H e l l e n i c
journal of
Nursing
Science
Volume 3, Issue 3, July-September 2010
[Robotics Surgery: the new Challenge for the Medical and
Nursing Staff at the 21st century]
[Help-seeking as a threat to self-reliance and selfesteem of an individual with mental health problems: a
questionnaire survey]
[The phenomenon of infant abandonment in Europe and in
United States of America and the way to deal with it]
[Research in occupational stress among nursing staff - a
comparative study in capital and regional hospitals]
The Scientific Journal of the
Hellenic Regulatory Body of Nurses
ISSN 1791-9002
H e l l e n i c
journal of
Nursing
Science
Publisher: Dimitrios Skoutelis
Publishing Director: Aristides Daglas
Production Editor: Michalis Pitsilidis
Editor-in-Chief: Dr. Athena Kalokairinou. Associate Professor, Faculty of Nursing, National and Kapodistrian University
of Athens, Greece
Administration support: Lampros Bizas, Dimitrios Pistolas
Subscriptions (Duty managers): Konstantia Belali, Dimosthenis Salikidis
Circulation: George Drahtidis, Georgia Blanta
SCIENTIFIC EDITORIAL BOARD
GREECE
Dr. Eleni Apostolopoulou, Associate Professor, Nursing Department, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Dr. Maria Gika, Nursing Instructor, Hellenic Red Cross
Dr. Sophia Zyga, Assistant Professor, Department of Nursing, University of the Peloponnese
Dr. Panagiota Iordanou, Associate Professor, A’ Nursing Department, Technological Educational Institute of Athens (TEI)
Dr. Evmorfia Koukia, Lecturer, Nursing Department, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Theocharis Konstantinidis, Professor of Applications, Nursing Department, Technological Educational Institute of Crete,
Iraklion
Dr. Fotoula Babatsikou, Assistant Professor, A’ Nursing Department, Technological Educational Institute of Athens (TEI)
Dr. Panagiotis Prezerakos, Assistant Professor, Department of Nursing, University of the Peloponnese
ΙNTERNATIONAL
Dr. Ehrenfeld, Mally RN, PhD, Head of Nursing Dep., Associate Professor, Tel Aviv University, Dep. of Nursing, Israel
Dr. Merkouris, Anastasios RN, PhD, Associate Professor, Cyprus University of Technology
Dr. Pavlakis, Andreas Professor, Open University of Cyprus
Dr. Papadopoulos, Irena PhD, MA(Ed), BA, DipNEd, DipN, NDNCert, RGN, RM, Professor of Transcultural Health and
Nursing, Head of the Research Centre for Transcultural Studies in Health, Middlesex University, London, UK
Dr. Papastavrou, Evridiki Lecturer, Department of Nursing, Cyprus University of Technology. President, Council of
Nursing and Midwifery
Sironi, Cecilia RN, BSc, MSc Universita degli Studi dell’ Insubria-Varese, Italy
SPECIAL ADVISORS
Ioannis Ifantopoulos, Professor of Social Policy, Law School, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Greece
Ioannis Kyriopoulos, Professor of Health Economics, Dean of the National School of Public Health, Greece
Nikolaos Maniadakis, Assistant Professor of Health Economics and Management, University of Piraeus, Greece
Gerasimos Bonatsos Professor of Medicine, Head of Nursing Department, National and Kapodistrian University of
Athens, Greece
Georgios Baltopoulos, Professor, Nursing Department, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Greece
Georgios Saroglou, Professor, Nursing Department, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Greece, President
Hellenic Center for Disease Control & Prevention (KEELPNO)
Alexios Pararas, Lawyer Public Law, Legal Consultant HRBoN
Spyros Vrettos, Writer, PhD in Literature
Volume 3 - Issue 3
CONTENTS
ALEXANDROPOULOU CHRISTINA–ATHANASIA, DR. PANAGIOTOPOULOS ELIAS
Robotics Surgery: the new Challenge for the Medical
and Nursing Staff at the 21st century ..................................................63
APHRODITI E. ZARTALOUDI
Help-seeking as a threat to self-reliance and self- esteem of an
individual with mental health problems: a questionnaire survey ........67
ATHANASOPOULOU MARIA, KALOKAIRINOU ATHINA
The phenomenon of infant abandonment in Europe
and in United States of America and the way to deal with it................75
MOUSTAKA ELENI, ANTONIADOU FOTINI, MALLIAROU MARIA,
ZANTZOS E. IOANNIS, KIRIAKI CONSTANTINA, CONSTANTINIDIS Κ. THEODOROS
Research in occupational stress among nursing staff a comparative study in capital and regional hospitals..........................79
ISSN 1791-9002
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
RESEARCH PAPERS
Robotics Surgery: the new Challenge
for the Medical and Nursing Staff
at the 21st century
Alexandropoulou Christina–Athanasia
Undergraduate Student, Department of Nursing,
Technological Educational Institute of Patras, Patras, Greece,
Dr. Panagiotopoulos Elias
Laboratory Collaborator, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Technological
Applications, Technological Educational Institute of Patras, Greece,
ABSTRACT
The aim of the present research work is to study the utilisation of
robotics in surgical science. We discuss the functionality of the daVinci
robotic system , its advantages and disadvantages, as well as the
specialities in which robotics surgery is applied. The daVinci robotic
system is worldwide the first and unique system of robotics surgery so
far used for performing surgical operations. Its advantages are multiple,
including endoscopic execution of microsurgical operations, stability and
detail in execution of surgical movements etc. Nevertheless, there are
important disadvantages as well, including high cost, which are further
examined in the present work. Indeed, robotics surgery is applied in a lot
of specialities of medical science. An essential requirement for the
correct application of robotics surgery is the continuous education and
training of medical and nursing staff.
Keywords: laparoscopic surgery, daVinci robotic system , robotics
surgery, surgical console, surgical field, technology Endo-Wrist.
INTRODUCTION
Twenty years ago, an experiment started. Its aim was
the execution of surgical operations without injury,
namely with a laparoscope. Its success was so great
that it changed the course of contemporary medicine
and created a new speciality, the one of minimally
invasive surgery. With the laparoscopic surgery, incisions
of the abdomen were not necessary and the hospitalisation
of a surgical patient dramatically changed. Complete
surgical operations are performed through small
apertures not exceeding in size one centimetre.
Postsurgical pain, loss of blood and complications
almost vanished. Operations requiring in the past many
days of hospitalisation, now can be performed in one
day (Susan C. deWit, 2009).
Laparoscopic surgery was an enormous technological
and medical innovation, but in the attempts of generalising
its utilisation, certain weaknesses emerged, limiting
its development. During the laparoscopic operation,
the surgeon is guided by video-image without directly
contacting the patient. The limited operating space
and optical field and the downgrading of surgeon’s
natural senses create serious obstacles in the development
of technological applications. Some laparoscopic
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[63]
RESEARCH PAPERS
Picture 1: Depiction of the daVinci robotic system.
operations, like the one for the inflammation of the
gall-bladder, developed easily and fast. However, this
was not the case with some most demanding operations,
like removal of the spleen, intestine, stomach, etc. All
studies agreed in the conclusion that advanced
laparoscopic surgery requires time-consuming education
and certain surgical abilities. Two solutions were
proposed in order to overcome these difficulties:
technological assistance of surgeons in order to improve
their abilities or replacing them for an automatic
machine free of the human weaknesses. Research
has been done to both directions (Sejal P., 2008).
As a result, after numerous studies and much research,
we now observe a revolution in the domain of surgery,
with the approval of robotics surgery, which led to the
use of robotics systems within human body under the
guidance of computers. These robotic systems require
operation and control by a surgeon. They are remotely
controlled and they are activated by voice (Chatzidimitriou
S., 2008).
In the present report, we examine the operation of
robotics surgery, the surgical system daVinci, its
advantages and disadvantages, as well as the specialities
in which it can be applied. Continuous education and
training of the medical and nursing staff is essential
for the correct application of robotics surgery science.
HISTORICAL RETROSPECTION
Robotics surgery is a reality thanks to the robotic
technology and tele-surgery. The development of digital
analysis provides the possibility to transfer information
in distance, promoting tele-surgery. Until recently, it
was unimaginable to perform an operation from a
distance, especially without having the patient and the
surgeon in the same room. This restriction led NASA
to begin research, in order to create a medical method
for operating astronauts by doctors working on the
ground. The same concept is investigated for its
[64]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
applicability in soldiers, whose life is in danger in the
field of battle, operated by doctors remaining in safe
and distance (Konstantinidis K. et. al., 2009).
In 1985, the robotic system PUMA 560 was used to
perform a brain biopsy under guidance with computed
tomography. In 1988, the system PROBOT, which was
developed in the Imperial College of London, was used
in urological operations of the prostate. The system
ROBODOC of Integrated Surgical Systems was launched
in 1992 for precise resurfacing during arthroplasty
and replacement of the hip. Further development of
robotic systems took place from Intuitive Surgical with
the manufacturing of daVinci system and from Computer
Motion with the AESOP robot and ZEUS robot. Intuitive
Surgical bought Computer Motion in 1994 and they
interrupted development of ZEUS. At the same time,
the daVinci system was getting approval from FDA for
a broad range of surgical operations including complete
operation for prostate cancer, hysterectomy and
restoration of mitral valve, and it is used in more than
800 hospitals in America and Europe. In May 1988, Dr.
Friedrich-Wilhelm Mohr performed the first robotic
aorto-coronary by-pass in Leipzig Heart Centre,
Germany, using the daVinci system. In 2001, J. Marescaux
performed from New York an operation for inflammation
of the gall-bladder, on a patient in Strasbourg, France
(Howe RD. et. al., 1999).
In Greece, daVinci surgical system is used since 2006
in Medical Centre of Athens, while in 2008, a second
system was placed in "Ygeia" Hospital. The use of
daVinci robotic system began in September 2006, and
during the first year, more than 250 absolutely successful
surgical operations have been performed. The person
behind this initiative is Mr. Konstantinos Konstantinidis,
Assistant Professor, who successfully performed the
first robotic surgical operations in collaboration with
other doctors (Konstantinidis K. et. al., 2009). The
surgical operations that have been performed include:
■ Surgical operation Heller-Dorr for the management
of achalasia of the oesophagus.
■ Restoration of diaphragm’s hernia at Nisssen.
■ Appendicectomies and operations for the inflammation
of the gall-bladder.
■ Ectoperitonial excision of inguinal hernia and abdominal
hernia with the insertion of a plexus.
■ Insertion and removal of gastric balloon for pathogenic
obesity.
■ Excision of pancreatic tumours and renal cysts.
■ Excision of the adrenal glands.
■ Excision of the ovaries and hysterectomy.
At the same time, A. Ploumidis, N. Pardalidis, V. Poulakis
and E. Panagiotou, urologists, performed a broad range
of complete prostate surgeries using the daVinci robotic
system, sparing the nerves of the area and erectile
function, as well as nephrectomies, pelvic operations
and total excision of cysts (Diamantes Th., 2009).
RESEARCH PAPERS
OPERATION OF THE SYSTEM
OF ROBOTICS SURGERY DA VINCI
Robotic surgery is the most recent and revolutionary
development in the field of minimally invasive surgery.
It is performed by the daVinci robotic system, which
is worldwide the first and unique system of its kind at
the moment, and it was approved by the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) for performing surgical operations.
It is a product of Intuitive Surgical, combining the
surgeon’s skills with robotic technology, enhanced by
a computer (Muhlmann G. et. al., 2003).
It consists of three compartments: the robot with the
special arms, the endoscopic tower and the surgical
console (Picture 1).
The surgeon controls the system through the surgical
console, having in front an enlarged three-dimensional
image of the surgical field. The surgical console
includes handles, where the surgeon places his fingers
and moves the levers as if he uses his hands. Each
surgeon’s movement is reproduced with absolute
precision and stability in the surgical field from the
surgical arms of the robot, which is usually placed to
the left of the patient, with the surgical team. The
robot’s surgical arms use the Endo-Wrist technology,
which involves flexible wrists, bendable by the surgeon
like his own, but with even more flexibility. The endoscopic
control tower includes two video cameras, a system
of automatic picture adjustment, a high definition
video recorder and other necessary components
(Morino M. et. al., 2006).
Designing of the daVinci surgical system began in
1995 and since 2000 it is used in more than 350 hospitals
worldwide. Its use has expanded rapidly during the
past years, due to its important advantages, such as
the ability of endoscopic microsurgical operations, its
big stability and its precision in surgical movements
execution, the three-dimensional views and the
availability of more degrees of freedom in comparison
to laparoscopic tools.
However, the daVinci robotic system presents the
following disadvantages:
■ High cost (one million US dollars).
■ Big weight resulting in a slow moving ability.
■ Time for preparation before the surgical operation
requiring at least 30 minutes.
■ Necessity of assembling all the tools before their
usage.
■ Regulation of the system (Link RE. et. al., 2006).
ADVANTAGES OF ROBOTICS SURGERY
There are multiple advantages of robotic surgery in
comparison to the conventional surgical operations
(Rocco B. et. al., 2006):
■ It is a minimally invasive and minimally traumatic
method, due to the precision of the surgical movements.
■ It provides for a minimum loss of blood.
Picture 2: Depiction of execution of surgical
movements by the surgical tools of robotic arms.
■ It minimizes pain and malaise after the surgical
operation.
■ It minimizes the probability of complications during
and after the surgery.
■ It considerably decreases the time and cost of
hospitalisation.
■ It provides rapid recovery and return in daily activities.
■ It provides better aesthetic result, with the absence
of scars.
■ It provides the surgeon with three-dimensional (3D)
view of surgical field in high enlargement.
■ It ensures higher precision of surgical movements.
While the surgeon’s operations on the console are
transformed to movements of the surgical arms, the
physiologic hand tremor is eliminated and as a result,
an unprecedented surgical dexterity is achieved.
■ It provides the opportunity to perform difficult surgical
operations. The surgical tools of robotic arms can
perform all movements of the human hand (7 degrees
of freedom for movement), with greater dexterity
and precision, and they can turn almost at 360ο in
the surgical field (Picture 2).
■ It provides greater comfort for the surgeon during
the operation. Contrary to the conventional surgical
method, robotic surgery allows the surgeon to perform
operations while seated, in a carefully designed and
ergonomically excellent environment. By this way,
the surgeon’s tiredness is decreased, with very
important benefits, particularly for the cases of
challenging and long-lasting operations.
■ It provides the opportunity to prepare the operation
on the computer, using images of internal organs
of the patient derived from their laboratory workup. The surgeon can also recall these images during
the operation and be supplied with useful images.
■ The surgeon derives the sense that his eyes and
hands are into the patient’s body. He is able to see
perfectly in places with poor optical accessibility
until recently.
■ It provides for less duration of anaesthesia and
decreased risk of infection.
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[65]
RESEARCH PAPERS
IMPLEMENTATION OF ROBOTIC SURGERY
Robotics is implemented in various surgical specialities,
including general surgery, bariatric surgery, cardiac
surgery, thoracic surgery, vascular surgery, paediatric
surgery, urological surgery, pelvic surgery, kidney’s
transplantation for graft taking and endocrine surgery
(Vassiliades, 2006).
Presently, most frequently performed robotic laparoscopic
operations, include bariatric indications, inflammation
of the gall-bladder, management of diseases of the
small intestine, management of gastro-oesophageal
reflux disease, surgical management of pelvic disease,
prostate’s surgery, kidney excision, endocrine surgery
etc., thus providing important benefits to the patient
(Nikiteas Ν., 2008).
CONCLUSION
According to the present discussion, it is obvious that
robotic surgery is an innovation of the 21st century,
with multiple benefits for patients, and medical and
nursing staff. The speed of the continuous development
in robotic surgery requires continuing training and
education of the medical and nursing staff. Important
factors for the development of a robotic surgery unit
include the experience of the surgical team in laparoscopic
operations, as well as the institution’s infrastructure
(Patel VR., 2006).
On the other hand, nursing is in front of a new challenge.
Nurses are charged with new responsibilities, targeting
to provide a high quality clinical care to the patients
that will be subjected to this new surgical technique.
Importantly, nursing staff will still be irreplaceable for
the patient, because nurses bridge the gap between
technology and science, confronting human pain with
human hope.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Howe RD. and Matsuoka Y., 1999. Robotics for Surgery, Annual
[66]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
Review Biomedical Engineering, 01:213.
2. Link RE., Bhayani SB. and Kavoussi LR., 2006. A prospective
comparison of robotic and laparoscopic pyeloplasty, Ann Surg.,
243(4):486-491.
3. Morino M., Pellegrino L., Giaccone C., Garrone C. and Bebecchi
F., 2006. Randomized clinical trial of robot-assisted versus
laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication, Br J Surg., 93(5): 553558.
4. Muhlmann G., Klauss A., Kirchmayer W., Wykypiel H., Unger
A., Holler E., Nehoda H., Aigner F. and Weiss HG., 2003. DaVinci
robotic-assisted laparoscopic bariatric surgery: is it justified
in a routine setting?, Obes Surg., 13(6): 848-854.
5. Patel VR., March 2006. Essential elements to the establishment
and design of a successful robotic surgery programme,
International Journal of Medical Robotics, 2(1): 28-35.
6. Rocco B., Matei DV., Melegari S., Ospina JC., Mazzoleni F.,
Errico G., Mastropasqua M., Santoro L., Detti S. and deCobellio,
2009. Robotic vs open prostatectomy in a laparoscopically naïve
centre: a matched-pair analysis, Division of Urology, European
Institute of Oncology, Milan, Italy.
7. Sejal P. Dharia and Tommasco F., April 2008. Robotics in
reproductive medicine, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology,
University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, Alabama.
8. Susan C. deWit, 2009. Medical-Surgical Nursing: Concepts
and Practice, 95.
9. Vassiliades TA Jr., March 2006. Robotics in cardiac surgery,
International Journal of Medical Robotics, 2(1): 4-6.
10. Diamantes Th.., 21-23 May 2009. Robotics Bariatric Surgery.
Congress of Laparoendoscopic Surgery and International
Symposium: ‘Collaboration for the development of Surgery’,
Athens.
11. Konstantinidis K., Chiridis S., Jiarchos A., Anastasakou K.,
Sampalis G.., Borias M., Georgiou M. and Thomas D.., 23-24
February 2009. The surgical robot DAVINCI at the General
Surgery: Two years later from the beginning of the first
programme of robotics surgery in Greece. 1ο Pan-Hellenic
Congress of Robotics, Athens.
12. Nikiteas N., 17-19 April 2008. Robotics Surgery of abdomen
– Present and Future. 3ο Pan-Hellenic Congress & International
Forum of the Hellenic College of Surgeons, Athens.
13. Chatzidimitriou S., 17-19 April 2008. The digital communication
and computer science at the service of surgery today and at
the future. 3ο Pan-Hellenic Congress & International Forum
of the Hellenic College of Surgeons, Athens.
RESEARCH PAPERS
Help-seeking as a threat to self-reliance and
self- esteem of an individual with mental
health problems: a questionnaire survey
Aphroditi E. Zartaloudi
PhD, MSc, RN, Sismanoglio General Hospital, Athens, Greece, Department of Psychiatry
ABSTRACT
Background: Individuals differ whether they are healthy or not. They
have different personalities and lifestyles, so that consequences of an
illness are perceived in individual ways. Therefore, they use to seek
different types of help.
Aim: To explore the way in which self-reliance and self-respect affect
help-seeking behaviour of individuals suffering from mental health
problems.
Method: A self-report questionnaire was administered and completed
by a total of 290 participants who sought help from the Community
Mental Health Centre (CMHC) during 2003-2007.
Participants: The total sample was divided into those who had sought
help from other mental health care service prior to their visit to CMHC
(former visitors: group A) and those who visited a mental health care
service for the first time in their live (first-time-visitors, group B).
Results: Subjects who totally believed that help-seeking is an
acknowledgment of one’s insufficiency and inability, had the most
positive attitudes towards help- seeking from a mental health
professional, the most positive orientation towards the utilization of
social support network and the greatest fear for mental health
interventions, in both groups A and B. Moreover, in group B, the
aforementioned acknowledgement was directly related with subject’s
positive opinions about psychiatry, but these patients would also wait
for longer until they ask for help for their first time.
Conclusions: Exploring the factors affecting the process of helpseeking may offer useful information to the mental health
professionals, enabling them to detect the individuals with mental
health problems and to intervene in earlier stages.
Key- words: help-seeking, mental health, self- esteem, self-reliance
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[67]
RESEARCH PAPERS
INTRODUCTION
Despite the availability of mental health services, a
great number of individuals don’t cope with their needs
and problems or they deal with them much later, when
their symptoms are more severe. The continuously
increasing focus of psychiatry on early intervention
underscores the importance of identifying delays in
help-seeking and providing appropriate and sufficient
mental healthcare, as well as the significance of early
referral of those with mental health problems to
specialized services.
People are different, either in health or in illness. They
belong to different cultures and they have different
personalities and personal histories, all of which make
them perceive their diseases in a specific manner.
They cope with the consequences of diseases in individual
ways and thus they require different types of help.
Some of them do not want anyone to help them; others
want more help than could sensibly be expected for a
certain degree of impairment or suffering that their
disease produces.
The exploration of some personality traits which possibly
influence help- seeking behaviour from a Community
Mental Health Centre (CMHC) or other specialized
mental health service may help health professionals
understand the factors affecting the process of helpseeking.
Only a small percentage of individuals seek professional
psychological help (Cui & Vaillant, 1997; Horwitz, 1987).
If this phenomenon is not due to a lack of the actual
need, it should highly concern community members
and health professionals.
This body of literature related to help-seeking pathways
examine the concept of individual’s “need” in the context
of other factors affecting the utilization of health
services. This study is a part of an effort to examine
other dimensions of help-seeking behaviour of community
residents with mental health problems, beyond individuals’
needs, as well as the factors contributing to an individual’s
unmet need. Better knowledge of the contributing
factors will help mental health professionals to
understand the factors that may inhibit or promote
early detection of individuals suffering from mental
health problems and early intervention in order to
meet their needs.
REVIEWING THE LITERATURE: PERSONALITY
CHARACTERISTICS AND HELP-SEEKING
There are many personality traits that affect helpseeking behaviour and attitudes (Feldman et al., 1999).
The characteristics that have been extensively studied
in this body of literature are: self-respect, self-esteem,
locus of control, shyness and authoritarianism, autonomy,
dominance, introversion, secrecy, need for success,
dependency, conservatism, rigidity and individuality.
Personal factors leading to higher rates of help-seeking
[68]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
or more positive attitudes towards receiving specialized
help include greater academic performance and
achievement (Berdie & Stein, 1966; Kirk, 1973), older
age, female gender (Sharp & Kirk, 1974; Tracey et al.,
1984), internal locus of control (Fischer & Turner,
1970; Robbins, 1981) and low self-esteem (Nadler,
1986; Raviv et al., 1991).
Individuals may believe that they control all situations
in their lives (internal locus of control) or that these
situations are controlled by others (external locus of
control). Persons may believe that they can control
the status of his health (e.g. "I am directly responsible
for my health"), or that their health depend on fate
(e.g. “Whether I am healthy or not is a matter of luck”)
or they may consider their health as being controlled
by some other serious circumstances (e.g. “I can do
only what my doctor tells me”) (Halter, 2004). All of
these beliefs seem to influence whether a person
may try to change his behaviour or not, as well as
the type of communication the individual may require
from health professionals. For example, if a health
professional encourages a person -who seems to
believe in an overall external locus of control- to
change his lifestyle, that person is difficult to cooperate
(Ogdenn, 2004).
Individuals who don’t seek help are likely to believe
that they are able to change things they don’t like and
solve their problems on their own (Simoni et al., 1991).
Halgin and Weaver (1986) and Halgin, Weaver and
Donaldson (1985) examined the advantages and
disadvantages of receiving psychotherapy. Many
researchers concluded that college students and
patients perceived similar advantages and disadvantages
in psychotherapy. The perceived benefits of psychotherapy
were: improved self- knowledge, relief from anxiety
and problem-solving. The disadvantages were: the
time and money required, coping with painful issues,
and the belief that help-seeking is an admission of
weakness.
Raviv, Raviv and Arnon (1991) point out that helpseeking from mental health professionals may lead
to the feeling of embarrassment. It is possible that the
extent to which an individual’s self-respect is threatened
by help-seeking is a crucial element of this process
(Wills & De Paulo, 1991).
There is a correlation between dependency and likelihood
of an individual to seek help (Dawkins et al., 1980;
O'Neill & Bornstein, 1970). The dependent people feel
helpless and seek guidance and support from others
(Bornstein, 1992; Bornstein et al., 1993; Roy-Byrne et
al., 2000).
Students who seek counselling and those who don’t
differ as far as autonomy and self-efficacy are
concerned (Anderson et al., 2006; Apostal, 1968).
The clients who seek help are less judgemental,
more intuitive, introspective and sensitive. Also, they
RESEARCH PAPERS
are more likely to internalize their problems and feel
they have less control over them, compared to nonclients (Mendelsohn & Kirk, 1962; Simoni et al., 1991).
They also indicate greater knowledge of their emotions
and reactions (Rickwood & Braithwaite, 1994). Selfreliance is one of the barriers that delay help-seeking.
Denial, repression and control of emotions are key
features of stoicism, leading people to believe they
should cope with their problems alone and suffer
silently, so they are more likely to delay help- seeking
until symptoms become more severe (Tang et al.,
2007).
West et al (1991) reported that one of the major barriers
is that individuals don’t feel comfortable to reveal their
TABLE 1: Sociodemographic characteristics of groups A and B (Ν=290)
N
GROUP A
%
N
GROUP B
%
P
Gender
Male
35
26.1
30
19.2
99
134
73.9
100.0
126
156
80.8
100.0
Single
66
49.3
78
50.0
Married
Divorced / widowed
40
28
29.9
20.9
60
18
38.5
11.5
134
100.0
156
100.0
Elementary
17
12.7
31
19.9
High school
College /university graduates
50
67
37.3
50.0
44
81
28.2
51.9
134
100.0
156
100.0
Parental family & With relatives
42
31.3
46
29.5
Own family
Lives alone
58
34
43.3
25.4
69
41
44.2
26.3
134
100.0
156
100.0
Professionals
31
24.4
52
33.3
Medium/small business owners/
clerks Skilled workers
Pensioners & housekeepers
37
36
29.1
28.3
41
38
26.3
24.4
23
127
18.1
100.0
25
156
16.0
100.0
Full time
45
33.6
74
47.4
Part time
None
21
53
15.7
39.6
26
56
16.7
35.9
15
134
11.2
100.0
0
156
0.0
100.0
Female
TOTAL
0.204
Marital status
TOTAL
0.063
Education
TOTAL
0.128
Lifestyle
TOTAL
0.942
Occupation
Students
TOTAL
0.438
Employment
None / for psychiatric reasons
TOTAL
0.000
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[69]
RESEARCH PAPERS
TABLE 2: Diagnostic categories in group A & B
Diagnostic
categories
Affective disorders
Neurotic stress related &
somatoform disorders &
Personality disorder
Relationship problems &
Schizophrenia and delusional disorder
TOTAL
N
71
GROUP A
%
53.0%
N
72
GROUP B
%
46.1%
N
143
%
49.3%
43
32.1%
50
32.1%
93
32.1%
20
14.9%
34
21.8%
54
18.6%
134
100.0%
156
100.0%
290
P=0.284
personal problems to a stranger. Emotional openness
is another variable related to personality traits and
associated to help-seeking attitudes.
Neuroticism is a personality trait that affects individuals’
perceptions about their vulnerability to the symptoms
and the seriousness of their health status (Brown &
Moskowitz, 1997; Costa & McCrae, 1987; Katon &
Walker, 1998; Neitzert et al., 1997). Individuals may
experience tension, anxiety, and agitation. These
feelings are reflected in their tendency to exaggerate
minor symptoms. They are more likely to complain
about symptoms and consider themselves vulnerable
to diseases (Brownhill, 2003; DiMatteo & Martin, 2006;
McClure et al., 1982). Other people experiencing the
same symptoms may fail to notice them at all.
The meaning that individuals attribute to each of their
symptoms may be a crucial factor. All individuals do
not react to a disease in the same way. While some
patients are willing to seek help even for minor symptoms,
others are unwilling to do so even for life-threatening
diseases (Mechanic, 1982). Indeed, people with the
same illness may have a completely different experience
of the situation and a completely different attitude,
especially regarding the degree to which the cause of
the disease is involved.
People who seek help are likely to have also sought
help in the past for emotional problems (Dew et al.,
1988). This finding indicates that an individual tends
to seek help all of the times (Henderson et al., 1992).
These individuals don’t accept living in situations they
don’t like and they tend to talk to others (Sorgaard et
al., 1999), including health professionals (Sherbourne,
1988), about their problems.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This research was conducted in the Community Mental
Health Center (CMHC), the last of its kind, which was
established in 2000 to serve a borough of the broader
area of Athens, 21 years after establishment of the
[70]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
TOTAL
100.0%
df = 2
first Community Mental Health Centre. The CMHC is
administered by the University of Athens and it includes
the Open Psychosocial Care Clinic, the Outreach
Program and the Day Care Centre. A multiprofessional
team staffs the CMHC.
The purpose of the present study was to explore the
way in which self-reliance and self-respect affect helpseeking behaviour of individuals with mental health
problems.
Two hundred and ninety individuals who sought help
from the CMHC during a 4-years period, from 1/1/2003
to 12/31/2007, who agreed to participate in the survey
and completed a questionnaire. The participants were
informed about the purpose of our research. The
questionnaires administered took 35 to 50 minutes to
complete. The participants were told that there are no
right or wrong answers. The researcher was available
to answer any question. Participation in this study was
voluntary and the participants were free to withdraw
at any point. The data were strictly confidential and no
names, codes, or any means that could reveal the
identity of the participants were used. Only the researcher
had access to the data. The participants completed an
informed consent sheet.
The researcher conducted a pilot study before the
actual distribution of the questionnaires. Twenty
volunteers participated in the pilot study. Feedback
and comments were obtained from each participant
so that the final version of the instrument should be
of appropriate length, clear, and free from biased
language. The questionnaire was translated from
English to Greek and back to English. The final version
was checked by two bilingual professionals for possible
inaccuracies in translation.
The population was divided in two groups: individuals
who had sought help from other mental health care
services before visiting our Centre (group A: former
visitors) and individuals whose visit to the Centre was
the first contact with a mental health service in their
RESEARCH PAPERS
lives (first-time-visitors, group B). The variables included
in the questionnaire are presented below:
Demographic Data: The demographic questionnaire
consisted of questions regarding the participant’s
gender, educational level, occupation, marital status,
lifestyle, and employment.
Duration of untreated disorder: The untreated period
for each individual was defined as the time (in months)
between the onset of psychopathological symptoms
and the time when the suffering individuals first
contacted a mental health service or a professional.
Diagnostic categories (information taken from medical
records): Organic brain syndrome, Schizophrenia and
delusional disorders, Affective disorders, Neurotic
stress related & somatoform & Personality disorders,
Relationship problems, Certificates and information,
Substance abuse.
Attitudes toward Seeking Professional Psychological
Help scale (ATSPPHS) is developed by Fischer &
Turner (1970). ATSPPH scale consists of 29 items
that are related to the Recognition of Personal Need
for Professional Help, the Tolerance of Stigma Associated
with seeking Psychological Help, and the Interpersonal
Openness and Confidence in Mental Health Professional.
Factor analysis in the population of community residents
who sought help from the C.M.H.C during 2003-2007
(Zartaloudi, 2008), resulted in 4 factors/subscales;
FACTOR 1: Assertiveness toward help-seeking; FACTOR
2: Isolation; FACTOR 3: Ambivalence toward helpseeking; FACTOR 4: Stigma. Higher scores represent
more positive attitudes toward seeking professional
help for psychological problems.
Orientation toward Utilization of Social Resources
Scale (OTUSRS) is a 20-item scale developed by Vaux,
Burda & Stewart (1986). OTUSRS is designed to measure
people’s orientation to having a social network, by
assessing their feelings about advisability or usefulness
of seeking social help, their past history of having
actually sought social help, and the extent to which
they feel that others cannot be trusted. Factor analysis
in the population of the community residents who
sought help from the C.M.H.C during 2003-2007
(Zartaloudi, 2008) resulted in 3 factors/subscales;
FACTOR 1: Interpersonal communication; FACTOR 2:
Distrust; FACTOR 3: Isolation. A higher score was
indicative of a positive social-network orientation, and
a lower score was indicative of a negative one.
Thoughts about Psychotherapy Survey (TAPS) is a 19item scale developed by Kushner & Sher (1989). This
measure assesses fears about therapist competence,
stigma concerns and fear of change. Factor analysis
in the population of the community residents who
sought help from the CMHC during 2003-2007 (Zartaloudi,
2008) resulted in 2 factors/subscales; FACTOR 1: Fear
of change; FACTOR 2: Fear about therapist competence.
Low scores indicate fewer concerns about therapy
while higher scores indicate greater concerns.
Opinions about Psychiatry is a 20-item scale, on which
factor analysis was conducted (Zartaloudi, 2008). The
20 items were divided into three subscales/factors;
FACTOR 1: Effectiveness of Psychiatry; FACTOR 2:
Ineffectiveness of Psychiatry; and FACTOR 3: Stigma.
Lower score is indicative of more positive opinions
about Psychiatry.
The participants were asked about their opinion regarding
the statement “I then believed that help-seeking was
an admission of insufficiency, weakness and inability
to solve my problems on my own” with possible answers
1=totally disagree, 2= disagree, 3= not agree or disagree,
4= agree and 5=totally agree.
STATISTICS
A statistical analysis was performed by the use of the
Statistical Package for Social Sciences XIII (Norusis,
2005). Student’s t-test was performed to examine
whether significant differences existed between means.
Chi square tests were used for comparisons between
the groups on several categorical variables. Statistical
procedures included descriptive statistics, t-test,
ANOVA, Mann Whitney test, Kruskal-Wallis test, and
Fisher's Exact test.
RESULTS
The social demographic and clinical characteristics
of all individuals completing the questionnaire (n: 290)
were analysed. Group A included 35 men (26.1%) and
99 women (73.9%) and Group B included 30 men (19.2%)
and 126 women (80.8%). Significant differences were
noticed in one out of six variables. The first-timers
(group B) were full-time employed more often than
individuals of group A. In group A, individuals were not
employed due to psychiatric reasons to a greater extent
in comparison to individuals of group B. No difference
was noticed between the two groups regarding educational
level, marital and occupational status and lifestyle.
The results are shown in Table 1.
The current diagnostic categories of group A and B by
gender are presented in Table 2. There is no significant
difference between diagnostic categories and groups.
A proportion of 88% of group A and 76.3% of group B
agreed or totally agreed with the statement “I then
believed that help-seeking was an admission of
insufficiency, weakness and inability to solve my
problems on my own”. In group A, there was a significant
correlation between the individual’s acknowledgement
of insufficiency and incapability and his/her attitude
toward seeking professional psychological help (p=0.000;
Kruskal Wallis test), his/her fear about therapy (p=0.001;
Kruskal Wallis test) and his/her orientation toward
Utilization of Social Resources Scale (p=0.000; ANOVA).
In group B, there was a significant correlation between
the individual’s acknowledgements of insufficiency
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[71]
RESEARCH PAPERS
and incapability and his/her attitude toward seeking
professional psychological help (p=0.000; Kruskal
Wallis test), his/her fear about therapy (p=0.001; Kruskal
Wallis test), his/her orientation toward Utilization of
Social Resources Scale (p=0.045; Kruskal Wallis test),
his/her Opinions about Psychiatry (p=0.000; Kruskal
Wallis test) and the duration of untreated disorder
(p=0.034; Kruskal Wallis test).
Individuals, who totally believed that help-seeking
is an acknowledgment of insufficiency and inability
had the most positive attitudes towards help- seeking
from a mental health expert, the most positive
orientation towards the utilization of a social support
network and the greatest fear about therapy. Those
who neither agreed nor disagreed achieved the next
higher scores in these scales both in group A and
group B. Moreover, in group B, the participants with
a stronger he belief that help-seeking is an
acknowledgement of weakness, were more positive
in their opinions about psychiatry, but they waited
longer before seeking help for the first time.
DISCUSSION
Psychic therapy is often related to “lunacy or madness”
or it is perceived as an element of mental or personality
weakness, decreasing individual’s self-respect. Most
explanations given for the individual’s unwillingness
to ask for help are related to the fact that the person
wants to consider himself as independent and selfsufficient. In general, help-seeking is perceived as an
acknowledgment of an individual’s weakness and
inability, an admission that leads to severe cognitive
and emotional consequences for the person who asks
for help (Franklin, 1992).
The individuals who totally believed that help-seeking
is an acknowledgment of insufficiency and inability
had the most positive attitudes towards seeking help
from a mental health specialist, the most positive
orientation towards utilization of a social support
network and the greatest fear for mental treatment
due to their insecurity and low self-confidence. Those
individuals were feeling vulnerable, not being able to
control their lives. Moreover, in group B, the participants’
with a stronger belief that help-seeking is an
acknowledgement of weakness were more positive in
their opinions about psychiatry but they showed prolonged
delay in seeking help for their first time. People who
need help often fail to utilize the appropriate resources
because help-seeking is a direct admission of insufficiency
(Simmons, 2000). This means that the individuals were
“open” to professionals’ and non-professionals’
interventions and opinions because they felt insufficient
and believed that their inadequacy was the cause of
their problems. They also looked for “a way out” but
at the same time their self-respect was threatened
and these feelings delayed them from making the final
[72]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
step and actually ask for help. Negative judgments
from others may inhibit individuals from seeking help,
despite that they could benefit from receiving appropriate
specialized services.
Many studies have shown that moral values like
competitiveness, self-reliance and independence, that
are dominate in western culture, don’t promote helpseeking that can be regarded as a sign of dependence.
From this point of view, help- seeking can be regarded
as “an act of immaturity, passivity, even inability” that
must be “avoided”. This happens despite the fact that
help-receiving is sometimes acknowledged as useful
and necessary. According to this model, the individual’s
willingness or unwillingness to ask for help depends
on his personal beliefs and self image. By asking for
help, the individual acknowledges his inability to manage
a failure and his self-esteem is wounded. A person
considers help-seeking to be a threatening or supportive
experience, depending on his/her personal and social
characteristics. Women are expected to be more willing
than men to realize and admit that they need help
(Cepeda-Benito & Short, 1998; Halgin et al, 1987; Kelly
& Achter, 1995).
When the individual makes the decision to seek (or
receive) help from a mental health specialist, he/she
has previously formed the intention of doing this.
There is a positive relationship between attitudes
towards help-seeking and help- seeking intentions
(Kelly & Achter, 1995). Intention is the most important
factor affecting the appearance of a certain behavior.
Attitudes towards help-seeking were the most significant
factor influencing the intentions to seek help from a
mental heath specialist (Mackenzie, Gekoski & Knox,
2007). An intention is serious when it is accompanied
by a clear understanding of the problem, an organized
action plan and a high degree of self-efficiency
(Stretcher et al., 1995). Self-efficiency is the individual’s
subjective evaluation of the self regarding personal
abilities (e.g., especially regarding his/her ability to
behave in certain ways or to achieve his/her goals)
(DiMatteo & Martin, 2006).
Self-reliance (when a person prefers to solve his
problems on his own) is one of the barriers of helpseeking. The development of the individual’s intention
to seek help can be influenced by personal factors
(e.g. duration of the problem, feelings of loss of selfreliance, the belief that persons who solve their
problems on their own are more worthy). Receiving
help affects a person’s self-esteem and self-respect
(Wills & De Paulo, 1991). According to Fischer, Winer
and Abramowitz (1983), help-seeking can be “a
threatening experience because it creates a superiorityinferiority relationship between the one giving and
the one receiving help and conflict with values like
self-reliance and independence reinforced during
the whole process of our socialization”. A source of
RESEARCH PAPERS
help can also be supportive. People are more likely
to seek help if they regard the source of help as
supportive and less likely if they regard it as threatening
for their self-esteem.
Help-seeking behaviors depend on whether individuals
attribute their need for help to internal or external
factors. In the first case, when the need for help is
attributed to internal factors (e.g. I need help because
I am incompetent), people are less likely to seek help
depending on the extent to which their self-esteem is
threatened. On the other hand, if they attribute the
need for help to external factors (e.g. I need help
because this is a difficult decision) they are more likely
to seek help as their self-esteem is not wounded.
Being expressive about personal inabilities, vulnerability,
emotions, familiarity or personal need for help and
support is an element of weakness (O’Neil, 1981).
Raviv, Raviv and Arnon (1991) point out that helpseeking from experts can lead to embarrassment. It
is possible that the extent to which the individual’s
self-respect is threatened is a central point in the
help-seeking process. People with high self-respect
are more sensitive, feel more threatened and seek
help less often compared to people with low selfrespect, who are more likely to seek help (Wills & De
Paulo, 1991).
STUDY LIMITATIONS
Our results cannot be invariably generalized to other
populations and other social settings. The study sample
had specific socio-economical characteristics and the
results cannot be generalized to populations with other
socio-economical conditions.
Given the delay that certain patients apparently showed
in visiting the Community Mental Health Centre (which
is especially true for group A, where individuals had
previously visited other mental health services) and
the self-report nature of the answers given by the
participants when they complete a questionnaire, there
are limitations regarding recall and accuracy of certain
information which is retrospectively collected. In
individuals of group A there is also a limitation regarding
their previous experience of treatment, possibly
influencing the recall and accuracy of information. A
future study could use interviews with the family
members so that collected data can be duplicated.
CONCLUSION
A great number of people are being identified in
epidemiological studies as fulfilling the criteria for a
mental disorder but not receiving treatment.
The decision to seek treatment is a complex matter
driven by a number of factors, such as the severity and
chronicity, the disability produced by the disorder, the
perception that treatment will be effective or not and
some personality traits. A better understanding of the
contributing factors that promote treatment seeking
will help health professionals to adopt more effective
intervention strategies.
Exploring the influence of self-reliance and self-esteem
of an individual with mental health problems to his/her
pathway towards the appropriate therapeutic interventions
may help mental health professionals to understand
the obstacles towards the early detection and intervention
regarding mental disorders.
REFERENCES
1. Anderson, C.M., Robins, C.S., Greeno, C.G., Cahalane, H., Copeland,
V.C., Andrews, R.M., 2006. Why lower income mothers do not
engage with the formal mental health care system: perceived
barriers to care. Qual Health Res 16, 926-932.
2. Apostal, R.A., 1968. Comparison of counselees and noncounselees
with type of problem controlled. Journal of Counseling Psychology
15, 407-410.
3. Berdie, R.F., Stein, J., 1966. A comparison of new university
students who do and do not seek counseling. Journal of Counseling
Psychology 13, 310-317.
4. Bornstein, R.F., Krukonis, A.B., Manning, K.A., Mastrosimone,
C.C., Rossner, S.C., 1993. Interpersonal dependency and health
service utilization in a college student sample. Journal of Social
and Clinical Psychology 12, 262-279.
5. Bornstein, R.F.,1992. The dependent personality: Developmental,
social and clinical perspectives. Psychological Bulletin 112, 323.
6. Brown, K.W., Moskovitz, D.S., 1997. Does unhappiness make you
sick? The role of affect and neuroticism in the experience of
common physical symptoms. Journal of Personality and Social
Psychology 72, 907-917.
7. Brownhill, S., 2003. Intensified constraint: The battle between
individual and social forces influencing hidden depression in
men. Thesis University of New South Wales.
8. Cepeda-Benito, A., Short, P., 1988. Self – concealment avoidance
of psychological services and perceived likehood of seeking
professional help. Journal of Counseling Psychology 45, 68-74.
9. Costa, P.T., Jr, McCrae, R.R., 1987. Neuroticism, somatic complaints
and disease: Is the hark worse than the bire? Journal of Personality
55, 299-316.
10. Cui, X., Vaillant, G.E., 1997. Does depression generate negative
life events? J Nerv Ment Dis 185, 145-150.
11. Dawkins, M.P., Terry, J.A., Dawkins, M.P., 1980. Personality and
life style factors in utilization of mental health services.
Psychological Reports 46, 383-386.
12. Dew, M.A., Dunn, L.O., Bromet, E.J., Schulberg, H.C., 1988.
Factors affecting help – seeking during depression in a community
sample. Journal of Affective Disorders 14, 223-234.
13. DiMatteo, R.M., Martin, L.R., 2006. Εισαγωγή στην Ψυχολογία της
Υγείας. Ελληνικά Γράμματα, Αθήνα.
14. Feldman, P., Cohen, S., Doyle, W., Skoner, D., Gwaltney, J., 1999.
The impact of personality on the reporting of unfounded symptoms
and illness. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 77 (2),
370-378.
15. Fischer, E.H., Turner, J.L., 1970. Orientations to seeking
professional help: Development and research utility of an attitude.
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 35, 79 – 90.
16. Fischer, E.H., Winer, D., Abramowitz, S.I., 1983. Seeking professional
help for psychological problems Development and evaluation
of a youth mental health community awareness campaign –
The Compass Strategy. BMC Public Health 6, 215-220.
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[73]
RESEARCH PAPERS
17. Franklin, A.J., 1992. Therapy with African American men. Families
in society. The Journal of Contemporary Human Services 73(6),
350-355.
18. Halgin, R.P., Weaver, D.D., Edell, W.S., Spencer, P.G., 1987.
Relation of depression and help seeking history to attitudes to
ward seeking professional psychological help. Journal of
Counceling Psychology 34, 177 – 185.
19. Halgin, R.P., Weaver, D.D., 1986. Salient beliefs about obtaining
psychotherapy. Psychotherapy in private practice 4, 23 – 31.
20. Halgin, R.P., Weaver, D.D., Donaldson, P.E., 1985. College students’
perceptions of the advantages and disadvantages of obtaining
psychotherapy. Journal of Social Service Research 8, 75 – 86.
21. Halter, M.J., 2004. The stigma of seeking care and depression.
Archives of psychiatry nursing xviii (5), 178-184.
22. Henderson, J., Alec Pollard, C., Jacobi, K., Merkel, W., 1992.
Help - seeking patterns of community residents with depressive
symptoms. Journal of Affective Disorders 26, 157-162.
23. Horwitz, A.V., 1987. Help- seeking processes and mental health
services. In Mechanic, D. (Ed.), Improving mental health services:
What the social sciences can tell us? New Directions for Mental
Health Services, no. 36. CA: Jossey- Boss, San Francisco.
24. Katon, W.J., Walker, E.A., 1998. Medically unexplained symptoms
in primary care. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 59, 15-21.
25. Kelly, A.E., Achter, J.A., 1995. Self – concealment and attitudes
toward counseling in university students. Journal of Counseling
Psychology 42, 40-46.
26. Kirk, B., 1973. Characteristics of users of counseling centers
and psychiatric services on a college campus. Journal of
Counseling Psychology 20, 463-470.
27. Kushner, M.G., Scher, K.L., 1989. Fear of psychological treatment
and its relation to mental health service avoidance. Professional
Psychology: Research and Practice 22, 196-203.
28. Mackenzie, C.S., Gekoski, W.L., Knox, V.J., 2007. Age, gender,
and the underutilization of mental health services: The influence
of help-seeking attitudes. Aging and Mental Health 10(6), 574582.
29. McClure, R., Mitchell, C., Greschuck, D., 1982. Self – concept
and identification of students needing a counseling center.
Psychological Reports 50, 487-490.
30. Mechanic, D., 1982. The epidemiology of illness behavior and
its relationship to physical and psychological distress. In Mechanic,
D. (ed.), Symptoms, illness Behavior and Help-seeking. Neale
Watson Academic Publication, New York.
31. Mendelsohn, G.A., Kirki, B.A., 1962. Personality differences
between students who do and do not use a counseling facility.
Journal of Counseling Psychology 9, 341-346.
32. Nadler, A., 1986. Self-esteem in the seeking and receiving of
help. Theoretical and empirical perspectives Progress in
Experimental Personality Research 14, 115 – 163.
33. Neitzert, C.S., Davis, C., Kennedy, S.H., 1997. Personality factors
related to the prevalence of somatic symptoms and medical
complaints in a health student population. British Journal of
Medical Psychology 70, 93-101.
34. O’Neil, J.M., 1981. Male sex role conflicts, sexism masculinity:
Psychological implications for men, women and the counseling
psychologist. The Counseling Psychologist 9, 61-80.
[74]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
35. O’Neil, R.M., Bornstein, R.F, 1990. Oral-dependence and gender:
Factors in help-seeking response set and self-reported
psychopathology in psychiatric inpatients. Journal of Personality
Assessment 55, 28-40.
36. Ogdeνn, J., 2004. Ψυχολογία της Υγείας. Επιστημονικές εκδόσεις
Παρισιανού, Αθήνα.
37. Raviv, A., Raviv, A., Arnon, G., 1991. Psychological counseling
over the ratio: Listening motivations and the threat to selfesteem. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 21, 253 – 270.
38. Rickwood, D.J., Braithwaite, V.A., 1994. Social-psychological
factors affecting help-seeking for emotional problems. Social
Science and Medicine 39, 563-572.
39. Robbins, J.M., 1981. Lay attribution of personal problems and
psychological help- seeking. Social Psychiatry 16, 1-9.
40. Roy-Byrne, P.P., Stang, P., Wittchen, U., Ustun, B., Walters, E.E.,
Kessler, R.C., 2000. Lifetime panic-depression comorbidity in
the National Comorbidity Survey. British Journal of Psychiatry
176, 229-235.
41. Sharp, W.H., Krick, B.A., 1974. A longitudinal study of who seeks
counseling when. Journal of Counseling Psychology 21, 43-50.
42. Sherbourne, C.D., 1988. The role of social support and life stress
in use of mental health services. Social Science and Medicine
27, 1393-1400.
43. Simmons, J., 2000. Kid’s mental health tackled. Counseling
Today, 1-26.
44. Simoni, J.M., Adelman, H.S., Nelson, P., 1991. Perceived control,
causality, expectations and help-seeking behavior. Counseling
Psychology Quarterly 4, 37-44.
45. Sorgaard, K., Sandanger, I., Sorensen, T., Ingebrigtsen, G.,
Dalgard, O., 1999. Mental disorders and referrals to mental
health specialists by general practitioners. Soc Psychiatry
Psychiatr Epidemiol 34, 128-135.
46. Strecher, V.J., Seijts, G.H., Kok, G.J., Latham, G.P. et al., 1995.
Good setting as a strategy for health behavior change. Health
Education Quarterly 22, 190-200.
47. Tang, Y., Sevigny, R., Mao, P., Jiang, F., Cai, Z., 2007. Help-seeking
Behaviors of Chinese Patients with Schizophrenia Admitted to
a Psychiatric Hospital. Adm Policy Ment Health & Ment Health
Serv Res 34, 101-107.
48. Tracey, T.J., Sherry, P., Bauer, G.P., Robins, T.H., Todaro, L.,
Briggs, S., 1984. Help seeking as a function of student characteristics
and program description: A logit-loglinear analysis. Journal of
Counseling Psychology 31, 54-62.
49. Vaux, H. Burda, P., Stewart, D., 1986. Orientation towards utilizing
support resources. Journal of Community Psychology 14,159170.
50. West, J.S. Kayser, L., Overton, P., Saltmarsh, R., 1991. Student
perceptions that inhibit the initiation of counseling. The School
Counselor 39, 76-83.
51. Wills, T.A., DePaulo, B.M., 1991. Interpersonal analysis of the
help-seeking process. In Snyder, C.R., Forsyth, D.R. (Eds),
Handbook of social and clinical psychology: The health perspective.
Pergamon Press, New York.
52. Zartaloudi, A., 2008. Factors affecting first contact with Community
Mental Health Centre. Dissertation. National and Kapodistrian
University of Athens. Faculty of Nursing.
RESEARCH PAPERS
The phenomenon of infant abandonment
in Europe and in United States of America
and the way to deal with it
Athanasopoulou Maria, RN, MSc, PhD(c), General Maternity Hospital “Elena Venizelou”
Kalokairinou Athina, Assistant Professor of Nursing, University of Athens
SUMMARY
From Oidipodas’ time, whose parents abandoned him in Kithairona
Mountain so that Pythia’s oracle would not be true, up to the Moses myth,
whose Israeli mother placed him on a papyrus on the Niles’ edges so that
the Pharaoh’s of Egypt daughter could find him, history has shown that
the phenomenon of infant abandonment has been a repeating reality. The
practice of infant abandonment right after their birth is a phenomenon
involving a variety of motives depending on several socio-economic
factors. Nevertheless, in the recent years there has been a rising interest
in illustrating the reasons for the persistence of this phenomenon in
contemporary society, despite changes in its structure and norms.
Aim: The aim of the present study is to investigate the infant
abandonment phenomenon, the factors leading a mother to abandon
her infant, as well as the available ways to deal with this issue, within
European countries and United States of America.
Methods: The study methods included the evaluation of published
retrospective and research studies on infant abandonment, causes of this
phenomenon, factors leading to abandonment and possible solutions
within European countries and United States of America. We also included
a literature review in MEDLINE and CINAHL databases (1990-2009).
Results: Infant abandonment is a complicated issue involving parental and
children rights. It involves the fundamental children’s right to live with their
families and know their roots of origin. Mothers abandoning their children
are under great psychological distress, they possibly suffer from mental
disorders or they are often victimized both in their personal and social life.
In the fight against infant abandonment, it is essential to secure a woman’s
right to freely choose the time to become a mother and to provide all the
social and financial support needed for a new mother and her child.
Key words: abandoned infants, infant abandonment in Europe and the
United States of America.
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[75]
RESEARCH PAPERS
INTRODUCTION
Data in international literature regarding newborns
abandonment by their mothers are scarce, as research
on this subject is limited. Research shows that there
will always be desperate mothers who feel that there
are important reasons to abandon their children soon
after birth (Cesario 2003 & Oberman 2008). Studies
also show that these women belong to different social
classes or they live in a state of social isolation. They
may also be living in family with a different structure
comparing to the standard conventional family.
Factors such as unemployment, poverty, women abuse
of any kind (financial or sexual), incest, parental
alcoholism, drug abuse, HIV infection, etc (Mousourou
2005) seem to be responsible for these situations. Other
researches indicate that women capable of abandoning
their children are even capable to commit child murder
(Oberman 1996). Some women experience more fear
in losing their mate rather than their child. As a result,
they take desperate measures to save their affair without
knowing that they bear a child; when suddenly the baby
arrives, they get into panic and simply wish to “get rid
of it” (Williams-Mbengue 2001 & Oberman 1996).
Reasons for negative acts behaviors towards the infant
may include negative childhood experiences, emotionally
poor parental relationships, unfulfilled interpersonal
relationship with the child’s father, negative or adverse
environmental and financial situations, poor living
conditions, etc (Riga and at, 1990).
Infant abandonment in Europe
In Western Europe most cases of infant abandonment
involve very young women deprived of some kind of
freedom (illegal immigrants, prostitutes, socially isolated
groups). Nongovernmental organizations indicate that
mothers in risk have no knowledge of their rights or
have no access to social or heath services. As a
consequence, they become vulnerable to exploitation
and they abandon their children without having a choice
(Doctors of the World, 2007). Both in Europe and in the
rest of the world, there is much controversy about the
re-introduction of the so-called baby drop box system,
used in Europe during Medieval times. In the 12th
century, Pope Innocentios the 3rd urged women to
leave children that were not able to raise on the stairs
of a church. At a monastery in Florence during the 14th
century there was a specially adjusted wooden rolling
barrel (la ruota) where unwanted newborns were left.
Throughout Europe, till the 19th century and in Greece
till 60’s, in nurseries where unwanted infants were
abandoned there were special admissions in use
(Pediatric Society Minute Archives, 2006).
In many countries, child abandonment in public place
is considered as a crime and the measure of baby drop
box is considered by many as a crime motivation whilst
mothers carry the overall responsibility. Those measures
[76]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
often have no legal basis, as it happens in Belgium.
Recently, in Germany, permission was granted for a
campaign, while in Italy, an unwanted pregnancy is still
considered as a sin and a social stigmatization (Williams
– Mbengue, 2001). Experts suggest that the establishment
of a baby drop box system is expected to reduce abortions,
child murders, child abuse and infant abandonment in
public place (Boyes R., 2007). The first electronic baby
drop boxes were introduced in Germany in 2000 (presently,
there exist in many countries all over the world). The
places where baby drop boxes are usually placed are
out of public view with no surveillance cameras placed
around. The infant is put in a reception surface – through
a “window” in a specially adjusted area of the wall of
a building– which gradually gets lower leading the infant
in a heated small bed. A special alarm notifies health
professionals for an infant arrival, and the child’s birth
is officially recorded in birth registries. Usually, there
is enough time for the mother to leave the area without
being noticed, and in case she changes her mind, she
is provided with a three months time to request her
child back (Poggioli, 2007).
Dealing with the phenomenon
in Europe and in United States of America
In 2007, the European Council, in order to collect opinions
and deduct some conclusions, conducted a research
regarding ways of dealing with the infant abandonment
phenomenon, in twenty countries of the European
Union. Among results of this research, it was found
that in some of the countries, national statistical data
on the percentages of abandoned infants are rarely
collected or they do not exist at all. With the assumption
that the situation in Ukraine (1549 cases of baby
abandonment in 2004, but only 998 in 2006) might be
useful as an example for a thorough analysis, the
introduction of an electronic database was decided,
aiming to exchange conclusions between the affiliated
countries (Hancock M., 2007).
France has established a privacy system for the mother
who abandons an infant and this country, as well as
United States of America, is the only where this system
is used. Five hundred cases of unknown births are
recorded yearly in France, in comparison to 10.000 a
year in 60’s, when contraception and abortions were
still illegal. Law allows a mother to give birth to a baby
reserving full anonymity not recording her identity to
any official data (http://assembly.coe.int, 2008). In
Germany, in 2003, the annual recorded number of
abandoned newborns was more than 70, and within
the first trimester of 2007, at least 23 infants were
recorded as murdered. Experts have expressed their
concern that the actual number is much higher. A
relevant campaign was started to illuminate the
importance and length of the problem and to promote
wider use of the baby drop box (Poggioli, 2007).
RESEARCH PAPERS
In Italy, more than 30 children were abandoned during
the last two years, especially in the rundown neighborhoods
of Rome, due to the rise of the immigrants’ population.
Multilingual campaign posters were used calling them
not to abandon newborns and at the same time, public
education campaigns were undertaken regarding the
right to have access to health and social services.
Additionally, a high tech baby drop box was placed in
a central hospital of Rome (Boyes R., 2007).
In United Kingdom, programs of foster parenting for
the abandoned children are promoted, along with the
implementation of strict rules for the procedure of
foster families’ choice, in order to avoid baby jamming
in the institutions. The aforementioned practice is known
in this country since 19th century and it was supported
by a volunteer spirit of wealthy families.
In Central and in East Europe, there is still in place a
strong tendency of parents to leave their children’s
care in institutions. This practice is in use especially in
Romania, a country which is still influenced by the
heritage of its old political status involving measures
by the state in order to take care of abandoned children.
In Ukraine, the suggested reasons for this phenomenon
include the parental family pressure on teenage mothers,
the limited financial sources, the case where the mother
herself has been a victim of abandonment and a number
of other problems related to drug and alcohol
addiction(Hancock M., 2007).
In many counties, legislation requires investigating for
the family of the abandoned child. In general, due to
differences in legislation and family practices at each
country, a consensus for dealing with this phenomenon
is difficult to reach (Hancock M., 2007).
United States of America voted a new legislation in
1999, which was implemented in pilot manner in Texas.
According to this, parents can anonymously leave their
baby to safe places (hospitals, police departments, fire
stations) without the risk of being prosecuted. During
hospitalization, care of the baby is assigned to a member
of the personnel (Rosner, 1997 & Cesario, 2003). Written
guidelines based on a certain protocol are provided to
the personnel of these services, which include the steps
they need to take from the moment they find an abandoned
infant (Buckley, 2007). In many circumstances, a letter
is sent to the mother of the infant – when her identity
is known- giving her information for available services
where she could ask for support for her and her baby
in case she changes her mind (Williams – Mbengue,
2001). By this way, the risk of abandoning a child in an
unsafe area where its life could be in danger is reduced.
This also protects the parents who feel that they have
no other choice than abandoning their child and offers
them a chance to leave their newborn in a safe place
(Drescher – Burke, 2004). The people in charge claim
that this legislation is a positive step but it should be
part of a wider effort to the improvement of health
services and related social services (Cesario, 2001 &
Buckley, 2007).
In Greece, from the very first years of the constitution
of the Hellenic State, care was provided for the orphans
and the abandoned children, in the capital of the country.
In 1883, the first baby drop box was established at the
Community Nursery of Athens and remained in use
until 1960 (Korasidou, 1992). In Greece, as in the other
countries, there was much controversy regarding its
purposes, since many believed that its use would
encourage birth of children outside marriage and
abandonment as a consequence (Pediatric Society
Minute Archives, 2006). In the present, there are only
isolated cases of infant abandonment, since family
bonds are still very strong. Infants found in pavements
or trash bins were transferred to a public hospital by
the police, where they were hospitalized and as soon
as a vacancy existed in the Centre of Child Care, they
are transferred. At the same time, an investigation
starts with the aim of identifying the mother. Data from
the Registry of Underage Care show that the percentage
of Greek and Immigrant women abandoning their
children is similar. In 2005, 13 abandoned children were
found, 9 in 2006, 10 in 2007 and 5 in the first semester
of 2008 (Eleutherotypia Newspaper – 05/07/2008). Today
there are thirteen Centers of Child Care in Greece, with
a total capacity for 600-700 children, along with six
Child City Centers where another 200-250 children are
hosted. These centers aim to offer medical treatment,
education and professional training to the children that
are unprotected and deprived of family care.
CONCLUSIONS
Child abandonment after birth is a complicated issue
which is related to both the parental and the child rights.
Nevertheless, in Europe and especially in Central and
Eastern Europe, financial and social factors including
poverty, social class and adolescent motherhood deprived
of financial support from the parental families are
responsible (Bloch, 1998). In Greece, a survey regarding
the views of Greek nurses for the phenomenon of child
abandonment indicated that the great majority believe
that adolescent mothers belong to low socio-economic
class, they do not have financial sources and that they
are more prone to abandon their infants (83.5%, 70,9%
and 73,8%, respectively) (Athanasopoulou, 2008). Health
policies, effective social and health services, accessibility
to those services and in particular, accessibility for socially
isolated groups play an important role in a woman’s
decision, especially when she confronts an unwanted
pregnancy and she has limited choices for dealing with
the situation (Rosner, 1997 & Green, 1999). Pregnancy
is unwanted in most such cases, whereas information
on contraception issues is inadequate. These women
have a fear for the health services or they don’t know
how to effectively use them, before or during their pregnancy
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[77]
RESEARCH PAPERS
(Cesario, 2003 & Oberman, 2008). Psychological changes
and stressors, as well, are causes for abandoning an
infant in public places (Bonnet, 1993 & Oberman, 1996).
Studies from international literature verify that those
women are importantly under significant stress, they
suffer from mental disorders and they are often victimized,
in personal and in social level, as well (Cesario, 2003).
Newborn abandonment raises the issue of accessibility
to special information services for young people and
mostly for women’s sexual rights and reproductive
health. Abortion has not yet been legal to most of the
countries. Even when it is allowed, it is usually subjected
to many bureaucratic procedures that inhibit many
women. In some of the cases and in some of the countries
there are strict time limits for the procedure of an
abortion, so that in everyday practice, the right of
abortion is of no value (Athanasopoulou & Kouta, 2009).
Beyond of a doubt, there is a need for family planning
which would take into account the demographic pressures
created by the birth of a child as well as the need of
young mothers to be followed up and supported. All
suggested measures should focus on the fundamental
principle of respect for the children’s rights and most
importantly, for the utmost human right of a child to
live with its family and to know its origin. Special attention
should be provided to socially vulnerable women coming
from minorities. Another important issue is the deinstitutionalization of the abandoned infants. Another
necessity is that these children are provided with
alternatives so that they are able to obtain a family
through adoption (Rosner D. et al, 1997).
Α mother’s failure to take care of her child is expressed
through abandoning of the child to a midwifery or
elsewhere. In Greece, cases like these are inconsistently
treated. On one hand, the state is having difficulty in
breaking the privacy of a family and on the other hand,
it is obliged to force the constitutional law for protection
of children and youth. As a result, whenever there is a
case of child abandonment or child abuse, in the face
of these difficulties, the state intervenes and only
temporarily offers to the child the choice of a foster
family or an institution (Mousourou, 2005). The responsibility
of effective care under the broader issue of child
protection from its parents is expressed in a close
emotional bond. A mother’s failure to respond to this
need could be a result of personal irresponsibility and
deficiency. A similar failure could also be attributed to
adverse socio-economic conditions combined with the
crisis that the institution of family is facing in our days.
REFERENCES
1. Athanasopoulou M., (2008). Postgraduate Diplomatic Work, The
Attitude of Nurses toward the Phenomenon of Infants Abandonment,
NKUA
2. Athanasopoulou M, and Kouta Ch., (2009).The Education for the
Sexual and Reproductive Health in the frames of European Policy,
[78]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science, Volume 2, issue 2
3. Bonnet C., (1993). Adoption at birth: Prevention against abandonment
or neonaticide. Child Abuse and Neglect. Vol17:501–513. [PubMed]
4. BoyesR.,«TheTimes»,http://www.dailygreece.com/ 2007/03/post_72.php
(Retrieved on 12/04/2008)
5. Buckley C., (2007).Safe-haven laws fail to end discarding of babies,
www.nytimes.com/2007/01/13/ nyregion/13babies (23/03/2008)
6. Cesario S, Kolbye S, Furgeson E, (2002).Public abandonment of
newborns: Policies and practices in the United States and around
the world. APSAC [American Professional Society on the Abuse
of Children]14(1):24–27
7. Cesario S. (2001).Newborn abandonment: Would you know what
to do? AWHONN [Association of Women's Health, Obstetric and
Neonatal Nurses] Lifelines.5 (5):42–48
8. Cesario S. Κ,(2003). Nurses’Attitudes and Knowledge of Their
Roles in Newborn Abandonment. The Journal of Prenatal Education
Vol.12,pp.31–40
9. Daily newspaper”Elefterotypia”, Article in the 05/07/2008. Retrieved
on 25/11/2008 from http://www.eleftherotypia.gr/
10. Drescher-Burke Κ, J. Krall and A. Penick, (2004). Discarded
infants and neonatacide: A review of the literature. National
Abandoned Infants Assistance Resource Center, pp. 1–13
11. First European Observatory for the Access in Care, without
papers, without health, Doctors of World, September 2007
12. Green E., (1999). Infanticide and infant abandonment in the New
South: Richmond, Virginia, 1865–1915. Journal of Family
History.V.24:187–211. Bloch H., (1998).Abandonment, infanticide,
and filicide. An overview of inhumanity to children. American
Journal of Disabled Children.Vol142:1058–1060
13. Hancock Μ, 2007. Prevention of the first form of violence on
children: abandonment at birth, Report of European Council
(Retrieved on 26/02/2008 from http://assembly.coe.int)
14. Korasidoy M., (1992). The philanthropists speak for the poor
and the poverty in Athens of 19th century. The Historicals.
Historical File of Greek Youth [KNE]/[EIE], Athens: 385-404
15. Ministry of health and social solidarity , retrieved on 11/03/2009
from http://www.mohaw.gr/
16. Minutes of the 1st meeting, (2006). History of the Greek Pediatric.
Greek Company of Pediatric History, pub. [Bita], Athens
17. Mousourou, L. M., (2005). Family and family policy. Pub. Gutenberg,
Athens
18. Oberman M. (1996), Mothers who kill: Coming to terms with
modern American infanticide, American Criminal Law Review,Vol
34, pp.15–19
19. Oberman Μ, (2008), Comment: Infant Abandonment in Texas
Santa Clara University. Child maltreatment, Vol. 13, No. 1, Feb,pp
94-95
20. Poggioli, S. (2007). Italy takes high-tech tactics for abandoned
babies. Retrieved on 08/03/2007 from www.npr.org/templates/story/
story.php? storyID=7730566
21. Riga A. - B., Kokkinakis [Th]., (1990). Maternity - Maternal instinct.
Statement in the Greek – French Conference of Psychosomatik
Gynecology - Obstetrics, Athens: Greek-French Institute
22. Rosner D, Markowitz G., (1997). Race, foster care, and the politics
of abandonment in New York City. American Journal of Public
Health.V.87:1844–1849. [PubMed]
23. Rosner D, Markowitz G., (1997). Race, foster care, and the politics
of abandonment in New York City. American Journal of Public
Health.V.87:1844–1849.
24. Rosner, D.(1997).Race, Foster Care, and the Politics of Abandonment
in New York City. American Journal of Public Health, November,
Vol. 87, No. 11
25. Williams-Mbengue N.,( 2001), Safe Havens for Abandoned
Infants, Policy Specialist , September Vol. 26, pp. 15- 21.
RESEARCH PAPERS
Research in occupational stress among
nursing staff - a comparative study in capital
and regional hospitals
Moustaka Eleni1, Antoniadou Fotini2, Malliarou Maria3, Zantzos E. Ioannis 4,
Kiriaki Constantina2, Constantinidis Κ. Theodoros5
1. Captain Nurse in 401 General Military Hospital of Athens, 2. Nurse in the General Thorax Hospital
“Sotiria” Athens, 3. Captain Psychiatric Nurse. M.Sc, 4. Mathematician,5. Medical Work Specialist,
Assistant Professor, Director of Health and Environmental Protection Laboratory, Medical
Department of Thrace Democritus University.
SUMMARY
Background: In European Union, occupational stress is second in frequency
as a health problem related with occupation affecting 28% of employees.
Occupational stress is a psychosocial risk factor in occupational field and it
is present when occupational demands overcome the ability to address or
control the situation.
Objectives: Research of occupational stress in the nursing staff of a General
University Hospital of Athens and identification of any differences in factors
related with stress in both samples under investigation.
Thesis plan: The population sample consisted of nurses and nursing assistants
working in a General University Hospital of Athens and a regional General
University Hospital.
Participants: The study sample consisted of 140 nurses and nursing assistants,
selected with a randomization technique.
Methods-Results: In order to collect the scientific data we used the following
methods:
1) The occupational stress scale of Kahn et al (1964).
2) A general information questionnaire.
The statistical tool SPSS Version 15 was used for analysis. According to the findings
of the present study, nurses suffer from occupational stress without any significant
differences between the two samples. Increased work overload and conflict
between professional and family roles contribute to the development of stress.
Conclusions: The evaluation of occupational conditions and the search for
factors which potentially harm employees’ health is essential for effective
prevention. Preventing occupational stress and occupational health in
general, as well as dealing with safety hazards should be an integral part
of management policies and of provisional and safeguarding procedures
for improvement of health care quality.
KEYWORDS
Nursing staff, occupational stresss
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[79]
RESEARCH PAPERS
TABLE 1. Occupational stress scale at the regional hospital
8
7
Συχνότητα
Frequency
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
12 18 19 20 22 23 24 26 27 28 29 30 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 45 46 47
Occupational
stress
Eπαγγελματικό
στρεσ
INTRODUCTION
Stress is the second in frequency health problem
regarding the occupational environment. It is estimated
that 28% (about 1 in 3 people) of employees within
European Union experience occupational stress
(Andoniou, 2007).
Occupational stress is defined as the adverse emotional
state experienced when the demands due to occupational
factors overcome the ability of an employee to address
or control the situation. There is a subjective aspect in
occupational stress, since a certain factor may be the
cause of stress for some individuals but not for others
( Lazarus, Folkman, 1984). The triggers usually connected
with stress are physical, physiological and behavioral.
In particular, physical symptoms include increased
arterial pressure, allergies, ulcer, heart conditions
and general symptoms concerning the employee’s
health, while psychological symptoms involve lack of
concentration, increased tension, boredom and low
work consistency. Finally, the behavioral symptoms
are evident in the employee’s performance and satisfaction.
Three basic strategies are recommended:
Reduction or modification of stressors or moving
the individual away from them
Adjusting occupational environment to the individual.
1
2
the individual’s coping through exercising,
3 Improving
meditation, relaxation techniques and social support
(Pandazopoulou-Fotinea, 2003).
[80]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
Nurses are one of the most vulnerable professional
groups to occupational stress, as they often encounter
stressful situations due to the special demands of their
profession (Papageorgiou, etc, 2007).
During the last two decades, the interest in stress
producing factors that contribute to nurses’ psychological
state has increased (Pagapeorgiou, etc, 2007).
The study of occupational stress is an imperative need
since it has been shown that stress has negative impact
both on nurses’ health and on the health organization
they are occupied, with absenteeism and low quality
of health care being the most frequent consequences
(Ouzouni, 2005). The major stress producing factors
in nurses are:
Frequently or rapidly alternating timeshifts, bad
occupational conditions
Role conflict
1
2
3 Constant communication with a variety of people
4 Work overload and severity of incidents
5 Routine dealing with death
lack of individual’s role in the occupational
6 The
environment (role ambiguity-lack of duties specification)
(Papamichael, 2005).
Another important factor is the lack of support and
positive feedback to the nursing staff by the administrative
RESEARCH PAPERS
TABLE 2. Occupational stress scale at the capital hospital
8
7
Frequency
Συχνότητα
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
15 17 18 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 40 42 43 44 45 48 53
Occupational stress
Eπαγγελματικό
στρεσ
executives in the nursing services (Ouzouni, 2005).
Clinical nurses work under conditions of intense stress
with limited autonomy in decision making, since they
often work under policies defined by others (Marvaki,
etc, 2007).
In the bottom line, the important one who will be
harmed due to nurses’ stress is the patient. A nurse
under stress will care for patients in a cold, indifferent
and depersonalized way, with apathy and disappointment
(Papageorgiou, etc, 2007). Moreover, it is possible that
a nurse under stress withdraws, behaves negatively
and has a short-temper, is often absent from work,
and performs in a less effective manner comparing to
her best and she has often wishes to quit the profession
(Papageorgiou, etc, 2007).
OBJECTIVE
The objective of the present study is to evaluate the
level of nurses’ occupational stress and to identify any
differences between the two samples.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The questionnaire was distributed to a total of 250
nurses and nursing assistants. In detail, it was distributed
to 150 nurses and nursing assistants of the regional
University Hospital and to another 100 of the capital
Hospital, during a time period of one month (November
2006). Sixty four questionnaires were returned completed
(response rate 42,6%) from the first hospital, while in
the latter hospital, the response rate was 76%. Eighty
five per cent of the sample was of female gender (15%
males). The gender in the two hospitals ranged as
follows: regional University Hospital, 6% females, 9,4%
males; capital General Hospital, 80,3% females, 19,7%
males. The average age of the sample was 37,19 years,
with a standard deviation of 6,5 and a range of 33,
minimum age 24 years and maximum 57 years. The
average age was 37,17 years for the regional hospital
and 37,21 for the capital hospital.
Data collection was conducted by a subgroup of the
researchers’ team after in person brief guidance from
departmental supervisors, on receiving of the sealed
envelopes with the completed questionnaires.
An anonymous self-completed questionnaire was used.
The first section contained questions about sociodemographic factors such as age, gender, marital
status, degree, further education, as well as work
factors like department of work, years of work, work
hours, type of service, average night shifts per month,
department selection.
The second section in included in the occupational
stress questionnaire developed by Kahn and associates
(1964). The stress evaluating scale regarding occupation
(in the form of role conflict, role ambiguity and overload)
contains 11 items and participants respond by choosing
one among five answers: Never, rarely, sometimes,
often, and almost always. These responses are scored
with 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5, respectively. The total score
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[81]
RESEARCH PAPERS
TABLE 3. How often do you experience
emotions due to excessive overload mostly
when you feel that you cannot finish your work
during a normal shift?
TABLE 4. How often do you feel
unqualified for your job?
Hospital
50%
Regional
Capital
40%
50%
Regional
40%
Hospital
Capital
30%
Regional
Capital
30%
Regional
Capital
20%
20%
10%
10%
0%
0%
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
TABLE 5. How often are you affected by your decisions
TABLE 6. How often do you feel that you are unable
which have an influence on your fellow human beings
and particularly on those that you are acquainted with?
to influence your supervisor’s decisions and actions
that concern you?
Hospital
50%
Hospital
50%
Regional
Regional
Capital
40%
Capital
Regional
40%
Regional
Capital
30%
Capital
30%
20%
20%
10%
10%
0%
0%
1
2
3
4
5
represents the occupational stress level of each
individual. A high score means high level of occupational
stress. Consequently, the scores of occupational stress
range between 11 and 55.
RESULTS
In the first part of the questionnaire: 60,9 % of nursing
personnel in Regional Hospital were graduates of
Technological Institutions and 39,1% had 2 years of
education in Nursing. In the Capital Hospital, these
proportions were 59,2% and 40,8%, respectively.
The mean of years on duty was 13.68 years [standard
deviation (SD) 7,7] ranging from 1 to 30 years. In detail,
in the Regional Hospital, the mean of years on duty
was 13,6 (SD, 8,9) and 13,74 (SD, 6,6) in the Capital
Hospital.
In the Regional Hospital, the mean score in stress
scale was 30,39 (SD, 7,27) ranging from 12 to 47. In
the Capital Hospital, the mean score in stress scale
[82]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
1
2
3
4
5
was 31 (SD, 7,29), ranging from 15 to 53.
The following graphs represent the frequencies of
scores in stress scale in each hospital.
There was no significant difference except in the items
regarding “work pressure” and “conflict between family
roles and professional roles.
DISCUSSION
According to the study findings, occupational stress
of nurses does not differ significantly between the two
samples.
Increased work overload along with conflicts regarding
work and family roles result in increasing stress.
These findings are consistent with those of previous
studies that classify the nursing profession as the most
stressful one compared with other health professions
(Adali, et al, 2000).
The work overload (1st item) and the conflict between
work and family roles (11th item) influence more,
RESEARCH PAPERS
TABLE 7. How often do you feel that during
your work you have to do things that contradict
your convictions?
Hospital
40%
TABLE 8. How often do you feel
that your work interferes with your family
and personal life?
Hospital
50%
Regional
Capital
30%
Regional
Capital
40%
Regional
Regional
Capital
Capital
30%
20%
20%
10%
10%
0%
0%
1
2
3
4
5
comparing to other items, the score in Kahn’s scale.
The conflict between work and family roles contributes
to occupational stress development because fulfilling
the work role may adversely affect fulfilling a role
within the family and vice versa. In detail, according
to Thoits (1991), a key concept to identify stressors for
each individual is the role he identifies with. As roleidentities, we define the ways of self awareness as
part of social living (e.g. a father, a husband/wife, a
member, a professional etc.). These roles offer an
identity, as well as behavioral rules. When an individual
fulfills the demands of his/her role-identity, selfawareness is enhanced. In case of failure, self awareness
is reduced and stress is increased. The real stressors
are the facts (positive or negative), depending on the
extent that they affect these roles-identities and interact
with our perception for them. In fact, Gruen, Folkman
and Lazarus (1988) showed roles and commitments
of individuals relate directly to the major every day
problems and the way they are perceived.
A study conducted on 282 nurses and nursing assistants
in Greek hospitals has shown that occupational roles
in a hospital influence personal, family and social
live of the nursing staff, and in particular, the life of
women and of people employed for more than 10
years (Marvaki, et al, 2007). According to other studies,
the nursing staff’s family life can be influenced by
their work, through frequent shifts, which are a main
feature of nursing occupation. (Weiss, 2004,
Michalacopoulou, 2003) and night shifts (PD Dr. Med.
Hm Hasselhorn, 2007).
A study conducted on 89 mental health nurses has
shown that among the most frequent sources of
occupational stress for nursing staff is the role conflict
between family and work (Ouzouni, 2005). Another
study on mental health of nurses had contradictory
1
2
3
4
5
findings, where conflict between family and work had
a low score in the stress scale that was used, interpreted
as role conflict not being a major source of stress in
that particular nursing staff (Ouzouni, 2005).
The increased workload as a stressor has been confirmed
by many studies (Callaghan, 1991, Chiriboga, 1986).
According to Pines (1982), workload has a negative
impact on the relationships among nurses, as they
have no time for social contact, interpersonal interaction
and positive feedback, discussions on professional
issues, determination of the healthcare unit targets
and assurance on the importance of their work. In
other studies, a moderate statistical significance
between occupational burnout syndrome and environmental
factors has been found (Stone, 1984, Constable, 1986).
CONCLUSIONS-SUGGESTIONS
Increased workload, in combination with the sense
that the work role contradicts the family one, lead to
development of occupational stress.
Two levels of intervention are recommended in order
to prevent and manage occupational stress:
primary level, where the focus is the organization
1 The
itself. The targets include the identification and
evaluation of the existing stressors, as well as corrective
measures. A part of the primary level for occupational
stress management is to take preventive measures
on all levels in order to avoid stressors (Psychargos
2nd phase, 2005).
To control the potential factors that contribute to the
development of occupational stress, we recommend
the following:
■ Evaluation of occupational stress risk factors and
management of these risks, taking preventive
measures for the employees (ICN).
Volume 3 - Issue 3
[83]
RESEARCH PAPERS
■ Reduction of work overload with rational management
of human recourses regarding nursing staff (Adali,
Lemonidou, 2001) establishes a balance between
work demands and capabilities of the nursing staff
(ICN).
secondary level focuses on persons and includes
2 The
an individual guided training, by organizations for
occupational stress management.
■ Support groups. These groups of nurses, which may
be coordinated by a psychologist or psychiatrist focus
a) on identifying all sources of occupational stress,
b) on exchanging experiences and realizing that many
nurses also face similar situations in their work, c)
on self-awareness and analysis of emotions and
responses of nurses, d) on reassessment of the ways
of managing certain stressors (Pateraki, et al, 1995).
■ Time to relax between work and home.
As mentioned above, occupational stress can negatively
influence a nurse’s personal and family life. Introducing
a time interval between work and return to home, as
well as having leisure activities helps a nurse relax
and block carrying stress in family life (Pateraki, et al,
1995). Of particular interest would be a program, during
the nurse’s shift, provided by hospital management,
with the aim to help nurses relax before returning
home.
To implement all of aforementioned suggestions,
executives should coordinate with nursing staff and
promote employees’ health and safety. Therefore it is
necessary that executives specialized in such fields
will be recruited in hospital departments of Health
and Safety.
Consequently, mechanisms for prevention and
management of occupational stress should act in
coordination and focus early on minimizing the stressors,
on one hand, and on enhancing psychophysical stability
of nurses, on the other (Pateraki, et al, 1995).
It is essential to reorganize work environment (in its
broad sense) and remove as many as possible stressors,
along with training of staff in ways with which they can
manage stress and achieve better adjustment. All
these should be coordinated by employers and take
place within the workplace. This interest from employers’
part should be sincere and visible, in order to promote
employees’ health and safety.
REFERENCES
1. Adali E., Priami M., Plati C., 2000. Influence of nurses’ demographic
and occupational characteristics in the appearance of work
burnout. Nursing, 4:313-324
[84]
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
2. Adali E., Lemonidou C., 2001. Contributing factors to the
appearance of nursing work burnout. Nursing, 2:15-22
3. Andoniou A.S., 2007. Occupational stress sources. ΕΛ.ΙΝ.Υ.Α.Ε.
4. Marvaki C., Dimoula Y., Kampisiouli E., Christopoulou I., Bastardis
L., Gourni I., Kalogianni A., 2007. The influence the profession
has on the nursing staff’s life. Nursing 46 (3):406-413
5. Michalakopoulou A., 2003. Nurse’ stress occupational in the
ER. Nursing, 42:293-298
6. Mpousinakis D., Chalcos G., 2006. The influence of stress and
satisfaction on organization operation. Occupational Relationships
Inspection, 42:43-55
7. Ouzouni C., 2005. A research study of the factors causing stress
in nursing staff in short treatment psychiatric units. Nursing
44(3), 355-363
8. Pantazopoulou-Fotinea. A., 2003. Occupational environment
and mental impact (Organizational-Industrial Psychology). An
approach based on her medical project.
9. Papageorgiou D., Karabetsou M., Nikolakou C., Paylakou N.,
2007. Stress levels and self-awareness of nurses occupational
in public hospitals. Nursing, 46:406-413
10. Papamichael E., 2005. Stress and adjustment. Nursing care
in ER, Business Project Health-Welfare 2000-20006, Athens,
2005
11. Pateraki A., Iordanidis P., Iakovidis A., Ierodiakonou C., 1995.
Nursing burnout: Causes, prevention and treatment. Nursing
1:28-39
12. “Psychargos-2nd Phase, 2005. Ministry of Health and Social
Support, European Social Fund – Business Project “HealthWelfare 2000-2006”. Burnout Syndrome in mental health and
psychosocial rehabilitation units. Interventions at an Individual
and Organizational Level. Support and Supervision Unit,
Athens.
13. Callaghan, P. 1991. Organization and stress among mental
health nurses. Nursing Times 87(34):50
14. Chiriboga, DA., Bailey, J.,1986. Stress and burnout among
critical care and medical surgical nurses: a comparative study.
Crit Care Quart, 9:84-92.
15. Constable, JF., Russell, Dw., 1986. The effect of social
support and the work environment upon burnout among
nurses. J Hum Stress 12: 20-26.
16. Gruen, R.J., Folkman, S., & Lazarus, R.S., 1988. Centrality
and individual differences in the meaning of daily hassles.
Journal of Personality, 56,743-762.
17. Hm. Hasselhorn, 2007. Psychosocial factors in Work and
Health among nurses in European countries – what is it that
makes the difference?” International Conference “Work
Hazards for staff in the health field” Athens.
18. ICN. Οn Occupational Stress and the Threat to Worker Health.
http://www.icn.ch/matters_ stress_print.htm
19. Lazarus, R.S., Folkman, S., 1984. Stress, appraisal and coping.
New York Springer.
20. Pines, ΑΜ., Κanner, AD., 1982. Nurses’ burnout: Lack of
positive conditions and presence of negative conditions as
two independent sources of stress Psychiatric Nurs, 20:3035.
21. Stone, GL., Jebsen, P., Walk, P., & Belsham, R., 1984. Identification
of stress and coping skills within a critical care setting. West
J nurs Res.201-211
22. Τhoits, P. A., 1991. On merging identity theory and stress
research. Social Psychology Quarterly, 54, 101-112.
23. Weiss, B., 2004. Finding time for fitness. United States, 67:53-54.
H e l l e n i c
journal of
Nursing
Science
INSTRUCTIONS FOR AUTHORS
The Greek Journal of Nursing Science (EPNE) is the
official journal of the HELLENIC NURSES’ ASSOCIATION.
It is a peer-reviewed, cross-disciplinary journal with
the purpose of promoting nursing science in Greece.
The Greek Journal of Nursing Science provides
opportunity for the publication of academic articles
presenting research conclusions, research based
reviews, discussion articles and commentaries of
interest to an international readership of professionals,
educators, administrators and researchers in all the
fields of nursing, and health care professionals.
TYPE OF ARTICLES
EPNE publishes articles which fall into three main
categories:
- Editorial articles
- Editorial articles which are relatively brief (200
words maximum)
- Original articles – research work
• Full articles relating to primary research can have
up to 5000 words.
• Clinical trials protocols should not exceed 2.500
words. Authors must state the trial registration
number (where available), as well as the timing of
the presentation of the conclusions.
Reviews and brief presentations (2000 words maximum)
• Reviews that contain:
- systematic reviews, meta-analysis
- book reviews
- political reviews
- other type (e.g. socio-economic)
not be published elsewhere, either in English or in
any other language, without the written consent of
the publisher.
REVIEW PROCESS
All articles are initially evaluated by the editorial
team and are thematically assigned to the reviewers.
Subsequently they are admitted for publication
following a double-blind review by at least two
anonymous reviewers. Reviewers decide whether
the article is:
(a) Accepted for publication without alterations.
(b) Accepted for publication after minor modifications.
(c) Accepted for publication after extensive revision.
(d) Rejected for publication in its present form
PREPARATION OF MANUSCRIPT
General Guidelines: All submitted work should be
suitable for an international audience and authors
should not limit their work to national and political
practices and to legislation specific to their country.
Each article must be accompanied by a cover letter,
an example of which can be found on the journal
website: www.enne.gr
The cover letter must provide the following:
• Statement that the work has not been published
in whole or in part in another journal.
• Statement that the final version has been acknowledged
and approved by all the authors.
• Written permission (registration number of approval)
for the research from the ethics committee of the
institution where the work was carried out.
• Full name, postal address, email address and
telephone number of the author responsible for
correspondence.
Detailed information about online submission of
manuscripts can be found on our website.
• Book reviews: Should not exceed 1000 words.
ORGANIZATION OF MANUSCRIPT
ARTICLE SUBMISSION
Authors must submit manuscripts via the journal
email address: journal@enne.gr. All correspondence,
including the editorial decision statement and rereview requests, will be carried out online. An article
is submitted on the condition that it has not been
previously published, that it is not under consideration
for publication elsewhere and that if accepted it will
Organize your manuscript in the following order:
article title, title page, acknowledgements, abstract
and keywords, text, references, tables, figures,
supplements (Font: TIMES NEW ROMAN size12, 1.5
line spacing). Please number the pages of your
manuscript.
Title: The title must describe the topic of the article,
Volume 3 - Issue 3
GENERAL
participants where relevant, clinical problem and
research method used.
Title page: The title page contains:
• Full name, full article title (maximum 90 characters),
academic and professional qualifications and
institute for every author.
• Email address of every author.
• Submission date of article.
Acknowledgements: Basic contributors to the work
are thanked in the acknowledgements.
A b s t r a c t : Abstracts should be no more than 250
words and should not include any references or
abbreviations.
Abstracts of research work should be structured
under the following headings, where possible: (a)
Introduction, (b) Materials and Methods, (c) Results,
(d) Discussion, (e) Research limitations and (f)
Conclusions, which must have a bearing on the
objectives and the context of the study, and provide
recommendations for clinical implementation of the
results.
Abstracts of reviews should come under the following
headings, where possible: Introduction, purpose,
secondary aims, references: data bases, review
methods, results, conclusions.
Abstracts of book reviews should provide a brief
summary of the rationale and conclusions.
Keywords: Up to six keywords in alphabetical order
should be included, stating clearly the context of the
article, objective and method used.
Use the medical title thesaurus (MeSH®) and (CINAHL)
where possible.
T e x t : The text introduction must refer to what is
already known on the topic and what this article has
to add to nursing science. Depending on the type of
article, it should be set out as follows:
Reviews should carry: (a) Introduction, (b) Purpose,
(c) Materials and Methods, (d) Results, (e) Discussion,
(f) Conclusions, and must expand in detail on the
summary.
Research works must follow a specific structure: (a)
Introduction, (b) Materials and Methods, (it is necessary
to state the time period for the collection of data,
data source, sample sizes and sample selection
methods, details of how they were chosen, selection
and exclusion criteria, number of new participants
or dropouts, relevant clinical and demographic
characteristics, data collection methods, data collection
device and permission and approval process for its
use, response rates, statistical methods used for
analysis (c) Results along with accurate rates of
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
statistical importance (d) Discussion, (e) Research
limitations and (f) Conclusion, which must have a
bearing on the objective and the context of the review,
and provide recommendations for clinical implementation
of the results.
Interesting cases are divided into: (a) Introduction,
(b) Case reports, (c) Comments.
Prolonged publications are separated into: (a)
Introduction, (b) Materials and Methods, (c) Results,
(d) Discussion.
Tables/figures: Tables and figures are printed only
when presenting further supporting data not provided
by text. Tables should be numbered consecutively,
given a concise title and must each be typed on a
separate page.
Units of Measurement: Length, height, weight and
volume must be expressed in metric units in accordance
with internationally recognized symbols.
Abbreviations: Avoid using abbreviations wherever
possible. All abbreviations to be used by the authors
must be written in their expanded form along with
their abbreviated form in parenthesis at first use.
Titles of journals should be abbreviated according
to the list of Index Medicus, which is published in
January every year in a separate issue (List of Journals
Indexed in Index Medicus). There is a relevant list
(IATROTEK) with abbreviations of Greek journals.
Statistics: Standardized and internationally approved
methods must be used to present statistical material.
Statement of Informed Consent: Authors must ensure
that research has been conducted in accordance with
the ethical principles clearly laid down in the International
Committee of Medical Journal Editors (www. icmje.org)
and the World Medical Association Declaration of
Helsinki, 2000. In other words it is imperative that
authors assure that the results of their studies arise
from research work which has obtained informed
consent from the participants and approval from the
formal ethics committee.
Permissions: Permission to reprint previously published
material must be obtained in written form from the
copyright holder.
Q u e s t i o n n a i r e s : Non-standard and unfamiliar
questionnaires and evaluation programmes used in
research work should be applied to supplements.
References: All publications referring to the text
must be cited in a reference list. References should
be presented according to the style used in «Harvard»
GENERAL
Revised for 2009 version 3.0 editions of: The Coventry
University (CU) Harvard Reference Style Guide
v3.0,Quickstart Guide v3.0,Glossary v3.0.
Examples
1. Book with one author: Biggs, G. (2000) Gender and Scientific
Discovery. 2nd edn. London: Routledge
2. Book with many authors: Ong, E., Chan, W. and Peters, J. (2004)
Advances in Engineering. 2nd edn. London: Routledge
3. Chapter or dissertation of specific author in a book: Aggarwal,
B. (2004) “Has the British Bird Population Declined?” In a Guide
to Contemporary Ornithology. ed by Adams, G. London: Palgrave,
66-99
4. Journal article: Padda, J. (2003) “Creative Writing in Coventry”.
Journal of Writing Studies 3 (2) 44-59
5. Website: Centre of Academic Writing The List of References
Illustrated [online] available from http://home.ched.coventry.
ac.uk/caw/harvard/index.htm [Sept 2009]
6. Article in electronic journal: Για ένα άρθρο σε ηλεκτρονικό περιοδικό: Dhillon, B. (2004) “Should Doctors Wear Ties?” Medical
Monthly [online] 3 (1) 55-88. available from http://hospitals/infections/
latest-advice [20 April 2005]
IMPORTANT NOTE
If submitting an article that has already been reviewed
by the editorial team of EPNE, please attach the
email message with your response to the comments
of the editor and reviewers.
AUTHOR SERVICES
Article progress can be checked ONLY online.
Reprints
Three reprints will be given free of charge to the
corresponding author of the article.
Copyright
Copyright of published articles belongs to the authors.
The journal retains the right to reproduce or republish
an article for the purposes of promoting Nursing
Science.
EPNE will take all necessary measures to protect
authors’ rights.
Volume 3 - Issue 3
H e l l e n i c
journal of
Nursing
Science
THE EPITOME OF USEFUL INFORMATION
INCORPORATION OF THE HELLENIC
REGULATORY BODY OF NURSES
The Hellenic Regulatory Body of Nurses was constituted
by the law 3252/2004 as a form of a Public Body and
functions as the official professional body representing
the nurses. The enrolment of all nurses is compulsory
as is done in corresponding chambers overseeing
other professions and functions as a regulatory body
and the official counselor of the state (Pan-Hellenic
Medical Association, Legal Association of Athens,
Technical Chamber of Greece etc.)
MAIN GOALS OF HRBN
In an effort to make the reasons that all nurses should
be subscribed to HRBN clear, shown below are the
basic goals as presented by the law 3252/2004 and
these should be implemented by HRBN:
• The promotion and development of nursing as an
independent and autonomous science and art.
• The research, analysis and study of nursing matters
and the formulation and submission of scientifically
documented studies of the various nursing problems
in the country.
• The construction of proposals on nursing matters.
• The continuous training and educating of nursing
staff and the materialization and utilization of
training programmes.
• The participation in materializing programmes
which are funded by the European Union or other
international organizations.
• The editing of certificates which are necessary for
obtaining a license to practice the nursing profession.
• The evaluation of the nursing care provided.
• The representation of our country at international
organizations regarding the nursing department.
• The publication of a journal, an informative bulletin,
text books and leaflets so as to inform its members
and the public.
• The study of Medicaid matters and the organization
of scientific congresses that are independent or in
cooperation with other bodies.
• The creation of an ethics committee for the nursing
profession.
• The definition and cost assessment of nursing
activities.
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
• The protection and enhancement of the level of
health of the Greek population.
MEMBERS OF HRBN
It is compulsory for members of HRBN to be nurses,
in other words they should be graduates of the following:
a) University level nursing schools
b) Technical level nursing schools
c) Former higher school for nursing, visiting nurses
belonging to the ministry of health, welfare and
social security
d) Former nursing school “KATEE”
e) Foreign nursing schools with degrees that are
accepted as equivalent to the corresponding Greek
schools
f) Military supreme nursing schools
STRUCTURE OF HRBN
HRBN is composed of a central administration, which
is located in Athens, and seven peripheral sections,
one in each health district of the country.
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATION
The central administration is made up of a 15 member
executive council and has its central office in Athens.
The address is 47 Vasilisis Sofias Avenue p.c. 10676,
tel: 210 3648044-048 and fax: 2103617859 and 210
3648049. HRBN’s website is www.enne.gr and email:
info@enne.gr.
PERIPHERAL SECTIONS
The peripheral sections correspond to the number
of health districts in the country and include:
1. 1st P.S. Attica: 47 Vasilisis Sofias Avenue, p.c.
10676, tel: 210 3648044-048 and fax: 2103617859
and 2103648049
2. 2nd P.S. Piraeus and Aegean: 47 Vasilisis Sofias
Avenue, p.c. 10676, tel:210 3648044-048 and fax:
2103617859 and 2103648049
3. 3rd P.S. Macedonia: 11 Mavili St., Thessalonika
p.c. 54630, tel: 2310 522229 and fax: 2310 522219
4. 4th P.S. Macedonia and Thrace: 11 Mavili St.,
Thessalonika p.c. 54630, tel: 2310 522229 and fax:
2310 522219
5. 5th P.S. Thessaly and Mainland Greece: 2 Navarinou
St., Larissa p.c. 41223 tel: 2410 284866 and fax:
2410 284871
GENERAL
6. 6th P.S. Peloponnese, Ionian Islands, Epirus, and
Western Greece: 1 Ipatis and N.E.O Patra-Athens,
Patra p.c. 26441 tel. and fax: 2610 423830
7. 7th P.S. Crete: 116 Menelaou Parlama St., Irakleio
p.c. 73105 tel: 2810 310366, 2810 311684 and fax:
2810 310014
MEMBER REGISTRATION AND SUBSCRIPTION
All nurses are obliged to apply for registration at
the nearest peripheral section. The application form
requires a certified copy of the nurse’s degree and
official identification, two coloured photographs,
the receipt from the bank statement for the amount
of 65 €, a simple copy of the license to practice the
nursing profession and other titles that the applicant
might have are optional (postgraduate degrees,
certificates for foreign languages, social activities
etc.).
All nurses are obliged to renew their subscription
annually, in person or by post (not by fax) till the end
of February, by handing in the appropriate statement
to the nearest peripheral section. The statement
should be handed in simultaneously with the annual
subscription fee, which has been assigned to the
amount of 45 € by the law 3252/2004.
All nurses who register or renew their subscription
to HRBN are given a Nursing Identity Card.
LICENSE TO PRACTICE THE NURSING PROFESSION
The license to practice the nursing profession can
be administered at the local prefecture by presenting
the necessary documents and certification of registration
at their HRBN peripheral section. When receiving
the license to practice it is compulsory to present a
copy to the peripheral section to which they belong.
According to the law 3252/2004, whoever practices
the nursing profession without a license to practice
will be prosecuted according to the article 458 of the
Greek penal code.
Any individual of the peripheral council or the board
of directors can file a complaint for illegal practice
of the nursing profession and thereafter must notify
the judiciary authorities.
In the case of a temporary disciplinary sentence or
final disqualification from HRBN the license to practice
is automatically suspended.
ADMINISTRATIVE BODIES
HRBN is administered by the assembly of representatives
and the executive council. The peripheral sections
are administered by the general assembly and the
peripheral council.
HRBN’S INTERNATIONAL REPRESENTATION
HRBN is a member of FEPI and has one of the seven
positions on the board of directors. England, Italy,
Spain, Ireland, Poland, Croatia, Romania and Portugal
participate in this European federation. France,
Cyprus and Belgium are under consideration for
participation. For more information the website is
www.fepi.org.
SELECTION AND SERVICE
OF ADMINISTRATIVE BODIES
HRBN’s board of directors is elected by the assembly
of representatives. The representatives are elected
separately for each peripheral section by the members
of the department’s General Assembly. The peripheral
councils are elected in a similar way by the members
of the peripheral department’s General Assembly.
These elections take place every 3 years and Nurses
that take part are members in good standing (subscription
payed).
DISCIPLINARY CHECK
The members of HRBN are initially submitted to a
disciplinary check by the peripheral section, which
also functions as a disciplinary council. The secondary
disciplinary check, as well as the disciplinary check
of the members of the board and the peripheral
councils is executed by the supreme disciplinary
council, whose president is the supreme court judge.
SCIENTIFIC JOURNAL
HRBN created the “Hellenic Journal of Nursing
Science” in 2008 which is its official journal. It is a
multidimensional journal with an editorial committee
which aims at the promotion of the nursing science
in Greece.
The “Hellenic Journal of the Nursing Science” is a
reliable, modern, quarterly scientific journal which
is published in Greek and English and is available in
electronic and printed form. A nominal fee is offered
to all interested researchers, university teaching
staff, students and the entire nursing community in
general as well as the tertiary university and technical
level schools (Greek or foreign).
Simultaneously it offers young scientists easy access
to knowledge and the chance for nursing to progress,
as well as a scientific step for the nurses who work
in the academic area and the clinical area to publish
their work and undergo some constructive criticism.
The journal publishes research studies, reviews,
original dissertations and book reviews.
The papers that are published, are credited in a
manner that is regulated and certified by the Greek
legislation according to international standards.
INFORMATIVE JOURNAL
HRBN created a monthly informative journal in 2008
“Rhythm of Health – Ρυθμός της Υγείας”, aiming at
promoting and demonstrating each nurse as a unified
Volume 3 - Issue 3
GENERAL
psychosomatic and professional personality.
The nurses in Greece have the need to solve primary
issues that concern their profession as well as the
need to express themselves, to communicate, to
enjoy themselves and to demonstrate the diverse
aspects of their social purpose.
“Rhythm of Health - Ρυθμός της Υγείας” aims at
uniting the voice of all nurses in the country and
becoming an immediate and dependable form of
communication, giving a chance to all voices of the
professional community to be heard.
GOALS FOR THE FUTURE
With the collaboration of all its members HRBN aims
at materializing and completing some important
projects that are requested by the nursing community,
some of which have already started being carried
out:
• The definition and cost assessment of nursing
activities.
• The creation of an open line of communication so
as to record and solve the nursing problems.
• The enhancement of international relations between
Greek nurses and organizations, for and international
institutes.
• The creation of an electronic digital library which
can be used free of charge by members of HRBN
and to which the whole country will have access.
Hellenic Journal of Nursing Science
• Will offer specific training and postgraduate courses.
• The organizing of scientific congresses and day
meetings with formal accreditation.
• The formation of specific project committees such
as a training committee, a documentation committee,
a foreign affairs committee and an informative
committee.
• The creation of a network of experts on nursing
issues and the provision of legal advice.
• The creation and function of specialization programmes.
• The certification of nursing specialties and nursing
adequacy.
CONTACTS
Nurses can contact us:
Tel: 2103648044, 210 3648048 (8:00-15:00)
Fax: 2103648049, 210 3617859
Email: info@enne.gr
• For professional matters
• For training matters
• For legal issues
• For their registration or renewal of subscription
• For general information (congresses, activities,
etc)
• Proclamations via the Hellenic public organization
for hiring personnel “ΑΣΕΠ”
• For positions in the health sector