slow but steady
increase of the beach. After 1970 and mostly after the coating of the torrent’s bed with gabions and
540
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
gabion mattresses, the porous of which are much bigger, than the biggest of the average transported
sandy debris, has led to the discontinuance of sand movement towards the beach, a process which
will last as much as the completion time of gaps of the layer of gabion mattresses. Due to this fact,
for that time span in the beach will only act the abducting, carrying-away mechanism, leading to the
downgrading of Fourka Beach.
During the 4-year period 01.07.2009 – 30.06.2013, the measured alluvium V4-year period=8.589,32m3,
after the bed coating, produces an average alluvium W=2.147,33m3/year. Based on this figure, the
full alluvium of the porous of gabions will occur in 32 years. Therefore, only the carrying-away
coastal mechanism will be function for this time span and Fourka beach will be put into a steady
downgrading process. As confirmation of the above stated, we report the recent significant loss
of Fourka beach westwards of the stream junction.
To encounter this problem the following are proposed:
The compulsory ploughing of the cultivated lands. This measure, aims at the increase of the produced
and incoming, to the central stream bed, debris amount.
The stirring up of sandy beds and slopes of central beds of contributing branches particularly of those
closer to Fourka Beach.
The disclosure – stirring up – broadening of slopes of the stream bed nearest to the stream estuary.
The broadening, beyond the starting of sand flow towards the beach, will be aiming at the
improvement of the anti-flood protection of the area.
The construction of sand-hold projections (Groynes) at the beach which will prevent the abduction
of sand from Fourka Beach.
REFERENCES
1. Cadenas Lοpez, 1993: «Torrent control and streambed stabilization», Food and Agriculture
Organization of the United Nations, Italy
2. Chow, V.T. (ed.). (1964): «Handbook of Hydrology», New York.
3. Gregory, K.J. and Walling, Ο. (1983): «Drainage Basin. Form and Process. Α.
Geomorphological Approach», Fletcher and Son L TD, Norwich. U.K.
4. Horton, R.E. 1945: «Erosional development of streams and their drainage basins: Hydrological
Approach to quatitative morphology», Bull of the Geol. Soc. Am., 56: 275-370.
5. Kirkby, M.J. and R.P.C. Morgan. 1980: «Soil erosion», John Willey and Sons.
6. Murphy, J., Wallace, Ο. and Lane, L. (1977). Geomorphic Parameters: Predict Hydrographic
Characteristics in the Southwest. Water Res. BuI. Am. Water. Res. Ass. νοl. 13(1), pp. 25-38.
7. HMGS., Ι.G.Μ.R.: Maps of scale 1:50.000: Sheet “Kassandreia “
8. Gaia S.A. Projects 2008: «Study of immediate anti-flooding protection works in the area of the
stream estuary Fourka-Kassandrino», Thessaloniki
9. Kotoulas D. 2001: «Mountainous Hydronomics, Vol. 1: ‘Flowing waters’», Thessaloniki
10. Margaropoulos P. 1963: «The aquatic erosion and the torrential phenomenon». Athens
11. Margaropoulos P. 1964:
FAO/EFC/TORR/64/2.
«Rapport
sur
la
classification
des
basins
torrentiels»,
12. Moulopoulos, Chr. 1968: «Mountainous Hydronomics», Thessaloniki
13. Pavlidis, Th. 1991: «Analysis of the flood action mechanism of Fourka’s stream and its correction
system under the prism of the recent flood of December 1990» Scient. Annals of School of
Forestry and Nat. Environ., Vol. ΛΛ/1, No. 24, pp. 664-720.
541
Protection and restoration of coastal zone and open sea waters
14. Pavlidis T.V., Emmanouloudis O. A., Rodriguez J.L., Filippidis E. I. “Analysis and Interpretation
of the flοοd Activity Mechanism of the Fourka Chalkidiki Torrent”, GREECE/SPAIN
15. Pavlidis Th. 1999a: «Study of utilizing the water dynamics and the debris material of Fourka’s
stream within the frames of managing the water and flood problems of Kassandreia Municipality,
Halkidiki». Thessaloniki. Study implemented for Fourka’s community.
16. Pavlidis Th. 1999b: «Study of correction-delimitation of Fourka’s stream», Thessaloniki. Study
implemented for Fourka’s community.
17. Pavlidis, Th. 2007: «Mountainous Hydronomics ΙΙ». Thessaloniki.
18. Pavlidis V. 2012: «Stream corrections at coastal areas within the Greek space: The case of
Fourka’s stream, Halkidiki». Thesis submitted to the Faculty of Civil Engineering, Aristotle
University, Thessaloniki
19. Tsakiris G. 1995: ‘Aquatic Resources, Technical Hydrology’, Athens
542
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Environmental hydrology
543
Environmental hydrology
544
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
COMPARISON OF METEOROLOGICAL DROUGHT INDICES IN
THESSALY WATER DEPARTMENT, GREECE
T. Karampatakis, L. Vasiliades* and A. Loukas
Laboratory of Hydrology and Aquatic Systems Analysis, Dept. of Civil Engineering, University of
Thessaly (UTH), GR- 38334 Volos, Thessaly, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: lvassil@civ.uth.gr, tel : +302421074115
Abstract
In an effort to capture various aspects of drought which contribute to the intensification of the
phenomenon, many indices have been suggested, based on one or more hydro-climatic parameters.
In this paper the behavior of four meteorological drought indices with different structure is discussed,
analyzing the spatial and temporal characteristics of drought in the water department of Thessaly.
More specifically the widely used indices: Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI), Standardized
Precipitation-Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI), and two modified multivariate indices based on the
Multivariate Standardized Drought Index (MSDI), are selected for a comparative regional drought
analysis. The first multivariate index is derived combining probabilistically the hydro-climatic
variables of precipitation and potential evapotranspiration, – while the second combining the indices
SPI and SPEI. The monthly precipitation and temperature data, covering the hydrological period
1960-2002, were used for the calculation of the considered indices at time scales: 1, 3, 6, 9 and 12
months. In order to obtain equal amount of precipitation and temperature data, the lapse rate method
is applied, forming 78 meteorological stations. A time-series analysis and a drought classification for
all the stations are performed, presenting the main similarities/differences in the behavior of four
indices. Additionally, a correlation analysis is conducted, displaying scatter plots and spatial patterns
of correlation values for the possible combinations of the examined indices. SPI and SPEI seem to be
the most appropriate indices for the detection of drought episodes in our region. Furthermore, it was
ascertained that the indices SPI and SPEI are more strongly correlated in the mountainous regions
where the influence of the potential evapotranspiration is not so noticeable.
Keywords: Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI), Standardized Precipitation-Evapotranspiration
Index (SPEI), Multivariate Drought Indices; Drought Variability, Thessaly Water Department
1.
INTRODUCTION
Several meteorological drought indices have been proposed based on the hydro-climatic variable of
precipitation. An illustration of this classification is the Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI; McKee
et al., 1993) which is acclaimed by an increasing number of scientists around the world and has been
recommended by the World Meteorological Organization as the primary tool for monitoring
meteorological droughts (WMO 2006). However, in some cases a single variable may not provide
adequate information for the assessment of droughts because droughts constitute a complex process
associated with multiple variables. Thus, apart from precipitation the parameter of temperature can
be included in a meteorological drought assessment. This approach is great significance especially
for studies related to climate change, as the indications of climate models for warmer climate
conditions in the future can affect considerably the drought characteristics (intensity, duration,
frequency, spatial extent) (Sheffield and Wood, 2008; Dai, 2013; Touma et al., 2015). The first
attempt was made in 1965 when the Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI; Palmer, 1965) was
545
Environmental hydrology
developed and its original purpose was to identify drought conditions in the crop-producing regions
of the United States. Recently, Vicente-Serrano et al. (2010) proposed the Standardized Precipitation
Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI; Vicente-Serrano et al., 2010) as an enhanced version of SPI,
introducing a simplified mode of water balance concept (Precipitation minus Potential
Evapotranspiration) in order to examine the effect of temperature on drought analysis. Finally,
according to Hao and AghaKouchak (2013, 2014) it is pointed out that “no of the existing single
indices is able to identify all aspects of meteorological, agricultural, and hydrological droughts”.
Consequently, a new multivariate approach based on the combination of several drought indices and
variables should be conducted for an overall drought assessment. In this view, they suggested the
Multivariate Standardized Drought Index (MSDI; Hao and AghaKouchak, 2013), which has the
capacity to combine the drought information not only from different drought-related variables, but
from different drought indices as well. The incorporation of different drought related variables and
indices can lead to more reliable and timely findings for the drought characteristics (Hao and
AghaKouchak 2013, 2014).
Main scope of this study is to examine the behaviour of four meteorological indices with different
structure taking into account the drought-related variables of precipitation and potential
evapotranspiration (PET). It should be mentioned that the selection of these indices was encouraged
considering their multi-temporal nature and their similar probabilistic procedure. More specifically,
the identification of drought events in the water department of Thessaly is attempted using the
commonly used index SPI, the more recent index SPEI, and two produced multivariate indices
motivated by the new promising index MSDI. It is highlighted that the first produced multivariate
model is estimated through constructing the joint distribution function of two meteorological
variables (precipitation and PET), while the second it is formed through constructing the joint
distribution function of two meteorological drought indices (SPI and SPEI). The major aim of this
multivariate synthesis is to extend the properties of MSDI concept, examining different combinations
of climate variables-indices from the original index, purposing to obtain two effective meteorological
drought measures, which can be used as supplementary tools in drought monitoring process. In order
to assess the short and medium term drought conditions, the four indices were calculated at time
scales: 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months.
2.
STUDY AREA – DATABASE
The study area of this research is the water department of Thessaly, Greece. It is located in the central
department of the mainland of Greece forming the greatest plain of the country which is also known
for the intense agricultural activity. It is surrounded by large mountainous masses, among which
Mount Olympus, rising to over than 2800 m, situated at the northern part of the plain. In the west,
there is the Pindus mountain range which is approximately 230 km long and reaches a width of over
70 km. Mountains Kissavos and Pelion are located in the east. In the south, there is the Othrys
mountain range. The total acreage of the region is 13377 km2 while the average elevation is estimated
at 500 m above sea level. As far as the climate of the area is concerned, two different areas can be
distinguished namely the coastal (lowland) eastern side of Thessaly with a Mediterranean climate,
which is characterized by warm and dry summers and cold and humid winters, – and the mountainous
western side, with a typical continental climate with great temperature variations between summer
and winter time. The average precipitation is relatively high in the west, more than 1850 mm, and
decreases in the plain region by 400 mm. The main drainage basin of the hydrological department of
Thessaly is the basin of the river Pinios which extends across an area of about 9500 km2. Smaller
tributaries are also included in the hydrological department.
The available precipitation and temperature data of the region were provided by the Laboratory of
Hydrology and Aquatic Systems Analysis of the University of Thessaly (Department of Civil
Engineering) and cover 42 hydrological years, from October 1960 to September 2002. Specifically,
546
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
the monthly precipitation data from 78 precipitation stations uniformly distributed over the water
department of Thessaly (Figure 1) have been used for the calculation of SPI.
Figure 1: Location and elevation of precipitation stations of Thessaly Water Department
In this project except for precipitation data, the inclusion of temperature data at the same positions of
precipitation stations must be considered for the estimation of PET and therefore of SPEI. Monthly
temperature data can be derived using the temperature lapse rate method, as there is a limited number
of meteorological stations at the desirable locations (locations of precipitation gauges). This method
relied on the assumption that temperature decreases linearly with increasing altitude. Based on this
assumption, a linear regression line can be fitted to the mean annual temperature data of the available
meteorological stations of Thessaly (Figure 2).
Figure 2: Linear regression of mean annual temperature for 26 meteorological stations in
Thessaly
3.
METHODOLOGY
The four examined meteorological drought indices of this study are differentiated in their structure,
incorporating the drought related variables, precipitation and PET in a unique way, defining the
different purpose of their formation on drought assessment. However they share some similar
characteristics, as the statistical approach of SPEI and MSDI relied on the tenable advantages of SPI
as analyzed by Hayes et al. (1999). Therefore, the four meteorological drought indices can be
standardized into normal variables, presenting the dry and the wet events in a similar way ensuring
547
Environmental hydrology
their interpretability over space and time. Positive values (above the average) of the indices depict
the wet conditions while negative indications (below the average) represent the intensity of drought
episodes. Furthermore they can be calculated at multiple time scales (1, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months),
examining the drought evolution among the various hydrological subsystems. Finally, they are simple
in their calculation, as in our case only precipitation and temperature data are required.
The computation of SPI (McKee et al., 1993) involves the accumulation of precipitation records for
each station, considering a predefined time step (usually over n months), and their fitting to the
gamma probability distribution which is then transformed into the standardized normal distribution
with mean 0 and standard deviation 1. The gamma distribution is defined by its frequency or
probability density function as:
𝑥
1
𝑔(𝑥) = 𝛽𝛼 Γ(α)
−
𝑥 𝛼−1 𝑒 𝛽
𝑓𝑜𝑟 𝑥 > 0
(1)
where 𝛼 and 𝛽 stand for shape and scale parameters respectively, 𝑥 describes the amount of
precipitation, and 𝛤(𝛼) is the gamma function.
Since the gamma distribution is undefined for x=0, a modified expression of the gamma cumulative
probability can be applied, solving the problem with the possible zero values in our monthly
precipitation data.
𝛨(𝑥) = 𝑞 + (1 − 𝑞)𝐺(𝑥)
(2)
where 𝑞 is the probability of no precipitation and 𝐺(𝑥) the cumulative probability of the incomplete
gamma function.
The more recently proposed index SPEI (Vicente-Serrano et al., 2010) was developed based on the
methodology of SPI, following similar computational processes. Therefore SPEI values can be
derived, adapting the accumulated monthly (or weekly) water balance (Precipitation minus Potential
Evapotranspiration), into a parametric statistical distribution, taking into account a fixed desired
period (time scale).The three parameter Log-logistic has been used for the normalization of SPEI
considering that it is possible to have negative values, as the applicability of the index is related with
the identification of moisture deficit (Precipitation < PET).The probability density function of a three
parameter Log-logistic distributed variable is expressed as:
𝛽 𝑥−𝛾 𝛽−1
𝑓(𝑥) = 𝛼 (
𝛼
)
−2
𝑥−𝛾 𝛽
(1 + (
𝛼
) )
(3)
where 𝛼, 𝛽 and 𝛾 represent the scale, shape and origin parameters respectively, for the accumulated
water balance 𝑥, in the range (𝛾 > 𝑥 < ∞).The estimation of monthly PET series has been conducted
using the Thornthwaite equation (Thornthwaite, 1948) as it only demands the temperature and the
latitudinal coordinate of the location.
The nonparametric method as proposed by Hao and AghaKouchak (2014) has been selected in order
to derive two multivariate models based on the available data (precipitation and temperature) of our
study area. According to this multivariate approach, a nonparametric empirical method expressed by
Weibull (Hirsch, 1981) or by Gringorten (Gringorten, 1963) plotting position formula, can be applied
in order to obtain the empirical joint probability of drought-related variables (or indices). Hence,
denoting the drought-related variables, precipitation and PET, as two random variables X and Y
respectively at a specific time scale, the empirical joint probability of the variables (𝑥𝑘 , 𝑦𝑘 ) can be
calculated as:
𝑚
𝑘
𝑃(𝑥𝑘 , 𝑦𝑘 ) = 𝑛+1
Weibull (Hirsch, 1981)
(4)
where 𝑛 is the number of the observation, and 𝑚𝑘 is the number of occurrences of the pair (𝑥𝑖, 𝑦𝑖 )
for 𝑥𝑖 ≤ 𝑥𝑘 and 𝑦𝑖 ≤ 𝑦𝑘, (1 ≤ 𝑖 ≤ 𝑛).
548
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
As the empirical joint probability of the drought-related variables, precipitation and PET, has been
estimated, the multivariate standardized drought model MSDI(Pr-PET) is formed according to the
following equation:
𝑀𝑆𝐷𝐼 = 𝛷−1 (𝑃)
(5)
where 𝜑 is the standard normal distribution function. Following the same procedure as described by
the equations (4) and (5) for the drought indices SPI and SPEI, the second multivariate standardized
model MSDI(SPI-SPEI) is derived.
In this study, a correlation analysis, is performed among the indices: SPI, SPEI, MSDI(Pr-PET) and
MSDI(SPI-SPEI), at time scales: 1, 3, 6, 9 and 12. Main purpose of this analysis is to conduct a more
integrated comparison among the indices providing scatter plots with their possible combinations at
all time scales. The Pearson correlation coefficient 𝑟 has been used as a statistical measure in order
to express the linear dependence among them. Furthermore, the Ordinary Kriging (OK) as an
effective interpolation method (Best Linear Unbiased Estimator, BLUE) Isaaks and Srivastava (1989)
has been selected, providing a spatial insight of these correlations in the water department of Thessaly,
at all time scales. Ordinary Kriging, as a geostatistical technique, differs from other spatial
interpolation methods such as IDW (Inverse Distance Weighting) method, considering not only the
distance between the sample points and the prediction location, but also the spatial covariance
structure (autocorrelation) of the sample points.
A general equation of Ordinary Kriging method can be determined as:
1
𝑧̂ (𝑥0 ) = 2𝑛 ∑𝑛𝑖=1 𝜆𝑖 𝑧(𝑥i )
(6)
where 𝑧̂ (𝑥0 ) is the value to be estimated at location 𝑥0 , 𝑧(𝑥i ) is the measured value at station 𝑥i , 𝜆𝑖
represents the weight of the measured value 𝑧(𝑥i ) at the 𝑖 𝑡ℎ station, and 𝑛 is the number of measured
values.The spatial dependence (autocorrelation) of the sample points is determined by fitting an
experimental semivariogram. An experimental semivariogram 𝛾(h) can be defined as half the average
squared difference between two neighbouring points:Ζ(𝑥i ), Ζ(𝑥i + h), separated by the distance h
(Goovaerts, 2000):
1
𝑛
𝛾̂(h) = 2𝑛 ∑𝑖=1[Ζ(𝑥i ) − Ζ(𝑥i + h)]2
4.
(7)
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Τhe results from station-2 which is located in the northwest side of Thessaly (Figure 1), will be used
indicatively for illustration purposes, analyzing the basic similarities/differences of SPI, SPEI,
MSDI(Pr-PET) and MSDI(SPI-SPEI) series at the examined time scales (1, 3, 6, 9 and 12). It should
be pointed out that it was considered appropriate a shorter period of time than the initial to be used,
in order to achieve best clarification of the results. Thus, the presentation of the results is conducted
during the hydrological period: October 1982 - September 2002. Concerning the results of station-2
(Figure 3), the monthly patterns of indices SPI, SPEI, MSDI(SPI-SPEI) seem to be quite similar at
all time scales. Therefore, they can be characterized as 3 highly correlated indices, providing a similar
behavior for the short and medium term drought conditions of the station. On the contrary, the
MSDI(Pr-PET), differs significantly from the other indices and appears to be biased in negative
values at all time scales. Regarding the results of the widely used indices SPI, SPEI, and the outcomes
of the research of Loukas and Vasiliades (2004), which were based on the average SPI values for the
period of time from 1960 to 1993 in Thessaly, the results of the index MSDI(Pr-PET) can be
characterized as overrated and abnormal for the region, showing several prolonged drought episodes.
Examining the effectiveness of the measures SPI, SPEI and MSDI(SPI-SPEI) in detecting the extreme
drought events (≤-2.0), of station-2, SPI and SPEI seem to be the more capable indices to capture
these extreme conditions, while the multivariate model MSDI(SPI-SPEI) limited to identify only
549
Environmental hydrology
severe drought episodes (-1.5 to -1.99), at all time scales. Specifically, at time scale (1), the most
extreme drought episode has been determined by the SPEI index (mid of 90s). As the time scale
increases (time scales: 3, 6, 9 and 12) and more smoothed patterns of temporal variability can be
derived, the most extreme drought events have been identified by the SPI index (early of 90s). It is
essential to underline once more, that the results above are suggestive and consequently the last
indication about the indices SPI and SPEI is distinctive for station-2, and does not represent the results
of the rest stations. For example, in stations where remarkable upward trends of temperature were
recorded, the most severe drought episodes in longer time scales have been identified by the SPEI
index.
Figure 3: Station-2 (Direction:Northwest, Elevation:586m). Time-series plots of drought
indices SPI (blue line), SPEI (red line), MSDI(Pr-PET) (grey line), MSDI(SPI-SPEI) (green
line), for 20 hydrological years (October 1982-September2002), at time scales: 1, 3, 6, 9 and 12
months.
A drought classification for 42 hydrological years has been performed, taking into account the results
of four indices, for all the stations, at all time scales. This classification involves the categories:
Extreme Drought (≤-2.0), Severe Drought (-1.5 to -1.99), Moderate Drought (-1.0 to -1.49), Normal
(-0.99 to 0.99), Moderately Wet (1.0 to 1.49), Severely Wet (1.5 to 1.99) and Extremely Wet (≥2.0)
conditions. In Table 2 are provided suggestively, the percentages of drought and rainfall events as
detected by the four examined indices, at all time scales, for the station-2. Analyzing the outcomes
related to the drought episodes of station-2, the similar behavior of indices SPI and SPEI can be
ascertained in this study for a second time. More specifically, the indices SPI and SPEI seem to have
similar results in each of the three categories of drought (slightly more increased are the percentages
of SPEI in the categories Moderate and Severe Drought, in most of the stations). In contrast, the
MSDI(Pr-PET) differs significantly in the number of moderate and severe drought events compared
to the other indices, accumulating higher rates in these categories. Moreover, it fails to detect extreme
drought episodes at all time scales (similar behavior at all stations). Therefore, the choice of the
variables of precipitation and PET for the formation of a competent drought index through a joint
distribution concept, does not infer the desirable results. Finally, the ΜSDI(SPI-SPEI) index shows
similar outcomes compared with SPEI index in the categories of Moderate Drought and Severe
Drought. Furthermore, it should be highlighted that in this case as well, the weakness of the
550
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
multivariate model to capture the extreme drought conditions of the station is obvious (also 0 values
at all stations in this category).
Table 2: Station-2 (Direction: Northwest, Elevation: 586m). Drought classification for 42
hydrological years (October 1960 - September 2002), providing the percentages of drought
events for indices: SPI, SPEI, MSDI(Pr PET), MSDI(SPI-SPEI), at time scales:1, 3, 6, 9 and
12 months.
In Figure 4, the scatter plots among the indices of station-2 (Northwest) are indicatively presented.
Similar results have been observed at all time scales for the 78 stations of the region. According to
the results of station-2, the standardized indices SPI and SPEI, appear significantly correlated at all
time scales. Furthermore, it is observed that as the time scale increases, the correlation between the
indices SPI and SPEI becomes stronger and therefore a perfect correlation can be accomplished. This
is reasonable, as in longer time scales the effect of PET is limited considerably, while for the
parameter of precipitation this is no true. Concerning the results of the MSDI(Pr-PET), the
unconformity of the multivariate model with the other indices can be determined. Specifically,
considerably lower correlation values (moderately to extremely low for most of the stations)
compared to the other indices at all time scales, are presented for all the possible combinations of the
model, indicating that the MSDI(Pr-PET) differs significantly from the indices SPI, SPEI and
MSDI(SPI-SPEI). The small number of correlated observations as was observed for several stations,
in each pair of MSDI(Pr-PET), can be explained by the tendency of model to approach many negative
values as described in subsection 4.1. Finally, the MSDI(SPI-SPEI) appears to be notably correlated
551
Environmental hydrology
with the indices SPI and SPEI, at all time scales. This can be explained by the fact that the multivariate
model has been structured, combining the drought information of two strong interrelated indices (SPI
and SPEI), ensuring highly correlated values for the pairs, MSDI(SPI-SPEI):SPI and MSDI(SPISPEI):SPEI.
Figure 4: Cross correlation among the indices: SPI, ,SPEI, MSDI(Pr-PET), MSDI(SPI-SPEI)
for time scales: (a) 1-month, (b) 3-month, (c) 6-month, (d) 9-month, and (e) 12-month
Subsequently, the spatiotemporal correlation distribution for each pair of the analyzed indices will be
discussed. Figure 5a shows the spatial patterns of Thessaly between SPI and SPEI. The results suggest
a strong correlation between these indices at all time scales (𝑟 ≥ 0.75), as expected. A remarkable
characteristic of these patterns is that the western region which is characterized as mountainous seems
to be more correlated than the central and eastern sides (plain areas) where many stations with lower
elevation are located (Figure 1). This can be explained by the fact that the effect of PET in
mountainous regions compared to the plain areas is lower, signifying that the indices SPI and SPEI
respond mainly to the fluctuations of precipitation, and therefore more correlated values can be
obtained for them. Paulo et al. (2012) presented a similar behavior for both indices at time scales (9)
and (12), comparing humid and semiarid environments in Portugal. Furthermore, it is important to
reiterate again that the PET variability decreases in longer time scales. Hence, the most correlated
patterns for these indices have been derived at time scales 6, 9, and 12, while in shorter time scales,
weaker correlation values have been extracted, verifying the above claim. It should be noted that the
correlations values at time scales: 9 and 12 compared to the 6-month timescale, appeared slightly
lower. According to Vicente-Serrano et al. (2010) the correlation between the two indices may
decrease in longer time scales when there are noticeable temporal trends in temperature. Regarding
the results of the MSDI(SPI-SPEI):MSDI(Pr-PET), moderately to extremely low correlation values
predominate in all maps, at all time scales (𝑟 ≤ 0.72) (Figure 5b). The limited number of correlated
observations between the two multivariate models can be explained by the fact, that the MSDI(SPISPEI) seems to be in accordance (similar patterns) with the widely used indices SPI and SPEI, while
the second model which is based on the combination of two hydro-climatic variables (precipitation,
PET) is differentiated considerably.
552
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 5: Spatial patterns of Thessaly, providing the correlation coefficient values between the
indices: a) SPI-SPEI, b) MSDI(SPI-SPEI)-MSDI(Pr-PET), at all time scales (1, 3, 6, 9, 12
months)
However, it is notable to mention that the MSDI(SPI-SPEI) seems to response slightly better with the
SPEI index, indicating more correlated values in northern and eastern regions. The highest correlated
patterns for the two observed pairs have been detected at longer time scales (9-month and 12-month).
Examining the correlation strength of the multivariate model MSDI(Pr-PET) with the indices SPI and
SPEI, moderately to extremely low correlation values seem to prevail in both cases, at all time scales
(a: 𝑟 ≤ 0.72, b: 𝑟 ≤ 0.67) for all the stations in the water department of Thessaly.
5.
CONCLUSIONS
The main objective of this study was to examine the effectiveness of four meteorological drought
indices with different structure, detecting the drought events in the water department of Thessaly.
Specifically, the recommended index SPI, its increased version SPEI, and two multivariate models
which combine probabilistically two hydro-climatic variables (precipitation and PET) and two
drought indices (SPI and SPEI) respectively, have been used for the drought analysis of the area. The
time-series analysis and the drought classification for each station showed that the indices SPI and
SPEI represent the most suitable measures for the drought monitoring of the region, appearing similar
patterns and similar rates in each category of drought events. Small differences between them have
been identified in stations where significant increased temperature values were noted, strengthening
the ability of SPEI index in the detection of the most severe drought events relative to SPI. Examining
the results of the two multivariate models, the MSDI(Pr-PET) appeared to be biased in negative
values, overestimating the number of moderate and severe drought episodes of the region compared
to the other indices. On the other hand, the second multivariate model MSDI(SPI-SPEI) was found
to be in consistency with the widely used indices SPI and SPEI, displaying similar patterns at all time
scales. Furthermore, it was shown the weakness of the two produced multivariate indices to determine
the extreme drought conditions of the region. A more comprehensive comparison among the indices
was conducted examining their linear dependence, and providing the spatiotemporal distribution of
correlation values, for all the possible combinations of the indices. The results suggested a strong
correlation between SPI and SPEI at all time scales. Also the discordance of MSDI(Pr-PET) with the
other indices was confirmed again presenting in several stations moderately to extremely low
correlation values, while the second multivariate model appeared highly correlated with the
interrelated indices SPI and SPEI. Moreover, it was observed that in mountainous areas (west side)
where the effect of potential evapotranspiration it is not significant, the indices SPI and SPEI appeared
to have more correlated coefficient values compared to the plain areas (central side). This means that
the two indices in high-altitude regions respond mainly to the variations of precipitation. Additionally,
553
Environmental hydrology
it should be noted that the weakest correlation values were presented at time scales: 1 and 3, indicating
the importance of PET in the short term drought conditions.
References
1. Dai A. (2013). ‘Increasing drought under global warming in observations and models’. Nature
Climate Change, 3, pp. 52-58.
2. Goovaerts P. (2000). ‘Geostatistical approaches for incorporating elevation into the spatial
interpolation of rainfall’. Journal of Hydrology, 228(1), pp. 113-129.
3. Gringorten I.I. (1963). ‘A plotting rule for extreme probability paper’. Journal of Geophysical
Research, 68(3), pp. 813-814.
4. Hao Z. and A. AghaKouchak. (2013). ‘Multivariate standardized drought index: a parametric
multi-index model’. Advances in Water Resources, 57, pp. 12-18.
5. Hao Z. and A. AghaKouchak. (2014). ‘A nonparametric multivariate multi-index drought
monitoring framework’. Journal of Hydrometeorology, 15(1), pp. 89-101.
6. Hayes M.J., M.D. Svoboda, D.A. Wilhite, and O.V. Vanyarkho. (1999). ‘Monitoring the 1996
drought using the standardized precipitation index’. Bulletin of the American Meteorological
Society, 80, pp. 429-438.
7. Isaaks E.H. and R.M. Srivastava. (1989). ‘An introduction to applied geostatisics’. Oxford
University Press, New York.
8. Loukas A. and L. Vasiliades. (2004). ‘Probabilistic analysis of drought spatiotemporal
characteristics in Thessaly region, Greece’. Natural Hazards and Earth System Science, 4(5/6),
pp. 719-731.
9. McKee T.B., N.J. Doesken and J. Kleist. (1993). ‘The relationship of drought frequency and
duration to time scales’. Proceedings of the 8th Conference on Applied Climatology, 17–22
January, Anaheim, CA, American Meterological Society, Boston, MA, pp. 179–184.
10. Palmer W.C. (1965). ‘Meteorological drought’. Weather Bureau Research Paper No 45, US
Department of Commerce, Washington, DC.
11. Paulo A., R. Rosa, and L. Pereira. (2012). ‘Climate trends and behaviour of drought indices based
on precipitation and evapotranspiration in Portugal’. Natural Hazards and Earth Systems
Sciences, 12 pp. 1481-1491.
12. Shieffield J. and E.F. Wood. (2008). ‘Projected changes in drought occurred under future global
warming from multi-model, multi-scenario, IPCC AR4 simulations’. Climate Dynamics, 31, pp.
79-105.
13. Thornthwaite C.W. (1948). ‘An approach toward a rational classification of climate’.
Geographical Review, 38(1), pp.55-94.
14. Touma D., M. Ashfaq, M.A. Nayak, S.C. Kao, and N.S. Diffenbaugh. (2015). ‘A multi-model
and multi-index evaluation of drought characteristics in the 21st century’. Journal of Hydrology,
526, pp.196-207.
15. Vicente-Serrano S.M., S. Beguería and J.I. López-Moreno. (2010). ‘A multiscalar drought index
sensitive to global warming: The Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index’. Journal
of Climate, 23(7), pp.1696-1718.
16. WMO. (2006). ‘Drought monitoring and early warning: concepts, progress and future
challenges’. WMO-No. 1006, World Meteorological Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
554
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
RAINFALL TEMPORAL DISTRIBUTION IN THRACE BY
MEANS OF AN UNSUPERVISED MACHINE LEARNING
METHOD
K. Vantas, E. Sidiropoulos* and M. Vafeiadis
Faculty of Engineering Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia,
Greece
*
Corresponding author e-mail: nontas@topo.auth.gr
Abstract
An unsupervised method that utilizes a combination of statistical and machine learning techniques is
presented in order to classify statistically independent rainstorm events and create a limited number
of design hyetographs for the Water Division of Thrace in Greece. The whole process includes the
necessary steps from importing raw precipitation time series data to producing the initially unknown
optimal number of representative design hyetographs. These hyetographs can be used for stochastic
simulation, water resources planning, water quality assessment and global change studying. The
present type of analysis is applied for the first time on data from a Greek region and, in addition, it
presents certain characteristics of a more general applicability. Namely, the method employed is fully
unsupervised, as no empirical knowledge of local rainfalls is implicated or any arbitrary introduction
of quartiles for grouping. Also, the critical time duration of no precipitation between rainstorm events
is not defined in advance, as is the case in the pertinent literature.
Keywords: Rainfall temporal distribution; design hyetographs; unsupervised machine learning;
hierarchical clustering; Principal Components Analysis
1.
INTRODUCTION
Knowledge about the temporal distribution of rainfall is essential in current methods of water
resources management such as drainage design, erosion control, water quality assessment and global
change studies. A typical methodology includes the determination of total duration and height of
rainfall and disaggregation of this height using a temporal pattern that represents the expected internal
rainfall structure, the design hyetograph (DH). Veneciano and Villani (1999) provided categorization
of methods for the production of design hyetographs, distinguishing four types. The first two methods
are based on intensity-duration-frequency curves, the third method is based on standardized profiles
derived from rainfall records and the last method relies on stochastic rainfall models via simulation.
The first three methods are used more frequently.
Huff (1967) presented a probabilistic method, in which storm data are classified using the quartile
where the maximum intensity occurs. More details about the development and utility of Huff’s curves
in disaggregation and stochastic simulation can be found in the literature (Bonta and Rao, 1987; Bonta
and Shahalam, 2003; Bonta, 2004a, 2004b; Vandenberghe et al., 2010). A necessary step prior to the
construction of Huff’s curves is the extraction of individual rainstorm events from precipitation time
series. Huff used a six-hour fixed Critical time Duration (CD) of no precipitation to separate these
events, and many researchers followed the same approach (Loukas and Quick, 1996; Williams-Sether
et al., 2004; Azli and Rao, 2010; Dolšak et al., 2016), although Bonta (2001) showed that CD has
555
Environmental hydrology
seasonal variability. The determination of rainfall temporal distribution is dealt with in this paper by
means of machine learning methods.
Applications of machine learning using hydro-meteorological data, in general, has been dealt within
the literature, in terms of supervised methods trained on big datasets, such as infilling erosivity values
(Vantas and Sidiropoulos, 2017) or to create more accurate models than widely used formulae, such
as the flow velocity prediction (Kitsikoudis et al., 2015). The use of unsupervised methods in relation
to the special issue of temporal distribution of rainfall is scarce. Self-organized maps have been
applied to a small data-set to estimate design storms (Lin and Wu, 2007) and k-means clustering has
been used to create a predefined number of rainfall patterns (Nojumuddin and Yusop, 2015).
This paper presents an original, controlled, fully reproducible, unsupervised method that produces
automatically and objectively the optimal number of DHs using precipitation records. This method
comprises of the following steps: a) Raw precipitation data is cleaned from noise and errors. b) CD
is determined on the basis of a Poisson process hypothesis. c) A temporal model of CD is constructed
with the above rainfall data. d) Unitless Cumulative Hyetographs (UCH) are compiled and Principal
Components Analysis (PCA) is applied to the UCH’s. e) Agglomerative hierarchical clustering is
applied on the principal components (HCPC). f) The number of clusters is determined by repetitive
statistical comparisons between the centers of the clusters already produced at the previous steps. g)
Finally, a limited number of DHs is produced that represents the rainstorm records.
2.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
2.1 Study area and Dataset
The study region, located to the north-east Greece (Fig 1.), extends to an area of 11,243 km2 that
covers the Water Division of Thrace. It is delimited by the boundaries of Greece, Bulgaria and Turkey
on the north and east, by the Thracian Sea on the south and by the watershed of Nestos River on the
west.
Figure 1: Location of the study area and the 13 meteorological stations from the Greek
National Databank for Hydro-meteorological Information.
The climate is predominantly Mediterranean and annual rainfall ranges from 500 mm in coastal and
insular areas to 1000 mm in the northern mountainous areas (Ministry of Environment and Energy,
2013). The data utilized in the analysis was taken from the Greek National Databank for Hydro556
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
meteorological Information (Vafeiadis et al., 1994) and came from 13 meteorological stations. The
data coverage was 37%, on average (Table 1). The time series comprised a total of 413 years of
pluviograph records with a time step of 30 minutes for the time period from 1956 to 1997. The time
series rainfall records were checked for consistency and errors which were: a) There were repetitive
values, where the same rainfall was recorded over a long-time period, and these were set to zero, b)
there were records of aggregated values, where the time step was larger than 30 min, and these were
removed, c) there were records where the time step was 5 min and these where aggregated to 30 min,
d) probably due to the initial digitization of the pluviometers’ bands, there were values near zero ≪
0.01 mm) which were set to zero.
Table 1: Meteorological stations location, pluviograph records data coverage and duration.
Elevation
Data Length
(m)
(yr)
24.79
75
41
1956
1997 62%
41.32
26.10
116
24
1973
1997 63%
FERRES
40.90
26.17
43
35
1962
1997 56%
200263
DIDYMOTEIXO
41.35
26.50
25
41
1955
1996 62%
5
200311
PARANESTI
41.27
24.50
122
36
1960
1996 65%
6
500250
GRATINI
41.14
25.53
120
31
1965
1996 21%
7
500251
KECHROS
41.23
25.86
700
31
1965
1996 20%
8
500253
MIKRA KSIDIA
41.13
25.64
70
31
1965
1996 25%
9
500262
THERMES
41.35
25.01
440
31
1965
1996 21%
10 500265
GERAKAS
41.20
24.83
308
31
1965
1996 26%
11 500267
ORAIO
41.27
24.83
656
31
1965
1996 18%
12 500272
SEMELH
41.09
24.84
65
24
1968
1992 21%
13 500273
CHRYSOUPOLI
40.99
24.69
15
26
1966
1992 16%
ID
Name
Lat ()
Long ()
1
200249
TOXOTES
41.09
2
200259
MIKRO DEREIO
3
200260
4
From To
Data
Coverage
2.2 Storm identification
A Poisson process hypothesis is assumed for the division of the precipitation time series to
statistically-independent rainstorm events, in which: a) the events’ interarrival times 𝑡𝛼 that come
from the same month are distributed exponentially, b) the events are separated by a monthly, constant,
minimum Critical time Duration of no precipitation, 𝐶𝐷, and c) there is a seasonal pattern for 𝐶𝐷 in
the area of interest. The probability density function of 𝑡𝛼 is (Restrepo-Posada and Eagleson, 1982):
𝑓(𝑡𝑎 ) = 𝜔 ⋅ 𝑒 −𝜔⋅𝑡𝛼 , 𝑡𝑎 ≥ 0 (1)
where ω is the average storm arrival rate and:
𝑡𝑎 = 𝑡𝑟 + 𝑡𝑏
(2)
where 𝑡𝑟 is the storm duration and 𝑡𝑏 is the dry time between rainstorms. The estimation of 𝐶𝐷 is
based on an iterative procedure of statistical tests where inter-month data per station are used to ensure
homogeneity (Koutsoyiannis and Xanthopoulos, 1990). In Algorithm 1, Appendix, a vector of test
𝐶𝐷 values is used to compute 𝑡𝛼 values and 𝜔
̂ is estimated from this sample of values. Then a nonparametric bootstrap method (Babu and Rao, 2004) that utilizes the one-sample KolmogorovSmirnov test (William, 1971) is applied to test the goodness-of-fit, only if the sample size is moderate
to large (i.e. ≥ 50), because the data suffer from significant proportions of missing values. Finally, a
557
Environmental hydrology
temporal, sinusoidal model for the Water Division’s 𝐶𝐷 values per month is fitted (Equation 4,
Algorithm 1).
2.3 Development of Unitless Cumulative Hyetographs and Principal Components Analysis
The rainstorms are extracted from the dataset using the monthly 𝐶𝐷 values obtained from the fitted
model of Algorithm 1. The general approach given by Bonta (2004) is followed and only the events
with duration greater than 3 hours and cumulative rainfall greater than 12.7 mm are used in the
analysis. The hyetographs of the rainstorms that meet these criteria are transformed to unitless form
in which a) the time expresses the percentage of the rainstorm duration and b) the cumulative rainfall
expresses the percentage of total rainstorm height. Because the UCHs’ vectors in this form have
variable length, linear interpolation is applied to compute the unitless cumulative rainfall for every
1% of unitless time values. Finally, a matrix of UCHs, 𝑼 is produced with the values of unitless
cumulative rainfall, with every row representing the rainstorm and every column the unitless time
values.
Because the time variables (i.e. the 𝑚 columns of the 𝑼 matrix) are highly correlated, Principal
Component Analysis (PCA, Pearson, 1901) is applied to reduce the dimensionality of the data to a
few dimensions. The number of dimensions to retain is determined using the proportion of total
variance of the data explained (Jolliffe, 1986). In this analysis this level is set to 99.5%, to ensure that
almost all the information from UCHs will be preserved.
2.4 Clustering Analysis
The Hopkins index, 𝐻 (Lawson and Jurs, 1990), for clustering tendency is applied, because all the
clustering algorithms can return clusters even if there was no structure in the 𝑼 matrix. The computed
value of 𝐻 was 0.88, thus it indicates clustering tendency at the 90% confidence level (Han et al.,
2011). The clustering method applied is Hierarchical Clustering on Principal Components (HCPC),
using Ward’s minimum variance criterion that minimizes the total within-cluster variance (Ward,
1963). This criterion was utilized because it is based on the minimum variance as is PCA (Husson et.
al, 2010). The result is a tree-based representation of the UCHs.
The number of clusters is selected from the produced hierarchical tree using the top-down iterative
Algorithm 2, Appendix. At each step of the iteration the dendrogram is cut into different groups of
UCHs. The center of each group represents a different design hyetograph and these hyetographs, for
all possible pairs, are tested if are drawn from the same distribution using the two-sample
Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (William, 1971). Because of the multiple pairwise tests, the p-values that
resulted are adjusted using the Benjamini and Hochberg method (Benjamini and Hochberg, 1995),
which controls the false discovery rate. If any of the produced design hyetographs’ p-values is not
smaller than a predefined significance level α, the procedure stops and the optimal number of clusters
is found. Silhouette analysis (Rousseeuw, 1987) was applied to validate the internal structure of
clustering.
3.
RESULTS
The relation between the p-values and CD-values was found to have a global maximum for every
station and month, which is a desirable feature of Algorithm 1. The fitted monthly sinusoidal model
of CD shows a temporal variation during summer months, with an average value of 9 hours, while
for the rest of the year the same quantity averages 6.5 hours. Using the calculated CD-values a
population of 1,622 out of 25,377 extracted rainstorms met the criteria of minimum duration and
cumulative height. From PCA it is concluded that using only the first two dimensions explains 78.5%
of total variance and the first 15 explains 99.5%. The application of Algorithm 2 identifies four
clusters and some of their statistics are presented in Table 2. The percentiles’ values of the DHs are
given in Table 3. The first cluster has the highest variance in monthly occurrence, and the highest
average value of maximum 30 min duration’s intensity. In Figure 2 the clusters’ 10th, 50th and 90th
558
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
percentiles are shown with the UCHs that belong to them and in Figure 3 the clusters’ monthly
occurrence.
Figure 2: Results from Algorithm 2. At the top the 10th, 50th and 90th-percentiles
dimensionless hyetographs curves derived from the four identified clusters. With grey lines
are shown the UCHs of each cluster.
Figure 3: The plot presents the variability of clusters’ monthly occurrence.
559
Environmental hydrology
Figure 4: A comparison between the results from HCPC and Huff’s quartiles clustering. At
the top the derived dimensionless hyetographs curves are shown. In the middle the UCH’s
plots are shown using the first two principal components and ellipses around the clusters. At
the bottom the silhouette plots are shown and with red, dashed line the average silhouette
width of the clustering methods
560
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 2: Average values of occurrence of clusters, duration, precipitation height and
maximum 30 min duration’s intensity of clusters’ rainstorms.
Cluster
1
2
3
4
Occurrence (%)
12.50
32.80
39.50
15.20
Duration (hr)
16.25
18.75
19.5
16.5
Prec. (mm)
16.5
19.4
19.5
18.5
I30max (mm/hr)
20.1
13.0
12.4
16.8
After developing DHs for each station and for every month, correlation matrices were computed,
utilizing Pearson’s 𝑟 coefficient (Helsel and Hirsch, 1992), using the respective UCHs per cluster.
These matrices showed very high similarity between a) the DHs per station with 𝑟 ≥ 0.98 and b)
the DHs per month with 𝑟 ≥ 0.95. A comparison among HCPC and Huff’s curves is shown in Figure
4. Three pairs of the Huff’s curves fail to reject the hypothesis that are drawn from the same
distribution for both 𝛼 = 0.05 and 𝛼 = 0.10. HCPC results in the clear separation of UHCs, as its
clusters ellipses are not overlapping and it creates clusters with better internal structure, as average
sill width is almost two times better.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
A temporal model of critical dry duration between rainstorms was introduced and implemented and
a seasonal variability of rainfall patterns is simulated by the proposed method, in contrast to more
simplified approaches of the literature. The unitless cumulative hyetographs produced were subjected
to Principal Components Analysis in order to investigate if they can be compressed to a few
dimensions, due to high correlation values, and it turned out that only a small number of them
sufficiently explain almost all of the variability. Hierarchical Clustering on Principal Components
was subsequently applied that yielded a small number of clusters. Clustering tendency and internal
structure validation was appropriately investigated and documented. Finally, based on the clustering
analysis four representative design hyetographs were produced. These hyetographs do not exist in
Greece, especially in a way that covers the various Water Divisions. The proposed methodology may
be utilized for the systematic production of such hyetographs, also based on intensity-durationfrequency curves. This method is fully unsupervised, as no prior empirical knowledge is used.
Table 3: Design Hyetographs
Storm
duration (%)
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
30.0
35.0
40.0
45.0
50.0
55.0
60.0
65.0
70.0
75.0
80.0
85.0
90.0
95.0
100.0
10th
0.0
3.9
15.0
29.8
41.8
47.8
52.0
55.8
57.5
60.3
62.7
65.2
68.7
71.8
76.0
79.5
82.0
85.5
89.5
94.6
100.0
Cluster 1
50th
0.0
15.7
31.4
44.9
55.7
64.5
71.4
76.7
80.0
81.8
83.5
85.3
87.4
89.1
90.8
92.5
94.8
96.6
97.7
98.8
100.0
90th
0.0
38.4
63.5
73.0
80.4
86.8
89.6
92.2
93.7
95.2
96.2
96.9
97.8
98.3
98.5
98.7
99.1
99.3
99.5
99.7
100.0
10th
0.0
0.4
1.6
3.9
8.0
13.5
20.7
29.9
39.5
47.5
54.0
60.0
64.7
69.0
72.8
77.6
82.1
86.7
91.2
95.6
100.0
Cluster 2
50th
0.0
3.1
8.1
14.9
22.4
30.5
38.9
46.7
54.5
61.8
68.7
75.1
80.4
84.9
89.1
92.3
94.3
96.0
97.5
98.8
100.0
90th
0.0
10.0
19.2
28.5
38.2
48.6
58.6
67.6
76.9
83.5
88.2
92.2
94.5
96.0
97.4
98.3
98.9
99.3
99.5
99.8
100.0
561
10th
0.0
0.4
0.8
1.3
2.0
2.9
4.2
6.2
9.6
13.8
19.6
26.9
34.4
43.4
53.1
62.2
70.7
79.0
86.9
94.0
100.0
Cluster 3
50th
0.0
1.7
3.6
6.0
8.9
12.0
15.7
20.1
25.5
31.6
39.2
47.1
54.2
62.4
71.0
78.5
85.4
91.3
95.5
98.3
100.0
90th
0.0
6.6
12.4
17.3
21.8
26.0
30.2
35.1
41.1
47.3
54.2
63.4
73.3
80.9
87.8
93.3
96.3
98.1
99.1
99.6
100.0
10th
0.0
0.4
0.8
1.1
1.6
2.2
2.7
3.5
4.3
5.2
6.1
7.7
10.1
13.0
16.9
22.8
32.4
46.2
60.2
78.0
100.0
Cluster 4
50th
0.0
1.9
3.7
5.5
7.4
9.2
10.9
12.7
14.9
17.6
21.1
24.4
28.3
33.6
40.3
47.7
56.1
67.0
81.1
92.7
100.0
90th
0.0
8.1
14.3
18.7
22.2
25.3
28.2
31.0
33.8
37.7
41.7
45.0
49.4
52.6
56.4
62.3
70.8
81.3
91.7
98.3
100.0
Environmental hydrology
APPENDIX
The analysis and the algorithms were implemented in the R language (R Core Team, 2018) using the
packages: hydroscoper (Vantas, 2018), FactoMineR, (Lê et al., 2008) and factoextra (Kassambara
and Mundt, 2017).
References
1. Azli, M. and Rao, A. R. (2010), ‘Development of Huff curves for peninsular Malaysia’, Journal
of Hydrology 388(1-2), pp. 77-84.
2. Babu, G. J. and Rao, C. (2004), ‘Goodness-of-fit tests when parameters are estimated’, Sankhya
66(1), pp. 63-74.
3. Benjamini, Y. and Hochberg, Y. (1995), ‘Controlling the false discovery rate: A practical and
powerful approach to multiple testing’, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B
(Methodological) pp. 289-300.
4. Bonta, J. (2001), ‘Characterizing and estimating spatial and temporal variability of times between
storms’, Transactions of the ASAE 44(6), pp. 1593-1601.
562
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
5. Bonta, J. (2004a), ‘Development and utility of Huff curves for disaggregating precipitation
amounts’, Applied Engineering in Agriculture 20(5), pp. 641-643.
6. Bonta, J. (2004b), ‘Stochastic simulation of storm occurrence, depth, duration, and within-storm
intensities’, Transactions of the ASAE 47(5), pp. 1573-1584.
7. Bonta, J. and Rao, A. (1987), ‘Factors affecting development of Huff curves’, Transactions of
the ASAE 30(6), 1689-1693.
8. Bonta, J. and Shahalam, A. (2003), ‘Cumulative storm rainfall distributions: Comparison of Huff
curves’, Journal of Hydrology (New Zealand) pp. 65-74.
9. Dolšak, D., Bezak, N. and Šraj, M. (2016), ‘Temporal characteristics of rainfall events under three
climate types in Slovenia’, Journal of Hydrology 541, pp. 1395-1405.
10. Han, J., Pei, J. and Kamber, M. (2011), Data mining: Concepts and techniques, Elsevier.
11. Helsel, D. R. and Hirsch, R. M. (1992), Statistical methods in water resources, Vol. 49, Elsevier.
12. Huff, F. A. (1967), ‘Time distribution of rainfall in heavy storms’, Water Resources Research
3(4), pp. 1007-1019
13. Husson, F., Josse, J. and Pages, J. (2010), ‘Principal component methods-hierarchical clustering
partitional clustering: Why would we need to choose for visualizing data’, Technical ReportAgrocampus.
14. Jolliffe, I. T. (1986), Principal component analysis and factor analysis, in ‘Principal Component
Analysis’, Springer, pp. 115128.
15. Kassambara, A. and Mundt, F. (2017), factoextra: Extract and Visualize the Results of
Multivariate Data Analyses. R package version 1.0.5.
16. Kitsikoudis, V., Sidiropoulos, E., Iliadis, L. and Hrissanthou, V. (2015), ‘A machine learning
approach for the mean flow velocity prediction in alluvial channels’, Water resources
management 29(12), pp. 4379-4395.
17. Koutsoyiannis, D. and Xanthopoulos, T. (1990), ‘A dynamic model for short-scale rainfall
disaggregation’, Hydrological Sciences Journal 35(3), 303-322.
18. Lawson, R. G. and Jurs, P. C. (1990), ‘New index for clustering tendency and its application to
chemical problems’, Journal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences 30(1), pp. 3641.
19. Lê, S., Josse, J. and Husson, F. (2008), ‘FactoMineR: A package for multivariate analysis’,
Journal of Statistical Software 25(1), pp. 1-18.
20. Lin, G.-F. and Wu, M.-C. (2007), ‘A SOM-based approach to estimating design hyetographs of
21. ungauged sites’, Journal of Hydrology 339(3-4), pp. 216-226.
22. Loukas, A. and Quick, M. C. (1996), ‘Spatial and temporal distribution of storm precipitation in
23. southwestern British Columbia’, Journal of hydrology 174(1-2), pp. 37-56.
24. Ministry of Environment and Energy (2013), Management plan of Thracian Water Division,
Technical report.
25. Nojumuddin, N. S. and Yusop, Z. (2015), ‘Identification of rainfall patterns in Johor’, Applied
26. Mathematical Sciences 9(38), pp. 1869-1888.
27. R Core Team (2018), R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing, R Foundation
for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria.
563
Environmental hydrology
28. Restrepo-Posada, P. J. and Eagleson, P. S. (1982), ‘Identification of independent rainstorms’,
Journal of Hydrology 55(1), pp. 303-319.
29. Rousseeuw, P. J. (1987), ‘Silhouettes: A graphical aid to the interpretation and validation of
cluster analysis’, Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics, 20, pp. 53-65.
30. Vafeiadis, M., Tolikas, D. and Koutsoyiannis, D. (1994), HYDROSCOPE: The new Greek
national database system for meteorological, hydrological and hydrogeological information, in
‘WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment’, pp. 1-8.
31. Vandenberghe, S., Verhoest, N., Buyse, E. and De Baets, B. (2010), ‘A stochastic design rainfall
generator based on copulas and mass curves’, Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 14(12),
pp. 2429-2442.
32. Vantas, K. (2018), ‘hydroscoper: R interface to the Greek National Data Bank for Hydrological
and Meteorological Information’. Journal of Open Source Software, 3(23), 625.
33. Vantas, K. and Sidiropoulos, E. (2017), ‘Imputation of erosivity values under incomplete rainfall
data by machine learning methods’, European Water 57, pp. 193-197.
34. Veneziano, D. and Villani, P. (1999), ‘Best linear unbiased design hyetograph’, Water Resources
Research 35(9), pp. 2725-2738.
35. Ward, J. (1963), ‘Hierarchical grouping to optimize an objective function’, Journal of the
American Statistical Association, 58(301), pp. 236-244.
36. William, J. C. (1971), Practical Nonparametric Statistics, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
37. Williams-Sether, T., Asquith, W. H., Thompson, D. B., Cleveland, T. G. and Fang, X. (2004),
‘Empirical, dimensionless, cumulative-rainfall hyetographs developed from 1959-86 storm data
for selected small watersheds in Texas’, Technical report, US Geological Survey.
564
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
DEVELOPMENT AND QUANTIFICATION OF VISUAL
ANALYTICS ALGORITHMS FOR INVESTIGATING EXTREME
WEATHER EVENTS IN TIME-VARYING GEOGRAPHIC DATA
P. P. Giannopoulos* and K. Moustakas
Dept. of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Patras, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: ece7756@upnet.gr, tel : +302610450612
Abstract
The large amount of measurement data from Greece's meteorological network requires visualization
and processing to be more understandable and useful. In this paper we study measurements and
forecasts of temperature and wind velocity for the geographical area of Greece and we produce useful
depictions through an interactive application. We also include statistical processing on the wind data
so that we can understand in which area of Greece there is a greater probability of extreme weather
events occurring. In general, Visual Analytics may help the emerging area of Artificial Intelligence
and Decision Support Systems. The data used in this work is obtained from the National Observatory
of Athens through the site of meteo.gr.
Keywords: Measurements, Temperature, Wind Data, Extreme Weather Forecasts, Decision Support
Systems
1.
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Motivation
Nowadays, the amount of information that passes through our eyes in a daily basis, from the
newspaper we read at breakfast, the emails we receive throughout the day, the data generated when
we make a bank statement to receive or store money or the conversation we have, is enormous. For
that reason, several scientific fields have been developed, such as Information Visualization and
Visual Analytics, in order to make the information we receive more comprehensive and cohesive,
and to make our lives simpler. The Information Visualization, the art of presenting the data in such a
way that we can clearly understand and manage it, can help us understand the meaning behind that
information in order to adopt and use it in everyday life.
On the other hand, Visual Analytics, which is an emerging field of Artificial Intelligence and Decision
Support Systems, aims to support analytical reasoning through various interactive visual interfaces.
The basic idea is the integration of the outstanding capabilities of humans in terms of visual
information exploration and the enormous processing power of computers to form a powerful
knowledge discovery environment.
1.2 Related work
A technique for classification of information visualization and optical data mining techniques have
been proposed [Keim, Daniel A. "Information Visualization and Visual Data Mining], based on the
type of data, the visualization method and the specific interaction and distortion of them. A new
approach regarding the visualization of data mining from a large database has been described and
evaluated [Keim, D.a., and H.-P. Kriegel, . Keim, D.a., E.e. Koutsofios, and S.c. North]. The basic
idea of the visualization techniques used for that purpose is to present as much as possible information
565
Environmental hydrology
on the screen at the same time, mapping every data value to a specific pixel and arranging the pixels
sufficiently. The information visualization techniques are usually limited to only a few thousand
objects. Fortunately, a description of new interaction techniques, that can manage millions of objects
and the emerging hardware-oriented techniques and new animation methodologies such as
stereovision and overlap count, have been given and evaluated [Fekete, J.-D., and C. Plaisant]. Also,
recent researchers [Kandel, S., Heer, J., Plaisant, C., Kennedy, J., van Ham, F., Riche] have invented
techniques, as well as visualization ones, that are pixel-based, in order to increase the density of the
data, that can be displayed, without the loss of the possibility to display individual values.
As statistics data sets become increasingly large and complex, the users require more effective multidimensional visualization tools and faster interactive performance. This challenge demands improved
fundamental methods for data model and visual exploration analysis. The potential to apply integrated
infovis and geovis tools for analyzing multivariate statistics data over time represents another
interesting research challenge. An attempt for summarization of those challenges has been done [Jern,
M] through real time examples.
Weather conditions concern multiple aspects of human life, such as economy, security and social
activities. For this reason, meteorological forecasts play an important role in society. Current weather
forecasts are based on Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) and create representations of
atmospheric flow. Interactive visualizations of geospatial data [Diehl, A., L. Pelorosso, C. Delrieux,
C. Saulo, J. Ruiz, M. E. Gröller, and S. Bruckner] have been widely used to facilitate analysis of
NWP models. A system that provides geographical representation of the probability of fire and the
identification of areas of the highest risk [Kalabokidis, Kostas & Nikos, Athanasis & Gagliardi,
Fabrizio & Karayiannis, Fotis & Palaiologou, Palaiologos & Parastatidis, Savas & Vasilakos,
Christos], based on a high-performance pilot application running on a server, has been developed.
1.3 Our contribution
We propose a visualization method of grid-based point data that describe weather conditions in
different locations in the area of Greece. We also make a statistical analysis of the data so that we can
make predictions of weather changes. Thus, we can make useful depictions of extreme weather
conditions, such as high wind accelerations through interactive visualizations.
2.
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
Our goal was to implement a semitransparent visualization above a map so that we could find windbased sensitive areas of Greece at a particular time. Those areas should tell us if the wind speed had
changed enough so that we could determine whether an extreme weather condition event was
occurring. A way to achieve this goal was to calculate from various timeframes the specific local
pixel mean value from the group of wind speed values in the given timeframe. Then, we had to find
the variance from the wind gust information we had about the specific pixel and the mean value we
already calculated. In this way, we can clearly see which areas are most vulnerable from extreme
weather conditions because the more the wind gust is away from the mean wind speed value the
bigger the value of the final pixel will be. The computational procedure is as follows:
First, we calculate the mean wind speed, 𝑢̅𝑗 , at each pixel 𝑗
1
𝑢̅𝑗 = ∑𝑛𝑖=1 𝑢𝑖
(1)
𝑛
where 𝑢𝑖 is the wind speed at the time interval 𝑖, 𝑖 ∈ {1,2, … , 𝑛} . Then, we calculate the wind speed
variance of the gust speed and as a last but important step, the standard deviation at each pixel 𝑗
566
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
1
2
𝑉𝑎𝑟(𝑢𝑔𝑖 ) = ∑𝑛𝑖=1(𝑢𝑔𝑖 − 𝑢̅𝑗 ) (𝑎)
𝑛
𝑠𝑡𝑑𝑒𝑣(𝑢𝑔𝑖 ) = √𝑉𝑎𝑟(𝑢𝑔𝑖 ) (𝑏)
(2)
The standard deviation is used as the criterion revealing the most vulnerable regions.
3.
ESTIMATING GRID VALUES FROM SCATTERED POINTS
3.1 Simple approach to grid approximation
The visualization of the data of interest would not be possible if we could not convert the input
scattered points to an actual regular grid first. In order to do that, we needed to map the values of the
input scatter point data to match the individual values of the grid covering the area of Greece. An
algorithm that is easy to implement and understand is the Kriging Method [A Basic Understanding
of Surfer Gridding Methods] which finds an approximate value of each grid point based on the
corresponding neighboring scattered points. Every point from the scattered points has a weight that
is been calculated based on the neighborhood area of the grid point. The flow diagram of the Kriging’s
Method algorithm can be seen in Figure 1. For example, in order to calculate the estimated value of
the grid point based on its neighbors we use the relationship:
𝑍𝐴 = ∑𝑛𝑖=1 𝑊𝑖 𝑍𝑖
(3)
where 𝑍𝐴 is the estimated value, 𝑛 is an arbitrary number of neighbors, 𝑊𝑖 is the corresponding weight
of the current neighbor and 𝑍𝑖 is the value of the current neighbor. The weights are calculated in a
way that the sum of them equals to unity. For example, we use the following formula:
𝑍𝑖
𝑊𝑖 = ∑𝑛
(4)
𝑗=1 𝑍𝑗
3.2 Inverse Distance Weighting (IDW) and Kriging method’s algorithm
The problem that occurs with the previous equation of the simple approach is that smaller distances
of the neighbors from the current grid point do not affect the corresponding weight and thus the final
estimation. Although, we always search for the closest neighbors from the grid point to find the
neighborhood and we get reliable results, we can still use better techniques to increase the accuracy
of the results. One of them is the Inverse Distance Weighting Method also called the Shepard method
[Robert Weibel] and is the method we have used in this work. Inverse Distance Weighting considers
the distance of the chosen neighboring points and calculates their weights. A simple approach of this
method is to find the weights from the direct inverse distance:
𝑊𝑖 =
1
(5)
𝑑𝑖
where 𝑑𝑖 is the distance of the current grid point from the 𝑖-th point of neighbors i.e. a hyperbolic
weight allocation method. Also with the prior weighting calculation the estimation now changes to:
𝑍𝐴 =
∑𝑛
𝑖 𝑊𝑖 𝑍𝑖
(6)
∑𝑛
𝑖 𝑊𝑖
567
Environmental hydrology
Figure 1: Flow diagram of the Kriging method
With the IDW simple equation we simply improved the distance correlation and the accuracy of the
results. The IDW method allows for very fast calculations and different distances can be integrated
in the equation. Also, with the usage of the distance-weighting exponent we can precisely control the
influence of those distances. Using the IDW method we are not able to do a direction-dependent
weighting. That means that spatially oriented relationships are ignored. There are also some
undesirable artifacts that appear called «Bulls-eyes» as shown in Figure 2.
Those artifacts are circular areas of equal values around known data points. In order to improve the
results and make the artifacts disappear we use a variation to the above equation using an exponent
of the distance as a parameter:
1
𝑊𝑖 = 𝑑𝑝
(7)
𝑖
568
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2: Τhe undesirable artifacts, also called “Bulls-eyes” that we try to reduce using an
exponent parameter p = 0.02 shown in the right image
4.
COLOR MAP BASED VISUALIZATION
Finding the values that match the grid coordinates from a group of scattered points is only the first
step that only requires some math computations and no visualization. In order to create the grid mesh
and visualize it on the screen, we have to follow some rules in order to give meaning to the final
visualization based on the variable we are currently working on (e.g. Temperature). A good way to
fulfill that purpose is to create a color map that is basically a collection of colors that have been
arranged in a "map" or array of colors so that each color corresponds to a specific value of our
variable. There are three types of color maps: The Qualitative, the Sequential and the Diverging color
map as shown in Figure 3. The Qualitative map is a collection of colors that cannot be related to each
other. A usage of it could be in a map where we want to distinguish one country from the other based
on its unique color. That type of color map has not been used in that particular work because the
emphasis is focused on the values appeared in the several regions of Greece and not on the regions
themselves. The Sequential color map is an important one because each color, when we look at the
colors in the array, has a slight difference, in terms of hue, from the neighboring colors. A great
example of a sequential color map is the Rainbow color map, which is widely used in many scientific
fields that require visualization to present the results. Although, that type of color map is very
important and gives a good sense of where our value belongs in the range of our variable and on the
color map, the following type of color map gives more reliable results and the more colorful nature
of it can be more aesthetically pleasing.
Figure 3: The different types of color maps: (a) Qualitative, (b) Sequential, (c) Diverging
569
Environmental hydrology
The Diverging color map [Moreland, Kenneth] can have up to twice the perceptual resolution of the
sequential color map without sacrificing the requirements of surface shading or losing viewers with
dichromatic vision. To create a diverging colormap we need to choose 2 colors that will play the role
of the extreme values of our scalar variable. Every color in between will be a combination of those
two and the color in the middle of the color map, which is an unsaturated color (e.g. the white). In
general, diverging color maps lack a natural ordering of the colors and because of that we have to
choose the extreme colors in a way so that we can understand them naturally. For example, a common
diverging color map is the cool to warm map, in which the endpoint colors are chosen so that they
have a natural meaning. It has been proven from studies that people identify red and yellow as warm
colors and blue or green as cool colors across subjects, contexts and cultures. When creating a
diverging color map, we must ensure that it maintains a perceptual uniformity and therefore it must
be true that the quantity
𝛥𝛦 {𝑐(𝑥),𝑐(𝑥+𝛥𝑥)}
(8)
𝛥𝑥
is constant for every x, where ΔΕ expresses a slight change in the visual color difference between two
consecutive colors.
We use CIELAB color space for precise control of the color difference. Unfortunately, the three
colors (e.g. red, white and blue) that the map passes through may not be in a line in CIELAB space.
That means we cannot use only a single interpolation method to find the colors of the diverging color
map directly from the difference between the three basic colors of the colormap. Prosperously, we
can ensure that the rate of change of the color difference between two consecutive colors is constant
if
lim
𝛥𝛦{𝑐(𝑥),𝑐(𝑥+𝛥𝑥)}
(9)
𝛥𝑥
𝛥𝑥→0
is also constant.
We can resolve the above equation by applying the ΔΕ operation and splitting up the c function into
its components (𝛥𝛦{𝑐1 , 𝑐2 } = ‖𝑐1 − 𝑐2 ‖ = √∑𝑖(𝑐1𝑖 − 𝑐2𝑖 )2 ).
‖𝑐(𝑥 + 𝛥𝑥) − 𝑐(𝑥)‖
𝑐(𝑥 + 𝛥𝑥) − 𝑐(𝑥)
= lim ‖
‖=
𝛥𝑥→0
𝛥𝑥→0
𝛥𝑥
𝛥𝑥
lim
2
𝑐 (𝑥+𝛥𝑥)−𝑐𝑖 (𝑥)
= lim √∑𝑖 ( 𝑖
) = √∑𝑖 ( lim
𝛥𝑥
𝛥𝑥→0
𝑐𝑖 (𝑥+𝛥𝑥)−𝑐𝑖 (𝑥) 2
𝛥𝑥→0
𝛥𝑥
)
(10)
In the final form of the equation (10), we can notice that the limit is the definition of a derivative and
by replacing the limit with a derivative, we get the following result:
lim
𝛥𝑥→0
‖𝑐(𝑥+𝛥𝑥)−𝑐(𝑥)‖
𝛥𝑥
2
= √∑𝑖(𝑐 ′ 𝑖 (𝑥)) = ‖𝑐 ′ (𝑥)‖
(11)
where 𝑐 ′ (𝑥), the constant rate of change requirement, is declared as the piecewise derivative of 𝑐(𝑥)
and the easiest way to ensure that the equation (11) is constant is to linearly interpolate in the CIELAB
color space. To make the linear interpolation pass also from the middle color (e.g. white), a piecewise
linear interpolation had to be implemented. That interpolation may cause undesirable artifacts in the
color map also called Mach bands, that can be reduced by setting a “leveling off” of the luminance
570
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
as we approach the middle area. To preserve the properties of a diverging color map the chromaticity
should also change more dramatically when we are working with that specific area.
The most suited color map for our work was the diverging color map so we chose to implement it and
used it for every possible visualization.
5.
IMPLEMENTATION
To test the results, we used temperature data as well as wind data from scattered points of
meteorological stations across Greece. Without the Inverse Distance Method, the results were good,
but they were lacking detailed estimation near specific areas because of the distance of each
neighboring point that was not considered when calculating the corresponding weights. Using the
Inverse Distance Method with exponent equal to 1 (𝑝=1) we made a more detailed visualization also
causing the "bulls-eyes" artifacts to appear. To reduce those artifacts, we simply chose the exponent
to be equal to 0.02 (𝑝=0.02) without loss in the quality.
For the temperature data, the cool to warm diverging color map was very well suited and helped a lot
to distinguish higher values from lower ones. The usage of green and purple colors as endpoints for
the description of the wind data also follows the same approach. The nature of green colors can
interpret mild or lower values of the wind speed perfectly. In contrast, purple colors can describe
more tense or higher values of the wind.
Another useful visualization which has been done in this work is the flow visualization of a vector
field either with the arrows in the corresponding positions of each grid cell or with the streamlines
that are tangent to each vector of the field. That kind of visualization is very useful for presenting
wind speed data that has a vector form and the intention of motion of the wind that is taking place in
certain regions of the map.
Beyond those visualizations, the interaction with the user is such so that zooming in specific area with
updated values through proper local normalization is possible. Additional features also included in
this work such as increasing the quality of the grid visualization using bilinear interpolation
[Numerical Recipes in C].
6.
RESULTS
Usually, in a GIS based application such as Virtual Fire [Kalabokidis, Kostas & Nikos, Athanasis &
Gagliardi, Fabrizio & Karayiannis, Fotis & Palaiologou, Palaiologos & Parastatidis, Savas &
Vasilakos, Christos], where meteorological data are needed for the visualization, greater accuracy can
benefit the results and the decisions we make based on those. Our application, even though it is simple
at its core, can produce good-quality images. It is also capable of providing control for increasing or
decreasing the quality of the visualization grid as much as we want overall or at specific regions of
the map.
The visualizations created with the temperature data is shown in Figure 4 and we can see how the
method that takes into account the distance for the calculation of the weights affects the accuracy of
the results. The user can interact with the grid by rotating it in 3D space holding the right mouse
button and moving the mouse around. Also, it is possible to zoom in and extract more detailed
information about a specific area. By looking at the colormap, the user can understand how each value
matches the values in the Greece and make proper decisions. The same techniques apply for the
visualization in Figure 5 where the data used as input is the wind data. The procedure is the same,
with the only noticeable difference in the results and the color map used in the specific visualization.
In Figure 6 we can see the visualization of the vector field and the corresponding streamlines for
presenting the wind speed data in a better way using also a separate color map.
571
Environmental hydrology
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 4: Grid Based Visualization of temperature data using (a) a simple neighboring
approach, (b) a simple Inverse Distance Weighting Method, (c) variation of the simple Inverse
Distance Weighting Method. Undesirable artifacts have been reduced in image (c) comparing
to image (b)
Figure 5: Visualization of Wind Speed Stand. Deviation Data based on multiple timeframes
Figure 6: Visualization of vector field. Image (a) shows the arrows that represent the wind
speed vectors in the vertices of each grid cell, image (b) shows the corresponding streamlines
and the wind speed stand. deviation on the values of the grid, image (c) shows the wind speed
stand. deviation in percentage
7.
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE WORK
By using the values of meteorological data from Greece, we can predict the wind changes in a specific
area of the map and the results are quite precise and reliable. Usually, typical weather models extract
ready-to-use grids that describe a specific meteorological variable, but in our case, we needed data
that should be taken in frequent periods (e.g. 10 minutes). If the sampling frequency of the weather
data provided by the weather forecasts increases in the future, we can get more accurate results.
The present finding may be helpful to Artificial Intelligence and Decision Support Systems.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to thank the PhD candidate Mr. Dimitar Stanev and the research associate Mr. Stavros
Nousias for their help to improve the work. We acknowledge Mr. Lagouvardos, Research Director of
the National Observatory of Athens, providing accessibility to the meteorological data of the
Observatory stations.
572
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
References
1. Keim, Daniel A. "Information Visualization and Visual Data Mining." IEEE Transactions on
Visualization and Computer Graphics. http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=614508 (accessed
October 18, 2017).
2. Keim, D.a., and H.-P. Kriegel. "Visualization techniques for mining large databases: a
comparison." IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering 8, no. 6 (1996): 92338. doi:10.1109/69.553159.
3. Keim, D.a., E.e. Koutsofios, and S.c. North. "Visual exploration of large telecommunication data
sets."
Proceedings
User
Interfaces
to
Data
Intensive
Systems,
1999.
doi:10.1109/uidis.1999.791458.
4. Fekete, J.-D., and C. Plaisant. "Interactive information visualization of a million items." IEEE
Symposium
on
Information
Visualization,
2002.
INFOVIS
2002.
doi:10.1109/infvis.2002.1173156.
5. Kandel, S., Heer, J., Plaisant, C., Kennedy, J., van Ham, F., Riche, N.H., Weaver, C., Lee, B.,
Brodbeck, D., Buono, P.: Research directions in data wrangling: visualizations and
transformations for usable and credible data. Inf. Vis. 10(4), 271–288 (2011).
6. Jern, M. "Research Advances in Geovisualization and Remaining Challenges." Ninth
International Conference on Information Visualisation (IV05). doi:10.1109/iv.2005.108.
7. Diehl, A., L. Pelorosso, C. Delrieux, C. Saulo, J. Ruiz, M. E. Gröller, and S. Bruckner. "Visual
Analysis of Spatio-Temporal Data: Applications in Weather Forecasting." Computer Graphics
Forum 34, no. 3 (2015): 381-90. doi:10.1111/cgf.12650.
8. Kalabokidis, Kostas & Nikos, Athanasis & Gagliardi, Fabrizio & Karayiannis, Fotis &
Palaiologou, Palaiologos & Parastatidis, Savas & Vasilakos, Christos. (2013). Virtual Fire: A
web-based GIS platform for forest fire control. Ecological Informatics. 16. 62–69.
10.1016/j.ecoinf.2013.04.007.
9. A Basic Understanding of Surfer Gridding Methods – Part 1. (n.d.). Retrieved from
"https://support.goldensoftware.com/hc/en-us/articles/231348728-A-Basic-Understanding-ofSurfer-Gridding-Methods-Part-1"
10. Robert Weibel(Overall), Philipp Weckenbrock(Translation), Helmut Flitter (Specials), Samuel
Wiesmann(Specials). (n.d.). Retrieved from
11. "http://www.gitta.info/ContiSpatVar/en/html/Interpolatio_learningObject2.xhtml
12. Moreland, Kenneth, "Diverging Color Maps for Scientific Visualization (Expanded),"
Proceedings in ISVC '09, Proceedings of the 5th International Symposium on Advances in
Visual Computing: Part II, Springer-Verlag, Belin, Heidelberg, Nov. 26, 2009, pp. 1-20.
13. Numerical Recipes in C, 1988–92 Cambridge University Press, ISBN 0-521-43108-5, pp. 123–
128. "http://www.aip.de/groups/soe/local/numres/bookcpdf/c3-6.pdf"
573
Environmental hydrology
DEVELOPING FLOOD ACTION PLANS ON THE
ADMINISTRATIVE LEVEL OF FARMERS’ ORGANIZATION
V. Pisinaras*, G. Arampatzis and A. Panagopoulos
Soil & Water Resources Institute, Hellenic Agricultural Organization - DEMETER, GR-57400
Sindos, Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: vpisinar@gmail.com
Abstract
Agriculture constitutes one of the most vulnerable sectors on floods impacts, the frequency and
severity of which are expected to increase within the context of climate change. Despite the fact that
floods’ action plans are commonly developed on national or regional level, it is important for each
water resources “key player” within a basin to compile local and case specific action plans in order
to increase its adaptability to the corresponding impacts and sufficiently contribute to floods
management in the basin. This necessity is also addressed by the business-oriented water management
certification schemes (e.g. the European Water Stewardship Standard), according to which
management of such incidents are of major importance.
Taking into account the above, this paper aims to introduce a simplified approach for the compilation
of flood action plans in Farmers’ Organization (F.ORs), which constitutes a common organizational
scheme of agricultural production in the Mediterranean. The first step is to assess the risk of: a) river
floods, based on flood risk assessment reports developed within the context of Floods Directive by
EU and b) flash floods, based on surface runoff potential estimated by a simplified methodology
incorporating spatially distributed runoff curve numbers, ground slope and precipitation. The second
step is to propose practices and actions in order to: a) contribute to basin’s flood risk reduction and
b) mitigate the impact of flood incidents. The above mentioned methodologies are applied in the area
of activity of a F.OR located in Crete Island, Greece.
Keywords: floods, droughts, agricultural water management, curve number, good agricultural
practices
1.
INTRODUCTION
Agriculture constitutes one of the production sectors that are fully exposed and impacted from
disasters related to climate. According to FAO (2015): a) 25% of total damage and losses related to
climate-induced disasters are absorbed by the agriculture sector and b) for the period 2003-2013, the
economic loss in crop and livestock production resulted from medium to large scale climate-induced
disasters in developing countries was estimated at USD 80 billion. This evidence indicate the high
vulnerability of agricultural sector in climate conditions and indicate not only the economic, but also
the social impact of such disasters. Among the several climate-induced disasters, floods and droughts
are considered the most frequent and severe. Indicatively, it is mentioned that crop and livestock
production losses occurred after floods and droughts in developing countries is estimated at 83%.
Considering the above, the well-organized and prompt response of agriculture sector in floods is of
paramount importance in order to reduce the socio-economic impact of those disasters. One of the
tools towards this way is the development of local and case specific flood action plans. The necessity
of flood action plans has been identified by the European Commission as reflected in the relevant
574
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Directives (2000/60/EC, 2007/60/EC). Moreover, business-oriented water management certification
schemes (e.g. the European Water Stewardship Standard) according to which management of such
incidents is of major importance, have also identified the necessity to develop such plans. Flooding
is an issue of major concern for farmers both at field and farm level (Pivot and Martin, 2002;
Posthumus et al, 2008).The present study aims to introduce an easily applied approach for the
compilation of flood action plans in Farmers’ Organization (F.ORs), which constitutes a common
organizational scheme of agricultural production in the Mediterranean. So, it is applied for Public
Services Company of Platanias Municipality, located in Crete Island, Greece. A set of practices and
measures are proposed in order to increase its preparedness and response level to floods, while
establishing communication channels with the competent authorities is necessary.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Floods action plan development methodology
In this study, the methodological framework followed in order to establish the flood action plan is
presented in Figure 1. Two are the main steps that each F.OR has to follow in order to compile it: a)
identify the areas characterized by high flood risk and b) compile a flood management strategy by
identifying actions, measures and practices that will lead to reduction of agricultural activity
contribution to surface runoff and mitigation of the corresponding floods’ impact. There are three
types of floods, which can potentially affect the agricultural sector: river floods, flash floods and
coastal floods. River floods occur when river water system capacity is exceeded and therefore river
water is not able to be channeled through the river course. Flash floods are developed from localized,
intense rainfalls and can occur anywhere in the basin, while coastal floods constitutes the result of
increased sea level rise caused by storm surges driven by tropical storms or strong windstorms.
According to Morris et al (2010), flood development consists of three major components: the sources,
the pathway and the receptor. Flood sources are the extreme rainfall events and/or the sudden snowcover melt, while pathway is considered as the land and the hydrological system which transfer the
water to the receptor. Finally, flood receptor is the area where flooding occurs. Agricultural land can
serve either as pathway or receptor.
With regard to river floods risk assessment, it can be based on reports, data and information developed
within the context of Directive 2007/60/EC, since it requires heavy scientific effort, which cannot be
maintained by a F.OR. Every EU Member State has to be conform to Directive 2007/60/EC on the
assessment and management of flood risks and therefore useful information such as preliminary flood
risk assessment reports and flood hazard and risk maps already produced for the most EU countries
can be used to identify high agricultural areas of flood risk and hazard.
With regard to flash floods risk assessment, it can be estimated by a simplified GIS-based
methodology (Figure 2), in which meteorological and physical factors are incorporated. The
methodology is based on the spatial determination of easily estimated or calculated parameters,
namely Curve Number (CN), ground’s slope and rainfall. CN corresponds to an empirical parameter
applied in hydrology for the prediction of direct runoff or infiltration from rainfall excess. The CN
constitutes the fundamental parameter of the runoff curve number method, which was originally
developed by USDA Soil Conservation Service (SCS) at 1954 in order to simulate direct runoff from
agricultural fields for specific rainfall events and since then, SCS-CN method is considered as the
most widely applied method for runoff estimation (Ajmal et al, 2015), while it has been integrated in
a wide variety of hydrologic, erosion and water quality models (Mohammad & Adamowski 2015).
CN is a function of soil type, land use and antecedent soil moisture conditions. Based on soil
hydrologic group and land use, an extensive record of CN values have been estimated and proposed
by NRCS (1986). The land use has been divided into three main categories including cultivated
agricultural land, other agricultural land and urban areas. Based on these categories and taking into
account the soil hydrologic group, the user can assign the appropriate CN in the study area.
575
Environmental hydrology
Figure 1: Diagram of floods action plan development methodology.
Slope is considered as one of the most influential parameters that can affect runoff. Slope gradient
can be easily calculated in GIS software using a Digital Elevation Model (DEM) and it is expressed
as degrees or percentage. ASTER GDEM (Tachikawa et al, 2011) is a product of NASA and METI
and was used for the purposes of this study. Rainfall is considered as the major contributor to runoff
due to the fact that it constitutes the water source of the runoff process. In fact it is not only the rainfall
amount related to runoff, but also its intensity and duration. Nevertheless, in a simplistic way, the
more precipitation that reach the ground, the more water is available for runoff. Therefore, in order
to incorporate the rainfall component in the runoff risk assessment methodology the annual rainfall
spatial distribution within the basin was produced by interpolation on meteorological station data with
kriging algorithm. Since the variation range of the three components is significantly different (31-100
for CN, 0-5% for slope, 0-1,800 mm for precipitation), it was necessary to perform a standardization
procedure in order to obtain a common variation scale. Therefore, linear increasing fuzzy membership
functions were applied in the three components. The variation range of the produced spatial
distribution maps is 0-1. After the standardization process, which can be easily applied in ArcGIS
software, the three components are summed and as a results the runoff risk assessment map is
produced with values ranging between 0 and 3. This range was classified into five categories, ranging
from very low to very high runoff potential (Figure 2).
576
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2: Diagram of flash floods risk assessment methodology.
Concerning flood risk management, actions, mechanisms and practices have to be identified in order
to:
Reduce the contribution of farms that indicate high surface runoff potential. These actions, measures
and practices are also contributing to the mitigation of flash floods impacts both in the farm and the
basin scale. They can be divided into two major categories including: a) measures that are applied on
farm and aim to reduce surface runoff potential and therefore flash flood risk and b) infrastructures
in which surface runoff can be collected and therefore flash floods impact can be mitigated, while
these infrastructures may also contribute to mitigate river floods.
Mitigate the impacts of river floods before their occurrence (i.e act in a preventive manner), during
them and after them. The actions, mechanisms and practices identified in the basin’s flood risk
management plans (in case that it is existing) which are related to F.OR activities, have to be
incorporated into the current flood risk management plan.
2.2 Study area
The above described methodology is applied for Public Services Company of Platanias Municipality,
located in Crete Island, Greece. Apart from the other activities, supporting the agricultural sector is
one of the main duties of the company. The agricultural activity is taking place in Tavronitis
watershed the boundaries and location of which are presented in Figure 3. As illustrated in Figure 3,
the upper half of the watershed is dominated by agricultural land, while olives constitute the main
crop cultivated there. The watershed covers an area of about 140 km2 while the elevation varies
between 0 and more than 1400 m amsl. According to Kourgialas et al (2015), the average annual
precipitation for the watershed is about 665 mm, while more than 95% of the total annual precipitation
occurs between October and May (Chartzoulakis et al, 2001). The hydrogeological regime of the
watershed consists of karstic formations (high to moderate permeability), alluvial deposits (variable
permeability, miocene deposits (moderate to low permeability), granular non-alluvial deposits (small
to very small permeability) and impermeable formations. According to Kourgialas et al (2015),
577
Environmental hydrology
Tavronitis watershed indicate significant surface runoff potential which is mainly attributed to the
impermeable formations existing at the semi-mountainous part of the watershed.
Figure 3: Location map and agricultural areas of Tavronitis watershed.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Floods risk assessment
With regard to river floods risk assessment, it was based on the Preliminary Floods Risk Assessment
report for Crete District (Hellenic Special Secretariat for Water 2012) as found on the website of the
Hellenic Ministry of Environment and Energy (http://www.ypeka.gr/Default.aspx?tabid=252), as
well as the corresponding flood risk and hazard maps (http://floods.ypeka.gr/) (Hellenic Special
Secretariat for Water 2016). As presented in Figure 4, one high flood risk zone was identified, located
in the northern half of Tavronitis basin, and mainly along Tavronitis main river courses. Moreover,
four recorded historic flood events were identified in Tavronitis River basin, based on the Preliminary
Floods Risk Assessment report, while several other flood events were found in the surrounding area.
The major part of the high flood risk zone is covered by agricultural land, while two education
facilities, one sport facility, two livestock farms and three water supply boreholes are included in the
infrastructures that can potentially be affected by a river flood in Tavronitis basin. With regard to the
population affected three settlements of less than 500 inhabitants each are identified. For recurrence
periods of 50 and 100 years, potential flood impact is predicted to be low or very low. Even for
recurrence interval of 1000 years, potential flood impact can be overall considered as low, except
from the northern part of the basin in which a moderate impact zone is identified and Voukolies
village in which a high impact zone is foreseen. According to the above, river floods risk for the
agricultural sector in Tavronitis basin is not high and it is concentrated to specific areas which cover
a small part of agricultural areas in the basin.
578
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 4: High flood risk areas and historic floods in Tavronitis basin, as identified in the
Hellenic Preliminary Floods Risk Assessment report.
With regard to flash flood risk assessment, the results of surface runoff potential estimation are
presented in Figure 5. The average runoff potential for all agricultural areas ranged from moderate to
high. The lowest average runoff potential was calculated for fruit trees and berry plantations (1.59moderate), while the highest runoff potential was calculated for land principally occupied by
agriculture, with significant areas of natural vegetation (2.52-very high). Especially for olive groves,
which constitute the dominant land cover for Tavronitis basin (32.34%), the average runoff potential
was 2.06 and it is considered as high, while the corresponding range of variation was 0.88 (low) –
2.75 (very high), thus indicating a significant degree of runoff potential variation. Considering the
above, it can be concluded that overall the contribution of the agriculture activity developed in
Tavronitis basin to the development of flash floods is moderate to high, and this is mainly attributed
to significant rainfalls experienced in the southern part of the basin and to the steep slopes of the
topographic relief.
3.2
Floods risk management
3.2.1 Reducing farms contribution to floods
The actions presented below aim to contribute to surface runoff potential reduction and therefore to
directly reduce the contribution of agricultural activity to flash floods. The direct reduction of flash
floods may reduce (depending on the incident) the contribution of agricultural activity to river floods.
A wide range of practices are proposed in the literature which aim to contribute to surface runoff
reduction from crop covered land. The actions practices and measures presented below are chosen
579
Environmental hydrology
from the pool of practices that are to be implemented in the context of the project as well as other
actions applicable to the specific case of Tavronitis basin.
Figure 5: Spatial distribution of runoff potential score and classes in Platanias basin.
The practices implemented and tested within the context of LIFE AgroClimaWater project that
directly or indirectly contribute to surface runoff potential reduction are the following:
No weed control: According to this practice, natural vegetation is preserved during the wet season.
Therefore, soil is covered during the rainy season resulting in surface runoff potential decrease. This
practice is similar to the establishment of cover crops.
No soil tillage: Despite the fact that this practice was incorporated with a view to reduce evaporation
losses, according to Aina (1993) other benefits such as storm runoff reduction and improved
infiltration capacity can be expected by its application.
Physical reduction of surface runoff: Surface runoff can be reduced by introducing physical materials
along the contour lines.
Other practices and measures that are well known to be effective in reducing surface runoff potential
from the farms are the following:
Conservation buffers: This practice includes the development and/or maintenance of small areas or
strips of permanent vegetation. There are several versions of this practice applied such as riparian
buffers, filter strips and grassed waterways.
Avoidance of vehicle movements and wheel ruts on wet soil.
Avoidance to the best possible degree, of heavy machinery use within the farm. Heavy machines are
contributing to soil compaction, which reduces water infiltration capacity thus increasing surface
runoff potential.
Water collection infrastructures can also contribute to flood impacts mitigation and serve as water
saving infrastructures that will provide water during the peak water demand periods. The F.OR has
to upgrade and maintain collaboration with the local authorities and mainly with the local Technical
Services Division and the Water Directorate, Decentralized Administration of Crete in order to
perform a feasibility study for the construction of water collection infrastructures and identify
580
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
potential funding tools such as the National Strategic Reference Framework (NSRF). With regard to
Tavronitis basin, Kourgialas et al. (2015) applied a hydrologic model and indicated several possible
locations for the construction of small hydraulic structures (dam and/or reservoir).
3.2.2 Actions before the flood
Two set of actions are proposed to be taken when a flood incident is expected to occur in order to
ensure sufficient preparation for the flood. The first set of actions is related to actions that can be
taken by the F.OR. The F.OR has to establish a communication channel with the local authorities in
order to be informed when a flood event is expected to occur, which in our case are the Independent
Civil Protection Offices and Fire Stations. Moreover, the F.OR can maintain a list of available
member farmers’ machinery that can be set at the disposal of the authorities to serve during the flood
and/or alleviate its impacts. This list that is originally drawn and maintained by the F.OR
administration, is notified to the Independent Civil Protection Office. As a second step, the F.OR has
to establish a second communication channel with its farmers-members in order to inform them about
the expected flood incident.
A second set of actions that can be applied by the farmers has to be established and communicated to
them. This set includes practical directions easily understood and applied by the farms such as:
Avoid applying fertilizers and plant protection products prior to the flood, since the possibility for
water bodies’ pollution from runoff or leaching is high.
In case that electricity supply is available in the farm, the farmers has to be sure that it is turned off
and secured.
In case that a groundwater pumping well or borehole exists in or near the farm, it has to be sealed
properly in order to avoid runoff water entering through the annulus.
A list of the existing on-farm machinery and equipment has to be drawn.
The farmer has to be sure that potentially hazardous substances, such as fertilizers, plant protection
products and fuels are not exposed in the farm. These should be securely stored in appropriate
infrastructure at the field or removed to such a place off the farm.
The farmer has to secure or remove heavy/hazardous equipment and machinery from the farm.
3.2.3 Actions during the flood
A set of actions can be taken in order to ensure sufficient preparation for the flood. The F.OR has to
get informed about the flood status. Therefore, the F.OR has to stay in touch with the local authorities
(e.g. the Independent Civil Protection Office and Fire Station) and report the availability of F.OR
member farmers’ machinery to help in case this is needed. Information about flood status can be also
retrieved by the local media. Moreover, it has to be clearly stated to the farmers that it is very critical
to avoid being on the farm or any other exposed location during the flood, to find a safe place to stay
and do move without any specific scope and finally to avoid using flooded bridges or river/creek
passages.
3.2.4 Actions after the flood
The set of actions that could be taken after the flood can be divided into those that can be implemented
by the F.OR and those that can be applied by the farmers. Concerning the F.OR actions, it has to get
informed about the impacts of the flood and follow the directions of local Independent Civil
Protection Office and Fire Station. Also the F.OR has to communicate with the local Department of
Rural Economy and Veterinary Prefecture since it is responsible for providing information of farmers
for the protection of agricultural properties according to the Preliminary Flood Risk Assessment
report (Hellenic Special Water Secretariat 2012). As a next step, the F.OR has to communicate the
information to the farmers and ask farmers if fertilizers of plant protection products have been applied
in the farm before the flood and relay this information to the Water Directorate of the District.
With regard to the actions that can be applied by the farmers, the following are proposed:
Be careful when trying to approach your farm in order to avoid injury.
581
Environmental hydrology
Compare the list of your equipment compiled before flood in order to identify damages or losses.
Check the overall status of your farm before and after the flood.
Stay in touch with the F.OR in order to guide you for the next steps.
In case that fertilizers of plant protection products have been applied in the farm before the flood,
communicate this information to the FOR.
Report loss of any agrochemical, piece of equipment or machinery and any changes to the soil cover
at your farm.
The most significant impacts of floods in a farm are deposition of sediment of productive land,
agricultural soil erosion and soil nutrient losses. In order to mitigate the above mentioned impacts the
following practices could be applied by the farmers:
Try to incorporate the sediment excess into the field by tillage. In case that this is not feasible the
sediment has to be removed from the farm and disposed off in a designated site. By no means should
this sediment be disposed off next to the course of a creek, torrent or river.
Try to rehabilitate soil erosion with appropriate tillage. In case that this is not feasible, try to fill the
erosion gaps with material from other sites. Take all precautions to use appropriate soil for this
purpose (adjacent site, consult an agronomist, etc).
Check the nutrient concentrations of the soil in the farm and properly adjust. Cover crops application
has been found to significantly contribute to soil recovery after flooding.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
Although a task of high scientific resources demand, usually organized in regional or national level,
the results of the present study indicate that flood action plans can be compiled in smaller scales, such
as this of Farmers Organization. This can be accomplished by:
gathering existing data from the relevant documents and maps developed in the context of Floods
Directive by EU,
implementing simplified methodologies based on GIS technology and
gathering well-established measures and practices that can contribute to floods’ risk management and
impact mitigation.
It is expected that the compilation and implementation of such action plans can significantly
contribute to floods impact preparedness and response level in the basin scale, since stakeholders and
groups of water users are more actively involved in floods risk and impact management and
mitigation, while the tailor-made action plans maximize the potential of action plans implementation.
With regard to application of the proposed methodology in Tavronitis basin, the results indicated that
despite the fact that river floods risk and impact is mild, flash flood risk is high in a significant part
of agricultural areas. A set of practices and measures easily applied are proposed in order to increase
its preparedness and response level to floods, while establishing communication channels with the
competent authorities is considered as necessary.
Acknowledgements
This work has been elaborated in the framework of the LIFE AgroClimaWater project (LIFE14
CCA/GR/000389) which is gratefully acknowledged.
References
1. Aina P.O. (1993) ‘Rainfall runoff management techniques for erosion control and soil
moisture conservation’, FAO Soils Bulletin (FAO).
2. Ajmal, M., M. Waseem, J.H. Ahn and T.W.Kim (2015) ‘Improved runoff estimation using eventbased rainfall-runoff models’, Water Resources Management, Vol 29(6), pp.1995-2010.
582
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3. Chartzoulakis K.S., N.V. Paranychianakis and A.N. Angelakis. (2001) ‘Water resources
management in the island of Crete, Greece, with emphasis on the agricultural use’, Water Policy,
Vol 3(3), pp. 193-205.
4. FAO (2015) ‘The impact of disasters on agriculture and food security’, Food and Agriculture
Organization.
5. Hellenic Special Secretariat for Water (2012) ‘Preliminary Flood Risk Assessment’, Hellenic
Ministry of Environment, Energy & Climate Change.
6. Hellenic Special Secretariat for Water (2016) ‘Flood risk management plan of Crete Water
District basins’. Hellenic Ministry of Environment & Energy.
7. Kourgialas N.N., G.P. Karatzas and G. Morianou (2015) ‘Water management plan for olive
orchards in a semi-mountainous area of Crete, Greece’, Global Nest Journal, Vol 17(1), pp. 7281.
8. Mohammad F.S. and J. Adamowski (2015) ‘Interfacing the geographic information system,
remote sensing, and the soil conservation service–curve number method to estimate curve number
and runoff volume in the Asir region of Saudi Arabia’, Arabian Journal of Geosciences, Vol
8(12), pp.11093-11105.
9. NRCS-USDA (1986) ‘Urban hydrology for small watersheds’, Technical Release 55 (TR-55)
(Second ed.). Natural Resources Conservation Service, Conservation Engineering Division.
10. Pivot J.M. and P. Martin (2002) ‘Farms adaptation to changes in flood risk: a management
approach’, Journal of Hydrology, Vol 267(1-2), pp.12-25.
11. Posthumus H., Hewett C.J.M., Morris J. and P.F. Quinn (2008) ‘Agricultural land use and flood
risk management: engaging with stakeholders in North Yorkshire’, Agricultural Water
Management, Vol 95(7), pp.787-798.
12. Tachikawa T., Kaku M., Iwasaki A., Gesch D.B., Oimoen M.J., Zhang Z., Danielson J.J., Krieger
T., Curtis B., Haase J. and M. Abrams (2011) ‘ASTER global digital elevation model version
2-summary of validation results’. NASA.
583
Environmental hydrology
MODERN MAPPING TECHNOLOGIES FOR MORPHOMETRY
DYNAMICS OF KERKINI RESERVOIR
I. Tsolakidis1* and M. Vafiadis2
1
Lake Kerkini Management Authority, GR-62055 Kerkini, Kato Poroia, Serres, Macedonia, Greece,
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, School of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th, GR54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
2
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: tsolakidisioannis@gmail.com, tel : +302327028004
Abstract
In a lake ecosystem environment or a reservoir system, the knowledge of some basic parameters, such
as the morphometry of the lake, the basin and the distribution of physical, chemical and biological
parameters is very crucial. The determination of these parameters is fundamental in the
implementation of a management plan for the protection and restoration of lakes and reservoirs. This
paper investigates modern mapping technologies such as GNSS/GPS and sonar systems, for the
estimation of morphometric parameters, as the bottom relief, the hypsographic curves, the volumeheights tables and also the calculation of the deposition rate of sediments in a reservoir. The latter is
a particularly critical problem in reservoirs where hydroelectric plants operate. At the same time, the
paper examines a mapping method, alternative to traditional techniques, faster and significantly more
economical, making a management plan viable. It is the method of satellite bathymetry, which is
based on the extraction of depths, using information from the spectral bands, of a satellite image. For
this purpose, the multi-spectral image of the Worldview-2 satellite is being used. In both mapping
techniques (hydrography and satellite bathymetry), all the necessary reliability checks are
implemented and the comparison between them, lead to conclusions about the use and applicability
of each method. The Kerkini reservoir is the case study, where all these methods and techniques are
applied. The aim of this paper is to describe and propose reliable mapping techniques that contribute
to the efficient management of water systems such as the Kerkini reservoir.
Keywords: Morphometry, GNSS/GPS, satellite bathymetry, reservoir management
1.
INTRODUCTION
In the guidance manuals for lake and reservoir restoration (Olem & Flock, 1990), the calculation of
basic morphometric parameters such as depth, area, volume, shoreline length and other important
elements, that can characterize the ecological value of the water body, is fundamental. The water
quality variables and aquatic organisms (Stefanidis & Papastergiadou, 2012) are also of prime
concern. Moreover, many researchers have highlighted the relationship between the morphometry
and other variables, such as fish production, benthic communities, sedimentation, stratification, and
other (Håkanson, 2005a; Håkanson, 2005b). In our case study, the Kerkini reservoir is a sensitive
ecosystem whose overall status is characterized as "Incomplete" according to the River Basin
Management Plan of the Eastern Macedonia Water Basin (EL11) (Antonaropoulos, 2017). In
addition, no methods and techniques are described for optimal monitoring morphometry of the
reservoir.
In the first part of the study, modern hydrographic techniques are used, such as the GNSS/GPS
systems and a topographical precision single beam sonar, for the determination of a) lake
morphometry and b) deposition rate of sediments, contributing to the overall assessment of ecological
584
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
status of the reservoir (Gąsiorowski, 2008). In the second part of the paper, the hydrographic method
is compared to the alternative method of satellite bathymetry, using the Worldview-2 satellite image,
with 2m spatial resolution and 8 spectral bands. The method of satellite bathymetry, investigates
which bands of the image have the least water absorption, or in other words which bands are most
suited for mapping the bottom (Philpot, 1989; Chang, 2011). For this purpose, two models are
examined, a) the Stumpf algorithm and b) a model of multiple linear regression (Dierssen et al, 2003).
The case study area for this work is the reservoir of lake Kerkini, at the Lake Kerkini National Park,
located in the northern western part of the prefecture of Serres, in the Region of Central Macedonia,
in Greece (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Location of Kerkini reservoir (https://www.google.gr/maps)
2.
HYDROGRAPHY OF KERKINI RESERVOIR
2.1 Methodology
The hydrographic process involved four steps: a) preparing the measurements, b) collecting data, c)
processing and finally d) analyzing the observations. During the first stage, the design of
measurements, calibration and control of measuring instruments (GNSS/GPS system + sonar) was
implemented. For this purpose, stainless steel structures were designed and constructed for both the
stabilization of instruments on the vessel (Figure 2) and their calibration. After all the necessary tests,
the hydrographic measurements were carried out.
Figure 2. Mounting pole with survey instruments on the surveying vessel
585
Environmental hydrology
For the mapping of Kerkini reservoir, the RTK GNSS/GPS method was used (Figure 3), in
conjunction with the depth measurements from echo sounder, while the contribution of the Network
RTK method of Virtual Reference Station (VRS) was investigated. (Henning, 2008; El-mowafy,
2012; Mageed, 2013). The mapping datum of the project was the Greek Geodetic Reference System
of 1987 (GGRS '87). The overall period of hydrographic measurements lasted from 29/05/2014 until
11/07/2014 (Figure 4).
Figure 4. Final hydrographic and topographic
measurements at Kerkini reservoir
Figure 3. Schema of RTK measurements
The mapping statistics of the Lake Kerkini were as follows:
• 17 days of hydrography
• 3 days of additional topographic measurements
• Total Points: 87271
• Total route length: 445.58Km
• Average hydrographic speed of the vessel: 6.19Km/h
• Total working hours: 69h 14m 30sec
A quality assessment of the GNSS/GPS observations from hydrographic measurements was then
followed. The last step was the "data cleaning" process and the selection of the interpolation method,
for the creation of bathymetric model (Figure 5).
For the external accuracy control of the bathymetric model, ten (10) points were topographically
measured with the RTK GNSS/GPS technique, well distributed in the revealed delta, during the
lowest water level season. Their elevations were then compared, with the corresponding elevations
of the model. After the completion of the external control, morphometric data were produced, such
as the bottom relief, volumetric tables, hypsographic curves, etc. (Figures 5, 6).
586
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 5. Bathymetry model of Kerkini reservoir with contour interval = 0.5m (pixel
size=20x20m)
Figure 6. Hypsographic curves of Kerkini reservoir
2.2 Sedimentation rate
Another study, very significant for monitoring the reservoir storage and also for the smooth operation
of hydroelectric plants at dams, was the determination of the deposition rate of sediments. It is noted
that a hydroelectric plant is operating at a close distance from Kerkini Dam. In order to draw
conclusions about the deposition rate at Kerkini reservoir, volumetric tables were used from earlier
mapping projects of Kerkini in 1984 and older. Comparing the volumes, a decrease in the deposition
rate of the reservoir was recorded, for the period of thirty years (1984-2014), equal to 683x103 m3/yr.
Combining older data, from the early years of construction and operation of the reservoir in 1933
(Psilobikos et al, 1994), the decline trend of the deposition rate can be observed for over all these
years, up to the last mapping in 2014 (Figure 7). It should be noted, however, that any calculations,
such as volumes and changing rates of volumes, must be accompanied by their respective
uncertainties, since the accuracy and specifications of the work and the instruments used in each
mapping project are not always known (Dorst, 2004; Wilson L & Richards M, 2006; Czuba et al,
2012; Tsolakidis, 2017).
587
Environmental hydrology
Figure 7.Deposition rate from 1933 to 2014 at Kerkini reservoir
3.
SATELLITE BATHYMETRY OF LAKE KERKINI
3.1 Methodology
The next step was the implementation of satellite bathymetry for extracting the depths of Lake
Kerkini. Satellite bathymetry is a more economical method for studying the morphology of water
bodies, which under conditions, might replace more traditional techniques, due to increasing spatial
and spectral resolution of new satellites. This method, which belongs to passive remote sensing
methods, attempts to replace the calculation of scattering and absorption coefficients at each point
with regression models using known depths and spectral values (Lyzenga, 1978; Stumpf & Pennock,
1989; Stumpf et al, 2003). Finally, two models were tested, a) the Stumpf linear model (Equation 1),
which is suitable for low reflectance bottoms and b) the model of Multiple Linear Regression
(Equation 2). The available captured date of the image used for satellite bathymetry, was 08/08/2014,
few days after the completion of hydrographic measurements.
(1)
Where:
z is the depth
m1, m0 are the addition and offset to adapt the results of the algorithm to the depth, respectively
Rw(λ1), Rw (λ2) the values of the pixels in the bands λ1 and λ2, respectively
(2)
Where:
z is the depth
a0, a1, a2, ..., an are the coefficients of the multiple regression
X1, X2, ..., Xn are the linearized values of the pixels of the satellite image, λ1, λ2, ..., λn, respectively
588
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
For practical reasons, the Stumpf model will be referred to as model 1 and the model of the multiple
regression as model 2.
3.2 Worldview-2 satellite image processing
All the necessary calibrations and corrections (geometric, atmospheric etc) were performed on the
Worldview-2 satellite image (Figure 8), in order to compute the water leaving radiance. The last step
was to apply a mask to the image, so that only the "wet" pixels (lakes, rivers) remain. The resulting
final image (Figure 9) was used to apply and evaluate the bathymetric models.
For the implementation of model 1, the Coastal and Yellow bands of the Worldview-2 final image
(Figure 8) were used, while all the bands were involved in model 2. The coefficients of the linear
regression were then calculated and the two models compared, based on the criterion of the largest
R2. The equation applied to the Worldview-2 image (Figure 9) was the one of multiple linear
regression (Equation 3).
Figure 8. Multispectral image of
Worldview-2 satellite before any correction
(R=6,G=3,B=2)
Figure 9. Final image of "wet" pixels at
Kerkini reservoir after all corrections
(R=5,G=3,B=2)
(3)
The last step was the accuracy control of the bathymetric model, obtained by the method of satellite
bathymetry. For this purpose the difference image technique was applied (Williams, 2012). The result
of satellite bathymetry was subtracted from the model that resulted from the hydrography. Then,
based on the difference image (Figure 10), the difference diagram was calculated, according to
specific depth ranges. From the study of the diagram of Figure 11, it appears that a percentage of
63.03% of the pixels of the two models have a difference ranging from 0 to 50cm.
589
Environmental hydrology
Figure 10. Difference image from hydrography and satellite bathymetry
Figure 11. Percentage of pixels per depth range from difference image
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
In this paper, the application of modern mapping technologies and methods (GNSS/GPS and sonar)
for the extraction of reliable morphometric parameters of Kerkini reservoir, aiming to the efficient
management of the water body was presented. In addition, it was investigated whether an alternative
technique such as satellite bathymetry, could replace more traditional mapping techniques and reduce
the final cost.
From the hydrographic results, it has been shown that the use of RTK GNSS/GPS and sonar systems
is indicated, for an efficient and accurate mapping of large reservoirs. For Kerkini, it should be noted
that any future mapping should follow modern methods (continuous semi automated) rather than
classical ones (manual point by point). In addition, the applied system can provide satisfactory
accuracy in calculating the bottom elevation. With the RTK GNSS/GPS method, this accuracy
decreases as the vessel moves away from the permanent GNSS station. Using the network method of
VRS, this problem is solved. Regarding the changing rate of the volume at the Kerkini reservoir, a
continuous decrease in the deposition rate was observed until 2014. However, it is crucial to mention
that in such applications, the knowledge of methods and accuracy of hydrographic projects is
590
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
prerequisite. The extraction of important morphometric data, such as volumetric tables etc, is based
on their reliability. Comparison between volumes of different years, produced by different
instruments and other specifications, should be carefully considered, taking into account relevant
uncertainties, in order to draw safe conclusions.
With regard to satellite bathymetry, it has emerged that the model of multiple linear regression leads
to better results than the Stumpf model. The most important band variables, from the Worldview-2
satellite, which contributed most to the depth extraction model, were Green and Red. However, the
results in a bathymetric model and their interpretation are directly dependent upon the clarity of water
and the atmospheric conditions that affect the image captured by the satellite. Concerning the
comparison of the model of the satellite bathymetry with the hydrographic model, it was found that
the majority of the pixels of the difference image (63.03%), had a difference ranging from 0 to 50cm.
The precision tolerance of the satellite bathymetry, for 63.03% of the bottom pixels, has a mean value
of ±25cm, if the hydrography is considered as a reference surface. For the other pixels, this value is
increased.
In general, the adoption of a method, in the extraction of morphometric parameters, depends on the
instruments and data available, the environmental and atmospheric conditions and the estimated
budget. In low-budget cases, where the morphometry of a reservoir is selected to be studied with
passive remote sensing methods, a distinction should be made between water status, turbidity and
atmospheric factors, because they are all affecting the reliability of satellite bathymetry. In cases of
low turbidity (typically<10 NTU), satellite bathymetry can be used with greater reliability, always in
conjunction with on-site depth measurements, which will calibrate the bathymetry model. In addition,
by using free data from Sentinel missions, with high temporal, spatial and spectral analysis, the total
cost is dramatically reduced. In cases of high turbidity of reservoirs such as Kerkini, the method to
be applied depends on the precision requirements of the application. For extracting bottom elevations
and assessing the changing rate in volume, where the specifications on accuracy are strict, the
hydrographic method is considered more appropriate. However, as shown in Figure 10, satellite
bathymetry has yielded satisfactory results across the depth range of the lake. The average accuracy
of ±25cm refers to both the low depths and the high ones. With a more appropriate date of image
selection and at a period with less turbidity in the reservoir, the percentage of the difference pixels,
ranging from 0 to 50cm, is estimated to increase over 85%, leading in more encouraging results about
the use of the method.
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank the Lake Kerkini Management Authority, which provided us with the satellite
image data and contributed to the implementation of hydrographic measurements. Also we are
grateful, for all the help they provided to this project, to Professor Krestenitis Ioannis, School of Civil
Engineering, AUTh, who provided us with the necessary topographic instruments and Professor
Albanakis Konstantinos, School of Geology, AUTh, for his comments on the sedimentation process
in lake Kerkini and satellite bathymetry models.
References
1. Antonaropoulos, P. (2017) ‘Review of River Basin Management Plan of Water District of Eastern
Macedonia (EL11)’, (in Greek).
2. Chang, C.W. (2011) ‘Retrieval of Water Optical Properties From Eight-Spectral Band
Worldview-2 Satellite Images’, 32nd Asian Conference on Remote Sensing 2011, ACRS 2011.
3. Czuba, J. a. et al. (2012) ‘Changes in Sediment Volume in Alder Lake’, Nisqually River Basin ,
Washington, 1945 – 2011.
4. Dierssen, H.M. et al. (2003) ‘Ocean color remote sensing of seagrass and bathymetry in the
Bahamas Banks by high resolution airborne imagery’, Limnology and Oceanography,
48(1_part_2), pp.444–455.
591
Environmental hydrology
5. Dorst, L.L. (2004). ‘Survey plan improvement by detecting sea floor dynamics in archived
echosounder surveys’, International Hydrographic Review, 5, pp.49–63.
6. El-mowafy, A. (2012) ‘Precise Real-Time Positioning Using Network RTK’, Global Navigation
Satellite Systems - Signal, Theory and Applications, pp.161–188.
7. Gąsiorowski, M. (2008) ‘Deposition Rate of Lake Sediments Under Different Alternative Stable
States’, Geochronometria, 32(1), pp.29–35. Available at:
8.
http://www.degruyter.com/view/j/geochr.2008.32.issue--1/v10003-008-0020-y/v10003-0080020-y.xml.
9. Håkanson, L. (2005a) ‘The importance of lake morphometry and catchment characteristics in
limnology - Ranking based on statistical analyses’, Hydrobiologia, 541(1), pp.117–137.
10. Håkanson, L. (2005b) ‘The importance of lake morphometry for the structure and function of
lakes’, International Review of Hydrobiology, 90(4), pp.433–461.
11. Henning, W. (2008) ‘National Geodetic Survey User Guidelines For Classical Real Time GNSS
Positioning’, Tech. Report.
12. Lyzenga, D.R. (1978) ‘Passive remote sensing techniques for mapping water depth and bottom
features’, Applied optics, 17(3), pp.379–383.
13. Mageed, K.M.A. (2013) ‘Accuracy evaluation between GPS Virtual Reference Station (VRS) and
GPS Real Time Kinematic (RTK) techniques’, World Applied Sciences Journal, 24(9),
pp.1154–1162.
14. Olem, H. & Flock, G. (1990) ‘The Lake and Reservoir Restoration Guidance Manual Second
Edition Lake and Reservoir Restoration’, pp.1–35. Available at:
15. http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.7282/T3JD4WCD.
16. Philpot, W.D. (1989) ‘Bathymetric mapping with passive multispectral imagery’, Appl. Opt.,
28(8), pp.1569–1578. Available at: http://ao.osa.org/abstract.cfm?URI=ao-28-8-1569.
17. Psilovikos, Α. et al. (1994) ‘Study of Environmental Impact Assessment of Strymonas River
Protected Area Projects, Lake Kerkini, Streams of the Serres Plain’, Ministry of Environment and
Waters, Directorate of Land Reclamation Works (D7), Department of Technical Support.
18. Stefanidis, K. & Papastergiadou, E. (2012) ‘Relationships between lake morphometry, water
quality, and aquatic macrophytes, in greek lakes’, Fresenius Environmental Bulletin, 21(10 A),
pp.3018–3026.
19. Stumpf, R.P. et al. (2003) ‘Determination of water depth with high-resolution satellite imagery
over variable bottom types’, Limnology and Oceanography, 48(1_part_2), pp.547–556.
20. Stumpf, R.P. & Pennock, J.R. (1989) ‘Calibration of a general optical equation for remote sensing
of suspended sediments in a moderately turbid estuary’ Journal of Geophysical Research,
94(C10), p.14363.
21. Tsolakidis, I., (2017) ‘Comparison of hydrographic and satellite bathymetry methods for
geomorphology study of reservoirs: Case study of lake kerkini reservoir’, Phd Thesis, Aristotle
University of Thessaloniki, (in Greek).
22. Williams, R.D. (2012) ‘DEMs of Difference’, Geomorphological Techniques, 2, pp.1–17.
23. Wilson L, G. & Richards M, J. (2006) ‘Procedural Documentation and Accuracy Assessment of
Bathymetric Maps and Area / Capacity Tables for Small Reservoirs’,U.S. Geological Survey
Scientific Investigations Report 2006-5208, 24p.
592
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Ground water resources management
593
Ground water resources management
594
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
BUILDING GROUNDWATER CONCEPTUAL MODELS UNDER
LIMITED INFORMATION SUPPLY: A CASE STUDY ON AXIOS
DELTA, NORTH GREECE
L. Kapetas1*, N. Kazakis1, T. Spachos2, K. Voudouris1
1
Lab. of Engineering Geology & Hydrogeology, Dept. of Geology, Aristotle University of
Thessaloniki, Greece 2Thessaloniki Water Supply & Sewerage Co. S.A.
*Corresponding author: E-mail: leonkapetas@gmail.com
Abstract
Poor hydrogeological conceptualisation can have adverse effects on the accurate representation of
flow processes simulated by numerical models. This work explores the idea of conceptual model
building in complex settings with limited spatiotemporal information supply. The case study of the
eastern coastal aquifer in the Axios Delta area is examined, where ecological, irrigation and urban
water supply demands exert pressure on local water resources. The water demands are covered by the
exploitation of surface water and groundwater resulting in a decrease in river flow over the last
decades and the salinization of Axios Delta area. The Delta is currently under the environmental
responsibility of numerous agencies which have available data according to their specific activities.
A detailed step-by-step data collection was performed including lithological profiles, water level
measurements, river abstractions, climatological data, geological and geomorphological maps. In this
context, a conceptual model accounting for surface-subsurface interactions, recharge processes and
human interventions is developed to support hydrogeological modelling for evaluating risk of
saltwater intrusion and long-term sustainability of the ecosystem under climate change scenarios.
Further uncertainty is introduced by the complex nature of the deltaic deposits. Confidence in the
conceptual model is discussed and how it propagates through to the simulation predictions. The
numerical model will inform systematic monitoring recommendations on an ease-of-implementation
basis to improve confidence. This can have implications on improving the understanding and overall
resilience of the deltaic ecosystem resource as supported by international policies. The establishment
of the hydrogeological conceptual model in this area could be the base of an integrated monitoring
plan, which is essential for a rational water management in the coastal zone.
Keywords: Coastal zone; Conceptual modelling; Hydrogeological model; Uncertainty management;
Saltwater intrusion; Climate change
1.
INTRODUCTION
Numerical simulation modeling has become the standard methodology in industry and academia in
the effort of analysing hydrological and hydrogeological processes. This has become possible thanks
to advanced commercial/research simulation engines that are supported by affordable, significant
computational power. It is critical that these computational models are based on a sound conceptual
model (Anderson et al., 2015). Good conceptual understanding requires data that are obtained in
strategically selected spatiotemporal scales. Only then computational models can become useful tools
to test the conceptual model, be calibrated to a set of observations and finally used to make future
predictions as, for instance, on the impact of anthropogenic activities, specific policies or those of
climate change (Middelkoop et al., 2001). It can be conceived as a three-step iterative methodology:
(i) information collection, (ii) conceptual model building, and finally (iii) computational model
595
Ground water resources management
construction, calibration and predictive simulations. There is an iteration between these three steps
depending on the confidence to the results.
Though hydrological or hydrogeological applications can vary in scale or purpose, the framework
remains broadly the same. For instance, flood modeling requires detailed terrain observations and
hydrological inputs over a catchment scale (Komi et al., 2017). This information is used to
conceptually understand the behavior of the catchment and supports models to understand the key
factors contributing to flood risk. Models can then be used to predict the impact that hard or soft flood
alleviation engineering measures can have (Roger Few, 2003). Other basin models exist that focus
on water resources management and planning. In this case, the information required is not focused
on extreme events, rather is meant to provide accurate water balance to inform decision making
around usage and allocation (Berhe et al., 2013). With regards to the development of groundwater
models, the conceptual model understanding requires knowledge on aquifer characteristics, such as
geometry, type, boundary conditions and thickness, aquifer properties (i.e. hydraulic conductivity,
storativity) and piezometric information as well as on recharge and discharge rates (Ye et al., 2010).
Groundwater interactions with surface water features (lakes, rivers), or the sea for a coastal aquifer,
define boundary conditions that influence subsurface flows.
The number of observations that are used for calibration of these models range across different spatial
scales (rainfall, head) and extrapolation is always applied. The density of the information network
will depend on the complexity of the study area, economics, as well as the spatial and temporal scale
at which the problems is explored. Depending on the nature of the particular study, seasonal
variability due to rainfall, exchange with surface water bodies or well abstractions is doomed less
important and the impact of these processes on the model can be dampened (Sutanudjaja et al., 2011).
On the other hand, when studying saltwater intrusion in a coastal aquifer or the mixing between waters
of different salinity such information becomes critical. Furthermore, as variable density will affect
flow dynamics, the computational model needs to account for mass transfer phenomena (Bear et al.,
2013). Thus, geochemical information is also required.
The iterative process of information collection and use in conceptual model building and simulation
model calibration is summarised in Figure 1. When there is sufficient confidence on the conceptual
model, based on the agreement between the numerical model and the observations, then the iteration
process is deemed complete.
Figure 1. Iterative process of information collection, its use to construct a conceptual model
and calibrate the numerical model.
596
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The breadth of applications clearly demonstrates the need to work across different scales where
catchments include different users and have physical complexity: decision-making regarding water
allocation can be modelled on the regional scale but can have impacts on sensitive ecosystems and
aquifers on a local scale. This is a well-known persisting challenge that policies for Integrated Water
Resource Management (IWRM) aim to address (Ingold et al., 2016). How data are collected to
supplement models and decision-making by stakeholders across different scales is the focus of this
paper. This is explored for the case of Axios Delta and its coastal aquifer. It is intended to build a
conceptual model using information collected by public and private organisations involved in a
variety of sectors and activities. This conceptual model will serve as the basis for a numerical
simulation model that will support the hydrogeological understanding of the aquifer.
Recommendations are made for new information requirements that will increase the confidence of
the conceptualisation and modeling response. Ultimately, this modeling tool will be used to produce
recommendations for the protection of the aquifer from climate change and anthropogenic threats.
2.
CASE STUDY AREA
2.1 Geography
The Axios River Delta is located on the coast of Northern Greece where Axios River discharges into
the Mediterranean Sea in the Gulf of Thermaikos. The Delta is formed at the confluence of four rivers,
namely Aliakmonas, Loudias, Axios and Gallikos from west to east. Aliakmonas contributes
significant flows to the delta. Axios is a transboundary river shared between FYROM and Greece. Its
catchment has an area of 24,437 Km2, with about 12% of this area in the Greek territory. Though an
agreement on river flow management and coordination was established between the two countries in
1959 (Global Water Partnership, 2012), no formal agreement is practically active today. Like Greece,
FYROM makes abstractions from the river for agricultural use. This has resulted in uncertain flows
reaching across the border depending on upstream abstractions requirements and climatic conditions.
Within the Greek territory, most abstractions take place at the mouth of the river as water intensive
rice paddy fields cover the largest part of the deltaic valley. Groundwater abstractions on its eastern
part take place to cover urban demands, primarily during drought condition when the alternative
major sources of water supply for the city of Thessaloniki are under pressure (EYATH, 2018). At the
same time, quality of transboundary surface water and groundwater is moderate due to nitrate
contamination, metal pollution, wastewater discharges and solid dumping (Karageorgis et al., 2005;
Milovanovic, 2007).
Axios Delta comprises a National Park since 2009 (Axios-Loudias-Aliakmonas Management
Authority, 2018), has significant biodiversity value and offers extensive ecosystem services
supported by the ecological flow (Hadjicharalambous et al., 2015), i.e. maintaining the functions of
this ecosystem depends on the supply of sufficient water quantity of good quality. It is critically
important to consider the aquifer’s regime in an Integrated Water Resource Management Plan
especially when a strong interaction between groundwater and surface waters occurs.
Climate is transitional continental to Mediterranean on the Koppen-Geiger classification (Bear-ID
Novatek, 2016; Kotinis-Zambakas et al., 1984). The mean annual precipitation is 443 mm, as
calculated from a continuous rainfall record in the area (Chalastra Station, 1974-2004) (Grimpylakos
et al., 2016) though recent years have seen higher precipitation.
2.2 Geology and Hydrogeology
The Axios catchment spans a range of geological formations and with complex geotectonical
structure. The mountainous part of the catchment comprises of schists, gneiss, ultramafic rocks and
granites as wells as carbonate rocks such as limestones and dolomites. Neogene and Quaternary
sediments are located in lowlands of the basin. In this study we focused on the sedimentary formation
in the boundaries of the model domain (Figure 2). Holocene deposits dominate in the study area
consisting of coastal deposits (gravel and sand), red clay with calcareous concretionary bodies, while
597
Ground water resources management
in the base the conglomerates dominate. Sand accumulations occur along the Axios river bed. Coarse
materials of pebbles and sand of small thickness occur in the northwestern part of the study area. In
the northern west part Neogene formation of sand and loose conglomerates of great thickness in
alternation with cohesive conglomerates and sandstones are placed. In the Northern east part of the
study area the red clay series consisting of red to brick red silty clays with mica and calcareous
concretionary bodies are located. The hydrogeological units can be distinguished based on the
geological formations of the quaternary and Neogene porous aquifers (Figure 2). The area of interest
is located in the quaternary formations and the aquifers are under unconfined and semi-confined
conditions. Groundwater flow direction is from the Northern part to the coast, while a strong
interaction occurs between the Rivers of Axios and Gallikos with the unconfined aquifer. The aquifer
is recharged by Axios River during the entire hydrological year, while Gallikos River has seasonal
flow recharging the aquifer during the winter period. However, the interaction between the Gallikos
River and the upper aquifer is under consideration. The deeper aquifers are recharged from margins
of the basin as well as the leaks of the upper aquifer.
2.3 Water Management
Water management for the protection of the Delta is addressed in the Integrated Water Management
Plan for the catchment of Axios, along with plans for other catchments in the Central Macedonia
Region (Ministry of Environment and Energy, 2014). The plan identifies as pressures to the broader
Delta area (i) the relatively small extent (3.3%) of urbanisation, (ii) the diversion of flows from the
River, (iii) the drainage of flows from Artzan and Amatobou to Axios River. With regard to the Delta,
the second intervention is the most significant. As shown in Table 1, the total abstraction at the Axios
Delta area amount to an annual 432,300,000 m3. Agricultural activities at the eastern section are
responsible for 50% of these extractions. Regarding the objectives set out in the Water Framework
Directive 2000/60, according to the Management Plan, the area is deemed likely not to meet them.
The key reasons are contamination from Loudias and the Deltaic Area (industrial/agro-industrial
waste, cattle farming, agricultural waste).
With respect to subsurface water bodies, the Management Plan pulls current knowledge (up to 2014)
of groundwater quality from different studies. A surface phreatic aquifer spreads across Axios Valley
(from Axioupoli to the Delta area), with a variable depth. This system is fed through interaction with
the surface and directly by the river. Well abstractions in the central part of the valley have caused a
significant drop in the local water table which is now below sea level. This causes concerns for
seawater intrusion. However, the surface irrigation of the rice fields in the delta area acts as a
hydraulic barrier. The effectiveness of this mechanism is not clear (AUTH & YETOS consultants,
2010). In the same study, historical precipitation and flow conditions (potentially indicating a
drought) have been analysed based on the Standardised Precipitation Index (SPI) and Standardised
Runoff Index (SRI) (Angelidis et al., 2012). Significant water stress periods have been detected for
four years between 1984-1992. An action plan is in place for drought emergencies and it includes
strategic drought prevention/precautionary measures, operational measures (water uses
prioritization), organisational and monitoring measures (European Commission - EuropeAid Cooperation Office, 2007). Operational measures include, among others, the increased use of
groundwater, the protection of protected wetlands, the increased abstraction from rivers near
discharge to the sea by relaxation of environmental flow regulation and the interruption of irrigation
to water-demanding crops. In the aforementioned measures a trade-off is necessary for the case of
Axios delta: the use of groundwater will affect the delta ecosystem. At the same time, the permitted
abstraction from the delta region will affect the protected zone. Post-drought measures include water
allocation to support ecosystem recovery. Droughts can also induce sea-water intrusion (Kouzana et
al., 2009). Depending on the local geochemistry this process can be near to irreversible (Han et al.,
2015) but this has not been recognised in the Management Plan (Ministry of Environment and Energy,
2014).
598
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2. Conceptual model boundaries and hydrogeological units to be considered. Axios and
Gallikos rivers form the west and east boundaries respectively.
3.
CONCEPTUAL MODEL
Potential impacts of climate change to the regional climate may lead to: (i) changes of rainfall patterns
both in terms of absolute total annual rainfall or seasonal variability with an increase of extreme
events, (ii) temperature changes altering evapotranspiration patterns and irrigation requirements (iii)
changes in river flows, and (iv) increased sea levels which can have a significant effect on the deltaic
area and the coastal aquifer. Such climate change impacts are non-uniform across Europe. Projections
have been attempted based on climate models and downscaling processes, while researchers have
been attempting to provide impact envelopes for projections (Gampe et al., 2016; Kontogianni et al.,
599
Ground water resources management
2014; Marcos-Garcia et al., 2017; Masciopinto & Liso, 2016). These projections can inform scenario
formulations of predictive simulations using hydrogeological flow/mass-transfer models.
At the same time, anthropogenic interactions with water resources, such as the excessive exploitation
of groundwater in the central Axios valley, can further increase risks to the subsurface water systems.
These risks combined make a risk analysis necessary for the subsurface system of Axios Delta and
estuary; the conceptual model presented here is the first step for this analysis. This model will inform
a hydrogeological flow/mass-transfer models.
Table 1. Average annual abstractions from Axios River at different locations in the wider
Delta Area. (source: Ministry of Environment and Energy, 2015).
Annual Volume (103m3/year)
Location
Ag. Athanasios (east)
88,232
Nea Magnisia (east)
6,488
Chalastra-Kalochori (east)
119,949
Brahias
40,180
Koufalia
4,570
Malgara
74,343
Monastiri
65,901
Chalkidona
32,637
Delta Total =
432,300
Delta East =
214,669
Abstractions Ratio (East/Total)%
49.7
The biophysical processes which comprise the components of the subsurface-surface interactions are
shown in Figure 3. Based on the hydrogeological information presented in Section 2, two aquifers
are conceptualized at this stage. Their thickness is variable and there are potentially other local-scale
aquifer units. However, due to lack of detailed information no further compartmentalization is
considered. Axios and Gallikos Rivers form the west and east boundaries of the area were also
considered. On the north of the modelled area, two hydrogeological units are conceptualized, namely
sand and loose conglomerates and red clay series.
Figure 3. Water fluxes among various conceptual model components.
Moreover, as shown in Figure 2, the boundaries of the conceptual model are marginally narrower
than the area of interest. The reason for this selection is that no information is currently available to
support a wider domain definition. The processes taking place in the domain include: upper aquifer
exchanges with Axios River (the direction of this flow is predominantly from Axios to the aquifer),
600
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
similar exchanges between the aquifer and Gallikos River, flows from the upper to the lower aquifer,
groundwater flows from the Hydrogeological Units of sand and loose conglomerates and red clay
series to the two aquifers, net deep-infiltration to the upper phreatic aquifer as a function of rainfall,
irrigation, water recirculation and evapotranspiration, river discharges to the sea, aquifer groundwater
discharge to the sea, well abstractions and seawater intrusion to the aquifers.The dynamics between
the latter three processes will be the subject for further characterisation in the numerical model (not
part of the present work).
4.
DATA ANALYSIS
Existing data to carry out this analysis have been collected from literature and stakeholders active in
the area. As data collection has been carried out for diverse purposes, and not for this particular
investigation, the spatial and temporal resolution is not ideal. Some extrapolations/projections were
carried out in this section and, whenever this was required, it has been reported. The ideal spatial and
temporal resolutions are being discussed to provide a better understanding of uncertainty propagation
when these are used as input to the numerical model.
(i)
River water levels: as Axios and Gallikos rivers comprise the boundary conditions of the
models, information regarding their water levels is necessary. For Axios river, these are obtained for
a range of fluxes from 5 to 60 m3/s which represent baseline to high flows at six locations along the
lower half of the east boundary. The respective free water surface is also known. Relationships
between topographic information and water surface will be used to calculate the boundary condition
in the upper half of the boundary. This input is obtained from the hydrodynamic model of Axios River
(Papadimos, 2015). Gallikos deltaic area in the downstream had been depleted in the past due to
anthropogenic interventions. Currently, continuous flow has been restored due to the recovery of the
river as well as due to water transfers from Aliakmonas River (channel transfer for Thessaloniki’s
water supply). Regular monitoring is proposed in the area to improve knowledge of this boundary
condition.
(ii)
River abstractions and irrigation: abstractions from Axios River are considered here in order
to calculate the irrigation rates. Irrigation takes place between the months of May and October. Daily
data were provided for the three main irrigation zones, namely Agios Athanasios, Chalastra and Nea
Magnisia. These data are averaged on a daily basis for every month as seen in Table 2. These values
can be uniformly distributed (as rice fields cover the whole area predominantly) to calculate irrigation
rates per unit area.
(iii)
Groundwater abstractions: groundwater abstractions within the model area are located in the
east section. An abstraction annual average of about 60x106 m3/year and 6x106m3/year is estimated
for Axios and Gallikos basins respectively (Ministry of Environment and Energy, 2014). These
extractions take place in the summer months; hence, a daily average needs to reflect the period
between May and September.
(iv)
Rainfall: a rainfall record is available for the last seven years. Table 3 presents total rainfall
depths for the years that have a complete record. These observations serve for the calculation of deep
infiltration, i.e. aquifer recharge.
(v)
Evapotranspiration and Recirculation: rice cultivation requires flooding of the area during the
summer months. For this reason, potential evapotranspiration (PET) rates are practically taking place.
The recirculation of drained water via a pumped system suggests that there is increased time for PET
to take place and, therefore, reduced deep percolation/infiltration occurs.
Groundwater levels and hydrochemistry: groundwater piezometric information exists for a number
of wells primarily situated in the east part of the study area. These observations suggest the presence
of an unconfined and a partially pressurized aquifer, as discussed in section 3. This inference is
corroborated by the differing hydrochemistry of the two sets of observations (Nitrate and TDS levels).
601
Ground water resources management
Ideally, more observations would be required on the southern border to identify the saltwaterfreshwater interface.
Table 2. Daily averaged abstraction flows (m3/s) from Axios River between 2010-2013
(source: GOEB).
Month
May
June
July
August
September
October
Daily Average (cumecs)
47
41
42
37
12
2
Table 3. Monthly rainfall depths (mm) for years with complete record between 2010-2017.
5.
Month/Year
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Total
2010
16
126
46
29
76
49
72
1
20
140
20
27
622
2012
24
27
45
45
110
29
1
15
59
34
111
60
561
2014
32
68
35
0
0
0
48
37
81
69
105
167
643
2015
45
40
111
19
11
93
4
36
69
101
33
0
562
2016
30
43
106
12
94
23
15
50
157
39
21
1
591
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
This work provided a methodological understanding of the building process of a hydrogeological
conceptual model under limited information supply. Hydrometric and hydrogeological data are not
always collected in a suitable spatiotemporal scale. Yet, the production of a conceptual model to
support the construction of a numerical model can still be feasible. The confidence to this conceptual
model will then need to be established during numerical model calibration. On this basis, new
observations can be requested in specific areas where simulation confidence is lower, i.e.
recommended targeted observation points. In the case study, these are the interface between saltwaterfreshwater and Gallikos river levels. Complementarily, piezometers on the north boundary with
longer record could improve confidence.
It was shown that a compromise needs to be made with regard to model dimensions, i.e. the selection
of boundaries. In cases where the available data do not provide sufficient information for a larger
area, it is proposed that the selected area can be smaller than the area of interest. The boundary
conditions of the model will play a major role in how the domain interacts with the area outside the
model. This approach was followed for Axios River Delta and its aquifers. Trade-offs exist between
(i) model domain size, (ii) expected simulation times (computational power), (iii) amount of collected
information and (iv) confidence to simulation results. Model parsimony has been the key principle
adopted. This model will support the construction of a hydrogeochemical model evaluating seawater
intrusion in the subsurface water systems.
Water management can affect how the phenomenon plays out in an uncertain future. Climate change
might alter hydrological patterns resulting in droughts and/or also cause sea level rise. The numerical
model supported by this conceptual model can be a useful tool to test these scenarios and create a
portfolio of effective management options; informed decision-making on water use and allocation
can be part of a mitigation strategy of seawater intrusion. This evaluation is relevant for other coastal
aquifers that are over-exploited and/or are likely to suffer similar impacts of climate change.
Acknowledgement
We thank the National Scholarship Foundation of Greece (IKY) for funding this research work. We
also thank the local stakeholders (Institute for Geology and Mineral Exploration, GOEV, the Hellenic
Agricultural Organisation, Land Reclamation Institute, Axios Delta National Park Authority) for
sharing their data and knowledge on the area.
602
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
References
1. Anderson, M.P., Woessner, W.W., & Hunt, R.J. (2015). Applied Groundwater Modeling:
Simulation of Flow and Advective Transport. Academic Press.
2. Angelidis, P., Maris, F., Kotsovinos, N., & Hrissanthou, V. (2012). Computation of Drought
Index SPI with Alternative Distribution Functions. Water Resources Management: An
International Journal, Published for the European Water Resources Association (EWRA), 26(9),
2453–2473.
3. AUTH & YETOS consultants (2010). Surface and Groundwater Quality Control in MacedoniaThrace-Thessaly: Results for Axios River Basin. Ministry of Agricultural Development (in
Greek).
4. Axios-Loudias-Aliakmonas Management Authority. (2018). Protection status – Axios Delta
National Park. Retrieved January 8, 2018, from http://axiosdelta.gr/en/national-park/protectionstatus/
5. Bear, J., Cheng, A., Sorek, S., Ouazar, D., & Herrera, I. (2013). Seawater Intrusion in Coastal
Aquifers: Concepts, Methods and Practices. Springer Science & Business Media.
6. Bear-ID Novatek (2016). European climate zones and bio-climatic design requirements.
Horizon 2020. Retrieved from www.pvsite.eu
7. Berhe, F.T., Melesse, A.M., Hailu, D., & Sileshi, Y. (2013). MODSIM-based water allocation
modeling of Awash River Basin, Ethiopia. CATENA, 109(Supplement C), 118–128.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.catena.2013.04.007
8. European Commission - EuropeAid Co-operation Office. (2007). Euro-Mediterranean Regional
Programme for Local Water Management (MEDA Water) and Mediterranean Drought
Preparedness and Mitigation Planning (MEDROPLAN).
9. EYATH (2018). EYATH abstractions. http://www.eyath.gr/ (accessed January 2018)
10. Gampe, D., Nikulin, G., & Ludwig, R. (2016). Using an ensemble of regional climate models to
assess climate change impacts on water scarcity in European river basins. Science of The Total
Environment, 573, 1503–1518. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.08.053
11. Global Water Partnership (2012). Vardar/Axios River basin — TWRM-Med [Page]. Retrieved
January 8, 2018, from http://www.twrm-med.net/southeastern-europe/transboundary-river-basinmanagement/shared-surface-water-bodies/new-river-basins/vardar-axios-river-basin
12. Grimpylakos, G., Karacostas, T.S., & Albanakis, K. (2016). Spatial and temporal distribution of
rainfall and temperature in Macedonia, Greece, over a thirty year period, using GIS. Bulletin of
the Geological Society of Greece, 47(3), 1458–1471. https://doi.org/10.12681/bgsg.10984
13. Hadjicharalambous, H., Dimaki, M., Zervas, D., Koutrakis, E., Poulis, G., Sapounidis, A., &
Hatziiordanou, L. (2015). Identification of ecological water requirements of the target habitat
types and species that depend on water, in the Axios River Delta, the Aliakmonas River
Delta and at the Coastal Lagoon Kitros. Greek Biotope/Wetland Centre.Han, D., Post, V. E.
A., & Song, X. (2015). Groundwater salinization processes and reversibility of seawater intrusion
in
coastal
carbonate
aquifers.
Journal
of
Hydrology,
531,
1067–1080.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2015.11.013
14. Ingold, K., Fischer, M., de Boer, C., & Mollinga, P. P. (2016). Water Management Across
Borders, Scales and Sectors: Recent developments and future challenges in water policy analysis.
Environmental Policy and Governance, 26(4), 223–228. https://doi.org/10.1002/eet.1713
15. Κarageorgis, A.P., Skourtos, M.S., Kapsimalis, V. et al. (2005). An integrated approach to
watershed management within the DPSIR framework: Axios River catchment & Thermaikos
603
Ground water resources management
Gulf. Regional Environmental Change, 5(2–3), 138–160. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-0040078-7
16. Komi, K., Neal, J., Trigg, M.A., & Diekkrüger, B. (2017). Modelling of flood hazard extent in
data sparse areas: a case study of the Oti River basin, West Africa. Journal of Hydrology:
Regional Studies, 10(Supplement C), 122–132. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrh.2017.03.001
17. Kontogianni, A., Tourkolias, C. H., Damigos, D., & Skourtos, M. (2014). Assessing sea level rise
costs and adaptation benefits under uncertainty in Greece. Environmental Science & Policy, 37,
61–78. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2013.08.006
18. Kotinis-Zambakas, S.R., Angouridakis, V.E., & Zambakas, J.D. (1984). A criterion for defining
transitional zones between humid continental and mediterranean climates in the region of Greece.
Journal of Climatology, 4(1), 99–104. https://doi.org/10.1002/joc.3370040108
19. Kouzana, L., Mammou, A.B., & Felfoul, M.S. (2009). Seawater intrusion and associated
processes: Case of the Korba aquifer (Cap-Bon, Tunisia). Comptes Rendus Geoscience, 341(1),
21–35. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crte.2008.09.008
20. Marcos-Garcia, P., Lopez-Nicolas, A., & Pulido-Velazquez, M. (2017). Combined use of relative
drought indices to analyze climate change impact on meteorological and hydrological droughts
in
a
Mediterranean
basin.
Journal
of
Hydrology,
554,
292–305.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2017.09.028
21. Masciopinto, C., & Liso, I.S. (2016). Assessment of the impact of sea-level rise due to climate
change on coastal groundwater discharge. Science of The Total Environment, 569–570, 672–
680. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.06.183
22. Middelkoop, H., Daamen, K., Gellens, D., et al. (2001). Impact of Climate Change on
Hydrological Regimes and Water Resources Management in the Rhine Basin. Climatic Change,
49(1), 105–128. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1010784727448
23. Milovanovic, M. (2007). Water quality assessment and determination of pollution sources along
the Axios/Vardar River, Southeastern Europe. Desalination, 2007, 213(1), 159–173.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.desal.2006.06.022
24. Ministry of Environment and Energy (2014). Management Plan for the River Catchments of
Central Macedonia.
25. Papadimos, D. (2015). Setup and calibration of the two dimensional hydrodynamic models
of the Axios delta, Aliakmonas delta and of Kitrous lagoon: part 1. Greek Biotope Wetland
Centre.
26. Roger Few (2003). Flooding, vulnerability and coping strategies: local responses to a global
threat.
Progress
in
Development
Studies,
3(1),
43–58.
https://doi.org/10.1191/1464993403ps049ra
27. Sutanudjaja, E.H., van Beek, L.P.H., de Jong, S.M., van Geer, F.C., & Bierkens, M.F.P. (2011).
Large-scale groundwater modeling using global datasets: a test case for the Rhine-Meuse basin.
Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 15(9), 2913–2935. https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-152913-2011.
28. Ye, M., Pohlmann, K.F., Chapman, J.B., Pohll, G.M., & Reeves, D.M. (2010). A ModelAveraging Method for Assessing Groundwater Conceptual Model Uncertainty. Ground Water,
48(5), 716–728. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-6584.2009.00633.x
604
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
INVESTIGATING GROUNDWATER FLOW AND SEAWATER
INTRUSION IN NEA MOUDANIA AQUIFER UNDER VARIOUS
MANAGEMENT SCENARIOS
I. Siarkos1, M. Katirtzidou1*, D. Latinopoulos2 and P. Latinopoulos1
1
School of Civil Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, GR54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
2
School of Spatial Planning and Development, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, GR54124
Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: mkatir@civil.auth.gr, tel : +302310695475
Abstract
Many coastal areas all over the world face significant water availability issues due to population
increase and numerous human activities (i.e., tourism development, commercial and agricultural
activities) taking place in the interior of them. This problematic situation becomes even worse when
groundwater resources constitute the sole source of freshwater. Moreover, coastal areas are threatened
by seawater intrusion caused due to the substantial decline of groundwater levels. To this task, the
implementation of various protective countermeasures, that should be carefully examined and
evaluated, is often required in these regions. For this reason numerical modeling is usually applied,
since it enables studying the spatial and temporal evolution of both hydraulic head and seawater
encroachment under different management perspectives. Within this framework, the present study
investigates the implementation of various management scenarios aiming at dealing with both
groundwater drawdown and seawater intrusion in the coastal aquifer of Nea Moudania, Halkidiki,
Greece, which faces both considerable decrease of groundwater levels and increased salinization due
to seawater intrusion. All management scenarios are actually related to the reduction of pumping rates
of the abstraction wells (irrigation and/or domestic wells) due to the implementation of pumping
restriction measures or the exploitation of alternative water resources (i.e. use of surface water). The
investigation and evaluation of the alternative scenarios are performed through the application of a
calibrated transient groundwater flow-solute transport model already developed for the reference
area, by studying the spatial and temporal evolution of both hydraulic head and chloride
concentrations resulting from each scenario.
Keywords: groundwater drawdown; seawater intrusion; groundwater resources management;
numerical modeling; Nea Moudania aquifer
1.
INTRODUCTION
Over-exploitation of groundwater resources in coastal areas worldwide has evolved into a widespread
environmental issue that in addition affects negatively the economy of these regions (Datta et al.,
2009; Werner et al., 2013; Siarkos and Latinopoulos, 2016a). Not only does groundwater overexploitation causes the intense decline of groundwater levels (quantitative degradation), but also has
as direct effect the intrusion of seawater (qualitative degradation), which, in turn, results in reduction
of the available and exploitable amounts of freshwater (Werner et al., 2013; Siarkos and Latinopoulos,
2016b; Siarkos et al., 2017). For this reason, application of preventive measures and development of
management strategies regarding groundwater abstraction are considered to be of utmost importance
(Papadopoulou, 2011; Siarkos et al., 2017).
605
Ground water resources management
The aforementioned management strategies in order to be effective and have positive results to the
local groundwater reserves should be thoroughly investigated in conjunction with the proper study of
the aquifer’s behavior. To this task numerical modeling is usually implemented. In this way, not only
does the aquifer’s behavior under various stresses (i.e., recharge and discharge conditions) is
examined, but also the comparison and evaluation of possible management scenarios are
accomplished in terms of both hydraulic head and seawater encroachment evolution (Pliakas et al.,
2005; Dausman et al., 2010; Pool and Carrera, 2010; Siarkos et al., 2017).
In this perspective, the present study investigates through numerical modeling the impact of various
management scenarios on the quantitative and qualitative status of the aquifer of Nea Moudania,
Halkidiki, Greece. These scenarios are related to the reduction of pumping rates of the abstraction
wells and/or the suspension of their operation, which is one of the most well-known preventive
countermeasures implemented in the effort of controlling seawater intrusion in coastal regions (Oude
Essink, 2001; Pool and Carrera, 2010; Kallioras et al., 2013; Siarkos et al., 2017). More specifically,
the management scenarios include: a) reduction of the pumping rates of irrigation wells in order to
achieve a balance between aquifer inflows and outflows and, therefore, no further groundwater level
decline occurs, b) suspension of the operation of certain wells located in the southern part of the
aquifer, due to probable unsuitable drinking water quality (salinization), and c) construction and
operation of a reservoir in a nearby basin (Olynthios river basin) and use of stored surface water in
order to cover water needs of the Nea Moudania basin, thus reducing groundwater resources
exploitation. To apply, compare and evaluate these alternative scenarios, a transient model involving
the simulation of both groundwater flow and solute transport and developed in a previous study
(Siarkos and Latinopoulos, 2016a), was used.
2.
STUDY AREA
The hydrological basin of Nea Moudania is located in the south-western part of the Halkidiki
Peninsula (south-east of Thessaloniki) and belongs to a wide region called “Kalamaria Plain”. The
basin occupies an area of about 127 km2 with a mean soil elevation of 211 m above mean sea level
and a mean soil slope of 1.8%. It is bordered to the south by Thermaikos Gulf and, therefore, there is
hydraulic connection between groundwater and seawater in this part of the region (Latinopoulos,
2003; Siarkos and Latinopoulos, 2016a, 2016b). In Figure 1 both the location and boundaries of this
basin are depicted, along with the two sub-regions of the basin: the hilly area in the north and the flat
area in the south. The climate of the study area is semi-arid to humid, typically Mediterranean, and
the average annual precipitation is 417 mm for the flat area and 504 mm for the hilly one
(Latinopoulos, 2003).
The basin is an agricultural area that is intensively cultivated and irrigated, thus requiring high water
quantities. Currently water needs in the region (irrigation, domestic and livestock needs) are
exclusively covered by the Nea Moudania aquifer system, which is considered to be semiconfined,
consisting of successive water-bearing layers separated by lenses of semi-permeable or impermeable
materials. Intense agriculture and uncontrollable irrigation have led to over-exploitation of local
groundwater resources, causing net deficit in the aquifer water balance and substantial decline of
groundwater levels. As a consequence, phreatic conditions are encountered in several locations.
Moreover, qualitative degradation of the aquifer is observed due to seawater intrusion caused by
groundwater over-exploitation, especially for irrigation purposes (Siarkos and Latinopoulos, 2016a,
2016b). An in-depth description of the Nea Moudania basin and the subjacent aquifer is presented in
Siarkos and Latinopoulos (2016a).
606
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1. Location and boundaries of the Nea Moudania basin.
3.
GROUNDWATER MODELING
As already mentioned, for the application and evaluation of various management scenarios a transient
model, previously developed by Siarkos and Latinopoulos (2016a), was used. In this model the
simulation of both groundwater flow and solute mass transport –chloride ions in particular– under
transient conditions was performed by applying the SEAWAT code (Guo and Langevin, 2002). The
SEAWAT design is based on the concept of combining two well-established and proven groundwater
programs, MODFLOW (McDonald and Harbaugh, 1988) and MT3DMS (Zheng and Wang, 1999),
into a single program that simulates variable-density groundwater flow and transport. The governing
equations of variable-density flow problems can be found in Guo and Langevin (2002). The procedure
followed for the development and application of the aforementioned model is thoroughly described
in Siarkos and Latinopoulos (2016a). In the present study, since its scope is focused on the
comparison and evaluation of the management scenarios, only the basic implementation steps of the
proposed methodology are presented:
Step 1: Development of three different models, i.e. a steady-state groundwater flow model by
applying the MODFLOW code, a false transient groundwater flow and solute transport model and a
transient groundwater flow and solute transport model by applying, in both cases, the SEAWAT code.
Each of these models has its own specific objectives, while their connection constitutes the backbone
of the whole procedure.
Step 2: Calibration of the aforementioned models by properly adjusting the models parameters,
i.e. aquifer hydraulic-hydrodynamic parameters, recharge and discharge components, boundary
conditions, and applying a repetitive trial-and-error procedure between the false transient and the
transient simulations.
607
Ground water resources management
Step 3: Performing a sensitivity analysis in order to strengthen the proposed methodology by
enhancing the calibration procedure and optimizing the adjustment of the various models parameters.
By applying the transient model under certain aquifer stresses, the temporal and spatial evolution of
both hydraulic head and seawater encroachment can be investigated, producing a clear image of the
aquifer’s quantitative and qualitative status. In the study of Siarkos and Latinopoulos (2016a), the
model was run for 33 years, and the projection of the two system variables, i.e. hydraulic head and
chloride concentrations, was made until October 2034 (the end of the assumed simulation period). In
this simulation, which will be henceforth called “Scenario 0”, and during the projection time period
(20 years), the pumping rates of the wells were assigned the values estimated during the calibration
procedure, corresponding to current abstraction conditions (2014 - model validation year). In Figure
2, both hydraulic head and chloride concentrations distributions at the end of the simulation period
are displayed. According to this figure it is expected that: a) high negative hydraulic head values will
be observed in the southern and central part of the study area and b) the seawater front will penetrate
at a considerable level towards the interior of the aquifer being at a maximum distance of 2.2 km from
the coast.
Figure 2. a) Hydraulic head (in m) distribution at the end of the simulation period (2034),
b) chloride concentrations (in mg/L) distribution at the end of the simulation period (2034).
4.
MANAGEMENT SCENARIOS
4.1 General issues
Based on the results of the transient model, maintaining the current groundwater exploitation
conditions, i.e. the current well abstraction regime, will inevitably lead to further deterioration of both
quantity and quality of local groundwater resources. This is translated to further groundwater levels
decline, as well as to further expansion of the seawater wedge towards the interior of the aquifer.
Therefore, in order to alleviate the existing problems, immediate preventive countermeasures should
be taken. In the present study three alternative practices/scenarios, referring to the modification of the
608
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
abstraction status of the study area (reduction of the pumping rates and/or suspension of the operation
of the wells) are examined, compared and evaluated applying the transient model mentioned in
Section 3. In the following sections (4.2 - 4.4), a detailed description of the aforementioned scenarios
is given by presenting the specific characteristics of every one of them. However, it is necessary
beforehand to provide some general issues referring to the application procedure of the alternative
scenarios:
The reduction of the pumping rates and/or the suspension of the operation of the abstraction wells
implies the decrease of the amount of groundwater extracted and, subsequently, of the amount of
water returning to the aquifer, either as irrigation return flow or as water supply leakage. This decrease
was taken into consideration in all cases.
The hydraulic head values assigned to the northern aquifer boundary (time-variable general head
boundary) in Scenarios 2 and 3 were the same as in Scenario 0 in order to achieve better comparison
of the management scenarios (focused on the effect of abstraction wells) and avoid setting arbitrary
hydraulic head values to the boundary. An exception was made in the case of Scenario 1, where the
nature of the problem requires the modification of the hydraulic head in that boundary, which is
analysed in detail in Section 4.2.
The implementation period of Scenarios 1 and 2 was set equal to the one of Scenario 0 (2014 2034), while in Scenario 3 a 10-year implementation period was considered (2024 - 2034).
4.2 Scenario 1
In this scenario, the pumping rates of irrigation wells are reduced in order to achieve a balance
between groundwater inflows and outflows and, therefore, maintain groundwater levels constant on
an annual base through the 20-year implementation period. To determine the new well pumping rates
a repetitive trial-and-error procedure was applied, modifying pumping rates in such a way that
groundwater levels, both locally and regionally, remain stable on annual base. At this point, it should
be noted that it is essential the hydraulic head at the northern boundary of the aquifer to be maintained
at the level calculated at the initial time step of the implementation period (May 2014). Therefore, the
hydraulic head values assigned to the northern aquifer boundary remain constant through the
implementation period, not following the temporal evolution of the other scenarios, i.e. Scenarios 0,
2 and 3.
4.3 Scenario 2
According to Scenario 2, pumping is locally ceased by pausing the operation of certain wells located
in the southern part of the reference area, due to probable unsuitable drinking water quality
(salinization). The selection of these specific wells was based on their relative position with respect
to the seawater wedge, as well as on the chloride concentration observed at the beginning of the
implementation period of the scenario. If chloride concentrations exceed certain limits, that vary
according to the use of the wells (water supply or irrigation wells), the wells operation is suspended,
considering them as unsuitable for the respective use. More specifically, in the case of water supply
wells, pumping is stopped when chloride concentration exceeds 250 mg/L (drinking water limit). On
the other hand, the operation of irrigation wells is paused when electrical conductivity, which
determines the suitability of water for irrigation purposes, exceeds the value of 5,000 μS/cm, which
denotes the limit between sensitive and partially sensitive crops (Maas, 1984).
4.4 Scenario 3
Scenario 3 investigates the alternative of designing and constructing a reservoir in a nearby basin that
will increase the study area’s water reserves by capturing the surface water runoff of the Olynthios
River hydrological basin. The operation of the reservoir aims to serve: (a) the domestic water needs
and (b) irrigation water requirements.
609
Ground water resources management
The Olynthios hydrologic basin covers 252 km2. The dam is designed to be rockfill, with a clay core
and a lateral spillway, with a height of 73 m and a volume of storage of 22.84 Mm3 (Karamouzis et
al., 2008). The reservoir inflows were calculated using the Thornthwaite and Mather model (McCabe
and Markstrom, 2007) for the Olynthios catchment and the average monthly values (Demertzi, 2013)
were imported in the model. Finally, the evaporation from the water surface of the reservoir was
estimated using the DeBruin equation (DeBruin, 1978). The simulation of the reservoir operation was
performed using the Water and Evaluation Planning (WEAP) software (Sieber and Purkev, 2005)
with a monthly step and no return flows, while first and secondary priority of the water supply were
assigned in the model to urban and agricultural demand sites, respectively (Katirtzidou and
Latinopoulos, 2017). The reservoir begins operating as empty on May 2024, while urban water supply
begins on November 2024 and agricultural water supply on May 2025. The reservoir water storage
volume during the study period is presented in Figure 3. The stored water quantity marginally covers
the annual water needs of the study area, while the higher and lower level is observed on April and
September of each year respectively.
Figure 3. Reservoir storage volume.
5.
APPLICATION AND EVALUATION OF MANAGEMENT SCENARIOS
In this section, the results of the application of the alternative scenarios are presented and evaluated.
The results refer to the impact of the management scenarios on both groundwater levels and chloride
concentrations in the study area, and are produced by applying the transient model and making
necessary modifications according to the nature of each scenario. First of all, in Figure 4 the temporal
evolution of the hydraulic head in a typical grid cell of the model through the whole simulation period
(2001 - 2034) for all scenarios is presented. What is worth mentioning is the steep increase of the
hydraulic head in the case of Scenario 3 when it is applied, which is attributed to the fact that all
abstraction wells in the study area cease operating and, therefore, no groundwater is used anymore.
With regard to the other scenarios, in Scenario 1 the hydraulic head remains constant on annual base
which is consistent with the fact that the aquifer’s water budget is balanced, while in Scenarios 0 and
3 the hydraulic head decreases over time, which is more intense in the case of Scenario 0, where no
preventive measures were applied.
610
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 4. Hydraulic head evolution through the simulation period (2001 - 2034) for all
scenarios.
Moreover, in Figure 5 the groundwater level in a certain aquifer section (section A-A’) at the end of
the simulation period (i.e. the year 2034) for all scenarios is illustrated. It is observed that the
hydraulic head in Scenario 3 is higher than in other scenarios, even though its implementation period
is shorter (10 years in Scenario 3 instead of 20 years in Scenarios 1 and 2). An increase in the hydraulic
head of Scenario 1 is also observed, in relation with Scenario 0, but to a lesser extent than in the case
of Scenario 3. In Scenario 2 only a slight increase of groundwater level occurs in the southern part of
the aquifer at a near distance from the coastline (local effect). What is worth noting is that in all
scenarios the hydraulic head is below the mean sea level (m.s.l.) in various parts of the study area
(south and central parts), with the lowest values being observed in Scenarios 0 and 2. This is very
important regarding seawater intrusion, since, as long as the hydraulic head is below the m.s.l.,
seawater will continue to infiltrate inland.
Finally, Figure 6 shows the location of the seawater front in terms of the 250 mg/L chloride
concentration contour at the end of the simulation period (2034) for all scenarios, as well as its
location at the beginning of the simulation (2001). It is worth mentioning that in all management
scenarios, i.e. Scenarios 1, 2 and 3, the seawater front expands over time ending up very close to the
position it occupies in the case of Scenario 0, where no protective measures were implemented. In
other words, seawater intrusion is slightly affected by the countermeasures examined in this study.
611
Ground water resources management
Figure 5. Groundwater levels at the end of the simulation period (2034) for all scenarios.
Figure 6. Location of the seawater front at the end of the simulation period (2034) for all
scenarios, along with its location at the beginning of the simulation period (2001).
Based on the results presented above, with regard to hydraulic head Scenario 3 is the most effective
one, since its application results in a considerable increase of groundwater levels throughout the study
area. This is wholly attributed to the fact that the operation of all abstraction wells in the region is
suspended, resulting in the substantial decrease of the aquifer discharge. Scenario 1 is the second
most effective, also leading to the increase of groundwater levels all over the study area, while
612
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Scenario 2 shows a rather poor performance, since its impact on groundwater levels is minor and
limited only to the southern part of the region close to the coastline (local effect). Regarding seawater
intrusion, no measure can be characterized as effective, since in all cases (Scenarios 1, 2 and 3)
seawater intrusion occurs and seawater front expands, while the results are almost similar to those of
Scenario 0, as if no preventive measures have been implemented.
6.
CONCLUSIONS
In the present study, various management scenarios regarding groundwater abstraction were
implemented, compared and evaluated in order to improve the quantitative and qualitative status of
the Nea Moudania aquifer. These scenarios are related to the reduction of the pumping rates and/or
the suspension of the operation of the abstraction wells in the study area. For the application of the
management scenarios a previously developed transient groundwater flow and solute transport model
was used. The evaluation of each scenario was based on the analysis of the results of the
aforementioned model regarding both the hydraulic head and chloride concentrations evolution over
time.
According to the results the case of constructing a reservoir in a nearby basin and providing the study
area with supplementary surface water (Scenario 3) is considered to be the most effective solution,
since it leads to the suspension of the operation of all abstraction wells in the study area, completely
ceasing the groundwater exploitation. But, even though the application of this scenario results in
considerable increase of groundwater levels, its impact, as far as the seawater intrusion is concerned,
is minor, as of other scenarios as well, not intercepting the movement of seawater front inland.
Therefore, it is concluded that in order to deal with seawater intrusion and avoid the expansion of
seawater wedge in the reference area, other type of preventive measures, like the construction of
injection and/or extraction barriers, have to be investigated and probably implemented.
References
1. Datta B., H. Vennalakanti and A. Dhar (2009) ‘Modeling and control of saltwater intrusion in a
coastal aquifer of Andhra Pradesh, India’, Journal of Hydro-environment Research, Vol. 3, pp.
148-159.
2. Dausman A.M., J. Doherty, C.D. Langevin and J. Dixon (2010) ‘Hypothesis testing of buoyant
plume migration using a highly parameterized variable-density groundwater model at a site in
Florida, USA’, Hydrogeology Journal, Vol. 18(1), pp. 147-160.
3. DeBruin H.A.R. (1978) ‘A simple model for shallow lake evaporation’, Journal of Applied
Meteorology, Vol. 17, pp. 1132-1134.
4. Demertzi K.A., D.M. Papamichail, P.E. Georgiou, D.N. Karamouzis and V.G. Aschonitis (2013)
‘Assessment of rural and highly seasonal tourist activity plus drought effects on reservoir
operation in a semi-arid region of Greece using the WEAP model’, Water International, Vol.
39(1), pp. 23-34.
5. Guo W. and C.D. Langevin (2002) ‘User’s Guide to SEAWAT: a computer program of
simulation of three-dimensional variable-density ground-water flow’, U.S. Geological
Survey, Techniques of Water-Resources Investigation, 6-A7.
6. Kallioras A., F. Pliakas, C. Schuth and R. Rausch (2013) ‘Methods to countermeasure the
intrusion of seawater into coastal aquifer systems’, In: Sharma S.K. and R. Sanghi (eds.),
Wastewater Reuse and Management, Springer Science & Business Media, Dordrecht, pp. 479490.
7. Katirtzidou M. and P. Latinopoulos (2017) ‘Allocation of surface and subsurface water resources
to competing uses under climate changing conditions: a case study in Halkidiki, Greece’, Water
Science and Technology: Water Supply, doi: 10.2166/ws.2017.166.
613
Ground water resources management
8. Karamouzis D. et al. (2008) ‘Preliminary environmental impact assessment of dam and
networks of Olynthios dam (in Greek)’, Final Report, Supplemental research for water
development plants in Chalkidiki–Olynthios dam, Thessaloniki, Greece.
9. Latinopoulos P. (2003) ‘Development of water resources management plan for water supply
and irrigation (in Greek)’, Research Project, Final Report prepared for: Municipality of
Moudania, Department of Civil Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece.
10. Maas E.V. (1984) ‘Crop tolerance’, California Agriculture, Vol. 38, pp. 20-21.
11. McCabe G. and S. Markstrom (2007) ‘A monthly water-balance model driven by a graphical
user interface’, U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston, VA, USA.
12. McDonald M.G. and A.W. Harbaugh (1988) ‘A modular three-dimensional finite-difference
ground-water flow model’, U.S. Geological Survey, Techniques of Water-Resources
Investigation, Book 6, Reston, VA, 586 pp.
13. Oude Essink G.H.P. (2001) ‘Improving fresh groundwater supply - problems and solutions’,
Ocean & Coastal Management, Vol. 44(5-6), pp. 429-449.
14. Papadopoulou M.P. (2011) ‘Optimization approaches for the control of seawater intrusion and its
environmental impacts in coastal environment’, Pacific Journal of Optimization, Vol. 193, pp.
532-540.
15. Pliakas F., C. Petalas, I. Diamantis and A. Kallioras (2005) ‘Modeling of groundwater artificial
recharge by reactivating an old stream bed’, Water Resources Management, Vol. 19(3), pp.
279-294.
16. Pool M. and J. Carrera (2010) ‘Dynamics of negative hydraulic barriers to prevent seawater
intrusion’, Hydrogeology Journal, Vol. 18(1), pp. 95-105.
17. Siarkos I., D. Latinopoulos, Z. Mallios and P. Latinopoulos (2017) ‘A methodological framework
to assess the environmental and economic effects of injection barriers against seawater intrusion’,
Journal of Environmental Management, Vol. 193, pp. 532-540.
18. Siarkos I. and P. Latinopoulos (2016a) ‘Modeling seawater intrusion in overexploited aquifers in
the absence of sufficient data: application to the aquifer of Nea Moudania, northern Greece’,
Hydrogeology Journal, Vol. 24(8), pp. 2123-2141.
19. Siarkos I. and P. Latinopoulos (2016b) ‘Development of constant and variable density models to
study groundwater flow and seawater intrusion in the aquifer of Nea Moudania, Greece’,
European Water, Vol. 55, pp. 53-66.
20. Sieber J. and D. Purkey (2005) ‘WEAP - Water Evaluation and Planning System. User Guide
for WEAP 21’, SEI, Stockholm Environment Institute, Somerville, USA.
21. Werner A.D., M. Bakker, V.E.A. Post, A. Vandenbohede, C. Lu, B. Ataie-Ashtiani, C.T.
Simmons and D.A. Barry (2013) ‘Seawater intrusion processes, investigation and management:
recent advances and future challenges’, Advances in Water Resources, Vol. 51, pp. 3-26.
22. Zheng C. and P.P. Wang (1999) ‘MT3DMS: a modular three-dimensional multispecies
transport model for simulation of advection, dispersion, and chemical reactions of
contaminants in groundwater systems - documentation and user’s guide.’, Contract report
SERD-99-1, US Army Corps of Engineers, Washington, DC.
614
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
SPATIOTEMPORAL GEOSTATISTICAL MODELING OF
AQUIFER LEVELS USING PHYSICALLY BASED TOOLS
E.A. Varouchakis*, P.G. Theodoridou and G.P. Karatzas
School of Environmental EngineeringTechnical University of Crete, Chania, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: varuhaki@mred.tuc.gr, tel : +302821037803
Abstract
Spatiotemporal geostatistics is a significant tool for groundwater level modeling and resources
management. Geostatistics is complementary to the physical models which are based on partial
differential equations that govern the flow and transport of pollutants in the groundwater. However,
physical models require significant amount of data for calibration (e.g., boundary conditions,
estimation of the hydraulic conductivity statistics and spatial correlation). In the case of sparsely
monitored areas the number of available data often does not support the use of physical models, which
makes a statistical stochastic approach necessary. Researchers in the field of hydrology investigating
the variability of aquifer properties are often involved in cases with scarce spatial and temporal data.
In such cases, modeling of the groundwater level as a random field, which can be analyzed and
estimated by means of geostatistics, is an alternative accessible option. Thus, it can be implemented
with fewer measurements and is computationally less complex than the solution of partial differential
equations. A recently developed non-separable physically based covariance function is appropriately
modified employing tools of physical meaning to enhance the efficiency and reliability of
spatiotemporal geostatistical modeling in groundwater applications. The proposed covariance
function is mathematically valid (i.e., constitutes permissible models), and provides a useful tool to
model scarce space-time groundwater level data. Herein, the efficiency of the proposed tools is tested
using groundwater level data from an alluvial unconfined aquifer.
Keywords: non-separable covariance; space-time interpolation; space-time modelling, groundwater;
sparse data
1.
SPATIOTEMPORAL GEOSTATISTICAL MODELLING
Spatiotemporal geostatistical models provide a probabilistic framework for data analysis and
predictions which is based on the joint spatial and temporal dependence between observations
(Kyriakidis and Journel 1999, Fischer and Getis 2010). Initial approaches to spatiotemporal data
modeling were based on separable covariance functions, obtained by combining separate spatial and
temporal covariance models (Rodriguez-Iturbe and Mejia 1974, Rouhani and Myers 1990, Cressie
1993, Dimitrakopoulos and Luo 1994). The last two decades there is significant development of nonseparable covariance functions. These models aim to improve spatiotemporal data modeling and
prediction (Cressie and Huang 1999, De Iaco, Myers et al. 2001, Gneiting 2002, Kolovos, Christakos
et al. 2004) by extracting in some case the covariance functions from physical laws such as differential
equations and dynamic rules (Christakos and Hristopulos 1998, Christakos 2000, Gneiting 2002,
Kolovos, Christakos et al. 2004).
The main goal of space-time analysis is to model multiple time series of data at spatial locations
where a distinct time series is allocated. The time variable is considered as an additional dimension
in geostatistical prediction. A spatiotemporal stochastic process can be represented by Z (s, t ) where
615
Ground water resources management
the variable of interest of random field Z is observed at N space-time coordinates (si , ti ) ,…, (s N , t N )
, while the optimal prediction of the variable in space and time is based on Z (si , ti ) ,…, Z (s N , t N )
(Cressie and Huang 1999, Giraldo Henao 2009). S/TRF Z (s, t ) can be decomposed into a mean
component mZ (s, t ) modeling the presence of a correlated trend and a residual S/TRF component
Z (s, t ) modeling fluctuations around that trend in both space and time. The trend can be calculated
either deterministically and the fluctuations using a stochastic framework such as space-time kriging
(Christakos 1991, Kyriakidis and Journel 1999).
2.
SPATIOTEMPORAL PREDICTION OF AQUIFER LEVEL
Mires basin of the Messara valley is a sparsely monitored basin located on the island of Crete, Greece.
Since 1981 where a rapid increase of drip irrigation and increased pumping were started, only 10
wells were consistently monitored biannually until the year 2015. The basin is consistently
overexploited and the result is a great drawdown of the water table; more than 35m since 1981. The
water resources availability in the area, especially the groundwater, are encountering great shortage.
The application of spatiotemporal geostatistics exploits the spatially short groundwater level dataset
to identify the historic spatiotemporal behavior of the aquifer and to take useful information regarding
the space-time data correlations for future predictions. Space-time geostatistical analysis considers
the following steps: 1) space-time variogram calculation, 2) application of space-time kriging, STOK
for prediction, 3) estimation of prediction accuracy.
STOK is a well-established method for space-time interpolation (Christakos, Bogaert et al. 2001, De
Cesare, Myers et al. 2001). It is however complicated, as the kriging system of equations needs to be
solved at the same time for spatial and temporal weights (Skøien and Blöschl 2007).
The primary concerns when modeling space–time structures, is to ensure that the chosen
spatiotemporal dependence model is valid and appropriate for space-time analysis. First, the
experimental spatiotemporal variogram is determined. Then it is modeled with theoretical
spatiotemporal variogram functions to determine the space-time dependence parameters.
3.
GEOSTATISTICAL TOOLS
Spartan covariance and variogram functions were introduced by Hristopulos (2003) and have been
applied to various environmental data sets (Hristopulos 2003, Elogne, Hristopulos et al. 2008, Elogne
and Hristopulos 2008, Hristopulos and Elogne 2009, Varouchakis and Hristopulos 2013, Varouchakis
and Hristopulos 2017). Herein, this family of functions is modified appropriately to model hydrogeological data. The Spartan covariance functions in d=3 dimensions are expressed as follows:
0 e h 2
sin(h1 )
0
2
, for 1 2, z
2
2 | 12 4 |
2 | 1 4 | h1
h
e
.
Cz (h) 0
, for 1 2, z2 0
8
8
0 (e h1 e h2 )
0
, for 1 2, z2
4 (2 1 ) h | 12 4 |
4 | 12 4 |
(1)
In the above function, 0 is the scale factor, 1 is the rigidity coefficient, 1 2 1
dimensionless
wavenumber,
2 2 1
1/2
2
616
and
1,2 1 2 ,
1/2
1/2
12 4
1/2
2 is a
,
are
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
dimensionless damping coefficients, is a characteristic length, h r is the normalized lag
vector, h | h | is the separation distance norm and z2 is the variance. A covariance function that is
permissible in three spatial dimensions is also permissible in two dimensions (Christakos 1991).
Hence, (1) can be used in two dimensions. The exponential covariance is recovered for 1 = 2, while
for 1 < 2 the product of the exponential and hole-effect model is obtained.
The spatiotemporal Spartan function constitutes a new approach in the interdependence modeling of
spatiotemporal data (Varouchakis and Hristopulos 2017). It forms a non-separable function, which is
based on the spatial Spartan variogram family. The function is derived by substituting h with the
following equation in its spatial form (1),
h h 2r h2 , h r
r
r
, h
, where τ is the time step lag.
The scale factor 0 that defines partly the variance of the variogram is expressed in terms of the
average spatiotemporal hydraulic gradient ( 0 dh / dl ) of the space-time groundwater level data set. The
latter is applied to obtain a physical parameter in the function that determines the highest value (sill)
of the measurement variable in terms of different spatial separation distances. A similar approach is
common in developing physically based covariance structures by including a parameter that affects
the spatial or temporal behavior of the measurement variable (Kolovos, Christakos et al. 2004).
Another new approach in the modeling of spatiotemporal data is the application of non-Euclidean
distance metrics. In this study we apply the Manhattan metric, described by equation (2), to examine
the effect of distance calculation on the data interdependence modelling and the prediction results:
Manhattan: d1 xi x j yi y j
(2)
where, (xi, yi), (xj, yj), i, j ∈ 1,..,n, are the Cartesian coordinates of the ith and jth monitoring points
(wells) at the corresponding study area and n is the number of wells.
Given a constant distance each time, the equation of locus of all points that equidistant from a given
point (focus) is a concentric circle in case of Euclidean distance and a concentric rhombus in case of
Manhattan distance, useful for grid-path data. Due to this special feature, the aforementioned distance
has the potential to capture spatial hydrogeological discontinuities in terms of the separation distances
between the measurements (Theodoridou, Varouchakis et al. 2017).
4.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Spatiotemporal geostatistical analysis of Mires basin groundwater level data was applied to identify
the spatiotemporal behavior of the aquifer since 1981 and to undertake predictions based on the spacetime data correlations using the proposed tools. The space-time experimental variogram is determined
from the biannual groundwater level time series at the 10 sampling stations for the period 1981-2014.
Validation of the estimates was performed for the wet and dry period of the year 2015.
The theoretical space-time variogram model fitting on the experimental space-time variogram
obtained from the observed data is presented in Figure 1. The average spatiotemporal hydraulic
gradient was calculated equal to dh/dl= 0.08m. The respective variogram parameters are z2 46.60
m2, r = 0.27 (≈ 3km), = 0.94 (≈ 12 months), 1 = 1.87, α = 0.12 and nugget variance c = 3.83 m2.
The nugget term was considered to improve the experimental variogram fit.
617
Ground water resources management
Figure 1. Space-time product-sum variogram fit using the Spartan structure.
The prediction involves STOK application to estimate the groundwater level at the specified locations
and time during the wet and dry period of the year 2015. The validation results in terms of absolute
estimation error (AE) are presented in the following table.
As it is presented in Table 1, STOK provides very good agreement with the reported values improved
by 35% compared to previous work that involved the original space-time Spartan variogram and the
Euclidean distance metric. The aquifer level map is then derived using STOK with the modified
Spartan spatiotemporal variogram structure and the Manhattan distance metric for the wet and dry
periods of the year 2015, the last period of available data and the most recent to date. The contour
maps of groundwater level spatial variability in physical space are presented in Figures 2 and 3. The
maps are constructed using estimates only at points inside the convex hull of the measurement
locations.
Table1. Absolute Error (AE) of STOK estimates for the wet and dry period of the year 2015.
Well No
Wet period AE (m)
Dry Period AE (m)
G1
1.2
1.38
G2
1.02
1.29
G3
0.72
0.94
G4
1.21
1.34
G5
1.32
1.43
G6
1.04
1.24
G7
0.84
0.95
G8
0.95
0.99
G9
0.68
0.84
G10
0.73
0.96
618
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2. Map of estimated groundwater level (meters above sea level – m.a.s.l) in the Mires
basin using STOK for the wet period of the year 2015.
Figure 3. Map of estimated groundwater level (meters above sea level – m.a.s.l) in the Mires
basin using STOK for the dry period of the year 2015.
The scope of this work was to employ two new tools of physical meaning in the variogram calculation
of the available data and to test their efficiency to model the spatiotemporal response of the
groundwater level variations in an aquifer. The model delivers an excellent variogram fit and very
accurate estimates. The spatial correlation length is determined after the variogram fitting equal to
619
Ground water resources management
almost 3km and the temporal length equal to almost 12 months. The latter denotes that spatiotemporal
prediction considers so the wet as the dry hydrological period of measurements. Therefore, leads to
accurate results. Figures 2 and 3 present the spatial variability of the estimated groundwater level
based on the space-time correlations of the data that consider the dynamic aquifer behavior.
5.
CONCLUSIONS
Reliable space-time estimates are important for groundwater resources management. This work
presented the space-time geostatistical analysis framework and examined the spatiotemporal
modeling of groundwater level in a hydrological basin where the groundwater resources have been
significantly depleted the past 35 years. The spatiotemporal approach employed the application of the
Spartan variogram function involving the term of hydraulic gradient to approximate the scale
parameter of the space-time variogram. This spatiotemporal structure fits very well the experimental
space-time variogram of the groundwater level capturing the space-time correlations of the available
data.
The Manhattan distance metric provides improved predictions. This may results from the physical
characteristics of the aquifer. Moreover, Manhattan distance metric has the property to estimate the
distance between two points of axes x and y accordingly to the axes orientation, while Euclidean does
not have this special feature. Thus, Manhattan metric is preferred to estimate a distance between two
locations when a geological barrier interferes (e.g. in a karstic aquifer, presence of faults). However,
it is worth mentioning that the aforementioned approach is not necessarily the appropriate for each
data set, but it depends on the characteristics of the system under study and on the scope of each
study.
The STOK estimates presented accurately the groundwater level variability for the examined
validation period and provided the spatial distribution of the aquifer level at ungauged locations for
the wet and dry period of the year 2015. The examined approach is shown to provide a reliable
alternative in spatiotemporal modeling of aquifer level. Another advantage is that it requires less data
than a numerical model to represent the head field and in less computational time.
References
1. Christakos, G. (1991). 'Random field models in earth sciences'. San Diego, Academic press.
2. Christakos, G. (2000). 'Modern Spatiotemporal Geostatistics'. New York, Oxford University
Press.
3. Christakos, G., P. Bogaert and M. L. Serre (2001). 'Temporal GIS: Advanced functions for
field-based applications'. Berlin, Springer Verlag.
4. Christakos, G. and D. T. Hristopulos (1998). 'Spatiotemporal environmental health modelling:
A tractatus stochasticus'. Boston, Kluwer.
5. Cressie, N. (1993). 'Statistics for spatial data (revised ed.)'. New York, Wiley.
6. Cressie, N. and H. C. Huang (1999). "Classes of Nonseparable, Spatio-Temporal Stationary
Covariance Functions." Journal of the American Statistical Association, 94(448), 1330-1340.
7. De Cesare, L. D., D. E. Myers and D. Posa (2001). "Estimating and modeling space-time
correlation structures." Statistics & Probability Letters, 51(1), 9-14.
8. De Iaco, S., D. E. Myers and D. Posa (2001). "Space-time analysis using a general product-sum
model." Statistics & Probability Letters, 52(1), 21-28.
9. Dimitrakopoulos, R. and X. Luo (1994). 'Spatiotemporal modeling: covariances and ordinary
kriging systems'. Dordrecht, Kluwer.
620
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
10. Elogne, S., D. Hristopulos and E. Varouchakis (2008). "An application of Spartan spatial random
fields in environmental mapping: focus on automatic mapping capabilities." Stochastic
Environmental Research and Risk Assessment, 22(5), 633-646.
11. Elogne, S. N. and D. T. Hristopulos (2008). Geostatistical applications of Spartan spatial random
fields. 'geoENV VI - Geostatistics for environmental applications in series: Quantitative
geology and geostatistics'. A. Soares, M. J. Pereira and R. Dimitrakopoulos, Berlin, Gemany:
Springer. 15: 477-488.
12. Fischer, M. M. and A. Getis (2010). 'Handbook of applied spatial analysis: software tools,
methods and applications'. Berlin, Springer Verlag.
13. Giraldo Henao, R. (2009). 'Geostatistical analysis of functional data' PhD, Universitat
Politechnica de Catalunya.
14. Gneiting, T. (2002). "Nonseparable, stationary covariance functions for space-time data."
Journal of the American Statistical Association, 97(458), 590-600.
15. Hristopulos, D. T. (2003). "Spartan Gibbs random field models for geostatistical applications."
SIAM Journal on Scientific Computing, 24(6), 2125-2162.
16. Hristopulos, D. T. and S. N. Elogne (2009). "Computationally efficient spatial interpolators based
on Spartan spatial random fields." IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing, 57(9), 3475-3487.
17. Kolovos, A., G. Christakos, D. T. Hristopulos and M. L. Serre (2004). "Methods for generating
non-separable spatiotemporal covariance models with potential environmental applications."
Advances in Water Resources, 27(8), 815-830.
18. Kyriakidis, P. and A. Journel (1999). "Geostatistical Space-Time Models: A Review."
Mathematical Geology, 31(6), 651-684.
19. Rodriguez-Iturbe, I. and M. J. Mejia (1974). "The design of rainfall networks in time and space."
Water Resources Research, 10(4), 713–728.
20. Rouhani, S. and D. Myers (1990). "Problems in space-time kriging of geohydrological data."
Mathematical Geology, 22(5), 611-623.
21. Skøien, J. O. and G. Blöschl (2007). "Spatiotemporal topological kriging of runoff time series."
Water Resources Research, 43(9).
22. Theodoridou, P. G., E. A. Varouchakis and G. P. Karatzas (2017). "Spatial analysis of
groundwater levels using Fuzzy Logic and geostatistical tools." Journal of Hydrology, 555, 242252.
23. Varouchakis, E. A. and D. T. Hristopulos (2013). "Improvement of groundwater level prediction
in sparsely gauged basins using physical laws and local geographic features as auxiliary
variables." Advances in Water Resources, 52(2013), 34-49.
24. Varouchakis, E. A. and D. T. Hristopulos (2017). "Comparison of spatiotemporal variogram
functions based on a sparse dataset of groundwater level variations." Spatial Statistics,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spasta.2017.1007.1003.
621
Ground water resources management
COST MINIMIZATION OF INTERMITTENT TRANSIENT
GROUNDWATER PUMPING
Iraklis A. Nikoletos
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th,
GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
Corresponding author: e-mail: irakniko@civil.auth.gr
Abstract
In this paper, consideration is being given to minimizing the pumping cost from a system of wells
under transient groundwater flow conditions in a confined aquifer.
In particular, previous work has been extended to include cases of intermittent pumping in both
infinite and semi-infinite aquifers, where the method of images applies.
The mathematical method used to find the minimum of the cost function was the Lagrange
multipliers.
It has been proved analytically that at any time, the pumping cost is minimized when the hydraulic
head level drawdowns at the locations of the wells are equal to each other.
Keywords: Optimization, method of images; Lagrange multipliers, pumping cost, groundwater
management
1.
INTRODUCTION
The cost of energy consumed for the pumping of water is one of the main problems of groundwater
management. This energy can be divided in two categories. The first category includes the energy
required to lift the water from the underground aquifer and the second one the energy needed to
overcome friction in pipes, the local losses of the pumps as well as other parts of the distribution
network used for transport of the water (Ahlfeld et al. 2011). The rapid advances in science have
helped to develop simulation models that solve quite accurately various pumping problems in
different types of aquifers. To make proper use of programs the user should be equipped with the
necessary theoretical background, in order to be able to check the computational results. This is
achieved through analytical solutions that justify, clarify and scientifically evaluate the results
(Mahdavi 2015). Conclusions resulting from analytical solutions are inextricably linked to simulation
models that lead to the realistic depiction of real situations and problems and contribute to their
optimal management both economically and environmentally (e.g. Fowler et al. 2008; Saeedpanah et
al. 2017; Shourian et al. 2017; Siarkos et al. 2017; Theodossiou 2004).
In this paper, analytical solutions taking into account transient flow (Katsifarakis et al, 2018) are
extended to intermittent transient groundwater pumping.
2.
FORMULATION OF THE OBJECTIVE COST FUNCTION
Energy consumption depends directly on the total flow rate pumped from a system of N wells. The
cost function of the energy consumed at any time in any type of aquifer is given by the relationship.
622
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
N
K A QJ (t )( s J (t ) J )
(1)
J 1
Where Κ is the pumping cost, QJ is the flow rate of well J, sJ(t) is the transient drawdown at point J
at the time t and δJ is the distance between the initial hydraulic head level at well J and the reference
level. Since Α is a constant coefficient, which is dependent on energy cost and with the assumption
that the aquifer is horizontal namely δJ = δ, the objective function that should be minimized is
N
K QJ (t ) s J (t )
(2)
J 1
2.1 Initial conditions - Constraints
We consider a system of Ν wells, which pump given total flow rates for Κ successive time periods.
For any well m [1,N] just before pumping begins ( t0 0 )
Qmt0 0 , s(t 0 , m) 0
(3)
For any time period i the following constraint applies (i=1, 2, 3… K)
N
Q
m1
i
m
QTi
(4)
Where QTi is the total pumped rate during time period i.
3.
INFINITE AQUIFERS
In infinite confined aquifers the drawdown at a point m at a random moment tk is given by the
relationship (Latinopoulos 1996, Theis 1935):
K
N
Srmj2
1
i
i 1
(5)
s (t k , m)
(Q j Q j )W (
)
4T (t k t i 1 )
i 1
j 1 4T
Where
W (u mj ) W (
Srmj2
4T (t k t i 1 )
e y
dy
umj y
)
(6)
is the well function, T is the aquifer’s transmissivity, S the aquifer’s storativity and r mj the distance
between well m and j. It is worth mentioning that W (u mj ) decreases while u mj is increasing. Using
the superposition principle (Bear 1979) the cost function at any time Κ-1 <tk <K takes the form
K
K tk
i 1
3.1
Srzj2
1
(Qzi Qzi 1 )W (
)
4T (t k t i 1 )
z 1 4T
N
N
(Q ij Q ij1 )
j 1
(7)
Analytical solution of the optimization problem for infinite confined aquifer
To find possible critical points under constraints, the method of Lagrange’ multipliers will be used.
The function (7) is subject to Κ equality constraints, as many as the periods of different total pumped
flow. Therefore, the function to be studied is the following:
K
Ltk K tk i g i
(8)
i 1
So, the system of equations that we need to solve, in order to find a critical point is
623
Ground water resources management
K
Ltk K tk i g i 0
(9)
i 1
g i 0, i 1,2,3..., K
(10)
Where λi is every Lagrange multiplier for every constraint and gi is the total pumping constraint for
each time step,
N
g i Q zi QTi 0
(11)
z 1
According to all these we shall calculate the first derivatives of Lt k with respect to the decision
variables, which are the flow rates Q ij .
For any m [1, N ] and for any y [1, K 1]
Lt K
Srmj2
1
y
y 1
(Q j Q j )W (
)
4T (t k t y 1 )
Qmy
j 1 4T
2
N 1
2
Srmm
1
(Qmy Qmy 1 )W (
)
4T
4T (t k t y 1 )
N 1
z 1
2
Srmz
1
(Qzy Qzy 1 )W (
)
4T
4T (t k t y 1 )
Srmj2
1
y 1
y
(Q j Q j )W (
)
4T (t k t y )
j 1 4T
N 1
2
2
Srmm
1
(Qmy 1 Qmy )W (
)
4T
4T (t k t y 1 )
N 1
z 1
Lt K
Qmy
2
Srmz
1
(Qzy 1 Qzy )W (
) y
4T
4T (t k t y )
(12)
2s m (tk t y 1 ) 2s m (tk t y ) y 0
(13)
For the last time step y=K and for any m [1, N ]
Lt K
2s m (tk t y 1 ) y 0
Qmy
(14)
To complete the system, we use the K equations of (10)
The system consists of Κ x (Ν+1) equations with Κ x (Ν+1) unknowns
For y=1, 2… Κ-1 and for any m [1, N ] and n [1, N ]
sm(tk t y 1 ) sm(tk t y ) y sn(tk t y 1 ) sn(tk t y ) y
For y=Κ respectively
624
(15)
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
sm(tk t y 1 ) y sn(tk t y 1 ) y
(16)
Introducing the Ν equations of (16) to Κ x Ν equations of (15) results into
sm(tk t y 1 ) sn(tk t y 1 )
(17)
Therefore, only one critical point exists, namely P(Q11 , Q21 ,..., QKN )
Point P refers to a local extreme point or to a saddle point. To decide we shall calculate the quantity
q, which is defined as:
h11
1
h
1
1
1
2
K
q= h1 , h2 ,.., hN , h1 ,.., hN H 2
(18)
...
hNK
Where h11 , h21 ,..., hNK are real numbers verifying the following equality:
g1
Q 1
1
g 2
Q11
...
...
...
g K
Q11
g1
Q21
g 2
Q21
...
g1
Q 1N
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
g K
Q21
...
g K
Q 1N
...
g1 h1
1
Q NK 1
h2
... ...
h1
N
... 2
h1
=0
... ...
...
g K
K
Q NK hN
(19)
And H the Hessian matrix with dimensions K*NxK*N whose elements have values
2 Ltk
Where Qj and Qi are the flow rates arranged in time order.
aij
Q j Qi
2 Ltk
1 2
(i.e. (Q1 )
W(
Sr112
Sr112
) W(
)
4Tt k
4T (t k t1 ) )
After trivial calculations we conclude from eq. (19)
h11 h21 ... h1N 0
h12 h22 ... hN2 0
(20)
...
h1K h2K ... hNK 0
And from eq. (18)
625
Ground water resources management
N
q= h
j 1
N
h
j 1
j 1
h W ( 4Tt
z 1
1
z
N
2
j
(h
N
h
Srzj2
N
1
j
z 1
2
z
N
K
j
(h
z 1
K
z
N
) h
j 1
k
h )W (
3
z
h
K 1
z
N
1
j
(h
z 1
Srzj2
h )W (
2
z
N
4T (t k t 2 )
)W (
1
z
) h
j 1
Srzj2
4T (t k t1 )
N
3
j
(h
z 1
N
3
z
j 1
h )W (
2
z
(h
z 1
Srzj2
4T (t k t 2 )
2
z
h )W (
1
z
Srzj2
4T (t k t1 )
) ....
)
(21)
Srzj2
)
4T (t k t K 1 ) >0
We also take advantage of the properties a ij a ji , W (
and
) h
N
2
j
Srij2
4T (t k t y )
) W(
Sr ji2
4T (t k t y )
)
Sr jj2
Srii2
Sro2
W(
) W(
) W(
)
4T (t k t y )
4T (t k t y )
4T (t k t y )
The quantity q is positive for the following reasons
Srzj2
Sro2
1) W (
) W (
) 0 (Katsifarakis et al. 2017)
4T (t k t y )
4T (t k t y )
where ro is the radius of each well
2) From eq. (20)
h11 h21 ... h1N 0 (h11 h21 ... h1N ) 2 0
(h11 ) 2 (h21 ) 2 ... (h1N ) 2 2h11h21 2h11h31 ... 2h1N 1h1N 0
The left-hand side of the last equation is positive as sum of squares. Hence, the right-hand side is
positive. Applying this result to q
Sr132
Srzz2
Sr122
1 1
1 1
1
1
1 1
1 1
(2h1 h2 2h1 h3 ... 2hK 1 hK )W (
) (2h1 h2W (
) 2h1 h3W (
) ...
4T (t k )
4T (t k )
4T (t k )
2hK1 1 hK1 W (
SrN21, N
4T (t k )
)) 0
3) From eq. (20) for 2 consecutively time steps we get
h1i h2i ... hNi h1i 1 h2i 1 ... hNi 1 h1i h2i ... hNi h1i 1 h2i 1 ... hNi 1 0
(h1i h2i ... hNi h1i 1 h2i 1 ... hNi 1 ) 2 0
(h1i ) 2 (h2i ) 2 ... (hNi ) 2 (h1i 1 ) 2 (h2i 1 ) 2 ... (hNi 1 ) 2 2h1i h2i 2h1i h3i ... 2hNi 1 hNi 2h1i h2i 1 ...
2hNi hNi 1 0
(2h1i h2i 2h1i h3i ... 2hNi 1 hNi 2h1i h2i 1 ... 2hNi 1 hNi 1 )W (
Sro2
)
4T (t k t i )
SrN2 1, N
Sr132
Sr122
i i
i
i
(2h h W (
) 2h1 h3W (
) ... 2hN 1 hN W (
)
4T (t k t i )
4T (t k t i )
4T (t k t i )
i
1
i
2
2h1i h2i 1W (
SrN2 1, N
Sr122
) ... 2hNi 1 hNi 1W (
)0
4T (t k t i )
4T (t k t i )
626
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
h1
So, quantity q is positive for all non-zero matrices ...
h
KN
that verify equation (19).
For all these reasons we infer that P is a minimum of Kk, and since it is the only critical point it’s the
absolute minimum.
Thus, at any time, the pumping cost is minimized when the hydraulic head level drawdowns at the
locations of the wells are equal to each other.
4.
SEMI INFINITE AQUIFERS
In the following paragraphs, we work on the pumping cost minimization problem, described by
equations (1) to (4), in semi-infinite aquifers, to which the method of images applies. We have studied
two fields. The first one has a straight-line impermeable boundary and the second one has a straightline rectilinear constant head boundary. The optimization procedure remains the same for both cases
as in the infinite aquifers. The basic concept of method of images is that a boundary can be “removed”
by adding a number of fictitious (or image) wells, symmetrical of the real ones with respect to it. The
relationship between the flow rate of each real well and that of its image depends on the boundary
condition along the “removed” boundary and guarantees its observance.
4.1 Flow fields with a straight-line impermeable boundary
The drawdown at the location of each well m at a random moment tk is given by the relationship
2
K
N
Srmj2
SrmJ
1
(22)
s (t k , m)
(Q ij Q ij1 )(W (
) W (
))
4T (t k t i 1 )
4T (t k t i 1 )
i 1
j 1 4T
Hence the cost function at any time Κ-1 <tk <K takes the form
K
N
N
Srzj2
SrzJ2
1
i
i 1
i
i 1
K tk (Q j Q j )
(Qz Qz )(W (
) W(
))
4T (t k t i 1 )
4T (t k t i 1 )
i 1
j 1
z 1 4T
(23)
As in the case of infinite aquifers we introduce the function
K
Ltk K tk i g i
(24)
i 1
For any m [1, N ] and for any y [1, K 1]
Lt K N 1 1
Srmj2
SrmJ2
y
y 1
(Q j Q j )(W (
) W (
))
Qmy j 1 4T
4T (tk t y 1 )
4T (tk t y 1 )
2
2
2
Srmm
SrmM
1
(Qmy Qmy 1 )(W (
) W(
))
4T
4T (t k t y 1 )
4T (t k t y 1 )
N 1
2
Srmz2
SrmZ
1
(Q zy Q zy 1 )(W (
) W(
))
4T (t k t y 1 )
4T (t k t y 1 )
z 1 4T
2
Srmj2
SrmJ
1
y 1
y
(Q j Q j )(W (
) W(
))
4T (t k t y )
4T (t k t y )
j 1 4T
N 1
627
Ground water resources management
2
2
2
Srmm
SrmM
1
(Qmy 1 Qmy )(W (
) W(
))
4T
4T (t k t y 1 )
4T (t k t y )
N 1
2
Srmz2
SrmZ
1
(Q zy 1 Q zy )(W (
) W(
))
4T (t k t y )
4T (t k t y )
z 1 4T
Lt K
Qmy
2s m (tk t y 1 ) 2s m (tk t y ) y 0
(25)
(26)
For the last time step y=K
Lt K
Qmy
2s m (tk t y 1 ) y 0
(27)
As in the case of infinite aquifers, it results in
sm(tk t y 1 ) sn(tk t y 1 )
(28)
To verify that point P refers to the absolute minimum we follow the same procedure as in infinite
Srzj2
SrzJ2
aquifers. We just need to prove that the value W (
) W(
) is positive.
4T (t k t i 1 )
4T (t k t i 1 )
It is obvious that the sum of two positive numbers gives a positive number.
Hence, minimization of pumping cost in the case of semi-infinite aquifers with a straight-line
impermeable boundary results from equality of drawdowns at each time step.
4.2 Flow fields with a rectilinear constant head boundary
The drawdown at the location of each well m at a random moment tk is given by the relationship
2
K
N
Srmj2
SrmJ
1
i
i 1
(29)
s (t k , m)
(Q j Q j )(W (
) W (
))
4T (t k t i 1 )
4T (t k t i 1 )
i 1
j 1 4T
Hence the cost function at any time Κ-1 <tk <K takes the form
K
K tk
i 1
Srzj2
SrzJ2
1
(Qzi Qzi 1 )(W (
) W (
))
4T (t k t i 1 )
4T (t k t i 1 )
z 1 4T
N
N
(Q ij Q ij1 )
j 1
(30)
The Lagrange function is
K
Ltk K tk i g i
(31)
i 1
For any m [1, N ] and for any y [1, K 1]
Lt K N 1 1 y y 1
Srmj2
SrmJ2
(
Q
Q
)(
W
(
)
W
(
))
j
j
Qmy j 1 4T
4T (tk t y 1 )
4T (tk t y 1 )
2
Srmm
SrmJ2
1
y
y 1
2
(Qm Qm )(W (
) W (
))
4T
4T (t k t y 1 )
4T (t k t y 1 )
628
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
N 1
2
Srmz2
SrmZ
1
(Q zy Q zy 1 )(W (
) W (
))
4T (t k t y 1 )
4T (t k t y 1 )
z 1 4T
2
Srmj2
SrmJ
1
y 1
y
(
Q
Q
)(
W
(
)
W
(
))
j
j
4T (t k t y )
4T (t k t y )
j 1 4T
N 1
2
Srmm
SrmJ2
1
y 1
y
2
(Qm Qm )(W (
) W (
))
4T
4T (t k t y 1 )
4T (t k t y )
N 1
2
Srmz2
SrmZ
1
(Q zy 1 Q zy )(W (
) W (
))
4T (t k t y )
4T (t k t y )
z 1 4T
Lt K
Qmy
(32)
2s m (tk t y 1 ) 2s m (tk t y ) y 0
(33)
For the last time step y=K
Lt K
2s m (tk t y 1 ) y 0
Qmy
(34)
As in the case of infinite aquifers, it results in
sm(tk t y 1 ) sn(tk t y 1 )
We just need to prove that the value W (
(35)
Srzj2
4T (t k t i 1 )
) W (
SrzJ2
) is positive.
4T (t k t i 1 )
The distance zj is smaller than the distance zJ so
Srzj2
Srzj2
SrzJ2
SrzJ2
rzj2 rzJ2
W (
) W(
)
4T (t k t i 1 ) 4T (t k t i 1 )
4T (t k t i 1 )
4T (t k t i 1 )
Therefore, minimization of pumping cost in case of semi-infinite aquifers with a rectilinear constant
head boundary results from equality of drawdowns of each time step. The results are shown to be
related to the proofs by (Katsifrakis 2008) and (Katsifarakis and Tselepidou 2009) for steady state
flow. This is something that is reasonable, if we consider that the steady state is achieved after
successive time intervals.
5.
CONCLUSIONS AND DISCUSSION
In this paper we have studied the minimization of pumping cost under transient groundwater flow
conditions and in particular the case of intermittent pumping in both infinite and semi-infinite
aquifers, where the method of images applies. The basic conclusion was that minimizing pumping
cost at any time, and by extension of energy consumption, is achieved when drawdowns due to
intermittent pumping of the total pumped flow rate of each time step are equal to each other. The next
step of this study would be to investigate its applicability to a real field. The way of construction and
the efficiency of the new system to reduce cost compared to existing systems is an issue of future
research.
629
Ground water resources management
Acknowledgement
The author would like to thank Professor K. L. Katsifarakis for his spiritual, moral but mostly
insightful support.
References
1. Ahlfeld, D.P., Laverty, M.M., 2011. Analytical solutions for minimization of energy use for
groundwater pumping. Water Resources. Research. 47, W06508.
2. Bear J. (1979) ‘Hydraulics of Groundwater’, McGraw-Hill.
3. Fowler KP, Reese JP, Kees CE, Dennis JE Jr, Kelley CT, Miller CT, Audet C, Booker AJ, Couture
G, Darwin RW, Farthing MW, Finkel DE, Gablonsky JM, Gray G, Kolda TG (2008) Comparison
of derivative-free optimization methods for groundwater supply and hydraulic capture community
problems. Advances in Water Resources 31(5):743–757
4. Siarkos I, Latinopoulos D., Mallios Z., Latinopoulos P. A methodological framework to assess
the environmental and economic effects of injection barriers against seawater intrusion. Journal
of Environmental Management Volume 193, 15 May 2017, Pages 532-540
5. Katsifarakis KL (2008) Groundwater pumping cost minimization-An analytical approach. Water
Resources Management 22(8):1089–1099
6. Katsifarakis KL, Tselepidou K (2009) Pumping cost minimization in aquifers with regional flow
and two zonesof different transmissivities. Journal of Hydrology 377(1-2):106–111
7. Katsifarakis, K.L., Nikoletos, I.A. & Stavridis, C. Minimization of Transient Groundwater
Pumping Cost - Analytical and Practical Solutions Water Resources Management (2017).
8. Latinopoulos P. (1996) ‘Hydraulics of groundwater’, XARIS PUBL.
9. Mahdavi, A. Transient-State Analytical Solution for Groundwater Recharge in Anisotropic
Sloping Aquifer. Water Resources Management (2015) 29: 3735.
10. Saeedpanah I, Golmohamadi Azar R (2017) New analytical expressions for two-dimensional
aquifer adjoining with streams of varying water level. Water Resources Management
31(1):403–424
11. Shourian, M. & Davoudi, S.M.J. Optimum Pumping Well Placement and Capacity Design for
a Groundwater Lowering System in Urban Areas with the Minimum Cost Objective Water
Resources Management (2017) 31: 4207.
12. Theis CV (1935) The relation between lowering of the piezometric surface and the rate and
duration of discharge of a well using ground water storage. Trans. Am. Geophys. Un., 16th
Annual meeting, 519-524
13. Theodossiou, N.P., 2004. Application of non-linear simulation and optimization models in
groundwater aquifer management. Water Resources Management 18, 125–141.
630
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
STUDY ON GROUNDWATER NITRATES IN THE NORTHWEST
OF THE THESSALONIKI REGIONAL UNIT (GREECE)
A. Terzopoulos*
2nd General Lyceum of Oraiokastro, GR–57013, Oraiokastro, Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: terzopoulosalexandros@gmail.com, tel : +302310695778
Abstract
The present study deals with the issue of local high nitrate ion concentrations in the groundwater of
the Greek region of Mygdonia. The specific phenomenon can be of great importance to Mygdonia
due to health effects described in literature and a possible reduction of crop yield, a major concern
for the regional agriculture-centred economy. Nitrate concentrations were measured in samples
collected from a multitude of locations in all three settlements of the region. Concentrations exceeding
the 50 mg/L EU limit were found in the majority of locations, especially around the area of the plains
of Mygdonia (settlements Drymos and Lete). This result was followed by statistical analysis of past
measurement data, which confirm chronically high levels in these locations as opposed to the more
mountainous area where acceptable concentrations were observed. Furthermore, slight rising linear
trends were calculated in locations of high nitrate concentrations and minimal negative trends in those
of lower concentrations.
A phytotoxicity screening of species Sorghum saccharatum and Sinapis alba in the presence of high
nitrate content water was also conducted, indicating a significant hindrance of early plant growth.
Thus, crop cultivation may also be at risk due to nitrate presence in groundwater used for irrigation.
Finally, probable causes are discussed and compared to previous studies, wherefrom an obvious
pattern of correlation to agriculture and N-fertiliser application arises; the region-specific
hydrogeological profile, however, also significantly raises the risk of groundwater contamination.
Specific handling suggestions for facing the nitrate problem are discussed in this study.
Keywords: Groundwater nitrates, Mygdonia aquifer, Phytotoxicity, N-fertilisation effects, Nitrate
vulnerability
1.
INTRODUCTION
Mygdonia is a 99.03 km2 rural region of the Thessaloniki regional unit (Greece), located about 15 km
north of the city. Mygdonia has been recorded to experience a problem of high nitrate (NO−
3)
concentration in the region's drinking water supply for at least the last decade (see section 2.1). The
issue has been principally associated with the arable plains of Mygdonia, which encompass the
settlements of Lete, Drymos, and the eastern part of Melissochori. According to hydrogeological data
of the respective Basin Management Plan [2012] compiled by the Ministry of Environment, Energy
and Climate Change of the Hellenic Republic, the region of Mygdonia is located on top of the more
extensive Mygdonia aquifer network (and corresponding groundwater body). Specifically the
settlements of Mygdonia belong to the Koroneia subsystem (GR1000071), whose ecological status
has been classified as "bad" (lowest possible classification) and the waters' chemical characteristics
as "failing to achieve good" (i.e. the majority thereof has had various substances' concentrations in
levels of potential threat to human health). In addition, data from the relevant municipal authorities
indicate that drinking water supply in Mygdonia originates exclusively from drilled water wells
631
Ground water resources management
exploiting said groundwater. Thus, the issue of excessive nitrates in the region's water can be viewed
as a specific case of nitrate accumulation in groundwater, a situation which has been repeatedly
encountered in existing literature [Gardner and Vogel, 2005; Johnson and Kross, 1990; Power and
Schepers, 1989; Strebel et al., 1989; Zhang et al., 1996].
Nitrates have been documented to negatively affect human health in numerous studies; according to
extant analytic reviews thereof [Bruning-Fann and Kaneene, 1993; Parvizishad et al., 2017; WHO,
2011], some common health risks arising from high nitrate consumption include infant ("blue baby
syndrome") and adult methaemoglobinaemia, as well as thyroid gland dysfunctions. The exact
correlation of nitrate intake and gastrointestinal tract tumours is still widely debated within existing
literature. Yet, nitrates in drinking water are generally considered harmful to public health and acute
toxicity results, such as methaemoglobinaemia, are observed when the concentration in drinking
water exceeds 45–50 mg/L of NO−
3 . In response to this, many countries including all members of the
European Community have set the "maximum admissible concentration" (MAC) of NO−
3 in drinking
water to 50 mg/L [Council Directive 98/83/EC, 1998].
Besides the great concern for human health, nitrates have been associated with adverse effects on
plant growth and potential reduction of crop yield [Chen et al., 2004; Maynard et al., 1976; Zhang et
al., 1996]. This would be a point of principal focus in Mygdonia, since the main economic activity of
the region is agricultural. The 2010 agricultural utilisation data from the Greek Payment Authority of
Common Agricultural Policy Aid Schemes ("OPEKEPE"), shows that 5014.71 ha (i.e. 50.64% of the
total region area) are fully irrigated and used for crop farming. Thereof, the vast majority (90.28% of
all farming area) is dedicated to the growing of cereals– mainly wheat, but also barley, oats, etc.
Existing research has focused on either nitrate content in plants as a risk to human health [Maynard
et al., 1976] or the correlation of soil nitrate concentration and plant growth [Chen et al., 2004]; the
present study examines the correlation of phytotoxicity and high nitrate concentration waters, such
as the ones that might be expected to be found in Mygdonia since water for irrigation is obtained from
the same aquifers as with drinking water.
From what has been discussed so far, high nitrate concentration in groundwater is evidently a major
issue and calls for further, case-specific, research on the possibly affected region of Mygdonia. To
this purpose, the present study has been compiled; experimental evaluation of the concurrent situation
in the drinking water of Mygdonia, statistical analysis of past data, the experimental testing of high
nitrate waters' effect on plant toxicity, discussion of the results and aetiology combined with
suggested measures comprise the total of the case study. The conclusions therefrom derived constitute
an as complete as feasible region profile in relation to groundwater nitrates; this profile can be
valuable in general as one additional reference case in related bibliography. Furthermore yet, it can
serve as an instrument for policy makers and local authorities aiding the better handling of the issue,
as well as a resource for public acknowledgement thereof.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Measurement of nitrate concentration (𝐍𝐎−
𝟑 mg/L) in the waters of Mygdonia & statistical
analysis of past nitrate concentration data
For the quantification of nitrate levels, a total of 9 samples of drinking water were obtained, 3 from
each settlement of the Mygdonia region (samples L1, L2, L3 from Lete; D1, D2, D3 from Drymos;
M1, M2, M3 from Melissochori; refer to Table 1). The samples were collected in clean PET bottles
from a multitude of outside faucets. After sampling was completed, all sample bottles were kept in
an insulated cool box until the measurements were conducted ~45 min later.
2.1
632
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1: Information and labelling of the samples collected for assessment of nitrate
concentration
Lete
samples
Sampling location
Drymos
samples
Sampling location
Melissochor
i samples
Sampling location
L1
Lete Comm. Hall
D1
Drymos Comm. Hall
M1
Cultural Association
L2
Local Fuel Station
D2
"Heroon" Region
M2
M/chori Comm. Hall
L3
"Skout" Region
D3
"Diskina" fountain
M3
Local Bakery
The procedure followed for the determination of nitrate concentration was the colourimetric
dimethylphenol method for drinking water, using the TNTplusTM 836 kit and HACH method 10206
as a reference method. LCK 339 cuvettes and 2,6-xylenol ("dimethylphenol") indicator were utilised,
with a DR 3900 spectrophotometer employed for measurements. The process was repeated twice (25
Jan 2018 & 1 Mar 2018) 35 days apart, with a set of 10 drinking water samples from the same sources
analysed using the same method.
Moreover, a statistical analysis of nitrate concentration measurements from the last ten years (2008–
2017) was performed. Past measurement data were treated with respect to water supply source (i.e.
water tank of each region), as per information provided by the Municipal Water Supply and Sewage
Corporation of Oraiokastro ("DEYAO"). According thereto: a) water distribution in Melissochori
originates from 3 disjoint water tanks ("Papadam", "Bizynou-Toumpa", and "Stam Petra", hereafter
referred to as m(I), m(II) and m(III) respectively); b) water supply in Lete is achieved through 2
disjoint water tanks ("Patoki" and "Vlahou", hereafter referred to as ℓ(I) and ℓ(II)); c) water
distribution in Drymos is comprised of multiple water tanks, which all do however originate from the
same larger tank ("Tsoukes") and as such the settlement's supply network is uniform (thus, it will be
treated as consisting of a single source, referred to as d). The value of nitrates (in mg/L) for each
source in the respective date was calculated as the average of all available measurements from sample
locations supplied by the corresponding source.
2.2 Experimental determination of phytotoxicity in high nitrate concentration waters
A phytotoxicity test was carried out in order to examine possible effects of high nitrate concentrations
in waters from Mygdonia on the germination of seeds and plant growth. To this purpose, 2 different
plant species (monocotyledon sorghum Sorghum saccharatum and dicotyledon white mustard Sinapis
alba) were screened using a MicroBio Tests Phytotoxkit, in 3 repetitions each with reference soil and
control water and further 3 repetitions each with reference soil and sample water. This process
completely adheres to the ISO standard 18763:2016 for the "determination of the toxic effects of
pollutants on germination and early growth of higher plants". Prior to the phytotoxicity testing, the
water sample collected from the D2 location to be used in the test group plates was spiked with
NaNO3 to a final concentration of 300.0 mg/L of NO3− . The plates containing the seeds and the
reference soil hydrated either with distilled water or sample water were kept in the incubator at a
steady temperature of 25°C (±0,5°C) and in constant darkness for 72 hours. At the end of the exposure
period, all plates were scanned. Afterwards, three different variables were measured:
i) Percentage of seed germination
For the ten seeds of each plate, the number of those which had germinated was recorded as a
percentage. The average of the germination success for each group (control/test) was calculated, as
well as the percent inhibition, which is given by the following formula:
𝐼𝑔 =
𝑔𝐶 − ̅̅̅
̅̅̅
𝑔𝑆
× 100%
𝑔𝐶
̅̅̅
633
Ground water resources management
,where 𝐼𝑔 is the seed germination success percent inhibition, ̅̅̅
𝑔𝐶 is mean control group germination
success and ̅̅̅
𝑔𝑆 is mean test group germination success. The corresponding p-values were also
calculated by Welch's unequal variances t-test (for a one-tailed hypothesis) using the statistical
software PSPP v. 1.0.1-g818227.
ii) Root growth (length measurement)
Root length measurement was carried out with image analysis software ImageJ v. 1.50i. Mean root
length r (in mm) for each plate was calculated from length measurements of the respective plate. For
the estimation of percent inhibition of root growth (𝐼𝑟 ) the group mean root lengths (referred to as 𝑟̅C
for a control group and 𝑟̅S for a test group) were computed, as the average of each group's plates' r
values. The formula
𝐼𝑟 =
𝑟̅C − 𝑟̅S
× 100%
𝑟̅C
was then used to obtain 𝐼𝑟 values for each plant species. Subsequently, p-values for the totality of
each group's root length data were calculated in PSPP by Welch's t-test for a one-tailed hypothesis.
The results are discussed in section 3.2.
iii) Shoot growth (length measurement)
The identical procedure as with root length was adopted for the measurement of shoot length of
individuals that exhibited any significant shoot growth; thus, mean shoot length values (s, in mm)
were determined for each individual plate. The group mean shoot lengths (𝑠̅C for a control group and
𝑠̅S for a test group, henceforth) were next calculated, as the average of each group's plates' s values.
The respective percent inhibition of root growth (𝐼𝑠 ) was given by the formula:
𝐼𝑠 =
𝑠̅C − 𝑠̅S
× 100%
𝑠̅C
Finally, p-values for each group's aggregate shoot length data were calculated by Welch's t-test for a
one-tailed hypothesis; results are presented and discussed in section 3.2.
3.
RESULTS
3.1. Experimental results of nitrate concentration measurement & past nitrate concentration data
statistical analysis
−
-1
Table 2: Results of 𝐍𝐎−
𝟑 measurements (expressed as 𝐍𝐎𝟑 mg∙L )
Date
Sampling location
L1
L2
L3
D1
D2
D3
M1
M2
M3
25 Jan 2018
56.6
61.8
62.9
72.6
72.4
70.1
7.86
8.06
6.86
1 Mar 2018
59.0
56.8
57.8
60.7
61.3
71.5
7.21
7.41
7.11
Loc. Average
57.8
59.3
60.4
66.7
66.9
70.8
7.54
7.74
6.99
The results of the spectrophotometric measurements conducted (refer to section 2.1) are given in
Table 2. Date and sampling location are noted, while the average of the measurements for each
location has also been included. All locations in Lete and Drymos were found to have NO−
3 levels
above the MAC, with notably high results observed in Drymos. In contrast, samples from
Melissochori all had acceptable levels.
634
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Following the experimental confirmation of the existence of a concurrent nitrate issue in Mygdonia,
the past data collected in section 2.1 were statistically evaluated. The concentration values (in mg/L)
for each water supply source were plotted against time for the 10-year interval of study (2008–2018).
In the resulting graph, Figure 1, nitrate concentrations are represented as data points (circles) of a
scatter plot, while a continuous straight line represents the linear trend for each supply source
calculated with the least squares method. Linear regression was selected to examine the nitrate
concentration statistical trend for all sources except m(II) as this particular data series was found to
be highly irregular and non-linear with a Pearson correlation coefficient of |r|~0,05. The irregularity
of m(II) values is consistent with –and could be caused by– the supply source using a multitude of
water sources (i.e. different wells) which exhibit varying behaviour in relation to nitrates, leading to
such scattered data.
Figure 1: Scatter plots of the evolution of nitrate concentration with time in different supply
sources of Mygdonia. Linear trends (in mg∙L-1∙annum-1) for each source were: ℓ(I) +0.84; ℓ(II)
+1.68; d +0.84; m(I) -0.66; m(III) -0.84
The choice of linear regression for the other sources was decided upon as a simple statistical
modelling of the concentrations, whose measurements can be approximately considered error-free
and homoscedastic. In reality, nitrate concentration in drinking water is an issue stemming from
complicated interrelations between many factors, some of which are discussed in section 3.3;
therefore, a more realistic model for groundwater nitrates would require complex statistical relations
and robust multivariable analysis [Strebel et al., 1989]. Such a task, and corresponding multi-level
research, is considered beyond the scope of the present study.
The sources' linear trends' rates of change (nitrate concentration in relation to time) were extracted
from the respective line's gradient; both positive and negative trending rates were found (expressed
as change of concentration units in respect to time units). It is notable that higher nitrate
concentrations as well as mostly positive trends were consistently observed in the area of the plains
of Mygdonia (Lete–Drymos–eastern Melissochori, the respective supply sources being ℓ(I), ℓ(II), d
and m(II)), while minimal negative trends and acceptable nitrate concentration were associated with
635
Ground water resources management
mountainous regions (in western Melissochori; specifically in sources m(I) and m(III)). These
correlations suggest that further causes lie behind the sub-regional situation of nitrate occurrence in
each landform's vicinity; said causes can be attributed to differing geological composition, variable
agricultural practice, water well construction details, etc., more thoroughly discussed in section 3.3.
3.1 Results and discussion of experimental phytotoxicity assessment
When the twelve plates were examined after the 72 h incubation period, a visually obvious
impediment of plant growth was observed in the test group plates, for both species. Yet, for the exact
assessment of phytotoxicity, the three dependent variables were separately examined:
Table 3: Results of the phytotoxicity experiment: average germination success, average root
length (in mm), average shoot length (in mm) and percent inhibition for each variable
Germination % and inhibition
Sorghum
sacch.
Root length (mm) and inhibition
Sinapis
alba
Sorghum
sacch.
Shoot length (mm) and inhibition
Sinapis
alba
Sorghum
sacch.
Sinapis
alba
𝑔𝐶
̅̅̅
83.33%
𝑔𝐶
̅̅̅
96.67%
𝑟̅C
43.14
𝑟̅C
53.92
𝑠̅C
14.82
𝑠̅C
22.09
𝑔𝑆
̅̅̅
83.33%
𝑔𝑆
̅̅̅
93.33%
𝑟̅S
33.27
𝑟̅S
37.58
𝑠̅S
13.34
𝑠̅S
21.05
𝐼𝑔
0.00%
𝐼𝑔
3.45%
𝐼𝑟
22.88%
𝐼𝑟
30.31%
𝐼𝑠
9.94%
𝐼𝑠
4.68%
p
0.5000
p
0.2592
p
0.0344
p
0.0017
p
0.3023
p
0.4117
i) Percentage of seed germination
No inhibition of seed germination was observed for Sorghum saccharatum, and only a small
percentage (3.45%) for Sinapis alba. Both results are not considered statistically significant as
p>0.05, therefore suggesting that high nitrate concentration plays no substantial role in negatively
influencing the process of seed germination of the two examined species.
ii) Root growth (length measurement)
The obtained values show major inhibition of root growth for both species, the impediment being
especially prevalent in the roots of dicotyledon Sinapis alba. The inhibition is statistically significant
(p<0.05) for both plants, yet for Sinapis alba an extremely strong result was obtained. This is
indicative of the sample water exhibiting unmistakable phytoxical effect.
iii) Shoot growth (length measurement)
Some inhibition was manifested for this variable, as well, though statistically insignificant as the pvalues suggest. Shoot growth impediment was marginally more prominent in monocotyledon
Sorghum saccharatum.
In total, the comparative examination of the phytoxicity test for the two plant species, returned the
following findings in relation to the dependent variables: i) zero to minimal seed germination
inhibition; ii) significant to strongly significant root growth for both species; iii) insignificant shoot
growth inhibition. Nonetheless, it should be noted that in general, and also according to the directives
of ISO 18763:2016 and relevant standards referenced therein, shoot development is of secondary use
as a phytotoxicity indicator; germination success and root growth should be primarily referred to,
instead. The implication for both species is that high nitrate concentration waters can pose a
considerable factor of phytotoxicity, as the hindrance of early plant growth is a significant indication
thereof. Existing literature confirms that nitrates in excess can have detrimental effects on plant
development similar to the ones recorded, however previous research was conducted solely on
examining effects of varying nitrate concentration soils and not the water used [Chen et al., 2004].
636
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
As such, the assertion can be made that excessive nitrate is an environmental pollutant, affecting plant
growth at least, in areas where its concentration in water has been steadily high. This potential
phenomenon can then be applied in the region of Mygdonia, inferring plausible peril for agriculture
and regional economic activities akin thereto, since the chronically high in nitrate water has been used
for the irrigation of the mainly monocotyledonous crops (e.g. wheat) as shown in section 1.
3.2 Discussion on aetiology
The arable plains of Mygdonia, where above limits nitrate concentrations and positive trends were
found, also comprise the chief area of the regional agricultural activity. Nitrate contamination of
groundwater and resulting accumulation in agricultural land areas is a common phenomenon in
previous studies, and has been most importantly linked to extensive use of nitrogen fertilisers (Nfertilisers) in crops therein grown [Ju et al., 2004; Power and Schepers, 1989; Strebel et al., 1989;
Zhang et al., 1996]. These fertilisers contain the essential plant nutrient N in a range of possible forms
(nitrate salts, ammonium salts, urea, anhydrous ammonia, cyanamide salts, etc.); however their
application in soil invariably leads to formation of some nitrates due to the natural process of
nitrification [Tsitsias, 2000]. The aforementioned studies have consistently linked higher N-fertiliser
application rates, especially so on irrigated land, to continuously lower crop N-uptake and nitrates
leaching into groundwater, therefore being the principal cause of nitrate contamination. In addition,
according to official documents "international literature suggests that [nitrate] concentrations above
10 mg/L are likely to be connected to anthropogenic pollution" [Special Secretariat for Water of the
Ministry of Environment, Energy and Climate Change of the Hellenic Republic, 2012], as "the natural
nitrate concentration in groundwater under aerobic conditions is a few milligrams per litre" [WHO,
2011].
Greek soils are generally quite poor in plant-available N, and as such the utilisation of N-fertilisers is
almost universal and necessary for most crops [Stylianidis et al., 2002; Tsitsias, 2000]. For wheat and
related cereals, which constitute the main crop of Mygdonia, the following fertilisation scheme is
most commonly adhered to in Greece, according to Tsitsias [2000]: a) an initial basal dressing of Nfertiliser (usually NH4NO3 or other nitrate salts) or binary NP-fertiliser (NH4H2PO4, (NH4)2HPO4
etc.) during sowing; b) a later topdressing and foliar application of straight N-fertiliser (most
preferably urea (NH2)2CO), which is ideally administered in two doses. The total recommended Ninput is 70–180 kg∙ha-1 equally distributed between basal and topdressing. Actual application may
not follow this amount or not be correctly distributed, which in combination with multiple factors of
fertiliser loss (e.g. surface runoff) leads to an average N-uptake of crops in Greece in the order of 50–
70%, in extreme cases getting as low as 20% [Stylianidis et al., 2002; Tsitsias, 2000]. Thus, an excess
of leftover N is expected in Greek soils, comparable to cases in international literature.
The specific qualitative geolithological characteristics of Mygdonia also indicate a natural
vulnerability to nitrate accumulation; the following information pertaining to the region's strata was
retrieved from the geological survey of Kockel et al. [1978] and lithostratigraphic analysis
accompanying water well data provided by DEYAO. According to these sources, the Mygdonian
underground is mainly composed of Quaternary sedimentary deposits (eluvial mantle, fluvial
terraces, fans, etc.). In the eastern part of the region, where plains predominate the landscape, strata
of granular characteristics (gravel, sand, sandy clay, gritstone, clay conglomerates, red clay series)
are abundant and constitute the vast majority of the underground around Lete, Drymos and east of
Melissochori. Some older Neogene deposits (red and silty clays) have also been detected in the
vicinity of Lete. The common pattern in the plain areas is an initial thin surface layer of clay (thickness
5–40 m), followed by alternating granular layers as aforementioned.
The type of lithological formations described above is the most susceptible to nitrate leaching and
contamination of groundwater, according to existing literature [Johnson and Kross, 1990; Power and
Schepers, 1989; Strebel et al., 1989; Tsitsias, 2000; Zhang et al., 1999]. This could result due to the
clay layers of limited thickness, interposed between hydraulically conductive sand–gravel layers, not
being able to sufficiently mitigate nitrate-rich surface water from leaching to lower groundwater
637
Ground water resources management
levels of the aquifer [Durner, 1994; Pupisky and Shainberg, 1979; Strebel et al., 1989]. This situation
can be aggravated in seasons of intense precipitation, markedly so when combined with N-fertiliser
application [Johnson and Kross, 1990; Ju et al., 2004; Strebel et al., 1989].
Specific to the region of the Koroneia basin subunit, the Greek Government under Joint Ministerial
Decision № 20419/2522/2001 has recognised the Mygdonia unit along with others in the wider region
of Thessaloniki as a "zone vulnerable to nitrate contamination from agricultural sources". The slight
rising trends found in section 3.1 can therefore be paralleled to similar trends all over Europe or other
parts of the world, where continuing rise of nitrates is observed in areas of agricultural activity and/or
granular–sandy soil composition [Ju et al., 2004; Strebel et al., 1989; Zhang et al., 1999]. The
corresponding minute negative trends in the case of western Melissochori could signify a presumed
break in the otherwise hydraulically connected –albeit variable– groundwater body of Mygdonia or
a differentiated response of the local lithostratigraphy. Indeed, in the westernmost of the region the
terrain becomes increasingly mountainous and the respective strata are differentiated. Therein, the
older Melissochori-Cholomon Unit exhibits calcareous flysch deposits of alternating calcareous
sandstone, phyllites and shale, dating to the Triassic–Middle Jurassic Era. Therefore, the aquifer is
expected to be situated in such types of formations rather than granular layers. Whether this can affect
the aquifer's response to nitrate contamination and the extent of such an effect has to be met with
future hydrogeological investigation.
In general, while the lithological and hydrogeological features of a region considerably determine the
risk of high nitrate levels in groundwater as has been hitherto discussed, the prevailing nitrate source
appears to be anthropogenic activity mainly through the use of fertilisers, as per the first paragraphs
of the section. Indeed, at least one multivariable statistical model for the description and prediction
of groundwater NO−
3 concentration has been presented, wherein nitrate levels are directly correlated
to land use; therein, significantly higher concentrations were predicted and observed in regions of
agricultural activity [Gardner and Vogel, 2005] where N-fertiliser use is expected.
3.3 Suggested measures for lowering groundwater nitrate concentration
A measure of prime significance for dealing with the most probable cause of nitrate accumulation –
excessive fertilisation, as per section 3.4– is the adoption of better N-fertiliser management practices,
as has been repeatedly proposed in existing literature [Ju et al., 2004; Power and Schepers, 1989;
Zhang et al., 1996, etc.]. Such course of action calls for monitoring of N-fertiliser input and crop
productivity, change of fertilisation regime (more frequent administration and in smaller dosages),
prevention of fertiliser application during rainy season, local government co-operation and incentive
schemes; in cases where some or all of said measures were applied, nitrate levels reduction and
increase of crop yield were accomplished [Power and Schepers, 1989; Zhang et al., 1996]. Assertive
action relating to economic policy has been proposed, as well [Ju et al., 2004].
The necessity of analogous measures in Mygdonia is evident, considering that fertilisation control in
Greece is minimal and bad farming practice is occasionally customary [Tsitsias, 2000]. While relative
legislature has been passed (Joint Ministerial Decision № 16175/824/2006) setting the acceptable
fertilisation level for wheat cultivation at 80–120 kg∙ha-1 of N with variable incentives-penalties,
nitrate levels remain higher than acceptable, as has been shown in sections 3.1 & 3.3. The existence
of said legislature, however, counts in itself as a positive step in addressing the issue.
In a further attempt to increase the efficiency and plant N-uptake from fertilisers, the use of slowrelease (otherwise known as controlled-release) N-fertilisers has been advocated [Tsitsias, 2000;
Zhang et al., 1996, etc.]. This type of fertilisers consist of granular particles which are either
encapsulated in a protective, slowly-dissolving polymer or sulfur layer, or contain urea derivatives
that have been treated to be insoluble in water, and as such less rapidly acting. Yet, their cost
compared to regular fertilisers has discouraged farmers from utilising them broadly.
At least one study has also demonstrated the effectiveness of catch-crop treatment of cereal crops in
substantially reducing the soil and drainage water nitrate content, as well as the extent of nitrate
638
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
leaching [Lewan, 1994]. Catch crops, such as Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum) used in said study,
are fast-growing annual crops let to grow between successive main crop sowings. The fact that the
aforementioned study was conducted on sandy soils with cereals as the main crop indicates such a
solution might be highly suitable to Mygdonia.
Further specialised suggestions involve construction of denitrification beds [Ghane et al., 2014]. Such
systems exploit the natural action of denitrifying anaerobic bacteria which are able to metabolise
nitrate NO3− primarily to harmless nitrogen gas N2 and secondarily nitrous oxide N2O; their
application has been proposed on a theoretical level in previous literature as well [Strebel et al., 1989].
The particular setup of Ghane et al. [2014] performed notably well in raising subsurface water quality
in relation to nitrates; comparable action can be suggested for the in situ or ex situ (in small scale
water-treatment plants) remediation of nitrate-contaminated groundwater in Mygdonia.
Another possible suggestion by Johnson and Kross [1990] for the handling of high nitrate
concentrations in drinking water obtained from wells in rural communities is the adoption of proper
well construction techniques. As per the DEYAO data relating to extant water wells in Mygdonia
basic construction conforms to the aforementioned instructions: wells have been so far drilled (rather
than dug) and in all cases their depth is greater than the 30 m minimum suggested by Johnson and
Kross (the range of depths being 140–260 m). Yet, a further, pivotal factor that should be considered
is the correct application of insulation (grouting) on the upper well layers so as to prevent the
migration of surface and subsurface water, which can hold the largest amount of nitrates from
irrigation effluents, to lower levels of the well wherefrom drinking water is extracted [Johnson and
Kross, 1990]. Cement grouting has been occasionally used in the water wells of Mygdonia, with great
variation observed on the depth of application. Grouting of 40–90 m has been employed in some
newer wells, while older wells have had a mere 4–20 m of upper layer insulation; swallow insulation
is especially evident around the settlements of Drymos and Melissochori. The effectiveness of current
insulation ought to be more thoroughly examined in future studies, with focus on the choice of the
most appropriate material and grouting depth.
Lastly, the compiling of a more complete local groundwater body profile is required. Therein a
comprehensive mapping of the aquifer in its present situation may be included, as well as specific
determination of the water renewal rate and monitoring of water mass equilibria. Such data could be
moreover used to assess whether blending water in the supply network of Mygdonia with other
regions' water, as has been proposed for analogous cases by the World Health Organization [2011],
is a viable strategy. It is worth noting that no singular course of action can guarantee the best
achievable reduction of nitrate levels; a combination thereof should be considered.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
The problem of higher than allowable NO3− concentrations in the drinking water of Mygdonia was
attested both experimentally in early 2018 and throughout data from the past decade. In the plain
regions (primarily surrounding Lete and Drymos) where the issue was the most prevalent, slight rising
trends of the nitrate levels were moreover found by statistical analysis. In contrast, around
Melissochori the acceptable nitrate levels observed were also accompanied by mostly negative trends
of small magnitude. Underlying differences may include varying hydrogeological substrates, since
the sandy soil of the plains makes the region much more vulnerable to groundwater nitrates than the
flysch deposit of the more mountainous Melissochori. The aetiology of the problem has also been
discussed focusing on human activity, viz. excessive N-fertiliser application since agriculture is the
main economic activity of Mygdonia and N-fertilisation is widespread. The aforementioned
lithostratigraphic factors have also been taken into consideration.
As part of the research on consequences from groundwater nitrates, notable phytotoxocity and
inhibition of early plant growth was experimentally verified by testing on plant species Sorghum
saccharatum and Sinapis alba. This indicates a possible cause of harm to crops, and an ensuing
negative impact on regional economy. Therefore, as well as due to considerations of human and
639
Ground water resources management
animal health described in previous studies, an overview of proposed solutions from analogous cases
in existing literature has been presented. Such measures should be adopted promptly, so as to ensure
both remediation and future prevention of high nitrate concentrations in the groundwater and drinking
water of Mygdonia.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author wishes to express his utmost gratitude foremost to Dr M. Petala and also to Dr V. Tsiridis
of the School of Civil Engineering of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki for their helpful
guidance and scientific advice. All experiments were conducted in the Laboratory of Environmental
Engineering & Planning of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki (School of Civil Engineering).
The assistance of the Municipal Water Supply and Sewage Corporation of Oraiokastro ("DEYAO")
in obtaining valuable data about regional water wells and past nitrate concentration measurements in
Mygdonia is appreciated.
References
1. Special Secretariat for Water. (2012). ‘Management Plan of the River Basins of Central
Macedonia River Basin District (GR10)’. Ministry of Environment, Energy and Climate
Change of the Hellenic Republic.
2. Gardner K.K. and R.M. Vogel. (2005). ‘Predicting ground water nitrate concentration from land
use’, Ground Water. 43(3), pp. 343–352.
3. Johnson C.J. and B.C. Kross. (1990). ‘Continuing Importance of Nitrate Contamination of
Groundwater and Wells in Rural Areas’. American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 18(4), pp.
449–456.
4. Power J.F. and J.S. Schepers. (1989). ‘Nitrate Contamination of Groundwater in North America’.
Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 26(3-4), pp. 165–187.
5. Strebel O., W. Duynisveld and J. Böttcher. (1989). ‘Nitrate Pollution of Groundwater in Western
Europe’. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 26(3-4), pp. 189–214.
6. Zhang W.L., Z.X. Tian, N. Zhang and X.Q. Li. (1996). ‘Nitrate Pollution of Groundwater in
Northern China’. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 59(3), pp. 223–231.
7. Bruning-Fann C.S. and J.B. Kaneene. (1993). ‘The Effects of Nitrate, Nitrite, and N-nitroso
Compounds on Human Health: A Review’. Veterinary & Human Toxicology, 35(6), pp. 521–
538.
8. Parvizishad M., A. Dalvand, A.H. Mahvi and F. Goodarzi. (2017). ‘A Review of Adverse Effects
and Benefits of Nitrate and Nitrite in Drinking Water and Food on Human Health’. Health
Scope, 6(3):e14164.
9. World Health Organization. (2011). ‘Nitrate and nitrite in drinking-water: Background
document for development of WHO Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality’. WHO.
10. Council of the European Union. (1998). ‘Council Directive 98/83/EC on the quality of water
intended for human consumption’. Official Journal of the European Communities, № L 330,
pp. 32–54.
11. Chen B.M., Z.H Wang, S.X. Li, G.X. Wang, H.X. Song and X.N. Wang. (2004). ‘Effects of nitrate
supply on plant growth, nitrate accumulation, metabolic nitrate concentration and nitrate
reductase activity in three leafy vegetables’. Plant Science, 167(3), pp. 635–643.
12. Maynard D.N., A.V. Barker, P.L. Minotti and N.H. Peck. (1976). ‘Nitrate Accumulation in
Vegetables’. Advances in Agronomy, 28, pp. 71–118.
13. https://it.opekepe.gr/aggregate (accessed 1 Mar 2018).
640
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
14. ISO. (2016). 18763:2016(en): Soil quality- Determination of the toxic effects of pollutants on
germination and early growth of higher plants. International Organization for Standardization,
Geneva.
15. Ju, X., X. Liu, F. Zhang and M. Roelcke. (2004). ‘Nitrogen Fertilization, Soil Nitrate
Accumulation, and Policy Recommendations in Several Agricultural Regions of China’.
AMBIO, 33(6), pp. 300–305.
16. Tsitsias K. (2000). ‘Lipasmatologia’. Technological Educational Institute of Larissa.
17. Stylianidis D.C., A.D. Simonis and G.D. Syrgiannidis. (2002). ‘Nutrition-Fertilization of
Deciduous Fruit Trees’. Stamoulis Publications.
18. Kockel F., P. Antoniadis, K. Ioannidis and N. Lalehos. (1978) ‘Geological Map of
Greece’. Institute of Geological and Mining Research of Greece.
19. Durner W. (1994). ‘Hydraulic conductivity estimation for soils with heterogeneous pore
structure’. Water Resources Research, 30(2), pp. 211–223.
20. Pupisky H. and I. Shainberg. (1979). ‘Salt Effects on the Hydraulic Conductivity of a Sandy
Soil’. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 43(3), pp. 429–433.
21. Lewan E. (1994). ‘Effects of a catch crop on leaching of nitrogen from a sandy soil: Simulations
and measurements’. Plant and Soil, 166(1), pp. 137–152.
22. Ghane E., N.R. Fausey and L.C. Brown. (2015). ‘Modeling nitrate removal in a denitrification
bed’. Water Resources, 71, pp. 294–305.
641
Ground water resources management
SIMULATION OF WATER FLOW IN THE UNSATURATED SOIL
ZONE TO ASSESS IRRIGATION IN A MAIZE FIELD
Ch. Doulgeris1, D. Voulanas2*, G. Arampatzis1 and E. Hatzigiannakis1
1
Soil and Water Resources Institute-Dept. of Land Reclamation, Hellenic Agricultural Organisation,
GR 57400, Sindos, Greece
2
Lab of Engineering Geology and Hydrogeology, Dept. of Geology, A.U.Th, GR 54124
Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: dvoulanas@yahoo.com tel: +306947511281
Abstract
Accurate estimation of the hydrological features in the unsaturated zone is mandatory for the effective
planning of irrigation strategies. Irrigation scheduling depends on crop and soil type as well as
climatic characteristics and is usually empirically conducted. This paper simulates the water flow in
the unsaturated zone of an agricultural field located in the River Strymonas basin using the HYDRUS1D model. The model is fed with meteorological data, soil data and soil moisture measurements
derived by field experiments. After the calibration of the model, model results were used to evaluate
the irrigation activities applied in the experimental field in terms of irrigation dose, irrigation interval
and soil moisture variation for the cultivation period.
Keywords: Vadose zone simulation, HYDRUS-1D, Maize, Irrigation
1.
INTRODUCTION
In agricultural areas where rain is insufficient during the cultivation period, irrigation consists of a
significant consumption of water resources and thus needs to be optimized in order to economically
secure the agricultural production and to environmentally protect water resources. Optimal planning
of irrigation depends heavily on climatological factors, crop and soil type. Irrigation activities are
usually scheduled and evaluated through empirical practices that quantify and predict the soil water
balance and related characteristics under a cultivated crop. On the other hand, analytical and
numerical models are continuously improving to study and evaluate water movement characteristics
and related phenomena (Vereecken et al. 2015). Numerical modelling of vadose zone can simulate
water fluxes within the soil-vegetation-atmosphere system to improve water use efficiency in
agriculture, especially in case of water scarcity (Babajimopoulos et al. 1995; Babajimopoulos et al.
2007; Sutanto et al. 2012; Zheng et al. 2017).
HYDRUS-1D model can simulate one-dimensional variably saturated water flow, heat movement
and transport of solutes involved in sequential first-order decay reactions by handling flexibly various
boundary conditions (Šimůnek et al. 2008a). It has been applied in several case studies and at various
climatological conditions to simulate, optimize and predict the water flow and solute transport in the
soil vadose zone under field experiments and lab conditions (Hanson et al. 2008; Jellali et al. 2009;
Ramos et al. 2011; Tafteh et al. 2012; Chang et al. 2015; Zheng et al. 2017).
This paper assesses the irrigation practices and estimates the groundwater recharge in an irrigated
maize field located in the River Strymonas basin by simulating the water flow in the unsaturated soil
zone. For that, the mixed form of Richards’s equation is numerically solved by applying the
HYDRUS model. Model results are evaluated both in terms of applied irrigation and soil moisture
642
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
measurements that have been conducted by the Institute of Soil and Water Resources (LRI, 2009;
Arampatzis et al., 2010; 2014).
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Study Area and Available Data
Nigrita – Flampouro agricultural area (Fig.1) is located at the southern part of River Strymonas basin
at an altitude of around 15 m a.m.s.l and a distance of 22 km from the sea. An irrigation network
operates under pressure using five pumping stations and supplies 6300 hectares. The main crop types
in the area are maize, cotton, alfalfa and industry tomato.
Figure 1: Nigrita - Flampouro agricultural area (outlined by the blue line) and the under
study maize field (pointed with the red arrow); the reddish lines depict the underground
distribution network
Data for the area were available from the project “Irrigation of crops with the use of meteorological
stations at Strymonas basin” and include meteorological data, soil data and in situ soil moisture
measurements (LRI, 2009). Meteorological data were recorded by an automatic meteorological
station located close to the agricultural area. The recorded meteorological parameters are
precipitation, temperature, relative humidity, wind speed and direction, sunshine duration and
evaporation measured with a class An evaporation pan. Soil samples were analysed in the lab using
the Bouyoucos method to determine the percentages of sand, silt and clay while the saturated
hydraulic conductivity, Ks, was measured with a Guelph device in situ (Table 1). The hydraulics
parameters in the soil column were determined by regression analysis based on the soil moisture
characteristic curve and van Genuchten equation (Table 2).
Soil moisture measurements were taken by field experiments that conducted from late March to early
August. A 10 cm diameter hole was dug up to 1 m depth and a DIVINER-2000 pipe was installed to
take measurements of soil moisture every 10 cm at regular intervals. Also, two wells of 2 m depth
were placed near the edge of the field to monitor the water table level. During the field experiments
the water table was below the 2 m depth and was not recorded.
643
Ground water resources management
Table 1: Soil properties in the study area
Silt (%)
Clay (%)
Sand (%)
66.8
19.2
14.0
Ks (cm/day)
0.3
Table 2: Hydraulic and van Genuchten parameters in the soil column
θr
a
n
m
Field Capacity
Wilting Point
θs
cm3 cm-3
cm3 cm-3
1/m
0.37
0.16
2.59
1.67
0.4
cm3 cm-3
cm3 cm-3
0.345
0.16
2.2 HYDRUS model setup
The HYDRUS model (Šimůnek et al. 2008b) applies the Galerkin finite element method to discretise
the soil profile in vertical one-dimension domain and simulate the unsaturated and transient water
flow under the presence of a crop. A soil column of 1 m height was considered by placing a
computational node every 1 cm. A variable time step was used; initial, minimum and maximum time
steps were set up to 0.01, 0.001 and 0.01, respectively. Uniform soil moisture of 0.25 was used as the
initial condition of the simulation considering the precipitation events prior to the simulation. The
simulation period was from 1 April to 31 August 2008.
The water movement in the unsaturated soil zone is described with the mixed form of Richard’s
equation (Eq. 1):
𝜕𝜃
𝜕𝑡
=
𝜕
𝜕𝑧
𝜕ℎ
[𝐾(ℎ) ( 𝜕𝑧 + 1)] − 𝑆(𝑧, 𝑡)
(1)
where θ is the volumetric water content (cm3 cm−3); h is the water pressure head (cm); t is time (day);
z is the vertical coordinate (cm); K is the hydraulic conductivity (cm day−1); and S is root water uptake
(cm3 cm−3 day−1).
In this HYDRUS application, the soil-hydraulic functions of van Genuchten (1980), who used the
statistical pore-size distribution model of Mualem (1976), are used to obtain a predictive equation for
the unsaturated hydraulic conductivity function in terms of soil water retention parameters. The van
Genuchten expressions are formulated as:
𝜃𝑠−𝜃𝑟
𝜃 +
𝜃(ℎ) = { 𝑟 (1+|𝑎ℎ|𝑛)𝑚
𝜃𝑠
𝐾(ℎ) =
𝐾𝑠 𝑆𝑒𝑙
ℎ<0
(2)
ℎ≥0
1
𝑚
𝑚 2
[1 − (1 − 𝑆𝑒 ) ]
(3)
𝜃−𝜃
𝑆𝑒 = 𝜃 −𝜃𝑟
𝑠
(4)
𝑟
where θs is the saturated water content (cm3 cm-3); θr is the residual water content (cm3 cm-3); Ks is
the saturated hydraulic conductivity (cm day-1); Se is the effective water content; and α, n, m are
relative empirical parameters, where m=1-1/n and l is the pore-connectivity parameter and is assumed
to be about 0.5 as an average for many soils.
The boundary conditions in the soil column were set up in the HYDRUS environment. The upper
boundary condition includes the inflow from precipitation and irrigation and the outflow from
evaporation and is given by:
644
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
𝜕ℎ
−𝐾 (𝜕𝑧 + 1) = 𝑞0 (𝑡)
𝑧=0
(5)
where q0 is the net inflow or outflow (mm/day).
The lower boundary condition is simulated as a free drainage condition, as the water table was not
recorded in any of the two wells placed near the field, and is expressed as:
𝜕ℎ
𝜕𝑧
=0
(6)
𝑧 = 100 𝑐𝑚
2.3 Evapotranspiration and irrigation
The reference evapotranspiration was calculated using the Penman-Monteith equation as
recommended by FAO (Allen et al. 1998). Actual evaporation (Ea) is calculated by HYDRUS based
on potential evaporation (Ep) and soil water content using Beer’s Law (Ritchie 1972; Childs 1975).
Potential evaporation is calculated using Eq. 7.
𝐸𝑝 = 𝐸𝑇0 𝑒 −𝑘𝐿𝐴𝐼
(7)
where ET0 is the reference evapotranspiration (cm), k is the constant for the radiation extinction by
canopy and LAI is the leaf area index adapted to the four crop growth stages by data obtained by
Antonopoulos (2000).
Root growth was modelled using the Verhulst-Pearl logistic growth function (Eq. 8) supposing that
50% of the growth is reached at the middle of the growing season. The root growth coefficient is
expressed as:
𝑓𝑟 (𝑡) = 𝐿
𝐿0
0 +(𝐿𝑚 −𝐿0 )𝑒
(8)
−𝑟𝑡
where L0 is the initial value of the rooting depth at the beginning of the growing season, r is the
growth rate, Lm is the maximum rooting depth and t is the time.
HYDRUS couples the aforementioned growth function with the root distribution model of Hoffman
and van Genuchten (1983). The potential water uptake distribution function in the soil root zone, b(x),
is given by:
1.66667
𝑏(𝑥) =
2.0833
𝐿𝑅
{
𝐿𝑅
𝐿−𝑥
(1 −
𝐿𝑅
𝑥 > 𝐿 − 0.2𝐿𝑅
)
0
𝑥 ∈ (𝐿 − 𝐿𝑅 , 𝐿 − 0.2𝐿𝑅 )
(9)
𝑥 < 𝐿 − 𝐿𝑅
where x is the soil coordinate measuring from the bottom of the soil column, L is the maximum length
of soil column and LR is the root depth. Therefore, the root depth, LR, is the product of the maximum
rooting depth, Lm, and the root growth coefficient, fr (Šimůnek and Suarez, 1993a).
Actual transpiration (Ta) is considered equal to the root water uptake assuming that plants use a minor
water quantity for tissue building. Actual transpiration was calculated using the Feddes water uptake
reduction model (Feddes et al. 1976).
𝑇𝑎 = 𝑆(𝑧, 𝑡) = 𝑎(ℎ, 𝑧)𝛽(𝑧)𝑇𝑝
(10)
645
Ground water resources management
where S is the water volume removed from the soil volume per time by plant water uptake, α is the
root water uptake stress response function (-), β(z) is the function of root water uptake distribution
(cm-1) and Tp is the potential transpiration (cm).
Irrigation is simulated within HYDRUS by triggering an irrigation event each time the pressure head
at a selected computational node, which was arbitrarily selected at 10 cm below soil surface, drops
below the value of -3950 cm. This pressure value was selected through a trial and error procedure
and intended to replicate the irrigation practices followed in the field experiments in terms of the
average irrigation dose and the irrigation date.
3.
RESULTS
3.1 Model calibration
The calibration of the model was performed by using a set of parameters for saturated hydraulic
conductivity (i.e. 0.3, 0.03 and 3 cm day-1), saturated water content (i.e. 0.37, 0.42 and 0.47 cm3 cm3
) and irrigation dose, and by comparing graphically and statistically the modelled soil moisture with
measurements and modelled irrigation doses with the experimental ones. Table 3 shows the final
selected set of model parameters.
Table 3: Calibrated model parameters
θs
θr
a
cm3 cm-3
cm3 cm-3
1/m
0.42
0.16
2.59
n
m = 1-1/n
l
Ks
cm/day
1.67
0.4
0.5
0.3
Figure 2 compares the modelled and measured mean soil moisture in the soil column for the
simulation period (1 April to 31 August 2008). Modelled soil moisture is considerably varied by
increasing rapidly in the initial stage of the simulation due to precipitation events and then follows a
gradual decline until the irrigation events begin. The soil moisture estimated by the model is
comparable with the soil moisture measurements, especially in terms of the response of the model to
irrigation and precipitation events. Considering the statistical criteria, the average mean error, root
mean square error and the mean absolute error are 1.25, 4.65 and 3.62 cm3 cm-3, respectively,
suggesting that the efficiency of the model is fairly good and model results are acceptable. A different
model setup involving a non uniform soil profile is expected to increase model performance and it
will be the focus of further research.
Figure 3 shows the irrigations doses and the date at which irrigation was applied in the field
experiments and the corresponding ones simulated by the model. The total amount of irrigation water
estimated by the model is 40.8 cm and is quite comparable with the total irrigation water applied in
the field experiments, which was 40.5 cm. The interval among irrigation dates estimated by the model
do not quite match with experiment data set, mainly because the irrigation module of HYDRUS does
not allow using a variable value for the irrigation dose.
3.2 Soil water balance assessment
The soil water balance can be expressed by Eq 11.
𝑃 + 𝐼 = 𝛥𝑆 + 𝐸 + 𝑇 + 𝐷
(11)
where P is precipitation (cm); I is irrigation (cm); ΔS is the soil water change; E is evaporation (cm);
T is transpiration (cm); D is deep percolation (cm) that recharges groundwater. Water balance
parameters estimated by the model are shown in Figure 4 for each month and summarized in Table 4
646
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
for the simulation period. Crop evapotranspiration (E+T) is estimated to 67.2% of the total water
inflow (P+I). The evapotranspiration is considerably higher than precipitation during the crop
growing period, except for April, and thus sufficient irrigation water should be applied to fulfil the
crop water requirements.
Figure 2: Soil moisture in soil column estimated by the model and field experiments
12
Irrigation Dose (cm)
10
8
6
4
2
0
Simulated Irrigation (cm)
Field Irrigation (cm)
Figure 3: Irrigation doses applied in field experiments and simulated by the model
Table 4: Water balance parameters for the simulation period
P (cm)
I (cm)
ΔS (cm)
ET (cm)
14.66
40.8
-6.88
37.25
647
Parmeter of Water Balance (cm)
Ground water resources management
20
16
12
8
4
0
April
Irrigation
May
June
Precipitation
July
August
Evapotranspiration
Figure 4: Monthly water balance parameters estimated by the model
4.
CONCLUSIONS
Irrigated agriculture consumes a significant amount of available water resources in the summer period
- when water availability is decreased in Greece - and thus irrigation water management is necessary
both for the protection of environment and for the maintenance of agricultural income. This paper
evaluates the irrigation activities applied in an experimental field located at an irrigation network of
the River Strymonas basin. For that, the HYDRUS model was used to simulate the flow in the
unsaturated soil zone of a maize field and to estimate the irrigation dose, the irrigation interval and
the variation of soil moisture for the cultivation period. HYDRUS model was proved capable to
simulate the soil water movement in the experimental field by providing useful information related
to water balance parameters and assisting to irrigation water management in the area. Further
development of this work will focus on modelling single irrigation events to find more efficient
solutions for various soil types and crops in the area as well as the involvement of inverse modelling
towards an efficient calibration of the model based on the soil moisture measured in situ at several
depths as well as the average moisture in the soil profile.
References
1. Allen R., Pereira L.S., Raes D. and M. Smith. (1998). ‘Crop evapotranspiration: guidelines for
computing crop water requirements’. FAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper 56. Food and
Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.
2. Antonopoulos V. Z. (2000). ‘Modelling of soil water dynamics in an irrigated corn field using
direct and pedotransfer functions for hydraulic properties’. Irrigation and Drainage Systems,
14, pp. 325–342.
3. Arampatzis G., Hatzigiannakis E., Evangelides C. and A. Panagopoulos. (2014). ‘A handy
irrigation management method through meteorological data. Case study in N. Greece’. Global
NEST Journal, 16(2), pp. 219-228.
4. Arampatzis G., Hatzigiannakis E., Panoras A., Panagopoulos A., Evangelides C. and S. Stathaki.
(2010). Irrigation water management though meteorological data. Case study in Nigrita area.
International Conference on Protection and Restoration of the Environment X, Corfu,
Greece.
5. Babajimopoulos C., Budina A. and D. Kalfountzos. (1995). ‘SWBACROS: A model for the
estimation of the water balance of a cropped soil’. Environmental Software, 10(3), pp. 211–220.
648
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
6. Babajimopoulos C., Panoras A., Georgoussis H., Arampatzis G., Hatzigiannakis E. and D.
Papamichail. (2007). ‘Contribution to irrigation from shallow water table under field conditions’.
Agricultural Water Management, 92(3), pp. 205–210.
7. Chang X., Zhao W., and F. Zeng. (2015). ‘Crop evapotranspiration-based irrigation management
during the growing season in the arid region of northwestern China’. Environmental Monitor
Assess, 187(11), pp. 1–15.
8. Childs S.W. (1975). ‘Model of soil salinity effects on crop growth’. Soil Science Society
America of Journal, 39(4), pp. 617–622.
9. Feddes R.A., Kowalik P. and H. Zaradny. (1976). ‘Simulation of field water uptake by plants
using a soil water dependent root extraction function’. Journal of Hydrology, 31(1), pp. 13–26.
10. Hanson B., Hopmans J.W. and J. Šimůnek. (2008). ‘Leaching with subsurface drip irrigation
under saline, shallow groundwater conditions’. Vadose Zone Journal, 7(2), pp. 810–818.
11. Hoffman, G.J. and M.Th. van Genuchten. (1983). ‘Soil properties and efficient water use: water
management for salinity control’. In: H.M. Taylor, W.R. Jordan and T.R. Sinclair (Editors),
Limitations to Efficient Water Use in Crop Production. American Society of Agronomy,
Madison, Wisconsin, pp. 393-417.
12. Jellali S., Diamantopoulos E., Kallali H., Bennaceur S., Anane M. and N. Jedidi. (2010).
‘Dynamic sorption of ammonium by sandy soil in fixed bed columns: Evaluation of equilibrium
and non-equilibrium transport processes’. Journal of Environmental Management, 91(4), pp.
897–905.
13. LRI. (2009). ‘Irrigation of crops with the use of meteorological stations at Strymonas basin, Land
Reclamation Institute’. National Agricultural Research Foundation, Sindos, Greece.
14. Mualem Y. (1976). ‘A new model for predicting the hydraulic conductivity of unsaturated porous
media’. Water Resources Research, 12(3), pp. 513–522.
15. Ramos T.B, Simunek J., Goncalves M.C., Martins J.C., Prazeres A., Castanheira N.L., and L.S.
Pereira. (2011). ‘Field evaluation of a multi- component solute transport model in soils irrigated
with saline waters’, Journal of Hydrology, 407(1–4), pp. 129–144.
16. Ritchie J.T. (1972). ‘Model for predicting evaporation from a row crop with incomplete cover’,
Water Resources Research, 8(5), pp. 1204–1213.
17. Šimůnek J., Sejna M., Saito H., Sakai M. and M.T.H. van Genuchten. (2008a). The HYDRUS1D software package for simulating the one dimensional movement of water, heat, and multiple
solutes in variably-saturated media version 4.0. Department of Environmental Sciences,
University of California Riverside, California.
18. Šimůnek J., van Genuchten MTH and M. Sejna. (2008b). ‘Development and applications of the
HYDRUS and STANMOD software packages and related codes’. Vadose Zone Journal, 7(9),
pp. 587–600.
19. Šimůnek, J., and D. L. Suarez. (1993a). ‘Modeling of carbon dioxide transport and production in
soil: 1. Model development’. Water Resources. Research, 29(2), pp. 487-497.
20. Sutanto S. J., Wenninger J., Coenders-Gerrits A. M. J. and S. Uhlenbrook. (2012). ‘Partitioning
of evaporation into transpiration, soil evaporation and interception: a comparison between isotope
measurements and a HYDRUS-1D model’. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 16, pp.
2605-2616.
21. Tafteh A. and A. R. Sepaskhah. (2012). ‘Application of HYDRUS-1D model for simulating water
and nitrate leaching from continuous and alternate furrow irrigated rapeseed and maize fields’,
Agricultural Water Management, 113, pp. 19-29.
22. van Genuchten MTH. (1980). ‘A closed-form equation for predicting the hydraulic conductivity
of unsaturated soils’. Soil Science Society America of Journal, 44(44), pp. 892–898.
23. Verrecken M., Huisman J. A., Hendricks Franssen H. J., Bruggemann N., Bogena H. R., Kollet
S., Javaux M., van der Kruk J. and J. Vanderborght. (2015). ‘Soil hydrology: Recent
methodological advances, challenges, and perspectives’, Water Resources Research, 51, pp.
2616-2633.
649
Ground water resources management
24. Zheng, C., Lu, Y., Guo, X., Li, H., Sai, J., & Liu, X. (2017). ‘Application of HYDRUS-1D model
for research on irrigation infiltration characteristics in arid oasis of northwest China’.
Environmental Earth Sciences, 76(23), pp. 785.
650
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
651
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
652
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
LAND-USE CHANGE ROLE IN CLIMATE CHANGE
MITIGATION GOALS ACHIEVEMENT
V. Jurevičienė*1,2 and R. Dagiliūtė1
1
Vytautas Magnus University, Faculty of Natural Sciences, Dept. of Environmental Sciences, LT 44404 Kaunas, Lithuania
2
State Forest Service, Dept. of National Forest Inventory, LT – 51327, Kaunas, Lithuania
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: vkazanaviciute@gmail.com, tel : +37062761662
Abstract
Land use, land-use change and forestry (LULUCF) sector plays an important role in climate change
mitigation and is a key element in Paris agreement. Long-term goal of carbon neutral economy in
second half of this century depends on LULUCF ability to sequestrate greenhouse gases (GHGs)
emissions in biomass and soil. With reference to the Paris Agreement, accounting rules of GHG
emissions and removals in LULUCF sector has been heavily discussed recently in the European
Union, seeking of trustworthy inclusion in the assessment of Union’s GHG emission reduction target.
Therefore, paper aims to analyze Lithuanian situation regarding LULUCF sector and total GHG
balance from the climate change perspective. For this, changes in greenhouse gas emissions and
removals in Lithuania have been studied during years 1990 - 2015. Lithuania’s total GHG emission
balance has changed significantly since 1990, with more than twice decreased emissions till 2015.
LULUCF sector absorption was increasing since 1990 and was equal around 1/3 of total country
emissions in 2015, removals were mainly composed of carbon sequestration in forest land. However,
mainly the basic level of estimations (Tier1 methodological level) is applied currently for GHG
absorption and emissions potential. Therefore, more exact emission factors and other possible
determinants (biomass demand for energy purposes, energy efficiency, economic growth) of
LULUFC potential should be analyzed in more detail in order to make corresponding and sound
political decisions.
Keywords: Land-use change; GHG inventory; sequestration; emissions; removals; climate change
mitigation; policy achievement
1.
INTRODUCTION
Land use, land-use change and forestry (LULUCF) sector is an important contributor in climate
change mitigation and greenhouse gas emission reduction, related to atmospheric GHG removals,
regarding its ability to sequestrate carbon in biomass and soil (Garcia-Oliva, Masera, 2004), as well
as substitution of biological products for fossil fuels or energy-intensive products (Smith et al., 2014;
Sanchez, 2015). However, due to its high uncertainties, sector’s contribution to the targets’
achievement were under strong debates since the start of Kyoto Protocol commitments (1st KP
Commitment period started in 2008) (Macintosh, 2011; Grassi, 2012). Sector’s contribution depends
on the accounting rules and is previously estimated to vary from 2 % of total EU GHG emissions in
1990 to 33 % of New Zealand’s 1990 emission level (Grassi, 2012). Regarding more detailed
understanding, forest carbon accounting for mitigation purposes is dependent on the definition of the
reference baseline (McKechnie et al., 2014), since the reference level has to be applied. Study in
Europe shows that forest harvesting for bioenergy use led to a slight decrease in the soil carbon
equilibrium but significantly increased the mitigation effect through bioenergy use (Perez-Cruzado
653
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
et al., 2012). Due to the specific nature of the sector and high uncertainties as well as significant
importance to cover other sectors’ GHGs emissions, LULUCF accounting rules have been updated
in 2011 before the second Kyoto Protocol Commitment period (UNFCCC, 2012). Kyoto Protocol
has established the possibility to account credits from GHG sequestration in forestry and agricultural
activities (Garcia-Oliva, Masera, 2004). Credits from afforestation and reforestation activities were
proposed under the Clean Development Mechanism to cover part of the GHG emission reduction
target under Kyoto Protocol commitment (UNFCCC, 2013). Furthermore, one of the latest policy
changes in EU intends to include LULUCF sector into overall GHG emission reduction target after
2020 (post Kyoto). EU is taking a significant step forward to implement Paris agreement goals with
the proposal of Effort Sharing Regulation (European Commission, 2016a) and the so called LULUCF
regulation (European Commission, 2016b). Proposal of LULUCF regulation provides guidelines to
include GHG emissions/removals from LULUCF sector and maintains similar rule as in Kyoto
Protocol requirements: emissions from the sectors accounting categories should be covered with
respective removals (European Commission, 2016b). Climate scientists state (Bötther, Graichen,
2015), that LULUCF inclusion into overall target would mean lower efforts from other sectors: after
the removals from LULUCF are accounted (sequestration effect assessed), 40 % emission reduction
target would actually mean only 35 %. In addition, other scientists claim that turnover to renewal
energy sources and exceptionally biomass would also affect LULUCF climate change mitigation
potential (Frank et al., 2016). Hence, these factors might be of importance to include for estimation
of LULUCF potential in climate change mitigation target achievement altogether with land-use
change induced carbon sequestration in pools.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Methods used in this study consists of policy and GHG accounting changes analysis, total and sectoral
(LULUCF) GHG emissions and removals analysis in 1990 - 2015 in the line with LULUCF role in
climate change mitigation goals achievement.
Lithuanian GHG emissions and removals in land use, land-use change and forestry sector for 1990 2015 were estimated using 2006 IPCC Guidelines (IPCC, 20060 with several national carbon stock
factors and default emission factors values. Activity data for LULUCF GHG estimation was obtained
from various databases and data sources. Most of the data is obtained from National forest inventory
measurements, which contains area estimates of different land uses and changes between land uses
and growing stock volume change. Additional activity data of areas is collected from State Forest
Cadastre (aerial data of forest land and newly afforested/reforested areas), data from National Paying
agency (declared agricultural land areas), Geological Survey of Lithuania (areas of peat extraction
lands), Statistics of Lithuania, etc. GHG emissions and removals were estimated for 5 main pools:
biomass, dead wood and litter (forest land category), mineral and organic soils. In addition to the
carbon stock changes in abovementioned pools, greenhouse gas emissions from biomass burnt in
wildfires (forest land, cropland and grassland categories), emissions due to the drainage of organic
soils and nitrogen oxide emissions due to the carbon loss in mineral soils were estimated for the
whole-time series. Emissions and removals from other sectors were obtained from submitted for
United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change Secretariat on 14th April 2017
(Lithuania’s National Inventory Report, 2017).
Statistical analysis was performed in order to estimate the most important categories under land use,
land-use change and forestry sector and sector’s impact to the overall country GHG emissions.
3.
CLIMATE CHANGE AND LULUCF RELATED POLICY
Accounting rules of LULUCF has been at least slightly changed for each of the commitment period.
Accounting in the terms of anthropogenic GHG emissions and removals means calculation of annual
(or at the end of commitment period) GHG emissions and removals under certain conditions, for
654
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
instance, for Kyoto Protocol LULUCF categories it is either net-net accounting, gross-net accounting
or business as usual (BAU) accounting. Net-net accounting means total GHG emissions/removals in
reporting year minus the value of the reference year/period, meaning that for the accounting reported
GHG emissions or removals shall be compared to the reference year/period GHG emissions or
removals to evaluate the change (country’s accomplishment). On the contrary, gross-net accounting
is the total GHG emissions or removals change in the accounting period without comparison to the
reference year/period value. BAU accounting is the most controversial and arguable way to account
GHG emissions and removals in the accounting category (Macintosh, 2011; CAN Europe, 2016) –
reported GHG emissions/removals are compared to the projected GHG emissions or removals in that
category for that certain year or period (European Commission, 2016). Despite the changes in
accounting rules between commitment periods, core “no debit” rule remains. “No debit” rule has been
applied in the 2nd KP CP (UNFCCC, 2012) and maintained for post-Kyoto EU legislation in order to
provide reliable and comparable country’s GHG emissions/reductions data (European Commission,
2016), meaning that sector’s emissions from sources shall not exceed corresponding sector’s
removals by sinks.
The commitment under the Kyoto Protocol, contained in Article 3, paragraph 1, requires each Annex
I Party (Annex I parties - developed countries with targets to reduce emissions) to ensure that its total
emissions over the commitment period do not exceed its allowable level of emissions, the so called
Party’s assigned amount (UNFCCC, 2008). LULUCF sector was not included in the GHG emission
reduction target, however, the requirements for KP LULUCF sector was established. Under the rules
set in the decisions of Conference of the Parties of the UNFCCC (15/CMP.1, 17/CMP.1, 2005)
mandatory reporting of Kyoto Protocol Article 3.3 activities (afforestation/reforestation and
deforestation, A/R/D) and optional reporting on article 3.4 activities (forest management (FM);
grazing land management (GM); cropland management (CM)) was established, with the aim to use
removal units (RMU’s) for balancing assigned emission amount. Kyoto Protocol LULUCF
accounting categories slightly differ from UNFCCC LULUCF reporting categories, due to its activity
based nature, while LULUCF categories are land-based.
For the second commitment period under Kyoto Protocol reporting, accounting rules for KP
LULUCF sector were slightly updated (6/CMP.9, 2013) to apply “no debit” rule and business as usual
accounting for forest management category which became mandatory, however, only up to 3.5 % of
total country’s base year emissions could be used from accounted FM credits to RMU’s – FM credits
were „cap’ed“. Forest management reference level is based on projection of GHG emission/reduction
changes in 2013 – 2020 using the historical (1990 – 2009) data on forest resource use, management
practice and most recent forest age class distribution as well as growing stock volume increment
values. The EU’s current 2020 greenhouse gas reduction target of -20% below 2005 emissions level
does not include GHG emissions nor removals from LULUCF sector, due to the heated debate on
how removals from LULUCF sector should be treated to transparently indicate its contribution to the
overall target. At the same time, KP LULUCF sector is included in the EU Kyoto Protocol’s targets
(UN, 2012). After the long discussions between climate scientists, NGO’s, politicians and other
stakeholders, starting in 2014 (European Council, 2014), accounting rules to include LULUCF sector
into EU’s target achievement were agreed in negotiations between European Parliament and
Commission in the end of 2017. Proposal for Regulation of LULUCF inclusion in EU target
achievement (European Commission, 2016) sets rules of accounting of GHG emissions and removals
from LULUCF categories until 2030. Changes from 2nd Kyoto Protocol commitment period cover
changes from activity-based (KP LULUCF) to land-based (LULUCF) accounting, keeping the “no
debit” rule for the accounted categories and “cap” for the forest management (forest land remaining
forest land) category as in 2nd Kyoto Protocol commitment period. Adoption of the LULUCF
regulation altogether with Effort Sharing regulation will provide EU member states both the
possibility to cover GHG emissions from sectors with least mitigation potential with LULUCF credits
and sets the requirement to keep LULUCF carbon stock in balance, compared to the historical level.
655
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
4.
GHG EMISSIONS AND REMOVALS IN LITHUANIA
4.1 Land-use changes and LULUCF GHG removals
Land use matrix has significantly changed since 1990 after the collapse of Soviet Union, which
resulted in abandonement of large agricultural areas (decreased cropland resulted in increasing
grassland areas). Land-use change pattern has turned over after 2005, when application of Common
Agricultural Policy measures started in Lithuania (Ministry of Agriculture, 2017). Forest land area
is constantly increasing in Lithuania, both due to the human induced afforestattion/reforestation and
natural forest expansion and has increased more than 3.5% since 1990 (State Forest Service, 2016).
Currently forests in Lithuania cover 33.5% of total country area (State Forest Service, 2016) with
agricultural land (cropland and grassland) covering another 50 % of total country area.
LULUCF sector has been a net sink of greenhouse gas emissions in Lithuania almost for the whole
reporting period (1990 – 2015), except for the 1996 and 1997 when LULUCF was a net source of
emissions (Figure 1). Emissions in 1996 and 1997 were the result of repetitive droughts and
consequent pests (Ips Typographus) invasion which caused huge damages and death of spruce stands
in Lithuania (Vasiliauskas, 2015). Greenhouse gas removals in LULUCF sector varies significantly
during the inventory time period, depending presumably on climate related factors, economic
situation, affecting land-use changes and biomass use for wood products. Three most important
subcategories in LULUCF sector are forest land, cropland and grassland, covering most of the country
territory – approx. 90 % of the total country area, with the increasing share of forest land subcategory
harvested wood products (Figure 1). While forest land acts as a net carbon sink, sequestrating carbon
in biomass, cropland has been acting as a net source of emissions due to intensive use of soils (mineral
and organic). It should be noted, that changes in cropland and grassland GHG emission and removals
depend directly on changes between those two categories – reduction of GHG emissions in cropland
during 1990 – 2005 resulted from changes of cropland to grassland enhancing carbon sequestration
in mineral soils.
Removals/emissions, kt CO2 eqv.
8000.0
6000.0
4000.0
2000.0
0.0
-2000.0
-4000.0
-6000.0
-8000.0
-10000.0
-12000.0
Forest land
Croplands
Grasslands
Wetlands
Settlements
Other land
HWP
Figure 1. Total GHG emissions/removals in Lithuania during 1990 – 2015, kt CO2 eqv.
Data from Lithuania’s National Inventory Report, 2017
4.2 Total Lithuania’s GHG emissions and target achievement
Tendencies of greenhouse gas emissions and removals in all economic sectors of Lithuania and ratio
between total GHG emissions and removals in LULUCF sector are presented in this part of the study.
Figure 2 shows total Lithuania’s GHG emissions trend during 1990 – 2015 and LULUCF potential
to sequestrate GHG emissions in biomass and soil if no accounting rules are applied (total reported
656
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
country removals) and if 2nd Kyoto Protocol Commitment period accounting rules are applied (KP
LULUCF accounted removals).
Mt CO2 eqv.
40
KP LULUCF accounted removals
Total country emissions
Total reported country removals
Gross domestic product
30
40000
35000
30000
Milion euro
50
25000
20
20000
15000
10
10000
0
5000
-10
0
Figure 2. GHG removals by LULUCF sector in Lithuania during 1990 – 2015, kt CO2 eqv.
Gross domestic product at market prices values - chain linked volumes (2010), million euro
Data from Lithuania’s National Inventory Report, 2017
GHG emissions were significantly decreasing in Lithuania since 1990 and have reached half as its
value in 2015 comparing to 1990. Lithuania has overachieved its target for 1st Kyoto Protocol
commitment period – GHG emissions in 2012 were reduced more than 50% instead of required 8%.
Increase in GHG emissions in overall Lithuanian GHG balance was observed during the economic
upturn period until 2008, as it can be seen from Figure 2. LULUCF sector, due to its nature, is less
dependent on economic situation, whereas its emissions and removals vary according to the natural
conditions – removals in LULUCF sector drastically decreased in 1996 and 1997 due to the
abovementioned adverse natural conditions (Figure 1, Figure 2). Total land use-related sector in
Lithuania could absorb nearly 40% of net country’s emissions in some years (without application of
specific accounting rules), therefore LULUCF contribution to achieve Paris agreement commitment
is of the most importance (Figure 2).
However, the picture of accounted GHG removals in Lithuania is significantly different if Kyoto
Protocol 2nd commitment period accounting rules are applied. GHG removals would decrease more
than half if estimated forest management reference level is applied (estimated in 2011, recalculated
in 2013 and 2015, included under EU decision 529/2013/EU), comparing to the bare LULUCF
removals. Forest management reference level for Lithuania is -5474 kt CO2 eqv., taking into account
technical recalculations which took place in 2013 and 2015. Accounted GHG removals from
LULUCF sector under 2nd Kyoto Protocol commitment period could cover from 17 % (in 2013) to
14 % (in 2015) of total other sectors’ emissions. LULUCF role in climate change mitigation target
achievement increases with increasing emissions from other sectors, especially after 2020, when
Lithuania’s national target for non-ETS sectors (not taking part in EU emission trading system) is set
to be –9%, comparing to 2005, which could be difficult to implement with economic growth.
5.
DISCUSSION AND FUTURE OUTLOOK
As mentioned before, LULUCF sector is very complex and its total GHGs removals may depend not
only on human-induced actions, but also natural circumstances, such as extreme climate events.
However, despite its complexity and high uncertainty, sector’s potential to participate in climate
change mitigation is undeniable through its direct carbon sequestration and substitution effects
(Nabuurs et al., 2017).
657
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
Changes in LULUCF sector’s weight in total Lithuania’s emissions and removals balance is related
to both decreased emissions from other sectors - energy, industrial processes and product use,
agriculture, waste and increased GHGs removals in LULUCF sector. There is a strong connection
between LULUCF and agriculture sectors - with increasing cropland areas (since 2005) emissions
from agriculture sector also increased and now plays an important role (nearly ¼ of total country’s
emissions in 2015) in the overall GHG emission balance in Lithuania, therefore complex measures to
decrease GHGs emissions and enhance carbon sequestration in land-use related sectors are needed.
Taking into account policy changes, enhanced carbon sequestration in LULUCF sector is of utmost
importance, due to the need of keeping the “no debit” rule and possibility to cover part of other
sectors’ emissions with LULUCF credits. It should be highlighted, that forestry sector shall maintain
good balance of carbon sequestration, sufficient wood supply for industry and biomass supply for
energy purpose, keeping in mind EU’s 27% renewable energy target until 2030 (COM, 2014).
Lithuania has already exceeded EU renewable energy source (RES) target in 2016, reaching more
than 25% of RES in total energy consumption (Ministry of Energy, 2017). In addition to the RES
target, adopted climate change mitigation strategies (2030 climate and energy framework) in EU
(COM, 2014) work proactive in enhancing the role of harvested wood products, as it may have a
significant impact to climate change mitigation not only due to the sequestrated carbon locked in
long-term wood based products (furniture, buildings, etc), but also due to the reduced use of less
climate friendly materials (substitution effect) (Bottcher, Graichen, 2015). Harvested wood products
pool should be considered for further incentivising in Lithuania also due to the significant role in
Lithuanian economy, covering 4.7% of country’s gross domestic product (State Forest Service,
2016). Energy efficiency target is also strongly related to renewable energy target and harvested wood
products promotion; therefore, energy efficiency trends should be of importance in further LULUCF
climate change mitigation potential evaluation.
LULUFC sector plays an important role in climate change mitigations policy. Depending on the
accounting rules and applied emissions factors, national achievements might significantly differ.
Therefore, more detail analysis including accurate emissions factors and other determinants of net
emissions from this sector are needed.
References
1. Grassi, G., Elzen, M. G. J., Hof, A. F., Pilli, R., Federici, S. (2012). ‘The role of the land use,
land-use change and forestry sector in achieving Annex I reduction pledges’, Journal of Climatic
change, 115(3–4), pp 873-881. doi: 10.1007/s10584-012-0584-4
2. Macintosh, A. K. (2011). ‘Are forest management reference levels incompatible with robust
climate outcomes? A case study on Australia’, Journal of Carbon Management, 2(6), pp. 691707
3. UNFCCC (2012). Decision 2/CMP.7 Land use, land-use change and forestry. URL:
http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2011/cmp7/eng/10a01.pdf#page=11 (accessed September 6th,
2017)
4. Garcia-Oliva, F., Masera, O. R. (2004). ‘Assessment and Measurement Issues related to Soil
Carbon Sequestration in Land-Use, Land-Use Change and Forestry (LULUCF) Projects under the
Kyoto Protocol’, Journal of Climatic Change, 65(3), pp. 347-364
5. Smith, P., Clark, H., Dong, H., Elsiddig, E. A., Haberl, H., Harper, R., House, J., Jafari, M. et al.
(2014). Chapter 11 - Agriculture, forestry and other land use (AFOLU). In: Climate Change
2014: Mitigation of Climate Change. IPCC Working Group III Contribution to AR5. Cambridge
University Press
6. Sanchez, O. C. (2015). ‘The climate effect of increased forest bioenergy use in Sweden:
evaluation at different spatial and temporal scales’. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Journal of
Energy and Environment, 5(2015), pp. 351-369
658
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
7. McKechnie, J., Colombo, S., MacLean, H. L. (2014). ‘Forest carbon accounting methods and the
consequences of forest bioenergy for national greenhouse gas emissions inventories. Journal of
Environmental Science and Policy, 44, pp. 164-173
8. Perez-Cruzado, C., Mohren, G. M. J., Merino, A., Rodriguez-Soalleiro, R. (2012). ‘Carbon
balance for different management practices for fast growing tree species planted on former
pastureland in southern Europe: a case study using the CO2Fix model’, European Journal of
Forest Research, 131(6), pp. 1695–1716
9. UNFCCC (2013). Afforestation and Reforestation Projects under the Clean Development
Mechanism: A Reference Manual. URL:
10. http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/publications/cdm_afforestation_bro_web.pdf,
March, 2018)
(accessed
20th
11. European Commission (2016a). Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the
Council on binding annual greenhouse gas emission reductions by Member States from 2021 to
2030 for a resilient Energy Union and to meet commitments under the Paris Agreement and
amending Regulation No 525/2013 of the European Parliament and the Council on a mechanism
for monitoring and reporting greenhouse gas emissions and other information relevant to climate
change. COM (2016) 482 final, Brussels.
12. European Commission (2016b). Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the
Council on the inclusion of greenhouse gas emissions and removals from land-use, land-use
change and forestry into the 2030 climate and energy framework and amending Regulation No
525/2013 of the European Parliament and the Council on a mechanism for monitoring and
reporting greenhouse gas emissions and other information relevant to climate change. COM
(2016) 479 final, Brussels.
13. Bottcher, H., Graichen, J. (2015). ‘Impact on the EU 200 climate target of including LULUCF in
the climate and energy policy framework. Report.’
Ӧko-Institut e.V.
URL:
http://www.fern.org/sites/fern.org/files/Impact%20of%20including%20LULUCF%20in%20203
0_Final_corr.pdf
14. Frank, S., Bottcher, H., Gusti, M., Havlik, P., Klaasen, G., Kindermann, G., Obersteiner, M.
(2016). ‘Dynamics of the land use, land-use change and forestry sink in the European Union: the
impacts of energy and climate targets for 2030’, Journal of Climatic change, 138, pp. 253-266.
15. State Forest Service (2016). ‘Lithuanian Statistical Yearbook of Forestry’. URL:
http://www.amvmt.lt/index.php/leidiniai/misku-ukio-statistika/2016, (accessed 15th January,
2018)
16. IPCC (2006). 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories, Prepared by the
National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Programme, Eggleston H.S., Buendia L., Miwa K., Ngara
T. and Tanabe K. (eds). Published: IGES, Japan
17. Lithuania’s National Inventory Report (2017). Lithuania’s GHG inventory submission under
UNFCCC, Kyoto Protocol and Regulation No 525/2013of the European Parliament and of the
Council
of 21 May 2013 repealing Decision No 280/2004/EC.
URL:
http://unfccc.int/national_reports/annex_i_ghg_inventories/national_inventories_submissions/ite
ms/10116.php, (accessed 16th October, 2017)
18. UNFCCC (2008). ‘Kyoto Protocol Reference Manual on Accounting of Emissions and Assigned
Amount’. URL: https://unfccc.int/resource/docs/publications/08_unfccc_kp_ref_manual.pdf,
(accessed 1st October, 2017)
19. UN (2012). Doha Amendment to the Kyoto Protocol. C.N.718.2012.TREATIES-XXVII.7.c
(Depositary Notification). Adoption of the Amendment to the Protocol
659
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
20. European Council (2014). European Council (23/24 October 2014) conclusions. EUCO 169/14.
URL:
http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_data/docs/pressdata/en/ec/145397.pdf,
(accessed 17th November, 2017)
21. COM (2014). Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the
European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions. A policy
framework for climate and energy in the period from 2020 to 2030, /* COM/2014/015 final
*/., Brussels.
22. CAN Europe: Climate Action Network (2016). NGO position on the post-2020 LULUCF
Regulation.
URL:
http://www.fern.org/sites/fern.org/files/CAN%20Europe-LULUCFPosition_final.pdf, (accessed 15th December, 2017)
23. Ministry of Agriculture of the Republic of Lithuania (2017). Bendrosios žemės ūkio politikos
įgyvendinimas Europoje bei Lietuvoje: tiesioginės išmokos. URL: https://www.zur.lt/wpcontent/uploads/2017/09/BZUP-igyvendinimasES-LT1.pdf (accessed 24th January, 2018)
24. Vasiliauskas, V. (2015). Žievėgraužis tipografas pasiruošęs pulti eglynus, Journal Mūsų girios,
4, pp. 14-16. URL:
25. http://www.amvmt.lt/Images/Veikla/MSAT/Publikacijos/2015.04.%20%C5%BDiev%C4%97gr
au%C5%BEis%20tipografas%20pasiruo%C5%A1%C4%99s%20pulti%20eglynus.%20V.Vasil
iauskas%20(pdf).pdf (accessed 21st November, 2017)
26. Nabuurs, G. J., Delacote, Ph., Elison, D., Hanewinkel, M., Hetemaki, L., Lindner, M. (2017). ‘By
2050 the Mitigation Effects of EU Forests Could Nearly Double through Climate Smart Forestry’.
Journal of Forests, 8(12), 484; doi:10.3390/f8120484
27. Ministry of Energy of the Republic of Lithuania (2017). Renewable energy resources, statistics.
28. URL:https://enmin.lrv.lt/lt/veiklos-sritys-3/atsinaujinantys-energijos-istekliai/statistika,
(accessed 24th January, 2018)
660
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION STRATEGIES IN GREECE:
RECENT DEVELOPMENTS AND TRENDS
E.D. Thoidou2* and D.N. Foutakis2
1
School of Spatial Planning and Development Engineering, A.U.Th., GR- 54124 Thessaloniki,
Macedonia, Greece,
2
Civil Engineering and Surveying Engineering and Geoinformatics Department, Technological
Institute of Central Macedonia, Serres, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: thoidouel@plandevel.auth.gr , tel.: +302310995518
Abstract
In recent years, climate change policies have put special emphasis on climate adaptation strategies,
alongside climate mitigation strategies, in an effort to address the inevitable impacts of climate
change. Many European countries have proceeded with the elaboration of adaptation strategies at the
national, regional and local levels, while many cities have prepared their adaptation strategies or have
incorporated adaptation options into their spatial planning strategies. The sustainable development
principles as well as the risk management approach have largely determined the character of these
strategies. At the same time, of key importance are the spatial dimensions of climate adaptation
strategies, since climate change impacts are territory-specific and are mostly addressed at the local
and regional levels.
In Greece, climate change mitigation is included in the targets set by the country’s strategy for
sustainable development launched in 2002. Provision for the country’s National Adaptation Strategy
(NAS) was first made in line with its ΕU cohesion policy and climate policy commitments and has
been ratified in 2016. Subsequently, the specifications of the regional plans for climate adaptation
have been prepared by the competent ministry, in order to promote the elaboration of such plans.
This paper seeks to examine the above-mentioned developments in the field of climate change
adaptation in Greece. It examines the character of the NAS as well as the emerging characteristics of
the regional plans for climate adaptation, especially in relation to sustainable development principles
and the risk-management approach. Particular emphasis is placed on the spatial dimensions of the
plans which are considered critical for both the implementation of plans and their linking with spatial
planning at the local and regional levels.
Keywords: Regional adaptation strategies, Climate adaptation strategies in Greece, Spatial planning
1.
INTRODUCTION
Concern about climate change adaptation has accentuated in recent years, due to the fact that on the
one hand the impact of climate change is becoming all the more evident and on the other hand
prospects for climate change mitigation face significant constraints. Adaptation is defined as “The
process of adjustment to actual or expected climate and its effects. In human systems, adaptation
seeks to moderate or avoid harm or exploit beneficial opportunities. In some natural systems, human
intervention may facilitate adjustment to expected climate and its effects” [IPCC, 2014]. These
adjustments may have a behavioural, technological, regulatory, institutional, or financial character.
Moreover, they may be proactive or reactive, with the majority of them being reactive, at least in
Europe, where “implemented adaptation measures are more of reactive nature, that is to say they do
661
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
not anticipate climate change impacts, but rather react to those impacts once they manifest"
[Venturini, Medri and Castellari, 2012, p. 28]. Adaptation strategies can be developed by various
bodies that extend from the world community to individuals, and at various levels, from the global to
the household. Two types of adaptation strategies can be discerned, namely collective and individual,
with the latter being less efficient in addressing climate change impacts [Eikelboom and Janssen,
2013]. The inadequacies of individual reaction to climate change impacts raise the need for
reinforcing collective reactions from the global to the local level. Adaptation strategy “for a country,
region or municipality refers to a general plan of action for addressing the impacts of climate change,
including climate variability and extremes. It may include a mix of policies and measures, selected to
meet the overarching objective of reducing the country’s vulnerability” [EEA, 2016a]. The
characteristics of and challenges for climate adaptation strategies with respect to their spatial
structure, particularly in Greece, are outlined below.
2.
CLIMATE ADAPTATION STRATEGIES
Climate change, despite being a global phenomenon, has strong territorial dimensions which are
reflected in the spatial dimensions of climate policies. This is much more true of climate adaptation
policies due to the fact that they deal with climate change impacts that occur in certain territorial areas
and are mainly addressed by territorial authorities. Climate adaptation policies are implemented from
the local to the national and global level (Martins and Ferreira, 2011), with local areas facing the
greater challenges. According to Aakre and Rübbelke [2010, p. 161], adaptation “requires many
levels of decision-making (EU, national, regional, local)”.
At the EU level, following the White Paper on adaptation [CEC, 2009], the EU Strategy on
Adaptation to Climate Change was adopted in 2013 with the aim of enhancing “the preparedness and
capacity to respond to the impacts of climate change at local, regional, national and EU levels,
developing a coherent approach and improving coordination” [EC, 2013]. It is stated in the strategy
that, “in view of the specific and wide ranging nature of climate change impacts, […] adaptation
measures need to be taken at all levels, from local to regional and national levels” (ibid.). Some
preliminary findings of the assessment of this strategy indicate that “it delivered its individual
objectives, with progress recorded against each of the individual actions. At the same time “the need
for an intensification and extension of the scope of action” is stressed [EC, 2017b].
In general all levels of adaptation strategies have distinct, albeit interconnected roles which are the
first to reveal their spatial dimensions. Interconnections between the levels of adaptation strategies,
either predefined or ad-hoc ones, are also representative of the spatial dimensions. At the national
level climate adaptation commitments are made in relation to the supranational and transnational
context (UN and EU). It is then, at the national level, that the adoption of global targets, guidelines
and commitments is made, as it happens with climate mitigation. On the other hand, the local level is
considered to be “the most important level for implementing national and regional adaptation
strategies and related amendments to planning laws. This is due to local responsibilities for urban
development and building permissions, but also to the fact that the population, in general, has more
trust in local authorities” [Greiving and Fleischhauer, 2012, p. 37]. As for the regional level, it could
be considered crucial in linking national and local levels, while at the same time specific adaptation
strategies, which concern the relationship between urban and peri-urban space as well as between
natural and human ecosystems, can be applied at this level. More particularly, these are defined as
follows:
A National Adaptation Strategy (NAS) “is a long term vision or general plan of action for
addressing the impacts of climate change, including climate variability and extremes” [Swart et
al. cited in Termeer, Biesbroek, and Van den Brink, 2012].
A Regional Adaptation Strategy (RAS) is “the combination of possible measures that help
develop from a current state of a region to one that better manages, adjusts to or copes with climate
662
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
change. The development of an adaptation strategy is an iterative, continuous learning process”
[Eikelboom and Janssen, 2013, p. 2].
A Local Adaptation Strategy (LAS) concerns local areas, usually cities or local territories with
specific geomorphological characteristics (coastal, mountain etc.). Despite the fact that they are
highly dependent on national adaptation strategies, local adaptation strategies have a long
tradition that extends from the first Local Agenda 21 [Hamin and Gurran, 2011]. Several
initiatives have given rise to local adaptation strategies since then. This is the case of the ICLEI
(International Council for Local Environmental Initiatives) as well as of the Covenant of Mayors
Initiative.
The overall characteristics of adaptation strategies, namely their status, content and structure, their
interlinkages, as well as the way they address sustainability and promote their objectives, relate to
their spatial dimensions.
With regard to the way the sustainable development dimension appears in each one of the three
types/levels of adaptation strategies, a National Adaptation Strategy (NAS) should adopt the
sustainability principle among its key objectives, which in turn characterizes adaptation strategies at
all levels. Regional Adaptation Strategies (RAS) can be considered capable of addressing the
relationship between environmental values and climate change impacts, which means that issues
pertaining to territorial organization and environmental protection are given priority. Local
Adaptation Strategies (LAS) are suitable for the implementation of sustainable solutions in practice
such as green infrastructure.
Concerning the status of adaptation strategies, the question arises for all the three types/levels as to
whether or not they constitute single and integrated policy domains. In other words, the question is
whether they only set the overall context, e.g. in the form of a policy document [Hamin and Gurran,
2011] or whether they also have institutional and funding instruments at their disposal to promote
adaptation.
The types of adaptation options are crucial. Among the various categorizations of adaptation
responses the one suggested by the European Environment Agency (EEA) identifies three broad
categories: “technological solutions — grey measures; ecosystem-based adaptation options — green
measures; behavioural, managerial and policy approaches — soft measures”. It is noted that “Green
and soft measures specifically aim at decreasing the sensitivity and increasing the adaptive capacity
of human and natural systems, basically, building resilience” [EEA, 2010]. It is then through the
notion of resilience that a connection with sustainable development can be made.
A description of the structure of adaptation strategies can be found in the climate adapt platform of
the EU [EEA, 2016b] as well as in the guidelines document on Regional Adaptation Strategies (RAS)
conducted on behalf of the European Commission [Ribeiro et al., 2009]. This structure is closely
related with the method and steps for their preparation and implementation. The climate adapt
platform of the EU has prepared the climate adapt tool to assist various users in preparing their own
strategies and plans at all levels. It suggests the following six steps: “Preparing the ground for
adaptation; assessing the risks and vulnerabilities to climate change; identifying adaptation options;
assessing adaptation options; implementation; monitoring and evaluation” [EEA, 2016b]. In the same
direction the guidelines document on RAS identifies the following factors for a successful RAS:
“Meaningful and sustained stakeholder engagement” (participation of public authorities, citizens and
stakeholders); “Use and dissemination of appropriate information” (specification of information from
the national and transnational level as well as collection of information at the local level); “Awareness
Raising” (leaders make RAS widely known in close cooperation with stakeholders, aiming to increase
resilience); “Monitoring, Evaluation & Review” (on the basis of the objectives set); and “Successful
management of multilevel governance” (vertical coordination between the levels of governance and
horizontal coordination between sectoral interests) [Ribeiro et al., 2009, pp. 17-18].
663
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
When it comes to the implementation stage, the issue arises as to which means are available for
promoting climate adaptation strategy in practice. Both institutional and funding instruments should
be utilized, however, the way these are embedded within overall governance and funding structures
vary among countries. Three cases can be discerned:
Identifying climate adaptation (and mitigation) as a distinct policy domain, possibly within the
framework of a wider policy. In many countries climate adaptation strategies are translated to
adaptation programmes within the context of environmental policy. For instance, in the case of
England the legislative framework for climate change is being specified by particular programmes
and actions [Carina and Keskitalo, 2010, pp. 103-105].
Mainstreaming adaptation to various other policies of either a developmental or a regulatory
character such as regional policy and regional spatial planning [Thoidou, 2017]. For example in
Finland, which is a pioneer in developing a National Adaptation Strategy, “On the one hand, at
the national level, the NAS predominantly concentrates on administrative sectors by
mainstreaming adaptation. On the other hand, the lower levels of governance are pursuing their
separate climate strategies that are based on voluntary initiatives with little input from the national
level” [Juhola, 2010, p. 149].
Emphasizing disaster risk reduction as a means of immediate response to the need to confront
climate adaptation impacts. Following Greiving and Fleischhauer [2012, p. 37] “Issues which are
related to climate change adaptation are in many cases communicated through disaster
management, which is usually better established than spatial planning. Therefore, adaptation is at
least indirectly addressed in those countries that do not yet have an adaptation strategy, such as
Greece and Poland”.
As regards the relationship between sectoral and spatial approaches, in most cases the former have a
key role, as climate change has an indispensable impact on a variety of sectors. A great deal of work
is being undertaken all over the world in order to analyse and forecast impacts as well as to identify
solutions. Territorial specification of this work is then dependent on the specificities of each country’s
characteristics such as governance structure. At the same time the role of spatial planning in
addressing climate change impacts, particularly at the initial stages of adaptation planning, has been
accentuated [Greiving and Fleischhauer, 2012; Davoudi, Crawford and Mehmood, 2009]. Spatial
planning can serve as a policy framework which is capable of coordinating various policies and
actions on a territorial basis as well as planning future developments on a territorial basis [Thoidou,
2013]. On the other hand, adaptation reflects a climate-sensitive approach with a wider view to risk
prevention and management that is important for spatial planning per se.
3.
ADAPTATION STRATEGIES IN GREECE
Adaptation strategies in Greece are being developed at the national and the regional level. As in all
countries, the first official documents on climate change in Greece in the early 2000s were dedicated
to climate mitigation, in accordance with commitments made within the UN and the EU framework.
The successive National Communications to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change
(UNFCCC) are the most representative documents in this respect. Even though they refer to the
national level, they do include several references to particular territorial areas regarding climate
adaptation, which could be considered to be a way of responding to the need for an adaptation policy
with a spatial approach. It was only in 2016 that the study for NAS was ratified by law for a 10-year
period, under the competence of the Ministry of Environment and Energy, following commitments
made within the EU. The key objectives of NAS are the following (MEEN, 2016):
“(1) Systematizing and improving decision making process (short and long term) regarding
adaptation (2) Linking adaptation with the promotion of a sustainable development pattern through
regional/local action plans (3) Promoting adaptation policies and actions in all sectors of the Greek
economy with an emphasis on the most vulnerable (4) Creation of a mechanism for monitoring,
664
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
evaluation and updating of adaptation policies and actions (5) Strengthening adaptive capacity of the
Greek society through information and awareness raising actions”.
The preparation of Regional Adaptation Action Plans (RAAPs) started in 2017 in accordance with
provisions made by the above-mentioned law. Following the drafting of specifications by the
competent ministry, the Plans for the 13 NUTS II regions of the country are being launched by the
corresponding regional authorities. In RAAPs “the sectors and territorial areas of priority are
identified and measures and actions for them are proposed with the aim of: avoiding impacts, reducing
the intensity and extent of impacts, and restoration” [MEEN, 2017]. The evaluation of proposed
measures and actions should be made against these aims, while the key objectives of the Plans are
connected with those of NAS.
Both national and regional adaptation strategies refer to each other. In the NAS it is declared that due
to its strategic role the feasibility and prioritization of specific measures and actions either on a
sectoral or on a territorial basis is a task not for the NAS but rather for the 13 RAAPs, which should
take into account the specificities of each region. In the same way NAS is considered to be the guiding
framework for RAAPs [MEEN, 2017].
Local adaptation strategies are not in the official agenda. However a variety of adaptation options are
being implemented at the local level, such as the bioclimatic upgrade of open public spaces in cities
and the protection of biodiversity in protected areas. Many local authorities have undertaken action
in the context of the EU climate adapt networks such as the Covenant of Mayors Initiative.
The dimension of sustainability in NAS is declared in the form of “a sustainable development pattern”
that constitutes one of its key objectives. Sustainable development in RAAPs is not referred to as
such, but it is included in specific themes such as that for “Fauna – Flora and Protected areas”. It is
noted that adaptation objectives should be linked to other objectives which pertain to sustainability
such as green development and prudent use of water resources [MEEN, 2017].
Both NAS and RAAPs are in the form of a study. NAS was prepared by the Ministry in cooperation
with the Climate Change Impacts Study Committee of the Bank of Greece and was exceptionally
endorsed by law as a public strategy [EC, 2017a]. NAS is a strategic orientation document. Therefore,
a question arises as to whether it follows the strategic planning approach, according to which
emphasis should be placed on the process of setting the objectives and promoting implementation,
above all by enhancing participatory procedures. RAAPs follow a rather different course: studies are
commissioned by regional authorities and performed by experts, a process which is currently in
progress.
As far as their content is concerned, all the above-mentioned three categories of adaptation options
are included in the measures proposed by NAS. The emphasis placed on green infrastructure in the
context of the ecosystems approach is perhaps the most innovative among them. Provision is also
made for grey infrastructure and technological solutions. In RAAPs grey infrastructure has a key role,
with the emphasis on climate-proof solutions being one of the innovations introduced, probably in
accordance with NAS, while green infrastructure is less evident. Provision is also made for soft
measures in both strategies. As far as the structure of the strategies is concerned, the main pillars of
the NAS are the following: “Analysis of climate risk and vulnerability of the Greek territory;
adaptation measures in fifteen sectors; instruments for the evaluation of adaptive investments and
policies; instruments for mainstreaming of adaptation policy into wider policy domains; the
international dimension; the enhancement of adaptive capacity; consultation with stakeholders; and
monitoring and revision of adaptation policies” [ΜΕΕΝ, 2016, p. 93]. RAPPs consist of the following
steps: “Analysis of objectives; overview of natural and human environment; evaluation of expected
climatic changes and climate vulnerability of sectors and territorial areas; estimation of direct and
long term impact of climate change in various environmental and socioeconomic domains; proposed
measures for priority sectors and territorial areas; examination of mainstreaming of measures into
other policies; examination of the compatibility of RAAP with other regional plans, examination of
665
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
the compatibility of RAAP with those of neighbouring regions; way of consultation; way of raising
awareness; monitoring of implementation” [MEEN, 2017].
It is evident that both NAS and RAAPs follow the main steps suggested by the above-mentioned
adaptation tools. As regards the participatory process which has a key role in shaping an adaptation
strategy [Ribeiro et al., 2009], in the case of NAS it was confined to formal public consultation. This
could be related to the fact that NAS was drafted by organizations which, despite their high scientific
performance, do not have competencies in participatory governance. In the specifications’ document
for RAAPs, the role of participatory processes is stressed, at both preparation and implementation
stages. This is not unrelated to the fact that adaptation strategy at the regional level falls under the
competence of regional self-government which can enable participatory processes for drawing up the
strategy. Finally, a shortcoming could be argued to be the fact that the role of the local level in
adaptation planning is yet not so clear.
The characteristics of adaptation strategies are related to their institutional status. One question is
whether and to what extent these strategies have a binding character and, furthermore, whether they
constitute single policy domains with their own institutional and funding instruments. Some evidence
can be drawn from the way the implementation of adaptation options is pursued. The following ways
can be found in the chapter “Adaptation in practice” of the NAS document [MEEN, 2016, pp. 75,
85]:
Adaptation policies should be mainstreamed into wider policy domains (prevention of natural
disasters, policies for food, infrastructure, energy, transport, quality of life in cities, protection of
biodiversity, and so on). Linking adaptation with mitigation efforts especially in the energy sector
is also a way of promoting adaptation. Closely related with this is the introduction of the criterion
of “climate-resilient investment” in all stages of approving and funding of any investment. It is
argued that “In nowadays’ recession and budgetary constraints an autonomous policy of
adaptation investments could not be justified. ‘Climate resilient investments’ will be increasingly
mainstreamed into individual sectoral policies. This entails deep transformations in the decision
making on investments” [MEEN 2016, p. 74].
Risk prevention and management is also very important, due to its long tradition in the country.
The civil protection law (No 3013/2002) aims at “protecting life, health and properties against
natural […], technological […] and other disasters which cause emergency situations at times of
peace”. In recent years civil protection has been developed within the Hyogo framework (20052015) and the Sendai framework (2015-2030).
Other ways of promoting adaptation options include the transnational and transboundary
dimension of adaptation, improving adaptive capacity through research, education and raising
awareness, as well as consultation with stakeholders. In the same way, mainstreaming adaptation
action into other policies, above all in the policy for natural disaster management, as well as
establishing the criterion of “climate-resilient investment” are also foreseen with regard to the
implementation of the measures proposed by RAAPs [MEEN, 2017].
In the NAS, the sectoral dimension is of major importance while a clear spatial dimension is not
particularly evident. The action “land use regulation” is included in the section “Biodiversity and
Ecosystems” under the logic of land protection and ecosystem services. References to the spatial
planning context are made in relation to the need for mainstreaming adaptation into various polices
as well as the need to link adaptation and mitigation policies. Particular reference is made to coastal
zones and transnational - transboundary areas. The role of cities and consequently of urban planning
with an emphasis on green infrastructure is stressed in the section “Built environment”.
The spatial dimension is more evident in the RAAPs and particularly in the part relating to the
evaluation of expected climatic changes and the climate vulnerability of sectors and territorial areas.
Priorities and measures proposed by RAAPs are also specified on a territorial basis, along with the
sectoral one, while coastal zones are particularly emphasized. Specific provision is made for the role
666
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
of spatial plans at all levels, from regional to local. As noted in the evaluation document of the whole
adaptation policy of the country, “the RAAPs will propose ways to integrate adaptation into existing
strategies, policies and plans, including urban and spatial (land/sea) policies and plans”, while
projections and assessments about climate change impacts will be useful inputs for spatial planning
[EC, 2017a, p. 16].
At the same time, from the view point of spatial policies, an awareness of climate adaptation can be
observed, especially in the two parallel policy contexts that constitute regional policies in Greece,
namely regional spatial planning and regional development policy with the latter having a significant
influence in terms of funding [Thoidou, 2017]. However, as Cartalis et al. (2017) note, the
potentialities offered by development programmes have not been fully exploited due to the fact that
national spatial plans have not yet been updated to explicitly address the dimension of climate change
adaptation.
In the context of the ongoing evaluation of the EU's Strategy for Adaptation to Climate Change a
draft country fiche was prepared which assess the state of play within the country. As noted in this
document “Despite the significant progress made in the last two years, there are still significant needs
with regard to policy coordination, development and dissemination of good practice, and most
importantly in terms of capacity building” [EC, 2017a, p. 5].
4.
CONCLUSIONS
Having as its starting point recent developments in the field of climate change adaptation, this paper
shortly presented adaptation strategies in Greece with a view to their spatial characteristics. The
development of these strategies in the country is quite recent. National Adaptation Strategy was
ratified in 2016 and Regional Adaptation Strategies are at the preparation stage in the form of RAAPs.
A hierarchical structure with spatially differentiated roles of the two strategies can be observed. The
spatial dimensions of both strategies are rather limited, especially in NAS which has adopted a
sectoral approach. The local level seems to be a part of the regional level, without having a distinct
role in the making of adaptation strategies and the same can be said about urban adaptation strategies.
At the same time the role of spatial planning in promoting climate adaptation is widely acknowledged
by both strategies. Hierarchical structure is reflected in the formal way participatory processes are
applied, which does not strengthen adaptive capacity. This goes in tandem with shortcomings
regarding the status and the strategic character of both strategies. As far as sustainable development
is concerned, the provision made by NAS [MEEN, 2016] for “linking adaptation with the promotion
of sustainable development through regional/local action plans” remains general and it is expected to
be specified through RAAPs.
Innovative elements introduced by adaptation strategies have to do with their structure and the way
they translate objectives into practice. Especially noteworthy is the emphasis placed on green
infrastructure as well as the so-called climate resilient investments. Mainstreaming adaptation action
into various policies as a means of promoting adaptation is stressed perhaps for the first time. At the
same time, the risk management policy seems to keep its key role in dealing with climate change
impacts, which indicates a reactive approach.
Overall, climate adaptation strategies at various territorial levels in Greece are at an initial stage,
therefore there is not enough evidence to estimate their characteristics and performance. As concluded
for the European level [ESPON CLIMATE, 2010, p. 77], “it appears that policy developments are
evolving in an interactive fashion between the central and the regional government”. This entails a
twofold challenge: on the one hand the elaboration of adaptation strategies at all levels in an
interconnected way, and on the other hand the elaboration of these strategies in the context of a
territorial governance approach that goes beyond formal competences and promotes an open
participatory process at all levels, from national to local. Possible improvements of adaptation
strategies in Greece may include an active role for the local and especially the urban level, as well as
an accentuation of the role of spatial planning in climate adaptation action at all levels. Moreover,
667
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
citizen and stakeholder involvement in all types and levels of the adaptation process is crucial, in
order that the prevailing top-down approach can be complemented by a bottom-up one.
References
1. Aakre S. and D.T.G. Rübbelke (2010) ‘Adaptation to Climate Change in the European Union:
Efficiency versus Equity Considerations’, Environmental Policy and Governance, Vol. 20, pp.
159–179.
2. Carina E. and H. Keskitalo (2010) ‘Climate Change Adaptation in the United Kingdom:
England and South-East England’, Developing Adaptation Policy and Practice in Europe:
Multi-level Governance of Climate Change’, ed. H. Keskitalo, Springer: Sweden.
3. Cartalis C., Coccossis H., Economou D., Santamouris M., Agathagellidis H. and H. Polydoras
(2017) ‘The impact of climate change on development’, https://www.dianeosis.org/wpcontent/uploads/2017/06/climate_change10.pdf (accessed 1-2-2018) (in Greek).
4. Commission of the European Communities (CEC) (2009) ‘White Paper. Adapting to climate
change: Towards a European framework for action’, COM (2009) 147 final.
5. Davoudi S., Crawford J. and A. Mehmood (eds) (2009) ‘Planning for climate change: strategies
for mitigation and adaptation for spatial planners’, Routledge.
6. Eikelboom T. and R. Janssen (2013) ‘Interactive spatial tools for the design of regional
adaptation strategies’, Journal of Environmental Management, Vol. 127, pp. S6-S14.
7. ESPON CLIMATE (2010) ‘Climate Change and Territorial Effects on Regions and Local
Economies’ Applied Version 22/03/2010, Applied Research Project 2013/1/4Revised Interim
Report https://www.espon.eu/sites/default/files/attachments/Annex.pdf (accessed 1-2-2018).
8. European Commission (EC) (2013) ‘An EU Strategy on adaptation to climate change’,
Brussels
16.4.2013,
COM(2013)
216
final,
http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legalcontent/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:52013DC0216&from=EN (accessed 1-8-2015).
9. European Commission (EC) (2017a) ‘Adaptation preparedness scoreboard: Draft country
fiche for Greece’, https://ec.europa.eu/clima/consultations/evaluation-eus-strategy-adaptationclimate-change_el (accessed 28-2-2018)
10. European Commission (EC) (2017b) ‘Study to support the evaluation of the EU Adaptation
Strategy
(Summary)’,
https://ec.europa.eu/clima/sites/clima/files/consultations/docs/0035/summary_interim_findings_
en.pdf (accessed 10-5-2018).
11. European Environment Agency (EEA) (2010) ‘The European Environment State and Outlook
2010: Adapting to Climate Change’, Publications Office of the European Union: Luxembourg.
12. European
Environment
Agency
(EEA)
(2016a)
‘Glossary’,
https://climateadapt.eea.europa.eu/help/glossary/index_html/#linkAdaptationStrategy (accessed 10-5-2018).
13. European Environment Agency (EEA) (2016b) ‘European Climate Adaptation Platform’
[online], http://climate-adapt.eea.europa.eu/knowledge/tools/adaptation-support-tool (accessed
15-2-2018).
14. Greiving S. and M. Fleischhauer (2012) ‘National Climate Change Adaptation Strategies of
European States from a Spatial Planning and Development Perspective’, European Planning
Studies, Vol. 20(1), pp. 27-48.
15. Hamin, E.M. and N. Gurran (2011) ‘Local Actions, National Frameworks: A Dual-Scale
Comparison of Climate Adaptation Planning on Two Continents’, University of
Massachusetts 34 Working paper, http://scholarworks.umass.edu (accessed 15-2-2018).
668
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
16. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) (2014) Annex II: ‘Glossary’ [Mach, K.J., S.
Planton and C. von Stechow (eds)]. In: Climate Change 2014: Synthesis Report. Contribution of
Working Groups I, II and III to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change [Core Writing Team, R.K. Pachauri and L.A. Meyer (eds)]. IPCC, Geneva,
Switzerland, pp.117-13
17. Juhola S. (2010) ‘Mainstreaming Climate Change Adaptation: The Case of Multi-Level
Governance in Finland’, Developing Adaptation Policy and Practice in Europe: Multi-level
Governance of Climate Change’, ed. H. Keskitalo, Springer: Sweden.
18. Martins R.D.A. and L.C. Ferreira (2011) ‘Opportunities and constraints for local and
subnational climate change policy in urban areas: insights from diverse contexts’,
International Journal of Global Environmental Issues, Vol.11 (1), pp. 37–53.
19. Ministry of Environment and Energy (MEEN) (2016) ‘National Adaptation Strategy for
Greece’
http://www.ypeka.gr/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=crbjkiIcLlA%3d&tabid=303&language=el-GR
(accessed 15-2-2018) (in Greek).
20. Ministry of Environment and Energy (MEEN) (2017) ‘Specifications for Regional Adaptation
Action Plans’, Government Gazette B/873/16-3-2017 (in Greek).
21. Ribeiro M., Losenno C., Dworak T., Massey E., Swart R., Benzie M. and C. Laaser (2009)
‘Design of guidelines for the elaboration of Regional Climate Change Adaptations
Strategies’, Study for European Commission – DG Environment - Tender DG ENV.
G.1/ETU/2008/0093r. Ecologic Institute: Vienna.
22. Termeer C., Biesbroek R. and M. Van den Brink (2012) ‘Institutions for adaptation to climate
change: comparing national adaptation strategies in Europe’, European Political Science,
Vol. 11(1), pp. 41-53.
23. Thoidou E. (2013) ‘The climate challenge and EU cohesion policy: implications for regional
policies’, International Journal of Innovation and Sustainable Development, Vol. 7(3), pp. 303320.
24. Thoidou E. (2017) ‘Climate adaptation strategies: cohesion policy 2014-2020 and prospects
for Greek regions’, Management of Environmental Quality: An International Journal, Vol.
28(3), pp. 350-367.
25. Venturini S., Medri, S. and Castellari, S. (2012) ‘Overview of key climate change impacts,
vulnerabilities and adaptation action in Europe’, CMCC Research Papers RP0142
https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2195399 (accessed 15-2-2018).
669
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
SPATIAL ANALYSIS FOR VULNERABILITY ASSESSMENT OF
URBAN COASTAL AREAS TO SEA LEVEL RISE
E.A. Stamatopoulou*1, G. Ovakoglou2, T.K. Alexandridis2, I.A. Tsalikidis3
1
Joint Master Programme in Landscape Architecture, Dept. of Architecture and Dept. of
Agriculture, A.U.Th, GR-54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
2
Laboratory of Remote Sensing, Spectroscopy and GIS, Faculty of Agriculture, A.U.Th
GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
3
Laboratory of Floriculture and Landscape Architecture, Faculty of Agriculture, A.U.Th
GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: amystamatopoulou@gmail.com, tel: +306945354313
Abstract
It is widely accepted that climate change poses a potential threat for urban environments, thus is one
of the largest challenges for humanity nowadays. The most common effect of climate change is the
Sea Level Rise (SLR), which develops in the long run and is directly connected to extreme weather
conditions at the coastal zone level. Coastal zones are most affected by extreme weather phenomena
caused by SLR. The understanding of the potentially dire impacts of climate change has resulted in
the widespread use of the resilience concept. This study examines methods of spatial analysis that
can introduce the variable of climate change to the landscape architecture analysis with the intention
to enhance resilience in the design process. The study reports the results of the application of a
methodology for the assessment of the vulnerability of coastal areas to SLR due to climate change. It
also allows identifying critical areas to this phenomenon and providing a useful classification of the
coastal areas in the selected study areas. Introducing Geographical Information System (GIS)
techniques and spatial analysis, the study approaches a methodology of determining coastal zone
vulnerability for Thermaikos and the Corinthian Gulf. Both case studies are vulnerable due to
accelerated SLR, high erosion rate that threatens urban areas and protected ecosystems on the coastal
zone. For the determination of the Coastal Vulnerability Index (CVI) geologic and physical variables
were considered. The CVI is giving results towards an evaluation of the likelihood that physical
changes may occur. The study attempts to introduce resilience on the coastal zone by identifying the
most vulnerable areas to SLR and consider them as an indispensable support for landscape
architecture projects and spatial intervention.
Keywords: Resilience, SLR, Coastal zone, Soft infrastructure, GIS, Spatial analysis, CVI
1.
INTRODUCTION
The impact of climate change and its consequent phenomena are in the centre of the discussion
regarding urban resilience. Climate is defined as long-term averages and variations in weather
measured over a period of several decades. Its effects have already been quite observable on the
environment through Sea Lever Rise (SLR), the melting of the Greenland ice sheet, the greenhouse
effect, causing intense droughts and floods, mean temperature rise and extreme weather conditions.
As the cities become vulnerable to climate change, their ability to adapt to expected or unexpected
changes defines their resiliency [Vale and Campanella, 2005]. Spatial analysis is a means of recording
the vulnerabilities or strengths of the environment and enables the understanding of space. The
670
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Geographical Information System (GIS) techniques can relate spatial or geographic data with
unrelated information, such as climate change effects, by using location as the key index variable.
It is common ground, that the first step to coastal protection against SLR is the spatial analysis and
quantification of the coastal erosion that takes place. In order to produce such results, the study looks
into literature for creating indices that can follow this principle.
Gornitz et al. (1991) argues that one of the most common worldwide methods of assessing coastal
vulnerability is the Coastal Vulnerability Index (CVI). The study of Dwarakish et al. (2009) has been
carried out with a view to calculate the Coastal Vulnerability Index (CVI), in order to identify the
high and low vulnerable areas and area of inundation due to future SLR, as well as the land loss due
to coastal erosion. The study of Doukakis (2005) has used CVI to map the relative vulnerability along
the coastline of western Peloponnese. The CVI calculation used physical contributors in order to
highlight the regions with maximum SLR effects and following, each CVI was computed on digitized
maps for comparison reasons. Using percentiles the coastline was grouped based on the vulnerability
extend.
This study uses the CVI in order to examine the coastal zone of two gulfs (Thermaikos and the
Corinthian Gulf) where the coastline is of a different morphology (closed gulf) than the above
mentioned studies. The study areas are characterized by densely populated coastlines, resulting in a
high risk in case of a future SLR. The aim of the study is to figure out whether it is possible to extract
results about CVI in areas other than linear coastlines and in small scale study areas. During this study
both conventional and remotely sensed data were used.
1.1
Coastal Vulnerability
1.1.1 Characteristics of the coastal zone
The coastal zone is historically important, as the space where human activity has developed
throughout the centuries. This theory is proved by the fact that two thirds of the planet’s total
population live within a distance of few kilometres from the coastline, given its socio-economic and
ecological importance. Coastal ecosystems are highly productive, rich in biotopes of fauna and flora.
Additionally, they work as a natural defence against the destructive forces of the sea.
However, the coastal zone faces pressures that alter its structure. These pressures can be distinguished
in two types, natural and anthropogenic processes, which in many cases cause irreversible effects in
the coastal landscapes. A noticeable natural process is the coastal erosion that can cause full or partial
remodelling of the landscape and tidal waves. Anthropogenic factors are the unregulated urban
development, loss of ecosystems and biodiversity, pollution, landscape degradation, depletion and
pollution of water resources. The above mentioned are common characteristics at most of the coastal
areas worldwide. Adding to these pressures, climate change causes short-term effects, as analysed
following.
1.1.2 Climate change and coastal vulnerability
Climate change has several impacts on urban environments with SLR being the most crucial for the
coastal zone. SLR develops over time due to thermal expansion, as causing the occurrence of extreme
weather events in the coastal zone. It is indicative of the magnitude of the impact on urban
environments, that 60% of the world's population lives within a distance of 60 kilometres from the
coastline, while 11 of the largest cities in the world are in coastal low-altitude areas [Bergdoll and
Nordenson, 2011].
SLR is a phenomenon that progresses over time, affects coastal, island regions, as well as areas
adjacent to Delta Rivers and causes compulsory migration of the population. It will lead to an increase
in the frequency of phenomena that are now characterized as extreme flooding. Krestenitis et al.,
(2015) pointed out that due to the higher water level, the frequency and intensity of floods due to
heavy storms will increase dramatically.
671
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
In this context, coastal vulnerability is defined as the composition of the risk of a natural coastal
system and the risk of the socio-economic system due to climate change [Doukakis, 2007]. The
impacts of SLR on a natural coastal system depend on its vulnerability to these, its adaptation, as well
as its strength. Adaptability and strength describe its physical stability in changes. In particular, the
strength expresses the ability of the system to resist to a possible disturbance, while adaptability
expresses the speed with which the system returns to its original condition. The ability of the coastal
system to respond and adapt to extreme changes mitigates its vulnerability and develops its resiliency
for the future.
2.
METHODOLOGY
2.1 Variables
Complexity in the form and functions of coastal zones does not favour the development of a coastal
vulnerability model with general application. Additionally, data used for the analysis of the variables
of a coastal vulnerability model show high variability in different spatial scales. Hammar-Klose and
Thieler (1999), argue that for a more comprehensive study of coastal vulnerability it is considered
that large-scale variables (waves, tides, sea-level trends) should be mapped with relatively good
accuracy, while small scale variables (geomorphology, coastal slope, shoreline change rate) should
allow the perception of their effects on the coast.
Historic shoreline change, geomorphology, coastal slope, mean tidal range, mean significant wave
height and global SLR are the six variables to the CVI calculation. The CVI allows these six variables
to be related in a quantifiable manner that expresses the relative vulnerability of the coast to physical
changes due to future sea level rise. The CVI calculation yields numerical data that cannot be equated
directly with particular physical effects. However, it does highlight areas where the various effects of
SLR may be the greatest. The six variables are classified into two groups, the Geologic variables and
the Physical variables [Dwarakish et al., 2009].
The geologic variables include (a) historic shoreline change, (b) geomorphology and (c) coastal slope.
The physical variables include (a) mean tidal range, (b) mean significant wave height and global SLR.
Once each section of the coastline is assigned a vulnerability value for each specific data variable,
the CVI is calculated as the square root of the product of the ranked variables divided by the total
number of variables:
2
CVI= √
abcdef
(1)
6
where a: geomorphology, b: shoreline change rate (m / yr.), c: coastal slope (%), d: mean tidal range
(m), e: mean significant wave height (m), f: global SLR (mm / yr.)
Actual variable values are assigned a vulnerability ranking based on value ranges, whereas the nonnumerical geomorphology variable is ranked qualitatively according to the relative resistance of a
given landform to erosion (Table 1).
2.1.1 Geomorphology
The geomorphology variable expresses the relative erodibility of different landform types. The
ranking is on a linear scale from 1 to 5 in order of increasing vulnerability due to SLR. Data from
Joint Research Centre (JRC) European Soil Data Centre (ESDAC) were used and in particular the
soil erosion by water dataset (RUSLE2015). From this dataset the layer of soil erodibility (ERODI)
was selected, which relates to the soil erodibility factor (K-factor).
672
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1: Ranges of vulnerability ranking for both study areas
a/a
Variable
Ranking of coastal vulnerability
Low
Moderate
High
2
3
4
Medium
River
Rocky cliffed cliffs,
Low cliffs,
deposits,
coasts
indented
lateritic plain
alluvial plain
coasts
Very low
1
Very high
5
Coastal plain,
beach mud
flats
a
Geomorphology
b
Shoreline
erosion/accretion
(m / yr.)
>+15
+5 to +15
-5 to +5
-15 to -5
<-15
c
Coastal Slope (%)
>0.6
0.5-0.6
0.4-0.5
0.3-0.4
<0.3
d
Mean tide range
>4.0
(m)
3.0-4.0
2.0-3.0
1.0-2.0
<1.0
e
Mean significant
<0.7
wave height (m)
0.7-1.4
1.4-2.1
2.1-2.8
>2.8
f
Mean sea level rise
<1.8
(mm / yr.)
1.8-2.5
2.5-3.0
3.0-3.4
>3.4
2.1.2 Shoreline change rate
The value of this variable was retrieved from literature and the study of Doukakis (2007), since the
available data is not detailed enough in order to provide accurate results in the study area’s scale. The
study shows that for a large number of coastal areas in Greece, an annual shoreline change rate is
calculated slightly more than -1.0 m / yr. With a horizon of 50 (2050) or 100 years (2100), a mean
rate was calculated resulting an annual rate of – 1.76 m / yr. (intensive erosion) and at - 0.14 m / yr.
(low erosion).
2.1.3 Coastal slope
Determination of the regional coastal slope identifies the relative vulnerability of inundation and the
potential rapidity of shoreline retreat [Dwarakish et al., 2009]. The coastal slope was calculated by
defining a distance of 12 km perpendicular to the coastline, 6 km towards the sea and 6 km towards
shore. The selection of the coastal zone distribution, as well as the classification of the slope was
based on literature. The bathymetric data was retrieved from the EMODNET (Portal for BathymetryBathymetry Viewing and Download Service), and DEM topography data was retrieved from curves
interpolation digitized from 1: 100000 GIS maps. The two raster files were delimited within the study
area and were then converted into joined slope data giving the total coastal slope.
2.1.4 Mean tidal range
Mean tidal range carries the information of the potential influence of storms on coastal evolution, and
their impact relative to the tide range. In Greece generally, the literature [Doukakis, 2007] explains
that tidal waves especially for small-scale study areas is negligible. This can be explained by the fact
that a micro tidal coastline is essentially always ‘‘near’’ high tide and therefore always at the greatest
risk of inundation from storms.
2.1.5 Mean significant wave height
Mean significant wave height information was retrieved from the COPERNICUS system and the
MEDSEA_ANALYSIS_ dataset FORECAST_WAV_006_011, using the layer “Spectral layer
significant wave height-mean significant wave height”. Daily data was used from each last day of the
month, for one year (systematic sampling), which we compiled to get the average maximum and
minimum values in the study areas.
673
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
2.1.6 Mean sea level rise
A sea level rise would directly result in a corresponding higher shift to the zone of wave action on
the beach. According to the projected SLR for Low Emissions (RCP2.6) of the European
Environment Agency, a mean sea level rise is expected for the Thermaikos Gulf about 0.3-0.4mm /
yr., while for the Corinthian Gulf, 4-0.5mm / yr.
2.2 Study areas
The study areas where CVI is calculated are Thermaikos (northern Greece) and the Corinthian Gulf
(south-west Greece). Their selection was based on literature research [Doukakis, 2007], since they
are considered areas with significant impacts from climate change.
Figure 1: The study areas of Thermaikos Gulf (left) and the Corinthian Gulf (right)
The intense erosion of the Corinthian Gulf coastline - nowadays - on the one hand and the hazard
scenarios of the coastal zone of the Thermaikos Gulf on the other, both imply the threat of the coastal
zone from human activities and increases vulnerability to SLR. As mentioned in the study of
Doukakis (2007) the Thermaikos Gulf west area is particularly vulnerable. Thermaikos is considered
the third most threatened Mediterranean region from SLR after the Nile Delta and the Gulf of Venice.
At the same time, the Corinthian Gulf faces very significant erosion problems, setting the coastal
zone particularly fertile for further study.
The two study areas have a high population density in their coastal zone and are strongly related to
socioeconomic activities. At the same time, their location favours research, as different climatic
conditions prevail, but also a different degree of exposure to natural phenomena, varied
geomorphology and landscape. They also both consist of different ecosystems (delta river, long
coastline), adding to variegated results.
2.3 Variables’ ranking in buffer zones
The variables that were analysed in chapter 2 were assigned in polygons defined through buffer zones
in the study area and thus CVI was calculated for these zones. Buffer zones are defined as areas of
influence of the coastline. Each buffer zone is partitioned in polygons per 5 km in a straight line,
taking into account their structure (small bays, estuaries, rivers) so that the polygon information is
proportionally equal. Polygons with special coastline structure are assigned as one in order to retain
the characteristics.
The 5km distance was set for this particular scale to provide the best possible variability of data, while
pointing out the micro scale coastline qualities. Additionally, the detail of the available data is applied
to the size of the polygons. The buffer zones for the two study areas were numerically separated as
shown in Figure 2:
674
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2: Thermaikos Gulf (left) and the Corinthian Gulf (right) with buffer zone and the
numbered polygons used for the assignment of the values per variable
3. RESULTS
3.1 Variables’ classification
Regarding geomorphology, no available data for coastal erosion models was retrieved. In order to
extract relatively detailed results we used the model of soil erodibility factor that was quite detailed.
The soil erodibility factor was used for the different erosion tendencies, with the results shown in
Figure 3:
Figure 3: Thermaikos Gulf (left) and the Corinthian Gulf (right) erodibility classification
The shoreline change rate is calculated slightly more than -1.0 m / yr. [Doukakis, 2007] as explained
in the Chapter 2.1.2; therefore both study areas belong to the class number 4. The calculation of
coastal slope was retrieved with gradient values that have a maximum value for Thermaikos Gulf
0.33%, while for the Corinthian 1.78% (Figure 4).
Figure 4: Thermaikos Gulf (left) and the Corinthian Gulf (right) coastal slope classification
675
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
The tide value in Greece reaches a maximum height of 0.3 m and is therefore included in the category
5 of very high vulnerability (mean tidal rate less than 1 m.) In the Corinthian Gulf, values for the
mean significant wave height vary from 0.095 m up to 0.17 m and in Thermaikos Gulf from 0.157 m
up to 0.59 m. The classification in the case of study areas is limited in the category of very low
vulnerability, due to values less than 0.7 m. Value 5 is given in regions with average significant wave
height greater than 2.8 m. As a result, the value for both study areas is defined as: 1- minimum
vulnerability < 0.7 m. In both study areas, the mean sea level rise is classified as with very low
vulnerability, since its values are less than 1.8 mm / yr., which is the least compared with the
Dwarakish et al., (2009) study.
Providing a specific value for each polygon of the coastline, the CVI has been calculated using Eq.
(1). The calculated CVI value for the Thermaikos Gulf varies from 6.20 to 8.62 and for the Corinthian
Gulf from 6.67 to 9.04 (Figure 5). The classification was made on a 5-pronged scale to indicate
differentiation within the study areas. Also, the distribution of values is made equally in 5 classes per
study area rather than comparing the two study areas to each other. As a result, areas of minimum
and very high vulnerability are related to the values of the area itself. The average coastal vulnerability
value for the Thermaikos Gulf is 7.16 and for the Corinthian Gulf 7.53, while the standard deviation
is 1.08 and 0.69 accordingly.
Figure 5: The visualisation of the CVI results for Thermaikos Gulf (left) and the Corinthian
Gulf (right) added with the Natura areas and the main cities in the surrounding area
4.
DISCUSSION
Regarding GIS and spatial analysis, this study attempted to highlight their valuable contribution in
analysing landscapes, especially in cases of changes that are unable to be measured. Presenting
various changes as concrete facts through numbers can make a decisive contribution to understanding
these phenomena, while at the same time facilitating their transmission to the general public. Through
a widen understanding the environmental issues can have a recognition that will inspire collaboration
between designers / architects and the public. The coastal vulnerability index in its depiction is an
understandable image for the public and gives the opportunity to open the discussion. Therefore, it is
proposed to be researched further and in depth, in order to point out the necessary tools for coastal
zone protection.
The present study was an attempt to combine a landscape architecture analysis and design process
with the realistic impacts of climate change. The methodology though, faced several difficulties in
providing an accurate result. The choice of the study areas led to a very large coastline with not much
detailed data for variables as the shoreline change rate. The scale of the data was hard to apply to a
length of several kilometres, since the available data could not depict the complexity of the coastline.
Variables such as geomorphology are appropriate to be used in large scale study areas (Doukakis,
676
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2007), yet the retrieved data did not include information on the coastal area itself providing relative
results.
The CVI analysis should probably better be applied in specific coastline parts with higher interest
(e.g. highly-densed or nature-protected areas). The land use could also be a variable in order to
provide results on the risk level of the coastal areas, adding to the information on vulnerability and
providing a social aspect on the final result. Compared to the Dwarakish study (2009) the results
extracted give a relatively good response of the study areas in future SLR with lower vulnerability
level. The study of Doukakis (2007) extracted higher CVI results for its areas of study in Western
Peloponnese than the present study, giving an opportunity to re-examine the present results.
5.
CONCLUSIONS
The CVI methodology can support spatial analysis for the coastal zone, providing useful results for
landscape architecture projects, policy making and risk management. It can be considered a support
for spatial intervention. Areas characterised with ‘high vulnerability’ should be set into priority for
protection as a means of prevention from future challenges due to SLR. The scale of the study areas
and the data available are crucial to the accuracy of the results and need to be clearly set from the
research context. Greece is a country developed by the coast and methodologies as CVI should be
able to support its future resilience practices to respond to climate change and SLR.
AKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank Konstantinos N. Topouzelis from the Department of Marine Sciences of the University of
the Aegean for assistance with material of bathymetric data for this study.
References
1. Vale, J.L., Campanella, J.T. (2005). ‘The Resilient City: How modern cities recover from
disaster’. Oxford University Press.
2. Gornitz, V.M., White, T.W., and Cushman, R.M. (1991). Vulnerability of the U.S. to future sealevel rise. In Proceedings of Seventh Symposium on Coastal and Ocean Management. Long
Beach, CA, USA.
3. Doukakis, E. (2005). Coastal vulnerability and risk parameters. European Water, 11(12), pp. 37.
4. Dwarakish, G. S., Vinay, S. A., Natesan, U., Asano, T., Kakinuma, T., Venkataramana, K.,
Jagedeesha Pai B., Babita, M. K. (2009). Coastal vulnerability assessment of the future sea level
rise in Udupi coastal zone of Karnataka state, west coast of India. Ocean & Coastal
Management, 52(9), pp. 467-478.
5. Bergdoll, B., & Nordenson, G. (2011). ’Rising currents: projects for New York’s waterfront’.
Museum of Modern Art.
6. Krestenitis, I., Kombiadou, K., Makris, C., Androulidakis, I., Karampas, T. (2015). Changes of
Sea Level.
7. Thieler E. R., Hammar-Klose E. S. (1999). National assessment of coastal vulnerability to SeaLevel Rise: preliminary results for the U.S. Atlantic coast. U.S. Geological Survey, Open-File
Report 99–593.
8. Doukakis, E. (2007). Natural Disasters and Coastal Zone. Conference of Preventing - Managing
natural disasters. The Role of the Rural-Surveying Engineer. Athens, Greece.
677
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
REFERENCE EVAPOTRANSPIRATION ASSESSMENT IN
CHALKIDIKI REGION UNDER CLIMATE CHANGE USING
FOUR EARTH SYSTEM MODELS
P. Koukouli*, P. Georgiou and D. Karpouzos
Dept. of Hydraulics, Soil Science and Agr. Engineering, School of Agriculture, A.U.Th, GR- 54124
Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: pkoukoul@agro.auth.gr, tel : +306973091293
Abstract
Reference evapotranspiration (ETo) is an important component in water resources, agricultural and
environmental modeling. Thus, the assessment of ETo changes in response to future climate change
has a great impact in agricultural sector. In this study, the effect of climate change on reference
evapotranspiration in Northern Greece, was assessed. For this purpose, the climate change scenario
RCP4.5 based on four Earth System Models (ESMs) CanESM2, GFDL-ESM2M, HadGEM2-ES and
IPSL-CM5A-LR was used for the time period 2081-2100 and for the baseline period (1981-2000).
The downscaling was performed using the weather generator ClimGen. Reference evapotranspiration
was estimated with the use of the FAO Penman-Monteith equation. Results showed that mean annual
reference evapotranspiration is projected to increase (from 6% up to 25%) in response to climate
change during 2081-2100 according to the four ESMs. Regarding reference evapotranspiration of the
irrigation period (May to September), the increase will be similar to annual, ranging from 5% to 27%.
The results indicate that the development of adaptation strategies is necessary for the improvement
of agricultural water management and the reduction of climate change impacts on agriculture.
Keywords: Climate change, Reference evapotranspiration, RCPs, Earth system models, ClimGen
1.
INTRODUCTION
Climate change is considered a major problem worldwide and its impacts on different aspects of
social activity and on the natural environment require careful assessment. Warming of the climate
system in recent decades is unequivocal, as is now evident from observations of increases in global
average air and ocean temperatures, widespread melting of snow and ice, and rising global sea level
(IPCC, 2013). The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Fifth Assessment Report
(AR5) projects that the global mean temperature will increase by the late 21st century (2081-2100)
relative to 1986-2005, by 1°C to 3.7°C according to RCPs scenarios (IPCC, 2013).
Climate warming observed over the past several decades is associated with changes on hydrological
and meteorological systems such as: changing precipitation patterns, intensity and extremes, melting
of snow and ice, increasing atmospheric water vapour, increasing evaporation, and changes in soil
moisture and runoff. Evapotranspiration is affected by climate change through many processes
beginning with the increasing concentration of greenhouse gases, followed by their impacts on large
scale circulation and changes to the global distribution of energy and moisture. Other factors that can
might affect ET under a changing climate include changing land cover patterns and the CO2
fertilization effects that can limit the rate of plant transpiration under elevated levels of CO 2 (Guo et
al., 2017).
678
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Climate change impact studies are usually based on projections of future climate from General
Circulation Models (GCMs) and recently Earth System Models (ESMs) which are converted into
reference evapotranspiration (ETo) using appropriate models. The assessment of ETo changes is
critical in understanding the impacts of anthropogenic climate change on the sector of agriculture.
Climate projections show increases in evapotranspiration (ET) over the 21st century because the
evaporative demand, or ‘reference evaporation’, is projected to increase almost everywhere. Changes
in ET are controlled by changes in precipitation and radiative forcing, and the changes would, in turn,
impact on the water balance of runoff, soil moisture, water in reservoirs, the groundwater table and
the salinization of shallow aquifers (IPCC, 2008).
The objective of this study was to investigate the effect of climate change on reference
evapotranspiration in Agios Mamas area in Greece for the end (2081-2100) of the running century.
For this purpose, data was derived from four ESMs: CanESM2 (Arora et al., 2011), GFDL-ESM2M
(Dunne et al., 2013), HadGEM2-ES (Martin et al., 2011) and IPSL-CM5A-LR (Dufresne, 2013)
under RCP4.5 climate change scenario using as a baseline period 1981-2000. The selected models
are the current generation of models used in IPCC AR5. The models performance has shown a good
capability in representing the observed behavior in past climate (IPCC, 2013). Although these models
can be considered a sufficient tool for future projections, no individual model clearly emerges as ‘the
best’ overall. For this reason, a number of models with different grid resolutions, was selected for
increasing the reliability of the future projections. Based on the data taken from the climate models,
the downscaling of daily climate variables was performed with the use of the weather generator
ClimGen (Stöckle and Nelson, 1999) for the generation of synthetic time series which depict the
future change of the climate variables. Future reference evapotranspiration was estimated using the
FAO Penman-Monteith equation for all climate models. The annual and irrigation period (May to
September) ETο for period 2081-2100 was compared with the baseline period for the assessment of
climate change impacts according to the different climate models used.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Study area and data
The impact of climate change on reference evapotranspiration was studied in Agios Mamas area in
the prefecture of Chalkidiki in Northern Greece which is located between 40°15' latitude and 23°20'
longitude (Figure 1). The climate in the Prefecture of Chalkidiki is mainly Mediterranean, with hot
summers and cool winters. The study area is agricultural and meteorological data that were used to
generate the climate change scenarios were provided by station. Furthermore, the station of Agios
Mamas is located in low altitude and, therefore, describes better the irrigation area. The time series
data used in this work were precipitation (mm), wind speed (m/s), actual sunshine duration (hrs),
mean temperature (oC), and relative humidity (%) for the baseline period 1981-2000 at daily time
step.
2.2 RCP scenarios
In climate research, emission scenarios are used as input to climate models to make projections of
possible future climate change. Emission scenarios provide plausible descriptions of how the future
may evolve with respect to a range of variables including socio-economic change, technological
change, energy and land use and emissions of greenhouse gases and air pollutants (van Vuuren et al.,
2011).
The Representative Concentration Pathways scenarios (RCPs) are the product of an innovative
collaboration between integrated assessment modelers, climate modelers, terrestrial ecosystem
modelers and emission inventory experts. The four RCPs together span the range of year 2100
radiative forcing values found in the open literature, from 2.6 to 8.5W/m2 (van Vuuren et al., 2011)
and are supplemented with extensions (Extended Concentration Pathways, ECPs), which allow
climate modeling experiments through the year 2300. The above scenarios are named after the
679
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
approximate radiative forcing (RCP2.6, RCP4.5, RCP6 and RCP8.5) relative to the pre-industrial
period achieved either in the year 2100, or at stabilization after 2100 (van Vuuren et al., 2011). They
include one mitigation scenario leading to a very low forcing level (RCP2.6), two medium
stabilization scenarios (RCP4.5 and RCP6) and one very high baseline emission scenario (RCP8.5)
(van Vuuren et al., 2011). According to the IPCC (2013) the atmospheric concentration of carbon
dioxide (CO2) in the year 2100 is predicted to reach 490 ppm, 650 ppm, 850 ppm and 1370 for
pathways RCP2.6, RCP4.5, RCP6 and RCP8.5, respectively. In this study, the moderate scenario
RCP4.5 is used for the assessment of reference evapotranspiration under climate change.
Figure 1: The location of Agios Mamas in Northern Greece
2.3 Climate models
Climate models are the primary tools for investigating the response of the climate system to various
forcings, for making climate predictions on seasonal to decadal time scales and for making projections
of future climate over the coming century and beyond (IPCC, 2013). Climate models have seen a
number of improvements with developing improved physical process descriptions, introducing new
model components and the improving model resolution. These models allow for policy-relevant
calculations such as the carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions compatible with a specified climate
stabilization target (IPCC, 2013). Many models have been extended into Earth System Models
(ESMs) by including the representation of biogeochemical cycles important to climate change. ESMs
are the current state-of-the-art climate models and are the most comprehensive tools available for
simulating past and future response of the climate system to external forcing, in which
biogeochemical feedbacks play an important role (IPCC, 2013). Climate model simulations for the
IPCC Fifth Assessment Report (AR5) are based on the fifth phase of the Coupled Model
Intercomparison Project (CMIP5) which incorporates the latest versions of climate models, the Earth
System Models, and focuses on the new scenarios RCPs.
In this study, CanESM2, GFDL-ESM2M, HadGEM2-ES and IPSL-CM5A-LR models under the
newly developed RCPs were used for assessing climate change impact. CanESM2 is an Earth System
Model developed at the Canadian Centre for Climate Modelling and Analysis (CCCma). The
atmospheric component of CanESM2 uses the spectral transform method with T63 resolution in the
680
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
horizontal (2.81 long x 2.79 lat) and has 35 vertical levels and the ocean component has a horizontal
resolution of 1.418 x 0.948 (long x lat) (Arora et al., 2011). GFDL-ESM2M is a global coupled
climate-carbon Earth System Model developed at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration (NOAA)/Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory (GFDL). The model, on land,
includes a revised land model to simulate competitive vegetation distributions and functioning,
including carbon cycling among vegetation, soil, and atmosphere and in the ocean, new
biogeochemical algorithms including phytoplankton dynamics (Dunne et al., 2013). This model has
an atmospheric horizontal resolution of 2.5 x 2.0 (long x lat) and its ocean component has a horizontal
resolution of 1.0 x 1.0 (long x lat). The HadGEM2-ES of the Met Office Unified Model (MetUM)
includes atmosphere, ocean and sea-ice components and an Earth-System (ES) component which
includes dynamic vegetation, ocean biology and atmospheric chemistry (Martin et al., 2011).
HadGEM2-ES has an atmospheric horizontal resolution of 1.875 x 1.25 (long x lat) that equates to
about 140 km at mid-latitudes. The ocean component has a horizontal resolution of 1.0 x 1.0, with
latitudinal resolution increasing smoothly from 30 N/S to 0.33 at equator. The IPSL-CM5A model
developed at Institute Pierre Simon Laplace (IPSL) is an Earth System Model (ESM). This model
includes an interactive carbon cycle, a representation of tropospheric and stratospheric chemistry, and
a comprehensive representation of aerosols (Dufresne, 2013). IPSL-CM5A-LR is a low resolution
version of IPSL-CM5A model with atmospheric horizontal resolution of 3.75 x 1.89 (long x lat).
2.4 Downscaling with weather generator - ClimGen
There is a great need to develop downscaling methods which establish relationships between local
weather variables and the large-scale ESMs’ outputs for climate change impact assessment.
Stochastic weather generators are statistical models used to produce synthetic weather time series,
which are expected to be statistically similar to the observed weather time series for a location of
interest (Georgiou and Karpouzos, 2017; Koukouli et al., 2018). They are usually combined with
hydrological and environmental models for water resources and environmental management and
more often as downscaling tools to produce high-resolution climate change projections (Chen and
Brissete, 2014). The weather generators compared to other statistical downscaling methods have the
advantage of producing an ensemble of equiprobable realizations of climate change projections for
analyzing risk-based environmental impacts (Chen and Brissete, 2014). ClimGen (Stöckle and
Nelson, 1999) is a daily time step stochastic model that generates daily precipitation (mm), maximum
and minimum temperature (oC), solar radiation (MJ/m2day), maximum and minimum relative
humidity (%) and wind speed (m/s) data series which preserve the statistical characteristics of the
historical weather data. The model requires inputs of daily series of these weather variables to
calculate the parameters used in the generation process for any length of period at a location of
interest. ClimGen has produced promising results for the generation of weather data for various
climatic conditions (Stöckle and Nelson, 1999).
2.5 Estimation of reference evapotranspiration
Given the likelihood of future change in the global hydrological cycle, clear understanding of ETo
dynamics is vital for the assessment of impacts of future climate change on water and subsequent
implications for the agricultural sector. Reference evapotranspiration (ETo) is the evapotranspiration
from a crop with specific characteristics and which is not short of water (McMahon et al., 2013).
Among the methods available to estimate ETo, the Food and Agricultural Organisation of the United
Nations (FAO) recommends the use of the Penman-Monteith equation (Allen et al., 1998) which is
known as FAO Penman-Monteith method, as it directly incorporates the relevant meteorological
variables which control evapotranspiration. It is often referred to as a combinational method, as it
combines the energy balance and mass transfer components of evapotranspiration, and takes into
account vegetation-dependent processes such as aerodynamic and surface resistances (Guo et al.,
2017). This method is the most reliable where sufficient meteorological data exist, but that in certain
climatological environments and where empirical calibrations are robust, less data-intensive methods
can also provide reliable approximations of ETo (Kingston et al., 2009). The FAO Penman-Monteith
681
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
equation is based on temperature, net radiation, wind speed and relative humidity. Adopting the
characteristics of a hypothetical reference crop (height=0.12 m, surface resistance=70 s/m and
albedo=0.23), FAO Penman-Monteith equation is described as follows (Allen et al., 1998):
0.408 Δ R n - G + γ
ETo =
900
Tmean + 273
Δ + γ 1 + 0.34 u 2
u 2 es - e a
(1)
where ETo is the reference evapotranspiration, (mm/day), Rn is the net radiation (MJ/m2day), G is the
soil heat flux (MJ/m2day), γ is the psychrometric constant (kPa/oC), es is the saturation vapour
pressure (kPa), ea is the actual vapour pressure (kPa), Δ is the slope of the saturation vapour pressure
- temperature curve (kPa/oC), Tmean is the mean daily air temperature (oC) and u2 is the mean daily
wind speed at 2 m (m/s).
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
This study was focused on the impact of climate change on the reference evapotranspiration (ETo) of
Agios Mamas in Northern Greece. For this purpose, weather data from CanESM2, GFDL-ESM2M,
HadGEM2-ES and IPSL-CM5A-LR Earth System Models under the climate change scenario RCP4.5
were used for the climate change period 2081-2100 and for the baseline period (1981-2000).
Based on the data derived from the four climate models, the downscaling of a 20-year data set (19812000) of daily climate variables including precipitation (Pr), maximum and minimum temperature
(Tmax, Tmin), solar radiation (Rs), maximum and minimum relative humidity (RHmax, RHmin), and wind
speed (u2) performed using the weather generator ClimGen for the generation of synthetic time series
which depict the future change of the climate variables. The change between the baseline period and
the period of climate change 2081-2100 was calculated for the different climate variables. According
to that change, the historic data series of the study area was perturbed. The perturbed time series then
was used by ClimGen for the generation of an ensemble of synthetic time series of the weather
variables which preserve the statistic characteristics of the historic time series. The generated and
observed weather data series were compared in order to confirm the statistical consistency. Finally,
this ensemble of synthetic time series of climate variables was used for the estimation of an ensemble
of reference evapotranspiration (mean annual and irrigation period) time series of the study area.
First the change in temperature is analyzed since it is a critical variable for the estimation of
evapotranspiration. In Table 1, the mean annual temperature and mean temperature during the
irrigation period of Agios Mamas under RCP4.5, based on CanESM2, GFDL-ESM2M, HadGEM2ES and IPSL-CM5A-LR models, for the period of climate change 2081-2100 and for the baseline
period 1981-2000, are presented. The models’ projections indicate that mean annual temperature will
increase by the end of the 21st century.
The predicted increases during 2081-2100 will be by 3.04oC (CanESM2), 1.08oC (GFDL-ESM2M),
3.83oC (HadGEM2-ES) and 3.39oC (IPSL-CM5A-LR) compared to the baseline period 1981-2000.
The rise in temperature of the irrigation period is projected to be by 3.89oC (CanESM2), 1.69oC
(GFDL-ESM2M), 4.62oC (HadGEM2-ES) and 3.29oC (IPSL-CM5A-LR). The greatest rise, both in
annual and irrigation period temperature, is projected by HadGEM2-ES model while the lowest by
GFDL-ESM2M. It is observed that the increase in mean temperature during the irrigation period will
be slightly greater compared to the annual, according to the climate models with the exception of
IPSL-CM5A-LR.
Box plots of mean temperature change (oC) under RCP4.5 projected by the four different climate
models are shown in Figure 2 concerning a) annual and b) irrigation period temperature. The increase
682
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
in mean annual and irrigation period temperature, projected by the models is obvious according to
the box plots. HadGEM2-ES model has the greatest maximum and mean value among all models,
indicating that the above model gives the highest increase in annual and irrigation period temperature.
The lowest maximum and mean value is observed according to GFDL-ESM2M showing the lowest
rise in annual and during the irrigation period temperature among the models used. According to the
box plots analysis, the largest spread in distribution of the mean temperature is observed for GFDLESM2M climate model for both annual and irrigation period.
Table 1: Differences in mean annual and irrigation period temperature (oC) of Agios Mamas
according to CanESM2, GFDL-ESM2M, HadGEM2-ES and IPSL-CM5A-LR under RCP 4.5
during 2081-2100 in relation to 1981-2000
Mean Temperature (oC)
Historical
RCP4.5 2081-2100
Ag. Mamas
Climate Models
1981-2000
CanESM2 GFDL-ESM2M HadGEM2-ES IPSL-CM5A-LR
14.42
17.46
15.50
18.25
17.81
ΔTmean
3.04
1.08
3.83
3.39
Irrigation
21.99
25.88
23.68
26.61
25.28
period
ΔTmean
3.89
1.69
4.62
3.29
Annual
In Table 2, the mean annual and irrigation period reference evapotranspiration of the study area under
RCP4.5 projected by the climate models CanESM2, GFDL-ESM2M, HadGEM2-ES and IPSLCM5A-LR for the period of climate change 2081-2100 and for the baseline period (1981-2000), are
depicted. It can be noted that all climate models predict an increase of mean annual reference
evapotranspiration during the period 2081-2100 compared to the historical period. CanESM2 projects
a rise in annual ETo by 181 mm, GFDL-ESM2M 60 mm, HadGEM2-ES 262 mm and IPSL-CM5ALR 195 mm. HadGEM2-ES gives the highest increase in annual ETo of 25% while GFDL-ESM2M
predicts the lowest increase of 6%. CanESM2 and IPSL-CM5A-LR give moderate values of ETo
increase of 17% and 18%, respectively. As regards to reference evapotranspiration of the irrigation
period, the increase will be by 123 mm, 32 mm, 182 mm and 113 mm according to CanESM2, GFDLESM2M, HadGEM2-ES and IPSL-CM5A-LR models, respectively. HadGEM2-ES projects the
highest increase in ETo of the irrigation period of 27% whereas GFDL-ESM2M predicts the lowest
increase of 5%. CanESM2 and IPSL-CM5A-LR models give moderate values of increase (18% and
17%).
In Figure 3 the box plots of a) annual and b) irrigation period reference evapotranspiration change
(%) for climate change period in relation to baseline period based on the four climate models are
presented. The greatest mean and maximum value is observed under HadGEM2-ES whereas the
lowest under GFDL-ESM2M model for both annual and irrigation period. CanESM2 and IPSLCM5A-LR have similar mean values indicating that the above models show similar rise in future
annual and irrigation period reference evapotranspiration for 2081-2100 in relation to the historical
period. All models show quite similar spread in the distribution of their values in mean annual ETo.
Additionally, regarding ETo for the irrigation period, it can be noted that the largest spread in
distribution is observed for GFDL-ESM2M and the lowest for HadGEM2-ES while the rest climate
models show similar spread.
683
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
Mean Annual Temperature
Tmean change (oC)
6,8
5,8
4,8
3,8
2,8
1,8
0,8
-0,2
CanESM2
GFDL-ESM2M
Annual Tmean
HadGEM2-ES IPSL-CM5A-LR
(oC)
Mean Irrigation Period Temperature
Tmean change (oC)
6,8
5,8
4,8
3,8
2,8
1,8
0,8
-0,2
CanESM2
GFDL-ESM2M
HadGEM2-ES IPSL-CM5A-LR
Irrigation period Tmean (oC)
Figure 2: Box plots of mean a) annual and b) irrigation period temperature change (oC) of
Agios Mamas according to CanESM2, GFDL-ESM2M, HadGEM2-ES and IPSL-CM5A-LR
under RCP 4.5 during 2081-2100 relative to 1981-2000
The box plots of reference evapotranspiration change (Figure 3) have similar pattern with those of
temperature change (Figure 2) for both annual and irrigation period. The greatest increases are
recorded for HadGEM2-ES while the lowest under GFDL-ESM2M for both ETo and temperature.
Additionally, CanESM2 and IPSL-CM5A-LR models show moderate values of increase in ETo as
well as in temperature. The above confirm that the rise in reference evapotranspiration is controlled
by the increase of temperature in the future. With higher temperatures, the water-holding capacity of
the atmosphere increases resulting in reference evaporation increase. Additionally, CO2 enrichment
of the atmosphere can increase plant growth, resulting in increased leaf area, and thus increased
transpiration. There were differences in future projections of temperature and ETo among the selected
climate models, which seem to not be related only with the model resolution. Thus, a number of
models with different spatial and meteorological characteristics should be used for increasing the
reliability of the results.
684
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 2: Differences in mean annual and irrigation period reference evapotranspiration (mm)
of Agios Mamas according to CanESM2, GFDL-ESM2M, HadGEM2-ES and IPSL-CM5ALR under RCP 4.5 during 2081-2100 in relation to 1981-2000
Historical
Ag. Mamas
1981-2000
Mean Reference Evapotranspiration (mm)
RCP4.5 2081-2100
Climate Models
CanESM2 GFDL-ESM2M HadGEM2-ES IPSL-CM5A-LR
1066
ΔETo
%
1247
181
17
1126
60
6
1328
262
25
1261
195
18
666
Irrigation
ΔETo
period
%
789
123
18
698
32
5
848
182
27
779
113
17
Annual
Mean Annual Reference Evapotranspiration
ETo change (%)
38
29
20
11
2
-7
CanESM2
GFDL-ESM2M
HadGEM2-ES IPSL-CM5A-LR
a) Annual ETo (%)
Mean Irrigation Period Reference Evapotranspiration
ETo change (%)
38
29
20
11
2
-7
CanESM2
GFDL-ESM2M
HadGEM2-ES IPSL-CM5A-LR
b) Irrigation period ETo (%)
Figure 3: Box plots of a) annual and b) irrigation period reference evapotranspiration change
(%) of Agios Mamas according to CanESM2, GFDL-ESM2M, HadGEM2-ES and IPSLCM5A-LR under RCP 4.5 during 2081-2100 relative to 1981-2000
685
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
4.
CONCLUSIONS
In this study, the effects of climate change on the reference evapotranspiration (ETo) of Agios Mamas
in Northern Greece for the end of the 21st century (2081-2100), were assessed. The climate change
projections were done according to CanESM2, GFDL-ESM2M, HadGEM2-ES and IPSL-CM5A-LR
Earth System Models under RCP4.5 climate change scenario. The results suggested that mean annual
temperature is projected to increase in 2081-2100 compared to 1981-2000. The rise in mean annual
temperature will, in turn impact on mean annual reference evapotranspiration which will increase
from 6% to 25% considering the climate model used. During the irrigation period, the rise in
temperature will be slightly greater compared to annual while the increase is projected to be similar
regarding ETo, ranging from 5% to 27%. There were differences in temperature and reference
evapotranspiration increase among the four climate models showing great variation for the ensemble
synthetic time series. This indicates that the use of a number of climate models is required in climate
change studies for increasing the reliability of the future projections. The changes in reference
evapotranspiration in response to the future climate change will have major impacts on the
agricultural sector. As a result, the estimation of reference evapotranspiration in climate change
research is critical in the development of adaptation strategies regarding irrigation planning and water
resources management.
References
1. Allen R.G., L.S. Pereira, D. Raes and M. Smith. (1998). ‘Crop evapotranspiration guidelines for
computing crop water requirements’. FAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper, No. 56. Rome, Italy.
2. Arora V.K., J.F. Scinocca, G.J. Boer, J.R. Christian, K.L., Denman, G.M. Flato, V.V. Kharin,
W.G. Lee and W.J. Merryfield. (2011). ‘Carbon emission limits required to satisfy future
representative concentration pathways of greenhouse gases’. Geophysical Research Letters,
Vol. 38, L05805, doi:10.1029/2010GL046270.
3. Chen J. and F.P. Brissete. (2014). ‘Comparison of five stochastic weather generators in simulating
daily precipitation and temperature for the Loess Plateau of China’. International Journal of
Climatology, Vol. 34, pp. 3089-3105.
4. Dufresne J.-L., M.-A. Foujols, S. Denvil, A. Caubel, O. Marti, O. Aumont, Y. Balkanski, S.
Bekki, H. Bellenger, R. Benshila, S. Bony, L. Bopp, P. Braconnot, P. Brockmann, P. Cadule, F.
Cheruy, F. Codron, A Cozic, D. Cugnet, N. de Noblet, J.-P. Duvel, C. Ethé, L. Fairhead,
T. Fichefet, S. Flavoni, P. Friedlingstein, J.-Y Grandpeix, L. Guez, E. Guilyardi,
D. Hauglustaine, F. Hourdin, A. Idelkadi, J. Ghattas, S. Joussaume, M. Kageyama, G. Krinner,
S. Labetoulle, A. Lahellec, M.-P. Lefebvre, F. Lefevre, C. Levy, Z.X. Li, J. Lloyd, F. Lott, G.
Madec, M. Mancip, M. Marchand, S. Masson, Y. Meurdesoif, J. Mignot, I. Musat, S. Parouty,
J. Polcher, C. Rio, M. Schulz, D. Swingedouw, S. Szopa, C. Talandier, P. Terray, N. Viony and
N. Vuichard. (2013). ‘Climate change projections using the IPSL-CM5 Earth System Model:
from CMIP3 to CMIP5’. Climate Dynamics, Vol. 40, pp. 2123-2165.
5. Dunne J.P., J.G. John, E. Shevliakova, R.J. Stouffer, J.P. Krasting, S.L. Malyshev, P.C.D. Milly,
L.T. Sentman, A.J. Adcroft, W. Cooke, K.A. Dunne, S.M. Griffies, R.W. Hallberg, M.J. Harrison,
H. Levy, A.T. Wittenberg, P.J. Phillips and N. Zadeh. (2013). ‘GFDL’s ESM2 Global Coupled
Climate - Carbon Earth System Models. Part II: Carbon system formulation and baseline
simulation characteristics’. Journal of Climate, Vol. 26, pp. 2247-2267.
6. Georgiou P.E. and D.K. Karpouzos. (2017). ‘Optimal irrigation water management for adaptation
to climate change’. International Journal of Sustainable Agricultural Management and
Informatics, Vol. 3(4), pp. 271-285.
7. Guo D., S. Westra and H.R. Maier. (2017). ‘Sensitivity of reference evapotranspiration to changes
in climate variables for different Australian climatic zones’. Hydrology and Earth System
Sciences, Vol. 421, pp. 2107-2126.
686
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
8. IPCC. (2008). Climate Change and Water. In B.C. Bates, Z.W. Kundzewicz, S. Wu and J.P.
Palutikof (eds.), Technical paper if the Intergovernmental Panel on climate change. IPCC
Secretariat, Geneva, Switzerland.
9. IPCC. (2013). Climate Change 2013: The physical science basis. In T.F. Stocker, D. Qin, G.-K.
Plattner, M. Tignor, S.K. Allen, J. Boschung, A. Nauels, Y. Xia, V. Bex and P.M. Midgley (eds.),
Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel
on Climate Change. Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA.
10. Kingston G., M.C. Todd, R.G. Taylor, J.R. Thompson and N.W. Amell. (2009). ‘Uncertainty in
the estimation of reference evapotranspiration under climate change’. Geophysical Research
Letters, Vol. 36, L20403, doi:10.1029/ 2009GL040267.
11. Koukouli P., P. Georgiou and D. Karpouzos. (2018). ‘Assessing the hydrological effect of climate
change on water balance of a River Basin in Northern Greece’. International Journal of
Agricultural and Environmental Information Systems (Accepted for publication-in press).
12. Martin G.M., N. Bellouin, W.J. Collins, I.D. Culverwell, P.R. Halloran, S.C. Hardiman, T.J.
Hinton, C.D. Jones, R.E. McDonald, A.J. McLaren, F.M. O'Connor, M.J. Roberts, J.M.
Rodriguez, S. Woodward, M.J. Best, M.E. Brooks, A.R. Brown, N. Butchart, C. Dearden, S.H.
Derbyshire, I. Dharssi, M. Doutriaux-Boucher, J.M. Edwards, P. D. Falloon, N. Gedney, L.J.
Gray, H.T. Hewitt, M. Hobson, M.R. Huddleston, J. Hughes, S. Ineson, W.J. Ingram, P.M. James,
T.C. Johns, C.E. Johnson, A. Jones, C.P. Jones, M.M. Joshi, A.B. Keen, S. Liddicoat, A.P. Lock,
A.V. Maidens, J.C. Manners, S.F. Milton, J.G.L. Rae, J.K. Ridley, A. Sellar, C.A. Senior, I.J.
Totterdell, A. Verhoef, P.L. Vidale and A. Wiltshire. (2011). ‘The HadGEM2 family of Met
Office Unified Model climate configurations’. Geoscientific Model Development, Vol. 4, pp.
723-757.
13. McMahon T.A., M.C. Peel, L. Lowe, R. Srikanthan and T.R. McVicar. (2013). ‘Estimating actual,
potential reference crop and pan evaporationusing tandard meteorological data: a pragmatic
synthesis’. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, Vol. 17, pp. 1331-1363.
14. Stöckle C.O. and R.L. Nelson. (1999). ClimGen: A weather generator program. Biological
Systems Engineering Department, Washington State University, Pullman, WA.
15. van Vuuren D.P., J. Edmonds, M. Kainuma, K. Riahi, A. Thomson, K. Hibbard, G.C. Hurtt, T.
Kram, V. Krey, J.-F. Lamarque, T. Masui, M. Meinshausen, N. Nakicenovic, S.J. Smith and S.K.
Rose. (2011). ‘The representative concentration pathways: an overview’. Climatic Change, Vol.
109, pp. 5-31.
687
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
ΑSSESSING THE TEMPERATURE CHANGES OVER EUROPE
FOR THE 21ST CENTURY USING A REGIONAL CLIMATE
MODEL
I. Sofiadis1*, E. Katragkou1, V. Pavlidis1, S. Kartsios1, K. Tsigaridis2, Μ. Karypidou1,
D. Melas3
1
Department of Meteorology and Climatology,
School of Geology, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Greece,
2
NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies, New York, NY 10025, USA
3
Laboratory of Atmospheric Physics, School of Physics, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki,
54124 Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: sofiadis@geo.auth.gr
Abstract
In the framework of the 7th FP project REQUA-“Regional climate-air quality interactions”, we
assessed climate change for the 21st century over Europe. Five regional climate modelling systems
from the Euro-CORDEX initiative were used, covering the time period from 1986 to 2100 with a
spatial resolution of 50 Km. The selected future scenario was the Representative Concentration
Pathway RCP8.5. The regional climate model simulations were forced by different Global Climate
Models and compared to available observational data, to estimate the models’ biases. The analysis
highlights the ability of regional climate models to properly simulate the European climate as well as
an expected average temperature increase for Europe until the end of the 21st century. Temperature
trends are estimated to be higher in southern Europe mainly in the summer. Geospatial information
on climate change is extremely useful for studies focusing on the impact of climate change on
different sectors including protection of the environment, adaptation and mitigation policies.
Keywords: Climate models, Euro-CORDEX, Climate projections, Climate change
1.
INTRODUCTION
Climate change has become one of the most urgent challenges for today’s society. According to
WMO (Weather Meteorological Organization), climate change refers to a statistically significant
variation in either the mean state of the climate or in its variability, persisting for an extended period
(typically decades or longer). Climate change may be due to natural internal processes or external
forcings, or to persistent anthropogenic changes in the composition of the atmosphere or in land use.
Climate models (numerical representations of the climate system) play a catalytic role in studying
and simulating climate. They solve extremely complex equations on a grid of spatial discrete points
with various arithmetic methods (Neelin, 2010). In essence, the result of calculations for a field on a
grid point refers to the mean value of the field in the grid box. Modern climatic models, thanks to the
strengthening of supercomputers, incorporate in their equations many natural processes that take
place between the elements of the climate system (IPCC, 2014).
Climate models are distinguished in global and regional depending on whether they cover the entire
Earth or only a limited area. Global models are characterized by low spatial resolution (the horizontal
distance between the grid points) and simulate only large scale spatial phenomena (Hong et al., 2014).
The need for study of regional climate has led scientists to the dynamic downscaling of global models.
688
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
In dynamic downscaling, the grid with the highest spatial resolution is placed in the grid with lowest
resolution and driven by it at its lateral boundaries (Laprise, 2008). Furthermore, regional climate
models due to their higher spatial resolution (~11km at continental level), are capable of simulating
natural processes with higher accuracy, as opposed to global models (Giorgi et al., 2015). However,
there are natural processes characterized by a very small spatial scale (e.g convection) and their
assessment through regional models is made using empirical formulas called parameterizations
(IPCC, 2014).
Τhe assessment of the future climate through climate models (climate projection) requires the choice
of a climate scenario. According to IPCC, as climate scenario is called a plausible and often simplified
representation of the future climate, based on an internally consistent set of climatological
relationships that has been constructed for explicit use in investigating the potential consequences of
anthropogenic climate change, often serving as input to impact models. Τhe most pessimistic scenario
of the newest version of IPCC scenarios is RCP8.5 which, among other things, estimates that the
world’s population will almost double and humanity will rely mainly on fossil fuels by the end of the
21st century (Riahi et al., 2007).
Because of the many uncertainties that arise from the different scenarios, the parameterizations, the
model structures as well as the physical climate variability, there is a need for coordination to study
the regional climate. Euro-CORDEX initiative (www.euro-cordex.net) includes a suite of
experiments and provides the scientific community with a controlled framework for models’
evaluation and regional climate projections.
Five regional climate models (CCLM4, RCA4, REMO2009, RACMO22E, ALADIN53) with
different configurations and physical parameterizations are implemented in this work, all performed
within the framework of Euro-CORDEX. The aim of this study is to evaluate the above regional
climate models as to their credibility and to identify in which regions and to what extent is there a
strong signal of the temperature change by the end of the century.
2.
DATA&METHODOLOGY
Mean surface temperature is analyzed for the time period 1986-2100. The simulations cover the EuroCORDEX domain (Figure 1) with a spatial resolution of 50 km. All simulations use the same
Representation Concentration Scenario (RCP8.5) for the climate projection (2006-2099) but driven
by different Global Circulation Model (GCM) (Table 1).
Figure 1: Euro-CORDEX domain.
689
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
Table 3: In the first column (left) are presented the Regional Climate Models (RCMs) used in
this study. In the middle column are the Institutes where simulations performed and in the
right column are the Global Circulation Models (GCMs) forcing the RCMs.
RCM
Institute
GCM
RCA4
Meteo-France/ National Center for Meteorological
Research
CCCMa-CanESM2
REMO2009
Helmholtz-Zentrum Geesthacht, Climate Service
Center, Max Planck Institute for Meteorology
MPI-M-MPI-ESM-MR
ALADIN53
Meteo-France/ National Center for Meteorological
Research
CNRM-CERFACS-CNRMCM5
RACMOΕ22
Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute, De Bilt,
The Netherlands
ICHEC-EC-EARTH
CCLM4
Climate Limited-area Modelling Community (CLMCommunity)
MPI-M-MPI-ESM-LR
In order to evaluate models’ simulations, we use E-OBS version 15.0 observational data set
(www.ecad.eu) which are available on a 50km rotated pole grid in order to have almost equal areas
over Europe. The RCM grid was interpolated to the EOBS grid, using the nearest neighbor method.
2.1 Methodology
The temporal analysis of surface temperature was carried out over three periods, corresponding to the
IPCC 5th Report (AR5) reporting periods: 1986-2005, 2046-2065 and 2080-2099, considering 19862005 as reference period. Also, the spatial analysis was carried out in eight sub-areas (Figure 2),
corresponding to the study areas of the PRUDENCE program.(Christensen et al., 2007).
Figure 2: The PRUDENCE sub-areas.
The temperature field was averaged and analyzed on a seasonal base. The seasons were averaged
from June to August (JJA) and December to February (DJF).
In order to test the statistical significance of differences between the two future periods and the
reference period, we calculate the quantity t (paired t-test):
𝑠2
t= (x-y) / ( )
(1)
𝑛
690
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
where x and y are the arithmetic means of the n=20 seasonal values, s is the standard deviation of the
n values. Differences are deemed significantly different at the 95% level if t >2.03.
Mann-Kendall is a non-parametric test which used so as to test if there is monotonic trend of average
seasonal anomalies of temperature of the period 2006-2099 comparing to reference period, at 95%
significance level. (Mann, 1945).
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The mean winter (DJF) and summer (JJA) temperature bias (Models minus EOBS) for the period
1986-2005 is presented in Figure 2. Their evaluation with EOBS indicates the ability of models to
reproduce the observed climatology. The ensemble mean of Euro-CORDEX models is systematically
colder than EOBS over the whole European domain both in summer and winter. Specifically, in
winter the bias is small and about the same for all areas (Table 2). In the summer, all areas are
characterized by greater bias values, mainly Alps, Scandinavia and France (average bias is -1.8oC, 1.6oC and -1.5oC respectively). Previous evaluation studies (Pavlidis 2015, Sofiadis 2017) have
shown that these regional climate simulations systematically underestimate the surface temperature
over the whole European domain in all seasons. According to Boberg and Christensen (2012), the
uncertainties presented by climate models for the present climate are linked with future uncertainties,
so it’s very important to evaluate climate models and identify areas with large bias in order to better
interpret climate projections.
Figure 3: Temperature winter (left) and summer (right) bias (Ensemble mean of models
minus EOBS) for the period 1986-2005. Units in degrees Celsius.
Then, the mean seasonal temperature anomalies over the period 2006–2100, relative to the period
1986–2005, have been calculated based on ensemble mean of Euro-CORDEX models output. The
time series of mean seasonal temperature anomalies at Scandinavia and Mediterranean regions are
shown in Figure 4. The temperature changes are evident, and the rates of change per decade for the
other PRUDENCE sub-areas are indicated in Table 3. All trends are statistically significant at the
95% confidence level. The temperature trends typically vary from 0.26° to 0.53°C per decade in
winter and from 0.39oC to 0.65oC in summer. The largest increases appear in regions of North-East
Europe for the winter and in South Europe for the summer. Our findings are consistent with those of
Sofiadis (2017), who presented recent warming trends and the respective models spread over these
regions.
691
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
Table 2: Average temperature winter and summer bias (Ensemble mean of models minus
EOBS) for the period 1986-2005. Units in degrees Celsius.
Subregions
AL
SC
IP
BI
FR
MD
EA
ME
Temperature Bias (°C)
Winter
Summer
-0.6
-1.8
-0.5
-1.6
-0.8
-1.2
-0.2
-0.7
-0.1
-1.5
-0.1
-0.5
-0.2
-0.6
-0.1
-1.1
Figure 4: Time series of mean seasonal (winter and summer) temperature anomalies of the
period 2006-2100 relative to the reference period (1986–2005) at Scandinavia and
Mediterranean regions. The red line shows the 5-year running average.
692
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 3: Linear trends (in °C/decade) of the mean seasonal temperature in PRUDENCE subareas for the period 2006-2100, relative to the reference period (1986–2005). All trends are
statistically significant at 95% level.
Subregions
AL
IP
BI
FR
EA
ME
Temperature Trend (°C/decade)
Winter
Summer
0.45
0.59
0.34
0.65
0.26
0.39
0.35
0.58
0.53
0.46
0.39
0.47
In Figure 5 we calculate the differences in mean seasonal temperature between the two future periods
(2046-2065 and 2080-2099) and the reference period 1986-2005, where the gradual rise is evident by
the end of the century. However, the spatial distribution of temperature changes is different for winter
and summer. In winter, there is a gradual increase from southwest to northeast Europe, while in the
summer larger differences are projected in the Mediterranean basin and smaller in Northern Europe.
This could be attributed to the ability of atmospheric circulation and land surface processes to
modulate the European climate. (Wang et al., 2014)
Figure 5: Projected changes of mean seasonal temperature for the period 2046–2065 (left) and
2080-2099 (right), compared to 1986–2005. All changes are statistically significant at 95%
confidence level.
4.
CONCLUSION
In this work we study the ensemble mean of five regional climate simulations all performed within
the Euro-CORDEX framework. The simulations cover the European domain with a resolution of 50
km for the period 1986-2099. All models were driven by different Global Circulation Models (GCMs)
and used different configurations. The ensemble mean of models is colder than the EOBS climatology
both in summer and winter for the whole domain, with bias to be slightly higher in the summer in
most areas. Furthermore, gradual temperature rise is estimated in Europe until the end of the century.
Specifically, higher temperature increase is expected in southern regions (Mediterranean, Iberian
693
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
Peninsula) in summer season. Our future work will focus on the study of other variables such as soil
temperature and precipitation to better interpret climate variation in Europe.
Acknowledgements
The work is supported by EU 7th Framework Programme Marie Curie Actions IRSES project:
REQUA (PIRSES-GA-2013-612671). The authors would like to thank Earth System Grid Federation
(ESGF) for providing Euro-CORDEX models output. We also acknowledge the technical support of
AUTH-Scientific Computing Center for providing scientific software and storage space, making this
study possible.
References
1. Neelin D. (2010) “Climate Change and Climate Modeling”, Cambridge University Press.
2. IPCC (2014) Synthesis Report– “Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Fifth
Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change”, International Panel for
Climate Change (IPCC).
3. Hong S.Y. and Kanamitsu M. (2014) ‘Dynamical downscaling: Fundamental issues from an NWP
point of view and recommendations’, Asia-Pacific Journal of Atmospheric Sciences, Vol.50,
pp.83-104.
4. Laprise R. (2008) ‘Regional climate modelling’, Journal of Computational Physics, Vol. 227,
pp. 3641-3666
5. Giorgi F. and Gutowski W. (2015) ‘Regional Dynamical Downscaling and the CORDEX
Initiative’, Annual Review of Environment and Resources, Vol.40, pp.467-490
6. Riahi K., Grubler A., Nakicenovic N. (2007) ‘Scenarios of long-term socio-economic and
environmental development under climate stabilization’, Technological Forecasting and Social
Change, Vol.74, pp.887-935
7. Christensen J. and Christensen O. (2007) ‘A summary of the PRUDENCE model projections of
changes in European climate by the end of this century’, Climate Change, Vol.81, pp7-30
8. Mann H. (1945) ‘Nonparametric Tests Against Trend’, Econometrica, Vol.13, pp.245
9. Pavlidis V. (2015) ‘Estimation of errors and uncertainties of radiation and cloudiness in regional
scale climate simulations’, MSc. thesis, Aristotle University, Thessaloniki.
10. Sofiadis I. (2017) ‘Study of climate change over Europe for the 21st century using a regional
climate simulation driven by the scenario RCP 8.5’, MSc. thesis, Aristotle University,
Thessaloniki.
11. Boberg F. and Christensen J. (2012) ‘Overestimation of Mediterranean summer temperature
projections due to model deficiencies’, Nature Climate Change, Vol. 2, pp.433-436
12. Wang G, Dolman A. Alessandri A. (2011), “A summer climate regime over Europe modulated
by the North Atlantic Oscillation”, Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, Vol. 15, pp.57-64
694
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS ON THE COASTAL SEA LEVEL
EXTREMES OF THE EAST-CENTRAL MEDITERRANEAN SEA
C. Makris*, P. Galiatsatou, Y. Androulidakis, K. Kombiadou, V. Baltikas, Y.
Krestenitis and P. Prinos
Division of Hydraulics & Environmental Engineering, Department of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th.,
GR- 54124, Thessaloniki, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: cmakris@civil.auth.gr, tel: (+30) 2310 995708
Abstract
Extreme events of sea level elevation, due to severe weather conditions, pose great threats to lowland coastal areas by extended inundation hazards. The latter take the form of short- to mid-term
flooding due to wave- and storm-induced sea level elevation and run-up on the coast. In this paper,
the impact of the combined effect of extreme storm surges and extreme wave set-up in nearshore
areas is investigated. The framework is set by future and historic climate change scenarios during a
period of 150 years (1951–2100) that affect the occurrence frequency and magnitudes of total (surgeand wave-induced) sea level extremes in the eastern Mediterranean, focusing on the coastal zones of
Greece. Inter-annual and multi-decadal patterns, trends and return levels of storm surge and wave setup extremes are calculated based on non-stationary bivariate statistical analysis with copula functions
of the Generalized Extreme Value distribution. The numerical data of storm surge- and wave-induced
sea levels are derived from post-processing of simulation results by GreCSS and SWAN models,
respectively, in order to transfer validated numerical data from offshore regions towards the shoreline
of selected areas prone to coastal flooding. An increase and a consequent attenuation of storminess
and inter-annual extremes of total sea level on the coast is estimated during the 1st and 2nd half of the
21st century, respectively. Different morphological characteristics of regional coastal zones in the
Aegean Sea are found to influence variability of sea level extremes.
Keywords: Storm surge, Wave set-up, Extremes, Mediterranean Sea, Climate change impact
1.
INTRODUCTION
Harsh weather conditions can cause extreme events of sea level elevation (SLE) in the marine
environment possibly leading to extended coastal flooding that has severe environmental and societal
impacts, such as loss of land and damages to onshore infrastructure, coastal structures and ports. In
the framework of a constantly changing climate with extreme SLE events of higher frequency and
intensity, both augmented by the estimated mean sea level (MSL) rise, the exposure and vulnerability
of society, infrastructure and the environment of coastal areas to severe damages are expected to
increase. The effect of climate change on the coastal zones of the Mediterranean and other Seas
around Europe has been studied in the past (Benetazzo et al., 2012; Conte and Lionello, 2013; Kvočka
et al., 2016; Vousdoukas et al., 2016; Satta et al., 2017; Vibilić et al., 2017), mostly focusing on the
variability and long-term trends in the evolution patterns of MSL rise, and the extremes of storm
surge events and waves, yet in a separative approach for the several hydraulic features contributing
in total SLE.
Our former work has been centered on proper implementation of extremal analysis for hydraulic
features in the marine environment (Galiatsatou, 2007; Galiatsatou and Prinos, 2008, 2014, 2015;
695
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
Galiatsatou et al., 2016) and validated hydrodynamic modeling of storm surges and waves in coastal
zones (Krestenitis et al., 2014, 2015; Androulidakis et al., 2015; Makris et al., 2015, 2016). In the
aforementioned studies, the impacts of climate change on the extremes of storm surges and waves
have been investigated (taking into account the MSL rise) in selected areas of the Mediterranean,
Aegean and Ionian Seas, detecting a considerable increase in the extreme wave/surge climate
especially in the 1st half of the 21st century. Yet, former literature has focused on analysis of SLE
extremes treating storm surge and severe wave events separately. Only recently Feng et al. (2018)
and Galiatsatou et al. (2017, 2018) have made efforts to study storm flood-prone coastal areas based
on coupled surge-wave simulations and recent advances in extreme analysis with copula functions
(Wahl et al., 2012; Bender et al., 2014), respectively. In the present work, a non-stationary
multivariate approach has been developed and implemented to assess design total water levels at the
shoreline of selected Greek coastal areas in the Aegean Sea under the effects of climate change.
2.
METHODOLOGY
2.1 Methodological approach and topographical characteristics of the study area
The methods and techniques of the present work have been implemented to the annual maxima of
random wave characteristics (i.e. significant wave height Hs and corresponding peak spectral period
Tp) in open seas, nearshore wave-induced sea level ηw, and associated SLE values due to storm surges
at selected locations of the east central Mediterranean (Aegean Sea). Three representative high floodrisk study areas (Makris et al., 2016; Galiatsatou et al., 2017, 2018) have been selected (Figure 1);
Area 1 in the North Aegean containing the coastal zone of Alexandroupolis and part of the Thracian
Sea, Area 2 in the Central Aegean containing the coast of Eresos in southern Lesvos Island, and Area
3 in the South Aegean containing a northern Crete coastal area of Heraklion. The selection of
representative group of points was based on proper statistical homogeneity measures for high
quantiles of the Hosking and Wallis type (Makris et al. 2016; Galiatsatou et al., 2017, 2018) assessed
for annual maxima of Hs and SLE for a control period (1951-2000), related to its counterpart 50-year
future periods in 2001-2100. High-wave events exceeding appropriately defined thresholds of Hs
(1.5-2 m) were selected at grid points in the study area, for durations >6 hrs, having onshore main
wave directions towards respective shorelines. Tp values were associated to the high sea states
corresponding to a period of 150 years (1951-2100). The choice of SLE data was based on a 5-day
time-window of storm surge-driven sea levels, covering the time of corresponding records of Hs
maxima (by 2.5 days bilaterally), indicated in order to estimate the largest possible SLE response to
the particular storm events (with maximum duration of 120 hrs in the Mediterranean basin; Conte and
Lionello, 2013; Makris et al., 2016).
2.2 Numerical models and data for storm surges and waves
The raw data of marine parameters in the present work are drawn from climatic-type numerical
simulations to estimate the (offshore) irregular wave characteristics (Hs, Tp and energy wave spectrum
features) from SWAN model implementations (Kapelonis et al., 2015; Makris et al., 2016), and SLE
due to storm surges from 2-DH high-resolution simulations with MeCSS and GreCSS hydrodynamic
models (Krestenitis et al. 2014; Androulidakis et al. 2015; Makris et al. 2015, 2016). The modelled
datasets were validated and bias-corrected by in situ measurements, satellite altimetry and modeled
forecasts, and covered a 150-year period (1951-2100), using atmospheric forcing of climatic data,
produced by a dynamically downscaled simulation with RegCM3 model (Tolika et al., 2015; Vagenas
et al., 2017), under 20C3M historical and SRES-A1B future scenarios for green-house gas emissions
(Makris et al., 2016; Vagenas et al., 2017).
696
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: Left graph: Selected study areas of the Aegean Sea; 1: Alexandroupolis coastal area
in the Thracian Sea (North Aegean), 2: Eresos coastal area in southern Lesvos Island (Central
Aegean), 3: Heraklion coastal area in the Cretan Sea (South Aegean). Right graph: Marine
map of the study area’s bathymetry (m) for the 1/20° (~5 Km) resolution computational
domain
2.3 Modelling approach for total sea level on the coast
The calculation method of the coastal hazard under investigation, i.e. the total (flood) water level at
the shoreline and on the coast, is concisely presented in the following (detailed entire approach by
Galiatsatou et al., 2018), by implementing a semi-analytic modelling approach for the derivation of
the nearshore (surf/swash zone) wave-induced sea levels (Goda, 2000). In order to correctly calculate
the total sea level in coastal areas, and specifically inside the surf zone and at the shoreline, we need
to transfer the spatially large-scale modelled (wave and storm surge) data from relatively deep (or
intermediate) waters in the open sea to nearshore shallow water areas and finally the shoreline
boundary. The storm surge is a huge-scale phenomenon (order of several Km) and coastal SLE values
were therefore adequately provided by dynamically downscaled numerical simulations in climatic
mode (150 years, 1/20° resolution; Makris et al., 2015, 2016). Nevertheless, the wave-induced sea
level in nearshore areas and close to the shoreline concerns finer scale effects due to irregular wave
breaking. Nonetheless, numerical simulations in climatic mode (150 years) with a 2-DH wave model
of very fine spatial resolution is still very arduous in terms of computational resources and available
detail in digital bathymetric and terrain models. Therefore, in the present work, we used the offshore
SWAN model results of Makris et al. (2016). Consequently we calculated the transformation of
extreme random wave characteristics (Hs, Tp, main wave direction) towards the shoreline with a semianalytical iterative model for irregular wave trains (Makris and Krestenitis, 2009), which takes into
account the crude variations of rather simple bathymetries (parallel depth-contours, nearly straight
coastlines and uniform slopes) crossing areas of nearshore intermediate to shallow waters and surf
zone Hs constraints for irregular wave breaking. Furthermore the wave-induced set-up ηsu was
calculated (Goda 2000), as it represents the short- to mid-term SLE in the coastal zone, due to random
wave action in shallow waters and secondary processes due to irregular wave breaking. We also added
another smaller component of SLE, i.e. the surf beat ηsb, associated to wave groups approaching
coastal zones in discrete high- and low-frequency bands. Conclusively, we estimated the (potential)
total wave-induced sea level ηw=ηsu+ηsb nearshore and on the shoreline, being qualitatively similar to
storm surge SLE, rendering it a fitting counterpart in a bivariate analysis of sea level values.
697
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
Transformation of random wave characteristics from open seas to shallow coastal waters was based
on spectral wave theory and analytic relations of Goda (2000) taking into account irregular wave
propagation, refraction, shoaling, and energy dissipation due to breaking and bottom friction. The
significant wave height Hs in arbitrary depth d is given by the relation Hs=krˊ·ksˊ·Hs,o (where o index
corresponds to deep-water offshore values). For areas with rather parallel depth-contours, the
effective spectral refraction and shoaling coefficients, krˊ and ksˊ, for irregular waves are given by:
N
2
kr E ij kr ij , analytically
i 1 j 1
kr f kr , h Lo,p , ap,o , smax , from graphs
d
ks ks 30 30
d
ks ks , d30 d
2/7
ks
, d50 d d30
(1)
ks B 0, d d50
(2)
where kr(f,θ) is the linear refraction coefficient of monochromatic wave components with frequency
f and propagation direction θ, (ΔE)ij are the components of relative wave energy with ith discrete
frequency and jth angle of incidence for discrete spectral bands, Lo,p is the deep water wavelength
corresponding to Tp. Hs,b (depth-limited breaker height) and the rest parameters are (Goda, 2000):
d30
Lo,p
2
2 Hs,o
ks 30 ,
30 Lo,p
d
C50 ks 50 50
L
o ,p
32
d50
Lo,p
2
2 Hs,o
ks 50 , B
50 Lo,p
ks 50 2 Hs,o
Lo,p 2 3
2 3
d
,
2 Hs,o Lo,p Lo,p
Lo,p
C50
2 Hs,o Lo,p d
32
(3)
π ds,b
d50
1 15 m 4 3
, Hs,b A Lo,p 1 exp 1.5
Lo,p
L
o,p
where A=0.12-0.18 is a shape parameter depending on the position of the broken wave inside the surf
zone, ds,b the incipient breaking depth of Hs,b, and m the bottom slope. Combining iteratively the
breaking model with the random wave transformation, we calculated an estimation of the wave setup evolution in the surf zone transverse to the coast, dη/dx (ηsu, ηsb exactly on the shoreline):
4 d Lp
2 db
d
1
d 1 2 1
3 2 8
Hs
, su
db
, sb
2
dx
1 3 8
16
d dx 8 2 sinh 4 d Lp
0.01 Hs,o
Hs,o
ds,b
1
Lo,p Hs,o
(4)
where γ=Hs,b/ds,b is the wave breaking index, Lp the local wavelength corresponding to Tp, and η the
local value of the sea level (mean water level) due to the random breaking-induced process of the
wave set-up in depth d. The estimation of the total (flood) water level at the shoreline ηt resulted from
the summation of all the SLE components: wave run-up R2% (contains the parameter ηsu), MSL rise
MSLR (due to ice melting, steric and mass addition components; Makris et al., 2016) the surf beat ηsb,
the storm surge-induced SLE, and the highest astronomical tide HAT (courtesy of Hellenic Navy
Hydrographic Service, https://www.hnhs.gr/en/):
t R MSLR sb SLH HAT
(5)
2%
where the wave run-up at the shoreline was based on the formulation of Stockdon et al. (2006):
1
Hs Lo 0.563 tan2 0.004
R2% 1.1 0.35 tan Hs Lo 2
2
1
2
698
1
and
R2% 0.043 Hs Lo 2 , for Ir 0.3
(6)
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
with tanβ the beach face slope and Ir=m/√(Hs,o/Lo,p) the Iribarren number (surf similarity parameter).
For dissipative beaches (Ir<0.3) the wave run-up is infragravity dominated.
2.4 Method for extreme value analysis
Extreme value analysis in the present paper is based on the Generalized Extreme Value (GEV)
distribution function, which includes location μ, scale σ>0, and shape ξ≠0 parameters, assessed by
Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE) or L-moments (LM) procedures (computed from linear
combinations of probability weighted moments), providing measures for shape of distributions or
data samples, such as location, dispersion, skewness and kurtosis. For data samples of {X1, X2, …,
Xn} arranged in increasing order, the sample probability weighted moments are:
bo
1 n
Xj ,
n j 1
br
1 n j 1 j 2 .... j r
Xj
n j r 1 n 1 n 2 .... n r
(7)
Extreme SLE values (e.g. 50-year return levels) exhibit non-stationarity, led by natural climatic
variability and climate change, viz. the El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) or North Atlantic
Oscillation (NAO) acting on different time scales. These can have significant impacts on SLE
extremes and occurrence frequency of coastal flooding events, thus assuming time-varying μ, σ, ξ:
-1/ t
x - t
x - t
, 1 t
G x exp - 1 t
0
t
t
(8)
The return level xp corresponding to a return period T=1/p is assessed in a non-stationary context as
a function of time, representing quantiles of the distribution function of SLE for every year:
xp t t -
σ t
- t
1- - log 1- p
ξ t
(9)
For the estimation of the parameters of the fitted distribution functions for all sea level variables, a
moving time-window of 40-years (Bender et al., 2014) was implemented in the present work, using
the LM method for each period. Their length was selected to be large enough to provide a good fit of
the marginal distributions of Hs, SLE, etc., as well as of their possible dependence structure. In a
multivariate framework (Galiatsatou et al., 2018), the non-stationary marginal distribution functions
for wave and storm surge variables has to be followed by a non-stationary joint probability analysis
of the dependent variables using bivariate copulas, which model dependence structure of e.g. Hs and
SLE, independently from their marginal distributions. To estimate the dependence structure of
nearshore sea level data within the non-stationarity framework, 40-year moving windows were also
applied to the bivariate data (Hs/Tp and Hs/SLE), utilizing Canonical Maximum Likelihood (CML)
without first specifying marginal distributions. This way, marginals are first transformed to pseudoobservations with uniform margins (Ui1, Ui2)T and then the dependence parameter a is estimated as:
n
aˆCML argmax a log c(Ui 1,Ui 2 ; a)
(10)
i 1
To select the appropriate copula function among five candidates (i.e. Clayton, Frank, Gumbel,
Student’s t, Gaussian), a parametric bootstrap procedure has been used (Galiatsatou et al., 2017,
2018). The test computes the Cramér – von Mises functional Sn, comparing the empirical copula of
the observations with a parametric estimate of the copula derived under the null hypothesis.
Approximate p-values for the test have been computed using the parametric bootstrap procedure.
Large values of Sn usually result in the rejection of the null hypothesis that the bivariate data result
from the tested copula function. After estimating the copula parameters, the statistic Sn and its
associated p-value were estimated for all moving windows and all candidate copula functions. For
699
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
each bivariate pair, the copula that resulted in p-values exceeding the 5% significance level for the
entire study period, was selected as the best-fit model and applied for joint exceedance probability
estimation. In case more than one of the fitted copulas satisfied the above condition, the selected
bivariate model was the one providing the lowest Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) values during
the largest part of the studied time interval (Galiatsatou et al., 2017, 2018).
3.
RESULTS
3.1 Numerically simulated data
Results for the 50-year patterns of Hs annual maxima in the study area are presented in Figure 2. A
projected increase of the Etesian winds at the central part of the Aegean (Tolika et al., 2015; Makris
et al., 2016) seems to be responsible for a small but traceable change in Hs,max patterns during 20012050. Intensification trends are mainly estimated to occur in the northern and central parts of the
Aegean Sea, with smaller values in the southern parts of the study area. An increase of Hs,max in the
Ionian and Libyan Seas during the 1st half of the 21st century and a consequent attenuation towards
2100, follows the climate change patterns of mean sea states (not shown here). During the low-energy
seasons, the entire study area reveals a consistent invariance. Figure 3 presents the spatial variability
of the averaged (for each of the three periods) values of the Storm Surge Index (SSI), which is a
representative annual maximum SLE, i.e. yearly mean of three maxima storm surge events
(Androulidakis et al., 2015; Makris et al., 2016), over each 50-year period (SSI50-yr). The highest SSI
values (>0.45 m) can be traced along the northern coasts of the Aegean Sea (coastal zone of
Alexandroupolis; Area 1). The SSI decreases from North to South, ranging from 0.32 to 0.38 m for
central parts of the Aegean, down to almost 0.3 m in the southern part of the study area (Crete), and
below 0.25 m for the northern African coasts. Lower values occur along the entire coastline in the 2nd
half of the 21st century, consistent with the estimated storm attenuation towards 2100. The change
signals between 2001-2050 and 1951-2000 range from −5.1 to +19.6 % locally. Storm surge-induced
SLE is estimated to generally decrease from the current to the future 50-year period, with changes of
−17.5 to +1.8 %.
Figure 2: Temporal mean of Hs annual maxima (m) during high- and low-energy (upper and
lower graphs, respectively) months over the study area for 50-year reference (left graphs),
current (central graphs) and future (right graphs) period time intervals
700
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3: Storm Surge Index SSI (m) along the coastline of the study area, time-averaged over
50-year reference, current and future periods (from left to right)
3.1
Extremes and return values of storm surges, waves, and total sea level on the coast
6.1
3.5
5.8
3.4
ηt (m)
Hs (m)
5.5
5.2
4.9
3.2
3.1
4.6
South Aegean
North Aegean
Central Aegean
4.3
4
1990
3.3
2010
2030
2050
3
2070
2.9
1990
2090
2010
2030
11.3
ηt (m)
Tp (s)
2090
2070
2090
2070
2090
3.4
10.7
10.4
3.3
3.2
10.1
3.1
9.8
3
2010
2030
2050
2070
2.9
1990
2090
2010
2030
2050
Time (year)
Time (year)
0.5
3.5
0.45
3.4
0.4
3.3
ηt (m)
Slh (m)
2070
3.5
11
9.5
1990
2050
Time (year)
Time (year)
0.35
3.2
3.1
0.3
0.25
1990
3
2010
2030
2050
2070
2090
2.9
1990
2010
2030
2050
Time (year)
Time (year)
Figure 4: Left panel: Time-dependent estimates of MLE wave event of Hs (top graph), Tp
(middle graph) and SLE (lower graph) in North Aegean (blue plots), central Aegean (green
plots), and South Aegean (red plots). Right panel: Time-dependent estimates of total water
level at the shoreline ηt at selected profiles in the coastal areas of Alexandroupolis (top),
Eresos bay (middle) and Heraklion (bottom). Solid lines represent MLE extracted without
parametric trends in marginals and dependence parameter of bivariate data; Dot-lines
consider all fitted trends
701
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
Figure 4 (left panel graphs) presents the time-dependent most likely design estimates of Hs, Tp and
SLE for the three studied areas in the Aegean Sera. In the North Aegean Sea, Hs MLE maxima
appeared in the 2nd half of the 21st century, around 2060, when including the parametric trends in the
marginal parameters and the dependence structure of the marine variables. Excluding parametric
trends, MLE Hs showed a bimodal behavior with pronounced peaks for short periods before and after
2050. MLEs of Tp (thus wave lengths too) are estimated to decrease rapidly during the last 30 years
of the 21st century. MLE of storm surge SLE presented more than 16% variations with maxima
probably occurring before the middle of the 21st century. In the Central Aegean Sea, MLEs of wave
features presented more intense variability (e.g. two distinct peaks for Hs, pronounced around 2020
and towards 2085, with Tp peaking around 2020, too). A progressive decrease of MLEs for storminduced SLE is obvious after a peak in 2010-2015. In the South Aegean Sea, the most likely design
events of Hs, Tp and SLE presented almost 22%, 10% and 37% variations, respectively. Wave heights
are estimated to decrease in the 2nd half of the 21st century, while wave periods are expected to
increase quite sharply in 2031-2070 and decrease rapidly during 2071-2100. SLE variation followed
the Tp trend peaking around 2060.
Figure 4 (right panel graphs) presents ηt in the 1990-2100 interval for three selected coastal profiles
having quite similar beach face slopes (7-8%) in each study area. Beach breadths varied from 14 to
40 m with berm heights from 2 to 3.2 m. In Alexandroupolis (Area 1) ηt varied more than 17% in the
21st century with highest values probably occurring in the 2nd half of the 21st century (i.e. around 2060
with parametric trends in marginal distributions and dependence structure of marine variables). The
variations of total water extremes presented similar trends to those of Hs MLEs. In Eresos (Area 2),
ηt variations exceeded 20% in 1990-2100 with maxima of total water level at the shoreline appearing
after 2020, presenting similar trends to all marine variables in the area, with wave parameters
(especially Tp) having a stronger influence on them. Finally, in the coastal area of Heraklion (Area 3)
ηt varies more than 12% in the 21st century, with its maxima around 2060 (or just after 2080 for no
parametric trends in marginals and dependence parameter of bivariate data). Total water levels on the
coast seem to most likely increase after 2030 maintain quite high values in the 2nd half of the 21st
century. Wave periods and storm surges are estimated to heavily influence ηt while high waves
appeared less correlated with it compared to central and northern Aegean areas.
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
In the present study, a novel approach has been developed and applied to selected Greek coastal areas
of the Aegean Sea to investigate the changes in the joint probabilities of extreme marine variables
(storm surge- and wave-induced sea level elevations) with time. The scope was to properly assess
design magnitudes of total (flood) water levels at the shoreline of extended, rather homogenous,
coastal areas, under the effect of climate change (based on a rather pessimistic future scenario). The
results of coupled, large-scale, numerical simulations of 2-DH hydrodynamic circulation for storm
surges and 3rd generation spectral wave transformation, are post-processed and blended with an
irregular wave transformation model for wave-induced sea level in nearshore areas and towards the
shoreline, leading to a novel, robust, analytic approach for extreme run-up and total flood water levels
on the coast (Galiatsatou et al., 2018), modeling dependence structure with the use of copulas. The
non-stationary analysis of the marginal distributions of all marine variables revealed statistically
significant trends in all parameters of the GEV at the selected areas of the Aegean Sea. Statistically
significant polynomial trends were also detected in the dependence structure of both offshore and
nearshore bivariate data. Variations in future trends for probable coastal flooding might be attributed
to geographical differentiations correlated to climate change signals of weather data (Makris et al.,
2016) and variations of marine variable (storm wave and surge characteristics) extremes (Galiatsatou
et al., 2017) in the area. The highest values of total water levels on the shoreline were calculated either
around 2020 or the middle of the 21st century, while the regime of long wave sea states was correlated
(significant influence) on extreme ηt estimates. The spatial differentiations of the patterns of extreme
marine variables, based on the intense topographical diversity of the Aegean archipelago, revealed
702
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
different results of former studies (Galiatsatou and Prinos, 2014, 2015; Makris et al., 2016), implying
the rise of extreme southerly winds in the Aegean Sea towards the middle of the 21st century and
beyond (corroborated by Vagenas et al., 2017). In the South Aegean, the Aeolian patterns show a
mild rise of northerly extreme winds after the 1st half of the 21st century, which might lead to an
increase of extreme peak periods and respective storm surges that are slightly intensified.
Nevertheless, due to the complex dense insular formation of the Cyclades, the random wave fields
are prone to diffraction, and this seems to cause a slight drop in the significant wave height extremes.
These findings (a 20- to 30-year transition of extreme sea level response to climate change on the
coastal zone) are different from former studies (Galiatsatou and Prinos, 2014, 2015; Makris et al.,
2016), which have shown clear patterns of storminess augmentation in the 1st half, and consequent
severe attenuation in the 2nd half of the 21st century. In the Central Aegean, a more coherent pattern
of sea level response to climate change signals can be traced, with the shift in the patterns of extreme
values of coastal marine parameters following climatic-type changes in northerly and southerly
extreme winds, giving rise in sea level extremes around 2020, which is in agreement with relevant
previous literature (involving analyses with A1B scenario). Therefore, the proposed novel approach
of extreme value calculation (incl. non-stationarity, time-dependence, bivariate analysis of extremes,
transferring sea-states from offshore to coastal areas) can produce significant alterations on the
patterns of extreme total sea levels on the shoreline, compared to former studies of univariate
stationary approaches, providing somewhat safer estimates and thus more reliable risk assessment
tools for coastal flooding under the effects of climate change.
References
1. Androulidakis, Y.S. et al. (2015). ‘Storm surges in the Mediterranean Sea: Variability and trends
under future climatic conditions’. Dynamics of Atmospheres and Oceans, 71, pp. 56-82.
2. Bender, J., Wahl, T. and Jensen, J. (2014). ‘Multivariate design in the presence of nonstationarity’. Journal of Hydrology, 514, pp. 123-130.
3. Benetazzo, A. et al. (2012). ‘Wave climate of the Adriatic Sea: a future scenario simulation’.
Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 12(6), pp. 2065-2076.
4. Conte, D. and Lionello, P. (2013). ‘Characteristics of large positive and negative surges in the
Mediterranean Sea and their attenuation in future climate scenarios’. Global and Planetary
Change, 111, pp. 159–173.
5. Feng, X. et al. (2018). ‘Study of storm surge trends in typhoon-prone coastal areas based on
observations and surge-wave coupled simulations’. International Journal of Applied Earth
Observation and Geoinformation.
6. Galiatsatou, P. (2007). ‘Joint exceedance probabilities of extreme waves and storm surges’.
XXXIII IAHR Congress, pp. 780.
7. Galiatsatou, P. and Prinos, P. (2008). ‘Non-stationary point process models for extreme storm
surges’. Flood Risk Management: Research and Practice: Proc. Floodrisk 2008, Oxford,
1045-1054.
8. Galiatsatou, P. and Prinos, P. (2014). ‘Analysing the effects of climate change on wave height
extremes in the Greek Seas’. ICHE 2014, Hamburg, Lehfeldt & Kopmann (eds), pp. 773-781.
9. Galiatsatou, P. and Prinos, P. (2015). ‘Estimating the effects of climate change on storm surge
extremes in the Greek Seas’. 36th IAHR World Congress, The Hague, The Netherlands.
10. Galiatsatou, P., Anagnostopoulou, C. and Prinos, P. (2016). ‘Modelling nonstationary extreme
wave heights in present and future climates of Greek Seas’. Water Science and Engineering,
9(1), pp. 21-32.
703
Climate change impacts and adaptation measures
11. Galiatsatou, P., Makris, C. and Prinos, P. (2017). ‘Non-Stationary Joint Probability Analysis of
Extreme Marine Variables to Assess Design Water Levels at the Shoreline in a Changing
Climate’. 3rd International EVAN Conference, 5-7 September 2017, Southampton, UK.
12. Galiatsatou, P. et al. (2018). ‘Nonstationary joint probability analysis of extreme marine variables
to assess design water levels at the shoreline in a changing climate’. Natural Hazards, Springer.
(submitted, under review).
13. Goda Y. (2000). ‘Random Sea and Design of Maritime Structures’. World Scientific.
14. Kapelonis, Z.G., Gavriliadis, P.N. and Athanassoulis, G.A. (2015). ‘Extreme value analysis of
dynamical wave climate projections in the Mediterranean Sea’. Procedia Computer Science, 66,
pp. 210-219.
15. Krestenitis, Y. et al. (2014). ‘Modeling storm surges in the Mediterranean Sea under the A1B
climate scenario’. 12th COMECAP, Heraklion (Crete), Greece, 28-31 May 2014, pp. 91-95.
16. Krestenitis, Y. et al. (2015). ‘Evolution of storm surge extreme events in Greek Seas under climate
change scenario’. 11th Pan-Hellenic Symposium on Oceanography and Fisheries, Mytilene,
Lesvos, Greece, 13-17 May 2015, pp. 849-852.
17. Kvočka, D., Falconer, R.A. and Bray, M. (2016). ‘Flood hazard assessment for extreme flood
events’. Natural Hazards, 84(3), pp. 1569–1599.
18. Makris, C.V. et al. (2015). ‘Numerical Modelling of Storm Surges in the Mediterranean Sea under
Climate Change’. 36th IAHR World Congress, The Hague, The Netherlands.
19. Makris, C. et al. (2016). ‘Climate change effects on the marine characteristics of the Aegean and
Ionian Seas’. Ocean Dynamics, 66(12), pp. 1603-1635.
20. Makris, C.V. and Krestenitis, Y.N. (2009). ‘Free Educational Software on Maritime
Hydrodynamics, Coastal Engineering and Oceanography’. 9th Pan-Hellenic Symposium of
Oceanography and Fisheries, Vol.1, pp. 546-551. (in Greek)
21. Satta, A. et al. (2017). ‘Assessment of coastal risks to climate change related impacts at the
regional scale: The case of the Mediterranean region’. International Journal of Disaster Risk
Reduction, 24, pp. 284-296.
22. Stockdon, H.F. et al. (2006). ‘Empirical parameterization of setup, swash, and runup’. Coastal
Engineering, 53, pp. 573-588.
23. Tolika, K. et al. (2015). ‘A comparison of the updated very high resolution model RegCM3_10km
with the previous version RegCM3_25km over the complex terrain of Greece: present and future
projections’. Theoretic and Applied Climatology, pp. 1–12.
24. Wahl, T., Mudersbach, C. and Jensen, J. (2012). ‘Assessing the hydrodynamic boundary
conditions for risk analyses in coastal areas: a multivariate statistical approach based on copula
functions’. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 12, pp. 495-510.
25. Vagenas, C., Anagnostopoulou, C. and Tolika, K. (2017). ‘Climatic Study of the Marine Surface
Wind Field over the Greek Seas with the Use of a High Resolution RCM Focusing on Extreme
Winds’. Climate, 5(2), pp. 29.
26. Vibilić, I. et al. (2017). ‘The Adriatic Sea: A long-Standing Laboratory for Sea Level Studies’.
Pure and Applied Geophysics, Sea Level 2017, pp. 1-47.
27. Vousdoukas, M.I. et al. (2016). ‘Projections of extreme storm surge levels along Europe’.
Climate Dynamics, 47(9), pp. 3171-3190.
704
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
705
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
706
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
BIOFILM GROWTH IN DRINKING WATER SYSTEMS UNDER
STAGNANT CONDITIONS
Erifyli Tsagkari* and William T. Sloan
School of Engineering, College of Science and Engineering, University of Glasgow, G12 8LT,
United Kingdom
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: Erifyli.Tsagkari@glasgow.ac.uk, tel: +447833637863
Abstract
Safe drinking water is essential for human health and its provision in a changing climate is a global
pressing problem. Research communities, governments and drinking water supplying companies are
working on improving the quality of drinking water and reducing its cost. Microorganisms colonise
the inner surfaces of pipes and form biofilms. In drinking water systems biofilms are problematic as
they cause loss of disinfectants, harbour pathogens and affect the aesthetics of drinking water. From
the engineering perspective, that leads to corrosion of the pipe’s material and reduced life of the
existing infrastructure. Thus, it is imperative that we gain a deeper understanding of the growth of
biofilms if we are to develop effective strategies for their removal or control.
In this study we focused on the growth of biofilms in drinking water under stagnant conditions, which
often occur in parts of drinking water pipes. A bioreactor was used to simulate the service lines of
drinking water systems. After 4 weeks, the thickness and density of the biofilms were characterised
using gravimetric measurements, and their surface area was determined using fluorescence
microscopy. Also, the concentration of cells and microcolonies both in the bulk water and on the
reactor surfaces was determined using fluorescence microscopy. Finally, spatial statistics were used
to describe the biofilm structures that were formed on the exposed surfaces of the reactor. It was
revealed that even under stagnant and oligotrophic conditions, drinking water bacteria moved from
the bulk water of the reactor and attached to the available surfaces forming a high number of
microcolonies. Biofilms were able to grow on the exposed surfaces of the reactor forming
characteristic structures consisting of dense cell clusters. Our results revealed that even under
unfavourable conditions biofilms can grow within our drinking water systems.
Keywords: biofilms; drinking water; microscopy; reactor; stagnant
1.
INTRODUCTION
Biofilms are found on virtually every wetted surface on earth. Even though the term “biofilm” may
not form part of the popular lexicon, most people are familiar with biofilms in one way or another, in
particular with those that can be seen by naked eye. The plaque on our teeth is a biofilm, the slime on
our contact lenses, the bathroom walls or rotting food is also a biofilm. Similarly, the green of brown
coating on rocks, pebbles or sand in a river is a biofilm [Hall-Stoodley et al., 2004]. A biofilm consists
of a group of microorganisms, such as bacteria, fungi, viruses and protozoa, which adhere to a surface
and are usually housed in a matrix of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS). The EPS are
biopolymers including polysaccharides, proteins, nucleic acids and lipids. In most biofilms, the
microorganisms may account for less than 10% of the total biofilm dry mass, whereas the EPS matrix
may account for over 90% of that. The biofilm matrix has been characterised as a three-dimensional
polymer network that interconnects and immobilises the cells that it consists of [Flemming and
Wingender, 2010].
707
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
It is estimated that 99% of the total population of bacteria in the world are found in the form of a
biofilm [Florjanic and Kristl, 2011]. One of the main reasons why bacteria opt for the biofilm, rather
than the planktonic mode of life, is the protection that the biofilm offers to them. This might include
protection against harsh conditions, such as nutrient deprivation, shear stresses, ultraviolet or acid
exposure, metal toxicity, dehydration, salinity, antibiotics and other antimicrobial agents [HallStoodley et al., 2004].
Biofilms can be very useful, especially in the field of bioremediation. Organisms may be used for
contaminant removal and for the purification of industrial wastewater. In biofilm filtration systems,
the filter medium presents a surface for the microbes to attach to and to feed on the organic material
in the water being treated. Such water cleaning systems are biologically more stable and their
disinfectant demand is lower than that of conventionally treated systems. Less microorganism
induced contamination is likely to occur in water that passes through a biofilm based filter than there
is in water that passes through another alternative treatment system [Campos et al., 2002].
On the other hand, biofilms can result in heavy costs for the cleaning and maintenance of the industrial
and domestic pipes that they colonise. The environment in which people are mostly exposed to
biofilms is the domestic environment [Garrett et al., 2008]. Although drinking water is closely
monitored in the developed countries, waterborne disease outbreaks are still being reported. These
outbreaks may be associated with pathogenic bacteria and viruses, and biofilms in the water pipe
networks are known to create favourable conditions for their survival and growth. In addition, the
detachment of biofilms from pipe walls is associated with changes in the water taste, odour and
colour. The main challenge of drinking water industries is to deliver water that is microbiologically
and chemically safe, aesthetically pleasing and adequate in quantity [Simões, 2012]. Thus, it is crucial
to find ways of managing the biofilms that will inevitably form.
Visualising biofilm structures is complicated due to the presence of debris, corrosion products and
mineral deposits, which provide new niches for bacteria to colonise [Batté et al., 2003]. Organic and
inorganic particles can accumulate in low-flow areas or dead-ends of drinking water systems and
enhance microbial activities by providing protection for bacteria against harsh conditions [Simões,
2012, Douterelo et al., 2013]. Biofilms are generally found to form very complex and heterogeneous
structures [van Loodsdrecht et al., 1995]. Thicknesses that have been recorded for biofilms in drinking
water systems range from a few tens of micrometres [Srinivasan et al., 2008] to a few hundreds of
micrometres [Momba et al., 2000]. Biofilms may be formed on the surfaces of drinking water pipes
within a few days or months and may reach a cell concentration of 107-109 cells/cm2 [Manuel, 2007].
The vast majority of bacteria, estimated at 95% of the total cell population, are attached to the surfaces
of the pipes, whereas only 5% are found in the water phase [Flemming et al., 2002].
In drinking water systems under high flow conditions, which are those that are mostly experienced,
microorganisms are transported by eddies in the flow [Kumarasamy and Maharaj, 2015]. Under low
flow conditions, the transport of bacteria from the bulk water to the exposed surfaces occurs due to
Brownian diffusion, sedimentation and cell motility. Stagnant conditions occur regularly in drinking
water systems (i.e. during overnight periods or near closed valves and flanges in the system) when
the water consumption is low [Manuel et al., 2007]. It is suspected that the biofilm growth
characteristics under stagnant conditions would be similar to those in laminar flow, where shear
stresses are low and the transport of nutrients and oxygen is driven by diffusion. However, very little
is known about biofilm growth under such conditions [Manuel et al., 2007, Liu et al., 2016]. Thus, in
this study, the development of biofilms in drinking water was investigated under stagnant conditions
after a 4-week period using a bioreactor. A 4-week period is considered a realistic time period of
water stagnation in service lines [Zlatanović et al., 2017]. Also, the reactor, which was used,
simulated the part of drinking water distribution systems, which is closer to the tap. The exact
structure and composition of drinking water biofilms are still unclear and have not been described in
detail yet due to difficulties in investigating such a small amount of biomass without disturbing it.
Biofilms in drinking water systems are generally thin but these low thicknesses that can be reached
708
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
are variable [Wimpenny et al., 2000]. Thus, the goal of this study was to investigate how biofilms
were developed under oligotrophic conditions in stagnant water and to characterize them.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Reactor conditions
Biofilms were grown in a jacketed rotating annular reactor (model 1320 LJ, BioSurface Technologies,
US). This reactor presents various advantages such as simple sampling process. Also, the liquid phase
of reactor is well mixed, which ensures that there is uniform distribution of bacteria in the bulk liquid
[Characklis and Marshall, 1990]. The reactor held 20 new and sterile vertical polycarbonate slides
(BST-503-PC) attached to its inner drum. The beveled edges of the slides were dropped into the
beveled slots on the reactor inner cylinder and they were removed from it using a sterilized hook. The
slides were placed in the inner cylinder in a symmetric way in order to avoid any imbalances. The
polycarbonate material of the slides was chosen as one of the plastic materials, which are used in
drinking water systems [Szabo et al., 2007, Garny et al., 2008]. The jacket of the reactor allowed the
temperature to be maintained in the system via heated water from a bath circulator (Isotemp Bath
Circulator, Fisher Scientific, UK). The temperature was chosen at 16oC as the representative
temperature of DWDS in the United Kingdom for spring and summer [Douterelo et al., 2013]. The
reactor was covered with aluminium foil in order to achieve dark conditions for biofilm growth. The
diameter of the pipe, which was simulated using this reactor, was at 30.3 mm. This pipe diameter
corresponds to the extremities of drinking water systems where the service lines start [Hall et al.,
2009]. The conditions in service lines are generally characterised by longer residence times, higher
stagnation periods, reduced flow rates and higher temperatures compared to those in the mains [Zheng
et al., 2015].
The medium that the reactor was filled with consisted of 150 ml of nutrient medium and 850 ml of
drinking water that was sampled from a domestic tap in Glasgow. The concentrations for mineral
salts of the reactor medium were: ammonium sulphate (1.2 mg/l), ammonium chloride (0.9 mg/l),
magnesium sulphate heptahydrate (0.3 mg/l), manganese chloride tetrahydrate (0.003 mg/l), copper
sulphate pentahydrate (0.002 mg/l), cobalt sulphate heptahydrate (0.001 mg/l), sodium molybdate
dehydrate (0.001 mg/l), zinc sulphate heptahydrate (0.01 mg/l), and boric acid (0.75 mg/l)
(Milferstedt et al., 2006), and the concentration for glucose of the reactor medium was 1.5 mg/l. These
concentrations kept the bulk water conditions in the reactor oligotrophic (Batté et al., 2003). The total
organic carbon (TOC) in the bulk water of reactor was determined using a TOC-L analyser
(SHIMADZU, Japan) as the difference between the total carbon and the total inorganic carbon. To
calculate the TOC 3 samples of 10 ml each were used. The TOC was measured at the onset of the
experiment and after 4 weeks. Finally, the concentration of total chlorine of the drinking water, which
was sampled from the tap, was measured immediately after its sampling and after 4 weeks. The
USEPA DPD Method 8167 [Chamberlain and Adams, 2006] was followed to measure the chlorine
concentration using the DR 900 Hach colorimeter (Colorado, US). The measurements were
performed for 3 samples of 10 ml each.
2.2 Cells and microcolonies measurements
To calculate the concentration of cells in the bulk water of reactor at the onset of the experiment 3
samples of 5 ml each were used. These samples were filtered through 47 mm Whatman® 0.2 μm
membrane filters (Sigma-Aldrich, Irvine, UK) after they were fixed with 0.5 ml of 2% formaldehyde
[Kepner and Pratt, 1994]. The membrane filters were then covered with 1 ml of 0.1% Triton X-100
solution in order to evenly disperse the cells. The cells on the membrane filters were then stained with
1 ml of 10 μg/ml (4΄,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole) DAPI for 20 minutes in the dark and visualised
using fluorescence microscopy (Olympus IX71, Japan) with the oil immersion UPlanFLN objective
lens (100X magnification/1.30 numerical aperture). More than 30 images per membrane filter were
obtained. The concentration of cells was calculated from [Brunk et al., 1979]:
709
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Σ𝑥
cells ( n ± 𝑠) Amemb d
=
ml
Afield Vfilt
(2)
where Σx/n is the mean number, s is the standard deviation, Amemb is the surface area of the membrane
filter, d is the dilution factor, Afield is the surface area of the microscope field and Vfilt is the volume
of the liquid sample filtered. The same procedure was used to calculate the concentration of
microcolonies in the bulk water of reactor but without using the Triton solution and by using the
objective lens with 10X magnification/0.30 numerical aperture instead of the one with 100X
magnification/1.30 numerical aperture. The microcolonies visualised had a diameter of
approximately 10 μm and consisted of approximately 10 cells.
To calculate the concentration of cells on the reactor slides after the 4 weeks, 3 slides were removed
from the reactor. The biomaterial attached to the reactor slides was gently scraped from the slides and
diluted in 5 ml distilled water. Then, the 5 ml samples were fixed with 0.5 ml of 2% formaldehyde
[Kepner and Pratt, 1994] and filtered on Whatman® 0.2 μm membrane filters. The same procedure
described above was followed. The concentration of cells was calculated from [Brunk et al., 1979]:
Σ𝑥
cells ( n ± 𝑠) Amemb dVsusp
=
cm2
Afield Vfilt Abiof
(3)
where Vsusp is the total suspension volume and Abiof is the area from which the biomaterial was
scraped. The same procedure was used to calculate the concentration of microcolonies on the reactor
slides. The microcolonies were similar to those described above.
2.3 Biofilm measurements
To calculate the biofilm thickness and density 3 slides were removed from the reactor. Gravimetric
measurements were used to characterise the thickness and density of the biofilms attached to the
slides [Staudt et al., 2004]. In brief, after the slides were removed from the reactor they were drained
for 5 minutes at a vertical position and then they were weighed for the determination of the wet mass.
Then, the slides were dried for 24 hours at 65oC in an oven and weighed again. After that, the dried
biofilm was washed off the slides with distilled water and laboratory tissues. The clean slides were
dried again for 24 hours at 65oC and then weighed again. The dry mass was determined by the weight
difference of the slides with and without the dried biofilm. The biofilm thickness, LF, was determined
by:
𝑚𝑊𝐹
(4)
𝐿𝐹 =
ρWF AF
and the volumetric biofilm density, ρF, was determined by:
𝑚𝐷𝐹
𝜌𝐹 = 𝑚
( ρ 𝑊𝐹 )
WF
(5)
where mWF and mDF are the wet and dry mass of the biofilm respectively. Also, ρWF is the density of
biofilm, for which there is the assumption that it is equal to that of water at 16 oC at 998.946 kg/m3.
Finally, AF is the surface area of the slide. The areal biofilm density was finally calculated as the
product of the biofilm thickness and the volumetric biofilm density.
To visualise the biofilm structures on the reactor slides after the 4 weeks, 3 slides were removed from
the reactor. The biofilms on the reactor slides were firstly fixed with 0.5 ml of 4% paraformaldehyde
[Chao and Zhang, 2011]. The samples were covered with 1 ml of 10 μg/ml DAPI for 20 minutes in
the dark. Biofilm structures were visualised using the objective lens with 100X magnification/1.30
numerical aperture. The surface area of biofilms on the reactor surfaces was then calculated in Matlab
by processing more than 30 images obtained from fluorescence microscopy. The original images
710
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
were firstly converted to gray-scale images using the Matlab command called “rgb2gray” and then to
binary images using the Matlab command called “im2bw” in order to separate the biomaterial from
the background of the image. After the surface area of the biofilm was calculated, it was divided to
the total surface area of the image in order to finally calculate the percentage of this surface area (%).
2.4 Spatial statistics
Textural entropy was used to characterise the biofilm structures. Entropy is used to describe the
randomness of the components of a gray-scale image by comparing the intensity of the image pixels.
The higher is the value of the entropy, the more heterogeneous is the biofilm. This means that more
complex biofilm structures are demonstrated in the image. Entropy refers to the gray levels, which
the individual pixels can adopt. In an 8-bit pixel image, for example, there are 256 such levels [Yang
et al., 2000, Beyenal et al., 2004]. The entropy, E, is here defined:
𝐸 = −Σ𝑝log 2 𝑝
(6)
where p is the pixel intensity associated with the gray level. Entropy was calculated using the Matlab
function called “entropy”. To calculate the entropy more than 30 images of the biofilm structures,
obtained from fluorescence microscopy, were used.
The semi-variogram was used as another measure to characterise the spatial variance of biofilm
structures within gray-scale images and quantify the spatial dependencies in the data sets. Its function
relates the semi-variance of the data points to the distance that separates them. Large distance of the
data points means more data pairs for the estimation of the semi-variance but less amount of detail in
the semi-variogram. In other words, the semi-variogram is a way of graphically capturing the spatial
variance of points on a landscape as a function of their distance. All combinations of points at a
distance are collated and their variance is determined for all possible separation distances [Carr and
de Miranda, 1998]. The semi-variogram was calculated using the Matlab function called
“variogram.m”.
The autocorrelation function (ACF) diagram was used as the last measure to characterise the biofilm
structures. The ACF diagram is, in essence, a two-dimensional extension of the semi-variogram. It
allows us to assess how the spatial autocorrelation changes with distance. It correlates pixel intensities
within gray-scale images and detects the repetitive structures within the image under consideration
by combining together all parts of it. The ACF diagram is a real-space image, so that its dimensions
have the same meaning as in the original image. Interpretation of the ACF diagram can be understood
by imagining the image to be printed on transparency and placed on top of itself but rotated by 180o.
By sliding the top image laterally in any direction, the degree of match with the underlying original
image is measured by this function [Heilbronner and Barrett, 2014]. The ACF diagram was calculated
using the Matlab function called “autocorr2d.m”.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Reactor medium, cells and microcolonies
The total chlorine of drinking water after it was sampled from the tap was found at 0.36 mg/l and
after the 4 weeks it was found at 0 mg/l, as it was expected, since chlorine can decay through its
interactions with the material of the slides or with the adhering on them biofilms [Brown et al., 2011].
Also, the TOC of reactor medium at the onset of the experiment was found at (1.95±0.3) mg/l and
after the 4 weeks it was found at (0.74±0.1) mg/l. This showed that the TOC was decreased with time
probably due to its consumption from the bacteria. The concentration of cells in the bulk water was
found at (5.1 ± 0.5)*105 cells/ml and the concentration of microcolonies in the bulk water was
determined at (3.6±0.2)*103 microcolonies/ml at the onset of the experiment. This showed that cells
were formed into microcolonies in the drinking water that was sampled from the tap rather than only
being at their own state. The concentration of cells on the reactor slides was determined at (1.9 ±
0.3)*103 cells/cm2 (Figure 1a) after 4 weeks. This indicated that a quite high portion of the bacteria
that were in the bulk water at the onset of the experiment were finally transferred to the reactor slides
711
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
after the 4-week period. The concentration of microcolonies on the reactor slides after the 4-week
period was found at (2.6 ± 0.7)*102 microcolonies/cm2 (Figure 1b). This showed again that a quite
high portion of the cells formed microcolonies on the reactor slides after 4 weeks. A microcolony is
a form of aggregate, which is the coming together of bacteria in the bulk water that might be
transferred finally onto the available surfaces. Thus, it is considered to be an important precursor for
the formation of biofilms [Sheng et al., 2010, Saur et al., 2017].
a.
b.
Figure 1 a) Cells of about 1 μm size attached to the reactor slides, b) microcolonies of about 10
μm size attached to the reactor slides as revealed by fluorescense microsocpy.
3.2 Biofilms
Under stagnant conditions, given that bacteria are not transported onto surfaces by flowing water,
then one might expect gravity to have an effect; thus, the vertical slides of reactor to be less prone to
cell colonisation. Also, the oligotrophic conditions implicate that there is not enough energy given to
bacteria to come together to each other and form biofilms. Shear stress conditions have a number of
effects on bacteria; they keep them in suspension and increase the probability of bacteria colliding by
chance. They also enhance mass transfer processes, oxygen distribution within the bulk water of
pipelines and any metabolic reactions between bacteria [Lee et al., 2002, Son et al., 2015]. Thus, it
was surprising to find that biofilms did grow in drinking water under stagnant conditions and their
percentage of surface area after 4 weeks was found at 19.2%. Also, after 4 weeks the thickness of
biofilms was found at 119.54 μm and their density at 9 mg/cm2. This validated that biofilms did form
in drinking water under stagnant conditions. However, the thickness of the biofilm was not high
compared to the thicknesses that have been found using the same method under shear stress conditions
[Horn et al., 2003, Staudt et al., 2004, Elenter et al., 2007].
3.3 Biofilm structures
Biofilms were found to form patchy structures consisting of rod-shaped bacteria (Figure 2) as
revealed by fluorescence microscopy. The hazy part of biofilms in Figure 2 is probably the EPS of
biofilms, which surrounded the cells. This patchy structure is also seen in laminar flow conditions
where shear stresses are low [Stoodley et al., 1999a]. In turbulent flows biofilms tend to form much
different structures such as filamentous structures that are also called streamers [Besemer et al., 2009].
However, streamers have been also identified in rare cases in laminar flow conditions [Rusconi et al.,
2010]. Bacteria under low flow conditions tend to form clusters, which are microcolonies that consist
of densely packed cells held together by EPS. Thus, the patchy structures consisting of cell clusters,
which were identified here, were not a surprising result.
712
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2 Biofilm structures stained with DAPI as revealed by fluorescence microscopy.
The entropy of biofilms was determined at 1.87. If all of the pixels of the image have the same value,
or the image has no structures, or the image is composed of only white pixels or voids, the entropy of
the image is 0 showing there is no gray scale variation in the pixels or heterogeneity. Increased
numbers of structures in the image increase entropy due to increased gray level variability and
heterogeneity in the image [Yang et al., 2000]. Thus, our measurements revealed that since entropy
was not 0 or close to 0 this shows that characteristic biofilm structures were actually formed on the
reactor surfaces.
The semi-variogram is here demonstrated (Figure 3a). An important part of a semi-variogram is the
“origin”, which represents the closest points of the diagram. Another important part of a semivariogram is the “sill”, which is the variogram upper bound that is equal to the variance of the data
set and it also reflects the amount of variability. The sill is usually found at large distances where
there is no gradient in the diagram [Cohen et al., 1990, Cressie, 1993]. The lag distance at which the
semi-variogram reaches the sill value is the “range”. In total, 12000 points were used for the
calculation of the semi-variogram shown in Figure 3a. The gradient in the variance close to the origin
was found to be shallow and linear. This indicated that values were co-located as the variance at short
distance was found to be low. These measurements showed that the topography of the biofilm was
now very heterogeneous, as it was expected for stagnant conditions [Stoodley et al., 1999b]. Finally,
the range was found at about 70 μm and the sill was equal to almost 9.
The ACF diagram is here demonstrated as a contour plot (Figure 3b). The almost radially symmetric
contours in autocorrelation do not suggest that there was only one spatially-correlated “lump” at the
centre of the image. It is the average autocorrelation for all pixels on the image. In the ACF diagram,
the central element provides a measure of the size and shape of the basic element that dominates the
original image. The rest contour lines reflect the size and shape of the neighbourhood elements of the
original image. Finally, the bar on the right side of the ACF diagrams provides a measure of the
autocorrelation. The darker is the colour on the bar, the less is the autocorrelation value with its lowest
value to be 0 and the highest one to be 1 [Russ, 2011]. In this diagram, the central element was found
to be a circular feature, which size and shape corresponded to a cell. The rest contour lines, which
were found to surround this main feature, were also circular and corresponded to a microcolony.
These measurements suggest that radially symmetrical lumps were the prevalent topographical
features, which could be associated with microcolonies. The contour plot in Figure 3b showed that
cells align with themselves creating characteristic microcolonies, as it was also indicated in Figure 2.
713
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
a.
b.
Figure 3 a) Semi-variogram; the vertical axis represents the semi-variance and the horizontal
one represents the distance in μm, b) ACF diagram; the axes represent the size of the original
image in pixels.
Overall, an annular reactor allowed us to grow biofilms in drinking water under stagnant conditions.
Understanding the functionality and mechanisms of biofilms during the moderate (weeks) stages of
their life will help in the consideration of future design of management strategies to control their
growth in real drinking water systems. Our experiments suggest that biofilms were able to form in
the reactor even under stagnant and oligotrophic conditions. However, these biofilms were not very
thick and dense as it was revealed by gravimetric measurements. Fluorescence microscopy also
revealed that biofilms were actually formed on the reactor surfaces creating characteristic patchy
structures consisting of cell clusters. Finally, spatial statistics showed that the microcolonies were the
most evident feature of the biofilm structures, which were not found to be complex, heterogeneous
and irregular. Engineers should not overlook the biofilm-associated problems since a cursory
understanding of the biology of the microorganisms that sit at the boundaries of our existing
infrastructure will lead to an enhanced functionality of them.
References
1. Batté, M., Appenzeller, B. M. R., Grandjean, D., Fass, S., Gauthier, V., Jorand, F., Mathieu, L.,
Boualam, M., Saby, S. and Block, J. C. (2003). 'Biofilms in drinking water distribution systems'.
Reviews in Environmental Science and Bio/Technology, 2, pp. 147-168.
2. Besemer, K., Hodl, I., Singer, G. and Battin, T. J. (2009). 'Architectural differentiation reflects
bacterial community structure in stream biofilms'. Isme Journal, 3, pp. 1318-1324.
3. Beyenal, H., Donovan, C., Lewandowski, Z. and Harkin, G. (2004). 'Three-dimensional biofilm
structure quantification'. J Microbiol Methods, 59, pp. 395-413.
4. Brown, D., Bridgeman, J. and West, J. R. (2011). 'Predicting chlorine decay and THM formation
in water supply systems'. Reviews in Environmental Science and Bio-Technology, 10, pp. 7999.
5. Brunk, C. F., Jones, K. C. and James, T. W. (1979). 'Assay for Nanogram Quantities of DNA in
Cellular Homogenates'. Analytical Biochemistry, 92, pp. 497-500.
6. Campos, L. C., Su, M. F. J., Graham, N. J. D. and Smith, S. R. (2002). 'Biomass development in
slow sand filters'. Water Res, 36, pp. 4543-4551.
7. Carr, J. R. and de Miranda, F. P. (1998). 'The semivariogram in comparison to the co-occurrence
matrix for classification of image texture'. Ieee Transactions on Geoscience and Remote
Sensing, 36, pp. 1945-1952.
714
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
8. Chamberlain, E. and Adams, C. (2006). 'Oxidation of sulfonamides, macrolides, and carbadox
with free chlorine and monochloramine'. Water Res, 40, pp. 2517-2526.
9. Chao, Y. Q. and Zhang, T. (2011). 'Optimization of fixation methods for observation of bacterial
cell morphology and surface ultrastructures by atomic force microscopy'. Appl Microbiol
Biotechnol, 92, pp. 381-392.
10. Characklis, W. G. and Marshall, K. C. 1990. 'Biofilms', New York: John Wiley and Sons.
11. Cohen, W. B., Spies, T. A. and Bradshaw, G. A. (1990). 'Semivariograms of Digital Imagery for
Analysis of Conifer Canopy Structure '. Remote Sens. Environ., 34, pp. 167-178.
12. Cressie, N. 1993. 'Statistics for spatial data, Wiley series in probability and mathematical
statistics, Revised Edition', New York, Wiley.
13. Douterelo, I., Sharpe, R. L. and Boxall, J. B. (2013). 'Influence of hydraulic regimes on bacterial
community structure and composition in an experimental drinking water distribution system'.
Water Res, 47, pp. 503-16.
14. Elenter, D., Milferstedt, K., Zhang, W., Hausner, M. and Morgenroth, E. (2007). 'Influence of
detachment on substrate removal and microbial ecology in a heterotrophic/autotrophic biofilm'.
Water Res, 41, pp. 4657-4671.
15. Flemming, H. C., Percival, S. L. and Walker, J. T. (2002). 'Contamination potential of biofilms
in water distribution systems'. Innovations in Conventional and Advanced Water Treatment
Processes, 2, pp. 271-280.
16. Flemming, H. C. and Wingender, J. (2010). 'The biofilm matrix'. Nature Reviews Microbiology,
8, pp. 623-633.
17. Florjanic, M. and Kristl, J. (2011). 'The control of biofilm formation by hydrodynamics of purified
water in industrial distribution system'. International Journal of Pharmaceutics, 405, pp. 1622.
18. Garny, K., Horn, H. and Neu, T. R. (2008). 'Interaction between biofilm development, structure
and detachment in rotating annular reactors'. Bioprocess Biosyst Eng, 31, pp. 619-629.
19. Garrett, T. R., Bhakoo, M. and Zhang, Z. (2008). 'Bacterial adhesion and biofilms on surfaces'.
Progress in Natural Science, 18, pp. 1049-1056.
20. Hall-Stoodley, L., Costerton, J. W. and Stoodley, P. (2004). 'Bacterial biofilms: from the natural
environment to infectious diseases'. Nat Rev Microbiol, 2, pp. 95-108.
21. Hall, J., Szabo, J., Panguluri, S. and Meiners, G. (2009). 'Distribution System Water Quality
Monitoring: Sensor Technology Evaluation Methodology and Results' A Guide for Sensor
Manufacturers and Water Utilities. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), USA.
22. Heilbronner, R. and Barrett, S. (2014). 'Image Analysis in Earth Sciences', Springer.
23. Horn, H., Reiff, H. and Morgenroth, E. (2003). 'Simulation of growth and detachment in biofilm
systems under defined hydrodynamic conditions'. Biotechnol Bioeng, 81, pp. 607-617.
24. Kepner, R. L. and Pratt, J. R. (1994). 'Use of Fluorochromes for Direct Enumeration of Total
Bacteria in Environmental-Samples - Past and Present'. Microbiological Reviews, 58, pp. 603615.
25. Kumarasamy, M. V. and Maharaj, P. M. (2015). 'The Effect of Biofilm Growth on Wall Shear
Stress in Drinking Water PVC Pipes'. Polish Journal of Environmental Studies, 24, pp. 24792483.
26. Lee, S. H., Lee, S. S. and Kim, C. W. (2002). 'Changes in the cell size of Brevundimonas diminuta
using different growth agitation rates'. PDA J Pharm Sci Technol, 56, pp. 99-108.
715
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
27. Liu, S., Gunawan, C., Barraud, N., Rice, S. A., Harry, E. J. and Amal, R. (2016). 'Understanding,
Monitoring, and Controlling Biofilm Growth in Drinking Water Distribution Systems'. Environ
Sci Technol, 50, pp. 8954-8976.
28. Manuel, C. M. (2007). 'Biofilm Dynamics and Drinking Water Stability: Effects of
Hydrodynamics and Surface Materials'. Ph.D Thesis, University of Porto, Portugal.
29. Manuel, C. M., Nunes, O. C. and Melo, L. F. (2007). 'Dynamics of drinking water biofilm in
flow/non-flow conditions'. Water Res, 41, pp. 551-562.
30. Momba, M. N. B., Kfir, R., Venter, S. N. and Cloete, T. E. (2000). 'An overview of biofilm
formation in distribution systems and its impact on the deterioration of water quality'. Water SA,
26, pp. 59-66.
31. Rusconi, R., Lecuyer, S., Guglielmini, L. and Stone, H. A. (2010). 'Laminar flow around corners
triggers the formation of biofilm streamers'. Journal of the Royal Society Interface, 7, pp. 12931299.
32. Russ, J. C. 2011. 'The image processing handbook, Sixth Edition', North Carolina State
University, Materials Science and Engineering Department, Raleigh, North Carolina, CRC Press.
33. Saur, T., Morin, E., Habouzit, F., Bernet, N. and Escudie, R. (2017). 'Impact of wall shear stress
on initial bacterial adhesion in rotating annular reactor'. PLoS One, 12,
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172113
34. Sheng, G. P., Yu, H. Q. and Li, X. Y. (2010). 'Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) of
microbial aggregates in biological wastewater treatment systems: A review'. Biotechnology
Advances, 28, pp. 882-894.
35. Simões, L. C. (2012). 'Biofilms in drinking water'. Biofilms in drinking water: formation and
control. LAMBERT Academic Publishing.
36. Son, K., Brumley, D. R. and Stocker, R. (2015). 'Live from under the lens: exploring microbial
motility with dynamic imaging and microfluidics'. Nature Reviews Microbiology, 13, pp. 761775.
37. Srinivasan, S., Harrington, G. W., Xagoraraki, I. and Goel, R. (2008). 'Factors affecting bulk to
total bacteria ratio in drinking water distribution systems'. Water Res, 42, pp. 3393-3404.
38. Staudt, C., Horn, H., Hempel, D. C. and Neu, T. R. (2004). 'Volumetric measurements of bacterial
cells and extracellular polymeric substance glycoconjugates in biofilms'. Biotechnol Bioeng, 88,
pp. 585-592.
39. Stoodley, P., Boyle, J. D., DeBeer, D. and Lappin-Scott, H. M. (1999a). 'Evolving perspectives
of biofilm structure'. Biofouling, 14, pp. 75-90.
40. Stoodley, P., Dodds, I., Boyle, J. D. and Lappin-Scott, H. M. (1999b). 'Influence of
hydrodynamics and nutrients on biofilm structure'. J Appl Microbiol, 85, pp. 19S-28S.
41. Szabo, J. G., Rice, E. W. and Bishop, P. L. (2007). 'Persistence and decontamination of Bacillus
atrophaeus subsp. globigii spores on corroded iron in a model drinking water system'. Appl
Environ Microbiol, 73, pp. 2451-2457.
42. van Loodsdrecht, M. C. M., Eikelboom, D., Gjaltema, A., Tijhuis, L. and Heijnen, J. J. (1995).
'Biofilm structures'. Water Science and Technology, 32, pp. 35-43.
43. Wimpenny, J., Manz, W. and Szewzyk, U. (2000). 'Heterogeneity in biofilms'. Fems
Microbiology Reviews, 24, pp. 661-671.
44. Yang, X. M., Beyenal, H., Harkin, G. and Lewandowski, Z. (2000). 'Quantifying biofilm structure
using image analysis'. J Microbiol Methods, 39, pp. 109-119.
716
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
45. Zheng, M. Z., He, C. G. and He, Q. (2015). 'Fate of free chlorine in drinking water during
distribution in premise plumbing'. Ecotoxicology, 24, pp. 2151-2155.
46. Zlatanović, Lj., van der Hoek, J. P. and Vreeburg, J. H. G. (2017). 'An experimental study on the
influence of water stagnation and temperature change on water quality in a full-scale domestic
drinking water system'. Water Res, 123, pp. 761-772.
717
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
RESTORATION OF TWO GREEK LAKES (KASTORIA AND
KORONIA): SUCCESS STORIES?
M. Moustaka-Gouni1*, M. Katsiapi1,2, N. Stefanidou1, E. Vardaka, S3. Genitsaris1, K.
A. Kormas4, F. Georgoulis1
1
School of Biology, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 541 24 Thessaloniki, Greece
EYATH SA, Thessaloniki Water Treatment Facility, 570 08, Nea Ionia, Thessaloniki, Greece
3
Department of Nutrition and Dietetics, Alexander Technological Educational Institute of
Thessaloniki, 574 00 Sindos, Greece
4
Department of Ichthyology & Aquatic Environment, School of Agricultural Sciences, University
of Thessaly, 384 46 Volos, Greece
2
*Corresponding author: e-mail: mmustaka@bio.auth.gr
Abstract
Lake Kastoria and Lake Koronia, both shallow (maximum depth 8-9 m) and large lakes (29 and 45
km2, respectively) of Greece, 50 years ago, have undergone heavy degradation by human activities
over the past decades. Since 2002, Koronia became a temporary lake due to a dramatic decrease in
surface area and depth owing to unsustainable water management. During the last two decades, efforts
have been made for the restoration of both lakes based on programmes of measures. In this work we
present the long-term phytoplankton changes in the lakes under restoration aiming to identify a)
critical changes in target phytoplankton attributes set for ecological restoration and b) success in
ecological water quality improvement. Following 23 years of sewage diversion in Kastoria and the
last two years’ adjustment of the lake’s water level through flushing, all phytoplankton metrics
(species composition, phytoplankton biomass, cyanobacterial biomass, Microcystis biomass) indicate
partial success in community restoration and an obvious water quality improvement. The dominance
of several non-harmful and good quality species of the genera Ceratium, Fragillaria, Dinobryon,
Mallomonas, Cryptomonas, Rhodomonas and Nitzschia indicates species recover, however not
complete, opening ecological processes restoration. In particular, after the episode of a heavy toxic
cyanobacterial bloom (with Microcystis dominating the phytoplankton community) in 2014, the
implementation of the flushing tool in 2016 - 2017 resulted in phytoplankton and cyanobacterial
biomass decrease and temporal restriction of harmful species. On the other hand, in Lake Koronia,
after the metaphyton dominance in the first years following the lake’s re-flooding (2010) the
phytoplankton “seed-bank” species ruled over. During 2015 -2017, phytoplankton biomass
comprised of a mixture of phytoplankton species recruited from the sediment, which dominated in
the lake water since 2003. Specifically, in 2015-2017, the composition and species dominance were
almost identical with those of the recently re-generated Lake Karla, known for its bad water quality
and the recurrent episodes of fish and bird kills. Co-occurrence of the potential toxic, “seed-bank”
species Anabaena aphanizomenoides /Aphanizomenon favaloroi, Prymnesium parvum, Planktothrix
sp., Anabaenopsis elenkinii, Arthrospira fusiformis, Cylindrospermopsis raciborskii and Pfiesteria
piscicida was recorded in Koronia in 2017. Based on the results of the present study, Lake Kastoria
improved to a moderate quality in 2017 while Lake Koronia was characterized by a bad water quality
the same year. This study is useful for the decisions involved in water quality management and
implementation of the restoration programmes in both lakes.
Keywords: Lakes Kastoria and Koronia, ecological restoration, water quality, phytoplankton
718
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
1.
INTRODUCTION
The core objective of the Water Framework Directive (WFD) is that all surface waters should be in
good or better ecological status by 2015 or at the latest in 2027 (European Commission, 2000). Excess
nutrient loading has induced the development of high phytoplankton biomass and harmful algal and
cyanobacterial blooms, degrading lake water quality (Vardaka et al, 2005; Michaloudi et al, 2009).
During the past century, efforts have been made throughout European countries to reverse
eutrophication and improve water quality by implementing various restoration measures. For
instance, in Lake Constance, after several decades of eutrophication, a decrease in phosphorus loading
over a decade (80’ s) led to a partial recovery from eutrophication (Sommer et al, 1993) and finally
the lake returned to oligotrophy (Eckmann et al, 2006). However, the eutrophication pressure still
represents an important threat to the integrity of lake ecosystems and one of the main causes that 44%
of European lakes fail to meet the good ecological status standards (EEA-ETC, 2012). To achieve the
good status, the Member States should define and implement the necessary restoration programmes.
Lake Kastoria and Lake Koronia were both shallow and large lakes of Greece 50 years ago. Since
then, the lakes have undergone heavy degradation by human activities. During the last two decades,
efforts have been made for the restoration of both lakes based on conservation programmes and the
implementation of various measures. In Lake Kastoria, a positive phytoplankton response and water
quality improvement was observed fifteen years after sewage diversion and nutrient control (Katsiapi
et al, 2013). However, a deterioration was evident in 2014 with the appearance of an extended
cyanobacterial scum (Figure 1) covering large part of the lake; this intense cyanobacterial incident
was responsible for the production of an unpleasant odor affecting the residents of the town of
Kastoria, thus even been mentioned in the Greek media. On the other hand, Lake Koronia became a
temporary lake since 2002, due to a dramatic decrease in surface area and depth, caused by
unsustainable water resource management (Michaloudi et al, 2012). In 2010, dense mats of
metaphytic chlorophytes and cyanobacteria appeared in the lake after it was artificially flooded
through a channel constructed under the lake’s restoration programme (Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2012).
In ecosystem restoration, the assumption is made that with the recovery of species, ecological
processes will also be restored (Lake et al, 2007). According to potential degradation - community
recovery pathways proposed by Lake et al (2007) and adapted from Sarr (2002), if the disturbance is
stopped and the habitat is rebuilt, then recovery will be complete and may be relatively rapid. In many
eutrophic lakes, restoration aims at a significant decrease of total phytoplankton biomass with
simultaneous shift in species dominance and if nutrients are successfully controlled then the
phytoplankton recovery will happen, however, relatively slow (Romo et al, 2005; Katsiapi et al,
2013). In attempts to re-establish populations, knowledge of the species’ life-histories is critical. The
life history traits contribute to the system’s ability to supply recruits and support established species
(Palmer et al, 1997). Knowledge of phytoplankton species life-histories is especially decisive for
community recovery and restoration success (Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2012) in shallow degraded lakes
with long histories of cyanobacterial and other disruptive phytoplankton blooms (e.g. MoustakaGouni et al, 2006; Michaloudi et al, 2009). Unsuccessful restoration is usually due to the emphasis
paid on restoring the abiotic factors and at the same time ignoring the biotic ones, e.g. phytoplankton
species life-histories and their population interactions (Suding et al, 2004). In the present study, we
use phytoplankton as a target indicator to identify critical changes for successful ecological
restoration and ecological water quality improvement. This selection is based on the double role of
phytoplankton as an indicator of ecological water quality and as an impact on ecosystem functioning
and services (Katsiapi et al, 2016) due to the formation of disruptive cyanobacterial and algal blooms
(Michaloudi et al, 2009; Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2016). Particularly, we combine published
information on phytoplankton changes and novel data of recent years from the lakes under restoration,
aiming to identify critical changes in phytoplankton indicators for ensuring ecological restoration
success. For this, total phytoplankton biomass, phytoplankton species biomass forming harmful and
disruptive cyanobacterial and algal blooms, two modified Nygaard’s indices and a new index based
719
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
on quality group species were estimated according to the innovative phytoplankton community index
PhyCoI (Katsiapi et al. 2016). PhyCoI was developed for monitoring ecological status and was
validated by using data from Greek lakes (Katsiapi et al, 2016). Ecological water quality was also
assessed by using the PhyCoI index. For Lake Koronia, we also focused on species recruitment traits
that are critical for their establishment in lake plankton after its drying out (Moustaka-Gouni et al
2012).
Figure 1. View of the water of Lake Kastoria along its shore in the town of Kastoria in
September 2014 (cyanobacterial scum) and September 2017 (cyanobacterial bloom).
2.
STUDY SITE
Lake Kastoria (40o 83′ 09″ N, 21o 81′ 89″ E) is a polymictic lake with a 30 km2 surface area, a
maximum depth of about 8 m, and an average depth of about 4 m, situated at 625 m above sea level.
In Lake Kastoria the presence of toxic cyanobacteria was established in 1987 (Cook et al, 2004).
From 1987 until 2014, several toxic cyanobacterial blooms occurred in the lake (Cook et al. 2004;
Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2006; Papadimitriou et al, 2010; Katsiapi and Moustaka-Gouni, 2016).
Lake Koronia (40o 40′ 58″ N, 23o 09′ 33″ E) at 75 m above sea level used to be the fourth largest lake
in Greece occupying an area of 46 km2 and having a maximum depth of 8 m in the 1960’s. The two
lakes in the 1960’s had similar basic morphometric attributes for the same lake type (WFD ANNEX
II; European Commission, 2000) differing only in their altitude. However, a dramatic decrease in the
surface area and depth of Lake Koronia due to anthropogenic effects and enhanced by prolonged
drought periods resulted in the drying out of the lake in 2002, 2007, 2009 and in January of 2014
(Michaloudi et al, 2012; Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2012; Moustaka-Gouni et al, unpublished data).
However, in 2014 - 2017 heavy rainfalls contributed to a lake maximum depth of about 2 m. In
addition to its dramatic size decrease and heavy pollution, Lake Koronia shifted from a freshwater to
720
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
a brackish lake. In September - October 2017 although conductivity of the lake water ranged in lower
values (5.5 and 6.0 mS cm-1) than previous years (e.g. Michaloudi et al, 2009) , Koronia still remains
a very shallow brackish lake, thus a heavily modified water body according to WFD definitions
(European Commission, 2000). Regarding the ecological harms in Lake Koronia, in August 1995
(maximum depth 1 m) a massive kill of all fish occurred coinciding with a pH > 10 due to
hypertrophic conditions and high photosynthetic rates of high populations of the nanoplanktic
phytoplankters Chlorogonium and Oocystis species (Michaloudi et al, 2012). In 2004, a massive bird
and fish kill occurred in the lake coinciding with an extremely dense bloom of the known toxic
Prymnesium parvum (Genitsaris et al, 2009). In 2007, a mass mortality of flamingos coincided with
a dense bloom of known toxic cyanobacteria (Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2007) while a bird kill in August
2015 also coincided with a bloom of known toxic cyanobacteria (this study).
3.
METHODS
For the long-term data of this study all the available publications in the scientific literature until
January 2018, involving studies on phytoplankton in relation to ecological restoration of Lake
Kastoria and Lake Koronia have been used. The most recent data (2014 -2017 for Lake Kastoria and
2015-2017 for Lake Koronia) come from the examination of phytoplankton samples collected from
the two lakes respectively.
Phytoplankton sampling was carried out during the warm period of the year in both lakes. In Lake
Kastoria samples were collected in August and September 2014, June, July, August and September
2016 and April, May, July, September and October 2017 in one sampling point. In Lake Koronia
samples were collected in July, August 2015 (by the National Monitoring Water Network), September
2016 and September and October 2017 in one or two sampling points (in 2017: Analipsi and
Anachoma; Figure 2).
Fresh and preserved phytoplankton samples were examined using an inverted microscope with phasecontrast technique (Nikon SE 2000) and species were identified to species level using taxonomic keys
and papers (e.g. Hindak and Moustaka, 1988; Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2016. Phytoplankton counts
(cells, filaments, colonies) were performed using the Utermöhl method; at least 400 individuals were
counted in each sample. The dimensions of 30 individuals (cells, filaments, colonies) were measured
and the cell, filament and colony volumes were estimated using appropriate geometric formulae (e.g.
Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2014). Both phytoplankton identification and counting were performed in a
highly consistent way by two scientists under the supervision of the same expert. Species comprising
of more than 10% to the total phytoplankton biomass were considered to be dominant.
The phytoplankton indicator that is used here as a target to identify critical changes for successful
ecological restoration and ecological water quality improvement is based on the calculation of the
PhyCoI index (Katsiapi et al, 2016). As a target indicator for lake restoration, we adopt here all five
metrics of PhyCoI, which are a) the total phytoplankton biovolume / biomass, b) the cyanobacterial
biovolume / biomass according to WHO Guidelines for safe water use (Bartram et al, 1999) plus, the
biovolume/ biomass of other known ecosystem disruptive algal blooms, c-d) the modified Nygaard
Index calculated as two different sub-indices using species richness and biomass, respectively and e)
the Quality Group species sub-index using the species richness of certain taxonomic groups that are
associated with water quality. Apart of the obvious harm to humans, harmful algal/cyanobacterial
blooms may disrupt ecosystem structure and function (e.g. blooms of Prymnesium parvum;
Michaloudi et al, 2009; Oikonomou et al, 2012) that is important metric in assessing the ecological
restoration success of a lake. The sum of their scores is a final indicator value, namely the PhyCoI
index, ranging from 0 to 5. This indicator range is subdivided in five classes of ecological quality
corresponding to the following levels of impairment: 0-1: bad, >1-2: poor, >2-3: moderate, >3-4:
good, >4-5: high/reference. For estimating the score of the metric phytoplankton biovolume /
biomass, class boundaries for total phytoplankton biovolume/biomass for Lake Kastoria and Lake
721
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Koronia are those of the preliminary lake types numbered 6 and 8, respectively, by Katsiapi et al
(2016).
Figure 2. View of the water of the Analipsi and Anachoma sampling points in Lake Koronia
in September 2017.
4.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
4.1 Phytoplankton long - term changes
The long - term changes of the total phytoplankton biomass scaled up to boundaries of the five classes
of ecological classification for the preliminary types of the studied lakes according to Katsiapi et al
(2016) are presented in Fig. 3. In Lake Kastoria the high phytoplankton biomass of the period 1994
– 1996, exceeding the poor - bad quality boundary, decreased in 2003 and 2005 indicating a moderate
quality; a reverse trend though in 2007 resulted again in a bad lake water quality in 2014.
Phytoplankton biomass decreased and water quality improved to a moderate level again in 2016 2017. This biomass decline was attributed to a flushing of lake water (Moustaka - Gouni et al, 2017).
Particularly, in 2016, water discharge from Lake Kastoria was regulated by ecologically - based water
level recessions within critical limits (Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2017). In March 1.27 % of lake water
volume was discharged within five days while in May 0.5 % of lake water volume was discharged
within two days. A shift of dominance in early summer from toxic cyanobacteria (Katsiapi et al, 2013)
to other phytoplankton groups is indicative of an improved water quality (Katsiapi et al. 2016).
Species such as the dinoflagellate Ceratium hirundinella and the diatom Fragillaria crotonensis
became dominant in 2016 (Figure 4) while the toxic cyanobacterium Microcystis decreased to very
low levels. In 2017, the dominance of the chrysophytes Dinobryon and Mallomonas in April - May,
and of the cryptophyte Cryptomonas and the diatom Nitzschia in October (Figure 4) indicates further
improvement of ecological water quality, though within the range of a eutrophic lake. This
dinoflagellate, diatom, cryptophyte and chrysophyte dominance from April to October, within the
722
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
hottest period that is ideal for cyanobacterial growth, restricted cyanobacteria during July-September,
suggesting partial recovery of the phytoplankton community (Katsiapi et al, 2013).
In Lake Koronia, phytoplankton biomass levels were indicative of a moderate water quality after the
lake drying out in 2002 and its initial flooding in 2003 (Figure 3). This was due to the initial
heterotrophic phase of plankton succession (Michaloudi et al, 2012). Harmful and disruptive blooms
contributed to the very high phytoplankton biomass recorded during 2004 - 2011, which was
indicative of a bad quality (Moustaka - Gouni et al, 2012). A significant decrease of total
phytoplankton biomass with a simultaneous increase of species diversity, indicative of good quality,
was recorded in 2015 (Figures 3, 5). However, the low phytoplankton biomass in the summer 2015
was preceded by a heterotrophic phase (until June) when the lake water was dominated by detritus
from metaphytic algae and conspicuous heterotrophic bacteria (Moustaka-Gouni et al, unpublished
data). In addition to the heterotrophic phase indicating high organic matter, phytoplankton biomass
although relatively low was not representative of a good water quality due to the dominance of
cyanobacteria (Figure 5). Specifically, in late August, species known to produce cyanotoxins such as
Anabaena aphanizomenoides re-classified as Aphanizomenon favaloroi according to MoustakaGouni et al (2016) and Anabaenopsis elenkinii (Table 1, Figure 5) comprising half of the total
phytoplankton biomass (14.6 mg L-1) coincided with a bird kill in the lake (Action for Wild Life, S.
Kalpakis pers. com.). These two cyanobacterial species were also observed in Lake Koronia in 2004
coinciding with a mass bird kill (Michaloudi et al, 2012). It is worth noting that A. favaloroi, reported
for first time in Europe, formed 100% of the total phytoplankton biomass in the brackish Lake
Vistonis in 2014 and was associated with the production of saxitoxins and a massive fish kill in the
lake (Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2016). Furthermore, the dominant cyanobacteria A. favaloroi and A.
elenkinii in Lake Koronia in August 2015 also dominated the phytoplankton community of the Greek
Lake Karla with a simultaneous cyanotoxins occurrence during the period of pelican mortality in July
2016 (Papadimitriou et al, 2018) and in 2017 (Moustaka-Gouni et al, unpublished data). In 2016 and
2017 despite the increase of water depth an abrupt increase in phytoplankton biomass and a worsening
of the water quality (poor in 2016 and bad in 2017) was observed (Figures 3, 5). The dominant species
were the known toxin-producing cyanobacteria A.aphanizomenoides /A. favaloroi,
Cylindrospermopsis raciborskii, A. elenkinii and Planktothrix sp. (Figure 5; Table 1). A rare
occurrence of the haptophyte Prymnesium cf. parvum and the dinoflagellate Pfiesteria piscicida was
also recorded (Table 1). This was the first record of P. parvum in the plankton community of Lake
Koronia after 13 years of its harmful bloom (Moustaka-Gouni et al. 2012), while this is the first record
of P. piscicida in the lake. Both species have been also recorded in Lake Karla (Table 1) coinciding
with fish kills (e.g. Oikonomou et al. 2012).
Figure 3. Long-term changes of total phytoplankton biomass scaled up to boundaries of the
five classes of ecological classification in lakes Kastoria and Koronia according to Katsiapi et
al (2016). Asterisk in Lake Koronia indicates the heterotrophic phase and the cyanobacteria
dominance in the relatively low phytoplankton biomass in 2015.
723
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Figure 4. Temporal changes in total phytoplankton biomass and species dominance in Lake
Kastoria.
Figure 5. Temporal changes in total phytoplankton biomass and species dominance in Lake
Koronia.
724
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1. Known toxin-producing species identified in the phytoplankton of Lake Koronia (this
study, 2015-2017) and Lake Karla [according to Oikonomou et al. (2012) and Papadimitriou
et al. (2018)].
Lake Koronia
Lake Karla
Anabaena aphanizomenoides
/Aphanizomenon favaloroi
√
√
Anabaenopsis elenkinii
√
√
Cyanobacteria
√
Arthrospira fusiformis
Cylindrospermopsis raciborskii
√
√
Planktothrix sp.
√
√
√
√
√
√
Prymnesiophyceae
Prymnesium cf. parvum
Dinophyceae
Pfiesteria piscicida
4.2 Phytoplankton indicator for assessing success in ecological restoration
The values of the target indicator (PhyCoI index) of the lakes’ restoration success are presented in
Figure 6. In Lake Kastoria, a significant decrease of total phytoplankton biomass with a simultaneous
decrease of the cyanobacterial biomass and a shift in species dominance from 2014 to 2016 resulted
in a sharp increase of the phytoplankton target indicator, reflecting a good water quality. The highest
indicator value (4.2) was recorded in April - May 2017 showing a further success in restoration
through partial recovery of those phytoplankton species reflecting improvement in ecological water
quality. In average, the indicator value was slightly below 3 for the years 2016-2017, the boundary
of moderate-good water quality. However, water quality still remains lower than good, while toxicity
of the remaining cyanobacteria in the lake water with possible health risks related to the use of lake
water for recreational activities has been recorded (Katsiapi and Moustaka-Gouni, 2017). Taking into
consideration these results, further effort for restoration should be continued by authorities to
eliminate toxic cyanobacteria leading to a complete species recovery.
In contrast to the obvious water quality improvement of Lake Kastoria in 2017 and the ongoing
success of ecological restoration (Figure 7), deterioration of water quality was abrupt in Lake Koronia
in 2017. The index value decreased from 2.2 (average 2015) and 1.1 (2016) to 0.8 (average 2017)
(Figure 6). This deterioration (Figure 7) can be explained by the assumption made by Lake et al
(2007) that with the recovery of species, ecological processes will also be restored. In Koronia,
phytoplankton species recovery (such as Stephanodiscus; Figure 5) was restricted in 2015. In 2016
and 2017, the lake’s phytoplankton community (Table 1, Figure 5) was characterized by species
dominating degraded lakes with frequent occurrence of harmful cyanobacterial blooms, disruptive
725
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Prymnesium blooms and euglenophytes blooms, characteristic of polluted waterbodies (e.g.
Oikonomou et al, 2012; Nikouli et al, 2013; Papadimitriou et al, 2018). Attempts to re-establish
populations of good quality species require knowledge of the species’ life-histories. In Koronia, when
the lake water volume increased in 2015-2017, the phytoplankton life-history traits contributed to the
ability of the system to supply recruits (Palmer et al, 1997) and support establishment of the harmful
sediment “seed-bank” species, previously established in the degraded lake as invaders and “seedbank” species (Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2012).
In particular, in 2004, the haptophyte P. parvum was considered a successful invader (MoustakaGouni et al, 2012) because of its well-known invasive behavior (for review see Roelke et al, 2016)
and the favoring habitat conditions in Lake Koronia (brackish water and pollution). Prymnesium can
survive in a wide range of salinities and it blooms in brackish inland waters worldwide as in the case
in the Greek Lake Karla (Oikonomou et al, 2012). It is a heteromorphic haptophyte with flagellate,
immotile cells and cysts in its life-cycle, whereas its immotile phase was first described from Lake
Koronia (Genitsaris et al, 2009). A. aphanizomenoides /A. favaloroi and A. elenkinii were also
recruited from the sediment and overgrew in the lake water. P. piscicida, a known harmful
dinoflagellate worldwide, reported in Karla Reservoir (Oikonomou et al, 2012) and Ismarida Lake in
Greece (Koutrakis et al. 2016) can be considered a new successful invader and a “seed-bank” species
for the future. C. raciborskii could be a “seed-bank” species due to its trait to form akinetes, as it is
known also from the neighboring Lake Volvi (Moustaka-Gouni, 1988). The re-appearance of
Planktothrix and Arthrospira in lake water after several years (Moustaka-Gouni et al, 2007) indicate
their recruitment from the sediment. Overall, in the temporary, very shallow Lake Koronia, the
phytoplankton community in 2017 was highly determined by the past phytoplankton species pool of
the sediment. These results partly explain why phytoplankton community did not recover in Lake
Koronia comprising an inherent barrier for successful restoration.
Figure 6. Temporal variations of the values of the target indicator of the lakes’ restoration
success scaled up to five classes (in the y-axis) of ecological classification according to Katsiapi
et al (2016).
726
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 7. Putative degradation-recovery pathways in Lake Kastoria (A) and Lake Koronia
(B) according to the ‘shifting target model’ as adapted from Sarr (2002) and Lake et al (2007).
Phytoplankton indicator in y-axis corresponds to the target indicator of the lakes’ restoration
success based on PhyCoI (Katsiapi et al, 2016).
References
1. Bartram J., M. Burch, I.R. Falconer, G. Jones and T. Kuiper-Goodman (1999) ‘Situation
assessment, planning and management’. In: Chorus, I., Bartram, J. (Eds.), ‘Toxic Cyanobacteria
in Water’, Taylor & Francis, London, New York.
2. Cook C.M., E. Vardaka and T. Lanaras (2004) ‘Toxic cyanobacteria in Greek Freshwaters, 19872000: Occurrence, toxicity, and impacts in the Mediterranean region’, Acta Hydrochimica et
Hydrobiologica, 32, pp. 107-124.
3. Eckmann R., S. Gerster and A. Kraemer (2006) ‘Yields of European perch from Upper Lake
Constance from 1910 to present’, Fisheries Management and Ecology, 13, pp. 381- 390.
727
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
4. EEA-ETC (2012) Ecological and chemical status and pressures in European waters. Thematic
Assessment for EEA Water 2012, Report, 146. Available at http://icm.eionet.europa.eu.
5. European Community (EC) (2000) ‘Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for the Community action in the field of
water policy’, Official Journal of the European Communities, L 327, pp. 1-72.
6. Genitsaris S., K.A. Kormas and M. Moustaka-Gouni (2009) ‘Microscopic eukaryotes living in a
7. dying lake (Lake Koronia, Greece)’, FEMS Microbiology Ecology,69, pp. 75–83.
8. Hindák F. and M. Moustaka (1988) Planktic cyanophytes of Lake Volvi, Greece. Arch.
Hydrobiol. Suppl. 80: 497–528
9. Lake P.S., N. Bond and P. Reich (2007) ‘Linking ecological theory with stream restoration’,
Freshwater Biology, 52, pp. 597–615.
10. Katsiapi M., E. Michaloudi, M. Moustaka-Gouni and J. Pahissa Lopez (2012) ‘First ecological
evaluation of the ancient Balkan Lake Megali Prespa based on plankton’, Journal of Biological
Research-Thessaloniki, 17, pp. 51–56.
11. Katsiapi M., M. Moustaka-Gouni, E. Vardaka and K.A. Kormas (2013) ‘Different phytoplankton
descriptors show diverse changes in a shallow urban lake (L. Kastoria, Greece) after sewage
diversion’, Fundamental Applied Limnology, 182 (3), pp. 219–230.
12. Katsiapi M. and M. Moustaka-Gouni (2016) ‘Toxin producing cyanobacteria species
identification in aquatic systems’. Technical report In: ARISTEIA operational research program
‘Cyanotoxins in Fresh Waters, Advances in Analysis, Occurrence and Treatment CYANOWATER’.
13. Katsiapi M., M. Moustaka-Gouni and U. Sommer (2016) ‘Assessing ecological water quality of
freshwaters: PhyCoI—a new phytoplankton community Index’, Ecological Informatics, 31, pp.
22–29.
14. Koutrakis E.T., G. Emfietzis, G. Sylaios, M. Zoidou, M. Katsiapi and M. Moustaka-Gouni (2016)
‘Fish kill in Ismarida lake, Greece: identification of drivers contributing to the event’,
Mediterranean Marine Science, http://dx.doi.org/10.12681/mms.1481.
15. Moustaka M. (1988) The structure and dynamics of the phytoplankton assemblages in Lake Volvi,
Greece. I. Phytoplankton composition and abundance during the period March 1984–March 1985.
Archiv fur Hydrobiologie, 112, pp. 251–264.
16. Moustaka-Gouni, M., E. Vardaka, E. Michaloudi, K.A. Kormas, E. Tryfon, H. Mihalatou, S.
Gkelis and Lanaras T. (2006) ‘Plankton food web structure in a eutrophic polymictic lake with a
history of toxic cyanobacterial blooms’, Limnology and Oceanography, 51, pp. 715-727.
17. Mοustaka-Gouni M., E. Michaloudi, M. Katsiapi and S. Genitsaris (2007) ‘The coincidence of an
Arthrospira-Ananaenopsis bloom and the mass mortality of birds in Lake Koronia’, Harmful
Algae News, 35, pp. 6–7.
18. Michaloudi E., M. Moustaka-Gouni, S. Gkelis and K. Pantelidakis (2009) ‘Plankton community
structure during an ecosystem disruptive algal bloom of Prymnesium parvum’, Journal of
Plankton Research, 31(3), pp. 301–309.
19. Moustaka-Gouni M., E. Michaloudi, K.A. Kormas, M. Katsiapi, E. Vardaka and S. Genitsaris
(2012) ‘Plankton changes as critical processes from restoration plans of lakes Kastoria and
Koronia’, European Water, 40, pp. 43-51.
20. Moustaka-Gouni M., A. Hiskia, S. Genitsaris, M. Katsiapi, K. Manolidi, S. Zervou, C.
Christophoridis, T. Triantis, T. Kaloudis and S. Orfanidis (2016) ‘First report of Aphanizomenon
728
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
favaloroi occurrence in Europe associated with saxitoxins and a massive fish kill in Lake Vistonis.
Greece’, Marine Freshwater Research, 67, 1e8.
21. Moustaka-Gouni M., S. Papadopoulos, E. Ampartzaki, S. Gargalas, Th. Μardiris and M. Katsiapi
(2017) ‘First attempt of using the ecologically based water level management of Lake Kastoria
for water quality improvement: Positive results-Zero Cost’, 6th Environmental Conference of
Macedonia, Thessaloniki, Greece (in Greek).
22. Moustaka-Gouni M., E. Michaloudi and U. Sommer (2014) ‘Modifying the PEG model for
Mediterranean lakes—no biological winter and strong fish predation’, Freshwater Biology, 59,
pp. 1136–1144.
23. Nikouli E., K.A. Kormas, P. Berillis, H. Karayanni and M. Moustaka-Gouni (2013) ‘Harmful and
parasitic unicellular eukaryotes persist in a shallow lake under reconstruction (L. Karla, Greece)’,
Hydrobiologia, 718, 73-83.
24. Oikonomou A., M. Κatsiapi, H. Karayanni, M. Moustaka-Gouni and K. Kormas (2012) ‘Plankton
microorganisms coinciding with two consecutive mass fish kills in a newly reconstructed lake’,
Scientific World Journal, 504135.
25. Palmer M.A., R.F. Ambrose and N.L. Poff (1997) ‘Ecological theory and community restoration
ecology’, Restoration Ecology, Vol.5, pp. 291-300.
26. Papadimitriou T., I. Kagalou, V. Bacopoulos and I.D. Leonardos (2010) ‘Accumulation of
microcystins in water and fish tissues: An estimation of risks associated with microcystins in most
of the Greek Lakes’, Environmental Toxicology, 25, pp. 418-427.
27. Papadimitriou T., M. Katsiapi, K. Vlachopoulos, A. Christopoulos, C. Laspidou, M. MoustakaGouni and K. Kormas (2018) ‘Cyanotoxins as the “common suspects” for the Dalmatian pelican
(Pelecanus crispus) deaths in a Mediterranean reconstructed reservoir’, Environmental
Pollution, 234, pp. 779-787.
28. Roelke D.L., A. Barkoh, B.W. Brooks, J.P. Grover, K. D. Hambright, J.W. LaClaire II, P.D.R.
Moeller and R. Patino (2016) ‘A chronicle of a killer alga in the west: ecology, assessment, and
management of Prymnesium parvum blooms’, Hydrobiologia, 764, 29-50.
29. Romo S., M. J. Villena, M. Sahuquillo, J. M. Soria, M. Giménez, T. Alfonso, E. Vicente and M.
R. Miracle (2005) ‘Response of a shallow Mediterranean lake to nutrient diversion: Does it follow
similar patterns as in northern shallow lakes?’, Freshwater Biology, 50, pp. 1706-1717.
30. Sarr D.A. (2002) ‘Riparian livestock exclosure research in the western United States: a critique
and some recommendations’, Environmental Management, 30, pp. 516–526.
31. Sommer U., U. Gaedke and A. Schweizer (1993) ‘The first decade of oligotrophication of Lake
Constance’, Oecologia, 93, pp. 276-284.
32. Suding K.N., K.L. Gross and G.R. Houseman (2004) ‘Alternative states and positive feedbacks
in restoration ecology’, Trends in ecology and evolution, 19 (1), pp. 46-53.
33. Vardaka E., M. Moustaka-Gouni, C.M. Cook and T. Lanaras (2005) ‘Cyanobacterial blooms and
water quality in Greek waterbodies’, Journal of Applied Phycology, 17, pp. 391–401.
729
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
EFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON GROUNDWATER
NITRATE MODELLING
G. Tziatzios*, P. Sidiropoulos, L. Vasiliades, J. Tzabiras, G. Papaioannou, N.
Mylopoulos and A. Loukas
Laboratory of Hydrology and Aquatic Systems Analysis Department of Civil Engineering, UTH,
GR 38334 Pedion Areos Volos,Thessalia, Greece
*Corresponding author: email: getziatz@uth.gr
Abstract
This paper investigates the impacts of climate change on groundwater quality at the eastern
hydrogeological basin of Thessaly in Greece. A modelling system has been applied, consists of
General Circulation Model for estimating the precipitation and temperature changes, a surface
hydrological model (UTHBAL) for the simulation of the surface hydrological processes and the
estimation of the groundwater recharge, a groundwater hydrological model (MODFLOW) for
simulation of groundwater flow and finally a transport and dispersion model of examining the nitrate
fate and transport under different climate changes. The analysis was conducted for two future periods,
a medium term period 2030–2050 and a long term period 2080–2100 examining three different
socioeconomic scenarios SRES (A2, A1B and B1). Concerning the results, nitrate concentration in
groundwater is likely to increase due to the reduction of groundwater recharge forced by climate
change impacts on surface hydrology processes since the agricultural practices does not change.
Keywords: Climate change, water resources management, nitrate contamination, nitrate modelling
1.
INTRODUCTION
Water pollution is a top priority for protecting both the quantity and quality of groundwater.
Groundwater quality degradation constitutes a common problem in the Mediterranean rural basins
because of the multiple pressures in aquifers from excessive pumping and from returning irrigation
flow which occurs after intense and extensive use of agrochemicals (Iglesias et al., 2007).
Nowadays, the issue of climate change is crucial to add in the main pressures on groundwater bodies.
Climate change is the most important environmental threat that mankind currently faces.
Furthermore, it is a fact that climate change and the hydrological cycle are closely linked. The spatial
and temporal distribution changes of precipitation; evapotranspiration; temperature as well as the
implementation of adaptation strategies in agriculture and ecosystems will have a direct impact on
water resources (Stoll et al., 2011).
Mediterranean area is recognized as one of the world regions most affected by climate change. The
majority of climatic models and scenarios predict less precipitation, higher mean and maximal
temperatures in the Mediterranean during the summer (Pascual et al., 2014). In addition to, changes
in the hydrological parameters of precipitation, temperature, evapotranspiration as well as the
groundwater recharge bring changes in the quantity and quality assessment of groundwater hydrology
(Pulido-Velazquez et al., 2015).
The purpose of this paper targets to the assessment of the impact to climate change on groundwater
quality concerning the nitrate pollution in the Lake Karla basin. Nitrogen is the main vital component
to enhance the plant growth. Due to this fact, the intensive use of nitrogen-based fertilizers has been
730
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
dominated in order to increase the productivity as well as the quality of crops in a large number of
rural areas on the world. However, the application of nitrogen-rich fertilizer exceeds the plant demand
and the denitrification capacity of the soil. Nitrogen is led to groundwater in the form of nitrate, which
is highly mobile with little sorption (Almasri and Kaluarachchi, 2005).
2.
KARLA LAKE CATCHMENT STUDY AREA
The basin of Lake Karla is located at the Eastern part of the Larissa plain. It presents a form of closed
elongated basin with a maximum length of 52 km and a width of 17-35 km. The basin is surrounded
by the river Pinios and the Ossa Mountain in the north, the Mavrovouni mountain and Pelion in the
east, the Chalkodonian Mountain and the Megavouni in the south and the Mount Phyllis in the West.
It is a rural basin, as the plain is the most productive agricultural area in Greece, without the presence
of urban and industrial areas. Cultivations correspond to the 67% of catchment area. The database of
CORINE Land Cover 2000 for Greece [EEA, 2007] was used in order to identify land use types of
the catchment area. The major crops are cotton, wheat, alfa-alfa, corn, tobacco and orchards
(Sidiropoulos et al., 2016).
The average slope of the basin is 11%, the terrain is smooth with less than 5% gradient in the
lowlands; while up to 15% slopes in the mountain area. The region of Karla is a tectonic graben
formed during the recent geological times (Sidiropoulos et al., 2013).
2.1 Climate and Hydrology
The microclimate of the region is classified in the Mediterranean continental climate; characterized
by warm and dry summer as well as cold and humid winter. The average annual rainfall in the area
is 450 mm. The average temperature is 16-17 oC, the lowest temperature presented in the winter and
the maximum temperature recorded in the summer. Moreover, during the period December-March
and rarely during the months of November to April observed frozen days. The mean annual relative
humidity is 67- 72 % in the region.
The hydrological basin of Karla presents geomorphological variety with altitude ranges from 40 to
1970 meters and average altitude about 230 m. There are two altitude zones (sub-basins); the
mountainous zone (altitude ≥ 200 m.) and the lowland zone (with altitude <200 m). The aquifer of
the study area is entirely located in the low altitude zone (Sidiropoulos et al., 2015).
2.2 Geology and Hydrogeological Conditions
Impermeable geological structures cover a 30.6% of the total area of Lake Karla watershed, karstic
aquifers cover a 14.5% and permeable structures, which appear mainly in the plain, cover a 54.9%.
The studied area of aquifer consists of alluvial deposits (Figure 1). The basement rocks, consisting of
impermeable marbles and schist, are located underneath the permeable structures (Mylopoulos and
Sidiropoulos, 2014). To the east, there is the Mavrovouni Mountain, which consists mainly of
impermeable bedrocks such as schist. The Thessaly plain continues to the west with the Halkodonion
Mountain located to the southwest .The underlying aquifer is located in the lower part of the basin,
covering an area of 500 km2. Most of the aquifer’s area is plain with an altitude ranging from 45 to
65 m. Only to the southwest the altitude reaches up to 90 m.
731
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Picture 1: Geological map of Lake Karla basin indicating the reservoir and the boundaries of
aquifer and of the basin
3.
METHODOLOGY – MODELLING SYSTEM
A physically based integrated modelling system was applied and its form presented in Figure 2. The
modelling system consists of four computational simulation programs:
General Circulation Models or global climate models (GCMs)
A Surface Hydrological model (UTHBAL) for the simulation of the surface hydrological processes
and the estimation of the groundwater recharge;
A groundwater flow numerical simulator (MODFLOW 2000) and finally
A solute and transport model for the advection and dispersion of nitrates. The evolution of
groundwater [NO3] under climate change was modelled using the MT3DMS code.
Modelling system was applied in a monthly time step from one historical period (06/1995 – 09/2007)
and two futures periods (2030 – 2050, 2080 – 2100). Three different socioeconomic scenarios SRES
(A2, A1B and B1) were examined for the two future periods, with the application of General
Circulation Models. The GCMs did not apply for the historical period.
732
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Picture 2: Flow chart of Nitrate Modelling System
3.1 Global Circulation Models (GCMs)
Climate models are coupled tools for examining local, regional or global climate behavior and
variability in relation to altering conditions on the Earth. They are in different forms; ranging from
simple climate models (SCMs) of the energy-balance type to Earth-system models of intermediate
complexity (EMICs) to comprehensive three-dimensional (atmosphere–ocean) general circulation
models or global climate models (GCMs). GCMs are the most sophisticated tools, available to
simulate the current global climate and future climate scenario (Green et al.; 2011). GCMs frequently
used to develop scenarios of future climate (rainfall; temperature; radiation; etc.) considering different
scenarios. The paper analyses three different socioeconomic scenarios, SRESA2, SRESB1 and
SRESAB1 for two future periods, one mid-term 2030–2050 and one long-term 2080–2100 (Kløve et
al.,2014; Tzabiras et al., 2016).
SRES A2 scenario assumes a strong economic growth, which is regionally oriented, and fragmented
technological change with an emphasis on human wealth. The B1 scenario describes a convergent
world with the same global population that peaks in mid-century and declines thereafter. SRESA1
indicates a rapid change in economic structures toward a service and information economy, by
reducing material and the introduction of clean and resource-efficient technologies. The emphasis is
on global solutions to economic, social and environmental sustainability, including improved equity,
but without additional climate initiatives. The three A1 categories are distinguished in three
subgroups by their technological emphasis: fossil intensive (A1FI), non-fossil energy sources (A1T)
and a balance across all sources (A1B) (where the balance is defined as not relying on a heavily one
particular energy source, but to the assumption that similar improvement rates apply to all energy
supply and end-use technologies) (IPCC, 2007).
733
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
3.2 Surface Hydrological Model
According to Loukas et al. (2007) the surface hydrological model has been developed by a network
of 12 precipitation stations and 26 meteorological stations in the study area for the estimation of
monthly average of surface precipitation; monthly average of evapotranspiration and monthly average
of surface temperature for historical period 1995-2007. Subsequently the statistical downscaling
method have been applied for the mid-term period (2030-2050) and the long-term period (2080-2100)
in the study area (Tzabiras et al., 2016).
3.3 Groundwater Hydrological Model
The groundwater hydrological model has been tested and applied for the study area of the alluvial
aquifer by Sidiropoulos et al. (2013). A grid has been formed by 12,500 active cells and dimension
of 200 m X 200 m. The inflows into the aquifer are: i) the infiltration due to the rainfall, calculated
in a monthly step from UTHBAL, ii) the irrigation return flow, which has been equal to 10% of the
irrigation requirements and has been aggregated in the recharge parameter and iii) the moderate
hydraulic connection with the adjacent aquifer to the west. The outflows are the extracted
groundwater from the wells. Modflow calculates the groundwater movement, the volumetric budget
of aquifer and creates maps of hydraulic heads (Sidiropoulos et al., 2015)
3.4 Solute and transport Model
MT3DMS was applied to study the spatial and temporal distribution of nitrate on the groundwater
regime for climate change prediction purposes. The spatial distribution of nitrates concentration is
defined mainly by the advection and dispersion mechanisms calculating the mass flux at sources/sinks
(Sharma et al., 2014). MT3DMS links to MODFLOW, directly. It retrieves the saturated thickness
for each cell, fluxes across cell interfaces in all directions, and the locations of flow rates of the various
sources and sinks. The nitrate fate and transport model is a three-dimensional areal model, as the
groundwater flow model (Almasri and Kaluarachchi, 2005).
Hydrodynamic dispersion coefficients, consist the main parameters of a solute and transport
modelling. Longitudinal dispersivity (aL) symbolizes the local variations in the velocity field of a
groundwater solute in the direction of groundwater flow (Schulze-Makuch et al., 2005).
The hydrodynamic dispersion parameters depend on geological characteristics of aquifer. As a result,
according to the review paper Gelhar et al. (1992) the longitudinal dispersivity (aL) was set to 20 m
and the transverse dispersivity (aT) value was equal to 0.1. The parameter of molecular diffusion was
considered as neglected. Nitrate leaching was estimated from empirical equation (equation 1) which
is based on bibliography data, that is approximately 30% to 50% of the applied nitrogen fertilizer
leaches to groundwater in the NO3 form (Siarkos et al., 2013). Furthermore, the nitrate loading
parameter based on data from Wichmann (1992) except from the groundwater recharge, which is
calculated by UTHBAL.
Nitrate loading (
rech arg e
Kg
)*0.4
day
mm
* cultivated area (m2 )
365
(1)
Cultivation data have been collected from the Integrated Management System of Cultivated Areas.
The spatial reference of cultivations has been done with the use of a Geographical Information System
at Municipal District Scale (Figure 3).
734
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Picture 3: Location of Sampling Points
A sensitivity analysis was conducted, in order to determine the parameters which mainly induced the
alterations on the simulated nitrate concentrations at the sources/sinks. The sensitivity analysis
indicated that the nitrate leaching parameter is the most uncertain parameter. Therefore, the model
was calibrated for the nitrate leaching parameter via the trial-and-error approach for the 1995 and
2007. Visual inspection (figure 4) and performance measures as explained by Nash–Sutcliffe model
efficiency coefficient (Eff= 0.96) indicate the successful modelling. In this period observed
systematic recording of groundwater quality by the Institute of Geological and Mineral Exploration.
Picture 4: Observed vs simulated concentration values of calibration process
735
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
4.
SIMULATIONS – RESULTS
4.1 Surface Hydrological Model
The study indicates that the average annual rainfall will show a decrease in all three socioeconomic
climatic scenarios in the medium-term future period 2030-2050. According to the expected trends in
all three scenarios, the water budget deficits observed elevated. The climate change impacts are more
obvious in the long-term period 2080-2100. As a conclusion should be mentioned the small increase
of the average annual temperature in the three scenarios for the medium and long term;
simultaneously. The recharge is the parameter which affects mostly the nitrate leaching on aquifer.
The recharge was estimated to 81.4 mm for historical period, while it was reached 83.4 mm for
SRESB1 scenario in the mid-term period, 81.0 mm for SRESA1B and 78.3 mm for the most intense
SRESA2 scenario. Conversely, during the long-term period 2080–2100 the recharge was 80.5 mm
for SRESB1, 75.8 mm for SRESA1B and 74.7 mm for SRESA2.
4.2 Groundwater Hydrological Model
Regarding the historical period 1995–2007, the aquifer’s water balance was negative by 143.65 hm3.
For the mid-term period 2030–2050 recorded an increase of water deficit by 1.02 % at 145.11 hm3
for SRESB1 scenario, 1.62 % at 145.98 hm3 for SRESAB1 scenario and 1.63 % also at 146 hm3 for
SRESA2 scenario. On the other hand, for the long-term period 2080–2100 groundwater deficit is
increased by 4.65 % at 150.33 hm3 for SRESB1 scenario, by 2.12 % at 146.69 hm3 for SRESAB1
and by 3.44 % at 148.59 hm3 for SRESA2 scenario, respectively.
The greatest drawdowns of aquifer are located at its central part for the two future periods. The
absolute height of hydraulic heads range from -100 m to 60 m for the medium future period and reach
up to -160 m for the long future period. The main feature is that the water demand is increased as a
result of climate change and therefore increasing the irrigation requirements.
4.3 Solute and transport Model
All three socioeconomic scenarios present changes in nitrate concentration concerning the historical
period. The differences between the three socio-economic scenarios in the medium and the long term
period can be characterized as negligible. It is worth noting that there is a slight change in the SRESA2
scenario in the northern part of the study area both in the medium-term (2030-2050) and the longterm (2080-2100). Nitrate concentrations on groundwater range from 0 to 30 - 35 mg /l for the
medium term period, while in the long term period range from 0 to 40 - 45 mg/l. The most high
nitrate concentrations are recorded on the south eastern part of the study area concerning the mediumterm period as well as the long term period.
On the contrary, the nitrate concentrations in the historical period range from 0 - 45 mg/l. The
maximum nitrate concentration of 45 mg/l is limited in the historical period on comparison with the
nitrate concentration which is recorded extensively on the long period, at the southeastern part. The
maximum allowable limit according to directive 98/83/EC is the 50 mg/l. In addition to the maximum
limit, the value of 25 mg/l has been also determined as ‘‘indicative value /guidance value’’ by the
directive. It is worth to mention the indicative value due to the fact that a large number of water supply
wells exist in the studied area, which are utilized for domestic use on the surrounding villages and the
Volos city (Sidiropoulos et al., 2015). The differences between the three socio-economic scenarios in
comparison with the historical period are ranged from 0 to 10 mg/l in the mid-period and 0 to 15 mg/l
in the long period (2080-2100).
736
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Picture 5: Nitrate concentrations maps of: a) Historical Period 2007; b) SRESA1B 2050,
SRESA1B 2100 c) SRESB1 2050, SRESB1 2100; d) SRESA2 2050, SRESA2 2100
5.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Climate change and variability will likely have numerous effects on recharge rates and mechanisms.
According to Green et al., (2011) a large number of climate change studies have predicted reduced
recharge although the effects of climate change on recharge may not necessarily be negative in all
aquifers during all the period. The effect of climate variability is responsible for changes in the
aquifer. From the groundwater climate change point of view, the optimal groundwater management,
the optimum volume of pumped water, the number and the location of pumping wells have to be
determined (Sidiropoulos et al., 2013; Tzabiras et al., 2016).
Concerning the groundwater quality, an increase in the concentration of nitrates are observed. This is
justified by the fact that nitrates are characterized as water soluble contaminants and the reduction of
recharge prevent their dissolution. Antonakos and Lambrakis, (2000), indicated that the areas of
increased recharge coincide with the areas of diluted nitrate ion concentration. Therefore, the nitrate
concentration in groundwater mainly depends on the recharge
Regarding the implications for nitrate leaching to groundwater as a result of climate change, Stuart
and his associates (Stuart et al., 2011) referred to the fact that there is not well enough understanding
them yet to make useful predictions without a lot of observed data. The few studies, which address
the hydrological cycle, show likely nitrate leaching ranging from limited increases to a possible
doubling of aquifer concentrations by 2100, since the current cultivation pattern will not change
(Stuart et al., 2011).
Acknowledgements
Georgios Tziatzios has been co-financed -via a programme of State Scholarships Foundation (IKY)
- by the European Union (European Social Fund - ESF) and Greek national funds through the action
entitled ”Scholarships programme for postgraduates studies -2nd Study Cycle” in the framework of
737
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
the Operational Programme ”Human Resources Development Program, Education and Lifelong
Learning” of the National Strategic Reference Framework (NSRF) 2014 – 2020.
Dr. Pantelis Sidiropoulos is a post-doctoral scholar of Stavros Niarchos Foundation and the
University of Thessaly. Part of the scientific publication was held within the framework of the
invitation "Granting of scholarship for Post-Doctoral Research" of the University of Thessaly, which
is being implemented by the University of Thessaly and was funded by the Stavros Niarchos
Foundation.
References
1. Almasri, M.N., Kaluarachchi, J.J (2007). Modeling Nitrate contamination of groundwater in
agricultural watersheds. Journal of Hydrology, Vol 343, 211-229.
2. Antonakos A. and Lambrakis N., (2000). Hydrodynamic characteristics and nitrate propagation
in Sparta aquifer, Water Resources Research, Vol 34, pp. 3977–3986.
3. Gelhar L. W, Welty C.,Rehfeldt K., (1992) ‘A critical review on Data on Field - Scale Dispersion
in Aquifers, Water Resources Research , Vol 28 , pp. 1955 -1974.
4. Green, T.R., Taniguchi, M., Kooi, H., Gurdak, J.J., Allen, D.M., Hiscock, K.M., Treidel, H.,
Aureli, A., (2011) ‘Beneath the surface: impacts of climate change on groundwater’, Journal of
Hydrology, Vol 405, pp. 532–560.
5. Iglesias A., L. Garrote, Fr. Flores, M. Moneo (2007). ‘Challenges to Manage the Risk of Water
Scarcity and Climate Change in the Mediterranean, Water Resources Management, Vol 21, pp.
775–788.
6. Institute of Geological and Mining Research. Recording and evaluation of the hydrogeological
characteristics of the groundwater systems of the country, Basement of the Aquatic Potential of
Thessaly, 2010 (WD 08).
7. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change IPCC (2007) Climate Change 2007 - The Physical
science basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Solomon S, Qin D,Manning M, Chen Z,
Marquis M, Averyt KB, Tignor M, Miller HL (eds), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
8. Kløve, B., Ala-Aho, P., Bertrand, G., Gurdak, J.J., Kupfersberger, H., Kvœrner, J., Muotka, T.,
Mykrä, H., Preda, E., Rossi, P., Bertacchi Uvo, C., Velasco, E., Wachniew, P., Pulido-Velázquez,
M., (2014) ‘Climate change impacts on groundwater and dependent ecosystems’ Journal of
Hydrology, Vol 518, pp. 250–266
9. Loukas A., Mylopoulos N. and Vasiliades L. (2007) ‘A Modelling System for the Evaluation of
Water Resources Management Scenarios in Thessaly, Greece’, Water Resources Management,
Vol 21, pp. 1673 – 1702.
10. Ministry of Rural Development and Food. Data on the Integrated Management System of
Cultivated Areas.
11. Pascual D., Pla E., Lopez-Bustins J.A., Retana J., Terradas J. (2015) ‘Impacts of climate change
on water resources in the Mediterranean Basin: a case study in Catalonia, Spain’ Hydrological
Sciences Journal, Vol 60, pp. 2132-2147.
12. Pulido-Velazquez M., Peña-Haro S., García-Prats A., Mocholi-Almudever A. F., Henriquez-Dole
L., Macian-Sorribes H., and Lopez-Nicolas A. (2015) ‘Integrated assessment of the impact of
climate and land use changes on groundwater quantity and quality in the Mancha Oriental system
(Spain), Hydrological and Earth System Sciences, Vol 19, pp.1677-1693.
13. Schulze-Makuch D., (2005). Longitudinal dispersivity data and implications for scaling
behaviour. Groundwater, Vol 3, 443-456.
738
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
14. Sharma MK, Jain CK, Rao GT, Rao VV., (2005) ‘Modelling of lindane transport in groundwater
of metropolitan city Vadodara, Gujarat, India’ Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
2015, Vol 187: 295.
15. Siarkos I., Kouvaritaraki D, Charcharidou A. and Theodosiou N., (2013) Modelling the Effect of
Agricultural activities on Groundwater Quality in the Aquifer of N. Moudania. Proc. of Int. Conf.
Conference on Environmental Science and Technology XIII, 5-7 September, Athens.
16. Sidiropoulos P., Mylopoulos N., Loukas A., (2013) ‘Optimal management of an overexploited
aquifer under climate change: the Lake Karla case, Water Resources Management’, Vol 27, pp.
1635–1649.
17. Sidiropoulos P., Mylopoulos N., Loukas A., (2015) ‘Stochastic simulation and management of an
over-exploited aquifer using an integrated modeling system’ Water Resources Management,
Vol 29, pp. 929–943.
18. Sidiropoulos P., Mylopoulos N., Loukas A., (2016). ‘Reservoir-aquifer combined optimization
for groundwater restoration: The case of Lake Karla watershed, Greece’ Water Utility Journal,
Vol (12), pp. 17-26.
19. Stoll S., Hendricks Franssen H.J., Butts M., and Kinzelbach W. (2011) ‘Analysis of the impact of
climate change on groundwater related hydrological fluxes: A multi-model approach including
different downscaling methods’ Hydrological and Earth System Sciences, Vol 15, pp. 21–38
20. Tzabiras J., Vasiliades L., Sidiropoulos P, Mylopoulos N, Loukas A (2016) ‘Evaluation of Water
Resources Management Strategies to Overturn Climate Change Impacts on Lake Karla
Watershed’ Water Resources Management, Vol 30, pp. 5819– 5844.
21. Wichmann W., (1992) ‘World Fertilizer Use Manual’, BASF AG, Germany, IFA, France.
739
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
AN ASSESSMENT APPROACH TO INVESTIGATE CLIMATE
CHANGE IMPACTS ΙN CHANIA GROUNDWATER SYSTEM
D. Charchousi1*, Κ. Spanoudaki2, A. Karali3, A. Nanou-Giannarou4, C.
Giannakopoulos3, M.P. Papadopoulou1
1
Laboratory of Physical Geography and Environmental Impacts, School of Rural and Surveying
Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Athens, Greece,
2
Institute of Applied and Computational Mathematics, Foundation for Research and TechnologyHellas, Heraklion, Crete, Greece,
3
Institute for Environmental Research and Sustainable Development, National Observatory of
Athens, Athens (Greece),
4
Laboratory of Applied Hydraulics, Department of Water Resources and Environmental
Engineering, School of Civil Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Athens, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: charchousi@gmail.com
Abstract
Prolonged dry periods observed during the past years and intense groundwater abstraction for
irrigation purposes have raised awareness on groundwater resources management in many
agricultural areas. Climate change is expected to increase the frequency of extreme dry periods and
groundwater systems recharge will be seriously affected.
The present study emphasizes on the investigation of climate change impacts on groundwater
availability in Chania plain groundwater system. Chania plain is considered one of the most important
agricultural regions in Crete, where groundwater is the prime source used for irrigation. Intense
irrigation needs put pressure on the groundwater system, especially during the dry period (AprilSeptember), when the water table is lowered by around 3.5 m. Groundwater flow simulations for the
area, using climatic projections for meteorological variables produced by the RCA4 Regional Climate
Model of the Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute (SMHI) driven by the Max Planck
Institute for Meteorology model MPI-ESM-LR, forced by the IPCC RCP 4.5 and 8.5 scenarios, have
shown an additional decrease of the water table of approximately 4 m, during the dry period of
predicted dry years.
Keywords: Groundwater system recharge, IPCC scenarios, MODFLOW, Irrigation water
1.
INTRODUCTION
Agriculture is an economic sector vulnerable to climate change, as it is highly dependent on climatic
conditions and on the availability of surface and groundwater resources for irrigation purposes.
During the last decades, forced by the importance of agricultural sector for the economic
sustainability and food security, awareness has been raised on future climate change impacts on
irrigation water. In many agricultural regions of the Mediterranean basin, agriculture is already under
pressure due to limited irrigation water resources, as Mediterranean countries are already facing
extended periods of drought during summer. Additional pressure is expected to be imposed due to
water resources vulnerability to future climate change.
Crete is highly dependent on the agriculture sector. The utilised agricultural area (consisting of arable
land, permanent crops, pastures - transitional forest/shrubland, pastures - combined
740
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
shrubland/herbaceous plants, pastures and heterogeneous agricultural areas) occupies approximately
70% of the total area and amounts to 653,305ha (Hellenic Statistical Authority, 2000/2010). About
42.3% of the cultivated land is irrigated [LIFE ADAPT2CLIMA, 2016].
In the present study, an assessment of groundwater system response to future climate change in
Chania Plain, an important agricultural and touristic area of Crete, under the pressure of climate
change climatic projections for meteorological variables produced by the RCA4 Regional Climate
Model of the Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute (SMHI) driven by the Max Planck
Institute for Meteorology model MPI-ESM-LR, forced by the IPCC RCP 4.5 and 8.5 scenarios is
presented.
2.
CASE STUDY
The Chania Plain is located on the north part of the Chania Prefecture, Crete, Greece (Figure 1). It is
mainly an agricultural area, where the main cultivations are olives, avocados, citrus and annual crops
such as tomatoes. In the coastal part of the aquifer, tourism zones have been developed.
Figure 1: The Chania Plain aquifer
The pilot aquifer is part of the granular aquifer of Chania, namely GR1300022 and is characterized
as satisfying in terms of quality and quantity [Special Secretariat for Water, 2015]. However, the
intense agricultural activities in the area impose significanet pressure to the groundwater resources.
As shown in Figure 2, the aquifer mainly consists of alluvium deposits, medium permeability rocks
and phyllites–quartzites units. A southern part of the aquifer neighbors with high permeability rocks
which comprise karstic limestones. In this part of the aquifer, Ayia springs are met, consisting a
significant recharge for the groundwater system.
741
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Figure 2: Hydrogeological map of Chania pilot aquifer
3.
METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH
A groundwater flow model is developed for Chania Plain aquifer in order to evaluate the impact of
future climate change and irrigation practices on groundwater availability. Groundwater flow model
calibration and validation is followed by the selection of a characteristic mean hydrological year to
approximate the current state with respect to water table. Then, a series of simulation runs were
performed in order to estimate changes in groundwater variability under pressure of a foreseen
extreme dry hydrological year based on the Regional Climate Models MPI-RCA4, forced by the IPCC
RCP 4.5 and 8.5 scenarios. The steps followed to investigate climate change impacts in groundwater
system are displayed in Figure 3.
Figure 3: Methodology flow chart
3.1 Groundwater flow model development
The Chania Plain groundwater flow model was developed using US Geological Survey MODFLOW
algorithm [McDonald and Harbaugh, 1988], a block-centered finite-difference computer code that
solves the groundwater flow equation. Visual MODFLOW Flex [Waterloo Hydrogeologic, 2017] was
also used as a pre- and post- processor. The groundwater flow model developed was calibrated on
transient conditions for the hydrological years 2004-2008 for the values of hydraulic conductivities
and pumping rates obtained from previous reports and the literature using a trial and error approach.
742
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Irrigation return flow during the irrigation season was estimated and included into the model as
additional recharge. The groundwater system is also enriched through local river interactions and
Ayia springs. Historic hydraulic heads measurements were used to calibrate subsurface flow while
pumping rates were estimated based on previous reports and data obtained from communication with
local farmers. Since calibration had been completed, the model was validated based on the additional
available historic data.
3.2 Climate change projections
In order to assess climate change impacts on Chania Plain aquifer, future precipitation data derived
from sets of Regional Climate Models (RCMs) simulations carried out were used in order to estimate
future recharge in the aquifer [LIFE ADAPT2CLIMA, 2017]. Future precipitation data used are based
on RCA4 Regional Climate Model of the Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute (SMHI)
(Strandberg et al., 2014 and references therein) driven by the Max Planck Institute for Meteorology
model MPI-ESM-LR [Popke et al., 2013] hereafter MPI-SMHI. The model has a horizontal resolution
of 12km2 and was developed within the framework of EURO-CORDEX (Coordinated Downscaling
Experiment - European Domain). Future model projections were based on two new IPCC scenarios,
namely the RCP4.5 and the RCP8.5.
RCP4.5 is a stabilization scenario where total radiative forcing is stabilized before 2100 by the
employment of a range of technologies and strategies for reducing greenhouse gas emissions [Clarke
et al., 2007]. Radiative forcing in RCP4.5 peaks at about 4.5 W/m2 (~540 ppm CO2) in year 2100
(Thomson et al., 2011). RCP4.5 is comparable to the SRES scenario B1 with similar CO2
concentrations and median temperature increases by 2100 according to Rogelj et al. [2012]. RCP8.5
is characterized by increasing greenhouse gas emissions over time, representative for scenarios in the
literature leading to high greenhouse gas concentration levels. RCP8.5 assumes a high rate of
radiative forcing increase, peaking at 8.5 W/m2 (~940 ppm CO2) in year 2100 (Riahi et al., 2011).
4.
RESULTS
4.1 Assessment of the current water resources conditions in Chania Plain aquifer
Chania Plain aquifer is characterized as adequate in terms of quantity conditions (Special Secretariat
for Water, 2015). Based on available historic head data series, it is observed that there is a balance
between groundwater withdrawal and recharge. However, an approximately 3.5 m level difference is
observed from dry to wet period (Figure 4).
(a) Wells location in Chania Plain pilot area
743
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
(b) Historic hydraulic head measurements – DL29
(c) Historic hydraulic head measurements – PL24
Figure 4: Groundwater level at various observation wells in Chania Plain pilot area
This 3.5 m groundwater level fluctuation between the dry and the wet period is also depicted on the
results of the numerical simulations (Figure 5).
(a)
(b)
Groundwater level contour 40 m a.m.s.l.
Figure 5: Groundwater level in Chania Plain aquifer for the base hydrological year – (a) end
of wet period and (b) end of dry period
744
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4.2 Chania Plain aquifer response to future climate change, under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5
Predicted groundwater level in Chania Plain aquifer for an extreme dry hydrological year, based on
the MPI-SMHI model, forced by the IPCC RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5 scenarios are presented on Figures
6 and 7, respectively.
(a)
(b)
Groundwater level contour 40 m a.m.s.l.
Figure 6: Predicted groundwater level in Chania Plain aquifer for extreme dry hydrological
year, based on the MPI-SMHI, under RCP 4.5 – (a) end of wet period and (b) end of dry
period
(a)
(b)
Groundwater level contour 40 m a.m.s.l.
Figure 7: Predicted groundwater level in Chania Plain aquifer for extreme dry hydrological
year, based on the MPI-SMHI, under RCP 8.5 – (a) end of wet period and (b) end of dry
period
Groundwater flow simulation results for the Chania Plain aquifer, using climatic projections forced
by the IPCC RCP 4.5 and 8.5 scenarios, have shown an additional decrease of the water table of
approximately 4 m, during the dry period of predicted dry years.
745
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
5.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Based on the present analysis Chania Plain aquifer will be subjected to severe climate change impacts,
as a mean groundwater level depletion of almost 4 m is foreseen. Especially in Ayia area, 6.5 m
depletion of mean groundwater level is estimated. Consequently, the results of the present research
underline the need for changes in agricultural practices. At the same time a more direct interpretation
of climate change impacts to aquifer sustainability is required. In 2012, Gleeson et al. introduced
Groundwater Footprint (GWF) that expresses the area required to sustain groundwater use and
groundwater dependent ecosystem services. GWF represents a water balance between aquifer inflows
and outflows, focusing on environmental flow requirements. Charchousi et al. [2017] have used the
GWF concept to assess groundwater resources sustainability under the current climatic conditions
and the existing pumping schemes. The estimated GWF indicates that the groundwater management
in the area is sustainable, in accordance to the aquifer characterization by the Special Secretariat for
Water [2015] as satisfying in terms of quantity.
The GWF could be proved to be a useful tool for groundwater analysis and policy as it can raise
awareness since it is intuitive to the general public. The GWF could also be proved to be useful for
identifying groundwater dependent ecosystems vulnerability to future climate change. For these
reasons, GWF estimation under the foreseen extreme dry years examined in the present study is
ongoing.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to acknowledge the European financial instrument for the Environment, LIFE,
for the financial support in the framework of the ADAPT2CLIMA project LIFE14 CCA/GR/000928.
References
1. Charchousi D., Spanoudaki K. and Papadopoulou M.P. (2017) ‘Assessing Groundwater
Resources Sustainability Using Groundwater Footprint Concept’, European Geosciences Union
General Assembly 2017, Vienna, Austria.
2. Clarke, L., J. Edmonds, H. Jacoby, H. Pitcher, J. Reilly and R. Richels (2007) ‘Scenarios of
Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Atmospheric Concentrations’, Sub-report 2.1A of Synthesis
and Assessment Product 2.1 by the U.S. Climate Change Science Program and the Subcommittee
on Global Change Research. Department of Energy, Office of Biological & Environmental
Research.
3. Gleeson T., Y. Wada, M. F. P. Bierkens and L. P. H. van Beek (2012) ‘Water balance of global
aquifers revealed by groundwater footprint’, Nature, 488(7410), pp. 197-200.
4. Hellenic Statistical Authority www.statistics.gr
5. LIFE ADAPT2CLIMA (2016) ‘Knowledge capitalization concerning the sectors of
agriculture in the regions of Crete, Sicily and Cyprus’, Deliverable C1.1, project
ADAPT2CLIMA LIFE14 CCA/GR/000928. http://adapt2clima.eu/uploads/2017/Del_C1_1.pdf
6. LIFE ADAPT2CLIMA (2017) ‘Future projections on climatic indices with particular
relevance to agriculture for the three islands (coarse resolution) and for each agricultural
pilot area (fine resolution)’, Deliverable C3.1, project ADAPT2CLIMA LIFE14
CCA/GR/000928.
7. McDonald M.G. and A.W. Harbaugh (1988) ‘A modular three dimensional finite-difference
ground-water flow model’, Techniques of Water-Resources Investigations of the U.S.
Geological Survey, Book 6, Chapter A1.
746
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
8. Popke D., B. Stevens and A. Voigt (2013) ‘Climate and climate change in a radiative-convective
equilibrium version of ECHAM6’ Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems, 5(1), pp.
1–14.
9. Riahi K., S. Rao, V. Krey, C. Cho, V. Chirkov, G. Fischer, G. Kindermann, N. Nakicenovic, and
P. Rafaj (2011) ‘RCP8.5—A scenario of comparatively high greenhouse gas emissions’, Climatic
Change, 109, pp. 33–57.
10. Rogelj J., M. Meinshausen and R. Knutti (2012) ‘Global warming under old and new scenarios
using IPCC climate sensitivity range estimates’, Nature Climate Change, 2, pp. 248–253.
11. Special Secretariat for Water (2015) ‘River Basin Management Plan District of Crete’.
12. Strandberg G., A. Bärring, U.Hansson, C. Jansson, C.Jones and E. Kjellström (2014) ‘CORDEX
scenarios for Europe from the Rossby Centre regional climate model RCA4’, Reports
Meteorology and Climatology, No. 116, SMHI.
13. Thomson A. M., K.V. Calvin, S.J. Smith, G. Page Kyle, A. Volke, P. Patel, S. Delgado-Arias, B.
Bond-Lamberty, M.A. Wise, L.E. Clarke and J.A. Edmonds (2011) ‘RCP4.5: A pathway for
stabilization of radiative forcing by 2100’, Climatic Change, 109, pp. 77–94.
14. Waterloo Hydrogeologic Inc. (2004) ‘Visual MODFLOW Version 3.1.84 Software and
Documentation’, Waterloo Hydrogeologic Inc.
747
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
SALINITY EFFECTS ON DIFFERENT VARIETIES OF
AMARANTUS SP.
G. Kacienė
Vytautas Magnus University, Dept. of Environmental Sciences, LT-44404 Kaunas, Lithuania
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: giedre.kaciene@vdu.lt, tel : +37067245718
Abstract
Amarantus sp. is recognized as a promising plant species due to high nutrition value and resistance
to adverse environmental conditions. Due to C4 photosynthetic pathway, amaranth can be grown
under elevated salinity or water deficit. As salinity is one of the most serious and continuously
increasing limiting agents in agriculture, investigations of resistant, high productivity and nutritional
value agricultural crops is of particular importance. The aim of this study was to investigate and to
compare the resistance of 3 Lithuanian genotypes of Amaranth (‘Raudonukai’, ‘Rausvukai’ and
‘Geltonukai’) to increased salinity. Pot experiments were conducted in growth chambers, plants were
exposed to 50 and 150 mM NaCl levels. Seed germination, shoot growth and photosynthetic rate were
investigated. At the earliest growth stage ‘Raudonukai’ demonstrated the highest resistance,
germinating 2-3 fold better as compared to other varieties. In contrast, growth of aboveground
biomass of ‘Raudonukai’ was the most seriously affected (up to 54% decrease), followed by
‘Geltonukai’ and ‘Rausvukai’. Leaf area decreased similarly in all varieties, slightly higher effect was
characteristic for ‘Rausvukai’. The photosynthetic rate declined for all plant species with increasing
salinity and exposure time. 50mM salinity level had no impact on photosynthetic performance. The
strongest effect for ‘Rausvukai’ and ‘Raudonukai’ was observed after 10 days of exposure to 150
mM (up to 33% and 24% inhibition, respectively), followed by adaptation and recovery to control
level after 15 days of exposure. Similar reduction of photosynthetic rate was detected for
‘Geltonukai’, however, photosynthetic adaptation was not observed. Results of this study have shown
that Amaranth can be classified as salinity resistant crop species, as vegetative growth and
photosynthetic performance were not significantly affected by relatively high (50mM) NaCl
concentrations. The negative effects of salinity depended on the growth stage of variety of Amaranth.
The most resistant variety at germination growth stage and with respect to photosynthetic
performance was ‘Raudonukai’, followed by ‘Rausvukai’ and ‘Geltonukai’.
Keywords: Amarantus sp., Soil salinity, Stress resistance, Germination, Photosynthetic rate
1.
INTRODUCTION
Soil salinity is one of the most prevalent soil degradation factor in Earth. In Europe, salt-affected soils
are in Hungary, Romania, Greece and Italy. According to the European Commission, there was about
had 1-3 million hectares of soils, affected by increased salinity in 2009, in the European Union. More
than 800 million hectares of land around the world are affected by salinity. It accounts for over 6%
of the world's land area (Munns & Tester, 2008).
Plant growth can be triggered by osmotic and ionic effects of increased soil salinity (Panuccio et al.,
2014). The response in plants occurs in two stages: the first one is the osmotic stress phase, the second
is the toxic stress induced by salts accumulated in leaves (Munns, 2002). The general effect is necrosis
and growth retardation (Omami & Hammes, 2006). One of the strategies to avoid salinity stress is
prolonged stomatal closure. It limits transpiration and sustains osmotic balance within plant tissues.
748
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
C4 photosynthesis allows the plants to acquire CO2 during the periods of reduced stomatal
conductance, therefore it increases plant resistance not only to drought and heat, but also to increased
soil salinity.
One of the C4 plants, characterized by high tolerance to soil salinity is Amaranths (Jeyanthi et al.,
2010; Amukali et al., 2016). These plants belong to the dicotyledones class, the caryophyllidae
family, the genus Amoranthaceae Juss. Because of the huge variety of genotypes, taxonomic
classification of Amaranths is difficult. There are about 60 genotypes of Amaranths in the world,
most of which are wild (Stallknecht & Schulz-Schaeffer, 1993). Amaranths are grown mostly for
leafs and grains, having high nutritive value (Kauffman & Weber, 1990). The aim of this study was
to investigate and to compare the resistance of 3 Lithuanian genotypes of Amaranth (‘Raudonukai’,
‘Rausvukai’, ‘Geltonukai’) to increased salinity at the germination and juvenile growth stages.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Plants were grown in phytotron chambers with the following conditions: photoperiod - 14 h, average
day/night temperature - 22° C /16° C, relative humidity - 75 %, light intensity - 150 µmol m-2 s-1. In
order to investigate salinity effects on the earliest growth stages of germination of Amaranth plants,
seeds were germinated in Petri dishes, 25 seeds in each. Petri dishes were protected from direct light.
Seeds were exposed to 0 mM, 50 mM and 150 mM NaCl solutions. Germination was monitored for
7 days.
A pot experiment was carried out to investigate salinity effects on Amaranth’s growth and
photosynthesis. Ten seeds were planted in plastic pots (volume 3 l), in universal peat substrate,
prepared for germination and growing of agricultural plants. Seedlings were rarefied till one plant per
pot 1 week after germination. NaCl treatment was started 7 weeks after germination and lasted for 15
days. Plants were watered with equal amounts of 0 mM, 50 mM ir 150 mM NaCl solutions.
At the end of the treatment, photosynthetic rate, dry shoot biomass and leaf area were analyzed. The
measurements of gas exchange were performed using a portable closed infrared gas analyzer LI-COR
6400 (LI-COR, Inc., Lincoln, NE, USA) with randomly selected the youngest fully expanded leaf.
Leaf area was measured with a scanner (CanoScan 4400F, Canon, USA) and determined using GIMP
2.8 software. All measurements were carried out in three replicates. The data were analysed using
STATISTICA 8 and the results were expressed as the mean values and their confidence intervals
(p<0.05) (±95% CI).
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Salinity effect on Amaranth’s germination
Salinity effect on Amaranth seed germination highly varied between varieties and NaCl stress
intensity (Figure 1). The variety ‘Raudonukai’ was least affected by increasing salinity: 50 mM NaCl
concentration reduced its germination by 18%; 150 mM NaCl concentration induced stronger
inhibition, however no statistically significant differences were detected between these two stress
levels. The variety ‘Rausvukai’ was similarly resistant to lower level of salinity, however it was
sharply inhibited by stronger NaCl stress. ‘Geltonukai’ was the most sensitive variety at this growth
stage, as germination of these plants were inhibited by approximately 40% and 78% throughout all
germinating periods for 50 mM and 150 mM NaCl stress, respectively (Figure 1). Besides inhibition
of germination, a delay in it was also observed for all Amaranth’s varieties, as it has been already
detected in the previous studies (Jeyanthi et al., 2010; Amukali et al., 2016).
749
Number of germinated
seeds, %
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
60
0
50
50
150
40
30
20
10
0
A
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Days after planting
Figure 1. Salinity effects on germination of different varieties of Amaranthus seeds (letters
represents different varieties: A-‘Rausvukai’, B-‘Geltonukai’, C-‘Raudonukai’).
3.2 Salinity effects on photosynthesis and plants’ growth
Different varieties of Amaranth varied significantly according to the tolerance to increased soil
salinity, as was detected by diverse inhibition of growth. ‘Rausvukai’ was found to be the most
tolerant with respect to dry shoot biomass: 150 mM NaCl induced the lowest (15.4%) growth
inhibition; about two-fold stronger effect was observed on other investigated varieties. Moreover,
‘Raudonukai’ was significantly affected by even 50 mM NaCl concentration. Whereas leaf
development of different varieties showed an opposite tendency. The treatment with 150 mM NaCl
solution reduced leaf area of all varieties of Amaranth plants, but the strongest negative effect was
observed for ‘Rausvukai’: 47% (p <0.05) reduction compared to control was detected. The order of
decreasing tolerance to salinity of investigated Amaranth plants with respect to leaf development was
as follows: ‘Geltonukai’, ‘Raudonukai’ and ‘Rausvukai’ (Figure 2).
750
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2. Salinity effects on leaf area and dry shoot biomass of different varieties of
Amaranthus.
The photosynthetic response of investigated Amaranth plants was measured 5, 10 and 15 days after
the beginning of salinity treatment as well as immediately before the treatment. The negative NaCl
effect on photosynthetic carbon assimilation revealed at the10th day of exposure, as photosynthetic
rate, measured 5 days after the treatment, did not differ significantly from the values measured before
the treatment. The differences between NaCl treated plants and control were also mostly statistically
insignificant 5 days after the beginning of the treatment. At the 10th day of the NaCl treatment an
effect of 50 mM NaCl level was still negligible for all varieties; however, 150 mM induced significant
reduction of photosynthetic rate: ~20% in ‘Raudonukai’ and ‘Geltonukai’ and 31% in ‘Rausvukai’.
The negative effect of lower salinity level was observed at the 15th day of exposure in ‘Geltonukai’
and ‘Rausvukai’, but not in ‘Raudonukai’. Moreover, the photosynthetic rate of the latter variety
recovered completely at the 15th day of exposure to 150 mM salinity level. A certain photosynthetic
adaptation to high level of salinity was also detected in ‘Rausvukai’ variety. In contrast, “Geltonukai”
was not able to adapt to prolonged salinity, as was detected from intensifying impairment of
photosynthesis (Table 1).
TABLE 1. Photosynthetic rate (µmols CO2 m-2 s-1) of different varieties of Amaranths exposed
to increasing salinity. Values are the means ± SE; letters indicate significant differences
between the measurements of particular variety.
Variety
‘Raudonukai’
‘Geltonukai’
‘Rausvukai’
4.
Treatment
Control
50 mM
150 mM
Control
50 mM
150 mM
Control
50 mM
150 mM
Before
treatment
2.99 ± 0.13 a
Days after beginning of the treatment
5 d.
10 d.
15 d.
2.77 ± 0.17 ab
2.79 ± 0.18 ab
2.75 ± 0.23 ab
2.68 ± 0.15 ab
2.49 ± 0.15 b
2.83 ± 0.13 a
2.92 ± 0.26 a
2.73 ± 0.22 ab
2.70 ± 0.20 ab
2.96 ± 0.10 a
2.97 ± 0.10 a
2.79 ± 0.09 ab
2.65 ± 0.05 b
2.28 ± 0.03 c
2.79 ± 0.07 a
3.00 ± 0.07 a
2.26 ± 0.02 c
2.85 ± 0.05 a
3.01 ± 0.06 a
2.00 ± 0.03 c
2.82 ± 0.14 ab
2.74 ± 0.21 ab
2.85 ± 0.08 ab
2.92 ± 0.09 a
2.41 ± 0.10 bc
2.23 ± 0.10 bc
2.83 ± 0.11 a
2.44 ± 0.12 b
2.69 ± 0.18 ab
CONCLUSIONS
Results of this study have shown that Amaranth can be classified as salinity resistant crop species, as
vegetative growth and photosynthetic performance were not affected by relatively high (50mM) NaCl
concentrations. At the earliest growth stage ‘Raudonukai’ demonstrated the highest resistance,
germinating 2-3 fold better as compared to other varieties. In contrast, growth of aboveground
biomass of ‘Raudonukai’ was the most seriously affected, followed by ‘Geltonukai’ and ‘Rausvukai’.
751
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
In spite of negligible growth inhibition, leaf development of variety ‘Rausvukai’ was affected
stronger than other varieties. Considering the photosynthetic performance, ‘Raudonukai’ was
detected to be the most tolerant variety: carbon assimilation was not affected by lower salinity.
Moreover, the negative effect of higher salinity level on this variety was relatively low and completely
disappeared after 15 days of the beginning of exposure. In contrast, the strongest inhibition of
photosynthetic system was observed in ‘Geltonukai’. Summarizing the results of this study it can
stated that ‘Raudonukai’ is the most salinity-tolerant of the three investigated Amaranth varieties,
since these plants demonstrated the highest resistance of germination and photosynthetic system. Less
tolerant variety is ‘Rausvukai’, showing the highest resistance with respect to growth of dry shoot
biomass, but only moderate resistance of photosynthetic system and high sensitivity of germination.
‘Geltonukai’, which growth was moderately affected, but germination and photosynthesis was
strongly inhibited by NaCl, could be classified as the most salinity-sensitive of investigated
Amaranths’ varieties.
Acknowledgements
Participation in the conference is funded by the European Social Fund under the No 09.3.3-LMT-K712 “Development of Competences of Scientists, other Researchers and Students through Practical
Research Activities” measure. Many thanks to Giedrė Gelčytė for assistance during the experiment
and permission to use her data for this publication.
References
1. Amukali O., B.O. Obadoni and J.K. Mensah (2015) ‘Effects of different NaCl concentrations on
germination and seedling growth of Amaranthus Hybridus and Celosia argentea’, African
Journal of Evironmental Science and Technology, 9, pp. 301-306.
2. Jeyanthi L.R., Soni D., Dhanalakshmi V. and S. Anbuselvi (2010) ‘Effect of exogenous
spermidine on salinity tolerance with respect to seed germination’, International Journal of
Applied Agricultural Research, 5, pp. 163-169.
3. Munns R. and M. Tester (2008) ‘Mechanisms of salinity tolerance’, Annual Review of Plant
Biology, 59, pp. 651-681.
4. Munns R. (2002) ‘Comparative physiology of salt and water stress’, Plant, Cell and
Environment, 25, pp. 239-250.
5. Omami E.N. and P.S. Hammes (2006) ‘Interactive effects of salinity and water stress on growth,
leaf water relations, and gas exchange in amaranth (Amaranthus spp.)’, New Zealand Journal
of Crop and Horticultural Science, 34, pp.33–44.
6. Stallknecht G.F. and J.R. Schulz-Schaeffer (1993) ‘Amaranth rediscovered’, Wiley.
7. Kauffman C.S. and Weber L.E. (1990) Grain amaranth, 1th National Symposium on New
Crops, pp. 127-139, Indianapolis, Portland.
8. Panuccio M.R., S.E. Jacobsen, S.S. Akhtar and A. Muscolo (2014) ‘Effect of saline water on seed
germination and early seedling growth of the halophyte quinoa’, AoB Plants, 6,
https://doi.org/10.1093/aobpla/plu047.
752
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
“DIRTY” SEA PHENOMENON IN THESSALONIKI BAY:
PLANKTON ABETTORS AND PERPETRATORS
S. Genitsaris, N. Stefanidou, M. Moustaka-Gouni*
Department of Botany, School of Biology, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 541 24,
Thessaloniki, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: mmustaka@bio.auth.gr
Abstract
The “dirty” Sea phenomenon, mentioned also as the mucilage phenomenon in the literature, is caused
by the accumulation of gelatinous organic material at and below the water sea surface. The organic
material tends to be whitish when young, becoming progressively darker with age. This phenomenon
was conspicuous in large extent in Thessaloniki Bay during June 2017. Plankton samples from 3
stations in Thessaloniki Bay were examined before (end of May 2017), during (late June 2017) and
after (early July 2017) the phenomenon in order to identify the possible abettors and perpetrators
members of plankton. Before the appearance, plankton community consisted of known mucilage
producing species such as the autotrophic common diatoms in the Bay Cylindrotheca closterium,
Leptocylindrus minimus, Leptocylindros danicus, Skeletonema costatum, the rare dinoflagellate
Gonyaulax cf. fragilis and the common heterotrophic Noctiluca scintillans with its rare relative
Spatulodinium pseudonoctiluca. These heterotrophic dinoflagellates were responsible for common
red tides in the Bay. In May, among the diatoms high abundances were recorded for Leptocylindros
minimus (26282 cells mL-1), Dactyliosolen fragilissimus (866 cells mL-1), and Cylindrotheca
closterium (168 cells mL-1), while for the heterotrophs high abundance was recorded for the largesized Noctiluca scintillans (0.5 cells mL-1, reaching 5 cells mL-1 in the next days). During the
phenomenon large mucilage macroaggregates, dead cells of the above mentioned species and alive
specimens of the dinoflagellate Gonyaulax cf. fragilis (68 – 330 cells mL-1) and the diatom
Cylindrotheca closterium (93 – 393 cells mL-1) were recorded in the “dirty” water. Very abundant
mucilage producing species Skeletonema costatum (maximum abundance 12454 cells mL-1),
Chaetoceros spp. (max 10408 cells mL-1), and Cylindrotheca closterium (max 1064 cells mL-1) were
observed few days later in the “clean” water after the “dirty” Sea phenomenon, which decayed after
strong winds, opposed to the rare occurrence of Gonyaulax cf. fragilis (18 cells mL-1).
Keywords: mucilage, plankton, Thessaloniki Bay, diatoms, Gonyaulax cf. fragilis, Noctiluca
scintillans
1.
INTRODUCTION
Large aggregates of organic material that are macroscopically visible have been rarely documented
in marine waters, mostly in the Marmara Sea, the Tyrrhenian Sea, the Aegean Sea and the Adriatic
Sea (Danovaro et al., 2009). Most of these citations concern Northwest Adriatic Sea, along the
Emilia-Romagna coast, where the process of eutrophication causes cycles of summer “red tide”
events followed by winter and spring large blooms of diatoms, which determine the so-called “dirty
waters” (Vollenweider et al., 1992). These structures are considered to be initially produced by
mucilage producing diatoms. In particular, the extracellular exudates produced by the in vivo
metabolism of the diatoms Amphora coffeaeformis and Cylindrotheca fusiformis have been identified
as the perpetrators of this phenomenon (De Angelis et al., 1993). In addition, Rhinaldi et al. (1995),
753
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
also characterized the dinoflagellate Gonyaulax fragilis as a possible perpetrator of “dirty sea”
phenomena in Adriatic and Tyrrhenian Sea by participating in the mucilage production. A
differentiation into five states or stages of the phenomenon was proposed in the case of Adriatic:
macroflocs, stringers, clouds, creamy surface layers, and gelatinous surface layers. This classification
was based only on size and shape of the macroaggregates, and took into consideration the relative
position in the water, stability, behavior, and effect on benthos (Stachowitsch et al., 1990). Although
larger aggregates of organic material, caused by mucus (clouds, creamy layers, and gelatinous layers)
are less frequent, recurring episodes of the “dirty sea” might lead to anoxia in bottom waters, cause
fish kills and other nuisances in fisheries and the regional tourist industry.
Thermaikos Gulf and especially its inner part, Thessaloniki Bay, has been accepting for decades a
large volume of domestic and industrial wastes from the city of Thessaloniki. In the 20th century,
these wastes were discharged in the Bay without any previous treatment, causing the eutrophication
of the system. The past couple of decades, wastewater treatment has been implemented, decreasing
the effects of anthropogenic eutrophication (Krestenitis et al., 2012). However, Thessaloniki Bay still
remains a nutrient rich environment, in which red tides and episodes of algal blooms frequently occur,
with substantial socio-economic impact in the area (Karageorgis et al., 2005). These events might be
enhanced by frequently observed in the Bay mucilage producing plankton species, which include
Cylindrotheca closterium, Leptocylindrus sp. and others (see publications by Nikolaides &
Moustaka-Gouni, 1990; Friligos et al., 1997; Genitsaris et al., 2011). In Thessaloniki Bay, the “dirty
sea” phenomenon appeared on the 22 June 2017, after 24 hours of strong winds (reaching 40 km h-1;
data from the Hellenic National Meteorological Service, Thessaloniki Airport Station) in the area,
and it lasted for about 10 days. The aim of this paper is to investigate the biological producers of this
extensive and unprecedented phenomenon in Thessaloniki Bay, by examining the planktonic
community before, during and after the phenomenon, and identifying potential planktonic abettors
and perpetrators.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Sampling
During the last 10 days of June 2017, the coastal front of the city of Thessaloniki was covered in large
extend with autochthonous gelatinous organic material which appeared mixed whitish-brownish and
became progressively darker with age (Figure 1), causing irritation and unpleasant odor to the citizens
of Thessaloniki.
Figure 1. Photographs of the “dirty sea” phenomenon in Thessaloniki Bay, taken about 300 m
from the shore, in 28 June 2017.
754
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
In total, 7 water samples from the sampling sites shown in Figure 2 were collected before (31 May
2017; 1 sample from site A), during (28 June 2017; 3 samples from sites LM, WT and MG,
respectively), and after (7 July 2017; 3 samples from sites LM, WT and MG, respectively) the “dirty
sea” phenomenon. The offshore sampling sites were selected based the macroscopic extent of the
phenomenon, while the coastal site (WT) was a focal sampling point, on the basis of the recent,
frequent red tides formed inshore in Thessaloniki Bay affecting good water quality and aesthetical
values for the residents and tourists of the city of Thessaloniki. The samplings in the offshore stations
were carried out on board of a ship under the supervision of the Coastal Guard. The water samples
were collected from the surface water layer (0-1 m) with a Niskin-type water sampler. Data from
samples taken from deeper depths are not included in this paper.
2.2 Microscopy
Fresh and preserved water samples were examined under a light inverted microscope (Nikon SE
2000), and species were identified using appropriate taxonomic keys. Unicellular planktonic
organism counts were performed using the sedimentation method of Utermöhl (1958). Briefly, at
least 400 plankton individuals were counted in samples, when possible, in sedimentation chambers
of 3 mL, 10 mL or 25 mL, depending on the total abundance in each sample. The dimensions of 30
individuals (cells, or colonies) of each dominant species (comprising of ≥ 10 % of the total plankton
in terms of abundance and biomass) were measured using the relevant tools of a digital microscope
camera (Nikon DS-L1). Mean cell, or colony volume estimates were calculated using appropriate
geometric formulae according to Hillebrand et al. (1999).
Figure 2. Study area in Thessaloniki Bay, indicating the location of the sampling sites (A:
coastal site near the White Tower; LM: about 500 m from the coast near the eastern part of
the Port of Thessaloniki; WT: about 500 m from the coast near the White Tower; MG: about
500 m from the coast near Thessaloniki Concert Hall).
755
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Species Composition
Overall, 25 unicellular planktonic taxa were identified in the water samples during the study period
in Thessaloniki Bay (Table 1). The highest species number was detected in the sampling of May, in
the coastal site A, where 18 taxa were identified. Among the taxa, known mucilage producing species
were observed in high abundances, such as the common diatoms in the Bay (Nikolaides & MoustakaGouni, 1990; Genitsaris et al., 2011) Leptocylindros minimus (26282 cells mL-1), Dactyliosolen
fragilissimus (866 cells mL-1), and Cylindrotheca closterium (168 cells mL-1), and the pelagic
dinoflagellate Gonyaulax cf. fragilis (168 cells mL-1). These species co-occurred with the common
heterotrophic dinoflagellate Noctiluca scintillans (Figure 3), with its rare relative Spatulodinium
pseudonoctiluca, which dominated in terms of biomass.
Table 1. List of unicellular planktonic taxa identified in the water samples collected before,
during and after the “dirty sea” phenomenon in Thessaloniki Bay. (*) Depicts presence of the
organism.
Taxa
Dinophyceae
Ceratium furca
Gonyaulax cf. fragilis
Gymnodinium spp.
Gyrodinium spirale
Heterocapsa nieii
Karenia sp.
Noctiluca scintillans
Prorocentrum micans
Protoperidinium spp.
Scrippsiella trochoidea
Spatulodinium
pseudonoctiluca
Bacillariophyta
Chaetoceros spp.
Cylindrotheca closterium
Dactyliosolen fragilissimus
Leptocylindrus danicus
Leptocylindrus minimus
Pseudonitzschia pungens
Rhizosolenia spp.
Skeletonema costatum
A (May)
LM
(June)
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
Sampling Site (Date)
WT
MG
LM
(June)
(June)
(July)
*
*
*
*
*
WT
(July)
MG
(July)
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
Cryptophyta
Plagioselmis sp.
Teleulax acuta
*
*
*
*
*
*
Haptophyceae
Chrysochromulina sp.
Coccolithales spp.
*
*
*
*
*
*
Chlorophyta
Tetraselmis sp.
*
Euglenozoa
Eutreptiella sp.
*
756
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
These heterotrophic dinoflagellates, known to especially adapt to a strongly fluctuant environment
(Gómes & Souissi, 2007), are characterized as perpetrators in Red Tide events globally (e.g. Uhlig &
Sahling, 1990; Hallegraeff, 1993; Huang & Qi, 1997 and many more), and were also responsible for
frequent and temporally and spatially extensive red tide events along the front in Thessaloniki Bay
during the previous year (Genitsaris et al., unpublished data). The accumulation of autochthonous
organic material (dead and alive material) from the repetitive red tides during spring to summer
plankton succession (Genitsaris et al., unpublished data), in combination with the hydrodynamic
conditions in the Bay and the presence of abundant mucilage producing species before and during the
“dirty sea” phenomenon are suggested to lead to the formation of the phenomenon. N. scintillans can
create a large quantity of mucus (Al Gheilani et al., 2011), observed also in our samples. The mucilage
producing species in Thessaloniki Bay were also incriminated for similar phenomena in other marine
systems (see Table 2). Moreover, Umani et al. (2007) in a 3 year study on the microbial community
of a coastal area in northern Adriatic Sea with frequent reports of “dirty sea” phenomena, showed
mucilage formation by plankton species derived from accumulated to slow-to-degrade organic matter,
similar to our observations.
Figure 3. Light micrographs (phase contrast) of preserved samples taken before the “dirty
sea” phenomenon (7 June 2017). Water sample indicating (A) the large dinoflagellate
Noctiluca scintillans (bubble-like), a known red tide forming organism, consuming the
dinoflagellate Gonyaulax cf. fragilis (white arrow); and (B) Noctiluca scintillans cells in a stage
of degradation and mucus release. Scale bar: 20 μm.
Table 2. List of unicellular planktonic taxa identified as perpetrators and abettors of the
“dirty sea” phenomenon in Thessaloniki Bay and in other marine systems.
Planktonic Abettors
and
Perpetrators
Thessaloniki Bay
in
Other locations of
contribution in
“dirty sea” phenomena
Contribution
References
Bacillariophyta
Adriatic Sea, Tyrrhenian
Sea
Adriatic Sea
Chaetoceros spp.
Mucilage formation
Cylindrotheca closterium
Leptocylindrus minimus
Mucilage formation
Mucilage formation
Skeletonema costatum
Mucilage formation
Adriatic Sea, Tyrrhenian
Sea
Rinaldi et al., 1995
Mucilage formation
Adriatic Sea, Tyrrhenian
Sea
Rinaldi et al., 1995
Noctiluca scintillans
Mucus creation, Organic
material accumulation
Omani Waters, Adriatic
Sea
Al Gheilani et al.,
2011; Umani et al.,
2004
Spatulodinium
pseudonoctiluca
Organic material
accumulation
Eastern English Channel
Gómes & Souissi, 2007
Rinaldi et al., 1995
De Angelis et al., 1993
Dinophyceae
Gonyaulax cf. fragilis
757
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
During the “dirty sea” phenomenon (June 2017), the diversity, by means of species number, decreased
dramatically, and only 4 different taxa were detected, mainly because the samples were characterized
by extremely high quantities of dense autochthonous organic material (Figure 4), with remnants of
the heterotrophic dinoflagellates previously forming red tides in the area. Also, the thecated
dinoflagellate Gonyaulax cf. fragilis (Figure 4B), a mucilage producing species was occasionally
present and identifiable in all three sampling sites. Cylindrotheca closterium and Gonyaulax cf.
fragilis were observed to produce mucilage during the phenomenon.
The species number was higher at the end of the phenomenon, reaching 17 identified taxa in the WT
site, and 14 taxa in the LM site, in the July sampling. Among these taxa, the identified planktonic
abettors and perpetrators of the phenomenon (i.e. the mucilage forming species Cylindrotheca
closterium, Leptocylindros danicus, Chaetoceros spp., Skeletonema costatum, Gonyaulax cf. fragilis,
and the red tide forming Noctiluca scintillans with its rare relative Spatulodinium pseudonoctiluca)
persisted in the water surface after the “dirty” Sea phenomenon with low numbers. At the same time,
plankton bio-indicators of good water quality (species of Coccolithales) also appeared and started
increasing in abundance (Table 1).
Figure 4. Light micrographs (phase contrast) of preserved samples taken during the “dirty
sea” phenomenon. Water sample indicating (A) high numbers of the diatom Cylindrotheca
closterium (resembling needles) and other planktonic organisms within mucilage below the
“dirty” surface; and (B) the dinoflagellate Gonyaulax cf. fragilis producing mucilage (white
arrow) attached in a mucilage aggregate (black arrow). Scale Bar: 20 μm.
3.2 Plankton Abundance and Biomass
Total plankton abundance was higher before and after the “dirty sea” phenomenon, and reached
highest values in WT site (> 25 000 cells mL-1 in total in both dates), mainly due to the dominance of
the diatoms Leptocylindrus minimus and Skeletonema costatum, respectively (comprising > 50 % of
the total plankton abundance). During the phenomenon, the plankton abundance that was recorded
was low (<400 cells mL-1; Figure 5A), but in fact the organic matter that covered the surface of the
water was extremely high, making it impossible to detect and identify microbial planktoners, except
from the thecated Gonyaulax dinoflagellate. On the other hand, few days after the phenomenon, in
July samplings, the diatoms Skeletonema costatum (12454 cells mL-1), Chaetoceros spp. (10408 cells
mL-1), and Cylindrotheca closterium (1064 cells mL-1) prevailed in the water surface, opposite to the
rare occurrence of Gonyaulax cf. fragilis (18 cells mL-1), after decay and dispersal of the microaggregates of the phenomenon, due to strong winds (reaching 40 km h-1; data from the Hellenic
National Meteorological Service, Thessaloniki Airport Station).
758
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 5. (A) Total plankton abundance (cells mL-1) and (B) biomass (mg L-1) in all samples.
In figure (B) primary y-axis corresponds to the biomass of site A, while the secondary y-axis
corresponds to the biomass of all other samplings.
On the contrary to abundance data, biomass of alive planktoners was extremely high in the May
sampling from the site A (> 75 mg L-1; Figure 5B), due to the high abundance of the large
heterotrophic dinoflagellate Noctiluca scintillans (0.5 cells mL-1), which made up > 95 % of the total
plankton biomass. Its dying is reported to create large quantity of mucus (Al Gheilani et al., 2011).
Naturally, the accumulated dead plankton biomass and the produced mucilage making up the
autochthonous organic matter of the “dirty sea” was several orders of magnitude higher than that, but
it was impossible to calculate with microscopy due to its amorphous mass. The diversity decreased
dramatically, and only a few planktonic species were possible to detect. Thus, the abundance and
biomass of living plankton appeared extremely low, even though a conspicuous mat of autochthonous
organic material produced by plankton covered km2 along the coastal front. The phenomenon lasted
for about 10 days, before strong winds (reaching 40 km h-1; data from the Hellenic National
Meteorological Service, Thessaloniki Airport Station) dissolved the mats of mucilagenous material.
Mechanical destruction of similar aggregates by wind stress in northern Adriatic Sea, has also been
reported (Azam et al., 2007). After the end of the phenomenon, the detected biomass of alive cells
dropped dramatically, but still was high for a marine system, especially in WT site (> 5 mg L-1; Figure
5B).
It is generally accepted in the public that the ecological water quality in Thermaikos Gulf has been
improved compared to 20 years ago (Mihalatou & Moustaka-Gouni, 2002). However, the “dirty sea”
phenomenon, observed in June 2017, in combination with the frequent red tide events in the city front
of the Bay recently, sound the alarm and demand continuous monitoring of the biological and abiotic
indicators of eutrophication/nutrient pollution and ecological water quality in the Bay. The
elimination of the factors contributing to these phenomena, is urgently needed.
759
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Acknoweldgements
This research is implemented through IKY scholarships programme and co-financed by the European
Union (European Social Fund - ESF) and Greek national funds through the action entitled
“Reinforcement of Postdoctoral Researchers”, in the framework of the Operational Programme
“Human Resources Development Program, Education and Lifelong Learning” of the National
Strategic Reference Framework (NSRF) 2014 – 2020. We are thankful to the Central Coastal Guard
of Thessaloniki and EYATH S.A. for their help in the offshore samplings.
References
1. Al Gheilani H.M., Matsuoka K., Alkindi A.Y., Amer S. and C. Waring (2011) ‘Fish kill incidents
and harmful algal blooms in Omani Waters’, Journal of Agricultural and Marine Sciences, 16,
pp. 23-33.
2. Danovaro R., Umani S.F. and A. Pusceddu (2009) ‘Climate change and the potential spreading
of marine mucilage and microbial pathogens in the Mediterranean Sea’, PLoS ONE, 4(9), e7006.
3. De Angelis F., Barbaruto M.V., Bruno M., Volterra L. and R. Nicolett (1993) ‘Chemical
composition and biological origin of ‘dirty sea’ mucilages’, Phytochemistry, 34(2), pp. 393-395.
4. Friligos N., Kondylakis J.C. and R. Psyllidou-Giouranovits (1997) ‘Eutrophication and
phytoplankton abundance in the Thermaikos Gulf, Greece’, Environmental Bulletin, 6, pp. 2731.
5. Genitsaris S., Moustaka-Gouni M. and K.A. Kormas (2011) ‘Airborne microeukaryote colonists
in experimental water containers: diversity, succession, life histories and established food webs’,
Aquatic Microbial Ecology, 62(2), pp. 139-152.
6. Gómes F. and S. Souissi (2007) ‘The distribution and life cycle of the dinoflagellate
Spatulodinium pseudonoctiluca (Dinophyceae, Noctilucales) in the northeastern English
Channel’, Comptes Rendus Biologies, 330(3), pp. 231-236.
7. Hallegraeff G.M. (1993) ‘A review of harmful algal blooms and their apparent global increase’,
Phycologia, 32(2), pp. 79-99.
8. Hillebrand H., Dürselen C.-D., Kirschtel D., Pollingher U. and T. Zohary (1999) ‘Biovolume
calculation for pelagic and benthic microalgae’, Journal of Phycology, 35(2), pp. 403-424.
9. Huang C. and Y. Qi (1997) ‘The abundance cycle and influence factors on red tide phenomena
of Noctiluca scintillans (Dinophyceae) in Dapeng Bay, the South China Sea’, Journal of
Plankton Research, 19(3), pp. 308-318.
10. Karageorgis A.P., Skourtos M.S., Kapsimalis V., Kontogianni A.D., Skoulikidis N.Th., Pagou
K., Nikolaidis N.P., Drakopoulou P., Zanou B., Karamanos H., Levkov Z. and Ch. Anagnostou
(2005) ‘An integrated approach to watershed management within the DPSIR framework: Axios
River catchment and Thermaikos Gulf’, Regional Environmental Change, 5, pp. 138-160.
11. Krestenitis Y.N., Kombiadou K.D. and Y.S. Androulidakis (2012) ‘Interannual variability of the
physical characteristics of North Thermaikos Gulf (NW Aegean Sea)’, Journal of Marine
Systems, 96-97, pp. 132-151.
12. Mihalatou H.M. and M. Moustaka-Gouni (2002) ‘Pico-, nano-, microplankton abundance and
primary productivity in a eutrophic coastal area of the Aegean Sea, Mediterranean’, International
Review of Hydrobiology, 87(4), pp. 439-456.
13. Nikolaides G. and M. Moustaka-Gouni (1990) ‘The structure and dynamics of phytoplankton
assemblages from the inner part of the Thermaikos Gulf, Greece. I. Phytoplankton composition
and biomass from May 1988 to April 1989’, Helgoländer Meeresuntersuchungen, 44, pp. 487501.
760
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
14. Rinaldi A., Vollenweider R.A., Montanari G., Ferrari C.R. and A. Ghetti (1995) ‘Mucilages in
Italian seas: the Adriatic and Tyrrhenian Seas, 1988-1991’, The Science of the Total
Environment, 165, pp. 165-183.
15. Stachowitsch M, Fanuko N. and M. Richter (1990) ‘Mucus aggregates in the Adriatic Sea: an
overview of stages and occurrences’, Marine Ecology, 11(4), pp. 327-350.
16. Uhlig G. and G. Sahling (1990) ‘Long-term studies on Noctiluca scintillans in the German Bight
population dynamics and red tide phenomena 1968-1988’, Netherlands Journal of Sea
Research, 25(1-2), pp. 101-112.
17. Umani S.F., Beran A., Parlato S., Virgilio D., Zollet T., De Olazabal A., Lazzarini B. and M.
Cabrini (2004) ‘Noctiluca Scintillans MACARTNEY in the Northern Adriatic Sea: long-term
dynamics, relationships with temperature and eutrophication, and role in the food web’, Journal
of Plankton Research, 26(5), pp. 545-561.
18. Umani S.F., Del Negro P., Larato C., De Vittor C., Cabrini M., Celio M., Falconi C., Tamberlich
F. and F. Azam (2007) ‘Major inter-annual variations in microbial dynamics in the Gulf of Trieste
(northern Adriatic Sea) and their ecosystem applications’, Aquatic Microbial Ecology, 46, pp.
163-175.
19. Utermöhl H. (1958) ‘Zur Vervollkommnung der quantitativen phytoplankton-methodik’ Mitt Int
Ver Theor Angew Limnol, 9, pp. 1-38.
20. Vollenweider R.A., Rinaldi A. and G. Montanari (1992) ‘Eutrophication, structure and dynamics
of a marine coastal system: results of ten-year monitoring along the Emilia-Romagna coast
(Northwest Adriatic Sea)’ International Conference on Marine Coastal Eutrophication’, pp.
63-106, Bologna, Italy.
761
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
MONITORING THE MARINE ENVIRONMENT OF
THERMAIKOS GULF
M. Petala1, V. Tsiridis1, I. Androulidakis2, Ch. Makris2, V. Baltikas2, A. Stefanidou3, S.
Genitsaris3, C. Antoniadou4, D. Rammou4, M. Moustaka-Gouni3, C.C. Chintiroglou4
and E. Darakas1*
1
Laboratory of Environmental Engineering & Planning, Dept. of Civil Engineering,
Laboratory of Maritime Engineering and Maritime Works, Dept. of Civil Engineering,
3
Laboratory of Botany, School of Biology,
4
Laboratory of Zoology, School of Biology, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54 124
Thessaloniki, Greece
2
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: darakas@civil.auth.gr, tel : +302310995719
Abstract
In this study, the quality of the marine environment of Thermaikos Gulf was appraised by measuring
physical, chemical and biological parameters of the water column and the seabed. Water and sediment
samples were seasonally collected from three sampling stations located at the inner part of
Thermaikos Gulf. Specific physical-chemical characteristics (temperature, salinity, density along
with pH and dissolved oxygen) throughout the water column were evaluated by conducting in situ
measurements during the sampling campaigns. In situ processing of the water density data enabled
the determination of the water column stratification. Afterwards, water samples were collected from
the different strata: surface, pycnocline and bottom, to assess relevant variations of the chemical and
the biological characteristics of the water masses. The studied chemical parameters included
ammonium nitrogen, nitrites, nitrates, phosphates and total phosphorus and the biological ones
phytoplankton and protozooplankton species composition, abundance and biomass. Sediment
samples were collected with a standard VanVeen grab from each sampling station. Benthic organisms
(macro-invertebrates) were sorted, enumerated under major taxa, and identified up to species levels
to assess ecological quality status applying the BENTIX biotic index. Sediment composition and
organic content were also assessed. The obtained results are discussed with regards to seasonal and
spatial variability and water column stratification.
Keywords: Thermaikos Gulf, monitoring, nutrients, phytoplankton, protozooplankton, benthic
organisms
1.
INTRODUCTION
The European Union Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD) 2008/56/EC establishes an
integrated framework for the achievement or maintenance of the good environmental status in the
marine systems by the year 2020 the latest. This Directive stipulates detailed procedures for its
implementation including the development of marine strategies by Member States, in order to protect
and preserve the marine environment. The program of measures shall take into account relevant
measures required under the European legislation, in particular the Water Framework Directive
(WFD) 2000/60/EC, the Council Directive 91/271/EEC concerning urban waste-water treatment and
the Bathing Water Directive (BWD) 2006/7/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council
concerning the management of bathing water quality (MSFD, 2008/56/EC). The BWD (Directive
2006/7/EC) aims to protect health and (marine) environment based on scientific knowledge under a
762
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
holistic approach that is integrated into all other European measures protecting the quality of all
waters through the WFD. WFD introduces the concepts of the ecological and chemical status for the
European water bodies. The ecological status is based on biological quality elements supported by
hydromorphological and physico-chemical environmental characteristics, and is divided into five
classes (‘High’, ‘Good’, ‘Moderate’, ‘Poor’, ‘Bad’). According to the normative guidelines of the
WFD, good ecological status is achieved when biological communities present are close to those that
would be present with minimal anthropogenic disturbance (2000/60/EC). According to guidelines of
the MSFD, qualitative descriptors to be used in assessing the ecological or environmental status
include biodiversity, non-indigenous species, exploited fish and shellfish, food webs, human-induced
eutrophication, sea-floor integrity, hydrographical conditions, contaminants and contaminants in fish.
All in all, the MSFD aims to be based upon an ecosystem-based approach that has a holistic view on
the management and protection of marine ecosystems, focusing on ensuring sustainable use of the
seas, and providing safe, clean, healthy and productive marine waters (Borja et al., 2008; Borja et al.,
2010).
Phytoplankton is the biological element of WFD most closely related to eutrophication and a primary
indicator for the assessment of water quality, as it forms the basis of food webs and exhibits high
reproduction rates and immediate response to environmental changes. Different phytoplankton
attributes are considered essential for the appraisal of ecological status, including species
composition, abundance and biomass, as well as frequency and intensity of phytoplankton blooms
(WFD, 2000/60/EC). Amongst quality descriptors, phytoplankton biomass, in terms of chlorophyllα, although it is a gross metric, it is simple and records the responses of phytoplanktonic communities
to nutrient enrichments (Tsirtsis and Karydis, 1998; Garmendia et al., 2013). However, chlorophyllα has been reported as being highly variable, thus also showing higher disagreement with the final
classification of the water bodies (Borja et al., 2004). On the other hand, the use of benthic indices
has been shown to provide valuable elements for the integrated quality status assessment of water
bodies (Borja et al., 2014). Composition and abundance of benthic invertebrate fauna has been proved
to be a biological quality element that can be reliably used for the classification of water bodies due
to responsiveness to major environmental or anthropogenic changes. Macro-benthic animals are
relatively sedentary (they are affected by environmental/ anthropogenic conditions), have relatively
long life-spans, consist of different species that demonstrate variable tolerances to chemical stresses
and have a substantial role in sediment processes, e.g., enhancing the flow of nutrients and materials
between the sediments and the water column, and vice versa, through bioturbation and bioirrigation
(Borja et al., 2000). For these reasons macrobenthic communities are listed among quality descriptors
for the implementation of MSFD (MSFD, 2008/56/EC). In this context, the classification of
ecological status is implemented using indices based on sensitivity/ tolerance of various species. In
European waters the most frequently applied indices are AMBI and M-AMBI that have been
developed using the data from the coastal marine areas and are mainly used to assess the organic
enrichment (Pitacco et al., 2018). However, for the Mediterranean Sea, and especially the eastern
basin, the most appropriate index is BENTIX, originally developed in the Aegean Sea (Simboura and
Zenetos, 2002), as revealed by the intercalibration procedure of the EU members (Simboura and
Reizopoulou, 2008). Accordingly, the BENTIX index, is the official tool for the ecological status
assessment in Greece and Cyprus sedimentary bottoms.
In Northern Greece, Thermaikos Gulf is a marine ecosystem of high complexity due to the various
activities taking place in the greater area. Thermaikos Gulf is the final receiver of the discharges of
Axios, Aliakmon, Loudias and Gallikos Rivers, as well as of the effluents of two municipal
wastewater treatment plants of Thessaloniki, with Axios River having the highest contribution of
freshwater input into the gulf. However, Thermaikos is not only affected by the discharges of the
watersheds of rivers, but also by the discharges of numerous industrial activities located along the
coast. The anthropogenic pressures that originate from agricultural, industrial, commercial, marine
and aquaculture activities have resulted in elevated concentrations of nutrients in the water column
and accumulation of trace elements in sediments (Friligos et al., 1997; Nikolaidis et al., 2006).
763
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Moreover, the exchanges with the open Aegean Sea waters across the southern boundary are an
additional factor that affects the stratification, circulation and renewal of the Gulf (Krestenitis et al.,
2012). The complexity of Thermaikos Gulf system, the variability of environmental factors and the
specific circulation and renewal dynamics of the system require the development of a quality
monitoring scheme that takes into account physical, chemical and ecological quality elements (in the
context of the European legislation). To this aim, the present study focuses on the quality assessment
of the marine environment of Thermaikos Gulf, using physical, chemical and biological/ecological
elements of the water column and the seabed.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Oceanographic surveys
Within the framework of this study, water and sediment samples that were seasonally (July, October
and December 2017) collected from three sampling stations located at the inner part Thessaloniki
Bay, inner and outer Thermaikos Gulf. The characteristics of the sampling stations (coordinates of
each station, corresponding depth and description of the area) are presented in Table 1. As it is shown
in Figure 1, the station S1 is located at the discharge point of the Municipal Wastewater Treatment
Plant of Thessaloniki (WWTPT) outlet, the station S2 is located at northern Thessaloniki bay, while
the station S3 is located at the discharge point of the Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plant of
Michaniona-AINEIA.
Table 1. Characteristics of sampling stations
Sampling
Station
Longitude
Latitude
Description
Depth
(m)
S1
40.55237285
22.8536432
Station at the outlet of the
WWTP of Thessaloniki
(WWTPT)
25
S2
40.61821578
22.94157171
Inner Thessaloniki bay
13
22.82078561
Station at the outlet of the
WWTP of Michaniona
(AINEIA)
30
S3
40.46212649
The physical oceanographic parameters were recorded by means of a CTD (SBE 19) profiler. Apart
from the standard sensors (conductivity, temperature, pressure), the instrument is equipped with
auxiliary sensors for dissolved oxygen and pH. Raw data were properly processed (low-pass filtering,
alignment, cell thermal effects removal) and corrected, to assure the accuracy of the derived
parameters. The processed data were averaged over depth-bins of 0.25 m. During sampling, in situ
processing of the water density data enabled the preliminary determination of the water column
stratification. Afterwards, water samples were collected from three levels of the water column
(surface, pycnocline and bottom) with a Niskin-type water sampler, in order to investigate the
variations of the measured chemical and biological parameters over the water column depth.
764
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1. Map of sampling stations, rivers and sub-regions in Thermaikos Gulf.
The chemical status of Thermaikos Gulf was appraised by performing chemical analyses including
nitrites (APHA-AWWA-WEF, 1999), nitrates (Grasshoff et al., 1999), ammonium nitrogen (Hach,
2013), phosphates (APHA-AWWA-WEF, 1999), total phosphorus (APHA-AWWA-WEF, 1999) and
silica (APHA-AWWA-WEF, 1999; Grasshoff et al., 1999).
2.2 Biological parameters/Phytoplankton and Protozooplankton
Fresh water subsamples (250 ml) were placed at portable refrigerator and subsamples (250 ml) were
immediately fixed with Lugol’s iodine. Fresh and preserved water samples were examined under a
light inverted microscope (Nikon SE 2000), and species were identified using appropriate taxonomic
keys. Unicellular planktonic organism counts were performed using the sedimentation method of
Utermöhl (1958). Briefly, at least 400 plankton individuals were counted in samples, when possible,
in sedimentation chambers of 3 mL, 10 mL or 25 mL, depending on the total abundance in each
sample. The dimensions of 30 individuals (cells, or colonies) of each dominant species (comprising
of ≥ 10 % of the total plankton in terms of abundance and biomass) were measured using the relevant
tools of a digital microscope camera (Nikon DS-L1). Mean cell, or colony volume estimates were
calculated using appropriate geometric formulae according to Hillebrand et al. (1999).
2.3 Zoobenthos and sediment composition
Two replicate sediment samples were collected with a standard VanVeen grab (0.1 m 2) from each
sampling station and period, whereas a third one was collected for sediment composition and organic
content analyses. Overall, 18 biological and 9 sediment samples were obtained. Sediment samples
were dried out to assess the organic content (H2O2 method) and the granulometric composition
(siphonometric menthod) applying the Folk’s system of sediment classification (Folk et al., 1970).
Each biological sample was sieved on board (mesh-opening 1 mm) and preserved in 10% formalin seawater solution. In the laboratory all living specimens were sorted out from each biological sample
under a binocular stereoscope, counted, and identified at species level using relevant identification
keys for each major taxa, and a microscope, when appropriate. The species/abundance data matrix
was analyzed by standard biocoenotic methods to estimate biodiversity, and by multivariate methods
based on Bray-Curtis distances to assess the similarity of zoobenthic communities’ structure and
765
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
possible spatial or seasonal effects, using the PRIMER software package (Clarke and Gorley, 2006).
Also, the BENTIX biotic index was applied to assess the ecological quality status of sampling
stations, using the freeware software developed and provided by the National Centre for Marine
Research (www. cloudfs.hcmr.gr/index.php).
3.
RESULTS
3.1 Physical and Chemical parameters
Very strong stratification, based on both salinity and temperature profiles, was observed in all stations
in July, supporting the stability of the water column (Figure 2). The temperature difference between
the surface and bottom was around 10oC in the inner Thermaikos Gulf (S1), while the smaller
difference was measured in S3 (<3oC). The stations of the inner Gulf (S1 and S2) showed similar
distributions in autumn (~21oC) and winter (~13oC). On the contrary, the outer station S3 revealed
strong thermocline at 15 m in autumn, where the temperature was reduced by 4 oC indicating the
possible intrusion of colder waters from the Aegean Sea. This finding agrees with Hyder et al. (2002)
and Krestenitis et al. (2012), who showed that this area is the passage of northern Aegean waters
supporting the renewal of the Gulf. The same station showed significantly higher temperature values
(~16oC) in comparison to the two northern stations (~13oC) in winter. Salinity was very low at the
surface of S1 and S2 stations in July (<36). Summer values were lower than winter values in all cases.
Moreover, in all cases, salinity was higher in the S3 station, which is usually out of the effect of the
riverine waters that are discharged at the western Gulf. Especially in autumn, the salinity distribution
of S3 station was not homogenous but increased at 15m from 37 to 39 (Aegean waters). This station
is also characterized by warmer and saltier waters along the entire water column during winter.
Figure 2. Vertical temperature and salinity profiles of the three Thermaikos stations in July
(left), October (middle) and December (right).
The chemical quality of Thermaikos Gulf was mainly based on the seasonal monitoring of nutrients
and included the inorganic forms of nitrogen, the orthophosphates and the total phosphorus. The
highest concentration of ammonium nitrogen, equal to 1.12 μmol/L NH4+, was recorded during the
third sampling campaign of December 2017 in the surface sample collected from the sampling station
S1 (data not shown). Moreover, relatively high concentration of nitrites, 0.31 μmol/L, was obtained
in the same sample, possibly denoting the presence (or the beginning) of reducing conditions in the
regional marine environment. The increased concentrations of nitrites were accompanied by a
significant reduction of nitrates, as it is shown in Figure 3.
766
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3. Nitrates concentration results.
The samples collected from the inner part of Thermaikos Gulf indicated rather low concentrations in
nutrients of nitrogen and phosphorus. However, during the winter sampling campaign, the red tide
phenomenon was observed on the sea surface; the seawater transparency was low, while the total
phosphorus concentration was significantly higher compared to the corresponding one measured
during the summer period (Figure 4).
Figure 4. Total phosphorus concentration results.
The results obtained from the third sampling station, at the outer part of Thermaikos Gulf,
demonstrated that the concentrations of nutrients were significantly lower compared to the rest
sampling stations. However, the concentration of nitrates varied between 0.40 and 0.62 μmol/L,
considerably higher compared to the results of 2014 (HCMR, 2015). Still, much higher
concentrations, exceeding 2.0 μmol/L, were recorded some years ago (Samanidou et al., 1989). The
intensification of sampling and measurements is needed, in order to extract safe conclusions on the
quality characteristics of this area.
3.2 Phytoplankton
Species composition
Overall, 87 phytoplankton and 13 protozooplankton taxa were identified in the water samples during
the investigation. Within the phytoplankton community, diatoms were recorded with the highest
number of species reaching 43 identified taxa, followed by dinophytes (32) and haptophytes (5). For
each of the rest phytoplankton taxonomic groups (cryptophytes, chlorophytes, dicthyophytes,
euglenophytes, raphidiophytes, xanthophytes) less than 5 representatives were identified. The
767
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
protozooplankter Noctiluca scintillans (Figure 5d) with its rare relative Spatulodinium
pseudonoctiluca, responsible for the frequent red tides in Thessaloniki Bay, were recorded in every
sample of the inner Gulf (S1 and S2).
a.
b.
c.
d.
10 μm
10 μm
e.
10 μm
h.
10 μm
g.
f.
10 μm
i.
10μm
10 μm
10μm
10μm
Figure 5. Light micrographs (phase contrast) of phytoplankton and protozooplankton taxa in
the water samples from Thermaikos Gulf in June, October and December 2017. a. Ceratium
furca b. Rhizosolenia setigera c. Noctiluca scintilans d. Pseudonitzschia pungens e. Gonyaulax
cf. fragilis f. Leptocylindrus danicus g. Chaetoceros sp. h. Dinophysis cf. acuminata i.
Mesodinium rubrum.
In July, after the “dirty sea” phenomenon the mucilage forming species Gonyaulax cf. fragilis and
Chaetoceros spp. were observed in the samples (Figure 5). During the winter sampling (on December
2017) a large extent red tide was conspicuous in the inner Gulf. Τhe autotrophic ciliate Mesodinium
rubrum (Figure 5i) was accountable for the phenomenon due to its extremely high abundance
(>10000 cell/mL) that was measured in the water samples.
Species number, phytoplankton abundance and biomass
The number of identified species was comparable among the 3 sites following the same trend in terms
of increasing depth; higher number of species was observed in the surface samples than the
pycnocline and the bottom samples. Diatoms and dinoflagellates were the most diverse taxonomic
groups with the first to dominate in richness almost in all samples apart from the occasional
dominance of the latter in S1 and S2. The phytoplankton abundance was higher and frequently
indicative for bloom formation in the inner gulf (sites S1 and S2) contrary to S3. Characteristically,
the maximum measured phytoplankton abundance in S3 was 6 times lower than the maximum in S1
and 12 times lower than in S2. Similarly, the phytoplankton biomass was higher in S1 and S2 than
S3 (Figure 6).
768
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Biomass (mg/L)
Figure 6. Phytoplankton biomass (mg/L) in each depth and in each site (S1, S2, S3) of
Thermaikos Gulf. The dark blue depicts the phytoplankton biomass in July 2017, the ciel blue
the biomass in October 2017 and the light ciel blue the biomass in December 2017.
The maximum phytoplankton biomass during the investigation (the extremely high value of 86 mg
L-1) was recorded in the surface sample of S2 simultaneously with the extensive red tide in the inner
Gulf (on December 2017). The phytoplankton biomass was also high (>5 mg/L) in the surface and
pycnocline samples of S1 and S2 on July 2017 (Figure 6). Conversely, the phytoplankton biomass in
S3 was typical for oligotrophic marine environments with exception of the surface sample on October
2017 where the measured biomass was 1 mg/L.
3.3 Zoobenthos
According to the granulometric composition, the sediment is characterized as muddy in S1 and S3,
and as sandy-mud in S2. The sediment composition was seasonally stable, with the exception of the
December period, where the proportion of sand increased in S1 and S3 shifting the characterization
of the sea-bottom as sandy-mud, as opposed to S2, where the proportion of clay increased and the
sediment became muddy. At the same time, increased amounts of biogenic fragments were also
observed in S2. The organic content showed spatial divergences with increased values in S2 (0.1465
± 0.023) and lower, but inter-se similar, in S1 and S3 (0.1174 ± 0.022 and 0.1104 ± 0.025,
respectively). Slight seasonal variations were also detected, but without following a similar trend
between stations.
Overall 2,945 macro-invertebrate specimens were collected identified to 207 species. Polychaetes
and molluscs were the most speciose groups, followed by crustaceans. The above groups prevailed
also in abundance. Zoobenthic diversity and abundance showed significantly (p<0.01) higher values
in S2 (mean S = 56, mean N = 347/0.1m2) and decreased ones in S3 (mean S = 29, mean N = 80.33)
and S1 (mean S = 16, mean N = 57.66), in particular. The most dominant and frequent species were
the polychaetes Ditrupa arietina, Magelona mirabilis, Nepthys hystricis, Notomastus latericeus,
769
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Sternaspis scutata, the ophiuran Amphiura chiajei and the bivalve Kurtiella bidentata. Multivariate
analyses discriminated samples primarily according to their geographic origin (R = 1 p < 0.05) and
secondary (within each station group) according to the season of sampling (R = 0.72 p < 0.05); the
latter case mostly due to the divergence of the samples collected in winter (Figure 7). This biotic
pattern was mainly correlated with the amount of clay and the organic content of the sediments
(Spearman ρ = 0.625).
similarity
W
S
A S
A
20
25
W
A
A
S S
S
W
S
W A
A
W
W
S1
S2
S3
Stress value: 0.12
Figure 7. Non-metric multidimensional scaling ordination of zoobenthic samples from
Thermaikos Gulf stations (S1-S3), based on Bray-Curtis similarity index calculated from
square-root transformed numerical abundance data of macro-invertebrate species. S =
summer sampling, A = autumn sampling, W = winter sampling.
The majority of macroinvertebrates were classified into the tolerant category, being positively
correlated with organic enrichment, with the exception of S1 in winter, where the sensitive species
group prevailed (Table 2). The BENTIX biotic index ranged from 2.51 to 3.66, and accordingly, the
ecological quality status of the stations ranged from moderate (S1, S2) to good (S3) (Table 2). The
ecological quality status of S1 improved in winter, whereas remained seasonally stable in S2
(moderate) and S3 (good). However, the percentage of species not assigned to any ecological category
overpasses 10% in some cases, and so these specific results should be viewed with caution.
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Although denser (colder and saltier) waters, possibly originated from the North Aegean, were
detected in the outer Gulf during the fall measurements, they were not observed in the northern areas,
indicating weak renewal of the inner Gulf. More brackish waters were detected in the drier summer
months although the river discharge rates are usually smaller. A possible explanation is the operation
of the power generation dams, which exist along the Aliakmonas river, leading to increased outflows
toward the sea (Krestenitis et al., 2012). Krestenitis et al. (2012), based on 5 long cruise period (19942007) showed a general decrease of Gulf's salinity. On the contrary, the current measurements, almost
10 years later, showed higher salinity values, supporting the inverse of the decreasing trend found in
older expeditions.
770
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 2. Number of species (S), numerical abundance (N), ecological groups (GS = Sensitive
species group, GT = tolerant species group, NA = not assigned species), BENTIX index, and
ecological quality (EcoQ) status assessment per seasonal sampling and station (S1 – S3) in
Thermaikos Gulf.
Sampling
Ecological Category
S N
ΒΕΝΤΙΧ
EcoQ
GS
GT
NA
Station
Season
S1
S2
S3
Summer 2017
18
80
18.75%
71.25%
10.00%
2.55
MODERATE
Autumn 2017
20
117
15.05%
80.34%
4.62%
2.51
MODERATE
Winter 2017
30
145
48.97%
35.86%
15.17%
3.66
GOOD
Summer 2017
93
623
32.74%
60.67%
6.58%
3.18
MODERATE
Autumn 2017
73
635
34.96%
59.53%
5.51%
3.29
MODERATE
Winter 2017
72
279
30.47%
56.99%
12.54%
2.96
MODERATE
Summer 2017*
48
193
32.12
54.40
13.47
3.02
GOOD
Autumn 2017*
44
111
33.33
53.15
13.51
3.06
GOOD
Winter 2017
32
114
39.47
57.01
3.51
3.51
GOOD
* >90% silt limits were used
The chemical status of both the inner and outer part of Thermaikos did not present remarkable
variations during summer and autumn, compared to earlier studies (HCMR, 2007; HCMR, 2015). In
particular, total phosphorus concentration values were close to those reported earlier for summer and
autumn (HCMR, 2007; HCMR, 2015). However, during the winter sampling, extremely high
concentrations of phosphates and total phosphorus were recorded in the surface samples, probably
related to the observed red tide phenomenon. The measured concentrations were higher than the
threshold for the good water quality (Dasenakis et al., 2015). In addition, rather high phosphorus
concentration was recorded in the outer part of the Gulf, especially in the sub-surface samples. So
far, comparable concentrations were only recorded many years ago (Samanidou et al., 1989),
implying the need for consecutive and more extensive monitoring of Thermaikos quality.
The occasional dominance of dinoflagellates in S1 and S2, the frequent phytoplankton blooms
concurrently with the high phytoplankton biomass (>0.7 mg/L, Bozatzidou 2013) in all samples of
S1 and S2 indicate a less than good water quality according to phytoplankton. Furthermore, the
protozooplankton abundance in these sites was indicative of red tide formations. These characteristics
demonstrate the eutrophic character of the inner Gulf, which disagrees with the requirement for
normal abundance and diversity of marine food webs elements, in order to establish good
environmental status (MSFD, 2008/56/EC). On the other hand, the species composition and the
phytoplankton abundance and biomass in S3 were indicative for higher than good water quality
except for the surface sample on October 2017.
The benthic fauna showed increased abundance but similar diversity values with previous studies
(HCMR, 2015). Polychaetes were the most dominant taxon, mainly represented by opportunistic
species and thus, indicating the prevalence of slightly disturbed environmental conditions. The
structure of zoobenthic communities differed among the three study sites, and especially between the
innermost and the outer Thermaikos stations (i.e. S2 vs S3). A typical seasonal pattern, i.e. divergence
of winter samples, was assessed in all stations, being more profound in S1 and S2 where colder water
771
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
masses occurred compared to the outer Gulf station (S3). The above biotic patterns derived from the
combined effect of three main environmental parameters: temperature, clay and sediment’s organic
content. According to the biological quality element of macro-invertebrates, the water quality status
of Thermaikos was assessed as moderate in the inner gulf stations (S1, S2), and as good in the outer
station (S3); however, water quality improved in S1 (the station in the intermediated part of the Gulf)
during the winter sampling reaching good status. These results are in agreement with the
phytoplankton monitoring, and generally conform to previous studies and the national monitoring
program (HCMR, 2015).
Acknowledgements
This study was carried under the program “Monitoring of the quality of marine environment of
Thermaikos Gulf” funded by Thessaloniki Water Supply & Sewerage Co. S.A (EYATH S.A.). The
view expressed herein can in no way be taken to reflect the official opinion of EYATH S.A.
References
1. APHA-AWWA-WEF (1999) ‘Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater’,
20th Ed. American Public Health Association: Washington, DC.
2. Borja, A. and D.M. Dauer (2008) ‘Assessing the environmental quality status in estuarine and
coastal systems: Comparing methodologies and indices’, Ecological Indicators, Vol. 8, pp 331337.
3. Borja, Á., F. Franco, V. Valencia, J. Bald and I. Muxica, I. et al. (2004) ‘Implementation of the
European water framework directive from the Basque country (northern Spain): a methodological
approach’, Marine Pollution Bulletin, Vol. 48 (3-4), pp 209-218.
4. Borja, Á., F. Franco and V. Perez (2000) ‘A Marine Biotic Index to Establish the Ecological
Quality of Soft-Bottom Benthos Within European Estuarine and Coastal Environments’, Marine
Pollution Bulletin, Vol. 40 (12), pp 1100-1114.
5. Borja, A., T. C. Prins, N. Simboura, J.H. Andersen, T. Berg, J. Marques, . . . and L. Uusitalo
(2014) ‘Tales from a thousand and one ways to integrate marine ecosystem components when
assessing the environmental status’, Frontiers in Marine Science, Vol. 1, Issue DEC, Article 72.
6. Borja, A. and J.G. Rodríguez (2010) ‘Problems associated to the ‘one-out, all-out’ principle, when
using multiple ecosystem components in assessing the ecological status of marine waters’,
Marine Pollution Bulletin, Vol. 60(8), pp 1143-1146.
7. Bozatzidou M. (2013). Assessing the ecological quality of Thermaikos Municipality coastal
system (based on phytoplankton). Master Thesis. School of Biology, Aristotle University of
Thessaloniki.
8. Clarke K.R. and R.N. Gorley (2006) ‘PRIMER v6 user manual and program’, PRIMER-E Ltd:
Plymouth, UK.
9. Dauer D.M. (1993) ‘Biological criteria, environmental health and estuarine macrobenthic
community structure’, Marine Pollution Bulletin, Vol. 26 (5), pp 249-257.
10. Dasenaikis et al. Δασενάκης Μ., M. Λαδάκης, Σ. Καραβόλτσος και Β. Παρασκευοπούλου (2015)
‘Χημική Ωκεανογραφία’, Σύνδεσμος Ελληνικών Ακαδημαϊκών Βιβλιοθηκών- Εθνικό Μετσόβιο
Πολυτεχνείο, Αθήνα. ISBN: 978-960-603-234-9.
11. European Commission (EC) (2000) Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for the Community action in the field of
water policy. Official Journal of the European Communities L 327: 1-72, European Commission,
Brussels.
12. European Commission (EC) (2006) Directive 2006/7/EC of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 15 February 2006 Concerning the Management of Bathing Water Quality and
772
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Repealing Directive 76/160/EEC, Official Journal of the European Communities L64: 37-51,
European Commission, Brussels.
13. European Commission (EC) (2008) Directive 2008/56/EC of the European Parliament and the
Council of 17 June 2008. Establishing a framework for community action in the field of marine
environmental policy. Official Journal of the European Communities L164: 19-40, European
Commission, Brussels.
14. Friligos N., J.C. Kondylakis and R. Psyllidou-Giouranovits (1997) ‘Eutrophication and
phytoplankton abundance in the Thermaikos Gulf, Greece’, Fresenius Environmental Bulletin,
Vol. 6, pp 27–31.
15. Folk R.L., P.B. Andrews and D.W. Lewis (1970) ‘Detrital sedimentary rock classification and
nomenclature for use in New Zealand’, N.Z. Journal of Geology and Geophysics, Vol. 13, pp
937-968.
16. Garmendia, M., Á. Borja, J. Franco, and M. Revilla (2013) ‘Phytoplankton composition indicators
for the assessment of eutrophication in marine waters: Present state and challenges within the
European directives’, Marine Pollution Bulletin, 66(1-2), pp. 7-16.
17. Grasshoff Κ., K. Kremling and M. Ehrhardt (1999) ‘Methods of Seawater Analysis, Third,
Completely Revised and Extended Edition’, WILEY-VCH Verlag.
18. Hach (2013) ‘Water Analysis Handbook’, Colorado, USA.
19. HCMR (2015) ΕΛΚΕΘΕ (2015) ‘Δειγματοληψίες και αναλύσεις για την παρακολούθηση της
οικολογικής ποιότητας παρακτίων υδάτων, σύμφωνα με τις απαιτήσεις του Άρθρου 8 της
Οδηγίας Πλαίσιο για τα Ύδατα 2000/60/ΕΕ, σε τρεις σταθμούς του Θερμαϊκού κόλπου που
ενδιαφέρουν την ΕΥΑΘ’ Τεχνική Έκθεση, Αθήνα, Δεκέμβριος 2015.
20. HCMR (2007) ΕΛΚΕΘΕ (2007) ‘Παρακολούθηση της ποιότητας του Θαλάσσιου Περιβάλλοντος
του κόλπου της Θεσσαλονίκης (ΘΕΡΜΑΪΚΟΣ 2006)’ Ενδιάμεση Τεχνική Έκθεση, Αθήνα,
Ιούλιος 2007.
21. Hillebrand H., C.-D. Dürselen, D. Kirschtel, U. Pollingher and T. Zohary (1999) ‘Biovolume
calculation for pelagic and benthic microalgae’, Journal of Phycology, 35(2), pp. 403-424.
22. Hyder, P., J.H. Simpson, S. Christopoulos, and Y. Krestenitis, (2002) ‘The seasonal cycles of
stratification and circulation in the Thermaikos Gulf Region of Freshwater Influence (ROFI),
north-west Aegean’, Continental Shelf Research, 22(17), pp.2573-2597.
23. Krestenitis, Y.N., K.D. Kombiadou and Y.S. Androulidakis (2012) ‘Interannual variability of the
physical characteristics of North Thermaikos Gulf (NW Aegean Sea)’ Journal of Marine
Systems, 96, pp.132-151.
24. Nikolaidis N., A. Karageorgis, V. Kapsimalis, G. Marconis, P. Drakopoulou, H. Kontoyiannis
and K. Pagou (2006) ‘Circulation and nutrient modelling of Thermaikos Gulf, Greece’, Journal
of Marine Systems, 60, pp 51–62.
25. Pitacco V., M. Mistri and C. Munari (2018) ‘Long-term variability of macrobenthic community
in a shallow coastal lagoon (Valli di Comacchio, northern Adriatic): Is community resistant to
climate changes?’ Marine Environmental Research, in press.
26. Samanidou V., K. Fytianos and G. Vasilikiotis (1989) ‘Distribution of nutrients in the Thermaikos
Gulf, Greece’, Toxicological & Environmental Chemistry, 20-21, pp. 29-37.
27. Simboura, N. and S. Reizopoulou (2008) ‘An intercalibration of classification metrics of benthic
macroinvertebrates in coastal and transitional ecosystems of the Eastern Mediterranean ecoregion
(Greece)’, Marine Pollution Bulletin, 56, pp. 116-126.
773
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
28. Simboura N. and A. Zenetos (2002) ‘Benthic indicators to use in ecological quality classification
of Mediterranean soft bottom marine ecosystems, including a new Biotic Index’, Mediterranean
Marine Science, 3, pp. 77–111.
29. Tsirtsis G. and M. Karydis (1998) ‘Evaluation of phytoplankton community indices for detecting
eutrophic trends in the marine environment’, Environmental Monitoring Assessment, 50, pp.
255-269.
30. Utermöhl H. (1958) ‘Zur Vervollkommnung der quantitativen phytoplankton-methodik’
Internationalen Vereinigung fur Theoretische und Angewandte Limnologie, 9, pp. 1-38.
774
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
INVESTIGATION OF QUANTUM DOTS TOXICITY,
GENOTOXICITY, CYTOTOXICITY, AND UPTAKE IN
RAINBOW TROUT ONCORHYNCHUS MYKISS LARVAE
Ž. Jurgelėnė*1, M. Stankevičiūtė1, N. Kazlauskienė1, D. Montvydienė1, J. Baršienė1, K.
Jokšas2, 3, A. Markuckas4
1
Institute of Ecology of Nature Research Centre, Akademijos st. 2, LT-08412 Vilnius, Lithuania,
Vilnius University, Faculty of Chemistry and Geosciences, Naugarduko st. 24, LT-03225 Vilnius,
Lithuania
3
Geology and Geography Institute of Nature Research Centre, Akademijos st. 2, LT-08412 Vilnius,
Lithuania
4
Vilnius University, Life Sciences Center, Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology,
Saulėtekio av. 7, 10223 Vilnius, Lithuania
2
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: zivile.jurgelene@gmail.com, tel.: +370 63385183
Abstract
Nanoparticles may be released into the environment and induce harmful effects to the aquatic
ecosystem. The aims of the present study were to determine: (1) toxicity, genotoxicity and
cytotoxicity to larvae of rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss exposed to 4 nmol/L CdSe/ZnS quantum
dots (QDs); (2) Cd accumulation; (3) the concentration of metallothionein (MT) in larvae after
exposure to QDs; and (4) explain the possible impact mechanism of the QDs to fish larvae. QDs at
sublethal concentration was used during the tests. Our findings revealed that heart rate (HR,
counts/min) of larvae didn’t differ significantly (p < 0.05) from the control; gill ventilation frequency
(GVF, counts/min) significantly (p < 0.05) increased only after 10 days of exposure to QDs compared
to the control. Total genotoxicity level (erythroblasts with micronuclei and nuclear buds) in larvae
significantly (p < 0.05) increased after 4 days of exposure. However, 4 nmol/L QDs did not induce
significant cytotoxicity over the concentration applied. QDs induced a significant increase in Cd
accumulation in larvae after 4-10 days of exposure in comparison with the control. MT was used as
a marker of internal Cd exposure, thus providing indirect information on in vivo QDs degradation.
The concentration of MT did not change in larvae during treatment. Therefore, QDs were stable
during 10 days of exposure. QDs absorption was not found to take place in larvae. Possibly, the effects
of QDs to larvae are related to mechanical impact of QDs.
Keywords: quantum dots; fish; accumulation; toxicity, genotoxicity and cytotoxicity;
metallothioneins
1.
INTRODUCTION
The rapid growth in the nanotechnology industry leads to use of novel nanomaterials like quantum
dots (QDs) for biomedical applications, such as diagnostics, drug delivery and nanotherapy. The
knowledge regarding the uptake mechanisms of nanoparticles (NPs) and toxicity to organism is not
well understood (Murugan et al, 2015). QDs are semiconductor crystals of nanometer dimensions (2–
10 nm), containing 200–10000 atoms, and can consist of a cadmium/selenide (CdSe) core with a zinc
sulfide (ZnS) shell with some type of surface coating. To their strong fluorescence intensity, their
stability, water solubility, small size and flexible surface charge enable QDs suitable agents to study
uptake with in vitro and in vivo studies (Zhang et al, 2011). Nevertheless, little is known about the
775
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
environmental risks of exposure to these NPs. Due to their possible large scale of production in future
and NPs release in the environment has led to alarming on their potential long-term toxicity related
to the fact that these materials contain heavy metals such as Cd, As, Zn, Pb (Libralato et al, 2017).
The question is open about the safety of using QDs for treating patients, as there are not enough
reliable studies on their toxicological effects. Oh et al (2016) study showed the need for more indepth analysis for major QDs types, because QDs toxicity is closely correlated with many specific
parameters of QDs, such as surface properties (including shell, ligand and surface modifications),
diameter, assay type and exposure time. Two major mechanisms are involved in the toxicity effects
of QDs: Cd2+ in the structure that could cause interference in DNA repair or increase of oxidative
stress and free radical formation. The release of Cd2+ from the core of QDs influences toxicity and
causing ROS generation (Ji et al, 2015).
Studies undertaken to investigate QDs effect have used a broad range of QDs types and included
classical cytotoxicity assays, and have examined the effects of QDs on cellular organelles and
gene/protein expression, as well as their behavior and fate in vertebrate and invertebrate models (Oh
et al, 2016; Rocha et al, 2017). Fishes or mice are usually employed to evaluate in vivo effects of
contaminants, but studies with mice are time consuming, present ethical issues and are expensive
(Yong et al, 2013). In recent years, the use of fish as an established animal model system for NPs
toxicity assay is growing exponentially (Chakraborty et al, 2016; Rocha et al, 2017). Different types
of parameters are used to evaluate NPs toxicity such as hatching achievement rate, developmental
malformation of organs, damage in gill and skin, abnormal behavior (movement impairment),
immunotoxicity, genotoxicity or gene expression, neurotoxicity, endocrine system disruption,
reproduction toxicity and finally mortality (Chakraborty et al, 2016).
QDs may be released into the environment and induce harmful effects to humans and the ecosystem
(Demir and Castranova 2017). QDs can be transferred from prey to predator in a microbial food chain
(Werlin et al, 2011). Lee et al (2015) showed a three-level (from Astasia longa (protozoa) to Moina
macrocopa (cladoceran), and to Danio rerio (fish)) transfer of QDs in the aquatic environment. In
addition, NPs with certain physicochemical characteristics can readily enter biological membranes
(Murugan et al, 2015). NPs may reach the embryo from somatic tissues, in case of their capability to
cross species-specific barriers, spanning from embryo protective layers (i.e., chorion membrane for
zebrafish and Drosophila) up to the highly structured mammalian placenta (Tortiglione 2011).
Many QDs produced characteristic signs of Cd toxicity that were weakly correlated with
metallothionein (MT) expression, indicating that QDs were slightly degraded in vivo (King-Heiden
et al, 2009). Using MT gene induction as an indicator of Cd2+ release, these studies could detect
breakdown of QDs after absorption by the organism (King-Heiden et al, 2009). Additionally, the
fluorescence emission shifts from red to blue and the excitation fluorescence peak become broader
during QDs biodegradation (Alaraby et al, 2015). Furthermore, the QDs degradation could be due to
low pH or oxidation of QDs surface (Khalil et al, 2011). The low pH conditions of the gastric tract
can contribute to QDs degradation in Drosophila larvae and fish (Alaraby et al, 2015; Duan et al,
2013).
The current knowledge is yet too limited to drawing conclusions about risks of QDs to early
development stages. Further investigations are needed for clarify toxic mechanisms of QDs,
particularly in early development of organisms. The aims of present study were to assess toxicity,
genotoxicity and cytotoxicity to larvae of rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss exposed to 4 nmol/L
CdSe/ZnS quantum dots (QDs), to determine accumulation of Cd and the concentration of
metallothionein (MT) in the whole body of larvae exposed to QDs, and to explain the possible impact
mechanism of the QDs to fish larvae.
776
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Exposure of fish was performed at the Laboratory of Ecology and Physiology of Hydrobionts (Nature
Research Centre, Lithuania). Embryos of O. mykiss in the eyed-egg stage were obtained from Simnas
Experimental Hatchery (Alytus District, Lithuania). All studies have been carried out with nonprotected life-stages in accordance with Directive 2010/63/EU.
Water-soluble, red emitting semiconductor QDs (Qdot® ITK™, Life Technologies, CA, USA) a size
of about 5 - 7 nm as determined by transmission electron microscopy were used at a concentration of
4 x 10-9 mol/L. The concentration of QDs was chosen according to the study of Yong et al (2013)
who showed that LC50 values of CdSe–ZnS to zebrafish are in the range of 0.7 - 4.2 x 10-7 mol/L. A
volume of 100 μL of a stock dispersion of 8 μmol/L QDs was diluted with deep-well water to achieve
final concentrations of 4 x 10-9 mol/L in the incubation media. Continuous aeration was used to keep
the particles suspended.
The toxicity test was performed in a climate cabinet (Bronson PGC-660, Zaltbommel, the
Netherlands) with continuous aeration under static conditions according to ISO 7346-1:1996, without
water changing. According to the OECD 210 (OECD 1992), the experiments were carried out in the
dark and the larvae were not fed (ISO 10229:1994). The studies were performed in three replicates.
Deep-well water used for dilution and as control water had a mean pH of 8.0; the temperature was
maintained at 10 ± 0.5 oC, and the oxygen concentration was 10 mg/L. Dissolved oxygen in the tanks,
temperature and pH were measured routinely with a hand-held multi-meter (Multi 340i/SET, WTW,
Weilheim, Germany). Heart rate (HR, counts/min) and gill ventilation frequency (GVF, counts/min)
of larvae were evaluated using stereomicroscope (RZ Series, Meiji Techno, Saitama, Japan). Samples
of larvae were taken upon days 4, 7 and 10 after exposure start.
Induction of micronuclei (MN), nuclear buds (NB), bi-nucleated (BN), fragmented-apoptotic (FA)
cells were analysed in erythroblasts of larvae. Total genotoxicity level was assessed as the sum of
MN and NB, as well as total cytotoxicity level – as the sum of BN and FA frequencies. Cell smears
were prepared from whole larvae (with removed yolk sac) body (gently nipped with tweezers):
directly smeared on glass slides and air-dried. Smears were fixed in methanol for 10 min. and later
were stained with 10 % Giemsa solution in phosphate buffer pH = 6.8 for 20 - 40 min. The stained
slides were analysed under light microscopes Olympus BX51 at final magnification of 1,000×.
Micronuclei and other nuclear abnormalities (NAs) were identified following criteria described by
Fenech et al (2003). The frequencies of abnormalities were recorded in 1,000 erythroblasts per slide
using blind scoring by a single observer.
Experiment of the accumulation of QDs in larvae lasted 10 days: starting from 1-day-old larvae under
static conditions according to ISO 7346-1:1996. The Cd accumulation was measured in the whole
body of larvae (10 individuals per 3 replicate). Sampled organisms were dried up on absorbent paper,
weighted and then stored at −18 °C until Cd analysis. For Cd analysis in larvae, the digestion method
was used (Thomas and Mohaideen 2015). The content of Cd in the experimental water and in the
whole body of the fish larvae was analyzed by an atomic absorption spectrophotometer SHIMADZU
AA-7000 (Japan) with a graphite furnace atomizer GFA-7000 and auto-sampler ASC-7000
(measured wavelength 185 to 900 ± 0.3 nm, high-speed deuterium lamp 185 to 430 nm, heating
temperature range 50 to 3000 0C, repeatability 2.5%) according to the analysis method LST EN ISO
15586: 2004. The concentration of Cd standard (Sigma-Aldrich Chemie GmbH, Germany) for atomic
absorption spectrophotometer is 1000 mg/L and Cd detection limit is 0.3 μg/L.
MT content determination was assayed according to the method of Peixoto et al (2003). For MT level
assays, 7 and 10 days old larvae of rainbow trout were weighted and frozen (-80 °C). The larvae were
homogenized with Potter-Elvehjem homogenizer in 4 volumes of 20 mM tris (hydroxymethyl)
aminomethane HCl buffer, pH 8.6, containing 0.5 mM phenylmethylsulphonyl fluoride and 0.01%
-mercaptoethanol. The homogenate was then centrifuged at 17,000 × g for 30 min at 4 °C. Aliquots
of 1 ml of supernatant containing MT were added with 1.05 ml of cold (-20 °C) absolute ethanol and
777
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
80 l chloroform. The samlpes were centrifuged at 6000 × g for 10 min at 4 °C. The collected
supernatant was combined with three volumes of cold ethanol (-20 °C), maintained at -20 °C for 1 h
and centrifuged at 6000 × g for 10 min at 4 °C. The metallothionein-containing pellets were then
rinsed with 1 ml of 87% ethanol and 1% chloroform mix and centrifuged at 6000 × g for 10 min at 4
°C. The MT content in the pellet was evaluated using the colorimetric method with 5,5’-dithio-bis(2nitrobenzoic acid) reagent. The pellet was suspended in 150 l 0.25 M NaCl and subsequently 150
l 1 N HCl containing 4 mM ethylendiamintetraacetic acid calcium disodium salt were added to the
sample. 4.2 ml 2 M NaCl containing 0.43 mM 5,5’-dithio-bis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) buffered with 0.2
M Na-phosphate, pH 8.0 was then added to the sample at room temperature. The sample was
centrifuged at 3000 × g for 5 min at room temperature. The supernatant absorbance was evaluated at
412 nm. MT concentration was estimated using molar absorption coefficient at 412 nm 14140 M-1cm1
and expressed as micrograms of SH groups per gram of wet weight.
Means and standard deviations or standard errors for each studied parameter were calculated.
Differences between the evaluated characteristics studied were tested by two-way ANOVA using
Statistica 7.0 software (StatSoft Inc., Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA). Results of nuclear abnormalities assay
were analyzed by non-parametric Mann-Whitney test (GraphPad Software Inc., San Diego, CA,
USA). Differences were accepted as significant at the 95 % level of confidence (p < 0.05).
3.
RESULTS
In this investigation, GVF of larvae after 10 days of exposure to QDs significantly (p < 0.05) increased
as compared to the control (Figure 1 A). Meanwhile, after 4 and 7 days of exposure to QDs GVF of
larvae did not differ significantly from the control. Also, HR of larvae throughout the exposure period
did not differ significantly from the control, ranging from 101.60 ± 6.73 to 103.73 ± 8.48 counts/min
(in control HR was from 101.33 ± 3.90 to 103.20 ± 5.06 counts/min) (Figure 1 B).
Results of total cytotoxicity and total genotoxicity levels in erythroblasts of O. mykiss larvae are given
in Figure 2. Significant elevation of the total cytotoxicity level was not found after QDs treatment.
However, total cytotoxicity level after 4 days of exposure was approximately 5-fold higher compared
to the control level. Treatment with QDs significantly increased total genotoxicity level in larvae
erythroblasts, which was 2.5-fold higher than the control level.
Figure 1. Toxic effect of QDs on biological parameters of O. mykiss larvae: (A) GVF
(counts/min) and (B) HR (counts/min) (mean ± SEM, N = 15). * Significant difference from the
control (p < 0.05).
778
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2. Total cytotoxicity (bi-nucleated (BN)+ fragmented-apoptotic (FA)) and total
genotoxicity (micronuclei (MN)+ nuclear buds (NB)) levels (mean ± SEM, N = 7) in
erythroblasts of O. mykiss larvae in control and QDs exposed groups. Asterisks (*) denote
significant differences from control group (p < 0.05)
Changes of Cd concentrations in larvae during experiment are shown in Figure 3. Samples of larvae
were taken upon days 4, 7 and 10 after exposure start to determine the accumulation of QDs to
rainbow trout larvae depending on the duration of exposure. Cd accumulation in larvae after 4, 7 and
10 days exposures to QDs were significantly (p < 0.05) different from the control (Figure 3). The
maximum value of accumulated Cd was found in larvae exposed to QDs after 10 days of exposure
(1.302 ± 0.272 µg/g). However, accumulation of Cd in larvae did not depend on the duration of
exposure.
Figure 3. Cd accumulation (wet weight, µg/g) in O. mykiss larvae after 4, 7 and 10 days of
exposure to QDs.
Measured MT content was used as a marker of internal QDs exposure. However, the MT contents in
larvae showed no significant changes after treatment QDs for 7 and 10 days compared to the control
(Figure 4).
Figure 4. Metallothionein content (SH groups, mg/g) in O. mykiss larvae after 7 and 10 days of
exposure to QDs.
779
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
The toxicity study showed significantly (p < 0.05) increased GVF of larvae as compared to the control
after 10 days of exposure to QDs, however GVF in larvae showed no significant changes after 4 and
7 days of exposure, and HR in larvae showed no significant changes after 4, and 10 days of exposure
to QDs (Figure 1 A and B). One possible explanation for these results is that QDs interfered with
breathing due to QDs adhesion in gill. Gill is an important organ for respiration, osmoregulation,
acid-base balance and nitrogenous waste excretion (Mansouri et al, 2016). Gills are most important
targets of waterborne objects such as NP (Chakraborty et al, 2016). For instance, Cu NPs may damage
gills lamellae of zebrafish (Griffitt et al, 2007). It was noticed that gill of larvae forms mucus complex
with QDs. Mucus secretion were also observed in the present study and were reported by other authors
(Federici et al, 2007; Smith et al, 2007) for rainbow trout exposed to single walled carbon nanotubes
and titanium dioxide nanoparticles. In addition, Ag NPs can induce excessive mucus secretion and
hyperplasia in gill tissue of zebrafish (Mansouri and Johari 2016). The larvae gradually developed
unique systems to protect themselves from the toxicity of chemicals. The number of mucous cells
may be an indicator of exposure to stressors (Ostaszewska et al, 2016). An increase in the number of
mucous cells secreting sulfated and carboxylated mucins is associated to the increase in mucus
viscosity, which improves its protective properties (Kumari et al, 2009). Mucus consists of
immunoglobulin, lysosome, and lectin that protect fish against infections. According to Poleksic et al
(2010) reduction of mucous cell abundance at the highest AgNPs concentration and a decrease in the
number and area of mucous cells in fish exposed to CuNPs show exhaustion of proliferative ability
of mucous cells.
The most obvious finding to emerge from the nuclear abnormalities analysis in larvae is that
significant increase of total genotoxicity level (as sum of MN and NB frequencies) in QDs exposed
larvae eryhtroblasts was determined. Xiao et al (2016) study results revealed that carbon QDs
exposure causes significant DNA damage in embryonic cells of Rare Minnow (Gobiocypris rarus).
Oxidative stress induced DNA damage and the inflammatory response are considered to be the main
mechanisms causing toxicity of the NPs (Xiao et al, 2016; Schins and Hei 2006; Schins and Knaapen
2007). Further studies focusing on QDs-induced genotoxicity should be performed using fish
erythroblasts/erythrocytes, which, as indicated by the present study, are important targets for in vivo
QDs toxicity.
As shown in Figure 3, the Cd amount in larvae was significantly (p < 0.05) different from the control
during the exposure period. QDs potential risk could be caused by the nanomaterial itself or by their
free metallic components (Hardman 2006). The determination of chemical concentration in larvae is
a challenge since it requires highly sensitive analytical techniques owing to the low sample amount
(1 larvae ~ 0.1 g). In this study, larvae do not feed yet, suggesting that one possible way to pass QDs
in the larvae are skin-absorption. It is well known that biological barriers play a significant function
to determine QDs biodistribution (Chu et al, 2010). A small size of QDs (between 1 and 100
nanometers) permits these NPs to get into the body through cellular barriers and can reach organs and
tissues and interact with biological structures, thus impact normal functions in different ways
(Maldiney et al, 2011). NPs could accumulate selectively in the head, yolk sac and the tail after NPs
enter into the larvae body through swallowing and skin-absorption (Kang et al, 2015). However, QDs
could be eliminated in the urine of larvae or degraded into particles and could be removed by
lysosome-like vesicles, and then accumulate in the kidney and liver (Lei et al, 2011). In contrast,
during normal metabolism, the primary accumulation tissues of heavy metal Cd are the liver and
kidneys (Haouem et al, 2007). Lei et al (2011) noted that MAA-QDs were unable to diffuse into the
yolk of larvae because of the high content of lipids in the yolk cell.
MT content (an indicator of metal ion exposure) were used to detect toxicity due to Cd2+, however
MT contents in larvae did not significantly increase after 7 and 10 days of exposure (Figure 4). Our
research data coincides with Fischer et al (2006) data that ZnS shell and surface ligands protect QDs
780
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
from degradation in vivo. Therefore, QDs were stable during 10 days of exposure and QDs absorption
was not in larvae. In contrast with our finding, King-Heiden et al (2009) noticed that QDs degraded
at least partially in vivo, MT expression correlated with CdCl2 and QDs exposure concentrations.
In summary, this study demonstrates that QDs induced significantly (p < 0.05) increased GVF of
larvae as compared to the control only after 10 days of exposure to QDs, however QDs did not cause
GVF changes in larvae after 4 and 7 days of exposure and HR changes in larvae after 4, 7 and 10 days
of exposure (Figure 1 A and B). Furthermore, total genotoxicity level was found to increase
significantly after 4 days exposure to QDs (Figure 2). The Cd amount in larvae was significantly (p
< 0.05) different from the control throughout the exposure period (Figure 3). Our study further
demonstrated that the MT levels of larvae were unchanged (Figure 4), which might explain that QDs
were stable and QDs absorption was not in larvae. Thus, our findings suggest that exposure to QDs
could be due to QDs adhesion in gill, which induced toxicity to larvae. Results of toxicity and
genotoxicity studies allow to assuming that the mechanical impact of QDs could be one of the factors
induced the changes of physiologic function in fish larvae. However, further investigation must be
undertaken to confirm this presumption.
Acknowledgment
Toxicity, accumulation of QDs and MT content assessment was funded by the Research Council of
Lithuania, Project No. MIP-108/2015. Genotoxicity and cytotoxicity studies were funded by the
Research Council of Lithuania, Project No. S-MIP-17-10.
References
1. Alaraby M., E. Demir, A. Hernández and R. Marcos (2015) ‘Assessing potential harmful effects
of CdSe quantum dots by using Drosophila melanogaster as in vivo model’, Science of the Total
Environment, Vol. 530-531, pp. 66-75.
2. Chakraborty C., A.R. Sharma, G. Sharma and S.-S. Lee (2016) ‘Zebrafish: A complete animal
model to enumerate the nanoparticle toxicity’, Journal of nanobiotechnology, Vol. 14: 65.
3. Chu M., Q. Wu, H. Yang, R. Yuan, S. Hou, Y. Yang, Y. Zou, S. Xu, K. Xu, A. Ji and L. Sheng
(2010) ‘Transfer of quantum dots from pregnant mice to pups across the placental barrier’, Small,
Vol. 6(5), pp. 670-8.
4. Demir E. and V Castranova (2017) ‘Evaluation of the Potential Genotoxicity of Quantum Dots.
A Review’, Scientific Pages Nanotechnology, Vol. 1(1), pp. 1-19.
5. Directive 2010/63/EU, of the European Parliament and of the Council of the European Union. On
the Protection of Animals Used for Scientific Purposes. Official Journal of the European Union
L276, 233-279, 2010.
6. Duan J., Y. Yongbo, L. Yang, Y. Yang, L. Yanbo, H. P, Z. Xianqing, P. Shuangqing and S. Zhiwei
(2013) ‘Developmental toxicity of CdTe QDs in zebrafish embryos and larvae’, Journal of
Nanoparticle Research, Vol. 15, 1700.
7. Federici G., B.J. Shaw and R.H. Handy (2007) ‘Toxicity of titanium dioxide nanoparticles to
rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss): gill injury, oxidative stress, and other physiological
effects’, Aquatic Toxicology, Vol. 84, pp. 415-430.
8. Fenech M., W.P. Chang, M. Kirsch-Volders, N. Holland, S. Bonassi and E. Zeiger (2003)
‘HUMN project: detailed description of the scoring criteria for the cytokinesis-block
micronucleus assay using isolated humanlymphocyte cultures’, Mutation research, Vol. 534, pp.
65-75.
9. Fischer H.C., L. Liu, K.S. Pang and W.C.W. Chan (2006) ‘Pharmacokinetics of nanoscale
quantum dots: In vivo distribution, sequesteration, and clearance in the rat. Advanced Functional
Materials, Vol. 16, pp. 1299-1305.
781
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
10. Griffitt R.J., R. Weil, K.A. Hyndman, N.D. Denslow, K. Powers, D. Taylor and D.S. Barber
(2007) ‘Exposure to copper nanoparticles causes gill injury and acute lethality in zebrafish (Danio
rerio)’, Environmental Science & Technology, Vol. 41, pp. 8178-8186.
11. Haouem S., N. Hmad, M.F. Najjar, A. El Hani and R. Sakly (2007) ‘Accumulation of cadmium
and its effects on liver and kidney functions in rats given diet containing cadmium polluted radish
bulb’, Experimental and Toxicologic Pathology, Vol. 59, pp. 77-80.
12. Hardman R. (2006) ‘Review A Toxicologic Review of Quantum Dots: Toxicity Depends on
Physicochemical and Environmental Factors’, Environmental health perspectives, Vol. 114,
pp. 165-173.
13. ISO 10229: 1994. “Water Quality -- Determination of the Prolonged Toxicity of Substances to
Freshwater Fish -- Method for Evaluating the Effects of Substances on the Growth Rate of
Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss Walbaum (Teleostei, Salmonidae))”
14. ISO 7346-1: 1996. “Water Quality -- Determination of the Acute Lethal Toxicity of Substances
to a Freshwater Fish [Brachydanio rerio Hamilton-Buchanan (Teleostei, Cyprinidae)]”-- Part 1:
Static Method.
15. Ji X., F. Peng, Y. Zhong, Y. Su and Y. He (2014) ‘Fluorescent quantum dots: Synthesis,
biomedical optical imaging, and biosafety assessment’, Colloids Surf. B Biointerf, Vol. 124, pp.
132-139.
16. Kang Y.F., Y.H. Li, Y.W. Fang, Y. Xu, X.-M. Wei and X.-B. Yin (2015) ‘Carbon Quantum Dots
for Zebrafish Fluorescence Imaging’, Scientific Reports, Vol. 5, 11835, DOI:
10.1038/srep11835.
17. Khalil W.K., E. Girgis, A.N. Emam, M.B. Mohamed and K.V. Rao (2011) ‘Genotoxicity
evaluation of nanomaterials: DNA damage, micronuclei, and 8-hyroxy-2deoxyguanosine induced
by magnetic doped CdSe quantum dots in male mice’, Chemical Research in Toxicology, Vol.
24, pp. 640-650.
18. King-Heiden T.C., P.N. Wiecinski, A.N. Mangham, K.M. Met, D. Nesbit, J.A. Pedersen, R.J.
Hamers, W. Heideman and R.E. Peterson (2009) ‘Quantum dot nanotoxicity assessment using the
zebrafish embryo’, Environmental Science & Technology, Vol. 43(5), pp. 1605-1611.
19. Kumari U., M. Yashpal, S. Mittal and A.K. Mitta (2009) ‘Histochemical analysis of glycoproteins
in the secretory cells in the gill epithelium of a catfish Rita rita (Siluriformes, Bagridae)’, Tissue
Cell, Vol. 41, pp. 271-280.
20. Lee W.M and Y.J. An (2015) ‘Evidence of three-level trophic transfer of quantum dots in an
aquatic food chain by using bioimaging’, Nanotoxicology, Vol. 9, pp. 407-412.
21. Lei Y., Q. Xiao, S. Huang, W. Xu, Z. Zhang, Z. He, Y. Liu and F. Deng (2011) ‘Impact of
CdSe/ZnS quantum dots on the development of zebrafish embryos’, The Journal of
Nanoparticle Research, Vol. 13, pp. 6895-6906.
22. Libralato G., E. Galdiero, A. Falanga, R. Carotenuto, E. de Alteriis and M. Guida (2017) ‘Toxicity
Effects of Functionalized Quantum Dots, Gold and Polystyrene Nanoparticles on Target Aquatic
Biological Models: A Review’, Molecules, Vol. 22, 1439; doi:10.3390/molecules22091439.
23. LST EN ISO 15586:2004. Vandens kokybė. Mikroelementu nustatymas atominės absorbcijos
spektrometrija, naudojant grafitine krosni (ISO 15586:2003).
24. Maldiney T., C. Richard, J. Seguin, N. Wattier, M. Bessodes and D. Scherman (2011) ‘Effect of
core diameter, surface coating, and PEG chain length on the biodistribution of persistent
luminescence nanoparticles in mice’, ACS Nano, Vol. 5(2), pp. 854-62. doi:10.1021/ nn101937h
782
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
25. Mansouri B. and S.A. Johari (2016) ‘Effects of short-term exposure to sublethal concentrations
of silver nanoparticles on histopathology and electron microscope ultrastructure of zebrafish
(Danio rerio) gills’, Iranian Journal of Toxicology, Vol. 10, pp. 15-20.
26. Mansouri B., R. Rahmani, N.A. Azadi and S.A. Johari (2016) ‘Combined effects of silver
nanoparticles and mercury on gill histopathology of zebrafish (Danio rerio)’, Journal of Coastal
Life Medicine, Vol. 4(6), pp. 421-425.
27. Murugan K., Y.E Choonara, P. Kumar, D. Bijukumar, L.C du Toit and V. Pillay (2015)
‘Parameters and characteristics governing cellular internalization and trans-barrier trafficking of
nanostructures’, International journal of nanomedicine, Vol. 10, pp. 2191-2206.
28. OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development). 1992. Guideline for the
Testing of Chemicals: Fish, Early-life Stage Toxicity Test, Part 210.
29. Oh E., R. Liu, A. Nel, K.B. Gemill, M. Bilal, Y. Cohen and I.L. Medintz (2016) ‘Meta-analysis
of cellular toxicity for cadmium-containing quantum dots’, Nature Nanotechnology, Vol. 11,
pp. 479-486.
30. Ostaszewska T., M. Chojnacki, M. Kamaszewski and E. Sawosz-Chwalibóg (2016)
‘Histopathological effects of silver and copper nanoparticles on the epidermis, gills, and liver of
Siberian sturgeon’, Environmental science and pollution research international, Vol. 23, pp.
1621-1633.
31. Peixoto N.C., T. Roza, E.M. Flores and M.E. Pereira (2003) ‘Effects of zinc and cadmium on
HgCl2-delta-ALA-D inhibition and Hg levels in tissues of suckling rats’, Toxicology Letters,
Vol. 46, pp.17-25.
32. Poleksic V., M. Lenhardt, I. Jaric, D. Djordjevic, Z. Gacic, G. Cvijanovic and B. Raskovic (2010)
‘Liver, gills, and skin histopathology and heavy metal content of the Danube sterlet (Acipenser
ruthenus Linnaeus, 1758)’, Environmental toxicology and chemistry, Vol. 29, pp. 515-521.
33. Rocha T.L., N.C. Mestre, S.M.T. Saboia-Morais and M.J. Bebianno (2017) ‘Environmental
behaviour and ecotoxicity of quantum dots at various trophic levels: A review’, Environment
International, Vol. 98, pp. 1-17.
34. Schins R.P. and A.M. Knaapen (2007) ‘Genotoxicity of poorly soluble particles’, Inhalation
Toxicology, Vol. 19, pp. 189-198.
35. Schins R.P. and T.K. Hei (2006) ‘Genotoxic Effects of Particles’, In: Donaldson K and Borm P,
Particle toxicology. CRC Press/Taylor & Francis Group, USA, pp. 285-298.
36. Smith C.J., B.J. Shaw and R.D Handy (2007) ‘Toxicity of single walled carbon nanotubes to
rainbow trout, (Oncorhynchus mykiss): respiratory toxicity, organ pathologies, and other
physiological effects’, Aquatic Toxicology, Vol. 82, pp. 94-109.
37. Thomas S. and J. A. Mohaideen (2015) ‘Determination of some heavy metals in fish, water and
sediments from Bay of Bengal’, International Journal of Chemical Sciences, Vol. 13(1), pp.
53-62.
38. Tortiglione C. (2011) ‘The heritable effects of nanotoxicity. Review’, Nanomedicine (Lond.),
Vol. 9(18), pp. 2829-2841.
39. Werlin R., J.H. Priester, R.E. Meilke, S. Krämer, S. Jackson, P.K. Stoimenov, G.D. Stucky, G.N.
Cherr, E. Orias and P.A. Holden (2011) ‘Biomagnification of cadmium selenide quantum dots in
a simple experimental microbial food chain’, Nature Nanotechnology, Vol. 6, pp. 65-71.
40. Xiao Y., L. Liu, Y. Chen, Y. Zeng, M. Liu and L. Jin (2016) ‘Developmental Toxicity of Carbon
Quantum Dots to the Embryos/Larvae of Rare Minnow (Gobiocypris rarus)’, BioMed Research
International, 11 pages.
783
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
41. Yong K.T., W.C. Law, R. Hu, L. Ye, L.W. Liu, M.T. Swihart and P.N. Prasad (2013)
‘Nanotoxicity assessment of quantum dots: from cellular to primate studies’, Chemical Society
Reviews,42(3), pp. 1236-1250.
42. Zhang L.W, W. Bäumer and N.A Monteiro-Riviere (2011) ‘Cellular uptake mechanisms and
toxicity of quantum dots in dendritic cells’, Nanomedicine (Lond), 6(5), pp. 777-791.
784
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
ERYTHROCYTIC NUCLEAR ABNORMALITIES, DNA DAMAGE,
BIOCONCENTRATION FACTOR AND HEMATOLOGICAL
CHANGES INDUCED BY METAL MIXTURE AT
ENVIRONMENTALLY RELEVANT CONCENTRATIONS IN
RUTILUS RUTILUS
M. Stankevičiūtė*1, G. Sauliutė1, A. Markuckas2, T. Virbickas1, J. Baršienė1
1
2
Nature Research Centre, Akademijos st. 2, LT-08412 Vilnius, Lithuania
Vilnius University, Life Sciences Center, Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology,
Saulėtekio av. 7, 10223 Vilnius, Lithuania
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: milda.stan@gmail.com, tel: +370 60716809
Abstract
The aim of this study was to assess bioconcentration factor (BCF), metallothioneins (MT),
genotoxicity, cytotoxicity and changes of haematological parameters in roach Rutilus rutilus after 14
days treatment with a six metals mixture (MIX) at environmentally relevant concentrations (Zn – 0.1,
Cu – 0.01, Ni – 0.01, Cr – 0.01, Pb – 0.005 and Cd – 0.005 mg/L) and with 6 variants (reduced
concentration of single metal while other metals concentration remain constant) of the MIX. Most
frequently the highest accumulated amount of metals in tissues (gills, liver, kidneys, muscle) was
detected after treatment with variants of MIX. Significantly reduced concentration of accumulated Ni
was measured after Cu↓, Cr↓, Pb↓ and Cd↓ treatments (10 times reduced Cu2+, Cr6+, Pb2+and Cd2+
concentration, respectively) in all tissues (except in liver after Cu↓, Cr↓ and Cd↓ treatments)
compared with MIX. Significant induction of MT in liver and kidneys was not detected. However,
positive correlation (r = 0.83; p = 0.022) was measured between MT and Zn amount in liver. DNA
damage in erythrocytes of roach was examined by comet assay. Additionally, erythrocytic nuclear
abnormalities were assessed in erythrocytes of peripheral blood, liver, kidneys and gills. Significant
DNA damage was measured after Cr↓, Pb↓ and Zn↓ treatments. Significant elevations in total ENAs
were measured after Cr↓ and Ni↓, MIX or Ni↓ treatments in peripheral blood, gills and kidneys
erythrocytes, respectively. The frequencies of separate ENAs such as micronuclei, enucleus were
significantly elevated after Cr↓, Ni↓ treatments in peripheral blood, respectively; apoptotic cells –
after MIX treatment in gills and enucleus after Ni↓ treatment in liver compared to control level.
Decreased number of red blood cells, haematocrit level, haemoglobin concentration and increased
number of white blood cells in peripheral blood was measured after MIX treatment. However, only
decrease in haemoglobin concentration was statistically significant.
Keywords: Genotoxicity; comet assay; cytotoxicity; bioconcentration factor (BCF); Rutilus rutilus;
metallothioneins
1.
INTRODUCTION
Metals in the environment continue to create serious global health concerns, because metals cannot
be degraded into non-toxic forms and are persistent pollutants in the ecosystems (Ayangbenro and
Babalola, 2017). Metals at certain concentrations are toxic to all life forms. However, contamination
of the ecosystems with metals continues to increase and exceed the recommended limit in the
environment (Dixit et al, 2015). Several studies showed that metals are toxic to fish even at low
785
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
concentrations and are capable of inducing genotoxicity, cytotoxicity, DNA fragmentation and other
toxicity endpoints (Zhu et al, 2004; Cavas et al, 2005). Genotoxicity and cytotoxicity of metal mixture
at Maximum-Permissible-Concentrations (MPC) previously were evaluated in rainbow trout
(Ochorhyncus mykiss) (Valskienė et al, 2015) and Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) (Stankevičiūtė et al,
2017). Significant accumulation of metals in S. salar tissues also was reported after treatment with
metal mixture at MPC (Stankevičiūtė et al, 2017). However, most of the studies evaluating joint metal
toxicity are dealing with binary metal mixtures toxicity at high concentrations (Driessnack et at.,
2016, 2017; Duran et al, 2015; Winter et al, 2012). Notwithstanding, fish in the environment
encounters with complex metal mixtures. Such exposure may lead to higher toxicity and
bioaccumulation levels due to interactions of compounds in the metal mixture (Heys et al, 2016;
Cedergreen, 2014).
This study was designed to evaluate metal mixture induced genotoxicity, cytotoxicity, changes in
haematological parameters, bioaccumulation and metallothioneins content in R. rutilus tissues using
whole mixture approach. Whole mixture testing is more similar to the current environment exposure,
because chemicals in the environment exist in mixtures and at low concentrations (Heys et al, 2016).
The main objectives of the present study were: 1) to assess bioconcentration factor (BCF) of metals
in different tissues (gills, liver, kidneys and muscle) of Rutilus rutilus after exposure to metal mixture
at a concentration corresponding to Maximum-Permissible-Concentrations (MPC) accepted for the
inland waters in EU, 2) to assess DNA damage and nuclear abnormalities in erythrocytes of roach
after treatment with metal mixture and variants of this mixture, 3) to evaluate metallothioneins content
in liver and kidneys tissue and 4) to assess haematological changes after fish exposure to metal
mixture.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Experimental set-up
The test was conducted on hatchery-reared 3–4 years old juveniles roach (Rutilus rutilus Linnaeus,
1758), average total weight 50.9 ± 12.4 g and average total length 160.6 ± 12.2 mm (mean ± SD, N
= 56 respectively). The fish was obtained from fish hatchery (Elektrėnai District, Lithuania) and kept
for acclimation in holding tanks (1000-L volume) supplied with flow-through aerated deep-well water
at least two weeks prior to testing. Fish were kept under a natural light cycle and fed commercial fish
feed (ALLER PLATINUM) daily in the morning; the total amount was no less than 1% of their wet
body mass per day. During the experiment, both water supply and diet were kept as during the
acclimation period. Deep-well water was used as the dilution water. Its chemical and physical
characteristics have been presented in our previous research (Stankevičiūtė et al, 2017). Reagent
grade metal salts («REACHIM» Company, Russia) were used as the toxicants. Stock solution was
prepared by dissolving the necessary amount of the salt in distilled water, the final concentration
being recalculated according to the amount of metal ion. The experiment was conducted under semistatic rotating water-current conditions on 8 groups of fish (treatment and control, N = 56). Seven R.
rutilus were put in each polyethylene (PE) tank of 35-L total volume filled to a level of 30 L with
continuously aerated dilution water (7 treatments), a total of 49 fish in treatment and 7 in control
groups. Test fish were exposed for 14 days period to a six metal (Zn, Cu, Ni, Cr, Pb and Cd) mixture
(hereinafter referred to as MIX) at a concentration corresponding to Maximum-PermissibleConcentrations (MPC) accepted for the inland waters in EU (Directive 2008/105/EC) (Table 1). Other
treatments were performed by reducing MPC of single metal in the mixture (MIX) made of 6 metals
by 10-times, while other 5 metals concentrations remain constant (e.g. Zn↓ (metal with reduced
concentration in MIX), while Cu, Ni, Cr, Pb, Cd concentrations remain constant (hereinafter referred
to as Zn↓) and etc.). Test solutions and clean water were renewed every day, and test fish were
transferred into freshly prepared solutions after they were fed.
786
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1. Metals and their test waterborne concentrations (mg/L) in test media.
Concentration (mg/L)
MIX
MIX
Metal↓
Metal
Source
Metal↓
(MPC)
Measured
Measured
nominal
nominal
(mean ± SD)
(mean ± SD)
ZnSO4·7H2O
Zn
0.1
0.115 ± 0.014
0.01
0.02 ± 0.001
CuSO4·5H2O
Cu
0.01
0.009 ± 0.001
0.001
0.0018 ± 0.0003
NiSO4·7H2O
Ni
0.01
0.011 ± 0.002
0.001
< 0.002
K2Cr2O7
Cr
0.01
0.012 ± 0.002
0.001
0.0016 ± 0.0002
Pb(NO3)2
Pb
0.005
0.0045 ± 0.0004 0.0005
< 0.001
Cd(CH3COO)2·2H2O
Cd
0.005
0.0052 ± 0.0003 0.0005
0.00042 ± 0.00003
The main physico-chemical parameters of the water were measured routinely with a hand-held multimeter (WTW Multi 340i/SET, Germany). Designed nominal metal concentrations in the tanks were
checked during blank tests (without fish) (N = 4) with an atomic absorption spectrophotometer
(SHIMADZU AA-6800, Japan) by graphite furnace technique using proprietary software. Each water
sample was acidified with reagent-grade nitric acid (final concentration 0.5% v/v) and analysed in
triplicate. Mean measured concentrations are presented in Table 1.
2.2 Metal bioaccumulation analysis
After the testing was completed, fish (of control and metal-exposed groups) were sacrificed. Fish
were measured (total body length, mm) and weighed (total body weight, g). Later, they were used in
the removal of needed tissues: muscle without skin (~3 g), gills (whole organ), liver (whole organ)
and kidneys (whole organ); organs were weighed to an accuracy of ±0.001 g. Fish samples were hot
air oven-dried at 85 ºC for 24 hours until reached constant weight, pre-digested tightly in a
concentrated ultrapure HNO3 (60%) and H2O2 (30%) (Lach-Ner, Chempur, respectively) at a ratio of
5:1 v/v for eight hours at a room temperature and then microwave-digested quickly (Jia et al 2005).
After cooling solutions were filtered through a 0.45 µm glass filter and diluted with deionized water.
Metal concentrations were measured by atomic absorption spectrophotometry on Varian Spectr AA
55 (USA) with a graphite furnace technique in accordance with standardized procedure ISO
15586:2003 final concentration being expressed as mg/kg of wet weight. Accuracy of analytical
procedure was checked using certified reference material fish homogenate (IAEA–407). Recoveries
were in acceptable range (within 10%) of the certified values.
2.3 Bioconcentration factors (BCF) estimations
Tissues with BCF greater than 1,000 are considered high, and less than 250 is low bioaccumulation
potential, with those between classified as moderate (Landis et al, 2011). BCF values in this study
were calculated as reported by Gobas et al (2009) where bioconcentration factor (BCF) is defined as
the ratio of the steady-state metal ions concentrations in the fish vs the concentration in water:
𝐵𝐶𝐹 =
𝐶𝑓𝑖𝑠ℎ (𝑚𝑔⁄𝑘𝑔 𝑤𝑒𝑡 𝑓𝑖𝑠ℎ)
𝐶𝑤𝑎𝑡𝑒𝑟 (𝑚𝑔∕𝐿)
,
(1)
2.4 Metallothioneins determination
Metallothionein content determination was assayed according to the method of Peixoto et al (2003).
For metallothionein level assays, the liver and kidney were removed, weighted and frozen (-80 °C).
The organs were homogenized with Potter-Elvehjem homogenizer in 4 volumes of 20 mM Tris-HCl
buffer, pH 8.6, containing 0.5 mM PMSF and 0.01% -mercaptoethanol. The homogenate was then
centrifuged at 17,000 × g for 30 min at 4 °C. Aliquots of 1 ml of supernatant containing
metallothioneins were added with 1.05 ml of cold (-20 °C) absolute ethanol and 80 µl chloroform.
787
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
The samples were centrifuged at 6000 × g for 10 min at 4 °C. The collected supernatant was combined
with three volumes of cold ethanol (-20 °C), maintained at -20 °C for 1 h and centrifuged at 6000 ×
g for 10 min at 4 °C. The metallothionein-containing pellets were then rinsed with 1 ml of 87%
ethanol and 1% chloroform mix and centrifuged at 6000 × g for 10 min at 4 °C. The metallothionein
content in the pellet was evaluated using the colorimetric method with DTNB reagent. The pellet was
suspended in 150 µl 0.25 M NaCl and subsequently 150 µl 1 N HCl containing 4 mM EDTA was
added to the sample. 4.2 ml 2 M NaCl containing 0.43 mM DTNB buffered with 0.2 M Na-phosphate,
pH 8.0 was then added to the sample at room temperature. The sample was centrifuged at 3000 × g
for 5 min at room temperature. The supernatant absorbance was evaluated at 412 nm. Metallothionein
concentration was estimated using molar absorption coefficient at 412 nm 14140 M-1cm-1 (Eyer et al,
2003) and expressed as micrograms of SH groups per gram of wet weight.
2.5 Erythrocytic nuclear abnormalities (ENAs) analysis in in vivo assay
ENAs analysis was performed in peripheral blood, gills, kidneys and liver erythrocytes. Blood was
immediately taken from the caudal vein. A drop of blood was directly smeared on microscopic slides
and air-dried. After the sacrifice, small pieces of cephalic kidneys, liver and gills were dissected,
softly dragged along clean slide and allowed to dry for 1-2 h. Dried smears were fixed in methanol
for 10 min. and were stained with 10% Giemsa solution in phosphate buffer pH = 6.8 for 8 min.
(Baršienė et al, 2004). The stained slides were analysed under bright-field microscopes Olympus
BX51 (Tokyo, Japan) using an immersion objective (1000) and the photos were taken with an
Olympus U-CMAD3 (Tokyo, Japan) camera. 4,000 erythrocytes with intact cellular and nuclear
membrane per fish were evaluated using blind scoring by a single observer. Final results were
expressed as the mean value (‰) of sums of analysed individual lesions scored in 1000 erythrocytes
per fish sampled from every study group. The formation of micronuclei (MN), binucleated
erythrocyte with nucleoplasmic bridge (BNb), nuclear buds (NB), nuclear buds on filament (NBf), 8shaped nuclei, fragmented (Fr), apoptotic (Ap), binucleated (BN) erythrocytes were identified using
criteria described by Fenech et al (2003) and Baršienė et al (2014). Additionally, kidney-shaped,
blebbed (BL), vacuolated nuclei (VacNuc), enucleus (EN) erythrocytes were identified (Harabawy
and Mosleh 2014).
2.6 Cell isolation and Comet assay
Peripheral blood samples were collected from the caudal vein using an insulin syringe (30G needle,
3.8% sodium citrate). Blood was placed in a 15 mL glass bottles containing 10 mL of chilled
phosphate buffered saline (PBS). The viability of the erythrocytes was assessed through the Trypan
Blue exclusion method (Anderson and Wild, 1994). Only cell suspensions with viability >90% were
used. Alkaline comet assay version technique was used as described by Singh et al (1988) with slight
modifications (Fatima et al, 2014). The slides were stained with ethidium bromide, placed under a
glass cover and analysed by fluorescence microscopy (Olympus BX51, Olympus U-RFL-T, Tokyo,
Japan); the photos were taken with an Olympus U-CMAD3 (Tokyo, Japan) camera. 50 nuclei of
each individual were scored randomly and captured at 40× magnification. Images were analysed
using Comet assay IV version 4.2 software and percentage of DNA in the tail (% Tail DNA) was
assessed.
2.7 Haematological analysis
Blood was sampled from the caudal vein of fish using an insulin syringe (30G needle, 3.8% sodium
citrate). Following indices of blood parameters were assessed: erythrocytes (RBC, 106 × mm-3),
haemoglobin concentration (Hb, g/l), haematocrit level (Hct, l/l), leukocyte count (WBC, 103 × mm3
) were determined using routine methods (Svobodova et al, 1991).
2.8 Data analysis and statistics
Geno- and cytotoxicity data do not follow a normal distribution (Kolmogorov-Smirnov and ShapiroWilk normality test). Geno-cytotoxicity data were analysed by the nonparametric Kruskal-Wallis test
788
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
followed by Dunns post hoc test (using GraphPad Prism® 5.01 (GraphPad Software Inc., San Diego,
CA, USA)). BCF and MT content data follow a normal distribution. Data for BCF in tissues were
evaluated by two-way factorial ANOVA followed by Bonferroni post hoc test, MT levels was
analysed by a one-way ANOVA followed by Bonferroni post hoc test through STATISTICA 7.0
(StatSoft Inc., Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA) software. Spearman correlation was used to assess the
relationship between MT content and metal accumulation in liver and kidneys tissues. The results
were expressed as mean ± standard error or standard deviation. The level of significance was
established at p<0.05.
3.
RESULTS
3.1 Bioconcentration factor
According to BCF classification scale (Landis et al 2011), low BCF values of analysed metals were
measured in fish tissues, except for Zn [in gills (393.1–613.1)), in liver (170.5–318.8), in kidneys
(249.4–476.7)] and Cu (in liver (971.7–1789.8), in kidneys (139.1–561.7)] (Fig. 1). BCF values
varied depending on metal, metal mixture treatment and specific tissue. BCF values for Zn and Cd in
different tissues after treatment with metal mixtures followed the sequence:
gills>kidneys>liver>muscle; Cu – liver>kidneys>gills>muscle; Ni – kidneys>muscle>gills>liver, Cr
– liver>gills>muscle>kidneys; Pb – gills>liver>kidneys>muscle.
The highest BCF value for Zn was detected in gills tissue after treatment with Pb↓ mixture, in liver –
after Ni↓ and in kidneys – Cu↓ treatment (Fig. 1). Treatments with metal mixtures resulted in the
highest Cu BCF values measured in liver tissue. The highest BCF value of Cu was detected in liver
after Pb↓ treatment, while in kidneys – after Ni↓ treatment. The lowest BCF values for all analysed
metals mostly were detected in muscle tissue after metal mixtures treatment.
BCF of Ni was highly affected by reduction of concentration of all metals (Fig. 1). BCF values for
Ni significantly differ after all treatments (with reduced concentrations of single metal) performed in
comparison to MIX treatment. The highest Ni amount accumulated in gills and muscle tissues was
measured after MIX treatment, in liver – after Cu↓, in kidneys – after Zn↓ treatment. BCF values for
Cr in gills and muscle tissues were significantly higher after Ni↓ treatment compared to MIX
treatment. While MIX treatment resulted in the highest Cr BCF value in liver tissue, and Cu↓
treatment – in the highest Cr BCF value in kidneys compared to MIX treatment. Significant
differences between BCF values for Pb were not detected in kidneys and muscle tissues after all
treatments performed. However, the highest Pb accumulation was measured after MIX treatment in
gills and liver tissues, followed by Pb↓ treatment in gills tissue. Significant differences between BCF
values for Cd were not detected after all treatments performed and in any analysed tissues in
comparison to MIX treatment. The highest Cd BCF was measured after Cr↓ treatment in gills and
kidneys tissues, while after Zn↓ and Cu↓ treatments in liver tissue.
In summary, 10 times reduction of MPC of certain metal, was not always associated with a significant
decrease in the same metal amount accumulated in R. rutilus tissues compared to MIX treatment.
Furthermore, the highest BCF values for metals were measured mostly after treatments with metal
mixtures with reduced metal concentration in comparison to BCF values after MIX treatment.
789
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Figure 1. Bioconcentration factor (BCF) in the selected organ tissues exposed to different
metal mixture (mean±SD, N=7). Grades (#) denote significant differences from MIX
treatment groups (p<0.05).
3.2
Erythrocytic nuclear abnormalities
Figure 2. Erythrocyte nuclear abnormalities (ENAs) in (A) peripheral blood, (B) gills, (C)
liver and (D) kidneys erythrocytes in control fish and fish treated with metal mixtures
(mean±SE, N=7). Asterisks (*) denote significant differences from control group (p<0.05).
790
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
14 days treatment with metal mixtures significantly affected micronuclei, enucleus and apoptotic
erythrocytes frequencies. The frequencies of separate ENAs such as MN, EN were significantly
elevated after Cr↓, Ni↓ treatments in peripheral blood erythrocytes, respectively; apoptotic (Ap) cells
– after MIX treatment in gills and enucleus after Ni↓ treatment in liver erythrocytes compared to
control level. Significant elevations in total ENAs were measured after Cr↓, MIX or Ni↓ treatments
in peripheral blood, gills or kidneys erythrocytes (Fig. 2).
3.3 Comet assay
The exposure of fish to Zn↓, Cr↓ and Pb↓ metal mixtures resulted in significant DNA damage
compared to those from the control group (Fig. 3). The highest percentage of DNA in the tail (22.59
%) was observed after Cr↓ treatment followed by Pb↓ (16.55 %) and Zn↓ (16.08 %) treatments.
Figure 3. DNA damage (percentage of DNA in the tail) in control fish and fish treated with
metal mixtures (mean±SD, N = 7). Asterisks (*) denote significant differences from control
group (p<0.05).
3.4 Haematological parameters and metallothioneins content
Decreased number of red blood cells, haematocrit level, haemoglobin concentration and increased
number of white blood cells in peripheral blood was measured after MIX treatment (Table 2).
However, only decrease in haemoglobin concentration was statistically significant. Metallothionein
content in liver and kidneys is presented in Table 2. Liver and kidneys MT level increased 1.22 and
1.25-fold after MIX treatment, respectively, nevertheless, significant differences were not detected.
Positive correlation (r = 0.83; p = 0.022) was measured between MT and Zn amount in liver.
Table 2. Effects of metal mixture (MIX) on haematological parameters and metallothioneins
(MT) content (mean±SD, N = 7) in R. rutilus liver and kidney.
MT
Treatme
RBC count, WBC count,
Hb, g/l
Hct, l/l
6
-3
3
-3
nt
10 × mm
10 × mm
Liver
Kidneys
Control
84.83±11.07 0.328±0.07
1.33±0.12
23.42±9.05 41.7±15.3
12.5±0.969
64.33±14.88
MIX
0.233±0.06
1.03±0.33
28.75±11.86 50.8±8.84
15.5±4.31
*
Asterisks (*) denote significant differences from control group (p < 0.05)
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
The results demonstrated significant DNA damage, elevation in micronucleus, enucleus and apoptotic
erythrocytes frequencies depending on analysed tissue and performed treatment. Moreover, the
findings of this study revealed that R. rutilus exposure to metal mixture and its variants induced
791
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
variation in metals BCF values, indicating possible interactions between components of primary
metal mixture (MIX) and its variants with 10-times reduced concentration of a single metal.
Significant effect of MIX on MT content was not detected. Nevertheless, significant decrease in
haemoglobin concentration was noted after MIX treatment.
In the present study, muscle tissue exhibited the lowest and less significant variations in metals BCF
values after treatment with MIX variants with 10-time reduced concentration of a single metal, as
compared with MIX (except Ni and Cr BCF). The highest values of BCF were detected in metabolic
body tissues of R. rutilus – gills, liver, kidneys, the least – in muscle. In accordance, Sauliutė et al
(2017) study showed similar results of metals BCF values in S. salar tissues (Sauliutė et al, 2017).
Pb↓ treatment highly affected accumulated amount of Zn and Cr in gill (increased 1.2 and 2.0–fold,
respectively) compared to MIX treatment. Zn↓ treatment 1.2-fold increased Ni accumulation in
kidneys, meanwhile Ni↓ highly affected accumulated amount of Cr in gill and muscle (increased 2.6
and 3.0–fold, respectively) compared to MIX treatment. The highest amount of Zn, Cr and Ni
accumulated was measured after Cu↓ treatment in kidneys and liver, respectively. However,
treatments with reduced concentration of a single metal showed the lowest variation in the amount of
accumulated Cd in tissues, compared to accumulated amount changes of other metals.
In this study, metal mixtures at MPC induced significant formation of MN, EN and Ap in Cr↓, Ni↓
or MIX treatments depending on analysed tissue. The total level of ENAs was also significantly
elevated after Cr↓, Ni↓ or MIX treatments. Gills erythrocytes, considering ENAs induction, were
mostly affected by MIX treatment. In peripheral blood erythrocytes, significant changes in single
endpoints or total ENAs frequencies were detected after Cr↓ or Ni↓ treatments, in liver and kidneys
erythrocytes – after Ni↓ treatment. The potential of metal induced damage to the genetic material
using environmentally relevant concentrations has scarcely been investigated. Prior studies, that have
evaluated toxicity responses in salmonids after treatment with metal mixture at MCP, also reported
significant elevation in geno- and cytotoxicity endpoints after 14 days treatment (Stankevičiūtė et al,
2017, Valskienė et al, 2015). Stankevičiūtė et al (2017) study reported significant genotoxicity
induction in kidneys erythrocytes, while significant cytotoxicity was detected in gills erythrocytes of
Salmo salar after 14-day treatment. Rainbow trout 14 days exposure to metal mixture at MPC also
resulted in elevation of genotoxicity endpoints in blood and kidneys erythrocytes, while significant
cytotoxicity was detected in all analysed tissues (Valskienė et al, 2015).
In the present study, treatment with MIX resulted in decrease of all analysed haematological
parameters, except leukocyte count (WBC). Nevertheless, only decrease in haemoglobin
concentration was significant. The results are in accordance with Vosylienė et al (2006) findings,
which showed decrease in erythrocyte count, haematocrit level and increase in leukocyte count after
rainbow trout exposure to complex metal mixture at various concentrations.
Acknowledgments
This work was funded by the Research Council of Lithuania, Project No. S-MIP-17-10.
Metallothioneins determination was funded by the Research Council of Lithuania, Project No. MIP108/2015.
References
1. Anderson S.L. and G.C. Wild (1994) ‘Linking genotoxic responses and reproductive success in
ecotoxicology’, Environmental Health Perspectives, Vol. 102(9-12).
2. Ayangbenro A.S. and O.O. Babalola (2017) ‘A New Strategy for Heavy Metal Polluted
Environments: A Review of Microbial Biosorbents‘, International Journal of Environmental
Research and Public Health, Vol. 14(94).
3. Baršienė J., J. Lazutka, J. Syvokienė, V. Dedonytė, A. Rybakovas, E. Bagdonas, A. Bjornstad,
O.K. Andersen (2004) ‘Analysis of micronuclei in blue mussels and fish from the Baltic and the
North Seas’, Environmental Toxicology, Vol. 19(4), pp. 365-371.
792
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4. Baršienė J., L. Butrimavičienė, W. Grygiel, T. Lang, A. Michailovas, T. Jackūnas (2014)
‘Environmental genotoxicity and cytotoxicity in flounder (Platichthys flesus), herring (Clupea
harengus) and Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) from chemical munitions dumping zones in the
southern Baltic Sea’, Marine Environmental Research, Vol. 96(56-67).
5. Cavas T., N.N. Garanko, V.V. Arkhipchuk (2005) ‘Induction of micronuclei and binuclei in
blood, gill and liver cells of fishes subchronically exposed to cadmium chloride and copper
sulphate’, Food and Chemical Toxicology, Vol. 43(4), pp. 569-74.
6. Cedergreen N. (2014) ‘Quantifying Synergy: A Systematic Review of Mixture Toxicity Studies
within Environmental Toxicology’, PLoS ONE, Vol. 9(5): e96580.
7. Directive 2008/105/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 496 16 December 2008
on environmental quality standards in the field of water 497 policy, amending and subsequently
repealing Council Directives 82/176/EEC, 498 83/513/EEC, 84/156/EEC, 84/491/EEC,
86/280/EEC and amending Directive 499 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the
Council. Official Journal of the European Communities L 500 348, 24/12/2008 p. 0084-0097.
8. Dixit R., D. Malaviya, K. Pandiyan, U.B. Singh, A. Sahu, R. Shukla, B.P. Singh, J.P. Rai, P.K.
Sharma, H. Lade (2015) ‘Bioremediation of heavy metals from soil and aquatic environment: An
overview of principles and criteria of fundamental processes’, Sustainability, Vol 7, pp. 21892212.
9. Driessnack M.K., A.L. Matthews, J.C. Raine, S. Niyogi (2016) ‘Interactive effects of chronic
waterborne copper and cadmium exposure on tissue-specific metal accumulation and
reproduction in fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas)’, Comparative Biochemistry and
Physiology – Part C 179 (165-173).
10. Driessnack M.K., A. Jamwal, S. Niyogi (2017) ‘Effects of chronic waterborne cadmium and zinc
interactions on tissue specific metal accumulation and reproduction in fathead minnow
(Pimephales promelas)’, Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, Vol. 140, pp. 65-75.
11. Duran S., M. Tunçsoy, B. Yeşilbudak, Ö. Ay, B. Cicik, C. Erdem (2015) ‘Metal Accumulation
In Various Tissues Of Clarias Gariepinus Exposed To Copper, Zinc, Cadmium And Lead Singly
And In Mixture’, Fresenius Environmental Bulletin, Vol. 24(12c).
12. Eyer P., F. Worek, D. Kiderlen, G. Sinko, A. Stuglin, V. Simeon-Rudolf, E. Reiner (2003) ‘Molar
absorption coefficients for the reduced Ellman reagent: reassessment’, Analytical Biochemistry,
Vol. 312, pp. 224-227.
13. Fatima M., N. Usmani, M.M. Hossain, M.F. Siddiqui, M.F. Zafeer, F. Firdaus, S. Ahmad (2014)
‘Assessment of genotoxic induction and deterioration of fish quality in commercial species due
to heavy-metal exposure in an urban reservoir’, Archives of Environmental Contamination
and Toxicology, Vol. 67(2), pp. 203-2013.
14. Fenech M., W.P. Chang, M. Kirsch-Volders, N. Holland, S. Bonassi, E. Zeiger (2003) ‘HUMN
project: detailed description of the scoring criteria for the cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay
using isolated human lymphocyte cultures’, Mutation Research, Vol. 534, pp. 65-75.
15. Gobas F.A.P.C, D. Wolf, W. Burkhard, L.P. Verbruggen, K. Plotzkeet (eds) (2009) ‘Revisiting
bioaccumulation criteria for POPs and PBT assessments’, Integrated Environmental
Assessment and Management, Vol. 5, pp. 624-637.
16. Harabawy A.S.A. and Y.Y.I Mosleh (2014) ‘The role of vitamins A, C, E and selenium as
antioxidants against genotoxicity and cytotoxicity of cadmium, copper, lead and zinc on
erythrocytes of Nile tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus’, Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety,
Vol. 104, pp. 28-35.
17. Heys K.A., R.F. Shore, M.G. Pereira, K.C. Jones, F.L. Martin (2016) ‘Risk assessment of
environmental mixture effects’, RSC Advances, Vol. 6, pp. 47844-47857.
793
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
18. ISO 15586:2003. Water quality. Determination of trace elements using atomic absorption
spectrometry with graphite furnace. Geneva, International Organization for Standardization.
19. Jia H., H. Ren, S. Satoh, H. Endo, T. Hayashi (2005) ‘Comparison of pre-treatment condition of
cadmium in fish sample and diet by microwave digestion method for ICP-AES’, Journal of the
Tokyo University Marine Science and Technology, Vol. 1, pp. 41-46.
20. Landis W., R. Sofield; M.H Yu, W.G. Landis, R.M. Sofield (2011) ‘Introduction to environmental
toxicology: molecular substructures to ecological landscapes’, 4th ed. Boca Raton, Florida: CRC
Press.
21. Peixoto N.C., T. Roza, E.M.M. Flores, M.E. Pereira (2003) ‘Effects of zinc and cadmium on
HgCl2-ALA-D inhibition and Hg levels in tissues of suckling rats’, Toxicology Letters, Vol. 146,
pp. 17-25.
22. Sauliutė G., M. Stankevičiūtė, G. Svecevičius, J. Baršienė, R. Valskienė (2017) ‘Assessment of
heavy metals bioconcentration factor (BCF) and genotoxicity response induced by metal mixture
in Salmo salar tissues’, “Environmental Engineering” 10th International Conference.
23. Singh N.P., M.T. McCoy, R.R. Tice, E.L. Schneider (1988) ‘A simple technique for
quantitationof low levels of DNA damage in individual cells’, Experimental Cell Research, Vol.
175, pp. 184-191.
24. Stankevičiūtė M., G. Sauliutė, G. Svecevičius, N. Kazlauskienė, J. Baršienė (2017) ‘Genotoxicity
and cytotoxicity response to environmentally relevant complex metal mixture (Zn, Cu, Ni, Cr,
Pb, Cd) accumulated in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). Part I: importance of exposure time and
tissue dependence’, Ecotoxicology, Vol. 26(8), pp. 1051-1064.
25. Svobodova Z. and B. Vykusova (Eds.) (1991) ‘Diagnostics, Prevention and Therapy of Fish
Diseases and Intoxications’ Vodnany: Czechoslovakia.
26. Valskienė R, Stankevičiūtė M, Butrimavičienė L, Greiciūnaitė J, Svecevičius G (2015) ‘Induction
of nuclear abnormalities in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) after exposure to a model
mixture of heavy metals (Zn, Cu, Ni, Cr, Cd, Pb) at maximum permissible concentration‘,
Proceedings of the 18th Conference for Junior Researchers “Science – Future of Lithuania“,
Vol. 15, pp. 100–105.
27. Vosylienė M.Z. and A. Jankaitė (2006) ‘Effect of heavy metal model mixture on rainbow trout
biological parameters‘, Ekologija, Vol. 4, pp. 12-17.
28. Winter A.R., R.C. Playle, D.G. Dixon, U.W.E. Borgmann, M.P. Wilkie (2012) ‘Interactions of
Pb and Cd mixtures in the presence or absence of natural organic matter with the fish gill’,
Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, Vol. 83, pp. 16-24.
29. Zhu Y., J. Wang, Y. Bai, R. Zhang (2004) ‘Cadmium, chromium, and copper induce
polychromatocyte micronuclei in carp (Cyprinus carpio L.)’, Bulletin of Environmental
Contamination and Toxicology, Vol. 72(1), pp. 78-86.
794
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
GENO-, CYTOTOXICITY AND TOXICITY INDUCED BY
SAPROLEGNIA PARASITICA AND CADMIUM ALONE AND IN
COMBINATION TO ONCORHYNCHUS MYKISS
M. Stankevičiūtė*1, Ž. Jurgelėnė1, J. Greiciūnaitė1, S. Markovskaja1, N. Kazlauskienė1,
J. Baršienė1
1
Nature Research Centre, Akademijos st. 2, LT-08412 Vilnius, Lithuania
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: milda.stan@gmail.com, tel: +370 60716809
Abstract
The aims of present study were to determine genotoxicity, cytotoxicity and toxicity induced by
Saprolegnia parasitica at concentrations 92000, 22400 and 5500 colony-forming units per milliliter
(cfu/mL) and Cd (2 μg Cd/L as CdCl2∙H2O) alone and in combination to rainbow trout Oncorhynchus
mykiss larvae after 8-day treatment. The formations of micronuclei (MN) and nuclear buds (NB) were
assessed as genotoxicity, while 8-shaped nuclei and fragmented-apoptotic (FA) erythroblasts were
assessed as cytotoxicity endpoints. Significant induction of MN frequency was detected after
treatment with the lowest concentration of S. parasitica and after co-exposure. In contrast, significant
elevation of NB was measured exceptionally after exposure to the highest S. parasitica concentration.
Total level of genotoxicity endpoints showed significant elevation after the highest, the lowest S.
parasitica concentrations and co-exposure treatments. Significant changes in cytotoxicity endpoints
were not detected after all treatments performed. Surprisingly, exposure to Cd did not induce any
significant changes of selected biomarkers. During the treatment, biological parameters such as heart
rate (HR, counts/min) and gill ventilation frequency (GVF, counts/min) were assessed. Toxicity study
demonstrated that HR of larvae exposed to S. parasitica at concentrations 22400 and 5500 cfu/mL,
and 5500 cfu/mL+Cd after 8 days was significantly (p<0.05) lower as compared to the control.
Additionally, S. parasitica at 5500 cfu/mL, and 5500 cfu/mL+Cd induced a significant decrease in
GVF in larvae at the end of the test.
Keywords: fish; genotoxicity; cytotoxicity; toxicity; Saprolegnia parasitica; cadmium
1.
INTRODUCTION
The aquatic fungus-like heterotrophs or straminipilous fungi referred also as “water moulds”
(traditionally oomycetes) of the order Saprolegniales is common and widespread in freshwater
environment (Rietmüller, 2000; Dick, 2001). Most of them are saprotrophs decomposing dead
organic material, but some species are known to be pathogens and have the ability to infect various
aquatic organisms including fish or crustaceans and induce a number of economically important
diseases (Willoughby, 1994; Wicker et al, 2001). Fungal disease such as saprolegniosis is known as
one of the common salmonids disease (Thoen et al, 2011). Naturally, Saprolegnia species are found
in all lotic and lentic freshwater basins (Rietmüller, 2000; Markovskaja, 2006). In aquaculture,
Saprolegnia infection causes severe problem in incubating eggs and newly hatched fry (Hussein et
al, 2001; Thoen et al, 2011; Van Den Berg et al, 2013). The lethal impact of saprolegniosis could
cause major financial loss in an industry of the global fish industry production (Phillips et al, 2008).
According to Bruno et al (2011), over 10% of salmonid eggs become infected with oomycetes in
hatcheries each year. Since 2002, when the use of malachite green, an organic dye very efficient at
killing the pathogen and previously widely used, was banned due to its toxicity, Saprolegnia infection
795
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
has reemerged in aquaculture. There are no chemicals now available that provide sufficient protection
against the saprolegniosis after hatching (Fornerisa et al, 2003). In order to mitigate Saprolegnia
infection in aquaculture, the development and testing of general or specific antifungal agents has
increased (Ali et al, 2014).
Songe et al (2016) emphasized, that Saprolegnia infection in salmonids eggs has been scarcely
investigated and the role of such infection in fish eggs remains unclear. Moreover, Saprolegnia
parasitica is thought to be most frequent species of Saprolegnia genus infecting fish egg (van West,
2006; Shahbazian et al, 2010). S. parasitica causes rapid death of eggs, because of hyphae penetration
into the chorion, and consequently failure of osmosis regulation (Songe et al, 2016). In fish, disease
is characterized by visible white or grey patches of filamentous mycelium on the body or fins of fish,
hyphae penetrate epidermal tissues causing dermal, epidermal damage and cellular necrosis.
Furthermore, lethargic behaviour, loss of equilibrium and death are the results of severe infection
(Pickering et al, 1982). The parasitic lifecycle of S. parasitica has been well described by Andersson
and Cerenius (2002), Dieguez-Uribeondo et al (1994), Torto-Alalibo et al (2005), Robertson et al
(2009), and van West (2006). The zoospores of this pathogenic oomycete may be transmitted by fish
eggs, wild fish, water sources, and equipment (Saha et al, 2016).
It is important to note, that toxins are very important virulence factors for many fungal diseases.
Oomycetes are known to secrete toxins, proteinaceous substances or hydrolytic enzymes (Soanes et
al, 2007). Torto-Alalibo et al (2005) have exuded and isolated several proteins of S. parasitica (CBD
proteins, CBEL-like proteins, glycosyl hydrolases, proteases, protease inhibitors) and emphasized
that these proteins can have a range of impacts on health. Moreover, Saprolegnia infection induce a
strong inflammatory response in fish. As concluded by Belmonte et al (2014) S. parasitica produces
the metabolite prostaglanding E2 (PGE2), which increases the inflammatory response in fish
leukocytes. Consequently, inflammatory responses may trigger the genotoxicity. Furthermore, joint
effects of parasitism and pollution may lead to unexpected toxicity endpoints. Parasites exposed to
environmental contaminants is a phenomenon, which is not well understood and, which deserves
further investigation (Sures et al, 2017). Additionally, no studies have been conducted to understand
the combined impact of the S. parasitica infection and sublethal concentration of toxic metal Cd and
their geno-, cytotoxicity and toxicity to developing fish. For this reason, the present study has the
following objectives: a) to identify possible genotoxicity and cytotoxicity potential of S. parasitica
infection using rainbow trout larvae, b) to assess combined effects of S. parasitica infection and Cd
exposure on geno- and cytotoxicity endpoints, c) to determine biological effects of S. parasitica and
Cd alone and in combination.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Experimental set-up
Rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss eggs (at 20 stages, eyed-egg stage embryos (Ballard, 1973))
were obtained from the Simnas hatchery (Lithuania) and risen in bare-bottom tanks supplied with
flow-through aerated deep-well water. Studies have been carried out with non-protected life-stages
accordance with EU Directive 2010/63/EU. The laboratory treatment was carried out in an
environmental chamber (Bronson PGC-660, Zaltbommel, The Netherlands) with continuous aeration
under static conditions (static non-renewal experiment) according to ISO 7346-1:1996, without the
water being changed. According to the OECD 210 (OECD, 1992), the experiments were carried out
in the dark and the larvae were not fed (ISO 10229:1994).
The fungus-like organism Saprolegnia parasitica Coker was isolated from naturally infected perch
(Perca fluviatilis). The identification of Saprolegnia isolate was performed at species level, by
taxonomic analysis of the sexual structures combined with morphological characterization of its
asexual stage under light microscope Nikon eclipse Ci with phases contrast at magnifications x 400
796
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
(up to x 1000). The nomenclature of identified species follows Seymour, 1970; Rietmüller, 2000;
Dick, 2001; Markovskaja, 2006.
The pure living cultures of Saprolegnia parasitica were isolated by the baiting technique (Seymour,
1970). Hemp seeds were used as baits, placed into the vessels with 100 mL of distilled water and
hyphae scraped from naturally infected fish. After 5-7 days white hyphae appeared on the hemp seeds
with developing asexual and later sexual organs. For the experiments a suspension of S. parasitica
colony-forming units (cfu - zoospores, oospores, hyphae), prepared from pure living culture with
concentration levels of 92000, 22400 and 5500 cfu/mL was used. Additionally, cadmium (2 µg Cd/L)
induced geno-, cytotoxicity and toxicity alone and in combination with S. parasitica at concentration
5500 cfu/mL were assessed.
Reagent grade cadmium chloride (CdCl2∙H2O) («REACHIM» Company, Russia) was used as the
toxicant and stock solutions were prepared by dissolving a necessary amount of salts in distilled
water. The concentration of 2 μg Cd/L was chosen according to the 96 h LC50 for rainbow trout
larvae (Cibulskaitė et al, 2015). Nominal metal concentrations in the tanks were checked during blank
tests (without larvae) (N = 3) with an atomic absorption spectrophotometer (SHIMADZU AA-6800,
Japan). Mean measured concentrations were within 10 – 15% of target.
Experiments were conducted on O. mykiss larvae 4 days post hatching. All treatments were carried
out with 3 replications and control groups (using glass tanks of 1-L total volume filled to a level of
500 mL with continuously aerated dilution water, a total of 35 larvae per treatment tank and 35 larvae
in control tank were used).
2.2 Analytical procedures
The main physico-chemical parameters of the water (temperature, dissolved O2, pH and conductivity)
were measured routinely with a hand-held multi-meter (WTW Multi 340i/SET, Germany). Physicochemical parameters of the laboratory water (deep-well) were as follows: dissolved oxygen 10±1
mg/L, temperature 10±0.5oC, pH 8.1±0.1. Chemical characteristics of the deep-well water have been
presented in our previous research (Stankevičiūtė et al, 2017).
2.3 Nuclear abnormalities (NAs) analysis
Nuclear abnormalities (NAs) analysis was performed in erythroblasts of O. mykiss larvae. Blood
smears were prepared from larvae body (gently nipped with tweezers): directly smeared on glass
slides and air-dried. Smears were fixed in methanol for 10 min. and later were stained with 10%
Giemsa solution in phosphate buffer pH = 6.8 for 20 - 40 min. The stained slides were analyzed under
light microscope Olympus BX51 (Tokyo, Japan) at final magnification of 1,000× and the photos
were taken with an Olympus U-CMAD3 (Tokyo, Japan) camera. Identification of micronuclei,
nuclear buds, fragmented-apoptotic and bi-nucleated cells was done using criteria described by
Heddle et al (1991) and Fenech et al (2003). The frequencies of abnormalities were recorded in 1,000
erythroblasts per slide using blind scoring. The test was carried out with 10 specimens of larvae in
each treatment and control groups for evaluating genotoxicity and cytotoxicity. Genotoxicity
[induction of micronuclei (MN) and nuclear buds (NB)] and cytotoxicity [induction of fragmentedapoptotic (FA) and 8-shaped nuclei cells] endpoints were analysed. Considering low frequencies of
separate cytotoxicity endpoints, total cytotoxicity level (FA+8-shaped) was assessed as the sum of
the frequencies of cytotoxicity endpoints.
2.4 Toxicity assay
Heart rate (HR, counts/min) and gill ventilation frequency (GVF, counts/min) were investigated.
Samples of larvae were taken upon days 8 after exposure start. HR and GVF of larvae was measured
for each larvae individually, and the mean value for 10 larvae was calculated.
797
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
2.5 Data analysis and statistics
The geno- and cytotoxicity data follow a normal distribution (Kolmogorov-Smirnov and ShapiroWilk normality test). Geno-cytotoxicity data were analysed by the one-way ANOVA followed by
Bonferroni post hoc test (using GraphPad Prism® 5.01 (GraphPad Software Inc., San Diego, CA,
USA)) for comparison of differences between groups. Toxicity data (HR and GVF) do not follow a
normal distribution (Kolmogorov-Smirnov and Shapiro-Wilk normality test). Differences between
the evaluated characteristics studied were tested by nonparametric Kruskal-Wallis test using
STATISTICA 7.0 (StatSoft Inc., Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA) software. The results were expressed as
mean ± standard error or standard deviation. The level of significance was established at p<0.05.
3.
RESULTS
Results of micronucleus tests with O. mykiss larvae are given in Figure 1. Treatment with the lowest
S. parasitica concentration (Sap3 – 5500 cfu/mL) significantly increased MN frequencies in
erythroblasts of larvae. Cadmium alone did not induce significant MN formation. However, Cd in
combination with S. parasitica at concentration 5500 cfu/mL significantly increased MN frequencies.
Notwithstanding, MN frequencies induced by Cd in combination with the lowest S. parasitica
concentration (Sap3) did not significantly differ from exposure to S. parasitica (Sap3) alone.
Figure 1. Mean values (mean ± SEM, N = 10) of micronuclei (MN) frequencies in
erythroblasts of O. mykiss larvae treated with cadmium (Cd, 2µg/L), three concentrations of
Saprolegnia parasitica (Sap1 – 92000, Sap2 – 22400, Sap3 –5500 (cfu/mL)) and Cd in
combination with S. parasitica (2 µg Cd/L + 5500 cfu/mL). Letters denote significant
differences between groups
Analysis of nuclear bud (NB) revealed a significant increase after treatment with the highest S.
parasitica concentration (Sap1). Exposure to Cd, other S. parasitica concentrations and co-exposure
did not significantly affect NB responses in erythroblasts of larvae (Figure 2).
798
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2. Mean values (mean ± SEM, N = 10) of nuclear bud (NB) frequencies in
erythroblasts of O. mykiss larvae treated with cadmium (Cd, 2µg/L), three concentrations of
Saprolegnia parasitica (Sap1 – 92000, Sap2 – 22400, Sap3 – 5500 (cfu/mL)) and Cd in
combination with S. parasitica (2 µg Cd/L + 5500 cfu/mL). Letters denote significant
differences between groups
Treatment with all S. parasitica concentrations and co-exposure treatment significantly increased
total genotoxicity level in larvae erythroblasts, except for the 22400 cfu/mL (Sap2) concentration
level.
Figure 3. Total genotoxicity (MN+NB) level (mean ± SEM, N = 10) in erythroblasts of O.
mykiss larvae treated with cadmium (Cd, 2µg/L), three concentrations of Saprolegnia
parasitica (Sap1 – 92000, Sap2 – 22400, Sap3 – 5 500 (cfu/mL)) and Cd in combination with S.
parasitica (2 µg Cd/L + 5500 cfu/mL). Letters denote significant differences between groups
Significant elevation of total cytotoxicity level was not found after all treatments performed.
However, the highest total cytotoxicity level was measured after treatment with the lowest S.
parasitica concentration (Sap3), followed by Sap3+Cd and Sap2 treatments.
799
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Figure 4. Total cytotoxicity (FA+8-shaped) level (mean ± SEM, N = 10) in erythroblasts of O.
mykiss larvae treated with cadmium (Cd, 2µg/L), three concentrations of Saprolegnia
parasitica (Sap1 – 92000, Sap2 – 22400, Sap3 –5500 (cfu/mL)) and Cd in combination with S.
parasitica (2 µg Cd/L + 5500 cfu/mL). Letters denote significant differences between groups
In this investigation, significantly (p<0.05) decreased HR of larvae as compared to the control after
8 days of exposure to Sap2 – 22400, Sap3 – 5500 (cfu/mL) and Cd in combination with S. parasitica
(2 µg Cd/L + 5500 cfu/mL). Meanwhile, in the highest S. parasitica treatment (Sap1) HR of larvae
did not differ significantly from the control. HR of larvae in the highest S. parasitica treatment (Sap1)
was significantly (p<0.05) different from Sap2 and Sap3+Cd treatments.
The lowest S. parasitica concentration (Sap3 – 5500 cfu/mL) and Cd in combination with S.
parasitica (2 µg Cd/L + 5500 cfu/mL) induced a significant (p<0.05) decrease in GVF of larvae.
Additionally, GVF of larvae in Cd treatment were significantly (p<0.05) different from Sap3 and
Sap3+Cd treatment.
A
160
140
bd
a
a
a
Sap1
Sap2
Sap3
Sap3+Cd
Heart rate,
counts/min
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Control
Cd
800
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Gill ventilation frequency,
counts/min
B
160
cd
140
a
a
Sap3
Sap3+Cd
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Control
Cd
Sap1
Sap2
Figure 5. Sub-chronic (8 days of exposure) effect of cadmium (Cd, 2µg/L), three
concentrations of Saprolegnia parasitica (Sap1 – 92000, Sap2 – 22400, Sap3 –5500 (cfu/mL))
and Cd in combination with S. parasitica (2 µg Cd/L + 5500 cfu/mL) on biological parameters
of O. mykiss larvae: gill ventilation frequency (counts/min) and heart rate (counts/min) (mean
± SD).
a
Significant difference from the control (p<0.05). Significant difference between treatments
(p<0.05): b significant difference from Sap2 treatment; c significant difference from Sap3 treatment;
d
significant difference from Sap3+Cd treatment.
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
This study was designed to identify possible geno- and cytotoxicity potential and to assess biological
effects of egg-pathogenic S. parasitica infection in rainbow trout larvae. Moreover, the exacerbation
of toxicity endpoints of joint parasitism and Cd exposure was assessed. The findings of this study
indicated a significant increase of separate genotoxicity endpoints and total genotoxicity depending
on exposure concentration of S. parasitica. However, genotoxicity endpoints did not show a clear
tendency to increase with increasing S. parasitica exposure concentration. Belmonte and co-authors
(2014) detected the immune suppression in Atlantic salmon before the pathogen infection
(establishment) or after early stages of interaction. Moreover, 12 days exposure of fish to S. parasitica
(104 zoospores/cysts liter−1) did not cause evidence of infection and no suppression of the antigen,
and no induction of proinflammatory genes were detected. These responses might indicate a
protection against the oomycetes. In this study, exposure to the highest concentrations of S. parasitica
did not induce the highest frequencies of all analyzed geno- and cytotoxicity endpoints. These results
might indicate the threshold for inhibition of certain geno- and cytotoxicity responses. Further
analyses using more frequent sampling and various concentrations of S. parasitica are therefore
suggested. Scientific literature data related to direct or indirect genotoxic effects induced by
Saprolegnia do not exist. The genotoxic potential of Saprolegnia parasitica in fish has not been
investigated at all. This study provides first toxicity data that show significantly increased genotoxic
activity in rainbow trout after S. parasitica exposure. Azimzadeh and Amniattalab (2017) indicated
oxidative stress, haematological and histopathological changes in rainbow trout infected with S.
parasitica. Moreover, parasitic Saprolegnia species produces metabolites, which may induce a strong
inflammatory response in fish (Belmonte et al, 2014). However, one of the limitations of these
findings is that it does not explain which mechanisms (direct or indirect) are responsible for such
genotoxicity outcome.
801
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Marcogliese et al (2005) concluded that parasitism in the presence of pollution may further
compromise the health by reducing the immunocompetence of the host. Furthermore, exacerbation
of toxicity effects may be noted even parasites infestation occurs at low intensities. In agreement with
that, the findings of this study, showed the highest total genotoxicity level after joint treatment with
the lowest S. parasitica concentration and Cd in comparison to other treatments.
In the present study, significant cytotoxicity was not induced by any S. parasitica concentration
tested, as well as after co-exposure treatment. As emphasized by Schaumburg et al (2006), parasites
can induce anti-apoptotic activities in the host.
In addition, during a sub-chronic test, S. parasitica induced negative effects on biological parameters
(decreased heart rate and gill ventilation frequency) of rainbow trout larvae. Moreover, these effects
did not relate to the concentration of S. parasitica. However, significant difference between S.
parasitica treatments was observed only in heart rate measurement. In fish gills serve as a principal
organ for respiration, osmoregulation, and excretion (Evans et al, 2005), they also become a
potentially important site of penetration by parasites (Mikheev et al, 2014). Therefore, in this study,
saprolegniosis seems to have damaged the gill, then gill ventilation frequency decreased in larvae and
the deficiency of oxygen induced bradycardia. Furthermore, saprolegniosis-induced hypoxia may be
responsible for the significant genotoxicity responses measured in this study. In fish, infection begins
on the head, gills, or fins and spreads over the entire surface of the body, for this reason, often
osmoregulatory failure results in the death of fish (van West, 2006). On the other hand, in contrast to
our study, Mikheev et al (2014) demonstrated that rainbow trout reacted to low oxygen concentration
with wider expansion of parasites (Diplostomum spathaceum), leading to an increase in gill
ventilation frequency. Additionally, physiological or social stressors could produce similar effects on
the transmission success of the parasites penetrating fish hosts using the gills.
This study result showed the negative effects of combined parasites and pollutant exposure. Similar
results of negative effects were found by Gheorgiu et al (2006), where significantly increased
mortality of guppies (Poecilia reticulata) exposed to Zn and infected with the monogenean
Gyrodactylus turnbulli were observed.
Marcogliese et al (2005) noted that cumulative effects of multiple stressors are becoming a major
problem in ecotoxicology and many other fields. In conclusion, this study highlights the potential to
advance our current understanding of the significance of a biological stressor (pathogen) on geno-,
cytotoxicity and toxicity endpoints. Furthermore, the potential to exacerbate toxicity endpoints after
fish exposure to multiple environmental stressors (pathogen infection and pollution) is emphasized.
Acknowledgments
This work was funded by the Research Council of Lithuania, Project No. S-MIP-17-10.
References
1. Ali S.E., E. Thoen, Evensen Ø and I. Skaar (2014) ‘Boric acid inhibits germination and
colonization of Saprolegnia spores in vitro and in vivo’, PLoS One, Vol 9, pp. e91878.
2. Andersson M.G. and L. Cerenius (2002) ‘Pumilio homologue from Saprolegnia parasitica
specifically expressed in undifferentiated spore cysts’, Eukaryotic Cell, Vol 1(1), pp. 105-111.
3. Azimzadeh K. and Amniattalab A. (2017) ‘Total Sialic Acid, Oxidative Stress and
Histopathological Changes in Rainbow Trout Saprolegniasis (Oncorhynchus mykiss)’, Kafkas
Universitesi Veteriner Fakultesi Dergisi, Vol. 23(1), pp. 55-62.
4. Belmonte R., T. Wang, G.J. Duncan, I. Skaar, H. Mélida, V. Bulone, P. van West and C.J.
Secombes (2014) ‘Role of Pathogen-Derived Cell Wall Carbohydrates and Prostaglandin E2 in
Immune Response and Suppression of Fish Immunity by the Oomycete Saprolegnia parasitica’,
Infection and Immunity, Vol 82(11), pp. 4518-4529.
802
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
5. Bruno D.W., P. van West and G.W. Beakes (2011) ‘Saprolegnia and other oomycetes in: Fish
Diseases and Disorders: Viral, Bacterial and Fungal Infections’, CABI International, Vol 3(2),
pp. 669-720.
6. Cibulskaitė Ž., N. Kazlauskienė and V. Kulvietis (2015) ‘Sublethal toxicity of quantum dots and
heavy metals to rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) in early ontogenesis. Proceedings of the
18th Conference for Junior Researchers „Science – Future of Lithuania“’, Environmental
protection engineering, pp. 31–37.
7. Dick M.W. (2001) ‘Straminipilous Fungi: systematics of the peronosporomycetes, including
accounts of the marine straminipilous protists, the plasmodiophorids, and similar organisms’,
Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht.
8. Dieguez-Uribeondo J., L. Cerenius and K. Soderhall (1994) ‘Repeated zoospore emergence in
Saprolegnia parasitica’, Mycological Research, Vol 98(7), pp. 810-815.
9. Evans D.H., P.M. Piermarini and K.P. Choe (2005) ‘The multifunctional fish gill: dominant site
of gas exchange, osmoregulation, acid–base regulation, and excretion of nitrogenous
waste’, Physiological Reviews, Vol. 85(1), pp. 97–177.
10. Fornerisa G., S. Bellardib, G.B. Palmegianoc, M. Sarogliad, B. Sicuroa, L. Gascoe and I.
Zoccarato (2003) ‘The use of ozone in trout hatchery to reduce saprolegniasis incidence’,
Aquaculture, Vol 221(1-4), pp. 157-166.
11. Gheorgiu C., D.J. Marcogliese and M. Scott (2006) ‘Concentration-dependent effects of
waterborne zinc on population dynamics of Gyrodactylus turnbulli (Monogenea) on isolated
guppies (Poecilia reticulata)’, Parasitology, Vol 132(2), pp. 225-32.
12. Hussein M.A., K. Hatai and T. Nomura (2001) ‘Saprolegniasis in salmonids and their eggs in
Japan’, Journal of Wildlife Diseases, Vol 37(1), pp. 204-207.
13. ISO (International Organization for Standardization) 10229 (1994) ‘Water Quality-Determination
of the Prolonged Toxicity of Substances to Freshwater Fish -- Method for Evaluating the Effects
of Substances on the Growth Rate of Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss Walbaum (Teleostei,
Salmonidae))’.
14. ISO (International Organization for Standardization) 7346-1 (1996) ‘Water Quality –
Determination of the Acute Lethal Toxicity of Substances to a Freshwater Fish [Brachydanio
rerio Hamilton-Buchanan (Teleostei, Cyprinidae)] -Part 1: Static Method’.
15. Marcogliese D.J., L.G. Brambilla, F. Gagné and A.D. Gendron (2005) ‘Joint effects of parasitism
and pollution on oxidative stress biomarkers in yellow perch Perca flavescens’, Diseases of
Aquatic Organisms, Vol. 63(1), pp. 77-84.
16. Markovskaja S. (2006) ‘Saprolegniaceae (Peronosporomycetes) in Lithuania. II. The genus
Saprolegnia’, Botanica Lithuanica, Vol. 12(2), pp. 97-112.
17. Mikheev V.N., A.F. Pasternak, E.T. Valtonen and J.Taskinen (2014) ‘Increased ventilation by
fish leads to a higher risk of parasitism’, Parasites & Vectors, Vol 7, pp. 281.
18. OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development) (1992) ‘Guideline for the
Testing of Chemicals: Fish, Early-life Stage Toxicity Test’, Part 210.
19. Phillips A.J., V.L. Anderson, E.J. Robertson, C.J. Secombes and P. van West (2008) ‘New
insights into animal pathogenic oomycetes’, Trends in Microbiology, Vol 16(1), pp. 13–19.
20. Pickering A.D. and L.G. Willoughby (1982) ‘Saprolegnia infections of salmonid fish. In: Roberts
R.J., editor. Microbial Diseases of Fish’, Academic Press, pp. 271-297.
21. Rietmüller A. (2000) ‘Morphologie, Ökologie und Phylogenie aquatischer Oomyceten’,
Bibliotheca Mycologica, Vol.185: 1–344.
803
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
22. Robertson E.J., V.L. Anderson, A.J. Phillips, C.J. Secombes, J. Dieguez-Uribeondo and P. van
West (2009) ‘Saprolegnia – fish interactions. In: Lamour K, Kamoun S, editors. Oomycete
genetics and genomics, diversity, interactions and research tools’, Hoboken, NJ, USA: WileyBlackwell, pp. 407-424.
23. Saha H., A.K. Pal, N.P. Sahu and R.K. Saha (2016) ‘Feeding pyridoxine prevents Saprolegnia
parasitica infection in fish Labeo rohita’, Fish and Shellfish Immunology, Vol 59, pp. 382-388.
24. Seymour R.L. (1970) ‘The genus Saprolegnia’, Nova Hedwigia, Vol. 19, pp. 1–124.
25. Schaumburg F., D. Hippe, P. Vutova and C.G. Lüder (2006) ‘Pro- and anti-apoptotic activities of
protozoan parasites’, Parasitology, Vol 132(S1), pp. S69–S85.
26. Shahbazian N., H.A. Ebrahimzadeh Mousavi, M. Soltani, A.R. Khosravi, S. Mirzargar and I.
Sharifpour (2010) ‘Fungal contamination in rainbow trout eggs in Kermanshah province
propagations with emphasis on Saprolegniaceae’, Iranian Journal of Fisheries Sciences, Vol
9(1), pp. 151–160.
27. Soanes D.M., T.A. Richards and N.J. Talbot (2007) ‘Insights from sequencing fungal and
oomycete genomes: what can we learn about plant disease and the evolution of pathogenicity?’,
Plant Cell, Vol 19(11), pp. 3318-3326.
28. Songe M.M., A. Willems, J. Wiik-Nielsen, E. Thoen, Ø. Evensen, P. van West and I. Skaar (2016)
‘Saprolegnia diclina IIIA and S. parasitica employ different infection strategies when colonizing
eggs of Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L.’, Journal of Fish Diseases, Vol. 39(3), pp. 343-352.
29. Sures B., M. Nachev, C. Selbach and D.J. Marcogliese (2017) ‘Parasite responses to pollution:
what we know and where we go in ‘Environmental Parasitology’’, Parasites & Vectors, Vol
10(1), pp. 65.
30. Thoen E., O. Evensen and I. Skaar (2011) ‘Pathogenicity of Saprolegnia spp. to Atlantic
salmon, Salmo salar L., eggs’, Journal of Fish Diseases, Vol 34(8), pp. 601-608.
31. Torto-Alalibo T., M. Tian, K. Gajendran, M.E. Waugh, P. van West and S. Kamoun (2005)
‘Expressed sequence tags from the oomycete fish pathogen Saprolegnia parasitica reveal
putative virulence factors’, BioMed Central Microbiology, Vol 5, pp. 46.
32. Van Den Berg A.H., D. McLaggan, J. Dieguez‐Uribeondo and P. van West (2013) ‘The impact
of the water moulds Saprolegnia diclina and Saprolegnia parasitica on natural ecosystems and
the aquaculture industry’, Fungal Biology Reviews, Vol 27(9), pp. 33-42.
33. Van West P. (2006) ‘Saprolegnia parasitica, an oomycete pathogen with a fishy appetite: New
challenges for an old problem’, Mycologist, Vol 20(3), pp. 99-104.
34. Wicker E., M. Hulle, F. Rouxel (2001) ‘Pathogenic characteristics of isolates of Aphanomyces
eusteiches from pea in France’, Plant Pathology, Vol 50(4), pp. 433-442.
35. Willoughby L.G. (1994) ‘Fungi and fish diseases’, Pisces Press.
804
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
PHYSIOLOGICAL RESPONSE OF BARLEY AND BARNYARD
GRASS TO INTERACTIVE EFFECT OF HEAT WAVE AND
DROUGHT
A. Dikšaitytė*, G. Juozapaitienė, G. Kacienė, I. Januškaitienė, D. Miškelytė, and J.
Žaltauskaitė
Department of Environmental Sciences, Faculty of Natural Sciences, University of Vytautas
Magnus, Vileikos str. 8, LT-44404 Kaunas, Lithuania
*
Corresponding author: Austra.Diksaityte@vdu.lt
Abstract
The short-term effect of +10 °C heat wave (HW) treatment both as single stressor (in well-watered
plants, HWW) and simultaneously with drought (HWD) was tested in growth chambers under control
environment using pot grown plants of barley (Hordeum vulgare L., var. ‘Aura DS’) and weed
barnyard grass (Echinochloa crus-galli L.) that exhibit C3 and C4 pathways, accordingly. During the
3-day long HW period, both plants grown under well-watered soil conditions showed significantly
increased transpiration rate (E) and decreased water use efficiency (WUE). Significant changes of
photosynthetic rate (Pr) were detected only for barley plants. On the last day of HW treatment, Pr in
well-watered barley plants decreased by 13.8% (p < 0.05), compared to the control (CTR) ones. When
the HW was imposed simultaneously with drought, at the end of the treatment, before plants were rewatered, E and WUE in barley plants were in totally different manner than under the single stressor
of HW − by 76.6% (p < 0.05) decreased and by 13.0% (p < 0.05) increased, accordingly. By contrast,
in barnyard grass, under HWD treatment, E and WUE were in the same manner as under HWW
treatment − by 18.4% (p < 0.05) increased and by 19.5% (p < 0.05) decreased, accordingly. Pr in
HWD-treated barley plants at the end of the treatment was considerably lower by 73.5% (p < 0.05)
and did not returned to the CTR one’s value after one-day recovery. While, in barnyard grass Pr was
only 6.3% (p < 0.05) reduced, but it fully returned to the CTR one’s value after one-day recovery.
Therefore, contrary to barley, physiological indices of C4 weed barnyard grass responded more
positive than negative to HWW treatment and demonstrated considerably higher tolerance to drought
under high air temperature conditions.
Keywords: heat wave, drought, barley, barnyard grass, photosynthesis, transpiration, water use
efficiency
1.
INTRODUCTION
Extreme climatic events such as heat waves and drought periods are predicted to increase in frequency
and severity in many regions under future climate scenarios (IPCC 2014; Mittal et al., 2014), and in
the natural environment these two abiotic stresses often occur simultaneously. In the last century,
Europe’s climate has become more extreme than previously thought (Della Marta et al., 2007; Toreti
et al., 2013) with increasing summer temperature variability (Jones et al., 2008). It has been stated
that extreme events occurring during the summer period would have the most dramatic impact on
plant productivity (De Boeck et al., 2011). The European summer heat wave and drought with July
temperatures up to 6 °C above average and annual precipitation 50 % below average in 2003
805
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
demonstrated the profound impact that extreme events may have (Fink et al., 2004). The 2003
European summer heat wave was followed in 2010 by an even more intense and widespread summer
heat wave, which scorched enormous areas across Eastern Europe (Barriopedro et al., 2011),
including western Russia, Belarus, Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania (Dole et al., 2011).
Acute heat and drought are perhaps the two most major abiotic stresses for plant vegetation
worldwide, and the combination of these stresses causes many physiological changes that affect
different plants and crop growth and functioning (Fahad et al., 2017; Sita et al., 2017). Physiological
responses of plants to drought stress are complex and vary with plant species and the degree or time
of the exposure to drought (Bodner et al., 2015). Moreover, plants respond differently to multiple
stresses from how they do to individual stress (Atkinson and Urwin, 2012). The evidence shown that
the response of plants to combinations of two or more stress conditions is different from that of single
treatment and cannot be directly extrapolated from the response of plants to each of the different
stresses applied individually, as the responses to the combined stresses are largely controlled by
different, and sometimes opposing, signaling pathways that may interact and inhibit each other
(Suzuki et al., 2014). Recent studies that examined plant responses to heat and drought have revealed
that when combined with drought stress, heat waves exacerbated the negative effect of drought stress
(Dreesen et al., 2012; Rollins et al., 2013; Duan et al., 2017), but the effects caused by the combination
of heat and drought were not simply the sum of single heat and drought effects, whereas were mostly
larger than the sum of single stresses (De Boeck et al., 2011; Ruehr et al., 2016).
In this study, there were used gas-exchange parameters to compare photosynthetic performance in
one of the most important crop, Hordeum vulagre (barley, C3), and one of the most noxious weeds in
modern agriculture, Echinochloa crus-galli (barnyard grass, C4), during and after the heat wave both
as single stressor and simultaneously with drought, and after one-day recovery, based on the
physiological characteristics of these species. Three following specific hypotheses were addressed:
(1) HW imposed alone will have a considerably less pronounced negative effect on the C4 weed than
the C3 crop; (2) drought imposed simultaneously with HW will exacerbate the negative impact of
HW with more severe effect for the C3 crop; (3) post-stress rate of photosynthesis and other gas
exchange parameters of C4 weed after one-day regeneration under control conditions will recover to
a larger extent to the control level than the C3 crop.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Plant material and growth conditions
Barley (Hordeum vulgare L. cv. ‘Aura DS’) and weed barnyard grass (Echinochloa crus-galli L.)
seeds were sown in plastic pots (3 l capasity; 10.6 cm diameter) filled with a mixture of field top-soil (taken
from Aleksandras Stulginskis University training farm, Kaunas district), perlite and fine sand (5:3:2,
by volume) under the monoculture conditions (15 plants per pot). Plants were grown in closed plant growth
chamber with volume of 10 m3 (Vytautas Magnus university, Lithuania) under control environment with a
day length of 14 h with lights on at 8:00 h and lights off at 22:00 h, a day/night ambient air temperature of
vegetation period of 21/14 °C, ambient CO2 concentration of 400 µmol mol−1, relative air humidity (RH) of
50±5% during the day and 70±5% at night. A light level of ~270 µmol m −2 s−1 photosynthetically
active radiation (PAR) was provided by a combination of ten natural day-light luminescent lamps (Philips,
Waterproof OPK Natural Daylight LF80 Wattage 2×58 W/TL-D 58 W) and one high-pressure sodium lamp
(Philips MASTER GreenPower CG T 600 W). Twice during the experiment, plants were fertilized with the
complex nutrient (NPK 12-11-18 + microelements) solution to the final N level of 150 kg ha−1.
Volumetric soil water content (SWC) was kept at 30% using a Theta Probe ML2x sensor combined
with a hand-set HH2 moisture meter with a depth of 6 cm (Delta-T Devices Ltd., Cambridge, UK).
Control (CTR) plants were kept under the conditions mentioned above throughout the experiment.
806
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.2 Treatments and experimental design
The treatments were imposed when both plants reached the 14 growth stage (Zadoks et al., 1974), i.e.
after full expansion of the third true leaf. Half of the seedlings in the CTR growth chamber were
randomly assigned to 3 day-long heat wave (HW) treatment and were transferred into HW growth
chamber (i.e. 31 ºC for 6.5 h per day and 21 ºC night temperature cycle and an ambient CO 2 of 400
µmol mol−1). The temperature in the heated growth chamber was increased gradually every day from
21 to 31 °C between 9:00-11:00 h, holding the temperature of 31 °C until 17.30 h, and then was
gradually decreased from 17:30-19:30 h to 25 °C that was maintained till 22:00 h until the period of
night began, when it decreased to 21 °C and was maintained overnight. After 3 day-long HW
treatment, at the 4th experimental day plants were moved back to the CTR growth chamber for oneday recovery. In this case, plants in HW were subjected to a 3 day-long of +10 ºC HW treatment for
6.5 h per day. Besides, half of the seedlings in HW treatment were also treated under drought stress
(HWD), i.e. were left without additional watering until they were rehydrated to the CTR plants level
of 30% SWC at the 4th experimental day (about 15:00 h). Well-watered pots in the HW treatments
(HWW), as well as CTR plants, were weighed (in the morning between 11:30 h and 12:00 h) each
day to determine gravitational water loss and to maintain target SWC of 30%. Pots within the same
growth chamber were rotated every day in order to minimize potential effects of growth chamber on
plant performance.
2.3 Leaf gas exchange measurements
Photosynthetic rate (Pr; µmol CO2 m−2 s−1), stomatal conductance (gs; mol H2O m−2 s−1) and
transpiration rate (E; mmol H2O m−2 s−1) were measured with a portable closed infrared gas analyzer
LI-COR 6400 (LI-COR, Inc., Lincoln, NE, USA), equipped with a 6 cm2 leaf chamber. The youngest
fully expanded leaves were fixed in the leaf cuvette, and the measurements were recorded 15 min
every 10 s when Pr and gs reached steady state levels. The gas exchange measurements were made at
least on one plant of each pot in CTR, HWW and HWD treatments at 10:00 h and 15:00 h, during the
3 day-long HW treatment, after HW and after one-day recovery of HWW and HWD plants in the
CTR chamber under unstressed ambient climate conditions. During the measurements, the CO2 level
in the leaf cuvette was set at the same CO2 level as the plants were growing at (i.e. 400 µmol mol−1
CO2), and a bloc temperature was set according to the plants growing conditions (either 21 or 31 ºC).
Air flow rate through the assimilation chamber was maintained at 500 µmol s−1, PAR outside the leaf
chamber was 225±1.3 µmol m−2 s−1. The air humidity (RH) and vapor pressure deficit (VPD) inside
the leaf cuvette were allowed to vary with ambient climate conditions outdoor. During the
measurements, RH and VPD in the control plants were, respectively, 23±0.7% and 1.8±0.0 kPa, and
19±1.1% and 3.2±0.1 kPa in the heat-stressed plants (all mean ± SE). Water use efficiency (WUE;
µmol CO2 mmol−1 H2O) was calculated as the ratio of Pr to E. All results were collected from lit
leaves of intact plants.
2.4 Statistical analysis
Data shown are mean ± standard error (SE). Statistical analysis was performed using Fisher’s Least
Significant Difference (LSD) tests (P < 0.05) with STATISTICA 8. Different lowercase letters in the
figure indicated significant difference among treatments within each day.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Effect of heat and drought on photosynthetic rate
Imposed single +10 °C heat wave (HW) treatment decreased photosynthetic rate (Pr) in well-watered
(HWW) barley plants by 8.3% (p < 0.05) and 13.8% (p < 0.05) on the 2th and the 3th days of HW
treatment, respectively. However, it returned to the control (CTR) value on day 4, when the HW was
released, and did not change from the CTR one’s after one-day recovery. No changes of Pr were
807
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
found in HWW-treated barnyard grass, moreover, it tended to be even a little bit higher for the entire
experimental period (Fig. 1 A and F). It is not very unexpected, as barnyard grass (Echinochloa crusgalli) is a weed of warm regions that requires high temperatures for dry matter production and growth
(Maun and Bennett, 1986). When the HW was imposed simultaneously with drought (HWD), Pr in
barley declined sharply with significant changes from the 2th day and the most pronounced reduction
on day 4, before plants were re-watered, when Pr in HWD-treated barley was lower by 73.5% (p <
0.05), as compared to the CTR ones. After one-day regeneration under CTR conditions, Pr in HWDtreated barley recovered to a large extent to the CTR one’s value, however, was still significant lower
(-4.0%, p < 0.05). By contrast, Pr in HWD-treated barnyard grass decreased significantly by 6.3%
only on day 4, i.e. when the treatment progressed (Fig. 1 A and F). These results reflect that, under
the combined impact of HW and drought, the crucial negative factor for both plant Pr was drought,
but not heat, what is consistent with the previous studies (Ruehr et al., 2016; Duan et al., 2017).
However, barnyard grass showed considerably higher photosynthetic tolerance to drought than did it
barley plants, what is also not surprised for the C4 type plant. Because of these characteristics (being
a C4 weed), barnyard grass has a strong potential for competing with C3 crops under such extreme
climatic events as a periods of heat wave simultaneously with water shortage, that are predicted to
increase in frequency and severity in many regions under future climate scenarios (IPCC 2014; Mittal
et al., 2014). The evidence already shown that E. crus-galli becomes more competitive than
agricultural crops and can cause significant yield losses under the conditions of future climate (Awan
et al., 2016).
3.2 Effect of heat and drought on stomatal conductance, transpiration and WUE
For the entire experimental period, stomatal conductance (gs) in HWW-treated barley plants did not
differ from the CTR ones, while it tended to decrease and was significantly lower by 23.8% and
11.0% on day 4 and after one-day recovery, respectively, in well-watered barnyard grass (Fig. 1 B
and G). Contrary to HWW treatment, gs in HWD-treated barley decreased sharply from the beginning
with the significant changes from the 2th day and the most pronounced reduction of gs by 83.9% (p <
0.05) on day 4, as in the case of Pr. After one-day regeneration under CTR conditions, full recovery
of gs in HWD-treated barley was not observed − it was 20.6% (p < 0.05) lower than in the CTR ones.
The exacerbated effect of drought on gs, under HWD treatment, was also found in barnyard grass, as
it was also significant lower from the 2th day with the most pronounced reduction by 39.0% (p < 0.05)
on day 4 and did not returned to CTR value (-12.7%, p < 0.05) after one-day recovery (Fig. 1 B and
G). It is known that stomatal closures are more closely related to the soil moisture content than leaf
water status, and it is mainly controlled by chemical signals such as abscisic acid produced in
dehydrating roots (Lisar et al., 2012). Therefore, the results show that gs of both plants responded
more to drought induced stress than to heat, but the changes were considerably higher in barley.
Transpiration rate (E), under well-watered soil conditions, during all the HW treatment, was
significantly higher by about 80% and 65% in barley and barnyard grass, accordingly, until it got
back to the CTR level after the release of HW on day 4 and did not differ from the CTR ones after
one-day recovery (Fig. 1 C and H). Contrary to HWW treatment, E in HWD-treated barley decreased
significantly by 42.0% and 76.6% on the 3th and the 4th days, respectively, as the treatment prolonged
(Fig. 1 C). It is shown that heat and drought imposed simultaneously might influence signals that
control gas exchange (Prasch and Sonnewald, 2013) that can cause antagonistic responses of plants
(Mittler and Blumwald, 2010). For example, during the heat stress, plants can increase transpiration
rate to evaporatively reduce their leaf temperature, in order, to avoid overheat and prevent deleterious
damages induced by heat stress (Ameye et al., 2012). However, when plants are subjected to heat and
drought simultaneously, they often reduce transpiration rate, avoiding unnecessary water loss, at the
cost of evaporative cooling, what in turn leads to increased leaf temperature (Barnabas et al., 2008;
Ruehr et al., 2016) and the damages on photosynthesis (Duursma et al., 2014; Ruehr et al., 2016),
which is thought to be among the most thermosensitive aspects of plant function (Wang et al., 2008).
Therefore, the obtained results show that, in the response to the combined impact of HW and drought,
808
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
barley plants preferred to reduce their stomata aperture to avoid water loss through transpiration,
perhaps at the cost of leaf cooling, once more implying that drought had considerably more negative
effect on their leaf physiology than did it HW. These results are consistent with other evidence that
water availability has a dominant role in determining plant physiological responses (Carmo-Silva et
al., 2012; Ruehr et al., 2016; Duan et al., 2017). However, after one-day regeneration under CTR
conditions, E in HWD-treated barley fully recovered to the CTR value (Fig. 1 C). In contrast to barley,
on the 3th and the 4th days, E in HWD-treated barnyard grass was still higher by 25.7% (p < 0.05) and
18.3% (p < 0.05), respectively, compared to the CTR ones, but also did not differ significantly after
one-day recovery (Fig. 1 H). This finding indicates that, under the same conditions with high air
temperature and simultaneously the absence of adequate water supply, barley plants, as it was
expected to C3 species, were more susceptible to drought than the C4 weed barnyard grass, which,
with the significant higher E under the prolonged HWD treatment, still preferred to employ
transpiration cooling to cope with heat instead of reducing transpiration, in order, to save water under
drought conditions, even on day 4, when the HW was already released.
During the 3-day long HW treatment, water use efficiency (WUE) in well-watered barley and
barnyard grass plants was reduced by 52.7% (p < 0.05) and 61.6% (p < 0.05) on average, respectively.
It returned to the CTR one’s level on day 4, after the HW was released, and did not differ after oneday recovery (Fig. 1 D and I). Under the heat wave conditions simultaneously with water shortage,
i.e. on the 2th and the 3th days of HWD treatment, WUE in both plants was reduced to a considerably
lower extent that under HWW treatment, although was still significantly lower (by 24.4% and 21.9%
on average, in barley and barnyard grass, respectively), compared to the CTR ones. However, on day
4, when HW was released, but plants were still not re-watered, WUE in HWD-treated barley increased
significantly by 13.0%, compared to the CTR ones. By contrast, in barnyard grass it was continuously
lower by 19.5% (p < 0.05), already suggesting that barley plants suffered substantially more from
drought than did it barnyard grass. Nevertheless, both plants WUE did not differ from CTR ones after
one-day recovery (Fig. 1 D and I).
3.3 Effect of heat and drought on intercellular CO2 concentration
The intercellular CO2 concentration (Ci) in HWW-treated barley plants did not differ from CTR ones
for the entire experimental period. By contrast, it was significantly lower by 12.3% on average on the
3th and the 4th days of treatment in barnyard grass and did not return to the CTR one’s value (-6.0%,
p < 0.05) after one day recovery (Fig. 1 E and J), but it had any influence on Pr (Fig. 1 F). In contrast
to HWW treatment, Ci in HWD-treated barley was significantly reduced by 19.6% on average from
the 2th day of the treatment. After one-day regeneration under CTR conditions, full recovery of Ci in
HWD-treated barley was not achieved (-7.4%, p < 0.05) (Fig. 1 E). These results indicate that
considerable reduction of Pr in HWD-treated barley to a large extent could be attributed to stomatal
closures and consequent reduced intercellular CO2 concentration. The same assumption was made by
Duan et al. (2017), who found that under high soil water availability, despite the initial sharp rise in
leaf stomatal conductance and transpiration at the onset of the heat wave, photosynthesis declined
gradually in parallel with stomatal conductance as heat wave progressed, maintaining a relatively low
leaf level water use efficiency. The exacerbated effect of drought on Ci, under HWD treatment, was
also found in barnyard grass, as on the 3th and the 4th days of the treatment it reduced significant more
(by about 10%) than under HWW treatment (Fig. 1 J). This also could by in part related to the
decrease of Pr in barnyard grass on day 4 under HWD treatment (Fig. 1 F). After one-day recovery,
Ci in HWD-treated barnyard grass was also still lower by 6.6% (p < 0.05), compared to the CTR ones
(Fig. 1 E and J), but it had no influence on photosynthesis.
809
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
6.0
a
a
a
4.0
a
a
a
a
ab
b
a
a
b
b
a
b
b
G
b
ab
0.08
b
c
0.04
b
C
a
a
b
b
0.04
b
a
a
0.0
0.12
a
a
a
a
b
b
H
0.00
3.0
a
2.0
b
b
b
1.0
b
a
a
c
2.0
a
ab
b
c
1.0
b
I
8.0
6.0
6.0
4.0
a
2.0
b
b
a
b
a
b
b
c
a
b
b
a
b
a
b
b
c
a
ab
b
4.0
2.0
J
E
300
a
a
200
b
a
a
b
a
a
b
a
a
b
a
b
a
ab
b
a
b
b
a
b
c
c
0.0
400
300
200
100
100
1
2
3
4
1
5
3
4
5
0
Recovery
HW stress
Recovery
HW stress
2
Ci (µmol CO2 m-2 s-1)
0.0
400
0
0.0
10.0
WUE (µmol CO2
mmol H2O-1)
D
a
ab
b
8.0
E (mmol H2O m-2
s-1)
E (mmol H2O m-2
s-1)
6.0
b
2.0
0.08
a
8.0
g (mol H2O m-2
s
s-1)
a
0.0
10.0
WUE (µmol CO2
mmol H2O-1)
a
a
B
a
F
a
b
0.00
3.0
Ci (µmol CO2 m-2 s-1)
E. crus-galli
b
b
c
CTR
HWW
HWD
2.0
a
a
b
c
4.0
0.0
0.12
g s (mol H2O m-2
s-1)
A
H. vulgare
P (µmol CO2 m-2
r
s-1)
Pr (µmol CO2 m-2
s-1)
8.0
Drought stress
Drought stress
Days
Days
Figure 1. The changes of photosynthetic rate (Pr), stomatal conductance (gs), transpiration
rate (E), water use efficiency (WUE), and intercellular CO2 concentration (Ci) in Hordeum
vulgare (barley) (A, B, C, D, E, accordingly) and Echinochloa crus-galli (barnyard grass) (F,
G, H, I, J, accordingly) during the 3 day-long HW stress (days 1-3), both as single stressor
(HWW) and simultaneously with drought (HWD), after the HW (day 4), and after one-day
recovery (day 5), compared to the control (CTR) plants. Values are means ± SE for at least
three independent replicates. Different lowercase letters indicate significant difference (P <
0.05) among treatments within each day as determined by Fisher LSD test
810
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4.
CONCLUSIONS
This study showed a predominant role of soil water availability for barley seedlings even during the
short-term heat wave period, as simultaneously impact of HW and water shortage caused far stronger
physiological changes in their leaves than the single HW treatment. When the heat stress was
accompanied by water stress caused by simultaneously imposed drought, the reductions of Pr, Ci and,
especially, gs in HWD-treated barley were significantly larger, compared to the HWW treatment, with
incomplete recovery after one day-long regeneration period under the control one’s conditions. By
contrast, Pr in HWW-treated barnyard grass tended to be even a little bit higher, and together with
the other gas exchange parameters demonstrated considerably higher tolerance to interactive effect
of HW and drought with fully or a better recovery to the CTR one’s value. Summarizing all the
obtained results, it can be concluded that barley, as the C3 type crop, suffered substantially more from
combined impact of HW and drought, while barnyard grass was far less susceptible to HWD
treatment. Therefore, being a C4 type weed, barnyard grass has a strong potential for competing with
C3 crops under such extreme climatic events that are predicted to increase in frequency and severity
in many regions under future climate scenarios.
Acknowledgments
This research was funded by the European Social Fund under the No 09.3.3-LMT-K-712
“Development of Competences of Scientists, other Researchers and Students through Practical
Research Activities” measure.
References
1. Ameye M., T.M. Wertin, I. Bauweraerts, M.A. McGuire, R.O. Teskey and K. Steppe (2012) ‘The
effect of induced heat waves on Pinus taeda and Quercus rubra seedlings in ambient and elevated
CO2 atmospheres’, New Phytologist, 196, pp. 448-461.
2. Atkinson N.J. and P.E. Urwin (2012) ‘The interaction of plant biotic and abiotic stresses: from
genes to the field‘, Journal of Experimental Botany, 63, pp. 3523-3543.
3. Awan T.H. and B.S. Chauhan (2016) ‘Effect of emergence time, inter- and intra-specific
competition on growth and fecundity of Echinochloa crus-galli in dry-seeded rice’, Crop
Protection, 87, pp. 98-107.
4. Barnabas B., K. Jager and A. Feher (2008) ‘The effect of drought and heat stress on reproductive
processes in cereals’, Plant Cell and Environment, 31, pp. 11-38. doi: 10.1111/j.13653040.2007.01727.x.
5. Barriopedro D., E.M. Fischer, J. Luterbacher, R.M. Trigo and R. García-Herrera (2011) ‘The hot
summer of 2010: redrawing the temperature record map of Europe’, Science, 332, pp. 220-224.
6. Bodner G., Nakhforoosh A. and Kaul H.-P. (2015) ‘Management of crop water under drought: a
review’, Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 35, pp. 401-442. doi:10.1007/s13593-0150283-4.
7. Carmo-Silva A.E., M.A. Gore, P. Andrade-Sanchez, A.N. French, D.J. Hunsaker and M.E.
Salvucci (2012) ‘Decreased CO2 availability and inactivation of Rubisco limit photosynthesis in
cotton plants under heat and drought stress in the field’, Environmental and Experimental
Botany, 83, pp. 1-11.
8. De Boeck H.J., F.E. Dreesen, I.A. Janssens and I. Nijs (2011) ‘Whole-system responses of
experimental plant communities to climate extremes imposed in different seasons’, New
Phytologist, 189, pp. 806-817.
9. Della-Marta P.M., M.R. Haylock, .J. Luterbacher and H. Wanner (2007) ‘Doubled length of
western European summer heat waves since 1880’, Journal of Geophysical Research, 112, pp.
103-113.
811
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
10. Dole R., M. Hoerling, J. Perlwitz, J. Eischeid, P. Pegion, T. Zhang, X.-W. Quan, T. Xu and D.
Murray (2011) ‘Was there a basis for anticipating the 2010 Russian heat wave?’ Geophysical
Research Letters, 38. L06702, doi:10.1029/2010GL046582.
11. Dreesen P.E., H.J. De Boeck, I.A. Janssens and I. Nijs (2012) ‘Summer heat and drought extremes
trigger unexpected changes in productivity of a temperate annual/biannual plant community’,
Environmental and Experimental Botany, 79, pp. 21-30.
12. Duan H., J. Wu, G. Huang, Sh. Zhou, W. Liu, Y. Liao, X. Yang, Z. Xiao and H. Fan (2017)
‘Individual and interactive effects of drought and heat on leaf physiology of seedlings in an
economically important crop’, AoB PLANTS, 9, plw090; 10.1093/aobpla/plw090.
13. Duursma R.A., C.V. Barton, Y.S. Lin, B.E. Medlyn, D. Eamus, D.T. Tissue, D.S. Ellsworth and
R.E. McMurtrie (2014) ‘The peaked response of transpiration rate to vapour pressure deficit in
field conditions can be explained by the temperature optimum of photosynthesis’, Agricultural
and Forest Meteorology, 189, pp. 2-10.
14. Fahad S., A.A. Bajwa, U. Nazir, S.A. Anjum, A. Farooq, A. Zohaib, S. Sadia, W. Nasim, S.
Adkins, S. Saud, M.Z. Ihsan, H. Alharby, C. Wu, D. Wang and J. Huang (2017) ‘Crop Production
under Drought and Heat Stress: Plant Responses and Management Options’, Frontiers in Plant
Science, 8, pp. 1147. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2017.01147.
15. Fink, A.H., T. Brücher, A. Krüger, G.C. Leckebusch, J.G. Pinto and U. Ulbrich (2004) ‘The 2003
European summer heat waves and drought – synoptic diagnosis and impacts’, Weather, 59, pp.
208-216.
16. IPCC (2014) ‘Summary for Policymakers’ In: Climate Change 2014: Mitigation of Climate
Change. Contribution of Working Group III to the Fifth Assessment Report of the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Edenhofer O., Pichs-Madruga R., Sokona Y.,
Farahani E., Kadner S., Seyboth K., Adler A., Baum I., Brunner S., Eickemeier P., Kriemann B.,
Savolainen J., Schlömer S., von Stechow C., Zwickel T., Minx J. C. (ed.). Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA, pp. 1-30.
17. Jones G.S., P.A. Stott and N. Christidis (2008) ‘Human contribution to rapidly increasing
frequency of very warm Northern Hemisphere summers’, Journal of Geophysical Research,
113, D02109, doi:10.1029/2007JD008914.
18. Lisar S.Y.S., R. Motafakkerazad, M.M. Hossain and I.M.M. Rahman (2012) ‘Water stress in
plants: causes, effects and responses’, Water Stress, I.M.M. Rahman (ed.), ISBN: 978-953-307963-9, InTech, Available from: http://www.intechopen.com/books/water-stress/water-stressinplants-causes-effects-and-responses.
19. Maun M.A. and S.C.H. Bennett (1986) ‘The biology of Canadian weeds. 77. Echinochloa crusgalli (L.) Beauv’, Canadian Journal of Plant Science, 66, pp. 739-759. doi:10.4141/cjps86-093.
20. Mittal N., A. Mishra, R.Singh and P. Kumar (2014) ‘Assessing future changes in seasonal climatic
extremes in the Ganges river basin using an ensemble of regional climate models’, Climate
Change, 123, pp. 273–286. doi:10.1007/s10584-014- 1056-9.
21. Mittler R. and E. Blumwald (2010) ‘Genetic engineering for modern agriculture: challenges and
perspectives’, Annual Review of Plant Biology, 61, pp. 443-462.
22. Prasch C.M. and U. Sonnewald (2013) ‘Simultaneous application of heat, drought, and virus to
Arabidopsis plants reveals significant shifts in signaling networks’, Plant Physiology, 162, pp.
1849-1866.
23. Rollins J.A., E. Habte, S.E. Templer, T. Colby, J. Schmidt and M. von Korff (2013) ‘Leaf
proteome alterations in the context of physiological and morphological responses to drought and
heat stress in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.)’, Journal of Experimental Botany, 64(11), pp. 32013212.
812
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
24. Ruehr N.K., A. Gast, C. Weber, B. Daub and A. Arneth (2016) ‘Water availability as dominant
control of heat stress responses in two contrasting tree species’, Tree Physiology, 36, pp. 164178.
25. Sita K., A. Sehgal, B. HanumanthaRao, R.M. Nair, P.V. Vara Prasad, S. Kumar, P.M. Gaur, M.
Farooq, K.H.M. Siddique, R.K. Varshney and H. Nayyar (2017) ‘Food Legumes and Rising
Temperatures: Effects, Adaptive Functional Mechanisms Specific to Reproductive Growth Stage
and Strategies to Improve Heat Tolerance’, Frontiers in Plant Science, 8, pp. 1658. doi:
10.3389/fpls.2017.01658.
26. Suzuki N., R.M. Rivero, V. Shulaev, E. Blumwald and R. Mittler (2014) ‘Abiotic and biotic stress
combinations’, New Phytologist, 203, pp. 32-43. doi: 10.1111/nph.1279.
27. Toreti A., P. Naveau, M. Zampieri, A. Schindler, E. Scoccimarro, E. Xoplaki et al. (2013)
‘Projections of global changes in precipitation extremes from Coupled Model Intercomparison
Project Phase 5 models’, Geophysical Research Letters, 40, pp. 4887-4892.
28. Wang D., S.A. Heckathorn, D. Barua, P. Joshi, E.W. Hamilton and J. J. Lacroix (2008) ‘Effects
of elevated CO2 on the tolerance of photosynthesis to acute heat stress in C-3, C-4, and CAM
species’, American Journal of Botany, 95, pp. 165-176. doi: 10.3732/ajb.95.2.165.
29. Zadoks J.C., T.T. Chang and C.F. Konzak (1974) ‘A decimal code for the growth stages of
cereals’, Weed Research, 14, pp. 415-421.
813
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
SOIL CARBON ACCUMULATION IN BARNYARD GRASS
UNDER ELEVATED CO2 AND SHORT-TERM HEAT WAVES
AND DROUGHTS CONDITIONS
Dikšaitytė and G. Juozapaitienė*
Faculty of Natural sciences, Department of Environmental sciences,Vytautas Magnus University
Vileikos 8, Kaunas, LT-44404, Lithuania
*
Corresponding authors: e-mail: gintare.juozapaitiene@stud.vdu.lt
Abstract
Climate change will increase the frequency of heat waves and droughts. In order of this, such extreme
weather events are predicted to impact the terrestrial carbon balance. The aim of this research is to
analyze the effect of heat wave as single stressor (in well-watered plants, HWW) and simultaneously
with drought (HWD) to soil carbon accumulation in barnyard grass (Echinochloa crus - galli L.) soil.
For this purpose, plants were grown in a closed growth chambers under conditions of 21°C/400 ppm
and 25°C/800 ppm. 3 days long heat waves (21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400 ppm and 25°C/800 ppm vs.
35°C/800 ppm) were applied – single and in combination with drought (i.e. fully and not watered
during the heat wave period). The results showed that under drought conditions both heat waves
(21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400 ppm and 25°C/800 ppm vs. 35°C/800 ppm) significantly decreased
carbon accumulation in barnyard grass soil. Under fully watered conditions only heat wave of
21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400 ppm significantly decreased carbon accumulation in soil. Also, it was
estimated, that the heat wave of 25°C/800 ppm vs. 35°C/800 ppm decreased carbon accumulation in
soil less than the heat wave of 21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400 ppm. These findings may indicate that
elevated CO2 could mitigate the effects of heat waves and droughts on soil carbon accumulation.
Keywords: heat wave; drought; carbon; soil; barnyard grass
1.
INTRODUCTION
Climate change and increasing concentrations of atmospheric greenhouse gases, not only lead to
gradual mean global warming but may also change the frequency, the severity and even the nature of
extreme events (IPCC, 2013). As a consequence of climate change, the incidence and severity of
heatwaves and droughts have substantially increased since the middle of the 20th century (Stocker et
al., 2013). Droughts often occur accompanied by severe heatwaves, which together generate
combined effects on carbon cycles (Yuan et al., 2016). A synthesis of the direct and indirect impacts
of climate extremes on the carbon cycle and the underlying mechanisms is still lacking (Frank, 2015).
In a recent broad perspective, Reichstein et al. (2013) highlighted the possibility that climate extremes
and their impacts on the global carbon cycle may lead to an amplification of positive climate–carbon
cycle feedbacks. Rising atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) concentrations are likely to affect several
important aspects of grasslands, such as the quantity and quality of the herbage produced, plant
species composition, soil fertility and the potential to sequester carbon (C) in the soil, to mitigate
the rise in atmospheric CO 2 concentrations (Soussana and Luscher, 2007). Accumulation of C in
grassland ecosystems occurs mostly below-ground and changes in soil organic C stocks may result
both in land-use changes (e.g. conversion of arable land to grassland) and in grassland management
(Soussana et al., 2004). Although C4 plants represent only a small portion of the world´s plant
species, accounting for only 3 % of the vascular plants, they contribute about 20% to the global
814
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
primary productivity because of highly productive C4 grass-lands (Ehleringer et al., 1997). The
conservation of grassland C stocks and the role of grasslands as C sinks will become increasingly
difficult to preserve in an altered climate with a high temporal variability and u nder high
atmospheric CO2 concentrations which may saturate the C sink in soils (Soussana and Luscher,
2007). Despite these difficulties the aim of this research is to analyze the effect of heat wave as
single stressor (in well-watered plants, HWW) and simultaneously with drought (HWD) to soil
carbon accumulation in barnyard grass (Echinochloa crus - galli L.) soil.
2.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The experiment was conducted in a controlled environment chambers located at Vytautas Magnus
University. Seeds of weed barnyard grass (Echinochloa crus-galli L.) (15 seeds per pot) were planted
in 3 L plastic pots containing a growth substrate composed of a mixture of field soil (Luvisols - the
soil was taken from ASU Training Farm, Kaunas District), perlite and fine sand (5:3:2, by volume).
Plants were grown under control environment with a day length of 14 h , a day/night ambient air temperature of 21/14
°C or elevated of 25/18 °C and ambient CO2 concentration of 400 µmol mol−1 or elevated of 800 µmol
mol−1, and relative air humidity (RH) of 50±5% during the day and 70±5% at night. A light level of ~270
µmol m−2 s−1 photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) was provided by a combination of ten natural
day-light luminescent lamps (Philips, Waterproof OPK Natural Daylight LF80 Wattage 2×58 W/TL-D 58 W) and one
high-pressure sodium lamp (Philips MASTER GreenPower CG T 600 W). A nutrient supply
corresponding to 120 kg N ha−1 was used until the beginning of treatment. Additional fertilization with a
complex nutrient (NPK 12-11-18 + microelements) solution, increasing the N level until 180 kg N
ha−1, was applied one day before the treatment. Volumetric soil water content (SWC) was kept at
30% using a Theta Probe ML2x sensor combined with a hand-set HH2 moisture meter with a depth
of 6 cm (Delta-T Devices Ltd., Cambridge, UK). When plants expanded the third true leaf (BBCH
14 (Meier, 2001)), half of the pots were randomly assigned to 3 day-long heat wave (HW) treatment
(i.e. 31 ºC for 6.5 h per day and 21 ºC night temperature cycle and an ambient CO2 of 400 µmol mol−1
and 35 ºC for 6.5 h per day and 25 ºC night temperature cycle and an elevated CO 2 of 800 µmol
mol−1). All treatments were run in three replicates. 6.5 h heat cycle was chosen for the purpose to
represent natural environment conditions. The temperature in the heated growth chambers was
increased gradually every day from 21 to 31 °C and from 25 to 35 °C. Besides, half of the pots in HW
treatment were also treated under drought stress - plants were left without additional watering. Wellwatered pots in the HW treatments, as well as control plants, were weighed each day to determine
gravitational water loss and to maintain target SWC of 30%.
After 3 day-long HW treatment soil samples were taken. The samples were air dried at room
temperature and sieved through 2 mm mesh on purpose to remove all visible roots and plant remains.
The dried samples of soil were ground to a fine powder with a mill (Retsch HM400, Germany).
Organic carbon content was measured with a Shimadzu TOC-V solid sample module SSM-5000A in
the laboratory of Vytautas Magnus University. Statistical analyses were carried out using
STATISTICA 8 software. Mean values of soil carbon and their standard errors (±SE) were
calculated. Mann-Whitney U-test was used to estimate the differences in each parameter. The overall
effects of soil carbon and modified climate conditions and their interactions were determined by oneway ANOVA. Spearman’s correlation coefficient between watered-drought conditions and soil
carbon accumulation was calculated, and the significance of the correlation was tested by the
Spearman’s test.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Changes in climate or altered frequency of extreme events can trigger nonlinear changes in C balance,
as new processes become important (Chapin et al., 2009). The results showed that heat wave
(21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400 ppm) - single and in combination with drought - significantly decreased
carbon accumulation in barnyard grass soil (Figure 1). Under watered heat wave conditions soil
815
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
carbon decreased by 9.2% (p<0.05). Drought conditions had more negative effect on carbon
accumulation in soil. Under heat wave (21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400 ppm) in combination with
drought soil carbon decreased by 12.4% (p<0.05). According to other authors (Ciais et al., 2005;
Saleska et al., 2003), under drier conditions, there are predictions of increased sequestration by
suppression of respiration and of net loss of carbon through decreased productivity.
Figure 1. Responses of soil C to heat wave and drought (21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400 ppm)
(mean ± SE). Watered: Volumetric soil water content – 30 %, drought: no water irrigation. *
- statistically significant difference between 21°C/400 ppm and heat wave of 31°C/400 ppm
applied single and in combination with drought at p<0.05.
Figure 2. Responses of soil C to heat wave and drought (25°C/800 ppm vs. 35°C/800 ppm)
(mean ± SE). Watered: Volumetric soil water content – 30 %, drought: no water irrigation. *
- statistically significant difference between 25°C/800 ppm and heat wave of 35°C/800 ppm
applied single and in combination with drought at p<0.05.
The heat wave (25°C/800 ppm vs. 35°C/800 ppm) - single and in combination with drought – also
decreased carbon accumulation in barnyard grass soil, but the change was not significant under
watered conditions (-5.2%, p>0.05) (Figure 2). Also, drought conditions had more negative effect on
carbon accumulation in soil than watered conditions. Under heat wave (25°C/800 ppm vs. 35°C/800
ppm) in combination with drought soil carbon decreased by 9.7% (p<0.05). According to Arnone et
al., (2008) one year after an anomalously warm season, soil heterotrophic respiration was enhanced
in a grassland, offsetting net ecosystem carbon uptake. The increase in C storage in the particulate
soil organic matter with atmospheric CO2 concentration was found to be non-linear and declining at
816
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
above ambient CO2 concentrations in another research, which may indicate that the soil C sink in
grasslands will become saturated in a high atmospheric CO2 concentration world (Gill et al., 2002).
Still, according to some authors (Loiseau and Soussana, 1999a; Gill et al., 2002) due to the large
variability in soil C content, significant differences in total soil organic-C content are very hard to
detect in individual studies and are usually not significant.
ANOVA analysis showed that modified climate conditions (heat waves (21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400
ppm and 25°C/800 ppm vs. 35°C/800 ppm) – single and in combination with drought) as factor
significantly changed soil carbon accumulation in the soil of barnyard grass (p<0.05). Also, it was
estimated, that there was a significant correlation between watered-drought conditions and soil carbon
accumulation. Under drought conditions soil carbon decreased more than under watered conditions
(R=-0.6, p<0.05).
Also, it was estimated, that the heat wave of 25°C/800 ppm vs. 35°C/800 ppm decreased carbon
accumulation in soil less than the heat wave of 21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400 ppm. The reason of this
may be elevated CO2 under 25°C/800 ppm vs. 35°C/800 ppm heat wave condition. Recent
experimental research confirms that carbon storage in soil organic matter pools is often increased
under elevated CO2, at least in the short term (Allard et al., 2005) and under the predicted near future
climate, elevated CO2 could mitigate the effects of extreme droughts and heat waves on ecosystem
net carbon uptake (Roy et al., 2016).
4.
CONCLUSIONS
Under drought conditions both heat waves (21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400 ppm and 25°C/800 ppm
vs. 35°C/800 ppm) significantly decreased carbon accumulation in barnyard grass soil.
The heat wave of 25°C/800 ppm vs. 35°C/800 ppm decreased carbon accumulation in soil less
than the heat wave of 21°C/400 ppm vs. 31°C/400 ppm.
Elevated CO2 could mitigate the effects of heat waves and droughts on soil carbon accumulation.
Acknowledgments.
This research was funded by the European Social Fund under the No 09.3.3-LMTK-712
“Development of Competences of Scientists, other Researchers and Students through Practical
Research Activities” measure.
References
1. Allard V., P. C. D. Newton, L. M. Soussana, R. A. Carran and C. Matthew (2005) ‘Increased
quantity and quality of coarse soil organic matter fraction at elevated CO2 in a grazed grassland
are a consequence of enhanced root growth rate and turnover’, Plant Soil, Vol 276, pp. 49–60.
2. Arnone J. A., S. J. Paul, V. D. W. Johnson, J. D. Larsen, R. L. Jasoni, A. J. Lucchesi, C. M. Batts,
C. Nagy, W. G. Coulombe, D. E. Schorran, P. E. Buck, B. H. Braswell, J. S. Coleman, R. A.
Sherry, L. L. Wallace, Y. Luo and D. S. Schimel (2008) ‘Prolonged suppression of ecosystem
carbon dioxide uptake after an anomalously warm year’, Nature, Vol 455, pp. 383-386.
3. Chapin F. S. III, J. McFarland, A. D. McGuire, E. S. Euskirchen, R. W. Ruess and K. Kielland
(2009) ‘The changing global carbon cycle: linking plant–soil carbon dynamics to global
consequences’, Vol 97 (5), pp. 840–850.
4. Ciais P., et al. (2005) ‘Europe-wide reduction in primary productivity caused by the heat and
drought in 2003’, Nature, Vol 437, pp. 529–533.
5. Ehleringer J.R., T.E. Cerling and B.R. Helliker (1997) ‘C4 photosynthesis, atmospheric CO2 and
climate’, Oecologia, Vol 112, pp. 285-299.
6. Frank D., M. Reichstein , M. Bahn, K. Thonicke, D. Frank, M. D. Mahecha, P. Smith, M. Van
Der Velde, S. Vicca, F. Babst, C. Beer, N. Buchmann, J. G. Canadell, P. Ciais, W. Cramer, A.
817
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Ibrom, F. Miglietta, B. Poulter, A. Rammig, S. I . Seneviratne, A. Walz, M. Wattenbach, M. A.
Zavala and J. Zscheischler (2015) ‘Effects of climate extremes on the terrestrial carbon cycle:
concepts, processes and potential future impacts’, Global Change Biology, Vol 21, p.2861–2880.
7. Gill R.A., H.W. Polley, H.B. Johnson, L.J. Anderson, H. Maherali and R.B. Jackson (2002) ‘Nonlinear grassland responses to past and future atmospheric CO2’, Nature, Vol 417, pp. 279–282.
8. IPCC (2013) ‘Summary for policymakers. In: Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis’.
Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel
on Climate Change (eds Stocker TF, Qin D, Plattner G-K, Tignor M, Allen SK, Boschung J,
Nauels A, Xia Y, Bex V, Midgley PM), pp. 3–29. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
and New York, NY, USA.
9. Loiseau P. and J-F Soussana. (1999) ‘Elevated CO2, temperature increase and nitrogen supply
effects on below-ground carbon accumulation in a temperate grassland ecosystem’, Plant and
Soil, Vol 212, pp. 123–134.
10. Meier, U., editor. (2001) ‘Growth stages of mono-and dicotyledonous plant’s. BBCH monogr.
Federal Biological Research Center for Agriculture and Forests, Berlin-Braunschweig, Germany.
11. Reichstein M., M. Bahn, P. Ciais et al. (2013) ‘Climate extremes and the carbon cycle’, Nature,
Vol 500, pp. 287–295.
12. Roya J., C. Picon-Cochardb, A. Augusti, M. Benot, L. Thiery, O. Darsonville, D. Landais, C. Piel,
M. Defossez, S. Devidal, C. Escape, O. Ravel, N. Fromin, F. Volaire, A. Milcu, M. Bahn and J.
Soussan (2016) ‘Elevated CO2 maintains grassland net carbon uptake under a future heat and
drought extreme’ National Academy of Sciences.
13. Saleska, S. R. et al. (2003) ‘Carbon in Amazon forests: unexpected seasonal fluxes and
disturbance-induced losses’, Science, Vol 302, pp. 1554–1557.
14. Soussana J-F. and A. Luscher (2007) ‘Temperate grasslands and global atmospheric change: a
review’, Grass and Forage Science, Vol 62, pp. 127–134.
15. Soussana J-F., P. Loiseau, N. Vuichard, E. Ceschia, J. Balesdent, T. Chevallier and D. Arrouays
(2004) ‘Carbon cycling and sequestration opportunities in temperate grasslands’, Soil Use and
Management, Vol 20, pp. 219–230.
16. Stocker T. F. et al. (2013) ‘Technical Summary Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science
Basis’ Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment Report of the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change ed T.F. Stocker et al. (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press), pp. 33116.
17. Yuan W., W. Cai, Y. Chen, S. Liu, W. Dong, H. Zhang, G. Yu, Z. Chen, H. He, W. Guo, D.
Liu, S. Liu, W. Xiang, Z. Xie, Z. Zhao and G. Zhou (2016) ‘Severe summer heatwave and
drought strongly reduced carbon uptake in Southern China’, Scientific Reports, 6.
818
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
SHORT-TERM EFFECTS OF ELEVATED AIR TEMPERATURE
AND ATMOSPHERIC CO2 ON BELOW-GROUND CARBON
ACCUMULATION IN HORDEUM VULGARE AND PISUM
SATIVUM
G. Juozapaitienė1*, A. Dikšaitytė1, J. Aleinikovienė2
1
Department of Environmental Sciences, Faculty of Natural Sciences, Vytautas Magnus University,
Vileikos St. 8, Kaunas, Lithuania;
2
Agroecosystems and soil institute, Aleksandras Stulginskis University, Studentų St. 11, Kaunas
district, Lithuania.
*Corresponding author: e-mail: gintare.juozapaitiene@vdu.lt
Abstract
Global changes such as elevated atmospheric CO2 and air temperature are altering the input rates of
carbon to plants and soil. In order to study organic carbon (Corg.) accumulation in the below-ground
and to investigate if there is a dependency between photosynthetic rate and below-ground processes
of different crop species under increasing levels of air temperature and atmospheric CO2, a closed
growth chamber experiment was performed with spring barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) and pea (Pisum
sativum L.) in a controlled environment at ambient [21 °C/400 ppm] and elevated [25 °C/800 ppm]
temperature and CO2 conditions. The results showed that after 4 weeks of treatment under elevated
air temperature and atmospheric CO2 conditions barley and pea has accumulated organic carbon in
roots and soil by different trends. While organic carbon increased (p>0.05) in roots and soil of pea, it
decreased (p>0.05) in roots and soil of barley under conditions of [25 °C/800 ppm], compared to that
under conditions of [21 °C/400 ppm]. Contrary, microbial biomass carbon increased in soil of both
plant species - microbial biomass carbon increased by 55% (p<0.05) in barley soil and by 40%
(p<0.05) in pea soil under conditions of [25 °C/800 ppm]. Our results also suggested that there was
no significant correlation between photosynthetic rate and below-ground processes.
Keywords: below-ground carbon; closed chamber experiment; spring barley; pea
1.
INTRODUCTION
Increase in atmospheric CO2 concentrations and the rise in temperature will have extreme effects on
terrestrial plant growth and productivity in the near future. Carbon dioxide (CO2) concentration has
increased since the pre-industrial period from 280 to 401.62 ppm currently (NOAA, 2016). It is
expected that this value could increase to an atmospheric concentration of between 750 and 1300 ppm
for the end of the century (IPCC, 2014). Also, emissions of greenhouse gases caused by human
activities have augmented 70% from 1970 to 2004. If greenhouse gas emissions continue at high
levels, temperature is predicted to increase between 1.8 and 6.0 °C (IPCC, 2014).
A doubling of the CO2 level initially accelerates carbon fixation in C3 plants by about 30%, yet after
days to weeks of exposure to high CO2 concentrations, depending on species, carbon fixation declines
until it stabilizes at a rate that averages 12% above ambient controls (Curtis, 1996). A change of just
10% in the SOC pool would be equivalent to 30 years of anthropogenic emissions and could
dramatically affect concentrations of atmospheric CO2 (Kirschbaum, 2000). The overall increase in
total soil C under elevated CO2 suggests a potential for soil C sequestration.
819
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
While it has long been known that aboveground processes, particularly gross primary production
(GPP) and plant community dynamics, strongly control belowground C and nutrient cycling, the
specific roles of roots have been less clear (Pendall et al., 2008). The vital role of roots as an interface
between the lithosphere and biosphere is necessary to understand plant response to elevated CO2.
Despite the important role roots play, they have been an understudied component of agricultural
research since they exist underground (Madhu, Hatfield, 2013). Atmospheric CO2 is not a factor
directly connected to the rhizosphere. Any effect of atmospheric CO2 enrichment on rhizodeposition
is through plant growth, in contrast to factors such as the soil texture or the presence of
microorganisms that act more directly on the release of C from roots (Nguyen, 2003). Some research
suggests that root inputs to soil represent 5–33% of daily photoassimilate (Jones et al., 2009), also
about 40% of photosynthates synthesized in plant parts is lost through the root system into the
rhizosphere within an hour and the rate of loss is influenced by several factors, e. g. plant age,
different biotic and abiotic stresses, etc. (Kumar, 2006). Also, it is investigated that increased
atmospheric CO2 stimulates photosynthesis (Dijkstra et al., 2005; Hungate et al., 2006) and the release
of root exudates, which in turn means more labile carbon available for microbial decomposition and
respiration (Hungate et al., 2006; Rayner et al., 2005; Friedlingstein et al., 2006; Ainsworth and Long,
2005; Heath et al., 2005). For this reason, the objective of this paper is to study organic carbon
accumulation in the below-ground of different crop species and to investigate if there is a significant
correlation between photosynthetic rate and below-ground processes.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was conducted in a controlled environment chambers located at Vytautas Magnus
University in 2017. Seeds of spring barley (Hordeum vulgare L. ., var. ‘Aura DS’) (15 seeds per pot)
and pea (Pisum sativum L., var. ‘Pinochis’) (15 seeds per pot) were planted in 3 L plastic pots
containing a growth substrate composed of a mixture of field soil (the soil was taken from ASU
Training Farm, Kaunas District), perlite and fine sand (5:3:2, by volume). A nutrient supply
corresponding to 120 kg N ha−1 was used until the beginning of treatment. Additional fertilization
with a complex nutrient (NPK 12-11-18 + microelements) solution, increasing the N level until 180
kg N ha−1, was applied one day before the treatments. Elevated atmospheric CO2 and air temperature
(day/night temperature of 25/18 °C and 800 ppm of CO2) treatment was applied when the seedlings
of barley and pea were germinated and lasted for 4 weeks. Until that time all plants were grown in
the control chamber under conditions of current climate – an average day/night temperature of 21/14
°C and 400 µmol mol–1 of CO2. The following stable conditions were maintained in all chambers: a
photoperiod of 14 h, relative humidity (RH) of 50/60%, and 300 µmol m–2 s–1 photon flux density of
photosynthetically active radiation (PAR). The pots in the chamber were watered sufficiently and
regularly. All treatments were run in three replicates.
Photosynthetic rate (Pr, μmol CO2 m−2 s−1) was measured with portable photosynthesis system LI6400 (LI-COR, USA) equipped with a 6 cm2 leaf chamber with randomly selected youngest fully
expanded intact leaves. Photosynthetic rate were recorded automatically for approximately 5 minutes
every 3 s when Pr reached steady state level. During the measurements, leaf chamber conditions were
controlled at 400 or 800 µmol mol−1 CO2, and 21 or 25 ºC (bloc temperature), according to the climate
treatments. Air flow rate through the assimilation chamber was maintained at 500 µmol s−1. The water
vapour concentration of air entering the leaf chamber was not controlled and tracked ambient
conditions, relative humidity was 51±0.9 % in ambient and 39±1.6 % in elevated atmospheric CO2
and air temperature treatment (all mean ± SE). PAR outside the leaf chamber was 226±4.0 µmol m−2
s−1 on average across all climate treatments.
Measurements of carbon accumulation were carried out at a 28-day period after the treatment. A
subsample of plant roots was dried in an electric air-forced oven at 70 °C until a constant dry weight
was obtained (at least 72 hours). Soil samples were also taken at a 28-day period after the treatment.
The samples were air dried at room temperature and sieved through 2 mm mesh on purpose to remove
820
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
all visible roots and plant remains. The dried samples of roots and soil were ground to a fine powder
with a mill (Retsch HM400, Germany). Organic carbon content was measured with a Shimadzu TOCV solid sample module SSM-5000A in the laboratory of Vytautas Magnus University. Microbial
biomass carbon was determined by chloroform fumigation direct extraction method (Beck et al.,
1997).
Statistical analyses were carried out using STATISTICA 8 software. Mean values of the parameters
(plant photosynthetic rate (Pr), carbon of root and soil, microbial biomass carbon) and their standard
errors (±SE) were calculated. Mann-Whitney U-test was used to estimate the differences in each
parameter. The overall effects of plant species and modified climate conditions and their interactions
were determined by two-way ANOVA.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Increasing levels of air temperature and atmospheric CO2 significantly increased (p<0.05) barley and
pea photosynthetic rate by 48% and 63% respectively under conditions of [25 °C/800 ppm] after 4
weeks of treatment compared to that of the reference treatment (Fig. 1 (A)). For photosynthetic rate,
the differences between plant species and modified climate conditions were significant (1 table), but
there was no significant correlation between photosynthetic rate and below-ground processes.
Isotopic tracer studies have revealed a rapid and close coupling between photosynthesis and
belowground C allocation to roots, soil organisms and respiratory processes in forests and grasslands
(e.g. Ostle et al., 2000; Johnson et al., 2002). According to Irigoyen (2014) when the atmospheric
CO2 concentration rises suddenly (or in a temporal window up to a few days) from 400 to
700 μmol mol−1, the photosynthetic C fixation of C3 plants increases. Either an increase in
photosynthesis by 25 – 75 % has been detected in many experimental studies on the impact of doubled
CO2 concentration on C3 crops (Urban, 2003; Kirschbaum, 2004).
The results showed that after 4 weeks of treatment under elevated air temperature and atmospheric
CO2 conditions barley and pea has accumulated organic carbon in roots by different trends (Fig. 1
(B)). Roots of barley under conditions of [25 °C/800 ppm] have accumulated less (-2.3%, p > 0.05)
amount of carbon than under conditions of [21oC/400 ppm]. Contrary, roots of pea under conditions
of [25 °C/800 ppm] after 4 weeks of treatment have accumulated more organic carbon (2.1%),
compared to that of the reference treatment, however, the difference was not statistically significant
(p > 0.05). For carbon in roots, only the interaction between plant species x modified climate
conditions were significant (p<0.1) (Table 1).
The results of carbon accumulation in plant roots are also inconsistent in other researches. For
example, Uprety and Mahalaxmi (2000) have established that elevated CO2 significantly increased
the carbon content of Brassica juncea roots, but according to Lu et al. (2016) elevated CO2 had no
effects on the total carbon concentration of wheat root. In general, Wang et al. (2010) noted that
biomass C accumulation was greater in winter than in summer crops. CO2 stimulation of root
exudation can speed rhizosphere decomposition, causing soil respiration to respond more strongly to
photosynthetic rate than to soil temperature (Craine et al. 1999). Also, plants grown under elevated
atmospheric CO2 concentrations generally increase the partitioning of photosynthates to roots which
increases the capacity and/or activity of below-ground C sinks (Soussana and Luscher, 2007).
821
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Fig. 1: Responses of photosynthetic rate (A), root C (B), soil C (C) and microbial biomass C
(D) to elevated air temperature and atmospheric CO2 conditions (mean ± SE). * - statistically
significant difference between ambient (21oC/400 ppm) and elevated CO2 and temperature
(25 °C/800 ppm) conditions at p<0.05.
Table 1: Effects (F value) among plant species, modified climate conditions and their
interactive effects on photosynthetic rate (Pr), carbon in roots (Croot), carbon in soil (Csoil)
and microbial biomass carbon (Cmicrobial). Significance values: * - p<0.05, ** - p<0.1.
Pr
Croot
Csoil
Cmicrobial
Plant (P)
3.9**
1.04
0.35
42.3*
Modified climate conditions (C) 98.6*
0.02
0.21
543.9*
PxC
2.3
4.11**
0.86
2.85
After 4 weeks of treatment under elevated air temperature and atmospheric CO2 conditions barley
and pea has accumulated organic carbon in soil also by different trends (Fig. 1 (C)). Similarly, as in
the case with roots, the amount of organic carbon in barley soil decreased up to 2.8% (p > 0.05) under
conditions of [25 °C/800 ppm] after 4 weeks of treatment, while it almost has not changed in the soil
of pea – only 0.9% (p > 0.05) increase under elevated air temperature and atmospheric CO2
conditions, compared to that of ambient air temperature and atmospheric CO2 conditions [21 °C/400
ppm]. According to De Graaff et al. (2006) only a small number of experiments reported a significant
impact of elevated CO2 on soil C sequestration, while some studies showed no differences and others
found decreases in soil C.
For microbial biomass carbon, the differences between plant species and modified climate conditions
were significant (1 table). Microbial biomass carbon increased by 55% (p<0.05) in barley soil and by
40% (p<0.05) in pea soil under conditions of [25 °C/800 ppm] (Fig. 1 (D)). Increasing CO2
concentrations can lead to enhanced below-ground allocation of labile carbon through roots and root
exudates, which can enhance microbial activity and foster decomposition of carbon material that has
been deemed stable but was in fact not being attacked because microbes were not active (Heimann
and Reichstein, 2008). Microbial activity generally increases with increasing temperature, yet, this
simple relationship is confounded by many co-varying factors (Davidson and Janssens 2006),
including the temperature sensitivity of different SOM fractions (Fierer et al. 2005, Fang et al. 2005),
822
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
soil moisture and aeration (Davidson and Janssens 2006), and allocation of plant C below ground
(Högberg et al. 2001).
1.
CONCLUSIONS
1. Organic carbon increased (p>0.05) in roots and soil of pea, but decreased (p>0.05) in roots and
soil of barley under conditions of [25 °C/800 ppm], compared to that under conditions of
[21 °C/400 ppm].
2. Microbial biomass carbon increased in soil of both plant species - microbial biomass carbon
increased by 55% (p<0.05) in barley soil and by 40% (p<0.05) in pea soil under conditions of
[25 °C/800 ppm].
3. Our results also suggested that there was no significant correlation between photosynthetic rate
and below-ground processes. Although for photosynthetic rate, the differences between plant
species and modified climate conditions were significant.
REFERENCES
1. Ainsworth E. A. and S. P. Long (2005) ‘What have we learned from 15 years of free-air CO2
enrichment (FACE)? A meta-analytic review of the responses of photosynthesis, canopy
properties and plant production to rising CO2’, New Phytol, Vol 165, pp. 351–372.
2. Beck T., R. G. Joergensen, E. Kandeler, F. Makeschin, E. Nuss, H. R. Oberholzer and S. Scheu
(1997) ‘An inter-laboratory comparison of ten different ways of measuring soil microbial biomass
C’, Soil Biol. Biochem, Vol 29 (7), pp. 1023-1032.
3. Craine J.M., D.A. Wedin and F.S. Chapin III (1999) ‘Predominance of ecophysiological over
environmental controls over CO2 flux in a Minnesota grassland’, Plant and Soil, Vol 207, pp.
77–86.
4. Curtis P. S. (1996) ‘A meta-analysis of leaf gas exchange and nitrogen in trees grown under
elevated carbon dioxide’, Plant Cell Environment, Vol 19, pp. 127–137.
5. Davidson E.A. and I.A. Janssens (2006) ‘Temperature sensitivity of soil carbon decomposition
and feedbacks to climate change’. Nature, 440, 165–173.
6. De Graaff M. A., K. J. Van Groenigen, J. Six, B. Hungate and C. Van Kessel (2006) ‘Interactions
between plant growth and soil nutrient cycling under elevated CO2: a meta-analysis’, Global
Change Biology, Vol 12, pp. 2077–2091.
7. Dijkstra F. A., D. Blumenthal, J. A. Morgan and D. R. LeCain (2010) ‘Elevated CO2 effects on
semi-arid grassland plants in relation to water availability and competition’, Functional Ecology,
Vol 24 (5), pp. 1152–1161.
8. Fang C., P. Smith, J.B. Moncrieff and J.U. Smith (2005) ‘Similar response of labile and resistant
soil organic matter pools to changes in temperature’, Nature, Vol 433, pp. 57–59.
9. Fierer N., J.M. Craine, K. McLauchlan and J.P. Schimel (2005) ‘Litter quality and the temperature
sensitivity of decomposition’, Ecology, Vol 86, pp. 320–326.
10. Friedlingstein P., P. Cox, R. Betts, L. Bopp, W. von Bloh, V. Brovkin et al. (2006) ‘Climate–
carbon cycle feedback analysis: results from the C4MIP model intercomparison’, J Clim, Vol 19,
pp. 3337–3353.
11. Heath J., E. Ayres, M. Possell, R. D. Bardgett, H. I. Black and H. Grant et al. (2005) ‘Rising
atmospheric CO2 reduces sequestration of root-derived soil carbon’, Science, Vol 309, pp. 1711–
1713.
823
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
12. Heimann M. and M. Reichstein (2008) ‘Terrestrial ecosystem carbon dynamics and climate
feedbacks’, Nature, Vol 451, pp. 289–292.
13. Hogberg P.A., A. Nordgren, N. Buchmann, A.F.S. Taylor, A. Ekblad and M.N. Hogberg (2001)
‘Large-scale forest girdling shows that current photosynthesis drives soil respiration’, Nature,
Vol 411, pp. 789–792.
14. Hungate B.A., E.A. Holland, R.B. Jackson, F.S. Chapin, H.A. Mooney, C.B. Field (1997) ‘The
fate of carbon in grasslands under carbon dioxide enrichment’, Nature, Vol 388, pp. 576–579.
15. IPCC (2014) ‘Summary for policymakers’ In: Climate Change 2014: Impacts, Adaptation, and
Vulnerability. Part A: Global and Sectoral Aspects. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth
Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Eds. C. B. Field, V. R.
Barros, D. J. Dokken, K. J. Mach,M. D. Mastrandrea, T. E. Bilir, M. Chatterjee, K. L. Ebi,
Y. O.Estrada, R. C. Genova, B. Girma, E. S. Kissel, A. N. Levy, S. MacCracken,P. R.
Mastrandrea,and L. L.White. Cambridge, United Kingdom:Cambridge University Press.P.1–32.
16. Irigoyena J. J., N. Goicoecheaa, M. C. Antolína, I. Pascual, M. Sánchez-Díaz, J. Aguirreoleaa and
F. Morales (2014) ‘Growth, photosynthetic acclimation and yield quality in legumes under
climate change simulations: An updated survey’, Plant Science, Vol 226, pp. 22–29.
17. Johnson D., J. R. Leake, N. Ostle, P. Ineson, D. J. Read (2002) ‘In situ13CO2 pulse-labelling of
upland grassland demonstrates a rapid pathway of carbon flux from arbuscular mycorrhizal
mycelia to the soil’, New Phytologist, Vol 153, pp. 327–334.
18. Jones D. L., C. Nguyen and R. D. Finlay (2009) ’Carbon flow in the rhizosphere: carbon trading
at the soil–root interface’, Plant Soil, Vol (321), pp. 5–33.
19. Kirschbaum M. U. F. (2000) ’Will changes in soil organic carbon act as a positive or negative
feedback on global warming?’, Biogeochemistry, Vol (48), pp. 21–51.
20. Kumar R., S. Pandey and A. Pandey (2006) ‘Plant roots and carbon sequestration’, Current
Science, Vol 91 (7), pp. 885–890.
21. Lu C., Y. Cao, C. He, X. Bao, R. Fang, Y. Wanf, X. Chen, Y. Shi and Q Li (2016) ‘Effects of
elevated O3 and CO2 on the relative contribution of carbohydrates to soil organic matter in an
agricultural soil’, Soil & Tillage Research, Vol (159), pp. 47–55.
22. Madhu M. and J. L. Hatfield (2013) ‘Dynamics of plant root growth under increased atmospheric
carbon dioxide’, Agronomy Journal, Vol 105, pp. 657–669.
23. Nguyen C. (2003) ‘Rhizodeposition of organic C by plants: mechanisms and controls’,
Agronomie, EDP Sciences, Vol 23, pp. 375–396.
24. NOAA
(2016)
‘Up-to-date
Weekly
Average
http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/weekly.html
CO2
at
Mauna
Loa’
25. Ostle N., P. Ineson, D. Benham and D. Sleep (2000) ‘Carbon assimilation and turnover in
grassland vegetation using an in situ13CO2 pulse labelling system’, Rapid Communications in
Mass Spectrometry, Vol 14, 1345–1350.
26. Pendall E., L. Rustad and J. Schimel (2008) ‘Towards a predictive understanding of belowground
process responses to climate change: have we moved any closer?’, Functional Ecology, Vol 22,
pp. 937–940.
27. Rayner P. J., M. Scholze, W. Knorr, T. Kaminski, R. Giering and H. Widmann (2005) ‘Two
decades of terrestrial carbon fluxes from a carbon cycle data assimilation system (CCDAS)’,
Global Biogeochem Cycles, Vol 19.
28. Soussana J-F. and A. Luscher (2007) ‘Temperate grasslands and global atmospheric change: a
review’, Grass and Forage Science, Vol 62, pp. 127–134.
824
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
29. Uprety D. C. and V. J. Mahalaxmi (2000) ‘Effect of elevated CO2 and nitrogen nutrition on
photosynthesis growth and carbon nitrogen balance in Brassica juncea’, Agronomy & Crop
Science, Vol 184, pp. 271–276.
30. Urban O. (2003) ‘Physiological impacts of elevated CO2 concentration ranging from molecular
to whole plant responses’, Photosynthetica, Vol 41, pp. 9–20.
31. Wang Q,Y.Li and A.Alva (2010) ‘Growing cover crops to improve biomass accumulation and
carbon sequestration:a phytotron study’,Journal of Environmental Protection,Vol 1,pp. 73–84.
825
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
THE USE OF MODERN TECHNOLOGIES ΙΝ RECORDING AND
MONITORING OF RIPARIAN FORESTRY SPECIES IN GREECE.
THE CASE OF CANKER STAIN DISEASE OF PLATANUS
ORIENTALIS L.
Grigorios Varras*1 and Georgios Efthimiou2
1
Department of Agricultural Technology, Unit Floriculture & Landscape Architecture, T.E.I. of
Epirus, GR- 47100 Arta, Epirus, Greece.
2
Department of Forestry and Natural Environment Management, T.E.I of Sterea Hellada,
Karpenissi, Central Greece, Greece. gefthi@yahoo.gr
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: grvarras@gmail.com
Abstract
Modern technologies are a useful tool for recording and monitoring the ecological status of
ecosystems. Riparian forests are at risk from intense human activities, pressure and diseases. The
Platanus orientalis L. is a riparian forestry species that has, for years, withstood human pressure.
However, in recent years it is in danger of extinction by Ceratocystis fimbriata f.sp. platani. There
are records and worrying facts about the spread of the fungus, mainly in western Greece.
Modern technology constitutes a key tool and can be used as an effective way of timely recording
and dealing with existing and future interference of the Platanus at national level. The system
combines innovative basic research into Urban Forestry and urban ecosystems by developing an
integrated platform for data collection and decision making to optimally manage and protect the
Platanus by visualizing and quantifying the problem of the proliferation.
The aim of this paper is to present the electronic database DENDROLOGIO, as well as its first
application in the recording of the spread of the post-chromatic ulcer of the Platanus orientalis L. in
western Greece.
Keywords: Riparian forests, Platanus orientalis L., Dendrologio, Ceratocystis fimbriata f.sp. platani
Greece
1.
INTRODUCTION
Monitoring of ecological parameters for all natural ecosystems is basic key tool for their rational
management and immediate action on probable problem identification. Riparian forest ecosystems,
while they are most dynamic ecosystems when operating naturally and unaffected, are at risk of
intense human pressures [1, 2].
The use of modern technologies is a useful tool for monitoring the ecological status of riparian forests,
identifying problems and pressures (biotic and abiotic), recording the extent of their degradation from
human activities or possible disease outbreaks. A serious disease which is threatening to extinction
riparian forests of plane tree is the pathogenic fungus Ceratocystis fimbriata f.sp.platani which creates
the canker stain disease of the plane tree (a new destructive disease) and leads to the total kill of trees
or groups of plane trees in rivers and streams of Greek territory [3]. Riparian forests of Platanus
(habitats 92CO) are protected.
826
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The Ceratocystis fimbriata f.sp. platani fungus is considered to be an indigenous species of North
America and in the 1930s and 1940s it has taken great proportions in the states of the eastern coast of
the USA [4]. In Europe, it was introduced during the Second World War when war material was
transferred to plane wood boxes. The first European records of the fungus are made in Italy and
France. At first it had observed in Greece in 2003 in Messenia prefecture (southwestern Peloponnese)
in natural stands of the oriental plane as well as in ornamental plantings [4, 5]. In 2005 it is already
recorded in the prefectures of Arkadia and Ilia [6], in 2010 it is first identified in Epirus [7], while in
2014 it is located in Thessaly [8]. The transmission and spread of the disease is becoming through
broken branches and trunks of affected trees transported from river water, with logging remnants
which are transported miles away with cars, loggers and pruning tools, if disinfection is not properly
disposed of in the outbreak.
Here is coming the decisive role of modern technology to be the management tool for the recording
of infected plane trees in order to capture the spread on the map and to take decisive measures to
quarantine areas to slow down or even prevent the spread of the destructive fungus in nearby healthy
plane forests.
The organization of a sustainable and viable management of canker stain of the plane tree and the
pilot application, are expected to provide a good practice for protection against necrosis of the plane
trees, caused by the fungus Ceratocystis fimbriata f.sp. platani [9]. The pathogen only infects species
of the plane tree and completely kills the atoms of the eastern plane tree (Platanus orientalis). It is
the most destructive disease of the plane tree internationally and since it spreads mainly through
contaminated tools, cross border cooperation is essential for the effective management of the disease.
The deterioration of the natural environment will affect the natural as well as the cultural elements of
Epirus which are associated with the tradition and history of the plane tree. The phenomena of
extensive necrosis are expected to reduce the spread of the disease drastically and directly by creating
incentives for protection through awareness campaigns. Similarly, the scientific monitoring/
management/ avoidance of these adverse effects by developing an innovative geographical
monitoring system with specialized recording and monitoring methodology, will lead to the upgrade
of services for immediate intervention and minimization of the pathogen transmission and spread of
the disease. The combination of the above is expected to constitute solutions concerning the
sustainability assurance of natural resources, the modernization of the two countries' management
with the EU requirements.
2.
COMMON PROBLEMS
Common problem is the simultaneous necrosis of thousands of plane trees (Platanus orientalis) due
to the appearance of the pathogenic and destructive fungus Ceratocystis fimbriata f.sp. platani, whose
spread is likely to be caused by human activities in the extended plane tree forests of the crossborder
region, including the use of contaminated tools and road construction machinery that played an
important role in spreading the fungus.
During the last two decades, the transnational cooperation that has taken place in the construction of
road projects on the Greek-Albanian border, made it possible for the fungus to be easily transferred
from one country to another with tools and road construction machinery, given that the pathogen was
first identified in Epirus, in the Region of Ioannina and specifically in the Tiria River area, in a
recreational area near the construction site of Egnatia Odos [10], while in Albania it was observed in
the Region of Argirokastro, mainly along the highway. The spread of the pathogen is also caused by
the transfer of infected wood, used as firewood. The economic crisis played an important role in this
task, which has prompted many rural residents as well as urban inhabitants of the two regions, to use
firewood for heating, often derived from smuggled logging [7]. In each infestation source, the
pathogen is also spread underground from infested trees to adjacent healthy ones by the contact and
anastomosis of their roots [11].
827
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
This type of disease spread is very common in natural ecosystems of the plane tree along rivers and
streams, where trees grow next to each other with their root system in contact. In rivers and streams,
the fungus is spread downstream by logs and branches of infested dead trees, which are broken and
transferred by the watercourse. Therefore, the spread of the disease from one country to another is
given. In June 2014, symptoms and extensive mortality of plane trees was observed in various
locations of the prefecture Gjirokastra in southern Albania. It should be recalled that in 2010, the
presence of the infestation was reported in Epirus, which is very close to the border with Albania.
Given that plane tree are species of rapid growth not only with great importance in the natural
ecosystem, but also from an environmental, economic, social and aesthetic aspect (retention of floods,
protection from torrent phenomena and damages due to water overflow, protection of arable riparian
land from erosion, protection of riparian settlements and structures such as bridges, warehouses, barn
facilities, irrigation networks, dams, fish-farming etc. outstanding beauty in the landscape,
landscaping squares and recreational areas of forests). At the same time Platanus is creating
exceptional environments (on the banks of river basins) and for health and recreation reasons (it is
the place where outdoor activities are performed, such as rafting, kayak etc.). It constitutes a priority
habitat for conservation in the European Union, since the species occurs only in the southern Balkans
in such an extent, forming riparian forests, which in turn make a habitat for various species, such us
chickadees, flycatchers, nuthatches, woodpeckers, etc., whose nests are in holes which created by
native debranching of the species, which is something that does not happen so often in other types of
trees. Plan tree has great historical and social significance since it is inextricably linked to popular
tradition, monuments, squares of mountain settlements, thus becoming the most favorites and
important species of local communities.
2.1 The importance of the plane tree role in the economies of the Regions
A common feature of both Regions is the significance of the plane tree in areas with tourism (e.g.
Ioannina Lake, mountainous settlements, river ecosystems of international repute such as Voidomatis
River etc.). Maintaining biodiversity of riparian ecosystems are comparative advantages of the
regions that include them, and make up their identity, and are the basis for the development and
promotion of the country's image, which is an element for tourist development recovery, with respect
to the resources on the basis of which it is intended. The protection, conservation and enhancement
of the aesthetic landscape are a concern and right of local communities, on the basis of which their
identity is constructed. The change from necrosis of the plane trees brings about a deterioration of the
historical continuity of the landscape that is now a major political priority, which emerges not only
at regional and national level but also (primarily) locally. These elements concerning the pop culture,
tradition and natural landscape are today the competitive advantage of local communities for many
parts of the world, the pillar of maintaining their identity and their historical character as well as the
pillar of the development policies for the utilization of this local resource, in terms of sustainability.
The economy of culture and creation is a matter to be studied today in the international economics,
while in many regions (both developed and emerging) it is located in the heart of the development of
a growth strategy [12, 13].
2.2 Determining the size of the infestation
The approach of the proposal seeks a solution to the phenomenon of the spread of Ceratocystis
fimbriata f.sp. platani, through an innovative online GIS log open system of infested trees, as well as
new recordings, for digital mapping of affected trees, with two quarantine zones under the existing
Greek legislation, one within 100 m. (focal strike zone) and another one within 1000 m. (safetyquarantine zone). The maps are automatically posted on an Internet platform, which is combined with
an offline field logger, that can be directly utilized for planning, prioritization and implementation of
combat measures each year, for monitoring the rate of the pathogen spread, for evaluating the
effectiveness of the mitigation measures in previous years with pilot implementation of solutions and
for searching response methods and coordinating activities between the two countries. Since the
increase in the number of dead plane trees will harm the local economy, we seek in combination, to
828
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
implement ways of improving decision-making methods for disease control areas, optimizing the
effect by monitoring the progress and evolution of the disease after taking the appropriate measures,
monitoring its natural spread rate for scripting the spread with the creation and implementation in
practice, of innovative recording tools, monitoring and raising public awareness and services and
methods of avoiding proliferation. An innovative approach of the proposal is the achievement of a
display system of the recorded plane trees (there will be fields that will be completed, related to the
mapping of health or infestation level, for each recording point) as well as the laboratory tests for
improvement of the efficiency of the measures. The course or discontinuation of the spread will be
monitored (risk management).
2.3 Local population - Services - Synergies
The program benefits the local population since the plane tree is inextricably linked to their history
and tradition. A detailed description and recording of historical plane trees and their importance for
local communities and areas of outstanding natural beauty filled with plane trees and plane tree forests
in Greece. The Forest Services will encourage those responsible for decision-making to minimize
forest fires. The building capacity in environmental management supports the reduction of the spread
caused by anthropogenic factors that is mainly due to random actions, oversight and lack of disaster
risk knowledge. By increasing awareness, joint integrated efforts are maximized.
2.4 Development of an innovative log and recording system of infested trees
The system and especially the web platform, it has to be noted that it consists of three subsystems;
1.The subsystem (A), for storing information that basically constitutes the database of the system
proposed. 2. The subsystem (B), for managing stored information, as recorded by the application. Via
the subsystem (there are licensing levels), the user is given the opportunity to see the stored
information, to process it and to delete it, the exact location, date of sampling, number of trees with
symptoms, height and diameter, number of infested trees and possible causes of infestation,
geographical coordinates etc. 3.The subsystem (B), or supervisory display subsystem of the
recordings, concerning the representation of the recorded information, in text form and by positioning
on a map. In subsystem (B) additional features are implemented, such as search, bulk import and
export of the recorded information, as well as many other features needed, so as to meet additional
requirements. In essence, it has the potential to include other data, according to specific needs (risk
management). After the creation of the innovative GIS system that captures and records infested trees,
training of those involved takes place as well as the provision of the appropriate hardware for the
offline field logger. There is the possibility of changing the background maps (e.g. hydronomic maps,
forest maps etc.) for risk management [14].
3.
METHODOLOGY
The online Database Support System (DSS), incorporates 3 information sub-systems:
1. IT sub-system for the spatial registration and tree registration,
2. IT sub-system for User Interface Design,
3. IT sub-system for the online development
Some additional functions of the online DSS is the geo-tagging, data search tool and spatial analysis
tool. It is an open – source and fully customizable application. For the needs of the pilot version, two
(2) zones were defined for each recorded point, that is an infeced tree, the first one of 100 meters,
where the risk of attack is intense and the other one of 1000 meters, which also has a risk of spreading
the disease, but reduced in comparison with that of 100 meters.
In the first stage, sampling and data collection was performed in site using smart phones or tablets
and then a spatial database was developed. The data collected in site were introduced into the database
and within a GIS environment in Google maps and in satellite maps. Furthermore, the Main Online
829
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
DSS Structure and Info Flow is presented. The online DSS platform is created in Greek language to
meet the needs of local Forest Units.
4.
RESULTS
Its usage was able to disseminate authenticated information to the forest community about the health
of trees in the specific FOREST UNIT that enabled the optimization of forest management with
special care to the mitigation of the disease. Therefore, the georeferenced database will be used for
integrated management of trees, Local sustainable development, sustainable use of natural resources
and environmental protection.
4.1 Main Online DSS Structure and Info Flow
In Figure 1 is mentioned the structure and the flow information of the online DSS. In the home page
the user can be informed about the online system and is also given an overview about the fungus that
causes the disease of the metachromatic ulcer of the plane tree. There are, also, mentioned the
symptoms of the infection of the plane trees and the spread of the disease. Moreover, responding to
the disease and “FAQ” about the disease are in home page, too (Figure 2).
WEBSITE structure
www.dendrologio.gr/dasarxeio
HOME
System
fungus
symptoms
RECORD MAP
spread
SEARCH
FILTER & PRINT
USER GUIDE
INPUT
addressing
Figure 1: Main Online DSS Structure and Info Flow
Figure 2: Homepage ain Online DSS Structure and Info Flow
4.2 Record Map
The platform incorporates a RECORD MAP, a visual database with spatial geographic location
information, including data on healthy and infected trees in the Forest Unit of Ioannina, in Epirus
Region in North-West Greece.
The default is GoogleMap though there is the option of viewing Bing Map, with appropriate color
indication that suggests their health. Greek Cadastre maps can also be launched. The quarantine zones
are illustrated within a radius of 100m and 1km-with red and yellow color respectively -of the affected
plane trees so as to take the appropriate measures to prevent the spread of the disease (Figure 3).
830
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Additional information registered for each tree appears by clicking the left mouse button on the
desired tree. With info about sampling and check of the tree, Lab, location, tree type, disease type,
results, date, name of employee, sampling protocol no, etc (Figure 4).
4.3 Searching
An infected plane tree of Multiple criteria or combination of them can be used for the online search,
such as: Date of sampling, Name of employee, Sampling Protocol no, Type of tree. Moreover, users
can even type the entire or part of the search criterion (Figure 5). This results in a view with
information and map as in Figure 4.
Figure 3: RECORD MAP. Here are mentioned the quarantine zones
4.4 Filtering and Printing
The user can print part of the map or the entire map while the blue dots correspond to the affected
plane trees and the yellow zone around them have a radius of 1 km (Figure 6). The user can choose
how to view the affected plane trees by setting a specific date (Filter Results), and adjust the
brightness of the yellow zone for printing purposes (Select transparency). After that, user decides on
the desired print view (e.g. launch Cadastre maps) by pressing the left mouse button on "Print Map",
the map is printed on the default printer. Furthermore, the user has the opportunity to save the map in
.pdf formation and download the default location. Alternatively, a snapshot of the map can be saved
by print screen (PrtSckey).
4.5 Input process and Input Forms
In order to insert a new plane tree in the system, user authentication is required via a Username and
Password (Figure 7).
The user fills in the form fields that are presented (Picture 8). If any or some fields remain blank, the
plane tree will be accepted by the system. The sampling date is selected by default as the registration
date. If the plane tree to be inserted is healthy, the value added in the field "AffectedNumber" is "0".
831
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Figure 4: Tree Info window of DENDROLOGIO.gr
Figure 5: Search window
Figure 6: Filtering and Printing Results
Figure 7: Input process
832
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 8: Input Forms
4.6 Placing the trees on the map
Regarding the placement of the new plane tree on the map, it is achieved by pressing the left mouse
button on the map point where the plane tree is located, a red indicator is shown at that point while
its longitude and latitude are automatically inserted in the corresponding fields of the form. Finally,
the new tree is recorded in the system by pressing the left mouse button on the «Save»option (at the
bottom left of the form) (Figure 9).
Figure 9: Placing on the Map
References
1. Efthimiou, G. (2000). Structure analysis, dynamic and ecological interpretation of riparian forests
of Nestos. PhD thesis, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Faculty of Agricultural, Forestry and
Natural Environment, Thessaloniki. (in Greek).
2. G. Efthimiou and S. Themelakis. (2017). Riparian Forests and Alien Invasive species. The case
of the Riparian Forest of Ardas river (GR1110008), NE Greece. Proc. 18th Panellenic Forest
Conference & International Workshop “Information Technology, Sustainable Development,
Scientific Network & Nature Protection” 8-11 October 2017 Εdessa Pellas, Greece, (vol 1: 10401047), 2017.
3. Tsopelas P. and Soulioti N. (2010). Invasion of the fugus Canker stain Ceratocystis platani in
Epirus, Greece: A potential environmental disaster in the natural ecosystems of plane trees. Abst.
15th Hellenic Phytopathological Congr., Hellenic Phytopathological Society, p. 33. Corfu,
Greece. (in Greek).
4. Tsopelas P., and Angelopoulos A. (2004). First report of canker stain disease of plane trees,
caused by Ceratocystis fimbriata f.sp platani in Greece. Plant Pathology, 53(4): 531.
5. Tsopelas P., and Soulioti N. (2013). Canker stain disease: a major threat to natural stands of
oriental plane in Greece. Proc. 16th Panhellenic Forestry Conf. (pp. 175-179). Thessaloniki
Greece.
833
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
6. Tsopelas P., Angelopoulos A. and N. Soulioti. (2005). Canker stain a new destructive disease of
plane in Greece. Proc. 12th Panhellenic Forestry Conf. (pp. 175-182), Drama, Greece.
7. Tsakiris P., Zoi S., Seli S., Leontaris G. and C. Lagos. (2014). Rapid expansion of canker stain of
plane tree (Ceratocystis platani) in Ioannina, Epirus region, NW Greece and the role of economic
crisis. Abst. 17th Hellenic Phytopathological Congr., Hellenic Phytopathological Society, p. 33.
Volos, Greece. (in Greek).
8. Tsopelas P., Soulioti N. and N. Chatzipavlis. (2014). Methods of managing the disease of the
post-chromatic ulcer of plane in Greece. Abst. 17th Hellenic Phytopathological Congr., Hellenic
Phytopathological Society, p. 43. Volos, Greece. (in Greek).
9. EPPO/CABI. (1997). Ceratocystis fimbriata f. sp. platani. In: Quarantine Pests for Europe, CAB
International, Wallingford (GB). 2nd edn, pp 674-677.
10. Tsakiris P., Zoi S., Seli S., Leontaris G. and C. Lagos. (2014). The most important Europe's plane
forests in immediate danger: the rapid the spread of the fungus Ceratocystis platani in the region
of Ioannina. Abst. 7th PanHellenic Ecology Congr., p. 163. Mytilini, Greece. (in Greek).
11. Panconesi A. (1999). Canker stain of plain trees: a serious danger to urban plantings in Europe.
Journal of Plant Pathology Vol. 81, pp 3-15.
12. Tasoulas E., Andreopoulou Z. (2012). Integrated Forest Environments Supporting Proper
Management. Protection and Ecology, Vol. 13(1), pp 338-344.
13. Tasoulas E, Varras G, Tsirogiannis I, & Myriounis C. (2013). Development of a GIS application
for urban forestry management planning, Procedia Technology, Vol. 8, pp 70-80.
14. Varras G, Andreopoulou Z, Tasoulas E, Papadimas CH, Tsirogiannis I, Myriounis CH, Koliouska
CH. (2016). Multi-purpose Internet-based Information System ‘Urban’. Urban Tree Database
and Climate Impact Evaluation, Vol. 17(1), pp 380-386.
834
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
STABLE ISOTOPE MASS BALANCE TO ASSESS CLIMATE
IMPACT IN LAKE SYSTEMS
P. Chantzi* and K. Almpanakis
Laboratory of Physical Geography, Dept. of Physical & Environmental Geography, School of
Geology, AUTH GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author e-mail : pchantzi@geo.auth.gr, tel : +302310998508
Abstract
Isotope mass balance was performed based on 10 eastern Mediterranean stations from International
Atomic Energy Agency - World Meteorological Organization (IAEA-WMO) precipitation network.
Theoretical lake water isotope values were calculated and compared with measured lake water isotope
values from literature data corresponding to different hydrological types of lake systems in the eastern
Mediterranean. It is concluded that isotope limnology theory corresponds well to different lake water
systems. δ2H/δ18O ratio is a robust index to monitor the response of lake systems to climate variations.
We can estimate the δ2H/δ18O ratio for lake systems with different topographical and hydrological
characteristics and compare it with the theoretical values that came up for the eastern Mediterranean
lakes resulting in conclusions about the intensification or recession of evaporation process. So, the
δ2H/δ18O ratio of measured data in lake systems is a quantitative method to estimate climate change
impact to lake systems. Isotope mass balance model unshackles us from the narrow grid-cell station
density to satisfy the monitoring goal and facilitates the study of lake systems in a larger spatial scale.
Keywords: Isotope mass balance model, lakes, Mediterranean, climate change
1.
INTRODUCTION
It has been well documented that Mediterranean area is strongly affected by climate change (Kelley
et al., 2012; Lelieveld et al., 2012). Several climate models end up to higher annual temperatures,
lower annual precipitation, sea level rise and intensity of extreme events (Mariotti et al., 2008; Seager
et al., 2014). In more detail, according to the IPPC reports 2013, mean temperature increase for the
period 2080-2100 is estimated about 2.2-5.1oC, while the decrease in mean annual precipitation is
estimated about 4-27%. What we stressed above all is that the most important issue is the increase of
interannual variability both for temperature and for precipitation (Giorgi 2006). Water cycle expresses
the circulation of water phases (liquid, solid, vapor) in climate system. Consequently, this climate
variation, in turn, affects the hydrologic response of Mediterranean basins, where, the seasonality and
the complex morphology are principal features (Hoerling et al., 2012). However, the alteration in
hydrological balance could have a direct impact both in safe living and economic activities. Extensive
droughts or floods increase the risk of extensive disasters. On the other hand, especially in southern
Mediterranean countries where their economic base is made up by the two pillars of agriculture and
tourism, any disruption to potential evapotranspiration and deficiency in water resources results in
several implications on their economic model. This article is focused on lake systems. Well defined
lake systems give the opportunity to assess climate variation as 1) they are worldwide representing
different climate conditions (temperature, precipitation, moisture), geographic location (north, south),
hydrology systems (open, closed, semi-closed), water types (fresh/sea water or mixing processes), 2)
the response in long-term intervals including records of hydrologic extremes, 3) they are directly
linked to climate variations incorporating the climate-driven episodes of their basins. The question
835
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
arises as to whether we can model the lake response to climate variation given the first comment
about their diversity in many factors. Water mass balance in lake systems is strongly correlated with
several climatic factors such as temperature, evaporation, precipitation and air moisture. Distribution
of precipitation, surface and groundwater circulation pattern related to their hydrological type while
continental relief define the ratio that a basin is exposed to the wind patterns. As climate change
warms the atmosphere and intervenes in water cycle, water mass balance in lake systems give the
opportunity to model and quantify the response of large watersheds to climate variation. However,
water mass balance requires a narrow grid-cell station density to satisfy the monitoring goal of
quantification of lake system responses to climate variation. An excellent tool for this attempt is the
combination of water mass balance with isotope hydrology. Stable isotopes of oxygen ( 18O) and
deuterium (2H) in water molecule constitute ideal traces for water cycle in large spatial and temporal
scale. Limnological isotope theory (Leng and Marshall, 2004; Roberts et al., 2008) is based on
climatic factors and precipitation-evaporation balance (P/E) for the two hydrological conditions of a
lake: open and closed systems. In case of hydrological open lakes, the origin of precipitation and
temperature oscillations determine the isotopic signature of lake water instant of the precipitationevaporation balance (P/E) that is the key factor for hydrological closed lakes. The main objective of
the study is to compare measured isotope values of different hydrological lake systems with
calculated values based on isotope limnology theory aiming to conclude to a tool that will facilitate
us to monitor and quantify the response of lake systems in climate variation. This attempt was earthed
on east Mediterranean area where Greece belongs.
2.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
2.1 Isotope hydrology model for lake systems
The isotopic mass balance (eq. 2) is based on the water mass balance (eq. 1) for a well-mixed lake
with constant water density:
dV/dt = P + Qi – E - Qo
(1)
d(VδL)/dt = PδP + QiδP – EδE - QoδL
(2)
where: V and t, are the lake volume and unit time. P and E are precipitation and evaporation on lake
surface per unit time.
Q factor is calculated by the surface and groundwater budget (Qx=Sx+Gx), where o and i markers
correspond to outflow and inflow respectively. The isotope values of precipitation, evaporation and
lake water are induced by δP, δE and δL respectively. The results are expressed in standard delta
notation (δ) as per mil (‰) deviation from the standard V-SMOW as:
δ = ((Rsample − Rstandard)/Rstandard) x 1000, where Rsample and Rstandard = 2H/1H or 18O/16O
of sample and standard, respectively. δP and δL are directly measurable on a water sample however it
is not as easy for δE. Craig and Gordon (1965) reported an evaporation model that is used to calculate
δE (eq. 3):
δE=(a*δL-hδA-ε)/(1-h+εk)
(3)
where,
h: relative humidity normalized to the saturation vapor pressure at the temperature of the air-water
interface
δA: the isotopic value of the air-vapor over the lake
εk: kinetic fraction factor, for δ18O with εk~14.2(1-h) ‰ (Gonfiantini 1986)
ε=ε⁎+ εk, where ε⁎=1000(1-α⁎)
836
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
α⁎: equilibrium isotopic fractionation factor dependent on the temperature at the evaporating surface
O: 1/a* = exp(1137TL-2 – 0.415 TL-1 – 2.0667*10-3
2
H: 1/a* = exp(24844TL-2 – 76.248 TL-1 – 52.61*10-3
18
(4)
(5)
TL: temperature of the lake surface water in degrees Kelvin (Majoube 1971)
Eq. 5 describes an additional equation for δE as proposed by Benson and White (1994) based on the
same evaporation theory which has been used in other lake models (Ricketts and Johnson 1996).
Re=[(RL/aeq) - (RHfadRad)]/[((1-RH)/akin) + RH(1-fad)]
(6)
where,
Rad: isotope ratio of the free atmospheric water vapor with respect to VSMOW,
RH: relative humidity, and
αeq: fractionation factor dependent on equilibrium isotopic fractionation factor with αeq=(1/α⁎)
αkin: fractionation factor dependent on wind speed where αkin=0.994 for wind speeds less than 6.8
m*s-1 (Merlivat and Jouzel, 1979)
fad: fraction of atmospheric water vapor in the boundary layer over the lake where fad=0 in case that
all the atmospheric water overlying the lake is derived from evaporation, rather than atmospheric
moisture.
Finally, δE is calculated by δi=(Ri-1)103 and Ri=(Ri/Rstandard) where R is the isotope ratio and the
standard, in this case, is VSMOW.
2.2 Methodology
Τhe higher precipitation recharge in Greece found in the western part of Greece with the contribution
of orographic injections of Pindos Mountains and the mountains of the Peloponnese. Eastern Aegean
comes second where the complex topography and the warm Aegean Sea result in a considerable
precipitation recharge. These significant precipitation amounts attributed to the depressions of
Atlantic or western and central Mediterranean origin that enter Greece on the west during their
eastwards route generating south-southwest wind over the Ionian Sea and southern Greece resulting
in reduced precipitation recharge in Central Greece. Also, Sahara depression contributes to significant
seasonal precipitation amounts (Flocas and Giles, 1991). Literature oxygen and deuterium data from
lake water samples in the eastern Mediterranean were collected (Table 1). The rule was to cover all
the hydrological types of lake systems in a spatial scale. Detailed, Sawa, Koronia and Pikrolimni
lakes considered rather closed systems where evaporation process predominates to their isotopic
signature contrary to Yliki and Paralimni lakes where key factors are seasonality and precipitation
origin. Doirani, Prespa and Ohrid Lakes sit within karstified basins while Ismarida Lake is
characterized by fresh-sea water mixing process.
Table 1: Lake sites that correspond to different altitudes and hydrological types
Lake Sites
Mygdonia Basin (Volvi
and Koronia Lakes)
Ismarida Lake
Pikrolomni Lake
Prespa and Ohrid Lakes
Dojran Lake
Kopais Basin (Yliki and
Paralimni Lakes)
Sawa
Lake
area,
southern Iraq
δ18Op ‰ VSMOW
δ2H ‰ VSMOW
Reference
-6.6 to -4.8 ‰
-49 to -38.5 ‰
Chantzi et al., 2016
-6.6 to -0.4 ‰
-7.2 to 4.9 ‰
-3.8 to -1.7 ‰
2 to 2.1 ‰
-40 to -8.6 ‰
-52 to 14.7 ‰
-35.4 to -21.4 ‰
1.1 to 1.9 ‰
Gemitzi et al., 2014
Dotsika et al., 2012
Eftimi et al., 2007
Griggiths et al. 2002a
-7.2 to -5.9 ‰
-49.7 to -38.3 ‰
Griggiths et al. 2002b
2.5 to 5.9 ‰
28.3 to 29.8 ‰
Ali et al., 2016
837
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
The main incoming air flow pattern in Mediterranean area is controlled by the Atlantic Ocean through
the Iberian Peninsula or France (for the western Mediterranean) or from the European continent (for
the eastern Mediterranean). So, the isotope value of the air-vapor over the lake from advecting air
masses could be calculated using the available data from the International Atomic Energy Agency World Meteorological Organization (IAEA-WMO) precipitation network [IAEA, 2017] for the
southern European stations assuming the isotopic equilibrium between precipitation and the air
moisture over the continent (Gat et al., 1996). Theoretical isotope values for lake waters that
correspond to east Mediterranean area were conducted by 10 stations of the Global Network of
Isotopes in Precipitation (GNIP) (IAEA/WMO, 2017). Selected stations distributed in the north-south
direction in the eastern Mediterranean area and around it (Table 2). Τhe prerequisite to select a station
was at least 5-year data for isotope value of precipitation, d-excess, temperature and average vapor
pressure. Although Thessaloniki station had available data only for 4 years it was decided to use it,
as this station was one of the two available in north Greece with a larger data set than Alexandroupoli
station (3 years). In these scenarios, we assume that isotopic signature of waters that enters the lake
correspond to that of precipitation stations. Moreover, isotope values for lake waters that correspond
to east Mediterranean Sea water were calculated, based on Gat et al, 1996 primarily data, as
evaporation process of land-locked Mediterranean Sea participate in isotopic signature of vapors.
Table 2: Selected stations of the Global Network of Isotopes in Precipitation (GNIP)
(IAEA/WMO, 2017) for the east Mediterranean
IAEA stations
Elliniko Athens, Greece
Pedeli Athens, Greece
Thissio Athens, Greece
Thessaloniki, Greece
Irakleio, Greece
Rhodes, Greece
Patra, Greece
Zagreb, Croatia
Edirne, Turkey
Ramnicu Valcea, Romania
Bet Dagan, Israel
Time series
1960; 1962-1968; 1970; 1972; 1974
2004-2016
2000-2016
2000-2003
1965-1968; 1972-1974
1963-1968; 1972; 1976
2000-2016
1980-1995
2008-2016
2012-2016
1960-1966; 1968-1979
Coordinates
37 53 0 N, 23o43΄47.99΄΄E
38o3΄0.39΄΄N, 23o52΄0.03΄΄E
37o58΄11.99΄΄N, 23o43΄11.99΄΄E
40o40΄12΄΄N, 22o57΄36΄΄E
35o19΄47.99΄΄N, 25o10΄47.99΄΄E
36o22΄48΄΄N, 28o6΄0΄΄E
o
36 16΄48΄΄N, 21o47΄23.99΄΄E
45o48΄24΄΄N, 15o58΄12΄΄E
41o40΄41΄΄N, 26o33΄33΄΄E
45o2΄7΄΄N, 24o17΄3΄΄E
o
315 59΄50.29΄΄N, 34o48΄58.17΄΄E
o
΄ ΄΄
Based on monthly data mean hydro-year values were estimated and then the mean values for the
given time series for each station (Table 3). The calculated mean air temperature corresponded to
lake surface temperatures. Relative humidity calculated as pw/pws 100% where pw: vapor partial
pressure given by IAEA/WMO, 2017 data, and pws: saturation vapor partial pressure at the actual dry
bulb temperature (Engineering ToolBox, 2004). Both h and RH have the same values % in Eq. 3 and
Eq. 6. It is assumed that mean wind spread is less than 6.8 ms-1 for the eastern Mediterranean so such
that αkin is constant. δA= δP-ε⁎ according to Gibson et al. (1999). Evaporation calculated by the
proposed equation of Penman (1948) which is simplified by Linacre (1992):
E(mm/day) = [0.015 + 4x10-4Tα+10-6z] x [480(Tα+0.006z)/(84-A)-40+2.3u(Tα-Td)]
where
Tα: air temperature (°C),
z: altitude (m),
A: latitude
838
(7)
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 3: Summary of average annual hydro-climate factors for the IAEA sites (data from
GNIP (IAEA/WMO, 2004)).
P
(mm/yr)
E
(mm/yr)
Tav
(oC)
δ18Op ‰
VSMOW
δ2H ‰
VSMOW
Altitude
(m asl)
RH
(%)
Qi=E-P
d-excess
388
1998
18
-6.05
-33.04
19
61
1610
14.96
561
1897
15.2
-7.48
-44.85
451
71
1336
14.98
433
2296
18.6
-6.42
-37.18
105
63
1863
14.26
335
1949
16
-6.69
-44.48
93
71
1614
9.03
495
760
734
1917
2027
2110
18.9
18.8
18.1
-7.24
-5.27
-5.78
-39.20
-25.70
-35.00
54
65
112
67
68
65
1422
1267
1376
18.69
14.94
10.99
862
1271
11.9
-8.70
-61.15
123
75
409
8.51
632
1669
15
-8.24
-54.36
80
71
1036
11.58
755
812
11.8
-8.09
-57.72
220
86
57
7.00
536
1792
19.3
-5.15
-23.44
44.9
71
1257
18.64
25.2
-6.42
-43.70
0
46
16
-12.19
-88.80
0
30
Elliniko
Athens
Pedeli
Athens
Thissio
Athens
Thessalon
iki
Irakleio
Rhodes
Patra
Zagreb,
Croatia
Edirne,
Turkey
Ramnicu
Valcea,
Romania
Bet
Dagan,
Israel
Sea Water
a
Sea Water
a
a: Gat et al., 1996
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The isotopic signature of Mediterranean lakes presents a high variation as different climatic factors
affect them (season, humidity, temperature) in the north-south direction. Their topographical and
hydrological regime define the rule under which these climate factors affect lake systems. The
character of Mediterranean lakes lies between temperate Europe and North Africa. So, we are
witnesses in lakes with fresh water and short residence-time and δ18OL values close to those of
precipitation and hydrological closed lakes where evaporation process prevails.
In a stable climatic and geomorphological environment, the lake system will be described as constant:
d(VδL)/dt = 0
dV/dt = 0
(8)
(9)
In a steady state, there are two border hydrological conditions that correspond to the lake system. The
first concerns closed lakes where theoretically there are no outflows. In this case Qo=0 and according
to Eq. 2 and eq.8 the isotope mass balance will be:
Pδp + Qiδp=EδE
(10)
which means that δE~δP. On the other hand, we have hydrological open lakes where theoretically we
have a continuous flow system without evaporation losses E=0:
839
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
Pδp + Qiδp = QoδL
(11)
which means that δL~δP.
Calculated lake water isotope values δL (δ18O and δ2H) for hydrological closed lakes presented in
Tables 4 and 5 according to eq.3 and eq.6. Based on (eq.3) δ18OL values range from -6.76‰ to 2.17‰ VSMOW and δ2HL values from -63.98‰ to -29.51‰ VSMOW. Based on (eq.6) we have two
conditions: a) fad=0 where δ18OL values range from 3.17‰ to 6.52‰ VSMOW and δ2HL values from
-73.12‰ to -43.88‰ VSMOW, b) fad=1 where δ18OL values range from -5.92‰ to 0.07‰ VSMOW
and δ2HL values from -62.40‰ to -27.77‰ VSMOW. The above equations applied for precipitation
data over Mediterranean Sea water stations. For eq.3 mean δ18OL and δ2HL values were -2.27‰
VSMOW and -56.85‰ VSMOW respectively. For eq.6 mean δ18OL and δ2HL values were 5.64‰
VSMOW and -50.75‰ VSMOW respectively for fad=0 while fad=1 mean δ18OL and δ2HL values were
1.55‰ VSMOW and -53.03‰ VSMOW respectively. The hydrological status of an open lake is
described by δ18OL and δ2HL data that are equal to precipitation data. In practical terms, that means a
range for lake water values from -8.7 to -5.27‰ VSMOW for δ18OL and from -61.15 to -25.70‰
VSMOW for δ2HL. Mean δ18OL and δ2HL values from precipitation samples over Mediterranean Sea
water were about -9.3‰ VSMOW and -66.25‰ VSMOW respectively for open lake systems.
Table 4: Calculated values of δ18O L and δ2H L using eq. (10), eq. (3) and eq. (6) for
hydrologically closed lakes
eq. 6
δ18ΟE
Elliniko
Athens
Pedeli Athens
Thissio
Athens
Thessaloniki
Irakleio
Rhodes
Patra
Zagreb,
Croatia
Edirne,
Turkey
Ramnicu
Valcea,
Romania
Bet
Dagan,
Israel
Sea Water a
Sea Water a
Mean SW
fad=0
18
δ ΟL
δ2ΗE
eq. 3
δ2ΗL
δ18ΟΑ
fad=1
18
δ ΟL δ2ΗΑ
δ2ΗL
δ18ΟL
δ2ΗL
-6.05
6.2
-33.04
-51.36
-15.91
0.07
-11.37
-38.32
-2.29
-40.7
-7.48
4.4
-44.85
-60.48
-17.59
-2.89
-26.44
-47.6
-4.65
-49.4
-6.42
5.66
-37.18
-56.08
-16.24
-0.61
-14.89
-42.29
-2.86
-44.57
-6.69
-7.24
-5.27
-5.78
5.16
4.6
6.52
6.23
-44.48
-39.2
-25.7
-35
-60.98
-58.62
-45.31
-53.61
-16.73
-17.03
-15.08
-15.63
-2.01
-2
-0.2
-0.26
-25.1
-16.52
-3.18
-13.19
-47.53
-43.82
-30.36
-39.7
-3.81
-4.05
-2.17
-2.39
-49.37
-45.89
-32.32
-41.85
-8.7
3.22
-61.15
-73.12
-19.12
-4.72
-46.74
-62.4
-6.23
-63.98
-8.24
3.66
-54.36
-69.62
-18.37
-3.63
-36.19
-56.91
-5.4
-58.74
-8.09
3.17
-57.72
-70.31
-18.51
-5.92
-43.35
-58.07
-6.76
-58.94
-5.15
6.4
-23.44
-43.88
-14.91
-0.61
-0.29
-27.77
-2.38
-29.51
-6.71
-8.88
5.88
5.4
5.64
-25.8
-36.6
-50.6
-50.89
-50.75
-15.69
-22.23
1.76
1.34
1.55
-14.2
-69.46
-45.47
-60.6
-53.03
-1.58
-2.96
-2.27
-48.77
-64.93
-56.85
a: Gat et al., 1996
According to oxygen isotope δ18O literature data, Ismarida and Pikrolimni lakes (Table 1) exhibit the
higher variation in isotope values. This range corresponds to eq. 6 for fad=0, were atmospheric water
vapor in the boundary layer over the lake derive by evaporation, for periods with low water-table and
eq.3 for periods with high water-table. This observation is totally agreed with the hydrological status
of both lakes. Ismarida lake suffers by fresh-seawater mixing process, especially in summer period
840
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
where the meteoric load is reduced (Gemitzi et al., 2014). Pikrolimni lake corresponds to a
hydrological closed system where the extensive evaporation in summer period defines lake water
isotope values (Dotsika et al., 2012). Mygdonia and Kopais basins present lake water isotope values
that correspond better to eq.3 and eq.6 for fad=1 where atmospheric water vapor in the boundary layer
over the lake derives from atmospheric moisture. Detailed, in Mygdonia basin, Koronia lake exhibits
enrichened δ18O value (-4.8‰ VSMOW) compared to that of Volvi lake (-6.6‰ VSMOW) (Chantzi
et al., 2016). Chantzi (2016) reported that a) groundwaters in Mygdonia basin do not present a long
retention time in underground aquifers exhibiting water isotope values close to that of precipitation
and b) they are in hydraulic communication with surface lake water. δ2H/δ18O ratio for both lakes
reflect evaporation processes in their reservoir depending on the seasonality of atmospheric moisture.
Regarding, Kopais basin, Yliki and Paralimni lakes sit within a karstified basin. Karst systems are
more buffered hydrological and consequently less sensitive to evaporation effect (Roberts et al.,
2008). Therefore, it is completely expected that in Kopais basin isotope values of lake waters will be
sensitive to atmospheric moisture with respect to seasonality. Indeed, Griggiths et al., 2002b reported
the limited degree of evaporative concentration of the modern lake waters in Kopais basin. Moreover,
Doirani, Prespa and Ohrid Lakes sit also within karstified basins. Prespa and Ohrid Lakes present
oxygen isotope values more enriched than those from Kopais basin though they are also described by
eqs. 3 and 6 for fad=1. Doirani lake exhibits much more enriched oxygen isotope values which meet
better eq. 6 for fad=0. This agrees with the conclusions by Griggiths et al., 2002a for evaporated lake
water according to modern precipitation data and the extent aridity in Doirani Lake (Ristevski, 1991).
Finally, Sawa lake with oxygen isotope values between 2.5 to 5.9 ‰ VSMOW corresponds better to
eq. 6 for fad=0 confirming its closed hydrological status that suffers by prolonged evaporation losses
as Ali et al., 2016 reported. Based on the aforementioned, it seems that eq. 6 for fad=1 meet better the
measured isotope values in east Mediterranean lake waters. On the other hand, eq. 6 for fad=0 is more
realistic for lake systems that suffer by extensive evaporation and/or fresh-seawater mixing processes.
It should be emphasized that the fad fraction of atmospheric water vapor in the boundary layer over
the lake with values fad=0 and fad=1 reflect the origins of atmospheric water overlying the lake:
evaporation and atmospheric moisture respectively. In fact, the actual mechanism over lake surface
is a continuous refresh where the air above the lake constantly supplies the evaporation process
permitting molecules to pass from the liquid to vapor phase and come away from the lake surface
(Tanny and Cohen, 2006). Without this supply, the evaporation would have stopped. The fact that eq.
6 includes the boundary conditions of the above mechanism with fad factor explains why eq. 6 satisfies
the large variations of the measured lake water isotope values according to literature data. As
previously reported, the isotopic character of Mediterranean precipitation varies depending on the
origin of the air masses and their interaction with the warm Mediterranean. North-east Europe air
masses result in depleted water isotopes while the Atlantic Ocean to less depleted (Rindsberger et al.,
1983). After their interaction with warmer Mediterranean Sea waters (Gat et al., 1996), the
topography in each lake basin determines the extent to which the basin is exposed to the dominant
wind patterns. Finally, eq. 3 corresponds better to the period with high water-table as it cannot render
accurately the evaporation process.
It is concluded that average values from eq. 3 and eq. 6, for both origins of atmospheric water
overlying the lake, are the modeled lake water isotope values for closed hydrological lake systems in
the eastern Mediterranean area. Figure 1 displays literature data of measured lake water isotope values
in the eastern Mediterranean and the calculated data according to limnological isotope theory. It
should be underlined that calculated deuterium isotope data δ2HL for lake waters do not present large
variation with respect to precipitation data (Table 5). Ozaydin et al., 2001 reported that deuterium
mass balance does not correspond well to sub-basin inflow and outflow load. Gat et al., 1996 reported
the constant deuterium sea water values with respect to salinity and oxygen isotopes in measured
samples in several Mediterranean Sea stations. He attributed this observation to the mixing process
between the isotopically depleted north European precipitation values with enriched Mediterranean
vapors. Subsequently, it is evident the large discrimination of d-excess between measured and
modeled isotope values (Figure 1). This large deuterium excess corresponds to the theoretical static
841
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
model for the estimation of lake water isotope values under the evaporation process only in closed
lake systems. Greater d-excess attributed to air masses in continental areas, due to extensive seawater
evaporation under moisture deficit (Gat and Carmi, 1970; Gat et al., 2003). Actually, d-excess is
linked to physical conditions such as moisture, air and sea surface temperature of the oceanic origin
and reflect the dominant conditions in interaction and mixing process as sea water air masses move
to precipitation site (Merlivat and Jouzel, 1979). It is a parameter that affected by kinetic fractionation
process which depends on moisture source areas (oceanic evaporation), cloud (condensation in
supersaturation conditions) and sub-cloud layer (re-evaporation of falling raindrops, moisture
exchange with ambient air). Detailed, Mediterranean Sea discriminates against open oceans as it is
surrounded by continental areas with considerable freshwater run-off. The evaporation process is
affected by continental air flow pattern that originates from isotopically depleted north Europe
precipitation. This interaction between sea and continental air masses results in the large deuterium
excess that characterizes the Mediterranean Sea. Generally, in eastern Mediterranean d-excess has
been reported between 15‰ (Gat and Dansgaard, 1972; Bowen and Revenaugh, 2003) and 22‰ (Gat
and Carmi, 1970). So, the moisture recycling and mixing during a precipitation event define the
isotopic signature of vapor in the cloud and sub-cloud layers mainly throughout a convective event
[Bony et al., 2008]. This process covers the distance between measure isotope values from literature
data and calculated isotope values for lake waters (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Deuterium (δ2H‰ VSMOW) and oxygen (δ18O‰ VSMOW) isotope values that
correspond to measured values from literature data and calculated values from Global
Network of Isotopes in Precipitation (GNIP) (IAEA/WMO, 2017) for the east Mediterranean:
Eastern Mediterranean Meteoric Water Line δ2Η=8δ18Ο+22 (International Atomic Energy
Agency, IAEA, 2001; Bowen and Revenaugh, 2003; Aouad et al., 2004); Local Meteoric Water
Line δ2Η=8.7δ18Ο+19.5 (Dotsika et al., 2010; Global Meteoric Water Line δ2Η=8δ18Ο+10
(Craig,H.,1961).
Lakes with measured isotope data present δ2H/δ18O ratio about 5.4 while those that their isotope
values estimated by isotope mass balance present δ2H/δ18O ratio about 5.9. Both ratios are similar
with strong correlation factor. We should note that δ2H/δ18O ratio of calculated values describes only
hydrological closed lake systems. It is a moderate mean theoretical ratio for closed eastern
Mediterranean lake systems considering both equilibrium and kinetic fractionation factors under the
evaporation process. However, the δ2H/δ18O ratio is a key factor for theoretical values. Literature data
δ2H/δ18O ratio is lower than that of calculated data. This is because literature data include Ismarida
lake that is characterized by the fresh-seawater process, mainly in summer. Isolating Ismarida lake
the δ2H/δ18O ratio becomes 5.6 closer to the theoretical ratio for continental lake systems.
842
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Furthermore, Gat et al., 1996 performed a large sample collection on shipboard in several
Mediterranean Sea stations resulting in water isotope data of Mediterranean Sea water and
precipitation in these stations. Using precipitation data, we calculated lake water values that better
response to coastal and transitional systems. Considering these calculated values, the theoretical
δ2H/δ18O ratio becomes 5.1 closer to measured values when we consider Ismarida lake. Moreover
Gat et al., 1996 reported the slope of Local Evaporation Line (MLEL) for the eastern Mediterranean
Sea about 4.3. δ2H/δ18O ratio for precipitation data is about 8.0 (Mediterranean Meteoric Water Line
to 8.7 (Local Meteoric Water Line). Therefore, we conclude that δ2H/δ18O ratio is a robust index to
monitor the response of lake systems to climate events. Based on the topographical and hydrological
characteristics of lake systems we can estimate the δ2H/δ18O ratio and compare it with the theoretical
values estimated for the eastern Mediterranean lakes resulting in conclusions about the intensification
or recession of evaporation process. So, the δ2H/δ18O ratio of measured data in lake systems is a
quantitative method to estimate climate change impact to lake systems.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
The main objective of present work was to quantify the response of lake systems in climate variation
based on isotope mass balance. It is concluded that isotope limnology theory corresponds well to
different lake water systems. Eq. 6 for fad=1 meet better the measured isotope values in east
Mediterranean lake waters. On the other hand, eq. 6 for fad=0 is more realistic for lake systems that
suffer by extensive evaporation and/or fresh-seawater mixing process. The different fad=0,1
fractionation factors characterize the origin of atmospheric water vapor in the boundary layer over
the lake (evaporation and atmospheric moisture). In fact, the actual mechanism is a continuous refresh
where the air above the lake constantly supplies the evaporation process permitting molecules to pass
from the liquid to vapor phase and come away from the lake surface. The fact that eq. 6 includes the
above mechanism explains why eq. 6 responds successfully to lake water isotope values covering a
large range of eastern Mediterranean lake systems. Moreover eq. 3 corresponds better to the period
with high water-table as it cannot render accurately the evaporation process. Lakes with measured
isotope data present δ2H/δ18O ratio about 5.4 while those that their isotope values estimated by isotope
mass balance present δ2H/δ18O ratio about 5.9. Both ratios are similar with strong correlation factor.
The δ2H/δ18O ratio for theoretical values represents hydrological closed systems in the continental
eastern Mediterranean area where isotopically depleted north Europe precipitation events and air
masses from seawater interact. Measured lake water values present a δ2H/δ18O ratio about 5.4, lower
than that of calculated. This is because it includes different hydrological systems. Isolating Ismarida
lake as it suffers by fresh-seawater mixing process, then δ2H/δ18O ratio becomes 5.6 closer to the
theoretical ratio for continental lake systems. Considering calculated values for lake waters based on
precipitation data in several stations in the Mediterranean Sea, the theoretical δ2H/δ18O ratio becomes
5.1 closer to measured values when we consider Ismarida lake. Moreover Gat et al., 1996 reported
the slope of Local Evaporation Line (MLEL) for the eastern Mediterranean Sea about 4.3. δ2H/δ18O
ratio for precipitation data is about 8.0 (MMWL) to 8.7 (LMWL). Therefore, we conclude that
δ2H/δ18O ratio is a robust index to monitor the response of lake systems to climate events. We can
estimate the δ2H/δ18O ratio for lake systems with different topographical and hydrological
characteristics and compare it with the theoretical values that came up for the eastern Mediterranean
lakes resulting in conclusions about the intensification or recession of evaporation process. So, the
δ2H/δ18O ratio of measured data in lake systems is a quantitative method to estimate climate change
impact to lake systems.
NOTES
This paper is part of first author’s PostDoctoral Research entitled “Research of climate impact in the
evolution of lake systems using isotope hydrology models” in Geology School of the Aristotle
University of Thessaloniki.
843
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
References
1. Aouad, A., Travi, Y., Blavoux, B., Job, J.-O., Najem, W., 2004. Isotope study of snow and rain
on Mount Lebanon: preliminary results. Hydrological Sciences Journal 49 (3), 429-441.
2. Benson, L.V., White, J.W.C., 1994. Stable isotopes of oxygen and hydrogen in the Truckee River
Pyramid Lake surface-water system 3. Source of water-vapour overlying Pyramid Lake.
Limnol. Oceanogr. 39, 1945-1958.
3. Bony, S., C. Risi, and F. Vimeux (2008), Influence of convective processes on the isotopic
composition (delta O-18 and delta D) of precipitation and water vapor in the tropics: 1. Radiativeconvective equilibrium and Tropical Ocean-Global Atmosphere-Coupled Ocean-Atmosphere
Response Experiment (TOGA-COARE) simulations, J. Geophys. Res, 113, D19305.
4. Bowen, G.J., Revenaugh, J., 2003. Interpolating the isotopic composition of modern meteoric
precipitation. Water Resources Research 39, 10 art. no 1299.
5. Chantzi, P., & Dotsika, E., 2016. Mygdonia Basin (N. Greece) in the View of Isotope
Geochemistry BT - Energy, Transportation and Global Warming. In P. Grammelis (Ed.), (pp.
677-683). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
6. Craig, H., 1961. Isotopic variations in meteoric waters. Science 133, 1702-1703.
7. Craig, H., Gordon, L.I., 1965. Deuterium and oxygen-18 variation in the ocean and marine
atmosphere. Stable isotopes in Oceanography Studies and Paleotemperatures. Laboratorio
di Geologia Nucleare, Pisa.
8. Dotsika, E., Lykoudis, S., Poutoukis, D., 2010b. Spatial distribution of the isotopic composition
of precipitation and spring water in Greece. Glob. Planet. Chang. 71, 141–149.
9. Dotsika E., Tzavidopoulos I., Poutoukis D., Raco B., Maniatis Y., Ignatiadou D., 2012. Isotope
contents, Cl/Br ratio and origin of water at Pikrolimni Lake: A natron source in Greece, as archive
of past environmental conditions, Quaternary International, Volume 266, Pages 74-80
10. Eftimi R., Amataj S., Zoto J., 2007. Groundwater circulation in two transboundary carbonate
aquifers of Albania; their vulnerability and protection. In Selected Papers on Hydrogeology Vol
11: Taylor & Fracis Group, London, UK, p.p. 199-212.
11. Engineering ToolBox, 2004. Relative Humidity in Air. [online]
https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/relative-humidity-air-d_687.html
Available
at:
12. Flocas, A.A., Giles, B.D., 1991. Distribution and intensity of frontal rainfall over Greece.
International Journal of Climatology 11, 429-442.
13. Gat, J.R., Carmi, I., 1970. Evolution of the isotopic composition of the atmospheric water in the
Mediterranean Sea area. Journal of Geophysical Research 75, 3039-3048.
14. Gat, J.R., Dansgaard, W., 1972. Stable isotope survey of the freshwater occurrences in Israel and
the Jordan Rift Valley. Journal of Hydrology 16, 177–211.
15. Gat JR, Shemesh A, Tziperman E, Hecht A, Georgopoulos D, Basturk O, 1996. The stable isotope
composition of waters of the eastern Mediterranean Sea. Journal of Geophysical ResearchOceansJournal of Geophysical Research-Oceans, 101, 6441-6451
16. Gat, J.R., Klein, B., Kushnir, Y., Roether, W., Wernli, H., Yam, R., Shemesh, A., 2003. Isotope
composition of air moisture over the Mediterranean Sea: an index of the air-sea interaction. Tellus
55B, 959-965.
17. Gemitzi A., Stefanopoulos K., Markantonis M., Richnow H., 2014. Seawater intrusion into
groundwater aquifer through a coastal lake - complex interaction characterised by water isotopes
2
H and 18O. Isotopes in Environmental Health Studies. 50.
844
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
18. Gibson, J.J., Edwards, T.W.D., Prowse, T.D., 1999. Pan-derived isotopic composition of
atmospheric water vapor and its variability in northern Canada. J. Hydrol. 217, 55-74.
19. Giorgi 2006, Climate change hot-spots. Geophysical Research Letters, Vol. 33, L08707
20. Gonfiantini, R., 1986. Environmental isotopes in lake studies. In: Fritz, P., Fontes, J.-C. (Eds.),
Handbook of Environmental Isotope Geochemistry Volume 2B. Elsevier, Amsterdam.
21. Griffiths H.I., Reed J.M., Leng M.J., Ryan S., Petkovski S., 2002a. The recent palaeoecology and
conservation status of Balkan Lake Dojran, Biological Conservation, Volume 104, Issue 1, Pages
35-49
22. Griffiths S. J., Street-Perrott F. A., Holmes J. A., Leng M. J., Tzedakis C., 2002b. Chemical and
isotopic composition of modern water bodies in the Lake Kopais Basin, central Greece: analogues
for the interpretation of the lacustrine sedimentary sequence, Sedimentary Geology, Volume
148, Issues 1-2, Pages 79-103
23. Hoerling, M., Eischeid, J., Perlwitz, J., Quan, X., Zhang, T., Pegion, P., 2012. On the Increased
Frequency of Mediterranean Drought, J. Climate, 25, 2146-2161.
24. International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), 2001. GNIP Maps and Animations. International
Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna.
25. IAEA/WMO, 2017. Global Network of Isotopes in Precipitation. The GNIP Database. Accessible
at: https://nucleus.iaea.org/wiser
26. IPCC, 2013: Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group
I to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Stocker,
T.F., D. Qin, G.-K. Plattner, M. Tignor, S.K. Allen, J. Boschung, A. Nauels, Y. Xia, V. Bex and
P.M. Midgley (eds.)]. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New
York, NY, USA, 1535 pp
27. Kelley, C., Ting, M.F., Seager. R. & Kushnir. Y 2012. The relative contributions of radiative
forcing and internal climate variability to the late 20th century winter drying of the Mediterranean
region. Climate Dynamics 38(9-10): 2001-15.
28. Leng, M.J., Marshall, J.D., 2004. Palaeoclimate interpretation of stable isotope data from lake
sediment archives. Quat. Sci. Rev. 23, 811-831.
29. Lelieveld. J., Hadjinicolaou. P., Kostopoulou. E. et al. 2012. Climate change and impacts in the
eastern Mediterranean and the Middle East. Climatic Change 1 14(3-4): 667-87.
30. Linacre E., 1992. Climate Data and Resources: A Reference and Guide. Routledge, London, p.366
31. Majoube, F., 1971. Fractionnement en oxygène-18 et un deutérium entre l'eau et sa vapeur. J.
Chim. Phys. 187, 1423-1436.
32. Mariotti, A., Zeng, N., Yoon, J.-H., Artale, V., Navarra, A., Alpert, P., Li, L. Z. X., 2008.
Mediterranean water cycle changes: Transition to drier 21st century conditions in observations
and CMIP3 simulations, Environ. Res. Lett., 3, 044001.
33. Merlivat, L., Jouzel, J., 1979. Global climatic interpretation of the D-18O relationship for
precipitation. J. Geophys. Res. 84, 5029-5033.
34. Özaydin V. & Şendil U., Altinbilek D., 2001. Stable isotope mass balance method to find the
water budget of a lake. Turkish Journal of Engin. and Environmental Sciences. 25. 329-344
35. Penman H.L., 1948. Natural evaporation from open water, bare soil and grass. Proc. Roy. Soc.
A. 193: 120-145.
36. Ricketts, R.D., Johnson, T.C., 1996. Climate change in the Turkana basin as deduced from a 4000year long delta O-18 record. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 142, 7-17.
845
Protection and restoration of ecosystems
37. Rindsberge Mr., Jaffe S., Rahamin S., Gat J., 1990. Patterns of the isotopic composition of
precipitation in time and space data from Israeli storm collection program, Tellus, 42B, 263-271.
38. Ristevski, P., 1991. Areal and time distribution of air temperature and precipitation in the region
of Gevgelija and Valandovo. In: Gasevski, M. (Ed.), [Sostojbite i perspectivite za zasˇtita na
Dojranskoto ezero. Zbornik na trudovi od sovetvanjeto vo Star Dojran.]. Dvizˇenje na
Ekologistite na Makedonija, Skopje, pp. 26–35. (in Macedonian with English abstract).
39. Roberts N., Jones M.D., Benkaddour A., Eastwood W.J., Filippi M.L., Frogley M.R., Lamb H.F.,
Leng M.J., Reed J.M., Stein M., Stevens L., Valero-Garcés B., Zanchetta G., 2008. Stable isotope
records of Late Quaternary climate and hydrology from Mediterranean lakes: the ISOMED
synthesis, Quaternary Science Reviews, Volume 27, Issues 25-26, Pages 2426-2441.
40. Seager. R., Liu. H.B., Henderson. N. et al. 2014. Causes of increasing aridification of the
Mediterranean region in response to rising greenhouse gases. journal of Climate 27(12): 465576.
41. Tanny, J., Cohen, J., 2006. Revisiting the boundary layer structure used in Craig and Gordon's
model of isotope fractionation in evaporation, International Workshop on the Isotope Effects
in Evaporation, Pisa, Italy, pp. 11-21.
846
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Soft and renewable energy sources
847
Soft and renewable energy sources
848
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
A NUMERICAL TOOL FOR THE TIME-DOMAIN ANALYSIS OF
FLOATING WAVE ENERGY CONVERTERS
N. Mantadakis* and E. Loukogeorgaki
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th, GR54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: mantadaki@civil.auth.gr, tel: +302310995951
Abstract
In the present paper, a computational tool (FloaTWEC tool) is developed for the time-domain analysis
of a floating oscillating-body Wave Energy Converter (WEC). Assuming a floating body with six
rigid-body modes, the WEC’s response is calculated based on the well-known Cummins equation,
where fluid memory effects are captured through appropriate convolution terms. The required
frequency-dependent excitation loads and hydrodynamic coefficients, as well as the hydrostaticgravitational coefficients are obtained using a standard hydrodynamics (waves-floating structure
interaction) software. The Power-Take-Off (PTO) mechanism can be modeled as a linear or nonlinear system, while mooring lines can be considered as additional stiffness forces. The equation of
motion is solved using the Newmark implicit time integration scheme, whereas the analysis can be
implemented under the action of regular and irregular waves, assuming motion in all or appropriately
selected rigid-body modes. FloaTWEC is, initially, validated through comparison of results with
numerical and experimental results of other investigators for three different floating structures. Then,
it is applied for the case of a heaving WEC with a linear PTO for: (a) assessing its response and its
power absorption under the action of regular and irregular waves of different characteristics and (b)
investigating the effect of the stiffness of the mooring lines on its performance.
Keywords: wave energy; wave energy converters; time-domain analysis; Cummins equation;
absorbed power
1.
INTRODUCTION
Wave energy presents an abundant renewable energy source, characterized by higher energy density,
compared to other ocean renewable energy forms, limited negative environmental impact in use and
larger consistency due to natural seasonal variability (Drew et al., 2009). Its efficient harnessing can
contribute to the satisfaction of the European Union’s decarbonisation targets, while it can support
energy security and long-term economic growth (e.g. Magagna & Uihlein, 2015). The above have
fostered, nowadays, the development of the wave energy sector and, so far, a variety of different types
of Wave Energy Converters (WECs) exists (Drew et al., 2009; de O Falcão, 2010). Floating
oscillating-body devices (e.g. floating heaving WECs), absorbing energy based on the relevant
translation or rotational WEC’s motion, present a characteristic WEC type that can be deployed in
deep waters in order to exploit the corresponding more powerful wave regimes.
The successful design of such WECs requires the development and the application of numerical tools
enabling the investigation and the accurate assessment of their performance (hydrodynamic behavior
and absorbed power) and, therefore, the efficient handling of existing design challenges. Under this
framework, several numerical tools for the hydrodynamic analysis of floating oscillating-body WECs
have been and are still being developed (Folley, 2016). Most of these tools are based on the linear
wave theory and they enable the implementation of the required analysis in frequency domain by
849
Soft and renewable energy sources
linearizing the hydrodynamic problem and the floating system (e.g. Babarit, 2010; Schay et al., 2013;
Pastor & Liu, 2014). Although frequency-domain numerical tools are characterized by low
computational time, they cannot model adequately non-linear effects resulting from different sources
(e.g. existence of complex Power-Take-Off (PTO) mechanisms and highly nonlinear relevant control
strategies). For overcoming this barrier, time-domain numerical tools should be deployed (e.g.
Eriksson et al., 2005; Pastor & Liu, 2014).
Motivated by this, in the present paper a computational tool (FloaTWEC tool) is developed for the
time-domain analysis of a floating oscillating-body WEC. Assuming that the floating body is rigid
with six Degrees of Freedom (DOFs), the WEC’s response is calculated based on the Cummins
equation (Cummins, 1962). The required (input to FloaTWEC) frequency-dependent excitation loads
(forces and moments) and hydrodynamic coefficients, as well as the hydrostatic-gravitational
stiffness coefficients are obtained using a standard hydrodynamics (waves-floating structure
interaction) software, which is based on the linear potential theory. The PTO force can be considered
in FloaTWEC using either a linear or non-linear model, while mooring lines can be represented as
additional stiffness forces. The equation of motion is solved using the Newmark implicit time
integration scheme. The analysis can be implemented under the action of regular and irregular waves
considering all or appropriately selected DOFs. FloaTWEC is initially validated through comparison
of results with numerical and experimental results of other investigators for a variety of floating
structures. Then, it is applied for the case of a heaving WEC with a linear PTO in order to: (a) assess
its response and its power absorption under the action of regular and irregular waves of different
characteristics and (b) examine the effect of the stiffness of the mooring lines on its performance.
2.
NUMERICAL FORMULATION
A floating oscillating-body WEC of draft h is placed in an area of constant water depth d, as shown
in Figure 1, where indicatively a floating heaving cylindrical WEC of diameter D is considered. In
this figure, OXYZ corresponds to the global coordinate system, while the PTO is schematically
presented as a damping mechanism.
Incident
wave
direction
Z
Mean Water Level
(MWL)
Y
θ
X
O
h
D
d
Mooring
lines
PTO
Figure 1. Coordinate system and definition of basic quantities (the cylindrical floating body
and mooring lines’ position are indicative).
The general procedure applied in the present paper for implementing time-domain analysis of the
aforementioned WEC using FloaTWEC is shown in Figure 2. At first, frequency-domain analysis is
implemented for calculating the frequency-dependent wave excitation loads and hydrodynamic
coefficients (added mass and radiation damping), as well as the hydrostatic-gravitational stiffness
850
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
coefficients, which are required as input in FloaTWEC. Next, for given incident wave conditions
(regular or irregular waves of direction θ, Figure 1) as well as for specific PTO and mooring lines’
characteristics, the equation of motion in time domain is solved and all quantities describing the
performance (e.g. response, power absorption etc) of the examined WEC are calculated. In the
following sub-sections, a short description of the frequency-domain analysis is, initially, given
focusing on the quantities required as input in FloaTWEC, while a detailed description of the timedomain numerical formulation follows. FloaTWEC was developed using Python.
Frequency-domain
analysis
- Excitation loads
- Added mass & radiation
damping
- Hydrostatic-gravitational
stiffness
FloaTWEC
Time-domain analysis
Performance of
WEC
Geometry
Water depth,
wave
frequencies
Incident wave
characteristics
Mass of the
floating body
PTO
characteristics
Mooring lines’
characteristics
Figure 2. Flowchart for implementing time-domain analysis using FloaTWEC.
2.1 Frequency-domain hydrodynamic analysis
The frequency-domain hydrodynamic analysis of the WEC subjected to incident regular waves is
implemented using WAMIT software (Lee, 1995). The analysis is based on a 3D linear wave
diffraction theory, where the floating body is also taken to undergo small oscillations in all six DOFs
(rigid-body modes), corresponding to three translations (surge, sway and heave) and three rotations
(roll, pitch and yaw) along and around X, Y and Z axes respectively. Assuming inviscid and
incompressible fluid and irrotational flow, the fluid motion is described in terms of a complex velocity
potential, which satisfies the Laplace equation everywhere in the fluid region and consists of three
components: the velocity potential of the incident waves, the scattered potential associated with the
disturbance of the incident waves by the floating body and the radiation potential related to the waves
radiated from the body due to its motions. The solution of the 1st order boundary value problem is
based on a direct computational method (3D panel method) utilizing the free-surface Green function
and imposing the appropriate boundary conditions on the free surface, the sea bottom and the floating
body (Lee, 1995).
Having solved the boundary value problem, the excitation loads, Fi, i=1,…,6 and the added mass and
radiation damping coefficients, Aij, Bij i, j=1,…,6 are calculated using the following equations:
Fi i w
1
SB
Aij i Bij
niD dS
SB
(1)
ni j dS
(2)
where ω and ζw are the incident wave frequency and the unit wave amplitude respectively, ρ is the
mass density of the water, D is the diffracted (incident plus scattered) potential, j, j=1,..,6 is the
851
Soft and renewable energy sources
radiation potential of the jth DOF, (n1, n2, n3)=n, with n the unit vector normal on the body’s wetted
surface SB, and (n4, n5, n6)= x×n, with x = (x, y, z).
Finally, it is noted that the hydrostatic-gravitational stiffness coefficients, Cij, i,j=1,…,6 are obtained
from WAMIT considering the mean wetted surface of the floating body (Lee, 1995).
2.2 Time-domain analysis
Assuming linear behavior and considering impulses in the components of motion, Cummins (1962)
obtained a vector integro-differential equation (known as the Cummins equation) for describing the
motion of a floating structure in time domain under the action of waves. In the case of a WEC shown
in Figure 1 this equation can be written as follows:
M ξ (t )
Fexc (t ) Frad (t ) B E ξ (t ) K E C ξ (t )
(3)
where t is time, M is the 6x6 mass matrix of the floating body, Fexc is the 6x1 matrix of the wave
excitation loads, Frad is the 6x6 matrix of the radiation loads, BE is the 6x6 damping matrix caused
by an external source (e.g. PTO mechanism), KE and C are the 6x6 stiffness matrices due to an
external source (e.g. mooring lines) and due to hydrostatic-gravitational forces respectively, while
ξ ,ξ and ξ are the 6x1 matrices of the floating body’s motions, velocities and accelerations
respectively.
Considering the action of irregular waves, for a given sea state described by a spectrum with
significant wave height Hs, and peak period Tp, Fexc and Frad (Taghipour et al., 2008) are given by the
following equations:
Fexc (t ) 2 F ( ) S ( ) cos(t ) d
(4)
Frad (t ) A () ξ (t ) K (t ) ξ (t ) d
(5)
0
t
In Equation 4, |F(ω)| is the 6x1 matrix of the amplitude of the complex wave excitation loads as
obtained from the frequency domain analysis (Equation 1), S(ω) is the spectral density of the
examined spectrum and ε [0, 2π], is the phase of each wave excitation component in the spectrum.
In Equation 5, A(∞) is the 6x6 added mass matrix corresponding to infinite frequency, with
coefficients calculated using Equation 2, τ is an auxiliary (dummy) time variable, while K is called
the “retardation function” and can be calculated as follows (Taghipour et al., 2008):
K (t ) 2 / Β( ) cos(t ) d
(6)
0
where B is the 6x6 frequency-dependent radiation damping matrix with coefficients calculated using
Equation 2. The last term in the right hand side of Equation 5 is the well-known convolution integral,
which based on Equation 6 represents the load contribution from the wave radiation damping. This
convolution also captures the so-called “fluid memory effects”; namely, the fact that changes in the
momentum of the fluid at a particular time affect the motion at the subsequent time.
On the other hand, in the case of an incident regular wave of amplitude A and frequency ω, Fexc and
Frad are simplified as follows:
Fexc (t ) A F( ) cos(t )
(7)
Frad (t ) A( ) ξ (t ) Β( ) ξ (t )
(8)
852
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
where A is the 6x6 frequency-dependent added mass matrix, with coefficients calculated using
Equation 2.
The equation of motion in time-domain (Equation 3) is solved in FloaTWEC using the Newmark beta
implicit time integration scheme with parameters α and β equal to 1/2 and 1/6 respectively (linear
acceleration method), and the response of the WEC (e.g. motions, velocities) are calculated. The
power absorbed by the WEC, P, can be, then, obtained depending on the WEC’s working direction
and the PTO mechanism. For example, in the case of a heaving WEC and a PTO modeled as a linear
damping system, with damping coefficient bpto, P is calculated as follows:
P(t ) b pto ξ(t )
2
(9)
It is noted that the analysis can be implemented considering motion in all DOFs or in specific DOFs
(the rest ones are assumed ideally restricted), while in the case of irregular waves a sea state can be
described by deploying either the Jonswap or the Pierson-Moskowitz spectrum (DNV-GL, 2017).
Finally, FloaTWEC is capable for calculating the natural period of each ith, i=1,…,6, DOF of the
floating body through the following equation:
Tni 2
3.
M
ii
Aii ( ni )
Cii K ii
E
i 1,..., 6
(10)
COMPARISON WITH NUMERICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
The FloaTWEC tool developed in this work is applied for the case of three different floating structures
in order to compare results with numerical and experimental results of other investigators.
The first floating structure corresponds to the free heaving cylinder of Watai et al. (2015), which has
h=1 m, D=2 m (Figure 1) and mass equal to 3140 kg. The cylinder is placed in an area of infinite
water depth, while the action of head (θ=0 deg, Figure 1) regular waves is considered. Indicatively,
in Figure 3, part of the time series of the computed heave excitation force, Fexc3, and heave
displacement, ξ3, are compared with the corresponding numerical results of Watai et al. (2015) for
Η=2 m and ω=4.202 rad/sec (Figure 3a), 9.905 rad/sec (Figure 3b) and 2.51 rad/sec (Figure 3c).
Moreover, Figure 3d shows the comparison of the computed Response Amplitude Operator in heave,
RAO3, (defined as the ratio of the ξ3 amplitude to A) with the corresponding results of Watai et al.
(2015). In the case of FloaTWEC, RAO3 has been obtained via the Fast Fourier Transformation
(FFT). It can be clearly seen that there is an excellent agreement between the present numerical results
and the corresponding ones of Watai et al. (2015).
The second floating structure examined in this work corresponds to the heaving WEC of Eriksson et
al. (2005). The WEC consists of a partially submerged cylinder tethered above a linear PTO located
on the seafloor. The PTO is connected by a spring of stiffness ks to the tether and it is modeled as a
linear damping system, with damping coefficient bpto. The tether, on the other hand, is modeled as a
rigid bar, assuming that the spring force is large enough to keep the tether stretched. Therefore, the
spring’s stiffness is assumed representative for the stiffness of the WEC’s mooring system. In order
to compare results, FloaTWEC is applied for the case, where the cylinder has h=1.5 m, D=4 m (Figure
1) and mass equal to 800 kg and it is placed in an area of constant water depth d=23 m. Moreover,
based on Eriksson et al. (2005), Equation 3 is solved with K33E=ks=3000 N/m and B33E=bpto=4000
N*sec/m. Considering the action of irregular waves described by the Jonswap spectrum with
Hs=1.175 m and Tp=2.228 sec, the time series of ξ3 computed using FloaTWEC agrees very well with
the corresponding one of Eriksson et al. (2005), as shown in Figure 4. The initial small phase-lag
observed between the time series of Figure 4 may be attributed to the consideration of different initial
conditions in FloaTWEC compared to Eriksson et al. (2005).
853
Soft and renewable energy sources
2000
4
(a): =4.202 rad/sec
2
Fexc3 (N)
Fexc3 (N)
1000
0
-1000
-2000
(b): =9.905 rad/sec
0
-2
5
7.5
10
12.5
-4
15
3
3.5
4
t (sec)
Watai et al. (2015)
6
RAO3 (m/m)
3 (m)
1
0
-1
-3
142
144
146
5
5.5
6 6.3
FloaTWEC
5
(c): =2.51 rad/sec
3
-5
140
4.5
t (sec)
148
150
4
(d)
3
2
1
0
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
t (sec)
(rad/sec)
Figure 3. Comparison of Fexc3 and ξ3 time series and of RAO3 with the corresponding results
of Watai et al. (2015).
0.6
0.4
3 (m)
0.2
0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
47 48
50
52
54
56
58
Eriksson et al. (2005)
FloaTWEC
60
62
64
66
t (sec)
Figure 4. Comparison of ξ3 time series with the corresponding results of Eriksson et al. (2005)
for Hs=1.175 m and Tp=2.228 sec.
854
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Finally, FloaTWEC is applied for the case of a horizontal floating cylindrical WEC in order to
compare results with the experimental and the numerical ones of Chen at al. (2016). Considering a
geometrical scale 1/10, the cylinder in the physical model has h=0.1 m, D=0.2 m (Figure 1), length
and mass equal to 1 m and 25.7 kg respectively, while the PTO corresponds to a linear damping
system. The experiments were conducted for d=1 m under the action of regular head waves. It is
noted that the numerical model of Chen at al. (2016) is based on the finite element and Volume of
Fluid (VOF) methods for incompressible viscous flow. In Figure 5, the time series of ξ3 computed
with FloaTWEC are compared with the corresponding experimental and numerical results of Chen at
al. (2016) for the case of ω=4.187 rad/sec and H=0.05 m (Figure 5a), and 0.10 m (Figure 5b) and for
B33E=bpto=100 N*sec/m (Chen at al., 2016). It is clear that the application of FloaTWEC results to ξ3
values which are very close to the experimental results of Chen at al. (2016). Moreover, the agreement
with the experimental results is greatly improved in the case of FloaTWEC compared to the numerical
model of Chen at al. (2016), illustrating the accuracy and the efficiency of the tool developed in the
present paper.
Numerical Chen et al. (2016)
0.03
Experimental Chen et al. (2016)
0.06
(a): H=0.05 m, =4.187 rad/sec
0.01
0.02
3 (m)
0.04
3 (m)
0.02
0
-0.02
-0.02
-0.04
4
5
6
7
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
t (sec)
(b): H=0.10 m, =4.187 rad/sec
0
-0.01
-0.03
FloaTWEC
-0.06
5
6
7
8
9
10
11 12
13
14
t (sec)
Figure 5. Comparison of ξ3 time series with the corresponding experimental and numerical
results of Chen et al. (2016).
4.
FLOATWEC APPLICATION
The developed in the present paper FloaTWEC tool is further applied for the case of the heaving
WEC of Eriksson et al. (2005) in order to: (a) assess the response and the power absorption of this
WEC under the action of regular and irregular waves of different characteristics and (b) examine the
effect of the spring stiffness on the WEC’s performance. In all the examined cases, the WEC has the
geometric characteristics mentioned in Section 3 and it is placed in an area of constant water depth
equal to 23 m. Moreover, based on Eriksson et al. (2005), Equation 3 is solved with B33E=bpto=4000
N*sec/m assuming all DOFs ideally restricted, except the one corresponding to heave (i.e. the motion
along the WEC’s working direction). All simulations are performed for 300 sec with a time step of
0.1 sec.
855
Soft and renewable energy sources
30
1
(a)
3 (m/sec)
Fexc3 (kN)
20
10
0
0.5
0
.
-10
-0.5
-20
-30
150
(b)
155
160
165
-1
150
170
155
160
t (sec)
4
P abs (kW)
165
170
t (sec)
(c)
3
T=2.0 sec
T=2.5 sec
T=3.0 sec
2
1
0
150
155
160
165
170
t (sec)
Figure 6. Effect of T on Fexc3, ξ3 and P for the case of the examined heaving WEC.
In the case of regular waves, H is taken constant and equal to 1.5 m, while three different T values
are investigated equal to 2.0, 2.5 and 3.0 sec. For these three different H and T combinations, the
equation of motion is solved for K33E=ks=3000 N/m. Figure 6 shows the effect of T on the heave
excitation force, Fexc3 (Figure 6a), on the heave velocity, ξ3 (Figure 6b) and on the power P absorbed
by the WEC (Figure 6c). Regarding Fexc3 (Figure 6a), it can be seen that by increasing T (i.e. transition
to longer waves) larger values of Fexc3 are observed in consistency with the real physical problem. On
the other hand, in the case of the heave velocity (Figure 6b), the largest ξ3 values are obtained for
T=2 sec, while the subsequent increase of T leads to a smooth reduction of the WEC’s response
(12.8% and 21.3% reduction of maximum ξ3 values for T=2.5 and 3.0 sec respectively with respect
to T=2.0 sec). This is attributed to the fact that resonance phenomena occur approximately at T=2.0
sec, since the natural period of the examined WEC in heave, Tn3, (Equation 10) is equal to 2.083 sec.
As for the power absorbed by the WEC (Figure 6c), the increase of T leads to a reduction of P (23.1%
and 38% reduction of maximum P values for T=2.5 and 3.0 sec respectively with respect to T=2.0
sec) in absolute accordance with Figure 6b.
Considering the action of irregular waves, focus is given on the effect of Tp and of the mooring lines’
stiffness on the WEC’s performance. For this purpose, two sea states with Hs=1.175 m and Tp equal
to 2.228 sec and 4.0 sec are taken into account, while simulations are performed for three different
values of the spring’s stiffness, ks, (representing the stiffness of the WEC’s mooring system as
mentioned in Section 3). The first value, ksinitial, is set equal to 3000 N/m as in Section 3, while the
other two values are set equal to 0.25* ksinitial=750 N/m and 4*ksinitial=12000 N/m.
Regarding the effect of Tp on Fexc3, ξ3 and P (Figure 7), analogous conclusions can be drawn as in
the case of regular waves. Specifically, the increase of Tp leads to an increase of Fexc3 (absolute
maximum Fexc3 values for Tp=2.228 and 4.0 sec are equal to 10 kN and 39.2 kN respectively) and to
a more intense variation of this quantity. On the other hand, by increasing Tp a reduction of both ξ3
(48.8% reduction of the absolute maximum ξ3 value relevant to Tp=2.228 sec) and P (73.8% and
856
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
40
30
20
10
0
-10
-20
-30
-40
(a)
3 (m/sec)
Fexc3 (kN)
63.1% reduction of maximum and mean P values respectively relevant to Tp=2.228 sec) is observed,
since resonance phenomena are pronounced in the case of Tp=2.228 sec.
.
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
-0.5
-1
-1.5
-2
(b)
0
50
100
P abs (kW)
t (sec)
150
200
250
300
t (sec)
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
(c)
Tp =2.228 sec
Tp =4 sec
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
t (sec)
Figure 7. Effect of Tp on Fexc3, ξ3 and P for the case of the examined heaving WEC with
ks=3000 N/m.
As for the effect of ks on the performance of the WEC (Figure 8), the time series of ξ3 and P for
ks=750 N/m do not show significant differences compared to the corresponding time series for
ks=3000 N/m. Thus, the decrease of ks from 3000 N/m to 750 N/m has a minor effect on the WEC’s
performance. This is attributed to the fact that ks=750 N/m leads to Tn3=2.098 sec, which is almost
equal to the heave natural period (2.083 sec) obtained for ks=3000 N/m. The above do not hold true
in the case of ks=12000 N/m, where the decrease of Tn3 to 2.018 sec leads to smaller ξ3 and P values
compared to the corresponding values obtained for both ks=750 N/m and 3000 N/m. For example, by
increasing ks from 3000 N/m to 12000 N/m, a 38.3% reduction of the absolute maximum ξ3 value is
observed, while the maximum and the mean values of P are reduced by 61.9% and 26% respectively.
.
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
-0.5
-1
-1.5
-2
ks=3000 N/m
(a)
P abs (kW)
3 (m/sec)
ks=750 N/m
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
ks=12000 N/m
(b)
0
50
100
150
t (sec)
t (sec)
857
200
250
300
Soft and renewable energy sources
Figure 8. Effect of ks on
ξ3 and P for the case of the examined heaving WEC under the action of irregular waves
with Hs=1.175 m and Tp=2.228 sec.
5.
CONCLUSIONS
In the present paper, a computational tool, named FloaTWEC, is developed for the time-domain
analysis of a floating oscillating-body WEC. The analysis can be implemented for any geometry
under the action of regular and irregular waves assuming motion in all or appropriately selected rigidbody modes. The WEC’s response is calculated based on the well-known Cummins equation, while
the required frequency-dependent excitation loads and hydrodynamic coefficients, as well as the
hydrostatic-gravitational coefficients can be obtained using a standard hydrodynamics (wavesfloating structure interaction) software. The PTO mechanism can be modeled as a linear or non-linear
system, while mooring lines can be represented as additional stiffness forces.
Initially, the developed tool was applied in order to compare results with numerical and experimental
results of other investigators. Excellent agreement of computed results with the aforementioned ones
has been observed, which demonstrates the accuracy and the efficiency of FloaTWEC in terms of
capturing important aspects of the physical problem.
Finally, the application of FloaTWEC for the case of a heaving WEC with a linear PTO for different
incident wave conditions and mooring lines’ stiffness has led to the following main conclusions: (a)
the increase of the incident wave period increases the heave excitation force in absolute accordance
with the real physical problem. At the same time, however, the transition to longer waves conditions
leads to a reduction of the response and the power absorbed by the WEC, since resonance phenomena
become less significant and (b) for a given sea state the mooring lines’ stiffness affect the performance
of the WEC only when the change of the stiffness affects directly the intrinsic dynamic characteristics
of the WEC (i.e. heave natural period).
The present model can be further applied for the case of a non-linear PTO mechanism, while it can
be further extended in order to account for a more accurate modeling of the mooring lines.
References
1. Drew B., A.R. Plummer and M.N. Sahinkaya (2009) ‘A review of wave energy converter
technology’, Proc. Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power and
Energy, Vol. 223(8), pp. 887-902.
2. Magagna D. and A. Uihlein (2015) ‘Ocean energy development in Europe: Current status and
future perspectives’, International Journal of Marine Energy, Vol. 11, pp. 84-104.
3. de O Falcão A.F. (2010) ‘Wave energy utilization: A review of the technologies’, Renewable
and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 14(3), pp. 899-918.
4. Folley M. (2016) ‘Numerical Modelling of Wave Energy Converters: State-of-the-Art
Techniques for Single Devices and Arrays’, Elsevier.
5. Babarit A. (2010) ‘Impact of long separating distances on the energy production of two interacting
wave energy converters’, Ocean Engineering, Vol. 37(8-9), pp.718-729.
6. Schay J., J. Bhattacharjee and C.G. Soares (2013) ‘Numerical Modelling of a Heaving Point
Absorber in Front of a Vertical Wall’, Proc. 32nd Int. Conf. Ocean, Offshore and Arctic
Engineering (OMAE2013), Nantes, France, 2013.
7. Pastor J. and Y. Liu (2014) ‘Frequency and time domain modeling and power output for a heaving
point absorber wave energy converter’, International Journal of Energy and Environmental
Engineering, Vol. 5(2).
858
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
8. Eriksson M., J. Isberg and M. Leijon (2005) ‘Hydrodynamic modelling of a direct drive wave
energy converter’, International Journal of Engineering Science, Vol. 43, pp.1377-1387.
9. Lee C.H. (1995) ‘WAMIT theory manual’, MIT Report 95-2, Department of Ocean
Engineering, MIT.
10. Cummins W.E. (1962) ‘The impulse response function and ship motions’, Report 1661,
Department of the Navy David Taylor Model Basin.
11. Taghipour R., T. Perez and T. Moan (2008) ‘Hybrid frequency–time domain models for dynamic
response analysis of marine structures’, Ocean Engineering, No. 35(7), pp. 685–705
12. Det Norske Veritas – Germanischer Lloyds (DNV – GL) (2017) ‘Environmental conditions and
environmental loads’, Recommended Practice DNVGL-RP-C205.
13. Watai R., F. Ruggeri, C. Sampalo and A. Simos (2015) ‘Development of a time domain boundary
element method for numerical analysis of floating bodies’ responses in waves’, The Brazilian
Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering, Vol. 37(5), pp.1569-1589.
14. Chen B., D. Ning, C. Liu, C.A. Greated and H. Kang (2016) ‘Wave energy extraction by
horizontal floating cylinders perpendicular to wave propagation’, Ocean Engineering, Vol. 121,
pp. 112-122.
859
Soft and renewable energy sources
OPTIMAL OPERATION SCHEDULING OF MULTIPURPOSE
PUMPED STORAGE HYDROPOWER PLANT WITH HIGH
PENETRATION OF RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES
P.I. Bakanos* and K.L. Katsifarakis
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th, GR54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author : e-mail : p.bakanos@civil.auth.gr
Abstract
The high penetration of renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind, into the electricity system
requires large-scale, flexible storage and production systems for uninterrupted power supply, to
reduce as much as possible the amount of energy discarded. The pumped-storage method through
coupled reservoirs has been globally recognized as a mature, competitive and reliable technology for
the storage of large quantities of electricity and is suitable for our country, due to its particular
geomorphology. Its application may increase the degree of exploitation of hydroelectric projects,
without decrease of the availability of water resources. Optimization of renewable energy sources
penetration through reversible reservoir systems is a very complex, multi-parameter, non-linear
problem, as the reservoirs, besides hydroelectric power generation, serve many other objectives such
as water supply, irrigation and flood protection, while their function should observe constraints such
as environmental flow.
This paper examines the possibility of optimizing the penetration of wind energy into a pumpedstorage multi-reservoir system. The process of simulating and optimizing the system has been
implemented through the development of a program in the Microsoft Visual Studio 2015, based on
the genetic algorithm (GA) method. Genetic algorithms are a widely used non-linear optimization
method that has been successfully implemented to problems of management of large scale complex
water and energy systems. The results show that when the operation of the reservoir system is
coordinated with the wind farm, the hydroelectricity generation decreases, but the total economical
revenue of the system increases by about 7.2% and can achieve high wind energy penetration to the
electricity grid.
Keywords: Pumped-storage plant, multi-reservoir systems, renewable energy, optimization, genetic
algorithms
1.
INTRODUCTION
In recent years, a significant effort has been made in the world to move to a low-carbon society and
to achieve energy independence from fossil fuels (e.g. coal, oil and natural gas). In this effort to
change the energy paradigm, renewable energy sources such as wind, sun, water, biomass and
geothermal heat play a key role. The use of wind and solar energy does not produce toxic pollution
or global warming and is one of the cleanest and most sustainable ways to produce abundant and
inexhaustible electricity. Renewable energy is the key to long-term efforts to mitigate climate change
and will play an increasingly important role in improving overall energy security.
The energy generated from the wind turbines and photovoltaic stations is intermittent, fluctuating and
distributed, resulting in instabilities of the electrical system. In order to achieve penetration of
860
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
renewable energy sources on a large scale, drastically upgraded flexible and stable systems are
required to effectively integrate the volatility and unpredictability of uncontrolled renewable energy
and to minimize discarding of produced energy.
In order to ensure the stability of electrical networks, the storage of electricity is of prime importance,
in order to match energy production with demand. For this reason, large-scale energy storage
techniques attract great interest around the world. Among the alternative energy storage technologies,
especially in large-scale applications, the Pumped Hydro Storage (PHS) is the most mature and
efficient, in order to increase the penetration of renewable sources, allowing for improved elasticity
and efficiency of the energy system [1, 2].
Moreover, it is a suitable technology in autonomous power systems with high levels of renewable
generation. The main difference between these plants and normal hydroelectric systems is that,
besides producing electricity, they also consume it. The operation of a Pumped Storage Hydro Power
Plant (PSHPP) is based on the storage of energy in the form of water pumped from a lower elevation
tank to a higher elevation one, using excess of energy produced by green sources (or even by
conventional sources), which, without storage, is wasted during low demand hours. These systems
are capable of storing and providing significant flexibility in starting, interruptions and demand
fluctuations. Pumping-storage facilities also provide ancillary network services, such as network
frequency control and reserve creation. This is due to the ability of pumping and storage facilities of
the hydroelectric plants, to respond to load changes within a few seconds [3, 4].
2.
GENETIC ALGORITHMS
The method of Genetic algorithms (GAs) was developed during the 1960s and 1970s by John Holland
and his collaborators [5]. It is a search and optimization technique based on the principles of genetics
and natural selection. The method mimics the biological evolution and is based on Darwin's natural
selection theory.
The genetic algorithm optimization process begins by coding the values of the decision variables into
a string of characters, which in analogy with the biological template, is called chromosome and is an
arbitrary solution to the problem under consideration. This is followed by the creation of the initial
population, which consists of a number of randomly generated chromosomes. These individuals are
evaluated on the basis of mathematically formulated criteria, and each is assigned a fitness value. The
fitness function may include penalties, which reduce it when the corresponding solution violates
constraints of the problem. Then the next generation of chromosomes is created with the help of three
key operators (possibly other additives) that mimic biological processes.
First, the selection operator, according to which the most suitable chromosomes have a higher chance
of survival and reproduction, is used. The most popular selection methods are the biased roulette
wheel and the tournament. The above methods do not fully guarantee that the best chromosome of
one generation will pass to the next one. In order to ensure the "survival" of the fittest chromosome,
an additional process, called elitism, is incorporated in many codes [6].
Then the crossover operator is applied, with which descendants are formed from two original
chromosomes, exchanging randomly parts thereof. The basic idea is that at least one of the new
chromosomes could be better than the two parents, if it includes some of their best features. Finally,
the mutation operator, which alters some of the characters that make up the strings of chromosomes,
introduces new genetic structures and adds some additional variability and diversity to the population.
The mutation helps the algorithm not to be trapped by local optima and to reach the global ones. This
process (evaluation of chromosomes - implementation of operators) is repeated for a number of
generations, determined from the beginning or resulting from a termination criterion. It is expected
that in the last generation the optimal, or at least a very good solution to the problem, will have been
found [7].
861
Soft and renewable energy sources
3.
OPTIMAL OPERATION SCHEDULING OF A PSHPP WITH WIND FARM USING
GENETIC ALGORITHMS
In this paper we present a tool to design the optimal configuration of a wind farm combined with a
pumped storage hydro-plant. The optimal generation scheduling of a hydro pump wind system aims
to the utilization of water storage ability to improve wind park operational financial gains and to
attenuate the active power output variations due to the intermittence of the wind-energy resource [8].
The short-term hydro-wind scheduling suggests that current market mechanisms are inducing
generation companies to generate water flows as large as possible, namely to profit from selling
electricity, when prices are higher and to pay for pumping as little as possible when prices are low
and the wind is high. At times of low electrical demand and high wind energy generation, electric
power is used to pump water into the upper reservoir, so the excess of the wind energy can be stored
and not discarded. During periods of high electrical demand, water is released back into the lower
reservoir through a turbine, thereby generating electricity. Taking into account the conversion losses
of the pumping process and evaporation losses, a maximum of 70% to 85% of the electrical energy
used to pump the water into the upstream reservoir can be regained.
3.1 Problem formulation and case study
In the present study we consider an open-loop two-reservoir system with hydropower plants in series
into a river, and a wind farm as well, shown in Figure 1. The upstream plant is pump storage, it has
three reversible pump turbines and is located at the level of the downstream reservoir. The second
hydro power plant has three turbines for electricity generation. The hydropower plants are
coordinated and cooperate with the wind park and are connected to the grid. The task is to maximize
the financial benefits from operating the system over a 24-hour horizon. The objective function in
Equation 1, is to maximize the profit from selling energy or power to the electric grid:
t 24
MaximizeEgrid MaximizePgrid ci Pgrid ,t
t 1
(1)
The maximization of the objective function of short term pumped storage hydro wind scheduling
problem is subject to a number of constraints. The operation constraints are summarized as follows
(Equations 2-15):
a)
System active power balance
Pgrid,t= Pw,t+P1,t+ P2,t
(2)
The output of hourly active power of the system that is injected to the grid is equal to the summation
of both the hydro production and the available wind power. If the turbine of hydro plant 1 is in pump
mode at time t, the P1,t in Equation 2 can be negative. The hydropower from the two reservoirs is
calculated by Equation 3 and the net head is calculated by the following Equation 4:
Phydroi ,t (MW )
ni g Qi ,t Hneti ,t
(3)
1000
Hneti,t= HFi,t - HTi,t - ki Qi,t2
(4)
If the turbine is in pump mode the pump power is calculated by Equation 5 and the pump head is
calculated by the following Equation 6:
P1 pump ,t ( MW )
g Qi ,t H1 pump ,t
(5)
1000 n1 pump
H1pump,t= HF1,t - HT1,t+ ki Qi,t2
(6)
862
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: The reservoirs system and the wind Farm (Generated by the authors)
Hydro power plants generation or pumping limits
Pi hydro, min ≤ Pi hydro, t ≤ Pi hydro, max
P1pump, min ≤ P1pump, t ≤ P1pump, max
(7)
(8)
Wind power plant generation limit
0 ≤ Pw, t ≤ Pw, max
(9)
The maximum allowable power exchange with the system has a maximum technical power limitation
of the transmission line, which is considered as fixed during all 24h periods
P grid, t ≤ 800MW
(10)
Dynamic water balance in reservoirs or equation of continuity:
Vi, t+1 = Vi, t + Ii, t - Qi, t
(11)
Maximum and minimum volume levels of reservoirs:
Vi, min ≤ Vi, t≤ Vi, max
(12)
Lower and upper discharge limits of the turbines:
Qi, min≤ Qi ≤ Qi, max
(13)
Lower and upper power limits of the pump mode:
Q1pump, min≤ Q1, pump≤ Q1pump, max
(14)
Initial and final reservoir storage volume:
Vi,12= Vi,0
(15)
The symbols in Equations 2 to 15 are explained in the following lines:
i: reservoir or hydropower plant index, i = 1,2
t: time interval (h), t = 1; 2; … ;24
E grid: injected energy to network (MWh)
Ei, t: energy output of hydropower plant i (MWh)
Ew, t: available wind energy output of wind farm (MWh)
863
Soft and renewable energy sources
P grid: injected power to network (MW)
Pi, t: power output of hydropower plant I at time t (MW)
Pw, t: available wind power output of wind farm (MW)
ci: spot electricity price at time t (€/ΜWh)
Ii, t: inflow in the reservoir i at time t (m3/sec)
Vi, t: water volume of reservoir i at time t (hm3)
Qi, t: discharge from reservoir i through hydro turbine (m3/sec)
HFi, t: Reservoir elevation of the plant at time t (m)
HTi, t: Tailrace elevation of the plant at time t (m)
Hneti, t=, Head for the plant at time t for hydropower production (m)
Vi, max, Vi, min: max and min volume limits of reservoir i·(hm3)
Qi, max, Qi, min: turbine discharge limits for station i; (m3/sec)
Q1pump, max, Q1pump,min : pump discharge limits for station 1 (m3/sec)
Vi,0: water volume in reservoir i in the first scheduling period(hm3)
Vi,12: water volume in reservoir i in the last scheduling period (hm3)
ni, hydro: hydropower generation efficiency factor for hydro plant i
n pump: pumping efficiency for hydro plant 1
ki: friction coefficients of penstocks (s2/m5)
g: gravity acceleration (9.81 m/sec2)
ρ: water density (1000 kg/m3)
3.2 Wind power
The wind speed is always fluctuating, and thus the energy content of the wind is always changing.
The variation depends both on the weather and on local surface conditions and obstacles. Energy
output from a wind turbine will vary as the wind varies, although the most rapid variations will to
some extent be compensated for by the inertia of the wind turbine rotor [9]. We consider that the
installed capacity of wind farm is Pw,max = 1000MW, taking into account the installed capacity of the
hydropower plants [8,10]. The wind power forecast (shown in Figure 2) is available for the day-ahead
and serves as input. The total energy output of the wind farm in standalone mode is 14300MWh and
the profit is 745000.00€.
3.3 Hydropower plants
The technical and operational characteristics of reservoirs and hydropower facilities are summarized
in Table 1, while the relationship between elevation and volume is shown in Figure 3. The natural
inflow for the first reservoir is I1,t = 0.30hm3/h (166.67m3/sec). The second has no natural inflow and
I2,t = Q1,t
Figure 2: Wind power profile and power limit of the grid
864
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1: Technical and operational characteristics of reservoirs and hydropower facilities
Reservoir 1
Reservoir 2
0,30
-
Initial volume (hm3)
25
21.25
Final volume (hm3)
25
21.25
Maximum volume operation level (hm3)
30
25
Minimum volume operation level (hm3)
20
17.5
Maximum Generation Release (hm3/h)
1.20
1.20
Minimum Generation Release (hm3/h)
0.12
0.12
Maximum Pumping Release (hm3/h)
1.20
-
Minimum Pumping Release (hm3/h)
0.20
-
a
-0.0071
-0.0052
b
0.3674
-0.2053
c
-2.8964
19.651
d
95.562
-180.81
Maximum Height Level (m)
149.63
100.90
Minimum Height Level (m)
129.79
72.34
Maximum Tailrace level (m)
100.9
20
Minimum Tailrace level (m)
72.34
20
Discharge efficiency
0.88
0.88
Pumping efliciency
0.85
-
0.00003
0.00007
Generation Capacity Power (MW)
231 (3 x 77)
237 (3 x79)
Capacity Pumping Power (MW)
300 (3 x 100)
-
Inflow (hm3/h)
Head vs Volume Curve Hi(m)=aiVi3+biVi2+ciVi+di
Friction coefficients of penstock (sec2/m5)
Figure 3: Relationships between reservoirs’ water level and volume
865
Soft and renewable energy sources
3.4 Electricity market price
The 24h day-ahead hourly energy price of the electricity market is shown in Figure 4.
Figure 4: Forecasted market prices of electricity for 24h ahead
4.
OPTIMIZATION RESULTS
4.1 Optimization without coordination between wind power and pump storage
In the first case where the reservoir system operates independently of the wind farm, the maximum
hydro energy power output, obtained by optimizing the hydrosystem with genetic algorithms is shown
in Table 2. The release from the reservoirs and the storage in this case are shown in the diagrams of
Figures 5 and 6.
Table 2: Optimization results for case 1
Pump Storage
Hydroplant 1
Hydroplant 2
Total Hydro
energy
Wind Farm
System Energy
Energy generation (MWh)
2166.62
2266.10
4432.72
14300.00
18732.72
Energy for pumping (MWh)
-458.50
-
-458.50
-
-458.50
-
-
-
-2456.70
-2456.70
1.708,12
2.266,10
3974.22
11843.30
15817.52
124954,80€
148228,90€
273183.70€
586589.35
859773.05
Energy discarded (MWh)
Net energy (MWh)
Economical Revenue
Figure 5: Reservoir 1 storage curve and release profile for case 1
866
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 6: Reservoir 2 storage curve and release profile for case 1
Adding the power of the wind farm to the hydropower the total power exceeds the maximum capacity
of the grid and an amount of energy is discarded as shown at diagram fig.7. The wind energy that can
be absorbed by the system is 11843.3MWh from the 14300MWh and the discarded energy is
2456.7MWh, which means 83% penetration of wind energy into the grid, as shown in Figure 7. The
energy produced from the reservoir system is 3974.22MWh and total energy transferred to the grid
is 15817.52MWh. The financial revenue from wind energy is 586589.35€, from hydropower
273183.70€ and the total profit 859773.05€ (Figure 8).
Figure 7: System power output diagram and the energy discarded for case 1
Figure 8: Financial profit diagram for case 1
4.2 Optimization with coordination of wind power and pump storage
Coordinating operation of the reservoir system and the wind farm, the optimization by GAs can
balance output of the system and reduce the energy which is discarded to zero, absorbing the excess
867
Soft and renewable energy sources
power (over 800MW) by pumping water from the downstream reservoir to the upstream one. In this
case the maximum hydro energy power output by optimizing the hydro-system with genetic
algorithms is shown in Table 3. The release from the reservoirs and the storage in this case are shown
in diagrams of Figure 9 and 10.
Table 3: Optimization results for case 2
Pump Storage
Hydroplant 1
Hydroplant 2
Total Hydro
energy
Wind Farm
System Energy
Energy generation (MWh)
1923.28
2391.22
4314.50
14300
18614.50
Energy for pumping (MWh)
-601.72
-
-601.72
-
-601.72
-
-
-
0
0
1321.56
2391.22
3712.78
14300
18012.78
60370.40 €
116444.95
176815.35€
745000
921815.35
Energy discarded (MWh)
Net energy (MWh)
Economical Revenue
Figure 9: Reservoir 1 storage and release diagram for case 2
Figure 10: Reservoir 2 storage and release diagram for case 2
The system can absorb all the 14300MWh of wind energy, which is 100% penetration of wind energy.
The energy produced from the reservoir system is 3712.78MWh, namely smaller than that of case 1,
but the total energy transferred to the grid is 18012.78 MWh, about 14% larger, as shown in Figure
11. The revenue from wind energy in this case is 745000.00€ and from hydropower 176815.35€,
summing to a total of 921815.35 €, which means increase 7.2% compared to case 1. The total
hydroelectric energy generation and the revenue in the second case are about 7% and 35% smaller
respectively, compared to case 1, because in case 1 the reservoir system was optimized taking into
account the hydro plant capacity only (Figure 12).
868
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 11: System power output diagram for case 2
Figure 12: Financial profit diagram for case 2
5.
CONCLUSION
In this work, an optimization approach based on genetic algorithms is developed for the optimal
scheduling and operation strategy of a cascade two-reservoir system, which has a pumped-storage
hydro power plant, a conventional hydro power plant and a wind farm. The aim is to maximize the
financial benefits of operating the system over a 24-hour horizon for two cases, with and without
coordination. The results show that when the reservoir system is coordinated with the wind farm, the
hydroelectricity generation decreases, but the total revenue of the system increases about 7.2% and
can achieve high wind energy penetration to the electricity grid.
References
1. E-Storage (2016) World Energy Resources, World Energy Council.
2. StoRE (2014) ‘Final Publishable Report’, Intelligent Energy – Europe (IEE).
3. Kaldellis J.K. (2010) ‘Stand-Alone and Hybrid Wind Energy Systems’, Technology, Energy
Storage and Applications, Woodhead Publishing.
4. Pérez-Díaz J.I., Chazarra M., García-González J., Cavazzini G. and Stoppato A. (2015) ‘Trends
and challenges in the operation of pumped-storage hydropower plants’, Renewable &
Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol.44, pp. 767-784.
5. Holland J.H. (1975) ‘Adaptation in Natural and Artificial Systems’, University of Michigan
Press, Ann Arbor.
869
Soft and renewable energy sources
6. Katsifarakis K.L. (2012) ‘Hydrology, Hydraulics and Water Resources Management: A
Heuristic Optimization Approach’, WIT Press.
7. Bakanos P. and K.L. Katsifarakis (2018) ‘Development and evaluation of a decision-making
system for optimal management of reservoirs in single time horizon’, 11th National Conferences
on Renewable Energy Sources, Institute of Solar Technology, Thessaloniki (in Greek).
8. Castruonovo E.D. and Peças Lopes J.A. (2004) ‘On the optimization of the daily operation of a
wind-hydropower plant’, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 19(3), pp.1599-606.
9. Wagner H.-J. and Mathur J. (2018) ‘Introduction to Wind Energy Systems Basics, Technology
and Operation’, Springer.
10. Kumar M., Saini P. and Kumar N. (2016) ‘Optimization of Wind-Pumped Storage Hydro Power
System’, International Journal of Engineering Technology, Management and Applied
Sciences, Vol. 4(4), ISSN 2349-4476.
870
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
EVALUATION OF CYPRUS ENERGY RESOURCES IN THE
FRAMEWORK OF ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY
USING A NOVEL SWOT-PESTEL APPROACH
M. Tsangas* and A.A. Zorpas*
Faculty of Pure and Applied Science, Open University of Cyprus, Environmental Conservation and
Management, Laboratory of Chemical Engineering and Engineering Sustainability, Giannou
Kranidioti, 33, P.O. Box 12794, 2252, Latsia, Nicosia, Cyprus
*Corresponding author: e-mail: antonis.zorpas@ouc.ac.cy, antoniszorpas@yahoo.com,
tsangasm@cytanet.com.cy tel : +357-22411936
Abstract
According to several EU Directives, Cyprus qualifies and is classified as an Emerging Market for
Natural Gas and also as Isolated Energy Market. The Country energy natural resources face several
contradictions. On one hand, there is not any specific strategy in political level regarding when and
how indigenous fossil reserves will be extracted although their commercial exploitation could offer
to the Island energy security. Moreover, there are not any oil or gas pipelines as well as no electricity
interconnections with other countries. On the other hand, several Sustainability (mainly
environmental) targets set by United Nations and the European Commission (either as policies,
regulations or directives) must be adopted and therefore fossil fuel use should not be promoted and
the contribution of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) must be increased. So, Cyprus needs rather
than any other country in the area a holistic sustainable strategy regarding the promotion of RES and
to manage its own fossil hydrocarbons reserves. For this a detailed energy resources sustainability
strategy analysis is required in order to be able to evaluate the available inputs and to formulate
sustainable energy strategic planning. This paper proposes a novel approach to combine PESTEL and
SWOT analysis in order to assess the ability to use PESTEL environmental context analysis to
categorize and evaluate not only the pillar of externalities, but also the energy resources sustainability
internalities. The method is implemented for Cyprus energy resources and emerges not only a number
of sustainability opportunities and threats, but also strengths and weakness for the island’s future
energy resources sustainable development strategy. Furthermore, it is obtained that the proposed
novel approach, as it is able to acquire useful results, is promised and suitable for environmental
analysis which is a crucial part of the strategic management planning process.
Keywords: PESTEL; SWOT; natural resources; sustainability; energy strategic planning
1.
INTRODUCTION
Cyprus has a completely isolated power system and no electricity interconnections (IRENA, 2015).
It has also proven natural gas reserves i.e. 141.6 Bcm until 2014 (WEC, 2016) and a renewable energy
potential able to provide 25 - 40% of total electricity supply by 2030 as assessed by International
Renewable Energy Agency (Lin et al., 2016). It is an insular Country, European Union member since
2004 and according to EU Directives qualifies and is classified as Emerging Market for Natural Gas
and as Isolated Energy Market (Directive 2009/72/EC, Directive 2009/73/EC). Although the
production of the indigenous natural gas could commence by 2022 (Taliotis et al., 2017) and its
exploitation could have considerable impact to the island economic development and energy security
(Henderson, 2013), there is not any specific known strategy regarding when and how fossil natural
871
Soft and renewable energy sources
resources will be extracted. In this framework, there are several energy strategy contradictions. On
the one hand, there is the option the natural gas reserves to be exploited and a fossil fuel dominated
energy system to be continued with the advantage of the indigenous sources. On the other hand, as
required by UN and related EU targets which focus on climate change, reduced hydrocarbon fuels,
increased contribution of RES, minimized environmental issues, turn to a low carbon society etc,
renewable energy should be promoted and fossil fuel use be mitigated. Therefore, Cyprus needs an
efficient energy strategic planning in order to exploit sustainably its energy resources and at the same
time conform to global warming mitigation obligations. This paper aims to propose a novel context
analysis method, which combines PESTEL and SWOT and is suitable to be used in this process.
2.
ENERGY STRATEGIC PLANNING
Due to the crucial importance of sustainable development and climate change mitigation, energy
planning optimization has become extremely important (Vazhayil and Balasubramanian, 2012) and
moreover not doing rigorous and quantitative energy planning may have high cost (Gómez et al.,
2016). Strategic management, initially involves environmental scanning and strategy formulation (i.e
strategic planning) and, consequently, strategy implementation, evaluation and control.
Environmental scanning requires internal and external factors analysis (Alkhafaji, 2003). Internal and
external environmental issues scanning and evaluation is an important step at the preparation of
strategic planning (Zorpas et al., 2018). Proper energy planning should be based on an internal and
external environment survey and as energy resources availability is key for effective energy planning
(Mirjat et al., 2017; Ervural et al., 2018) this paper focuses on such an analysis for Cyprus.
3.
ANALYSIS METHOD
3.1 SWOT and PESTEL tools
The PESTLE (Political, Economic, Social, Technical, Legal and Environmental) analysis is an
analytical tool for assessing the impact of external contexts on a project or a major operation and also
the impact of a project on its external contexts (Basu, 2009). PESTEL (or PESTLE) analysis was
originally conceived as ETPS for the economic, technical, political, and social sectors of the
environment by Aguilar in 1967. Later in the 1960s, Brown for the Institute of Life Insurance
reorganized the analysis as STEP. This macro external environment analysis, or environmental
scanning for change, was modified again as so-called STEPE analysis, including also the ecological
taxonomy; more recently “L” was also added for legislative or legal concerns (Richardson, 2006).
Being a practical business analysis tool (Basu, 2009), PESTEL has been broadly used in
environmental research (Fozer et al., 2017; Song et al., 2017; Climent Barba et al., 2016; Zalengera
et al., 2014; Shilei and Yong, 2009). As sustainability has social, economic and environmental
dimension, it is important in a decision making process to add the institutional dimension (Sharifi and
Murayama, 2013). PESTEL provides an essential framework for sustainability analysis and planning.
An important aspect of the strategic planning process is SWOT analysis (Alkhafaji, 2003); that is a
strategic analysis tool that combines the study of the strengths and weaknesses of an organization,
territory or sector with the study of the opportunities and threats in its environment (Fertel et al.,
2013). The name of SWOT analysis is the initials of the words strengths (S), weaknesses (W),
opportunities (O), and threats (T). Strengths are positives and weaknesses are negatives related to
system internal factors, while opportunities are external factors that have positive interaction with the
system and the threats to the system are the negative effects of the system environment (Srdjevic et
al., 2012). SWOT analysis is broadly used in energy planning related research (Fertel et al., 2013;
Ervural et al., 2018; Khan, 2018).
3.2 SWOT - PESTEL combination novel approach
Prior to the SWOT analysis, the internal and external factors should be well defined (Fertel et al.,
2013). As PESTEL refers to external environment factors, it seems suitable for external issues
872
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
recognition. The tool may be used for the external environment analysis in order to identify
opportunities and threats (Bell and Rochford, 2016). However this paper proposes a novel method,
arguing that the PESTEL framework analysis is suitable to spot both external (opportunities and
threats) as well internal (strengths and weaknesses) factors.
Although applications conclude to strengths and weaknesses using PESTEL environment analysis
are met in the literature (Mayaka and Prasad, 2012; Srdjevic et al., 2012) the issue how the
internalities can be provoked by the external environment analysis remains in question. The difficulty
to distinguish between internal and external factors may lead to confuse strengths with opportunities
or weaknesses with threats (Fertel et al., 2013). To confront this confusion a methodology to discern
the internalities from externalities is hereby proposed. In this approach, it is fundamental to define
which, concluded by the PESTEL analysis environment factors, may be considered as internal and
which as external.
The internal environment involves the resources and capabilities of a company, whereas external
environment involves factors beyond the control of a company, but which, nevertheless, are relevant
to - and affect the company (Yüksel, 2012). According to Nwagbara (2011) the factors outside the
control of the system are external and factors within the control of the system are internal. Outside
forces over which management has little or no control, but they affect the organization’s development
and success compose the external environment (Alkhafaji, 2003).
External environment understanding according to ISO 9001:2015, may be enabled by examining
parameters arise by the institutional, technological, cultural, social and financial environment, the
competition and the market in international, national, district and local level. In a different approach,
according to Bilovaru et al. (2009), referring to a country market characteristics analysis, political,
economic, social, technological, environmental and legislative conditions determine country image
itself, and, thus, they represent the internal elements of SWOT.
As specified in ISO 9001:2015, internal environment understanding may be enabled by examining
parameters connected to organization values, culture, knowledge and performance. Organizations
internal environment “is typically described by its organizational structure, resources, climate and
culture'' (Tang, 1998 cited in Zain and Kassim, 2012). According to literature for SMEs, the
categories of internal environmental factors affecting business success are entrepreneur
characteristics, SME characteristics, management, products and services, customers and markets,
doing business way and cooperation, resources and finance, strategy, company’s competitive
position, human resources skills, technological capabilities and employees values and backgrounds
(Hin et al., 2012). Key internal variables that affect a corporation’s strategy formulation are the
structure, culture, and resources. Communication processes, work flow, authority and responsibility
relationships define structure. Culture is the collection of beliefs, expectations, and values shared by
the corporation’s members and are transmitted through generations. Corporate resources are the
financial, physical, and human resources, organizational systems and technological capabilities
(Alkhafaji, 2003).
Based on the internal and external factors outline is derived from the above, two distinguishable sets,
referring to energy resources parameters, could be formed. A set including factors classified as
internal and a set including factors that are external. So, external or internal factors gleaned by the
PESTEL analysis can be distinguished, depending on which set they belong, and they can be
classified as S, W, O or T s consequently.
The two sets are the below:
The “Energy resources Internal Factors (IF)” set: IF = {current energy strategy, current production
characteristics and resources, energy resources availability}.
The “Energy resources External Factors (EF)” set: EF = {energy demand, economy trend, technology
and human resources trends, environmental impacts, legislation, policies, social framework}.
873
Soft and renewable energy sources
The outline of PESTEL framework can be collected and gleaned by secondary data review as
academic literature, government or international organizations websites, factsheets, reports etc.
Besides as strengths and opportunities are positives and weaknesses and threats are negatives the
methodology sequence proposed to be followed in order to spot them by the SWOT – PESTEL
analysis is presented in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Method
Although sustainability definition is complex and multiply approached, explained and analyzed (Pater
and Cristea, 2016; Moldavska and Welo, 2017; Glavic and Lukman, 2007), the results in the proposed
method are formulated with a direct approach. Energy resources sustainability strengths, weaknesses,
opportunities and threats are either these concern the effort to currently exploit the resources
efficiently, or these which are connected to the ability the resources development to be prosperous
and not harmful in the long term and for the future generations.
4.
CYPRUS ENERGY RESOURCES PESTEL ANALYSIS
4.1 Political Framework
Cyprus is a European Union member since 2004. Its political system is Presidential Republic. On
July 1974, Turkey invaded against the Republic of Cyprus and since then 36.2% of the sovereign
territory of the country remains under Turkish occupation. This situation is known as the Cyprus
problem (PIO, 2017a). Cyprus is geographically and nationally divided into two parts. The south part
which is internationally recognized as Republic of Cyprus, and the North part, where there is a selfdeclared State, recognized only by Turkey. Greek Cypriots live in the southern part and Turkish
Cypriots live in the northern part (Laouris and Michaelides, 2017). Hydrocarbon development could
potentially be enabler for a Cyprus problem settlement (Gürel and Le Cornu, 2014).
The energy policy of the Government of the Republic of Cyprus has as main axes the market healthy
competition ensuring, the energy supply ensuring and the country energy demands satisfaction, with
the smallest burden on the national economy and the environment and is fully harmonized with EU
energy policy (EAC, 2017a). Cyprus 2020 targets are to reduce 5 % GHG emission limits compared
to 2005 greenhouse gas emissions levels, 13% share of energy production by renewable sources and
2.2 Mtoe maximum primary energy consumption (EC, 2018a). Especially for electricity generation
and cement and ceramics production the national target set is 21% reduction of GHC emissions by
2020 (DoE, 2017).
874
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
So far three hydrocarbons exploration licensing rounds have already held in Cyprus Exclusive
Economic Zone (CHC, 2017). According to EU policy, National Governments have control over their
oil and gas reserves, but they must follow a set of common EU rules to ensure fair competition during
licensing granting for search and production activities (EC, 2018b). Besides, member states must take
account the decarbonisation priorities when exploit hydrocarbon reserves (EC, 2014).
Although currently there are no Cyprus pipeline or electric cable interconnections there is such a
potential. A 600 kV DC underwater electric cable, currently known as the Euro Asia Interconnector,
to connect Israel - Cyprus – Greece transmission networks and a gas pipeline from the East
Mediterranean gas reserves to Greece mainland via Crete, currently known as "EastMed Pipeline",
have been labelled as Projects of Common Interest (PCI) by European Union (EC, 2017).
4.2 Economic Framework
Cyprus is a eurozone member since 2008 and after financial and economic crisis in 2013 the
government required an economic support program funded by EU and IMF which included obligation
for a number of reforms as the privatization of state-owned assets, utilities and services (Panayides et
al., 2017). The Country has exited the program and fifteen months after the exit Cyprus’s economic
growth was evaluated as broad-based (IMF, 2017). Country GDP growth rate during the third quarter
of 2017 was estimated at + 3.8% comparing to the same quarter of 2016 (MoF, 2017).
Although full liberalization of Cyprus electricity market was formally achieved on 2014, it is not yet
implemented in practice. Electricity Authority of Cyprus (EAC) which is semi-public body is
presently the only supplier (EC, 2014) and operates three thermal power stations with a total installed
capacity of 1478 MW mainly produced with heavy fuel oil (EAC, 2017b). Energy production in
Cyprus is mainly depended on imported fuel with 96,4% energy dependence in 2013 amounted 7.1%
of the country’s GDP, which decreased to 6.7% in 2014 (EY, 2016). Electricity generation of insular
systems because of a number of factors are extremely expensive and less secure in the long term
(Fokaides and Kyllili, 2014). Cyprus’s energy system isolation increases electricity generation costs
and imported energy sources dependence (Fokaides et al., 2014).
Cyprus Government supports GHC emissions mitigation targets with renewables and energy
efficiency promotion subsidy schemes (Energy Service, 2017), feed in tariffs and net-metering
supporting schemes (Poullikas, 2013) and PV projects competitive auctions licensing (Kylili and
Fokaides, 2015). Although according to empirical results, renewable energy consumption has positive
impact on economic growth, for Cyprus no causality is found (Alper and Oguz, 2016). The natural
gas discoveries in Cyprus EEZ are large enough to have considerable impact to the island economic
development and energy security (Henderson, 2013) and have the potential within a decade to
disengage country energy production from imported oil products and to improve the trade balance in
order to reduce the cost of electricity to the economy (Taliotis et al., 2017).
4.3 Social Framework
Cyprus population is estimated at 952100 (PIO, 2017b). In Cyprus there is an ongoing ethnic partition
between the Greek Cypriot majority and the sizeable Turkish-Cypriot minority and the island is
divided in two ethnically homogenized parts, the Republic of Cyprus in the southern part practically
dominated by the Greek-Cypriots, and the ‘Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus’, a formation that
is recognized only by Turkey occupied by Turkish Cypriots. Although last years there is a relative
freedom of movement across the dividing line of the two parts but the partition still remains in place
(Zembylas et al., 2016).
Unemployment in Cyprus has a decreasing trend since a peak noted by end of 2015 and in December
2017 was 11.3% decreased, compared to 12.8% in December 2016 (MoF, 2018). Country total
employment is forecasted to grow in next years (HRDA, 2017a) and in the same trend new
employment needs are also forecasted for electricity supply and natural gas sector (HRDA, 2017b).
875
Soft and renewable energy sources
4.4 Technical Framework
Energy demand in Cyprus is prospected to rise calculated to be 5% to 44% higher in 2040 than it was
in 2010 (Zachariadis and Taibi, 2015). Approved long term forecast of annual total generated
electricity upper limit in Cyprus in 2026 according to TSO (2017) is 7215 GWh. Cyprus has
significant renewable energy potential with solar potential to be calculated up to 1900 KWh/m2 per
year, total wind potential about 150 and 250 ΜW (Pilavachi et al., 2009) and annual biodegradable
waste biogas generation potential at 242 GWh minimum (Kythreotou et al., 2012). Renewable energy
penetration in Cyprus electricity system in 2016 was 8.4% of total generation i.e. 4.7% by wind parks,
3% by PV projects and 0.7% by biomass plants (TSO, 2018).
Cyprus offshore recoverable natural gas quantities are estimated by the Government and foreign
energy institutes to may be up to 200 tcf expected to become available in the forthcoming years
(Cyprus Institute of Energy, 2012 cited in Fokaides and Kylili, 2014). Proven natural gas reserves
until 2014 was 5000.6 bcf (WEC, 2016). Once natural gas becomes available, as a result of provisions
made in Vasilikos power station units, generation can switch to this fuel instead of diesel and heavy
fuel oil (Taliotis, et al., 2017).
4.5 Environmental Framework
Fossil fuel energy production is connected with many environmental impacts as global warming,
ozone layer depletion, abiotic depletion, acidification, eutrophication, fresh water aquatic ecotoxicity,
human toxicity, marine aquatic ecotoxicity, photochemical ozone creation and terrestrial ecotoxicity
are closely connected with (Atilgan and Azapagicm, 2015). On the other hand producing electricity
from RES environmental benefits, including the reduction of GHG emissions, are well known (Serri
et al., 2018). However these are also connected with environmental impacts (Zorpas et al., 2017).
Natural gas is a promising transition energy source between higher-carbon fossil fuels and RES in
part due to its relatively low GHG emissions and local air pollutants, (Chávez-Rodríguez et al., 2017).
On the other hand, offshore hydrocarbon exploration and production as Cyprus case are associated
with significant potential impacts to the environment which may include marine pollution and
toxicity, benthic disturbance, impacts to wildlife, birds and fish, biological depletion, loss of
archaeological heritage, health and safety incidents, atmospheric emissions and drilling fluids, muds
and cuttings as well as other solid and fluid waste production (Elbisy, 2016; Speight, 2015). Besides,
offshore platforms accidents may result to severe environmental damage (Stout et al., 2017).
4.6 Legal Framework
Several laws and regulations regulate energy activities in Cyprus. Energy infrastructure projects
including natural gas and renewable energy projects, with the exception of under 100 kW photovoltaic
systems, require Environmental Impact Assessment preparation (Zorpas et al., 2017). Health and
Safety issues of energy activities are regulated under Safety and Health at Work Laws of 1996 to
2015 and the related regulations also. Department of Environment strategic plan 2016 - 2018 include
activities for appropriate restructure of the institutional framework with respect to the management
of the environmental aspects of energy and hydrocarbons (DoE, 2017).
The conditions for granting and using authorizations for the prospection, exploration and production
of hydrocarbons are regulated by the Republic of Cyprus legislation harmonized with directive
94/22/EC. The safety of offshore oil and gas operations issues are regulated by legislation harmonized
with directive 2013/30/EU which establishes minimum requirements for preventing major accidents
in offshore oil and gas operations and limiting the consequences of such accidents.
5.
RESULTS
Implementing the methodology presented in Figure 1., the findings that can be classified as internal
or external positive or negative effect facts are gleaned by the above PESTEL framework analysis.
876
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
So the Cyprus Energy Sources sustainability strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats are
concluded as follows.
Considering internal factors set members is emerged that, regarding current energy strategy, the lack
of a known coherent Country energy strategy is a negative effect fact so it is a weakness.
Commencement of hydrocarbons exploitation, interconnections political approval, electricity system
legal liberalization and EU membership can be classified as related positives so they are strengths.
Regarding energy resources availability, it is positive that the Country has natural gas and renewable
energy potential but island energy isolation and imported fuels dependence are negatives. Besides
current heavy fuel oil based electricity production has negative effect so it is a weakness referring to
production characteristics.
External factors set members consideration emerges that energy demand prospected raise, observed
economy growth, GHG emissions reduction targets, solid legal requirements for energy related
activities, natural gas and renewables environmental benefits, existing power plants conversion to
natural gas potential and natural gas reserves enabled Cyprus problem resolution potential are positive
effect facts. These are connected to energy resources external factors set members, so there are
opportunities. Relevant negative effect factors, therefore threats, are the Cyprus problem and the
existing ethnic partition, electricity system factual liberation delay and the noted unemployment
decreasing trend in combination with increased energy sector employment needs.
A Cyprus Energy Sources SWOT matrix containing above results is presented in Figure 2.
Figure 2. Cyprus Energy Resources SWOT matrix
6.
CONCLUSIONS
The proposed SWOT-PESTEL qualitative analysis method implemented, emerged a number of
sustainability strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. SWOT analysis typically generates
strategic alternatives (Alkhafaji, 2003) and aims to maximize strengths and opportunities potential
while minimizing weaknesses and threats effects (Schmoldt and Peterson, 2000 cited in Fertel et al.,
2013). So the observations can be used to evaluate the Cyprus energy resources and to formulate
energy strategy aiming to maximize strengths, minimize weaknesses, enhance opportunities and
confront threats. Therefore, the energy policy of the Country should be more coherent deploying
877
Soft and renewable energy sources
European Union policies, targets and guidelines. Electricity and pipelines interconnections as well as
natural gas reserves exploitation should be sought to in combination with power plants conversion
for this fuel use, energy market actual linearization and renewables contribution maximization.
Regarding social issues energy sector employment should be taken into consideration and energy
planning to be thought as a Cyprus problem solution enabler.
As SWOT analysis, even if it is well structured, it is subjective and it is difficult to reach a consensus
about its results (Fertel et al., 2013), the proposed methodology must be connected to the same
limitation. But its application shows that it is suitable to overcome the core limitation of effective
internal and external factors detection and segregation. It must also be mentioned that limitations of
this paper results are that analysis is based on available secondary data and that transportation as well
as domestic heating systems energy needs have not been considered.
References
1. Alkhafaji A. F. (2003) ‘Strategic Management Formulation, Implementation, and Control in
a Dynamic Environment’, The Haworth Press.
2. Alper A. and Oguz O. (2016) ‘The role of renewable energy consumption in economic growth:
Evidence from asymmetric causality’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 60,
pp. 953–959.
3. Atilgan B. and Azapagic A. (2015) ‘Life cycle environmental impacts of electricity from fossil
fuels in Turkey’, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 06, pp. 555-564.
4. Basu R. (2009) ‘Implementing Six Sigma and Lean: A Practical Guide to Tools and
Techniques’, Butterworth-Heinemann.
5. Bell G. G. and Rochford L (2016) ‘Rediscovering SWOT’s integrative nature: A new
understanding of an old framework’, The International Journal of Management Education,
Vol. 14, pp. 310-326.
6. Bivolaru E., Andrei R. and Purcăroiu G. V. (2009) ‘Branding Romania: A PESTEL Framework
Based on a Comparative Analysis of Two Country Brand Indexes’, Management & Marketing,
Vol. 4, No. 4, pp. 101-112.
7. Chávez-Rodríguez M. F. et al (2017) ‘Modelling the natural gas dynamics in the Southern Cone
of Latin America’, Applied Energy, Vol. 201, pp. 219–239.
8. CHC (2017), http://chc.com.cy/activities/brief-outline/ (accessed December 27th, 2017)
9. Climent Barba F. et al. (2016) ‘A technical evaluation, performance analysis and risk assessment
of multiple novel oxy-turbine power cycles with complete CO2 capture’, Journal of Cleaner
Production, Vol. 133, pp. 971-985.
10. DIRECTIVE 2013/30/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 June 2013 on
safety of offshore oil and gas operations and amending Directive 2004/35/EC
11. DIRECTIVE 2009/73/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 July 2009
concerning common rules for the internal market in natural gas and repealing Directive
2003/55/EC
12. DIRECTIVE 2009/72/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 July 2009
concerning common rules for the internal market in electricity and repealing Directive
2003/54/EC
13. DIRECTIVE 94/22/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 1994 on the
conditions for granting and using authorizations for the prospection, exploration and production
of hydrocarbons
878
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
14. DoE
(2017)
http://www.moa.gov.cy/moa/environment/environmentnew.nsf/
4874C4A6C6CE24F5C2257EF2003365EA/$file/Strategic%20Plan%202016-2018.pdf
(accessed December 27th, 2017)
15. EAC (2017a) https://www.eac.com.cy/EN/EAC/Sustainability/Pages/Energiakipolitiki. aspx
(accessed December 27th, 2017)
16. EAC (2017b) https://www.eac.com.cy/EN/eac/operations/Pages/Generation.aspx (accessed
December 27th, 2017)
17. EC
(2018a)
https://ec.europa.eu/info/business-economy-euro/economic-and-fiscal-policycoordination/eu-economic-governance-monitoring-prevention-correction/europeansemester/european-semester-your-country/cyprus/europe-2020-targets-statistics-and-indicatorscyprus_en (accessed February 24th, 2018)
18. EC
(2018b)
https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/oil-gas-and-coal/oil-and-gas-licensing
(accessed February 24th, 2018)
19. EC (2017) ‘The Union List of Projects of Common Interest ('Union List')’, European
Commission.
20. EC (2014), European Energy Security Strategy, European Commission.
21. Elbisy M. S. (2016) ‘Environmental Management of Offshore Gas Platforms in Abu Qir Bay,
Egypt’, KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering, Vol. 20 (4), pp. 1228–1241.
22. Energy Service (2017) http://www.mcit.gov.cy/mcit/EnergySe.nsf/page11_gr/page11_gr?
OpenDocument (accessed December 27th, 2017)
23. EY (2016) Energy Sector Dynamics, Ernst & Young.
24. Ervural B. C., Zaim S., Demirel O.F., Aydin Z. and Delen D. (2018) ‘An ANP and fuzzy TOPSISbased SWOT analysis for Turkey’s energy planning’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Reviews, Vol. 82, Part 1, pp. 1538-1550.
25. Fertel C., Bahn O., Vaillancourt K. and Waaub J-P. (2013) ‘Canadian energy and climate policies:
A SWOT analysis in search of federal/provincial coherence’, Energy Policy, Vol. 63, pp. 11391150.
26. Fokaides P. A. and Kylili A. (2014) ‘Towards grid parity in insular energy systems: The case of
photovoltaics (PV) in Cyprus’, Energy Policy, Vol. 65, pp. 223–228.
27. Fokaides P. A., Miltiadous I.-Ch. , Neophytou M. K.-A. and L.-P. Spyridou (2014) ‘Promotion
of wind energy in isolated energy systems: the case of the Orites wind farm’, Clean Technologies
and Environmental Policy, Vol. 16 (3), pp 477–488.
28. Fozer D. et al. (2017) ‘Life cycle, PESTLE and Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis of CCS process
alternatives’, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 147, pp. 75-85.
29. Glavic P. and Lukman R. (2007) ‘Review of sustainability terms and their definitions’, Journal
of Cleaner Production, Vol. 15, pp. 1875-1885.
30. Gómez A., Dopazo, C. and Fueyo N. (2016) ‘The “cost of not doing” energy planning: The
Spanish energy bubble’, Energy, Vol 101, pp. 434-446.
31. Gürel A. and Le Cornu L. (2014) ‘Can Gas Catalyse Peace in the Eastern Mediterranean?’ The
International Spectator, Vol. 49 (2), pp. 11-33.
32. Henderson S. (2013) ‘Natural Gas Export Options for Israel and Cyprus’, The German
Marshall Fund of the United States.
33. Hin C. W., Bohari A.M., Isa F. M. and Maddin A. M. (2012) ‘Assessing The Model of Wheelen
and Hunger (2008) Model of Internal Environmental Scanning And Its Applications to the Small
879
Soft and renewable energy sources
Medium Enterprise (SME) in Malaysia’, Asian Journal of Business and Management Sciences,
2 (8), pp.24-33.
34. HRDA
(2017a)
http://www.anad.org.cy/images/media/assetfile/Forecasts%20of%
20Employment%20Needs%20in%20the%20Cyprus%20Economy%202017-2027%20%20Summary.pdf (accessed December 27th, 2017)
35. HRDA (2017b) http://www.anad.org.cy/images/media/assetfile/D.pdf (accessed December 27th,
2017)
36. IMF (2017) Country Report No. 17/148, International Monetary Fund.
37. IRENA (2015) ‘Renewable Energy Roadmap for the Republic of Cyprus’, International
Renewable Energy Agency.
38. ISO (2015) Quality management systems — Requirements, ISO 9001. ISO, Geneva.
39. Khan M.I. (2018) ‘Evaluating the strategies of compressed natural gas industry using an
integrated SWOT and MCDM approach’, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 172, pp. 10351052.
40. Kylili Α and Fokaides P. A. (2015) ‘Competitive auction mechanisms for the promotion
renewable energy technologies: The case of the 50 MW photovoltaics projects in Cyprus’,
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 42, pp. 226-233.
41. Kythreotou, N., Tassou, S.A. and Florides, G. (2012) ‘An assessment of the biomass potential of
Cyprus for energy production’, Energy, Vol. 47, pp. 253- 261.
42. Laouris Y. and Michaelides M (2017) ‘Structured Democratic Dialogue: An application of a
mathematical problem structuring method to facilitate reforms with local authorities in Cyprus’.
European Journal of Operational Research, article in press.
43. Lin J-H., Wu Y-K. and Lin H-J. (2016) ‘Successful experience of renewable energy development
in several offshore islands’, Energy Procedia, Vol. 100, pp. 8 – 13.
44. Mayaka. M. A. and Prasad, H. (2012) ‘Tourism in Kenya: An analysis of strategic issues and
challenges’, Tourism Management Perspectives, Vol. 1 (1), pp. 48–56.
45. MoF
(2017)
http://mof.gov.cy/en/economic-indicators/macroeconomics/main-economicindicators/gdp-growth-rate-2013-q1-2017-q3 (accessed December 27th, 2017)
46. MoF
(2018)
http://mof.gov.cy/en/economic-indicators/macroeconomics/main-economicindicators/1-unemployment (accessed February 24th, 2018)
47. Mirjat N. H., Uqaili M. H., Harijan K., Das Valasai G., Shaikh F. and Waris M. (2017) ‘A review
of energy and power planning and policies of Pakistan’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Reviews, Vol. 79, pp. 110-127.
48. Moldavska A. and Welo T. (2017) ‘The concept of sustainable manufacturing and its definitions:
A content-analysis based literature review’, Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 166, pp. 744755.
49. Nwagbara U. (2011) ‘Waterstone’s and the changing bookselling environment in the UK: the
journey so far and prospects,” Economic Sciences Series, Petroleum - Gas University of
Ploiesti BULLETIN, Vol. LXII, No. 3, pp. 14-26.
50. Panayides P. M., Lambertides N. and Andreou C. (2017) ‘Reforming public port authorities
through multiple concession agreements: The case of Cyprus’, Research in Transportation
Business & Management, Vol. 22, pp. 58-66.
51. Pater L. R. and Cristea S. L. (2016), ‘Systemic Definitions of Sustainability, Durability and
Longevity’, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, Vol. 221, pp. 362 – 371.
880
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
52. Pilavachi, P.A., Kalampalikas, N.G., Kakouris, M.K., Kakaras, E. and Giannakopoulos, D. (2009)
‘The energy policy of the Republic of Cyprus’, Energy, Vol. 34 pp. 547-554.
53. PIO (2017a) http://www.aspectsofcyprus.com/consequences-of-the-cyprus-problem/ (accessed
December 27th, 2017)
54. PIO (2017b) http://www.aspectsofcyprus.com/population/ (accessed December 27th, 2017)
55. Poullikkas A. (2013) ‘A comparative assessment of net metering and feed in tariff schemes for
residential PV systems’, Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments, Vol. 3, pp. 1-8.
56. Richardson J.V. Jr., (2006) ‘The Library and Information Economy in Turkmenistan’, IFLA
Journal, Vol. 32 (2), pp. 131–139.
57. Serri L., Lembo E., Airoldi D., Gelli C. and Beccarello M., (2018) ‘Wind energy plants
repowering potential in Italy: technical-economic assessment’, Renewable Energy, Vol. 115, pp.
382-390.
58. Sharifi A. and Murayama A., (2013) ‘A critical review of seven selected neighborhood
sustainability assessment tools’, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, Vol. 38, pp.73–
87.
59. Shilei L. and Yong W., (2009) ‘Target-oriented obstacle analysis by PESTEL modeling of energy
efficiency retrofit for existing residential buildings in China's northern heating region’, Energy
Policy, Vol. 37 (6), pp. 2098-2101.
60. Song J., Sun Y. and Jin L. (2017) ‘PESTEL analysis of the development of the waste-to-energy
incineration industry in China’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 80, pp. 276–
289.
61. Speight J. G. (2015) Handbook of offshore oil and gas operations, First edition, Elsevier.
62. Srdjevic Z., Bajcetic R. and Srdjevic B., (2012) ‘Identifying the Criteria Set for Multicriteria
Decision Making Based on SWOT/PESTLE Analysis: A Case Study of Reconstructing AWater
Intake Structure’, Water Resour Manage, Vol. 26, pp. 3379–3393.
63. Stout S. A. et al. (2017) ‘Assessing the footprint and volume of oil deposited in deep-sea
sediments following the Deepwater Horizon oil spill’, Marine Pollution Bulletin, Vol. 114 (1),
pp. 327-342.
64. Taliotis C., Rogner H., Ressl S., Howells M. and Gardumi F. (2017) ‘Natural gas in Cyprus: The
need for consolidated planning,’ Energy Policy, Vol 107, pp. 197–209.
65. The Safety and Health at Work Laws of 1996 to (N. 2) of 2015 (Unofficial Consolidation and
Translation of the Law)
66. TSO
(2018)
http://www.dsm.org.cy/el/cyprus-electrical-system/electrical-energygeneration/energy-generation-records/yearly/res-penetration (accessed February 24th, 2018)
67. TSO
(2017)
http://www.dsm.org.cy/en/cyprus-electrical-system/electrical-energygeneration/long-term-forecast (accessed December 27th, 2017)
68. Vazhayil J. P. and Balasubramanian R. (2012) ‘Hierarchical multi‐objective optimization of
India's energy strategy portfolios for sustainable development’, International Journal of
Energy Sector Management, Vol. 6, Issue: 3, pp. 301-320.
69. WEC (2016) ‘World Energy Resources 2016, 3. Natural Gas’, World Energy Council.
70. Yüksel I. (2012) ‘Developing a Multi-Criteria Decision Making Model for PESTEL Analysis’,
International Journal of Business and Management, Vol. 7 (24) pp. 52-66.
881
Soft and renewable energy sources
71. Zain M. and Kassim N. M. (2012) ‘The Influence of Internal Environment and Continuous
Improvements on Firms Competitiveness and Performance’, Procedia - Social and Behavioral
Sciences, 65, pp. 26 – 32.
72. Zachariadis T. and Taibi E. (2015) ‘Exploring drivers of energy demand in Cyprus – Scenarios
and policy options’, Energy Policy, Vol. 86, pp. 66–175.
73. Zalengera C. et al. (2014) ‘Overview of the Malawi energy situation and A PESTLE analysis for
sustainable development of renewable energy’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,
Vol. 38, pp. 335–347.
74. Zorpas A. A., Voukkali I. and Pedreno J.N. (2018) ‘Tourist area metabolism and its potential to
change through a proposed strategic plan in the framework of sustainable development’, Journal
of Cleaner Production, Vol. 172, pp. 3609-3620.
75. Zorpas A., Tsangas M., Jeguirim M., Limousy L. and Pedreno J. N. (2017) ‘Evaluation of
renewable energy sources (solar, wind, and biogas) established in Cyprus in the framework of
sustainable development’, Fresenius Environmental Bulletin, Vol. 26, pp. 5529-5536.
76. Zembylas M., Charalambous P. Charalalmbous C. and Lesta S, (2016) ‘Human rights and the
ethno—nationalist problematic through the eyes of Greek-Cypriot teachers’ Education,
Citizenship and Social Justice, Vol. 11 (1), pp. 19 – 33.
882
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
BIOCLIMATIC HOUSE DESIGN BY APPLYING PASSIVE
SYSTEMS AND GREEN ROOF
1
1
S. M. Bagiouk*, 2S. S. Bagiouk, 2A. E. Agiou, 1A. S. Bagiouk
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Aristotle
University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
2
Department of Civil Engineering, Democritus University of Thrace, 67131, Xanthi, Greece
*Corresponding author: 1E-mail: smpagiou@civil.auth.gr, Tel +30 2310 995893, +30 6944189218
Abstract
A major issue that contemporary society deals with is adopting "sustainability" and "viability" values.
The solution to this problem comes through a complex process. In that process the building sector is
a vital factor and should not be eliminated. In this paper, it is presented the design and the construction
of a house that obeys to the principles of bioclimatic design. In this bioclimatic residence, it is applied
passive systems over its building shell. Moreover, one more characteristic which worth to be
mentioned is the use of green roof because of the benefits that derives through it. The aim of this
paper is the design of a building that exploits natural resources, reduces carbon dioxide emissions and
provides thermal comfort to its users. Finally, it is displayed a comparison of the economic and energy
benefits between a bioclimatic home and a conventional one.
Keywords: bioclimatic design, green roof, passive systems, energy benefits, natural resources
1.
INTRODUCTION
Bioclimatic housing is the environmentally friendly building that utilizes natural factors and climatic
data. It is properly adjusted to the topography of the soil and through the right design itis ensured the
creation of the appropriate microclimate, providing coolness in the summer and warmth in the winter.
It is mainly governed by bioclimatic design which is not a new created design trend as it appears to
have been applied since ancient Greece.A characteristic reference is made in the memoirs of
Xenophon, as well as in Hippocrates' work ‘’On air waters and places’’, where reference is made to
Socrates' Solar House and to the principles of bioclimatic architecture respectively, with the sole aim
of ensuring a harmonious relationship between the man and the environment [1]. In modern times,
particularly in Europe, where the building sector is responsible for 40% of total energy consumption
and 36% of CO2 emissions (European Commission of Energy Efficiency in Buildings) the European
Union has been aiming to improve energy efficiency, to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 20%
(compared to 1990), and to increase the amount of RES by 2020[4].In the case of Greece as well as
other Mediterranean climate countries, a bioclimatic house can have a 30% energy savings compared
to a conventional building.However, this savings can also reach 80% if they are compared to an older
one without insulation building[7].Bioclimatic design has the ultimate goal of protecting the
environment, saving energy, reducing operating costs and improving the indoor climate of the
buildings so as to ensure thermal and visual comfort, as well as offering an overall living quality for
users.To achieve this, the correct orientation of the building, the proper layout of the spaces, the
proper design of the building shell is chosen, in order to maximize the sunshine during the wintertime
and minimize it during the summertime and finally a guiding principle of bioclimatic design is being
used, ie the use of passive heating and cooling systems.In the present paper, in the house of which
bioclimatic architecture was studied and depicted, the Trombe wall was chosen as a basic passive
883
Soft and renewable energy sources
system and in addition a planted roof was placed as a passive energy saving technique in order to
provide additional environmental and economic benefits.A bioclimatic house in order to approach
the standards of the ideal residence should not just provide comfort and energy savings, but it is
desirable to offer the user aesthetic satisfaction[2], which in our case is achieved with the planted roof
and the features of bioclimatic architecture.The present paper aims to the highlighting of the energy
and economic gains generated by the use of passive systems and also at the situating of a planted roof
in a hypotheticalhouse designed according to the general principle of bioclimatic design[6].The
passive systems[8] as well as the openings were designed and attached to the south face of the study
building based on the climatic and environmental conditions of Central Macedonia.In addition, the
thermal insulation proposed for the specified house in order to exhibit satisfactory results could
display characteristics (thermal conductivity, specific heat capacity, density etc) close to those of
graphite expanded polystyrene.Finally, the house under study of this paper has been accepted as being
constructed in an open space, remaining unaffected by neighboring buildings.
2.
BIOCLIMATIC DESIGN GUIDELINES AND GREEN ROOF
2.1 House shape and orientation
The house has an elongated shape along the east-west axis, creating a larger surface to the south for
collecting and utilizing solar heat in the winter months through the openings and passive systems [5].
The ratio of its sides is about = 1/1.5 which makes it very close to the ideal one according to the
calculations and the measurements made in various ratios, as with this ratio it is managed to avoid
creating dark spaces as there is no part of the house that is not fully illuminated, even partially[9].As
far as the orientation is concerned, it follows the Southeastern orientation just like the traditional
Greek house[2] as it is considered to be the ideal orientation for the current case and for the
geographical position of Greece, in order to exploit the sun and all the environmental
benefits.Specifically in the house which is examined, the south side was considered for the living
room, the east for the kitchen and the bedrooms and the west side whichis considered most appropriate
for the location of a room mainly used in the winter, where sun protection measures were taken in
order to avoid overheating of the indoor space in the afternoon hours of the summer.Finally, the north
side was considered suitable for warehouses, stairwells and bathrooms which are secondary spaces,
as it offers low levels of lighting during all seasons and is characterized by the cold.
2.2 Spaces Layout
The residence that is designed is a two-storey bioclimatic house with a siting of the interior places
that utilizes every piece of the house for the intended use [5].More generally, the house meets the
general principle of bioclimatic design[6], ie it places the South side for the siting of the most
important functions of the building and for use of passive solar heating systems, while the North side
is appropriate for maintaining the heat and offering protection against the winds.In particular, in the
southern parts of the building are placed the main areas of the house, those rooms in which the tenants
spend most of their time such as the living room (Figure 1 and Figure 2).It is considered to be the
most suitable choice for these places because during the winter months the sun's rays are low on the
horizon and thus they enter deep into the interior by heating and lighting the rooms while during the
summer months the rays are high and with the use of a sunblindthe overheating of the interior spaces
is prevented.On the contrary, on the northern side there are secondary areas and spaces where the
users do not stay for many hours such as a warehouse, bathroom and guesthouse. These spaces are
cooler, require more protection from strong winds, act as a buffer zone against cold winds and reduce
the heat loss of the main use areas.Also on the eastern side there are placed spaces that need to enjoy
the morning sunshine, to warm up in the morning and to cool down at midday hours.Finally in the
west there are spaces that are mainly used in the winter and not spaces such as the kitchen since if the
heat produced by the cooking added to the heat of the sun, the interior space would be overheated at
undesirable levels[16].The need for sun protection of the passive systems and openings to avoid high
temperatures during the summer months, can easily beachieved with the installation of special sun
884
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
blinds. In this case this role is adopted and implemented by appropriately designed and shaped
balconies. In general, the use of sun blinds is not the only option for protection as there is a range of
choices.
Another simple and natural way for sun protection of the building ,as well as its passive systems and
openings, can be achieved by placing deciduous trees and vegetation in the south orientation, which
once again proves that the nature and the environment not only do not oppose the construction but
are allies for a much better result.The layout of the places, the relationship between the sides, the
openings and the architecture are not the only features that make the building unique since it displays
passive systems such as the Trombe wall[8] and the green roof,which besides its energy and economic
benefits provides also aesthetic. (Figure 3).
Figure 1. Ground floor plan view
Figure 2. First floor plan view
885
Soft and renewable energy sources
2.3 Openings
The openings are not designed and manufactured with the same dimensions in all directions but differ
as each dimension serves a different purpose. Large size openings are selected to the south, medium
size in the east and west, while small openings are selected to the north[12] [6]. The larger openings
must be oriented towards the south so as to make the building cool in the summer and warm in the
winter, while on the north side of the building there must be placed solid walls and as small as possible
openings so that they can function as heat-insulation (thermal losses reduction).However, the northern
openings in the house must necessarily exist and not be omitted since they provide adequate natural
lighting, cross ventilation and cooling, especially in the north-south direction during the summer
months.
Figure 3. South view
2.4 Southern Openings Dimensioning
Considering the relationship between outdoor temperature and openings and knowing the mean
outside temperature of the area (4.5 degrees Celsius), a gamut was created within which the area of
the openings would range, by multiplying the area of each space by its coefficients.
Using coefficients from semi-empirical formulas [6] [20], the results are as follows:
Area of Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen= 56,59m2
Minimum Opening Area of Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen= 56,59m2x0,13 = 7,36 m2
Maximum Opening Area of Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen = 56,59m2x 0,21 = 11,88m2
7,36<Opening Area <11,88
Minimum Opening Length of Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen = 7,36/2,20 =3,35
Maximum Opening Length of Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen=11,88/2,20 =5,40
3,35< Opening Length<5,40
Area of Room 3= 19,34
Minimum Opening Area of Room3= 19,34m2x 0,13 = 2,51m2
Maximum Opening Area of Room3= 19,34m2x 0,21 = 4,06 m2
2,51<Opening Area (3,08) <4,06
Minimum Opening Length of Room3= 2,51/2,20 = 1,14
Maximum Opening Length of Room 3= 4,06 /2,20 = 1,85
1,14<Opening Length (1,40) <1,85
886
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Area of Room 2 = 15,17
Minimum Opening Area of Room2= 15,17m2x 0,13 = 1,97 m2
Maximum Opening Area of Room 2= 13,99m2x 0,21 = 3,18 m2
1,97<Opening Area (3,08) <3,18
Minimum Opening Length of Room2=1,97/2,20 =0,90
Maximum Opening Length of Room2= 3,18/2,20 =1,45
0,90<Opening Length (1,40) <1,45
Area of Room 1= 18,34
Minimum Opening Area of Room 1= 18,34m2x 0,13 = 2,38m2
Maximum Opening Area of Room1= 18,34m2x 0,21 = 3,85m2
2,38<Opening Area (3,08) <3,85
Minimum Opening Length of Room1=2,38/2,20 = 1,08
Maximum Opening Length of Room1= 3,85/2,20 = 1,75
1,08<Opening Length (1,40) < 1,75
Table 1. Relationship between average outdoor winter temperature and openings [6] [20]
Average outdoor temperature(°C)
Openingarea / floorplanunit
1.7
0.16-0.25
4.5
0.13-0.21
7.2
0.11-1.17
2.5 Trombewall pre-dimensioning
The Trombe wall [8] is part of the passive solar design systems and achieves indoor heating by taking
advantage of the direct sunlight. It consists of upper and lower opening, glass, gap and high thermal
mass wall. The wall is made of materials with high heat capacity and, in our project the wall is made
of concrete. The determination of the Trombe wall area results from its relationship to the average
outdoor temperature. Using Table 2 [6] [20], combined with the present outdoor temperature of the
region (4.5 degrees Celsius), the following results are obtained:
Area of Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen = 56,59m2
Minimum TROMBE Wall Area of Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen= 56,59m2x0,28= 15,85m2
Maximum TROMBE Wall Area of Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen= 56,59m2x 0,46 = 26,03m2
15,85< TROMBE Wall Area <26,03
Minimum TROMBE Wall Length of Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen=15,85/2,35=6,63
MaximumTROMBE Wall Length of Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen= 26,03/2,35= 11,08
6,63<TROMBE Wall Length <11,08
Area of Room3 = 19,34
Minimum TROMBE Wall Area of Room3= 19,34m2x 0,28 = 5,42 m2
Maximum TROMBE Wall Area of Room3 = 19,34m2x 0,46 = 8,90m2
5,42<TROMBE Wall Area <8,90
887
Soft and renewable energy sources
Minimum TROMBE Wall Length of Room3= 5,42/2,35=2,31
MaximumTROMBE Wall Length of Room3= 8,90/2,35 = 3,79
2,31<TROMBE Wall Length (2,40) <3,79
Area of Room2 = 15,17
Minimum TROMBE Wall Area of Room2= 15,17m2x 0,28 = 4,25m2
Maximum TROMBE Wall Area of Room2= 15,17m2x 0,46 = 6,98m2
4,25<TROMBE Wall Area <6,98
Minimum TROMBE Wall Length of Room2= 4,25/2,35 = 1,81
MaximumTROMBE Wall Length of Room2= 6,98/2,35 = 2,97
1,81<TROMBE Wall Length <2,97
Area of Room1 = 18,34
Minimum TROMBE Wall Area of Room1= 18,34m2x 0,28 = 4,58m2
Maximum TROMBE Wall Area of Room1= 18,34m2x 0,46 = 8,43m2
4,58<TROMBE Wall Area <8,43
Minimum TROMBE Wall Length of Room1= 4,58/2,35 = 1,95
MaximumTROMBE Wall Length of Room1= 8,43/2,35= 3,59
1,95<TROMBE Wall Length <3,59
Table 2. TrombeWall area per indoor area unit 1m2 depending on average winter
temperature [6] [20]
Average outdoor temperature(°C)
TROMBE Wall Area/floorplanunit
-1
0.43–0.78
4.5
0.28 – 0.46
2.6 GreenRoofplacement
The Green Roof is not a finding of the recent years as it emerges from the dawn of civilization and
the Hanging Gardens of Babylon up to the Modern times, where it plays a leading part in many
European cities such as Stuttgart, Germany and the USA as well [14].
For a city to be considered sustainable, according to the European Environment Agency, it should be
corresponded 10sq.m. green per inhabitant [3]. In this need, the green roofs of buildings can play a
leading role and contribute significantly. They can also provide clean air and cover high oxygen
requirements, as only 1.5 square feet of a Green Roof is enough to produce so much oxygen to meet
the annual needs of an adult for clean air [3].
The building was not housed with a sloping roof but it was chosen to be placed a planted roof. This
option, combined with passive systems [8], appropriate openings' size and orientation, aims at
creating a bioclimatic house of great energy potential that, apart from the ecological and economic
benefits, it will also achieve an aesthetic result [2]. The type chosen was the extensive type as it was
considered the most suitable between the semi-intensive and the intensive type that requires higher
planting requirements.
The extensive type [10] is organized on a multi-level stratification with a light growth plant substrate
of 10 to 15 cm high, the maintenance of which requires little care. The load ranges from 70 to 140 kg
/ m and the root system of the plants is superficial. The limited weight does not cause problems and
888
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
fear in the static endurance of the building as it will not lead the total load to exceed the calculated
load predicted by the static study. Then, while in gradients above 20 ° the additional use of retaining
elements of the substrate such as honeycombs are required, in the present construction there is no
such thing since the slope placed is the elementary 2% -2.5%. If the slope of the soil does not exceed
the 1.5%, water accumulation is likely to occur, which can cause a runoff problem and lead to
destruction of the overall structure [13]. In general, care should be taken to avoid stagnant water
accumulation, with particular emphasis on the drainage system, as it may create suffocation
conditions in the roots of plants, which may lead to the failure of the vegetation installation on the
roof. Such cases are avoided when basin planning is in line with national, European legislation and
international standards [15] [13].
Ideal plants for this species are low-vegetation plants with a superficial root system that can easily
breed, such as vegetal rugs, wildflowers, herbaceous plants, sedum and ground cover plants.
The extensive type roof is not suitable for use and access to humans as opposed to semi-intensive and
intensive-type planted roofs [7].
In order to protect the workers who take care of the maintenance of the roof and the electromechanical
installations, railings have been installed as safety measures because the roof of the structure is at a
height of more than 3 m above the ground [10].
The materials in general that play a leading role in the construction[15] of the planted roofs are: the
plant material, the infrastructure materials which are a prerequisite for the vegetation installation and
the irrigation system materials, which are necessary for the vegetation maintenance.All materials and
components selected are resistant to continuous exposure to water, to the biological action of
microorganisms and water-soluble substances, do not contain ingredients that are harmful to plants,
do not create air pollution and are compatible with each other according to the International Standards
in order to ensure mutual chemical compatibility[10].The stratification of the planted roof is being
presented below(Figure 4 ).
Figure 4. Green Roof section
889
Soft and renewable energy sources
So the extensive plant roof type will provide an aesthetic result with many energy and economic
benefits [13]. It will make possible the existence of an ecological landscape with what that entails
with the minimum return, as it offers all the advantages of the Green Roof, requiring a low installation
cost and a low to zero maintenance cost. It also, relieves the user of a series of problems in the
building endurance since it adds to the total load a minimum weight, compared to other types,
intensive and semi-intensive. It also requires minimal care as it does not require daily irrigationwatering of plants from the user. Finally, it provides a high ecological benefit with an immediate
depreciation[12], making the choice of a Green Roof placement even more attractive.
2.7 Innovation in the Green Roof.
In the innovation of the planted roof placement, two more proposals that will frame it and make it
even more special come to add. These two proposals concern the composting and the water
channeling system.Their common denominator is the exploitation of goods that are available but not
exploitable posing the nature as an ally and the recycling as a basic principle[5].
Composting [19] is a natural process that converts organic materials into a richly dark substance
called compost or soil improver. It is a very direct and important method of recycling and it has been
estimated that 35% of household waste can be composted [19]. For the current roof, composting
involves the garbage composting so that the rubbish becomes exploitable. In particular, the garbage
become a fertilizer which is transported to the roof and to the plants of the green roof. This fertilizer
is mainly derived from organic residues and acts as a booster for the growth and healthy preservation
of plants. In the present paper, an extensive type for the planted roof has been chosen using plants
with a superficial root system that easily germinate like sedum, herbaceous plants, herbs, flowers or
lawns a more limited use of compost is made, ie the fertilizer produced. However, in the case of using
another type such as semi-intensive or intensive type, it would be beneficial to make a further use of
compost-fertilizer to achieve corresponding satisfactory results.
Recycling and the full utilization of every element that is already present and around us is not limited
to the use of garbage alone, but extends to the basic and necessary for the plants good, the water.
Hence, the next proposal concerns the water channeling system.In particular, it is proposed that the
water from the daily use other than sewage and the water coming from the rainwater collection should
be concentrated in a reservoir.Then, after the water is set for cleaning (and small treatment) through
a filter it is re-used to irrigate the plants of the green roof.Specifically, the collected and treated
purified water will be transported with a modern system of drainage water into the roof and by
extension on the plants, relieving the user of the house to make additional use of water for watering
the plants of the green roof.Finally, this water that has been treated and cleaned can also be used in
other cases such as housework, watering of the balcony plants, cleaning of the outdoor areas, etc.,
offering thereby the residents more possibilities[17] in combination with the economy and a friendlier
attitude towards the environment.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Advantages and Benefits of the Green Roof
A bioclimatic home that delivers comfort and energy savings it can also offers the user aesthetic
satisfaction, such combination is desirable and brings the construction even closer to the standards of
the ideal housing[5].The aesthetics in the present paper, apart from the building architecture, is
reinforced and highlighted by the extensive Green Roof type with a variety of plants with a superficial
root system that can easily germinate, such as vegetal rugs, wildflowers, herbaceous plants, sedum
and ground cover plants.It is capable of adding color, utilizing the free and usually untapped space to
create a small oasis and even change not only the image of the construction but also a wider whole
such as a city [13]. Besides aesthetic benefits, the planted roof also provides a number of other energy
and economic benefits.Specifically, the extensive type [10] chosen in the planted roof is the most
890
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
appropriate because it combines all the ecological and economic benefits with zero needs and direct
depreciation from the first placement day.Worldwide, it is widely selected but also in the case of
Greece it is considered the most efficient as it is combined with its climate, characterized by strong
winds, temperature fluctuations and limited water sufficiency. In general, it offers multiple benefits
[17] to both their users and the city as well as the whole planet. It improves the air quality as the
planted roofs retain the heavy metals and enrich the atmosphere with oxygen. It reduces the external
noise by 10 decibel lower, compared to a conventional insulation, resulting in the Green Roof to be
seen as an ideal sound-proofing solution [12].The green roof protects the buildings from the fire as it
prevents the spread of fire with the use of the planting water retention, which enhances the buildings
fire safety and also protects them from electromagnetic radiation to a very high percentage of over
95% [7].The planted roof is not limited to the individual house but extends to the whole city level as
it solves the problem of the thermal islands which greatly alters the microclimate of the cities as the
planted roofs offer thermal insulation and shade to the buildings by helping them cool and reduce
their temperature [12].At the city level, it comes to resolve another problem, the flood defense as it
retains and filters over half of the amount of rainwater, providing flood protection in the city[13] and
protecting the water from pollution.Another key sector in which the Green Roof benefits, increasing
further the value of our construction is the economic one. It provides economic benefits as the green
roof of the building is heated and cooled much slower than a typical roof, resulting in the building
being air-conditioned easier, more efficiently and at a lower cost. Even in relation to a conventional
roof, it reduces the superficial terrace temperature, which can reach 80 ° C to 45 ° C, limiting it
thereby even to 35 ° C during the summer days [7] .
Besides the outdoor superficial temperatures reduction, during the summer months it reduces the
indoor temperature of the building by up to 10 ° C while in the winter months it reduces the heat loss
from inside the building [7].All this result in economical and energy benefits for the construction as
the heating and cooling cost of the building is reduced by up to 50% [12].Financial benefits also come
from the building maintenance cost reduction, as the Green Roof protects the surface of the roof not
only from the weather conditions, but also from the radiation, greatly increasing thereby the shelf life
of the roof, which can even reach its doubling[12].The Green Roof building is not only protected
from the damage caused by the weather conditions, but also by the strain of the building due to
thermal contractions and expansions, as the temperature range of variation of the green roof
decreases.Thus, the construction is upgraded because of their high rating in the building energy
identity, resulting in increasing its commercial and objective value [13].
The disadvantages they present are much less and in the present construction measures have
beentaken for them.
The financial burden, the planted roof’s static charge and the continuous care of the garden have been
provided and taken into account with the extensive type choice, while the risk of moisture has been
addressed by proper waterproofing and drainage of the Green Roof [15][10].Finally, a proposal that
can make the green roof even more efficient and provides even more benefits is its combination with
photovoltaics[11].In the construction of the paper it would be very simple and feasible as the planted
roof is of an extensive type.
The plants remain unaffected and at the same time help to make photovoltaics work more efficiently
by relieving them of the problem of overheating [17].
3.2 The Efficiency of Passive Systems and Bioclimatic Architecture.
Passive systems constitute the building elements of the house and belong to the bioclimatic design.
Their function is based on the energy exchange with the environment as well as the proper storage
and distribution of energy within the premises[8].From thermal analyzes made with the use of
software [9][18] (Ecotect Analysis 2011) to houses with passive solar systems (such as the Trombe
wall),with proper interior design and seamless southern sunshine, cooling savings of over 28% and
heating savings of over 27.5% have been achieved.The thermal needs reduction for cooling and
heating becomes more striking, if only the half-day areas and the bedrooms on the southern side
891
Soft and renewable energy sources
where the total energy savings are up to 45% are considered [9].By creating a bioclimatic home
combined with passive systems, the benefits are many not only in the energy, environmental and
economic spheres, but also in the level of comfort and living quality[17][5].Specifically, conditions
of optical and thermal comfort as well as energy saving for heating and cooling are assured. Sunlight
and solar energy and, more generally, renewable sources of energy play a key role in this.In the case
of Greece, which is governed by the Mediterranean climate, the buildings can, after being properly
designed and built, heated by the sun at 70-80% in the winter and in the summer to be kept cool
without air conditioning[6].A fact that makes the need for Bioclimatic Architecture and the use of
passive systems even more urgent[8], as Trombe Wall, in our case.Thus, with a small extra
construction cost, energy saving can be achieved, large future operating costs can be avoided, the
environment can be protected and the houses upgraded to healthy and hospitable buildings [18].But
even with passive solar systems and sufficient sunblinds there cannot be 100% energy autonomy
throughout the year, yet with the addition of the basic passive system, the Trombe wall, and also with
appropriate design based on the climatic characteristics of the area, energy saving for heating 46.6%
but also cooling up to 39.5% for southern thermal zones can be achieved[16][18].So when passive
technologies are implemented and actualized in a proper and satisfactory way, the difference in the
energy balance of the building, which energy technologies are called upon to cover, is very
small.Moreover, a Passive Building is profitable to a large extent when it is the result of bioclimatic
architecture with the right orientation, proper aspect ratio and optimal spaces layout [16].Furthermore,
when it provides high levels of thermal insulation, the desired thermal storage mass that will absorb
excess heat per day and attribute it at night, passive technologies such as modern passive systems and
glass panes that have characteristics that allow for the necessary solar gain income during the day in
winter and limit the thermal losses during the night while not leading to room overheating in the
summer [8].Such a passive house reaches the point of using up to 90% less energy for heating and
cooling than a conventional building as it interacts with the environment and functions as a living
organism that adapts to the local climate and exploits the physical elements [12][16].Although such
a building's potentials are increasing to a very large extent, it is still very difficult to achieve energy
self-sufficiency and independence. For this reason it is proposed to use RES to meet additional energy
needs such as photovoltaic modules[11][18], wind turbines as well as the use and exploitation of
geothermal energy, which is practically an inexhaustible source of energy.Active passive systems
such as photovoltaics or wind turbines can also be installed later, which does not bind the
manufacturer and the user for their selection and installation during the building construction.Finally,
bioclimatic architecture provides many benefits and profits at all levels, making it efficient and
appropriate in many cases [17].Even in large urban centers and in densely-built areas where there is
a concern about the layout of the buildings on the plot, their orientation and shading from the opposite
buildings, there is an answer and such an implementation is possible [6].The answer is not that
bioclimatic design cannot be applied or that bioclimatic design is limited to ideal situations but that
the way of dealing with it should be changed in such a case that there is no bioclimatic home design
but bioclimatic settlement design.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
The two-storey bioclimatic house designed and built according to the principles of bioclimatic
architecture and the addition of passive systems and Green Roof has presented a plethora of
advantages and capabilities that provide the user with a home that covers a large part of its energy
needs, which also with the addition of active systems such as photovoltaics will be able to touch
energy autonomy [18]. A home that offers comfort and living quality in complete harmony with
nature and the environment and multiple economic profits. A number of parameters have been taken,
modern technological means have been utilized and an aesthetic result has been presented that
provides a healthy, functional and efficient building close to the standards of an ideal home that does
not oppose the environment but instead respects, exploits and interacts positively with it.
892
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
References
1. Papageorgioy A., 1993. Xenofon the Athenian, Complete Works 1 – Memoir 1.Kaktos, Athens.
2. Tzelepis P., 1997. Greek Folk Architecture.Themelio, Athens.
3. https://www.eea.europa.eu/el(accessed November 6th, 2017)
4. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=URISERV%3Aen0021(accessedDecember
10th, 2015).
5. Tsipiras K., 1996. The Eco-house. NeaSinora – A. A. Livani, Athens.
6. Axarli K., Giannas S., Evangelinos E., Zaharopoulos E. &Marda N., 2001. Bioclimatic design of
buildings and surroundings. VolumeA, GreekOpenUniversity, Patra.
7. Liu, K and Bascaram B., 2003.Thermal performance of green roofs through field evaluation.
Greening Rooftops for Sustainable Communities, Proceedings of the First North American Green
Roof Conference. Chicago, USA.
8. European Commission, 1998. Energy in architecture, The European Handbook on Passive Solar
Buildings. MalliarisPaideia, Athens.
9. Lantitsou K. and Panagiotakis G., 2012. Bioclimatic Design of a Settlement – Based on
ECOTECT software. 1st Environmental Conference of Thessaly (eds. A. G. Kungolos, O.
Christopoulou, C. Laspidou), September 8–10, Skiathos Island, Greece, 375–382.
10. http://www.cres.gr (accessed September 18th, 2017)
11. Mandalaki M., Papantoniou S. and Tsoutsos T., 2014.Assessment of energy production from
photovoltaic modulesintegrated in typical shading devices. Sustainable Cities andSociety, 10,
222–231.
12. Wines J. 2000.Green Architecture, Koln, Germany.
13. Aravantinos D., Eumoropoulou A., "Planted Roofs", Ktirio Magazine. June 2006, pp. 87-113
14. https://el.wikipedia.org/wiki/(accessed October 9th, 2017)
15. LUCKETT, K. (2009) Green Roof Construction and Maintenance, USA, McGRAW-HILL’S.
16. Κ. Lantitsou,S. M. Bagiouk, G. D. Panagiotakis, S. S. Bagiouk, 2016. Bioclimatic design in a
modern house with Macedonian architecture elements, Proceedings of 13th International
Conference on Protection and Restoration of the Environment, Mykonos Island, Greece, July 3–
8, 2016, pp 864–870.
17. CHESHIRE, D. G., ZAC; (2007) CIBSE Guide L: Sustainability, U.K., CIBSE.
18. Κ. Lantitsou,S. M. Bagiouk, S. S. Bagiouk, G. D. Panagiotakis, 2017. Energy upgrade of houses
by using Autodesk Revit software Case study: Macedonian building in Northern Greece,
Proceedings of Sixth International Conference on Environmental Management,Engineering,
Planning and Economics, Thessaloniki, Greece, June 25-30, 2017, pp 739–748.
19. https://el.wikipedia.org/wiki/ (accessed October 13th, 2017)
20. Andreadaki E. (2006) ΄Bioclimatic Design: Environment and Sustainability΄,UNIVERSITY
STUDIO PRESS, Thessaloniki
893
Soft and renewable energy sources
OPTIMIZATION OF SITE SELECTION OF AN ANAEROBIC
DIGESTION PLANT FOR TREATMENT AND VALORIZATION
OF LIVESTOCK LIQUID MANURE WITH THE AID OF GIS
E.K. Oikonomou*, E. Tekidis and A. Guitonas
Department of Transportation and Hydraulic Engineering, Faculty of Rural & Surveying
Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Hellas
*Corresponding author: e-mail: eoikonom@topo.auth.gr, tel: +30 2310 994360
Abstract
Mygdonia Basin is located mostly in north and northeast part of Thessaloniki Regional Department
and in a small part of north Halkidiki Regional Department, including two lakes, Koronia and Volvi,
the forest of the Macedonian Tembi Valley and many streams forming a dense water network. The
whole area of 2,090 km2 is protected by two Joint Ministerial Decisions, which define all land uses
and economic activities that are allowed to be developed in each of its three zones of protection. The
area of study involves a “Natura 2000” site – “Special Protected Areas” – as well. The area is
characterized for its intense agricultural activities, as well as livestock plants and activities, which
demand a great amount of irrigation water; a great number of the 80,722 inhabitants in 80 small towns
live from such economic activities. However, most of the livestock farms operate without effective
animal wastes management methods, while such wastes involve high organic load.
The present paper investigates the possibility for optimization of site selection of an anaerobic
digestion plant for liquid manure treatment in the area of Mygdonia Basin, with the aid of
Geographical Information System (GIS). For this reason, legal, social, ecological and economic
criteria are set, identified and briefly described. They are related to: the restrictions in land uses and
activities permitted by the two joint ministerial decisions for Mygdonia Basin (legal criteria); a
minimum necessary distance of the proposed anaerobic digestion plant from current towns (social
criteria); the ecological characteristics of the area of study with the “Special Protection Area” and the
local wildlife refuges (ecological criteria); and the need for location of the proposed anaerobic
digestion plant mostly next to the largest livestock farms (economic criteria). With the appropriate
spatial data and spatial analysis within the GIS, the synthesis of all criteria that have been set, is
completed successfully and the site for the anaerobic digestion plant location is chosen. The present
paper set and selected simple criteria, while the problem of site selection for the anaerobic digestion
plant is more complex; however, it is a pilot work showing that there are possibilities to solve
problems in this area that has been polluted for more than two decades. Furthermore, a critical
comment is made related to the implications of Environmental Impact Assessment Study for such a
project, which is strongly affected by land use patterns proposed by General Local Plans.
Keywords: Livestock liquid manure, Anaerobic digestion, Spatial analysis with GIS, Mygdonia
Basin
1.
INTRODUCTION
Anaerobic digestion is a dynamic biodegradation process: wastes with high organic loading are
degraded and stabilized, and thus, converted to biogas methane, carbon dioxide and in less
concentration, hydrogen sulfide, hydrogen, nitrogen gas, etc. As a process it may involve biosolids
894
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
with low concentration in solids (wet digestion) or with high concentration in solids (dry digestion).
Depending on operation temperature, anaerobic digestion is regarded as psychrophilic (10-20oC),
mesophilic (28-38oC) and thermophilic (50-65oC). The whole process is divided into three stages:
hydrolysis of organic matter, with carbohydrates, proteins and fats being broken down to sugars,
amino-acids and fatty acids; acidogenesis, with acidogenic bacteria and hydrogen producing
acetogenic bacteria producing acetate, volatile fatty acids, carbon dioxide and hydrogen; and finally,
methanogenesis, during which methanogenic bacteria produce methane and carbon dioxide [1].
Problems in the process of anaerobic digestion may be observed in case of accumulation of volatile
fatty acids (VFA) during the second stage, when organic loading is high or when hydraulic residence
time is short. Specific growth rate of acidogenic bacteria of the second phase is higher than specific
growth rate of methanogenic bacteria of the third phase and this is the reason why, not all quantity of
volatile fatty acids produced leads to methanization. As a result of this, pH is decreased and anaerobic
digestion is blocked. Imbalance appears usually when the operation of digestors starts and until the
development of satisfactory methanogenic flora; then the process operates well and appears to be
resistant both to changes in substrate as well as any other possible operational accidents, such as high
concentration of ammonia nitrogen. Free ammonia levels should be maintained below 80 mg/l, while
ammonium ion can generally be tolerated up to 1,500 mg/l as NH4+-N [2]. Despite that, it has been
found that with acclimatization (usually several months), stable operation can be achieved for
ammonia nitrogen concentration up to 8,000 mg/l [3].
Anaerobic digestion, apart from sludge stabilization in Wastewater Treatment Plants (WWTPs), is
widely used in high loadings of livestock wastes degradation, producing good quality compost,
without pathogens, and producing simultaneously biogas, which may produce thermal and electric
power by cogeneration. Consequently, the production of biogas by anaerobic digestion of livestock
wastes has many advantages related to: production of renewable energy and reduction of energy
deriving from fossil fuels; decrease of imported fossil fuel from Hellas and European Union;
contribution to livestock wastes treatment and sanitation, which is a major problem in Hellenic
primary sector, causing impacts in water bodies; decrease of greenhouse gas emissions, in terms of
CO2; and finally, positive impacts in creation of new jobs, new economic activities and better
operation of livestock farming activities with cost savings to farmers, since the produced residual of
digestion may be used as a fertilizer, farms may operate without odors and serious environmental
impacts, while their environmental permits may be easier to be obtained [4]. Thus, the process of
anaerobic digestion of livestock wastes contributes mostly to the strategic goals of circular economy.
2.
THE AREA OF STUDY – MYGDONIA BASIN – CRUCIAL PARAMETERS
Mygdonia Basin, with its 2,090 km2 surface, is located in the Region of Central Macedonia, east of
Thessaloniki (Figure 1), and it comprises two lakes, Koronia and Volvi, and the forest of the
Macedonian Tembi Valley with Rihios River (from Lake Volvi to Strymonikos Gulf). Lake Koronia
is about 11 km long and 4.5 km wide (surface of 4,600 Ha and max depth of 8 m), and Lake Volvi,
the second largest lake in Hellas, is about 19.5 km long and 3.4 km wide (surface of 6,800 Ha and
max depth of 21 m). The whole basin is recognized as a region of high ecological importance and it
is protected by two Joints Ministerial Decisions 6919/2004 [5] and 39542/2008 [6], which divide it
into three zones (Figure 2), with several economic activities being prohibited in its one. A
Management Plan o the area is also approved by the Joint Ministerial Decision 58481/2012 [7], which
redefines the boundaries of all protected areas within the Mygdonia Basin, redefines all economic
activities permitted in these areas and determines all necessary processes for every possible permit
and all necessary public authorities that should express their opinion or offer the permits to
developers. The wetlands are characterized as “Special Protected Areas” (code GR1220009) and “Site
of Community Importance” (codes GR1220001 and GR1220003) the two lakes are protected by
Ramsar Convention (code 3GR005) and the Macedonian Tembi Valley belongs to the Network
‘Natura 2000’. More than 1,000 different flora species have been identified in forest ecosystems of
the basin, 343 different bird species have been recorded (58% of total Greek bird species), 34 mammal
895
Soft and renewable energy sources
species have been identified (27 of them protected by Hellenic legislation), 35 reptiles and amphibia
(17 of them protected by Hellenic legislation) and 29 different fish species can be found in Lake
Volvi.
Figure 1: The area of study, Mygdonia Basin with the boundary (in green), the two lakes,
Koronia and Volvi, in the middle of the Basin, and Richios River from Lake Volvi to
Strymonikos Gulf in the east
The basin includes 80 small towns with a total population of 80,722 inhabitants (census 2011), which
are organized in two municipalities and 16 municipal departments (10 of them geographically in the
basin). The most popular economic activities involve agriculture, stockbreeding (28,000 cattle and
106,500 sheep and goats, with total 748 livestock farms), fishing (now mostly in lake Volvi) and
small industries mostly located in the area of Lagkada city, northwest of Lake Koronia. At this point,
it should be underlined that there are many archaeological sites in the basin, as well as many byzantine
monuments and traces of villages near the lakes have been found since the Neolithic Era. Macedonian
Tembi Valley played always a strategic role in history, being the passage for the communication of
Central Macedonia with East Macedonia and Thrace. However, Lake Koronia has been gradually
degraded: in 1945 its surface was 4,858 Ha, in 2002 1,925 Ha and in the summer of 2008, there was
no water surface. Its depth was diminished from 8.5 m in 1977 to 1 m in 2003 and less than 90 cm in
2004 [8].
896
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2: The area of study, Mygdonia Basin with the three subareas: in blue, the area of the
two lakes, in green the protected area around the two lakes and Richios River, and in light
brown the rest of the protected area
Figures 3 and 4: The evolution of the surface of the Lake Koronia 1945-2002 and the great
number of livestock farms, located mostly northwest of the Lake Koronia and north of Lake
Volvi
Lake Koronia suffered from severe environmental degradation: total loss of fish stock and loss of
wetland birds, due to high concentration of organic and mostly inorganic pollutants. The main reasons
897
Soft and renewable energy sources
and parameters for such phenomena are summarized as follows: the reduction of rainfall during the
period 1988-1993; the existence of around 3,000 irrigation drills in the area, most of them informal;
the insufficient irrigation water management, leading to an increase of 23% of water consumption
during the period 1996-2001; pollution from agricultural chemicals, inorganic pollution from small
industrial plants operating illegally without wastewater treatment facilities and organic pollution from
all towns, due to the absence of wastewater treatment plants. It is worth mentioning that pH reached
a value of more than 10, concentration of Na+ was more than 1,200 mg/l, concentration of Cl- was
more than 1,300 mg/l, electric conductivity reached a value of more than 6,000 μS/cm and the ratio
of COD to BOD reached a value of more than 20. In September 2004 all fish died and in October of
the same year around 30,000 birds also died.
It is worth underlining that the Management Body of Lakes Koronia and Volvi expressed its positive
opinion for the operation only of 125 livestock farms out of the total 748 farms, during the process
for the renewal of their environmental permits, because the proposed wastes treatment measures were
criticized as not adequate. The great majority of the farms treat their wastes by separating solid from
liquid, by placing solid wastes in piles, while wastewater is disposed in septic tanks; however, it is
impossible to achieve effluent standards of less than 1,200 mg/l BOD and 4,500 mg/l COD, since
influent concentration reaches from 15,000 – 35,000 mg/l BOD, depending on the type of livestock.
So far, the absence of pollution control measures from public authorities, in combination with the
costs of anti-polluting methods in livestock farms, are responsible for the current situation, which
seems to be changing towards efforts of sustainable manure waste treatment and management. A
possible solution for effective livestock waste treatment in the area of Mygdonia Basin could be
anaerobic digestion for the production of biogas, with the aim of producing heat and electricity.
3.
SITE SELECTION OF THE BIOGAS PLANT
3.1
The process of licensing a biogas production plant by anaerobic digestion of livestock
wastes
The process of licensing a biogas production plant by anaerobic digestion of livestock wastes and
other appropriate types of waste involves many steps, as described briefly in the following
paragraphs:
Firstly, a preliminary investigation is needed related to the current land-use patterns in the area or
the specific land parcel, the possible existence of forest land or archaeological sites, being
obstacles in the process of licensing.
Secondly, a production permit is needed by the Regulatory Authority for Energy if the electric
power produced is more than 1 MW.
Then the environmental permit is achieved, by conducting an Environmental Impact Assessment
Study, either from the Ministry of Environment and Energy or from the Decentralized
Administration/Department of Environment and Spatial Planning. The criterion, according to the
Ministerial Decision 37674/2016, is the influent annual loading of wastes (more or less than
100,000 t/year for biogas production).
Then the installation license is needed offered by the Operator of the Electricity Market.
One more installation license is needed by the Regional Veterinary Department.
The building permit is needed for the construction of the biogas plant.
After the plant is constructed, a license for operation is needed by the Operator of the Electricity
Market, as well as by the Regional Veterinary Department.
The whole process needs 2-3 years to be accomplished, if it is taken into consideration that only for
the environmental permit, 12 – 18 months are needed. Bureaucracy and generally, the operation of
the public sector, as well as a framework of land-uses that is 31 years-old (Presidential Decree of
898
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
1987), and cadastre and forest cadastre not yet existing in many areas in Hellas, are major parameters
that do not aid such investments in renewable energy projects.
3.2 Criteria set for the site selection of the biogas plant
For the site selection for a biogas plant by anaerobic digestion of livestock wastes, spatial, legislative,
social, environmental and economic criteria are proposed to be set [9]:
The spatial criterion is related to the need to select a site as far away from the two lakes as possible.
Legislative criteria are connected to the joint ministerial decisions already mentioned and the most
important commitment is that it is not allowed to choose a land parcel in Protection Zones A and
B.
A social criterion is set that the biogas plant should be located at least 1,000 m away from small
towns and villages. Τhe Special Framework of Spatial Planning and Sustainable Development for
Renewable Energy Resources [10] defines that Renewable Energy Plants up to 5 MW may be
located at no minimum distance from settlements and towns, while for industrial plants a
minimum distance of at least 1,000 m away from towns must be kept, according to Hellenic
legislation and this was set as a criterion in the case study presented.
Environmental criteria are related to a commitment that the biogas plant will be located out of
areas of the Network “Natura 2000” and out of areas characterized as Wildlife Shelters.
The economic criterion is related to the distance of the proposed biogas plant from livestock farms,
according to their livestock capacity, as the more capacity there is an area, the more wastes will be
produced and the less distance they will be transported to the biogas plant.
3.3 GIS data setting and processing
After setting the criteria for the site selection of the biogas plant by anaerobic digestion of livestock
wastes, the GIS data set is formed and spatial analysis starts:
The shapefile “NATURA.shp” is formed by the tool “clip”, using the shapefile of all “Natura
2000” areas in Hellas and the latter is ‘cut’ in the area of study. The shapefile of all “Natura 2000”
areas can be found in the web GIS “geodata.gov.gr/maps”.
Then the shapefile “LIVESTOCK_FARMS.shp” is entered using an available Excel file with
their coordinates.
Zones A and B, which involve protected areas and are excluded as possible areas for the site
selection of the biogas plant, are introduced by the shapefile “ZONES_A_B_merge.shp”, using
the tool “merge”.
Two existing Wildlife Shelters are also introduced by the shapefile “WS_merge.shp”, using again
the tool “merge”.
All zones that should be excluded from possible areas for the site selection of the biogas plant
(Zone A and B of protection areas, “Natura 2000” areas and Wildlife Shelters) are removed from
the area of study, the rest of Mygdonia Basin, Zone C, using the tool “erase” and the shapefile
“ZONE_FINAL.shp” is formed.
All towns with their boundaries and with a buffer of 1,000 m around them are introduced by the
shapefile “TOWNS_WITH_BUFFER.shp” and again by the tool “erase”, the areas of the towns
with their buffer are excluded and a new shapefile is formed, named
“ZONE_FINAL_WITHOUT_TOWNS.shp”. The image formed in the GIS is shown in Figure 5.
The economic criterion, as already mentioned, is related to the fact that the biogas plant should be
located next to the majority of the livestock farms, as calculated not only by the number of farms, but
also by their capacity. For this reason, firstly, the farms in the suitable selected (blue) area are chosen,
899
Soft and renewable energy sources
then the farms nearby this area and finally, the farms with important capacity and density (forming
groups, because of their density). The result is shown in Figure 6.
LEGEND
LIVESTOCK FARMS
AREA SUITABLE FOR THE PLANT
Figure 5: The GIS map, as formed just before the final economic criterion is taken into
consideration
A new shapefile is formed, with the aid of “ExportData”, which is named
“LIVESTOCK_FARMS_MAJOR.shp” and by taking data from the attribute table, it is revealed
that the 78% of the total capacity of the livestock farms is selected in this process.
In order to find the best site for the biogas plants, in terms of minimizing total distance travelled,
the tool “Median Center” is used in order to measure geographic distributions. Thus, a new
shapefile is formed, named “MEDIAN_CENTER.shp”. Consequently, the best site for the
construction of the biogas plant, according to the economic criterion implemented, covering the
78% of the total capacity of the livestock farms, is shown in Figure 7.
As presented in Figure 7, the best site for the biogas plant, “MEDIAN_CENTER”, is located
outside the suitable (blue) area, which is the outcome of the implementation of the legislative,
social and environmental criteria. As a result of this, with the tool “Near” the point which is the
closest to the shapefile “MEDIAN_CENTER.shp”, the exact best site for the biogas plant is
found, taking into account all the criteria set, including the economic one. This point is shown in
Figure 8.
Finally, the final site for the biogas plant construction, set by all the criteria mentioned before, may
be also shown in Google Earth and for this reason, the point is transferred to the system of coordinates
900
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
WGS 84, with the aid of the tool “project”, in order to change the map projection. At the end, the
final shapefile may be transformed to a KML file, by using the tool “LAYER_to_KML.shp”.
Figure 6: The livestock farms selected, taking into account the economic criterion described
4.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
There is an urgent need for Hellas to implement the National Waste Management Plan of 2015, which
proposes recycling of organic wastes by composting or efficient use for energy production, which is
also considered to be a renewable energy resource, as it derives from biogas produced by anaerobic
digestion of the organic wastes. Such methods are important not only because they contribute to
valorization of bio-wastes and avoid landfilling of them, but also because the also offer solutions in
waste treatment. Especially for livestock farms, this is crucial because many of them have introduced
insufficient methods of wastes treatment, with poor results in terms of environmental protection; on
the other hand, public authorities are more efficient in environmental inspections and new
technologies, such as drones and satellite images offer new opportunities in environmental
monitoring, thus, it is much more difficult for livestock farms to support an Environmental Impact
Assessment or even ensure their operation license. In the case study of site selection of a biogas
production plant by anaerobic digestion of livestock wastes in the ecologically sensitive area of
Mygdonia Basin, legislative, social, environmental and economic criteria were set, the data set was
introduced in the GIS and the best site was calculated. This methodology is based on the crucial data
of the exact position of all livestock farms, as well as their exact capacity.
901
Soft and renewable energy sources
LEGEND
MEDIAN_CENTER
LIVESTOCK FARMS (MAJOR)
AREA SUITABLE FOR THE PLANT
Figure 7: The best site for the biogas plant, “Median Center”, according to the economic
criterion of travel – distance minimization
Figure 8: The final site for the biogas plant, taking into account all legislative, social,
environmental and economic criteria
The following issues should be also underlined, as crucial factors, towards sustainable bio-wastes
management:
902
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
It is not obvious how to choose between anaerobic digestion for biogas production and
composting of livestock wastes, with the former producing energy from renewable resources and
the latter leading to quality compost, especially in the case of vermicomposting. Although the two
different processes seem to be competitive, this is not true for two reasons: firstly, because they
can work in synergy e.g. the remaining organic wastes after anaerobic digestion is finished, may
be used in a composting or vermicomposting second-phase process, in order to continue wastes
treatment, thus producing compost for possible use in agriculture; and secondly, because as
Oikonomou et al. (2014) mention [11], there are many small (less than 150 cattle) livestock farms,
decentralized, in Hellenic rural and mountainous areas, and in this case composting or
vermicomposting in each farm may be a more viable solution for effective wastes treatment. On
the contrary, constructing small low-cost effective biogas plants, decentralized in each farm or in
a small group of 2-3 farms, might be a more difficult issue to be implemented.
It is not easy to have an Environmental Impact Assessment study for a biogas plant approved,
while the land-use system is based on the well-known presidential decree of 1987, when such
environmental systems did not even exist. A new land-use framework is just about to be enacted,
however, this is some expectation the last 2-3 years.
The sustainable model may probably be to construct many biogas production plants, one in every
livestock farm, with at least 120 cattle or in a small group of 2-3 farms, as it is better to enhance
effective wastes treatment in the source. This seems to be difficult, as farmers may not be willing
to invest in such environmental systems or may be difficult to persuade, since environmental
legislation is not implemented, while environmental inspections are not so often conducted.
The recent construction and operation of some biogas production plants show that in the
beginning, investors found it difficult to agree with farmers to take their livestock wastes for their
plants, as farmers were very suspicious. On the contrary, some other investors offered to buy their
livestock wastes, leading to a future competition or “stock exchange” of bio-wastes, with negative
impacts on circular economy.
Finally, there is not a framework in Hellas to promote the development of small decentralized biogas
production plants, consequently, up until now the most popular investment amongst them seems to
be medium-sized biogas plants, leading to the need to transfer bio-wastes from several livestock farms
to the biogas plants, thus provoking more negative environmental impacts. It is clear that is
investment is based on profit of the investor and not on sustainable treatment and valorization of
liquid manure wastes.
References
1. Al Seadi T. (2001). ‘Good practice in quality management of AD residues from biogas
production.’ Task 24 - Energy from Biological Conversion of Organic Waste. Published by IEA
Bioenergy
and
AEA
Technology
Environment.
Available
at:
nd
http://www.manuremanagement.cornell.edu/ (accessed February 2 2018).
2. FEC SERVICES LTD. (2003). ‘Anaerobic digestion, storage, oligolysis, lime, heat and
aerobic treatment of livestock manures.’ Final Report / Provision of research and design of
pilot schemes to minimize livestock pollution to the water environment in Scotland. Available at:
http://educypedia.karadimov.info/library/0002224.pdf (accessed February 2nd 2018).
3. Velsen A.F.M. Van. (1979). ‘Anaerobic digestion of wet piggery waste.’. In: Engineering
problems with effluent from livestock, (ed. J.C. Hawkins), CEC, Luxembourg, pp. 476-489.
4. Al Seadi T. and C. Lukehurst. (2012). ‘Quality management of digestate from biogas plants
used as fertilizer.’ Task 37- Energy from Biogas. Published by IEA Bioenergy and AEA
Technology Environment. Available at: https://www.iea-biogas.net (accessed February 2nd 2018).
5. Joint Ministerial Decision 6919/2004. (2004). ‘Characterization of the lake terrestrial and
water environment and the wetland system of the lakes Koronia, Volvi and the Macedonian
903
Soft and renewable energy sources
Volvi as “National Park” and determination of protection zones and definition of land-uses
and restriction of activities and building permits’ Government Gazette D΄ 248/2004 (in Greek,
available at: www.et.gr).
6. Joint Ministerial Decision 93542/2008. (2008). ‘Amendment of the Joint Ministerial Decision
6919/2004’ Government Gazette AAP 441/2008 (in Greek, available at: www.et.gr).
7. Joint Ministerial Decision 58481/2012. (2012). ‘Approval of the management plan of the
National Park of lakes Koronia – Volvi and the Macedonian Tembi’ Government Gazette B΄
3159/2012 (in Greek, available at: www.et.gr).
8. Michaloudi Ε., Moustaka-Gouni Μ., Gkelis S. and K. Pantelidakis. (2008). ‘Plankton community
structure during an ecosystem disruptive algal bloom of Prymnesium parvum.”. Journal of
Plankton Research, vol. 31 (3), pp. 301-309.
9. Ruiz M.C., Romero E., Perez M.A. and I. Fernandez. (2012). ‘Development and application of a
multi-criteria spatial decision support system for planning sustainable industrial areas in Northern
Spain.’ Automation in Construction, vol. 22, pp. 320-333.
10. Joint Ministerial Decision 49828/2008. (2008). ‘Approval of the Special Framework of Spatial
Planning and Sustainable Development for Renewable Energy Resources’ Government
Gazette B΄ 2464/2008 (in Greek, available at: www.et.gr).
11. Oikonomou E.K., Guitonas A. and C. Hatzimarianos. (2014). ‘Anaerobic digestion for treatment
and valorization of cattle liquid manure.’ Fresenius Environmental Bulletin, vol. 23, no. 11, pp.
2707-2711.
904
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
DESIGN OF A GROUND SOURCE HEAT PUMP SYSTEM FOR A
SCHOOL AND A HOTEL OPERATING IN DIFFERENT SEASONS
S.A. Vlachos*, F. Gaitanis and K.L. Katsifarakis
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th, GR54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail:sotiris.vlachos@hotmail.com, tel : +306948729855
Abstract
In this paper, we study the design of a ground source heat pump system (GSHP), which serves both
a school and an adjacent hotel, to improve the financial performance of the project and minimize the
impact on the ground source temperature. For the purposes of this study we assume that the GSHP
provides part of the required heating during the school’s operating months and part of the required
cooling for a five- month- operating period for the hotel.
The paper introduces a simple way to estimate the length of the ground heat exchanger (GHE),
minimizing the total cost of the project. The total cost includes the initial cost composed of drilling,
excavation, heat pumps and piping network. The operational cost is included to account for the energy
consumed for the heating and cooling of the buildings. The peak load for each building is calculated
with the commercial software 4M and the monthly & yearly annual load are calculated with both the
national calculation tool for building energy performance - TEE KENAK and RETScreen 4. For the
calculation of the total length of the GHE, the method proposed by ASHRAE and modified by
Philippe is used. We test multiple scenarios for different thermal load inputs, corresponding to
different percentages of the heating and cooling demand. The economic viability of the project is
determined by calculating the Net Present Value of each of the respective scenarios.
Keywords: Geothermal heat exchanger, Ground Source Heat Pump, RETScreen, Cost optimization
1.
INTRODUCTION
Energy is the principal motor of macroeconomic growth and development, prerequisite for meeting
basic human needs, but at the same time a source of environmental stress. Therefore, its proper use
is a vital component of sustainable development [UNDP, 2002].
During an energy project’s lifecycle, environmental impact differs widely. The pollution of the
atmosphere is primarily caused by the combustion of fossil fuels in energy conversion devices. The
use of nuclear power raises a number of concerns, such as annual generation of 20-30 tons of highlevel nuclear waste [Smith et al, 2017]. The use of biomass for energy has to compete with food
production. Other renewable energy sources such as solar and wind have implications for land-use
[Jenkins, 2015]. Geothermal energy is a renewable energy source which is not bound by the above
limitations.
In particular, ground coupled (or ground source) heat pump systems (GSHP) are among the best
renewable energy technologies. In 2015, geothermal energy contributed to around 3% of total primary
production of renewable energy in the EU-28 countries [Eurostat, 2016]. With regard to other
geothermal applications, they have the largest annual energy production and installed capacity
worldwide, (55.15% and 70.90% respectively). The installed capacity is 50,258 MWt and the annual
energy production is 326,848 TJ/year, with a capacity factor of 0.206 (in the heating mode) [Mac905
Soft and renewable energy sources
Lean et al, 2018]. Although most GSHP systems have been installed in North America, Europe and
China, the number of countries using the technology increased from 26 in 2000 to 43 in 2010 and to
48 in 2015 [World Energy Council, 2016]. Additionally, according to the International Energy
Agency (IEA) geothermal energy could account for around 3.5% of annual global electricity
production and 3.9% of energy for heat (excluding ground source heat pumps) by 2050 [Eurostat,
2016].
The underground heat exchanger of GSHP systems is composed of one or several vertical boreholes,
typically 10–15 cm in diameter and 80–200 m long. In each borehole, a U-tube is inserted and
connected to the HP (Heat Pump). The fluid circulates in the U-tubes to diffuse heat into the ground
in cooling mode or to extract heat from the ground in heating mode. The design of GLHE (GroundLoop Heat Exchangers) systems requires a forecast of the fluid temperature reached at any time
during the exploitation of the system; that temperature is a function of the building variable needs
and of the GLHE design and operation. The goal is to ensure that the HP capacity and specifications
are neither exceeded nor underexploited.
2.
METHODOLOGY
The total cost of the project is obtained by summing the operating costs and the initial capital invested.
Every annual money flux is converted into its present value, by means of the pertinent well-known
formula.
2.1 Operating cost
The operating cost is the cost of the energy, which is consumed by the heat pump, the heat transfer
fluid circulation pump and the backup heating and cooling system. The substantial factor determining
the overall behaviour of the shallow geothermal installation is the seasonal heat pump performance.
During the heating period, GHP consumes electricity (QHP) to pump heat from the ground (QG). The
sum of QG and QHP is delivered to the building. In a similar way, during the cooling period, GHP
consumes electricity (QHP) to pump heat from the interior of the building (QB) and to deliver it to the
ground (QG). The mathematical description for the heating and cooling period respectively takes the
form:
QBh = QGh + QHPh (kW)
(1)
QGc = QBc - QHPc (kW)
(2)
From its definition, the efficiency coefficient of the heat pump is mathematically described by the
relationship:
COP= QB / QHP
(3)
The Coefficient Of Performance (COP) of the heat pump usually results as a function of the fluid
inlet temperature of the pump and is provided by the manufacturers.
2.2 Initial cost
The initial cost is the sum of the costs of the heat pump, drilling, excavation and piping:
𝐶𝑖𝑛𝑖𝑡𝑖𝑎𝑙 = 𝐶𝐻𝑃 + 𝐶𝑑𝑟𝑖𝑙𝑙 + 𝐶𝑒𝑥 + 𝐶𝑝𝑖𝑝𝑒
(4)
The heat pump purchase cost is a function of the maximum heating load that could be delivered to
the building by the heat pump. The heat pump cost is evaluated by the following empirical formula:
906
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
𝐶𝐻𝑃 = 0.0443 ∗ 𝑄ℎ𝑒𝑎𝑡 2 + 455.63 ∗ 𝑄ℎ𝑒𝑎𝑡
(5)
where Qheat is the capacity of the heat pump [kW]. Drilling cost depends on the number of the
boreholes and their depth. For our study the cost per meter was assumed 35 €/m with the mathematical
description:
𝐶𝑑𝑟𝑖𝑙𝑙 = 35𝑁𝑥 𝑁𝑦 𝐻
(6)
Nx equals to the number of boreholes in the x axis, Ny equals to the number of boreholes in the y axis
and H is the depth of the borehole.
Excavation is required in order to install the borehole-connectcting pipes. The evaluation of the
excavation cost was performed considering that one trench is needed for every row in the x-direction
to link the boreholes together. In the present work, we used trench dimensions of 0.6 m width and 1.2
m of depth. So, the excavation cost could be evaluated by:
𝐶𝑒𝑥 = 9.6[𝑁𝑦 (𝑁𝑥 𝐵) + (𝑁𝑦 𝐵)]
(7)
Piping cost depends on the length needed. Since the diameter of each pipe might be different, their
actual cost per unit length would likely be different. Therefore, the cost for the piping is:
𝐶𝑝𝑖𝑝𝑒 = 2 ∗ 3 ∗ [𝑁𝑥 𝑁𝑦 𝐵 + 𝑁𝑦 𝐵 + 𝑁𝑥 𝑁𝑦 𝐻]
3.
(8)
CALCULATION OF THE LENGTH OF A GEOTHERMAL HEAT EXCHANGER
To determine the length of the geothermal heat exchanger we use the equation proposed by ASHRAE
and modified by Phillipe and Bernier [ASHRAE, 2009]. This method, based on Kavanaugh and
Rafferty's work, requires the peak load, the maximum average monthly load, and the average annual
load provided by the geothermal heat exchanger. The peak load of each building was calculated,
based on the design study of the existing heating system, following the ASHRAE specifications,
while the maximum average monthly load and average annual load were determined by means of the
national (Greek) calculation tool for building energy performance TEE-KENAK. To ensure speed in
the calculations, according to Kavanaugh and Rafferty - as amended by Bernier - we use the
mathematical expression below:
(9)
Where L = total drilling length (m), Tm = average fluid temperature in the borehole (oC), Tg =
undisturbed ground temperature (oC) and Tp = temperature effect - representing the correction of Tg
due to thermal interference between boreholes (oC). Temperatures can be conveniently measured in
o
C, since temperature differences have the same value in oC and K. Moreover, qy, qm and qh are equal
to the annual average ground load, the highest average monthly ground load and the peak hourly
ground load, respectively, measured in W. Equation 1 is based on the worst-case scenario represented
by three successive thermal pulses with durations corresponding to 10 years, one month, and six
hours, as shown in Figure 1 [Philippe et al, 2010].
R10y, R1m, R6h represent soil thermal resistance for soil loads corresponding to 10 years, one month
and six hours (m∙K/W). They are expressed as follows [Philippe et al, 2010]:
907
Soft and renewable energy sources
Figure 1: Three consecutive ground load pulses (source: Philippe, 2010)
1
R6h =𝑘 G (αt6h / r2bore)
(10)
1
R1m= 𝑘 [ G (at1m+6h / r2bore) – G (αt6h / r2bore )]
R10y=
1
𝑘
(11)
[ G (αt10y+1m+6h / r2bore ) – G (αt1m+6h / r2bore)]
(12)
G-function represents the cylindrical heat source solution, k is the ground thermal conductivity (Wm1 -1
K ), a is the ground thermal diffusivity (m2day-1) and rbore is the borehole radius (m).
The cylindrical heat source solution is strictly valid for one-dimensional (in the radial direction)
transient heat transfer. As mentioned by Philippe et al (2010), Eskilson (1987) has shown that axial
effects start to be significant, after a time period equivalent to H 2//(90a), where H is the borehole
depth. The error introduced when using the cylindrical heat source has been calculated by Philippe et
al (2010).
Based on these results, it appears that the axial effects are only significant for the R 10y term and that
the error remains below 5% for typical values of thermal diffusivities. More accurate solutions, such
as the two-dimensional finite line source model could be used [Eskilison, 1987].
The resulting deliverable is the number NB of boreholes that can be constructed in the available area,
while the entire calculation procedure follows specific constraints concerning the Tp correlation,
which is valid between adjacent boreholes.
The constraints are:
-2 ≤ ln (t / ts) ≤3
(13)
4 ≤ NB ≤144
(14)
1≤A≤9
(15)
0.05 ≤ B / H ≤ 0.1
(16)
908
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
where B is the distance between successive drillings, based on the available ground surface
(considered as rectangular) and A the ratio of drillings’ numbers along its two dimensions.
3.1 Optimization procedure
With the above methodology, we have determined the length of the geothermal heat exchanger for
each building. To deliver the optimal drilling field covering both buildings, we have explored the cost
of installing the system to cover different percentages of the peak load (ranging from 10% to100%).
We have used the RETScreen 4 software to determine the relationship between power and total
energy production for each case, the TEE-KENAK software to calculate the energy demand. The
optimization methodology is based on the one presented by Gaitanis et al (2014).
4.
CASE STUDY
A school and a hotel nearby were chosen [Vlachos, 2017]. The two-storey school has rectangular
shape, with dimensions 33.14 x 12.00 m (Figure 2). The four-storey hotel has square shape with
dimensions: 15.55x15.00 m (Figure 3). Both buildings have an inclined tiled roof and the internal
height of each floor is 3.00 m. The school building is north to south oriented. Both buildings are
located in Paramythia (NW Greece), which belongs to climate zone C. The total area of the structural
elements of the buildings in the four main orientations, the heat transfer coefficient of each element
as well as the average heat transfer coefficient of the building are presented in Tables 1 and 2.
Figure 2: Plan view of the school (Spyropoulos, 2012)
Table 1: Heat transfer coefficients of the School building per structural element and
orientation
2
Area (m ) and orientation of the element
Heat transfer
Structural element
coef. (W/m2K)
North
South
East
West
Masonry walls
201.15
214.51
121.60
121.60
5.20
Reinforced concrete
50.33
74.41
58.02
58.02
4.40
Windows
57.51
98.85
18.82
24.5
4.10
Doors
3.01
8.25
0.00
0.00
5.00
Masonry wallsab
53.8
30.22
0.00
0.00
3.10
Reinforced concreteab
21.4
20.11
0.00
0.00
2.80
Floor
1053.64
3.75
909
Soft and renewable energy sources
Figure 3: Plan view of the typical floor of the hotel (Spyropoulos, 2012)
Table 2: Heat transfer coefficients of the hotel building per structural element and orientation
Area (m2) and orientation of the element
Heat transfer
Structural element
coef.
(W/m2K)
North
South
East
West
Brick walls
133.15
134.17
182.34
149.53
0.59
Reinforced concrete
45.21
44.19
81.55
35.61
0.62
Windows
0.00
52.70
50.16
44.55
3.40
Doors
3.01
0.00
3.12
0.00
2.20
Brick wallsab
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.39
Reinforced concreteab
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.48
Floor
1234
0.54
In Tables 1 and 2, index ab indicates structural element above non-heated space. The large differences
in heat transfer coefficients of the two buildings is due to the following reason: The structural
elements of the school, which was built in 1937, are not insulated and its windows are single-glazed.
On the contrary, the hotel bears insulation and double-glazed windows.
5.
RESULTS
First, we checked each building separately. Results regarding the number of required boreholes and
the total borehole length appear in the diagrams of Figures 4 and 5. It is clear that the heating
requirements are larger.
910
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Numbers of Boreholes per case
90
N
u
m
b
e
r
s
B
o
r
e
h
o
l
e
o
s
f
80
70
60
50
Hotel
40
School
30
20
10
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90 100
Percentage of maximum power coverage
Figure 4: Number of boreholes considering the two buildings separately
Total Length per case
T
o
t
a
l
L
e
n
g
t
h
6000
5500
5000
4500
4000
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
Hotel
School
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90 100
Percentage of maximum power coverage
Figure 5: Total drilling length considering the two buildings separately
Then we turned to the combined heating-cooling system and we checked the following combinations
in order to select the optimal one (C stands for cooling and H for heating):
C100 % - H70% C90% - H70% C 80% - H 60% C70% - H50%
C60%- H40% C50% - H30% C40 % - H30% C30% - H20%
911
Soft and renewable energy sources
These combinations ensure minimum long-term temperature change of the ground. Among them, we
try to find the one with the smallest cost (for a 20-year period), taking into account the auxiliary
heating and cooling sources.
Number of boreholes combined
60
N
u
m
b
e
r
s
B
o
r
e
h
o
l
e
o
s
f
50
40
School
30
Hotel
20
10
0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Percentage of maximum power coverage
Figure 6: Number of boreholes for the combined heating-cooling system
4500
Length of boreholes combined
T
o 4000
t
3500
a
l 3000
L
e
n
g
t
h
2500
School
2000
Hotel
1500
1000
500
0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Percentage of maximum power coverage
Figure7: Total borehole length for the combined heating-cooling system
In the diagrams of Figures 6 and 7, the required number of boreholes and the total borehole length
for the combined heating-cooling system are presented. Comparative results regarding the total cost
for the 20 year period appear in Table 3 and in the diagram of Figure 8. It can be concluded that the
combination C50-H30 is the optimal one.
912
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 3: Aggregated financial results of possible final installation and operating combinations
over 20 years
Assumptions
Cost of
Drilling
Cost of
Excavations
Pipeline
Costs
Pump
Costs
C100-H70
110.884
1.708
20.183
112.730
C90-H70
103.761
1.627
18.909
107.379
C80-H60
90.073
1.423
16.428
C70-H50
79.958
1.260
C60-H40
66.731
C50-H30
Hotel's air
conditioning
unit
Cost
Boiler
Operating
Cost
Total
Cost (€)
1.405
209.248 456.158
5.754
1.410
192.209 431.049
93.414
11.518
1.581
196.140 410.575
14.586
79.490
17.291
1.727
206.679 400.990
1.055
12.182
65.609
23.073
1.856
220.038 390.543
56.581
931
10.359
51.769
28.864
1.973
225.202 375.680
C40-H30
55.451
889
10.138
46.477
34.666
1.973
226.392 375.984
C30-H20
40.817
681
7.489
32.691
40.476
2.080
287.696 411.930
Total Cost
480,000
440,000
400,000
360,000
320,000
280,000
240,000
200,000
Total Cost
160,000
120,000
80,000
40,000
0
Figure 8: Total cost for the 20-year period
6.
CONCLUSIONS
One of the main barriers to the penetration of renewable energy sources, such as GSHP, is the high
initial cost, the recovery of which can be achieved in the long run due to the low operating cost.
Sharing the initial cost to installations that operate in different periods of the year and in different
modes, can improve the GSHP financial performance. In this paper, we have studied a GSHP serving
both a school and a hotel, operating during the heating and the cooling period respectively. Our results
show that the best financial results are achieved, when the GSHP system is planned to cover 50% of
the cooling demand and 30% of the heating demand, with minimum change of the ground
temperature. While these results are site-specific, the proposed methodology can be easily applied to
other cases with different climate, building and ground features.
913
Soft and renewable energy sources
References
1. ASHRAE (2011) ‘ASHRAE Handbook-HVAC Applications’.
2. Eskilson P. (1987) ‘Thermal Analysis of Heat Extraction Boreholes’, Ph.D. Thesis, University
of Lund, Department of Mathematical Physics, Lund, Sweden.
3. Eurostat
(2016)
http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/environmental-data-centre-on-naturalresources/natural-resources/energy-resources/geothermal-energy (accessed February 1st, 2018).
4. Gaitanis F., Katsifarakis, K.L. and Bikas D. (2014) ‘Economic Optimization of Systems
Combining Vertical Ground Heat Exchanger with Conventional Heating and Cooling Systems’,
10th National Conference on Renewable Energy Sources, pp. 1179-1188, Thessaloniki, Greece
(in Greek).
5. Jenkins J. (2015) How Much Land Does Solar, Wind and Nuclear Energy Require?
6. Kavanaugh S.P. and Rafferty K. (1997) ‘Ground-Source Heat Pumps: Design of Geothermal
Systems for Commercial and Institutional Buildings’, ASHRAE, Atlanta.
7. Lund, J.W. and Boyd T.L., (2016) ‘Direct Utilization of Geothermal Energy 2015 Worldwide
Review,’ J. Geothermics, 60, pp. 66-93.
8. Mac-Lean C. (2018) ‘Application of low enthalpy geothermal energy: the case of low
enthalpy of physical and mathematical sciences at the university of Chile’, Int. J. of Energy
Prod. & Mgmt., 3(1), pp. 69-78.
9. Philippe M., Bernier M. and Marchio D. (2010) ‘Sizing Calculation Spreadsheet Vertical
Geothermal Borefields,’ ASHRAE J., 20, pp. 20-28.
10. Robert F. and Gosselin L. (2014) ‘New Methodology to Design Ground Coupled Heat Pump
Systems Based on Total Cost Minimization,’ J. App. Ther. Eng. 62, pp. 481-491.
11. Shortall R., Davidsdottir B., and Axelsson G. (2015) ‘Geothermal Energy for Sustainable
Development: A review of Sustainability Impacts and Assessment Frameworks’, J. Ren. And
Sustain. En. Rev., 44, pp. 391-406.
12. Smith S., Clark M., Fairbanks T., Prinzi T., Delgado K. (2017) Nuclear Power – Pros and Cons
Thermodynamics
13. UNDP (2002) ‘Energy for Sustainable Development: A Policy Agenda’, United Nations
Development Program.
14. Vlachos S. (2017) ‘Design of a vertical geothermal heat exchanger system serving a school
and a hotel that operate in different periods of time’, Master thesis, Dept. of Civil Engineering,
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece (in Greek).
15. World Energy Council (2016) ‘World Energy Resources’
914
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
FEASIBILITY STUDY OF A FLOATING OFFSHORE WIND
FARM IN GREECE
V. Kafritsa* and E. Loukogeorgaki
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th, GR54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: vicky.kafritsa@gmail.com, tel: +302310995951
Abstract
Offshore wind energy presents an abundant renewable energy source that can contribute to the
satisfaction of the European Union’s energy policy targets. Although nowadays large-scale Offshore
Wind Farms (OWFs) have been commercially deployed in shallow waters areas, the existence of
stronger and more consistent wind fields in offshore areas of deeper waters has triggered the
development of floating Offshore Wind Turbines (OWTs) of large capacity and has very recently
lead to the installation of the first pilot floating OWF. Greece is a Mediterranean country with a vast
wind energy potential at specific marine areas characterized by deep-water conditions. Thus, the
potential of deploying floating OWFs should be considered and examined.
Motivated by this, the aim of the present paper is to determine the economic feasibility of a floating
OWF in Greece. The proposed OWF is considered to be deployed at a marine location in the northcentral Aegean (east of Mykonos island), which satisfies specific sitting criteria, and it is designed to
cover the annual energy demands of Mykonos, Delos and Rhenia islands. For the development of the
proposed investment, two alternative scenarios are examined, by modifying the number and the rated
power of the OWTs, as well as the distances between them. The 1st scenario corresponds to an OWF
with 11 floating OWTs (spar buoy floating platform) of 33 MW total rated power, while the 2 nd one
to an OWF with 7 floating OWTs (spar buoy floating platform) of 35 MW total rated power. The net
annual energy production of the two alternative scenarios is estimated considering wake losses,
electrical losses and OWTs’ availability. Wake effects are estimated using Jensen’s model. The
selection of the best scenario is based on the comparison of the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) of
the two alternatives. The finally selected scenario (1st scenario) is evaluated using the net present
value method, the internal rate of return and the payback period of the investment.
The results indicate that the most important parameter affecting LCOE and, therefore, determining
the final investment decision between the two proposed alternative scenarios, is the OWF’s capacity
factor. Moreover, the results of the economic analysis/evaluation of the finally selected scenario
clearly illustrate the economic sustainability of the proposed OWF and, therefore, its potential for
covering effectively the annual energy demands of the examined islands.
Keywords: Floating offshore wind farm, Levelized cost of energy, Investment evaluation, Net
present value, Internal rate of return
1.
INTRODUCTION
The recent vast industrialization, the increasing population trends and, therefore, the increasing
energy demands have led the governments worldwide to search for renewable energy resources, in
order to reduce the dependence on fossil fuel and support environmental sustainability. It is essential
for the power generation industry to face the daunting challenge in meeting global energy needs,
915
Soft and renewable energy sources
which will double globally and triple in developing countries by 2030. The solution to the power
generation problem may be given by the exploitation of appropriate wind power generation systems,
which have been already used since 1970s (Kaldellis and Za, 2011). Such systems providing not only
a wide range of environmental benefits, but constituting an attractive techno-economical solution to
the power generation problem are, nowadays, of particular interest.
Wind power generation systems, mostly known as wind farms, are utilized onshore or offshore.
Though they have higher capital costs than onshore wind farms, Offshore Wind Farms (OWFs) have
attracted great interest recently, as they allow the generation of large amounts of electricity from wind
energy (IRENA, 2012). Offshore, average mean wind speeds tend to be higher than onshore;
therefore, the electricity output can be increased by 50% compared to onshore wind farms (Li et al.,
2010). Additionally, going offshore enables turbines to be installed in plentiful numbers without the
planning and space constraints found onshore (Tong, 1998). Ultimately, OWFs will allow a much
greater deployment of wind in the longer-term. At the end of 2017, Europe has a total installed
offshore wind capacity of 15.78 GW corresponding to 92 OWFs located mainly in the coastal and
offshore areas of Northern Europe (EWEA, 2018). Greece, contrary to the northern European
countries, has not yet begun to exploit its offshore wind energy potential. In the framework of
supporting the future development of Greece’s offshore wind policy, a feasibility study of an OWF
located in the Greek seas is of significant importance.
A feasibility study aims to uncover objectively and rationally the strengths and weaknesses of a
proposed project, the opportunities and threats existing in the natural environment, the resources
required to carry through, and ultimately the prospects for success (Georgakellos and Marcis, 2009).
In its simplest terms, the two criteria to judge feasibility are cost required and value to be attained
(Young, 1970). Many authors have already conducted feasibility studies for offshore wind farms
(Pantaleo et al., 2005; Ozerdem et al., 2006; Kim et al., 2013; Satir et al., 2018). Konstantinidis et al.
(2014) implemented a viability analysis of an OWF in the Greek sea area based on a technoeconomical study. Using the software RETScreen, the annual energy generation was estimated.
Followed by the cost estimation, the investment’s viability was investigated using the Net Present
Value (NPV), the Internal Rate of Return (IRR), the Benefit to Cost Ratio (BCR) and the Cost of
Energy (COE).
In the present paper, a techno-economic feasibility analysis of a floating OWF in Greece is presented.
The proposed OWF is considered to be deployed at a marine location in the north-central Aegean
(east of Mykonos island), which satisfies specific sitting criteria, and it is designed to cover the annual
energy demands of Mykonos, Delos and Rhenia islands. For developing the proposed investment,
two alternative scenarios, that differ in terms of the number of Offshore Wind Turbines (OWTs), the
OWTs’ rated power and the distances between OWTs, are proposed and examined. The choice of the
best solution is based on the comparison of the Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE) of the two
alternative scenarios. The scenario, finally, selected is financially evaluated using the NPV method,
the IRR and the Payback Period (PP) of the investment.
2.
SITE SELECTION AND TECHNICAL DESCRIPTION
2.1 Site Selection
In the present paper, the OWF is proposed to be installed at a marine area located in the north-central
Aegean and, more specifically, east of the Mykonos island (Figure 1), 42 km from the existing port
of Mykonos. The coordinates (based on the Hellenic Geodetic Reference System 1987) of the specific
quadrilateral polygon ABCD (Figure 1), where the OWF is proposed to be installed, are shown in
Table 1. The proposed area has been selected based on the results of Vasileiou et al. (2017), where a
GIS-based multi-criteria decision analysis for the site selection of hybrid offshore wind and wave
energy systems in Greece has been implemented. According to that study, the proposed marine area
can be considered eligible for the deployment of an OWF, since it does not satisfy a set of exclusion
criteria related to: (a) utilization restrictions imposed by human activities and environmental
916
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
constraints (e.g. the specific site does not correspond to an area for military operations or
hydrocarbons’ exploration/exploitation and or to a marine protected area), (b) economic/technical
constraints (i.e. mean wind speed is larger than the threshold of 6 m/s, water depth is smaller than the
threshold of 500 m) and (c) social implications (i.e. the distance from the shore of the selected area
is larger than the threshold of 25 km). Moreover, the selected area is characterized by significant wind
speeds (6-8 m/s, 10 m above the mean water level) and water depths (60-200 m) that advocate the
deployment of a floating OWF (Vasileiou et al., 2017), while the recent development of electricity
transmission infrastructure between Mykonos and mainland, through the Tinos and Andros islands,
may contribute to costs’ reduction.
Figure 1: Marine area in the north-central Aegean (red sign) for the deployment of a floating
OWF
Table 1: Exact coordinates of the polygon, where the OWF is proposed to be installed
Point
Easting
Northing
A
641680
414974
B
645040
414974
C
645040
413406
D
641680
413406
Wind data, consisting of wind speeds and wind directions, is of significant importance for the Annual
Energy Production (AEP) calculations. In the present paper, due to lack of field data for the selected
marine area, the required wind data were obtained from the Global Wind Atlas using WaSP software
(Mortensen et al., 2011). Based on this data, in the examined marine area winds of northern direction
mainly exist, while the average annual wind speed, 100 m above the mean water level, is between 7.4
m/s and 8.5 m/s.
2.2 OWF Scenarios
In the present paper, two alternative scenarios (S1 and S2) of a floating OWF, covering the annual
needs of the islands of Mykonos, Rhenia and Delos, are examined. Specifically, based on the wind
conditions of the selected marine area, the examined scenarios are formed by deploying two different
types of WTs: (a) the WT V112-3 MW (Vestas SA) and the WT G128-5 MW (Gamesa Corp.), which
917
Soft and renewable energy sources
is suitable for windier sites with an average wind speed at the hub height up to 8.5 m/s. The
aformentioned types of turbines have 112 m and 128 m rotor diameter and 3 MW and 5 MW rated
power respectively. The hub heights above the mean water level are taken equal to 94 m and 95 m
respectively. Considering a mean capacity factor of around 40% (Dodson et al., 2005), the AEP for
each WT is estimated equal to 10512 MWh/year and 17520 MWh/year respectively. Based on these
values and aiming at covering the annual energy demand of Mykonos, Rhenia and Delos, which for
the year 2013 was 113000 MWh (RAE, 2013), the number of WTs required for each examined
scenario is, then, defined. The corresponding results are shown in Table 2. It is noted that for both
scenarios, a spar-buoy floating platform is seleted as the supporting structure of each OWT.
Table 2: Technical characteristics and AEP of the examined OWF scenarios
Examined
scenario
Type of WT
Number of
WTs
OWF total rated power
(MW)
AEP estimation
(MWh/year)
S1
V112-3 MW
11
33
115632
S2
G128-5 MW
7
35
122640
In both scenarios, the WTs are organised into two rows, as shown in Figure 2. As a rule of thumb, the
distance of the WTs in an OWF is taken between 5 and 9 rotor diameters along the prevailing wind
direction, and between 3 and 5 diameters in the direction perpendicular to the prevailing winds. Based
on the above, for each examined scenario the in-between distances of the WTs are taken equal to 7
rotor diameters along the north direction (prevailing wind direction) and 5 rotor diameters in the
direction perpendicular to the prevailing winds, as shown in Figure 2. Finally, it is assumed that there
is no need for an offshore substation due to the low capacity of the proposed floating OWF.
Figure 2: Distances (m) between the WTs for the examined scenarios
2.2 Energy Production
In the present study, gross AEP for each WT is estimated considering the Weibull distribution of the
wind obtained by WaSP (Mortensen et al., 2011), along with the power curve of the WT selected for
each scenario. As for the net AEP, this quantity is estimated by calculating losses due to wake effects
according to Jensen’s model (Jensen, 1983), where the frequency of wind direction is taken into
account. The corresponding results are presented in Table 3.
It should be mentioned that the wind data obtained from the Global Wind Atlas and used for
calculating the net AEP values of Table 3 (111113.60 MWh/y and 104450.56 MWh/y for S1 and S2
respectively) are based on onshore measurements. However, in the marine site, where the OWF is
proposed to be installed, obstacles in the prevailing wind direction contrary to an onshore site do not
exist. Therefore, the mean wind speed at the examined area is expected to have a bit larger values
than the ones obtained from the Global Wind Atlas. This is also confirmed by RAE statistics, where
the mean wind speed at the examined area appears to be 10% larger than the mean wind speed
obtained from the Global Wind Atlas. Thus, combining all the above, a correction of the net AEP
values of Table 3 is required in order to account for larger mean wind speeds. In the light of the above,
918
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
a conservative 24% increase of the net AEP is assumed in the present study. Moreover, considering
95% availability of the floating OWF and annual electrical losses equal to 2%, the final net AEP for
scenarios S1 and S2 is estimated to reach 128275 MWh/year and 120583 MWh/year respectively.
Based on the above, the capacity factor for scenarios S1 and S2 is evaluated to be equal to 44% and
39% respectively, which correspond to quite conservative values.
Table 3: Gross and Net AEP for each floating OWF scenario
Scenario 1 (33 MW)
Scenario 2 (35 MW)
Losses
(%)
WT
No.
WT1
10956.84
3.18
WT2
10415.92
WT3
WT4
Gross
AEP
(MWh/y)
Net AEP
(MWh/y)
Losses
(%)
WT1
16007.27
3.24
7.96
WT2
15191.38
8.17
10132.66
10.46
WT3
14892.52
9.98
10096.27
10.79
WT4
15100.09
8.72
10147.85
10.33
WT5
14722.82
11.01
10352.57
8.52
WT6
14254.19
13.84
WT7
10116.02
10.61
WT7
14282.29
13.67
WT8
9768.25
13.68
WT9
9677.20
14.49
WT10
9664.23
14.60
WT11
9785.80
13.53
111113.60
10.74
104450.56
9.80
WT5
WT6
Total
3.
Gross
AEP
(MWh/y)
Net AEP
(MWh/y)
WT
No.
11316.80
124484.83
Total
16543.50
115804.50
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS/EVALUATION
For realizing an economical sustainable OWF project, the OWF should be capable of producing
energy not only in a long-term, but also in a cost-efficient manner. As a result, a financial
analysis/evaluation is necessary to illustrate the viability of the proposed OWF, by taking into account
the energy production cost as well as the market value of the generated energy (Manwell et al., 2009).
In the present study, a financial analysis of the two floating OWF scenarios is implemented to define
the most profitable solution by estimating the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) for each scenario.
The finally selected scenario is, then, evaluated using the Net Present Value (NPV) method, the
Internal Rate of Return (IRR) and the Payback Period (PP) of the investment. The procedure followed
is briefly described in Figure 3.
For both scenarios, LCOE is calculated considering Capital Expenditure (CapEx), Operational
Expenditure (OpEx) and the Net AEP (Myhr et al., 2014). In the present paper, CapEx including the
construction financing, development costs and operational capital besides the investment, is estimated
based on Mone et al. (2015) and Heidari (2017). Regarding OpEx, this is rarely reported by
developers, so, high amount of uncertainty applies due to lack of empirical data. In this study,
investment costs are estimated based on personal communication with a representative from Athens
Business Consulting-ABEC LP. In the following paragraphs the results of the economic
analysis/evaluation are presented.
919
Soft and renewable energy sources
3.1 CapEx and OpEx Estimation
CapEx estimation for both floating OWF scenarios is presented in Table 4. The estimated turbine cost
includes the tower and the Rotor-Nacelle-Assembly (RNA) cost. Insurance and contingency are
considered to be equal to 1% and 9% of the CapEx respectively, according to usual practices.
LCOE EVALUATION
CapEx estimation for scenarios
S1 & S2
Total Cost
OpEx estimation for scenarios
S1 & S2
FINANCIAL
EVALUATION
COST ESTIMATION
NO
LCOE calculation for
scenarios S1 & S2
LCOE
accepted
YES
Best investment
decision
Comparison of the two
investments scenarios
(LCOE1 vs LCOE2)
Final evaluation of the best investment scenario
(NPV method, IRR and PP of the investment)
Cash flow of the investment scenario
and other financial factors
Figure 3: Procedure followed for the financial analysis/evaluation of the examined OWFs
Table 5 presents OpEx estimation for the two proposed scenarios considering maintenance as a
percentage of the CapEx assets. Annual transportation costs, personnel costs and overheads are
considered similar to both scenarios due to the small difference of the OWF capacity between the two
proposed scenarios. Overheads refer to costs related to the incorporated joint venture that will be
established for the purposes of the proposed project.
CapEx Breakdown
Project development
Turbine
Substructure
Mooring system
Electrical
Interconnector
Installation
Insurance
Other
Contingency
Total CapEx (€)
Table 4: CapEx breakdown for both scenarios
Scenario S1
Scenario S2
Percentage
Percentage
€/MW
€
of total
€/MW
€
of total
CapEx
CapEx
74250
2450250
3
72381
2533327
3
990000 32670000
40
940950 32933250
39
396000 13068000
16
410158 14355519
17
49500
1633500
2
48254
1688885
2
321750
10617750
13
289523
10133308
12
396000
29700
0
222750
2475000
13068000
980100
0
7350750
81838350
16
1
0
9
100
410158
24127
0
217142
2412692
14355519
844442
0
7599981
84444231
17
1
0
9
100
920
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 5: OpEx breakdown for both scenarios
Scenario S1
Asset
Maintenance Maintenance
(€/MW) (% of asset) (€/MW/year)
Project development 74250
0
0
Turbine
990000
2
19800
Substructure
396000
1
3960
Mooring system
49500
1
495
Electrical
321750
3
9653
Interconnector
Installation
396000
1
3960
Insurance
29700
0
0
Other
0
0
0
Contingency
222750
0
0
Total Maintenance
37868
Insurance
24750
Transportation
191
Personnel
10730
Overheads
1515
TOTAL OpEx (€)
82560
OpEx Breakdown
Scenario S2
Asset
Maintenance Maintenance
(€/MW) (% of asset) (€/MW/year)
72381
0
0
940950
2
18819
410158
1
4102
48254
1
483
289523
3
8686
410158
24127
0
217142
1
0
0
0
4102
0
0
0
36190
24127
191
10117
1429
72054
3.2 Final Investment Decision
The selection of the final investment decision is based on the LCOE calculation for both scenarios
for the whole life-cycle of the OWF, which in the present study is taken equal to 25 years (5 years for
licensing procedures, design and construction and 20 years for operation). LCOE is calculated
considering the sum of lifetime discounted generation costs and the sum of discounted lifetime
electricity output, which is the net metered output after all losses. Equity and debt are taken equal to
30% and 70% of the total financing respectively, considering a 5-year grace period for loan
repayment. Cost of equity is evaluated using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), which
estimates the cost of equity by adding the risk-free rate with an additional premium for exposing the
investment to systematic risk. In the present study, cost of equity and cost of debt are taken equal to
14.5% and 9% respectively, and the corporate tax rate is considered to be 34% according to the
national taxation (2017). Table 6 presents the results of the LCOE for both scenarios.
Comparing LCOE1 with LCOE2, it is obvious that scenario S1 should be selected as the final
investment decision; namely, the floating OWF consisting of 11 WT (V112-3 MW) of 33 MW total
rated power. The main characteristics of this scenario are summarized in Table 7. The aforementioned
result is supported by the fact that the net capacity factor of S1 (44%) is larger than the net capacity
factor of S2 (39%), while both scenarios have almost the same costs over lifetime (Tables 4 and 5).
Table 6: LCOE for both scenarios
Scenario S2
Scenario S1
LCOE Breakdown (€/MWh)
Percentage of
LCOE
LCOE Breakdown
(€/MWh)
Percentage of
LCOE
CapEx
71.78
77.17%
CapEx
78.70
77.35%
OpEx
21.24
22.83%
OpEx
23.04
22.65%
LCOE1 (€/MWh)
LCOE2 (€/MWh)
93.02
921
101.74
Soft and renewable energy sources
Table 7: Final investment decision (scenario S1)
Investment Decision
V112 (Vestas)
Type of WT
3
Rated Power (MW)
11
Number of WT
33
Total Rated Power (MW)
128271
Net AEP (MWh/year)
48
Capacity Factor (%)
€ 81838350
CapEx
€ 2724471
OpEx
93
LCOE (€/MWh)
3.3 Financial Evaluation
Financial evaluation for the final investment decision (Scenario S1, Table 7) is implemented through
NPV, IRR and PP, considering 8.51% weighted average cost of capital, 2% inflation rate and 25 years
life cycle duration. Revenues are calculated per year considering the electricity price to be 0.185
€/KWh (Feed in Tariff) for an OWF, according to Europe pricing for offshore electricity production.
The net cash flow of the investment was calculated per year and it was, then, transformed in present
values to calculate the cumulative cash flow presented in Figure 4.
Figure 4: Cumulative cash flow of the final investment decision
As presented in Figure 4, the first 5 years of operation lead to a negative balance resulting in a 5-year
PP of the proposed investment. The NPV of the proposed investment is 175878564 € and IRR is
10.1%. The aforementioned results show that the proposed investment is viable since the NPV is
922
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
positive and the IRR is larger than the interest rate (8.51%). For Feed in Tariff value less than 0.101
€/KWh the proposed investment is unviable, since such values lead to negative NPV.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
In the present study, the economic feasibility of a floating OWF near Mykonos, in the Aegean Sea,
in Greece, for electricity production to cover the annual demands of Mykonos, Rhenia and Delos, is
implemented. Two alternative scenarios (S1 and S2) are investigated, by modifying the number and
the rated power of the OWTs, as well as the distances between them. In the case of scenario S1, the
proposed OWF consists of 11 floating OWTs (spar buoy floating platform) of 33 MW total rated
power, while scenario S2 corresponds to an OWF with 7 floating OWTs (spar buoy floating platform)
of 35 MW total rated power.
Initially, the net AEP for the two alternative scenarios is estimated considering wake losses, electrical
losses and OWTs’ availability. Specifically, the net AEP of S1 and S2 is estimated to reach 128275
MWh/year and 120583 MWh/year respectively, leading to a net capacity factor equal to 44% (S1)
and 39% (S2). The calculation of the CapEx, OpEx and LCOE of the two scenarios follows. In the
case of S1, LCOE is equal to 93.02 €/MWh, while for S2 it is 101.74 €/MWh. By comparing the
LCOE of the two alterative scenarios, S1 is finally selected to be further financially evaluated using
the NPV, the IRR and the PP of the investment. The NPV for this scenario corresponds to a positive
number, equal to 175878564 €, indicating the sustainability of the proposed investment. Furthermore,
the IRR is 10.1%, which is larger than the weighted average cost of capital (8.51%). Therefore, the
viability of the proposed OWF can be demonstrated. Finally, the payback period of the proposed
investment corresponds to 5 years.
The results indicate that the capacity factor is the most important parameter affecting LCOE and,
therefore, determining the final investment decision. Moreover, the results of the economic
analysis/evaluation of the finally selected scenario clearly illustrate the economic sustainability of the
proposed OWF and, its ability for covering the annual energy demands of the examined islands.
References
1. Dodson L., K. Busawon and M. Jovanovi (2005). ‘Estimation of the power coefficient in a wind
conversion system’. Proc. 44th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control, and the European
Control Conference 2005. Seville, Spain.
2. European Wind Energy Association (EWEA). (2018). ‘The European offshore wind industryKey trends and statistics 2017’. Wind Europe.
3. Georgakellos D.A. and A.M. Marcis (2009). ‘Application of the semantic learning approach in
the feasibility studies preparation training process’, Information Systems Management, Vol.
26, pp. 231-240.
4. Heidari S. (2017). ‘Economic modeling of floating offshore wind power’. Master of Science in
industrial economics, Malardalen University: Sweden.
5. International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA). (2012). ‘Renewable energy technologies:
Cost analysis series, Wind power’. IRENA working paper, Bonn, Gernamy.
6. Jensen N.O. (1983). ‘A Note on wind generator interaction’. Technical Report: Riso-M-2411.
7. Kaldellis J. and D. Za. (2011). ‘The wind energy (r)evolution: A short review of a long history’.
Renewable Energy, Vol. 36(7), pp. 1887-1901.
8. Kim J.-Y., K.-Y. Oh, K.-S. Kang and J.-S. Lee. (2013). ‘Site selection of offshore wind farms
around the Korean Peninsula through economic evaluation’. Renewable Energy, Vol. 54, pp.
189-195.
923
Soft and renewable energy sources
9. Konstantinidis E.I., D.G. Kompolias and P.N. Botsaris. (2014). ‘Viability analysis of an offshore
wind farm in North Aegean Sea, Greece’. Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy, Vol.
6, pp. 023116-1-023116-23.
10. Li J., P. Shi, H. Gao, H. Xie, Z. Yiang, W. Tang and L. Ma. (2010). ‘2010 China wind power
outlook’. Chinese Renewable Energy Industries Association (CREIA), Global Wind Energy
Council and Greenpeace.
11. Manwell J.F., J.G. McGowan and A.L. Rogers. (2009). ‘Wind energy explained: Theory,
design and application’. John Wiley & Sons Ltd, UK.
12. Mone C., M. Hand, M. Bolinger, J. Rand, D. Heimiller and J. Ho. (2015). ‘2015 Cost of wind
energy review’. National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), Technical Report NREL/TP6A20-66861, USA.
13. Mortensen N.G., D.N. Heathfield, O. Rathmann and M. Nielsen. (2011). ‘Wind atlas analysis
and application program: WAsP 10 help facility’. Roskilde: DTU Wind Energy.
14. Myhr A., C. Bjerkester, A. Agotnes and T.A. Nygaard. (2014). ‘Levelized cost of energy for offshore
floating wind turbines in a life cycle perspective’. Renewable Energy, Vol. 66, pp. 714-728.
15. Ozerdem B., S. Ozer and M. Tosun. (2006). ‘Feasibility study of wind farms: A case study for
Izmir, Turkey’. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, Vol. 99(10), pp.
725-743.
16. Pantaleo A., A. Pellerano, F. Ruggiero and M. Trovato M. (2005). ‘Feasibility study of off-shore
wind farms: An application to Puglia region’. Solar Energy, Vol. 79(3), pp. 321-331.
17. RAE (2013). http://www.rae.gr/site/el_GR/categories_new/electricity/market/mdn.csp (accessed
February 22nd, 2018).
18. Satir M., F. Murphy and K. McDonnell. (2018). ‘Feasibility study of an offshore wind farm in the
Aegean Sea, Turkey’. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 81(Part 2), pp. 25522562.
19. Tong K. (1998). ‘Technical and economic aspects of a floating offshore wind farm’. Journal of
Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, Vol. 74-76, pp. 399-410.
20. Vasileiou M., E. Loukogeorgaki and D.G. Vagiona .(2017). ‘GIS-based multi-criteria decision
analysis for site selection of hybrid offshore wind and wave energy systems in Greece’.
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 73, pp. 745-757.
21. Young G.I.M. (1970). ‘Feasibility studies’. Appraisal Journal, Vol. 38(3), pp. 376-383.
924
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
FLOATING PHOTOVOLTAIC POWER GENERATION SYSTEM
DEVELOPMENT IN A LAKE
A. Zamanidou* and E. Loukogeorgaki
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th,
GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: zamanidou.afroditi@gmail.com, tel: +302310995951
Abstract
Solar energy is practically an inexhaustible, clean source of energy. In order to produce multi-MW
electricity from solar energy, large capacity facilities are required, that occupy wide installation areas.
Therefore, an important prerequisite at an early stage of the realization of a multi-MW solar energy
project is the availability of suitable, large-size, surface areas. In countries, such as Greece, which
have quite limited land area, with a significant proportion allocated for agriculture, protected forests
and for other land uses, the deployment of floating photovoltaic systems in closed water bodies to
harness solar energy presents a potential, attractive, alternative solution.
Motivated by this, the aim of the present paper is to propose, develop and investigate the feasibility
of a Floating Photovoltaic power generation System (FPVS) in a lake in Greece. For this purpose, the
Polyfytos artificial lake in North Greece is selected, considering environmental/legal restrictions and
the available lake’s surface size. This selection is further supported by the satisfaction of other siteselection criteria related to economical/technical parameters. The exact installation location of the
FPVS in the lake is defined considering, mainly, minimization of visual impacts and shading effects
from the surrounding mountains, as well as easy accessibility facilitating maintenance actions. A
FPVS of 2 MW power capacity is proposed, so that the electricity demands of the neighboring villages
can be met. This FPVS is preliminary designed by defining its geometrical and technical
characteristics. For increasing the power production of the proposed FPVS, smart technologies are
integrated within its design (i.e. use of tracking system), exploiting the advantage of the FPVS’s
deployment in a water body. Finally, the economic performance of the proposed FPV power
generation system in terms of levelized cost of energy is estimated by calculating and assessing
construction, operation and maintenance costs.
The results of the present paper illustrate that the proposed FPVS deployed in the Polyfytos Lake in
Greece has the potential to present a viable economic solution for covering effectively the energy
demands of the neighboring areas. Moreover, the development of a FPVS over a water reservoir has
a significant positive effect (increase) on the electricity production effectiveness compared to a landbased PV power generation system, since in the case of a FPVS smart technologies can be more
efficiently applied.
Keywords: Floating photovoltaic power generation system, Greece, Lake, Financial analysis,
Levelized cost of energy
1.
INTRODUCTION
Solar energy is practically an inexhaustible, clean source of energy. For multi-megawatt scale
electricity generation from solar energy, wide installation areas are required, which puts restrictions
on land use for agricultural purposes. The main motivation for the deployment of Floating
925
Soft and renewable energy sources
PhotoVoltaic Systems (FPVSs) was the land premium, especially, for agricultural areas, where the
land was more valuable for the growth of the crops (Trapani and Santafé, 2014). FPVSs have been
already utilized worldwide, mainly, in closed water bodies within terrestrial areas, such as reservoirs,
wetlands, small artificial and natural lakes. A FPVS consists of conventional PV panels installed in
the form of PV arrays on a floating structure, which has suitable floaters to balance the structure on
the surface of the water. The aforementioned PV arrays avoid the increase of the solar cell’s
temperature by taking advantage of the surrounding water’s existence.
The deployment of a FPVS has numerous advantages compared to onshore PVSs, related mainly to
the efficiency of the PV modules and the installation environment (Choi et al., 2013). Specifically, in
the case of a FPVS a slight increase in the electrical efficiency of the conventional PV arrays utilized
has been observed, which may be related to the cooling provided by the underlying water to the
floating PV arrays. Regarding the environment and the ecosystem of the installation area, there are
two key benefits: (a) in case of total or partial (at a large percentage) coverage of the reservoir’s water
surface by the installed FPVS, evaporation of water is reduced significantly, as most of the incident
radiation is absorbed by the PV cells, and (b) phytoplankton growth decreases, as the amount of solar
radiation reaching the bottom decreases, which in turn reduces the rate of photosynthesis. It is
important to note that the aforementioned advantages refer to artificial ponds and reservoirs, where
water is used either for irrigation purposes or for water supply. However, the deployment of a FPVS
is also characterized by drawbacks and challenges that should be overcome, such as high deployment
cost, corrosion risk and difficult access for operation and maintenance.
In general, there are innovative technologies that can be applied to conventional PV arrays in order
to increase their efficiency. A solar tracking system can be used to increase PV cell efficiency and,
thereby, increase power generation. In this way, the solar rays penetrate perpendicularly to the PV
cells, resulting to an increase up to 30% (Choi et al., 2014) of their performance compared to the
deployment of a fixed type PV power generation systems. Additionally, the PV panel efficiency is
sensitive to the panel temperature and decreases as the temperature of the panel increases. Applying
an active cooling technique, the operating temperature of a PV module can be dropped significantly
to about 20% and an increase of 9% (Bahaidarah et al., 2014) in the electrical efficiency can be
reached. These technology applications for efficiency increase can be implemented either for Onshore
PV arrays (OPV) or for FPV arrays. However, in the case of FPV arrays, technologies for increasing
efficiency can be realized with simpler structures and they can be applied to a larger number of PV
panels.
In light of the above, it is concluded that FPVSs present a novel technology to exploit the most
inexhaustible energy source, the sun. Motivated by this, the present paper aims at proposing,
developing and investigating the feasibility of a FPVS for power generation in the Polyfytos artificial
lake in North Greece. This lake is selected considering environmental/legal restrictions and its
available surface size. However, the selected area satisfies additional site-selection criteria related to:
(a) the system’s production effectiveness, (b) construction and maintenance issues and (c)
connectivity with the existing electricity distribution network. The exact installation location of the
FPVS is defined in terms of minimizing visual impacts and shading effects from the surrounding
mountains, as well as easy accessibility. In order to meet the electricity demands of the neighboring
villages, a 2 MW FPVS is proposed and it is preliminary designed, using, also, smart technologies
(i.e. tracking system) for increasing the FPVS’s power production. Finally, the economic performance
of the proposed FPV power generation system in terms of levelized cost of energy is estimated.
2.
SELECTION AND MAIN CHARACTISTICS OF THE STUDY AREA
An important prerequisite for the deployment of a FPVS is the determination of a suitable installation
area, so that a sustainable system can be realized. According to Choi (2014), as a FPVS corresponds
to a floating on the water surface structure, site-selection criteria have to be considered and assessed
related to: (a) power generation efficiency, e.g. solar radiation, fog, shade occurrence, etc., (b)
926
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
installation and maintenance, e.g. water depth (water level fluctuation), frost, inflow of floating
particles, accessibility, interference with dam facilities (water intake tower, waste-way), etc., (c)
connectivity with the existing power system, e.g. spare capacity of distribution line, distance to
distribution line, distance to load (receptor), etc. and (d) legal restrictions, e.g. special countermeasure
area (Framework Act on Environmental Policy), waterfront area (related River Acts), Local
Environment Preservation Act, Protection of Wild Fauna and Flora Act, fishing prohibition area,
marine leisure activity prohibition area, civil complaints, excessive compensation expense,
inducement of environmental problems, etc.
In the case of Greece, all natural lakes and most of existing artificial lakes (created by the Public
Power Corporation (PPC) for power generation via hydroelectric power plants) are included in the
list of community importance sites of NATURA 2000 network. Therefore, environmental and
legislative restrictions lead to a small number of Greek lakes that could be potentially considered for
the deployment of a FPVS (Table 1). By taking into account the size of these lakes, Polyfytos artificial
lake (Figures 1a~1b) is chosen for the deployment of a FPVS, since it has the largest surface area
among the various environmentally eligible candidates. It is noted that the selection of the Polyfytos
Lake is further supported by the satisfaction of additional site-selection criteria as described in the
following paragraphs.
Table 1: Greek artificial lakes not included in NATURA 2000 list
Name
Location
Surface area (km2)
Polyfytos Lake
Kozani
74000
Kastraki Lake
Aetolia-Acarnania
26804
Pineios Lake
Elis
19895
Pournari Lake
Arta
8233
Ladona Lake
Arcadia
3048
Lake Polyfytos is an artificial lake of Aliakmonas river, located in North Greece (40.13ο Ν, 21.58ο Ε)
in the regional unit of Kozani (Figure 1a~1b). The lake was formed in 1973, after the construction of
the Polyfytos dam in the river. It is owned by the Greek PPC, but it has been granted to the
surrounding residents for fishing and ecotourism exploitation. Briefly, the Polyfytos Lake is used for
water supply, irrigation, fishing, power generation, recreation and sports. The lake has a wetland code
of 133103000 and does not have any legal status for environmental protection. The lake covers an
area of 74 km² (flooded) and receives mainly the waters of the Aliakmon River and some torrents
from a catchment area of 5630 km². The largest area of the lake (about 70%) is located at the territory
of the Servia Municipality (Figure 1b). Its maximum length and width are equal to 29.84 km and 4.14
km respectively, while its average depth is equal to 55 m. Changes in water level correspond to about
15 m. The rapid renewal of the lake's water enables rapid removal of polluting loads, resulting in the
lake's "mesotrophic" status. Waters mostly flooded the agricultural land after the construction of the
dam, and finally artificial lake of Polyfytos was created.
For supporting the adequacy of the Polyfytos Lake for the deployment of a FPVS based on the siteselection criteria mentioned previously in this section, the irradiation of the sun in the study area is,
initially, investigated and quantified. This parameter represents the most crucial meteorological
parameter affecting the efficiency of the FPVS. For this purpose, climatology maps of the region of
Western Macedonia are used (HNSE, 2013). These maps were formed based on simulations using a
radiation propagation model, satellite images of cloudiness and satellite assessments of atmospheric
suspensions. Considering the map of the regional unit of Kozani, the average annual solar energy per
unit area (kWh/m2) in the area of the Polyfytos Lake is equal to 1485 kWh/m2, which is the highest
average annual solar energy per unit area in the region of Western Macedonia (HNSE, 2013). The
aforementioned value has been also verified from (JRC-IET, 2012).
927
Soft and renewable energy sources
Figure 1: (a)~(b): Study area, (c): FPVS proposed installation location at Polyfytos Lake
Next, the shading percentage of the lake by natural or artificial barriers is investigated. As there are
no artificial barriers on the surface of the lake, the shading of the lake by the surrounding mountain
masses on December 21, 2015, (winter solstice) is checked, from sunrise until sunset. The natural
hurdles are located North, Northeast, East, Southeast and South of the Polyfytos Lake. At several
locations on the lake's surface, especially, near the mountains, sunlight is limited.
Furthermore, other weather parameters (i.e. fog, cloudiness, temperature and frost) that affect the PV
modules’ efficiency and, therefore, the generation performance of a FPVS are taken into account. For
this reason, relevant meteorological data of the last 30 years are gathered by the meteorological station
in Kozani (National Meteorological Service, 2015) and the following statistical quantities and data
are derived and considered for the FPVS’s deployment:
The maximum, monthly average, fog occurs in December (1.32%), while the minimum, monthly
average, fog occurs in July and August (0.01%).
The maximum, monthly average, total cloudiness occurs in December (57.88%), while the
minimum, monthly average, total cloudiness occurs in August (27.50%).
The maximum, monthly average, low cloudiness occurs in December (30.63%), while the
minimum, monthly average, low cloudiness occurs in August (14.75%).
The maximum, monthly average, temperature average appears in August (24.69 °C), while the
minimum, monthly average, temperature average appears in January (5.57 °C).
The maximum, monthly average, temperature minimum appears in July (12.3 °C), while the
minimum, monthly average, temperature minimum appears in January (-7.85 °C).
The maximum, monthly average, temperature maximum appears in July (36.77 °C), while the
minimum, monthly average, temperature maximum appears in December (14.9 °C).
There is no appearance of frost all year round.
Regarding the accessibility and connectivity of the lake with an existing power system, the
accessibility of the study area is quite good as the lake is crossed by the national road of the cities of
Kozani - Larissa, and there is a network of provincial roads. Additionally, there is large space
available for installing a construction site near the lake. The location of the neighboring to the lake
villages limits the available FPVS deployment options to the West and Southwest surface of the
Polyfytos Lake. This will, to a large extent, prevent, also, the visual disturbance. Finally, around the
lake there is an electricity distribution network of PPC, to which the villages around the lake are
928
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
connected. Furthermore, there is an electricity transmission line at the Northeastern point of the lake,
where the Polyfytos hydroelectric plant is installed.
Additionally to the above, data related to the water depth and the fluctuation levels of the Polyfytos
Lake were collected from the Polyfytos Hydroelectric Power Plant (HPP). Water depth presents a
parameter which is crucial for defining the FPVS’s installation position in the lake, since it has a
direct effect on the mooring system’s requirements and, therefore, on the construction cost of the
FPVS. In the case of the examined lake, the average depth is 55 m, while the maximum depth is
located at the position of the dam and is between 75-80 m. On the other hand, the fluctuation of the
lake's surface varies between 10 m and 15 m. This fluctuation affects the design requirements of the
FPVS’s mooring system, which should be selected and designed, so that the FPVS can adequately
follow the vertical variations of the free surface in terms of ensuring the continuous and safe operation
of the system.
Finally, regarding the water supply and drainage facilities, wastewater from the villages and from
irrigation activities dispose after the appropriate treatment into the lake. In addition, part of the lake's
water is diverted to the water supply network of Thessaloniki area, when demand is increased. As
there is a rapid renewal of the lake water, the inflow and accumulation of floating particles on the
lake surface is limited. Thus, the floating structure and the mooring system of the FPVS are not
expected to be affected by floating particles.
Table 2: Site-selection criteria and their assessment for the Polyfytos Lake
Criterion
Value (quantitative or qualitative)
No
Description
1
Solar Energy
1485 kWh/m2
2
Shade by surrounding mountains
Only from N, NE, E, SE, S directions
3
Fog-Cloudiness
Medium appearance
4
Temperature
Slight rise in summer
5
Depth
55 m (average)
6
Surface fluctuation
10-15 m
7
Frost
No
8
Inflow of floating matters
No
9
Accessibility
Yes
10
Water supply and drainage facilities
Wastewater inflow
11
Electricity distribution/transmission network
Yes
12
Neighboring villages
Yes (at the N, NW, NE, E, SE and S adjacent
sides)
13
Road network
Yes
14
Construction site area
Yes
15
NATURA 2000 restriction
No
16
Restriction zones
No
Table 2 summarizes the above information and provides the site-selection criteria considered for the
deployment of a FPVS in Polyfytos Lake. Based on this Table and the aforementioned relevant
discussion, it can be concluded that the Polyfytos Lake can be considered suitable for the deployment
of a FPVS. Regarding the determination of a specific location in the lake for installing the FPVS,
since there are no relevant restrictions in the study area, a specific location is proposed aiming at: (a)
929
Soft and renewable energy sources
preventing shading during the day, (b) avoiding visual disturbing and (c) ensuring easy access for
maintenance. The proposed installation position located in latitude 40°13'10.85" N and longitude
21°56'19.32" E is shown in Figure 1c.
3.
PRELIMINARY DESIGN OF THE FPVS
According to the survey on energy consumption in households of the Hellenic Statistical Authority
conducted during October 2011 – September 2012, the average annual electricity consumption per
household is 3750 kWh (Hellenic Statistical Authority, 2013). Moreover, according to the 2011
Population and Housing Census (Hellenic Statistical Authority, 2014), where the number of
households and the number of their members were collected, one person households and two person
households constitute 55.2% of the total number of households. Based on the above data and the
population (2011 census) of the neighboring to Polyfytos Lake villages, the average annual electricity
consumption of the villages is calculated (Table 3), assuming that the households consist of two
members.
Table 3: Average annual electricity consumption of villages around Polyfytos Lake
Village
Population
Number of
households
Average annual electricity consumption (kWh)
Rymnio
161
81
301875
Goyles
185
93
346875
Kranidia
461
231
864375
Neraida
148
74
277500
Imera
156
78
292500
Avra
56
28
105000
Total
1167
584
2188125
The size of the proposed FPVS is determined in order to meet the energy demands of the villages
around the Polyfytos Lake (Table 3). The average annual power production of 1 kW installed in an
OPV power plant varies, and for Greece is estimated to be equal to 1300 kWh (obtained from
communication with market representatives and verified from JRC-IET, 2012). Thus, the efficiency
of an OPV power plant is 14.84%. To produce the annual electrical energy demand of the villages
around the Polyfyto Lake (2188125 kWh), a 2 MW OPV power plant, with 2600000 kWh annual
energy production, is required. Assuming the same capacity for the proposed FPVS in the examined
area, Table 4 shows the FPVS’s efficiency estimated for a FPVS: (a) without any smart technologies,
(b) with active cooling system and (c) with active cooling system and tracking type system for solar
tracking. Based on this Table, it can be easily concluded that the efficiency of the FPVS, where both
active cooling and tracking type systems are utilized, is 60.92% higher than the efficiency of an OPV
power plant. Moreover, contrary to the OPV power plant, where a 2 MW plant must be installed to
meet the annual electricity demands of the villages around the Polyfytos Lake, a FPVS with active
cooling and tracking systems of only a 1.1 MW capacity could be utilized to meet the same demand.
However, a 2 MW FPVS is, finally, proposed in the present paper assuming that the additional energy
generated can be supplied and sold to the central power grid for other use. For the proposed FPVS,
Polycrystaline-Silicon (Poly-Si) 250 Wp PV panels (Table 5) are selected to be used considering
market availability, lowest possible cost and maximum efficiency. For developing a FPVS of 2 MW
capacity and of 4.18 GWh average annual energy production (Table 4), 8000 PV panels (Poly-Si 250
Wp, 60 cells) are required with a total weight of 160000 kg (weight of the PV panels only).
930
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 4: Efficiency estimation of a 2 MW FPVS installed at the Polyfytos Lake
Nominal
Average annual
Efficiency
Type of PV system (plant)
capacity
energy production
(%)
(kW)
(kWh)
OPV power plant
2000
2600000
14.84
FPVS [9]
2000
2885964
16.47
FPVS with active cooling system [3]
2000
3145701
17.95
FPVS with active cooling system and
tracking type system [2]
2000
4183783
23.88
Table 5: Technical and geometrical characteristics of Polycrystaline-Silicon 250 Wp PV panel
(Poly-Si 250 WP, 60 cells)
Parameter
Value
Parameter
Value
Pnom (Wp)
250
Cell Area (m2)
1.46
Width (m)
0.99
Tref (oC)
25
Length (m)
1.64
Weight (kg)
20
Area (m2)
1.63
(a)
PV panels
Longitudinal
beams
Figure 2: Perspectives of the preliminary design of the proposed FPVS
The design concept of the proposed FPVS as developed in this paper is presented in Figure 2. PV
panels are placed in 30o tilt angle and are arranged in 4 circular grids (Figure 2) of 50 m radius each,
in order to prevent shading among the panels and provide adequate distance between them for
maintenance accessibility. In each circular grid, the PV arrays are mounted on longitudinal beams,
which are supported by a circular ring (Figure 2). All the above are, finally, mounted on a floating
polygon (Figure 2). The floating platform of the proposed FPVS consists of 4 polygons (one polygon
for each circular grid) with rectangular cross-section of 4 m in width and 3 m in height. Vertical axis
tracking system is placed on every floating polygon, while an active cooling system, taking advantage
of the surrounding lake water, is deployed for keeping the PV panels’ temperature low. Regarding
the mooring system, a system that effectively follows the lake’s fluctuations is proposed (e.g. Seaflex)
(Seaflex, 2018). Based on the above, the total rectangular installation area is estimated equal to 58752
m2. It is noted that in the present paper the dimensions of the floating platform were preliminary
estimated in order to ensure buoyancy. Detailed design and modelling of the hydrodynamic and
931
Soft and renewable energy sources
structural behavior of the FPVS’s floating platform including mooring lines presents items for future
investigation.
4.
ASSESSMENT OF THE ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE OF THE PROPOSED FPVS
For assessing the economic performance of the proposed FPVS, capital and Operation & Maintenance
(O&M) expenditures have to be initially estimated. Starting with the capital expenditures, these costs
include the cost of the PV arrays’ electromechanical equipment, as well as the construction costs of
the floating platform (including the PV panels’ mounting configurations and the floaters) and of the
mooring system. An estimation of these costs is shown in Table 6.
Table 6: Estimated construction cost of the proposed FPVS
Cost Category
Cost sub-category
Main electromechanical equipment (PV panels, inverters,
connectors, tracking system, etc.)
Cost (€)
2356000.00
Electromechanical Cables - Tables
equipment
Supplementary Systems (Lightning protection, earthing,
safety and protection systems)
165000.00
Subtotal
2627000.00
Supporting longitudinal beams
106000.00
450747.00
Supporting ring
Floating structure
Floaters
and mooring
system
Mooring system
`439000.26
1660479.10
249071.87
Subtotal
2799298.23
Total
5426298.23
The cost of the electromechanical equipment has been estimated based on relevant costs existing in
the case of an OPV power plant (obtained from communication with market representatives) and it
includes tracking system for sunlight tracking and cooling system. It is emphasized that the cost
estimation of the FPVS’s electromechanical equipment is quite conservative, especially with regard
to the cost of the tracking and the cooling systems. The latter cost, which is high in OPV installations,
can be significantly reduced in the case of a FPVS due to the support structure’s simplification.
Regarding the cost of the FPVS’s platform, this is is estimated using the weight of the steel required
for its construction and a unit cost of 0.58 €/kg (average steel cost of 7850 kg/m3 density in the Greek
market). It is mentioned that 4396.95 tn of steel are considered to be required in total (777.15 tn for
the longitudinal supporting beams, 756.90 for the circular supporting ring and 2862.90 tn for the
floaters) for constructing the FPVS’s platform. The above quantities have been defined based on the
preliminary design of the FPVS presented in the previous section. As for the mooring system, the
Seaflex-type mooring system is proposed (Seaflex, 2018) the cost of which is calculated as a
percentage (15%) of the construction cost of the floaters. With regard to the O&M expenditures, these
are mainly related to the O&M of the PV panels and are taken equal to 15 €/kW (NREL, 2018).
Considering the annual yield of the proposed 2 MW FPVS, the annual O&M cost for the proposed
FPVS is calculated equal to 30000 €. Moreover, assuming a 35-year operation period the O&M cost
for the proposed FPVS is equal to 1050000 €.
Having estimating capital and O&M expenditures, the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) (€/KWh) is
used to assess the economic performance and the economic viability of the proposed FPVS. In the
present paper, LCOE is evaluated based on the methodology described in Said et al. (2015) and
932
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Murphy et al. (2015). Specifically, for a given installation area of a FPVS, the LCOE assuming a 35year operation period Said et al. (2015) is calculated according to the following equation:
LCOE
CCI
(1)
35 AEP
where AEP is the Annual Energy Production by the FPVS (KWh) and CCI is the Capital Cost
Indicator of the investment (€), which can be calculated using the following equation:
CCI DCI 0.3DCI
(2)
where DCI corresponds to the Device Cost Indicator of the FPVS (€). In the present paper, this
quantity is calculated as follows:
DCI Cstr ( M str M PV ) CPV PNOM
(3)
where Cstr is the cost per unit weight (€/tn) of the FPVS’s floating structure and electromechanical
equipment, CPV is the O&M cost per unit power (€/kW) for 35 years related to the nominal power of
the PV panels, Μstr and ΜPV present the weight (tn) of the floating structure and of the PV panels
respectively, while PNOM is the nominal power (KW) of the PV panels. Using the economic and
technical data presented previously in the section, Cstr, CPV, Mstr, MPV, PNOM and AEP are calculated
equal to 1234.11 €/tn, 525 €/kW, 4396.94 tn, 160 tn, 2000 kW and 2091888 kWh respectively.
Finally, Table 7 shows the DCI and CCI values (Equations 2~3) and the LCOE (Equation 1) of the
proposed FPVS. It can be seen that the LCOE for the proposed 2 MW FPVS at the Polyfytos Lake
corresponds to 0.118 €/kWh; thus, based on the current Greek energy market the proposed FPVS has
the potential to be considered as an economic viable solution.
Table 7: Values of quantities for LCOE calculation and LCOE of the proposed FPVS
5.
Quantity
Value
DCI (€)
6673755.39
CCI (€)
8675882.01
LCOE (€/kWh)
0.118
CONCLUSIONS
In the present paper, a 2 MW FPVS is proposed to be installed at the Polyfytos Lake in the North
Greece to meet the energy demands of the neighborhood villages. Polyfytos Lake is selected for this
installation, as it occupies the largest area compared to other environmentally eligible Greek lakes
(not included in the NATURA 2000 network). This selection is further supported by the satisfaction
of other site-selection criteria related to economical/technical parameters. The FPVS is proposed to
be located at the West side of the lake near its shore, avoiding shading by the surrounding mountains
during the day and visual disturbance, and facilitating accessibility for maintenance. For the examined
FPVS a 30o tilt angle to the PV panels is proposed, while a tracking system resulting to a 30%
efficiency increase is utilized. Moreover, an active cooling system is deployed, which can keep the
temperature of the PV modules closer to the nominal PV cell operation temperature and, thus, it
increases the efficiency up to 9%. The two latter smart technologies lead to a FPVS of 60.92% higher
efficiency compared to an OPV power plant of the same capacity. The floating platform of the
proposed FPVS consists of longitudinal beams and circular rings for supporting the PV arrays, as
well as of floating polygons (floaters). Based on this preliminary design, the FPVS’s construction
cost has been estimated equal to 5.43 M€, while the annual O&M cost corresponds to 30000 €.
933
Soft and renewable energy sources
Finally, the estimated LCOE equal to 0.118 €/kWh, demonstrates the potential of the 2MW FPVS at
the Polyfytos Lake to be considered as an economic viable solution.
References
1. Trapani K. and M.R. Santafé. (2014). ‘A review of floating photovoltaic installations: 2007-2013’.
Progress in Photovoltaics, Vol. 23(4), pp. 524-532.
2. Choi Y.K., N.H. Lee and K.J. Kim. (2013). ‘Empirical Research on the efficiency of Floating PV
systems compared with Overland PV Systems’. CES-CUBE, Vol. 25, pp. 284-289.
3. Choi Y.K., N.H. Lee, A.K. Lee and K.J. Kim. (2014). ‘A study on major design elements of
tracking-type floating photovoltaic systems’. International Journal of Smart Grid and Clean
Energy, Vol. 3(1), pp. 70-74.
4. Bahaidarah H., A. Subhan, P. Gandhidasan and S. Rehman. (2013). ‘Performance evaluation of a
PV (photovoltaic) module by back surface water cooling for hot climatic conditions’. Energy,
Vol. 59, pp. 445-453.
5. Choi Y.K. (2014). ‘A case study on suitable area and resource for the development of floating
photovoltaic system’. International Journal of Electrical, Computer, Electronics and
Communication Engineering, Vol. 8(5), pp. 816-820.
6. HNSE. (2013). http://www.helionet.gr/maps/clima_yearly_avg/total/Greece (accessed January
17th, 2018).
7. JRC-IET. (2012). http://re.jrc.ec.europa.eu/pvgis/ (accessed April 23rd, 2018).
8. National Meteorological Service. (2015). Data of Kozani Meteorological Station (station code
16632), period 01/01/1980 - 31/12/2014.
9. Hellenic Statistical Authority. (2013). Press release. Survey on energy consumption in
households, 2011-2012.
10. Hellenic Statistical Authority. (2014). Demographic and social characteristics of the Resident
Population of Greece according to the 2011 Population - Housing Census revision of 20/3/2014.
11. Seaflex. (2018). http://www.seaflex.net/ (accessed January 17th, 2018).
12. NREL. (2018). https://www.nrel.gov/analysis/tech-cost-om-dg.html (accessed January 17th,
2018).
13. Said M., M. EL-Shimy and M.A. Abdelraheem. (2015). ‘Photovoltaics energy: Improved
modeling and analysis of the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) and grid parity – Egypt case study’.
Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments, Vol. 9, pp. 37-48.
14. Murphy J., K. Lynch and K. O’Sullivan. (2012). ‘MARINA PLATFORM Deliverable D3.3:
Methodologies for analysis and assessment of wind-ocean combined concepts’. Marine
Renewable Integrated Application Platform (MARINA PLATFORM) project.
934
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
MAXIMIZING THE BUILDING ENERGY PERFORMANCE WITH
ADVANCED VENTILATED FAÇADE SYSTEMS ON EXISTING
STRUCTURES
D.K. Bikas, K.G. Tsikaloudaki*, T.G. Theodosiou, D.C. Tsirigoti and S.P. Tsoka
Laboratory of Building Construction and building Physics, Division of Structural Engineering,
Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: katgt@civil.auth.gr, tel : +30231099770
Abstract
Within the existing European building stock, a large share is built before 1960, when there were only
a few or no requirements for energy efficiency. Given that only a small portion of these buildings
have undergone major energy retrofits, it is easily concluded that the oldest part of the building stock
contributes greatly to the high energy consumption of the building sector. The most common action
for the energy retrofit of the building envelope is the external insulation of the existing walls.
Recently, ventilated façade systems were developed to offer thermal insulation together with the
protection of buildings against the combined action of rain and wind, offering at the same time high
level aesthetic characteristics. However, even if an advanced technological solution is used, such as
the ventilated façade one, the poor air quality problems of older buildings are not always addressed,
as through the interventions the buildings are made more airtight, and consequently less naturally
ventilated. The research project E2VENT, funded within the H2020 program, attempts to address
these problems met in existing residential buildings. It concerns merely a cost effective, high energy
efficient, low C02 emission, replicable, low intrusive, systemic approach for retrofitting of residential
buildings, through the integration of an advanced ventilated façade system, a heat exchanger and a
heat storage system.
In this paper the technological solution that is developed within the framework of the research project
is described, the possible barriers of its market acceptance are given, and results on its expected
performance when installed in typical existing buildings are presented. Emphasis is given on the
parameters that are associated with the thermal performance of the E2VENT system, as its main target
is to reduce the building energy substantially, supporting the framework of the nZEB concept.
Keywords: Ventilated facade; building energy performance; energy retrofit; existing buildings;
thermal insulation
1.
INTRODUCTION
Within the existing European stock, a large share (more than 40%) was built before 1960’s when
there were only few or no requirements for energy efficiency and only a small part of buildings have
undergone major energy retrofits [1-2]. That means that the great majority is of low insulation levels
and is equipped with old and inefficient systems. For these reasons, the oldest part of the building
stock contributes greatly to the energy consumption in the building sector [3-4].
It is now clear that the largest energy saving potential is associated with the older building stock.
Moreover, although heating needs in Southern countries such as Portugal and Italy are lower due to
milder winters, the energy use in these countries is relatively high, which can be an indication of lack
of sufficient thermal envelope insulation in their building stocks [2, 4]. For these countries, where
935
Soft and renewable energy sources
buildings are usually equipped with air conditioning systems, cooling becomes an important
contributor to the overall consumption.
The most common action for the energy retrofit of the building envelope is the thermal insulation and
mainly the external insulation of the existing walls. However, the technology used in each case differs
with regard to the construction of the existing wall and to the technologies that were applied in every
country, according to climate, or special conditions [2, 5, 6]. Recently, ventilated façade systems were
developed to offer thermal insulation together with the protection of buildings against the combined
action of rain and wind, offering at the same time high level aesthetic characteristics. They constitute
of a bearing structure, anchored to the building wall with brackets and anchoring elements, the
insulation material and the external cladding, which are separated by the air cavity.
However, even if an advanced technological solution is used, such as the ventilated façade one, the
poor air quality problems of older buildings are not addressed. Furthermore, retrofitting strategies
usually focus on the reduction of air infiltration, in order to reduce energy demands for heating &
cooling. However, as building energy efficiency is improved with insulation and weather-stripping,
buildings are being made more airtight, and consequently less naturally ventilated. Since all buildings
require air renewal to guarantee acceptable indoor air conditions, the corresponding losses of heat
due to the ventilation air are increased.
In this paper, a retrofit solution that improves the energy performance of existing buildings by
addressing both ventilation and conductivity losses is presented; such a hybrid solution combines
active and passive means and is developed through the research project E2VENT.
2.
DESCRIPTION OF E2VENT
The research project E2VENT, funded within the H2020 program (GA 637261), attempts to address
these problems met in existing residential buildings. It is merely a cost effective, high energy efficient,
low CO2 emission, replicable, low intrusive, systemic approach for retrofitting of residential
buildings, through the integration of an advanced ventilated façade system, comprising of various
components, described in the following sections.
The research project is run by 13 organizations across Europe (Nobatek, European Aluminium
Association, ELVAL, FENIX, FASADA, Pich architects, Tecnalia, Acciona, Cartif, University of
Hull, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, University of Burgos, D’ Appolonia) and coordinated by
Nobatek. The project started on January, 2015 and it will last 42 months. Apart from the development
of the solution and the necessary preparations for its introduction into the market, the project involves
pilot studies, which will demonstrate the capabilities of the system.
The E2VENT system is an external refurbishment solution with external cladding and air cavity that
embeds different breakthrough technologies to ensure its high efficiency (Figure 1):
• A Smart Modular Heat Recovery Unit. The heat exchanger is specifically designed for the E2VENT
system. It will be aluminium-made, in order to be lighter and with good thermal conductivity. The
unit is designed to preheat inlet ventilation air in winter and precool it in summer. Apart from the
normal winter and summer modes, it allows heat storage and free cooling modes. The unit is modular,
allowing operation in series or parallel, depending on heating/cooling requirements.
• A Latent Heat Thermal Energy Storage Unit. The Latent Heat Thermal Energy Storage Unit (Fig.
2) is based on phase change materials, aiming at providing a heat storage system for the reduction of
peak of electricity consumption and/or for cooling in summer.
• A smart management system. Nowadays, Building Energy Management systems (BEMs) are critical
elements in the energy retrofitting strategies in buildings, in combination with active and passive
solutions. In fact, the BEMs could achieve up to 40% of energy savings by controlling HVAC,
lighting and other systems. In E2VENT, a smart management system will control the components on
936
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
a real time basis targeting optimal performances. A series of sensors will ensure that the E2VENT
system will recognize the predicted weather and communicate with existing systems.
a.
b.
Figure 1. The smart modular heat recovery Unit (a.) and the latent heat thermal energy
storage unit (b) of the E2VENT system [7].
• A ventilated façade system. The ventilated façade system is composed of (Fig. 2) the bearing
structure, which is made of aluminium and is designed especially for this application, both from a
mechanical and a thermal point of view, the thermal protection, offered by thermal insulation
positioned on the outer surface of the building and the external cladding, made of composite
aluminium panels. Special attention is given to the production of an efficient anchoring system that
limits thermal bridges and allows for an easy and durable installation. Load bearing elements made
of aluminium, support the ventilated façade. Vertical T-shaped beams bear the outer cladding; each
one is supported by an L-shaped bracket, which is anchored on the wall. All bearing elements have
been selected in order to comply with the structural requirements and have the necessary bearing
capacity for the selected loadings and combination of loadings. Thermal insulation is positioned
between the anchors, covering all exterior opaque elements. The structural system selection of
building’s construction parts involves the choice of the lightest parts of the most economical material,
allowing for the most efficient configuration that is appropriate to the anticipated loads [8, 9]. The
choice of aluminium as the material of the main supporting system, the anchors and the brackets of
the system, is a relatively new but efficient design solution. Wind, seismic, thermal action and any
other possible design load imposed on the building according to the limit design states are defined in
accordance to Eurocodes. A significant number of analyses of structural models with various crosssection dimensions of the principal structural and connection members has been performed. By this
procedure an optimal design by strengthening at specific cases for the system has been attempted.
937
Soft and renewable energy sources
Figure 2. The E2VENT ventilated façade system anchored with full and half height brackets.
3.
EXPECTED PERFORMANCE
It is expected that the E2VENT system will lead to significant energy savings and CO2 emissions
reduction. This is achieved not only by the thermal protection of the opaque elements, which enhances
the thermal behaviour of the building skin, but also by the use of the heat exchanger and the heat
storage systems, which contribute to the minimization of heating and cooling loads. Of course, if
E2VENT is employed in a major renovation of an existing building, addressing in parallel the glazed
components and the HVAC equipment, the building energy performance would be optimized,
reaching the nZEB concepts.
The energy behaviour of the system has been assessed with detailed simulations, which showed the
capabilities of each component and the system as a whole. Special attention was given in minimizing
the thermal break effect occurring at the anchorage points of the cladding. Recent studies have shown
that the problem of thermal bridges in cladding systems cannot be neglected since the actual heat
flows tend to be significantly higher than the estimated ones when point thermal bridges are not
treated properly [10]. Within the framework of this project, the process of developing a thermally
efficient anchoring system by proper selection of support system parts, detailed parametric analysis
of the characteristics affecting the thermal bridge problem and by integrating advanced modern
materials into the final proposed product is presented.
According to EN ISO 20211, a thermal bridge is defined as the “part of the building envelope where
the otherwise uniform thermal resistance is significantly changed by full or partial penetration of the
938
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
building envelope by materials with a different thermal conductivity, and/or a change in thickness of
the fabric, and/or a difference between internal and external areas, such as occur at wall/floor/ceiling
junctions” [11].
The three dimensional nature of the thermal bridge effect on cladding systems requires a detailed
calculation approach in order to take into account the complex geometry and the great differences in
Thermophysical properties of adjacent materials. According to ISO 10211, in order to achieve reliable
results regarding the magnitude of thermal bridging in such complicated structures, a detailed finite
element analysis is needed. In the case of this study, the calculation platform that was finally selected
was ANSYS Workbench.
The conducted multi-parametric showed that the thermal bridge problem is quite complicated and it
is strongly related to many factors. Existing technologies like thermal break pads are an established
technology that, unfortunately, cannot efficiently minimise the thermal bridge magnitude, especially
when the substrate wall is highly thermally conductive like the case of concrete walls. Stability, safety
and mechanical requirements are obviously the most important parameters in every construction, and
in the case of metal cladding systems, these requirements create limits on the permitted thickness and
thermal break layer thermophysical properties.
The type, condition and material of the substrate wall are factors that highly affect the thermal bridge
phenomenon. Since the anchors penetrate the insulation material and the thermal break pad in order
to be securely fixed within the substrate wall, this part of the support system remains the weakest.
The only possibilities for minimising these problems rely on the use of chemical anchors. Although
the area of the wall affected by the chemical anchor is limited and can’t stop the heat flow, it can
provide considerable thermal resistance compared to traditional anchor materials like steel, while at
the same time it provides numerous advantages related to the mechanical strength of the system.
The effect of this technology to the overall thermal transmittance of the façade is presented in figure
3. It shows the design U-value (calculated without considering the thermal bridge effect) increment
of the building element due to the point thermal bridge effect. It can be seen that, depending on the
required thermal insulation protection, the effect can account for more than 50% of the U-value.
Figure 3. Design and actual thermal transmittance (U-value) of the external envelope for half
and full-height steel brackets [10].
939
Soft and renewable energy sources
4.
POSSIBLE BARRIERS
The E2VENT system is designed and developed as a new retrofit solution. In order to ensure its wide
acceptance in the European market, it is essential to identify the potential barriers that may come up.
These barriers may stem from regulatory and morphological issues, as well as from the façade and
the HVAC characteristics of the buildings targeted [12].
Since the implementation of the E2VENT will require additional area coverage, it is essential that the
building under a refurbishment study has a leftover of ground surface coverage. E2VENT may meet
such problems in densely built areas such as urban centers. A possible solution could be the
construction of the system from the first storey and above, which may also be important in cases
where shops or other facilities do not allow such interventions. Additionally, buildings under
protection of cultural heritage rules may face significant barriers in implementing the E2VENT
system. In some cases restrictions permit refurbishment under specific conditions. Finally, a crucial
factor is the ownership status of the building. Since a partial implementation of the E2VENT system
is not effective or realistic, a single building manager could assist in applying such large-scale actions.
On the contrary, the existence of many owners renders the decision of approving the E2VENT system
construction very difficult not only on the basis of such a major refurbishment construction, but also
to other, minor but still significant decisions like the external color and surface treatment. Although
such problems are also present in the case of ETICS, the presence of heat recovery units and thermal
storage, adds more complexity to such decisions.
As regards the morphological parameters, the shape of the building is a factor that affects the
complexity of the design, the costs and also aesthetics of the building. Box-shaped buildings with flat
facades without balconies are preferable. The existence of rooms with overhangs may present some
problems, especially in the case where these overhangs do not lay beyond the external panels of the
E2VENT. The most significant factor that can hinder the selection of E2VENT may be the presence
of balconies. Problems related with balconies are of two types:
Those related to the interruption of the system’s continuity on the vertical axis. In this case, the air
gap is not continuous; as a result, fastening of the system to existing elements needs some special
treatment.
Problems related to the useful width of the balcony after the intervention. In narrow balconies, the
presence of the system may cover a relatively large part of the width, leaving a small area that is
possibly useless to users since they cannot walk with safety on this. Very narrow balconies may be
completely covered by the ventilated façade, altering significantly the architectural view of the
building.
Furthermore, the structural system and the materials of the existing façade play an important role in
the way the E2VENT system could be applied on a building. Depending on various parameters, not
all existing buildings can support such a refurbishment with safety. Buildings with reinforced
concrete elements are more likely to support the extra loads. In most cases, anchoring will be mainly
fastened on the concrete elements, while secondary or intermediate anchoring could assist load
bearing capabilities of a building. In the absence of concrete elements, a higher density of anchors is
required complicating the loads study, construction and thermal performance of the ventilated façade.
Façade areas with different colors, shapes and materials will be covered by the panels of the ventilated
façade. In such cases, the existing façade pattern could be recreated by the use of panels with different
colors. The size, number and shape of doors and windows on the façade affect the construction of
E2VENT. Wide glass areas interrupt the façade in a way similar to balconies, but with the additional
disadvantage that they decrease further the area available for the ventilation systems installation. In
addition, a large number of windows can complicate the construction process, while this is also true
in the case of non-orthogonal window layouts. Outgoing elements, small (like window sills and
frames) or large (like shading devises), constitute also a factor that needs to be taken into account
940
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
since the preservation of smaller architectural elements is impossible, while larger ones may lose their
functionality and may need reconstruction.
Among the parameters that should also be taken into account is the existence of air ventilation inlets
and exhausts like those usually found at kitchens and bathrooms. During the design process, decisions
on how to combine the operation of the E2VENT with existing ventilation strategies should be made.
In cases where heating or cooling is provided through individual external units (split-units, external
gas boilers, etc.), the design of the façade should take into account the proper integration of these
units in order to avoid aesthetic, construction and safety problems.
Apart from the above mentioned technical issues, social barriers may appear, involving mainly the
potential users and the technical world (architects, engineers and builders). Both derive from the lack
of knowledge or experience in selecting an advanced ventilated façade system as an energy measure
for building retrofitting. In order to investigate further the social acceptance of the E2VENT system,
a survey was addressed to building professionals and potential users. Given the different background
of these two groups, some of the questions are differentiated between the two surveys so as to avoid
frustrating and confusing possible end users with specialized technical questions. More than 1000
people answered the two survey forms, providing the E2VENT team with valuable information.
The majority of potential users are owners of an apartment in multifamily buildings in urban centres.
According to the obtained results, the improvement of the energy performance of their residence is
very significant; however the decision making for implementing an innovative energy efficient
technology requires initially their increased awareness on the system’s operation. Moreover, thermal
insulation efficiency, energy efficiency issues and the risk of water and moisture penetration are the
prevailing parameters that influence the users’ decision for the refurbishment of the façade of their
residence. On the other hand, installation and construction costs along with maintenance frequency,
easiness and cost are the most significant restraints that prohibit users from applying such a system.
Given that E2VENT solution involves mechanical ventilation, a great number of the respondents
seem unwilling to substitute opening of windows and natural ventilation with mechanical means, a
fact that can be explained by the increased survey participation of Mediterranean countries. To
overpass this obstacle and increase the social acceptance of the system, market managers and other
corresponding actors should make efforts to inform the public regarding the advantages of mechanical
ventilation such as increased indoor air quality, energy gains etc. Positive end-user opinions
appreciated the high thermal insulation efficiency and the energy efficiency of the system as the most
important parameters in order to apply it in a retrofit project, but increased cost of acquisition,
installation and maintenance were presented as an important obstacle.
In terms of the technical world, the majority of engineers have already experience in retrofit projects
but only a few have been implicated in ventilated facades projects. A great number is willing to apply
a ventilated façade in a future project but the lack of holistic knowledge may be an important obstacle
to face.
5.
CONCLUSIONS
This paper presents the main element of a new system developed for building retrofits within the
framework of a European Research Project. It comprises advanced technological features, integrated
in one modular system, which addresses mainly heat flows through the building skin and heat flows
due to ventilation. The system is still under development and its performance has not been validated
yet, but it is expected that its impact on the energy and the environmental performance of buildings
will be extremely significant.
The improved efficiency of existing buildings represents a high-volume, low-cost approach to
reducing energy use and greenhouse gas emissions. Additionally, it not only generates energy savings
with attractive levels of return on investment, but it also improves the energy security, creates jobs
and makes buildings more liveable.
941
Soft and renewable energy sources
Acknowledgements
This work has been developed within the project E2VENT: Energy Efficient Ventilated Facades for
Optimal Adaptability and Heat Exchange enabling low energy architectural concepts for the
refurbishment of existing buildings http://www.e2vent.eu/. The project has received funding from the
European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant agreement No 637261.
References
1. Andeweg M. Th., Brunoro S. and Verhoef L.G.W. (2007) COST C16 Improving the Quality of
Existing Urban Building Envelopes, state of the art, IOS Publications.
2. Economidou M., Atanasiu B., Despret Ch., Maio J., Nolte I. and Rapf O. (2011) Europe’s
buildings under the microscope: A country-by-country review of the energy performance of
buildings, BPIE.
3. Bragança L., Wetzel Ch., Buhagiar V. and Verhoef L.G.W. (2007) COST C16 Improving the
Quality of Existing Urban Building Envelopes, facades and roofs, IOS Publications.
4. Giulio Di R. (2010) COST Action, TU0701 Improving the Quality of Suburban Building Stock,
UnifePress.
5. TABULA (2012) “Typology Approach for Building Stock Energy Assessment”. Accessed
December 2017, http://www.building-typology.eu/.
6. EPISCOPE (2012) Accessed December 2017, http://episcope.eu/building-typology/country/gr/.
7. E2VENT (2015) Accessed December 2017, http://www.e2vent.eu/.
8. Gerhardt H.J. and Janser F. (1994) “Wind Loads on Wind Permeable Facades”, Journal of Wind
Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, Vol. 53, pp. 37-48.
9. Marques da Silva F. and Gomes M.G. (2008) “Gap Inner Pressures in Multi-Storey Double Skin
Facades”, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 40, pp. 1553-1559.
10. Theodosiou T.G., Tsikaloudaki A.G., Kontoleon K.J and Bikas D.K. (2015) “Thermal bridging
analysis on cladding systems for building facades”, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 109, pp. 377–
384.
11. Anon (2007) BS EN ISO 10211 Thermal bridges in building construction — Heat flows and
surface temperatures — Detailed calculations, ISO.
12. Bikas D., Tsikaloudaki K., Kontoleon K.J., Giarma C., Tsoka S., Tsirigoti D. (2017) “Ventilated
Facades: Requirements and Specifications Across Europe”, Procedia Environmental Sciences
vol. 38, pp. 148 – 154.
942
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
APPROPRIATE WIND FARM SITTING: THE CASE STUDY OF
REGIONAL UNIT OF MAGNESIA
A. Kouroumplis and D.G. Vagiona
Department of Spatial Planning and Development, A.U.Th, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia,
Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: dimvag@plandevel.auth.gr,
Abstract
Wind energy is one of the most important renewable energy sources, especially in regions where
appropriate wind power potential exists, hence, decisions on harvesting such a resource plays an
instrumental role in determining the appropriate policies required to achieve energy and climate
targets. The appropriate siting of such facilities has become of great concern the last decade and is
revealed by the significant growth in onshore wind farm siting applications across different
application areas worldwide. Wind velocity, slope, distance from specific areas (protected areas,
forests, urban areas, archeological sites) as well as from specific infrastructures (airports, road
network, electricity grid) are amongst the prevailing criteria used in defining sustainable sites for
wind farm development. The main aim of this paper is to identify appropriate sites for onshore wind
farm applications considering the restrictions imposed by the legislative framework of the Special
Framework for Spatial Planning and Sustainable Development for renewable energy sources
(SFSPSD-RES) (Greek institutional framework for wind farm siting) with the use of Geographical
Information Systems (GIS). The application focuses on the Regional Unit of Magnesia. The
methodology involves excluding areas and zones defined by the SFSPSD-RES as well as outstanding
criteria applied in the international literature review. The results reveal that the appropriate sites for
wind farm siting are rather handful mainly due to the low wind potential of the area.
Keywords: Renewable Energy Sources (RES); wind energy; wind farm siting, exclusion criteria
1.
INTRODUCTION
Over the past 40 years, there has been a sharp increase in the planet's population, which has a direct
result in the exploitation of natural resources. This has influenced the environment negatively leading
to its continuous deterioration. Demand for energy in the past years had been mainly covered by
conventional forms of energy, such as coal and oil, which burdened the environment even more. In
recent years, however, a greater sense of responsibility for environmental issues has been adopted,
which has resulted in the development of effective environmental policies. As a result, alternative
forms of energy sources, more environmental friendly, have been exploited and developed.
Nowadays, the exploitation of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) help to move to a low-carbon
economy, resulting in sustainable development. All the relevant policies aim to adopt environmental
friendly sources of energy to cover energy demand and mitigate environmental problems such as air
pollution and climate change. The European Union has created a legislative framework for the use of
RES so as to curb these emissions and promote cleaner transport but also reduce its dependence on
unreliable and volatile fossil fuels markets. The current framework sets the target for all Member
States of the European Union, a 20% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions compared to 1990 levels,
a 20% penetration of renewable energy in gross final energy consumption and a 20% saving primary
energy by 2020.
943
Soft and renewable energy sources
As far as wind energy is concerned, it is a fast-growing renewable energy technology. It provides a
cost-effective and scalable alternative to conventional actions, both in developing and developed
countries. No greenhouse gases and other pollutants are emitted, the impact on the environment is
almost negligible, and the cost of their construction and operation continues to decline.
Of course, an important prerequisite is that wind farm installations are properly located, since they
will mitigate and prevent even more potential impacts on both natural and anthropogenic
environment. The most crucial issue of wind farm development is its appropriate sitting. A
conventional power plant can be installed almost anywhere, unlike wind farms, which should be
located in places where certain wind velocity exists. In addition, specific areas with specific
characteristics, either environmental, technical/economic or social, that set the installation of the
onshore wind farms unviable, should be excluded from the outset.
In order to avoid the land-based negative impacts of wind farm siting in Greece, minimum and
maximum distances and safety limits around specific areas have been recorded in the legislative
framework of the Special Framework for Spatial Planning and Sustainable Development for
renewable energy sources (SFSPSD-RES) (MEECC, 2008).
In the present paper, the restrictions set by SFSPSD-RES are considered for the appropriate wind
farm sitting in the Regional Unit of Magnesia in Greece. It should be noted that in cases where the
above-mentioned framework does not provide any specific distances to spatial criteria, values cited
in the international literature are considered (eg Baban and Parry, 2001; Tegou et al, 2007; Aydin et
al, 2010; Lejeune and Feltz, 2008; Georgiou et al, 2012; Wang et al., 2014; Latinopoulos and
Kechagia, 2015; Kazim et al, 2015). The exclusion criteria as well as the minimum safety distances
are applied through Geographical Information Systems (GIS). In addition, areas that have been
already occupied by wind farms are excluded from the analysis. The paper concludes to appropriate
areas for onshore wind farm siting, satisfying environmental criteria as well as technical, economic
and social constraints.
2.
ONSHORE WIND FARM SITING CRITERIA
2.1 Literature Review on Onshore Wind Farm Siting Criteria
Many environmental, technical, economic and social factors influence decision-making on site
selection of onshore wind farm applications, including wind speed, topography and geology of land,
network structure, areas with significant natural resources, etc. In order to avoid negative impacts
imposed by onshore wind farms, minimum-maximum distances as well as safety limits should be
defined around specific areas. The primary siting criteria according to the international literature
include: wind velocity, distance from residential areas, distance from areas of environmental interest,
distance from networks (road networks, electricity distribution networks, airports, telecommunication
infrastructure), distance from tourist activities and points of interest, slope, altitude and land use. The
most cited criteria amonsgt them are (Bili and Vagiona, 2017): wind velocity, slope, proximity to
residential areas, protected areas and road networks.
1.Wind velocity
Wind velocity is one of the most important factors in determining onshore wind farm siting. The
viability of wind energy in a given location depends on the existence of efficient wind velocity at the
height at which the turbine is to be installed (Vanek and Albright, 2008). Any wind turbine design
option should be based on the average wind speed in the selected wind turbine area (Ucar and Balo,
2009). The criterion of wind velocity is considered as the primary and most important criterion in
wind farm siting applications and is incorporated in almost every study.
The proposed wind velocity thresholds found in the literature vary significantly. Argyros (2011) notes
that electricity can be generated from a wind turbine even at 2m/s. Baban and Parry (2001) consider
the speed limit acceptable at 4-5 m/s, Grammatikogiannis and Stratigea (2009) report that locations
944
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
where the wind speed is greater than 7m/s should be selected, while Blankenhorn and Resch (2014)
and Latinopoulos and Kechagia (2015) indicate that areas with average wind speed lower than 4.5m/s
should not be considered as appropriate. Sunak and Höfer (2015) note that an average annual wind
speed below 6 m/s is considered to be no longer economically feasible and, therefore, areas with a
wind speed of less than 6 m/s are excluded.
2. Distance from residential areas
Wind farm siting in or close to urban areas is restricted in order to prevent noise and visual impacts,
landscape effects and shadow flicker. Moreover, it is not possible to install wind farms in urban areas
because of space availability as well as the impact on inhabitants’ welfare. The majority of researchers
in wind farm siting exclude the developed area itself and a buffer zone around it, apart from Gorsevski
et al (2013) and Rodman and Meentemeyer (2006), who solely exclude the developed area.
Buffer zones less than 550 meters from residential areas and 400 meters from mixed land use areas
should be excluded according to Höfer et al (2016). Distances from residential areas vary from 500
meters (Yue and Wang, 2006) to 2500 meters (Bennui et al, 2007) in the literature. Ouamni et al
(2012) evaluate the feasibility of installing wind turbines in potential areas on the basis of a distance
from urban areas greater than 1000m. Gass et al. (2013) applied a GIS buffering to exclude all areas
within 1km of distance to settlement areas from technically feasible wind turbine sites. Tsoutsos et al
(2015) applied a series of criteria set by SFSPSD-RES and related to the implementation of minimum
distances from urban activities. A minimum distance of 1000 m from the settlement boundaries
should be considered for towns and settlements with population over 2000 inhabitants and a distance
of 1500 m from settlement boundaries of traditional settlements. The minimum distance for the rest
settlements as well as monasteries is set to 500 m.
3. Distance from areas of environmental interest
Wind power installations occupy large areas, usually in hills or mountains. The construction of roads
to access wind farms, the excavations in construction phase as well as the huge quantities of concrete
needed for the bases of turbine towers, change the geomorphology of the area and affect negatively
flora and fauna. The proposed distance from areas of environmental distances depends on the regime
of environmental protection. For example, Baban and Parry (2001) suggest that the wind farm
location should not be located within 1000m of areas of ecological value or special scientific interest.
Aydin et al (2010) proposed minimum distances of 1000m from areas of ecological value, of 250m
from ecologically sensitive areas, of 500m from wildlife conservation areas and of 300 m from nature
reserves to reduce risk to birds. Latinopoulos and Kechagia (2015) propose that wind farms should
not be sited on or within 1000m from protected landscapes, in order to preserve the esthetic value of
natural environment. According to Tsoutsos et al (2015), a minimum distance from Sites of
Community Importance of Natura 2000 should be set to 1500m.
4. Distance from networks (road networks, electricity distribution networks, airports,
telecommunication infrastructure)
Wind turbines should be located near existing transmission lines and access roads in order to reduce
construction, operational and maintenance costs. However, there is no generally valid definition of a
maximum distance from the wind turbines either to the road or to the electricity distribution network.
Wakeyama and Ehara (2011) propose a maximum distance of 200 meters from road networks. Bennui
et al (2007) and Tegou et al (2010) set the maximum distance to the next road to 2500m, whereas,
Baban and Parry (2001) and Gorsevski et al (2013) set it to 9000m and 10000m, respectively.
Tsoutsos et al (2015) record a safety distance of 120 meters from all networks, while in Höfer et al
areas with a larger distance than 500 m from roads get the lowest value score (the value scores
increase with decreasing distance).
945
Soft and renewable energy sources
5. Distance from tourist activities and points of interest
Tourism, historic, cultural and religious places are considered as restricted areas that are excluded
from the total land and the remainder is the land on which it is possible to erect an on-shore wind
farm (Ali et al, 2017). To minimize the impact of wind farms on local tourism, Tsoutsos et al (2015)
report that wind farms should be at a distance of at least 1000 meters from touristic activities. Xydis
et al. (2013) and Latinopoulos and Kechagia (2015) agree with this value in their studies performed
in the Greek territory. In order to preserve the cultural heritage, Baban and Parry (2001) claim that
wind farms should not be located on or within 1000 m of historic sites and National Trust property.
Tsoutsos et al (2015) propose that safety distances of 3000m should be considered from World
Heritage, archeological monuments and historical places of high importance, of 500m from the rest
archeological sites, cultural monuments, historical sites and of 500m from monasteries.
6. Slope
Soil slope is a very important factor in wind farm siting as it affects the ease of construction and
maintenance. Steep slopes may reduce the accessibility of cranes and trucks and increase construction
costs. Wakeyama and Ehara (2011) report that the maximum slope ranges from values with a
maximum gradient of 20%. Bennui et al (2007) exclude hilling areas steeper than 15% slope, while
Haaren and Fthenakis (2011) suggest that the slope should under no circumstances exceed 15%. Höfer
et al (2016) assume a maximum slope of 30% that corresponds to the opinions of the regional wind
power experts and wind farm planners who participated in a conducted survey. However, very deep
slopes (>10%) have been excluded in the majority of wind farm siting studies (eg Baban and Parry,
2001; Haaren and Ftenakis, 2011; Georgiou et al, 2012; Kazim et al., 2015).
7. Altitude
As far as the altitude is concerned, the generated wind energy decreases as the altitude increases, as
the air density decreases at higher altitudes. Digital Elevation Models are used to define suitable land
based on elevation. Wakeyama and Ehara (2011) select areas with altitudes below 1000m, while Gass
et al (2013) and Noorollahi et al (2016) propose 2000m as the cut-off criterion.
8. Land use
Some types of land uses are considered more suitable for onshore wind farm sitting. Areas with sparse
vegetation are more suitable for wind farm siting than areas with dense vegetation. Baban and Parry
(2001) in their study note that it is forbidden to develop wind energy projects on agricultural land.
Land uses such as agricultural land, barren land, grassland and shrubland are considered more
appropriate, while forest land less, according to Haaren and Fthenakis (2011). Gorsevski et al (2013)
distinguish classes representing different levels of land use suitability. Classes representing cropland,
pasture, shrub land, or barren land are considered the most suitable land cover. Grassland and forested
land represent moderately suitable land cover. Classes such as low intensity residential areas are
considered as the least suitable areas while developed areas, open water, and wetlands are considered
constraints. Lozano et al (2014) distinguish nine classes of agrological capacity (suitability of land
for agricultural development) that range from 0 (excellent – not suitable to host a wind farm) to 8
(low – very favourable to host wind energy facilities).
2.2 Greek institutional framework for wind farm siting
Article 6 of the Special Framework for SFSPSD-RES (MEECC, 2008) notes that the installation of
wind farms is not permitted inside: 1) World Heritage areas, archaeological monuments and historical
places of high importance, as well as in archaeological sites of zone A; 2) Areas of absolute protection
of the nature; 3) Wetlands RAMSAR; 4) Centre of national forests, nature monuments, aesthetic
946
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
forests; 5) Sites of Community Importance of Natura 2000; 6) Inside urban plans and settlement
boundaries; 7) Areas of integrated touristic development and organized productive activities of the
tertiary sector, thematic parks, touristic ports and beaches; 8) Tourist and residential areas (outside
the building plan); 9) Notable coasts and beaches (included in water bathing monitoring program);
10) High-productivity farmland; 11) Quarries and mines; 12) Areas or part of areas that are subject
to a specific land-use regime, which forbids wind farm siting.
2.3 Selected criteria and buffer zones for onshore wind farm siting
Several exclusion areas according to criteria recorded in SFSPSD-RES are identified in the Regional
Unit of Magnesia. Table 1 lists all the exclusion criteria and incompatible buffer zones for onshore
wind farm siting applied in this study. It should be noted that in cases that the SFSPSD-RES does not
provide any specific buffer zone, values found in the international literature are considered.
3.
ANALYSIS OF THE STUDY AREA
The Regional Unit of Magnesia is one of the 52 Regional Units of Greece and administratively
belongs to the region of Thessaly. It has an area of 2637 km2 and its population population reaches
190010 people according to the 2011 census. The capital of the regional unit of Magnesia is Volos,
that counts 144449 inhabitants.
The Regional Unit of Magnesia includes valuable natural and cultural resources as well as remarkable
tourist infrastructures. Traditional settlements, facilities of particular architectural interest, historical
and archaeological sites, as well as various museums can be found in the area. In addition, there is a
railway network, port facilities, an airport, a ski center and numerous tourism paths. The national road
network has a total length of 321 km.
Areas that belong to the network of core breeding and resting sites for rare and threatened species,
and some rare natural habitat types which are protected in their own right (Natura 2000) include: Oros
Pilio (GR 1430008/ 36216.5ha), the area covered by reservoirs of the former Karla lake (GR 1430007/
12422.9ha), Oros Mavrovouni (GR1420006/ 37146.90ha), Kouri Almyrou-Agios Serafeim
(GR1430002/ 100.28ha), Oros Orthys-Vouna Gkouras-farangi Palaiokerasias (GR1430006/
31093.50ha). In the Regional Unit of Magnesia, several Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty
(AONBs) and Wildlife Refuges can be found.
Figure 1 depicts wind farm applications that are in production license or have already been rejected
as well as the wind capacity of the Regional Unit of Magnesia. Wind velocity in the Regional Unit of
Magnesia is relatively low, since wind velocity does not exceed 5m/s in most parts of the study area.
Nevertheless, in the wider area of Pelion, the wind velocity increases and reaches up to 9m/s. It should
also be noted that the highest carrying capacity is measured at Municipal Units of Almyros and
Velestinos (> 100).
947
Soft and renewable energy sources
Table 1: Exclusion Criteria Restrictions
Α/Α
Exclusion Criteria
Buffer zones
SFSPSD-RES
(d=85m)
Buffer zones Literature
review
Buffer
zones
Present
case study
1
Wind Velocity
5m/s
5m/s
(eg Baban and Parry, 2001;
Tegou et al, 2007; Georgiou et
al, 2012)
2
Distance from areas of
environmental interest
1000m
1000m
(eg Baban and Parry, 2001;
Aydin et al, 2010; Wang et al.,
2014;
Latinopoulos
and
Kechagia, 2015)
3
Bathing Waters
4
Archaeological
595m (7d)
monuments and historical
places of high importance
595m
5
Monasteries
500m
6
Distance from residential 1000m
areas>2000 population
1000m
7
Distance from residential 500m
areas<2000 population
500m
8
Traditional Settlements
1500m
9
Distance
from
road 127.5m (1.5d)
networks,
electricity
distribution networks
10
Distance from airports
11
High-productivity
farmland
127.5m (1.5d)
127.5m
12
Quarries and Mines
500m
500m
1500m
1500m
500m
1500m
127.5m
5000 m (Lejeune and Feltz, 5000m
2008; Kazim et al, 2015)
* d is the diameter of the wind turbine’s rotor, which is equal to 85 m
948
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: Wind potential and existing wind farms
4.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
In the present application, areas which are excluded due to incompatibility include ports, the airport,
bathing waters, listed cultural monuments, monasteries, telecommunication antennae, the road
network and the electricity grid, SCIs and SPAs of the Natura 2000 network, Wildlife Refuges,
AONBs, settlements and high-productivity farmland. The excluded areas are presented in Figure 2.
Figure 2: Excluded areas
In addition, the minimum distances presented in Table 1 are applied, leading to the appropriate areas
for wind farm siting in the Regional Unit of Magnesia.
949
Soft and renewable energy sources
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
Figure 3: (a) Buffer zones from areas of residential areas (b) Buffer zones from areas of
environmental interest (c) Buffer zones from cultural interest (d) Buffer zones from
infrastructures (e) Areas with wind velocity lower than 5 m/sec and (f) Land suitability areas.
It is obvious that the available areas for wind farm siting in the Regional Unit of Magnesia are really
handful due to the special morphology of the area, the prevailing wind (wind velocity below 5m/s) as
well as the existing onshore wind farm infrastructures. Compatible areas for wind farm siting can be
found mainly on the southern part of Pelion and on the eastern side of the Municipal Unit of Almyros.
The surface of areas that have been already occupied by wind farms in production license covers
0.77% of the total area, while the surface of compatible areas found from the above analysis covers
0.87% of the total area.
5.
CONCLUSIONS
In recent years, there has been a constant increase in the share of energy from RES, especially wind
energy due to its high potential in final energy consumption. However, wind farm siting is a complex
issue, including various technical, socio-economic and environmental factors. Numerous studies
investigating onshore wind farm siting can be found in the literature.
A thorough research into the Greek institutional framework, which comprises the Special Framework
of Spatial Planning and Sustainable Development for Renewable Energy Sources and an extensive
literature review has been performed to formulate the exclusion criteria, which are finally included in
950
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
this analysis. The primary objective for selecting the appropriate criteria is the sustainable siting of a
wind farm that minimizes or even avoids any impact on physical and anthropogenic environment.
The present research constitutes a mainland application on the Regional Unit of Magnesia, where
wind velocity is quite low over a large part of the area. However, it can serve as an ex-ante evaluation
of potential new onshore wind farm investments and provide useful directions for policy and decision
makers. The criteria selected in this study could be applied in any spatial scale, from local to national
contributing to the sustainable onshore wind farm siting.
References
1. Ali S., Lee S.-M., Jang C.-M. (2017) ‘Determination of the Most Optimal On-Shore Wind Farm
Site Location Using a GIS-MCDM Methodology: Evaluating the Case of South Korea’, Energies,
10(12), 2072.
2. Argyros N. (2011) ‘Econometric study and evaluation of the construction of wind farms in
the Greek territory’, National Technical University of Athens, pp. 54.
3. Aydin N., Kentel E., Duzgun S. (2010) ‘GIS-based environmental assessment of wind energy
systems for spatial planning: A case study from Western Turkey’, Renewable and Sustainable
Energy Reviews, 14, pp. 364–373.
4. Baban S.M.J. and Parry T. (2001) ‘Developing and applying a GIS-assisted approach to locating
wind arms in the UK’, Renewable Energy, 24, 59–71.
5. Bennui A., Rattanamanee P., Puetpaiboon U., Phukpattaranont P., Chetpattananondh K. (2007)
Site selection for large wind turbine using GIS, International Conference on Engineering and
Environment (ICEE 2007), pp 561-566, Phuket, Thailand.
6. Bili A. and Vagiona D. (2017) Criteria and methodologies for onshore and offshore windfarm site
selection: A literature review research, 6th International Conference on Environmental
Management, Engineering, Planning and Economics (CEMEPE) and to the SECOTOX
Conference, Thessaloniki, Greece.
7. Blankenhorn V. and Resch B. (2014) ‘Determination of Suitable Areas for the Generation of
Wind Energy in Germany: Potential Areas of the Present and Future’, ISPRS International
Journal of Geo-Information, pp. 942-967
8. Gass V., Schmidt J., Strauss F., Schmid E. (2013) ‘Where the wind blows: Assessing the effect
of fixed and premium based feed-in tariffs on the spatial diversification of wind turbines’, Energy
Policy, 53, pp. 323-30.
9. Georgiou A., Polatidis H., Haralambopoulos D. (2012) ‘Wind Energy Resource Assessment and
Development: Decision Analysis for Site Evaluation and Application’, Energy Sources Part A,
34, pp. 1759-67.
10. Gorsevski P.V., Cathcart S.C., Mirzaei G., Jamali M.M, Ye X., Gomezdelcampo E. (2013) ‘A
group-based spatial decision support system for wind farm site selection in Northwest Ohio’,
Energy Policy, 55, pp. 374–85.
11. Grammatikogiannis E. and Stratigea A. (2010) ‘Evaluation of Alternative Sites for Wind Park
Location: A Methodological Framework’, Technika Chronika ,3, pp. 85-86.
12. Haaren R. and Fthenakis V. (2011) ‘GIS-based wind farm site selection using spatial multi-criteria
analysis (SMCA): Evaluating the case for New York State’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Reviews, 15, pp. 3332– 3340.
13. Höfer T, Sunak Y, Siddique H, Madlener R. (2016) ‘Wind farm siting using a spatial Analytic
Hierarchy Process approach: A case study of the Städteregion Aachen’, Applied Energy, 163,
pp. 222–43.
951
Soft and renewable energy sources
14. Kazim B., Simsek Α., Aydin U., Tosun Μ. (2015) ‘A GIS-based Multiple Criteria Decision
Analysis approach for wind power plant site selection’, Utily Policy, 37, pp. 86-96.
15. Latinopoulos D. and Kechagia K. (2015) ‘A GIS-Based MultiCriteria Evaluation for Wind Farm
Site Selection: A Regional Scale Application in Greece’, Renewable Energy, 78, pp. 550-560.
16. Lejeune P., Feltz C. (2008) ‘Development of a decision support system for setting up a wind
energy policy across the Walloon Region (southern Belgium)’, Renewable Energy, 33, pp. 241622.
17. Lozano-Sánchez J.M., García-Cascales M.S., Lamata M.T. (2014) ‘Identification and selection
of potential sites for onshore wind farms development in Region of Murcia, Spain’, Energy, 73,
pp. 311-324.
18. Ministry of Environment, Energy and Climate Change (MEECC). Specific framework for spatial
planning and sustainable development for renewable energy sources; 2008. JMD 49828/2008,
OGHE B′ 2464/3-12-08.
19. Noorollahi Υ., Yousefi Η., Mohammadi Μ. (2016) ‘Multi-criteria decision support system for
wind farm site selection using GIS’, Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments, 13,
pp. 38-50.
20. Ouammi Α., Ghigliotti V., Robba M., Mimet A. and Sacile R. (2012) ‘A decision support system for
the optimal exploitation of wind energy on regional scale’, Renewable Energy, 37, pp. 299-309.
21. Rodman L.C., Meentemeyer R.K. (2006) ‘A Geographic Analysis of Wind Turbine Placement in
Northern California’, Energy Policy, 34, pp. 2137-49.
22. Sunak Y. and Höfer T. (2015) ‘A GIS-based Decision Support System for the Optimal Siting
of Wind Farm Projects’, E.ON Energy Research Center Series.
23. Tegou L.I., Polatidis H., Haralambopoulos D.A.. (2007) Distributed Generation with Renewable
Energy Systems: The spatial dimension for an autonomous Grid, 47th conference of the
European Regional Science Association ‘Local governance and sustainable development’,
Paris, France.
24. Tegou L.I., Polatidis H., Haralambopoulos D.A. (2010) ‘Environmental management framework
for wind farm siting: Methodology and case study’, Journal of Environmental Management,
91, pp. 2134–47.
25. Tsoutsos T., Tsitoura I., Kokologos D., Kalaitzakis K. (2015) ‘Sustainable siting process in large
wind farms case study in Crete’, Renewable Energy,75, pp. 474-480.
26. Vanek F. and Albright L. (2008) ‘Energy Systems Engineering: Evaluation and Implementation’,
McGraw-Hill Professional.
27. Ucar A. and Balo F. (2009) ‘Evaluation of Wind Energy Potential and Electricity Generation at
Six Locations in Turkey’, Applied Energy, 86, pp. 1864-1872.
28. Wakeyama T. and Ehara S. (2011), Estimation of Renewable Energy Potential and Use- A Case
Study of Hokkaido, Northern-Tohoku Area and Tokyo Metropolitan, Japan, World Renewable
Energy Congress 2011, pp 3090-3097, Linkoping, Sweden.
29. Wang Q., Mwirigi M., Kinoshita I. (2014) ‘A GIS-Based Approach in Support of Spatial Planning
for Renewable Energy: A Case Study of Fukushima, Japan’, Sustainability, 6, pp. 2087-2117.
30. Xydis G. (2013) ‘A techno-economic and spatial analysis for the optimal planning of wind energy
in Kythira island, Greece’, International Journal of Production Economics, 146, pp. 440-52.
31. Yue C. and Wang S. (2006) ‘GIS-based evaluation of multifarious local renewable energy
sources: a case study of the Chigu area of southwestern Taiwan’, Energy Policy, 34, pp. 730–42.
952
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
HARNESSING THE BLUE RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES OF
THE COASTAL CEPHALONIA’S PARADOX AND THE EURIPUS
STRAIT
A. Stergiopoulou1, V. Stergiopoulos2*, G. Klironomos2, E. Ververis2, M. Syrganis2, K.
Papaioannou2 and M. Theodoridou2
Institut für Wasserwirtschaft, Hydrologie und konstruktiven Wasserbau, B.O.K.U. University,
Muthgasse 18, 1190 Vienna, Austria
2
ASPETE, Department of Civil Engineering Educators, ASPETE Campus, Athens 14121, Greece
1
*
Corresponding author : e-mail : bstergiopoulos@aspete.gr
Abstract
The sea represents a huge potential for Blue Renewable Energy Sources (BRES) such as waves, tides
and marine currents, including the Euripus Straits and the Cephalonia’s Coastal Paradox. The
possibility of exploiting the BRES, of zero-head sea and tidal currents, for power generation has given
little attention in Europe, in Mediterranean countries and in Greece, despite the fact that such currents,
representing a large renewable potential, could be exploited by modern technologies to provide
important levels of electric power. The present paper tries to describe simple physical models for the
hydraulic explanations of two of the most astonishing marine currents of the world, the Cephalonia's
Coastal Paradox (CCP) and the Euripus Strait Current (ESC), continuing to puzzle the scientists for
many decades. The CCP is consisting of a mysterious flow of the "through the island" strong
underground coastal current, with a continuous seawater inflow in the Livadi Gulf, near Argostoli,
reappearing in the other side of the island, in the Gulf of Sami. Passing from the Ionian Sea to the
Aegean Sea, the CCP finds its hydraulic flow analogue, in the tidal current of ESC, also among the
most famous world coastal phenomena. This is a remarkable exceptional fact in spite that tidal
currents in the Mediterranean Sea are in general comparatively weak. Since ancient times many
scientists try to cite advanced arguments towards parts of the global “Euripus problem” solution. One
of the main aims of the present paper is to propose innovative efficient technical solutions, in order
to harness the current potential of the CCP and the ESC, with a series of innovative Horizontal
Archimedean Screw Turbines, based on the first in the world Horizontal Archimedean Screw Turbine
built and studied at BOKU Vienna University.
Keywords: blue renewable energy sources, coastal Cephalonia’s paradox, Euripus strait current,
kinetic small hydro plants, Archimedean screw turbines
1.
INTRODUCTION
The present paper, part of the research project entitled “Research of Sea Hydraulic Mysteries of
Euripus and Cephalonia-Inventory of Blue Hydropotential”, examines two special cases of Blue
Renewable Energy Sources (BRES) probably unique in the world, Cephalonia and Euripus cases and
how harnessing their potential (Figure 1). Both sites are a glance at the sea water current and tidal
past and a promising modern look into the future blue renewable hydraulic kinetic energy.
953
Soft and renewable energy sources
Figure 1: How harnessing the Blue Renewable Energy Sources (BRES) of the Coastal
Cephalonia’s Paradox (CCP) and Euripus Strait Current (ESC)?
It is well known that the sea represents a huge potential for Blue Renewable Energy Sources such as
waves, tides and marine currents, including the Euripus Straits and the Cephalonia’s Coastal Paradox.
The possibility of exploiting the BRES, of zero-head sea and tidal currents, for power generation has
given little attention in Europe, in Mediterranean countries and in Greece, despite the fact that such
currents, representing a large renewable potential, could be exploited by modern technologies to
provide important levels of electric power. The particular sea and tidal currents of Cephalonia and
Euripus Strait and their living forces were in the past used by sea-mills and tidal mills for cereal
exploitation playing an important role to the local society and economy [1,5,6]. The pioneer English
Stevenson made important observations of the over the centuries unexplained Thalassomili
Katavothres phenomenon and created in 1835 the first cereal productive Argostoli mills exploiting
the unknown living forces of sea water penetrated into the local katavothres and disappearing into the
porous limestone of the island. According to the geologist Miliaresis [2,3] the 1953’s earthquakes
made the destruction of the productive Cephalonia sea-mills. Fuller [2] and Crosby [3] made
important works about the fundamental role of the slight variations in sea water density introducing
sufficient differences in pressure to produce circulation. Koder [4] gives some very valuable
information for three existing tidal mills in Negreponte (Chalkis) during the Venetian period.
Unfortunately, Cephalonia sea mills and Euripus tidal mills stopped to operate. For the case of Chalkis
there are no fingertips of the glorious tidal mill past. For the case of Cephalonia, the
seamills of nowadays, build in Argostoli during 60’s, have only a touristic attraction, without any cereal
or electrical productivity.
The island of Cephalonia is the site of one of the most astonishing hydrological phenomena in the
world, its coastal cross flow paradox [5]. Α strange seawater massive current flows continuously into
the karst substratum of the island through sinkholes, in the Livadi Gulf, near Argostoli (Figure 2).
The present paper tries to describe some quite simple physical models for the hydraulic explanation
of the strange cross-flow Cephalonia's coastal paradox and to find hydraulic correlations with a strong
lost and forgotten water near-shore processes memory [6, 7]. This seawater current disappearing in
the water channel entrance, in the Livadi Gulf, reappears on the opposite coast of the island at brackish
springs, near the town of Sami (Figure 2). This strange “through the island continuous seawater
current”, seems to be a real world unique sea hydraulic mystery, the so called ‘Cephalonia's Coastal
Paradox’ or ‘Cephalonia's Sea-River’.
954
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 2: Schematic representation of the most astonishing hydraulic phenomenon in the
world.
Passing from the Ionian Sea to the Aegean Sea, the Cephalonian Sea-River finds its hydraulic flow
analogue in the tidal current of Euripus Strait, which is also among the most famous coastal
phenomena in the world, despite the fact that tidal currents in the Mediterranean Sea are in general
comparatively weak. Since ancient times many renowned men of science, Eratosthenes, Strabo,
Posidonius, Seleucus, Pliny the Elder and Aristotle among them, cited advanced correct arguments
towards parts of the “Euripus problem” concerning the narrow channel of the Euripus, subject to
strong tidal currents, which reverse direction approximately four times a day. Between the midnineteenth and mid-twentieth centuries, many scientists, among them Eginitis [9] contributed towards
the complete solution of the Euripus problem. A recent analysis with simulations of the tidal flows in
the North and South Evvoikos Gulfs, separated by the Euripus Strait has been presented by Tsimplis
[10].
2.
2. ABOUT THE CEPHALONIA’S COASTAL PARADOX
According to Bonacci’s Karst Hydrology the only permanent sea katavothres in the world, is the case
of Argostoli [11]. Generally, Cephalonia’s katavothres, swallowing sea water permanently, are wellorganized fissures in the karst mass through which the water sinks underground and they play an
important role, from a hydraulic and hydro-geologic standpoint of view, in the whole water karst
flow. This strange strong seawater current is disappearing continuously in the Livadi Gulf through
sinkholes, which have formed in fractures in the rock (Triassic, Jurassic, Cretaceous and Cainozoic
limestone and dolomite). This seawater current reappears on the opposite coast of the island at
brackish springs, near the town of Sami. The underground seawater current route between Argostoli
and Sami is about 15Km long (Figure 3). Such inflow-outflow seawater current phenomenon has not
been observed in other karst islands in the Mediterranean or in other parts of the world.
Figure 3: Schematic representation of the Cephalonia paradox.
955
Soft and renewable energy sources
There must necessarily be a continuous source of energy to cause this hydraulic phenomenon of the
continuous inflow of water below sea level, since the latter represents minimum potential for water,
in the field of terrestrial gravity. However, it is well known that an important continuous marine
current, the Levantine Intermediate Water (LIW), formed in the Levantine Sea, with a Northwards
direction follows the Aegean current, which runs round the southern coast of Greece and joins the
Adriatic circuit currents, and touches the island of Cephalonia, could probably have a vital driving
force importance behind the Cephalonia underground sea. Who maintains the movement of the
C.C.P.? Does the presence of a labyrinth of karst conduits play a certain role in the whole throughout
current flow? Is it possible to occur simultaneously, various factors, like the energy of the AegeanAdriatic marine current, the density flow and the presence of karst conduits, for the control of the
whole phenomenon? [13, 14]. Which is the role of the Ghyben-Herzberg ratio of fresh and salt-water
density to the dynamic interface of this unusual marine current phenomenon? [15, 16]. Many other
questions and problems persist. We could probably assume that there is, in the substratum of the
island, a kind of strange attractor, a quasi - natural ejector, which works on the principle of the water
ram pump jet and that there, is probably operated by infiltration of water [12, 13, 16, 17, 18]. This
good hypothesis is nevertheless not very efficient from a hydrodynamic point of view. In addition, it
is possible to report that physical conditions of flow through siphons, venturi tubes, and tubular
openings in the carbonate rocks could explain the whole phenomenon.
However, judging from the negative head in the sinkholes the velocity of the fresh water appears to
be insufficient to operate a ‘natural ram jet pump’ or suggested ‘venturi tubes’. Observing seawater
flowing through the entry canal near Argostoli and disappearing in a system of katavothres, they
erroneously concluded that it must flow through the interior of the island, where it looses its “earthy”
component, thus becoming the pure water that could be observed at the springs in the foothills. The
clouds often observed at the relatively high mountainous volume of Ainos further supported this idea
(Figure 4). They took this as a clear indication that this water was in fact transformed into clouds
when reaching mountaintops, thus closing the hydrological cycle. In the same figure shown is another
explanation of the coastal cross-flow current by analogy to a jet pump. According to this analogy high
velocity fresh water sucks seawater creates a strong Venturi effect able to power the whole
mechanism.
Figure 4: Representations of ‘natural ram jet pump’, ‘venturi tubes’ and other hydraulic
hypothesis for the local explanation the CCP.
A quite simple hydrostatic model of three in equilibrium connected vertical tubes (3, 1, 2), filled with
sea water, fresh and brackish water, could be used to simulate the Cephalonia Argostoli-Sami sea
water flow mechanism (Figure 5). In this three-tube model, H is the unknown depth of mixing zone,
ΔH1 is the karst hydraulic gradient with ρ1 the density of fresh water, ΔH2 is the altitude of the exit
brackish spring furnishing brackish water having density ρ2 and ΔH3 is the input variation of the sea
level with a density of sea water ρ3, with ρ1<ρ2<ρ3. According to the principle of communicating
vessels the fundamental equation of hydrostatics will give
(Η+ΔΗ3).ρ3.g = (H+ΔΗ1).ρ1.g =(Η+ΔΗ2).ρ2.g
956
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 5: Schematic presentation of the communicating vessels principle with 3 vertical tubes
When fresh water is injected in the fresh water pipe 1, then a current moves towards the brackish pipe
2, where the density is lower than in the sea pipe 3. It is clear that the introduction of fresh water in
the brackish pipe provokes a dilution and decreases. After mixing, the brackish water is not as heavy
as sea water and, therefore, rises along the interface of the fresh water and salt water to springs. The
true causes of the CCP phenomenon have not been elucidated so far. It seems that this throughout
Cephalonia current will continue to challenge and to puzzle us continuously.
3.
ABOUT THE EURIPUS STRAIT CURRENT
It is well known that gravitational forces between the moon, the sun and the earth cause the rhythmic
rising and lowering of ocean waters around the world and the creation of the tide waves. The moon
exerts more than twice as great a force on the tides as the sun due to its much closer position to the
earth. The development of tidal science began in Antiquity, with the cosmology of Aristotle, who
observed that ‘ebbings and risings of the sea always come around with the Moon and upon certain
fixed times’. Aristotle used his books “On the Heavens and Physics” to put forward his notion of an
ordered universe divided into two distinct parts, the earthly region and the heavens [6, 7]. Other
developments in tidal science at this time included those by Pytheas, who travelled through the Strait
of Gibraltar to the British Isles and reported the half-monthly variations in the range of the Atlantic
Ocean tides, and that the greatest ranges occurred near the new and the full Moons. Many other
aspects of the relationship between tides and the Moon are noted in Pliny the Elder’s “Natural
History” [6, 7]. Pliny described how the maximum tidal ranges occur a few days after the new or full
Moon, and how the tides at the equinoxes in March and September have a larger range than those at
the summer solstice in June and winter solstice in December.
Tidal flows are very weak in the Eastern Mediterranean, and the Euripus strait is a remarkable
exception. Tidal flow peaks at about 12Km/h, either northwards or southwards, and lesser vessels are
often incapable of sailing against it. When nearing flow reversal, sailing is even more precarious
because of vortex formation. The whole problem has not yet been given a general and complete
solution. Some of the questions associated with this subject have been correctly explained, but not
always with completeness and the required scientific proofs, others were given a bad solution or
misunderstood, while others have been quite ignored, owing to the lack of the necessary tidal data
and some had not been studied at all. The complete solving of the Euripus problem is due to
D. Eginitis, who published his conclusions in 1929 [9]. It seems that Eginitis gives the general
solution of this famous Euripus tidal problem, with all the proofs provided by the theory and the
observations, based on the laws of Hydrodynamics and Celestial Mechanics and the respective rules
of Hydraulics, taking into consideration the tide observations made by the Hydrographical Service of
the Ministry of Marine.
957
Soft and renewable energy sources
It seems that the tide observed in the gulf of Euboea is nearly exclusively derivative, and it is produced
not only by a local tide of the Aegean Sea as up to this time it was erroneously thought to be, but it
comes from the Eastern basin of the Mediterranean Sea which is simultaneously fluctuating with the
Western Mediterranean. On this latter there is a slight influence of the tides of the Atlantic Ocean. So
the Aegean Sea could be considered as a gulf of the Eastern Mediterranean, through which its tide is
transmitted to the gulf of Euboea entering it through its two ends and so reaching Euripus. Without
this tide, coming from the Eastern basin of the Mediterranean Sea, the great difference of the times
of establishment of the two ports of Chalkis, situated at a distance of a few metres, remains in suspense
(left part of the Figure 6). According to Tsimplis et al [10] the reported values for the Euripus Strait
tidal currents are as high as 4.4 m/sec, the tidal signal is choked at the strait and consequently very
little energy is transferred between the north and the south Evvoikos Gulf. It seems that the sea level
of both gulfs oscillates independently of each other and causes significant sea level differences and
strong currents across the Euripus Strait. The tide reaches the south part of the north Evvoikos Gulf
later than it reaches the northern part of the south Evvoikos Gulf. Moreover, the tidal amplitude is
lower at the southern opening of the south Evvoikos Gulf than at the north opening of the north
Evvoikos Gulf, due to the standing wave nature of the semi-diurnal tide within the Aegean. The tides
are further enhanced while propagating through the canals of Trikeri and Oreoi in the north Evvoikos
Gulf. As a result, the north Evvoikos oscillates everywhere with amplitudes which are virtually the
same everywhere in the basin. In contrast, the southern Evvoikos Gulf has much smaller tides. Thus
the six-hourly variation of currents is produced mainly by the relatively large semi-diurnal tides of
the north Evvoikos Gulf, which introduce six- hourly changes in the sign of sea level differences
between the two gulfs (left part of the Figure 6). A characteristic optical view of the tidal model of
Tsimplis et al [10] concerning the sum of the major tidal components in the Hellenic Seas is given in
the right part of the Figure 6.
Figure 6: Views of the tidal model of Tsimplis et al [10] for the major tidal components in the
Hellenic seas.
The kinetic power P, expressed in W, in sea currents, such as the cases of the Cephalonia's Coastal
Paradox (CCP) and the Euripus Strait Current (ESC), is related to the velocity of the water passing
through the cross section of a sea channel and is given by the equation P (1 / 2). . V 3 dA ,where ρ
is the water density (kg/m3), A is the cross sectional area of the channel (m2) and V is the sea current
flow velocity (m/s). Figure 7 shows the expected influence of the flow speed on kinetic power density
P/A expressed in kW/m2.
958
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 7: Kinetic power density expressed in kW/m2.
Figure 7 shows that the kinetic power flux density in a 3m/s current is approximately 15
kW/m2. This suggests that the kinetic power available for conversion in various parts of the
world, including those of ESC of Euripus and CCP of Cephalonia, should be very useful blue
renewable energy to be exploited by innovative horizontal axis Archimedean screw turbines.
In order to study and to investigate theoretically and experimentally the horizontal screw turbine
performances, the first in the world horizontal Archimedean screw turbine has been built and tested
at BOKU Vienna University [20]. The basic geometrical characteristics of this innovative screw rotor,
that is installed and experimented in the hydraulic channel at the Laboratory of the Institute for Water
Management, Hydrology and Hydraulic Engineering, in Vienna, are given in Figure 8. The length L,
the diameters (output and input), the pitch S and the number of blades of the screw rotor are L=0.945
m, Do=200mm, Di=100mm, S=200mm, S/Do=1 and n=3 (number of blades).
Figure 8: One blade basic design characteristics of the three bladed horizontal screw rotor
[20].
The horizontal screw rotor could rotate horizontally and change orientation direction (θ1, θ2, θ3….,
with Δθ=100o), forming an upstream maximum value of azimuthal angle of 50o and a downstream
maximum azimuthal angle of 50o with its initial position, as indicated in Figure 9.
Figure 9: Modalities of horizontal orientation direction changes of the horizontal screw rotor.
959
Soft and renewable energy sources
Two realistic pictures of the first in the world developed horizontal axis 3-bladed screw turbine, in
experimental operation, in the laboratory channel of BOKU Vienna University, with upstream and
downstream views, are given in the following Figure 10 [20].
Figure 10: Upstream and downstream views of the horizontal screw rotor in the laboratory
channel [20] (photos: Alkisti Stergiopoulou).
The hydrodynamic performances estimation of the horizontal screw turbine is based on the idea of
the undershot horizontal axis screw waterwheel. Consider the horizontal screw waterwheel, having
an effective radius R (m), a frontal screw blade wet section A(m2) and an angular velocity ω(rad/s)
rotating in a stream flow of velocity V (m/s) (see Figure 11). The available input power Pin (W) and
the output power produced Pout(W) of the horizontal axis Archimedean screw turbine can be
determined by the relations Pin (W)= (1/2). ρ. V 3.A and Pout = T . ω, where ρ=water density (Kg/m3)
and Τ=torque (N.m). The angular velocity ω is given by ω=2.π.Ν/60, where Ν=rotation speed (RPM).
Τhe torque T is obtained by the relation T=Fd .R, in function of the drag force exerted on the screw
blade Fd =Cd. (1/2).ρ.A.V 2, with Cd the screw blade drag coefficient. The efficiency degree η could
be defined by the following relationship η = Pout / Pin. A simple schematic representation of the
horizontal screw waterwheel rotating in stream flow of velocity V is given in Figure 11.
Figure 11: Horizontal screw waterwheel rotating in stream flow of velocity V.
According to the obtained experimental results, the highest value of the experimental efficiency could
arrive the level of about 83 %, with an azimuthal angle of 35o at various rotation speeds (e.g. 75 RPM)
[20].
4.
HARNESSING THE KINETIC POTENTIAL OF THE ESC AND CCP WITH
HORIZONTAL ARCHIMEDEAN SCREW TURBINES
According to the two scenarios proposed by Tsimplis [10], concerning the current velocities of the
Strait of Euripus, of about 3.4 m/s and 4.4 m/s, the power densities could be (P/Α) 1,tsimplis = 20.14
960
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
KW/m2 and (P/Α) 2,tsimplis = 43.66 KW/m2. Approximate estimations of the theoretical total current
power of the strait could be P1,th,tsimplis = 6,45ΜW and (P)2,th, tsimplis=13,92MW. By taking into account
the Lanchester-Betz limit Cp of about Cp=16/27, the total strait current power could be equal to
P1,tsimplis = 3,82ΜW and P2,tsimplis=8,25 MW. For the case of five horizontal axis Archimedean screw
turbines to operate in the Euripus Strait, geometrically similar to the first horizontal screw rotor
studied in BOKU University, as indicated in Figure 12, with a length 2m and a frontal blade area 2m2,
the maximum installed kinetic power for the set of the five horizontal screw turbines could be P 1,5,
tsimplis =119,37kW and P2,5, tsimplis =258,71kW [21].
Figure 12: A set of five horizontal axis Archimedean screw turbines to operate in the Euripus
Strait (photo: A. Stergiopoulou).
For the velocities scenarios of Tsimplis, the approximations made for the installed capacity of a
horizontal axis screw turbines park, having 20 similar series of five screw machines, could give
P1,park=P1,5,20 tsimplis= 2.39 MW and P2,park =P2,5,20 tsimplis = 5.17 MW. Such future horizontal axis screw
turbines parks could be implemented along the coasts or perpendicularly to the main current direction
of the Euripus Strait, as indicated in Figure 13.
Figure 13: Two future implementation scenario of future horizontal axis screw turbines parks
in Euripus.
For the mysterious flow of the Cephalonia's Coastal Paradox (CCP), our mean current velocity
measurements, in the input channel of Argostoli, show a mean value of about V1(Argostoli)= 0.5 m/s
[21]. The measurements of the current velocity in the output channel of Sami show a mean value of
about V2(Sami) =1.62 m/s [21]. The input current power density P/A is estimated to be
P/A=0.64 kW/m2. The output current power density P/A is estimated to be P/A=2.18 kW/m2. For the
case of one horizontal axis Archimedean screw turbine to operate in the output channel of Sami,
geometrically similar to the first horizontal screw rotor studied in BOKU University, as indicated in
the Figure 14, with a length 2m and a frontal blade area 1m2, the maximum installed kinetic power
could be 2kW.
961
Soft and renewable energy sources
Figure 14: Mechanism of the horizontal axis Archimedean screw turbine to operate in the
CCP output channel (photo: A. Stergiopoulou).
A screw hydropower turbines park, with a series of similar 200 horizontal screw turbines, will have
an overall installed kinetic power capacity of about 0.4 MW (Figure 15).
Figure 15: Schematic representation of a screw hydropower turbines park in CCP
(photo: A. Stergiopoulou).
5.
TOWARDS SOME PRELIMINARY CCP AND ESC CONCLUSIONS
Very promising innovative horizontal Archimedean Screw Turbines, based on the first in the world
horizontal Archimedean screw turbine built, developed, perfected and studied at BOKU Vienna
University, are proposed in the present paper. These horizontal screw turbines could be used in
Euripus and in Cephalonia in the future, in the form of Archimedean screw parks, harnessing the
kinetic hydropotential of ESC and CCP. Figure 16 gives two artistic views of horizontal axis screw
turbines to exploit the blue energy potential of the CCP in the output channel near Sami.
Figure 16: Artistic views of horizontal axis screw turbines in the output channel of the CCP
(photo: A. Stergiopoulou).
962
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 17 gives a series of artistic views of different horizontal and vertical axis screw turbines in the
Strait of Euripus.
Figure 17: Artistic views of horizontal and vertical axis hydrodynamic screws in the ESC.
(photo: A. Stergiopoulou).
A future aim of the present paper, part of our research project “Research of Sea Hydraulic Mysteries
of Euripus and Cephalonia-Inventory of Blue Hydropotential”, is to make C.F.D. (Computational
Fluid Dynamics) simulations of the very complicated current flows of the CCP and of the ESC, by
using the Flow-3D program. To simulate in the present research, the very complex tridimensional
flow phenomena of CCP and ESC, in the presence of various rotating horizontal screw turbines,
harnessing their important unexploited blue energy potential, a series of modern CFD simulations are
required. A first characteristic post-processing view of such a first CFD simulation of the very strange
and complicated “through Cephalonia sea river”, using the Flow-3D program, is presented in Figure
18.
Figure 18: A characteristic C.F.D. post-processing view of the first Flow-3D simulation for the
“through Cephalonia sea river”.
963
Soft and renewable energy sources
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The research work of the present paper has been financed by the Greek School of Pedagogical and
Technological Education through the operational program "Research strengthening in ASPETE"–
Project “Aspete’s Coastal Cephalonia’s and Euripus Straits Sea Blue Energy Laboratory” [21].
References
1. Petrochilou A. (1997) ‘About the Sea Mills and the Labyrinth of Cephalonia’ (personal
communication)
2. Fuller M. L. (1908) ‘Conditions of circulation at the Sea Mills of Cephalonia’, Bul. Geol, Soc.
America, vol. 18, pp. 221-232.
3. Crosby F.W., Crosby, W.O. (1896) ‘The Sea Mills of Cephalonia’, Tech. Quart., vol. 9, pp. 623
4. Koder Johannes Negroponte (1973) ‘Untersuchungen zur Topographie und Siedlungsgeschichte
der Insel Euboia während der Zeit der Venezianerherrschaft Österreichische Akademie der
Wissenschaften Veröffenlichungen der Kommission für die Tabula Imperii Byzantini (Band I),
(pp. 77, 80-81, 85) Wien
5. Stergiopoulos V. (2007) ‘About hydraulic paradox of the karst volume of Cephalonia’, ASPETE
Report, (in Greek).
6. Stergiopoulos V. (1996) ‘Water memory’, INFORMATION, Athens.
7. Stergiopoulos V. (1996) ‘The water remembers. You?’, ASPETE Report, (in Greek).
8. Stergiopoulos V. (2005) ‘About karst hydrology of Greece”, ASPETE Report, (in Greek).
9. Eginitis D. (1929) ‘The problem of the Tide of Euripus’, Proceedings of the Academy of Athens
A, 49-59 (in Greek).
10. Tsimplis M.N. (1997) ‘Tides and Sea-level Variability at the Strait of Euripus’, Estuarine,
Coastal and Shelf Science, 44, 91-101
11. Bonacci O. (1987) ‘Karst hydrology‘, Springer Verlag, Berlin.
12. Millot C. (2005) ‘Circulation in the Mediterranean Sea: evidences, debates and unanswered
questions’, Scientia Marina, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientificas.
13. Hamad N., Millot C, Taupier-Letage I. (2006) ‘The surface circulation in the eastern basin of the
Mediterranean Sea’, Scientia Marina, 70 (3), 457-503.
14. Stergiopoulou, A. and Stergiopoulos, V. (2009) ‘From the old Archimedean Screw Pumps to the
new Archimedean Screw Turbines for Hydropower Production in Greece’, Proceedings of
SECOTOX and CEMEPE Conference, Mykonos.
15. Stergiopoulos V., Stergiopoulos G. and Stergiopoulou A. (2007) ‘The coastal Cephalonia’s
paradox: Quo vadis?’, Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Environmental
Management, Engineering, Planning and Economics - CEMEPE, Skiathos, 2007.
16. Stergiopoulos V., Stergiopoulou A. (2008) ‘The Coastal Cross-Flow Cephalonia’s Paradox: A
Lost Atlantic Attractor’, Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference “The Atlantis
Hypothesis: Searching for a Lost Land”, Athens, 10-11 November 2008.
17. Bauer E.W. (1971) ‘Les secrets du monde souterrain’, FLAMMARION, Paris.
18. Drogue C. (1989) ‘Continuous inflow of seawater and outflow of brackish water in the substratum
of the karstic island of Cephalonia’, Journal of Hydrology, 106.
19. Hydrographical Department of War Navy, (2013) ‘Data for the Tide of Euripus’.
964
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
20. Stergiopoulou A. (2017) ‘Computational and experimental investigation of the hydrodynamic
behavior of screw hydro turbine’, Ph.D. Thesis, N.T.U.A.
21. Stergiopoulos V., Stergiopoulou A. (2018), ‘Research of Sea Hydraulic Mysteries of Euripus and
Cephalonia Inventory of Blue Hydropotential’, ACCESS-BEL ASPETE Research Project.
965
Soft and renewable energy sources
A PANHELLENIC SURVEY (2017-2018)
REGARDING ENERGY NEEDS COMFORT CONDITIONS
AND ATTITUDES TOWARDS RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES
P. Kosmopoulos1*. A. Kantzioura1, I. Kosmopoulos1, K. Kleskas1, A. M. Kosmopoulos1
1
Κ-eco Projects co, f. Director of the Laboratory of Environmental and Energy Design of Buildings
and Settlements, DUTH
*Corresponding author: E-mail: pkosmos@env.duth.gr
Abstract
There is no official estimation regarding the Energy Poverty in Hellas during the recent years. Several
studies have been carried out independently, regarding specific areas or social groups, but none has
covered the whole of the population.
The main aims of this research study, presented here are how peoples' attitudes and views towards
the Energy subjects and the use of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) are affected by the Economic
Crisis, and a rather dystopian general future. How serious and important are the environmental issues
considered to be when people feel that their everyday life is threatened? This subject is approached
through this Panhellenic survey analyzing the data gathered by questionnaires.
A large number of areas and cities have been covered, offering a satisfactory image of the subject.
Conclusions of this research project regard:
a) the comfort conditions in the houses of the participants, and how these conditions have been
changed lately. Due to the economic crisis.
b) The attitudes of the people towards Renewable Energy Sources (photovoltaics, wind turbines, etc),
the energy saving policy and related devices and how these attitudes have been affected by the
economic crisis, the tariff policy and the bureaucracy.
c) The attitudes of the participants towards energy and environmental subjects in our country, and
how these attitudes have been affected by the current situations.
The conclusions of the research project are hopefully very important describing the people’s attitudes
towards energy needs, fuel consumption and R.E.S. matters during this critical period of the country.
Keywords: Energy needs; social survey; Energy poverty, RES; Economic crisis.
1.
INTRODUCTION
The Panhellenic social research presented here, examines the energy consumption, the energy needs,
the comfort conditions of the people of today’s Hellas and also their attitudes towards R.E.S.
After an extremely heavy winter (below 0oC for twenty days, very rare for Greece) and within a
framework of an international economic crisis, Hellas has been the first of the European countries
that has been badly affected and recently Energy Poverty is a well known fact. But at the same time,
according to the E.U. Directives, Hellas has to conform with the regulations regarding the application
and the use of Renewable Energy Sources.
It is also interesting to see how environmental matters are faced in general, regarding energy sources,
fuels and related costs during this transitory period.
966
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The sensitivity of Hellenic people towards environmental matters is a diachronically acknowledged:
the traditional architecture, the antiquities, the natural environment and the related protective
legislation, have established a concrete culture, which more or less, nowadays has to be denied. It is
obvious that a new environmental aesthetics culture has to be shaped.
But parallel to the above, Hellenic people have to face their household economics, their traditional
attitudes towards their environment (both built and natural) and their dependence from imported fuels
(oil and gas). Among other research projects, every two years, we conduct a social research regarding
the attitudes of Hellenic people towards R.E.S. (see Kosmopoulos 2002; 2004; 2006; 2008; 2011;
2013; 2015; 2017).
This study, adds to the existing literature the recent opinions and attitudes of the participants towards
poor comfort conditions, economic crisis, RES and environment aspects.
2.
THE RESEARCH PROJECT
The survey has been planned and carried out by members of the K-ecoprojects co. and a large number
of students, postgraduates, and PhDs that have attended our lectures.
The questionnaires gathered, have been processed by the staff and the collaborators of K-eco projects.
The task has been to extract easily understandable data, in order to help the authorities that might be
interested to use the results of our survey. The questionnaire is based upon the Guttman scale (Canter,
1988) but it has been adapted to the well approved and generally accepted 5 point Likert scale, in
order to be comparable to all previous relative study (see Kosmopoulos 2002; 2004; 2006; 2008;
2011; 2013; 2015; 2017).
3.
THE SURVEY
The research project, regarding the social attitudes towards the environmental subjects during this
critical period, has lasted from 1/2017 to 2/2018 (ongoing), all over Hellas (and Cyprus) through the
collection of questionnaires, and has covered the following respective number of valid questionnaires:
City
AGRINIO
ATHINA
ALEXANDROUPOLI
AMYNTAIO
VEROIA
VOLOS
GIANITSA
GREVENA
DIDYMOTEICHO
DRAMA
EDESSA
IGOUMENITSA
IRAKLEIO
THESSALONIKI
THIVA
IOANNINA
KAVALA
KALAMATA
KARDITSA
KASTORIA
KATERINI
KERKYRA
KILKIS
Quest.
19
219
21
14
21
43
14
21
11
23
21
19
33
189
19
27
29
19
21
29
15
19
12
City
KOZANI
KOMOTINI
KORINTHIA
KOS
LARISA
LEFKADA
MYTILINI
NAFPLIO
XANTHI
ORESTIADA
PATRA
PEIRAIAS
RETHYMNO
RODOS
SERRES
SPARTI
TRIKALA
TRIPOLI
TYRNAVOS
FLORINA
CHALKIDA
CHANIA
CYPRUS
Quest.
Map
31
47
21
7
39
7
17
13
46
13
47
33
17
13
39
13
11
7
8
33
11
21
47
Map source: web.gys.gr and the authors
TOTAL: 1399
967
Soft and renewable energy sources
The cities where printed questionnaires have been collected are a) the same with all our previous
similar surveys (in order to make analytic comparisons later), and b) they are the home towns of our
non-employed collaborators for this -and the previous- surveys. They have been chosen as to cover
the different (climatic and economic) areas of Greece.
4.
THE SOCIAL SURVEY RESULTS:
2. Sex
1. Male
4. I live…
3. Age Groups
53.1
46.9
5. Educational level
7.1 What is your main mean for heating?
6. Occupation
7.2 What is your main mean for cooling?
7.3 How much money did you spent annually on various forms of energy, e.g seven years ago and
how much this year? (Averages)
8. Do You know what Renewable Energy Sources 9. How well do you know about the following:
9.1 Photovoltaics in buildings:
are?
968
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
9.2 Photovoltaics
properties:
in
land 9.3 Photovoltaic Parks:
9.4 Wind Generators:
9.5 Wind Generators Parks:
9.6 Geothermy for buildings:
9.7 Geothermy for settlements:
9.8 Biomass (wood blocks and
pellets):
9.9 Double Glazing
9.10 Insulation in walls
9.11 Glass House:
9.12 Fan:
10. Do you know that all of the above
can help the family income?
1.
Yes
2.
No
969
1.
Yes,
1,…
2. No,
1,
5.29
Soft and renewable energy sources
11. Do you know that all of the above
can help our national economy to
become independent from imported
oil and natural gas?
12. Do you know that all of the above
can help to reduce environment
pollution?
13.1 If yes, which one:
13. Do you already use any of the
above?
13.2 If no, would you like to install for example
P.V.S.?:
14. If you have already
attempted to do so, what is your
comment on the necessary
beaurocracy?
15. If you are reassured from the
authorities that you will have
definite economic gain, and a
simple beaurocratic procedure,
would you proceed to install any
of the above?
17. Would you accept a nuclear
plant in our country?
18. We have learned that there are fossil fuels in our country.
Do you think that their exploitation:
970
16. Do you think that the
installation of P.V.S and W.G.S
insult/destroy
the
aesthetics/natural beauty of
buildings and/or the natural
environment?
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
19. Finally, would you wish to see a wide use of R.E.S. for the following reasons:
5.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
1. Beginning with R.E.S. an important point that has been underlined, is that since August 2012 a
new law has decreased the income from the installation of PVs and it seems that this policy will
continue. This legislation has a negative effect to the interest towards new installations of PVs. New
hopes seem to arise with the Law regarding “Energy Communities” (1/2018).
2. Regarding bureaucracy, which seems to be a major problem in Greece, people seem to be
disappointed, but in case the state should establish simple and clear rules and also some guaranteed
economic gain for the citizens, R.E.S. applications should definitely increase.
3. Another interesting subject, is the change of the attitudes towards the aesthetics of the environment
concerning the installation of R.E.S. all over the country. During two previous surveys (e.g. 2007,
2009) people seemed to be firmly against large scale installations, arguing about the natural
environment preservation. Nowadays, most people seem to be more interested in installing R.E.S.
even in their property, since 55.01% declare not to be disturbed by the PVs and/or W.Gs.
4. Recently, it has been known that in Greece there are large amounts of fossil fuels, oil and gas. Of
course people are not precisely informed, but anyway they consider that in case these fuels are
exploited, firstly it would help the economy and the energy problem of this country, but also that it
would offer profits to the (foreign) oil companies.
5. Regarding the Energy poverty in our country, the average expenses per household, as well as the
average consumption of the several fuels, do not fully represent reality: the averages are produced
from 0 to X. Thus, as understood, there are families with not at all heating during the winter period.
This fact cannot be presented with simple statistics…
6. Recent researches show that especially in large cities (e.g. Athens, Thessaloniki) where apartments
have to share the heating expenses, due to the inability of some households to pay the bills, the whole
building is without central heating. And moreover, another research (Institute of GSEE 2/2018) shows
that 43% of the households in Athens metropolitan area are completely without heating!
971
Soft and renewable energy sources
The money spent for heating has increased. The quantity of fuel consumed, has decreased. It is
completely understood that the decrease of full consumption by the households is in immediate
relationship with the decrease of the income of the people (or the lack of it) and of course the increase
of the prices of oil and gas…
7. The comfort conditions in the houses, has been differentiated. During the last years, most people
say that in their houses, they have to use heavier clothing than in past, because of the lack of heating.
Discussions with older persons lead to the following conclusions:
a. During the 1950’s and the 60’s people were satisfied with 10o ~ 12oC in the mainly used rooms
only by burning charcoal and/or wood.
b. During the 1970’s, oil has become popular in the houses and multi-storey apartments. It was easy
to use and relatively cheap. Therefore, comfort conditions have been altered. For at least three
decades, people lived comfortably in their houses with 20o ~ 25oC degrees.
c. But during the last decade since 2009, when firstly Hellas has officially been bankrupted, the
households’ income has decreased dramatically, and prices in general continue to increase. Among
the first matters to be affected have been the comfort conditions of the people. Due to the difficulty
to pay the costs of heating, many apartments and houses decrease or completely cut the oil burning,
and use auxiliary devices for short periods of time. Heavy clothing seems to be again the solution in
general… A mean of 17o ~ 19oC degrees seems to be very satisfactory in most of the households.
We also have to point out the differentiation between households that have independent means for
heating (gas, oil, air-condition, wood burning etc.) and the apartments that have a single and common
for all heating system, something very common in the Greek cities; in this case all of the households
have to pay their bills, in order for the system to be used for the whole of the apartment building.
However, each household has to face independently its own needs, and to invent the most economic
combinations for means of heating.
d. Regarding gas, during the last 15 years in several large cities, gas has been distributed and been
installed in many households. But since the mean income has decreased and the prices have increased,
even gas, seems to be an expensive mean for heating.
e. Prices of electricity tend to put A/C inverters and electric heaters out of question or as a final
solution for a short period of time…
f. Now, regarding wood burning. There are the following categories:
Legally bought wood and pellets
Illegally cut wood from the forests
Parts of useless wood furniture (they contain toxic chemicals)
i. We also have to mention newspapers, cardboxes, and paper products with toxic chemicals.
It is a fact that the above heat producing items, are a lot cheaper than oil and gas, not to mention nonorganic garbage (even if it is recyclable or toxic) which is completely free.
6.
CONCLUDING REMARKS
1. People are interested indeed for the protection of the environment, for the national economy, for
the release from imported fuels, and finally for the personal/family economic profit from the
application of R.E.S., but they are also disappointed from the new economic policy applied to R.E.S.
and the necessary bureaucracy.
2. Now, regarding R.E.S. some 12-15 years ago, after aspiring promises by the state, many people
had chosen to install P.V.’s at their houses, buildings or land properties, but their reward has been
disappointing. Despite the enthusiasm and the investment, prices per Kwh have dropped down
dramatically, and new investors are hard to show up. New hopes seem to rise with the legislation
972
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
regarding “Energy Communities”, after the well-established and successful example of several E.C.
countries. Ιt is a pity that our country is not yet fully exploiting the potential of the sun and the wind.
3. It is completely understood that the decrease of fuel consumption by the households is in immediate
relationship with the decrease of the income of the people (or the lack of it) and of course the increase
of the prices of oil and gas.
4. Energy poverty in today’s Hellas is a fact. Urgent measures have to be applied by the state in order
to satisfy the energy needs of the mean households.
5. Finally, I feel ashamed of the fact that when Jeremy Rifkin (The hydrogen economy) visited
Greece, said "I wonder how a country with such both sun and wind remains dependant on
hydrocarbons". And also recently, Jeffrey Sachs (UN Sustainable Development Network) has stated
the same in an interview.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Many thanks are due to the members of K-ecoprojects co. and to all of the students, postgraduates
and PhDs who have helped to gather the questionnaires. But most of all to the Greek people that have
willingly participated to this research.
References
1. CRES, 2/2018, Observatory for Energy efficiency/poverty, http://www.cres.gr/energyefficiency/poverty.html
2. Daskalaki, E., Balaras C.A., Droutsa, P., Kontoyannidis, S., Graglia, A. 2007. Datacollection
from Energy audits for Hellenic Buildings. In IEE Project. Data Mine. IEE Project.
3. E.E. 2008, Commission of the European Communities, Brussels. In Proposal for a directive of
the European Parliament on the promotion of the use of energy from Renewable Sources.
4. European Parliament, ITRE Committee, 8/2015, How to end Energy Poverty? (Report)
5. Institute of G.S.E.E., 2018, Report on the economics of Greece
6. Kosmopoulos, P. et al 2011, A Social Survey on how the economic crisis affects peoples’
attitudes towards the environmental subjects. MESAEP. Ioannina.
7. Kosmopoulos P. et al 2008, Research regarding the R.E.S. applications and attitudes towards the
environment, 3rd PERSYMAK (in Greek)
8. Kosmopoulos, P. et al 2008, Buildings, Energy and the Environment. Thessaloniki: University
Studio Press.
9. Kosmopoulos, P. et al 2004, Environmental Psychology. Thessaloniki: University Studio Press.
10. Kosmopoulos, P. et al. 2005, ZED-KIM, a pilot house using renewable energy sources, I.C.
MESAEP.
11. Kosmopoulos, P. et al 2005, Social Attitudes about Environmental Design. I.C.PALENC.
Santorini.
12. Kosmopoulos, P. et al 2006, The use of Renewable Energy Sources in houses. I.C. PLEA.
Geneva.
13. Kosmopoulos, P., Ioannou, T. 2005, Social Attitudes about Environmental Design and R.E.S..
14. Mihalakakou, G., Santamouris, M., Tsangrassoulis, A. 2002. On the Energy consumption in
Residential Buildings. Energy and Buildings 34(7, 08):727-36.
15. Panas E., 2012, Research on the Energy Poverty in Greece, T.C.G.
973
Soft and renewable energy sources
16. The Greek Ombudsman, 2016, The economic crisis should not change to a rejection of the state
of justice (Annual report)
17. Tsoutsos, Th. et al. 2009, Photovoltaics in buildings I and II, PURE, I.E., E.C.
18. Papadopoulos, A.. 2002, Strategies for a more efficient integration of Renewable Energy Systems
in Urban Buildings. 33rd Congress on Heating, Refregeration and Air Conditioning.
Belgrade.
19. Renewable Energy Sources and Energy Saving, 2008, www.cres.gr/kape/main.htm. Ed. CRES.
Transl. C.R.E.S..
20. Santamouris, M., Asimakopoulos, D., 2013, Energy Saving in Urban Environment Buildings.
Solar Energy and Energy Saving.
974
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
A TWO STEP PROCESS FOR THE ELECTROCHEMICAL
CONVERSION OF CO2 TO METHANOL
A. Schizodimou, I. Kotoulas and G. Kyriacou*
Laboratory of Inorganic Chemistry, Dept. of Chemical Engineering, A.U.Th, GR- 54124
Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: kyriakou@eng.auth.gr, tel : +302310996238
Abstract
The direct electrochemical conversion of CO2 to methanol, which is the product of choice, is quite
difficult. On the contrary, formic acid is easily formed from CO2 on various metal electrodes by both
high rate and %Current Efficiency (%CE) reaching 90%. This work proposes a two-step process for
the electrochemical conversion of formic acid to methanol which includes the conversion of CO2 to
formic acid in the first and the reduction of formic acid to CH3OH in the second. The work contains
experimental results on the reduction of formic acid on chromium and chromium alloys. The main
products obtained from the electrochemical reduction of HCOOH on Cr in 85% H3PO4, at 80 C were
HCOOCH3 (2.1%), CH3OH (17.5%) and CH4 (4.9%). The rate of the reduction increased with the
negative potential. The total %CE in some experiments exceeded 100% and this was attributed to the
cathodic dissolution of chromium which provided an additional reduction capacity. The reduction on
electrodeposited chromium on Pb gave CH4 (25.7%) and less amounts of CH3OH and HCOOCH3.
On stainless steel cathodes the main products were CH3OH (%7.2) and HCOOCH3 (23.1%) and
smaller amounts of CH4.
Keywords: Formic acid; electrochemical reduction; chromium
1.
INTRODUCTION
Many efforts have been made during the last years aiming to the reduction of the CO 2 emissions
through the replacement of fossil fuels by renewable and/or alternative energy sources, like
photovoltaics and wind turbines. Given that the energy produced from renewable sources is not
constant during time, a stage of electrical energy storage is required. Olah et al. [1], showed that the
most efficient way for the storage of the excess of the energy produced by renewable energy sources,
is its use for the electrochemical conversion of CO2 to methanol. Consequently, methanol could be
used as a fuel, after minor modifications of the existing internal combustion engines or in fuel cells.
Also, methanol could be used as a raw material for the production of other organic compounds of
higher added value [2-4]. Therefore, the conversion of CO2 to methanol is a challenging topic [5, 6].
As it has been proved by literature sources, the direct conversion of CO2 to methanol is very difficult,
because it takes place at extremely low rate for industrial applications. Conversely, CO2 can be easily
converted to formic acid by a %CE near 100% [7]. A different scheme for converting CO2 to methanol
can be a two step process as follows:
In the first stage, CO2 will be converted electrochemically to HCOOH:
CO2 + 2H + + 2e- → HCOOH + H2O
(1)
and in the second stage the produced HCOOH will be converted to CH3OH
975
Soft and renewable energy sources
HCOOH + 4e- → CH3OH + H2O
(2)
The conversion of formic acid to methanol according to the reaction (2) is also extremely difficult
and, for this reason, this CO2 reduction scheme was poorly studied in the literature. Prior research
from our laboratory showed for the first time that chromium is the most efficient cathode for the
reduction of HCOOH. The main products at 85% v/v H3PO4 at 80 °C were methyl formate, methanol
and small amounts of hydrocarbons with 1-4 carbon atoms. The study was conducted in a narrow
range of cathodic potentials from -0.6 V to -0.95 V, where the main products were methyl formate
and methanol. The %CEs of methanol and methyl formate displayed a maximum of 37.4% and 166%
37.6% respectively at -0.65 V. The fact that% CE was greater than 100% was attributed to the
cathodic dissolution of chromium which gave an additional reduction capacity [8]. The challenge is
to find conditions under which Cr dissolution does not take place in order to make a commercially
applicable method.
The aim of this present work was to investigate the possibility of avoiding the corrosion of chromium
that takes place during the conversion of HCOOH to methanol.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A Teflon cell having a total volume of 24 mL divided in two equal volume compartments by a Nafion
117 (H+ form) cation exchange membrane was used in all electrolytic experiments. The anode and
the cathode were Pt and Cr foils, respectively; having the same geometrical area (7 cm2).The cell was
placed in a thermostated water bath until the required tempera- ture was achieved. The potential was
controlled by a Wenking POS 73(Bank Elektronik) potentiostat and the reference was the saturated
calomel electrode (SCE). A stream of He having a flow rate of 10 mL min-1 was used to withdraw
the gaseous products and a part of the produced organic liquids from the cell during the electrolysis.
The escaped liquids from the cell by the gaseous stream were collected in three tubes containing cold
water. No significant volume loss of the catholyte was observed at the end of electrolysis since the
liquid sample was only 1 mL. A gas chromatograph (GC) supplied by a Plot Q 30 m, 0.530 mm and
a Molecular Sieve 5A, 30 m, 0.530 mm connected in series by a three way valve and a TCD detector
was used for the determination of H2, CO and CO2. A second gas chromatograph supplied by a Pora
Plot Q 25 m, 0.53 mm column and FID detector was used for the analysis of the low molecular weight
organics and hydrocarbons. The detection limit for methane, methyl formate and methanol was 1 ppm
and the reproducibility of the experimental results was established to be within 5%.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Reduction of HCOOH on Cr
In this study the reduction was carried out in more negative potentials, where the dissolved chromium
which is in the solution mainly in the form Cr(II) could be redeposited on the electrode surface in
order to avoid the mass loss of the electrode. The electrodeposition of Cr corresponds to a normal
potential of -0.74 V but the deposition in practical applications usually requires a potential more
negative than -1.5 V vs. NHE. At so high potential the IR Drop is very high so the measurement of
the potential is not reliable. For this reason, our experiments were carried out under galvanostatic
conditions.
Table 1 shows the reduction results on an electrolyte consisting of 50/50 v/v of 85% H3PO4 and 98%
HCOOH.
976
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1: Influence of the current density on the reduction of HCOOH in solutions that made
by mixing 85% H3PO4 with HCOOH in 50:50 volume proportion at 80 C. Electrolysis time
90 min
j / mA cm-2
100
150
200
300
%CE
CH3OH
2.1
1.9
1.6
0.9
HCOOCH3
17.5
16.3
14.8
9.2
CH4
4.9
4.5
5.6
6.2
H2
174
167
153
111
Total
198.5
189.7
175.0
127.3
The main products of the reduction were CH3OH, HCOOCH3 and CH4. The %CEs were significantly
lower than that on metallic chromium [8] but the reduction rate was about 1.8 times higher. The %
CEs of products, including hydrogen, were higher than 100% in all experiments, and this was
attributed to the cathodic corrosion of chromium. In all experiments severe cathode (Cr) corrosion
was observed. The corrosion was visible to the naked eye, since the cathodic solution became colored
during the time. We conclude that the rate of dissolution of chromium was higher than the rate of
deposition of dissolved chromium. Therefore, the electrode corrosion could not be avoided by this
way.
3.2 Reduction on electrodeposited chromium on Pb
A further attempt to avoid the problem of the cathodic corrosion of (Cr), was made by reducing
HCOOH on electrodeposited Cr on a Pb cathode. In this way we aimed to find conditions under which
the amounts of the electrodeposited Cr on the Pb and that of dissolved Cr via cathodic corrosion are
equal. The electrodeposition solution contained [9]:
50% v/v H3PO4 και 50% v/v HCOOH
CrCl3•6H2O 100 g/L
NH4Cl 80 g/L
Sodium citrate 95 g/L
H3BO3 40 g/L
The deposition current density was 300 mA/cm2 and the temperature was 60 °C. The products of the
reduction were CH3OH (0.1%), HCOOCH3 (3.8%) and CH4 (25.7%). Additional experiments were
not carried out in this direction because the main product was CH4 and not CH3OH which is the
product of choice.
3.3 Reduction of HCOOH on stainless steels
As it was mentioned above, the chromium was dissolved under cathodic conditions resulting in a
mass loss of the electrode that makes the method economically inefficient. An additional attempt was
made for the reduction of HCOOH on chromium alloys in order to prevent its cathodic corrosion.
The reduction was performed on stainless steel (series 300 according to the American AISI-SAE
standards) alloys because they are widely known for their corrosion resistance. The chemical
composition of the alloys is shown in Table 2.
Table 2: The chemical composition of austenitic stainless steels
EN
1,4301
1,4541
1,4404
1.4833
1,4845
ASTM
Standards
304
321
316L
309S
310S
C (%)
N (%)
Cr (%)
Ni (%)
Mo (%)
others
0.04
0.04
0.02
0.06
0.05
0.06
0.01
0.06
0.08
0.06
18.3
17.3
17.3
22.5
25.0
8.7
9.2
11.0
12.5
20.0
2.2
-
Ti
-
977
Soft and renewable energy sources
Tables 3 show the products obtained from the reduction of HCOOH on various stainless steels in
solutions made by mixing 85% H3PO4 with HCOOH in 50:50 volume proportion at 80 C and
potentials of -0.65 V and -0.8 V.
Table 3: %CEs of the reduction products at -0.65V and -0.8 V in solutions made by mixing
85% H3PO4 with HCOOH in 50:50 volume proportion at 80 C. Electrolysis time 90 min
Cathode
(ASTM
Standards)
304
321
316L
309S
310S
304
321
316L
309S
310S
%CE
CH3OH
-0.65 V
5.5
4.6
4.3
6.6
7.2
-0.80 V
2.5
1.9
1.5
2.9
3.5
HCOOCH3
CH4
H2
15.4
14.8
14.2
19.3
23.1
0.09
0.06
0.08
0.11
0.12
106.8
103.5
115.3
120.9
123.2
9.6
10.7
8.2
12.2
13.1
0.8
0.9
0.5
0.9
1.1
88.2
89.5
91.7
102.8
103.5
The % CEs of the products increased with the increase in chromium content of steel since the alloy
310S which contains 25% Cr was the most efficient. The maximum %CEs of CH3OH, HCOOCH3
were 7.2% and 23.1%, respectively at -0.65 V. The obtained CEs and the reduction rate (8.2 mA/cm2)
were much lower than those reported for the reduction of HCOOH on Cr [8] but the cathodic
corrosion of the electrode which is the main problem was significantly lower. It should be mentioned
that the reduction potential (-0.65 V) is only 200 mV higher than expected by the thermodynamics.
These experiments have shown that chromium alloys can be effective electrocatalysts for the
reduction of HCOOH. More efforts should be made in this direction because higher chromium content
alloys would give higher %CEs.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
The electrochemical reduction of HCOOH on a chromium cathode and 50/50 v/v of 85% H3PO4 and
98% HCOOH solution, gave CH3OH (2.12%), HCOOCH3 (17.5%) and CH4 (4.9%) as main products.
The total %CE in some experiments exceeded 100% and this was attributed to the cathodic dissolution
of chromium which provided an additional reduction capacity. The reduction on electrodeposited
chromium on Pb, yielded CH4 (25.7%) and smaller amounts of HCOOCH3 (3.8%) and CH3OH
(0.1%). On stainless steels alloys the main products were CH3OH and HCOOCH3 with maximum
%CEs of 7.2 and 23.1% respectively and less amount of CH4 (1.1%). The experimental results
showed that chromium alloys are promising electrodes for the reduction of HCOOH.
REFERENCES
1. Olah G.A., A. Goeppert and G.K.S. Prakash (2006) ‘Beyond oil and gas: the methanol
economy’, Wiley-VCH Weinheim.
2. Olah G.A., A. Goeppert and G.K.S. Prakash (2009) ‘Chemical Recycling of Carbon Dioxide to
Methanol and Dimethyl Ether: From Greenhouse Gas to Renewable, Environmentally Carbon
Neutral Fuels and Synthetic Hydrocarbons’, J. Org. Chem., 74, pp. 487-498.
3. G.A. Olah, G.K.S. Prakash, A. Goeppert (2011) ‘Anthropogenic Chemical Carbon Cycle for a
Sustainable Future’, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 133, pp. 12881-12898.
978
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4. Goeppert A., M. Czaun, J.P. Jones, G.K.S. Prakash and G.A Olah (2014) ‘Recycling of carbon
dioxide to methanol and derived products – closing the loop’, Chem. Soc. Rev., 43, pp. 79958048.
5. Aresta M. (2010) ‘Carbon Dioxide as Chemical Feedstock’, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
6. Faias S., J. Sousa and R. Castro (2009) ‘Embedded Energy Storage Systems in the Power Grid
for Renewable Energy Sources Integration’, in: T. Hammons, Renewable Energy, InTech.
7. Qiao J., Y. Liu and J. Zhang (2016) ‘Electrochemical Reduction of Carbon Dioxide:
Fundamentals and Technologies’, CRC Press.
8. Kotoulas I. and G. Kyriacou (2017) ‘Conversion of carbon dioxide to methanol through the
reduction of formic acid on chromium’, J. Chem. Technol. Biotechnol, 92, pp. 1794–1800.
9. P. Benaben (2011) ‘An overview of hard chromium plating using trivalent chromium solutions.
Plating and Surface Finishing’, American Electroplaters' Society Inc.
979
Soft and renewable energy sources
EFFECT OF SUCCESSIVE SMALL HYDROPOWER PLANTS ON
WATER QUALITY
G. Kacienė
Department. of Environmental Sciences, Vytautas Magnus University LT-44404 Kaunas, Lithuania
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: giedre.kaciene@vdu.lt, tel : +37067245718
Abstract
The aim of this work was to evaluate the influence of two successive small hydropower plants (SHPs)
on the water quality of the Vokė river (Lithuania). Two SHPs (‘Vokė’ and ‘Grigiškės’) is situated in
the 7 km long section of the river, close to Vilnius, the capital and the biggest Lithuanian city. Water
samples were taken in the dams above SHPs, in the rapids immediately below SHPs and 2 km below
each SHP. The concentrations of nitrates (NO3--N), nitrites (NO2--N), ammonium (NH4+-N) and
phosphates (PO43+-P), and chemical oxygen demand (COD) were investigated. An increase in N and
P compounds was detected in the dams above both SHPs. The highest increases were characteristic
for phosphates (~40%, p <0.05) and nitrates (34% and 41%, p <0.05, in the ‘Vokė’ and ‘Grigiškės’
dams, respectively). Strong and statistical significant increase in the level of ammonium was observed
only in the ‘Grigiškės’ dam (31%). Contrary to NO3--N, NH4+-N and PO43+-P, concentration of NO2-N was lower in the dams of both SHPs. Strong and significant increase in COD (33%, p <0.05) was
detected only in the dam of ‘Vokė’ SHP. Considering the river sections 2 km below the SHPs, water
quality changed negligibly. The levels of biogenic N and P compounds tended to decrease; however,
sharp increase in PO43+-P concentration was detected below ‘Vokė’ SHP, indicating an impact of
subsequent ‘Grigiškės’ SHP. The levels of nitrates and phosphates were higher in the downstream
‘Grigiškės’ SHP, as compared to ‘Vokė’ SHP, both in the dams and in the subsequent rapids. The
results of this study have shown that the levels of biogenic and/or organic compounds tend to increase
in the dams above SHP. The concentrations of phosphates and nitrates further increase downstream
due to the successive SHPs.
Keywords: Small hydropower plants, water quality, biogenic compounds, chemical oxygen demand
1.
INTRODUCTION
Hydroelectric power stations are global source of power. Since the first hydroelectric power station,
which was built in France in 1880, its size and complexity, due to new stacking technology and market
demand, have highly increased. The economic and social benefits of hydropower plants are
enormous, due to competitive and universal technology. These include irrigation, water supplies,
flood control, recreation (Yuksel, 2010). On the other hand, hydropower plants interfere with
environmental integrity. Although hydroelectric power plants are important are important for
different sectors of the economy, their adverse environmental effects must be taken into account
(Abbasi and Abbasi, 2011).
Hydropower Plants does not consume or purify the water it uses to produce electricity, but disrupts
the natural flow of the river and changes the flow distribution in time and space. Since water flow is
the main factor promoting the ecological processes of a river, the disruption of natural current
drastically affects the status of river ecosystems (Pang et al., 2015). The negative impact on
ecosystems, biodiversity, habitats of plants and animals, fish migration is widely investigated (Baxter,
1977; Jansson et al., 2000; Anderson et al., 2006; Santos et al., 2012; Vaikasas et al., 2015). Apart
980
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
from this damage, hydropower plants interfere with nutrient cycling (Zhou et al., 2013), the water
reservoirs produce large amounts of greenhouse gases (Rosenberg et al., 2000) and pollute water with
methylmercury (Pang et al., 2015).
Large hydropower plants are not accepted as a clean, renewable energy source by most ecologists
and environmental activists. Therefore small hydropower plants (SHP), which installed power are
usually below 10 MW and whose popularity has declined in the middle of XX century, was restored
as a substitute for clean energy as alternative for large hydroelectric power plants (Abbasi and Abbasi,
2011; Punys et al., 2015). On a global scale, most political strategies support the idea, that SHP have
a minimal impact on the environment or are completely environmentally friendly (Darmawi et al.,
2013). However, an increasing number of researches show that SHP interfere with rivers ecosystem
stability by reducing the flow rate, increasing accumulation of N and/or phosphorus compounds and
changing composition of invertebrates’ communities (Zhou et al., 2009; Punys et al., 2015; Vaikasas
et al., 2015)
The aim of this study was to evaluate the influence of two successive small hydropower plants (SHP)
on the water quality of the Vokė river (Lithuania). Two SHP (‘Vokė’ and ‘Grigiškės’) is situated in
the 7 km long section of the river, close to Vilnius, the capital and the biggest Lithuanian city.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The investigated river Voke is located 10 km to the Southwest from Lithuania capital Vilnius. It is
the left influent of Neris. Total length of Voke is 35.8 km, the capture area 572,7 km², an average
discharge 4,9 m³/s. SHP ‘Voke’ (installed power 300 kW) is located in the southwestern part of
Vilnius city. Hydro scheme consists of earth dam with concrete gated overflow spillway. The plant
was reconstructed in 2010 from old water mill. The reservoir area is 12.2 ha. SHP ‘Grigiskes’
(installed power 340 kW) in Grigiškės town, a district of Vilnius city. It was built in 1934
(reconstructed in 2000) sing the existing (since 1922) concrete dam with 5 gates over-flow spillway.
The plant is used for electricity production (1,656 GWh), it consists of two turbines. Discharge of one
turbine is released into the river Vokė, whereas the second – into short adjacent canal. The reservoir
area is 9.7 ha (Lithuanian Hydropower association, Hydropower in Lithuania 1996-2011
http://www.lsta.lt/files/Leidiniai/Lietuvos%20HIDROENERGETIKA/Knyga_Lietuvos%20HIDRO
ENERGETIKA.pdf).
Water samples were taken in six places, in 7 km long section of the Voke river. The following places
were chosen: in the reservoirs above SHPs (No 1 and 4), in the rapids immediately below SHPs (No
2 and 5) between the SHPs (No 3) and 2 km below the SHP ‘Grigiskes” (6) (Figure 1).
The 1st place is located in the reservoir immediately above SHP ‘Vokė”. The surroundings of the
reservoir have low population density, consists of small forests and meadows.
The 2nd place is below SHP ‘Vokė”. There is a road network nearby, the river flow is rapid, the bottom
predominantly graveled.
The 3rd place is located between the two SHPs: 2,25 km below SHP ‘Voke’ and 4,25 km above SHP
‘Grigiskes’. The shores are forested and winded, the bottom is sandy and intermittently dumbbell.
The 4th place is located in the reservoir immediately above the SHP ‘Grigiskes’. The town Grigiskes
is situated around the reservoir, there were housing and a highway close to this sampling place. The
bottom is covered with deep layer of sludge.
The 5th place is located below the SHP ‘Grigiskes’. The river flow is rapid, the bottom predominantly
graveled. There is a highway close to the sampling place, the other shore is steep and forested.
The 6th place is located 2 km below the SHP ‘Grigiskes’ and 1 km above the river inflow. The shores
are urbanized.
981
Soft and renewable energy sources
Water samples were stored at -20 ⁰C until chemical analysis. The concentrations of nitrates (NO3-N), nitrites (NO2--N), ammonium (NH4+-N) and phosphates (PO43--P) were investigated according to
Bartošová et al. (2012) with minor changes. Chemical oxygen demand (COD) was analysed using
AQUANAL™-professional tube tests and WINLAB® photometer according to manufacturer
instructions.
All analysis were performed in three replicates. The data were analysed using STATISTICA 8 and the
results were expressed as the mean values and their confidence intervals (p<0.05) (±95% CI).
Figure 1. Sampling points in the river Voke.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Concentrations of nitrogen compounds
The concentrations of inorganic N compounds, such as ammonium, nitrites and nitrates were
investigated (Figure 2). Tendentious increases of the levels of ammonium and nitrates are
characteristic for water reservoirs above each SHPs. The highest concentration of NH4+-N was
detected above SHP ‘Voke’, it gradually decreased until the lowest level between the two SHPs.
However, strong and significant increase was observed in the second downstream reservoir above
SHP ‘Grigiskes’: 31% (p < 0.05), as compared to the level below this SHP (Figure 2A). Two
kilometres below this dam, the level of NH4+-N increases again, most possibly due to the impact of
diffused pollution from the highway and from the town Grigiškes, situated around the reservoir and
982
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
the downstream section of the river. In spite of these fluctuations, the highest concentration of
ammonium is characteristic for the first reservoir above the SHP ‘Voke’ and for the rapids
immediately below this dam.
Figure 2. Concentrations of inorganic nitrogen compounds in the section of Voke river,
containing two successive SHPs (SHP-1 and SHP-2 are SHP ‘Voke” and SHP ‘Grigiskes”,
respectively).
Both SHPs increased the level of nitrates above the dams, inducing even higher increases of NO3--N
than NH4+-N concentrations in the reservoirs. The lowest level of NH4+-N varied from 0.166 mg/l in
the forested part of the river between the dams till 0,171 mg/l and 0,187 mg/l in the rapids below the
dams ‘Voke’ and ‘Grigiskes’, respectively. This level increased till 0,259 mg/l and 0,282 mg/l in the
reservoirs above these dams. Therefore, the concentrations of nitrates were higher by 34% and 41%
(p <0.05) in the ‘Voke’ and ‘Grigiškes’ reservoirs respectively, as compared to the rapids below the
983
Soft and renewable energy sources
dams. Gradual, but statistically insignificant, decrease of the level of NO3--N was observed in the
downstream sections of Voke river, several kilometers away from SHPs (Figure 2C).
Contrary to NO3--N and NH4+-N, concentration of NO2--N were lower in the reservoirs of both SHPs
(Figure 2B). The lowest concentration of nitrites was found in the reservoir above SHP ‘Grigiskes’.
The highest level of NO2-N was characteristic for the rapids below the SHP ‘Voke’ (0,049 mg/l) and
for the sections of the river above and below this dam (0,042 mg/l).
3.2 Phosphate and chemical oxygen demand
Both SHPs increased the level of phosphates in the reservoirs above the dams. The lowest level of
PO43+-P was detected in the sections of the river immediately below the SHP ‘Voke’ (0,022 mg/l)
and 2 km below SHP ‘Grigiskes’ (0,021 mg/l) (Figure 3A). The concentrations of PO43+-P was higher
by ~34% (p<0.05) in both reservoirs compared to the rapids below the dams (Figure 3A). An increase
of the level of phosphorus compounds is explained by the accumulation of sediments, adsorbing and
transporting phosphorus (Mihailova et al., 2013; Zhou et al. 2013). The amount of P sequestration
can exceed 80% in big dams, as was detected by Zhou et al. (2013). Phosphorus sequestration in the
lower dam (SHP ‘Grigiskes’) increased PO43+-P even several kilometres above the reservoir, in the
sampling place between the two dams (Figure 3A). The reservoir ‘Grigiskes’ was characteristic of
the highest concentration of phosphates (0,037 mg/l), this might be influenced by the nearby town
Grigiskes and diffused P pollution from uncontrolled point sources in the private sector.
Figure 3. Concentration of phosphates (A) and chemical oxygen demand (B) in the section of
Voke river, containing two successive SHPs (SHP-1 and SHP-2 are SHP ‘Voke’ and SHP
‘Grigiskes’, respectively).
Water reservoir above SHP ‘Voke’ was characteristic by the highest value of chemical oxygen
demand. COD in this dam (50,4 mg/l) was significantly higher as compared to any other sampling
points downstream the Voke river, where COD varied within the range 25,7-33,9 mg/l. The difference
984
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
between COD above and below SHP ‘Voke’ was 33 %. COD was even lower in the downstream
reservoir ‘Grigiskes’ (49 %, p<0.05), therefore SHP ‘Voke” functions as a trap for organic matter.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
Two successive SHPs ‘Voke’ and ‘Grigiskes’ changed the levels of biogenic compounds and
chemical oxygen demand in the course of the river. The most intensive change was detected for
phosphates and nitrates. The level of these substances was approximately one-third higher in the
reservoirs above the dams, compared to the rapids below. Both investigated SHP tended to increase
NH4+-N and to decrease NO2--N concentrations in the reservoirs above the dams. The upper SHP
‘Voke” seems to function as a trap of organic matter, as COD is sharply higher in the reservoir above
this dam as compared to all investigated points in the course of the river below.
Acknowledgements
Participation in the conference is funded by the European Social Fund under the No 09.3.3-LMT-K712 “Development of Competences of Scientists, other Researchers and Students through Practical
Research Activities” measure. Many thanks to Rytis Liasis for assistance during the experiment and
permission to use his data for this publication.
References
1. Abbasi T. and S.A. Abbasi (2011) ‘Small hydro and the environmental implications of its
extensive utilization’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 15, pp. 2134 –2143.
2. Anderson E.P., M.C.Freeman and C.M. Pringle (2006) ‘Ecological consequences of hydropower
development in Central America: impacts of small dams and water diversion on neotropical
stream fish assemblages’, River research and applications, 22, pp. 397–411.
3. Bartošová A., A Michalíková, M. Sirotiak and M. Soldan (2012) ‘Comparison of two
spectrophotometric techniques for nutrients analyses in water samples’, Research Papers
Faculty of Materials Science and Technology Slovak University of Technology, 20(32), pp.
8-19.
4. Baxter R.M. (1977) ‘Environemtal effects of dams and impoundments’, Annual Review of
Ecology and Systematics’, 8, pp. 255-283.
5. Darmawi, R. Sipahutar, S.M. Bernas and M.S. Imanuddin (2013) ‘Renewable energy and
hydropower utilization tendency worldwide’, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 17,
pp. 213–215.
6. Jansson R., C. Nilsson and B. Renofalt (2000) ‘Fragmentation of riparian floras in rivers with
multiple dams’, Ecology, 81, pp. 899-903.
7. Mihailova P., I. Traykov, A. Tosheva and M. Nachev (2013) ‘Changes in biological and
physicochemical parameters of river water in a small hydropower reservoir cascade’, Bulgarian
Journal of Agricultural Science, 19(2), pp. 286–289.
8. Pang M., L.Zhang, S. Ulgiati and C.Wang (2015) ‘Ecological impacts of small hydropower in
China: Insights from an emergy analysis of a case plant’, Energy Policy, 76, pp.112–122.
9. Papadopoulou M.P., E.A. Varouchakis, and G.P. Karatzas (2010), ‘Terrain Discontinuities
Effects in the Regional Flow of a Complex Karstified Aquifer’, Environmental Modeling and
Assessment, 15(5), pp. 319-328.
10. Punys P., A. Dumbrauskas, E. Kasiulis, G. Vyčienė and L. Šilinis (2015) ‘Flow regime changes:
from impounding a temperate lowland river to small hydropower operations’, Energies, 8,
pp.7478-7501
985
Soft and renewable energy sources
11. Rosenberg D.M., P. McCully and C.M. Pringle (2000) ‘Global-Scale environmental effects of
hydrological alterations: introduction’, BioScience, 50 (9), pp.746-751.
12. Santos J.M., A. Silva, C. Katopodis, P. Pinheiro, A. Pinheiroe, J. Bochechas and M.T. Ferreira
(2012) ‘Ecohydraulics of pool-type fishways: Getting past the barriers’, Ecological Engineering,
48, pp. 38– 50
13. Vaikasas S., N. Bastiene and V. Pliuraite (2015) ‘Impact of small hydropower plants on
physicochemical and biotic environments in flatland riverbeds of Lithuania’, Journal of Water
Security, 1, pp. 1-13
14. Yuksel I. (2010) ‘Hydropower for sustainable water and energy development’ Renewable and
Sustainable Energy Reviews, 14, pp. 462–469
15. Zhou A.S., T. Tang, N. Wu, X. Fu, W. Jiang, F. Li and Q. Cai (2009) ‘Impacts of cascaded small
hydropower plants on microzooplankton in Xiangxi River, China’, Acta Ecologica Sinica, 29,
pp. 62–68
16. Zhou J., M. Zhang and P. Lu (2013) ‘The effect of dams on phosphorus in the middle and lower
Yangtze river’, Water resources research, 49, pp. 3659–3669.
17. http://www.lsta.lt/files/Leidiniai/Lietuvos%20HIDROENERGETIKA/Knyga_Lietuvos%20HID
ROENERGETIKA.pdf (accessed March 21st, 2018)
986
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
River and open channel hydraulics
987
River and open channel hydraulics
988
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
DISCHARGE AND SEDIMENT TRANSPORT IN THE NESTOS
RIVER BASIN, DOWNSTREAM OF THE DAM OF
PLATANOVRISI
G. Paschalidis, I. Iordanidis and P. Anagnostopoulos*
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Department of Civil Engineering, Division of Hydraulics and
Environmental Engineering, Thessaloniki 54124 Greece
*Corresponding author: E-mail: anagnost@civil.auth.gr, Tel +30 2310 995675, Fax: +30 2310
995680
Abstract
The prediction of the runoff and sediment yield in the basin of the Nestos River, located in Macedonia
and Thrace, Northern Greece, is the subject of the present study. The AGNPS software was employed,
in order to assess the basin’s behavior downstream of the hydroelectric dam of Platanovrisi, which is
located approximately at the middle of the river’s course inside the Greek territory. The technique
used in order to model the impact of the dam, was to modify the study area’s digital elevation model
and represent the discharge of the dam as a point source of water. Two different simulations were
conducted, one for the years 1980-1990 and another for the period 2006-2030. The simulation for the
years 1980-1990 was conducted using recorded meteorological data, whereas the simulation for the
period 2006-2030 was based on rainfall and climate data generated by two software packages, namely
GlimClim and ClimGen.
Keywords: River basin, Discharge, Sediment transport, Dam
1.
INTRODUCTION
Watersheds are often subjected to flooding, erosion and sedimentation hazards, leading to
environmental, social and economic complications. Thus, proper quantification of soil erosion and
runoff in watersheds are essential for effective land use planning. The prediction of the runoff and
sediment yield of a watershed has been an ambitious goal for a variety of scientists, such as engineers,
hydrologists, geologists and others. In particular, the estimation of sediment yield in various temporal
and spatial scales is a vital key point for the assessment and design of major hydraulic systems, such
as hydroelectric dams and flood attenuation structures.
Computer modeling is considered to be a cost-effective tool for the prediction of the runoff and
sediment yield of a watershed. Several non-point source (NPS) models have been developed for this
purpose [1]. The Agricultural Non-Point Source Pollution Model (AGNPS) is a suite of NPS Models,
developed as a planning tool for forested or agricultural watersheds [2]. It was developed jointly by
the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Agricultural Research Service (ARS) and the
USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS).
In this paper, the Agricultural Non-Point Source Pollution Model (AGNPS) was used to predict runoff
and sediment losses from a section of a predominantly forested watershed of Nestos River, in
Macedonia and Thrace, Northern Greece. In particular, the study area is the basin downstream of the
hydroelectric dam of Platanovrisi, which is located approximately at the middle of the river’s course
inside the Greek border (Fig. 1). The area of the basin is 884 km2. Runoff and sediment yield were
estimated at the location Toxotes, at the outlet of the study area.
989
River and open channel hydraulics
Figure 1. The study area.
AGNPS is a daily time-step, distributed model, which enables the modeling of all different processes
and parameters that affect sediment transport, allowing the creation of a detailed model of the study
area [3]. Extensive rainfall and climate data, such as wind speed, relative humidity, temperature and
solar radiation are also necessary [4]. The use of the model as prediction tool requires its calibration
for the conditions in the study area.
Two different simulations were conducted, one for the years 1980-1990 and another for the period
2006-2030. The simulation for the years 1980-1990 was conducted using recorded meteorological
data, whereas the simulation for the period 2006-2030 was based on rainfall and climate data
generated by two software packages, namely GlimClim and ClimGen.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
AGNPS is based on the Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE) combined with a GIS
(Geographic Information System) interface for more convenient preparation of input data. RUSLE is
a simple empirical model which is based on regression analyses of soil loss rates. It has the following
structure, similarly to the USLE [5]:
A R K LS C P ,
(1)
A is the computed spatial and temporal average soil loss per unit area
R is the rainfall-runoff erosivity factor
K is the soil erodibility factor
LS is the slope length and steepness factor
990
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
C is the vegetation cover and management factor
P is the conservation support practices factor
It is widely used because of its relative simplicity, robustness and ability to enable prediction of
average annual erosion by multiplying several factors together, such as rainfall erosivity (R), soil
erodibility (K), slope length and steepness (LS).
A large amount of input data is necessary for the model setup. AGNPS simulates runoff and sediment
transport from land to streams, as a result of storm flow. Runoff is calculated in the model using a
variation of the Technical Release 55 (TR-55) method [6]. TR-55 employs simplified procedures to
calculate runoff volume in small watersheds. A modified Einstein deposition equation, using the
Bagnold suspended sediment formula for the transport capacity by particle size class, was used for
the sediment transport in the watershed.
AGNPS uses amorphous cells, each cell being a grouping of individual square grid elements, which
collectively represent homogeneous hydrological response units. Using the ArcView interface, the
basin is dissected into cells and the attributes of spatial data are allocated to each of the cells. Based
on the critical source area (CSA) and minimum source channel length (MSCL) parameter values, the
watershed was discretised into 1568 cells and 699 channel reaches.
2.1 Terrain and soil parameters and land use data
The Digital Elevation Drainage Network Model (DEDNM) module of AGNPS performed the terrain
parameterization and defined the drainage network. The cell attributes include drainage area, average
elevation, average slope, shallow flow slope and length, concentrated flow slope and length, and the
LS-factor, a basic factor of RUSLE, which computes the effect of slope length and steepness on
erosion. The reach attributes include drainage area, contributing cells, receiving reaches, average
elevation and channel slope and length
The texture of the soil samples obtained from various locations of the basin were identified and
categorized per soil type. Four soil types were identified, the average texture of which was calculated
and a specific code number was assigned to each soil type. The average textures, for the four soil
types, are shown in Table 1.The AGNPS/ArcView interface was then used to assign the soil type to
each cell. The soil properties mentioned before were assigned to each soil code number via the input
editor.
Table 1. Average texture of various soil types and corresponding K values
Soil Type
Sand
Clay
Silt
K
(%)
(%)
(%)
(Mg h)/(MJ mm)
Sandy Clay Loam
55
19
26
0.314
Silty Loam
22
21
57
0.272
Loamy Sand
78
4
18
0.223
Silty Clay Loam
8
39
53
0.285
Land use data were acquired from the European Environmental Agency. This dataset is a raster, georeferenced, categorized land cover data layer. The raster data were converted into shapefile format
using ArcView version 9.3, and the AGNPS/ArcView interface was then used to determine the land
use in each cell. According to the existing land use data, the cells within the watershed were classified
into groups for more convenient handling and management.
Land uses in AGNPS are classified into two categories:
a) Non-cropland
991
River and open channel hydraulics
b) Cropland
There is a total of 16 distinct land uses in the study area. Thirteen of them are “non-cropland uses”
and include urban infrastructure, wooded land and other non-cultivated land uses. Annual Rainfall
Height, Annual Cover Ratio, Root Mass and Surface Residue Cover were inputted in order to simulate
non-cropland uses. Cropland uses consist of crop-related activities such as sowing, harvesting, etc.
Since the study area contains cropland land uses, it is necessary to simulate the effects of agricultural
activities such as sowing and harvesting, including their time schedule during a year. The connection
of each land use with the above activities was assigned via the input editor and specifically the “Field
Data Management” option. Each field data contains one or more events, which are scheduled to take
place at a specific time of the year. The time period for sowing and harvesting was determined through
the “Management Schedule” option. Furthermore each schedule is associated with the runoff curve
number, which corresponds to its own land use.
2.2 Meteorological data
Meteorological (rainfall and climate) data were taken from two meteorological stations inside the
basin (Fig. 2). AGNPS requires daily meteorological data for the simulation period, stored in a
separate file. The meteorological data contain eight daily parameters: date, precipitation, daily
maximum temperature, daily minimum temperature, dew point temperature, sky cover or solar
radiation, wind speed and wind direction. These are the minimum information required to calculate
surface runoff and other physical processes, which are simulated with AGNPS.
Figure 2. The study area with meteorological stations.
992
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
The two meteorological stations mentioned previously contain monthly rainfall and climate data for
the period 1964-2009. The complete sets of data on a daily basis suitable for use by AGNPS are
confined for the periods 1980-1990 and 2006-2009. Stochastic time-series of the necessary
meteorological parameters at a daily time step for the period 2006 to 2030 were generated with the
use of two software packages, namely GlimClim and ClimGen. GlimClim was developed by
Chandler [7] and ClimGen by the University of Washington in collaboration with the United States
Department of Agriculture (U.S.D.A). The rainfall and climate data for the period 2006-2009 were
used for the calibration of these two software packages. After the calibration, GlimClim was used to
estimate daily rainfall values in the study area for the period 2006-2030 and ClimGen was used to
estimate the daily values for all the other meteorological parameters (temperature, relative humidity
and wind speed) for the same period.
A large number of simulations was conducted with the use of GlimClim for the period 2006-2030.
Since GlimClim is a statistical model; the large number of simulations serves in obtaining an adequate
sample of estimated values of rainfall for each day in the simulation period. For all simulations, the
rainfall for each day in the interval 2006-2009 was compared with the corresponding recorded value.
The simulation which yielded daily estimated rainfall closest to the recorded throughout the interval
2006-2009 was selected as the most reliable.
2.3 Model implementation
AGNPS was employed for the study of sediment transport in the basin of the Nestos River,
downstream of the hydroelectric dam of Platanovrisi, which is located approximately at the middle
of the river’s course inside the Greek territory. An important input parameter for the calibration of
runoff is the approximate amount of direct runoff (Curve Number) [6], which provides information
on the runoff properties of the soil in the study area. Since runoff is sensitive to changes of the Curve
Number, the Curve Numbers must be carefully selected, in order to produce reliable results. Runoff
is calculated by
Q
WI 0.2 S 2 ,
WI 0.8 S
100
1
where S 245
CN
(2)
where Q is the surface runoff for each cell, WI the water input (precipitation or irrigation), S the
retention variable and CN the Curve Number. CN has a range from 30 to 100; lower numbers indicate
low runoff potential, whereas larger numbers indicate increased runoff potential. The lower the curve
number, the more permeable the soil is. The Curve Number depends on the land use and soil type of
each cell, as described by TR-55 [6].
The annual sediment yield, Sy, (tn/km2) is calculated by
S y 0.22 Q0.68 q p
0.95
K L S C P
(3)
where Q the surface runoff, qp the peak rate of surface runoff and K, L, S, C and P are factors of the
Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation (1).
The most important of these factors is the soil erodibility factor, K, which influences the spatial
variability of sediment losses. Factor K, which is important for the determination of the sensitivity of
soil to erosion, the sediment transportability and runoff rate, is directly related to soil properties. Soil
texture, structure and particle composition are the main factors affecting soil erodibility. The values
of K range typically from about 0.10 to 0.45 [(Mg h / (MJ mm)]. Similarly to Liu et al. [8], the
erodibility factor was calculated using the method in the Erosion Productivity Impact Calculator
(EPIC) model, given by the equation
993
River and open channel hydraulics
Κ = {0.2 + 0.3 exp [-0.256 S d (1 - S i /100)] [ S i /( Ci + S i )]}0.3
{1.0 - 0.25 C0 /[ C0 + exp(3.72 - 2.95 C0 )]}
(4)
where Sd is sand content, Si is silt content, Ci is clay content and C0 is soil organic carbon.
The values of K for the four soil types of the present study, as calculated using Eq. (4) from the
average textures of Table 1, are also listed in Table 1. These values are close to those reported by Liu
et al. [8], which lie in the range between 0.278 and 0.344.
Slope length and steepness factors, LS, are topographic factors that indicate the terrain impacts on
soil erosion. Slope length is evaluated by the model from the change in elevation at a specified
distance in the DEM. The steepness factor, which accounts for the effect of slope steepness on soil
erosion, is evaluated internally by the model.
The vegetation cover and management factor, C, represents the effect of both the natural vegetation
cover on reducing soil loss in non-agricultural situations, and of cropping and management practices
in agricultural activities. The C factor is calculated by the model for all non-water cells in the study
area, depending on the land use (cropland or not). For cropland cells AGNPS calculates 24 values of
C factor for each year, and an average C factor for each year for non-cropland cells. For cropland
land uses, the effects of agricultural activities, such as sowing and harvesting, and their time schedule
during a year, are important for the determination of C factor.
The conservation support practice factor, P, is the ratio of soil loss under a particular conservation
support practice, to soil loss for up and down slope cultivation on the unit plot, with no conservation
support [9]. Conservation support practices include cropping along the contour, strip-cropping and
terracing. It is evident that the lower the P factor value, the better the practice for controlling soil
erosion. Similarly to C factor, P factor is calculated by the model for all non-water cells in the study
area. AGNPS calculates sub-factors for contour cropping, strip-cropping and terracing, from which
the P factor of the corresponding cell for each year is evaluated.
An important requirement of the model application for future predictions is the determination of
suitable values of the parameters which influence the sediment yield. The calibration was conducted
by modifying the value of each parameter within the limits specified by TR-55 [6]. The selected
values of these parameters were those which rendered the difference between estimated and measured
values of runoff and sediment yield for a specific year at the location Toxotes minimum. The
validation of the calibration was performed using estimated and measured values of runoff and
sediment yield at the same location for the following year. The calibration-validation procedure is
described in detail by Paschalidis et al. [10].
3.
APPLICATION, RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Two different simulations were performed by AGNPS, one for the period 1980-1990 and another for
the period 2006-2030. The purpose of both simulations was the estimation of the runoff and the
sediment yield at the outlet of the river Nestos basin, at the location Toxotes. The period 1980-1990
was selected in order to compare the results of AGNPS with those of a study by Hrissanthou [11] at
the same location and period of time. The availability of recorded meteorological data throughout this
period was expected to increase the accuracy of results. The period 2006-2030 was selected for the
future prediction of sediment yield in the study area. The necessary climate and rainfall data required
for this simulation, were obtained using the ClimGen and GlimClim.
Table 2 presents the estimated values of sediment yield of the Nestos River for the years 1980-1990
using the AGNPS model, in comparison with results of two different simulation models by
Hrissanthou [11] at the same location and period of time. The year average of runoff and sediment
yield for the period 1980-1990 are listed in Table 3.
994
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 2. Estimated values of sediment yield (tn/year)
Year
AGNPS
Hrissanthou [11]
Model 1
Model 2
1980
210,182
298,000
278,000
1981
422,646
528,000
588,000
1982
467,195
446,000
426,000
1983
105,124
80,000
73,000
1984
295,626
492,000
494,000
1985
170,985
119,000
131,000
1986
256,752
196,000
198,000
1987
511,482
638,000
673,000
1988
350,203
396,000
383,000
1989
306,669
201,000
207,000
1990
234,517
75,000
64,000
Table 3. Estimated values of mean annual runoff and sediment yield for years 1980-1990
Hrissanthou [11]
Technique
AGNPS
Model 1
Model 2
Runoff (m3/s)
46.3
Sediment Yield (tn/year)
302,852
315,500
319,500
The deviation of the results of the two studies lies within acceptable limits. It is noteworthy, that in
spite of the differences in specific years, the mean annual sediment yield for the period 1980-1990 is
very close to that obtained by the two models of Hrissanthou [11].
Table 4 presents the estimated values of mean annual runoff and sediment yield at the location
Toxotes, for the years 2006-2030 using the AGNPS model. As stated previously, climate and rainfall
data for this period were generated by Glimclim and ClimGen. The mean runoff for the period 20062030 is lower than that for the period 1980-1990 by less than 5%. The mean sediment yield for the
period 2006-2030 is lower than that for the period 1980-1990 by approximately 20%. Therefore, the
rainfall and the resulting runoff seem to play a key role for the sediment yield.
Table 4. Estimated values of mean annual runoff and sediment yield using AGNPS for years
2006-2030
3
Runoff (m /s.)
44.3
Sediment Yield (tn/year)
4.
252,266
CONCLUSIONS
The AGNPS software was employed in order to simulate both runoff and sediment yield at the
location Toxotes downstream of the hydroelectric dam of Platanovrisi, located in the basin of Nestos
River. Two different simulations were performed by AGNPS, one for the period 1980-1990 and
another for the period 2006-2030. The mean annual sediment yield for the period 1980-1990 was
995
River and open channel hydraulics
very close to that obtained at the same location by Hrissanthou [11], in spite of the differences existing
in specific years. Apparently, the good agreement of the mean annual sediment yield reinforces the
validity of the present model. The simulation for the period 2006-2030, the necessary climate and
rainfall data for which were obtained using the GlimClim and ClimGen software packages, yielded
reduced value of the mean runoff by 5% and reduced value of the mean annual sediment yield by
20%, compared to the corresponding values for the period 1980-1990. This constitutes strong
evidence, that the rainfall and the runoff play a key role for the sediment yield.
References
1. Binger, R.C., Mutchler, C.K., Murphee, C.E., 1992. Predictive capabilities of erosion models for
different storm sizes. Transactions of American Society of Agricultural Engineering, 35(2),
505–513.
2. Binger, R.L., Theurer, F.D., 2001. AGNPS98: A suite of water quality models for watershed use.
Proceedings of the Sediment Monitoring, Modeling, and Managing, Seventh Federal
Interagency Sedimentation Conference, March 2001, Reno, NV, USA, 25–29.
3. Binger, R.L., Theurer, F.D., 2005. AnnAGNPS Technical Processes documentation, version 3.2,
USDA-ARS, National Sedimentation Laboratory.
4. Iordanidis, I., 2010. Investigation of nitrate pollution in a river basin from rural activities. Ph.D.
Thesis, University of Thessaloniki, Department of Civil Engineering, Thessaloniki, Greece (in
Greek).
5. Renard, K.G., Foster G.R., Weesies, G.A., McCool, D.K., Yoder D.C., 1997. Predicting soil
erosion by water - a guide to conservation planning with the Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation
(RUSLE). United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service (USDA-ARS)
Handbook No. 703. United States Government Printing Office: Washington, DC.
6. Binger, R.L., Darden, R., Herring, G.J., Martz, L.W., 1998. TOPAGNPS User Manual. TR-55
USDA-ARS.
7. Chandler, R., 2002. GLIMCLIM: Generalized linear modelling for daily climate time series
(software and user guide), Tech. Rep. 227, Dept. of Stat. Sci., UCL, London.
8. Liu, X., Qi, S., Huang, Y., Chen, Y., Du. P., 2015. Predictive modeling in sediment transportation
across multiple spatial scales in the Jialing River Basin of China. International Journal of
Sediment Research, 30, 250-255.
9. Meyer, D., 1984. Evolution of the universal soil loss equation. Journal of Soil and Water
Conservation, 39(2), 99–104.
10. Paschalidis, G., Iordanidis, I., Anagnostopoulos, P., 2014. Discharge and sediment transport in a
basin with a dam at its upper boundary. Proceedings of the International Conference on
Protection and Restoration of the Environment XII (eds. A. Liakopoulos, A. Kungolos, C.
Christodoulatos, A. Koutsospyros), 29 June-3 July, Skiathos Island, Greece, Vol. II, 1081-1088.
11. Hrissanthou, V., 2002. Comparative application of two erosion models to a basin. Hydrological
Sciences, 47(2), 279–292.
996
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
URBAN STREAMS OF THESSALONIKI (GREECE): SPATIAL
AND HYDRAULIC ASPECTS
S. Tsoumalakos* and K.L. Katsifarakis
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, A.U.Th
Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: tsoustav@yahoo.gr, tsoustav@arch.auth.gr
Abstract
Rapid and poorly planned urban development has resulted in severe deterioration of the environment,
in many parts of the world, including Greece. Amongst the environmental elements that have been
heavily affected are local streams of small and medium size. Degradation resulted mainly from flaws
of the respective legal framework and from trespassing, which was tolerated, more or less, by the
pertinent authorities. In other cases, streams were reduced to closed conduits, according to
development plans that disregarded environmental components. This behavior towards urban streams
had many adverse effects. The most severe is aggravation of flood phenomena, which are further
intensified by turning permeable soil into an impermeable surface during the urbanization process.
Today, in contrast to these practices, an attempt is being made to promote streams as key factors in
the achievement of sustainable urban development through a more integrated management. Following
this approach, we study the possibility of managing the streams that are preserved, at least partly,
within the administrative boundaries of the Municipality of Thessaloniki, Greece. Thessaloniki is a
very densely built area, within which several streams or stream parts are "hidden". In particular, we
analyze and evaluate the spatial and hydraulic characteristics of these streams, together with the
pressures they have received from human activities. We round off, this paper, by presenting certain
proposals concerning the nexus of streams in the Municipality of Thessaloniki, Greece.
Keywords: urban streams, environmental impact, drainage system, Thessaloniki, Greece
1.
INTRODUCTION
Many of the world's cities have been built along rivers or streams. The interaction of their functions
with the aquatic element is therefore particularly important and long-lasting. Actually, streams shape
the geomorphology and the landscape of the region through which they flow [EEA, 2016], and quite
often they influence the way cities develop. In recent decades, they have often been the focus of
discussion on the renovation and revival of cities, since, in the past, many streams had been
considered a nuisance rather, than a social and environmental asset. Actually, urbanization without
proper planning during the second half of the 20th century has led to the deterioration of natural
elements, such as streams, in many cities, e.g. in the Mediterranean area [Giannakourou, 2005]. Since
the 1980s, though, in many parts of the western and northern Europe, a considerable number of
programs and actions for the rehabilitation and reintegration of rivers and streams in urban areas has
been developed. They aimed mainly at the creation of new open spaces and the remodeling of the
image of the cities, which had largely lost their contact with the natural landscape. For this reason,
streams and rivers were the most suitable elements for changing the face of a city and for connecting
the artificial with the natural environment [EEA, 2016].
997
River and open channel hydraulics
Today, urban streams face a series of important problems. The first problem lies in the quantity of
water: surface runoff increases due to extreme weather phenomena and the replacement of natural
pervious surfaces with impermeable ones (streets and buildings), resulting in increased flood
phenomena. Moreover, the quality of water is also significantly affected by the discharge of polluted
surface runoff or even sewage discharge. Urban stream pollution may also affect the downstream
areas [American Rivers, 2013]. Another problem results from changes in the structure of urban
streams, especially on their banks. The natural banks are replaced by artificial walls, disrupting the
connection between the stream and the surrounding area, while, sometimes, the stream is undermined
completely [EEA, 2016]. At the same time, such projects remove the riverside vegetation and
seriously damage the local flora, while the temperature in the stream and in the surrounding area
increases significantly [EEA, 2016].
2.
STREAM MANAGEMENT IN THE URBAN AREA: A MODERN CONCEPT
River rehabilitation projects offer an opportunity for future urban planning in the context of
sustainable development and quality of life improvement. The concept of restoring streams is related
to objectives, measures and actions that have, as their main concern, the improvement of their
functions, but also of the environment. In many cases, urban river rehabilitation projects do not begin
with the aim of improving aquatic biological systems, but are part of urban regeneration projects,
which are closely linked to streams that cross the cities. However, because of the interdependencies
created between the ecosystems within and around the streams, it is difficult to bring streams to their
initial condition [Simsek, 2012].
In addition to rehabilitation, the practice of stream restoration, which refers to the partial rebuilding
of ecosystem functions disturbed by human activities, is very common. This can be achieved by
removing, at least partly, the sources of nuisance. The final purpose is the creation and preservation
of a natural ecosystem [Simsek, 2012]. Some plans include actual reconstruction of streams, which
had been turned into underground pipe systems in previous years. Ideally, such recreated streams
should follow their initial course. Such projects, though, are very complex and, in most cases, too
expensive.
The improvement of urban streams contributes to the reduction of flood risk. At the same time,
creation of new open spaces and enhancement of the greenery network offers access to the natural
environment to city inhabitants and supports wildlife. Additionally, another very important asset is
the reduction of the urban thermal island phenomenon, by achieving appropriate ventilation
conditions.
Moreover, the rehabilitation of streams can have wider socio-economic consequences, as it creates
an attractive environment that encourages recreation, enhances the physical and mental health of
people, strengthens business investment and tourism locally, and increases the value of real estate.
Moreover, management of streams can be integrated with rain water management in urban areas (UN,
2016). Towards this direction, green and blue infrastructure can play a very important role in
mitigation flood phenomena, reduction of sewer system operation cost, support of local vegetation
and replenishment of local aquifers.
3.
THE STREAMS OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF THESSALONIKI, GREECE
The study area, namely the Municipality of Thessaloniki, is shown in Figure 1. Eight streams have
been traced and studied. Most of them are characterized by small and intermittent flows. At the time
of this survey (summer 2017), water could be seen in 2 stream beds only. This is due to the
construction of a flood control channel, a few decades ago, which has cut off the urban stream parts
from their mountainous drainage basins. Moreover, rain runoff from the remaining urban parts of
drainage basins is partly collected by the sewer system. On the other hand, though, surface runoff
increases due to the replacement of natural pervious surfaces with impermeable ones.
998
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: (a) Thessaloniki in South-eastern Europe (b) The Municipality of Thessaloniki in
the Region of Central Macedonia, Greece. (c) Stream beds in the urban fabric of Thessaloniki
Municipality (based on Google maps, processed by the authors)
The visible traces of the studied streams are shown as blue lines in Fig.1(c). Along large parts of their
initial course, they have been reduced to underground pipe systems, to spare space for streets or other
necessary facilities, such as schools, in poorly planned areas of the urban fabric. Even the preserved
stream parts suffer from cross-section reduction, mainly due to trespassing by individuals, motivated
by pressing housing demand and encouraged by flaws in the legal system and poor enforcement of
the existing one. The construction of the aforementioned flood-control channel (called in Greek
Perifereiaki Tafros and literally translated as Circumferential Trench) rendered trespassing on the rest
of the steams less risky, from the hydraulic point of view.
Nowadays, within the context of sustainable development, the aforementioned practices are
unacceptable. On the contrary, the goal is to regain the natural elements of streams as much as
possible and to integrate them in the densely built urban fabric, under given functional and financial
999
River and open channel hydraulics
constraints. The task is site-specific, since the characteristics of the preserved stream parts vary
widely, even along rather short distances, as testified by the photos of Fig. 2.
Figure 2: Natural elements of streams. (a) In Evangelistrias stream, (b) In Saranta Ekklesies
stream. Source: First author’s Archive.
4.
A COMPARISON OF STREAMS
Our research has identified the types of pressures upon the 8 streams of the specific study area and
has classified them in the following way: a) illegal house building, b) road network, c) school building
d) athletic facilities and e) broader urban environment. Results regarding each stream are summarized
in Table 1.
Table 1: Forms of pressures upon the urban streams of Thessaloniki.
Pressures from Pressures from Pressures from Pressures Pressures from the
Urban streams of the Municipality of
Illegal House
the Road
School
from Athletic
Broader Urban
Thessaloniki
Building
Network
Buildings
Centers
Environment
Perifereiaki Tafros (Circumferential
Trench)
Χ
Regas Feraios Stream
Stream of Western Walls
Evangelistria Stream
Χ
Saranta Ekklesies Stream
Doxa Stream
Ortansia Stream
Nestoros Tipa Stream
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Χ
Street construction along streams has been one of the main pressures, planned by local or central
authorities. The most affected in the study area is the Regas Feraios stream, which has been
completely reduced to an underground conduit, to allow mainly for the construction of a street. Its
original course can be traced by a longitudinal green space along that street. The streams of Saranta
Ekklesies, Doxa, Ortansia and Nestoros Tipa have been partially reduced to underground conduits.
Even in the preserved parts, though, their initial stream bed has been partly occupied by streets along
them. Moreover, closed conduits have been constructed at the junctions of the streams with transverse
streets, as shown in Fig. 3. A notable exception is the Circumferential Trench. Although it has
incorporated parts of pre-existing streams, it has not been affected by planned interventions, due to
its special role in flood protection. Even when it meets transverse streets, traffic is facilitated via
1000
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
bridges, without damaging its banks. Typical examples are the bridges of G. Lambrakis Street and of
N. Plastira Street (in Municipality of Pylaia - Chortiatis).
Figure 3: Closed conduits at the junctions of streams with transverse streets (a) Doxa stream
(b) Ortansia stream. Source: First author’s Archive.
Figure 4: Trespassing Illegal house (a) In Doxa stream (b) In Ortansia stream. Source:
Author’s Archive
The next pressure that affects the streams of the study area stems from illegal private constructions.
Within the context of this work, during the field investigation which was conducted, illegal
constructions were mainly located at the edges of the urban space and hence in the upper parts of the
streams. Trespassers have used stream banks and beds to construct their houses or to extend their
properties. Two characteristic examples from Doxa and Ortansia streams are shown in Fig. 4. An
important exception is the stream of Evangelistria, where house building has been officially
permitted, downstream of its entrance to the urban fabric. Schools and athletic installations are also
sources of pressure. We have detected such facilities along the streams of Saranta Ekklesies and
Ortansias. Also, part of the bed area of the Regas Feraios stream, which has been reduced to a closed
conduit, have served similar purposes.
1001
River and open channel hydraulics
5.
A STRATEGY FOR THE STREAMS OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF THESSALONIKI
AND SUSTAINABLE SPATIAL DEVELOPMENT
Table 2: S.W.O.T. analysis
S (Strengths)
W (Weaknesses)
The existence of parts of the Unregulated urban sprawl
streams whose natural bed
and increase of
has being preserved.
impermeable surfaces.
O (Opportunities)
T (Threats)
Connecting urban green
spaces with the peri-urban
forest.
Increase of flood probability due
to increase of impermeable
surfaces.
The existence of dense
riparian vegetation in several
streams.
Reduction of the natural
river bed.
Interconnection of green
spaces within the urban
fabric.
Environmental degradation due
to the decline of the natural
ecosystem.
The existence of additional
non- built areas along some
streams.
Partial substitution with
closed conduits.
Improvement of soil
permeability and the
drainage system.
Increase of illegal occupation of
the stream bed.
Natural ventilation of the
urban area.
Water pollution from
surface run-off.
Reducing natural replenicement
of shallow aquifers.
Within the framework of this survey, a SWOT analysis has been conducted, summarized in Table 2.
This analysis forms the basis for building an integrated strategy for the streams, following the three
pillars of sustainable development: society - economy - environment. A basic concept of a modern
strategy is that streams are free spaces and as such they must remain. Based on this reasoning, the
basic principles of designing and management of the streams of Thessaloniki are organized. This is
done for the protection of their surviving parts, and of the vegetation that accompanies them. The
overall objectives set, at a strategy level, for the streams of the area under study, are summarized as
follows:
Maintenance of the natural stream bed and its banks where feasible.
Reduction of the use of impermeable materials to delimit the streams.
Preservation and even upgrading of the role of streams as drainage systems, using ecological
rain water management techniques (e.g. Katsifarakis et al, 2015).
Reduction of the pressures on the streams, caused by external interventions and trespassing.
Introduction of a participatory process by inviting the citizens of Thessaloniki to actively
participate in the effective management of streams.
The main purpose of these general objectives is the creation of networks of green spaces where their
main trunk will be the streams themselves. Moreover, as the streams of Saranta Ekklesies and
Ortansia (and the Circumferential Trench as well) extend up to the peri-urban forest of Thessaloniki,
they can serve for the connection of the urban fabric with the forest area. Conservation of currently
not built spaces close to the preserved stream beds, and their incorporation within the green space
network, would greatly increase its value.
The management of these natural aquatic elements within the urban fabric can be accomplished by
creating a multifunctional project plan. The aim of this project should therefore be to balance the
issues related to the three main pillars of sustainable urban development, with a particular emphasis
on the hydraulic and environmental role of the streams. Their hydraulic role can be upgraded in
connection with ecological rain management techniques. Construction of rain gardens in parts of the
beds of the Saranta Ekklesies, Doxa and Ortansia streams [Basdeki et al, 2017, Katsifarakis et al,
2015] would increase their role in mitigation of local flood phenomena and would contribute to the
replenishment of the local shallow aquifer. Regarding the environmental role of streams, it is
extremely important to strengthen local biodiversity and to improve the connection amongst the
preserved parts of the streams, which are fragmented.
1002
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Sustainable development (society - economy - environment), with regard to the streams, should be
sought, taking into account the context in which its three main pillars are accomplished. For this
reason, it is proposed - at a social level - to create public spaces that are the links of the areas
previously separated by these natural aquatic elements. Therefore, there is talk of upgrading the
quality of life at, primarily, a local level, as well as setting up a network of recreational activities or
even commuting at a daily basis. The economic sector concerning the streams under scrutiny, may
develop as a natural consequence of a wider urban regeneration, but it is not the primary focus in the
present work. However, it is worth noting that the creation of some urban cultivation on the banks
and slopes of streams can contribute to the achievement of specific economic benefits (either
individually or collectively). Regarding the environmental field, which is probably the most important
part of stream management, we propose creation of urban habitats or at least strengthening of existing
ones. These biotopes enhance urban biodiversity while at the same time improve microclimate
conditions locally. In this way, streams can contribute to the achievement of urban resilience against
extreme climate change.
However, the streams of the area under scrutiny, as already mentioned, are facing a number of
pressures. The two main ones are street networks and trespassing. Regarding the street networks, it
is proposed that we redefine the importance and the role of the car as well as the occupation of land
so as to serve its needs, in the fringes of the stream areas. This can be achieved by taking into account
both the principles of sustainable urban mobility and the impact of the presence of cars on both sides
of the streets. Regarding trespassing, demolition of illegal constructions, currently in use, is not
recommended in the current framework of financial crisis, which has led to an increased number of
homeless people. On the contrary, abandoned installations should be demolished right away.
Moreover, further trespassing should be discouraged, with an appropriate surveillance of the stream
areas and by explicitly denying any possibility of “legalizing” illegal constructions in the future.
Finally, integration of schools and sport facilities, which have been constructed in streams, should be
sought, as they can contribute to the smooth reintegration of streams into the urban fabric.
6.
CONCLUDING REMARKS
The main purpose of this work is to contribute to the protection and restoration of streams that are
preserved within the administrative boundaries of the Municipality of Thessaloniki, Greece. Within
its framework, the basic pressures that have been exerted upon the streams, are identified and
classified. These pressures are tightly connected to the built environment, and are the main obstacles
to achieving environmental balance, even around preserved stream parts.
Today, although these water elements are fragmented, they are still an important mechanism for
ventilating a densely populated urban environment, such as that of Thessaloniki. The existence of
streams in the urban tissue can make a significant contribution to improving the microclimate of the
area through which they pass. Moreover, although their hydraulic role has been greatly reduced (with
the exception of the Circumferential Trench), they are still important points of reference, especially
during the periods of rainfall, when the city's sewer network fails to cope. At the same time, they can
serve for the replenishment of local aquifers, especially in a city where impermeable surfaces
dominate. Apart from the city's ventilation and the hydraulic role of streams, it is particularly
important to use these elements for recreational purposes. Although the city of Thessaloniki has a
wide and fully-fledged coastal urban front, which is a point of reference and recreation for its citizens,
at a neighboring level, even in the inner part of the city, it lacks significantly in spatial amenities. This
spatial inequality can be reduced by restoring the streams of the study area.
1003
River and open channel hydraulics
References
1. American Rivers (2013) Daylighting Streams: Breathing Life into Urban Streams & Communities
At: http://americanrivers.org/wpcontent/uploads/2016/05/AmericanRivers_daylighting-streamsreport.pdf (accessed November 25, 2017).
2. Basdeki A., L. Katsifarakis and K.L. Katsifarakis (2017) “Design, calculations and performance
evaluation of rain gardens in an urban neighborhood of Thessaloniki, Greece”, Desalination and
Water Treatment, 99, pp. 4-7
3. European Environment Agency (EEA) (2016). Rivers and lakes in European cities. Past and
future challenges. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union (26).
4. Giannakourou, G. (2005). Transforming Spatial Planning Policy in Mediterranean Countries:
Europeanization and Domestic Change. European Planning Studies. 13(2).
5. IPCC (2012). Summary for Policymakers: In Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and
Disasters to Advance Climate Change Adaptation. Special Report of Working Group I and II of
the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. UK. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
At: https://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/special-reports/srex/SREX_Full_Report.pdf (Accessed: December
12, 2017).
6. Katsifarakis K.L, M. Vafeiadis and N. Theodossiou (2015) “Sustainable Drainage and Urban
Landscape Upgrading Using rain gardens. Site Selection in Thessaloniki, Greece”, Agriculture
and Agricultural Science Procedia 4, pp. 338-347
7. Simsek, G. (2012). Urban River Rehabilitation as an Integrative Part of Sustainable Urban Water
Systems. 48th ISOCARP Congress. http://www.isocarp.net/Data/case_studies/2239.pdf (accessed
November 14, 2017).
8. Special Service for Public Works of Thessaloniki (2003) General Regulatory Plan for Flood
Protection and Sewerage of the Rainy Regions of Thessaloniki. (December 2003). Athens:
Ministry of Environment, Urban Planning and Public Works. General Secretariat for Public
Works. Special Service of Public Works for Water Supply, Sewage and Wastewater Treatment
of Thessaloniki. (in Greek).
9. United Nations (UN) (2016). River Restoration. A strategic approach to planning and
management. Paris: United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. At:
http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0024/002456/245644e.pdf (accessed December 20, 2017).
1004
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
ON THE USE OF THE INTEGRAL MOMENTUM-BALANCE TO
CALCULATE DRAG ON A SQUARE CYLINDER IN A
COMPOUND-CHANNEL FLOW
M. Gymnopoulos1*, P. Prinos2, E. Alves3 and R. M.L. Ferreira4
Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, PT- 1049-001 Lisboa, Portugal
Division of Hydraulics and Environmental Engineering, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Aristotle
University of Thessaloniki, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
3
Laboratório Nacional de Engenharia Civil, PT- 1700-066 Lisboa, Portugal
4
CERIS, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, PT- 1049-001 Lisboa, Portugal
1
2
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: miltos.msn@hotmail.com, tel : +306979284007
Abstract
River flooding, threatens nearby infrastructure, as overbank flow occupies the adjacent berms
(floodplains) and poses significant drag loads on the existing structures. The drag coefficient of such
structures is possible to be influenced by the strong shear-layer formed at the interface of the main
channel and the floodplain. Herein, this assumption is investigated in an experimental configuration
involving the placement of an emergent cylinder at the main-channel/floodplain interface. The drag
force on the cylinder at a certain distance from the floodplain bed is assessed through the application
of the momentum-balance equation, in its integral form. The method is based on local measurements
of the mean flow and turbulence characteristics. Drag is expressed as counteraction to the force on
the flow in a control volume and is estimated as the residual in the momentum-balance equation.
The experiment was conducted in the straight compound-channel facility of Laboratório Nacional de
Engenharia Civil (LNEC), Lisbon. Uniform-flow conditions were set in the channel for a relative
flow-depth hr=hfp/hmc=0.31 (hfp is the floodplain flow-depth and hmc is the main-channel flow-depth).
A square cylinder was placed in one of the floodplains right next to the main-channel/floodplain
interface. An Acoustic Doppler Velocimeter (ADV) was used for measuring the three-component
instantaneous velocities at sequential positions on the surfaces of a fluid control-volume.
The terms of the momentum-balance equation were estimated. Then the drag coefficient emerged
from the respective drag force and the characteristic velocity U0 that accounts for the existence of the
compound-channel-flow shear layer. The same calculations were applied to the case in which a
cylinder is found in flow with uniform upstream velocities. This reference case is represented by
placement of the cylinder in the middle of the floodplain in the same facility. The effect of the shear
flow is assessed through comparison of the corresponding terms of the momentum-balance equation
and the drag coefficients.
Keywords: Drag, Momentum balance, Square cylinder, Compound channel, Velocity measurements
1.
INTRODUCTION
Bluff bodies in open-channel flows are commonly met in the form of vegetation elements and
infrastructure e.g buildings and bridge piers. During flood events, cylindrical structures, found at
close proximity to river banks, obstruct the overbank flow, and are subjected to the relevant drag
loads. In this work the drag force on such an obstacle in an open-channel flow is assessed
experimentally. In particular, the study considers a compound-channel flow, where a square cylinder
1005
River and open channel hydraulics
is placed on the floodplain, near the main-channel/floodplain (mc/fp) interface. In such a case, the
cylinder faces a strong shear-layer that is typical in compound channels and is formed at the interface.
This region is characterized by strong streamwise-velocity gradients in the lateral direction (Prinos et
al., 1985) and the presence of secondary currents and vortices (Nezu & Nakayama, 1997; Shiono &
Knight, 1991) travelling along the interface. Consequently, the wake of the obstacle is influenced by
these processes.
The objective of the current study is to determine the effect of the shear layer of the compoundchannel flow on the cylinder-wake processes and the value of the drag coefficient. The drag effect on
the flow is estimated considering momentum balance, as proposed by Hinze (1975). The relevant
equation is applied in its integral form in a fluid control-volume encompassing the cylinder. Meanvelocity and flow-depth measurements within the control volume are fed into the equation for
extracting the mean drag force at a certain distance from the channel bed. The main contributions to
drag in the momentum-balance equation are presented and discussed. Then, the drag coefficient is
estimated based on a velocity that characterizes the flow in the interfacial shear layer. The relevant
estimated value is compared to the one of a cylinder in flow with uniformly-distributed velocities
found by the authors and those mentioned by previous studies.
2.
THEORETICAL CONSIDERATIONS
Conservation of time-averaged momentum is considered in a fluid control-volume, encompassing the
wake of an emergent cylinder. The relevant equation writes as:
Sc \S
U i (U j n j )dS =
( 0)
Sc \S
( 0)
Pni dS + gi dV +
Vc
Sc \S
uiuj n j dS +
( 0)
T
n
d
S
Pn
d
S
+
T
n
d
S
ij
j
i
ij
j
( 0)
Sc \S ( 0)
S ( 0)
S
(1)
where ni is the outward pointing normal unit-vector, Ui is the time-averaged velocity vector, P is the
time-averaged pressure, Tij is the time-averaged viscous-stress tensor, u iu j the Reynolds-stress
tensor, gi the acceleration of gravity, ρ the fluid density, Vc the control volume, Sc the total surface of
the control volume and S(0) the part of Sc that is bounded by the cylinder wall. The last two terms in
the right-hand part of Eq. (1) compose the acting force on the flow by the cylinder, so that
L Ri
S
(0)
Pni dS + Tij n j dS
S
(2)
(0)
where L is the wet length of the cylinder,
Pn dS
i
is the pressure component and Tijn jdS is the
S0
S0
viscous component of the average force Ri on the cylinder per unit length.
Applying Eq. (1) to a prismatic control volume with height h (Figure 1a) and assuming negligible
viscous stresses we get:
Ri h gi dV
Vc
U U n dS P n dS uu
k 16
k
k
i
j
k
k
j
k
i
k
S
k
S
i
k
S
j
k
k
n j dS
(3a)
with n(1)=[-1,0,0], n (2)=[0,+1,0], n (3)=[+1,0,0], n (4)=[0,-1,0], n (5)=[0,0,+1], n (6)=[0,0,-1].
After converting the integral components to summations of discrete values, for the streamwise
direction x we get:
Rx h gsin( )Vc
(k )
U x k U j k njk S ( k ) P k nx k S ( k ) u xu j n j k S ( k )
k 16
k 16
k 16
where tan(θ) is the channel slope. Brackets denote surface averaging.
1006
(3b)
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
In this paper, sum ρ
- Uxk Ujk n jk S(k) is referred as “net momentum-transport term”,
k=1…6
-P k n xk S(k) as “pressure-difference term” and ρ -u x u j n j k S(k) as “net stress term”.
k=1…6
k=1…6
(k)
Figure 1: a) General depiction of the control volume in the x-y and y-z planes b) velocity
profile across the symmetric part of a compound channel
The drag coefficient per unit wet length of an isolated square cylinder is estimated as:
Cd
2 Rx
U 02 d
(4)
where d is the width of the cylinder and U0 the streamwise velocity of the upstream flow laterally
averaged within the limits of the cylinder’s frontal area.
3.
EXPERIMENTAL FACILITY, EQUIPMENT AND PROCEDURE
3.1 Experimental facility
Experiments were conducted in the 10m-long straight symmetrical compound channel of the National
Laboratory for Civil Engineering in Portugal (LNEC). The trapezoidal section of the main channel
rests in the middle of the compound channel with side slope 1:1. The floodplain consists of two
adjacent sections bounded with vertical walls, as shown in Figure 2, where the main geometric
features of the channel are presented. The longitudinal bed-slope is 0.0011. The bottom of the main
channel is hydraulically smooth (polished concrete) while that of the floodplain is artificially
roughened by a layer of synthetic grass, the detailed characteristics of which are described in
1007
River and open channel hydraulics
Fernandes, Leal, and Cardoso (2014). The inlet of the main channel is separated from the inlet of the
floodplain, improving the efficiency in establishing uniform-flow conditions. Adjustable tailgates are
placed at the outlet for defining uniform-flow depth for a given total discharge. Water depth is
measured by point gauges at 1 m and 8 m downstream the channel entrance. The two independent
inflow rates (main channel and floodplain) are monitored by electromagnetic flowmeters. A more
detailed description of the facility can be found in Fernandes (2013).
Figure 2: Channel cross-section
3.2 Experimental configuration
A square cylinder was placed initially in the middle of the floodplain, in order to obtain drag in flow
with uniform velocities-distribution. Then the cylinder was placed at the mc/fp interface, as shown in
Figure 1b. The two experiments will be referred as S0 and S1 respectively. Uniform-flow conditions
were established in the compound channel, under which the cylinder was emergent in both tests. Total
discharge Qtot was distributed in the main channel and the floodplains as shown in Table 1. The
relative flow-depth hr, defined as the ratio between the floodplain flow-depth, hfp, and the mainchannel flow-depth, hmc, was fixed at 0.31. Under these flow conditions the cylinder is emergent. A
summary of the main parameters including the Reynolds number based on the cylinder width
(Red=U0d/v) is given in Table 1.
Experiments
Table 1: Experimental flow-conditions and parameters
Red (-)
hr (-)
hfp (m) Qtot (ls-1) Qmc (ls-1) Qfp (ls-1)
d (m)
S0
8365
0.31
0.045
58.9
42.3
16.6
0.045
S1
12032
0.31
0.045
58.9
42.3
16.6
0.045
3.3 Velocity and depth recordings
The three dimensional (3-D) instantaneous-velocity field was acquired with a side-looking NortekVectrino Acoustic Doppler Velocimeter (ADV) at a rate of 200 Hz. The duration of measurements
was set at three minutes. The grid shown in Figure 3 was applied at two elevations from the floodplain
bed, z=0.015 m (hfp/3) and z=0.012 m. Despiking of the velocity time-series was achieved by applying
the phase-space filter, proposed by Goring and Nikora (2002). Measurements of the free-surface
elevation were conducted with ultrasound recorders. The recordings had duration of two minutes and
were performed at a rate of 10 Hz.
1008
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3: The grid of the measuring points, applied at two elevations for both S0 and S1. The
flow is from left to right
4.
RESULTS
4.1 Contributions to drag
The drag force was estimated by Eq. (3b) for a variety of control volumes with the same width
b=1.33d and height h=3 mm, and various lengths l (Figure 1a). For each calculation, inlet surface S(1)
was set at a fixed distance of x/d=2.11 (Figure 3),while the position of the outlet surface S (3) varied
within the range 0.89 <x/d<3.11. For each case of the assumed control volume, estimation of the drag
force Rx, involved evaluation of the terms of Eq. (3b). Each term in Eq. (3b) corresponds to a
particular hydrodynamic process in the wake flow. The contribution of a term to drag expresses the
magnitude of the related process relatively to that of the others occurring in the wake region.
Therefore, considering multiple cases of positioning of S(3) of the control volume, besides the fact
that someone can obtain drag assuming different control-volume geometries, it is also possible to
observe the nature and behavior of these processes along the flow direction.
In general, an obstacle in a flow causes pressure drop and momentum loss of the fluid at the
downstream shaded region. Then, longitudinal momentum is laterally drawn into the area of the
maximum pressure-drop, restoring it partially. Since the lateral faces of the examined control volumes
are found close to the cylinder’s walls, the shaded region is encompassed and the relevant processes
are evident though the values of the contributions to Eq. (3b). Herein, these contributions are
discussed. The ones referring to the sheared wake (S1) are compared to those referring to the
symmetrical wake produced by the cylinder in flow with uniformly-distributed velocities (S0). The
presented terms of Eq. (3b) represent momentum-transport processes, fluid pressure and turbulent
stresses. Fluid pressure is considered to follow hydrostatic distribution along depth. In Figures 4a and
4b, the three main contributing terms are examined for different distances of S(3) downstream the
cylinder for cases S0 and S1. The terms are normalized with the quantity C= ρU02dh/2.
As it may be observed in Figures 4a and 4b, all processes in S1, including the turbulent stresses, have
similar tendencies with those occurring in S0. In particular, significant pressure differences are
observed at small distances downstream the cylinder (S1). These differences gradually decrease,
while momentum influxes in the near-wake field and generation of turbulence become stronger.
However, the gradients of all terms are more intense than those corresponding to S0 test. This may
be attributed to the higher Reynolds number of the flow in the main channel, next to the mc/fp
interface of the compound channel, which distorts the geometry of the wake, suppressing its
boundaries at smaller distance downstream the cylinder. Higher Reynolds number though, cannot
explain the differences that the patterns of the particular terms exhibit, in comparison with those of
the symmetrical wake.
The main difference is the increased contribution of the net transport term at the expense of the net
stress term and the pressure-difference term. Moreover, the gradient of the curve that the relevant
values form is positive throughout the entire examined downstream length, which contrasts to the
findings referring to S0, where the contribution of this term decreases up to distance x/d~1.2. Analysis
of results, not presented in this paper, demonstrated that this distance coincides with the wakeformation length.
Higher positive values of the net momentum-transport term in Eq. (3b) imply net influx to the control
volume. The responsible underlying mechanisms are better understood if the behavior of the
particular transport terms is investigated. Figure 5 presents the net contribution of the flux imbalance
at the control surfaces a) in the streamwise direction and b) in the lateral direction. Higher positive
values of the flux imbalance between S(1) and S(3) denote significant momentum loss in the main-flow
direction downstream the obstacle. On the other hand, positive values of the flux imbalance between
S(2) and S(4) imply net momentum-influx from the lateral control-volume faces. According to Figure
5a, momentum loss due to streamwise-velocity deficits downstream the obstacle is more intense in
1009
River and open channel hydraulics
the symmetrical-wake case. At the same time, integral momentum transfer at the lateral control
surfaces S(2) and S(4) (Figure 5b) is directed outwards the low-pressure region. This means that flow
deflection upstream the cylinder is so intense that fluxes from S(2) and S(4) downstream the cylinder
do not compensate for the lost momentum of the deflected flow. When the wake is sheared, instead,
integral lateral fluxes have values close to zero, meaning that flow deflection upstream the cylinder
is balanced with flow attraction downstream. At this point, it can be assumed that this balance derives
rather from limited flow deflection than intense flow attraction, since the S1 curve (Figure 5b) is
found well above the S0 curve, and at the same time, both curves have similar gradients.
Figure 4: Contributions of the terms of Eq. (3b) for different positions of the outlet surface S (3)
of the control volume for a) S0 and b) S1
In order to investigate the source of this flux balance on S(2) and S(4) for the S1 case, the relevant
longitudinal flux-imbalance-distribution is examined in Figure 6. Negative fluxes upstream and at the
sides of the cylinder (x/d<0) are due to the flow-deflection process described above. It is well seen in
Figure 6 that these fluxes for S0 are higher than those for S1. Therefore, the assumption made in the
previous paragraph can be considered valid.
Figure 5: Contribution of the transport-terms imbalance on a) S(1), S(3) and b) S(2), S(4)
1010
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 6: Flux-imbalance distribution on S(2) and S(4)
Distribution of the net-stress (turbulent) contributions of S1 has similar gradients to that of S0 (Figure
4). However, the relevant values are decreased to such a level, so that they are significantly
outweighed by those of the net momentum-transport. This decrease is more evident for x/d>1.2,
where the corresponding values for S0 become positive. Someone would expect that the turbulent
contributions for S1 would exceed those for S0, due to the existence of the shear layer which leads to
stronger shear stress in the region next to the mc/fp interface. It appears though, that the
aforementioned momentum transfer from the sides of the shaded region includes fluxes from the
high-velocity fluid of the main channel, enriching the wake with streamwise momentum and
prohibiting the formation of high streamwise-velocity gradients in the lateral direction. Therefore,
relatively mild velocity gradients do not generate significant shear stresses on S(2) and S(4), and in
turn, high stress contributions to drag.
4.2 Drag coefficient
The drag coefficient of the cylinder subjected to the shear flow was estimated for the elevation of
reference z=hfp/3. Its value is compared to that of the cylinder in flow with uniform velocities
distribution (experiment S0). Table 2 summarizes the results and presents the values produced by
other studies regarding similar Red numbers for symmetrical wakes.
The Cd of the cylinder at the interface seems to be lower than that of the cylinder in S0 experiment.
This difference is better evaluated by comparing it with the range of values of the symmetrical-wake
Cd of the previous studies. This range is bigger but is formed with values concerning also air flows.
The coefficient referring to a closed water-channel (Lyn et al., 1995), as well as that produced in an
open-channel flow for several Red numbers (Robertson, 2016) are higher than those of S0. The
relevant difference is significant, and of the same magnitude with the difference between C d of S0
and S1. Therefore, the reference test S0 is considered to be necessary for assessing the drag coefficient
of the cylinder in the shear layer, since otherwise it would be further underestimated accounting for
the existing studies. As a conclusion, in any case and given that the bed friction effect is not felt at
the elevation of calculation of the drag force, drag coefficient Cd of the cylinder decreases when it is
subjected to the shear layer of the compound channel.
1011
River and open channel hydraulics
Table 2: Drag coefficient of isolated square cylinder
Studies
Red (-)
5.
Cd (-)
Current, S0
8365
2.06
Current, S1
12032
2.00
Yen and Yang, 2011
6300
1.86
Norberg, 1993
13000
2.15
Yen and Liu, 2011
21000
2.06
Lyn et al., 1995
21400
2.10
Robertson, 2016
10000-22000
2.11
CONCLUSIONS
This study demonstrated how the shear layer of a compound channel affects drag on an emergent
square cylinder located at the interface between the main channel and the floodplain. The momentumbalance equation was applied in its integral form in an assumed control volume for the estimation of
the drag force at a certain elevation from the floodplain bed. The wake processes were also identified
through determination of the terms engaged in the momentum-balance equation and they were
compared to the ones related to the symmetrical wake produced by a cylinder in a flow with uniform
velocities distribution.
The main deviations that emerged through this comparison are:
the lower streamwise-momentum deficits in the shaded region donwstream the cylinder,
the limited flow deflection upstream the obstacle,
the lower net shear from the flow at the sides of the cylinder wake.
Regarding the drag coefficient Cd, a small decrease was observed comparatively to that yielded by
the cylinder with the symmetrical wake. The assessed value is found within the range of values
mentioned in previous studies and it approximates rather the lower estimations.
References
1. Fernandes J.N. (2013). ‘Compound channel uniform and non-uniform flows with and without
vegetation in the floodplain’. Ph.D thesis, Univ. of Lisbon, Portugal.
2. Fernandes J.N., J.B Leal and A.H. Cardoso. (2014). ‘Improvement of the lateral distribution
method based on the mixing layer theory’. Advances in Water Resources, Vol. 69, pp. 159-167.
3. Goring D.G. and V.I. Nikora. (2002). ‘Despiking acoustic doppler velocimeter data’. Journal of
Hydraulic Engineering, Vol 128(1), pp. 117-126.
4. Hinze J.O. (1975). ‘Turbulence’. McGraw-Hill.
5. Lyn D.A., S. Einav, W. Rodi and J.H. Park. (1995). ‘A laser-Doppler velocimetry study of
ensemble-averaged characteristics of the turbulent near wake of a square cylinder’. Journal of
Fluid Mechanics, Vol. 304, pp. 285-319.
6. Nezu I. and T. Nakayama. (1997). ‘Space-time correlation structures of horizontal coherent
vortices in compound channel flows by using particle-tracking velocimetry’. Journal of
Hydraulic Research, Vol. 35(2), pp. 191-208.
7. Norberg C. (1993). ‘Flow around rectangular cylinders: pressure forces and wake frequencies’.
Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, Vol. 49, pp. 187-196.
1012
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
8. Prinos P., R. Townsend and S. Tavoularis. (1985). ‘Structure of turbulence in compound channel
flows’. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, Vol. 111(9), pp. 1246-1261.
9. Robertson F.H. (2016). ‘An experimental investigation of the drag on idealised rigid, emergent
vegetation and other obstacles in turbulent free-surface flows’. Ph.D thesis, Univ. of Manchester,
UK.
10. Shiono K. and D.W. Knight. (1991). ‘Turbulent open channel flows with variable depth across
the channel’. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, Vol. 222, pp. 617-646.
11. Yen S.C. and J.H. Liu. (2011). ‘Wake flow behind two side-by-side square cylinders’.
International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, Vol. 32, pp. 41-51.
12. Yen S.C. and C.W. Yang. (2011). ‘Flow patterns and vortex shedding behavior behind a square
cylinder’. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics, Vol. 99(8), pp. 868878.
1013
River and open channel hydraulics
A FUZZY MULTICRITERIA DECISION APPROACH TO SELECT
THE OPTIMAL TYPE OF SPILLWAY AT A SPECIFIC DAM
V. Balioti*, C. Tzimopoulos and C. Evangelides
Division of Transportation and Hydraulic Engineering, Dept. of Rural & Surveying Engineering,
A.U.Th, GR- 54124 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: vasilikimpalioti@hotmail.com , tel : +306939320723
Abstract
The selection of the optimal type of a spillway is considered as one of the most important parameters
for the dam construction. The objective of this research is to develop a multi-criteria decision making
model (MCDM) based on fuzzy set theory. For this purpose 5 alternative types of spillways were
selected with nine criteria. Since most information available in this stage is not numerical and
uncertain, fuzzy set theory and linguistic variables, parameterized by triangular fuzzy numbers (TFN),
are used to represent the evaluation ratings of candidate items. The developed model, which is a
combination of both methods TOPSIS (Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal
Solution) and AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process), ranks candidate items and assists decision makers
in selecting the most proper type of spillway. An example of selecting the optimal spillway is used to
illustrate the concept developed.
Keywords: Optimal spillway, Linguistic variables, MCDM, TFN, Fuzzy, TOPSIS method, AHP
1.
INTRODUCTION
Multi-criteria decision making methods (MCDM) in a fuzzy environment can deal with problems
which are too complex or ill-defined. In other words, a MCDM method is the process of finding the
optimal alternative among all feasible alternatives (Tecle et al. 1988; Weng et al. 2010). Several
techniques are available such as the Compromise Programming (Zeleny, 1974), the Analytic
Hierarchy Process (Saaty, 1980), the Cooperative Game Theory (Nash, 1953; Szidarovszky et al.,
1984), the Composite Programming (Bardossy et al., 1985) etc. Among those techniques we selected
TOPSIS method into fuzzy environment, using a linguistic scaling and a part of the AHP to assign
weights to the data of the problem.
The optimal type of a spillway is one of the most complex issues in water management including
considerable uncertainty due to the existence of qualitative criteria. The main criteria were determined
using extensive library studies and experts’ opinion. The institutes that were found to give special
recommendations for the spillway type selection are the Indian Standards Institute (Bureau of Indian
Standards, 1982) and U.S. Bureau of Reclamation (Reclamation, 2014). Finally, nine criteria have
been chosen: a) C1= construction costs, b) C2= maintenance costs, c) C3= foundation, d) C4= reservoir
capacity, e) C5= static/ construction difficulty, f) C6= discharge capacity, g) C7= physical space, h)
C8= conveyance feature (costs and construction difficulty) and i) C9= aesthetic, to evaluate the five
alternatives (types of spillway): a) X1= ogee or overfall spillway, b) X2= shaft or morning glory
spillway, c) X3= side channel spillway, d) X4= siphon spillway and e) X5= gated spillway.
1014
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.
TOPSIS (TECHNIQUE FOR ORDER PREFERENCE BY SIMILARITY TO IDEAL
SOLUTION) METHOD
TOPSIS (Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution) method was first developed
at 1981 by Yoon and Hwang (Yoon and Hwang, 1981). Its basic concept is that the chosen alternative
should have the shortest distance from the ideal solution and the farthest from the negative-ideal
solution. In the last two decades TOPSIS and Fuzzy TOPSIS have been employed in many fields;
fuel buses selection (Vahdani et al., 2011), bridge scheme selection (Mousavi, 2008), inter-company
comparison (Deng et al., 2000), risk identification (Ebrahimnejad et al., 2010), robotics (Chu and Lin,
2003), supply chain management (Chen et al., 2006), temporary storage design in industrial plants
(Heydar et al., 2008) etc. For hydraulic and water management issues in particular, it has been used
in selecting dam site (Tzimopoulos et al., 2013), irrigation networks (Tzimopoulos et al., 2012,
Tzimopoulos, 2012), risk assessment of dam removal (Qi, 2010) etc.
There have been several approaches for Fuzzy TOPSIS. The chosen one for this application is Chen’s
approach (Chen, 2000). According to this theory, the attributes are expressed in TFNs, the
normalization method is linear and vertex method is proposed for the calculation of the distance
measurements for the final ranking. The procedure of fuzzy TOPSIS is similar to the classic one and
can be expressed in a series of steps:
a) Construct the normalized decision matrix.
– In the fuzzy environment, in order to avoid the complicated normalization formula used in
classical TOPSIS, the linear scale transformation is used to transform the various criteria
scales into a comparable scale.
~r a ij , b ij , c ij , c* max c
ij
ij
c* c* c* j
i
j j j
x ij a ij , b ij , c ij are the elements of the decision matrix.
where ~
(1)
b) Construct the weighted normalized decision matrix.
~ν w
~ ~r ,
j=1,2,…m , i=1,2,…n
(2)
c) Determine the fuzzy ideal and fuzzy negative-ideal solutions.
A {~ν , ~ν ,...~ν }
(3)
ij
j
ij
1
2
m
A {~ν1 , ~ν2 ,...~νm }
(4)
where ~ν j =(1,1,1) and ~ν j =(0,0,0), j=1,2,…m.
d) Calculate the separation measure:
– Ideal separation
m
Si d(~ν ij , ~ν j )
i=1,2,…n
(5)
i=1,2,…n
(6)
j 1
– Negative-ideal separation
m
Si d(~ν ij , ~ν j )
j 1
where d(~ν ij , ~ν j ) and d(~ν ij , ~ν j ) are distance measurements calculated with the vertex method:
1015
River and open channel hydraulics
d( ~
x ij , ~
yij )=
1 1
1 2
2
2 2
3
3 2 ,
x
y
x
y
x
y
ij
ij
ij
ij
ij
3 ij
~
x ij x1ij , x ij2 , x 3ij , ~
y ij y1ij , y ij2 , y 3ij
(7)
e) Calculate the relative closeness to the Ideal Solution.
c*i
Si
,
(Si Si )
c*i =1
if
Ai=A+
c*i =0
if
Ai=A-
0< c*i <1,
i=1,2,…,n
(8)
f) Rank the preference order.
– A set of alternatives can now be preference ranked according to the descending order of c*i
Figure 1: Basic concept of TOPSIS method (A+: Ideal point, A-: Negative -Ideal Point)
The method presupposes that:
a. Each criterion in the decision matrix takes monotonically either increasing or decreasing
utility.
b. A decision matrix of n alternatives and m criteria and a set of weights for the criteria are
required.
c. Any outcome which is expressed in a non-numerical way should be quantified through the
appropriate scaling technique.
3.
LINGUISTIC VARIABLES EXPRESSED IN TFN (TRIANGULAR FUZZY
NUMBERS)
The extension of TOPSIS method in the fuzzy environment can be achieved by expressing the weights
of criteria and ratings as linguistic variables. A linguistic variable is a variable whose values are
linguistic terms. The concept of linguistic variable is very useful in dealing with situations which are
too complex or too ill-defined to be reasonably described in conventional quantitative expressions
1016
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
(Zadeh, 1975). According to many authors, the linguistic variables can be expressed in positive
triangular fuzzy numbers as shown in Tables 1 and 2 (Chen, 2010).
Table 1: Linguistic variables for the importance weight of each criterion
Very low (VL)
(0.1,0,0)
Low (L)
(0.3,0.1,0.1)
Medium low (ML)
(0.5,0.3,0.3)
Medium (M)
(0.7,0.5,0.5)
Medium high (MH)
(0.9,0.7,0.7)
High (H)
(1,0.9,0.9)
Very high (VH)
(1,1,1)
Table 2: Linguistic variables for the ratings
Very poor (VP)
(1,0,0)
4.
Poor (P)
(3,1,1)
Medium poor (MP)
(5,3,3)
Fair (F)
(7,5,5)
Medium good (MG)
(9,7,7)
Good (G)
(10,9,9)
Very good (VG)
(10,10,10)
TRIANGULAR FUZZY NUMBERS (TFN)
~
We define a fuzzy number M on R+ to be a triangular fuzzy number in case its membership function
x
x [, c],
c c ,
x
u
~ (x)
μ M~ (x): R → [0, 1] is equal to μ Μ
,
x [c, u],
(9)
cu cu
0,
otherwise
~
where ≤ c ≤ u. The triangular fuzzy number M can be denoted by ( , c, u).
1
0
c
u
~
Figure 2: A triangular fuzzy number M
1017
River and open channel hydraulics
~
~
~
~
Consider two triangular fuzzy nucbers M 1 and M 2, M 1 = ( 1, c1, u1) and M 2 = ( 2, c2, u2).
1. ( 1, c1, u1) + ( 2, c2, u2) = ( 1 + 2, c1 + c2, u1 + u2)
(10)
2. ( 1, c1, u1) × ( 2, c2, u2) = ( 1 × 2, c1 × c2, u1 × u2)
(11)
3. (λ, λ, λ) × ( 1, c1, u1) = (λ 1, λc1, λu1), λ>0, λ R
(12)
4. ( 1, c1, u1)-1 = (1/u1, 1/c1, 1/ 1)
(13)
5.
ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS (AHP) SCALING
The analytic hierarchy process (AHP) (Saaty, 1980) is based on decomposing a complex MCDM
problem into a system of hierarchies. There is a fundamental scale of absolute numbers from 1 to 9
shown in Table 3, in order to design the hierarchy.
When we estimate dominance in making comparisons, particularly when the criterion of the
comparisons is intangible, instead of using two numbers wi and wj from a scale (rather than
interpreting the significance of their ratio wi/wj ) we assign a single number drawn from the
fundamental scale 1 to 9 of absolute numbers shown in Table 3 to represent the ratio (wi/wj)/1. It is a
nearest integer approximation to the ratio wi/wj. The derived scale will reveal what the wi and wj are.
This is the main fact about the relative measurement approach and the need for a fundamental scale.
Table 3: Fundamental Scale of Absolute Numbers
Intensity of Importance Definition
Explanation
Two activities contribute equally to the
1
Equal Importance
objective
2
Weak or slight
Experience and judgment slightly favor
3
Moderate importance
one activity over another
4
Moderate plus
Experience and judgment strongly favor
5
Strong importance
one activity over another
6
Strong plus
An activity is favored very strongly over
Very
strong
or
7
another; its dominance demonstrated in
demonstrated importance
practice
8
Very, very strong
The evidence favoring one activity over
9
Extreme importance
another is of the highest possible order of
affirmation
If activity i has one of the
above nonzero numbers
assigned to it when
Reciprocals of above
compared with activity j, A logical assumption
then j has the reciprocal
value when compared
with i
1018
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
6.
ILLUSTRATIVE APPLICATION
The chosen dam is named “Pigi Dam” by “Kotza- Dere” river, which is located in Northern Greece.
It is considered as a large dam (GCOLD, 2013) and was constructed on 1999. It is a rockfill dam with
the upstream face made of concrete (impervious zone) constructed for irrigation. The dam is 38 m
tall, 159 m long and its volume is calculated at 139×103 m3. Its reservoir capacity and surface are
2,750 ×103 m3 and 265 ×103 m2 respectively and the discharge capacity of its spillway is 884 m3/s.
In order to define the optimal type of this dam’s spillway, the calculation steps that need to be made
are described below. Firstly, the decision maker computes the weights for the different criteria (Table
5) and the decision matrix by creating pairwise comparison matrices according to AHP. It is important
to mention that in all cases, C.R. (Consistency Ratio) is less than 0.1 and the judgments are acceptable.
C
1
Table 4: Comparison matrix for the weights
C2
C3
C4
C5
C6
C7
C8
C9
C1
1
1
4
4
4
5
7
3
9
C2
1
1
4
4
4
5
7
3
9
C3
0.25
0.25
1
0.2
1
4
6
0.25
6
C4
0.25
0.25
5
1
5
6
5
0.25
7
C
5
0.25
0.25
1
0.2
1
5
5
0.25
6
C
6
0.20
0.20
0.25
0.17
0.20
1
3
0.2
4
C
7
0.14
0.14
0.17
0.20
0.20
0.33
1
0.14
5
C
8
0.33
0.33
4
4
4
5
7
1
8
C9
0.11
0.11
0.17
0.14
0.17
0.25
0.20
0.13
1
C1
C2
C3
0.235
0.235
0.074
Table 5: Criteria’s weights
C4
C5
C6
0.133
0.075
0.039
C7
C8
C9
0.029
0.164
0.015
Figure 3: Importance of each criterion after AHP evaluation
1019
River and open channel hydraulics
C
Table 6: Decision matrix after AHP evaluation
C2
C3
C4
C5
C6
C7
1
C8
C9
X1
0.22
0.50
0.29
0.08
0.36
0.06
0.13
0.11
0.28
X2
0.47
0.13
0.06
0.08
0.04
0.52
0.34
0.04
0.52
X3
0.22
0.26
0.06
0.08
0.08
0.06
0.13
0.28
0.06
X4
0.05
0.07
0.29
0.08
0.16
0.28
0.34
0.28
0.06
X5
0.03
0.03
0.29
0.67
0.36
0.06
0.06
0.28
0.06
At the second step fuzziness is introduced to the process so as to confront the uncertainties of
judgments or calculations of the previous step. After normalizing the decision matrix and the weights’
matrix for the criteria by dividing each element with the maximum value per criterion, the decision
maker reconstructs these matrices using linguistic variables. Finally, he applies the linguistic
variables to the TFNs proposed by Chen in Tables 1 and 2.
1
C
VH
2
C
VH
3
C
ML
Table 7: Linguistic and fuzzy weights
C4
C5
C6
C7
M
ML
L
L
(0.9,1,1) (0.9,1,1) (0.1,0.3,0.5) (0.3,0.5,0.7) (0.1,0.3,0.5)
(0,0.1,0.3)
(0,0.1,0.3)
Table 8: Decision matrix in linguistic terms
C3
C4
C5
C6
C7
C1
C2
X1
F
VG
VG
P
VG
P
X2
VG
MP
P
P
P
X3
F
F
P
P
X4
P
P
VG
X5
P
P
VG
C1
C2
C8
MH
C9
L
(0.5,0.7,0.9)
(0,0.1,0.3)
C8
C9
MP
F
F
VG
VG
P
VG
MP
P
MP
VG
P
P
F
F
VG
VG
P
VG
VG
P
MP
VG
P
C7
C8
C9
(1,3,5)
(3,5,7)
(3,5,7)
Table 9: Fuzzy decision matrix
C3
C4
C5
C6
X1
(3,5,7)
X2
(9,10,10) (1,3,5)
(0,1,3)
(0,1,3)
(0,1,3)
(9,10,10) (9,10,10) (0,1,3)
X3
(3,5,7)
(3,5,7)
(0,1,3)
(0,1,3)
(1,3,5)
(0,1,3)
(1,3,5)
X4
(0,1,3)
(0,1,3)
(9,10,10) (0,1,3)
(3,5,7)
(3,5,7)
(9,10,10) (9,10,10) (0,1,3)
X5
(0,1,3)
(0,1,3)
(9,10,10) (9,10,10) (9,10,10) (0,1,3)
(9,10,10) (9,10,10) (0,1,3)
(9,10,10) (0,1,3)
(1,3,5)
The procedure continues with the TOPSIS’ calculations (Equations 1-8).
1020
(9,10,10)
(9,10,10) (0,1,3)
(9,10,10) (0,1,3)
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 4: Separation measures; Ideal separation, Negative-ideal separation
Finally, we obtain the ranking between the alternatives by calculating the relative closeness.
X1 (0.313) >X5(0.261) > X3(0.246) > X2(0.243) > X4(0.224)
X1= ogee spillway > X5= gated spillway > X3= side channel spillway > X2= shaft spillway > X4=
siphon spillway
7.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
This paper presents the first application of the combination of the proposed MCDM methods with
fuzzy logic to solve the problem of selecting the optimal type of a spillway in all types and sizes of
dams.
Although a spillway is an important chapter in hydraulics, little guidelines on how to select its type
can be found in literature. As a result, in most cases, the selection derives from a techno-economic
and feasibility analysis. Our study proves that more parameters rather than technical feasibility and
low construction costs should be taken into consideration. X2 (shaft or morning glory spillway)
spillway has the highest evaluation for C1 (construction costs) criterion (Table 8), which means that
it is the most cost-efficient alternative. Nevertheless, in the presented approach, X2 would be the
fourth choice out of the five.
Finally, it is suggested that engineering problems involving decision making could be better dealt
with MCDM methods and fuzzy logic. It helps the decision maker not only to get the optimal solution,
but also have a ranking order. The aforementioned process could also be implemented in various
engineering problems.
References
1. Bardossy, A., I. Bogardi and L. Duckstein. (1985). ‘Composite Programming as an Extension of
Compromise Programming’. Mathematics of Mulitobjective Organization, ed. P. Serafine, pp.
375-408, Springer-Verlag, New York.
2. Bureau of Indian Standards. (1982). ‘IS 10137: Guidelines for selection of spillways and energy
dissipators’. New Delhi.
1021
River and open channel hydraulics
3. Chen, C. T. (2000). ‘Extensions of the TOPSIS for group decision-making under fuzzy
environment’. Fuzzy sets and systems, Vol 114(1), pp. 1-9.
4. Chen, C. T., C. T. Lin and S. F. Huang. (2006). ‘A fuzzy approach for supplier evaluation and
selection in supply chain management’. International journal of production economics, Vol
102(2), pp. 289-301.
5. Chu, T. C. and Y. C. Lin. (2003). ‘A fuzzy TOPSIS method for robot selection’. The
International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, Vol 21(4), pp. 284-290.
6. Deng, H., C. H. Yeh and R. J. Willis. (2000). ‘Inter-company comparison using modified TOPSIS
with objective weights.’ Computers & Operations Research, Vol 27(10), pp. 963-973.
7. Ebrahimnejad S., S. M. Mousavi, and H. Seyrafianpour. (2010). ‘Risk identification and
assessment for build–operate–transfer projects: A fuzzy multi attribute decision making model’.
Expert systems with Applications, Vol 37(1), pp. 575-586.
8. GCOLD (Greek Committee on large dams). (2013). ‘The dams of Greece’. Proc. Nat. Conf. 2nd
National Conference on Dams. Athens, Greece.
9. Heydar, M., R. Tavakkoli-Moghaddam, S. M. Mousavi and S. M. H. Mojtahedi. (2008). ‘Fuzzy
multi criteria decision making method for temporary storage design in industrial plants.’. In
Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management, 2008. IEEM 2008. IEEE
International Conference on pp. 1154-1158.
10. Mousavi, S. M., H. Malekly, H. Hashemi, and S. M. H. Mojtahedi. (2008). ‘A two-phase fuzzy
decision making methodology for bridge scheme selection.’. In Industrial Engineering and
Engineering Management, 2008. IEEM 2008. IEEE International Conference on, pp. 415419.
11. Nash J. F. (1953). ‘Two-Person Cooperative Games’. Econometrica Vol. 21, pp. 128-140.
12. Qi, C. Q. (2010). ‘Research on risk assessment of dam removal.’. Future Information
Technology and Management Engineering (FITME), 2010 International Conference on,
Vol. 2, pp. 185-188. IEEE.
13. Reclamation, U. B. O. (2014). ‘General Spillway Design Considerations.’ Design Standards No.
14 Chapter 3: Final: Phase 4.
14. Saaty T. L. (1980). ‘The Analytic Hierarchy Process: Planning, Priority Setting, and Resources
Allocation’, McGraw-Hill.
15. Szidarovsky, F., L. Duckstein and I. Bogardi. (1984). ‘Multiobjective Management of Mining
under Water Hazard by Game Theory’. European Journal of Operations Research Vol. 15, pp.
251-258.
16. Tecle A., M. Fogel and L. Duckstein. (1988). ‘Multicriterion selection of wastewater management
alternatives’. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, Vol 114(4), pp. 383398.
17. Τzimopoulos, C., V. Balioti and C. Evangelides. (2012). ‘Multi- criteria decision making using
TOPSIS method. Application in irrigation networks.’ Proc. Int. Conf. XI Protection and
Restoration of the Environment, (PRE XI). Thessaloniki, Greece.
18. Τzimopoulos, C. (2012). ‘Application of the TOPSIS method in the irrigation networks of GOEVThessaloniki.’. Proc. Nat. Conf. 2nd National Joint Conference HHA-EEDYP, Patras, Greece.
19. Τzimopoulos, C., V. Balioti and C. Evangelides. (2013). ‘Fuzzy multi- criteria decision making
method for dam selection’. Proc. Int. Conf. 13th International Conference on Environmental
Science and Technology (CEST 2013), Athens, Greece.
1022
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
20. Vahdani, B., M. Zandieh and R. Tavakkoli-Moghaddam. (2011). ‘Two novel FMCDM methods
for alternative-fuel buses selection’. Applied Mathematical Modelling, Vol 35(3), pp. 13961412.
21. Weng S. Q., G. H. Huang and Y. P. Li. (2010). ‘An integrated scenario-based multi-criteria
decision support system for water resources management and planning–A case study in the Haihe
River Basin’. Expert Systems with Applications, Vol 37(12), pp. 8242-8254.
22. Zadeh, L. A. (1975). ‘The concept of a linguistic variable and its application to approximate
reasoning—I’. Information sciences, Vol 8(3), pp. 199-249.
23. Zeleny M. (1974). ‘A Concept of Compromise Solutions and the Method of the Displaced Ideal’.
Computers and Operations Research Vol. 1, pp. 479-496.
1023
River and open channel hydraulics
MODELLING ENVIRONMENTAL FLOWS WITH LAGRANGIAN
PARTICLE MESH-FREE METHODS
A. Liakopoulos*, F. Sofos, T. Karakasidis
Hydromechanics and Environmental Engineering Laboratory,
Dept. of Civil Engineering, University of Thessaly,
Pedion Areos, GR-38334, Volos, Greece
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: aliakop@civ.uth.gr
Abstract
Particle methods are computational techniques in which material particles move under the action of
forces obtained from the discretization of the governing partial differential equation (e.g. the NavierStokes equations in fluids). A large group of recently proposed particle methods are meshless, i.e they
do not require an associated mesh or grid in order to track the motion of the particles. As such,
particle methods are very well suited for modelling and simulating flows with interfaces undergoing
large deformations. In this paper we present a brief review of particle methods with emphasis on the
method of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH). Basic concepts of the SPH method such as the
integral interpolation method, the discretization of partial differential equations (PDEs) based on
distributed nodal points (particles), and the choice of interpolation kernel functions are reviewed. We
describe recent work on corrections applied to the original SPH method, the implementation of the
method in LAMMPS and on validation of computer codes based on test cases.
Keywords: Particle Methods, Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH), LAMMPS, Environmental
flows
1.
INTRODUCTION
The methods of conventional Computational Fluid Dynamics and Computational Hydraulics are
based on Partial Differential Equations (PDEs) derived in the conceptual framework introduced by
Euler. These methods have reached a very good level of maturity nowadays. However, at the same
time, the weaknesses of these methods have been exposed and the limits of their applicability are now
fairly well understood. For example, these methods fail in cases of large deformation of free surfaces
or, more generally, interfaces. In contrast, Lagrangian methods, based on the concept of describing
the flow by following the motion of fluid particles appear to have the capability to overcome the
problems associated with large deformations. In addition, Lagrangian particle-based methods offer a
unified framework for overcoming the difficulties associated with multi-scale modeling and
simulation.
A number of particle methods have been proposed over the past three decades, e.g. Smoothed Particle
Hydromechanics, Moving Particle Semi-implicit, Element–free Galerkin method, Material Point
Method, among many others. These particle methods do not require a mesh (grid) for their
implementation. It should be noted that there are particle methods that require grid such as the Particle
in Cell (PIC) method. These methods are not in the category of numerical methods discussed in this
work.
1024
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Among the particle methods, Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics has become very popular with
researchers in coastal engineering, computational hydraulics and wave/structure interaction. SPH was
originally proposed as a method for the solution of problems in astrophysics (Lucy, 1977, Gringold
& Monaghan 1977) for the solution of Newtonian non-viscous compressible flow. For approximately
fifteen years the method was exclusively at the hands of astrophysicists. Monaghan (Monaghan,
1994) proposed the application of SPH to free-surface flow simulation. The original formulation
assumed a weakly compressible fluid. Monaghan’s paper kicked off a period of great interest in SPH
which lead to significant improvements and extensions of the method. SPH is a purely Lagrangian
method. Its success depends on the use of appropriate interpolation kernels (smoothing kernels), i.e.
functions that interpolate the unknowns based on their values at irregularly spaced points (i.e., at the
positions of particles). Some subtle points of the method include the topics of consistency, stability
and convergence. SPH offers a number of important computational and modeling advantages over
traditional CFD methods. SPH momentum equation does not contain the nonlinear advection terms
that create a lot of difficulties in the computation of momentum dominated flows. Consequently, SPH
does not require upwinding schemes. The method follows easily free surfaces in liquid flows without
the need of special techniques, such as Volume of Fluid (VOF) or level-set methods to track the freesurface. Furthermore, SPH incorporates easily solid boundaries of complex geometry and serves as
an approximate Large Eddy Simulation (LES) method in fluid flow simulation (for another view see
Cleary and Prakash 2004). In addition, SPH can easily incorporate models of processes, such as heat
transfer, solidification, solute transport, sediment transport, etc. to the basic fluid flow SPH equations.
Generally, mesh-free particle methods are better suited for adaptive refinement procedures and for
multi-scale computations (Li and Liu 2002, 2004).
2.
THE METHOD OF SMOOTHED PARTICLE HYDRODYNAMICS
The central idea in SPH is the subdivision of the system under study to a number of moving particles
(“chunks” or blobs of matter) (Monaghan, 1988 and 1992). The conservation laws of continuum fluid
dynamics, in the form of partial differential equations, are transformed into their particle forms by
integral equations through the use of an interpolation function that gives the kernel estimate of the
field variables at a point. Information is extracted only at discrete points (the particles) and the
integrals are evaluated as sums over neighboring particles. Each particle has a constant mass and
time-dependent velocity, density, pressure, dynamic viscosity, temperature (as needed by the problem
under study). In the SPH framework the governing PDEs describing the system in motion are
transformed to a number of ordinary differential equations (ODEs). For example, a possible form of
SPH formulation of conservation of momentum and mass PDEs leads to a set of ODEs for the
velocities and densities of the particles which can be integrated by a numerical method of integration
of ODEs (e.g. Verlet, Euler, Runge-Kutta, etc). The positions of the particles are then calculated by
integrating the velocity. Detailed work on SPH can be found in (Gingold and Monaghan, 1977;
Koumoutsakos, 2005; Shao, 2009; Bouscasse et al. 2013; Hieber and Koumoutsakos, 2008).
3.
THE MATHEMATICS OF SMOOTHED PARTICLE HYDRODYNAMICS
In this section we briefly review the basic steps in developing an SPH formulation for a given partial
differential equation. The case of Navier-Stokes equations and the energy equation for a Newtonian
fluid is treated in some detail.
3.1 Integral approximation of functions and their derivatives
The starting point of an SPH formulation is an integral approximation of a function f x . In its ideal
form the approximation has the form of the identity
f x f x x x dx
(1)
1025
River and open channel hydraulics
where x is the position vector and x x is the Dirac’s delta function defined as
1 όταν
0 όταν
x x
x x
x x
In section 3 boldface characters denote vectors or tensors. Dirac’s delta function is a generalized
function (distribution) of point support that has the important property (1).
In order to be able to use the integral representation given by eq. (1) in a discrete computational
scheme one has to replace the delta function by another function, say Wx x; h with finite support.
This function is called kernel of the integral approximation and plays the role of a smoothing function
over a spatial neighbourhood of dimension h .
f x f x Wx x; h dx
(2)
As expected the kernel (smoothing function) has to satisfy a number of conditions (Monaghan 1992).
Equally important for the success of the SPH method is that the spatial derivatives can be computed
by formulas of the form
f x f x Wx x; h dx
(3)
It is clear that the choice of the kernel is important for the success of the method. Furthermore, the
smoothing length h has to be chosen judicially.
3.2 Discretization using a set of particles
The second step in developing an SPH formulation is the discretization of the problem domain by a
set of point masses (particles). The smoothing kernels (also known as interpolation kernels) are
centered at the point masses. The value of a field variable and its derivative at particle i are calculate
by the discete forms of equations (2) & (3). For a variable f x , we calculate its value at x i by
f x i m j
j 1
fj
j
W x i x j
(4)
and the gradient at position x i by
f x i m j
j 1
fj
j
Wij m j
j 1
fj
j
j Wij
(5)
Since W is radially symmetric
j Wij
x ij dWij
(6)
x ij drij
where x ij x i x j , xij x ij , W x i x j W xij
3.3 An SPH formulation of the Navier-Stokes equations
Starting point of the procedure is the general continuum form of the conservation equations for a
general fluid. In rectangular Cartesian coordinates x1 ,x 2 ,x 3 the conservation equations for mass,
momentum and energy are written in indicial notation as
D
Dt
x
(7)
1026
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
D a
Dt
1 a
ba
x
(8)
De 1 a a q a
Dt
x x a
(9)
where is the fluid density, 1 , 2 , 3
are the components of the velocity vector, a the
components of the total stress tensor, q1 , q 2 , q 3 is the heat flux vector, b1 , b 2 , b 3 is the body force
per unit mass, a 1,2,3 and 1,2,3 . Here, repeated indices imply summation from 1 to 3. The
D
symbol
denotes the material (substantial) derivative. Incorporating the constitutive equations for
Dt
Newtonian fluids we obtain the well known Navier-Stokes equations. Incorporating the SPH particle
approximation for the dependent variables and their derivatives (eqs. 4 and 5) we obtain the SPH
equations for the Navier-Stokes, continuity and energy equations as follows:
Wij
D i
m j ij
Dt
xi
j 1
(10)
Wij
D ia
j
m j i 2 2 b ia
Dt
j xi
j 1
i
(11)
p
pj
Wij
De i 1
m j i2 2 ij
i ia ia
Dt
2 j 1 i
2 i
j
xi
(12)
where ij i j and
a 2
V
x a x 3
p
where are the components of the stress deviator, m j is the mass of the jth particle, i is the
density of the ith particle, p i is the pressure of the ith particle, i1 , i2 , i3 the velocity of the ith
particle, and i the dynamic viscosity coefficient of ith particle.
3.4 The choice of the smoothing function
It is obvious that the choice of the smoothing function W and the smoothing length, h, is very
important and can lead to success or failure of the method. A smoothing function must have a number
of properties such as the “property of unity”, compact support (i.e, local support), positivity, decay,
smoothness, symmetry, as well as the “Delta function property”. Among these seven desirable
properties, two of them are indispensable:
Wx x; h dx 1
(“unity” property)
(13)
(“Delta function” property)
(14)
and
lim W x x; h x x
h 0
1027
River and open channel hydraulics
A number of smoothing function have been proposed over the years (see Liu & Liu 2010). Here we
x x
list the most important of them. Let R
. Then, three useful smoothing functions are:
h
Gaussian kernel (Gingold & Monaghan, 1977)
WR, h ad e R
2
(15)
where
ad
1
h
for 1-D, a d
5
h
2
for 2-D,
ad
105
h 3 3 / 2
for 3-D problems.
Cubic B-Spline
23 R 2 12 R 3 ,
W R, h a d 16 2 R 3 ,
0,
ad
1-D
2-D
3-D
1h
15 7 h 2
3 2 h 3
0 R 1
1 R 2
(16)
R2
Quintic spline
3 R 5 62 R 5 151 R 5 ,
5
5
3 R 62 R ,
WR, h a d
5
3 R ,
0,
ad
1-D
2-D
3-D
120 h
7 478 h 2
3 359 h 3
0 R 1,
0.5 R 2,
2 R 3,
(17)
R 3
3.5 SPH equations as solved in LAMMPS
In the LAMMPS implementation the field variables are , v, e, P, Q that is density, velocity, internal
energy, the stress tensor, and the heat flux vector. The descritized equations are:
Local density for particle i
i m j
j 1
j
Wij m j Wij
j
j 1
(18)
This is frequently referred in the mathematical literature as “partition of unity”.
Momentum equation for particle i
Pj
dv i
P
i2 m j j Wij m j 2 j Wij
dt
i j 1
j
j 1
(19)
1028
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
where P is the stress (pressure) tensor. Note that the pair-wise forces are
fi mi
P
Pj
dv i
m i m j i2 2 j Wij
dt
j
j 1
i
(20)
Continuity equation
d i
m j v j j Wij v i m j j Wij m j v ij j Wij
dt
j 1
j 1
j 1
(21)
Energy equation
mi
m m
P
Pj
dei
1
i
j
i
j
i
j
m i m j i2 2 : v ij j Wij
rij j Wij
2
dt
2 j 1
j
rij
j 1 i j
i
(22)
Newman-Richter type artificial viscosity
Monaghan has introduced an artificial viscosity term in order to avoid instabilities in this SPH
formulation of the N-S equations. It is adopted in the LAMMPS formulation so that the pair-wise
forces are modified and take the form
fi mi
P
Pj
dv i
m i m j i2 2 ij j Wij
dt
j
j 1
i
(23)
With
ij α h
ci c j
v ij rij
(24)
i j rij2 εh 2
where c i speed of sound of particle i , c j speed of sound of particle j , α auxiliary factor for
control of dissipation, ε auxiliary factor used to avoid singularities when rij 0 . As a rule of
thump ε 0.01 . The energy equation has to be also modified.
3.6 Some remarks about SPH formulations for fluids
In relation to the application of the SPH method in fluid dynamical problems we should mention that
the treatment of pressure for incompressible flow can be carried out either through an equation of
state or by enforcing the incompressibility condition via a Poisson equation for pressure. Another
important issue in viscous water flows is the treatment of viscosity, which is a key quantity in
determining water transport. In addition, the computational enforcement of boundary conditions
(especially inlet-outlet boundary conditions) requires further development (Lykov et al., 2015 Lei et
al., 2011). Collision detection at impermeable solid boundaries is also very important.
4.
RESULTS
We applied the SPH simulation method on a software platform that has been widely used for research,
primarily for Molecular Dynamics simulations of atomistic systems, LAMMPS-Large-scale
Atomic/Molecular Massively Parallel Simulator (Plimpton, 1995). Due to its particle nature, SPH is
directly compatible with the existing code architecture and data structures present in LAMMPS for
MD (Sofos et al., 2009, 2010, 2013, Liakopoulos, 2016) and Dissipative Particle Dynamics (DPD)
(Kasiteropoulou, 2012). Furthermore, its parallel nature offers a boost in all simulations that could be
1029
River and open channel hydraulics
executed in parallel tasks (Herault et al., 2010, Verma et al., 2017, Wu et al., 2017). Here we
investigate two SPH test cases, the development of an unsteady (transient) Couette flow, and the welldocumented, water column collapse example. Model screenshots are created with Ovito [Stukowski,
2010].
4.1 Transient Couette flow
A 3-D rectangular simulation box is created for unsteady Couette flow, as shown in Fig. 1. The
dimensions in x-, y- and z-directions are =20, =10, =10. The asterisc denotes values scaled to
Lennard-Jones values. Wall and fluid particles are set on fcc sites in the beginning of the simulation
and remain on their initial position until the upper rigid plate moves. The upper wall is given a
constant velocity, vx* =3.0, in the x-direction and drives the flow due to friction. There are 2000 wall
particles and 6000 liquid particles in the simulation. The nominal density is constant ρ*=1. Periodic
conditions are enforced in the x and z directions. The simulation runs with a timestep of Δt*=0.001
for 2x106 timesteps.
4.2 Water column collapse in a tank with obstacles
In this example we present the collapse of a water column in a rectangular tank with obstacles
(Gomez-Gestheira et al. 2010). Walls remain stationary. Simulation for 5x104 timesteps (or, 7.5 sec)
can reveal the full evolution of the phenomenon (Fig. 3) and agrees with documented results.
Figure 1: A Couette flow model (
=20,
=10,
=10)
The velocity profiles extracted at various times are shown in Fig. 2. Velocity profiles tend to reach a
linear velocity distribution across the y-direction at steady state, as expected from the Navier-Stokes
theory.
Figure 2: Couette flow: x-Velocity profile across the y-direction.
1030
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
5.
CONCLUSIONS
We have shown that the SPH method, as a purely particle method, has many similarities to Molecular
Dynamics, the well-documented atomistic simulation method, as well as to mesoscopic methods such
as Dissipative Particle Dynamics (DPD). We have also reviewed some of the most basic concepts in
the SPH formulation for solving partial differential equations with emphasis on the particular method
for the N-S equations implemented in LAMMPS. SPH is well suited for flows of liquids with free
surface such as wave propagation, wave/structure interaction, wave/ship interaction, sloshing to
mention a few. Furthermore, SPH is very useful in applications in soil mechanics, geotechnical
engineering, and water resources engineering such as: flood wave propagation modeling, floodplain
inundation predictions, open channel hydraulics etc. Finally, we would like to address the practical
problem of reducing the required CPU time for SPH and more generally for particle methods. Parallel
processing and hardware innovations offer the best hope for improvements. The high-performance
parallel architecture provided by CUDA-enabled GPUs is ideal for SPH models. The use of graphic
cards and CUDA has allowed much finer details to be revealed, due to the ability to run computations
with hundreds of times more particles in far shorter times than required for similar code runs on a
single CPU or even on many clusters.
t=0 sec
t=0.75 sec
t=1.5 sec
t=2.25 sec
t=3.0 sec
t=4.0 sec
t=5.5 sec
t=6.5 sec
t=7.5 sec
Figure 3:Water column collapse in a tank with obstacles
1031
River and open channel hydraulics
References
1. Bouscasse B., Calagrossi A., Marrone S., Antuono M. (2013) ‘Non linear water interaction with
floating bodies in SPH’, J. Fluids Struct. 42, 112-129.
2. Cleary P.W., Prakash M. (2004) ‘Discrete–element modelling and smoothed particle
hydrodynamics: potential in the environmental sciences’, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A 2004 362
2003-2030; DOI: 10.1098/rsta.2004.1428.
3. Gingold R.A., J.J. Monaghan (1977) ‘Smoothed particle hydrodynamics: theory and application
to non-spherical stars’, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 181, 375–389.
4. Gomez-Gesteira M., Rogers B.D., Dalrymple R.A., Crespo A.J.C. (2010) ‘State-of-the-art of
classical SPH for free-surface flows’, Journal of Hydraulic Research, 48(extra):6, 27.
5. Hérault Alexis, Bilotta Giuseppe, Dalrymple A. Robert (2010) “SPH on GPU with CUDA”,
Journal of Hydraulic Research, Vol. 48 Extra Issu, e pp. 74–79, doi:10.3826/jhr.2010.0005.
6. Hieber S.E., Koumoutsakos P. (2008) ‘An immersed boundary method for smoothed particle
hydrodynamics of self-propelled swimmers’, J. Comput. Phys., 227, 8636–8654.
7. Kasiteropoulou D., Karakasidis T.E., and Liakopoulos A., (2012) ‘A Dissipative Particle
Dynamics study of flow in periodically grooved nanochannels’, International Journal for
Numerical Methods in Fluids, v. 68, Issue 9, pp. 1156–1172.
8. Koumoutsakos P. (2005) ‘Multiscale flow simulations using particles’, Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech.
37, 457–487.
9. Lei Huan, Fedosov Dmitry A., Karniadakis George Em. (2011) ‘Time-dependent and outflow
boundary conditions for Dissipative Particle Dynamics’, Journal of Computational Physics 230
3765–3779.
10. Li S., Liu W.K. (2002) ‘Meshfree and particle methods and their applications’, Appl. Mech. Rev
55(1), 1-34. doi:10.1115/1.1431547.
11. Li S., Liu W.K. (2004) ‘Meshfree Particle Methods’, Springer.
12. Liakopoulos A., Sofos F., Karakasidis T.E. (2016) ‘Friction factor in nanochannel flows’,
Microfluidics Nanofluidics, Vol. 20, Issue 1, pp. 1-7.
13. Liu M.B., Liu G.R. (2010) ‘Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH): an Overview and Recent
Developments’, Arch of Comput Methods in Eng., 17:25-76.
14. Lucy L.B. (1977) ‘A numerical approach to the testing the fission hypothesis’, Astron. J. 82,
pp.1013–1024.
15. Lykov K., Li X., Lei H., Pivkin I.V., Karniadakis G.E. (2015) ‘Inflow/Outflow Boundary
Conditions for Particle-Based Blood Flow Simulations: Application to Arterial Bifurcations and
Trees’, PLoS Comput Biol 11(8).
16. Monaghan, J. J. (1988) ‘An introduction to SPH’, Computer Physics Communications 48, pp.
89–96.
17. Monaghan, J. J. (1992) ‘Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics’, Annual Review of Astronomy and
Astrophysics 30, pp. 543–574.
18. Monaghan, J. J. (1994) ‘Simulating free surface flows with SPH’, J. Comput. Phys. Vol. 110,
399 406.
19. Plimpton S. (1995) ‘Fast Parallel Algorithms for Short-Range Molecular Dynamics’, J. Comp.
Phys. 117, 1-19.
20. Shao S. (2009) ‘Incompressible SPH simulation of water entry of a free-falling object’, Int. J.
Numer. Methods Fluids 59, 91–115.
1032
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
21. Sofos F., Karakasidis T.E. and Liakopoulos A. (2009) ‘Transport properties of liquid argon in
krypton nanochannels: Anisotropy and non-homogeneity introduced by the solid walls’, Int. J.
Heat Mass Transf., 52 735-743.
22. Sofos F., Karakasidis T.E., Liakopoulos A. (2010) ‘Effect of wall roughness on shear viscosity
and diffusion in nanochannels’, Int J Heat Mass Tran 53: 3839–3846.
23. Sofos F., Karakasidis T.E., Liakopoulos A. (2013) ‘Parameters affecting slip length at the
nanoscale’, Journal of Computational & Theoretical Nanoscience, Vol. 10, pp.1-3.
24. Stukowski A. (2010) ‘Visualization and analysis of atomistic simulation data with OVITO - the
Open Visualization Tool’, Modelling Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 18, 015012.
24. Verma K., Szewc K. and Wille R. (2017) Advanced load balancing for SPH simulations on multiGPU architectures, IEEE High Performance Extreme Computing Conference (HPEC),
Waltham, MA, pp. 1-7.
25. Wu W., Li H., Su T., Liu H., Lv Z. (2017) ‘GPU-accelerated SPH fluids surface reconstruction
using two-level spatial uniform grids’, The Visual Computer 33, 1429-1442.
1033
River and open channel hydraulics
1034
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Environmental law and economics
1035
Environmental law and economics
1036
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
SPATIAL MULTI-CRITERIA DECISION MAKING MODEL FOR
SUSTAINABLE COASTAL LAND-USE AND DEVELOPMENT.
THE CASE STUDY OF KALAMARIA-PILEA SEAFRONT IN
THESSALONIKI, GREECE.
S. Anastasiadis*, A. S. Partsinevelou and Z. Mallios
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: stavrosanastasiadis@yahoo.gr, tel: +302313302679
Division of Urban Planning and Urban Development,
Dept. of Urban Planning, Municipality of Pilea-Chortiatis,
GR- 55535 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
Abstract
In the last decade, applications of the Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) techniques in GISbased land suitability procedures have been increased, especially at a regional-scale planning
processes. Through these procedures, conflicts between urban growth and ecological conservation
have been brought to the forefront, especially in developing coastal areas, while potential ecological
environmental risks have been emerged as a result of land-use changes (e.g. urbanization). An
optimized land-use planning and development could reduce this risk at a regional scale. Modern
planning theories encourage approaches with Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) techniques,
combined with GIS, as they have been applied successfully in a number of land suitability analysis
and environmental planning and management scenarios.
This study aims to present a realistic and detailed set of criteria and a group decision making, by using
MCDM techniques and Analytical Hierarchy Procedure (AHP - Fuzzy AHP), in order to define the
most preferred option to secure a sustainable coastal land-use and development at the Pilea-Kalamaria
seafront in Thessaloniki, Greece, where no land-use is configured in its largest part. In order to built
the MCDM model, the study was organized into four principal stages: (i) defining the land suitability
criteria of the model, (ii) ranking the importance of each criterion, (iii) generating land suitability
maps for each criterion, and (iv) generating a final map with the suitable land-uses of the study area
accompanied by a detailed analysis of the results of the MCDM model and a comparison of the results
with the most recently approved General Urban Plan of the study area.
Keywords: MCDM model; land-use planning; coastal area; urban development; spatial optimization
1.
INTRODUCTION
Urban land-use suitability can be influenced by the large numbers of environmental, economic and
social factors, such as ecological health, population growth and economic development. As cities
expand physically, the frontiers between urban and rural activity are distorted and merged, presenting
opportunities for beneficial linkages (Phua & Minowa, 2005).
Over the past years, many tools based on Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and Remote Sensing
(RS) techniques have proved useful for land management. The incorporation of multi-criteria
evaluation methods into GIS has emerged as a promising research area by creating a modular
hierarchical system of the land suitability index, which will aim at delivering a strategic
environmental assessment of developmental land-uses for regional planning (Marull et al., 2007).
However, the limitation of most existing multi-criteria evaluation models and land-use allocation
models is that the uncertainties about the future distribution of land-uses are not explicitly taken into
1037
Environmental law and economics
account (Verdoodt & Ranst, 2006). There are many important factors associated with environmental
quality, construction investment, soil resources and population density during the evaluation process.
These factors can be sorted into different indicators, but the complicated interrelationships among
them cannot be simply expressed by the restrictive equalities or inequalities in the conventional
evaluation models (Mosadeghi, 2013, Langemeyer et al., 2016).
For the creation of a realistic Multi Criteria Decision Model (MCDM), the Analytic Hierarchy Process
(AHP) is proved as a useful systematic analysis tool for handling multi-criteria decision-making
process. It enables the consideration of social and economic objectives, which are recognized to be
of the same importance as the ecological and environmental ones (Xu et al., 2006, Zeng et l., 2007).
However, it depends excessively on the subjective weight of each performance indicator from
experience, while the interrelationships among multiple indicators are ignored (Yang et al., 2008).
This study proposes a spatial analysis system for urban land-use management integrating
environmental assessment tools with multi-criteria land resources information system, in order to
define the most preferred option to secure a sustainable coastal land-use and development. The
MCDM model was created using AHP analysis in order to rank correctly the importance of each
criterion used. An integrated land suitability evaluation model based on GIS is proposed and applied
in Kalamaria-Pilea seafront as a case study.
The great needs in the area of Thessaloniki, which is densely populated around of its historical center,
highlight the fact that its urban and metropolitan area must be redefined. Therefore, in the region of
Thessaloniki, the reconstruction and development of the seafronts of Kalamaria and Pilea will help
to create a connection with the historical center of the city, thus achieving new dynamics in the
transformation of the city. Similar examples of expansion of metropolitan areas with the simultaneous
development of new recreational areas, cultural sites and green spaces, could be seen in many
European cities, such as in London and in Barcelona (Organization of Thessaloniki, 2001). The
construction and redevelopment of Kalamaria-Pilea seafront will upgrade the wider urban landscape
and the offer of high quality of life, which is general considered as a first priority (Anastasiadis,
2015).
2.
THE STUDY AREA
The Kalamaria-Pilea seafront is bordered southeast by the coastal front of Thermi, in which most of
the facilities of Thessaloniki International Airport ʻMacedoniaʼ are extended, while at northeast is
bordered by the urban area of Kalamaria Municipality. Also in the extended area of Kalamaria-Pilea
seafront, a part of the farm of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki is included (Figure 1).
The Kalamaria-Pilea seafront was used for many years as an open beach, with the beach of Dalianon
to be widely known. This situation changed radically after the apparent contamination of Thermaikos
Gulf, when it stopped being a pole of attraction for the residents' summer baths (Anastasiadis, 2015).
The total length of the Kalamaria-Pilea seafront is approximately 3.5 km. Characteristic features of
this area are its key location, where there is access to central public transport facilities, as well as the
existence of large free spaces that allow the further urban development of the seafront. Road network
along the coastline does not exist and the beach is accessible to pedestrians only from the shopping
center ʻApollonia Politiaʼ up to the farm of the University of Thessaloniki.
Despite the very good features of the area, the Kalamaria-Pilea seafront is a neglected area with strong
signs of abandonment and contamination from the existing land uses (small shipbuilding zones, etc.).
However, according to the approved General Urban Plans of the Municipality of Kalamaria and the
Municipality of Pilea-Chortiatis, an urban planning is proposed for the seafront, which aims in the
sustainable development of the area.
1038
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: The extended study area of the Kalamaria-Pilea seafront in Thessaloniki.
3.
METHODOLOGY
This study aims to present a realistic and detailed set of criteria and a group decision making, by using
MCDM techniques and Analytical Hierarchy Procedure (AHP), in order to define the most preferred
option to secure a sustainable coastal land-use and development at the Pilea-Kalamaria seafront in
Thessaloniki, Greece.
Before building the MCDM model for the study area, it was necessary to map the land cover at the
Kalamaria-Pilea seafront. For this purpose, a cloud-free Sentinel-2A image was downloaded for the
28th of June 2017 and orthorectified. This imagery was selected in order the peak of the vegetative
season to be captured, thereby enhancing the detection of green spaces, which are the free spaces of
the study area (Lefebvre et al., 2016).
In order to proceed with the MCDM model of the Kalamaria-Pilea seafront, it was necessary to know
the opinion of the inhabitants about the development of the area, as the approved Urban Plans were
not put to public consultation. This problem was solved by conducting an in-depth research, using a
well-formatted questionnaire, through personal interviews and via the internet (electronic survey),
where the results were included in the criteria used for the model.
Finally, in order to built the MCDM model, the study was organized into four principal stages: (i)
defining the land suitability criteria of the model, (ii) ranking the importance of each criterion, (iii)
1039
Environmental law and economics
generating land suitability maps for each criterion, and (iv) generating a final map with the suitable
land-uses of the study area accompanied by a detailed analysis of the results of the MCDM model
and a comparison of the results with the most recently approved General Urban Plan of the study
area.
3.1 Mapping the land cover of the area using Sentinel-2A imagery
For mapping the current unexploited space in the study area, the orthorectified Sentinel-2A on the
Hellenic Geodetic Reference System (GGRS’87) was used, which has accuracy up to 10 m.
Specifically, the bands 12, 11 and 4 were selected using the ENVI software, in order to map the urban
area and the free space in each municipality in the Kalamaria-Pilea seafront, as the combination of
these 3 bands results an enhancement of the urban area shown with purple color, while the free space
is designated with green or/and white color (Figure 2). Here it should be noted that the farm of the
University of Thessaloniki was not taken into account, as it cannot be exploited further.
Figure 2: Unexploited area of the Kalamaria-Pilea seafront in Thessaloniki.
3.2 Defining the land suitability criteria
Significant steps have been taken recently around the world to harmonize land use with natural terrain
conditions, as well as to assess the relative degree of intolerance of the terrain with regard to proposed
land use alterations (Collin & Melloul, 2012). In this study, in order to secure an environmental
friendly and sustainable coastal land-use and development at the Pilea-Kalamaria seafront in
Thessaloniki, areas which are environmentally unsuitable for exploitation must be first excluded.
For this purpose, some basic environmental criteria have been applied in the unexploited areas, such
us the morphology, the hydrology and the distance from the coastline (Table 1 & Table 2). Thus,
areas that are in a distance less than 50 m from the coastline, have a high morphological slope (>20%)
based on the Digital Elevation Model of the area and are in a distance less than 100 m from a stream
1040
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
are considered unsuitable for further exploitation and have been excluded (Figure 3). The
environmental factors of soils and vegetation were not used for this study area, as the geology of the
unexploited space is characterized by the presence of undivided Holocene deposits and a sandstonemarl series (Antoniades & Ioannidis, 1970), which are partly impermeable soils, while at the same
time there is no tree cover in the same areas.
At this point it should be noted that while in the General Urban Plan of the Municipality of Kalamaria
the areas that should not be used for the protection of the environment have not been included in the
general urban plan of the Municipality of Pilea-Chortiatis, environmental criteria have not been
included and the areas that are designated to be developed are different.
In order to proceed with the definition of the final criteria which will determine the final land uses of
the study area, the results of a well-formatted questionnaire were used, which constitute the socioeconomical criteria. The results of the analysis this questionnaire indicate that the inhabitants of both
municipalities (Kalamaria and Pilea-Chortiatis), prefer the construction of specific activities, with
low cost and high economic benefit (Anastasiadis, 2015). These results, according to each answer’s
percentage, were weighted in order to show the preferences of the public (Table 3).
Table 1: Land usage categories and intensities for various environmental factors (modified
from Melloul and Collin, 2001).
Recommended Land-Use Intensity
Environmental
Factor
Recreation
Conservation
High slope
>20%
Commercial &
Industrial
High
Intensity
Low
Intensit
y
Field
Crops
Orchards
High
Intensity
Low
Intensity
High
Intensity
Low
Intensity
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
2
4
2
4
3
5
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
2
4
2
4
3
5
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
2
4
2
4
3
5
4
3
2
4
2
4
3
4
4
3
3
4
3
4
3
5
4
1
Morphology
Low slope
Hydrology
Residential
Settlement
Agricultural
Ranking Criteria
<20%
Distance
<100m
from
hydrologica
l network >100m
1
Permeable
1
Soils
Impermeable
Tree cover
1
Vegetation
Other cover
Table 2: The environmental criteria used in the MCDM model.
Environmental Factor
Ranking Criteria
Recommended Land-Use
High slope
>20%
None
Low slope
<20%
Commercial & Industrial
Distance from
hydrological
network
<100 m
None
>100 m
Residential Settlement
Morphology
Hydrology
<50 m
None
>50 m
Commercial & Industrial Residential
Settlement Agricultural
Distance from the coastline
Recreation
1041
Environmental law and economics
Figure 3: Environmentally suitable areas for sustainable land use development.
Table 3: The socio-economical criteria used in the MCDM model
Socio-economical Factor
Ranking Criteria
Weights resulting by questionnaires
Sports, etc.
4
Shopping Malls
3
Cultural Sites
2
Tourist Facilities
1
Low
3
Medium
2
High
1
Low
1
Medium
2
High
3
Activities
Cost
Economic Benefit
As a result, the main criteria that have been used in order to finalize the MCDM model are:
The type of the facility that is going to be constructed, which is related with the environmental
impact. For example, sport facilities that are related to nature (such as swimming) are more
1042
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
environmental friendly than shopping malls and tourist facilities that would completely
change the present landscape.
The cost of the facility.
The economic benefit.
3.3 Ranking the importance of each criterion – AHP Analysis
The selection of the criteria mentioned was based on the preferences of the public and the
environmental impact that would have in today’s landscape. These criteria were weighed according
to Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) proposed by Saaty (1977). The Analytical Hierarchy Process
is a well-known and excellent method of calculating criteria of gravity ratios, which helps to obtain
subjective and objective evaluation measures. It is a very useful tool for checking the correctness of
these measures and the alternatives proposed, significantly reducing the error rate.
This process involves pairing comparisons and creates a list of reasons. It takes inputs as pair wise
comparisons and generates relative weights (gravity coefficients). In particular, the weights are
determined by normalizing the eigenvector associated with the maximum value of the inverse ratio.
The relationship of each criterion is expressed by numerical values given as in Table 4. These values
are not arbitrary, they follow a certain scale of sizes. This price comparison scale was proposed by
Saaty (1977) and Saaty & Vargas (1984) and ranges from 1 to 9. The value 1 expresses criteria of
equal importance, while at the other end of the scale, value 9 represents criteria which are of great
importance compared to those that are compared each time.
Table 4: The fundamental scale of AHP (Saaty & Vargas, 2001).
Intensity of Importance
Definitions
Explanation
1
Equal importance
Two activities contribute equally to the
objective
2
Weak importance
3
Moderate importance
4
Moderate plus importance
5
Strong importance
6
Strong plus importance
7
Very strong or demonstrated
importance
8
Very, very strong importance
9
Extreme importance
Experience and judgement slightly favour one
activity over another
Experience and judgement strongly favour one
activity over another
An activity is favoured very strongly over
another; its dominance demonstrated in
practice
The evidence favouring one activity over
another is of the highest possible order of
affirmation
After the correlation of the criteria has been made, the values are processed in order to weight the
criteria. In order to reduce any chance of error, Saaty (1977) proposed a numerical index to check the
correctness of the matrix comparison matrix, the so-called CR (consistency ratio). This index is equal
to the fraction of the consistency index CI and an average consistency index RI. The RI value is the
average consistency value of random squares of different classes (Saaty, 1977), while for CR≥0.1,
Saaty & Vargas (1984) proposed a re-examination of the original table.
Final results of the AHP analysis are shown in Table 5. From this analysis the Land Use Sustainability
(LUS), can be calculated by the following equation:
LUS=0.48*E+0.41*B+0,11*C
Where:
1043
Environmental law and economics
E, the Environmental friendly facility
B, the economic Benefit
C, the Cost of the construction and the conservation of the facility
Table 5: Weights of paired factors concerning the MCDM model for the Kalamaria-Pilea
seafront.
3.4 Land suitability maps generation
According to the LUS equation the land suitability map of the study area is generated, where from
the environmentally suitable areas, 48% must be an environmental friendly facility, 41% must be a
facility which will provide a sufficient economic benefit, while the 11% will be not developed in
order to keep the cost low.
Figure 4: Final sustainable land uses in the Kalamaria-Pilea seafront.
1044
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
For the areas selected in the Kalamaria-Pilea seafront 32,5% belongs to Kalamaria Municipality,
while the rest 67,5% belongs to Pilea-Chortiatis Municipality. This means that this area must have
land uses within the municipality borders, as it is very difficult to have multiple land uses using area
from both municipalities.
According to the above criteria, the final land use sustainable development map has been created,
with the use of ArcGIS 10.5 software and the Raster Calculator tool (Figure 4).
4.
RESULTS OF THE MCDM MODEL
By applying the MDCM model and the AHP analysis in the study area, the sustainable land uses of
the Kalamaria-Pilea seafront were selected according to Figure 4. Transportation facilities were
selected in a key area, where most of the facilities would be accessible to the public. Small green
areas were selected, in order to keep the cost low, while tourist facilities were selected to be developed
at the southern part of the study area, as in a small distance the marina of Pilea will be constructed,
according to the General Urban Plan of Municipality of Pilea-Chortiatis. Furthermore, sport facilities
and shopping malls were selected to be constructed as they were chosen by the public through the
questionnaire. Finally, the area of each sustainable land use is presented in Table 6.
Table 6: Type and total area of each selected sustainable land use for the Kalamaria-Pilea
seafront.
Sustainable Land Use
Area (km2)
5.
Cultural sites
0,12
Green areas
0,09
Shopping malls
0,15
Sport facilities
0,22
Tourist facilities
0,18
Transportation facilities
0,05
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) techniques in GIS-based land suitability procedures have
been increased, especially at a regional-scale planning processes. By selecting basic environmental
criteria and socio-economical criteria based on the public’s opinion, which could be easily given
through a well-formatted questionnaire, the sustainable land uses for any area with no land cover can
be extracted and be added to a General Urban Plan of any Greek Municipality.
The MDCM model, which has been presented in the current study, is enhanced by using the AHP
analysis in order to minimize the errors in selecting the suitable land use. In addition, Remote Sensing
Methods have been proved necessary in order to map the study area in its current situation.
Finally, it should be noted that the selection of land uses must be focused both on the environment
and the economic development of each municipality, as it has been observed from the current study
that the General Urban Plan of Municipality of Kalamaria had both designated green areas, several
facilities and zones of environmental protection (coastal zone), while the General Urban Plan of
Municipality of Pilea-Chortiatis has focused only for the economical development of the
municipality, without concerning about the environmental protection of the coastal zone. This had
the result that the sustainable land uses which were selected for the Municipality of Kalamaria were
close enough to its General Urban Plan, while the sustainable land uses which were selected for the
1045
Environmental law and economics
Municipality of Pilea-Chortiatis differ from its General Urban Plan, demonstrating that this General
Urban Plan should be furthermore studied.
References
1. Anastasiadis S. (2015) ʻInvestigation of the possible development of Kalamaria-Pilea
Seafrontʼ, Master of Science Thesis, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki.
2. Antoniades P. and Ioannides K. (1970) ʻGeological map of Thessalonikiʼ, Institute of Geological
and Mining Research, Greece.
3. Collin M.L, Melloul A.J. (2012) ʻLand-Use Planning Guidelines for Optimal Coastal
Environmental Managementʼ, Journal of Environmental Protection, 3, pp 485-501.
4. Langemeyer J., Gomez Baggethum E., Haase D., Scheuer S., Elmqvist T. (2016) ʻBridging the
gap between ecosystem service assessments and land use planning through Multi-Criteria
Decision Analysisʼ, Environmental Science and Policy, 62, pp 45-56.
5. Lefebvre A., Sannier C., Corpetti T. (2016) ʻMonitoring Urban Areas with Sentinel-2A Data:
Application to the update of the Copernicus High Resolution Layer Imperviousness
Degreeʼ, Remote Sensing, 8, 606.
6. Marull J., Pino J., Mallarach J., et al. (2007) ʻLand suitability index for strategic environmental
assessment in metropolitan areasʼ, Landscape Urban Plan, 81(3), pp 200-12.
7. Melloul A. J. and Collin M. L. (2001) ʻA Hierarchy of Ground- Water Management, LandUse, and Social Needs Integrated for Sustainable Resource Developmentʼ, Environment,
Development and Sustainability Journal, Vol. 3, pp 45-59.
8. Mosadeghi R. (2013) ʻA spatial multi-criteria decision making model for coastal land use
planningʼ, PhD Thesis, Griffith University.
9. Organization of Thessaloniki (2001) ʻTransformations of the urban landscape. Architectural
studies and works of the European Capital of Culture Organization Thessaloniki 1997ʼ,
Livani Publishing House SA, Thessaloniki.
10. Phua M.H., Minowa M. (2005) ʻA GIS-based multi-criteria decision making approach to
forest conservation planning at a landscape scale: a case study in the Kinabalu Area, Sabah,
Malaysiaʼ, Landscape Urban Plan, 71 (2-4), pp 207-222.
11. Saaty T.L. (1977) ʻA scaling method for priorities in hierarchical structuresʼ, Journal of
Mathematical Psychology, Vol. 15, pp 234 – 281.
12. Saaty T.L., Vargas L. (1984) ʻInconsistency and Rank Preservationʼ, Journal of Mathematical
Psychology, 28, pp 205-214.
13. Verdoodt A. & Ranst E.V. (2006) ʻEnvironmental assessment tools for multiscale land
resources information systems: a case study of Rwandaʼ, Agric Ecosyst Environ, 114(2-4), pp
170-84.
14. Xu M., Zeng G.M., Xu X.Y., et al. (2006) ʻApplication of Bayesian regularized BP neural
network model for trend analysis, acidity and chemical composition of precipitation in
north Carolinaʼ, Water Air Soil Pollut, 172(1/4), pp 167-84.
15. Yang F., Zeng G., Du C., Tang L., Zhou J., Li Z. (2008) ʻSpatial analyzing system for urban
land-use management based on GIS and multi-criteria assessment modelingʼ, Progress in
Natural Science, 18, pp 1279-1284.
16. Zeng G.M., Jiang R., Huang G.H., et al. (2007) ʻOptimization of wastewater treatment
alternative selection by hierarchy grey relational analysisʼ, J Environ Manage, 82(2), pp 25089.
1046
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
APPLYING THE CONTINGENT VALUATION METHOD TO
ESTIMATE THE ECONOMIC VALUE OF THE THESSALONIKI
SUBURBAN SEICH-SOU FOREST AMENITIES
E.K. Oikonomou* and A. Guitonas
Department of Transportation and Hydraulic Engineering, Faculty of Rural & Surveying
Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Hellas
*Corresponding author: e-mail: eoikonom@topo.auth.gr, tel: +30 2310 994360
Abstract
Environmental economic valuation of natural public goods and resources is focused on how to place
a monetary value on goods and bads, arising from changes that take place within the natural
environment and affect environmental quality or the available stocks of some natural resources. The
economic techniques available for economic valuation can be divided into three groups: conventional
market approaches; constructed market approaches; and implicit market approaches. In constructed
market, the most widely approach used is the contingent valuation method (CVM), which uses a
direct approach – some form of questionnaire – in order to ask people what they are willing to pay
(WTP) for an environmental benefit or willing to accept (WTA) in compensation for a loss. The
popularity of the method may be attributed mainly to two factors: firstly, it does not require any great
amount of data that is usually necessary for other techniques; and secondly, it can be applied in a
great variety of goods and services, including use and non-use values.
In the present paper the results of a questionnaire survey are presented, in an effort to investigate on
people’s WTP for better eco-management and protection of the important for Thessaloniki suburban
forest of Seich-Sou. The current situation of the forest is characterized by abandonment and low
quality of green space and tree flora, as a result of the ten-year on-going Greek economic crisis.
However, the forest is regarded as of vital importance, because of its contribution to the quality of
urban life: the micro-climate of the Thessaloniki’s urban area is strongly and positively affected by
the forest; it contributes to flood protection; it offers recreational activities; it offers a pleasant
landscape, etc. The paper describes how the questionnaire has been formed in order to seek for reliable
answers; how the survey has been organized, designed and implemented; and how the results have
been critically assessed, in order to reach to safer conclusions on the WTP answer. General
conclusions may be reached on the successfulness of organizing WTP surveys during the Greek
economic crisis, by comparing the results of a similar survey conducted some years before this crisis.
Keywords: Contingent valuation method, Seich-Sou suburban forest, Willingness to pay,
Questionnaire survey
1.
INTRODUCTION
Suburban forest areas are of vital importance, since they strongly affect positively many parameters
of the quality of life of urban areas inhabitants: they are close to urban areas, contributing, thus, to
enlarge the surface of green space in the built environment; they are visited by many inhabitants,
usually for walking, and other purposes related to sports and light recreation activities, covering such
needs and offering a better quality for their body and mind; they may decrease levels of atmospheric
pollution, noise pollution and they create better micro-climate conditions for the near-by urban area;
1047
Environmental law and economics
they have an educational role, offering the opportunity for schools excursions and students visits;
they contribute positively to better relations between different groups and stakeholders in urban
societies; and in some cases, they enhance touristic activities, thus, offering opportunities for income
increase of local people. Suburban forests usually form better urban landscapes and affect real estate
and housing prices in areas next to green spaces. The contribution of suburban forests to the quality
of life in urban areas should also be taken into consideration under the parameter that by 2025, around
3 billion people will be living in cities, while in Hellas, more than 60% of total population already
lives in cities and towns of more than 10,000 inhabitants, according to the population census of 2011
of the Hellenic Statistical Authority. In several USA cities relevant research has estimated in
monetary expression the economic costs of measures to decrease atmospheric pollution that are not
implemented, due to the existence of such forest areas or economic benefits or the economic benefits
from measures that are not needed, in order to prevent soil erosion or the economic benefits that are
gained in energy consumption for heating and cooling, due to better micro-climate conditions, etc.
[1]. In this paper the results of a questionnaire survey are presented, which was conducted by using
the Contingent Valuation Method, in order to investigate on the economic value of the suburban forest
of Thessaloniki, Seich-Sou. The paper includes a brief description of the most important
characteristics of the area of study, some details on the questionnaire survey design and
implementation, and finally, the results of the survey with useful comments on the quality and
reliability of the survey and its results.
2.
ENVIRONMENTAL VALUATION BY ECONOMIC TECHNIQUES
Environmental valuation by economists is focused on how to place a monetary value on goods and
bads arising from changes that take place within the natural environment and affect environmental
quality or the available stocks of some natural resources, which impact on the utility or well-being of
individuals. Τhe total value of a change in environmental goods is considered to be the sum of the
values of its effects on individuals, while different kinds of impact can be compared and some
quantity of money can always act as a substitute for some quantity of an environmental good; and
finally, environmental goods of equal value can be substituted for each other with no loss of welfare.
In order to determine the Total Economic Value (TEV) of a resource, use values and non-use values
need to be captured by valuation techniques [2]. Use values may be subdivided to actual use values
and option values, with the former reflecting the benefits that result from the direct contact with the
natural resource and the latter expressing a preference, ‘a willingness to pay’, for the preservation of
an environmental asset against the probability that the individual will make use of it. On the contrary,
non-use values or else existence values, correspond to those benefits that do not imply direct contact
between the consumers and the good, and they derive from the knowledge that a particular good exists
[3], [4]. Finally, the TEV of an environmental asset is obtained by summing up actual use value,
option value and existence value. The economic techniques available for environmental valuation can
be divided into three groups: conventional market approaches; constructed market approaches; and
implicit market approaches. These groups are subdivided into actual behavior-based techniques,
potential behavior-based techniques and other techniques. Conventional market approaches seek to
establish a link between an environmental impact and some other good that already has a market
value. Implicit market techniques assume that the behavior of individuals reveals implicit valuations
of features of the environment: wages accepted to work in locations with different levels of
environmental quality, prices or rents paid for properties that have particular levels of environmental
amenities or costs associated with specific activities, such as recreational trips. In constructed market,
the most widely approach used is the contingent valuation method (CVM), which uses a direct
approach – some form of questionnaire – in order to ask people what they are willing to pay (WTP)
for an environmental benefit or willing to accept (WTA) in compensation for a loss [5].
The CVM, used in the research presented in this paper, is especially used in environmental costbenefit (CBA) and impact assessment (EIA). However, it is suggested that WTP is better than WTA
and it should be used in CV studies, although in developing countries, EIA Studies deal with the
1048
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
negative environmental effects of a proposed project and thus, WTA compensation is considered a
more appropriate measure [6]. The popularity of the method may be attributed mainly to two factors:
firstly, it does not require any great amount of data that is usually necessary for other techniques; and
secondly, it can be applied in a great variety of goods and services, including use and non-use values.
However, the CVM is not a panacea: the questionnaire response is not appropriate to the respondents
who are ignorant of the object of preservation interest; respondents may not imagine the same product
as questioners think they are offering; the scenario suggested for paying for the product (the ‘payment
vehicle’) may not be believable; and finally, there may not be incentives for respondents to answer
truthfully [7]. Thus, Carson et al. believe that the CVM survey results should not draw attention to
the final economic result, by a direct economic interpretation, unless the environmental good that is
valued, is clearly explained to the respondents, its delivery to the public is acceptable and a realistic
scenario of payment is created [8]. Since the 1990s, the CVM has been widely implemented as a
valuation tool for environmental goods and services e.g. the World Bank has commissioned CVM
studies through its WASH (Water for Sanitation and Health) program to measure people’s WTP for
water projects in developing countries. Valuations of benefits from air quality improvements have
also been estimated using CVM; some argue that the CVM is particularly useful for valuing visibility
improvements at national parks or assessing ecological benefits, such as preserving endangered
species, where existence value is likely to be significant [4].
The accuracy of the CVM is not easy to define and a number of problems, known as systematic biases,
appear leading to unreliable or inaccurate bids or responses [6]:
3.
WTP seems to be the most appropriate measure for gainers and WTA the proper measure for
losers, assuming that it is easy to identify gainers and losers, and consequently.
Strategic bias appears when the respondents on purpose misrepresent their true WTP or WTA,
in order to manipulate the results of the survey, for example to generate high values. Several
studies conclude that strategic bias is not a significant problem because it can be ameliorated
by proper survey design. Sometimes respondents are not WTP for goods because they
anticipate enjoying them without payment (the free-rider problem).
The final value obtained in a survey is strongly influenced by the form of questioning (design
bias). The question posed could be a single closed-format question or it could be an iterative
bidding process or a continuous open-ended bid. The final value is also influenced by the
starting point bias when the interviewer suggests some amount of money.
The ‘vehicle’ or instrument of payment bias is referred to the form or method of payment by
which the bids offered by respondents will be collected (e.g. changes in taxes, entrance fees,
extra charges on bills, higher prices on goods, etc.). Studies show that WTP may be higher
with payroll taxes compared with increased entrance fees.
The information bias refers to the level of information about the environmental good under
evaluation, which is given to the respondents. Studies, such as Hoehn and Randall, reveal the
strong relation between resource quality information and contingent values [9].
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE CVM IN SEICH-SOU ENVIRONMENTAL
VALUATION
3.1 The area of study
The Seich-Sou suburban forest of Thessaloniki is located in the northeast of the city, sometimes
adjacent to the urban limit (Figure 1), and it took its current form, as an artificial forest, in the 1930s,
when a major reforestation project took place, mostly with pine trees, in an area of 3.000 hectares.
Historical sources mention that from the establishment of Thessaloniki around the year 315 b.C. by
Kassandros, king of Macedonia after Alexander the Great, rich forest areas existed all around today’s
urban area; however, during the Byzantine Empire and the Ottoman Empire, the forest areas gradually
1049
Environmental law and economics
disappeared, as wood was needed for several purposes. And since the hilly area northeast of
Thessaloniki includes many springs and streams, the reforestation project that started in the 1930s
contributed also to the protection of the urban area from flooding. During the period of 1931-1953,
around two million of small trees (90% of them were pine trees) were used for the reforestation
project; simultaneously, the first flood defense projects were constructed. In 1973, by the Prefectural
Decision 2193/9-10-1973, the area of Seich-Sou was declared as forest protection area. In the summer
of 1997 a fire destroyed almost 55% of the total forest area, but nowadays, the signs show that the
forest is recovering, while some more flood defense projects were constructed, in order to avoid soil
erosion in the parts of the forest that were affected by the fire. The natural environment of the forest
involves 277 species of flora, 18 species of fauna, 95 bird species and 21 species of reptiles. The
surface water network comprises 17 small streams, with basins from 0.4 to 5.6 km2 and mean slope
of the basins from 8% to 16%.
Figure 1: The Seich-Sou is next to the city border, while part of the city by-pass was
constructed inside the forest area (green and yellow colors express levels of altitude)
The last 10 years, in the period of Hellenic economic crisis, many problems arose for the condition
of the Seich-Sou suburban forest: increased possibility for fire, mostly due to many wastes, disposed
all-round the forest area by irresponsible visitors, while wastes collection services were weakened;
illegal wastewater disposal in few streams; illegal wood cutting for heating purposes; and finally,
pine processionary caterpillars reflect a great danger for trees, as they form many nests, while there
is almost no funding, in order to spray with appropriate airplanes. Therefore, there is an urgent need
to find the necessary funds, so as to implement a program towards forest restoration and protection.
As all these parameters are well-known to many citizens of Thessaloniki, it was an opportunity to
conduct surveys and investigate on their WTP, in order to ameliorate the Seich-Sou and thus, relate
this WTP to the value of the forest.
1050
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.2 Questionnaire survey planning, design and implementation
In order to conduct a questionnaire survey, there is a need to: define the aims of the survey and how
the results will be used; design the necessary research methods and techniques; develop the survey
instrument; select people to be approached (target groups); assemble the questionnaire package (how
the survey questions look, the sections of the questionnaire and type of questions); conduct the survey;
and, finally, process and report the survey results [10]. While constructing the questionnaire used in
the survey, the following elements were considered: the shorter the questionnaire is, the higher the
response rate; specific questions are better than general ones; and closed questions force people to
choose among offered alternatives, instead of answering in their own words, but they are more
specific and therefore, more apt to communicate the same frame of reference to all respondents. The
contingent valuation scenario should be also short, realistic and simple. As mentioned by Converse
and Presser, the two main advantages of specificity are a more precise communication of question
intent and an aid for the respondent to recall [11]. To sum up with, closed questions produce answers
that can be meaningfully compared as well as less variable answers, they are easier to be answered
and finally, they produce answers that are easier to computerize, analyse and process. However,
closed questions may also produce problems associated with recording responses, as the interviewer
may record answers inaccurately or even neglect to read all of the response options [12]. The order
of question sequence is also very important: the questionnaire must be attractive to the respondent,
avoid putting ideas into the respondent’s mind early in the interview and the first questions seem to
be crucial in order to “hook” the respondent into answering the survey. Apparently, the first questions
should be intriguing (perhaps asking for an opinion on an interesting topic), easy to answer, general
and impersonal [11, 13].
200 hundred interviews were conducted in June 2014, with 120 respondents that were visitors and
were found and interviewed in the forest, and 80 respondents, inhabitants of Pefka, which is a suburb
of Thessaloniki, a town of 13,000 inhabitants, the closest community to the Seich-Sou. The reason to
conduct the survey also in Pefka was the available information that although this suburb is adjacent
to the forest, the interaction between the forest and the urban area is poor. The respondents were
asked questions related to their relation with the forest (how often they visit it, for which reasons,
how much time they spend, their knowledge about the degradation problems facing the forest), their
WTP in order to raise funding to support forest protection and restoration, and finally, some personal
information, related to their annual income, their education level, their age, their profession, etc. The
questionnaire involved 18 questions, all of them closed and semi-closed.
3.3 The results of the survey
The results of the CVM survey are presented in the following paragraphs, separately for visitors
interviewed in the forest and inhabitants of Pefka suburban town:
25% of Pefka inhabitants visit often the forest (more than seasonally often), while for the
Seich-Sou visitors this percentage is more than triple, 85%. In total, 61% of all respondents
visit the forest often. The main reasons for Pefka inhabitants for not visiting the forest often
are “lack of free time” (27%), “forest degradation” (27%), “other choices” (25%) and “no
combination to other activities” (10%).
The main reasons for visiting the forest by Pefka inhabitants are “recreational activities”
(36%), “sports/cycling” (30%) and “walking” (28.3%), while for visitors interviewed in the
forest the results reflect 28.3%, 13.3% and 41.7% respectively (in total 30.7%,18.5% and
37.6% respectively).
The two target groups of the questionnaire survey responded to the most important problems
that the forest was facing, leading to its degradation and the respondents replied “the absence
of organized sites for recreation” (26% – 27%), “safety of the forest” (22% – 30%), “no
maintenance of paths” (17% – 18%), “no organized sports facilities” (14% – 10%) and
1051
Environmental law and economics
“accessibility problems” (13% – 10%) – the first percentage in every parenthesis reflects
results from Pefka residents and the second from visitors in the forest.
The forest area is accessible to all respondents “on foot” (57%), “in car” (30%), “by bicycle”
(8.4%), “by bike” (2.6) and “by bus” (2%), showing that many visitors live nearby the forest
and when they live in a more distance, they travel in car, because there no buses serving
effectively the several entrances to the forest. This is why 65% of total visitors of the forest
travel up to 10 minutes to arrive to the forest, either on foot or in car.
The average time spent in the forest is, for the inhabitants of Pefka, “less than an hour” (59%)
or “2 – 3 hours” (41%), while for the visitors interviewed in the forest, “2 – 3 hours” (67.5%),
“more than 3 hours” (20%) and “less than an hour” (12.5%).
Figures 4 & 5: The frequency of visit to the forest, by Pefka inhabitants and visitors of SeichSou
The respondents were also asked to evaluate the benefits of Seich-Sou for Thessaloniki and
its inhabitants. Pefka inhabitants recognize the following benefits from the most important to
the less important: “flood protection”, “source of oxygen”, “better micro-climate”,
“recreation/sports”, “landscape”, “tourism” and “educational/scientific benefits”. For the
visitors interviewed in the forest, “source of oxygen”, “recreation/sports”, “flood protection”,
“landscape”, “better micro-climate”, “educational/scientific benefits” and “tourism”.
The respondents were asked to comment on the necessary projects for the forest protection
and restoration. For the Pefka inhabitants from the most important to the less important, the
projects are: “new recreation infrastructure”, “lighting”, “ensure safety”, “restoration of
paths”, “construction of WC”, “wastes collection”, “provision of freshwater and electricity”,
“more garbage bins” and “new sites for view appreciation”. For the respondents interviewed
in the forest, “more garbage bins”, “restoration of paths”, “construction of WC”, “new
recreation infrastructure”, “new sites for view appreciation”, “provision of freshwater and
electricity”, “ensure safety”, “wastes collection” and “lighting”.
Results for socioeconomic characteristics of total respondents are presented in Tables 2 and
3:
Table 2: Age of the respondents
The age of the respondents
Total
Classification of age
18-24
25-34
35-44
45-55
56-65
66 +
Number of responses
20
51
37
38
23
31
200
10,0%
25,5%
18,5%
19,0%
11,5%
15,5%
100%
Percentage
1052
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 3: Main profession of the respondents
Main profession
Type
profession
of
Number
responses
of
Total
Employee in
the private
sector
Employee in
the public
sector
Selfemployed
60
23
46
41
14
16
200
30,0%
11,5%
23,0%
20,5%
7,0%
8,0%
100%
Percentage
Retired Student Other
Table 4: Family annual income of the respondents
Annual family income
8.001- 16.001- 24.001- 32.001Classification of income <8.000€
>40.000€
16.000€ 24.000€ 32.000€ 40.000€
Number of responses
Percentage
Total
42
60
50
28
12
8
200
21,0%
30,0%
25,0%
14,0%
6,0%
4,0%
100%
The final and crucial question in the research was related to the WTP of the respondents, in order to
enhance protection and restoration of the Seich-Sou forest. Out of the 200 respondents in total, 104
were positive in financial contribution (52%), which is a typical percentage of positive response in
many CVM studies. However, the positive response percentage is much different between Pefka
inhabitants (37.5% - 30 positive answers out of 80 respondents) and respondents interviewed in the
forest (61.7% - 74 positive answers out of 120 respondents), which was expected, since as already
shown, Pefka inhabitants do not often visit the forest, do not spend so much time when they visit the
forest, etc. The average WTP was calculated to 5.07 € for the 104 total positive respondents, with the
average being 5.27 € for positive Pefka inhabitants and 4.99 € for positive respondents interviewed
in the forest. The answers to the willingness-to-pay question are presented in the following Table 5
and Figures 6 and 7:
Table 5: The WTP bids for positive Pefka inhabitants, respondents interviewed in the forest
and total respondents
Willingness-to-pay bids
Total
Bids in €
Number of
(Pefka)
responses
Percentage
Number
(forest)
5€
6
40.0% 20.0%
of
responses
Percentage
Total number of (positive)
responses
Percentage
2€
12
38
16
8€
0
0%
1
10 €
6
22
1
9
15
48.1% 21.2% 0.9% 14.4%
1053
>20 €
1
other
4
20.0% 3.33% 3.33% 13.33%
51.4% 21.6% 1.4% 12.2%
50
20 €
1
30
100%
2
2
6
74
2.7%
2.7%
8.0%
100%
3
3
10
104
2.9%
2.9%
9.6%
100%
Environmental law and economics
Figures 6 and 7: The WTP bids for positive Pefka inhabitants and respondents interviewed in
the forest
Furthermore, to those who were negative in WTP, responded for their reason of their denial: for Pefka
inhabitants 53% of the respondents mentioned that public authorities / the state should protect the
forest with economic funding from people’s taxes; 27.5% replied that they cannot afford it; and 17.7%
do not trust public authorities with financial management and they are suspicious of using the money
in the proper way for the forest protection and restoration. On the other hand, for respondents that
were interviewed in the forest, 43.4% replied that public authorities / the state should protect the
forest with economic funding from people’s taxes; 37.8% are suspicious on the effective financial
management for the protection of the forest; and 17% replied that they cannot afford it. Finally, to
those who were positive in WTP (total respondents), there was one more question about the
appropriate vehicle of payment and they replied that the best would be if all Thessaloniki inhabitants
become members of an environmental organization and pay a subscription there (64%), 20% believe
that they should pay an extra amount to the local municipality, 10.7% by a new environmental tax
and 4.9% of the respondents believe that people should buy tickets in the entrances of the forest.
3.4 Discussion
It is always a challenge in a WTP survey and research to conclude from the WTP bids that the results
and answers are reliable or not and exclude unreliable questionnaires from the final results of the
survey. Statistical analyses are not always the correct methodology, in order to investigate the issue
of reliability and research on the biases mentioned in paragraph 2 of the current paper. Such biases
are successfully dealt with the aid of some questions in the survey that are related on to each other;
consequently, their results can be examined together and compared for their reliability. For this
reason, in the present CVM survey, after the first results, further analysis was made, comparing results
of WTP with other answers e.g. in socioeconomic and other questions.
The WTP results are strongly correlated with the annual family income of the respondents. 30% of
the respondents replied that their annual family income was 8,001 – 16,000 €, 25% was 16,001 –
24,000 €, 14% was 24,001 – 32,000 €, etc. or 45% of the respondents replied 16,001 – 40,000 €, as
seen in Figure 8. Calculating the WTP of each group of family annual income, one would expect that
there is a certain ration between them, meaning that the more annual income is, the more could be the
WTP bid. The results are shown in Figure 9, but since there were only four respondents with more
than 40,000 € annual family income, these four questionnaires may be excluded from WTP results
and then Figure 10 can show better the relation between WTP and family annual income. From Figure
10 it may be concluded either that the average of 5 € for respondents with family annual income of
16,001 – 24,000 € is higher than ‘expected’ (4.50 € approximately) or the average of 4.80 € for
respondents with family income of 24,001 – 32,000 € is lower than ‘expected’ (5.40 € approximately).
1054
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 8: The annual family income of the respondents
Further analysis, as shown in Figure 11, reveals that WTP results, according to family annual income
of the respondents, are different for Pefka inhabitants than respondents interviewed in the forest. For
Pefka inhabitants it seems that WTP results are quite reliable, as it is shown that there is a certain
‘rational’ ratio between family annual income and WTP bids, except for respondents with annual
income of 16,000 – 24,000 € (2.85 € WTP, while the ‘proper’ would be around 5.30 €). On the
contrary, for respondents interviewed in the forest, it seems that WTP results may not correlate with
family annual income, since all averages were calculated between 4.10 € and 4.60 €, while the average
of 5.75 € for respondents with family annual income 16,001 – 24,000 € may be unreliable. Another
possible explanation could be that replies of respondents interviewed in the forest, with family annual
income of less than 16,000 € were more optimistic in WTP bids, as they are visitors of the forest, they
really need to help financially with forest protection and restoration, and they also realize that the
whole questionnaire survey is just theory and the WTP question is completely hypothetical. All these
comments are based on the assumption that respondents are honest while answering about their family
annual income.
Figures 9 and 10: The WTP results, according to the family annual income (FAI) of the
respondents, and again the results, after excluding the four respondents with FAI of more
than 40,000 €
1055
Environmental law and economics
Figure 11: The WTP results, according to the family annual income of the respondents of
Pefka inhabitants and respondents interviewed in the forest
Comparing WTP averages, according to the educational status of the respondents, it seems that the
more educated they are, the bigger is the WTP bid, which seems reasonable, since it could be
generally stated that people with better educational status may have a bigger family annual income
or they can realize better the usefulness of the Seich-Sou. Results are shown in Figure 12: the relation
between WTP and education seems ‘linear’ for the first three groups, while WTP results become
much higher for the respondents with postgraduate studies.
Figure 12: The WTP results, according to the educational status of the respondents
Finally, the WTP results were correlated with the frequency of visits of the respondents, while it
would be expected that the more often they visit the forest, the higher would be the WTP bid. In
Figure 13 results are presented for all the respondents and it could be concluded that for daily visitors
and seasonally often visitors one would expect higher WTP bids than the averages calculated.
Looking at WTP results for Pefka inhabitants and the respondents interviewed in the forest, as
presented in Figure 14, it seems that for Pefka inhabitants’ replies are more reliable, with the only
exception of the average of ‘seasonally often’ visitors. On the other hand, WTP averages of the
respondents interviewed in the forest seem that they are not in a linear relation with visit frequency.
If it is assumed that often visitors were more honest, then the average of seasonally rarely visitors is
higher than expected and the average of daily visitors is much lower than expected.
1056
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figures 13 and 14: The WTP results, according to the visit frequency of all respondents, and
again the results, separately for Pefka inhabitants and respondents interviewed in the forest.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
The WTP questionnaire survey for the suburban forest of Thessaloniki – Seich-Sou – was a pilot
survey, addressed to 200 respondents in total, 80 Pefka inhabitants and 120 respondents interviewed
in the forest. WTP results were calculated and further analysis was made, correlating WTP averages
with other parameters and more specifically, with the annual income of the respondents, the
educational status and the visit frequency. In some cases, some WTP averages seem to lack reliability,
but generally, the WTP survey overall could be characterized by success and reliability, especially if
it is taken into consideration that the interviews were conducted with the aid of a postgraduate student
of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki who has none experience in surveys and the project was
not funded. To summarize, the following comments may interpret some of the results of the survey:
The WTP question was quite vague, because it did not clarify if the WTP bid was monthly,
yearly or just once, because of an emergency situation, related to lack of funding by the Region
of Central Macedonia, in order to support protection and restoration of the forest Seich-Sou.
A vague WTP question may lead to higher WTP bids and higher averages. On the other hand,
this might be one reason why daily and seasonally often visitors are willing to pay less than
other categories of respondents, because they may have understood that they would pay every
time they visit the forest.
The WTP question did not mention any specific ‘vehicle of payment’ e.g. an increase in the
municipal taxes paid through the electricity power bill, and this absence make the interviewers
think of the WTP question as completely hypothetical and so for this reason again, their
answers may result in higher WTP bids than they were really willing to pay.
Pefka inhabitants were not so positive to support financially the forest for its protection and
restoration, because as it had been already known, the access from the town of Pefka to the
forest was very difficult and still is, consequently, they are not so often visitors and this is
why the positive response percentage for WTP was 37.5% for them and 61.7% for respondents
interviewed in the forest.
The WTP survey was conducted in the middle of 2014, with Hellas being for the fifth year in
economic crisis, with many families losing even more than 50% of their annual income, and
with a high percentage of unemployment, almost 30%, rising to 50% for young people at the
age of 25 – 35 years old.
1057
Environmental law and economics
Finally, if the WTP survey was to be repeated, it would be better to focus only on respondents
interviewed in the forest and not to any Pefka inhabitants, as they seem not to have a strong
relation to the forest, which is adjacent to the suburban town, but with not an easy access. And
the WTP question would be more specific referring to the ‘vehicle of payment’ and the
frequency of payment e.g. monthly, yearly, occasionally, etc.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors are grateful for the assistance given by Mrs E. Zoura, Forester AUTh, MSc in Water
Resources, particularly with her assistance in the interviews of the survey.
References
1. Kalavrytinos N. and D. Damigos. (2006). ‘The economic value of urban green spaces in Attica
Basin.’ Technika Chronika Scientific Journal of the Technical Chamber of Greece, vol. II,
no. 1-2, pp. 7-21 (in Hellenic with extended summary in English).
2. Edwards-Jones G., Davies, B. and S. Hussain. (2000). ‘Ecological Economics-An
Introduction.’ Blackwell Science Ltd.
3. Pearce D.W. and R.K. Turner. (1990). ‘Economics of natural resources and the environment.’
Harvester Wheatsheaf.
4. Callan S.J. and J.M. Thomas. (1996). ‘Environmental Economics and Management-Theory.
Policy and Applications.’ Irwin.
5. Munasinghe M.C. (1993). ‘Environmental Economics and Sustainable Development.’ World
Bank Environment Paper No 3, The World Bank, Washington DC.
6. Venkatachalam L. (2004). ‘The contingent valuation method: a review.’ Environmental Impact
Assessment Review, vol. 24, pp. 89-124.
7. Price C. (2000). ‘Valuation of unpriced products: contingent valuation, cost-benefit analysis and
participatory democracy.’ Land Use Policy, vol. 17, pp. 187-196.
8. Carson R.T., Flores N.E. and N.F. Meade. (2001). ‘Contingent valuation: controversies and
evidence.’ Environmental and Resource Economics, vol. 19, pp. 173-210.
9. Hoehn J.P. and A. Randall. (2002). ‘The effect of resource quality information on resource injury
perceptions and contingent values.’ Resource and Energy Economics, vol. 24, pp. 13-31.
10. Oppenheim A.N. (1966). ‘Questionnaire Design and Attitude Measurement.’ First ed.,
Heinemann, London.
11. Converse J. and S. Presser. (1986). ‘Survey Questions – Handcrafting the Standardized
Questionnaire.’ SAGE Publications.
12. Foddy W. (1993). ‘Constructing Questions for Interviews and Questionnaires – Theory and
Practice in Social Research.’ First ed., Cambridge University Press.
13. Suckie L.A. (1992). ‘Questionnaire Survey Research: What Works.’ Association for
Institutional Research, Florida.
1058
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
APPLYING A CONTINGENT VALUATION METHOD (CVM) FOR
THE PRESERVATION /RESTORATION OF THREE LAKES IN
NORTHERN GREECE
Odysseas N. Kopsidas*
Department of Industrial Management & Technology, University of Piraeus, 80 Karaoli &
Dimitriou, GR 18534 Piraeus, Greece,
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: odykopsi@yahoo.gr, +30 6974964415
Abstract
The preservation/restoration of natural environment is usually entailing high cost mostly paid by
citizens through taxes. The effect of these taxes is double. The direct effect is the obvious additional
income for the State, and the indirect effect is an additional income for the citizen, due to increasing
tourism. Since the evaluation of this good cannot be in market terms, we apply a modified Contingent
Valuation Method (CVM), which is part of Experimental Economics, in order to find out the order
of concern that people have about natural environment. We also, try to investigate their willingness
to pay (WTP) for supporting activities for preservation/restoration of three lakes in Northern Greece,
in particular, lake of Ioannina, lake of Florina and lake of Kastoria. For the purpose of this research,
we use parametric and non-parametric approaches, as well as Linear Regression and Logic Models.
Keywords: Valuation Method (CVM), Natural Environment, Willingness to pay (WTP), Logit
Model, Linear Regression, Parametric and Non-Parametric Approaches.
1.
INTRODUCTION
Wetlands –and especially lakes– are the most productive ecosystems in the world. They support
plenty of ecological activities and important natural habitats. These ecological activities translate
strictly into economic functions and services such as flood protection, water supply, improved water
quality, commercial and recreational fishing and hunting (Barbier et al., 1997; Woodward and Wui,
2001; Brouwer et al., 1999; Brander et al., 2006).Although, it is a common knowledge that the
multiple role of wetlands is usually biased towards the economics benefit from commercial use and
exploitation. Usually, the natural benefits of wetlands are underestimated, and the order of
exploitation is so high that leads to the extensive degradation (Fog &Lampio, 1982). Despite the
uncertainty in total area of wetlands around the world, there are some figures indicating the
importance of the problem. In Europe, 50% to 60% of wetlands have been lost in past century due
to the human intervention, while the United States have lost 54% of its original wetlands (Barbier et
al., 1997). The accelerated rate of wetlands loss was a great alarm for many countries and scientists
around the world to take care of the situation. In 1971, more than100 countries created the Ramsar
Convention of Wetlands of International Importance, providing the first step for a greater
international cooperation about the protection and the “wise use” of wetlands and their resources
(Ramsar, 1996). The increasing number of valuation studies on environmental sector contributes
evidence about the importance of wetlands. Kazmierczak (2001) and Boyer and Polasky (2004)
provide a variety of studies which include many valuation methods, such as Contingent Valuation
Method (CVM), replacement value method etc. Woodward and Wui (2001) use 39 wetlands
valuation studies to create a meta-analysis using CV method. Brouwer et al. (1999) also created a
1059
Environmental law and economics
meta-analysis of 30 CV applications. A few years later, Brander et al. (2006) made a meta-analysis
using 190 wetlands valuation studies.
Despite the fact that there is a great international scientific concern about the restoration and
protection of wetlands, in Greece there are only a few studies. Kontogianni et al. (2001) used CVM
to evaluate stakeholders’ preferences among four possible hypothetical scenarios for a wetland in
Lesvos Island. Another CV research by Psychoudakis et al. (2005) estimates the use values of
ecological functions of Zazari-Cheimadidita wetland. In present study, we are using CVM to valuate
three wetlands in Greece. In particular, we are investigating the willingness to pay (WTP) of local
citizens to preservation/restoration of three lakes in Northern Greece, lake of Ioannina (lake
Pamvotida), lake of Kastoria (lake Orestiada) and lake of Florina (lake Cheimaditida). This research
is organized in five sections. The first section is the introduction and previous relative works. In
section 2, we present some information about each lake, which leads us to this research. In section 3,
we present the data and the empirical analysis of the research. Last but not least, in section 4 there
are the conclusions, while the bibliography takes place in section 5.
2.
KNOWING THE LAKES
2.1 Lake of Florina (Lake Cheimaditida)
Cheimaditida is a lake of northern Greece, located 40km south of the prefecture of Florina. It is one
of the lakes formed among the mountains of Verno, Voras, Askio and Vermio. Among these
mountains, there are some more wetlands, like Lake Vegoritida, Lake Zazari etc. Cheimaditida’s
surface is around 10.8 squared km, its maximum length is 6.3km and it is located in an altitude of
593m. Its average depth is 1 meter and the maximum is 2.5m. The water quality of Lake
Cheimaditida is affected by household waste of the adjacent nine communities. Apart from this
pollution, the quality of lake water is affected by livestock waste from animals, which are breeding
around. However, the critical pollution factor is the excessive use of fertilizers and pesticides in crops,
which end up in lake through ground dismantling. The level of Lake Cheimaditida has been
dramatically reduced in recent decades, mainly due to irrigation, with adverse effects on the flora and
fauna of the area. The Greek Biotope-Wetlands Center investigated the concern of local citizens
(farmers, fishermen and local authorities) about the problem. The results declared the willingness of
the citizens to pay for the restoration of the lake.
2.2 Lake of Kastoria (Lake Orestiada)
Lake of Kastoria, Orestiada, is located in Western Macedonia in western part of Kastoria Prefecture,
northeast, east and southeast of the town of Kastoria and between the aerias of Verno, Aschi, Korissos
and Vigla. Orestiada’s surface is around 28 squared km and located at an altitude of 630m.
Orestiada’s average depth is around 3.5 meters and the maximum depth is 9.5 meters. The coast
length is about 31km. The water of the lake comes mainly from streams. In the area, there are nine
streams leading to the lake. The largest of these is the stream of Xiropotamos. In addition to streams,
rain water and snowfall, Lake Orestiada is also fed by many lush springs. Orestiada is an urban lake
with intense human activity over the last decades, due to the threat of ecological balance of the area
which is polluted by urban waste water, sewage effluents, fertilizers and solid waste. In Orestiada,
the eutrophication phenomenon is intense, with all its negative effects on the quality of its water. The
water of the lake, as the ultimate recipient of all natural processes, as well as the human activities, is
constantly receiving loads of nutrients and other components and, in particular, phosphorus charges.
According to results of a study which took place in lake of Kastoria (Mantzafleri et al., 2009), when
the lake freezes perhaps every year, there is a decrease in oxygen and in the summer an increase in
pollution due to agricultural activities.
2.3 Lake of Ioannina (Lake Pamvotida)
Lake of Ioannina, Lake Pamvotida, is located in the north-western part of Greece at an altitude of
470 meters above the sea level and is perhaps one of the rare cases, where a lake has been connected
1060
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
so much to the history and like of a city, Ioannina. The lake is 7.5km long, 1,5 − 5 km wide, has
average depth 4 − 5meters, maximum depth 11 meters and surface around 22.8 squared km. It is
surrounded by the Mitsikeli and Tomaros mountains and it is formed by water of three main springs.
The drainage of the water takes place through the Lapista ditch and flows from the river Kalamas.
The pollution of the natural environment of Lake Pamvotida and mainly of the lake’s waterderives
from human activities related to the city of Ioannina, small and large communities and residential
areas located around, as well as the industrial output. The main source of pollution of the lake is urban
and industrial waste water, as well as the waste of a large number of poultry farms, pig farms and
cheese dairies in the area, many of which are illegal. Around 75%of the output of these farms is
transferred indirectly to the lake resulting a crucial pollution to the water.
3.
DATA AND EMPIRICAL RESULTS
3.1 Data
In order to investigate the willingness to pay (WTP) of the citizens around each lake, we collected
three random samples from each town (Ioannina, Florina, Kastoria) and we asked them to complete
some questionnaires. We collected 60 questionnaires from citizens of Florina, 90 questionnaires from
citizens of Ioannina and 80 questionnaires from citizens of Kastoria. The main question we asked on
each interviewee is the amount of money that he/she is willing to pay per month in order to restore
the lake of his/her town. We also asked their opinion about the lake and their living distance from the
lake. A list of variables which were tested is the following.
𝑿𝟏 :
𝑿𝟐 :
𝑿𝟑 :
𝑿𝟒 :
𝑿𝟓 :
𝑿𝟔 :
𝑿𝟕 :
𝑿𝟖 :
𝑿𝟗 :
𝑿𝟏𝟎 :
𝑿𝟏𝟏 :
𝑿𝟏𝟐 :
𝑿𝟏𝟑 :
𝑿𝟏𝟒 :
𝑿𝟏𝟓 :
𝑿𝟏𝟔 :
𝑿𝟏𝟕 :
𝑿𝟏𝟖 :
𝑿𝟏𝟗 :
𝑿𝟐𝟎 :
𝑿𝟐𝟏 :
𝑿𝟐𝟐 :
𝑿𝟐𝟑 :
𝑿𝟐𝟒 :
𝑿𝟐𝟓 :
𝑿𝟐𝟔 :
𝑿𝟐𝟕 :
𝑿𝟐𝟖 :
Table 1: List of Variables
Visiting the lake
Way of information about the lake condition
Ecological condition of the lake
Main problem of the lake
Reason of the ecological problem
Authorities’ concern about the lake
Membership of an ecological organization
Local authorities participation every 100 euro
People participation every 100 euro
What do you wish to be done?
Willingness to pay for the restoration (WTP)
Willingness to pay for the restoration if you were living next to the lake (WTP1)
What do you want to restore first?
Amount of money that you would accept in order not to restore the lake (WTA)
Industries
Gender
Age
Living
Heritage close to the lake
Working around the lake
Distance from the lake
Working condition
Work relative to the lake
Marital status
Members of the family
Education level
Income according to citizen in Northern Greece
Income according to citizen of the town
1061
Environmental law and economics
The above table shows the variables of the model. In this model, the WTA is the dependent variable
and the others are independent variables. So, the WTA is estimated as a function of all these variables.
3.2 Empirical Results
In the first part of the analysis we present some descriptive statistics about citizens’ willing to pay in
each town. In Table1, we present the descriptive statistics for WTP.
Table 2: Descriptive Statistic for WTP of the citizens of each town
Mean
Standard Deviation
Range
Min
Ioannina
1.99
0.772
Kastoria
13.16
11.221
50
Florina
8.22
12.356
50
Max
On the one hand, descriptive statistics provide evidence that citizens of Kastoria are willing to pay
more for the restoration of the lake. On the other hand, citizens of Ioannina are willing to pay far less
for the restoration of their lake.
In the next part of the analysis we estimate a linear regression model with dependent variable 𝑋11
(WTP). One of the main supposes of linear regression is the absence of multi-collinearity between
the independent variables. In order to examine the existence or absence of multi-collinearity we
estimate a Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) test in SPSS. From this test we observe that 𝑋17 and
𝑋22have VIF-value higher than. In order to solve this problem, we choose to exclude 𝑋17 from the
model. Then we estimate the linear model with remain variables for each lake and the results can be
observed in Table 3.
Table 3: Linear Regression Model for each lake
Town
Linear Regression Model
Ioannina
𝑋11 = 0.195 ∗ 𝑋4 + 0.349 ∗ 𝑋6 − 0.174 ∗ 𝑋10 − 0.595 ∗ 𝑋12
Kastoria
𝑋11 = 1.164 − 0.279 ∗ 𝑋9 + 0.82 ∗ 𝑋12 − 0.147 ∗ 𝑋14 − 0.173 ∗ 𝑋19 + 0.113 ∗ 𝑋28
Florina
𝑋11 = 0.743 + 0.222 ∗ 𝑋7 − 0.322 ∗ 𝑋9 + 0.581 ∗ 𝑋12 − 0.174 ∗ 𝑋19
Note 1: The coefficients which were not statistically significant are excluded from the models.
Note 2: Coefficients were examined in 5% level of significance.
Table 3 provides evidence that only few variables can affect the WTP of the local citizens. Some
variable were found statistical significant in every model and some variables only in one model. This
happens because every area in Greece has its own particularities. In the next step of the analysis, we
made a Variance analysis (ANOVA) of each model, in order to examine if there is a good adaptation
of the theoretical model. The results of each model are presented in Table 4 below.
Town
Kastoria
Ioannina
Florina
Table 4: ANOVA for every model of each town
Sum of
Mean
Model
Df
F statistic
Squares
Square
Regression
36.408
19
1.916
19.851
Residual
5.792
60
0.097
Total
42.200
79
Regression
39.670
25
1.587
7.625
Residual
13.319
64
0.208
Total
52.989
89
Regression
39.421
19
2.075
4.762
Residual
17.429
40
0.436
Total
56.850
59
1062
Sig
0.000∗
0.000∗
0.000∗
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
As it is observed in the last column of table 4 the 𝑝 −value of 𝐹 −statistic in each model in lower
than 0.05, which means that all models have good adaptation to the theoretical model. This is
powerful evidence that our research is steady and our results are valid. The R2 factors for Kastoria,
Ioannina and Florina are 0.863, 0.789 and 0.765 respectively.
In the last step of analysis is the estimation of a logit model for every model (one for each lake). First,
we estimate the fitting of each model by the logit fitting information test, the results of which are
presented in Table.
Town
Kastoria
Ioannina
Florina
Table 5: Logit Model Fitting Information
−𝟐Log
Model
Chi-square
Df
Likelihood
Intercept
175.04
Only
Final
0.000
175.049
19
Intercept
199.351
Only
Final
76.177
123.174
24
Intercept
152.153
Only
Final
78.925
73.228
19
Sig
0.000∗
0.000∗
0.000∗
As it is observed in the last column of the table 5 the fit of the models are statistically significant
while the 𝑝 −value of all three tests is lower than 0.05, which means that the results of the logit
estimation will be valid. In any case the binary dependent variable is WTA.
In Table 6 below, we can see the results of the logit model (we show only the statistically significant
variables). The provided model is a function of nonlinear regression analysis. Especially it is used the
Logit model which is located in logistic models of regression analysis. In this model the dependent
variable is the WTA and all the others are independent.
Town
Kastoria
Ioannina
Florina
Table 6: Logit estimation result
Variable affect WTP (sign)
𝑋12 (+), 𝑋13 (+), 𝑋14 (−), 𝑋19 (+)
𝑋1 (−), 𝑋4 (+), 𝑋6 (+), 𝑋10 (−), 𝑋12 (+), 𝑋15 (+)
𝑋10 (−), 𝑋12 (+), 𝑋24 (−)
According to Table 6, we can say for example for Kastoria, that if the citizens live next to the
lake(𝑋12 ), the possibility to pay is higher, while the same possibility is also higher if the citizens have
heritage next to the lake (𝑋19 ). On the other hand, the possibility to pay is lower if a good amount of
money is offered to them in order to ignore the degradation of the lake (𝑋14 ). Similar results are
excluded for each town.
4.
CONCLUSION
According to the results of the empirical analysis we can separate the conclusion in three different
sections, each for every lake. About the lake of Kastoria, Orestiada, we found that the citizens are
able to play higher amount of money for the restoration of the lake, while they believe that the
protection of the lake is a crucial subject. The same willingness to pay is increased if the citizen lives
close to the lake, if the amount of money that would get as compensation is decreased, if he/she has
heritage next to the lake and if his/her income is higher than the average of the local community.
1063
Environmental law and economics
About the lake of Ioannina, Pamvotida, we found that a citizen’s willingness to pay is increased if
he/she visits the lake very often, if he/she believes that the appearance of the lake is awful, if he/she
thinks that the local authorities are not able to take care of the problem and if he/she lives close to the
lake.
Finally, about the lake of Florina, Cheimaditida, we also found that a citizen’s volition to pay for the
preservation/restoration of the lake is increased, while the ecological condition of the lake is really
bad. The same willingness to pay is also increased if the citizen lives close to the lake and if the
citizen is married.
According to the results above, we cannot ignore the fact that those three important wetlands of
Greece are degraded. Citizens who live next to those lakes declare to pay higher in order to restore
the lake. This is evidence about the condition around these lakes. It is important to mention that there
are different parameters that affect the citizens’ willingness to pay in every town. This is a normal
fact because of the very different situation and living conditions in every town resulting to different
requirements of local people. Last but not least, is the social dimension which appears in Florina,
because if the citizen declares “married”, is willing to pay higher in order to restore the lake. It is
probably a future concern because he/she wants his/her children to grow up in more healthy and
beautiful environment. This study is about three big wetlands of Greece. It should be a part of a
greater project about environmental protection which has to be supported by every single citizen and
all authorities because the environmental pollution may lead to the human extinction.
References
1. Barbier, E. B., Acreman, M. C. and Knowler, D. (1997). ‘Economic valuation of wetlands’: A
guide for policy makers and planners. Ramsar Convention Bureau, Gland, Switzerland.
2. Boyer, T. and Polasky, S. (2004). ‘Valuing urban wetlands’: A review of non-market valuation
studies.Wetlands, 24(4), pp.744-755.
3. Brander, L., Florax, R. and Vermaat, J. (2006). ‘The Empirics of Wetland Valuation’: A
Comprehensive Summary and a Meta-Analysis of the Literature. Environmental & Resource
Economics, 33(2), pp.223-250.
4. Brouwer, R., Langford, I., Bateman, I. and Turner, R. (1999). ‘A meta-analysis of wetland
contingent valuation studies’. Regional Environmental Change, 1(1), pp.47-57.
5. Fog, J., Lampio, T., Rooth, J. and Smart, M. (1982). ‘Managing Wetlands and Their Birds’.
International waterfowl Research Bureau, Slimbridge, England.
6. Kazmierczak, R.F. (2001). ‘Economic linkages between coastal wetlands and hunting and
fishing’: a review of value estimates reported in the published literature. Louisiana State
University Agricultural Center, Baton Rouge, Staff Paper 2001-03.
7. Kontogianni, A., Skourtos, M., Langford, I., Bateman, I. and Georgiou, S. (2001). ‘Integrating
stakeholder analysis in non-market valuation of environmental assets’. Ecological
Economics, 37(1), pp.123-138.
8. Mantzafleri, N., Psilovikos, A. and Blanta, A. (2009). ‘Water Quality Monitoring and
Modeling in Lake Kastoria, Using GIS’. Assessment and Management of Pollution
Sources.Water Resources Management, 23(15), pp.3221-3254.
9. Psychoudakis, A., Ragkos, A. andSeferlis, M. (2005). ‘An assessment of wetland management
scenarios’: the case of Zazari–Cheimaditida, Greece. Water Supply 5(6), pp.115–123.
10. Ramsar, (1996). ‘Wetlands, Biodiversity and the Ramsar Convention’: IUCN Publications
Services Unit, 219c Huntingdon Road Cambridge CB3 0DL UK. 196 pp. 1996.
11. Woodward, R. T., and Wui, Y. S. (2001). ‘The economic value of wetland services: A metaanalysis’. Ecological Economics, 37(2), pp.257–270.
1064
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
EXAMINATION OF THE PROPOSAL FOR THE
CONSTRUCTION OF A PIER AT NEW WATERFRONT OF
THESSALONIKI
E. I. K. Koutsovili*, A. D. Kosta, Z. Mallios and T. Karambas
Department of Civil Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124, Thessaloniki, Greece
*Corresponding authors: e-mail: koutsovil@civil.auth.gr, kostaalexa@civil.auth.gr
Abstract
The waterfront of Thessaloniki in northern Greece is one of the essential features of the city and
consists of two parts the old and the new waterfront. It is a reference point for the city and the
residents’ favorite leisure area, especially during the summer months. In this paper is presented an
estimation of the social benefits derived from the potential construction of a pier at the waterfront of
Thessaloniki, by the Contingent Valuation Method (CVM). According to the CVM framework,
personal interviews were conducted on a representative sample of Thessaloniki residents. The
questionnaires included questions about the demographics of the respondents and their opinion about
the proposed project, while the citizens’ willingness to pay for the maintenance of the project was
extracted through a dichotomous choice question. Finally, the statistical analysis of the sample data
and the reduction of the results in the overall population lead to an estimate of the total value of the
project and its contribution to the welfare of the city residents. Finally, a cost-benefit analysis was
carried out to highlight the importance of the project to the welfare of the residents of Thessaloniki.
Keywords: Contingent Valuation method, Cost benefit analysis, Thessaloniki
1.
INTRODUCTION
Thessaloniki is a city of around 1,000,000 inhabitants, which is located in northern Greece and is the
second largest Greek city. One of the essential features of the city is the waterfront, which consists of
two parts the old, and the new waterfront. It is a reference point for the city and its inhabitants, and a
place where most of the city residents prefer as a recreational area, especially during the summer
months. The waterfront of Thessaloniki is one of the largest urban waterfronts worldwide that can be
accessed throughout its length by feet.
The recent reconstruction projects on Thessaloniki's coastal front have made it even more attractive,
offering city residents who visit it many leisure opportunities. Visitors of the waterfront can either
enjoy the sun and the sea in one of the thematic parks along the shore or spend time with activities
such as walking, running and cycling. However, there are many who claim that the form of the
waterfront keeps the man away from the sea. So, additions, which bring the visitors of the waterfront
closer to the sea, should be made. With this reasoning, the present study examines whether the citizens
of Thessaloniki agree with this idea, and then assesses the social benefit that will derive from the
addition of a pier to the coastal front. The purpose of the new pier would be to give visitors of the
coastal front the opportunity to walk on it and thus get closer to the sea. The assessment of the social
benefit expected from the construction of the pier is achieved by carrying out a contingent valuation
survey.
1065
Environmental law and economics
Contingent valuation is a well-known method that is used for the valuation of goods that are not
subject to financial transactions (Mitchell and Carson, 1989). Such goods are water, air quality, etc.
On the other hand, examples of implementation of the method to projects concerning the quality of
the urban environment as the one discussed in this paper can be found in works such as those in Jim
and Chen (2011) and Latinopoulos et. al. (2016). To close, the evaluation of the project is
accomplished, with a cost - benefit analysis, which compares the social benefit resulting from the
contingent valuation method with the indicative construction budget. In particular, cost benefit
analysis is carried out in terms of economic analysis. The economic analysis appraises the project
contribution to the welfare of the region or the country. It is made on behalf of the whole society
(region or country) instead of just the owner of the infrastructure like in the financial analysis.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 General description of the pier
The proposed pier will be extended 80m from the coast and it will reach 5.5m in depth. This will
consist of a vertical bent curve front 50m in length and 8m in width, two “fins” left and right of the
platform 4m and 7m respectively and two rounded squares at the end of the platform 20m and 30m
in diameter. The squares will be constructed at different levels with slope 10% and will have
vegetation, benches, metal sunshades and equipment as shown in picture 1.
Picture 1: The proposed Pier - View from above
2.2 The survey questionnaire
The Contingent Valuation Method (CVM) is a well-known and very popular valuation technique. It
is used to elicit the value people ascribe to non-marketable environmental goods and services
(Mitchell and Carson, 1989). The method is applied by conducting a questionnaire survey. The
questionnaire describes a hypothetical market where the environmental goods under consideration
are being traded. In the context of the survey, a random sample of people are asked to state their
maximum willingness to pay (WTP) (or their maximum willingness to accept compensation - WTA)
for a hypothetical change in the level of supply of the environmental goods or services being studied.
The analysis of the data obtained from the survey sample leads to the assessment of the value of this
change (Carson et al., 2003; Mitchell and Carson, 1989).
1066
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Following the CVM framework the questionnaire formed for the survey presented here, consists of
twenty questions in total, divided into three sections. The first section, consisting of seven questions
related to the respondents demographic characteristics (sex, age, education level, etc.). The second
section consists of nine questions and concerns the respondent’s attitude about the environment good
in question, e.g. the activities the respondents prefer when they visit the waterfront (biking, walking,
etc.) and their opinion about the proposed project on the waterfront of Thessaloniki, in general.
Following the above two sections, respondents were introduced all information regarding the
proposed project about the construction of a pier at the waterfront of Thessaloniki. Then, each
respondent had to answer the questions of the third section. At first, the respondents were asked if
they find the proposal useful and if they agree with this project. If their answer was negative, they
had to explain their refusal, but if their answer was positive, they were explained that to allow the
construction and the maintenance of the pier, there should be an increase in municipal taxes they
already pay. This kind of question is introduced here in order to identify those who have indifference
for the project and therefore a zero WTP. According to the scenario of the hypothetical market,
respondents should express agreement or disagreement about the proposed increase in taxes, which
will be paid through the electricity bill every two months. This issue was described as payment
principle by Kontogianni et al. (2001). Negative respondents to the payment principle question were
next asked to explain their attitude. On the other hand, those who agreed with the tax increase were
asked a dichotomous choice question (or a close-ended format question). The question was if they
were willing to pay or not a certain amount (bid) of increase on the taxes per electricity bill, for the
construction and the maintenance of the proposed project. This particular elicitation format (payment
vehicle) was chosen because, as it is suggested by the CVM literature (Arrow et al., 1993; Bateman
and Turner, 1993), it has to be a realistic way of payment, familiar and acceptable by the respondents.
The initial bid values were randomly selected from the following five bid levels, €1, €2, €5, €7 and
€10 per bill, and they were almost uniformly distributed across the sample.
This structure of the questionnaire, and especially the precedence given to the question about
respondents agreement with the project and, the payment principle question, was chosen to face the
frequent problem of biases introduced in the estimation of central tendency measures of WTP
(Kontogianni et al., 2001). These biases are mainly related to a large proportion of respondents in the
sample who give a negative response when answering dichotomous valuation choice questions. The
reasons leading to such answers can be one or more of the following: aversion or indifference to the
good, inclination for a free riding access to it, inability to pay the proposed or any amount at all,
disagreement with the proposed institutional setting, adverse reaction to the interview in general, or
in particular to the payment vehicle adopted etc. (Kontogianni et al., 2001). In our case, we expected
that some respondents could express indifference, since it is possible that many people will not find
useful and will not agree with the construction of the proposed pier and its maintenance. The question
that arises at this point is on how to confront this issue. In the literature, there is a big debate and there
have been many different approaches such as those proposed by Haab and McConnell (1997),
Kristrom (1997), and Reiser and Shechter (1999). All approaches aim to recognize the two different
categories of people who do not accept the payment principle question. In any case, researches try to
identify protest respondents and exclude them from the sample; this is why debriefing questions exist
in all CVM questionnaires. In this paper, we follow the approach of Reiser and Shechter (1999)
because of its simplicity. We examine how the mean and the median WTP are affected by the different
treatment of those who gave a negative answer to the payment principle question.
2.3 Logistic Regression
In most CVM surveys, the dichotomous choice format is used for the elicitation of the respondents
WTP. The expressed WTP in this case is not a monetary value but a “yes” or “no” to a proposed
“bid”. Consequently, this type of responses form a binary depended variable and, the WTP value can
be obtained by introducing a statistical model that links the dependent variable to the monetary
amounts which people are asked to pay in the survey (the “bid” values). Notably the most commonly
used distribution function in the analysis of a binary dependent variable is the logistic distribution
1067
Environmental law and economics
(Hosmer and Lemeshow, 2000). Logistic regression is used in this case in order to form a model that
describes the relation between the dependent binary variable and all other independent variables. The
logistic function that is implemented to perform such an analysis is:
e g ( xi )
1
( xi )
(1)
g ( xi )
g x
1 e
1 e i
where π(xi) is the expected value of the outcome variable, given a set of k explanatory variables xi.
The logistic function is useful because it can take an input with any value from negative to positive
infinity, whereas the output always takes values between zero and one and hence is interpretable as a
probability. As in our case k > 1 (i.e. more than one explanatory variables) the above relation describes
a multiple logistic function, the inverse of the logistic function or logit transformation is defined as:
xi
(2)
g ( xi ) ln
B0 B1 x1 B2 x2 ... Bk xk
1 xi
The logit, g(xi), is linear in its parameters and continuous. Fitting the logistic regression model to a
set of data - like those obtained from CVM surveys - requires the estimation of the values of the
unknown coefficients B0 which is the constant term, B1 which is the coefficient of the “bid” variable
and the rest of Bi’s, which relate to the corresponding specific variables of the model. The application
of the maximum likelihood method is the best approach to yield the values of the unknown parameters
(Hosmer and Lemeshow, 2000). The corresponding likelihood function of the logit transformation is:
n
x
i
yi
1 yi
1 xi
(3)
1
where yi is the response of the i-th individual to the valuation question. After estimating the unknown
coefficients, the logistic regression model can be utilized for the estimation of the central tendency
measures of WTP. In the subsequent analysis we have used the following formulas to estimate the
mean and the median WTP (Ekstrand and Loomis, 1998; Hanemann, 1984).
B
ln 1 e 0
MeanWTP
(4)
| B1 |
B0
| B1 |
MedianWTP
(5)
For the current analysis, B1 is the estimate of the bid amount coefficient and B0 is the sum of the
estimated constant plus the sum of the products of the mean of each variable in the model times their
coefficients.
On the other hand, Reiser and Shechter (1999) assumed that the population of interest could be
considered to be composed of two sub-populations. One sub-population is simply not willing to pay
at all for the good in question, while the other sub-population is willing to pay and has a continuous
WTP distribution. In this case, the corresponding likelihood function for the analysis takes the
following form (Reiser and Shechter, 1999):
n
p1 Si 1 p i
S
1
n
x 1 x
1 y i
yi
i
(6)
i
1, S i 1
where p denotes the probability that an individual chosen at random has zero WTP and Si is the
response of the i-th individual to the payment principle question, π(xi) is the expected value of the
outcome variable, given a set of k explanatory variables xi, and yi is the response of the i-th individual
to the valuation question. The likelihood function of equation 6 breaks up into two separate parts:
n
p 1 p
1 S i
Si
(7a)
1
1068
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
n
x 1 x
1 yi
yi
i
(7b)
i
1, S i 1
Equations 7a and 7b are actually two logistic regression models, so the mean value of eq.7a can be
estimated by the following equations:
Logit pi a0 a1 x1 ... an xn
(8a)
n
pˆ
n Si
i 1
(8b)
n
Equation 8b is actually the mean value of the payment principle question. In other words, it is the
observed percentage of respondents, who refused to pay anything for the construction of the proposed
pier. It follows that the mean and median WTP for this setting is the product of (1 – p) times the
outcomes of equations 4 and 5 respectively.
2.4 Cost Benefit Analysis
Cost benefit analysis is defined as a systematic process for calculating and comparing benefits and
costs of a decision, a policy or a project in general. A cost benefit analysis aims at a conclusion about
the liability of a proposed investment, by examining the values of three major indicators, Net Present
Value (NPV), Internal Rate of Return (IRR) and the Benefit - Cost Ratio (European Commission,
2014). In this study due to lack of space, the analysis is limited to the assessment of one of these
indicators, the net present value.
Net present value is the difference between the present value of the projects’ cash inflows and the
present value of the projects’ cash outflows as they are estimated for the needs of the analysis. NPV
is one of the measures used in capital budgeting to analyze the profitability of an investment. NPV
compares the values of a monetary unit received or spend today to the value of that same monetary
unit received or spend in the future, taking inflation and returns into account. The net present value
of an investment is given by the following equation:
N
NBt
(9)
NPV C0
t
t 1 1 r
Where, C0, is the construction cost of the project in question, NBt, is the net benefits of the year t, r,
is the discount rate, and N, is the project’s life cycle in years. Positive NPVs indicate feasible
investments, while negative ones imply non-acceptable investments. For projects related to the
government policy as the one described in the current study, net benefits for year t are given as:
NBt SBt Bt OM t
(10)
where, SBt, is the estimated social benefit of year t, Bt, is the income of the year t, OMt, is the operation
and maintenance cost of the year t. According to the European Commissions’, guide to Cost-Benefit
analysis of investment projects the discount rate and the project life cycle of such projects are defined
to 6% and 30 years respectively (European Commission, 2014).
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Survey design and data
The survey was conducted in the spring of 2017 in the city of Thessaloniki. Using the random
sampling method 350 questionnaires were filled in by in-person contingent valuation interviews. Of
all the questions that respondents had to answer during the interview, a set of explanatory variables
was formed and used for the estimation of the logistic regression models. Table 1 presents the
1069
Environmental law and economics
variables that turned out to be significant in any of the models presented below, plus their descriptive
statistics, which were calculated for the whole sample of 350 respondents. Of all the respondents, 336
(96%) agreed with the construction of the pier and only 14 (4%) denied. In addition, 203 respondents
(58%) answered “yes” to the payment principle question, meaning that most of the respondents are
willing to accept higher taxes for the construction and the maintenance of the project. On the other
hand, the remaining 133 (38%) respondents that agreed with the proposal, refused to accept higher
taxes for this purpose. They justified their response as follows: a) 45 (33.8%) because they are not
able to pay more taxes; b) 66 (49.6%) because they believe that the construction and the maintenance
of the pier is a state’s obligation; c) 4 (3.0%) because they are not willing to pay if they do not use
the pier; d) 18 (13.5%) because they believe that the taxes that they already pay are enough for the
construction and the maintenance of the project.
In Table 1, the descriptive statistics of the variables reveal some interesting information about the
sample. First, it is impressive that the great majority (96%) of the respondents agree with the proposed
project, but those who are willing to pay something for the project are much less. Most of the
respondents believe that the proposed project will be a significant aesthetic upgrade for the waterfront
of Thessaloniki, and it will offer new recreational activities to its visitors. Most of the respondents
were between 21-30 years old while most of them were university graduates. The average value of
the “Income” variable is 2.37 meaning that the respondents average monthly income is between 400
and 600 €/month.
Table 1: Variables description and descriptive statistics
Variable name Variable description
Mean Std.
Dev.
WTP
Willingness to pay a certain amount (0 = no, 1 = yes)
0.41
0.49
Construction
Agreement to the construction of the pier (0=no, 1=yes)
0.96
0.20
Bid
Proposed bid (1€, 2€, 5€, 7€, 10€)
5.00
3.29
P.Princ
Payment principle question (0 = no, 1 = yes)
0.58
0.49
Income
Respondents monthly family income: 1 = <400 €/mon, 2 = 401 2.37
- 600 €/mon, 3 = 601 - 800 €/mon, 4 = 801 - 1000 €/mon, 5 =
1001 - 2000 €/mon, 6 = >2001 €/mon
1.73
Winter
Frequency of respondents visits to the waterfront in winter
4.68
5.01
New activities
Rating of the contribution of the pier in new activities (0-5)
3.69
1.10
Aesthetic
upgrade
Rating of the contribution of the pier in aesthetic upgrade of the 3.93
waterfront (0-5)
1.12
Age group
Age of respondents in year groups
2.74
1.35
(1 = 16-20, 2 = 21-30, 3 = 31-40, 4 = 41-50, 5 = 51-60, 6= >60)
Walk
Frequency of the respondents walking during a week
2.54
2.06
Tourism
Rating of the contribution of the pier in the development of 3.79
tourism
1.07
Education
Education Level (1=primary school, 2= secondary school, etc.) 3.77
0.73
It worth to mention that the pretty big percentage of younger ages in combination of the economic
crisis that our country is suffering from, is the main reason for the very low average income of the
participants. Finally, the high participation rate of younger ages is due to their greater desire to
participate in the survey in relation to older ages.
1070
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.2 Models and results
Three separate models were estimated for the analysis of the data collected from the questionnaire
survey. The first model examines the relation between the answer that the 350 respondents gave to
the payment principle question and their personal characteristics. Table 2 presents the results of the
logistic regression for this model. The variables that turned out to be significant and included in the
model are presented together with the values of the estimated coefficients, the relevant standard
errors, the Wald statistic and the corresponding significance level. Parameters that assess the
performance of the models are also included in the table. The performance statistics of this model
indicate that the goodness of fit of this model is quite low. The obvious explanation for this result is
that the agreement or not of the respondents to the imposition of the proposed tax depends on a
parameter that was not detected and was not included in this survey.
Table 2: Estimated parameters of the model for the payment principle question
Variable name
B
S.E.
Wald
Sig.
Exp(B)
Education
0.303
0.157
3.726
0.054
1.353
Income
0.113
0.068
2.793
0.095
1.120
Winter
0.055
0.025
4.801
0.028
1.057
New activities
0.273
0.109
6.262
0.012
1.314
Aesthetic upgrade
0.279
0.107
6.824
0.009
1.322
Constant
-3.418
0.795
18.468
0
0.033
-2 Log Likelihood
445.124
Nagelkerke R Square
0.114
Cox and Snell R Square
0.085
Overall Percentage
61.7
N
350
For the estimation of the second model, is assumed that all the respondents expressed their WTP.
Meaning that those who did not agree with the tax increase in the first place would be negative to any
bid, in case they were offered one, if the payment principle question were not posed to them at all.
On the other hand, for the estimation of the third model, the answers of 262 of the respondents are
analyzed. This group includes those who agreed with the tax increase and answered the bid question
(203), those who answered “no” to the construction of the pier (14) and those who invoke disability
to pay (45). It is accepted that those who have a financial burden have stated true zero WTP because
they want to contribute but they cannot. In addition, people who did not agreed with the construction
of the proposed pier are included to this analysis because they do not find any utility to the project
and therefore they state a true zero WTP.
The results from the application of the logistic regression for the two models formed for the estimation
of respondents WTP are shown in Tables 3 and 4. In each table, the variables that turned out to be
significant and included in each model are presented together with the values of the estimated
coefficients, the relevant standard errors, the Wald statistic and the corresponding significance level.
Like before, the parameters that assess the performance of the models are also included in each table.
Finally, the values of the mean and median WTP for both models are also shown in tables 3 and 4,
which were estimated by equations 4 and 5 respectively. All variables used for forming these models
and described in detail in Table 1 were more or less expected to be included in the analysis. The
coefficients of all models mostly in terms of their signs but also and in terms of their values are
reasonable and explain the attitude of the respondents.
1071
Environmental law and economics
Table 3: Estimated parameters for the valuation question and all respondents
Variable name
B
S.E.
Wald
Sig.
Exp(B)
-0.320
0.120
7.153
0.070
0.726
Income
0.387
0.092
17.679
0.000
1.472
Winter
0.079
0.024
11.019
0.001
1.082
New activities
0.225
0.117
3.691
0.055
1.252
Aesthetic upgrade
0.338
0.119
8.046
0.005
1.402
Amount
-0.140
0.038
13.853
0.000
0.869
Constant
-2.271
0.649
12.245
0.000
0.103
Age group
-2 Log Likelihood
419.929
Nagelkerke R Square
0.196
Cox and Snell R Square
0.145
Mean WTP
€6.10
Median WTP
€2.14
Overall Percentage
67.7
350
N
Table 4: Estimated parameters for the valuation question for 262 respondents
Variable name
B
S.E.
Wald
Sig.
Exp(B)
Education
0.476
0.198
5.578
0.016
1.609
Income
0.315
0.089
12.403
0.000
1.370
Walk
0.135
0.072
3.522
0.061
1.144
Winter
0.090
0.033
7.528
0.006
1.094
Tourism
0.495
0.143
11.978
0.001
1.641
Amount
-0.140
0.044
10.316
0.001
0.869
Constant
-4.218
1.062
15.572
0.000
0.015
-2 Log Likelihood
301.523
Nagelkerke R Square
0.269
Cox and Snell R Square
0.201
Mean WTP
€9.32
Median WTP
€7.07
Overall Percentage
70.2
N
262
The significantly large difference between the estimated values of mean and median WTP for the
model of Table 3 is explained by the fact that the analysis included all responses. Consequently, as
shown in Table 1, there was a large negative response rate to the valuation question leading to this
outcome. On the other hand comparing the estimated values of WTP shown in Tables 3 and 4, the
1072
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
estimated values for the mean WTP from the two models are €6.10 and €9.32 respectively, whereas
the same values for the median are €2.14 and €7.07. This significantly large difference between the
estimated values of the mean and the median WTP derived from the two models, is explained by the
fact, that in the model of table 3 were included the data collected from all respondents, while in the
model of table 4 most of the negative answers to the valuation question were not taken into account.
Following the approach of Reiser and Shechter (1999) described above, two more values for mean
and median WTP are estimated respectively, by multiplying the (1-p) value of the first model with
the mean and the median WTP of the third model. The estimated mean and the median WTP following
this approach are €5.47 and €4.15 respectively. This last estimate of the mean WTP is very close and
comparable to the estimate of the mean WTP of the second model. The advantage of this approach is
that using the whole sample leads to more symmetric values of mean and median WTP. This result
also indicates that we cannot say which one is the true estimate of the WTP, but it is safer to say that
WTP ranges between €5.47 and €9.32.
3.3 Cost - Benefit analysis
The cost-benefit analysis presented here is carried out in terms of economic analysis and not in terms
of financial analysis, as there is no direct income for the city from the pier itself. Therefore, to carry
out the cost-benefit analysis for the construction project of the pier, it is claimed that the project will
be completed in two years and the time horizon of the analysis will be thirty years. Specifically, the
costs to be considered are the construction cost of the project for the first two years, which was
estimated at €1,211,490.55, and the annual operating cost, which was estimated at €35,920. As for
the construction cost, it is the sum of costs in the first and the second year. In particular, the first year
is assumed that will be completed the 60% of the construction, meaning the cost will be €726,872.49
and the second year, the cost will be €484,618.06 as it will be completed the remaining 40%. The
next years, there are no more construction costs as the construction of the project will have been
completed. Regarding the annual operating costs, they start from the third year and consist of
maintenance and electricity costs and clean-up cost and they were estimated at €34.000 and €1.920
respectively. In particular, an indicative amount of maintenance cost per year is estimated to be
around €4000. The electricity cost is estimated about €30000 per year, as it is considered that, the
pier will have 20 luminaires operating for 12 hours per day. Operating costs are increased by 12% to
take account of unforeseen costs. Finally, the clean-up cost is estimated to be €1920, based on the
assumption that 480 work hours are required per year, with remuneration 4€ per hour.
On the other hand, the benefit in the analysis is the estimated social benefit, which according to
welfare theory equates to the willingness of citizens to pay, which was estimated in the previous
section. In particular, the annual value of the project for the citizens of Thessaloniki is estimated by
the reduction of the samples’ mean willingness to pay, which was estimated by the logistic regression
models, in the total population of the city. So, by accepting the most conservative estimate of the
willingness to pay which is €5,47 according to the approach of Reiser and Shechter (1999), the annual
value of the project for the residents of Thessaloniki equals to the product of the mean WTP (€5.47)
times the number of households that exist in the city (332848 households) and times the number of
bills paid by every household in a year (6 bills). The amount resulting from this reduction is
€10,924,071.36. So, the net benefit required for the cost benefit analysis is:
NBt SBt OM t €10,924,071.36 €31,920 €10,892,151.36
(10)
The NPV for the project under study is estimated for thirty years, as follows:
N
NPV C0
t 1
30
NBt
1 r
t
€1,211,454.16
t 1
€10,892,151.36
1 0.05t
€153,356,974.17
(11)
The NPV value estimated by equation 11 is particularly high, even by the most conservative
estimates. This value is significantly higher from corresponding NPV value of about €95,000,000
estimated by Kaitsis and Mallios (2015) in a similar analysis for the reformation project of the new
1073
Environmental law and economics
waterfront of Thessaloniki. The conclusion drawn from the comparison of these two estimates is we
can assume that when the respondents stated their WTP for the construction of the pier, they
subconsciously stated their WTP for the entire waterfront of Thessaloniki. Therefore, we can assume
that the actual social benefit that will derive from the upgrade of the coastal front of the city due to
the addition of the proposed pier is the value resulting from the difference between these two
estimates. In any case, the estimates highlight the importance of the waterfront for the city of
Thessaloniki; indicate that the construction of a pier at the Waterfront of Thessaloniki is a project
with a positive influence for the welfare of the local society.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
The application of the contingent valuation method for the estimation of the social benefits that will
derive from the construction of pier at the waterfront of Thessaloniki and the cost-benefit analysis
that followed highlight the following useful conclusions concerning the city of Thessaloniki but also
some technical issues of the method. As for the city of Thessaloniki, it is proved that the residents of
the city recognize the need for more amenities in the city, give high priority and bring into this need
a significantly high value. On the other hand, the conclusions of the different values of the WTP
estimated above are summarized as follows: a) the payment principle question is useful but not able
to identify free riders or protest responses even with the combination of the debriefing questions; b)
questions like the one about the agreement of the respondents for the proposed project, which was
introduced in this study for the first time, are proved useful for the identification of true zero bids and
similar questions should be incorporated in all CVM studies; c) it is safer to report a range for the
WTP instead of a single value. Finally, the application of the cost-benefit analysis leads on the
conclusion that a project can be considered unprofitable in financial terms, but it can become
necessary because of its social and environmental scope. After all, when the state chooses to build a
project, its primary objective is to use and meet various needs and, secondarily, to profit from it.
References
1. Arrow, K., Solow, R., Portney, P. R., Leamer, E. E., Radner, R., and Schuman, H. (1993). Report
of the NOAA Panel on Contingent Valuation. Federal Register, 58(10), pp. 4601–4614.
2. Bateman, I. J., and Turner, R. K. (1993). Valuation of the environment, methods and techniques:
the contingent valuation method. Sustainable Environmental Economics and Management:
Principles and Practice, Belhaven Press, London, pp. 120–191.
3. Carson, R. T., Mitchell, R. C., Hanemann, M., Kopp, R. J., Presser, S., and Ruud, P. A. (2003).
Contingent valuation and lost passive use: Damages from the Exxon Valdez oil spill.
Environmental and Resource Economics, 25(3), pp. 257–286.
4. Chen, W. Y., and Jim, C. Y. (2011). Resident valuation and expectation of the urban greening
project in Zhuhai, China. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 54(7), pp.
851–869.
5. Ekstrand, E. R., and Loomis, J. (1998). Incorporating respondent uncertainty when estimating
willingness to pay for protecting critical habitat for threatened and endangered fish. Water
Resources Research, 34(11), pp. 3149.
6. European Commission. (2014). Guide to Cost-Benefit analysis of investment projects.
Brussels.
7. Haab, T. C., and McConnell, K. E. (1997). Referendum Models and Negative Willingness to Pay:
Alternative Solutions. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 32(2), pp.
251–270.
8. Hanemann, M. W. (1984). Welfare Evaluations in Contingent Valuation Experiments with
Discrete Responses. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 66(3), pp. 332.
9. Hosmer, D. W., and Lemeshow, S. (2000). Applied logistic regression. N. York: J Wiley & Sons.
10. Kaitsis, A., and Mallios, Z. (2015). Valuation of the “New Waterfront” of the city Thessaloniki
in Greece with the Contingent Valuation Method. In Fifth International Conference on
1074
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Environmental Management, Engineering, Planning & Economics pp. 525–532. Mykonos
Greece.
11. Kontogianni, A., Skourtos, M. S., Langford, I. H., Bateman, I. J., and Georgiou, S. (2001).
Integrating stakeholder analysis in non-market valuation of environmental assets. Ecological
Economics, 37(1), pp. 123–138.
12. Kristrom, B. (1997). Spike Models in Contingent Valuation. American Journal of Agricultural
Economics, 79(3), pp. 1013–1023.
13. Latinopoulos, D., Mallios, Z., and Latinopoulos, P. (2016). Valuing the benefits of an urban park
project: A contingent valuation study in Thessaloniki, Greece. Land Use Policy, 55, pp. 130–141.
14. Mitchell, R. C., and Carson, R. T. (1989). Using Surveys to Value Public Goods: The
Contingent Valuation Method. Washington DC: Resources for the Future.
15. Reiser, B., and Shechter, M. (1999). Incorporating zero values in the economic valuation of
environmental program benefits. Environmetrics, 10(1), pp. 87–101.
1075
Environmental law and economics
DRONES AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION LAW IN
GERMANY AND GREECE
A.K. Douka
Lawyer, PhD Candidate, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki,
GR - 55131 Thessaloniki, Macedonia, Greece
*Corresponding authors: e-mail: anastdouka@law.auth.gr
Abstract
Unmanned aircrafts, subsumed under the term "drones", have become in recent years due to their
number and wide application a mass phenomenon. Despite the overall contribution of drones to the
environmental protection, they may also have negative effects on the environment. There are fears
that birds, seals or other animals are disturbed, that the drone controllers enter protected areas or that
the landscape is affected. At EU level, the development of special drone rules is at a draft stage. The
aviation Regulation (EC) No 216/2008 provides technical safety requirements, the airfields and
controllers of unmanned aircrafts, but for a drone weight above 150 kg. Those below that weight are
to be regulated by each Member State as they see appropriate. In Germany, the new Drone Regulation
entered into force on 7 April 2017. It integrated nature conservation aspects of drone operations into
the existing aviation legislation. However, the German nature conservation legislation lacks explicit
provisions regulating drone flights as a permissive intervention to protected areas. In Greece, the
Regulation of Flights of Unmanned Aircraft Systems (drones) entered into force on 1 January 2017
(Off. Gaz. Β 3152/30-9-2016). This Regulation specifies the terms, conditions and the way for
obtaining the license of a drone operator, instructor and examiner, but does not contain any specific
nature conservation standards regarding the use of drones. The aim of the present paper is to examine:
a) the new general legislative framework for drones and b) the legal conflicts arising out of the use
of drones in protected areas in Germany and Greece.
Keywords: drones, environmental protection, legal conflicts, protected areas
1.
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Current state of the drone use
Drones, known in the colloquial speech as aircrafts, which are operated with no pilot on board (Juul,
2015), can be generally used for scientific, commercial, military, police and private purposes (Brahms
and Maslaton, 2016). The field of application for military purposes ranges from simple
reconnaissance tasks to complex surveillance scenarios using armed systems (Müllenstedt, 2015).
Although drones were initially developed for military and defense purposes, they are increasingly
used for various civil purposes, including photography, rescue operations, infrastructure monitoring,
forest fire monitoring, farming and aerial mapping (House of Lords and European Union Committee,
2015). The provision of Internet access and the transport of goods by drones are in test operation
(Brahms and Maslaton, 2016). Nevertheless, there is criticism about the use of drones over
demonstrations, major events or in general over densely populated areas due to the danger of falling
(Sattler and Regh, 2011).
Remarkable is that the progressive integration of drones into airspace poses various risks. In some
cases drones have narrowly missed commercial manned aircrafts, flown over or landed on the
residences of public figures, nuclear power stations, embassies and tourist attractions, obstructed
1076
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
firefighting and injured people (Juul, 2015). Because of the fact that drones usually carry video
cameras to allow the remote pilot to fly them, they may record images and include technologies such
as high-power zoom, microphones and a multitude of sensors as well as GPS systems recording the
location of persons filmed (Juul, 2015). As a result, concerns are expressed about the increasing use
of drones in respect of data protection and privacy (House of Lords and European Union Committee,
2015).
The use of drones can also have negative effects on the natural environment. Irresponsible drone use
could cause harm to birds including disrupting nests by reducing the breeding success of sensitive
bird populations, provoking attacks, scattering leks, interrupting feeding and midair collisions
(Mayntz, 2017).
1.2 The European regulatory framework
Under the EU Aviation Law, drones are referred to as unmanned aircrafts (Annex II (i) of the Aviation
Regulation 206/2008). Both the German and the Greek Aviation Law draw a distinction between
model aircrafts and unmanned aerial systems according to the purpose of the use of drone. Drones
used for the purpose of sport or for recreational activities are classified as model aircrafts (§ 1 para.
2 no. 9 of the German Air Traffic Act (Luftverkehrsgesetz, hereinafter: LuftVG) and art. 3 of the
Greek Regulation of Flights of Unmanned Aircraft Systems), whereas drones operated for any other
purpose, such as for commercial visual recordings for commercial purposes, are called unmanned
aerial systems (§ 1 para. 2 of the German LuftVG and art. 3 of the Greek Regulation of Flights of
Unmanned Aircraft Systems).
At EU level, the Aviation Regulation (EC) No 216/2008 provides technical safety requirements, the
airfields and controllers of unmanned aircrafts, but for a drone weight above 150 kg (art. 4 § 4 in
conjunction with Annex II (i) of the Aviation Regulation (EC) No 216/2008). Those below that
weight are to be regulated by each Member State as they see appropriate.
The EU proposed a change to the Aviation Regulation (EC) No 216/2008 (European Commission,
2015). Following the so - called Riga Declaration (Riga Declaration on remotely piloted aircrafts
(drones), 2015), the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA), on behalf of the European
Commission, made initial proposals for the establishment of a single legislative framework for the
use of drones of all weight classes. Based on the risk the operation is posing to third parties (persons
and property), drones are divided into three categories: ‘Open category’ (low-risk), ‘Specific
category’ (medium-risk) and ‘Certified category’ (high-risk). The safety should be provided, among
other things, by operational limitations, especially by "geo-fencing". Geo-fencing is the concept of
restricting drone access by designating specific areas where the drone’s software and/or hardware is
designed not to enter, even if the pilot, without intent, instructs the drone to go (European Aviation
Safety Agency (EASA), 2015). The proposed changes are based on the regulatory approach, to
develop the potentials of drone technology and thereby to ensure the security of their operation
(Schrader, 2017). The Riga Declaration introduced the cause of noise by the use of drones as an
environmental issue, which needs to be addressed at the local level (Riga Declaration on remotely
piloted aircrafts (drones), 2015). However, it is noted that the proposed European framework about
drones lacks in nature conservation issues, as geo-fencing does not contain nature conservation areas
(Schrader, 2017).
2.
GERMAN LAW
2.1 The new Drone Regulation
The former German Aviation Law contained different levels of regulation for model aircrafts and for
unmanned aerial systems. The rise of aircraft models below 5 kg was possible for people of all ages
without prior knowledge and without any air traffic permission (§ 20 para. 1 no. 1 a) of the Regulation
relating to air events, Luftverkehrsverordnung, hereinafter: LuftVO). The rise of unmanned aerial
systems was subject to authorization (§ 20 para. 1 no. 7 LuftVO). An authorization was issued if their
1077
Environmental law and economics
use did not pose a risk to the aviation safety or public safety or order and there was no violation of
data protection rules (§ 20 para. 4 LuftVO).
The Federal Ministry of Transport adopted the new Drone Regulation, which introduced amendments
to Air Traffic Licensing Order (Luftverkehrs-Zulassungs-Ordnung, hereinafter: LuftVZO) and to
LuftVO and which entered into force, with minor exceptions, on 7.4.2017. According to the new
legislative framework, drones up to 250g are not subject to any specific restrictions. Drones weighing
over 250g must have the name and address of the controller attached (§ 19 para. 3 LuftVZO). For
unmanned aerial systems and model aircrafts with a take-off mass above 5 kg there is an authorization
requirement (§ 21a para. 1 no. 1 LuftVO). The authorization is granted when the intended operation
does not pose a danger to the aviation safety or public safety or order and there is no violation of data
protection and nature conservation rules (§ 21a para. 3 no. 1 LuftVO). However, there is an exception
from the authorization requirement, if the drone operation is necessary for the fulfillment of official
tasks (§ 21a para. 2 no. 1 LuftVO).
2.2 Nature conservation aspects
Nature conservation aspects, which are not limited to the protection of certain areas, but, for example,
may include species protection aspects, are expressly mentioned in the terms of the new authorization
procedure (Schrader, 2017). According to § 21a para. 6 LuftVO, protection regulations, such the
Federal Nature Conservation Act (Bundesnaturschutzgesetz, hereinafter: BNatSchG), which have
been issued under this Act or continued to apply, as well as the nature conservation laws of the
countries, remain unaffected. Moreover, in accordance with § 21b para.1 no. 6 LuftVO, general
operating bans exist in environmentally sensitive areas, such as nature reserves, national parks and
Natura 2000 sites, as far as the operation of unmanned aircrafts in these areas are not otherwise
regulated by the national provisions. In this regard, the new German Aviation Law recognizes further
protective provisions of the nature conservation law, whereas it does not contain any regulations on
geo-fencing (Schrader, 2017).
Legal conflicts can most likely arise in nature reserves (Schrader, 2017). Drones can be beneficial for
nature conservation law. They can be used for nature photography or for the rescue of wild animals
from an agricultural mowing (Thaysen, 2016). Furthermore, drones can be used as monitoring aids
for the observation of nature and landscape (§ 6 BNatSchG). In the field of landscape planning, drones
can be used to determine the existing state of nature and landscape. At local level, they can collect
information for landscape and green order plans (§ 11 BNatSchG) and determine soil and water
parameters in addition to vegetation, landscape features, larger animals and impairments (Schrader,
2017).
Moreover, drones can be used for carrying out and securing the compensation measures. The
competent authority has to carry out appropriately compensation and replacement measures,
including any necessary maintenance measures (§ 17 para. 7 BNatSchG). For this purpose, it may
require the polluter to submit a report. Drones can contribute to these controls (Schrader, 2017).
In addition, drones can play an important role in the protection of nature, landscape and species.
Drones in a monitoring program could contribute to the examination of the achievement of the
protective purpose in many protected areas, especially outside the Natura 2000 network. As far as the
observation of invasive species is concerned (§ 40 para. 2 BNatSchG), recorders on drones,
programmed for the giant hogweed or the Himalayan balsam, can more effectively identify the spread
than inspections (Schrader, 2017).
On the other hand, it is noted that the German Air Traffic Act (LuftVO), applying to a federal level,
lacks in explicit provisions with regard to the protection of the nature reserves. All acts, leading to
destruction, damage or change of territories or its constituents or to lasting disruption, are prohibited
(§ 23 para. 2 BNatSchG). This absolute prohibition on change also applies to the national parks (§ 24
para. 3 BNatSchG). However, § 21 b para.1 no. 6 LuftVO on general operating bans for unmanned
aircrafts in environmentally sensitive areas does not refer to national parks, national natural
1078
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
monuments and natural monuments mentioned in §§ 24 para.4, 28 para. 2 BNatSchG, which are also
like nature reserves protected, so that there is no air traffic operating ban over them (Schrader, 2017).
At the legislation level of the individual German states, drones had for the first time in 2016 an effect
on a state nature conservation law.§ 13 para. 3 no. 3 of the National Nature Conservation Act of
Schleswig-Holstein prohibits in nature reserves the rise and landing of model aircrafts and unmanned
aerial systems. Forbidden is, however, the rise and landing in only one nature reserve, but not close
to it. This prohibition is narrower than the prohibition on change of § 23 para 2 BNatSchG (Schrader,
2017), which also includes activities outside of one nature reserve (Landmann, Rohmer and
Gellermann,2017).
Moreover, National Nature Conservation Act of Schleswig-Holstein does not regulate the overflight
and does not make clear, whether the prohibition ‘in nature reserves’ applies also to types of areas
equal to nature reserves. The remaining legislative gaps regarding overflight, rise and landing in areas
close to nature reserves or in areas equal to nature reserves may be filled by the individual protection
statement of the respective area (Schrader, 2017).
As mentioned above, drones can disturb birds. Drones could violate the general prohibition of
deliberate disturbance of wildlife (§ 39 para. 1 no. 1 BNatSchG) as well as the special prohibition of
disturbance of wildlife of protected species and European species of birds during certain time periods (§ 44 para. 1 no. 2 BNatSchG). A disturbance, according to § 44 para. 1 no. 2 BNatSchG,
presupposes the detrimental effects of actions on the psychological well-being of a protected animal
and its externally recognizable fear, escape or startle reactions (Landmann, Rohmer and Gellermann,
2017). Externally recognizable reactions have to be considerable for the conservation status of the
local population. A deliberate disturbance presupposes positively the intent of the disturbance and
negatively the absence of any justifying, apologizing or otherwise objectively comprehensible reason
(Giesberts L., Reinhardt M. and Gläß, 2017). In this context, the disturbance for a simple private
photography or without any justification would be deliberate, whereas a scientific animal
photography not. An expertise is required in order to be able to fulfill the requirements of a prohibited
state in individual cases prove by drones. A professional expertise is needed in order to prove in
individual cases the fulfillment of the requirements of the above mentioned prohibitions (Schrader,
2017).
3.
GREEK LAW
3.1 The Drone Regulation
In Greece, the first Drone Regulation, issued by the Civil Aviation Authority (hereinafter: CAA),
entered into force on 01.01.2017 (Off. Gaz. Β 3152/30-9-2016). The Regulation applies only to
Unmanned Aerial Systems (Art. 2§1 of the Regulation). Aeromodels, unmanned aircrafts used for
military or other state purposes by the respective state bodies (armed forces, security forces, etc.) as
well as tethered or free balloons are excluded from the scope of the Regulation (Art. 2§2 of the
Regulation).
The Regulation defines the whole procedure regarding Unmanned Aerial Systems, including safety,
privacy, data protection, civil liability and environmental protection issues. The structure of the
Regulation is formulated within the framework of the principles of the European Aviation Safety
Agency (EASA) in such a way as to enable the full integration of the relevant European regulations
in the future.
According to the Regulation, drones are classified into three categories: open, specialized and
certified. All drones flying more than 50 meters away from their operator, regardless of the reasons
for their use, should be recorded in a register of the Civil Aviation Authority (Art. 10§1 of the
Regulation). Upon request by the interested parties, drones are categorized in the open or special
category and are included in the special register of unmanned aircrafts of the CAA. Drones,
1079
Environmental law and economics
categorized by the CAA in the certified category, are entered in the register of Greek civil aircrafts
and they receive nationality and registration marks (Art. 10§1 of the Regulation).
Drones of the open category have a take-off mass below 25 kg, fly in less than 500 meters away from
the operator and the maximum allowable flight height is 400 feet. The operator has direct view of the
drone. Flights of drones of this category are forbidden above concentrations of persons, unless they
have a commercial license and meet specific safety requirements (Art. 6§1 of the Regulation).
For drones belonging to the special category, an operating permission is required. This is granted
under the condition that the person concerned provides a security risk assessment plan, a flight
operation’s manual and an insurance contract (Art. 8§1 of the Regulation). In case of commercial use
of the drones belonging to this category, a registration of the drones in a special register and the
obtaining of a special license through a fee payment are also required (Art. 8§2 of the Regulation).
For drones of the certified category, a registration of the aircraft in a special register and the issue of
a special certificate of airworthiness are required (Art. 9 of the Regulation).Furthermore, the operator
of this category is obliged to have a special training, the content of which and the exams required will
be determined by a decision of the CAA operation commander (Art. 9§3 of the Regulation).
For the commercial exploitation of unmanned aircraft of any category, a special license provided by
the CAA is required (Art. 13§1 of the Regulation), which has a twelve-month validity and is renewed
after re-control and a new fee payment (Art. 13§4 of the Regulation). A prerequisite for the granting
of the license is, among others, a certification that the operator of drones has obtained basic
knowledge of air traffic rules after the attendance of certain relevant courses (Art. 13§2 of the
Regulation).
The Regulation contains specific rules for air traffic and the conduct of unmanned aircraft flights.
Among others, it provides that drone flights are generally allowed in airspace segregated from the
airspace used by manned aircraft. In particular, Unmanned Aerial Systems are allowed to fly: a) below
the permitted limits for the operation of manned aircrafts in accordance with Instrument Flight Rules
(IFR) and/or Visual Flight Rules (VFR) or at a maximum altitude of 400 feet above ground or sea
surface; b) above the upper limits of the controlled airspace for the operation of manned aircraft (flight
level: 460-46.000 feet); c) within temporary segregated areas for drone flights, which are determined
by the air traffic services of CAA and d) at defined traces and heights specified by special
authorizations of the air traffic services of CAA (Art. 5§1 of the Regulation).
On the contrary, drone flights are generally prohibited in airspace: a) in which flights of manned
aircrafts take place in accordance with Instrument Flight Rules (IFR) and/or Visual Flight Rules
(VFR); b) within the airport operations zones and, in any event, in a distance less than 8 km from the
aerodrome perimeter and from landing/ take-off paths from/to the airport; c) in prohibited areas for
unmanned aircraft systems as defined by the competent bodies and published by a decision of CAA
and d) in areas, defined by air traffic services as prohibited and restricted, in which the flights of
manned aircrafts are not allowed (Art. 5§2 of the Regulation). However, in special cases and upon
request to the CAA, it is possible to allow the flight in airspace concerned (Art. 5§3 of the Regulation).
Finally, the Regulation provides that unmanned aircrafts belonging to special, certified category or to
the open category with a take-off mass between 4 kg - 25 kg as well as unmanned aircrafts for
professional use of any category/subcategory require an insurance coverage for damage to third
parties (up to 150.000 € for third party material damages and up to 1,000,000 € for personal injuries,
Art. 14 of the Regulation). The Regulation also refers to privacy issues. In particular, it provides that
any possible processing of personal data during air transport operations of drones has to comply with
the relevant legislation in force (Art. 15 of the Regulation).
3.2 Nature conservation aspects
Similar problems with those arising under German law are also found here. The only nature
conservation aspect of the Greek Drone Regulation is the general ban on the operation of drones over
1080
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
environmental protection areas. According to Art.19§3 of the Regulation, the operation of drones
over these areas is subject to special authorization by the Ministry of Environment, Energy and
Climate Change.
Pursuant to Art. 19 of Law 1650/1986, as amended by Art. 5 of Law 3937/2011, environmental
protection areas are strict nature reserves (areas with extremely sensitive ecosystems), nature reserves
(areas of high ecological or biological value, in which any activity or operation changing or altering
the physical condition, composition or development of the natural environment is prohibited), natural
parks (terrestrial, maritime areas or areas of a mixed character of particular value and interest because
of the quality and variety of their natural and cultural features), and Natura 2000 sites.
This general ban does not contain any specific nature conservation standards for the use of drones. It
does not specifically define to which of the above-mentioned environmental protection areas the
general ban on drone flights applies, if there are any exceptions from this general ban and, if so, on
the basis of which criteria and at which height are drone flights allowed over an environmental
protection area. On the other hand, a basic lack of this general provision is that it does not prohibit
drone flights close to environmental protection areas, and in particular close to Natura 2000 sites.
This provision seems at first sight to protect the environment against the operation of drones.
However, this general prohibition of drone flights over environmental protection areas may also run
counter to the environmental protection. The general requirement for a special authorization for the
operation of unmanned aircrafts over all the above-mentioned environmental protection areas, even
if it works for the benefit of the environment (e.g. forest fire monitoring etc.), may eventually become
fatal.
Furthermore, a special provision for the protection of birds against the noise caused by the drones is
not detected in the Regulation. According to the general provision of Art.11 of the Common
Ministerial Decision No 33318/3028/11.12.1998 (Off. Gaz. Β 1289/28-12-1998) implementing
Directive 92/43/EC, only the deliberate disturbance of wildlife during their reproduction season,
during the period in which the pups are dependent on the mother, during hibernation and migration
is prohibited. It is therefore necessary to prove the drone operator's intention to disturb the bird. This
is extremely difficult to prove in case of the use of drone for both recreational and professional
purposes given their general contribution to the environmental protection.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
It follows from the above that there is a paradox with the use of drones. While they generally
contribute to the protection of the environment, they run the risk of disturbing birds. The
environmental factors that should be taken into account by the legislator for the operation of drones
over environmental protection areas are abstract and general in both German and Greek law. There
is therefore a need for a common European Regulation that will introduce clear restrictions on the
drone flights over sensitive ecosystems such as nature reserves and the Natura sites. The restrictions
in order to be clear and efficient, should provide for the permissible distance between the operator
and the drone and prohibit on the basis or numerical criteria low flights of drones over the abovementioned areas. Geo-fencing technology (software program incorporated in the drone to define
geographical boundaries) could be especially helpful for the achievement of this goal.
References
1. Brahms F. and Maslaton M. (2016) ‘Die gewerbliche Nutzung von Drohnen im Lichte der
geplanten Novelle der LuftVO’, Neue Zeitschrift für Verwaltungsrecht, Vol. 16, pp. 1125 –
1130.
2. Juul M. (2015) ‘Briefing of the European Parliamentary Research Service, Civil drones in the
European
1081
Environmental law and economics
Union’http://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/BRIE/2015/571305/EPRS_BRI%282015
%29571305_EN.pdf (accessed February 28th, 2018).
3. Müllenstedt D. (2015) ‘Technische Grundlagen des Einsatzes von unbemannten
Flugsystemen,http://docplayer.org/19747107-Technische-grundlagen-des-einsatzes-vonunbemannten-flugsystemen.html (accessed February 28th, 2018).
4. House of Lords and European Union Committee (2015) ‘7th Report of Session 2014-15. Civilian
Use of Drones in the EU’, https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld201415/ldselect/ldeucom/122/122.pdf (accessed February 28th, 2018).
5. Sattler Y. and Regh T. (2011) ‘Unbemannte Flugsysteme im zivilen Krisenmanagement. Echte
Perspektive oder technische Spielerei? ‘https://www.bbk.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/BBK/DE/Publikationen/Publ_magazin/bsmag_1_11.pdf?__blob=publicationFile
(accessed
February 28th, 2018).
6. Mayntz M. (2017) ‘Birds and Drones. Drones - Helpful or Harmful to Birds?’
https://www.thespruce.com/birds-and-drones-3571688 (accessed February 28th, 2018).
7. European Commission (2015) ‘Proposal for a Regulation on the European Parliament and of the
Council on common rules in the field of civil aviation and establishing a European Union Aviation
Safety Agency, and repealing Regulation (EC) No 216/2008 of the European Parliament and of
the
Council’,
http://eur-lex.europa.eu/resource.html?uri=cellar:da8dfec1-9ce9-11e5-878101aa75ed71a1.0001.02/DOC_1&format=PDF (accessed February 28th, 2018).
8. Riga Declaration on remotely piloted aircraft (drones) (2015) ‘Framing the future of aviation’,
https://ec.europa.eu/transport/sites/transport/files/modes/air/news/doc/2015-03-06-drones/201503-06-riga-declaration-drones.pdf (accessed February 28th, 2018).
9. European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) (2015) ‘Proposal to create common rules for operating
drones in Europe’, https://www.easa.europa.eu/system/files/dfu/205933-01-EASA_Summary%20of%20the%20ANPA.pdf (accessed February 28th, 2018).
10. Schrader C. (2017) ‘Drohnen und Naturschutzrecht’, Natur und Recht, Vol. 39, pp. 378 – 385.
11. Thaysen J. (2016) ‘Mehr Wildrettung bei der Mahd‘, https://www.lksh.de/fileadmin/dokumente/Bauernblatt/PDF_Toepper_2016/BB_16_23.04/44-45_Thaysen.pdf
(accessed
February 28th, 2018).
12. Landmann R., Rohmer G. and Gellermann M. (2017) ‘Umweltrecht, Kommentar’, § 23
BNatSchG, recital 19, C.H. Beck, Munich.
13. Landmann R., Rohmer G. and Gellermann M. (2017) ‘Umweltrecht, Kommentar’, § 44
BNatSchG, recital 10, C.H. Beck, Munich.
14. Giesberts L., Reinhardt M., Gläß A. – C. (2017) ‘BeckOK Umweltrecht’, § 39 BNatSchG, recital
3, C.H. Beck, Munich.
1082
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Water and wastewater treatment and management
1083
Water and wastewater treatment and management
1084
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
FROM WASTE TO ENERGY: OPTIMIZING GROWTH OF
MICROALGAE SCENEDESMUS OBLIQUUS IN UNTREATED
ENERGETIC-LADEN WASTEWATER STREAMS FROM AN
AMMUNITION FACILITY FOR BIOENERGY PRODUCTION
A. RoyChowdhury1, J. Abraham1, T. Abimbola1, Y. Lin1, C. Christodoulatos1, A.
Lawal1, P. Arienti2, B. Smolinski2, and W. Braida1*
1
Stevens Institute of Technology 2RDECOM-ARDEC, Picatinny Arsenal
*Corresponding Author: email: wbraida@stevens.edu, Tel: +1 516 567 4835
Abstract
Wastewaters from industrial ammunition facilities often contain enough nutrients to support
microalgae growth. Initial studies showed promising results on sustaining growth of a freshwater
microalgae Scenedesmus obliquus under a blend of untreated energetic-laden wastewater from an
industrial ammunition facility. Initial laboratory studies were scaled up to 100L open raceway
reactors for growing S. obliquus in the same untreated wastewater mixture. The raceway reactors
were set-up up as follows: 50 rpm paddle-mixer speed, 14:10 hours light:dark photoperiod, and 6895 µmol/m2/s of light intensity. Continuous monitoring of pH and temperature of the growth medium,
periodic analysis of cell density and dry weight of microalgae, and analysis of the media’s nutrient
contents were performed. Biomass harvesting from the raceway reactors was conducted on a weekly
basis and the harvested algal biomass was tested for its oil content. Different conditions such as light
penetration, nutrient availability, and retention times were evaluated in order to optimize the biomass
growth as well as the oil content of S. obliquus in a semi-continuous setting. The results showed that
only nitrogen starvation increased the lipid production from 13% to 29% of oil based on the dry
weight of biomass, whereas no increment in oil or biomass production was noticed with the increase
of light penetration in the two different retention times tested. This study provided significant
information towards microalgae growth in energetic-laden wastewater streams. This study also
showed that wastewaters from industrial ammunition facilities can be reused for culturing microalgae,
which can be utilized for renewable energy production.
Keywords: microalgae, energetic-laden wastewater, renewable energy
1.
INTRODUCTION
The manufacturing of energetic compounds at industrial ammunitions facilities generates large
variety of wastewater streams containing organic pollutants (e.g., solvents, energetic materials
residues, reagents) which are also rich in nutrients, mainly nitrogen. These streams are subject to
regulatory discharge permits and require different levels of treatment (e.g., physical-chemical,
biological) prior to disposal into adjacent water bodies. Previous studies have shown (Abraham et
al., 2016, 2018; RoyChowdhury et al., 2017) that many of these streams can support algae growth
without or with minimal treatment. For this study, 10 different untreated wastewater samples were
obtained from an industrial ammunition plant. Laboratory based toxicity studies showed that several
of these untreated wastewater samples could be used to grow microalgae Scenedesmus obliquus at
appropriate dilution levels. Thus, 100L open raceway reactors were set-up for culturing Scenedesmus
obliquus in ammunition-laden untreated wastewater streams with the objective of assess biomass and
1085
Water and wastewater treatment and management
oil productivity depending upon reactor operation conditions (nutrient level, hydraulic retention time,
and light penetration).
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Based on the results of our previous laboratory studies a mixture of wastewaters was prepared by
mixing 55% of wastewater#2, 40% of wastewater# 4, and 5 % of wastewater#1 diluted 1000 times in
wastewater#3 to use it as culture media of Scenedesmus obliquus. The characteristic of the individual
wastewater samples along with the mixture are presented in Table 1.
Table 1. Characterization of selected untreated waste streams and their mixture.
Waste
pH
TN
NNTP
TOC
Energetic
N-NO3
Streams
NH
Compound
3
NO2
(ppm)
(ppm) (ppm)
Identified
(ppm) (ppm)
(ppm)
1
5.12
287,000
82,400
124,645
B.D.L.
B.D.L.
192
-
2
6.75
33.70
0.53
1.21
1.41
0.04
57.1
RDX
3
4.61
16.30
28.30
B.D.L.
B.D.L.
0.04
175
-
4
6.59
221
12.70
2.84
70.86
0.12
2132
RDX, NTO,
NQ
Mixture
7.06
87
4.45
19.8
B.D.L.
77.5
1042
RDX
TN: total nitrogen, TP: total phosphorus, TOC: total organic carbon, B.D.L. = below method detection
limit.
2.1 Setting-up 100L Raceway Reactor for Algal Culture Using Untreated Wastewater
Initially, one 100L raceway reactor (R1) was filled up with 90L mixed wastewater, then the chemicals
present in commercial BG-11 media were added to it with exception of all nitrogen sources as it is
presented in Table 2. Then reactor was inoculated with 10L of Scenedesmus obliquus inoculum. The
reactor was operated under a 14:10 hour light:dark period, 68-95 µmol photons/m2/s light intensity
(using a HydroFarm FLP46, fluorescent grow light fixture), and 50 rpm speed of the rotating wheel.
Every week a 10L volume was removed (harvested) from the reactor and was processed for oil
extraction as described below. DI water was added in the raceway reactor (~1-1.5L/day) every day to
make-up the natural evaporation of water from the raceway reactor and to maintain the 100L working
volume. The raceway reactor was equipped with a continuous monitoring systems of pH and
temperature and these data was logged in and saved for recording purposes. Samples were
periodically collected and analyzed for cell density (by measuring fluorescence at 685 nm using a
Synergy mx Biotek microplate reader), dry weight (following standard USEPA protocol), change in
nutrient concentrations (using a Dionex IC with IonPac 4 mm×250 mm AS16 column equipped with
a IonPac 4 mm×50 mm AG16 guard column), and RDX concentration change over time (using
Agilent HPLC). The 100L raceway reactor, R1 was operated for a period of 37 days.
2.2
Culture of Scenedesmus obliquus in Raceway Reactors using untreated wastewater and
50L working volume
It has been shown that light penetration plays an important role in algae growth. Over time, it was
observed that the liquor in R1 was getting darker as a result of algae growth which was potentially
inhibiting light penetration and uniform light distribution throughout the reactor. In order to assess
light penetration, the entire 100L content of the R1 reactor was divided into two aliquots and two new
raceway reactors with a working volume of 50L each were set-up and were labelled as R2 and R3. It
was hypothesized that by lowering the total volume inside the reactor from 100L to 50L the light
penetration pathway will be reduced allowing a better light distribution throughout the whole reactor
1086
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
volume. Both raceway reactors were kept under the same operating condition as of raceway reactor
R1. This study was also designed to analyze the impact of different retention time on algae growth.
In order to assess this, 10L working volume was harvested from R2 and 4L working volume was
harvested from R3 on a weekly basis. The harvested liquor was processed for oil extraction and the
equivalent amount of wastewater mix was added to each of the reactors after harvesting. Natural
evaporation from the reactors was compensated as described in section 2.1. As before, continuous
monitoring of pH and temperature of the culture media was performed for both reactors. Periodically,
samples were collected from both reactors and were analyzed for cell density, dry weight, change in
nutrient concentrations, and RDX concentration over time following the previously mentioned
analytical procedures. Both reactors were operated for 77 days.
Table 2. Composition of media used for Scenedesmus obliquus culture in 100L raceway
reactor. This media was prepared by modifying Sigma Aldrich’s C3061- BG-11 medium.
Composition
mg/L
1
Magnesium sulfate. 7H2O
75
2
Potassium phosphate dibasic
40
3
Calcium Chloride dihydrate
36
4
Sodium carbonate
20
5
Citric acid
6
6
Ferric ammonium citrate
6
7
Boric acid
2.86
8
Manganese chloride. 4H2O
1.81
9
EDTA disodium magnesium
1
10
Sodium molybdate. 2H2O
0.39
11
Zinc sulfate. 7 H2O
0.222
12
Cupric sulfate. 5H2O
0.079
13
Colbat nitrate. 6H2O
0.0494
2.3 Harvesting of Algae
Algae slurry/liquor removed from the raceway reactors was first subjected to gravity settling for 24h
after which the supernatant was decanted. The biomass rich slurry after gravity settling was further
dewatered using an EXD explosion-proof centrifuge purchased from Thermo-Electron Corporation.
The centrifuge has a maximum capacity of 6L (1L in each of the 6 centrifuge cups) with a working
volume of 4.8L (800mL in each of the 6 centrifuge cups). The slurry samples to be centrifuged were
collected in 1000mL Nalgene™ PPCO centrifuge bottles. The centrifuge was run at 2900rpm for 15
minutes. After the removal of water, the final concentrated slurry from each of the bottles were added
together to make one sample slurry. The final slurry was further homogenously mixed on the shaker
before the dry weight was determined.
2.4 Dry Weight Determination of Algae Slurry and Paste
A CO2 Resistant Shaker operating at 120rpm was used to mix the slurry for 10 minutes before dry
weight determinations. Then, 2mL of the sample slurry was collected in each of 3 tared sample tubes.
Whatman glass microfiber filter purchased from Fisher Scientific with a pore size of 0.7micron were
first rinsed with de-ionized water by placing a stack (minimum of 2) on a filter funnel and then
deionized water was made to flow through with the aid of a vacuum pump. The filter were ashed in
1087
Water and wastewater treatment and management
a furnace at 550°C for 20 minutes. The 2mL samples collected were then vacuum filtered and all
solids in the sample were retained on the glass microfiber filter. The three sample residues obtained
from the filtration step were collected in an aluminum pan and placed in an oven at 105°C for 16
hours to completely dry the sample. The dry weight percent was calculated as shown below:
Dry weight (%)
mass of (dry biomass + filter paper) (g)-mass of ashed filter paper (g)
×100
mass of the 2mL sample (g)
(1)
2.5 Extraction of Oil from Algae and Quantification of Extractables
A Soxhlet extractor equipped with Whatman cellulose thimbles of pore size 10µm and dimensions
27mm X 80mm (external diameter x external length) (Fisher Scientific) was used for oil extraction
using ethanol (Reagent Grade) as solvent. The biomass to solvent ratio used was 1:25 and the heating
mantle was set to 150°C. The time taken for complete extraction varies between 6 and 10 hours. The
boiling flask with the wet extracted lipids was placed in an oven at 105°C for 16 hours for complete
dryness. After drying, the dried lipid was weighed relative to the tared boiling flask and recorded.
The weight percent of the lipid extract was calculated as shown below:
% wt of extractables (lipids) in dry biomass=
3.
dry mass of lipids (g)
×100
dry mass of biomass, m (g)
(2)
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Culture of Scenedesmus obliquus in 100L Raceway Reactor (R1)
Over the 37 days of the experiment, the average pH of the media in R1 was 8.6 ± 0.16, and the average
temperature was 19.9°C ± 0.6. pH values were within the optimum algae growth range (pH 7-9)
throughout the study. Although the raceway reactor was open and maintained under laboratory
condition, the temperature was always within optimum algae growth range, 18-25°C.
Figure 1 represents the changes in cell density and dry weight for the algal culture over time. At the
end of the study (day 37), cell density in the reactor was 2.49 × 107 cells/mL. The fluctuation in the
cell density observed in Figure 1 was due to the harvesting process. The gradual increase in the dry
weight in R1 can also be seen in Figure 1. The highest dry weight was obtained in the raceway reactor
at day 35 and was 0.4± 0.1 g/L. Both, cell density and dry weight increases, were indicative of algal
growth in R1 and showed that Scenedesmus obliquus can grow in untreated ammunition-laden
wastewater without showing any toxic impact. No external nitrogen source (in form of nitrogen
containing salts) was added into the system during this study assuming that all necessary nitrogen
sources would be provided by the wastewater streams. After each week’s harvesting and addition of
10L of wastewater mixture to compensate for the volume harvested, total nitrogen concentration of
the system always increased (data not shown). Concentrations of nitrate and sulfate (data not shown)
indicates that suitable nutrient sources were present in the media for sustaining algae growth
throughout the experiment. Figure 2 shows the change in color in R1 as result of algae growth.
3.2 Culture of Scenedesmus obliquus in 50L Raceway Reactors R2 and R3
The daily change in pH and temperature in reactors R2 and R3 were logged in through their respective
probes and data acquisition system. The average pH of R2 and R3 were 8.45± 0.33 and 8.58±
0.31,respectively, both values within the 7-9 optimum pH range. The average temperature of R2 and
R3 were 17.36°C ± 1.19 and 17.03°C ± 1.08, respectively.
1088
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Dry Weight (g/L)
Cell Density (cells/mL)
3.00E+07
2.50E+07
2.00E+07
1.50E+07
1.00E+07
5.00E+06
0.00E+00
0
5
0.45
0.4
0.35
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0
10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Time (days)
5
10
15 20 25
Time (Days)
30
35
40
Figure 1. Change in S. obliquus cell density (left) and dry weight (right) in the 100L raceway
reactor, R1 over time.
Figure 2. R1 color evolution as a result of algae growth.
Figure 3 presents the changes in cell density of the algae culture for R2 and R3 over time. In both
reactors cell density gradually increased over time. No significant difference in cell density was found
between R2 and R3 throughout the study. Also, no major difference in cell density was observed
between R1, R2 and R3 on equivalent time point throughout the study. For example on day 37 of
study the measured cell density of R1, R2 and R3 were 2.49 × 107, 2.15× 107, and 3.26× 107 cells/mL,
respectively. This result showed that different light penetration paths (changing depths) did not made
any significant change in algal growth for the system tested. It was found that at day 77, cell density
in R2 and R3 were 5.08 × 107 and 5.67 × 107 cells/mL, respectively. Figure 3 also presents the change
of dry weight in algal culture in R2 and R3 over time. A steady increase in dry weight was noticed in
both reactors during the study. A dry weight of 0.88± 0.15 and 1.31± 0.23 g/L was found in R2 and
R3 respectively on day 77. At the beginning of this study, nitrate and phosphate salts (sodium nitrate
and sodium phosphate monobasic) were added to both reactors at a N:P ratio of 15:1 (150 mg/L of
nitrate and 10 mg/L of phosphate) to ensure that the media in both reactors contained enough nutrient
to support algae growth. Due to the depletion of nutrient levels inside the reactors, a second addition
of nitrogen and phosphate salts at the 15:1 ratio was made to both reactors on day 31. All throughout
the study a steady decrease in nitrate concentration was observed in both reactors which correlates
with the steady increase of algae biomass (data not shown).
1089
Water and wastewater treatment and management
8.00E+07
Dry Weight (g/L)
Cell Density (cells/mL)
1.00E+08
6.00E+07
4.00E+07
2.00E+07
0.00E+00
1.40
1.20
1.00
0.80
0.60
0.40
0.20
0.00
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
0
Time (days)
R2
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
Time (Days)
R3
R2
R3
Figure 3. Change in S. obliquus cell density (left) and dry weight (right) in the 50L raceway
reactor, R2 and R3, over time.
3.3 Effect of Phosphorus and Nitrogen Concentration on the Amount of Algae Oil Recovered
Oil extraction was carried out on a weekly basis (7 days interval) by implementing the protocols
presented in sections 2.3, 2.4 and 2.5. Table 3 shows the amount of oil extracted along with the
concentrations of nutrients in the reactor at the time of harvesting S. obliquus (R1). Prior to the weekly
oil extraction, triplicate concentrated algae slurry samples were prepared from the 10L of liquor
harvested from the raceways by dewatering the sample to about 5wt% total solid, following the
procedure presented in section 2.3. At the end of the experiment, the oil content of S. obliquus was
recorded as a percentage of the dry weight of the algae slurry sample extracted. The maximum
deviation of oil content from average oil content recorded was 0.5%. The trends in the variation of
algae oil content with nutrient are shown in Figures 4(a.) and 4(c.) while oil productivity changes
with nutrient are shown in Figures 4(b.) and 4(d.). Oil productivity is presented in (gal/acre year) to
compare with baseline values used to measure the performance of algae cultivation on large scale.
Table 3. Biomass productivity, oil content and oil Productivity of S. obliquus grown in the
munitions-laden wastewater.
Day
Dry
Biomass
Nitrates Phosphorous
Oil
g oil/m2
Oil
weight Productivity (mg/L)
(mg/L)
content
d
productivity
(g/L)
%
(gallons/acre
(g/m2d)1
year)2
7
0.227
2.903
31.75
10.9
13.0
0.3774
170.44
16
0.326
2.507
29.11
5.8
17.1
0.4321
195.16
23
0.377
2.206
22.1
6.05
14.9
0.3287
148.45
30
0.390
1.781
16.27
2.8
25.6
0.4559
205.91
37
0.374
1.356
14.26
4.7
26.5
0.3593
162.29
1.
Biomass productivity calculated by converting the dry weight (g/L) to (g/m 3), dividing by the time interval (days)
and then multiplying by the pond depth (8inches = 0.2032m).
2.
Oil productivity was calculated by multiplying the oil content with the biomass productivity and an appropriate
conversion factor (451.63) to convert from g/m2/day to gallons/acre/year.
1090
30
20
10
0
5
25
45
Number of Days
250
200
150
100
50
0
60
40
20
0
5
25
45
Number of Days
Nitrate Concentration (ppm)
40
Oil Productivity (Gallons/acre.
Yr)
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Nitrate Concentration (ppm)
Oil Content (%)
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Oil Productivity
Oil Content (%)
Nitrates (ppm)
Nitrate concentration (ppm)
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
25
45
Number of Days
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
5
25
Number of Days
Oil Content (%)
Oil Productivity
Phosphorus Concentration (ppm)
Phosphorus concentration (ppm)
(d.)
10
200
8
150
6
100
4
50
2
0
0
15
25
35
45
30
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
25
Oil Content (%)
250
Biomass Productivity (g/m2 day)
Oil Productivity (Gallons/acre. Yr)
(c.)
5
45
20
15
10
5
0
Number of Days
5
15
25
35
Number of Days
Biomass Productivity (g/m2 day)
5
250
200
150
100
50
0
Phosphorus concentration (ppm)
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Oil Productivity (Gallons/acre.
Yr)
(b.)
Phosphorus Concentration (ppm)
Oil Content (%)
(a.)
45
Oil Productivity
Oil Content
Biomass Productivity
Biomass Productivity
(e.)
(f.)
Figure 4. Variation of oil content and oil productivity of S. obliquus with nutrient
concentration over the period of algae cultivation: (a.) Plot of oil content and nitrate
concentration versus time of cultivation; (b.) Plot of oil productivity and nitrate concentration
versus time of cultivation; (c.) Plot of oil content and phosphorus concentration versus time of
cultivation; (d) Plot of oil productivity and phosphorus concentration versus time of
cultivation; (e.) Plot of oil productivity and biomass productivity versus time of cultivation;
(f.) Plot of oil content and biomass productivity versus time of cultivation.
These baseline values are set at 13g/m2 of biomass a day at 25 wt% oil content which is equivalent
to an oil productivity of 1300 gal/acre year. (Davis et al, 2012). As it was pointed out, the sole source
1091
Water and wastewater treatment and management
of nitrate used in algae cultivation in the R1 experiment was the wastewater. After every weekly
harvest, 10L of fresh wastewater were used to make up the reactor volume and replenish the
consumed nitrates, nevertheless nitrates and phosphorus might have been the limiting substrate for
algae growth during the first experiment.
The oil content of S. obliquus increased as the concentration of nitrate decreased. According to
previous research on the effect of nutrients availability on the accumulation of lipid in algae, nitrogen
starvation is one most critical processes enhancing lipid metabolism in algae (Darzins et al, 2008).
The observed increase in the oil content of algae was a confirmation of this established mechanism
for improving oil content. However, in the third week of the experiment, the oil content dropped and
this was suggested to be the result of the increase in the concentration of phosphorus in the third
week. Figure 4(f.) shows the variation in the oil content and biomass productivity at a given time
points over the growth period while Figure 4(e.) presents the variation of oil productivity and biomass
productivity at given time points during the period of growth. Biomass productivity decreased as a
result of depriving algae of nutrient while the oil content increased (from 13% to 26.5%). On the
other hand, the trend in oil productivity only showed that an optimum exist while the increase in the
concentration of phosphorus in the third week explains the drop in oil productivity during that week.
The variation in the concentrations of nutrients was observed to affect the oil productivity indirectly
through changes in the oil content of algae. Oil productivity can improve if one of the two parameters
(biomass productivity and oil content) is kept fairly constant and the other is increased by using any
of the available mechanisms to achieve this purpose. For example nutrient starvation mechanism can
be implemented to improve the rate of lipid synthesis in algae while other growth parameters such as
light intensity and rate of mixing can be enhanced to keep high biomass productivity. Batch
operations using high nutrient concentration during the exponential growth phase and nutrient
starvation before harvesting could be an alternative approach to maximize oil productivity.
3.4 Effect of Retention Time and Light Penetration on the Amount of Algae Oil Recovered
In this study, S. obliquus liquor cultivated in R1 was divided into two reactors (R2 and R3) to reduce
the depth of algae in the raceways thereby reducing light intensity attenuation. Similarly, weekly
harvest was carried out by removing 10L of algae slurry from R2 while 4L slurry was harvested from
R3. Thus, R2 has shorter retention time compared to R3. These two factors were investigated over a
growth period of 77 days. In the first two weeks, a mix of slurry from the two reactors was dewatered
and used for extraction due to the limited amount of biomass produced. The oil content of algae in
the first and second week of the experiment does not change significantly from the last oil content
obtained in the previous experiment, (26.5±0.2)%. Table 4 shows the oil content of S. obliquus
recovered over the growth period while Figure 5 provides a graphical representation of the oil
recovery trends.
Based on the oil content data obtained for R3 and R2, it was observed that the recovered oil content
from algae in R3 was higher than those in R2 (see Figures 5 and 6). Apart from nutrient-depleted and
harsh environmental conditions to which algae respond by biosynthesizing lipids to store carbon and
energy as an adaptive feature, aging of algal culture can also affect triacylglycerol and fatty acid
composition of algae (Darzins et al, 2008). This explains why the values of oil content of algal slurry
samples from R3 are higher than those from R2. Thus the age of the algae culture (based on the
hydraulic retention time) adds to the effect of nutrient concentrations (nitrogen and phosphorus) on
algae’s oil content. In agreement with the outcome of the previous experiment, oil content of algae
increased with decrease in the concentration of nitrate in both R3 and R2. The effect of nutrient was
evident especially on the 36th day of the experiment (see Figure 5). The maximum deviation from the
average oil content recorded was ±1.65%. In the 5th week, maximum oil content was achieved in R3
(29.5±0.34) % while the maximum oil content obtained in R2 was (27.93±0.15) % in the 10th week.
1092
25
90
20
40
15
10
-10
20
30
40
50
Number of days
60
Oil content of S. obliquus in R2
30
5
4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
25
20
15
10
20
40
Number of days
60
Concentration of phosphorus
(ppm)
140
Oil content of S.obliquus (%)
30
Concentration of nitrate (ppm)
Oil content of S.obliquus (%)
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Oil content of S. obliquus in R2
Oil content of S.obliquus in R3
Oil content of S.obliquus in R3
Concentration of nitrate (ppm)
Concentration of phosphorus (ppm)
(a.)
(b.)
Figure 5. Variation of oil content of S. obliquus with nutrient concentration in R2 and R3 for
the first 60 days: (a.) Variation with nitrate concentration (b.) Variation with phosphorus
concentration.
Day
4.
Table 4. S. obliquus oil content as a function of retention time.
Oil Content R3
Oil Content R2
Oil Content R2/R3
mixture
(4 L sample) %
(10L sample) %
7
-
-
26.73
14
-
-
26.97
21
25.92
21.97
-
31
25.92
23.50
-
36
29.50
26.99
-
43
27.03
23.25
-
50
26.91
22.75
-
60
28.16
23.41
-
70
26.53
24.83
-
77
28.15
27.93
-
CONCLUSIONS
The current research assessed the feasibility of growing microalgae, specifically S. obliquus, using
untreated or minimally treated (e.g. dilution) munitions-laden industrial wastewater with minimum
addition of external sources of nutrients. Nevertheless, extensive optimization work is necessary in
order to bring up biomass yields to accepted industry standards. The influence of light penetration,
hydraulic retention time, and nutrient content was also preliminarily assessed. Light penetration did
not have a major role on algae biomass yield and oil content in the raceway setup using in this study
perhaps due the particular high mixing rate that can be achieved allowing all biomass to be exposed
to light in a fairly constant fashion. Older biomass (higher retention time) appears to favor higher oil
content, although clear trends could not be developed. Nutrient starvation shows the stronger
correlation with algae oil content underlying the need of perform an optimization process using the
engineering variables at hand (nutrient profile, retention time, mixing rate, CO2 uptake, etc.) in order
1093
Oil Content (%)
Water and wastewater treatment and management
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
21
31
36
43
50
60
70
77
Number of days
Oil Content R2 (10L sample)
Oil Content R3 (4L sample)
Figure 6. Changes on oil content of S. obliquus in R2 and R3 over the entire growth period.
to maximize the algae oil yield which is the product of the algae biomass yield times the algae’s oil
content. Lastly, the fate of the energetic materials during algae growth is not discussed as it was
outside the scope of the current study.
Acknowledgment
This work was supported by the Consortium for Energy, Environment and Demilitarization (CEED)
contract number SINIT-15-0013.
References
1. Abraham J., A. RoyChowdhury, C. Christodoulatos, Y. Lin P. Arienti, B. Smolinski, and W.
Braida (2016) ‘The cycle of nutrients at industrial plants: valorization of energetic-laden
nd
wastewater streams using microalgae Scenedesmus obliquus to produce bioenergy’, 2 RCN
Conference on Pan American Biofuels & Bioenergy Sustainability, Buenos Aires, Argentina,
September 13-16, 2016.
2. Abraham J., Y. Lin, A. RoyChowdhury, C. Christodoulatos, P. Arienti, B. Smolinski, and W.
Braida (2018) ‘From Waste to Energy: Algae Toxicological Assessment and Valorization of
Energetic-laden Wastewater Streams Using Scenedesmus obliquus’, Journal of Cleaner
Production (submitted, under review).
3. Davis R., D. Fishman, E.D. Frank, M.S. Wigmosta, A. Aden, A.A. Coleman, P.T. Pienkos, R.J.
Skaggs, E.R. Venteris, and M.Q. Wang, M.Q. (2012). Renewable Diesel from Algal Lipids: An
Integrated Baseline for Cost, Emissions, and Resource Potential from a Harmonized Model.
http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy12osti/55431.pdf.
4. Darzins A., Q. Hu, M. Sommerfeld, E. Jarvis, M. Ghirardi, M. Posewitz, and M. Seibert, (2008).
Microalgal triacylglycerols as feedstocks for biofuel production: perspectives and advances, The
Plant Journal. 54, 621-639.
5. RoyChowdhury, A., J. Abraham, C. Christodoulatos, Y. Lin, P. Arienti, B. Smolinski, and W.
Braida (2017) Generation of bioenergy from energetic-compounds-contaminated wastewater
streams using microalgae Scenedesmus obliquus. 33rd Annual International Conference on Soils,
Sediments, Water, and Energy. Amherst, Massachusetts October 16-19, 2017.
1094
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
ELUTION HISTORY OF BASIC OXYGEN FURNACE SLAG TO
PRODUCE AKLALINE WATER FOR REAGENT PURPOSES
A. Caicedo-Ramirez1, M.T. Hernandez1, D.G. Grubb2,*
1
Department of Civil, Environmental, and Architectural Engineering, University of Colorado
Boulder, ECOT 441 UCB 428, Boulder, CO 80309-0428, USA
2
Phoenix Services LLC, 148 W. State Street, Suite 301, Kennett Square, PA 19348 USA
*Corresponding Author: email: dennis.grubb@phxslag.com, tel: +12155272786
Abstract
This paper summarizes the elution history of packed BOF slag fines (< 10 mm diameter) after a
running liquid:solid (L/S) ratio of 1573 L/kg (13111 pore volumes or PV) with an empty bed contact
time (EBCT) of 15 min. High alkalinity (>1000 mg CaCO3/L) was obtained up to a L/S 63 L/Kg (526
PV). pH >12 persisted to about L/S <77 L/Kg (580 PV), then monotonically decreased to
approximately 11 at 150 L/Kg (1245 PV) when it appears the residual lime/portlandite content was
exhausted, which triggered the dissolution of calcium silicates, most prominently, larnite. The pH
plateaued thereafter, likely due to buffering effect of silicic acid (pKa1(H4SiO4) ≈ 9.8) from the larnite.
Thereafter, calcium concentration approached background levels of the influent tap water (~12.10
mg/L) whereas the dissolved silicon increased and remained steady between 1 and 10 mg/L. The
mass loss of BOF slag fines measured at the end of the experiment was 19.4 wt%. Based on the
QXRD data, the sequential dissolution of lime/portlandite and larnite appear to be the dominant
processes driving changes in alkalinity, pH, and aqueous elemental composition. Aluminum
hydroxide [Al(OH)3] also dissolved, further adding to the amorphous content. The Toxicity
Characteristic Leaching Procedure (TCLP) and de-ionized water leaching data suggest that the BOF
slag fines are non-hazardous, and exceptionally clean from an environmental perspective and
compare very well with the TCLP data of other US BOF slags [Proctor et al 2000], in either the virgin
or exhausted form.
Keywords: BOF slag, leaching, XRD, calcium, silicon, pH buffering,
1.
INTRODUCTION
Prior research conducted at the Stevens Institute of Technology [Jagupilla et al 2012a,b; Grubb et al
2016a,b] revealed that the leaching of a ~0.3 m long, 10.2 cm diameter packed column of <10 mm
basic oxygen furnace (BOF) steel slag aggregate particles by tap water and acidic metals-laden
solutions at typical groundwater velocities (~1 m/day) did not reduce the effluent pH of the BOF slag
packed column below its natural pH of approximately 12.5 for over a 100 pore volumes (PV). This
was due, in part, to the very strong alkaline buffering capacity of the BOF slag. Grubb et al [Grubb
et al 2011] showed that the 10 mm minus fraction (BOF slag fines) took 7.5 equivalents of HNO3 to
achieve a neutral pH at a liquid:solid (L/S) ratio of 20:1. The BOF slag was found to contain
approximately 10-15 wt% lime/portlandite as well as several other Ca, Fe and Mg silicates and oxides
that produced alkalinity. Since there is anecdotal evidence BOF slag excavated from the internal cores
of historical dumps and stockpiles dating back to the 1800s and impacted ground water have pH
values close to its natural pH of 12.0 to 12.5 [e.g. Roadcap et al 2005], this naturally lead to the
question as to when the pH would significantly drop by water leaching. Accordingly, a study was
undertaken to intentionally leach a BOF slag sample in attempt to lower its pH near neutrality. This
1095
Water and wastewater treatment and management
is the first step in an assessment of the potential value of using BOF slag eluate as a possible reagent
substitute for conventional lime-water or for irrigation purposes, as silicic acid (H4SiO4) is an
essential source of silica for plant growth and health to improve the blight, pest and drought resistance
of plants [Datnoff et al 2011].
2.
MATERIALS & METHODS
2.1 BOF Slag media
Freshly crushed, screened, and de-metallized BOF slag fines (< 10 mm diameter) produced at the
Indiana Harbor East (IHE) Steel Mill in East Chicago, IN, were randomly collected and stored in a
sealable clean plastic bucket at their natural moisture content. These materials were used as-is for
column testing. The total and leaching behavior of the BOF slag media is described elsewhere [Grubb
et al submitted].
2.2
Column Experiment
Two clear PVC columns, end caps and all tubing were fabricated to study the elution history of the
BOF slag fines in parallel. The column diameter and length were set at 8.5 cm (3.35 in) and 10.4 cm
(4.09 in), respectively. A schematic and photo of the packed column is shown in Figure 1.
Preliminary determination of the pore volume (PV) of the packed column was as follows: 500 g of
BOF slag fines was added to the elution column in a vertical orientation. Next, tap water was slowly
added and the water-slag slurry was mixed until saturation. The column was then gently tamped until
all visibly entrapped air bubbles were removed. The volume of water added to reach saturation was
defined as the PV (60 mL).
Figure 1. A) Elution system diagram with relevant design parameters. B) Photograph of the
elution system (front view). Flow direction indicated with blue arrows.
1096
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
A palladium circular screen (mesh size 2 mm) was inserted at 4.05 cm from the bottom of the empty
elution column to facilitate the uniform egress and flow of the tap water into the packed column. Prior
slag addition, a filter paper (No.1 Whatman) was placed completely covering the mesh in order to
avoid solid fines from settling at the bottom. Leak-proof grease and paraffin film were used to secure
the end caps to the column. The columns were packed with 500 g of pre-wetted BOF slag fines on
top of the filter paper to facilitate workability and densification. Based on the aspect ratio (H/L)
considerations, the compacted height of the BOF slag media in the column was 4.76 cm (1.87 in).
The elution process was conducted in a continuous up-flow mode through use of a peristaltic pump
(Masterflex® L/STM 7520-10, Cole-Parmer). The eluate from the columns was directed to the
bottom of equally-sized cylindrical PVC reservoirs. Effluent samples were taken at half the height
of the reservoir by means of a septum sampling port. An Empty Bed Contact Time (EBCT) of 15
minutes was used to reliably achieve a target effluent construction of approximately 1000 mg/L Ca
and pH~12.5 consistent with the equilibrium concentration of Ca from prior column and EPA 1313
testing [Jagupilla et al 2012b; Grubb et al submitted].
Eluate samples (25 mL) were taken at different PV intervals from both packed columns and were
analyzed for pH, alkalinity, conductivity, and elemental composition (Ca, Si, Al, Fe, Mg, Mn, Na,
K). pH and conductivity were measured by using a calibrated pH meter (SympHony SP70P, VWR),
and conductivity meter (FiveGoTM F3, Mettler Toledo). Alkalinity was measured by titration of
aliquots with 0.1 N H2SO4 to a final pH of 4.5. Elemental composition of the eluate was determined
by inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometer (ICP-OES), on a calibrated ARL 3410+.
An analytical blank, along with three standards that were made by accurately diluting certified
standards, were used for calibration.
3.
RESULTS
The elution history for the two parallel elution systems was recorded for a total running L/S of
approximately 1573 L/kg (13111 PV) and reported as the averages, as shown in Figure 2. Influent tap
water elemental concentrations were monitored for the duration of the experiment and used as
background control, as provided in Table 1.
Alkalinity changes were described by an initial sharp decreasing profile. High alkalinity (>1000 mg
CaCO3/L) was obtained up to 63 L/kg (526 PV). After 318 L/kg (2650 PV), a plateau was reached
and minimum changes occur thereafter. A similar trend was observed for dissolved calcium, which
rapidly decreased from ~870 mg/L to the background level of the influent water (~12.1 mg/L) after
L/S 150 L/kg (1245 PV). pH decreased from ~12.5 to ~9.7 after 505 L/kg (4212 PV) and stabilized
at ~9.7 for the duration of the experiment.
The BOF slag elution history suggests that most of the alkalinity was initially provided by dissolution
of readily available calcium compounds (e.g. lime and portlandite). Lime (CaO) readily hydrates to
portlandite [Ca(OH)2] which further dissociates producing the initially very elevated pH (~12.5) and
Ca concentration observed in Figure 2. As the lime and portlandite are exhausted, this triggers the
dissolution of many other minerals in the BOF slag, including larnite [Ca2(SiO4)]. Larnite, a major
constituent of BOF slag (see Table 2), initially hydrates to produce portlandite and the ultimate endproducts of the dissolution process are OH-, Ca and dissolved silicates such as silicic acid, or H4(SiO4)
[Roadcap et al 2005; Huijgen and Comans, 2006; de Windt et al 2001; van Zomeren et al 2011], the
latter of which has a pKa on the order of 9.7 to 9.9.
This explanation is reinforced by the observed changes in elemental Si concentrations in the BOF
slag eluate. Silicon concentrations increased then fluctuated between 1 and 10 mg/L after 260 L/Kg
(2160 PV). Aluminum concentration was observed at ~ 0.1 mg/L until L/S 260 L/Kg (2160 PV). A
slightly decreasing profile occurred thereafter. All other analyzed elements (except for aluminum)
were found within, or below, the concentration range of the influent water for the duration of the
experiment (see Table 1).
1097
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Split samples of the BOF slag fines in their “as-received” (virgin) and “exhausted” (exhausted)
condition after L/S 1575 L/kg (13100 PV) leaching were analyzed by quantitative x-ray powder
diffraction (QXRD) using the Rietveld (1969) method, the Toxicity Characteristic Leaching
Procedure (TCLP; EPA Method 1311) and De-ionized water (DIW) leaching by ASTM D3987. The
raw QXRD results based on the analysis of two replicates are shown in Table 2. The exhausted BOF
slag fines results may somewhat reflect that the inner core of the larger BOF slag particles (10 mm
top size) may still resemble its initial composition because it was occluded from the pore solution
during the extended leaching test. Nevertheless, comparison of the two samples still reveals several
significant differences in the mineralogy of the virgin and exhausted BOF slag fines by the Student
t-test with p<0.05. The mineralogical trends suggest that the sequential dissolution of
lime/portlandite and larnite resulted in the increased formation of amorphous and calcite/vaterite
(both CaCO3). Aluminum hydroxide [Al(OH)3] also dissolves, further adding to the amorphous
content.
Figure 2. (TOP) Average alkalinity (Alk), dissolved calcium and pH of BOF slag eluate with
increasing L/S ratio. (BOTTOM) Average concentrations of major elements (Ca, Si, Al) of
BOF slag eluate with increasing L/S ratio. Dotted lines indicate the detection limit (DL) for
each element.
1098
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 1. Average influent tap water concentrations of major elements (mg/L) and total
alkalinity (mg CaCO3/L) (n=4).
Ca Si Mg Na K Mn
Al
Fe Alk
Average 12.10 1.86 1.64 3.33 0.28 <0.001
<0.007 <0.06 25.2
St. Dev. 6.62 0.28 0.6
-
1.69 0.48 -
-
9.3
The mineralogical change correlates well with the dissolved elemental concentration history
previously presented in Figure 2. Due to the extended elution duration, a significant portion of the
initial BOF slag was lost. Figure 3 shows the normalized weight percentages of the key minerals
corrected for the 19.4 wt% mass loss between virgin and exhausted BOF slag fines. To make the
trends clear in Figure 3, the lime and portlandite contents have been paired because of their linkage
by direct hydration. Also paired are the calcium carbonates (calcite and vaterite) as these are
polymorphs and constitute the end-products of the carbonation of slag by atmospheric CO2. The loss
of the residual lime content and carbonation of the BOF slag are unmistakable, as is the loss of larnite,
very likely by the aforementioned hydration reactions that produce the silicate concentrations
observed in the Figure 2 and Table 3.
Table 2 Average QXRD results of virgin and exhausted <10 mm BOF Slag fines (n=2).
Compounds
Mineral Name
Formula
Virgin BOF
Slag Fines
Exhausted BOF
Slag Fines
Averag
e
Averag
e
SD
wt%
Amorphous Material
Significant
Difference
SD
(t-test,
p<0.05)
wt%
40.7
1.8
47.3
0.6
Yes
Srebrodolskite
Ca2Fe2O5
13.4
0.6
14.5
0.1
No
Larnite
Ca2SiO4
10.9
0.1
7.8
0.0
Yes
Portlandite
Ca(OH)2
6.0
0.0
0.6
0.0
Yes
Wuestite
FeO
5.5
0.1
6.1
0.4
No
Magnesioferrite
MgFe2O4
5.6
0.3
6.4
0.0
No
Calcite
CaCO3
4.2
0.1
7.1
0.4
Yes
Nordstrandite/Gibbsi
te
Al(OH)3
4.2
0.4
1.2
0.1
Yes
Akermanite
Ca2(Mg0.75Al0.25)(Si1.75Al0.25
O7)
2.9
0.1
3.1
0.8
No
Fe0.23Mg0.77O
2.2
0.1
2.6
0.1
Yes
Vaterite
CaCO3
1.7
0.1
1.6
0.0
No
Lime
CaO
1.3
0.1
1.1
0.0
No
Periclase
MgO
1.2
0.4
0.5
0.1
No
Hydrotalcite
Mg6Al2(CO3)(OH)16-4(H2O)
0.5
0.2
0.2
0.3
No
Quartz
SiO2
0.3
0.1
0.3
0.1
No
Sum
100.2
0.1
100.2
0.1
Magnesium
Oxide
Iron
Notes: wt% = percent by dry weight based on averages.
1099
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Figure 3 Mineralogical comparison of virgin and exhausted BOF slag fines (<10mm fraction)
after a running L/S of 1575 L/kg (13100 PV) of water flow, corrected for mass loss (19.4
wt%). P = Portlandite, L = Lime, V = Vaterite, C = Calcite.
Table 3 shows the TCLP for the virgin and exhausted BOF slag fines samples as well as the DIW
leaching of the exhausted BOF slag fines by ASTM D3987 for the EPA Target Analyte List (TAL)
metals, less mercury (Hg), as it typically occurs at <0.5 mg/kg in BOF slag [Proctor et al 2000]. The
RCRA metals limits are shown for comparison to illustrate the both the virgin and exhausted BOF
slag fines are non-hazardous. The TCLP data suggest that the BOF slag fines are exceptionally clean
from an environmental perspective and compare very well with the TCLP data of other US BOF slag
[Proctor et al 2000], in either the virgin or exhausted form.
1100
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 3 Leaching comparison of virgin and exhausted <10 mm BOF slag fines after approximately 13100 PV tap water leaching (L/S ~ 1575).
Constituent
post-extraction
(SU)
Metals (mg/L)
Virgin BOF Slag Fines
RCRA (TCLP)
Symbol (mg/L) Replicate 1
Replicate 2
-
Average
Exhausted BOF Slag Fines
(TCLP)
Replicate 1
Replicate 2
12.7
10.7
Average
Exhausted BOF Slag Fines
(ASTM DI Water)
Replicate 1
Replicate 2
Average
10.8
10.7
10.8
pH
12
12.6
Aluminum
Al
Antimony
Sb
Arsenic
As
5
Barium
Ba
100
0.13
Beryllium
Be
Cadmium
Cd
Calcium
Ca
Chromium
Cr
Cobalt
1
12.7
10.8
10.9
0.90
J
0.46
J
0.68
J
0.79
J
0.48
J
0.64
J
0.17
0.0014
J
0.0011
U
0.0013
J
0.0011
U
0.0011
U
0.0011
U
0.00080 UJ
0.00080 U
0.00080 UJ
0.0027
U
0.0027
U
0.0027
U
0.0027
U
0.0027
U
0.0027
U
0.00040 U
0.00040 U
0.00040 U
0.0046
0.0074
0.0060
0.56
0.35
0.045
0.93
0.49
J
B
0.17
J
B
0.17
J
B
0.00043 U
0.00043 F1F2 0.00043 U
0.00043 U
0.00043 U
0.00043 U
0.00010 U
0.00010 U
0.00010 U
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.00010 U
0.00010 U
0.00010 U
75
F1
72
0.046
B
0.048
U
U
0.0010
U
U
U
U
1300
1500
1400
680
750
715
68
0.0099
0.0077
0.0088
0.038
0.034
0.036
0.050
Co
0.00032 U
0.00032 U
0.00032 U
0.00032 U
0.00032 U
0.00032 U
0.00010 U
0.00010 U
0.00010 U
Copper
Cu
0.0060
U
0.0060
U
0.0060
U
0.021
0.011
J
0.016
J
0.028
B
0.026
B
0.027
B
Iron
Fe
0.12
J
0.12
U
0.12
J
0.31
J
0.12
U
0.22
J
0.12
U
0.12
U
0.12
U
Lead
Pb
0.0022
J
0.0037
J
0.0030
J
0.0034
J
0.0021
J
0.0028
J
0.00010 U
0.00012 J B
0.00011 J
Magnesium
Mg
1.3
0.38
J
0.84
J
3.7
3.0
3.4
0.13
U
0.13
U
0.13
U
Manganese
Mn
0.0077
J
0.0046
U
0.0062
J
0.055
0.038
0.047
0.0035
BJ
0.0020
JB
0.0028
JB
Nickel
Ni
0.0011
U
0.0011
U
0.0011
U
0.0011
U
0.0011
U
0.0011
U
0.00050 U
0.00050 U
Potassium
K
4.2
B*
3.8
B
4.0
B*
2.7
JB*
2.8
JB
2.8
JB
0.41
U*
0.41
UF1* 0.41
U*
Selenium
Se
0.021
U
0.021
U
0.021
U
0.021
U
0.021
U
0.021
U
0.0019
JB
JJB
Silicon
Si
Silver
Ag
Thallium
Zinc
5
5
1
B
B
0.00050 U
0.0021
B
0.0020
1.3
1.1
1.2
39
38
39
20
18
F1
19
0.00043 U
0.00043 U
0.00043 U
0.00043 U
0.00043 U
0.00043 U
0.00080 U
0.00080 U
0.00080 U
Tl
0.0012
J
0.00068 J
0.00094 J
0.00065 U
0.00065 U
0.00065 U
0.00080 U
0.00080 U
0.00080 U
Zn
0.019
J
0.21
0.11
0.029
0.49
0.26
0.0052
0.0052
0.0052
5
J
J
J
U
U
U
TCLP = Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure, EPA 1311. , RCRA = Resource Conservation and Recovery Act. , "B" flag = Compound was found
in the blank and sample. , "F1" flag = MS and/or MSD Recovery is outside acceptable limits. , "F2" flag = MS/MSD RPD exceeds control limits, "J"
flag = Result is less than the RL but greater than or equal to the MDL and the concentration is an approximate value. , "U" flagged = The analyte was
analyzed for, but was not detected above the reported sample quantitation limit. * = LCS or LCSD is outside acceptance limits.
1101
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Numerically, the TCLP results of the exhausted BOF slag sample are very similar to the virgin sample
except for the lower pH (~2 units), dissolved Ca (50% less), dissolved Cr and Mg (~4x more) and
dissolved Si (30x more). The DIW water extraction results on the exhausted sample show much less
dissolved Ca, Mg and Si but slightly more Cr than the TCLP results for essentially the same pH.
Compared to the virgin sample, many of the dissolved concentrations of the amphoteric metals (e.g.
Cd, Pb, Zn) and oxyanions (e.g. As, Se) are significantly less than the virgin sample TCLP results
due to pH solubility-controlled behavior.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
This paper summarizes the elution history of packed BOF slag fines (<10 mm diameter) after a
running L/S of 1573 L/kg (13111 PV) and an EBCT of 15 min. pH >12 persisted to about L/S <77
L/Kg (580 PV), then monotonically decreased until residual portlandite/lime was leached out. pH
plateaued thereafter, likely due to buffering effect of silicic acid (pKa1(H4SiO4) ≈ 9.8). High alkalinity
(>1000 mg CaCO3/L) was obtained up to a L/S 63 L/Kg (PV 526). Minor changes occurred after 318
L/kg (2650 PV), with values approaching that of the influent tap water (~25.2 mg CaCO3/L). Calcium
leaching trend followed pH and alkalinity profiles. After L/S 150 L/Kg (1245 PV), calcium
concentration approached the background level of the influent tap water (~12.10 mg/L).
Dissolved silicon increased and remained steady between 1 and 10 mg/L after 150 L/Kg (1245 PV).
Silicon concentrations after L/S 260 L/Kg (2160 PV) were likely governed by silicic acid, since pH
~ Pka1 ~ 9.8. Aluminum concentrations were observed at ~ 0.1 mg/L until L/S 260 L/Kg (2160 PV).
A slightly decreasing profile occurred thereafter. No other analyzed element was detected at relevant
levels. The mass loss of BOF slag fines after the experiment resulted in 19.4 wt%. Based on the
QXRD data, the sequential dissolution of lime/portlandite and larnite are suggested to be the dominant
processes driving changes in alkalinity, pH, and aqueous elemental composition. Aluminum
hydroxide [Al(OH)3] also dissolved, further adding to the amorphous content. The TCLP data suggest
that the BOF slag fines are exceptionally clean from an environmental perspective. Compared to the
virgin fraction, the exhausted BOF slag fines leached significantly less amphoteric metals and
oxyanions, due to pH solubility-controlled behavior.
The fact that neutral pH was not achieved at the end of the experiment indicates the remarkable
capacity of BOF slag fines in generating high-pH, environmentally clean eluate for extended
liquid:solid ratios. These properties make BOF slag eluates an attractive alternate for lime water
solutions.
Acknowledgments
The mineralogical evaluations shown in Table 2 were completed by Pittsburgh Mineral and
Environmental Technology Inc. (New Brighton, PA). The TCLP and ASTM D3987 testing on shown
in Table 3 was completed by the former CH2M Applied Sciences Laboratory (Corvallis, OR).
References
1. Datnoff, L.E., Snyder, G.H. and Korndörfer, G.H. eds., 2001. Silicon in agriculture (Vol. 8).
Elsevier.
2. De Windt, L. Chaurand, P., and J. Rose (2011) “Kinetics of steel slag leaching: batch test and
modeling.” Waste Management 31, 225-235.
3. Grubb, D.G., Jagupilla, S.C., and Wazne, M., 2016a. Immobilization of Copper (Cu), Nickel (Ni)
and Lead (Pb) using Steel Slag Fines,” Geo-Chicago 2016: Sustainable Waste Management and
Remediation, Geotechnical Special Publication 273, N. Yesiller, D. Zekkos, A. Farvid, A. De
and K.R. Reddy (eds.), pp. 70-78.
4. Grubb, D.G., Jagupilla, S.C., and Wazne, M., 2016b. Immobilization of Cadmium (Cd) and Zinc
(Zn) using Steel Slag Fines,” Geo-Chicago 2016: Sustainable Waste Management and
1102
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Remediation, Geotechnical Special Publication 273, N. Yesiller, D. Zekkos, A. Farvid, A. De
and K.R. Reddy (eds.), pp. 513-521.
5. Grubb, D.G., Wazne, M, Jagupilla, S.C., and Malasavage, N.E., 2011. The beneficial use of steel
slag fines to immobilize arsenite and arsenate: Slag characterization and metal thresholding
studies, J. Hazard. Toxic Radioact. Waste 15(3) 130-150.
6. Grubb, D.G., Berggren, D.R.V., and A.C. Garrabrants (submitted). “Metals Leaching from Basic
Oxygen Furnace (BOF) Slag Fines: USEPA Method 1311, 1312, 1313, 1315 and 1316 results”.
J. Hazard. Toxic Radioact. Waste, submitted.
7. Huijgen, W.J.J., and R.B. Comans (2006). “Carbonation od steel slag for CO2 sequestration:
Leaching of Products and Reaction Mechanisms.” Environ. Sci. Technol., 40(8), 2790-2796.
8. Jagupilla, S.C., Grubb D.G., and Wazne, M., 2012a. “Immobilization of Sb(III) and Sb(V) using
Steel Slag Fines,” GeoCongress 2012:State of the Art and Practice in Geotechnical
Engineering, Geotechnical Special Publication 225, R. Hryciw, A. Athanosopoulos-Zekkos, and
N. Yesiller (eds.), pp. 3988-3994.
9. Jagupilla, S.C., Grubb D.G., and Wazne, M., 2012b. “Immobilization of Se(IV) and Se(VI) using
Steel Slag Fines,” GeoCongress 2012:State of the Art and Practice in Geotechnical
Engineering, Geotechnical Special Publication 225, R. Hryciw, A. Athanosopoulos-Zekkos, and
N. Yesiller (eds.), pp. 4033-4041.
10. Rietveld, H. M. (1969). “A profile refinement method for nuclear and magnetic structures.” J.
Appl. Crystallogr., 2, 65–71.
11. Roadcap, G.S., Kelly, W.R., and C.M. Bethke, (2005). “Geochemistry of extremely alkaline
(pH>12) ground water is slag-fill aquifers.” Ground Water 43(6), December, 806-816
12. Proctor, D. M., and et al. (2000). “Physical and chemical characteristics of blast furnace, basic
oxygen furnace, and electric arc furnace steel industry slags.” Environ. Sci. Technol., 34(8),
1576–1582.
13. van Zomeren, A., van der Laan S.R., Kobeson, H.B.A, Huijgen, W.J.J., and R.B. Comans (2011).
“Changes in mineralogical and leaching properties of converter steel slag resulting from
accelerated carbonation at low CO2 pressure,” Waste Management 31, 2236-2244.
1103
Water and wastewater treatment and management
PHOSPHATE REMOVAL USING A REACTIVE
GEOCOMPOSITE MAT PROTOTYPE
D.G. Grubb1*, A.S. Filshill2, D.R.V. Berggren3
1
Phoenix Services LLC, 148 West State Street, Suite 301, Kennett Square, PA 19348, USA;
2
INOVA Geosynthetics,1500 Chester Pike, Eddystone, PA 19022, USA;
3
Jacobs, 1100 NE Circle Blvd., Suite 300, Corvallis, OR 97330, USA
*
corresponding author: dennis.grubb@phxslag.com; +12155272786
Abstract
This paper reports on the development and prototype testing of a Reactive Geocomposite Mat or RGM
that allows for passive treatment of impacted water is both the cross-plane and in-plane directions.
The RGM was fabricated of and Enkadrain™ core and reactive media sandwiched between two nonwoven geotextiles. For illustrative purposes, a testing program was carried out to evaluate the
potential removal of orthophosphate at typical stormwater concentrations (1 mg/L) using a
proprietary phosphorus removal media (PRM-1). As-received PRM-1 was tested in the RGM
configuration to assess the response in PO4 removal, total dissolved solids (TDS) and total suspended
solids (TSS) as a function of the hydraulic residence time (HRT). Overall, the PRM-1 was able to
achieve greater than 90% removal of dissolved PO4 concentrations at HRTs greater than 30 seconds.
Total PO4 removal was greatest (near 55%) at an HRT of 60 seconds. It was hypothesized that a
majority of the dissolved PO4 transforms to a colloidal form at HRTs ≥30 seconds, but are kinetically
or physically limited from precipitating out of solution. Below a 30-second HRT, the RGM was
overwhelmed and PO4 removal significantly decreased, with an increasing percentage of the total
PO4 found in the dissolved form. TDS concentrations remained under secondary drinking water
criteria (500 mg/L) while TSS was below 14 mg/L throughout the test.
Keywords: Passive treatment, geocomposites, mats, water treatment, phosphorus removal
1.
INTRODUCTION
About 15 years ago, CETCO (www.cetco.com) introduced their Reactive Core Mat (RCM™) product
line which primarily features the use of granulated organoclay (about 1 lb/ft2) between two needlepunched nonwoven geotextiles (NWGTs) as a flexible mat for use in sediment capping applications
to eliminate the migration of hydrocarbons (including free product) perpendicular to the roll direction
of the mat (cross plane direction). The RCM base technology enabled other (relatively soft) reactive
media to be placed between the NWGTs prior to needle punching such as granular activated carbon
(GAC) and apatite, the latter of which was intended to immobilize heavy metals. These thin layered
mats are less than 25 mm (1-inch) in thickness, meaning they de facto treat water in only the crossplane direction, or Z direction shown in Figure 1a. However, a major fabrication limitation of needlepunching is that hard, granular media cannot be incorporated into the RCM platform because the
needle boards would require frequent change out due to the breakage and dulling of needles.
A second major technology platform for reactive treatment and sediment capping applications is
currently offered by Aquablok (www.aquablok.com). Aquablok uses a composite particle approach
without geosynthetics for treating impacted and upwelling waters into streams, rivers, estuaries, etc.
The composite particles typically have a hard, quarried aggregate core serving as ballast (to prevent
erosion) coated by either high swelling clays (Aquablok; for permeability reduction) or reactive
1104
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
coatings (Aquagate; for water treatment as a granular media) whose chemistries can be tailored to the
remedial challenge. In many cases, Aquagate is placed directly on the sediment surface by itself to
treat water in the cross-plane direction. However, this can lead to large treatment layer thicknesses
depending on the mass loading of contaminants, necessary reaction times, etc. However, thin
drainage blankets of Aquagate (typically 5 to 15 cm) with long flow paths can be created by placing
an upper layer of Aquablok above the Aquagate except for intentionally day-lighted sections at the
offshore edges of the application area to enable treated water to enter the water column and to
dissipate upwelling water pressures. However, while it enables in-plane flow (X and Y-directions,
Figure 1a), the Aquablok system does not incorporate geosynthetics whatsoever, but the layering
approach is typical for the creation of horizontal and sloped reactive lenses of porous media in
remedial engineering. The authors are not aware of another pre-fabricated geocomposite system akin
to the RCM that can enable in-plane flow.
a)
b)
Figure 1. a) Reactive geocomposite mat (RGM) design showing cross-plane (Z) and in-plane
(X,Y) flow directions. b) Cross section showing reactive media (black polygons) embedded in
Enkadrain core heat bonded to outer geotextiles.
This paper reports on a new generation of thin layer mats for treating impacted waters which may be
placed in a variety of settings. The Reactive Geocomposite Mat or RGM is a US patent pending
technology that is comprised of an Enkadrain™ core heat-bonded to opposing woven or nonwoven
geotextiles with opening sizes selected based on the reactive aggregates used. Intermingled on both
sides of the Enkadrain are single or various granular, porous reactive media that are trapped in place
due to the irregular 3D waffle-board or egg-carton like mesh of the Enkadrain, see Figure 1b for
cross-section. The incorporation of the Enkadrain™ in the RGM imparts two major engineering
advantages over the current offering of pre-fabricated geosynthetic mats: 1) it enables in-plane flow
in the X,Y directions as shown in Figure 1a; and, 2) its particle entrapment enables the RGM to be
used in both sloped and vertical orientations without risk of the reactive media moving or slumping
within the RGM to the bottom of the profile. Moreover, depending on the challenge, one (or both)
of the geotextiles may be switched to a geomembrane to redirect cross-plane (Z) water flow to inplane (X,Y) flow.
Photos of an RGM prototype are shown in Figure 2a wherein a hard aggregate material (grey) with
a top size of 9.5 mm (3/8-inches) is nested on both sides of a 20-mm thick Enkadrain™ core (white)
sitting atop a lower 4-ounce non-woven geotextile (NWGT) (black). Figure 2b shows the final
prototype after heating bonding of a second, upper NWGT to the topmost asperities of the
Enkadrain™ core.
1105
Water and wastewater treatment and management
One potential application for the RGM would be to use it as a thin layer mat to aid in the rapid removal
of phosphorus from agricultural runoff and stormwater sources, and/or roof gardens etc. According,
to demonstrate the potential efficacy and use of the RGM, a RGM profile containing phosphorus
removal media (PRM-1) was tested in the cross-plane direction, as this would be the shortest flow
path for prototype testing.
Figure 2. Photo showing PRM-1 aggregates nested within Enkadrain core atop 4 ounce
polypropylene nonwoven geotextile (NWGT) (left). Final prototype after heat bonding of top
NWGT (right).
2.
MATERIALS & METHODS
2.1 Materials Characterization
PRM-1 is a mixture of Ca-Mg-Fe silicates and oxides (including lime) comprised primarily of hard
sand-sized particles. A photograph of the as-received PRM-1 (Figure 3) provides an indication of the
grain size and consistency of the material.
Figure 3. Photo (left) of PRM-1 aggregate and grain size (right).
The PRM-1 was homogenized and a subsample having a representative particle-size distribution was
collected for analysis of moisture content and loss on ignition (LOI) by ASTM D2974. A moisture
content of 6.33% and LOI of 2.39% were measured for the PRM-1 media. A 1 mg/L phosphate
solution was made in 75-L batches using dechlorinated tap water and sodium phosphate dibasic
heptahydrate (Na2HPO4 · 7H2O, ACS grade). The PO4 solution was analyzed for total PO4 and orthoPO4 prior to contact with PRM-1.
2.2 RGM Column Testing
The test column consists of a 25 cm (10-inch) diameter PVC column with a single end cap and central
drain to release PO4-impacted water sprayed over the RGM. The RGM was composed of PRM-1
deployed within a 20-mm Enkadrain core and confined by 4-ounce NWGT. PRM-1 was inserted at a
density of 4 pounds per square foot (lb/ft2) or approximately 19.5 kg/m2. As shown in the Figure 4,
1106
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
the RGM was supported by a two-dimensional geogrid and addition drainage support, and weighed
down with a 1-inch layer of polypropylene beads, which also promoted an even distribution of flow.
The individual layers are shown as an exploded view in Figure 5. To mitigate the potential for
channeling, the effluent discharge was raised to a height equal to that of the upper RGM, maintaining
saturated conditions within the mat.
Figure 4. Schematic of High Flow Reactive Geocomposite Mat (RGM) Testing Device.
Figure 5. Exploded view of RGM layers shown in Figure 4. From left to right: Drainage
support (white), geogrid support (black), lower 4-oz NWGT (black), Enkadrain (white), upper
4-oz NWGT (black) and sample tray with plastic beads (white) and PRM-1 (grey).
A total of 225 L of fluids were delivered to the top of the RGM through a rain-shower head during
testing. The first 25 L was tap water to set a baseline, while the remaining fluid was the PO4-impacted
water (1 mg/L PO4). The fluids were delivered at various HRTs, including 30 seconds (25 L of tap
water followed by 50 L of impacted water), 60 seconds (100 L impacted water), and 20 seconds (50
L impacted water), which correspond to flow rates of 0.8, 0.4, and 1.2 L/minute, respectively. Effluent
samples (500 milliliters) were collected for every 5 L of effluent, then submitted for analysis of pH,
dissolved (ortho-) PO4, total PO4, TDS, and TSS.
2.3 Chemical Analysis
pH, total PO4, TSS, and TDS measurements were not filtered prior to submission for analysis, while
ortho-PO4 samples were filtered through a 0.45 µm syringe filter. pH was measured immediately after
collection using a Thermo Scientific Orion 3 Star pH benchtop meter. Total PO4 and ortho-PO4 were
analyzed via USEPA methods 365.4 and 365.1 respectively. TSS and TDS were measured following
Standard Method 2540 D and C, respectively. Standard analytical quality assurance/quality control
1107
Water and wastewater treatment and management
(QA/QC) procedures were followed for all chemical analyses, which includes analysis of method and
analytical blanks, evaluation of initial and continuing calibration standards, and assessment of mass
recovery from spiked analytical samples.
3.
RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Effluent pH is plotted in Figure 6. pH was the highest (12.0) in the first effluent tap water sample,
and gradually decreased to a pH of 11.5 over the first 75 L of effluent (equivalent to 188 pore volumes,
or 81.4 liquid-to-solid (L/S) ratios. The pH then increased to 11.9 when the HRT was increased to 60
seconds, and gradually decreased with increasing L/S. When the HRT was decreased from 60 seconds
to 20 seconds at an L/S of 190, the pH decreased from 11.5 to 11.0 within one 5-L sample interval,
then continued to decline for the remainder of the test. The final effluent pH was 10.7.
The effluent ortho-PO4 concentration and removal trends are shown in Figure 7 and Figure 8,
respectively. Ortho-PO4 removal was greater than 93 percent at HRTs of 30 and 60 seconds, but
rapidly decreased at an HRT of 20 seconds, as the flow rate likely overwhelmed the treatment kinetics.
Total PO4 removal (Figure 9 and Figure 10) also increased with increasing HRT, however, overall
removal was much lower than dissolved PO4. An average total PO4 removal of 36%, 55%, and 24%
was measured at HRTs of 30, 60, and 20 seconds, respectively. Total PO4 was not detected (<0.153
mg/L) in the tap water flushes at the initiation of column testing, and therefore, was not being released
from the PRM-1. These results suggest that at HRTs of 30 seconds or greater, dissolved PO4 partially
transformed to colloidal PO4 and remained suspended in the effluent flow, while the remainder
precipitated out of solution. The steady increase of ortho-PO4 concentrations under the 20-second
HRT while total PO4 was nearly constant indicates that the total mass of PO4 that precipitates out of
solution is primarily a function of the HRT, but the ratio of dissolved to colloidal PO 4 is not fixed
under a single HRT.
Trends in TDS are presented in Figure 11. Immediately after initiation of flow with tap water, TDS
values were near 550 mg/L, and rapidly decreased below the secondary drinking water standard (500
mg/L) within an L/S of 10. Concentrations continued to decrease until an L/S of 40 was reached.
Here, the TDS appeared to stabilize at a concentration of 250 mg/L until the HRT was increased to
60 seconds. It is not clear why the TDS values initially rebounded when the HRT was doubled from
30 to 60 seconds, but the system gradually stabilized to 250 mg/L again. The 20 second HRT data
suggests that water was passing through the RGM without significant reaction. Although an increase
in TDS was associated with the longer HRT (60 seconds), concentrations at all points were below the
secondary drinking water criteria after a short-lived initial flush.
13.0
TAP WATER
ONLY
30s HRT
12.5
30s HRT
60s HRT
20s HRT
pH (SU)
12.0
11.5
PO4 =1 mg/L
pH0 = 7.25
1 PV RGM = 0.4 L
RGM = 0.922 kg PRM-1
11.0
10.5
10.0
0
50
100
150
200
250
L/S Ratio (<9.5 mm PRM -1)
Figure 6. Effluent pH from RGM in Vertical Cross-Plane Flow Format for Different
Hydraulic Residence Times (HRTs).
1108
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
1.0
TAP WATER
ONLY
30s HRT
Ortho-PO4 Concentration (mg/L as PO4)
0.9
30s HRT
20s HRT
60s HRT
0.8
PO4 =1 mg/L
pH0 = 7.25
1 PV RGM = 0.4 L
RGM = 0.922 kg PRM-1
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
0
50
100
150
200
250
L/S Ratio (<9.5 mm PRM -1)
Figure 7. Effluent Ortho-PO4 (Dissolved) Concentrations from RGM in Response to
Simulated Rain Event.
100%
90%
Ortho-PO4 Removal
80%
70%
60%
PO4 =1 mg/L
pH0 = 7.25
1 PV RGM = 0.4 L
RGM = 0.922 kg PRM-1
50%
40%
30%
TAP WATER
ONLY
30s HRT
20%
10%
30s HRT
20s HRT
60s HRT
0%
0
50
100
150
200
250
L/S Ratio (<9.5 mm PRM -1)
Figure 8. Removal of Ortho-PO4 by RGM in Response to Simulated Rain Event.
1.0
TAP WATER
ONLY
30s HRT
Total PO4 Concentration (mg/L as PO4)
0.9
20s HRT
60s HRT
30s HRT
0.8
PO4 =1 mg/L
pH0 = 7.25
1 PV RGM = 0.4 L
RGM = 0.922 kg PRM-1
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
0
50
100
150
200
250
L/S Ratio (<9.5 mm PRM -1)
Figure 9. Effluent Total PO4 Concentrations from RGM in Response to Simulated Rain
Event.
1109
Water and wastewater treatment and management
100%
PO4 =1 mg/L
pH0 = 7.25
1 PV RGM = 0.4 L
RGM = 0.922 kg PRM-1
90%
Total PO4 Removal
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
TAP WATER
ONLY
30s HRT
10%
60s HRT
30s HRT
20s HRT
0%
0
50
100
150
200
250
L/S Ratio (<9.5 mm PRM -1)
Figure 10. Removal of Total PO4 by RGM in Response to Simulated Rain Event.
600
Secondary Drinking Water
Criteria
500
TDS (mg/L)
400
PO4 =1 mg/L
pH0 = 7.25
1 PV RGM = 0.4 L
RGM = 0.922 kg
PRM-1
300
TAP WATER
ONLY
30s HRT
200
30s HRT
20s HRT
60s HRT
100
0
0
50
100
150
200
250
L/S Ratio (<9.5 mm PRM -1)
Figure 11. Effluent Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) Concentration from RGM in Response to
Simulated Rain Event.
TSS trends are presented in Figure 12. The TSS concentration was scattered, but many samples had
a concentration below the reporting limit of 6.3 mg/L. On average, the samples collected at a 30s
HRT were near 1.8 mg/L greater than those at the 60s HRT, while all samples under the 20s HRT
were below the reporting limit. These trends match the PO4 data well, with total PO4 (believed to be
predominantly in colloidal form at HRTs ≥ 30 seconds) at 30 seconds being slightly greater than at
60 seconds, and an overall decrease of colloidal PO4 under an HRT of 20 seconds.
1110
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
14
12
TSS (mg/L)
10
8
6
Reporting Limit = 6.3 mg/L
PO4 =1 mg/L
pH0 = 7.25
1 PV RGM = 0.4 L
RGM = 0.922 kg PRM-1
4
TAP WATER
ONLY
30s HRT
2
30s HRT
20s HRT
60s HRT
0
0
50
100
150
200
250
L/S Ratio (<9.5 mm PRM -1)
Figure 12. Effluent Total Suspended Solids (TSS) Concentration from RGM in Response to
Simulated Rain Event.
4.
CONCLUDING REMARKS
This testing program was carried out to evaluate potential enhancements offered by the preferential
use of PRM-1 in an RGM. As-received PRM-1 was tested in the RGM configuration to assess the
response in PO4 removal and other pertinent parameters (TDS and TSS) when HRT changes.
Overall, the PRM-1 was able to achieve greater than 90 percent removal of dissolved PO 4
concentrations at HRTs greater than 30 seconds. Total PO4 removal was greatest (near 55%) at an
HRT of 60 seconds. It is hypothesized that a majority of the ortho-PO4 transforms to a colloidal form
at HRTs ≥30 seconds, but are kinetically or physically limited from precipitating out of solution.
Below a 30-second HRT, the RGM was overwhelmed and PO4 removal significantly decreased, with
an increasing percentage of the total PO4 found in the dissolved form. TDS concentrations remained
under secondary drinking water criteria (500 mg/L) while TSS was below 14 mg/L throughout the
test.
Ongoing research with the RGM is being conducted at the Arizona State University Center for Biomediated and Bio-inspired Geotechnics (ASU-CBBG) where PRM-1 is being paired with
biologically active organic media to enable the joint removal of phosphorus and nitrogen in an effort
to develop an RGM that can aid in the rapid removal of nutrients to streams, rivers and estuaries to
prevent bacterial and algal blooms. The organic media will also aid in pH buffering.
Acknowledgements
Thanks to Ryan Church of Phoenix Services LLC for constructing the flow-through test apparatus.
1111
Water and wastewater treatment and management
UTILIZATION AND DESIGN OF FIRE SAFETY SYSTEMS WITH
THE USE OF TREATED WASTEWATER
M. G. Zerva and I. K. Kalavrouziotis
School of Science and Technology,
Hellenic Open University,
Tsamadou 13-15 & Saint Andrea, GR- 26222 Patras, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: ikalabro@eap.gr
Abstract
Over the past few years, a number of natural phenomena such as earthquakes, greenhouse effect,
floods and fires have been taking place, for which reference is made in the present work. Due to the
fact that fires can often be catastrophic, various techniques are being applied for their control, which
usually are based on the evolution of technology. Thus, the present work examines and designs fire
protection plans using treated wastewater originating from the Wastewater Treatment Plant of Patras.
By means of this system, the negative effects of the fire are significantly reduced and at the same time
the environment is adequately protected and the ecosystem are not subjected to the adverse and
harmful effects of the sea and lake, water use, which is used to extinguish the fires. In fact, in the
present study, the area that studied was the Industrial Park of Glafkos Patra, where the fire hydrants
were fed with the treated water with the assumptions that were made on the basis of the design of the
fire safety system. The relevant results and the various computational methods used for the
completion of this study were listed accordingly.
Keywords: Fire; fire safety systems; fire detection; Fire brigade; fire hydrants.
1.
INTRODUCTION
Fire is one of the most important inventions of humanity which plays an important role in today's
scientific successes. On the other hand, it can be so damaging to the extent that it can wipe out an
entire ecosystem.
To deal with the above phenomenon, man devised various techniques and constructed various modern
means of extinguishing. As time goes by, this phenomenon shows signs of becoming worse and due
to the fact of the constant evolution of technology and accumulation of thermal load goods, the risk
of fires are increasing. For this reason, the prevention and suppression of fires is assigned to certain
services (Bento-Gonçalves et al., 2012) as shown in Figures 1 and 2.In Figure 1 below, the fire
categories and in Figure2, the mission of the Fire Brigade are reported.
1112
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: Fire categories (Fire- fighting side), (Panagiotidis K. G., 2011).
-
Fire protection
Investigating
Organizations
updates
Seminars
Exercises
It takes place in
case of need
It takes place all
the year
Figure 2: Mission of the Fire Brigade. Relationship between Prevention and Repression,
(Panagiotidis K. G., 2011).
The severity of the fire delineates how ecosystems respond to fire and it is commonly used to describe
the effects of fire on soil, the flora and fauna, water, the atmosphere, and even on the society. The
severity of burning can be categorized as light/-low-, medium- or high-intensity, as it is considered a
product of fire intensity and duration. It is difficult to determine the relationship between the intensity
and the severity of the fire, because of some problems that arose by relative research (Hungerford et
al., 1990). For the treatment of these problems, DeBano et al. (1998) setup the following criteria:
Low fire severity: - <2% is burned severely, <15% is burned moderately and the rest is burned
with low severity or does not burn at all.
Moderate fire severity: <10% is burned severely,>15%is burned moderately and the rest is
burned with low severity or does not burn.
1113
Water and wastewater treatment and management
High fire severity: >10% there are areas that are burned with high severity, >80% is burned
moderately and the rest is burned with low severity.
A product that can be used as an indicator of the severity of a fire is ash, as it is the material which
biomass is burned with. Essentially, the ash is the residue a fire leaves.
Thus, taking into consideration the negative effects of the phenomenon of fire, there is an urgent need
to find various fire safety and fire extinguishing systems so as, with proper prevention, to achieve
their complete extinguishing. In Table 1 below, the intensity of fire as a function of temperature is
given.
Table 1: Intensity of fire as a function of temperature (Panagiotidis K. G., 2011).
Intensity of fire
Temperature (°C)
Low
up to 800
Medium
800-1000
High
1000-1200
The purpose of fire protection systems is to reduce the risk of fires. Applying the most appropriate
method or technique, we can create conditions for more effective prevention and suppression of fires,
always based on the rules of fire protection.
The present study aims at designing fire protection systems for the Industrial Park of Glafkos Patra,
which will use the treated wastewater originating from the Wastewater Treatment Plant of Patras.
This water will be, at the same time, an innovative means for fire- fighting, with the prerequisite that
it will be utilized properly in fire safety systems for the elimination of fires.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Description of Wastewater Treatment Plant of Patras
The facilities of Wastewater Treatment Plant (WTP) of Patras are located in «Kokkinos Mylos», in
the southwestern edge of the Municipality of Patras, a plot of about 80.000square meters (50.000
square meters’ constructions, 15.000square meters of lawn, 200 trees, 2000 shrubs) and are one of
the most modern wastewater treatment plants in Greece. It boasts the latest and the most modern
technology and it has been in operation since 2001. This plant covers the needs of people residing in
the Municipalities of Patras, Rio, Parallax, Vrachnaika and Messatida. This particular plant solely
processes urban wastewater (Municipal Corporation Water Supply of Patras).
The disinfected wastewater is driven to the loading shaft of the underwater pipeline, out falling
through a1000-mm-diameter HDPE, where an average initial dilution of 100 is made for the most
difficult conditions, and then the wastewater is driven out to the sea. The treated wastewater is
disposed of in the Patraikos Gulf, at the «Kokkinos Mylos" site. In particular, the treated sewage is
discharged into the sea at a depth of approximately 35 m with a disposal pipeline of, about 215 m
long on the earth and about 975 m under the water. It’s important to note that the wastewater treatment
pipeline from the plant outlet shaft to the recipient shaft is located underground. Also, a part of the
treated water feeds the industrial water production plant, with the ultimate goal of saving water for
the operation and irrigation of the plant. Therefore, it covers almost all the plant's requirements in
industrial water, such as for scrub washing, as well as for the irrigation of the outside area of the
facility (Municipal Corporation Water Supply of Patras).
1114
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3: Location of WTP Patras from a close view (maps.google.com).
2.2 Purpose of the study
The purpose of this study is the design and develop fire safety systems so as to enable proper use of
treated water and prevent its disposal in the Patraikos Gulf or in landfills. Ultimately, treated water
will be used for irrigation, agriculture, fires extinguishing, etc., producing many environmental
benefits.
2.3 Installation sites of fire protection systems
In the context of our study, an installation will be set up, where the treated water will be stored next
to the Sewage Treatment Plant in "Kokkinos Mylos", in Patra. Ιn this facility reservoir will be built
to store a part of the treated water from the Wastewater Treatment Plant and the stored water will
then be fed to the fire hydrants which will be located in the Industrial Park of Glafkos Patras. In
Figure 4 below, the hydrants network located in the Industrial Park of Glafkos Patras is given, which
consists of 28 fire hydrants.
Figure 4: Hydrants network in the area of the Industrial Park of Glafkos Patras (Google
Earth).
1115
Water and wastewater treatment and management
2.4 Characteristics of the treated water storage reservoir
The capacity of the reservoir to be built next to the WTP facilities should cover the operation of the
28 fire hydrants. Therefore, a concrete reservoir will be constructed in an adjacent site in the
Wastewater Treatment Plant, with dimensions of 9m x 6m x 4m and a total capacity of 216m3, as
calculated below. The reservoir will be fed with a 2"pip.
The reservoir will be accompanied by all the required filling and level control instruments, as well as
the emergency stop instruments including the inspection port for maintenance and cleaning.
Figure 5: Reservoir site in the Wastewater Treatment Plant (Google Earth).
In Figure 5 the reservoir where, the treated water from the Wastewater Treatment Plant will be stored
to be transferred afterwards to the fire hydrants, shown with a blue square shape, with the help of the
"red line", which represents the path from the reservoir until the desired height where the hydrants
are located, the treated water will be transported through pipelines (made of polyethylene). In Figure
6 below, the path (red line) of the water flow until the fire hydrants is seen.
Figure 6.: Pipe transfer route of the treated wastewater from the reservoir to the fire hydrants
(Google Earth).
1116
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.
SIMULATIONS – RESULTS
For the design of the fire safety system it was assumed that at an event of a fire, 3 fire hydrants will
be opened manually. If a hydrant produces water for two hours with a rate of 10lt/ sec, then the three
hydrants will produce water with a rate of 30 lt / sec.
As mentioned above, the pipes to be used for the hydrant network will be made of third generation
polyethylene for water systems. Assuming that the operating pressure is 16 bar and the outer diameter
of the tubes is Φ225 then the wall thickness will be 20.5 (unit). Then, the internal diameter of the
tubes can be calculated as follows:
dinter. = 225 – 2*20,5 = 184 mm = 0,184 m
The provision of m3/ h units to find the water supply speed that comes out of the reservoir can then
be converted as shown below:
Q= 30
= 30
= 108
Therefore, the water supply speed is:
u=
=
=
⇒ u = 4.075,47
=
⇒u
1,13
Also the volume of the reservoir for duration t = 2hr is calculated as follow:
V= Q * t= 30
* 2hr ⇒ V= 30
* 7200 sec ⇒ V= 216.000 lt ⇒Vres.= 216
According to the above calculations, the dimensions of the reservoir will be 9m x 6m x 4m. and the
length of the water transfer path to the hydrants is L = 2,102 m (Google Earth). Therefore, it is
necessary to measure the Pump Manometric, which is indicated below:
Manometric =Ηgeod. + Ηlosses+ Hf
Ηgeod. altitude difference between the reservoir and the fire hydrant at the highest point,
which is 52-2 = 50 m.
Ηlosses are 44 m (1 atm = 10m, 4 atm= 40m, 40m * 1.1 [local losses] = 44m.
As to the calculation of the permanent energy losses in the circular cross-section (linear
losses), the following Darcy-Weisbach equation has been taken into consideration:
Hf = f
(1),
Where → f: coefficient of friction
L: cylindrical pipeline length
D:cylindricalpipeline diameter
g: 9.81 m/sec2
1117
Water and wastewater treatment and management
The coefficient of friction f is given by: f = a + bR-c (2) (Brater E.F.)
where, a = 0,094
+ 0,53
b = 88,0
c = 1,62
The Flow Loss Factor f is given by the Moody diagram, as a function of the Reynolds flow number
and the relative roughness of the pipe:
F = F (Re, ) Re=
where, ε = absolute roughness (mm)
ε/ D= relative roughness
V= kinematic coherence (KatsaprakakisD.Al.)
From the tables presenting the properties of water, we find the kinematic consistency equal to V =
1.15 x 10-6 m2/ sec.
Then the Reynolds flow number is calculated:
Re=
Re =
= 1,808 x
Also, the absolute roughness of polyethylene (PE) is ε = 0.005cm. So, the relative roughness is
calculated as:
=
= 2,72x
Substituting the relative roughness for the constants a, b and c, we have:
a = 0,094
= 0,094 *
= 8,83 x
+ 0,53
+ 1,44 x
b = 88,0
= 88,0 *
c = 1,62
= 1,62*
+ 0,53 *
a= 8,84 x
= 88 * 9,8
c = 0,40
So, by replacing the equation (2) we have
f = a + bR-c
f = 8,84x
+ 0,86 *
= (8,84 + 7,89) x
f =0,0156
So the equation (1) becomes:
1118
b= 0,86
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Hf= f
= 0,0156
=
Hf= 11,62m
Therefore, Manometric =Ηgeod. + Ηlosses+ Hf= 50m + 44m + 12 m= 106 m
Consequently, the total height losses are 106 m. Essentially, the required manometric height of the
pump (energy difference) is the sum of the height difference (= static height difference) and the loss
of pressure (loss height) in the pipes and fittings.
In fact, the total manometric is the total pressure produced by the pump to transfer the treated water
from the reservoir that is too low (with a flow rate of 108 m3/ hr) and to raise it to a height of 106
meters (where the fire hydrants are located), in order to provide the needed kinetic energy or pressure.
That is, the pump creates a vacuum which absorbs water and transfers it to the network.
Thus, the manometric attempts to overcome the altitude differences and the flow of water through the
pipe (linear and local losses) and operates at a pressure of 4 atm.
In fact, the pump system is so important because it can transport water through a piping network even
at very high heights, and in particular, for this study, it’s enabled through an installation which is
located to the Wastewater Treatment to launch so much water that it can supply 28 fire hydrants
located in the area of our case study, the Industrial Park of Glafkos Patras.
In brief, our findings are reported in the table below.
Table 2: Summary of the study results.
DESCRIPTION
VALUE
Operating pressure
16 bar
Outer tube diameter
Φ225
Wall thickness of pipes
20,5( units)
Inner tube diameter
0,184 m
Provision (Q)
108 m3/hr
Water supply speed (u)
1,13 m/sec
Reservoir volume (Vres.)
216 m3
Path length (L)
2.102 m
Reynolds number
1,808 x
Relative roughness
2,72 x
Total manometric
106 m
4. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
For everything we mention above and for the proper management of water, the innovation of this
work is evident. With the design of fire protection systems, wastewater treatment is being utilized to,
extinguish fires, without inexorably use of water in the network and the sea. Thus, the treated waste
water originating from the Wastewater Treatment of Patras can be used to extinguish fires and not
being disposed of in Patraikos Gulf or in landfills. Therefore, many environmental and economic
benefits are generated, as water scarcity is one of the most important environmental problems for
many countries in the world.
Concluding, it should have mentioned that prevention is a profound concept, which relieves us of
moral, criminal or even administrative responsibilities. For this reason, as the ultimate aim is the
suppressing of fires, the necessary actions to be taken are as follows:
Cleaning of the premises.
Appropriate ventilation of the premises.
1119
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Storage of flammable materials in separate rooms.
Prohibition of open flame in areas of production.
Ban on smoking in hazardous areas.
Detailed maintenance of electrical installations.
Defining safety zones and access roads within production areas, warehouses, forests, etc.
Fully inform the public about any appropriate measures.
Signaling and flags with special symbols or colors.
Instructions (eg. signs with recommendations for the handling of dangerous articles.
Communication, alarm, intercom, fire announcement and dehumidification systems.
Because of the originality of this paper, comparing the results with corresponding results from other
researches is not easy, but we believe that this will be the trigger for further studies.
References
1. Bento-Gonçalves A., Vieira A., Úbeda X., Martin D., (2012). ‘Fire and soils: Key concepts and
recent advances’, Geoderma 191 (2012) 3-13.
2. Brater F. Ernest. ‘Horage Williams King’, Late Professor of Hydraulic Engineering University of
Michigan, Sixth Edition, Handbook of Hydraulics for the Solution of Hydraulic Engineering
Problems, McGraw – Hill Book Company.
3. DeBano, L.F., Neary, D.G., Ffolliott, P.F., (1998). ‘Fire’s Effects on Ecosystems’, John Wiley &
Sons, New York.
4. Hungerford, R.D., Harrington, M.G., Frandsen, W.H., Ryan, R.C., Niehoff, J.G., (1990).
‘Ιnfluence of fire on factors that affect site productivity’, In: Harvey, A.E., Neuenschwander, L.F.
(Eds.), Symposium on Management and Productivity of Western-Montana Forest Soils. Boise,
Idaho, USA, pp. 32–51.
5. Katsaprakakis D. Al. 'Pipes', Hydrodynamic Machines, Wind Energy Laboratory, T.E.I. of Crete.
6. Municipal Corporation Water Supply of Patras. ‘Facilities of Wastewater Treatment Plant of
Patras, Protection of the sea - Respect for the environment'.
7. Panagiotidis K.G., (2011). ‘Investigation of the experience of permanent and seasonal firemen in
Forest Fire Management aiming at the formulation of an integrated Forest Fire Management
System: The case of the Fire Service of Rhodes’, University of Aegean, Faculty of Humanities,
Department of Preschool Education and Educational Design, Environmental Education,
Postgraduate Diploma, Rhodes.
1120
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
CARBON NANOTUBES APPLICATION FOR HEXAVALENT
CHROMIUM ADSORPTION FROM CONTAMINATED
GROUNDWATER
Thanasis Mpouras*, Angeliki Polydera, Dimitris Dermatas
School of Civil Engineering, Department of Water Resources and Environmental Engineering,
National Technical University of Athens, Iroon Polytechniou 9, 157 80 Zografou, Athens, Greece
*Corresponding author: e-mail: th.mpouras@gmail.com, tel.: +30 210 772 2835
Abstract
In recent years, nanomaterials have attracted increasing concern in the sector of water treatment. The
present study investigates the removal of hexavalent chromium from groundwater using multi-walled
carbon nanotubes as adsorbent. In order to determine the adsorption efficiency of carbon nanotubes
batch and column experiments were conducted using groundwater sampled in a heavily polluted area
in Asopos river basin, Viotia, Greece. Batch experiments were used for investigating the effect of pH,
the concentration of the adsorbent and contact time on the sorption process. Afterwards, by using upflow column experiments the adsorption capacity of carbon nanotubes for hexavalent chromium was
determined. Hexavalent chromium desorption from the nanotubes was also tested in order to check
the reversibility of the process and thus to estimate the potential reusability of the nanomaterial.
According to the results, the adsorption was found to be a fast process and adsorption capacity was
increased with decreasing pH values and increasing the adsorbent’s concentration. The desorption
efficiency of the nanomaterial indicated that carbon nanotubes have promising potential for
environmental remediation as adsorbing materials.
Keywords: Multi wall carbon nanotubes, hexavalent chromium, adsorption, groundwater
1.
INTRODUCTION
Chromium, a heavy metal that naturally occurs in the Earth’s crust, can be found in the environment
in several oxidation states. The trivalent (Cr(III)) and hexavalent (Cr(VI)) are the most common states
in groundwater. Cr(III) is an indispensable element for the human beings and seems to be much less
hazardous than Cr(VI), which is reported to cause serious health problems (dermatitis, diarrhea,
nausea, bronchitis, internal hemorrhage etc) and act as carcinogenic agent (Dehghani et al., 2016).
Additionally, Cr(VI), which usually occurs as an oxyanion in the form of CrO4- and Cr2O72-, is soluble
in almost the whole pH range and more mobile than Cr(III) (Zeng et al., 2010).
Groundwater contamination with Cr(VI) can be either of geogenic or anthropogenic origin. However,
significantly high concentrations of Cr(VI) in groundwater, even in the range of mg/L, are attributed
exclusively to anthropogenic activities (Dermatas et al., 2015; Dermatas et al., 2016). Mining,
electroplating, textile dyeing and leather tanning are some indicative industrial activities which lead
to accidental or uncontrolled release of chromium to the environment. More specifically, chromium
concentration may range from 0.5 to 270 mg/l in industrial wastewater and, as a result, high levels of
Cr(VI) concentrations can be found in groundwater (Saha et al., 2011; Dermatas et al., 2016).
In recent years, several methods have been applied for the removal of Cr(VI) from wastewater or
groundwater, including ion exchange, reduction of Cr(VI) to Cr(III) prior to precipitation using
reducing agents, coagulation, solvent extraction, membrane technologies, chemical precipitation and
1121
Water and wastewater treatment and management
adsorption on natural or synthetic materials (Qureshi et al., 2017; Jung et al., 2013). Among the
aforementioned techniques, adsorption seems to have many advantages, such as operation simplicity,
low cost, high removal efficiency, as well as the potential regeneration of the adsorbent (Borna et al.,
2016). The use of nanomaterials as adsorbents results in even higher performance of the process, due
to their fast kinetics, high reactivity and large specific area (Zhang et al., 2016).
Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) are a relatively new form of carbon materials that were discovered by
Iijima (Iijima, 1991). They are allotropes of carbon with a cylindrical structure and can be
manufactured as single-walled (SWCNTs) or multi-walled (MWCNTs), depending on their number
of graphite layers (Jung et al., 2013). Their potential for regeneration and reuse is their main
advantage comparing to common activated carbon and other nanomaterials (Matlochová et al., 2013;
Gehrke et al., 2015). This property in combination with their high surface area makes CNTs very
attracting adsorbents. Consequently, CNTs are of the most common and efficient nanomaterials
employed for removal of heavy metals from polluted water.
The present study aims at investigating the Cr(VI) removal capacity of MWCNTs from heavily
contaminated groundwater. The effect of pH, the adsorbent’s concentration and the contact time for
achieving equilibrium, on Cr(VI) adsorption were tested by carrying out batch experiments. In
addition, column experiments were performed in order to investigate the potential of using CNTs at
up scaling applications for the treatment of such Cr(VI) contaminated groundwater.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) characterisation
The MWCNTs used in the present study were provided by Glonatech S.A. (Greece). They are
produced by the chemical vapor deposition (CVD) method. The morphology of MWCNTs was
analyzed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) (JEOL FEG 7401F). A thermogravimetric analysis
(TGA) was also performed using a Perkin Elmer 4000 instrument, in order to estimate the purity and
the thermal stability of the material. Finally, for the determination of point of zero charge (PZC)
different amounts of MWCNTs (0.01, 0.1, 1, 5, 10, 20 % wt) were suspended in 0.1 M NaCl solution
and the solution pH was measured after 24hr of contact time.
2.2 Batch experiments
Batch experiments were performed to investigate Cr(VI) sorption behavior on MWCNTs using
Cr(VI) contaminated groundwater sampled from Inofyta area, Greece. Cr(VI) concentration in
groundwater was equal to 11 ppm. All batch experiments were conducted at room temperature (23oC).
The samples were placed in an orbital shaker at 200 rpm and after equilibrium they were filtered
through a 0.45μm pore membrane filter (Whatman No 45) and analyzed for Cr(VI) applying the
7196A (diphenylcarbazide) EPA method. All the experiments were performed in duplicates and mean
values are reported.
The effect of pH, adsorbent’s concentration and contact time were investigated. The effect of pH on
the sorption process was tested in the range of 3-9. pH adjustment was achieved by using HCl and
NaOH solutions of 0.01M. In this case the contact time was 24 hours and MWCNTs concentration
was equal to 25g/l. In order to assess the effect of MWCNTs concentration, dosages in the range of
10 to 50g/l, were used. Two series of experiments using these dosages and different pH values 7 and
8 were carried out while contact time was kept constant at 24hr. For investigating the effect of contact
time, Cr(VI) concentration was measured in the range of 15 to 120min. Three series of experiments
at pH values 7, 8.3 and 9 were carried out. The concentration of the adsorbent was constant at 25g/l.
The percentage sorption of Cr(VI) was calculated according to the following equation:
A(%)
Co C f
Co
*100
(1)
1122
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
where Co (mg·L-1) is the Cr(VI) initial concentration and Cf (mg·L-1) the final Cr(VI) concentration
in the equilibrium solution
2.3 Column experiments
Despite the fact that batch experiments provide important information regarding the adsorption of
Cr(VI), column experiments are useful for the practical application of this process for the treatment
of polluted water (Goel et al., 2005). For this reason, three up-flow column experiments were
conducted by using a column of 135 ml total volume (diameter=3cm, height=19cm) and a peristaltic
pump for achieving the proper contact time. In the inlet and outlet of the column 0.45 μm pore
membrane filters (Whatman No 45) were placed for filtering groundwater and to avoid leakage of the
adsorbent. The column was continuously fed with the heavily contaminated groundwater (11ppm
Cr(VI) concentration) while the pH of the groundwater was adjusted at 4, 7 and 8.3 (three series of
column experiments). The pH value of 8.3 refers to the pH value of groundwater as measured after
sampling. For the adjustment of the two other pH values HCl 0.01M was used. The pH value 7 aimed
at investigating Cr(VI) adsorption capacity of MWCNTs in the case of treating groundwater with
lower pH, while the pH value 4 at investigating the adsorption capacity of MWCNTs towards
wastewater that would simulate the physicochemical properties of groundwater. Parameters like
contact time, flow rate and MWCNTs concentration were constant at all series of experiments and
equal to 1hr, 0.3ml/min and 40g/L, respectively.
Finally, in order to check the reversibility of the process column experiments were performed aiming
at Cr(VI) desorption. The column was continuously fed with NaOH solution 0.1M in order to increase
the pH of the solution at value around 12. This would cause the desorption of Cr(VI) from the
carbonaceous material.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Characterisation of CNTs
SEM analysis provides useful information regarding the shape, size and orientation of MWCNTs.
Figure 1 illustrates that MWCNTs are randomly oriented, significantly tangled and curved. Their
diameter ranges from 26 to 82 nm. TGA analysis showed that the tested MWCNTs are oxidized
between 550 and 670 oC in air conditions (Figure 1). The residual verified purity higher than 94%.
The high thermal stability under oxidative environment is a unique characteristic of MWCNTs
comparatively with other carbonaceous materials. Regarding pHPZC, it was estimated at 6.32, which
is in agreement with values reported in other studies (Ai et al., 2011; Pourfadakari et al., 2016).
Figure 1. SEM image (left) and TGA analysis (right) of the tested MWCNTs.
1123
Water and wastewater treatment and management
3.2
Results of batch experiments
3.2.1 Effect of pH on Cr(VI) adsorption
In this series of experiments the effect of pH on Cr(VI) adsorption from groundwater was investigated
using 25 g/L MWCNTs and equilibrium time equal to 24 h. Adsorption efficiency of Cr(VI)
maximized (100%) for pH values up to 6.3 and decreased sharply for higher pH values reaching
almost 20% at pH equal to 9 (Figure 2). In the tested pH range (3-9), Cr(VI) exists as hydrogen
chromates (HCrO4-) at low pH values and chromates (CrO42-) at higher pH values. Cr(VI) adsorption
is generally attributed to electrostatic forces between Cr(VI) ions and the surface of MWCNTs. It is
known that functional groups such as –OH and –COOH exist on the MWCNTs surface. For pH values
lower than the PZC point these groups are protonated causing attraction to the chromium anions and
thus, enhancing adsorption capacity of the solid surface. In addition, at low pH values possible
reduction phenomena of Cr(VI) by the functional groups have been reported. On the contrary, for pH
values higher than the PZC point the surface is negatively charged due to the deprotonation of the
functional groups causing electrostatic repulsions with chromates, reducing thus the adsorption
phenomena (Hu et al., 2009; Qureshi et al., 2017; Di et al., 2004).
Figure 2. Effect of pH on Cr(VI) adsorption ([Cr(VI)]0=11mg/L, CMWNTs=25g/L, t=24h)
3.2.2 Effect of adsorbent’s concentration on Cr(VI) adsorption
The effect of adsorbent dosage on Cr(VI) adsorption was investigated for two different pH values, 7
and 8, in the range 10 to 50 g/L (Figure 3). Results showed that adsorption efficiency increased with
increasing the MWCNTs concentration, independently the pH values. This phenomenon is attributed
to the higher number of available sites for Cr(VI) sorption with increasing the mass of MWCNTs.
However, the pH value of the groundwater affected significantly Cr(VI) adsorption since the increase
was found to be higher for the lower pH value. This can possibly be attributed to the presence of
enhanced electrostatic attractions at pH 7 than for pH value 8, indicating that the parameter of pH
plays an important role on Cr(VI) adsorption. More specifically, adsorption increased from 40% to
100% at pH equal to 7, and from 40% to 88% at pH 8.
1124
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3. Effect of adsorbent’s concentration on Cr(VI) adsorption for two pH values
([Cr(VI)]0=11mg/l, t=24hr)
3.2.3 Effect of contact time on Cr(VI) adsorption
Figure 4 presents the effect of contact time on Cr(VI) adsorption for three different pH values (7, 8.3
and 9) in the range of 15-120 min. The results showed that for pH equal to 7 equilibrium is reached
in almost 15 minutes, while for pH equal to 8.3 and 9 equilibrium in almost 60 minutes. The decrease
of pH caused a slight decrease at the time needed for achieving equilibrium. However, at all cases the
time required for equilibrium was much lower than the 24 h used in this study. These low values of
time required for achieving equilibrium indicate that adsorption mainly occurs only on the surface of
MWCNTs and probably not to sorption phenomena in the structure of MWCNTs which would
demand more contact time (Di et al., 2004). In addition, as shown from Figure 4, the effect of pH is
more significant than the contact time since the adsorption efficiency was found to be controlled by
pH value.
Figure 4. Effect of contact time on Cr(VI) adsorption for three pH values ([Cr(VI)]0=11mg/l,
CMWNTs=25g/l)
1125
Water and wastewater treatment and management
3.3 Results of column experiments
3.3.1 Effect of pH on Cr(VI) adsorption
The column experiments were conducted using MWCNTs/groundwater (g/L) ratio equal to 40,
contact time equal to 1 hr and initial Cr(VI) concentration equal to 11 mg/L. Three series of column
experiments were carried out testing different pH values 4, 7 and 8.3 (Figure 5). The operation of
each column ended when removal percentage reached almost 10%. At all cases, as operation time
increased, Cr(VI) removal was gradually decreased indicating the saturation of the MWCNTs
regarding Cr(VI) removal capacity. At the pH values tested, the total volume of groundwater passed
through the column was 3.5, 1.1 and 0.6 L, respectively. The corresponding total amount of Cr(VI)
removed at these cases was 36, 4.7 and 0.7 mg. It is clear that the pH of groundwater plays a crucial
role regarding the removal capacity of MWCNTs.
Figure 5. Cr(VI) adsorption capacity over operation time during column experiment for three
different pH values ([Cr(VI)]0=11ppm, contact time=1hr, CMWNTs=40g/l).
3.3.2 Regeneration of MWCNTs
In order to verify the reversibility of the adsorption process, column experiments were performed
aiming at Cr(VI) desorption (Figure 6). The columns were loaded with the material used in each case
described in paragraph 3.3.1 and were continuously fed with NaOH solution 0.1M which created an
effluent with pH about 12. This would cause the desorption of Cr(VI) from MWCNTs. The operation
of the column was stopped since Cr(VI) concentration in the effluent was measured lower than 20
μg/L. The amount of the base solution used in each case for initial pH 4, 7 and 8.3 was equal to 1.5,
0.6 and 0.5 L, respectively. The difference of the amount adsorbed in the first step and of the desorbed
amount of Cr(VI) indicates that the removal mechanism can be attributed to irreversible adsorption
mechanisms like chemisorption or to possible Cr(VI) reduction after adsorption. Reduction can be
attributed to the surface functional groups or to the residual catalyst that used in the synthesis process.
Thus, further investigation is needed in order to determine the exact removal mechanism and
determine the reusability of MWCNTs for decontamination of Cr(VI) contaminated groundwater.
1126
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 6. Cr(VI) desorption over operation time for the three tested pH values (contact
time=1h, CMWCNTs=40g/l)
4.
CONCLUSIONS
The MWCNTs exhibited high adsorption capacity for Cr(VI). Depending on solution pH, MWCNTs
concentration and contact time, Cr(VI) removal could even reach 100%. The pH estimated as a crucial
factor on adsorption, since Cr(VI) was maximized for pH values lower than pHPZC and was sharply
decreased for higher pH values. Increase in MWCNTs concentration led to higher removal percentage
while the short contact time required for adsorption indicates that MWCNTs are effective adsorbents
that can be used in practical applications. The crucial role of pH was also verified when performing
column experiments, since MWCNTs with pH solution equal to 4 adsorbed almost 8 and 50 times
higher amount of Cr(VI) than MWCNTs with pH equal to 7 and 8.3, respectively. Finally, desorption
column experiments indicated that only a very small amount of the adsorbed Cr(VI) can be desorbed
back to the aqueous solution. This phenomenon is possibly due to irreversible adsorption mechanisms
or reduction of Cr(VI) to Cr(III). As a result, more investigation is necessary for the determination of
the exact removal mechanism and the potential reusability of MWCNTs for water treatment
applications.
AKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors gratefully acknowledge the company Glonatech SA (www.glonatech.com) for supplying
the multi-walled carbon nanotubes.
References
1. Ai L., Zhang C., Liao F., Wang Y., Li M., Meng L. and Jiang J. (2011) ‘Removal of methylene
blue from aqueous solution with magnetite loaded multi-wall carbon nanotube: Kinetic, isotherm
and mechanism analysis’, Journal of Hazardous Materials, 198, pp. 282–290.
2. Borna M.O., Pirsaheb M., Niri M.V., Mashizie R.K., Kakavandi B., Zare M.R. and Asadi A.
(2016) ‘Batch and column studies for the adsorption of chromium(VI) on low-cost Hibiscus
Cannabinus kenaf, a green adsorbent’, Journal of the Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers,
68, pp. 80–89.
1127
Water and wastewater treatment and management
3. Dehghani M.H., Heibati B., Asadi A., Tyagi I., Agarwal S. and Gupta V.K. (2016) ‘Reduction of
noxious Cr(VI) ion to Cr(III) ion in aqueous solutions using H2O2 and UV/H2O2 systems.”,
Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry ,33, pp. 197–200.
4. Dermatas D., Mpouras T., Chrysochoou M., Panagiotakis I., Vatseris C., Linardos N., Theologou
E., Boboti N., Xenidis A., Papassiopi N. and Sakellariou L. (2015) ‘Origin and concentration
profile of chromium in a Greek aquifer’, Journal of Hazardous Materials, 281, pp. 35-46.
5. Dermatas D., Panagiotakis I., Mpouras T. and Tettas K. (2016) ‘The origin of Hevalent Chromium
as a Critical Parameter for Remediation of Contaminated Aquifers’, Bulletin of Environmental
Contamination and Toxicology, 98, pp. 331–337.
6. Di Z.C., Li Y.H., Luan Z.K. and Liang J. (2004) ‘Adsorption of Chromium(VI) Ions from Water
by Carbon Nanotubes’, Adsorption Science & Technology, 22, 6, pp. 467-474.
7. Gehrke I., Geiser A. and Somborn-Schulz A. (2015) ‘Innovations in nanotechnology for water
treatment’, Nanotechnology, Science and Applications, 8, pp. 1–17.
8. Goel J., Kadirvelu K., Rajagopal C. and Garg V.K. (2005) ‘Removal of lead(II) by adsorption
using treated granular activatedcarbon: Batch and column studies’, Journal of Hazardous
Materials, B125, pp. 211–220.
9. Hu J., Wang S.W., Shao D.D., Dong Y.H., Li J.X. and. Wang X.K (2009) ‘Adsorption and
Reduction of Chromium(VI) from Aqueous Solution by Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes’, The
Open Environmental Pollution & Toxicology Journal, 2, pp. 66-73.
10. Iijima S. (1991) ‘Helical microtubules of graphitic carbon’, Nature, 354, pp. 56-58.
11. Jung C., Heo J., Han J., Her N., Lee S.-J., Oh J., Ryu J. and Yoon Y. (2013) ‘Hexavalent
chromium removal by various adsorbents: Powered activated carbon, chitosan, and single/multiwalled carbon nanotubes’, Separation and Purification Technology, 106, pp. 63-71.
12. Matlochová A., Plachá D. and Rapantová N. (2013) ‘The Application of Nanoscale Materials in
Groundwater Remediation’, Polish Journal of Environmental Studies, 22, pp. 1401-1410.
13. Pourfadakari S., Yousefi N. and Mahvi A.H. (2016) “Removal of Reactive Red 198 from aqueous
solution by combined method multi-walled carbon nanotubes and zero-valent iron: Equilibrium,
kinetics, and thermodynamic”, Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering, 24, pp. 1448–1455.
14. Qureshi M.I., Patel F., Al-Baghli N., Abussaud B., Tawabini B.S. and Laoui T. (2017) ‘A
Comparative Study of Raw and Metal Oxide Impregnated Carbon Nanotubes for the Adsorption
of Hexavalent Chromium from Aqueous Solution’, Bioinorganic Chemistry and Applications,
Article ID 1624243, 10 pages.
15. Saha R., Nandi R. and Saha B. (2011) ‘Sources and toxicity of hexavalent chromium’, Journal
of Coordination Chemistry, 64, pp. 1782–1806.
16. Zeng Y., Woo H., Lee G. and Park J. (2010) ‘Adsorption of Cr(VI) on hexadecylpyridinium
bromide (HDPB) modified natural zeolites’, Microporous and Mesoporous Materials, 130, pp.
83–91.
17. Zhang Y., Wu B., Xu H., Liu H., Wang M., He Y. and Pan B. (2016) ‘Nanomaterials-enabled
water and wastewater treatment’, Nano Impact, 3–4, pp. 22–39.
1128
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
THE USE OF NANOCRYSTALLINE TITANIUM DIOXIDE IN
REMOVING HEAVY METALS FROM WATER: A HISTORICAL
PERSPECTIVE OF SCIENTIFIC ADVANCEMENTS
G. P. Korfiatis*, X. Meng and Q. Shi
Center for Environmental Systems, Stevens Institute of Technology, Hoboken, New Jersey 07030,
United States
*Corresponding author: e-mail: gkorfiat@stevens.edu, tel.: +12012165348
Abstract
In early 2000, a research group at Stevens Institute of Technology discovered that nanocrystalline
TiO2 (anatase) with a particle size of about 7 nm had very high adsorption capacity for arsenic, lead,
and other heavy metals. When the particle size increased from 7 to 30 nm, the adsorption capacity
decreased dramatically. A patent application was filed in 2002 and a U.S. patent was granted in 2005
for the invention. This patented nano-crystalline TiO2 shows high performance for heavy metal
removal in water and consists of anatase with crystalline diameter of 7 nm and specific surface area
of 330 m2/g. It exhibited much higher arsenic removal ability than other commercial TiO2 materials
(Degussa P25 and Hombikat UV100, 3.5-22.5 mg/g) (Dutta et al., 2004; Pena et al., 2005a), and was
effective in removing other heavy metals such as lead, copper, uranium, mercury, chromium, and
cadmium. This invention became the catalyst for systematic studies of the adsorption mechanisms of
many heavy metals leading to significant increases in publications on the subject. Before 2003, most
of researchers used commercial TiO2 (Degussa P25) as photocatalyst for oxidation of organic
compounds and very few researchers studied its adsorption properties. Degussa P25 is a mixture of
anatase and rutile with a particle size of 30 nm and a specific surface area of 55 m2/g, compared to a
specific surface of 330 m2/g for nanocrystalline TiO2 (anatase, 7 nm). It has much lower adsorption
capacity than nanocrystalline TiO2. From 2003 to 2017, the annual publication rate on heavy metal
removal by TiO2 has increased from less than 10/yr to more than 90/yr while the annual rate of
citations of the related papers have increased from 150/yr to about 1900/yr. A commercial entity was
launched in 2005 to market the nanocrystalline TiO2 product for treatment of arsenic and heavy metals
in water. The annual sales of the adsorbent have reached $7M in 2017. This paper addresses the
historical scientific developments of nanocrystalline TiO2 that have taken place over the past 15 years
and the impact these developments have had on water treatment.
Keywords: nanocrystalline TiO2; heavy metal; arsenic; adsorption; oxidation; water treatment
1.
INTRODUCTION
TiO2 had been recognized as an effective photocatalyst for treatment of organic compounds for many
years before it was used as adsorbent for heavy metal removal from water in the research around
2000. In 1998, studies regarding the Pb2+ and Cr(VI) adsorption ability of TiO2 were reported
(Hongxiang et al., 1998; Vohra and Davis, 1998). A material consisting of calcium oxalate-coated
with TiO2 layer was tested for Pb2+ and Hg2+ extraction from aqueous solutions (Fu et al., 1998). Lee
and Choi (2002) reported oxidation of As(III) to As(V) in TiO2 suspension.
In 2001, a research group at Stevens Institute of Technology synthesized the nano-crystalline TiO2,
which showed high performance for heavy metal (such as arsenic, lead, and selenium) removal in
1129
Water and wastewater treatment and management
water. This work led to a patent (Meng et al., 2005) and a 14 publications (Bang et al., 2005; Jing et
al., 2005a; Jing et al., 2005b; Pena et al., 2005b; Pena et al., 2006; Wazne et al., 2006; Choy et al.,
2008; Jing et al., 2008; Liu et al., 2008; Xu et al., 2008; Jing et al., 2009; Xu and Meng, 2009a; Bang
et al., 2011; Guan et al., 2012). According to Google Scholar, those publications have been cited by
other researchers in about 70 countries more than 1650 times. Our study regarding nanocrystalline
TiO2 and the historical perspective of scientific advancements after our work are reviewed in this
paper.
2.
DEVELOPMENT AND ADSOPRTION PROPERTIES OF THE NANOCRYSTALLINE
TITANIUM DIOXIDE
The nanocrystalline TiO2 was synthesized through hydrolysis of titanium solutions under controlled
temperature (Meng et al., 2005). The transmission electron microcopy (TEM) image in Figure 1
shows the morphology and size of the primary TiO2 particles. The X-ray diffraction (Figure 2)
analysis determined that the precipitates were anatase and the average size of the primary crystalline
particles was about 6.6 nm. The specific surface area of the material was 330 m2/g. It showed
significantly higher As(III) (37.5 mg/g) and As(V) (59.9 mg/g) removal ability than other commercial
TiO2 materials (Degussa P25 and Hombikat UV100, 3.5-22.5 mg/g) (Dutta et al., 2004; Pena et al.,
2005a). The nanocrystalline TiO2 could also be used for the removal of other heavy metals, such as
lead, copper, uranium, mercury, cadmium, chromium, and arsenic (Meng et al., 2005). The
mechanisms of arsenic adsorption by the nanocrystalline TiO2 was investigated with electrophoretic
mobility (EM) measurements, Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, extended X-ray
absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy, and surface complexation modeling (Pena et al.,
2006). Both As(V) and As(III) formed bidentate binuclear surface complexes with an average TiAs(V) bond distance of 3.30 Å and Ti-As(III) bond distance of 3.35 Å.
Figure 1. Transmission electron microscopy image of nanocrystalline TiO2.
1130
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
o
25.29
Bragg law: 2dsin =n; (FeK) = 1.9373 Å
Scherrer Crystallite Size =K / cos =7.57nm
o
Intensity [a.u.]
(K=0.89, FWHM unbroadened peak=0.15 )
o
FWHM=1.215
o
47.90
o
38.00
o
54.77
o
62.71
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
65
o
2 [ ]
Figure 2. X-ray diffraction spectra of nanocrystalline TiO2.
Further research was performed to study and effect of the nanocrystalline TiO2 size on the adsorption
properties (Xu and Meng, 2009b). The anatase TiO2 samples with crystallite size of 7.0, 10.5, 14.8
and 30.1 nm were prepared by calcining the 6.6 nm TiO2 at 200, 350, 500, and 700 ◦C for 3 h. The
crystalline size the nano TiO2 had significant effect on the As(III) and As(V) removal. With increasing
size, the specific surface area, pore volume and surface –OH density decreased, and the average pore
diameter increased. The As(III) and As(V) removal ability of TiO2 decreased significantly with the
increase of crystalline size (Figure 3). The amount of adsorbed As(V) decreased from 26.5 to 1.7 mgAs/g when the crystalline size of TiO2 increased from 6.6 to 30.1 nm. The size effect was mainly
attributed to the reduced specific surface area and surface –OH density.
30
Arsenate removal
As removal (mg/g)
25
Arsenite removal
20
15
10
5
0
6.6
7
10.5
14.8
30.1
Nanoparticle size of titanium dioxide (nm)
Figure 3. Size effects of nanocrystalline TiO2 on As(V) and As(III) removal, 1g/L TiO2 in tap
water, 50 mg-As/L, mixed for 1 hour, pH=7.0 ± 0.1.
3. PROGRESS IN TITANIUM DIOXIDE RESEARCH
Since the Stevens group reported the effective removal of arsenic by nanocrystalline TiO2 in early
2000s, many researchers have made significant progress, such as development of TiO2 composite
adsorbent, treatment of other heavy metals with TiO2, and synthesis of TiO2 with specific facets and
high adsorption capacities.
1131
Water and wastewater treatment and management
3.1 Treatment of other heavy metals using TiO2
The application of nanocrystalline TiO2 was extended from arsenic and uranium to other heavy metal
removal (Table 1). For example, Engates and and Shipley (2011) synthesized TiO2 nanoparticles with
the specific surface area of 185.5 m2/g. They further compared the performance of heavy metal
removal by nano and bulk TiO2 (size of 329.8 nm, and surface area of 9.5 m2/g). The results indicated
much higher lead (Pb2+, 83.1 mg/g), zinc (Zn2+, 15.3 mg/g), and nickel (Ni2+, 6.8 mg/g) removal by
nano TiO2 than bulk TiO2 (64.7, 6.2, and 3.7 mg/g for Pb2+, Zn2+, and Ni2+, respectively).
Moreover, a commercial nanostructured TiO2 (10-15 nm) from was proved to be able to remove
selenite (Se(IV) and selenite (Se(VI) effectively at pH 2-6 (Zhang et al., 2009). Zhao et al. (2009)
synthesized nanohybrid WO3/TiO2 by a sol-gel method with titanium alkoxide and phosphotungstic
acid (H3PW12O40) as precursors. The WO3/TiO2 consists of WO3 clusters on nano TiO2 (15-20 nm)
and performed well for silver (Ag+) removal. Additionally, different nanocrystalline TiO2 with a size
range from 40-150 nm was synthesized and successfully used for antimony (Sb) removal (Song et
al., 2017; Yan et al., 2017).
Table 1. Nanocrystalline TiO2 used for other heavy metals removal.
Crystalline size of TiO2 Heavy metals
Published
Reference
(nm)
year
8.3
Ni2+, Zn2+
2011
(Engates and Shipley, 2011)
10-15
Se(IV), Se(VI)
2009
(Zhang et al., 2009)
40-150
Sb(VI)
Sb(III)
2017
(Song et al., 2017; Yan et al.,
2017)
15-20
Ag+
2009
(Zhao et al., 2009)
and
3.2 Nanocrystalline TiO2 based composite adsorbents
After the good performance of TiO2 for heavy metal removal was reported, numerous studies were
reported regarding composite materials by doping nanocrystalline TiO2 on other well-known
adsorbents. Widely used composites are TiO2-coated carbon-based materials, including graphene
(Wang et al., 2017), graphene oxide (Lee and Yang, 2012), carbon nanotube (Doong and Chiang,
2008), and chitosan (Tao et al., 2009; Samadi et al., 2014). The synthesized composite materials
showed good removal performance for Zn2+, Cd2+, Pb2+, Hg2+, Fe2+, Cr(VI), As(V), and As(III).
Moreover, TiO2 was also composited with other metal oxides for heavy metal removal. Slag-iron
oxide and WO3 were synthesized in the presence of Ti(IV) solution, and tested for removal of Ag+,
Cr(VI), Hg2+, and As(V) removal (Zhang and Itoh, 2006; Zhao et al., 2009).
Table 2. Composited adsorbents based on nanocrystalline TiO2 for heavy metal removal
Adsorbents
Heavy metals
Published year
Reference
TiO2-Fe2O3
As(III)
2006
(Zhang and Itoh, 2006)
2+
2008
(Doong and Chiang, 2008)
2009
(Tao et al., 2009)
2009
(Zhao et al., 2009)
2012
(Lee and Yang, 2012)
TiO2-carbon nanotube
Cu
TiO2-chitosan
Pb2+
TiO2-WO3
2+
Cr(VI), Hg , Ag
2+
2+
+
2+
TiO2-graphene oxide
Zn , Cd , Pb
TiO2/Cu-chitosan
Pb2+, Cr(VI)
2014
(Samadi et al., 2014)
TiO2-graphene
Cr(VI)
2017
(Wang et al., 2017)
1132
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.3 Effect of crystalline facets
As a nanostructured metal oxide with good crystalline quality, significant structural differences
occurred on different crystalline facets of TiO2, which obviously affects the heavy metal removal
ability. The effects of crystalline facets on As(V) and As(III) removal were revealed by Yan et al. (in
2016). The {001} facets on TiO2 showed higher performance for As(V) and As(III) removal than
{101} surfaces. Moreover, the crystal facets also determine the adsorption of Sb(III) on
nanocrystalline TiO2 (Song et al., 2017; Yan et al., 2017). Nanocrystalline TiO2 with a high index
crystalline facet of {201} showed better Sb(III) removal than that with a crystalline facet (e.g. {001}
and {101}), although the former had a lower surface area. This difference was attributed to the higher
surface energy (γ = 1.72 J m−2) of {201} facets calculated by density functional theory (DFT).
4. CONCLUSIONS
A historical progress in the development of TiO2-based adsorbents for treatment of heavy metals is
summarized in Figures 4 and 5. After the discovery of high adsorption property of nanocrystalline
TiO2 with crystalline size within a range of about 1 – 30 nm, the application of TiO2 has expanded
from photo-catalysis to adsorption of heavy metals. Various TiO2-based composite adsorbents and
TiO2 with specific crystalline facets have been developed.
Figure 4. Progress of heavy metal removal by nanocrystalline TiO2.
Figure 5 shows that the number of papers on heavy metal removal by TiO2 has increased
exponentially from a few per year before 2003 to about 90 per year after 2014. Meanwhile the citation
of related publications has increased from less than 150 per year before 2003 to about 1900 per year
since 2016.
Figure 5. The number of publications (left) and citations (right) on heavy metal removal using
TiO2 from 1991 to 2017, through the Web of Science™ Core Collection. The keywords for
searching are “heavy metal” and “TiO2.”
1133
Water and wastewater treatment and management
References
1. Dutta, P.K., Ray, A.K., Sharma, V.K., Millero, F.J. (2004) ‘Adsorption of arsenate and arsenite
on titanium dioxide suspensions’, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science Vol 278(2), pp. 270275.
2. Pena, M.E., Korfiatis, G.P., Patel, M., Lippincott, L., Meng, X.G. (2005a) ‘Adsorption of As(V)
and As(III) by nanocrystalline titanium dioxide’, Water Research Vol 39(11), pp. 2327-2337.
3. Hongxiang, F., Gongxuan, L., Shuben, L. (1998) ‘Adsorption of Chromium(VI) Ions on to TiO2
from Aqueous Solution’, Adsorption Science & Technology Vol 16(2), pp. 117-126.
4. Vohra, M.S., Davis, A.P. (1998) ‘Adsorption of Pb(II), EDTA, and Pb(II)-EDTA onto TiO2’,
Journal of Colloid and Interface Science Vol 198(1), pp. 18-26.
5. Fu, H.X., Lu, G.X., Li, S.B. (1998) ‘Adsorption of chromium(VI) ions on to TiO2 from aqueous
solution’, Adsorption Science & Technology Vol 16(2), pp. 117-126.
6. Lee, H., Choi, W. (2002) ‘Photocatalytic Oxidation of Arsenite in TiO2 Suspension: Kinetics and
Mechanisms’, Environmental Science & Technology Vol 36(17), pp. 3872-3878.
7. Meng, X., Dadachov, M., Korfiatis, G.P., Christodoulatos, C. (2005) Methods of preparing a
surface-activated titanium oxide product and of using same in water treatment processes. US
Patent: 6,919,029.
8. Bang, S., Patel, M., Lippincott, L., Meng, X. (2005) ‘Removal of arsenic from groundwater by
granular titanium dioxide adsorbent’, Chemosphere Vol 60(3), pp. 389-397.
9. Jing, C., Liu, S., Patel, M., Meng, X. (2005a) ‘Arsenic leachability in water treatment adsorbents’,
Environmental science & technology Vol 39(14), pp. 5481-5487.
10. Jing, C., Meng, X., Liu, S., Baidas, S., Patraju, R., Christodoulatos, C., Korfiatis, G.P. (2005b)
‘Surface complexation of organic arsenic on nanocrystalline titanium oxide’, Journal of Colloid
and Interface Science Vol 290(1), pp. 14-21.
11. Pena, M.E., Korfiatis, G.P., Patel, M., Lippincott, L., Meng, X. (2005b) ‘Adsorption of As (V)
and As (III) by nanocrystalline titanium dioxide’, Water Research Vol 39(11), pp. 2327-2337.
12. Pena, M., Meng, X., Korfiatis, G.P., Jing, C. (2006) ‘Adsorption mechanism of arsenic on
nanocrystalline titanium dioxide’, Environmental Science & Technology Vol 40(4), pp. 12571262.
13. Wazne, M., Meng, X., Korfiatis, G.P., Christodoulatos, C. (2006) ‘Carbonate effects on
hexavalent uranium removal from water by nanocrystalline titanium dioxide’, Journal of
Hazardous Materials Vol 136(1), pp. 47-52.
14. Choy, C.C., Wazne, M., Meng, X. (2008) ‘Application of an empirical transport model to simulate
retention of nanocrystalline titanium dioxide in sand columns’, Chemosphere Vol 71(9), pp.
1794-1801.
15. Jing, C., Liu, S., Meng, X. (2008) ‘Arsenic remobilization in water treatment adsorbents under
reducing conditions: Part I. Incubation study’, Science of the Total Environment Vol 389(1),
pp. 188-194.
16. Liu, S., Jing, C., Meng, X. (2008) ‘Arsenic re-mobilization in water treatment adsorbents under
reducing conditions: Part II. XAS and modeling study’, Science of the Total Environment Vol
392(1), pp. 137-144.
17. Xu, Z., Jing, C., Li, F., Meng, X. (2008) ‘Mechanisms of photocatalytical degradation of
monomethylarsonic and dimethylarsinic acids using nanocrystalline titanium dioxide’,
Environmental Science & Technology Vol 42(7), pp. 2349-2354.
1134
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
18. Jing, C., Meng, X., Calvache, E., Jiang, G. (2009) ‘Remediation of organic and inorganic arsenic
contaminated groundwater using a nanocrystalline TiO 2-based adsorbent’, Environmental
Pollution Vol 157(8), pp. 2514-2519.
19. Xu, Z., Meng, X. (2009a) ‘Size effects of nanocrystalline TiO 2 on As (V) and As (III) adsorption
and As (III) photooxidation’, Journal of Hazardous Materials Vol 168(2), pp. 747-752.
20. Bang, S., Pena, M.E., Patel, M., Lippincott, L., Meng, X., Kim, K.-W. (2011) ‘Removal of
arsenate from water by adsorbents: a comparative case study’, Environmental Geochemistry
and Health Vol 33(1), pp. 133-141.
21. Guan, X., Du, J., Meng, X., Sun, Y., Sun, B., Hu, Q. (2012) ‘Application of titanium dioxide in
arsenic removal from water: a review’, Journal of Hazardous Materials Vol 215(pp. 1-16.
22. Xu, Z., Meng, X. (2009b) ‘Size effects of nanocrystalline TiO2 on As(V) and As(III) adsorption
and As(III) photooxidation’, Journal of Hazardous Materials Vol 168(2), pp. 747-752.
23. Engates, K.E., Shipley, H.J. (2011) ‘Adsorption of Pb, Cd, Cu, Zn, and Ni to titanium dioxide
nanoparticles: effect of particle size, solid concentration, and exhaustion’, Environmental
Science and Pollution Research Vol 18(3), pp. 386-395.
24. Zhang, L., Liu, N., Yang, L., Lin, Q. (2009) ‘Sorption behavior of nano-TiO2 for the removal of
selenium ions from aqueous solution’, Journal of Hazardous Materials Vol 170(2), pp. 11971203.
25. Zhao, D., Chen, C., Yu, C., Ma, W., Zhao, J. (2009) ‘Photoinduced Electron Storage in
WO3/TiO2 Nanohybrid Material in the Presence of Oxygen and Postirradiated Reduction of
Heavy Metal Ions’, The Journal of Physical Chemistry C Vol 113(30), pp. 13160-13165.
26. Song, J., Yan, L., Duan, J., Jing, C. (2017) ‘TiO2 crystal facet-dependent antimony adsorption
and photocatalytic oxidation’, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science Vol 496(Supplement
C), pp. 522-530.
27. Yan, L., Song, J., Chan, T., Jing, C. (2017) ‘Insights into Antimony Adsorption on {001} TiO2:
XAFS and DFT Study’, Environmental Science & Technology Vol 51(11), pp. 6335-6341.
28. Wang, W.L., Wang, Z.F., Liu, J.J., Zhang, Z.G., Sun, L.Y. (2017) ‘Single-step One-pot Synthesis
of Graphene Foam/TiO2 Nanosheet Hybrids for Effective Water Treatment’, Scientific Reports
Vol 7, pp. 8.
29. Lee, Y.-C., Yang, J.-W. (2012) ‘Self-assembled flower-like TiO2 on exfoliated graphite oxide for
heavy metal removal’, Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Vol 18(3), pp. 11781185.
30. Doong, R.-A., Chiang, L.-F. (2008) ‘Coupled removal of organic compounds and heavy metals
by titanate/carbon nanotube composites’, Water Science and Technology Vol 58(10), pp. 19851992.
31. Tao, Y., Ye, L., Pan, J., Wang, Y., Tang, B. (2009) ‘Removal of Pb(II) from aqueous solution on
chitosan/TiO2 hybrid film’, Journal of Hazardous Materials Vol 161(2), pp. 718-722.
32. Samadi, S., Khalilian, F., Tabatabaee, A. (2014) ‘Synthesis, characterization and application of
Cu–TiO2/chitosan nanocomposite thin film for the removal of some heavy metals from aquatic
media’, Journal of Nanostructure in Chemistry Vol 4(1), pp. 84.
33. Zhang, F.-S., Itoh, H. (2006) ‘Photocatalytic oxidation and removal of arsenite from water using
slag-iron oxide-TiO2 adsorbent’, Chemosphere Vol 65(1), pp. 125-131.
34. Yan, L., Du, J., Jing, C. (2016) ‘How TiO2 facets determine arsenic adsorption and
photooxidation: spectroscopic and DFT studies’, Catalysis Science & Technology Vol 6(7), pp.
2419-2426.
1135
Water and wastewater treatment and management
DEGRADATION OF 2,4-DINITROANISOLE (DNAN) IN
AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS BY MG-BASED BIMETALS
A. Mai1, P. Karanam2, E. Hadnagy2, S. Menacherry3, W. Braida1, C. Christodoulatos1,
A. Koutsospyros2*, T. S. Su1
1
Center for Environmental Systems, Stevens Institute of Technology,Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA
2
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of New Haven
3
Department of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, University of New Haven, West Haven, CT
06516, USA
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: akoutsospyros@newhaven.edu, tel : +012039327398
Abstract
The industrial production of munition 2,4-dinitroanisole (DNAN) generates waste streams that
require treatment. Treatment of DNAN has been attempted previously using zero-valent iron (ZVI)
and Fe-based bimetals. Use of Mg-based bimetals maybe advantageous to Fe in terms of potential
higher reactivity and relative insensitivity to pH conditions. This work reports results on the
degradation of DNAN by three Mg-based bimetals: Mg/Cu, Mg/Ni, and Mg/Zn. Kinetic data obtained
in benchtop-scale batch reactors were modelled according to a pseudo-first-order expression.
Parametric studies were conducted to assess the effect of type of bimetal pair and initial pH on DNAN
degradation. Pseudo-first order kinetic constants were 0.119, 0.102, 0.018, and 0.009 min-1 for
Mg/Cu, Mg/Zn, Mg/Ni, and ZVMg, respectively (unadjusted initial pH, 0.5% S/L, 10:1 Mg: catalytic
metal). Initial acidification with acetic acid (pH range 3.3-4.0) improved significantly the reaction
rate by all of the attempted bimetal formulations and ZVMg producing DNAN degradation half-lives
in the range of 0.9-1.4 minutes. Constant temperature experiments at 20, 26, 32, 36 and 450C, using
the most effective bimetal pair under normal pH conditions (Mg/Cu), were conducted under identical
conditions of solids loading (0.5% S/L) and base to secondary metal ratio (10:1). The activation
energy for the reductive degradation of DNAN by Mg/Cu bimetal was determined to be 8.18 kJ/mol.
Keywords: 2,4-dinitroanisole, DNAN, insensitive munition, magnesium bimetal, reductive
degradation
1.
INTRODUCTION
The search for safer explosives that reduce the risk of accidental detonation has led to development
of new energetic compounds. The nitro-aromatic compound DNAN is an explosive of decreased
sensitivity often incorporated into various munitions formulations. The production of DNAN
generates contaminated wastewater streams that, if untreated, may pose environmental risk [Olivares
et al., 2016]. Several researchers currently work on elucidating the fate and transport of DNAN and
its transformed products [Olivares et al., 2016; Hawari et al., 2015; Taylor et al., 2017; Arthur et al.,
2017], however, more work is needed for complete characterization. Meanwhile, various treatment
methods have been tested for the removal and/or degradation of DNAN.
Known treatment methods of DNAN include biotic (using various strains of bacteria) and abiotic
(photochemical degradation, chemical oxidation/reduction) technologies. One type of abiotic process
involves treatment using zero-valent metals (e.g. zero-valent iron, ZVI) or bimetal combinations
1136
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
(typically iron- or magnesium-based) to degrade DNAN via a reductive pathway. ZVI and iron-based
bimetals have been most commonly used for the degradation of DNAN [Liu et al., 2015; Ahn et al.,
2011; Shen et al., 2013; Koutsospyros et al., 2012; Kitcher et al., 2017]. However, recent advances
in bimetal technology indicate that magnesium-based bimetals can successfully degrade various types
of organic [Ghauch & Tuqan, 2009; DeVor et al., 2008] and inorganic [Ramavandi et al., 2011]
contaminants and offer a promising more effective alternative to Fe-based treatment [Morales et al.,
2002].
Previously, treatment of DNAN by Fe-based bimetals have been studied [Koutsospyros et al., 2012;
Kitcher et al., 2017]. Koutsopyros et al. (2012) used Fe/Cu to remove DNAN and other explosive
and energetic compounds from industrial pinkwater and reported short treatment times in the span of
minutes. Kitcher et al. (2017) treated DNAN both in insensitive munition explosive (IMX)
wastewater and pure solutions with Fe/Cu bimetal under acidic pH conditions (2.3-2.9). The major
variables studied in Kitcher’s work included: matrix effects, activation energy, effect of pH and acid
type, impact of solid vs. dissolved base metal (i.e. Fe), and impact of type of bimetal contact (i.e.
physical mixture of Fe0/Cu0 vs. Cu-coated Fe0). Both of these studies investigated DNAN removal in
acidic media (i.e. pH <3) since Fe-based bimetals have been shown to be the most effective in
degrading organic contaminants at acidic pH levels [Khalil et al., 2016; Rivero-Huguet & Marshall,
2009; Tian et al., 2009]. Mg-based bimetals, on the other hand, may be less sensitive to pH conditions
[Patel & Suresh, 2008], thus providing a potential alternative for DNAN treatment for situations when
additional pH adjustment in the treatment system is undesired. The treatment of DNAN with Mgbased bimetals has not yet been researched, nor have subsequent parametric studies been established.
In the present work, parametric studies were conducted to investigate the reaction kinetics of DNAN
degradation by various Mg-based bimetals. This work reports on the impact of secondary metal type
(namely Cu, Ni, and Zn), initial pH adjustment, and temperature.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Chemicals and materials
Solid magnesium particles (20-230 mesh, reagent grade, 98% purity), copper (II) chloride (99%),
nickel (II) chloride (98% purity), zinc chloride (98% purity) and glacial acetic acid (99 %+) were all
purchased from Sigma Aldrich (St. Louis, MO). Syringe filters (0.45 micron, nylon) were purchased
from Achemtek (Worcester, MA). DNAN solids and DNAN standard dissolved in acetonitrile were
obtained from an industrial munitions facility. Catalytic metal chloride solutions (i.e. CuCl2, ZnCl2,
NiCl2) were prepared in DI water such that addition of a fixed volume, i.e. 1 mL, to the reactor
delivered a 10:1 ratio of Mg base metal to secondary metal (i.e. Ni, Cu, or Zn).
2.2 Kinetic experiments
All batch experiments were carried out in 40 mL Volatile Organic Analyte (VOA) vials containing
24 mL reaction solution with 0.5 % solids-to-liquids (S/L) ratio and 10:1 Mg to secondary metal (i.e.
Cu, Ni, and Zn) ratio in both the absence and presence of 4.35 N acetic acid. First, 0.12 g of Mg
granules was placed in the reactor vial and 12 mL of water was added and mixed fully. Next, to
synthesize the bimetal reagent, 1 mL of the catalytic metal solution was added and mixed for 5
minutes. The reaction was initiated by adding 10 mL of DNAN solution of 250 ppm. In the unadjusted
initial pH experiments, 1 mL of water was added and in the lowered initial pH experiments, 1 mL of
4.35N acetic acid was added to the reaction mixture. Experiments were conducted in duplicate.
Venting was provided for the hydrogen gas generated by capping the reactor with punctured
aluminum foil. The initial and the final pH of the solution were measured. At the end of the reaction,
an aliquot of the reaction solution was taken using a 0.45 µm nylon syringe filter and subsequently
samples were stored in amber glass vials.
Sacrificial sampling was used to determine the rates and extent of degradation of DNAN, as opposed
to semi-continuous sampling from one large batch reactor. Separate identical batch reactors were
1137
Water and wastewater treatment and management
prepared and were removed for sampling at the prescribed times of 5, 10, 15, 30, 60, 90, 120 and 150
minutes.
2.3 Temperature controlled experiments
Degradation of DNAN by Mg/Cu was tested at different temperatures (i.e. 20°C, 26°C, 32°C, 36°C
and 45°C) to evaluate the impact of temperature and to determine the activation energy of the reaction.
The experimental conditions were the same as in previous experiments, i.e. 0.5% S/L ratio and 10:1
base metal to catalyst ratio. The initial pH was not adjusted. A temperature control chamber was used
to maintain constant temperature during the reaction. The reaction solution was equilibrated to the
specified temperature prior to the start of the reaction. The temperature was measured using a
thermometer placed in water to remove bias from the digital controller of the constant temperature
chamber. Samples were taken at 5, 10, 15, 20, and 30 minutes. All experiments were conducted in
duplicate.
2.4 Analytical methods
DNAN concentrations were analyzed by reversed-phase high pressure liquid chromatography
(HPLC) on an Agilent 1260 instrument (Santa Clara, CA) equipped with a Grace Alltech
Adsorbosphere HS C-18 (5μm, 150x4.6mm) and a DAD detector. The mobile phase was an isocratic
mixture of methanol: water at 70:30 (v/v), pumped at 1 mL/min; the injection volume was 10 μL of
sample; the analytical wavelength was 254 nm. At these conditions, DNAN eluted at 4.1 min. Blank
samples and known concentration standards were periodically run for QA/QC purposes.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
In this work, the impacts of catalytic metal type, initial pH, and temperature on DNAN degradation
by Mg-based bimetals are reported.
3.1 Influence of the catalytic metal
The kinetics of DNAN degradation in aqueous solutions was investigated using three bimetallic
systems, namely Mg/Cu, Mg/Ni and Mg/Zn, and treatment effectiveness was compared to that with
zero-valent magnesium (ZVMg) without the addition of a catalytic metal. Kinetic experiments were
conducted to establish time-concentration profiles and a pseudo-first-order reaction rate constant, k
was determined by fitting and exponential decay model via nonlinear regression.
Time-concentration profiles for ZVMg and the three bimetallic systems (i.e. Mg/Cu, Mg/Ni, Mg/Zn),
shown in Figure 1, indicate a fast DNAN degradation reaction for the first 30 minutes, which tends
to taper off thereafter. DNAN degradation by ZVMg alone (i.e. without a catalytic metal), was the
least effective with 34% DNAN removal in 150 minutes (Figure 1a). On the other hand, treatment
with Mg/Cu removed 99% of DNAN in 30 minutes (Figure 1b), while 99% removal by Mg/Zn was
achieved after 120 minutes (Figure 1d). Treatment with Mg/Ni was slower with 93% of DNAN
degradation in 150 minutes (Figure 1c). These results proved that the presence of a catalytic metal
increased both the rate and the extent of DNAN degradation. In addition, the extent to which DNAN
removal efficiency was improved depended on the catalyst type, generally Cu being the most
effective, followed by Zn, and then by Ni.
The pH of each bimetal system was initially in the neutral range of 6.8-7.8 and increased to a final
pH of 9.7-10.3 (Figure 1). Conversely, for ZVMg treatment, the system pH was generally slightly
higher with an initial pH of 11.4 and final pH of 10.9. The initial pH (measured at time 0) was
determined immediately after the addition of the DNAN solution to the synthesized bimetal.
1138
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
1.0
12
1.0
0.8
8
4
0.4
0.2
4
0.2
0.0
0
0
30
60
90
120
0.0
150
0
0
Time (min)
(a) ZVMg
30
60
90
120
150
Time (min)
(b) Mg/Cu
1.0
1.0
12
12
0.8
pH
0.6
0.4
4
0.2
C/C0
8
8
0.6
0.4
4
pH
0.8
C/Co
pH
0.4
8
0.6
C/Co
0.6
pH
C/Co
0.8
12
0.2
0.0
0
0
(c) Mg/Ni
30
60
90
120
0.0
150
Time (min)
0
0
30
(d) Mg/Zn
60
90
120
150
Time (min)
Legend:
Figure 1: DNAN degradation and pH over time by: (a) zero-valent magnesium (ZVMg), (b)
Mg/Cu, (c) Mg/Ni, and (d) Mg/Zn (0.5% S/L, 10:1 Mg to catalyst ratio)
The time-concentration profiles were used for the determination of reaction rate constants. The
reaction was evaluated by applying a pseudo-first-order kinetic expression (Equation 1) to the initial
nonlinear portion of the C/C0 vs. time (t, min) curve and the reaction rate constants were determined
by nonlinear regression analysis:
𝐶
= 𝑒𝑥𝑝(−𝑘𝑡)
(1)
𝐶
0
Where:
C = Contaminant concentration at time t (mg/L)
Co = Initial contaminant concentration (mg/L)
k = Pseudo-first-order reaction rate constant (min-1)
t = Reaction time (min)
DNAN degradation was the slowest using ZVMg with a reaction rate constant of 0.009 min-1 (Table
1). The fastest reaction rate constant (0.119 min-1) was achieved with Mg/Cu and was 13.6 times
faster than that of ZVMg. Treatment by Mg/Ni and Mg/Zn gave reaction rate constants of 0.018 and
0.102 min-1 (5 and 10 times faster than ZVMg), respectively. Half-lives were determined from
Equation 1 for the C/C0 = 0.5 and the determined reaction rate constants. The determined half-lives
for the three bimetal formulations are in the range 5.8-37.7 minutes and are much shorter than the
half-life of ZVMg which is longer than 1 hour.
1139
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Table 1: Reaction rate constants of DNAN degradation
Treatment System
k (min-1)
R2
k/kZVMg*
Half-Life, min
ZVMg
0.009
0.781
1
78.8
Mg/Cu
0.119
0.946
13.6
5.8
Mg/Ni
0.018
0.995
2.1
37.7
Mg/Zn
0.102
0.726
11.6
6.8
*Reaction rate constants are normalized with respect to ZVMg
3.2 Influence of lowered initial pH
DNAN degradation kinetic experiments using low initial pH conditions were also performed and
results of these experiments were compared to the initial unadjusted pH runs. The initial pH of the
reaction solution was lowered by addition of 4.35N acetic acid. The experimental conditions were
kept the same as in the unadjusted pH experiments at 0.5% S/L ratio and 10:1 base metal to catalyst
ratio. The lowered adjusted initial pH for all treatment systems was between 3.3 and 4.0. No
subsequent pH adjustments were made and the reaction pH was measured at each sampling time. In
a low pH medium, any oxidized layer of the metal surface is dissolved, typically resulting in increased
reactivity of the bimetal surface [Liu et al., 2015; Guan et al., 2015].
ZVMg alone removed 98% of DNAN in just 10 minutes under acidic conditions, showing excellent
treatment efficiencies superior to those obtained in the unadjusted pH runs (Figure 3). In addition,
treatment with ZVMg at the lowered initial pH resulted in at least 5 times faster DNAN degradation
than treatment without pH adjustment by any bimetal system. Mg/Zn effectively removed 99% of
DNAN in 10 minutes and exhibited the fastest reaction kinetics compared to ZVMg and the other
two bimetals (i.e. Mg/Cu and Mg/Ni, Figure 4d). Treatment with Mg/Cu and Mg/Ni exhibited slightly
slower reaction kinetics with 93% DNAN removal within 10 min (Figure 4b, 4c).
1
12
0.8
8
pH
C/Co
0.6
0.4
4
0.2
0
-10
0
10
30
50
70
90
110
130
150
Time (min)
Figure 2: Comparison of DNAN degradation kinetics and pH for unadjusted and lowered
initial pH conditions in the ZVMg treatment system
1140
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
1
1
12
0.8
0.4
4
0.2
8
0.6
pH
0.6
C/Co
8
pH
0.4
4
0.2
0
0
0
(a) ZVMg
50
100
0
150
0
0
Time (min)
(b) Mg/Cu
1
50
100
150
Time (min)
1
12
12
0.8
8
pH
0.6
0.4
4
C/Co
0.8
0.2
8
0.6
pH
C/Co
0.8
C/Co
12
0.4
4
0.2
0
0
0
(c) Mg/Ni
50
100
Time (min)
0
150
0
0
(d) Mg/Zn
50
100
150
Time (min)
Legend:
Figure 3: DNAN removal and pH over time with lowered initial pH: (a) ZVMg, (b) Mg/Cu, (c)
Mg/Ni, and (d) Mg/Zn (0.5% S/L, 10:1 Mg to catalyst ratio)
Despite differences in degradation rates, all treatment systems exhibited ultimately the same DNAN
removal efficiency of over 99.7% in 150 min. Furthermore, pH measurements showed that within 30
min, the pH equilibrated to approximately 9.6 where it remained for the rest of the reaction for all
systems. For ZVMg, the pH equilibrated slightly higher at approximately 10.
A visual examination of the concentration-time curves reveals a rapid reaction period within the first
10 min producing near zero values thereafter. This behavior is consistent with reported literature
[Rivero-Huguet and Marshall, 2009] for other bimetal systems. Accordingly, the rapid target
compound depletion is dominated by the reduction reaction whereas passivation phenomena control
the final period. Viewed under this prism, the pseudo-first order model describes adequately the initial
reaction period but falls short of producing a good fit for the final period data. Thus, kinetic constants
reported herein, are obtained using the initial slope method for reaction times of 2,4,5,6, and 10 min.
The nonlinear regression analysis produced fair to very good quality curve fitting with correlation
coefficients (R2 values) in the range of 0.765-0.934 (Table 2). Data variability is attributed to
challenges associated with sampling and quenching a rapid heterogeneous reaction rather than to
model inadequacies. The reported values of the determined pseudo-first order constants vary within
the same order of magnitude (0.5 - 0.8 min-1), show a much smaller variability than the unadjusted
respective values, and mark comparable treatment effectiveness for all ZVMg and bimetal systems
(DNAN half-lives 0.9-1.4 min).
In comparison to the bimetal systems, ZVMg was affected drastically by the lowered pH, showing a
73-fold increase of the rate constant. Mg/Ni and Mg/Zn were fairly affected by the lowered pH
showing increases of k by 29 and 8-fold, whereas Mg/Cu was less affected with an increase of k by
4-fold. Interestingly, although the DNAN degradation performance of Mg/Cu was superior to the
other bimetals (Mg/Zn and Mg/Ni) in the unadjusted initial pH experiments, this was reversed when
the initial pH was lowered. This performance reversal may be associated to reaction mechanisms
elicited by the lowered pH. Under lowered initial pH, corrosion of the bimetal (and thus the
subsequent production of electrons) as well as dissolution of passivating oxide layers may be
dominant. Conversely, under normal initial pH conditions, electron release may be dominated by the
1141
Water and wastewater treatment and management
galvanic potential of the bimetal pair. Thus, corrosion and dissolution appear to dominate DNAN
degradation rates for all systems (ZVMg, bimetals) for lowered initial pH, while the galvanic potential
difference (highest for Mg/Cu) controls the unadjusted pH conditions. Further work is required to test
and validate this hypothesis.
Table 2: Reaction rate constants (k) with lowered initial pH
Treatment
System
k (min-1)
R2
kadj pH/
kunadj pH
Half-Life, min
ZVMg
0.641
0.934
72.8
1.1
Mg/Cu
0.497
0.831
4.2
1.4
Mg/Ni
0.525
0.765
29.2
1.3
Mg/Zn
0.776
0.930
7.6
0.9
3.3 Impact of temperature and activation energy
The impact of temperature on DNAN degradation kinetics was evaluated for the most effective
bimetal pair (Mg/Cu) under normal pH conditions, at temperature values of 200C, 260C, 320C, 360C
and 450C. The experimental conditions were the same as in previous tests, i.e. 0.5% S/L ratio and
10:1 base metal to catalyst ratio with unadjusted initial pH. As expected, as the temperature increased,
reaction rates also increased. The activation energy (Ea) of the reaction was determined by the
Arrhenius equation (Equation 2, Arrhenius S.A., 1889):
𝑘 = 𝐴 ∗ 𝑒𝑥𝑝 (−
Where:
𝐸𝑎
𝑅𝑇
)
(2)
Ea = Activation energy (kJ/mol)
k = Reaction rate constant (s-1)
A = Pre-exponential Factor (s-1)
T = Temperature (0K)
R = Universal gas constant (8.3110-3 kJ/mol∙K)
The slope of the fitted line is obtained by regression analysis of the linearized form of Equation 2:
𝐸
𝑙𝑛𝑘 = 𝑙𝑛𝐴 − 𝑅𝑇𝑎
(3)
The activation energy for DNAN degradation by Mg/Cu was determined to be 8.18 kJ/mol (Figure
4). For DNAN degradation by Fe/Cu bimetallic systems, the activation energies were reported as
121.8 kJ/mol and 30.57 kJ/mol in Koutsospyros et al. (2012) and Kitcher et al. (2017), respectively.
However, several differences must be noted between those and the present study including the type
of bimetal pair (Fe/Cu vs. Mg/Cu), preparation of the bimetal matrices (contacted primary and
catalytic metal surfaces vs. primary metal coated with the catalytic metal) as well initial pH of the
reaction (acidified at pH 3.0 vs. normal unadjusted pH).
1142
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
1/T
0.0031
-1.7
0.0032
0.0033
0.0034
0.0035
-1.8
lnK
-1.9
-2
-2.1
y = -983.31x + 1.2845
R² = 0.9197
-2.2
Figure 4: Natural logarithm of the degradation rate constant plotted as a function of inverse
temperature for DNAN removal using Mg/Cu (0.5% S/L, 10:1 Mg to catalyst ratio)
This indicates that the Mg/Cu technology is a potentially more viable option, since generally a lower
activation energy indicates less energy needed for a compound to undergo reactions. Furthermore,
determination of the activation energy allows extrapolation of kinetics constant at another
temperature in a similar range, again using Equation 2.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
The addition of a catalytic metal to zero-valent magnesium created an effective means for removal of
DNAN, while ZVMg, without any catalytic metal, was only effective in low pH media. At neutral
pH, Mg/Cu was the most effective and removed 98% of DNAN in 30 minutes, whereas the same
extent of removal by Mg/Zn was achieved at 120 min. The largest extent of removal for Mg/Ni was
95% at the end of the tested 150 min. ZVMg, without any catalytic metal, was not as effective and
resulted in only 33% DNAN removal after 150 min. These findings may help determining an
appropriate technology for the treatment of certain waste materials, e.g. in acidic mediums, only
ZVMg may be necessary, whereas in neutral pH media, use of bimetals may be necessary.
Furthermore, the kinetics of the DNAN degradation reaction followed a pseudo first order model.
Parametric studies of the reaction kinetics showed that the addition of Cu, Ni and Zn increased the
kinetic constant by 14, 2, and 12 times, respectively, compared to that of ZVMg alone. In addition,
the lowering of the initial pH of the reaction solution had a significant impact on DNAN degradation.
Under acidic initial pH conditions, all three bimetallic systems as well as ZVMg were very effective;
almost complete removal of DNAN was achieved using Mg/Zn and ZVMg within 10 min and
approximately 90% degradation was observed by Mg/Cu and Mg/Ni in only 15 min. Further work
may be done on investigating the roles of acidic pH and the galvanic potential simultaneously on the
bimetal configuration. The activation energy of DNAN degradation by the Mg/Cu bimetallic system
was calculated as 8.18 kJ/mol. Overall, the magnesium-based bimetallic treatment system was shown
to be a promising method for DNAN degradation in aqueous solutions.
References
1.
C.I. Olivares, L. Abrell, R. Khatiwada, J. Chorover, R. Sierra-alvarez, J.A. Field, ( Bio )
transformation of 2 , 4-dinitroanisole ( DNAN ) in soils, Journal of Hazardous Materials.
304 (2016) 214–221.
1143
Water and wastewater treatment and management
2.
J. Hawari, F. Monteil-Rivera, N.N. Perreault, A. Halasz, L. Paquet, Z. Radovic-Hrapovic, S.
Deschamps, S. Thiboutot, G. Ampleman, Environmental fate of 2,4-dinitroanisole (DNAN)
and its reduced products, Chemosphere. 119 (2015) 16–23.
3.
S. Taylor, M.E. Walsh, J.B. Becher, D.B. Ringelberg, P.Z. Mannes, G.W. Gribble, Photodegradation of 2,4-dinitroanisole (DNAN): An emerging munitions compound,
Chemosphere. 167 (2017) 193–203.
4.
J.D. Arthur, N.W. Mark, S. Taylor, J. Šimunek, M.L. Brusseau, K.M. Dontsova, Batch soil
adsorption and column transport studies of 2,4-dinitroanisole (DNAN) in soils, Journal of
Contaminant Hydrology. 199 (2017) 14–23.
5.
J. Liu, C. Ou, W. Han, Faheem, J. Shen, H. Bi, S. Xiuyun, J. Li, L. Wang, Selective removal
of nitroaromatic compounds from wastewater in an integrated zero valent iron (ZVI) reduction
and ZVI/H2O2 oxidation process, RSC Advances. 5 (2015) 57444–57452.
6.
S.C. Ahn, D.K. Cha, B.J. Kim, S.Y. Oh, Detoxification of PAX-21 ammunitions wastewater
by zero-valent iron for microbial reduction of perchlorate, Journal of Hazardous Materials.
192 (2011) 909–914.
7.
J. Shen, C. Ou, Z. Zhou, J. Chen, K. Fang, X. Sun, J. Li, L. Zhou, L. Wang, Pretreatment of 2
, 4-dinitroanisole ( DNAN ) producing wastewater using a combined zero-valent iron ( ZVI )
reduction and Fenton oxidation process, Journal of Hazardous Materials. 260 (2013) 993–
1000..
8.
A. Koutsospyros, J. Pavlov, J. Fawcett, D. Strickland, B. Smolinski, W. Braida, Degradation
of high energetic and insensitive munitions compounds by Fe/Cu bimetal reduction, Journal
of Hazardous Materials. 219–220 (2012) 75–81.
9.
E. Kitcher, W. Braida, A. Koutsospyros, J. Pavlov, T.-L. Su, Characteristics and products of
the reductive degradation of 3-nitro-1,2,4-triazol-5-one (NTO) and 2,4-dinitroanisole (DNAN)
in a Fe-Cu bimetal system, Environmental Science and Pollution Research. 24 (2017) 2744–
2753.
10.
A. Ghauch, A. Tuqan, Reductive destruction and decontamination of aqueous solutions of
chlorinated antimicrobial agent using bimetallic systems, Journal of Hazardous Materials.
164 (2009) 665–674.
11.
R. DeVor, K. Carvalho-Knighton, B. Aitken, P. Maloney, E. Holland, L. Talalaj, R. Fidler, S.
Elsheimer, C.A. Clausen, C.L. Geiger, Dechlorination comparison of mono-substituted PCBs
with Mg/Pd in different solvent systems, Chemosphere. 73 (2008) 896–900.
12.
B. Ramavandi, S.B. Mortazavi, G. Moussavi, A. Khoshgard, M. Jahangiri, Experimental
investigation of the chemical reduction of nitrate ion in aqueous solution by Mg/Cu bimetallic
particles, Reaction Kinetics, Mechanisms and Catalysis. 102 (2011) 313–329.
13.
J. Morales, R. Hutcheson, C. Noradoun, I.F. Cheng, Hydrogenation of Phenol by the Pd/Mg
and Pd/Fe Bimetallic Systems under Mild Reaction Conditions, Industrial & Engineering
Chemistry Research. 41 (2002) 3071–3074.
14.
A.M.E. Khalil, O. Eljamal, S. Jribi, N. Matsunaga, Promoting nitrate reduction kinetics by
nanoscale zero valent iron in water via copper salt addition, Chemical Engineering Journal.
287 (2016) 367–380.
15.
M. Rivero-Huguet, W.D. Marshall, Reduction of hexavalent chromium mediated by microand nano-sized mixed metallic particles, Journal of Hazardous Materials. 169 (2009) 1081–
1087.
16.
H. Tian, J. Li, Z. Mu, L. Li, Z. Hao, Effect of pH on DDT degradation in aqueous solution
using bimetallic Ni/Fe nanoparticles, Separation and Purification Technology. 66 (2009)
1144
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
84–89.
17.
U.D. Patel, S. Suresh, Effects of solvent, pH, salts and resin fatty acids on the dechlorination
of pentachlorophenol using magnesium-silver and magnesium-palladium bimetallic systems,
Journal of Hazardous Materials. 156 (2008) 308–316..
18.
X. Guan, Y. Sun, H. Qin, J. Li, I.M.C. Lo, D. He, H. Dong, The limitations of applying zerovalent iron technology in contaminants sequestration and the corresponding countermeasures:
The development in zero-valent iron technology in the last two decades (1994-2014), Water
Research. 75 (2015) 224–248.
1145
Water and wastewater treatment and management
POTABLE WATER DISINFECTION WITH SILVER IONS
DURING SPACE MISSIONS: THE ROLE OF WATER TANK AND
WATER SUPPLY MATERIALS
V. Tsiridis1, M. Petala1*, I. Mintsouli2,N. Pliatsikas3, S. Sotiropoulos2, M. Kostoglou4,
E. Darakas1, T. Karapantsios4
1
Laboratory of Environmental Engineering & Planning, Dept. of Civil Engineering,
2
Laboratory of Physical Chemistry, Dept. of Chemistry,
3
Division of Solid State Physics, Dept. of Physics,
4
Laboratory of Chemical and Environmental Technology, Dept. of Chemistry, Aristotle University
of Thessaloniki, 54 124 Thessaloniki, Greece
*Corresponding Author: e-mail: petala@civil.auth.gr, tel: +302310 996208
Abstract
The availability of potable water, both in terms of quality and quantity is essential for the International
Space Station (ISS) crew. Potable water is produced on ground and is transported to the ISS. During
each launching campaign, water quality complies either to Russian or US standards. The disinfection
agent is silver for the Russian type of water and iodine for the US type of water. So far, fluctuations
of silver concentration in water have been confirmed and thus, health issues arise concerning the safe
storage of potable water supplies in future (long term) missions.
The aim of this study is a) to evaluate the behavior of the disinfectant agent, silver, with various
metallic and polymeric wetted materials used throughout the process of water preparation and storage,
and b) to examine the phenomena responsible for silver concentration fluctuations in water systems
for crew usage. Silver ions were added into Russian type water electrolytically, so as to reach either
a silver ions’ concentration equal to 10 or 0.5 mg Ag+/L. Afterwards, water was brought in contact
with various surfaces at surface (S) to volume (V) ratio equal to 5.0 cm-1 and temperature 30oC, and
was stored either for 7d (water with high Ag concentration) or 28 d (water containing low Ag
concentration). At the end of the storage period all surfaces were leached, in order to examine the
deposition of Ag onto the surfaces. Moreover, solid surfaces were further analyzed (using SEM and/or
XPS), in order to elucidate the underlined deposition phenomena.
Silver losses from water containing 10 mg Ag+/L varied from 7.4% up to 96.8%, while silver losses
from water containing 0.5 mg Ag+/L varied between 62.5% and 100%. Leaching of wetted materials
verified the deposition of silver onto their surface. The phenomena that were responsible for silver
deposition are discussed thoroughly, with respect to the type of wetted surface material.
Keywords: Silver deposition, Potable water, Disinfection, International Space Station
1.
INTRODUCTION
Orion Multi-Purpose Crew Vehicle (MPCV) has been designed by National Aeronautics and Space
Administration (NASA) for exploration missions beyond low-Earth orbit. Orion MPCV will carry
the Orion service module, which is provided by the European Space Agency (ESA) and is designed
for the storage of water, nitrogen and oxygen, among other duties [Jones, 2012]. Potable water is,
after oxygen, the second consumable needed by crew members to live aboard a spacecraft and by far,
the most critical with regards to mass. In the context of manned long term spaceflight missions, long
1146
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
shelf life for potable water is required. To this regard, prevention of water contamination within the
water systems is essential, in order to prevent potential crew health risks. Currently, control of potable
water contamination is ensured by the addition of adequate amounts of biocidal agents at production
sites [Rebeyre, 2012]. There are two water quality standards defined for water consumption by the
ISS crew: the US potable water and the Russian potable water. The major differences between the
two types of water are summarized as follows: the disinfection agent is silver for the Russian type of
water and iodine for the US type of water, the TOC maximum acceptable levels are significantly
higher according to the Russian water quality standards, Russian standards enable more minerals than
the US ones and the maximum allowable total chromium level is significantly higher in the Russian
type of water compared to the US type of water. So far, the European Space Agency (ESA) has
successfully delivered potable water using ionic silver as biocide [Rebeyre, 2012] aboard by the
Automated Transfer Vehicle (ATV). For future long term missions, ionic silver has been identified
as the biocide agent of potable water (Wallace et al., 2016). Ionic silver has been acknowledged as
an efficient disinfectant agent and can be safely consumed by humans, unless it is consumed at high
concentrations for a long period of time [Wadher and Fung, 2005]. Besides NASA’s plans to use
ionic silver in future long term missions, ionic silver is currently used as the disinfectant agent for
potable water aboard the Russian segment of the International Space Station (ISS). However, during
the launch campaigns a fluctuation of silver was observed by performing water quality analyses at
different steps of the water process during each campaign, implying possible water quality
degradation [Wallace et al., 2016; (Rebeyre, 2012b].
The main type of wetted surface of water storage tanks from the Ground Support Equipment (GSE)
used for water transportation and loading has been Stainless Steel (SS). Indeed, there are few relevant
studies found in literature, which show that silver depletion from bulk water might occur on SS
depending on various factors, such as the wetted surface area to water volume ratio (S/V), type of
wetted surface, etc [Callahan et al. 2007; Roberts et al. 2007; Petala et al. 2017; Petala et al. 2016].
However, other types of materials –part of the water systems– may come in contact with water and
contribute to the silver ions’ concentration variation. The understanding of the underlying phenomena
may contribute to optimize water systems used aboard. Besides, such systems are also used in
terrestrial applications, such as portable water purification (employed by military personnel,
survivalists, and others for water purification when they need to obtain drinking water from untreated
sources) [Shamsuddin et al. 2016] or drinking water disinfection for unprivileged societies [Parr and
Kim 2016].
This work is part of a project supported by ESA (European Space Agency) to examine the phenomena
responsible for biocide concentration fluctuations in water systems for space crew usage. The scope
of this work is to investigate the decrease of biocidal Ag+ concentration in water exposed to different
types of materials and assess the chemical state of deposited Ag on these materials. To this aim,
specific objectives of the work are: (i) to investigate the types of materials that may cause silver
depletion from water, (ii) to verify silver deposition on the surfaces and (iii) to examine the materials’
surfaces after exposure to water with high silver ions’ concentration.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Potable water for the Russian ISS crew originates from Regina Margherita ground water in Torino.
Raw ground water complies with the water quality requirements without any pre-treatment, whereas
the quality is rather stable over years, regarding both chemical and microbiological parameters
[Lobascio et al. 2004]. The treatment steps for the Russian water preparation are [Lobascio et al.
2004] : a) addition of sodium fluoride solution, prepared directly in the source water, to the raw water
in the reaction tank, b) mixing and further treatment using a silver ionization cell, in order to dissolve
silver ions, c) microfiltration for the removal of the readily produced insoluble silver chloride, d)
ionization treatment for the achievement of the target final concentration of silver in the water, which
is 10 mg/L for disinfection water and 0.5 mg/L for the flight potable water and e) final step of
1147
Water and wastewater treatment and management
microfiltration prior to the transfer to the Water Gas Liquid Unit (WGLU). Afterwards, the WGLU
is transferred to the launch site, where the potable water is loaded into the ATV water tanks. The
loading procedure includes an initial step of soaking with high silver concentration (10 mg/L) water
for 24 h, then draining and flushing with high silver concentration (10 mg/L) water, and finally
draining and filling with low silver concentration (0.5 mg/L) water [Grizzaffi et al. 2008]. In this
study, both types of water were examined, in order to better elucidate the underlying phenomena
related to silver ions concentration fluctuations.
2.1 Water preparation
Water was produced in the lab according to the Russian water standards containing either 0.5 mg
Ag/L or 10 mg Ag/L. The produced water complied with the quality determined during ATV missions
(Lobascio et al. 2004). Water was freshly prepared, before each experiment, in 1 L volumetric flasks.
The basis for either type of water was ultrapure water (Direct-Q 3 UV, Millipore). Adequate quantities
from stock solutions of various salts were introduced to ultrapure water, so as to comply with the
water quality standards. Next, silver ions were added using a silver ionization unit (CSG-1, UK)
equipped with silver electrodes of high silver purity (99.99%). Water was filtered through a 0.2 μm
filter (Pall Corporations, USA) after the addition of silver ions and silver concentration was measured
spectrophotometrically (LCK354, Hach Lange). The chemical characteristics of the produced water
are presented in Table 1. All hardware items (glassware, plastic ware, etc) were sterilized prior to use,
in order to avoid microbial contamination.
2.2 Types of tested surfaces
Flat strip coupons of solid materials (Length x Width x Depth: 76 x 12.7 x 1.6 mm) were obtained
from Metal Samples (Alabama, USA). The types of tested coupons included: Teflon FEP 500L
(polymeric), Teflon PTFE (polymeric), EPR Parker (rubber), SS 316L (stainless steel), SS 15-5 pH
(heat and air passivated stainless steel), SS 316L/ WW (stainless steel with welding), SS 316L/ P
(acid passivated stainless steel), SS 316L/ P&E (acid passivated and electropolished stainless steel)
and Ti Alloy 6Al4V (titanium alloy).
Table 1: Composition of high (10 mg Ag/L) and low (0.5 mg Ag/L) silver concentration water
Parameter
Concentration
Parameter
Concentration
High Ag
conc. water
Low Ag
conc. water
High Ag
conc. water
Silver (mg/L)
10
0.5
TOC (mg/L)
0.5
0.5
pH
8.14
8.10
TDS (mg/L)
235
235
Conductivity
(μS/cm)
338
310
Ammonium
(mg/L)
<0.05
<0.05
Calcium (mg/L)
41.8
42.7
Color (Pt-Co)
0.0
0.0
Magnesium
(mg/L)
12.5
12.8
Chromium (μg/L)
6.0
6.0
Turbidity (NTU)
0.23
0.10
Nickel (μg/L)
3.0
3.0
Nitrate (mg/L)
13.4
18
Barium (μg/L)
6.0
6.0
Chloride (mg/L)
<0.05
0.8
Zinc (μg/L)
3.0
3.0
Fluoride (mg/L)
1.0
1.0
Total
(CFU)
1148
coliforms 0
Low Ag
conc. water
0
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Prior to experiments (about 24h before) coupons were meticulously cleaned, according to
JRP5322.1G (NASA) and ASTM G1 protocols (JSC, 2008; ASTM, 1999). After cleaning, all
coupons were dried and stored under nitrogen atmosphere until the performance of the experiments.
Verification of their cleanliness was performed not only by visual inspection under UV light (Figure
1a), but also by measuring the dynamic surface tension of MilliQ water after contact with the cleaned
coupons for more than 3 hours. Dynamic surface tension is determined using the maximum bubble
pressure technique. In all cases, the surface tension of water was practically the same with that of
MilliQ water (about 71-72 mN/m), as shown in Figure 1b.
Figure 1: Verification of coupons’ cleanliness: a) inspection under UV light, b) results
obtained from dynamic surface tension measurements
2.3 Testing procedures
Exposure of various types of surfaces to water disinfected with silver ions took place inside
polypropylene containers (HJ-Bioanalytik, Germany), as described elsewhere [Petala et al. 2016].
Tests were implemented in triplicate, while in each series of tests, there was also a blank sample
(without exposed metal) in order to examine possible deposition of silver on the polypropylene (PP)
walls of the experimental container (multiwell plate). Testing conditions were based on a worst case
scenario that is high surface to volume ratio (S/V=5 cm-1), high temperature (30οC) and exposure
Figure 2: Testing methodology for the evaluation of silver deposition
time of 14 d and 28 d for the low silver concentration water, and 7 d for the high silver concentration
water. These conditions were chosen, in order to intensify the phenomena and verify the deposition
of silver on the surfaces. After the exposure periods, both liquid and solid samples were analyzed
1149
Water and wastewater treatment and management
regarding the concentration of silver (Figure 2) using the methodology described in detail elsewhere
[Petala et al. 2016]. Silver mass balance was calculated for each material, while the surfaces that were
prone to silver deposition were further analyzed using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS).
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Initial experiments included the exposure of all types of materials to water with high silver ions
concentration (10 mg/L) for 7 d at temperature 30oC and S/V ratio equal to 5.0 cm-1. The initial Ag
concentration in the bulk water was 10 mg/L, while the final Ag concentration in the bulk water after
contact with each solid material is presented in Table 1. Solid materials caused removal of silver from
the disinfection water bulk in the order: Teflon PTFE(7.4%)< Teflon FEP 500L (14.7)<SS 316L /
P&E (21%)< EPR Parker (63.2%)<SS 15-5 pH (78.4%) < 316L/ WW (84.2%) < SS316L/ P (94.7%)
< SS316L (96.8%) ~ Ti Alloy 6AL-4V(96.8%).
Afterwards, all solid materials were exposed to potable water (0.5 mg/L Ag) for 14d and for 28d at
temperature 30oC and S/V ratio equal to 5.0 cm-1. Solid materials after 14d of exposure to potable
water caused removal of silver from the bulk water in the order: Teflon FEP 500L (41.8%)<Teflon
PTFE (45.2%)< SS316L (97.9%)< EPR Parker (98.5%)< SS 15-5 pH (99%)< 316L/ WW(100%)~
SS316L/ P ~ SS 316L/ P&E ~Ti Alloy 6AL-4V. Solid materials after 28d of exposure to potable
water caused removal of silver from the bulk water in the order: Teflon PTFE (62.5%)< Teflon
FEP(65.3%)< SS316L(100%)~ EPR Parker~ SS 15-5 pH~ 316L/ WW~ SS316L/ P~ SS 316L/
P&E~ Ti Alloy 6AL-4V.
Leaching of coupons was performed after each batch of experiments in order to realize whether the
silver was deposited on the solid materials or the PP walls of the multiwell plate. Indeed, significant
amount of silver was recovered in the leachates and silver mass balance closed reasonably well
(>90%). Therefore, leaching of coupons showed that in all cases silver was deposited on the surface
of the solid materials [Petala et al. 2016]. The surfaces that were more prone to silver deposition were
identified after calculating the concentration of deposited silver per materials surface unit, for the case
of high silver concentration water. The results that are shown in Figure 3, demonstrate that the
metallic surfaces favor the deposition of silver.
Table 2: Silver concentration in bulk water after contact with the solid materials for 7d at
30oC and S/V ratio equal to 5.0 cm-1
Type of surface Silver concentration Silver concentration Silver concentration
after 7d (mg/L)
after 14d (mg/L)
after 28d (mg/L)
(Initial Ag conc. 10 mg/L)
(Initial Ag conc. 0.5 mg/L)
(Initial Ag conc. 0.5 mg/L)
Blank
Teflon FEP 500L
9.5
8.1
0.482
0.279
0.479
0.166
EPR Parker
SS 316L
SS 15-5 pH
Ti Alloy 6AL-4V
SS 316L/ WW
SS 316L/ P
SS 316L/ P&E
Teflon PTFE
3.5
0.3
2.05
0.3
1.5
0.5
7.5
8.8
0.007
0.010
0.004
0.000
0.001
0.001
0.001
0.263
0.006
0.004
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.180
1150
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3: Surface concentration of silver considering the silver mass in the leachates and the
wetted surface area of each material. The dashed line refers to the maximum silver
concentration if all silver from the bulk water (with initial silver concentration 10 mg/L) was
deposited on the wetted surface
The maximum concentration of silver was calculated equal to 2 μg/ cm2 on the SS and titanium alloy
surfaces. Remarkably, the treatment of SS surface by acid passivation and electro polishing resulted
in much less silver deposition, slightly above 0.5 μg Ag/cm2 of wetted surface. This value was
comparable to those obtained for Teflon materials that presented the lowest silver surface
concentration after their contact with the high silver concentration water. The presence of silver was
also verified by using XPS analysis. Figure 4 shows the atomic concentration of depth profiles
obtained by XPS spectroscopy data for SS 316L. The very high carbon atomic concentration obtained
in the case of not-sputtered sample indicates surface contamination. The carbon concentration was
dramatically reduced between 0 and 20 sec that is after 1 nm of Ar sputter – etching. Due to carbon
contamination, significant Fe, Cr and Ni concentrations (characteristics of a SS substrate) only appear
after sputtering/cleaning of the surface. At 20 sec the surface is almost clean from carbon
contamination, allowing the appearance of Fe, Cr and Ni peaks. The Ag concentration slightly
increases and then remains almost stable.
80
1
70
60
atomic conc. %
0.8
50
0.6
40
Ag
F
C
O
Fe
30
0.4
20
Cr
Ni
0.2
10
0
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
t / sectime, sec
Sputtering
Figure 4: Atomic concentration depth profiles obtained by XPS spectroscopy data for the SS
316L coupon
1151
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Moreover, XPS analysis data revealed that silver was in its metallic form on the SS surface, in line
with a galvanic deposition mechanism [Petala et al. 2016, Petala et al. 2017]. According to this, silver
is reduced on the surface of the samples while components of the underlying metal are oxidized. As
regards titanium, XPS spectroscopy confirmed the presence of Ag on its top surface layers, too
(Figure 5). This was observed in the wide XPS spectra (data not shown) before and after sputtering,
as in the case of SS316L. After sputtering, the carbon atomic concentration was diminished indicating
almost total removal of surface contamination. Therefore, the concentrations of the other constituents
of the tested coupon (Ti, Al and V) significantly increased.
However, the results of XPS analysis showed that, unlike stainless steel substrates, silver is present
in its oxidized forms Ag+ and Ag+++ on Ti Alloy 6Al-4V. Thus, it is either deposited in ionic form
(possibly bound on O-containing surface groups-see also below) or originally deposited as metallic
silver (via a galvanic deposition mechanism that involves silver ion reduction and substrate oxide
growth) and subsequently transformed to Ag2O and Ag2O3 oxides by oxygen spillover from oxygenrich Ti, Al and V [14]. The ionic form of silver on the coupon could be explained by an ion-exchange
mechanism, whereby positively charged Ag ions are bound by the negatively charged native oxide
surface of TiO2 at the pH>7 values of the experiment [Mintsouli et al. 2018].
Sputtering time, sec
Figure 5: Atomic concentration depth profiles obtained by XPS spectroscopy data for the Ti
alloy 6Al-4V coupon
4.
CONCLUSIONS
The results of this study demonstrated that silver contained in water interacts with the solid materials
of the ATV water system. Silver was almost fully depleted from water bulk after a 7-day exposure
period of metallic surfaces to potable water. On the other hand, exposure of surfaces to conditioning
water revealed that non-passivated metallic surfaces along with rubber surface led to significantly
higher silver removal from the water bulk compared to the rest of the materials. Best performance –
less silver removal- was observed for SS electropolished and Teflon materials. Analysis of leachates
from the exposed surfaces allowed to close the total silver mass balance reasonably well proving that
silver was deposited on the surfaces. Detailed XPS analysis indicated the chemical state of deposited
silver on the examined surfaces.
Spectroscopic analysis confirmed that the thickness of the deposited silver layer on SS surface was
thicker than 3 nm, as shown by the repeated sputter-etching process applied to different spots of the
SS coupons and the resulting near constancy of Ag composition as determined by XPS. The chemical
state of silver was identified by high resolution XPS analysis. Results verified that both metallic Ag
and Ag oxides exist on the surface layers of silver deposits. Silver oxides are found on the outer
surface of the deposits (in depth less than 1 nm), while interior to the deposits, Ag is in its metallic
1152
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
form. Therefore, silver is deposited in its metallic form on all SS surfaces, in line with a galvanic
deposition mechanism.
On the other hand, on the Ti6Al4V alloy surface, Ag is found only in its oxidized form (as AgO, a
mixture of Ag2O and Ag2O3). The above does not exclude the possibility of galvanic replacement
mechanism also for the Ti alloy. This would be the case, if the initially deposited metallic silver was
transformed to oxides by oxygen spillover from the O-rich moieties of the surface oxides of the Ti,
V and Al components of the Ti alloy, whereby surface oxygen species are replenished by water
dissociation. Alternatively, an ion-exchange mechanism might hold in the case of the Ti alloy,
whereby Ag ions are bound by the negatively charged native Ti surface oxides/hydroxides (acidic
dissociation of OH surface groups at pH values higher than the TiO2 isoelectric point of pH<7).
References
1. Callahan M.R., N.K. Adam, M.S. Roberts, J.L. Garland, J.C. Sager and K.D. Pickering (2007)
‘Assessment of Silver Based Disinfection Technology for CEV and Future US Spacecraft:
Microbial Efficacy’, SAE International Technical Paper Series, 01- 3258.
2. Grizzaffi, L., C. Lobascio, G. Bruno and A. Saverino (2008) ‘ATV Water Preparation Campaign’
Proc. of Int. Conf. International Conference on Environmental Systems, ICES 2008-01-2192.
3. Jones T.D. (2012) ‘The view from here: Moving beyond earth: NASA's steps through 2020’,
Aerospace America, Vol. 50(3), 16-19.
4. Lobascio, C., G. Bruno, L. Grizzaffi, L. Meucci, M. Fungi and D. Giacosa (2004) ‘Quality of
ATV Potable Water for ISS Crew Consumption’ Proc. of Int. Conf. International Conference
on Environmental Systems, ICES 2004-01-2491.
5. Mintsouli I., V. Tsiridis, M. Petala, N. Pliatsikas, P. Rebeyre, E. Darakas, M. Kostoglou, S.
Sotiropoulos and Th. Karapantsios (2018) ‘Behavior of Ti-6Al-4 V surfaces after exposure to
water disinfected with ionic silver’, Applied Surface Science, Vol. 427, pp 763-770.
6. Parr J.M.P. and Y. Kim (2016) ‘Electrochemical silver dissolution and recovery as a potential
method to disinfect drinking water for underprivileged societies’, Environmental Science and
Water Research Technology, 2, pp 304-311.
7. Petala M., V. Tsiridis, E. Darakas, I. Mintsouli, S. Sotiropoulos, M. Kostoglou, Th. Karapantsios
and P. Rebeyre (2016) ‘Silver deposition on wetted materials used in the potable water systems
of the International Space Station’, Proc. of Int. Conf. 46th International Conference on
Environmental Systems, 10-14 July, Vienna, Austria, ICES-2016-445, pp 1-12.
8. Petala M., V. Tsiridis, I. Mintsouli, N. Pliatsikas, T. Spanos, P. Rebeyre, E. Darakas, P. Patsalas,
G. Vourlias, M. Kostoglou, S. Sotiropoulos and T. Karapantsios (2017) ‘Silver deposition on
stainless steel container surfaces in contact with disinfectant silver aqueous solutions’, Applied
Surface Science, 396, pp 1067-1075.
9. Rebeyre P. (2012) ‘ATV Water Quality: ATV1 and ATV3 Water Quality Overview’, TECMMG/2012/324.
10. Rebeyre P. (2012b) ‘ATV Water Process Overview – ATV Water Delivery System, Water
Production and transportation to Launch Site, Water Quality Control’ TEC-MMG/2010/29.
11. Roberts M.S., M.E. Hummerick, S.L. Edney, P.A. Bisbee, M.R. Callahan, S. Loucks, K.D.
Pickering and J.C. Sager (2007) ‘Assessment of Silver Based Disinfection Technology for CEV
and Future US Spacecraft: Microbial Efficacy’, SAE International Technical Paper Series, 013142.
12. Shamsuddin N., D.B. Das and V.M. Starov (2016) ‘Membrane-Based Point-Of-Use Water
Treatment (PoUWT) System in Emergency Situations’, Separation and Purification Reviews,
45(1), pp 50-67.
1153
Water and wastewater treatment and management
13. Wadhera A. and M. Fung (2005) ‘Systemic argyria associated with ingestion of colloidal silver’,
Dermatology Online Journal, Vol. 11 (1), pp 12.
14. Wallace W.T., S.L. Castro-Wallace, C.K. Mike Kuo, L.J. Loh, E. Hudson, D.B. Gazda, J.F. Lewis
(2016) ‘Effects of Material Choice on Biocide Loss in Orion Water Storage Tanks’, Proc. of Int.
Conf. 46th International Conference on Environmental Systems, 10-14 July, Vienna, Austria,
pp 1-10.
1154
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
DETERMINATION OF AMMONIUM IN RECYCLED AND
POTABLE WATER SAMPLES FOR SPACE APPLICATIONS
G. Giakisikli, V. Trikas, Th. Karapantsios*, G. Zachariadis, A. Anthemidis
Department of Chemistry, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, GR - 54124 Thessaloniki,
Macedonia, Greece
*Corresponding Author: e-mail: karapant@chem.auth.gr, tel: +302310997772
Abstract
In terms of crew survival, water is the second most consumable needed in manned space missions,
after the air, and by far, the most critical with respect to mass. There is a great need for water recycling
systems, which are being developed by the European Space Agency (ESA), the Russian Federal
Space Agency (ROSCOS-MOS) and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA),
to minimize the water supplied from the ground. So far, water recycling is limited to water recovery
from cabin condensate and urine. Ammonium ion is considered as one of the critical chemical
components in the waste water stream to recycle as it is the product of urea decomposition. For this
reason, there is a need for continuous monitoring of ammonium ion in different stages of recycling
process. There are numerous analytical methods, including automated or batch ones, available in the
literature for reliable NH4+ determination in recycled waters. However, in space, the analytical
procedure differs significantly from the one on earth. Sequential injection analysis (SIA) coupled
with a fluorimetric detector is a potential candidate for such purpose and has the advantage of not
only performing automated analysis, but also improving sensitivity with the possibility of further
miniaturization.
Keywords: Trade-off methodology, Sequential injection analysis, Ammonium determination;
Fluorimetry, Microgravity, International space station
1.
INTRODUCTION
The International Space Station (ISS) is a microgravity research laboratory in low Earth orbit, suited
for the testing of spacecraft systems and equipment required for long-lasting manned space missions.
Water is provided to the crew from appropriate water storage/transfer systems. It would be impractical
to stock the ISS with water for long periods of time, or continuously supplying it from the Earth, so
the development of water recycling systems is critical [H.W. Jones and M.H. Kliss (2010)]. The
recycling system developed by ESA is designed to produce hygiene and potable water either from
cabin condensate or grey water (waste hygiene water) or even urine, by physical/chemical processes
in order to remove contaminants, as well as different filtration steps and heat sterilization to ensure
the water quality. The produced water requires a high level of quality control, which until now, it
involves its transportation to Earth, resulting in questionable measurements due to the time lapse
between the sample collection and ground analysis. Thus, there is a need for in-flight analytical
measurements.
In the ISS, there are some requirements of ESA that should be fulfilled, in order an analyzer to
properly operate in space. The requirements concern the analytical performance characteristics of the
method (limit of detection/quantification, dynamic range, selectivity, precision, accuracy), and the
space adaptation characteristics (mass/volume of the analyzer, power consumption, voltage/current
intensity) due to limitations in space and energy availability [W. T. Wallace, D. B. Gazda, T. F.
1155
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Limero, J. M. Minton, A. V. Macatangay, P. Dwivedi and F. M. Fernandez (2015)]. Thus, an analyzer
must be microgravity compatible, operating in a fully automated mode for long periods. The low
consumption of sample/reagent solutions is important, considering the limited space in the ISS and
the weight. Special care should be taken to a totally closed system to avoid any leaking of fluids or
release of gases into the isolated station’s environment. Finally, the use of low toxicity reagents and
minimum flammable materials is important to ensure the safety of the crew and the station.
A factor that affects the quality of the water is the concentration of the ammonium ion/ammonia; thus,
its continuous on-line monitoring is crucial. In water, both toxic unionized ammonia (NH3) and the
relatively non-toxic ionized ammonium ion (NH4+) exist. Each form is converted to the other
depending on the pH, salinity and temperature. NH4+ is predominant when the pH is below 9.0, while
NH3 exists at higher values. Several automated analytical techniques have been developed for the
quantitative determination of the two species with various detectors (spectrophotometric,
fluorimetric, conductimetric), but there are only few that meet the requirements for proper operation
in space. The automated flow analyzers, based on the flow injection analysis (FIA) and sequential
injection analysis (SIA) techniques, work in a totally “closed loop” mode and offer automatic on-line
liquid manipulation using low volumes of sample/reagents solutions, resulting in minimum waste
production.
The aim of this work is to perform a trade-off analysis of the automated flow methods for NH4+
determination, reported in the literature, based on critical operational parameters under space
conditions and to select the top ranked one for evaluation. For this purpose, a SI analyzer with a
fluorimetric detector was employed and tested. A fully automated method has been developed to meet
the requirements for possible use in manned space missions. The derivatization reaction between
ammonia and o-phthaldialdehyde in the presence of sulfite in alkaline media (pH ca. 11) results in
the formation of a fluorescent product (isoindol-1-sulfonate), which is then quantified at 425 nm. The
chemical, flow and space factors affecting the operation of the system were optimized, to enhance
the effectiveness of the proposed method. The accuracy and precision of the method were estimated
by analyzing a standard reference material (SRM) as well as using the Certified Method (phenate).
The method was applied to hygiene and potable water samples.
2.
EXPERIMENTAL
2.1 Instrumentation
A miniSIA flow analyzer with an acrylic Chem-on-Valve™ monolithic manifold
(https://www.globalfia.com) was used throughout the experiments for the ammonium determination.
The device is equipped with a bi-directional milliGAT™ pump coupled to a thermostated holding
coil and a multi-position valve (MPV) modified in such a way in order to accept the Chem-on-Valve
(COV) manifold. This configuration facilitates the fluid manipulation in a microfluidic way inside
the closed system. Two fiber optic cables are used for the emission and excitation light as well as a
fluorescence flow cell which is directly mounted on the COV. A monochrome white LED is used as
an excitation light source (365 nm). A fluorimetric spectrometer (Ocean Optics USB-4000) is used
as a detection system. The monochromator has been set at 425 nm emission wavelength. The recorded
fluorescence intensity is given as arbitrary units (AU). The FloZF 5.2 software
(https://www.globalfia.com) is used for the device control and data acquisition. The tubing is made
from PEEK or PTFE. Polyethylene bottles were used as solution containers.
A Varian DMS 100S UV Visible Spectrophotometer with a 1.0 cm × 1.0 cm absorption cell was used
for ammonium determination by employing the reference method (indophenol blue). The analytical
wavelength was set at 640 nm. A Sartorius analytical balance has been employed for mass
measurements. An Orion EA940 pH-meter has been used for pH measurements.
1156
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
2.2 Reagents and samples
All chemicals were of analytical reagent grade and provided by Merck (Darmstadt, Germany,
http://www.merck.de). All ammonium standard solutions were prepared by appropriate stepwise
dilution of 1000 mg L−1 NH4+. A 10.0 mmol L-1 o-phthaldialdehyde (OPA, C8H6O2) solution was
prepared by dissolving 268.0 mg of solid in 50.0 mL methanol and filling the volumetric flask to
200.0 mL with double deionized water (DDW). Phosphate buffer was prepared by dissolving 26.81g
Na2HP04 in 900 mL of DDW, adjusting the pH to 11.0 with 2.0 mol L-1 NaOH and filling the
volumetric flask to 1000 mL (0.1 mol L-1). A 1000 mL solution of 3.0 mmol L-1 Na2SO3 was prepared
by dissolving 378.0 mg of solid Na2SO3 in phosphate buffer. The reagent solutions are light sensitive,
so they were kept in dark bottles in the fridge remaining stable for at least 5 weeks. A 20% m/v
alkaline citrate solution was prepared by dissolving 50.0g trisodium citrate and 2.5g ΝaΟΗ in 250
mL of DDW. A 5% m/v sodium hypochlorite solution was prepared by dissolving 5.0g sodium
hypochlorite (NaClO) in 100.0 mL of DDW. A 0.5% m/v sodium nitroprusside solution was prepared
by dissolving 1.25g sodium nitroprusside (Na2Fe(CN)5NO) in 250.0 mL of DDW. A 1% m/v sodium
hypochlorite solution in 16% m/v citrates was prepared by mixing 80.0 mL of 20% m/v alkaline
citrate solution and 20.0 mL of 5% m/v sodium hypochlorite solution. A 11.1% v/v phenol (C 6H6O)
solution in ethanol was prepared.
An ammonium standard reference solution from NIST (National Institute of Standards and
Technology, Gaithersburg, MD, USA) NH₄Cl in H₂O 1000 mg L-1 NH₄+ CertiPUR® was analyzed to
investigate accuracy. Three different potable artificial water samples (PAW) at 0.0, 0.4 and 0.8 mg
L-1 concentration level of NH4+ and three different hygiene artificial water samples (HAW) at 0.0,
1.0 and 5.0 mg L-1 concentration level of NH4+ were prepared. The chemical composition of each
artificial water sample is given in Table 1. Laboratory glassware was treated with freshly prepared
10% (v/v) nitric acid solution for at least 24 hours and finally rinsed with ultra-pure deionized water
before use to avoid contamination factors as much as possible.
Table 1: Chemical composition of artificial potable (PAW) and hygiene (HAW) water
samples. Concentrations are given in mg L-1. All solutions are slightly acidic (6.0-6.5)
Parameter
PAW1 PAW2 PAW3 HAW1 HAW2 HAW3
Ammonium
0.4
0.8
1.0
5.0
Chloride
100
100
200
125
125
250
P-PO4
2.5
2.5
5.0
25
25
50
Nitrate
12.5
12.5
25
25
25
50
Sodium
75
75
150
140
140
280
Potassium
1.5
1.5
3.0
3.0
3.0
6.0
Magnesium
25
25
50
25
25
50
Calcium
50
50
100
50
50
100
Fluoride
0.5
0.5
1.0
5.0
5.0
10
Iron
0.15
0.15
0.30
1.5
1.5
3.0
Copper
0.5
0.5
1.0
1.5
1.5
3.0
Zinc
2.5
2.5
5.0
2.5
2.5
5.0
Cadmium
0.0025 0.0025 0.005
0.025
0.025
0.050
Nickel
0.025 0.025
0.050
0.250
0.250
0.500
Lead
0.025 0.025
0.050
0.250
0.250
0.500
Chromium
0.025 0.025
0.050
0.250
0.250
0.500
Manganese
0.025 0.025
0.050
0.250
0.250
0.500
Arsenic
0.005 0.0050 0.010
0.050
0.050
0.100
Mercury
0.001 0.001
0.002
0.010
0.010
0.020
1157
Water and wastewater treatment and management
2.3 Analytical procedure
The manifold of the flow system is schematically presented in Figure 1. The analysis of ammonium
using the miniSIA is based on the OPA method. Three operational sequences have been used during
the experiments. At the beginning, the analyzer runs the “startup” sequence in order to prepare the
device (filling of the tubes, heating of the holding coil) for the analysis. Then, the “analytical cycle”
sequence begins, during which appropriate portions of sample/standard solution (40.0 μL), OPA (40.0
μL) and sodium sulfite (20.0 μL) solutions are sequentially aspirated with a flow rate of 10.0 μL s-1,
into the thermostated holding coil in a sandwich type format by means of the milliGAT pump in order
to produce a fluorescent product (isoindol-1-sulfonate) which can be directly quantified. The
chemical reaction between ammonia and o-phthaldialdehyde in the presence of sulfite takes place in
alkaline media (pH ca. 11). The fluorescent product, is time and temperature affected, thus, after a 2min stop in the thermostated holding coil at 70 oC, it is delivered into the flow-cell where it is
quantified at 425 nm (excitation wavelength, 365 nm). Finally, the analyzer runs the “shutdown”
sequence in order to clean the entire system (rinsing of the tubing, holding coil and flow-cell).
Figure 1: Schematic diagram of the miniSIA Flow Analyzer. MP, milliGATTM pump; D,
detector; THC, thermostated holding coil; FC, flow cell; COV, Chem-on-Valve; f.o., fiber
optics; LED, led excitation light source; Line 1, DDW; Line 2, Std sol./sample; Line 3, OPA
sol.; Line 4, sulfate sol
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Trade-off methodology
There are many published automated flow methods for ammonium/ammonia determination in the
literature. The flow systems, which are commonly used for ammonium determination, are categorized
as follows: segmented flow analysis (SFA), flow injection analysis (FIA) [N. Amornthammarong and
J.-Z. Zhang (2008), Y. Zhu, D. Yuan, Y. Huang, J. Ma, S. Feng and K. Lin (2014)], sequential injection
analysis (SIA) [R. A. Segundo, R. B. R. Mesquita, M. T. S. O. B. Ferreira, C. F. C. P. Teixeira, A. A.
Bordalo and A. O. S. S. Rangel (2011)], multisyringe flow injection analysis (MSFIA) [C. Henrıquez,
B. Horstkotte and V. Cerdà (2013)], multiCommutated flow injection analysis (MCFIA) [S. M.
Oliveira, T. I. M. S. Lopes, I. V. Toth and A. O. S. S. Rangel (2009)] and multipumping flow injection
analysis (MPFIA) [C. Henríquez, B. Horstkotte and V. Cerdà (2014)] with or without a gas diffusion
(GD) unit. Among them, only few meet the requirements for proper operation in space conditions.
In accordance with the ESA standard procedures, trade-off studies shall evaluate the candidate
concepts for a mission candidate technique. Therefore, to evaluate and select the most appropriate of
them, a trade-off methodology has been developed taking into account the detection / quantification
requirements (LOD, LOQ, accuracy, repeatability, etc.) and critical items regarding the adaptation to
space (microgravity applicability, volume/mass of the analyzer, solutions consumption, wastes
production) as well as safety criteria (use of hazardous materials/reagents, pressure, heating,
flameability). Every criterion was scored, based on defined scale/levels of each one with a specific
1158
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
weighting factor (WF). Each particular weighting factor has been attributed to every criterion taking
into consideration the significance of the specific parameter. For instance, parameters that could affect
the crews’ wellbeing, such as maintenance and safety issues, were evaluated as of higher importance
(x10 WF) compared with others that are subject to design adaptation and could be optimized, like
volume of the analyzer (x5 WF) and power consumption (x4 WF). In addition, since the concept of
the WF refers mainly to the criteria, in order to distinguish between the examined methods, a scale
was required to be established for each criterion in order to provide a reliable assigned value for each
one. The scale of the criteria is based on numeric features. The score of each criterion for every
method was given as the result of a value (into the range of scale) x weighting factor.
The requirements for the developed method are the following: working range, 0.1 mg L-1 - 50 mg L1
NH4+, limit of detection, 0.05 mg L-1 NH4+; limit of quantification, 0.1 mg L-1 NH4+, precision, at a
value of standard deviation of ± 0.05 mg L-1; accuracy, at an error level of 0.05 mg L-1. The space
adaptation criteria are the following: volume of the on-line ammonium analyzer, lower than
516×440×253 mm3 (based on the ISS Locker); mass of the on-line ammonium analyzer, lower than
27 Kg; minimal consumed sample volume and waste generation during analysis; safe disposal; power
consumption, lower than 300W; current intensity, 116-126V DC. Finally, special attention should be
focus on the safety. The Table 2 presents the examined parameters together with the score of each
one as well as the total score of each analytical flow method.
The SIA fluorimetric methods [N. Amornthammarong and J.-Z. Zhang (2008), C. Frank, F. Schroeder,
R. Ebinghaus, W. Ruck, (2006)] were top ranked compared to the others, according to the trade-off
methodology. Among the commercially available SIA systems coupled with a fluorimetric detector,
the miniSIA analyzer seemed to be more promising and selected for further evaluation. The miniSIA
analyzer is an automated and miniaturized integrated system with a low volume and mass (size: 200
mm × 300 mm × 250 mm; weight: 7.5 Kg, power: 110-250VAC, 2.5A). It is an easy-to-use system
which allows for an automatic handling of the solutions without any human intervention, avoiding
any potential errors, regarding overpressure or overheating of the system. In addition, it uses low
volumes of sample/reagents solutions resulting in low production of wastes, considering not only the
restricted space inside the ISS, but also the weight. Finally, the operation of the whole procedure in a
totally “closed loop” makes it microgravity applicable and prevents problems like leakage or gas
elimination, which could create harmful environment inside the limited and isolated space station.
Table 2: Trade off methodology of the examined flow methods
Trade off criteria
Scale
Weighting
factor
10
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
Limit
of
0-5
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
Detection
Limit
of
0-5
9
45
45
45
45
45
45
45
Quantitation
Analytical
Working range
0-5
3
12
15
12
12
12
6
9
Performance
Selectivity
/
0-2
5
0
0
10
10
10
0
0
interferences
Precision
0-10
4
36
28
40
40
20
28
32
Accuracy
0-5
6
18
18
30
30
24
18
30
Volume
of
0-5
5
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
analyzer
Mass of the
0-5
5
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
analyzer
Adaption
Sample volume
0-5
5
25
25
25
25
25
20
25
Characteristics
Wastes Volume
0-5
5
20
25
25
25
25
20
25
Power
0-3
4
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
consumption
Maintenance
0-5
10
0
0
30
30
30
0
0
Hazardous
0-5
10
40
40
30
30
20
40
30
Reagents
/
Safety Criteria
Wastes
Heating
0-2
10
20
20
0
0
0
20
20
Total score
328
328
359
359
303
314
328
*A, MPFIA-GD-Conductimetric [8]; B, MSFIA-GD-Conductimetric [6], C, FIA-OPA-SULFITE-Fluorimetric [3]; D, SIA-OPA-SULFITEFluorimetric [9]; E, FIA-INDOPHENOL-UV-Vis [4]; F, SIA-GD-INDICATOR-UV-Vis [5]; G, MCFIA-GD-INDICATOR-UV-Vis [7].
1159
Water and wastewater treatment and management
3.2 Chemical and flow parameters optimization
All chemical and flow parameters of the proposed system considering the requirements for space
adaptation and safety criteria were thoroughly studied.
Effect of temperature: The chemical reaction which takes place in the OPA method is depended on
the temperature of the mixture inside the holding coil, affecting the formation of the fluorescent
product. The effect of temperature was studied from 30 to 80 oC. The experimental results showed
that the increase of the temperature was effective in accelerating the desired reaction in the studied
region, as it increased the fluorescence intensity (Figure 2). However, 70 oC were selected in order to
avoid any possible bubbles formation inside the closed system.
Effect sample aspiration order: In SIA methods, the aspiration order of the solutions into the holding
coil is a key factor to the formation of the fluorescent product. Six reagents/standard aspiration order
combinations have been studied. The results showed that the highest sensitivity was achieved by
consecutive aspiration of 20 μL of 15.0 mmol L-1 OPA solution, 20.0 μL of 2.0 mg L-1 NH4+ standard
and 20.0 μL of 3.0 mmol L-1 sodium sulfite solution, as given in Figure 3. Thus, the aspiration order
of OPA-Standard/Sample-Sulfite was adopted.
Effect of concentration and volume of OPA solution: The concentration of OPA solution and its
aspirated volume inside the holding coil are of high significance to its complexation with ammonia,
affecting the efficient formation of the fluorescent product. The effect of OPA concentration was
studied at concentrations between 0.5 and 50.0 mmol L-1, while the effect of the volume was studied
at the range of 20.0 - 50 μL. The concentrations of NH4+ standard and sulfite solutions were 2.0 mg
L-1 and 3.0 mmol L-1, respectively. The fluorescent intensity increased as the concentration of the
reagent increased up to 3.0 mmol L-1 and, then, remained practically stable. Regarding the aspirated
volume of OPA solution, the results showed an increase in the intensity by increasing the volume up
to 40.0 μL, while at higher values a slight decrease was observed. Hence, a volume of 40.0 μL of
OPA solution at a concentration level of 3.0 mmol L-1 was chosen as optimum.
Effect of sample volume: In on-line flow systems, sample volume plays a significant role affecting
the sensitivity of the method. In order to evaluate the influence of the sample volume on the intensity,
a standard solution of NH4+ at a 2.0 mg L-1 concentration level was used, varying the aspirated volume
within the range 5.0 - 60.0 μL. The experimental results showed a positive correlation of the analytical
signal with the sample volume up to 40.0 μL, leveling off at 50.0 μL, while at higher volumes, a slight
decrease of the signal was observed (Figure 4). Therefore, a sample volume of 40.0 μL of was adopted
for further studies.
Figure 2: Effect of temperature on the fluorescence intensity of 2.0 mg L-1 NH4+. Heating
time: 90 s. Error bars were calculated based on standard deviation values (±1s)
1160
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 3: Effect of reagents/standard (or sample) aspiration order on the fluorescence
intensity of 2.0 mg L-1 NH4+
Effect of concentration and volume of sodium sulfite solution: The presence of sodium sulfite as a
reducing agent enhances the sensitivity and the specificity of the reaction between OPA and
ammonium ion, by eliminating possible interferences of dissolved amino acids and primary amines
[Z. Genfa and P. K. Dasgupta (1989)]. Experiments using different concentrations of sodium sulfite
solution showed that at 3.0 mmol L-1 concentration level the fluorescent reaction was maximum and,
thus, it was employed for the study of the effect of its volume on the fluorescence intensity. The
aspirated volume of sulfite solution was studied in the range between 5.0 and 25.0 μL. An increase
of the analytical signal was observed by increasing the sulfite volume up to 20.0 μL, while then it
was leveled off. Consequently, a volume of 20.0 μL was used as optimum.
Figure 4: Effect of sample volume on the fluorescence intensity of 2.0 mg L-1 NH4+. Error bars
were calculated based on standard deviation values (±1s)
Interferences: The water system in ISS recycles cabin condensate, hygiene waters and urine. Thus,
primary amines are a potential interference, which has been studied at concentrations up to 0.40 mg
L-1 CH3NH2 for interfering in 0.50 mg L-1 NH4+ determination using the optimized method. Higher
concentrations of methylamine are not expected, according to the Reference Documents of ESA for
the quality of the recycled water in ISS. Another compound that could act as interference is the silver
ion which is used as a disinfectant in the ISS water system [M. P. Arena, M. D. Porter and J. S. Fritz
(2003)]. Experimental results revealed that CH3NH2 and Ag(I) can be tolerated at least up to 0.40 and
1.0 mg L-1 (Table 3).
1161
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Table 3: Potential interferences in 0.50 mg L-1 NH4+ determination with the miniSIA method
3.3 Chemical and flow parameters optimization
The analytical performance characteristics of the miniSIA method for NH4+ determination under the
optimal conditions were calculated and presented below. With a total analysis time of 174 s, the
proposed method was linear from 0.06 mg L-1 up to 4.00 mg L-1 NH4+, while the sensitivity, S (slope
of calibration curve) was S = 13218 L mg-1. The detection limit, based on 3s criterion, was found to
be 0.018 mg L-1, while the quantification limit, based on 10s criterion, was found to be 0.06 mg L-1,
according to IUPAC [International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC)]. The “intra-day
precision” was calculated to be 2.30 % (at 0.50 mg L-1, 5-subsequent times), while the “inter-day
precision” was calculated to be 2.40 % (at 0.50 mg L-1, 5-times 5-subsequent days).
In order to validate the accuracy of the proposed method, an NTRM reference material was analyzed
using the miniSIA Flow Analyzer under the proposed method. The reference material was an
ammonium standard solution traceable to SRM from NIST NH₄Cl in H₂O 1000 mg L-1 NH₄+
CertiPUR®. The relative error was calculated to be 2.52%. The accuracy of the method was also
tested using the certified method (indophenol blue) for ammonium determination [Standard Methods
for the Examination of Water and Wastewater]. For this purpose, three potable artificial water
samples (PAW) as well as three hygiene artificial water samples (HAW) at different concentrations
of ammonium were prepared and analyzed with both the miniSIA method and the certified method.
The results are presented in Table 4. The overall relative errors were 3.39% and 2.33% for PAW and
HAW samples respectively.
Table 4: Accuracy of the miniSIA method comparing with the Certified Method
Certified Method
miniSIA method
Sample
True value
Actual value
Actual value
Relative
(mg L-1)
(mg L-1)
(mg L-1)
Error (%)
PAW1
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
PAW2
0.40
0.33
0.32
3.03
PAW3
0.80
0.7
0.75
7.14
Overall relative error
3.39
HAW1
0.00
0.0
0.0
0.00
HAW2
1.00
1.05
1.08
2.86
HAW3
5.00*
5.72
5.38
5.94
Overall relative error
2.93
*, after 1:1 dilution
The volume of the consumed solutions and produced wastes during the analytical cycle is also an
issue to be considered in case of an analyzer for possible operation in a space shuttle. These volumes
were calculated during an analytical cycle using the miniSIA ammonium analyzer and are presented
in Table 5. The very small amounts of sample and reagents solutions as well as the wastes have been
considered as acceptable to be used in space missions, allowing the miniSIA analyzer’ s operation in
a green-friendly manner.
1162
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Table 5: Volume of consumed solutions and produced wastes during the analytical cycle
Solutions
Volumes of consumed
Volumes of produced
solutions (μL)
wastes (μL)
Sample/std solution
40.0
40.0
OPA solution
40.0
40.0
Sodium sulfite solution
20.0
20.0
Carrier solution
390.0
390.0
Total volume
490.0
490.0
The developed method was applied to the determination of ammonium in real water effluents
produced by the Water Treatment Unit Breadboard (WTUB) located in the Antarctic Concordia
research station. Concordia is a selected place from ESA to test the water recycling system, similar
to that in ISS, as it is a realistic simulation for some aspects of human spaceflight. Three different
types of water samples were provided by ESA: 1 (urine and shower water), 2 (shower water) and 3
(grey water). These water samples have similar chemical composition as the ones of the recycled
water on board the ISS. The water samples were analyzed with the miniSIA and the certified method
and the results were compared (Table 6).
Table 6: Results of the analysis of WTUB water samples by CM and miniSIA
Sample
CM (mg L-1) miniSIA (mg L-1)
Standard error (%)
1 (urine+shower)
3.55
3.28
-7.6
2 (shower)
0.34
0.32
-5.9
3 (grey water)
18.66
19.02
+1.9
The results of ammonium determination in WTUB water samples ranged between 0.30 up to 19.00
mg L-1. Regarding the comparison of miniSIA with the CM method, good agreement was observed,
and the percentage error ranged from -7.6% up to +1.9%, which complies with the space flight
requirement for accuracy.
4.
CONCLUSIONS
A trade off methodology has been developed for the evaluation of the published flow methods for
ammonium/ammonia determination in terms of the ISS requirements for proper operation in space
conditions. The miniSIA analyzer coupled with a fluorimetric detector was selected among other flow
systems and evaluated with a view to a possible use for water quality monitoring in recycled potable
and hygiene water samples in a microgravity environment. The analyzer is adaptable to space flight
requirements considering that its volume and mass are suitable for the limited room-space inside the
ISS. In addition, it allows for automatic handling of the solutions as well as the use of minimum
sample and reagents volumes, resulting in low waste generation per analytical cycle. It is an integrated
system which performs the analysis principle and measurements in a closed flow system without any
crew involvement avoiding any possibility for fluid or gas discharges Thus, it conforms to the safety
requirements not only for the crew, but also for the ISS environment.
References
1. H.W. Jones and M.H. Kliss (2010) ‘Exploration life support technology challenges for the crew
exploration vehicle and future human missions’, Adv. Space Res. Vol 45, pp. 917–928.
2. W. T. Wallace, D. B. Gazda, T. F. Limero, J. M. Minton, A. V. Macatangay, P. Dwivedi and F.
M. Fernandez (2015) ‘Electrothermal vaporization sample introduction for spaceflight water
quality monitoring via gas chromatography-differential mobility spectrometry’, Anal.Chem. Vol.
87, pp. 5981–5988.
1163
Water and wastewater treatment and management
3. N. Amornthammarong and J.-Z. Zhang (2008) ‘Shipboard fluorometric flow analyzer for highresolution underway measurement of ammonium in seawater’, Anal. Chem. Vol. 80, pp.10191026.
4. Y. Zhu, D. Yuan, Y. Huang, J. Ma, S. Feng and K. Lin (2014) ‘A modified method for on-line
determination of trace ammonium in seawater with a long-path liquid waveguide capillary cell
and spectrophotometric detection’, Marine Chemistry Vol. 162, pp. 114–121.
5. R. A. Segundo, R. B. R. Mesquita, M. T. S. O. B. Ferreira, C. F. C. P. Teixeira, A. A. Bordalo
and A. O. S. S. Rangel (2011) ‘Development of a sequential injection gas diffusion system for the
determination of ammonium in transitional and coastal waters’, Anal. Methods Vol. 3, pp. 20492055.
6. C. Henrıquez, B. Horstkotte and V. Cerdà (2013) ‘Conductometric determination of ammonium
by a multisyringe flow injection system applying gas diffusion’, Intern. J. Environ. Anal. Chem.
Vol. 93, pp. 1236-1252.
7. S. M. Oliveira, T. I. M. S. Lopes, I. V. Toth and A. O. S. S. Rangel (2009) ‘Determination of
ammonium in marine waters using a gas diffusion multicommuted flow injection system with inline prevention of metal hydroxides precipitation’, J. Environ. Monit. Vol. 11, pp. 228–234.
8. C. Henríquez, B. Horstkotte and V. Cerdà (2014) ‘A highly reproducible solenoid micropump
system for the analysis of total inorganic carbon and ammonium using gas-diffusion with
conductimetric detection’, Talanta Vol. 118, pp. 186–194.
9. C. Frank, F. Schroeder, R. Ebinghaus, W. Ruck, (2006) ‘A Fast Sequential Injection Analysis
System for the Simultaneous Determination of Ammonia and Phosphate’ Microchim Acta Vol.
154, pp. 31–38.
10. Z. Genfa and P. K. Dasgupta (1989) ‘Fluorometric Measurement of Aqueous Ammonium Ion in
a Flow Injection System’, Anal. Chem. Vol. 61, pp. 408-412.
11. M. P. Arena, M. D. Porter and J. S. Fritz (2003) ‘Rapid, low level determination of silver(I) in
drinking water by colorimetric–solid-phase extraction’, Anal. Chim. Acta Vol. 482, pp. 197–207.
12. International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC), Compendium of Analytical
Nomenclature, Definitive Rules 1997, 3 rd ed.Blackwell, Oxford, 1998.
13. Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater, © Copyright 1999 by American
Public Health Association, American Water Works Association, Water Environment Federation
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank ESA for its financial support through the project “On-Line
Ammonium Analyzer for water recycling systems, Contract No: 4000113078/14/NL/SFe”.
1164
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
GIS’ CONTRIBUTION IN BIOLOGICAL PROCESSING OF
WASTE WATERS IN SMALL SETTLEMENTS. CASE STUDY BY
USING AN ARTIFICIAL WETLAND SYSTEM.
S. Kariotis, E. Giannakopoulos and I.K. Kalavrouziotis*
School of Science and Technology, Hellenic Open University, Tsamadou 13-15 & Saint Andrea,
26222 Patras, Greece
*
Corresponding author e-mail: ikalabro@eap.gr, Tel +302610 367546, Fax: +302610 367528
Abstract
The construction of natural waste processing systems should take into account a wide range of
territorial and legal factors in order to reduce negative impacts on the environment. This article
describes the contribution of Geographical Information Systems (GIS) technology to generate spatial
data for site assessment in small settlements, for the construction of natural waste processing systems
by using artificial wetlands (AWL’s) method. The site suitability is assessed on a scale based on
territorial indexes that measure the risk of contamination of the following environmental components:
surface water, groundwater, atmosphere, soil and human health. The GIS technology described in this
article has been used to evaluate an area for the construction of an AWL in the settlement Orinis of
Municipality Serres in Greece, with fewer than 2000 people, where there isn't a waste processing
system. The results showed that the use of GIS technology is a base tool to analyse and make decisions
for the finding of areas for construction of natural waste processing systems that constitute the optimal
solution to protect the environment for small settlements according to the European Union waste
management program.
Keywords: artificial wetland system; geographical information systems (GIS); waste waters
1.
INTRODUCTION
Landfill siting is a complex process involving social, environmental and technical parameters as well
as government regulations. As such, it evidently requires the processing of a massive amount of
spatial data. Various landfill siting techniques have been developed for this purpose. Some of them
use Geographic Information Systems (GIS) to find suitable locations for such installations (Zamorano
et.al., 2008; Kontos, D, Th. et al., 2003; Siddiqui M., 1996). For example, in the past, Lin and Kado
(1998) developed a mixed-integer spatial optimization model based on vector-based data to help
decision makers find a suitable site within a certain geographic area (Lin and Kado, 1998), while
recently Heidi et.al. are described the contribution of Geographical Information Systems (GIS)
technology to generate spatial data for site assessment in small settlements, for the construction of
natural waste processing systems by using AWL’s method (Heidi et.al., 2016). According to Alemany
et al. these systems constitute the optimal solution to protect the environment of small settlements
(Alemany et.al., 2005) and the site suitability must is assessed on a scale based on territorial indexes
that measure the risk of contamination of the following environmental components: surface water,
groundwater, atmosphere, soil and human health (Dai et. Al., 2016). This article describes the
contribution of Geographical Information Systems (GIS) technology to generate spatial data for site
assessment in small settlements, with fewer than 2000 people, for the construction of natural waste
processing systems by using artificial wetlands method. The GIS technology described in this article
has been used to evaluate an area for the construction of an AWL in the settlement Orinis of
1165
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Municipality Serres in Greece, with fewer than 2000 people, where there isn't a waste processing
system.
2.
METHODOLOGY
2.1 Phase 1: Plotting artificial wetlands plants (AWL’s) with GIS Tool
The current map projection system in Greece is the Transverse Mercator Projection 6° (TM_87) and
Datum, GGRS_87 with GRS_80 ellipsoid (Kariotis and Panagiotopoulos, 2013). HMGS’ schematic
maps on a scale of 1:5,000 were used for the vectorization of the road and hydrographic network. The
1:5,000 scale allows for accuracy of about 1.25 m during the vectorization (resolution ¼ mm in
relation to the scale).HMGS’ schematic maps are in azimuthal projection (HATT) with Bessel as a
reference ellipsoid. Greece has been divided in large 1:100,000 mapsheets, each of which has its own
Cartesian coordinate system. The 1:5,000 HMGS maps refer to 1:100,000 mapsheets where the
mapsheet centre distance is per 30’ (large mapsheets). HATT was converted to TM_87 (GGRS_87).
Simultaneous, the Orthophotomaps of the National Cadastre and Mapping Agencywere used to locate
forest areas so that siting in said areas could be avoided. For this aim, ArcGIS program and EGSA
projection system_87 were used with 421,501 points in X, Y, Z format. The points were input in such
a way that a simple data file can be converted to usable information, exportable to shape file.
2.2 Phase 2: Parameterization of the model
The eligible sites must fall within the boundaries of the study area, which are also the administrative
boundaries of the settlement. An additional criterion is for the site to be in such a position that allows
for the transport of the waste through gravity alone (minimizing operational cost). Therefore, the
desirable altitude of the unit should be lower than that of the lowest part of the designated boundaries
of the settlement, according to the prefectural planning decisions which demarcate the settlement.
Spatial queries were submitted so that the information returned fulfil the requirements above. The
queries were submitted so that there is a circumferential safety margin in the rendering of the terrain
(i.e. there will be no gaps in the terrain).
3.
APPLICATION OF THE METHODOLOGY: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Point selection
According to criterions of point selection (see methodology), discern that there are 1,413 sites within
the settlement boundaries. Classified by altitude, it ensures that the site with the highest altitude is
Z=899.64m and the lowest is Z= 711.71m. Thus, a second query was submitted to the system, which
deals with the selection of sites with an altitude lower than 711.71m (select by Attributes) from the
total number of the areas introduced in the system. The sites were then limited to the south side of the
settlement. This area fulfills the requirements above.
3.1
Upon this result, the third spatial query was introduced to choose the areas that are included within
the study area that is the administrative boundaries of the settlement. Selection of areas within a 50m
radius of the administrative boundaries of the settlement is recommended (and applied in this study)
to ensure that the relief of the terrain corresponds to the boundaries of the area and there are no gaps.
The result is the highlighted blue area in Figure 1. With the procedure mentioned above, the initial
421,501 points have been limited to 25,854. The Attribute table shows that the altitude variation
ranges between 711.70 and 348.68 m.
1166
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: Result Select by Location
3.2 TIN (triangulated irregular network) creation
The Delaunay triangulation is fundamental in computational geometry and is used for terrain
modelling. TIN creation aims for the digital rendering of the terrain and contributes to spatial
selection as it calculates the slope of the terrain. Therefore, with a similar query, polygons with less
than 10% ground gradient can be chosen and the researcher can limit their research in alternative
positions that will emerge (Astaras et.al., 2011) (Figure 2). The application of the algorithm shows
that 51,676 triangles have been created covering the area, the slope of each has been calculated and
expressed as a percentage (%) and the orientation is also calculated. The result of Figure 2 includes
triangles whose size is bigger than 200 m2 (gray areas). Provided the primary points were distributed
in grid data per 20m in X and Y, the triangles created will have a maximum area of 200m2. Any larger
triangle is located circumferentially of the area in question and contains incorrect information. With
the fourth query, only triangles with an area ≤200m2 are requested. Out of 52,676 triangles, 50,609
were selected, which have an area of ≤200 m2, which means that the gray areas in Figure 2 were
removed. Figure 3 shows the area without such errors. The next selection criterion is the slope that
was defined at ≤10% to save up on earthworks. The next task is to integrate adjacent triangles so that
there is a single polygon from which the area will initially be assessed.
Figure 2 Colour gradation
of altitude result
Figure 3: ΤΙΝ debugging
After the integration, 551 polygons were created out of the original 1,023 triangles. Sorting the table
by AREA and descending order it is discernible that there are only 6 integrated locations with an area
> 3,000 m2. In this point, the research will focus on locations: far (1st alternative) and next to (2nd
alternative) from final recipient stream, Figure 4.
1167
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Figure 4: Six locations with an area > 3,000 m2
Through geodata.gov.gr, we can reject additional areas downstream by uploading the hydrographic
network and importing the shape file in the working environment. When georeferenced pictures of
MinAgric are imported, from which information about the ownership status is obtained, Figure 5
occurs.
1168
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 5: Hydrographic network and MinAgric schematic map (ownership)
1st alternative: A=4,800 m2, distance from settlement boundaries 2,200 m. The Figure 6 shows long
distance from settlement (2,200 m) without expropriation required, away from final recipient stream/
Figure 6: 1st alternative
1169
Water and wastewater treatment and management
2nd alternative: A=3,200 m2, distance from settlement boundaries 2,000 m. This alternative rejected,
because it is downstream from the final recipient (Figure 7).
Figure 7: 2nd alternative
If the area query is expanded to include areas under 3,000 m2, two more interesting alternatives come
up, which are not only adjacent to the final recipient but also connected to neighbouring areas,
therefore eligible for the location of the unit.
4.
CONCLUSION
Environmental management is, to a large degree, a spatial procedure. The data used for the placement
study require the clear definition of the criteria and characteristics these places should govern.
Therefore, combinational, multi-parameter and multi-level interpretation of map data is required to
reject or accept alternate site locations. The proposed criteria are financial and concern the
minimization of construction and operating cost of the unit. In the placement study, alternative sites
that fulfil the criteria are selected and eventually the most appropriate one is chosen. The slope of the
land, the distance from the settlement (which also affects the anthropogenic factor) and the possible
expropriation required for the construction play a major role in the construction cost. The use of GIS
deals with spatial and descriptive issues without substituting the researcher but minimizing the
alternate site research time and giving results that fulfil the required criteria. Therefore, an interaction
between the researcher and the software develops in which the researcher defines the criteria and the
software in essence carries out the repetitive process of testing to reach one or more optimal results.
The results showed that the use of GIS technology is a base tool to analyse and make decisions for
the finding of areas for construction of natural waste processing systems such as AWL's that constitute
the optimal solution to protect the environment for small settlements according to the European Union
waste management program
1170
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
References
1. Alemy J., Comas J., Turon C., Balaguer M.D., Poch M., Puig M.A., Bou J., (2005) ‘Evaluating
the application of a decision support system in identifying adequate wastewater treatment for
small communities. A case study: the Fluvia River Basin’, Water Science & Technology,
Vol.51, pp.179-186
2. Dai C., Guo H.H., Tan Q., Ren W., (2016) ‘Development of a constructed wetland network for
mitigating nonpoint source pollution through a GIS-based watershed-scale inexact optimization
approach’, Ecological Engineering, Vol.96, pp.94-108
3. Heidi van Deventer, Jeanne Nel, Namhla Mbona, Nancy Job, Justine Ewart-Smith, Kate Snaddon,
Ashton Maherry, (2015) ‘Desktop classification of inland wetlands for systematic conservation
planning in data-scarce countries: mapping wetland ecosystem types, disturbance indices and
threatened species associations at country-wide scale’, Aquatic Conservation, 57-75
4. Zamorano Montserrat, Molero Emilio, Hurtado Alvaro, Grindlay Alejandro, Ramos Angel,
(2008) ‘Evaluation of a municipal landfill site in Southern Spain with GIS-aided methodology’,
Journal of Hazardous Materials, Vol.160, pp.473-481.
5. Kariotis S. and Panagiotopoulos, Applied Surveying, Tome A, Disigma, 137, 2013
6. Kontos, D, Th., D.P. Komilis, P,D., HalvadakisP, C., (2003), SitingMSW landfills in Lesvos
Island with a GIS-based methodology,Waste Management and Research 21(3) 262–327.
7. Lin, Y, H., Kado J, J., (1998) A vector-based spatial model for landfill siting, Journal of
Hazardous Materials 58, 3–14.
8. Siddiqui, Z, M.,(1996), Landfill siting using Geographic Information Systemes: a demonstration,
Journal of Environmental Engineering 122 (6) 515–523.
1171
Water and wastewater treatment and management
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF FE-MN BIMETAL
MODIFIED KAOLIN CLAY MINERAL IN AS(III) REMOVAL
FROM GROUNDWATER
R Mudzielwana1*, W.M Gitari1 and P Ndungu2
1
Department of Ecology and Resource Management, University of Venda, Thohoyandou, South
Africa, +27 (0) 15 962 8572,
2
Department of Applied Chemistry, University of Johannesburg, South Africa, +27 (0) 11 559
6180.
*Corresponding author’s email address: mudzrabe@gmail.com
Abstract
In this study Fe-Mn bimetal modified kaolin clay mineral was synthesized and its performance for
As(III) removal from groundwater was evaluated. The adsorbent was characterized using XRF, FTIR
and SEM. The adsorbent contains SiO2 (39.39%), AlO3 (9.89%), FeO (16.66%) and MnO (4.02%)
as main chemical constituents. Its morphology appears more porous and granulated. Effect of contact
time, initial pH, initial concentration and co-existing ions on As(III) removal by Fe-Mn bimetal
modified kaolin were evaluated using batch experiments. The results showed that the % As(III)
removal was above 80% at initial pH range of 2-10 from initial As(III) concentration of 5 mg/L,
contact time of 60 min at 250 rpm shaking speed, adsorbent dosage of 0.4 g/100 mL. The adsorbent
was successfully regenerated for up to 4 adsorption-desorption cycles. The adsorption of As(III) in
presence of co-existing anions can be summarized in a decreasing order of Cl-> F-> NO3->SO42>CO32-. The adsorption data fitted better to pseudo second order reaction kinetic model indicating
that adsorption occurred through chemisorption. Furthermore, isotherm data was described by
Langmuir adsorption isotherm model. These results proved that Fe-Mn bimetal modified kaolin clay
mineral is a promising adsorbent for As(III) remediation from groundwater.
Keywords: Adsorption; Characterization; kaolinite; Pseudo second-order; Langmuir adsorption
isotherm.
1.
INTRODUCTION
Clean and drinkable water is a necessity for human wellbeing. Nowadays there is reduction in clean
water due contamination of water bodies by geochemical factors and industrial activities. Arsenic is
one of the contaminants of that poses threat to living organisms, in particular human beings. It is
linked to development of various types of cancer, skin thickening and neurological disorder diseases
(Tiwari and Lee, 2012). Evidence of these diseases and their link to arsenic has been reported in
countries such as India, China, Mexico, Bangladesh, Chile and United States (Naujokas et al., 2013;
Rahman et al., 2018).
Due to increasing incident rate of arsenic related diseases, the World Health Organization (WHO)
reduced the standard of arsenic in water for human consumption to 0.01 mg/L from 0.05 mg/L in
1993 (WHO, 1993; Smith and Smith, 2004). This standard has been accepted by several countries
including South Africa (Kempster et al., 2006). As such in areas where there is no alternative source
of clean water, efforts need to be directed towards removal of arsenic to a permissible limit of 0.01
mg/L. Adsorption is often considered as a sustainable and flexible method for arsenic removal and
other contaminants due to its simplicity in design. Several adsorbents such as iron coated cement
1172
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
(Kundu and Gupta, 2007), Fe/Al bimetallic (Cheng et al., 2016), lepidocrocite (Wang and Giammar,
2015), modified montmorillonite (Ren et al., 2014), surfactant modified bentonite clay (Su et al.,
2011), hydrous ferric oxide (Wilkie and Hering).
Iron oxides have shown higher adsorption efficiency in wide range of pH towards arsenic species
mainly As(V) than As(III) which is highly toxic. As such pre-oxidation of As(III) to As(V) is widely
preferred to enhance its removal by iron oxides based sorbents. Manganese oxide is a known to be a
good oxidizing agent for As(III). For this reason, several studies has been conducted on synthesis of
Fe-Mn binary sorbent for arsenic removal from water (Li et al., 2012; Zhang et al., 2012; Cui et al.,
2014; Qi et al., 2015). Although clay modified with iron oxides and manganese oxides has been
evaluated for arsenic removal (Mishra and Mahato, 2016), little has been done in synthesis of clay
based Fe-Mn binary sorbents. Therefore, this present study aims at 1) to synthesize Fe-Mn binary
coated clay adsorbent for As(III) removal, 2) to optimize the conditions for As(III) removal using
synthesized adsorbent, 3) to elucidate As(III) removal mechanism.
2.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
2.1 Materials
Locally available kaolin clay soils containing quartz and kaolinite as main minerals was collected
from Dzamba Village, Limpopo Province South Africa. All chemical reagents were purchased from
Rochelle Chemicals & Lab Equipment CC, South Africa Ltd and were of analytical grade and they
were used without further purification. Stock solutions containing 1000 mg/L As(III) was prepared
by dissolving 0.1733 g AsNaO2 respectively, in a 100 mL flask using Milli-Q water (18.2 MΩ/cm).
The solution was preserved by adding few drops of 3 M HNO3. Working solutions were prepared by
appropriate dilutions.
2.2 Synthesis of Fe-Mn bimetal modified kaolin rich mineral
To synthesize Fe-Mn binary modified kaolin clay (FMK), solutions of Fe and Mn were mixed
together at a volume ratio of 7.5 mL: 2.5 mL (Fe: Mn) in a 250 mL plastic bottle to make up a final
volume of 10 mL. To this, 1 g of clay was added and the mixture was agitated for 10 min to ensure
proper soaking. This was followed by addition of 20 mL of 2 M NaOH to the mixture to precipitate
Fe and Mn into their respective oxides. The mixture was agitated for further 60 min and then aged
for 48 hours for further precipitation. Thereafter, the mixture was centrifuged at 3000 rpm. And the
residues were washed with Milli-Q water to remove excess supernatants till the pH was close to
neutral and then oven dried for 12 hours at 110 ᴼC. Modified clay was then milled to pass through
250 µm sieve and then stored in a zip lock plastic bag.
2.3 Physicochemical characterization of the modified clay
Elemental composition of the modified clay were examined using S1 titan hand held XRF (Bruker,
Germany). Functional groups were determined using ATR Diamond FTIR (Bruker, Germany). The
morphological characteristics determined using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) (Leo1450
SEM, Voltage 10 kV, working distance 14 mm).
2.4 Batch adsorption experiments
The efficiency of Fe-Mn bimetal modified kaolinite clay mineral in As(III) removal was evaluated
using batch experiments. Parameters such as contact time, adsorbent dosage, adsorbate concentration
and initial solution pH were evaluated. To evaluate the effect of contact time, 100 mL solution contain
5 mg/L As(III) was pipetted onto 250 mL plastic bottle and 0.1 g of the modified clay was added.
Mixtures were agitated for various contact times ranging from 10 to 120 min on a Stuart Reciprocator
Table Shaker. To evaluate the effect of adsorbent dosage, the clay mass was varied from 0.05 to 0.5
g. For the effect of adsorbate concentration, the concentration was varied from 1 to 30 mg/L and to
evaluate the effect of pH the initial solution pH was adjusted from 2 to 12 using 0.1 M NaOH and 0.1
M HCl. The effect of co-existing anions was carried out in the presence of 5 mg/L of Cl-, F-, NO3-,
1173
Water and wastewater treatment and management
CO32-, SO42-. After agitation, samples were filtered using 0.45 µm pore filter membrane using a
vacuum pump. The solution pH was measured using JENWAY 3510 pH meter. The residual As(III)
concentration was measured using ScTRACE Gold electrode attached to 884 professional VA
Polaography (Metrohm, SA). A composite solution containing 1 mol/L sulfamic acid, 0.5 mol/L
citrilc acid and 0.45 mol/L KCl was used an electrolyte. All experiments were carried out in triplicate
and the mean values were reported. Equation 1 and 2 were used to compute the percentage of removal
and the adsorption capacity respectively.
% 𝑟𝑒𝑚𝑜𝑣𝑎𝑙 = (
𝐶𝑖 −𝐶𝑒
𝑞𝑒 = (
𝑚
𝐶𝑖 −𝐶𝑒
𝐶𝑖
) × 100%
(1)
)×𝑣
(2)
Where Ci and Ce represent the initial and equilibrium As(III) concentration (mg/L) respectively and
m represent mass of the dry adsorbent (g). V is the volume (L) and qe is the adsorption capacity
(mg/g).
2.5 Adsorbent regeneration and reuse
To evaluate the reusability of the adsorbents, 4 repetitive adsorption cycles were conducted as
follows: 100 mL of solution containing 5 mg/L of As(III) was pipetted into 250 mL and 0.4 g of the
clay soils was added to make adsorbent dosage of 0.4 g/100 mL. Mixtures were agitated for 60 min
at 250 rpm. After agitation samples were filtered through 0.45 µm filter membranes. Residues were
rinsed with Milli-Q water to remove free As(III) ions and then oven dried at 105 ◦C and reused for
adsorption. For regeneration, residues were treated with 100 mL of 0.01 M Na2CO3 for 30 min to
desorb the adsorbed ions thereafter samples were filtered to through 0.45 µm filter membrane and
then washed gently with Milli-Q water. The regenerated adsorbent was then used for As(III)
adsorption. The procedure was repeated up to 4th adsorption cycles.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Physicochemical characterization
3.1.1 Bulk chemical composition
Table 1 presents major and minor chemical composition of raw kaolinite and Fe-Mn modified
kaolinite clay. From the results it is observed that SiO2 and AlO3 are the major chemical oxides of
the clay. After modification an increase in Fe2O3 and MnO was observed which shows that the
material was successfully coated. Furthermore, a decrease was observed in the percentage
composition of other oxides. This could be attributed to ion exchange, dilution and dialumination
during modification.
Table 1: chemical composition of raw and modified clay.
Oxides(%w/w) SiO2
Al2O3
Fe2O3
MnO
MgO
CaO
K2O
TiO2
Raw
56.06
22.05
3.88
0.01
0.57
0.95
0.16
1.76
Modified
39.39
10.08
16.66
4.02
LOD
0.55
0.13
1.31
3.1.2 Morphological analysis
Figure 1A and B presents SEM micrographs of raw and modified kaolin clay soils, respectively. The
morphology of the raw clay appears spongier with some irregular shaped agglomerates. After
modification, the surface appears more porous with irregular shaped agglomerates. The EDS
spectrum for the modified clay confirmed the presence of Mn and Fe on the surface of the clay. Which
shows that the surface of the clay has been modified successfully.
1174
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Figure 1: Micrographs of raw and modified kaolin clay soil.
3.1.3 FTIR analysis
The FTIR spectra of raw and modified kaolin clay recorded is presented in Figure 2. The spectra
showed major band at 3619.36 cm-1 showing the vibration of structural -OH group of the clay
material. The bands observed at 3633 and 1601 cm-1 could be attributed to vibration of hydroxyl
groups in due to physiosorbed water and the hydroxyl groups located between the octahedral and
tetrahedral sheets of the clay.
Raw clay
FMK
FMK-As
1
Transmittance
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
Wavelength (cm-1)
Figure 2: FTIR spectra of raw, modified clay (FKM) and after As(III) adsorption (FKM-As)
1175
Water and wastewater treatment and management
The band at 1020 cm-1 could be associated with the vibration of Si-O. The bands at 918, 762.96, 665
and 532 cm-1 could be ascribed to the vibration of Al-OH-Al, Al-O-Si. After modification, a decrease
in the transmittance intensity of major bands at 1020, 918, 762. 96, 665 and 532 cm-1 was observed.
This could be ascribed to loss of silica and alumina during modification of the clay with Fe-Mn
oxides. A slight increase in these band was observed in the spectra recorded after As(III) adsorption.
3.2
Batch experiments
3.2.1 Effect of contact time and adsorption kinetics
The effect of contact time on As(III) adsorption capacity by Fe-Mn modified clay is depicted in Figure
3. It is observed that the adsorption capacity increased with increasing contact time reaching a
maximum of 5.68 mg/g at 120 min. The increase in sorption capacity could be attributed to
availability of more active sites in the adsorbent. The system reached equilibrium within 60 min and
it was therefor used as optimum contact time for subsequent experiment. To further illustrate the rate
limiting steps and possible reaction mechanism, linear equations of pseudo first order and pseudo
second order reaction models (Eq. 3 and 4) together with the intra-particle model of Weber Morris
(Eq. 5) were used (Tran et al., 2017; Weber and Morris, 1963).
𝐾 𝑡
1
log( 𝑞𝑒 − 𝑞𝑡 ) = − 2.303
+ log 𝑞𝑒
𝑡
𝑞𝑡
1
= (𝑞 ) 𝑡 + 𝐾
𝑒
(3)
1
(4)
2
2 𝑞𝑒
𝑞𝑡 = 𝐾𝑖𝑑 𝑡1/2 + 𝐶𝑖
(5)
Where qe and qt (mg/g) are the adsorption capacities of As(III) on the adsorbents at the equilibrium
and at time t (min), K1 (min-1) and K2 (mg/g. min-1) are the rate constants of the pseudo first order
equation and pseudo second order equation, respectively. Kid (mg/g. min1/2) is the intra-particle
diffusion rate constant and Ci is the intercept.
The adsorption data was described better by pseudo second order model as shown by the plot in
Figure 4 as compared to pseudo first order model (figure not presented). This suggests that As(III)
adsorption occurred via chemisorption. This was further confirmed by the models constant values as
presented in Table 2. The intra-particle diffusion plot showed three different phases (Figure 5). The
first linear plot indicate adsorption of As(III) on the external surface of the adsorbent, second plot
indicate the film transport of As(III) into the pores of the adsorbent and lastly the third one indicate
the intra-particle diffusion at equilibrium. The Kid value phase 1 was higher compared to Kid values
at phase 2 and 3 indicating that adsorption on the external surface was much faster compared to other
phases. This could be attributed to increasing mass transfer resistance as confirmed by increasing
boundary layer thickness constant (Ci) value from phase 1 to 3.
Table 2: Constant values for Pseudo first order and second order reaction kinetics models.
Pseudo first order
Pseudo second order
K1 (min-1)
qe (mg/g)
R2
K2(g/mg.min-1) qe (mg/g)
R2
0.027
1.76
0.89
0.028
6.0
0.99
Table 3: Constant values for Intra-particle diffusion model.
Kid1
(mg/g. Ci1
Kid2
(mg/g. Ci2
min-0.5)
min-0.5)
0.724
1.22
0.241
3.77
1176
Kid3
(mg/g. Ci3
min-0.5)
0.05
5.10
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
6
qe (mg As(III)/g)
5
4
3
2
1
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
time (min)
Figure 3: Effect of contact time on As(III) adsorption capacity (0.1g /100 mL adsorbent
dosage, 5 mg/L adsorbate concentration, 6.4 solution pH and 250 rpm shaking speed).
25
20
t/qe
15
10
5
0
0
20
40
60
80
time (min)
Figure 4: Linear plot for pseudo second order.
1177
100
120
140
Water and wastewater treatment and management
y = 0.054x + 5.1093
R² = 0.8715
6
y = 0.2411x + 3.775
R² = 1
5.5
qe (mg/g)
5
y = 0.7242x + 1.2214
R² = 0.9974
4.5
4
3.5
3
3
4
5
6
7
time
8
9
10
11
12
(min1/2)
Figure 5: Intra-particle diffusion plot.
3.2.2 Effect of adsorbent dosage
Figure 6 presents the effect of adsorbent dosage on As(III) percentage removal and also on the q e
(mg/g) adsorption capacity. The results showed that the percentage As(III) removal increased with
increasing adsorbent dosage up to 0.4 g/100 mL thereafter, no further increase was observed.
Conversely, the adsorption capacity decreased with increasing adsorbent dosage. The trend is linked
to increasing active adsorption sites for a limited As(III) ions available in the solution as the adsorbent
dosage increases. Therefore, 0.4 g/100 mL was chosen as the optimum adsorbent dosage for
subsequent experiments.
90
5
4.5
4
3.5
70
3
60
2.5
2
50
qe (mg As(III)/g
% As(III) removal
80
1.5
1
40
0.5
30
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
0.4
0.45
0.5
0.55
Adsorbent dosage (g/100 mL)
Figure 6: Effect of adsorbent dosage onto % As(III) removal and As(III) adsorption capacity
(Adsorbate concentration 5 mg/L; pH 6.32 and contact time of 60 mins at 250 rpm).
1178
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.2.3 Effect of adsorbate concentration and adsorption isotherms
Figure 7 depicts the effect of adsorbate concentration on % As(III) removal and As(III) adsorption
capacity. It is evident that the percentage As(III) removal decreases with increasing adsorbate
concentration while the adsorption capacity increases as the initial concentration. This could be
attributed to increasing ratio between the active adsorption sites and the adsorbate molecules as the
concentration increases. At lower concentration, the ratio of active sites is to As(III) ions is higher
resulting in sufficient interaction of ions with the active sites for efficient As(III) removal.
To further illustrate the relationship between the adsorbate concentration and the adsorbent the linear
equations for Langmuir (Eq. 6) and Freundlich (Eq. 7) isotherm model were used (Langmuir, 1918;
Tran et al., 2017).
𝐶𝑒
𝑞𝑒
= (𝑄
1
𝑚𝑎𝑥
) 𝐶𝑒 + 𝑄
1
(6)
𝑚𝑎𝑥 𝐾𝐿
log 𝑞𝑒 = 𝑛 log 𝐶𝑒 + log 𝐾𝐹
(7)
Where Ce (mg/L) is the As(III) concentration at equilibrium, qe (mg/g) is the adsorption capacity at
equilibrium, Qmax (mg/g) is the maximum saturated monolayer adsorption capacity, KL (L/mg) is the
constant related to the affinity between adsorbent and adsorbate, KF (mg/g) is the Freundlich constant
related to adsorption capacity and n is the Freundlich intensity parameter which indicate the
magnitude of the adsorption driving force or the surface heterogeneity. The value of Qmax and KL are
determined from the slope and intercept of Ce/qe Vs Ce while the value of Kf and n are determined
from the slope and intercept of log qe Vs log Ce. The data for adsorption of As(III) by Fe-Mn modified
clay fitted better to Langmuir adsorption isotherm as compared to Freundlich isotherm model. Figure
8 shows the plot for Langmuir isotherm model while Table 4 presents the constant values for both
isotherm models. The better fitting to Langmuir isotherm model suggests monolayer uniform
adsorption on the surface of the adsorbent.
Table 4: constant values for Langmuir and Freundlich adsorption isotherms.
Langmuir adsorption isotherm
Freundlich adsorption isotherm
2
qm (mg/g)
KL (L/mg)
R
Kf (mg/g)
n
R2
2.07
0.64
0.99
1.54
0.44
0.90
% As (III) removal
qe As (III)
90
2.5
80
2
60
1.5
50
40
1
qe (mg/g)
% As(III) removal
70
30
20
0.5
10
0
0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Adsorbate concentration (mg/L)
Figure 7: Effect of adsorbate concentration on As(III) removal and adsorption capacity (0.4 g
adsorbent dosage, 6.33 pH, 60 min contact time at 250 rpm)
1179
Water and wastewater treatment and management
14
y = 0.4872x + 0.7533
R² = 0.9985
12
Ce/qe
10
8
6
4
2
0
0
5
10
15
20
25
Ce (mg/L)
Figure 8: Linear plot for Langumuir adsorption isotherm.
90
13
85
12
80
11
75
10
70
9
65
8
60
pH final
% As (III) removal
3.3.4 Effect of pH
Figure 9 shows the effect of pH on adsorption of As(III) removal. It is evident that the percentage
As(III) removal remained above 80 % from the initial pH of 2-8 and then decrease drastically at pH
above 8. This trend can be attributed to As(III) speciation at different pH values. At pH <9 the most
dominant species of As(III) is neutrally charged H3AsO3 whereas at pH>9 the dominant species is
negatively charged H2AsO3-. The decrease in As(III) removal could be attributed to electrostatic
repulsion between the OH- in the adsorbent surface and also the competition between the abundant
OH- in the solution and H2AsO3-.
7
55
50
6
45
5
40
4
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
initial pH
Figure 9: Effect of initial pH on % As(III) removal (5 mg/L adsorbate concentration, 0.4 g/100
mL adsorbent dosage and 60 min contact time).
1180
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3.3.5 Effect of competing anions
The effect of co-existing anions is presented in Figure 10. The presence of fluoride, nitrate, carbonate
and sulphate ions showed inhibition of As(III) by FMK by about 1% while chloride showed greater
influence by about 2.5%. Although the As(III) removal decreased in the presence of other anions, the
overall % of removal was still beyond 90 %. As such FMK synthesized in this study can still be used
to treat groundwater containing all these ions. The effect of co-existing anions on As(III) removal can
be summarized in the decreasing order of Cl-> F-> NO3->SO42->CO32-.
3.3.6 Regeneration and reuse
For the adsorbent to be considered economically viable for use in water it must be able to be reused
and regenerated effectively. To evaluate the regeneration potential, Na2CO3 was used as a regenerant
solution. After each adsorption cycle, adsorbent was treated with 100 mL deionized water, oven dried
and reused for As(II) removal. Figure 11 shows the results for four adsorption- reuse cycles. The
value for fresh denotes the percentage As(III) removal observed from freshly prepared sorbent. The
results showed that the % As(III) removal with the first two cycles was almost equal to the one that
was archived by fresh adsorbent. The percentage removal showed significant decrease going to 3 rd
and 4th adsorption cycles. This could be attributed to two possible factors 1) inadequate regeneration
of the adsorbent and 2) dissolution of major chemical oxides from the adsorbent due to treatment by
alkaline solution. The same trend was observed after treating used sorbent with Milli-Q water. This
result signifies that FMK is a possible candidate for As(III) removal from groundwater.
96
95.5
% As(III) removal
95
94.5
94
93.5
93
92.5
92
91.5
Blank
Chloride
Fluoride
Nitrates
Carbonates
Sulphates
Figure 10: Effects of co-existing anions in As(III) removal by FMK (5 mg/L As(III) initial
concentration, 5 mg/L of each co-existing ions, 0.4 g/100 mL adsorbent dosage, 6.7 initial pH
and 60 min agitation time at 250 rpm)
1181
Water and wastewater treatment and management
90
80
% As(III) removal
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Fresh
Repeat
Cycle 1
Repeat
Cycle 2
Repeat
Cycle 3
Repeat
Cycle 4
Repeat
Cycles
Figure 11: Variation of % As(III) removal as a function of regeneration and repeat cycles (6
mg/L As(III), 0.4 g/100 mL adsorbent dosage, 60 min contact time at 250 rpm shaking speed).
4.
CONCLUSIONS
The Fe-Mn bimetallic modified kaolin clay was successfully synthesized. The prepared FMK proved
to be effective for As(III) removal from water. The percentage of removal was found to be above
80% at pH range between 2 and 8 from the initial As(III) concentration of 5 mg/L using 0.4 g/100
mL adsorbate concentration after 60 min of contact time. As(III) removal was observed to be low at
alkaline pH levels. The adsorption kinetics data fitted well to pseudo second order of reaction
indicating that As(III) adsorption occurred via chemisorption. Furthermore, the data also fitted well
to Langmuir adsorption isotherm indicating monolayer adsorption of As(III) on the surface of
adsorbent. The adsorption of As(III) in presence of co-existing anions can be summarized in a
decreasing order of Cl-> F-> NO3->SO42->CO32-. The adsorbent was effectively regenerated and
reused for 4 consecutive cycles although a decrease in As(III) removal was noted after the 2 nd
regeneration cycle. The obtained results suggest that FMK developed in this study is a possible
candidate for As(III) removal from groundwater.
Acknowledgement
Authors would like to acknowledge financial assistance from National Research Foundation, SaiF
and University of Venda (RPC).
References
1. Cheng, Z. Fu, F. Dionysiou, D.D. Tang, B. 2016. Adsorption, oxidation, and reduction behavior
of arsenic in the removal of aqueous As(III) by mesoporous Fe/Al bimetallic particles. Water
Research, 96, pp. 22-31.
2. Cui, H.J. Cai, J.K. Zhao, H. Yuan, B. Ai, C.L. Fu, M.L., 2014. Fabrication of magnetic porous
Fe–Mn binary oxide nanowires with superior capability for removal of As(III) from water.
Journal of Hazardous Materials, 279, pp. 26–31.
3. Kempster, P.L. Silberbauer, M. Kuhn, A., 2007. Interpretation of drinking water quality
guidelines – The case of arsenic. Water SA, 33(1), pp. 95-100.
4. Kundu, S. Gupta, A.K., 2007. Adsorption characteristics of As(III) from aqueous solution on iron
oxide coated cement (IOCC). Journal of Hazardous Materials, 142, pp. 97–104.
1182
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
5. Langmuir, I., 1918. The adsorption of gases on plane surfaces of glass, mica and platinum.
Journal of the American Chemical Society, 40 (9), pp. 1361-1403.
6. Li, X. He, K. Pan, B. Zhang, S. Lu, L. Zhang, W., 2012. Efficient As(III) removal by macroporous
anion exchanger-supported Fe–Mn binary oxide: Behavior and mechanism. Chemical
Engineering Journal, 193(194); 131–138.
7. Mishra, T. Mahato, D.K. 2016. A comparative study on enhanced arsenic(V) and arsenic(III)
removal by iron oxide and manganese oxide pillared clays from ground water. Journal of
Environmental Chemical Engineering, 4, pp. 1224–1230.
8. Naujokas, M.F. Anderson, B. Ahsan, H. Aposhian H.V. Graziano, J.H. Thompson, C. Suk, W.A.,
2013. The Broad Scope of Health Effects from Chronic Arsenic Exposure: Update on a
Worldwide Public Health Problem. Environmental Health Perspectives, 121(3), pp. 295-302.
9. Qi, J. Zhang, G. Li, H., 2015. Efficient removal of arsenic from water using a granular adsorbent:
Fe–Mn binary oxide impregnated chitosan bead. Bioresource Technology, 193, pp. 243–249.
10. Rahman, M.A. Rahman, A. Khan, M.Z.K. Renzaho, A.M.N., 2018. Human health risks and
socio-economic perspectives of arsenic exposure in Bangladesh: A scoping review.
Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 150, pp. 335–343.
11. Ren, H. Zhang, Z. Luo, H. Hu, B. Dang, Z. Yang, C. Li, L, 2014. Adsorption of arsenic on
modified montmorillonite. Applied Clay Science, 97–98, pp. 17–23.
12. Smith, A.H. Smith M.M.H., 2004. Arsenic drinking water regulations in developing countries
with extensive exposure. Toxicology. 198, pp. 39–44.
13. Su, J. Huang, H.G. Jin, X.Y. Lu, ZQ. Chen, Z.L., 2011. Synthesis, characterization and kinetic of
a surfactant-modified bentonite used to remove As(III) and As(V) from aqueous solution. Journal
of Hazardous Materials, 185, pp, 63–70.
14. Tiwari, D. Lee, S.M., 2012. Novel hybrid materials in the remediation of ground waters
contaminated with As(III) and As(V). Chemical Engineering Journal, 204–206, pp. 23–31.
15. Tran, H.N. You, S.J. Bandegharaei, A.H. Chao, H.P. 2017. Mistakes and inconsistencies
regarding adsorption of contaminants from aqueous solutions: A critical review. Water
Research, 120, pp. 88-116.
16. Wang, L. Giammar. D.E., 2015. Effects of pH, dissolved oxygen, and aqueous ferrous iron on the
adsorption of arsenic to lepidocrocite. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 448, pp. 331–
338.
17. Weber, W.J. Morris, J.C., 1963. Kinetics of adsorption on carbon from solution. Journal of the
Sanitary Engineering Division, 89(2), pp. 31-60.
18. WHO, 1993. Guidelines for Drinking Water Quality: Recommendations, Vol. 1. World Health
Organization, Geneva.
19. Wilkie, J.A. Hering, J.G., 1996. Adsorption of arsenic onto hydrous ferric oxide: effects of
adsorbate/adsorbent ratios and co-occurring solutes. Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical
and Engineering Aspects, 107, pp. 97-110.
20. Zhang, G. Liu, H. Qu, J. Jefferson, W., 2012. Arsenate uptake and arsenite simultaneous sorption
and oxidation by Fe–Mn binary oxides: Influence of Mn/Fe ratio, pH, Ca2+, and humic acid.
Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 366, pp. 141–146.
1183
Water and wastewater treatment and management
REUSE POTENTIAL OF CATAPHORESIS WASTEWATERS IN
AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY
P. Karacal1, C. Aliyazicioglu Ozdemir2, E. Erdim2 and F. Germirli Babuna*1
1
Environmental Engineering Department, Istanbul Technical University, Maslak 34469, Istanbul,
Turkey
2
Environmental Engineering Department, Marmara University, School of Engineering, Goztepe,
Kadikoy 34722, Istanbul, Turkey
*
Corresponding author: e-mail: germirliba@itu.edu.tr, tel: +905324090355
Abstract
Extensive amount of water input together with various chemicals are required by automotive industry.
The cataphoresis process is composed of two main sub-processes: pretreatment and electrodeposion
(ED) coating. The retreatment or surface preparation process consists of a series of operations, which
includes the hot water rinsing, degreasing, rinsing, surface activation and phosphate coating followed
by several rinsing steps. After these operations, electrodeposition coating takes place. As a result, of
the cataphoresis process, a metal surface resistant to corrosion and ready to further surface
applications is obtained. Recycling and reuse of wastewater in this process is of great importance for
sustainability studies as substantial amounts of water is consumed and wastewater is generated out of
it. On the other hand, there is limited information in the literature on the reuse of wastewaters
produced from cataphoresis rinse pools. The wastewater originating from the cataphoresis process
contains heavy metal ions. In order to remove heavy metal ions from these effluents various treatment
methods ie. chemical precipitation, adsorption, oxidation-reduction, electrochemical treatment,
membrane technologies etc. can be used. The economic and technical limitations resulting from
applying the mentioned methods trigger research activities to focus on promising emerging
technologies such as removal with nanoparticles. In this context the objective of this study is to
evaluate the widely used cataphoresis process of automotive industry in terms of its water
consumption and pollution loads, and to investigate the reclamation and reuse potential of segregated
effluents arising from this process. The results indicate that 43 % of the continuous effluents arising
from cataphoresis process is reusable in nature. The amount of reusable wastewater streams can also
be elevated by adding discharges from cooling system and boiler to the mentioned segregated
wastewaters. By doing so 20 % of the whole wastewaters can be designated as reusable effluents after
being subjected to an appropriate treatment.
Keywords: industrial pollution; wastewater reuse; cataphoresis; automotive manufacturing;
segregated effluents.
1.
INTRODUCTION
The depletion and pollution of the water resources can be considered as one of the most important
environmental problems in the world. Due to industrialization and the increase in the consumption,
water resources are declining and getting more polluted every day. Over the last decade water
reclamation and reuse applications have increased as they represent effective approaches for
conserving limited, high-quality fresh water supplies. To meet the future needs of domestic and
industrial water requirements and to protect the quality of water resources, methods should be
developed to reduce water usage and water-wastewater management strategies need to be improved.
1184
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
Therefore, studies on re-use and recovery of wastewater in industrial sectors gain more and more
significance.
Effluents from industrial process and operations, such as metal finishing, electroplating and mining
contain heavy metals. Heavy metals, such as mercury, lead, cadmium, nickel generates toxic
wastewaters.
According to the data of 2016, the automotive sector corresponds to about 5 % of the world's
economy. As a result, the sector is placed as the fourth largest economy with a share of 4 trillion
dollars (IDBT, 2017). The automotive industry in Turkey plays an important role in the
manufacturing sector of the Turkish economy. In 2017, Turkey produced more than 1 million motor
vehicles (AMA, 2017). With a cluster of car makers and parts suppliers, the Turkish automotive sector
has become an integral part of the global automotive manufacturers network, exporting nearly 28.4
billion dollar worth of motor vehicles and components (AMA, 2017).
Quite a high amount of water with various chemical additives are consumed by automotive industry.
It is stated in the literature that approximately a water usage ranging from 2.31 to 8 m3/vehicle is
required for car assembly and production (Tejeda et al, 2012). The wastewaters generated from the
mentioned sector in turn are treated by means of many different technologies; such as micro filtration
(Zhang et al, 2006), oxidation (Zhu et al, 2017), coagulation-flocculation (Bakar and Halim, 2017),
advanced oxidation (Consejo et al, 2005; Mudliar et al, 2009). Moreover, biological treatment can
also be applied for removing pollutants from these effluents (Sarioglu and Gokcek, 2016; Mackulac
et al, 2016).
The cataphoresis process, composed of two main sub-processes, pretreatment and electrodeposion
(ED) coating, is an important operation in automotive industry. The pretreatment or surface
preparation process consists of a series of operations which include the hot water rinsing, degreasing,
rinsing, surface activation and phosphate coating followed by several rinsing steps (US EPA, 1994).
After these operations electrodeposition coating takes place. As a result, the cataphoresis process, a
metal surface resistant to corrosion and ready to further surface applications is obtained (US EPA,
1994). Recycling and reuse of wastewater in this process is of great importance from a sustainability
standpoint as substantial amounts of water is consumed and wastewater is generated out of it. On the
other hand, there is limited information in the literature on the reuse of wastewaters produced from
cataphoresis rinse pools. The wastewater originating from the cataphoresis process contains heavy
metal ions. In order to remove heavy metal ions from these effluents various treatment methods ie.
chemical precipitation, adsorption, oxidation-reduction, electrochemical treatment, membrane
technologies etc. can be used.
In this context the objective of this study is to evaluate the widely used cataphoresis process of
automotive industry in terms of its water consumption and pollution loads, and to investigate the
wastewater reclamation and reuse potential of segregated effluents generated from the mentioned
process.
2.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study covers and provides the necessary information on the technical steps required for a
comprehensive survey, involving detailed process profile, water demand, wastewater generation,
wastewater segregation for optimum treatment, water balance and conceptual basis of wastewater
recycling potential. All wastewater samples collected (once every 2 months) from the processes on a
regular basis, were analyzed directly. The wastewater samples were characterized in terms of
chemical oxygen demand (COD), pH, suspended solids, ammonium nitrogen (NH4-N). All analyses
were carried out according to the Standard Methods (APHA, 1998). The analytical methods adopted
are given in Table 1.
1185
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Table 1: Adopted wastewater characterization methods
Parameter
Method
pH
Electrometric Method
COD
Closed Reflux-Colorimetric
Suspended Solids
NH4-N
Gravimetric Method
Nesslerization (SM 4500-NH3 C)
3.
DESCRIPTION OF THE INDUSTRY AND PRODUCTION PROCESSES
In the automotive industry, production processes are basically divided into four main production lines.
These four main production lines are: pressing, welding, painting and assembly.
The production of vehicles starts with the press process. The parts forming the body of the vehicles
are shaped on the press lines. Chassis and some body parts of trucks and busses are compressed in
the pressing area. Pressing takes place in three steps. In the first stage, industrial flat plate sheets that
come as plate get in first form. Then by means of the second press stage, the edges and the inner parts
the segment which has been shaped in the previous step are cut out. In addition, cutting and drilling
operations required to achieve the final shape of the part is performed in this stage. During the third
stage of the press process holes are opened at the required points and the edges of the part are curled.
Spot welding is the most commonly used welding process for automotive and sheet metal works. At
car body parts assembling line, sheet bodies are linked with spot welding machines. Then iin the
‘carrossery’ section of the production line; vehicle cabin, front side panel engine cover parts
integration are performed. Annually, the production capacity of the assembly line is 12,500 vehicles.
The aim of painting is to form a coating film on the surface of an object in order to protect the object
and give a fine appearance. Painting may also have other special functions. There are various types
of coating methods. Spray painting and cataphoresis are currently used in many types of industrial
painting. First, the vehicle bodies will undergo surface preparation and pre-paint treatment. This
preparation involves thorough washing and wipe-cleaning. The pre-paint treatment process causes a
chemical crystallization to occur on the vehicle surface that provides improved paint adhesion and
anti-corrosion protection. The vehicle bodies are then conveyed directly from this phosphate prepaint treatment process to the electro-coating process, which is typically a full immersion process.
The vehicle bodies are immersed in the electro-coating bath, which causes electro-deposion on the
vehicle bodies. That is, opposite charges are applied to the material and the vehicle, which causes the
material to readily adhere to the surface of the vehicle. After applying the electro-coating, the vehicle
bodies are conveyed to a curing oven (bake oven) where the coating is cured and dried prior to being
conveyed to the prime-coat spray booth. As the vehicle moves toward and into the prime-coat spray
booth, sealers and other protective coatings, such as antichip, are applied.
The assembly department is the last stage in the production process. The components of the car such
as the seat, steering wheel, tires, headlights, mirrors, interior wardrobe, instrument panel, electrical
system, doors and mechanics parts such as engine, gearbox etc. produced in the factory are installed
to the car.
The processes investigated in this study are from a real car body-assembling factory. Process water
is supplied from well water and then it is passes through disinfection, sand filter, activated carbon,
ion-exchange, RO treatment and DI if necessary to used up different processes. The majority of this
water (%41) is used for paint shop operations. 17 per cent are used for irrigation and fire systems and
83 percent is allocated for sanitary purposes, cooling tower and other purposes. The wastewater from
the production plant is treated onsite with standard physical-chemical treatment before discharge. The
annual amount of wastewater generation is 23,000 m3.
1186
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
4.
WATER CONSUMPTION AND QUALITY REQUIREMENTS FOR VARIOUS
WATER USES
Throughout the plant water is used not only for the production process and domestic purposes (water
supply for workers and personnel), but also for irrigation and in the fire suppression system. Figure
1 presents the total water consumption of the plant. The total daily water requirement is calculated as
approximately 134 m3 d−1.
The appropriate quality criteria for water consumption in industrial applications changes according
to the specific demands of the manufacturer. Apart from irrigation, three different water quality
requirements are set by the manufacturer i.e., for fresh cooling water inputs and for process waters
(either deionized (RO/DI) or soft). The relevant quality requirements for different type of water uses
in the installation are classified as well water, soft water, potable water and reverse osmosis (RO)
treated or deionized DI water. As may be noted from the Table 2, conductivity and pH level is the
sole quality parameter considered for the production lines. The specified conductivity level varies in
a wide range from 2 to 1080 μS cm−1, depending on the particular use. Process water requirement is
divided into soft water, deionized (DI) water / reverse osmosis (RO) as given in Table 2.
Table 2: Water quality requirements
pH
Conductivity (µS/cm)
Well Water
7.95
1080
Potable Water
7.86
397
Soft Water
8.07
210
RO/DI Water
7.3-9.5
2.12-16.19
The amount of either continuous or intermittent water requirements within the whole plant are
presented in Figure 1. Water requiring spots in the premise together with their amounts are given in
Table 3.
Table 3: Water consumption
Input purpose
Irrigation
Fire System
Domestic
Non-process
Boiler
Cooling
Cooling
Process
1
2
5.
Amount
m3/d
20.80
1.72
51.29
Type
Quality
Intermittent
Intermittent
Continuous
Well
Well
Potable
1.61
17.10
1.61
Intermittent
Intermittent
Intermittent
Well
Soft
Well
22.20
17.2
Intermittent
Intermittent
Soft
DI/RO
WASTEWATER GENERATION AND TREATMENT
Process wastewaters together with domestic effluents and non-process discharges are produced in the
premise. Both continuous as well as intermittent wastewater discharges are generated from the
production processes. The flowrates of segregated process wastewaters are outlined in Table 4. As
can be seen from the table process effluents are 37 % of the total amount.
1187
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Table 4: Wastewater generation
Wastewater source
Domestic
Non-process
Boiler
Cooling
Process
Bus Paintshop
Truck Paintshop
TOTAL
Amount
m3/d
34.83
1.10
9.87
9.86
14.00
65.51
Domestic wastewater is treated by sequencing batch reactors after passing from drum screens. In
Table 5 raw wastewater characterization together with the effluent of treatment plant are listed.
Table 5: Wastewater characterization
Parameter
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD mg/L)
Suspended solids (SS mg/L)
Oil and Grease (mg/L)
Ammonium nitrogen (NH4-N mg/L)
Nitrite Nitrogen (NO2-N mg/L)
Total Chromium (T.Cr mg/L)
Chromium (Cr+6 mg/L)
Iron (Fe mg/L)
Aluminum (Al mg/L)
Lead (Pb mg/L)
Copper (Cu mg/L)
Zinc (Zn mg/L)
Mercury (Hg mg/L)
Fluoride (F- mg/L)
pH
6.
Raw wastewater
551
205
7.49
0.57
<0.03
0.005
<0,01
1.196
1.234
0.003
0.017
2.727
<0.00013
14.7
6.45
Effluent of treatment
53
20
0.34
33.7
0.84
0.006
<0,01
0.47
0.309
0.0027
0.013
0.297
<0.00013
1.82
7.33
REUSE POTENTIAL OF CATAPHORESIS EFFLUENTS
Approximately 59 % of the process wastewaters are generated from truck paint shop where
cataphoresis process takes place. Cataphoresis process operates with 10 baths totally, in two stages,
of Pretreatment (PT) and Electrodeposition (ED). In the Pretreatment (PT) line the metal car body
pass through the subsequent baths of hot water rinsing (bath 1), degreasing (bath 2), rinsing I (bath
3), surface activating (bath 4), phosphate (bath 5), rinsing II (bath 6), DI water rinsing (bath 7).
Besides, in the Electrodeposition (ED) line, the metal car body pass through cataphoresis painting
(bath 8), UF rinsing (bath 9), DI water rinsing (bath 10) baths. Both continuous and intermittent
discharges arise from these baths. Water requirement and wastewater generation of cataphoresis
process are given in Table 6 and 7, respectively.
1188
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
3
64,8 m /d
48%
Irrigation Fire System
15,5%
1,5%
20,78 m3/d-1 1,72 m3/d-1
12,2 m3/d-1
9%
40m3/h
Cooling Water 2
4,9 m /d
4%
-1
200 m3
Storage 30,4 m3/d-1
Ion Exchange
Ion Exchange
40m3/h
Active Carbon Filter
83%
111 m3/d-1
Active Carbon Filter
Sand Filter
Disinfection
134 m3/d-1
34,4 m /d
25%
2500 m3
Storage
Cooling Water 1
-1
3
WELL WATER
Bus Paintshop
22,2 m3/d-1
16%
23%
3
3
25,5 m /d
19%
-1
RO
3
46,2 m /d
34%
-1
Waste
-1
Domestic Usage
Truck
Bus
Treatment Plant
Cooling Water
Other Buildings
Boiler
Truck Paintshop
3
23,6%
31,67 m /d
6,0%
8,1 m /d
3
-1
-1
3
1,2%
1,61 m /d-1
1,2%
1,61 m3/d-1
1,2%
1,61 m3/d-1
1,2%
3
1,61 m /d
-1
Figure 1. The total water usage of the plant
1189
12,7 m3/d-1
10%
DI
Truck Paintshop
4,5 m3/d-1
3%
8,3 m3/d-1
6%
Water and wastewater treatment and management
Table 6: Water requirement and frequency of Cataphoresis process baths
Name of the bath
DI/RO Water Requirement and frequency(m3) Total DI/RO water
(Bath Number)
requirement (m3 /year)
Continuous
Intermittent
Hot water rinse (1)
1 m3 /day
100 m3 /year
340
3
3
Degreasing (2)
1 m /day
50 m /year
290
Water rinse tank-1 (3)
1 m3 /day
700 m3 /year
940
3
3
Surface activation (4)
1 m /day
200 m /year
440
3
Phosphating (5)
0.4 m /day
96
Water rinse tank-2 (6)
1 m3 /day
700 m3 /year
940
3
3
DI Water rinse tank (7) 1 m /day
500 m /year
740
ED Coating (8)
UF Rinse (9)
DI Water Rinse (10)
1 m3 /day
100 m3 /year
340
Table 7: Wastewater generation in Cataphoresis process baths and frequency of discharges
Name of the bath
Wastewater Generation and frequency
Total Wastewater
(Bath Number)
Generation (m3/year)
Continuous
Intermittent
Hot water rinse (1)
0.6 m3 /day
100 m3 /year
244
3
3
Degreasing (2)
0.6 m /day
50 m /year
194
Water rinse tank-1 (3)
0.6 m3 /day
700 m3 /year
844
3
3
Surface activation (4)
0.6 m /day
200 m /year
344
Phosphating (5)
negligible
Water rinse tank-2 (6)
0.6 m3 /day
700 m3 /year
844
3
3
DI Water rinse tank (7)
0.6 m /day
500 m /year
644
ED Coating (8)
negligible
UF Rinse (9)
negligible
3
3
DI Water Rinse (10)
0.6 m /day
100 m /year
244
TOTAL
4.2 m3 /day
2350 m3 /year
3358
The results of the characterization study performed on the mentioned bath discharges are tabulated in
Table 8. As baths 8 and 9 are operated as a closed loop system, characterization of it is not given in
the mentioned table.
Table 8: Wastewater characterization of Cataphoresis process baths
Parameter
Bath Number
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
11
12.6 10.6
10.3
3
6
6
pH
2005
27800 1226 1430
1608
342
27
Conductivity (µS/cm)
0.176
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
Zinc (mg/l)
0.027
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
Nickel (mg/l)
0.03
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
Manganese (mg/l)
7.817
109
5
163 16331
127 <0.15
Phosphate (mg/l)
2.449
8.34 <0.2 <0.2
28.8 <0.8
<0.2
Nitrite (mg/l)
2.074
925 <0.2 <0.2
839
78
<0.2
Nitrate (mg/l)
3.0175
11
0.8
1.4
118
2
0,3
Sulphate (mg/l)
4.519
8.34
1.1
1.3
20.4
0.6
0.5
Chloride (mg/l)
0.24
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
Iron (mg/l)
10
5
59
ND
ND
ND
<0.15
0.3
13
3
<0.2
ND
As can be seen from Table 8, conductivity levels together with other pollutant parameters of
continuous effluents arising from baths 6, 7 and 10 are relatively low. Therefore, these baths are
1190
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
chosen as the reusable wastewater streams. By doing so 43 % of the continuous effluents can be
reused.
Apart from the mentioned reusable effluents of cataphoresis process, discharges generated from
boilers and cooling system can also be recovered and reused. As a result 20 % of the whole
wastewaters can be quoted as reusable effluents.
7.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Reuse potential of cataphoresis wastewaters in an automotive industry is investigated. The results of
the study indicate that around 43 % of the continuous effluents generated from cataphoresis
operations are reusable after passing through an appropriate treatment. Besides when discharges from
cooling system and boiler are added to the mentioned reusable process effluents, 20 % of the whole
wastewaters can be quoted as reusable in nature.
Therefore, the reuse of segregated cataphoresis wastewaters together with discharges of cooling
system and boiler could contribute to sustainable production once a cost-effective treatment process
is addressed.
References
1. Bakar A. F. and Halim A. A. (2013) “Treatment of automotive wastewater by coagulationflocculation using poly-aluminum chloride (PAC), ferric chloride (FeCl3) and aluminum sulfate
(alum)”, AIP Conference Proceedings, 1571, 524.
2. Cosejo C., Ormad M. P., Sarasa J. and Ovelleiro L. J. (2005) “Treatment of wastewater coming
from painting process: Application of conventional and advanced oxidation technologies” Ozone
Science and Engineering, 27, 279.
3. Sarioglu M. and Gokcek O. B. (2016) “Treatment of automotive industry wastewater using
anaerobic batch reactors: the influence of substrate/inoculum and molasses/wastewater” Process
Safety and Environmental Protection, 102, 648.
4. IDBT (2017) Turkey Automotive Competitiveness and Internal Market Prospects Demand
Dynamic Perspective in 2020, Industrial Development Bank of Turkey, January 2017.
5. Mackulak T., Bodik I., Smolinska M. Takacova A, Drtil M., Gal M. and Faberova M. (2016)
“Automotive industry wastewater treatment by mixture of enzymes” Monatsh Chem, 147, 159.
6. Mudliar R., Umare S. S., Ramteke D. S. and Wate S. R. (2009) “Energy efficient-advanced
oxidation process for treatment of cyanide containing automobile industry wastewater” Journal
of Hazardous Waste, 164, 1474.
7. AMA (2017) Automotive Industry Monthly Report, Automotive Manufacturers Association,
November 2017
8. Tejada F., Zullo J., Yen J., Guldberg T. and Bras B. (2012) “Quantifying the life cycle water
consumption of a passenger vehicle” Proceedings of 2012 SAE World Congress, Conference
and Exposition. SAE International, Troy.
9. U.S. EPA (1994) Emission Standards Division, Automobile Assembly Plant Spray Booth
Cleaning Emission Reduction Technology Review, EPA-453/R-94-029, Research Triangle Park,
North Carolina, March 1994.
10. Zhang J., Sun Y., Chang Q., Liu X. and Meng G. (2006) “Improvement of crossflow
microfiltration performances for treatment of phosphorus-containing wastewater” Desalination,
194, 182.
1191
Water and wastewater treatment and management
11. Zhu Y., Zhu T., Groetzbach M., Han H. and Ma Y. (2017) “Multi-level contact oxidation process
performance when treating automobile painting wastewater: Pollutant removal efficiency and
microbial community structures” Water, 9, 881.
1192
Protection and restoration of the environment XIV
SPONSORS
Faculty of Engineering,
Research Committee,
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
Regional Association of Solid
Waste Management Agencies of
Central Macedonia
Thessaloniki Water Supply &
Sewerage Co S.A.
ATTIKO METRO S.A.
Greek National Tourism
Organization
Ydrofili T.S.A.
Manolesakis G. and CO
Haitoglou Bros S.A.
1193