read

From IndieWeb

This article is a stub. You can help the IndieWeb wiki by expanding it.

To read or reading is the act of viewing and interpreting posts or other documents; on the IndieWeb, a read post expresses that something has been read, like a book or section thereof. This could serve as a way to share books etc. with followers, or to notify the author of a document that you have read it (if the document can receive webmentions).

Why

Read posts serve a potential variety of functionalities including:

  • Tracking what you've read as a reminder, potentially with notes for writing a later review. (See also commonplace book.)
  • Keeping track of where you're at in a longer work, particularly when it may not be read in one sitting so that you can come back to the same place at a later time. Compare/contrast this to the idea of a bookmark.
  • Provides a potential means of discovery for readers looking for interesting content.
  • Indicate to others what you've explicitly read, particularly as on many social silos people will post articles and there isn't any indication that they've read much beyond the headline. (See articles below.)
    • A read post adds some additional information to a post to better differentiate from a bookmark, potentially indicating one wants to read something, as well as likes or favorites which don't necessarily indicate the content at the particular link was read.
  • Online magazines, newspapers, journals, blogs, etc. might choose to show webmentions of read posts as a social indicator of how popular or widely read a piece of content is. Compare this with the generic social shares, bookmarks, reposts, etc. which may indicate how broadly a headline was shared without any indication about the piece actually having been read.
  • Educators or book clubs might assign reading and read posts and attendant webmentions of those could be conglomerated for potential grading or other online discussion depending on the setting.

How to

See #Brainstorming for now.

IndieWeb Examples

gRegor Morrill

gRegor Morrill is experimenting with posting to-read posts and reading progress check-ins since 2015-01-25:

Earlier work

From 2015-01 through 2015-02, I experimented with a handful of posts to track my reading progress. I did not continue in part because there were no consumers of those microformats. I also realized I was more interested in the simpler use-case of tracking what I want to read, am currently reading, and have finished reading.

Notes:

  • Used p-page and p-total to indicate progress. The percentage complete can be calculated and graphed from these values.
  • Used h-item and u-identifier for the book title. The identifier's href is in the format ISBN:XXXXX.
  • Manually POSSE to Goodreads.
  • Feedback is welcome, since this may not be the "best" way.

rhiaro

Amy Guy displays read posts since 2015-08-04. These are different to bookmarks, as I expicitly mean bookmarks as to-read or to-read-again. I expect to add notes (content) to read posts in the future, too. Marked up with the made-up microformat u-read-of.

Tantek

Tantek Çelik is experimenting with posting "read" posts as plaintext notes of a specific format, based on his brainstorming thoughts.

Short stories as part of a volume, starting with "read ", (smart)quoted name of the work, optionally part of what larger work, "by ", name or @-name of author, punctuation of some sort with additional contextual remarks or commentary. Examples:

Books of (collections of) distinct essays, short stories, other writing:

Books, starting, finishing chapters, finishing a whole book, a book in a series, also based on brainstorming thoughts

Magazines / periodicals, progress, and articles read:


Will likely only post when I've finished reading a complete "chunk" of a work, a named section or numbered chapter perhaps.

Ryan Rix

Ryan Rix (rrix) has posted Read items on Arcology since it was created, as a way to signal other people that something is worth reading. Read posts are treated identically to regular posts, or notes, but with a URL in the heading and body. Some notes contain a pull quote or comment on the article, which are just shoved in to the e-content like any other post.

Most read items are pointing to blog posts or other online "long reads" though they could also link to books on Amazon or so, as I am doing reading through a book and taking notes as I go.

Chris Aldrich

Beginning in the late summer of 2016, I began posting read books along with reviews, highlights, notes, and marginalia on my site to a great extent owning large portions of data that I now POSSE (manually) to GoodReads.com, Amazon, and other book related silo services. In large part I'm using many of the ideas from brainstorming thoughts below along with thoughts here from Tantek and others. A good example of such a post can be found at Maps of Time: An Introduction to Big History. Another post which includes links to individual status updates of interstitial progress can be found here.

Beginning on 10/30/16 I began owning the articles I'm actively reading online using a modified PESOS workflow using both Reading.am and IFTTT. It's described in more detail at Owning My Online Reading Status Updates. In this workflow, I actually prefer to bookmark the article I'm reading in real time and the PESOS workflow allows/reminds me to post notes/thoughts to the post once I'm finished reading, or very shortly thereafter.

In December 2016, I began using PressForward to internally save private bookmarks for web-based articles/pages I want to read later, as well as a way to easily publish them as read posts when done. PressForward saves the canonical URL of the original post and allows a setting for the archived post on my own site to forward to the original after a set number of seconds.

On 2017-01-07, I began pinging the Internet Archive with URLs of both my own posts as well as links within posts using Post Archival in the Internet Archive in a method similarly suggested previously by Jeremy Keith.

2017-12-11 Expanded microformats mark up of read posts for physical books.

Jeremy Cherfas

Jeremy Cherfas in February 2017 began posting reviews of books he's read along with notes and highlights, and marginalia from his Amazon Kindle. Example: Cuisine and Empire: Cooking in World History

ColoradoBoulevard.net

2018-05-29: While ColoradoBoulevard.net can easily support posting reads, as a local newspaper for the Pasadena, CA and surrounding areas, it focuses more on displaying webmentions for incoming read posts

UI example from ColoradoBoulevard.net of facepiled Reads

Jamie Tanna

  Jamie Tanna now tracks reads on https://www.jvt.me/kind/reads/ i.e. https://www.jvt.me/mf2/2020/09/zrpkc/

Tracy Durnell

Tracy Durnell started publishing book reviews as read posts in Fall 2020.

  • Most posts link to the book's Goodreads page, alternatively the book page on the author or publisher's website
  • Non-fiction book read posts also include highlights exported from Kindle, manually organized and formatted -- as of summer 2022, posts with extensive notes are set to private
  • Manually POSSE reviews (sometimes condensed) to Goodreads
  • Books read each year are grouped on a page as an h-feed, with each book marked as h-cite book, and p-name booktitle for book title and p-author for each author
  • No star ratings, but indicate books liked or loved with thumbs up emojis 👍
  • Current reading is listed on the same page, not as a feed
  • Did not finish books are also listed on the same page, not as a feed
  • "Why I track my reading"

Claudine Chionh

claudinec since 2024-04-01: a simple single Reading page, using Hugo shortcodes for minimalistic metadata (thought process here)

Tools

indiebookclub

indiebookclub is a Micropub client for posting read posts to your site. It can also consume the read-of microformat from a URL to pre-populate the new post form.

Semantic Linkbacks WordPress Plugin

The Semantic Linkbacks WordPress plugin consumes the read-of microformat to display a separate facepile of people reading the post. See #ColoradoBoulevard.net above.

Managing Kindle highlights with Python and GitHub

A python script to extract notes and highlights from Kindle and created a Markdown formatted file that could then be stored on Github or elsewhere. See [1]

IndiePass

IndiePass supports posting reads using Micropub form requests.

Other Examples

Other interesting or notable examples of people posting about reading on the web, perhaps lists of articles or books they have read, perhaps on another site but not on a "read" post silo.

Nieman Lab

Assuredly in part to feed their reportage and research, The Nieman Lab publishes a "What we're reading" section on their website at https://www.niemanlab.org/reading/

We keep an eye out for the most interesting stories about Labby subjects: digital media, startups, the web, journalism, strategy, and more. Here’s some of what we’ve seen lately.


Brainstorming

Tom Morris

Tantek thoughts

Some thoughts from having experimented with a couple of "read" posts (see above).

  • text-first design - here's a modest design for the plain text versions of "read" posts (suitable to get started with posting on your own site, and POSSEing to text-primary destinations like Twitter.
    • simple: 📕 read “{name-of-work}” by {name or @-name of author}.
    • chapter/section: 📖 read {name-number-of-section-chapter} in/of “{name-of-work}” by {name or @-name of author}.
      • e.g. "📖 read chapter 7 of …"
      • or shorten chapter to "ch." for POSSE tweet shortening purposes.

The terminating period (.) in each example could be any punctuation, other sentence terminators (!), or a comma(,) indicating commentary afterwards.

  • continuing with the design, some optional aspects following the above
    • hashtags, e.g.
      • #hardcopy indicating something was read in physical printed (on paper) form.
    • {URL} to the work itself online, or an online representation of a physical product
    • other commentary
    • terminating with a permashortlink or permashortcitation.

Details of terminology used in text-first design:

read
meaning I started and finished reading it in close temporal proximity
started reading (note Twitter search/usage)
finished reading (haven't used yet, but thinking about)
meaning I started reading this sometime in the past (days, months, years? ago), and just now finished reading it.
in
indicates section/chapter as part of some larger work. any following information (hashtags, URLs) apply to the larger work
by
prefix indicating author information follows, either as an @-name, or Capitalized Full Name

Considering:

  • a leading emoji at the start like the musical note for jam posts, e.g.
    • 📕📗📘📙📚📖
  • perhaps separate emoji for particular sub-types of read posts, e.g.
    • 📕 started reading / read / finished reading a whole book - good default. when you start you’re about to open the book, and when you finish, you’ve closed the book.
    • 📗 ... a whole book that is second in a series
    • 📘 ... third in a series
    • 📙 ... fourth in a series
    • 📚 ... a trilogy / set of books
    • 📖 read / finished reading a section or chapter of a book, or perhaps just even up to a page number, but have not yet finished the book.
    • ...

Chris Aldrich thoughts

Having played with nearly every reading app and website in existence, I've been contemplating the time-changing nature of reading related posts. I've written some ideas and thoughts based on past experiments and UI examples from reading/book-based silos for future implementation. The tl;dr is a reading post type that subsumes the longer workflow of read later >> bookmark >> notes/highlight/fragmention/annotations/marginalia >> read >> review. Thoughts for concatenating verbiage are appreciated. The linked post also includes some screenshots of silo-based systems and UI.

I like Tantek's thoughts about using emoji as visual indicators, particularly when POSSEing to platforms like Twitter. I'm considering (example) using the following as indicators within my workflow described above:

  • 🔖 Bookmark: To indicate interest or "want to read" or generally come back to read later
  • 📖 Open Book or 🕮 New book: To indicate either I'm currently reading or haven't yet finished a longer work; equivalent to a location checkin within a longer piece. Potentially also including a progress of either % or page X of Total.
  • 📓 Notebook or 📔 Notebook with Decorative cover: for general notes taken while reading
  • 📑 Bookmark Tabs: to indicate stopping points or points of interest within the text. This seems to be a better visual use case for moving a bookmark though a text
  • 🗟 Page with Circled Text: For highlight/fragmention other annotations
  • 🙶 Sans-serif Heavy Double Turned Comma Quotation Mark Ornament: For pull quotes from read material
  • 📕 Closed book: to indicate I've "finished reading" (This has the added benefit that on most systems it renders in the color red to visually intimate "stop" as well; compare with 📗 Green Book, which could be used to indicate "starting" a book)
  • ...

Read Receipts

Main article: read receipt

A read post in reply to a message, from one of the recipients of that message, is a read receipt of that message.

Micropub client

There was some discussion about a micropub client for posting books being read/completed: https://indiewebcamp.com/irc/2016-06-09#t1465505870288

gRegor Morrill thoughts

Thoughts on how to mark up, based on my experience and on indiebookclub:

mark up and post a read

To post a read, the post's h-entry should have properties:

  • p-x-read-status: indicates the status of the read post
    • current values being used: to-read, reading, and finished
  • p-read-of (or u-read-of): indicates what is being read
    • it's recommended to use an h-cite for this so you can include author and uid information (ISBN or DOI), but you can use just the title as a minimum viable read post.
    • u-read-of may be preferable if the h-cite includes a URL. This depends on whether the consumer expects a URL or the name of what's being read. If there is no URL in the h-cite, the value will be the plain text of the h-cite, including author name and ISBN/DOI.

A minimal post indicating you want to read Kill Process would be: 

<div class="h-entry">
	<span class="p-summary"><data class="p-x-read-status" value="to-read">Want to read</data>: <cite class="p-read-of h-cite">Kill Process</cite></span>
</div>

A more complete post would use an h-cite as the p-read-of, with the author and uid: 

<div class="h-entry">
	<span class="p-summary"><data class="p-x-read-status" value="to-read">Want to read</data>: <span class="p-read-of h-cite"><cite class="p-name">Kill Process</cite> by <span class="p-author">William Hertling</span>, ISBN: <span class="p-uid">9781942097037</span></span>
</div>

on the read-status property

In #microformats chat [2] with Tantek Çelik about adding proposed properties to the h-entry spec, I realized that read-status may be an overly-specific property name. There's potential for similar properties to proliferate for listen, watch, and exercise posts (listen-status, watch-status, exercise-status), so there's definitely more work to be done before moving the property through the standardization process.

Since read-status is actually an experimental property at this point, ideally it should be published as p-x-read-status as reflected in the updated examples above.

Linking to a book

Thoughts, approaches, and examples on linking to books.

It’s not clear what's the best approach, from a usability/user-friendliness perspective, a link-robustness perspective, etc. Worth documenting existing practices, brainstorming possible alternatives, and how they may be better or worse.

Using a local to domain link that live redirects:

  • Tantek Çelik examples (list above at #Tantek) use an autolinked tantek.com/isbn/*** URL which algorithmically redirects to an Amazon URL for that *** ISBN
    • Advantage: it can be changed in the future to redirect somewhere else
  • ...

Using multiple direct links:

Browser Extensions for free local resources There's a free, non-commercial browser extension called Library Extension which allows users to specify their local library(s) such that when landing on most commercial book seller pages online, the extension will add a box of information showing free available physical and electronic copies of books and other media at a local library. It also has quick link buttons for allowing the person viewing the site to place holds on them or retrieve them immediately. This is quite similar to a related browser extension LibX which focuses on academic libraries and also shows the available journal articles available by proxy through research libraries. It would be nice if there were a proxy service available for these that would allow the building of URLs to help focus and center free local library holdings to users who clicked on these links.

Non-commercial online catalogues Sometimes a website owner may have moral, ethical, or other reasons for not wanting to link to and support the commercial sales of books and media through particular for-profit online silos like Amazon, Goodreads, BookShop.org or other similar retailers even if they provide affiliate links which compensate the site owner for recommending books.

To help remedy this, below is a list of common public library sites which encourage freely available public resources without centering corporations and profitmaking.

  • WorldCat is an online library catalogue which lets you search the collections of libraries in your community and thousands more around the world. WorldCat grows every day thanks to the efforts of librarians and other information professionals. Users with accounts can specify their local libraries so that searches of materials will show local copies that are available for them to check out for free. More details available at: https://www.worldcat.org/whatis/default.jsp
  • Open Library is a catalog and platform not too dissimilar to Goodreads. The ultimate goal of the Open Library is to make all the published works of humankind available to everyone in the world. It is is an initiative of the Internet Archive, a 501(c)(3) non-profit, building a digital library of Internet sites and other cultural artifacts in digital form. The catalog is easily editable so that materials can be added directly and linked to if they didn't previously exist in the catalog.
  • Internet Archive is a non-profit library of millions of free books, movies, software, music, websites, and more.
  • Wikidata is a non-profit database included information about books, academic articles, movies, dramas, operas, musics, albums, games, etc, which all published under CC0.
  • inventaire can import books information from Wikidata, and support ActivityPub.

Daily Summaries

Tantek Çelik For articles I read on the web, rather than post individual read posts, I’d like to post a daily read collection post. Is anyone doing this?

Similarly for bookmarks.

Generalize to any media

See: https://github.com/microformats/h-entry/issues/10#issuecomment-671090023

Generalize to any task

See: task#Reading_use-case_as_inspiration

Silo Examples

Goodreads

  • Goodreads allows you to check-in your reading progress.

Goodreads to FB

Goodreads has a way to cross-post your "read" (and review) posts to your Facebook profile.

Screenshots of functionality

  • Recent updates inlcuding
    • Update with note and progress
    • Started reading
    • Review
    • Want to read

  • Activity for a particular book

  • Reading progress snapshot for a particular book

  • Goodreads Widget for Currently reading (including progress bar)

Here are the read-post-specific aspects that are interesting - these are all purely textual approximations / wire-frames. Other screenshots welcome! 

(avatar) Person-Name made progress with a book on Goodreads.
(large photo of book cover)
Name of Book
Just started reading

(avatar) Person-Name made progress with a book on Goodreads.
(large photo of book cover)
Name of Book
On 300 of 416 pages

(avatar) Person-Name reviewed Name of Book on Goodreads.
(small photo of book cover) Name of Book

Specifically the reporting of page # and # of pages total may help inform plain text design brainstorming.

LibraryThing

  • LibraryThing allows you to check-in your reading progress, write reviews as well as indicate books you want to read or books you have acquired.

BookSloth

BookSloth is an app for iOS and Android focused on discovery, connecting with other readers, and personal recommendations. A web app is in beta.

Facebook

  • Facebook allows you to choose 'Reading' as an activity and pick a book/article from its drop down, or type in free text, as part of updating your status.
When posting a new status, there is button for "Feeling/Activity."
Clicking "Feeling/Acvivity" lets you select from multiple options.
After selecting "Reading," type in the name of the book.
After selecting the book, you can optionally add a comment.
The final result when posted: https://www.facebook.com/gregorlove/posts/10102475519750644

Twitter

Twitter does not have any explicit "reading" activity or post, however people post tweets that resemble "read" posts, e.g.:

There are some examples of people dedicating entire Twitter accounts to what they'd like to read:

Reading.am

Reading.am is specifically designed for quickly bookmarking "exactly what you're reading online right now."

Articles

Articles about reading on the web:


Camp Sessions

Related sessions at IndieWebCamps

See Also

Retrieved from "https://indieweb.org/wiki/index.php?title=read&oldid=95534"